<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 05:19:25 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Living in the face of death]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/living-in-the-face-of-death-3d288b70c12f?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3d288b70c12f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[existentialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 May 2025 06:00:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-23T06:36:59.241Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*VCqIxx_pESAJxclV6r_khA.jpeg" /></figure><p>It is an inescapable reality, a timeless law of nature. From the moment we are born, one thing is certain: one day we will die. It happens to all of us, the ancient Roman philosopher Seneca already pointed out, “it happened to your father, your mother, your forefathers, it happens to all people before you and after you.” As far as we know, humans are the only living beings on earth who are aware of this. We have to face death, whether we like it or not. “Death stands there as the only reality,” the French existentialist philosopher Albert Camus wrote in <em>The Myth of Sisyphus</em>. And so we have to find a way to deal with this reality.</p><p>Some people would rather not think about death. Death freaks them out, because it is, well, the end. Final and irreversible. This is true. “After death, everything ends,” Camus said, and I share his conviction. Death is the end of life and after that, nothing follows. So why is it that there are many people who believe that after death, something <em>will</em> follow? A new life, a heavenly existence. Stories and myths about death and what comes after exist in almost all cultures and religions. The German philosopher Wilhelm Schmid therefore argues that the idea of ​​death as “the absolute boundary of life” is culturally determined. “Death does not necessarily mean that life is over in all respects, but that it is over in this form,” he writes. “Death is a boundary,” according to Schmid, but a boundary that “depends on the idea you have of it, and that in turn depends on the culture in which you live.”</p><p>In my opinion, Schmid takes relativism a step too far here. It’s a denial of what death is. These culturally determined ideas about death do not so much relate to what death actually is, but rather to what people <em>hope</em> it is. They reflect our lack of knowledge about death and appeal to people’s fear of it. People don’t want their lives to end, or their loved ones gone forever, so what if death <em>isn’t</em> really the end? With myths about death people try to alleviate the suffering of dying. (Also, these myths are used in a manipulative way to influence people’s behavior, by telling them that after ‘the last judgment’ they will be rewarded in heaven or doomed to burn in hell. An unacceptable form of religious mental abuse that only increases the fear of death.)</p><p>Myths promise a heavenly existence, or a return to earth (reincarnation), and thus create the image that life does not end; there is life after death. For many people, such myths provide a relief from fear or sorrow. But they are also ways of denying the truth, denying one’s own temporality, of not having to face the inevitable reality. For an existentialist, believing in such myths is a form of ‘bad faith’, of insincerity. Existentialists do not believe in life after death or in reincarnation. We only get one shot at life, this is it. And when we die, that’s the end. Our bodies cease to function. Our hearts stop beating, our brain activity — and thus our consciousness — ends, and our organs shut down. Then the natural process of decomposition begins, in which our bodies literally cease to exist. There is no ‘soul’ that lives on independently of our bodies. Death, whatever Wilhelm Schmid thinks of it, marks the “absolute boundary of life.”</p><p>And we have no choice. The fact that we will die is beyond our sphere of influence. We do not have the freedom to decide otherwise. Like it or not, death brings an end to our freedom. As Camus states, “I do not have the freedom to continue existing.” We do not even always have the freedom to choose between living and dying. Some people die without wanting to at that moment, as the result of an illness, or an accident, or an act of violence. (As a matter of fact: Camus himself tragically died in a car accident, after accepting a ride from his publisher and friend, even though he had initially planned to take the train. The train ticket was in his pocket when the car crashed…) Other people would like to die, but cannot or are not allowed to. (I think humans are the only species that forces their own kind to stay alive against their will.)</p><p>Although we talk about ‘death’, death is no more than a concept; it doesn’t exist in reality. Death is: not living. It is the absence of life. The Dutch philosopher Maarten van Buuren makes the comparison with light and darkness. Light exists, darkness does not, he argues, because darkness is nothing but the absence of light. The same applies to life and death. Death is the absence of life. Life exists, death does not. In other words: all there is, is existence and non-existence. Our life takes place in a brief span between not-yet-existing and no-longer-existing. Dying is the moment when existence changes into non-existence. This is not some modern idea from the era in which “God is dead” (dixit Friedrich Nietzsche), Roman philosopher Seneca already said it two thousand years ago: “Death is: not being,” he said, “after me comes the same as before me.” Or in the words of American writer Mark Twain: “To be dead will not be different from being unborn.” Personally, I find this view of ‘death’ not only plausible, but also very reassuring. “If death is truly the end, then what exactly is there to fear? [Death is] the end of fear,” as Ryan Holiday states in <em>The Daily Stoic</em>. Exactly. Death as the end, with nothing left after that, is a reassuring thought.</p><p>Yet many people find this idea hard to accept. They cannot grasp that there is nothing after we die, there <em>must</em> be something. People don’t want to die, at least not yet, and I get that. Most of us prefer to postpone our death as long as possible. Some people would even like to banish their end altogether, be immortal — which, of course, is impossible. It is simply a law of nature that everything in our lives, on our planet and in the universe is temporary. Everything around us, including ourselves, is, to use the words of British historian Edith Hall, “in a permanent process of coming into being or generation, growth, alteration, decay and cessation.” Writer Oliver Burkeman argues that death is actually not the main problem. “The real pain,” he says, “is of course that we are no longer alive.” Most people are attached to life and therefore they don’t want it to end. That’s why, according to the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle, we find death “the most terrible of all things, for it is the end.”</p><p>Admittedly, the idea of ​​dying can be frightening (personally I don’t mind the prospect of being dead, I do sometimes worry about <em>how</em> I will die. I hope it will be quick and painless). The idea of dying is scary because of the unfamiliarity with it, because we don’t know what it will be like. On the one hand dying is a universal human event — ​​it happens to all of us, we will all die one day. At the same time, it is an extremely individual event, which only we can experience ourselves. In the words of the German philosopher Rüdiger Safranski: “Everyone must die their own death.” Even if you have seen someone else die, you don’t know what it is like to die yourself. “Reflecting on our own death,” says the American existentialist philosopher Skye Cleary, “is a vague exercise in imagination. We can’t know what it feels like (…) we don’t know anything about what death involves in any subjective sense.” Dying isn’t something you can learn, or practice. It’s not even something you do, but something that happens to you. Even in the case of a self-chosen death, only the act that leads to death is something you do, the consequence — dying itself — is not. That happens. It’s a natural process. “Flawlessly executed and final,” as the French philosopher Michel de Montaigne dryly remarked.</p><p>Just as no one knows in advance what it is like to die, no one can say with certainty what it is like to be dead. We cannot know, simply because we no longer exist. We will one day experience dying, but it is impossible to experience death. We only experience death as a spectator, when other people die. We experience what it is like when someone is no longer here. But we cannot experience what it is like to no longer be here ourselves. “Try to imagine the absence of your own consciousness,” says Rüdiger Safranski. That is impossible. “Death is outside every experience of life and cannot be reconciled with it,” says German philosopher Erich Fromm. Plus there is no point in speculating about what will happen after you die. Edith Hall refers to the Chinese philosopher Kong Fuzi (better known by his Latinized name Confucius), who emphasized that it is more important “to lead a morally good life in the here and now, rather than speculating about ghosts or the afterlife.”</p><p>According to the ancient Greek philosopher Epicurus, we should not concern ourselves with death at all during our lives. Because, as he said, “when we exist, death is not yet present, and when death is present, then we do not exist.” Why bother? Existentialists would disagree. The fact that we will die one day is inextricably linked to our lives. And that knowledge, the realization that our lives will end at some point, is an integral part of our thinking and actions, whether we are very consciously aware of it or not. Even if we do not concern ourselves with death in the Epicurean way, we will at some point in our lives be confronted with the inescapable fact that our existence is temporary. That’s why it’s better to consciously relate to your own mortality. Not in a depressing, nihilistic sense (“what’s the point of it all if I’m going to die anyway?”), but to consciously choose life, to live your life the way you want to, and to enjoy it. “Acknowledgement of our mortality and confrontation with its full implications can be used effectively to help us to live and die well,” says Edith Hall. Someone like Steve Jobs also saw the value of this: “Reminding myself that I’m going to be dead in the not-too-distant future is the most important tool I’ve ever had to help me make the big choices in life,” he said before he, well, died.</p><p>The finitude of life can serve as a guideline for shaping your life, exactly because life <em>has</em> the end. Even philosopher Wilhelm Schmid agrees with that: “Death as the boundary of life calls people to live and strive for fulfillment. To do this, you do not have to be fixated on death, but only be aware of the boundary. The boundary of life is at the same time the condition that makes it possible: you destroy life if you want to have it forever, just as you destroy a lust if you want to enjoy it forever. All lust wants eternity, but eternity means its death; the same applies to life.” If you were immortal, you would fall into idleness. You would no longer get anything done, because you can keep postponing everything forever. “Why should you live your life now, if you can still do so in the distant future?” Schmid asks rhetorically. Immortality is not at all as attractive as it seems. According to Australian philosopher Roman Krznaric, this is what the phrase ‘carpe diem’ essentially means. ‘Carpe diem’ is not about living without restraints like there is no tomorrow, it’s about “keeping in mind that we do not have eternal life and therefore we must focus on what is really important, and remain true to our values ​​and our personal vision.” At some point in the future, you won’t be here anymore. And time passes quickly. “So don’t wait for life to happen to you,” Krznaric says, “start living it now. You only live once.”</p><p>Existentialists don’t think life has an inherent meaning, other than the meaning we give it. The same goes for death. Death itself is as meaningless as life, but we can give death meaning in our lives by living consciously, knowing our time on earth is finite, and being aware of our mortality. Not just letting life pass by, but really living it, while it lasts. Or in the words of Albert Camus: “Facing death. After that, anything is possible.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3d288b70c12f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The solo mindset and living authentically]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/the-solo-mindset-and-living-authentically-d172e00202d0?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d172e00202d0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[solo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[singles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authenticity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autonomy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 May 2025 08:45:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-16T08:45:46.709Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0Bdin4gMEvuEpiv_xoE_uQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I recently stumbled on the book <em>Solo</em>, by behavioral scientist Peter McGraw. In his book, McGraw explores various ways people can relate to being either single or in a relationship, other than riding the standard “relationship escalator”, i.e. dating, officially declaring to be in a relationship, moving in together, marrying, having kids. I was intrigued, because the standard model of marrying and having kids has never appealed to me. During my adult life I have been in and out of relationships, and the older I grew, the more obvious it became: I was not the kind who would settle, not in the traditional way at least. If only because I have always known I didn’t want to have children.</p><p>But what struck me the most was the concept of the solo identity. McGraw distinguishes being ‘solo’ from being ‘single’. “The solo mindset is independent of relationship status,” he writes. Solos are independent people, who do not rely on their relationship with others (whether romantic or platonic) and do not necessarily strive to be in a relationship just because that’s what society expects. Solos look “past conventions to design their own lives.” Hmm… Independent people, looking past conventions, designing their own life, that sounded very much like… me! The solo concept resonated with me, because it’s very much who I am.</p><p>In 2020 I wrote an essay titled <a href="https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/is-autonomy-a-myth-spoiler-no-it-is-not-c9b16fceceec"><em>‘Is autonomy a myth?’</em>,</a> in which I advocated living autonomously, which I described as “the freedom — within the framework of your circumstances — to decide independently and at your own discretion about how you want to live your own life.” I also noted that living autonomously lies at the heart of existentialism, the philosophy that is central to my writings. According to French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre “man is free” to choose who he wants to be. We are responsible for shaping our own lives. Given our circumstances, we choose how we want to live our lives, that is autonomy. In this sense, solos are existentialists. “Solos embrace autonomy, sovereignty and self-reliance,” McGraw writes. They live their lives “aligned with personal goals, tastes, values and lifestyle.”</p><p>Existentialists call this ‘living authentically.’ In my essay <a href="https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/on-authenticity-50f028f80ab6"><em>‘Authenticity: your values, your choice’</em></a> I wrote that the essence of authenticity is “that you make your own choices, freely and based on the values ​​that are important to you, and your idea of ​​how you want to live your life — regardless of what other people do.” I quoted Dutch philosopher Joep Dohmen, who said: “He is authentic who knows no fear of freedom, who has the courage not to conform to the prevailing norms, but who develops his own motives.” McGraw echos this view when he writes: “Solos are comfortable with values and lifestyles that may diverge from the dominant culture (…) They are not afraid of being alone; they embrace their solitude, their freedom, and their opportunity to create a life that is uniquely theirs.”</p><p>Although this is true, it may not always be easy. In another essay, <a href="https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/individuality-conformity-and-our-need-for-social-acceptance-954d70c6b4b3"><em>‘Individuality, conformity and our need for social acceptance’</em></a>, I noted that people massively conform to what other people do and to what (they think) society expects from them. “Few people dare to ignore that kind of ‘social expectations’. Who really make their own decisions and dare to choose their own path in life, even if by doing so they deviate from the ‘norm’,” I wrote. This urge to conform stems from our need for social acceptance. People have a deep-rooted need to feel accepted by those around them. To fit in, to belong. Going your own way takes courage. You need mental strength to resist social pressure and to make your own choices. To go it alone requires courage and mental resilience.</p><p><strong>Solos and authentic relationships</strong></p><p>McGraw stresses that being solo “is not about relationship status. It’s a perspective. A state of being.” Having a solo mindset means “Rejecting societal expectations of marriage and family.” Solos can “move in and out of relationships” and are perfectly fine being single. This is no doubt thanks to their autonomy, their need for freedom and solitude and their ability to go it alone. The key is: solos don’t <em>need</em> a relationship. Being in a relationship is not a goal in itself. Solos “view relationships — romantic or platonic — as a means to enhance life rather than repair it,” says McGraw.</p><p>This reflects the way existentialists view relationships. Looking for a relationship in order to complete us would be ‘bad faith’, or inauthentic, as existentialists call it. “It’s an escape from taking responsibility for pursuing our own fulfillment,” says existentialist philosopher Skye Cleary. In an authentic relationship, “each person trusts, appreciates, and respects one another as autonomous individuals who freely choose to be together.” People don’t cease to have a solo mindset when they are in a relationship. They remain the autonomous, independent, self-relient individuals they have always been, and want to shape their relationship according to their needs and wishes.</p><p>For this McGraw introduces the term ‘relationship design’, which he describes as “the process by which two or more people intentionally engage in cocreating a customized relationship.” People who design their own relationship aim to to suit their own needs and desires, “rather than defaulting into the rules expected by society.” Maybe somewhat naively, I always thought that <em>every</em> relationship was a relationship-by-design. People are different, so relationships are different, and that it’s up to the people involved create their own customized relationship as they wish. At least that’s how I have always approached my own relationships.</p><p>But of course that’s not what most people do. “You will find that few people have experience explicitly designing a relationship,” McGraw writes. Most people just “default in”, following the expectations of family members, friends, and wider society, riding the “relationship escalator.” Because that’s what people do, right? Well, no. Not people who have a solo mindset. Solos “customize relationships by prioritizing their own desires over societal expectations,” McGraw writes. That’s my kind of relationship. In a relationship-by-design, people communicate their needs, wishes and expectations. They look for compatibility, are open about their needs and wishes, share their ideas of a future together, and make clear their boundaries.</p><p>This reflects the way existentialists approach relationships. According to Skye Cleary in an authentic relationship, instead of defaulting in, people choose to <em>create</em> a relationship together. “It is up to lovers to work it out themselves,” says Cleary, “relationships will be different for everyone at different times in their lives.” In his book McGraw quotes a solo who is “looking for the Venn diagram where your wants and needs overlap my wants and needs.” Nicely put.</p><p>As McGraw says: “Not all singles are solos, and not all solos are single.” To that I would like to add: Not all solos are existentialists and not all existentialists are solo. But I think a solo mindset may just be a key element to an authentic, existentialist lifestyle.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d172e00202d0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why existentialists are atheists]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/why-existentialists-are-atheists-52671ecd8b64?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52671ecd8b64</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[existentialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[atheism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 May 2025 07:08:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-15T07:08:27.157Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SlFr83YSVruOKtb4WxuK6A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Just Google the words ‘existentialism’ and ‘religion’ and you’ll notice there is quite some debate whether existentialism should be equated with atheism or not. To me, the answer is ‘yes.’ Existentialists are atheists by definition. And the reason is simple: Existentialism is in many ways the complete opposite of religion. Nevertheless, some people maintain there is such thing as ‘religious existentialism.’</p><p>One of the most famous existentialists, French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre, said there are ‘atheist existentialists’ and ‘religious existentialists’. “What they have in common”, he stated, “is to believe that existence precedes essence.” Now Sartre uses a very limited definition of existentialism here, taking one of the existentialist maxims and conveniently leaving aside the other core ideas of existentialism (we will talk about those core ideas in a bit).</p><p>Sartre was not very consistent about his view on religion (neither was he about the term existentialism). He did claim though that “existentialism is a humanism”, and he has repeatedly expressed that he did not believe in the existence of a God (as in a divine being). And just like that other French existentialist philosopher, Albert Camus, Sartre rejected moral and ethical frameworks based on religion.</p><p>Compare that to Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard, who is often considered to be one of the first existentialists. He was one of the first philosophers who came up with some of the ideas that are central to existentialism. But there is a large ‘but.’ Kierkegaard assumed the existence of God (not surprising in the nineteenth century) and tried to unite that with ideas about freedom, authenticity, existential anxiety, etc., which we also encounter later in the thinking of the twentieth-century existentialists.</p><p>But that does not make Kierkegaard an existentialist. The Danish philosopher addresses existential questions, but does so within the framework of religion. What Kierkegaard advocates, in my opinion, is a ‘religious philosophy of existence’. Which is not the same as ‘existential philosophy.’ Therefore I would say Kierkegaard can be seen as a predecessor of the existentialist philosophers of the twentieth century.</p><p>For sure, religious people can have views about existence that show similarities to the ideas of existentialist philosophy, but that doesn’t make them existentialists. Because the fundamental ideas and maxims of the large monotheistic world religions are incompatible with the core ideas of existentialism. Like I said, in many ways they are complete opposites. Let’s take a closer look at this, reflecting on the four key elements, the core ideas, of existentialist philosophy: meaning, freedom, responsibility and authenticity.</p><h4>Meaning</h4><p>According to the monotheistic religions, life (in general, but also your life) has a predetermined meaning. You were put into this world (by God, apparently) for a specific purpose. As humans we follow the path God has set out for us. Existentialists, on the other hand, believe <strong>life has no inherent meanin</strong>g. This is the first key element in existentialism. The world is contingent and so is your existence. According to existentialists, there is no ‘reason’ why we exist. There is no divine plan and life doesn’t have a God-given purpose or meaning. Existentialists argue that you have to create your own meaning. Life only has the meaning you choose to give it. It’s obvious that these two visions could not be more different.</p><p>The existence of God is itself an assertion that seperates existentialism from religion. The monotheistic religions state that the world and the universe were created by an almighty God. This God created man in his own image (God is apparently a man, although there is no evidence for this). Existentialists, on the other hand, are rationalists in the sense that they belief that idea that God created the universe, the world, life, and man, is contrary to the historic and scientific facts and should therefore be rejected.</p><p>The existence of a divine/supernatural being who is the source of meaning and purpose is irreconcilable with the fundamental ideas of existentialism. I guess it would be an existentialist thing to say that in the search for meaning, man created God after his own image, instead of the other way around. Existentialist thinking aligns with the consequence of the Nietzschean idea that ‘God is death’: without a God, humans have to figure out their meaning and purpose in life themselves. You don’t need a God to be a good person and to lead a meaningful life. Not an almighty God, but humans are ‘signifiers.’ Meaning is something that people assign, it is a uniquely human concept.</p><h4>Freedom</h4><p>The second key element in existentialism is the idea that <strong>people are fundamentally free</strong>. Existentialists believe people are self-determining beings: we become who we are by the choices we make. And existentialists believe that we are fundamentally free to make our own choices and by doing so shape our lives. Whereas this freedom is a cornerstone in existentialism, religion on the other hand comes with a set of rules to live by. The monotheistic world religions all prescribe how to live, what is ‘a good life’ and what is ‘sinful’. As a believer, you only have to follow those rules obediently. It is not for nothing that God is often presented as a ‘shepherd’, which implies that believers are the ‘sheep’.</p><p>Existentialists are not sheep. They are not confiormists, and they dislike herd behavior, blindly following whatever rules for life they are told. Religeous teachings that prescribe how to live take away people’s fundamental freedom to make their own choices. Contrary to religion, existentialism does not provide one clear answer to the question how to live. Nor does it provide a set of rules to live by or guidelines on how to live a good life. It doesn’t say ‘you must do this’ or ‘don’t do that.’ Existentialists believe it’s up to you to figure out which path in life you choose to follow.</p><p>A path that is finite. Existentialists are aware that life is temporary and humans are mortal beings. This is another aspect that seperates existentialism from religion. Religious people believe in life after death. Life does not end, our earthly existence is not even what it is all about. Our soul, our essence, is immortal. In some religions that soul goes to a heavenly paradise, in others the soul reincarnates and then returns to earth in another body. Existentialists, on the other hand, don’t believe in an afterlife, in heaven or hell, or in reincarnation. You only get to live once. You get only one shot. This is it.</p><h4>Responsibility</h4><p>The religious denial of our fundamental freedom has profound consequences for the way people approach life. For existentialists, freedom always comes with <strong>responsibility</strong>, the third key element of existentialism. You have to take responsibility for your own life and for the choices you make. You are in the driver’s seat of your own life and you get to choose how you want to live it, according to your own convictions, hopes and desires. And you have to take responsibility for those choices.</p><p>Compare that to the religious belief that it is the almighty God who gives your life meaning and purpose. Religious faith puts God in the driver’s seat instead of you. Religion does not only denies our fundamental freedom, it takes away our personal responsibility in shaping our own lives and the choices we make. It allows people to avoid taking responsibility, shifting responsibility to some power outside themselves, a.k.a. God. And it also allows them to accept that things are as they are (God intended it that way). It promotes resignation. Do not resist. Do not deviate. Just resign yourself to your fate. After all, it’s all ‘God’s will.’</p><h4>Authenticity</h4><p>Imposing a pre-determined meaning of life, denying our fundamental freedom and undermining our responsibility inevitable makes it impossible for people to <strong>live authentically</strong>, the fourth key element of existentialism. Living authentically means living the way you want and become who you want to be, through the choices you make. The opposite is inauthenticity, or what Sartre calls ‘bad faith.’ Inauthenticity is the denial of the fact that you are fundamentally free and deliberately avoiding the responsibility that comes with it. It’s inauthentic to say you believe things because that’s what you have been told. It’s inauthentic to live your life the way other people do, because ‘that’s what one does’.</p><p>Religion demands the opposite from people: subservience. Accepting the religious teachtings about God and creation and all, gloryfying his almightiness, submitting yourself to his omnipotence, and admitting you are sinful — just because you were born and some made-up story says so. Religion requires you to obey divine authority (which of course is human authority dressed as divine). Living a life according to the values imposed this way would be considered ‘bad faith’ by existentialists.</p><p>What about morality then? Doesn’t religion call on people to act ethically, fight injustice and violence and all, striving to make this world a little better? Sure religion provides a moral and ethical framework, tells you what is ‘good’ and what is ‘bad’ (albeit founded on questionable sources and arguments); however, existentialists would argue that religion doesn’t have a monopoly on morality. Rejecting morality based on religious teachings, existentialists base their moral compass on their humanity (hence Sartre’s “existentialism is a humanism”). In my opinion this is a much more powerful vision; if we are intrinsically motivated to act righteous and ethically, according to a morality that stems from our humanity, instead of acting that way because that’s what some religion teaches…</p><p>Existentialists acknowledge that people crave meaning, and that they want to make sense of the world and the universe. They would agree that there is a lot we don’t know and which science cannot (yet) explain. That’s exactly where man’s invention of God(s) stems from; the need for answers and security. But making things up doesn’t provide any answers. An existentialist can’t see how one can find security in believing in a supernatural being that defies logic. Instead, existentialism encourages us to accept and deal with the harsh realities and uncertainties of life, instead of trying to escape them by believing in fantasies, delusions and speculations.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52671ecd8b64" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Loneliness is not being alone. It’s the feeling that nobody cares]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/loneliness-is-not-being-alone-its-the-feeling-that-nobody-cares-f0cf3436e867?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0cf3436e867</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[loneliness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[connection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Dec 2020 13:37:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-12T13:37:26.931Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A journey into the world of loneliness — and how to deal with it</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*oaq9pn5-boRNnKjatD0Pug.jpeg" /></figure><p>In our modern societies having a ‘rich social life’ is widely seen and promoted as an essential part of a successful and happy life. At the same time there is a growing awareness that not everybody meets the social standard of having many friends and close family relations and that loneliness is a serious mental health issue that needs our attention. An increasing number of initiatives aims to battle loneliness, ranging from an annual ‘loneliness awareness week’ in The Netherlands to a dedicated Secretary of Loneliness in the United Kingdom and from setting up informative websites with practical advice to addressing the negative effects of isolation in times of a worldwide pandemic.</p><p>Despite the large number of initiatives to raise awareness about loneliness, there is unfortunately still a lot of ignorance about what loneliness actually is. Loneliness is still in a sense a taboo subject. People who feel lonely find it difficult to openly express it. And other people are often unsure how to respond to it. “Loneliness,” says British writer and loneliness expert Olivia Laing, “feels like such a shameful experience, so counter to the lives we are supposed to lead, that it becomes increasingly inadmissible, a taboo state whose confession seems destined to cause others to turn and flee.”</p><p>Breaking that taboo, I think, starts with a better understanding of loneliness. So, if you haven’t “turned and fled” after this introduction, let me take you on a little journey into the world of loneliness.</p><p><strong><em>What is loneliness?</em></strong></p><p>First we have to get rid of the biggest misunderstanding about loneliness, which is that people equate loneliness with being alone. Loneliness is <em>not</em> the same as being alone, those are two different things. Being alone simply means there are no people around you. It is an actual condition, which you can determine simply by looking around you. If there are no people around you, you are alone. If there are people around you, you are not alone. Lonely, on the other hand, is not a fact, nor can it be determined by counting the number of people around you. Loneliness is an emotion, independent of whether you are alone or not. You can be alone without feeling lonely (if you value this positively, it’s called solitude) and you can feel lonely while you are not alone. Being alone is something you <em>are</em>, lonely is something you <em>feel</em>.</p><p>You would think that people who are alone more often also feel more lonely, but that is not necessarily the case. According to Norwegian philosopher Lars Svendsen, there is “no correlation at all between the degree of physical isolation and the intensity of the loneliness felt.” People who feel lonely spend as much time around other people as non-lonely people. That’s why the much-heard, and no doubt well-meant advice to “just go out and meet people” is not the solution to loneliness. Or at least not the whole solution. “What matters,” Svendsen says, “is not the extent to which an individual is surrounded by other people, but rather how that individual experiences his relationship to others.” So it’s not about surrounding yourself with other people, but about how you connect with those people — or even better: how you <em>experience</em> your connections with those people. In the words of Olivia Laing: “Loneliness does not necessarily require physical solitude, but rather an absence of connection, closeness, kinship: an inability, for one reason or another, to find as much intimacy as is desired.”</p><p>We humans are social beings. The need to live in community with other people is programmed into our DNA. We all need friendship and love in our lives. Meaningful relationships with other people is one of the most important contributors to a happy life. But the fact that we are a social being and therefore need connections with others does not mean that that need is met. Meaningful and satisfying relationships are not guaranteed. Loneliness is the emotional pain you experience when those meaningful social connections are missing. An important need is not being met. Feeling lonely doesn’t mean there’s something wrong with you, is it simply means that you have, as the American social neuroscientist John Cacioppo and co-writer William Patrick put it, “a normal human need for social connection, as well as a very normal adverse reaction to disconnection, real or perceived.”</p><p>So loneliness is a subjective feeling based on how you personally experience your relationships with others — not a description of the actual situation. You may experience your relationships as insufficiently satisfying, while someone else might judge them as satisfactory. There is <em>a mismatch between need and satisfaction</em>, between your personal need for connection and the degree to which that need is fulfilled. And this is about quality, not quantity: A close relationship with a limited number of people is a stronger buffer against feelings of loneliness than a loose relationship with a large number of others. “What determines our loneliness,” American psychologist Guy Winch says, “is not the quantity of our relationships but rather their subjective quality, the extent to which we perceive ourselves to be socially or emotionally isolated.” It’s about how meaningful (or meaningless) you rate your relations with other people.</p><p><strong><em>How does loneliness feel?</em></strong></p><p>OK, so loneliness is the emotional response to the desire for, and lack of meaningful connections with other people. But, you might ask, how does it actually feel? There is no clear answer to that; emotions are by definition extremely individual, so different people will experience loneliness in different ways, it won’t feel the same for everyone. That said, ask a group of people who feel lonely to describe their emotions and chances are their replies will be more or less like this: First they will probably tell you they feel sad. Loneliness is primarily a sense of sadness. And then they may tell you they feel detached, isolated, alienated, misunderstood, rejected, hurt, disconnected, worried, insecure, vulnerable, anxious, ashamed, ostracized, helpless, hopeless, trapped, desperate… Some may even feel angry or resentful.</p><p>What this wide range of emotions comes down to, is that people who feel lonely, feel left out. They don’t feel accepted. They don’t feel loved. They feel, like Olivia Laing puts it, that they are “not being admitted into the magic circles of connection and acceptance.” The social standard of having many friends and an active social life reinforces that feeling. If you spend your evenings and weekends alone at home, you may get the impression that everyone is socializing all the time — except for you. Even though this does not match reality, it hurts because you feel you don’t belong, and having a sense of belonging is a very human need. That’s why the idea that everybody else finds themselves surrounded by loved ones is so painful for the lonely person. I think Olivia Laing put it very well when she said that “<em>it feels like being hungry while everyone around you is readying for a feast. It hurts.</em>” The world is partying and you haven’t been invited. What makes loneliness so painful is not being alone, but the feeling that no one cares.</p><p>Since loneliness is the result of an unfulfilled need, it is by definition accompanied by a desire. A desire for meaningful connections, the wish to overcome the mental distance between yourself and others. Feeling lonely comes with a strong need for what’s lacking: acceptance, connection, companionship, intimacy, feeling heard and understood. And although all this requires the physical presence of other people, it is not enough. Because even surrounded by people, the lonely person may feel locked up and shut out. Olivia Laing calls this “internal isolation.” I think she described it very well when she said: “I was often feeling like I was <em>walled up in glass</em>, that I could see out all too clearly but lacked the ability to free myself or to make the kind of contact I desired.”</p><p><strong><em>The consequences of loneliness</em></strong></p><p>Everyone feels lonely from time to time (for example, if you have just moved to another city or country, where you don’t know anyone yet). According to psychologist Guy Winch, 40 percent of people experience (temporary) feelings of loneliness at some point in their lives. Now, temporarily experiencing feelings of loneliness is unpleasant, but you will get over it. However, if you feel lonely often, or almost always, then you suffer from chronic loneliness. And that’s a different story.</p><p>Research shows that about twenty percent of people “feel sufficiently isolated for it to be a major source of unhappiness in their lives.” An estimated half of them (1 in 10 people) feel seriously lonely permanently. That type of loneliness, in the words of Olivia Laing, “cuts right to the heart of what we value and what we need.” Chronic loneliness affects your identity, affects your entire life and can even become an existential problem. That cannot be without consequences and it doesn’t: Time and again studies show that loneliness has a major impact on your mental and physical health.</p><p>People who feel lonely often or always experience life as less satisfying, valuable and meaningful. Various studies have also shown that loneliness affects blood pressure and the immune system, causes an increase of stress hormones and increases the risk of dementia. People struggling with loneliness experience lower sleep quality. This makes them feel more tired during the day, which in turn affects their mental abilities, such as concentration and decision making. Loneliness also correlates with higher alcohol consumption and a less healthy lifestyle in general. Perhaps even more worrying, there is a strong correlation between loneliness and depression and suicide.</p><p><strong><em>Why does one person feel lonely while the other doesn’t?</em></strong></p><p>Wherever there are people, there is loneliness. But not everyone is affected by it to the same degree. Why is that? Cacioppo and Patrick distinguish three factors that influence the extent to which you may experience feelings of loneliness: 1. Your “level of vulnerability to social disconnection.” Every person needs recognition by others, to be seen, accepted and appreciated. But not to the same degree. Some people need a lot of social interaction and like to socialize with large groups of people. Others are more private and prefer a small number of people around them. 2. Your “ability to cope with the emotions associated with feeling isolated.” Some people cope better with feeling lonely than others. And this may change over time: You may have felt lonely as a child very often, but not at a later age. Or the other way around: in the past you rarely had feelings of loneliness and nowadays a lot. 3. Your “mental representations and expectations of, as well as reasoning about, others.” How we see ourselves and others influences how we see our social connections, and the other way around: Loneliness affects the way we see ourselves and others.</p><p>According to Cacioppo and Patrick, 48% of all this is genetically determined. Our genetic predisposition determines, as it were, the threshold value for our personal feeling of loneliness: the lower our need for social connections, the higher our natural resistance to loneliness. The other 52% of our sensitivity to loneliness is determined by our experiences with the people we meet in our lives.</p><p>Remarkable about the causes of loneliness is that they have nothing to do with the prejudices that are often associated with it. Contrary to those prejudices, it turns out that lonely people are no more or less physically attractive than others; they are no more or less intelligent; loneliness has nothing to do with age either; and even your social skills are not decisive per se: Research by Cacioppo and Patrick shows that lonely people “have the capacity to be just as socially adept as anyone else.” And lonely people are not emotionally incapable of making connections either: Lars Svendsen rightly points out that “only a person who can exhibit friendship and love can feel lonely.”</p><p>Where non-lonely people often think that it is the lonely person themselves who’s to blame (“you’re just not trying hard enough”), the lonely person often thinks that it is the fault of others (“people have let me down”). The truth — as so often — lies somewhere in the middle. Lonely people are not just victims of a society that does not see them, nor is it entirely their own fault. “The vicious circle by which loneliness proceeds does not happen in isolation,” says Olivia Laing, “but rather as an interplay between the individual and the society in which they are embedded.”</p><p>Part of this interplay is an aspect that, if you feel lonely, deserves your attention: Trust. Studies show that there is a clear correlation between low levels of trust and loneliness: the more trustworthy you are, the less lonely; and the less trusting you are, the more lonely. “The ability to trust others and the ability to develop attachments are closely related,” Svendsen notes. “Lack of trust produces a caution that undermines the immediacy that is so important in our attachment to others.” In order to build meaningful connections, we have to have some basic level of trust. “People with low generalized trust do not necessarily view others as malicious, but rather as <em>risky</em> — as people who could hurt them,” Svendsen points out, and “mistrust prevents you from reaching outside yourself.” With loneliness as a likely result.</p><p><strong><em>How loneliness sustains itself</em></strong></p><p>If you have (had) to deal with (long-term) feelings of loneliness, then you know that it is very difficult solve that situation. The negative tension between need and satisfaction, the feeling of being “walled up in glass” as Olivia Laing described it, can feel very oppressive. Why is it so difficult to deal with feelings of loneliness? According to Guy Winch this is because “once loneliness sets in, it triggers a set of psychological reactions that can lead us to inadvertently perpetuate our situation and even to make it worse.” Yes, he’s basically saying that your own behavior is bringing about the very thing you seek to avoid. And according to Olivia Laing, in the worst case scenario it takes you into “a vicious circle” in which you become “increasingly isolated, suspicious and withdrawn.” Getting out of that “vicious circle” is not easy.</p><p>There are (at least) three pitfalls that perpetuate the situation. The first is that you develop a (too) high standard that the connections you desire must meet. “The chronically lonely have much higher expectations of interpersonal relationships than do not-lonely people,” Lars Svendsen notes. “They entertain higher demands, both for themselves and for others, in social interactions.” As a result, there is a risk that you will not see meaningful connections — or opportunities for them — or that you will reject them because they do not meet your expectations.</p><p>The second pitfall is that you develop negative expectations, which make you look too much for signals that indicate that a contact is not meeting the requirements. “When we are lonely, the social expectations and snap judgments we create are generally pessimistic,” Cacioppo and Patrick say. “Loneliness makes us constantly on guard, prepared for the disappointment and rejection we are sure will come. As a result, we miss opportunities to make social connections.” Loneliness thus becomes a kind of ‘self-fulfilling prophecy’. Guy Winch also sees that danger: “Because we don’t expect our social interactions to be positive, we make fewer efforts to seek them out and we are less responsive to them when they occur.”</p><p>The third pitfall is that you develop a negative self-image. If you feel lonely (for a long time), you will judge both yourself and other people more negatively, you will become too focused on the differences between yourself and others, and you will assume the worst about how others feel about you. As a result, you feel less safe in social situations, you act more reserved and you are more focused on signals that indicate disapproval or rejection. Not infrequently this leads to social avoidance strategies. Loneliness, Guy Winch observes, thus leads to “cycles of self-protection and avoidance that cause us to create self-fulfilling prophecies and to inadvertently push away the very people we hope to engage.” Svendsen describes the irony of this aptly: “In many cases, it will be correct to say: you are not lonely because you are alone, you are alone because you are lonely.”</p><p><strong><em>How to deal with feelings of loneliness?</em></strong></p><p>If you feel lonely for a long time, you may tend to simply surrender, to give up the hope of ever being able to satisfy your need for meaningful connections. You simply accept that you feel lonely and that things will remain that way for the rest of your life. We have already seen what that does to your mental and physical health.</p><p>You can also see the feeling of loneliness as a warning. As a signal that something is wrong and you need to do something about it. “Loneliness creates a space in which we can reflect on our relationship to others, and feel how much we actually need them,” Lars Svendsen says. And Cacioppo and Patrick see loneliness as “a stimulus to get humans to pay more attention to their social connections, and to reach out towards others.” Now that sounds nice, but it’s not that simple. The problem is that loneliness makes us, in the words of Guy Winch, “extremely hesitant to create new opportunities for social engagement or to take advantage of existing ones.”</p><p>As I said, going out and meeting people is part of the solution, but not the whole solution. After all, you do not so much lack the possibility of social interaction as you lack meaningful connections. And lasting, meaningful connections don’t just happen. Overcoming loneliness, says Olivia Laing, is “something which cannot be achieved by sheer willpower or by simply getting out more, but only by developing intimate connections.” Now, because feelings of loneliness are the result of your personal situation and needs, there is no simple one-size-fits-all step-by-step plan to get rid of your loneliness. You can, however, try a number of things to establish social contacts — and thus at least <em>increase the chance</em> of lasting, meaningful contacts.</p><p>So here’s a few practical suggestions:</p><p>• Find out who you already know and make a list of them. Family members, friends, vague acquaintances, colleagues. Include what you appreciate about that person and why you enjoy interacting with them. This way you gain insight into your social network (however limited that may be).</p><p>• Select one or two people from your list with whom you would like to meet up and contact them. Even if it has been a long time since you spoke to them. Simply asking how they are doing can be enough and the start of renewed contact. Or propose to meet. (It’s scary, I know, but hey, what have you got to lose?)</p><p>• Check whether there are online communities where you can meet new people or websites that organize activities or meetups. In The Netherlands there is a website called “Nieuwe Mensen Leren Kennen”, which literally translates as “meeting new people”. The more internationally oriented website “MeetUp” is another example. These are great places to meet other people who are looking for new connections, just like you.</p><p>• Think about things you enjoy doing. Your hobbies, things you are interested in. Chances are there’s a club or community for people who like those things too. Join them. That way you can get to meet people with similar interests.</p><p>• Did you succeed in catching up with someone you already knew or get acquainted with someone new and did you have a nice time? Make a proposal to see each other again. That way you start to build a (hopefully) lasting contact.</p><p>Keep a few things in mind:</p><p>• Try to be positive. Don’t expect a negative outcome. As Devora Zack points out, “Every interaction is an opportunity.” It might actually work.</p><p>• If you have agreed to seeing somebody or going to a meetup, and at the last moment you start to have doubts or you don’t feel like going after all: make yourself go. Force yourself. You will experience that afterwards it feels very satisfying that you went anyway.</p><p>• Don’t dismiss people too quickly. You don’t have to be 100% the same to have a connection.</p><p>• Don’t expect too much at once. Take a first step instead of expecting depth from the start. Just try to have a nice time. Connecting takes time, don’t give up too soon.</p><p>• Do not worry too much about the image you may have of what your social contacts should be like. Connections have to be meaningful and satisfying for you and the other person involved, not according to some external measure.</p><p>It’s not going to be easy. It’s going to take time and a lot of effort. Your past experiences and your expectations may make you feel hesitant. There may be disappointments. You may not succeed. Keeping things the way they are is a lot safer, but the price you will pay is that you will remain feeling lonely. Reaching out means you will feel vulnerable. But it’s the only way. It starts with simply making a decision. Decide that you are not going to surrender to your loneliness, you are going to do something about it. You are going to reach out and meet people. Making that decision and committing to it is the first step towards change. One thing you know for sure: If you stay alone at home and do nothing, nothing will change. Like Cacioppo en Patrick note, tackling your loneliness “is both as simple and as difficult as being open and available to others.” And remember: Many people struggle with this. You are not alone.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0cf3436e867" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is autonomy a myth? (Spoiler: No it is not.)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/is-autonomy-a-myth-spoiler-no-it-is-not-c9b16fceceec?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c9b16fceceec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autonomy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[choices]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Dec 2020 16:36:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-04T16:36:11.913Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*BCBUFEbG497ExBCnkJ2DFw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Are humans autonomous beings or is autonomy a myth? In the debate on this question, two views are often diametrically opposed: on the one hand there are people who believe that everyone is autonomous or should at least strive to be, and on the other, those who believe that people are not autonomous at all and also <em>cannot</em> be.</p><p>They are two seemingly irreconcilable visions of the nature of man. As so often, the alleged incompatibility is the result of a lack of clarity about what exactly we mean when we talk about a concept like autonomy. After all, without a good understanding of what autonomy is — and what it is <em>not</em> — we will be having different conversations.</p><p>So the question is: what exactly do we mean when we talk about autonomy? Autonomy is derived from the Greek words ‘auto’ (self) and ‘nomos’ (law) and means something like ‘according to your own law’. Living autonomously means living according to your own rules. No, you shouldn’t take that literally; autonomy does not mean that you no longer have to take rules into account and can do whatever you want. Let me try to clarify.</p><p>British philosopher Isaiah Berlin sees the pursuit of autonomy as a result of “the individual’s desire to be master of himself.” Autonomy is therefore closely related to self-determination: the freedom to decide independently and at your own discretion about how you want to live your own life. Berlin calls this positive freedom: “I want my life and my decisions to depend on myself, not any outside forces.”</p><p>It is the latter aspect that has met with criticism from those who believe that people are not and cannot be autonomous. No one can live his life completely free and independent of any outside influence, because we are constantly influenced by all kinds of factors (circumstances, other people). Humans are social beings, embedded in society and networks of relationships with others.</p><p>Those critics are of course right about that. No one is completely independent. Nobody lives in a vacuum, completely isolated and on their own. We always relate to our environment, both to our physical living environment and to the people around us and we are also dependent on that.</p><p>We depend on our natural environment: from the oxygen we breathe and the light of the sun to the food we eat and the water we drink. We depend on other people: from those who provide for our necessities (the farmer, the baker, the doctor) to the people who help and support us (family, friends). We depend on our circumstances: the place where we were born, the environment in which we grew up, and the traits and skills we have. And in our modern society we depend on the structures we are part of (democratic institutions, the company where we work) and the laws, rules and customs that guide our behavior.</p><p>And we cannot freely decide on some of those circumstances and dependencies. Sure, you can decide to move to a different environment, with different people and different circumstances. And you can decide to look for another job or learn a new skill. Those decisions — which you can make in freedom — may change your circumstances and dependencies, but not your dependence as such. Rather, the examples confirm that all your choices, all your actions, happen in the context of your environment and dependencies.</p><p>That dependence is inherent to human existence. Why then say that humans are autonomous? If people are by definition dependent on environmental factors, isn’t autonomy indeed a myth? The answer is no. We are autonomous beings because we are free to determine how we relate to our environment and circumstances.</p><p>Circumstances and dependencies mean constraints, preconditions, boundaries. But within those you have a lot of room to choose for yourself, to determine for yourself what your life looks like. It is inherent to making choices that those choices are made in a context. “A prerequisite for a choice”, says the German philosopher Wilhelm Schmid, “is that you take into account that it is limited by structural circumstances and that you do not situate it in empty space.”</p><p>Autonomy thus takes shape in the context of circumstances and dependencies. This may mean, for example, that you want something that is not feasible in the given circumstances. Or that your beliefs in some area have been influenced by what you have learned from others. But that does not mean that you are not autonomous. Autonomy is not absolute. Isaiah Berlin points out that freedom is never absolute: “Everything I do inevitably affects or is affected by what others do.”</p><p>The Swiss philosopher Peter Bieri describes two aspects of autonomy. The first is the external aspect, namely: leeway. The room to relate to your environment. The second is the internal aspect: The room to be who you want to be in terms of “thinking, experiencing and wanting”. That room, that autonomy, is an inherent aspect of human existence.</p><p>This idea is at the heart of existentialism. According to French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre “man is free” to choose who he wants to be. This autonomy means that “man is nothing other than his own project,” according to Sartre, “he is nothing more than the sum of his actions.” We are responsible for shaping our own lives. Existentialism, Sartre says, “defines man by his actions” and “man’s destiny lies within himself.”</p><p>This is the essence of autonomy, the freedom to choose how we use the leeway that we have and thus shape our lives. And, says Sartre, there is no way around that. We <em>always</em> have room to choose. “It is impossible not to choose,” according to Sartre. Given your circumstances, you choose. And by doing so, you choose who you will be. That is autonomy.</p><p>Faced with what comes your way, given the circumstances, the question is always: How do you relate to it? Do you accept it? Or do you consciously choose your own course? The compass we can use to navigate in determining that course, how we want to relate to our environment and dependencies, are our own personal values, ideas, beliefs and wishes.</p><p>British philosopher John Stuart Mill points out that this is precisely where our freedom is located: In “the world of inner consciousness.” If there is one area in which we are autonomous, according to Mill, it is our “freedom of thought and feeling, absolute freedom of opinion and disposition on all subjects, practical or speculative, scientific, moral or theological.”</p><p>Like we do not act in a vacuum, our ideas do not arise in a vacuum. We depend on — and are influenced by — the ideas and opinions of others, what we hear or read, and the dominant norms and values in society. Our ideas also do not come about completely independently and free from influences. But again, that doesn’t mean we aren’t autonomous.</p><p>People who are against seeing humans as autonomous beings see it not only as contrary to human nature (because they mistakenly assume that autonomy means total independence while humans are social beings), but also as undesirable. Undesirable because it would lead to a society of atomic individuals living alongside each other.</p><p>This idea is reflected for example by Dutch philosopher Joep Dohmen. He links the “myth of autonomy” to the “neo-liberal zeitgeist” that has ensured that “self-determination and non-interference” have become kind of sacrosanct. According to Dohmen, this has led to a society in which everyone has to save themselves, which encourages selfishness and narcissism. But this negative image has little to do with what autonomy is about.</p><p>The pursuit of autonomy stems, as Isaiah Berlin puts it, from the desire to be recognized as a “thinking, willing, acting being, who bears responsibility for his choices and is able to explain them on the basis of his own ideas and intentions.” Autonomy is therefore about human dignity. It is for a reason that the Austrian psychiatrist Viktor Frankl, who has experienced what it is like to be stripped of your human dignity, states: “Everything can be taken from a man but one thing: the last of the human freedoms — to choose one’s attitude in any given set of circumstances, to choose one’s own way. ”</p><p>Autonomy is therefore the freedom — within the framework of your circumstances — to decide independently and at your own discretion about how you want to live your own life. Live ‘auto nomos’ — according to your own rules. Or as Peter Bieri puts it: “Our life is autonomous if we manage to live it both internally and outwardly in accordance with our self-image, if we succeed in acting, thinking, feeling and wanting to be who we would like to be. ”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c9b16fceceec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why you should always keep asking ‘why?’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/why-you-should-always-keep-asking-why-9ecc409d212d?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ecc409d212d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[authenticity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conformity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Dec 2020 09:47:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-03T09:47:40.189Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*qQjPncVVRePH2k9fwfzHvg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I like to refer to myself as a “critical thinker” and that is not without reason. In my opinion critical thinking is one of the most important qualities that you can develop as a person. What does critical thinking entail? And why is it important?</p><p>In my opinion, critical thinking is above all an attitude: the willingness to put a question mark on everything, to question the obvious, and to wonder why things are the way they are. Not critical in the sense of dismissive or negative, but in the sense of asking critical questions. Or, as British philosopher Julian Baggini puts it, “to be appropriately skeptical without being indiscriminately cynical.”</p><p>Critical thinking means reflecting on your ideas and beliefs about yourself, life and the world. Taking nothing for granted, including your own beliefs, and instead forming your own judgment, determining for yourself what you want to believe or what you want to do.</p><p>Thinking critically, says Dutch philosopher Paul van Tongeren, automatically means breaking through the obviousness of it: “Obvious are the things you don’t think about. So thinking about things presupposes that they are no longer taken for granted. ” For a critical thinker nothing is self-evident — except for critical thinking itself.</p><p>Critical thinking therefore requires courage. Courage to question your own beliefs. To examine your assumptions and to subject your certainties to critical consideration. One of the consequences of this may be that you become less convinced of your ideas about yourself, life and the world around you.</p><p>You have formed these ideas in the course of your life, influenced by the environment in which you were born, the people who played a role in your life and the experiences you have had. We tend to consider them to be ‘normal’, we are used to them. Our habits and beliefs therefore seem self-evident, but they are not. In the words of the Swiss philosopher Peter Bieri, they are just “elements that we have simply picked up and become accustomed to through repetition.”</p><p>It is precisely what we consider ‘normal’ that is the subject of reflection for a critical thinker. Why do we do things a certain way? For what purpose and what assumptions is it based on? Where does a particular habit come from? Is what I think actually correct? Is my approach the best?</p><p>And what do we actually mean by certain concepts? Terms that we often use in daily life and we think we know what they mean. In fact, we assume that others understand the same. Until we question critically and it turns out that that may not be the case at all. What does ‘being happy’ really mean? When is something ‘righteous’? What is ‘success’?</p><p>Critical thinking requires a certain amount of open-mindedness. That you are able to see potentially positive aspects in a belief that you do not share or a position that is not yours. That you can see the pros and cons of different choices. An open attitude that allows you to look at things in a different way.</p><p>Critical thinking also requires that you can substantiate your opinion, belief or choices with arguments. It’s easy to have an opinion, but being able to substantiate it is something else. “Just because” or “because he or she did or said so” is the opposite of critical thinking.</p><p>Someone who thinks critically can not only express what he thinks, but also explain why. Argumentation, evidence and logical reasoning are prerequisites for this. A critical thinker will not just rely on the opinion or behavior of someone else. He only takes things as true when he has good reasons to do so.</p><p>In an earlier article I wrote that that people conform massively to what the majority does or to the group to which they belong. They conform to what is considered ‘normal’, without asking themselves why. And that while we humans are fundamentally free, free to shape our lives as we see fit, to live our lives in a way that we find valuable ourselves. Critical thinking is an important aspect of that freedom.</p><p>According to British philosopher Bertrand Russell, a proponent of critical thinking, we need only conform to prevailing beliefs “as far as is necessary not to starve and not go to prison.” In all other cases, Russell argues, to conform without thinking for yourself is nothing more than “a voluntary submission to unnecessary tyranny.”</p><p>According to Russell, thinking critically instead of blindly conforming is an important precondition for a happy life itself. The way we live our lives must, according to Russell, stem from our own beliefs “and not from the casual preferences of those who happen to live next door or are related to us.”</p><p>In a world where the vast majority blindly conform themselves to their immediate environment, with the result that large groups of people display the same behavior, the same opinions, the same habits, etc., the critical thinker is often viewed strange when he calls into question what the people around him take for granted. The critical thinker is a disturber, someone who is “being difficult”.</p><p>The critical thinker will have to live with that. British philosopher John Stuart Mill has argued that it is important for people to be resilient “to the pressures of current opinions and beliefs, to society’s tendency to impose its ideas and habits on those who deviate from them.” Learning to think critically contributes to that resilience.</p><p>Critical thinking doesn’t just arm you against illogical conclusions, irrational choices or unreasonable positions. It is also an effective remedy for prejudice and stereotyping. Fact-free politics has no grip on someone who thinks critically. And critical thinking makes you resilient to political and religious indoctrination.</p><p>“Dare to think for yourself, against all authority,” the German enlightenment philosopher Immanuel Kant urged us. I admit, that’s not always easy. But thinking critically yourself contributes to living an authentic life: a life in which you make your own choices, freely and based on the values that are important to you, and your idea of how you want to live your life — regardless of what other people do.</p><p>The German philosopher Erich Fromm also believes that something should not be taken as true “only because an authority or the majority say so.” Fromm encourages us to have confidence in our own experience, observations and judgment, so that our beliefs are “rooted in an independent conviction based upon one’s own productive observing and thinking, in spite of the majority’s opinion.”</p><p>So yes, critical thinking can make you less convinced of your beliefs, deviate from those around you, or be perceived as being difficult. But on the other hand, critical thinking makes you resilient to peer pressure and indoctrination. And it makes you more aware of yourself, life and the world around you. Why you think what you think, why you make certain choices, why things are the way they are.</p><p>Therefore: Don’t take anything for granted. Reflect on your ideas and your beliefs. Dare to put a question mark on everything. Question the obvious. And above all: Always keep thinking for yourself. Always keep asking ‘why’. Always stay critical.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ecc409d212d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Perfection is an illusion. Pursuing it is a recipe for unhappiness]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/perfection-is-an-illusion-pursuing-it-is-a-recipe-for-unhappiness-1733c6197cb9?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1733c6197cb9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anxiety]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[failure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[perfection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Dec 2020 06:58:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-01T06:58:32.488Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*bHBZTvg1BLfEXg0DIA-hyg.jpeg" /></figure><p>There are many ways in which people can make life hard on themselves. One of the best ways to do so, is without a doubt the pursuit of perfection. Perfectionism is a recipe for unhappiness.</p><p>If you are a perfectionist, anything less than perfect is considered a failure. Which means you ‘fail’ all the time. You will always feel anxious, because you are afraid you will fail and failing is unacceptable to you. You feel miserable all the time, because whatever you do, whatever you gain, whatever you achieve, it is never good enough.</p><p>If your eyes are only aimed at perfection, you will easily miss the gains you do get and the progress you are making. You will dismiss them because they are not good enough — and by doing so you will dismiss the value they have for you. Instead, you feel ashamed that you didn’t try harder. You will blame yourself and feel like you’re a disappointment — which you are not. You are only human.</p><p>If nothing less than perfect is acceptable, chances are that you will not even try, because the challenge is just too big. You will have difficulties making choices, since none of the options will be perfect. So you get stuck in indecisiveness. And perfectionism will lead to overthinking. Ruminating over and over again all the options and pros and cons, in search of the perfect answer. Which will never show.</p><p>Of course, you can work harder, try harder, do more. But let’s add some realism, OK? Expecting yourself to do everything perfectly — to <em>be</em> perfect — is an expectation you can never live up to. So you will feel like a failure all the time, feel like you didn’t do enough, didn’t try harder. It’s completely unrealistic and actually quite cruel to do that to yourself. Striving for perfection is exhausting, it’s stressful, and it will drain your energy.</p><p>Moreover — and the funny thing is that even perfectionists know this: Perfection is an illusion. An unattainable goal. Perfection doesn’t exist. “Nothing or no one will ever be able to create the perfect world in which life is trouble-free,” the German philosopher Wilhelm Schmid tells us. A perfect world with perfect people in which life is perfect will never exist. Nobody can make that happen. So why would you measure yourself according to an unrealistic standard?</p><p>Perfectionism is not something you are born with. If you’re a perfectionist, somehow, at some point in your life, you have come to believe that anything less than perfect is simply not good enough. Chances are that this idea has in some way to do with how you think other people will judge you (or have judged you in the past). Maybe you have been told one time too many that only the best is good enough. Maybe you feel people have high expectations of you and therefore you set the bar for yourself even higher.</p><p>So ask yourself why you have such high expectations? Why do you feel you ‘must’ do everything perfect? Are you afraid you will be criticized? Afraid you will let other people down? Afraid of what people will think of you when you do less than perfect? Afraid you will not be good enough? The thing is, fear is actually the main driver behind perfectionism. The British writer Oliver Burkeman points out that “perfectionism is essentially a fear-driven pursuit to avoid failure at any cost.” And this leads to a constant tension.</p><p>Perfectionism only leads to stress, disappointment and exhaustion. So why be so hard on yourself? You probably already know it doesn’t make you feel good. Perfectionism is the way to go if you do <em>not</em> want to feel self-confident and up to your task, let alone relaxed and joyful. So why be so strict? Give yourself a break. Focus on what is going right, instead of what is going wrong. On what you have instead of what’s lacking. On what you have achieved, instead of what you haven’t. If you keep striving for perfection, you will not be able the enjoy any of this. It will basically make it impossible to enjoy your life at all.</p><p>Of course it’s great if you want to grow as a person or to learn new skill. It’s laudable if you want to be a good person, a good partner, a good employee. Go for it. Do your best. But always, always remember: Good is good enough. Strive to be good in everything you do, but don’t expect things — including yourself — to be perfect. And if you fail? Well, it’s not great of course, it’s not a pleasant experience. But the world will not come to an end because of it. And hey, we all fail sometimes, remember? At least you tried. And you probably learned something.</p><p>What perfectionists need, is a shot of realism. Nothing and nobody is perfect. We are all fallible human beings. We all have our shortcomings. We all make mistakes. And we always will. That’s the way it is. No way around it. In the course of our lives we all will fail sometimes. We will screw up tasks. We will make wrong judgements. We will disappoint people. It sounds bland, but acceptance is key. People are not perfect. Relationships are not perfect. Your job probably isn’t perfect. The world is not perfect. In the words of Rebecca Solnit: “This is earth. It will never be heaven.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1733c6197cb9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Individuality, conformity and our need for social acceptance]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/individuality-conformity-and-our-need-for-social-acceptance-954d70c6b4b3?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/954d70c6b4b3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[individuality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[choices]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conformity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-acceptance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Jun 2020 11:51:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-06T11:51:00.883Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/746/1*vyK7SOiyjslkjfzuG0KrmA.jpeg" /></figure><p>One of the most paradoxical aspects of human behavior, if you ask me, is the universally felt need for freedom to be yourself and the simultaneous tendency to conform to your environment. Between making your own choices and doing what ‘everyone else’ does. That paradox creates a ​​tension that many people struggle with.</p><p>People are social creatures and living in a community means that we have to live and cooperate with other people and so we need to adapt to some degree to what is socially desirable and accepted. A certain level of conformity to rules and social conventions is necessary to prevent things ending in chaos. I am glad most people conform to road rules for instance. Or that we conform to the social habit of putting on clothes before we go out. Imagine what would happen if we’d say “f*ck conformity” in these cases… So in many cases conformity can be helpful. It makes society run more or less smoothly and it helps us to fit in and function properly.</p><p>On the other hand, living in a free society offers us all the space to develop our individuality. To become who we want to be. To pursue our own dreams, make plans and take initiatives. To have your own beliefs and opinions — and to speak out openly. We not only appreciate that, it is also widely promoted to be ‘your own unique and authentic self’.</p><p>So it is all the more striking that people massively conform to what the majority does or to the group to which they belong. Fashion trends are an obvious example of this. And the customs and codes of conduct within subcultures. But even when it comes to individual choices, many people conform to what is considered ‘normal’. There’s a lot of people who get married and have children because that’s what their social environment is expecting from them (or at least they think that is what is expected). Other people don’t pursue their dream career because it doesn’t meet their parents’ standards. On the one hand, making your own choices is promoted, on the other hand, most people tailor those choices to their social environment.</p><p>Few people dare to ignore that kind of ‘social expectations’. Who really make their own decisions and dare to choose their own path in life, even if by doing so they deviate from the ‘norm’. This is actually at odds with the image that our society has been extensively individualized in recent decades, the idea that people are no longer restricted by tradition, family, religion, social class, etc., but that you are free to develop as an individual. But in addition to the pressure to conform (which is still the order of the day in many totalitarian society and strict religious communities), there also appears to be such a thing as the urge to conform. Behold the paradox: Obligate people to conform and they want to be free; let them be free and they conform …</p><p>German-American philosopher Erich Fromm is not surprised about this. “People want to conform to a much higher degree than they are forced to conform,” he says. “Most people (…) live under the illusion that they follow their own ideas and inclinations, that they are individuals, that they have arrived at their opinions as the result of their own thinking — and that it just happens that their ideas are the same as those of the majority.” But that is not the case at all, says Fromm.</p><p>In reality, most adult people still do what they did as a child: imitate others. Many people adapt to their environment without much thought. Apparently, the fact that other people do something is a strong indication for many people that it is the right thing to do. Apparently what ‘everybody else’ does is what you’re ‘supposed to’ do. Friedrich Nietzsche sees man as a ‘herd animal’ for a reason. Of all human qualities, he argues, “obedience has been practiced and cultivated the best and the longest among men.” As a result, he thinks that the urge to conform is innate nowadays, and he is not very positive about it; Nietzsche despises herd behavior.</p><p>German philosopher Bettina Stangneth is less judgmental. According to her, the tendency to conform to the majority stems from a “desire for absolute clarity about what is expected of you (…) a life without doubt in which you simply function as part of a larger whole that determines and directs everything.” Many people like to orient themselves to the majority because they make them part of a community. That makes them feel stronger, more secure.</p><p>Conforming to your environment leads to certainty, while following your own path entails uncertainty. The danger of conforming, however, is that group behavior becomes all-determining; you only belong if you behave like the rest. Not your own judgment is leading, but that of others. Not your own wishes and needs are central, but the interests of the group. Compliance is required. And that is the opposite of developing your own individuality.</p><p>In that context, Fromm speaks of “the equality of men who have lost their individuality.” When you see to what extent group behavior and social pressure determine the behavior of many people, you cannot escape the impression that — despite all the rhetoric — ‘being the same’ is considered by many to be more important than ‘being yourself’. It’s all about the <em>idea</em> of ​​individuality, the <em>idea</em> that you are free to make your own choices — and to subsequently make the same choices as your friends, family, peers, and so on.</p><p>Why is that? Why do so many people value individuality and yet choose conformity? Some blame it on the capitalist consumption culture, others on the influence of social media. But I think these are mere symptoms. The culture of consumption and the influence of social media are expressions of the urge to conform, which — as Nietzsche and Fromm indicate — is ingrained in our genes.</p><p>I believe that this urge to conform stems from our need for social acceptance. People have a deep-rooted need to feel accepted by those around them. So much so that it is a driving force in the way we relate to our environment. “Since the dominant values ​​for most people in our society are being liked, accepted and approved of,” says existential psychologist Rollo May, “much anxiety in our day comes from the threat of not being liked, being isolated, lonely or cast off.”</p><p>Many people only want one thing: to fit in, to belong. They are afraid to do what they want themselves, because they are afraid that they will be judged, that deviant behavior will be rejected. “What is most dreaded,” I think May rightly says, “is not fitting in. People lack courage because of their fear of being subjected to ‘social isolation’. People are deathly afraid of standing on their own convictions at the risk of being renounced by the group.” The fear of not being accepted means that people do not start from what they want, but look at what is ‘socially desirable’. “Many people judge the value of their actions not on the basis of the action itself,” May says, “but on the basis of how the action is accepted.”</p><p>I think he is right. The need to be accepted, to be part of a group, naturally leads to an urge to conform. It starts when you are a child and are trained to behave as expected of you. As a child you already experience what happens when you deviate, when you are not the same as your peers. “The real threat is not to be accepted, to be thrown out of the group, to be left solitary and alone,” said May. And you need mental strength to resist that kind of social pressure and to make your own choices, even if they mean that you are not or less socially accepted. To stand alone requires courage and mental resilience.</p><p>The need for individual freedom on the one hand and the need for social acceptance on the other; in that area of ​​tension, your own strength as an individual and your resilience to the social pressure exerted by society ultimately determine to what extent you conform to your environment and to what extent you dare to make your own choices.</p><p>The main reason why people struggle with this tension is because they conform too much to the (supposed) expectations of their environment and thereby ignore their own needs and wishes. To counteract this, self-reliance, critical thinking and mental resilience are necessary. The realization that herd behavior is not the only option. That it is OK to make your own choices instead of doing what ‘everybody else’ around you is doing. And that your self-esteem does not depend on the approval of others (after all, that is nothing but conformity).</p><p>Focusing on your own individuality doesn’t mean you have to throw all the rules and social conventions out the window. As with so many things, it’s about finding the right balance. The right balance between making your own individual choices and following your own life path on the one hand, and adapting to your environment and what life in a community with others requires of you on the other. That balance will not be the same for everyone. Some people will place more emphasis on individuality and others will feel more comfortable with more conformity.</p><p>If you notice that you no longer feel comfortable with what is expected of you, if you no longer support your own choices, it may indicate that the balance is gone. Be aware of that. And don’t blindly follow what others are doing, just to fit in. Conformity is perfectly fine as long as 1) you do so by free choice, 2) because you have thought about it and have good reasons to do so, and 3) you feel OK about it. In all other cases I would encourage you to rely on your own strength, make your own choices, follow your own path and become who you want to be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=954d70c6b4b3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hope is not enough]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/hope-is-not-enough-63223fad3ba8?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63223fad3ba8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[courage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[despair]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[perspective]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cynicism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 May 2020 13:31:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-24T13:31:23.184Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*WiECpQM6ACliaKBmromznQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Where there is life is hope, they say. But where there is life, there is also hopelessness. And despair. And cynicism. And wishful thinking, that meaningless hope that will never come true.</p><p>I have always found hope a difficult concept. Elusive. Fragile. When someone tells me not to give up hope, I always think, “OK, but <em>how</em>?” And what exactly is hope? You think you know what it is until you try to explain it, then it turns out to be quite a complicated concept.</p><p>I think the Czech writer and politician Václav Havel comes quite close to a striking description of what hope is. Hope, he says, is “an orientation. A state of mind, not a state of the world. ” Hope is not something tangible, it is an inner state of mind. A state of mind that is not based on what is, on facts and circumstances. “A state of mind <em>despite</em> the state of the world,” I would say.</p><p>Hope is about the future, about a better future. And we all have our wishes, ideas and expectations about that future. Both with regard to our own personal future and the world at large. Of some wishes we are quite sure that they will come true, everything points in that direction; those are our expectations. About other wishes we are a little less sure, but the facts and circumstances look good, so we have confidence.</p><p>Hoping for a better future, hoping that our wishes will come true, is the most uncertain form of looking at the future. You could say that hope moves somewhere between wish and expectation; hoping is to have some confidence even if there is actually no reason to have confidence.</p><p>Hope is therefore different from optimism. An optimist assumes that things will work out alright; someone who hopes assumes things <em>may</em> work out, but does not just assume they <em>will</em>. So it’s a rather uncertain, unsteady state. But one with a positive undertone, in the words of the American writer Rebecca Solnit: “You could call it an account of complexities and uncertainties, with openings.”</p><p>Hope is the opposite of both hopelessness and despair. Hopelessness is the absence of hope. Those who feel hopeless have lost confidence that their desired future will become a reality. The (negative) expectation has defeated the wish. They have given up. Despair is also the absence of hope, but without surrendering. Those who despair also have lost confidence that their desired future will become a reality, but nevertheless hold on to it. Wish and expectation clash. Those who despair, struggle and are unable to do what they want to do, achieve what they want to achieve. Powerlessness leads to despair.</p><p>Hope is also the opposite of fear. Where hope is always about something positive, fear always refers to something negative. We know that fear makes for a poor advisor; basing your actions on what you fear is usually not a very fruitful idea. Hope ensures that you focus on a positive outcome. Hope is somewhere between what we wish <em>will</em> happen and what we fear <em>might</em> happen.</p><p>Hope is therefore one of the ingredients you need to feel somewhat positive and cheerful. In fact, hope is essential. If you have no hope (anymore), no faith and confidence whatsoever that what you do will lead to something or that things will get better, why would you do anything at all? Life without hope is empty and gloomy, nothing makes sense anymore. Hope keeps you going, as it were; whoever gives up hope falls silent. Without hope you become apathetic.</p><p>OK, so now we know what hope is and why it is important, but we don’t yet have an answer to the question “how?” Because it can be damn difficult sometimes to keep hope. Whether it’s on a personal level or about major developments in the world at large, it is not surprising if you sometimes wonder whether hoping for a better future is not just plain naive.</p><p>Where hope seems to be lost, cynicism lurks. Especially for those, like me, who are used to thinking critically. Critical thinking and hope seem to be opposites. “Critical thinking without hope is cynicism. Hope without critical thinking is naïveté,” says Bulgarian-American writer Maria Popova. Finding the balance between critical thinking and hope is “a difficult dance,” she rightly says. But we have to, because as I said, whoever gives up hope surrenders to cynicism, and cynicism kills all hope. It is a “closed-door policy”, as the American philosopher Robert Solomon calls it.</p><p>Hope, as Rebecca Solnit pointed out, keeps the door to the future open. That way, hope can empower you to get through tough times. To keep going if things aren’t going that well and you feel down. In order not to get stuck in negativity. You could say that we are confronted with hope when we are on the verge of losing it. The moment we are about to give up hope. The more difficult the situation we are in, or the more difficult it is to achieve our desired future, the more is required of our hope.</p><p>But hope, whichever way you look at it, is a shaky foundation. You hold onto something that actually offers little to hold on to. “It transcends the world that is immediately experienced, and is anchored somewhere beyond its horizons,” says Václav Havel. And that makes it so intangible. I therefore think that, in order not to fall into apathy or cynicism, hope is not enough.</p><p>The first thing you need besides hope is perspective. You can hope that something will happen or that the situation will improve, but if that never happens, your hope will diminish and eventually disappear. You cannot keep hoping and have confidence indefinitely without at least something coming true. You need something to look forward to. Something that is concrete enough, that is achievable, somewhat within reach — or at least within sight. Something that you know can happen and will give you pleasure or satisfaction, even if the desired better future will not be realized.</p><p>Hope is what drives you when that perspective is lacking. If, as I said earlier, the facts and circumstances do not point to that better future. So you cannot do without hope, but in the end you cannot do without perspective either, the prospect that the situation will improve, that in the (near) future fun, nice, valuable things are bound to happen, that the things you do will help make your life (and that of others) a bit more meaningful and enjoyable.</p><p>Without that perspective, hope eventually fades away. Hopelessness is perspectivelessness. Hope is “anchored beyond the horizon” says Havel, but if a viable perspective never appears on that horizon, hope is ultimately no more than a mirage. In the long run, you don’t know how things will go. And there is so much that is beyond your sphere of influence. But in the short term you can set your concrete goals, so that you can take small steps that are concrete enough to offer you more than the fragile grip that just hope offers.</p><p>And with that I automatically come to the second thing you need: courage. Courage to continue even if there is no concrete perspective for a while. In order not to let cynicism win and to stick to the idea that things <em>may</em> get better. To hold on to your wishes and ideals, to swim against the current. The situation is uncertain, but with openings, Solnit says. Whoever hopes holds on to those openings, that possibility without certainty, and from that takes the courage to continue.</p><p>Hope gives you the strength, according to Havel, “to work for something because it is good, not just because it stands a chance to succeed.” Hope does not remove the uncertainty, Rebecca Solnit says as well: “Hope just means another world might be possible, not promised, not guaranteed.” And in that possibility, according to Solnit, there is room for action: “When you recognize uncertainty, you recognize that you may be able to influence the outcomes.”</p><p>Hope, perspective and courage. Those three together, interconnected and affecting each other, can inspire, motivate and stimulate you to get (and keep) moving. To live, to try new things, to take on challenges. Hope that a better future is possible, the courage to act on that and perspective to make it concrete enough. All based on, as Solnit says, “the belief that what we do matters.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63223fad3ba8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why we need to be angry sometimes (regardless what the Stoics say)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mennovanderland/why-we-need-to-be-angry-sometimes-regardless-what-the-stoics-say-ca0fffc3f4d4?source=rss-7574b269de79------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ca0fffc3f4d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stoicism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emotions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anger]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Menno van der Land | Existential Reflections]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 May 2020 15:22:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-10T15:22:24.841Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/962/1*ZzhHcoEVO5iMfMVt_5OQ1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>I don’t know about you, but I can get quite angry sometimes. It doesn’t happen often, but things like injustice, cheating and disrespectful behavior can really piss me off. It is a trait that I have had all my life; as a child I used to throw a tantrum if I felt treated unfairly.</p><p>In philosophy (and also psychology) there are different ideas about how best to deal with anger. According to the Greek philosopher Seneca, who considered peace of mind as the most important characteristic of a happy life, you must suppress anger. If you’re angry about something, you have to deal with it rationally and not let your emotions run wild, Seneca said. Immanuel Kant also believed that getting angry is unwise. According to him, we have to deal with our emotions in a ‘sensible’ way and according to Kant that means we have to control our anger.</p><p>The problem with this rational approach is that anger is a strong emotion, often popping up in a sudden wave. It is difficult to keep your head cool in such a moment of strong emotion and to react in a controlled and rational manner. That sounds nice in theory, but staying ‘zen’ in the middle of such an eruption is not easy to do. You may even question whether it’s necessary. Isn’t it better to express your emotions rather than suppress them?</p><p>Following Seneca, the Stoics (and many contemporary Stoicism-based movements) say: Anger means that you want the situation to be different than it is. And that is pointless, because the situation is the way it is. What has happened has happened, you cannot change that anymore. Of course they are right about that. But rejecting anger because it doesn’t change the situation is — in my opinion — a fallacy. Firstly, there is a difference between your reaction to a situation and wanting to change that situation. And secondly, anger can indeed be a driving force for change.</p><p>Getting angry is human, and in some situations it would be weird if you didn’t. By showing your anger, you can show the person you are angry with what his or her behavior is doing to you, that you have been hurt by something someone has said or done. I’m not saying you should start kicking and screaming, but reacting very cool and rational may not do justice to the emotional pain you feel. Anger is sometimes necessary to make your point, make yourself heard, or stand up for yourself (or someone else). To make sure something doesn’t happen again.</p><p>Anger can also be an outlet. Suppressing anger can cause you to bottle it up and become bitter. Denying your emotions this way leads to a resentment that continues to simmer, but sooner or later it will surface. Expressing your anger appropriately, on the other hand, can be a relief and, if the anger has subsided (which always happens!), offer room to move forward.</p><p>So I think anger is not necessarily wrong, also not from a moral point of view. Sometimes it is completely justified to get angry, for example when you are confronted with great injustice or when someone shows offensive or disrespectful behavior. Anger is not seldomly one of the driving forces behind social protest movements. German philosopher Wilhelm Schmid sees anger as “rebelling against what is intolerable.” In this way, anger can be an incentive for seeking respect and justice.</p><p>However, it is important to know why you get angry. That may sound strange, because when you are angry, you usually think it is entirely justified anyway. But as with most intense emotions, there is often an underlying emotion. Anger can be an expression of the pain a person feels because he or she feels hurt. It can also be an expression of powerlessness because the person in question sees no way out of the situation.</p><p>Anger can even be an expression of irritation about something completely different that has nothing to do with the current situation. The situation has then only been the ‘trigger’. These cases can often be recognized by the intensity of the emotion, which is not in reasonable proportion to the event. If your reaction is not angry, but furious, if you are raging like a madman, it might be good to ask yourself what is going on and where exactly your reaction is coming from.</p><p>That is why Seneca and Kant are not entirely wrong; after all, it is wise to control your anger to a certain extent. Giving your emotion free rein can have a destructive effect on the relationship with the person you are angry with, uncontrolled anger does not contribute much to the solution of the situation and usually doesn’t make you feel any better. So try to make your point without lashing out.</p><p>In my opinion, the Greek philosopher Aristotle has come up with the best way of dealing with anger. According to Aristotle, it is important “to be angry with the right person, to the right amount, at the right time, for the right purpose, and in the right way”. He adds that this is not easy. But as an ideal, I think it can help you to consciously manage your anger and use it for the better.</p><p>It is therefore advisable, when you find yourself angry, to try to build in a moment of reflection and ask yourself if your anger is justified. Ask yourself three questions: Why exactly am I angry? Is the situation really worth getting angry? And what do I want to achieve with my anger?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ca0fffc3f4d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>