<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Miguel Rivera on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Miguel Rivera on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:28:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@miguelrr/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Posthuman, Heartless Formalism of Greta Gerwig’s Barbie]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/the-posthuman-heartless-formalism-of-greta-gerwigs-barbie-dc995d297777?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dc995d297777</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lacan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[barbie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Aug 2023 13:53:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-01T13:53:39.059Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*Tpc2FE1CNvQKgLRq.jpeg" /></figure><p>The essay below is excerpted from the 285th edition of my weekly <a href="https://miguelrivera.substack.com/"><em>Paradox Newsletter</em></a>, published on Substack.</p><p>If you like what you read, please consider subscribing.</p><h3>The Posthuman, Heartless Formalism of Greta Gerwig’s Barbie</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Syly63ozoAJXq8wT.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Barbie: Dead at Birth</h4><p>Émile Chartier writes, “The art of the screen has been dead since its birth owing to [the] absence of man.” But if that really were true — that “man” is absent from “the art of the screen,” there would be no such film as <em>Barbie</em> (2023) that takes as part of its mission to correct the overrepresentation of <em>men</em> on the silver screen. Of course, I am deliberately misreading Chartier, as he refers not to the masculine gender but to humanity itself, advancing the thesis that the human factor is always alien to the dead art of cinema. In that sense, Greta Gerwig’s film is testimony to the truthfulness of Chartier’s statement.</p><p>It is a work of extreme, regimented formalism, an absolute aesthetic opposite to the pretension of naturalism of Gerwig’s so-called “mumblecore” filmmaking — itself regimented in its formality to produce the effect of unfiltered access to a filmmaker’s interiority or supposedly genuine affect. But to understand Gerwig’s trajectory, as well as the differences and similarities between films like <em>Lady Bird</em> (2017) and <em>Barbie</em>, one must take a detour to this fundamental assertion of Chartier’s.</p><p>Adjusting Chartier’s intended meaning yet again, film is inert relative to the aliveness of the human audience, a complimentary corollary to Roland Barthes’ claim in “The Death of the Author” (1977):</p><blockquote><em>we know that to restore to writing its future, we must reverse its myth: the birth of the reader must be ransomed by the death of the Author</em></blockquote><p>The liveliness that escapes film, “man’s” absence from it, means that film and the novel relate the audience to meaning in the same way. A film’s essence cannot be derived from directorial intent. In fact, while the director’s touch may be visible, their only presence in the film is an absence. Film never presents the director’s thoughts or feelings without mediation. There is always the elaborate form of the film that is a product of the director’s intellect, unconscious, and aesthetic sense (as well as those of the other contributors), but is never equal to those things. The “honest” or “heartfelt” filmmaking of so-called “mumblecore,” then, must be read in this light. The work of <em>Mistress America</em> (2015), <em>Lady Bird</em>, and other independent films from the late 2000s into the late 2010s use the techniques of supposedly unfiltered naturalism to purposefully elide their formalism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*okkyqzKk3P2iPU4l.png" /></figure><p>To the extent that <em>Lady Bird</em> and other such films have been called “heartfelt,” one should recognize both the inaccuracy and disparagement implicit in such a designation. <em>The Godfather</em> (1972), <em>Vertigo</em> (1958), and <em>Citizen Kane</em> (1941) are unlikely to ever be described in such a way, but their cinematic triumph inspires genuine emotion in the audience. <em>Vertigo</em>, as an example, despite what affect it may stir, is seen less as Hitchcock’s self-aware confession and more as the impossibility to repress effusion of something that seeps into a meticulously designed and executed work. I would argue that <em>Lady Bird</em>, despite its unassuming plot, is also a meticulously designed and executed work, as the films of most great directors are. Every feeling it conveys may not be calculated, but the structure of the film <em>to convey feeling</em> is what Gerwig understands so keenly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/490/0*MyRM-JHKpib9zn_e" /></figure><p><em>Barbie</em> is an answer to the notion of <em>Lady Bird</em> (et al.) as “heartfelt,” and proof positive that Gerwig is one of the great filmmakers aspiring to the heights of Coppola, Hitchcock, and Welles even as she does so in this particular case with some Luhrmann-esque flare. <em>Barbie</em> does not just revel in its explicit and self-aware formality, it throws it in the audiences face at every opportunity. Gerwig’s sets are sound stages with painted skies, her characters are inhuman dolls, and her set pieces are choreographed dance numbers even when there’s no musical number. This is Gerwig showing herself to be as heartless as the greats, never heartfelt, saccharine, or trite — and to show that whatever of those qualities one might read into her previous films is a misreading. To call <em>Barbie</em> a “heartless” film is to confer upon it the highest praise.</p><h4>“I don’t want to play with you anymore”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QI7yTLJs-hLZUkUp.jpeg" /></figure><p>As should be clear, there is no question about my evaluation of <em>Barbie</em>’s quality. It is a good, maybe even great, film full of all the spectacle, contradiction, bizarre incongruences, and accidental brilliance that makes me love movies. It is, however, also a film called <em>Barbie</em> named after a children’s toy still sold in stores today with potentially deleterious social effects. One of my favorite analyses of the Barbie phenomenon comes from Katha Pollitt’s “Why Boys Don’t Play With Dolls” (1995), where she describes both the harm Barbie might do as well as the purchase it has on the American imaginary. She writes:</p><blockquote><em>I’m at a children’s birthday party. “I’m sorry,” one mom silently mouths to the mother of the birthday girl, who has just torn open her present — Tropical Splash Barbie. Now, you can love Barbie or you can hate Barbie, and there are feminists in both camps. But apologize for Barbie? Inflict Barbie, against your own convictions, on the child of a friend you know will be none too pleased?</em></blockquote><p>One can imagine Gerwig as the mother gifting Barbie to the collective U.S. consciousness while mouthing “I’m sorry,” all the while, as so much of her engagement with the notion of Barbie seems like an apology for committing the Mattel trademark to celluloid in the first place. But Pollitt goes on:</p><blockquote><em>Even the most attractive, I’m willing to bet, had suffered over her body’s failure to fit the impossible American ideal. Given all that, it seems crazy to transmit Barbie to the next generation. Yet to reject her is to say what Barbie represents — being sexy, thin, stylish — is unimportant, which is obviously not true, and children know it’s not true.</em></blockquote><p>The extent to which Gerwig engages with the important ideas Pollitt brings up is insufficient. <em>Barbie</em> as a film doesn’t take them seriously and doesn’t seem to have any interest in resolving them. The movie’s shortcoming as a commodity and work of self-awarely political art is exemplified in the marketing, a trailer boldly declaring “If you love Barbie, This movie is for you. If you hate Barbie, This movie is for you.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Ck2XLEc0_4kSwLmv.jpeg" /></figure><p>In reality, who this movie is <em>for</em> is a tremendous number of people who <em>don’t care</em> about Barbie, and the vast majority of its viewers will be people for whom Barbie entered their consciousness in an acute way as a consequence of Gerwig’s film.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/498/0*HIwfdXprkteygNbL.gif" /></figure><p>The work <em>Barbie</em> does to “surface” Barbie for the masses, outside of the context of the Christmas and birthday lists of young children, isn’t matched by its critical or deconstructive work of the Barbie phenomenon itself. The film could have been called <em>Farbie</em> and been about any random legally distinct fashion doll and likely been as effective for all the consideration it gives to the specificity of Barbie as a signifier. To that extent, it reproduces some of the harms of the Barbie doll as unrealistic beauty ideal. Gerwig casts actors of varying body types, but only momentarily acknowledges the history of the beauty standards Barbie promotes. This issue is compounded by every literal Barbie doll toy shown in the film being the same mold as well as the performers themselves who are all attractive movie stars — though there’s not too much you can do about that, it’s Hollywood after all. To make matters worse, Gerwig decides to recognize the legitimate critiques of Barbie, only momentarily, through Sasha (Ariana Greenblatt), the daughter of Mattel employee Gloria (America Ferrera), who is cast as the jaded, too-cool-for-school, yet simultaneously immature and naive child, suggesting such criticism come from an unsophisticated, infantile position to the end of asserting one’s “coolness” rather than legitimately opposing a manifestation of all the ways the United States harms women.</p><p>Sasha abandons her criticism of Barbie and chooses to embrace her potential, following the wisdom of the mother who can recognize the complexity and contradiction in all things — though why that recognition should demolish the critiques is a question that can only be answered by understanding this is a product tie-in film. <em>Barbie</em> promotes a recuperative, “perfect is the enemy of the good” ideology that dismisses serious criticism or analysis of Barbie as “perfectionism.” Sasha even says it, trying to motivate her disillusioned mother at a moment of uncertainty in the film, “just because you can’t make things perfect doesn’t mean you can’t make them better.”</p><p>None of these things make <em>Barbie</em> a bad movie, though, nor are they reason in my view for censure of or attacks on Gerwig. Most major motion pictures aren’t exactly “good” for society, nor is it their prerogative to be. <em>Barbie</em> invites this kind of analysis more than most because of the fraught signifier at its center. But <em>Barbie</em> is no more “harmful” than a <em>Top Gun</em>, <em>Avengers</em>, <em>Mission: Impossible</em>, or <em>Fast and Furious</em>. I am personally disappointed this is not a film that truly interrogates Barbie as such, but the movie offers a great deal more than what I bargained for. It seems to me that Greta Gerwig doesn’t really care about Barbie and the movie itself isn’t interested in the politics or sociology of the Barbie doll. The way Gerwig treats Barbie is based on her own perception of the toy, not the broader social function of Barbie as symbol. This is the deliberate choice of a good filmmaker, intent on exploring certain ideas with Barbie a self-made sandbox. By rejecting much of the baggage, Gerwig makes a better film, though I could have done without the dismissive posture taken toward Sasha.</p><h4>“Maybe all the things that you thought made you you aren’t really you”</h4><p>Instead of a close attention to Barbie as social phenomenon and specific historical signifier, <em>Barbie</em> is about all the things that Greta Gerwig has always liked making movies about: being a woman in contemporary culture, awakening to one’s singularity, and the even bigger existential questions that come as a product of these kinds of inquiry. Where the use of the Barbie idea within the context of the film is most successful is in its treatment of gender, a thread that begins with Barbie (Margot Robbie) announcing to a group of cat calling construction workers that she does not have a vagina and Ken (Ryan Gosling) does not have a penis and ends with Barbie, as Barbara, visiting a gynecologist for the first time. <em>Barbie</em> is concerned with how much the genitals are a defining feature of gendered subject positions and of human subjectivity itself. At the most theoretical level, Gerwig shows how the dolls Barbie and Ken are categories that are separate and distinct from the gendered subject position of woman and man. Barbie <em>isn’t</em> a woman and Ken <em>isn’t</em> a man, “Barbie is everything” and “Ken is just Ken.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/0*2w1DqIkRPas0P_6I.jpeg" /></figure><p>Beyond their absentedness from the category of gender, Barbie and Ken are also <em>dolls</em>, not humans. They are toys, and their missing humanness is also a tremendous issue for the film. Gerwig’s formulae for what Barbie and Ken are (by the film’s end, Ken is “Kenough,”) evocative of the Lacanian graph of sexuation. While “Barbie is everything” and “woman does not exist,” may seem contradictory at first glance, <em>Barbie</em> shows how the two statements are equivalent. <em>If </em>Barbie is taken as woman by society, she literally does not exist — precisely the thinking Gerwig hopes to correct. Likewise, despite the exterior projection of liberal feminist notions of gender difference, <em>Barbie</em> is a film that ultimately subverts the coherent organization of gender into discrete categories.</p><p>If <em>Barbie</em> is the next great Lacanian feature film, it’s not for nothing then that Barbieland is missing a crucial feature of normal life — mirrors. This is another instance of Gerwig diverging from the <em>fact</em> of Barbie, as Mattel uses reflective paint or adhesives for semi-functional mirrors in their dollhouses. In the film, every mirror is an empty shape with nothing within the outline. Though the mirror stage that constitutes the emergence of the human subject doesn’t <em>require</em> mirrors, Gerwig’s choice to omit them sends a clear message — the Barbies and Kens and Allan (just one) of Barbieland aren’t subjects.</p><p>Women and girls, however, are subjects, in the same way that any gendered subject has an indelible quality that grants them their subjectivity — they are “Kenough.” But <em>what</em> makes a woman a woman and a girl a girl is an open question for this film posited at its opening. During the <em>2001: A Space Odyssey </em>pastiche, the narrator (Helen Mirren) says “since the first little girl ever existed, there have been dolls.” Though the initial reading of the line might suggest that, while “little girls” and “dolls” emerge contemporaneously, “little girls” have some causal force to create “dolls.” I believe, however, that the more productive reading is the opposite. The doll makes the girl. It is the existence of dolls that create the category of “little girl,” serving to define them on the socializing ideological assembly line to motherhood — or, later, aspirant to the ideals of Barbie.</p><p>The idea that some meaningless exterior factor — like a doll — serves to define a human subject in a concrete social way is one half of the film’s most interesting point. The other element of this vision of the subject is that the defining exterior factor, despite its determinative effects, falls short of the ontological level to actually define someone’s being. The “little girl” emerges because of the doll and can’t escape the designation — or at least has serious impediments to such a flight — but at the level of being or essence, the little girl isn’t a little girl at all. This idea is dramatized again and again, particularly with Ryan Gosling’s Ken who is “Beach Ken.” One of the film’s greatest running gags is that Gosling’s <em>job</em>, like doctor, lifeguard, or president, is <em>beach</em>. It’s yet another meaningless external factor that <em>defines</em> Ken. But what Barbie is able to suggest at the film’s conclusion is that Ken <em>isn’t</em> Beach Ken, he’s just Ken — “Kenough.” Though the resulting portmanteau of “Ken” and “enough” is obviously intended to be comedic, it also traffics one of <em>Barbie</em>’s most important philosophical points. Subjectivity means having something as the guarantor of humanity that defies definition or identification, and can only be expressed as the pure yet obscure <em>something</em> that renders “I am human because I am human” sense rather than tautology.</p><h4>“I’m here to see my gynecologist”</h4><p>All of this sounds shockingly anti-identitarian for a movie that positions Barbies and Kens as characters that behave in ways that are decisively feminine and masculine. These stereotypical behaviors facilitate a major plot point, with the Barbies able to subvert the Kens’ ambition of a Kendom by deception that indulges their “manly” whims. But that simple representation becomes far more interesting considering both that the Kens are not men nor are the Barbies women, as the film repeatedly insists upon. Thus, their behavior is not men acting in accordance with their nature nor women with theirs, but instead a pantomime of learned behaviors. The Barbies learn how to act from <em>actual human women</em>, Sasha and Gloria. The Kens become socialized under a set of bizarre patriarchal ideas transmitted by Gosling’s Ken centered around a Matchbox 20 song and horses. The horses, Ken says, are “men extenders” — a formulation well suited to a Lacanian reading of the phallus that breaks the desirous dyad between parent and offspring.</p><p>The treatment of the phallus, as a signifier and a genital organ, is insistent in this film from its opening. Looking at the <em>2001</em> pastiche again, Barbie comes to replace the monolith which in Kubrick’s film has obvious phallic signification. It is an object that nothing can be known about but serves as a designator of power and object of desire despite the inability to understand what it is. With <em>Barbie</em>’s substitution, there is a confluence of a master signifier — Barbie — and the inscrutable phallic monolith. Even as Barbie’s social and political consequences can be understood and explicated — though, that would be done by a work that isn’t the <em>Barbie</em> film — Barbie as a phallic (in the Lacanian sense) signifier means there is excess and incoherence at its core.</p><p>Barbie and Ken’s relationship to the phallus is even more complex because they are both <em>not without having it</em>. Rather than difference, Barbie and Ken have <em>the same thing</em> where one would expect to find genitals, a “nude blob” as Weird Barbie (Kate McKinnon) calls it. When Barbie and Ken enter the real world, a group of catcalling construction workers harass the duo to which Barbie responds “I don’t have a vagina. And he doesn’t have a penis.” The scene is remarkable. The unusualness of the claim doesn’t seem to dissuade the misogynistic hail of the construction workers. And Ken, who propositions Barbie for an overnight stay but <em>doesn’t know</em> that his request implies sex, or even what sex is, knows enough to claim <em>he does have genitals</em>, “all the genitals,” he claims.</p><p>This moment reveals plenty. It affirms the relatively common insight that sexual harassment isn’t about sex, or even lust, as the construction workers’ continue even when faced with an absolute impasse at fulfilling their threats. It also suggests that the phallus, as Lacan suggests, has nothing to do with genitals. One may as well have a plastic “nude blob,” one’s navigation of desire will always be subject to the phallus at the level of signifier and fantasy.</p><p>Though Weird Barbie never draws up the graph of sexuation, what a gag that would have been, Lacan’s work has seeped deep into this film. In the climactic moment where Gloria gives a scathing, infographic-echoing account of the various ways misogyny has made women’s lives hard, she prefaces it by saying “it is literally impossible to be a woman.” What she goes on to describe is all the ways meeting the contradictory ideals of womanhood is extremely challenging. They, in fact, seem designed to be impossible to meet all at once and deeply destructive even as one aspires to them. But, reading her <em>literally</em>, this impossibility is precisely what is at stake in Lacan’s statement “woman does not exist.” The most charitable, concrete reading one could offer of Lacan’s abstract account is that the feminine ideal does not exist as a coherent unity, precisely as Gloria says. The contradictions are too great. Manhood, on the other hand, is coherent in the violence, exploitation, and cruelty it motivates.</p><p>As the film comes to an end, it drives home that Barbie and Ken <em>are not humans</em> in both the literal and philosophical sense. At least, not yet. But Barbie wants to become a woman in the sense of Pinocchio’s “real boy” — though Gerwig at least has the sense to avoid the transphobic signification of the formulation of “real woman.” Unlike Pinocchio, who must complete a set of trials to prove his humanity, Barbie simply can choose it. She asks, “so being human is not something I need to ask for? Or even want? I can just… it’s something I discover I am?” This question doesn’t call for an answer, it is a declaration of the film’s thesis in itself. What <em>can</em> make Barbie human is that inexplicable, inarticulable something that also makes Ken “Kenough” and emerges through the process of discovery that is existential questioning. One makes their life worth living, becomes human, Gerwig posits, through examination of that life. And not always self-examination, but examination of bare life, as Barbie does sitting at a bus stop and looking at excerpts from other, unmade Gerwig fims.</p><p>If Barbie is a woman because she says so, what is the attachment this film has to genitals? With all the self-realization and self-making, Barbie’s final act is to visit a gynecologist with the implication that her “nude blob” has transformed into a vagina, conferring on her finally the status of cisgender woman instead of children’s toy. This transformation dramatizes another trajectory hidden within the film. If Gosling’s Ken is Beach Ken and McKinnon’s is Weird Barbie, who is Robbie’s Barbie? Stereotypical Barbie, “the Barbie you think of when you think of Barbie.” In the film’s final act, Gloria also pitches an “Ordinary Barbie,” one that is unremarkable and suffers the vicissitudes of woman’s existence under patriarchy. But what, exactly, is the difference between “Stereotypical” and “Ordinary.” Both are judgments relative to a standard of normality, suggesting that one is adhering to it. “Stereotypical” might be a description at the level of fantasy and “Ordinary” at the level of sociological reality, but they bleed into one another easily. Ordinary life quickly becomes stereotypical, and what’s stereotypical is easily mistaken for ordinary. That mistake — confusing stereotypical for ordinary — is precisely the mistake of Barbie’s circulation as a signifier. Gerwig would likely prefer not to promote unhealthy beauty standards or beauty standards of any kind. For all the depth of <em>Barbie</em>’s treatment of gender and individuality, the movie seems to miss exactly how much ordinary life’s constraints are a result of the stereotypes that perhaps Barbie didn’t cause, but is nonetheless a testament to.</p><p>The philosophical sophistication of this film is exceptional. And it certainly gives its viewers much to think and talk about, as all great films do. There is, however, the inextricable, inexcisable mark of corporate capitalism and product placement. Most of the film’s failings can be in some way attributed to the restrictions, implicit or explicit, of making a work called <em>Barbie</em> that also carries its trademark.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://miguelrivera.substack.com/p/issue-285-3600-words-on-greta-gerwigs"><em>https://miguelrivera.substack.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dc995d297777" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“You know what is paying for these three days in Marrakech?”:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/you-know-what-is-paying-for-these-three-days-in-marrakech-bcd7892c4eee?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bcd7892c4eee</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[alfred-hitchcock]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yorgos-lanthimos]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-man-who-knew-too-much]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sophies-choice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Jan 2018 06:49:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-03T06:55:11.717Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“You know what is paying for these three days in Marrakech?”: Lanthimos’s The Killing of a Sacred Deer, Hitchcock’s The Man Who Knew Too Much, and The Commodified Human Body.</h3><p>Reviewing nearly any movie is, in actuality, the task of reviewing a film already made by Alfred Hitchcock. Following that logic, one of the questions Yorgos Lanthimos posits in <em>The Killing of a Sacred Deer </em>(2017)<em> </em>is the question of the value of one life relative to another. Who gets to choose who lives or dies? And on what basis? Or are we always-already engaged in such a valuation, such a judgment of the value of one’s life? <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/culture/richard-brody/the-square-killing-of-a-sacred-deer-and-the-unfortunate-influence-of-michael-haneke">Some people</a> might suggest the prime parallel for such themes would be <em>Sophie’s Choice</em> (1982). Those people would be ignoring Hitchcock’s <em>The Man Who Knew Too Much </em>(1956).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1pi8MuXjJ2lam-qEH0XSZg.jpeg" /></figure><p>As James Stewart’s Ben McKenna and Doris Day’s Jo Conway stroll through the outdoor market in Marrakech, Hitchcock posits the resolution to the philosophical question he’ll spend the rest of the film engaging with. Jo says to Ben, “You know what I was just thinking? You know what is paying for these three days in Marrakech? … Mrs. Campbell’s gallstones.” The two laugh, sharing what seems to be the only genuine moment of marital happiness in the entire film. The relationship, predicated on the subordination of Jo’s “Conway” surname, is sutured only by the child that will in turn become the psychoanalytic lost object of the film. Before Hank’s disappearance, though, Jo and Ben can laugh about Jo’s Parisian purse being paid for by Bill Edward’s tonsils.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/716/1*X0aIZOF2cLpWkHGaxDEMBg.jpeg" /></figure><p>This scene barely needs to be analyzed, but I’ll offer a perfunctory account: here, humans are instrumentalized and evaluated, valued and exchanged, the capital machinations of the medical practice and its existential implications laid bare. This puts the lie to <em>Dr.</em> McKenna’s difficulty when it comes to making a choice between the life of his son and the Prime Minister. Ben is paralyzed by the task of weighing one life over another and making a decision about who lives and who dies. But of course, he already must make choices like these! Mrs. Campbell’s gallstones covered the cost of the McKenna family vacation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hipOYuGHpzYjGOHUqNiFiQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Colin Farrell’s Steven Murphy, then, has the same problem. Lanthimos seems keenly aware that depicting a man like Murphy, an accomplished and wealthy surgeon, as the hapless and helpless arbiter of moral justice, makes just the right kind of symbolic sense. As the young Martin, played by Barry Keoghan, insists: “it’s a metaphor… a symbol,” taking a chunk out of Steven’s arm and then his own with a fierce bite. That fierce bite is one the audience feels all too well, as Lanthimos becomes Murphy’s double with his poking and prodding of his themes and his surgical shooting of each scene.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qxV4OlhspWLns3P5elEggQ.png" /></figure><p>The film’s climax, diegetically, is precisely the opposite of surgical. With Murphy’s family bound and gagged, he covers his eyes with a winter hat and spins around, firing at random. Eventually, it is his ‘effeminate’ (in the logic of the film) son that is killed. Just like Hank McKenna, Bob Murphy is a son born under the sign of the mother. Bob wants to be an ophthalmologist like his mother rather than a cardiologist like his father. While Ben insists Hank must become a doctor rather than a singer or performer, Bob’s last plea for life is a commitment to his father to cut his lengthy, luscious hair, do his chores, and become a cardiologist just like dad. But a last grasp at phallic authority and power becomes a last gasp as Bob pays the price for his father’s own impotence¹.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K2Vv1FbonObXvggQ-JlsCA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Critics of Lanthimos would accuse him, and Michael Haneke, his most pronounced influence, of “a constipated realism that rubs others in their filth while keeping their own hands rigorously pristine.” True, Steven is able to shed the bloody gloves of a botched surgery and throw them away. But to write off Lanthimos (and Haneke) in such a way is to ignore, in addition to crucial parts of their filmmaking practice, their relation to Hitchcock. Lanthimos does not just diagnose social ills, he levels a scathing critique of the way value is assigned to human lives. The way those lives are put into relation is enough to turn anyone into a Martin.</p><p>[1] Nicole Kidman’s Anna Murphy stokes the flames of Steven’s ego: “The most logical thing to do is kill a child. We can have another. Well, I know I can. And if you can’t, we can always try IVF. But I’m sure you can.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bcd7892c4eee" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Games of 2017]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/the-games-of-2017-4608506fac2b?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4608506fac2b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[year-in-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[xenoblade-chronicles-2]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persona-5]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nier-automata]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Dec 2017 00:22:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-29T00:22:52.238Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am always frustrated by the fact that there is not a larger academic apparatus for the study of video games. I don’t mean any new-fangled interactivity studies or any of the sort of work that has been done pushing the envelope of interactive art. That type of work may be extremely valuable, but it is not of interest to me. No, I mean textual analysis of 90s JRPGs. I’m still waiting for a monograph on <em>Shin Megami Tensei</em>. The world of these games is so rich and the reward, it seems to me, for the scenario writers and graphic artists who pad these games with endless allusions is so pitiful. Their effort deserves recognition and their work deserves study.</p><p>But why this sentiment is so important to 2017 is twofold. First, this year began my attempt to correct this oversight in earnest. However, the fruits of those labors won’t appear for a little while now. The second reason, developers gave enthusiasts more material than ever to contemplate. The backlog of games that deserve serious academic papers and monographs have increased. These games, inevitably, become my favorites. Below are the games I enjoyed the most this year. <strong>Be advised, spoilers for the various titles follow, although I have attempted to keep them to a minimum.</strong></p><h3>Nier: Automata</h3><p>Yoko Taro responded to my inane tweets about my desire to write extensively about <em>Nier: Automata</em> with care and attention. That is to say, with a fav and a follow back. Taro is unquestionably an auteur, and much can be said about both his PR persona and his texts: <em>Nier: Automata</em> is crowning achievement. <em>Automata</em> is a triumph of storytelling, artistry, and gameplay, Platinum Games’s intervention on this point being no small contribution to why <em>Automata</em> excels in all the ways Taro’s games usually fail. But failure is par for the course in a Taro title, and each of his games meditate on the idea of failure among the cavalcade of concepts marched in front of the player.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dhJxIyeUEXlDONheaVOPpg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A game with character names such as Hegel, Engels, and Pascal might seem pretentious, but Taro pairs his heady philosophical allusions with an otaku flourish. One need not remark on <em>Automata</em>’s character design — there are better and more intelligence people who might remark on its successes and failures. What <em>Automata</em> offers at its core, beyond a superlative gameplay experience, is a worthy intervention into conversations about war, humanity, prejudice, and artificial intelligence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VoqLS4JzoJH383BFSuACkQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AZg2zHakj0juzNW7YuWlsg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GjsBkZZEGcCLMtgI_DdAdQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Automata</em> is a game that is, like almost everything, in dialogue with psychoanalysis. Taro dramatizes primal repression and repetition compulsion. <em>Automata</em>’s closest artistic cousin is Christopher Nolan’s <em>Memento</em> (2000). Leonard’s endlessly repetitive burning of the photograph which might evince he has avenged his (perhaps not even dead) wife his the clear parallel to 2A’s endlessly repeated murder of 9S. The structure of the android society itself is metonymized by 2A’s murder of 9S. The truth about the circumstance of the androids, and the pointlessness of their conflict with the machine lifeforms posited as their antagonists, must be concealed. It is just as Leonard says in the closing moments of <em>Memento</em>, “we all lie to ourselves to be happy.” The nature of that lie is exposed in both <em>Automata</em> and <em>Memento</em>. This insistent question and the answer <em>Automata</em> provides makes the game a triumph.</p><h3>Persona 5</h3><p>I’ve already gotten started on my processing of <em>Persona 5</em>. I wrote about it <a href="https://medium.com/@miguelrr/the-other-you-who-exists-within-desires-it-thus-the-question-of-imprisonment-and-the-7d1baac86428">here</a>. That brief engagement with some of <em>Persona 5</em>’s themes does not take us far beyond the first dungeon. I am ashamed to say, despite being at the precipice of the game’s conclusion, I did not and will not complete it before the year is at an end. However, its substance has already make itself unmistakably clear. <em>Persona 5</em> is an angry game and engages with the populist dissatisfaction with the status quo that has made itself the most important facet of American political life. The game has more in common with contemporary American politics than one might immediately except. The conclusions the game seems to come to may be unsettling for many players. After all, it is a dissatisfaction with an anodyne liberalism and a hostility to the field of politics as such that has resulted in our current political situation. <em>Persona 5</em> dramatizes that tension but also is dissatisfied with its own status quo. From the perspective of mechanics, <em>Persona 5</em> changes so much about the familiar rhythm of <em>Persona 3</em> and <em>4</em>. While the carefully crafted dungeons of <em>Persona 5 </em>offer a greater opportunity for exploring the game’s themes, I found the puzzles frustrating and pointless impediments to my progress.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tr2BYcoNk_93Zp-HmjCo6Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Still, many of the psychological questions of the<em> Persona </em>series more broadly are strikingly articulated here. The role of desire in politics and sociality is a rich question to explore. But like any good piece of mass-market storytelling in the postmodern era, <em>Persona 5</em> seems to repudiate the truths it tells in the middle. Desire is transgressive and destructive to the possibility of political and social organization. But the later <em>Persona</em> games are founded on the very idea of the social link. How can the destructive insistence of desire be squared away with the nurturing sociality <em>Persona 5</em> tries to represent? I guess I’ll have to finish the game to find out.</p><h3>.hack//G.U. Last Recode</h3><p>I guess it is a bit unfair to call this game one that belongs on a “best of 2017” list. But its resonances with some of the greatest art ever created making it too striking to omit. As Atoli begs Haseo to see her <em>as her</em>, and not the avatar of the woman who serves as the locus of Haseo’s libidinal investment, my heart broke in the same way as watching the parallel scene in Alfred Hitchcock’s <em>Vertigo </em>(1958). The theme of the construction of our social identities runs throughout the <em>.hack series</em>. After all, in an MMORPG such a thing is materially true, rather than just allegorically or symbolically. Each player inhabits a created avatar within the constraints of the game’s code. Thus, Atoli appearing identical to Haseo’s lost love, Shino, isn’t the result of the same sort of sinister plot that gave Kim Novak one of her best roles: Judy Barton and Madeleine Elster. But Atoli is to Judy as Shino is to Madeleine, and the drama that unfolds in this tripartite structure (with Haseo and Scottie Ferguson at the middle, respectively) is identical. As Atoli begs for Haseo’s unmediated love, we know such a thing is impossible. Love is always mediated by fantasy. Being mistaken for someone else is as good as any other. <em>G.U.</em> knowingly concedes this point, but gives us a spark of hope for Atoli shattering the constraints of her constructed avatar that has ultimately cursed her with tainted love. Atoli has a power that exceeds the game’s code, the power to hear the sound of the villainous corruption that infringes on the proper function of <em>The World</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dtqf7uJXe4Q3R2QR_MB2Jw.jpeg" /></figure><p>But the love triangle between Haseo, Atoli, and the absent Shino is the least of the interventions <em>.hack//G.U.</em> offers. This game, too, remains unfinished, although I beat the first three titles upon their original release. I am waiting to break into that newly-minted fourth game, entitled <em>Reconnection</em>. But <em>Vertigo</em> as an intertext to <em>G.U.</em> is reason enough for sustained engagement.</p><h3>Xenoblade Chronicles 2</h3><p>This game has caused a baffling amount of controversy upon its release. Although the strange appropriation of free-to-play mechanics is frustrating, the game is superlative. The slot-machine aspect of the title is a minor annoyance rather than a reason to abandon the game wholesale. Coming to the game off of <em>G.U.</em> (and my weekly rewatch of <em>Vertigo</em>), I mistakenly attributed this same concern about the construction of identity and particularly the construction of the gender “woman” to <em>Xenoblade</em>. The twinned leads of Pyra and Mythra seem to lend themselves to such a reading. But as the game progresses, their narrative function changes. They are two parts of the same whole and the issue of one being seen as simply a poor substitute for the other is never explored. Instead, <em>Xenoblade</em>’s chief concern is memory and self-identity. Thus, we find ourselves back squarely in the realm of <em>Nier: Automata</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vlYiGL48bLA5F_tM8wIqCg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The similarities between the questions of the two games are striking, and just as striking is the different ways the two games approach the questions. The subordinated class of Blades (sometimes indistinguishable from humans, save for a glowing crystal somewhere on their body) live an eternal life but are constantly forced to forget. Their memory is only as long as their human companion, called a Driver. Some Blades maintain journals and archives dedicated to the preservation of the lost memories, but most are reborn endlessly with no inkling of what their last life was like. A group of Blades, frustrated by this status quo, make up the rogues gallery. However, by the game’s conclusion, what is ultimately demystified is the nature of the world itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6cNI-GMN-gUZW3oTDWb0Vw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Zy2NObaUGqhQi0e-actVg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Mw6kQvxaF_dEiyQC3tYK2Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cePSzy0aWnh4ERnrTJsJww.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iVtOVQLbiXdPElBFFyi3PA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Xenoblade</em> contends with the perennial question of “who has the right to create life?” and its accompanying gendered anxiety. Such a question extends to one of the more merited controversies accompanying the game’s release — the crassness of the character design. In an early scene, the characters have a dust-up about an artificial Blade (<em>Xenoblade Chronicles 2 </em>certainly has the most confused symbolic universe of all the games I have played this year… what is the nature of the artificial Blade when ‘normal’ Blades must assert their humanity?) and her apparently sexual function. Later, Blades Pyra and Brighid offer harsh words to Driver Tora, the creator of the artificial Blade, Poppi. They take issue with the sexually titillating outfits Tora created for Poppi. Their critique rests on the fact that Poppi should be able to choose her own outfits, and she certainly shouldn’t be dressed in such an indecent fashion by the whim of her creator. Of course, Pyra and Brighid are both scantly clad… as dictated by their character designer. This contradiction is part of what makes <em>Xenoblade Chronicles 2</em> so rich. It bumbles its way into self-critique!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L_eoxIdL7Ph7Foo8yUrC3Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ki7Wr4bNXdwcIngGbW0bww.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UisqiAg5g44o7TFkDMfFDA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This isolated scene, though, connects to <em>Xenoblade</em>’s broader themes about the creation of life. And beyond analyzing the themes, the plot itself is quite fascinating. <em>Xenoblade Chronicles 2</em> connects to its two predecessors in the <em>Xenoblade </em>series, as well as the Namco owned <em>Xenosaga</em> series and the Squaresoft published <em>Xenogears</em>. These wide-ranging material and thematic connections make the game exceedingly rewarding, especially for long-time fans.</p><p>Rich, allusive storytelling had a victory in 2017. New entries into the <em>Nier</em>, <em>Persona</em>, <em>.hack</em>, and <em>Xenoblade</em> series proved that. The relative financial success of each game promises more to come. Someday, I hope every entry into these series will be easily accessible. After all, criticism of <em>Automata</em> is all the more rich with an accompanying close look at <em>Nier </em>(2010). And I would love engage more comprehensively with the connections between <em>Xenoblade</em> and <em>Xenosaga</em>. Maybe next year I’ll have something to write about a <em>Xenosaga</em> HD Collection. Or perhaps I will just have replayed the PS2 games!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4608506fac2b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Don’t Send in The Clowns — A Review of American Horror Story: Cult Episode 1]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/dont-send-in-the-clowns-a-review-of-american-horror-story-cult-episode-1-bc4c0ed65910?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bc4c0ed65910</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[american-horror-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-reviews]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Sep 2017 03:44:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-07T03:15:29.483Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Is <em>American Horror Story: Cult</em> the television equivalent of Marvel’s <em>Secret Wars</em> event? Fan favorites like Evan Peters are turned into unrepentant fascists, characters like Twisty make unexpected and inexplicable returns, and as nakedly as <em>Cult </em>demonstrates its aspirations toward political commentary it remains unclear what the show is trying to convey. The complexities of the issues <em>Cult</em> is trying to take on may result in a season that is as in poor taste as <em>Secret Wars</em>, especially considering their shared ideological murkiness. Because the show seems to take aim at both Sarah Paulson’s left-leaning Ally (the name, as <em>AHS</em> always is, is painfully on the nose) and Evan Peters’s Kai, one might accuse Ryan Murphy of false equivalence. And yet, Ally is unquestionably heroic and Kai is unrepentantly villainous. This distinction is important. On a day when DACA is under threat, representing an existential horror far beyond what <em>AHS</em> is artistically equipped to depict, the perspective that “everyone is worried over nothing, ‘both sides’ need to calm down” is unwelcome. At least as of the first episode, I’m not immediately alienated by some poorly thought out centrism.</p><p>While <em>Cult</em> is a high risk (and, perhaps, low reward) proposition, it gets a lot right. I found this episode inspiring fear and dread in excess of other seasons of <em>AHS</em>. It’s not just the political drama, either. Peters is a menace on the screen, chewing scenery, firing off nonsensical diatribes, and committing heinous acts. The sinister nanny is also a powerful fear-generating machine. The powerlessness of Ally and Ivy to intervene on the life of their child and protect him from this intrusion is profoundly unsettling. But beyond that, it’s slick camera work and memorable costuming that do the job. The monstrous clowns that terrorize Ally and her son and commit suburban murders are as striking as the returning Twisty.</p><p>I’m appreciative that the show verified Ally’s encounters with the clowns as “real” as opposed to long-playing the possibility of hallucination. Horror rarely treats mental illness with the nuance it deserves and <em>Cult</em> is no exception. Ally’s condition played up as an isolation based horror is crass, and her treatment by both the narrative and the other characters is unconscionable. The quicker the show decides to pivot away from this hackneyed plot device, the better.</p><p>Overall, I’m intrigued by what is on offer with this season of <em>AHS</em>. I don’t expect any groundbreaking political commentary. For some, that might be enough reason to dismiss the show at best or argue it should have never been made at worst. I’m sympathetic to those arguments. But there’s something about the craft of this first episode that has grabbed me. And I appreciate seeing the naked fascism of Kai on screen, rendered as incoherently and unsympathetically as it deserves. But I shudder to think what other viewers might take away from Murphy’s glib and over-the-top depiction of the entire political spectrum. The fact that Kai might affirm or embolden some white supremacist is a horror of which I don’t need to be reminded.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bc4c0ed65910" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What does science know? Lacan against positivism in his lost seminar, “On the Names-of-the-Father”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/what-does-science-know-lacan-against-positivism-in-his-lost-seminar-on-the-names-of-the-father-c05827d87543?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c05827d87543</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[james-damore]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jacques-lacan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Aug 2017 14:43:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-16T14:43:56.574Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I think about the Google Anti-Diversity memo that is circulating, I can’t help but think of Jacques Lacan’s complicated relationship with science and how his ideas serve to contradict the foundation on which James Damore, the author of the memo, might claim to know anything at all.</p><p>To provide some context, in 1963, on the wrong end of the <em>Société Française de Psychanalyse</em>, one of his most groundbreaking seminars, “On the Names-of-the-Father,” was interrupted by his demotion from the position of <em>didacticien</em>.</p><p>Drawing a stark distinction between psychology as a tool of maintaining the status quo and psychoanalysis as, among other things, a tool to elucidate the subject and resolve symptomatic behavior, Lacan writes:</p><blockquote>In the positivist perspective, intelligence is but one affect among others, based on the hypothesis of intelligibility. This justifies a psychology of Tarot card readers, which is concocted in places that are supposedly freest from this kind of claptrap: endowed university chairs. [To positivists,] affect, conversely, is thus merely an obscure form of intelligence.</blockquote><blockquote>What escapes people who study such teachings is the obscurantism to which they are subjected. We know what it leads to: to the ever more intentional undertakings of a technocracy; to the psychological standardization of subjects who are seeking jobs; and to acceptance of the established boundaries of society as it currently exists, head bent forward under the weighty standard of the psychologist.</blockquote><blockquote>I say that the meaning of Freud’s discovery is radically opposed to that. (“On the…” 60–61)</blockquote><p>At the beginning of the seminar, one can hear Lacan’s frustration as his analysand-like confession of momentary disgrace is conveyed to his students.</p><p>But this quotation goes beyond frustration and beyond the discipline of psychology and the practice of psychoanalysis. Lacan’s critique of positivism and the technocracy it would precipitate reflect how Lacan sees scientific knowledge and how he might envision psychoanalysis as a science. For Lacan, science is formalized but has little to do with knowledge. Science’s exclusive claim to knowledge is a fantasy.</p><p>We see that in Lacan’s critique here. Lacan disputes the hypothesis of intelligibility, claiming that any psychology that purports to offer insight into an individual’s value by indexing their intelligence is tantamount to, Lacan’s cultural insensitivity aside, baseless speculation. Lacan calls psychology’s practice of making an inventory of an individual’s traits, strengths, and weaknesses, obscurantism. For all the ways psychology claims to give a clear picture about a given person, it obscures what is most important about the subject for Lacan: that they know nothing.</p><p>Furthermore, as stated above, Lacan believes psychoanalysis is a practice that can scrutinize systems of knowledge rather than anything that can claim to be knowledge itself. This coincides with Lacan’s constant refrain that psychoanalysis is not an ontology. For Lacan, psychology’s function as a tool of hiring, firing, and social control is antithetical to psychoanalysis’s insurgent potential.</p><p>Bruce Fink explicates an aspect of Lacan’s relationship to science quite well in his 2002 essay, “Knowledge and Jouissance.” Fink writes:</p><blockquote>Modern science, for example, is ostensibly about measurements and the production of “hard facts,” and thus virtually the entire American psychological establishment has enlisted itself in the production of measures and statistics of all kinds.</blockquote><blockquote>But is that the kind of scientificity that psychoanalysis can hope to achieve or even wish to achieve? The <em>APA Monitor</em>, the main organ of the American Psychological Association, occasionally lists which aspects of Freud’s theories have been borne out by empirical research: of course, when we consider what they have reduced Freud’s theories to in order to test them, and then examine the research design they have come up with to test such watered-down theories, we may well wonder whether the supposed confirmations are of any more value than the alleged refutations!</blockquote><blockquote>According to Lacan, this is not at all the kind of scientificity at which psychoanalysis must aim: to his mind, psychoanalysis is not currently a science, and it is not by going in that direction that it will become one. “It is not what is measured in science that is important, contrary to what people think” (Seminar XX, 116/128). (Fink 27)</blockquote><p>Here, we can see again the conflict between psychoanalysis and psychology, ranging from the <em>Société Française de Psychanalyse </em>which made itself accountable to associations of psychology and thus censured Lacan and the <em>APA Monitor</em>.</p><p>Fink goes on to say of Lacan’s view of Antiquity’s view of knowledge (a mouthful, I know), “All knowledge at that time, participated, in Lacan’s words, ‘in the fantasy of an inscription of the sexual link’ (Seminar XX, 76/82) … The relation between knowledge and the world was consubstantial with a fantasy of copulation” (Fink 28). Lacan goes on to criticize the position of his psychoanalytic contemporaries, suggesting that the fantasy of copulation has given way to the always-in-the-distance potential for harmony between “the sexes.” If we seem far afield from the initial point, or perhaps dangerously close to sharing Damore’s position that the gender of man and the gender of woman are inherently different, that would not be Lacan’s position. Lacan’s argument of harmony as a fantasy is not one of inherent difference between individuals assigned whatever gender at birth. Lacan believes that sex has nothing to do with biology, but rather a given psychic structure.</p><p>What is important here is Lacan’s conception of the “unknowing subject” and formalization over knowledge. Damore represents the scientific position of a potential harmony between two genders if these two genders are understood as totally bifurcated and biologically determined. Lacan subverts this position by deploying the unknowing subject and attempting to eliminate the fantasy of harmony, a harmony that is only possible through an acknowledgement of fundamental biological difference, a claim which Lacan consistently refutes in every bit of his work. Fink gives Lacan’s reasoning for extolling Freud’s deployment of Oedipus in his work, “Oedipus was … a perfect model for the unknowing subject, for a subject who acts without knowing why, in any conscious sense of the word ‘knowing.’ From the vantage point of psychoanalysis, ‘There’s no such thing as a knowing subject’ (Seminar XX, 114/126) says Lacan” (Fink 30).</p><p>According to Fink, Lacan contends that one of the most important aspects of Freud’s discovery of the unconscious is that unconscious knowledge is totally inaccessible to the subject. Fink goes on to say, “Lacan is generally suspicious of the whole” (Fink 31). The wholeness of a world inhabited by individuals in “their proper place” is a fantasy that Lacan abhors.</p><p>It is not that Lacan is opposed to science itself, but how science can be said to relate to knowledge and truth. Lacan writes in “Beyond the ‘Reality Principle’” from <em>Ecrits </em>(1966),<em> </em>“I am not playing at being paradoxical by claiming that science need know nothing about truth … But truth in its specific value remains foreign to the order of science” (<em>Ecrits</em> 63). As Lacan attempted to move psychoanalysis toward a system of mathematical formalization, with his convoluted “mathemes,” he embraced a version of science that does not have an exclusive claim to truth or knowledge and, in fact, cannot definitely produce either.</p><p>Doesn’t science itself, without Lacan, put the lie to Damore’s authority? Doesn’t it undercut the value of the cries of his supporters that his sexist memo is “science!” So what? Empirical research on human behavior provides the tentative and possible rather than the definitive and uncontestable. From a colloquial understanding of science, studies contradict themselves infinitely. They are only worth as much as their research methodology. Scientific positivism can only offer contingent knowledge. Results that simply await dispute by the next study.</p><p>Lacan’s longtime editor, Jacques Alain-Miller, would write of “On the Names-of-the-Father”:</p><blockquote>Having concluded from his tribulations that “psychoanalytic discourse” had not authorized him to lift, as he had intended, the veil Freud had cast over the true mainspring of psychoanalysis, and that he had been struck down for his sacrilegious act, he signaled, in a word to the wise, in particular in the ironic title that he gave to a later Seminar, <em>Les non-dupes errent</em>, that he would keep close to his chest truths that were too tempestuous.</blockquote><p>Ultimately, though Lacan’s fate might appear to share some commonalities with Damore despite their fundamental ideological disagreement, there is a critical distinction between the professional failings of the two. Lacan was momentarily discredited for doing complex, difficult work that defied the understanding of the psychoanalytic establishment. Primarily it was his practice of the variable length session that led to his censure. Damore, on the other hand, has uncritically deployed so-called scientific material to fall back on the fantasy of wholeness that numbers and mathematization can provide.</p><p>Above all, what “On the Names-of-the-Father” and Fink’s “Knowledge and Jouissance” demonstrate is the importance of Lacanian psychoanalysis today. Lacan offers unparalleled insights into the nature of knowledge, science, and psychology: brutally critiquing them all. And yet Lacan seeks to redefine psychoanalysis in the terms of a science that would prioritize formalization over knowledge. It is Lacan’s challenge to science that broadly refutes Damore’s claim of authority. Just like the poor empirical research of the <em>APA Monitor </em>in relation to Freud,<em> </em>individual examination of Damore’s citation make his argument similarly spicious. But beyond this broad, epistemological challenge to Damore and others like him, Lacan can also serve to contract Damore’s vision of gender concretely through his ideas of sexuation and disharmony.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c05827d87543" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Whatever you want to do, I will support you forever”: Fatherhood and Festival in DJ Khaled’s…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/whatever-you-want-to-do-i-will-support-you-forever-fatherhood-and-festival-in-dj-khaleds-ec25805820ac?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec25805820ac</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dj-khaled]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[samurai-warriors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grateful]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fatherhood]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Jun 2017 19:55:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-24T20:04:32.804Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“Whatever you want to do, I will support you forever”: Fatherhood and Festival in DJ Khaled’s Grateful</h3><p>When father’s day rolled around, I was just finishing up a video game called <em>Samurai Warriors: The Spirit of Sanada</em> (2017). I planned to write about it in conjunction with my thinking on fatherhood and family, as I found the story of the historical Sanada family quite compelling and delivered deftly by the game. However, I didn’t write the essay. A partial draft exists that may someday emerge or be completed. But for now, that idea serves as scaffolding to my thinking about DJ Khaled and his most recent album, <em>Grateful </em>(2017).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VSnHfBMByn8y2IX6SDZJMQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6wQkHqAtbxj68GT_pvjIyA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wDS5dhjSaEWWVJLwDe6qOA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Samurai Warriors: The Spirit of Sanada (2017)</em></figcaption></figure><p>The story of <em>The Spirit of Sanada</em> was one of legacy and purpose. A dedicated father, Masayuki, violated military and social conventions to build something he could leave to his children, Yukimura and Nobuyuki. Masayuki died in exile with his son Yukimura, with Nobuyuki carrying on the Sanada clan facing suspicion and hostility. Khaled, like Masayuki, is building something with <em>Grateful</em> for his son. To that end, Khaled has been extremely successful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/645/1*cUqu9L-GnlVu-xr9ie55qg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Khaled and Asahd</figcaption></figure><p><em>Grateful</em> is an enormous improvement over its predecessor, <em>Major Key</em> (2016). While both <em>Major Key</em> and <em>Grateful </em>are packed with unexpected features and unique artist pairings, <em>Major Key </em>comes off like a disorganized slog whereas<em> Grateful</em>, despite clocking in at 23 tracks to <em>Major Key</em>’s 14, feels like the celebration you would expect getting all these artists together. There are a lot of questions about what DJ Khaled’s talents actually are and what he brings to these albums brimming with accomplished artists and producers. I think what is clear in <em>Grateful</em> is that Khaled has creative concepts and can bring out unique strengths in the artists he features. For instance, in “Down For Life,” Khaled masterfully directs PARTYNEXTDOOR in the hook to bring an energy to the track that PND isn’t known for. PND is followed by Future and then Travis Scott delivering a smoragsboard of autotuned crooners that demonstrates the legitimacy of the program yet again. A few songs earlier, on “Don’t Quit” (featuring Calvin Harris along with Travis Scott and Jeremih) Khaled has Travis exploring his vocal range to great success. Travis Scott has never sounded less like himself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/790/1*if4VbO-_tBzwDu7WjRqFIg.png" /><figcaption>Travis Scott and Khaled</figcaption></figure><p>Khaled, too, is unafraid to experiment with a number of unfamiliar musical influences. On the Drake assisted “To the Max,” Khaled samples the Vine hit “Gus Get Em Right” by Jay-O, which in turn samples T2’s “Heartbroken.” Khaled’s pastiche of Miami “jook” music is welcome for me as a listener, potential socio-cultural negatives bracketed for the moment. Likewise, the standout “I Love You So Much” featuring Chance the Rapper borrows from New Orleans bounce. These interruptions and insertions into the otherwise conventional pattern of pop-rap make <em>Grateful</em> feel like something truly unique. More than that, these songs pose a challenge to the conventionality of prospective radio singles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*jd7FKoSfZPLbzFM0WUPjkA.gif" /><figcaption>“did the Drake vocals come in yet?”</figcaption></figure><p>The record is a thrill, revealing new sides to itself and familiar artists as it proceeds. But the running strain of fatherhood and the frequently credited Asahd Khaled (DJ Khaled’s infant son who is credited with executive producing the album and whose gurgling can be heard on the album’s last song) grounds the cavalcade of features and music styles. It is on the aforementioned “I Love You So Much” where Khaled’s approach to the album is most clear. Khaled has a larger-than-usual vocal presence on the track along with Chance’s refrains about his family. Khaled speaks affirmations to his infant son, calling him a legend, an icon, and a mogul. Meanwhile, Chance sings the ABCs and sampled vocals direct Asahd to identify his eyes, ears, mouth, and nose.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*DFaGs-W3do5GMxPdMoX_dA.jpeg" /></figure><p>As I listen to this song and look at the various images of Asahd on the album artwork, I struggle with my own cynicism. Am I irritated with Khaled’s deployment of his 8 month old son as the crux of a crass marketing scheme, or deeply stirred by this open display of fatherly affection? Ultimately, I come down feeling the latter. Khaled seems to be speaking something into the world for his son. Building not just an empire of large houses, cars, money, and a music career, but a castle of self-esteem for Asahd, born into a hostile world. Khaled’s disposition toward his son is a more immediately admirable variation of how Lavar Ball speaks about his sons, or how Kanye West asserts his own value. But I find something to love in DJ Khaled and Lavar Ball, even if their love for their sons is inseparable from money making schemes that deploy those same sons as the advertising copy. For DJ Khaled, at least, it seems a fundamental truth about his love for his son is spoken in the words of “I Love You So Much.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*nYhjtZVwqPHPhEm-Dkcnmg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/248/1*1FsG11N78b8cdTPScjFm7w.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/370/1*R52mAHAnrFts528uNds0LA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Khaled says to his son “You’re amazing, you’re handsome, you’re incredible, you’re a genius … there’s nothing you can’t do.” We can only hope to give the people we care about the same warm affirmations.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec25805820ac" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The (Critical) Fate of the Furious]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/the-critical-fate-of-the-furious-ad82eafef9a6?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ad82eafef9a6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[the-fate-of-the-furious]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fast-and-furious]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Apr 2017 15:29:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-14T15:29:20.678Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The Fast and the Furious </em>franchise’s critical day in the sun could only last so long. With <em>Fast Five </em>(2011), <em>Fast &amp; Furious 6 </em>(2013), and <em>Furious 7</em> (2015) defying all odds to be critical successes, with 67, 61, and 67 scores on <em>Metacritic</em> respectively, the axe had to fall eventually. <em>The Fast and the Furious</em> is just too good, too smart, too earnest, and all in the conventional blockbuster package, to maintain a critical appeal. The argument can be made that the movies are formulaic. This is true, although Aristotelian tragedy is also a formula. But film critics begin to get antsy if they think they are being served the same movie over and over again and getting tricked into enjoying it through advertising hype and explosions. They wonder about their own legitimacy as critics and so their intuition is to criticize. They fail to recognize how a formula might be a vessel, and a film series can fill that vessel with something new, something that pushes the limits ever so slightly, every time, even if the result is something familiar and comforting.</p><p>The thing that often goes ignored or unstated is that reviewing films for money is an enterprise subtended by one of two possible fantasies: that there is some kind of objective way to discern the quality of a film that critics tap into through years of training, or that the film critic’s opinion is representative enough, insightful enough, or entertaining enough that it offers some use value to viewers attempting to make a decision about how to spend their time. Critics that predicate their work on the first fantasy are far worse than the second. And it’s critics of that first school that would be the quickest to pan a <em>Fast and Furious</em> film. Still, most critics can’t avoid slipping into the delusion that they have some aesthetic authority, that is how you get criminally underrated films. It’s not for nothing that the best film in the <em>Fast and Furious</em> franchise is 2006’s <em>Tokyo Drift</em>, burdened by an embarrassing 46 score on <em>Metacritic</em>.</p><p>But the subject of my inquiry today is <em>The Fate of the Furious</em> (2017) rather than <em>Tokyo Drift </em>or the series’s critical legacy more broadly. There is no question: <em>The Fate of the Furious</em> is an excellent film. If it is worse than the previous entries from <em>Five</em> onward, it is only slightly. On the level of plotting, it is perfection. There is only one entirely regrettable scene in the film, Dom’s first encounter with Charlize Theron’s villainous Cypher, which is the fault of an irregular failing of an otherwise fantastic script. And while I think the film underutilized Tyrese and Ludacris to a point, it is ingenious work on the part of F. Gary Gray and Chris Morgan to make a film with an ever-expanding cast an intimate one for Vin Diesel’s Dominic Toretto. That intimacy, however, comes at a cost. As Morgan and Gray are intent on moving Dom forward, his isolation means sacrificing some of the interpersonal relationships that have come to serve as the series’s engine (please forgive the obvious car metaphor). This doesn’t make the film less enjoyable, but it does make it feel different. The Rock’s Luke Hobbs and Dom, in particular, share so few moments on screen that it almost feels as if they were barely on set together. Reports of The Rock and Vin Diesel’s confrontations during production may have been overstated, but their characters’s positioning in the film lends credence to such a claim. Hobbs, at the film’s end, seems poised to make his permanent exist from the franchise into his own spin-off series, if the rumors are to be believed.</p><p>This is emblematic of the disconnection that distinguishes the film from its predecessors. Dom is isolated by an unknown truth about himself, both on the level of plot and symbolism. While I won’t reveal the circumstance that makes him subordinate to Cypher (rest assured, it will not disappoint), Cypher also calls into question who Dom is. She addresses the question of Dom’s <em>desire</em>, arguing that Dom is happiest in the “ten seconds between the start and the finish line of a race.” Cypher describes a Dom enraptured, within his <em>jouissance</em>, apart from his family in his experience, living his life a “quarter mile at a time.” Dom, however, refuses to acknowledge her claim. Cypher argues that Dom’s centering of family is less real than his experience of pleasure that comes from driving a flaming jalopy down the streets of Cuba and into the Atlantic ocean or stealing nuclear launch codes from a Russian dignitary. However, Cypher’s argument is off the mark. She says that Dom’s attachment to family is based on a “biological fantasy” dating back to primitive humans based on their procreative urges. And yet, Dom’s family is anything but biological. Dom traverses the fantasy of the biological family to rewrite the rules of kinship. The plot draws out powerful tensions between the biological and adoptive modes of kinship formation, but the film positions Dom in such a way that despite the harshness of his opposition to his former team, he never truly betrays them. After all, where could a sequel go if such a thing happened?</p><p>Dom’s isolation from his family also gives Vin Diesel an opportunity to do a little bit of acting that makes him unfamiliar to viewers. Thinking of Diesel’s performance throughout the film, I can’t help but think of what <a href="http://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/advice-for-robert-downey-jr-avengers-ultron-cultural-genocide">Richard Brody wrote about Robert Downey Jr. in <em>Age of Ultron</em> (2015)</a>:</p><blockquote>Downey is a majestic actor in a paradoxical situation: as Tony Stark, in “Avengers: Age of Ultron,” he has some screen-crushing close-ups that have more intensity, complexity, and individuality than many acclaimed actors’ movie-long performances. He’s a performer in involuntary overdrive — which may well be the natural condition of all the best actors.</blockquote><p>The same, then, could be said of Diesel. His anguish is evident in his remarkable facial expressions throughout the film. The scene where Cypher kisses Dom is a remarkable example, viewable by all in the film’s many sizzling trailers. The work he does during his close-ups is astonishing, and totally alien to the series thus far. Diesel’s familiar oscillation from imposing stoicism to tense warmth is disturbed by what the script calls for him to do, and it’s a rousing success for the actor.</p><p>Though your mileage may vary on the change in focus from “the family” to Dom himself, these thematic points are worth drawing out to establish just how Dom has changed through the franchise. Surprisingly, <em>Fate</em> relies on the past three films in ways that each predecessor has stood alone. In this sense, it brings the disparate plotlines from the fifth, sixth, and seventh films together. The Shaw brothers return with Helen Mirren doing a tremendous job as the Shaw matriarch, and references to the events of the past three films abound. Don Omar and Tego Calderon even make triumphant returns to the franchise, even if it is more of an easter egg than a full fledged role. The way each of those films feeds into <em>Fate</em> is almost <em>too good</em> on the part of Morgan’s writing, as I can’t imagine he had this all planned out from the beginning. This makes <em>Fate</em> all the more rewarding to franchise devotees.</p><p>While the themes of kinship and <em>desire</em> are newly drawn to the fore, the film’s focus on superheroics over street racing follows the mold of the past three films in the same way the plot of <em>Fate</em> serves as a culmination of the work they’ve done. Dom’s family might as well be The Avengers, called upon to do high-risk deniable ops for the US government in a way that feels like campy fun rather than a hokey challenge to viewer’s suspension-of-disbelief. Even in the more grounded moments with Dom in Cuba at the film’s outset, the action defies normal logic and sets the tone for what is coming. Because the plot is so rich and filled with satisfying twists, however, <em>Fate’s </em>plotting<em> </em>seems to have more in common with espionage and heist films than its predecessors. That shared cinematic history is used to great effect with quick cutting flashbacks to reveal details of Dom’s capers. <em>The Fast and the Furious</em> takes more than a few pages from the Marvel Studios playbook, using familiar themes and visuals in the context of fundamental changes in generic approaches. But in the case of <em>Fate</em>, those changes in genre are less legible because of the visual homogeneity and familiar explosive action set pieces, for better or for worse.</p><p>Along with the trouble discerning some of the smart and valuable changes <em>Fate</em> makes to the formula, <em>Fate</em>’s status as the eighth film in the franchise makes apparent the datedness of some franchise hallmarks, relics of the time when these films were different and for a different audience. For instance, as amazing as the introductory scenes in Cuba are, the familiar montages that ostensibly demonstrate the city’s street racing culture but really only serves to display scantily clad women and expensive cars have always been poorly executed. They are deeply troubling in considering the franchises’s orientation to questions of gender, but this sleazy scene feels even more irregular in the case of <em>Fate</em> — particularly in the context of the spirit of, dare I say, wholesomeness that permeates the film embodied by the familial interactions between the Hobbses and the Shaws. These partially-ironic family moments also serve as the crux of the film’s humor outside of Tyrese’s lines. The ability to negotiate different tones, in the moments where viewers find themselves laughing, is one of the film’s great strength in contrast to the slightly jarring detritus of series conventions. For instance, Jason Statham’s Deckard Shaw fighting through an airplane with a baby in tow is one of the film’s most brilliant and hysterical moments. Such a moment is novel, inventive, and serves as Shaw’s moral redemption that is initiated by the understated revelation by Hobbs that Shaw is an English patriot rather than a traitorous terrorist.</p><p>If this review sounds conflicted, it shouldn’t. I wholeheartedly recommend <em>The Fate of the Furious</em> to anyone, as long as they are not delusional close-minded film elitists with tastes predicated on self-congratulatory fantasies. Because, it’s true, the films we enjoy make us. They determine our social body and how we are perceived by others. What we claim to like will make people trust or distrust our future recommendations in proportion to how our likes match another’s perception of quality. But I pose the same question to viewers as Cypher poses to Dom: Don’t you want to be free? Free to enjoy? Any argument of a film’s quality or a description of why one enjoyed it might just be an alibi for a pathological attachment to it. That might be all this is. An essay to justify an inarticulable (or not yet articulable) pleasure I experience watching and endlessly analyzing a <em>Fast and Furious </em>film. Abandoning the delusion of a film’s objective quality, then, is an important step toward that <em>enjoyment</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ad82eafef9a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“The ‘other you’ who exists within desires it thus”: The Question of Imprisonment and the…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/the-other-you-who-exists-within-desires-it-thus-the-question-of-imprisonment-and-the-7d1baac86428?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d1baac86428</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[david-lynch]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Apr 2017 12:52:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-05T12:52:08.450Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“The ‘other you’ who exists within desires it thus”: The Question of Imprisonment and the Unconscious in Persona 5</h3><blockquote>Note: This is the first installment in what will hopefully be a weekly series of vaguely connected essays on <em>Persona 5</em> as I make my way through it. This essay contains light spoilers for the first two hours of the game.</blockquote><p>Beyond the question of Jungian psychoanalysis and Ingmar Bergman, one of the most pressing questions of <em>Persona 5</em> is that of imprisonment. Early promotional material (quite inadvisably, in my view) evocatively depicted chains (presumably for the protagonist and playable characters) alongside ball-and-chains posing the question <a href="http://thenerdybomb.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/persona5.jpg">“You are a slave. Want emancipation?”</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vpzFhKQ9SI_fwVVfWTNAmQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Early promotional material for Persona 5</figcaption></figure><p>One might attribute this immediately concerning tone-deafness to issues of cultural context and translation. That attribution is supported by how the game, while still alluding to enslavement and “slaves” in an abstract fashion, shifts its primary motif from enslavement to imprisonment.</p><p>The <em>Persona</em> series always features a space “between dream and reality” known as the Velvet Room accessible only to the nameless protagonist. <em>Persona 5</em>’s iteration of the Velvet Room is a prison which, according to Igor, the Velvet Room proprietor, reflects the “the state of [the protagonist’s] heart.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*Lz7TPlWU6aJt-KXa2fdQHw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Persona 5’s Velvet Room</figcaption></figure><p>The Velvet Room as it features into the <em>Persona </em>series more generally is fascinating in itself. One can’t help but look at the plush blue scenery of every Velvet Room dating all the way back to 1996’s original <em>Persona</em> and not think of the titular fabric of David Lynch’s <em>Blue Velvet</em> (1986) or from a more contemporary perspective, the dreamlike unreality of the blue lit Club Silencio in Lynch’s <em>Mulholland Drive</em> (2001).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*eV0aJrLJ6MSA2Vfydk6pHw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/639/1*XmzF9CD--3NkAsM9W_VgtQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Persona’s (1996) Velvet Room and the “real life” member’s only Club Silencio at 142, rue Montmarte in Paris modeled after the fictional club</figcaption></figure><p>Putting broader symbolisms aside, the anonymized protagonist (and thus, the player themselves) is never named as a “slave,” (as the early advertisement might indicate) but rather as a “prisoner,” or “inmate.” In the case of the protagonist, this is both literally true and symbolically relevant. The event that sets the plot into motion is the protagonist’s arrest and subsequent conviction on an assault charge where by all accounts he was saving a woman in distress. In addition, the story is told retrospectively by the protagonist to a prosecuting attorney, Sae Niijima, after the protagonist’s arrest on a litany of charges related to his “phantom thievery.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*foGEyYVqAdi8-JXJo1Wr9w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Replace Lucas Black’s face with that of Persona 5’s protagonist</figcaption></figure><p>For the “state of [his] heart” to be that of a prison, then, is apt. He has faced judicial sanctions and will, unbenounced to him at the time of his first entry into the Velvet Room, have to again. The protagonist’s unceremonious transfer from his hometown to Tokyo’s Shujin Academy (in this case I think of, rather than Lynch, Justin Lin’s <em>The Fast and The Furious: Tokyo Drift</em> [2006]), his lodging in a stranger’s curry restaurant, and his social isolation in school as a consequence of his criminal record all perpetuate his imprisonment.</p><p>In addition to being a prisoner, however, the protagonist is also cast as a “Trickster.” Igor says the purpose of the protagonist’s presence in the Velvet Room is to be “rehabilitated into a free man.” Igor continues to make references to the “miracle” of the protagonist’s “rehabilitation” throughout the early sections of the game. Igor also poses the question to the protagonist, “are you ready to fight against the world’s corruption?” Igor’s rehabilitation takes the form of the “phantom thievery” and resistance to the law rather than obedience to it. This resistance is aligned with the “Other” (in the Lacanian sense) and the Freudian unconscious, as becomes evident in the game’s first dungeon.</p><p>The game’s dungeons take the form of “Palaces” controlled by a “ruler.” As Morgana explains to the protagonist, “This place is another reality that the ruler’s heart projects. One could say it’s a world in which one’s distorted desires have materialized. In order to prevent such distortions, one must hold a powerful will of rebellion.” Here again, the distortions of a “ruler” run parallel to the “world’s corruption” that Igor cautions against, and the “will of rebellion” is necessary for the protagonist’s “rehabilitation” and, thus, his freedom. Important, too, is the way “distorted desires” materialize as the Palace that imprisons. As Freud says in the third heading of <em>The Interpretation of Dreams</em> (1913), “The Dream Is the Fulfilment of a Wish.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/285/1*Hl1WtpFopioKJZoeQ_n2VQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>What connects the fulfillment of the wish in Freud’s view and the distorted desires that materialize in the form of the Palace is precisely that which connects <em>wish</em> and <em>desire</em>. As Dylan Evans writes in <em>An Introductory Dictionary of Lacanian Psychoanalysis </em>(1996), “Lacan’s term, <em>désir</em>, is the term used in the French translations of Freud to translate Freud’s term <em>Wunsch</em>, which is translated as ‘wish’ by Strachey in the <em>Standard Edition</em>” (35). Thus, recognizing that desire in Lacan and the wish in Freud share the principle that they are <em>always in the unconscious</em>, and never consciously articulated, is crucial to understanding imprisonment in <em>Persona 5</em>.</p><p>When Ryuji Sakamoto unleashes his Persona for the first time, Captain Kidd, Kidd says to Ryuji, “You made me wait quite a while. You seek power, correct? Then let us form a pact … The ‘other you’ who exists within <em>desires </em>it thus” [emphasis added]. To be clear, both Palaces and Persona, like desire and wish, are of the unconscious. But <em>Persona 5</em> distinguishes itself from its predecessors by positioning the unconscious as capable of both imprisonment and liberation. Kidd, the ‘other [Ryuji]’ that <em>desires</em>, is freed from imprisonment by Ryuji’s assertion of his “will of rebellion” in the face of the hostility of the villainous Suguru Kamoshida’s Shadow (which is, like Persona, a manifestation of the unconscious, though it is distinct from Persona by being fundamentally repressed). And yet, it is the unconscious that creates the Palace that imprisons Kamoshida’s phantasmatic “slaves” and perhaps Kamoshida himself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/591/1*h2pORuFEcKkWNSRVYz4pLA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kamoshida and Ryuji</figcaption></figure><p>Though the “slaves” have no real world presence, they correspond to real individuals and reflect Kamoshida’s perception of them. When the protagonist, Ryuji, and Morgana find the imagos of athletes on Kamoshida’s volleyball team being tortured in the Palace, the space of Kamoshida’s unconscious desire, the logic of Freud’s belief “The Dream Is the Fulfilment of a Wish” results in Morgana concluding, “this is horrible. It must mean he treats [his athletes] as slaves in the real world too.” Despite the fact that the “slaves” are not corporeal and the Palace is simply the manifestation of the unconscious, these forms have a significant presence that is sufficient to draw conclusions about how the “ruler” acts in the real world. Though a desire may be unarticulated, in <em>Persona 5</em>, if a desire produces a Palace, it must be the case that it is being acted upon in the real world.</p><p><em>Persona 5 </em>is immediately impressive in the way it interrogates the familiar themes of the unconscious and desire (in the case of the recurrent features of the story like Persona, Shadows, and the Velvet Room) alongside the particular theme of imprisonment (in the case of the unique features and motifs of the story, such as the protagonist’s legal woes, social isolation, rebellion, thievery, and Palaces) to great effect. The apparent shift in the primary motif from one of “slavery” to one of “imprisonment” pays enormous dividends both in terms of political advisability and theoretical richness. The translation team at Atlus deserves a great deal of recognition for their fine work. Though <em>Persona 5</em> suggests the unconscious provides both potential for liberation and imprisonment depending on the status of the subject, the opening hours of the game also make clear that the unconscious’s function is particular in its production of Palaces, Shadows, and Persona depending on precisely that same status. The schematization of the unconscious would make Lacan proud, as this repetitious scheme which constantly produces unique results within a formula mirrors the Lacanian dictum that “the unconscious is structured like a language.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d1baac86428" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“I’ve still got vibrations to send”: More Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/ive-still-got-vibrations-to-send-more-life-dafc143a02e2?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dafc143a02e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[more-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hip-hop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drake]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Mar 2017 18:31:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-26T19:48:15.239Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“I wanna move to Dubai so I don’t never have to kick it with none of you guys”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*XljBK4mUo1cew1nyOKo3tg.gif" /></figure><p>Drake is a certified pop star. So, it makes perfect sense that he’d come out swinging on <em>More Life </em>(2017)<em> </em>with “Free Smoke.” A metaphor that refers to the smoke proceeding a bullet from a gun, it is an unquestionably ill-fitting metaphor for the actor-turned-singer who is unlikely to have participated in much criminal activity. But it’s not the first jarring metaphor Drake has ever used. It sounded like nails on a chalkboard when Drake rapped on “Come Thru,” “Rap game, crack game, ain’t that different ya know?” or on “10 Bands” when he said, “In the six cooking with the wrist motion.”</p><p>But maybe it’s just me who has an issue with Drake appropriating frequently used hip-hop tropes of drug trafficking and violence when I am sure what is more familiar to him are spotlights and sound stages and makeup artists. The more immediate deception is Drake’s insistence on calling <em>More Life</em> a playlist. By what metric? It is clearly not. Maybe people will stick to the old mixtape/album binary, too. But what was a mixtape when I was growing up? Someone would drop a CD that they couldn’t or didn’t want to get on the shelves at Walmart. When digital distribution was more in vogue, the standard shifted to online releases vs. physical ones. Perhaps, too, something was far more likely to be a mixtape when it was a rapper using beats from other hit songs (see: Lil Wayne’s <em>No Ceilings</em> [2009]).</p><p>But sure, if we’re gonna call <em>If You’re Reading This It’s Too Late</em> (2015) a mixtape, then fine, <em>More Life</em> can be a mixtape. If a mixtape is utterly indistinguishable from an album, why not. But what is the purpose of calling <em>More Life</em> a playlist? Perhaps Drake was trying to get across the sense of collaboration and playfulness of the record. After all, “No Long Talk” comes in with a Giggs feature and it is the first of many featured artists. Drake even gives up tracks to Sampha and Skepta where he doesn’t say a word. But Drake isn’t the first to have a record with a lot of features or with tracks that seem to be almost entirely by different artists. Let’s put this whole playlist premise to bed.</p><p>If “Free Smoke” and “No Long Talk” are <em>If You’re Reading This</em> Drake, “Passionfruit” brings back the vibed-out “Hold On, We’re Going Home” Drake. Across the album, we are reminded of Drake’s viability as both a rapper and a singer. Although I have a preference for the latter, even “Passionfruit” doesn’t usurp the Nai Palm intro to “Free Smoke” as my favorite moment of the album thus far. Still, I think “Passionfruit” will be a slow burner for me. It characterizes something else that makes this record great: sparse verses with a number of repeated lyrics that fill out the brilliant beats in unexpected ways.</p><p><em>“I cannot tell who is my friend. I need distance between me and them. Gonna have to teach me how to love you again.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/529/1*6KIntIEH9XUoVP4IkceJmQ.gif" /></figure><p>After Jorja does work on the immaculate “Get It Together,” (adapted from Black Coffee’s “Superman”) the record really takes off for me. “Madiba Riddim” and “Blem” are an unskippable pair. The familiar reference to Mandela in the title and the accusation of Drake’s “cultural pillaging” sit in uncomfortable tension with each other. I have no interest in or authority to adjudicate this conflict, but I enjoy Drake’s exploration into dancehall and Caribbean sounds. My ears just feel <em>good</em> when the beats kick in. When you hit those vibes like “Get It Together,” “Madiba Riddim,” and “Blem,” just like “One Dance” before them, you can imagine doing that 1, 2 step like Ciara or Drake in the “Hotline Bling” video. Of course, it is also worth mentioning that the end of “Jorja Interlude” uses the same Stevie Wonder flute sample from “Doing It Wrong” off <em>Take Care</em> (2011). Not only does it sound dope as hell, but it signals that Drake will be drawing not only from <em>If You’re Reading This</em> and <em>Views</em>, but also channeling the <em>Take Care</em> vibe that he revisits later with “Teenage Fever.”</p><p><em>“Now it’s my world, you can have the scene”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/383/1*x6U8GPN4_iqavZU7flhRiQ.gif" /></figure><p>So Sampha does his thing on “4422,” then we get the Sampha-less “Gyalchester” which is not my favorite song on the record (don’t worry, it’s still good), but what we really need to discuss is “Skepta Interlude.” Skepta’s verse makes a point clear that has gone unstated throughout —Drake might put eyes on talent, but he doesn’t <em>make</em> it. And the relationship is symbiotic. Skepta is an institution. He brings to Drake an international legitimacy that Drake desperately needs to make the kind of music he is making. So in a way, it is Skepta who made the Drake of <em>More Life</em>. And what a verse this is!</p><p>“Portland” initiates a series of strange sounding sampled instruments on the back end of the album. Maybe the flute here is the sibling of the one from “Mask Off”? But I have never jammed so hard to what sounds like a recorder in my life. Murda’s production tag lets us know “Murda on the beat so it’s not nice,” but it is nice. The beat is very nice. This is undeniably one of the most radio friendly tracks on the album with both Quavo and Travis killing their verses. This is a unique track where Travis is able to do is thing and add to a texture of a track without totally taking it over, probably because he didn’t also produce it.</p><p>But it’s really the “Skepta Interlude” that sets off this part of the album. I can’t just listen to it alone, though. If I put it on, I feel compelled to listen through to “Sacrifices.”</p><p><em>“I made sacrifices, I been ballin’ ever since”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*R7pfyvIf-uNaDIMAZF32BQ.gif" /></figure><p>How much medical work had to be done reattaching jaws after Young Thug’s verse on “Sacrifices” came in. Can someone tell me? Get me the numbers on this? If Young Thug never raps like this again, it would be a tragedy. Drake’s matching of Thug’s cadence at the beginning of the record is masterful. It shows how largely Thug looms on the track, considering Drake probably heard Thug’s verse and rewrote his own or changed how he was gonna deliver it. Even the premise of the flow defies conventional rhyme but also stops short of being the corny Young Money-esque punchlines that Nicki and Wayne are so famous for. Thug’s wordplay, going from sweet to suite, freak to fleek to geek, the lines about his Patek, and of course the bars about the woods… so next level. Beyond all that, the last 8 lines are superlative. References to two bottled beverages and Jumanji are the kind of bars I’m trying to hear. In a world where “every song sound like Drake featuring Drake,” Young Thug absolutely dominates this song in a way that invigorates and propels the listener through the following, more downbeat tracks.</p><p>“Nothings Into Somethings” is where some of the more interesting production conspiracy theories of this record creep up. We know Bryson Tiller tweeted in December that he was working with Drake for something on <em>More Life</em>. Is this the song? The “Don’t” comparisons are inescapable. Tiller would have been right at home crooning alongside Drake here. And the song is short, too! Two and a half minutes cause Tiller’s verse got dropped? The world may never know.</p><p>“Teenage Fever” follows “Nothings” sounding like a <em>Take Care</em> b-side in a good way. This track picks up the thread he laid down at the end of “Jorja Interlude.” Following this track with “KMT” is genius. People want to say Drake bit this or that, but the real scandal should be that Ness &amp; Cameron Pasquale sampled “His World,” a song from <em>Sonic </em>’06, one of the worst video games ever made.<em> </em>What I don’t want to hear is any sideways talk about Giggs’s verse. Are you kidding me? He goes off. He’s got the perfect “Whippin’ Excursion” cadence, that voice, and a well placed “UGH” during Drake’s verse. And Giggs talking about “jokers” and going on to reference the famous frame of Batman slapping Robin from <em>World’s Finest</em> in 1965, you can’t beat that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*gx13g3XHfaL6wtNK8zg2Yw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In “Lose You,” Drake seems to be addressing his listeners. Drake raps:</p><blockquote>When did all the things I mean from the bottom of my heart start to lose meaning? Maybe I share it with too many people. Back then it used to just feel like our secret. Back when I would write and not think about how they receive it.</blockquote><p>The self-reflexive “talk to the fans” thing was just done on Bieber’s “I’ll Show You,” but made famous by a Michael Jackson late in his career (think “Scream”/“Childhood”). Drake makes a pretty good case for himself here. Before the lines quoted above he raps:</p><blockquote>Why is my struggle different than others’? Only child that’s takin’ care of his mother as health worsens and bills double. That’s not respectable all of a sudden? I don’t get a pat on the back for the come up?</blockquote><p>I think of Drake as having always been rich, but he probably wasn’t making that much working on <em>Degrassi</em>. So this track hits at just the right time. If you’ve become anxious after hearing countless exhortations of excess and celebrations of wealth (see: “Sacrifices” and the rest of this whole project basically) your celebration of Drake’s success is affirmed as the moral lauding of a hard worker endeavoring on a worthy project, taking care of his mother. Beyond that, “Lose You” is a good song. The twinkling keyboard sounds as unique as the recorder in “Portland” or the weird string sample in “Sacrifices.” 40 on his “A” game.</p><p>Oh, and we don’t even need to talk about “Can’t Have Everything.” I know I said “Gyalchester” wasn’t great, but this song straddles bad. I don’t skip it yet, but maybe down the line I will. “Tried to serve me up a cheese steak / I gave them back a clean plate” is such an ill advised line. The whole of the third verse goes from sounding mediocre to whack. But the song is saved by Drake’s wonderful mother dropping some knowledge for all of us to lead us into “Glow.”</p><p><em>“I still have my guard up. Blame this thing I’m part of.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*LPixTi2zNdW543lxbpWUUg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The situation between Kanye and Drake seems, at best, tense. I know that’s not the world I want to live in, one where Kanye and Drake are in a fight. They haven’t collaborated together enough. After an unsatisfying single-only version of “Pop Style” and swapping verses on Big Sean’s “Blessings” (also the extended, non-album version), this sounds like their first authentic collaboration. But the success of this song probably won’t mend their relationship. Still, interpellating “Touch the Sky” and “Started From the Bottom” in Kanye’s bars sounds great. The two of them showcase their singing, and then hit us with that “Devotion” sample. Perfect.</p><p>“Since Way Back” and “Fake Love” follow. PND gets saved for late in the game even though he could’ve popped up on “Nothings Into Somethings” or “Teenage Fever.” “Since Way Back” is kind of a sleeper hit. Between “Glow” and “Fake Love” is a tough position to be in, but this song embodies what PND brings to the table like no other.</p><p>“Fake Love” is a hit. What more can I say? The song rocks.</p><p><em>“I wanna see you do more in this life if we takin’ it there”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*qsoFdkXo916KaGjCx6vMQw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The change up in “Ice Melts” is amazing. It’s so brief. Hitting at about two minutes in, I was waiting to hear it again at the end of the song. The fact that it’s only in the song once, that brevity, makes it all the more precious. Maybe like the ice that’s melting under the Jamaican sun in a 911? Might mess up the seats though. But almost ending the record with a song like this is a powerful statement. This song is easy to envision as a radio hit. Just like “Portland,” Thug drives the tracks most suited for air play. The upbeat piano on the beat is a nice touch. I like to imagine it is the spiritual successor to Travis Scott’s “Pick Up the Phone” from last year’s <em>Birds in the Trap Sing McKnight</em> (2016).</p><p><em>“Takin’ summer off, ’cause they tell me I need recovery. Maybe gettin’ back to my regular life will humble me. I’ll be back in 2018 to give you the summary</em>.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*VWeKFE4mCWavDvahmsaR2A.gif" /></figure><p>Drake closes out this joint with something that reminds me of “Last Call.” Since <em>The College Dropout</em> (2004) is one of the best albums of all time, that sets the standard for retrospectives tracks as the definitive way to close out blockbuster records. “Do Not Disturb” picks up many of the themes of “Lose You,” and lets people know where Drake is at and where he’s going. The Snoh Aalegra sample sounds fantastic and this song is all bars no chorus. But should we take what Drake says at face value? Is this going to be a world without Drake until 2018? Maybe, but that would be fine. I’ll be spinning <em>More Life</em> for a while.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dafc143a02e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“part of my responsibility — as a witness — was to move as largely and as freely as possible, to…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miguelrr/part-of-my-responsibility-as-a-witness-was-to-move-as-largely-and-as-freely-as-possible-to-37d580e6dc04?source=rss-a157ccd24ac6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37d580e6dc04</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[raoul-peck]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[james-baldwin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Miguel Rivera]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Mar 2017 16:18:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-21T16:20:25.638Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“part of my responsibility — as a witness — was to move as largely and as freely as possible, to write the story, and to get it out”: James Baldwin and Raoul Peck’s filmic vision in I Am Not Your Negro</h3><p>Consider, for a moment, this passage from J. Hoberman’s <em>Get Out </em>(2017) review from the <em>New York Review of Books</em>:</p><blockquote><em>Most obviously, </em>Get Out<em> is the latest instance of the remarkable and remarkably varied African-American cinema of the past few years. This includes popular and critical successes like Ryan Coogler’s </em>Fruitvale Station<em> and </em>Creed<em>, Ava DuVernay’s </em>Selma<em>, Denzel Washington’s adaptation of </em>Fences<em>, and </em>12 Years a Slave<em>, but also the scandalous rise and fall of Nate Parker’s ambitious </em>Birth of a Nation<em>, the restoration of Richard Wright’s </em>Native Son<em> film, the discoveries of Kathleen Collins’s </em>Losing Ground<em> and of the teenage avant-garde filmmaker Edward Owens, and the release of the scholarly, multi-disc box set </em>Pioneers of African American Cinema<em>.</em></blockquote><p>Putting aside the curious canon-formation Hoberman engages in, he goes on to place the film version of <em>I Am Not Your Negro</em> (2016) in the canon of “remarkably varied African-American cinema.” Prior to seeing the film, I first read the paperback version of the script published by Vintage International. Because this text, authored in the most technical sense by Baldwin but brought to life both on the screen and page by Raoul Peck, is the script of the film they must be considered in tandem. The script, though, is no less lively than the film.</p><p>Still, there is something that doesn’t quite come across in this script. It’s something that carries the spectre of the sanitized Alex Haley rendering of Malcolm X. In my view, the late Baldwin is the most interesting material. The Baldwin of <em>Just Above My Head</em> (1979), “Open Letter to the Born Again” (1979), and <em>The Evidence of Things Not Seen </em>(1985) is the unassimilable Baldwin, unsanitizable, irreducible to platitudes or liberal humanist assimilationism. This is <em>not</em> that Baldwin, not exactly. Part of the reason is the texts from which this text was constructed. There is an unrealized tension between the Baldwin of <em>Remember This House</em>, the fragments from the mid-late 1980s that would go on to constitute the majority of <em>I Am Not Your Negro</em>, and the public Baldwin of the various 1960s interviews that also feature in Peck’s vision. For Peck’s vision to be truly comprehensive, that tension should have been exposed, the encounter between the two Baldwins staged. The attempt at placing the two in lock-step with each other is jarring, to say the least. For one, Baldwin’s position on Israel in his 1968 appearance on <em>The Dick Cavett Show</em> explicitly contradicts his later support of Palestine evident in “Open Letter to the Born Again.” One need not go far to expose other curiosities here, effaced aspects of Baldwin’s positions and personalities that would be ill-suited to a certain vision of Baldwin.</p><p>And yet, I refuse to indict Peck for what I perceive as a serious problem. It is an easily resolved one — reading Baldwin’s late work first hand. <em>I Am Not Your Negro</em> is a work of unmistakable genius, both because of Peck’s guiding hand and Baldwin’s unbelievable intellectual power. If Peck is not completely faithful to what scholars consider to be the essence of late Baldwin, he is beholden to two great callings. The first, Baldwin’s vision of cinema and how it should function. The second, how to produce a cohesive narrative out of various fragments. Throughout <em>I Am Not Your Negro</em>, Baldwin’s meditations on film are placed side-by-side the material from <em>Remember This House</em>. Peck has an eye for the provocative, asking the precise questions one should about Hoberman’s view of so-called “African-American cinema” whilst being placed in such a canon. This self-awareness is a delicious testament to Baldwin’s own tendency toward provocation.</p><p>There are things the film accomplishes that the published version of the script does not. Peck, in the film version, leans into the present. In fact, the printed version, despite including plenty of images from the film, omits any that reference contemporary events. Images of uprisings, civil unrest, Ferguson, are sutured to the filmic images explored in Baldwin’s language and present Baldwin’s words as prescient. There is an entire essay that could be written on Peck’s clever cutting from a close up of Alex’s face after a shooting spree in <em>Elephant</em> (2003) to a matching close up of a militarized police officer in Ferguson. One could imagine these images as Baldwin’s nightmares, as he constantly warns talk-show hosts and TV viewers that the fate of the country and the fate of Black people in it are intertwined, obvious as it might seem. As Dick Cavett asked Baldwin in 1968, “Is it at once getting much better and still hopeless?” Cavett poses the question to Baldwin with surprising introspection and pathos. Baldwin replies:</p><blockquote>Well, I don’t think there’s much hope for it, you know, to tell you the truth as long as people are using this peculiar language. It’s not a question of what happens to the Negro here or to the black man here — that’s a very vivid question for me, you know — but the real question is what is going to happen to this country. I have to repeat that.</blockquote><p>Before anyone accuses Baldwin of pessimism (as if there aren’t worse things to be accused of), Peck decides to end the film with Baldwin’s words from Henry Morgenthau III’s <em>The Negro and the American Promise</em> (1963):</p><blockquote>I can’t be a pessimist, because I’m alive. To be a pessimist means you have agreed that human life is an academic matter, so I’m forced to be an optimist. I’m forced to believe that we can survive whatever we must survive. But the Negro in this country . . . the future of the Negro in this country is precisely as bright or as dark as the future of the country.</blockquote><p>In moments like these, I am reminded of a comment that a teacher of mine gave during a talk on her recently released book. She was asked by one of my younger colleagues, “how do you ensure your work maintains relevance?” My teacher replied something like this, “because I write about anti-Blackness, I hope my work loses its relevance. If my work were to lose relevance, that would mean that anti-Blackness will have been dislodged in this country. But because that would be a fundamental restructuring of the way our world works, I suspect my work will remain relevant.” That uncomfortable reality of the timelessness of certain kinds of work because it addresses social ills so fundamentally ingrained in the structure of our world was a realization I could feel dawning on my teacher, not for the first time, but as if anew as she replied to her student. Baldwin might be equally uncomfortable with how we take his work at such a late date, but certainly he would not be surprised.</p><p>This text (the script and the film, both) is essential, but also must be approached with caution. I am reminded of how difficult it is for those who misuse or misunderstand Martin Luther King Jr. quotations to come to grips with his lesser known positions. I am also reminded of the fact that his insistence on expanding the purview of his organization and his leadership, addressing poverty and the war in Vietnam, continued until his assassination. One could argue that the two share some kind of causal relation. “Beyond Vietnam,” (1967) then, embodies the incendiary, unassimilable “late King” in the way “Open Letter” embodies the late Baldwin. The same could be said of Malcolm X, who was always difficult for American culture to come to grips with but made easier by Haley’s clean cutting <em>The Autobiography</em>(1965). Peck showcases Baldwin’s broad-lensed view of these figures, going beyond their reduction to finite ideological positions and slogans. We owe Baldwin, then, the same capacious assessment he offered King, X, and Evers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37d580e6dc04" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>