<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Meera Chakravarthy on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Meera Chakravarthy on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@meerachakravarthy?source=rss-20d0f166c8da------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 01:43:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@meerachakravarthy/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[CULTURAL PLACEMAKING]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@meerachakravarthy/cultural-placemaking-5ef10b89ebf9?source=rss-20d0f166c8da------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ef10b89ebf9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-diplomacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economic-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arts-and-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[placemaking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Meera Chakravarthy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Apr 2019 13:16:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-11T13:16:56.017Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Why don’t we put arts and culture in the center of international development?</strong></p><p>For millennia, culture has been the driver in how and why humans congregate, communicate, and relate. Across time and space, we have used culture as the vehicle to sustain and create lives and identities for future generations to learn and thrive in their communities. America itself has attempted to keep arts and culture in the center of its domestic development efforts (case in point NYC), but has been diverted from using it as a primary driver in development as other industries, with more immediately measurable outcomes, took precedence. In recent decades, there has been increased concern and fear that competitive globalization, a strong desire for economic growth and resulting gentrification may eradicate cultural nuance, ultimately causing more harm and dispute within and amongst countries, and may even result in renewed efforts to colonize rather than develop the least-developed nations. Yet, as “developed” countries reach out to support “developing” nations through diplomacy, technical, financial, and military assistance, what if the development community also were to focus its strategy on developing clusters of artistic communities that had potential to create a longstanding economic and social impact? Whether that were through enhancing the tourism industry or the global exchange of music, what if we helped developing nations diplomatically exchange elements of their cultures beyond just learning about them on a micro scale, but helping set the structure for and develop artistic communities in places all across the world, ultimately benefiting not only the developing nations, but also teaching the developed nations about a country’s culture?</p><p>International development is a general term for a wide variety of actions designed to improve the quality of life and the effectiveness of governance amongst less-developed countries, ultimately helping to economically and socially grow a mature nation. International development can also be seen as a measure of how advanced a client society is, usually in economic terms. Its practices and studies lay the foundation for connecting and helping improve the sustainability of the world’s countries and cultures. In 2015, member states of the United Nations created a blueprint for peace and prosperity for people and the planet, and shared a set of 17 sustainable development goals to end poverty and other deprivations. These goals centered on health and education, reducing inequality, and economic growth. To achieve these goals, international development experts often borrow from models of successful business, trade, or industry to spur similar economic or cultural gains in areas all over the world. These models vary from refining policy to developing anchor institutions that will serve as information hubs in developing regions. These models are often adequate in achieving short term economic change, but assume a standard of success based on economic growth, such as how can businesses be built up to increase job growth and international trade opportunities. They tend to forget the unique factors that signify and spark growth in our society are sports, music, dance, arts. It is culture.</p><p>In the past decade, the term “cultural diplomacy” came into our lexicon, describing actions focused on exchanging ideas, values, and traditions rooted in culture or identity that strengthen relationships, cooperation, and a provoke interest in the unique cultures across the world. Cultural diplomacy programs have existed in the public, private, and nonprofit sectors, mostly rooted in cultural exchange programs for artists and scholars. This includes scholarship programs like the Fulbright, and state department artist exchange programs such as American Music Abroad. These types of exchanges bring about mutual learning opportunities where artists are collaborating and learning about cultures just as much as they are showing others the importance of their own culture. However, taking an American dance troupe to Nepal to collaborate, perform, and integrate with the community for a week is not going to instigate long standing economic or social change. How do we create sustainable cultural diplomacy across our nations?</p><p>Here’s an idea. Why can we not merge international development and cultural diplomacy; why can we not use arts and culture as an economic and social development strategy that will help us “developed” nations learn just as much as we help our fellow “developing” nations?</p><p>In 2018, Patrick Kabanda from the World Bank published a book on this very topic titled “<em>The Creative Wealth of Nations</em>”. In it, Kabanda argues for the value of the performing arts as a central driver for development, and presents cases and areas of exploration to realize this development, ranging from education and innovation to data, arts policy, and trade. Kabanda provides case study examples of how employing a performing arts institution or a music school as a development strategy will ultimately ignite economic growth by creating jobs and wealth opportunities by way of already existing habits amongst citizens. What Kabanda seemed to have left out of this impressively observant and articulate publication, was the connection between international development and placemaking.</p><p>Placemaking is a concept centered on the planning, design and management of places, particularly public spaces. In 2010, the National Endowment for the Arts, alongside Ann Markusen, coined a term, creative placemaking, which is the concept of putting arts and culture in the center of community development. Creative placemaking advocated for getting artists a seat at the table in community development projects, and focused on using arts to help redevelop places whether they be artist studios or spaces for public art. Creative placemaking was founded on the principal of using arts and culture to help develop communities to ensure their deeply rooted community talents and skills are preserved and brought to light, demonstrating and strengthening their value as long-term economic drivers. It also helped redefine the role of industries such as the tourism and the hospitality, as well as parks and public space management.</p><p>What if we lifted creative placemaking to a global scale, and introduced it, deliberately and systematically, into the international development conversation? If we want to focus on cultural diplomacy and international development, we are, at the end of the day, focusing on developing communities and creating spaces for economic growth. What if American diplomacy could encourage governments to demand that any effort at economic development, whether American, or Chinese, or Russian or any of the other givers of “aid,” included support for the preservation and development of those things that give a nation its identity, or, rather, identities, in the first place? This could look like redeveloping an abandoned warehouse into an arts space or a school, or along with building a technology-industry park, placing a music school in a community that will provide opportunities for artists to learn how to reproduce and market their work across the globe. What if we helped developing nations focus on creating spaces where they put their own cultural interests, specifically the arts, at the center of developing places?</p><p>There is no argument that this is a hefty ask. Most assuredly, it will require a multidimensional approach, ensuring that a basic set of development needs are met, in addition to helping economically grow a place based on the work of its artisans and cultural figures. This includes helping promote the development and maintenance of sustainable agriculture and water purification systems so that there is adequate access to food and water at all times. It also includes ensuring the development of universal broadband access to ignite cross cultural collaborations and guarantee easy access to free information exchange. Finally, this also includes providing opportunities to create and sustain healthy communities and healthy living.</p><p>This multidimensional approach can borrow its techniques from creative placemaking. ArtPlace America, a ten year collaborative created in 2010 to help explore how artists can create cross-sector improvement/development in communities, focuses exactly on how arts and culture can play a role in economic development, promoting healthy growth in other sectors such as transportation, health, public safety, and water access/agriculture. “By holistically considering the economic, environmental, and social needs of a community, artists can help projects achieve multiple benefits and minimize negative impacts. Artists can play a valuable role in watershed-scale thinking and action by serving as liaisons between different stakeholder groups or helping people see familiar things from new perspectives. They can bridge diverse interests and needs to cultivate cross-sector partnerships that work toward common goals. Artistic processes and methods that prioritize inclusion and engagement of all community members can help build community connections, trust, and resilience. All of these skills are assets in tackling the complicated, interconnected … challenges of today […]” (<a href="http://uswateralliance.org/sites/uswateralliance.org/files/publications/uswa_artsculture_FINAL_PAGES_RGB_0.PDF">US Water Alliance, 2018</a>) Ultimately, by using arts and culture as a catalyst for international development, arts and culture can be strategically leveraged to help develop multiple other aspects of society, such as agriculture, technology and healthcare.</p><p>The arts build trust. Once trust is built in a community, it is much easier to develop and gain support for needs such as universal access to internet or healthcare. But, in order to first develop in nations, there need to exist a natural order of trust, and this can be done through the vehicle of arts development projects.</p><p>Successfully developing an international arts community requires deep study and learning from existing models of creative placemaking, whether it is called that or not, where communities have successfully and have NOT successfully put arts and culture in the center of planning conversations. As we turn to help other nations develop, we want to help them not make the common mistakes that have led our own nation towards gentrification and a loss of culture amongst community. We want to help other nations capitalize, in the most positive sense of that word, on the very culture that makes them unique. By including artists and arts development projects at the forefront of development, developing nations are more likely to experience a multiplier effect of economic growth by way of tourism or international and web-based trade. For example, if we help develop interesting spaces like an arts market in Kita, Mali where women can obtain micro-finance loans to sell their work and express themselves, tourists will want to come, learn, and spend money that is good for the economy. Crafts might be put online to be sold and shipped across the world.</p><p>While all this work requires much deeper research, the guiding principles must be the following:</p><ul><li>We must ensure that economic growth goes into the developing nations’ economy and that money goes into the pockets of the artists</li><li>We must ensure that using arts as a catalyst for development does not further gentrify the communities we develop or turn into a tourist destination that forgets to prioritize the nation’s citizens</li><li>We must put the safety and sustainability of the developing nation’s citizens at the forefront of any and every project, ensuring their basic life and living needs are met and supported</li><li>We must have a genuine understanding from all parties involved that these projects focus on mutual development, i.e. that developed countries learn just as much from developing nations when trying to build cultural industries</li></ul><p>If we want to build cross-cultural community and exchange, activate global leaders across industries, and help eradicate poverty, we can benefit greatly from leveraging one of the most resourceful community building tools, the arts. When we use arts and culture as the conduit to drive economic growth in developing nations, we show nations our ability to be collaborators. We ignite a shared understanding that we value what another community values, we want to provide them the resources to help achieve their own versions of success, and most importantly, we treasure their arts and culture and want to create environments where we mutually learn and grow.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ef10b89ebf9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Community in a Creative Place]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@meerachakravarthy/community-in-a-creative-place-35eca44a3a18?source=rss-20d0f166c8da------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/35eca44a3a18</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[urban-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Meera Chakravarthy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Mar 2019 18:33:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-16T18:33:58.770Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Tucked away amongst a pocket of restaurants and small businesses on 18th street in Washington, DC sits a charming 3-story brick building vibrating with culture. As you walk past, you hear the sounds of nations spilling out onto 18th street — a guitarist playing an elongated solo in tribute to his Latin American roots. A shekere keeping the beat for a West African ngoni and dancing to the eccentric rhythms.</p><p>Gentrification has brought new demographics, socioeconomic statuses and higher rents into Adams Morgan, one of DC’s iconic neighborhoods. But Bossa Bistro has kept a steady, beating pulse of culture for over 18 years.</p><p>Calling this place quaint is an understatement. Walls lined with a mixture of Brazilian and African art, a wait staff with the warmest hearts who eloquently speak broken English, and secret moving meditation classes on the second floor; all of it fills this place with vibrancy. Whoever you are, whatever culture, creed, or orientation, when you walk in, you feel like two big arms are wrapping you up and singing “welcome home”.</p><p>I am blessed with both deep sensitivity and sound practicality. I studied both music and economics at university, always trying to find a way to blend the two; feeding my creativity and my intellect. I began studying a concept called creative placemaking, which puts arts and culture in the center of urban planning and community development. Creative placemaking invigorated me because it was a way I could communicate the value and impact musicians like me had on society. However, I was hesitant to make a career out of it, as I didn’t know how to fully develop or position myself in this space. Therefore, moving to DC was for a practical reason — to enter the corporate world as a management consultant with a prestigious firm, a position I was grateful to have been offered. But, when I arrived, I desired to find the sensitivity and unique factors within my community.</p><p>Surrounded mostly by young professionals who were discovering what it felt like to make a fat paycheck for the first time, I was initially lured into engaging in the rituals of bonding over alcohol, clubs, and working too much in order to get promoted. However, while my colleagues were ordering their 3rd round of beers and complaining about their surprisingly mundane jobs, I was striving to not be trapped in the loneliness of corporate America; so I began to throw myself into exploration.</p><p>Thus, I would spend all my free time going to community events, trying to find ways to become rooted to my community. You might find me venturing into local independent bookstores, engaging in conversations with a DC women’s business pop up store, giving input on the DC cultural plan, or taking a leadership role in my local arts collaborative. I met activists who yearned to bring to the forefront the narrative of African American history on Georgia Ave., once the prime real estate of the African American gentry, being re-gentrified by yoga studios and beer gardens. I engaged with developers who had owned family property for years, trying to sustain such small businesses as diners and bookstores, but struggling to keep their businesses afloat. Their stories offered new perspectives that ignited a fire of motivation as I engaged with my new city.</p><p>But something still didn’t feel right; I had yet to find a community place to call my own.</p><p>The first time I walked into Bossa Bistro, having lived in DC for a month, I brought a group of millennial friends to visit this obscure little bar that sat right in the heart of Adams Morgan. As soon as my foot crossed the threshold of Bossa, a wind of cultures encircled me as if they had been here for centuries. Live music was bouncing off the patterned brick walls while folks were dancing salsa and sipping caipirinhas. It was as if I had walked into the real-world manifestation of creative placemaking, a concept I was striving to re-engage with in DC. Immediately, I declared to all my friends that this was MY spot in DC. The practicality in me fought to explain to others why I was so attached to this place. The sensitivity in me knew no explanation was needed; the energy just felt right.</p><p>Bossa and I continued to date each other for months. Anytime new friends came into town, this is the place I would ritualistically take them to. When I wanted to be alone or heard, I felt safe coming here, welcomed by the doorman who no longer had to check my ID. Many nights, I tipsily dreamt of being on stage with my flute, while the practical side of me envisioned running a business like this one day. Unknown to both of us, Bossa served as a source of stability in the early months of my professional life.</p><p>As with all great occurrences in life, the beauty of happenstance brought the community of Bossa Bistro deeper into my life. After 1.5 years in DC, my creative brain was hurting and yearning for fulfillment, so I began volunteering with an immigrant arts nonprofit, whose leader told me she needed more performers for an event she was hosting at Bossa and asked if I would play flute. At that point I had not played in public for about 2 years, but after seeing my minimal resistance, she easily convinced me. That night, I went up on stage and asked the guitar player from the previous set if he could improvise in the key of D.</p><p>For two minutes, we total strangers wrapped ourselves in a dialogue in D major, supporting each others’ melodic patterns, agreeing and disagreeing sonically until we hit a rhythm, and improvised a story in front of our audiences’ eyes.</p><p>After our piece, I learned that the guitarist I was playing with co-owned Bossa Bistro and wanted me to play flute in some of his other projects. That day I went from having not played music for 2 years, to joining 4 different music projects spanning a host of cultures from Malian music to Indian music. It was as if all the family and communities I had left behind across the world had suddenly reappeared; I was once again home, playing music. This was community. My community.</p><p>I began to spend almost every night at Bossa, making and listening to music, and developing friendships with the regulars. I’d look forward to seeing the smile of the young woman who worked for the NIH but was also an impressive dancer. I loved commiserating in the drudgery of life with the overworked IT professional who had just quit his job to become a full time bass player.</p><p>I also spent hours learning the story of the co-owner, Rob, who like me, had lived a dual life. Years ago, he had been extremely successful in helping build the foundation of the internet, but also had a deep passion and talent for music. After he retired early, he purchased this bar and brought to life all of the community’s cultural projects.</p><p>When he started this club, it was out of a passion to combine the pure intimacy and musical genius of a New Orleans jazz club with the artistic taste and vibrant characters of a New York music club. To him, Bossa was not necessarily a profit making entity, rather it followed more of a nonprofit business model, focusing on ways to preserve and sustain the ever-evolving cultures of DC by way of music. However, with a constantly gentrifying neighborhood that had a McDonalds and a Subway within two storefronts of each other, making a profit had become an increasing need for Bossa’s sustainability in this city. Rob and I would spend hours trying to problem-solve genuine ways to create profitable approaches for his unique business.</p><p>By engaging in his narrative, I came to realize how the more visible world of DC politics and business was truly transient; what laid the foundation of this community were places like Bossa Bistro that had lasted for years — and will continue to last — not because of a system, but because of individuals who recognize a mutual dream, and who wake up every day to put that dream into practice. This was the type of individual I wanted to be.</p><p>Over the next few months Bossa, its patrons, staff, and owners saw me transition. I went from working a corporate job to working as an independent contractor for a small firm, granting more time to figure out my creative goals in life. By day I struggled with new managers, shifting dreams, and a wavering sense of self confidence. Each night I got up on stage and improvised music into the audience at Bossa where a nurturing force always told me “everything is going to be ok.” The energy of this whole community in Bossa was better than any therapist I could have consulted.</p><p>This space exemplifies the intersections of communities merging. I have been able to see all versions of my person thrive in this space, from having a drink with a Supreme Court justice’s son to participating at an event on the “divine feminine’. You can never quite tell who walks into this space on any given day, but you love them all the same.</p><p>Bossa has not only opened up my sense of community locally, but also internationally. A few months ago, I had the honor of traveling to Mali with the West African band I play with at Bossa. With the support of the Ambassador of Mali, UNESCO Center for Peace, and a whole cohort of folks, we are exploring how to improve the arts and culture scene in DC, and abroad.</p><p>Bossa Bistro is now my second home- a place where I can freely feel valued and supported, and a place that taught me to love DC. It has helped me rediscover Washington as not just the nation’s capital, but a unique and thriving artistic city, attracting ambassadors and refugees, poets and technicians. Bossa organically expresses the melting pot this nation was built to be.</p><p>My relationship with Bossa has taught me what policy, research, and evaluation work cannot teach me when it comes to creative placemaking.<em> Bossa has taught me what creative placemaking actually feels like. </em>This level of artistic depth and tactical understanding is so necessary for us folks who straddle the world of practicality and sensitivity. We need a lab where we can creatively test all our ideas and bring what we learn back to the design, evaluation, and operation of a creative place.</p><p>As the framework of our American cities begins to change, and as we introduce new players into our community, I often wonder how the composition of creative places will also change. As bright young minds come into Washington, DC ready to redevelop the “community”, will they be able to acknowledge the practicality of spaces like Bossa, or have they lost their sensitivity?</p><p>To address these questions, I turn to the art of improvisation. The beauty of improvisation is that it is the ultimate democracy; everyone has an opportunity to share and be heard. Every night I go on stage and play my flute, I actively open my ears, listen to the chords and keys played by the band, find a space to enter the dialogue, and begin to improvise with others. When we humans develop our communities, we naturally engage in a similar dialogue of improvisation. My experiences in Bossa have taught me that part of our duty as citizens who want to preserve creative places in gentrifying communities is that we must similarly invite others to experience and collaborate in what we create, must open space for a dialogue, and ultimately improvise solutions together.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=35eca44a3a18" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Will You Help Launch the Evolution of Arts Evaluation?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@meerachakravarthy/will-you-help-launch-the-evolution-of-arts-evaluation-351396dd09e?source=rss-20d0f166c8da------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/351396dd09e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evaluation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Meera Chakravarthy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Oct 2017 01:44:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-16T01:44:11.187Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is time for us to start getting smarter about the evidence we use to evaluate and advocate for the arts.</p><p>What can we as community members, a government, a business, a society who cares about the arts, do to advance the <strong><em>state of the arts? </em></strong>From the neighbor down the street to the city government agency, we can all become more effective advocates if we are equipped with the right tools and the right vocabulary. My mission is to enable us to explain and support the arts, a field which holds a unique power within our communities.</p><p><strong>Why should we advocate for the arts?</strong></p><p>Arts bind communities, give voice to our causes, and expression to our identities. Regardless of what ideology we support, the arts are a tool of expression and communication that help us better tell the stories of who we are and what we believe. Arts are not a danger; they are simply a language by which we communicate; a language that needs protection. When society is at its lowest points, our culture and our arts are often the strongest forces. In the US, the arts industry contributes over $704 billion dollars and employs over 4.7 million wage and salary workers. Arts have a far-reaching effect on almost every part of our lives. We should advocate for the arts because the arts make immediate and long-term impacts, ranging from economic and political to social and personal. These impacts are strong forces, but are hard to communicate. This is why we must emphasize evaluation.</p><p><strong>How do we advocate for the arts?</strong></p><p>Historically, we have used stories, case studies, and qualitative evidence to measure and communicate the impact of arts in our communities. Organizations such as Americans for the Arts have created indexes to help us gain a comprehensive picture of the impact the arts have on communities. The data sources used are broadly available or nationally collected sets of metrics from agencies such as the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the Bureau of Labor Statistics and the US Bureau of the Census, local agencies or individually tailored surveys. Most all conclusions regarding impact tend to be derived from classic economic measures, measures that may not recognizably change during a single grant life cycle. Because of this, an argument centered on only changes in the dollar value of the arts in communities is incomplete and often unpersuasive. It is particularly unpersuasive to the artists and their organizations who are more likely to prioritize aesthetics over economics.</p><p>Why not start tailoring the evidence we use to advocate for the arts? We have enough data available to better consolidate arts information and go beyond measuring economic impact. What if our data sources combined with mission data of arts organizations and sentiment data from patrons to comprehensively tell a data-driven story about the arts?</p><p><strong>How can we evolve the way we advocate for the arts?</strong></p><p>Let’s take a step back and look at how we evaluate impact in other sectors. In the world of business, decisions have become data-driven in ways we could hardly have predicted a few years ago. Business analysts can mine, model, and study business centric data, in order to improve their sales and many other variables, choosing a variety of data sources such as public, commercial and social media data.</p><p><strong><em>How can we bring this way of thinking to the arts? Are there nonprofit arts organizations that use (or can use) some of the same sophisticated analytics and sentiment-monitoring tools that today’s businesses use to measure and predict their impact?</em></strong></p><p>How might arts organizations benefit? What if an opera company or a local symphony orchestra, could more effectively measure <em>who</em> they are, (and are not) reaching, <em>how</em> their audiences feel about a performance, and <em>why</em> certain segments of the population would attend, or even donate?</p><p>This approach of evaluation is considerably more in depth than a survey; we are asking organizations to actually test ideas with predictive analytics models and obtain statistics that would permit them to more effectively schedule special events, performances, or to improve the likelihood of an audience’s return for future performances.</p><p>Could we create an analytics study before committing to an entire season of Shostakovich?</p><p>Could we use data on previous donors to create a targeted donor strategy model? With data and analytics, we as the arts sector could make more effective decision making and fewer costly errors. More importantly, we may be able to provide a more satisfied, evidence based method of feedback for donors, grantmakers, and artists themselves.</p><p><strong>How may this affect arts policy?</strong></p><p>To create change in how we advocate for the arts, we can manufacture new technology, indexes and metrics, but we must turn to policy to truly lead us forward. Arts policy has traditionally lacked in providing direct and compelling tools for arts advocacy. Arts policy, which can range from legislation to evaluation, has focused on researching the importance of the arts rather than evaluating it. By creating more sophisticated tools to help us monitor and evaluate the impact of the arts, we can deepen policy. First and foremost, federal, state, and local governments can adopt and adapt methods of evaluation that will monitor impact to create evidence-based truths for the arts. It will require us to partner with the organizations such as Americans for the Arts or the National Endowment for the Arts to hold policy roundtables or institutes. However there is also an expanding need for more focused arts policy vocabulary, so that when asked by our citizens and representatives, “What is the role of arts and culture in our communities?” our leaders are equipped with the language and strategy to articulate the importance of the arts. Stronger methods of arts evaluation can impact the type of policy we create around arts evaluation, but it can also help strengthen legislation. For example, by having a more robust view on how the Metropolitan Museum of Art affects the surrounding neighborhoods in Manhattan, from demographics to economics, we can create legislation that protects or promotes diversity of culture and equality within our communities.</p><p><strong>How will this change our communities?</strong></p><p>By using tools and stronger methods of evaluation, we may be able to prove that arts and culture are necessary, central, and useful to advance the wellbeing and vibrancy of our communities. Our support can help small, local arts businesses take shape and make a name for themselves. We should be able to make a case for why a developer must build an arts collective in the neighborhood rather than a call center or a high rise. Ultimately stronger arts evaluation will help our communities grow; not necessarily in size, but in richness, and in spirit and eventually economic vitality. As I see it, arts and culture can promote and develop meaning in our communities which will make us more connected in an increasingly disconnected society, and lead us to invest.</p><p>But, we have to first prove that this meaning and growth actually exists.</p><p>It will take the intersection of policy, strategy, and community, but with the right tools, we can make a case for why arts should be a part of the forethought, not an afterthought when building communities.</p><p><strong>Will you help launch the evolution of arts evaluation?</strong></p><p>How do these ideas sit you? Do you want to help?<strong> I’d really like to hear from you! </strong>Please share your thoughts and/or feedback in comments.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=351396dd09e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The NEA Gave Me Life. Please, Don’t Take it Away.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@meerachakravarthy/the-nea-gave-me-life-please-dont-take-it-away-c558ac06cda8?source=rss-20d0f166c8da------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c558ac06cda8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arts-advocacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Meera Chakravarthy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Apr 2017 04:05:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-10T04:13:28.544Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The NEA Gave Me Life. Please, Don’t Take it Away.</strong></p><p><em>“Art is a nation’s most precious heritage. For it is in our works of art that we reveal to ourselves, and to others, the inner vision which guides us as a Nation. And where there is no vision, the people perish.”</em> –Lyndon B. Johnson, 1965</p><p>When I was four, my family gave me a toy piano keyboard. It had about 20 keys in all the colors of the rainbow, with every feature a toddler could wish for, including the option to create farm animal sounds. To this day, I still remember excitedly running up to my parents with the keyboard in hand, sitting them down in the living room, and making them listen to my premiere piece titled “Ding Dong Poli.” With lyrics and music by Meera Chakravarthy, this short, less than 30 second piece took the audience up and down a C# major scale with the words “Ding Dong Poli’s on her way today” outlining the story of a girl who had come to save the world today… <strong>with her music.</strong></p><p>This essay is not meant to detail in depth the economic value of the arts, nor will it provide a series of facts and figures on why the arts sector should be saved at the federal level. Great organizations and advocacy groups are already on top of this, such as Americans for the Arts. This essay details my story of how the arts, and specifically the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA), have shaped the American I am today, and the American I will continue to become.</p><p>Growing up in an Indian family in the suburbs of Kansas City, I might easily have been expected to spend my day to day studying for the SAT or dreaming about the Ivy League school I would someday attend. On the contrary, as a young girl in Overland Park, Kansas, I found a life for myself in marching band. The place I felt most energized, supported, and at peace with myself was on the football field with a flute parallel to the ground at all times, eyes on the conductor’s hand, and feet moving smoothly across the turf — heel, ball, toe — step! Marching band, an arts program within my public school system, taught me more about what I wanted from life than any other program, institution, person, or experience. While I didn’t take the route many high school music lovers did by becoming an arts educator or professional classical musician, the arts left a massive impression on me that I yearned to explore beyond classrooms, halls, and studio walls…</p><p><strong>We mustn’t stop federal support of arts education. </strong>Over the past 50 years, the National Endowment for the Arts has supported more than $238.6 million dollars in arts education. However, the support that the NEA has given to arts education runs deeper than just grants. The NEA helps arts education grow as a field. Throughout the years, the NEA has published reports such as<a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/Arts-At-Risk-Youth.pdf"><em> The Arts and Achievement in At Risk Youth: Findings from Four Longitudinal Studies</em></a><em> </em>to show how arts education has led to stronger civic engagement, creativity, and better thinkers. In addition to research on the impact of arts education, the NEA’s professional development grants help the actual arts educators in our country become stronger teachers. We want arts to be available to not only the student who is in a magnet music school in Manhattan, but also to the aspiring painter in rural Iowa. From “collective impact grants” that help local K-12 schools partner with city agencies and local businesses, to strategic education planning, the NEA helps arts remain available and accessible to each student in our democracy and is present in every congressional district in the United States. <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/Arts_Education_fact_sheet_nov2016.pdf">(cite)</a></p><p>When I entered college at UNC Chapel Hill, I chose to major in both music and economics. Anyone who has studied music seriously (or any art for that matter) understands the deep-set competition that inevitably comes with this field. <em>Did you get first chair orchestra? At what tempo are you playing the Bach in C major?</em> I quickly learned that I had not had a similar artistic upbringing to many of my peers. I hadn’t trained from the age of 5 with private tutors or orchestra camps, rather, as I mentioned, I grew up in suburban Kansas, picked up flute in my 5th grade elementary school, and took lessons at the music store in the strip mall down the street. In college, I was an average flautist whose main music exposure was through my public school system. In my youth, I had attended school plays, musicals, and band shows; not ballets, operas and orchestras. Because I didn’t draw my inspiration from “high art forms” grounded in the private sector, my college music interests and experiences were more eclectic than what I would have gotten in a traditional conservatory setting. I engaged in deep-set cross-cultural dialogue, community music ensembles, and I <em>studied</em> the role and the evaluation of public access to the arts in making a community a more vibrant space. If my exposure to the arts had been solely through “high-culture”, highly competitive arts, I likely would not still be in arts. Rather, my experiences as a music major in a public American institution beautifully shaped me, not only as a flautist, but as a well-rounded and self-aware student of the arts.</p><p><em>“Where there’s liberty, art succeeds.”</em> -Ronald Reagan, 1985</p><p><strong>Public support of the arts is vital to the well-being of all Americans</strong>. Federal funding is meant to democratize our country, not stratify and divide it. If we leave arts funding to the private sector we encourage a form of competition that could ultimately restrict funds from reaching the very rural and developing areas of our country that we want to reach in order to “make America great again.” For example, without funding supported by taxes at every level, from federal taxes to a local special-use sales tax passed by its very own residents, McPherson, Kansas could never have restored its opera house, today a thriving part of the local economy and the regional arts ecosystem. On their website, the opera house leadership states, “<em>Funding came from individual donors, foundations, government and private grants, as well as from State and Federal Rehabilitation Tax Credits — government done right.” </em><a href="http://www.mcphersonoperahouse.org/aboutUs.htm"><em>(cite)</em></a></p><p>In areas of the economy where our federal administration is boasting that it will restore jobs, such as the coal mining industry, federal arts funding has distinctly improved the community and quality of life with accessible art. As the West Virginia Division of Culture and History states, ”<em>Through grants and technical services funded by the West Virginia Legislature and the National Endowment for the Arts, we collaborate with artists, schools and nonprofit organizations to help provide cultural activities that improve the quality of life in West Virginia, help provide a complete education to our children and boost economic development in communities throughout the state”.</em><a href="http://www.wvculture.org/arts/artsindex.aspx"><em> (cite)</em></a></p><p>If left entirely to the private sector, it is inevitable that donors and philanthropists will have more than just a say in who and what gets funded. By letting only the private sector control arts funding, we allow that sector to dictate the standards of artistic excellence and merit to our American people, rather than the arts organizations themselves. Using federal funds for the advancement of the arts is really no different from the rationale for federal commitment to support basic research in other disciplines such as the sciences. When we want to fund specific treatments of a disease so rare with little commercial interest, we fund it with tax dollars because we as citizens believe that a solution is more important than mere commercial viability. Federal arts funding works very similarly — if it didn’t, American artistic expression would be less the vision of a democracy and more a menu of what will yield short-term profit for a commercial business.</p><p>Every 3 years, my family would travel back to our hometown of Bangalore, India. The summer of my sophomore year in college, I committed to taking traditional Bansuri (indian bamboo flute) lessons and interviewing local musicians and relatives. With each new lesson, I learned not just to understand, but to play the very Carnatic music I grew up listening to in the car. Through informal interviews, I learned of the hidden talents many of my family members possessed, and I felt their joy consume them as they excitedly ran into their closets to pull out old cassette tapes of their music — something they hadn’t been asked about for around 40 years. When I returned to my university after my trip, I devoted an entire independent study to Indian music theory and practice, even composing a flute recital around Indian music in order to expose my friends and family to the art of fusion music. My experiences with the folk and traditional art of my own culture were part of the process of self-discovery for me as a musician, and as an American. Studying the music of India helped me understand the unique nuances I bring, whether that is to the classroom, a group of friends, or even a business meeting.</p><p><strong>Engaging in Folk and Traditional Arts helps us understand our America.</strong> While America is comprised of almost innumerable cultures, languages, religions, orientations, and more, still, out of many, we are one. Understanding each other’s individual stories allows us to blend these into a communal narrative; recognizing and valuing our diversity can actually help us form community. The NEA acknowledges this by supporting folklife arts. From funding basket weaving apprenticeship programs to maritime construction, the NEA understands the value of passing down disciplined cultural practices to help America continuously understand itself, and its people. The NEA has funded diverse traditions that have led to programs such as digital storytelling and unique research fieldwork, ultimately enabling state arts agencies and local nonprofits to better engage with their underserved communities. As humans, we will continually be singing mariachi music, doing Cambodian dances, and painting Afghanistan artwork in order to express ourselves. The NEA’s support of this work, and the understanding that it brings, helps unify us as a nation.<a href="https://www.arts.gov/artistic-fields/folk-traditional-arts"> (cite)</a></p><p>As I struggled to make meaning of a competitive music world, I found myself grounded in the arts for the first time when I ventured out of my college town into Durham, North Carolina. It was 2013 — the night my friend Ledah took me to see her violin professor play in a small, funky venue off of Main Street. We ate at a pub and were lost for 20 minutes before finding the venue: a square hut-like building with green and blue smoke spiraling upward. I remember needing to finish an economics assignment that night, but thinking “Who in the world can think about the money market when we can sit in this space and listen to this music?” I was transfixed. That night in Durham, I finally understood how my majors, music and economics, actually intersected in the real world. At last I was truly<em> </em>communicating with the community in my new home of North Carolina. I actually felt the <em>space</em> around me falling into <em>place</em>. I knew this feeling — this macro view of the role of the arts in a community — was what I wanted to share with the world.</p><p>In 1965 when the NEA was created, Lyndon B. Johnson said <em>“It is in the neighborhoods of each community that a nation’s art is born. In countless American towns there live thousands of obscure and unknown talents. What this bill really does is to bring active support to this great national asset, to make fresher the winds of art in this great land of ours.”</em><a href="http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=27279"> (cite)</a></p><p><strong>The NEA sets national standards for arts communities across America</strong>. The NEA has dedicated time to foster partnerships with, and among, state and regional arts organizations in every state. These partnership agreements help create a shared set of priorities to ensure that each individual in our nation benefits from engaging in the arts. It matches state government funds, while regional organizations are matched by private support. The NEA requires that states must allocate a portion of their funding to strengthen arts education and serve underserved populations. Without being the “overbearing parent”, the NEA sets guidelines so that states all across America have a model to provide the best artistic support to every citizen in our nation. If this model did not exist, communities all over America, especially rural communities, would almost certainly not have the support system they need to create a vibrant arts environment in their town.<a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/State_and_Regional_fact_sheet_nov2016.pdf"> (cite)</a></p><p>As a senior in college, I had finally found the blend of academia and the arts. After studying the impact of the arts in my nearby community of Durham, I yearned to find a way to study this more systematically and on many more levels. When I told my advisor, Emil Kang, this, he immediately introduced me to a concept called “creative placemaking,” a term coined by the NEA in 2010 that represented the policy of putting arts and culture in the center of urban planning. That year, I both interned at arts organizations that practiced creative placemaking and wrote a senior thesis on measuring the impact of creative placemaking through social media data. You see, the funny thing about “creative placemaking” is that it’s just putting a new name on a practice that has existed for centuries. As human beings, we yearn to put arts and culture in the center of our lives in order to thrive. Finally putting a name to this concept allows centralization of both resources and funding to help us cultivate the best places for us to dwell.</p><p><strong>The NEA creates life in communities. Please, don’t take that away</strong>. In the 2000s there was a shift in the NEA. The new chairman led the NEA to become closer to Lyndon B. Johnson’s vision: an agency focused on supporting the arts through research and community development grants. Up until the late 2000s, the NEA had little or nothing to do with revitalization projects. Moreover, the NEA was recovering from a reduction in arts funding due to the “NEA Four” artist scandal, when four artists were taken to court in the 1990’s because their projects were deemed by some to be too controversial to be funded by taxpayer money. Although the artists’ projects were ultimately funded, Congress decided it was best to simply stop funding all individual-artist projects, changing the nature of NEA funding. The nonprofit arts sector was also losing ground as federal and state funding waned, so rather than funding specific artists, the NEA found a new way to fund the arts. Appointed chairman of the NEA in 2009, Rocco Landesman soon addressed the country’s changing urban trends. He noted that areas across America were adopting the “creative city” model as they revitalized their old industrial and manufacturing centers. Landesman saw this as an opportunity to make the arts a part of the revitalization process. Chairman Landesman began work on a new form of arts funding — community-building projects through the perspective of the arts. These grants were designed to minimize gentrification even as they helped revitalize spaces, especially in rural towns across America, hence, “creative placemaking.” Since 2009, the NEA has created an entire division to champion creative placemaking projects and fund creative placemaking through Our Town Grants. These grants have funded artist communities all over the US; surprisingly, perhaps, 60% of those artist communities are found in rural areas.<a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/Artist_Communities_fact_sheet_nov2016.pdf"> (cite)</a></p><p>It’s true that you never understand something fully until you experience it. The day I attended my first NEA public meeting, my perspective on the arts was altered forever. From meeting members of the NEA to listening to accounts of the work they did, such as helping veterans through music therapy, I understood a layer of the arts ecosystem that touched and guided all of us. Finally, here was an agency that had the same passion for research, education, and awareness of the arts that I did <strong><em>at a level that I wanted.</em></strong> In those few short hours, I saw how this agency affected my entire life: from 4 year old Meera in suburban Kansas to 23 year old cosmopolitan Meera in Washington, DC.</p><p>Today, I find myself in Washington, DC as a management consultant for a great technology firm. My passion for studying the macro impact of the arts through evaluation methods and data analytics has led me to get more training and understanding in the corporate world to bring back to the arts field in the near future. Though I do not work directly in the arts, I breathe it every single day. Whether that is composing Indian fusion music, or blogging about arts and technology, I live the arts ecosystem on all of its levels. And I know that without this top layer — the National Endowment for the Arts of the United States of America, the ecosystem cannot long survive.</p><p><strong>You see, the NEA has given me hope, and in turn happiness</strong>. When I did not want to be a solo musician or a teacher in the arts, the NEA helped me find a home in the arts nonetheless. And to this day it continues to shape and build that home through its numerous projects.</p><p>The NEA itself is never going to be a cultural trendsetter, nor should it be. It’s not going to singlehandedly create the next Broadway star. It is an institution founded to support and promote the development of the arts across our nation. Its existence is vital as a thought leader, a research institution, and a national nonpartisan supporter of the arts. We may need to rebrand the NEA to better fit its research role, modernize it to fund more technology-oriented and popular work, or create a more robust grant allocation and evaluation process. However, none of those changes requires the NEA’s destruction.</p><p><em>“I am certain that after the dust of centuries has passed over our cities, we, too, will be remembered not for victories or defeats in battle or in politics, but for our contribution to the human spirit.”</em>- John F. Kennedy, 1962</p><p>When our world is in violent disarray, and lives are at stake every day, you may ask, why care about the arts? Isn’t it a luxury? Well…I ask you, is happiness a luxury? Is love a luxury? Is understanding the world a luxury? No, these qualities, the very qualities that drive the arts, are all part of our human nature. Surely, it is the role of our government to protect what is human.</p><p>Our government, when it is a true manifestation of our Declaration of Independence and our Constitution, is in the business of guaranteeing us three main rights: life, liberty… and the pursuit of happiness. <strong>How, then, can our government help us pursue happiness if our government does not actively pursue and support the arts?</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c558ac06cda8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>