<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by arasinya on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by arasinya on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@melda_namarie?source=rss-56aa8e65b8b3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 07:35:20 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@melda_namarie/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where Pain and Delight Flow Together]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@melda_namarie/where-pain-and-delight-flow-together-b29a387b1e69?source=rss-56aa8e65b8b3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b29a387b1e69</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[eucatastrophe]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[arasinya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Feb 2025 19:33:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-17T19:13:12.714Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Tolkien’s Concept of Eucatastrophe in <em>Piranesi</em></h4><p>(A project written for Contemporary Fantasy Literature: An Introduction 2024)</p><p>In the third volume of J.R.R. Tolkien’s <em>The Lord of the Rings</em>, after the shadow of Sauron has been vanquished, the hosts of Gondor and Rohan gather upon the Field of Cormallen to celebrate their victory. Amid the mingling of triumph and grief, where the echoes of battle still linger, Aragorn rises and calls for silence. In that hush, a minstrel of Gondor steps forward, and he sang:</p><blockquote>“now in the Elven-tongue, now in the speech of the West, until their hearts, wounded with sweet words, overflowed, and their joy was like swords, and they passed in thought out to regions where pain and delight flow together and tears are the very wine of blessedness.” (The Return of the King)</blockquote><p>The minstrel’s song, evoking both the sweetness of victory and the ache of loss, encapsulates the paradox at the heart of Tolkien’s work: that joy and sorrow are deeply interwoven. This tension partly finds its expression in the concept of <em>eucatastrophe</em>, a term Tolkien coined in his essay <em>On Fairy-Stories</em> to describe a sudden, joyous shift that arises from despair — a narrative “turn” that does not negate suffering but is born from it. <em>Eucatastrophe</em> is not merely an occasional device in Tolkien’s legendarium; it is a central principle reflecting his belief that redemption is powerful only when it emerges against “<em>dyscatastrophe,” </em>the shadow of sorrow and failure. This idea is integral to Tolkien’s concept of consolation, also elaborated in <em>On Fairy-Stories</em>. For Tolkien, consolation is more than mere comfort; it is an emotional and spiritual fulfillment that offers hope, joy, and a reaffirmation of meaning even in the face of suffering. It is a recognition of a deeper truth — a glimpse beyond the ordinary struggles of life toward the possibility of ultimate joy and redemption.</p><p>While Tolkien’s narratives are rich with dramatic instances of <em>eucatastrophe</em>, Susanna Clarke’s <em>Piranesi</em> offers a subtler reflection of this concept. Through the protagonist’s solitary journey of self-discovery, <em>Piranesi</em> resonates with Tolkien’s idea of consolation. The novel’s melancholic tone and the protagonist’s solitary psychological transformation evoke a gentler form of <em>eucatastrophe</em> — not a single miraculous event, but a gradual, inward revelation of beauty and meaning, rooted not in external events but in an interior transformation that reforms the enduring presence of wonder.</p><h4>The Imperfect Worlds of Peril</h4><p>The stories of both Tolkien and Clarke are fundamentally melancholic because of the imperfections embedded within their worlds. Yet, it is precisely these flaws that make the beauty more striking, the redemption sweeter. In <em>Piranesi</em>, one of the key components contributing to its desolate tone is the setting of the (secondary) world. The House, vast and sublime, is also a space marked by fragmentation, loss, and forgotten histories. It echoes with the remnants of what once was, now irretrievably lost, at least according to the academics Valentine Ketterley and Laurence Arne-Sayles, who discovered it. The House contains countless statues, each representing entities, memories, or ideas from a reality the protagonist can no longer fully access. As Piranesi observes, he sometimes cannot grasp the meaning of the statues or the remnants of a past he barely remembers. This incompleteness is shown in his exchange with Arne-Sayles, where he asks, <em>“Do the Statues exist because they embody the Ideas and Knowledge that flowed out of the other World into this one?”</em> Arne-Sayles responds affirmatively, <em>“I think that highly likely”</em> reflecting the statues’ role as relics of the real world, fragments that have lost their full meaning for those who dwell too long in the House. Though filled with grand forms, the House is haunted by absence; it is marred because it exists as a collection of symbols disconnected from their original referents. Persistent decay is presented through the isolation of the self and the slow, inevitable fading of once-vivid truths, as the protagonist reflects on the gap between his fragmented reality and the fullness of what once was.</p><p>Moreover, the quality of the imperfection of the House is explicitly acknowledged when the protagonist guides Raphael through the House after the flood. As she reflects on the crimes committed against Piranesi and others, she remarks bitterly, <em>“I said that this is a perfect world. But it’s not. There are crimes here, just like everywhere else.”</em> This admission shatters the illusion of the House as a beautiful heaven the protagonist perceived. The House, despite its grandeur, is not immune to the moral failings and cruelties that plague the real world. Its beauty exists alongside darkness, with the echoes of exploitation and manipulation embedded in its very walls.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XmdhxwdlEdEvF0jzMMJ6ow.jpeg" /><figcaption>Giovanni Battista Piranesi, <em>Le Carceri d’Invenzione, plate X: Prisoners on a Projecting Platform</em> (detail) (circa 1750)</figcaption></figure><p>The notion of a marred reality and a sense of decay in the House reminds me of the concept of <em>Arda Marred</em> in Tolkien’s legendarium. In <em>The Lord of the Rings</em> Book II, as the Fellowship is brought before Galadriel, she mentions this enduring struggle to Frodo, saying, <em>“For ere the fall of Nargothrond or Gondolin I passed over the mountains, and together through ages of the world we have fought the long defeat.”</em> The “long defeat” encapsulates the Elves’ struggle against the inevitable decline of beauty, goodness, and light in a world tainted by Melkor’s corruption. The fall of Nargothrond and Gondolin, once great Elven realms, marks the tragic loss of beauty and wisdom to the creeping shadow of evil. As depicted in <em>The Silmarillion</em>, the Elves, the most beautiful children of Ilúvatar, witness the world grow dim through their eternal lives. They have seen the Two Lamps that once lit Arda toppled by Melkor, followed by the destruction of the Two Trees of Valinor by Melkor and Ungoliant. Throughout the ages, they watch evil seep into every corner of Arda, darkening even the brightest places. Despite this, the Elves remain beings filled with goodness and peace amid their sorrow. As Sam describes them in <em>The Fellowship of the Ring</em>, <em>“They are quite different from what I expected — so old and young, and so gay and sad, as it were.”</em> This duality captures the essence of their beauty: eternal yet fading, joyful yet marked by grief.</p><p>Similarly, in <em>Piranesi</em>, the protagonist (transformed, no longer the original Matthew Rose Sorenson at this point) finds wonder amid ruins. Despite the harshness of his existence — facing constant cold, scarcity of food and nutrition (being fed multivitamins regularly), and the lack of proper clothing — he approaches the world with an unwavering sense of curiosity, kindness, and awe. He endures loneliness and deprivation, relying on meager supplies and surviving in an environment indifferent to his needs, yet his spirit remains untouched by bitterness. Instead of despair, he is filled with gratitude and reverence for the House, believing <em>“The Beauty of the House is immeasurable; its Kindness infinite,”</em> even after he no longer resides in the House and has witnessed the ugliness of the real world. His ability to find solace amid desolation reflects a quiet strength, mirroring Tolkien’s characters who persist in goodness despite living in a reality marred by imperfection.</p><p>As said by Haldir, an Elf of Lothlórien, while he leads the Fellowship through the forest after their harrowing escape from Moria, <em>“The world is indeed full of peril, and in it there are many dark places; but still there is much that is fair, and though in all lands love is now mingled with grief, it grows perhaps the greater.”</em> It is because the world is filled with peril that beauty shines more brightly, and the shadow of darkness lays the ground for moments of unexpected grace and joy.</p><h4>Tolkien’s Eucatastrophe: Joy Sharp as Swords and Poignant as Grief</h4><p>Tolkien defines eucatastrophe as “the sudden joyous turn” in a story, and this joy is sharp like swords. The suddenness of eucatastrophe is what gives it its emotional force — an unexpected burst of light piercing through overwhelming darkness. This concept is significantly represented in the scene of the destruction of the Ring. As Frodo succumbs to the Ring’s power and claims it as his own, all hope seems lost, and the long quest appears to have failed. Yet, in a sudden turn, Gollum intervenes, seizing the Ring and falling into the fires of Mount Doom. This unforeseen act embodies the nature of eucatastrophe: a sudden, unexpected redemption born from despair. Frodo’s triumph comes not from his own strength but through an unexpected grace. This is the paradox of eucatastrophe: the joy of salvation carries the shadow of failure, making the sharpness of this joy transformative. It cuts through despair with piercing clarity, both wounding and healing, leaving behind a joy that is as bittersweet as it is profound.</p><p>Yet there is another scene that illustrates this sharpness more intimately. In <em>The Return of the King</em>, when Sam, exhausted and hopeless in Mordor, looks up and sees a single star shining in the dark sky: <em>“The beauty of it smote his heart, as he looked up out of the forsaken land, and hope returned to him. For like a shaft, clear and cold, the thought pierced him that in the end the Shadow was only a small and passing thing: there was light and high beauty forever beyond its reach.”</em> Surrounded by overwhelming darkness, this sudden realization of hope is like a blade of light, cutting through despair and leaving Sam momentarily breathless with the stark beauty of that distant star.</p><p>This usually unreachable, fragile moment of hope shines because of the overwhelming darkness surrounding it. Tolkien acknowledges that in the case of eucatastrophe, <em>“the possibility of these [sorrows] is necessary for the joy of deliverance.”</em> The fusion of joy and grief, like “tears being the wine of blessedness,” is part of the core of Tolkien’s narrative vision. It is the sudden, piercing nature of this joy, like a sword that not only cuts through the darkness but leaves a gleaming edge where light and shadow meet, that makes it striking yet enduring.</p><h4>Eucatastrophe in <em>Piranesi</em>: The Progression Towards Joy</h4><p>While <em>Piranesi</em> lacks the dramatic eucastastrophic events seen in Tolkien’s work, its narrative is imbued with eucatastrophe through the protagonist’s personal journey of acceptance. His path is marked by psychological progression, shaped by the gradual unraveling of his fragmented identity and the haunting echoes of a life he can no longer fully recall. At the start of the novel, Piranesi exists in a state of, shall I say, blissful ignorance, living harmoniously within the vast labyrinth of endless halls, statues, and tides. His journal entries reveal a mind at peace, filled with curiosity and reverence for the House’s immeasurable beauty. However, as he begins to uncover inconsistencies in his understanding of the world — realizing that his memory is fractured — this tranquil existence gives way to internal conflict.</p><p>The pages of his journal reveal not just the world around him but fragments of a past long buried, the earlier life of Matthew Rose Sorensen. This realization emerges gradually, not as a sudden revelation but as a faint trace that becomes clearer as the plot unfolds. His initial curiosity grows from the quiet confusion of noticing gaps in his memory and inconsistencies in his understanding of the House. As he delves deeper into his records, the conflict within him intensifies, driven by a need to reconcile the life he knows with the life he may have forgotten. This tension reaches a turning point with the introduction of 16, whose presence challenges the protagonist’s perceptions and marks a significant shift in his psychological transformation.</p><p>Initially, Piranesi grapples with the Other’s warnings about 16, caught between the pull of innate curiosity and the shadow of fear instilled by manipulation. Yet their brief, charged interactions plant the seeds of doubt. As he uncovers more of his past through his journals, the foundation of the Other’s authority begins to crumble. Piranesi gradually detaches emotionally from the Other, as his heart realigns with the quiet, steadfast presence of 16. In time, clarity pierces the fog: <em>“It is 16 that is my friend and not the Other.” </em>This simple realization carries the weight of a revelation, not forged in sudden epiphany but through the gentle, persistent discovery of the reality.</p><p>16, later revealed as Raphael, represents the light of reason and knowledge. Grounded in the real world, she becomes the bridge between realms, a thread connecting ignorance to understanding. She does not come as a savior to drag Piranesi from his sanctuary, but as a quiet guide, her presence a beacon rather than a command. Despite her mission to recover Matthew Rose Sorensen, Raphael does not force Piranesi to confront his past. She exhibits profound empathy, respecting his pace and gently guiding rather than pulling him from the secondary world he cherishes. This empathy is coupled with pragmatism; she acknowledges the House’s significance to Piranesi, even though it serves as both sanctuary and prison. Raphael understands that the resolution of Piranesi’s internal conflict is not something that can be rushed; it is a gradual process that requires both time and space. By offering him the freedom to explore his fragmented identity at his own rhythm, she becomes instrumental in his psychological journey. Her quiet presence creates a space where Piranesi can confront the painful truths of his past without coercion. This patience is what allows him to gradually integrate his memories and experiences, fostering a transformation of acceptance.</p><p>The gradual pace in <em>Piranesi</em> stands in stark contrast to the sudden nature of eucatastrophe in Tolkien’s works. Where Tolkien often depicts abrupt turns of fortune — moments where hope bursts forth like a star at the very brink of despair — Clarke presents healing as something slow and unfolding. In Tolkien, the sharp, piercing joy of eucatastrophe strikes like lightning, dramatic and immediate. In contrast, Piranesi’s transformation is like the slow erosion of stone by water: gentle and persistent. Raphael does not deliver salvation in an instant; instead, she is a figure who provides the steady light by which Piranesi can find his own way out of the labyrinth. This slow progression towards self-acceptance makes the joy he finds quieter but equally profound, not forged in a sudden revelation but through enduring reflection, courage, and the slow acceptance of all that he is. In the end, the development and transformation of Sorenson is not marked by triumph but by acceptance, the soft echo of a heart learning to carry its own story, and still choose to see beauty around, even in brokenness.</p><p>In both Tolkien’s <em>The Lord of the Rings</em> and Clarke’s <em>Piranesi</em>, the journey towards consolation is rooted in the interplay between sorrow and joy, imperfection and beauty. Tolkien’s concept of eucatastrophe reveals that even in the face of overwhelming darkness, a sudden, piercing joy can emerge — sharp as swords, radiant against despair. In contrast, Clarke presents a more subdued form of <em>eucatastrophe</em>, where transformation develops gradually through introspection. Despite their differing approaches, both narratives affirm a notion in common: it is because the world is marred and fragile that beauty holds such weight, and it is through suffering that the possibility of redemption gains its significance.</p><h4>Is Everything Sad Going to Come Untrue?</h4><p>Returning to <em>On Fairy-Stories</em>, Tolkien reflects on a question often asked by children regarding fairytales, as noted by Andrew Lang: “Is it true?” Tolkien acknowledges this fundamental yearning and responds with a layered answer. At first, he states simply: if the secondary world is built well, then “yes: it is true in that world.” But then Tolkien goes further, suggesting that in the moment of eucatastrophe, the answer to “Is it true?” transcends the boundaries of fiction, engaging with a spiritual truth, “a far-off gleam or echo of <em>evangelium</em> in the real world.” For Tolkien, this joy reflects a fragment of the Gospel, suggesting that fairy-stories resonate with humanity’s deepest hopes for redemption, for a reality where sorrow can be undone.</p><p>This longing can be found in <em>The Return of the King</em> when Frodo awakens in Ithilien after the destruction of the Ring. Seeing Gandalf alive, he gasps: <em>“Gandalf! I thought you were dead! But then I thought I was dead myself. Is everything sad going to come untrue?” </em>This question, filled with wonder and disbelief, captures the essence of the human yearning for hope beyond grief. Perhaps in time closer to our own, people also ask the same question, again and again, while wandering through the dilapidated halls of life, facing struggles, burdened by the unknown, wishing it weren’t so. As depicted in Matthew Rose Sorenson’s journey through the endless halls of the House, to confront what is sad can sometimes make the anguish feel so overwhelmingly unbearable. Yet, at least in a well-built fairy-story, there will be moments when joy overwhelms despair. In such stories, there exists the possibility that sadness can come untrue — not undone, but transfigured into something that speaks of grace or beauty, however brief.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/735/1*Ufq-L8Zkym2AEpyA6-6gZw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>works cited and references</h4><p>Clarke, Susanna. 2020. Piranesi.</p><p>Tolkien, J.R.R., 1992, The Silmarillion</p><p>Tolkien, J. R. R. 1966. The Fellowship of the Ring. 2nd ed.</p><p>Tolkien, J. R. R. 1966. The Return of the King. 2nd ed.</p><p>Tolkien, J. R. R., Verlyn Flieger, and Douglas A. Anderson. 2008. Tolkien on Fairy-Stories. Expanded edition, with commentary and notes.</p><p>Tolkien Gateway’s entries on Arda Marred and the Long Defeat</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b29a387b1e69" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>