<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Marshall K. Beck on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Marshall K. Beck on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mkbportage2001?source=rss-4bd716568b0f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 18:03:56 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mkbportage2001/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[North Coast: Summaries of All Chapters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mkbportage2001/north-coast-summaries-of-all-chapters-c43e66606d61?source=rss-4bd716568b0f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c43e66606d61</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stroke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[exvangelical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coming-of-age]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[agnosticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marshall K. Beck]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 10:27:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-17T10:27:57.393Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>North Coast / Chapter Summaries</strong></p><p><strong>A recovering evangelical describes his religious upbringing, explains why he left the church, and reflects upon the nature of belief.</strong></p><p><strong><em>North Coast </em>by Marshall Beck</strong></p><p><strong>Fictional memoir, family chronicle</strong></p><p><strong>Word count: 57K</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>PART ONE</strong></p><p><strong>Chapter 1 / MOVING DAY</strong></p><p><strong>A third-person flashback opens the story, setting the first scene in a small town in the Midwest during the summer of 1968. Annie and Bill Powell are moving to fictional Devon Mills, Ohio, where their three young sons will attend a different school in the fall. Bill installs a rope swing to hang from the largest tree in the back yard of the new house, hoping to attract other grade-schoolers in the neighborhood and give the boys a chance to make friends. With the whole summer ahead of them, the swing serves its purpose better than the parents ever imagined, and by August any worries about a new school disappear.</strong></p><p><strong>The narrative shifts to the first person and flashes forward to the present day. Daniel Powell, the middle son, has retired recently, and is thinking about the summer his father put up the rope. He’s started work on a manuscript, and wants to tell what happened to his family after 1968, and how, after living for years like millions of other American families, all their lives change overnight. <em>(1069 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 2 / BEGINNINGS</strong></p><p><strong>Both born during the Great Depression, Bill and Annie’s earliest memories are overshadowed by World War II. The chapter includes separate profiles of their childhoods, and closes with an account of their meeting, courtship, and engagement in the late 1950s. Use of the first person fades from the story here, not to return until the second half of the book. <em>(1604 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 3 / FAMILY</strong></p><p><strong>The narrator describes the birth of the children and the early years of marriage, with emphasis on the role that evangelical Christianity plays in the Powells’ lives. When a high school English teacher assigns the play <em>Inherit the Wind</em>, it prompts a great deal of discussion within the family. <em>(1366 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 4 / MIDDLE YEARS</strong></p><p><strong>As the boys become teenagers and their parents enter middle age, widespread layoffs in the nearby steel mills foreshadow the coming of the Rust Belt. When the last son moves out on his own in 1982, Annie and Bill relocate to the Cleveland area (what the locals call the North Coast) and thrive in their new surroundings. <em>(2420 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 5 / STRIKE</strong></p><p><strong>In 1985 Bill suffers a catastrophic stroke, enduring weeks of “locked-in syndrome,” which devastates Annie as much as it does her husband. <em>(2254 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 6 / AUTUMN</strong></p><p><strong>Bill remains hospitalized for six months. Defying the prognosis of his doctors, he regains a limited ability to speak and walk. Excerpts from Annie’s letters make clear that she credits the role of faith in Bill’s recovery. <em>(2820 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 7 / SPRING</strong></p><p><strong>The Powells leave the hospital and return home to pick up the threads of their lives. The first months are marked by a sense of optimism, but later the family suffers a number of setbacks. Annie is forced to go back to work, and the sons arrange their lives in support of their mother and father. <em>(3263 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 8 / AUTUMN AGAIN</strong></p><p><strong>Two years after the stroke, Bill suffers a second health catastrophe, and Annie never recovers from it. Her deepening despair becomes total when she is diagnosed with a brain tumor. Annie dies in 1991 at age 53, and Bill, 56, dies five months later. <em>(3295 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>PART TWO</strong></p><p><strong>Chapter 9 / RETROSEPCT</strong></p><p><strong>The narrative returns to the first person and the present day as Daniel Powell reflects on the deaths of his parents more than thirty years earlier. He tries to reconcile his experiences as an adult with the memories of his childhood beliefs. Having long since left the church, and skeptical now of both religion and irreligion, he admits that the only thing he can be sure of is his own ignorance. Part of his reason for writing is an attempt to make clear in his own mind where he stands, and he’ll examine several of the classic “proofs” for God in the following chapter. <em>(2389 words).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 10 / CLAIMS</strong></p><p><strong>Powell acknowledges the long list of arguments for God’s existence, and narrows his evaluation to what he considers the two most persuasive claims. He starts with the cosmological argument, sometimes called the argument from creation, and speculates to what extent the scientific models of a Big Bang and a multiverse are relevant to the idea of creation. He moves on to the question of design in nature, and evaluates the impact of Darwin and the evidence for a chemical origin of life. Although both the creation and design arguments maintain that a reasonable person can deduce God from evidence in the natural world, he finds his survey inconclusive, neither proving nor disproving a deity. In his view, the issue is still an open question. <em>(5765 words; seven subheadings).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 11 / PROSPECTS</strong></p><p><strong>As Powell sees it, theists and atheists both look at an incomplete picture and jump to a conclusion. No one has proof one way or the other, so admitting he doesn’t know seems the most honest stance. At the same time, he realizes that even though the universe might be pointless, few would prefer it that way. He will accept that ambiguity, but he’ll also speculate on the plausibility of optimism.</strong></p><p><strong>The remainder of the chapter explores a number of topics, among them the logical paradox of omnipotence, the nature of time and the question of free will, the implications of a mathematical basis to existence, and the undeniable presence of beauty in nature. He evaluates two works of fiction, Theodore Sturgeon’s <em>Microcosmic God</em> and Carl Sagan’s <em>Contact</em>, and considers their relevance to the idea that the universe might have a purpose. <em>(16,852 words; nine subheadings).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Chapter 12 / A DARK HORIZON</strong></p><p><strong>Daniel Powell, now in his sixties, recalls the funerals of his parents, and weighs the prospect of an afterlife that has nothing to do with the heaven and hell of his childhood. Deliberating on the role of religion in parenting, he tells how he and his wife, former evangelicals but now firm agnostics, have raised their children. He speculates on the fate of the human race, and, in the final section, ponders the curious sense of anticipation he feels as the end of his life draws near. <em>(14,253 words; four subheadings).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>NOTES &amp; SOURCES</strong></p><p><strong>The text does not contain footnotes or numbers in superscript, but at the back of the book the narrator does include a list of page numbers, quotations, and bibliographic information to attribute the sources of the ideas he considers in the last four chapters.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c43e66606d61" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[North Coast]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mkbportage2001/north-coast-65f2517515f0?source=rss-4bd716568b0f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/65f2517515f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[exvangelical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stroke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[agnosticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coming-of-age]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marshall K. Beck]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 18:57:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-04T19:14:33.991Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>North Coast</em></strong></p><p><strong>A NOVEL</strong></p><p><strong>Marshall K. Beck</strong></p><p><strong><em>A recovering evangelical describes his religious upbringing, explains why he left the church, and reflects upon the nature of belief.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Fictional memoir / 57K words</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>AUTHOR’S NOTE</strong></p><p><strong><em>Although I grew up in an evangelical church and attended Sunday school regularly as a child, what follows is a work of fiction. Ohio has no Devon Mills or Campbell County, and the accounts of those places are based on several different locations in the Midwest.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>CONTENTS</strong></p><p><strong><em>PART ONE</em></strong></p><p><strong>1 Moving Day</strong></p><p><strong>2 Beginnings</strong></p><p><strong>3 Family</strong></p><p><strong>4 Middle Years</strong></p><p><strong>5 Strike</strong></p><p><strong>6 Autumn</strong></p><p><strong>7 Spring</strong></p><p><strong>8 Autumn Again</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>PART TWO</em></strong></p><p><strong>9 Retrospect</strong></p><p><strong>10 Claims</strong></p><p><strong>11 Prospects</strong></p><p><strong>12 A Dark Horizon</strong></p><p><strong><em>** Notes</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>** Sources</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>Part One</em></strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER I</strong></p><p><strong><em>Moving Day</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The station wagon pulled away from the house near the river and headed into the sunrise. Behind the wheel sat a man in his thirties who looked younger. He kept the windows rolled down to catch the early summer breeze. All around him, boxes full of household goods crowded the inside of the car. A child’s bicycle rested across the load on the back seat, almost touching the ceiling. Laundry supplies filled the passenger space to his right. In the rear cargo section of the wagon, coiled under bags of clothing and toys, lay a fifty-foot length of heavy manila rope.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The man and his wife had just bought a home on the edge of Devon Mills, Ohio. They had three young sons, all still in grade school. For one week, the family had the door keys to both the old house in town and the new house in the suburbs. Friends and relatives were helping with the move, and they all expected to meet the deadline with time to spare. School was out for the summer, and the sons would attend a new district in the fall. The parents wanted to settle in early and give them a chance to make new friends in the neighborhood.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>On this particular morning, the couple agreed that the man would take over the first load of the day by himself. They had a surprise planned, and he needed time alone at the new house to prepare it. On the way there he heard an update over the car radio about the assassination of Robert Kennedy, which had happened just a few days earlier. Both parents felt grateful the boys were still too young to understand the turmoil sweeping over the country that year.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Turning into their new driveway, he looked up again at the trees that dominated the landscape. The couple loved the house, but the trees around it had sealed their decision to buy the property. Maples, elms, and hickories towered over every rooftop up and down the street, forming a canopy that cast a deep green glow over the whole neighborhood. During their first visit, his wife said that the sunlight filtering through the foliage reminded her of the light from a stained-glass window.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Parking the wagon, he entered the garage, brought out an aluminum extension ladder, and carried it into the back yard. An immense oak tree stood near the center of the lawn, its lower branches spreading out from the trunk more than three stories above the ground. He placed the ladder upright against the tree and returned to the wagon for the manila rope.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>After several attempts, he managed to throw a weighted cord over the lowest branch and use it to draw up the heavier rope. Mounting the ladder, he looped the manila twice around the branch, tied fast a bowline, and lashed the knot with the cord. With the upper end safely attached, he descended the ladder and used a hacksaw to cut away the excess length. This allowed the main segment to hang freely, almost touching the ground. To prevent fraying, he wrapped the cut end with the cord and added an oversize knot at the very bottom of the rope. The couple had decided against using an old car tire for a seat, but he could see that the knot, nearly a foot in diameter, would serve as an effective saddle. He closed the ladder, tipped it away from the tree, and laid it on the grass.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>With a running start, the man jumped astride the swing and rode the knot upward as it swept away from the ground. The rope’s anchor so high in the canopy meant a broad track at the bottom of the pendulum, and his momentum on the return sweep increased enough to whip his shirt tail behind him. At each end of the arc, in the instant of weightlessness before reversing direction, his feet dangled high over the lawn. It almost felt like flying, and he grinned at the thought of showing this surprise to the boys later that morning. After several more trial swings, he picked up the tools, returned to the garage, and began unloading the first boxes of the day.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The couple had planned the rope with the idea of easing their sons’ transition to a new neighborhood and a new school, and it would serve its purpose better than they could have imagined. All three brothers fell in love with the swing that same day, and before long the activity in the back yard caught the attention of the girl and boy next door. The word went out, and within a week every grade-schooler for blocks around knew all about The House With The Rope. Gathering at the foot of the tree in greater numbers each day, they had a whole summer ahead of them, and the brothers would make friends with future classmates they might not have met otherwise until months later. By August, any worries about a new school would disappear, as their parents intended.</em></strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Those three boys from 1968 grew up and scattered, and I am the middle son. My mom and dad died years ago, and I keep in touch with my brothers mostly by e-mail. I don’t remember the last time one of us mentioned the rope swing, but lately I’ve been thinking about it. For that summer anyway, we sure didn’t have any doubts about the future.</strong></p><p><strong>My name is Daniel Powell. Until recently, I taught history at a community college near Cleveland, but decided last year to take advantage of a program offering early retirement. My wife, also a teacher, had retired the year before. Our kids are grown and married, with the first grandchild on the brink of starting middle school. When my day job ended, I began working on this manuscript.</strong></p><p><strong>I don’t intend to write an autobiography. But I do want to tell what happened to our family, particularly my parents, after the summer my dad put up the rope. For years we lived like millions of other American families, and then our lives changed overnight. I need to make sense of those changes — how we felt growing up, what we experienced as adults, and what the difference between the two might mean now. I think I learned something. At least I hope so. What a waste if I didn’t.</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER II</strong></p><p><strong><em>Beginnings</em></strong></p><p><strong>Like my parents before me, I was born and raised in Devon Mills, a small town about an hour’s drive east of Cleveland. This corner of Ohio was once part of Connecticut, and some of its first English-speaking inhabitants were Connecticut veterans of the Revolutionary War. The original surveys laid out the town square in the New England style, and the industries that would eventually surround the business district did not arrive until much later.</strong></p><p><strong>By the mid-19th century, the population had grown to almost two thousand, and the town center included a courthouse, flourmills, general stores, and a number of churches. Abundant coal and ore deposits made the region, which included nearby Youngstown and Pittsburgh, an ideal location for the emerging iron industry. Local factories contributed to the national effort toward World War I, and production really took off with the explosive demand for steel during World War II.</strong></p><p><strong>Anyone who grew up in Devon Mills after the war remembers the glow in the night sky that meant a furnace door had opened down at one of the plants, and the late shift was hard at work. The steel trade and its partner industries dominated the economic and social fabric of the region. The first baby boomers began to arrive, and their parents and grandparents worked hard to give them homes. Schools, housing developments, and shopping districts sprang to life within the city limits and surrounding townships. Most residents could not help but feel confident about their lives and the town’s future. The phrase “rust belt” would not enter the language for a long time.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>William Michael Powell was born in 1935, six years before the beginnings of wartime prosperity. His father worked in the mill, as did more than half the men in town at the time, and his mother held a part-time job as a clerk in a clothing store. He had one sibling, a brother three years his senior.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill would retain fond memories of childhood despite the hard times through the Depression. His generation was the last to grow up before the advent of television. When the first TV sets in Devon Mills appeared, he was already in high school. Instead, books, movies, and radio shaped his early impressions about the outside world. He heard the initial reports from Pearl Harbor at age six over the Mutual Radio Network, and followed the course of the war with his parents on an RCA cabinet receiver. Nearly every Saturday, he joined the other kids in the neighborhood at the local movie theater. The schedule consisted of newsreels, cartoons, serial shorts, the first feature, more cartoons, and finally the second feature, which took up most of the day. The titles included Flash Gordon and Buck Rogers, which would lead to an interest in science fiction.</strong></p><p><strong>Radio and film each had its place, but the pulp magazines and novels of the 1940s made the greatest impact on Bill’s childhood. Reading for pleasure became a permanent habit, and he would grow up an avid reader of any subject that interested him. Like most fans of science fiction, he became by default an amateur astronomer. He sought out back issues of <em>Amazing Stories</em> while waiting for new installments from Edgar Rice Burroughs, Andre Norton, Robert Heinlein, and similar authors. History also captured his imagination, particularly accounts of the ancient world before the rise of Athens and Rome. He was a sort of proto-geek, although he didn’t look the part, and went on to play high school football and excel in machine shop and industrial arts.</strong></p><p><strong>After graduating in the winter class of 1954, Bill Powell followed his brother into the service and enlisted in the U.S. Army’s 82nd Airborne Paratroopers Division. Active-duty enlistments required just a two-year commitment at the time, and his military life began with 18 weeks of boot camp at Fort Knox, Kentucky, followed by a ten-day leave at home in Devon Mills. Afterwards, he reported to Fort Bragg, North Carolina, and spent the remainder of his tour training as a combat soldier in parachute assault operations. In addition to airborne instruction, he participated in field maneuvers at Camp Polk, Louisiana, and Fort Stewart, Georgia. He made 22 jumps in all, and early in 1956 received an honorable discharge with the rank of Infantry Corporal. For the rest of his life, he would remain proud of his military service.</strong></p><p><strong>A civilian once again, Bill returned to Devon Mills in search of work. He considered college, but decided for the moment to explore the job market, which was excellent for job seekers at the time. The steel mills offered steady employment, but he knew from his father and a thousand neighborhood anecdotes how hard those jobs were, and the kind of sacrifice they demanded. He turned instead to the town’s other mainstay, the auxiliary companies serving the auto industry. Although Devon Mills had no auto assembly plant, it was home to dozens of small factories that made glass, plastic, tools, electronics, spare parts, and other products used by Ford and GM throughout the Midwest. One month after his discharge, he took a job with Scott and Whiteford Manufacturing, a company that made machine tools, drills, grinders, and other implements for metalworking. He started in the production department and later switched to sales, where he did well and the company soon promoted him. Determined to save money, he boarded with his parents and later his brother to keep living expenses low. During the evenings, he managed to complete several freshman courses at Youngstown State University. He was still working at Scott and Whiteford when he met my mother the following year.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Elizabeth Ann Meyer was born in 1938, three years before the American entry into World War II. Her father worked in the mill, where he would be exempt from military service (as would Bill Powell’s father) due to the strategic role steel production played in the war effort. Elizabeth, or Annie, as everyone called her, was the younger of two children. Her mother worked as a secretary at a local church, where aunts, uncles, and cousins were members of the congregation.</strong></p><p><strong>Like her future husband, Annie Meyer held fond memories of growing up in Devon Mills. By the time she entered grade school, the worst hardships of the Depression were in the past. A model student, she grew up with swim classes, piano lessons, and two weeks of summer camp every June. She developed into a genuine tomboy, partly because her sister was four years older and partly because of her stature — in her early teens she would reach an adult height of not quite five feet tall. This seemed to motivate rather than discourage her, as if she meant to prove that a trivial matter like physical size would have no bearing on her view of life. Annie was the youngest of her extended family, and they all adored her.</strong></p><p><strong>Life in the Meyer household revolved around the church. In addition to Annie’s mother serving as church secretary, her father was one of its founding members. Unlike Bill, whose childhood experiences in a different church were marginal, for Annie and her sister it became a second home. The whole family attended services regularly, which meant every Sunday morning as well as most Wednesday nights. The church belonged to an evangelical Protestant denomination, and by 1950 it had grown into one of the largest congregations in the county. They sponsored missionaries overseas as well as promoted local activities for adults and young people. For these particular parishioners, no aspect of life — not work, school, finances, or politics — took on an importance greater than that of the church. Their children made friends with each other in Sunday school and absorbed the tenets of Scripture at a very early age.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie’s high school years fell right in the middle of the 1950s. She was a junior when Elvis burst across America, and her school yearbooks were full of pictures showing crew cuts, sock hops, and pep rallies in the school gym. She did well academically, thriving on reading but sometimes struggling with mathematics. Having a flair for drama, she participated in the theatrical productions staged at the downtown music hall every autumn. During her junior and senior years, she worked part time as a grocery store cashier. She gave that up after graduation and took a full-time position as a second shift receptionist in the admitting department at Campbell County Memorial Hospital. She was still working there when she crossed paths with my father the following year.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Annie Meyer met Bill Powell in the early summer of 1957 at a swimming and picnic area popular with local teenagers. Although they had attended the same high school, at three years apart they’d never spoken to each other as students. Now both graduated, they began to spend a great deal of time together as the summer gave way to fall. In January 1958, only six months after their first meeting, Bill’s parents — my paternal grandparents — died in a car accident. They were driving on a two-lane highway when an oncoming truck swerved left of center and killed them both instantly. Annie offered a refuge that helped Bill through the worst of his shock. The trauma deepened their relationship, and in December she accepted his proposal of marriage. Bill remained employed with the machine tool sales staff and was living temporarily with relatives. Annie continued working in the hospital admitting office and still lived at home with her parents. They set their wedding date for the spring of 1959.</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER III</strong></p><p><strong><em>Family</em></strong></p><p><strong>The first child came along a week after their first wedding anniversary, and two more boys soon followed. Annie switched from nights to days at the hospital, while Bill experienced continued success in sales. Although his income varied from year to year, his overall progress showed a distinct upward trend. Both parents and children led a life typical of millions of American families, and later all the Powells would look back on the 1960s with great affection.</strong></p><p><strong>Several episodes from this period stood out in the memories of all three sons. The American space program fascinated Bill Powell. His teenage love of science fiction made this inevitable, and he began to convert Annie to the implications of astronomy even before they were married. The Russian launch of the Sputnik satellite occurred just a few months after they met, and it helped to kindle her interest in space. Bill convinced her to read stories by Isaac Asimov and Arthur C. Clarke, and soon she was on her way. Together they watched Kennedy’s speech in 1961 committing the United States to land an astronaut on the Moon by the end of the decade. The boys were too young to remember the first crewed rocket launches, but they would have vivid memories of the later <em>Ranger</em> program to crash camera-carrying probes into the Moon. Close-up photos of the lunar surface appeared on the front page of the <em>Devon Mills Chronicle</em>, and Bill spread the newspaper out alongside maps of the Moon in books brought home from the library. This prompted a flood of questions from the boys. He answered them all, and shared an idea from his reading they would all remember.</strong></p><p><strong>Mathematicians have an ancient trick for using two sides of a right triangle to calculate the unknown length of the third side. Bill explained to his sons how it worked, and made the idea more understandable when he sketched a diagram of the number sentence A2 + B2 = C2:</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/390/1*TtTLsLTnlP0zK7Gk7Zsh1Q.png" /></figure><p><em>(If the illustration doesn’t come through in the post, please see the figure at the top of the Wikipedia article* “Gauss’s Pythagorean Right Triangle Proposal.”)</em></p><p><strong>This image, going back centuries, is a visual representation of the Pythagorean Theorem, and stands as a milestone in the history of mathematics. He told them about a man named Carl Friedrich Gauss, who in the 1800s proposed a project involving this same diagram. Gauss noted that astronomers had achieved good telescopic views of Mars and the Moon, and any hypothetical inhabitants of those places might very well be observing the Earth through their own telescopes. He suggested reproducing the image of the three squares on a scale hundreds of miles across, thereby making it visible from space. Immense fields of light-colored wheat would make up the interior of each square, and strips of dark pine forest would outline the borders. Gauss argued that if human beings could produce an identically large diagram on Mars, we would be able to see it in our telescopes. Detecting the image on Earth, an extraterrestrial observer would likely interpret it as a sign of intelligence.</strong></p><p><strong>This idea predated the invention of radio by almost a century, and radio, as well as other developments in astronomy, would eventually make it obsolete. Nevertheless, the prospect of drawing giant pictures on the side of the Earth struck a chord with the boys, as their father intended.</strong></p><p><strong>It could do little else given the spirit of the times. In the middle 1960s, the Space Age was everywhere. Many Americans fully expected colonies on Mars by the end of the century. Elementary schools displayed bulletin boards with a timeline marking the 66 years between the first flight of the Wright Brothers and the impending mission of Apollo 11. Teachers brought televisions into classrooms — a novelty at the time — to follow rocket launches and splashdowns. Families would gather in living rooms to watch the same events, some with tears in their eyes. Annie and Bill made sure the boys knew the <em>Ranger</em> program was only one small part of a complicated preamble to landing on the Moon. When Neil Armstrong finally stepped onto the lunar surface in 1969, the children of that decade would remember it for the rest of their lives. The future was wide open.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Apollo 11 took place the year after the move to the house with the rope. The kids settled in at school, and their parents earned enough to keep the bills paid. Although the worst of Vietnam was happening around this time, the boys were still too young to hear much about the war from their parents. Kent State University is not very far from Devon Mills, and they’d all remember the shootings there in 1970, but the details would have to wait until they were older and could read about it on their own. Bill and Annie followed the news and voted in every election, but they rarely discussed politics with their sons at that age. The political tensions of the time were ugly enough anyway. Aside from the space program, the boys had only a hazy knowledge of current issues as the Apollo missions came to an end.</strong></p><p><strong>Eventually this would change, and the oil crisis, Watergate, and the fall of Saigon later became subjects of conversation around the family dinner table. Another topic, however, carried greater weight in their memories as adults. The oldest son’s English teacher had assigned the class to read the play <em>Inherit the Wind</em>, a fictionalized account of the arrest and trial of John Scopes. Scopes was a high school biology instructor charged with teaching Darwinian evolution in violation of Tennessee state law in the 1920s. Network television had broadcast the first movie version of the story in the 1960s, and the elder Powells were familiar with the case. Other students in the neighborhood were reading the play as well. Around the same time, news outlets reported the story of “Lucy,” a fossilized Australopithecine skeleton discovered in East Africa. Darwin became a hot topic in certain kitchens and classrooms across Devon Mills.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill Powell had belonged to a mainline Protestant church in his youth. As an adult, he rarely attended services, and when he did, he went with Annie to her church rather than the one from his boyhood. Nominally a Christian, he seemed to have gravitated toward a kind of informal deism later in life, although he never called himself a deist. Bill had no doubts about the reality of Darwinian evolution, and accepted the evidence that the Earth was billions of years old rather than the few thousand years claimed in Genesis. Sometimes he made offhand comments about the talking snake or the magic apple, but for the most part he didn’t say much about his beliefs.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie was different. She had no trouble accepting a primeval Earth, but did so by interpreting the six “days” of creation as a metaphor for a far longer span of time. Many at her church disagreed with this view, and argued in favor of a literal interpretation of Scripture. Annie’s figurative reading allowed her to acknowledge evolution as part of a divine plan, much the same way she acknowledged electricity and photosynthesis — they were all cogs in the machinery of creation. Darwinism did not shake her faith. She was a committed Christian, and actively raised her sons to be Christian. Nevertheless, she felt they should be free to make up their own minds about how Darwin fit into the world.</strong></p><p><strong>The sons would do so, with their inner deliberations spread out over many years, but mostly starting with <em>Inherit the Wind</em>. They’d known vaguely of evolution beforehand, but, like Vietnam and the counterculture, they were too young to make much sense of it. Annie and Bill did not use the play to assert their own opinions, but instead welcomed the occasion as an exercise in critical thinking. Some of the boys’ Sunday school teachers saw Darwin as evil, but the elder Powells did not. Annie had stepped back from biblical literalism but still embraced Christianity; Bill had stepped back from Christianity but still accepted theism. Even <em>Inherit the Wind</em> left room for a universe designed by providence. Despite the emphasis on free inquiry, no one brought up the possibility that an understanding of Darwin might lead to doubts about creation itself.</strong></p><p><em>* Note: The illustration comes from the Wikipedia article “Gauss’s Pythagorean Right Triangle Proposal.”</em></p><p><em>By en: User: Wapcaplet — Transwikied from en:. Originally created by en: User: Michael Hardy, then scaled, with colour and labels being added by en: User: Wapcaplet, transformed in svg format by fr: Utilisateur: Steff, changed colors and font by de: Leo2004, CC BY-SA 3.0, </em><a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=640875"><em>https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=640875</em></a></p><p><strong>CHAPTER IV</strong></p><p><strong><em>Middle Years</em></strong></p><p><strong>Both Annie and Bill changed jobs in the early 1970s. She resigned at the hospital and took a part-time position as a receptionist in a doctor’s office. Bill still worked in sales, but transferred to a different machine tool company with a larger clientele.</strong></p><p><strong>Around this time they joined the Maplewood Swim Club, located only a half mile from their house. Although Devon Mills had a small number of exclusive country clubs for its wealthier residents, Maplewood was not among them. Instead, it belonged to an informal league of a half-dozen local pools that only remained open during the summer. Most of these sponsored organized swim teams that competed against each other in July and August, wrapping up with a championship meet two weeks before Labor Day. Nearly all the families with children in the neighborhood belonged to Maplewood. In addition to the in-ground, Olympic-sized pool, the club included a pavilion, food court, showers, locker rooms, and an acre of shaded green lawn for blankets and beach chairs. Given the winters in northern Ohio, summers at Maplewood became a hub of activity for both children and their parents. The Powell boys joined the swim team and spent nearly all their waking hours at the pool during the season, along with many of the kids they first met around the rope swing. Annie and Bill came to every swim meet and occasionally went to parties at the pavilion on weekends. They rarely drank, but the parties were always crowded, and sometimes they made an exception.</strong></p><p><strong>Alcohol had nothing to do with an incident that occurred one autumn after the pool had closed for another season. It was Halloween night, and one of the last years all the boys were still young enough to go out trick-or-treating. They had just returned from their rounds, and were huddled in a back bedroom sorting through piles of candy. Their mother picked up an abandoned rubber mask from the living room floor, one that covered not just the face but the entire head as well. Their father was still answering the front door and passing out treats. Annie slipped quietly into the laundry room, removed all her clothes, put on the mask and a full-length raincoat, tiptoed out the back door, and circled around to the front of the house. No children were in sight. She rang the bell, and after Bill answered the door with a smile and a cheerful greeting, she snapped the raincoat wide open. He stopped smiling immediately, only catching on after he recognized Annie’s muffled laughter from behind the mask. The kids didn’t hear a thing, and only learned of it from a family friend years later.</strong></p><p><strong>By the middle 1970s, the oldest child had started high school, with the others soon to follow. The family tradition of keeping up with the American space program continued. Nearly every boy and girl in the neighborhood grew up with the <em>Star Trek</em> reruns that dominated weekday afternoons in those days, and some would feel vindicated when NASA announced plans to christen the first space shuttle <em>Enterprise</em> in honor of the TV series. The Powell boys were old enough now to stay up for Johnny Carson, and they watched the astronomer Carl Sagan explain the <em>Pioneer </em>and <em>Viking</em> programs. At their parents’ urging, all three sons became regular readers of science fiction. They took the novels of Asimov, Clarke, Heinlein, Burroughs, and other writers to school, propping them up inside an open textbook to read covertly in class. When the first <em>Star Wars</em> movie came out in 1977, they were among the earliest fans.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>In the years leading up to <em>Star Wars</em>, teenagers in the neighborhood began earning their drivers’ licenses one by one. Until then, they all relied on bicycles to get around town. The decade saw a cycling craze as traditional utility bikes gave way to new styles with banana seats and multiple gears, all intended for the booming youth market. Schwinn dominated the field, at least in Devon Mills, and offered models with names like <em>Sting Ray, Fastback, </em>and<em> Gray Ghost. </em>The long, bottle-green Schwinn tandem sat parked alongside station wagons in several garages around the neighborhood. New bikes every two or three years, unknown in Annie and Bill’s childhood, became landmarks of growing up, for parents as well as their kids. As girls and boys grew older, they graduated to imported twelve-speeds with dual derailleurs and lugged frames. The racks outside Maplewood pool bristled with bicycles on hot summer days.</strong></p><p><strong>Devon Mills stood out as a kind of cyclists’ wonderland in those years. The terrain was flat or rolling toward the west, and turned to steep hills approaching the eastern side of the county. Wooded areas broke up the landscape, some of them spanning hundreds of acres and extending well into the city limits. An improvised network of unpaved trails crisscrossed these broad tracts. Speeding down a backstreet, a group of riders might suddenly veer off the pavement and drop onto a dirt path leading into dense foliage. There kids could imagine themselves far beyond Ohio.</strong></p><p><strong>Away from the woods, residential areas made up the bulk of the road network. A few brick streets still existed, but all the others were paved with smooth asphalt. Most of these followed a grid pattern, with many designed as dead ends to minimize car traffic. The greenbelts broke up these grids, but the bike paths through them put nearly all points within reach. Commercial routes enclosed the side streets, and here the landscape became a patchwork of stores, churches, and restaurants. Riders could avoid city traffic by cutting across the parking lots or shooting past the loading docks behind the stores. Any trip downtown or through the suburbs would typically pass over a half-dozen kinds of terrain.</strong></p><p><strong>Even before kindergarten, toddlers began clamoring for their first two-wheelers, and by second grade they were taking regular trips to the corner store for candy and gum. Later they would go farther and stay out longer, knowing that when the streetlights came on, it was time to head for home. Annie, Bill, and the other parents gradually allowed that curfew to become negotiable, and by the end of junior high school their sons and daughters had all built up detailed mental maps of every shortcut and backstreet in town. Many of the roads leading out of the eastern hills had long downward slopes, where a band of teenagers could stand up on the pedals, look out over a carpet of treetops, and glide down into the valley. The movie <em>E.T.</em> has a scene showing a group of young cyclists riding with great skill to escape the villains chasing them, in the end literally flying away on their bikes. That sense of running with the pack, captured briefly in the movie, took hold in actual childhood for whole summers at a time. The Maplewood kids were all understandably counting down the days until their parents handed over the car keys, and they didn’t yet realize what they would leave behind.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>By the fall of 1977, all three Powell boys were in high school. On September 19 of that year, a date known locally afterwards as “Black Monday,” the factories of Youngstown Sheet and Tube closed without notice and furloughed five thousand steel workers. The plants in Devon Mills soon followed with similar layoffs. The causes of the steel crisis were complex, but ultimately traced their roots to international competition, a reluctance to upgrade American mills, and a drop in prices as demand fell. Black Monday represented the start of an economic decline that would play out over decades in the Midwest, and Campbell County and the surrounding communities have never recovered. For the residents of Devon Mills in late 1977, the early ripples — soon to become tidal waves — were about to arrive.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie moved to full-time work as her doctor’s primary receptionist. His practice enjoyed great success, welcoming a partnering physician and adding additional staff. Annie became the nerve center of the office, adding to a wide range of contacts across her hometown. In an age before computers, she also kept up an active sideline typing term papers for high school and college students. A standard 250 words per page (double-spaced, with one-inch margins) determined the rate of payment. A lightning typist, she added considerably to the family income.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill was by now a full-fledged member of the machine tool community, which, like most of industrial America, had suffered a contraction from oil shocks and recessions even before Black Monday. A son once asked him what a machine tool was, and he described it as a place where one tool serves to guide another. In the simplest terms, a drill is a hand tool, a drill press, a machine tool. The latter, where the drill is mounted on a frame with a handle that can raise or lower the height of the drill, brings together two components: first, the drill itself, and second, the assembly of levers and gears that allows the operator to direct the drill without touching it. This basic arrangement serves as the foundation for complex, multi-staged mechanisms that can bore, cut, or grind metal and other materials into almost any conceivable shape. The makers of automobiles, aircraft, and household goods all relied on these devices to produce exact copies of the parts they needed. The machine tool people saw themselves much as long-haul truck drivers and their families did: vital to maintaining modern life, yet usually ignored or taken for granted. Like truckers, electricians, mechanics, and other essential workers, they tended to stick together.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill never failed to bring home a paycheck, but his income depended on the sporadic nature of sales, and could vary widely from month to month. Although a period of great success lay just ahead, he didn’t know it then, and Annie carried the bulk of the economic burden through some very lean months as the 1970s came to an end. The brothers would later talk among themselves and realize how hard their parents must have worked to keep three naïve teenagers unaware of the stresses on the family budget.</strong></p><p><strong>In the spring of 1981, the youngest Powell boy graduated from high school. The oldest had already followed his father into industrial sales, while the middle son was enrolled as an undergraduate at Kent State. Within a year, the youngest would be on his way toward becoming a successful building contractor. One by one, they moved out of the house and out of town, and by the summer of 1982 Bill and Annie were faced with an empty nest, even though all three boys still lived within an hour’s drive. For the first time, the elder Powells had the option of relocating when it came to considering a change of jobs. Bill wanted to leave the Ohio winters behind and move to the Sunbelt, but Annie preferred to stay closer to home. Although the boys were all still single, the oldest was giving indications of changing that, and she wanted to live near any future grandchildren.</strong></p><p><strong>They spent a year considering employers, submitting applications, and following the local grapevine when it came to job prospects. In August 1982 Bill accepted an offer for the position of Regional Sales Manager at Haider Coleman Industries, headquartered in Cleveland. The company made precision metalworking tools and had long-standing ties to the auto industry. Annie resigned from the doctors’ office, and, after saying goodbye to the house with the rope (long since taken down), she and Bill bought a place in the Cleveland suburbs about an hour west of Devon Mills. The responsibilities of Bill’s new job required him to travel extensively, and Annie planned to accompany him. Although she was not an employee of Haider Coleman, the company would pay her travel expenses and support her as an unofficial organizer alongside her husband. They made Cleveland their home base, and their circuits would cover cities in ten states east of the Mississippi river.</strong></p><p><strong>Occasionally they went by commercial airline to keep business appointments, but mostly they traveled by automobile. The company provided a new full-sized van as their primary means of transport. It had a high roof, swiveling captain’s chairs, and a plush interior with venetian blinds and a built-in refrigerator. It also contained a foldout double bed, but they never slept there overnight; the company paid for lodging in comfortable hotels. Nevertheless, the van became the headquarters for every trip, serving as a mobile office, stockroom, and wardrobe. They logged nearly 100,000 miles in it the first year on the road.</strong></p><p><strong>Settling into their new roles, Bill and Annie enjoyed an agreeable work schedule: two or three weeks of travel followed by two to three weeks at home. They both fell in love with the Gulf Coast, as well as the upstate counties of North and South Carolina. Bill’s experience paid off as he closed sales and earned substantial revenue for the company, which rewarded him generously. Annie learned a great deal about the business, loved traveling, and made him better at his job. They counted any work-related success a mutual victory.</strong></p><p><strong>During the weeks at home, the Powells visited their sons around northeast Ohio as well as family and friends in Devon Mills. Large sections of the steel mills were closing irregularly, and many workers endured long layoffs followed by uncertain periods of employment. Bill’s brother belonged to this group, and he struggled to earn a living in the wake of Black Monday. Keeping in touch by phone, the two usually met for dinner on the Powells’ trips back home. Annie never failed to see her parents during these visits, and her sister, who lived outside nearby Akron, often joined them. In the fall of 1983, the whole family gathered to attend the wedding of Bill and Annie’s oldest son.</strong></p><p><strong>By 1984, the Powells had grown into their roles and become a valued asset to Haider Coleman. In the spring of that year Bill closed a long-term contract with General Motors and received a substantial commission on top of his regular salary. In stark contrast to what was happening back in their hometown, Annie and Bill were now in a better financial position than they’d ever been in their lives. They paid off all their debts, and the following year bought a cottage on Lake Erie and spent almost the whole of July there. As the summer of 1985 ended, Bill, age 50, and Annie, 47, had every reason to anticipate a bright future.</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER V</strong></p><p><strong><em>Strike</em></strong></p><p><strong>On an overcast Tuesday afternoon in late October 1985, Bill Powell departed Cleveland to attend a vender meeting in Pittsburgh. He took the new van, his third with the company and the most comfortable so far. Annie decided to stay home during the brief side trip into Pennsylvania. Knowing Pittsburg well, Bill checked into a downtown hotel he’d used on previous visits. He rose early the next morning and spent the whole day seeing clients and exchanging information with other attendees.</strong></p><p><strong>Later that evening, he met for dinner with a group from the conference and held himself to a light meal. His family doctor had advised him in the past about the dangers of high cholesterol, but Bill tended to shrug off that advice as a young man. He and Annie used tobacco from their late teens into their early thirties, and — after several attempts — had both quit for good. Their use of alcohol was moderate, and had tapered off as they grew older. Now, living in a new city and seeing a new doctor, they put real effort into exercise and improving their diet. Bill especially lost weight and lowered his cholesterol and blood pressure. The state of his health was now probably better than most American men his age. He carried a laminated card in his wallet listing the nutritional contents of various entrees, and had been faithfully following a special diet for over a year.</strong></p><p><strong>The dinner broke up around ten p.m., and Bill was back in his hotel room before eleven. He called home and talked briefly with Annie about the day’s events. After the phone call, he climbed into bed and watched the local news and the Carson monologue. He planned to have an early breakfast with a colleague, a final round of meetings in the morning, and be back on the road by early afternoon.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>At around 1:00 a.m. Bill woke up abruptly with a severe pain in the back of his head. It felt especially sharp between his right ear and the center of his neck. The right side of his face was numb. Climbing out of bed, he walked into the bathroom to look in the mirror, thinking he’d had a stroke. He could move both sides of his face and talk normally despite the numbness on the right side. Except for the pain at the back of his head, the rest of his body seemed normal. Returning to bed, he propped up pillows against the headboard and turned on the TV. Dozing off and on, he stayed in a sitting position the rest of the night. The headache persisted but did not seem to be getting any worse. The facial numbness on the right side faded toward daybreak. When the six-a.m. wake-up call came through from the front desk, he was already up and getting dressed.</strong></p><p><strong>The early meeting in the hotel restaurant went off as planned. Bill mentioned his headache, and the colleague, an old friend he’d known for years, offered to drive him to the emergency room. He declined, and insisted they continue with their working breakfast. Feeling a little better after eating, Bill drove back to the conference center to wrap up the session. A phone call home in the late morning, his first since the night before, went unanswered, but he wasn’t surprised. Annie often ran errands throughout the day. He still planned to leave for Cleveland soon after lunch.</strong></p><p><strong>Traffic was normal on the drive back, but he began experiencing short, sporadic periods of double vision, which cleared up after a few seconds. The headache seemed to come and go. He made several stops to get out of the van and stretch his legs. With great care he finished the trip and pulled into their driveway around five p.m. to find Annie at home.</strong></p><p><strong>She saw right away that he didn’t look well. They sat down at the kitchen table as Bill recounted his symptoms since first waking up with the headache in the early hours of the morning. All he wanted now was a hot bath, and put off Annie’s plea that they call the doctor that night. After the bath, he felt much better. The headache was fading, the right side of his face was no longer numb, and the flashes of double vision had stopped. He had no trouble walking or talking. Annie reluctantly agreed that they would call the doctor first thing in the morning. Bill went to bed and immediately fell into a deep sleep.</strong></p><p><strong>He slept almost nine hours. Awakening around seven, he said the headache was gone, although Annie thought he still looked pale and haggard. She called their family doctor, who agreed to see Bill at eleven o’clock that morning. Afterwards she called their sons to let them know what was happening.</strong></p><p><strong>The doctor made an examination, could not make a definitive diagnosis, and arranged for him to see a neurologist later that afternoon. The neurologist ordered a CAT scan, and after reading it told the Powells that it ruled out stroke (as well as tumor) as the cause of Bill’s symptoms. He said he didn’t think it necessary to admit him to the hospital and made a follow-up appointment for Monday morning. Annie made several calls to share the good news. Duncan, their youngest son, arrived later that evening with plans to spend the night.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>At half-past four the next morning, Bill awoke in great distress. Unable to move normally, he struggled to grasp Annie’s lower arm and rouse her. She woke with a start, turned on the light, and looked closely at her husband. He was trying to speak, and after several attempts she made out the words <em>something’s wrong</em>. His face held a look of panic, and he managed to gasp out the words <em>whole</em> <em>body’s getting stiff</em>. Annie shouted at the top of her voice to wake Duncan down the hall in the guest bedroom.</strong></p><p><strong>They helped him to a sitting position, which seemed to alleviate some of his anxiety and made speaking a little easier. Annie dialed the number for the physician’s answering service given to her by the neurologist the previous day. The operator told her that she would relay the message and have the on-call physician phone her at home as soon as possible. With Annie on one side and her son on the other, they were able to help Bill stand and support him as he staggered into the living room. The agony of effort that this required convinced Annie not to wait for the doctor’s call. After a brief rest in an upright chair, they struggled to get Bill to the garage and into the passenger seat of Annie’s car. They knew he could never manage the steps leading into the van.</strong></p><p><strong>Duncan took the wheel while Annie leaned forward in the back seat and cradled Bill’s head and shoulders from behind as they drove. A sense of terror welled up inside her as he slanted further to the right with each passing moment. Although he outweighed her by almost 50 pounds, she managed to keep his torso and head upright during the short drive to the hospital.</strong></p><p><strong>They pulled into the emergency room receiving bay, and Annie stayed with him while her son hurried inside to find help. Two orderlies came with a wheelchair, and the four of them were able to lift Bill into it after seeing that he’d lost the ability to stand, even with assistance. They took him to the ER waiting area. Duncan propped Bill up with an arm over his shoulders while Annie filled out paperwork. Bill’s body was rigid, and by this time he was crying.</strong></p><p><strong>The ER physician examined Bill and afterwards held a brief conference in the hallway with Annie. He wasn’t sure what was wrong, but they were conducting a battery of tests and would know more shortly. Based on the information Annie provided, he was aware of Bill’s case during the 48 hours prior to their appearance in the ER. He had called the office of their family physician and expected to hear from him soon. The ER doctor said not to worry about the crying — it appeared in all sorts of neurological problems. In the meantime, they started Bill on several medications and admitted him to a private room where family could stay around the clock if necessary. Annie thanked him and wrote down the location of Bill’s new room on another floor in the hospital. On the way there, she called their other two sons from a pay phone in the lobby. Both agreed to leave right away for the hospital and would arrive later that morning.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill’s condition continued to deteriorate. The ability to swallow disappeared along with the ability to talk, and the nurses, Annie, and her son put great effort into suctioning the inside of his mouth so he wouldn’t choke on his own saliva. He had no movement or reaction in his arms or legs; the only muscles he could move were his eyes and eyelids. Annie quickly came up with a system whereby one blink meant “no” and two blinks meant “yes” as they worked frantically to relieve his distress.</strong></p><p><strong>By mid-morning, all the boys — David, Daniel, and Duncan — were present, and the ER physician as well as the Powells’ family doctor called the whole group into a nearby conference room. They told them that despite the CAT scan of the day before, all Bill’s symptoms indicated a severe cerebrovascular infarction — a stroke caused by a blocked artery in the brain. The doctors wanted to move him to the Intensive Care Unit that afternoon. Annie and the boys could use a separate waiting area with chairs and couches, but could not remain at his bedside as in the private room. ICU rules permitted only brief visits by immediate family members, and no more than one person at a time. The doctors and staff there would support him closely, and they hoped that a clearer picture of what was happening would soon emerge.</strong></p><p><strong>All the Powells remained overnight in the hospital. Despite the rules limiting visitors in the ICU, the nurses allowed one of them to remain by Bill’s bedside the whole night. They used the suction device constantly to help keep his mouth and airway clear. One of the nurses, seeing Annie attempt to communicate using the one/two blink method, brought a placard showing the letters of the alphabet, the numbers 0–9, and a list of common words arranged in columns. By pointing at the items in turn and having Bill confirm characters with blinks, they were able to slowly communicate. Later the staff came to take Bill to the MRI department. They allowed Annie to accompany him coming and going but not — despite her pleas — into the scanning area. They both returned to the ICU an hour later.</strong></p><p><strong>Shortly after nine a.m., the doctors arranged for another family conference in another room near Intensive Care. Annie wanted to know how this could be a stroke when the neurologist told them on Friday that the CAT scan ruled that out. They said while it was true that the original scan did not show an infarction, Bill’s allergy to the contrasting iodine dye used for X-rays did not allow them to obtain the most detailed result possible. Also, those images were now almost two days old, and the primary blockage very likely occurred after the original scan. The MRI taken that morning clearly showed three small areas of dead tissue in the brain stem. These images, along with Bill’s symptoms since admittance, left no doubt as to the diagnosis of stroke. No further tests would change this diagnosis.</strong></p><p><strong>Right now, they had to plan for Bill’s immediate needs. Because he lacked a reflex for coughing and gagging as well as swallowing, he’d need a suctioning tube placed through his nose to collect the secretions in the upper respiratory tract. He would also need a feeding tube inserted alongside it, through the nose and into the stomach. The nasal tubes would be temporary, and the surgeon would have to make an opening in the base of his throat to provide an airway, as well as cut through the abdominal wall into the stomach in order to place a feeding tube. He would also likely need a urinal catheter inserted sometime in the near future.</strong></p><p><strong>The whole family — particularly Annie — looked stunned, but there was more to come. The doctors told them how rare this kind of stroke was, and why the location of the blockage in the brain stem made it so serious. No kind of surgery could correct or relieve what had happened. The patient might not survive the day. If he did, they should not expect a full recovery. In fact, based on what they knew so far, the family might possibly expect a 20% chance of any recovery at all. Bill would need constant care for the rest of his life. If he stabilized in the near future, they would have to transfer him to a rehabilitation facility better equipped to handle his kind of case and work toward whatever limited recuperation might be possible. Annie should apply for Social Security Disability and start the complicated process of finding long-term care. They were sorry to be the bearers of such terrible news, but even with the best possible outcome, their father and husband would never be the same.</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER VI</strong></p><p><strong><em>Autumn</em></strong></p><p><strong>Bill Powell remained in Intensive Care for the next 27 days. More than a dozen family members, co-workers, and friends came to visit and offer comfort to Annie. Their sons stayed for the first week, shuttling back and forth between the Powell home and their father’s bedside. Eventually their mother insisted that the boys return to school and work. She knew they could all come back on short notice if necessary.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie refused to leave the hospital. Friends and relatives brought clean clothes as needed, and the staff allowed her access to a shower and permission to sleep on a couch in the ICU waiting room. She spent every possible moment at her husband’s side. The family came to know the term “locked-in syndrome,” which aptly described his condition. He remained conscious and mentally alert, but suffered from total paralysis — unable to move his head, arms, and legs as well as losing the ability to swallow, cough, and talk. The only exceptions were his eyes, and his only means of communication the eye blinks that Annie devised during their first night in the hospital. As crude as this was, it allowed her to ask a series of yes/no questions and determine that Bill’s memory remained intact and he was fully aware of what was happening.</strong></p><p><strong>During the second week, the doctors placed all the tubes they described to the family the day after Bill’s admission. The feeding tube through the nose and into the stomach could not remain long or it would permanently damage the vocal cords. To replace it, the surgeons guided a small camera with a light down the esophagus and into the digestive tract. This assisted them in cutting an opening through the abdominal wall for the new feeding port leading directly into the stomach. As agonizing as this was, it allowed for the removal of the nasal tube, and, once the operation was over, made him relatively more comfortable. This also applied to the procedure for making an opening into the trachea. The surgery was painful and left him with a hole in his neck, but it also removed another tube from his nose and made breathing easier.</strong></p><p><strong>Nearly a month after admission, Bill left the ICU for a standard bed elsewhere in the same hospital. He regained some movement in the head and neck, but his arms and legs remained immobile. The brothers continued to visit frequently, and Annie returned home for the first time to wash clothes and shop for groceries. She still spent 18 or more hours each day at the hospital. During this time, she began to keep a diary of what was happening to her husband.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/3/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Bowels impacted. Severe abdominal pain — unable to tolerate “feedings.”</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/6/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>20 enemas in three days — stool softener in &amp; laxative in IV tube plus “total chemical nutrition.”</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Blinked to me . . . I-M F-U-L-L O-F S-H-I-T</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/7/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Still intense stomach pain — burning sensation — terrible leg cramps.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/10/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Bowels finally clear. Barium enema to provide contrast for X-rays.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/11/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>X-rays: esophagus, stomach, duodenum, small intestine.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/13/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Abdominal pain even worse. Full feeling — started vomiting several times daily — Unable to tolerate tube feedings.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/15/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Barium still in Bill — same nerve that controls swallow/gag/cough reflex also controls digestion and movement of food (&amp; barium) thru stomach, intestines, and bowels —</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Digestion &amp; passage of food thru the GI tract not working right.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/18/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Still vomiting — X-ray of stomach still shows barium — moving out very slowly.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/20/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Stopped tube feeding — hiccups and vomiting — Every time he vomits he could suffocate.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/22/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Hiccups 48 hours straight — Exhausting when they last so long. Medication to stop them only works sometimes.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/24/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>BAD DAY — physically and emotionally — The boys came and stayed all of Christmas Eve. Thinking about this time last year.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Told Bill that this didn’t happen only to him, but to us, and WE are going to beat it.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/25/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Better than yesterday.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Rebecca and Frank </em>[Annie’s sister and brother-in-law]<em> visited and brought a Sony Walkman, cassettes of WW II broadcasts &amp; old radio shows for Bill.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Mom &amp; Dad brought stuffed stockings, nut roll, and cookies.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>12/26/85</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Feeling better — stomach settling down — barium finally out — Dr. said barium usually passes within eight hours — for us it took 17 days.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Thank the Lord!! Restart feedings 25cc qoh</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Annie would use these and later entries as the basis for letters written to family and friends updating them about her husband’s condition.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>The doctors had planned to move Bill to a rehabilitation hospital soon after leaving the ICU, but the problems with the barium delayed the transfer. Finally, two days before New Year’s Eve, he traveled by ambulance to Garfield Memorial Rehabilitation Hospital, a specialized facility devoted to medical recovery 35 miles east of Cleveland. By this time, he’d lost nearly 50 pounds, but also regained some movement in his lips and jaw. Annie now used the blink method of communication with a “quad board,” a clear acrylic 16” x 24” panel with the vowels in the upper right corner and the consonants spread out over the other three quadrants. Unlike the opaque laminated card they used earlier, she could look through this board at Bill’s face and see his eye blinks directly when pointing to a letter. Although they became adept at communicating in this way, Annie hoped that with the gains in mouth movement she would eventually be able to read his lips. He still had no voice at all.</strong></p><p><strong>With the move to Garfield Hospital, the family settled into a weekly routine. Annie no longer slept in the waiting room, but she spent long days at Bill’s bedside and came to know everyone connected with his case. Unlike the first hospital, the drive from their house in Cleveland to GMRH took almost 45 minutes. Annie usually left before dawn and returned after dark. Her parents’ house in Devon Mills was slightly closer to Garfield, and sometimes she drove there to spend the night rather than return to Cleveland. Her sons came to see both their parents every weekend, and during the week one or more of them usually accompanied their mother to the hospital and stayed overnight at home afterwards. Surrounded by family, Annie rarely found herself alone.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill continued to regain function in the lower half of his face. Although he still couldn’t talk, he began to mouth words that Annie could understand. Soon she was able to supplement the quad board by lip-reading whole sentences, and their ability to communicate rapidly improved. The doctors examined Bill’s throat and vocal cords and said it was probably too soon for speech. Nevertheless, when they temporarily closed the opening in his trachea and asked him to try speaking, he was able to manage a few words in a low, raspy voice. Annie cried.</strong></p><p><strong>Shortly afterwards, the family received another piece of good news. Bill showed some voluntary movement and control in his right hand and wrist, soon followed by movement in the left index finger. This happened more than three months after the stroke, and for the first time Annie felt they might have some reason for hope. She continued keeping up the notes in her daily calendar book. Every few weeks she would convert the entries into a group letter addressed to family and friends.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>2/9/86</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Hi All,</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Sorry about this photocopied letter. I seem to say the same things to everyone and thought if I made copies it would make it easier. If I repeat something I’ve already told you, please forgive!</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Bill is doing great! In fact, so great that the even doctors can’t believe it. They tell me he is unique, but I already knew that . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>They now have him sitting up in a wheelchair for several hours each day. He still has trouble holding up his head, but the chair has a curved headrest and can tip back like a recliner. You can’t imagine what a difference it makes just to get out of bed . . . His voice and arm movements are getting better all the time . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>I was asked to get him a pair of tennis shoes with Velcro tabs. His slippers keep falling off his feet — he’s lost so much weight. When the physical therapist came in, Bill held up his right leg (while sitting in the wheelchair) to show him his new shoes. It took a second for all of us to realize that he was holding up his right leg! Now they have him lifting a two lb. weight on his right ankle . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>All of those involved in his care can’t believe how fast he is improving — but he doesn’t think it’s fast enough! Can you blame him? He’s the one going through it all. He said to me yesterday, “Why can’t I talk like I used to? Why can’t I eat as I used to?” There aren’t any answers — but I know he will improve — more &amp; more — as he keeps working hard and God continues to answer prayer. I’ve told the doctors here — all that Bill regains, we will credit to Garfield Rehab and God — &amp; not necessarily in that order!</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Thank you — all — for your cards, your</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>letters — and most of all, for your prayers.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Love,</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Annie &amp; Bill</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Once he could leave his bed, Bill’s progress accelerated, aided by the news that their daughter-in-law had given birth to a son, and he and Annie were now grandparents. The occupational therapist set up a “sling on a spring” to help him practice handwriting. His first attempts showed an illegible scrawl, but within a week he managed to sign his name in a shaky script and copy short sentences. He had trouble with vision in the left eye, but the doctors prescribed a patch over the right eye to help strengthen the weak side. This worked as planned, and he gradually discarded the eye patch.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>The sales director from Haider Coleman visited twice during the first weeks after the stroke. Annie kept him informed of their progress over the phone and in her group letters. Now, in light of Bill’s remarkable recovery, he called her to arrange another visit. Although her husband looked forward to this, Annie felt anxious, even though the meeting would not take place for several weeks. So far, the company medical insurance had paid every charge without dispute, but she knew that could not continue indefinitely, and worried about how long Bill might still have a job.</strong></p><p><strong>Despite Annie’s fears about employment, Bill continued to make gains. In late February the doctors removed the tracheostomy valve and closed the hole in his neck. Annie told him that the indentation was the perfect size for the knot of a tie. He started taking liquids by mouth to supplement the feeding tube in his stomach, and gradually worked up to a soft diet. Finally, the doctors removed the abdominal portal, and afterwards all his meals consisted of real food. He was tubeless for the first time since the stroke.</strong></p><p><strong>The therapists continued to transfer their patient from bed to wheelchair several times daily. Soon they had him using a walker to help support some of his weight during the transfers, and before long he could stand briefly on his own while holding the walker in front of him. The first time this happened Bill said, “The air is kinda thin up here.” He stood with the walker for longer and longer periods, and eventually advanced to using the parallel bars in Physical Therapy. He still had trouble lifting his left foot, but Annie felt hopeful. She prayed that in due course he could replace the walker with a cane.</strong></p><p><strong>Unfortunately, Bill suffered a setback shortly before his boss and colleagues from the company were due to arrive. He started having difficulty breathing and suffered from bouts of claustrophobia. The doctors ordered tests and discovered several areas in his lungs full of tiny blood clots. They said these clots had broken away from a larger clot in his pelvic area and ordered immediate bed rest. The staff inserted an IV of blood thinner running continuously to dissolve the clots. After a week of inactivity, the doctors pronounced his lungs clear and switched him to oral doses of another blood thinner, telling Annie he might need to take it the rest of his life. She called to postpone the meeting with Bill’s boss, unsure of how he might respond.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill lost headway during the enforced bed rest, but after great effort worked back to where he’d been before the lung scare. Soon he surpassed that point and continued his extraordinary — almost miraculous — recovery. The therapy department suggested an afternoon outing to the local shopping mall, and both Powells agreed at once. Bill made the trip in his wheelchair and used a hospital van equipped with a ramp and hydraulic lift. The occupational therapist accompanied them, and they ate pizza at a restaurant inside the mall. Annie said that she felt like they were out on a date, and they counted it as another victory.</strong></p><p><strong>The following weekend they finally had a chance to spend time alone. Annie described it in a letter:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>We were allowed to stay in a studio apartment the rehab unit has — right on the same floor and down the hall from Bill’s room. The hospital uses this apartment for people who will be going home — to see what problems they might have in normal, daily living. We did our own cooking — etc. — and managed (from Fri. night until Sun. night) just fine.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>There was, of course, a call switch in the living/bedroom — and one in the bathroom — in case we did need help. We only had to use it once. That weekend was wonderful — much better than just a date. All of this just made us that much more homesick . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Thank goodness for our faith in a loving Father. Now we know that prayers are answered.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>By the middle of March, the doctors began considering plans for Bill’s eventual discharge from the hospital. They balanced the physical gains of continued care as an in-patient with the psychological benefits of returning home. Both Bill and Annie strongly favored the latter, and participated in several team conferences with the doctors and staff to discuss the transition. Even though GMRH would arrange for a physical therapist to visit three times weekly, they cautioned the Powells not to underestimate the challenges that would come with leaving the hospital. They’d need to mount handrails in the bathroom, purchase a shower chair for the tub, and install a riser to elevate the toilet seat. Bill’s voice was still weak and hoarse, and they encouraged Annie to buy a portable wireless intercom so she could hear him if she were in another room. They would also need to arrange for their own walker and wheelchair. Pending any changes over the next several weeks, the doctors set a tentative discharge date for the last week of April.</strong></p><p><strong>Shortly after this decision, Bill’s boss called to arrange a date for the working visit postponed earlier. Despite Annie’s pride in her husband’s recovery, she knew he was nowhere near being able to socialize with clients the way he had before the stroke. He still suffered from partial paralysis of the vocal cords, and spoke in a soft, labored voice even after months of speech therapy. She mentioned more than once in her letters how much she wished his voice would improve; he could have conducted a great deal of business over the phone. More troubling, Bill continued to cry easily over trivial matters. He’d gained some control over this, but a casual mention of some incident from the past could still set off tears. Annie considered this his greatest impediment to working again, and refused to think that the bulk of improvement in this area might have already occurred.</strong></p><p><strong>The group from Haider Coleman arrived in late March, just a month before Bill’s planned discharge. To Annie’s great relief, the meeting went well. Both Powells, the senior sales director, and three of their colleagues participated, occupying a hospital conference room for over an hour. They discussed a few items of company business, but mostly talked about Bill’s recovery. After the meeting ended, the director took Annie aside and told her the company still considered her husband a valuable employee and would continue to support his rehabilitation after he left the hospital. He thanked Annie for all she’d done, and hoped to see them both back on the road before long. Bill had held his emotions in check throughout the meeting, but when Annie told him this afterwards back in his room, they both cried.</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER VII</strong></p><p><strong><em>Spring</em></strong></p><p><strong>Throughout the month of April, the Powells prepared to return home. Bill made further progress and suffered no setbacks. The staff at GMRH was like family now, and over the final week many stopped in, some on their days off, to say goodbye. The couple spent another weekend in the hospital apartment, and this time didn’t use any of the call buttons to ask for assistance. No longer needing the van with hydraulic lift, Bill could now transfer himself from the wheelchair to the passenger seat of a standard sedan. Putting this skill to good use, they celebrated their 27th wedding anniversary by taking temporary leave from the hospital and spending two nights in a nearby hotel, even having dinner in the hotel restaurant. Annie could not have been prouder. Her husband had come a long way from blinking once for no and twice for yes.</strong></p><p><strong>On Saturday, April 26, 1986, 184 days after awakening with the first symptoms of stroke in the middle of the night, William Michael Powell received his formal discharge from Garfield Memorial Rehabilitation Hospital. His team of doctors came by with a dozen red roses, and staff lined the hallway and applauded as Bill and Annie passed through the lobby and headed out the main doors. All three of their boys accompanied them, with the oldest receiving the honor of driving his mom and dad home. Outside, family and friends crowded the sidewalk, carrying flowers, balloons, and posters of congratulations. A caravan would follow Annie and Bill’s car as they left the hospital.</strong></p><p><strong>Spring had come early that year, and the expression on Bill’s face during the drive home was indescribable. He’d only been outside a handful of times over the previous six months, and most of those were in the dead of winter. Now, the passing scenery seemed to celebrate his release along with everyone around him. Soon they entered the outskirts of Cleveland, and as the car passed the marquee of a banquet hall near their home, they saw the illuminated sign reading “WELCOME HOME BILL AND ANNIE.” Another banner with the same words stretched across the front of their house. Friends had stocked the refrigerator, cooked two turkeys, and spread out a buffet in the dining room. Bill only partly succeeded in controlling his emotions. Most of the guests stayed late, and after they left the sons cleaned up and helped their father get ready to sleep in his own bed. When Annie and Bill finally turned in, it was almost midnight, and they slept nearly ten hours.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>In spite of their joy at coming home, the Powells found the first week harder than expected. The house was less than five years old, but the interior seemed small and cramped after the open spaces inside the hospital. Only the living room, dining area, and kitchen had entrances wide enough to make a 90 degree turn with the wheelchair. To enter the other rooms, Bill had to lock the wheels, stand up with the walker, pass through the doorway, and wait for Annie to pivot the empty chair and bring it in behind him. Fortunately, they didn’t have to contend with a second floor, but Bill could only manage the three steps to the front porch with the walker and a helper on each side. Until he regained the ability to navigate stairs on his own, the finished basement would be off limits. The bathroom remained their biggest problem. Duncan had installed the handrails and other accommodations a month earlier, but his father still needed a great deal of help in the shower and on the toilet.</strong></p><p><strong>Nevertheless, the Powells were thankful to be out of the hospital. After a great deal of trial and error, they worked out the routines that allowed Bill to continue making progress. The sons came for longer stays now that their father was home, and relatives from Devon Mills visited frequently. Three times each week the physical therapist made a house call, and during the off days Annie or one of the boys guided Bill through the same sequence of exercises.</strong></p><p><strong>Both elder Powells’ birthdays came in May, and they hosted a single party to mark the occasions together. Annie described in a letter how much this meant to them. Six months earlier, it appeared doubtful that Bill would even have another birthday. Now, as he turned 51, and Annie turned 48, the transition from hospital to home appeared to be working.</strong></p><p><strong>They both grew stronger as the spring gave way to summer. Bill still struggled to hold a book open and turn the pages, but he had no trouble with magazines, and Annie took out or renewed a number of subscriptions. Sitting at the kitchen table, they enjoyed catching up on all they’d missed since the stroke. Annie checked out a stack of audiobooks from the library, and Bill came to appreciate tilting back in his recliner and listening to a book through the headphones. They also discovered the video cassette player, which was still a novelty at the time. Their sons bought one for their birthdays, and Annie and Bill loved watching movies that summer, especially the sci-fi comedy <em>Back to the Future.</em> Having both graduated from high school in the 1950s, the nostalgia in the story held a special meaning for them now. Home computers were in their infancy as well, and the boys gave Bill a Commodore 64, encouraging him to experiment with it and work on his typing skills. In the middle of August they took a daytrip to Devon Mills, where the Maplewood Swim Club held a party in their honor. Bill cried, but so did many others. Events seemed to be proving that they could rise above the stroke.</strong></p><p><strong>In September the whole family gathered for Labor Day. They enjoyed the long weekend together, but the next day Bill appeared to fall ill. He seemed weak and groggy upon waking, and spoke with greater effort than usual. By mid-morning, Annie was on the phone to the hospital. She’d kept in touch with GMRH frequently since returning home, supplementing the therapist’s reports with her own accounts of Bill’s progress. Recently his primary physician had ordered several changes in medication, and Annie thought the downturn might stem from those changes. For the next two weeks, they tried further adjustments to see if Bill’s condition improved. Annie saw a change for the better, but he still appeared unsteady and lethargic compared to a month earlier. He had trouble standing, even with assistance, and had less control of his arms and hands. In mid-September the doctors asked that he return to the hospital for a full evaluation.</strong></p><p><strong>Back in April, the staff had scheduled Bill for a routine follow-up exam at the hospital in October. Both Powells looked forward to this at the time, hoping to show their progress to the doctors and therapists after the summer at home. Now, Annie felt a sense of dread as she arranged for the new appointment a month earlier than planned. She wasn’t sure what to expect. In the best case, the tests would show an imbalance that a change in medication could correct, and Bill would resume making his usual headway. She didn’t want to think about a worse case. Even the remote possibility that her husband might go back to GMRH as an in-patient made her want to cry. The brothers had come home several times after Labor Day, and they could see the changes in Bill that Annie described over the phone. The family continued with the physical therapy, but he seemed to be losing ground. As the appointment drew near, David and Daniel returned to stay with them until further notice. Duncan was away on a project, but he kept in touch by phone every night. His older brothers planned to drive their parents to the hospital the day of the exam and remain with them to learn the results.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>The four Powells arrived at Garfield Memorial on a Monday morning as scheduled. Coming into the lobby, Bill and Annie’s reception looked like a subdued version of their departure five months earlier. Staff gathered to greet them and inquire about their time at home. After filling out paperwork, a nurse showed the couple to an exam room. The doctors planned to conduct a complete physical and administer a battery of tests. Annie stayed in the room with Bill, while the two sons waited in the lobby.</strong></p><p><strong>Forty minutes later she came out, and the bad news showed on her face. The doctors wanted to admit Bill overnight and carry out additional tests. They said it as just a precaution, but to Annie it seemed that her nightmare was coming true. The nurse came to tell them they would have a short wait while the staff prepared Bill’s room. In the meantime, she suggested that Annie accompany the orderlies with her husband to the MRI department. His room would be ready after the technicians completed the scans. To Annie’s relief, she saw they would not be on the same floor as their previous stay.</strong></p><p><strong>After the MRI, they all met in the new room. It contained two beds, but for the moment the second one remained unoccupied. Bill sat in his wheelchair and appeared more animated and aware than he had for several days. He comforted Annie as much as she comforted him, saying that no matter what happened, they never expected any guarantees about the future. Both sons reminded them that they’d only just arrived, and had yet to hear any diagnosis from the doctors. The bedside telephone rang, and Annie answered it to hear Duncan’s voice on the line. David had called him earlier to give an update, and now he joined his brothers in offering encouragement.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill’s dinner arrived on a tray, and he ate while Annie helped with the containers. Later she and the boys took turns visiting the cafeteria. Annie had packed a bag, and she knew the nurses would not object to her staying in the room through the night. The brothers remained past the end of visiting hours and then drove back to their parents’ house. They both planned to return early in the morning.</strong></p><p><strong>Just before noon the next day, the doctors came to Bill’s room for a conference. All four Powells were present. The other bed was still empty, and no one suggested moving to a separate meeting room. The lead physician did most of the talking. He began by saying that they had good news and bad news, and he’d give them the bad news first. The MRI showed that Bill had suffered a second stroke, also in the brain stem but on the opposite side from the first stroke. They wanted to admit him indefinitely and monitor his condition. They were restarting him on the blood thinner and now firmly advised that he take it for the rest of his life. This in itself posed serious risks. If Bill fell on his head and suffered a scalp wound, he would very likely bleed to death. The final decision was up to the Powells, but the doctors felt that the risk of another stroke outweighed the risk of a serious bleeding episode.</strong></p><p><strong>Then came the good news. The second stroke was nowhere near as catastrophic as the first. Bill would restart in-house therapy, but at a level of function much higher than the previous winter. He stood a good chance of recovering what he’d lost and moving on to further gains. In the meantime, the doctors all agreed that he should return to the rehabilitation wing of the hospital while they prepared a detailed treatment plan. They were deeply concerned about this setback, but considering the alternatives, it could have been much worse.</strong></p><p><strong>When the four of them were alone again, Annie sobbed, put her hands to her face, and said, “It’s not fair.” Bill blinked once, reached out to touch her arm, and whispered, “Nobody said life was fair.”</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>He remained in the hospital for almost three months. Annie took up the same daily routine, arriving early and staying late, one son generally alongside while the others took care of the house. The sales director from Haider Coleman paid a visit — alone this time — and made small talk with Bill. He spoke to Annie on the way out and told her the company still stood by her husband, but the first priority was for him to get better before they could make any plans about returning to work. She wrote afterwards that while he appeared genuinely supportive, she didn’t know what he was really thinking. In December, just a few days before Christmas, the doctors released Bill from GMRH once again. He’d made significant progress during the second stay, but did not regain the same level of ability he had in the spring.</strong></p><p><strong>Returning home this time, all the Powells knew what to expect. Even though Bill made gains at a slower rate, he didn’t appear to lose ground, and for that Annie gave thanks. They bought a stationary bicycle, and at first Bill found it difficult to mount and dismount. With help he kept at it, and eventually worked up to a daily schedule of cycling while watching cable TV news. The therapists continued the thrice-weekly visits, and Bill settled into a tolerable routine. Annie described that winter and spring as a series of small victories.</strong></p><p><strong>The brothers were now all in their mid-twenties, and had rearranged their lives in order to help their mother and father. David, the oldest, switched from sales to quality control and welcomed the opportunity to spend more time at home. He and his wife Julie had a young son and another child on the way. The middle son Daniel had moved to the east side of Cleveland in order to live near his parents, taking a job teaching high school history in a nearby district. Duncan, the youngest, found plenty of work as a construction contractor, keeping up his business and still finding time to complete home repairs for his mom and dad. Like his middle brother, he was still single. All three now lived within a short drive of their parents’ house. The bulk of the effort to support Bill still fell on Annie, but her sons made every effort to help. Their mother said repeatedly in her letters how she couldn’t have managed without the boys.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Toward the end of the January 1987, Annie received a phone call from Bill’s boss. He said the company would be sending them a package in few days and he wanted to give Annie a heads-up before it went out. Unfortunately, Haider Coleman decided that the likelihood of her husband returning to work was very small, and the time had come for Bill and the company to part ways. They would continue to pay his full salary and insurance through December, and arrange for other insurance to begin the following year. The package would contain all the necessary paperwork as well as letters from colleagues and clients. Considering Bill’s emotional control, they felt that this was the least traumatic way to break the news. If Annie preferred a face-to-face meeting with anyone in the company, he would arrange it at the Powells’ convenience. They were all terribly sorry about what happened to Bill, but knew they must stay realistic in making long-term business plans. He told her to call any time with questions or concerns.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie had seen this coming, but it still hit her hard. The financial anxiety was bad enough, but she felt greater concern over what it would do to Bill’s confidence. He desperately wanted to return to work, and refused to admit that the second stroke made that a distant dream. He knew he wasn’t up to meeting clients in his present state, but kept up hope that eventually he’d walk with just a cane and could travel again as a sales representative. No one had contradicted this scenario. Annie waited for the notice to arrive in the mail and thought a great deal about what she would say.</strong></p><p><strong>The news did bring Bill to tears, although he took it more calmly than she expected. Annie guessed that deep down he might have realized how much he’d lost. Bill welcomed her suggestion that they had almost a full year of pay coming and could still work toward the skills that might eventually lead to re-employment. That became their motivation, even as the brothers talked among themselves about how unlikely it appeared their father would ever work again.</strong></p><p><strong>With the coming of spring, the Powells made a concerted effort to get out of the house more often. Duncan built a porch ramp for the wheelchair and a portable stair-step that made it easier for Bill to use the van, which the company had allowed them to keep. They took advantage of it frequently, even though any outing involved a great deal of preparation. The Cleveland area (what the locals call the North Coast) is home to a score of lovely municipal parks, and they visited many of them over the spring and summer. Annie kept in close touch with her sister in Akron and her parents in Devon Mills, and the whole family took several day trips to both places. Her mother and father, both now in their late seventies, still lived in the house where Annie had grown up.</strong></p><p><strong>Driving around their hometown gave all the Powells a shock. Stores and restaurants they’d taken for granted in their youth were now closed, and the steel mills were operating at reduced capacity or shut down altogether. Bill’s brother, along with many other ex-factory workers, had left for Texas the previous winter in the hope of finding work. Abandoned houses, with sheets of plywood nailed over the window frames — unknown twenty years earlier — were spreading from the downtown area outward into the suburbs. During the previous presidential campaign, Walter Mondale had used the phrase “Rust Bowl” during a debate, and it caught on and soon became “Rust Belt.” Local residents hated the expression, but driving through Devon Mills, one could see why an outsider would judge the label accurate.</strong></p><p><strong>Over the summer Annie arranged to sell the cottage on Lake Erie. Although the boys had used it several times, the elder Powells hadn’t been there since before the first stroke. They received a good price when it sold, but the money went immediately toward hospital bills and living expenses. Even with comprehensive insurance, their financial picture remained bleak. Bill continued to make limited progress, but he was in no shape to return to any kind of work. They’d reached a plateau, and, as one of the boys overheard Annie say on the phone, they weren’t happy, but they weren’t exactly unhappy, either. Money was a problem, but the situation could have been much worse. Given no further setbacks, it seemed they could continue their present level of daily function indefinitely. October would mark two years since the first stroke. Her husband was disabled for life, but his memories and sense of humor remained intact. She wrote in a letter they felt more in love that year than at any other time in their lives. But the year was drawing to a close, and when it ended Bill would have no income. Reluctantly, as the last leaves came down from the trees, Annie started looking for a job.</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER VIII</strong></p><p><strong><em>Autumn Again</em></strong></p><p><strong>She sent out a half-dozen resumes. Searching for part-time secretarial work, Annie heard back from most of the recipients by the first week of November and arranged three interviews. The first position was in a dentist’s office, the second in a college student union, and the third at the corporate headquarters of a local hotel chain. She completed the first two interviews and came away with a favorable impression of the college. The third interview would not take place for several days, and in the meantime she continued with Bill’s routine at home.</strong></p><p><strong>On the Friday before Thanksgiving, Annie and Bill rose at their usual hour. Finishing breakfast in the kitchen, they returned to the bedroom for a session of physical therapy. They were alone in the house. The therapist was not due in that day, and Annie didn’t expect any of the boys until later in the afternoon.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill lay on his back, stretched out on the bedcover while Annie helped him work through the list of exercises. The first of these required her to help lift one of Bill’s knees to his chest, and then place the palm of her hand across the sole of his elevated foot. With his leg sharply bent, Bill pushed back against the resistance Annie offered as he worked to straighten the leg.</strong></p><p><strong>They completed a set of five repetitions on each leg and started on a second set. Performing this basic activity thousands of times over the previous two years, neither had any premonition that this day would turn out differently. Annie described what happened next in a letter written a month later:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>Bill and I were doing PT in the bedroom. He said he felt dizzy, and then a few seconds later passed out. I was trying to arouse him when I noticed a dark stain spreading on his clothes around the waistline. I pulled down his pants and saw gushes of blood coming from his rectum . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>I called the ambulance, and by the time they arrived, he had no pulse, and no blood pressure. I rode in the back with the paramedics on the way to the hospital. Bill was unconscious the whole time, and I thought he was gone.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>In the ER they found he was bleeding from multiple areas in the colon. They said it was especially dangerous because his blood was so thin from the anticoagulants. He received in excess of 100 units of blood and had surgery to remove the colon. The next day, he had surgery again — this time, they said, to remove the spleen . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>I almost didn’t sign the permission papers. I thought, “How much does he have to endure?” But I did sign for him to have surgery again. I felt then — and still feel — that those are God’s decisions.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The second surgery ended up being just exploratory — they didn’t remove the spleen. They packed his abdomen, and after a long time controlled the bleeding.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The surgeon rerouted the path of his lower digestive tract during the first surgery to make up for the loss of the colon. Because of this, Bill won’t have to wear an external ‘bag’ — and will have somewhat normal bowel movements, although he’ll have to be really careful about what he eats . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The doctors are evaluating his medications. They want to minimize the risk of further bleeding but still provide some protection against another stoke caused by a blood clot. They told me that — given his medical history — Bill only had a small chance of surviving longer than twelve months.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>The trip to the emergency room and the colectomy took place at the local hospital near the Powell home. After a month as an in-patient there, Bill transferred back to GMRH for the third and final time. Annie and the boys spent Christmas and the New Year with him at Garfield. Bill had stabilized, but with his level of ability now far below what he could manage during his earlier stays.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie came daily at first, but soon her schedule changed. During the last week of December, she returned to the college for a second interview. Bowman Sanger was a small four-year school located in the eastern suburbs of Cleveland, just a ten-minute drive from their house. The interview went well and resulted in a formal job offer, which Annie decided to accept. She talked it over first with Bill and then the rest of the family, and everyone thought it a good idea and promised their support.</strong></p><p><strong>The student union sat right in the center of campus, and she would work alongside several other secretaries in the union offices. Her duties consisted of coordinating extracurricular events and resolving resident life issues for students and staff. They wanted her to start at three days weekly, from noon until four, and if that went well she’d have the option of later expanding to five weekday afternoons. During the interviews Annie explained her circumstances at home, and the human resources department seemed supportive and willing to work with her in putting together a practical schedule.</strong></p><p><strong>In mid-January 1988, Annie started work, and after two weeks of chaos began to find her way around the office. She loved earning a paycheck again, and solving problems far removed from hospitals and health care. Several college students also worked part-time in the office, and one of them started calling her “Mom Number Two.” The nickname stuck, and Annie enjoyed hearing about their lives and giving advice when they asked for it, which they did increasingly often. With Bill in the hospital, she didn’t have to worry about him needing help. She knew his discharge was coming, and soon enough she’d have plenty to worry about, but in the meantime she appreciated working again.</strong></p><p><strong>Bill saw his wife throughout the winter, usually several times every week. He regained a measure of function after the bleeding, but now Annie felt he was just going through the motions with therapy. His personality had changed, and he had less energy and seemed more irritable. In April the doctors asked to see Annie alone, and told her that soon Bill would reach his capacity and the hospital could do nothing more for him. The insurance would not cover the stay unless he displayed measurable progress, and they felt that his ability to make progress was nearing an end. The doctors and staff showed great compassion to Annie; they’d known the Powells now for over three years and thought of them almost like family. Nevertheless, they echoed the ER doctors in the local hospital by cautioning her to prepare for another medical crisis, saying that Bill would likely pass away within the year.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie had switched to five days weekly at Bowman Sanger in April, but now she took off three weeks altogether when her husband came home again in May. They picked up where they’d left off, with fewer resources and with Bill’s abilities greatly diminished. The therapists no longer visited, although the family kept up with the same exercises. Bill maintained no illusions now about returning to work, but he was determined to show he could still stay alone for short periods. If he couldn’t work, he sure wasn’t going to let himself stop Annie from working. He could see that she loved the job at the college and wanted her to continue. Staying alone in the house became a personal point of pride.</strong></p><p><strong>The family worked to make his goal a reality. They purchased a wearable call button that would auto-dial a monitoring service as well as several phone numbers. Rearranging the living room, they put the TV closer to the bath and made a kind of nook for his solo time with tissues, cordless phone, TV remote, water, and bathroom supplies. Bill would sit in his wheelchair with the walker in front of him, and could manage a number one restroom break by standing up with a urinal. A number two break required a trip to the bathroom, and although he always made an honest effort on all the required steps, Annie or one of the boys usually cleaned up after him. Fortunately, the chance of needing a number two break during the time alone was minimal. Bill worked toward doing as much as possible on his own, even with family present, and insisted on several trial runs staying in the house by himself.</strong></p><p><strong>At the end of three weeks, Annie returned to work, soon moving back to five days again. When the school year ended in June, the middle son moved into his parents’ house for the summer, and remained there in the fall after arranging a job share at the high school that allowed him to have the afternoons free. This dovetailed well with Annie’s schedule, and all the brothers pitched in as before. David’s wife Julie put great effort into helping her mother-in-law, and Annie’s sister came more often now that Annie was back to work. Her parents and the other sons’ girlfriends rounded out the list of usual visitors, and although Bill could stay alone for several hours as needed, there was usually someone else at home.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Annie continued her letters, but they became more sporadic. By Christmas 1988, the health catastrophe predicted by the surgeon the previous year had not arrived, but dread of it was never far away. Worse, the bleeding changed Bill’s personality, which she described in a letter to her sister:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>He came home on May 3rd . . . so much (and so little) has happened since then. Bill is currently doing okay. He continued to improve for several months, after arriving home, but nothing much has happened since then. When I say improve, I mean mentally, not physically. I don’t think he is as good, physically, as when we left.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>He now suffers from “global neurological deficiency,” which was caused from lack of oxygen to the brain. So, now he is still Bill, but not really. I think he’s only vaguely aware of the fact that he isn’t the same, and for that I’m grateful . . .</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Most of the time he can’t remember how old he is, or what year it is, although occasionally he does know. Some days are better than others, both mentally and physically, and he’s happy to be home.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>He doesn’t read any more. I think he has trouble remembering from one paragraph to the next. That makes me want to cry — he was always such a reader. Now that’s gone and he doesn’t know it. He reminds me in some ways of a very loving, obedient child.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>As for me, the last three years have been a bit like watching someone die slowly, in bits and pieces. I don’t have it in me to tell you the anguish of it all. My heart is breaking every day.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Little changed in the New Year. Bill worked hard to maintain his abilities, while Annie continued at the college. Later she sent out another update:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>The major issue is the loss of short-term memory. He can remember anything and everything, up to the bleeding, but forgets most of what has happened since. I can tell him daily things, and sometimes he remembers, but mostly, not. He is extremely emotional — crying frequently, and over the littlest thing. He is like a child, but not the least bit nasty.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>He depends upon me for just about everything — he can do very little on his own, except he can feed himself (sort of messily). It’s hard to take him anywhere. He’s nowhere near what he was before the bleeding.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Last spring the doctors told me he had six months to a year, they thought, before he had another problem, or passed away. That was 14 months ago now, and he is still doing okay — not good, but not terrible, either. At least he is not in any pain — although to do anything is extremely difficult for him (for me, too.)</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Annie wrote that in the summer of 1989, and their circumstances remained unchanged through the fall. They lived in the gray twilight of their earlier optimism. Since the first stroke in 1985, bad news always seemed to come in the autumn. As the final Christmas of the 1980s drew near, the Powells hunkered down and hoped just to hold on to what they had.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>December 7th, Pearl Harbor Day, fell on a Thursday that year. The late afternoon saw a dusting of snow across Cleveland’s eastern suburbs, with the sun setting shortly before five p.m. The middle son sat in the living room at his parents’ house, watching a TV program with his father about the anniversary of the Japanese attack. The lights in the room were turned down to highlight the glow from the Christmas tree. Annie had arrived home a few minutes earlier, and father and son heard the sound of the answering machine as she checked messages in the kitchen.</strong></p><p><strong>Following her usual routine, Annie came back into the living room to sit on the couch and return calls. She put a writing pad with phone numbers on the end table next to the telephone. The son turned down the TV volume as she dialed the first number and exchanged greetings with the person who answered. Annie sat leaning forward on the edge of the couch, her left hand holding the phone to her ear and her right hand idly twirling her eyeglasses.</strong></p><p><strong>The twirling stopped. Something in her manner caught the attention of the son but not the father. Annie dropped her glasses silently on the carpet and looked down between her feet as she listened.</strong></p><p><strong>“Let me call you right back,” she said, and hung up.</strong></p><p><strong>“What’s going on?” the son asked.</strong></p><p><strong>“Nothing,” she said. “I need some papers on my desk for this call. Just a sec.”</strong></p><p><strong>Shortly afterwards, the son heard the muffled voice of his mother talking on the bedroom extension. Then came a period of silence, followed by Annie’s return to the living room.</strong></p><p><strong>“Turn off the TV, honey,” she said to her son. “I have to talk to you both.”</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>She’d been having headaches, but thought they were related to stress and didn’t want to say anything. Eventually Annie made an appointment — without telling anyone — to have the headaches checked out. The phone call on December 7 was from her doctor about the results of his examination, and he gave her the worst possible news: the symptoms came from a brain tumor, still in its early stages. She learned later it was an extremely aggressive form of glioblastoma, and the prognosis was virtually hopeless. The news devastated the whole family, especially Bill, and no one could make sense of it. On one hand, Annie’s illness may have been another random tragedy occurring alongside all that happened over the last four years. On the other, it may have stemmed from the repeated emotional whiplash she’d endured throughout Bill’s ongoing medical crises. The brothers thought the latter possibility more likely, but agreed never to say so, because it seemed to put the blame on their father.</strong></p><p><strong>Her doctor referred her to a cancer specialist in downtown Cleveland. She had surgery the first week of January and remained an in-patient undergoing chemotherapy until the middle of March. Bill was unable to visit her during that time, but those who did were stunned at how much she’d changed. The operation grossly distorted her personality, much more than the changes Bill had experienced. The doctor warned them that the size and location of the tumor made this inevitable, but hearing it calmly described in his office before surgery was far different from meeting the stranger afterwards who had somehow replaced their mother. She was erratic, obstinate, and suspicious by turns, all traits far removed from her former self. The sons saw immediately that their mother could not return to work, but she insisted on making a heartbreaking phone call to the college to inquire about her job. The supervisor gently told her they knew she wasn’t up to working just yet, but they’d keep the position open for whenever she felt ready. Her coworkers hoped this tender white lie might help Annie cope, but her family feared she was already gone.</strong></p><p><strong>The brothers all moved into their parents’ house and shouldered the full responsibility for both parents’ care. They also took over the accounts Annie had been keeping, and realized how much she’d accomplished with so few resources. In addition to the balances outstanding from Bill’s previous care, the charges began to arrive now for Annie’s hospitalization. Their financial situation was unsustainable, and the sons began to talk about selling the house.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie came home for six weeks in March and April, but soon tests showed that the tumor had recurred, and she underwent surgery again in May. Her sister Rebecca had been a constant visitor, but after the second operation she insisted that Annie come home with her to Akron. Knowing how much care Bill required, she wanted to give her nephews the space to look after him without having to care for their mother as well. She also knew that despite the profound changes in Annie’s personality, she would still refuse to put her own needs before those of her husband.</strong></p><p><strong>The house in Akron was a 40-minute drive from the Powell home, and the brothers visited there frequently over the summer of 1990. Their aunt and uncle made a heroic effort to help their mother, paying for in-home health aides out of their own pocket and rearranging their lives around her needs. David’s wife Julie constantly shuttled back and forth between Cleveland and Akron, and although the other brothers’ girlfriends also contributed, Julie became the fourth sibling. Annie and Bill spoke on the phone daily at first, despite the fact that the calls caused stress on both sides. The brothers felt compelled to bring Bill to Akron in July, but the emotional trauma that came from it convinced them to postpone a second visit. Their father did not ask to return, and they kept him informed at home with daily updates of Annie’s condition. Their mother continued to deteriorate, and her questions about Bill and requests to call home became less frequent.</strong></p><p><strong>Annie became bedridden in October, and by Thanksgiving her sister and brother-in-law could no longer care for her. She entered a nursing home under the supervision of hospice the following month. After a great deal of discussion within the family, Bill became a resident of the same nursing home, sharing a room with his wife. He wanted to be with Annie over her final days, but she had declined to the point where she was rarely aware of his presence. Although they were together again, both their conditions continued to worsen through the first months of 1991. The sons sold the house to pay medical expenses. Annie lingered on through the spring, and then died in early June. She was 53 years old, and had been unconscious the last two weeks of her life.</strong></p><p><strong>After the funeral, the family arranged for Bill to leave the nursing home and move in temporarily with David and Julie. They planned for him to live with each son in turn while deciding what to do over the long term. During the process of applying for Medicaid, Bill came down with a severe respiratory infection. In early October 1991 he entered the hospital, and three weeks later he died. The doctors listed pneumonia as the cause of death. He was 56 years old.</strong></p><p>End of Part One</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>PART TWO</em></strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER IX</strong></p><p><strong><em>Retrospect</em></strong></p><p><strong>More than thirty years have passed since my parents died. I keep in touch with David and Duncan, although much less now than in the aftermath of my father’s stroke. They both moved away years ago, but I still live in a suburb of Cleveland on the North Coast. All three of us are grandparents now.</strong></p><p><strong>My own maternal grandparents died in the 1990s, but Aunt Rebecca is still alive. Last year my wife and I visited Devon Mills with her and drove around the old neighborhoods. The house where she and my mother grew up remains standing, as does the house with the rope. Both places look old and ragged, and the rest of the town looks even worse. I wouldn’t ride a bicycle now in broad daylight on some of the streets I traveled nightly as a kid.</strong></p><p><strong>Although the population of Devon Mills has fallen by a third, membership at the church has grown. During our visit we stopped there to have a look around. The board of elders voted to have the original building renovated and expanded several times over the years, and I hardly recognized the place. Sometimes my mom came back and attended services during my dad’s illness, and the whole congregation knew our family history and prayed for us regularly. Annie may not have agreed on every point of doctrine with every church member, but I know the prayers were sincere.</strong></p><p><strong>I’ve tried to reconcile my experiences as an adult with my memories of growing up in that church. Our Sunday school teachers always said that suffering was God’s will, and to ask why it happened was futile. As a teenager I might have agreed, but in my teens I hardly thought about stroke and cancer beyond a vague awareness of their dictionary definitions. Looking back now, I question whether what happened was God’s will.</strong></p><p><strong>I’m writing this book for three reasons. First, I want to preserve my parents’ story for our children and grandchildren; second, I need to make clear in my own mind where I stand; and third, I hope these pages might prove useful to others.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>If a visitor to the church in Devon Mills were to ask for a written summary of the beliefs of its members, it might look like this:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>God created the universe as described in the Book of Genesis. The purpose of the universe was to set the stage for humanity. The purpose of humanity was to provide fellowship for God. Adam and Eve spoiled this perfect covenant by their disobedience in the Garden of Eden. God cursed Adam, Eve, and all their descendants with pain and misery as punishment for this disobedience. He did not cause the suffering Himself, but allowed Satan to inflict the suffering instead. However, He also provided a means to renew the original covenant through the sacrifice of his Son. Those who accept this sacrifice receive their reward after death in Heaven. Those who reject the sacrifice receive punishment after death in Hell. All of this is described in the Holy Scriptures, every word of which is eternally true.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>I can’t speak for other churches, or even speak for any member of the Devon Mills congregation, but I think the majority of Christians would agree with this summary.</strong></p><p><strong>As a kid I accepted this creed without thinking much about it. My brothers and I attended church regularly as boys, and stories from the Bible were as much a part of growing up as Bugs Bunny, Santa Claus, and Dr. Seuss. Our grandparents gave us a multi-volume set of Arthur Maxwell’s <em>The Bible Story,</em> an illustrated digest of the Old and New Testament for children. The first volume contained a picture of sinners pounding on the closed door of Noah’s Ark as the floodwaters rose around them. Even in kindergarten, I remember thinking that the panic on their faces didn’t fit with idea that God loves all his children, a phrase I heard repeatedly in Sunday school. Nevertheless, our teachers inspired us with their retellings of parts of the Bible, especially when it came to the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus. They — both the teachers and the stories — assured us that the universe made sense.</strong></p><p><strong>About the age of ten or so the lessons became more involved. I remember hearing about the <em>Book of Job</em> around this time, which seemed to fit with the rest of the narratives. God allowed Satan to test a devout, prosperous believer with extreme adversity, this believer retained his faith throughout the ordeal, and God rewarded his loyalty by granting even greater prosperity after the trial ended. We were only kids, and it never occurred to us to question the premise behind the test. No one would have dreamed of suggesting that it seemed a lot like two delinquent teenagers torturing a puppy and betting on the outcome. We just filed it away with the other stories. I know my mother read and re-read that part of the Bible during the last years of her life. Her nightmare seemed much like Job’s trial, except for the happy ending.</strong></p><p><strong>Our Sunday school teachers rarely mentioned Judaism or Islam, and never once brought up Hindus or Buddhists. The Pope, however, was another matter. I had a good friend who happened to attend a Catholic church, and sometimes we talked about the differences between Protestants and Catholics in Devon Mills, and wondered why there seemed to be so much bad blood between them. I asked my father about this, and after giving me a brief account of Martin Luther’s life, he suggested I compare different encyclopedia articles describing the Protestant Reformation. I read about the Catholic-Protestant schism, the earlier Orthodox-Catholic schism, and how the Protestants had further fragmented into dozens of different branches in the centuries after Luther. Rather than working toward a universal kinship, the community of Christians seemed to be forever breaking apart and turning their backs on each other.</strong></p><p><strong>As I left high school behind, each point in the earlier summary of church doctrine seemed more uncertain. I’ve already mentioned how <em>Inherit the Wind</em> prompted talk around our dinner table. The teachers at Sunday school assured us that a close reading of the Bible would answer our questions and strengthen our beliefs, but I found such readings to have the opposite effect. It went beyond discrepancies like God creating day and night before creating the Sun, or Cain finding a wife when his parents were the only other people on Earth. Instead, I began to question the foundation of the whole faith.</strong></p><p><strong>Why was God so vindictive? Why did he punish everyone for the disobedience of two people? He cursed all mankind with suffering for the sin of tasting forbidden fruit. He required a human sacrifice as additional payment for the consequences of same offense. He forced his own son to serve as the sacrifice he could have revoked. He sentenced most of humanity to the eternal fires of hell for not acknowledging the wisdom of his actions. Why? Couldn’t he have avoided it all by putting the Tree of Knowledge outside the Garden of Eden, or by not creating the Tree in the first place?</strong></p><p><strong>The more I thought about it, the more it seemed that Adam and Eve were less responsible for their downfall than the game was rigged from the start. They were set up to fail. An impartial observer could argue that God — at least according to Christianity — was a sadist, and suffering the whole point of creation.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Forty years later, I don’t see it that way. I haven’t rejected the religion of my childhood so much as put it in the context of the wider world. Christianity stands as a single exhibit in a vast museum of past and present beliefs. Our teachers insisted that we were right and everyone else was wrong, but I know now that teachers of other faiths make the same claim. If I were born in India, I’d have grown up learning why Hinduism is the one true religion, and all the others mistaken.</strong></p><p><strong>I still find it worthwhile to read the Bible, but now approach it the same way I’d approach a reading of Homer or Shakespeare. The Old and New Testaments are valuable windows into the past, but I no longer consider them divinely inspired. I think the authors were highly fallible human beings, struggling to explain where we came from and why we’re here, and those questions are older than any organized religion. The world contains Christianity, not the reverse.</strong></p><p><strong>The world also contains nonbelief, which I don’t remember our Sunday school teachers ever mentioning. As a counterweight to the claims of the church, I put together my own summary of atheist principles:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>There is no God. Human beings fabricated the concept of gods in prehistory, and any deity exists only in the imagination. Life arose from strictly physical elements, shaped solely by the blind forces of nature. The soul and the afterlife are, like God, only instances of wishful thinking. All consciousness permanently ends when the brain ceases to function. The human race could become extinct at any time from a multitude of causes, and its disappearance would have no effect on the ultimate course of the universe.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>I could say I believe or disbelieve these claims, but “believe” is not right word. To believe means to accept an idea as beyond dispute, and I wouldn’t say that every point in this summary is beyond dispute. Other ideas, not necessarily related to religion, do qualify as indisputable.</strong></p><p><strong>I accept, for example, that the Earth is round rather than flat, mostly because I’ve seen pictures of it from space. Still, as an exercise in critical thinking, I could consider the possibility that those pictures might not be real. A global conspiracy might exist to cover up the knowledge that the Earth is actually flat. After all, most of the information I have about the shape of the Earth is secondhand. Parents, teachers, globes, textbooks, and photographs have assured me since childhood that the Earth is round, but then again I’ve never personally looked down on the Earth from space. There exists, in principle anyway, some room for doubt.</strong></p><p><strong>Nevertheless, I accept that the Earth is round for several reasons. I can see for myself the curve of the Earth’s shadow during a lunar eclipse. I’ve seen departing ships disappear over the horizon, with the hull vanishing first and the tip of the mast vanishing last. I’ve experienced firsthand that sunrise and sunset occur at different times in different locations. These observations, and others like them, support a spherical Earth.</strong></p><p><strong>Secondly, I accept the Earth is round because the arguments against it are extremely weak. Those who maintain the Earth is flat ignore the kind of confirmations in the previous paragraph and offer alternative “proof” in its place, such as turning a capped bottle half-full of water on its side and claiming the water level inside shows a perfectly flat plane rather than a curved surface. Actually, the water inside the bottle <em>does </em>curve, but the curve is imperceptible to the eye at such a small scale. Precise measurements will prove it. This demonstration stands as a prime example of pseudoscience: the claimant starts with a predetermined point of view, and then shops around for some basis to justify that view, while ignoring all evidence to the contrary.</strong></p><p><strong>Finally, in order to accept a flat Earth, I have to concede that these few eccentrics are in the right, while all the astronomers, astronauts, airline pilots, sailors, and engineers who say otherwise are not only wrong, but also part of a conspiracy to deceive the public. On the contrary, I believe — or rather, I accept as virtually certain — that the Earth is round. I would call that a conclusion beyond any reasonable doubt.</strong></p><p><strong>Other issues are not so clear-cut. Are human beings, for instance, alone in the universe, or does intelligence exist somewhere beyond the Earth? That stands as a simple yes or no question, and so far the jury is still out. Good arguments exist on both sides. Given the current evidence, I can say I <em>hope</em> intelligent life exists elsewhere, or I <em>think</em> the evidence suggests we may not be alone, but I would never say I <em>believe</em> it one way or the other. I simply don’t know, and will probably never know.</strong></p><p><strong>I hold a similar ambiguity regarding the existence of God. I don’t consider the atheist view as the final word, and I have varying degrees of doubt about some of its assertions. But I have to keep in mind that it <em>may</em> be true — perhaps is even likely the truth. The evidence for the atheist model outweighs the evidence for the model offered by the Devon Mills congregation. The former rests on rational experience, while the latter rests on dubious claims of religious revelation. On the other hand, skepticism about established religion does not mean an unqualified embrace of atheism. As I see it, whether or not an organizing intelligence had anything to do with the origin of the universe is an open question, similar to the questions about extraterrestrial life.</strong></p><p><strong>Atheism seems bleak but straightforward. It eliminates the compulsion to search for significance in the kind of suffering my parents endured. From a strictly physical standpoint, the “why” behind a stroke doesn’t go beyond physical causes: diet, blood chemistry, genetic predisposition, and similar factors. Grieving loved ones have no need to agonize over how God could have prevented such torment but chose to let it happen instead. A clogged artery leading to a stroke is no more an enigma than a clogged pipe under a kitchen sink.</strong></p><p><strong>Atheists may be right, but I don’t think the issue is settled to the same degree the dispute over the shape of the Earth is settled. The classic proofs for God’s existence are debatable, and I want to consider several of them in the following chapter. I’ve included a list of sources relevant to the second part of this work at the back of the book. Some of what I’ll say in the remaining pages refers to those authors and their ideas. Readers curious about a specific passage can check the <em>Notes </em>appearing after Chapter 12.</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER X (Abstract)</strong></p><p><strong><em>Claims</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>For the remainder of the book I’ve posted an abstract for Chapter 10 and selected excerpts from Chapters 11 &amp; 12. I still have hopes of finding a traditional publisher, and don’t yet want to make the entire manuscript available online. I will send the full text of the last three chapters to any reader upon request.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Powell acknowledges the long list of arguments for God’s existence, and narrows his evaluation to what he considers the two most persuasive claims. He starts with the cosmological argument, sometimes called the argument from creation, and speculates to what extent the scientific models of a Big Bang and a multiverse are relevant to the idea of creation. He moves on to the question of design in nature, and evaluates the impact of Darwin and the evidence for a chemical origin of life. Although both the creation and design arguments maintain that a reasonable person can deduce God from evidence in the natural world, he finds his survey inconclusive, neither proving nor disproving a deity. In his view, the issue is still an open question. <em>(5765 words; seven subheadings).</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>* Introduction: The Existence of God</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>1. The Argument from Creation</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>2. A Possible Multiverse</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>3. The Argument from Design</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>4. Darwin</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>5. Abiogenesis</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>6. Fine-Tuning</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>7. Personal Conclusions</em></strong></p><p><strong>Excerpts from</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER XI</strong></p><p><strong><em>Prospects</em></strong></p><p><strong>When I was in high school, my father told me a story about Napoleon Bonaparte. According to his account, in the early 1800s Napoleon granted an audience to a man named Pierre-Simon de Laplace, a famous French scientist and mathematician. Laplace had just published his book <em>Celestial Mechanics</em>, which included a survey of the movements of the planets and a hypothetical model of the origin of the Solar System. Napoleon congratulated Laplace on the work, remarking on the fact that never once had the author mentioned the Creator. “Your Majesty,” Laplace was supposed to have replied, “I have no need of that hypothesis.”</strong></p><p><strong>Although I came across that story again many times as an adult, I heard it first from my father, and only later learned that it may be apocryphal. Nevertheless, the idea behind it has become a keystone of science in the two centuries since Laplace. Carl Sagan once made a similar observation in the 1970s. “The universe,” he said, “doesn’t exclude a god, but it doesn’t require one either.” In other words, existence appears wholly self-sufficient. All events have their roots in natural causes, and we have no credible evidence for the supernatural. By accepting this idea, I concede several points from the summary of atheist principles in Chapter 9.</strong></p><p><strong>Skeptics of science reject this viewpoint as narrow-minded materialism, saying it dismisses any possibility of spirit, soul, or intuition. The term <em>materialism</em> is somewhat misleading — it excludes non-material realities such as time, space, and energy — but I think I know what they mean. Although <em>physicalism</em> might be a better word, I’ll stick with materialism when referring to the idea that only the physical is real, and that any claim for phenomena outside the realm of physics is wishful thinking. At first glance, this appears to rule out intangibles such as honesty or friendship, which clearly do exist, but a materialist would argue that those experiences, and others like them, also lie wholly in the physical world. Thoughts, emotions, and codes of conduct come from fluctuating patterns of neurochemistry and electrical connections in the brain, and as powerful as those states might seem subjectively, they are ultimately grounded in physics. To a materialist, the mind exists solely as the function of the brain.</strong></p><p><strong>I can’t be certain that this is true, but the evidence seems to point in that direction. Does accepting materialism rule out any kind of deity? The congregation at Devon Mills would say it does, but I’m not so sure. Strict materialism does contest the Christian view of God, but my motive here is not to disparage Christianity. Instead, I want to consider the possibility of a purpose to existence that is consistent with science and a self-contained universe.</strong></p><p><strong>The reader might think that I’m only desperately casting about for some way to reconcile my religious upbringing with the fate of my parents. That could very well be the case; I can hardly be objective about a subject so central to my own experience. This whole book could come out of a bias brought on by childhood conditioning, and the chance of overcoming that bias now is virtually nil.</strong></p><p><strong>On the other hand, almost everyone wonders where we came from, why we’re here, and where we might be going. Those are fair questions, and they transcend any particular individual. I think few would <em>prefer</em> that our existence is essentially pointless. I’m pretty sure I don’t know the meaning of life, so why jump to a conclusion now? On this topic anyway, certainty is an illusion of childhood, and tolerance for ambiguity a mark of experience. For the moment I’ll reserve judgment, but in the meantime, I want to speculate on the plausibility of optimism.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong><em>1. Agnosticism</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>2. Omnipotence</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>3. Time</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>4. Numbers *</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>5. Hierarchy *</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>6. Laboratory *</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>7. Composition *</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>8. Obscurity</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>9. Beauty</em></strong></p><p>* not included in this posting</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>1. Agnosticism</em></strong></p><p><strong>In <em>The God Delusion</em>, Richard Dawkins’ 2006 bestseller about religion, the author includes a seven-point scale, from theism to atheism, describing his view of the spectrum of religious belief. The label for the first point reads: <em>“Strong theist. 100 per cent probability of God. In the words of C.G. Jung, ‘I do not believe, I </em>know<em>.’”</em> The seventh point reads: “<em>Strong atheist. I know there is no God, with the same conviction that Jung ‘knows’ there is one.”</em> Between points one and seven, the labels show a steadily decreasing percentage of probability for belief in God’s existence, with the middle point reading: <em>“Exactly 50 percent. Completely impartial agnostic. God’s existence and non-existence are exactly equiprobable.”</em></strong></p><p><strong>I can understand the attempt to rank the strength of belief, but I wonder if quantifying it with percentages is the right approach. I really don’t find myself anywhere on this scale. Given a choice of the labels <em>theist</em>, <em>agnostic</em>, or <em>atheist</em>, I would take the middle option, but I’d never say that God’s existence and non-existence are exactly equiprobable. The particulars of belief or disbelief depend on many factors. I can rank a movie or a restaurant on a number scale, but not complex subjects like people, relationships, or deliberations about religion. If I had to grade my own religious perspective, I’d rate the probability of God’s existence lower on an intellectual basis, but higher on an emotional basis. Most atheists would say emotions only cloud the issue, but I wonder about that.</strong></p><p><strong>Dawkins does qualify his view on agnosticism by dividing it into temporary and permanent camps, and I agree with him that the former makes more sense than the latter. Temporary agnostics hold that we cannot presently demonstrate God’s existence, but new information might lead to a different conclusion in the future. Permanent agnostics maintain that the question of God’s existence will forever remain outside the bounds of human knowledge. I’m not sure about the rationale for the latter claim. Does it mean that God exists, but will never reveal himself? Or does it mean that atheism can be disproven, but theism cannot? Don’t theists and atheists both look at an incomplete picture and jump to a conclusion? For now, I count myself on the side of the temporary agnostics. No one has absolute proof, so admitting I don’t know at the present time seems the most honest stance.</strong></p><p><strong>There’s a kind of freedom in ignorance, and casting off the hobbles of convention can open up all sorts of possibilities. Theists hold that religious belief has a direct connection to the afterlife, but to an agnostic that may not necessarily follow. All the traditional associations are up for grabs. God may exist, but there may be no afterlife. Or there may be no God, but consciousness somehow endures after death. Or God may be an interested spectator of humanity, but have no control over the course of events. Or he may have an abiding hatred for the human race, dispensing just a few tantalizing hints of goodwill in order to foster a false hope. Or there may be many gods, all of them active, but none having any concern for the aberration called life. Anything is possible, including the notion that God exists exactly as my Sunday school teachers described him, and the Christian Bible, despite its contradictions, is truly the revealed word of God. In my opinion, that final scenario seems the least likely of all.</strong></p><p><strong>Another scenario is that the hardcore atheists are right. Theologians and philosophers put a great deal of effort into contemplating why we’re here, but there may not even be a why. In spite of that distinct possibility, I would not concede to live life on the assumption that God (or something like God) does not exist. The prospect that the universe has a purpose, or that death might not be the end, changes one’s point of view, and has value in itself. To repeat: I don’t know, so why assume the worst?</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>2. Omnipotence</em></strong></p><p><strong>“If God can do anything,” the comedian George Carlin once said, “can he make a rock so big that he himself can’t lift it?” Our Sunday school teachers told us repeatedly that God is all-knowing, all-powerful, and present in all times and places — omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent, usually putting those three words together in the same sentence. Like most of what they said, I didn’t give it much thought until I’d grown older.</strong></p><p><strong>Presumably being all-knowing includes knowing about the past, and if God knows every detail of history with absolute certainty, that means the past is fixed, which precludes his power to change it. Omniscience compromises omnipotence. He can’t do anything contrary to what he knows already happened, and could only change the past by deleting it and substituting an alternative version of events. And doing that would still require continuity in the substitution; a person couldn’t be born in 1960 and turn 40 years old in 1970. The past and the present would still have to agree with each other.</strong></p><p><strong>I’ve lived now for over three decades in the wake of my parents’ deaths, and I’d gladly give it all up if God could somehow go back and do a re-write, and make it so I were in my twenties again, and my mother and father healthy and whole. Yet if that happened, the new timeline would erase the old, and I wouldn’t be aware of the suffering they’d avoided. I’d lose the last thirty years, and go on to become a different person. My family’s struggles were in no way worth the perspective that came out of that time, but the experience did shape much of who I am now. If God rewrote the past, all that would disappear. Either the past is set, and God can’t change it, or the past is variable, and he is forced to decide on a particular sequence of events. Both circumstances expose something God can’t do. As I see it, absolute omnipotence is impossible.</strong></p><p><strong>I think there’s a kind of immaturity in the claim that God can do anything, one not so different from a toddler declaring that his daddy is the strongest man in the world. Only as adults do we come to understand that our mothers and fathers are mortal and imperfect, and look back to see how the hero worship of early childhood gradually gave way to the realization that much of life was out of their hands. As a grown man, I watched my parents cope with an adversity severe by any standard, and it evoked a depth of love I never knew as a child and probably never would have known had they lived full lives. Their vulnerabilities made me appreciate them more, not less. I wonder if a conception of God doesn’t warrant a similar reconsideration.</strong></p><p><strong>If God really could do anything, and effortlessly cure or prevent cancer, but chooses to let it happen for his own reasons — that’s the traditional Christian view. But if God is not omnipotent, but merely potent enough to assemble the universe, and that universe includes a measure of accident and error — that’s something else entirely. In my opinion, dropping the insistence on omnipotence makes the case for God more credible.</strong></p><p><strong>Any such argument has to address what philosophers call the problem of evil. In other words, if God is good, why is the world so bad? In this context, “evil” means the suffering the human race has experienced throughout its history and continues to endure every day. It makes little sense to say God can do anything, then turn around and say he bears no responsibility for all the misery in the world. If God is omnipotent and maintains evil, then he is not benevolent. If he is benevolent but cannot prevent evil, then he is not omnipotent. This argument is older than Christianity, and goes all the way back to the ancient Greeks.</strong></p><p><strong>The paradox is evident if we assert both omnipotence and omni-benevolence, but it disappears if we grant that one or both do not hold true. Setting aside for the moment the idea of an omnipotent God who is actively malicious, let’s accept for the sake of argument a benevolent creator who is less that all-powerful. Doing so resolves many conundrums about divine justice, and casts suffering as an unavoidable part of a mutable universe.</strong></p><p><strong>Take the stars in the sky as an example. Stars shine because they convert hydrogen and helium into heavier elements by way of nuclear fusion, which produces heat and light. Eventually the fuel runs out; some stars burn out relatively quickly, some shine for ages, and some violently explode, but eventually they all “die.” This process of stellar death will include, in a few billion years, our own Sun, which will doom any life remaining on Earth. A benevolent God may have it within his power to create stars that shine for a very long time, but not stars that shine for eternity. That might be impossible, much as drawing a triangle with four corners is impossible. Which is the greater failure — no stars at all, or imperfect stars, some of which foster the emergence of life? The perishable nature of stars could be an inevitable consequence of having stars in the first place.</strong></p><p><strong>The same argument applies to human beings, who are far more complex than stars. Disease, aging, and death, not to mention human malice and folly, may well be inescapable, for a multitude of practical reasons. Declaring that the world contains more bad than good does not nullify the good; on the contrary, it underscores its value. Life is far from perfect, but we have a great deal to admire when we imagine how much more dreadful it might have been. This isn’t the best of all possible worlds, but it certainly isn’t the worst of all possible worlds, either. To say that evil overwhelms good is like arguing we should reject music because noise is more common. A finite creator, who works hard and sweats the details of an imperfect creation, is a better answer to the problem of evil than the notion of a transcendent, all-powerful God, who could end suffering with a snap of his fingers, but for some reason allows it to stand.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>3. Time</em></strong></p><p><strong>Imagine a group of four college students, all friends with each other, and all working at the same restaurant. Every member of this group is a fan of college football, and it just so happens that a crucial game is coming up on Saturday. Unfortunately, their manager has scheduled all four to work that afternoon, forcing them to miss the game.</strong></p><p><strong>They agree on a plan to overcome this problem. One student will arrange to record the game while they’re at work, and later they’ll gather at his apartment to watch the recording of what happened earlier that afternoon. This particular restaurant is not a sports bar, and no TV screens are visible anywhere inside the building. All four agree to turn off their phones, tell the other employees their plan, and ask that no one spoil it for them. On the day of the game, they’ll make the same request of the patrons in the restaurant.</strong></p><p><strong>Two days before Saturday, one of the group trips on a stair and sprains his ankle. The campus doctor wraps the ankle, prescribes a pair of crutches, and informs the student that waiting tables is out of the question for the next two weeks. The injured student tells the other three what happened, and they all decide to stick to the original plan. The one on crutches agrees to record the game (but not watch it), and they’ll all still meet afterwards in the evening. Since no one in the group will know the outcome, for them it will be happening in real time.</strong></p><p><strong>Saturday afternoon arrives, and the injured student at home finds he can’t resist watching the game, even though he promised otherwise. His friends call from the restaurant at one point to make sure he’s doing something else, and, after carefully muting the TV audio, he answers the phone and swears he is nowhere near a television.</strong></p><p><strong>Later that evening, the other three arrive as planned, and everyone watches the game. The injured student might be tempted to use his advantage and place a bet on the outcome, but he does not, and maintains a convincing front that he has no idea how the game will end. The others are none the wiser.</strong></p><p><strong>For three people in the room, what occurs on the screen is immediate and real. For the fourth, the game is predetermined — he already knows what will happen, and the others don’t know that he knows. In effect, two versions of time now exist: one for the three unwitting spectators, in which the game occurs in the present, and one for the injured student, in which the game already lies in the past. For the former, the players on the field have perfect freedom to move and react as the game requires, but to the latter, the players have no choice but to move in the way that they do. From his point of view, the game has only one possible outcome, and their freedom of choice is an illusion.</strong></p><p><strong>If an omniscient God exists, wouldn’t his perspective resemble that of the injured student? Wouldn’t he stand outside of time, knowing how the game (or any other event) will turn out? If so, then wouldn’t his omniscience mandate a predetermined future? My Sunday school teachers would have answered yes to the first two questions, but they might have hedged on the third. I remember them saying repeatedly that God knew every detail about the past, present, and future of an individual’s life — even before that person was born. At other times, they were equally insistent that everyone possessed free will in making the choice between good and evil. I don’t recall anyone suggesting that free will and a predetermined universe seemed to contradict each other, but if it had come up, they probably would have said that what appeared impossible to human beings was fully within the power of an omnipotent God. I would have been content with that at the time.</strong></p><p><strong>Until the early 20th century, the paradox between determinism and free will remained mostly an academic debate, carried out in books and lecture halls by theologians and philosophers. Einstein would change that. A key part of his work challenges the everyday notion of dividing time into past, present, and future. Most people accept this conventional model of time without question, perceiving the future as fluid and changeable, and the past as a solid block of transpired events, out of reach and invulnerable to change. In this view, the present serves as a kind of membrane, through which the future flows into the past.</strong></p><p><strong>According to Einstein, this perception of time is a fallacy. There is no universal “right now.” The present stands relative to a particular situation, and can vary from one place to another. The pace of a clock depends on local conditions, and synchronized clocks in different locations can fall out of step with each other depending on changes in gravity, motion, and acceleration. The satellites that make the Global Positioning System possible orbit the Earth at 14,000 kilometers per hour, and that velocity actually bends the local time for that particular satellite, altering the cadence of the clock onboard. In order for the system to function properly, the internal computer must compensate for the disparity between its own clock and the clocks on the ground. Although in this case the difference is only a fraction of a second, time warps dramatically at velocities approaching the speed of light. A clock on a spaceship accelerating toward light speed would fall out of step with Earthbound clocks — first by days, then weeks, then eventually by years.</strong></p><p><strong>A contingent present, dependent on local circumstances and varying from one location to another, means that one person’s future can lie in another person’s past — much as the students watching the football game. <em>All</em> of time, not just the past, is a solid block of unchanging events. The past remains locked away behind us, while the future stands locked away ahead of us. Einstein’s model of time resembles the celluloid underlying a movie: the circumstances within the story may change, but the physical filmstrip is a changeless object. The characters in the middle of a movie don’t know how it will end, but the ending, which can unfold in only one way, awaits them just the same. Although it doesn’t appear so to the characters, their freedom of choice is an illusion.</strong></p><p><strong>I don’t know for certain that this is true, but a substantial number of philosophers and physicists accept this interpretation of time. If it <em>is</em> true, what are the implications of that? On one hand, it means we have no free will and no control over our fate. On the other hand, it means a kind of frozen immortality, a permanent presence in time that never changes. Every person who has lived and died still exists in the past, “back there” in a time just as real as the current moment. The same holds true for those born up ahead of what we perceive as the present. History and future history are embedded in time, and our births and deaths only represent the edges of our place within the story.</strong></p><p><strong>I’m not sure what to make of this idea. Does it make sense to call it grounds for optimism? The block time hypothesis offers a kind of eternal life, but nothing like what my Sunday school teachers had in mind. The happiness of my parents’ youth may exist forever, but then so would the horror of their final years. Looking back at the entirety of their lives, I find it disheartening to think they were locked on course from the very beginning — from even before they were born — destined to carry out roles they had no say in determining. If the pseudoimmortality of block time represents the only afterlife we can ever know, they’d have much good to mitigate the bad. I think they would both say the whole of life was worth it the long run. Not everyone, however, would come to the same conclusion.</strong></p><p><strong>Einstein could be wrong. Not all physicists agree with him on this subject, and the intuitive view of time could be the correct one. The future might stand wide open, we all have free will, and only the past remains fixed, a block of time growing larger with each passing second. But if so, how to account for the contingency of the present? I don’t know what’s more plausible — block time, a growing block, or something else entirely. I doubt anyone knows for sure. But let’s accept for the moment the idea that past, present, and future are all one and the same. Does it automatically follow that we have no free will? My layman’s grasp of theoretical physics is vague at best, but I think I understand a resolution that allows free will and determinism to coexist.</strong></p><p><strong>Science offers a kind of footnote to the multiverse hypothesis, one that isn’t necessarily part of astronomy but nevertheless contains some of the same concepts. I’ll use the term <em>cosmological multiverse</em> to refer to what I’ve been talking about up to now, and call the footnote version the <em>quantum multiverse</em>. While the former operates on a grand scale and looks outward to the stars, the latter hypothesis involves laboratory experiments conducted with subatomic particles. Although the details are complicated, essentially these experiments show that, under certain conditions, one isolated electron can appear in two different places at the same time, a phenomenon called <em>superposition</em>. No one is quite sure how this happens, and there have been a number of attempts to explain it.</strong></p><p><strong>Physicists call one of these tentative explanations the <em>many-worlds interpretation</em>, and it proposes that rather than the same electron showing up simultaneously in different locations, the additional appearance is actually a point of overlap with another reality co-existing with our own. Unlike the cosmological multiverse<em>, </em>which posits distinct universes separated by vast distances, the quantum version suggests “next door” dimensions that occur alongside ours, much as pages in a book can touch each other but remain separate. We don’t see superposition in our daily lives because it can only be demonstrated at the scale of subatomic particles.</strong></p><p><strong>According to this model, the other dimensions carry out all the potential consequences for any event in our universe having more than one possible outcome. When a driver chooses the right-hand fork in a road, that decision reveals a counterpart driver in another dimension who chooses the left-hand fork, and those individuals drive off into different futures, both of which are equally real. This happens continually, every time we face an alternative, with consequences large and small. Do I want tea or coffee? Will the game be rained out? Did I get the job? Each question has more than one potential answer, and all the possible outcomes occur in a host of parallel dimensions. The varying results comprise the “many worlds” that give the hypothesis its name. As crazy as this sounds, microscopic experiments in the laboratory have repeatedly shown that a single electron can simultaneously take <em>both</em> forks in a road. No one knows if this might extend to the macroscopic world.</strong></p><p><strong>Let’s assume that it does, and for the sake of argument consider the many-worlds hypothesis valid. This idea, coupled with the concept of determinism, changes the picture of time from a single filmstrip into an immense maze of branching realities. The number of permutations encompassing every possible outcome in the universe would be inconceivably vast, either infinite or virtually so. In this scenario, all three facets of time — past, present, and future — are still a block, with all the differing pathways predetermined, but an individual would never know <em>which</em> path through the maze he or she was bound to take. It would allow for a profusion of fixed futures, and at the same time preserve free will, or at least something very close to free will. The outcome of any alternative, whether by conscious choice or random chance, would open another door through a unique path in the maze.</strong></p><p><strong>It’s one thing to think of my parents locked forever into the single history I experienced alongside them, but something else to consider that multiple versions of my mother and father might be alive elsewhere under very different circumstances. I can imagine a trillion trillion editions of my parents, spread out through all the different dimensions — some better off, some worse, some similar, some unrecognizable — all perpetually living out lives just as real as the one I knew them to have here. That’s the upshot of this hypothesis, and not just for my parents, but for everyone.</strong></p><p><strong>Could physicists one day confirm the reality of the many worlds? I’m only a history teacher who happens to read science fiction, but it seems to me that current science leaves room for an affirmative answer to that question. If that sounds outrageously farfetched, imagine how a description of the 21st century technologies we take for granted would have seemed to a person living five or ten centuries ago. Demonstrating the presence of other dimensions might even open the door to communication between them, but if that proved impossible, just the knowledge they existed would profoundly alter the way we see the world. What if it were true? What if <em>both</em> the cosmological and quantum versions of the multiverse were true?</strong></p><p><strong>If they were, that wouldn’t necessarily prove or disprove any of the arguments regarding existence of a deity. On one hand, the many-worlds model could be the keystone of God’s <em>Magnum Opus</em>, and the answer to the paradox of determinism and free will; on the other, it could stand as simply another characteristic of a godless material multiverse, an unplanned existence that includes heaven, hell, and immortality, all in the absence of a creator.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>8. Obscurity</em></strong></p><p><strong>The Soviet Union launched the <em>Sputnik</em> satellite into orbit in 1957, and since then countries around the world have put scores of probes into space. Mars alone has over a dozen remotely operated vehicles on its surface (most of which are no longer operational), and more are in orbit around the planet. Similar uncrewed vessels, guided by radio commands from terrestrial controllers, have visited all the major bodies in the Solar System, as well as a number of moons, asteroids, and comets. The two Voyager missions, launched in the 1970s, completed their surveys of the outer planets and continued traveling outward from the Sun, eventually leaving the Solar System altogether and entering interstellar space. The Apollo program may have ended in 1972, but the use of probes with no onboard astronauts has expanded dramatically in the meantime.</strong></p><p><strong>This trend will almost certainly continue in the decades to come. A number of present-day missions still carry crews, but most do not venture beyond low Earth orbit. The challenge of protecting vulnerable human beings in space imposes serious engineering constraints on any ship intended to carry people. Missions without crews, lacking the need to carry food, water, and air, face fewer limitations, and will have greater capabilities as they become more sophisticated. Imagine what these robot surveyors might look like several centuries from now.</strong></p><p><strong>To date, all such craft have consisted of single-shot missions launched and controlled from Earth. In the future, a more effective approach to exploration may be to deploy a small number of independent probes, all piloted by onboard artificial intelligence and — most importantly — having the ability to replicate themselves. Each vehicle would operate not only as a spaceship but also as an automated factory, able to land on a moon or asteroid, covert the natural resources there into engineered components, and assemble those parts into one or more vessels identical to the original. Although this may sound highly implausible, the digital revolution has made the idea far more credible now than it would have been at the time of <em>Sputnik</em>. Think of the workers who built Ford’s Model T cars a century ago — what would they have made of present-day robotic assembly lines? Spaceships capable of copying themselves offer so many advantages that eventually technology will catch up with the idea.</strong></p><p><strong>Suppose in a century or two we launch ten such self-replicating craft from Earth. Once in space, the computers on board allow all the ships to proceed without any further human guidance. They head for the asteroid belt, where deposits of heavy metals and other necessary elements exist in abundance. After months of travel, the fleet arrives and fans out, searching for the raw materials needed for each one to manufacture two identical “daughter” spacecraft. Assume that all of the original ten probes are successful, and after each vessel produces two offspring within twelve months, the parent ship shuts down its reproductive phase and concentrates wholly on exploration. The 20 daughter ships repeat the process, meaning that two years after arrival there are now 70 probes roaming the Solar System — the original ten, plus 20 daughters and 40 granddaughters.</strong></p><p><strong>Three years after arrival, 150 ships now exist — the original ten, 20 daughters, 40 granddaughters, and 80 great-granddaughters, all sending streams of data back to astronomers on Earth. Some would expire from mechanical failure, but given that each one could duplicate itself from scratch, they would necessarily possess sophisticated facilities for repair. Even assuming a modest success rate of 50%, in a single decade thousands of surveyors would be in operation among the planets. Built-in safeguards would have to exist in order to limit reproduction, or else the ships might continue unchecked and convert the entire mass of the Solar System into copies of themselves. Considering all the challenges of replication, it seems plausible to assume that reliable provisions against uncontrolled reproduction would be possible.</strong></p><p><strong>Now imagine scaling up the program to an interstellar level. Even the closest stars are tens of thousands of times more distant than the planets, so the transit time to reach them would be centuries or millennia rather than months. (The laws of physics probably rule out faster-than-light travel, despite its ubiquity in science fiction.) Human beings will likely never leave the Solar System, but our machines already have. If a probe more advanced than the self-replicating planetary version were able to accelerate to one percent of the speed of light, and create hundreds of copies of itself rather than just two, its descendants could permeate the galaxy in a few tens of millions of years. This span of time, although vast in human terms, is only a blink of an eye in the age of the universe.</strong></p><p><strong>Could we ever initiate such a program? A better question might ask why it hasn’t happened already. I don’t mean through human effort, but launched instead by extraterrestrials in the distant past. Our galaxy is more than 13 billion years old — nearly as old as the entire universe. The elements that make it up, as well as the laws that govern those elements, are, as far as we can tell, identical in all directions. The same physical processes that produced life on Earth should have done so on other worlds. Billions of stars and planets much older than our own have existed since the early universe, and it seems reasonable to suppose that other civilizations would have evolved, attained space travel, and achieved the skills necessary to create a fleet of sentient, self-sustaining spacecraft. It would only take a single such world to place a surveyor in orbit around every planet in the galaxy. Taking into account the number of stars within the range of our telescopes, we should already have evidence of alien artifacts. Yet no such evidence exists. The vast majority of UFO reports turn out to have mundane explanations, and the few that remain unexplained fall far short of confirming the existence of extraterrestrials. We have no proof that life occurs anywhere else, let alone intelligence. The universe appears empty, but it shouldn’t. Why?</strong></p><p><strong>Welcome to the Fermi Paradox, named after physicist Enrico Fermi, who commented on this contradiction in the 1950s. The universe is so big, and so old, we should have company — so where is everybody? Typing the words <em>Fermi Paradox</em> into a search engine will give some idea of the vast literature attempting to explain it.</strong></p><p><strong>The simplest possible solution to the paradox is probably the least likely: we may truly be alone, and life has occurred here but nowhere else, for reasons not yet understood. Another possible explanation is that extraterrestrials exist, but since we’ve only been searching in earnest for a relatively short time, we have yet to come across any sign of them. One day soon we’ll discover the evidence and resolve the paradox. Or perhaps Hoyle’s quarantine idea is valid, and somehow applies to artificial machines as well as organic life, confining any intelligence to the planetary system of its origin. Or it could be that proof of aliens is all around us, but we don’t recognize it as such. Their technology may be too small to detect, or their radio signals indistinguishable from static. Or possibly intelligence is unstable, and only survives for a relatively short time. Perhaps <em>all</em> civilizations (including our own) destroy themselves soon after acquiring the means to do so.</strong></p><p><strong>Another scenario is that extraterrestrials do in fact exist, but conceal their presence from human beings. The universe isn’t empty — it’s just arranged to appear that way to us. Either the aliens somehow keep themselves undetectable, or the entire night sky is an artificial projection intended to show a universe devoid of life. This notion, sometimes called the Zoo Hypothesis, is one of the weaker of the many proposed solutions to the Fermi Paradox. Its proponents, after all, make the dubious claim that the <em>lack</em> of evidence is actually evidence in itself. In spite of this, I think the idea is worth a closer look.</strong></p><p><strong>The first zoos were nothing more than bare pits or cages, but gradually some zookeepers attempted to make the exhibits more like the animals’ natural environment. Eventually, as the enclosures became more sophisticated, some creatures lost the sense they were <em>in</em> a zoo; their surroundings had become virtually identical to their native habitat. Nowadays, even beyond the zoo, biologists observing animals in the wild take great care to conceal themselves from their subjects of study. Seeking an accurate picture of behavior in nature, they know that the sight of an intruder would spoil their observations. In a similar fashion, any hypothetical extraterrestrials monitoring the human race could have a comparable motivation to keep themselves hidden.</strong></p><p><strong>Science fiction fans may notice a similarity between the Zoo Hypothesis and the “Prime Directive” from the world of <em>Star Trek.</em> In that show, an interstellar federation of planets operated under a strict decree that no member could interfere with the evolution of any world that hadn’t yet attained space travel. Much as the biologists in the field, the idea was to let the inhabitants shape their own development in their own way. (I grew up with the reruns of the original show in the 1970s, and thinking back now over the series, I don’t know how “prime” the directive really was — Kirk and company seemed to violate it about every other episode.) The basic idea is also central to <em>2001: A Space Odyssey</em>:<em> </em>humanity remained isolated in its cage, i.e., the Earth, until astronauts discovered the monolith on the Moon, whereupon the door to the cage opened and the zoo became obsolete. A motive not to intervene might explain the Fermi Paradox, even if there is no evidence to support it.</strong></p><p><strong>Looking beyond science and science fiction, one can find instances of this principle in everyday life. Take Major League Baseball as an example. Professional baseball (or any other formal game) exists as a universe unto itself. At the season’s start, all the teams have identical win-loss records, and their world consists of field, equipment, roster, and rules. Ideally, the schedule will run its course and in the end produce the best team. It would defeat the whole point of the game if the Commissioner of Baseball could pick up the phone and demand that his favorite batter receive four strikes at the plate instead of three. By the same token, the competition would lose all meaning if the fans could leap the wall at any time and join the game. On the contrary, a strict policy of non-interference prevails, keeping events on and off the field distinctly separate.</strong></p><p><strong>Working zoologists, the proprietors of professional sports, and presumed extraterrestrials all have a vested interest in maintaining a hands-off policy in their respective domains; could a creator-God have a comparable motive regarding the universe? This idea — the Zoo Hypothesis applied to theology — sounds a lot like old-fashioned deism. According to the original deists, God did in fact create the universe, but once it was finished, he had no further contact with his creation. Much like an absentee landlord, he issued the ground rules and then disappeared from the scene. Deists saw the divinity of Christ, the Resurrection, the Second Coming, and other doctrines of Christianity as strictly human inventions. In their eyes, knowledge of God could only come from applying human reason to the natural world. As I recall, they had little to say about what might have occupied the creator after the process of creation was complete.</strong></p><p><strong>What could be God’s possible motives? He may not intervene in the world, but that doesn’t mean he still couldn’t closely observe what happens here. Why create a dynamic universe and then have no interest in how it plays out? It would be like the Commissioner of Baseball shrugging his shoulders and saying he doesn’t follow baseball. I can understand why an atheist might call that ridiculous, and say that the simple reason we have no evidence for a deity is because God does not exist. While I admit that could be the case, for the sake of argument I’ll temporarily presume that a theological Zoo Hypothesis is valid.</strong></p><p><strong>Why would God remain hidden? How could such a policy benefit the purpose of creation? We’ve already touched on several possible explanations. If Earth is an experiment, any interference would ruin the test. If humanity is only one small element in a grand cosmic enterprise, we may not have the capacity to comprehend the whole. If our universe is a work of art, maybe the artist is more concerned with constructing new universes than attaching a signature to this particular canvas. I once saw a picture of Picasso in a studio, standing with his arms folded across his chest and staring directly into the camera. Behind him, hundreds of his paintings and sketches leaned against the walls or stood upright between plywood partitions. Looking at the expression on his face, I suspected he’d forgotten about many of them. Presumably the act of creating new art was more important than any regard for work already accomplished. Perhaps God takes a similar perspective.</strong></p><p><strong>Of course this is all speculation. So far in this section I’ve made no mention of an afterlife, or, as long as we’re speculating, whether the silence of the dead has anything to do with the obscurity of a creator. More on that in the next chapter.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>9. Beauty</em></strong></p><p><strong>Several years ago I had the good fortune to stand on the south rim of the Grand Canyon at sunrise. I’d never been there before, and the sky that morning looked particularly beautiful. The colors overhead appeared almost as stunning as the landscape below; the earth and sky seemed to collaborate in making a statement about the nature of the universe. A few other visitors stood nearby, speaking to each other in low tones, almost as if they were in a cathedral. No photograph can capture the effect of witnessing that view in person. It practically qualifies as a religious experience. Anyone who’s been there knows what I mean.</strong></p><p><strong>But the Grand Canyon is, after all, just a big hole in the ground, a pit eroded by wind and water over millions of years. Why is it beautiful? The same question applies to the sunrise. In the early morning, the sun’s rays strike that part of the Earth at an oblique angle, and they travel through a greater distance of atmosphere before reaching the ground. The longer journey through the air bends and filters the light to a greater degree, producing a wider spectrum of color than when the sun is directly overhead. Why should that matter? Why is the sky more beautiful at dawn and dusk than at midday?</strong></p><p><strong>Unlike the land and the sky, I can understand the basis for seeing beauty in a human face. People find each other attractive for a variety of reasons, but the prospect of starting a family usually overshadows other considerations in intimate relationships. Physical attraction is the prerequisite to courtship, so the perception of beauty in another person has, at least in part, a Darwinian explanation. Young couples on first dates ultimately evaluate each other in terms of their fitness to become parents. The initial attraction extends beyond the individual to include his or her possessions; people routinely use everyday items as status symbols in order to impress potential partners and social contacts. We can describe a house or a car or an outfit as beautiful without necessarily thinking about how those objects influence personal relationships.</strong></p><p><strong>Could one say the same about the beauty of, say, Mozart or Shakespeare? Is great art also fundamentally attributable to evolutionary forces? I would say yes, in the sense that art is how Mozart and Shakespeare made their livings, and their livings enabled them to pass their genes on to the next generation. Even for artists and others who remain childless, their work ultimately serves as the means of acquiring food, clothing, and shelter, not to mention the approval of their contemporaries. The acute awareness of social hierarchy is a primary driver of human behavior, with or without the prospect of parenthood. So I can make a distinction between the beauty of human beings and their possessions on one hand, and the beauty of nature on the other.</strong></p><p><strong>Is it possible to explain the wonder of the Grand Canyon in terms of Darwin? Before considering that, what about the <em>ugliness</em> of nature in Darwinian terms? Anyone can admire a sunrise, but how many admire mudslides, beg bugs, sinkholes, or pond scum? All of those are features of nature too. Are they just inherently repugnant, or is the aversion rooted in their threat to human well-being? Think of the creatures living in the deepest part of the ocean, most of which look like something straight out of a nightmare. Could their ghastly appearance stem from the fact that they live in the most hostile environment on Earth — a place instantly fatal to any human being who might suddenly appear there unprotected? We shun what could threaten our lives or our welfare. One can admire a tiger, at least until it attacks. At that point the admiration turns to horror. I would say the perception of the nature’s ugly side has roots in evolutionary biology.</strong></p><p><strong>So what about natural beauty? Like most people, I think horses, trees, and rivers are beautiful, but all those have been turned to human advantage, so the admiration may have practical roots, and come from an awareness of humanity’s self-interest over millennia. What are the practical benefits of seeing beauty in the Grand Canyon? An investor might dream of building condominiums along the rim to exploit the view, but that scheme would never have occurred to the prehistoric hunter-gatherers who first saw it. We can’t know what passed through their minds at that moment, but I imagine their emotional reaction was much the same as it is for almost anyone who sees it now. Would they have considered it a desirable place to live? I would think that conditions inside the Canyon presented a greater challenge to securing food and other necessities than the surrounding terrain. They wouldn’t have been drawn to it because if offered easy living, yet I suspect they still found it beautiful. The few who chose to stay there did so in spite of the difficulties. So far as I can tell, the visual impact of the Grand Canyon has no Darwinian explanation.</strong></p><p><strong>The idea of beauty with no apparent cause extends to other natural wonders. Few people nowadays have the opportunity to witness a night sky undimmed by artificial lights, but for those who do, they may well stand in disbelief upon seeing it for the first time. The power of that spectacle is even greater when it includes celestial objects the ancients never saw. The rings of Saturn, for instance, remained unknown until the invention of the telescope in the 1600s. Their grandeur could in no way have influenced the evolution of early humans, yet watch the face of anyone seeing Saturn through a really good telescope for the first time. The images of galaxies and nebulae beyond the Milky Way have the same effect. A person would have to be dead not to consider them beautiful, yet until recently no one had the faintest idea they existed. Their absence from nearly all of human history suggests the beauty may be objective, and not just something inside our heads.</strong></p><p><strong>A sense of the beautiful doesn’t necessarily have to come from grand spectacles like mountains or galaxies. During the year after my father’s first stroke, when we all still thought he might have a chance to recover, he kept a series of notebooks for handwriting exercises. He’d put down random thoughts on paper, and my mother would add brief responses after each entry. The point wasn’t so much what he wrote as it was to improve his manual dexterity. I still have those notebooks, and as bittersweet as they are to read now, the entries are mostly offhand remarks about neighbors or meals or a story in the news that day. One item, however, has stuck with me ever since he wrote it in the summer of 1986:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>I’m out on the porch now. The sky is skying, the leaves are leavesing, the wind is winding, and it’s a wonderful day just to see it.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>I know exactly what he meant, and I suspect the reader does too. Sometimes simply being outdoors is enough to realize how lovely the world can be.</strong></p><p><strong>Am I just cherry-picking the different facets of nature? Let’s set aside the question of where beauty comes from, and grant that the natural world is a mix of the ugly and the beautiful. Could we itemize nature and draw up a balance sheet, with beauty on one side and ugliness on the other? Assign a numerical value to each entry, tally them up, and arrive at a bottom line? I’m not sure nature can be quantified in that manner. How many tar pits would it take to nullify the Grand Canyon? Assuming that such an enumeration is possible, I would concede that the negative outweighs the positive. But so what? I can say the same about the human race. Scoundrels may outnumber heroes, but that doesn’t mean the heroes disappear. Common ugliness does not invalidate uncommon beauty. On the contrary, the latter — either in spite of its rarity or because of it — makes life worthwhile.</strong></p><p><strong>The perception of beauty often carries a parallel impression that all we see around us is a mere veil, the outer surface of a deeper reality that extends beyond the range of our senses or our instruments. Intuition is a dubious guide, but sometimes it leads to discovery, and only a fool would ignore it completely. Natural beauty gives rise to amazement, and although that feeling may well be deceptive, it might also serve as a genuine clue toward explaining why anything exists at all. Can a gut feeling ever count as evidence? It certainly can in matters of the heart, but I’m talking about the kind of evidence that might shed light on the fundamental purpose of the universe. In that case, no, such an emotion is inconclusive — I have no way of knowing if the awe I feel for certain aspects of nature has some deeper significance, or if it only emerges from time to time as a byproduct of my own psychology. I’ve never seen the gates of heaven, so maybe it should come as no surprise that certain sunsets can look just as I’d expect the gates of heaven to appear.</strong></p><p><strong>Nevertheless, sunsets, canyons, thunder, lightning — sometimes just the wind through the trees — can evoke (in me, anyway) a powerful sense of intent. I know all those phenomena spring from entirely explainable causes, but the end results still suggest an underlying intelligence. During those moments, I can’t help but suspect that we’re here for a reason, and the world is moving toward some deliberate conclusion. That impression, although often overwhelming, never rises to the level of conviction. But it does leave room for hope.</strong></p><p><strong>One final word about beauty. Up to this point I’ve been assuming that certain aspects of the natural world imply the goodwill of a creator, but what if the opposite were true? What if a malevolent god fabricated the universe as a cruel hoax, and incorporated beauty as a ploy? The marvels of nature might only exist to foster a false sense of optimism, and convince the human race to keep going in the face of adversity. I once saw a cartoon of a donkey pulling a cart, with a pole attached to the cart and extending out over the donkey’s head. A carrot dangled from the tip of the pole, placed there as a lure to keep the animal moving toward the promise of a sham reward. Could a sadistic god dangle beauty before humanity to serve a similar purpose?</strong></p><p><strong>I don’t know that any more than I know anything else about the creator of the universe, including if there even is one. But a person could argue that such a scenario seems to rule out malevolent omnipotence. If a vindictive, all-powerful creator wanted to trick us using beauty, why not come up with a better trick? Shouldn’t the deception be more deceptive? Rather than manufacture intangible notions of purpose we have no way of proving, why not plant fully convincing evidence of benevolent intentions?</strong></p><p><strong>Of course that discrepancy could just be part of the con. For all I know, the deity really <em>is</em> vengeful and omnipotent, and the mix of beauty and ugliness around us is carefully designed to make the fraud more realistic. Or it could be that God is less than all-powerful, but still fully malicious, and the misery people endure is the most effective evil he can manage. I’d call the prospect of such a creator a subset of the overall god hypothesis. In my opinion, the question of whether the deity is good or bad is secondary to the question of whether any god exists at all. All I can say for certain is I don’t know. I doubt anyone knows.</strong></p><p><strong>Excerpts from</strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER XII</strong></p><p><strong><em>A Dark Horizon</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>1. Prayer</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>2. The Possibility of an Afterlife</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>3. Raising the Children</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>4. Autumn Again *</em></strong></p><p>* not included in this posting</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>We held my mother’s funeral at the church in Devon Mills. Although she hadn’t lived there in nearly ten years, several hundred people turned out for the service. While many were members of the congregation, many were not, and came simply because they’d known Annie in her youth. One of her friends from school hugged me and said that my mother was the most vivacious person she’d ever known.</strong></p><p><strong>Five months later, we held my father’s funeral in the same church. The second turnout was smaller, mostly because he’d never formally joined the congregation. Still, my brothers and I shook hands with scores of mourners, and some comforted us by saying that Annie and Bill were together in heaven now. Nearly all of them said we were in their prayers.</strong></p><p><strong>Those comments about prayer stayed in my mind long after the funerals ended. Up until kindergarten, I said my nightly prayers kneeling on the rug next to my bedside. Later on, I dropped the kneeling but still mentally raced through the same prayers after climbing into bed. Even now, I can recall that litany from childhood, and I’d bet my brothers could do the same. I doubt we’re alone in that.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>1. Prayer</em></strong></p><p><strong>Maybe the whole idea of prayer is a fool’s errand. Atheists say that the faithful delude themselves into thinking they can communicate with the deity, when in fact they’re speaking to a void. I could understand calling prayer a delusion if we had absolute proof that God did not exist, but we (or at least I) don’t know that for certain. Given the absence of evidence, I don’t think prayer is necessarily foolish.</strong></p><p><strong>My parents’ graves are in Devon Mills, just a few miles from where we grew up. I only visit there occasionally, but sometimes I find myself whispering a few words to my mother and father while standing in front of their headstone. I don’t know that they can hear me, and I’m not sure if I’m speaking more to them or more to myself, but I always feel better after those visits. Does that qualify as prayer? I think I’d still do it even if I knew for a fact that their spirit and souls are gone for all eternity. That may very well be the case, but I can never know for sure, and sometimes I do get the feeling that they’re looking over my shoulder, sharing in the ups and downs of daily life. Whether or not that’s true, I’d find it hard to come up with a better code of conduct than to live as if they can see me now.</strong></p><p><strong>My Sunday school teachers would have rejected any notion that whispering to a headstone in a cemetery might count as prayer, but I disagree. Unlike the deity, I’m positive my parents once existed, and they still exist in my memory. I have a greater justification directing my thoughts to them than I do to an unknown providence. For all I know, they really <em>can</em> see me, and I always ponder what they would have said whenever an important decision comes up. Prayers addressed to God are another matter, and to consider those . . . well, this might be a good time for an allegory. Please bear with me as I tap into my science fiction boyhood once again and offer a thought experiment.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Imagine at some point far in the future, human beings have colonized the galaxy, and starships regularly zip back and forth across interstellar space, visiting a wide variety of planets. One small ship is traveling on such a journey, with only a single pilot on board. For some reason, the navigation system fails, and not only does the ship veer off course, it also plunges through a dimensional wormhole in space, coming out the other side into an unknown part of the multiverse. Although the vessel has suffered serious damage, luckily a nearby star, with a host of orbiting planets, lies within reach. One of these planets has an oxygen atmosphere and appears habitable. The pilot has no time for a detailed survey, but he is able to land the ship intact.</strong></p><p><strong>He proceeds to take stock of the situation. He has no chance to take off again without a major overhaul of the ship’s engines, a complicated process impossible to carry out on his own. Although several continents were visible during the descent from space, he seems to have landed on an island. Beaches and forests lie within sight of the ship, but he sees no coastline or other islands across the surrounding ocean. Tests show the air is breathable, and the food synthesizers and water purifiers on board remain undamaged. The ship’s radio, however, is broken beyond repair.</strong></p><p><strong>A week’s reconnaissance reveals he is indeed on an island, one several square miles in extent. He’s seen no artifacts of any kind, and no evidence of animal life. The vegetation, while profuse, is fernlike in appearance, and there are no trees he might use to build a boat. Even assuming he could make it off the island, he has no idea if the planet is inhabited, or if he’s even in his own universe. For the moment, he’s stuck where he is.</strong></p><p><strong>He does, however, have one thin hope, and it depends on the cargo inside the ship. It just so happens he was delivering an order to a buyer on the other side of the galaxy: ten thousand sturdy glass bottles, all empty, and each one sealed with a watertight cap. He also happens to have several skids of heavyweight paper, as well as an ample supply of fountain pens and indelible ink. For the lack of anything better to do, he begins writing messages, placing them inside the bottles, and hurling the bottles into the sea. It may not help, but it certainly doesn’t hurt.</strong></p><p><strong>He’d realize the unlikelihood of anyone finding a bottle, but the chance would be zero if he made no attempt at all. Before composing the messages, he’d have to consider a host of issues. Who might find them? How would they respond? Would they even recognize the bottle as an artifact? They wouldn’t know his language — how could he make himself understood? Could the simple act of sending a message be just as important as any content? Even if the planet turned out to be truly desolate, and every single bottle destined to drift unopened forever, he wouldn’t know that at the time of writing. Just the effort of composition would have powerful psychological benefits. It would focus his energies and offer a reason for hope, forcing him to take a broader view of his circumstances. It’d be much better than sitting around doing nothing. And who knows? One of the messages just might get through.</strong></p><p><strong>To come to the point: is this castaway throwing bottles into the sea in any way like a person offering prayers to the heavens? Is that a fair comparison?</strong></p><p><strong>Looking back over the last few paragraphs, I already see flaws in the analogy. For one thing, I know that when the congregation in Devon Mills prayed, all (or nearly all) of them had no doubt that God was hearing them in real time. Many would have sworn that some of their prayers had already been answered. They considered prayer a direct line to heaven, not an open letter to some hypothetical recipient.</strong></p><p><strong>Secondly, not all prayers are requests for intervention. People might plead to God to cure their cancer (or a loved one’s cancer), but many prayers only offer praise or thanksgiving, and make no appeal at all. I grew up saying grace before meals, and although the words varied according to the occasion, it basically came down to an expression of gratitude for the food on the table. Sometimes it included a recognition of God’s authority (”Our heavenly Father…”), or an acknowledgement of his wisdom (”Thy will be done”), but it almost never involved, at least at the dinner table, a request for God to intervene in the world and take some specific action.</strong></p><p><strong>Other prayers are straightforward statements of belief. I think most Christians would agree that the 23rd Psalm qualifies as a prayer, and a beautiful one at that. The Apostles’ Creed, another text I had to memorize in Sunday school, would fit in the same category. Neither of these proclamations is a plea for intercession. Parts of the Lord’s Prayer fall into this category as well. In all of these instances, the faithful are saying “this is what I believe” rather than “please help me.”</strong></p><p><strong>That being said, many Christian prayers are in fact direct appeals for God to act. I remember our minister sharing a list of prayer requests from the pulpit almost every Sunday, usually asking the congregation to pray for those suffering from serious health problems. Looking back now, he seemed to be saying that we had greater strength in numbers, as if God were more likely to hear a whole congregation rather than a lone individual. It didn’t make sense. If God knows everything, what’s the difference between one prayer and many? Wouldn’t all prayers be redundant? What’s the point of asking, if God knew the outcome before the petitioner was even born? If he allowed the cancer in the first place, why would he reverse himself upon appeal, especially when he’d known every detail of the appeal long in advance? I wonder if all petitionary prayer is a kind of unintended admission that God’s omniscience may be less than absolute. Our minister would never have agreed with that, but I’m sure he’d agree that knowing others are praying for one’s family gives great comfort, even if not every family member accepts the prayer at face value. I can attest to that from personal experience.</strong></p><p><strong>I think my castaway allegory is best suited to the agnostic. I don’t know that prayers are heard by anyone, but they might be. And if they’re not, they have value in themselves. They still mean a great deal, even if never received. To an agnostic, prayer is a manifestation of hope, and the instinct to hope is the greater part of being human.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>2. The Possibility of an Afterlife</em></strong></p><p><strong>Warner Brothers released <em>The Exorcist</em> in December 1973, but the movie didn’t make it to Devon Mills until the following spring. My mother declared it off limits, but a friend and I managed to sneak away to the neighborhood theater one Saturday afternoon. The ticket clerk never should have admitted a couple of unaccompanied young kids, but she wasn’t much older than we were. Two hours later, we came out to find a group of our friends sitting on their bikes, all making mock retching sounds and jokes about pea soup. I should have listened to my mother.</strong></p><p><strong>I don’t recall any mention of <em>The Exorcist</em> in Sunday school, but I do remember a great deal of talk about another best-selling book (and later film adaption) that came out around the same time. Hal Lindsey’s <em>The Late Great Planet Earth</em>, first published in 1970, is a literal, credulous, and lurid interpretation of biblical prophecy that draws heavily on the Book of Revelation. The paperback edition appeared on best seller lists, and I remember kids who didn’t go to my church talking about it in high school. Although the publisher categorized it as religion, at least one bookstore in Devon Mills displayed it in the science fiction section. Our minister denounced the book from the pulpit, not so much over the subject matter, but because the author had the audacity to attach specific dates to his predictions. The Sunday school teachers dismissed it as well, repeatedly citing First Thessalonians 5:2 (”the return of the Lord shall come without warning, as a thief who comes in the night”), and maintained that Lindsey’s linking of prophecy to contemporary events proved that he didn’t know what he was talking about.</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Exorcist</em> and <em>The</em> <em>Late Great Planet Earth</em> both declared that heaven and hell — particularly hell — were absolutely real. Although that gave me plenty to think about in my teens, I’ve long since abandoned the picture of life after death as depicted in those stories. I think the doctrine of hell is the weakest link in the New Testament, and the most compelling reason to hold Christianity in doubt. That’s not to say, however, that I scoff at the idea of an afterlife entirely. Just as I’m open to the possibility of a universe conceived by an unknown intelligence, I’m also open to the possibility of a hereafter that has nothing to do with heaven or hell. I emphasize the word <em>possibility</em>, because even if the universe does exist by intent, it doesn’t necessarily follow that such intent would provide for an afterlife. Nevertheless, I’ll try to make clear why I’m not completely resigned to personal oblivion at death. I’m not saying this is what I <em>believe</em>, but only offering the idea as one more item in a survey of possibilities.</strong></p><p><strong>Before doing that, I want to briefly raise one particular issue in order to take it off the table. Almost everyone has heard stories of near-death experiences — the visions and emotional states some hospital patients report as they approach the point of clinical death. Accounts of leaving one’s body, seeing a brilliant white light, or feeling a mystical connection to the whole universe are common features of these experiences. Maybe these cases really do constitute a glimpse of the afterlife, but I suspect they’re closer to ordinary dreams than supernatural visions. Anyone curious about the details can explore the literature on subject, but I’ll make no more mention of it here.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>When I was in high school, I took a ride one Friday night with a group of teenage boys in my best friend’s car. It was the middle of autumn, and we were all on our way to a high school football game. For some reason, the expression “the meaning of life” came up in conversation, which everyone found hilarious at the time. <em>The meaning of life? What the hell are you talking about</em>? After a number of unlikely suggestions,<em> </em>someone in the back seat offered up the name of a certain girl we all hoped to see at the game later that night. <em>There you have it, dudes. The meaning of life. </em>Now that I think about it, that observation may have been closer to the mark than we realized at the time. For all we knew, a carload of teenage girls on their way to the same game were having the same conversation about one of us. To a biologist, the transfer of genes into the next generation <em>is</em> the meaning of life. And if the atheists are right, that’s all it is.</strong></p><p><strong>So what about the meaning of life? Is that a serious idea, or just a worn-out cliché? Of course life does have meaning in a narrow, everyday sense of the term. If I have a flat tire, it has meaning — to me, anyway, and to a lesser degree to those around me. On a broader scale, it means a great deal to me whether my loved ones succeed in their pursuit of happiness. On an even broader scale, I’m glad to be alive, and would jump at the offer to live the same life over again if given the chance. I think my parents would do the same.</strong></p><p><strong>But I don’t think that’s what most people have in mind when they talk about the meaning of life. A paraphrase would be more like “why am I here?” or “what’s the point of it all?” In that sense, maybe life doesn’t have a meaning. Children grow up, become parents, and then die; their children grow up, become parents, and then die as well. The cycle perpetuates itself, but is it going anywhere? Apparently evolution is an opportunistic process that has no long-term goal. Each generation lays the foundation for the next generation, and its success or failure depends on the conditions of that particular environment. The flow of a given population across time is as mechanical as the flow of a river across a landscape. “Meaning” has nothing to do with it.</strong></p><p><strong>This argument is even more evident on the scale of the cosmos. The universe has been expanding ever since the Big Bang, and predictions about its ultimate end look about as bleak as one can imagine. According to astronomers, not only are all the galaxies moving away from each other, the rate of that expansion is accelerating. The universe will likely expand forever, dissipating in space the way a drop of ink dissipates in the ocean. Such a fate suggests there is no meaning in the long run, and existence is ultimately pointless. That picture is so desolate, and so disheartening, that it cries out for another interpretation. I want to propose an alternative point of view, but before doing that, I’ll need a little space to give some context to that alternative.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Edwin Abbott (1839–1926), an Anglican priest, English schoolmaster, and scholar of Shakespeare, wrote the novel <em>Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions</em>, first published in 1884. A wide-ranging mathematical fantasy, <em>Flatland</em> depicts a world populated by talking geometric figures — triangles, squares, pentagons, and other sentient, two-dimensional shapes that live together on an imaginary plane. The narrator, Mr. Square, describes Flatland as a place much like a paper map on a tabletop: Flatlanders can move north, south, east, west, or any combination of those directions, but never “up” or “down” — that is, above or below the map. They have no conception of a third dimension, and the words <em>up</em> and <em>down</em> do not exist in their vocabulary. Their world is simply flat.</strong></p><p><strong>After a detailed description of how society functions in Flatland, Square has a dream of a place called Lineland<em>,</em> which only consists of a single dimension. Linelanders can only move left or right on the single line that defines their existence, and have no inkling of any other direction. Square tries to explain the concept of another dimension, describing a north and south to complement their east and west, but to no avail. The citizens of Lineland take offense at such a radical idea, and threaten their visitor with death.</strong></p><p><strong>After waking from his dream, Square encounters a character called Sphere, a visitor from Spaceland, a universe of three dimensions. To Square, Sphere appears as a circle, a two-dimensional cross-section that appears, grows, and disappears as Sphere enters and exits the plane of Flatland. Just as Flatland is incomprehensible to the Linelanders, Spaceland is incomprehensible to Square, at least until Sphere takes him on a trip “up” into the third dimension, where he can look down on Flatland and see it from a new perspective. Square has an epiphany, realizing how a point can become a line, a line can become a square, and a square can become a cube. He wonders if the sequence continues, and if higher dimensions might exist, but Sphere curtly dismisses such presumption.</strong></p><p><strong>I won’t pretend to understand the math that allows for four-, five-, and six-dimensional hypercubes, but I’m told that such figures do exist as mathematical concepts. They inhabit, as Abbott puts it, a place called <em>Thoughtland</em>, and mathematicians can deduce<em> </em>the objects that dwell there. As far as I know, no engineer in the everyday world can take pieces of metal or wood and construct a physical model of a hypercube in the sixth dimension; such an object can only occur — for us, anyway — as a mental abstraction. But does that mean it’s not real? Near the end the novel, Square learns that the higher realms do in fact exist, and are just as tangible as our familiar world of three dimensions.</strong></p><p><strong>I take <em>Flatland</em> as an allegory not just about mathematics, but knowledge in general. It has parallels to everyday experience. Our dogs, for example, are bona fide members of the family, but as much as they know about us and our daily routine, they don’t have a clue about the tax returns we file every year. Those will remain forever outside their comprehension. It makes me wonder what concepts exist beyond the grasp of human beings. Surely what we know is only a tiny fraction of what we don’t know, or even <em>can</em> know. How should one interpret the higher realms of Flatland? Are they meant to represent Heaven? Nirvana? Wisdom? Scientific understanding? The multiverse? As I read it, Abbott’s novel is a hymn to the unknown.</strong></p><p><strong>Ignorance can very often lead to frustration, but it also allows for a kind of freedom. If death is really the end, then that’s a hard truth, but it’s one I’d rather know now than take refuge in a comforting falsehood. But the point is I don’t know, at least not for certain. No one does. Yes, the weight of the physical evidence is on the side of the atheists, but that evidence is far from conclusive, and I’m not convinced that the subjective experience of awe in the face of nature isn’t a vital clue we have yet to understand. In the meantime, the absence of certainty gives free rein to the imagination.</strong></p><p><strong>I once saw a bumper sticker that read:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>Theists will never see the proof they were wrong.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Atheists will never see the proof they were right.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>As much as I appreciated the irony, the word <em>never</em> led me to take both statements with a grain of salt. Presumably “the proof” meant a missing afterlife and the extinction of all consciousness at death, but wasn’t the author making a claim to certainty in the absence of proof? It reminded me of the analogy from astronomy mentioned in an earlier chapter: we may one day prove the existence of extraterrestrial intelligence, but we’ll never <em>prove</em> that we’re alone in the universe. The first prospect, like theism, is verifiable, while the second, like atheism, is not.</strong></p><p><strong>So I accept that an afterlife is, if unlikely, at least possible. Is there <em>any</em> reason to think it might actually exist? If we stipulate that potential evidence must be confirmed by laboratory experiment, then the answer is almost certainly no. Maybe science will one day discover some previously unknown aspect of physics that confirms an afterlife, but I doubt it. At this point all we have is conjecture. An atheist might call that a waste of time, and argue we have to go on what we know, not what we wish. That’s sound advice, but I’d still consider it unwise to abandon conjecture entirely.</strong></p><p><strong>Earlier I brought up mathematical Platonism, the idea that the principles of mathematics are independent of human beings. According to that hypothesis, mathematicians explore the properties of numbers the same way astronomers explore the properties of stars. Both seek to uncover previously unknown truths. Mathematicians don’t invent equations; they discover them. The Pythagorean Theorem, Galileo’s principles of motion, the formula for pi, and Newton’s law of gravity all existed long before they were recognized by human beings. They antedate humanity, and will endure long after the human race is gone. <em>Where</em> they exist is another question. Do mathematical objects float somewhere in a higher realm, waiting to be identified by a mathematician and brought down into the “real” world? Is there some corner of the multiverse that contains nothing but numbers? If there is, I imagine such a place wouldn’t be just one more universe among many, but instead a kind of primary template that generates the secondary universes.</strong></p><p><strong>The “Platonism” in the term <em>mathematical Platonism</em> refers to the Greek philosopher Plato (429?-347? BCE), a key figure in the history of Western thought. His best-known work, <em>The Republic</em>, contains the famous Allegory of the Cave. Plato asks us to imagine a group of prisoners held immobile by chains and confined deep inside a cave. They are restrained in such a way that no one can turn around and look back toward the entrance; they can only look straight ahead at wall of the cave in front of them. Out of sight behind this group lies a fire burning between them and the entrance. A shallow trench, flanked by a low parapet, runs across the cave floor between the fire and the prisoners. The prisoners’ jailors move back and forth along this trench, all carrying various objects — animals, plants, artifacts — raised above their heads. The prisoners can see the moving shadows of the objects cast by firelight upon the wall, but the shadows of their jailors remain blocked by the parapet next to the trench, much as the sight of a puppeteer is blocked by the partition below a puppet show. They can only see the shadows on the wall, as well as hear the voices of their jailors behind them. The prisoners have spent their entire lives here, never having ventured outside the cave or even looked in the direction of its opening. They think the voices they hear come from the shadows themselves, and all they can do is look at the wall and say <em>that’s life.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Later one of the prisoners is released, and able to stand up, turn around, and stumble toward the entrance. At first he is blinded by the light of the fire and the Sun, but eventually makes his way outside to see the real world, and comes to realize the shadows on the wall that he thought made up all of existence were just pale imitations of a far more abundant reality. When he returns to the cave to enlighten his fellow prisoners, they reject his account as insane, and would kill him if not for the fact that they were held back by their chains. The parallels to Mr. Square’s experiences are obvious, and I suspect Abbott had the Cave Allegory in mind when he wrote <em>Flatland</em>.</strong></p><p><strong>There are other examples of the same idea in the world of fiction. The movies <em>Tron,</em> <em>The Matrix, </em>and <em>The Truman Show</em> all cover similar ground, and feature characters who come to see that what they thought was real turned out to be an illusion. The digital revolution and the ubiquity of computers have made the prospect of a simulated reality that much more plausible. I’m old enough to remember the first generation of video games, and I’ve seen how those games have changed over just a few decades. What will they look like a century from now? Future games with a playing field indistinguishable from reality don’t seem all that farfetched.</strong></p><p><strong>Nick Bostrom, a professor of philosophy at Oxford University, takes that premise a step further. In 2003 he published “Are You Living in a Computer Simulation?” in the journal <em>Philosophical Quarterly</em>, and articles about his hypothesis would later appear in <em>The New York Times</em>. I’ve paraphrased the introduction from Bostrom’s paper below:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>In the future, the human race will likely build computers vastly more powerful than those available today. These future generations, curious about their ancestors, might have the means to create comprehensive computer models that simulate the past. These models would have enough sophistication to include virtual inhabitants who, while fully conscious, don’t realize they inhabit a simulation.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The speed and capacity of the computers would also permit the number of active historical simulations to run into the millions. In order to test various hypotheses, our descendants might launch each simulation with a different set of initial conditions, allowing each one to run its course without interference.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>If this is true, our own universe is more likely one of the simulated realities rather than the familiar world we mistakenly think of as real.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>I don’t know enough about computers to judge the plausibility of this idea, but I suspect the primary challenge in creating such a scenario would not be to construct a sufficiently detailed model of the environment, but to populate that environment with billions of fully sentient, simulated personalities. Despite the recent advances in artificial intelligence, there’s an ongoing academic debate as to whether general, all-purpose AI on a par with human intellect is actually possible. If it is, then the simulation hypothesis would be another conjecture that our local reality is only one facet of a broader existence. Could it be true? I don’t know. As with beauty, time, and God, I have no certainties, just a range of tentative opinions.</strong></p><p><strong>Assuming the simulation hypothesis as valid would have implications for just about every topic raised in this book. My first question would focus on the programmers responsible for the simulation. Who are they? Bostrom says they’d be our descendants, but other candidates are possible. Given that the simulation would include our history as well as our memories, neither of which we could trust, the programmers could just as easily be our ancestors as our descendants. For all we know, they might be highly evolved, intelligent dinosaurs, a species that escaped extinction, acquired the use of tools, and invented digital technology. Maybe a long time ago they received a grant to come up with a computer program modeling what would happen if an asteroid wiped out most of the dinosaurs, and our world is the result. Civilized dinosaurs could still rule the Earth in external reality — we just wouldn’t know it from inside our simulation. If we couldn’t trust any aspect of ourselves or our surroundings, there’s not much we could learn about the programmers. They might be ancestors, descendants, contemporaries, extraterrestrials, or intelligent machines, and we still wouldn’t know who was responsible for our existence.</strong></p><p><strong>Even if we couldn’t determine the programmers’ identity, just the discovery that we really do inhabit a simulation would be the mother of all paradigm shifts. It would prove that our universe is not the whole of reality, and that we’re here by design and not by accident. Why would the programmers build a simulator unless they intended to achieve some specific goal? Using a digital code to generate the underlying program would explain why mathematics is such an effective tool for describing and predicting “natural” phenomena. Since we seem to be on the verge of creating our own form of seamless virtual reality, it’s conceivable that the programmers who created us could be simulations themselves. Maybe <em>their</em> reality has been designed by another level of programmers operating even further behind the scenes. Simulated universes might exist on multiple levels, with the laws of physics varying from one level to another. One would assume that a foundational “basement” domain of creators existed somewhere, but even then, those in the basement could never be sure they were in fact the original programmers. The slightest indication that reality might be manufactured would spoil the experiment at any level, so safeguards to prevent detection would have to be built in from the outset. The inhabitants might or might not acquire the ability to evade those safeguards and discover the wider world existing beyond their own.</strong></p><p><strong>A simulated universe would not only imply that we’re under observation, but that we’re being documented as well. The writers of our program could save, delete, or copy any part of the output, and edit the narrative as they saw fit. Given that they might plan for subsequent editions, or cut and paste the most effective passages, an afterlife could be a real possibility. So could the prospect of reward and punishment handed down by the programmers. They’d essentially function as gods, intervening in the world to cultivate whatever outcome they deemed significant. The problem of evil might be part of the design, with adversity included, as it is in military boot camps, to strengthen and screen the participants. That principle is the foundation for much of religion: our present life of hardship is justified as a preparation for the hereafter.</strong></p><p><strong>In short, the simulation hypothesis addresses a great deal of what religion is supposed to address. If it turned out to be true, it would explain virtually everything, at least about this world, and give weight to the idea that death might not be the end. Even if it turned out to be false, it could still serve as a reflection of actual existence. If reality isn’t literally a computer program, computer programs might nevertheless mimic reality. An unknown, off-site intelligence could still have designed and launched the universe, and still have plans for its output.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>Abbott, Plato, and Bostrom all bring to mind the metaphor of the iceberg. They all suggest that our familiar existence could be just the visible tip of a much greater whole, most of which remains out of sight. This model holds true even if there is only a single universe operating under a single set of physical laws. Deep space remains obscure to us because the light from distant objects is still in transit, and has yet to reach the Earth. The stars appear now as they looked millions of years ago, when their light began the journey across the gulf separating us and them. The more distant the star, the older its image in our telescopes; what any star looks like at present is unknown. This holds true even for our own Sun, whose light takes about eight minutes to reach the Earth. The light from the star closest to the Sun takes about four years to get here, constantly streaming a picture to our eyes that is always four years old. Presumably what we haven’t yet seen is comparable to what we already have, but there’s no way to know for sure. The observable universe is likely just a tiny speck in the greater cosmos, even without the prospect of a multiverse.</strong></p><p><strong>Adding this uncertainty to topics already mentioned, we can list eight examples of the iceberg model, some of which overlap: Flatland, the Cave Allegory, the cosmic multiverse, the quantum multiverse, mathematical Platonism, the Zoo Hypothesis, the Simulation Argument, and finally the yet-to-arrive celestial images just described. The first two items on the list come from literature, but the others arguably qualify as scientific hypotheses.</strong></p><p><strong>I don’t know to what degree any of these ideas might be refuted or upheld by future investigation, but I do think the analogy of the iceberg has some bearing on the meaning of life. It makes little sense to call the universe bleak and pointless when we’re not sure how complete our present picture of existence really is. We haven’t even fully explained what we <em>can</em> observe, let alone what remains out of sight. As I said earlier, life would have meaning even if there were no God. It would have greater meaning if God existed but there were no afterlife. It would have the greatest meaning if God existed, we were here by design, and this life served as a prerequisite for the next one.</strong></p><p><strong>With that possibility in mind, if an afterlife awaits us, what would be the point of keeping it hidden? Could knowing death is not the end somehow spoil the life that precedes it? I think it could. If we knew for certain that an afterlife existed, it would diminish all the moments leading up to it. We’d race through this world in our haste to arrive at the next one. Some cult members do just that. Impatient for heaven, they commit suicide as a short cut to the hereafter, abandoning whatever they might have accomplished had they lived out their lives. Atheists occupy the other end of spectrum. As they see it, this life is all we have, and when it’s over, that’s it. They can live fulfilling lives and bring happiness to those around them, but in the end atheists expect only oblivion. Even if the good they do lives after them, in the long run humanity itself will disappear in the ashes of a dying universe.</strong></p><p><strong>I stand between those two extremes. I don’t know what happens when people die, but the idea of an afterlife matters to me in that how I consider it changes how I live my life now. I value this existence because it might end, but I value it even more because it might not. I know I’m happier with the hope that death might be a beginning as well as an end. If it turns out that my memories and my self-awareness permanently vanish at the close of life, I won’t be around to know it. On the other hand, if death really is a threshold to another place, then my hopes will have been justified. In the meantime, I live with the ambiguity. I refuse, in view of my own ignorance, to abandon hope altogether, and I suspect that even diehard atheists sometimes wonder if oblivion is as certain as they think.</strong></p><p><strong>In the 17th century, the French mathematician Blaise Pascal modeled this dilemma as a straightforward demonstration in decision theory. The result was the famous “Pascal’s Wager,” which Richard Dawkins summarized as follows:</strong></p><p><strong><em>You’d better believe in God, because if you are right you stand to gain eternal bliss and if you are wrong it won’t make any difference anyway. On the other hand, if you don’t believe in God and you turn out to be wrong you get eternal damnation, whereas if you are right it makes no difference. On the face of it the decision is a no brainer. Believe in God.</em></strong></p><p><strong>I once had a teacher sketch the argument as a diagram on the blackboard:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Resolved: <em>I believe in God.</em></strong></p><p><strong>If God exists, I go to heaven.</strong></p><p><strong>If God does not exist, I have no gain or loss</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Resolved: <em>I do not believe in God</em></strong></p><p><strong>If God exists, I go to hell.</strong></p><p><strong>If God does not exist, I have no gain or loss</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>I agree with Dawkins that the premise is flawed, as well as the implication that Pascal may have suggested it somewhat tongue-in-cheek. It is, after all, cast as a “wager,” not a doctrine or principle. Belief is not something one can turn on and off with a switch, or place like a bet at a gaming table. Furthermore, Pascal seems to refer specifically to the God of Christianity. Not all gods demand belief as a requirement for salvation, or threaten eternal agony as punishment for disbelief. Maybe a different deity would place greater value on honest skepticism, or find blind faith particularly offensive.</strong></p><p><strong>Nevertheless, I do think that a modified form of Pascal’s Wager can make sense. Following the same format as the diagram above, if one substitutes “hope” for “belief” and “afterlife” for “God,” it shifts the emphasis from heaven and hell to the here and now:</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Resolved: <em>I hope for an afterlife.</em></strong></p><p><strong>If an afterlife exists, I go there after death.</strong></p><p><strong>If an afterlife does not exist, I still live with hope.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Resolved: <em>I do not hope for an afterlife.</em></strong></p><p><strong>If an afterlife exists, I go there after death.</strong></p><p><strong>If an afterlife does not exist, I still live without hope.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>The original wager casts belief as a strict choice between yes and no, but I think of hope as more of a spectrum. Even though the second diagram doesn’t show any intermediate stages, expanding it to include varying degrees of hopefulness wouldn’t change the outcome regarding an afterlife. Hope, whatever its measure, shapes this life, not the next. I’m hopeful more often than not, but I don’t choose hope like an entree on a restaurant menu. It’s not so much a choice as it is part of my temperament. Whether I’d feel the same way if religion hadn’t been such a significant part of my childhood, I don’t know. In any case, I’m inclined toward optimism, and if that comes from my upbringing, then I’m grateful for it.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>So ends my sermon on the prospect of an afterlife. If my long-ago Sunday school teachers could read it now, some would call it blasphemy, but some would be sympathetic. An atheist, on the other hand, would probably consider it just one more elaborate psychological defense mechanism erected to guard against the knowledge of death. That could very well be the case — I’ve said all along that I don’t dismiss that possibility out of hand. I only hope that any reader who might see these pages can come away with something useful.</strong></p><p><strong>At the beginning of this chapter, I mentioned that even though I don’t know if my parents can see me from beyond the grave, I’m better off assuming they can. The benefit of that assumption outweighs any doubt over whether or not it’s true. I use it as a kind of mental exercise — <em>what would my parents say about this?</em> — whenever I need to take action or make a decision. If they really can see me, then I have a chance to make them proud. If they can’t, the behavior that would make them proud is still almost always the best course of action. I win either way. Using that principle as a benchmark, I can expand it to take in the prospect of an afterlife as a whole.</strong></p><p><strong>If death really is a passage to another place, I’m glad I’ve always been open to that possibility. I’ve tried to live under the assumption that my behavior now could have consequences later, and that I might have the chance to use what I’ve learned here in the hereafter. On the other hand, if death is truly the end, then that same code of conduct has still served me well in this life. Again, I win either way. I’m not troubled by doubt, or by the awareness of approaching death. On the contrary, I live with hope.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>3. Raising the Children</em></strong></p><p><strong>When I was around eight or nine years old, my parents asked me to sit down with my brothers in the living room for a talk. I didn’t realize it at the time, but this would turn out to be <em>the</em> talk. I guess we already had a general idea of where babies came from, but my mother and father added certain details and cleared up a number of misconceptions. If they dreaded that day, as many parents do, I don’t remember them showing it, or us kids being embarrassed. As I recall they did a good job. Although we would have further, unplanned conversations about different aspects of human reproduction in the years that followed, never again did we all sit down for a heart-to-heart family discussion on just that subject.</strong></p><p><strong>Our family talks about religion were different. Instead of getting together on one special occasion, we learned about church a little at a time over many years. I don’t remember any specific introduction to Jesus — he was more or less always there, hovering in the background. Religion was so pervasive in our house that I just took it for granted, picking up details without really thinking about them. We had a set of Arthur Maxwell’s <em>The Bible Story</em>, which I mentioned earlier, and I remember listening to my mother read parts aloud while we looked at the pictures. But that came later, after my brothers and I had moved on from the nursery room at church and into our first Sunday school classrooms. We never had the equivalent of “the talk” when it came to religion.</strong></p><p><strong>That wasn’t the case for our own kids. My wife Jennifer and I did sit them down on one particular afternoon for the sole purpose of discussing belief, and it happened the week after a terrible accident in our neighborhood. Our youngest child was in third grade, and his classmate died when a drunk driver entered the highway from the wrong direction and collided head-on with the car carrying my son’s friend. The boy, his parents, and the driver all died at the scene. The boy’s younger sister, home with her grandparents at the time, became an orphan. The deaths stunned the neighborhood, especially the grade-school students who’d known the family well. In the days after the accident, we weren’t the only parents struggling to help their kids make sense of what happened.</strong></p><p><strong>Prior to this, our children had only vague ideas about religion. That was by intent. Jennifer grew up in a household similar to mine, and we didn’t want our kids snowed under at church the way we’d been. They’d seen several weddings, and we had a family tradition of going to the Christmas Eve service in a different church every year, but that was about it for church attendance. This wasn’t due to laziness or procrastination, but entirely on purpose. We didn’t <em>want</em> our children in Sunday school. We wanted their introduction to Jesus to be on a par with their introduction to George Washington and Christopher Columbus. On the rare occasions they asked religious questions on their own, we dealt with them in noncommittal terms, avoiding the claims for divine revelation that our Sunday school teachers were so quick to apply. Postponing the big questions while they were young, we wanted them to be old enough to consider those matters for themselves.</strong></p><p><strong>Then came the road accident that took the lives of our friends. In the days that followed, every child in the neighborhood heard an adult say that the boy and his parents were in heaven now. Our whole family attended the funeral, which was crowded with scores of children and their parents. The service ended with a graveside gathering around the three coffins prepared for burial. After coming home, Jen and I sat the kids down in the living room for the talk we’d anticipated since before they were born. Our youngest was eight years old, his sister was eleven, and her older brother was twelve. The conversation lasted more than an hour.</strong></p><p><strong>We started by emphasizing that people around the world had different ideas about heaven, and those differences depended on the time and place where they lived. Still, even when people disagreed, their beliefs had much in common. We showed them pictures of Stone Age burial sites, saying that the graves often contained tools and other belongings placed alongside the people who had died. Their families and friends believed that they would need those things in another life. This happened thousands of years ago, all over the world, among groups too far apart to have known each other. Prehistoric people seemed to have an instinct about an afterlife long before anyone thought of planting crops or raising cities.</strong></p><p><strong>We had them compare pictures of religious buildings and monuments across the globe, reiterating that people in different parts of the world often developed similar ideas about God. We told them about Abraham, Buddha, Confucius, Jesus, and Muhammad, pointing to the birthplace of each on a map. They’d heard of the last two, but not the others. We stressed that all these founders of the world’s major religions lived far apart and long ago, and although they all believed in heaven, they didn’t always agree about the details. Some, for example, thought that when people died their souls went straight to heaven, while others thought that before going there the soul lived through many different lives on here on Earth. We stressed that their own parents didn’t know exactly what happened after death, comparing our lack of knowledge about the afterlife to our lack of knowledge about life on other planets. In both cases, we didn’t know about the details, but we had good reason to think that both ideas were true.</strong></p><p><strong>Of course the kids had questions, and we took them all one by one. Who exactly is God? What is a soul? Where is heaven? They wanted to know what their friend and his parents were doing at that exact moment, and we said we didn’t know. We said it was like they’d taken a trip to a different country, only they weren’t coming back, and we had no way of contacting them. We could imagine what they were doing, but there was no way to know for sure. We told them that most of the founders of the world’s religions had written stories about what they thought God and heaven were like. Parts of these stories, however, were so different from one other that we believed they were mostly guesses rather than certain knowledge. Still, some people argued, sometimes violently, about which religion was best. We their parents didn’t worry about how the world’s religions were different, but instead kept in mind how much they were alike. All religions said that the world was made on purpose, we were put here to help each other, and we would find out about the afterlife when we died.</strong></p><p><strong>My wife and I gave our children more food for thought in that one hour than we ever had before in their lives. Later on, much later, there would be further discussions about faith, reason, science, free will, suffering, sacrifice, nonbelief, agnosticism, sin, martyrdom, and hell, among other topics, but on that afternoon those were all in the future. The kids were too young to think about any of that now. We hoped that we’d made a good start, helping them cope with the deaths of their neighbors while at the same time avoiding the indoctrination we’d both gone through in our own childhoods.</strong></p><p><strong>I think we made the deepest impression when Jennifer shared a quote from an interview with Albert Einstein, reading aloud the following passage (slightly edited for a younger audience):</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong><em>We are [like] a little child, entering a huge library whose walls are covered to the ceiling with books in many different [languages]. The child knows that someone must have written those books. It does not know who or how. It does not understand the [words] in which they are written. The child [senses] a definite plan in the arrangement of the books, a mysterious order, which it does not [understand], but only dimly suspects. That, it seems to me, is the attitude of the human mind . . . toward God.</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>The human race on Earth, my wife said, is like that child in the library. She repeated the passage in paraphrase, putting it in the language of a third-grader, and compared it to a walk in the woods we’d all taken a few weeks earlier. Remember the trees and the animals? The sun, the wind, the clouds? They all came from somewhere. We don’t know exactly how or why, but we can sense a harmony in the world, and we’re grateful for it. All religions, no matter how different, have that in common.</strong></p><p><strong>When she finished speaking, their silence — and the looks on their faces — meant more to us than any other part of the afternoon. A few minutes later they scattered to go their separate ways. Jen and I sat a while longer, hoping we’d helped prepare the ground for their future deliberations. In the months afterwards, we made it a point to visit different houses of worship in our area. Most every school of faith has a street address somewhere in Cleveland, and we went to see many of them. Although the kids weren’t always eager to go, I know that later they appreciated it.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>I wish my own childhood experience with religion had been closer to that of my kids. As it was, I found church a mixed blessing. On one hand, it made me think about questions I never would have considered on my own, but on the other it demanded that I see everything through the lens of revealed religion. My parents mitigated that perspective, telling us repeatedly that we should value both religion <em>and</em> science. Not everyone at church would have agreed with that. As I grew older, I wondered why my mother sent us there in the first place, given the reservations she had about what they taught. Only later, after I’d left church altogether, did I come to realize how hard my grandparents had pushed to have us in Sunday school from the beginning. Jen once asked me if I thought we’d been brainwashed as kids. I suppose we were, some of the time anyway, although much of life is brainwashing, and not all brainwashing is necessarily bad.</strong></p><p><strong>Take an example familiar to everyone. Santa Claus is an imaginary character that nearly all parents present to their children as real. My family was no exception, and as preschoolers my brothers and I put out cookies for Santa every Christmas Eve, gaping in amazement the next morning at the sight of the thank-you note and the crumbs on the empty plate. That was powerful evidence, and I know we weren’t alone in being convinced by it. Does it do any harm to encourage such a fiction when they’re so young? I doubt it. In fact, I think <em>not</em> teaching about Santa Claus is probably worse in the long run. Few families, at least in the United States, have the option of ignoring the Santa tradition — it’s impossible to avoid in the weeks leading up to Christmas. If parents decide to opt out, and maintain that Santa does not exist, they have to somehow explain to their children why all their friends are being conned, as well as expect a great deal of resentment from the other families in the neighborhood. I’d say it’s better to let kids participate than force them to be left out. Even though Jen and I talked about this at length between ourselves, we never seriously considered denying Santa Claus to our children. I guess that would qualify as brainwashing, but it’s also part of growing up in America, and we didn’t lose any sleep over it.</strong></p><p><strong>How much one can compare Santa Claus to Sunday school is another matter. As far as I could tell, all of the adults in my church took the story of Noah’s Ark as the literal truth. One middle-aged teacher went so far as to tell us that dinosaur fossils could be explained by the fact that God had excluded dinosaurs from the Ark. Would that count as brainwashing? I know for a fact that that particular teacher accepted every detail of the story — including the explanation for rainbows — at face value. I doubt he still believed in Santa Claus, but he certainly believed in Noah’s Ark. That would be entirely his prerogative, except that he was misleading a bunch of little kids who didn’t know any better. Of course most adults do the same with Santa Claus, but the difference is that adults <em>know</em> Santa isn’t real, and expect children to grow out of a childhood fantasy.</strong></p><p><strong>That’s not the case when it comes to Noah and the Flood. Many adults desperately desire that children — <em>all</em> children, not just their own — accept the account as historical fact, and insist they believe it throughout their entire lives. They dismiss any observation that casts doubt on the story, such as the fact that the dimensions of the Ark given in Genesis would never have provided enough space to house even a tiny fraction of the number of animals claimed. Any wooden ship large enough to accommodate them all would have broken apart under its own weight. These objections, and others like them, are ignored or glossed over.</strong></p><p><strong>In my case, my mother and father both interpreted the Flood as an allegory, but they didn’t actually make that clear until I was older, probably because they wanted to avoid trouble with my grandparents. Looking back now, I think a literal reading of Santa Claus and a literal reading of Noah’s Ark are about equally plausible, and my Sunday school teachers, at least when it came to the Flood, were engaged in the worst kind of brainwashing. It’s one thing to tell the story as a parable or a metaphor, but to teach it to teenagers as authentic history defies common sense, and sets a powerful precedent to abandon critical thinking in general. Yet millions of people all over the world still believe that Noah existed exactly as described. There are even large-scale models of the Ark that visitors can pay admission to see, with many bringing their kids along on the tour.</strong></p><p><strong>Parents nearly always have the right to teach their children as they see fit, but some conduct goes beyond any argument for religious liberty or parental rights. No court would consider taking a preschooler to a replica of Noah’s Ark as child abuse, but other circumstances do fit that definition. Stephen King’s novel <em>Carrie</em>, for example, includes an account of a fanatically religious mother who locks her daughter Carrie in a closet as punishment for what the mother considers sinful behavior. The closet is lit by a dim blue light, and painted scenes of hell cover the walls, with the faces of the damned contorted in agony as they writhe in the flames. The teenage Carrie has been repeatedly subjected to these “lessons,” which often last for hours, since she was a toddler. King’s story is fiction, but if that occurred in the real world, I’d hope a court would call it abuse and intervene on behalf of the child.</strong></p><p><strong>And yet a similar spectacle is not only legal but popular in parts of the United States. Some evangelical churches offer what they call <em>Hell Houses</em> — theatrical displays similar to the haunted houses that appear around Halloween, but with a religious theme, and open the year round. Attendees, many of them young children, can witness actors in staged depictions of hell, screaming in torment while crew members fan the smell of fire and brimstone onto the audience from behind the set. I suppose Hell Houses aren’t considered abuse because the children are not confined, and free to leave at any time, but don’t their parents bring them there in the first place? I’m sure there have been instances when the kids wanted to leave but the adults forced them to stay. My own parents would have been appalled.</strong></p><p><strong>Other cases are clearly crimes, or should be. Christian Scientists and Jehovah’s Witnesses routinely withhold lifesaving medical care from their children because of their faith, which can become a legal issue depending on when and where it occurs. My impression is that the courts tend to take the side of religious freedom in such cases. I think any adult has the right to refuse medical care, but it becomes an entirely different matter when a parent makes that decision for a child, particularly a very young child. I’d call that gross neglect, not religious freedom.</strong></p><p><strong>I feel pulled in different directions on this subject. How other parents raise their children in terms of religion is none of my business. On the other hand, if I found out that my next-door neighbors were locking their child in a closet mock-up of hell, I’m pretty sure I’d report it. Fortunately cases like that are rare, and most of the time another parent’s religious instruction to a child remains none of my business. That’s not to say, however, that I have no opinion on the subject.</strong></p><p><strong>Millions of American children are homeschooled in the name of religion every year, and while many of those kids thrive, many suffer because of it. Sometimes home schooling means no schooling at all, with the kids kept at home only to take care of younger siblings. Sometimes it means nonstop Sunday school, with the academic subjects abandoned altogether. Those particular students might learn that the Earth is flat and the Tooth Fairy is one of the devil’s many helpers. As sorry as I feel for those kids, I wouldn’t campaign to ban home schooling. I’d be open to the idea of regulation, but given the number of families involved, as well as the opposition it would entail, I’m not sure regulation is possible.</strong></p><p><strong>Our own children are in their late 20s and early 30s now, and the grandkids are all preteens — about the same age their parents were when our neighbors died in the car accident. They attend public school and visit church only occasionally. Although we don’t interfere with what our grandkids learn about religion, their parents seem to have taken to heart our talk in the living room all those years ago. I was proud of my children on that day, even though I knew at the time we were only giving them part of the picture. No real discussion of religion can avoid the subject of atheism, and the possibility that any concept of a creator is only a figment of the imagination. But would we really want to bring that up when they were so young? Especially in the wake of their friend’s death? Jen and I were not about to look them in the eye and submit that the universe is pointless, death is the end, and there is no hope in the long run. Even if I knew all that to be true, I’d never say any of it to a third grader.</strong></p><p><strong>Still, we didn’t lie to them. I don’t think we imposed a watered-down version of the brainwashing my wife and I went through in our own childhoods. We offered hope but no certitudes. We did what we set out to do: help our children cope with their first experience of death, and set the stage for them to form their own opinions later in life.</strong></p><p><strong>* * *</strong></p><p><strong>When my brothers and I were little, every couple of months we’d spend the night at my grandparents’ house. Not only did that give our mom and dad a break, but it was a treat for us too, and we always looked forward to it. In the evening, after putting on our pajamas and brushing our teeth, we’d all sit in the living room, the kids watching TV while the adults read the newspaper. Looking through the obituaries was part of their routine, and Nana would make comments to Papa about the people they’d known who had died. I remember thinking how strange that was — none of my friends had ever died, and here it seemed their friends were dying all the time. Of course I knew that eventually it happened to everyone, but I was still just a little kid, and it hadn’t yet sunk in that one day my grandparents would be gone.</strong></p><p><strong>Now, more than fifty years later, I’m about the same age they were then, and the same newspaper is available online, and I find myself following the same routine. If a doctor told me I had six months to live, I’m sure I’d spend a part of those six months looking back at the obituaries of people I grew up with, remembering our school days together, and knowing that they’d already gone through something I’d soon be going through myself. Some might find that morbid, but for me, when the time comes, I know I’ll take comfort in it.</strong></p><p><strong>My parents both died in their middle fifties, and I’m almost a decade older than that now. I might have ten good years left, maybe longer, but no matter what happens, the end is in sight. It’s inevitable, and there’s only one part of it that really bothers me. Jen and I are about the same age, and since we probably won’t die at the same time, whoever dies first has no choice but to leave the other behind. Just thinking about that makes me ill. There are only two possible scenarios, both horrifying, and I don’t know which one is worse. It doesn’t surprise me at all when I hear of two people married for half a century dying just a few days apart; I can imagine, now more than ever, the last hours of the widowed spouse. Still, that’s part of what Jen and I signed up for, and we both understand that bereavement is a small price to pay for a lifetime of intimacy. We have all our affairs in order, and the kids will know exactly what to do when the time comes.</strong></p><p><strong>I don’t think about that very often, but there is one side to growing older that I didn’t expect. When I was in grade school, the holidays were always a big deal. I know that’s true for many families, but it seemed especially true in our house. My mom and dad went out of their way to make sure we’d have vivid memories of every Christmas. The anticipation started around Thanksgiving, and steadily escalated in the weeks leading up to December 25th. We had music and lights and shopping for gifts; the first snowfall of the season; picking out a tree and then bringing it home to decorate the same day; Rudolph and Santa and Charlie Brown on TV; a long vacation on the horizon; and classroom parties at school and Sunday school. On Christmas Eve the whole family went to church, where the minister would light a single candle in the darkened sanctuary, then touch the flame to the unlit candles held by the ushers, who then touched their candles to those of the waiting congregation. The light spread through the pews, and when the last candle was lit, we all sang Silent Night. What could be lovelier than that?</strong></p><p><strong>After the service, my brothers and I went with our parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins to visit the homes of each family in turn. Every house, including our own, glowed inside and out, and thirty or forty people would crowd into the kitchens and living rooms, sharing food and good will before moving on to the next stop. It lasted until midnight, and a whole month of expectation was nearing its peak. I knew that before the sun came up I’d be back home again, opening presents with my family.</strong></p><p><strong>The point is that lately I feel the same way. I don’t mean just around the holidays, but in every month of the year. I have the same sense of anticipation now as a grandfather that I had as a kid every December, when I knew the big day was coming, and I was just marking time until it arrived. Strangely enough, when I think about my life coming to an end, I get the same butterflies in my stomach I had as an eight-year-old the week before Christmas. I don’t know if I’ll ever see my departed loved ones again, but I <em>might</em>, and thinking about that brings back a bittersweet echo of childhood. If the rituals of December celebrate the close of a single year, maybe the rituals of growing old celebrate the close of a whole life. Once again, I know the big day is coming, only this time it probably won’t fall on the 25th of December. Of course this whole notion might be just a lingering remnant of Sunday school, but the flutter in my stomach says otherwise. In the meantime, it’s a joy beyond words to watch my grandchildren grow up, at Christmas and every other occasion, knowing they’re making their own memories, and knowing my wife and I will be a part of them.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>NOTES <em>for the Chapter 11 excerpts</em></strong></p><p><strong>p.2 “it may be apocryphal.” : (Stenger 90; Hitchens 67)</strong></p><p><strong>2 “doesn’t exclude a god, but”<em> </em>:<em> </em>(Sagan, <em>Broca</em> 291)</strong></p><p><strong>4 “tolerance for ambiguity” : (Sagan, <em>Varieties</em> 156)</strong></p><p><strong>4 “a seven-point scale” : (Dawkins, <em>Delusion</em> 50)</strong></p><p><strong>5 “does qualify his view on agnosticism” : (Dawkins, <em>Delusion</em> 47)</strong></p><p><strong>7 “in order to foster a false hope.” : (Gardner, <em>Whys</em> 201)</strong></p><p><strong>7 “there may not even be a why.” : (Vonnegut 77)</strong></p><p><strong>7 “a rock so big that” (Carlin, audio recording). The basic argument goes back to antiquity.</strong></p><p><strong>10 “a measure of accident and error” (Herbert 277)</strong></p><p><strong>10 “older than Christianity” : (Gardner, <em>Whys </em>243)</strong></p><p><strong>15 “A key part of his work challenges” : (Falk 170)</strong></p><p><strong>16 “no universal ‘right now.’” : (Falk 166)</strong></p><p><strong>16 “at 14,000 kilometers per hour” : (Pogge)</strong></p><p><strong>16 “must compensate for the disparity” : (Ashby, Falk 174)</strong></p><p><strong>17 “celluloid underlying a movie” : (Gardner, <em>Whys</em> 109)</strong></p><p><strong>17 “a substantial number of philosophers” : (Falk 171)</strong></p><p><strong>18 “pseudoimmortality of block time” : (Gardner, <em>Whys </em>281)</strong></p><p><strong>18 “Not all physicists agree” : (Gardner, <em>Whys</em> 109, Al-Khalili 56)</strong></p><p><strong>19 “I understand a resolution” : (Falk 199, Al-Khalili 148)</strong></p><p><strong>20 “a phenomenon called <em>superposition</em>.” : (Al-Khalili 22)</strong></p><p><strong>20 “one of these tentative explanations” : (Al-Khalili 148)</strong></p><p><strong>20 “actually a point of overlap” : (Al-Khalili 147)</strong></p><p><strong>20 “much as pages in a book” : (Heinlein, <em>Glory</em>, 71)</strong></p><p><strong>21 “take <em>both</em> forks in a road.” : (Al-Khalili 23)</strong></p><p><strong>21 “an immense maze of branching realities. : (Falk 200, Al-Khalili 148)</strong></p><p><strong>24 “the ability to replicate themselves” : (Davies, <em>Eerie</em> 110)</strong></p><p><strong>28 “where is everybody?” : (Davis, <em>Eerie</em> 116)</strong></p><p><strong>29 “sometimes called the Zoo Hypothesis : (Shostak; Sagan, <em>Varieties</em> 238)</strong></p><p><strong>30 “the Zoo Hypothesis and the ‘Prime Directive’” : (Shostak)</strong></p><p><strong>31 “the Commissioner of Baseball” : The idea of God as Commissioner of Baseball lies at the heart of Robert Coover’s 1968 novel <em>The Universal Baseball Association, Inc.</em></strong></p><p><strong>33 “maybe the artist is more concerned” : (Stapledon, <em>Star Maker</em> 425)</strong></p><p><strong>34 “the silence of the dead” : <em>(</em>Gardner<em>, Whys </em>273<em>)</em></strong></p><p><strong>36 “how Mozart and Shakespeare made their livings” : (Dawkins, <em>Delusion</em> 86)</strong></p><p><strong>40 “Intuition is a dubious guide, but” : (Clarke, <em>Imperial </em>35)</strong></p><p><strong>40 “Can a gut feeling” : (Sagan, <em>Demon</em> 180; Dawkins, <em>Delusion</em> 47)</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>NOTES <em>for the Chapter 12 excerpts</em></strong></p><p><strong>p.2 “prayer is necessarily foolish” : (Gardner, <em>Whys</em> 224)</strong></p><p><strong>10 “lurid interpretation of biblical prophecy” : (Lindsey)</strong></p><p><strong>11 “the doctrine of hell” : (Gardner, <em>Whys</em> 301)</strong></p><p><strong>14 “Edwin Abbott (1839–1926)” : (Clute 1)</strong></p><p><strong>15 “much like a paper map” : (Abbott 4)</strong></p><p><strong>15 “a place called Lineland” : (Abbott 54)</strong></p><p><strong>15 “a visitor from Spaceland” : (Abbott 68)</strong></p><p><strong>16 “wonders if the sequence continues” : (Abbott 90)</strong></p><p><strong>16 “a place called <em>Thoughtland</em>“ : (Abbott 91)</strong></p><p><strong>17 “just as tangible” : (Abbott 95)</strong></p><p><strong>17 “what we don’t know, or even <em>can</em> know.” : (Haldane 286)</strong></p><p><strong>17 “allows for a kind of freedom.” : (Shermer 272)</strong></p><p><strong>20 “the famous Allegory of the Cave.” :<em> </em>(Perry 87)</strong></p><p><strong>22 “appear in <em>The New York Times</em>.” : (Manjoo, Overbye)</strong></p><p><strong>22 “paraphrased the introduction” : (Bostrom I)</strong></p><p><strong>25 “could be simulations themselves.” : (Bostrom VI)</strong></p><p><strong>26 “an afterlife could be a real possibility.” : (Bostrom VI)</strong></p><p><strong>26 “the prospect of reward and punishment” : (Bostrom VI)</strong></p><p><strong>26 “essentially function as gods” : (Bostrom VI)</strong></p><p><strong>29 “I don’t know what happens when people die” : (Browne)</strong></p><p><strong>30 “You’d better believe in God, because” : (Dawkins<em>, Delusion </em>103)</strong></p><p><strong>31 “place greater value on honest skepticism” : (Dawkins<em>, Delusion </em>104)</strong></p><p><strong>40 “We are [like] a little child, entering a huge library” : (Viereck 372)</strong></p><p><strong>46 “’lessons,’ which often last for hours” : (King 46)</strong></p><p><strong>46 “Hell Houses” : (Dawkins, <em>Delusion</em> 319)</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>SOURCES <em>for all of NORTH COAST</em></strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Abbott, Edwin A.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Dover, 1952</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Al-Khalili, Jim</strong></p><p><strong><em>Quantum: A Guide for the Perplexed</em></strong></p><p><strong>London: Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson, 2003</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Ashby, Neil</strong></p><p><strong>“Relativity in the Global Positioning System,”</strong></p><p><strong>Living Reviews in Relativity, 6, (2003)</strong></p><p><a href="http://www.livingreviews.org/lrr-2003-1"><strong>http://www.livingreviews.org/lrr-2003-1</strong></a></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Asimov, Isaac</strong></p><p><strong>“The Unblind Workings of Chance”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Only a Trillion</em> (Chapter 7)</strong></p><p><strong>New York: Ace, 1957, 1976</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Baraniuk, Chris</strong></p><p><strong>“The Cyborg Chess Players That Can’t Be Beaten”</strong></p><p><strong>4 December 2015</strong></p><p><strong>bbc.com</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Barlow, Connie, ed.</strong></p><p><strong>Excerpts from James Lovelock</strong></p><p><strong><em>From Gaia to Selfish Genes: Selected Writings in the Life Sciences</em></strong></p><p><strong>Cambridge: MIT Press, 1991</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Blatty, William Peter</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Exorcist</em> (1973 film)</strong></p><p><strong>Screenplay based on his 1971 novel</strong></p><p><strong>Directed by William Friedkin</strong></p><p><strong>Warner Brothers, 1973</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Bostrom, Nick</strong></p><p><strong>“Are You Living in a Computer Simulation?”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Philosophical Quarterly</em> (2003) Vol. 53, №211.</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.simulation-argument.com/"><strong>www.simulation-argument.com</strong></a></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Browne, Jackson</strong></p><p><strong>“For a Dancer”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Late for the Sky</em> (audio recording)</strong></p><p><strong>New York: Elektra/Asylum, 1974</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Buchert, Jean-Marc</strong></p><p><strong>“Advanced/Cyborg Chess: How Chess Players and</strong></p><p><strong>Machines Can Work Together”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Man Plus Machines</em></strong></p><p><strong>May 13, 2021</strong></p><p><a href="https://manplusmachines.com/advanced-chess-human-computer-skills/"><strong>manplusmachines.com</strong></a></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Carlin, George</strong></p><p><strong><em>Class Clown </em>(audio recording)</strong></p><p><strong>New York: Little David, 1972</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — -</p><p><strong>Clark, John, gen. ed.</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Essential Dictionary of Science</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Barnes, 2004</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Clarke, Arthur C.</strong></p><p><strong><em>2001: A Space Odyssey </em>(novel)</strong></p><p><strong>New York: Penguin, 1968</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Clarke, Arthur C.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Childhood’s End</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Ballantine, 1953</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Clarke, Arthur C.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Imperial Earth</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Ballantine, 1976</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Clarke, Arthur C.</strong></p><p><strong>“The Obsolescence of Man”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Profiles of the Future </em>(Chapter 18)</strong></p><p><strong>New York: Harper &amp; Row, 1973</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Clute, John; Nicholls, Peter</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: St. Martin’s Griffin, 1993</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Coover, Robert</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Universal Baseball Association, Inc.</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Penguin, 1968</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Darwin, Charles Robert</strong></p><p><strong>Letter to J.D. Hooker 1871</strong></p><p><strong>Darwin Correspondence Project, Letter no. 7471</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-7471.xml"><strong>https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-7471.xml</strong></a></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Davies, Paul</strong></p><p><strong><em>Cosmic Jackpot</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2007</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Davies, Paul</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Eerie Silence</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2010</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Dawkins, Richard</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Blind Watchmaker</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: W.W. Norton, 1986</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Dawkins, Richard</strong></p><p><strong><em>The God Delusion</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2006</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Dawkins, Richard</strong></p><p><strong><em>Growing Up in the Universe</em> (television broadcast)</strong></p><p><strong>London: BBC, 1991</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Edis, Tanner</strong></p><p><strong><em>Science and Nonbelief</em></strong></p><p><strong>Amherst: Prometheus, 2008</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Ekeland, Ivar</strong></p><p><strong><em>Mathematics and the Unexpected</em></strong></p><p><strong>Chicago, London: University of Chicago, 1988</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Falk, Dan</strong></p><p><strong><em>In Search of Time</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: St. Martin’s, 2008</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Fiore, Michele; Strazewski, Peter</strong></p><p><strong>“Prebiotic Lipidic Amphiphiles and Condensing Agents on the Early Earth.”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Life</em> 2016, vol.<em>6</em>.</strong></p><p><a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/life6020017"><strong>https://doi.org/10.3390/life6020017</strong></a></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>“Galileo and the Mathematics of Motion; Part I: The Inclined Plane Experiments”</strong></p><p><a href="http://www.mcm.edu/academic/galileo/ars/arshtml/"><strong>http://www.mcm.edu/academic/galileo/ars/arshtml/</strong></a></p><p><a href="http://www.mcm.edu/academic/galileo/ars/arshtml/%20%20%20mathofmotion1.html"><strong>mathofmotion1.html</strong></a></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Gardner, Martin</strong></p><p><strong><em>Gardner’s Whys and Wherefores</em></strong></p><p><strong>Amherst: Prometheus, 1999</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Gardner, Martin</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Jinn from Hyperspace</em></strong></p><p><strong>Amherst: Prometheus, 2008</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Gardner, Martin</strong></p><p><strong><em>When You Were a Tadpole and I Was a Fish</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Farrar, Straus, &amp; Giroux, 2009</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Gardner, Martin</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Whys of a Philosophical Scrivener</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: St. Martin’s Griffin, 1983, 1999</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Gatti, Roberto Cazzolla</strong></p><p><strong>“Gaia, our planet, is alive and we are its spermatozoon, a new study suggests”</strong></p><p><a href="https://robertocazzollagatti.com/2018/08/13/"><strong>https://robertocazzollagatti.com/2018/08/13</strong></a></p><p><strong>August 13, 2018</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Gould, Stephen Jay</strong></p><p><strong><em>Bully for Brontosaurus</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: W.W. Norton, 1991</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Haldane, J.B.S.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Possible Worlds and Other Essays</em></strong></p><p><strong>London: Chatto and Windus, 1927</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Heinlein, Robert</strong></p><p><strong><em>Glory Road</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Berkley, 1963</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Heinlein, Robert</strong></p><p><strong><em>Stranger in a Strange Land</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Berkley, 1961</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Herbert, Frank</strong></p><p><strong><em>Dune</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Ace, 1965</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Hitchens, Christopher</strong></p><p><strong><em>god is not Great</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Hachette, 2007</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Hoyle, Frederick</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Intelligent Universe</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Holt, 1983</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Huang, Tina</strong></p><p><strong>“Why Computer-Assisted Humans Are The Best Chess</strong></p><p><strong>Players — And What That Means For Technology Operations”</strong></p><p><strong>January 7, 2022</strong></p><p><strong>forbes.com</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>King, Stephen</strong></p><p><strong><em>Carrie</em></strong></p><p><strong>Garden City: Doubleday, 1974</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Lindsey, Hal; Carlson, Carole C.</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Late Great Planet Earth</em></strong></p><p><strong>Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1970</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>March, Robert H.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Physics for Poets</em></strong></p><p><strong>Chicago: McGraw-Hill, 1978</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Manjoo, Farhad</strong></p><p><strong>“Opinion / We Might Be in a Simulation. How Much Should That Worry Us?”</strong></p><p><strong><em>The New York Times</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jan. 26, 2022</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Nisen, Max</strong></p><p><strong>“Humans Are On The Verge Of Losing One Of Their Last Big Advantages Over Computers”</strong></p><p><strong>November 5, 2013</strong></p><p><strong>businessinsider.com</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Oro, J.</strong></p><p><strong>“Chemical Synthesis of Lipids and the Origin of Life.”</strong></p><p><a href="https://link.springer.com/journal/10867"><strong><em>Journal of Biological Physics</em></strong></a><strong> 1995, vol. 20.</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Overbye, Dennis</strong></p><p><strong>“Are We Living in a Computer Simulation, and Can We Hack It?</strong></p><p><strong><em>The New York Times</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jan. 17, 2023</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Palmer, R. R.; Colton, Joel</strong></p><p><strong><em>A History of the Modern World</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: McGraw-Hill, 1995</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Perry, Marvin, ed., et. al.</strong></p><p><strong>Excerpts from Plato’s <em>Republic</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Sources of the Western Tradition</em>, vol. I</strong></p><p><strong>Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1987</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Pogge, Richard W.</strong></p><p><strong>“Real-World Relativity: The GPS Navigation System”</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.astronomy.ohio-ate.edu/">https://www.astronomy.ohio-ate.edu/</a></p><p><strong>pogge.1/Ast162/Unit5/gps.html 2017</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Preston, Richard</strong></p><p><strong>“The Mountains of Pi”</strong></p><p><strong><em>New Yorker</em> magazine</strong></p><p><strong>March 2, 1992 Issue</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Primack, Joel R.; Abrams, Nancy Ellen</strong></p><p><strong><em>The View from the Center of the Universe</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Riverhead, 2006</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Rees, Martin</strong></p><p><strong><em>Just Six Numbers</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Basic, 2000</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Sabaroff, Robert</strong></p><p><strong>“The Immunity Syndrome”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Star Trek: The Original Series</em></strong></p><p><strong>Season 2, Episode 18</strong></p><p><strong>Directed by Joseph Pevney, NBC, 1968</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Sagan, Carl</strong></p><p><strong><em>Broca’s Brain</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Random House, 1979</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Sagan, Carl</strong></p><p><strong><em>Contact</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Simon &amp; Shuster, 1985</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Sagan, Carl</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Demon-Haunted World</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Ballantine, 1996</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Sagan, Carl</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Varieties of Scientific Experience</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Penguin, 2006</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Sheldon, Alice (writing as James Tiptree, Jr.)</strong></p><p><strong>“A Momentary Taste of Being”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Star Songs of an Old Primate</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Ballantine, 1975</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Shermer, Michael</strong></p><p><strong><em>Why People Believe Weird Things</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: W.H. Freeman and Co., 1997</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Shostak, Seth</strong></p><p><strong>“The Zoo Hypothesis May Explain Why We Haven’t Seen Any Space Aliens”</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.seti.org/zoo-hypothesis"><strong>https://www.seti.org/zoo-hypothesis</strong></a></p><p><strong>April 3, 2019</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Stapledon, Olaf</strong></p><p><strong><em>Last and First Men </em>and<em> Star Maker</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Dover, 1968</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Stenger, Victo</strong></p><p><strong><em>God and the Multiverse</em></strong></p><p><strong>Amherst: Prometheus, 2014</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Sturgeon, Theodore</strong></p><p><strong>“Microcosmic God”</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Vol. I</em></strong></p><p><strong>Ed. Robert Silverberg</strong></p><p><strong>New York: Avon, 1970</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Thomas, Lewis</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Lives of a Cell</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Viking, 1974</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Viereck, George S.</strong></p><p><strong>Interview with Albert Einstein</strong></p><p><strong><em>Glimpses of the Great</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Macauley, 1930</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Ville, Claude, ed., et. al.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Biology</em></strong></p><p><strong>Philadelphia: Saunders, 1985</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Vonnegut, Kurt</strong></p><p><strong><em>Slaughterhouse Five</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Dell, 1968</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Ward, Peter D.; Brownlee, Donald</strong></p><p><strong><em>Rare Earth</em></strong></p><p><strong>New York: Copernicus, 2000</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Warmflash, David, MD; Lents, Nathan, Ph.D.</strong></p><p><strong>“Origins of Life II”</strong></p><p><strong><em>Visionlearning</em> 2016 Vol. BIO-4.</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.visionlearning.com/en/library/Biology/2/"><strong>https://www.visionlearning.com/en/library/Biology/2/</strong></a></p><p><strong>Origins-of-Life-II/227</strong></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>END OF POSTED MANUSCRIPT</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=65f2517515f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>