<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mike Mesterharm on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mike Mesterharm on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mike-mesterharm?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 00:28:06 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mike-mesterharm/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Will You Hear Me?”: An Elegy for Evelyn Job]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/will-you-hear-me-an-elegy-for-evelyn-job-7b7377a95c36?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b7377a95c36</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 02:22:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-16T02:42:39.243Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4PFiRNxI9OwE3f0i-rZddg.png" /></figure><p><em>Writers note: I wrote this in pieces last year, but never got it together enough to share anywhere. I think it is as done as it will get, and I wanted to tell the world about Evelyn, our third child lost to miscarriage: Who she was to me, who she is to me, who she will never get to be, and how knowing and not knowing her changed me. If you’re living with loss, you are not alone. May we all heal and remember.</em></p><p>We buried Evelyn Job, returned her to the earth in an impromptu ceremony before work on a cloudy weekday morning. We could not find our large shovel, lost somewhere in the seemingly endless shuffling in our garage, so I dug the hole with a tiny toy trowel that our son uses when he imagines he’s digging great canals or deep holes to find buried treasure or whatever else his young and still-infinite mind might conjure. I dug as deep as I could into the mound of dirt where she would be laid to rest, her tiny tiny body and her tiny tiny heart which stopped after we only got to hear it once. I dug and I imagined, just like my son probably does as he digs, a world where things were different than they are. Brief, unbidden images came to me of a future where I could hear her laugh, see her smile and learn and grow. I felt lost in those dreams for a moment, the world seemed to swim around me, and then my wife placed her in the ground and I covered her up and it was all over.</p><p>The whole thing felt both impromptu and also dignified in its own way, these proceedings to honor the grief we felt but for which our world and our shared social consciousness seems to lack form and syntax.</p><p>I hugged my wife and we cried and then we both had to get to work, the incongruity of my own feelings and the reality pressing against them bordering on humorous. I sat in our car and wiped my now-runny nose with a baby wipe from the center console and I wondered not for the first time where I was supposed to fit all this grief, why it never felt like there was space for it in my heart or in this world.</p><p>A few weeks earlier, I told the Uber driver that I was headed to a brewery and she said that that sounded like fun, was I just going to meet some friends?</p><p>I said yes, I was going to meet my wife and some of her work friends and she said that sounded so nice and then she started talking about the weather.</p><p>I told her the truth but not the whole truth because how do you tell a stranger that your wife is having a miscarriage in the bathroom? How do you tell her that the cooler you’re carrying has ice packs in it so that we can keep the fetal remains of our child cold so that they can perform some genetic tests and maybe tell us what went wrong and maybe, but not probably, why this happened? How do you tell her about the joy that disappeared so suddenly? About the child who surprised you and filled your imagination with thoughts of what could be? About the way that all vanished in a heartbeat when there was no heartbeat to be found?</p><p>In a moment of deep absurdity, I wondered what would happen to my Uber rating if I had tried to tell her all of that. How would this loss, and my success or failure in communicating it to another human being, be translated ultimately into another contribution to another algorithm? Why do our minds go to the places they go?</p><p>So I did not tell her. Instead, I looked at the clouds and shared her surprise that it had not rained yet, that the dark skies looked ready to wash us all away but were holding back for reasons of their own, reasons neither of us could understand.</p><p>We were on a plane when J told me she was likely pregnant, the second plane of the day with our two children who were both several meltdowns deep into their emotional reserves and had taken an impromptu and mercifully coordinated breather. We were flying back from a beautiful and chaotic weekend with her family on the Carolina coast.</p><p>I was surprised. We were both surprised. Family planning is complicated and we had agreed a few months ago to stand pat on any plans to grow our family, to revisit the topic sometime in the coming months to check in, but, it seemed then, leaning towards moving ahead without having another child.</p><p>After blinking a few times, I looked around at the two beautiful, hangry, chaos machines seated quietly, for a moment, around us. What would adding another be like? How might our lives change? It would be a long, fraught road, I knew, to get to the point that a new child was joining us, and the journey after that would be even longer, even more fraught. But then I felt joy, and I felt hope. Evelyn was hope and she was joy.</p><p>I was at work when J texted me that they couldn’t find a heartbeat. I shared an office and knew that I was visibly upset so I had to tell one of my closest friends at work both that J had been pregnant and that she was now miscarrying, my own emotional whiplash mirrored, in a time-condensed format, on her face as I spoke. We both teared up and my friend said how sorry she was and I said thank you, because what else can you say, what else could either of us say, in the face of something so painful and mysterious, in the face of something neither of us could really quantify or understand?</p><p>In the days after we got the news that Evelyn was gone, I felt a familiar kind of lost. I worried about J and what she would have to go through physically at some indeterminate but pressingly immediate point in her future. I thought about how I had failed to walk the knife’s edge of loving this new child and maintaining enough of a barrier between us so that their potential loss would not unmake me.</p><p>I thought about Evelyn’s siblings. I thought of my son and daughter and the people they were always becoming and the joys and pains of this growth. I thought of the two other kids we lost before we could know them. I thought of Roan Isaiah, lost before our younger child, our daughter, was born, and our daughter’s “vanishing twin,” Mary Thomas. I thought about how much I loved and grieved them too, surprised at how open those wounds still felt years later, how they must have sat raw and open out of view for all those years, navigated around rather than fully healed. I thought about how the wounds I felt for the loss of all three of them would always be with me but how, in some sense, the kids would be with me too, my own trinity, three holy ghosts.</p><p>We named her Evelyn, which means, among other things, “desired,” because although she caught us by surprise, she was loved and wanted from the very beginning. J suggested Job for her middle name and I agreed that it fit perfectly. Job suffered and sought in vain the wisdom to understand what was happening to him. Wisdom, it turns out, is not really for us mortals to possess. “It is hidden from the eyes of every living thing, concealed even from the birds in the sky.”</p><p>I’ve written before about my own inability to adequately frame suffering when I experience it. My heart feels pain and my brain immediately steps in to try and provide some way in which it can make sense. This almost always involves some inevitably doomed exercise in quantification (“How much does it hurt?”) followed immediately then by comparison (“This does/doesn’t hurt as much as it when XXXXX happened” or “YYYYYYYYY experienced XXXXXX and that must have been worse.”) It never actually gives me any answers but my brain does it automatically anyway and I am always left feeling disoriented. This core human feeling of pain and this core human experience of grief by its very structure defies the quantitative framework that I let myself believe guides my decisions about nearly everything else in my life.</p><p>Deprived of my usual way of making sense of the world, I find my brain spiraling, trapped and circling the interior edges of a profound grief without the tools necessary to understand what these edges mean, to fully understand the black hole that they encircle.</p><p>Even stranger still, I find myself thinking of how much I love my two children that I’ve gotten to meet and how my love for them seems to grow every day.</p><p>Is this true? I love them with my whole heart every day, but is that amount really less today than it will be tomorrow? Does this mean I love my daughter less because my love for her has had less time to grow? Do I love Evelyn less than Roan because we lost her earlier in the pregnancy?</p><p>There are not really any answers to these questions, flawed as they are down to their roots. It’s absurd, certainly, and on the merits makes absolutely zero sense. Perhaps it makes the most sense to just leave it there, but my nagging brain does not seem to let me. I find myself tortured by these deeply stupid questions as my mind circles and circles and circles the void that Evelyn’s, and Roan’s, and Mary’s absence has left in my heart.</p><p>I have close friends who have experienced loss by miscarriage and still-birth. Hearing their stories and attempting to empathize, I always run into the same problem: these stories are the same, in a deep sense, but they are always different in so many ways that seem to matter materially to fully gaining any sense of understanding the pain that someone else is undergoing. The context is never exactly the same and so the grief is never the same either. Where does their grief fit into this world? How do our experiences align and differ? Do these differences matter? Where does my wife’s suffering fit, the specific ways in which she encounters these losses, so different even from mine? Where does it all fit? Where does it all go?</p><p>My recent thinking has brought me back to where I started, focusing on the fact that it’s not just “order” that my brain looks for, not just any organizing principle for the information that I contain within myself, taken in from the world. Instead, for reasons I don’t really fully understand but will try to unpack again here, I tend towards a desire for hierarchy, a way in which certain bits of coded information about the world and the people in it allow me to place things in an order where value and worth are made obvious by positionality, certain things above others, certain things below. This is patently obvious even in the way that I’ve described this before, but I think it’s telling that I got away from thinking about this despite the fact that, even in that earlier piece, this is exactly what I said I was doing. I think it’s actually because this hierarchical ordering is my default mode of processing the world that the assumptions embedded in this mental model were not, and indeed are not, immediately clear to me without careful attention paid to remembering and understanding it.</p><p>Whether or not this inherent hierarchical urge is biological or cultural or both I don’t really know. I can see certain evolutionary advantages to this type of thinking that might have embedded this tendency into the lizard brain that sits atop my spine, whose programming shapes my higher order thinking in ways that I often find uncomfortable to consider. In a survival sense, ranking things is important: potential threats for the level of danger they represent, potential mates for their suitability in passing on my genes, different options to pursue for nourishment based on the net value they provide between nutrition gleaned from consumption and energy expended to obtain them, etc. In a cultural sense, it’s also obvious why I might fall into this mode of observation and processing. Rationalist thinking is the machinery that underlies our entire modern world. It only makes sense that it would work its way into the more deeply personal machinery of my mind as well.</p><p>I think the process of making meaning of suffering also is perhaps uniquely prone to this kind of hierarchical thinking. While joy is no less complicated and interesting in the ways in which we individually and collectively experience and process it, the experience of joy has obvious intrinsic value. I do not need to look elsewhere to understand why joy is valuable or why it is meaningful to me. Importantly, even when processing joy, I am not immune to this kind of thinking (keeping up with the Jones’s is a very real phenomena, and comparison is, as always, the thief of joy) but by and large, when I feel joy, I do not need to immediately look outside myself to understand it or contextualize it. By its very nature, by existing in my heart and mind, joy makes its meaning immediately known to me.</p><p>When I suffer, when I encounter grief, the value isn’t so immediately obvious, and so my tendency is to triangulate with external references. Even if this instinct is rooted in a desire to better understand my own experience, the act of comparing immediately taints that understanding in key ways. When I look around and begin my subconscious sorting of the ways that suffering and grief are made manifest in the world and try to place my own experience among them, I begin to, as I so often do, miss the whole point that might actually be found through this painful endeavor.</p><p>See, at its root, this process fucks up the way that I understand grief and pain. I want my suffering to be meaningful and so I seek this meaning through external triangulation, but this immediately draws attention to the ways in which my suffering might be different or unique, and draws attention to the pieces of the experience that might differentiate my experience within some perceived, but ultimately fictional, hierarchy. This is wrongheaded because the meaning of suffering, if I’m really looking for a meaning that will do more than make my pain worse, is actually embedded in the opposite. When I find myself looking for the ways in which my suffering is special or unique, and by proxy find myself looking for the ways that it might make me special or unique, I might find those elements, but those elements are distractions from the substance of the case that might hold any real meaning.</p><p>See, here is where I land:</p><p>My suffering is not special and it does not make me special.</p><p>Why does this sting to read? I think it stings because this thought robs me of any kind of innate satisfaction, an easy answer to what it all means. My suffering is not special and it does not make me special, so therefore there is no deeper meaning just for me inside this pain. Instead the pain just provides me with a signpost that points directly back into the difficulty of the experience itself. My suffering has true, innate value only insofar as it reminds me that everyone that I meet, and everyone that I do not, suffers too. So perhaps the way to take away the sting is to consider it this way:</p><p>My suffering is not special and it does not make me special, but it makes me human.</p><p>My pain is not unique among the many hurts the world sees fit to dole out. I am not made special by grief. We all suffer, as humans, so while I cannot be made special through all this, if I am diligent, and lucky, I can be made more human, or I can at least begin to better understand what being human actually means. I may want to be the hero of my story, but it’s actually a lot better for me if I realize that any heroic piece of me that I might be lucky enough to forge though my pain is not unique but is instead mirrored everywhere in the hearts of so many others if I can just be bothered to think about it and look for it.</p><p>As I said, this is not necessarily easy to sit with. For one, it does not do much to answer my questions, but only gives me a new set of questions that I then have to try and answer.</p><p>What does it mean to become more human? Is it really worth this? Where, ultimately, can I find a space in my heart for this pain to fit if I’m robbed of the illusion that I am somehow unique for experiencing it? How do I make sense of this loss worth grieving as that grief still sits, strange and alien, astride the deep channel that lies between my head and my heart?</p><p>I don’t know, really. This framing helps with the head part of the process, but my heart still grieves, and it will take time to find an answer, if there is indeed an answer there to find.</p><p>It gets worse though, and maybe you see this coming. This all seems well and good to me, in my own head, as I’m writing this, but when the rubber meets the road, in the real world, I run into another issue: what if those whose suffering is worse than mine, on something resembling an objective scale, feel, perhaps rightly aggrieved by my flippant eschewing of the scale that weighs their grief against my own?</p><p>Does the loss of an unborn child give me the authority to imply that those who have lost someone that they knew and loved, fully and deeply, to traumatic circumstances, should weigh our grief equally?</p><p>Does the grief that makes its way into my privileged life really rate as worthy of note in the grand scheme of this universe, with all the terrible prices it exacts on a daily basis?</p><p>If my own tendency to impose a hierarchy on suffering is not entirely of my own making (and I don’t think it is) then what right do I have to throw that hierarchy away? Is this the right question to ask or does this kind of thinking only further trap all of us?</p><p>I don’t know. Genuinely, I do not know. I do not know where the truth lies or really where to begin looking. Maybe my answer will come in time. I have a very real feeling that it may not.</p><p>But I have not yet fully scratched the itch, and my mind keeps circling. What else is embedded here, beneath my conscious threshold? What flawed machinery is whirring away beneath the surface of those statements?</p><p>I think maybe the thing that keeps me spinning is the perceived imbalance of it. It feels like all void without mass. Maybe this is the flawed central tendency that I need to address, to focus not on what I’ve lost or gained, on the void or the mass, but on both.</p><p>But where is the mass here, in this case? I feel the void still, acutely, as we hit the year anniversary of that impromptu burial of Evelyn’s tiny, fragile body.</p><p>And yet, I feel the weight of my daughter’s existence. While we all, as good physics students, know that weight does not mean mass, I can’t help but feel that it doesn’t matter in this case. My daughter left a void when she left us, but she is not a void. She was here. She is here, or at least there, wherever there is.</p><p>No, I think it was right the second time. She is here. And to honor her mass, her presence, I wish to speak with her, with my daughter. I very much wish to speak with you, Evelyn.</p><p>I love you, Evelyn Job.</p><p>I miss you, now, the person you were, and I will miss forever the person you might have, would have, been.</p><p>Where are you, little one?</p><p>Surely you are not just in the ground. Are you here with me? Are you in the breeze and in the leaves and in the sun that filters through them? Are you in the rain that falls and in the rain that doesn’t, for reasons all its own? Are you in the cold and in the heat?</p><p>How do I find you? How can I hear your voice in all the beauty and pain in this world when I never really got to hear it at all?</p><p>What would have made you laugh? What would you have said that would have remade me anew, washed me away in wonder? How much poorer will my life be, will the world be, to never hear it? What can I become, should I become, here and now in your silence?</p><p>What do I owe you?</p><p>My dear one, what have you learned since you’ve left us and is it even fair for me to ask you? Are you up so high that you can see the wisdom hidden even from the birds of the sky?</p><p>Can I speak to you, Evelyn Job? Will you hear me?</p><p>I will look for you, little one.</p><p>Not in the ground. I will look for you in the breeze and in the leaves and in the sun that filters through them. I will look for you in the rain that falls and in the rain that doesn’t, in the clouds that hold back, for reasons all their own. I will look for you in the cold and in the heat.</p><p>I will listen for your voice, for what you would have said and for what you are saying to me now. I will try to find what would have made you laugh. I will try and laugh for both of us. I will let the love I feel for you in your silence be what remakes me anew even as your silence, your absence, cuts me.</p><p>I will love better because I did not get to know you. This is perhaps the only thing I can offer to you. Is it enough?</p><p>No. It will not be enough.</p><p>None of this is fair. You deserved so much more, but it is all that I can offer. It is the best that I can do.</p><p>I love you, Evelyn Job. I will love you until the very end. If there is really a way, if I can find a way, I will love you after that.</p><p>I will speak to you, Evelyn Job. Will you hear me?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b7377a95c36" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dr. Languagemodel: or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love ChatGPT]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/dr-languagemodel-or-how-i-learned-to-stop-worrying-and-love-chatgpt-31539c197dc7?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31539c197dc7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chatgpt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Feb 2023 20:11:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-06T21:28:02.549Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uSKtZYVhrvFMbdXUL-nD1w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Seen above: a teacher’s face upon reading the 50th essay written by ChatGPT. Actual photo credit to Stanley Kubrick’s deeply strange and wonderful 1964 classic Dr. Strangelove.</figcaption></figure><p>The recent hubbub surrounding ChatGPT has created something of a good news bad news situation for middle and high school English teachers, or anyone who teaches a writing- centric course for that matter.</p><p>You might have to squint a bit for the good news, but why not start there?</p><p>If you’re a teacher, ChatGPT isn’t going to take your job. Cold comfort, perhaps, but a comfort nonetheless, and one that is, at least per the current spate of debatably accurate media headlines, not necessarily true for other similarly educated white collar workers.</p><p>It’s true though. ChatGPT isn’t about to stand up in front of your classroom or sit next to your students and help them learn anything. It won’t make accommodations for diverse learning needs and it won’t design tight formative and summative assessments that reveal the intricate inner workings of adolescent brains and the progress those brains are making toward learning objectives.</p><p>You do all of those things better than any current general language model, and will do those things better than any language model for the foreseeable future.</p><p>So then, the bad news: unless you change your game up a little bit, you might have to read a bunch of tightly constructed, factually dubious, and utterly soulless paragraphs, essays, etc. composed by ChatGPT (or any other number of competitors that will almost certainly emerge now that the cat is out of the proverbial bag).</p><p>It’s already started. A simple Google search turns up the fact that hundreds of Stanford undergraduates used ChatGPT on their finals, that ChatGPT can now pass the bar / Ivy League MBA exams / Constitutional Law class exams / the US medical licensure exam / the eye test of old school baseball scouts who think it has a “good makeup” and projects well as a catcher at the MLB level although some favor a move to first base to preserve the knees and keep the bat in the lineup with more frequency.</p><p>The last one is made up, but for all the froth in the media surrounding this tool, can you really be sure that it is?</p><p>So now the questions start:</p><p>Where does that leave us, as an education community?</p><p>How should we be thinking about and then tackling the immediate issues that predictive language models will create in classrooms?</p><p>Just as importantly, how might we collectively imagine a world in which these tools, which will change the world largely in ways that we can’t yet imagine, can be usefully incorporated into curricula in a way that enhances student learning and builds fluency in these tools without damaging the core progress that we want students to make toward being better thinkers?</p><p>It’s probably worth starting here: I don’t think that reductive takes about general language AI models being the ‘new calculator’ are particularly helpful. This type of take tends to flatten the very real concerns of educators who are genuinely interested in making sure that students still learn the basic underlying mechanics of writing and, obviously more importantly, interested in helping students build the critical thinking skills that learning how to write helps to promote. It also provides a lazy sound bite for anyone who is trying to paint teachers as idiot Luddites who are afraid of the future. In general, this type of take largely ends up being used to signal the end of the conversation by indicating that there is no problem with the underlying technology and that the problem is instead with the teachers who don’t want to change. The venn diagram of people who will say this and those who want to talk about how teachers are too woke is probably uncomfortably close to being just a circle.</p><p>Still, I think there is at least one important framework that we can take from this analogy, and it’s one that doesn’t end the conversation but instead starts a conversation that could ultimately be really fruitful: Let’s consider predictive language models as a tool in the same way that calculators are a tool. How might this change writing instruction?</p><p>At this point, I’m going to avoid the rabbit holes that I would inevitably fall down on the pedagogical theory side of things but dropping down to where the rubber meets the road and getting into concrete instructional practices. On the practical side, what can you do in your classroom to not only avoid reading AI- generated essays but also enhance your student’s skills in writing, revising, and evaluating? I’ll start with things that many if not most teachers have their students do already and transition into new practices that ChatGPT might make possible. To be clear, this is not meant to be an exhaustive guide or the basis for a comprehensive curriculum that’s AI proof. Instead, I’m interested in exploring what options can emerge when you start to think of these models as a tool and then juxtapose that method of thinking with the practical realities of building out a classroom activity or lesson.</p><p>The Practice: Writing with pen and paper in the classroom</p><p>The Upside: The bane of so many math students for decades is likely set to make a roaring return to composition classrooms across the world: showing your work. Hilariously creative videos of 3D printers producing written work utilizing ChatGPT aside, this is always going to be one way to get students producing pieces of writing that can be assessed for evidence of learning.</p><p>The Downside: There are definitely downsides here. It’s a lot of paper to collect, track, grade, etc. particularly if you work in a school heavily reliant on technology. You’ll deal with terrible handwriting. You’re limited in terms of time and, as a result, it’s not easy to work through revisions, which is really where a lot of the real work of learning to write comes in.</p><p>The Verdict: This is a solid way to work on building blocks of good thinking and writing and is certainly worth considering for incorporation into your lesson planning if you don’t do it already. Thinking holistically about an entire year worth of curriculum, this would probably be a good place to start with a focus on the sentence and the paragraph level.</p><p>The Practice: Supporting an argument with specific evidence from sources chosen by the teacher.</p><p>The Upside: Essentially, this is currently something that ChatGPT cannot do, so even if you have your students working on a device or working outside the classroom, there’s going to need to be some thinking that takes place. Even if a student were to utilize a language model to provide some basic ideas or to write a draft of their essay, they would need to thoughtfully consider the ways in which to incorporate sources into that framework to support the arguments that ChatGPT provided. Which leads to…</p><p>The Downside: The ghost is back in the machine here, and you’re likely to end up with some AI assisted writing making its way across your desk.</p><p>The Verdict: It’s worth considering your learning objectives here. Is the goal to build a robust argument from scratch based on evidence in source material? If so, you might not be getting back an assessment that will allow you to evaluate progress toward that goal. That said, it’s worth considering the value of the type of skills that students might be building even if they are utilizing assistance from a language model to frame up their argument and do the work of providing a structure within which they can place their chosen evidence. If your goal of a specific lesson or unit is focused in this way, on choosing and incorporating evidence to support an argument, then this isn’t the end of the world. In fact, this practice might mirror how a person might use a language model tool in their everyday lives going forward to produce pieces of writing. This might be a watered down goal, but it’s not without value in terms of scaffolding up toward the useful skills that the practice of writing is meant to develop.</p><p>The Practice: Specifically instructing students to provide different prompts to a language model and then produce, for their assessment, a piece that compares the relative strength of the responses produced.</p><p>The Upside: With something like this, you’re actually pushing into the territory of considering how a language model can be used as a tool, which I think is the really worthwhile thing to consider here. On the practical side, this is again something that ChatGPT would struggle with, i.e. asking it to produce two different pieces of writing on the same topic and then produce a third piece of writing citing specific pieces of the two earlier pieces for the purpose of comparison of relative strength. This is also a pretty sophisticated level of analysis that you’d be asking your students to perform, pushing up to the analyze / evaluate level on Bloom’s taxonomy (although with the right scaffolding / tools being made available to students, one could build a lesson that plausibly engages at the “application” level).</p><p>The Downside: Because of the relatively high level of cognitive performance required (again, without careful construction of the lesson) you might find yourself painted into a corner. You’d typically find yourself pushing students to the analysis and evaluation after building out a strong base of skills that were built, in large part, through careful and rigorous writing instruction, and if you’re teaching composition at the middle school level, they’d be unlikely to be pushing that far up the taxonomy on your watch anyway.</p><p>The Verdict: This could very well be a workable structure for an assessment if the goal is tailored to match it. That said, I think the real value of thinking through something like this is what I mentioned above- the creative use of a tool like a predictive language model is going to be the best way to ensure that the tool won’t short circuit your efforts to teach and assess your students ability to think and write clearly.</p><p>I should close by mentioning that this entire piece was written by ChatGPT. Just kidding. But seriously, it was. (It wasn’t.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31539c197dc7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Two Separate But Related Questions: Will Hugh Freeze Get What He Deserves?]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/on-two-separate-but-related-questions-will-hugh-freeze-get-what-he-deserves-b9eb1dadf84b?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9eb1dadf84b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Dec 2022 05:12:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-02T14:49:43.252Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>On Two Separate But Related Questions: Will Hugh Freeze Get What He Deserves? Do We Deserve Hugh Freeze?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pMd-PBl_ODhO_pF9.png" /><figcaption>Just take it all in.</figcaption></figure><p>Hugh Freeze, in general, seems like a shitty person. To review why I might say this, he:</p><ul><li>Got canned from his job at Ole Miss after overseeing a program that <a href="https://www.si.com/college/2019/02/12/ole-miss-vacates-wins-ncaa-violations">committed a whole lot of NCAA recruiting violations</a> and <a href="https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2727789-hugh-freeze-called-escort-service-while-on-ole-miss-recruiting-trip">then, in a borderline hall of fame case of Being Horny Right Now, called an escort services from his work phone</a></li><li>Went to coach at Liberty where he DM’ed a sexual assault victim who was currently suing LU, writing, incredibly:</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/0*VDmSHYt0KpTGjmjj" /></figure><ul><li>Coached at a high school where he allegedly <a href="https://www.al.com/auburnfootball/2022/11/what-was-new-auburn-coach-hugh-freeze-accused-of-sexual-misconduct-personal-misconduct-allegations.html">forced a female student to change her shirt in front of him</a> and <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/ncaaf/2017/07/29/who-hugh-freeze-conflicting-views-former-ole-miss-coach-emerge/522705001/">paddled another female student, a punishment that was generally only available to the males enrolled at the school.</a></li><li>He’s done all this while remaining a, I don’t even know what you’d call it, stout evangelical Christian? Anyway, he tweets out Bible verses and talks about how God is good when he hosts press conferences after he gets fired and <a href="https://twitter.com/BudElliott3/status/1597430283951026176">tells recruits, when he’s about to fired, that he’s basically Jesus and his upcoming crucifixion / dismissal from Ole Miss will surely be as redemptive as the first go around</a></li></ul><p>I think probably more than I should, as an adult person with other more pressing concerns, about college football coaches. This is mostly because I am still a college football fan despite knowing better. They are, as a subclass of human beings, pretty relentlessly interesting to consider, I think because the pressures and incentives of the field tend to attract and then further warp a group of human beings that are already probably pretty warped to begin with.</p><p>You get <a href="https://www.barstoolsports.com/blog/359279/jim-harbaugh-is-a-psychopath-example-6-million-frank-beamers-orange-bowl-story">borderline psychopathic weirdos like Jim Harbaugh</a>, <a href="https://bamahammer.com/2017/01/16/lane-kiffin-speculated-legacy-joey-freshwater/">you get Joey Freshwater/ Lane Kiffin,</a> y<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQ3oXkDPKbM">ou get Mike Gundy who will forever be a man of 40 to me</a>, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nGAxZfzwcSw">you get Mike Leach who will reliably say shit like his players stink because they want to sit around with their fat girlfriends and drink lemonade</a>, you get whoever LSU currently happens to employ from the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MkncCVvRzM">grass eating Les Miles</a>, to t<a href="https://www.mediaite.com/sports/ed-orgeron-reportedly-hit-on-pregnant-wife-of-lsu-official/">he pregnancy-intrigued Ed Orgeron</a>, to the<a href="https://medium.com/@mike-mesterharm/notre-dame-will-change-you-if-you-let-it-the-freemanera-the-free-market-and-what-it-all-21f17838df02"> newly southern (?) and perhaps mentally broken Brian Kelly</a>. You might not be pleased that some of these guys are the highest paid employees on the respective state / university payrolls, but if you hold your nose and squint a little bit, maybe you can see the institutional logic that makes their employment at least partially defensible. A good football program ostensibly keeps donors happy and keeps money flowing in that makes all the other shit that universities at least on paper should be trying to do a little bit easier. A shit heel like Freeze is actually kind of borderline, which says a great deal about some of the other characters in the CFB dramatis personae. If you keep running your finger down the cast list then you eventually <a href="https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/33365146/the-line-art-briles-downfall-baylor-hire-grambling-state">get Art Briles</a>, you get <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penn_State_child_sex_abuse_scandal">Joe Paterno</a>, you get <a href="https://www.espn.com/college-football/columns/story?columnist=frei_terry&amp;id=1739319">Gary Barnett. </a>Basically you get to a non-trivial number of coaches who sure seem to have actively damaged people’s lives in ways that perhaps don’t feel as inexplicable if you take a minute to think about the system and incentive structure that gives both shape and employment to these guys.</p><p>Because that’s the thing. Huge Freeze is who he is and has never really tried to be anything else, mostly because he has never had to. The system that we’ve built to hold all of this dumb shit that permeates our collective consciousness on fall Saturdays creates absolutely no incentive for assholes like Freeze to be anything else. The utterly bullshit and borderline hilarious statement that Auburn put out at his hiring rings true when considering Hugh Freeze the man as well as <a href="https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/35132793/freeze-agrees-next-coach-auburn-sources-say">Hugh Freeze the End Product of the Thoughtful, Thorough, and Well-Vetted Coaching Search.</a> Of the latter, Auburn AD John Cohen had this to say: “We ended where we started, with Huge Freeze.” Of the former, this statement also almost certainly applies. In the end, of course, you end up becoming yourself, and never in Hugh Freeze the man’s evident professional arc or personal life has he ever appeared to be interested in becoming anything other than the assbag we see before us now. Frankly speaking, why would he? He was/is a self-righteous dickhead whose evident abilities to do jobs that matter to people who write checks to institutions were, perhaps now even more in retrospect, ALWAYS going to allow him to land on his feet. He managed this at Liberty and then he simply bided his time until he won the game of chicken that he was playing collectively with every SEC school that might have an interest in hiring a coach that’s beaten Nick Saban twice. Still, in this game of chicken he won by achieving an ending where the two deserving parties unceremoniously, hideously, crash into each other to the horror of most anyone looking on. The honor of taking part in this particular institutional car crash obviously went to Auburn.</p><p>So here’s the weird questions that I’ve found myself asking. Am I mad at Hugh Freeze because of the various shitty things that he’s done and the success (in getting hired, at least) that he’s enjoyed despite them? Are you mad at Hugh Freeze?</p><p>I’ve almost been surprised by my answer, which is, not really. I guess I feel a vague sense of abstract resentment that he is the way he is. I even feel a general sadness that people that do what he has done choose to do what they do and that they frequently get away with it. Still, as I’ve pondered this, I’ve also found myself contemplating a related question: Will Hugh Freeze ever get what he deserves? Unless you feel like he deserves three to five mediocre seasons featuring three to five losses to the Crimson Tide and then a big buyout (or perhaps some other minor variation on this theme) then the reality is probably going to disappoint you. The sad part is that this is probably the closest Freeze will come to getting what his caliber of human would generally be due. The scarier option is that he has a few good seasons and secures an extension that will make his buyout even larger once the all-powerful Auburn boosters get tired of the kind of waning focus that saw Liberty close out the season with a loss to a New Mexico state team that came into their tilt with a 4–6 record that wasn’t as impressive as it looked.</p><p>So no, I’m not particularly angry at Hugh Freeze the man, and unfortunately I’m not particularly sure that he’ll end up with an ending befitting the type of man he definitely seems to be. He is, in the end, unlikely to get what he deserves. That said, I think the more interesting question is, do we deserve Hugh Freeze? Do we, collectively, bear the blame for the level of institutional rot, corruption, and hypocrisy that make Hugh Freeze (and Art Briles, and Joe Paterno) possible? My answer here also kind of surprised me, which is that yes, I think, we do. Not me, necessarily, certainly not you, personally, and certainly not the groups of people (women and young boys who were sexually assaulted, athletes (largely athletes of color) who for decades went uncompensated for the enormous value they provided to the collegiate athletics industrial complex) who represent the collateral damage of a system that values wins on a field over human dignity. We don’t individually deserve this, but collectively, we do. We allow this system to persist. We tune in every Saturday. We buy the tickets and the merch. We elect the politicians that have such a heavy vested interest in the status quo that they won’t ever do anything to undermine the authority of the <a href="https://www.lawinsport.com/topics/item/the-ncaa-college-basketball-bribery-scandal-the-scheme-that-continues-to-shake-collegiate-sports">hilariously</a> <a href="https://www.cbssports.com/college-basketball/news/ncaa-head-of-enforcement-is-frustrated-and-disappointed-most-bribery-and-corruption-cases-are-still-ongoing/">corrupt</a> and <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/college/columnist/dan-wolken/2022/03/31/ncaa-mark-emmert-no-clue-solve-myriad-problems/7238781001/">incompetent</a> NCAA. I honestly don’t know where to begin dismantling a system this large, but if this episode has taught me anything, again, it’s that if things stay the way they are, we’re going to end up where we started. With Hugh Freeze.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9eb1dadf84b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Who is this supposed to be for?”]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/who-is-this-supposed-to-be-for-a5ccecca8914?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a5ccecca8914</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fundraising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[notre-dame-fighting-irish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chicago-cubs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Jul 2022 00:55:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-17T20:29:40.234Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“Who is this supposed to be for?” Crappy Baseball, Weaponized Nostalgia, and the Market Eating Everything</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/797/1*phhl8s0c_9GW9uyJCwit1g.png" /><figcaption>Go Cubs Go</figcaption></figure><p>I used to think that the Chicago Cubs were for me, in the general sense.</p><p>When you are eight or nine, and you have long summer days to pass, and there is a baseball team whose games come on in the early afternoon, not on cable but over the air, to the TV in your parents room, where you can at least feel some of the cold air blowing through the upstairs window AC unit, then you can easily believe that the team is playing for you.</p><p>My first time at Wrigley Field was a quasi-religious experience. It felt surreal to be walking through the living museum of the game that I had grown up watching in 15 diagonal inches of pixelated broadcast-grade glory. It was easy to feel that same thing then, as I took it all in, that all of this was somehow, at least a little bit, there for me.</p><p>When the Cubs won their first World Series in more than a century, I sat tearing up on the couch of one of my oldest friends, and I thought about those endless summer afternoons spent propped up on my elbows <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TiO-6VmDRk">watching Steve Trachsel</a> or whoever else getting shelled in a meaningless early August game, and I thought about how somehow, even after all these years, it still felt like some piece of this was for me.</p><p>By then I kind of knew it wasn’t really, but it could still feel that way.</p><p>By that 2016 season the Rickett’s ownership group and their affiliates had started to overlay Wrigley and the surrounding area with kind of “Disney’s Main Street USA but paved down the middle of the Uncanny Valley” vibe, and honestly, when I go back to Wrigley these days, the phrase that echoes through my head is actually a quote from the first season of True Detective where Matthew McConahey’s Rust Cohle looks around at a broken down southern Louisiana moonscape and says,<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z113cALjgl0"> “It’s like somebody’s memory of a town. And the memory is fading.”</a></p><p>Wrigley and the bars and restaurants of Waveland and Addison today feel today like what someone in marketing thinks someone’s memories of Wrigley and Wrigleyville, what someone’s memories of baseball, should feel like, but the memories are fading. To walk through Wrigleville today is to feel like you’re walking through a simulation generated by an AI that was fed thousands and thousands of images of theme parks, baseball stadiums, and slickly produced exhibit booths you might see at a pharmaceutical or software conference. The pieces are all there, but there’s something else there too, something that’s tough to put your finger on.</p><p>Now, let’s be clear- I will still go to Cubs games whenever I can. I will sit in whatever seats are offered to me or that I can afford a few times a year, and I will buy a few very expensive Old Styles and maybe a few marginally more expensive craft beers over the course of the game, and I will drink them, and I laugh with my friends that I came with and I will cheer for the Cubs. I will, by and large, have a good time.</p><p>Still, when I do this, my experience is no longer the quasi-religious experience I had all those years ago the first time I took in the ivy covered outfield walls, my smallness and frailty in the presence of a timeless institution of this great country laid bare by my novel proximity to one of it’s great cathedrals. I no longer stand in awe, my soul immersed in a history that offers to help me understand myself and the world a little bit better.</p><p>Instead, now I go because I like the Cubs and I like baseball and I still have my own warm and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYzLhljyMzA">fuzzy memories of Glenallen Hill absolutely obliterating the ball on some of Ernie Els-grade easy swings.</a> I tolerate the fact that my Cubs baseball experience at least pretends to really be about me and my enjoyment of the game, that this facsimile of someone’s memory of what baseball games should be like is presented to me in lieu of any kind of authentic opportunity to connect to the game. This is done because if the experience is not carefully designed and curated then it is all the more difficult to capture, analyze, and later monetize.</p><p>My love of the game is often enough, and the Old Style, and the laughs with my friends are mostly enough to obscure the fact that this threadbare amalgamation of what dozens of focus groups of people said a baseball game should feel like actually only barely conceals the fact that now the game, and my enjoyment of it, are now just data points in the new and most important relationship of our modern times. This is, of course, the relationship between my money and the marketing folks, the relationship in which I exist not as a party but instead as a medium that must be manipulated appropriately so that the former can pass through me from its current location, my pockets, into its rightful location in the coffers of the latter.</p><p>When I used to tune into WGN all those summer days and watch Karl Rhodes softly ground into a fielder’s choice, it felt like it was me and the Cubs, like there was a kind of visceral connection between me and a baseball team, as well as the broader community that this connection created. To be clear, I know this was not strictly the case. WGN did not get the rights to those games for free. The Tribune Company certainly wanted to make money from their ownership of the team. Also to be clear, I do not think that anyone who owns a professional sports team should be obligated to lose money running it.</p><p>Still now, when I watch the Cubs’ bullpen collapse or maybe even scratch out a win these days, it’s honestly pretty obvious that the experience is a mediated one. I am not simply watching the Cubs win or lose, I am being watched as I watch the Cubs win or lose, and the person watching me is determining the likelihood that the outcome on the field will affect the ability of the organization to entice me to pay more money in the future, or is determining whether or not I will continue to pay attention to the team which will affect their ability to sell my attention (as I watch the Cubs win or lose) to someone else who is weighing whether or not whatever they pay for my attention is likely to yield the net benefit of me opening my wallet to purchase whatever it is they are going to try and insert into my attention span.</p><p>This relationship, the one between the watcher and my money and attention, is actually the central one to this whole enterprise. To make me more engaged and to make my valuable attention more readily available to their buyers, it’s in the best interest of the marketing folks to create a shared consensus memory of what baseball should feel like that will be both frictionless and broadly appealing even if that broad appeal makes it at the same time slightly uncanny to me as an individual. Keep in mind, in this relationship my dollars are indistinguishable from anyone else’s, and so my relevance to the team is only important insofar as anything that might drive me and my money/attention away from the team does not somehow replace me with either more money or someone else with more valuable attention to sell to advertisers. I might not like seeing “Gallagher” painted on the infield turf, but I will allow you to guess where the profit-making calculus lands on that particular question of stadium aesthetics.</p><p>As a fun bonus, as many owners have discovered, this broad appeal can be created without really any need for spending money on assets that actually allow you to win baseball games. In fact, the need for a winning baseball team can actually be completely incidental to packaging and selling my attention, and because you are part of a legal monopoly wherein you and your pals/nominal competitors actually share a bunch of the revenue that you generate, you can make money even if no one wants to buy the non-existent attention of your non-existent fan base that you’ve driven away through years and years of management practices designed to minimize expenses at the expense of everything else.</p><p>So maybe I wasn’t actually wrong in my feelings about the game during those long summer days of the early to mid 90s. Maybe the game actually was for me. At one point, the central relationship might actually have realistically been between me and the team, because under a previously accepted prevailing logic, that might have been the relationship that was the attention-based asset that could then be flipped to WGN who could then flip to advertisers who might have an interest in knowing that a 10 year old was likely to be watching the Cubs at 2pm on a Tuesday during late July. The better the team, the more the owners invested, the more likely that I would keep watching, and so incentives were at least partially aligned around this central relationship.</p><p>No longer.</p><p>Again, I am now just something of a pliable medium which can be manipulated, through a variety of priming mechanisms and triggers (only some of which might relate to winning baseball games) to part with the most important and valuable of my constituent pieces: my money and my attention (which can be sold for additional money). This new central relationship is grounded seemingly only by coincidence within the trappings of modern major league baseball.</p><p>In one final, deeply late-capitalist touch, the value of the baseball team is not even necessarily all that dependent on how good the team performs or even how much money you can cleverly extricate from the pockets of fans. Instead, as with other disquieting areas of modern life, your Major League Baseball franchise is mostly just worth what someone else will pay for it. Rather than even concerning yourself with current cashflows and organizational performance, if you can just hold onto the team for a decade without pissing off the other owners enough, you can just sell your team later for windfall levels of profit.</p><p>It all feels like someone’s memory of baseball. But the memory is fading.</p><p>As I acknowledge above though, the Cubs and Major League Baseball are ultimately for profit enterprises. While it certainly sucks that rich assholes get to exploit federal antitrust exemptions and degrade unique American cultural institutions in their pursuit of more and more money, it also feels difficult to carve out the shitty feeling that this causes from the kind of more diffuse shitty feeling that seems to have pervaded across most of American civic life at this exact moment. Maybe it’s because I was born in the 1980s and have never known a time when corporate power was meaningfully reined in, but I ultimately have kind of a tough time imagining a world in which we ever have the political will to meaningfully make any changes to our system of rich people doing rich people shit in a social space that is pretty unapologetically dedicated to rich people doing rich people shit. I can be bummed that the market has eaten everything while also acknowledging that this really feels kind of part and parcel of a broader American brokenness, and that within this broader context, this might be kind of low on the list of problems that this larger brokenness is causing for people every day.</p><p>There are certainly arguments to be made for the inherent wrongness of the ways in which the structure of the modern MLB shares important features of both OPEC and a Ponzi scheme, and rereading the previous paragraph, I probably should get more pissed off about rich people abusing an antitrust exemption in order to amass ever greater fortunes. Still, I just don’t necessarily think I’m the guy to make that argument, at least not now, because I’m still sitting here, months after the fact, basking in the glow of an outrageously joyous and incredibly powerful Notre Dame Day Experience.</p><p>That’s right, folks. In this, our time of discontent, of social malaise that runs both deep and broad, I want to take the time to acknowledge how incredibly lucky we are to have, scattered across the American civic landscape, the shining beacons of hope that can only be kept lit by the beauty and magic of a major research university Day of Giving.</p><p>I will now extract my tongue from my cheek where it usually stays planted when discussing this because unlike past years, I’m not actually super interested in making jokes. As much as I’ve enjoyed jagging Father Jenkins for holding two Notre Dame days in a seven months span during a pandemic or engaging in some light reimagining of 1984 featuring the Notre Dame Administration as a cheerier version of Big Brother, this year I had COVID during the run up to Notre Dame Day and was sick enough that I couldn’t dedicate my usual effort to coming up with any material. In the afterglow/aftermath of the day itself, jokes just don’t seem like they’ll do this trick this go around. I even wrote most of this piece and then sat on it for a few months, no sure exactly where I wanted it to go. Ultimately though, I think I want to seriously and soberly consider what it is about #NDDay that just kind of bums me out. I want to explore why this ostensible celebration of all things Irish actually just kind of feels to me like some focus-grouped imaginary memory of what makes Notre Dame a worthwhile institution.</p><p>I also want to come right out and state my very real affection and support for the hardworking fundraising staff at nonprofits around the country, including in big university fundraising shops, who bust their asses to find creative and engaging ways to get people thinking about spending their hard earned dollars not on something for themselves right now or on an appreciating asset that will benefit them later, but on something right now for someone else that they likely do not even know. It is a brutally difficult job and the people who do it very much tend to do it for all of the right reasons.</p><p>It’s also worth giving something of a mea culpa here because I am a former fundraiser and I need to admit that I have done the following: started days of giving at institutions that previously did not employ them and worked at a software company where one of my main contributions was pushing our nonprofit fundraising platform toward making days of giving a readily available, affordable, and easily workable solution for our clients.</p><p>Basically I want to make clear up front that I get it:</p><p>I get that a day of giving is an effective mechanism for driving participation from those who might otherwise not be drawn in by your fundraising efforts.</p><p>I understand that it’s also an effective means to gather data about your donors and their particular attachment to any number of an expansive subset of affinity groups within your broader base of support.</p><p>I understand that data can then make your subsequent engagement efforts more relevant for that donor and, ostensibly, more authentic.</p><p>It makes sense that it’s likely to activate the portion of your donor base that might ever make a gift while those who gripe about it are significantly less likely to make a gift whether or not you tick them off with a Notre Dame Day flurry of emails.</p><p>I get that everyone else is doing it and that if you don’t do one now, your boss is going to come into work and say “Hey, I saw…” and then you’ll be doing one anyway.</p><p>I get that programmatic budgets, as a rule, do not shrink and that revenue streams, as a rule, do not grow without some additional tricks being added into the proverbial mix.</p><p>I understand that there are external bodies that request access to metrics that a university day of giving may help to enhance, namely young alumni giving percentage, and that these metrics are important for enhancing the reputation of a university, which, arguably, improves the ability of the institution to perform its mission.</p><p>So if I know all this, then what’s the big deal? What sticks in my craw so much about a major university hosting a day of giving?</p><p>I think ultimately what emerges for me is a question that I heard from at least a half dozen people when ND Day 2022 rolled around. See, at least with baseball, even if there is a kind of weird, waxy feel to the whole affair, there is at least some kind of core link to the central conceit that baseball, and all sport, is for the fans. Even if the memory is fading, the whole affair benefits from that historical heft. With something like a university day of giving though, a truly modern invention, it ends up being the case that there isn’t really an answer to the question that I kept finding myself asking:</p><p>“Who is this supposed to be for?”</p><p>For the few reading this piece who might be unfamiliar with my background and history with ND, I do want to point out that I am very much a fan of Notre Dame and I have a long history with the University. Three degrees from the place, two years on staff selling the school to prospective undergraduate applicants, met my wife there, baptised our first child in the log chapel, talk to my friends from ND on a daily basis, etc. I credit Notre Dame and the communities in which it allowed me to embed myself with making me the person that I am today across every dimension of my being: moral, spiritual, intellectual, etc. Probably 30% of my clothing has the ND logo on it. Hilariously, my toddler son refers to any logo that he sees as “a Notre Dame.” I follow ND sports and I weep openly at the grotto every time I read Tom Dooley’s letter at the grotto when he wrote, “I have monstrous phantoms . . . as all men do. But I try to exorcise them with all the fury of the middle ages. And inside and outside the wind blows.” And so on, and so on.</p><p>I highlight all of that mostly to point out that if there is someone who might come to mind as a good audience for Notre Dame Day, that person might have a profile a lot like mine. Instead, every year, the school manages to completely alienate me through the use of approximately one million emails and spammy social media posts, none of which seem to do anything other than offer me assurance that Notre Dame Day is really a joyous and happy occasion without actually offering anything to me that demonstrates the presence of real joy or happiness.</p><p>It kind of makes me feel like a crazy person.</p><p>The general idea seems to be that if you write an email campaign and shoot enough video content containing a sufficiently high concentration of buzzwords (impact, joy, excitement, students) that these buzzwords will then, through some kind of reality-bending capillary effect, bleed over into the real world and create a true and meaningful experience for folks.</p><p>I think what bothers me the most is that I feel almost like I’m being robbed of what was and maybe still can be a joyful connection to a place. I have such a tremendous affinity for the school, but now my every interaction with the institution is mediated, a layer placed between me and the things that I loved and still feel at least something of a connection too. I understand that being a nonprofit institution does not magically grant the university the ability operate at a loss, and I understand that the development office performs a great deal of important work to make sure that the school can remain, in the founding vision of Father Sorin, “one of the most powerful means for good in this country.” But when my only connection to the school starts to feel largely extractionary, when my interactions with anything Notre Dame start to feel like they’re being monitored so that some day I might get an email from a red-headed former Irish dancer who is now a manager at South Dining Hall asking me to support the scholarship fund that made my own Notre Dame education a possibility, it’s difficult to not feel at least a little bit more disconnected. At the end of the day, it feels like it’s becoming increasingly obvious who all of this is for.</p><p>In the same way that the central relationship to the sports ecosystem is no longer between me and my favorite team but instead between that team’s marketing department and my money, Notre Dame Day is not actually for me or for most members of the Notre Dame community in any kind of obvious or even potentially meaningful way. Instead, Notre Dame Day is for the person watching me interact with Notre Dame Day, and it is about the information that they will gain from that watching, and the ways in which they will use that data to improve their ability to raise more money from me or others like me in the future. Even though I have immense sympathy for the the ultimate aims of the people who work very hard to get my money, I also am not a huge fan of feeling like a bank account where the university tries to hack my PIN which is made up of the right sequence of digital heart string tugs based on my existing relationships to the place. I don’t like feeling like I’m being attacked with weaponized nostalgia mined from my own institutional relationships and hurled back at me with borderline disturbing cheerfulness.</p><p>I think this is why ND Day feels, to me, not like any kind of genuine celebration of my alma mater but instead like someone’s hollow idea of what a celebration of Notre Dame might look like. It’s like someone’s memory of what has made the university great, but the memory is fading.</p><p>I think the other, broader concern that I have is that large universities like Notre Dame cast long shadows and their organizational behaviors are not without downstream effects. Essentially, <a href="https://www.onecause.com/blog/giving-day-planning-guide/">these school’s fundraising practices quickly disseminate through the space and become standard practice</a>, and suddenly, almost a decade after the first Notre Dame Day, I can search my email inbox for the last twelve months and see literally dozens of invites to celebrate days of giving with a variety of organizations. I want to call out my own hypocrisy here one more time as a person who has both implemented days of giving and sold software that helped people implement days of giving, but I can’t deny the overall effect of these practices becoming more widely spread: an enormously degraded donor experience.</p><p>It makes me question if for smaller organizations without a university’s massive non-fundraising cashflows to underwrite development activities and without a university’s durable brand, are they burning through goodwill faster than they can raise money that will allow them to do programming that will allow them to build that goodwill back up? <a href="https://www.philanthropy.com/newsletter/fundraising-update/2022-07-13">Does the broader crisis that we’re seeing in generosity</a> have something to do with the fact that brute force engagement tactics like Notre Dame Day now pervade our digital (that is to say, everyday) lives in a way that a<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jerry_Lewis_MDA_Labor_Day_Telethon"> Jerry Lee Lewis telethon never could </a>and are just turning everyone off? If we, broadly speaking, are unwilling to entertain the idea that the answer to any institutional question can be rooted in non-market logic or have a purpose other than bringing in more money, is it even possible to build relationships that won’t feel at least partially extractive and kind of gross?</p><p>I don’t have a great way to close this out. I wish I did. Maybe what I said earlier applies here as well. Perhaps my desiccated sense of the possible just doesn’t have the space to accommodate a vision of the world where the market doesn’t eat everything or where Notre Dame or any other university could imagine a future for itself that didn’t require the need for expanding budgets and explosive growth, a future where there might be space for me to connect to the place without some genius, recent-graduate data analyst looking over my digital shoulder to parse me and my love for the place into so many data points.</p><p>But then again, I don’t think I would have had the energy to write all this if I wasn’t at least a little bit hopeful, and I think the root of that hope lies in something that I mentioned already: my faith in the good hearts and clever minds of the people who go into fundraising.</p><p>Maybe the solution starts with the right question, asked in the right meeting, by the right people. Maybe someday, someone will take a look at a project plan for the latest multi-channel assault on my attention span and have the courage to ask:</p><p>“Who is this supposed to be for?”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a5ccecca8914" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“I Wanted an Ape That Reminded Me of Me”: NFTs, Depression, and the Price (and Worth) of Everything]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/nfts-depression-and-the-price-and-worth-of-everything-5906be428baf?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5906be428baf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nft]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Mar 2022 15:42:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-18T16:04:35.518Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/0*4QQolmtDTCRyULyk.jpg" /><figcaption>I wanted an ape that reminded me of me. Image captured from the Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon.</figcaption></figure><p>In the current pantheon of late night television talk show hosts, I rank Jimmy Fallon significantly ahead of James Corden and slightly behind everyone else. As I’ve aged and the deep weirdness/borderline punk rock sensibility that <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YLJtiU7m9Q8">Craig Ferguson</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GS39vMhag-A">Conan O’Brien</a> brought to the mix on a nightly basis fade further into the mists of memory from my college years, the late night crew has become a mostly densely packed group (Corden excepted) of which Fallon is the least palatable, but who is still alright enough at his job that, if the remote is far away and I’m particularly tired, I won’t work too hard to change the channel. I might even laugh at some of his jokes,<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmSN8U_3gNw"> although not as hard as he is liable to.</a></p><p>That said, the last few weeks I’ve been thinking by far the most about Fallon versus any of the other late night hosts, which I supposed means he’s doing his job. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zi12wrh5So&amp;t=220s">Specifically I’ve been haunted by a clip that I stumbled across on YouTube the week after it aired</a>. In it, Fallon interviews Paris Hilton who, the previous fall, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oiN1_6pb_eE&amp;t">had been on his show to hawk a documentary series about her wedding and to introduce Jimmy to the idea of non-fungible tokens, or NFTs.</a> She returned, newly married, in January to complete the obvious arc and to discuss with Jimmy the pair of NFT apes that they had each purchased (<a href="https://www.thegamer.com/jimmy-fallons-paris-hilton-nft/">likely for more than $200k each</a>). To close out the already odd interview, she awkwardly declared that she was gifting him an NFT of <a href="https://s1.cdn.autoevolution.com/images/news/gallery/paris-hilton-hosts-first-televised-nft-giveaway-writes-awkward-history_4.jpg">a collage that she made about her new husband</a>, and she then even more awkwardly announced that she was giving one to every member of the audience, an audience who then waited an extremely telling beat before (presumably) realizing that the applause sign was illuminated and proceeding to reach an extremely diluted level of wild.</p><p>The whole thing is just kind of uncanny.</p><p>Breaking the weirdness down to its constituent parts might lessen the overall effect, but there are a few highlights worth mentioning:</p><ol><li>Hilton says that she wanted an ape that reminds her of herself. She then says “but…” as if to pivot before saying, “This one does.” To reiterate, she says: “I wanted to buy an ape that reminded me of myself, but this [ape that I purchased] does.” For the record, the image in question is a cartoon primate wearing a leather hat.</li><li>Fallon follows up by saying that he also wanted an ape that reminded him of himself. To explain further, he says that, among other things, he also likes striped shirts, he sometimes wears sunglasses “as a joke,” and he “likes being breezy.” The awkwardness is palpable. The audience seems to be as confused as I am every single time I watch it.</li></ol><p>Seriously, what the fuck are they talking about? If I had to describe NFTs to someone even more confused than me, I would do so in two steps. The first layer is getting some intuitive sense of the blockchain technology that underpins the claims of ownership associated with digital assets. NFTs then sit on top of this</p><p>Imagine that you own a safe deposit box at a bank. The bank keeps a record of the fact that you own this safe deposit box, as well as a record of how much money is inside. This record is kept in a ledger book that the bank keeps.The box also has a window into it, and as long as someone knows which box is yours, they can actually just look right in and see what’s in your box. You alone have the key to this box, which provides the first layer of security: as long as you keep your key to yourself, no one else can access the box directly. This prevents someone from breaking into the box, and it is very secure, provided that you keep your key safe.</p><p>But stealing is only one way that someone might steal your asset- what if someone broke into the bank and changed the bank’s records to show that they were actually the owner of your box? The second layer of security that mitigates this threat is actually in the ledger book that records your ownership. Now, imagine that this ledger isn’t just stored at the bank. Instead, it is stored in a series of ledger books all across the world, and that in order to transfer your safe deposit box and it’s contents to someone else, every ledger in the world would need to receive a confirmation from you that not only confirms that you wish to transfer your asset but also that this transfer is occurring at exactly the same time and in exactly the same way in each ledger, an unbroken chain that, when corroborated across all the participating ledgers, proves that no tampering took place and that you indeed want to transfer ownership of this asset. This ensures that if someone were to gain access to one of the ledger books and then try to alter it and claim that your box was actually theirs, the other books could be used to prove them wrong. Your assets will remain in their safe deposit boxes until you opt to transfer them to someone else and when you do, this “block” of information regarding the new owner will be added to the long “chain” of information stored in these ledger books across the world.</p><p>The second portion of the explanation is what differentiates NFTs from other fungible digital assets that might use the blockchain, i.e. cryptocurrencies. With cryptocurrencies, you can, at any given point, use any search engine you like to look up the current exchange rate for your digital currency in just about any denominated currency in the world. You can then exchange your digital asset for this amount of money (again, generally speaking). As I’m writing this, I just looked up that Bitcoin is currently trading at $42,120.50 and up almost 8% today. Volatility aside, you can always be aware of what your asset is worth on the open market at least in part because your digital asset is fungible- one bitcoin is functionally the same as any other bitcoin and anyone looking to purchase a bitcoin for the going rate would just as gladly buy yours in exchange for currency (fiat or crypto) as buy anyone else’s. This fungibility is a key feature of anything that might be considered money.</p><p>My “volatility aside” comment above does a lot of heavy lifting- <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00181-020-01990-5">volatility in the “crypto to fiat” markets remains a prominent obstacle to any adoption as a viable currency.</a> Still, at least the interchangeability of one BTC for another provides ease of exchange. With NFTs, this type of exchange is by definition not possible- each NFT is unique and different from any other. Your free version of Paris Hilton’s collage that you got from being in the audience at the Tonight Show is “different” from<a href="https://www.nft-stats.com/collection/my-forever-fairytale-by-paris-hilton"> the one that I might someday purchase on OpenSea.</a> Still, we haven’t even touched on what strikes me as the most problematic feature of NFTs, which is that the digital blockchain ledger that records the ownership of these assets does not actually contain the image itself, but instead contains a hyperlink that points to the image, which is also readily and easily copied by anyone who would like to use it. Still, <a href="https://www.lamag.com/article/nft-law-copyright/">questionable definitions of which kind of “ownership” is actually conveyed by the blockchain aside,</a> the deep abstraction of the whole market drives us ever closer to what seems to be the ecstatic culmination of market thinking, the end of the line as the market slowly creeps into every single aspect of our lives and we have prices assigned to even those things we can only possess in the most bizarre and abstracted sense of the word. It’s like we have finally reached the point where every single piece of this world we occupy and the digital world that we’ve created has an inherent worth that can be measured exactly and immediately evaluated, a single quantitative metric that the market is always willing and able to provide. Everything is worth what someone else is willing to pay for it on the open market.</p><p>I’m at least a little bit perturbed by the idea that worth can be distilled down to one number, or perhaps more accurately perturbed by the question of whether or not it should be. As I move through each successive step of the valuation process wherein every possible type of utility that person could attain from anything gets distilled with a finer and finer grain, each step can make sense, but eventually when I zoom back out I wind up wondering why I’m agreeing that a monkey with a stripe shirt that likes to keep it breezy is somehow worth more than what I paid for my entire undergraduate degree or why it is worth more more than a one bedroom condo in a small to mid-sized US city. We’ve taken the final leap and completely severed the end of a value chain from anything remotely physical. It is making me feel insane.</p><p>What the fuck are we talking about? Have we broken our brains? I think maybe we have, but then again my brain is already broken.</p><p>Let’s start again from somewhere else and work our way back in.</p><p>Think about the last time that you were nauseous. Think about it now, about how the feeling was maybe in your stomach but also in your head, maybe diffusing down into your fingers and toes somehow. You knew that this feeling was bad. You did not ever need to learn this fact, did not need to discover the inherent badness of it. You’ve known it from the very beginning, from the first time you felt it to the last time that you were imagining just now, know it in some part of yourself that you don’t ever need to think about, in some core area of your physical body and then consequently in some part of your mental construction of yourself.</p><p>There are many things that we know in this way, in a way so visceral that it transcends that process of conscious thought, not because this knowledge is elevated but conversely because it is so base, so deeply wired into the pieces that construct the self. Our consciousness glides over the surfaces that these pieces make up. These surfaces, they are the well worn ground beneath our feet, the basis for all the other parts of our identities, the base upon which we build ourselves. We all contain knowledge that is so much a part of us that it barely has a name. Because of this deep-rootedness, this knowledge is not learned in any kind of meaningful sense, but more discovered, revealed to us in the due course of moving through our lives. We cast our gaze inward and we see who and what we already are, who and what we have always been. Using two different senses of the same word, this unlearned knowledge can never be unlearned. If one must encounter nausea as part of their regular and everyday life, say as part of a chronic illness or as a side effect of a necessary medication, perhaps one can construct a mental infrastructure that might make the experience more tolerable, but it will not make the nausea into a pleasant or even neutral experience. Our conscious selves can only do so much in the face of the immense weight of such ancient, bodily awareness.</p><p>In his oft quoted (at least by me)<a href="https://fs.blog/david-foster-wallace-this-is-water/"> commencement speech at Kenyon College in 2005,</a> the writer David Foster Wallace described this phenomena in a way that sticks with me. He begins with a joke about two fish swimming along who encounter an older fish who greets them and inquires, “How’s the water?” when one of them looks over at the other and goes “What the hell is water?” I come back to this frequently because it communicates one of the truths that I find most difficult to remember. It reminds me of the fact that, as Wallace put it, “the most obvious, important realities are often the ones that are hardest to see and talk about.” I know for me that certain pieces of this deep knowledge feel so obvious that they even escape my notice as being “knowledge” and instead feel like something more essential and thus fading into the background like the baseline hum of the energy of the universe. It can be difficult to realize and even more difficult to remember this knowledge that we possess so deep within our core.</p><p><a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/unwilled-inheritances-and-terrifying-passengers-on-depression-entropy-and-systemic-inequality-409f2b2f9a">I’ve written before about how it seems to me that the physical roots of my depression can be traced all the way down to the entropic forces that pull at the molecules that make up my body.</a> This disease is deeply rooted into my physical being and this is why I cannot consciously unlearn it. There is no cure for this essential bug in my system, my eternal and terrifying passenger. Acknowledging this essentiality is helpful in keeping me on my guard. And yet, I cannot always stay ahead of this invisible companion that I carry with me always.</p><p>Lately I’ve been thinking about notions of worth, and I think it’s because of what my essential bug weaves into my core personhood: I know, in the same way that I know that nausea is unpleasant, that I am worthless. In my core, I know that I lack inherent value. I want to be clear that I do not think I am worthless on any real conscious or cognitive level. I can consciously acknowledge that this is not the case in the same way that one might consciously train themselves to weather severe nausea caused by necessary or life saving medicine, but I cannot unlearn this fact, cannot remove my inherent sense of my lack of worth. I might not, and indeed do not, think that I am worthless in my mind. My brain knowledge is one thing. Instead, I know it somewhere deep and ancient within my heart. My body knowledge carries this “truth” with me always.</p><p>I also want to point out that considering whether or not this deep, bodily knowledge is “true” in any kind of real way immediately leads to incomprehensibility. What would it mean to say that it’s not “true” that nausea is unpleasant? Or that smiling is an expression of happiness? These pieces of knowledge are rooted directly in biology. They are “facts” in the sense that I cannot alter the ways in which I will always perceive them, chemical processes in my brain telling me I am nauseous and that it sucks, chemical processes telling me that I lack inherent worth. Medication, therapy, etc. these things can help prevent this body knowledge from creeping into the realm of brain knowledge where it might threaten my health and safety. They can help keep my terrifying passenger in check, but again, they are not a “cure.”</p><p>I think it’s also important to note that I write and share this publicly not seeking any reassurance that I am in fact worth something. Again, I do not cognitively believe it to be true that I am not. On most days, my conscious habits and deliberately formed cognitive patterns are sufficient to keep me in balance, but there’s something missing for me that makes me vulnerable to being knocked off balance unexpectedly. I think comedian Neal Brennan in his special “3 Mics” actually gave the most accurate description of mental illness, particularly mood disorders, that I’ve ever heard. It’s so accurate that the first time I heard it, I had to stop watching the special because I couldn’t stop crying. It was probably the first time in my remembered life when I didn’t feel an extremely specific and brutal type of loneliness. See I had known that I was sick for some time but it’s almost impossible to grasp that anyone else is feeling what you feel until you hear someone else fine the exact words for it. As I sat in my den watching Netflix by myself and I heard those words, I recognized the voice of someone else naming a core piece of myself for the first time. I was thirty years old. I wept and could not stop because someone else had found the words for what that I saw whenever I turned my gaze inward. As Brennan puts it:</p><blockquote>Like, to say I have low self-esteem is not true. I have no self-esteem. I don’t have the architecture for good feelings. You could give me a trophy, it will slide right down. I just don’t have the shelving.</blockquote><p>Like Brennan, I just don’t have the shelving. Yes, you can try and build your own shelving. Yes, you should do this. I do all the time, every day. You can do what I do and try to build it with therapy and journaling and antidepressants. But that shelving will always be built on a foundation that seemingly has an active interest in not supporting it. After a COVID quarantine that left my self-built shelving in shambles and had me rapidly spiraling back into the depths of my illness, I’ve been thinking about this core bug that still occasionally creeps from the realm of my body knowledge into my brain knowledge. I’ve been considering again how it can slowly eat away at the mental bulwarks that I seek to construct and maintain to keep myself secure. I’ve been thinking about how misguided notions of worth can change or threaten everything that we build on top of them.</p><p>I took my first economics class in high school and it was a revelation to my young brain. There it all was, the chaotic world explained in a series of elegant graphs, a grand theory that linked the individual decisions that we make every day up into the grand sweeps of history and geopolitics, and all of it explained by that purest form of human knowledge, mathematics. It was genuinely kind of intoxicating. I went on to study econ in college as well, and I continued to find solace in the clear and compelling logics that offered explanations of everything from <a href="https://www.nber.org/papers/w24355">birth rates in developed countries</a> to my own decision of <a href="https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w7322/w7322.pdf">where to attend college</a> to the<a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11127-013-0103-9"> decline of the Catholic Church</a> of which I was and still am a member. I also studied English literature, and when I got tired of feeling as if I was sliding across the face of a particularly complex work of fiction, there was a certain solace in the apparent anchoring effect of the numbers and charts that my economics classes provided in spades.</p><p>From my studies in economics, I either learned or came to recognize a few ideas that became deeply (or perhaps just more deeply) embedded into my thinking: my deeply rooted instinct that efficiency is always the most valuable end to be pursued, my sense that if you any problem can be solved scientifically if you can collect the right data and parse it the right way, the idea that every human decision can be broken down to the utility that a given person generates from the outcome of any decision, meaning you can directly compare the real value of two things as disparate as spending time at the bedside of a dying loved one and buying a new car. I think it’s this last one that has perhaps become embedded most deeply and I operate generally with these (and countless other ideas) as my baseline. The market really does eat everything, even in my own brain. I have this deeply rooted sense now that if someone is choosing option A over option B, it must be because on some level they are deriving a higher level of utility from choosing A than they would if they had chosen B. I like to think that I’m intellectually flexible enough and morally resolute enough to adapt my thinking in the face of compelling arguments to the contrary or when confronted with obvious ethical quandaries that emerge from the models of understanding that I build on these foundations, but your baseline is important.</p><p>Our starting point matters. We can only ever travel so far from it.</p><p>So what is anything worth? How can we evaluate the agreed-upon value of any two “things”? We can look at your choice between two alternatives to evaluate their value relatively. When you face a choice between two different ways to expend any resource, whether it’s time, energy, money, etc. you reveal both to yourself and to others what you really value and we are given a crystal clear understanding into which option gives you, as the economic decision maker, more utility. For example, do you:</p><ol><li>Make your car payment, or</li><li>fly to Florida to sit by the bedside of your grandmother during her last moments on earth as she lies dying of metastatic bone cancer in the hospice room she won’t ever leave alive</li></ol><p>Whichever option you choose clearly is the one that you prefer.</p><p>We can also evaluate them by how much they cost. For example, let your car payment costs be X while we let the cost of a last minute plane ticket be Y. Is X&gt;Y? Vice versa? We can quickly evaluate the worth of each option using money as a proxy for the utility that can be gained from each one. So by evaluating price, we can judge whether or not your car is more valuable than the time spent with your grandmother as she prepares to pass from this world into the next.</p><p>What the fuck are we talking about? Are either of these comparisons fair? They might credibly pass for fair if you don’t think about it too deeply or, more accurately, if you are not living through this decision making process. They are not fair, almost as a matter of course, when you are considering this scenario as a real human being or if you are living it out personally. This is why your baseline matters. Relative valuations feel obvious from the outside, even when closer examination of context reveals that any quick comparison between the two options will yield nothing in terms of deeper knowledge. Money is, at the end of the day, an apparently unbiased way of keeping score even when it should be obvious that there is not even a game being played. So I know this, and yet I still frequently find myself defaulting to monetary value as a kind of shorthand for worth, even when this kind of reductive view jeopardizes my own moral and mental fortitude.</p><p>Another story. I think about the value of my house a fair amount. I am passively subscribed to a few different websites that send me monthly estimates of how much my house is worth and so at least a few times per year I actually open one of these emails and then I think about how the value of the house has changed since we purchased it and what that might mean and how much equity we have now and what that might mean and how much we’ve invested in upgrades and repairs and what that might mean, and so on, and so on. Then I close the email and I just continue to live in my house in exactly the same fashion as I did before all that musing. If something breaks, we repair it. If it’s cold, we turn the heat up.</p><p>There are probably a few reasons why I remain subscribed to these emails that tell me the dollar value of my home despite it not really changing anything about how I live my life. The most pertinent is probably that I am endlessly fascinated by real estate. It tickles a certain part of my brain to keep an eye on how the real estate market is performing, what’s being built where, how housing stock is being maintained or repurposed in a given geographic area, why is the western world doing such a fucking terrible job maintaining a viable market for middle class people to purchase homes, etc. I think one of the things that I find fascinating about the housing market is that for all it’s various inefficiencies (and there are many), it still performs the most essential and basic function of a market: to distill all of the various types of utility that might be derived from the purchase of a piece of housing into one number. Although I mentioned before my ambivalence about this function, you cannot argue that, at least in one very important respect, at the end of the day, a house is worth what someone will pay for it. The market can always tell you what your house is worth.</p><p>We bought our house in December of 2020 after months of talking long walks mostly to see houses in our neighborhood. This all started largely as an activity to pass the time during the early days of the pandemic but as we considered growing our family and the logistics of getting two kids under 2 up and down the stairs to our third floor walk-up condo and as we tracked the trendline for prices in our neighborhood, it became clear that it would probably be in our best interest (both financial and logistical) to move earlier rather than later. We found our house and we loved it immediately. We closed on it shortly after we lost our second child in a miscarriage. The home we imagined filling with our growing family would stay a little emptier for at least a little longer. Was it worth less to us then, because one of the reasons that we wanted it had changed in dramatic and deeply unpleasant fashion?</p><p>It becomes readily apparent that while your house might be worth what someone else would pay for it, there are other factors at play that might determine it’s worth to you. The most important of these other factors is that we live in our house. Every day I come home to my house and then I spend time in it, eating dinner, reading books, brushing teeth, and so on and so on. Then I go to sleep, and the house largely keeps me warm and dry while I do these various activities. It has walls and doors that keep out cold wind and which, while I am at work, keep other people from coming and taking away other things that I own that I keep inside the house. It does these things largely independently of the value of the house as listed in my emails. If we do not take care of the house then eventually it will decrease in value, sure, but to pretend that there is some kind of tight relationship between what the house does for us on a daily basis and the worth of it per those emails that I receive would be dishonest.</p><p>All this to say that per these emails that I receive, my house has appreciated anywhere from 10–15% since we purchased it 14 months ago, which is quite a bit of money. This change in price almost entirely reflects changes in factors external to the house itself. These factors, per people who know more than I do, include things like: shifts in demand toward housing with more space to allow knowledge workers to work from home; increases in the appetite of institutional investors to buy up single family homes and carry them as part of a broader income-generating rental portfolio; a housing stock that has not managed to keep up with surging demand as the largest generation (the much maligned millennials) comes of house-buying age; housing policy that has de-emphasized the kind of high density urban environments which can generate economies of scale in housing stock; etc.</p><p>I say all of this to point out that my house does not perform the various housing related jobs that I ask of it on a daily basis 10–15% better than it did when we purchased it. The house might be worth a larger sum of money to some hypothetical buyer but to me, it is still worth the same thing, which is to say that it is worth a house, which is to say that it is very valuable. I enjoy living there and being kept warm and dry and having a place to put the other things I own such that they do not get taken by other people while I am at work. It is also very valuable because it is a place to spend a great deal of time with my family. Asking if that time is worth 10–15% more now that it was 14 months ago again pushes the question of valuation into red-lined incoherence.</p><p>So what’s my point? My house is worth a great deal to me because it is my house, but ultimately the market will also tell me that it is worth something else, some dollar value to someone else who might purchase it. This all seems fine, but as I said before, the market eats everything, and the same drive to insane abstraction that nearly toppled the housing market before hasn’t actually gone anywhere. Is my house doing anything 10–15% better now than it was 14 months ago? Is it worth any more or less to me? Or is this new valuation being pushed upward by the same drive for institutional returns that inflated demand for mortgages in the run up to the 2008 housing collapse and that has now moved on to seek its returns not from mortgage interest payments but from renters?</p><p>It is.</p><p>Has anyone asked if this is actually good?</p><p>Sure they have, but not anyone who is actually in a position to do much about it, it seems.</p><p>And so what then? What of our broken systems of valuation?</p><p>What then of the domestic debate over gas prices and the potential trade-off costs that place Ukrainian lives across from folks struggling to buy gas to pay for transportation to work that they need to feed their families?</p><p>And what then of the relative value of the life of a Palestinian woman killed by a rocket fired by a US ally onto the ancestral lands where her family has lived for literally centuries compared against the haunting image of a white, pregnant Ukrainian mother, killed by a rocket fired by a hostile international force into a maternity ward in a civilian hospital? Can we evaluate their relative worth by the news coverage they have received and further by the cost of producing that coverage?</p><p>And what then of NFTs, what of the digital collages of Paris Hilton’s husband and the jpeg images of monkeys who like keeping it breezy and who share Jimmy Fallon’s affinity for wearing heart-shaped sunglasses as a joke? Is it really possible that they are worth something?</p><p>I’m closing here with a lot of questions because this is certainly a case where I don’t have any answers, even after all this digital spilled ink. Mostly it seems to me that we haven’t actually learned our lesson. We’re apparently no closer to understanding that there is no real wisdom in the short term pressures, monetary and otherwise, that drive wild valuations that are seemingly completely decoupled from any other kind of value. I’m afraid, ultimately, that we all are making the same mistake that I still sometimes fall victim to, the same mistake that I worry constantly might be the thing that kills me: poisoning our ideas about ourselves and who we can and should be by building these gestalts on top of foundations which contain stunted or incomplete notions of worth. In the same way that I am perpetually impoverished by my own inability to ever fully integrate some notion of my own self worth into my worldview, I’m left wondering: have we all become impoverished by our own lack of moral imagination in the face of seductive, quantitative arguments about the relative worth of everything around us from the house we live in to the life of a human being thousands of miles away?</p><p>To put it another way, what the fuck we are actually talking about?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5906be428baf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Notre Dame Will Change You, If You Let It”: The #FreemanEra, the Free Market, and What It All…]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/notre-dame-will-change-you-if-you-let-it-the-freemanera-the-free-market-and-what-it-all-21f17838df02?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/21f17838df02</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[notre-dame]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[college-football]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Dec 2021 03:25:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-16T03:25:09.783Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“Notre Dame Will Change You, If You Let It”: The #FreemanEra, the Free Market, and What It All Costs</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eo67gsBJWx_Ylf5m2dIjvw.png" /><figcaption>If you have a positive feeling about the University of Notre Dame, but it doesn’t get effectively monetized, did you really feel it at all?</figcaption></figure><p>If you had asked me just a few weeks ago if there existed a series of possible events that, if triggered in the proper sequence, might make my beloved Notre Dame football seem to a broader national audience both sympathetic and maybe even cool, I would have said that no, this sequence of events did not exist in any kind of realistic potentiality.</p><p>Notre Dame football had reached what seemed to be something of the steady state that, if we were lucky, might persist for a few more years:</p><ul><li>averaging around 10 mostly fun wins with the occasional down year,</li><li>very strong but not necessarily world-beating recruiting classes, and</li><li>an occasional shot at the absolute top tier programs where we would likely be out-coached if not necessarily out-classed athletically, but</li><li>hey, we had a chance which was more than a lot of programs could say.</li></ul><p>I didn’t particularly love Brian Kelly as a coach or as the human being that he tended to come across as being, but he had at least mellowed considerably from the borderline insane <a href="https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/3WDHYR6-x3WmnyRC6GkV8nFRDHQ=/0x0:275x183/1720x0/filters:focal(0x0:275x183):format(webp):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/15992505/download.jpg">red-faced rants </a>of his early years at the Golden Dome. His players seemed to like him well enough to keep working hard and to not tell other top recruits to seek greener pastures elsewhere.</p><p>Perhaps crucially, I was also wisely learning to invest less and less of my own emotional well-bring into how effectively a group of 18 to 22 year old men performed a set of specific physical tasks on green rectangles in South Bend, Indiana and across the country. I was learning to enjoy the wins while not necessarily losing full Saturday’s to grumpy wallowing following the losses. These two trends, the Irish’s ascendancy to perennial decency and my own new found sanity as a sports fan, combined to make the last several years very enjoyable: for the first time in my life as an Irish fan, we were having FUN, for like, extended periods of time, having fun for SEASONS in a row. I think I was also tickled by the contrast of the present to my own time in school where I had been psychologically conditioned to accept miserable losses as simply part and parcel of the Irish Fan Experience. My classmates and I saw more losses during our four years than any other class at Notre Dame to that point (although we would eventually get passed by the classes after us.)</p><p>The fun had continued this season- one loss to a Cincinnati team that beat everyone else they played and a late season resurgence by both Jack Coan and the Marcus Freeman coached defense had us poised to potentially back-door our way into the playoff or, more likely, to get a slightly more winnable match up in a different New Year’s Six bowl. This was good and fun! After some stressful wins early in the season, the last five games of the season were actually relaxing to watch as the Irish cruised across the finish line. This really seemed like our best case scenario, season after season, until Brian Kelly decided to retire. Honestly, that all felt fine.</p><p>Even after I had peeled my jaw off the floor following Lincoln Reilly’s departure from OU to coach ND’s rival USC, it still didn’t seem possible that the college coaching chaos would reach the sleepy Catholic college near the southernmost bend of the Saint Joseph’s river. Brian Kelly had been<a href="https://www.nbcsports.com/philadelphia/eagles-candidate-brian-kelly-stay-notre-dame"> courted by NFL teams in the past</a> but if I’m being honest, I didn’t think he’d leave because in some sense these last few seasons felt like his ceiling as well. He had worked his ass off to build a very strong program in a unique place in the college football landscape. If he could beat the odds, if he could line the stars up just right once in the next five or six years, there was a non-zero chance that he could bring a national title to Notre Dame and in doing so, become a legend at a place that, despite his odd affect, genuinely seemed to matter to him.</p><p>This all obviously ended up not being the case.</p><p>On any given Saturday during the fall, my phone will spend the day buzzing as part of any number of text threads with family and sub-groups of ND friends. The day it all went down, on one of these threads, a friend sent the text “…Irish?” and I dutifully called up the browser on my phone to see what had happened. And holy shit. The coaching carousel had come and spun through South Bend. Brian Kelly would be headed to LSU to coach in the SEC. The Irish would be needing a new head coach for the first time in more than a decade thanks at least in part to the statistically unlikely event that the pregnant wife of a high ranking LSU official would end up at t<a href="https://dailysnark.com/2021/10/17/report-ed-orgeron-hit-on-pregnant-wife-of-lsu-official-at-gas-station-2021-will-be-final-year-as-lsu-hc/">he same gas station as now-former LSU coach Ed Orgeron</a> and the apparently not so statistically unlikely event that Coach O would be a huge creep.</p><p>On a semi-related side note, I kind of love LSU. During a semi-hung over jog around their campus in 2009, I stumbled into the parking lot that they were using as a staging area for some kind of homecoming parade. Everyone was awesome and very welcoming as I ran around wearing a Notre Dame t-shirt giving high fives to floats full of people. I even got to hug Mike the Tiger (the <a href="https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/1044310634899345409/ANRR6Ko3_400x400.jpg">costumed, anthropomorphic version</a>, not the actual live Bengal tiger).</p><p>Since his jump to Baton Rouge, Brain Kelly has seemingly broken his brain, <a href="https://twitter.com/Mike_Bundt/status/1466224226818473989?">developing a southern accent </a>that he embarrassingly displayed during an introduction at a Tiger basketball game and <a href="https://twitter.com/Walker_Howard4/status/1470191799662792705">doing some kind of weird dance on a rotating platform with his top QB recruit (?!)</a>. It’s honestly been hypnotizing, like watching an actor you knew from playing a librarian on a soap opera suddenly appear as the kazoo-playing band leader on a late night television show- it doesn’t seem to fit, you’re not sure why it happened, but you also feel compelled to watch. I’ve watched the video of BK saying “faymeely” more times than I can count at this point, mostly because I think it scratches some obscure itch in my brain similar to like a magic eye picture or something, revealing something hidden and novel that is also deeply unimportant.</p><p>He was also pretty much universally shit on for the way he left. His players found out through social media that he was departing and he awkwardly texted them that his love for them was limitless before meeting with them for 10 minutes the next morning and then heading out to seek his fortune down south. He failed to recruit any of his assistants to join him, and they proceeded to obviously, delightfully throw shade at him in their announcements to the players that they would be remaining. The Observer, ND’s student newspaper, posted <a href="https://ndsmcobserver.com/2021/12/dear-brian/">a humorous op-ed letter to Kelly</a> that captured the feelings of one student editor using the timeless and powerful lyrics of Olivia Rodrigo and Taylor Swift. <a href="https://twitter.com/PregameEmpire/status/1466814798482616324">Twitter did what Twitter does</a>, grinding the story down to a pulp until <a href="https://twitter.com/juicefrom300/status/1468391655829118981">all that remained were the memes</a> to be sifted out like so many gold nuggets from the banks of the internet’s stream of consciousness.</p><p>Notre Dame ended up with Marcus Freeman as their new head coach, and frankly he seems awesome. I’ve loved seeing the way his players responded to the news that he was their coach. It speaks volumes that Notre Dame lost only two recruits. When he stood up and introduced himself to the world in his new position, he talked about how he wanted to model for the young men on his team how he lives a life worth living,<a href="https://www.si.com/college/notredame/football/notre-dame-football-marcus-freeman-quotes-from-first-press-conference"> which for Freeman means being a husband and father</a>. Above all, he seems like an extremely decent dude. I obviously hope he wins a lot of games at Notre Dame, but for now, it does bring me a certain amount of satisfaction to just see the way he rather refreshingly approaches being a human being and a football coach in that order. As I mentioned earlier, between ND now getting to play the jilted party in the BK saga and making their move to promote a charismatic and beloved players coach while retaining a young and potentially ascendant offensive coordinator that also seems beloved by his players, Notre Dame has potentially found itself in the unique position of carrying a public institutional persona that is, likely only for the most fleeting of instants, both sympathetic and even cool. Life really does come at you fast.</p><p>Another semi-related side note, I also just love Tommy Rees. He manages to take his brand of goofy anti-charisma and somehow turn it into an asset. I am immensely grateful to him for one of my all-time favorite sports memories, watching the Rees-led Irish beat USC, in person, in the Coliseum after years of humiliating defeats at the hands of the Trojans. I love Tommy Rees so much that during the hubbub surrounding Johnny Manziel making some money signing autographs, my roommates and I made a shirt promoting Rees as <a href="https://mms-images.out.customink.com/mms/images/catalog/colors/4601/views/alt/front_medium_extended.png?design=hza0-000w-mp7a&amp;pblegacy=1&amp;pblegacysize=small&amp;pblegacywm=1">“Tommy Football,”</a> a kind of anti-Manziel. <a href="https://mms-images.out.customink.com/mms/images/catalog/colors/4601/views/alt/back_medium_extended.png?design=hza0-000w-mp7a&amp;pblegacy=1&amp;pblegacysize=small&amp;pblegacywm=1">We found a quote by F. Scott Fitzgerald about Rees’s hometown of Lake Forest </a>to put on the back of the shirt and we spent like 50 bucks each to get them printed just for the three of us. Anyway, kind of a long way of saying: Tommy Rees Forever.</p><p>Ultimately, Kelly being the kind of chameleonic weirdo that fakes a southern accent in an attempt to ingratiate himself to a fanbase makes it significantly easier to dunk on him for the way he left ND. That said, I think it also obscures the deeper point that many folks were making about Kelly, which was that this scenario mirrored very closely his arrival in South Bend twelve years earlier, a scenario in which he led Cincy to its second BCS bowl in two years but then departed for Notre Dame before the game, leaving his team to get crushed by a Florida team led by fellow well-liquor-tier human being/questionable decision maker Urban Meyer. He announced his departure at the team’s postseason banquet and then left without talking to the media.</p><p>Many of the takes I read perhaps rightly pointed to this as evidence of Kelly’s inherent brokenness or cowardice, that some things never change, but they mostly discussed how things would never change with Brian Kelly, that he would forever be the type of dude who would skulk out the back door when the chance to secure an ever larger bag presented itself. This is plausibly true.</p><p>Then again, folks, Brian Kelly took his police escort out of that Westin banquet hall in Ohio twelve years ago, and it was Notre Dame who hired Kelly away from Cincy and who presumably presented the timeline they would require from him in order to take the job. Did BK get a big fat raise when he made the jump to ND and did he get another one when decamped for Baton Rouge? Of course he did. That said it seems willfully foolish to ignore the fact that this was always also about money for the institutions involved.</p><p>Both Notre Dame and LSU had a variety of rationally defensible institutional logics behind hiring a coach away from another team at this awkward fissure point in the college football calendar, all of which are ultimately related to their ability to make more money. These schools will then, these logic models suggest, invest this money into either improving the mission of the school directly or into other activities which will generate even more money which will be invested into either improving the mission of the school directly or into other activities which will generate even more for money, and so on, and so on, and so on. I will mention here that it is not lost on me that in the specific context of college football these men will make ungodly amounts of money themselves and ungodly amounts of money for their hiring institutions largely by profiting off the unpaid labor of young men, largely young men of color. These institutions had to be dragged kicking and screaming into a future/present where even SOMEONE ELSE could pay the athletes that compete on the institution’s behalf, which is frankly insane and deserves a fuller treatment, one that examines the ways in which these institutions have desires that extend beyond money and into the related realms of power and control.</p><p>Anyway, you don’t make a head football coach the highest paid person at a private institution or pay them the largest salary of any public employee in a state for any reason other than an expectation that their ability to do their job, their ability to recruit young men with a talent for doing a specific set of physical tasks on green rectangles all over the country and then to further improve the skill of those young men in doing those specific physical tasks, will generate a return (in merch, in ticket sales, in donations from happy athletic boosters, etc.) And when you are making that kind of investment, you deploy it in a timeframe and in a fashion that will maximize that return. Time in the market beats timing the market, so you get your guy as early as possible both so that he can get started on the recruiting trail and so that the other guys can’t get him first.</p><p>The underlying game theory of getting the best coach for the best price might seem complicated at the micro level but when you pull out to the macro it is screamingly obvious the direction that salaries and schedules get pulled: upward and earlier, respectively. It doesn’t make for a great look for anyone participating in the whole new grubby race to the bottom but there also isn’t a clear off ramp for all of us. Within the next ten years, and barring some kind of intervention from the slapdash mix of piety and bureaucratic incompetence that is the NCAA or the slapdash mix of piety and bureaucratic incompetence that is the US government, is it possible that we’ll see a major program hire a hot coaching name away from a smaller program mid-season by making them an offer that they simply cannot refuse? Why not? Because of norms? Call me a cynic, but we’ve seen how well those have been holding up lately in the face of the opportunity to secure an ever stronger grip on the levers of power and an ever larger bag of cash.</p><p>Ultimately we’re left with the question of whether or not we are more concerned with the perhaps more entertaining brand of brokenness that Brian Kelly presents to us or with the much more complicated and almost certainly less interesting brand of brokenness that pervades the institutions that make the Brian Kelly’s of the world possible. While we are at it, we can question how a broken society would almost universally decry a man for taking the opportunity to secure generational wealth for his, uh, faymeely, but not more intensely interrogate the fact that the parameters of this particular labor market are not dictated in any real way by the coaches themselves, scarce though their talents might be.</p><p>Which brings me back to Notre Dame. I mentioned that I had reached a sort of equanimity when it came to my Notre Dame football fandom, but in the immediate aftermath of Kelly’s departure, this did nothing to blunt my curiosity about the coaching search. Like so many others across the country, I followed the news closely, and presumably like many others, the more I learned about Marcus Freeman, the more I hoped he would become the next head coach at Notre Dame. As I mentioned above, I was thrilled when his hiring was announced.</p><p>Freeman made a series of comments over the next several days, and in all cases acquitted himself well. He also absolutely crushed the speaking portion of his official introductory presser. I didn’t watch it live, but watched it that night after my wife went to bed while I was feeding our newborn daughter before putting her down for the night. As I tend to when people speak eloquently about the place, I found myself feeling nostalgic and even choked up. Even as much as I complain and even after all these years, I still love the school.</p><p>The next day as I settled into my desk at work to drink my coffee and scan my email, I saw the inevitable missive from the development team at Notre Dame sitting in my inbox. <a href="https://app.mobilecause.com/form/O-XoGg?vid=ol9ma">This one was from the good folks at the Rockne Athletic Fund, inviting me to give $100 and in return receive a t-shirt emblazoned with one of the admittedly more badass lines from Freeman’s introductory comments:</a></p><p>“Notre Dame will change you, if you let it.”</p><p>It had been sent at 1:44pm CT, primed to hit my inbox just as the program was ending.</p><p>Before I could help myself, I found myself thinking that damn, that t-shirt is pretty badass and then I realized that I had been taken in again. In an almost Faustian twist, my alma mater was selling me a vision of the school, that of a borderline sacramental-grade change agent, in exchange for my own cold hard cash. To be clear, I understand the logic at play here: money being fungible and all that, Notre Dame will invest this money into either improving the mission of the school directly or into other activities which will generate even more money which will be invested into either improving the mission of the school directly or into other activities which will generate even more for money, and so on, and so on, and so on.</p><p>What I found myself unrealistically wishing was that maybe Notre Dame could have, even just this once, let us have a nice thing without the need to then, literally immediately, try to brutally and efficiently monetize the experience, converting my excitement about the hiring of a guy who seems to be both professionally excellent and deeply personally decent into cash flow. In some abstract sense I understand that it’s all for the mission, and the Rockne Athletic Fund sounds very fine in its scope and its ambitions but do we need to always give the impression that even the smallest detail of the place has been carefully curated to enhance the brand which has been carefully crafted in order to enhance the schools ability to raise money? Nonprofit institutions like universities exist to, at least in part, solve problems that markets are ill equipped to solve, but that hasn’t stopped us from letting a variety of markets dictate seemingly every decision that these institutions make. This is an institutional problem, sure, but then also on a personal note, can you please for for one fucking second stop trying to sell me back my own happy feelings?</p><p>As I think back on my own now long personal history with ND as an undergraduate, graduate student, employee, then graduate student again, then just plain (increasingly) old alum, I find I can’t necessarily give an accurate assessment of whether or not things were always this way or if the slow progression of the market eating everything has slowly eroded our ability to conceive of an institution of higher learning as anything other than a surplus-generating endeavor with every piece of the place that does not at least in part pull its weight in this surplus generation liable to be scrapped or “reimagined” into something that will sell either to sports fans, or to tuition-paying students, or to donors.</p><p>Maybe it was always this way and I was just clueless, or maybe it has inched further and further, year by year, into a vision of the future where it represents some kind of abject failure if the administration fails, in even the smallest instance, to convert literally every piece of joy that someone feels in connection to the place, immediately and efficiently, into economic capital. Either way, I have a sinking feeling that there is no going back.</p><p>Marcus Freeman is right, I think, and for this reason I will continue to watch and love my alma mater. Tender, strong, and true, after all. I was and continue to be, in some personally meaningful ways, made better by my time at Notre Dame and the communities to which it has connected me. I am a broken human being, certainly, but the Notre Dame community gave me the tools and the help to try and make both myself and the world at least a little bit better.</p><p>So yes, I think our newest head coach is correct. Notre Dame will change you, if you let it.</p><p>My larger concern at this point is that, in the ways it may need to most, Notre Dame might not longer be willing or able to change at all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=21f17838df02" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who We are to Each Other : The Risks of Loving an Ungovernable Other]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/who-we-are-to-each-other-the-risks-of-loving-an-ungovernable-other-24f8927e319f?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24f8927e319f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Dec 2021 05:42:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-06T16:01:21.597Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Who We are to Each Other : The Risks of Loving an Ungovernable Other</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/613/1*dhqO38MfoT11jnJY1ew9vg.png" /></figure><p>In the spring of 2016 I was in my second semester of my current round of graduate school. Two days every week I would commute for work from my home in Ukrainian Village in Chicago down to Chicago Heights where I worked in fundraising at my high school alma mater, and then all the way back up north to Rogers Park for three hours of class.</p><p>At the end of those long days, I loved walking across the dark and largely empty campus to my car and driving home down a sparsely populated Lake Shore Drive. I find so much peace in deserted spaces that are often otherwise crowded. There is so much magic in the off-season resort town and the after-hours school building. But even despite the sustaining power of that magic, I was quite tired by 9:30pm when my classes would end and I would begin the journey home. Often, I felt so emptied by the experience of the day that I would drive in silence. When I was feeling more ambitious, I would turn on the radio. On one of those more energetic drives that April of 2016,<a href="https://onbeing.org/programs/david-whyte-the-conversational-nature-of-reality/"> I heard an interview with David Whyte, on an episode of On Being,</a> where he said something that shook me. It was an almost off-hand comment he was making about parenthood and the ways in which our hearts are guaranteed to be broken:</p><blockquote>“This is another delusion we have, that we can take a sincere path in life without having our heart broken. You think about the path of parenting; there’s never been a mother or father since the beginning of time who hasn’t had their heart broken by their children. Nothing dramatic has to happen. All they have to do is grow up.”</blockquote><p>I wasn’t a parent then, but I am a parent now, and I often think about those words. I feel the weight of them.</p><p>Along these lines, and knowing full well that this will not hit you with the same weight that it hits me, I want to explain to you how my two year old son says the word “baby” and also some context for why he’s been saying it a lot lately.</p><p>My wife recently gave birth to a baby girl, and she is wonderful in the way that all babies are wonderful and tiring in the way that all new human beings are tiring. A lot happened in the year leading up to her arrival<a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/f-ma-on-bodies-loss-and-feeling-grief-in-2021-1530eadc99d9"> including a miscarriage</a> and the loss of her twin sister earlier in this pregnancy, so we were on pins and needles in the way that all parents are on pins and needles until we actually go the chance to see her and hold her and hear her tiny but insistent cries.</p><p>As any parent who has thought through the logistics of bringing home a new baby to a household that currently includes a toddler can attest, there is a lot of advice floating around out there about how to make sure that your toddler transitions well into having a younger, more attention-demanding sibling join the household. This advice largely focuses on telling your kid, a lot, that a new baby is coming and framing it as something that they should be excited about. So we did this with our son. A lot. We talked about the new baby all the time. We watched all the Daniel Tiger episodes about the Tiger Family setting up for and bringing home Baby Margaret. And we talked about it. And we talked about it.</p><p>One other thing that we heard in a variety of places is that you as the parents should be in the room with the toddler and then have someone else bring the baby in to meet their sibling for the first time. This is ostensibly to prevent the new toddler from feeling like they have been replaced in the family, and instead more closely mimics the actual dynamic that’s in play, with the new child joining a family in progress. The baby is incapable of feeling any type of way about this, so as a parent you take advantage of the fact that in this instance, and for a least another month or two, you don’t need to worry too much about two sets of feelings that you can only partially comprehend.</p><p>So this is what we attempted.</p><p>We got home from the hospital and put the baby in her bassinet upstairs. J and I were going to greet our son as he came back from a walk with J’s mom, and then we would talk with him while she went upstairs and got the baby. That was the plan, at least. He was having none of it. As soon as he came in the door, he didn’t even say anything to J and me other than “Baby, baby, baby, baby” and immediately started looking around the house for her. And now it’s time. Imagine that this child of two comes running into the house, and starts saying “baby” but he’s not actually saying “baby,” instead he’s saying “bee bee” in a kind of oddly guttural tone that sounds like it starts somewhere south of the back of his throat and doesn’t seem to mimic any sound that we’ve heard him make at any other point in his life. He also drags out the second syllable, so it comes out sounding something like “bee beeeee” but also at least a half octave lower than the rest of all the other words that he says. And then imagine that he is the most excited he has ever been in his whole short life and he’s running around saying this, looking furiously for his new baby sister. He was so excited that I ended up going upstairs and getting the bassinet and bringing it down, and his first impulse was to grab one of his many prized toy cars and bring it to her in her bassinet and place it at her feet, all while saying “bee beeeee, bee beeeeee.”</p><p>It was incredible. I loved it so much and I was so proud of the generosity and love already blossoming in the heart and the mind of this tiny human being.</p><p>My heart broke a few weeks later, when I was driving him home after picking him up from a day with my folks. I always talk to him on these drives home, even if he doesn’t have the words to answer me yet. That day he did.</p><p>I asked him who we were going to see when we got home, and without pausing he said, “Baby.” Not “Bee beeeeee.” My wife had noticed that his pronunciation was changing and mentioned to me that we needed to get it on video, but it was about more than him losing the adorable pronunciation that just absolutely knocked me out. It hit me on that drive that the version of my son that had run through the house, looking for the perfect car to give to his new baby sister, excitedly shouting “bee beeeeee, bee beeeee” was, to some extent, gone already. We change so quickly. Looking in my rear view mirror was an incrementally new human being, one that I loved just as much, and in fact, that I loved even more. But my heart, at least a piece of it, broke anyway.</p><p>How many tiny quirks of this small and beautiful human being that bring me so much joy every day will pass away without me even realizing it? Will their passage be less meaningful without me having the capacity to notice and note it? At what point will the accretion of these tiny shifts enough that I’ll look at this dark-eyed and dimpled Ship of Theseus and realize that the little boy I knew has been replaced by someone that I love more fiercely than ever but that I may struggle more than ever to fully understand? Why do we ever think we handle the weight of this terrible risk?</p><p>Nothing dramatic has to happen. All they have to do is grow up.</p><p>I think a lot about Whyte’s words in my own inverse context as well, not in my still relatively new skin as a parent but in my much worn well-worn identity as a son. I think of my parents and how many times I must have broken off pieces of their hearts. I think of the funny habits I never knew I had that I sloughed off, maybe the way I used to read science fiction books and tell them about them in more detail than they could possibly have wanted. Did they miss this? And did they realize as I did this for the last time that it was over for good?</p><p>I think about the way I used to be much more of an optimistic soul, how I would share that optimism with them, and how that fell away and gave way to my quieter, much more rough hewn (and in retrospect, intermittently depressed) high school and college years. Did they miss the boy that I was even as they might love the man that I’ve become? How many beloved iterations of their son slipped away from them over those years, and did they mourn his leaving in ways even they might not have realized?</p><p>I think this is the point in the discussion where it makes the most sense to state something that from moment to moment feels somehow both obvious and obscure- we are not to blame for these particular types of breakages in the hearts of those that we love. I’m not speaking here of sins committed that require atonement- those are something else entirely. Instead, in some sense these small, inevitable breakages are the cost for the greater love that can then emerge and they are completely unavoidable in the context of any relationship.</p><p>But the idea of cost is also inadequate- these small breakages of the heart are not something that is paid, and in that sense given away. The cost is not something that can be erased by the payment, no. Instead I think we carry some marks of these wounds for all of our time. The tiny griefs that come from losing pieces of those we love to the inevitable processes of human growth will stand alongside forever the deep appreciation of the people who can emerge on the other side of the swirling chaos of the human experience. But we should also note here that it is chaotic, and there is always the chance that the person that emerges on the other side, even if they are growing exactly as they should, might push themselves forward in ways that strain the ties that bind.</p><p>It is always a risk, such a tremendous and terrifying risk, to love an ungovernable other.</p><p>Nothing dramatic has to happen. All they have to do is grow up.</p><p>As I sit here and write this amidst news of a potential new wave of a global pandemic, I’ve been thinking a lot about what we owe to each other, what our freedoms really mean if they come at the expense of the well being of someone else. For almost two years now, it’s felt like the most pressing question. It also was the most pressing question, before the pandemic, even as those with the microphone in our shared civic spaces failed to ask it. It will remain the most pressing question going forward long after the coronavirus has receded to the background, it’s destructive power reduced to the same quiet hum as the modern forces that chew at the margins of our lives rather than ravaging the center. But this question has also been frustrating for me, because what feels very obvious to me is apparently not obvious to many others. So the wheels grind onward.</p><p>I think a related central question has been on my mind these last few weeks, since my son uttered those two perfectly formed syllables in the backseat of our car and since the little boy he had been suddenly, subtly, transformed. I’ve been thinking a little bit less about what we owe to each other and a little bit more about who we are to each other, the weight we carry in the lives of others even without doing anything at all except growing up. I’ve been thinking about the terrible risks that we take on each other, about the pains we unintentionally inflict through our inherent ungovernability, through our journeys into and out of the chaos at the heart of our shared experience. I’ve been thinking about how while I may not be to blame, necessarily, for those tiny heartbreaks that I bring into the lives of those I love, I am still responsible for them, and that I might move more gently and love more ably if I am cognizant of that responsibility.</p><p><a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/unwilled-inheritances-and-terrifying-passengers-on-depression-entropy-and-systemic-inequality-409f2b2f9a">I’ve written before about how I see the entropic realities of the universe manifesting themselves in the flawed selves and in the broken systems that shape our lives every day.</a> I’ve considered how we’re called to grow in resistance to those entropic forces, and that while we may not be culpable for the systemic injustices of our world, we are responsible for working to fix them. I think it’s been sinking in for me that this growth, this resistance, is not without its costs. In the same way, we may not be culpable for the pains our movements through the chaos inflict on those who we love, but we are, in the end, responsible for them.</p><p>This is certainly not any kind of advocacy for the avoidance of growth as a human being- this is, ultimately of course, not even an option. As time’s arrow moves inexorably forward you will grow into your future self regardless of your efforts otherwise, and the choice to try and avoid growth will instead merely shape who you become just as surely as any other decisions. No, instead I’m thinking about how an awareness of who we are to others might allow us to move more gently through the world, might help us understand more, might ultimately make us better. Who might we choose to be if we knew that that the person we choose to be gives us a gravitational pull that can alter the orbits of all those we encounter?</p><p>Greg Boyle, a Jesuit priest and the CEO of Homeboy Industries,<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8eQsHEjfRrY"> was one of the speakers at my commencement ceremony when I finished business school.</a> He was great, as he tends to be, and he repeated one of the many themes that populate his work, which is that “only the soul that ventilates the world with tenderness has any chance of changing it.” That phrase has been echoing for me as I’ve turned over this question of who are to each other, and I think I missed something the first several hundred times I thought it through. I used to read “with tenderness” to mean that we must use tenderness as a tool with which to ventilate the world. This may very well be true (and may be what Boyle meant) but it’s been hitting me differently lately. Instead now, I’ve been reading it in the sense that we will ventilate the world no matter what.</p><p>We will, through our very existence, poke holes in the lives of those we encounter and particularly in the lives and hearts of those we love the most. Thus, we are called to undertake this ventilation with great tenderness. If we move more carefully through the world, if we are more cognizant of who we are to others and the ways in which our very act of being affects them, then this ventilation can be a process through which greater love can emerge. This greater love can change the world. In fact might in fact be the only thing that can, and nothing dramatic even has to happen for us to take advantage of this ability to make the world better. We just have to grow up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24f8927e319f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Don’t Blame It on the Pop: Does Popular Music Hold the Key to Fixing our Broken Digital…]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/dont-blame-it-on-the-pop-does-popular-music-hold-the-key-to-fixing-our-broken-digital-85073d073f65?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85073d073f65</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Sep 2021 19:53:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-20T19:53:23.028Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Don’t Blame It on the Pop: Does Popular Music Hold the Key to Fixing our Broken Digital Epistemologies?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HYT-lu79-ncfMCvk0PCvCQ.png" /><figcaption><em>“I put my pants on</em> just like the rest of you — <em>one leg at a time. </em>Except, when my pants are on, I <em>make gold records</em>.” — Christopher Walken as recording legend Bruce Dickinson.</figcaption></figure><p>I need to start here: I love pop music. At pretty much any point since getting my driver’s license, if you hopped into my car, you stood a non-zero chance of hearing me jamming along to whatever was currently populating the Billboard Top 40 list.</p><p>There are many things that I like about the experience of listening to pop music, and t<a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/empty-tombs-and-rothko-rooms-art-easter-and-the-language-of-redemption-2296b36f2d02">hey are perhaps not always what one would hope to gain from immersing oneself in art. </a>There are types of music that I engage with to learn about the mind or heart of the artist and what the experience of listening and hearing can tell me about myself. There are other types of music that can open up a toolbox or a roadmap that gives the chance to experience something new or the route to find a new emotional territory within my own soul. Pop music can do some of these things, but these are not the reliable common denominator for what you will hear on the radio.</p><p>Rather, all pop music is interesting for what it reveals about the overlap between what musicians/producers/record company executives believe the public wants to hear and what actually catches on because the public wants to hear it. Setting aside the role that taste makers, station directors, media moguls, etc. might take in manufacturing consent from the public on what is currently popular, at some level what you find playing when you turn on your average “Top 40” radio station is going to represent the center of this venn diagram between taste makers thoughts on what the public will want/should want at any given point and what taste takers actually end up streaming, buying, etc.</p><p>The emerging consensus can be revealing of both what those at least nominally in positions of cultural power think you should be consuming/want to be consuming and also of what creatives are feeling and also what the proverbial plural you is feeling and consuming. In some sense you’re also hearing how we as a society use this one type of art to navigate this sort of negotiation between art and commerce. In short, turning on Kiss 103.5 here in Chicago is kind of like listening to a recorded snippet of a large portion of the US populace attending therapy and working through their current feelings and desires and hopes filtered/warped through the myopic lens that market capitalism places between us and the things we touch and live with every day. Even if the music isn’t “good,” isn’t that experience worthwhile?</p><p>As a pop music lover, I am lately one of an increasingly small number of people (based on YouTube views) who impatiently awaits and then immediately plays on repeat the yearly mash-ups that DJ Earworm puts out every year. If you are of a certain age (my age) and want to be taken back, I’d suggest listening to any of these year-end compilations from the last twelve years, but for me (and again, based on YouTube views) many other people, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNzrwh2Z2hQ">the seminal track will always be the 2009 version, “Blame it on the Pop.” </a>The way Earworm captures both the deep anxiety that still seemed to be permeating the whole of the country as we entered the slow recovery from the 2008 collapse of the housing market and the wider economy (how many songs that year had the word “down” in their hook? It sure feels like a lot) with the broader positivity narrative surrounding the then-nascent recovery takes me back very quickly to a sweaty dance floor at Finny’s/Corby’s/The Linebacker in South Bend where I could typically be found dancing the night away for a few euphoric hours three or four nights per week before waking up the next morning feeling both like maybe my life was falling apart but also that hey that was kind of fun and what’s the point anyway because what awaits us but an uncertain economic future and a society that has already decided that we’re economically and spiritually worthless deadbeats?</p><p>We all have our own searches for meaning.</p><p>Which is a long way of saying that I am the type of listener who likes music that tells me something. Sometimes music tells us something true. Something music tells us something false (which, if you think about it, can also tell you something true).</p><p>There is one of these lies at the core of one of my most frequently played tunes from the last six months. It’s a song by the Menzingers, a (now) punk(ish) outfit out of Philadelphia who have recorded some genuinely excellent records over the years. For my money, their third studio album, “On the Impossible Past’’ is where you’ll find them at the peak of their powers. The back to back tracks of “Gates” and the “Obituaries” provides one of the most cathartic scream-along music experiences that one can find (rivaled perhaps only by screaming “Love Story” by Taylor Swift on the aforementioned Finny’s dancefloor, just kidding, no but seriously, do it). There’s the anthemic swells of “Casey” and the ironic sting of “Nice Things” paired with the earlier, despairing “Good Things.” It’s just really good. Their next effort, “Rented World” couldn’t recreate quite the same energy, and they started to pick up the pieces and begin the pivot that brings me to the song in question with the extremely good and more smoothly produced “After the Party.” Then in 2019 they released “Hello Exile” followed by an acoustic take on the whole album, recorded during COVID isolation and released in 2020, titled “From Exile.”</p><p>Both “Exile” albums are very good, and I like the idea of getting two looks at the same songs. It can tell you things about what they were trying to do the first time or how they want to keep leaning into a more political bent (“America I Love You”) or how the the first round’s push into country didn’t feel quite far enough for them (“I Can’t Stop Drinking”).</p><p>Perhaps not surprisingly for a guy who just openly admitted that he loved pop music, my favorite song on both albums is the first single from “Hello Exile,” the slickly produced “Anna.” It’s great. It’s honestly like the Gin Blossoms put out one of their top five songs twenty-two years after they broke up for the first time.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtHE4AoNRV4">You should listen to it,</a> but if you can’t right now or whatever, the song is about a guy whose girlfriend has essentially left him behind, traveling a lot with a new job and using their shared studio apartment as “just a place to keep [her] stuff.”</p><p>It starts on its highest note, when the narrator opens with the lie that forms the core of the song. “I memorized every single moment, every fleeting passage of time, the way you’d laugh and dance in the kitchen after drinking too much cheap red wine. I always rewind the home movies in my mind.” Interestingly, the second cut at the song on “From Exile” adds an additional couplet that builds on this: “In my picture perfect memory, I recall it all so clearly, the way we decorated the walls with nothing much at all.”</p><p>The overall effect is both nostalgic and depressing, this guy insisting that he remembers everything perfectly from their relationship and then homing in on their early, happy first days moving in together drinking too much and not decorating their walls. We see the beginning through his eyes and we see the end that he doesn’t seem to realize is an end at all, without seeing the painful middle at all. The way all this collapses in on itself over the song is masterful, and the most heartbreaking line comes at the end of the hook when he says, “This place ain’t the same without you, Anna.” This may be true (neighborhoods do change, as he says), but the deeper truth is more likely that Anna isn’t the same even if he is, or maybe because he is. Maybe his memory of those days isn’t as perfect as he thinks it is, and those days probably weren’t all that perfect either.</p><p>What a deeply human flaw, to believe that we have perfect knowledge (or perfect memories) and what a heartbreaking outcome to witness, the slow burnout of a relationship with one party so wrapped up in his home movies of a perceived perfect past that he can’t even see the smoldering ash of his love in front of his eyes.</p><p>We are a people who forget.</p><p>A few weeks ago, my wife was out of town for a week which left me home with our two year old son. It was great. On Thursday, I took the day off work and we went for a walk. He held my hand when we crossed the street and even let me keep holding it when we got onto the sidewalk. I thought about how there would be a last time that I would get to hold his hand.</p><p>We sat on a bench on Blue Island and watched for trucks. We waved to a few and got waves and some honks in return. He pointed at everything he found interesting and said “Dada.” I pondered how few the weeks were where I would be one of the only things he could talk about, and how incredible and sad that made me feel at the same time.</p><p>The next morning, I got up early to get some work done before I headed into school, but Felix got up early too. I didn’t mind. I didn’t get work done, but I did accomplish the following:</p><ul><li>Hiding</li><li>Seeking</li><li>Laughing</li><li>Tucking Finley the teddy bear back into bed</li><li>Reading “Good Night, Good Night, Construction Site”</li></ul><p>It was a perfect morning. It also broke my heart, because I found myself wanting to record all of it perfectly in my head. Even now, as I write this weeks later, I know there are pieces of those moments, those moments that are already so finite and few, that are gone, slipped out of my imperfect memory into the ether.</p><p>And that is just from one morning. How many thousands of wonderful moments will fade without even recognition that they are leaving me? At this age, a child is a different person every day, and if I can’t remember every day then I can’t remember every person that he is. This breaks me, that pieces of my son should slip away from me. I am a person who forgets.</p><p>There are ways that we can help ourselves remember, of course. We use them all the time. Calendars, pictures, journals, post-it notes. These can help us remember everything from our to-do list to the way that our loved ones looked at a given point in time.</p><p>There is an offshoot of cognitive philosophy, the Extended Mind Thesis/Theory/Hypothesis <a href="https://www.nyu.edu/gsas/dept/philo/courses/concepts/clark.html">initially formalized by Andy Clark and David Chalmers</a> in 1998 (one year after the Gin Blossoms broke up for the first time), that even contends that exterior, material/physical pieces of the world can and do function as pieces of the self when they are integral parts of cognitive processes. In this way, per the theory, a notebook or a computer can function as a part of the self if it is serving in the same way that an “intracranially” stored memory might (providing an address, for example).</p><p>I find this fascinating and provocative, even if following this theory to the endpoints it suggests leads to some deeply goofy conclusions (is a pen really part of my mind if it helps me record memories in my notebook?). There is also further research about how couples form interpersonal cognitive systems and rely on each other to fill in the gaps in each other’s memories. As a married person, I can certainly anecdotally admit that this is true for me. I rely on my wife frequently to fill in gaps in my memory.</p><p>Speaking of music and what it can tell us about the world, one of the most heart-rending depictions of this phenomena I’ve come across in any art form is “The Dutchman,” written by Chicago-based folks artist Michael Peter Smith and made popular through covers by a wide variety of artists. I distinctly remember (or do I?) hearing the chorus sung by <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=429PaSejZCE">the Clancy brothers and Tommy Makem</a> and seeing my parents tear up, and with each passing year the line, “Long ago, I used to be a young man, and dear Margaret remembers that for me” gets harder to sing aloud past the lump it inevitably forms in my throat.</p><p><a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/empty-tombs-and-rothko-rooms-art-easter-and-the-language-of-redemption-2296b36f2d02">I think music and all art also can serve as an extension of our minds, allowing us to recall feelings with a ferocity that would otherwise be difficult to manifest.</a> It’s one thing for me to sit in silence and contemplate the beautiful and terrible costs of unconditional love. It’s entirely another for me to have those same feeling evoked by listening to “The Dutchman” and weeping quietly as I do the dishes. How powerful then does this collective recall of our feeling become when a large collective shares the same feelings with a piece of art or music? How much more powerful is it, above and beyond losing myself in solitude with a song, to sing a song along with a crowd of people at a live show? I’ll revisit this potential for music to bind us together. It might be the key.</p><p><a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/its-still-real-to-me-dammit-pro-wrestling-kayfabe-and-the-mathematical-function-of-faith-975f25e997a4">I’ve also written about how social institutions serve the same function of externalized memory storage for me personally.</a> In the same way that I might rely on my calendar to tell me I have a meeting at 10:30am call and rely on my wife to remind me who is married to who at a get-together with people we don’t see frequently, I rely on religion and other social rituals (voting, paying my taxes, etc.) which can, when contextualized properly, serve as reminders of my own embedness in a world in which we owe much to each other. <a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/unwilled-inheritances-and-terrifying-passengers-on-depression-entropy-and-systemic-inequality-409f2b2f9a">And yet the same entropic principles that eat away at my own ability to remember everything without the aid of an extended mind nip away at the edges of those extensions on which I’ve come to rely. </a>Even with our extended minds, we are a people who forget.</p><p>On the broader unreliability of these digital mind extenders:</p><p>One of the communities of which I genuinely feel lucky to be a part is the broad community of the Alliance for Catholic Education (ACE). Driven in part by own search for meaning in service and, realistically, in part by the same broader economic and social forces that depressed both me and the job market during my senior year of college, I spent the first two years after undergrad teaching high school in Montgomery, Alabama as part of ACE’s sixteenth cohort of Teaching Fellows. Those two years were among the most formative of my entire life, and we recently lost Doc Doyle, one of the great human beings who made them thus, for me and countless others.</p><p>I had not done a good job of keeping in touch with Doc, and knowing that he is gone makes me miss him terribly. Upon hearing of his passing, I could only reflect that the most remarkable part about Doc for me personally was one of the most interesting and complex people I’ve ever met actually left me with some of the most uncomplicated feelings I’ve experienced in my adult life. Uncomplicated awe at the clarity of his thinking, the depth of his faith, and the warmth of his heart underneath all of it. Uncomplicated joy when I finally submitted a tiered assessment design that linked tightly to a developmentally appropriate Bloom verb. Uncomplicated pride to have known him and to have been his student.</p><p>It was so obvious being in his class and talking with him that Doc believed in the power of Catholic education, but what was so important, and perhaps almost unbelievable, was the way that Doc believed in all of us to be a part of that vital mission but also just believed in us as human beings. I remember saying to one of my classmates very early on that first summer that I wanted to be the kind of teacher that Doc seemed to believe I could be.</p><p>When I heard he was gone, I immediately went looking for perhaps the only picture I knew of with the two of us together. I wanted some tangible reminder that I had once occupied the physical presence of someone as good as Doc and that he knew me and believed in me. The photo had been taken at a Notre Dame basketball game, snapped by someone I was with, and we were both leaning forward taking in the game. I had never seen this picture in any physical form, only tagged on Facebook after someone uploaded it, I can’t even remember who. When I went to look for this picture, it was gone, vanished into the digital ether in the same way a hundred thousand moments will slip away from me before it’s my own time to go.</p><p>That same week, on our anniversary, my wife and I sat down to watch our wedding video. We had three flash drives that we had received from the video vendor in the weeks after our wedding day six years ago. All three of them had been corrupted, and we ended up looking through our wedding album instead. While we were able to get an archived version from the vendor, who then chided us to transfer the videos to a hard drive, since the USB drives are prone to this kind of breakdown over time, I found myself contemplating how these pieces of our extended minds are as prone to failure as our intracranial machinery, and without even the benefit of intuition of how and when these breakdowns might occur. We tend to miscalculate the durability of our extended minds, particularly when they’re stored digitally.</p><p>I came of age as a “person who might need to do research” right as the ability to store and retrieve information digitally became commonplace. I’ve only recently begun to consider how this might lead to me valuing knowledge, understanding the cost of constructing it, and miscalculating the fragility of it. While I have an intuitive sense of what I am likely to retain in my own mind (although even the accuracy of my own intuition there is debatable), I don’t think it’s a stretch to say that someone who has easy access to Google (or an unbelievably robust university library’s worth of digitized journals, resources, etc.) will enter intellectual maturity with a deeply different view of these aspects of knowledge than someone who was even ten years older.</p><p>The digital revolution had profound implications on the speed with which knowledge production could occur, and I think this is where I’ve previously tended to stop my analysis. I have focused on how much more knowledge is readily available to me and anyone else at any given point in time, which is a good thing, and not pushed further to understand the effects this would have on my own implicit understandings about the structure of knowledge and the data that aids in its construction.</p><p>Further, I think the simple idea that more is better, or that ease equals quality, begins to break down pretty quickly. The way I lost the last picture I had with Doc can prove how pictures easily produced and stored can just as easily disappear without us even noticing until it is too late. Norm MacDonald, who we also recently lost, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MZHHBb3rP4">had a great bit where he imagined the future of our vast proliferation of photos through digital photography. </a>He asks the right questions, and the direction toward the correct answer is obvious, even if the road to get there would almost certainly prove more complex : were pictures worth more when every person only had one? Will we ever want the 100,000 pictures of ourselves that we create, even if they were to defy the odds and survive into the future?</p><p>The accessibility of a constantly proliferating body of information has obscured for me that knowledge is still inherently fragile and every system that stores that information is still, at root, prone to some kind of failure. <a href="https://www.fastcompany.com/90666430/parts-of-the-web-are-disappearing-every-day-heres-how-to-save-internet-history">The internet is disappearing</a> and <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/09/saving-the-world-from-code/540393/">as software eats the world, we’re seeing more and more of the cracks it forms. </a>One mistake <a href="https://qz.com/646467/how-one-programmer-broke-the-internet-by-deleting-a-tiny-piece-of-code/">can be enough to bring down entire swaths of the internet.</a></p><p>Further, no matter the advances through which an expanded mind can incorporate an increasingly sophisticated suite of resources and tools, the core of that mind remains as feeble and broken, as human, as it always has been. When presented with the largest ever collection of human knowledge, all accessible through a terminal, <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/biases-make-people-vulnerable-to-misinformation-spread-by-social-media/">there will still be our deeply human tendency to seek out and even share bad information as long as it makes us feel better</a>. Even with good information, I am still prone to make mistakes. There are certain boundaries that I cannot hope to transcend.</p><p>To be clear, I am not the Luddite math teacher of the zeitgeist, decrying the use of calculators and demanding that students use a compass or a table of z-scores in lieu of a calculator or Excel spreadsheet. Technology can make us better and frankly, even if this isn’t a given, it doesn’t matter. We cannot go back.</p><p>Rather, I just think it’s likely that these analytic failures in considering how knowledge functions in the modern world are not unique to me. When we don’t consider the ways in which the machinery on which we rely to extend our collective consciousness is prone to failure, we run serious risks including a communal inability to grasp the fragility of the foundations of our now digitally dependent society. The results of these failures, or our success in avoiding them, will shape the arc of the next phase of our shared history. If we lack a shared fundamental understanding of how the work of the sciences, both hard and social, are not only performed but communicated and understood, then that next phase of our history could be very short indeed, ended by threats currently debated or perhaps some threat unknown.</p><p>In the end though, I come back to where I felt compelled to begin- to pop music. I return here because, as I mentioned previously, we might already have the key to conveying complex shared social truths through methods that defy the rational. Perhaps just a piece of the solution can be <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I">as simple as a I–V–vi–IV progression.</a> Maybe it’s coming in over the airwaves and fiber optic cables right now, shaped by that chaotic mix of market tides and millions of personal decisions made while turning through the radio dial or queuing up the next playlist on Spotify or Apple Music. Perhaps it’s all drilling deep into our collective subconscious to form the bedrock of tastes that will shape wedding set lists and barroom DJ requests for decades to come. Perhaps the reminders of our shared and beautiful fragility can be found lurking just beneath the surface of the latest four chord wonder or synth-driven remix of a remix, part of a communal memory that will never be picture perfect, but for now at least, is some piece of our lives that’s still at least somewhat broadly shared.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85073d073f65" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Loving Something Broken: Finding Cracks and Pieces of Church, Country, and Self in West Virginia]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/loving-something-broken-finding-cracks-and-pieces-of-church-country-and-self-in-west-virginia-2dfe8bd36a9c?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2dfe8bd36a9c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[catholicism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[appalachia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jul 2021 14:43:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-22T16:29:08.396Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SLw_yDbq_4xL21a1GjLx4Q.png" /></figure><p>When I used to work in college admissions, I would get frequent questions about topics for admissions essays. Having read thousands of these, I would always offer (and would still offer) the same advice: tell me the most interesting thing about you. It’s my hope that this will help applicants steer clear of the arduous process of seeking out and then unnecessarily aggrandizing life experiences and steer them more towards a deeper truth: everyone has something interesting in their hearts, if they look for it.</p><p>As these conversations went on, one question that would inevitably follow from at least a few applicants would be something along the lines of: well, can I write about my mission/service trip? I would always reply that of course you could, just remember my first piece of advice, and if your mission trip helps you talk about that piece of yourself, then you’re good to go.</p><p>I just got back from leading one of these week-long service trips with my parish youth group, and I say all this to highlight something:</p><p>Setting aside even my own skepticism about the long term value delivered to partners on these kinds of trips (although in mild defense of our local instance of the practice, I think we’ve had some success in finding partners who can genuinely benefit from our unskilled labor), they are definitely the youth ministry-related highlight of the year for the teens and have real value in terms of forming them as human beings who fundamentally understand the importance and value of service to and relationship with their fellow human beings.</p><p>I will also say that, selfishly, they’re equally as valuable for me as an adult in terms of regrounding myself in these same important principles, frequently with people who come from worlds and spaces that are, objectively, very different from my own. As a person who forgets these things without timely repetition, there is always something that has slipped away from me in the intervening months (or in this case years) since my last trip and beyond that, there is always some new piece of knowledge to uncover.</p><p>I think these days of knowledge less as a finite pool of information from which we all drink and more of a massive and constantly shifting river of experiences and data with definable, recognizable forms and features but chaotic, uneven composition from the standpoint of one just wading through, as I think we all are. I was and am always grateful for these trips and the chance they offer to dip my feet back into the river even as the chaos sometimes feels as if it will pull me under.</p><p>The weeks prior to our departure were difficult times to be a Catholic, witnessing yet more revelations of the evils that poison the history of the Church. This time it was the revelation of large unmarked graves being discovered next to “residential schools” in Canada, sites where indigenous children were taken as part of the Church’s “civilizing” efforts. It was and is disgusting and faith-shaking.</p><p>Yet again I found myself asking the same questions that have echoed in my heart and mind for most of my adult life as I thought through the ethics and consequences of engaging with and making a public and personal commitment to an institution that had committed and covered up atrocities of borderline surreal severity over the centuries. It’s all so fucked up.</p><p>I entered the week feeling, frankly, pretty lost about what my own future in the Church might look like, which certainly felt like precarious footing for starting a week-long expedition as a leader of a trip like this.</p><p><a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/unwilled-inheritances-and-terrifying-passengers-on-depression-entropy-and-systemic-inequality-409f2b2f9a">I’ve written previously about my thoughts on the root causes of the disorder that I find myself falling prey to, and about the ways in which my frequent failures are grounded in my physical body and its flawed composition.</a> It makes a certain sense, I’ve then concluded, that any institution constructed by and composed of flawed bodies will also be necessarily, even essentially, flawed.</p><p>But what is the allowable margin for these institutional flaws and errors? What is our legitimate capacity to forgive historical atrocities and what does it say about us in the present day if we associate with a Church that committed them? Does a decision to continue engaging with and within a structure that has enabled the commission of atrocities mean that I am offering some kind of forgiveness for these sins even if forgiveness is not mine to offer? Do the sins and flaws that crept upward from our human brokenness into our Church then creep back downward or outward and poison our souls and minds further through association with a sinful Church? What direction does sin flow in this world?</p><p>Basically, after acknowledging how fucked up it all is, how can you stick around in a Church that has done all of these things and is it possible to do so with a clear conscience?</p><p>These are not just theoretical questions. For a historical observer, knowing in an abstract sense that an institution is essentially flawed is something different entirely from thinking of your two year old son being ripped from your arms, dying from neglect at the hands of his clergy kidnappers, being buried forever in an unmarked grave without your knowledge and then knowing that the universal Catholic church in which you state your Creed every Sunday is responsible for this happening to countless hundreds or thousands of families.</p><p><a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/empty-tombs-and-rothko-rooms-art-easter-and-the-language-of-redemption-2296b36f2d02">I’ve talked before about how as I grow older, my questions about religion stray from the necessity for unrelenting or unquestioning faith in God,</a> and my questions here move in the same direction. In instances like this, I wonder less about my God (“What kind of God would allow this?”) and wonder more about my Church (“Is an institution whose historical foundations contain such enormous ethical fissures really where I can find a way to live a life in greater harmony with my fellow human beings?”). I still do not know for sure. I’m quite certain these questions will haunt me until the grave.</p><p>That said, I found some peace in West Virginia. It’s not the answer, but it is a small reprieve.</p><p>During my time in Wheeling, I met fantastic women and men who are deeply committed to their communities. They have watched as environmental and economic exploitation have hollowed out the beauty of their gorgeous homeland and as an opioid epidemic driven by a combination of corporate greed and inter-generational poverty has gutted families and driven people from the state in search of hope. Wheeling specifically and West Virginia broadly are broken places. To be clear, I say this not in judgement. Every place is a broken place.</p><p>And so, where do we begin? What does one do when faced with ownership of an unretractable and abiding love of a broken thing?</p><p>I met a woman who started an organization more than twenty years ago that now supplies furniture and clothing to families across Appalachia through a robust network of institutional and personal supporters. The floods that prompted the original founding of the organization now occur more regularly than they did when she started, and these folks are still frequently in need thanks largely to economic policies and practices that continue to undermine the quality of life for folks across Appalachia. She has stayed and continued to love into being a vision of hospitality and community that has changed thousands of lives for the better.</p><p>We worked with a group founded on the vision of food grown locally, sold locally, and cooked in peoples’ kitchens with the help of some resources that can help reshape deeply ingrained thought patterns about food that largely serve to keep folks eating processed foods shipped in from hundreds of miles away. As the guy talking with us about their work described his path home to West Virginia after a PhD in materials science and time spent in the defense industry out on the west coast, I was struck by the power of coming home to broken place to love it until it is made better.</p><p>I stood on a bluff overlooking a coal mine waste disposal site filled with coal slurry, standing with a guy who as a child used to ride his bike through the neighborhood where property values were currently cratering thanks to the slow motion environmental car crash that we were looking down into. He stays, mostly to help educate people who come into his home state so that they can leave better informed and perhaps help work toward change. He loves a broken thing so much that he stays.</p><p>These women and men are able to do this because the ugliness that plagues their home does not define their home. The environmental turmoil, the poverty, the drugs- these are the cracks, they are not the pieces. They are the void, they are not the substance. These cracks in this country that I love dearly- the deep inequality, the political malaise, the systemic problems that continue to plague my black and brown sisters and brothers- these are the cracks, and not the pieces. They are part of the whole but they need not be what shapes and defines it as we move forward.</p><p>The cracks are so easy to find in all the different aspects of our lives. I needed my time away to remind me of the pieces. In West Virginia, we connected with all of these people thanks to the Catholic church, which remains a strong and vital source of healing and hope in Wheeling and in countless places across the country and the world. I was able to access these experiences because of the Catholic church. The teenagers I was so lucky to accompany on this trip came home back to Chicago ready to work hard for a more just and equitable world, again, because of the Catholic church. In West Virginia, I considered in a concrete way how, in addition to its immense historical wrongs, the Catholic church has assembled a massive infrastructure dedicated to relieving some of the worst social ills afflicting our world today and provides a rich background of resources for me, on a personal level, to grow in love of my fellow human beings.</p><p>Still, the truly difficult question remains: do these things balance out? When one side of the scale is all cracks, is a void of immense and terrible proportions, is balance even the right thing to seek?</p><p>I don’t know. This is obviously not a permanent place for my mind and heart to dwell. The questions that have echoed in my mind will echo still. In my heart forever the weight and costs of staying and seeking will be subconsciously weighed against the weight and costs of leaving, the known and unknown weights in this world and the unknown costs in the next. But in the examples of these loving women and men, I’ve found enough hope to keep me afloat for at least a little while. It sustains me now like an air pocket found in those chaotic torrents of knowledge in which I find myself immersed. I’ll breathe it in as long as I can, this miraculous hope inspired by the courage of those who have bravely loved the pieces that make up our cracked world.</p><p>The Church, my Church, is a broken institution because it is a human one, centered even as it tries to be around a core of the Divine. This country where I live, this country that I love, is a broken state because it is a human endeavor, inspired even as it is by the core values of liberty and justice for all. I myself am a broken person, riddled irrevocably with flaws that snake down into the core of my being, even as I believe in the possibility and live in the hope of a redemption made possible through a God who is Love.</p><p>These statements are not outright indictments of a church or of a country or of a man. Rather, I think that they are clear statements of fact that I hope, that I think, lay the groundwork for the real work of loving, both myself and my fellow human beings, to begin. It is no accident that they are the bedrock, the essential first step, of the same call: to love a broken thing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2dfe8bd36a9c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s Still Real to Me, Dammit: Pro Wrestling, Kayfabe, and the (Mathematical) Function of Faith]]></title>
            <link>https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/its-still-real-to-me-dammit-pro-wrestling-kayfabe-and-the-mathematical-function-of-faith-975f25e997a4?source=rss-faf733f0562f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/975f25e997a4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wrestling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kayfabe]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike Mesterharm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Jun 2021 02:33:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-17T02:33:15.837Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Du3uHtFyjbIAOlR70REByw.png" /><figcaption>Don’t let this post distract you from the fact that in 1998, The Undertaker threw Mankind off Hell In A Cell, and plummeted 16 ft through an announcer’s table.</figcaption></figure><p>I was in probably fifth or sixth grade when wrestling’s popularity was at a fever pitch in my grade school. With a level of commitment that only idiot children can ever generate, my classmates and I created a “wrestling league” wherein each member of our class was assigned an identity and we would, conceivably, take on these identities and then play out either the actual storylines taking place in the various showings what was then called the WWF or perhaps make our own.</p><p>I played (I was?) Mankind. I don’t know how I remember that while I can’t remember my work email password.</p><p>We talked about this a lot before any real “matches” were set to take place. There was drama over who was who (who played who? I’m really not sure how to phrase this) who was a heel, who was a face. I should also mention that I had never actually seen my namesake/new identity wrestle and did not actually know anything about him/myself. I don’t remember if it was because wrestling was on cable (which we didn’t have) or because my parents thought it was garbage (which is also believable) but it was simply not a realistic possibility for me to watch any wrestling in my house. As a result, I kind of nodded and faked my way through this whole experience, pretending that I had seen whatever match everyone was talking about last night and trying to gather enough context clues that I could get in early with some kind of statement about the quality of the match without exposing the fact that I had no clue how the match had gone.</p><p>Even as I describe it, I feel like I’m doing a poor job of stressing how dumb this all was. So one more thing:</p><p>One undercurrent to all of this was the still frequent discussion surrounding whether or not wrestling was “real.” This despite the fact that we were probably coming up on a decade after Vince McMahon and his wife had both testified under oath in civil cases in New Jersey that wrestling was scripted and thus not subject to the jurisdiction of state athletic commissions. This semantic gymnastics to escape regulation was for a variety of reasons including the fact that wrestlers, if performing under the watchful eye of a state commission, might be banned from performing certain wrestling moves and almost certainly not allowed to rampantly abuse steroids in the way that was fashionable at the time and maybe still fashionable now with a certain crowd. They, Vince and his wife Linda and then many other people thereafter, used the term “sports entertainment” to describe what took place in those rings and on those backstage sets. It wasn’t sports, but it was sports entertainment. It wasn’t “real” in a sense, but it could be as interesting as anything else if you acted like it was, which could then bring about its own sense of reality.</p><p>So yes, we, these idiot children, argued over something that had been laid to rest in sworn testimony in New Jersey, testimony directly from the man who had effectively made modern wrestling into what it was and is now.</p><p>In our defense, I can only offer the following:</p><ol><li>These were the days before the internet</li><li>Even today, children in middle school are unlikely to be perfectly up to date on civil case testimony delivered in New Jersey</li></ol><p>I vaguely remember one recess where we attempted to have a kind of Royal Rumble/ Cage Match mash-up to kick off the whole “league” we were starting where the winner needed to climb a fence on the border of the massive asphalt parking lot that constituted our playground while, obviously, preventing anyone else from doing the same by any other means necessary. I don’t think anyone won because recess was only twenty minutes, but it got us all excited. It set the stage for the events that would end the whole operation.</p><p>I went to an extremely small Catholic school, so we had like 20 kids n our grade which led to some odd social dynamics, even outside of us each being assigned a wrestling persona that we were maybe meant to come to fully embody. One of the results of this unique dynamic was that it wasn’t unheard of for functionally our whole class to end up doing things outside of school in the interest of no one being left out. At some point I remember our whole class went and saw Waterboy in a movie theater on like a Saturday in some kind of unsanctioned off-hours field trip.</p><p>I mention this because if my memory serves me correctly, it was at a birthday/Halloween party attended by the vast majority of my classmates that we decided to have the first real one-on-one “match” of our little endeavor.</p><p>The match was short. One of the more athletic members of our class was set to participate and he managed to pull off an extremely gymnastic drop kick to the face of his opponent which immediately ended the match and let to the effective death of this odd little enterprise.</p><p>As I reflect back on it, I think the kick to the face made it a little bit too real. We were kids pretending that the adults we were pretending to be were really doing the things that they were pretending to be doing a few times a week in front of a crowd of people. These people may or may not have been plugged into the truth that had been spoken aloud into the public record in that courtroom in New Jersey: none of this was real, but maybe it was at least more interesting when everyone acted like it was.</p><p>You might say that, in our youthful inexperience, we were not emotionally equipped to maintain kayfabe in the face of an actual dropkick delivered to the face of an associate.</p><p>I’ve been thinking a lot about kayfabe and how it functions lately, but if you’re not into wrestling or need a refresher on what it is, I’ll refer to the that great and unassailable source of modern truth that might have set us straight all those years ago if only we had access to it: Wikipedia.</p><p>Straight from Wikipedia:</p><p>In <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_wrestling">professional wrestling</a>, kayfabe <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help:IPA/English">/ˈkeɪfeɪb/</a> (also called work or worked), as a noun, is the portrayal of staged events within the industry as “real” or “true”, specifically the portrayal of competition, rivalries, and relationships between participants as being genuine and not staged. The term kayfabe has evolved to also become a code word of sorts for maintaining this “reality” within the direct or indirect presence of the general public.</p><p>So it’s important to remember this: kayfabe should have been dead as a concept. The big man in charge, to avoid having his industry regulated, put his hand on a bible and said it was all bullshit. But it wasn’t dead, and many of us back then still thought that maybe it wasn’t really bullshit. We still wanted it to be real, and even if we thought maybe it wasn’t, maybe it just made more sense for us to act as if it was.</p><p>I remember much later than the backyard dropkick to the face but much earlier than right now, as viral videos were becoming a thing that people talked about and sent to each other over email or whatever, t<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yvd3aEsThbc">here was some poor fuck who was sitting in some bleachers at a wrestling event and when he got his chance on the mic he started crying about how wrestling was still real to him.</a> Naturally, he became famous for this because he was a man showing genuine emotion about something important to him that everyone else thought was stupid.</p><p>I laughed, sure, and shook my head uncomfortably, but this is what I keep coming back to about this dude as he chokes up and screams how it’s still real to him as his voice cracks into the mic- he’s so unbelievably sincere and passionate about this.</p><p>What seems to get lost behind the deeply memeable phrase of “It’s still real to me, dammit!” is that he’s actually using his time with the conch shell to thank the wrestlers for the show they provide despite the toll it all takes on their bodies. He’s grateful that these men would risk life and limb, TBI’s and CTE, all for his entertainment. What he seems to be attempting to communicate, as you watch the clip, isn’t that he really believes the dumb shit that happens in the ring is “true” in the sense that the obviously concocted story lines reflect reality. Instead, he’s moved as he reflects that these particular men that tell these stories, partially through complex and dangerous gymnastic prop fights, have a very real and meaningful connection to his life.</p><p>What’s more, you can start to trace the outlines of a compelling argument that it’s part of the deal for this guy that he knows that what he is seeing isn’t “real” and that this fact actually helps to make it meaningful. There’s something almost sacred about the sacrifice that a marginally successful regional wrestler might make to turn a fight that he is destined (read: scripted) to lose into an entertaining and cathartic experience for the homie watching from the bleachers in the civic center who’s just trying to unwind with a couple of beers and some sports entertainment after a rough week. Holding both the kayfabe surface level meaning and this deeper more complex understanding of what’s really happening in his mind at the same time may help this guy connect with these athletes in a way that either singular experience alone would not allow.</p><p>I don’t know if it was always this way. The ever-reliable Wikipedia calls the staged nature of wrestling matches an “open secret” largely only kept by the hustlers and weirdos who ran the early forerunners to the current WWE, making sure that scripted rivals weren’t seen traveling to shows or dining together when traveling to a new city. So maybe this kind of multivalent experience of professional wrestling has always been part of the deal?</p><p>I’m actually fascinated by this idea that I can’t know what people really thought about pro wrestling in the past because a part of the experience required that they speak and act as if it was real even if they did not believe that it was. It’s kind of a modern instance of the difficulty of understanding whether or not the great storytellers of our early oral traditions really believed in things like flood narratives and gods who lived wildly interesting lives just outside the edges of human perception or if they just understood that the lessons contained in these stories would, if believed and enacted in a certain way, would lead to a certain shape of society that was ultimately beneficial and would support that society’s continued existence.</p><p>Whether or not kayfabe in wrestling has been an open secret since the mid-twentieth century when it started to first grow in popularity or if it’s only been since the McMahon’s sworn courtroom admission or since the advent of the internet, it doesn’t really matter- it’s more interesting for the openness of the secret. A more complex relationship to reality and to fans only makes things more enjoyable and perhaps the extreme distance between the world of the kayfabe in wrestling and the everyday lived experience of the viewers makes the contrast obvious and more easily mined.</p><p>Still, what I think captures me the most about the idea of kayfabe is wrestling is that, while it’s bizarre in the unique context that it occupies — that of sweaty people pretending to beat each other up as part of elaborate storylines — iit is also an extension of everyday human behavior.</p><p>Stumble onto any social network (or for the sake of your sanity, don’t) and find yourself awash in the deeply strange constructions of reality that we all try to pass off to some extent as real. I am basically a 34 year old Boomer and I know that I am too keenly aware of the ways in which what I put out onto social media will be perceived (or how I perceive that they will be perceived). These presentations of myself are not necessarily inauthentic, although they might be. They are not, in any kind of meaningful sense, real.</p><p>Then again, perhaps this process of digitizing ourselves (which actually more closely resembles the creation and deployment of digital others who bear varying levels of resemblance to ourselves) has just made visible a process that is core to our humanity, only now taken to dizzying and potentially horrifying extremes. Your grandfather might tell you a story about how he went down to the local plant to shake the manager’s hand and look him in the eye and hand over his resume before getting a union job for his whole career and retiring with a pension. Was that resume really all that different from the personal brand that you might cultivate by posting on your LinkedIn?</p><p>Hilariously, a friend of a friend once recounted a story about how he had blown an interview with a large financial services company that he was so, so sure he was going to just knock out of the park.</p><p>How did he fuck it up? When asked his greatest weakness, he replied with perhaps the realest possible answer of all time:</p><p>“Well, sometimes I just get really, really drunk.”</p><p>Goddamn. Even as I type that out it’s just incredible, but alas, it also represented an egregious breach of the kayfable of the working world. Despite the fact that many, many people who were applying for this entry level accounting job surely shared this man’s greatest flaw, they had the good sense to maintain kayfabe for the interview.</p><p>Who among us is exactly the same person with their friends as they are with their parents as they are with their kids as they are with themselves when they come home to an empty house or hotel room and face down the prospect of only their own company until they leave again the next morning? Who hasn’t felt the odd shift in energy when worlds collide and you start work with a friend who only knows you from your wild college days or when you run into a coworker on the dance floor at a wedding immediately after popping up from the floor after doing the worm? The uneasiness comes from breaking the particular kayfabe of your specific context with this other individual. You have been forced to acknowledge the truth that you and this other person exist as multidimensional entities.</p><p>Perhaps it is now the dizzying speed with which contexts can overlap that makes things more difficult. When changing contexts physically required changing your physical location it made things easier in terms of maintaining certain illusions when interacting with others or imagining yourself.</p><p>I think what I also find troubling is that while I’ve moved through the contexts within which kayfabe-type social constructs can be interesting or just slightly muddled, there are certainly contexts within which these types of dynamics can be extremely damaging. That’s because, as the astute reader might have picked up on, the deployment of kayfabe differs only in matters of degree from another common human practice: lying.</p><p>I think where we start to run into trouble with this is when the deployment of kayfabe-adjacent behaviors loses the wink that makes the multivalent understanding of the underlying phenomena possible. Wrestling would be dumb and kind of suck shit to watch without the winking acknowledgement that something else is happening other than what you’re seeing and what’s being said aloud.</p><p>I’m thinking, perhaps obviously, now about the ways in which the internet and its sprawling digital social networks which largely serve to breakdown the self into a more malleable target for advertising have made possible the rampant spread of conspiracy theories and misinformation that is then both shared in bad faith by malignant actors who steadfastly refuse to wink and by folks who (maybe?) take it all as fact.</p><p>Again, the issue I run up against here is that same thing that I find myself coming back to as I consider the ancient Greeks and their gods of Olympus- can you really believe something when the truth is so obviously in front of you? Can you believe that there is a pizza shop with a pedophilic capitalist cabal hanging out in the basement in the same way that you can believe that a mountain that you can see and very much climb and investigate also houses your all-powerful gods? Or is this all kayfabe in the same way that wrestling is and I am just out of tune with the winks and nods and whatever else is happening?</p><p>I genuinely don’t know, and it’s maddening how much you can be shut out of knowing what (or if) a person is really thinking by their steadfast refusal to tell you and just as steadfast refusal to wink. Does the Q-Anon follower who thinks that Donald Trump will be back in office in August of 2021 with Joe Biden and Hilary Clinton serving as his human footstools for the remainder of his term thanks to a forthcoming SCOTUS decision really think that this will happen? Or is that in itself some kind of wink as the story conveys some kind of truth on a frequency that I am just unable to hear? I honestly have no idea. The Russian trolls who parrot and even create this information, for example, don’t believe it, and they don’t have to. They honestly don’t care if the people who read it actually believe, they just know that the world will be better for them if people acted as if they did believe it. It might be the same with the people reading it and resharing it. It’s probably some complex mix of both. It’s worth considering more deeply. I don’t have a lot of answers.</p><p>Breaking away from the generalized ways in which kayfabe and kayfabe-adjacent activities have come to shape the broader world we live in, I’ve been also reflecting on something significantly more personal to me, which is how this concept might apply to my own understanding of and relationship to religion.</p><p><a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/empty-tombs-and-rothko-rooms-art-easter-and-the-language-of-redemption-2296b36f2d02">I’ve written before how the idea of asking whether or not I believe in specific portions of the Catholic faith feels more and more like an incidental question, not unlike asking whether or not I believe in calculus or music as I consider what we can glean from a particular equation or what I feel when listening to piece by Beethoven.</a> The Catholic faith and the regular practice of it reveals to me truths about myself and my relationship with other human beings that would otherwise remain forgotten, hidden, or both from my underdeveloped and egocentric person- what would it mean to not believe in that? Do you believe in the third derivative?</p><p>That said, I definitely engage in the kayfabe of the whole enterprise on a weekly basis. I profess the creed at mass every week, even when I don’t feel the truth of it down to the core of my being.</p><p>Call it my teleological suspension of the theological- I have come to living my life in a way where the absence of requiring true theological belief while engaging in religious practice can actually lead me to better embracing the principles that these theological beliefs might call for.</p><p>This is not to say that I do not want to believe, or even that I have given up on striving to understand the deeper truths that striving for belief might unlock for me. It’s frankly just unrealistic for me to demand that I believe all the time. My broken and faillible body does not really even make it possible</p><p>Speaking of calculus, I also consider it this way.</p><p>Consider a function with an infinite discontinuity at the finite point 0, like the following:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/754/1*xIl4a6D0cjBkPEoOtgn3yw.png" /></figure><p>For me, true faith exists at the vertical asymptote in this function. Faith is at 0. <a href="https://mike-mesterharm.medium.com/unwilled-inheritances-and-terrifying-passengers-on-depression-entropy-and-systemic-inequality-409f2b2f9a">Given the finite and failing nature of my physical body, I cannot ever really hope to reach the point of full belief because full belief and full understanding would be the same. Since I am limited by my physicality, since disorder is baked into the very core of my physical self, I will surely fail to come to perfect knowledge of any kind, and unfortunately for me, thanks to another fact of my genetic wiring, this also tends to diminish or even preclude faith in the binary sense.</a></p><p>It’s in this that understanding that I’ve freed myself from the guilt and angst that I so often felt about my own inability to “just believe” in something. The limit of my own theological function as I approach full faith is infinity- I will not attain it in this life or in this body. Does this mean that it is not worth examining these discontinuities? Of course not. They form the basis for one of the greatest revolutions and leaps forward in the history of human knowledge.</p><p>These functions will never reach the point of the discontinuity, but we can certainly learn a lot from working the equations as if they might. They might not make it to the finite point at 0, but they push on toward infinity merely by approaching it. What is the limit as we push ourselves to approach faith?</p><p>I will never understand the divine mysteries described by the great faith traditions of this world, but I can certainly lead a richer and better life by working to live as if I did understand fully and thus did believe. Perhaps in this work I will find myself creeping further and further up the vertical asymptote toward heights of knowledge and understanding that I cannot yet conceive or touch.</p><p>Maybe this is also part of this whole kayfabe thing. Maybe we’re wired to want to believe things that we know are not rationally true provided that these beliefs give us something. Maybe it’s why we used to have playground debates about the reality of pro wrestling years after literal sworn testimony in a federal court should have put it to rest. It gave us a new set of identities to cling to during the weirdness and pain of torturous adolescence. Perhaps religion is an emergent property of human consciousness, perhaps ONLY an emergent property of human consciousness. <a href="http://jeffguhin.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/The-Ongoing-Plausibility-of-Peter-Berger.pdf">It gives us the sacred canopy under which our social bonds can be more strongly anchored and we can safely overcome our baser, more animal instincts and flourish in larger civilized groups.</a></p><p>I think it may be the case that our richest and most important understandings of ourselves and our world and how we all fit together can come when we can achieve something of the winking status that pro wrestling has attained, when kayfabe is maintained but as an open secret, when we can shed the binary of belief and non-belief and embrace the gray space that our flawed natures seem to always create. Perhaps pro wrestling can actually show us one useful model of how rational and irrational/supra-rational world views can not only coexist in the world but sit side by side in our minds and enhance our communal existence.</p><p>I know that there’s magic in the act of believing but there’s also magic in the separate interpretation of a rational reality that lies underneath everything. The real magic lies in the multivalent understandings that we can only open up by holding these two frames together. I can know that it may not necessarily be rational or be “real”, but dammit, it’s still real to me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=975f25e997a4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>