<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mirrors of Play on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mirrors of Play on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mirrorsofplay?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 06:47:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mirrorsofplay/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Wants to Kill ‘Werewolf’?]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/who-wants-to-kill-werewolf-f3a514c328f9?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3a514c328f9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[werewolf]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Jul 2026 08:45:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-31T08:45:44.896Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>In the Clutches of a Global Genre</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KMvGHGGpW3YKEmviInGsxQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Surprising as it may seem, sociology tells us that only a few years ago, more than 70% of French people had never even heard of <em>The Werewolves of Miller’s Hollow</em> (Berry &amp; Coavoux, 2021). This despite the concept’s worldwide success, its first French edition dating back to 2001, and the affection held for the game by virtually every scout camp in the country. All of this is likely about to change with the game’s adaptation into a <em>Jumanji</em>-like feature film and, perhaps even more significantly, a television game show produced by Canal+.</p><p><em>The Werewolves of Miller’s Hollow</em> belongs to the family of “social deduction games,” alongside many others such as <em>The Resistance</em>, <em>Secret Hitler</em>, <em>Sporz</em>, <em>Shadow Hunters</em>, <em>Jinrou</em>, <em>Blood on the Clocktower</em>, and even the video game <em>Among Us</em>.</p><p>Yet the success of its lupine variant has become so overwhelming that it is no longer unusual to speak of an entire genre: the “werewolf game.” Its major motifs are now well established: hidden roles, an informed minority versus an uninformed majority, voting phases, special powers to spice things up, but above all a game structure built around speech and communication.</p><p>In this article, I wanted to move beyond the usual debate of whether one loves or hates <em>Werewolf</em> and instead ask what is truly at stake in a game of <em>The Werewolves of Miller’s Hollow</em>. What does this game, which leaves crowds thoroughly bitten, actually tell us?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*18x9GgLEmn2vVvl_h-yPiQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>GrabFood Ma dói</em></strong>, a vietnamese version of the game — The French movie <strong><em>Loups Garous</em></strong> (François Uzan, 2024)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Emergence of a Popular Game</h3><p>The history of <em>Werewolf</em> is a winding one, though its major milestones are relatively well documented. At its origin lies an embryonic game: <em>Mafia</em>, imagined in Moscow during the mid-1980s and rooted in the tradition of experimental psychology. Role asymmetry, debate, and voting were already present — the rest would merely become variations on the same formula. The format proved appealing and quickly spread beyond classrooms and dormitories. Easy to organise, entertaining to play, and highly effective at creating social bonds, it had all the makings of a future hit.</p><p>Imported into the United States, the game underwent a thematic makeover during the 1990s, replacing mobsters with werewolves and introducing special characters such as the Seer, thus giving rise to <em>Werewolf</em>. Today, in France, it is <em>The Werewolves of Miller’s Hollow</em> that remains the most familiar incarnation of the genre, recognisable through its small square box and its curious swastika-like emblem, inherited from the former publisher Lui-Même (since acquired by Asmodee). Yet these flagship titles are merely the tip of the iceberg: dozens of variations on the concept exist, particularly across Asia, not to mention online adaptations and the countless mutations created by fan communities.</p><p>This capacity for reinterpretation and appropriation (Becker, 2020) is probably one of the key factors behind the game’s transition into the realm of the commons. Thanks to the minimalism of its components and rules, the genre takes on a life of its own: it transforms, evolves, and generates a myriad of avatars, communities, fan-made creations, and derivative cultural products (including, unfortunately, a film). Today, it belongs to our shared cultural heritage.</p><p>But perhaps its success also stems from the fact that the game’s structure reproduces a situation that is both rare and necessary: the exercise of collective, unconstrained decision-making. Through a simple protocol and a temporary community, <em>Werewolf</em> offers an experience of democracy stripped to the bone. The life and death of members of the community are decided through votes, alliances, and majorities. The game produces a ritualistic, almost mystical experience in which all the fantasies — and realities — of organised society are reenacted and fulfilled: manipulation, deceit, paranoia, blind lynching, and the rule of the mob.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XxgDM11R_a40UezmDTd7Cg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Wolf </em></strong>(Mike Nichols, 1994) — “A Game of Deception, Paranoia, and Mob Rule” : original rules of <em>Werewolf</em></figcaption></figure><h3>The Randomness of Roles</h3><p>In <em>Werewolf</em>, each player receives a card that secretly defines their role (villager, werewolf, or another special character, generally considered part of the village faction). This initial random allocation erases any predetermined team composition, disregarding potential affinities or predispositions toward a particular role. Yet while blind distribution is a fundamental assumption of game culture, it is by no means devoid of meaning.</p><p>In a game that reveals group dynamics and power relationships through emergent play, the randomness of roles compels players to step outside their <em>habitus</em>. The genealogy of social position is thus suspended: I wake up one day guilty or innocent. From that moment on, any defence must be constructed <em>ad hoc</em>. It cannot rely on a lifetime of duplicity or integrity — I will have to improvise myself.</p><p>Here lies the first worm in the democratic apple that the game invites us to bite into: the obliteration of all past history. A game of <em>Werewolf</em> is disconnected from any broader context; it exists in a vacuum. The village that awakens has no History — other than that of previous games and the familiarity among players — it has only beliefs. Does not the worst of our societies emerge precisely from the substitution of one for the other?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q8mF143U9sfbDvmxNkaBBQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>12 angry men </em></strong>(Sydney Lumet, 1957) — <strong><em>Mafia </em></strong>(Dimitry Davidoff, published by Art. Lebedev Studio, 2007)</figcaption></figure><h3>Werewolf Heuristics: The Strategy of Survival</h3><p>Although structured around two opposing camps, <em>Werewolf</em> is fundamentally an individualistic game: everyone wants to save their own skin. Strategies therefore operate with this single objective in mind, under the guise of defending the community. This is where the game’s depth resides — and where the mirror it holds up to us becomes most revealing: the pursuit of my own self-interest may contribute to the survival of the collective. Every player is thus confronted with the same question: what way of playing will benefit me the most?</p><p>A game’s “heuristics” (Elias et al., 2012) encompass both an informed reading of the current state of play and the strategic possibilities available to players. One can distinguish between “positional heuristics” (who is currently winning?) and “directional heuristics” (which strategy should I adopt to move toward victory?). A game’s heuristics are almost never explicitly stated in its rulebook: they are fundamentally emergent and must be discovered — or transmitted — through repeated play. Some are immediately accessible to novice players. Others, more complex, only reveal themselves at intermediate or advanced levels of expertise.</p><p>In the case of <em>Werewolf</em>, heuristics are at once straightforward and remarkably complex, precisely because they depend so heavily on group composition, the personalities involved, individual charisma, and each player’s persuasive abilities. This is one of the game’s great attractions: no strategy is guaranteed to succeed and must constantly be reassessed. Excessive zeal directed against another player may easily backfire against you: where does your certainty come from? Could it not be that you yourself are the werewolf?</p><blockquote>“Is a large group of uninformed individuals more powerful than an informed elite?” — <em>Dmitry Davidoff, creator of Mafia</em></blockquote><p>Too quiet? Suspicious. Too talkative? Suspicious. Even the most gifted speakers are not always destined to prevail: in this context, competence itself can appear threatening. One effective strategy therefore consists in using the weight of the group to eliminate a leader or a player who, were they to confront you directly, would prove more skilled than you. It is a familiar manoeuvre, found not only in televised survival competitions and multiplayer games of <em>Magic: The Gathering</em>, but also within institutions, businesses, and public administrations.</p><p>Ultimately, the primary heuristic of <em>Werewolf</em> is moderation. One must be present and engaged — but not excessively so; discreet and measured — but not too much. In short, one must appear, in the eyes of others, as a figure of wisdom whose judgement is sound and whose words can be trusted. In a single phrase: one must become a good influencer. The connection with the contemporary meaning of the term is hardly accidental: we place our trust in these polarising figures and relinquish the critical thinking necessary for the formation of our own judgement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*buyrLXWjZBAM8JoVgi26pQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>The Chase </em></strong>(Arthur Penn, 1966)</figcaption></figure><h3>Pleading Ex Nihilo</h3><p>Communication and discourse analysis lie at the very heart of <em>Werewolf</em>. The problem is that, at the outset… there is nothing to analyse. Tangible evidence only emerges over time: the longer the game lasts, the more behaviours become legible, positions clarify, alliances take shape, and convictions strengthen, fuelled by the revelation of the roles of eliminated players. Accusers refine their arguments based on the accuracy of their previous suspicions.</p><p>A large part of the game therefore consists of forming opinions about those around us without any support other than intuition, direct observation, and the interpretation of immediate signs. The first accusations are necessarily arbitrary, based on a detail, a glance, a suspicious silence — or even a haircut. One false move and the entire group may turn against you: after all, it is always more comfortable to accuse someone else, even an innocent person, than to become the target of suspicion oneself.</p><p><em>Werewolf</em> perfectly embodies the subtle art of constructing meaning out of nothing. By the end of a game, players will have succeeded in developing an entire framework of values, trust, and ethics without any fundamental axioms to sustain it. At the foundation of everything lies nothing tangible — only air and doubt.</p><p><em>Werewolf</em> is therefore, quite rightly, inhabited entirely by the question of trust, particularly within the majority group of villagers. How can I know who is my ally and who is my enemy? Around me, there are only masks dancing, and my survival depends upon a leap of faith: the decision to take another person’s word at face value.</p><p>In this sense, <em>Werewolf</em> reminds us that within an organised society — or even within a friendship or a romantic relationship — the trust we place in others begins with a choice, whether reasoned or instinctive. This gift of trust forms the foundation of every community. Yet the premise remains fragile: once doubt has entered the crack in my credulity, how can I continue to believe? A lesson, perhaps, for politicians and unfaithful spouses alike.</p><blockquote>“Honest players have to suspect everybody, but they have an advantage of being the majority.” — Mafia <em>rulebook</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CkULQ-zjbCn1Vph9DXr6yg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Trial</strong> (Orson Welles, 1962) — <strong>Concetto spaziale</strong> (Lucio Fontana, 1968)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Death of Evidence</h3><p>The Other may not be who they claim to be — a timeless anxiety running through human history. This is precisely why the werewolf theme has never felt more relevant: it evokes the panic-inducing fear of alterity concealed within sameness, fertile ground for all the irrational excesses of crowd behaviour: suggestibility, “contagion,” irresponsibility (Le Bon, 1895).</p><p>If <em>Werewolf</em> resonates so strongly today, it is because it aligns perfectly with our age of “post-truth,” in which emotional appeal often outweighs the temperance of facts. Political debate, social media, and games of <em>Werewolf</em> are merely some of the arenas shaped by this marginalisation of critical thinking. And even if the concept of post-truth remains contested — emotions have, after all, always played a role in decision-making — it nonetheless remains true that within our “democracy of the credulous,” we frequently fail in our responsibility to rationalise information and remain, by our very nature, highly susceptible to systems of belief.</p><blockquote>“The regime of knowledge made possible by scientific progress is an exceptional regime, whereas belief is our normal condition. We are creatures of belief.” — <em>Gérald Bronner, interview, 2017</em></blockquote><p>In <em>Werewolf</em>, as on the internet, the distinction between truth and falsehood becomes relative: all that matters is one’s response to the attacks seeking to discredit and eliminate us. Since debates revolve less around facts than around feelings, the appearance of truth becomes sufficient, so long as it reinforces our convictions and enables us to belong to an identity group that ensures our survival. The reality of evidence no longer matters. Beyond a certain accumulation of interpretative layers, the edifice of our reasoning eventually forgets that it was originally built upon nothing more than an idiosyncratic belief.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3NEg_Ly2B61nSNp6vFyS3A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Sporz Original Outbreak </em></strong>(2011, Éditions La Donzelle) — <strong><em>The Thing</em> </strong>(John Carpenter, 1982)</figcaption></figure><h3>A Lesson for the Future</h3><p><em>Werewolf</em> is, in miniature, an exercise in collective life — both fascinating and terrifying, marked by a biting cynicism. On the one hand, it serves as a training ground for wolves in sheep’s clothing: how does one deceive others while maintaining dominance over the uninformed? On the other, it offers a scaled-down lesson in the mechanisms of eroding trust: how does paranoia give rise to blind violence?</p><p>At its core, the original sin dramatized by the game may well be that of opacity — the lack of transparency surrounding roles, intentions, and motives. A perfect reflection of the culture of secrecy that permeates our societies, the hidden-role mechanic alone is sufficient to open Pandora’s box of our alienations.</p><p>Beyond the horizon lies, if not the outright destruction of the social body, then at least its gradual erosion. How can we escape the deadlock of the werewolves, if not through ever greater transparency, honesty, and trust? Might <em>Werewolf</em>, in the end, constitute a plea for a society that is less opaque and more open? Indeed, it may finally be time for the village to wake up.</p><h3>References</h3><blockquote>Aho-Nienne, Céline (2021). “Who Owns <em>The Werewolves of Miller’s Hollow</em>? Revisiting a Game That Became a Common Good.” Published on the Okopix website. Available online.</blockquote><blockquote>Becker, Iniz (2020). <em>Transmedia Practices and Appropriation Practices within Social Deduction Game Communities: The Case of Werewolf</em>. Master’s thesis in Information and Communication Studies, supervised by Clotilde Chevet, CELSA — Sorbonne Université. Available online.</blockquote><blockquote>Berry, Vincent &amp; Coavoux, Samuel (2021). “‘Who Wants to Play Monopoly?’ Board Game Cultures and Practices in France.” <em>Sciences du jeu</em>, 14.</blockquote><blockquote>Elias, G. S., Garfield, R., &amp; Gutschera, K. R. (2012). <em>Characteristics of Games</em>. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.</blockquote><blockquote>Le Bon, Gustave (1895). <em>The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind</em>.</blockquote><blockquote>Olicard, Fabien (2023). “The Secret (and Not So Pretty) History of <em>The Werewolves of Miller’s Hollow</em>.” Published on the CKanKonJoue channel. Available online.</blockquote><blockquote>Tuckman, Bruce &amp; Jensen, Mary Ann (1977). “Stages of Small-Group Development Revisited.” <em>Group &amp; Organization Management</em>, 2.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3a514c328f9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pandemic Legacy: Learning to Govern]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/pandemic-legacy-learning-to-govern-cfb673776ef5?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cfb673776ef5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-studies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Jul 2026 03:07:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-07T03:07:02.544Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>What a Board Game Can Teach Us About Leadership</strong></h4><p><em>For those who read French, you can find the </em><a href="https://ludogamie.com/pandemic-legacy-apprendre-a-gouverner/"><em>the original article here</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hMlCwnRUZpJUrnSoYSZjjg.jpeg" /></figure><p>In many ways, board games can be understood as loops.</p><p>There is, first of all, what game designers call the <strong>gameplay loop</strong>: the sequence of actions that players repeat from the beginning of the game until its resolution. It forms the mechanical heart of the experience and can itself exist within larger loops. A turn belongs to a round, a round belongs to a game, and a game belongs to the broader ritual that stretches from opening the box to packing everything away again.</p><p>From the outward flow of components to their eventual return, the board game traditionally describes a circle. It begins in one state and ends in precisely the same one: the beast goes back into its cardboard cage.</p><p>With the arrival of <strong>legacy games</strong>, however, another geometric figure emerged: the arrow.</p><p>The game can now end in a different state from the one in which it began. While the familiar gameplay loops remain intact, something else progresses. The experience leaves a trace.</p><p>Traditionally, board games operate according to the logic of the reset. Every completed session is followed by a ritual return to the original state. Components are sorted, decks are rebuilt, tokens are redistributed. The game becomes ready to be played again, exactly as before.</p><p>Legacy games challenge this fundamental assumption. There is no going back.</p><p>First explored with <em>Risk Legacy</em> in 2011, the format gained widespread recognition with the success of <em>Pandemic Legacy</em> (2015), which has since expanded into a trilogy. In their most radical form, legacy games permanently transform their own material as players progress through the campaign. Cards are torn up. Stickers are applied to boards and rulebooks. Players write directly onto components.</p><p>These alterations are often the consequences of decisions made during play or of events triggered by the game’s evolving narrative.</p><p>In doing so, legacy systems invite players to question some of board gaming’s most deeply held assumptions: the idea that exploration should be free of consequences, or that replayability is the ultimate measure of value (Daviau, 2017).</p><p>Like a bowling ball crashing through a line of pins, legacy games disrupted the way we think about board games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-DGJNOxkdaqZ9uHMGJ0bfA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Outbreak</strong> (Wolfgang Petersen, 1981) —<strong> <em>Groundhog Day</em> </strong>(Harold Ramis, 1993)</figcaption></figure><h3>Episodic Play</h3><p><em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em> (2017), which concerns us here, is a game that demands time.</p><p>At a minimum, players will complete thirteen sessions — assuming they succeed on their first attempt each month — with each game lasting roughly forty-five to sixty minutes. The components may remain set up between sessions, quietly occupying part of the household landscape rather than disappearing back into the box.</p><p>Over time, the game becomes an anticipated appointment. It creates a form of companionship that bears a striking resemblance to watching a television series.</p><p>More specifically: a suspenseful espionage thriller.</p><p>All the genre’s familiar ingredients are present. The relentless pacing. The constant pressure. The dramatic reversals. Even the names of the laboratories encountered throughout the campaign — OPAL, JADE, PEARL, TOPAZ — sound like intelligence agency code names.</p><p>The <strong>supplies</strong> and <strong>cures</strong> pursued by the players function as Hitchcockian <strong>MacGuffins</strong>: narrative pretexts that propel the plot forward while their precise nature remains largely irrelevant. Like secret documents, bomb codes, or lists of undercover agents, their importance lies not in what they are, but in what they motivate.</p><p>The players’ actions themselves reproduce the classic gestures of the spy genre. They race from city to city. They exchange crucial information at the last possible moment. They uncover previously hidden aspects of the world. They gain access to fragments of vital knowledge.</p><p>Where traditional board games present themselves in their entirety from the outset — rules, components, possibilities all immediately available — <em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em> cultivates a sustained sense of discovery by withholding much of its content until specific moments in the campaign.</p><p>This “lock and gate” mechanic (Elias &amp; Egelston, 2019) contributes to the gradual process of understanding so characteristic of espionage fiction.</p><p>Spy stories often begin by plunging both protagonists and audiences into confusion and uncertainty.</p><p><em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em> follows the same logic.</p><p>Players encounter fragmented histories, an incomplete map of the world, and mysterious rulebooks containing conspicuous gaps. Gradually, however, the pieces begin to align. The puzzle takes shape. Meaning emerges.</p><p>The transformation of the game’s material becomes, in turn, a witness to the passage of time within the fiction itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9jmNu5JDSKsNxKZQWGWL-w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Torn Curtain</em></strong> (Alfred Hitchcock, 1966) — <strong><em>Cliffhanger</em> </strong>(Renny Harlin, 1993)</figcaption></figure><p>As Rob Daviau himself has explained, the campaign was structured from the outset around the three-act framework of classical storytelling (Daviau, 2017). The narrative was then fragmented and distributed across a succession of cards, gradually revealed and assembled into a coherent whole as players progressed through the game.</p><p>The design also makes extensive use of what screenwriters sometimes call <strong>“milking”</strong>: the art of stretching limited narrative material across a longer duration. With relatively few major events, the game nevertheless manages to sustain an entire season’s worth of suspense.</p><p>As is often the case in board games, this authored content intertwines with the players’ own secondary narratives. From one session to the next, stories emerge organically around the table: the spectacular mistake that almost doomed humanity, the impossible comeback, the heated argument over priorities, the triumphant final turn.</p><p>In the end, these are often the moments that matter most.</p><p>The game remains episodic to the very end. New regions of the world are gradually added to the board. New objectives emerge. Additional effects and constraints reshape familiar situations. The campaign continually engineers its own <strong>cliffhangers</strong>, creating the irresistible desire to discover what happens next — or simply to play one more session.</p><p>The sensation of progression is first and foremost visual.</p><p>The spaces marking completed months are crossed out. Torn cards accumulate beside the board. Secret compartments are opened one by one.</p><p>Combined with the game’s temporal structure, these hidden boxes evoke something very close to an <strong>Advent calendar</strong>, recreating the same mixture of anticipation and impatience. Each revelation becomes a small ritual of discovery.</p><p>Much like binge-watching a television series, players quickly develop a compulsive desire to know how the story ends — alongside an equally powerful determination to save the world.</p><p>These parallels with serialized storytelling reveal the permeability of games within the broader cultural ecosystem that surrounds them (see, on this subject, our article on <em>Unmatched</em>). Play constantly evolves by borrowing forms, rhythms, and devices from other narrative media.</p><p>In this sense, the ways we play — our postures, our pacing, our rituals — may represent only a small part of a much larger continent that remains to be explored.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nePnKAS_M-f25pKVe1ADRQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em></strong> — Game components</figcaption></figure><h3>A Clever Illusion</h3><p>Take a pattern, repeat it, and you have the beginnings of a game.</p><p>Repetition has always been one of the driving forces of play — perhaps even its founding principle. Most games invite us to revisit the same structures over and over again.</p><p>In <em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em>, players spend much of their time making and unmaking. They prepare decks, distribute infection cubes, organise components, and then carefully restore everything at the end of each session.</p><p>This resembles Penelope’s endless weaving and unweaving: a perpetual labour undertaken in the hope of holding disaster at bay.</p><p>The repetition evokes many of our own daily struggles — feeding ourselves, preserving peace, maintaining self-control — endeavours whose success depends less on grand gestures than on patient consistency.</p><p>And yet, from the outside, the game appears to evolve dramatically from one session to the next.</p><p>The board transforms. The map expands. Cards are destroyed. Rules seem to change constantly. By the end of the campaign, the game feels almost unrecognisable.</p><p>Plot twist: <strong>its underlying mechanics have barely changed at all.</strong></p><p>This is where the brilliance of <em>Pandemic Legacy: Season </em>2’s design truly lies: its ability to create the <strong>illusion of radical transformation</strong>.</p><p>Part of the confusion stems from the inherently slippery nature of what we call a <strong>game mechanic</strong>.</p><p>Although designers have produced countless lists, taxonomies, and encyclopaedias of mechanics, these remain merely particular ways of describing systems. Mechanics are indispensable tools for designing games — and, indeed, for marketing them — but they become much more porous when subjected to analytical scrutiny.</p><p>Determining where one mechanic ends and another begins is ultimately a matter of perspective. A cluster of actions that one observer identifies as a distinct mechanic may, for another, dissolve into more fundamental axioms or become absorbed within a broader system.</p><p>As a result, different players may perceive the same game through entirely different mechanical lenses.</p><p>The mechanics of <em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em> are, in fact, relatively easy to identify and remain remarkably stable throughout the campaign: action points, hand management, cooperation, pick-up-and-delivery, and so on (the BoardGameGeek taxonomy provides a useful overview).</p><p>What truly evolves are not the mechanics themselves, but what we might call their <strong>modifiers</strong>.</p><p>Consider a simple example.</p><p>The base rules state that players may only give a city card to another player if they occupy the same city and if the card being transferred corresponds to that location.</p><p>Later in the campaign, a new rule appears:</p><p>players may now exchange any city card while occupying a particular type of location, regardless of where the recipient is, provided the card shares the colour of the city they currently inhabit.</p><p>The mechanic — <strong>giving a card to another player</strong> — remains intact. Only the conditions governing its application have changed. This is where the designers demonstrate remarkable ingenuity.</p><p>They make an evolving format possible through a system of communicating vessels. As players acquire favourable modifiers that expand their capabilities, the game simultaneously introduces new constraints that increase the overall challenge.</p><p>Occasionally, genuinely new actions emerge. Players may, for example, construct <strong>shelters</strong>, protecting characters from infection under certain circumstances. Yet even these additions are largely variations built upon existing foundations.</p><p>The same principle applies to the campaign’s countless evolving rules governing cards, movement, buildings, populations, and resources.</p><p>The engine itself never changes. Only the scenery surrounding it does.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Eto3b3QvN-qnctVh50n33w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Heisenberg’s Magic Mirror of Uncertainty</em></strong> (Duane Michals, 1998) — <strong><em>The Persistence of Memory</em></strong> (Salvador Dalí, 1931)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Accounting of the Post-Apocalyptic World</h3><p>Board games offer no shortage of opportunities to save the world. The real challenge lies in deciding by what means, through which mechanics and narrative devices, players might actually experience the emotions attached to such a responsibility.</p><p><em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em> immerses players in a retro-post-apocalyptic world. Humanity has fled a devastating plague and taken refuge in offshore havens — isolated islands cut off from the rest of the world.</p><p>As in any society turned inward upon itself, the Other becomes an abstraction.</p><p>The enemy becomes a concept.</p><p>Players must contend with the threat posed by the <strong>Hollow Men</strong>, as the game calls these faceless bands of raiders who spread the disease. Their presence is diffuse and invisible. Significantly, the original English term — <em>Hollow Men</em> — evokes emptiness more than monstrosity, referring less to zombies than to figures deprived of substance.</p><p><em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em> tells us something about the way self-sufficiency distances us from embodied forms of antagonism and encourages a binary vision of the world, one in which Good and Evil remain clearly identifiable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sz_3SdAp9YRpCA161YJ2bA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Waterworld</em> </strong>(Kevin Reynolds, 1995) — <strong><em>Hollow Man</em></strong> (Paul Verhoeven, 2000)</figcaption></figure><p>Although the action takes place on Earth and invites players to reconnect real cities — Paris, New York, Kinshasa, and others — the overall movement of the game is toward a higher level of abstraction.</p><p>The cities on the board possess neither countries nor cultures.</p><p>They are defined only through factual and utilitarian characteristics: whether they contain a port (allowing “teleportation” to another port through a special action), the number of connections they maintain with neighbouring cities (are they hubs or dead ends?), and the size of their population, represented by a value that fluctuates throughout the campaign and determines their capacity to withstand future waves of infection.</p><p>Players are thus confronted with a schematic world reduced to numbers.</p><p>It is here that <em>Pandemic Legacy: Season 2</em> reveals a form of relentless — and yet remarkably lucid — cynicism: crisis management causes human beings to disappear behind figures, replacing lived experience with an accounting view of reality.</p><p>The various story cards gradually revealed throughout the campaign struggle to restore flesh and complexity to these computational mechanics.</p><p>The player characters suffer a similar fate.</p><p>At the beginning of the game, we assign them names, ages, and portraits.</p><p>Very quickly, however, they become reduced to their function. They are little more than cogs within a larger machine, distinguished only by the powers and special abilities they contribute to the group.</p><p>They are scarcely more than archetypes: the Scientist, the Biologist, the Soldier.</p><p>The game therefore allows us to experience governance itself: a simulation of decision-making at the highest level, in which individuals become variables. A number in a spreadsheet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rb2c8V-E1YRQ0hZidiICqw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Suprematist Composition</em> </strong>(Kazimir Malevich, 1915) — <strong><em>Good Kill</em> </strong>(Andrew Niccol, 2014)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Torn Veil</h3><p>Not all legacy games require players to literally destroy their components. In fact, this remains relatively uncommon: only around a third of legacy games make use of such spectacular forms of irreversibility (Xiang, 2020). Yet conferences and articles devoted to the topic tend to repeat the same refrain: “It’s traumatic for gamers.”</p><p>This visceral discomfort surrounding the destruction of game components is, in itself, rather surprising. We spend our days destroying and discarding things — packaging, disposable products, and, the more cynical among us might add, lives. Other games, such as crossword puzzles or Sudoku books, exist precisely through their one-time use.</p><p>And yet, because we are dealing with a “proper” board game — an object we have purchased, collected, and grown attached to — the very same destructive gesture suddenly takes on a different meaning. The joy of destruction is, however, one of childhood’s great motifs. What happened in the meantime?</p><p>Legacy games reveal the profound attachment to material possessions that characterises Western societies. The sociology of legacy players — a niche within the niche of modern board gaming — would probably reveal a population particularly attached to material comfort. Legacy games are expensive and, despite their mainstream success, still retain something of the avant-garde. They might not the games one casually brings out after Sunday lunch with the family.</p><p>The anxiety provoked by destruction therefore belongs to a very particular social group, caught between its affection for play and the luxuries afforded by consumer society. To destroy the object that brings us joy is to threaten our ideal way of life. It is to tear apart the magical veil surrounding games — a world in which going backwards is always possible. Suddenly, my actions have real consequences.</p><p>I become responsible for my choices. And I must live with them.</p><p>This is where destructive legacy games mark a fascinating turning point in the history of board games. The formula was nevertheless quickly absorbed and softened by the market. New forms of non-destructive legacy games emerged: “evolving” games capable of being reset. Players were reassured: the breach had closed. The components had been saved. The world had returned to its normal state, that is to say: <em>infinitely replayable</em>.</p><p>To be continued.</p><p><em>P.S. If you’ve made it this far, tear up your computer and go outside.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cfb673776ef5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unmatched: the Recycling of Imagination]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/unmatched-the-recycling-of-imagination-c59db2258570?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c59db2258570</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-studies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jun 2026 15:23:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-29T15:23:54.815Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What Remains After a Fight in the Void</h4><p><em>For those who read French, you can find the </em><a href="https://ludogamie.com/unmatched-mythologies-d-un-blockbuster/"><em>the original article here</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*ndUGvF42kLYO_4XYEBGYnQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>By now, Lewis Carroll, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, and H. G. Wells are probably turning in their graves.</p><p>Their iconic characters — Alice, Sherlock Holmes, and the Invisible Man — have been torn from their original worlds, cast into plastic miniatures, chopped into thirty-card decks, and thrown into an arena to fight to the death. Welcome to <em>Unmatched</em>.</p><p>One of the game’s great ideas has been to refresh its roster by drawing on literature (Dr. Jekyll, Dracula), popular culture (Robin Hood, King Arthur, Sinbad), and mythology (Medusa, Achilles).</p><p>In a mainstream imagination saturated by Marvel and Disney, such an approach has something genuinely intriguing — even seductive — about it. Although, it should be noted, Marvel has since managed to absorb the franchise itself by introducing no fewer than fifteen superheroes into the line-up.</p><p>Each character comes with a distinct playstyle, reinforcing the sensation of playing <em>as</em> them — or at least through the designers’ interpretation of these emblematic figures, which may sometimes overlap with the vague, archetypal image we ourselves carry of them.</p><p>This is the logic of the <strong>crossover</strong>, familiar from games such as <em>Smash Up</em> or <em>Villainous</em>. Their mechanics differ, but what they ultimately sell is the same thing: the permeability of fictional worlds.</p><p>Pandora’s box of the multiverse has been opened, and as long as the licensing rights can be secured, every hybridisation becomes possible.</p><p>Will we one day witness King Kong facing Bilbo Baggins? Tom Sawyer crossing swords with Gavroche? Harry Potter fighting Barbie? Vladimir Putin taking on Al Gore?</p><p>It is, in fact, rather surprising that <em>Unmatched</em> has yet to feature Frankenstein’s creature, since it could well serve as the perfect metaphor for these monstrous assemblages emerging from the entertainment industry’s factory of fantasies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*-gx7B1lGEl7LjKAWVq2iqg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Epic Rap Battles of History</em></strong> (Nice Peter &amp; EpicLLOYD, since 2010) — <strong><em>Frankenstein</em> </strong>(Kenneth Branagh, 1994)</figcaption></figure><p>In reality, what is taking place is far more serious: it is the swan song of imagination itself.</p><p>Reluctant to take the risk of exploring new horizons, the great marketplace of culture has found its own interpretation of sustainability: <em>infinite recycling</em>.</p><p>In <em>Unmatched</em>, the traditional hero is uprooted from their native soil — their original narrative habitat, one might say — and placed in a jar of chloroform.</p><p>They are drained of their blood — that is to say, of their meaning. Their identity solidifies into a necrotic form that the entertainment industry waves before our nostalgic eyes. Its practitioners are necromancers, and day after day we attend spectacles that increasingly smell of death. <em>Unmatched</em> is merely the latest incarnation of this colonisation of the imagination by an army of the undead.</p><p>When one remembers that <em>Unmatched</em> itself emerged from the exhumation of <em>Star Wars: Epic Duels</em> (by the same designer) combined with elements from <em>Tannhäuser</em>, this comes as no surprise: hybridisation is part of its DNA.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*2VClsURU0Ce9LnFX7laESA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Unmatched</em> </strong>game board — <strong><em>Counter-Strike</em></strong> (Valve, 2000)</figcaption></figure><h3>A Long-Distance Chase</h3><p>But what about the game itself?</p><p>If its theme confirms the standardisation of imagination eating away at a large part of the cultural landscape, do its mechanics at least manage to redeem Sherlock Holmes and company?</p><p>In <em>Unmatched</em>, the objective is simple: eliminate your opponents by reducing their health to zero. Players begin with five cards in hand and, on each turn, effectively receive two action points that may be used to:</p><ol><li>Draw a card and move (a combined action called <strong>Maneuver</strong>);</li><li>Attack an opponent by challenging them with a card;</li><li>Play a <strong>Scheme</strong>, activating a special ability.</li></ol><p>All of this unfolds within a closed arena divided into interconnected zones.</p><p>At the heart of the system lies a deceptively simple interaction: both players select a card face down and reveal it simultaneously. The higher value usually prevails.</p><p>What follows is a flurry of effects and abilities designed to modify the outcome by manipulating the game’s various variables — attack and defence values, card draw, positioning, and so forth.</p><p>For all its Tarantino-esque flair, <em>Unmatched</em> is fundamentally a game of <strong>War</strong>, crossed with tactical positioning and seasoned with bluffing.</p><p>But it is a game of War punctuated by ellipses. Players do not always possess the cards required to resolve a confrontation on their own terms. They wait for the right moment, the right opportunity, the right card.</p><p>In the meantime, they <em>wander</em>.</p><p>Because <em>Unmatched</em> is a game about movement. Movement is vital precisely because it allows players both to replenish their hands and to access the game’s other actions.</p><p>Depending on our cards — or our lack thereof — we spend our time either closing in on our prey or fleeing to recover our strength.The strategic challenge then becomes cutting off the retreat of an opponent who has exhausted their hand.</p><p>The game could almost have been called <strong>The Hunt</strong>, so pervasive is the anxious sensation that there is nowhere left to escape.</p><p>The board itself, as though borrowed from an introductory course in graph theory, is ultimately nothing more than a labyrinth folded back upon itself. Entrance and exit become one and the same. Players take turns embodying each other’s Minotaur.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*H19HGMTSz2BCAQp3QM8OwA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Sisyphus</em> </strong>(Jana Sterbak, 1998) —<strong> <em>The Shining</em></strong> (Stanley Kubrick, 1980)</figcaption></figure><h3>Mythological Torments</h3><p>This sensation of having nowhere left to run resonates with a feeling of powerlessness that regularly haunts the game.</p><p>Sometimes, it is the helplessness of being unable to defend oneself when challenged by an opponent while holding no defence cards. The attack lands mercilessly, and every point of damage goes through.</p><p>At other times, it is the helplessness of a character trapped in their space, surrounded by enemy fighters or sidekicks and unable to escape.</p><p>There is, finally, the helplessness that comes from exhausting one’s options. Faced with an empty or inadequate hand, retreat becomes the only sensible course of action.</p><p>Condemned to this necessary wandering, heroes — and players alike — are repeatedly invited to experience themselves as prisoners of circumstance, victims of a fate that relentlessly pursues them.</p><p>Looked at closely, <em>Unmatched</em> may well belong to the genre of <em>torments</em>.</p><p>On one side stands <strong>Sisyphus</strong> and his legendary boulder. <em>Unmatched</em> players are perpetually caught in a cycle of accumulation and depletion: the ebb and flow of the very thing that makes action possible — their hand of cards. For an empty hand is synonymous with death.</p><p>One must then undertake a slow resurrection, painstakingly rebuilding one’s capacity for harm through successive Maneuvers, all in the hope of drawing the right card.</p><p>And this is where another punishment enters the stage: that of <strong>Tantalus</strong>, forever unable to reach the banquet laid before him.</p><p>Before us lies the object of desire: the perfect hand that will allow us to finish off our wounded opponent. Between ourselves and that royal flush stretch the infinite variations of the deck and all its disappointments.</p><p>Behind it all lurks one final torment: that of <strong>Prometheus</strong>.</p><p>Chained to the board itself — a network of interconnected paths — we are condemned to gnaw at our own livers until our strength gives out and another game begins anew.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*X8V1fTkGEbmMh8TEbNNBiA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Jurassic Park</em></strong> (Steven Spielberg, 1993) — <strong><em>Fight on the Sidewalk</em></strong> (Jeff Wall, 1994)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Meaning of the Brawl</h3><p>For all its blockbuster status, <em>Unmatched</em> has the feel of a street fight. Forget the boxing ring and the <em>dohyō</em>. Think instead of the alleyway and the parking lot.</p><p>This is the kingdom of near misses, quick knife thrusts, and chaotic scuffles. And therein lies the game’s central contradiction: it summons venerable figures — positive counterparts to our own imperfections, imbued with an aura of admiration and desire — only to bring them crashing down into the gutter.</p><p>Not content with disregarding the meanings originally carried by the stories from which it borrows, <em>Unmatched</em> completes its bleaching of the imagination through the degradation of the very heroes it invokes.</p><p>Culture — understood here as a subversive space for reinventing both the world and ourselves — died one Monday evening at 10 p.m. in a Burbank parking lot.</p><p>It is hardly a revelation to observe that board games do not escape the commodification of culture. <em>Unmatched</em>, for all the pleasure it offers and the genuinely enjoyable duels it creates, follows in the footsteps of works devoted to capitalism with a very short memory.</p><p>The point is no longer to celebrate history and its legacy, nor to seek within them some illumination of our present condition. No. Cultural recycling operates through cloning. From a single drop of blood, we have recreated a dinosaur — astonishing and terrifying in equal measure, but ultimately and desperately unnecessary.</p><p>Beneath the polished surface, we are standing still.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*kkfkreWuwk9xPIh4HIyiaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Unmatched: Bruce Lee</em></strong> — <strong><em>Miami Vice</em></strong> (Michael Mann, 2006)</figcaption></figure><p>And the formula works. New sets and expansions continue to appear: Bruce Lee, Buffy the Vampire Slayer…</p><p>We are told:</p><blockquote><em>“Unmatched</em> is more than a fighting game. It’s an invitation to cast yourself as the hero in an epic story, something Marvel has absolutely <em>no </em>shortage of.” <em>(</em><a href="https://mondoshop.com/blogs/news/4-new-marvel-themed-unmatched-game-titles-coming-from-mondo-restoration-games-in-2021"><em>Interview of Jayme Boucher</em></a><em>, Director of Games at Mondo)</em></blockquote><p>This kind of marketing discourse nevertheless reveals a certain blindness — whether conscious or not — to the processes at work behind such productions.</p><p>As though merely invoking a hero were enough to immerse us in their world, their texture, their sensuality. In truth, there is nothing inside these straw figures.</p><p>Everything is beautiful, polished, precise, and immediately legible — the essential ingredients of commercial success. And herein lies the system’s deepest ambiguity: its ability to be both hollow and desirable at once. Because it must be said: for all its contradictions, <em>Unmatched</em> remains a good game.</p><p>All things considered, there may still be one legendary duel missing from the collection: Jean Baudrillard versus Steve Jobs.</p><p>But we already know who won.</p><h3>Games Mentioned</h3><ul><li><em>Unmatched</em> — Rob Daviau, Justin D. Jacobson &amp; Brian Neff (Restoration Games, 2019)</li><li><em>Star Wars: Epic Duels</em> — Rob Daviau &amp; Craig Van Ness (Milton Bradley, 2002)</li><li><em>Tannhäuser</em> — William Grosselin &amp; Didier Poli (Fantasy Flight Games, 2007)</li><li><em>Smash Up</em> — Paul Peterson (Alderac Entertainment Group, 2012)</li><li><em>Disney Villainous</em> — Prospero Hall (Ravensburger, 2018)</li></ul><h3>Novel Mentioned</h3><ul><li><em>Frankenstein</em> — Mary Shelley (1818)</li><li><em>Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland</em> — Lewis Carroll (1865)</li><li><em>The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes</em> — Arthur Conan Doyle (1892)</li><li><em>The Invisible Man</em> — H. G. Wells (1897)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c59db2258570" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where's David Lynch?—The Gamification of Culture]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/wheres-david-lynch-the-gamification-of-culture-b6e573614fba?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6e573614fba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[david-lynch]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gamification]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-studies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Jun 2026 20:03:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-22T20:03:49.130Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Where’s David Lynch? — The Gamification of Culture</h3><h4><strong>Play as Symbolic Neutralisation</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*wrP-45NB-ii1ki5e-2UJoA.jpeg" /></figure><p>What exactly is the connection between the <em>Where’s Waldo?</em> books and the famous American filmmaker David Lynch? And why might these two worlds have been better off never ending up on the same page?</p><p>The answer to the first question can be found in a book: <em>Where’s David Lynch?</em>, published by the Australian publisher Smith Street Books. In a similarly playful spirit, this prolific publisher — creatively surfing the waves of popular culture — had previously released titles such as <em>Where’s David Bowie?</em> and <em>Where’s Prince?</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q650AS1tIzzfJbsJJJOZEw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The answer to the second question — the problem of David Lynch’s “Waldofication” — is precisely what this article seeks to explore.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yBFxv98gSth_buYxkNdWsA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The Art of Omniscience</h3><p>Let us begin with the playful dimension of this uncanny crossover. The <em>Where’s Waldo?</em> books, illustrated by British author Martin Handford, rose to prominence following their first publication in 1987. They are arguably the most famous children’s books in the world.</p><p>These books belong to the broader family of what Germans call <em>Wimmelbücher</em> (“hidden-object books”) or <em>Wimmelbilderbücher</em> (“hidden-object picture books”). The term refers to an entire constellation of works built around a game mechanic that game designers would describe as “search and find.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uFGnK99gp7pLiYlTowGzLg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Within images overflowing with detail, players must locate a specific character or object, sometimes under time constraints. The scenes depicted are often infused with humour and mischief, strengthening the sense of complicity between the work and its readers.</p><p>Every corner of the image tells a small story. Some can be grasped immediately, while others reveal themselves only through the accumulation of details — and this is precisely where their richness lies.</p><p>The <em>Wimmelbuch</em> tradition undoubtedly finds its origins in the paintings of fifteenth- and sixteenth-century Netherlandish artists such as Hieronymus Bosch and Pieter Bruegel the Elder. Although these works were not conceived as games, they nevertheless possessed this playful “search-and-find” quality.</p><p>As products of their time, these precursor paintings also served as vehicles for education and moral instruction. Like cathedral stained-glass windows or tapestries, the scenes they depicted carried a dense symbolic charge — a layer of signification that is far less present in contemporary <em>Wimmelbuch</em> productions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gBLYmfq-4DnxyUqECDutrw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Netherlandish Proverbs</em></strong> (Pieter Bruegel the Elder, 1559) —<strong> <em>Christ in Limbo</em> </strong>(Hieronymus Bosch, c. 1575)</figcaption></figure><p>The genre also found its way into video games from the earliest days of computer gaming, notably through point-and-click adventures such as <em>The Secret of Monkey Island</em> (LucasArts, 1990). Part of the experience consisted precisely in searching the on-screen environment for the detail that would unlock a situation or move an investigation forward.</p><p>Today, the genre is firmly established through a myriad of games explicitly built around this mechanic: hidden object games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oiXKxOTkv3EJ5fmRNUYYeg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Hidden City</strong> (G5 Entertainment, 2016) —<strong> <em>The Secret of Monkey Island</em></strong> (Lucas Art, 1990)</figcaption></figure><p>Board games, too, have embraced the format, most notably with the success of <em>MicroMacro: Crime City</em>, released in 2020, which adds investigative and narrative dimensions to the <em>Wimmelbuch</em> tradition — a genre that appears to be truly timeless.</p><h3>The Disappearance of Off-Screen Space</h3><p>The enduring appeal of search-and-find activities and the lasting success of the <em>Wimmelbuch</em> probably stem from one of the fundamental mechanisms of the human brain: pattern recognition. Our minds are machines designed to identify forms and patterns. The animal kingdom, of which we are unquestionably a part (despite some lingering doubts on the matter), has quite literally organised its survival around this ability. So-called generative AI, for that matter, is itself trained through pattern recognition.</p><p>Yet beyond the natural pleasure we derive from searching and finding, the <em>Wimmelbuch</em> tells us something far more specific: the disappearance of off-screen space.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tObn5nvi_zSiYEBNQTInRA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The arrival of the protagonist of <strong><em>Mulholland Drive</em></strong> in Los Angeles. The airport sequence is constructed around a significant reliance on off-screen space.</figcaption></figure><p>In cinema, off-screen space refers to everything that exists beyond the frame — that is, everything that remains unseen outside the square or rectangle within which moving images unfold. The manipulation of off-screen space is one of the hallmarks of great filmmakers, and David Lynch undoubtedly belongs among them. What remains outside the frame is sometimes far more powerful than what is shown.</p><p>A <em>Wimmelbuch</em>, however, offers an impossible and omniscient perspective: everything appears to be contained within the image and immediately accessible to our gaze. The player — or viewer — sees everything, producing an accompanying illusion of mastery. The universe becomes reassuring because everything is visible and therefore, in theory, understandable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CAh9PF801JCv47K9pAx7Tg.jpeg" /></figure><p>In <em>Where’s Waldo?</em> — and by extension in <em>Where’s David Lynch?</em> — the answer to the world’s riddle is already before our eyes. It is not hidden; it is merely submerged beneath an abundance of details and requires a little patience to uncover.</p><p>Here lies the first contradiction with the universe of David Lynch.</p><h3>The David Lynch Case</h3><h3>The Uncanny</h3><p>David Lynch was an American artist best known for films such as <em>Mulholland Drive</em>, <em>Blue Velvet</em>, and the television series <em>Twin Peaks</em>. His prominence within the world of cinema — and, more broadly, contemporary art — has even led to the adjective <em>Lynchian</em> becoming a relatively common aesthetic descriptor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mVunGKJYvsotdv9cee9ZGA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Put simply, most interpretations of Lynch’s work revolve around a central idea: the uncanny.</p><p>The uncanny is a concept theorised by Freud at the beginning of the twentieth century, based on the German word <em>unheimlich</em>, which translates roughly as “unfamiliar” or “uncanny.” Its root, <em>heim</em>, can refer both to “home” and to “that which is concealed.” The concept seeks to capture that moment when something familiar suddenly becomes unsettling, even terrifying. In Freud’s reading, the uncanny emerges when that which was meant to remain hidden reappears — the return of the repressed is never far away.</p><p>The uncanny is not a fear embodied by some horrific monster, even if the fantastic may occasionally tip into horror. On the contrary, the <em>unheimlich</em> manifests itself through the family, the home, the model American suburb that begins to malfunction. Fear takes on the appearance of normality, and this is precisely the motif that Lynch’s cinema exploits so abundantly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mTZN_IwtqNJeE3jsFHbIxA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Opening sequence of <strong><em>Blue Velvet</em></strong></figcaption></figure><h3>Violence Beneath the Surface</h3><p>Another major theme running through Lynch’s work is the subterranean violence that coexists with the American Dream — and, by extension, with the broader Western dream. Beneath polished appearances lies violence, perhaps even terror.</p><p>One of the most common interpretations of the opening sequence of <em>Blue Velvet</em> illustrates this perfectly. The camera begins by presenting an idyllic vision of suburban America, pristine and orderly. Then things begin to malfunction, culminating in a character collapsing from a heart attack. The camera descends toward the lawn, pushing ever deeper beneath the grass until it reveals a horrifying swarm of insects. This serves as a metaphor for Lynch’s entire body of work: the notion that civilisation rests upon repressed violence. The history of the United States, founded upon genocide, stands as perhaps the most obvious embodiment of this idea.</p><p>In Lynch’s cinema, reality always possesses a second layer of meaning. Beneath the surface of everyday life lies another world. And herein lies the crucial distinction from the <em>Wimmelbuch</em>: the visible does not encompass the entirety of reality. The world is populated by doubles, fragmented identities, and dreams that bleed into waking life. What can be seen is merely a façade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fuLtiCYWQmSA9jd-MBnITg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Twin Peaks: The Return</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Unstable Identities</h3><p>Through this recurring motif, Lynch stages several intuitions central to contemporary philosophy: human identity is not something stable or fixed. Whether in the work of Michel Foucault, Jacques Lacan, or Gilles Deleuze, one repeatedly encounters, in different forms, the idea that identity is not an immutable essence. Rather, it is produced through social, symbolic, or psychic structures, and remains fundamentally unstable. Identity is a fragile construction.</p><p>In other words, what we call an identity is perhaps better understood as a narrative. It is an assemblage of fantasies, images, and stories that we tell ourselves about who we are — or that others tell about us. In Lynch’s cinema, these narratives inevitably begin to crack. Through those fractures, we discover that what we took for reality may have been nothing more than an illusion. And yet, even when the illusion is exposed, we continue to believe in it.</p><p>One famous scene from <em>Mulholland Drive</em> embodies this idea perfectly. The film’s two protagonists attend a performance at Club Silencio. A figure appears on stage to announce: “No hay banda” — there is no orchestra. The music we hear is a recording. There are no musicians, yet the music persists. Even when we know that everything is an illusion, we continue to believe. Later in the same sequence, a singer with an extraordinarily moving voice collapses in front of the microphone, revealing — to everyone’s astonishment — that she had been lip-syncing all along.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CSGiN6go6ywXo70dFXP5Kg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Mythological Recuperation</h3><p>David Lynch’s work is therefore entirely devoted to ambiguity — to that which is difficult to express or even to look at, yet with which we must nevertheless learn to live. It is anything but a consensual, comfortable, or immediately accessible body of work.</p><p>And yet the figure of David Lynch — elegance, cigarette, and flowing white hair — has become a synecdoche for his own oeuvre, transformed into a symbol that now finds itself embedded within a commercial search-and-find book.</p><p>This is merely another manifestation of a process that Roland Barthes analysed with remarkable precision: mass culture transforms cultural objects into myths. According to Barthes, myth empties signs of their history. The symbolic figure that David Lynch has become is thus stripped of its original meaning, even as its external signifiers continue to be mobilised — motifs, locations, objects, characters, and so forth. <em>Where’s David Lynch?</em> summons the tropes of Lynch’s cinema and conceals their author among them, only to freeze them forever into the form of a postcard.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*H4ffc_Re-6KgYgKsx9dDyA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This search-and-find book therefore offers a perfect illustration of Pierre Bourdieu’s analysis of how works circulate within the cultural field, passing through a series of successive transformations.</p><ul><li>First comes a phase of marginality: the work stands in opposition to dominant norms and offers a critique of society or of the prevailing system.</li><li>Second comes a phase of cultural recognition: the work finds its audience and acquires cult status.</li><li>The third stage is that of canonisation: the work enters the cultural canon and, inevitably, becomes simplified. It is gradually reduced to an image, a symbol, or even an icon that can be easily recognised and disseminated.</li></ul><p>Finally comes institutionalisation: symbols become cultural products. At this point, the critique once embodied by the work has been entirely neutralised — and the system can continue functioning exactly as before.</p><p>With <em>Where’s David Lynch?</em>, the American filmmaker has officially joined the pantheon of figures recuperated by the system, alongside Che Guevara, whose image now adorns mass-produced T-shirts, or the rebellious punk rock of the Sex Pistols, repurposed for automobile advertisements.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gcEdED126IvMzu-lrxVQEQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>At its core, this is already what Andy Warhol’s work was telling us. The leading figure of Pop Art remained profoundly ambiguous: his practice oscillated between critique of capitalism and fascination with consumer society.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p5AIl3lVi3gL-FEJswJVxw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Today, Warhol himself has become a brand — a decorative motif found on mugs, schoolbags, and placemats. In a sense, the message of his work has been fulfilled with prophetic precision.</p><p>Guy Debord summarised this process succinctly: capitalism absorbs every critique and transforms it into merchandise.</p><h3>The Digestive Power of Play</h3><p>In the case of <em>Where’s David Lynch?</em>, however, the fact that this recuperation takes place through play is particularly revealing. When a figure becomes the hero of a game, they seem to be fixed permanently within the postcard. Gamification functions as a form of symbolic neutralisation.</p><p>This is precisely the starting point of the surprisingly lucid <em>The Matrix Resurrections</em>. In this fourth instalment, the Matrix and Neo’s adventures have themselves become — within the new version of the Matrix — a video game franchise. In the world of the film, Thomas Anderson, Neo’s real name, is a game designer who developed a trilogy entitled… <em>The Matrix</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/564/1*qI0EZWCxyripyhwU6--OmQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Matrix’s masterstroke, allowing it to maintain its control over humanity, was to transform what had once been an act of resistance — the struggle of Zion against the machines — into a commercial entertainment product. In doing so, the film positions itself as a mirror of our own world, in which the original <em>Matrix</em> trilogy has undergone precisely the same fate.</p><p>One scene near the beginning of the film depicts the development team brainstorming ideas for a fourth instalment of the game, attempting to define the “essence” of <em>The Matrix</em> — quite literally reducing the series to bullet time, kung fu, and cool philosophy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1JvhV9DUsTjGFwN8L1MpAA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In this sense, the film converges with the argument of this article by suggesting that the most effective way to neutralise a revolution is to transform it into entertainment. Players can thus relive rebellion, resistance, and insurrection against oppression without ever threatening the actual system in which they live.</p><p>When David Lynch becomes the protagonist of <em>Where’s David Lynch?</em>, he undergoes the same process of digestion as Neo — yet another manifestation of this mechanism through which subversive discourse is drained of its vitality. Play, despite itself complicit in this process, becomes the final signal that the digestion is complete.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yKBeyni5NSlBqVR9kLip_Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>As is so often the case, play is not necessarily the cause of this recuperation — it is its ultimate manifestation. The presence of historical or fictional figures on the covers of board games (as we have previously noted in the case of <em>Unmatched</em>) may legitimately lead us to question what remains of the ideas these figures once embodied.</p><p>As it turns out, David Lynch and Waldo were never really on the same page.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6e573614fba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When the Dead Die Hard]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/when-the-dead-die-hard-d4104d51a1f6?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d4104d51a1f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zombies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boarg-game]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Jun 2026 10:46:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-22T21:59:20.412Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Zombie Boardgames: <strong>When the Dead Die Hard</strong></h3><h4><strong>From Counterculture to Supermarket Shelves: What Do Board Game Zombies Tell Us?</strong></h4><p><em>For those who read French, you can find the </em><a href="https://ludogamie.com/quand-les-morts-ont-la-vie-dure/"><em>the original article here</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1001/1*1bS67nlIEcv-Dmn6ZkXmOg.png" /></figure><blockquote>“For all I know the brains are already dead. It’s still the idiots that are still alive.” — <em>Dawn of the Dead</em> (Romero, 1978)</blockquote><p>The zombie is a superstar. Within just a few decades, this aberration of nature has become — against its own will — the ultimate gimmick of horror culture. Since its emergence in cinema during the 1960s (<em>Repulsion</em>, 1965; <em>Night of the Living Dead</em>, 1968), the contemporary zombie has taken many forms, rising from its B-movie origins to mainstream production.</p><p>The “Z” apocalypse has since spread across every cultural sector, from comics to video games, without sparing the world of board games. There is nothing surprising about this: the dead have always been more famous than the living.</p><p>Although Romero’s <em>Dawn of the Dead</em> / <em>Zombie</em> (1978) was adapted into a board game under the same title the very year it was released — perhaps the very first board game to feature this theme — the true wave of zombie games emerged in the early 2000s (the classic <em>Zombies!!!</em> dates from 2001), with annual production seemingly doubling during the following decade (BGG, 2023).</p><p>The zombie has become a genuine public-domain franchise, as bankable as vampires, pirates, or the planet Mars.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1001/1*uHACo4wWAie6s4uRORC0Xw.png" /><figcaption><em>Dawn of the Dead</em>, the first zombie board game? — Book derived from “zombie culture”</figcaption></figure><h3>Disjointed Puppet</h3><p>Before being consumed in turn by consumerism, the zombie first emerged in cinema as a metaphor — a pretext for thinking about the world.</p><p>In Romero’s films, true matrices of the genre, the zombie becomes the occasion for a subtle dialectic surrounding what society represses: that which we refuse to see, yet which resurfaces on our lawns and knocks at our windows. The zombie thus serves as a yardstick for our own humanity: if I can define what the monster is, I can, by contrast, define myself — and all the more so in extreme situations.</p><p>For while catastrophe can sometimes artificially reunite a “community threatened with implosion” (Daney, 1976), here it becomes a revealing basin for our dysfunctional behaviours.</p><p>Yet despite this capacity to speak about society, the zombie itself says nothing: it is merely a walking corpse, a trepanned figure emerging from hell. Like a monolith, it is a surface. Meaning arises instead from the treatment it receives at the hands of its “puppeteers” — whether filmmakers or game designers.</p><p>And while cinema has long asked the question, “what vision of the world are the living dead the custodians of?” (Thoret, 2007), board games seem largely uninterested in the political dimension of the zombie figure. They borrow its codes and symbols, but only rarely mobilise its legacy as a signifier. The rallying cry of the board game zombie appears to be: “Move along, there’s nothing to see here.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1001/1*SOMZBlyb0zwlMI35zP4y2A.png" /><figcaption><em>Dead of Winter</em> — <em>They Live</em> (John Carpenter, 1988)</figcaption></figure><h3>An Unwelcome Neighbour</h3><p>The zombie is everywhere. Even in the streets of Paris, whether during a Zombie Walk or on the set of a spin-off from a popular television series. The first consequence of this saturation is clear: the zombie figure has been hollowed out.</p><p>It has become nothing more than torn flesh, blood, and the simulation of horror. On the surface, nothing now distinguishes the political zombie from the carnival zombie. The zombie has become a caricature of itself, reduced to the function of an entertainment puppet. In doing so, it has fulfilled its destiny: to become a zombie “for real” — an empty, brainless creature whose sole purpose is to occupy space.</p><p>This geographical function is particularly evident in zombie board games, which very often revolve around territories to explore or defend, whether represented by a board, modular tiles to reveal, or cards depicting different locations.</p><p>Zombies are always the assailants laying siege to some kind of stronghold. They are the wandering monsters players must weave between to survive, the vermin infesting an overrun home.</p><p>In <em>Zombicide</em> and <em>City of Horror</em>, the game’s stage is the city block and its surrounding streets. In <em>Zombie Kidz Evolution</em>, it is a school divided into several areas. In <em>Dawn of Zeds</em> and <em>Dead of Winter</em>, it is a colony of survivors. In <em>Hit Road Z</em>, it is a series of “location” cards, each offering its own effects and items.</p><p>Most zombie games therefore revolve around territorial control. Humans and zombies are, above all else, fighting for the exclusive right to exist: coexistence is never an option.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1001/1*u3nFijDqcRD48GROHazKhA.png" /><figcaption><em>Dawn of the Dead</em> (Romero, 1978) — <em>Zombie Kidz Evolution</em> — Black Friday scene</figcaption></figure><h3>Blasting Undead</h3><p>There is undoubtedly a certain pleasure in gunning down zombies — indeed, it is one of the genre’s defining expectations.</p><p>Much like the faceless henchmen of action films (the moment an enemy puts on a mask, they lose their status as a fellow human being), zombies provide an opportunity to kill without guilt. The eradication of these non-humans takes the form of a legitimate hunt against a parasite, and board games fully embrace this cathartic function of lawful violence.</p><p>The zombie has become a convenient way of representing a global, depersonalised threat, embodying the perfect antagonist: it never has to justify its actions, there is no ambiguity regarding its intentions, and negotiation is impossible. The zombie is hungry and wants to devour any biped within reach. Extermination is the only possible outcome.</p><p>By consistently treating the zombie as an external threat to be eliminated, board games reinstate the notion of a simple dualism: there are good guys and bad guys, and both are immediately identifiable. This state of affairs likely reflects a broader shared anxiety, one in which it becomes increasingly difficult to disentangle the complex web of actors involved in real-world conflicts.</p><p>The terrors imagined by Romero, Polanski (<em>Rosemary’s Baby</em>, 1968), or Don Siegel (<em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers</em>, 1956) were subversive in their time because, unlike the classical cinema of the frontier — with its clearly defined boundaries between good and evil — they came from within. Hence the difficulty of pulling the trigger.</p><p>What would you do if the monster had been your child or your lover only hours before? Before becoming the living dead, zombies were human beings. Are they still — and to what extent? This recognition of the Other (and therefore of oneself) within the monster is one of the great absentees of zombie board games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1001/1*1YVJhL4ex8xfcrDI2kSHJQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Dawn of the Dead</em> (Romero, 1978) — <em>Study for a Head</em> (Francis Bacon, 1952, detail)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Gestures of Survival</h3><p>Let us remember: the zombie is, above all else, synonymous with the end of the known world. Its very existence amounts to an apocalyptic scenario from which there is no escape. The origin of this catastrophe ultimately matters little — an inexplicable force, a contagious virus, spores from outer space, a pangolin… Only the present matters — to survive — and everything that came before has ceased to exist.</p><p>In a doomed world, “the gestures of survival are the only ones left available” (Thoret, 2017): this is the great motif of the zombie universe. The world “before” has collapsed, and now one must find weapons, food, and supplies. Scavenging and discovering useful items are recurring mechanics in zombie games.</p><p>They are, in fact, the leitmotif of the genre: scarcity of resources, the inexorable pressure of the horde, and the anxiety-inducing hostility of the environment. In this respect, <em>Dead of Winter</em> distinguishes itself from other productions within the genre through its depiction of the meticulous organisation of a colony of survivors. Beyond its dilemmas and semi-cooperative structure, the game is, at its core, a story about exhaustion — a struggle against fatigue. To play is to resist the relentless tide that overwhelms and devours us.</p><p>To embody survival, zombie games draw upon two major families of meta-mechanics: chance and optimisation. Here, a die roll determines the outcome of combat; there, the coordinated planning of one’s actions dictates the efficiency of a turn. These mechanics simultaneously convey the constant uncertainty and the everyday micromanagement inherent to a world overrun by the living dead. In doing so, they allow players to endlessly replay the dawn of humanity itself: the survival of the tribe in a hostile environment. This may well be one of the reasons for the genre’s enduring popularity.</p><p>The zombie is a profoundly pessimistic fiction: we are condemned to inhabit a perpetual nightmare. Yet while this perspective is readily accepted as one of the genre’s fundamental premises, it is, once again, only rarely explored in board games.</p><p>Games tend instead to sustain the illusion of a possible “victory” over the zombies (<em>Zombies!!!</em>, for instance, can be won either by reaching the helicopter or by killing twenty-five zombies). In reality, while individual battles may be won, the war itself never can: a world of zombies is a world without end. The only question that remains — and one that board games have thus far shown little interest in asking — is this: how does one live without hope?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1001/1*jzJi_bsYYWIdkWce15VwZw.png" /><figcaption><em>Pulp Fiction</em> (Tarantino, 1994) — <em>Zombicide</em></figcaption></figure><h3>The Zombie Joke</h3><p>It has been a long time since zombies were synonymous with terror. The very word <em>horror</em> seems to have lost its meaning. Our overexposure to the violence of the world — inseparable from the total invasion of our lives by digital channels — has undoubtedly contributed to this desensitisation. Board games, moreover, borrow very little from the register of fear: they lack the conditions of sensory and bodily captivity found in cinema, the atmosphere and ambience cultivated by role-playing games, or the environmental immersion offered by escape rooms.</p><p>As a result, the zombie of board games has naturally drifted toward a particular subgenre: the burlesque zombie. The marriage of horror and humour, both sharing the same cathartic function, has long demonstrated its commercial appeal. Tongue-in-cheek gore and macabre comedy have become established and popular cinematic genres, from <em>Braindead</em> to <em>Shaun of the Dead</em> and <em>Zombieland</em>.</p><p>Board games have enthusiastically embraced this humorous dimension. <em>Escape: Zombie City</em>, <em>Zombie Kidz Evolution</em>, <em>Flashback: Zombie Kidz</em>, <em>Eat Z’em All</em>, and the entirely unnecessary <em>Oh My Brain</em> offer perfect illustrations of this tendency. The zombie has now crossed fully into the realm of cartoons, completing its transformation into a parlour clown. Under such conditions, it becomes difficult to make it signify anything other than its own emptiness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1001/1*Yhag1RV6hbC934i2OyCuvg.png" /><figcaption><em>Braindead</em> (Peter Jackson, 1992) — Advertisement featuring a delighted child</figcaption></figure><h3>The Reassuring World of Games</h3><p>The zombie tears bodies apart and devours flesh: at its core, it is a nightmarish creature. Yet board games have managed to invent a “civilised” version of the zombie, frozen in a single pantomime — arms dangling or stretched out in front of it, jaw hanging open, body awkwardly contorted.</p><p>It has been cast into a plastic miniature that can be touched, moved, and “managed.” The zombie no longer frightens us: it has become an empty shell under our control. Yet the living dead were terrifying precisely because they were uncontrollable. Excess, overflow, the collapse of boundaries — these are the defining characteristics of the zombie.</p><p>But the domestication of the zombie within board games reflects more than the transition of a countercultural figure into an icon of consumerism. It also reveals board gaming’s characteristic abandonment — whether through lack of context or lack of intention — of the political question. Of the zombie, games have retained only the form. They have turned it into a tamed beast: a generic enemy that is familiar, consensual, and harmless — the ideal form of alterity, precisely because it no longer disturbs anyone.</p><p>In this respect, board games merely follow a broader tendency within mainstream culture: the representation of a world sustained by the fantasy of total control. A world in which the living dead — those who should unsettle us because they challenge our understanding of reality and the rules that govern it — have become nothing more than variables to be managed, reintegrated into the ordinary order of things. By invoking the zombie without allowing it to disturb, trouble, or unsettle us, board games continue to contribute to our collective slumber.</p><p>Make no mistake: the zombie apocalypse is already here. Outside lies a hostile wasteland, and huddled within our small communities, all that remains is to lull ourselves with the spectacle of harmless death. Let the feast of brains begin.</p><h3>References</h3><ul><li>BGG, BoardGameGeek. The largest online database dedicated to board games.</li><li>Daney, Serge (1976). “Matière grise”, <em>Les Cahiers du cinéma</em>, no. 265.</li><li>Malausa, Vincent (2017). “George Romero, Horror as a Strategy Game and Combat Sport.” Lecture delivered as part of the George A. Romero retrospective at the French Cinematheque. Available online:<a href="https://www.cinematheque.fr/video/1164.html"> https://www.cinematheque.fr/video/1164.html</a></li><li>Rauger, Jean-François (2017). Introductory text to the George A. Romero retrospective. French Cinematheque. Available online:<a href="https://www.cinematheque.fr/cycle/george-a-romero-429.html"> https://www.cinematheque.fr/cycle/george-a-romero-429.html</a></li><li>Thoret, Jean-Baptiste (2007). <em>Politique des Zombies</em> [<em>The Politics of Zombies</em>]. Ellipses.</li><li>Thoret, Jean-Baptiste (2013). <em>Les Monstres Américains</em> [<em>American Monsters</em>]. Online lecture:<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0SKIcPp-0Nw"> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0SKIcPp-0Nw</a></li></ul><h3>Games Mentioned</h3><ul><li><em>City of Horror</em> (Nicolas Normandon, Repos Production, 2012)</li><li><em>Dawn of the Dead</em> (John H. Butterfield, SPI, 1978)</li><li><em>Dawn of Zeds</em> (Hermann Luttmann, Victory Point Games, 2011)</li><li><em>Dead of Winter</em> (Jonathan Gilmour &amp; Isaac Vega, Plaid Hat Games, 2014)</li><li><em>Eat Z’em All</em> (Loïc Lamy, Origames, 2024)</li><li><em>Escape: Zombie City</em> (Kristian A. Østby, Queen Games, 2014)</li><li><em>Flashback: Zombie Kidz</em> (Baptiste Derrez &amp; Marc-Antoine Doyon, Le Scorpion Masqué, 2022)</li><li><em>Hit Road Z</em> (Martin Wallace, Asmodee, 2016)</li><li><em>Oh My Brain</em> (Bruno Cathala &amp; Théo Rivière, Lumberjacks Studio, 2021)</li><li><em>Zombie Kidz Evolution</em> (Annick Lobet, Le Scorpion Masqué, 2018)</li><li><em>Zombicide</em> (Raphaël Guiton, Jean-Baptiste Lullien &amp; Nicolas Raoult, CMON, 2012)</li><li><em>Zombies!!!</em> (Todd Breitenstein &amp; Kerry Breitenstein, Twilight Creations Inc., 2001)</li></ul><h3>Films Mentioned</h3><ul><li><em>Braindead</em> (Peter Jackson, 1992)</li><li><em>Dawn of the Dead</em> / <em>Zombie</em> (George A. Romero, 1978)</li><li><em>Invasion of the Body Snatchers</em> (Don Siegel, 1956)</li><li><em>Night of the Living Dead</em> (George A. Romero, 1968)</li><li><em>Repulsion</em> (Roman Polanski, 1965)</li><li><em>Rosemary’s Baby</em> (Roman Polanski, 1968)</li><li><em>Shaun of the Dead</em> (Edgar Wright, 2004)</li><li><em>Zombieland</em> (Ruben Fleischer, 2009)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d4104d51a1f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Three States of Play]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/the-three-states-of-play-444c11fb9297?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/444c11fb9297</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Jun 2026 17:45:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-17T11:11:16.195Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The Benefits of an Emerging Trinity</h4><p><em>For those who read French, you can find </em><a href="https://ludogamie.com/les-trois-etats-du-jeu/"><em>the the original article here</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*m_medJREQGlw8js0kIpuzA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Following the metaphor</h3><p>Since early childhood, you have learned about the states of water. Liquid, solid, gaseous: the same substance can take different forms depending on its environment, its temperature, or the pressure applied to it.</p><p>Did you know that play — whatever form it takes — also exists in several different states?</p><p>We tend to perceive it only in its most common and obvious form: the lived experience, the activity referred to by the verb <em>to play</em>.</p><p>Yet, with time and a touch of curiosity, we may discover that the territory of play has other entry points which, although interconnected, possess distinct properties.</p><p>These are what I have chosen to call <strong>the three states of play</strong>. Let us take a closer look.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*04b9aHOiUH7Hv_JlcqqgFQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Playing — The Liquid State 💧</h3><p>The first form of play is also the first one we encounter in life: playing.</p><p>It is perhaps the most widespread and universal form of play there is. The verb itself captures its essence quite well, even if it sometimes feels too narrow to encompass the diversity of realities evoked by the word <em>play</em> (four letters is not much to carry all that it implies).</p><p>I associate this state with the liquid state because it is the state of movement and flow. It is both highly tangible — people generally know what counts as play for them — and yet perpetually shifting. Play exists largely in the space between players, in the interactions they build together, interactions that are never exactly the same twice.</p><p>This liquid materiality reinforces the idea that play exceeds the boundaries we usually assign to it. We may bottle it here and there, contain it within swimming pools or ponds, but its fundamentally oceanic power will always overflow culturally standardized categories such as video games, board games, gambling, and so on.</p><p>As I have argued elsewhere, play is a space. We enter this space much like crossing the threshold into another world — a world within the world. Play can exist without components, with improvised rules, without having to justify itself to anyone.</p><p>But playing is also an opportunity to <em>make society</em>: to bring members of our species together around an activity that is, in principle, voluntary and enjoyable — and that does not, for once, consist of killing one another (for real).</p><p>Of course, play is not always synonymous with harmony. Games can exclude, humiliate, or reproduce forms of domination and cultural bias. Yet precisely because they cannot be anything other than reflections of our societies, they provide a privileged terrain from which to observe them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KE1YhyhWqA7u0BbCB5FDqw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Making Others Play — The Solid State 🧊</h3><p>The second state of play is <strong>making others play</strong>.</p><p>To make others play is to consciously and deliberately give shape to play. It is what all professionals within the world of games do: publishers, designers, developers. In short, all the links in the chain through which a game comes into existence — whether or not they make a living from it: authors, illustrators, manufacturers, distributors, game retailers, game design educators, and so on.</p><p>More broadly, making others play encompasses everyone who produces and/or mobilises play, whether for commercial, recreational, social, educational, or even artistic purposes. This includes libraries dedicated to games, gaming festivals, game design conventions, local associations, as well as educational spaces — whether they are schools devoted specifically to games or schools and community centres that use play in their activities and programmes.</p><p>Becoming aware of this second state means recognising that games do not simply fall from the sky. They are produced by situated individuals, within specific economic, cultural, and historical contexts. They may constitute a profession, a hobby, or a form of civic engagement that contributes to the public good.</p><p>To continue the metaphor, the liquid play of the first state is something rather difficult to hold in one’s hands. The second state, however, is that of <strong>solid play</strong>, in which play becomes an object, a device, or a medium that can be refined, improved, and exchanged.</p><p>Making others play consists in stepping outside the experience of play itself in order to organise the conditions under which that experience may occur. This can mean taking an existing game and introducing it to new audiences, or creating entirely new games.</p><p>It is in this spirit that certain game design theorists, such as Eric Zimmerman, describe game design as a <strong>second-order design problem</strong>: the designer creates structures — rules — that shape behaviours, which in turn generate experiences. Designers therefore do not directly create experiences, nor do they exercise perfect control over what players will ultimately feel or do. Rather, they establish the conditions within which meaningful interactions may emerge.</p><p>Put more simply, those who contribute to this second state of play are like <strong>hosts at a gathering</strong>, making sure their guests have a good time. They, too, may enjoy the evening and occasionally forget that they are the hosts. Yet their role and responsibilities never fully overlap with those of their guests.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vDNqYPhMXFuzL4O0d0KWWw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A conference with Mary Flanagan</figcaption></figure><h3>Thinking About Play — The Gaseous State ☁️</h3><p>Thinking about play is this final state in which play becomes the subject of discourse, research, or critical reflection: it is the <strong>gaseous state</strong> of play.</p><p>This state took time to emerge. It is only relatively recently that we have been able to speak of <strong>game studies</strong> or, in some contexts, the <strong>science of play</strong> as distinct fields of inquiry. Of course, disciplines such as sociology, philosophy, anthropology, psychology, and history have long engaged with play as an object of thought. Today, however, this intellectual practice continues to expand and diversify year after year.</p><p>In concrete terms, <em>thinking about play</em> encompasses everything from journalistic work shaped by the commercial news cycle to specialised gaming media, politically engaged game criticism, fundamental academic research (such as works like <em>This Is Not Just a Game</em> or the <em>Dictionary of Game Studies</em>), and even research-creation programmes such as <strong>Rhétolud</strong>.</p><p>Thinking about play offers an opportunity to reflect upon an object that is inseparable from society through questions that are still too rarely asked: What narratives do games convey? What do they reveal about a particular era, a society, or a worldview? What responses can play offer to the challenges of today’s world — or the world to come?</p><p>To consider play exempt from formal, sociological, or political analysis would be to grant it a form of <strong>extraterritorial status</strong>. It would mean treating the rules, representations, and systems that games stage as though they had no connection to reality — or worse, as though they could somehow be experienced independently of it.</p><p>And yet, we have everything to gain from exposing the dialogue between play and the world.</p><p>Because it is built around rules, play can help us reflect on our own relationship to norms. Because it generates interactions, it can shed light on social and psychological dynamics. Because it stages imaginaries, it participates in the construction and perpetuation of our collective representations.</p><p>Admittedly, the gaseous state is one of abstraction. It is the least visible of the three states, and undoubtedly the most difficult to grasp. It is therefore also the state that remains least present within society. Much remains to be done if we wish to invite more people to explore this dimension of play, and one of the reasons for the existence of <em>Miroir des jeux</em> is precisely to contribute to this endeavour.</p><p>Fortunately, you do not need a Master’s degree in game studies to begin exploring this third state. Simply taking the time to look at a game as something more than a mere object of entertainment is already a way of stepping into the gaseous state.</p><p>From there, the task is gradually to cultivate one’s gaze and one’s sensibility — to develop the habit of confronting games with the world in which they exist, without losing sight of the pleasures of the first state.</p><p>Because, rest assured, thinking about play does not mean dissecting it in order to strip it of its magic. Nor does it mean analysing what works and what does not in order to produce the next blockbuster hit — that belongs to the work of the second state. Thinking about play is, first and foremost, about giving it the opportunity to acquire depth.</p><p>Can you see the cloud beginning to form?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_lpk-i-q0HSdh0bhSUiUJw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>A Fourth State? ☀️</h3><p>There is a fourth state that I have not yet mentioned, but one that should not be overlooked: the state of <strong>non-play</strong>. In a sense, it is the antimatter of the playful universe.</p><p>In this state, play is simply excluded from a person’s concerns, interests, or priorities. This may be because it is reduced to board games or video games and therefore not embraced as a leisure activity (“I don’t like games”), because it is not considered legitimate (“games are for children”), or because it is not seen as productive (“I’m wasting my time playing”).</p><p>Despite the interpretative biases that often reveal a limited understanding of play, this “ghost state” paradoxically has an important place within the ecosystem of play. Non-play is <strong>not</strong> the enemy of play.</p><p>Among other things, it reminds us that it is healthy to step outside the playful world and look elsewhere. It acts as a useful safeguard. After all, there is more to life than games — and games are certainly not the answer to everything.</p><p>If this fourth state intrigues you, I discuss it at greater length in a video available on our channel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rn7WPHWFxn3lGIrr10QKCQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Sea, Snow, and Clouds: Why Choose?</h3><p>Despite their different properties, these three states of play are not mutually exclusive. Nor is there any hierarchy to be found among them. They may serve converging purposes, stand in radical opposition to one another, or function in synergy. More often than not, however, they do not share the same temporality :</p><ul><li>When we explain the rules of a game, we are not quite playing.</li><li>When we are playing, we are not analysing the game.</li><li>When a designer playtests a prototype, they are not entirely playing, nor are they necessarily reflecting on the deeper meanings of its mechanics. They are also thinking about how the game functions and how it is received by others — that is, operating within the second state.</li><li>You may manufacture games without any desire either to play them or to think critically about them — for instance, in technical production roles.</li><li>And it is entirely possible to think about games… without ever playing them! (Admittedly, this is a rather rare profile, and the only person I personally know who fits it is my former professor and friend Gilles Brougère.)</li></ul><p>The same individual may therefore move through different states of play over the course of a single evening. These positions sometimes overlap, and their boundaries are, of course, porous.</p><p>Recognising these different moments of play may help us avoid some of the misunderstandings that arise within gaming communities — particularly the notion that any one of these states alone could fully define what play is, or claim a monopoly on truth.</p><p>In practice, it is often the third state — the act of thinking about play, of which this article is itself an example — that is challenged. One hears statements such as “games are not political” or “analysing games is just intellectual masturbation.” More often than not, however, this state simply remains unexplored because the culture surrounding games has not yet developed sufficiently. In other words, the temperature has not risen enough for play to reach its gaseous state with ease.</p><p>Of course, this metaphorical description of the states of play is intended, in part, to defend and democratise this third state. But let us avoid falling into the opposite trap of overvaluing critical distance to the point of ending up with our heads permanently in the clouds.</p><p>To see games only as objects of study is sometimes to lose sight of what makes them singular and beautiful: the pleasure of playing for the sake of playing, of existing purely for themselves, without any explanation beyond what they are.</p><p>What matters, ultimately, is that these three states are allowed to coexist and continue developing in synergy if we wish to foster a richer culture of play within society.</p><p>The attitude that seems most balanced to me is therefore one of navigation: moving from one state to another. Ensuring that spaces exist in which people can play; that game creation can become more democratic and accessible; and that critical and sensitive reflection on play can gain legitimacy beyond academic circles.</p><p>The cultural maturity of this medium lies precisely in our ability to accept that it can be all of these things at once.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=444c11fb9297" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A New Chapter: Writing in English]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/le-blog-change-dadresse-2d4068f59436?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d4068f59436</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Nov 2025 07:54:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-12T17:54:05.950Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A small announcement: this Medium account is now switching to <strong>English!</strong></p><p>Writing about games has brought me into contact with people from many different countries. Since many of the conversations I care about are already happening internationally, it felt like the right time to make this space more accessible.</p><p>If you read French, nothing is disappearing: <strong>my articles in French will still be available on my website</strong>, where <em>Le Miroir des jeux</em> (a.k.a. <em>Mirrors of Play</em>) will continue to grow.</p><p>Thank you for being here. Let’s keep thinking through games together.</p><p>🇫🇷 French articles: <a href="https://ludogamie.com/blog"><em>ludogamie.com/blog</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d4068f59436" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Subir ‘Skyjo’]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/subir-skyjo-559446388241?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/559446388241</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sciences-du-jeu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeu-de-société]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[skyjo]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Sep 2024 06:32:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-11T05:43:16.240Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>Le phénomène d’un jeu « à gratter »</em></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oeTU4W4ZWayu9_rR6S4GbQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Skyjo </strong>(Alexander Bernhardt, 2015) —<strong> Orange Mécanique</strong> (Stanley Kubrick, 1978)</figcaption></figure><p>Qui ne l’aura pas vu cet été sorti sur une table ou une serviette de plage ?</p><p>Top des ventes sur Amazon, carton des boutiques de jeu, incontournable de la grande surface, adoré des <em>reviewers</em> et boudé des joueurs « experts », <em>Skyjo</em> est bien parti pour finir, à l’instar du Uno et du Scrabble, dans tous les placards des chaumières de France et de Navarre. Bon sang, mais que se passe-t-il avec ce jeu ?</p><p>Bien que le titre de cet article évoque le sentiment non feint de son rédacteur, la question n’est pas de savoir si l’on aime ou pas <em>Skyjo</em> — la réponse importe peu — ni de savoir s’il s’agit ou non d’un « bon » jeu.<em> Skyjo</em> crée des moments joyeux autour de la table et, quelles que soient ses qualités intrinsèques, rien ne pourra lui retirer le plaisir qu’il génère… même si c’est aussi ce que l’on dit de la bataille corse et de la pizza.</p><p>En réalité, ce qui va nous intéresser ici c’est de comprendre ce qui se joue avec ce curieux phénomène conçu par Alexander Bernhardt, édité chez Magilano et distribué en France par Blackrock Games. À l’instar, dans un autre champ culturel, de <em>Bienvenue chez les Ch’tis</em> (<a href="https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3nnuja">très bien analysé par le critique Jean-Baptiste Thoret</a>), <em>Skyjo</em> est un hit populaire qui répond à un besoin de son époque et nous en donne des clefs de lecture. Bienvenue dans la Skyjologie.</p><blockquote>« Anticipez et soyez audacieux…! <em>Skyjo </em>est un jeu de cartes simple, subtil et terriblement addictif » <em>(éléments de langage officiels du jeu)</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nMAg4Z-v2szUwBPTPGU2fA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Set up <strong>Skyjo</strong> — <strong>Bienvenue chez les Ch’tis </strong>(Dany Boon, 2008)</figcaption></figure><h4>Recette pour un blockbuster</h4><p>Il est toujours plus facile d’expliquer les raisons d’un succès <em>a posteriori</em>. En réalité, c’est une alchimie complexe qui fait la popularité d’un jeu, mêlant les conditions de sa genèse, la force de son marketing, la prise du bouche à oreille, sa résonance avec l’air du temps, son thème ou, évidemment, sa qualité mécanique. Chaque « hit » mériterait ainsi une enquête sociologique, historique et économique approfondie — hors de portée de cet article. Nous pouvons néanmoins, à partir des caractéristiques observables du jeu, décrypter certains des ingrédients qui en facilitent la prise avec le public, comme une « affordance au succès ». Objectivement, <em>Skyjo</em> est donc :</p><p><strong>Facile à mettre en place. </strong>Chaque joueur reçoit douze cartes pour composer devant lui un tableau de 3 par 4 cartes face cachée, puis en retourne deux au choix. Difficile de faire plus simple. Chacun possède ainsi <em>son</em> terrain, <em>son</em> champ à cultiver, espérant pouvoir en tirer un meilleur parti que les autres. Cet individualisme intrinsèque, cela ne surprendra personne, s’accorde à merveille à celui de son époque. Le pot commun de la pioche fonctionne ainsi comme un espace collectif symbolique (la planète, la vie en société) où nous venons projeter nos espoirs — passifs — d’une amélioration de notre condition personnelle d’existence.</p><p><strong>Conçu pour une jauge très souple</strong>. <em>Skyjo</em> est jouable 2 à 8 (vous l’avez certainement vu testé à plus), mais surtout les joueurs peuvent se rajouter inopinément jusqu’au dernier moment. Ce facteur ajoute à la spontanéité et à l’ouverture sociale. Le jeu s’inscrit à rebours-poil d’une certaine rigidité logistique que l’on peut parfois rencontrer dans le monde du jeu de société — la limite physique du nombre de participants à l’amusement. <em>Skyjo</em> s’affranchit de cette contrainte. La raison : son <em>game design</em> reste très peu impacté par cette variable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V92N6TczhFtKFNFoD0eAUw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>HoodDocumentary</strong> (série TV, 2016) — Un « tableau » individuel <strong>Skyjo</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Facile à expliquer et à comprendre</strong>. Pas de fausse promesse là-dessus : les règles sont simples. Piocher une carte puis l’échanger avec une de son tableau ou la défausser. <em>C’est tout</em>. Si cette simplicité (ou « manque d’agentivité » diront les mauvaises langues) est ce que l’on peut reprocher au jeu, c’est aussi là toute sa force — <em>il n’y a pas à réfléchir</em>. L’essentiel des productions culturelles, jetant l’éponge de leur potentielle fonction subversive, relève du « <em>no brainer </em>», du remplissage indolore et confortable, caractéristique parfois consubstantielle du top des ventes. En réalité, et cette démarche d’analyse s’en veut la preuve, il n’existe pas de tels objets « creux ». C’est toujours notre esprit critique que nous laissons sous anesthésie, pour une raison ou pour une autre. La profondeur existe toujours dans l’œil du regardeur — à nous d’en maintenir la braise.</p><blockquote>Là même où tu te trouves, sonde !<br> La source est au fond !<br> Laisse donc brailler les sombres oiseaux :<br> « Toujours au fond se trouve — l’enfer ! »<br> (Nietzsche, <em>Le Gai savoir</em>)</blockquote><p><strong>Rapide à jouer</strong>. Vous le savez, les « gros jeux » font peur aux non-experts (certains moins que d’autres, vu le succès de mastodontes comme <em>Terraforming Mars</em>). Annoncer plus d’une heure de partie et se lancer dans vingt minutes d’explication de règles décourage une grande majorité de joueurs (et de non-joueurs !). Les jeux rapides (moins de 30 minutes) remportent toujours l’adhésion la plus large, dans une majorité de situations. Avec des parties moyennes de 15 minutes, <em>Skyjo</em> coche naturellement cette case. Qui a encore le temps de jouer ? Le monde occidental d’aujourd’hui est un monde pressé : il faut aller vite, faire vite, jouir vite, et la durée n’est plus célébrée que par des résistants — les films d’Apichatpong Weerasethakul, les performances de Marina Abramović, les pièces de Wajdi Mouawad… ou les jeux d’Intrafin Games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bWUZcPUCTdsr8PwcJrzbaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Oncle Boonmee, celui qui se souvient de ses vies antérieures</strong> (Apichatpong Weerasethakul, 2010)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Abstrait et sans ambiguïté visuelle</strong>. Malgré un renouveau constant et un « déguisement » thématique aujourd’hui très fort, les jeux abstraits ont moins le vent en poupe que dans les années 80 et 90 (voir <a href="https://youtu.be/AI_iAkvkTTw">l’évolution du jeu française de 1950 à 2000</a>). Leur grande force est pourtant leur intemporalité, à l’instar du jeu de carte traditionnel, du Go ou encore des dominos. <em>Skyjo</em> s’inscrit dans cette tradition : il n’est composé que de cartes portant l’information d’un nombre. Les couleurs n’ont aucune incidence sur le jeu sinon d’en faciliter la lecture en redoublant l’information. Ce design à l’épure fait l’économie de toute fiction et, aussi clivant soit-il, ajoute à la facilité de prise en main : aucun temps n’est « perdu » dans la lecture et la découverte du matériel. Cette formule nous questionne sur la prégnance de la thématisation dans le jeu de société moderne. Pourrions-nous imaginer que l’habillage narratif des jeux passe de mode ? Que dans vingt, trente ans ou cinquante ans les jeux reviennent à leur formule « primitive » abstraite ? Une chose est sûre : ils n’en perdraient rien de leur force évocatrice. <em>Skyjo</em> pourrait être un jeu pythagoricien, fasciné par les nombres et leur symbolique. Rien ne l’empêcherait non plus d’être détourné à des fins de divination…</p><p><strong>Pratique. </strong>Avec son nom facile à retenir et sa petite boite qui s’emporte partout (vendue autour de 16€), <em>Skyjo</em> s’assure là encore qu’il n’y ait aucun frein à son acquisition et à sa circulation. Les éditeurs oublient parfois l’importance de la vie quotidienne des jeux une fois acquis. Le rangement et le transport sont autant de facteurs facilitant ou bloquant la vie d’un jeu. Une grosse boîte reste à la maison et circule peu, là où un petit jeu s’emporte partout et a d’autant plus de chance de voyager, d’être montré et de bénéficier d’un solide bouche à oreille.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QmS8f8oPyYzML1juckD60w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Une “bonne carte” à Skyjo — <strong>Hard Heigh</strong> (Paul Thomas Anderson, 1996)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Un jeu de hasard</strong>. C’est un truisme bien connu des <em>game designers</em> : l’aléatoire a toujours plus de succès auprès du grand public (le hasard est un grand égalisateur des chances de réussite), tandis qu’à l’inverse les jeux experts vont avoir tendance à le minimiser pour privilégier la compétence des joueurs. N’en déplaise à son descriptif officiel qui n’ose pas l’assumer comme tel, <em>Skyjo</em> est bien un jeu de pur hasard. La minime interaction avec le voisin de gauche, via la carte que l’on défausse (et que celui-ci peut récupérer au lieu de piocher), ne suffit pas pour en faire un quelconque espace « stratégique ». Dans <em>Skyjo</em>, la compétence n’existe pas. Le message est clair : pour réussir, seule suffit la chance. Suivez votre instinct !</p><p><strong>Une mécanique éprouvée historiquement</strong>. Il est intéressant de retrouver une filiation du jeu dans le « <em>Golf </em>» : un <a href="https://escaleajeux.fr/jeu/golf_">jeu de carte traditionnel</a>, dans lequel chaque joueur a un tableau de quatre cartes devant lui et doit obtenir le moins de points en fin de partie. <em>Skyjo</em> vient donc bien de quelque part et c’est tant mieux. Le game design est un art mutant — il absorbe et transforme en permanence ce qui l’a précédé, en y ajoutant sporadiquement des mutations spontanées qui ouvrent de nouveaux embranchements génétiques. L’important ici est de comprendre que la mécanique de base a déjà fait ses preuves : c’est une donnée pertinente pour jauger la robustesse d’un système et sa popularité, à l’instar du <a href="https://www.ludogamie.com/blog/la-belote-et-ses-metaphores">jeu de pli</a>.</p><p>Ainsi, comme les films et autres productions culturelles, les blockbusters du « jeu de poche » ont leur recette — souvent éprouvée par le marché –, même si son application à la lettre ne prévient aucunement d’un échec potentiel. Un éditeur se lançant dans la conception d’un jeu aux mêmes caractéristiques que <em>Skyjo</em> pondrait-il un autre hit ? C’est possible. Peu ou prou, ce sont là des éléments que l’on retrouve dans <em>Le 6 qui prend</em> — un autre jeu à succès. En son temps, <em>Jungle Speed</em> en faisait également la démonstration (en remplaçant le hasard par les réflexes). La question qui reste est : le public se lassera-t-il des mêmes recettes ? Pas sûr…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LC06yYHZCK3tauenOpO4RQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jeux à gratter — <strong>The Addiction</strong> (Abel Ferrara, 1995)</figcaption></figure><h4>Vous avez dit addiction ?</h4><blockquote>« On vous a dit déjà que vous risquiez de devenir accroc… ? <em>(sur le site du </em><a href="https://blackrockgames.fr/game/MAG002SK"><em>distributeur</em></a><em>)</em></blockquote><p>« Addictif » est l’élément de langage le plus usité par le marketing de <em>Skyjo</em>. Le mot, nous dira-t-on, est à prendre dans son sens figuré : personne ne se réveille la nuit pour jouer à <em>Skyjo</em>, ni a besoin d’une cure de détox. C’est toutefois bien ce vocabulaire qui nous met sur la piste de la véritable clef de lecture du jeu — les jeux à gratter.</p><p>Au fond, <em>Skyjo</em> rentre sous la peau de ses afficionados parce qu’il procure la même sensation qu’un Banco ou un Millionnaire — éprouver sa chance devant les autres. La mécanique même du jeu converge vers cette sensation : qu’il s’agisse de piocher une carte ou d’en retourner une de son tableau, chacun espère y trouver une valeur basse (–2, –1 ou 0) ou une carte qui lui permette d’éliminer une colonne (si trois cartes d’une colonne sont identiques, elles sont automatiquement défaussées). À chaque action de jeu notre esprit est ainsi conditionné, quasiment de façon pavlovienne. Je retourne une carte — Vais-je avoir de la chance ? Et si je n’en ai pas eu, ce n’est pas grave : peut-être en aurais-je à la prochaine carte. Jouez vite, car je suis impatient de gratter à nouveau ! Pas de millions à gagner à la fin sinon le sentiment grisant « d’avoir eu de la chance ».</p><p>La chance est une mystique universelle. Certains ont une chance de cocu, d’autre ont la poisse d’un roturier. Mais la chance tourne. Y a-t-il un destin ? Une bonne étoile ? Le monde est-il avec moi ? La qualité de ma vie est-elle toute entière due à la chance ou à ma volonté ? Autant de questions qui traversent tous les esprits. Tout le monde aimerait avoir de la chance — et tout le monde envie ceux qui en ont. On se moque des malchanceux, on jalouse les chanceux : la dynamique sociale de <em>Skyjo</em> fonctionne à merveille, portée par cette légèreté <em>a priori</em> sans conséquence propre aux jeux de société. Chaque action d’un joueur entraine la réaction de ses partenaires : le commentaire est immédiat (admiration, jalousie, moquerie). Quelle que soit son issue, votre action est <em>reconnue</em>, considérée — une richesse dans un monde où règne le fléau de l’indifférence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o4lih8LopK4HcmHKzVTGAg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Truman Show </strong>(Peter Weir, 1998)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Skyjo</em>, à l’instar des pur jeux de dés comme le Yam’s, réveille ce territoire inconscient du <em>désir de différence</em> (pour soi et vis-à-vis des autres) et en fait le cœur de son système. Les joueuses et joueurs sont pris dans une sorte d’étau mental auquel il est difficile de résister (« et si cette fois j’avais de la veine et que l’on me voyait comme quelqu’un de chanceux ? »). Malgré une différence dans les cartes initiales entièrement liée à la chance — ce qui est l’exact reflet de nos conditions de naissance — <em>Skyjo</em>, à l’instar des jeux à gratter et du loto, entretient le topos du <em>court-circuit</em> : tout est possible, peu importe votre condition de départ. Nous revoilà hantés par le fétiche du discours libéral, si séduisant : tout le monde a sa chance.</p><p>Ainsi, <em>Skyjo</em> répond à un ensemble de besoins humains sur le plan inconscient, presque subliminal, et reflète particulièrement bien certaines dynamiques du corps social. Mais le jeu ne prend pas parti — bien que l’on puisse associer son existence même à une prise de position, par reproduction et validation. En réalité, <em>Skyjo</em> nous donne ce que nous réclamons : de l’espoir et de la considération. Reste à nous de décider si nous voulons passer le reste de notre vie à Seahaven*… ou en sortir.</p><p><em>Romain Pichon-Sintes — Le Miroir des jeux — Avril 2024</em></p><p>*ville imaginaire où se situe l’action du film <em>The</em> <em>Truman Show</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*XfbH8TCvgtlqxvlpDYwlIA.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=559446388241" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Anatomie de l’escape box]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/anatomie-de-lescape-box-e00156abea2f?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e00156abea2f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sciences-du-jeu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeux-de-société]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[escape-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[escape-box]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Aug 2024 14:28:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-12T07:55:16.110Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Quand l’énigme se fait langage du monde</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TgEEhnT7I4Nmm6Uq1jd3gg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Derrière la bannière du mot « escape game » se cachent de multiples réalités. Si nous avons déjà évoqué certains des paradoxes de l’<a href="https://www.ludogamie.com/blog/mission-impossible-au-bureau-des-legendes">escape room immersive</a>, il nous fallait encore nous attaquer à ce genre particulier qu’est l’<em>escape box</em>, parfois aussi appelé escape game « de table » ou simplement jeu d’enquête.</p><p>Cette famille ludique inonde aujourd’hui les boutiques (physiques et virtuelles) et, pour certains éditeurs au bras long, les grandes surfaces. Vous en connaissez déjà les gammes les plus courantes — <em>Unlock</em>, <em>Exit</em>, <em>Dossiers Criminels</em>, <em>Sous Scellé</em>, <em>Chronicles of Crime</em>, <em>Deckescape — </em>souvent regroupées sur la même étagère d’un vendeur et ce bien qu’elles ne soient assurément pas toutes créées égales : le champ de l’escape box est semé d’autant de perles que de navets.</p><p>Malgré la diversité de ses titres et le flou de ses frontières, l’étalement des mécaniques et des expériences qu’il propose, le genre se caractérise au fond par l’extraction d’un même gisement : <em>le mystère</em>. Au-delà du sens commun (ce qui est caché, secret), le mystère est un puissant méta-moteur de jeu : il porte en lui un objectif clair (découvrir le caché, combler un défaut de connaissance) et s’adapte à une multitude de chemins et d’imaginaires construits pour atteindre cet objectif.</p><p>Le mystère est un mur que le public des jeux d’énigme et d’enquête cherche à enjamber pour voir ce qu’il y a derrière : un mur plus ou moins haut, plus ou moins bien bâtit, plus ou moins vraisemblable. Bienvenue dans l’art subtil de l’escape box.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2qxekb2AkSqKa7zpcXv-5A.jpeg" /><figcaption>L’excellente gamme <strong>The Curious Correspondance Club</strong></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Du concept</strong></h4><p>Pour être précis, il nous faut dans un premier temps distinguer <em>jeux d’enquête</em> et <em>jeux d’énigmes</em>. Les deux mettent à l’épreuve la sagacité des joueurs et supposent la recherche d’une solution au problème contenu dans la boîte. Leurs mécaniques de jeu diffèrent sensiblement, bien qu’elles puissent circuler d’une catégorie à l’autre, tout en allant puiser dans un pot commun de mini-jeux, cryptages, problèmes mathématiques et autres casse-têtes. L’enquête et l’énigme ne sont d’ailleurs pas exclusives : elles sont le fruit de la même graine — le caché.</p><p>Les éléments de jeu d’une enquête se distinguent toutefois par leur <em>intelligibilité immédiate</em>. Un rapport de police, une note manuscrite du suspect, un écran de vidéo-surveillance, un ticket de métro poinçonné : l’information que porte l’objet est directement accessible. C’est la <em>chronologie</em> et l’<em>interdépendance</em> des faits, cachées à nos yeux, qui construisent le mystère. Les « purs » jeux d’enquête (comme <em>Sous Scellé</em>, <em>Cold Case </em>ou le renommé<em> </em><a href="https://gusandco.net/2018/11/13/detective-jeu-critique-iello/"><em>Detective</em></a>) sont fondamentalement des jeux d’<em>assimilation </em>: il nous faut ingurgiter une grande quantité d’informations nouvelles et morcelées pour ensuite tisser des liens entre elles. Éprouver notre finesse d’analyse est tout l’intérêt du jeu, dont l’objectif est généralement de répondre à une série de questions de compréhension (qui est le tueur ? quel est son mobile ? etc).</p><p>Les jeux d’énigmes sont à l’inverse marqués par une certaine <em>inaccessibilité première </em>: le contenu même de ce que je vois ne fait pas sens <em>a priori</em>. Qu’il s’agisse d’une disposition particulière d’objets sur une table, d’un message crypté, d’une prophétie sibylline, d’un alignement incongru de signes, de morceaux de poterie sous forme de puzzle… l’énigme se reconnait à l’opacité de son énoncé. Elle met à l’épreuve l’esprit du joueur, « confronté en quelque sorte aux pièges de ses propres projections mentales, de ses cadres de pensée » (Schmoll, 2024). L’énigme nous invite plus globalement à regarder le monde sous un angle nouveau.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rXcirKfiXBTxqv8VUIowcw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Detective box</strong></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Du matériel</strong></h4><p>L’escape box reprend une caractéristique essentielle du jeu de société : la centralisation de son matériel. La boîte contient tous les éléments nécessaires à la résolution du problème. Si les enquêtes de type ARG (<em>alternate reality games</em>) travaillent l’idée d’<em>éclatement de la source</em> (via des supports réels et extérieurs au jeu, comme des faits historiques et documents en ligne), l’escape box vise au contraire sa <em>concentration</em>. Le genre nous offre ainsi un « baluchon de mystère » avec lequel cheminer le temps d’une soirée.</p><p>Cette concentration produit d’ailleurs un effet complexe à solutionner en termes de game design : la confusion de la découverte simultanée de tous les éléments de jeu. Ce <em>brouillard de guerre</em>, excitant de découverte, se double d’une première étape généralement fastidieuse de prise de connaissance intégrale du contenu disponible. Certains jeux jugulent ce débordement en organisant la découverte progressive de l’information par un système d’exploration spatiale (<em>Unlock</em>, <em>Time Stories, Chronicle of Crimes, </em><a href="https://gusandco.net/2023/11/30/guilty-houston-2015-jeu-critique-iello/"><em>Guilty</em></a>). L’ouverture classique par « commotion cérébrale » (tout d’un coup !) peut toutefois rester une source de plaisir et faire partie intégrante de l’expérience.</p><p>Pour des raisons de praticité et de coût de fabrication, le matériel des escape boxes commercialisées est essentiellement constitué de papier. Sur la table, des feuilles étalées de différents formats sur lesquelles se penchent des visages concentrés et perplexes — de loin, pas de différence avec la prise de tête d’une déclaration d’impôts. L’usage d’un matériel original et en volume (objet exotique ou inattendu) produit toujours un effet marquant (comme dans les géniaux <em>Codex</em> et <em>Legacy : Quest for a Family Treasure</em>), même s’il peut parfois rester purement décoratif (<em>On Circus Ground</em>).</p><p>C’est justement cette distinction par le matériel et l’exploration de la dimension tactile qui font tout l’attrait des escape boxes événementielles (comme celles du <a href="https://www.village-enquete.com/">Village Enquête</a> ou des diverses « malles à escape game » que l’on trouve en festival, team-building ou exploration urbaine). Généralement uniques ou produites en peu d’exemplaires, ces boxes réinvestissent l’objet, sa sensualité, son magnétisme, son aura, comme source inépuisable d’énigmes et de fascination.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lRKswQlYZSNYI1gWzuJn-w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Legacy : Quest for a Family Treasure</strong><em> (Mathias Daval, 2023)</em></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Du réalisme</strong></h4><p>C’est donc sur le papier que se joue la bataille de la représentation : que montrer et comment le montrer ? Resurgit ici tout le dilemme du « second degré » (Brougère, 2005) et du « faire-semblant » : dès lors que l’objet qui sert narrativement de support à l’information utile n’est pas lui-même une feuille de papier (comme l’est un rapport d’enquête, une photo, un flyer ou un plan de ville), ce qui est représenté reçoit de fait le sceau du factice. C’est notre imagination et notre volonté « d’y croire pour le jeu », de combler diligemment le fossé entre le signifiant et son signifié, qui rendent l’engament possible avec ce monde de faux.</p><p>La gamme <em>Unlock</em> illustre parfaitement cette tension : le jeu n’est composé que de cartes. Mais les éléments de l’histoire, eux, ne sont jamais <em>sur</em> des cartes : ils sont sur la coque d’un sous-marin, sur un meuble, dans un sac à main, etc., qui sont <em>représentés</em> sur la carte : les joueurs manipulent ainsi des <em>images</em> (et non l’objet lui-même).</p><p>Si les jeux d’enquêtes en particulier — et c’est ce qui fait leur attrait — aspirent plus qu’ailleurs à une certaine pureté de la forme et privilégie au maximum le réalisme de ses documents, la grande majorité des escape boxes recherche l’effet de réel. L’objectif est, sinon de faire coïncider l’élément de jeu avec l’objet réel (un rapport de garde à vue A4 livré « tel quel »), du moins la représentation réaliste d’un objet qui <em>pourrait</em> être réel (en une sorte de nature morte d’objets entassés sur une table, comme dans <em>Mystery Poster</em>).</p><p>Dès lors, le photoréalisme s’impose comme la technique privilégiée du genre : c’est ce qui le distingue du reste de la production ludique, plutôt tournée vers l’illustration figurative. Ce quête de réalisme se fonde sur un désir d’immersion. En minimisant la friction de la représentation, tout un pan d’escape boxes visent ainsi le <em>frisson du réel </em>: ce que vous avez entre les mains pourrait être vrai.</p><p>Les concepteurs et conceptrices sont ainsi en permanence à se poser la question : jusqu’où pousser la vraisemblance ? Bien qu’il existe une grande diversité de supports papiers (carte postale, plan, rapport, livre, etc.), s’affranchir du vraisemblable offre un important renouvellement de la matière des énigmes. Il s’agit, en clair, de faire certaines concessions sur le réalisme de l’objet et de sa représentation pour ouvrir le champ des possibles. C’est notamment là qu’excellent les jeux d’énigme, dont l’équilibre fragile entre support et représentation est parfois brillamment réussi (comme dans <em>Curious Correspondance Club</em> où l’on se retrouve, dans l’un des épisodes, à faire tourner une « caisse » en papier sur le plan d’un entrepôt pour trouver un code) ou terriblement déceptif, laissant un arrière-goût de bâclé proche du degré zéro de l’immersion (<em>HomecapeHome, Deckscape</em> et nombre de « livres-escape » de supermarché).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8vyFQ1e-u0oYmKf8uygLTQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>De l’histoire</strong></h4><p>Toutes les escape boxes s’inscrivent dans un imaginaire qui est, plus encore que pour le jeu de société, la vraie porte d’entrée de l’expérience : le titre, la couverture, les éléments visuels, le pitch — tout concoure à nous plonger dès le départ dans une histoire. L’univers et le cadre géo-temporel viennent ensuite donner une cohérence stylistique à l’ensemble des objets réunis dans la boîte : c’est sa <em>couleur narrative</em>. Le contraire — un assemblage d’énigmes et de casse-têtes sans histoire — rendrait l’expérience relativement austère, quoique non dénuée de plaisir : c’est déjà ce que nous faisons avec le Sudoku, les puzzles et les exercices de maths. Si nous venons à l’escape box, c’est bien pour être <em>contés</em>.</p><p>L’émergence du genre pourrait être vue en cela comme une forme de réponse à ce difficile emboitement du jeu de société et du narratif, malgré les <a href="https://gusandco.net/2024/04/16/le-defi-de-la-reine-jeu-solo-medieval-fantastique-des-hasard/">tentatives modernes</a> toujours plus savantes pour allier les deux. Les escape boxes — du moins les plus réussies — ont besoin de l’histoire, à la manière d’une force gravitationnelle, pour faire tenir leur expérience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tbVCBxDG3UUKxMBX6qbQPA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mais comment raconter une histoire à travers une série d’énigmes et de documents hétérogènes ? C’est là que se loge tout l’art des « problémistes » de l’escape box (ceux qui conçoivent les énigmes, par opposition aux « solutionnistes » que constituent les joueurs). Ils doivent doser la répartition de l’information « pertinente » (utile à la résolution) et « décorative » (le narratif, le <em>lore</em>, le « fluff ») à travers les multiples supports du jeu, la première étant généralement cachée dans la seconde.</p><p>L’histoire, nécessairement diffuse et fragmentée, est ainsi présente à la fois dans le design graphique des documents (tel choix de texture, de police de caractère, de photo, de façon de présenter l’information pertinente) et dans le discours énonciateur — ce que dit le jeu directement aux joueurs sous la forme d’un texte dans le meilleur des cas diégétique (le classique texte introductif ou « lettre de mission », une note manuscrite, une page d’un journal intime, une capture d’écran de mail), mais également hors jeu (règle du jeu, texte sur la boîte et contenu additionnel de l’application dédiée). Certains jeux d’enquête affublés d’un manuel ou d’une application offrent ainsi un espace étendu de « littérature » permettant d’étoffer leur univers (<em>Les Animaux de Baker Street</em>, <a href="https://gusandco.net/2020/06/29/sherlock-holmes-detective-conseil-francs-tireurs-jeu/"><em>Sherlock Holmes — Détective Conseil</em></a>, <em>Chronicle of Crimes</em>). D’autres privilégient la dimension narrative et interactive (<a href="https://gusandco.net/2022/09/27/dune-house-of-secrets-jeu-critique/"><em>Dune : House of Secrets</em></a>, <a href="https://gusandco.net/2023/02/28/mortum-jeu-critique/"><em>Mortum : enquêtes médiévales</em></a>) avec plus ou moins de réussite.</p><p>Deux démons menacent toutefois fréquemment cette entreprise à l’alchimie difficile : 1) le <em>péché mignon du romancier</em> (vampiriser certains documents avec une surabondance de texte décoratif, souvent parce que « ça ne coûte pas plus cher ») ; 2) le <em>piège du collier de perle</em> (enchaîner les énigmes et mini-jeux en espérant lier l’ensemble par un filet narratif trop mince). Les meilleures escape boxes réussissent à intégrer la narration finement à travers tous les supports, de façon à rendre fluide et naturelle la plongée dans l’univers du jeu, jusqu’à une résolution logique et satisfaisante.</p><p>L’histoire que raconte l’escape box est ainsi toujours kaléidoscopique : c’est un puzzle mental que reconstituent les joueurs. L’objectif du jeu est l’aiguillon qui nous fait progresser à travers cette histoire en pelote. Il s’agit toujours de trouver une information que nous n’avons pas au départ : notre cheminement est celui du passage de l’ignorance à la connaissance. Cela peut être de répondre à un ensemble de questions (qui a tué Mme Perroquet ? et pourquoi ?) ou trouver un équivalent-code très important (la combinaison, le mot de passe, le nom secret, la localisation, etc.), une sorte d’exploration du « MacGuffin » hitchcockien (Truffaut, 1966). Ce cheminement est, vous l’aurez compris, à sens unique : une escape box n’est jouable qu’une fois, à l’instar d’un <em>whodunit</em> filmique ou romanesque.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l2cCUdix3vudLgAU7_Ekpg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Codex : L’Ultime secret de Léonard de Vinci</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Des mécaniques</strong></h4><p>Si le narratif reste la porte d’entrée de l’escape box c’est parce que les mécaniques de jeu sont relativement constantes et connues : il s’agit toujours de bien observer, d’associer des éléments disparates entre eux et de découvrir la logique interne du jeu (aussi tortueuse soit-elle !). Les escape boxes restent des jeux « intellectuels » qui challengent l’esprit et récompensent l’effort cognitif.</p><p>C’est à l’intérieur de ce cadre général balisé et attendu que se développe l’art subtil de l’énigme, au milieu d’un ballet de tartes à la crème et de capillotractage irrécupérable. Ce qui distinguera une escape box d’une autre, c’est bien la finesse de ses séquences logiques, sa difficulté savamment dosée, son évidence une fois résolue, et l’originalité de ses supports.</p><p>Certains éditeurs, soucieux de renouveler le genre, poussent l’exploration vers de nouvelles formes du jeu d’énigme/enquête (<em>Perspective</em>, <a href="https://gusandco.net/2022/11/04/flashback-zombies-kidz-jeu-critique/"><em>Flashback : Zombi Kids</em></a>, <a href="https://gusandco.net/2023/11/30/guilty-houston-2015-jeu-critique-iello/">Guilty</a>, mais aussi le futur <em>Split Stories</em>) tandis que d’autres se vautrent dans l’exploitation sans imagination du filon (éviter la désespérante gamme <em>Escape Box</em> de 404 éditions).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fbD1V-jR1OlUruYw7mWcZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Les jeux d’enquête « purs » (<em>Cold Case</em>, <em>Sous Scellé</em>, <em>Dossier Criminel</em>) gravitent autour de la même mécanique, celle de la <em>déduction</em>. Prenez trois éléments (l’heure de passage de la voiture A, le témoignage du personnage B, la vitesse du vent dans le lieu C) et déduisez que le coupable est X. Le modèle théorique sous-jacent est souvent celui des ensembles mathématiques (la solution regroupe tous les bons critères), même s’il peut rester une part d’interprétation qui sème le doute jusqu’à la résolution finale.</p><p>Pour les jeux d’énigme, les mécaniques et approches cognitives offrent plus de diversité, puisque moins contraintes par le réalisme d’une enquête et sa <em>méthodologie</em>. On y retrouve ainsi un large panel d’actions, comme compter, classer, organiser, agencer, superposer, manipuler, à tel point que l’on atteint parfois les limites de la vraisemblance que nous avons évoqué plus haut (la question qui fâche est toujours : « Qui, dans l’histoire, a créé l’énigme, et pourquoi s’être donné cette peine pour cacher l’information ? »). L’utilisation de matériel exotique ajoute à cette diversité des expériences (l’ombre d’une Tour Eiffel miniature projetée sur un plan dans <em>Legacy</em>, les pions d’un faux prototype de jeu dans <em>LUDUS</em>, un faux-miroir à percer dans l’épisode 3 de <em>Curious Correspondance Club</em>).</p><p>Ainsi, la différence entre jeu d’enquête et jeu d’énigme est un peu celle entre <em>Se7en</em> et <em>Indiana Jones </em>: les arrangements avec le réalisme et la vraisemblance sont différents — mais les deux produisent des chefs-d’œuvre.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wTT0tEvPXU_dHRl07ma7Aw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Guilty : Houston 2015</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Du sens à tout cela</strong></h4><p>Il n’y a pas à chercher bien loin pour comprendre la raison d’être des escape boxes : ces jeux reflètent l’énigme même du réel. Depuis l’aube des siècles, l’humanité cherche à comprendre ce qui <em>a priori</em> est incompréhensible. Nous sommes ontologiquement habités par le spectre de l’énigme.</p><p>Les escape boxes réalisent ainsi le fantasme d’une quête perpétuelle de sens. Elles nous donnent accès à tout le matériel nécessaire à la résolution d’une énigme, sans ôter le plaisir du cheminement vers sa résolution. Les énigmes du réel sont obsédantes car nous n’avons précisément pas accès à toute l’information. Les faits nous sont cachés et la culture du secret (des familles, des organisations, des gouvernements) est telle que nous devons vivre en permanence avec des <em>hypothèses</em> et des dossiers irrésolus.</p><blockquote>« La diffusion des jeux cryptiques n’est sans doute pas telle qu’ils puissent prétendre être l’expression d’une société plus intelligente. Néanmoins, penser la possibilité d’une catégorie de jeux qui valorisent le mystère et sa résolution manifeste l’émergence d’une société du moins plus réflexive, qui s’interroge sur elle-même. » (Schmoll, 2024)</blockquote><p>L’omniscience de notre époque (accès permanent au monde entier) n’a pas diminué l’épaisseur du mystère, au contraire : les connexions se sont multipliées et les possibilités d’<em>interprétation</em> tout autant. C’est tout le paradoxe du progrès souligné par Edgard Morin (2017) : à mesure que les connaissances objectives progressent, de nouveaux mystères émergent — ainsi que de nouvelles croyances.</p><p>Les escape boxes répondent à cette anxiété en offrant une forme de résolution, de clôture dans un monde qui n’en a aucune. Au fond, l’émergence de l’escape box coïncide avec le besoin d’être rassuré — à tort ou à raison — sur la possibilité d’une explication au profond mystère qui enveloppe nos vies.</p><p><em>Romain Pichon-Sintes — Le Miroir des jeux — Août 2024</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*2hYvMBj7btmS_o2JbWYXkg.png" /></figure><h4><strong>Références</strong></h4><blockquote>Brougère, Gilles (2005). <em>Jouer/Apprendre</em>. Economica.<br>Morin, Edgard (2017). <em>Connaissance, ignorance, mystère</em>. Fayard.<br>Schmoll, Patrick (2024). « Énigme », dans <em>Dictionnaire des Sciences du jeu</em>, sous la direction de Gilles Brougère et Emmanuelle Savignac. Éditions érès.<br>Truffaut, François (1966). <em>Le Cinéma selon Alfred Hitchcock</em>. Robert Laffont.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e00156abea2f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Présupposés de culture ludique]]></title>
            <link>https://mirrorsofplay.medium.com/pr%C3%A9suppos%C3%A9s-de-culture-ludique-ac944d71d207?source=rss-0b0d17ce4058------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac944d71d207</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sémiologie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture-ludique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sciences-du-jeu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeu-de-société]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mirrors of Play]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jun 2024 06:18:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-10T14:42:01.440Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>Retour sur certaines lapalissades du jeu de société</em></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yzWAVrBm8qGkCM6IQ2CaoQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Los jugadores de dados (Simó Gómez, 1874)</figcaption></figure><p>Imaginons pour un instant que vous n’ayez jamais croisé la route d’aucun jeu de société. Ni <em>Monopoly</em>, ni Scrabble, ni Uno, ni <em>Cluedo</em>, ni Mancala, ni <em>Mille-Bornes, </em>ni Échecs, ni Poker, ni<em> </em><a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/1824/trump-the-game"><em>Trump The Game</em></a>, ni <em>Skyjo</em>, ni <em>Catan</em>, ni Morpion, ni <a href="https://gusandco.net/2024/03/31/unmatched-mythologies-dun-blockbuster/"><em>Unmatched</em></a>, ni <a href="https://lemiroirdesjeux.medium.com/pandemic-legacy-apprendre-%C3%A0-gouverner-b0592937c76d"><em>Pandemic Legacy</em></a> — bref, le désert des Meeples.</p><p>Un jeu de société pourra vous apparaître comme un objet bien curieux dont l’intérêt même vous laissera peut-être de marbre. Mais surtout, toute personne cherchant à vous expliquer des règles, rituel nécessaire d’une <em>mise à égalité</em> des participants, aura du souci à se faire : vous partez littéralement de zéro.</p><p>Et pour cause, nous sommes dotés d’un <em>capital culturel ludique</em> fort de nombreux tropismes et présupposés qui se passent d’explications. Ces acquis que l’on ne pourra plus désapprendre nous permettent tout autant une prise en main rapide du matériel et des mécaniques d’un jeu que l’exercice de formes d’expression toujours plus complexes et raffinées.</p><p>Nous allons ici tenter de rebattre les cartes et de revenir à la donne la plus fondamentale possible. Non seulement dans une perspective de conscientisation des écarts culturels qui pourraient exister avec des non-joueurs — la culture ludique n’échappe pas aux dérives perverses de la distinction bourdieusienne — mais aussi, précisément, pour son intérêt dans la recherche de formes nouvelles. C’est en effet en questionnant sans cesse les fondements d’un art, même les plus évidents, que des embranchements formels originaux peuvent émerger.</p><p>Quels sont donc les présupposés de cette fameuse culture ludique ? Arrêtons-nous sur quelques-uns d’entre eux.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nLSOxeh0AjFvp0EEd6n0nw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>L’Origine </strong>(Marc Antoine Matthieu, 1990) — <strong>Suprematist painting</strong> (Malevich, 1915)</figcaption></figure><h4>Piocher une carte</h4><p>Piocher une carte est tout ce qu’il y a de plus commun dans un jeu de société. Vous ne trouverez aucune règle de jeu qui vous en expliquera le principe, à savoir : prendre la carte du dessus d’un paquet — c’est spontanément ce que vous auriez fait. Mais pourquoi ne pas le faire au milieu du paquet ou même à la fin ? D’un point de vue statistique, c’est relativement équivalent dans la plupart des jeux.</p><p>Psychologiquement, cependant, la prochaine carte à devoir être piochée est connue, <em>maîtrisée</em> : elle est à la vue de tous et en cela acquiert un statut particulier qui la distingue des autres — c’est <em>la carte du dessus</em>. En piochant cette carte précisément, vous préservez l’ordre établit du paquet : le destin est figé (au moment de battre les cartes) et vous ne faites que dérouler le programme secret de la pioche.</p><p>L’action « Piocher » est l’une des briques élémentaires du jeu de société, au même titre que « Distribuer » ou « Lancer un dé », si familière qu’elle ne soulève plus de question. Elle présuppose néanmoins de savoir identifier l’<em>origine</em> (où va-t-on piocher : d’un méta-élément de jeu formant la « pioche », d’un autre paquet, de la main d’un autre joueur, d’un sac ou de tout autre zone de jeu accessible ?) et la <em>destination</em> (que faire de cette chose que j’ai maintenant en main ?). Piocher est ainsi plus que le geste qu’il sous-entend : il est intrinsèquement chargé d’informations propres au jeu et à la règle. C’est précisément cette capacité à identifier avec aisance ce qui enveloppe l’action de piocher qui constitue un premier « capital ludique » de base.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pFUYGeXYStJd-bmFCEXpWg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Dice Man</strong> (Luke Rhinehart, 1971) — <strong>La partie de cartes</strong> (Fernand Léger, 1917) — <strong>Un coup de dés jamais n’abolira le hasard </strong>(Stéphane Mallarmé, 1897)</figcaption></figure><h4>Défausser</h4><p>Double maléfique de « Piocher », l’action « Défausser » est un autre grand classique de la culture ludique, plus riche encore. Elle présuppose qu’il existe une zone du jeu distincte de la pioche, la « défausse », une sorte d’espace mort qui contiendrait les cartes (ou autres éléments) mises de côté. Le sens fondamental de Défausser pourrait se résumer ainsi : écarter un élément actif du jeu vers une zone identifiée et lui donner le statut de « défaussé », globalement synonyme de hors-jeu, sur lequel je n’ai généralement plus d’emprise ou d’intérêt pour la suite de la partie.</p><p>Mais le concept de défausse implique un certain nombre de propriétés qui en font une action plus difficile à assimiler qu’il n’y paraît. La défausse peut être collective ou personnelle ; les cartes peuvent être défaussées face cachées ou face visible ; elles peuvent passer d’une appartenance exclusive à une disponibilité collective ; la défausse peut, ou non, être consultée ; les cartes défaussées ne pourront plus resservir pendant la partie en cours, sauf dans le cas des jeux qui utilisent la défausse de façon active (de <em>Magic</em> à <em>Skyjo</em>) — certains jeux indiquent d’ailleurs parfois de « remettre dans la boîte » pour signifier physiquement l’irréversibilité de la défausse.</p><p>Défausser est si diversement utilisé que l’on peut légitimement en faire une autre brique élémentaire des jeux de société. D’un point de vue formel, il n’y a par exemple pas de différence objective entre « jouer un pli » et « défausser une carte de sa main face visible au centre de la table puis comparer les valeurs des cartes ainsi défaussées ». D’autant que la notion peut-être élargie à autre chose que les cartes : les pièces d’Échecs prises (qui restent disponibles en cas de promotion du pion), les ressources remises « à la banque » (qui reviennent au pot commun) ou encore les documents utilisés d’un escape game (qui ne serviront plus) peuvent être considérés comme autant d’éléments défaussés.</p><p>La notion de défausse implique ainsi deux présupposés : une conscience de la <em>spatialisation signifiante de l’espace de jeu</em> (certaines zones géographiques possèdent des fonctions particulières, notamment la défausse) et une reconnaissance de <em>l’instabilité</em> <em>des propriétés des éléments de jeux</em> (qui peuvent changer d’état au cours du de la partie, comme passer d’accessible à inaccessible, de privé à public, etc.).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NGJxbLmszXV0alYndto4Qg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Kaartenhuis </strong>(Château de cartes) (Patrick Van Caeckenbergh, 1993) — <strong>Batman </strong>(Tim Burton, 1989)</figcaption></figure><h4>Tenir ses cartes en main</h4><p>Une règle d’un jeu pourrait dire : « Distribuez cinq cartes à chaque joueur ». Mais que suis-je sensé faire <em>concrètement</em> de mes cartes ? La réponse pourra vous sembler évidente mais c’est précisément tout l’enjeu de notre réflexion — questionner l’évidence.</p><p>Tout jeu pose la question : comment manipuler son matériel ? Pour ne pas avoir à tout réexpliquer, les jeux de société s’appuient implicitement sur un capital ludique acquis depuis l’enfance. Dans le cas des cartes, l’instruction la plus courante est certainement celle de les prendre avec les deux mains et d’utiliser les pouces pour les faire défiler en éventail. L’aurions-nous fait autrement si nous ne l’avions jamais vu faire ? Question anthropologique, assurément.</p><p>Mais si prendre en main un objet que l’on vous distribue et orienter vers vous son information pertinente (ici, le recto de la carte) est l’option « naturelle », si telle est son <em>affordance primaire</em>, les cartes pourraient très bien appeler à un usage différent, comme rester devant vous (et c’est parfois ce que le jeu demande), être tournées vers les autres (comme dans <em>Hanabi</em>) voire ne pas être regardées du tout. Le geste particulier demeure contextuel mais aussi culturel.</p><p>Ainsi, la <em>proprioception pertinente </em>des éléments d’un jeu est bien un apprentissage. Relativement stable et répandue dans le cas d’un jeu avec des cartes (encore que la question du mélange d’un paquet de cartes est un véritable observatoire de la disparité des pratiques), la proprioception n’en est pas moins un savoir discriminant en ce qui concerne le reste du matériel traditionnel (pions, jetons, plateau, dés). Certes, il n’y aura jamais rien dans un jeu qui ne puisse être rapidement <em>pris en main</em> — seule la quantité d’information portée par le matériel et la complexité des dynamiques peuvent constituer des freins à l’entrée. Mais ce n’est pas tant la manipulation physique qui compte que sa mise en relation dans un espace codifié et ritualisé. L’utilisation de l’objet doit se faire dans le respect des règles communes, servir notre lecture et compréhension du jeu, informer notre éventuelle stratégie, traduire nos options modales et exprimer nos intentions : le programme est chargé !</p><p>Apprendre à manipuler ses cartes est autant destiné à rendre possible le jeu avec l’autre qu’à servir son propre jeu. Cela pose une autre question : une fois les cartes en main, doit-on et comment les organiser ? Cet aspect est souvent laissé à la discrétion de chacun, l’objectif d’un tri quelconque étant généralement d’alléger notre charge cognitive. Dans un jeu traditionnel, il est courant de classer ses cartes par couleur et ordre numérique. Mais c’est un acquis qui en présuppose un autre : la connaissance des valeurs relatives des cartes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nsxg5FYQ_3nolmTMArWWzQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Le jeu traditionnel <strong>Dou Shu Qi </strong>— <strong>Triangle of Sadness</strong> (Ruben Östlund, 2022)</figcaption></figure><h4>Hiérarchiser les éléments de jeu</h4><p>Que l’information circule sur des cartes, des tuiles ou des cubes ne fait fondamentalement pas de différence : les jeux s’appuient régulièrement sur un système interne de valeurs qui permet de hiérarchiser la « force » des éléments entre eux.</p><p>Tous les jeux de <em>comparaison</em> s’appuient ainsi sur des modalités de classement qui leur sont propres, des jeux les plus traditionnels (Pierre-Feuille-Ciseaux, Tarot, Poker, etc.) aux plus modernes (<em>Unmatched</em>, <em>Challenger</em>, <em>Stratego</em>, <em>Love Letters, Blitzkrieg</em> et même <em>Magic</em>) : une information est comparée à une autre et une règle commune aux joueurs « juge » de qui l’emportera entre les deux.</p><p>Les jeux de cartes traditionnels ont réussi à instaurer une culture commune de la hiérarchie des figures. Il est de notoriété publique qu’une Dame « bat » un Valet, bien que ce présupposé soit parfois remis en question, comme à la <a href="https://lemiroirdesjeux.medium.com/la-belote-et-ses-m%C3%A9taphores-acc6bc418a4f">Belote</a> — ce qui laisse entrevoir la profonde versatilité des usages et renvoie en permanence le jeu à des cultures locales.</p><p>Le cas des comparaisons de valeurs numéraires reste le système le plus simple à acquérir « instinctivement » (la valeur la plus haute gagne toujours), mais le jeu a plus d’un tour dans son sac et rien n’est jamais acquis : il a fallu que le « 1 » (l’As) soit le meilleur ! Les cartes fortes peuvent en outre devenir désavantageuses lorsqu’elles se convertissent en points dans un jeu où il s’agit d’avoir le score le plus faible. Cette inconstance de la valeur chiffrée s’observe jusque dans un jeu de capture traditionnel comme le <em>Dou Shu Qi</em>, qui fait s’affronter des animaux classés de 1 (le rat) à 10 (l’éléphant). Si dans l’approche la plus répandue les valeurs hautes battent les plus petites, dans certaines versions chinoises du jeu, c’est l’inverse. Pour ajouter à l’intérêt stratégique, le 1 peut battre le 10… uniquement s’il initie l’attaque, offrant ainsi des renversements de situation passionnants.</p><p>Au fond, c’est cette habitude de manipuler des puissances relatives et constamment changeantes d’un jeu à l’autre qui constitue cette part de bagage culturel ludique. Elle tient autant à notre capacité à comprendre les tenants et aboutissants d’une règle du jeu (qu’est ce qui est objectivement « fort ») qu’à une solide lecture des dynamiques et des stratégies (qu’est-ce qui est circonstanciellement fort).</p><p>Les éléments de jeu peuvent en outre mêler des « coûts » (d’acquisition, de pose, etc.) et des opportunités (les effets produits), qui complexifient le système économique des jeux (la dépense nécessaire à une action étant toujours ramenée à son gain). Si aux Échecs n’importe quelle pièce peut « manger » une autre, leurs valeurs relatives sont toutefois régulièrement comparées dans l’optique d’un « échange » : je perds un Cavalier mais je prends une Tour — suis-je gagnant ?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-OXiasMw-OWDrzIBhbnT2Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Ghost Writer </strong>(Roman Polanski, 2010) — <strong>Le village </strong>(M. Night Shyamalan, 2004)</figcaption></figure><h4>Garder cachée l’information</h4><p>La prise en main de cartes ou de pièces porteuses d’informations nous amène à un autre truisme important du monde ludique : le secret. Si deux grandes catégories de jeux devaient être retenues, il y aurait d’un côté ceux dans lesquels l’information est, à tout moment, connue de tous (on parle généralement de jeux à « information parfaite »), et d’un autre ceux qui s’appuient sur une forme plus ou moins partielle de masquage de l’information : la connaissance objective que l’adversaire a du jeu n’est pas dans ce cas superposable à la mienne.</p><p>Le présupposé ici est celui de l’<em>adhésion tacite</em> au fait de maintenir cachée l’information qui doit l’être : l’intérêt du jeu en dépend. Une distribution au hasard des rôles (comme c’est le cas dans le <a href="https://gusandco.net/2024/04/24/loups-garous-thiercelieux-miroir-societe-democratie-comportements-humains/">Loup-Garou</a>) ou d’une main de départ (comme au Poker) n’a de sens que si les joueurs gardent secrète l’information qu’ils ont reçu. Même si la règle peut parfois explicitement mentionner de « ne pas montrer ses cartes », nous savons, avant même de commencer à jouer, qu’il s’agit là d’un présupposé élémentaire. Or c’est précisément parce celui-ci vous semble si évident que cet habitus ludique doit être identifié comme tel.</p><p>Les joueurs, dans leur grande majorité, adhèrent, pour l’intérêt de la communauté, au respect de l’information cachée. Contrevenir à cette règle commune, volontairement ou involontairement, nuit au <em>projet collectif</em> que constitue tout jeu. Notre capital culturel est ici la conscience d’un ensemble de règles tacites dictant de ce qui est bon et nécessaire au fonctionnement idéal d’un jeu de société.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3fLwyw7HUIEgyjRh0GPJTA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Le Tricheur à l’as de carreau</strong> (George de La Tour, c. 1636) — <strong>Pickpocket </strong>(Robert Bresson, 1959)</figcaption></figure><h4>Respecter la règle ou tricher</h4><p>De la même façon que je sais qu’il ne faut pas, pour l’intérêt du jeu, montrer les informations que je suis sensé garder cachées, ce qui relève de la triche est un savoir généralement bien identifiable par les joueurs.</p><p>Globalement, toute action qui détourne ou ignore les règles de façon déloyale à l’avantage d’un joueur peut être considéré comme triche. Mais les règles ne sont pas un manuel exhaustif de toutes les actions qu’il ne faut <em>pas</em> faire : se servir à la banque, reprendre une carte d’un pli joué, déplacer son pion sans lancer le dé, jouer les pièces de l’adversaire, échanger des cartes entre joueurs, etc. Il y a donc un immense champ des possibles pour faire <em>autre chose</em> que ce que le jeu attend de nous, ce dont nous empêche là encore notre culture ludique — et plus largement notre éducation : les deux se superposent dans le cas du respect de la règle.</p><p>La triche n’a bien sûr rien de spécifique aux jeux. De l’évasion fiscale à l’anti-sèche du bac ou encore aux bagarres à dix contre un, l’Humanité se distingue par sa capacité au détournement et au contournement de la règle. La triche raconte pourtant notre recherche quasi programmatique de l’efficience (un maximum de gain pour un minimum d’effort) : pourquoi suivre le chemin balisé, quand le raccourci à travers la forêt me fait gagner du temps, de l’énergie et de l’argent ? Allez expliquer cela à l’administration française.</p><p>Mais si la sauvagerie du réel nous apprend (nous encourage ?) à tricher, les jeux nous invitent à une autre vision du monde : la triche brise la confiance des joueurs entre eux et dévalue l’expérience collective, détruit le sens qu’on lui donne. Respecter la règle commune pour l’intérêt général est un présupposé de culture ludique qu’il nous se serait bien avisé faire déborder du monde du jeu.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D1uilNhGguFzGXfOPCCdcg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Scrooge McDuck</strong>, alias Picsou (dessin origiaux de Meg Furey) — <strong>Furiosa </strong>(George Miller, 2024)</figcaption></figure><h4>Convertir la ressource</h4><p>Une ressource dans un jeu de société correspond grosso modo à un élément de jeu qui peut être converti en un autre ou être « dépensé » pour déclencher ou résoudre un effet particulier. Quasiment tout est une forme de ressource. Qu’il s’agisse d’argent pour acheter une carte Rue dans le <em>Monopoly</em>, de matière première pour créer des routes et des villages dans <em>Catan</em>, de vivres et points de santé dans <em>L’Expédition perdue</em>, de mana dans <em>Magic</em>, de temps dans <em>Kite</em>, de mines de gemmes dans <em>Splendor</em> ou de chaînages technologiques dans <em>7 Wonders</em>. Même les dés peut-être vus comme une ressource : ceux qu’on lance dans un « roll and move » pour avancer, ceux d’un « yam’s avec des baffes » (<em>King of Tokyo</em>, <em>Wanted</em>)<em>, </em>ou encore ceux qu’on attribue à des zones pour déclencher des combos (<em>La Mort aux trousses</em>). Les points de victoire, enfin, sont également à voir comme une forme de ressource, souvent non convertible, qui peuvent constituer l’objectif et sur lesquels tout le moteur du jeu branche son circuit général de conversion de ressource.</p><p>Cette évidence, même si elle n’est pourtant pas toujours perçue comme telle par les joueurs, entre dans notre bouquet de présupposés car elle constitue le langage naturel des jeux. Autour de la table, nous jouons bien souvent avec un moteur logico-mathématique habillé d’une histoire, un moteur plus ou moins complexe de gestion de la ressource.</p><p>D’un point de vue macroscopique, les jeux sont en quelque sorte de grandes plateformes de conversions, d’échange et d’altération de variables que l’on appelle or, blé, mana, points d’action, etc. Les joueurs aguerris ont à l’oreille cette petite musique de la ressource et naviguent avec d’autant plus de facilité dans l’océan ludique.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*izoHw9vF7g0zhKSGjvQiTA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Le réveil de Kumbhakarna</strong> (Sahibdin, gouache sur papier, 1653) — <strong>There Will Be Blood</strong> (Paul Thomas Anderson, 2007)</figcaption></figure><h4>Désirer gagner</h4><p>Tout joueur, à un moment ou à un autre de l’explication d’une règle, posera spontanément la question : quel est le but du jeu ? Un jeu qui n’aurait pas d’objectif appartiendrait à un espace limite questionnant sa nature même de jeu. C’est bien parce qu’il y a un objectif à atteindre et des contraintes acceptées et partagées (les règles) qu’il peut y avoir jeu de société.</p><p>Pourtant, au-delà de cette nécessité, il est tout aussi légitime de se demander : pourquoi un jeu aurait-il un but sinon celui de s’amuser ? Nonobstant les « jeux à enjeux », le but premier d’un jeu est certainement le plaisir qu’il est sensé provoquer à travers son usage. Poser la question de la finalité n’est donc pas anodine. C’est d’ailleurs un débat que vous avez certainement eu autour d’une table : jouer pour gagner ou jouer pour s’amuser ? Si le premier n’exclut pas le second, le jeu pour le pur amusement pourrait très bien se passer d’une façon de jouer tendue vers l’objectif. Je peux participer au jeu et au plaisir du moment sans pour autant me préoccuper de ce que me demande de faire le jeu.</p><p>La culture ludique nous lègue cependant une certaine désirabilité de la victoire, là encore pour l’intérêt du jeu. La combativité est attendue des participants, au risque dans le cas contraire de provoquer l’ennui ou le désintérêt — ce qui ferait effondrer le projet même de jeu. Le désir de victoire est dans ce cas le présupposé attendu à l’entrée de toute expérience ludique : c’est ce que les joueurs se doivent les uns aux autres. Cette victoire peut n’avoir aucun enjeu (émotionnel, financier, égotique), et le résultat final peut très bien me laisser indifférent. Mais il y a une différence de taille entre ne pas se soucier des écarts du score en fin de partie et se battre jusqu’au bout pour avoir le meilleur score.</p><p>Le capital ludique est ici celui de l’engagement dans l’expérience, de la <em>présence active</em>. Si je ne travaille pas à avancer du mieux que je peux vers l’objectif du jeu, je dois m’efforcer de ne pas le montrer : la pratique du jeu nous invite dans ce cas à une certaine forme de retenue. « Un homme, ça s’empêche », disait Camus, avec justesse. C’est peut-être aussi de cette forme élégante de discrétion que le jeu tire son héritage.</p><p>Cette brève exploration de quelques présupposés de la culture ludique vous aura peut-être donné le goût d’en chercher d’autres. Ce territoire est encore vaste — ouvrez l’œil !</p><p><em>Romain Pichon-Sintes — Le Miroir des jeux — Juin 2024</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*2AZ48kC0Dxk8S5GbNTKA7g.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac944d71d207" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>