<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Claire Willett on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Claire Willett on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@miss.willett?source=rss-39f1f3e4bff0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 11:12:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@miss.willett/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Last Supper, Table for One]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miss.willett/last-supper-table-for-one-73bd80882694?source=rss-39f1f3e4bff0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/73bd80882694</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holy-week]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[easter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[catholicism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Claire Willett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 10 Apr 2020 06:05:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-10T07:13:04.352Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Last Supper, Table For One</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kWAd9qUTudZBD66ZBZLgHw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Tonight I went to Holy Thursday Mass from my yoga mat.</p><p>Like every church on the planet which takes its parishioners’ health and safety seriously, my parish— Saint Andrew Catholic Church in Portland, Oregon — is closed for Holy Week, for Easter, and for the foreseeable future. So tonight, I watched the liturgy on my laptop, streamed on Facebook through a hundred or so computer screens.</p><p>I sat there on my yoga mat, in my meditation position, and I closed my eyes, and I sang the songs and I said the prayers, and when they read the Gospel in Spanish I worked on my breathing and tried to pick out the new words I’ve been learning from Duolingo.</p><p>I opened my eyes when Father Dave began his homily, and that’s when I started to cry.</p><p>Normally when I’m there on Sunday mornings, Saint Andrew is an ocean of cheerful chaos. There are lots of kids in the parish, and a community of adults with developmental disabilities who attend every week, so noise just kind of happens and nobody cares. Also, it’s a church that loves to sing. It’s not a building that feels right when it’s empty. It’s a building where, when they do the Sign of Peace at Mass, they basically take a halftime; everyone wanders around, stretches their legs, gives hugs, says hi to everyone they know, chats about how the kids are doing, and then only begins meandering back to their place a full five or ten minutes later.</p><p>Tonight, the church had exactly five people in it: the priest, a reader, two musicians (including my dad), all spaced a careful 6+ feet apart in a circle around the center of the room with a camera man in the middle. Father Dave stood there, alone, in front of the altar of a nearly-empty church, surreal in its stillness and quiet, and he talked about the Gospel he had just read, where Jesus offers to wash the feet of his disciples. (Another liturgical tradition lost to us this year; during Holy Thursday Mass, priests often wash and anoint the feet of twelve members of the community, sometimes people who are sick and in need of healing, or who represent the community of the parish.) He talked about how different the Gospel of the Last Supper feels this year, now that our world has changed so profoundly, and that perhaps we are all now learning that all along, the heart of God was in the very simplest part of the whole story: friends, sitting down together at a table.</p><p>The part so many of us don’t have anymore.</p><p>I am not, as a rule, a weepy person. Six months after my mother died I went to therapy because I had not cried for her yet and I thought there was something wrong with me. 90% of the time when I exclaim, on Twitter, that “OMG I CRIED SO HARD” over something, what I really mean is that I teared up slightly and experienced a cathartic wave of emotion.</p><p>That was not what happened tonight. Tonight, I <em>sobbed. </em>Shoulders shaking, tears streaming down my face. Definitely harder than I’ve cried at church since . . . ever, maybe??? But I just sat there, with my laptop balanced on my cork yoga blocks, and I cried and cried and cried. Partly, of course, I’m just tired and anxious and not sleeping very well, like everybody else on this planet. Partly shock, I think, at yet another way that Everything Is Different Now — like the way it felt to hear my voice singing together side-by-side with my father’s, sounding just the way it has always sounded in the almost thirty years that we’ve been singing at Masses together . . . except that this time, I was at my house, and he was on the other side of a screen, with his guitar in that almost-empty church, and he could not hear me.</p><p>But also partly, I think, because for most of my life, whenever I’ve spent any time contemplating the chapters of Jesus’ life and death we commemorate during Holy Week, I’ve believed that all the holiness — the Big Meaning, the Real Presence of God — is embedded in the things that seem farthest away from me, and therefore must be, mustn’t they, the things which are most profound? Surely the key moments here, the things that make Jesus special and the rest of us regular, are the Big, Shocking Plot Twists (betrayal! torture! murder!). Surely the line of demarcation is his effortless access to the divine. God’s voice, thundering from the heavens. Prophecies, healing, resurrections. Lazarus. Cana. Concrete, undeniable miracles, taking place right in front of you; things, in short, which Happened To Them Then but not things which Happen To Us Now. Things which have no place in our solidly medium-sized human lives.</p><p>I thought about my favorite line from my favorite play, Tom Stoppard’s <em>Arcadia,</em> and the way the character of Valentine talks about science. The thing about physics, he explains, is that it’s great at making sense of galaxies and molecules — “the very big and the very small” — but we still have to make our own meanings of everything that happens in the middle:</p><blockquote>“The ordinary-sized stuff which is our lives, the things people write poetry about — clouds — daffodils — waterfalls — what happens in a cup of coffee when the cream goes in — these things are full of mystery, as mysterious to us as the heavens were to the Greeks.”</blockquote><p>It’s strange how life under quarantine has flung all normal definitions of words like “introvert” or “extrovert” entirely out the window. The most gregarious people you know, the ones who crave 24/7 human contact and start climbing the walls if you leave them alone too long, are slowly beginning to unravel, trapped in their apartments with roommates they can’t take breaks from or children who are now out of school until September. And people like me, who require endless stretches of solitude to recharge — people who would have said to you, in mid-December for example, during the height of family holiday madness when every day on the calendar is stacked with two to four social events, that six weeks alone in my house would be a<em> vacation</em>, and would immediately ask where to sign up — we are unraveling too, completely ill-equipped to navigate a level of Alone-ness which is <em>this</em> alone. No pets. No roommates. My parents and sister live in different houses, my brothers in different states, my girlfriend in a different country. Just me, crying on my yoga mat, wondering how long it will be before I can have dinner with my family again.</p><p>I thought about Alice, across the sea in England, and how I was supposed to get on a plane tomorrow morning to meet her family at Easter, and how having to cancel an overseas trip any other year would leave me with at least the consolation of getting to spend the day with my own family instead, a tradition I haven’t missed since I moved home to Portland after college.</p><p>My mother died on the Tuesday of Holy Week in 2008, and the family got together for Easter brunch five days later anyway. We put on springy floral dresses and dyed eggs and ate way too much chocolate and laughed and hugged and all I remember of that day was joy, the one interlude of sunshine during an interminably long stretch of gray, because even in the midst of grieving life does not stop, because why are we even Catholic, then, what was the point of <em>any of this</em>, if you just leave the stone blocking the entrance to the tomb and stay in the darkness forever?</p><p>I thought about my Jewish friends who celebrated Passover through Skype or Zoom. I thought about the living nightmare of losing someone during a pandemic, when it’s too dangerous to gather for a funeral, or of being separate from a sick loved one in a hospital who you can only touch through a pane of glass. I thought about how human beings have been social, tribal, communal creatures since we first learned to walk upright and that to most of our ancestors — lacking the access we have, through technology, to at least see one another’s faces on a screen from time to time — the isolation we’re in right now would feel like either the height of incomprehensible privilege, or a cruel and unusual punishment, but it certainly would not feel like human life.</p><p>I thought about all the times I have sat down at a table with people I love and taken the moment for granted, not realizing how holy it was until it disappeared. Four decades of Christmases and Thanksgivings with my big, noisy extended family, so many of whom who aren’t here with us anymore. Late-night fries with the theatre kids at Shari’s or Denny’s, midnight pancakes with my sister at The Roxy. Dinner at Tavern on the Green with my cousin Justin, who took me there when I lived in New York after college so I could tell people later that I’d done it. My grandfather’s sourdough pancakes. Board game brunches and holiday cocktail parties and Oscar night, my house loud and crowded and full of laughter, my kitchen counter laden with cheese plates and baked goods. Tapas and sangria at The Maiden, the long-shuttered Spanish bar across the street from the ballet where we used to go for happy hour after work. Drinking pints of cider with Alice at the Quays in Galway, the pub where I set the epilogue of <em>The Rewind Files</em>. The perfect, crunchy fried potatoes at the Cadillac Cafe, our mother’s favorite breakfast spot, where all four siblings would spend the whole meal fighting for dominance at “The Parsley Game” (a diabolical pastime we learned from one of Dad’s Penn &amp; Teller books, whose object is to sneak your garnish onto someone else’s plate before they see you). Sitting on the couch in front of my TV, surrounded by friends in sweatpants and pajamas, drinking champagne and eating junk food and watching all ten <em>Friends </em>Thanksgiving episodes in a row. The 10 p.m. — 2 a.m. happy hour at Cassidy’s, where all the theatre people in Portland go for burgers and whiskey sours and gossip after opening nights. The dining room table in our Tokyo apartment, where I learned as a child to love so many foods I once hated, from chili con carne to falafel, because they were things I remembered my mother serving to us at home and my desperate yearning for familiarity was stronger than everything else.</p><p>That’s where God is, I think. That’s where God always was. Not a dramatic voice bellowing down from the heavens, thunder and lightning booming all around. Just people who love each other, sitting around a table.</p><p>It was right there with us, the whole time.</p><p>I am not a perfect person, and I am not a perfect Catholic. Sometimes I am not even a very good one. But I think, when I come to the end of my life, and look back, I hope that what I see is that my faith taught me how to love people better. Because if it wasn’t about that, it wouldn’t feel so wrong to be at Mass alone in my house. It wouldn’t be so surreal to see the church empty during the three days of the year it’s supposed to be the most full.</p><p>Because if it wasn’t about that, then what was the point?</p><p>I’m uncomfortable with the language we sometimes use now, about all the ways this utterly world-shattering pandemic is leading us to a sunnier, brighter future. Look, the skies in Los Angeles are so clear! Look, artists throughout history who created profound and magnificent works during disease epidemics in their own time! Look, random acts of kindness everywhere! What a kinder, gentler, more compassionate world we will have when all of this is over! And I think there’s truth in that. I think we might. But there are already thousands of people who won’t make it to that future, and thousands more we’ll lose between now and then. And in the meantime, there is this impossibly disorienting new reality where whatever balance between solitude and company each of us normally requires to feel grounded, none of us can get it. This seems, in my admittedly limited anecdotal experience, to be almost universally true, whether you are alone in a silent house like me, talking to your plants and desperate for the opportunity to be closer than six feet away from your family and friends; or whether you are lying awake at night, worrying about their health and safety because they are too far away and you cannot get to them; or whether you are stuck with them all day long in an apartment which seemed like a perfectly comfortable size back when you were allowed to leave it, but now that you can’t you are heartily sick of their faces.</p><p>We are living, like Tom Stoppard said, in the very big and the very small — at the mercy of a tiny virus, floating around our planet and wreaking mass destruction on an almost unimaginable scale — and all I want every day is to go back to living in the middle.</p><p>So insofar as I feel comfortable speaking to what The World After This Ends could look like, and the gifts it might return to us which we have lost, I am thinking only this, and perhaps you are too:</p><p>I pray that as long as I live, every time I sit down at a table with people that I love, I will never take it for granted again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=73bd80882694" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The One With the Definitive Ranking of “Friends” Holiday Episodes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miss.willett/the-one-with-the-definitive-ranking-of-friends-holiday-episodes-3039fe678f4b?source=rss-39f1f3e4bff0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3039fe678f4b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[friends]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christmas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holidays]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-picks]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Claire Willett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Nov 2019 04:39:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-11T04:39:21.563Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rLDnrxKCtYr54pcioOcq5g.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s November, which means every pop culture media outlet is about to bombard us all with variations on that favorite parlor game of Gen-Xers who grew up during the years when NBC’s Thursday night lineup was the best show in town: namely, endless ranking and re-ranking the <em>Friends</em> Thanksgiving episodes, or asking you to contemplate what your favorite says about you. Are you a “Geller football rivalry” person? a “Rachel’s beef trifle” person? a “special guest star Brad Pitt” person who hasn’t rewatched that episode in a few years and forgot that the episode’s culminating punchline is that Rachel was once known as “the hermaphrodite cheerleader from Long Island”? I am here to tell you that one HAS NOT AGED WELL. Consider switching camps and joining me as a “special guest star Christina Applegate” person. It’s so much better over here. (Also, watch <em>Dead to Me</em>.)</p><p>But as Pumpkin Spice Season gradually gives way to Red Cup Season at Central Perk — fancy overpriced espresso beverages being the only thing we basic bitches love more than thinking way too much about 90’s sitcoms — I strongly encourage you not to neglect the other slice of the <em>Friends</em> holiday episode canon: Christmas, New Year’s, and Hanukkah (that’s right, despite Monica’s opulently-decorated trees, every once in awhile the show actually remembers the Gellers are Jewish).</p><p>Ten thousand words of plot analysis ranking eleven episodes of a television show which has been off the air for fifteen years is certainly not everyone’s cup of tea, but as someone whose entire online brand is <a href="https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/gyyqjb/what-i-learned-about-real-relationships-when-my-friends-take-went-viral">Inappropriately Strong Opinions About <em>Friends</em></a>, I’m just going to trust those folks to self-select out, and proceed accordingly.</p><p>For everyone else: could I <em>be</em> any more excited to start this list?</p><p>Let’s go!</p><h3>11th Place: “The One With Christmas In Tulsa”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w9mpj4fUtnIlMye9CPqk5Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Selma Blair violates human resources sexual harassment policy in Season 9, Episode 10: “The One With Christmas In Tulsa.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p><em>Friends </em>leaned heavily on clip shows to squeeze a few extra episodes out of recycled “greatest hits” content (I’m particularly fond of Joey’s <em>Soap Opera Digest</em> interview as a framing device for his most ridiculous moments, from the singing Freud to that infomercial for the milk spout). So I suppose a Christmas clip show was inevitable, particularly towards the end of the run, but this one is a real disappointment. The actual non-flashback plot is <em>very</em> thin, and a lot more depressing than funny for those of us who have actually experienced the nightmare of being stuck at work while everyone you love is having holiday fun together without you.</p><p>The whole Chandler-moves-to-Oklahoma subplot never worked for me; this is an ensemble comedy, after all, and it really suffers when the gang is split up for too long. There’s something so dismal about one character being alone for the holidays (even though somehow, through the magic of Sitcom Airline Physics, he manages to make it home for Christmas anyway).</p><p>The episode’s one glimmer of light comes from a largely-wasted Selma Blair as Wendy, the only person at the Tulsa office given anything like a real personality (jealous of the festive holiday bash underway at the insurance company downstairs, she does what any of us would do, and steals their ham), but sexism manages to ruin this THE WAY IT RUINS EVERYTHING. It’s irritating enough to watch Monica’s immediate suspicion of Wendy after Chandler is guilted into sending the rest of the staff home for Christmas, leaving him alone in the office with a hot female coworker; but it’s downright maddening that the show actually <em>goes</em> there, making the laziest writing choice imaginable by having Wendy try to seduce her married boss.</p><p>Though much of this show has aged terribly (the blinding whiteness! the completely unexamined transphobia! the fetishization of lesbians juxtaposed with the boys’ nonstop gay panic! the notion that dinosaurs aren’t cool!), there are still moments where <em>Friends</em> is more surprisingly feminist than I remembered it. Some of the conversations about working moms, for example, were remarkably progressive for the 90’s, and “no uterus, no opinion” might be Rachel’s single most iconic line. It also often does a nice job of sidestepping obvious opportunities to pit women against other women (remember when Phoebe had to tell Rachel that Paolo grabbed her ass, and she was so nervous Rachel would be upset, but instead Rachel immediately believed her and broke up with Paolo on the spot?) So it’s disappointing to hear a jealous Monica say something as malicious as “Wendy is a fat girl name” (SHE WOULD <em>NEVER</em>, AND WE ALL KNOW IT). The whole thing is a pile of outdated, crappy tropes and a waste of a terrific guest actress. Sure, it does give us a fun relationship montage, prompting Chandler to quit his job and move back to New York so we can finally put Tulsa behind us, but GOD, AT WHAT COST</p><p>The episode’s one truly great joke — painfully familiar for those of us who have worked in office jobs — is the envelopes which everyone thinks contain Christmas bonuses but actually contain form letters saying “a donation has been made in your name to the New York City Ballet.”</p><p>Too real, <em>Friends. </em>Too real.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>Phoebe reciting “The Night Before Christmas” to Joey and convincing him she wrote it herself. Also this is a very good hair episode for all three of the women. I’M REALLY REACHING HERE.</p><p><strong>LOWS: </strong>Everything else.</p><p><strong>BEST LINE: </strong>Chandler, rebuffing Wendy’s advances: “This is probably the wrong thing to worry about, but you’re getting ham on my only tie.”</p><h3><strong>10th Place</strong>: “The One With the Inappropriate Sister”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-GN2FQXydoqmN6wbXRKJUw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Phoebe’s bell-ringing career is predictably short-lived in Season 5, Episode 10: “The One With the Inappropriate Sister.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The actual Christmas content here is minimal and only affects Phoebe, but it’s a reasonably enjoyable little side plot, where a holiday gig as a Salvation Army bell-ringer (<a href="https://www.advocate.com/religion/2017/12/08/salvation-army-we-meet-human-need-without-discrimination">no one tell her gay ice dancer ex-husband</a>!) causes her to revert back to form as terrifying Street Phoebe. By the end of the episode, she’s covered her bucket in cardboard signs (“I HAVE NO MACY’S INFO!” “PLEASE RESPECT MY PERSONAL SPACE!” “WE ARE NOT A URINAL!”) and loses her primo spot at the main store entrance after getting caught screaming at a grandma. Lisa Kudrow does terrific work as Phoebe gradually unravels from buoyant holiday cheer to open hostility, which is honestly the only rational response to standing in front of Macy’s all day while people throw lit cigarettes into your bucket. YOU’RE VALID, PHEEBS!!!</p><p>Meanwhile, in the episode’s most entertaining storyline, Ross is on sabbatical from the museum following a Thanksgiving sandwich meltdown and temporarily crashing with the guys. Joey is down in the dumps after losing out on an audition he thought he was perfect for; bored and adrift with nothing to do, Ross takes him on as a project, encouraging him to write a screenplay.</p><p>As one of four kids, I always love it when the show remembers that Ross and Monica are siblings, and finds little ways to remind us of all the ways they’re similar to each other. We’ve frequently watched one Geller take charge of her friends’ lives to boss them around, and it’s a nice bit of consistent world-building to see the other do the same, especially when continually foiled by Chandler as the devil on Joey’s other shoulder (and the inventor of a <em>wildly</em> irresponsible game called “Fireball”). The bickering escalates until Joey finally forces them to make up in the most Joey way possible: by writing a terrible apology scene, and tricking them into acting it out.</p><p>The episode title comes from its most unfortunate plot, wherein Rachel is forever acting like an idiot in front of Danny the cute downstairs neighbor (formerly known as the “Yeti”); here, she finally goes on her first date with him, only to bolt after meeting his sister and observing their, to put it delicately, Big Lannister Energy. George Newbern is such a likeable actor, but he’s almost as wasted as Selma Blair, and Rachel’s awkwardness around him is unwatchably painful (I mean that literally, I usually fast-forward). Though once again the Gellers are in fine form, aggressively judging Danny and his sister for the weird fact that they still tickle-fight as adults — before a disagreement over whether Monica could still take Ross devolves into a living room wrestling match right.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>Joey has apparently been prank-calling Chandler every day for six months, crooning <em>“I loooooove youuuuuuu”</em> in a creepy high-pitched voice, then hanging up, everything about which is perfect. Also, pause during the scene in Estelle’s office to take a look around; the set dressing is particularly nice here. Cigarettes everywhere, half-eaten sandwiches, mugs with lipstick smudges, and just the right amount of half-assed Santa decorations. Sitcom design teams don’t always get the credit they deserve, but Estelle’s office is actually a remarkably detailed little world. (In fact, don’t sleep on the holiday episode production design overall; I like Joey’s white dog statue sporting a red nose and felt antlers, and Monica’s Christmas trees are always spectacular.)</p><p><strong>LOWS: </strong>When worn in her apartment, Monica’s pigtails, purple satin pants, striped henley and slippers appeared to be pajamas, but taking that look out in public is a crime.</p><p><strong>BEST LINE: </strong>Every word of Joey’s screenplay, especially Chandler being forced to do a bad Chandler impression (“Could I <em>be</em> any more sorry?”)</p><h3>9th Place: “The One With All the Candy”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4hGrlIBrk2Pebmw9bf-ERQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Monica gets a brutal lesson in supply-and-demand economics in Season 7, Episode 9: “The One With All the Candy.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>As the episode immediately prior to the one at the very top of my list, it’s inevitable that it would fall a little flat by comparison. The less said the better about the profoundly uncomfortable plot where Rachel has to fill out a performance evaluation for her assistant Tag, whom she is now dating. Because this is a sitcom, <em>obviously</em> she fills out a “joke” version full of positive feedback on his cute butt and including “a small pornographic sketch,” and <em>obviously</em> Tag doesn’t check the envelope before sending it down to HR, and <em>obviously</em> there’s an excruciating exchange with Rachel’s boss before Tag ultimately takes the fall so she doesn’t get fired. (But hey, at least her workplace takes sexual harassment seriously, which is more than can be said for <a href="https://www.vox.com/identities/2019/10/28/20936150/nbc-lauer-weinstein-employees-sexual-harassment-nda">the network which aired this show</a>.)</p><p>Meanwhile, in the episode’s one holiday-related plot, Monica hangs a basket of handmade candy on her door for the neighbors, with predictable results: namely, the creation of a chocolate-starved stampede of greedy, demanding jerks — and a caught-up-in-the-mob-mentality Joey — who pound on the door with sugar cravings at 4 a.m. (In fairness, it looks <em>delicious</em>.)</p><p>Monica, of course, is desperate to be loved (Chandler’s sudden realization that this is why she became a chef is surprisingly astute) and caves immediately, wearing herself to the bone to churn out hundreds of homemade chocolates. She refuses offers of help (“YOU DON’T UNDERSTAND THE SYSTEM!” she barks at Ross), but can’t say no to the restless mob outside her door because, well, they think her candy tastes like “little drops of heaven.” Finally, bedraggled and frosting-streaked and circling a full-on panic attack, she is rescued by a furious Chandler, who sends everyone home for ruining the holiday fun. It’s a nice moment for them — Chandler doesn’t get to be the hero very often — but it scores very low on Christmas spirit.</p><p>Ross and Phoebe fare much better. Storylines featuring these two are rare, and generally involve his frustration at her weirdo belief system (like the fact that she thinks he studies dragons). But here we get one of the few Ross Gellers I genuinely like, the one who is both literally and figuratively the Dad Friend of the group. The gang is devastated to learn that riding a bike is another one of those youthful rites of passage they all took for granted but Phoebe missed out on, so Ross sets out to buy her the bike of her childhood dreams. He locates the exact model Baby Phoebe yearned for, complete with plastic daisies on the wicker basket and tassels on the handle. Everyone quickly realizes, however, that as much as she adores the bike, she’s afraid to ride it. Ross, in endearing Dad Mode, is successful in teaching her up to a point; but once he lets go and she crashes, she freaks out and swears off bikes forever. In the end, he’s forced to resort to trickery, convincing her that unless it fulfills its destiny, the bike will die. And, because this is Phoebe we’re talking about, that works: she gets back in the saddle and rides merrily off through the playground, ringing her adorable little bell.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>Two beautiful moments where someone opens a door to reveal Phoebe doing something completely bizarre which is never acknowledged or explained: cutting Joey’s hair in his apartment while he sits there with a bowl on his head, and putting her bike helmet on her teddy bear to vroom him around the bed.</p><p><strong>LOWS:</strong> Rachel, you know I love you, but you are a walking Human Resources violation.</p><p><strong>BEST LINE:</strong> Joey describing the neighbors in their building: “There’s, let’s see . . . Guy With a Mustache . . . Smokes-a-Lot Lady . . . some kids I’ve seen . . . oh, and a red-haired guy who does <em>not </em>like to be called ‘Rusty.’”</p><h3><strong>8th </strong>Place: “The One With the Monkey”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vOfGEu_p99WVvFsZbVpxQg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Happy New Year from five human disasters and Phoebe Buffay, in Season 1, Episode 10: “The One With the Monkey.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The premise is simple: the gang makes a pact to celebrate New Year’s without dates, which they all break almost immediately, but somehow they all end up single again by the stroke of midnight anyway. It’s a nicely-structured, though pedestrian, sitcom plot, but with one <em>infuriatingly</em> irritating twist, and is only saved from an even lower ranking by appearances from two of my all-time favorite <em>Friends</em> guest stars.</p><p>Monica and Joey have the least significant storylines. His party date is a hot single mom he met while he was working as a Macy’s holiday elf, but she arrives with her buzzkill children in tow and then makes out with another guy all night. Monica invites her ex-boyfriend Fun Bobby, who shows up in a decidedly un-fun mood because his grandfather just died, which is how Monica learns that nothing brings a party to a crashing halt like the words “open casket.”</p><p>Rachel’s night isn’t much better; she’s expecting her boyfriend Paolo (the only Italian stereotype on the show more egregious than the Tribbianis) but he doesn’t make it. Jennifer Aniston’s comedy chops are on full display as a bruised, mud-splattered Rachel limps into the party, in an inexplicably marshmallowesque white parka, to reveal that Paolo missed his flight and then apparently she got into it with some other lady waiting for an airport cab, a fight I truly wish we’d seen.</p><p>Chandler invites his on/off girlfriend Janice out of desperation, then breaks up with her before midnight because, as we all know, Chandler does not actually like Janice that much. It’s always entertaining watching him struggle to extricate himself from this relationship, mostly because Janice is Teflon, and you always know that you have not seen the last of her; the writers deploy her beautifully over ten seasons, letting her pop back in to gleefully torment the gang at all kinds of inopportune moments. I am <em>obsessed</em> with Janice, a true Chaotic Good who I consider criminally underrated by both the characters and the audience. I love her honking laugh, her unshakeable self-confidence, her hot pink and leopard print wardrobe, her cheerful resilience no matter what life brings. While I am thrilled to see her in this or any episode, quite frankly she deserves better than Chandler.</p><p>I would happily have traded all of Ross’ screen time for more Janice, but apparently someone thought this show needed a Capuchin monkey for him to creepily treat as his significant other. His annoyance at Monica’s refusal to treat Marcel like a real guest is ludicrous; he should know his own sister better than that by now! I do appreciate that the other characters’ reactions feel pretty realistic; at first Marcel is a novelty (Chandler has a great time monkey-sitting while Ross is at work), but within about ten minutes everyone is sick to death of him, which honestly feels like exactly the reaction I would have if my brother got a high-maintenance exotic pet.</p><p>But the heart of the episode belongs to Phoebe, and to the debut of Hank Azaria as geeky scientist David, who — with all due respect to Paul Rudd — will forever in my heart remain Phoebe’s lobster. David and his hilariously dickish research partner have landed a three-year research grant in Minsk, and while he’s perfectly willing to stay to be with her, Phoebe is wise enough to know that both of them would regret it if he did. They share a heartbreaking goodbye as she sends him on his way before the ball drops, “because you don’t want to start the New Year with me if you can’t finish it.” It’s a rare moment of genuine emotion, and deserves to be higher up on this list; but I just can’t stand that goddamn monkey.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>Joey’s elf costume; Phoebe’s boobs in that Renaissance Faire corset dress; David’s inner conflict between the desire to romantically sweep everything off the desk and the fear of damaging expensive science equipment.</p><p><strong>LOWS: </strong>Joey kissing Chandler at midnight is not the show’s <em>worst</em> gay panic moment, but it’s definitely high on the list. Also Paolo naming Rachel’s breasts is so slimy I need to take a shower.</p><p><strong>BEST LINE: </strong>Janice, forcing Ross to take one thousand photos of her and Chandler: “I’m gonna blow this one up and write ‘REUNITED!’ in glitter.”</p><h3>7th Place: “The One Where Rachel Quits”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VLqYrSjOIpWRxehU8sf_Pw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Rachel moves up in the world and breaks Gunther’s heart in Season 3, Episode 10: “The One Where Rachel Quits.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In a storyline that would never make it past a network today, Ross befriends the cute little Girl Scout — sorry, “Brown Bird” — played by baby Mae Whitman whose leg he accidentally broke. It is pretty endearing to watch Ross, Chandler and Joey attempt to replicate the space camp experience she’s missing out on, and I do think it’s worth noting that a little girl being passionate about science is correctly depicted as totally normal. (Also, her bedroom full of space stuff is the <em>most</em> cute.) And it’s very sweet to see Dad Ross take an earnest interest in helping a fellow baby nerd. But seriously, where are this little girl’s parents that they let a strange man just HANG OUT ALONE IN HER BEDROOM???? (Although, she does tell us her dad plans to go to Atlantic City to play the slots and “double the college money my grandma left me,” so maybe I’ve answered my own question.)</p><p>Meanwhile, in a plot every other character on this show could take a lesson from, Gunther does not allow a crush to prevent him from doing his job: namely, telling Rachel that she is a terrible waitress. He’s only trying to get her to do Central Perk Freshman Orientation again, but it backfires when she decides to quit instead. Or, rather, when Joey and Chandler convince her that she’ll never take the risk to pursue the career she wants until she finds “The Fear,” which, honey, PLEASE DO NOT TAKE CAREER ADVICE FROM JOEY TRIBBIANI</p><p>The little fakeout ending is a nice touch; Joey hooks Rachel up with a new job for a clothing retailer and she proudly announces to Central Perk that she is quitting and will never have to make coffee again . . . after which we cut to her first day of work, as a cranky old Italian dude mansplains how to make terrible drip coffee the way the boss likes it. (I want to believe even Rachel, Central Perk’s most half-assed employee, has enough pride not to reuse a filter, but honestly it could go either way.) Still, she’s on the first rung of the ladder for the career in fashion that will change her life and send her on an amazing adventure to a new life in Paris (which is where she is in my head, because <a href="https://www.eonline.com/news/872595/this-friends-twitter-thread-may-finally-prove-that-rachel-and-joey-should-have-ended-up-together">she should never have gotten off that plane</a>), and that’s something to celebrate. For my money, Rachel’s professional aspirations and her journey to find herself make for a <em>way</em> more interesting ten-season arc than her relationship with Ross, and for everyone who has ever quit a job in the desperate hope that something better will come along, this storyline is painfully relatable.</p><p>The Christmas of it all comes in the Phoebe/Joey storyline, a pairing which always results in pure delight. This one is a classic, featuring a trifecta of surefire hits: A) yet another in Joey’s long list of random temporary jobs, B) some bizarrely specific new belief Phoebe is suddenly invested in, and C) the gang’s desire to shelter her from reality and preserve her innocent joy in something, even if that something is weird. After she informs Joey that she is now opposed to the sale of Christmas trees because it’s cruel to chop them down, the boys convince her that the trees are merely “fulfilling their Christmas destiny.” But when she visits Joey at work, she is horrified to see that the trees deemed too old to sell are destined for the chipper, so Monica and Joey team up to buy them all. Phoebe’s pure unbridled joy at seeing Monica’s apartment full of brown, dried-out Christmas tree carcasses and then exclaiming “God bless us, every one!” is irresistible. Linus and Charlie Brown would approve.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>While Ross ultimately fails to unload enough cookies to win Mae Whitman that trip to space camp, his idea to roam the NYU campus at night selling them to stoners is genius. Also, the whole gang humming “Pomp and Circumstance” as Rachel serves her last cup of coffee is adorable.</p><p><strong>LOWS:</strong> There is no such thing as a thoughtfully-executed Fat Monica storyline, and the whole “lol she’s addicted to Mint Treasures” thread grates on my last nerve from beginning to end. (The show is right, however, in implying that Thin Mints are the best Girl Scout cookie.)</p><p><strong>BEST LINE:</strong> Ross attempting to justify why he bought so many of the boxes of cookies himself: “My doctor says I have a very serious nougat deficiency.”</p><h3>6th Place: The One With the Girl From Poughkeepsie</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0fsAlptBoA8HE0V1YfQJ2Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Phoebe debuts the first track on her upcoming holiday album in Season 4, Episode 10: “The One With the Girl From Poughkeepsie.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>This is a solidly medium episode, which benefits from A+ Phoebe content and some refreshing deck-shuffling: Chandler gets a story with Rachel (a rare and always welcome occurrence), and Monica is paired with Joey.</p><p>In the throwaway story that gives us the episode title, Ross attempts to date a woman who lives two and a half hours away by train, then dumps her for someone he likes less but who lives closer. That’s it, that’s the whole thing. Yes, the hassles of dating someone who lives a long, annoying commute away are real, but his behavior to both women is pretty obnoxious. (Also it’s hard for me to muster any sympathy for him when my own girlfriend lives in London.)</p><p>Rachel is mopey about being single over the holidays, so Chandler offers to set her up with a guy from his office, and accidentally mentions that Rachel is just looking for a casual fling. Apparently “Hot Rachel that you brought to the holiday party last year” made quite an impression, and every guy in the office wants to hook up with her, bribing Chandler with free cigars, whiskey, and 401K accounts to cut to the front of the line. So, I mean . . . yes, it’s a problematic hook to hang a plot on; but this friendship is woefully underrated (my biggest cry in ten seasons of this show is their goodbye in the finale before she leaves for Paris), and it ends on a sweet note, with the two of them cuddling in the recliner while Chandler kisses the top of Rachel’s head, tells her what a catch she is, and takes her to a Ranger game with one of his many sets of free tickets.</p><p>Meanwhile, the entire staff at Monica’s new job are treating her like garbage, and it is incredibly hard to watch. They write “QUIT, BITCH” on her chef’s hat (Phoebe, trying to help: “Maybe they meant to say ‘Quiet, Bitch!’”) and make up fake specials they then force her to cook. Chandler suggests she take a page from the Orson Welles playbook; on the set of all his movies, he used to hire a crew member just to fire them on the first day so everyone would know who was boss. Joey volunteers to come be a crappy waiter so Monica can fire him, but at the last minute he chickens out (it turns out the tip money is pretty good). But after they lock her into the walk-in fridge, she’s on the verge of snapping completely when Joey swoops in (better late than never) to deliver his half of the dramatic argument they rehearsed. After watching her fire “Dragon” (Joey’s restaurant nickname), the rest of the staff is finally scared enough that Monica can do her job. In classic Joey fashion, he overplays his hand at the very end (“looks like it’s gonna be a lean Christmas at the Dragon house this year,” he laments theatrically as he exits), but it’s the thought that counts.</p><p>The Christmas content levels in this episode are not high, but it’s elevated from the bottom by Phoebe’s iconic holiday song. Her first attempt (“Happy Hanukkah, Monica/ May your Christmas be snowy, Joey/ Happy New Year, Chandler and Ross/Spin the dreidel, Rachel”) is discarded because “dreidel” and “Rachel” don’t rhyme. Take two, of which all we hear is “Happy happy Hanukkah, Chandler and Monica” gets tossed out after Chandler informs her he isn’t Jewish. (Phoebe, irritably: “Ross doesn’t really decorate his tree with floss, but you don’t hear <em>him</em> complaining!”) It remains a forever mystery how many drafts it actually takes her to arrive at a version she’s willing to perform at Central Perk, but she finally lands on “Monica, Monica, have a happy Hanukkah/ Saw Santa Claus, he said hello to Ross/And please tell Joey that Christmas will be snowy/ And Rachel and Chandler <em>[indecipherable mumbling]</em>”. It’s no “Smelly Cat,” but it’s classic Phoebe.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>Monica and Joey rehearsing their fake feud and then ending with a little cheek kiss is one of my all-time favorite moments of their entire relationship.</p><p><strong>LOWS: </strong>Do you have to be a New Yorker to find Poughkeepsie jokes hilarious?</p><p><strong>BEST LINE:</strong> Joey doesn’t quite understand how rhyming actually works: “Lots of things rhyme with Rachel.<strong> </strong>Bagel. Mail. Jail. Bail. Able. Maypole . . .”</p><h3><strong>5th P<em>lace: “The One With Phoebe’s Dad”</em></strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RxzeZMxozHIfzDQqSHVf_w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Phoebe is extremely easy to shop for in Season 2, Episode 9: “The One With Phoebe’s Dad.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Phoebe has always been the<em> Friends</em> gang’s most unique character — the child of tragedy who overcame a truly horrifying past to reinvent herself as an effervescent, relentlessly cheerful hippie weirdo. Storylines focused on the mythology of Phoebe tend to be standouts, and this one is no exception: when she learns that the random stock photo guy in the picture frame is not, as her grandmother claimed, her real dad (a celebrity tree surgeon in Burma worshiped by villagers, apparently), she decides to track him down. Kudrow is, I think, the best actor in the whole ensemble, and mines real emotion out of even Phoebe’s looniest moments; so it’s hard not to get a little misty here as she realizes she’s still not ready to get out of the taxi and go knock on her dad’s door. Chandler and Joey — who tagged along to do some last-minute Christmas shopping on the drive home — are true bros here, reassuring her that she took a really big step and that he would be lucky to have a daughter like her.</p><p>Then, in one of the show’s all-time best episode tags, they return to the apartment with terrible Christmas gifts for the whole gang which they bought at a gas station on the way home, after missing their shot at hitting the mall: wiper blades and “new car smell” for Rachel, toilet seat covers for an unironically delighted Phoebe, two cans of soda for Ross, and condoms for Monica.</p><p>Meanwhile, back at the apartment, Monica is broke and decided to tip everyone homemade cookies instead of cash, which is met with violent scorn — both in the form of smashed-up cookies inside her newspaper delivery, and in endless criticism from Ross. After he accidentally breaks their furnace (causing Monica and Rachel to hastily retcon their holiday party as a “tropical theme”), Ross is convinced that Mr. Traeger is refusing to fix it until he gets a cash tip. We’re still in the middle of the “Ross Made a List of Reasons Not To Date Rachel” plot, and all his attempts to make it up to her — buying her a Slinky, encouraging her to make a list of <em>his</em> flaws (whiny, insecure, obsessive, wears too much hair gel. Nailed it, Rach), trying to rescue her from the furnace catastrophe — fall flat. It turns out, because Mr. Traeger is adorable, that he loved the cookies, he’s genuinely working on the broken radiator, and Ross has lost $100 for nothing.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>Chandler and Joey giving genuine moral support; Gunther’s first line!</p><p><strong>LOWS: </strong>How is it possible that <em>Joey</em> knew how to switch off the girls’ radiator from underneath but Mr. Traeger didn’t?</p><p><strong>BEST LINE: </strong>Ross, disdainfully receiving his pair of sodas: “This is too much. I feel like I should get you <em>another</em> sweater.”</p><h3><strong>4th P<em>lace: “The One With the Creepy Holiday Card”</em></strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ixSzOtyNSMM4BhjUIX-kow.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Mona deserves better in Season 8, Episode 9: “The One With the Creepy Holiday Card.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Well, if I never have to endure another “MEN ARE SCARED OF COMMITMENT” plot arc on another sitcom it will be too soon, but since that’s where we’re at, let’s just get it over with. Mona — who is sane, confident in what she wants out of a relationship, and emotionally stable, making her far too good for both Ross Geller and this show — suggests the two of them send out the photo they had taken in front of the Rockefeller Center Christmas tree as a holiday card. What follows is a downward cascade of tired, sexist tropes that culminate in Ross offering Mona a key to his apartment as a way to avoid having to have The Talk, then immediately having the locks changed.</p><p>Mona is a classic example of one of the most exasperating things about rewatching this show decades later: a totally likeable love interest who is painted in a negative light to bolster sympathy for one of the mains. Nothing she asks for in this episode is at all unreasonable, as Phoebe points out, yet the narrative is clearly on the side of the hysterically paranoid Ross (just look at the title!). Mona, however, is the only one acting like an adult, and if you look at it from her point of view the worst thing she’s really done is decide to date Ross in the first place. She backs down immediately when she realizes Ross is uncomfortable with the card, and she sincerely isn’t trying to trap him when she asks where the relationship is going. She’s an adult woman in her 30’s who doesn’t have time to waste! <em>It’s a reasonable question!</em></p><p>Meanwhile, Chandler goes to elaborate lengths to get out of dinner with his monstrous boss Doug, who has just gotten divorced (“Finally chewed my leg out of that bear trap!” he cheerfully announces to the newlywed Bings, which somehow makes me laugh<em> every single time</em>.) Doug was apparently not invited to the wedding after he peed on the ice sculpture at their engagement party, something I’m glad we didn’t see but would deeply have enjoyed witnessing Monica’s reaction to. (He is also mired in sexual harassment suits, something it’s a little harder to chuckle at in 2019, especially on an NBC show.) Chandler manages to save Monica from having to endure dinner with Doug by pretending they broke up, but is unable to save himself from getting dragged along for a night of booze, strip clubs, and throwing his wedding ring into the East River.</p><p>The funniest storyline involves pregnant Rachel, who, at four months, has now hit what Phoebe refers to as the “Evander Holyfield phase,” where apparently your sex hormones start going crazy and you’ll bang anything that will stand still. (PHOEBE: “And I was carrying triplets, so in medical terms I was <em>thrice</em> as randy.”) The running gag of Rachel’s pervy desperation is a good one; we never see any of the guys she’s ogling, but her increasingly dire descriptions (“he’s kind of short, and I think he’s talking to himself”; “all I want to do is rip off his sweatpants and fanny pack”; “bowl haircut, hairy fingers . . .”) get funnier and funnier as the episode progresses.</p><p>I also really love seeing Rachel and Phoebe bond over pregnancy stuff. It’s such a realistic, lived-in depiction of a female friendship, and a nice reminder that one of the reasons Phoebe is so valuable to the group is that she’s unshockable; her own life has been so wild that she’s a safe choice to ask for advice on almost anything. She does, however, <em>dramatically </em>overreach in her attempt to help, by foisting a random stranger on Rachel and announcing he’s there to have sex with her. (Sorry, Roger. It’s not gonna happen.)</p><p>And, of course, because you knew I had to bring it up, this is also the episode that kicks off my #1 <em>Friends</em> ship, with a tag at the end where the desperate-to-get-laid Rachel starts eyeing Joey. Nothing happens yet; but it’s the very next episode where he realizes he has feelings for her, so the wheels are already turning.</p><p><strong>HIGHS:</strong> Phoebe bringing Rachel her life-sized cardboard Evander Holyfield cut-out, then at the last minute being unable to part with him.</p><p><strong>LOWS:</strong> #FreeMona</p><p><strong>BEST LINE: </strong>Chandler, coming home from his horrible guys’ night out with Doug: “Honey, I’m home.” Monica, wrinkling her nose in disgust: “From the tequila factory?”</p><h3>3rd Place: “The One With All the Resolutions”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ylUDaNuO55TBNaUSJV2Tig.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sneaking a New Year’s kiss in under the radar in Season 5, Episode 11: “The One With All the Resolutions.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Seasons 5 and 7 have two holiday episodes apiece; this one follows hard on the heels of the inappropriate sister, but is a <em>vastly</em> superior half hour of television in every way. It benefits from a pretty clean plot structure — gang makes, and then struggles to keep, a slate of wildly unrealistic New Year’s resolutions — but each thread works like gangbusters. It’s not just half an hour of solid jokes; there’s real plot momentum here too.</p><p>Not to mention, of course, <em>ROSS AND THE LEATHER PANTS.</em></p><p>God, this episode is good.</p><p>Things are firing on all cylinders right from the pre-credits opener, set as everyone is waiting for the ball to drop on television at the New Year’s party. Monica and Chandler’s relationship is still on the DL, but they want to kiss at midnight, so Joey orchestrates an elaborate system to provide them some cover: he tells the whole gang they have to kiss someone at midnight, then craftily pairs everyone up to leave Monica and Chandler with each other, while he gets Rachel (LOVE THIS FOR ME) and Ross gets Phoebe. It’s a sweet gesture, but it’s also genuinely hilarious watching him use the same selling point to both Ross (“Who would you rather have kissing your sister, me or Chandler?” “Oh, good point”) and Rachel (“Who would you rather have kissing you, me or Chandler?” “Oh, good point”).</p><p>The plot kicks in right away, with the gang tidying up the post-party shrapnel and discussing their resolutions. Let’s take them each one at a time.</p><p><strong>PHOEBE: <em>Pilot a commercial jet.</em></strong> (Chandler: “That’s a good one, Pheebs. Now all you have to do is find a planeload of people whose resolution is to plummet to their deaths.”) Disappointingly, we don’t see any of this one, although she is apparently hanging out at the airport in her free time hoping someone leaves a plane unattended.</p><p><strong>MONICA: <em>Take more pictures. </em></strong>This one serves mostly as a runner about how Monica can never read the room, butting in with a huge-ass flashbulb when other characters are in high-tension moments to annoy them yet further.</p><p><strong>JOEY: <em>Learn how to play guitar. </em></strong>In one of my all-time favorite Phoebe/Joey plots, he decides it would be nice if at least one of the “special skills” listed on his acting resume wasn’t completely fabricated, so Phoebe offers to teach him. The process is exactly as bananas as you would expect: she has renamed the chords based on the shape her hand makes while she’s playing them (Bear Claw, Dragon, Old Lady), and takes it as a personal betrayal when Joey cheats on her with an actual music teacher to learn the real ones. Watching him attempt to strum and sending Phoebe’s guitar crashing to the floor in the process is the perfect capper.</p><p><strong>CHANDLER: <em>Stop being such an asshole.</em></strong><em> </em>This isn’t so much a resolution as a dare, after Ross bets him $50 that he couldn’t go a week without making fun of them — a challenge made exponentially worse the more everyone else’s resolutions start falling apart. Part of what makes it so satisfying is that Chandler’s incessant sarcasm, while perfect for a sitcom, would be unbearable in real life; it’s actually kind of nice to see the other five weirdos fly their freak flags in temporary safety for a couple of days. Watching him desperately beg and plead for someone, <em>anyone,</em> to make one of the thousands of jokes he can’t make feels like a just punishment. He finally just gives up, forks over the money and lets it all out, but it’s great to watch him spend the whole episode in a hell of his own making.</p><p><strong>RACHEL: <em>Gossip less. </em></strong>This is a nice way to get some forward momentum on the secret relationship storyline that feels really organic. We all knew it was just a matter of time before someone besides Joey found out; but it’s a fun twist to have Rachel pick up the phone, overhear a flirty exchange between Monica and Chandler, and then be unable to tell anyone what she knows. Like Chandler, she had no idea how addicted she was until forced to quit cold turkey. Watching her and Joey struggle to get the other to crack first and admit they know the same secret is tons of fun, as is Joey’s near-hysterical relief at finally, <em>finally, </em>having someone he can talk about it with.</p><p><strong>ROSS: <em>Do one thing every day he’s never done before.</em></strong> Ross’ yearning to be impulsive is what propelled him into his disastrous relationship with Emily, so this checks out; he’s always wished he was a bolder, cooler guy than he really is. He starts off okay, asking out a cute blonde he meets at Central Perk, but it devolves into chaos almost instantly. The absurd decision to buy a pair of leather pants (cruelly twisting the knife to Chandler: “I just thought to myself, you know, I’ve never owned a <em>really good-smelling</em> pair of pants before”) and then wear them on his first date with Elizabeth Hornswoggle (again, my God, poor Chandler) instantly devolves into my favorite kind of <em>Friends</em> plot: “Something Mortifying Happens to Ross.”</p><p>Ross and the leather pants is actually a pretty deft little master class in comedy structure. We know as soon as we see them that this is going to turn into a disaster, and the only question is how. It starts small, with the gang immediately roasting him the second Chandler flees the room. Then he’s on his date’s couch, sweltering because the pants are so warm. Then they start making embarrassing noises when he moves. Then he bolts for the bathroom to tear them off and let his legs breathe, but can’t get them back on. Panicked, he calls Chandler but gets Joey, who helpfully advises him to raid Elizabeth’s bathroom for anything that might absorb the moisture. Neither talcum powder nor lotion help; they make everything worse, in fact, by combining to form a paste. (Joey, helpfully: “If the paste matches the pants, you could make yourself a pair of paste pants and she’ll never know the difference!”)<em> </em>Ross’ increasingly hysterical refrain of <em>“They’re not coming on, man!”</em> veers closer and closer to sobbing until he’s devolved into a wild-eyed crazy person. And, of course, all of this is happening while he’s been in the bathroom for what is now an <em>alarmingly</em> long time. By the time he emerges, we’ve watched the whole thing escalate into madness tiny bit by tiny bit, but we can also see how horrifying it looks to poor Elizabeth Hornswoggle as she watches him shuffle pantslessly out of her bathroom, smeared head to toe in paste.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>A<strong> </strong>flawless bit of physical comedy where Joey covers his ears, closes his eyes and yells “LA LA LA LA LA LA” to drown out the sound of Rachel gossiping, which provides the perfect opening for Chandler to sneak in, pick up the duck, and let Joey open his eyes to find himself nose-to-beak with a wildly flapping bird.</p><p><strong>LOWS:</strong> Why does Ben have the most hideous bowl cut I have ever seen in my life? Were we really doing that to children in the nineties? WHERE ARE HIS LESBIAN MOMS’ GAY BEST FRIENDS TO REMEDY THIS? Is this why he always wears a hat when he grows up to play Sexy Jughead on <em>Riverdale</em>?</p><p><strong>BEST LINE:</strong> Rachel deflating Ross’ New Year before it has even started. “You know what, I’m gonna go out on a limb and say no divorces in ’99!” “But your divorce isn’t even final yet.” [pause] “Just the one divorce in ’99!”</p><h3>2nd Place: “The One With the Routine”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZvE-9Ebd2ippIKQsZ3YAJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Gellers try for another honorable mention in the Brother/Sister Dance Category in Season 6, Episode 10: “The One With the Routine.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>This is a terrific half-hour of television, with every Friend getting A+ material and holiday content in every storyline, including the delightful opener where Monica generously allows Joey, Phoebe and Rachel to help her decorate the tree, then turns their crappily-decorated half toward the window so only her pristine, perfectly-decorated half is showing. (As someone who also has a rigid tree-decorating system — biggest ornaments first, evenly spaced, then medium, then small, so you can fill in the gaps — I’m sort of Team Monica here. Their half looks like a tinsel monster threw up on it.)</p><p>At the apartment, Phoebe and Rachel hunt for Monica’s hidden stash of Christmas gifts, something they attempt unsuccessfully every year. (They also search across the hall, which means they have <em>absolutely </em>seen the hidden porn stash at the back of Chandler’s closet, a joke which feels so quaint now in the Digital Age.) Chandler initially objects on principle, but jumps on board once he starts to panic that what he got Monica won’t be as good as whatever she’s getting him. The gift hunt is a perfectly-structured little three-part comic bit. First, they find a fake present: an old shoe, with a note from a seemingly-omniscient Monica (“Chandler, I knew they’d break you”). Second, they find a bunch of crappy presents, which of course turn out to be an indignant Chandler’s. Finally, Rachel accidentally discovers that that window seat is hollow, and locates the hidden gifts, revealing that Monica’s gift for Chandler, a water purifier, is actually the crappiest gift of all.</p><p>(Seriously, though, why do they hate those bookends???)</p><p>But the A-story belongs to Joey and the Gellers. Joey has a massive crush on his roommate Janine (played by supermodel Elle MacPherson), who has landed a background dancer gig as one of the Party People on <em>Dick Clark’s New Year’s Rockin’ Eve</em> and invites Joey to be her dance partner. When she learns the siblings are Dick Clark superfans (Ross: “You get to be a Party Person? Those guys <em>rock the most!</em>”) , she invites them as well, leaving the group divided about whether she was asking Joey on a date or not. He decides the only way to tell is to kiss her at fake midnight and see what happens. The Gellers, meanwhile, are laser-focused on making sure they end up in the shot so their parents see them on television, but keep getting ignored by the camera crew. Everyone is at the mercy of an obnoxious producer, who won’t put Ross and Monica on the raised platforms where they would actually be seen on TV, and calls “cut” before Joey gets to kiss Janine (though they do share a sweet kiss when they get back to the apartment).</p><p>As mentioned earlier, I cherish any episode of <em>Friends</em> where the plot hinges on the specific nuances of Ross and Monica’s relationship as siblings — their fundamental Geller-ness, if you will — instead of treating them as simply two members of the same six-person social group. There’s always fun to be mined out of their lopsided parental relationships, and their shared personality traits like ruthless competitiveness. But those plots generally pit sibling against sibling; what makes “The Routine” such a holiday joy is seeing the Gellers united as a team against the rest of the world. After all, these were two profoundly unpopular, dorky kids who didn’t have a lot of friends growing up, and underneath the goofy premise we get a bittersweet little glimpse into their childhood where despite all the bickering they were probably each other’s closest companion. So of <em>course</em> they stayed home every New Year’s to watch <em>Dick Clark’s New Year’s Rockin’ Eve, </em>and of <em>course </em>that Geller hustle comes out in force as they desperately try to make the most of their fifteen minutes of fame, and of <em>course </em>they already have a choreographed routine at the ready, because of <em>course </em>back in the day they entered a brother/sister middle school dance competition.</p><p>It goes without saying that the routine itself (set, if you are curious, to the impossibly catchy “Trouble With Boys” by Loreta, a song I literally only know from this) is absurd, but that doesn’t matter. What matters is that Ross and Monica <em>commit. </em>From the fake slap at the beginning to the finale where Monica leaps and Ross catches her, they are 100% in sync, eyes locked, dead serious, every cheesy movement impeccably precise. It is a thing of beauty. “Ross and Monica Are Terrible Dancers” is an easy, predictable joke; “Ross and Monica Have Terrible Dance Moves Executed With Military Precision and Ruthless Competitive Spirit” is much funnier, more surprising, and truer to their relationship.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>The amazing late-90’s fashion on all the Party People.</p><p><strong>LOWS:</strong> Janine’s new dance partner is wearing khakis, which is a crime. How dare he show up to fake New Year’s in business casual, SHOW SOME RESPECT FOR DICK CLARK</p><p><strong>BEST LINE</strong>: Rachel dismissing Chandler’s insistence that he already has a great idea for a present for Monica:<strong> </strong>“Chandler, that’s not enough. I mean, what if she gets you a great present, two medium presents, and then a bunch of little presents, and you’ve just gotten her one great present? That’s just going to make her feel bad! Why would you do that to her, Chandler? Why? Why?”</p><h3>1st Place: “The One With the Holiday Armadillo”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*54-d3NwLIUaTYbNwXxp0cA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Chandler Claus, Aunt Monica, and one extremely desperate father team up to save Hanukkah in Season 7, Episode 10: “The One With the Holiday Armadillo.”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Guys. This one is so good.</p><p>It’s not just my favorite <em>Friends</em> holiday episode; it’s pretty close to being my favorite <em>Friends</em> episode, full stop, and possibly my favorite holiday episode of any television show. If you haven’t seen it in awhile, go watch it immediately; it’s so much more fun than you remember it.</p><p>“The Holiday Armadillo” lands at the top of the list for several reasons. The first and simplest is just that, even nearly twenty years after it aired, it remains refreshingly unproblematic. No eye-rolling lesbian jokes, no clunky sexist tropes, and a surprising level of sensitivity in a storyline about religion.</p><p>It’s also loaded with truly memorable visual comedy, starting from the pre-credits opener when Phoebe saunters in holding a human skull full of Twizzlers like it’s the most normal thing in the world. Ross is in the middle of explaining that he has his son for the holidays this year (more on this later) and wants to use this year to teach Ben about Hanukkah, to which Phoebe excitedly suggests that she can help by teaching Ben about human mortality via “The Christmas Skull,” prompting Rachel to observe that “you may need to use this year to teach Ben about Phoebe.”</p><p>There’s also a small but delightful runner which pops up in every storyline about Chandler’s inability to master that cool-guy trick of slipping someone cash when you shake their hand, something Richard could <em>of course</em> pull off effortlessly. (I know, I know, the doesn’t-want-kids thing was a very valid dealbreaker, but I really did love Richard, you guys.)</p><p>The bulk of the episode splits the gang in half, with Rachel, Joey and Phoebe in one apartment and Chandler, Monica and Ross in the other. We’re still in the middle of the game of Roommate Musical Chairs that began when Chandler and Monica moved in together; Rachel has been living with Phoebe, but a fire in their apartment at the end of the previous season split them up, sending Phoebe into Rachel’s old room at Monica’s, and Rachel into Chandler’s old room at Joey’s. The repairs now complete, Phoebe is suddenly paranoid that Rachel is having more fun at Joey’s and doesn’t want to be her roommate anymore. So, of course, as befits an adult woman, she sits down with Rachel immediately for a heart-to-heart and opens up about her concerns.</p><p>HA HA, JUST KIDDING, she does the exact opposite, concocting an elaborate plan to buy Joey Christmas presents she thinks will make his apartment an unbearable place for Rachel to live.</p><p>It backfires completely, of course; Rachel unexpectedly loves tarantulas, and they both go nuts over the drum set (though Chandler and all the other neighbors apparently want to light it on fire). Short-haired, soft-butch, Circa-Joey’s-apartment Rachel is my absolute favorite Rachel, and this is a terrific episode for her. She’s come such a long way from the spoiled Long Island runaway bride we met in the pilot. And in the end, it all works out, since Rachel is perfectly happy to move back in with Phoebe, and also perfectly happy to stay with Joey once they realize Phoebe’s old apartment has been turned from a two- to a one-bedroom, and Phoebe decides to live there by herself. And even Chandler gets a win, since Rachel hiding the drumsticks inside the tarantula’s glass tank means Joey will never play the drums again. It’s a total delight, and if you can stop yourself from smiling at the sight of Rachel Karen Green cooing over a huge furry spider, you are made of sterner stuff than I.</p><p>The heart of the episode, however — and I can’t believe I’m saying this out loud — is Ross.</p><p>It is probably no secret to you by now that Ross is my least favorite of all the Friends, especially if you have met me; but part of why “The Routine” and “The Holiday Armadillo” rank so high on my list is that they find a way to mine comedy out of showing him in his best light (meaning, his family relationships) rather than his worst (his neurotic, controlling relationship with Rachel). In this episode we see him wrestle with an actual, real-world parenting problem: how to navigate conflicting holiday traditions in a blended family. Ross gets Ben for the holidays and wants to teach him about Hanukkah, which Carol and Susan don’t celebrate; as parents of all faiths know full well, however, it is <em>really hard</em> to keep a kid’s attention with quiet and contemplative stories about your culture’s religious traditions in the midst of the screaming, blaring, jingle-bell-ing chaos of Christmas commercialism. What do you say to a kid who has been conditioned by society to think that celebrating Hanukkah means missing out on something, being <em>deprived</em> of Christmas, instead of experiencing an important piece of his own family heritage, which means so much to his dad? For a lot of families, the question of how you balance different holiday traditions is a profoundly relatable one, and it’s nice to see Ross wrestle with a parenting crisis that isn’t a joke at the expense of lesbian moms (there isn’t even a laugh at the utterly perfect detail about Susan dressing up as Santa every year, something a lazier episode would have turned into a punchline).</p><p>This is, however, a sitcom, which means that Ross’ attempts to be a good dad devolve almost instantly into total chaos. Ben is immediately bored with the story of the Maccabees and crushed that Santa isn’t coming this year, so Ross attempts to compromise, hoping if he dresses up like Santa he can slip in a little religious history on the side. But it’s two days before Christmas and his emergency costume hunt comes up dry; so, by the forces of sitcom logic, he decides the second-best option is . . . an armadillo costume.</p><p>Everything from the moment Ross enters Monica’s apartment dressed as an armadillo is comedy gold. He has no control over the movements of his tail and keeps bumping into things. He has adopted a goofy, hopping little walk and a strange made-up voice. Kids are easily distracted by weird things, and Ben is intrigued enough by the big alien-looking creature to consider sitting down and hearing how this whole “Festival of Lights” business plays out . . . until a well-meaning Chandler bursts in ho-ho-ho-ing like a pro, dressed in a Santa suit he borrowed from a guy at work and immediately eclipsing the Holiday Armadillo (or, as a confused Chandler describes him, “Weird Turtle Man”). Monica is inexplicably turned on by Chandler Claus, but Ross wants him to leave; he’ll never get Ben interested in Hanukkah if Santa is right there to distract him.</p><p>Watching all the adults frantically try to improvise over Ben’s head without giving anything away leads to some of the episode’s best dialogue, including Ross explaining that the Holiday Armadillo is “Santa’s representative for all the Southern states” and Chandler saying he has to leave because “if Santa and the Holiday Armadillo are ever in the same place for too long, the universe will implode!” But, in a crushing little moment, Ben decides he wants the weird armadillo to leave and Santa to stay. Chandler Claus compromises, however, and tells Ben he’ll stay if Ben will sit next to him on the couch to learn about Hanukkah.</p><p>And then, because the best comic beats happen in threes, just as Ross begins the story again, Joey enters the apartment dressed as Superman. Because Joey.</p><p>Collectively, Chandler Claus, Super Joey and Aunt Monica manage to keep Ben’s attention long enough for him to actually become interested in the Holiday Armadillo’s story about Hanukkah. The episode ends with Monica lighting the menorah (Rachel, entering to see a bunch of weirdly-costumed characters standing around in the dark: “It looks like the Easter Bunny’s funeral in here”) underneath a little snippet of “Tradition!” from <em>Fiddler on the Roof</em> as the credits roll.</p><p><strong>HIGHS: </strong>The MVP of this episode is the sales clerk at the costume store, who greets a perfectly normally-dressed Ross with a cheery, “Hello, sir! Here to return those pants?”, which makes me laugh <em>every time.</em></p><p><strong>LOWS: </strong>Don’t think too hard about Monica’s Santa Claus fetish.</p><p><strong>BEST LINE: </strong>Chandler giving us a preview of a moment I truly wish we’d gotten to watch Ross react to: “My favorite part was when Superman flew all the Jews out of Egypt.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3039fe678f4b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Brief History of Time]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@miss.willett/a-brief-history-of-time-4c8eed9aa1ed?source=rss-39f1f3e4bff0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c8eed9aa1ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[grief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[als]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Claire Willett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Mar 2018 01:06:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-19T07:05:57.689Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Disjointed reflections on grief, loss, and Stephen Hawking on the tenth anniversary of my mother’s death.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gGaUC-Vm67r1aZlGeRFKKQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>I. Relativity</h4><p><em>“In the theory of relativity there is no unique absolute time, but instead each individual has his own personal measure of time that depends on where he is and how he is moving.” <br></em>— Stephen Hawking</p><p>Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis took Stephen Hawking four days ago, and my mother ten years ago today. Two moments in time that are unconnected for most of the universe but permanently intertwined for me. I wasn’t prepared for the way Hawking’s death knocked me sideways during a week where I already felt fragile enough, but I’ve been circling round and round it for days, trying to find my way through to an explanation.</p><p>Grief bends time the way gravity bends light. Sometimes ten years is a century and my mother has been gone so long that I can’t remember what her voice sounds like until I hear it in my sister’s laugh. Sometimes ten years is a millisecond, she was <em>just here,</em> I can smell her lemon verbena hand cream and hear the whistle of the teakettle. Sometimes I <em>feel</em> like a person whose mother has been dead for ten years, I carry every accumulated minute of that weight; other times, I resist with almost violent force that aspect of my own identity, recoiling from how old and tired it makes me feel. It’s a true thing that only intermittently <em>feels</em> true in my bones and has entirely scrambled my already-tenuous sense of the way time moves.</p><p>Before, time marched along mostly straight lines; now it shifts backwards and forwards and sideways, leaving my mother somehow simultaneously both present and gone.</p><p>* * * *</p><p>I am twenty-six years old.</p><p>My mother’s dead body is laid out on a table in the funeral home’s viewing room.</p><p>She is wearing one of her favorite outfits, a pantsuit of lavender shantung silk. There was a chunky amethyst bracelet that always went with it, but I borrowed it a few months ago and forgot to give it back, and now I can’t bring myself to part with it. The unsettling behind-the-scenes preparations of the mortician (which I struggle mightily not to think about) have had a peculiar time-warping effect: by artificially plumping up the facial muscles with chemicals, they have erased the slack, drooping expression she could no longer shake once ALS had spread up her body. The dead body looks more the mother I remember from childhood than she has in years.</p><p>Degenerative diseases force you to acclimate to change little by little, and eventually you reach a place where this is all there is, and the idea that there once was a “before” seems remote and alien. I have begun to forget what the Theresa who wasn’t sick looked like, and now suddenly she is back, and so <em>real</em> that I cannot silence the part of my brain that is convinced any moment she will sit up and ask me where the hell her amethyst bracelet is.</p><p>What a strange trick of time, that death should bring back the face she had before she began dying. I can’t decide if it’s cruelty, or a gift.</p><p>* * * *</p><p>I am ten years old.</p><p>My mother has sewn me a Halloween costume from scratch. I wanted to be a bride. She has created a lacy concoction of a dress, with long sleeves to keep me warm in a damp Oregon October. There is a circlet of white silk flowers with a little veil, and she does my makeup before I leave for school. I am a chubby, nerdy, bookish child who has already begun to anticipate the hell that puberty and middle school will be, but I am wearing a wedding dress and my mother has made me feel beautiful.</p><p>When I get to school, every cool girl in my class is dressed as a witch. They laugh at my dress. “Are you a <em>bride?”</em></p><p>I hide the veil in my backpack and try desperately to convince them I’m the White Witch from <em>The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe</em>, which our father has been reading to us, chapter by chapter, every night before bedtime. Nobody buys it.</p><p>I don’t feel pretty again until I go home and my mother puts the veil back on my head to take us out trick-or-treating.</p><p>I hate school for nearly my entire childhood, even though I’m very good at it. But I don’t like being there. I secretly love being sent home when I’m sick, where I can curl up on the couch next to my mother and eat ramen noodles and watch <em>Perry Mason.</em></p><p>I already know that she is the only place my little heart feels safe. The idea of an existence without her is so impossible that I never consider it. I’m not afraid of my mother dying, because I simply don’t believe she ever could. How could she ever be <em>not here,</em> when she is my entire world?</p><p>* * * *</p><p>I am twenty-two years old.</p><p>My bags and boxes are packed and I am leaving in the morning for New York, where I have an internship with a theatre company.</p><p>I have never gotten used to leaving my mother. Every time I go somewhere new, whether summer camp or college, I cry for the first three nights because she isn’t there. The fact of this grows more embarrassing as I get older — <em>I’m an adult, I should be used to this, other people are used to this</em> — but it doesn’t diminish.</p><p>I am already terrified of New York, terrified to fail there, terrified to leave home, terrified to be too far away to come home if I need her, terrified of not being enough to get by on my own.</p><p>It’s August, and we are sitting on the back porch on a warm summer night, drinking lemon drops — her favorite — out of big martini glasses. She tells me that she moved straight from her parents’ house to her sorority house to her husband’s house. She has never lived alone. Never paid her own electric bill, never had to move to a new city and learn their public transportation system. She loves the life she has, and she doesn’t regret the choices she made, but it means something to her that the world is different now, that her daughters have different choices, that my sister and I are “the kind of women who will go off and have adventures.”</p><p>I don’t want to go off and have adventures. I want to live at home with my mother for the rest of my life and never have to grow or leave or change or say goodbye to her. But my bags are packed, so I go anyway.</p><p>I cry myself to sleep every night for the first week.</p><p>By the time I see my mother again, I have friends and a job and an electric bill and a church and a favorite Thai place, and I have mastered the subway system enough to navigate us everywhere we need to go without a map.</p><p>Just as she told me I would.</p><h4>II. Entropy</h4><p><em>“The increase of disorder or entropy is what distinguishes the past from the future, giving a direction to time.” <br></em>–Stephen Hawking</p><p>It was very difficult for most of my twenties not to resent Stephen Hawking.</p><p>When your family is given an ALS diagnosis, you are told by your doctors that the outlook is grim. Five years is the best you can hope for, usually, and many people like my mother don’t get even that.</p><p>And yet there he was, the world’s most famous physicist, diagnosed young with a rare strain of the disease, identical to my mother’s in nearly every way except for time. He was given the same dark prognosis, and proved it wrong. The span of his life was not measurably decreased. He had health complications, certainly, but he <em>lived. </em>Time moved differently for him. His illness began earlier, and lasted longer; it defined nearly the entirety of his adult life; but he got more years than my mother did. He was diagnosed in his twenties and died in his seventies. My mother was diagnosed in her fifties and she died in her fifties. Would I trade all the good, healthy years she had, in exchange for knowing we had two more decades ahead of us? Would I rather have had her be an entirely different person, and by necessity have had an entirely different childhood, which would make <em>me</em> an entirely different person, but get to keep her awhile longer?</p><p>If Hawking was right about alternate universes, then somewhere there is a Claire whose mother did not die of ALS at the age of fifty-four. There could be millions of them. Somewhere there is an alternate universe where my mother is right here next to me, where she was supposed to be. But somewhere else there is an alternate universe where we were crossing the street and she was hit by a car, killed instantly, and the three years we had during her illness to say all the things we wanted to say to each other never happened. Or she loses her mind and ceases to be the person she once was. Or she is alive and healthy but a terrible person who none of us can love. Or she went off and had adventures when she was twenty-two, and never married or had children. Somewhere there is an alternate universe where my mother is alive but my father is not, or my sister is not. Things could always be better, but they could also always be worse.</p><p>I think about those other selves sometimes, the other lives they’re out there living, but they don’t feel real to me. The only one I really know is mine. There are no trade-ins. There’s just whatever cards you get dealt, and what you do with them. So we get the diagnosis we get, and we have the life we have, and I might have acclimated much earlier to the inevitability of the endpoint we were facing, except that<em> Stephen goddamned Hawking was still alive.</em></p><p>Sometimes hope is dangerous. Sometimes it keeps you waiting for the helicopter that will swoop in from the heavens and save you, when you’re really supposed to be figuring out how to paddle yourself to shore on your own, because no one is coming to rescue you from this. Not God, not science, not anybody.</p><p>But maybe there was hope for her, because out there was at least one person who had survived the diagnosis she’d been given, so maybe it would turn out all right, maybe we didn’t have to give up just yet, maybe we could keep death at bay a few more decades until I was an adult who could handle it, maybe time would bend sideways for my mother too.</p><p>“You never know,” say people trying to be helpful. “She could still have a long, full life. Think about Stephen Hawking.”</p><p><em>I already do, every single day,</em> I think. <em>It doesn’t help.</em></p><p>* * * *</p><p>The deterioration of the human body, molecule by molecule, as we age, is entropy. For most of us, it’s a slow drip drip drip; one day you’re twenty and invincible, the next day you are thirty-six and cannot handle more than one glass of white wine. ALS accelerates entropy with a gleeful, malevolent rapidity, like watching your body deteriorate in fast-forward. Three years was all it took. The hands that could once perform delicate embroidery or butterfly a leg of lamb, now stilled forever, lying flat and motionless on the armrests of a wheelchair. They were soft, suddenly, for the first time in her life. No more calluses from gardening trowels, no more dry skin from washing dishes. Impossibly delicate skin, like a child’s. Her body moving in two different directions, forward and backward at once. Aging in reverse. Needing to be bathed, dressed, fed by other hands once again. To be cared for like a baby, with all the adult’s mortification and indignity and awareness that all of this is wrong.</p><p>I am twenty-five.</p><p>My mother needs to ask to go to the bathroom, like a child, because someone needs to help her out of her wheelchair, hold her hands and walk her to the door, pull down her pants and underwear, and then pull them back up again.</p><p>Today I am too slow, and we don’t make it in time. We stand in the bathroom of the house where I was born, where she taught my toddler self to use the toilet over two decades ago, and I hold her while she cries and urinates all over herself and me and her clothes and the floor. I hold her in my arms and stroke her back. “It’s okay,” I tell her. “We’ll get it cleaned up. We’ll fix it. It’s okay. It’s okay.”</p><p>But none of it is okay. Everything about it is horribly inverted and she knows it. I was never supposed to be the one doing this for her. Every time I have to take her to the bathroom or feed her with a feeding tube, time has doubled back on itself and reversed our positions in a way we are both ill-suited to bear: her, frustrated and uncomfortable, me, anxious and afraid. I am not a natural caretaker. I am terrified of making a mistake, terrified to be alone with her in case something goes wrong.</p><p>Once, while my father is at Easter choir practice, I am alone with her and can’t figure out the complicated piece of machinery which vacuums saliva out of her esophagus because she no longer has the ability to swallow. She is panicking and I am panicking and both of us have tears streaming down our faces as I struggle to figure out this unfamiliar technology that is the only thing keeping her from choking to death in front of me. My hands are shaking and I don’t remember how my father explained this to me and I am convinced that this is the end and it will be my fault.</p><p>When my father comes home, he fixes everything, the way he always has, the way he always will, and it’s fine, she’s fine, everything’s fine, but I am so relieved to see him walk in the door that my hands don’t stop shaking for another ten minutes.</p><p>By the time she was the age I am now, my mother already had a baby.</p><p><em>I never want children,</em> I think to myself. I never want to hold anyone else’s life in my hands ever, ever again.</p><p>I am afraid to be alone with my mother for longer than a few minutes, after that.</p><h4>III. Black Holes</h4><p><em>“Black holes ain’t as black as they are painted. They are not the eternal prisons they were once thought . . . things can get out of a black hole, both on the outside and possibly to another universe. So if you feel you are in a black hole, don’t give up — there’s a way out.” <br></em>–Stephen Hawking</p><p>I am twenty-six years old.</p><p>My mother has been dead for three months.</p><p>I do not want to start seeing a therapist because seeing a therapist means you are admitting that you have problems you cannot grit your teeth and solve on your own, which is my family’s way, but I also desperately <em>do</em> want to start seeing a therapist because my mother has been dead for three months and I have not cried. Not just about her, about anything. It’s like my body has forgotten how. I cried the first day, when my father called to give me the news, mostly out of shock; but nothing since then. Everyone else seems able to cry for her but me. I feel nothing at all. It’s like someone has flipped a lightswitch inside me and shut everything off.</p><p>I am secretly convinced I am broken forever.</p><p>No one says the words “depression” to me and I do not say them to myself. I don’t feel <em>sad.</em> I don’t want to hurt myself. I’m just . . . blank. Blank and tired and existing in a kind of dull gray fog that lifts just often enough for me to feel like maybe the broken thing is fixed and I will be okay now.</p><p>I tell my therapist I have not cried for my dead mother and I wait for her to look at me as though am a sociopath, which a great deal of time is how I feel: as though everyone in the world has access to a range of felt emotions which I am only capable of understanding intellectually and abstractly. I know that I miss my mother. I know that I loved my mother. I know that my life will be different forever. But I understand these things to be true the same way I understand that the Oregon state capitol is Salem and the state bird is the Western meadowlark. They aren’t things I <em>feel</em> the way everyone else seems to feel them.</p><p>My therapist does not seem to think that I am a monster, but I know it’s only because she doesn’t know me yet. There are still so many things I don’t tell her. When confronted with the huge ugly mess of my emotional landscape, I close the door and ignore it and use the entire hour to just talk about work.</p><p>* * * *</p><p>I am twenty-seven years old.</p><p>When my emotions finally return, they are terrible.</p><p>Instead of crying, I am angry.</p><p>I am angry at my mother for dying, I am angry at my father for getting remarried, I am angry at my brother — who still lives in our family home — every time he moves a single vase or picture frame away from the place where my mother left it. I am angry at my friends for not being able to read my mind and understand what I need, even though <em>I</em> don’t understand what I need. I am angry at my therapist, who has not fixed me yet. I am angry at God for all of this bullshit. I am angry at myself for still not being able to feel sadness, like a normal person is supposed to.</p><p>Then the anger fades, and I am just tired again, and the fog resettles. But I think I am better. Everyone thinks I am better. My reactions have returned to a proportionate size, which seems like progress.</p><p><em>This is just what normal feels like now, </em>I tell myself.</p><p>* * * *</p><p>I am thirty-four years old.</p><p>My best friend, who has dealt with depression on and off for many years, has begun to realize she is having another major episode and needs to go back to her doctor. She can tell that this is extremely serious because she remembers the symptoms from before. She lists them to me.</p><p>I listen in silence as she describes my entire life.</p><p>I have lost the capacity to remember that it did not always used to be like this, and that perhaps it is not like this for everyone. Inside the dark place, I cannot see that there are plenty of people who do not find it impossible to get out of bed, feel so exhausted by human contact that even talking to their friends and family is too much effort, or lose the ability to care about the things that once mattered.</p><p><em>I used to enjoy things, didn’t I?</em> I ask myself, trying to remember. <em>Didn’t there used to be something other than this? </em>But it’s been so long I’m not sure.</p><p><em>This is how it has always been,</em> says the voice in my head. <em>This is just your life now. This was always your life.</em></p><p>I continue to tell my therapist I’m fine, and talk about work.</p><p>* * * *</p><p>I am thirty-five years old, and an anxiety attack that leaves me shaking and crying and hyperventilating in a coffee shop finally convinces me to go to an actual doctor and say the words “antidepressants.”</p><p>The doctor gives me a long questionnaire to fill out, with a huge list of potential symptoms that could indicate depression, and asks me to check all the boxes that reflect things I have felt or done or experienced in the past two weeks.</p><p>I check every box but three, and tell her most of them go back for years. I walk out with a bottle of Welbutrin in my hand.</p><p>Once the fog begins to clear, the tiniest bit at a time, and I can look back behind me and see where I was and finally realize that it was not normal, that life was not supposed to be that way, everything changes.</p><p>All my life I believed nothing could ever escape from a black hole, but Stephen Hawking says differently. He theorized that some black holes, as they shrink and die, actually do emit forms of radiation, and that the halo around a black hole might contain traces of everything that has ever passed the event horizon to be pulled inside by gravity and trapped there.</p><p>Depression tells you there is nothing else outside of this. It tells you to surrender to gravity. It tells you there’s no reason to get out of bed, that nothing you do matters, that nobody who says they love you actually does.</p><p>What other things did I once believe, and then discover were wrong, about darkness and hopelessness and despair? How many dark rooms was I trapped inside, thinking there was no exit, when I just couldn’t see my way to the door?</p><p>If Hawking radiation really exists, then maybe anything is possible, for all of us. Maybe there’s no dark place we can’t get out of, if someone shows us how to find our way to the light.</p><p>Maybe even when you think you’re most alone, you can send up a flare and someone will find you.</p><h4>IV. The Theory of Everything</h4><p><em>“I believe in the possible. I believe, small though we are, insignificant though we may be, we can reach a full understanding of the universe . . . We are very, very small, but we are profoundly capable of very, very big things.” <br></em>–Stephen Hawking</p><p>I am twenty-nine years old.</p><p>My mother has been dead for three years.</p><p>I am on my way to an artists’ retreat to write a play about a telescope, which I will name <em>Dear Galileo.</em> My father sends me to Connecticut with his old, dog-eared, well-loved copy of Stephen Hawking’s <em>A Brief History of Time. </em>For the first four days, all I do is read it over and over again, like I’m decoding a secret, like Hawking is trying to tell me something about the way that human beings behave and the way our lives unfold through the way he talks about black holes and red shift and the movements of the stars.</p><p>I do not know yet that this play will change my life, that I will spend the next seven years writing and rewriting it, searching through Stephen Hawking’s universe for a way to live without the one fixed point, the mathematical constant, that held my entire world in place for the first twenty-six years of my life, and then vanished, leaving me unmoored.</p><p>It never matters what I think I’m sitting down to write about, in the beginning. By the time I get to the end I realize that I am always writing about my mother.</p><p>It’s because she was so contradictory, because she is gone now and I will never get to the bottom of her, that I find myself drawn over and over again to writing my way through these questions. I was writing <a href="http://www.orartswatch.org/star-bright-claire-willetts-galileo/">a play about astrophysics</a>, and then I was writing <a href="https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0986115746/ref=ox_sc_act_title_23?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&amp;psc=1">a book about Watergate and time travelers</a>, but in the end I am always writing about her. I am always hunting through the universe for clues and meaning. Who am I, because of her? Who am I because she died? Who would I be if she were still here? Are my memories right? Would my sister or my father or my aunt remember them differently? Am I allowed to be angry at her, now that she’s gone? Can I hold space for the way I never felt safer than when I was curled up in her arms and also for the way I felt like I was never quite going to be good enough to live up to her standards? Could she have been both extremely susceptible to grudges, and also the most generous and openhearted person I knew? Can she be the mother who taught me to have compassion for others and the mother who made it impossible for me to have compassion for myself, at the same time? Is ten years long enough to say that there are pieces of her in me that I have been trying to extract so I can set them down and let them go?</p><p>Stephen Hawking reshaped our understanding of black holes, and he also cheated on his wife. He fundamentally changed the world of physics, and he was also a great man with a God complex who could sometimes be unbearable to the people around him. People are complicated. Hawking was not a saint who deserves to be treated with kid gloves because he was in a wheelchair; that view is infantilizing, and people with disabilities resent it. “Don’t send me flowers because you feel bad that I’m dying,” I once heard my mother snap after a massive spray of orchids with a syrupy “Thinking of You” note were delivered by a man she had viewed for years as her professional nemesis. “You didn’t like me before I got sick. Don’t start liking me now because you feel guilty.”</p><p>The longer she’s gone, the more the balance shifts. I can see things clearly, in her, in myself, that I don’t want to be, because when she was here she shone so brightly that she was all I could see. She eclipsed me in every way, even to myself. Can I miss her every day, and wish for her back, while also liking the person that I am now, who has had to learn that her mother was not infallible?</p><p>I think over and over about my favorite line from e.e. cummings, the only thing about time that feels truer to me in my bones even than Hawking does: <em>“time is a tree/this life one leaf,”</em> he wrote, <em>“but love is the sky.”</em></p><p>Stephen Hawking did not believe in my Catholic mother’s God, but my mother believed in both God and Stephen Hawking. Between the two of them, my parents had five science degrees, while also remaining the most devout and faithful people I knew. The universe has room for an infinite number of paradoxes and contradictions that the human mind prefers to limit. A great many things can be true at once.</p><p>I would like to believe that Heaven is the one thing in the universe Hawking was wrong about, because it allows me to imagine them somewhere in the great afterlife, together. I picture Hawking delivering a brilliant, erudite speech on quantum physics while my mother sits in the front row, taking studious notes. In Heaven, the microphones never cut in and out and the lecture hall seats are impossibly comfortable and no one ever raises their hand during the Q&amp;A portion to say “this is more of a statement than a question” and every facet of this extraordinary universe is finally knowable.</p><p>In Heaven, my mother would no longer resent Stephen Hawking for the extra decades of life his ALS gave him that were taken away from her. It’s been ten years. Maybe it’s time for me to let that go, too.</p><p><em>“One of the most curious traits about time is the fact that it only spins forward. We move only in one direction, straight ahead, like an arrow. Now, of course, if you’re familiar with quantum mechanics you know about the theory of ‘imaginary time’ which treats it like a geographic direction — if you can walk north, you can turn around and walk south, so if you’re going forward in time, you should be able to turn around and go backward. But of course in every practical, measurable way, this isn’t true.</em></p><p><em>There are three arrows of time: thermodynamic, in which entropy increases; cosmological, in which the universe is expanding; and of course psychological, in which we feel time go by, and we remember the past but not the future. And, curiously, all three clearly point in the same direction. Why? Why is it necessary that the aging of the human body and the expansion of the universe and the ticking of the clock on our office wall are all moving forward on the same line?</em></p><p><em>To me, it’s clear that there is only one answer: all of creation, from humans to stars, is tightly woven together. We’re the feather on the back of the arrow, inextricably bound to it as it shoots through the air, a perfect straight line, moving only forward. We can no more hop off and go backwards than we could disentangle ourselves from each other. And this is a good thing. It means the world is in the hands of our children and not our ancestors. It means the light at the end of the tunnel is getting closer and closer. It means the course of history has not yet been determined. It means death is not the end. The arrow is still in the air.”</em></p><p>— from <em>Dear Galileo</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c8eed9aa1ed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>