<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Holzman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Holzman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mgholzman?source=rss-ade69460bec------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 12:44:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mgholzman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Post 710 Israel Trip Lessons]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mgholzman/post-710-israel-trip-lessons-75e64dbe2484?source=rss-ade69460bec------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75e64dbe2484</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-gaza-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaza-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Holzman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Dec 2023 13:57:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-06T13:57:11.595Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I first heard about the Shalom Hartman Institute Rabbinic Solidarity mission, my urge to sign up was overpowering. I love Hartman. For those of you who do not know them, The Shalom Hartman Institute provides high level Jewish learning and thinking for community leaders from their beautiful campus in Jerusalem and through programs in North America. I was a research fellow with the Kogod Research Center in 2020–2021, and I am on the Hartman faculty. They run a program called <em>Rabbanut Yisraelit </em>which ordains rabbis from across the denominational spectrum throughout Israeli society. Our itinerary relied upon that network of students and alumni to share their experiences and the volunteer work they’ve been doing since 10/7. And I must also mention that I really wanted to go visit our friends from Kehillat Achvat B’kerem, Tamir and Adit Nir and whichever of their adult children were around, to stay in their home, enjoy meals together, and just see each other.</p><p>But I will say that my immediate powerful urge to sign up surprised me. First, I am temperamentally risk-averse, and so the idea of flying into a literal war zone was not obvious. Second, and this is more important, I was born in 1973, and my feelings about Israel have always been complicated. Prior to October 7th, solidarity was not automatic for me. I have often felt like Israel was a bully — to its Arab citizens, to Palestinians in the occupied territories, and to Reform Jews like me. I have been frustrated, revolted, infuriated, insulted and alienated by the policies of the state. I am a Zionist. I love Israel. I believe the Jewish people should have a state in our homeland. But, solidarity has never been a natural fit. Yet, the minute I heard about the trip, I knew in my gut that I had to go.</p><p>So as I departed I wrote about my confusion in my journal. The sheer horror of October 7th naturally made me want to do something, to act, to do <em>hesed</em>. The realization that this was a historic slaughter of Jews, deepened my sense of vulnerability, so perhaps I had a subconscious need to go to a place where young Jews are carrying big guns everywhere you look. But I think the most powerful driver of my participation was the almost immediate, loud, widespread progressive support for the Palestinian cause without equal declarations of outrage at Hamas and condolence for the Jewish people. I wrote in my journal about feeling bewildered, literally cast out by ideological allies in the fight for civil and human rights. So maybe through this trip I sought a path out of the wilderness.</p><p>In short, I can say that the trip was amazing, perhaps even life or career changing. I am still digesting what just happened, but I can say that my journey as a human, a Jew, and a rabbi, has been shifted in three profound ways. First, I felt the power of something so simple: an embrace. This trip brought me a totally different emotional connection to Jewish people and Jewish peoplehood, and a degree of intimacy I felt between my sense of Americanness and my Jewish peoplehood. Second, I saw the amazing power of activism, entrepreneurship, and institutions. And based on my learning through the Rebuilding Democracy Project since 2017, I think this is critically important for Israeli democracy. Third, I can say that we have all entered a total rethinking of the Zionist project. We are already in it, even if we were not aware. I will illustrate these three lessons with high points from the trip.</p><p>To explain what I found, I want to ask you to picture your past trips to Israel, for those of you who have gone. Think about the sense of anticipation, the excitement of seeing Jewish history — ancient and modern — all around you, the desire to experience a place where Judaism and Jews surround you, the fun of international travel, the spiritual yearning to experience a land called Promised, or Holy, Eretz Yisrael. This trip was none of that, which was apparent before I even arrived.</p><p>At the gate at JFK, gone were the boisterous birthright groups, the bubbling families heading to big B’nai Mitzvah or weddings, and the synagogue groups or tourists eagerly reading travel guides. There were even far fewer Orthodox families heading back and forth. Instead, the gate was filled with determined faces, adults like me traveling alone, and people traveling with IDF lone-soldier sweatshirts.</p><p>Then, walking down the gangway, I looked out at the rainy night and saw the El-Al plane. I was not prepared for the rush of emotion, seeing that blue and white plane, and the Israeli flag on the tail. Through the raindrops, the sight was overwhelming. The closest comparison was the sense of relief I felt when I received my first vaccination shot during Covid: doing something so mundane in the midst of a rushed and crowded public space, while feeling these profound and intensely personal emotions well up. Seeing that flag gleaming in the night, tears fell down my cheeks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Dc4ZT-CMb1EhGMQPXXRrCQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Boarding my flight, I was stunned by my first sight of an Israeli flag.</figcaption></figure><p>On the plane, when I opened the in-flight entertainment system, the normal El-Al advertisement began like it does on every ariline. You know, the little video with sparkling planes, attractive flight staff, and exciting destinations. But this video was different. It was cell phone clips of messy planes, exhausted and dissheveled staff, and young men and women filling the rows, standing in aisles, sleeping in galleys. Israeli flags hung from ceilings. These were from that first week after the attack, when the national airline told reservists to just show up at airports around the world, and El-Al would fly them home to serve. More tears. Later in the trip when I shared this with Adit, she told me that many of her friends have said they will never fly another airline again.</p><p>When I arrived at Ben Gurion, I was staggered by two things. First, the normally busy airport was a ghost town, and second, there were posters of the hostages everywhere. Perhaps you remember that gigantic, grand sloping entry hall with images from Jewish history everywhere. Now it has a poster of a different hostage on every railing banister. It is one long, somber hostage display.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*izKKHuiDlQry7UXKFzlXug.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ben Gurion Airport’s entry hall.</figcaption></figure><p>This kind of emotional saturation continued throughout the trip. Pride and solidarity were constant. In a place where people are usually self-absorbed and rushing through the markets and streets jostling each other, this trip was filled with people in uniform, doing some kind of volunteer work, carrying signs, wearing slogans, talking about the latest hostage release, or all of the above. The place is in a constant need to embrace one another. The popular slogan for this war that has emerged says <em>b’yachad l’natzeach</em> (“Together we will prevail”).</p><p>In fact, the normal term to describe the area of the 10/7 attacks is <em>Otef Gaza</em>, which literally means “the Gaza envelope.” But the residents want to discard that name, saying that they never again want to name the location of their homes in reference to Gaza. They want to call it <em>Otef Yisrael</em>, “the envelope of Israel,” which has a double meaning, as the word <em>otef</em> can also mean “embrace.”</p><p>And that explains the mood right now, the entire country wants to embrace the survivors, the displaced, the soldiers, each other, visiting Americans, and especially the hostages and their families. And it explains why the first time I saw Tamir he gave me an enormous hug, and then later the first time I saw Adit, I got an even bigger hug. <em>Otef Yisrael.</em></p><p>On the first night of our trip we talked with the leaders of a program called Edut 710. Edut means “witnessing” and the program applies the techniques of recording testimony from Holocaust survivors to capturing the experiences of Israelis on 10/7, which Israelis know as 7/10. They explained that their guiding philosophy comes from French Philosopher Emmanuel Levinas, who says that we are obligated to help other people find the ability to respond to their traumas and sufferings, something he calls “response ability.” It is a powerful lesson, that my humanity includes a duty to help others express their humanity.</p><p>And I saw the importance of this “response ability” throughout the rest of the journey. On the second day, we started with learning from Melila Hellner Eshed, scholar of mysticism, who talked about how in the first weeks after 10/7 people needed grieving circles, gathering just to experience the pain together, and how people are still not fully able to find words to describe the moment.</p><p>Then we went to our first volunteer projects. I went to visit a school set up by the displaced residents of Kibbutz Sa’ad, a religious kibbutz that successfully kept the Terrorists outside their gates, but had to be evacuated, nonetheless. There are 250,000 displaced people like this in Israel, staying in hotels everywhere, but mostly in Jerusalem, the Dead Sea area, and Eilat. Setting up schools for all the children has been a major challenge. The 7–9th graders of Kibbutz Saad were meeting in the national parks facility at the foot of Masada.</p><blockquote>In the shadow of the Jewish monument to tenacity and vulnerability, these young Jews and their teachers had to build a school. Once a week, classes take the cable car up the mountain to have morning meetings to process the Hamas attacks, in the exact place where Jewish Zealots once held out against Roman attacks.</blockquote><p>We were coming to practice English with the 9th grade English class, but the students wanted to talk to us about their experiences. They complained about normal 9th grade things, and also about the hardships of living in hotels for 2 months, dealing with the constant noise, the lack of privacy, the repetitive food, the inability for most of them to be in the same room or even on the same floor with parents. The kid next to me wanted to talk about his love of rap music and his desire to become a barber, a plan frustrated because there was no longer a regular barber shop nearby where he could learn his trade. Then one of the girls said she was afraid that all her friends from the surrounding Kibbutzim would not be there when they will go home, and that she would never be able to go back to her old life. Everyone nodded. In addition to grieving the people who died on 10/7, these kids were grieving imagined teenage years that will never be. I could not help but think about Nicole’s grandmother Ursula who, in 1937, had to flee Berlin at their age. Her family still feels that trauma generations later.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s1SSUvBCj6d0sc-P5yRIFA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Three of us practiced English with a class of 9th graders displaced from Kibbutz Sa’ad now attending class in the visitor center of Masada National Park.</figcaption></figure><p>After Masada, we went to Kibbutz Ein Gedi, a beautiful garden and guest house by the Dead Sea, for lunch and small group discussion. My group got sidetracked by a cute dog sitting with an older couple having lunch. The man spoke perfect English and said, who are you and why are you here. The three of us explained that we were a group of rabbis visiting from the United States to learn about how Israel is doing right now. He said, “You want to know about October 7th? I’ll tell you about October 7th!” His hands started shaking. “I was there. I held my gun and shot those damn terrorists at my front door. I shot one, and the other two ran off and left a bomb outside my house. I sat outside my shelter with my family behind me and my 25 year old son said, ‘Dad, maybe we need to do what they did at Masada.’ And I said I would sit outside and never do that.” Over the next 45 minutes, Yishai and Yael Admati from Beiri related their story to us. As we had to wrap up, Yael took out her phone and opened Facebook, and showed us her list of friends: “Dead, Dead, Kidnapped, Dead, in the U.S., Dead, Dead, Dead, Kidnapped . . ., this one is alive.’”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cD7raWOJaLrTOPbnm6sbfw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Our group meeting with survivors from Kibbutz Holit on the beautiful grounds of Kibbutz Ein Gedi where they have been relocated.</figcaption></figure><p>We gave them hugs and departed for our next program, where our group sat in an enormous circle and listened as four women from Kibbutz Holit related their similar story. And then as I left that group and walked to the bathroom, I was stopped by another woman who grabbed my arm and asked me who I was. I told her I was a rabbi. She said in Hebrew, “From America?” And I said, “Yes, where are you from.” And she said “Sderot,” which is a small city near Gaza. Then one of her children interrupted us, and I asked how many she had. Four. I asked if she had help. She paused and tilted her head, and told me her husband was a police officer in Sderot. And I said, “he is not here.” And she said, “He is dead.” I hugged her. She took out her phone to show me his picture. I was overwhelmed and forgot to remember his name. I hugged her again, I told her I would not forget her and her family, and I said goodbye. What could I do? Take a selfie? That was the hardest single moment of the trip.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4k2HQA_Ry6eSQ4RyskgLeg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The image of police officer from Sderot on his widow’s cell phone. The interaction was so sudden, and her need to tell her story so unexpected, I forgot to record his name.</figcaption></figure><p>From there we went up to Jerusalem to the <strong>H</strong>a<strong>m</strong>a<strong>l </strong>(“<strong>H</strong>eder <strong>M</strong>i<strong>l</strong>chama” war-room) volunteer operations center which is in a performing arts school that has been donated to the cause. Under the name <em>Lev Echad, </em>(which means “One Heart,”) there are 25 Hamals set up all over Israel. They function as a one stop shop for 20 different projects to help the country. They collect supplies for those in need or for reservists and soldiers. They operate free “stores” where displaced people can find clothes, toys, books or personal items. They provide volunteer opportunities, which keeps the average Israeli sane. And perhaps most importantly, they have united a massive range of civic and political groups, from across the spectrum into a coalition whose only requirement is to put ego aside.</p><p>Our group had brought tons of supplies, things that the Hamal had specified before departure. You should know that I spent about $1,000 from my discretionary fund to buy soft-shell jackets and flashlights that clip on to M-16s. This was from a list generated by the Hamal. We spoke with the leader who said that before 10/7 it was not obvious that the Jewish people had the ability to give so much, and he said that it was not obvious that American Jewry would give. He said that our generosity has been noticed, and has felt like another embrace.</p><blockquote>He also said that Israelis are aware of what we are facing in the United States, aware of the anti-Semitism, aware of the criticism of Israel, aware of the pro-Palestine marches. And they are sending us their support.</blockquote><p>This sentiment was surprisingly common during my trip. I heard it again the next day, on Wednesday, when I spent the afternoon in the community garden with Rabbi Nir and our sister community Achvat B’kerem. I was there to help out, to take photos, to be honored because NVHC has supported the building of their garden pavilion, and to talk with members. As Tamir taught the children how to make beer (something he might be arrested for in the U.S. but that is perfectly normal to teach in Israel), their parents and other volunteers spoke with me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ya6RBIpMDJv1kEWWlJ-o3A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rabbi Tamir Nir teaching children from Kehillat Achvat B’Kerem how to make beer in their community garden.</figcaption></figure><p>They told me two main things. The first was that concern about anti-Semitism. Separately five different people asked me about it. Here I was going to support Israel and they wanted to support me and you. And the second thing seemed obvious but was actually even more interesting. They said that the community garden had become a kind of refuge for them, a source of resilience. They spoke about how gathering there, having a joint project, about decision-making, about the stability of the community, all provided a refuge against the chaos that has fallen on Israel not just since October 7th, but also for the past year during the pro-democracy protests.</p><p>This concept also was a major theme of the trip — the need for institutions. When describing displaced people, we heard three different times that residents from the kibbutzim and moshavim had fared far better than people from cities like Sderot. The city folk were isolated, alone and disoriented, like that woman I met from Sderot. The kibbutz communities had not just familiar faces, but also established roles, rules, processes and duties. One kibbutz had even told the hotel staff to stop cleaning and cooking so that the kibbutz members could re-establish their old <em>toranut </em>schedule (the responsibilities that children and adults have for work). As Rabbah Tamar Edad Applebaum from Hartman said at one point, the word <em>Torah </em>contains <em>toranut, </em>the spiritual need for work and duty.</p><p>I saw this again when I went to Hostage Square on Thursday afternoon of my trip, which formerly was the plaza of the Tel Aviv Art Museum, but now is a combination public art installation, venue for vigils, prayer services, and performances, and a place where strangers can sit in circles of chairs and talk with the families of the kidnapped. We spoke with one woman who was selling solidarity symbols whose daughter had been released the night before. When I said, “What are you doing here? Go be with your daughter!” She said, my daughter is safe, she wants quiet, and I need to be here, with these people, doing my job.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f3hIPLQecx_dyGduzlWOgw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A corner of Hostage Square, a pop-up gathering place in the plaza of the Tel Aviv Museum of Art and across the street from IDF headquarters.</figcaption></figure><p>The pop-up nature of Hostage square, the circles of chairs, the public art, is its own uniquely Israeli form of resilience. Israel also has a system of permitting and permissions, but enforcement is far more selective. The square happened there because it is across the street from Israel’s version of the Pentagon. The families want the IDF to never forget to prioritize the hostages. I have a few necklaces and ribbons from Hostage square to give out, but I ask that if you take one, you wear it, and you tell anyone who asks why you are wearing it, how the entire Jewish people is thinking day and night about the hostages being held by terrorists.</p><p>Another pop-up Israeli project was the site of my volunteer work on Thursday. I went to meet students from the Keshet High School — a mixed religious and secular school set up after the Rabin assassination. During the pandemic a teacher, who also happens to be a Rabbanut Yisraelit ordainee, had set up a program to cook for about 20 elderly couples in the neighborhood. Because it was the pandemic they cooked in the school garage. Now they serve 300 soldiers, displaced families, and people with reservists away on duty. Still in the garage. As I worked with the students, chopping vegetables, putting trays into portable ovens, we had to pause and move aside when cars had to drive through. As I stood there, I could almost feel a health inspector from Fairfax County going to my house to fine me. But in Israel this was nothing.</p><blockquote>If the first lesson of this trip was the need for an emotional embrace, the obligation of witnessing or “response ability,” this was my second major learning, the uniquely Israeli way of creating institutions.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EAfgAZUPOxHnCqXFHAbHkQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A few of us rabbis with the volunteer team from Keshet High School, operating a kitchen in the school garage, to prepare meals for IDF reservists and their families.</figcaption></figure><p>In the Rebuilding Democracy Project we talk about this a lot — the importance of institutions. Best articulated by Alexis de Tocqueville in the 1830s, American democratic norms and behavior are nurtured in our country’s vast network of civic associations and formal leadership opportunities. Institutions are places where ordinary people learn how to function collectively, based upon a larger sense of purpose, within rules established by the collective. They are little incubators of citizenship. And America has tons of them.</p><blockquote>When I went to Israel in 2021 to research Israeli democracy, one of the most important takeaways was the dearth of a similar Israeli infrastructure. I spoke to scholars, journalists, activists, and rabbis. They all said that institutions that once provided democratic glue, especially the IDF and the kibbutzim had become divided by class and ethnicity, and no longer created a larger sense of duty. One person derisively said the kibbutzim were nothing more than real estate developers. At that time, in 2021, people said that the government was the only major institution left in society.</blockquote><p>Six months ago, at an event in DC, I even asked Donniel Hartman how the protest movement might turn into an ongoing institution, and he responded by saying it should not become a political party. I pointed out that I had not asked about a political party, and he suddenly realized his assumption. He said, Israelis automatically think every movement should be a party. They don’t think of institutions that way.</p><p>Observing Israel during this trip, I think that has changed. The conflict, coming on the heels of 10 months of protests against judicial reform, following Covid, have created a new ecosystem of institution building. The resilience of the kibbutz communities, the experience of people like members of Achvat B’kerem, the volunteers who set up the vast Hamal network, the leaders at Hostage Square, the alumni network of Rabbanut Yisraeli, and the volunteer projects operating in places like High School garages, all reflect the ways that Israelis govern, lead, deliberate, and build. They are informal, resourceful, creative, determined, flexible, and spiritual in ways that American organizations are usually more bureaucratic and rigid. If we learn democracy through procedures and meetings run by Robert’s Rules, Israelis may be learning democracy on WhatsApp. I believe that this moment has crystallized the need for a renaissance in Israeli institution building.</p><p>And Judaism’s role in creating institutions may be shifting as well, but that would take too long to explain today.</p><p>And that leads to the third major learning of this trip. I went out of order in describing my itinerary, because scattered throughout the schedule were meetings with scholars to discuss this moment. Some of these were with the big group, and some I set up on my own.</p><p>In extremely broad strokes, I heard one overpowering message, from speakers across the huge range of society: Zionism needs a reboot. Let me explain. From its origins, Zionism has been a multi-faceted thing. Its core idea, that the Jewish people need a Jewish state in our homeland, requires commentary. Kind of like the Shema, which in 6 words articulates a clear, simple dogma, but which requires a Torah of elaboration, Zionism has layers of interpretation.</p><p>Leading up to October 7th, an array of assumptions had become ossified in Zionism. At one point, Micah Goodman ticked off how all the assumptions had been shattered, some revealing enormous weaknesses in Israel, and others revealing tremendous strength. Zionism had assumed a competent, powerful state; that is gone and replaced by a vibrant civic volunteer culture. Zionism had assumed a terribly divided society, held in place largely by political maneuvering; that has been exploded by the absurd levels of solidarity, service, coalition building, and activity explicitly crossing political lines. Zionism had assumed little need for or expectation of the diaspora, American Jewry or even really the U.S.; those myths have been busted and replaced by a deep yearning for worldwide Jewry, a gigantic gratitude for us and for President Biden, and a concern for our wellbeing. Zionism had assumed that the Palestinian Citizens of Israel (who I will call Arab Israelis for short because no consensus name exists for this group) would join any Palestinian uprising against the State of Israel; the exact opposite has happened, and Israeli Jews really do not know how to respond. Zionism assumed that the Palestinians under occupation could be “managed” with walls and with electronics; 10/7 has shown that the current “conceptzia” is simply not secure.</p><blockquote>There are so many other examples, but the message remains the same: we need to be preparing ourselves for what happens next. All of the assumptions are wiped away. Micah Goodman spoke about how this is an enormous opportunity. “Nothing is sacred. Everything is on the table.” And then he spoke about the threat that when this is over, all the grief and trauma that is now directed at Hamas will be directed by Israelis at other Israelis.</blockquote><p>Rana Fahoum said that already Israeli Arabs are being arrested if they merely express sympathy for their families in Gaza. Nobody has been prosecuted, but there have been arrests, lost jobs, threats. The distrust is deep. Many Arab and Druze Israelis have refused to evacuate their homes, which are actively under threat of missile attack, because they have memories of 1948 and do not trust Israel to allow them to return. So the moment is filled with promise, and with mistrust. Precarious.</p><p>By the way, if you are wondering about military strategy and the war in Gaza, sadly the message I received on this trip was exceptionally clear: things are going to get ugly before they get better. I heard a range of expressions of this idea. Even the President of Rabbis for Human Rights, as liberal as you get in Israel, said he still works toward peace and co-existence but he has to turn away from Gaza as long as Hamas is there. He grew up going into Khan Younis as the nearest big city, and going to Gaza beaches after work in the fields of his kibbutz. He said they used to sing about a time when there would be no fence between Khan Younis and his kibbutz, but then he lived through a day with no fence. He cannot even think about peace with Gaza as long as Hamas is across the fence.</p><p>While people here seem to be obsessed with the suffering of Gazans, angry only at Israel for their deaths, people in Israel think only about Hamas, and see Gazans as unfortunate victims of their own leaders.</p><p>Yishai Admati, with his dog at Ein Gedi, simply said “No mercy, no mercy, no mercy,” to my face. Yossi Klein Halevi talked about the need for a massive reorientation of power in the entire Middle East and said that Gaza was the simplest part. A 9th grader at Masada gave maybe the most sophisticated political analysis: we cannot go home until we know Hamas is gone, because we cannot let Israel assume we will live with that threat. Over and over, the message was, the war will continue, they have to defeat Hamas, they have to get every hostage back.</p><p>While over here we are hearing about calls for Cease Fire, and people are working to end the war, over in Israel there is exactly zero appetite to end the war. They are still grieving, and they are solidly determined to change the status quo ante with Gaza.</p><p>To conclude I will say, I do not know if I lived up to Levinas’ ethic of “response ability,” but I can tell you that every Israeli I met felt this intense need to share their stories and their concerns, especially with American Jews. It was painfully clear that my presence, and my listening, provided one more filament connecting them back to reality. Their need was almost like someone underwater who needed air. Not just to be heard, but to be heard by us in particular. I think our Americanness was important. We are Jews, but unlike other Jews in the world, nobody expects us to make Aliyah. We are separate and we are supposed to be secure. We are equals. And this conflict has revealed that we are not entirely separate or secure. The conflict affirms a Jewish bond that transcends time and space, and thus in a way, mortality. I felt a true <em>otef, </em>an embrace.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NyDs13iWRxg4JV7aVjfplg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The sign for the “Otef” store at the Jerusalem Hamal (volunteer headquarters) where displaced people can pick up personal items or receive counseling.</figcaption></figure><p>I will say that I was blown away by the institution building everywhere I looked. It does not resemble American institution building. It happens in garages and acting schools converted into war-rooms. It forms in a Kibbutz movement that rediscovers its depths of resilience and in rabbinical alumni networks who activate in communities across the country. It happens in community gardens and in public plazas. I asked multiple times if this energy was sustainable and could be converted into a durable constellation of civic institutions, and I never got a firm answer. But I believe this would be essential to what comes next.</p><p>And on the question of the future, the answer is far from clear. Zionism needs a reboot. I know everyone is thinking about it, but I also know that people are comfortable not knowing yet. The now is too intense. The grief still to raw. The strength, solidarity, determination, relentlessness, and pride is too dedicated to the hostages and the soldiers. But beneath all of that is an openness to a future undefined. And for the first time in my life and career I hear a strong desire that we, American Jews, are part of figuring it out.</p><p>I started the trip by sitting on the airplane writing in my journal about my reflexive urge to go. I realized that since October 7th a huge tension had been growing within me, one that emerged from the deep wound inflicted on our particular Jewish family, and one exacerbated by the behavior of my allies in the fight for universal human rights. This trip affirmed for me that the universal principle of God’s image embedded in every human can only be expressed and sustained through collective particularism. My Jewishness makes me more human. My particularism sustains my universalism.</p><p>We cannot have universal human dignity without the Jewish <em>otef</em>, without institutions to sustain that embrace, and without a vision for Zionism that will rebuild the Jewish state. I felt a reflexive need to sign up for the trip, because I knew in the depths of my soul that my humanity depended upon the Jewish state, and an expression of my Zionism that pushes the Jewish state to be its most humane, universalist and fair. October 7th opened all these things for us. I have no idea what comes next.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75e64dbe2484" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[After Huwara, What’s our Israel Curriculum?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mgholzman/after-huwara-b339f51128db?source=rss-ade69460bec------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b339f51128db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Holzman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Mar 2023 13:54:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-07T17:19:48.243Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>An open letter to CCAR colleagues and friends,</p><p>I do not post to our facebook page much, but I pose this question to you as respected and respectful colleagues, leaders of the Jewish people. I pray we can search together for answers.</p><p>I recently heard a colleague exhorting a group of rabbis to support a protest against the appearance of Smotrich at an upcoming Israel Bonds event in Washington, DC. “This is a Soviet Jewry moment,” she said.</p><p>The comment struck me at first as overblown, and then as profound. I think she was hoping for broad American Jewish support to protest the current Israeli government, but if that were to happen, if American Jewry was inspired and transformed by this moment, what would it mean? Playing out the metaphor, who is the oppressive regime, who is the beleaguered minority, who is in diaspora, and where are the refusniks hoping to go? And what does all this mean for how we teach Israel in our congregations?</p><p>If this is a Soviet Jewry moment, then what about our trips to Israel? Do we just walk through Roman ruins, colorful Safed synagogues, Syrian bunkers, and Tel Aviv streets, and continue teaching the miracle of Jewish survival, creativity, persistence, and ingenuity? Or do we realize that we have become like those 1980s rabbis smuggling prayer-books in our suitcases, sustaining an underground Judaism representing our vision of hope? Do we start teaching our congregations about the two Israels, the one embracing the unfettered use of power against its enemies (Jewish, Israeli, Arab, Palestinian, all), and the one struggling to keep liberal democracy alive? And what does this place we visit mean for us, for our Jews, for our Judaism?</p><p>Since at least 1967, our curriculum has lived somewhere between Leon Uris and Ari Shavit. Israel was the fruit of plucky <em>halutzim </em>returning Jewry to power using home-made weapons. And modern statehood had demanded some ugly realities, true atrocities <em>in our past </em>necessitated by other atrocities <em>in our past.</em> As Shavit put it (to us, in the New Yorker, not in Ha’aretz), “either reject Zionism because of Lydda or accept Zionism along with Lydda.” These narratives neatly aligned with our North American experience, growing into mastery of liberal democracy, embracing power, and then accepting the complicated dance of self-interest, privilege and moral responsibility. Israel taught us sovereignty.<em> Fiddler </em>could stand on Broadway and joke, “God bless and keep the Czar far, far from here,” because we, North American Jews, were no longer in <em>galut.</em></p><p>But Huwara changes everything. Purim explains why. For us, it is a child’s carnival because it directly contradicts our experience of sovereignty. The holiday is a Jewish fantasy of <em>galut </em>power, where violence is legitimatized by nothing other than proximity to the despot. Purim pokes holes in our assumptions about state power and turns everything upside down, because in Esther, violence is a whim. Our North American Judaism sees the farce. We live in a world where state violence is illegal and immoral unless sanctioned by democratic process. Democracy calls that, “rule of law.”</p><p>But from the ultra-nationalist, messianic, ultra-religious worldview of Samarian hilltops, Purim is reality: Jews are forever in mortal danger, protected only by killing their enemies as soon as possible. <em>Atrocities in the present and future</em> are allowed, even encouraged. In North America, we solve grievance with the tools of statehood — law, policy, regulation, carefully calibrated authority, institutions — but Huwara exposes Israel as<em> </em>a place where the use of force depends on the caprice of whichever Haman is in charge at the time. That’s <em>galut </em>Judaism.</p><p>So I wonder, what are we teaching? I am not asking about how our curriculum impacts Israel — our lobbying, our travel, our purchasing. I am not advocating BDS or calling Israel an <em>apartheid </em>state. Those are arguments for a different time. Right now, I ask how our Israel curriculum impacts us, our souls. Perhaps we are in diaspora, but the Judaism that fills our lives is not in <em>galut.</em></p><p>Long ago, the miracle of Israel intertwined sovereignty’s moral calculus into the DNA of my faith. The 1987 Soviet Jewry rally was our political coming out ceremony as full Jewish actors in a liberal democracy. It was a milestone in the development of a Judaism I cultivate and cherish, on ethat grapples with the moral responsibility of applying our power to confront injustice in the world.</p><p>This Purim, as we read about Jews taking violent revenge against their enemies, senior members of the government encourage wiping towns off the map, the IDF stands idly by, and pogromists pause to pray. To visit Israel now is to smuggle hope to its persecuted minority —the Jews committed to democracy, not to mention its Arabs! By abandoning the rule of law, it has abandoned the very sovereignty that it built into our Judaism. Without fair democratic process, its security-state oppressions lose all legitimacy, its financial bonds become dirty paper, its government a Czar, and its anthem a painful mockery. By accepting rampant hatred and discrimination as normal, Israel becomes not the manifestation of Exodus (either Bible or Uris), but rather a crumbling Moscow-Shushan where caprice reigns.</p><p>My Judaism and my Zionism compel me to visit Israel, but, unless I am willing to stick to the Epcot highlights itinerary, the journey no longer inspires my congregation as a miracle. I am still a Zionist, a believer in the necessity and just cause of Jewish statehood in our homeland. But after Huwara, if we are rescuing our Judaism from <em>galut </em>thinking, from a Shushan, what is our Israel curriculum here at home?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b339f51128db" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Need Sanctuaries For Politics, not From Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/office-of-citizen/we-need-sanctuaries-for-politics-not-from-politics-c1a2d32d9f41?source=rss-ade69460bec------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c1a2d32d9f41</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pace-faith-democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civic-engagement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philanthropy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Holzman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2020 22:23:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-17T22:23:00.500Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2ld0DVg5lYvOYI_UWhIfQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@timmossholder?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Tim Mossholder</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/humanity?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Life is messy. We disagree, argue, compromise, reconsider, regret, resent, resolve, and repeat cycles of confusion and clarity. Even, or especially, when we love each other, we families, couples, friends, communities sometimes find ourselves in moments of painful disarray, seeking the good, but struggling to discern a common way forward. Multiply this by millions and we have the messiness of a nation. But the brutal binary of elections is that they demand a simple result: someone has to win and someone has to lose. This simplicity denies our lived reality, and as our candidates become more and more strictly associated with specific and opposing policy solutions, that denial becomes painful. The more we allow our political culture to define the other candidate as the ultimate evil, the more pain will echo through the losing half of the population.</p><p>Nations evolve systems to contain the messiness and bear the disappointment and pain. The symbolic holiness of a monarch, for example, remaining above and separate from the helter-skelter of politics, provides a reassuring anchor of accountability when losers fear winners and winners must embrace losers. Democracies shift divine right to citizens, and we usually see this solely as a shift in authority, but it is also a shift in symbolic responsibility. When divinity resides in the citizenry, the only thing that helps us bear the fear of losing and the responsibilities of winning is our self-evident humanity.</p><p>We need systems to sustain and nourish that humanity. In her 2004 book, <em>Talking to Strangers</em>, Harvard professor of political philosophy, Danielle Allen writes, “Democratic citizens are by definition empowered only to be disempowered. As a result, democratic citizenship requires rituals to manage the psychological tension that arises from being a nearly powerless sovereign.” Essentially, we need rituals for losing.</p><p>The problem we face right now is a loss not just of specific rituals, but of the value of rituals themselves, and the value of whole segments of human experience that elevate our minds beyond the Hobbesian competition for power. Add to the list of problems created by social media the fact that the algorithms are fed by simple, binary choices (like vs. not like, friend vs. unfriend, swipe left vs. right). This training rots the mind and starves the soul, replacing the stuff that helps us bear the messiness of living with other human beings: rituals, sacred words, holy scriptures, hallowed ground, healthy norms, and above all else, the relentless imperative of looking into our neighbor’s face.</p><p>After the 2020 election, our society remains handicapped without ways to uphold and emphasize the divinity within citizenship. Without a rebirth of what I will call democratic spiritualism, some future manipulator will easily take advantage of the barren space once inhabited by the obligations we felt for each other and the nation.</p><p>Democratic spiritualism can rescue us from the corrupted moments currently passing for national holidays, flag salutes, and honors for veterans. When the United States military began paying the National Football League and Major League Baseball to honor the troops, it created almost the perfect demonstration of cynicism. Our national holidays have become mattress sales. Our public institutions have been made into partisan platforms and canvases for defacement.</p><p>Democratic spiritualism responds by giving people the experience of the sacred in our citizenship. This can be done through secular means, which is what Eric Liu does with Citizen University, an explicit transfer of religious behaviors to civic contexts. But why not turn to religion itself? More than a handful of commentators have pointed to the potential for religious identities, institutions and values to become the cornerstones of a new democratic unity. While these elements are important, they fail to address the inner workings of religious life, the problems and potential of prayer, ritual, scripture, acts and affiliation, in short, the mechanics of faith. This is the stuff upon which a democratic spiritualism must rest, and our faith institutions and leaders should be the ones teaching us how to use them.</p><p>Unfortunately, establishment religious institutions are largely disconnected from the lived pain of American democracy. Churches, synagogues, mosques and other houses of worship tend to follow one of two paths — complete avoidance of politics or complete adherence to one political point of view — ignoring the larger conversation about democracy itself. We create sanctuaries from politics where we keep the spirituality inside and the politics outside. This is because our seminaries train our clergy and our denominations train our laity to become either spiritualists or partisans, and to keep the two separate.</p><p>The one exception to this rule is the Black church, which, to generalize, has regularly included the problems of the day in its sacred service. Perhaps, separating spirituality from the nation’s problems was a privilege not afforded the people most likely to suffer those problems. This explains why Dr. King could infuse his politics with his spiritualism at the precise moment President John F. Kennedy sought to separate the two in claiming “an absolute separation of church and state.”</p><p>For clergy to bridge the divide between spiritualism and political activism, we would have to apply our religious habits to the topics of our political ecosystem. We would have to bring the political into our sanctuaries, and use the safety, accountability, and dignity housed within to host political speech that so easily turns into vitriol in the outside world. Our sanctuaries have the capacity to prevent the pollution of our politics. Here’s how:</p><p>Our prayers and rituals must be expanded and changed to apply theological concepts and passages to the burning questions of our moment. When we witness a national reckoning on a subject as complicated as race, we can turn to concepts of revelation to find ways to communicate the enormity of the newly discovered truth. When we struggle with the ways we have treated the planet, we can explore words like sin and atonement to find a path forward. Prayer and ritual rely on liturgy, calendar, performance, space — the tools of religious life which could all reinvigorate our national democratic ethos.</p><p>Second, our study of text needs to change the way we relate to information, exercising the muscles of interpretation, exegesis, and conversation and inoculating us against viral rants and simplifying memes. We all have traditions of wrestling with scripture. Even the most fundamentalist faiths strive to explain opaque texts to disciples of the tradition. We can apply these hermeneutics to the great texts of America, giving people an opportunity to encounter the words of our American ancestors in the same way we encounter holy books. And this is not to deify the words of Jefferson or Reagan, for every person of faith knows the intellectual, moral and spiritual struggle of uncovering the offensive passage in the midst of a treasured document. Honest, rigorous, curious, sacred conversations about Jefferson’s reference to Native Americans as “savages,” or Reagan’s denial of the people left behind in America, will help us grapple with the complexity of our civilization.</p><p>Third, our practice of sacred acts needs to include an awareness of geographic and social political sorting. One of our greatest problems as a nation is a lack of encounters with people of the opposite political party. Faith institutions can serve as holy archways across those divides, to bring partisans into human relationships over the things we all care about. The bitterness and toxicity of our national polarization disappear when serving the homeless together or visiting each other in a hospital room. These are the types of things all faith institutions promote and enable, and we need to find ways to do them together and for each other.</p><p>Last, we need to bolster the importance of affiliation and revive the experience of governance. Twenty years ago, Robert Putnam documented the decline of institutional affiliation in American culture. As the concept of “joining” becomes foreign, we should not be surprised to see a general notion of institutional norms dissolve. One way to restore those norms is to clarify the meaning behind affiliation and the adjoining experience of institutional stewardship. Common is the church, synagogue or mosque that cannot find candidates to fill Board positions, because this work is often, sometimes tedious, and occasionally confrontational. But successful organizational stewardship teaches important citizenship skills and exercises the muscles of healthy deliberation.</p><p>These are just four ways of creating democratic spiritualism through the existing infrastructure of American religiosity. This is not a call to greater civic engagement on specific issues, rather a call to retake religion’s role in determining the ethos of American politics. For the past three years the Rebuilding Democracy Project, founded at Northern Virginia Hebrew Congregation, has experimented with these techniques, and the lessons learned have changed the way we think about politics and react to the world around us. For example, after the murder of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, we created a Juneteenth Tikkun, applying to the issue of racism the traditional Jewish practice of overnight study prior to the moment of Revelation at Mt. Sinai. This is the kind of creativity that helps us retake our role in society.</p><p>I say retake because this was a role religion played for most of American history. In December, 1952, President-elect Eisenhower described a conversation he had with Soviet General Marshal Zukhov in Berlin at the end of World War II, in which Zhukov said, “Of course we have difficulty promulgating our theory, because we appeal to the idealistic in man and you appeal to all that is materialistic and selfish.” Eisenhower’s famous response: “[O]ur form of Government has no sense unless it is founded in a deeply felt religious faith, and I don’t care what it is.”</p><p>In 1952, religion’s role was clear. As Ike explained, government exists “to guarantee [to citizens] the opportunity to live in dignified fashion with their God and with their fellow citizens.” For him the system could survive only with a regular diet of human dignity, fed through religious practice. But the disappearance of traditional American religion has allowed our “materialistic and selfish” urges to win. The normative white, Anglo-Saxon, Protestant religious establishment of Eisenhower’s day will not return, nor should it. But a larger democratic spiritualism, championed by the 384,000 Christian, Catholic, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Bahai, and Buddhist houses of faith can cultivate the sacred ground from which our democracy flourishes anew.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c1a2d32d9f41" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/office-of-citizen/we-need-sanctuaries-for-politics-not-from-politics-c1a2d32d9f41">We Need Sanctuaries For Politics, not From Politics</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/office-of-citizen">Office of Citizen</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Addressing Guns by Moving Morality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/office-of-citizen/addressing-guns-by-moving-morality-98ffd23cf092?source=rss-ade69460bec------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/98ffd23cf092</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion-and-spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pace-timely-topics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gun-violence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Holzman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Jun 2018 13:42:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-08T14:59:59.359Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>In a public square fractured by debates on moral questions — how can we make space to address them and find common ground?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hPmIzaZ1QdmKojCUZn-gsA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Heather Mount</figcaption></figure><p>In my community, back in March, the response to this moment was a request for buses for our congregation to attend the “March for Our Lives” together. My congregants assumed we would act in the name of our tradition. They assumed that political advocacy would be easy for our community, because, like the rest of America, we had sorted ourselves into a homogeneous enough group. They were wrong. Jewish tradition puts plenty of support behind limiting the availability of deadly weapons, but it also supports using violence in self-defense. And this faith community has members on both sides of the gun debate.</p><p>As the spiritual leader of our congregation, I felt compelled to advocate with the Parkland students and arrange the buses. But I felt equally compelled to reject the tidal forces of political sorting that might push some members out of my community. I wanted to embrace the Jewish tradition of advocacy, as well as the Jewish value of respecting dissent. On this issue especially, those two values are at odds. Political engagement is a Jewish spiritual imperative, but our political system cannot digest the moral complexity and partisan polarization intertwined on this issue. Regardless of our position on the issue of gun control, we could not rush into the broken politics without harming the moral integrity of my community.</p><p>The gun control debate is both an opportunity for greater civic engagement, and another canary in the coal mine of broken politics. If Carl von Clausewitz, the famous military historian, said “War is the continuation of politics by other means,” then politics should be the prevention of war by other means.</p><h3>Politics should enable us to disagree without killing each other.</h3><p>But, as we saw in Charlottesville last summer, after local elected officials deliberated and voted on removing a Civil War statue, our toxic national politics actually contributed to violence. So, when we think about addressing gun ownership, we need a healthy politics now, more than ever. We are talking about deadly weapons, after all.</p><p>Behind every political issue lie moral questions. When we disagree about taxes, we’re also debating the balance between self and community. When we argue about criminal justice, we’re also grappling with legacies of intolerance, the need for communal safety, the ethics of punishment, and the stewardship of communal resources. And when we dispute the role of guns in society, we are contending with the values of individual liberty, the right to self-defense, the obligation to protect human life, and the duty to restrain violence. Scratch the surface of political discourse and we find that morality is intertwined with complicated policy.</p><h3>But politics is ill-suited for the task of addressing moral questions.</h3><p>What matters in politics is who has the power to exert the most influence and achieve the desired results. We might hope that those wielding influence and those feeling its push will prioritize the best interests of the community, but that hope is naïve. To remain in office, a politician needs to amass power, and individual lobbyists, commentators, analysts, and activists exist to exert it. In this environment, respectful moral disagreement gets crushed beneath the necessary wheels of power.</p><p>Look at the gun debate. The students have policy aims, but they elevate their cause into a fight “for our lives.” Gun-rights advocates seek not only to shape policy, but also to preserve a beloved “gun culture.” To disagree is to threaten either “lives” or a whole “culture.” The high-stakes emotional language reflects the underlying morality, which attracts and motivates followers, but the container of politics cracks under the pressure.</p><blockquote>Uncontained moral rhetoric leaves our communities divided and our political system weakened. While passionate speeches at gigantic marches may motivate civic engagement, they are no time for complicated discussion of morality. Without providing an alternate venue for moral passion, one that encourages nuance and demands respect for dissent, the political system chokes on competing moral demands.</blockquote><p>What does this look like in the institutions especially responsible for addressing morality (and by that I mean, faith institutions)? One common solution is to self-sort as a community to one political extreme or the other, giving parishioners with reservations the option to either leave or become a silent minority. This is the most common path for faith institutions seeking to engage in policy advocacy, and while it may inspire tremendous citizen engagement, it exacerbates our national partisan rifts. When faith communities advocate on any given issue, their chosen sides can claim — in addition to any political or economic arguments — divine approval. The volatility this adds to policy discussion, pushes advocates away from the center, and widens our divides.</p><p>Other churches, synagogues, mosques, and temples remain politically diverse, but preserve that diversity by avoiding policy altogether, a position somewhat at odds with the imperatives of faith traditions: all religions are concerned not only with the world to come, but also with the world as it is. So complete avoidance of policy within the faith institutions abandons part of our spiritual heritage and religious obligation. For those who believe in God, the divine voice speaks to the workings of the marketplace, the rules of the neighborhood, the ethics of the workplace and the issues in the public square. Therefore, avoidance undermines our integrity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s-Rk78dHzpeWunakoPFfuA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Heather Mount</figcaption></figure><p>As the March for Our Lives approached, my community rejected both of these approaches. We did not want to avoid policy altogether, and we also refused to self-sort. Instead, we created a different path by carefully designing a moral space to address this political issue.</p><p>Three weeks before the march, 150 of our community members gathered to discuss gun violence. We structured the evening carefully, following guidance from the <a href="https://www.better-angels.org/">Better Angels website</a> and other sources. We placed the event in our sanctuary to provide a spiritual context. We included multiple generations as 30 teens, some of whom had experienced actual “false-alarm” lock-downs, participated in the conversation. And we reminded everyone present that we are bound by a covenant of membership in our community. I shared that our tradition spoke clearly to me on the need to address the easy availability of mass-killing weapons in America, and equally clearly on the need to hear dissenting opinions.</p><p>We heard from a community member who leads a local Mom’s Demand Action chapter organizing support for the March, and from another member who is an NRA instructor and once had to rely upon her weapon to defend a tenant from her husband, a former Marine who suffered from PTSD. We paused for silence after each testimony. Then, we opened the floor for community members to respond, with the guidance that respondents should avoid attempting to change anyone’s opinion. I was nervous and feared a shouting match, but after every comment, we embraced a spiritual practice to say the Hebrew word <em>shamati </em>which loosely translates to “I heard you,” and the night progressed in peace. At the end of the evening, as most people had left, our two speakers embraced.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a9m3C_Qs5JEvaI8sP1i-Zw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Matheus Ferrero</figcaption></figure><p>The greatest accomplishment of the evening was no great policy breakthrough, but rather the experience of hearing intelligent disagreement while remaining in one community. This ability should be at the core of our democratic process. What else is democracy than my respect for your right to be wrong?</p><h3>Citizens need moral spaces in addition to political spaces.</h3><p>In fact, political engagement becomes easier and healthier when the other side’s opinions are respected — especially when we think that they are wrong — because this value builds a faith that my opinions will be respected when the other side prevails and they think I am wrong. In a moral space, we get beneath policy to discover deeply-held values, personal narratives, and aspirational world views, all of which are critical, but not always helpful to finding pragmatic solutions to problems.</p><blockquote>Moral spaces can relieve some of the pressurized passion from politics while encouraging greater civic commitment. They exercise our atrophied muscles of healthy dissent and remind us to honor disagreement.</blockquote><p>There are hundreds of thousands of houses of worship in America. These are places where we practice ritual, prayer, silence, music, fellowship, deep and careful textual study, covenant, acts of loving-kindness, and often faith in a power separate from humanity. These places have sacred spaces, employ spiritual leaders, welcome all classes and backgrounds, incorporate multiple generations, and place a priority on compassion, service and a belief in truth. These are precisely the assets and skills we need to create moral spaces for rigorous intellectual discussion about hard policy questions, where difference is embraced and not self-sorted. This is what we do well. This is our core purpose.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tstNQUE3Yz0FUDVRTHCRng.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Ben White</figcaption></figure><p>When we apply our religious skills and assets to public policy conversation, we strengthen both our politics and our faith communities. Failing to do so weakens our political discourse and betrays our faith commitments. <strong><em>So, I ask faith institutions, has not the time come for us to create moral spaces and heal our politics?</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=98ffd23cf092" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/office-of-citizen/addressing-guns-by-moving-morality-98ffd23cf092">Addressing Guns by Moving Morality</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/office-of-citizen">Office of Citizen</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Faith Makes Us Purple]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/office-of-citizen/how-faith-makes-us-purple-bded14b36ffe?source=rss-ade69460bec------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bded14b36ffe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[interfaith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pace-faith-democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civic-engagement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Holzman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Feb 2018 15:10:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-11T14:32:29.256Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Last year was a major opportunity for civic engagement in the Commonwealth of Virginia: we were the only state with a truly contested gubernatorial election, just one year into the Trump administration. So when the leadership of Virginians Organized for Interfaith Community Engagement (VOICE) gathered to plan our strategy, we knew national media attention would give us leverage to push for whatever issues we chose. VOICE is an affiliate of the Industrial Areas Foundation, the venerable group founded by Saul Alinsky, to help local people organize for change in their communities. We are an interfaith team representing around 50 houses of worship, and our issues tend to skew left, so given this opportunity in the summer and fall of 2017, what did we do?</p><h4>We went non-partisan. And it wasn’t easy.</h4><p>Many of our congregation members were angry that we would give “the other guy” a platform to speak. And when one of the candidates refused to attend our marquee event in October, many of our members were angry we did not publicly shame him for disrespecting the Northern Virginia faith community. The “empty chair” tactic was on the table. We could point to the chair in front of the 1,565 people we had painstakingly recruited to our event and say, “Look, that’s what candidate X thinks of you.” But as we looked at each other across a crowded conference room, just weeks before the event, we felt the kind of clarity that people of faith call, “God’s voice.” We could not go baldly partisan. We could not shame one side.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q8Iv6GlosFh6kgheYZOsSg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Virginians Organized for Interfaith Community Engagement (VOICE) hosted the largest event of the Virginia gubernatorial campaign with both candidates present (1565 people).</figcaption></figure><p>Within our individual houses of worship, especially in the past year, we had all sensed the pain of our congregants or parishioners feeling estranged from each other — from neighbors, friends, and family on the other side of the political divide. That day, we elevated above any individual issue, the sacred American covenant between citizen and community, which is rooted in the electoral process. We knew that hearing both sides fairly was essential to our purpose as people of faith seeking to better God’s world.</p><p>We devoted the next hour to developing a stealth assault strategy to get the reluctant candidate in that chair. And we succeeded. Our event was the largest in the entire campaign where both candidates were present. We had explicit non-partisan ground rules. We refused the temptation of yes/no or “gotcha” questions. We politely asked the crowd to refrain from booing and cheering during the speeches, and then we had to admonish them when they initially could not resist. And afterwards, more than one person remarked how reasonable “the other guy” sounded.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/1*PnFOc8Fa_FO9fbRDS1E-eA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The VOICE 2017 Election Action was based on specific ground rules to preserve the non-partisan ethic that the interfaith community had established.</figcaption></figure><p>Why did we choose this path? At our roots, people of faith rely upon the tools of religion — prayer, text, community, and acts of kindness — to discover God’s voice in our lives. Those tools shape our souls and build our institutions, but we see how they chip and crack upon the harsh stones of bitterness within and around our houses of worship. We can hear God’s voice drowned out by pointless partisan warfare. Alongside the relentless call we might hear for immigrants, the poor, the weak, and, for some, the unborn, we also hear the call of our neighbors, our friends, and our colleagues struggling to hold our community together.</p><p>As much as I feel the need to shout about the inequality of our educational system, I must also pray with the people who love that system. As much as I see our criminal justice system as an affront to the divine in every human being, I must also welcome every human being to sit with me as we study text. As much as God demands us to seek Medicaid expansion dollars for the sick, we must also visit the sick who oppose those dollars.</p><h4>At this moment, while we feel pain for the suffering members of society, we also feel pain as members of a society that suffers. That is what drove us to be proudly non-partisan.</h4><p>Religion’s role in supporting the pillars of our democratic system is uncommon in the history of religious involvement in civic engagement. Faith leaders have played key roles in major American policy debates since the founding of our republic; history shows that some of our best national decisions (Civil Rights) and our worst (Temperance) were driven by the faith community. But across that time, and through much of America today, religion has pushed groups away from compromise and moderation. If our body politic suffers the diseases of polarization and partisanship, history teaches that religion can only be another complicating infection. But the disease did not progress with us that day in October — or since. Instead, religion functioned to unify people across party lines through a commitment to the greater good of democracy, of citizenship, and of our sacred electoral rights and responsibilities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*5VFJYxo2aV0YHHFCTYdLHQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Though their non-partisan Get-out-the-Vote campaign, VOICE volunteers raised turnout by over 25% in most precincts where they worked.</figcaption></figure><p>Through Virginia’s gubernatorial election, the interfaith community committed ourselves to getting out the to vote, and so, with our purple shirts on, we reached out to huge lists of people who had never voted in a non-presidential election. When they opened the door, the first question we heard was often a cynical sneer, “Which one are you for?” When we said, “We have no opinion on that,” faces brightened and smiles widened. So we followed with, “We just want you to vote, so that whomever gets elected will see that this neighborhood cares enough to show up.” This simple practice helped us to increase voter turnout by 24–39% in six of the precincts where we worked. Many of the people we met knocking on doors were first-time voters.</p><h4>This is the bottom line of civic engagement: while we may have strong and divergent opinions about the best solutions to particular problems, our commitment to the democratic process must transcend disagreement and the parties on either side.</h4><p>I believe that as our faith compels us to model non-partisanship, open-mindedness, calm discourse, and inclusive disagreement, we can heal the body politic and strengthen the office of the citizen. I believe that our faith institutions and the regular practice of prayer, study, community, and acts of kindness hold us accountable as citizens, and they demand a different kind of activism. And I believe that our interfaith partnerships can become a foundation for redeeming politics from the meaningless warfare that it has become to instead be a source of peace and public decision-making we need.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bded14b36ffe" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/office-of-citizen/how-faith-makes-us-purple-bded14b36ffe">How Faith Makes Us Purple</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/office-of-citizen">Office of Citizen</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>