<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Luke Skywalker on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Luke Skywalker on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 14:46:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“The Art of Knowing”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/the-art-of-knowing-9f3a10211cdf?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f3a10211cdf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theory-of-everything]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cosmology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Feb 2018 00:33:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-27T21:19:05.935Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>“The Art of Knowing”</strong></p><p>The reason for the following story and why Langan is writing about it and where it came from and when? Also how will you make sense of it when its obviously crazy? The answers in this order: This story is about free will. He writes about free will because he and as should we find it interesting. The basic story originally came from a physicist named William Newcomb and was popularized by the Harvard philosopher Robert Nozick circa 1969. If you find it crazy, its not because you can prove its crazy but only because you assume it’s crazy. For all you know it could actually happen. If you’re wondering why I say you “should be” interested in free will, I’ll risk belaboring the point out that the question and what’s the meaning of life?</p><p>Because we feel as though we are exercising free will in order to make decisions and perform voluntary actions, we take its existence for granted. Our social, political, and religious rights, civil liberties, moral responsibility, crime and punishment, and good and evil are already heavily invested in the concept… heavily enough that if the existence of free will were ever disproved, it would literally destroy everything we believe about ourselves and the world we inhabit.</p><p>The above scenario for how the contestant should choose comes down to “Newcomb’s Problem” and Newcomb’s paradox”. There remains a subtle difference between the “Problem” and “Paradox”. To solve Newcomb’s problem, one must explain how the contestant should choose and why and there are two different ways to answer. It’s so difficult to say which answer is right they’re considered to have equal claim on correctness.</p><p>That’s where Newcomb’s paradox enters: Two “equally correct solutions” that contradict each other add up to a paradox. To resolve a paradox, once must either do one of three things: (1.) decide the issue, showing why one solution is correct (and the other incorrect); (2) describe a framework into which both solutions fit under different circumstances; or (3) prove the scenario unreal and the question meaningless.</p><p>-The first solution, “take both boxes”, is called the dominance solution.</p><p>-The second, “take only the opaque box”, is called the expected utility solution.</p><p>Now of What box am I referring what scenario and Langan made his own stylist touches to say scenario developed by a physicist named who that’s relevant to free will how? And when I said earlier from the following scenario above even though it’ll be below because I haven’t described the scenario but by saying the scenario above is indicating I’ll probably be writing about it………etc.</p><p>“In Nukem’s most notorious routine, he offers a randomly chosen contestant a choice between one or both of two boxes.”</p><p>-So the contestant can choose box-B or both box A and B. Only those two choices either only box-B for choice one or the other choice Box A and B both, you can’t do just box-A that’s the name of the game; so to recap the contestant has two choices: 1.Box B or 2.Box A and B.</p><p>(Box A) is transparent and contains a thousand dollars, and one of which (Box B) is opaque and contains either a million dollars or nothing at all.</p><p>Here’s the catch, A neutral referee, usually either a professional debunker James or an equally curmudgeonly associate of the Skeptical Enquirer, holds a single well-sealed envelope containing a single slip of paper on which the prediction regarding the choice (the setting is an act on the Tonight Show hosted by Jay Leno by the way and Nukem is a famous prognosticator who has infallible predictive abilities). If the slip says “B”, then box B contains nothing. In other words, if Nukem has predicted that the contestant will leave the thousand on the table (Box A), then there is $ 1,001,000 on the table; if Nukem has predicted that the contestant will grab the “extra” thousand, then what you see is exactly what you get, and there is nothing more on the table than the price of a good office chair. Now your saying what? That doesn’t make exact sense does it? Cause it’s a tricky scenario conjured up by a physicist but it isn’t that tricky. Slip says “B” means Nukem has predicted that the contestant will choose box B and also B then contains 1 million dollars. “If”, however the slip says A and B then Box “B” contains nothing and Nukem predicted you’d pick both. So if Nukem wants to win why doesn’t he just leave nothing in B ahead of time so that when they will obviously choose both they only get a thousand? At least the contestant gets something for trying no matter what. They’ll at least get 1,000! What kind of game is that though? What risk is that? Well what if the contestant chooses just B but B has nothing? Then the contestant gets nothing. So common sense tells you to just pick both no matter what cause if B has a million you get the max prize and if it doesn’t your guaranteed 1000 but the two options are only B and both A and B there’s no third option of just A. Now remember Nukem has already made the prediction and has been right in predicting people in the game 1,000 times in a row. But what’s in the envelope and the box “B” is fixed and can’t change. What’s done is done and at this point out of Nukem’s control. His prediction is made. Even if Nukem somehow scans the brain or reads the mind of the contestant before making his prediction, and even if this causes a million dollars to be placed in Box B, there is obviously nothing stopping the contestant from changing his mind at the last minute and snagging the extra thousand. After all, that’s what free will is all about. Let’s summarize two choices and two outcomes for each choice so 2 choices and 4 possible outcomes depending on Newkem’s prediction sealed in the envelope! Outcomes: Remember the slip of paper is Nukem’s prediction of what the contestant will choose.</p><p>1. Chooses Box B and slip says “A and B”- cause nothing in B so zero “0” prize money.</p><p>2. Choice of B but slip says B so contestant wins a million</p><p>3. Chooses both A and B and slip says B wins the grand prize of 1,001,000</p><p>4. Choice of A and B but slip says A and B so just the office chair of 1,000.</p><p>The thing is, the prediction in the envelope always turns out to be correct! Even if the contestant tries to pull a fast one or catch the mentalist in a deception. Nukem knows exactly how much confidence the contestant has in his abilities. Those who believe that he has predicted correctly and choose accordingly are always rewarded with a seven-figure retirement fund; those who think they can ‘pull a fast one’ at the eleventh hour and belie his prediction are doomed to kick their own cans forever after throwing away a certified ticket to Easy Street, the additional $999,000 they’d have won had they merely given predictive credit where credit was due. Wait a minute this should be more simple than that! What’s so complicated about this game?! well let’s dissect the problem!</p><p>​</p><p>Yes the contestant knows that Nukem made a prediction that’s written in the envelope. That’s part of the game and wouldn’t be a game without that! Plus he’s done this routine 1,000 times so everyones seen or heard it. With 100% success rate. Nukem predicts the outcome everytime. Well if Nukem just says B everytime then there’s always a million in the box everytime that simple! (which he would because no mentalist want’s the contestant to get the full prize with 1,001,000 cause remember if the contestant chooses B and A when the slip just says B then they win the grand prize and Nukem loses.) Then the contestant just has to go with B everytime. But remember if the slip says A and B there is “0” in B so just choosing B will get you zero. So based on common sense assumptions that Nukem will just write B on the slip and for odds sake will choose A and B and that gets us the grand prize nothing to it. However, lets deduce the problem to an even simpler level!</p><p>​</p><p>If the slip says B there’s a million in the opaque box if it doesn’t say B there’s not a million in the Box. The goal of the game for you is to get as much money as you can and the extra G that extra thousand with a million would mean you win and beat Nukem at his game. Either agree with Nukem and get a million or try to pull a fast one and beat him. Look at it this way, if there isn’t a million in the box not much is at stake and you’d want to choose option 1 and go with both so you at least walk away with something. The 1,000 from Box A! So you’re out there on the stage and either 1 million is in the box or it isn’t. So the game makes more sense if the million is there everytime so you’re playing with something Nukem can look like he’s always right he’s generous enough to give you a million. On the other hand if there never is a million in there the game wouldn’t be fair and would be far to predictable. So if there’s always a million you know to choose A and B cause the opaque Box contains what it does and Nukem’s already made his prediction nothing more to it. He can’t make a million go away you have free will to change your mind at the last second. Well then how can Nukem be so accurate. You can’t ignore that although there probably is a million in there and you have freedom of choice Nukem’s track record says the odds of you beating his prediction are 2¹⁰⁰⁰:1. Two to the thousandth power to 1. Way beyond astronmical. This alone would suggest that the laws of physics are not everything they’re cracked up to be. Doesn’t particle physics recognize time as flowing in both directions? How can Nukem really know always ahead of time what the contestant will always choose with the correct answer on the slip of paper always especially when what’s in the opaque box “B” is already determined and the contestant has freedom of choice? Well there’s a bigger picture.Obviously if you’re catching on one of the ideas is a person having free will even though the outcome is already known. The other is how can Nukem Know?</p><p>​</p><p>​</p><p>Nukem is either passively reading the future without affecting it, or actively controlling the thought and behavior of his contestants in such a way that they cannot directly detect his influence.</p><p>​</p><p>Statistical Induction-indicates the contestant’s chance of beating the mentalist are around .5¹⁰⁰⁰ (.5 for two choices, 1000 power for being correct consecutively 1000x’s in a row. Mine as well bet against death, taxes and 1+1=2.</p><p>​</p><p>There are however a couple of philisophical kinks in the wire. The first one is Goodman’s Grue, is about the limitations of induction. Supose you have two hypotheses, namely “emeralds are green”, and “emeralds are green and will remain so until New Year’s Day 2050, at which point they will turn blue.” (This can also be expressed by saying that “emeralds are grue”, where “grue” is defined as “green until 2050 and blue thereafter”.) Statistically, both of these hypotheses are equally confirmed by current observations. This implies that Nukem’s past successes can also be regarded as confirming two hypothesis, namely “Nukem is able to predict the future” and “Nukem was able to predict the future up to the last contest, but not thereafter.” With loopholes like that, arguments from induction can be hard to trust. Cause how don’t you know for sure despite past successes his powers won’t run Out! On the other hand, laws of physics are themselves discovered by induction. This suggests that all of the observations and experiments confirming the currently accepted laws of physics also support the following hypothesis: “The currently-known laws of physics hold perfectly well until Damon Nukem decides to predict the future, at which point they bend subtly to his will. “This of course, raises an important question: in what kind of reality could a prognosticator like Nukem bend the laws of physics with the power of his will, yet remain undetected? Even is his powers are entirely passive, even if he only “watches” the future without ever taking a hand in it, how can he trancend the flow of time? Where time is understood to progress steadily from past to future, how can his mind leapfrog into the future and back again? How can information go from future to past? hmmm….?</p><p>​</p><p>Suddenly you remember a hit movie called “The Matrix”, what if the world is a kind of digital simulation running on a powerful computer and displayed on a vast quantum-pixelated 3D monitor? What if “people” are just software homunculi who consider themselves sentient, but cannot detect the higher level of reality containing the computer and its programmer? Perhaps the programmer of such a simulation could influence the behavior of these homunculi without being detected. In fact, maybe he could freeze the action, fast-forward the program, gather information on future events, back the program up to the “present moment” and resume the simulation precisely where it left off so that nobody inside would ever know. What if Nukem has a direct line to the Great Programmer in the sky, or maybe his competition down below? Where would the laws of physics including the flow of time be then? Anyway you make your choice open the opaque box and Nukem the Magnificent is right again!</p><p>​</p><p>“The Dominance Solution” is supported by the idea that since time runs in only one direction, the player can olse nothing by taking the extra “K” in the transparent box; the million is either in the opaque box or it is not, and this fact is not subject to last-minute change.</p><p>​</p><p>“Expected Utility” is a striaght forward calculation of mathematical expectation based on statistical induction from Nukem’s long and unbroken string of successful predictions.</p><p>​</p><p>The Solution-One simply has to construct a payoff matrix for the game defined by the Newcomb scenario, computes the expected value for each possible move, and chooses the move with the highest value. Ha! So much for the philisophical impasse regarding Newcombe’s paradox.</p><p>​</p><p>Now we need to avail ourselves to a branch of mathematical logic called Model Theory. Model Theory- according to model theory using a theory to correctly describe some part of the world is logically equivalent to specifying a valid interpretation of that theory, which means specifying a model of the theory. In this case, the theories are the rationales used to justify the solutions, and the models of those theories are their (superficially) valid interpretations in the real world… assuming, of course, that the Newcomb scenario is possible in the real world, which is a bit of a stretch (in this context, “valid” means only “not yet invalidated”). The key ingredient of the dominance model is a one-way arrow of time, while the key ingredient of the expected utility model is a natural induction principle.</p><p>​</p><p>While neither of these ingredients is yet well understood feature of reality, neither has yet been disproved- The two facts that time flows in one direction from past to future and that concepts or principles like the laws of physics that have like the induction principal have been observed to have been constant and never changing and have worked everyday as long as humans have noticed or since the laws have been discovered have yet to be disproved. So both have been observed to be true and take place in nature but have sharply conflicting implications in the Newcomb scenerio, and therein resides the paradox.</p><p>​</p><p>Thus the conflicting elements in a hypothetical configuration of physical reality suggests that its proper resolution requires a theory and model of reality in which the relationship between these elements can be meaningfully evaluated. In other words a theory of reality in which we can explore the nature of time in an inductive context. It is important to note that weird or improbable scenarios have held the keys to new insight many times in the history of science, the far-out nature of the paradox is beside the point. Where the stakes include a better understanding of time, induction and free will, even a scenario as unlikely as Newcomb’s is worth a gander.</p><p>​</p><p>But before we get into another aspect of free will let us ask the question of what would it take to decide the question of free will? The answer depends on whether the whole universe (of which within everything else is contained) at large evolves in a deterministic or nondeterministic way. This ends up being a metaphysical question rather than merely a psychological question. Indeed, answering this question requires and understanding of not only psychology (which is science of and from the mind) and reality at large, but their logical interface… the relationship of mind and reality. In other words, it requires a comprehensive theory of reality uniting the subjective and objective sides of existence. Within the overarching framework of such a theory, psychological and neurological phenomena could finally be interpreted in a way that clarifies their deeper philisophical signifigance.</p><p>​</p><p>“The Buck Starts Here: Another Disquisition on Free Will”</p><p>​</p><p>Instead of pretending your playing an imaginary game taken from the hypothetical scenerio called “Newcomb’s Paradox”, imagine that you’re part of a scientific experiment. Except maybe not so hypothetical… In 1983 at the Neurological Institute at San Francisco’s Mount Zion Hospital and Medical Center, and reported in the journal Brain in a paper entitled Time of Conscious Intention to Act in Relation to Onset of Cerebral Activity (Rediness Potential) by Libet, Gleason, Wright and Pearl. The paper reported that after subjects were invited to make freely-timed voluntary movements of their right hands, an electrical brain wave called the Bereitschaftspotential (“readiness-potential”) appeared over the motor areas of their left cerebral hemispheres some 500 to 800 milliseconds (0.5–0.8 seconds) before they were aware of intending to act, with muscular electrical activity not appearing until its near completion another 0.2 seconds later. On the basis of these data, the experimenters concluded that voluntary neural activity appears to be preceded by physiological neural activity, and that even though awareness of intent comes almost a second after the onset of the neural activity in question, it is interpreted by the subject as having come “first”. In other words, a voluntary act may begin well in advance of the conscious intent to perform it, but the subject interprets things the other way around. That evidence is the Bereitschaftspotential brain wave appearing 500 to 800 milliseconds before they were aware of intending to act.</p><p>​</p><p>Could we really be so clueless that what we call our “intentions” are just delusions that occur only after our actions are first initiated by our subconscious minds (AKA the readiness-potential), perhaps under the rigid guidance of deterministic mechanisms in light of which we amount to little more than self-deluding automata? What could possibly be going on here? Reflex- an automatic muscular reaction that does not directly involve the brain and can’t be consciously vetoed. They have a protective punction so speed is of the essence.</p><p>​</p><p>The resulting movements from a reflex are general enough that no conscious action is required. An example is the patellar reflex, the familiar medical “knee-jerk test” in which the tendon just below the kneecap is tapped with a rubber hammer. In a healthy patient, this causes a quick, unintended outward jerk of the lower leg. Why? The tap triggers sensory nerve cells that send a message to the spinal cord. Ordinarily, sensory stimuli travel up the spinal cord to the brain for conscious processing, but not in this case. Instead, the spinal cord responds directly to motor neurons in the muscle, causing the muscle to contract and the lower leg kick out. Although the brain seems to exercise a general one-way “gating effect” influencing reflexes throughout the body, the sense-response loop or “reflex arc” never gets far enough up the spinal cord for brain-based conscious volition to specifically intervene.</p><p>​</p><p>In contrast, a voluntary movement originates not with the sensation of heat on a fingertip or a hammer to the knee, but in the brain itself, the seat of consciousness. It has always been assumed that voluntary acts are just what they appear to be: actions resulting from, and therefore following, causative volition. The chain of events is supposed to be as follows: (1) We think about something we desire, possibly on the basis of sensory input. (2) We form the goal of having it and formulate a plan to get it, even if that plan consists of only a simple body movement. (3) We execute the plan. (4) We obtain or fail to obtain the desired object or state. Where step 1 takes place in the cerebral cortex and hypothalamus (the source of drives). Step 2 involves higher-order reasoning and judgment occuring mainly in the frontal lobes. Step 3 involves those parts of the cerebral cortex specialiazed for voluntary movement, including the primary motor cortex , its associated premotor areas, and other motion-specific neural aggregates. And step 4 feeds back into the limbic system, which registers the satisfaction or frustration of the original drive.</p><p>​</p><p>Now let’s have a closer look at the distinction between a reflex and a voluntary act.</p><p>Voluntary- is purposeful and directed towards the completion of a task. Performed in response to a stimulus can cary according to the task being performed. Endogenous or internally generated. Adapted to various circumstances, and its speed and accuracy improved through practice.</p><p>reflex-merely a response to a stimulus. No task involved. Externally stimulated. Immutable</p><p>​</p><p>And because higher levels of the motor system can dissociate the informational content of a stimulus from its capacity to trigger a movement, the information can be voluntairily processed and the movement either permitted or interdicted. With a reflex, there is no such opportunity. However, the work of Libet et al introduces a new degree of similarity to voluntary and reflex actions: both are to some extent beneath awareness and therefore “unconscious in that sense of the term. In the type of voluntary act studied by Libet and his colleagues, conscious awareness is still technically in control; it precedes the act itself by 0.2 seconds and can in principle “veto” the movement even after the readinesspotential has been initiated. But regarding this point of initiation, one kind of act is no more voluntary than the other. In neither case does the act begin with conscious awareness of the intention to act. The main difference is that while something belatedly purporting to be conscious intent finally appears half a second or more after the begining of the so-called “voluntary” act, it never appears at all with the reflex. Or if one prefers, the reflex lacks the volitire equivalent of esprit de l’escalier.</p><p>​</p><p>How are these results to be interpreted? Libet himself feels that since the 200 ms separating conscious intent from muscular contraction is time enough to consciously veto or permit the movement precipitated by the readiness potential free will remains intact. Thus, although we cannot be held accountable for our apparently unconscious impulses to act, we remain accountable for whether or not we yield to them.</p><p>​</p><p>However, others have more extreme opinions. For example, C.M. Fisher (If there were No Free Will, 2001) speaks for many when he suggests that Libet’s research points to a conclusion that “may be reached on the basis of rather elementary observation…the behavior of humans represents the electrochemical activity of the brain, involuntary, devoid of will and wish. We are automatons.”</p><p>​</p><p>But as regards the question of free will, neither of these interpretations is entirely staisfactory. For while neither Libet nor Fisher holds that the data alone decide the issue, each nevertheless voices a bias regarding the existence of free will, Libet’s affirmative and Fisher’s negative. In each case the opinion posits a definite restriction on what most of the human race considers “free will” to be.</p><p>​</p><p>In fact there are other ways to explain the data. For example, the subject may unconsciously choose a target position for the circle and wait for the circle to reach this position before “deciding” to act. In this case, the readiness potential could be merely anticipatory, following the unconscious choice of a target position. Along much the same lines, the subject may choose a task and formulate an appropriate general plan on a combination of conscious and unconscious levels, delegating certain parts of the execution of this plan, as well as details of scheduling, to the unconscious mind. The unconscious mind would then take responsibility for that which has been delegated to it, executing various subtasks when appropriate and “reminding” the conscious mind of its responsibility to “intend” those acts just before committing them. The conscious mind would automatically take these cues, thereby reserving the right of final authorization and selectively permitting or interdicting the associated unconscious impulses.</p><p>​</p><p>The latter explanation incorporates several key concepts. One such concept is the mind’s supposed ability to delegate various responsibilities to conscious or unconscious levels of processing, implying that the unconscious mind can to some extent function autonomously, without benefit of direct, step-by-step conscious oversight. Another is the distinction between tasks and subtasks in goal-related processing and behavior. This distinction permits the distinction of an overall task-related decision, e.g. deciding to perform a sequence of voluntary hand movements, from constituent subtask-related decisions, e.g. deciding to perform one of the hand movements in question.</p><p>​</p><p>Yet another such concept is higher-order intentionality, or “intent to intend”. For example, intending to perform a sequence of voluntary hand movements amounts to intending to intend to perform each of the hand movements in the sequence, and where the latter (lowerorder) intentions are generated by the unconscious level of processing, they can in turn be regarded as unconscious intentions to consciously intend to permit or veto the impulses associated with the unconscious intentions themselves. We thus have a kind of “volitional loop” involving two levels of processing, and two levels of intentionality, instead of the single level usually acknowledged multilevel control loop in which the “higher” (conscious) level of volitional processing is insulated from the noise and complexity generated by the “lower”, unconscious nuts-and-bolts level, which thus functions to some extent autonomously. Does this new explanation of volitiona as a multilevel control loop have any weaknesses?</p><p>One possible weakness is the fact that because we associate control with consciousness, the very idea of “unconscious volition” seems semantically inconsistent. Relegating any part of a colitional control function to a non-conscious level of mental processing seems to contradict the premise that we possess the freedom to control our actions.</p><p>​</p><p>However, a little reflection should reveal that the horse of cognition is already long gone from the barn of consciousness anyway. If the conscious mind, which has an innate need to function within a well-defined conceptual system in order to ensure its informational integrity were even made responsible for the details of the complex, tentative, rapid-fire neural dialogue that microscopically relates one well-defined state of consciousness to its successor, cognition would immediately break down like a tired old jalopy. With a catastrophic “kapow”! from its exhaust pipe and a sad sigh of defeat from beneath its hood, it would forcibly retreat into the wakeless sleep of unrealizability. One might as well demand that the output of a computer never be acknowledged until the user has accounted for each of the millions of logical operations by means of which it was generated. Such a demand cannot be met within the bounds of practicality.</p><p>​</p><p>Above we cited an assumed chain of events comprising a voluntary act. We can now refine that chain as follows. (1) We think about something we desire, possibly on the basis of sensory input. This step amounts to consciously setting general parameters for a supertask or task sequence. (2) We form the goal of possessing the object of desire and formulate a plan to get it. This step, which may consist of numerous individual tasks or substeps, is executed on a tentative basis by the unconscious mind, which generates impulses that are subjected to conscious oversight as they become sufficiently well-defined to emerge into consciousness. (4) We obtain, or fail to obtain, the desired object or state, at which point the limbic system registers satisfaction or frustration.</p><p>​</p><p>Notice that at no point does anything come into being without the involvement of the conscious mind. The conscious mind chooses the overall task and clears or vetoes each subtask as it emerges from the unconscious background to which it was delegated under conscious oversight.</p><p>In interpreting the Libet experiment, we need simply remember that when the subject consciously accepts the task of generating a sequence of voluntary actions (subtasks) over a given period of time, the entire future contribution of the unconscious mind is automatically requisitioned. At all times, the subject is doing just what he or she has consciously agreed and decided to do, but with the indispensable help of unconscious faculties without which the conscious mind could not function. The Libet experiment merely provides data that clarify the operation of free will on the assumption that it does exist by elucidating the control dynamics of volition.</p><p>​</p><p>What if the brain’s experimental subjects, including electrical potentials and conscious ideations, could be monitored without their knowledge by means of a remote scanning procedure and the experiment were concealed to make them unaware of it? Then they would not be known by the experimenters to have agreed to a specific experimental task, and some of their actions might truly appear spontaneous. It would be interesting to see whether the Bereitschaftspotential still precedes conscious intent in all cases. But if so, could spontaneity be ascertained? It is hard to see how a voluntary act of any kind could be certified as “spontaneous” where responsibility for subtasks is automatically delegated to the unconscious mind. Any such act could be related to any purpose consciously adopted at any time in the past, and even the subject may be unable to identify the purpose in question. In principle, the unconscious mind could be involved in a complex, protracted, consciously-authorized sequence of sensorimotor transitions in which the role of a given “spontaneous” act may be quite inscrutable&gt;</p><p>​</p><p>A FREE WILL CYBER-SYNTHESIS</p><p>​</p><p>Newcomb’s Paradox, a controversial prediction paradox that highlights an apparent conflict between two basic principles: the macroscopically apparent linearity of time, whereby time flows from past to future always, and the principle of induction whereby we form conclusions about reality on the basis of what we observe. We concluded that the relationship between these principles depends on the model of reality in which we interpret them.</p><p>​</p><p>We analyzed a controversial scientific experiment which appears to show that the supposedly voluntary acts of human beings precede any conscious intent to perform them. Although Benjamin Libet, the lead scientist in that experiment opined that the free will hypothesis survives this finding intact, others believe that it proves mankind a race of automated puppets driven by laws and circumstances beyond our control. We leaned decidedly in favor of Libet in that debate, but again concluded that a final resolution of the issue would require a conceptual framework illuminating the interface between objective reality and the subjective source of volition, namely the mind. As we saw it is possible to explain the Libet experiment by positing discrete levels of intentionality, with broader and less immediate levels being regulated to the unconscious mind. Where this generalized unconscious level of self-determination is responsible for the integration of specific acts, it must initiate the preliminary stages of any voluntary act and leave only final clearance to the conscious mind; logically, this is the only way meaningful volition can work. Indeed, the role of the unconscious is simply to remind the conscious mind of its goals and notify it of an impending opportunity to act in such a way that some long-term goal will be wholly or partially achieved. Unfortunately, it is not easy to see how this applies to Newcomb’s paradox.</p><p>​</p><p>The Newcomb scenario, in which a predictor (nukem) unerringly forecasts the behavior of human subjects, and the Libet experiment, in which the subject’s own nervous system seems to play the role of “predictor” in beating consciousness to the punch, have more than a little in common: where it is assumed that a future decision process is being passively read rather than actively caused by the predictive agency they both require that the predictor make a counterintuitive leap through time. In Newcomb’s paradox, the predictor must leap into the future and back again with information about a future state or event, while in Libet et al, the subject’s unconscious mind must leap forward in time in order to “predict” an instance of conscious volition and its outcome (otherwise it would have to usurp conscious volition entirely). Nukem must predict a specific act in advance while ordinary volition requires merely reality at large provide alternative outcomes for all possible acts and their timing… provide “multiple alternative futures” in one of which a given act will result. For volition to work in either case, the body and environment must predictably mirror the neural dynamics of the brain. In other words, The picture of reality in our heads must accurately depict reality as it really is, and reality must in turn allow us to form reliable pictures of it.</p><p>​</p><p>Our success in negotiating the often-treacherous road of life depends largely on the accuracy of our pictures of reality and how closely our actions conform to them. To this extent reality is like the Newcomb predictor. If it “predicts” that our mental pictures of it are faithful and that we will act in conformance with them, it rewards our volition, while if it predicts that our pictures are inadequate, it frustrates us instead. What “pictures of reality” are we required having in our heads? First, we must have a picture that represents our bodies. At coarse resolution, this “picture” is a brain map called the motor homunculus. If the human body were a puppet and motor nerves its strings, the motor homunculus would be the internal wiring diagram that tells the brain which strings to “pull” to cause particular voluntary movements involving particular parts of the body.</p><p>Second, we must have an immediate, real-time picture of the environment with which our bodies interact and in which our movements have meaning. We get such a picture through our sense organs. Third, we must have at least a rudimentary understanding of how the world works so that we can predict the outcomes of our actions; this picture is gradually learned by experience and augmented by theoretical reasoning.</p><p>Newcomb’s paradox involves an appreciable time interval between prediction and outcome, in the middle of which resides the act that must be predicted. But in the Libet scenario and in fact for volition in general, the “prediction” is actually exhaustive provision for a full range of outcomes. No matter what we do, the world must have our reward or frustration waiting for us in advance; it can make it up on the spot no more than we can choose our goal-oriented actions without advanced planning. The burning question is how the world makes this “exhaustive prediction” with such unerring accuracy. One might object that since it is possible to build a machine that rewards those who use it correctly and frustrates those who do not and since the universe may be exactly that machine, there is no need for prediction or exhaustive provision. After all, machines function automatically. But this simply begs the question, for the “automatic” operation of any machine depends on preexisting laws of mechanics. Were the laws of mechanics to suddenly break down so would the machine. So as a first step, the laws of mechanics must be reified and maintained. Unfortunately, reifying and maintaining complete laws of mechanics is a cosmological issue very different from building a machine. When one builds a machine, there is preexisting nomological framework of which one may take advantage; in building the nomological framework itself, there is not (if there were, then instead of being excused from delivering an explanation we would simply have to explain the more nomological framework).</p><p>​</p><p>So the world’s exhaustive real-time “prediction” of our actions, and the way it rewards or frustrates us in response, is ultimately synonymous with the laws by which it enforces its own self consistency. Prediction and control are passive and active sides of the same coin; the laws that allow the world to write itself i.e. evolve, also allow it to read itself. Thus, the laws of physics double as the means by which the world detects, analyzes and evaluates our actions, and the means by which it “predicts” and readies the outcome. In providing general causal mechanisms by which the world can yield an appropriate result for every action, these laws also provide means by which the concept of “actions” would have no meaning, and the result of particular actions would not even be regular much less “appropriate”. In other words, maintaining a set of unbreakable laws, e.g. the laws of physics, amounts to predicting (or exhaustively “meta-predicting”) that anyone who tries to break those laws will definitely end up a loser. While predicting different outcomes for different actions entails a set of laws that allow actions and outcomes to be distinguished. Our real world faith in these laws is analogous to our faith in Nukem’s predictive infallibility and our willing obedience to them is analogous to our acceptance of his predictive powers as a strategic criterion. Perhaps the main difference is that while there may be doubt as to whether we can beat Nukem at his own game-his existence may, after all, be incompatible with necessary features of reality-there is very little hope that we can beat reality itself. For while we are physically separate from Nukem the Magnificant, reality contains all living beings and does not permit them to violate its laws.</p><p>​</p><p>​</p><p>As we observed Newcomb’s paradox pits the principle of induction against the idea that time flows exclusively from past to future. Either we can reason from local reality to global reality, or we can continue to think of time as nothing but an orderly past-to-future sequence, but not both (as we can see from the way these principles support conflicting decisions in the Newcomb scenario). Because the principle of induction permits us to attribute generality to laws active in our local vicinity it has a “metapredictive” aspect; it lets us “predict” that observations distant in space or time, regardless of specific content, will be similar to local observations (although this principle is troubled by the aptly-named “problem of induction”, we use it out of necessity anyway). But as we have just observed, prediction and control are passive and active sides of the same coin, in some respects, enforcing laws is equivalent to “proactively predicting” the outcomes of a set of possible actions. Thus, the predictive principle of induction is in some respects equivalent to a control function that distributes general laws over space and time. Do science and mathematics offer us any insight on matters of control? As it happens, all of this is right up the alley of a relatively young field of mathematics called cybernetics. Creator: MIT Wunderkind Norbert Wiener as “the science of control and communication in animal and machine “, pits freedom against constraint in biological systems consisting of multiple control strata, with higher strata dominating lower ones in overall self-regulatory relationships. The central dynamical concept is the feedback loop, whereby actions or instructions issued by a control object affect a controlled object, which sends information on its new state back to the controller, which then updates its routine to further maintain or adjust the state of the controlee (and round and round they go in more or less complex flow diagrams). Cybernetics, the mathematical bedrock of the computer age, is about as close as mainstream science has yet come to forming a mechanical picture of purposive, goal-oriented behavior. However cybernetics confines its explanations of mechanics or biological systems analogous to electronic computers. Regarding the metaphysical phase of control concerned with selecting, enacting and distributing laws and forces that allow machines to be built, cybernetics yields only silence. Cybernetics in a self contained system explains it on a mechanical level through internal feedback. Where a system isn’t self contained cybernetics pursues mechanical control and feedback past the systemic boundary into the environment. But beyond this, cybernetics makes the usual round of too-convenient assumptions, e.g. that it is possible to regress from one control level to another ad infinitum and that because explanatory regression through successive control strata never terminates, pre-mechanical or metaphysical considerations need never be addressed. The system of interest is simply placed within a nested series of mechanical systems within systems through which control and feedback can be plotted. But the universe is more than a mechanical system it is a nomological “predictor” of all that it contains. The universe is so powerful a predictor it can allow for all possible acts by providing a possible outcome for everyone of them. As Newcomb’s paradox reminds us, we usually think of time as one-dimensional and one-directional, a linear dimension along which the present moves from past to future. Unfortunately, this kind of time is simply too limited to support nomological meta prediction, providing means and explanation, along with that which is to be explained, requires the existence of a control level above that of time itself…a level representing hidden temporal structure. What is the nature of this stratification? Cybernetics can offer some pointers. First let’s try a cybernetic player game based on a computer simulation or virtual reality. There are two control levels 1. One simulated 2.Simulative, to which correspond the roles of “subject” and “programmer”.</p><p>Programmer-is in charge of a computer on whose monitor runs a simulation containing the subject, controls the subject and his fate. As far as the subject is concerned, the programmer is a veritable “master of time”, having the ability to fast-forward, reverse and replay the simulation at will. Objective: Occupy the role of a programmer. There’s a third “role” to consider: The game’s Designer. Because the designer makes the rules that the player(s) must obey, this is an important role indeed.</p><p>There are four possible positions in the 2-player game version.</p><p>(1) Player A and player B are both subjects. In this case, neither controls the game and it’s a toss-up.</p><p>(2) A is in the role of a programmer and B the subject. In this case, A controls the game so A wins.</p><p>(3) B-Programmer A-Subject. In this case B controls and wins.</p><p>(4) A and B are programmers- forced to cooperate which leads to a draw.</p><p>Newcomb’s paradox- Newcomb is player A and his subject is player B; the Newcomb scenario corresponds to position 2. Nukem always wins. Nukem is definitely in the role of a programmer. He determines the outcome whether or not the subject chooses to cooperate. Whats important is what cybernetics tells us about where he is sitting: somewhere above the subject in a control hierarchy.</p><p>Let’s consider the Libet experiment. In this scenario, there is only one player, the experimental subject. In the solitaire version of this game, a lone player must lay both roles, and the only possible object of the game is therefore self-control. But what is self control? It is precisely that which enables voluntary action. The experimental subject, in attempting to commit a string of voluntary acts, is trying to simultaneously put himself in the role of a programmer and subject so that he can control and perform his own movements. According to our explanation for the peculiar timing of the neural events involved in this endeavor, the subject executes his duties as “Programmer” in two phases relegated to his unconscious and conscious mind respectively.</p><p>Notice what this says about the relationship between the Newcomb and Libet scenarios. In displacing the player from the role of a programmer, Nukem is either usurping the player’s self-control and thus depriving him of free will, or making sure that whatever self-control the player insists on retaining turns out to be disappointingly unprofitable. In the latter case Nukem must do something more impressive than merely controlling the player; he must control the contents of a certain box to ensure that the player is robbed of success and thereby punished for his or her willfulness. In other words in making his prediction, Nukem must control some part of the subject-enviroment complex in a way that violates our intuitive notions of time and causality.</p><p>What about the designer of the game? Because the Designer makes the rules, and because rules are analogous to laws, the Designer’s real-world analogue is the universal principle responsible for selecting, distributing and enforcing the laws of reality, and thereby setting the stage for volition. This represents a higher level of control than those occupied by programmer and subject; the programmer derives his ‘programmatic’ ability to see into and/or control future states of reality subjective and objective alike, wholly from the Designer. That this applies to volition in general should now be clear as a bell.</p><p>There’s still the problem of whether or not free will exists but if its set-up were this easy the issue would’ve been answered long before we got to it.</p><p>Where does it all lead? To exciting new extensions of cybernetics? And other fields of mathematics? New inroads in physics and cosmology? To new insights regarding theological concepts like God, the human soul, and ethical refinements based on an enhanced understanding of good and evil? As a matter of fact yes it does. But why not leave a little something for later?</p><p>Solution for the Problems of Free Will, Good and Evil, Consciousness and God</p><p>We’ll now try to extract some momentous implications from the little thread we got going. Specifically, we’re going to show that free will definitely exists. Then we’re going to explain that while this doesn’t necessarily mean that human beings possess it in a ny immediate sense, there are good reasons to believe that they do.</p><p>Now in relation to the virtual reality game described in the last chapter there were three control levels altogether. Control flows downward through these levels, from designer to programmer to subject. Due to the quality and quantity of control associated with the role of designer, the designer has a clear theological analogue: God. In the contest of the game, denying the existence of the Designer would amount to asserting that despite the complex structural organization of the Game, it is random in origin.</p><p>Let’s begin by reviewing a few historical viewpoints regarding the free will issue. First, we have the idea, dear to the hearts of most of us and especially to those who framed the U. S. constitution and other rational codes of law and ethics, that human beings have free will. We acknowledge laws of causality that apply to everyone regardless of time or place e.g. “for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction”-these are not sufficient to control our behavior, leaving us free to “make our own laws” when it comes to our personal preferences. This corresponds to the solitaire version of the game, but with a tacit restriction on the fast-forward, reverse and replay options: they are usually considered to be exclusively ‘mental”, i.e. confined to our respective thought processes.</p><p>Then we have determinism-the idea that the laws of causality determine our every move. Impulses triggered in our minds and bodies by external stimuli are completely motivated by the laws of physics, reductively including the laws of genetics, biology and psychology. There is no causal gap in which free will can find a toehold. This corresponds to a version of the game in which the Designer leaves no open controls for the programmer to use; the structure of the game, as fixed by the Designer, absolutely controls the simulation and the subject.</p><p>Randomism- the idea that causality is only an illusion and that everything, including human behavior, is utterly random. This represents a bizarre mutation of the game in which one or both of the following condition hold.</p><p>(1) The Designer is absent, dead, or out to lunch; the Game, and its rules of causality and inter level control, exist solely by “chance”. An obvious drawback it fails to account for the probabilistic laws of chance themselves.</p><p>(2) Causality doesn’t exist they only supposed to exist by the subject and break down where the subject’s powers of self-delusion end, beyond which chance rules openly. When a subject is assuming to make a decision he’s actually rolling the die, and somehow, his sequential delusions of intent, action outcome perfectly match the dice roll. This seems to give a whole new meaning to the term “improbable”.</p><p>Predestination- The idea God looks at a person, measures his or her tendencies towards goodness and/or badness, predict how the person will decide to behave in his or her particular setting, and consign that person’s soul to heaven or hell on that” basis. Where God’s insight relies on the existence of laws that transform information on a person’s innate tendencies and environmental conditions to information on behavior-these laws are ostensibly what he uses to make his prediction-predestination amounts to determinism with a theological twist. Where God determines both personality of the subject and the laws that determine his behavior, this boils down to the following scenario: God makes a person, sizes up his handiwork, says either (a) “Man, am I good!” or (b) “screwed up again!” and tosses his newest creation onto the pile marked “Heaven Bound” or Born to Lose”. If you happen to be a Calvinist, this is your lot in life.</p><p>However there is another strain of predestination, favored by (e.g.) the Roman Catholic Church, that does not rely on determinism. According to this version of the doctrine, God might instead do one of the following.</p><p>(1) Scan the subject for freely-formed higher-order intent. As we recall, persistent higher-order intent is what the experimental subject generates in agreeing to participate in the Libet experiment and move his hand repeatedly at will. To capture the theological flavor of predestination compare this to “what the subject generates in freely selling his soul to the devil and agreeing to commit a lifelong string of felonies and misdemeanors”.</p><p>(2) Let the subject play out and determine his own simulation then use the rewind control to back up to the subject’s moment of birth and invisibly stamp him “Accepted” or “Rejected”. In this case, God is simply jumping forward in time to observe the subject’s timeline, and then jumping back through time to affix the proper invisible label to its origin. This kind of predestination leaves room for free will.</p><p>Notice where free will is absent, the mind is reduced to a mere byproduct of deterministic material reality. Consciousness including the psychological sensation of intentionality and self-awareness in general, becomes a kind of meaningless sideshow compulsively played by our irrelevant “minds”, as we are forced to call them, to interpret that which they cannot affect. The idea that the mind is just a side effect of objective physical processes is called epiphenomenalism. One is truly intrinsic to our material brains and bodies, or just some kind of ethereal thread. But either way if intentionality has nothing to do with the structure of reality, then matter and the laws of physics are all that really count. Our minds are just along for the ride. While cybernetics is a respected branch of modern science it is based on a naïve understanding of causality which holds that with respect to anything not locked into a determinative causal relationship, randomness prevails. For example, modern physics characterizes reality on three scales: the overall cosmic scale, the macroscopic scale of ordinary objects, and the ultramicroscopic scale of atoms and subatomic particles, to which it applies the rules of relativity, classical mechanics and quantum mechanics respectively (where relativity is understood as a classical theory. Unfortunately, the dichotomy between “classical” and quantum reality is essentially the same as that between causality and randomness or determinacy and indeterminacy. It thus excludes all of the above scenarios except determinism and randomism leaving free will with no apparent scientific explanation.</p><p>Determinacy and indeterminacy… at first glance, there seems to be no middle ground. Events are either causally connected or they are not, then the future would seem to be utterly independent of the past. Either we use causality to connect the dots and draw a coherent picture of time, or we settle for a random scattering of independent dots without spatial or temporal pattern and thus without meaning. But there is another possibility after all: self-determinacy. One can be the author of one’s own personal “causality”, setting up a volitional feedback loop between one’s will and one’s goals, where “goals” include everything from spontaneous bodily movements to the fruits of long labor and well-laid, well-executed plans.</p><p>Self-determinism means that one determines one’s own path independently of general laws of causality, where “independence” describes a situation in which one is constrained by, but also free to exploit at will, the laws of physics and biology. Despite randomness and causality there is enough room between them for human beings who are parts of reality to get a word in “edgewise” and have the final say in the determination of reality.</p><p>How is this possible given that the general laws of causality, linear and chaotic, are the only things short of “quantum randomness” that can possibly account for the structure of reality as a whole? It is possible only if there is more to the overall structure of reality than randomness or the laws of causality can fully determine, and only if human beings possess a means of shaping this extra structure at will. So if meaningful volition exists, reality itself must have meaning, and there must be an objective, meaningful scale on which its value can be gauged.</p><p>In order to be objective something must be “real”. On what real, objective scale can reality be measured? If we define reality in the most straightforward and tautological way, namely as “that which contains all and only that which is real”, no such thing as an external scale is possible. For by our definition, anything real enough to quantify reality from the outside is already included in reality and therefore on the inside! Since this is a logical contradiction the idea that reality can be externally evaluated is logically invalid. This implies that in order to possess meaningful existence and thus be capable of supporting meaningful volition, reality must be “self evaluating”. All of its value scales must be internal to it, and its meaning must be intrinsic.</p><p>In the traditional view of science, that which is not random must be created or selected according to ambient (externally extended) principles of causality. But where external causality requires external scales against which to be defined, it can no more possess real existence than the external scales themselves. Again, anything real enough to affect reality from the outside is already included in reality and therefore on the inside, and since this is a logical contradiction, the idea of external causality is a priori invalid with respect to reality. This implies that in order to possess meaningful existence and therefore support meaningful volition, reality must be “self-caused”. But this comprehensive kind of self-causation entails an even deeper form of self-determination than that usually associated with volition; reality must not only determine its own structure independently of external causality, but must do so starting with nothing but itself! In other words, the universe must possess a global analogue of free will that lets it internally define and calibrate the scale which intrinsic value is internally measured.</p><p>Are we ignoring the possibility that the universe is simply “random”, i.e. uncaused? Not really, externally speaking, that’s exactly what it is!</p><p>In deducing that the universe is unaffected by external causality, we find that it is externally acausal or “random” in that specific sense of the term. And since our observations of a coherent, well regulated, profoundly ordered universe rule out the possibility of internal randomness from the start there is no way that a system as coherent and complex as the real universe can be accurately described as “randomly disordered” So reality being self-determinative but externally unconstrained, possesses a global, self-enabling analogue of free will that generates its own means of realization. If these means can be utilized by human beings within reality, then human beings possess free will, and because they are included in reality, they can use it to contribute to the realization of the global self-structuring imperative. On the other hand, even if human beings cannot avail themselves of free will, they can still be used by it for the same purpose.</p><p>(3) Let</p><p>(The phrase “Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe” contains three main ingredients: cognitive theory, model, and universe. Cognitive theory refers to a general language of cognition (the structural and transitional rules of cognition); universe refers to the content of that language, or that to which the language refers; and model refers to the mapping which carries the content into the language, thus creating information. The way in which the title brings these three ingredients together, or “contracts” their relationship to the point of merging, reflects their perfect coincidence in that to which the title implicitly refers, i.e., reality (the physical universe plus all that is required to support its perception and existence). Thus, the CTMU is a theory which says that reality is a self-modeling universal language, or if one prefers, that the universe is a self-modeling language.</p><p>The operation of combining language, universe, and model to create a perfectly self-contained metalanguage results in SCSPL, short for Self-Configuring Self-Processing Language. This language is “self-similar” in the sense that it is generated within a formal identity to which every part of it is mapped as content; its initial form, or grammatical “start symbol”, everywhere describes it on all scales. My use of grammatical terminology is intentional; in the CTMU, the conventional notion of physical causality is superseded by “telic causation”, which resembles generative grammar and approaches teleology as a natural limit. In telic causation, ordinary events are predicated on the generation of closed causal loops distributing over time and space. This loop-structure reflects the fact that time, and the spatial expansion of the cosmos as a function of time, flow in both directions — forward and backward, outward and inward — in a dual formulation of causality characterizing a new conceptualization of nature embodied in a new kind of medium or “manifold”.</p><p>For now, we may simply observe that science consists of building accurate conceptual models of the world, and that the theory of models has thus become a crucial ingredient of scientific reality. Perhaps the most distinctive characteristic of model theory is its use of “metalanguages”, or languages that talk about languages, to analyze the mappings, or correspondences, between scientific theories and their universes of discourse. Logically, such metalanguages amount to relationships between theoretical cognition and perceptual reality… or with a slight frame shift, between the mind and the real world of scientific observations. Because these relationships do more than just describe reality — because they turn out to be primary conditions of its existence — they distribute over it on all scales, uniting the ubiquitous subjective and objective sides of its nature. cognitive models become more sophisticated, cognition becomes increasingly abstract; concepts become increasingly independent of the particular objects they describe. Among the first things to be abstracted are space and time. The most general abstract system incorporating both is a language. Although the term “language” usually refers to a natural language like English, it is actually more general. Mathematically, a formal language consists of three ingredients: a set of elements to be combined as strings (e.g., symbols, memes), a set of structural rules governing their arrangement in space, and a set of grammatical rules governing their transformations in time. Together, the latter two ingredients form the syntax of the language. It follows that neural, cognitive-perceptual, and physical systems can be described as languages, and the laws which govern them as their syntaxes. level, time itself can be abstractly characterized as the grammar of the joint language of cognition and perception. The rules of this grammar are the general ingredients of subjective time. The origin of our time concept, the self, becomes the origin of time itself. Our cognitive models of time become a model of time-ascognition. And the languages of cognition and physics become one self-configuring, self-processing language of which time is the unified grammar. Talk about “time out of mind”! )</p><p>In either case while the using versus used question remains up in the air humans are integral parts of reality that contribute to its structure, and must either be using the inherent freedom of reality to do so, or be freely used as tools by some higher level of reality to the same end. So whether it belongs to the universe or man also free will exists.</p><p>Convincing cybernetic evidence that we participate in the self creation of reality-Because intentional self-creation entails an internal stimulus response dynamic consisting of feedback, any self configuring system needs internal sensors (agents, internal self-proxies) capable of not only recognizing and affecting its state from local internal vantages, but of responding to higher-level instructions tending to enforce global structure criteria. Moreover the system must possess a stratified utility function allowing it and its agents to prefer one possible future over another. Humans are useful to reality on both of these accounts. The first criterion then of reality is the possibility, and in fact the inevitability, of the existence of “sensors” just like us…Sensors with an advanced capacity to recognize, evaluate and respond to internal states of the system.</p><p>How in general would the universe self-configure? It would select itself from a set of internally-generated internally-refined structural possibilities in order to maximize its self-defined value. In the (somewhat inadequate) terminology of quantum mechanics, this set of possibilities is called its quantum wave function or QWF, and the utility maximizing self selection principle is traditionally called teleology. In explaining this self-actualization mechanism, human beings would select their specific goals from the global QWF according to their own specific self selection principles or “teleses”. In the course of being realized, these individual teleses would interfere with teleology (and each other) in a constructive or destructive way. In this case the “good”, or teleologically constructive is distinguished from bad or teleologically destructive. Free will would give people a real choice between good and evil a choice that already seems to exist.</p><p>Doesn’t the question of good and evil evoke theology? Yes! “God” is just the name we give to the protean creative principle that generates and enforces teleology, or equivanlently, that entity whose “will” equals teleology. This is the entity whose self-structuring operations are guided by teleology namely, reality, we have a measure of equivalence between reality and God. This means reality can be mathematically modeled as a self-configuring self-processing Language (SCSPL), a dynamic system possessing not just a global analogue of volition i.e. teleology, but a global analogue of self-awareness as well, i.e. SCSPL self processing. Where “consciousness” is an attribute with active and passive dimensions amounting to volition and self-awareness, “God” and “reality” are equally good answers for the question “what entity possesses the global form of consciousness described by SCSPL? In other words as we expected God is the ultimate reality.</p><p>This brings us back to the notion “God” is a real-world analogue of the Designer in our cybernetic Game. But now the game is reality, its object is the Designer’s own self-creation, and any number of players occupying any number of lower control strata are just participants in the self-configuration of the reality they inhabit (for now we’ll ignore the long running debate over whether God can inject Himself into the bottom-level simulation as a “messiah”, simply answering “yes” and leaving it at that). When we use freedom we inherit from reality at large to properly choose our teleses and exercise our powers of veto we favorably tilt the balance between teleology and anti-teleology, good and evil, and thus inherit meaning in the bargain. This meaning enriches our lives and sustains the conscious identities with which reality has endowed us as its internal proxies.</p><p>On the Perils of Metaphysical Skysurffing</p><p>Without a parachute-although we often forget to act like it, human beings are indisputably the brightest bulbs on the evolutionary tree. We are the ones who climbed to the top of the evolutionary ladder.., spectacularly outsmarted the biological competition cleaned up in the All-Time Grey Matter Sweepstakes. So much for the creatures that preceded us on the timeline of creation, what of those which came after us… the creatures of metal, plastic, and silicon we birthed to aid us in our physical and mental labors? Here the same applies a fortiori. Regardless of horsepower, clock rate or memory capacity, none of our machines can hold a candle to even the weakest among us. For machines merely obey the laws of physics, while we alone can study, formulate and manipulate those laws to our advantage. Ours are the hands on switch and dial, on mouse and keyboard, on tiller and wheel, on gas hose and power plug. Without our protection and guidance, even our most durable machines would be naturally selected for fast extinction. We are human not just because of our intelligence, but because of our will to control… our will to supremacy. Not satisfied with our quantitative superiority of intelligence we philosophically transform it into a qualitative difference setting us forever apart from other animate and inanimate entities. Historically this difference was expressed in statements like “human beings have souls; machines and lower animals do not.” Because this is an age of science, and science pretends to have no use for that which cannot be empirically demonstrated, such statements are now heard a bit less frequently. A tacit but unbreakable confidence in the unique nature of human consciousness and its sovereign place in the eternal hierarchy of being, this qualitative difference is central to our ethos. It is central to what we call “the meaning of life” and to our own meanings as individuals. And because it is absolutely essential to our collective self-importance, we like to think of it as anything but accidental. Indeed if it has any real significance, it cannot be a quirk of fate, a chance pattern of spots on the cosmic dice. Our claim to preeminence must be based not on mere physical dominion but on metaphysical distinctiveness. We are what and who we are because this is how it was meant to be.</p><p>Unfortunately, certain trends in science threaten to kill it nonetheless. For example our vaunted intelligence dolphins, porpoises and other cetaceans display playfulness, task learning ability and mental agility impressive even to humans. A strain of lab mice called “Doogie mice”- Remember Doogie Hauser?- are bred for high densities of brain proteins called NR2B receptors that enhance their performance on task-based animal intelligence tests, narrowing the IQ gap between humans and rodents. Researchers locating human genes associated with high IQ to genetically engineer super-smart drugs to cause IQ spikes of 50 extra points. How special is intelligence if it can be dispensed from a bottle or syringe to humans and animals alike?</p><p>Even if task performance has a biological basis, could there be something special in our use of language? Well, not necessarily. Human linguistic ability has been localized to brain modules, like Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas, that seem to have counterparts in the brains of some animals. A monkey’s pre-motor cortex contains an area known as F5 that is considered analogous to Broca’s area and contains special cells, called “mirror neurons”, that appear to be present in human brains as well. Meanwhile certain African grey parrots can seemingly hold rudimentary but meaningful conversations involving both quality and quantity. Great apes like gorillas and chimpanzees, with which we share up to 98% of our DNA, regularly communicate using sign language vocabularies of thousands of words. If certain studies are correct, enough to rival the functional vocabularies of many humans.</p><p>What about empathy in our language is empathy unique to humans a distinctive spiritual human attribute? Not by the look of recent findings. Having noted that the brain of a human observer generates excitatory patterns that mirror patterns in the brain of someone performing a task, a team of researchers has examined monkey brains and found a new class of brain cells in which such mirrored patterns reside. The location? F5! The sympathetic firing of these “mirror neurons” bids fair to be the neural equivalent of empathy. No longer is empathy a moral and spiritual attribute of personhood of social human social interaction. Like the jerk of a tapped knee and the dilation of a pupil in sudden darkness, empathy appears to be just another biological phenomenon reducible to the ubiquitous of proton, neutron, and electron in random chunks of matter.</p><p>So much for vaunted intelligence and empathy as evidence for human spiritual ascendancy, what of spirituality itself? World literature has several telling adumbrations of modern scientific research. Fyodor Dostoievsky described in his tragicomic novel The Idiot, Fyodor Dostoievsky described the expansive feeling of beatitude experienced by his protagonist Prince Myshkin just prior to the onset of epileptic seizures. In so far as Dostoievsky himself suffered from epilepsy, these fictionalized accounts seem to have been taken directly from the author’s personal experience… and the Great Russian novelist was far from alone. Many patients afflicted with temporal lobe epilepsy have reported that when a spell overtakes them, they “see God” or experience “enlightenment”. Searching for an explanation, neurologists were finally able to find a connection between temporal lobe epilepsy and spontaneous religious feelings: epileptic seizures can stimulate a structure called the “God Module” (!) in the temporal-limbic region of the human brain. Inspired by such successes, science is now looking at the neurological correlates of religious experience in general. This emerging field “neuro-theology” has a central premise: that feeling of spirituality are due to the genetic wiring of the human nervous system. Neuro-theological researchers recently conducted an unusual experiment where Tibetan Buddhist tugged on a strand of twine as he entered a state of meditative transcendence. Upon the prearranged signal, a researcher injected a radioactive racer into an IV line attached to the subject’s arm and scanned his brain with a SPECT. SPECT’S circuits registered a dramatic reduction in neural activity within a specialized region at the top rear of his brain…, an area known to be responsible for translating sensory data into comprehension of the boundary between self and environment. Having shut down his “self-delimiter” module” by meditative sensory deprivation, the subject had destroyed the subjective distinction between internal and external reality and become “one with the universe”. According to brain scans, praying makes Franciscan nuns feel “oneness with God” by suppressing the activity of their self-delimiter modules. The neural aspects of religion are by no means confined to meditation and prayer. A 1997 Japenese study showed rhythmic repetition of ritual chanting and dancing causes a certain brain component, the hypothalamus to generate a mantra transports a yogi to a state of deep inner calm, Sufi mystics feverishly dance themselves to states of excitement in which they feel like “live wires” crackling with the infinite energy of the universe. But does this provide evidence for anything of an objectively transcendental nature? The response of neuro-theology to this question is; given the physical nature of that which is to be explained, there is no need for such a hypothesis.</p><p>The elevated status of human consciousness grows ever more precarious upon the swaying tightrope of metaphysical distinctiveness. First came violence for the physical basis of consciousness in the various aphasias and apraxias associated with brain lesions; then came the frontal assault of operant conditioning on free will; now we have brain-scanned nuns and the possibility of genetically engineered intellectual and spiritual “geniuses”. Intelligence, language, empathy, spirituality… all of our claims to metaphysical distinctiveness seems to be falling beneath the heartless scythe of physical reductionism. Fortunately, we are not facing an ideological dead end for our renewed confirmation of our “specialness” in the scheme of things. Just ahead on the intellectual horizon looms a new science of metaphysics… a logical framework in which the importance of humankind is unthreatened by reductionism, and in which the significance of human feelings and emotions is uncompromised by their correlation with lowly biological processes. Rather than declaring us the abject slaves of natural laws beyond our control, this framework yields a new understanding of space and time in which the very laws of physics can be viewed as an expression of our minds. For now we may simply observe that science consists of building accurate conceptual models of the world, and that the theory of models has thus become a crucial ingredient of scientific reality. Perhaps the most distinctive characteristic of model theory is its use of “metalanguages”, or languages that talk about languages, to analyze the mappings, or correspondences, between scientific theories and their universe of discourse. Logically, such meta-languages amount to relationships between theoretical cognition and perceptual reality… or between the mind and the real world of scientific observations. Because these relationships do more than just describe reality-because they turn out to be primary conditions of its existence- they distribute over it on all scales uniting the ubiquitous subjective and objective sides of its nature. The universal distribution of these relationships implies the existence of a homogeneous cognitive and perceptual medium embracing the real universe and propagating the influence of our minds throughout the cosmos. Within the distinctive logical structure of this medium, time and causality turn out not to be confined to the familiar past-to-future direction. Instead, the future-past direction becomes important. The bi-directionality of time implies that the universe is in a state of extended spatiotemporal self-superposition, each of its serial configurations, as defined at each successive moment of time, in contact with all others. At first this seems to say that the universe is completely determined … that as Laplace believed, every state in the universe is implicit in any state. Not only is such an assumption unnecessary, it would ultimately lead to intractable inconsistencies. In fact, the logical structure of space time provides the universe with the wherewithal of being, endowing it with self-creative freedom and permitting it to rise from a sea of undifferentiated ontological potential.</p><p>What does this have to do with neuro-theology? Insofar as God is generally defined as the Prime Mover or first principle of reality, God is by definition real, and thus a part of the real universe. This 1st principle is by definition primary — because there is by definition no preexisting reality to contain it-reality cannot properly include it, so the real universe must coincide with God; scientific knowledge is theological knowledge, and science a form of theology. It follows that our ability to use science to better the plight of our species-our capacity to know God and to help others know God- is part of what makes us “special”. And where true science is a key ingredient of our claim to metaphysical distinctiveness, our place in the hierarchy of being cannot be threatened by science done thoroughly, correctly, and without a priori restrictions on our role in the scheme of things. But what is that role? Where does humanity fit into the scheme even now being revealed to us by science…? It turns out we are microsms, images of the universe within the universe. And because of the symmetric connection between source and image, cosmos and mircrocosm, we function as agents through whom the universe realizes its being. We are its children and heirs, poised on the threshold of adulthood and charged with shaping destiny itself, with helping the living universe choose its form and content from a background of undifferentiated potential. Though eons removed from the moment of creation, we actively retrodcit it, sending the power of our minds back through time to help the Prime Mover, our parent and provider, self-creatively embody the universe we inhabit.</p><p>A Brief History of Time (summed up by Chris Langan)</p><p>Unlike a slug whose nervous system has barely enough complexity to let it interface with the environment, a man’s nervous system, nucleated by the adaptive and inventive human brain, can abstractly model its surroundings and project itself consciously and creatively through time. Because the slugs brain can’t form an internal model of its changing relationship with the garden, the slug can’t recognize its memories as “changes”; the state of its nervous system at any given moment can pass for all that is has ever known. The neural function by which the slug identifies self is instinctual and perceptual as opposed to cognitive- because the slug “defines itself” strictly by non-reflective instinctual processing of environmental stimuli-the dependent neural function time is limited to here-and now. The slug recognizes no past self or future self on which to define an extended temporal relationship. Our awareness of time depends on the extent to which our mental models of reality reflect change. To see an object change, one must recall one’s former perception of it. Because perception is an interaction between self and environment, this amounts to bringing one’s former self into conjunction with one’s present self.</p><p>The fact that past and present selves can be brought into conjunction across a temporal interval implies that momentary selves remain sufficiently alike to be conjoined, that they can intersect at any given moment to compare content means that the intersection is changeless. So when self is generalized as the intersection of all momentary selves, it acquires a property called time invariance. It is the rock of perception, the unchanging observation post from which the net of temporal connections is cast and to which it remains anchored. Indeed, it is the fabric from which the net is woven, its relationship with the environment serving as the universal template for all temporal relationships.</p><p>Through learning, mental models of time evolve in time. As the brain’s neural connections are modified and the strengths of existing connections are adjusted to account for new information regarding both self and environment-as it learns-its model of time changes as a function of time. In other words, the model changes with that which is modeled. If the brain is smart enough, then it can model itself in the process of being changed, and depict its own learning process at a higher level of time. But even as the self absorbs its educational history and deepens its reflexive understanding it remains static at its core. Otherwise, it would lose temporal flow it describes. This description arises by abstraction. As cognitive models become more sophisticated, cognition becomes increasingly abstract; concepts become increasingly independent of the particular objects they describe. Among the first things to be abstracted are space and time. The most general abstract system incorporating both is a language. Although the term “language” usually refers to a natural language like English, it is actually more general. Mathematically, a formal language consists of three ingredients: a set of elements to be combined as strings (e.g., symbols, memes), a set of structural rules governing their arrangement in space, and a set of grammatical rules governing their transformations in time. Together, the latter two ingredients form the syntax of the language. It follows that neural, cognitive-perceptual, and physical systems can be described as languages, and the laws which govern them as their syntaxes. level, time itself can be abstractly characterized as the grammar of the joint language of cognition and perception. The rules of this grammar are the general ingredients of subjective time. Because time is defined in terms of transformations among spatial arrangements of objects, it is conceptually entwined with space. Thus its actually a part of a linguistic complex called space time. Spatiotemporal relations exist on many levels; if level one consists of simple relationships of objects in space and time, then level two consists of relationships of such relationships, and so on. Because logic is stratified in much the same way, one can say that time is stratified in a manner corresponding to predicate logic. This must be true in any case, since any meaningful description of time is logically formulated. Spatiotemporal stratification allows time to be viewed on various scales corresponding to ascending series of contexts: e.g. personal awareness, interpersonal relationships, social evolution, evolutionary biology, and so on. The histories of people, institutions, cultures, and species are nested like Chinese boxes, with the abstract principals of each history occupying a level of temporal grammar corresponding to an order of predicate logic. Because of the relation between self-awareness and temporal awareness, temporal stratification induces a stratification of self. What we have already described as the static intersect of momentary selves becomes a stratified relationship… a terrace of temporal vantages conducing to long-term self-integration. As the self becomes stratified, the principles abstracted from higher orders of experience tend to be objectivized due to their generality with science and philosophy among the results. Thus, the subjective and objective sides of reality-the self and the environment-tend to merge in a symmetric way. On one hand, the environment is absorbed by the self through experience, and the laws of nature are thereby abstracted; on the other hand, the self is projected onto the environment in such a way that it “selects” the laws of nature by analogy to its own internal laws. Either way, the core self tends to intersect with the environment as momentary selves are intersected within it. This brings the subjective and objective phases of reality-and time- into closer correspondence, blurring the distinction between them from an analytic standpoint.</p><p>As time grows more abstract ways are sought to measure it and analyze it numerically. This requires a universal depiction of space and time against which arbitrary processes can be differentially graphed and metered. Such a depiction was introduced by the Frenchmen Rene Descartes in the 17th century. It was called analytic geometry, and it depicted time and the dimensions of space as straight, mutually perpendicular axes. In analytic geometry, any set of numerically-scaled space and time axes associated with any set of properties or attributes defines a coordinate system for assigning numbers to points, and simple processes appear as the graphs of algebraic functions. A few decades later, Newton and Leibniz independently discovered a new kind of math, infinitesimal calculus, by which to numerically quantify the rates of such processes. These innovations, which laid the foundations of modern science and engineering, suffice to this day in many practical contexts. Even though garden-variety analytic geometry was superseded by the Theory of Relativity which was constructed on an analytic-geometric foundation- it gives a very close approximation of relativity in most situations. Unfortunately, the conveniences of analytic geometry came at the price of mind-body dualism. This was Descartes’ idea that the self, or “mind”, was a nonphysical substance that could be left out of physical reasoning with impunity. For some purposes, this was true. But as we saw in the nextto-last paragraph, the relationship of mind to reality is not that simple. While the temporal grammar of physics determines the neural laws of cognition, cognitive grammar projects itself onto physical reality in such a way as to determine the form that physical grammar must assume. Because the form of physical grammar limits the content of physical grammar, this makes cognition a potential factor in determining the laws of nature. In principle, cognitive and physical grammars may influence each other symmetrically.</p><p>The symmetric influence of cognitive and physical grammars implies a directional symmetry of time. Although time is usually seen as a one-way street, it need not be; the mere fact that a street is marked “one way” does not stop it from being easily traveled in the unauthorized direction. Indeed, two-way time shows up in both quantum physics and relativity theory the primary mainstays of modern physics. Thus, it is not physically warranted to say that cognition cannot influence the laws of physics because the laws of physics “precede cognition in time”, if we look at the situation from the other direction, we can easily say that cognition “precedes” the laws of physics in reverse time… and point to the strange bidirectional laws of particle physics to justify our position. These laws are of such a nature that they can as well be called laws of perception as laws of physics.</p><p>Physical reasoning sometimes requires a distinction between two kinds of time: ordinary time and cosmic time. Observations made at normal velocities, ordinary time behaves in a way described by Newtonian analytic geometry; at higher velocities, and in the presence of strong gravitational fields, it behaves according to Einstein’s Special and General Theories of Relativity. After Einstein formulated his General Theory, it was discovered that the universe, AKA space time, was expanding. Because cosmic expansion seems to imply that the universe began as a dimensionless point, the universe must have been created and the creation event must have occurred on a higher level of time: cosmic time. Whereas ordinary time accommodates changes occurring within the space time manifold, this is obviously not so for the kind of time in which the manifold itself changes.</p><p>It is the nature of the cognitive self to formulate models incorporating ever-higher levels of change (or time). Obviously, the highest level of change is that characterizing the creation of reality. Prior to the moment of creation, the universe was not there; afterwards, the universe was there. This represents a sizable change indeed! It also constitutes a sizable paradox. If the creation of reality was a real event, and if this event occurred in cosmic time then cosmic time itself is real. But then cosmic time is an aspect of reality and can only have been created with reality. This implies that cosmic time, and in fact reality, must have created themselves!</p><p>The idea that the universe created itself brings a whole new meaning to bidirectional time, and thus to the idea that cognition may play a role in the creation of reality. As a self-creative mechanism for the universe is sought, it becomes apparent that cognition is the only process lending itself to plausible interpretation as a means of temporal feedback from present to past. Were cognition to play such a role, then in a literal sense, its most universal models of temporal reality would become cognition, and space would become a system of geometric relations that evolves by distributed cognitive processing.</p><p>Here comes the surprise: such a model exists. Appropriately enough, it is called the cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe, or CTMU for short. A cross between John Archibald Wheeler’s Participatory Universe and the Stephen Hawking-James Hartle “imaginary time”theory of cosmology proposed in Hawking’s phenomenal book A Brief History of Time, the CTMU resolves many of the most intractable paradoxes known to physical science while explaining recent data which indicates that the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate. Better yet it bestows on human consciousness a level of meaning that was previously approached only by religion and mysticism. If it passes the test of time-and there are many good reasons to think that it will-then it will be the greatest step that humanity has yet taken towards a real understanding of its most (or least?) timeless mystery. And so the circle closes. Time becomes a cosmogonic loop whereby the universe creates itself. The origin of our time concept the self, becomes the origin of time itself. Our cognitive models of time become a model of time-ascognition. And the languages of cognition and physics become one self-configuring, self-processing language of which time is the unified grammar.</p><p>Which Came First</p><p>The question “which came first, the chicken or the egg?” looks at first glance like a matter of straightforward reproductive biology. But before we can even begin to answer we must define terms. So actually, it is a classic case of semantic ambiguity… a problem of meaning and interpretation. We all know what a chicken looks like. But the term egg is more general and a possible source of ambiguity. Do we mean (1) any egg, or (2) a chicken egg? And is the “chicken egg” (3) an egg laid by a chicken, (4) an egg containing a chicken, or (2c) Both? Reformulating the question to reflect each possible meaning of “egg” leads to four distinct versions of the chicken-or-egg question.</p><p>1. Which came first? The chicken or (just any old) egg?</p><p>2. The chicken or an egg laid by a chicken?</p><p>3. Chicken or an egg containing a chicken?</p><p>4. Chicken or egg laid by and containing a chicken?</p><p>1. Then answer is “the egg” because species that lay eggs have been around a lot longer than modern chickens. For example we have plenty of fossil evidence that dinosaurs laid eggs from which baby dinosaurs hatched, and dinosaurs predate chickens by millions of years. Indeed, a growing body of research indicates that dinosaurs were among the biological ancestors of chickens!</p><p>2. The answer to this one is “the chicken” on semantic grounds alone. That is, if a chicken egg must be laid by a chicken, then before a chicken egg can exist, there must by definition be a chicken around to lay it.</p><p>3. Logically, the fact that a chicken egg must be laid by a chicken precedes and therefore “dominates” the (biologically subsequent) requirement that it contain a chicken. So we needed paleozoo logical evidence to answer question 1 question 2 and 3 require no biological evidence at all!</p><p>Saving the best for last and most interesting version 2b: which came first, the chicken or an egg containing a chicken? This version is interesting because an egg containing a chicken might have been laid by a chicken or a non-chicken, which of course affects the answer. Thanks to modern genetic science, we can now be sure that the egg came first. This is because reproductive mutations separating a new species from its progenitor generally occur in reproductive rather than somatic DNA and are thus expressed in difference between successive generations, but not in the parent organisms themselves. While the somatic (body) cells of the parents- e.g. wing cells, drumstick cells and wishbone cells-usually contain only the DNA with which they were conceived, germ (reproductive) cells like ova and spermatozoa contain non-somatic DNA that may have been changed before or during mating by accidental deletion, insertion, substitution, duplication or translocation of nucleotide sequences. This is what causes the mutation that result in the new species.</p><p>Where an animal qualifies as a member of a given species only if its somatic DNA (as opposed to its reproductive DNA) conforms to the genotype of the species, the parents of the first member of a new species are not members of that new species. At the same time, all the biological evidence says that the ancestors of modern chickens were already oviparous or egg-laying… that a male and a female member of the ancestral species of the modern chicken, call this species “proto chicken”, mated with each other and created an egg. (could the first chicken have evolved from a viviparous or live-bearing species and after being born alive, have started laying eggs? All the biological evidence says “no”.) But because their act of mating involved a shuffling of reproductive genes that were not expressed in the body of either parent-if they had been expressed there, the parents themselves have been members of the new species-the fetus inside the egg was not like them. Instead, it was a mutant… a modern chicken!</p><p>Only two loose ends remain: the “gradual” and “sudden” extremes of the evolutionary spectrum. These extremes are evolutionary gradualism-Darwin’s original slow-paced timetable for natural selection-and punctuated evolution, as advocated more recently by evolutionary theorists including the controversial Stephen J. Gould.</p><p>Gradualism says that mutations are biologically random, but subject to a selection process determined by environmental (external) conditions to which species must adapt over the course of many generations. Taken to the limit, it implies either that each minor mutation that occurs during the evolutionary change of one species into another is random and independent of any other mutation, in which case a useful combination of mutations is highly improbable, or that each individual mutation confers a selective advantage on the mutant… that every evolutionary advantage of a new species over its precursor decomposes into smaller advantages combined in a more or less linear way. Unfortunately, this makes it almost impossible to explain complex biological structures that do not break down into smaller structures useful in their own right… structures like bacterial cilia and flagella, and even the human eye.</p><p>When does the quality and quantity of mutations justify a distinction between “species”… when does a proto chicken become a chicken? But either way the answer remains the same.</p><p>At the other extreme, evolution sometimes appears to progress by leaps and bounds, moving directly from the old to the new in “punctuated” fashion. And to complicate matters this sometimes seems to happen across the board, affecting many species at once. The most oft-cited example of punctuated evolution is the (Cambrian Explosion. Where sedimentary rocks that formed more than about 600 million years ago are poor in fossils of multi-cellular organisms, slightly younger rocks contain a profusion of such fossils conforming to many different structural templates. The duration of the so-called “explosion”, a mere geological eyeblink of no more than 10 million years or so, is inconsistent with gradualism; new organs and appendages must have been popping out faster than the environment alone could have selected them from a field of random mutations. The kind of punctuated evolution that occurs between generations is not the end of the line in sheer biological acceleration. Sometimes, an evolutionary change seems to occur within the lifespan of a single organism! For example, in the spirit of “ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny”, insect metamorphosis almost seems to hint at an evolutionary process in which an ancient grub or caterpillar underwent a sudden transformation to something with wings and an exoskeleton…or alternatively, in which a hard-shelled flying bug suddenly gave birth to an egg containing a larva. While that’s not what really happened-as is so often the case, the truth lies somewhere in the middle-what occurred was just as marvelous and just as punctuated, what seems to have happened was this. Due to a reproductive mutation, a whole sequence of evolutionary changes originally expressed in the fetal development of an ancestral arthropod, and originally recapitulated within the womb and egg it inhabited, were suddenly exposed to the environment, or at least to the hive, in a case of “ovum interruptus”. A fetal stage of morphogenesis that formerly occurred within womb and egg was interrupted when the egg hatched “prematurely”, making the soft fetus into an equally soft larva and giving it a valuable opportunity to seek crucial nourishment from external sources before being enclosed in a pupa, a second egg-like casing from which it later hatched again in its final exoskeletal form. So metamorphosis turns out to be a case of biological common sense, providing the fetus-cum-larva with an opportunity to acquire the nourishment required for the energy-consuming leap into adulthood.</p><p>This doesn’t however affect our answer to the chicken or egg question? For even where the life cycle of an organism includes distinct morphological stages, the DNA of egg-laying insects does not change after conception. And since it is reproductive and not somatic DNA modification that distinguishes one species from the next in line, our answers stand firm.</p><p>Perhaps there is another loose end. Asking which of two things came first implies that time flows in a straight line from past to future (those are the “loose ends”). But what if time were to flow in either direction, or even to loop around, flowing in what amounts to a circle? No more loose ends in fact loops have no ends at all! But in this case the answer depends on whether we’re on the forward or reverse side of the loop, heading towards the future or the past. Another way to say it “does the cause lead to the affect or the effect lead to the cause?” Either direction the original answers of the chicken or egg question are all affected the same way. They are either all unchanged or all reversed with no additional ambiguity save that pertaining to the direction of time (not a problem for most non-physicists and non-cosmologists).</p><p>Of Trees, Quads and God</p><p>The question that seems to be every schoolchild’s introduction to philosophy “If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound?” This question is about the empirical philosophy of the celebrated 18th century philosopher Bishop George Berkeley. The question has to do with the relationship between reality and perception, or more generally, the relationship between reality and mind. As with most philosophers, the nature of reality was something that preoccupied Berkeley.</p><p>The first thing we notice about reality is that it’s everywhere. The next thing we notice is that because its everywhere there isn’t anything to contrast it with or compare it to in order to define it. There are always dreams, fantasies and illusions, of course, but what are they? And if we don’t know what they are, then how can we use them to define reality? It gets worse. Understanding reality as the medium of existence is necessary for understanding anything that exists. We’re parts of reality. So if we don’t know what reality is, how do we know what we are? And if we don’t know what we are, then how do we know what anything else is? How do we know anything at all?</p><p>Science doesn’t help. When we use science, all we’re doing is using various parts of reality to define other parts, not defining reality with respect to its complement. Physical reality is not a stand-alone proposition; it requires universal rules in order to exist and maintain its consistency. From a logical standpoint, those rules are more than merely physical. The question “If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound?” Can be reduced to the notion of unrequited duality. The unrequited or missing part is the listener. For in contrast to the objective physical disturbance called a “sound wave”, a sound is a perception that requires both an object to make it and a subject to hear it. The lesson is clear: when it comes to perception, it takes two to tango. Perception: is a duality involving both object and subject; for every perception, there is something perceived and someone who perceives it. Here the clarity ends, the lesson has two possible interpretations. The first: “perception and reality are separate. The foremost exponent of this viewpoint was the French mercenary, philosopher and mathematician Rene Descartes (1596–1650). At this point we need to know just two things about Descartes, the first being he was a rationalist. Rationalist believe the most basic concepts in terms of which we understand the world- e.g. self and causality-are known intuitively rather than through experience. Descartes held that we can deduce truths with absolute certainty from such “innate ideas” in the same way that theorems are deduced from axioms in geometry. In fact, rationalists see mathematical demonstration as the perfect means of establishing truth, and thus as a general model for the pursuit of knowledge.</p><p>between mind and matter… and specifically, the human mind and body. Descartes said reality consists of two independent substances mind and matter. Both are real, Descartes assured us, but never the twain shall meet except through the act of perception, which must itself have a dual nature in order to bridge the gap. The problem is one gets stuck trying to explain the medium or the composition of the medium in which the various essential substances are related to each other.</p><p>The second relational hypothesis is that perception and reality are intuitively related. The first philosopher usually associated with this is John Locke (1632–1704). Locke held the mind is a blank state or slate on which all knowledge is imprinted by experience. (opposing innate ideas) He distinguished primary objective qualities like number, extension and solidity, which mechanically affect sense organs through perception, from secondary subjective qualities like color, smell and sound, which are produced by the direct impact of the world on the sense organs. Once past the sense organs, Locke theorized, these secondary experimental qualities combined to form ideas that mirror reality and constitute the basis of science. But what kind of science? Although Locke believed that we know the world only through experience, he also believed in the existence of a world apart from the mind, with perception and experience mediating between the mind and the world around it. It thus seems that Locke’s apple fell not too far from Descartes’ tree after all. For his theory of primary and secondary qualities whereby the mind knows only secondhand experiences impressed upon it by perception, implies that scientific knowledge is itself a secondhand affair… that the true essences of physical objects cannot be scientifically known. So Locke agreed with Descartes not only about mind-body duality- that the conceptual, subjective world of the mind is forever separate from the concrete, objective world it perceives-but that mathematics is the only route to certainty. So far the real difference between Descartes and Locke isn’t much. Descartes says that the mind possesses innate knowledge; Locke says that the mind is a blank slate on which reality leaves its imprint. Descartes and Locke are both dualists, and their respective solutions of the tree-in-the-quad problem are the same; the material existence of the trees is independent of perception they exist whether anyone is watching them. This agreement is strange in view of the fact that Descartes and Locke are respectively considered founders of rationalism and empiricism two opposing philosophies about the source of human knowledge. Where do these philosophies diverge? Enter George Berkeley (1685–1753), Anglo-Irish philosopher and clergyman who went Locke one better. Locke allowed the independent existence of matter, Berkeley held that reality and perception are the same thing and matter can’t exist without perception. He said “to be is to be perceived”. Technically this made him an adherent of idealism, a strain of philosophy which holds that nothing exists apart from mind and their contents. In contrast to the mind-body dualism of Descartes, Berkeley’s perceptual monism reduced reality to a single “substance”, perception. Berkeley held that all qualities are mental or ideal in nature. But he acknowledged a key distinction: ideas are mutable and evanescent, material objects are stable and persistent. From this, he reasoned that the mind on which material objects depend must be divine rather than human. That is from the common-sense notion that physical objects exist even when no one perceives them, Berkeley inferred the Official Perciever of trees and other objects must be God himself. The God-in-the-quad answer to the tree-in-the-quad question is in some ways an oversimplification. In fact, Berkeley would have said that the material quad does not exist at all except as an archetype in God’s mind, God’s own subjective description of the quad’s physical appearance. According to Berkeley, people who enter the quad “perceive” the quad, only because these experiences are produced by reference to God’s own archetype. We perceive quads by referring to the contents of the Mind of God. Our perception follows God’s cognition. To this extent, Berkeley’s perceptual monism is cognitive monism.</p><p>Enter David Hume (1711–1776) Hume carried the empiricism of Locke and Berkeley to the logical extreme of radical skepticism, repudiating the possibility of certain knowledge. According to Hume, the mind is nothing but a series of sensations, and causality is merely an illusion that happens when one impression follows another. Even though cause precedes effect, says Hume, there is no proof that the cause is responsible for the effect’s occurrence. Because Hume flatly rejected God or theology he took the tree-in-the-quad problem out of God’s lap and put it back in man’s. Hume is credited for another problem. The problem of induction: How do human beings form beliefs about unobserved matters of fact, and are these beliefs justified? Do our powers of reasoning permit us to form valid conclusions about the parts of nature we haven’t observed? The bearing of this problem on that of the tree-in-the-quad is obvious: in principle, a strong constructive solution for the problem of induction would let us determine the existence of any tree anywhere from our perception of any subset of trees. If human reasoning were sufficiently powerful, and human powers of generalization sufficiently strong, then to perceive any subset of trees would be as good as to perceive them all. In effect, human cognition (and not divine) would suffice to relieve perception of much of its ontological responsibility. But that’s optimistic and Hume isn’t an optimist his solution is downright gloomy.</p><p>First he defined induction as the construction of a general theory from limited data by applying a principle asserting the uniformity of nature. That is, induction generalizes from the part to the whole on the assumption that nature is everywhere the same. From this it followed that all beliefs about unobserved facts are derived by induction from experience. But while Hume considered the inductive schema (pattern of reasoning) logically valid, he denied the validity of the uniformity premise. For while the validity of the premise can only be established by induction, every inductive argument necessarily employs it. Since the premise is “circular” or self-justifying, said Hume, it cannot be proven. After Hume things look bad for any tree in the empty quad. Neither Go nor induction could philosophically warrant its existence. In comes Kant</p><p>Enter Immanuel Kant (1724–1804) a German philosopher. Kant’s central thesis was this: we can know objective reality only insofar as it conforms to the structure of our minds. Beyond this point Kant deemed reality unknowable. Kant called knowable objects of experience phenomena, and the knowable objects underlying these phenomena noumena or “things-inthemselves” (think “objects independent of perception”). By definition, noumena are immune to affirmation, denial or scientific confirmation. The relationship between phenomena and noumena is bedeviled by a particularly troublesome form of dualism that resists transformation into a unified (monic) explanation of reality. Whereas Descartes asserts mind and matter occupy a divinely- mandated similarity relationship, Kant denies that the parallel relationship between phenomena and noumena can be known at all, even to the extent of calling it a “similarity relationship”. From this follows some bad news:noumenal trees are untouchable by phenomenal perception. But there is some good news as well: phenomenal trees must conform to the structure of our minds. In principle, this yields a solution to the problem of induction with respect to phenomenal reality.</p><p>Although it may seem hard to believe this brings us right up to the present in terms of “metaphysics”, or our knowledge of deep reality. Even now science struggles in vain with the problem of induction, waiting for philosophy to tell it how to construct a general theory of reality from the limited data accessible to its instruments; floundering in a confusing welter of dualism, but analytic philosophy, long ago cowed by the brilliant successes of its scientific offspring, remains preoccupied with emulating the hard sciences, and thus finds little room for metaphysical thought.</p><p>But the tree in the quad saga is not yet over. Using ideas from each of the alone philosophers along with some newer concepts, it is possible to synthesize a new mind-matter, mind-body connection that leaves reality neither irrevocably split, nor hanging in the balance in the ontological limbo of a quad at once atheistic, noumenal and empty. Look to the future. For when science and philosophy remarry at last, their progeny will populate and enrich our intellectual world.</p><p>The Pros and Cons of “Machine Intelligence”</p><p>AI, oh magical acronym! Artificial Intelligence, perhaps the hottest topic of the digital era, has captivated the imaginations of computer scientists and screen writers since the days of vaccum tubes and punch cards. AI, having failed repeatedly to merge on schedule, now finds itself with a bad record, and a bad name, and increasingly bad credit at the Bank of Big expectations. However, there are a couple of new and disturbing trends on the horizon. In fact, they started at the horizon some time ago and have since gotten considerably closer. Do they involve startling breakthroughs in computer science? Well, yes and no. They do involve computers. But the “science” has at least as much to do with biology-or as they say in the AI biz, “wetware”-as with hard ware and software, and it opens up a number of disturbing possibilities reminiscent of movies like Colossus: The Forbin Project, Demon Seed, War Games, Terminator and The Matrix. Suffice it to say that if you still take solace from the trite belief that “computers can’t do anything we humans don’t program them to do!”, you need to… well, re-compute your position.</p><p>But before we go there how did it all begin? It began with Alan Turing. The subject of a play called Breaking the code-he was famous for cracking German’s “unbreakable” Enigma code in WW2-Turing was a British mathematician whose ideas sowed the seeds of modern computer science. No sooner had scientists wishfully added electronic computers to the list of Neat Things we want for Christmas, than their friends the mathematicians began to use abstract models to explore their capabilities. As the world waited for a real computer to be built, Turing’s universal machine became the abstract model computer of choice. A harbinger of disappointments to come, Turing used it to show that there are problems that no computer will ever be able to solve. Not one to give up, Turing nevertheless went on to become the world’s first AI theorist. First, he reasoned that a computer would someday become powerful enough to duplicate some of the functions of the human mind. Would this make the computer intelligent? To answer this question would require a test, but of what kind? Since subjective attributes like intelligence do not readily lend themselves to the scientific method, the test should measure the objective correlates of intelligence rather than intelligence itself. But against what scale? Since people introspectively know how it feels to be intelligent, and know intelligence when they encounter it in others, human judgment should serve as the scale. So the best test, reasoned Turing, would be to put a computer and a person on opposite sides of an opaque partition and let them interact, e.g. engage in written dialogue. If the person is fooled into thinking that another person is behind the partition, then the computer passes the Turing Test for artificial intelligence.</p><p>Unfortunately, a machine that fools a human proves itself no more than a convincing fake. After all, the computer can do nothing but what it is programmed to do… or can it? Granted, a computer is mechanical. But human beings can themselves be described as biomechanical systems. Granted, a computer is deterministically programmed and therefore devoid of free will. But there remains a philosophical controversy over the possession of free will by humans, whose own “programming” involves a mixture of genetics and environmental exposure over which they arguably have little control. In fact, Turing even described abstract machines capable of making intelligent guesses, which amounts to a form of free will and obscures the distinction completely. So where is the functional difference between computers and people? The superficiality of the Turing Test. Its failure to probe beneath surface appearances in search of the “true essence” of intelligence, human or otherwise-reflects the difficulty of pinning down this distinction, at least for a mathematician.</p><p>The bottom line: our best working definition of intelligence is “problem-solving ability”. But then the meaning of intelligence devolves to that of problem, and where a “problem” is whatever you want it to be, intelligence is whatever you want it to be as well. Which, of course, recreates the original problem, namely how to find a meaningful definition of intelligence. This takes us right back to the Turing Test, which-if we sensibly go along with Turing regarding the limitations of the scientific method with respect to subjective intelligence-is an optimal test of intelligence in man or machine. We mine as well talk about intelligence in terms of humans and machines. So we’ll pick up where Turing left off. Not long after Turing invented his eponymous abstract model of a computer real mechanical computers had been built and were ready for the Turing Test of machine intellect. For programmers there were two ways to do this. 1. Gaming programs and expert systems they could program a computer to play a game against a human and either beat the human or come close to it. Or program a computer to answer a series of questions ordinarily posed to a human expert like a doctor or a lawyer.</p><p>The most famous gaming program of all time is Deep Blue that beat world chess champion Gary Kasparov in 3.5 out of 6 games (In May 1997 in a draw each player gets ½ game. Billed by Newsweek as “The brain’s last stand”, it was ballyhooed as a huge victory for AI. In response to each of Kasparov’s moves, the machine was known to be rapidly executing thousands upon thousands of lines of code containing cumulative “if… then” statements, something which a human would be incapable even if it seemed like a good idea. Partition or not, it was all to clear that the combination of heuristics and brute force employed by Deep Blue was not what most of us really mean by “intelligence”.</p><p>What about expert systems? To build an expert system, a “knowledge engineer” interviews experts in a given field and tries to collect their knowledge in a computer program designed to answer ?’s or perform one or more domain-specific tasks. There are two problems with this: 1. The computer is not “thinking”; it is merely storing, sorting, and relaying the insights of human experts. 2. When the program’s human interlocutor transgresses the bounds of its narrow range of borrowed “expertise”, it typically starts making stupid errors that give it away. These problems apply to the entire AI strategy including gaming programs, expert systems, mathematical theorem-proving programs, natural language parsers, so-called “intelligent agents” and other conventional automated procedures designed to mimic human intellectual processes. Once this became obvious, the search began for alternative approaches. Among the possibilities, two stood out. 1. Connectionism-is to directly simulate the human brain on the intercellular level. 2. Called by suggestive names like “genetic algorithms” and “evolutionary programming”, was an idea that had long been talked about, but seemed so improbable and outrageous that few took it seriously: instead of mimicking the output of biological systems, programmers would attempt to electronically recreate them.</p><p>Connectionism aims to duplicate human intellectual abilities using the brain’s simplified model of its own structure: the artificial neural network. Just as a brain consists of neurons connected by synapses, a neural network consists of artificial neurons called “neurodes” and their “synaptic” interconnections. To each connection is assigned a strength or “weight”. The pattern of synaptic weights is the network’s “program”… the informational construct according to which input is converted to output. The neural net also incorporates a higher-level program called a learning function that adjusts synaptic weights according to input. The learning function tells the network how to do what the brain does effortlessly: learn from experience. Already, neural nets quickly but fallibly learn such tasks as facial recognition, rudimentary language processing and predicting the stock market.</p><p>Remember the idea computers only do what we program them to? The brain-like computer called a neural net is equipped with a higher-level program that lets it program itself. Here’s another eye-opener. According to genetic programmers it won’t do to build lifelike computers when you can do what mother nature did: get them to build themselves by the process of evolution.</p><p>First, the genetic programmers create a random population of computer programs to perform a given task or subtasks. Each program is measured against a “fitness criterion” by which the degree of correctness of its output may be determined. A “selection principle” then rewards fitter programs with a survival advantage-that is, a higher probability of survival-and penalizes the less fit, making them more likely to die out. As in nature, survivors have the opportunity to “breed”, in the course of which they mutate and combine to form new programs that inherit their traits. After many generations produces programs that have the highest possible level of fitness…programs that can perform the intended set of tasks (almost) perfectly filling the niche in their electronic ecosystem.</p><p>In adopting genetic and connectionists’ viewpoints, AI intersects with biology on multiple scales and promises to outdo humanity itself. As it stands, a human with low fitness can apply a series of temporary medical patches to whatever ails him or her and reproduce like a rabbit anyway. Not so for genetic programs.</p><p>The ban news: connectionism and genetic programming still have a long way to go. Their theories are relatively primitive. The opaque panel in the Turing Test is essentially the same divider used by Descartes, in his doctrine of Cartesian Dualism, to separate mind from matter and sever the mind-body connection in the name of science. Thus, like Cartesian dualism itself, the Turing Test offers no insight to the intrinsic nature of intelligence; in the current state of philosophy, all we can say is intelligence is as intelligence does”.</p><p>The good news: There is a way out. But it involves a shift from Cartesian dualism to cognitive monism and the concept of an “intelligent Universe”, according to which generalized intelligence becomes a universal property of which our minds are just localized examples. (yes that is ultimately what it takes to restore the mind-body connection).</p><p>In Ethics Not Everything Is Relative</p><p>After the events of 9–11, destructive and heroic, it seems like a good time to discuss ethics and moral relativism. We all know the meaning of ethics; ethics are what tell human beings how to do the right thing by each other. Unfortunately, this can be a very complex calculation, and that’s where moral relativism enters the picture.</p><p>“Was the World Trade Center Disaster morally wrong?” In NYC and the US this? Would draw an overwhelming number of affirmative responses. But if one where to ask this question in the streets of the enemy of the US, the answers might be very different. One might instead hear a series of blame-the-victims tirades about how US meddling and/or non-meddling in the affairs of other sovereign nations entitles those nations to lash out violently against their “oppressors” (us). Each of the two view points is clearly the opposite of the other, as reflected in “yes” and “no” answers to the same question. It would seem only one can be “moral” or “ethical” and one side should be able to prove itself right and the other have to admit being “wrong”. More often then not, each side in a dispute claims the moral high ground. This tends to rob of itself the concept ethical or moral correctness. If the lightest shade is white and the lightest shade black, then the “lightness attribute would have no power to distinguish one shade from another, and this would correspond to ambiguity in the meanings of “white” and “black”. The ethical dialogue of this dilemma involves ambiguity in the meanings of “good” and “evil”, and “right” and “wrong”. How is the ethical dilemma to be solved? One way would be to provide an absolute definition of right and wrong; good and evil. Spelling out the right-wrong distinction in a way that could be applied straightforwardly in any context to identify the best course of action. Attempts to define absolute good include 1.Ten commandments 2. U.S. Bill of Rights 3. The Golden Rule-a sophisticated rolling of many ethical principles into one. But ethical absolutism is not without its difficulties. For example take a penniless man’s child suffering from a curable disease, and the man’s every attempt to get money to pay for the expensive cure has failed. Now supposed the man knows where the cure is stored in quantity and has a good chance of stealing a dose without detection. Should he be deterred from doing so by the fact that theft is wrong, given that it would also be wrong to let his innocent child die? If we examine this closely we see 3 distinct view points. 1. That of the poor man and his dying child. 2. The manufacturer of the cure whose purpose is to get a maximum return on his investment or at least a fair return. 3. The third frame contains the first two is the overall context with respect to the absolute morality of “thou shalt not steal” has been determined, but lacks any absolute proscription against letting innocent children die for their poverty.</p><p>Such examples imply that no finite set of moral principles suffices to determine ethical behavior in a world characterized by endless complications. This has lead to an even less productive way for approaching ethical dilemmas, namely moral relativism. A moral relativist takes the following position: It is useless to speculate about moral laws of an overall context that can never be fully known. Because the right wrong distinction depends on those who apply it, we can do no better than consider each frame independently, reformulating the distinction when switching from one frame to the other. This difference of ethical frames renders them in commensurable in forming common goals and cooperation to achieve them. This restricts the moral relativist to the default “common goal” of mutual tolerance. Where mere tolerance is sufficient one viewpoint is defined precisely by its tolerance, this can be unproductive, and the relativist is powerless to fix the problem. Fixing the problem requires the imposition of a common ethic or a judgment against intolerance, moral relativism lacks an ethical basis for taking such measures or validating such judgments.</p><p>For example, consider the problem of constructing an extended context in which the Western and Islamic worlds can peacefully co-exist. One side believes in freedom, capitalism and the separation of church and state; the other believes in various blends of feudalism, theocracy and plutocracy. One has given its citizens the world’s highest average quality of life; the other has concentrated its considerable wealth in the hands of an incredibly opulent ruling class that is perfectly happy to let the impoverished masses blame outsiders for their problems. One treats even its criminals with compassion; the other summarily plucks out eyes and lops off body parts from hands to heads. And the differences go on. One regards women as full and equal citizens; the other regards them as something less. One allows itself to be criticized by its own citizens and shapes its policies according to their will; the other appoints external scapegoats for all of its problems and lashes out at them instead of cleaning up its own political domicile. One is a diverse family of immigrants the generously opens its doors to the world of promise of equal opportunity; the other belongs to a set of warring groups characterized by millennia of bloodshed and turmoil, unfair distribution of resources, and annihilative creeds encouraging preferred groups to subject other groups to physical, psychological and economic violence “in the name of God”.</p><p>Such examples point to the main weakness of moral relativism: between absolute right and wrong it fails to distinguish right from wrong</p><p>· Unable them to deal equitably with situations where one side is more right than the other</p><p>· Balances pain of victim against the pleasure of the victimizer</p><p>· Agony of murdered child against the dark fiend who murders.</p><p>Indeed it places angels of heaven and devils of Hell on equal footing. The pure moral relativist would have to juggle the benefits of brotherly love with those of demonic torment.</p><p>Most real world politicians and diplomats go for an ad hoc blend of the two in which frames, e.g. nations, remain essentially independent but are expected to agree on the “absolute goodness” of mutual tolerance. The idea is to find a goal that both frames have in common-survival for instance and encourage each frame to modify whatever ingredients might interfere with conflicting ingredients of the other frame to jeopardize the goal in common. This fails where the source of trouble is irrational hostility of religious fundamentalists adhering literally to “holy writ” in which tolerance is literally banned (Islamic scripture calls for eradication of Islamic “infidels”.</p><p>What, then, is the solution? That’s a long story, so we’ll merely outline it here. First, we need to mention several advanced concepts.</p><p>1. “utility”-means value and may vary by frame for any given thing. The greater “utility” of something to a person the higher its value.</p><p>2. A “utility function” is a rule that assigns a personal or group value to something according to the values of its parameters.</p><p>3. A “rational utility function” is one designed to maximize utility for those who apply it.</p><p>4. “Utilitarianism” prescribes the greatest good for the greatest number and provides us with a scale on which to measure an optimal solution involving multiple frames.</p><p>5. “game” or “decision theory” is a field of math that lets players how to formulate winning, utility maximizing strategies in various competitive scenarios or “games”.</p><p>Game theory, which was initially formulated around utility of individual players, was eventually found to give rise to paradoxes in which individual utility conflicts with the utility of one or more groups involved in the game. If enough players “cheat”, i.e. defect from the group strategy in order to employ individual strategies that let them profit at the group’s expense, the group infrastructure collapses, and where the well being of the group is essential to that of its individual members, individual utility collapses as well. Thus a player who cheats can end up cheating himself coming away with less than if he and others played fair. Because a person’s “rational” attempt to maximize his own personal gain can cause him to lose, the standard theory fails.</p><p>The extended version of game theory designed to resolve such paradoxes is called “the theory of “metagames”. Metagame theory is designed for games in which players belong to various groups, e.g. nations or religions, for which higher-level utility functions are also defined. In this case, utility is a combination of personal and group factors. Because the player’s true utility function, which accounts for his group status, differs from that obtained when he considers only himself, the self is effectively “stratified”. That is, a full definition of “self” must include all of the external relations tying the self to other selves at all levels of organization relevant to all possible games. This redefinition of “self” turns out to be of crucial importance across the entire ethical spectrum. The theory of metagames permits the computation of strategic optima for any real-world scenario to which it can be properly applied (its proper application requires an accurate representation of the individual players and the groups to which they belong, the rules according to which they interact, and the overall context they share). Why hasn’t this theory been used to solve all of the worlds problems? The reason: abstractly applying the theory is easier than completely applying its results, especially in problematic situations where the ethical frames of the players are incompatible. Too often circumstances that pit nation against nation or person against person pit ethic against ethic. A lopsided ethic can encourage players to defect rather than accept the globally optimal solution.</p><p>Because it leads to a stratification of self, the theory of metagames can be reduced to a single general self-based strategy: the Golden Rule. The Golden Rule distributes over all players in the global geopolitical metagame and is therefore absolute, those who defect from this strategy depart from absolute morality. In the case of the WTC tragedy, the reason for defection is clear: the Golden Rule is contradicted by the teachings of Islam, which isolates the self and utility functions of terrorists from those of their victims. To successfully apply decision theory to the current situation, influential and well meaning Moslems who prefer a literal, fundamentalist interpretation of holy writ earn a place in paradise through prayer and good works rather than Kamikaze terrorism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f3a10211cdf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The 7 Methods of Understanding/comprehending, Perception, and efficiency thereof]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/the-7-methods-of-understanding-comprehending-perception-and-efficiency-thereof-604ac1b1db0a?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/604ac1b1db0a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cognitive-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cognition]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 23 Feb 2018 20:13:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-23T20:13:25.917Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>9/9/2015</p><p>What does it mean to comprehend a concept? It means to be able to apply it correctly in a given problem or situation to reach a specific end, and to get the correct answer. What I’m saying is the only real way to tell if someone understands a concept is by giving them a corresponding situation or problem to the concept at hand and see if they get the right answer. This is what I call objective standards. It is technically impossible to tell for absolute certainty by using subjective standards (feelings/emotions, human behavior, conversation) without any objective standards that someone understands a concept. For instance say in economics class your learning about elastic and inelastic prices. The teacher teaches it to the class but the only way for absolute certainty can they know that the student understands it is if they can get the correct answer on those types of questions on a test. Odds rule out the idea of guessing right or getting it right using the wrong thinking every time on a test, and this is where they would be applying the concept of elastic prices. Another good way is if they ask related and relevant questions, but the thing is, is that we can’t read minds or know what anyone else is thinking for sure. We can’t see insight to their brain if they are making necessary biological connections that happen when they learn something new. It is only when putting the concept to the test with questions where they are required to use the concepts to get the right answers can we see if they truly understand the concept. Basically what happens in school is teachers try to get there students thought process on the exact same trail as the teachers themselves. The relevance of all of this that in any scientific theory if it can’t be tested or applied to get the desired results it is totally irrelevant and the debates about it are useless. Which is why I oppose the idea of philosophical ideas where its supposedly largely debated among the scientific community and then they decide if it is fact. They talk about a theory and it is up to them to decide for the general public if it is fact. No facts exist where it is the consent of opinions. All that matters is if the theory when put to the test can produce the predicted results. If it can that is all that matters and that is all the facts you need. It’s not about consent of scientists to decide if it is fact. If that is what it boils down to it doesn’t matter if it is fact or not. What matters is if the predicted results happen. It’s all in the results.</p><p>A good question is how do we learn anything? It is through perception and understanding. Without a perception we cannot comprehend anything. Obviously we make perceptions using our senses as tools but it is only through are brain that understanding comes. Nor can we make a perception without our brain using our senses. So what happens to our brain when we learn something? Something changes in it biologically, but that I’m not going to delve into on this paper. What I am going to look at is the format for how we learn new material. <em>We can learn without thinking about the format for it, but sometimes the learning doesn’t reach its full potential due to the lack of the implementation of understanding and using these methods of understanding and perception. Without using these our perceptions may not reach their full level of complexity as they are capable of by using the brain you have, and the material becomes: disorganized, inefficient, and the way we approach things can be greatly misguided causing serious error and inaccuracy. I believe utilizing these 7 methods learning will be achieved at a more complex level by all students, in a more efficient manner, more organized, and a far greater level of understanding.</em> What I believe about these 7 methods of understanding and perception is that these are the ways we come to comprehend any concept. I believe this is the format of how our brains work in learning absolutely anything. This is the format are brains use to comprehend anything. These are the seven ways we learn anything or make any perception at all. You could break it down and get very specific about how lots of things are learned in lots of different ways, which is all necessary and true. People learn doing a task by maybe hands on, or listening, or watching, or reading, or just on their own. They learn by practice, by music, by ear etc. But that is not what these methods are. They are the basic format of how our brain comprehends concepts that are taught to us. It is a more basic and broader level of things. These methods are specific they are big, broad, and highly encompassing. What they are is if you take methods of learning and combing and categorize broader and broader yet in a much generalized way where they expand so as to include everything until they become mutual exclusive of each other and can’t be combined any more. They then become seven distinct learning methods. When you do that with methods of learning you get I believe and will try to explain seven basic methods of format of how our brain comprehends material. We’ve all used these without realizing it. So then what is the point if we use them without thinking about them? Why bother elaborating on them if we unconsciously use them. It is to enhance learning. By this I mean learning will be able to be done in a more organized and efficient way with most importantly comprehending complex concepts never thought possible by some people. Learning will be done with more accuracy. With these methods being recognized and exploited to the fullest extent things will be taught in a simpler format, kids will learn better and clearer and people will learn better everywhere in all aspects of life. These would probably be recognized in the more formalized situations. Places like internships, job shadows, school classes, sports, driving, and all kind of training. I earnestly believe these will blow the roof of learning and accelerate it to a whole new level. I believe harmful assumptions and possibly even stereotypes and other common criticisms will die. Life will become in the learning zone a happier, far more relaxed, less stressed and pressured environment because with my theories I’m about to explain less criticism about intelligence will be made and there will be more understanding of situations and people won’t have to fear of making a mistake as much in the learning process. It will in part create a society like a visionary of someone to the magnitude of Einstein would’ve hoped. By this I mean when he had thoughts like this “<em>Common sense</em> is the collection of prejudices acquired by age eighteen.”-Einstein. Here is an example of how utilizing this to the conscious which will expand it in the unconscious mind or in other words recognizing these learning format methods will enhance learning. One of the top tennis coaches in the world a while back named Vic Braden could do something quite interesting. Due to his plethora of experience around the sport of tennis he could determine the instant before a player was about to serve if they were going to double fault. He could not figure out how he did this. It would just come to him. He would know they were going to double fault but he wasn’t aware of what it was about the way they served that caused him to predict they were going to double fault with very precise accuracy. In one tournament in Indian Wells, California he decided to keep track and of the matches he watched he correctly predicted 16 of 17 double faulted serves. Now all of the thinking to predict when a player is going to double fault right before they serve is going on in his unconscious mind. But I predict if he could be consciously aware of it and know exactly what causes it he could predict it with 100 percent accuracy, Because he would see it every time. The rare few times he normally gets it wrong he would know what about it is causing them to double fault and if he were aware that they weren’t doing it he wouldn’t call it. Now this is not what I purpose for this exact situation. I’ll I’m doing is making a comparison<strong>. If we were aware of exactly how learning works and are brain thinks through things we can all of the time be on the same page as student teacher relationship.</strong> I think this would solve the problem of the two not being on the same page, because as you’ll see by using focusing in on these methods the teacher can locate exactly where a student is confused and break it down into a simpler format so the student understands it. Now I am aware that thinking done in the unconscious is best left undisturbed or that process will be interrupted and ruined. For a thing like tennis it would be impossible probably to say precisely this and this factor causes a double fault. There could be numerous variables to consider with too much varying degree in each factor. For instance the net is only so tall. But players heights are always different, so is the wind speeds, the wind direction, the angle the ball is hit at, where on the racket it is hit, there serve stance, the timing of every single body motion etc. It would go on and on forever. But by being exposed to so many serves so many times his unconscious mind can now put all of that together with amazing accuracy. This is actually the exact replica of one of the methods. Now I’m aware people may say “well if we constantly have to stop and think about which method were using it will disrupt the natural process of learning especially that which goes along with the unconscious” However that will not be a problem. Some things are best left to the unconscious where we are better off not trying to explain it and over analyzing data but some things where it gets very specific; in matters of pure logic we need to such as math. There are methods for both types of learning. When we learn them will understand what to do with them in relation to our learning, so that won’t be a problem. Plus this will be so natural to us we won’t have to hesitate thinking about them once we understand them. If we do that it will be methods where that type of thinking is done (the kind of thinking where you have to consciously ponder unlike the tennis coach whose unconscious catered to that) like when it comes to chess. The last thing I need to be clear on to make sure I definitively define what I’m getting at is this isn’t the grand methods to problem solving. Problem solving will be greatly involved but it does not encompass all of problem solving. It more so encompasses understanding a concept or learning of a situation or how to do something. These methods won’t be used in solving personal relationships or an engineer’s problem with a bridge or building a rocket. But it will enhance learning how a combustion in an engine works or a 30–60–90 triangle in trig works or understanding how all of the organs or body systems function together, how they are different and similar, how to learn dance moves, how to learn steering a car or tractor, comprehending chemical equations and say ionic compounds in chemistry. It will help you understand E=mc² and help teachers teach it more effectively and then you can go from there and be creative and problem solve. But understanding it comes first. It’s as simple as if you want to pick up your job training faster with fewer mistakes and the employer being less confusing so both are on the same page with less criticism on the things we know or don’t know. But it won’t tell you how to conjure up E=mc² but it may teach you how to become the funniest guy at a party or how to be creative. It won’t tell you what to create but it is the basis for it. Like Einstein put it “You have to <em>learn</em> the <em>rules</em> of the <em>game</em>. And <em>then</em> you have to <em>play better than anyone else</em>”-Einstein. Very similar is learning then problem solve or create. These methods do the first part. Another good example that comes to mind would be learning how to play piano. Again I believe these methods cover every type of concept we can learn in one form or another. Let’s dive into them then!</p><p>“<em>Identification Method”</em>-This method of perception is based on labeling. In order to identify something all you need is one thing that separates it from its surroundings. This is for efficiency sake. That’s all of the thought necessary for recognizing a location or object. That one thing is a label. What this does is eliminates all irrelevant information and focuses only on the relevant information. This will bring to the core causes for something. This is what you should do when you have to perceive if something is a case like a diagnosis. What this is saying is the only way to make the perception and in the most efficient manner is to find the few things that have effect on it. It’s also used in simpler situations. Consider if you’re in a flower shop. You have to buy your wife’s favorite flower. Now you could have been attentive and remembered the name when she told you the name of it, but say you didn’t listen. You’ve seen it before and vaguely remember what it looks like with the shape, size, and color a little bit. When you get there though there is all kinds of flowers and your memory only serves vague enough where many flowers look similar. For next time knowing there are many variations of that flower and you don’t want to mess up to save for all of the yelling instead of studying it and ones similar to it all you have to do is find one simple unique characteristic of the flower that makes it distinct from the rest. You don’t have to know anything else about it. Just Like that you could walk in there discover the attribute that makes it stand out to you and you know that’s the flower. That one factor that makes it distinct from the rest is what it means to apply the identification method. That is how it works and how it is used. That is how you go in there and make the perception of the correct flower very efficiently. That is a bad example of how it works but there are many other instances such as if you need directions to find a place. Maybe there is three of the same restaurants in a city and you can’t remember for sure which one it is that you’re supposed to meet at. All you need to know is it’s the one turn by the bakery and you got it. Or you’re looking for a house can’t remember the exact address. Its 900 something. Just look for the one with orange shutters. That s essentially the purpose street names fulfill. Street names are an efficient way of identifying the turns you need to take to get to a certain place. There are all kinds of ways this is used in daily life. The guy was filling up on gas and pulled a drive away without paying. Telling the owner of the store or the police it was a red car doesn’t help. There are lots of red cars. Even if you say it’s a ford Buick won’t solve the problem because there are lots of Ford Buicks. That’s where the license plate comes in. That is the only Ford Buick with that license plate. The license plate serves as the identification factor. It makes determining a lot of things so simple. That’s how we label anything and categorize, this here lets you know it’s a maple tree, these leaves tell you it’s an evergreen, these type of feathers tell you it’s this kind of bird etc. A real prominent place this can be used is the medical field. They make diagnosis’s all of the time. The easiest way to do this is using the identification method. Find the few things that determine what something is or what procedure needs to be done and block out all of the other unnecessary info. A prime and extremely practical example of this is of a situation back in the 1990’s in Cook County Hospital in Chicago. This example being used here is taken from Malcolm Gladwell’s book blink where he portrays the story in a very detailed oriented manner. What this boils down it is how the hospital went about to change its ways of diagnosing chest pain from patients who were coming to the ER about their chest pain problems. A man by the name Brendan Reilly came to the hospital in 1996 to be a part of the hospital’s Department of Medicine. The problems that existed started at their limited resources being stretched to the limit especially at the ED (Emergency Department). 250,000 thousand patients a year came in seeking medical attention at Cook County Hospital because it was their last resort for most of them who were without most of the patients. Most of the patients there were without medical insurance so they came in the hospital through the ED. Plain and simple the hospital was running out of room. Lines of people down the halls, rooms were jammed and not enough equipment for patients to run tests or beds to sleep. How were they supposed to go about taking care of all of the patients? The sick ones had to be admitted to the hospital, but how do you figure out who needs what? How do figure out the right way to distribute the medical attention to those who need it the most because all of the resources are overwhelmed by the amount of people coming in. The problem of heart attacks was at the foremost of attention and that’s where Reilly steps in and so does the identification method. According to Galdwell’s book about 30 patients a day came worried if they were having a heart attack due to chest pain. “Those thirty used more than their share of beds and nurses and doctors and stayed around a lot longer than other patients. Chest-pain patients were resource-intensive. The treatment protocol was long and elaborate and — worst of all — maddeningly inconclusive”. “A patient comes in clutching his chest. A nurse takes his blood pressure. A doctor puts a stethoscope on his chest and listens for the distinctive crinkling sound that will tell her whether the patient has fluid in his lungs — a sure sign that his heart is having trouble keeping up its pumping responsibilities. She asks him a series of questions: How long have you been experiencing chest pain? Where does it hurt? Are you in particular pain when you exercise? Have you had heart trouble before? What’s your cholesterol level? Do you use drugs? Do you have diabetes (which has a powerful association with heart disease)? Then a technician comes in, pushing a small device the size of a desktop computer printer on a trolley. She places small plastic stickers with hooks on them at precise locations on the patient’s arms and chest. An electrode is clipped to each sticker, which “reads” the electrical activity of his heart and prints out the pattern on a sheet of pink graph paper. This is the electrocardiogram. In theory, a healthy patient’s heart will produce a distinctive — and consistent — pattern on the page that looks like the profile of a mountain range. And if the patient is having heart trouble, the pattern will be distorted. Lines that usually go up may now be moving down. Lines that once were curved may now be flat or elongated or spiked, and if the patient is in the throes of a heart attack, the ECG readout is supposed to form two very particular and recognizable patterns. The key words, though, are “supposed to.” “The ECG is far from perfect. Sometimes someone with an ECG that looks perfectly normal can be in serious trouble, and sometimes someone with an ECG that looks terrifying can be perfectly healthy. There are ways to tell with absolute certainty whether someone is having a heart attack, but those involve tests of particular enzymes that can take hours for results. And the doctor confronted in the emergency room with a patient in agony and another hundred patients in a line down the corridor doesn’t have hours. So when it comes to chest pain, doctors gather as much information as they can, and then they make an estimate.” The problem was the doctors were trying to sift through an amazing amount of information to make an educated guess on the severity of their chest pain. To be accurate here consistently is nearly impossible with taking into account all of this information, some of which is subjective because it isn’t based on test results but patients answers to questions. To do this with many different patients and cases in a short period of time only adds to it. What would solve the problem would be to research only the essential causes related to a heart attack. Not information that increases the risk of having a heart attack but only that which precisely deals with if the patient at that moment in time is having a heart attack. This is exactly what Reilly does. “The problem with that estimate, though, is that it isn’t very accurate. One of the things Reilly did early in his campaign at Cook, for instance, was to put together twenty perfectly typical case histories of people with chest pain and give the histories to a group of doctors — cardiologists, internists, emergency room docs, and medical residents — people, in other words, who had lots of experience making estimates about chest pain. The point was to see how much agreement there was about who among the twenty cases was actually having a heart attack. What Reilly found was that there really wasn’t any agreement at all. The answers were all over the map. The same patient might be sent home by one doctor and checked into intensive care by another. “We asked the doctors to estimate on a scale of zero to one hundred the probability that each patient was having an acute myocardial infarction [heart attack] and the odds that each patient would have a major life-threatening complication in the next three days,” Reilly says. “In each case, the answers we got pretty much ranged from zero to one hundred. It was extraordinary.” With a hospital barley scraping by to help everyone they can were money is very limited it didn’t help when the place had to spend time and money on people who were admitted care because of chest pain yet they weren’t even having a heart attack.</p><p>So what Reilly acted on this and turned to a cardiologist by the name of Lee Goldman. He was interested in using mathematical principals to determine if someone was suffering from a heart attack. So Goldman fed multiple scenarios into a computer trying to determine what kinds of factors actually correlated with having a heart attack. He came up with an algorithm to predict such a thing. What it boiled down to was a matter of three identification factors along with ECG testing. 1. Is there chest pain they are suffering from unstable angina? 2. Is there fluid in the patients lungs? 3. Is the patient’s systolic blood pressure below 100? “For each combination of risk factors, Goldman drew up a decision tree that recommended a treatment option. For example, a patient with a normal ECG who was positive on all three urgent risk factors would go to the intermediate unit; a patient whose ECG showed acute ischemia (that is, the heart muscle wasn’t getting enough blood) but who had either one or no risk factors would be considered low-risk and go to the short-stay unit; someone with an ECG positive for ischemia and two or three risk factors would be sent directly to the cardiac care unit — and so on”. The medical community didn’t want to change their methods at the time so Goldman’s decision tree didn’t get any attention that it needed. Reilly however didn’t feel the same way and made a deal with doctors he went and presented this to. “For the first few months, the staff would use their own judgment in evaluating chest pain, the way they always had. Then they would use Goldman’s algorithm, and the diagnosis and outcome of every patient treated under the two systems would be compared. For two years, data were collected, and in the end, the result wasn’t even close. Goldman’s rule won hands down in two directions: it was a whopping 70 <em>percent</em> better than the old method at recognizing the patients who weren’t actually having a heart attack. At the same time, it was safer. The whole point of chest pain prediction is to make sure that patients who end up having major complications are assigned right away to the coronary and intermediate units. Left to their own devices, the doctors guessed right on the most serious patients somewhere between 75 and 89 percent of the time. The algorithm guessed right more than 95 percent of the time.” What you have here is a prime example of the identification method being put into use were its actually saving lives. Now the reasoning for pointing the necessity of the method out is to tell us we need to use it. The method itself isn’t what comes up with Goldman’s algorithm but it tells us that we have to use it in order to solve our problems. It tells us we need a simple, efficient, organized, clear way to accurately comprehending if someone is having a heart attack. Without Goldman recognizing that necessity of the identification method to comprehend if someone is having a heart attack the doctors never would’ve changed their system. Now when he was doing his research he probably wasn’t thinking in terms of the method but unaware that is what he was doing to a “T”. Instead of doing a bunch of other tests and gathering all of this data through the tests and many questions and trying to sift through it in your head it’s as simple as: is the Chest pain Angina, Is there Fluid in the lungs, and is the systolic blood pressure below 100. Nothing else matters and just like that you’ve made an accurate diagnosis. The point in this instance is relying on intuition isn’t going to work and there needs to be made more systematic approach in a very efficient manner, for that you have your identification factors. Those simple labels that let you know in an instant if this is right. This is one way you’ll learn or understand if someone is having a heart attack. Now all we have to do is expand our thinking to many areas of life where this can be applied. Expanding our thinking should always be the goal to encompass more, and that is called using your imagination.</p><p>“x= method” While I don’t have an example quit like that, that will make these other ones come to life quit like the identification method I’ll prove them valid equally as well through step by step rational thought and some creativity. In the x= method the x stands for in algebra when you solve for x that is what x is. It is that plain and simple and all there is to it. That is the value x stands for there is nothing more to question or comprehend. What the x= means is when learning it is a matter of practically following directions (in some cases). This method is how we learn by simply being told this is what is or this is what you do there are no levels of complexity beyond it. Why questions here are completely unnecessary. Consider when learning chess. When they teach the names of the pieces that is what the names are there is nothing more to comprehend. When they tell you their movements then you just mimic it or follow the directions. Say you are first learning how to drive a car and the instructor tells you how to use the blinker by lifting up or down the little lever. Then you just have to comprehend that exact motion of flipping the blinker handle. It is the most basic level of understanding there is. Learning builds on it from there. X= method is the basic method of comprehending concepts. If you break everything down to its simplest form it will always boil down to a matter of the x= idea. That’s for any complicated concept. For instance in chemistry if you’re talking about chemical bonds and don’t understand them then you explain elements and charges but still don’t get it. So you break it down more basic to what atoms are. There is nothing more to break down at this point. Atoms are what they are. It is what all matter is made up of. So then when you’re told that electrons are attracted to protons but repelled by their own it isn’t a time to ask why. That is all the simpler we know on the subject, and that is the simplest you’ll be taught in a chemistry class. We can’t explain why opposite charges attract they just do. If later on we found out a why, then there is one more step basic and that would be where it becomes x= and that’s just the way it is. That’s the laws of physics. Mass is attracted to mass. You push on something it pushes back. Maybe you get a complex term thrown your way and ask what does this mean. They break it down 4 or 5 steps maybe and eventually you’ll come across to something that, that is what it is and you build on it from there to greater concepts. This is the base format of understanding everything and this is what complexity builds upon. There are countless examples of this and it is the most common format you use to comprehend concepts. Such as if you walk into a store and you want to buy something but you need to consider the price. To learn what the price is you look at the price tag and the price is what it says; there are no tricks to it. You want to learn the price for things? Well then look at the price tags because it is what the tag says. It’s that simple. Now all of that changes when you have to maybe consider deals or coupons or percentages when buy items. Such as buy one get one 50% off. At this point you have to up your level of thinking one step to understand you have to buy one and then get the item half of its price tag. This goes for anything that is a matter of what it is told it is or as you see it, such as typing a letter “L” on a keyboard you press the button with your finger the key that has the shape of an “L” on it. When motor skills are less developed this becomes more difficult for hands on actions. You want to turn something off then hit the off switch. This one is that simple and doesn’t require more explanation than that. So what is the value in recognizing this? It is at this point then you can learn you have all of the understanding you need to learn more. If you break all concepts down enough they’ll always inevitably boil down to something in this realm. This is where all learning starts. The importance here is we must understand that before we can understand complex concepts we must learn the basis for what something is. This and like every other method takes memory- the better memory the more you set yourself up for success in learning new things. Before teachers should move ahead to more complex material they ought to makes sure all the students know the x= part. A teacher moves on before the students learn the base x=’s they’ll inevitably be confused at some point. This is important because it is the first step and the most common. This is the learning where our concepts evolve from. On tests in school this is equivalent to the vocabulary you must learn. Tests typically start out with this if there is any. The word is what the word means. Strictly speaking you could use this method and a great memory can get you a 100 percent on any test. In that instance it comes down to a matter of x= vs solution no solution deductive reasoning as you’ll see when we get to that method. But if you don’t understand many of the concepts you could memorize many situations to answer questions correctly. You may not actually know how to apply the square root principal in math but you could memorize simply by using a calculator all of the problems for that you would have to know. If you type in square root of 64 and it =8 you only have to memorize that. That would be a prime example of x=. You may not know how to do that in your head though. If someone asked you to do the square root of 16 if you don’t have it memorized the only way to figure it out is by apply the principle of it. Which is 4x4=16 so 4 is the root, and if you don’t understand that you won’t get the right answer unless you memorize simply from someone telling you, using a calculator, or flashcards to get the correct answer. Now this isn’t the best example because you’ll probably end up just memorizing exponents anyway even though you understand the process of square rooting, but if we expand this idea you could apply it to many important situations. The benefit of knowing this is to train your memory and know that any concept you can’t comprehend in the amount of time given, and then memorize it, however some things just have to be memorized because they are that basic in themselves. Like the keys on a piano or stings on a guitar, you just have to memorize them you can’t break them down any further. The great thing about this method is the greatest thing about all of this I’m writing. This effectively proves all things can be comprehended by all people. If we can do the mimicry and comprehend x= then everything else can be learned. Which we all do the x= as babies mimicking everything. You couldn’t know anything if you can’t do this and since it’s inherent if you’re alive you know something (unless maybe a vegetable from a horrible accident which isn’t what I’m talking or writing about). Then you just build upon the bases of what is and grasp the next concept in line and until you do that you don’t move on. That is the very kind of thing that happens in school is teachers have to teach so much material in a given year or semester and they move on before the students grasp it. The fact is this: all students can learn calculus.</p><p>“Concept Map” This method accounts for matters of relationships, and knowing the similarities and differences of a matter. It is a categorization. When you have to categorize at various levels of groups from more specific to general with various distinctions in between, and keep all of that in your head simultaneously, and then were to write it down on paper it would look like a concept map. A concept map is the best way to take notes for this. This is why I give it that title. If you were to right things down here in random spots on the paper and give the classification of an object you would still have to sort it out in your head. Using this method you understand that you won’t comprehend anything until you learn the similarities, differences, and the category of how general or specific. A good example is in biology for understanding all kinds of classifications. Such as is this a mammal, amphibian, reptile etc. Then what kind of reptile and break it down even more. The best example I can think of is in biology where there are all kinds of classifications. Going from organisms-species-populations-communities-biomes and in this group you can’t make any connection in your head unless you understand how each our related and different and what is within what category. This is the method of all classification used in science. Another good way to think of it is the human body. Start basic and build it back up to more complex. Starting off with an atom-molecule-organelle-cell-tissue-organ-organ system-life and with this you need to know that each of these substances make up the next. You have within each group such as a cell different kinds, different tissue, different organs, and different organelles. Within the organelles you’ll have to know how each one is different and how it is the same. What makes it different is that there is more than one organelle. Probably its function makes it stand out. Then how the organelles are the same because they are still in the same group, and then how it is different from a cell or molecule but also the same because they are all related. This here makes up the concept map method. <strong>When we understand the matter of confusion is a lack of relationships explained within their respective groups then the confusion will dissipate into the wind.</strong> There exist relationships amongst everything and the level of the thinking required to comprehend the concept doesn’t change or become more complex. The confusion will become when the difference between the two hasn’t been made manifest or the similarity or what category it is in. Without understanding how anything is related how could we comprehend much of anything? The importance is that it is noted that the relationships must be established before comprehending can begin and confusion can end in matters of relations. As long as it is understood that the classification for the concept map needs to be made we will be golden in our understanding.</p><p>“Step by Step” This is where the learning happens that builds upon the x= method. Math is a prime example for this because it’s pure logic and builds on itself. In this format of learning it happens when you learn one thing then learn another and you learn more complicated material and then become an expert in your field. This method will map out your learning process from when you first started till you have your degree or win the Nobel Prize in the field. Let’s take a closer look at it though. You first start at x= and learn how to count and the numbers and what their respective symbols represent. Now taking a step forward you learn to add numbers and subtract. Then to multiply and divide, then exponents, fractions, then algebra and so on; it’s like this: you count 1,2,3,4 then add 4 + 4=8. Then you take one more step forward in your learning to understand 4*4. Which really means 4+4+4+4, that is four plus four-four times. Then you take the next step and learn exponents which in this case would be 4⁴ power. It really means 4*4 four times. So 4*4*4*4, and if you break that down even more it is (4+4+4+4) + (4+4+4+4) + (4+4+4+4) + (4+4+4+4). In one section of parenthesis you did 4*4 with four parenthesis so you did 4*4 four times and that is the learning that takes place to understand what 4⁴ means. Now if we just expand our thinking on this and take this into every field this is how it works to become a high school graduate to a doctor or lawyer or cop etc. This is what it takes to learn calculus. <strong>It’s all just steps.</strong> This is learning truly in my mind being mapped out. When we understand these things we no longer need to understand that we learn best by symbols or visual cues or verbal or hands on. Just understand the concepts and put them to practice. On real technical terms a teacher can’t ever tell 100 percent that the student ever understands what their talking about by conversation and such. They can’t see in their mind of the neurons are forming the proper connections. The only real way to test if the student understands the concept is to test it by seeing if they can do the task themselves with a familiar situation but not an exact replica so as to do it by memory but solving by having to apply the concept. Truth is only real truth by testing and observing the actual results. What happens between each step or I like to think of them as jumps in learning is somewhat iffy. Your brain has to make the proper jump to understand the next level of complexity which the great thing is if you’re always building on what you already know you’re only expanding upon the concepts you already know to learn the next. Which if you break down far enough and follow that train of thought far enough you know that everything really is based off of an x=idea. What happens between the jumps is some sort of middle ground. It is a matter of your brain just making the jump and through enough thought and time your unconscious will do that for you. Train your unconscious with practice and you’ll be able to pick up concepts faster than anyone which is the conclusion you reach from this. This maps out precisely how learning should be approached in schools or absolutely anywhere. It is a matter of what step are you teaching and what step is the student at. You must learn with this you can’t skip a step till the previous is learned. This is why things have to be taught before being able to take a certain class. It is as simple as you can’t be trying to teach kids to write sentences if they haven’t learned to spell yet or completely learned the alphabet yet. Expand the thinking on this to everywhere in the classroom and learning in life and you’ll see what I mean. Then with the understanding of a few basic concepts you can answer a lot of different questions which brings me to the next basic method of comprehending conceptual material.</p><p>“Solution/No Solution Deductive Reasoning” Here we have the idea of applying a concept to solve many similar problems. First I’ll theoretically explain the idea and how I gave it the name then I’ll connect it to real world examples. In algebra (Here we go again with the math, I know right. But try to stay focused cause this is huge) when you graph absolute value inequalities you typically shade the area of solution on the graph. The proper coordinates on the graph paper where the solution lies. Then you shade this area in. Now, we could figure out the solution by one other way which is testing every possible other number that could be a solution. Eventually by answering no to every number you take the numbers left over and there is your solution. What’s far more efficient though (As remember efficiency is a part of this whole thing)Is if you want to know if some random number is the solution use deductive reasoning to say okay this doesn’t fit the inequality. That’s all you need to do is understand the inequality and you can answer every single question about that if it is a part of the solution instead of testing every number to see what doesn’t fit test to see what does and if it isn’t a part of that it doesn’t fit. This is how I came up with that title because it relates to the idea of applying a concept to figure answer many different questions. That is essentially what school is. That is all the student has to do. Two steps 1. Comprehend the concept being taught 2. Apply it to many situations that relate to the concept. It is much like life lessons. Always be honest they tell you. Assuming that to be true without much thinking any tricky situation that comes your way you can you know what to say cause you’re going to be honest. It is where rules come in to play. Rule number one always do this for this etc. A better example is improvisation acting. The rule they tell you is always going along with the situation or the next idea the person comes up with whatever it is. Otherwise you get unsure about what you’ll do next and if this or that works or makes sense. All of your confusion in your head goes away with the applying the one concept to the idea of going with the flow. By learning the one idea to do addition you can answer many different problems. 4+4, 6+12 etc. This idea is everywhere in life though. Tip the waitress this much percent. Okay apply that idea and no matter the bill you’ll know what the proper tip is worth. The only thing you have to do here is fill in the gaps. Cause with a few concepts it doesn’t tell you every little thing to do but usually it is assumed you know it. That is where the big mistake in learning happens. We are assumed we were always paying attention, have lived the same life as this person, never forgot anything, or didn’t miss anything along the way, but it’s so vital you can’t live without it, NOT! Such as trivial matters, where no one should ever get criticized for not knowing a trivia fact, because trivia first off has nothing to do with intelligence. You just have never heard of the fact big deal. What does that change in your life? Nothing! So I didn’t know the capitol of my own state. Just tell me and I’ll know it. Now I’ll have the knowledge of what you’re making fun of me for not knowing. Especially when it’s something you can just look up. Does life depend on knowing how many states there are in the America? If it is something everyone should know then it is so easy probably to comprehend that if you just tell me all know it and that’s all it takes to understand it is tell me and I can say it back. Point is trivia has nothing to do with a person’s intelligence. What should be more important is that we know how to think. Once Einstein was asked what the speed of sound was and he said he doesn’t remember things he can readily look up in a book. He focused on complex thoughts. Nevertheless I digress and what this leads up to is to understand something that you’ll apply to various situations if you don’t know what is so basic and assumed to know they should (the instructor or whoever) just review it without a problem and this time you’ll pay attention and in no time you’ll be up to speed. People make too big of a deal of not knowing something. They don’t know it probably because they weren’t paying attention when it was taught. Big deal, but in this method it’s those few things or few rules you need to know do the whole job and every little detail. You don’t need to know everything that isn’t a solution just know the few things that are and it’ll tell you everything that isn’t. That way you only have to memorize a few things.</p><p>“Leap Frogging” In this method it is where someone will learn to think ahead. It is a huge part of efficiency and is what naturally happens you begin to master certain skills. Everyone knows what it’s like to be a genius. The answer just comes to them. Something in their head works for them that to them it feels effortless. The average functioning person can do a lot of things without thinking about doing them. Tying your shoes or driving a car. We do them so much that we are on autopilot while doing them. We can carry on a deep conversation while playing with the radio, thinking about something else all simultaneously and still drive just fine. Reading words or talking, how easy is that? For a wide receiver in football to catch a ball playing catch. What’s 2+2? That all comes to you without hesitation, and that is what it is like to be a genius, because the same thing happens to the kids who learn so fast and breeze through school with flying colors. The difference is, is that they don’t have to spend as much time contemplating how to do something or thinking about the answer. It will just come to them and so does learning the material. Well a real expert in something will spend less time thinking about more complicated tasks. When you first learn to play guitar keeping track of both hands might be quite difficult. To Jimmy Hendrix he could play guitar blind folded. For him keeping track of both hands is nothing. He’s done it so much he can leap frog ahead of all of that and focus on more complicated things. The one who wins in chess is the one who thinks further ahead. The pieces do the same things for each of the players but the one who wins is the one who can think the most steps ahead. When your an expert at something it’s the more things you can do effortlessly, so what is really intriguing are the tasks that geniuses do have to spend time thinking about. Like when I type on this keyboard I don’t have to think at all where the letters for each key is or look at the keyboard. Cause I’ve spent so much time on it. So how does this have to do with comprehending and learning? It is really efficient in problem solving for one thing and that is part of what this paper is about (efficiency). Yes it also deals with comprehending concepts. What happens say in a complicated math problem where you’re solving say a quadratic function using the quadratic formula? The first time you use it you’ll have to write everything out, and every little step of the formula ( you know what I’m talking about if you’ve had to use it). You do it over and over you can do most of the step in your head automatically and only write down and think about a few of them. You can leap frog ahead of some steps to solve it because they come to you like that. Chess is the perfect example of this where you are familiar with a situation up to 4 or 5 moves and when you start thinking about it then you can maybe add a couple of steps. So what you’re doing is keeping 7 steps ahead in your mind simultaneously. The other person may have a better memory but is inexperienced and can do none automatically but thinks hard to attempt to plan ahead 4 steps. The point is here is what do you need to think about and what can you skip ahead to. Eventually what happens is this (which is the greatest thing about this method) the less information you need to solve a problem. The process works like this: Someone who is inexperience on cars hears something wrong in the engine and doesn’t know what’s wrong with it. So they’ll need to know all of these things to figure out what’s wrong with it. An expert would come in could take a look at something very detailed skip ahead a bunch of steps and just knowing this one thing knows all of these other things that is wrong with the car engine. It’s like a Rube Goldberg machine in your head. When you first look at a machine you see each individual step and know that this causes this and this causes this to make this happen. In All its 30 steps to do what you accomplished. When you continue to spend time with it you find you only need these 10 steps make get the thing to do the function you want it to. Well the expert with the cars can figure out that this is what’s wrong with the car based on this and you’ll ask how in the world you figured it out knowing that. Haven’t you’ve ever heard that before. How did you do that just using this or something along those lines? Because what they are doing is essentially leap fogging in their head or thinking ahead. It is what will happen when you become an expert. The less you’ll need to know to fit the pieces together in your head. So it’s the rest that you don’t even have to think about. This is leap fogging and it is a mental learning process that happens in your head especially when you become an expert at something. You learn to skip steps and become more efficient at something. The less information you need to solve something and the less you have to think about the more you can do automatically. It’s thinking ahead like in chess. They are familiar with a given situation and automatically can think ahead so many steps and boom just like that its check mate.</p><p>“Flexibility” This is the greatest method in the process of learning of all. It truly is the gift of the human mind. It is the intuition that is inside us all and without it we couldn’t do any complex tasks. It’s what happens when all of the sudden the light bulb flicks on inside your head and you have an amazing idea. It is the calculating that is going on inside your mind that you can’t really tap into. You aren’t aware it’s going on. It is the main method of learning that happens in when learning to do really fast paced things or sports or extremely complicated tasks. Say for instance like shooting at shells. Someone has done it so much that they are an expert at it. When the shell they are shooting at is so many feet up in the air they can’t sit there and try to calculate the angle they need to hold the gun at to hit the shell. They just kind of have a feel for it and let it fly and hit the target. They just eye it up probably not even looking at exactly where they are holding the gun to aim. Their unconscious does those calculations for them. In football when a running back learns to instantly see the field juke all of these players out and twist and turn in all of these different angles in a split second they don’t stop and think about it, their mind is flexible enough to do it. It figures it out for them. In baseball the pitcher is pitching sometimes in the 90’s miles per hour. The batter has a split second to time it just right. They don’t sit there and calculate in their head how fast it’s going the distance from the mound, how long their swing takes and when to start swinging. It would take some serious math to do this and the unconscious does it all without you feeling like your thinking about the situation. They just eye the ball and have a feel for when to swing. Then they need to connect the bat to the ball. This would be absolutely impossible if your mind wasn’t flexible enough to do it for you automatically and you had to calculate it yourself. It is the gift of the intuition. There are all kinds of situations and scenarios we can’t sit there and think about the situation we just have to act on it. I call this flexibility because your mind has to be incredibly flexible to balance between all of these fast paced situations that you just eye and don’t even think about it but do it. The only way to develop this is through practice through all kinds of different situations with the hardest of difficulty and your flexible mind will figure it out overtime. I don’t believe I need to go into great detail on this because if you expand your thinking you’ll see what I’m talking about. The flexibility method is just those things you can’t explain. You know what it is but can’t explain it. You do it but you don’t know how. A prime example is when the environment changes and your mind adapts your getting the feel for it and adjust. It does all of the calculations for you just by practicing, because they are way too complicated to sit there and think about. It’s one of those things where you just have to do it. Such as reading, do you remember every word you learned to read? No! Just by reading over and over you learn to do it faster. Did you look up in the dictionary every single word you know that you speak with? No! You see the point. It’s all in the minds flexibility.</p><p>This is my entire thesis on learning. I believe with these seven steps I have mapped out the entire learning process that takes place within the mind. This is how it works. It is how I came to see it and nothing was worked for me better then understanding these to aid in my learning. I really do believe they are huge and definitely should be considered. There is no way I made all of this up. I would have to be extremely bored. No, rather I was excited when I finally pieced it all together. This is how learning works. I seriously doubted it to but kept telling myself I wasn’t making this up and picked it up through my intuition and the more I think about these steps trying to relate them the more it is clear. It is something now when I come across everyday situations I totally see how they fit in.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=604ac1b1db0a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Why the CTMU as I see it is the Greatest Theory Ever Conceived, Eternal, Irreplaceable and as it…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/why-the-ctmu-as-i-see-it-is-the-greatest-theory-ever-conceived-eternal-irreplaceable-and-as-it-7dc1ed4f94df?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7dc1ed4f94df</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quantum-physics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jan 2018 22:41:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-29T22:41:07.990Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>“Why the CTMU as I see it is the Greatest Theory Ever Conceived, Eternal, Irreplaceable and as it specifically applies to Physics”</strong></h3><p><strong>The Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe as the Nexus of Spirituality and Cosmology:</strong></p><p>An Interdisciplinary Approach to Reality</p><p>Christopher Michael Langan</p><p>1. General Introduction</p><p>Since the dawn of our species, human beings have been asking difficult questions about themselves, the universe and the nature of existence, but have lacked a unified conceptual framework strong and broad enough to yield the answers. Enter the</p><p>Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe (CTMU).</p><p>This will be laid out in two parts. Part 1 will be the philosophy and the logic of how the theory is developed that should change how we view and use science forever. Part 2 is strictly physics and what the CTMU says about physics at least in the basics. So 1. Philosophy as it relates to science. 2. As it relates to physics such as resolving the quantum non locality paradox and a new interpretation of quantum physics with a new model fundamental conceptualization more fundamental than the atom and the ultimate conclusions or solutions come at the end such as non-locality with some mixed at or hinted in throughout when I get to that part. But all of that is preceded by some preliminary rudimentary physics on things such as time and how physics relates to the expression of our minds as Langan lays out and briefed here so that nothing much is to be assumed but is still just an overview in the best way I could summarize and brief it while reaching some grand conclusions specific to physics without getting into too much detail the best I could. So again Part 1. The logic of the CTMU 2. As it is applied to physics with a new model of space-time.</p><p>Before I get into the rest of elaborating on the physics part I would like to try again in another approach in one sentence or one phrase(As I agreed to for clarification) what the theory even is because there is another maybe even better way to put it then I did before that’s more clear: <strong>“The CTMU is a theory that says all of the physical outcomes from the original formation of the universe and all its content physical or non-physical are outcomes of logical structure and it is through these absolute rules of logic that everything in existence conforms to on some level, and is how we can use these absolute rules of logic-because everything by the nature of its existence conforms to these rules of logical structure in being created- the CTMU lays out as logical axioms to solve any problem in science including in the realm of quantum physics and actually solve anything we haven’t or can’t directly observe by-passing empirical induction where the predictions that flow from such solutions will be subject to empirical confirmation later on.”</strong></p><p>In the CTMU everything in existence embedded in reality conforms to logical structure of some kind and the CTMU proposes to get to the bottom of the absolute rules of logic. These rules of logic can even be applied to quantum mechanics and that not even HUP-Heisenberg Uncertainty violates these logical principles. For example in getting to the bottom of it with logic to an absolute invariant level that would apply to all reality and all physical structure and even simultaneous electrons that can’t seem to be tracked in one place at one specific location with the perfect momentum in one moment in time cannot violate this fundamental rule of logic which truth is based on called the Tautology principle:</p><p>For example, take the sentential tautology “X v ~X” (X OR NOT-X). Applied to perception, this means that when something is seen or observed, <strong>it is not seen in conjunction with its absence(Such as an electron)</strong>; if it were, then two contradictory perceptions would coincide, resulting in a “splitting off” of perceptual realities. In effect, either the consciousness of the perceiver would split into two separate cognitive realities in a case of chain-reactive dissociation, or the perceiver himself would physically split along with physical reality. When “X v ~X” is composed with other tautologies (or itself) by substitution, the stakes are exactly the same; any violation of the compound tautology would split perceptual and cognitive reality with disastrous implications for its integrity.28</p><p>Also: Even so called “nonstandard” logics, e.g. modal, fuzzy and many-valued logics, must be expressed in terms of fundamental two-valued logic to make sense. In short, two-valued logic is something without which reality could not exist. If it were eliminated, then true and false, real and unreal, and existence and nonexistence could not be distinguished, and the merest act of perception or cognition would be utterly impossible.</p><p>The CTMU says these rules of logic it lays out can be used to investigate the substance of science and that this principle no electron if it exists in space time can violate which this is a good start to solving everything.</p><p>The only problem results is when things get really complex lots of details and informational complexity increases in the various scientific phenomena we are studying whether its cell organelles in cell biology or complex interaction of electrons and making sense of quantum gravity and trying to unify that with relativity or any number of things such as trying to find the cause and/or for cancer which is what Langan means when he says:</p><p>“As complexity rises and predicates become theories, tautology and truth become harder to recognize. Because universality and specificity are at odds in practice if not in principle, they are subject to a kind of “logical decoherence” associated with relational stratification. Because predicates are not always tautological, they are subject to various kinds of ambiguity; as they become increasingly specific and complex, it becomes harder to locally monitor the heritability of consistency and locally keep track of the truth property in the course of attribution(Such as the HUP Principle in QM) (or even after the fact). Undecidability,26 LSAT intractability and NP-completeness, predicate ambiguity and the Lowenheim-Skolem theorem, observational ambiguity and the Duhem-Quine thesis27 …these are some of the problems that emerge once the truth predicate “decoheres” with respect to complex attributive mappings. It is for reasons like these that the philosophy of science has fallen back on falsificationist doctrine, giving up on the tautological basis of logic, effectively demoting truth to provisional status, and discouraging full appreciation of the tautological-syntactic level of scientific inquiry even in logic and philosophy themselves. In fact, the validity of scientific theories and of science as a whole absolutely depends on the existence of a fundamental reality-theoretic framework spanning all of science…a fundamental syntax from which all scientific and mathematical languages, and the extended cognitive language of perception itself, can be grammatically unfolded, cross-related and validated. Tautology, the theoretical basis of truth as embodied in sentential logic, is obviously the core of this syntax. Accordingly, reality theory must be developed through amplification of this tautological syntax”…. Here is an example of Langan saying how tautologies and these absolute philosophical rules of logic can be used to solve scientific paradoxes in various theoretical contexts and settings of any kind of scientific phenomena even under a microscope or through a telescope whatever your looking at:</p><p>“By converting tautologies into other tautologies, the rules of inference of sentential logic convert cognitive-perceptual invariants into other such invariants. To pursue this agenda in reality theory, we must identify principles that describe how the looping structure of logical tautology is manifest in various reality-theoretic settings and contexts on various levels of description and interpretation; that way, we can verify its preservation under the operations of theoretic reduction and extension. I.e., we must adjoin generalized principles of loop structure to logical syntax in such a way that more and more of reality is thereby explained and comprehensiveness is achieved.”</p><p>To amplify this and hit this home how the CTMU proposes and uses logic to study science we haven’t even observed including metaphysics and solve anything in science and the idea that everything physical conforms to this logical structure consider his first answer in the CTMU Q and A of what the CTMU even is and how its constructed which this one response should show how the CTMU changes science as we know it but this one answer about the CTMU may even change your entire outlook on studying science as it did me!:</p><p>Chris, I’m not a mathematician or physicist by any stretch, but I am a curious person and would like to know more about the <strong>CTMU</strong> (Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe). I am particularly interested in the theological aspects. Can you please explain what the <strong>CTMU </strong>is all about in language that even I can understand?</p><p><strong>A</strong>: Thanks for your interest, but the truth is the <strong>CTMU</strong> isn’t all that difficult for even a layperson to understand. So sit back, relax, kick off your shoes and open your mind…</p><p>Scientific theories are<strong> <em>mental</em> </strong>constructs that have <strong><em>objective reality</em></strong> as their content. According to the scientific method, science puts objective content first, letting theories be determined by observation. But the phrase “a theory of reality” contains two key nouns, <strong><em>theory </em></strong>and <strong><em>reality</em></strong>, and science is really about both. Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms — we could just as well start with these properties and see what they might tell us about objective reality. Just as scientific observation makes demands on theories, the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe.</p><p>In other words, a comprehensive theory of reality is not just about observation, but about theories and their logical requirements. Since theories are mental constructs, and <strong><em>mental</em></strong> means “of the mind”, this can be rephrased as follows: <strong><em>mind</em></strong><em> </em>and<em> </em><strong><em>reality</em></strong> are linked in mutual dependence at the most basic level of understanding. This linkage of mind and reality is what a <strong>TOE</strong>(Theory of Everything) is really about. The <strong>CTMU</strong> is such a theory; instead of being a mathematical description of specific observations (like all established scientific theories), it is a “metatheory” about the general relationship between theories and observations…i.e., about science or knowledge itself. Thus, it can credibly lay claim to the title of <strong>TOE</strong>.</p><p>Mind and reality — the abstract and the concrete, the subjective and the objective, the internal and the external — are linked together in a certain way, and this linkage is the real substance of “reality theory”. Just as scientific observation determines theories, the logical requirements of theories to some extent determine scientific observation. Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty, and this means that a comprehensive theory of reality cannot be based on scientific observation alone. Instead, it must be based on the process of making scientific observations in general, and this process is based on the relationship of mind and reality. So the <strong>CTMU</strong> is essentially <strong><em>a theory of the relationship between mind and reality</em></strong>.</p><p>In explaining this relationship, the <strong>CTMU</strong> shows that reality possesses a complex property akin to <strong><em>self-awareness</em></strong>. That is, just as the mind is real, reality is in some respects like a mind. But when we attempt to answer the obvious question “<strong><em>whose</em></strong> mind?”, the answer turns out to be a mathematical and scientific definition of God. This implies that we all exist in what can be called “the Mind of God”, and that our individual minds are parts of God’s Mind. They are not as powerful as God’s Mind, for they are only parts thereof; yet, they are directly connected to the greatest source of knowledge and power that exists. This connection of our minds to the Mind of God, which is like the connection of parts to a whole, is what we sometimes call the <strong><em>soul</em></strong> or <strong><em>spirit</em></strong>, and it is the most crucial and essential part of being human.</p><p>Thus, the attempt to formulate a comprehensive theory of reality, the <strong>CTMU</strong>, finally leads to spiritual understanding, producing a basis for the unification of science and theology. The traditional Cartesian divider between body and mind, science and spirituality, is penetrated by logical reasoning of a higher order than ordinary scientific reasoning, but no less scientific than any other kind of mathematical truth. Accordingly, it serves as the long-awaited gateway between science and humanism, a bridge of reason over what has long seemed an impassable gulf.</p><p>It’s worth taking a close look at this if not from the authors someone else’s perspective to see what I mean when this answer and the CTMU is capable of changing humanities entire outlook on science or knowledge itself-Which as I said I would interject my own thoughts periodically as the CTMU hit me as how I have come to understand it and make sense of what the CTMU is trying to tell us-as if from another dimension:</p><p>Scientific theories are<strong> <em>mental</em> </strong>constructs that have <strong><em>objective reality</em></strong> as their content. As I don’t think this is debatable the idea of a theory is something we came up with from our own minds and hypothesized on our own. Consider Einstein’s thought experiments but any theory is this way. And the theory is conjecturing about objective reality which is things we can observe and touch and feel and see and experimentally test in the laboratory and using technology and microscopes etc. We theorize and form a mental construct about something we observe.</p><p>According to the scientific method, science puts objective content first, letting theories be determined by observation. The order in which science is done is observing phenomena then thinking about it abstractly in deep thought trying to make sense of it and forming a theory about it. But in doing this science says our theories are determined by what we can observe or the data we test for and observe. From this data the scientists modifies the theory to accommodate the data observed and if the data invalidates the theory then the theory is thrown out. Which is what this is saying. Our theories are determined by the observed data we test for and let that determine truth content and the validity of our theories. And there is nothing wrong with that however…</p><p>But the phrase “a theory of reality” contains two key nouns, <strong><em>theory </em></strong>and <strong><em>reality</em></strong>, and science is really about both. Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms. Science isn’t just about what we can observe but theorizing about it. Our theories is our actual acquired body of knowledge. Science if it is a process and means anything at all isn’t just go look at stuff for we can all see the universe outside of us. This is indisputable science is about both what we can observe and theorize as that’s where the mind and intelligence comes in and our historical respect for brilliance. We all have observed gravity and motion and acceleration but it wasn’t until Newton came along and actually theorized about what he observed and formed equations about it that did it matter. No one can just look at light and observe it and see the theory of relativity that took Einstein’s theory and equations. So science is about both theory (our mental constructs) and reality (what we observe the empirical data).</p><p>Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms. This is very true and insightful when one thinks about it. Newton’s theory of motion doesn’t exist without logical properties and abstract mathematical reasoning, F=MA. The theory doesn’t exist without that equation. That is the only way we can understand what Newton means. Same with Einstein’s E=MC². Similar to every theory and established scientific law they all have necessary logical properties that require ABSTRACT thought and reasoning to figure this out and put it together. For Newton to come up with F=MA and Einstein to figure E=MC² took a brilliant mind and why intelligence matters in the scientific process and very deep and abstract thought and advanced mental reasoning that’s not so concrete and easily laid out. It takes a mind to do this kind of thinking and is more than just observing and look at things. These properties of our theories are independent of observation. The logical and mathematical properties of our theories and equations are completely separate from observation for if they weren’t we could all just observe motion and know this. And it is these properties of our theories and logical reasoning that we can know anything at all and understand out world in conceptual terms. So now that we now this here’s the idea of how the CTMU can change science as we know it:</p><p>We could just as well start with these properties and see what they might tell us about objective reality. Just as scientific observation makes demands on theories, the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe. So here’s the main idea, we could essentially this is saying we can also instead of observing something first and thinking about it and letting all our theories be determined by just empirical data and the reason this runs into problems is- because of empirical induction assuming the uniformity of nature-There are things we can’t observe. Also there are things we can’t just make sense of and understand by mere observation even when observing it. So science has its limits. So to get around this and circumvent this problem here Langan is saying for instance in Einstein’s case would could’ve have just started with E=MC² and us that to tell us what we can observe. Einstein had to observe light and think about it deeply to come up with the equation and Newton likewise had to observe gravity and motion but this is saying Newton or Einstein never having observed these things and tested for them or in relativity with the bending of light we can just start with the logic and math and if it’s based on correct absolute rules of logic and mathematical reasoning use that to tell us what we will observe before or never having observed it. We can flip science around backwards the process and use that to investigate reality. We can start by developing rules of logic and math without observing anything and have that be the decider of what is true or how the empirical data will go. Same with a mathematical proof of God even though we don’t claim to have seen or known to have seen God the idea is the same. We can start with developing the math and logical reasoning never observing anything then use these rules to apply it to everything we observe and a theory developed this way is without flaw error or at the least any assumptions. It just takes a brilliant mind to figure out how to do this. That’s why when Langan writes: the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe. With this idea our knowledge and understanding isn’t just limited to what we can directly observe. We can continue to further and further develop the logic of theories to deepen our explanatory scope and the CTMU is the theory that says how to do this. Any number of scientists or mathematicians or philosophers that get their hands on this kind of knowledge can use it to solve any number of problems they are working on that Langan doesn’t solve in his lifetime why Langan elsewhere in the CTMU Q and A page writes: “Unlike other TOEs, the CTMU does not purport to be a “complete” theory; there are too many physical details and undecidable mathematical theorems to be accounted for (enough to occupy whole future generations of mathematicians and scientists), and merely stating a hypothetical relationship among families of subatomic particles is only a small part of the explanatory task before us. Instead, the CTMU is merely designed to be consistent and comprehensive at a high level of generality, a level above that at which most other TOEs are prematurely aimed.<br> <br> The good news is that a new model of physical spacetime, and thus a whole new context for addressing the usual round of quantum cosmological problems, has emerged from the CTMU’s direct attack on deeper philosophical issues. The point is the CTMU is eternal and irreplaceable because these rules of logic it uses to investigate reality can be used by any scientists and applied to any problem solving problems in particle physics forever. This is what a theory of everything would do that is truly comprehensive unless the only other way would be to actually describe all of the informational data and everything science can ever observe forever in the universe and know everything at once which is humanly impossible. Why the CTMU defines reality as: “we can refine the definition of reality as follows: “Reality is the perceptual aggregate including (1) all scientific observations that ever were and ever will be, and (2) the entire abstract and/or cognitive explanatory infrastructure of perception” (where the abstract is a syntactic generalization of the concrete standing for ideas, concepts or cognitive structures distributing over physical instances which conform to them as content conforms to syntax).”-Pg.16.</p><p>One would have to be God to know everything there is at once Why the CTMU defines God as: “This implies that we all exist in what can be called “the Mind of God”, and that our individual minds are parts of God’s Mind. They are not as powerful as God’s Mind, for they are only parts thereof; yet, they are directly connected to the greatest source of knowledge and power that exists.” And also about knowing everything “Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty, and this means that a comprehensive theory of reality cannot be based on scientific observation alone.” So there we have God as defined as the greatest source of power and knowledge that exists which if God exists would be the greatest being in existence there could be. Then we have the idea that why science will always be able to occupy us as the CTMU also shows reality is in a constant state of self-creation which includes free will take from the 56 page paper “Telic recursion is a fundamental process that tends to maximize a cosmic self-selection parameter, generalized utility, over a set of possible syntax-state relationships in light of the self-configurative freedom of the universe.”-Pg.35. In other words information is always being added to the universe Which Langan has also been recorded in an interview saying “The classical Laplacian-deterministic worldview is all but dead. As reality is affected by every possible kind of ambiguity, uncertainty, indeterminacy, and undecidability, no theory of reality can ever be complete. In principle, this makes any such theory a permanent work-in-progress in which a very great deal always remains to be done. Exploration must continue.</p><p>However, a theory of reality can still be comprehensive, classifying knowledge in the large rather than determining it exhaustively.” The point is there is always more to learn which again is why Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty. But back to the original point of the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe. The idea is this how the CTMU changes our outlook on science: Newton by observing motion and acceleration could quantify things such as the acceleration of gravity or how force accelerates motion. He observed it and then thought about it for a while as Newton himself is quoted as saying “If I have done the public any service, it is due to my patient thought.”<br> Read more at: <a href="https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/isaac_newton_135550">https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/isaac_newton_135550</a></p><p>The main idea is Newton as though Newton figured out F=MA and it was shown to successfully work by measurement and experimental data we can say that the logic of theories makes demands on what we observe. F=MA was correct by experimental data. From this knowledge and any valid scientific theory that was confirmed by observation we can say the or just as well say instead of letting our theories be determined by observation Newton could’ve just started with F=MA without observing anything and know he was right just by mathematical and philosophical rules of reasoning and logic. This idea shows we can flip it and start with logic first. The CTMU shows just how to do this. The CTMU is saying Newton could’ve never observed motion and still come up with it and be correct. And that F=MA does make a demand on what we will observe. Through these logical requirements we can look at them if they are done with correct logic which logic is the valid rules of thought and use these concepts to tell us what we will observe in the universe before we have observed it and know we are right and use it to increase our knowledge on what we can observe. We can just develop the logic and math to do this. F=MA makes a demand on what we observe in the universe. Same with any logical principles if they can be done according to absolute invariant rules of logic. The Central hypothesis of the theory then one could say is everything observable in the universe conforms to certain rules of logic and that nothing is random and it is through these rules of logic we can classify all knowledge in the universe and successfully describe anything because everything physical by its existence conforms to such rules of logic.</p><p>In other words, a comprehensive theory of reality is not just about observation, but about theories and their logical requirements. Since theories are mental constructs, and <strong><em>mental</em></strong> means “of the mind”, this can be rephrased as follows: <strong><em>mind</em></strong><em> </em>and<em> </em><strong><em>reality</em></strong> are linked in mutual dependence at the most basic level of understanding. This linkage of mind and reality is what a <strong>TOE</strong>(Theory of Everything) is really about. The <strong>CTMU</strong> is such a theory; instead of being a mathematical description of specific observations (like all established scientific theories), it is a “metatheory” about the general relationship between theories and observations…i.e., about science or knowledge itself. Thus, it can credibly lay claim to the title of <strong>TOE</strong>. This how saying how then the CTMU was developed and what it means to be a theory of everything and why it can credibly lay claim to such a title and be used as so to apply to anything science can get its hands on.</p><p>And so this is the idea of how it is developed as such and is without assumptions and stripping away constraints and actually developed backwards from science and does it the opposite way and flips the process on its head as we were just describing. Instead of our theories be determined by observation our theories determine observation: “This precludes a neat series of cumulative definitions, which is possible in any case only by taking for granted the content and wherewithal of theorization (unfortunately, one can take nothing for granted in reality theory). As we will see below, the recursive nature of the CTMU is unavoidable. Secondly, the CTMU is developed “backwards” with respect to the usual deductive theories of science and mathematics, by first peeling away constraints and only then using the results to deduce facts about content. Most theories begin with axioms, hypotheses and rules of inference, extract implications, logically or empirically test these implications, and then add or revise axioms, theorems or hypotheses. The CTMU does the opposite, stripping away assumptions and “rebuilding reality” while adding no assumptions back.”-Pg.15 So the CTMU is without assumption developing inescapable rules of logic that can apply to describing anything in existence qualifying it as a theory of everything. And that’s what most of the 56 page paper is about. This shows that science cannot be divorced from philosophy.</p><p><strong><em>The CTMU and Physics (</em></strong>The physics here is obviously summed up but is also edited from how this is formatted from this same section on page 17–18 of the 19 page document summarizing the CTMU I printed off and put together of a Hodge podge different answers or responses of Chris about the CTMU in general of what it is and has to offer and why it’s important or anyone should care. This here is strictly physics a little more in depth from the messy copy and paste format of this part on page 17 and 18 of that with the new definition of space, time, matter and motion.<strong>)</strong></p><p>The avowed goal of physics is to produce what is sometimes called a “Theory of Everything” or TOE. As presently conceived, the TOE is thought to consist of one equation describing a single “superforce” unifying all the forces of nature (gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak nuclear forces).But this is actually an over simplification; every equation must be embedded in a Theory, and theories require models for their proper interpretation. Unfortunately, the currently available theory and model lack three important properties: closure, Consistency and comprehensivity. That is, they are not self-contained; they suffer from various intractable paradoxes; and they conspicuously exclude or neglect various crucial factors, including subjective ones like consciousness and emotion. Since the excluded factors fall as squarely under the heading everything as the included ones, a real TOE has no business omitting them. So as now envisioned by physicists, the TOE is misnamed as a “theory of everything”. The CTMU, on the other hand, is a TOE framework in which “everything” really means everything</p><p>Whereas the currently-envisioned TOE emphasizes objective reality at the expense of its subjective counterpart (mind), the CTMU places mind on the agenda at the outset. It does this not by making assumptions, but by eliminating the erroneous scientific assumption that mind and objective reality can be even tentatively separated. To do this, it exploits not just what we know of objective reality–the so-called “everything” of the standard TOE–but also what we know of the first word in “TOE”, namely theory. In other words, it brings the logic of formalized theories to bear on reality theory. Although this is a mathematically obvious move, it has been almost completely overlooked in the physical and mathematical sciences. By correcting this error, the CTMU warrants description as a theory of the relationship between the</p><p>Mind of the theorist and the objective reality about which it theorizes, <strong>completing the program of subjective-objective unification already inherent in certain aspects of the formalisms of relativity and quantum mechanics. In the process, it also brings the quantum and classical realms of physics into the sort of intimate contact that can only be provided by a fundamentally new model of physical and metaphysical reality…a model truly worthy of being called a “new paradigm”.</strong> <strong>Fundamental to this new model are revisions of basic physical concepts including space, time, matter and motion.</strong> <strong>Space</strong>, once a featureless medium aimlessly proliferating through cosmic expansion, becomes a distributed syntactic structure iteratively reborn of matter and subject to conspansive evacuation and rescaling. <strong>Time</strong>, previously envisioned as a quasi-spatial linear dimension along which the cosmos hurtles like a runaway locomotive, becomes the means by which the universe self-configures… an SCSPL-grammatical symphony of logico-linguistic transformations played by the self-creating cosmos. Lumps of <strong>matter</strong>, no longer the inert pawns of external laws of physics, become SCSPL syntactic operators containing within themselves the syntactic rules by which they internally process each other to create new states of physical reality. And <strong>motion</strong>, once seen as the passage of material attribute-ensembles through adjacent infinitesimal cells of empty space displaying them as content, becomes an iterative, self-simulative sequence of endomorphic self-projections by moving bodies themselves</p><p>SCSPL relates <strong>space</strong>, <strong>time</strong> and <strong>object</strong> by means of conspansive duality and conspansion, an SCSPL-grammatical process featuring an alternation between dual phases of existence associated with design and actualization and related to the familiar wave-particle duality of quantum mechanics.-Pg. 1 of Abstract.</p><p>By distributing the design phase of reality over the actualization phase, conspansive spacetime also provides a distributed mechanism for Intelligent Design, adjoining to the restrictive principle of <strong>natural selection a basic means of generating information and complexity </strong>(This is how in the theory intelligent design and evolution go together as evolution is added or natural selection is added information whether it be the human genome or what have you into biological life. Its added information into the universe. Evolution is not random but added information as it evolves which it must as things evolve organs and such and it’s also a design process guided by cosmic evolution in the CTMU is a process called telic causation<strong>.</strong>-also page 1.</p><p>Duality is a ubiquitous concept in mathematics, appearing in fields from logic and the theory of categories to geometry and analysis. The duality relation is symmetric; if dualizing proposition A yields proposition B, then dualizing B yields A.</p><p>Duality principles thus come in two common varieties, one transposing spatial relations and objects, and one transposing objects or spatial relations with mappings, functions, operations or processes. The first is called space-object (or S-O) duality; the second, time-space (or T-S/O) duality. In either case, the central feature is a transposition of element and a (spatial or temporal) relation of elements. Together, these dualities add up to the concept of triality, which represents the universal possibility of consistently permuting the attributes <strong>time</strong>, <strong>space</strong> and <strong>object </strong>with respect to various structures. From this, we may extract a third kind of duality: ST-O duality. In this kind of duality, associated with something called conspansive duality, objects can be “dualized” to spatiotemporal transducers, and the physical universe internally “simulated”(<strong> it is possible to apply a logical-Pg.41 transformation which inverts this picture, turning it “outside-in”. This results in a “distributed subjectivization” in which everything occurs inside the objects , effectively putting every object “inside” every other one in a generalized way and thereby placing the contents of space on the same footing as that formerly occupied by the containing space itself. In effect, the universe becomes a “selfsimulation” running inside its own contents); </strong>by its material contents. (<strong>But where communication happens on all scales, the distinction between inside and outside is not so clear. The languages communicated among language users and processors, and the languages embodied by users and processors themselves, occupy an overall medium with a unified communicative syntax largely indifferent to the distinction. The laws that govern a system may be reposed in the space that contains its objects, or in the objects themselves. Classical physics reposes everything in space, applying spatial concepts like vectors and tensors to fields outside the objects. However, it is possible to apply a logical 41 transformation which inverts this picture, turning it “outside-in”. This results in a “distributed subjectivization” in which everything occurs inside the objects; the objects are simply defined to consistently internalize their interactions, effectively putting every object “inside” every other one in a generalized way and thereby placing the contents of space on the same footing as that formerly occupied by the containing space itself. Vectors and tensors then become descriptors of the internal syntactic properties and states of objects. In effect, the universe becomes a “selfsimulation” running inside its own contents. This view, which is complementary to the conventional geometric one, is called transductive algebra. The “dual” relationship between geometry and transductive algebra is called conspansive duality. In conjunction with other principles including hology and SCSPLinfocognitive-telic reducibility, conspansive duality can afford fresh insight on the nature of reality and the physical world. One simply takes the conventional picture, turns it outside-in, puts the two pictures together, and extracts the implications</strong>).</p><p>We can now through the CTMU classify these four elements of physics space, time, matter and motion and all of reality and perception at large which in the CTMU is contained in the HCS which is distributed over the entire universe; short for Human-Cognitive-Syntax. This contains everything physics studies and more:</p><p>“The primary transducers of the overall language of science are scientists, and their transductive syntax consists of the syntax of generalized scientific observation and theorization, i.e. perception and cognition. We may therefore partition or stratify this syntax according to the nature of the logical and nonlogical elements incorporated in syntactic rules. For example, we might develop <strong>four</strong> classes corresponding to the fundamental <strong>trio</strong> space, time and object, a class containing the rules of logic and mathematics, a class consisting of the perceptual qualia in terms of which we define and extract experience, meaning and utility from perceptual and cognitive reality, and a class accounting for more <strong><em>nebulous feelings</em></strong> and <strong><em>emotions i</em></strong>ntegral to the determination of utility for qualic relationships.44 For now, we might as well call these classes <strong>STOS</strong>, <strong>LMS</strong>, <strong>QPS</strong> and <strong>ETS</strong>, respectively standing for space-time-object syntax, logico-mathematical syntax, qualioperceptual syntax, and emo-telic syntax, along with a high-level interrelationship of these components to the structure of which all or some of them ultimately contribute. Together, these ingredients comprise the Human Cognitive-Perceptual Syntax or HCS”.-Pg.41-In the HCS would be contained all of the information content of the entire universe including all of physics or what physics studies.</p><p>For it seems that just ahead on the intellectual horizon looms a new science of metaphysics…a logical framework in which the importance of humankind is unthreatened by reductionism, this framework yields a new understanding of <strong>space</strong> and <strong>time</strong>. The logical structure of <strong>space-time</strong> provides the universe with the wherewithal of being, endowing it with self-creative freedom and <strong>permitting it to rise</strong> from a <strong>sea</strong> of undifferentiated <strong>ontological potential</strong>.</p><p>Thus, the universe “selects itself” from unbound telesis or UBT, a realm of zero information and unlimited <strong>ontological potential</strong>, by means of telic recursion, whereby infocognitive syntax and its informational content are cross-refined through telic (syntax-state) feedback over the entire range of potential syntax-state relationships, up to and including all of <strong>spacetime</strong> and reality in general.</p><p>In this ostensibly inanimate, impersonal universe, a garden is a miracle. All the more so is a garden slug, an animal that can extract sufficient energy from the garden’s vegetable matter to move from place to place under its own power. When one is in the right mood, watching the shimmering spotted slug slide over the mulch evokes the miracle of biology in all its splendor; the creature’s pulsating aliveness is hypnotic. But then one recovers his bearings and 85 realizes that this is only, after all, a garden slug, and that the ladder of biology goes much higher. The miracle of life has culminated in one’s own species, man. Unlike the slug, whose nervous system has barely enough complexity to let it interface with the environment, a man’s nervous system, nucleated by the adaptive and inventive human brain, can abstractly model its surroundings and project itself consciously and creatively through time.</p><p>To see an object change, one must recall its former state for comparison to its present state, and to do that, one must recall one’s former perception of it. Because <strong>perception:</strong> is an interaction between self and environment(This will show a good transition from the most basic work to his 56 Page paper of the definition of perception “perception is a sensory intersect of mind and reality”-pg.19) , this amounts to bringing one’s <strong>former</strong> self into conjunction with one’s <strong>present</strong> self. That past and present selves can be brought into conjunction across a temporal interval implies that momentary selves remain sufficiently alike to be conjoined; that they can intersect at any given moment to compare content means that the intersection is changeless. So when self is generalized as the intersection of all momentary selves, it acquires a property called time invariance. It is the rock of perception, the unchanging observation post from which the net of temporal connections is cast and to which it remains anchored.</p><p>Through learning, mental models of <strong>time</strong> evolve in <strong>time</strong>. As the brain’s neural connections are modified and the strengths of existing connections are adjusted to account for new information regarding both self and environment — as it learns — its model of time changes as a function of time. In other words, the model changes with that which is modeled. If the brain is smart enough, then it can model itself in the process of being changed, and depict its own learning process as a higher level of <strong>time</strong>. But even as the self-absorbs its educational history and deepens its reflexive understanding, it remains static at its core. Otherwise, it would lose temporal cohesion and fall apart. Since self is static, <strong>time</strong> too should possess a static description that does not change in the temporal flow it describes (if <strong>time</strong> were the water flowing in a river, then a static description of <strong>time</strong> would be analogous to the rocky banks that determine the river’s course).</p><p>Such a description arises by abstraction. As cognitive models become more sophisticated, cognition becomes increasingly abstract; concepts become increasingly 88 independent of the particular objects they describe. Among the first things to be abstracted are <strong>space</strong> and <strong>time</strong>. The most general abstract system incorporating both is a <strong>language</strong>. Although the term “language” usually refers to a natural language like English, it is actually more general(This is taken from an online chat with Langan describing what a language actually is: “Most people think that a language must be a natural, spoken or written language like English, French or German. But in mathematics and logic, the definition of language is far more general. Reality itself can be viewed as a language,”) <strong>mathematically</strong>, a formal <strong>language</strong> consists of three ingredients: a set of elements to be combined as strings (e.g., symbols, memes), a set of <strong>structural rules</strong> governing their arrangement in <strong>space</strong>, and a set of <strong>grammatical rules</strong> governing their <strong>transformations</strong> in <strong>time</strong>. Together, the latter two ingredients form the <strong>syntax</strong> of the language. It follows that <strong>neural</strong>, cognitive-perceptual, and physical systems can be <strong>described as languages</strong>, and the <strong>laws</strong> which govern them as their <strong>syntaxes</strong>. On a subjective level, <strong>time </strong>itself can be abstractly characterized as the <strong>grammar</strong> of the joint language of cognition and perception. The rules of this grammar are the general ingredients of <strong>subjective time</strong>.</p><p>Because <strong>time-</strong> is defined in terms of transformations among spatial arrangements of objects, it is conceptually entwined with <strong>space</strong>. Thus, it is actually part of a linguistic complex called <strong>spacetime</strong>. Spatiotemporal relations exist on 89 many levels; if level one consists of simple relationships of objects in space and time, then level two consists of relationships of such relationships, and so on. Because <strong>logic</strong> is stratified in much the same way, one can say that time is stratified in a manner corresponding to <strong>predicate logic</strong>. This must be true in any case, since any meaningful description of <strong>time</strong> is logically formulated. Spatiotemporal stratification allows time to be viewed on various scales corresponding to ascending series of contexts: e.g., personal awareness, interpersonal relationships, social evolution, evolutionary biology, and so on. The histories of people, institutions, cultures, and species are nested like Chinese boxes, with the abstract principles of each history occupying a level of <strong>temporal grammar</strong> corresponding to an order of <strong>predicate logic</strong>.</p><p>Because of the relation between self-awareness and temporal awareness, temporal stratification induces a stratification of self. What we have already described as the static intersect of momentary selves becomes a stratified relationship…a terrace of temporal vantages conducing to long-term self-integration. As the self becomes stratified, the 90 principles abstracted from higher orders of experience tend to be objectivized due to their generality, with <strong>science and philosophy</strong> among the results. Thus, the subjective and objective sides of reality — the self and the environment — tend to merge in a symmetric way. On one hand, the environment is absorbed by the self through experience, and <strong>the laws of nature</strong> are thereby abstracted; on the other hand, the self is projected onto the environment in such a way that it “selects” the laws of nature by analogy to its own internal laws <strong>(</strong>Langan gives a very good example of this in the CTMU Q and A “My question is this: If you could answer the question what is the mathematical difference between visible light and invisible light, i.e. ultraviolet rays, wouldn’t this answer the question concerning the importance of further study into what is defined as physical. After all how do you perceive ultraviolet rays — as a sunburn or plant growth. Therefore, although not visible there indeed may be other energy forms that coexist right where we are, having an impact on us, without our knowing its source. It is not visibly physical yet its effect on us is very physical.</p><p><strong>A</strong>: Visible and UV light differ in <em>frequency</em>, or number of waves transmitted or received per second. Because light always travels at the same speed (c = ~300K km/sec), higher frequency means shorter waves:</p><p>lambda = c/frequency (where lambda = wavelength)</p><p>I.e., more energetic, higher-frequency light has a smaller <em>wavelength</em> than less energetic, lower-frequency light. Unfortunately, the tiny light sensors in our retinas, called <em>rods </em>and<em> cones</em>, cannot detect short-wavelength UV light.</p><p>Your question seems to be this: how can we call UV light “physical” when we cannot directly detect it? The answer is twofold but simple: we can call it “physical” because of (1) its perceptible physical effects on animals, plants, minerals and detection devices, and (2) our need to acknowledge the full definitions and logical implications of our perceptions and concepts.</p><p>Answer (2) is why reality is not merely “physical” in the concrete or material sense. In order to exist as a self-consistent perceptible entity, reality must ultimately make logical sense; our perceptions of it must conform to a coherent <em>cognitive syntax</em> containing the rules of perception and cognition and incorporating logic. This syntax tells us that if light exists <em>below</em> the maximum visible frequency, then in the absence of any extra constraints, it can exist <em>above</em> it as well.</p><p>Specifically, having identified the physical cause of light to be photon emission by subatomic oscillators called <em>electrons</em>, we are compelled to recognize the existence of “light” at whatever frequencies such oscillators may exhibit, right up through X and gamma radiation. The logical component of our cognitive syntax ultimately forces us to define and cross-relate all of the concepts in terms of which we apprehend reality, including light, in a logically consistent way”-This with the scientific example of UV rays and visible and invisible light is saying we can only know and understand reality through LOGIC period. And that’s all physical substance of the universe conforms to categories of LOGICAL SYNTAX. All of the stuff of science has to exist by the rules of logic somehow<strong>)</strong>. Either way, the core self tends to intersect with the environment as momentary selves are intersected within it. This brings the subjective and objective phases of reality — and time — into closer correspondence, blurring the distinction between them from an analytic standpoint. As time grows more abstract, ways are sought to measure it, diagram it and analyze it numerically. <strong>This requires a universal depiction of space and time against which arbitrary processes can be differentially graphed and metered. Such a depiction was introduced by the Frenchman René Descartes in the first half of the 17th century. It was called analytic geometry, and it depicted time and the (P.91) dimensions of space as straight, mutually perpendicular axes.</strong> In analytic geometry, any set of numerically-scaled <strong>space</strong> and <strong>time</strong> axes associated with any set of properties or attributes defines a coordinate system for assigning numbers to points, and simple processes appear as the graphs of algebraic functions. A few decades later, Newton and Leibniz independently discovered a new kind of mathematics, <strong>the infinitesimal calculus</strong>, by which to numerically quantify the rates of such processes. These innovations, which laid the foundations of modern science and engineering, suffice to this day in many practical contexts. Even though garden-variety analytic geometry was technically superseded by the <strong>Theory of Relativity</strong> — which was itself constructed on an analytic-geometric foundation — it gives a very close approximation of relativity in most situations. Unfortunately, the conveniences of analytic geometry came at the price of <strong>mind-body dualism</strong>. This was Descartes’ idea that the self, or “mind”, was a nonphysical substance that could be left out of physical reasoning with impunity. For some purposes, this was true. But as we saw in the next- (P.92) to-last paragraph, the relationship of mind to reality is not that simple. <strong>While the temporal grammar of physics determines the neural laws of cognition, cognitive grammar projects itself onto physical reality in such a way as to determine the form that physical grammar must assume</strong>. Because the form of physical grammar limits the content of physical grammar, this makes <strong>cognition </strong>a potential factor in determining the laws of nature. In principle, cognitive and physical grammars may influence each other symmetrically. The symmetric influence of cognitive and physical grammars implies a directional symmetry of time. Although time is usually seen as a one-way street, it need not be; the mere fact that a street is marked “one way” does not stop it from being easily traveled in the unauthorized direction. Indeed, two-way time shows up in both quantum physics and relativity theory, the primary mainstays of modern physics. Thus, it is not physically warranted to say that cognition cannot influence the laws of physics because the laws of physics “precede cognition in time”. If we look at the situation from the other direction, we can as easily say that cognition “precedes” the laws of physics in reverse time…and 93 point to the strange bidirectional laws of particle physics to justify our position. These laws are of such a nature that they can as well be called <strong>laws of perception</strong> as laws of physics.</p><p>Before we get to the final word on <strong>time</strong>, there is one more aspect of physical grammar that must be considered. Physical reasoning sometimes requires a distinction between two kinds of time: <strong>ordinary time</strong> and <strong>cosmic time</strong>. With respect to observations made at normal velocities, <strong>ordinary time</strong> behaves in a way described by Newtonian analytic geometry; at higher velocities, and in the presence of strong gravitational fields, it behaves according to Einstein’s Special and General Theories of Relativity. But not long after Einstein formulated his General Theory, it was discovered that the universe, AKA <strong>spacetime, was expanding</strong>. Because cosmic expansion seems to imply that the universe began as a dimensionless point, the universe must have been created, and the creation event must have occurred on a higher level of time: <strong>cosmic time</strong>. Whereas o<strong>rdinary time </strong>accommodates changes occurring within the spacetime manifold, this is obviously not so for the kind of time in which the manifold itself changes. 94 Now for the fly in the cosmological ointment. As we have seen, it is the nature of the cognitive self to formulate models incorporating ever-higher levels of change (or time). Obviously, the highest level of change is that characterizing the creation of reality. Prior to the moment of creation, the universe was not there; afterwards, the universe was there. This represents a sizable change indeed! Unfortunately, it also constitutes a sizable paradox. If the creation of reality was a real event, and if this event occurred in cosmic time, then cosmic time itself is real. But then cosmic time is an aspect of reality and can only have been created with reality. This implies that cosmic time, and in fact reality, must have created themselves! The idea that <strong>the universe created</strong> <strong>itself</strong>(The idea that the universe creates itself because there is nothing other than the universe to do this goes along with how the CTMU characterizing the universe as an SCSPL language or Self Configuring Self Processing Language. The idea that the universe created itself means its “Self-Configuring” and it has its own mind is at this point at least very plausible that we live in a conscious and intelligently evolving universe or in the CTMU this is called how evolution and natural selection is consciously guided and an intelligent design process “Intelligent Self-Design.” This is how evolution happens in the universe anywhere. It designs itself intelligently. This is in the 56 page paper of the CTMU “The CTMU has a meta-Darwinian message: the universe evolves by hological self-replication and self-selection. Furthermore, because the universe is natural, its self-selection amounts to a <strong>cosmic form of</strong> <strong>natural selection</strong>. But by the nature of this selection process, it also bears description as <strong>intelligent self-design</strong>”-Pg.50. Langan has written what the idea of an intelligent and conscious universe means and if this can be firmly proven and it can <strong>“(</strong>Christopher Michael Langan’s HIQ &amp; A <br> <br> Chronological order from bottom to top of page <br> <br> <br> <br> Q: Many people conceive of the universe as a “supreme being”. The interconnectedness is evident in the consistency of physical laws and repetition of motif seen on a many levels. What is interesting is understanding the sentience of that supreme being. A drive toward growth, or self-actualization seems evident, but how can we prove a “will of God” that would go beyond a drive toward optimal actualization?<br> <br> A: There are several ways that we can be logically certain that the being called “reality” or “the universe” is sentient.<br> <br> 1. *We’re* sentient. Because we live in the medium known as “reality”, and because any attribute supported by a medium exists throughout the medium in the form of potential (to be objectively actualized), sentience implicitly exists in reality.<br> <br> 2. Despite the principle of locality — the existence of separate locales and local systems within the universe — the universe is globally consistent. The aspect of a system which reflexively enforces global consistency is necessarily globally coherent, and that which is coherently reflexive (self-active, self-referential) is, in effect, “sentient”.<br> <br> 3. Because, by definition, there is nothing outside of reality that is sufficiently real to recognize the existence of reality, reality must distributively recognize its own existence; every time one object interacts with another within it, the objects “recognize” each other as things with which to interact. But that means that reality is distributively self-aware.<br> <br> Now, given the absolute logical certainty that the universe is sentient (self-aware) — a certainty that nobody can possibly refute, as we see from the inevitability of 1–3 above — can we characterize its “will”?<br> <br> Yes. First, what is will? That function of a sentient entity which forms intent prior to actualization. So by definition, the “will” of the universe is that function which determines how the universe will configure itself “in advance” of actualization. <strong>In cosmological terms, this function is just that which determines, among other things, the laws of mathematics and physics embodied by reality.<br> <br> Such a function must, after all, exist. For without it, there would be no reason, from one moment to the next, why the laws of physics should not spontaneously change into one of the infinite number of other nomologies that might have arisen</strong>. Concisely, this function is defined as that reflexive mapping which effects the nomological character and stability of reality. The “will of the universe”, AKA the “will of God”, AKA teleology, is the name of this function, which we have just concretely defined.<br> <br> Does the universe “feel” its volition as do we? Well, let’s see. What the universe feels properly includes what *we* feel, plus much more (because we are merely parts of it). The universe therefore “feels” teleology far more powerfully than a mere human being “feels” an act of human will. The mechanism of its “feeling”? Well, there are a lot of those, including every human being, every animal, every plant, and every alien microbe on every planet in every star system in every galaxy in the cosmos. As you can well imagine, the impressions that get channeled to the universe through all of these “sense receptors” add up to very powerful sensations indeed.<br> <br> In fact, these are the sensations that feed back to teleology to tell the universe how to self-actualize in the “optimal” way…i.e., <strong>so that it ends up with the “best feeling” possible.</strong> <strong>They have already told the universe how to configure the laws of math and physics</strong>; for more specific elements of configuration, <strong>the universe relies on US. Every decision we make, including our every act of will, we make on behalf of the universe.</strong> That’s why we should always make the very best decisions we can.<strong>)”</strong> brings a whole new meaning to bidirectional time, and thus to the idea that cognition may play a role in the creation of reality. As a self-creative mechanism for the universe is sought, it becomes apparent that cognition is the only process lending itself to plausible interpretation as a means of temporal feedback from present to past. Were cognition to play such a role, then in a literal sense, its most universal models of 95 temporal reality would become identical to the reality being modeled. <strong>Time would become cognition</strong>, and <strong>space:</strong> would become a <strong>system</strong> of <strong>geometric relations that evolves by distributed cognitive processing.</strong> Here comes the surprise: such a model exists. Appropriately enough, it is called the “<strong>Cognition-Theoretic Model of the Universe”, or CTMU for short</strong>. A cross between John Archibald Wheeler’s Participatory Universe and the Stephen Hawking-James Hartle “imaginary time” theory of cosmology proposed in Hawking’s phenomenal book A Brief History of Time, the CTMU resolves many of the most intractable paradoxes known to physical science while explaining recent data which indicate that <strong>the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate</strong>. Better yet, it bestows on human consciousness a level of meaning that was previously approached only by religion and mysticism. If it passes the test of time — and there are many good reasons to think that it will — then it will be the greatest step that humanity has yet taken towards a real understanding of its most (or least?) timeless mystery. And so the circle closes. <strong>Time becomes a cosmogonic 96 loop whereby the universe creates itself</strong>. The origin of our time concept, the self, becomes the origin of time itself. Our cognitive models of time become a model of time-ascognition. And the languages of cognition and physics become one self-configuring, self-processing language of which time is the unified grammar. Talk about “time out of mind”! And all this because of a little garden slug.</p><p><strong>A New Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics</strong></p><p>After standing for over two centuries as the last word in physics, the differential equations comprising the deterministic laws of Newtonian mechanics began to run into problems. One of these problems was called the <em>Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle</em> or <strong>HUP</strong>. The HUP has the effect of “blurring” space and time on very small scales by making it impossible to simultaneously measure with accuracy certain pairs of attributes of a particle of matter or packet of energy. Because of this blurring, Newton’s differential equations are insufficient to describe small-scale interactions of matter and energy. Therefore, in order to adapt the equations of classical mechanics to the nondeterministic, dualistic (wave-versus-particle) nature of matter and energy, the more or less <em>ad hoc</em> theory of quantum mechanics (<strong>QM</strong>) was hastily developed. QM identifies matter quanta with “probability waves” existing in ¥-dimensional complex <em>Hilbert space</em>, a Cartesian space defined over the field of complex numbers a+bi (where a and b are real numbers and i = Ö-1) instead of the pure real numbers, and replaces Hamilton’s classical equations of motion with Schrodinger’s <em>wave equation</em>. QM spelled the beginning of the end for Laplacian determinism, a philosophical outgrowth of Newtonianism which held that any temporal state of the universe could be fully predicted from a complete Cartesian description of any other. Not only uncertainty but <em>freedom </em>had reentered the physical arena</p><p>Unfortunately, the HUP was not the only quantum-mechanical problem for classical physics and its offshoots. Even worse was a phenomenon called <em>EPR (Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen) nonlocality</em>, according to which the conservation of certain physical quantities for pairs of correlated particles seems to require that information be instantaneously transmitted between them regardless of their distance from each other. The EPR paradox juxtaposes nonlocality to the conventional dynamical scenario in which anything transmitted between locations must move through a finite sequence of intervening positions in space and time. So basic is this scenario to the classical worldview that EPR nonlocality seems to hang over it like a Damoclean sword, poised to sunder it like a melon. Not only does no standard physical theory incorporating common notions of realism, induction and locality contain a resolution of this paradox — this much we know from a mathematical result called <em>Bell’s theorem</em> — but it seems that the very foundations of physical science must give way before a resolution can even be attempted!</p><p>If we add this descriptive kind of ambiguity to ambiguities of measurement, e.g. the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle that governs the subatomic scale of reality, and the internal theoretical ambiguity captured by undecidability, we see that ambiguity is an inescapable ingredient of our knowledge of the world. It seems that math and science are…well, inexact sciences.</p><p>How, then, can we ever form a true picture of reality? There may be a way. For example, we could begin with the premise that such a picture exists, if only as a “limit” of theorization (ignoring for now the matter of showing that such a limit exists). Then we could educe categorical relationships involving the logical properties of this limit to arrive at a description of reality in terms of reality itself. In other words, we could build a self-referential theory of reality whose variables represent reality itself, and whose relationships are logical tautologies. Then we could add an instructive twist. Since logic consists of the rules of thought, i.e. of mind, what we would really be doing is interpreting reality in a generic theory of mind based on logic. By definition, the result would be a <em>cognitive-theoretic model of the universe</em>.</p><p>For example, modern physics is bedeviled by paradoxes involving the origin and directionality of time, the collapse of the quantum wave function, quantum nonlocality, and the containment problem of cosmology. Were someone to present a simple, elegant theory resolving these paradoxes without sacrificing the benefits of existing theories, the resolutions would carry more weight than any number of predictions.</p><p><strong>The New Interpretation of QM-Sum over Futures and the Extended Superposition Principle</strong></p><p>The superposition principle highlights certain problems with quantum mechanics. One problem is that quantum mechanics lacks a cogent model in which to interpret things like “mixed states” (waves alone are not sufficient). Another problem is that according to the uncertainty principle, 30 the last states of a pair of interacting particles are generally insufficient to fully determine their next states. This, of course, raises a question: how are their next states actually determined? What is the source of the extra tie-breaking measure of determinacy required to select their next events (“collapse their wave functions”)?</p><p>The answer is not, as some might suppose, “randomness”; randomness amounts to acausality, or alternatively, to informational incompressibility with respect to any distributed causal template or ingredient of causal syntax. Thus, it is either no explanation at all, or it implies the existence of a “cause” exceeding the representative capacity of distributed laws of causality. But the former is both absurd and unscientific, and the latter requires that some explicit allowance be made for higher orders of causation…more of an allowance than may readily be discerned in a simple, magical invocation of “randomness”. The superposition principle, like other aspects of quantum mechanics, is based on the assumption of physical Markovianism. 40 It refers to mixed states between adjacent events, <strong>ignoring the possibility of nonrandom temporally-extensive relationships not wholly attributable to distributed laws. By putting temporally remote events in extended descriptive contact with each other (</strong>Extended superposition “atemporally” distributes antecedent events over consequent events, thus putting spacetime in temporally-extended self-contact. In light of the Telic Principle (see below), this scenario involves a new interpretation of quantum theory, sum over futures. <strong>Sum over futures</strong> involves an atemporal generalization of “process”, telic recursion, through which the universe effects on-the-fly maximization of a global self-selection parameter, generalized utility.) [( <strong>Sum over futures</strong> involves an atemporal (existing or <strong>considered without relation to time</strong>) <strong>before determining the next state(In the Sum Over Futures Principle)</strong>, <strong>Reality takes all of the past and future into account and then chooses a particular state</strong> on the basis of its own values), through which the universe effects on-the-fly (as time passes) maximization of a global (over all of Reality) self-selection parameter (measurement), generalized utility (what the universal Desire hopes to achieve).]</p><p>In extending the superposition concept to include nontrivial higher-order relationships, the Extended Superposition Principle opens the door to meaning and design. Because it also supports distribution relationships among states, events and syntactic strata, it makes cosmogony a distributed, coherent, ongoing event rather than a spent and discarded moment from the ancient history of the cosmos (This parallelism has powerful implications. When a human being dies, his entire history remains embedded in the timeless level of consciousness…the Deic level). Indeed, the usual justification for observer participation — that an observer in the present can perceptually collapse the wave functions of ancient (photon-emission) events — can be regarded as a consequence of this logical relationship.</p><p>Examined within the distinctive logical structure of this medium, time and causality turn out not to be confined to the familiar past-to-future direction. Instead, the futureto-past direction becomes important as well. The bidirectionality of time implies that the universe is in a state 81 of extended spatiotemporal self-superposition, each of its serial configurations, as defined at each successive moment of time, in contact with all others. At first glance, this seems to imply that the universe is completely determined…that as Laplace believed, every state of the universe is implicit in any state. But not only is such an assumption unnecessary, it would ultimately lead to intractable inconsistencies. In fact, the logical structure of spacetime provides the universe with the wherewithal of being, endowing it with self-creative freedom and permitting it to rise from a sea of undifferentiated ontological potential.</p><p>, the Extended Superposition Principle enables coherent cross-temporal telic feedback and thus plays a necessary role in cosmic self-configuration.</p><p><strong>Why Physics needs Metaphysics and is incomplete without as they directly correlate</strong></p><p>Although supersymmetry was eventually dropped because its 11-dimensional structure failed to explain subatomic chirality (whereby nature distinguishes between right- and left-handedness), its basic premises lived on in the form of 10-dimensional <em>superstring theory</em>. Again, the basic idea was to add additional dimensions to GR, slice and splice these extra dimensions in such a way that they manifest the basic features of quantum mechanics, and develop the implications in the context of a series of Big Bang phase transitions (“broken symmetries”) in which matter changes form as the hot early universe cools down (mathematically, these phase transitions are represented by the arrows in the series GàHà…àSU(3) x SU(2) x U(1)àSU(3) x U(1), where alphanumerics represent algebraic <em>symmetry groups</em> describing the behavioral regularities of different kinds of matter under the influence of different forces, and gravity is mysteriously missing)</p><p>Unfortunately, just as General Relativity did nothing to explain the origin of 4-D spacetime or its evident propensity to “expand” when there would seem to be nothing for it to expand <em>into</em>, string theory did nothing to explain the origin or meaning of the n-dimensional strings into which spacetime had evolved. Nor did it even uniquely or manageably characterize higher-dimensional spacetime structure; it required the same kind of nonstandard universe that was missing from GR in order to properly formulate quantum-scale dimensional curling, and eventually broke down into five (5) incompatible versions all relying on difficult and ill-connected kinds of mathematics that made even the simplest calculations, and extracting even the most basic physical predictions, virtually impossible. Worse yet, it was an unstratified low-order theory too weak to accommodate an explanation for quantum nonlocality or measurable cosmic expansion.</p><p>Recently, string theory has been absorbed by a jury-rigged patchwork called “membrane theory” or <em>M-theory</em> whose basic entity is a p-dimensional object called, one might almost suspect eponymically, a “p-brane” (no, this is not a joke). P-branes display mathematical properties called <em>S- </em>and<em> T-duality</em> which combine in a yet-higher-level duality called <em>the Duality of Dualities</em> (again, this is not a joke) that suggests a reciprocity between particle size and energy that could eventually link the largest and smallest scales of the universe, and thus realize the dream of uniting large-scale physics (GR) with small-scale physics (QM). In some respects, this is a promising insight; it applies broad logical properties of theories (e.g., duality) to what the theories “objectively” describe, thus linking reality in a deeper way to the mental process of theorization. At the same time, the “membranes” or “bubbles” that replace strings in this theory more readily lend themselves to certain constructive interpretations.</p><p>But in other ways, M-theory is just the same old lemon with a new coat of paint. Whether the basic objects of such theories are called strings, p-branes or bubble-branes, they lack sufficient structure and context to explain their own origins or cosmological implications, and are utterly helpless to resolve physical and cosmological paradoxes like quantum nonlocality and <em>ex nihilo</em>(something-from-nothing) cosmogony… paradoxes next to which the paradoxes of broken symmetry “resolved” by such theories resemble the unsightly warts on the nose of a charging rhinoceros. In short, such entities sometimes tend to look to those unschooled in their virtues like mathematical physics run wildly and expensively amok.</p><p>Alas, the truth is somewhat worse. Although physics has reached the point at which it can no longer credibly deny the importance of metaphysical criteria, it resists further metaphysical extension. Instead of acknowledging and dealing straightforwardly with its metaphysical dimension, it mislabels metaphysical issues as “scientific” issues and festoons them with increasingly arcane kinds of mathematics that hide its confusion regarding the underlying logic.</p><p>Now let us backtrack to the first part of this history, the part in which René Descartes physically objectivized Cartesian spaces in keeping with his thesis of mind-body dualism. Notice that all of the above models sustain the mind-body distinction to the extent that cognition is regarded as an incidental side effect or irrelevant epiphenomenon of objective laws; cognition is secondary even where space and time are considered non-independent. Yet not only is any theory meaningless in the absence of cognition, but the all-important theories of relativity and quantum mechanics, without benefit of explicit logical justification, both invoke higher-level constraints which determine the form or content of dynamical entities according to properties not of their own, but of entities that measure or interact with them. Because these higher-level constraints are <em>cognitive</em> in a generalized sense, GR and QM require a joint theoretical framework in which generalized cognition is a distributed feature of reality.</p><p>Let’s try to see this another way. In the standard objectivist view, the <em>universe</em> gives rise to a <em>theorist</em> who gives rise to a <em>theory</em> of the universe. Thus, while the universe creates the theory by way of a theorist, it is not beholden to the possibly mistaken theory that results. But while this is true as far as it goes, it cannot account for how the universe itself is created. To fill this gap, the CTMU <em>Metaphysical Autology Principle</em> or <strong>MAP</strong> states that because <em>reality</em> is an all-inclusive relation bound by a universal quantifier whose scope is unlimited up to relevance, there is nothing external to reality with sufficient relevance to have formed it; hence, the real universe must be self-configuring. And the <em>Mind-Equals-Reality</em> (<strong>M=R</strong>) Principle says that because the universe alone can provide the plan or <em>syntax</em> of its own self-creation, it is an “infocognitive” entity loosely analogous to a theorist in the process of introspective analysis. Unfortunately, since objectivist theories contain no room for these basic aspects of reality, they lack the expressive power to fully satisfy relativistic, cosmological or quantum-mechanical criteria.</p><p>In view of the vicious paradoxes to which this failing has led, it is only natural to ask whether there exists a generalization of spacetime that contains the missing self-referential dimension of physics. The answer, of course, is that one <em>must </em>exist, and any generalization that is comprehensive in an explanatory sense must explain <em>why</em>. In <em>Noesis/ECE</em> 139, the SCSPL paradigm of the CTMU was described to just this level of detail. Space and time were respectively identified as generalizations of information and cognition, <strong>and spacetime was described as a homogeneous self-referential medium called <em>infocognition</em> that evolves in a process called <em>conspansion</em>.</strong> Conspansive spacetime is defined to incorporate the fundamental concepts of GR and QM in a simple and direct way that effectively preempts the paradoxes left unresolved by either theory alone. Conspansive spacetime not only incorporates non-independent space and time axes, but logically absorbs the cognitive processes of the theorist regarding it. Since this includes any kind of theorist cognitively addressing any aspect of reality, scientific or otherwise, the CTMU offers an additional benefit of great promise to scientists and nonscientists alike: it naturally conduces to a unification of scientific and nonscientific (e.g. humanistic, artistic and religious) thought.</p><p><strong>The Process of Conspansion and the Circles</strong></p><p><strong>(The fundamental concept or action that governs all motion of elementary particles)</strong></p><p>A (Minkowski) spacetime diagram is a kind of “event lattice” in which nodes represent events and their connective worldlines represent the objects that interact in those events. The events occur at the foci of past and future light cones to which the worldlines are internal. If one could look down the time axis of such a diagram at a spacelike cross section, one would see something very much like a Venn diagram with circles corresponding to lightcone cross sections.</p><p>The <strong>areas inside the circles correspond to event potentials,</strong> and where events are governed by the laws of physics, to potential instantiations of physical law or “nomological syntax”.</p><p>That is, each <strong>circle</strong> depicts the “entangled quantum wavefunctions” of the objects which interacted with each other to generate it.</p><p>The small dots in the centers of the circles represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen, As a result, new states are formed within the images of previous states</p><p>Once one of these intrinsically atemporal <strong>circles</strong> has “inner-expanded” across vast reaches of space and time</p><p>That is, the circular boundaries of the Venn circles can be construed as those of “potentialized” objects in the process of absorbing their spatiotemporal neighborhoods.</p><p>The outward growth (or by conspansive duality, <strong>mutual absorption</strong>) of the circles is called inner expansion, while the collapse of their objects in new events is called <strong>requantization</strong>.</p><p>Conspansion consists of two complementary processes, <strong><em>requantization</em></strong> and<em> inner expansion</em>. Requantization downsizes the content of Planck’s constant by applying a quantized scaling factor to successive layers of space corresponding to levels of distributed parallel computation. This <em>inverse scaling factor</em> 1/R is just the reciprocal of the <em>cosmological scaling factor</em> R, the ratio of the current apparent size dn(U) of the expanding universe to its original (Higgs condensation) size d0(U)=1. Meanwhile, inner expansion outwardly distributes the images of past events at the speed of light within progressively-requantized layers. As layers are rescaled, the rate of inner expansion, and the speed and wavelength of light, change with respect to d0(U) so that relationships among basic physical processes do <em>not</em> change…i.e., so as to effect nomological covariance. The thrust is to <em>relativize</em> space and time measurements so that spatial relations have different diameters and rates of diametric change from different spacetime vantages. This merely continues a long tradition in physics; just as Galileo relativized motion and Einstein relativized distances and durations to explain gravity, this is a relativization for conspansive “antigravity”</p><p>The circles themselves are called IEDs, short for inner expansive domains, and correspond to pairs of <strong>interactive syntactic operators</strong> involved in generalized-perceptual events (note the hological “evacuation” and mutual absorption of the operators). Spacetime can be illustrated in terms of a <strong>layering of such Venn diagrams</strong>, mutual contact among which is referred to as “extended superposition” (in the real world, the Venn diagrams are 3-dimensional rather than planar, the circles are <strong>spheres</strong>, and “layering” is defined accordingly). Extended superposition “atemporally” distributes antecedent events over consequent events, thus putting spacetime in temporally-extended self-contact.</p><p>while the twin dots where the circles overlap reflect the+</p><p>fact that any possible new event, or interaction between objects involved in the old events, must occur by mutual acquisition in the intersect. As a result, new states are formed within the images of previous states.</p><p>Since the event potentials and object potentials coincide, potential instantiations of law can be said to reside “inside” the objects, and can thus be regarded as functions of their internal rules or “object syntaxes”.</p><p>The circles themselves are called IEDs, short for inner expansive domains, and correspond to pairs of <strong>interactive syntactic operators</strong></p><p>(in the real world, the Venn diagrams are 3-dimensional rather than planar, the <strong>circles are spheres</strong>, and “layering” is defined accordingly).</p><p>series of Venn diagrams in which circles inner-expand, interpenetrate and “collapse to points” at each interactive generalized-observational event. This scenario is general, applying even to <strong>macroscopic objects consisting of many particles of matter</strong>;</p><p>Because each circle is structurally self-distributed, nothing need be transmitted from one part of it to another; Conspansion thus affords a certain amount of relief from problems associated with so-called <strong>“quantum nonlocality”</strong></p><p>a new circle appears within the old one by syntactic embedment, the circles are intrinsically</p><p>undefined in duration and are thus intrinsically atemporal. Time arises strictly as an ordinal</p><p>relationship among circles rather than within circles themselves.</p><p>As previously described, if the conspanding universe were projected in an internal plane, its evolution would look like ripples (infocognitive events) spreading outward on the surface of a pond, with new ripples starting in the intersects of their immediate ancestors. Just as in the pond, old ripples continue to spread outward in ever-deeper layers, carrying their virtual 0 diameters along with them. This is why we can collapse the past history of a cosmic particle by observing it in the present, and why, as surely as Newcomb’s demon, we can determine the past through regressive metric layers corresponding to a rising sequence of NeST strata leading to the stratum corresponding to the particle’s last determinant event. The deeper and further back in time we regress, the higher and more comprehensive the level of NeST that we reach, until finally, like John Wheeler himself, we achieve “observer participation” in the highest, most parallelized level of NeST…the level corresponding to the very birth of reality.</p><p>Conspansive domains interpenetrate against the background of past events at the inner expansion rate c, defined as the maximum ratio of distance to duration by the current scaling, and recollapse through quantum interaction. Conspansion thus defines a kind of <strong>“absolute time”</strong> metering and safeguarding causality. Interpenetration of conspansive domains, which involves a special logical operation called <em>unisection</em> (distributed intersection) combining aspects of the set-theoretic operations <em>union</em> and <em>intersection</em>, creates an infocognitive relation of sufficiently high order to effect quantum collapse. Output is selectively determined by ESP interference and reinforcement within and among metrical layers.</p><p>Accordingly, the universe as a whole must be treated as a static domain whose self and contents cannot “expand”, but only <em>seem </em>to expand because they are undergoing internal rescaling as a function of SCSPL grammar. The universe is not actually expanding in any absolute, externally-measurable sense; rather, its contents are shrinking relative to it, and to maintain local geometric and dynamical consistency, it appears to expand relative to them. Already introduced as <em>conspansion</em> (contraction <em>qua</em> expansion), this process reduces physical change to a form of “grammatical substitution” in which the geometrodynamic state of a spatial relation is differentially expressed within an ambient cognitive image of its previous state. By running this scenario backwards and regressing through time, we eventually arrive at the source of geometrodynamic and quantum-theoretic reality: a primeval conspansive domain consisting of pure physical potential embodied in the self-distributed “infocognitive syntax” of the physical universe…i.e., the laws of physics, which in turn reside in the more general HCS.</p><p>The microscopic implications of conspansion are in remarkable accord with basic physical criteria. In a self-distributed (perfectly self-similar) universe, every event should mirror the event that creates the universe itself. In terms of an implosive inversion of the standard (Big Bang) model, this means that every event should to some extent mirror the primal event consisting of a condensation of Higgs energy distributing elementary particles and their quantum attributes, including mass and relative velocity, throughout the universe. To borrow from evolutionary biology, spacetime ontogeny recapitulates cosmic phylogeny; every part of the universe should repeat the formative process of the universe itself.</p><p>Conspansion is not just a physical operation, but a logical one as well. Because physical objects unambiguously maintain their identities and physical properties as spacetime evolves, spacetime must directly obey the rules of 2VL (<em>2-valued logic</em> distinguishing what is true from what is false). Spacetime evolution can thus be straightforwardly depicted by Venn diagrams in which the truth attribute <strong>(</strong>I.e., scientific explanations and interpretations glue observations and equations together in a very <strong>poorly understood</strong> way. It often works like a charm…but why<strong>[((One of the main purposes of the CTMU is to explain why this works-That scientific observations go together with mathematical equations so well ex. E=MC² but why do observations and interpretations of the observations and equations that quantify the interpretations go together with such success? In other words why does science work? One of the goals of the CTMU is to make this scientific processes of such success in explaining reality…, better understood, changing science as we now know it and broaden its scope vastly! That’s what Langan is trying to say. Essentially explain why science works.))]</strong> ? One of the main purposes of reality theory is to answer this question. 12 The first thing to notice about this question is that it involves the process of <strong>attribution</strong>, and that the rules of <strong>attribution</strong> are set forth in stages by mathematical logic. The first stage is called sentential logic and contains the rules for ascribing the attributes true or false, respectively denoting inclusion or non-inclusion in arbitrary cognitive-perceptual systems. Reality theory is about the stage of <strong>attribution</strong> in which two predicates analogous to true and false, namely real and unreal, are ascribed to various statements about the real universe. Now we know that the closed, single-predicate definition of the Reality Principle is actually a closed descriptive manifold of linked definitions in principle containing the means of its own composition, <strong>attribution, recognition</strong>, processing and interpretation. So now we know that reality is more than just a linguistic self-contained syndiffeonic relation comprising a closed descriptive manifold of linked definitions containing the means of its own configuration, composition, <strong>attribution, recognition</strong>, processing and interpretation. Where sets contain their elements and <strong>attributes</strong> distributively describe their arguments, this implies a dual relationship between <strong>topological containment</strong> and <strong>descriptive attribution</strong> as modeled through <strong>Venn diagrams</strong>-of the circles but attribution is important it assigns by attribution the circles or events its properties that the circles topologically contain-. The point of this paraenthesis is to show why the word <strong>“attribution”</strong> is so important and why Langan uses it so much to describe things and what he means when he does in describing what is true.<strong>)</strong>, a high-order metapredicate of any physical predicate, corresponds to topological inclusion in a spatial domain-The domain of the circle or venn-shpere light cone cross section-corresponding to specific physical attributes. I.e., to <strong>be true</strong>, an effect must be not only logically but <strong><em>topologically contained((Inside the circle of the event to be true))</em></strong> by the cause{The cause of the event is…”<strong> instead, the information required for (e.g.) spin conservation is distributed over their joint ancestral IED…the virtual 0-diameter spatiotemporal image of the event that spawned both particles</strong>}; to inherit properties determined by an antecedent event, objects involved in consequent events must appear within its logical <em>and</em> spatiotemporal image[The circle or light cone cross section venn-sphere.] In short, logic equals spacetime topology.</p><p>In a conspansive universe, the spacetime metric undergoes constant rescaling. Whereas Einstein required a generalization of Cartesian space embodying higher-order geometric properties like spacetime curvature, conspansion requires a yet higher order of generalization in which even relativistic properties, e.g. spacetime curvature inhering in the gravitational field, can be progressively rescaled. Where physical fields of force control or <em>program</em> dynamical geometry, and programming is logically stratified as in NeST, fields become layered stacks of parallel distributive programming that decompose into <em>field strata</em> (conspansive layers) related by an intrinsic requantization function inhering in, and logically inherited from, the most primitive and connective layer of the stack. This “storage process” by which infocognitive spacetime records its logical history (This parallelism has powerful implications. When a human being dies, his entire history remains embedded in the timeless level of consciousness…the Deic level) is called <em>metrical layering</em> (note that since storage is effected by inner-expansive domains which are internally atemporal, this is to some extent a misnomer reflecting weaknesses in standard models of computation).</p><p>The metrical layering concept does not involve complicated reasoning. It suffices to note that <em>distributed</em> (as in “event images are outwardly distributed in layers of parallel computation by inner expansion”) effectively means “of 0 intrinsic diameter” with respect to the distributed attribute. If an attribute<strong> </strong>Corresponding to a logical relation of any order is distributed over a mathematical or physical domain, then interior points of the domain are undifferentiated with respect to it, and it need not be transmitted among them<strong> (</strong>really the definition of a circle or the properties of a circle here. Which remember domain is — domain (lightcone cross section, Venn sphere)-Domain is the inside of a circle and the fact the as it says the interior points of the domain are undifferentiated and it need not be transmitted among them is because in a circle it consists of an infinite related interior points that aren’t differentiated so therefore interconnected and homogeneous so nothing is transmitted by skipping space because of the undifferentiated interconnected points inside the circle as it appears to in non-locality((information appears to skip space instantly)).<strong>)</strong>. Where space and time exist only with respect to logical distinctions among attributes, metrical differentiation can occur within inner-expansive domains (IEDs) only upon the introduction of <em>consequent</em> attributes relative to which position is redefined in an overlying metrical layer, and what we usually call “the metric” is a function of the total relationship among all layers.</p><p>The spacetime metric thus amounts to a <strong>Venn</strong>-diagrammatic conspansive history in which every <strong>conspansive domain</strong> (lightcone cross section, <strong>Venn</strong> sphere) has <em>virtual 0 diameter</em> with respect to <strong>distributed attributes</strong>, despite apparent nonzero diameter with respect to metrical relations among subsequent events. <strong>What appears to be nonlocal transmission of information can thus seem to occur. </strong>Nevertheless, the CTMU is a localistic theory in every sense of the word; information is never exchanged “faster than conspansion”, i.e<strong>. faster than light</strong> (the CTMU’s unique explanation of quantum nonlocality within a localistic model is what entitles it to call itself a consistent “extension” of relativity theory, to which the <em>locality principle</em> is fundamental).</p><p>Thus, one perceives the model’s evolution as a conspansive overlay of physically-parametrized <strong>Venn</strong> diagrams directly through the time (SCSPL grammar) axis</p><p>To make things even simpler: the CTMU equates <em>reality</em> to <em>logic</em>, <em>logic</em> to <em>mind</em>, and (by transitivity of equality) <em>reality</em> to <em>mind (</em>Because quantum-scale objects are seen to exist only when they are participating in observational events-((See observer participation here. Quantum scale objects seen to exist when there is observer participation)) it means reality is like a mind. It displays mental characteristics. <strong>When a mind perceives it</strong>. Thus the laws of physics is as much an expression of our minds or perception as they are objectively physical. This what is meant when Langan writes at the end of the blue up above- reality to mind [Langan actually writes this and lays this out in his most basic yet wonderful work in the Art of Knowing and I won’t share the whole argument he lays out but here’s his conclusion: “So where will we go now, at the dawn of the New Millennium, for renewed confirmation of our “specialness” in the scheme of things? Fortunately, we are not yet facing an ideological dead end. For it seems that just ahead on the intellectual horizon looms a new science of metaphysics…a logical framework in which the importance of humankind is unthreatened by reductionism, and in which the significance of human feelings and emotions is uncompromised by their correlation with lowly biological processes. Rather than declaring us the abject slaves of natural laws beyond our control, this framework yields a new understanding of space and time in which the very <strong>laws of physics can be viewed as an expression of our minds.</strong> Granted, this framework remains hidden despite its portentous approach. But if its ongoing delay contributes to our collective store of humility, perhaps this is not entirely a bad thing.”-Pg.79. Then it makes a big <strong>Venn</strong> diagram out of all three, assigns appropriate logical and mathematical functions to the diagram, and deduces implications <strong>in light of <em>empirical data</em></strong>. A little reflection reveals that it would be hard to imagine a simpler or more logical theory of reality.</p><p><strong>“The Complete Description of the Interacting Circles In Conspansion in the CTMU”</strong></p><p>-The small dots in the centers of the <strong>circles</strong> represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen.</p><p>- Where each circle corresponds to two or more objects</p><p>-until a new circle appears within the old one by syntactic embedment, the circles are intrinsically undefined in duration and are thus intrinsically atemporal. Time arises strictly as an ordinal relationship among circles rather than within circles themselves. With respect to time-invariant elements of syntax active in any given state (circle)</p><p>That is, each <strong>circle</strong> depicts the “entangled quantum wavefunctions” of the objects which interacted with each other to generate it. The small dots in the centers of the <strong>circles</strong> represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen, while the twin dots where the circles overlap reflect the fact that any possible new event, or interaction between objects involved in the old events, must occur by mutual acquisition in the intersect. The outward growth (or by conspansive duality, mutual absorption) of the circles is called inner expansion, while the collapse of their objects in new events is called requantization. The circles themselves are called IEDs, short for inner expansive domains, and correspond to pairs of interactive syntactic operators involved in generalized-perceptual events (note the hological “evacuation” and mutual absorption of the operators). Spacetime can be illustrated in terms of a layering of such Venn diagrams, mutual contact among which is referred to as “extended superposition” (in the real world, the Venn diagrams are 3-dimensional rather than planar, the circles are spheres, and “layering” is defined accordingly).</p><p>Conspansive duality, the role of which in the CTMU is somewhat analogous to that of the Principle of Equivalence in General Relativity, is the only escape from an infinite ectomorphic “tower of turtles”. Were the perceptual geometry of reality to lack a conspansive dual representation, motion of any kind would require a fixed spatial array or ectomorphic “background space” requiring an explanation of its own, and so on down the tower. Conspansion permits the universe to self-configure through temporal feedback. Each conspanding <strong>circle</strong> represents an event-potential corresponding to a certain combination of law and state; even after one of these intrinsically atemporal <strong>circles</strong> has “inner-expanded” across vast reaches of space and time, its source event is still current for anything that interacts with it, e.g. an eye catching one of its photons. At the same time, conspansion gives the quantum wave function of objects a new home: inside the conspanding objects themselves. Without it, the wave function not only has no home, but fails to coincide with any logically evolving system of predicates or “laws of physics”. Eliminate conspansion, and reality becomes an inexplicable space full of deterministic worldlines and the weighty load of problems that can be expected when geometry is divorced from logic.</p><p>The areas inside the circles correspond to event potentials, and where events are governed by the laws of physics, to potential instantiations of physical law or “nomological syntax”. Where each circle corresponds to two or more objects, it comprises object potentials as well. That is, the circular boundaries of the Venn circles can be construed as those of “potentialized” objects in the process of absorbing their spatiotemporal neighborhoods. Since the event potentials and object potentials coincide, potential instantiations of law can be said to reside “inside” the objects, and can thus be regarded as functions of their internal rules or “object syntaxes”. Objects thus become syntactic operators, and events become intersections of nomological syntax in the 28 common value of an observable state parameter, position. The circle corresponding to the new event represents an attribute consisting of all associated nomological relationships appropriate to the nature of the interaction including conserved aggregates, and forms a pointwise (statewise) “syntactic covering” for all subsequent potentials. Notice that in this scenario, spacetime evolves linguistically rather than geometrodynamically. Although each Venn circle seems to expand continuously, its content is unchanging; its associated attribute remains static pending subsequent events involving the objects that created it. Since nothing actually changes until a new event is “substituted” for the one previous, i.e. until a new circle appears within the old one by syntactic embedment, the circles are intrinsically undefined in duration and are thus intrinsically atemporal. Time arises strictly as an ordinal relationship among circles rather than within circles themselves. With respect to time-invariant elements of syntax active in any given state (circle), the distinction between zero and nonzero duration is intrinsically meaningless; such elements are heritable under substitution and become syntactic ingredients of subsequent states.</p><p><strong>“The Ultimate Answer To quantum Non Locality”</strong></p><p><strong>Because each circle is structurally self-distributed, nothing need be transmitted from one part of it to another(Thus, just as the initial collapse of the quantum wavefunction (QWF) of the causally self-contained universe is internal to the universe, the requantizative occurrence of each subsequent event is topologically internal to that event[Inside each circle in this case], and the cause spatially contains the effect. The implications regarding quantum nonlocality are clear.</strong></p><p><strong>No longer must information propagate at superluminal velocity between spin-correlated particles; instead, the information required for (e.g.) spin conservation is distributed over their joint ancestral IED…the virtual 0-diameter spatiotemporal image of the event (The circle itself and topologically internal is just that inside it or inside the IED or Inner-inside-Expanding Circle) that spawned both particles(So from the instant to entangled particles generated a circle as it expands the two particles have always been sharing information throughout the circle or the gap between them so when it seems they are doing it instantaneously it’s because they’ve been connected the whole time but the circle expands or in the CTMU conspands at the speed of light. But they would exchange information across this circle not faster than light. When it appears they are instantaneously they were already connected in this circle event from the beginning of the circles expansion or of that information exchange in my own words.) As a correlated ensemble</strong> <strong>(</strong>The small dots in the centers of the <strong>circles</strong> represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen,<strong>). The internal parallelism of this domain — the fact that neither distance nor duration can bind within it — short-circuits spatiotemporal transmission on a logical level. A kind of “logical superconductor”, the domain offers no resistance across the gap between correlated particles; in fact, the “gap” does not exist!), </strong>locality constraints arise only with respect to additional invariants differentially activated within circles that represent subsequent states and break the hological symmetry of their antecedents. Conspansion thus affords a certain amount of relief from problems associated with so-called “quantum nonlocality”</p><p>The CTMU, on the</p><p>other hand, is conspansive and telic-recursive; because new state-potentials are constantly being created by evacuation and mutual absorption of coherent objects (syntactic operators) through conspansion, metrical and nomological uncertainty prevail wherever standard recursion is impaired by object sparsity. This amounts to self-generative freedom, hologically providing reality</p><p>with a “self-simulative scratchpad” on which to compare the aggregate utility of multiple self-configurations for self-optimizative purposes.</p><p>In a Venn diagram, the contents of circles reflect the structure of their boundaries; the boundaries are the primary descriptors. The interior of a circle is simply an “interiorization” or self-distribution of its syntactic “boundary constraint”. Thus, nested circles corresponding to identical objects display a descriptive form of containment corresponding to syntactic layering, with underlying levels corresponding to syntactic coverings. Through the</p><p>principle of conspansive duality, ectomorphism is conjoined with endomorphism, whereby things are mapped, generated or replicated within themselves. Through conspansive endomorphism, syntactic objects are injectively mapped into their own hological interiors from their own syntactic</p><p>boundaries.</p><p>Because quantum-scale objects are seen to exist only when they are participating in observational events, including their “generalized observations” of each other, their worldlines are merely assumed to exist between events and are in fact syntactically retrodicted, along with the continuum, from the last events in which they are known to have participated. This makes it possible to omit specific worldlines entirely, <strong>replacing them with series of Venn diagrams in which circles inner-expand, interpenetrate and “collapse to points” at each interactive generalized-observational event.</strong></p><p>SCSPL is logical in construction, has a loop-like dynamic, and <strong>creates information</strong> and syntax (SCSPL-grammatical process featuring an alternation between dual phases of existence associated with design and actualization…, principle of <strong><em>natural selection</em></strong> a basic means of <strong>generating information and complexity</strong>.-Pg.1 Abstract) , including the laws of physics, through telic recursion generated by agent-level syntactic operators whose acts of observer-participation are essential to the self-configuration of the Participatory Universe. These acts are linked by telic recursion to the generalized cognitive-perceptual interactions of quantum-level syntactic operators, the <strong>minimal events comprising the fabric of space-time</strong> (Lumps of <strong>matter,</strong> syntactic operators containing within themselves the syntactic rules by which they internally process each other to create new states of physical reality.)</p><p>You may ask what in the world is a <strong>syntactic operator</strong>? What in the hell is it? Best explained in the 56 page paper where it’s the fundamental objects everything is made of and why the CTMU can united and adopt string theory as well: “In conventional physical theory, the fundamental entities are <strong>point particles</strong>, <strong>waves</strong> and more recently, <strong>strings</strong>; each class of object has its problems and paradoxes. In the CTMU, the <strong><em>fundamental objects are “syntactic operators” </em></strong>(units of self-transducing information or infocognition) that are not only capable of emulating all of these objects and more, but of containing the syntactic structures to which they must inevitably conform and resolving their characteristic paradoxes in the bargain.”-Pg.20.</p><p>attempts to explain reality entirely in terms of physics are paradoxical; reality contains not only the physical, but the abstract machinery of perception and cognition through which “the physical” is perceived and explained. Where this abstract machinery is what we mean by “the supraphysical”, reality has physical and supraphysical aspects. Physical and supraphysical reality are respectively “concrete” and “abstract”, i.e. material and mental in nature.</p><p>The question is, do we continue to try to objectivize the supraphysical component of reality as do the theories of physics, strings and membranes, thus regenerating the paradox? Or do we take the CTMU approach and resolve the paradox, admitting that the supraphysical aspect of reality is “mental” in a generalized sense and describing all components of reality in terms of SCSPL <strong>syntactic operators</strong> with subjective and objective aspects?</p><p>One of the biggest moments in the history of physics was when they discovered they could create an atomic bomb Due to Einstein’s equation that an isotope if it can be split could cause a chain reaction of neutrons running into each other and imploding on each other richaing the neutrons off of the next nearby atom in line causing a massive release of energy which we know from Einstein’s equation. In the CTMU atoms are made up of Syntactic Operators or that Syntactic Operators are still fundamental to the atom. I’m not sure if the practicality goes with syntactic operators that we can split one. But as far as physics go they play a fundamental role in all of the particles and stings and waves.</p><p>���L�H��H��3tGM�</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7dc1ed4f94df" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Why the CTMU as I see it is the Greatest Theory Ever Conceived, Eternal, Irreplaceable and as it…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/why-the-ctmu-as-i-see-it-is-the-greatest-theory-ever-conceived-eternal-irreplaceable-and-as-it-b240552702f3?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b240552702f3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jan 2018 06:22:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-29T06:22:31.458Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Why the CTMU as I see it is the Greatest Theory Ever Conceived, Eternal, Irreplaceable and as it specifically applies to Physics”</p><p><strong>The Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe as the Nexus of Spirituality and Cosmology:</strong></p><p>An Interdisciplinary Approach to Reality</p><p>Christopher Michael Langan</p><p>1. General Introduction</p><p>Since the dawn of our species, human beings have been asking difficult questions about themselves, the universe and the nature of existence, but have lacked a unified conceptual framework strong and broad enough to yield the answers. Enter the</p><p>Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe (CTMU).</p><p>This will be laid out in two parts. Part 1 will be the philosophy and the logic of how the theory is developed that should change how we view and use science forever. Part 2 is strictly physics and what the CTMU says about physics at least in the basics. So 1. Philosophy as it relates to science. 2. As it relates to physics such as resolving the quantum non locality paradox.</p><p>Before I get into the rest of elaborating on the physics part I would like to try again in another approach in one sentence or one phrase(As I agreed to for clarification) what the theory even is because there is another maybe even better way to put it then I did before that’s more clear: <strong>“The CTMU is a theory that says all of the physical outcomes from the original formation of the universe and all its content physical or non-physical are outcomes of logical structure and it is through these absolute rules of logic that everything in existence conforms to on some level, and is how we can use these absolute rules of logic the CTMU lays out as logical axioms to solve any problem in science including quantum physics and actually solve anything we haven’t or can’t directly observe by-passing empirical induction where the predictions that flow from such solutions will be subject to empirical confirmation later on.”</strong></p><p>In the CTMU everything in existence embedded in reality conforms to logical structure of some kind and the CTMU proposes to get to the bottom of the absolute rules of logic. These rules of logic can even be applied to quantum mechanics and that not even HUP-Heisenberg Uncertainty violates these logical principles. For example in getting to the bottom of it with logic to an absolute invariant level that would apply to all reality and all physical structure and even simultaneous electrons that can’t seem to be tracked in one place at one specific moment in time cannot violate this fundamental rule of logic which truth is based on called the Tautology principle:</p><p>For example, take the sentential tautology “X v ~X” (X OR NOT-X). Applied to perception, this means that when something is seen or observed, <strong>it is not seen in conjunction with its absence(Such as an electron)</strong>; if it were, then two contradictory perceptions would coincide, resulting in a “splitting off” of perceptual realities. In effect, either the consciousness of the perceiver would split into two separate cognitive realities in a case of chain-reactive dissociation, or the perceiver himself would physically split along with physical reality. When “X v ~X” is composed with other tautologies (or itself) by substitution, the stakes are exactly the same; any violation of the compound tautology would split perceptual and cognitive reality with disastrous implications for its integrity.28</p><p>Also: Even so called “nonstandard” logics, e.g. modal, fuzzy and many-valued logics, must be expressed in terms of fundamental two-valued logic to make sense. In short, two-valued logic is something without which reality could not exist. If it were eliminated, then true and false, real and unreal, and existence and nonexistence could not be distinguished, and the merest act of perception or cognition would be utterly impossible.</p><p>The CTMU says these rules of logic it lays out can be used to investigate the substance of science and that this principle no electron if it exists in space time can violate which this is a good start to solving everything.</p><p>The only problem results is when things get really complex lots of details and informational complexity increases in the various scientific phenomena we are studying whether its cell organelles in cell biology or complex interaction of electrons and making sense of quantum gravity and trying to unify that with relativity or any number of things such as trying to find the cause and/or for cancer which is what Langan means when he says:</p><p>“As complexity rises and predicates become theories, tautology and truth become harder to recognize. Because universality and specificity are at odds in practice if not in principle, they are subject to a kind of “logical decoherence” associated with relational stratification. Because predicates are not always tautological, they are subject to various kinds of ambiguity; as they become increasingly specific and complex, it becomes harder to locally monitor the heritability of consistency and locally keep track of the truth property in the course of attribution(Such as the HUP Principle in QM) (or even after the fact). Undecidability,26 LSAT intractability and NP-completeness, predicate ambiguity and the Lowenheim-Skolem theorem, observational ambiguity and the Duhem-Quine thesis27 …these are some of the problems that emerge once the truth predicate “decoheres” with respect to complex attributive mappings. It is for reasons like these that the philosophy of science has fallen back on falsificationist doctrine, giving up on the tautological basis of logic, effectively demoting truth to provisional status, and discouraging full appreciation of the tautological-syntactic level of scientific inquiry even in logic and philosophy themselves. In fact, the validity of scientific theories and of science as a whole absolutely depends on the existence of a fundamental reality-theoretic framework spanning all of science…a fundamental syntax from which all scientific and mathematical languages, and the extended cognitive language of perception itself, can be grammatically unfolded, cross-related and validated. Tautology, the theoretical basis of truth as embodied in sentential logic, is obviously the core of this syntax. Accordingly, reality theory must be developed through amplification of this tautological syntax”…. Here is an example of Langan saying how tautologies and these absolute philosophical rules of logic can be used to solve scientific paradoxes in various theoretical contexts and settings of any kind of scientific phenomena even under a microscope or through a telescope whatever your looking at:</p><p>“By converting tautologies into other tautologies, the rules of inference of sentential logic convert cognitive-perceptual invariants into other such invariants. To pursue this agenda in reality theory, we must identify principles that describe how the looping structure of logical tautology is manifest in various reality-theoretic settings and contexts on various levels of description and interpretation; that way, we can verify its preservation under the operations of theoretic reduction and extension. I.e., we must adjoin generalized principles of loop structure to logical syntax in such a way that more and more of reality is thereby explained and comprehensiveness is achieved.”</p><p>To amplify this and hit this home how the CTMU proposes and uses logic to study science we haven’t even observed including metaphysics and solve anything in science and the idea that everything physical conforms to this logical structure consider his first answer in the CTMU Q and A of what the CTMU even is and how its constructed which this one response should show how the CTMU changes science as we know it but this one answer about the CTMU may even change your entire outlook on studying science as it did me!:</p><p>Chris, I’m not a mathematician or physicist by any stretch, but I am a curious person andwould like to know more about the <strong>CTMU</strong> (Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe). I am particularly interested in the theological aspects. Can you please explain what the <strong>CTMU </strong>is all about in language that even I can understand?</p><p><strong>A</strong>: Thanks for your interest, but the truth is the <strong>CTMU</strong> isn’t all that difficult for even a layperson to understand. So sit back, relax, kick off your shoes and open your mind…</p><p>Scientific theories are<strong> <em>mental</em> </strong>constructs that have <strong><em>objective reality</em></strong> as their content. According to the scientific method, science puts objective content first, letting theories be determined by observation. But the phrase “a theory of reality” contains two key nouns, <strong><em>theory </em></strong>and <strong><em>reality</em></strong>, and science is really about both. Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms — we could just as well start with these properties and see what they might tell us about objective reality. Just as scientific observation makes demands on theories, the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe.</p><p>In other words, a comprehensive theory of reality is not just about observation, but about theories and their logical requirements. Since theories are mental constructs, and <strong><em>mental</em></strong> means “of the mind”, this can be rephrased as follows: <strong><em>mind</em></strong><em> </em>and<em> </em><strong><em>reality</em></strong> are linked in mutual dependence at the most basic level of understanding. This linkage of mind and reality is what a <strong>TOE</strong> (Theory of Everything) is really about. The <strong>CTMU</strong> is such a theory; instead of being a mathematical description of specific observations (like all established scientific theories), it is a “metatheory” about the general relationship between theories and observations…i.e., about science or knowledge itself. Thus, it can credibly lay claim to the title of <strong>TOE</strong>.</p><p>Mind and reality — the abstract and the concrete, the subjective and the objective, the internal and the external — are linked together in a certain way, and this linkage is the real substance of “reality theory”. Just as scientific observation determines theories, the logical requirements of theories to some extent determine scientific observation. Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty, and this means that a comprehensive theory of reality cannot be based on scientific observation alone. Instead, it must be based on the process of making scientific observations in general, and this process is based on the relationship of mind and reality. So the <strong>CTMU</strong> is essentially <strong><em>a theory of the relationship between mind and reality</em></strong>.</p><p>In explaining this relationship, the <strong>CTMU</strong> shows that reality possesses a complex property akin to <strong><em>self-awareness</em></strong>. That is, just as the mind is real, reality is in some respects like a mind. But when we attempt to answer the obvious question “<strong><em>whose</em></strong> mind?”, the answer turns out to be a mathematical and scientific definition of God. This implies that we all exist in what can be called “the Mind of God”, and that our individual minds are parts of God’s Mind. They are not as powerful as God’s Mind, for they are only parts thereof; yet, they are directly connected to the greatest source of knowledge and power that exists. This connection of our minds to the Mind of God, which is like the connection of parts to a whole, is what we sometimes call the <strong><em>soul</em></strong> or <strong><em>spirit</em></strong>, and it is the most crucial and essential part of being human.</p><p>Thus, the attempt to formulate a comprehensive theory of reality, the <strong>CTMU</strong>, finally leads to spiritual understanding, producing a basis for the unification of science and theology. The traditional Cartesian divider between body and mind, science and spirituality, is penetrated by logical reasoning of a higher order than ordinary scientific reasoning, but no less scientific than any other kind of mathematical truth. Accordingly, it serves as the long-awaited gateway between science and humanism, a bridge of reason over what has long seemed an impassable gulf.</p><p>It’s worth taking a close look at this if not from the authors someone else’s perspective to see what I mean when this answer and the CTMU is capable of changing humanities entire outlook on science or knowledge itself-Which as I said I would interject my own thoughts periodically as the CTMU hit me as how I have come to understand it and make sense of what the CTMU is trying to tell us-as if from another dimension:</p><p>Scientific theories are<strong> <em>mental</em> </strong>constructs that have <strong><em>objective reality</em></strong> as their content. As I don’t think this is debatable the idea of a theory is something we came up with from our own minds and hypothesized on our own. Consider Einstein’s thought experiments but any theory is this way. And the theory is conjecturing about objective reality which is things we can observe and touch and feel and see and experimentally test in the laboratory and using technology and microscopes etc. We theorize and form a mental construct about something we observe.</p><p>According to the scientific method, science puts objective content first, letting theories be determined by observation. The order in which science is done is observing phenomena then thinking about it abstractly in deep thought trying to make sense of it and forming a theory about it. But in doing this science says our theories are determined by what we can observe or the data we test for and observe. From this data the scientists modifies the theory to accommodate the data observed and if the data invalidates the theory then the theory is thrown out. Which is what this is saying. Our theories are determined by the observed data we test for and let that determine truth content and the validity of our theories. And there is nothing wrong with that however…</p><p>But the phrase “a theory of reality” contains two key nouns, <strong><em>theory </em></strong>and <strong><em>reality</em></strong>, and science is really about both. Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms. Science isn’t just about what we can observe but theorizing about it. Our theories is our actual acquired body of knowledge. Science if it is a process and means anything at all isn’t just go look at stuff for we can all see the universe outside of us. This is indisputable science is about both what we can observe and theorize as that’s where the mind and intelligence comes in and our historical respect for brilliance. We all have observed gravity and motion and acceleration but it wasn’t until Newton came along and actually theorized about what he observed and formed equations about it that did it matter. No one can just look at light and observe it and see the theory of relativity that took Einstein’s theory and equations. So science is about both theory (our mental constructs) and reality (what we observe the empirical data).</p><p>Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms. This is very true and insightful when one thinks about it. Newton’s theory of motion doesn’t exist without logical properties and abstract mathematical reasoning, F=MA. The theory doesn’t exist without that equation. That is the only way we can understand what Newton means. Same with Einstein’s E=MC². Similar to every theory and established scientific law they all have necessary logical properties that require ABSTRACT thought and reasoning to figure this out and put it together. For Newton to come up with F=MA and Einstein to figure E=MC² took a brilliant mind and why intelligence matters in the scientific process and very deep and abstract thought and advanced mental reasoning that’s not so concrete and easily laid out. It takes a mind to do this kind of thinking and is more than just observing and look at things. These properties of our theories are independent of observation. The logical and mathematical properties of our theories and equations are completely separate from observation for if they weren’t we could all just observe motion and know this. And it is these properties of our theories and logical reasoning that we can know anything at all and understand out world in conceptual terms. So now that we now this here’s the idea of how the CTMU can change science as we know it:</p><p>We could just as well start with these properties and see what they might tell us about objective reality. Just as scientific observation makes demands on theories, the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe. So here’s the main idea, we could essentially this is saying we can also instead of observing something first and thinking about it and letting all our theories be determined by just empirical data and the reason this runs into problems is- because of empirical induction assuming the uniformity of nature-There are things we can’t observe. Also there are things we can’t just make sense of and understand by mere observation even when observing it. So science has its limits. So to get around this and circumvent this problem here Langan is saying for instance in Einstein’s case would could’ve have just started with E=MC² and us that to tell us what we can observe. Einstein had to observe light and think about it deeply to come up with the equation and Newton likewise had to observe gravity and motion but this is saying Newton or Einstein never having observed these things and tested for them or in relativity with the bending of light we can just start with the logic and math and if it’s based on correct absolute rules of logic and mathematical reasoning use that to tell us what we will observe before or never having observed it. We can flip science around backwards the process and use that to investigate reality. We can start by developing rules of logic and math without observing anything and have that be the decider of what is true or how the empirical data will go. Same with a mathematical proof of God even though we don’t claim to have seen or known to have seen God the idea is the same. We can start with developing the math and logical reasoning never observing anything then use these rules to apply it to everything we observe and a theory developed this way is without flaw error or at the least any assumptions. It just takes a brilliant mind to figure out how to do this. That’s why when Langan writes: the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe. With this idea our knowledge and understanding isn’t just limited to what we can directly observe. We can continue to further and further develop the logic of theories to deepen our explanatory scope and the CTMU is the theory that says how to do this. Any number of scientists or mathematicians or philosophers that get their hands on this kind of knowledge can use it to solve any number of problems they are working on that Langan doesn’t solve in his lifetime why Langan elsewhere in the CTMU Q and A page writes: “Unlike other TOEs, the CTMU does not purport to be a “complete” theory; there are too many physical details and undecidable mathematical theorems to be accounted for (enough to occupy whole future generations of mathematicians and scientists), and merely stating a hypothetical relationship among families of subatomic particles is only a small part of the explanatory task before us. Instead, the CTMU is merely designed to be consistent and comprehensive at a high level of generality, a level above that at which most other TOEs are prematurely aimed.<br> <br> The good news is that a new model of physical spacetime, and thus a whole new context for addressing the usual round of quantum cosmological problems, has emerged from the CTMU’s direct attack on deeper philosophical issues. The point is the CTMU is eternal and irreplaceable because these rules of logic it uses to investigate reality can be used by any scientists and applied to any problem solving problems in particle physics forever. This is what a theory of everything would do that is truly comprehensive unless the only other way would be to actually describe all of the informational data and everything science can ever observe forever in the universe and know everything at once which is humanly impossible. Why the CTMU defines reality as: “we can refine the definition of reality as follows: “Reality is the perceptual aggregate including (1) all scientific observations that ever were and ever will be, and (2) the entire abstract and/or cognitive explanatory infrastructure of perception” (where the abstract is a syntactic generalization of the concrete standing for ideas, concepts or cognitive structures distributing over physical instances which conform to them as content conforms to syntax).”-Pg.16.</p><p>One would have to be God to know everything there is at once Why the CTMU defines God as: “This implies that we all exist in what can be called “the Mind of God”, and that our individual minds are parts of God’s Mind. They are not as powerful as God’s Mind, for they are only parts thereof; yet, they are directly connected to the greatest source of knowledge and power that exists.” And also about knowing everything “Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty, and this means that a comprehensive theory of reality cannot be based on scientific observation alone.” So there we have God as defined as the greatest source of power and knowledge that exists which if God exists would be the greatest being in existence there could be. Then we have the idea that why science will always be able to occupy us as the CTMU also shows reality is in a constant state of self-creation which includes free will take from the 56 page paper “Telic recursion is a fundamental process that tends to maximize a cosmic self-selection parameter, generalized utility, over a set of possible syntax-state relationships in light of the self-configurative freedom of the universe.”-Pg.35. In other words information is always being added to the universe Which Langan has also been recorded in an interview saying “The classical Laplacian-deterministic worldview is all but dead. As reality is affected by every possible kind of ambiguity, uncertainty, indeterminacy, and undecidability, no theory of reality can ever be complete. In principle, this makes any such theory a permanent work-in-progress in which a very great deal always remains to be done. Exploration must continue.</p><p>However, a theory of reality can still be comprehensive, classifying knowledge in the large rather than determining it exhaustively.” The point is there is always more to learn which again is why Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty. But back to the original point of the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe. The idea is this how the CTMU changes our outlook on science: Newton by observing motion and acceleration could quantify things such as the acceleration of gravity or how force accelerates motion. He observed it and then thought about it for a while as Newton himself is quoted as saying “If I have done the public any service, it is due to my patient thought.”<br> Read more at: <a href="https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/isaac_newton_135550">https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/isaac_newton_135550</a></p><p>The main idea is Newton as though Newton figured out F=MA and it was shown to successfully work by measurement and experimental data we can say that the logic of theories makes demands on what we observe. F=MA was correct by experimental data. From this knowledge and any valid scientific theory that was confirmed by observation we can say the or just as well say instead of letting our theories be determined by observation Newton could’ve just started with F=MA without observing anything and know he was right just by mathematical and philosophical rules of reasoning and logic. This idea shows we can flip it and start with logic first. The CTMU shows just how to do this. The CTMU is saying Newton could’ve never observed motion and still come up with it and be correct. And that F=MA does make a demand on what we will observe. Through these logical requirements we can look at them if they are done with correct logic which logic is the valid rules of thought and use these concepts to tell us what we will observe in the universe before we have observed it and know we are right and use it to increase our knowledge on what we can observe. We can just develop the logic and math to do this. F=MA makes a demand on what we observe in the universe. Same with any logical principles if they can be done according to absolute invariant rules of logic. The Central hypothesis of the theory then one could say is everything observable in the universe conforms to certain rules of logic and that nothing is random and it is through these rules of logic we can classify all knowledge in the universe and successfully describe anything because everything physical by its existence conforms to such rules of logic.</p><p>In other words, a comprehensive theory of reality is not just about observation, but about theories and their logical requirements. Since theories are mental constructs, and <strong><em>mental</em></strong> means “of the mind”, this can be rephrased as follows: <strong><em>mind</em></strong><em> </em>and<em> </em><strong><em>reality</em></strong> are linked in mutual dependence at the most basic level of understanding. This linkage of mind and reality is what a <strong>TOE</strong> (Theory of Everything) is really about. The <strong>CTMU</strong> is such a theory; instead of being a mathematical description of specific observations (like all established scientific theories), it is a “metatheory” about the general relationship between theories and observations…i.e., about science or knowledge itself. Thus, it can credibly lay claim to the title of <strong>TOE</strong>. This how saying how then the CTMU was developed and what it means to be a theory of everything and why it can credibly lay claim to such a title and be used as so to apply to anything science can get its hands on.</p><p>And so this is the idea of how it is developed as such and is without assumptions and stripping away constraints and actually developed backwards from science and does it the opposite way and flips the process on its head as we were just describing. Instead of our theories be determined by observation our theories determine observation: “This precludes a neat series of cumulative definitions, which is possible in any case only by taking for granted the content and wherewithal of theorization (unfortunately, one can take nothing for granted in reality theory). As we will see below, the recursive nature of the CTMU is unavoidable. Secondly, the CTMU is developed “backwards” with respect to the usual deductive theories of science and mathematics, by first peeling away constraints and only then using the results to deduce facts about content. Most theories begin with axioms, hypotheses and rules of inference, extract implications, logically or empirically test these implications, and then add or revise axioms, theorems or hypotheses. The CTMU does the opposite, stripping away assumptions and “rebuilding reality” while adding no assumptions back.”-Pg.15 So the CTMU is without assumption developing inescapable rules of logic that can apply to describing anything in existence qualifying it as a theory of everything. And that’s what most of the 56 page paper is about. This shows that science cannot be divorced from philosophy.</p><p><strong><em>The CTMU and Physics (</em></strong>The physics here is obviously summed up but is also edited from how this is formatted from this same section on page 17–18 of the 19 page document summarizing the CTMU I printed off and put together of a Hodge podge different answers or responses of Chris about the CTMU in general of what it is and has to offer and why it’s important or anyone should care. This here is strictly physics a little more in depth from the messy copy and paste format of this part on page 17 and 18 of that with the new definition of space, time, matter and motion.<strong>)</strong></p><p>The avowed goal of physics is to produce what is sometimes called a “Theory of Everything” or TOE. As presently conceived, the TOE is thought to consist of one equation describing a single “superforce” unifying all the forces of nature (gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak nuclear forces).But this is actually an over simplification; every equation must be embedded in a Theory, and theories require models for their proper interpretation. Unfortunately, the currently available theory and model lack three important properties: closure, Consistency and comprehensivity. That is, they are not self-contained; they suffer from various intractable paradoxes; and they conspicuously exclude or neglect various crucial factors, including subjective ones like consciousness and emotion. Since the excluded factors fall as squarely under the heading everything as the included ones, a real TOE has no business omitting them. So as now envisioned by physicists, the TOE is misnamed as a “theory of everything”. The CTMU, on the other hand, is a TOE framework in which “everything” really means everything</p><p>Whereas the currently-envisioned TOE emphasizes objective reality at the expense of its subjective counterpart (mind), the CTMU places mind on the agenda at the outset. It does this not by making assumptions, but by eliminating the erroneous scientific assumption that mind and objective reality can be even tentatively separated. To do this, it exploits not just what we know of objective reality–the so-called “everything” of the standard TOE–but also what we know of the first word in “TOE”, namely theory. In other words, it brings the logic of formalized theories to bear on reality theory. Although this is a mathematically obvious move, it has been almost completely overlooked in the physical and mathematical sciences. By correcting this error, the CTMU warrants description as a theory of the relationship between the</p><p>Mind of the theorist and the objective reality about which it theorizes, <strong>completing the program of subjective-objective unification already inherent in certain aspects of the formalisms of relativity and quantum mechanics. In the process, it also brings the quantum and classical realms of physics into the sort of intimate contact that can only be provided by a fundamentally new model of physical and metaphysical reality…a model truly worthy of being called a “new paradigm”.</strong> <strong>Fundamental to this new model are revisions of basic physical concepts including space, time, matter and motion.</strong> <strong>Space</strong>, once a featureless medium aimlessly proliferating through cosmic expansion, becomes a distributed syntactic structure iteratively reborn of matter and subject to conspansive evacuation and rescaling. <strong>Time</strong>, previously envisioned as a quasi-spatial linear dimension along which the cosmos hurtles like a runaway locomotive, becomes the means by which the universe self-configures… an SCSPL-grammatical symphony of logico-linguistic transformations played by the self-creating cosmos. Lumps of <strong>matter</strong>, no longer the inert pawns of external laws of physics, become SCSPL syntactic operators containing within themselves the syntactic rules by which they internally process each other to create new states of physical reality. And <strong>motion</strong>, once seen as the passage of material attribute-ensembles through adjacent infinitesimal cells of empty space displaying them as content, becomes an iterative, self-simulative sequence of endomorphic self-projections by moving bodies themselves</p><p>SCSPL relates <strong>space</strong>, <strong>time</strong> and <strong>object</strong> by means of conspansive duality and conspansion, an SCSPL-grammatical process featuring an alternation between dual phases of existence associated with design and actualization and related to the familiar wave-particle duality of quantum mechanics.-Pg. 1 of Abstract.</p><p>By distributing the design phase of reality over the actualization phase, conspansive spacetime also provides a distributed mechanism for Intelligent Design, adjoining to the restrictive principle of <strong>natural selection a basic means of generating information and complexity </strong>(This is how in the theory intelligent design and evolution go together as evolution is added or natural selection is added information whether it be the human genome or what have you into biological life. Its added information into the universe. Evolution is not random but added information as it evolves which it must as things evolve organs and such and it’s also a design process guided by cosmic evolution in the CTMU is a process called telic causation<strong>.</strong>-also page 1.</p><p>Duality is a ubiquitous concept in mathematics, appearing in fields from logic and the theory of categories to geometry and analysis. The duality relation is symmetric; if dualizing proposition A yields proposition B, then dualizing B yields A.</p><p>Duality principles thus come in two common varieties, one transposing spatial relations and objects, and one transposing objects or spatial relations with mappings, functions, operations or processes. The first is called space-object (or S-O) duality; the second, time-space (or T-S/O) duality. In either case, the central feature is a transposition of element and a (spatial or temporal) relation of elements. Together, these dualities add up to the concept of triality, which represents the universal possibility of consistently permuting the attributes <strong>time</strong>, <strong>space</strong> and <strong>object </strong>with respect to various structures. From this, we may extract a third kind of duality: ST-O duality. In this kind of duality, associated with something called conspansive duality, objects can be “dualized” to spatiotemporal transducers, and the physical universe internally “simulated”(<strong> it is possible to apply a logical-Pg.41 transformation which inverts this picture, turning it “outside-in”. This results in a “distributed subjectivization” in which everything occurs inside the objects , effectively putting every object “inside” every other one in a generalized way and thereby placing the contents of space on the same footing as that formerly occupied by the containing space itself. In effect, the universe becomes a “selfsimulation” running inside its own contents); </strong>by its material contents. (<strong>But where communication happens on all scales, the distinction between inside and outside is not so clear. The languages communicated among language users and processors, and the languages embodied by users and processors themselves, occupy an overall medium with a unified communicative syntax largely indifferent to the distinction. The laws that govern a system may be reposed in the space that contains its objects, or in the objects themselves. Classical physics reposes everything in space, applying spatial concepts like vectors and tensors to fields outside the objects. However, it is possible to apply a logical 41 transformation which inverts this picture, turning it “outside-in”. This results in a “distributed subjectivization” in which everything occurs inside the objects; the objects are simply defined to consistently internalize their interactions, effectively putting every object “inside” every other one in a generalized way and thereby placing the contents of space on the same footing as that formerly occupied by the containing space itself. Vectors and tensors then become descriptors of the internal syntactic properties and states of objects. In effect, the universe becomes a “selfsimulation” running inside its own contents. This view, which is complementary to the conventional geometric one, is called transductive algebra. The “dual” relationship between geometry and transductive algebra is called conspansive duality. In conjunction with other principles including hology and SCSPLinfocognitive-telic reducibility, conspansive duality can afford fresh insight on the nature of reality and the physical world. One simply takes the conventional picture, turns it outside-in, puts the two pictures together, and extracts the implications</strong>).</p><p>We can now through the CTMU classify these four elements of physics space, time, matter and motion and all of reality and perception at large which in the CTMU is contained in the HCS which is distributed over the entire universe; short for Human-Cognitive-Syntax. This contains everything physics studies and more:</p><p>“The primary transducers of the overall language of science are scientists, and their transductive syntax consists of the syntax of generalized scientific observation and theorization, i.e. perception and cognition. We may therefore partition or stratify this syntax according to the nature of the logical and nonlogical elements incorporated in syntactic rules. For example, we might develop <strong>four</strong> classes corresponding to the fundamental <strong>trio</strong> space, time and object, a class containing the rules of logic and mathematics, a class consisting of the perceptual qualia in terms of which we define and extract experience, meaning and utility from perceptual and cognitive reality, and a class accounting for more <strong><em>nebulous feelings</em></strong> and <strong><em>emotions i</em></strong>ntegral to the determination of utility for qualic relationships.44 For now, we might as well call these classes <strong>STOS</strong>, <strong>LMS</strong>, <strong>QPS</strong> and <strong>ETS</strong>, respectively standing for space-time-object syntax, logico-mathematical syntax, qualioperceptual syntax, and emo-telic syntax, along with a high-level interrelationship of these components to the structure of which all or some of them ultimately contribute. Together, these ingredients comprise the Human Cognitive-Perceptual Syntax or HCS”.-Pg.41-In the HCS would be contained all of the information content of the entire universe including all of physics or what physics studies.</p><p>For it seems that just ahead on the intellectual horizon looms a new science of metaphysics…a logical framework in which the importance of humankind is unthreatened by reductionism, this framework yields a new understanding of <strong>space</strong> and <strong>time</strong>. The logical structure of <strong>space-time</strong> provides the universe with the wherewithal of being, endowing it with self-creative freedom and <strong>permitting it to rise</strong> from a <strong>sea</strong> of undifferentiated <strong>ontological potential</strong>.</p><p>Thus, the universe “selects itself” from unbound telesis or UBT, a realm of zero information and unlimited <strong>ontological potential</strong>, by means of telic recursion, whereby infocognitive syntax and its informational content are cross-refined through telic (syntax-state) feedback over the entire range of potential syntax-state relationships, up to and including all of <strong>spacetime</strong> and reality in general.</p><p>In this ostensibly inanimate, impersonal universe, a garden is a miracle. All the more so is a garden slug, an animal that can extract sufficient energy from the garden’s vegetable matter to move from place to place under its own power. When one is in the right mood, watching the shimmering spotted slug slide over the mulch evokes the miracle of biology in all its splendor; the creature’s pulsating aliveness is hypnotic. But then one recovers his bearings and 85 realizes that this is only, after all, a garden slug, and that the ladder of biology goes much higher. The miracle of life has culminated in one’s own species, man. Unlike the slug, whose nervous system has barely enough complexity to let it interface with the environment, a man’s nervous system, nucleated by the adaptive and inventive human brain, can abstractly model its surroundings and project itself consciously and creatively through time.</p><p>To see an object change, one must recall its former state for comparison to its present state, and to do that, one must recall one’s former perception of it. Because <strong>perception:</strong> is an interaction between self and environment(This will show a good transition from the most basic work to his 56 Page paper of the definition of perception “perception is a sensory intersect of mind and reality”-pg.19) , this amounts to bringing one’s <strong>former</strong> self into conjunction with one’s <strong>present</strong> self. That past and present selves can be brought into conjunction across a temporal interval implies that momentary selves remain sufficiently alike to be conjoined; that they can intersect at any given moment to compare content means that the intersection is changeless. So when self is generalized as the intersection of all momentary selves, it acquires a property called time invariance. It is the rock of perception, the unchanging observation post from which the net of temporal connections is cast and to which it remains anchored.</p><p>Through learning, mental models of <strong>time</strong> evolve in <strong>time</strong>. As the brain’s neural connections are modified and the strengths of existing connections are adjusted to account for new information regarding both self and environment — as it learns — its model of time changes as a function of time. In other words, the model changes with that which is modeled. If the brain is smart enough, then it can model itself in the process of being changed, and depict its own learning process as a higher level of <strong>time</strong>. But even as the self-absorbs its educational history and deepens its reflexive understanding, it remains static at its core. Otherwise, it would lose temporal cohesion and fall apart. Since self is static, <strong>time</strong> too should possess a static description that does not change in the temporal flow it describes (if <strong>time</strong> were the water flowing in a river, then a static description of <strong>time</strong> would be analogous to the rocky banks that determine the river’s course).</p><p>Such a description arises by abstraction. As cognitive models become more sophisticated, cognition becomes increasingly abstract; concepts become increasingly 88 independent of the particular objects they describe. Among the first things to be abstracted are <strong>space</strong> and <strong>time</strong>. The most general abstract system incorporating both is a <strong>language</strong>. Although the term “language” usually refers to a natural language like English, it is actually more general(This is taken from an online chat with Langan describing what a language actually is: “Most people think that a language must be a natural, spoken or written language like English, French or German. But in mathematics and logic, the definition of language is far more general. Reality itself can be viewed as a language,”) <strong>mathematically</strong>, a formal <strong>language</strong> consists of three ingredients: a set of elements to be combined as strings (e.g., symbols, memes), a set of <strong>structural rules</strong> governing their arrangement in <strong>space</strong>, and a set of <strong>grammatical rules</strong> governing their <strong>transformations</strong> in <strong>time</strong>. Together, the latter two ingredients form the <strong>syntax</strong> of the language. It follows that <strong>neural</strong>, cognitive-perceptual, and physical systems can be <strong>described as languages</strong>, and the <strong>laws</strong> which govern them as their <strong>syntaxes</strong>. On a subjective level, <strong>time </strong>itself can be abstractly characterized as the <strong>grammar</strong> of the joint language of cognition and perception. The rules of this grammar are the general ingredients of <strong>subjective time</strong>.</p><p>Because <strong>time-</strong> is defined in terms of transformations among spatial arrangements of objects, it is conceptually entwined with <strong>space</strong>. Thus, it is actually part of a linguistic complex called <strong>spacetime</strong>. Spatiotemporal relations exist on 89 many levels; if level one consists of simple relationships of objects in space and time, then level two consists of relationships of such relationships, and so on. Because <strong>logic</strong> is stratified in much the same way, one can say that time is stratified in a manner corresponding to <strong>predicate logic</strong>. This must be true in any case, since any meaningful description of <strong>time</strong> is logically formulated. Spatiotemporal stratification allows time to be viewed on various scales corresponding to ascending series of contexts: e.g., personal awareness, interpersonal relationships, social evolution, evolutionary biology, and so on. The histories of people, institutions, cultures, and species are nested like Chinese boxes, with the abstract principles of each history occupying a level of <strong>temporal grammar</strong> corresponding to an order of <strong>predicate logic</strong>.</p><p>Because of the relation between self-awareness and temporal awareness, temporal stratification induces a stratification of self. What we have already described as the static intersect of momentary selves becomes a stratified relationship…a terrace of temporal vantages conducing to long-term self-integration. As the self becomes stratified, the 90 principles abstracted from higher orders of experience tend to be objectivized due to their generality, with <strong>science and philosophy</strong> among the results. Thus, the subjective and objective sides of reality — the self and the environment — tend to merge in a symmetric way. On one hand, the environment is absorbed by the self through experience, and <strong>the laws of nature</strong> are thereby abstracted; on the other hand, the self is projected onto the environment in such a way that it “selects” the laws of nature by analogy to its own internal laws <strong>(</strong>Langan gives a very good example of this in the CTMU Q and A “My question is this: If you could answer the question what is the mathematical difference between visible light and invisible light, i.e. ultraviolet rays, wouldn’t this answer the question concerning the importance of further study into what is defined as physical. After all how do you perceive ultraviolet rays — as a sunburn or plant growth. Therefore, although not visible there indeed may be other energy forms that coexist right where we are, having an impact on us, without our knowing its source. It is not visibly physical yet its effect on us is very physical.</p><p><strong>A</strong>: Visible and UV light differ in <em>frequency</em>, or number of waves transmitted or received per second. Because light always travels at the same speed (c = ~300K km/sec), higher frequency means shorter waves:</p><p>lambda = c/frequency (where lambda = wavelength)</p><p>I.e., more energetic, higher-frequency light has a smaller <em>wavelength</em> than less energetic, lower-frequency light. Unfortunately, the tiny light sensors in our retinas, called <em>rods </em>and<em> cones</em>, cannot detect short-wavelength UV light.</p><p>Your question seems to be this: how can we call UV light “physical” when we cannot directly detect it? The answer is twofold but simple: we can call it “physical” because of (1) its perceptible physical effects on animals, plants, minerals and detection devices, and (2) our need to acknowledge the full definitions and logical implications of our perceptions and concepts.</p><p>Answer (2) is why reality is not merely “physical” in the concrete or material sense. In order to exist as a self-consistent perceptible entity, reality must ultimately make logical sense; our perceptions of it must conform to a coherent <em>cognitive syntax</em> containing the rules of perception and cognition and incorporating logic. This syntax tells us that if light exists <em>below</em> the maximum visible frequency, then in the absence of any extra constraints, it can exist <em>above</em> it as well.</p><p>Specifically, having identified the physical cause of light to be photon emission by subatomic oscillators called <em>electrons</em>, we are compelled to recognize the existence of “light” at whatever frequencies such oscillators may exhibit, right up through X and gamma radiation. The logical component of our cognitive syntax ultimately forces us to define and cross-relate all of the concepts in terms of which we apprehend reality, including light, in a logically consistent way”-This with the scientific example of UV rays and visible and invisible light is saying we can only know and understand reality through LOGIC period. And that’s all physical substance of the universe conforms to categories of LOGICAL SYNTAX. All of the stuff of science has to exist by the rules of logic somehow<strong>)</strong>. Either way, the core self tends to intersect with the environment as momentary selves are intersected within it. This brings the subjective and objective phases of reality — and time — into closer correspondence, blurring the distinction between them from an analytic standpoint. As time grows more abstract, ways are sought to measure it, diagram it and analyze it numerically. <strong>This requires a universal depiction of space and time against which arbitrary processes can be differentially graphed and metered. Such a depiction was introduced by the Frenchman René Descartes in the first half of the 17th century. It was called analytic geometry, and it depicted time and the (P.91) dimensions of space as straight, mutually perpendicular axes.</strong> In analytic geometry, any set of numerically-scaled <strong>space</strong> and <strong>time</strong> axes associated with any set of properties or attributes defines a coordinate system for assigning numbers to points, and simple processes appear as the graphs of algebraic functions. A few decades later, Newton and Leibniz independently discovered a new kind of mathematics, <strong>the infinitesimal calculus</strong>, by which to numerically quantify the rates of such processes. These innovations, which laid the foundations of modern science and engineering, suffice to this day in many practical contexts. Even though garden-variety analytic geometry was technically superseded by the <strong>Theory of Relativity</strong> — which was itself constructed on an analytic-geometric foundation — it gives a very close approximation of relativity in most situations. Unfortunately, the conveniences of analytic geometry came at the price of <strong>mind-body dualism</strong>. This was Descartes’ idea that the self, or “mind”, was a nonphysical substance that could be left out of physical reasoning with impunity. For some purposes, this was true. But as we saw in the next- (P.92) to-last paragraph, the relationship of mind to reality is not that simple. <strong>While the temporal grammar of physics determines the neural laws of cognition, cognitive grammar projects itself onto physical reality in such a way as to determine the form that physical grammar must assume</strong>. Because the form of physical grammar limits the content of physical grammar, this makes <strong>cognition </strong>a potential factor in determining the laws of nature. In principle, cognitive and physical grammars may influence each other symmetrically. The symmetric influence of cognitive and physical grammars implies a directional symmetry of time. Although time is usually seen as a one-way street, it need not be; the mere fact that a street is marked “one way” does not stop it from being easily traveled in the unauthorized direction. Indeed, two-way time shows up in both quantum physics and relativity theory, the primary mainstays of modern physics. Thus, it is not physically warranted to say that cognition cannot influence the laws of physics because the laws of physics “precede cognition in time”. If we look at the situation from the other direction, we can as easily say that cognition “precedes” the laws of physics in reverse time…and 93 point to the strange bidirectional laws of particle physics to justify our position. These laws are of such a nature that they can as well be called <strong>laws of perception</strong> as laws of physics.</p><p>Before we get to the final word on <strong>time</strong>, there is one more aspect of physical grammar that must be considered. Physical reasoning sometimes requires a distinction between two kinds of time: <strong>ordinary time</strong> and <strong>cosmic time</strong>. With respect to observations made at normal velocities, <strong>ordinary time</strong> behaves in a way described by Newtonian analytic geometry; at higher velocities, and in the presence of strong gravitational fields, it behaves according to Einstein’s Special and General Theories of Relativity. But not long after Einstein formulated his General Theory, it was discovered that the universe, AKA <strong>spacetime, was expanding</strong>. Because cosmic expansion seems to imply that the universe began as a dimensionless point, the universe must have been created, and the creation event must have occurred on a higher level of time: <strong>cosmic time</strong>. Whereas o<strong>rdinary time </strong>accommodates changes occurring within the spacetime manifold, this is obviously not so for the kind of time in which the manifold itself changes. 94 Now for the fly in the cosmological ointment. As we have seen, it is the nature of the cognitive self to formulate models incorporating ever-higher levels of change (or time). Obviously, the highest level of change is that characterizing the creation of reality. Prior to the moment of creation, the universe was not there; afterwards, the universe was there. This represents a sizable change indeed! Unfortunately, it also constitutes a sizable paradox. If the creation of reality was a real event, and if this event occurred in cosmic time, then cosmic time itself is real. But then cosmic time is an aspect of reality and can only have been created with reality. This implies that cosmic time, and in fact reality, must have created themselves! The idea that <strong>the universe created</strong> <strong>itself</strong>(The idea that the universe creates itself because there is nothing other than the universe to do this goes along with how the CTMU characterizing the universe as an SCSPL language or Self Configuring Self Processing Language. The idea that the universe created itself means its “Self-Configuring” and it has its own mind is at this point at least very plausible that we live in a conscious and intelligently evolving universe or in the CTMU this is called how evolution and natural selection is consciously guided and an intelligent design process “Intelligent Self-Design.” This is how evolution happens in the universe anywhere. It designs itself intelligently. This is in the 56 page paper of the CTMU “The CTMU has a meta-Darwinian message: the universe evolves by hological self-replication and self-selection. Furthermore, because the universe is natural, its self-selection amounts to a <strong>cosmic form of</strong> <strong>natural selection</strong>. But by the nature of this selection process, it also bears description as <strong>intelligent self-design</strong>”-Pg.50. Langan has written what the idea of an intelligent and conscious universe means and if this can be firmly proven and it can <strong>“(</strong>Christopher Michael Langan’s HIQ &amp; A <br> <br> Chronological order from bottom to top of page <br> <br> <br> <br> Q: Many people conceive of the universe as a “supreme being”. The interconnectedness is evident in the consistency of physical laws and repetition of motif seen on a many levels. What is interesting is understanding the sentience of that supreme being. A drive toward growth, or self-actualization seems evident, but how can we prove a “will of God” that would go beyond a drive toward optimal actualization?<br> <br> A: There are several ways that we can be logically certain that the being called “reality” or “the universe” is sentient.<br> <br> 1. *We’re* sentient. Because we live in the medium known as “reality”, and because any attribute supported by a medium exists throughout the medium in the form of potential (to be objectively actualized), sentience implicitly exists in reality.<br> <br> 2. Despite the principle of locality — the existence of separate locales and local systems within the universe — the universe is globally consistent. The aspect of a system which reflexively enforces global consistency is necessarily globally coherent, and that which is coherently reflexive (self-active, self-referential) is, in effect, “sentient”.<br> <br> 3. Because, by definition, there is nothing outside of reality that is sufficiently real to recognize the existence of reality, reality must distributively recognize its own existence; every time one object interacts with another within it, the objects “recognize” each other as things with which to interact. But that means that reality is distributively self-aware.<br> <br> Now, given the absolute logical certainty that the universe is sentient (self-aware) — a certainty that nobody can possibly refute, as we see from the inevitability of 1–3 above — can we characterize its “will”?<br> <br> Yes. First, what is will? That function of a sentient entity which forms intent prior to actualization. So by definition, the “will” of the universe is that function which determines how the universe will configure itself “in advance” of actualization. <strong>In cosmological terms, this function is just that which determines, among other things, the laws of mathematics and physics embodied by reality.<br> <br> Such a function must, after all, exist. For without it, there would be no reason, from one moment to the next, why the laws of physics should not spontaneously change into one of the infinite number of other nomologies that might have arisen</strong>. Concisely, this function is defined as that reflexive mapping which effects the nomological character and stability of reality. The “will of the universe”, AKA the “will of God”, AKA teleology, is the name of this function, which we have just concretely defined.<br> <br> Does the universe “feel” its volition as do we? Well, let’s see. What the universe feels properly includes what *we* feel, plus much more (because we are merely parts of it). The universe therefore “feels” teleology far more powerfully than a mere human being “feels” an act of human will. The mechanism of its “feeling”? Well, there are a lot of those, including every human being, every animal, every plant, and every alien microbe on every planet in every star system in every galaxy in the cosmos. As you can well imagine, the impressions that get channeled to the universe through all of these “sense receptors” add up to very powerful sensations indeed.<br> <br> In fact, these are the sensations that feed back to teleology to tell the universe how to self-actualize in the “optimal” way…i.e., <strong>so that it ends up with the “best feeling” possible.</strong> <strong>They have already told the universe how to configure the laws of math and physics</strong>; for more specific elements of configuration, <strong>the universe relies on US. Every decision we make, including our every act of will, we make on behalf of the universe.</strong> That’s why we should always make the very best decisions we can.<strong>)”</strong> brings a whole new meaning to bidirectional time, and thus to the idea that cognition may play a role in the creation of reality. As a self-creative mechanism for the universe is sought, it becomes apparent that cognition is the only process lending itself to plausible interpretation as a means of temporal feedback from present to past. Were cognition to play such a role, then in a literal sense, its most universal models of 95 temporal reality would become identical to the reality being modeled. <strong>Time would become cognition</strong>, and <strong>space:</strong> would become a <strong>system</strong> of <strong>geometric relations that evolves by distributed cognitive processing.</strong> Here comes the surprise: such a model exists. Appropriately enough, it is called the “<strong>Cognition-Theoretic Model of the Universe”, or CTMU for short</strong>. A cross between John Archibald Wheeler’s Participatory Universe and the Stephen Hawking-James Hartle “imaginary time” theory of cosmology proposed in Hawking’s phenomenal book A Brief History of Time, the CTMU resolves many of the most intractable paradoxes known to physical science while explaining recent data which indicate that <strong>the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate</strong>. Better yet, it bestows on human consciousness a level of meaning that was previously approached only by religion and mysticism. If it passes the test of time — and there are many good reasons to think that it will — then it will be the greatest step that humanity has yet taken towards a real understanding of its most (or least?) timeless mystery. And so the circle closes. <strong>Time becomes a cosmogonic 96 loop whereby the universe creates itself</strong>. The origin of our time concept, the self, becomes the origin of time itself. Our cognitive models of time become a model of time-ascognition. And the languages of cognition and physics become one self-configuring, self-processing language of which time is the unified grammar. Talk about “time out of mind”! And all this because of a little garden slug.</p><p><strong>A New Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics</strong></p><p>After standing for over two centuries as the last word in physics, the differential equations comprising the deterministic laws of Newtonian mechanics began to run into problems. One of these problems was called the <em>Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle</em> or <strong>HUP</strong>. The HUP has the effect of “blurring” space and time on very small scales by making it impossible to simultaneously measure with accuracy certain pairs of attributes of a particle of matter or packet of energy. Because of this blurring, Newton’s differential equations are insufficient to describe small-scale interactions of matter and energy. Therefore, in order to adapt the equations of classical mechanics to the nondeterministic, dualistic (wave-versus-particle) nature of matter and energy, the more or less <em>ad hoc</em> theory of quantum mechanics (<strong>QM</strong>) was hastily developed. QM identifies matter quanta with “probability waves” existing in ¥-dimensional complex <em>Hilbert space</em>, a Cartesian space defined over the field of complex numbers a+bi (where a and b are real numbers and i = Ö-1) instead of the pure real numbers, and replaces Hamilton’s classical equations of motion with Schrodinger’s <em>wave equation</em>. QM spelled the beginning of the end for Laplacian determinism, a philosophical outgrowth of Newtonianism which held that any temporal state of the universe could be fully predicted from a complete Cartesian description of any other. Not only uncertainty but <em>freedom </em>had reentered the physical arena</p><p>Unfortunately, the HUP was not the only quantum-mechanical problem for classical physics and its offshoots. Even worse was a phenomenon called <em>EPR (Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen) nonlocality</em>, according to which the conservation of certain physical quantities for pairs of correlated particles seems to require that information be instantaneously transmitted between them regardless of their distance from each other. The EPR paradox juxtaposes nonlocality to the conventional dynamical scenario in which anything transmitted between locations must move through a finite sequence of intervening positions in space and time. So basic is this scenario to the classical worldview that EPR nonlocality seems to hang over it like a Damoclean sword, poised to sunder it like a melon. Not only does no standard physical theory incorporating common notions of realism, induction and locality contain a resolution of this paradox — this much we know from a mathematical result called <em>Bell’s theorem</em> — but it seems that the very foundations of physical science must give way before a resolution can even be attempted!</p><p>If we add this descriptive kind of ambiguity to ambiguities of measurement, e.g. the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle that governs the subatomic scale of reality, and the internal theoretical ambiguity captured by undecidability, we see that ambiguity is an inescapable ingredient of our knowledge of the world. It seems that math and science are…well, inexact sciences.</p><p>How, then, can we ever form a true picture of reality? There may be a way. For example, we could begin with the premise that such a picture exists, if only as a “limit” of theorization (ignoring for now the matter of showing that such a limit exists). Then we could educe categorical relationships involving the logical properties of this limit to arrive at a description of reality in terms of reality itself. In other words, we could build a self-referential theory of reality whose variables represent reality itself, and whose relationships are logical tautologies. Then we could add an instructive twist. Since logic consists of the rules of thought, i.e. of mind, what we would really be doing is interpreting reality in a generic theory of mind based on logic. By definition, the result would be a <em>cognitive-theoretic model of the universe</em>.</p><p>For example, modern physics is bedeviled by paradoxes involving the origin and directionality of time, the collapse of the quantum wave function, quantum nonlocality, and the containment problem of cosmology. Were someone to present a simple, elegant theory resolving these paradoxes without sacrificing the benefits of existing theories, the resolutions would carry more weight than any number of predictions.</p><p><strong>The New Interpretation of QM-Sum over Futures and the Extended Superposition Principle</strong></p><p>The superposition principle highlights certain problems with quantum mechanics. One problem is that quantum mechanics lacks a cogent model in which to interpret things like “mixed states” (waves alone are not sufficient). Another problem is that according to the uncertainty principle, 30 the last states of a pair of interacting particles are generally insufficient to fully determine their next states. This, of course, raises a question: how are their next states actually determined? What is the source of the extra tie-breaking measure of determinacy required to select their next events (“collapse their wave functions”)?</p><p>The answer is not, as some might suppose, “randomness”; randomness amounts to acausality, or alternatively, to informational incompressibility with respect to any distributed causal template or ingredient of causal syntax. Thus, it is either no explanation at all, or it implies the existence of a “cause” exceeding the representative capacity of distributed laws of causality. But the former is both absurd and unscientific, and the latter requires that some explicit allowance be made for higher orders of causation…more of an allowance than may readily be discerned in a simple, magical invocation of “randomness”. The superposition principle, like other aspects of quantum mechanics, is based on the assumption of physical Markovianism. 40 It refers to mixed states between adjacent events, <strong>ignoring the possibility of nonrandom temporally-extensive relationships not wholly attributable to distributed laws. By putting temporally remote events in extended descriptive contact with each other (</strong>Extended superposition “atemporally” distributes antecedent events over consequent events, thus putting spacetime in temporally-extended self-contact. In light of the Telic Principle (see below), this scenario involves a new interpretation of quantum theory, sum over futures. <strong>Sum over futures</strong> involves an atemporal generalization of “process”, telic recursion, through which the universe effects on-the-fly maximization of a global self-selection parameter, generalized utility.) [( <strong>Sum over futures</strong> involves an atemporal (existing or considered without relation to time) <strong>before determining the next state(In the Sum Over Futures Principle)</strong>, <strong>Reality takes all of the past and future into account and then chooses a particular state</strong> on the basis of its own values), through which the universe effects on-the-fly (as time passes) maximization of a global (over all of Reality) self-selection parameter (measurement), generalized utility (what the universal Desire hopes to achieve).]</p><p>In extending the superposition concept to include nontrivial higher-order relationships, the Extended Superposition Principle opens the door to meaning and design. Because it also supports distribution relationships among states, events and syntactic strata, it makes cosmogony a distributed, coherent, ongoing event rather than a spent and discarded moment from the ancient history of the cosmos (This parallelism has powerful implications. When a human being dies, his entire history remains embedded in the timeless level of consciousness…the Deic level). Indeed, the usual justification for observer participation — that an observer in the present can perceptually collapse the wave functions of ancient (photon-emission) events — can be regarded as a consequence of this logical relationship.</p><p>Examined within the distinctive logical structure of this medium, time and causality turn out not to be confined to the familiar past-to-future direction. Instead, the futureto-past direction becomes important as well. The bidirectionality of time implies that the universe is in a state 81 of extended spatiotemporal self-superposition, each of its serial configurations, as defined at each successive moment of time, in contact with all others. At first glance, this seems to imply that the universe is completely determined…that as Laplace believed, every state of the universe is implicit in any state. But not only is such an assumption unnecessary, it would ultimately lead to intractable inconsistencies. In fact, the logical structure of spacetime provides the universe with the wherewithal of being, endowing it with self-creative freedom and permitting it to rise from a sea of undifferentiated ontological potential.</p><p>, the Extended Superposition Principle enables coherent cross-temporal telic feedback and thus plays a necessary role in cosmic self-configuration.</p><p>The <strong>areas inside the circles correspond to event potentials,</strong> and where events are governed by the laws of physics, to potential instantiations of physical law or “nomological syntax”.</p><p>That is, each <strong>circle</strong> depicts the “entangled quantum wavefunctions” of the objects which interacted with each other to generate it.</p><p>The small dots in the centers of the circles represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen, As a result, new states are formed within the images of previous states</p><p>one of these intrinsically atemporal <strong>circles</strong> has “inner-expanded” across vast reaches of space and time</p><p>That is, the circular boundaries of the Venn circles can be construed as those of “potentialized” objects in the process of absorbing their spatiotemporal neighborhoods.</p><p>The outward growth (or by conspansive duality, mutual absorption) of the circles is called inner expansion, while the collapse of their objects in new events is called requantization.</p><p>while the twin dots where the circles overlap reflect the+</p><p>fact that any possible new event, or interaction between objects involved in the old events, must occur by mutual acquisition in the intersect.</p><p>Since the event potentials and object potentials coincide, potential instantiations of law can be said to reside “inside” the objects, and can thus be regarded as functions of their internal rules or “object syntaxes”.</p><p>The circles themselves are called IEDs, short for inner expansive domains, and correspond to pairs of <strong>interactive syntactic operators</strong></p><p>(in the real world, the Venn diagrams are 3-dimensional rather than planar, the <strong>circles are spheres</strong>, and “layering” is defined accordingly).</p><p>series of Venn diagrams in which circles inner-expand, interpenetrate and “collapse to points” at each interactive generalized-observational event. This scenario is general, applying even to <strong>macroscopic objects consisting of many particles of matter</strong>;</p><p>Because each circle is structurally self-distributed, nothing need be transmitted from one part of it to another; Conspansion thus affords a certain amount of relief from problems associated with so-called <strong>“quantum nonlocality”</strong></p><p>a new circle appears within the old one by syntactic embedment, the circles are intrinsically</p><p>undefined in duration and are thus intrinsically atemporal. Time arises strictly as an ordinal</p><p>relationship among circles rather than within circles themselves.</p><p>As previously described, if the conspanding universe were projected in an internal plane, its evolution would look like ripples (infocognitive events) spreading outward on the surface of a pond, with new ripples starting in the intersects of their immediate ancestors. Just as in the pond, old ripples continue to spread outward in ever-deeper layers, carrying their virtual 0 diameters along with them. This is why we can collapse the past history of a cosmic particle by observing it in the present, and why, as surely as Newcomb’s demon, we can determine the past through regressive metric layers corresponding to a rising sequence of NeST strata leading to the stratum corresponding to the particle’s last determinant event. The deeper and further back in time we regress, the higher and more comprehensive the level of NeST that we reach, until finally, like John Wheeler himself, we achieve “observer participation” in the highest, most parallelized level of NeST…the level corresponding to the very birth of reality.</p><p>Conspansive domains interpenetrate against the background of past events at the inner expansion rate c, defined as the maximum ratio of distance to duration by the current scaling, and recollapse through quantum interaction. Conspansion thus defines a kind of <strong>“absolute time”</strong> metering and safeguarding causality. Interpenetration of conspansive domains, which involves a special logical operation called <em>unisection</em> (distributed intersection) combining aspects of the set-theoretic operations <em>union</em> and <em>intersection</em>, creates an infocognitive relation of sufficiently high order to effect quantum collapse. Output is selectively determined by ESP interference and reinforcement within and among metrical layers.</p><p>Accordingly, the universe as a whole must be treated as a static domain whose self and contents cannot “expand”, but only <em>seem </em>to expand because they are undergoing internal rescaling as a function of SCSPL grammar. The universe is not actually expanding in any absolute, externally-measurable sense; rather, its contents are shrinking relative to it, and to maintain local geometric and dynamical consistency, it appears to expand relative to them. Already introduced as <em>conspansion</em> (contraction <em>qua</em> expansion), this process reduces physical change to a form of “grammatical substitution” in which the geometrodynamic state of a spatial relation is differentially expressed within an ambient cognitive image of its previous state. By running this scenario backwards and regressing through time, we eventually arrive at the source of geometrodynamic and quantum-theoretic reality: a primeval conspansive domain consisting of pure physical potential embodied in the self-distributed “infocognitive syntax” of the physical universe…i.e., the laws of physics, which in turn reside in the more general HCS.</p><p>The microscopic implications of conspansion are in remarkable accord with basic physical criteria. In a self-distributed (perfectly self-similar) universe, every event should mirror the event that creates the universe itself. In terms of an implosive inversion of the standard (Big Bang) model, this means that every event should to some extent mirror the primal event consisting of a condensation of Higgs energy distributing elementary particles and their quantum attributes, including mass and relative velocity, throughout the universe. To borrow from evolutionary biology, spacetime ontogeny recapitulates cosmic phylogeny; every part of the universe should repeat the formative process of the universe itself.</p><p>Conspansion is not just a physical operation, but a logical one as well. Because physical objects unambiguously maintain their identities and physical properties as spacetime evolves, spacetime must directly obey the rules of 2VL (<em>2-valued logic</em> distinguishing what is true from what is false). Spacetime evolution can thus be straightforwardly depicted by Venn diagrams in which the truth attribute <strong>(</strong>I.e., scientific explanations and interpretations glue observations and equations together in a very <strong>poorly understood</strong> way. It often works like a charm…but why<strong>[((One of the main purposes of the CTMU is to explain why this works-That scientific observations go together with mathematical equations so well ex. E=MC² but why do observations and interpretations of the observations and equations that quantify the interpretations go together with such success? In other words why does science work? One of the goals of the CTMU is to make this scientific processes of such success in explaining reality…, better understood, changing science as we now know it and broaden its scope vastly! That’s what Langan is trying to say. Essentially explain why science works.))]</strong> ? One of the main purposes of reality theory is to answer this question. 12 The first thing to notice about this question is that it involves the process of <strong>attribution</strong>, and that the rules of <strong>attribution</strong> are set forth in stages by mathematical logic. The first stage is called sentential logic and contains the rules for ascribing the attributes true or false, respectively denoting inclusion or non-inclusion in arbitrary cognitive-perceptual systems. Reality theory is about the stage of <strong>attribution</strong> in which two predicates analogous to true and false, namely real and unreal, are ascribed to various statements about the real universe. Now we know that the closed, single-predicate definition of the Reality Principle is actually a closed descriptive manifold of linked definitions in principle containing the means of its own composition, <strong>attribution, recognition</strong>, processing and interpretation. So now we know that reality is more than just a linguistic self-contained syndiffeonic relation comprising a closed descriptive manifold of linked definitions containing the means of its own configuration, composition, <strong>attribution, recognition</strong>, processing and interpretation. Where sets contain their elements and <strong>attributes</strong> distributively describe their arguments, this implies a dual relationship between <strong>topological containment</strong> and <strong>descriptive attribution</strong> as modeled through <strong>Venn diagrams</strong>-of the circles but attribution is important it assigns by attribution the circles or events its properties that the circles topologically contain-. The point of this paraenthesis is to show why the word <strong>“attribution”</strong> is so important and why Langan uses it so much to describe things and what he means when he does in describing what is true.<strong>)</strong>, a high-order metapredicate of any physical predicate, corresponds to topological inclusion in a spatial domain-The domain of the circle or venn-shpere light cone cross section-corresponding to specific physical attributes. I.e., to <strong>be true</strong>, an effect must be not only logically but <strong><em>topologically contained((Inside the circle of the event to be true))</em></strong> by the cause{The cause of the event is…”<strong> instead, the information required for (e.g.) spin conservation is distributed over their joint ancestral IED…the virtual 0-diameter spatiotemporal image of the event that spawned both particles</strong>}; to inherit properties determined by an antecedent event, objects involved in consequent events must appear within its logical <em>and</em> spatiotemporal image[The circle or light cone cross section venn-sphere.] In short, logic equals spacetime topology.</p><p>In a conspansive universe, the spacetime metric undergoes constant rescaling. Whereas Einstein required a generalization of Cartesian space embodying higher-order geometric properties like spacetime curvature, conspansion requires a yet higher order of generalization in which even relativistic properties, e.g. spacetime curvature inhering in the gravitational field, can be progressively rescaled. Where physical fields of force control or <em>program</em> dynamical geometry, and programming is logically stratified as in NeST, fields become layered stacks of parallel distributive programming that decompose into <em>field strata</em> (conspansive layers) related by an intrinsic requantization function inhering in, and logically inherited from, the most primitive and connective layer of the stack. This “storage process” by which infocognitive spacetime records its logical history (This parallelism has powerful implications. When a human being dies, his entire history remains embedded in the timeless level of consciousness…the Deic level) is called <em>metrical layering</em> (note that since storage is effected by inner-expansive domains which are internally atemporal, this is to some extent a misnomer reflecting weaknesses in standard models of computation).</p><p>The metrical layering concept does not involve complicated reasoning. It suffices to note that <em>distributed</em> (as in “event images are outwardly distributed in layers of parallel computation by inner expansion”) effectively means “of 0 intrinsic diameter” with respect to the distributed attribute. If an attribute<strong> </strong>Corresponding to a logical relation of any order is distributed over a mathematical or physical domain, then interior points of the domain are undifferentiated with respect to it, and it need not be transmitted among them<strong> (</strong>really the definition of a circle or the properties of a circle here. Which remember domain is — domain (lightcone cross section, Venn sphere)-Domain is the inside of a circle and the fact the as it says the interior points of the domain are undifferentiated and it need not be transmitted among them is because in a circle it consists of an infinite related interior points that aren’t differentiated so therefore interconnected and homogeneous so nothing is transmitted by skipping space because of the undifferentiated interconnected points inside the circle as it appears to in non-locality((information appears to skip space instantly)).<strong>)</strong>. Where space and time exist only with respect to logical distinctions among attributes, metrical differentiation can occur within inner-expansive domains (IEDs) only upon the introduction of <em>consequent</em> attributes relative to which position is redefined in an overlying metrical layer, and what we usually call “the metric” is a function of the total relationship among all layers.</p><p>The spacetime metric thus amounts to a <strong>Venn</strong>-diagrammatic conspansive history in which every <strong>conspansive domain</strong> (lightcone cross section, <strong>Venn</strong> sphere) has <em>virtual 0 diameter</em> with respect to <strong>distributed attributes</strong>, despite apparent nonzero diameter with respect to metrical relations among subsequent events. <strong>What appears to be nonlocal transmission of information can thus seem to occur. </strong>Nevertheless, the CTMU is a localistic theory in every sense of the word; information is never exchanged “faster than conspansion”, i.e<strong>. faster than light</strong> (the CTMU’s unique explanation of quantum nonlocality within a localistic model is what entitles it to call itself a consistent “extension” of relativity theory, to which the <em>locality principle</em> is fundamental).</p><p>Thus, one perceives the model’s evolution as a conspansive overlay of physically-parametrized <strong>Venn</strong> diagrams directly through the time (SCSPL grammar) axis</p><p>To make things even simpler: the CTMU equates <em>reality</em> to <em>logic</em>, <em>logic</em> to <em>mind</em>, and (by transitivity of equality) <em>reality</em> to <em>mind (</em>Because quantum-scale objects are seen to exist only when they are participating in observational events-((See observer participation here. Quantum scale objects seen to exist when there is observer participation)) it means reality is like a mind. It displays mental characteristics. <strong>When a mind perceives it</strong>. Thus the laws of physics is as much an expression of our minds or perception as they are objectively physical. This what is meant when Langan writes at the end of the blue up above- reality to mind [Langan actually writes this and lays this out in his most basic yet wonderful work in the Art of Knowing and I won’t share the whole argument he lays out but here’s his conclusion: “So where will we go now, at the dawn of the New Millennium, for renewed confirmation of our “specialness” in the scheme of things? Fortunately, we are not yet facing an ideological dead end. For it seems that just ahead on the intellectual horizon looms a new science of metaphysics…a logical framework in which the importance of humankind is unthreatened by reductionism, and in which the significance of human feelings and emotions is uncompromised by their correlation with lowly biological processes. Rather than declaring us the abject slaves of natural laws beyond our control, this framework yields a new understanding of space and time in which the very <strong>laws of physics can be viewed as an expression of our minds.</strong> Granted, this framework remains hidden despite its portentous approach. But if its ongoing delay contributes to our collective store of humility, perhaps this is not entirely a bad thing.”-Pg.79. Then it makes a big <strong>Venn</strong> diagram out of all three, assigns appropriate logical and mathematical functions to the diagram, and deduces implications <strong>in light of <em>empirical data</em></strong>. A little reflection reveals that it would be hard to imagine a simpler or more logical theory of reality.</p><p><strong>“The Complete Description of the Interacting Circles In Conspansion in the CTMU”</strong></p><p>-The small dots in the centers of the <strong>circles</strong> represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen.</p><p>- Where each circle corresponds to two or more objects</p><p>-until a new circle appears within the old one by syntactic embedment, the circles are intrinsically undefined in duration and are thus intrinsically atemporal. Time arises strictly as an ordinal relationship among circles rather than within circles themselves. With respect to time-invariant elements of syntax active in any given state (circle)</p><p>That is, each <strong>circle</strong> depicts the “entangled quantum wavefunctions” of the objects which interacted with each other to generate it. The small dots in the centers of the <strong>circles</strong> represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen, while the twin dots where the circles overlap reflect the fact that any possible new event, or interaction between objects involved in the old events, must occur by mutual acquisition in the intersect. The outward growth (or by conspansive duality, mutual absorption) of the circles is called inner expansion, while the collapse of their objects in new events is called requantization. The circles themselves are called IEDs, short for inner expansive domains, and correspond to pairs of interactive syntactic operators involved in generalized-perceptual events (note the hological “evacuation” and mutual absorption of the operators). Spacetime can be illustrated in terms of a layering of such Venn diagrams, mutual contact among which is referred to as “extended superposition” (in the real world, the Venn diagrams are 3-dimensional rather than planar, the circles are spheres, and “layering” is defined accordingly).</p><p>Conspansive duality, the role of which in the CTMU is somewhat analogous to that of the Principle of Equivalence in General Relativity, is the only escape from an infinite ectomorphic “tower of turtles”. Were the perceptual geometry of reality to lack a conspansive dual representation, motion of any kind would require a fixed spatial array or ectomorphic “background space” requiring an explanation of its own, and so on down the tower. Conspansion permits the universe to self-configure through temporal feedback. Each conspanding <strong>circle</strong> represents an event-potential corresponding to a certain combination of law and state; even after one of these intrinsically atemporal <strong>circles</strong> has “inner-expanded” across vast reaches of space and time, its source event is still current for anything that interacts with it, e.g. an eye catching one of its photons. At the same time, conspansion gives the quantum wave function of objects a new home: inside the conspanding objects themselves. Without it, the wave function not only has no home, but fails to coincide with any logically evolving system of predicates or “laws of physics”. Eliminate conspansion, and reality becomes an inexplicable space full of deterministic worldlines and the weighty load of problems that can be expected when geometry is divorced from logic.</p><p>The areas inside the circles correspond to event potentials, and where events are governed by the laws of physics, to potential instantiations of physical law or “nomological syntax”. Where each circle corresponds to two or more objects, it comprises object potentials as well. That is, the circular boundaries of the Venn circles can be construed as those of “potentialized” objects in the process of absorbing their spatiotemporal neighborhoods. Since the event potentials and object potentials coincide, potential instantiations of law can be said to reside “inside” the objects, and can thus be regarded as functions of their internal rules or “object syntaxes”. Objects thus become syntactic operators, and events become intersections of nomological syntax in the 28 common value of an observable state parameter, position. The circle corresponding to the new event represents an attribute consisting of all associated nomological relationships appropriate to the nature of the interaction including conserved aggregates, and forms a pointwise (statewise) “syntactic covering” for all subsequent potentials. Notice that in this scenario, spacetime evolves linguistically rather than geometrodynamically. Although each Venn circle seems to expand continuously, its content is unchanging; its associated attribute remains static pending subsequent events involving the objects that created it. Since nothing actually changes until a new event is “substituted” for the one previous, i.e. until a new circle appears within the old one by syntactic embedment, the circles are intrinsically undefined in duration and are thus intrinsically atemporal. Time arises strictly as an ordinal relationship among circles rather than within circles themselves. With respect to time-invariant elements of syntax active in any given state (circle), the distinction between zero and nonzero duration is intrinsically meaningless; such elements are heritable under substitution and become syntactic ingredients of subsequent states.</p><p><strong>“The Ultimate Answer To quantum Non Locality”</strong></p><p><strong>Because each circle is structurally self-distributed, nothing need be transmitted from one part of it to another(Thus, just as the initial collapse of the quantum wavefunction (QWF) of the causally self-contained universe is internal to the universe, the requantizative occurrence of each subsequent event is topologically internal to that event[Inside each circle in this case], and the cause spatially contains the effect. The implications regarding quantum nonlocality are clear.</strong></p><p><strong>No longer must information propagate at superluminal velocity between spin-correlated particles; instead, the information required for (e.g.) spin conservation is distributed over their joint ancestral IED…the virtual 0-diameter spatiotemporal image of the event (The circle itself and topologically internal is just that inside it or inside the IED or Inner-inside-Expanding Circle) that spawned both particles(So from the instant to entangled particles generated a circle as it expands the two particles have always been sharing information throughout the circle or the gap between them so when it seems they are doing it instantaneously it’s because they’ve been connected the whole time but the circle expands or in the CTMU conspands at the speed of light. But they would exchange information across this circle not faster than light. When it appears they are instantaneously they were already connected in this circle event from the beginning of the circles expansion or of that information exchange in my own words.) As a correlated ensemble</strong> <strong>(</strong>The small dots in the centers of the <strong>circles</strong> represent the initial events and objects from which the circles have arisen,<strong>). The internal parallelism of this domain — the fact that neither distance nor duration can bind within it — short-circuits spatiotemporal transmission on a logical level. A kind of “logical superconductor”, the domain offers no resistance across the gap between correlated particles; in fact, the “gap” does not exist!), </strong>locality constraints arise only with respect to additional invariants differentially activated within circles that represent subsequent states and break the hological symmetry of their antecedents. Conspansion thus affords a certain amount of relief from problems associated with so-called “quantum nonlocality”</p><p>The CTMU, on the</p><p>other hand, is conspansive and telic-recursive; because new state-potentials are constantly being created by evacuation and mutual absorption of coherent objects (syntactic operators) through conspansion, metrical and nomological uncertainty prevail wherever standard recursion is impaired by object sparsity. This amounts to self-generative freedom, hologically providing reality</p><p>with a “self-simulative scratchpad” on which to compare the aggregate utility of multiple self-configurations for self-optimizative purposes.</p><p>In a Venn diagram, the contents of circles reflect the structure of their boundaries; the boundaries are the primary descriptors. The interior of a circle is simply an “interiorization” or self-distribution of its syntactic “boundary constraint”. Thus, nested circles corresponding to identical objects display a descriptive form of containment corresponding to syntactic layering, with underlying levels corresponding to syntactic coverings. Through the</p><p>principle of conspansive duality, ectomorphism is conjoined with endomorphism, whereby things are mapped, generated or replicated within themselves. Through conspansive endomorphism, syntactic objects are injectively mapped into their own hological interiors from their own syntactic</p><p>boundaries.</p><p>Because quantum-scale objects are seen to exist only when they are participating in observational events, including their “generalized observations” of each other, their worldlines are merely assumed to exist between events and are in fact syntactically retrodicted, along with the continuum, from the last events in which they are known to have participated. This makes it possible to omit specific worldlines entirely, <strong>replacing them with series of Venn diagrams in which circles inner-expand, interpenetrate and “collapse to points” at each interactive generalized-observational event.</strong></p><p>SCSPL is logical in construction, has a loop-like dynamic, and <strong>creates information</strong> and syntax (SCSPL-grammatical process featuring an alternation between dual phases of existence associated with design and actualization…, principle of <strong><em>natural selection</em></strong> a basic means of <strong>generating information and complexity</strong>.-Pg.1 Abstract) , including the laws of physics, through telic recursion generated by agent-level syntactic operators whose acts of observer-participation are essential to the self-configuration of the Participatory Universe. These acts are linked by telic recursion to the generalized cognitive-perceptual interactions of quantum-level syntactic operators, the <strong>minimal events comprising the fabric of space-time</strong> (Lumps of <strong>matter,</strong> syntactic operators containing within themselves the syntactic rules by which they internally process each other to create new states of physical reality.)</p><p>You may ask what in the world is a <strong>syntactic operator</strong>? What in the hell is it? Best explained in the 56 page paper where it’s the fundamental objects everything is made of and why the CTMU can united and adopt string theory as well: “In conventional physical theory, the fundamental entities are <strong>point particles</strong>, <strong>waves</strong> and more recently, <strong>strings</strong>; each class of object has its problems and paradoxes. In the CTMU, the <strong><em>fundamental objects are “syntactic operators” </em></strong>(units of self-transducing information or infocognition) that are not only capable of emulating all of these objects and more, but of containing the syntactic structures to which they must inevitably conform and resolving their characteristic paradoxes in the bargain.”-Pg.20.</p><p>attempts to explain reality entirely in terms of physics are paradoxical; reality contains not only the physical, but the abstract machinery of perception and cognition through which “the physical” is perceived and explained. Where this abstract machinery is what we mean by “the supraphysical”, reality has physical and supraphysical aspects. Physical and supraphysical reality are respectively “concrete” and “abstract”, i.e. material and mental in nature.</p><p>The question is, do we continue to try to objectivize the supraphysical component of reality as do the theories of physics, strings and membranes, thus regenerating the paradox? Or do we take the CTMU approach and resolve the paradox, admitting that the supraphysical aspect of reality is “mental” in a generalized sense and describing all components of reality in terms of SCSPL <strong>syntactic operators</strong> with subjective and objective aspects?</p><p>One of the biggest moments in the history of physics was when they discovered they could create an atomic bomb Due to Einstein’s equation that an isotope if it can be split could cause a chain reaction of neutrons running into each other and imploding on each other ricochet the neutrons off of the next nearby atom in line causing a massive release of energy which we know from Einstein’s equation. In the CTMU atoms are made up of Syntactic Operators or that Syntactic Operators are still fundamental to the atom. I’m not sure if the practicality goes with syntactic operators that we can split one. But as far as physics go they play a fundamental role in all of the particles and stings and waves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b240552702f3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The True purpose and Meaning of the CTMU from a Bird’s Eye View]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/the-true-purpose-and-meaning-of-the-ctmu-from-a-birds-eye-view-9fccb89d26b9?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9fccb89d26b9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dogs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Jan 2018 07:45:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-28T07:45:45.904Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A New Kind of Reality Theory<br> No longer is empathy a moral and spiritual attribute of personhood of social human social interaction. Like the jerk of a tapped knee and the dilation of a pupil in sudden darkness, empathy appears to be just another biological phenomenon reducible to the ubiquitous of proton, neutron, and electron in random chunks of matter.<br> So much for vaunted intelligence and empathy as evidence for human spiritual ascendancy, what of spirituality itself? World literature has several telling adumbrations of modern scientific research. Fyodor Dostoievsky described in his tragicomic novel The Idiot, Fyodor Dostoievsky described the expansive feeling of beatitude experienced by his protagonist Prince Myshkin just prior to the onset of epileptic seizures. In so far as Dostoievsky himself suffered from epilepsy, these fictionalized accounts seem to have been taken directly from the author’s personal experience… and the Great Russian novelist was far from alone. Many patients afflicted with temporal lobe epilepsy have reported that when a spell overtakes them, they “see God” or experience “enlightenment”. Searching for an explanation, neurologists were finally able to find a connection between temporal lobe epilepsy and spontaneous religious feelings: epileptic seizures can stimulate a structure called the “God Module” (!) in the temporal-limbic region of the human brain. Inspired by such successes, science is now looking at the neurological correlates of religious experience in general. This emerging field “neuro-theology” has a central premise: that feeling of spirituality are due to the genetic wiring of the human nervous system. Neuro-theological researchers recently conducted an unusual experiment where Tibetan Buddhist tugged on a strand of twine as he entered a state of meditative transcendence. Upon the prearranged signal, a researcher injected a radioactive racer into an IV line attached to the subject’s arm and scanned his brain with a SPECT. SPECT’S circuits registered a dramatic reduction in neural activity within a specialized region at the top rear of his brain…, an area known to be responsible for translating sensory data into comprehension of the boundary between self and environment. Having shut down his “self-delimiter” module” by meditative sensory deprivation, the subject had destroyed the subjective distinction between internal and external reality and become “one with the universe”. According to brain scans, praying makes Franciscan nuns feel “oneness with God” by suppressing the activity of their self-delimiter modules. The neural aspects of religion are by no means confined to meditation and prayer. A 1997 Japenese study showed rhythmic repetition of ritual chanting and dancing causes a certain brain component, the hypothalamus to generate a mantra transports a yogi to a state of deep inner calm, Sufi mystics feverishly dance themselves to states of excitement in which they feel like “live wires” crackling with the infinite energy of the universe. But does this provide evidence for anything of an objectively transcendental nature? The response of neuro-theology to this question is; given the physical nature of that which is to be explained, there is no need for such a hypothesis. {Cut out from Langan’s text was as Napoleon said}</p><p>The elevated status of human consciousness grows ever more precarious upon the swaying tightrope of metaphysical distinctiveness. First came evidence for the physical basis of consciousness in the various aphasias and apraxias associated with brain lesions; then came the frontal assault of operant conditioning on free will; now we have brain-scanned nuns and the possibility of genetically engineered intellectual and spiritual “geniuses”. Intelligence, language, empathy, spirituality… all of our claims to metaphysical distinctiveness seem to be falling beneath the heartless scythe of physical reductionism. So where will we go now, at the dawn of the New Millennium, for renewed confirmation of our “specialness” in the scheme of things? Fortunately, we are not yet facing an ideological dead end. For it seems that just ahead on the intellectual horizon looms a new science of metaphysics… a logical framework in which the importance of humankind is unthreatened by reductionism, and in which the significance of human feelings and emotions is uncompromised by their correlation with lowly biological processes. Rather than declaring us the abject slaves of natural laws beyond our control, this framework yields a new understanding of space and time in which the very laws of physics can be viewed as an expression of our minds. Granted, this framework remains hidden despite its portentious approach. But if it’s ongoing delay contributes to our collective store of humility, perhaps this is not an entirely bad thing. For now we may simply observe that science consists of building accurate conceptual models of the world, and that the theory of models has thus become a crucial ingredient of scientific reality. Perhaps the most distinctive characteristic of model theory is its use of “metalanguages”, or languages that talk about languages, to analyze the mappings, or correspondences, between scientific theories and their universe of discourse. Logically, such meta-languages amount to relationships between theoretical cognition and perceptual reality… or between the mind and the real world of scientific observations. Because these relationships do more than just describe reality-because they turn out to be primary conditions of its existence- they distribute over it on all scales uniting the ubiquitous subjective and objective sides of its nature. The universal distribution of these relationships implies the existence of a homogeneous cognitive and perceptual medium embracing the real universe and propagating the influence of our minds throughout the cosmos. Within the distinctive logical structure of this medium, time and causality turn out not to be confined to the familiar past-to-future direction. Instead, the future-past direction becomes important. The bi-directionality of time implies that the universe is in a state of extended spatiotemporal self-superposition, each of its serial configurations, as defined at each successive moment of time, in contact with all others. At first this seems to say that the universe is completely determined … that as Laplace believed, every state in the universe is implicit in any state. Not only is such an assumption unnecessary, it would ultimately lead to intractable inconsistencies. In fact, the logical structure of space time provides the universe with the wherewithal of being, endowing it with self-creative freedom and permitting it to rise from a sea of undifferentiated ontological potential.<br>What does this have to do with neuro-theology? Insofar as God is generally defined as the Prime Mover or first principle of reality, God is by definition real, and thus a part of the real universe. This 1st principle is by definition primary — because there is by definition no preexisting reality to contain it-reality cannot properly include it, so the real universe must coincide with God; scientific knowledge is theological knowledge, and science a form of theology. It follows that our ability to use science to better the plight of our species-our capacity to know God and to help others know God- is part of what makes us “special”. And where true science is a key ingredient of our claim to metaphysical distinctiveness, our place in the hierarchy of being cannot be threatened by science done thoroughly, correctly, and without a priori restrictions on our role in the scheme of things. But what is that role? Where does humanity fit into the scheme even now being revealed to us by science…? It turns out we are microsms, images of the universe within the universe. And because of the symmetric connection between source and image, cosmos and mircrocosm, we function as agents through whom the universe realizes it’s being. We are its children and heirs, poised on the threshold of adulthood and charged with shaping destiny itself, with helping the living universe choose its form and content from a background of undifferentiated potential. Though eons removed from the moment of creation, we actively retrodcit it, sending the power of our minds back through time to help the Prime Mover, our parent and provider, self-creatively embody the universe we inhabit. <br>The CTMU resolves many of the most intractable paradoxes known to physical science while explaining recent data which indicate that the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate. Better yet, it bestows on human consciousness a level of meaning that was previously approached only by religion and mysticism. If it passes the test of time — and there are many good reasons to think that it will — then it will be the greatest step humanity has yet taken towards solving its most timeless mysteries.</p><p>Langan, Christopher Michael; Langan, Chris . The Art of Knowing: Expositions on Free Will and Select Essays (Kindle Locations 754–757). Mega Foundation Press. Kindle Edition.</p><p>What is the CTMU? How is it Developed? What is the main premise of how it extends investigation beyond merely the scientific method?<br>Scientific theories are mental constructs that have objective reality as their content. According to the scientific method, science puts objective content first, letting theories be determined by observation. But the phrase “a theory of reality” contains two key nouns, theory and reality, and science is really about both. Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms — we could just as well start with these properties and see what they might tell us about objective reality. Just as scientific observation makes demands on theories, the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe. <br>In other words, a comprehensive theory of reality is not just about observation, but about theories and their logical requirements. Since theories are mental constructs, and mental means “of the mind”, this can be rephrased as follows: mind and reality are linked in mutual dependence at the most basic level of understanding. This linkage of mind and reality is what a TOE (Theory of Everything) is really about. The CTMU is such a theory; instead of being a mathematical description of specific observations (like all established scientific theories), it is a “metatheory” about the general relationship between theories and observations…i.e., about science or knowledge itself. Thus, it can credibly lay claim to the title of TOE.<br>Mind and reality — the abstract and the concrete, the subjective and the objective, the internal and the external — are linked together in a certain way, and this linkage is the real substance of “reality theory”. Just as scientific observation determines theories, the logical requirements of theories to some extent determine scientific observation. Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty, and this means that a comprehensive theory of reality cannot be based on scientific observation alone. Instead, it must be based on the process of making scientific observations in general, and this process is based on the relationship of mind and reality. So the CTMU is essentially a theory of the relationship between mind and reality.<br>In explaining this relationship, the CTMU shows that reality possesses a complex property akin to self-awareness. That is, just as the mind is real, reality is in some respects like a mind. But when we attempt to answer the obvious question “whose mind?”, the answer turns out to be a mathematical and scientific definition of God. This implies that we all exist in what can be called “the Mind of God”, and that our individual minds are parts of God’s Mind. They are not as powerful as God’s Mind, for they are only parts thereof; yet, they are directly connected to the greatest source of knowledge and power that exists. This connection of our minds to the Mind of God, which is like the connection of parts to a whole, is what we sometimes call the soul or spirit, and it is the most crucial and essential part of being human. <br>Thus, the attempt to formulate a comprehensive theory of reality, the CTMU, finally leads to spiritual understanding, producing a basis for the unification of science and theology. The traditional Cartesian divider between body and mind, science and spirituality, is penetrated by logical reasoning of a higher order than ordinary scientific reasoning, but no less scientific than any other kind of mathematical truth. Accordingly, it serves as the long-awaited gateway between science and humanism, a bridge of reason over what has long seemed an impassable gulf.<br>A curious child often asks “why” questions, and when an answer is given, immediately asks another why question about the answer. Such a child is unsatisfied with superficial explanations, craving instead an ultimate rationale for existence. Example: “Why is grass green?” “Chlorophyll’s green.” “Why does grass have chlorophyll?” “Because it needs to photosynthesize.” “Why?” “Because it gets its energy from the sun.” “Why does the sun make energy?” “Because it’s a huge fusion reactor that takes energy from atoms.” “Why do atoms have energy?” “Because, as a man named Einstein showed, matter is energy.” “Why?” “Because that’s the way the universe is made.” “What’s the universe and who made it?” At this point, the weary adult has exhausted his scientific knowledge and must begin to deal with the most general and philosophically controversial abstractions in his mental vocabulary… or give up.<br>Stephen Hawking is among those who have proposed a way out of the regress. In collaboration with James Hartle, he decided to answer the last question — what is the universe and who made it? — as follows. “The universe made itself, and its structure is determined by its ability to do just that.” This is contained in the No Boundary Proposal, which Hawking describes thusly: “This proposal incorporates the idea that the universe is completely selfcontained, and that there is nothing outside the universe. In a way, you could say that the boundary conditions of the universe are that there is no boundary.” To mathematically support this thesis, Hawking infuses the quantum wavefunction of the universe with a set of geometries in which space and time are on a par. The fact that time consists of a succession of<br>Individual moments thus becomes a consequence of spatial geometry, explaining the “arrow of time” by which time flows from past to future.<br>Unfortunately, despite the essential correctness of the “intrinsic cosmology” idea (to make the universe self-contained and self-explanatory), there are many logical problems with its execution. These problems cannot be solved simply by choosing a convenient set of possible geometries (structurings of space); one must also explain where these geometric possibilities came from. For his own part, Hawking explains them as possible solutions of the equations expressing the laws of physics. But if this is to be counted a meaningful explanation, it must include an account of how the laws of physics originated… and there are further requirements as well. They include the need to solve paradoxical physical conundrums like ex nihilo cosmogony (how something, namely the universe, can be created from nothing), quantum nonlocality (how subatomic particles can instantaneously communicate in order to preserve certain conserved physical quantities), accelerating cosmic expansion (how the universe can appear to expand when there is no external medium of expansion, and accelerate in the process to boot), and so on. Even in the hands of experts, the conventional picture of reality is too narrow to meaningfully address these issues. Yet it is too useful, and too accurate, to be “wrong”. In light of the fundamentality of the problems just enumerated, this implies a need for additional logical structure, with the extended picture reducing to the current one as a limiting case.<br>The CTMU takes the reflexive self-containment relationship invoked by Hawking and some of his cosmological peers and predecessors and explores it in depth, yielding the logical structures of which it is built. Together, these structures comprise an overall structure called SCSPL, acronymic for SelfConfiguring Self-Processing Language. The natural terminus of the cosmological self-containment imperative, SCSPL is a sophisticated mathematical entity that possesses logical priority over any geometric explanation of reality, and thus supersedes previous models as a fundamental explanation of the universe we inhabit. In doing so, it relies on a formative principle essential to its nature, the Telic Principle. A logical analogue<br>of teleology, the Telic Principle replaces the usual run of ontological hypotheses, including quasi-tautological anthropic principles such as “we perceive this universe because this universe supports our existence,” as the basis of cosmogony.<br>Since the dawn of our species, human beings have been asking difficult questions about themselves, the universe and the nature of existence, but have lacked a unified conceptual framework strong and broad enough to yield the answers. Enter the Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe (CTMU).</p><p>In its exciting development of these and other ideas, the Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe helps us to understand not only the nature of reality, but the integral role played by human beings in the creation and maintenance of the world they inhabit. In the process, the CTMU enables us to comprehend the psychological, metaphysical, and ethical ramifications of the relationship between man and the cosmos, and thus what it means to be human.<br>Among the questions that are answered within the framework of the CTMU: What is the nature of humanity’s relationship with God? What is our relationship with each other on individual and cultural levels? Do human beings possess free will? Is there life after death? Is there a physical basis for spirituality? Where did the universe come from? Is there such a thing as absolute good or absolute evil? These are just a few of the many burning philosophical dilemmas that mankind has pondered since its infancy. When these dilemmas are finally considered in the advanced conceptual framework of a true TOE like the CTMU, their answers fall into place as though under the influence of an attractive force. The mystery melts away, but not the wonder.<br>In its role as a comprehensive theory of reality, the Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe serves as a firm basis for the unification of science and theology, leading us inevitably in the direction of intellectual enlightenment and a collective spiritual awakening. The traditional Cartesian divider between body and mind, matter and thought, science and spirituality is penetrated by logical reasoning of a higher order than ordinary scientific reasoning, but no less scientific than any other kind of mathematical truth. Accordingly, it serves as the long-awaited gateway between science and humanism, a bridge of reason over what has long seemed an impassable gulf.<br>The avowed goal of physics is to produce what is sometimes called a “Theory of Everything” or TOE. As presently conceived, the TOE is thought to consist of one equation describing a single “superforce” unifying all the forces of nature (gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak nuclear forces). But this is actually an oversimplification; every equation must be embedded in a theory, and theories require models for their proper interpretation. Unfortunately, the currently available theory and model lack three important<br>properties: closure, consistency and comprehensivity. That is, they are not self-contained; they suffer from various intractable paradoxes; and they conspicuously exclude or neglect various crucial factors, including subjective ones like consciousness and emotion. Since the excluded factors fall as squarely under the heading everything as the included ones, a real TOE has no business omitting them. So as now envisioned by physicists, the TOE is misnamed as a “theory of everything”.<br>The CTMU, on the other hand, is a TOE framework in which “everything” really means everything. Whereas the currently-envisioned TOE emphasizes objective reality at the expense of its subjective counterpart (mind), the CTMU places mind on the agenda at the outset. It does this not by making assumptions, but by eliminating the erroneous scientific assumption that mind and objective reality can be even tentatively separated. To do this, it exploits not just what we know of objective reality — the so-called “everything” of the standard TOE — but also what we know of the first word in “TOE”, namely theory. In other words, it brings the logic of formalized theories to bear on reality theory.<br>Although this is a mathematically obvious move, it has been almost completely overlooked in the physical and mathematical sciences. By correcting this error, the CTMU warrants description as a theory of the relationship between the mind of the theorist and the objective reality about which it theorizes, completing the program of subjective-objective unification already inherent in certain aspects of the formalisms of relativity and quantum mechanics. In the process, it also brings the quantum and classical realms of physics into the sort of intimate contact that can only be provided by a fundamentally new model of physical and metaphysical reality…a model truly worthy of being called a “new paradigm”.<br>Fundamental to this new model are revisions of basic physical concepts including space, time, matter and motion. Space, once a featureless medium aimlessly proliferating through cosmic expansion, becomes a distributed syntactic structure iteratively reborn of matter and subject to conspansive evacuation and rescaling. Time, previously envisioned as a quasi-spatial<br>linear dimension along which the cosmos hurtles like a runaway locomotive, becomes the means by which the universe self-configures… an SCSPLgrammatical symphony of logico-linguistic transformations played by the self-creating cosmos. Lumps of matter, no longer the inert pawns of external laws of physics, become SCSPL syntactic operators containing within themselves the syntactic rules by which they internally process each other to create new states of physical reality. And motion, once seen as the passage of material attribute-ensembles through adjacent infinitesimal cells of empty space displaying them as content, becomes an iterative, self-simulative sequence of endomorphic self-projections by moving bodies themselves.<br>The name literally says it all. The phrase “Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe” contains three main ingredients: cognitive theory, model, and universe. Cognitive theory refers to a general language of cognition (the structural and transitional rules of cognition); universe refers to the content of that language, or that to which the language refers; and model refers to the mapping which carries the content into the language, thus creating information. The way in which the title brings these three ingredients together, or “contracts” their relationship to the point of merging, reflects their perfect coincidence in that to which the title implicitly refers, i.e., reality (the physical universe plus all that is required to support its perception and existence). Thus, the CTMU is a theory which says that reality is a self-modeling universal language, or if one prefers, that the universe is a self-modeling language.<br>The operation of combining language, universe, and model to create a perfectly self-contained metalanguage results in SCSPL, short for Self-Configuring Self-Processing Language. This language is “self-similar” in the sense that it is generated within a formal identity to which every part of it is mapped as content; its initial form, or grammatical “start symbol”, everywhere describes it on all scales. My use of grammatical terminology is intentional; in the CTMU, the conventional notion of physical causality is superseded by “telic causation”, which resembles generative grammar and approaches teleology as a natural limit. In telic causation, ordinary events are predicated on the generation of closed causal loops distributing over time and space. This loop-structure reflects the fact that time, and the spatial expansion of the cosmos as a function of time, flow in both directions — forward and backward, outward and inward — in a dual formulation of causality characterizing a new conceptualization of nature embodied in a new kind of medium or “manifold”.<br>The CTMU is not just a theory; it is logical model theory applied to metaphysics, and as much a logical necessity as any branch of mathematics or philosophy. One can no more escape from it than from X=X or 1+1=2. But when it comes to something that packs this combination of scope and power, many people, including certified academics, committed atheists, and even some religious believers, are apparently afraid to stare X=X in the face.<br>Little wonder. After all, once one has beheld the metaphysical structure of reality, there is no longer any such thing as plausible deniability or defense by ignorance; it’s the end of innocence, so to speak. Understandably, many people find that a little scary.</p><p>Obviously, the CTMU is a cross-disciplinary project. On what disciplines does it draw?<br>Because an ultimate theory must accommodate every valid theory pertaining to every part or aspect of reality, it must be approached in the most general terms possible. It must also be formed from the top down rather than just from the bottom up, as it is easier to maintain initial coherence as specificative distinctions are added than to create it ad hoc by cobbling together distinct entities. This means that we must begin with a perfectly general theoretic identity and work inward.<br>One therefore begins with mathematical logic, all the way from the propositional and predicate calculi to lattices and model theory; arithmetic, abstract algebra, and elementary analysis; basic probability theory and statistics; foundational mathematics, including the theories of sets and categories; and of course, metaphysics and theology. One can then move on to the theories of computation and information; the algebraic and computational theories of language, generative (computational) grammar and the logical theory of metalanguages; geometry and the theory of manifolds; classical and quantum physics, including relativity theory and cosmology; the study of causality and evolution in fields like biology, neuroscience, and cognitive psychology; decision theory and economics, especially as they relate to the nature and maximization of utility and the stratification of utility functions and distributions; and so on up to (intellectual) exhaustion.<br>I’ve just named what some would view as an intractable multiplicity of disciplines, each splitting into branches, each of which is rich enough to occupy a dedicated specialist throughout his/her entire academic career. This naturally presents a problem for generalist-interdisciplinarians, especially independent researchers without access to academic libraries or the academic grapevine. Outsiders are seldom invited to academic conferences and symposia designed to bring interested academics up to speed on the work of specialists; they may even lack knowledge of up-to-date search terms through which to filter recent academic literature for material relevant to their work. Accordingly, they may find it more expedient to address conceptual deficiencies and solve problems from scratch than to sift through vast piles of academic literature for what they need.<br>Take mathematics, for example. The scholarly output of the mathematical community has been nothing short of tremendous. This obviously has an upside: mathematicians who are “in the loop” can often find what they need in the prior work of other mathematicians, or at least determine that they’re in virgin territory unexplored by others. But it also has a downside: those who are not in the loop may literally find it easier to discover or rediscover the mathematics they need than to scour the literature for some intelligible indication that somebody else has already written about it, and then decipher and back-engineer the meaning of the complex vocabularies and symbologies employed by previous authors. Personally, I’ve found myself in this position on more than a few occasions.<br>Much the same applies to other fields of science, where it can be even more difficult to solve problems instead of looking up their solutions. So let’s just say that I’ve had my share of challenges along the way…and that I really appreciate the Internet!<br>What are you trying to accomplish with the CTMU?<br>As a general theory of reality — or if one prefers, the general framework of such a theory — the CTMU has potential applications in virtually every field of human inquiry and endeavor.<br>Human knowledge is a veritable Tower of Babel. Various theories of science, mathematics, and philosophy centering on various parts and aspects of reality are couched in diverse formalisms and vocabularies that often bear little resemblance to each other and exhibit no obvious connections. The situation is reminiscent of a disorderly range of mountains; one can get from one valley to another by climbing the mountains, but by the time one gets to the next valley, the last is no longer visible. Worse, the inhabitants speak a different tongue with no discernable connection to the languages spoken in other valleys.<br>Theoretical compartmentalization creates the impression that certain parts or aspects of reality are indefinitely related to each other or not related at all, causing rifts and false divisions to appear in our conceptual and perceptual topography, fracturing and fragmenting our worldview. Sometimes, this leads to scientific crises; for example, relativity theory is seemingly impossible to unite with quantum theory. Some rifts may even be seen as mutual irrelevancies; for example, science and theology are often considered to be separated by an unbridgeable gulf, and thus mutually irrelevant.<br>This is hardly an ideal situation. In a reality where the physical world is held accountable to empirical or mathematical science, any scientifically irrelevant theology is implicitly displaced. This makes theological systems untouchable by science and vice versa, depriving science of moral guidance and encouraging the revelatory creation of different metaphysical realities associated with conflicting promises and instructions involving the physical world. (These metaphysical realities include not just overtly religious frameworks, but the random materialism embraced by many scientists and followers of science.) The resulting disagreements cause, or provide pretexts for, real-world conflicts.<br>In order to unify and make sense of our knowledge, we must have a universal foundational language in which the special-purpose languages of science can be consistently expressed and interpreted. The fact that this foundational language controls the interpretation of physical theories demands that it be metaphysical; it must refer to science “from above”. Yet, in order to do its job, it must also be necessarily true, which requires that it be a mathematically verified ingredient of science.<br>In other words, the required metalanguage is that through which science, including both mathematics and empirical applications of mathematics, becomes self-referential and self-normative…the “bootstrapping” of ordinary mathematical-scientific discourse to a higher verificative level of discourse spanning science in its entirety. This requirement leads directly to the CTMU and SCSPL, exactly as described in this interview and elsewhere.<br>Among the benefits of such a language are these: properly developed and applied, it can synergistically unite the various fields of science; it can remove false conceptual divisions, reconciling science with philosophy and theology, mathematics with physics, and physics with metaphysics; it can promote a general understanding of reality, so that people cannot be so easily cheated of meaning by those wishing to create an illusion of amorphous “relativism” in order to exploit the attending moral vacuum; and it can serve as the basis of an overarching worldview capable of modeling all lesser theories and creeds up to mutual consistency, thereby promoting intellectual accord and conducing to peace and harmony on earth.<br>The classical Laplacian-deterministic worldview is all but dead. As reality is affected by every possible kind of ambiguity, uncertainty, indeterminacy, and undecidability, no theory of reality can ever be complete. In principle, this makes any such theory a permanent work-in-progress in which a very great deal always remains to be done. Exploration must continue.<br>However, a theory of reality can still be comprehensive, classifying knowledge in the large rather than determining it exhaustively. The CTMU already provides a self-contained framework for theorization about reality, represents a pronounced departure from established lines of inquiry, and was ready for prime time even as presented in my 2002 overview The Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe: A New Kind of Reality Theory.<br>Of course, the CTMU doesn’t end with the paper. I do something new to develop and refine it nearly every day, and it all adds up. As a metaphysical (ontological, cosmological, and epistemological) framework, the CTMU has no real competition, and can thus be developed without fear of having to start over from scratch.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9fccb89d26b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The CTMU Theory Claims’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/the-ctmu-theory-claims-e6b3fa19e65a?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6b3fa19e65a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cosmology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Jan 2018 07:12:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-28T07:12:52.130Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Intro: Cosmology, Laws of Physics, the big questions</em></strong></p><p>You know what they say about theories: everybody’s got one. In fact, some people have a theory about pretty much everything. That’s not one Master Theory of Everything, mind you…that’s a separate theory about every little thing under the sun. (To have a Master Theory, you have to be able to tie all those little theories together.)</p><p>That is, the CTMU is as close to “absolute truth” as we will ever be privileged to get along computative or intellectual pathways.-Taken from Resolution to Newcomb’s paradox,</p><p>Of particular interest to natural scientists is the fact that the <strong>laws of nature are a language.</strong> To</p><p>some extent, nature is regular; the basic patterns or general aspects of structure in terms of</p><p>which it is apprehended, whether or not they have been categorically identified, are its “laws”.</p><p>The existence of these laws is given by the stability of perception. Because these <strong>repetitive</strong></p><p><strong>patterns or universal laws</strong> simultaneously describe multiple instances or <strong>states of nature</strong>, they can</p><p>be regarded as <strong>distributed “instructions”</strong> from which <strong>self-instantiations of nature cannot deviate</strong>;</p><p>thus, they form a <strong>“control language”</strong> through which nature regulates its self-instantiations. This</p><p>control language is not of the usual kind, for it is somehow <strong>built into the very fabric of reality</strong> and</p><p>seems to override the known limitations of formal systems. Moreover, it is profoundly reflexive</p><p>and self-contained with respect to configuration, <strong>execution</strong> and <strong>read-write </strong><em>(We will see later that Langan later describes this read-write process that programs and writes the laws of physics and reads them and updates them as they go/evolve is referred to as grammar. The laws of physics will be referred to as grammar by the language of the universe Which will be called SCSPL short for: self-configuring self-processing language.)</em> Operations.-Pg.3</p><p>Only the</p><p>few and the daring have been willing to consider how this might work…to ask where in reality the</p><p>laws might reside, how they might be expressed and implemented, why and how they came to</p><p>be, and how their consistency and universality are maintained. Although these questions are</p><p>clearly of great scientific interest, science alone is logically inadequate to answer them; a new</p><p>explanatory framework is required. This paper describes what the author considers to be the</p><p>most promising framework in the simplest and most direct terms possible.</p><p>Cosmology, humanity’s grand attempt to explain the origin and nature of the universe, has</p><p>traditionally amounted to the search for a set of “ultimate laws” capable of explaining not only how</p><p>the universe currently functions, but how it came to be. Unfortunately, even were such a set of</p><p>laws to be found, the associated explanation could not be considered adequate until the laws</p><p>themselves were explained, along with the fundamental objects and attributes on which they act.</p><p>This gives rise to what seems like an imponderable question: how can a set of laws, objects and</p><p>attributes be explained except by invoking another set of laws in the form of an explanatory</p><p>syntax that would itself demand an explanation, and so on ad infinitum?</p><p>The answer is hiding in the question.</p><p>The <strong>universe “selects itself”</strong> from unbound telesis or UBT, a realm of zero information and</p><p><strong>unlimited ontological</strong> <strong>potential</strong>, by means of <strong>telic recursion</strong>, whereby info-cognitive syntax and its</p><p>Informational content are cross-refined through telic (syntax-state) feedback over the entire range</p><p>Of potential syntax-state relationships, up to and including <strong>all of space-time</strong> and reality in general.-pg.38</p><p>According to the Reality Principle, the universe is self contained, and according to infocognitive</p><p>monism, it regresses to a realm of nil constraint (unbound telesis or UBT) from which it must</p><p>refine itself. According to the <strong>Telic Principle</strong>, which states that the universe must provide itself</p><p>with the means to do this-Pg.42</p><p>In CTMU</p><p>cosmogony, “nothingness” is informationally defined as zero constraint or pure freedom (unbound</p><p>telesis or UBT), and the apparent <strong>construction of the universe</strong> is explained as a self-restriction of</p><p>this potential. In a realm of unbound ontological potential, defining a constraint is not as simple</p><p>as merely writing it down; because constraints act restrictively on content, constraint and content</p><p>must be defined simultaneously in a unified syntax-state relationship.-Pg.27</p><p>Through telic feedback, state and syntax are cross-refined from unbound telesis or UBT, a zeroinformation</p><p>domain of ontological potential, under the guidance of a higher-order law called the</p><p><strong>Telic Principle</strong>…a protean “law without law” through which <strong>order is extracted from disorder</strong> as</p><p><strong>laws are configured</strong> according to the generalized utility of state-syntax relationships <strong>for</strong> agent-level</p><p>operators or <strong>observer-participants</strong>.-Pg.47</p><p><strong><em>How the CTMU is constructed to produce scientific insight</em></strong></p><p>(Relating logic, philosophy to scientific observation)</p><p><strong>Reality theory</strong> is about the stage of attribution in which two predicates analogous to true and</p><p>false, namely real and unreal, are ascribed to various statements about the real universe. In this</p><p>sense, it is closely related to sentential logic.-Pg.13</p><p>That is, <strong>reality theory</strong> must describe reality on a</p><p>level that justifies science, and thus occupies a deeper level of explanation than science itself.-Pg.13</p><p>In fact, the validity of scientific theories and of science as a whole absolutely depends on the</p><p>Existence of a fundamental reality-theoretic framework spanning all of science.-Pg.14</p><p>conceptual framework in which the relationship between mind and matter, cognition and</p><p>information, is made explicit.-Pg.2</p><p>Because of the universal scope of reality theory, it is subject to unique if seldom recognized</p><p>demands; for example, since it is by definition a universal theory of everything that is</p><p>real, it must by definition contain <strong>its rules of real-world interpretation</strong>. That is, reality theory must</p><p><strong>contain its own model</strong> and effect <strong>its own self-interpretative mapping</strong> thereto, and it must conform</p><p>to the implications of this requirement. This “self-modeling” capacity is a primary criterion of the</p><p>required framework.-Pg.4</p><p>In short, two-valued logic is something</p><p>without which reality could not exist. If it were eliminated, then true and false, real and unreal,</p><p>and existence and nonexistence could not be distinguished, and the merest act of perception or</p><p>cognition would be utterly impossible.-Pg.13</p><p>In other words, the means by which the theory is constructed must be</p><p>Rational</p><p>and tautological</p><p>while those by which it is subsequently refined may be <strong>empirical</strong>-Pg.15</p><p>According to the nature of sentential logic, truth is tautologically based on the integrity of cognitive</p><p>and perceptual reality. Cognition and perception comprise the primitive (self-definitive) basis of</p><p>logic, and logic comprises the rules of structure and inference under which perception and</p><p>cognition are stable and coherent. So when we say that truth is heritable under logical rules of</p><p>inference, we really mean that tautology is heritable, and that the primitive cognitive-perceptual</p><p>basis of sentential logic thus maintains its primary status. <strong>By converting tautologies into other</strong></p><p><strong>tautologies,</strong> the rules of inference of sentential logic convert cognitive-perceptual invariants into</p><p>other such invariants. To pursue this agenda in reality theory, we must identify principles that</p><p>describe how the <strong>looping structure of logical tautology is manifest in various reality-theoretic</strong></p><p><strong>settings and contexts on various levels of description and interpretation; that way, we can verify</strong></p><p><strong>its preservation under the operations of theoretic reduction and extension. </strong>We must adjoin</p><p>generalized principles of loop structure to logical syntax in such a way that more and more of</p><p>reality is thereby explained and comprehensiveness is achieved.-pg.14</p><p>nature consists of all that is logically relevant to perception-Pg.19 “Cheating the Millennium by Langan”</p><p>Perception, after all, can be described as the modeling of objective</p><p>reality in cognition, and the modeling of cognition in objective reality. The self-evident perceptual</p><p>stability of reality, on which the existence and efficacy of <strong>science and scientific methodology</strong></p><p><strong>absolutely depend</strong>, bear unshakable testimony to the existence of a <strong>fundamental model</strong> of the</p><p>real universe.-Pg.50</p><p>Does this mean that reality theory is mathematical? Yes, but since mathematics must be justified</p><p>along with science, meta-mathematical would perhaps be a better description… and when all is</p><p>said and done, this comes down to <strong>logic</strong> pure and simple. It follows that reality theory must take</p><p>the form of an <strong>extended logic</strong>…in fact, a “limiting form” of <strong>logic</strong> in which the relationship between</p><p>theory and universe, until now an inexhaustible source of destructive model-theoretic ambiguity, is at last reduced to (dual-aspect) monic form, short-circuiting the paradox of Cartesian dualism</p><p>and eliminating the epistemological gap between mind and matter, theory and universe. -Pg.13</p><p>CTMU is a monic theory of perception that simply eliminates the</p><p>gulf by tautologically injecting logic in its entirety, including logical extensions of model theory and</p><p>the logic of formalized theories, into reality as distributed self-transductive syntax.-Pg.49</p><p>What is now required is thus what has been required all along: a</p><p>conceptual framework in which the relationship between mind and matter, cognition and</p><p>information, is made explicit. This framework must not only permit the completion of the gradual</p><p>ongoing dissolution of the Cartesian mind-matter divider, but the construction of a footworthy</p><p>logical bridge across the resulting explanatory gap.</p><p>It provides exactly what is required in light of any thesis and antithesis: synthesis.</p><p>This synthesis yields a new class of model(s)6</p><p>preserving the best features of both thesis and</p><p>antithesis, continuum and quantum, uniting them through general and preferably self-evident</p><p>principles. This paper presents this new class through a single example, the Cognitive-Theoretic</p><p>Model of the Universe (CTMU). (pg.5 par.1)</p><p>Physics and mathematics are usually viewed not as languages, but as theories. Even though</p><p>they are necessarily expressed in terms of language, they are usually considered “more specific”.</p><p>But like automata, they too meet linguistic criteria. For instance, mathematical theories have</p><p>syntaxes consisting of axioms and rules of inference, and various derived expressions such as</p><p>definitions, theorems and corollaries. More generally, a theory is simply an informational</p><p>construct that plays a direct definitive, descriptive or explanatory role with respect to something</p><p>that needs to be defined, described or explained. <strong>Because theories</strong> consist of recognizable</p><p>strings of symbols taking the form of statements and equations and obey “syntaxes” consisting of</p><p>axioms, principles, hunches or rules of thumb, and in fact share their syntaxes with the objects of</p><p>theorization up to descriptive isomorphism, they are languages.</p><p>Most-Pg.40</p><p>Of all mathematical structures, language is the most general, powerful and</p><p>necessary. Not only is <strong>every formal or working theory of science and mathematics by definition</strong></p><p><strong>a language, but science and mathematics in whole and in sum are languages.</strong> Everything that</p><p>can be described or conceived, including every structure or process or law, is isomorphic to a</p><p>description or definition and therefore qualifies as a language, and every sentient creature</p><p>2</p><p>constantly affirms the linguistic structure of nature by exploiting syntactic isomorphism to</p><p>perceive, conceptualize and refer to it.-Pg.3</p><p>By the Principle of Linguistic Reducibility, reality is a language. Because it is self-contained with</p><p>respect to processing as well as configuration, it is a <strong>“Self-Configuring Self-Processing Language”</strong></p><p>or SCSPL whose general spatiotemporal structure is hologically replicated everywhere within it as</p><p>self-transductive syntax. This reduces the generative phase of reality, including <strong>physical</strong></p><p><strong>cosmogony,</strong> to the <strong>generative grammar</strong> of SCSPL.-Pg.42</p><p><strong>theories begin</strong> with axioms, hypotheses and rules of inference, extract implications, logically or</p><p>empirically test these implications, and then add or revise axioms, theorems or hypotheses. The</p><p><strong>CTMU does the opposite, stripping away assumptions and “rebuilding reality” while adding no assumptions back</strong>.-Pg.15</p><p><strong>Grander implications deeper ramifications</strong></p><p>(What does the CTMU say about what it means to be human?)</p><p>The CTMU resolves many of the most <strong>intractable paradoxes known to physical science</strong> while explaining recent data which indicate that the <strong>universe is expanding at an accelerating rate.</strong> Better yet, it <strong>bestows on human consciousness a level of meaning that was previously approached only by religion and mysticism.</strong> If it passes the test of time — and there are many good reasons to think that it will — then it will be the greatest step that humanity has yet taken towards a real understanding of its most (or least?)</p><p>Timeless mystery.</p><p>But what is that rôle? Where does humanity fit into the scheme even now being revealed to us by science…we, who have lately found ourselves reduced to the wearing of metaphysical sackcloth?</p><p>It turns out we are <strong>microsms, images of the universe within the universe.</strong> And because of the symmetric <strong>connection</strong> between source and image, cosmos and mircrocosm, we function as agents through whom the universe realizes its being.</p><p>We are its children and heirs, poised on the threshold of adulthood and charged with <strong>shaping destiny</strong> itself, with helping the living universe choose its form and content from a background of <strong>undifferentiated potential.</strong> Though eons removed from the moment of creation, we actively retrodcit it, sending the power of our minds back through time to help the Prime Mover, our parent and provider, self-creatively embody the universe we inhabit.</p><p><strong><em>The Fundamentals-</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>[</em>What is everything made of?]</strong></p><p>in this sense, any</p><p>exclusively materialistic interpretation of physical theory is prima facie absurd — and because</p><p>physics is a non-self-explanatory theory regardless of model. To explain organic phenomena</p><p>using natural selection, one needs an explanation for natural selection, including the “natural</p><p>selection” of the laws of physics and the universe as a whole.</p><p>Theoretical reduction involves a regressive unbinding of progressive informational constraints in</p><p>order <strong>to achieve increasingly basic explanations.</strong> Closed theoretical signatures are ripped open</p><p>and reduced to more basic concepts that can be reformed into more basic and expressive</p><p>signatures. However, the informational part of the regress terminates where further reduction</p><p>would compromise <strong>intelligibility</strong>; there can be no further reductive regress through increasingly</p><p>fundamental theoretic strata once the requirements of regression, reduction, theorization and</p><p>stratification have themselves been lost. Beyond this point, infocognition gives way to</p><p>informational and cognitive potential, or <strong>telesis</strong>.-Pg.32–33</p><p>CTMU monism says that the universe consists of one “dual-aspect” substance, <strong>infocognition</strong>, created by internal feedback within an even <strong>more basic</strong> (one-aspect) substance called <strong>telesis.</strong> That everything in the universe can manifest itself as either information or cognition (and on combined scales, as both)-2nd to last para. In Physics and metaphysics paper.</p><p>Whereas ordinary computational models are informational and syntactic in character, the</p><p>protocomputational nature of SCSPL requires a generalization of information and syntax. With</p><p>respect to the origin or ultimate nature of perceptual reality, explanation is a reductive/inductive</p><p>process that regressively unbinds constraints in order to lay bare those of highest priority and</p><p>generality. This process eventually leads to the most basic intelligible descriptor that can be</p><p>formulated, beyond which lies only the unintelligible. This marks the transition from information</p><p>and syntax to a convergent reductive generalization, <strong>telesis</strong>.-Pg.46 (In other words everything is made of Telesis including higgs boson particles)</p><p>The reality-theoretic benefits of this addition</p><p>are incalculable. In conventional physical theory, the fundamental entities are point particles,</p><p>waves and more recently, strings; each class of object has its problems and paradoxes. In the</p><p>CTMU, the <strong>fundamental objects are syntactic operators</strong> (units of self-transducing information or</p><p>infocognition) that are not only capable of emulating all of these objects and more, but of</p><p>containing the syntactic structures to which they must inevitably conform and resolving their</p><p>characteristic paradoxes in the bargain.-Pg.20</p><p><strong>The CTMU-Cosmic and Biological Evolution</strong></p><p>No universe that exists or</p><p>evolves strictly as a function of <strong>external determinacy</strong>, <strong>randomness </strong>or an alternation of the two can</p><p>offer much in the way of meaning. Where <strong>freedom</strong> and <strong>volition</strong> are irrelevant, so is much of</p><p>human experience and individuality.-Pg.5</p><p>SCSPL evolves <strong>by telic recursion</strong>, jointly configuring syntax and state while maximizing a generalized selfselection</p><p>parameter and adjusting <strong>on the fly to Freely-Changing</strong> internal conditions.</p><p>the informational boundary of <strong>a</strong></p><p><strong>coherent object</strong> (syntactic operator) is <strong>hologically multiplexed</strong> with respect <strong>to state</strong> (attribute and</p><p>value) in order to define the <strong>descriptive interior of the operator</strong> as it participates in global <strong>selfprocessing</strong></p><p>without input. This <strong>multiplexing</strong> of possibilities is just the replication of the structure of</p><p>the boundary over the interior of the boundary as a function of time.</p><p>CTMU, which says that the universe and everything in it ultimately</p><p>evolves by <strong>self-multiplexing</strong> and <strong>self-selection</strong>. In the CTMU, design and selection, generative</p><p>and restrictive sides of the same coin, are dual concepts associated with the alternating stages of</p><p>conspansion. The self-selection of reality is inextricably coupled to self-design, <strong>and it is this two phase</strong></p><p><strong>process that results in nature.</strong> Biological evolution is simply a reflection of the evolution of</p><p>reality itself, a <strong>process of telic recursion</strong> mirroring that of the <strong>universe as a whole.</strong> Thus, when</p><p>computations of evolutionary probability are regressively extrapolated to the distributed instant of</p><p>creation, they inevitably arrive at a logical and therefore meaningful foundation.-Pg.51</p><p>This alternation, which</p><p>permits localized mutual refinements of cognitive syntax and informational state, is essential to an</p><p><strong>evolutionary process</strong> called <strong>telic recursion</strong>-Pg.30</p><p>and reality is a tautological self-interpretative process</p><p>evolving through SCSPL grammar.-pg.50</p><p>The Telic Principle is responsible for</p><p>converting <strong>potential</strong> to <strong>actuality</strong> in such a way as to maximize a universal self-selection</p><p>parameter, generalized utility-Pg.37</p><p>It asserts that the meta-cybernetic mechanism of evolution is <strong>telic recursion</strong>, an</p><p>atemporal process which sets up a stratified dialectic between syntax and state, <strong>organism and</strong></p><p><strong>51</strong></p><p><strong>environment,</strong> with mutually consistent mutable and invariant levels. It says that this process,</p><p>though subject to various forms of noise, interference and competition predicated on the internal</p><p>freedom of reality, <strong>tends to maximize the utility of the universe and its inhabitants.</strong> And it thus</p><p>says that evolution is much more than a mere environmental dictatorship in which inexplicable</p><p>laws of nature call the tune as biology slavishly dances the jig of life and death.</p><p>describing the</p><p>universe as an intelligently self-designed, self-organizing system.-Pg.2</p><p>telic recursion is integral to the cosmic, teleo-biological</p><p>and volitional levels of evolution.-Pg.37</p><p>Where space and time respectively</p><p>correspond to information and a combination of generalized cognition and telic recursion, one</p><p>may therefore conclude that the conspansive evolution of spacetime is an alternation of teleocognitive</p><p>and informational phases cross-refined by <strong>telic recursion</strong> involving extended, transMarkovian</p><p>telonic relationships.-Pg.46</p><p>Biological evolution is simply a reflection of the evolution of</p><p>reality itself, a process of <strong>telic recursion</strong> mirroring that of the universe as a whole.-Pg.51</p><p>The CTMU has a meta-Darwinian message: the universe evolves by hological self-replication and</p><p>self-selection.-pg.50</p><p>In effect, the universe becomes a “selfsimulation”</p><p>Running inside its own contents.-pg.42</p><p>It is by virtue of telic recursion that the SCSPL universe</p><p>Can be described as its own self-simulative, self-actualizative “quantum protocomputer”.-pg.36</p><p>The CTMU says that by its self-generative, self-selective nature, which follows directly from the</p><p>Analytic requirement of self-containment, <strong>reality is its own “designer”</strong>.-Pg.52</p><p>something called <strong>conspansive</strong></p><p><strong>duality,</strong> objects can be “dualized” to spatiotemporal transducers, and the physical universe</p><p>internally “simulated” by its material contents.-Pg.25</p><p>Conspansion permits the</p><p>universe to self-configure through temporal feedback.-Pg.30</p><p>This amounts to self-generative freedom, hologically providing reality</p><p>with a <strong>“self-simulative scratchpad”</strong> on which to compare the aggregate utility of multiple self configurations</p><p>for self-optimizative purposes.-Pg.36</p><p>The CTMU says that reality is a language…a self-explanatory, self-theorizing, self-modeling</p><p>structure identical to its universe.-Pg.49</p><p>on the level of cognitive-perceptual syntax,</p><p>reality equals reality theory-pg.19</p><p>The Principle of Linguistic Reducibility merely clarifies the issue of whether</p><p>reality is a linguistic predicate or the objective content of such a predicate by asserting that it is</p><p>both. –pg.19</p><p>13</p><p>is at last reduced to (dual-aspect) monic form, short-circuiting the paradox of Cartesian dualism</p><p>and eliminating the epistemological gap between mind and matter, theory and universe.-pg.13-</p><p>SCSPL evolves by <strong>telic recursion</strong>, jointly configuring syntax and state while maximizing a generalized selfselection</p><p>parameter and <strong>adjusting on the fly to freely-changing internal conditions.</strong> SCSPL relates space,</p><p>time and object by means of conspansive duality and conspansion, an SCSPL-grammatical process</p><p>featuring an alternation between dual phases of existence associated with design and actualization and</p><p>related to the familiar <strong>wave-particle duality of quantum mechanics</strong>. By distributing the design phase of</p><p>reality over the actualization phase, conspansive spacetime also provides a distributed mechanism for</p><p><strong>Intelligent Design</strong>, adjoining to the restrictive principle of <strong>natural selection a basic means of generating</strong></p><p><strong>information and complexity.</strong> Addressing physical evolution on not only the biological but <strong>cosmic</strong> level,</p><p>the</p><p>CTMU addresses the most evident deficiencies and paradoxes associated with conventional discrete and</p><p>continuum models of reality, including temporal directionality and accelerating cosmic expansion, while</p><p>preserving virtually all of the major benefits of current scientific and mathematical paradigms.-Pg.1 Abstract</p><p>conspansion holds the size of the universe changeless and endomorphically changes the</p><p>sizes of objects. Because the universe now plays the role of invariant, there exists a global</p><p>standard rate of inner expansion or mutual absorption among the contents of the universe (“cinvariance”),</p><p>and due to syntactic covariance, objects must be resized or “requantized” with each</p><p>new event according to a constant (time-independent) rescaling factor residing in global syntax.-Pg.30</p><p><strong><em>Time</em></strong></p><p>Thus, time is not “fed into” the explanation of existence, but is a function of</p><p>conspansive, telic-recursive SCSPL grammar.-pg48</p><p>The bidirectionality of time implies that the universe is in a state of extended spatiotemporal self-superposition, each of its serial configurations, as defined at each successive moment</p><p>of time, <strong>in contact with all others.</strong> At first glance, this seems to imply that the universe is completely determined…that as Laplace believed, every state of the universe is implicit in any</p><p>state. But not only is such an assumption unnecessary, it would ultimately lead to intractable inconsistencies. In fact, the logical structure of spacetime provides the universe with</p><p>the wherewithal of being, endowing it with self-creative freedom and permitting it to rise from <strong>a sea of</strong></p><p><strong>undifferentiated ontological potential.</strong>-Pg.81 Art of Knowing by Langan</p><p>On the other hand, the conspansive nesting of atemporal events <strong>puts all of time in</strong></p><p><strong>“simultaneous self-contact”</strong> without compromising ordinality. Conspansive duality can be viewed</p><p>as the consequence of a type of gauge (measure) symmetry by which only the relative</p><p>dimensions of the universe and its contents are important.-Pg.30</p><p>Extended superposition “atemporally” distributes antecedent events over consequent events, thus</p><p><strong>putting spacetime in temporally-extended self-contact.</strong> In light of the Telic Principle (see below), this scenario</p><p>involves a <strong>new interpretation of quantum theory</strong>, sum over futures. Sum over futures involves an atemporal</p><p>generalization of “process”, telic recursion, through which the universe effects on-the-fly maximization of a global</p><p>self-selection parameter, generalized utility-Pg.28</p><p>The superposition principle, like other aspects of quantum mechanics, is based on the</p><p>assumption of physical Markovianism.</p><p>40 It refers to mixed states between adjacent events,</p><p>ignoring the possibility of nonrandom temporally-extensive relationships not wholly attributable to</p><p>distributed laws. By<strong> putting temporally remote events in extended descriptive contact with each</strong></p><p><strong>other</strong>, the Extended Superposition Principle enables <strong>coherent cross-temporal telic feedback</strong> and</p><p>thus plays a necessary role in cosmic self-configuration. Among the higher-order determinant</p><p>relationships in which events and objects can thus be implicated are utile state-syntax</p><p>relationships called telons(telons in the CTMU are human beings), telic attractors capable of guiding cosmic and biological evolution-Pg.31</p><p><strong><em>The 3M’s</em></strong></p><p>The following <strong>principles</strong> are presented in three stages. The first stage includes the Reality</p><p>Principle, the Principle of Linguistic Reducibility and the <strong>Principle of Syndiffeonesis</strong>, which may be</p><p>considered <strong>preliminary</strong> to <strong>MAP, M=R</strong> and <strong>MU</strong> respectively (the order of presentation may differ</p><p>slightly from that just given). The second stage consists of <strong>MAP</strong>, <strong>M=R</strong> and <strong>MU</strong> themselves, while</p><p>the third stage consists of <strong>several auxiliary principles</strong> that can be viewed <strong>as their consequences</strong>.-Pg.15</p><p>{{{ reality is a syndiffeonic relation.-pg.16</p><p>The M=R principle, a tautological theoretical property that dissolves the distinction between</p><p>theory and universe and thus identifies the real universe as a “self-reifying theory”-Pg.15</p><p>reality is a self-resolving paradox.-pg.24</p><p>reality is more than just a linguistic self-contained syndiffeonic relation</p><p>comprising a closed descriptive manifold of linked definitions containing the means of its own</p><p>configuration, composition, attribution, recognition, processing and interpretation. It is also a self processing</p><p>theory identical to its universe. –pg.23</p><p>{, reality comprises a “closed</p><p>descriptive manifold” from which no essential predicate is omitted, and which thus contains no</p><p>critical gap that leaves any essential aspect of structure unexplained[In other words this MAP principle or axiom in the CTMU says everything in the universe is explained by its composition or what it’s made of and that we can know everything in the universe]. Any such gap would imply</p><p>non-closure-Pg.20</p><p>Another way to state this is that</p><p><strong>MAP</strong>, like the Reality Principle, requires that everything to which any reality-theoretic definition,</p><p>description, explanation or interpretation refers be located within reality.-Pg.20}-the Map principle;</p><p>The M=R Principle entails comprehensivity by defining all of our perceptions, along with</p><p>their syntax-level cognitive-syntactic infrastructure, as parts of reality regardless of decidability.-Pg.22</p><p>Through its structure, the</p><p>universe and its contents are mutually inclusive, providing each other with a medium.-Pg.23-<strong>Hology Principle</strong></p><p><strong>The hology property itself is distributed over reality.-Pg.25</strong></p><p>MU serves as a unifying concept for a complex of ideas having to do with coherence and</p><p>consistency in the reality-theoretic context, including hology and several CTMU duality principles.-Pg.24</p><p>the overall structure of the universe is</p><p>everywhere distributed within it as accepting and transductive syntax, resulting in a homogeneous</p><p>syntactic medium.-Pg.-Pg.24</p><p>The universe topologically contains that which descriptively contains the universe. <strong>MU, the</strong></p><p><strong>minimum and most general informational configuration of reality</strong>, defines the relationship holding</p><p>between unity and multiplicity, the universe and its variegated contents. Through its structure, the</p><p>universe and its contents are mutually inclusive, providing each other with a medium.-Pg.23}}}</p><p>After all, since information does nothing but attribute linguistically organized</p><p>predicates to objects in the context of models, its meaning involves the mathematics of</p><p>34</p><p>predicates, languages and models. And third, it must be generalized to an ultimate ancestral</p><p>medium, telesis, from which cognitive syntax and its informational content arise by specificative</p><p>feedback as part of a unified complex…a recursive coupling of information and metainformation,</p><p>or transductive syntax.-Pg.34–35</p><p>Due to the self-configurative freedom inherited by reality from UBT, the dynamically</p><p>self-configuring universe displays uncertainty and complementarity and thus cannot be locked</p><p>into locally-determinate answers for all possible questions at once-Pg.48</p><p>In any case, since the theory we are describing in this paper is</p><p>designed to address reality in its <strong>most basic form</strong>, and <strong>thus to address all conceivable realities as</strong></p><p><strong>its possible instantiations</strong>(In other words the concepts and processes explained in this paper would apply to all other existing universes or dimensions of existence. For instance everything would still be made of Telesis)<strong>,</strong> it supersedes any explanation afforded by MW alone.-Pg.54</p><p>For example, to physically realize the informational structure of a</p><p>language in a printed or electronic medium, it must be expressed in terms of physical particles</p><p>that dynamically recognize each other’s locations to the extent required to maintain the spatial</p><p>relationships comprising its informational structure. This is a general requirement, extending from</p><p>the physical and concrete to the mathematical and abstract.-This would apply to all universes and all physical particles necessary. For their to be particles at all to be individual separate ones that make up matter to exist as separate point particle entities the fundamental requirement are that for instance for all atoms they have to as it just said from what I quoted above which is from the CTMU “must be expressed in terms of physical particles</p><p>that dynamically recognize each other’s locations to the extent required to maintain the spatial</p><p>relationships comprising its informational structure. So for particles to exist and work and make sense to make up matter as it does they must each atom or subatomic particle such as a higgs boson or proton or electron must exist this way among each other recognizing each other’s locations to the extent required to maintain the spatial relationships comprising its informational structure. To state it in as simple a way as possible, reality must ultimately possess a stable 2-valued object-level distinction between that which it is and that which it is not, maintaining the necessary informational boundaries between objects, attributes and events. The existence of closed informational boundaries within a system is ultimately possible only by virtue of systemic closure under dualistic (explanansexplanandum) composition. So one atom to exist as a separate individual point particle must exist among the other particles to recognizing the other atom’s location to the extent to maintain the spatial relationship or distance that separates each atom from one another to define each particle as its own atom or proton. They have to have separation and recognize the other one to the extent or the other location of the particle required to maintain the space between them that comprises its informational boundaries that separates the particle or defines what it is from the space around it or particle it isn’t. This is as absolute fact and abstract concept that has to always apply to all of existence. Which is what the CTMU is properties of certainty that can apply to everything including emotions etc. But to enhance this example another CTMU definition came to me which is something is defined all matter or anything at all has to have its definition that separates its boundaries from what it isn’t or from everything else to exist as its own unique entity. Such a boundary would be an information construct. In the CTMU this is defined as: That is, the informational boundary of a coherent object (syntactic operator) is hologically multiplexed with respect to state (attribute and value) in order to define the descriptive interior of the operator as it participates in global self processing without input. This multiplexing of possibilities is just the replication of the structure of the boundary over the interior of the boundary as a function of time. Again, the operator ultimately has nothing else in terms of which to express its spatiotemporal capacity. -Composition say of a particle of matter or an atom. That’s the way an atom and all elementary particles are defined with closed information boundaries to the extent that they all recognize the distance and space or spatial relationship between each particle of matter and has to be for anything of matter to be defined in all universes. That’s why in that phrase of describing particles he says: “physical particles</p><p>that dynamically recognize each other’s locations to the extent required to maintain the spatial</p><p>relationships comprising its informational structure”.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6b3fa19e65a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“CTMU-Cognitive Theoretic Model of the Universe”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/ctmu-cognitive-theoretic-model-of-the-universe-1eee2ad8cf96?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1eee2ad8cf96</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theory-of-everything]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Jan 2018 22:53:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-27T22:53:56.262Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What is the CTMU even? What is the theory? (<em>Physics Included</em>)</p><p><strong>The Greatest Theory of all Time</strong></p><p>In My own words in one sentence condensed “The CTMU is a Theory of the universe or not only equivalent but also surpasses what physicists would call the grand unified theory and is actually a comprehensive description of the entire universe showing that the universe is and behaves like a mind that contains physical matter, and capable of describing all of reality and anything that can ever exist, and specific to physics shows that as evolution is true and a fact that the human race can collectively evolve into beings who can all communicate telepathically with one another and understand each other instantly and control reality and physically what’s outside of us with the power of our minds and that we participate in the self-creation of reality; also showing the heights of what is all physically possible and the limits and capacity of human knowledge and furthermore it does this lastly though not everything and all informational content in the universe can be known ever at once”-That’s it in one sentence in my own definition of what the theory is. The idea that not everything in the universe can be known at once is taken from his 56 page paper here: “Due to the self-configurative freedom inherited by reality from UBT, the dynamically</p><p>Self-configuring universe displays uncertainty and complementarity and thus cannot be locked</p><p>Into locally-determinate answers for all possible questions at once.”-Pg.48</p><p>And the idea that we play a role in the creation of reality and can control physical matter and what comes out of the universe by the creative power of our minds is also hinted at in that paper here: “This amounts to self-generative freedom, hologically providing reality</p><p>with a “self-simulative scratchpad” on which to compare the aggregate utility of multiple selfconfigurations</p><p>for self-optimizative purposes.”-Pg.36 And “In particular, the Extended</p><p>Superposition Principle, a property of conspansive spacetime that coherently relates widelyseparated</p><p>events, lets the universe “retrodict” itself through meaningful cross-temporal feedback.</p><p>Moreover, in order to function as a selection principle, it generates a generalized global selection</p><p>parameter analogous to “self-utility”, which it then seeks to maximize in light of the evolutionary</p><p>freedom of the cosmos as expressed through localized telic subsystems which mirror the overall</p><p>system in seeking to maximize (local) utility.”-Pg.38-To add to the quote here and cross relate what Langan writes to prove its consist and clarify what he means this is taken from another work of his the most basic explaining his theory the Art of Knowing about that widely separated events lets the universe retrodicts itself and is expressed through localized telic subsystems which is us <strong>“Though eons</strong></p><p><strong>removed from the moment of creation, we actively retrodict</strong></p><p><strong>it, sending the power of our minds back through time to</strong></p><p><strong>help the Prime Mover, our parent and provider, self-</strong></p><p><strong>83</strong></p><p><strong>creatively embody the universe we inhabit.”-Pg. 82–83</strong></p><p>“That is, where universal laws are syntactic and the</p><p>initial mass-energy distribution is the initial state of spacetime, secondary transitions are derived</p><p>from the initial state by rules of syntax, including the laws of physics, plus telic recursion. The</p><p>primary stage is associated with the global telor, reality as a whole; the secondary stage, with</p><p>internal telors (“agent-level” observer-participants). Because there is a sense in which primary</p><p>and secondary telic recursion can be regarded as “simultaneous”, local telors can be said to</p><p>constantly “create the universe” by channeling and actualizing generalized utility within it.”-Pg.36 Where telors are “The</p><p>primary stage is associated with the global telor, reality as a whole; the secondary stage, with</p><p>internal telors (“agent-level” observer-participants).”-Pg.36 So in other words Telors is human beings or us. We are also localized telic subsystems. We can use our minds to channel what comes into the creation of the universe with our wills. Imagine what this says about using our wills to increase intelligence.</p><p>Someone just requested a 30-word description of the CTMU.</p><p>“The CTMU is a supertautological (ontologically closed) metaphysical theory of reality which is everywhere its universe and model, embedding physical reality as the l-ectomorphic limit of a conspansive SCSPL manifold.” (That’s 30 words. Of course, you’d need at least 15 technical definitions to understand it, and those definitions would then require expansions of their own.)</p><p>Here’s another of only 10 words: “The CTMU is the general theory of identification and intelligibility.”</p><p>Here’s an 8-word description: “The CTMU is a metaphysical formulation of logic.”</p><p>Here’s a 2-word description: “Ultimate Reality”.</p><p>We even have a one-word description, which one needs only the New Testament to understand: “Logos” (interpreted in light of John 1:1 as a synonym of “the Word”: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.”)</p><p>It would not be an exaggeration to say that the CTMU is the deepest, broadest, and most valuable theory ever conceived … and with all due respect, this is not debatable.</p><p>The major shortcoming of philosophy is that it has been arrogated by Academia, Inc., which functions like an intellectual trade union / pyramidal growth economy / Ponzi-style credentialization scam with membership standards irrelevant to the content of philosophy and for that matter intellectual merit. Because Academia has been corporatized and therefore tightly standardized, and because its socialization and indoctrination functions have come to outweigh its traditional education function, it now enforces a rigid philosophical narrative based on PC doctrine. This kind of ideological standardization is diametrically opposed to free intellectual inquiry and intellectual balance and integrity. As a result, the phrase “modern philosopher” is now all but oxymoronic. The typical modern philosopher, or at least one who commands recognition as such, is a professional academic who cannot think independently, who lives in abject fear of losing his/her job for deviating from institutional orthodoxy (or saying boo to an administrator), and who wouldn’t know a worthwhile philosophical framework if it crashed the stage on live television, bit him on the nose, and yanked his undies down around his knees. This is why physicists and other scientists have been eating philosophy’s lunch for the last few decades with total impunity, “bitch-slapping” the discipline around the block virtually at will.</p><p>I agree with the idea, more or less stated in another comment, that being smart and having a high IQ are not necessarily equivalent properties. But this makes judging intelligence all the more difficult. To be judged extraordinarily intelligent, one must communicate extraordinary thoughts to those doing the judging. But this raises a vexing issue: as any really intelligent person knows, communication is always a two-way street. This is not only because communication consists of at least two people exchanging information, but because each must understand what the other is saying. Unfortunately, extraordinary thoughts are often extraordinarily hard for most people to understand.</p><p>As relatively few people properly understand the CTMU, it is occasionally subject to erroneous opinionation. For example, it is not self-contradictory as claimed in this Q&amp;A, but uniquely consistent … provably so, in fact. And at this point, perhaps the main reason — aside from bias and obstinacy — that its critics don’t better understand it is that the modern system of intellectual communication and commerce dominated by Academia, Inc. has been completely walled off from those who lack the academic stamp of approval (to which, if the truth be told, any reasonable concept of intellectual excellence is increasingly irrelevant). It’s a circular enterprise, a corrupt intellectual trade union that would make the Mafia blush. I can’t even post a paper to arXiv — one needs an institutional affiliation for that! (So much for the alleged neutrality and infallibility of “peer review”.)</p><p>Just to dispel any remaining confusion, the CTMU is absolutely serious. Furthermore, it is incontrovertible. What do I mean by that? I mean that if anyone were to gather the “best” philosophers, theologians, mathematicians, and physicists from the “best” universities in the world, they couldn’t put a dent in it even if those criticizing it here were helping them. They could, and would, be squashed like bugs, as publicly as one might like. If no one else were able or disposed to perform this service, I could easily handle it myself. The most with which they could get away would be an admission that the theory is unclear to them, or that they don’t find it “mathematical enough”. But in fact, the CTMU is a theory of metaphysics that is based entirely on mathematics, albeit of kinds that are not taught to most students in these fields.</p><p>Although some have maintained that the CTMU is “information-free” despite the mathematics that it obviously contains, the real truth is that they are personally incapable of registering the level of information that the CTMU conveys. For this, I can take no more than partial responsibility.</p><p>If you haven’t read it yet, Chris gives a great definition of the CTMU in his Super Scholar interview:</p><p>“Can you sketch the CTMU — in plain English — for our readers?”</p><p>“The name literally says it all. The phrase ‘Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe’ contains three main ingredients: cognitive-theory, model, and universe. Cognitive theory refers to a general language of cognition (the structural and transitional rules of cognition); universe refers to the content of that language, or that to which the language refers; and model refers to the mapping which carries the content into the language, thus creating information. The way in which the title brings these three ingredients together, or ‘contracts’ their relationship to the point of merging, reflects their perfect coincidence in that to which the title implicitly refers, i.e., reality (the physical universe plus all that is required to support its perception and existence). Thus, the CTMU is a theory which says that reality is a self-modeling universal language, or if one prefers, that the universe is a self-modeling language.</p><p>The operation of combining language, universe, and model to create a perfectly self-contained metalanguage results in SCSPL, short for Self-Configuring Self-Processing Language. This language is ‘self-similar’ in the sense that it is generated within a formal identity to which every part of it is mapped as content; its initial form, or grammatical ‘start symbol’, everywhere describes it on all scales. My use of grammatical terminology is intentional; in the CTMU, the conventional notion of physical causality is superseded by ‘telic causation’, which resembles generative grammar and approaches teleology as a natural limit. In telic causation, ordinary events are predicated on the generation of closed causal loops distributing over time and space. This loop-structure reflects the fact that time, and the spatial expansion of the cosmos as a function of time, flow in both directions — forward and backward, outward and inward — in a dual formulation of causality characterizing a new conceptualization of nature embodied in a new kind of medium or ‘manifold’.</p><p>That’s as simple as I can make it without getting more technical. Everything was transparently explained in the 56-page 2002 paper I published on the CTMU, which has been downloaded hundreds of thousands of times. But just in case this still doesn’t qualify as ‘plain English’, there’s an even easier way to understand it that is available to any reader familiar with the Bible, one of the most widely-read and best-understood books ever written.</p><p>In the New Testament, John 1 begins as follows: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was *with* God, and the Word *was* God” (my italics). Much controversy has been centered on this passage, as it seems to be saying that God is literally equivalent to logos, meaning ‘word’, ‘wisdom’, ‘reason’, or ‘truth’. Insofar as these meanings all refer to constructs or ingredients of language or to language itself, this amounts to the seemingly imponderable assertion that God, of Whom believers usually conceive as an all-powerful entity or Being, somehow consists of language. The CTMU is precisely what it takes to validate this assertion while preserving the intuitive conception of God as the all-knowing Creator — or in non-theological terms, the ‘identity’ or ‘generator’ — of reality. Nothing but the CTMU can fully express this biblical ‘word-being duality’ in a logico-mathematical setting.</p><p>The CTMU is not just a theory; it is logical model theory applied to metaphysics, and as much a logical necessity as any branch of mathematics or philosophy. One can no more escape from it than X=X or 1+1=2. But when it comes to something that packs this combination of scope and power, many people, including certified academics, committed atheists, and even some religious believers, are afraid to stare X=X in the face.</p><p>Little wonder. After all, once one has beheld the metaphysical structure of reality, there is no longer any such thing as plausible deniability or defense by ignorance; it’s the end of innocence, so to speak. Understandably, many people find that a little scary.”</p><p><a href="http://superscholar.org/intervi%E2%80%A6/christopher-michael-langan/">http://superscholar.org/intervi…/christopher-michael-langan/</a></p><p>Happy New Year, everyone! (There will be a new CTMU paper in the same journal that published the last one, by the way — I’m not yet sure when that will be. This one is very accessible, applying the CTMU to religion and social theory.)</p><p>“According to Chris Jesus did exist and was the perfect example of how one should live their life. Jesus was every bit as real according to Chris. Its just that today’s messenger is Chris Langan with the knowledge we need in western philosophy and society’s age.”</p><p>I’ve explained my position on Jesus on several occasions. In keeping with his spiritual functionality, Jesus was / is real on a higher level of being than that occupied by an ordinary human.</p><p>While the message brought by Jesus was as advanced as it could be for those to whom it was imparted, a more advanced version of this message is now required (this much is obvious from the fact that Christianity is under withering global attack and is disintegrating as a result). This more advanced spiritual message is called the CTMU. The result of its delivery will be either a new beginning or an eternal abruption, depending on the free choice of humankind. That’s it. (Don’t like it? Tough smash; it is what it is, and I’m fresh out of apologies.)</p><p>As for how I fit into the picture, it’s like this. Owing to the fact that the CTMU arrives as a function of the destiny of its messenger, I cannot be separated from it; the message and the messenger are entwined. (I’ve previously defined “destiny” right here, so I shouldn’t have to repeat myself.) But I’ve never requested special treatment or consideration on this account, and I certainly haven’t received much for my trouble. As for me, I am what I am; as for you, it’s all about your personal relationship with God Almighty.</p><p>Regarding this “Alexa” construct, its programming is par for the course given the anti-Christian atheist-materialist leanings of our precious techie billionaires, who get vastly more credit for brainpower than even the best of them deserves. What a bunch of troublesome and contentious little dunces they are!</p><p>Thanks for your attention, and I hope that everyone has a great evening.</p><p>In other words, a comprehensive theory of reality is not just about observation, but about theories and their logical requirements. Since theories are mental constructs, and mental means “of the mind”, this can be rephrased as follows: mind and reality are linked in mutual dependence at the most basic level of understanding. This linkage of mind and reality is what a TOE (Theory of Everything) is really about. The CTMU is such a theory; instead of being a mathematical description of specific observations (like all established scientific theories), it is a “metatheory” about the general relationship between theories and observations…i.e., about science or knowledge itself. Thus, it can credibly lay claim to the title of TOE.</p><p>Mind and reality — the abstract and the concrete, the subjective and the objective, the internal and the external — are linked together in a certain way, and this linkage is the real substance of “reality theory”. Just as scientific observation determines theories, the logical requirements of theories to some extent determine scientific observation. Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty, and this means that a comprehensive theory of reality cannot be based on scientific observation alone. Instead, it must be based on the process of making scientific observations in general, and this process is based on the relationship of mind and reality. So the CTMU is essentially a theory of the relationship between mind and reality.</p><p>In explaining this relationship, the CTMU shows that reality possesses a complex property akin to self-awareness. That is, just as the mind is real, reality is in some respects like a mind. But when we attempt to answer the obvious question “whose mind?”, the answer turns out to be a mathematical and scientific definition of God.</p><p>..a couple of questions about the CTMU:</p><p>Christopher Michael Langan said in his introduction following: “Thus, if D(S) contains supraphysical components, they are embedded in S right along with their physical counterparts (indeed, this convention is already in restricted use in string theory and M-theory, where unseen higher dimensions get “rolled up” to sub-Planck diameter).”</p><p>If I understood it right, the supraphysical component in string- and M-theory is called supraphysical, because the model does not assume it to be part of the physical universe. Taking on that thought and considering the definition of the REAL UNIVERSE in the CTMU I have to doubt that the supraphysical component is even part of the REAL universe. Does anyone know where my mistake in thought lies?</p><p>A: As noted by Berkeley, we can know reality only through perception. So our theories of reality necessarily have a perceptual or observational basis. But as noted by Kant, the process of observation has substantial internal complexity; it is a relationship of subject and object with sensory (phenomenal) and cognitive (categorical) components. So reality is at once monic, because uniformly perceptual, and dualistic, because perception has two complementary aspects. Thus, the “dual aspect monism” of the CTMU. Now consider physics. Because physics is governed by the scientific method, it deals exclusively with phenomena. Thus, it effectively diverts attention away from the cognitive, categorical aspect of perceptual reality, without which neither phenomena nor scientific theories could exist. Because physics is irreducibly dualistic and takes the fundamental separation of mind and matter as axiomatic, it cannot provide us with a complete picture of reality. It can tell us only what lies outside the subjective observer, not within.</p><p>By definition, reality must contain all that it needs to exist; equivalently, anything on which the existence of reality depends is real by definition (if it were not, then reality would be based on nonreality and would itself be unreal, a semantic contradiction). So attempts to explain reality entirely in terms of physics are paradoxical; reality contains not only the physical, but the abstract machinery of perception and cognition through which “the physical” is perceived and explained. Where this abstract machinery is what we mean by “the supraphysical”, reality has physical and supraphysical aspects. Physical and supraphysical reality are respectively “concrete” and “abstract”, i.e. material and mental in nature.</p><p>The question is, do we continue to try to objectivize the supraphysical component of reality as do the theories of physics, strings and membranes, thus regenerating the paradox? Or do we take the CTMU approach and resolve the paradox, admitting that the supraphysical aspect of reality is “mental” in a generalized sense and describing all components of reality in terms of SCSPL syntactic operators with subjective and objective aspects?</p><p>My advice: we take the CTMU approach, relegating the scientific method to the phenomenal side of reality theory — after all, M-theory is beyond the empirical scope of the scientific method already — and recognizing that the universe is everywhere both subjective and objective, rational and empirical, mental and material. Anything else would lead to reductio ad absurdum.</p><p>If I have interpreted you correctly, you maintain that the universe created itself. How did this come about? What existed before the Universe and when did the Universe create itself or come into being? — Celia Joslyn</p><p>A: You’re asking three distinct but related questions about cosmology: how, when and as what did the universe self-create?</p><p>The universe can be described as a cybernetic system in which freedom and constraint are counterbalanced. The constraints function as structure; thus, the laws of physics are constraints which define the structure of spacetime, whereas freedom is that which is bound or logically quantified by the constraints in question. Now, since there is no real time scale external to reality, there is no extrinsic point in time at which the moment of creation can be located, and this invalidates phrases like “before reality existed” and “when reality created itself”. So rather than asking “when” the universe came to be, or what existed “before” the universe was born, we must instead ask “what would remain if the structural constraints defining the real universe were regressively suspended?” First, time would gradually disappear, eliminating the “when” question entirely. And once time disappears completely, what remains is the answer to the “what” question: a realm of boundless potential characterized by a total lack of real constraint. In other words, the real universe timelessly emerges from a background of logically unquantified potential to which the concepts of space and time simply do not apply.</p><p>Now let’s attend to your “how” question. Within a realm of unbound potential like the one from which the universe emerges, everything is possible, and this implies that “everything exists” in the sense of possibility. Some possibilities are self-inconsistent and therefore ontological dead ends; they extinguish themselves in the very attempt to emerge into actuality. But other possibilities are self-consistent and potentially self-configuring by internally defined evolutionary processes. That is, they predicate their own emergence according to their own internal logics, providing their own means and answering their own “hows”. These possibilities, which are completely self-contained not only with respect to how, what, and when, but why, have a common structure called SCSPL (Self-Configuring Self-Processing Language). An SCSPL answers its own “why?” question with something called teleology; where SCSPL is “God” to whatever exists within it, teleology amounts to the “Will of God”.</p><p>Einstein says that gravity is a result of “mass-energy” causing a curvature in the four dimensional space time continuum. At the planck scale, (10^(-33)) centimeters, is space still continuous?, or is space discontinuous? I have read books saying space time may have holes or breaks in continuity. Are these holes related in any way to “gravitons”, or reverse time causality? (Question from Russell Rierson)</p><p>A: A mathematical space is continuous if it has a metric that withstands infinitesimal subdivision. To understand what this means, one must know what a “metric” is. Simplistically, a metric is just a general “distance” relationship defined on a space as follows: if a and b are two points in a space, and c is an arbitrary third point, then the distance between a and b is always less than or equal to the sum of the distances between a and c, and b and c. That is, where d(x,y) is the distance between two points x and y,</p><p>d(a,b) &lt;= d(a,c) + d(b,c).</p><p>If this relationship continues to hold no matter how close together the points a, b and c might be, then the space is continuous. On the other hand, where the distance concept is undefined below a certain threshold, metric continuity breaks down on that scale. Since the Planck limit is such a threshold, space is discontinuous below the Planck scale…implying, of course, that it is discontinuous, period. Not only is it “granular” in a slippery kind of way, but the grains in question are effectively without spatial extent.</p><p>Because space and time are undefined below quantum limits, they no longer have extensionality or directionality. But if we interpret this to mean that anything, including causality, can “flow” in any direction whatsoever, then reverse causality is conceivable on sub-Planck scales. In fact, some theorists conjecture that on these scales, continuous spacetime becomes a chaotic “quantum foam” in which distant parts of the universe are randomly connected by microscopic “wormholes”. That’s pretty much the party line among physicists.</p><p>Now let’s bring philosophy to bear on the issue. At one time, space was considered to consist of “ether”, a quasimaterial “substance” through which physical objects were thought to swim like fish through water. But since the introduction of Einstein’s Theory of Relativity, nothing material remains of empty space; although it is permeated by fields and “vacuum energy”, these are merely contained by space and are not equivalent to space itself. Space has instead become a mathematical abstraction called a “tensor field” that confers relative attributes like location, direction, orientation, distance, linear and angular velocity, and geometry on physical objects and energy fields. Because empty space, as abstracted from its contents, cannot be observed and has no observable effect on anything, it is not “physical” in the usual sense.</p><p>That which is immaterial is abstract, and abstraction is a mental process that “abstracts” or educes general relationships from observations. So from a philosophical viewpoint, saying that space is immaterial and therefore abstract amounts to saying that it is “mental”…that it is to some extent composed of mind rather than matter. Although this runs against the scientific grain, it is consistent with our dominant physical theories of the very large and the very small, namely relativity and quantum mechanics. In relativity, space and time are combined in an abstract manifold called “spacetime” whose “points” are physical events that can be resolved in terms of mutual behavioral transduction of material objects, a process fundamentally similar to mentation. And quantum mechanics characterizes matter in terms of abstract, immaterial wave functions that are physically actualized by interactions of an equally immaterial nature.</p><p>What does this mean regarding the continuity of spacetime? Simply that like spacetime itself, continuity and its quantum-scale breakdown are essentially mental rather than material in character. As Berkeley observed centuries ago, reality is ultimately perceptual, and as we know from the subsequent debate between Hume and Kant, perception conforms to mental categories… categories like space and time. So rather than being purely objective and “physical” in a materialistic sense, space has a subjective aspect reflecting the profoundly mental nature of our reality.</p><p>Gravitons, though subject to some of the same reasoning, are another matter.</p><p>Hey Chris, what’s your take on the theory of Max Tegmark, physicist at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton. He has a paper on the web which postulates that universes exist physically for all conceivable mathematical structures. Is it as “wacky” as he postulates?</p><p>A: Since Max claims to be on the fast track to a TOE of his own, I just thought I’d offer a few remarks about his approach, and point out a few of the ways in which it differs from that of the CTMU.</p><p>Many of us are familiar with the Anthropic Principle of cosmology (the AP) and Everett’s Many Worlds (MW) interpretation of quantum theory. These ideas have something in common: each is an attempt to make a philosophical problem disappear by what amounts to Wittgensteinian semantic adjustment, i.e., by a convenient redefinition of certain key ingredients. Specifically, MW attempts to circumvent the quantum measurement problem — the decoherence of the quantum wave function — by redefining every quantum event as a divergence of universes, shifting the question “what happens to the unrealized possible results of a measurement when one possibility is exclusively actualized?” to “why can we not perceive the actualizations of these other possible results?”, while the AP shifts the question “why does the universe exist?” to “why is this particular universe perceived to exist?” Both MW and the AP thus shift attention away from objective reality by focusing on the subjective perception of objective reality, thereby invoking the distinction between subjectivity and objectivity (what usually goes unstated is that mainstream physical and mathematical science have traditionally recognized only the objective side of this distinction, sweeping the other side under the rug whenever possible).</p><p>Perhaps intuiting the MW-AP connection, Max Tegmark (formerly at the Institute of Advanced Studies at Princeton) has effectively combined these two ideas and tried to shift the focus back into the objective domain. First, noting that MW is usually considered to involve only those universes that share our laws of physics (but which differ in the initial and subsequent conditions to which those laws are applied), Tegmark extends MW to include other universes with other sets of physical laws, noting that since these sets of laws are mathematical in nature, they must correspond to mathematical structures…abstract structures that we can investigate right here in this universe. And that, he says, may explain why this universe is perceived to exist: the conditions for the evolution of perceptual entities may simply be the mean of a distribution generated by distinct physical nomologies corresponding to these mathematical structures. In other words, the conditions for the existence of “self-aware substructures” (perceptual life forms) may simply be the most likely conditions within the distribution of all possible universes. And since the latter distribution corresponds to the set of mathematical structures in this universe, the hypothesis can be tested right here by mathematical physicists.</p><p>Of course, Tegmark’s attempt at a TOE leaves unanswered a number of deep philosophical questions. First, what good does it do to “anthropically” explain this universe in terms of an MW metauniverse unless one can explain where the metauniverse came from? What is supposed to prevent an informationally barren infinite regress of universes within metauniverses within meta-metauniverses…, and so on? Second, what good is such a theory unless it contains the means to resolve outstanding paradoxes bedeviling physics and cosmology — paradoxes like quantum nonlocality, ex nihilo cosmology, the arrow of time, and so forth? Third, what is the true relationship between mathematics and physics, that one can simply identify sets of physical laws with mathematical structures? It’s fine to say that physics comes from mathematics, but then where does mathematics come from? Fourth, where are the mathematical tools for dealing with the apparently ultra-complex problem of computing the probability distribution of universes from the set of all mathematical structures, including those yet to be discovered? Fifth, what is the real relationship between subjective and objective reality, on which distinction both Many Worlds and the Anthropic Principle are ultimately based? (Et cetera.)</p><p>Since one could go on for pages, it seems a little premature to be calling Tegmark’s theory a TOE (or even a reasonable TOE precursor). And although I ‘m not saying that his theory contains nothing of value, I’m a bit puzzled by the absence of any mention of certain obvious mathematical ingredients. For example, topos theory deals with topoi, or so-called “mathematical universes” consisting of mathematical categories (mapping algebras) equipped not only with the objects and morphisms possessed by categories in general, but special logics permitting the assignment of truth values to various superficially nonalgebraic (e.g. “physical”) expressions involving the objects. Why would any “TOE” purporting to equate physical universes to mathematical structures omit at least cursory mention of an existing theory that seems to be tailor-made for just such a hypothesis? This in itself suggests a certain amount of oversight. Tegmark may have a few good ideas knocking around upstairs, but on the basis of what his theory omits, one can’t avoid the impression that he’s merely skirting the boundary of a real TOE.</p><p>In contrast, the CTMU deals directly with the outstanding paradoxes and fundamental interrelationship of mathematics and physics. Unlike other TOEs, the CTMU does not purport to be a “complete” theory; there are too many physical details and undecidable mathematical theorems to be accounted for (enough to occupy whole future generations of mathematicians and scientists), and merely stating a hypothetical relationship among families of subatomic particles is only a small part of the explanatory task before us. Instead, the CTMU is merely designed to be consistent and comprehensive at a high level of generality, a level above that at which most other TOEs are prematurely aimed.</p><p>The good news is that a new model of physical spacetime, and thus a whole new context for addressing the usual round of quantum cosmological problems, has emerged from the CTMU’s direct attack on deeper philosophical issues.</p><p>s a general theory of reality — or if one prefers, the general framework of such a theory — the CTMU has potential applications in virtually every field of human inquiry and endeavor.</p><p>Human knowledge is a veritable Tower of Babel. Various theories of science, mathematics, and philosophy centering on various parts and aspects of reality are couched in diverse formalisms and vocabularies that often bear little resemblance to each other and exhibit no obvious connections. The situation is reminiscent of a disorderly range of mountains; one can get from one valley to another by climbing the mountains, but by the time one gets to the next valley, the last is no longer visible. Worse, the inhabitants speak a different tongue with no discernable connection to the languages spoken in other valleys.</p><p>Theoretical compartmentalization creates the impression that certain parts or aspects of reality are indefinitely related to each other or not related at all, causing rifts and false divisions to appear in our conceptual and perceptual topography, fracturing and fragmenting our worldview. Sometimes, this leads to scientific crises; for example, relativity theory is seemingly impossible to unite with quantum theory. Some rifts may even be seen as mutual irrelevancies; for example, science and theology are often considered to be separated by an unbridgeable gulf, and thus mutually irrelevant.</p><p>This is hardly an ideal situation. In a reality where the physical world is held accountable to empirical or mathematical science, any scientifically irrelevant theology is implicitly displaced. This makes theological systems untouchable by science and vice versa, depriving science of moral guidance and encouraging the revelatory creation of different metaphysical realities associated with conflicting promises and instructions involving the physical world. (These metaphysical realities include not just overtly religious frameworks, but the random materialism embraced by many scientists and followers of science.) The resulting disagreements cause, or provide pretexts for, real-world conflicts.</p><p>In order to unify and make sense of our knowledge, we must have a universal foundational language in which the special-purpose languages of science can be consistently expressed and interpreted. The fact that this foundational language controls the interpretation of physical theories demands that it be metaphysical; it must refer to science “from above”. Yet, in order to do its job, it must also be necessarily true, which requires that it be a mathematically verified ingredient of science.</p><p>In other words, the required metalanguage is that through which science, including both mathematics and empirical applications of mathematics, becomes self-referential and self-normative…the “bootstrapping” of ordinary mathematical-scientific discourse to a higher verificative level of discourse spanning science in its entirety. This requirement leads directly to the CTMU and SCSPL, exactly as described in this interview and elsewhere.</p><p>Among the benefits of such a language are these: properly developed and applied, it can synergistically unite the various fields of science; it can remove false conceptual divisions, reconciling science with philosophy and theology, mathematics with physics, and physics with metaphysics; it can promote a general understanding of reality, so that people cannot be so easily cheated of meaning by those wishing to create an illusion of amorphous “relativism” in order to exploit the attending moral vacuum; and it can serve as the basis of an overarching worldview capable of modeling all lesser theories and creeds up to mutual consistency, thereby promoting intellectual accord and conducing to peace and harmony on earth.</p><p>Obviously, the CTMU is a cross-disciplinary project. On what disciplines does it draw?</p><p>Because an ultimate theory must accommodate every valid theory pertaining to every part or aspect of reality, it must be approached in the most general terms possible. It must also be formed from the top down rather than just from the bottom up, as it is easier to maintain initial coherence as specificative distinctions are added than to create it ad hoc by cobbling together distinct entities. This means that we must begin with a perfectly general theoretic identity and work inward.</p><p>One therefore begins with mathematical logic, all the way from the propositional and predicate calculi to lattices and model theory; arithmetic, abstract algebra, and elementary analysis; basic probability theory and statistics; foundational mathematics, including the theories of sets and categories; and of course, metaphysics and theology. One can then move on to the theories of computation and information; the algebraic and computational theories of language, generative (computational) grammar and the logical theory of metalanguages; geometry and the theory of manifolds; classical and quantum physics, including relativity theory and cosmology; the study of causality and evolution in fields like biology, neuroscience, and cognitive psychology; decision theory and economics, especially as they relate to the nature and maximization of utility and the stratification of utility functions and distributions; and so on up to (intellectual) exhaustion.</p><p>I’ve just named what some would view as an intractable multiplicity of disciplines, each splitting into branches, each of which is rich enough to occupy a dedicated specialist throughout his/her entire academic career. This naturally presents a problem for generalist-interdisciplinarians, especially independent researchers without access to academic libraries or the academic grapevine. Outsiders are seldom invited to academic conferences and symposia designed to bring interested academics up to speed on the work of specialists; they may even lack knowledge of up-to-date search terms through which to filter recent academic literature for material relevant to their work. Accordingly, they may find it more expedient to address conceptual deficiencies and solve problems from scratch than to sift through vast piles of academic literature for what they need.</p><p>Take mathematics, for example. The scholarly output of the mathematical community has been nothing short of tremendous. This obviously has an upside: mathematicians who are “in the loop” can often find what they need in the prior work of other mathematicians, or at least determine that they’re in virgin territory unexplored by others. But it also has a downside: those who are not in the loop may literally find it easier to discover or rediscover the mathematics they need than to scour the literature for some intelligible indication that somebody else has already written about it, and then decipher and back-engineer the meaning of the complex vocabularies and symbologies employed by previous authors. Personally, I’ve found myself in this position on more than a few occasions.</p><p>Much the same applies to other fields of science, where it can be even more difficult to solve problems instead of looking up their solutions. So let’s just say that I’ve had my share of challenges along the way…and that I really appreciate the Internet!</p><p>Have you completed work on this model or is it still a work in progress? What, if anything, remains to be done?</p><p>The classical Laplacian-deterministic worldview is all but dead. As reality is affected by every possible kind of ambiguity, uncertainty, indeterminacy, and undecidability, no theory of reality can ever be complete. In principle, this makes any such theory a permanent work-in-progress in which a very great deal always remains to be done. Exploration must continue.</p><p>However, a theory of reality can still be comprehensive, classifying knowledge in the large rather than determining it exhaustively. The CTMU already provides a self-contained framework for theorization about reality, represents a pronounced departure from established lines of inquiry, and was ready for prime time even as presented in my 2002 overview The Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe: A New Kind of Reality Theory.</p><p>Of course, the CTMU doesn’t end with the paper. I do something new to develop and refine it nearly every day, and it all adds up. As a metaphysical (ontological, cosmological, and epistemological) framework, the CTMU has no real competition, and can thus be developed without fear of having to start over from scratch.</p><p>The Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe as the Nexus of Spirituality and Cosmology:</p><p>An Interdisciplinary Approach to Reality</p><p>Christopher Michael Langan</p><p>1. General Introduction</p><p>Since the dawn of our species, human beings have been asking difficult questions about themselves, the universe and the nature of existence, but have lacked a unified conceptual framework strong and broad enough to yield the answers. Enter the</p><p>Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe (CTMU).</p><p>The CTMU and Physics</p><p>The avowed goal of physics is to produce what is sometimes called a “Theory of Everything” or TOE. As presently conceived, the TOE is thought to consist of one equation describing a single “superforce” unifying all the forces of nature (gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak nuclear forces).But this is actually an over simplification; every equation must be embedded in a Theory, and theories require models for their proper interpretation. Unfortunately, the currently available theory and model lack three important properties: closure, Consistency and comprehensivity</p><p>. That is, they are not self-contained; they suffer from various intractable paradoxes; and they conspicuously exclude or neglect various crucial factors, including subjective ones like consciousness and emotion. Since the excluded factors fall as squarely under the heading everything as the included ones, a real TOE has no business omitting them. So as now envisioned by physicists, the TOE is misnamed as a “theory of everything”. The CTMU, on the other hand, is a TOE framework in which “everything” really means everything</p><p>.Whereas the currently-envisioned TOE emphasizes objective reality at the expense of its subjective counterpart (mind), the CTMU places mind on the agenda at the outset. It does this not by making assumptions, but by eliminating the erroneous scientific assumption that mind and objective reality can be even tentatively separated. To do this, it exploits not just what we know of objective reality–the so-called “everything” of the standard TOE–but also what we know of the first word in “TOE”, namely theory</p><p>.In other words, it brings the logic of formalized theories to bear on reality theory. Although this is a mathematically obvious move, it has been almost completely overlooked in the physical and mathematical sciences. By correcting this error, the CTMU warrants description as a theory of the relationship between the</p><p>Mind of the theorist and the objective reality about which it theorizes</p><p>, completing the program of subjective-objective unification already inherent in certain aspects of the formalisms of relativity and quantum mechanics. In the process, it also brings the quantum and classical realms of physics into the sort of intimate contact that can only be provided by a fundamentally new model of physical and metaphysical reality…a model truly worthy of being called a “new paradigm”. Fundamental to this new model are revisions of basic physical concepts including space, time, matter and motion. Space, once a featureless medium aimlessly proliferating through cosmic expansion, becomes a distributed syntactic structure iteratively reborn of matter and subject to conspansive evacuation and rescaling. Time, previously envisioned as a quasi-spatial</p><p>linear dimension along which the cosmos hurtles like a runaway locomotive, becomes the means by which the universe self-configures… an SCSPL-grammatical symphony of logico-linguistic transformations played by the self-creating cosmos. Lumps of matter, no longer the inert pawns of external laws of physics, become SCSPL syntactic operators containing within themselves the syntactic rules by which they internally process each other to create new states of physical reality. And motion, once seen as the passage of material attribute-ensembles through adjacent infinitesimal cells of empty space displaying them as content, becomes an iterative, self-simulative sequence of endomorphic self-projections by moving bodies themselves</p><p>Chris, I’m not a mathematician or physicist by any stretch, but I am a curious person and would like to know more about the CTMU (Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe). I am particularly interested in the theological aspects. Can you please explain what the CTMU is all about in language that even I can understand?</p><p>A: Thanks for your interest, but the truth is the CTMU isn’t all that difficult for even a layperson to understand. So sit back, relax, kick off your shoes and open your mind…</p><p>Scientific theories are mental constructs that have objective reality as their content. According to the scientific method, science puts objective content first, letting theories be determined by observation. But the phrase “a theory of reality” contains two key nouns, theory and reality, and science is really about both. Because all theories have certain necessary logical properties that are abstract and mathematical, and therefore independent of observation — it is these very properties that let us recognize and understand our world in conceptual terms — we could just as well start with these properties and see what they might tell us about objective reality. Just as scientific observation makes demands on theories, the logic of theories makes demands on scientific observation, and these demands tell us in a general way what we may observe about the universe.</p><p>In other words, a comprehensive theory of reality is not just about observation, but about theories and their logical requirements. Since theories are mental constructs, and mental means “of the mind”, this can be rephrased as follows: mind and reality are linked in mutual dependence at the most basic level of understanding. This linkage of mind and reality is what a TOE (Theory of Everything) is really about. The CTMU is such a theory; instead of being a mathematical description of specific observations (like all established scientific theories), it is a “metatheory” about the general relationship between theories and observations…i.e., about science or knowledge itself. Thus, it can credibly lay claim to the title of TOE.</p><p>Mind and reality — the abstract and the concrete, the subjective and the objective, the internal and the external — are linked together in a certain way, and this linkage is the real substance of “reality theory”. Just as scientific observation determines theories, the logical requirements of theories to some extent determine scientific observation. Since reality always has the ability to surprise us, the task of scientific observation can never be completed with absolute certainty, and this means that a comprehensive theory of reality cannot be based on scientific observation alone. Instead, it must be based on the process of making scientific observations in general, and this process is based on the relationship of mind and reality. So the CTMU is essentially a theory of the relationship between mind and reality.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1eee2ad8cf96" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is God a Nihilist]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/is-god-a-nihilist-49e927f416ce?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/49e927f416ce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[knowledge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jan 2018 02:46:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-26T02:46:37.564Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In pondering over and figuring out the structure of reality and the fabric of the cosmos I find myself asking Is there meaning to life? why live life? what’s to get excited about? There must be reasons as to how God made the universe to give us things to get excited about for God to have made this and us to live it in the first place. There must be much more to reality if there is a God and he made the structure of what reality consists of there must be much more meaning if God made it then just what we think or see outside of us. If God made the universe and life and us to live it there must be deep deep very proud reasons at a lot more to reality than we ever thought behind what we can’t see. For God wanting us to do this for us to live this there must be amazing reasons underneath everything and they must be knowable for God to be coherent and make sense we must have the chance at understanding in what we live in and why. Otherwise what would be the fucking point of it all especially when God can do anything nothing is a challenge to him and he already knows prior to making everything how it will play out? Why even do this does God have to did anyone make him? There must be very deep spiritual reasons of meaning that would enrich our lives and be purpose driven but mind blowing and of earth shattering important. But it can’t be to easily discovered for it to be profound and mean so much. And why would God even have us live life if he just did it all and gave us everything we need and made everything perfectly complete and just there it is everything is full and complete will be forever happy that’s all that exists ever is everyone made in full happiness, and you know everything you need too. Its perfect despite having a lot of internal complexity. Although that is what heaven is supposed to be and ultimately the end goal why even live this life then? And where would be the meaning in just making us in heaven forever if there is no change and challenge and evolution and complexity to figure out and mysteries to solve and endurance and I guess even pain suffering in death and overcoming that to achieve happiness. But God didn’t have to make us to need meaning in our lives so why did God do things the way that he did? That’s the ultimate question God could’ve done things anyway he wanted to why this way? Why not some other way where we get all of our meaning with no suffering ever? Why not? However with God being the greatest source of intelligence there can be there must be more than a one word answer and life must be a journey of trial and error and discovery for God to mean anything at all and be this deep profound being. But I do know this given the internal complexity of reality and all of the pain and loss humanity goes through it must be more than just a bible or buying goods or possessions or material things or jobs or better car or farming or saying a few prayers. There must be so much more to the structure of reality for this life to mean anything at all. And if it’s God’s universe he must be creative creating all kinds of formats and realities for us to live in and discovery as for the true meaning of life I do not know but to grasp what God is and why he did it this way with this kind of meaning is the questions to be answered. But as deep as God is there must be a lots of big deep reasons for it. But God must have created so many aspects to life and reality than there just to be nothing but material goods and having a nihilistic world view. I mean if God created everything is he a nihilist? Is God a Nihilist? Then if not neither should we because there is so much more to God than us to discover that it would overshadow our world views by millions and millions of times.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=49e927f416ce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Job Culture Vs. The Alternative]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/the-job-culture-vs-the-alternative-918049d6ee4b?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/918049d6ee4b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[job-search]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 Jul 2017 14:38:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-22T14:38:08.501Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In today’s world and America largely our time is occupied mostly by one thing; and that’s jobs. Always have to have a job. Getting a job is what’s it&#39;s all about. Its how you make your living and money and pay for a house and support a family etc. Pay for vacations and everything else. Well we have to do some kind of work because work is what is needed to be done. We need farming done, we need people to drain septic tanks and dig for and install and replace water wells, we need people to put out our fires and to teach and to weld and do other manual labor. That’s just a fact of life right? Majority of people are stuck at a menial labor job from 9 to 5 or so 40 plus hours a week barely getting by and living paycheck to paycheck. You know the story the working middle class. Well anything can happen but people who work hard and in construction don’t always get paid what they deserve and have to put in extra and odd hours sometimes. But they spend most of their energy and time doing this. Some of this needs to be done. We need people to lay cement and lay brick and lay asphalt. Carpenters as well. Then we have things we don’t necessarily need and people can do themselves that are self help that we don’t need but it helps to have jobs for. Then you have greeters and people who push carts and load grocery bags. Pizza delivery and fast food workers. Fast food workers are busy most of the time but they are steadily doing the same thing over and over. What does doing the same basic menial thing over and over do to the human brain? It numbs it out and bores it etc. Working on a forklift and whatever else it doesn’t matter. Most of our jobs and paperwork that’s unnecessary pre-occupies the lives of many and is a pastime for most. Jobs they don’t like are slave labor and redundant tasks over and over again to no end in sight. People are stuck in these buildings over and over again sometimes for their whole life. Some tasks are needed some aren’t. But even if they are does have to be as many hours everyday and every week the same pay same tasks with the same company and same people and even if all of that is fine you have no energy or time or money to do much else. Just doing your job and what your told and get paid what you get paid with little hope of expanding or moving up. This describes most of the working class. I’m not against jobs or having one but is there another way to approach the situation? This there an alternative? Is there a different and better way to maximize the potential of the human mind? Is this the only way to live life does it have to be lived this way? It&#39;s all about ideas right? All the ideas and best ideas you’ll have in your lifetime? What is the best and most efficient and interesting way to expand on this ability of ideas to get more out of a person? Is it by doing the same thing and standing in the same spot with the same boring task over and over again their whole life? Is that how? So we have invented and discovered so many things that have improved life and amazing discoveries that have produced so much prosperity and made life better and easier and added to our truth content so much and the best we have for most people is the shopping isle? Folding cloths and stocking the shelf? Working a cash register? Nothing wrong with doing those things if one likes to but is there another way a better way that humans are made for? Not just boring monotonous tasks over and over for years on end? Can we raise a generation with the alternative and have it taught the same way? It&#39;s a good question and we can. So what is this alternative I’m referring to…?</p><p>It&#39;s the<strong> Pursuit of Knowledge</strong>. Instead of being a job and pharmacy culture why can’t we be a culture of knowledge. A culture that feeds off of the pursuit of knowledge and is built and based around that very thing? Isn’t that really what life&#39;s about. When jobs get replaced or erased isn’t it because of some new invention or technology where that drudgery of labor isn’t needed anymore? We can have machines do it. But inventions make life that much better. They do this. The greatest inventor Nikola Tesla that gave us the electrical age said he wanted to see if he could make life a little easier for men. As soon as we don’t need coal we don’t need people mining and dying of lung cancer or whatever disease they get. Those people can now enjoy a life after the pursuit of knowledge. Our best game in town. If everyone was inventing like Tesla then what kind of world would it be? So do we need such full time professional labor. Maybe an hour here from a person and an hour there. Do they need to spend their whole life this way? Isn’t the pursuit of knowledge what we enjoy as humans and are really built for? Work to but when did we become a job culture and why? Okay so someone needs a well installed now we did let’s get back to the microscope examining bone marrow or the telescope examining Saturn’s rings. I don’t see how this has to do with democracy either or what the fathers of the declaration of independence had in mind. We could be a culture based on the pursuit of knowledge and spend our lives doing that rather than menial slave labor jobs and live as if a kid in wonder our whole lives. Oh what kind of world it could be. It&#39;s only an increase in knowledge and discovery and invention that makes life better, safer, healthier, smarter, more purposeful, useful, problem solving, life saving and disease curing, eye opening, surprising, exciting, interesting, work worthy, more worth living and more rewarding and well spent and fulfilling. Knowledge gives us prosperity the very thing we dream of and strive for everyday at our jobs. We certainly can make it so we make money this way if we wanted. Rather the pursuit of knowledge seems to go to a select few ignoring all of the other kinds of intelligence out there and potential. I think somewhere along the way we fell into a dead end trap for most. An increase in knowledge is what will make the GDP and quality of life dramatically go up. It&#39;s what extends the lifespan of people. It&#39;s what makes life worth living the most. The pursuit of knowledge is what it&#39;s all about. Would you rather get up in the morning to look through a telescope examining DNA and other human tissue and smash particles of atoms together and dabble with forces of nature and program computers or push carts? Or paint everyday all day and we get people to think this is all they can do. Well the only reason they aren’t so book or white collar or scientifically smart is because they don’t get to spend their whole life doing that. It&#39;s really a catch 22. No one has to spend their whole life painting or putting up sheetrock. No one. They can if they want. But I think our culture is backwards and missing it. Plus if they quit their job they can’t make money right now off of pursuing knowledge or some field of inquiry. And one week or month off of their job and they are already behind on bills.We should be able to spend most of our time to pursue knowledge for the good of mankind rather than stuck tiling floors. I do think this messes with our psychology as humans as well. Our investigative brains are the most powerful tool we have with so much possibilities. Now think of it this way. Say we live in a society where a great deal of general labor is either done part time or by the young or mostly artificial intelligence. Say crime is no more. We as a people are no longer so preoccupied with money. What would we do then? How would we spend our time? No more jobs? What if you got to wake up to everyday which is what it would be with all of these other problems of crime and poverty and political corruption gone and with AI and middle class and slave menial general labor out of the way would be waking up to exploring new things and a culture entirely based on learning and maximizing not only human capital and intellectual potential but a culture where we aim to space travel and shoot for the stars and discover new things and use the best microscopes and telescopes and lenses to peer into unseen things and play with the elements of life and chemistry and contemplate reality and philosophy and used advanced math and enhance transportation and computers to the next realms and learn what’s all out there. We could be a culture that spends its time based on learning rather than being job slaves. Cause lets face it we as a people are job slaves. Your a job slave that’s what most of your are. To find out if that’s what you are just answer a few basic questions in which it could be a list of much longer list of questions: 1. Do you like your job? most people its no! 2. Do you spend at least 40 hours if not several more a week there? Yes. Do you have very little time to pursue your other life passions and family time and are struggling to make ends meet and pay the bills and living paycheck to paycheck? Yes. Do you find on your job doing the same repetitive thing that’s rather dull over and over occupying most of your existence and find very boring and doesn’t excite you? Yes! Is there much expanding or moving up in your job? No! Is it dead end? Usually this ends up being yes! Okay so then with all of these answers and plus one additional question do you get to spend much time at your job learning and adding to the knowledge of mankind? No probably not that much right? And not much learning and not learning of your choosing or that grand. Okay so then with all of these answers I think its clear your a job slave. We could be a culture where our time spent pursuing knowledge and contributing to the knowledge of mankind. So why not make that our mission as a culture. So that’s the alternative. You want a political revolution make it to be a culture about the pursuit of knowledge. The very thing we are meant to do as humans. The very thing that pulled us out of the dark ages and out of the caves and got us passed horse and buggy and gave us rockets and airplanes and jets and trains and cars and the electric car and the power grid and computers. The very thing that gave us the historical age of the enlightenment, renaissance, and the scientific revolution. The kind of people we were meant to be and born to be. That’s the way culture is supposed to be. Its our current Job Culture Vs. The Pursuit of knowledge culture we could be. That would make life far more exciting, accomplishing and purposeful and worth living. I guarantee its different kinds of learning that where people’s true heart and passions lay. That’s our alternative so lets become the culture of people that’s after the pursuit of knowledge rather than job slaves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=918049d6ee4b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Free Energy to Power the Earth-No Manual Labor necessary; I don’t know about that]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mcphailsamuel/free-energy-to-power-the-earth-no-manual-labor-necessary-i-dont-know-about-that-132fa84c4512?source=rss-ee304173473c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/132fa84c4512</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[solar-flare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Skywalker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 20 Jul 2017 21:47:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-21T02:51:41.948Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/225/1*mIBgbO0DTWLR_sV1lFmahA.jpeg" /></figure><p>My idea which isn’t original with me but it&#39;s a rare thing having been considered or discussed. And at this present time not quite possible. I know that it&#39;s at the limits of what’s possible for our society but we just aren’t that advanced yet. But I don’t know either whether Tesla’s free energy solution to power the world would’ve worked either, with his Tower to get energy from the atmosphere and wirelessly transmit it throughout the world endlessly. It may have I don’t know. But there is another way to collect intense amounts of energy to power the earth with free energy and nearly unlimited energy reserves or at least for a long time. It would certainly power the earth and then some until we did it again easily on my assumption. If we could get near 100 percent of it. How can this be done what other way is there to collect a big enough bulk of energy to power the whole earth? All of these other ways through- water flow and wind and solar and nuclear and batteries they all give us energy in limited forms at a time with what the demands are so we need a constant pull of energy from these systems. How can we as a species in one big bulk collect enough energy to power the earth for everyone for free with unlimited for a long time? Where on Earth or what reserve is there where we could collect enough energy at once at one event that’s so massive at scale to power the Earth and easily for a long time probably by the time we leave this place? There is such an event that takes place but its outside of the Earth’s atmosphere and happens in the solar system. That is an event that is capable of also causing sever damage to the Earth’s power grid and knocking it out completely and throwing us right back into barbaric times. The dark ages and bringing down the electrical grid. What event is that. Its the kind of energy released with a coronal mass ejection!</p><p>That’s right you guessed it. A Solar Flare! A Solar Flare has huge amounts of plasma ejected from the Sun. These ejections extend and are way massive off of the Sun’s surface with far more area than the surface of the Earth. Several probably hundreds of times more. could we capture this energy and harness it to power the earth with some kind of satellite or several of them? It just may be possible. Plasma in itself is a whole new kind of energy form that we’ve or mankind has never harnessed so its an out there idea but it could be done. It would be the greatest engineering feat ever pulled off- that’s for sure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/222/1*vVFP_sOkWWMOT1ff9IFlxg.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=132fa84c4512" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>