<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Mouritsen | RP on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Mouritsen | RP on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:38:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Processing Information Reports at Meetings]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/processing-information-reports-at-meetings-634814570dcd?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/634814570dcd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[board]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jul 2026 17:06:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-21T00:51:19.529Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/661/1*4X_TakAlXpJStYt_tXEtbg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Information Please: Lily Tomlin as Ernestine the Phone Operator.</figcaption></figure><p>I’m occasionally asked how to handle ‘information reports’, i.e., reports on the agenda that are submitted for information only, as distinct from ‘action reports’ that contain recommendations to be voted on. The agendas for many meetings contain a mix of both kinds of reports, and it is not unusual to see more information reports than action reports in some organizations.</p><p>Questions that arise include: do these reports need a motion to receive or adopt them, even if there is no ‘action’ item; despite their status as ‘information’ reports, is the content open to discussion or debate, or is it restricted to questions only; does there need to be a motion on the floor before you can have debate; how does the chair deal with questions from members beyond the scope of the report; and can members move motions from the floor to deal with the content of information reports?</p><p>Let’s start by considering the purpose of an information report and why it is included on an agenda. Executive officers and committees often report on their activities since the last meeting (of the board or of members), or offer a progress report on specific initiatives, or provide a monthly or quarterly statistical update, with the objective of keeping members informed on the work of the body or organization. Such reports may be oral (if they are very brief), but should be provided in writing in advance of the meeting. If they are true information reports, they will not include any recommendations or other motions to be voted on (although it is conceivable that some reports might contain one section for information items and another part recommending action on other topics).</p><p>Why are these reports even on the agenda if they are not action items? After all, isn’t the purpose of a business meeting to make group decisions? Although the main purpose of many bodies is indeed to make decisions, debating and voting don’t occur in a vacuum. Decision-making requires information, and sometimes that information is provided to members over an extended period of time, at a succession of meetings, before a recommendation is finalized. An information report might flag an issue at a preliminary stage so that, when the members are ultimately asked to make a decision on the matter, they already have sufficient context and don’t feel they are being blindsided by something they knew nothing about.</p><p>As my colleague, Jim Lochrie, puts it so well in his 2003 book <em>Meeting Procedures</em>, ‘A meeting generally trades nothing except information. It is the currency by which decisions are made; appropriate and reliable information must be available if the decisions are to be effective.’</p><p>In addition to educating members, information reports are an accountability mechanism. In reporting on their activities, officers and committees can provide members with an assurance that those in leadership positions are fulfilling their responsibilities.</p><p>Reports that are included on an agenda are there because they are specified in the order of business that the body has adopted for its meetings (usually contained in the bylaws or in a special rule of order). As discussed <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/preparing-approving-and-amending-an-agenda">previously</a>, the order of business lists the <strong>categories</strong> of business, and their sequence, to be considered at each meeting, including reports of officers and committees. Two quick comments, however:</p><p>1. Officers and committees should only be reporting <strong>if </strong>they actually have something to report. <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised (RONR)</em> makes clear (in 41:13) that for meetings other than the annual meeting, ‘the chair calls only on those who have reports to make’. Just because the order of business may list each officer and each committee, the specific agenda for each meeting should only list those officers and committees who have a report to present at that meeting, and the others shouldn’t feel they have to report every time just for the sake of reporting.</p><p>2. Not all reports are ‘equal’; some reports will generate more discussion, and require more time, than others, which is why organizations should make effective use of a ‘<a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/using-a-consent-agenda-for-efficient-and-effective-meetings">consent agenda</a>’ to group together uncontentious items (probably including many information reports) that are only discussed if a member specifically asks to add it to the regular agenda. Members are still expected to <strong>read</strong> the information reports on a consent agenda (preferably before the meeting), but they often do not need time to be discussed.</p><p>If an information report <strong>is</strong> on the agenda for consideration, the presiding officer of the meeting should call on the officer or committee chair to present the report. If the report is in writing and has been pre-circulated, the officer or committee chair should provide a brief introduction and summarize the highlights without reading the entire document. If the report has been pre-circulated, members will have had an opportunity to read it themselves (and they should have done so!).</p><p><strong>Role of the meeting chair</strong></p><p>The chair of the meeting (who I will refer to as the presiding officer to avoid confusion with the chair of a reporting committee) should then open the floor to discussion by asking if there are any questions.</p><p>Questions from members about the report should be directed to the presenter (the reporting officer or committee chair) <strong>through </strong>the presiding officer of the meeting (see <em>RONR</em> 3:12). The presenter also responds to questions through the presiding officer. This level of formality (which can be relaxed somewhat in meetings of smaller boards or committees) is important for three main reasons:</p><ul><li>Insisting that members address all remarks to the presiding officer helps elevate the discussion (including questions and answers) to a more professional, and less personal, level, helping to reduce potential breaches of order, such as offensive or irrelevant questions or answers.</li><li>If members are asking questions through the presiding officer, he or she can monitor them to try to avoid one or two questioners from dominating the discussion, to the possible exclusion of other members. It is important that someone other than the presenter is responsible for recognizing questioners and doing so in a fair and equitable way.</li><li>With the presiding officer handling questions, it makes it clear to members that he or she continues to actually <strong>preside</strong> during the presentation and discussion of the report, with an obligation to impartially enforce the rules. I’ve seen some organizations allow presenters, particularly committee chairs, to take over the chair during the consideration of their reports, enabling them to recognize and respond directly to questioners. Even if there are no motions in the report, however, a meeting always requires a neutral presiding officer, which is not a role that should be delegated to or expected of the presenter of a report. Indeed, <em>Robert</em> is clear that ‘the practice in some organizations of permitting the chairman of a committee to preside over the assembly . . . during the presentation and consideration of the committee’s report <strong>violates numerous principles of parliamentary law</strong> . . .’ (47:12, emphasis added).</li></ul><p><strong>Are there limits to the questions that can be asked?</strong></p><p>Questions raised about the content of a report essentially are Requests for Information, which falls under the category of ‘Requests and Inquiries’ in <em>Robert</em>. According to Standard Descriptive Characteristic #1 in 33:2, requests and inquiries can be made at any time, including ‘when no question is pending’. In other words, there does not have to be a motion on the floor in order to ask a question.</p><p>Members’ questions must, however, be germane to the content of the report, in the same way that debate on a motion must be germane (i.e., relevant) to the motion. The presiding officer may need to remind members of this requirement and to rule some questions out of order if they do not pertain to items in the report. Questions cannot be asked that are outside the scope of the report. A Request for Information is ‘a request directed to the chair, or through the chair to another officer or member, for information <strong>relevant to the business at hand</strong> . . .’ (33:6, emphasis added).</p><p>In addition to asking questions that are relevant to the report, and addressing all remarks through the chair, it is worth noting that the other rules governing decorum in debate (<em>RONR</em> 43:19–43:28) also apply to the asking (and answering) of questions, even if there is no motion on the floor, as in the case of an information report. This includes: refraining from attacking a member’s motives, refraining from criticizing a prior action of the organization, and refraining from disturbing the meeting with disorderly behaviour. Members have an obligation to treat other members with courtesy and respect at <strong>all</strong> times during a meeting, including when they are asking or responding to questions.</p><p><strong>Is an information report open to discussion or only questions?</strong></p><p>The general rule, of course, is that debate (as distinct from questions) should only be permitted if there is a motion on the floor, primarily to focus discussion and expedite decision-making. <em>Robert </em>does, however, permit the presiding officer to exercise discretion to allow <strong>limited</strong> informal discussion without a motion on the floor. An information report should not be an opportunity for members to debate the content of the report, but some brief discussion of the content <strong>might</strong> be permitted, particularly in smaller meetings, <strong>if</strong> the presiding officer believes it would be helpful, and provided it doesn’t get out of control. If it does, the presiding officer must be prepared to intervene quickly and firmly.</p><p><strong>If an information report doesn’t contain a recommendation or motion, can a member move a motion from the floor related to the content of the report?</strong></p><p><em>Robert</em> states (in 51:53) that a report containing only information, whether ‘an account of work done or a statement of fact or opinion’, should simply be filed: ‘no action on it is necessary and <strong>usually</strong> none should be taken’ (emphasis added). It seems to me, however, that in using the word ‘usually’, <em>Robert </em>is anticipating that, depending on the circumstances, it might be possible for a member to move a motion in response to the content of an information report. The <em>AIP Standard Code of Parliamentary Procedure</em> makes this possibility explicit: ‘If a committee presents information that a member feels should lead to action, but the report includes no such recommendation, a new main motion germane to the content of the report may be offered and considered’ (<em>AIPSC</em>, 31.62[9]).</p><p>In my recent blog post on ‘<a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/making-decisions-without-motions-or-a-vote">Making Decisions Without Motions or a Vote</a>’, I cited as an example a meeting in which members wanted to endorse an action reported for information (and in that particular case, the presiding officer assumed a motion and members voted in favour of endorsing the action). Any such motion from the floor, of course, must be germane to the content of the report, and a presiding officer is entitled to rule the motion out of order if it is not germane.</p><p>The problem with unscheduled motions moved from the floor during consideration of an information report is that they can effectively hijack an agenda, potentially eating into the time needed for more urgent agenda items. If a motion from the floor <strong>is</strong> germane, and appears likely to take up quite a bit of time, there are ways to manage the situation. The presiding officer might suggest that the member raise the motion later in the meeting under New Business (particularly if there is more important business on the agenda). This could be done using unanimous consent if the mover is agreeable. Alternatively, the member’s motion could be <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/to-table-or-not-to-table-is-that-the-question">laid on the table</a> (with majority support), to be taken from the table at a later time in the meeting once the more urgent business has been finished. The motions to Refer or Postpone could also be employed.</p><p>The bylaws of some organizations, however, prohibit the introduction of any substantive motions unless prior notice has been given; in such organizations, it would not be possible for a member to move a motion from the floor related to an information report.</p><p><strong>Should we be voting to adopt, accept or receive information reports?</strong></p><p>As noted earlier, an information report should simply be filed. No action is required, which means there is no need for a motion on it at all.</p><p>In 51:13, <em>Robert</em> states that a motion to <strong>adopt</strong> an entire report (as distinct from its recommendations, if there are any) means ‘endorsing every word in the report’ and ‘is seldom wise’. The meeting can’t amend or otherwise change an information report, and, in any event, to defeat the motion to adopt the report would be meaningless; the report is still the report. Some organizations believe that voting to <strong>accept </strong>an information report is a benign alternative, but <em>Robert</em> points out in 51:14 that ‘accept’ is equivalent to ‘adopt’. Avoid both.</p><p>Other organizations have a practice of voting to <strong>receive</strong> information reports, in the mistaken belief that it is necessary either (a) <strong>before</strong> the report can be considered or (b) <strong>after </strong>the report was given, to formally record that the report was, in fact, considered. A report is already ‘received’, however, at the time it is added to the agenda; a motion to receive it <strong>at</strong> the meeting is ‘meaningless and is therefore not in order’ (51:15). To repeat: No. Motion. Is. Required.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>You are now armed with information on how to take inaction on information reports!</p><p><em>The author is a professional parliamentarian based in Ontario, Canada. More resources can be found at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><strong><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></strong></a><em>. Feedback (including pushback!) is always welcome.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=634814570dcd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making Decisions Without Motions or a Vote]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/making-decisions-without-motions-or-a-vote-70ec500d47c8?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/70ec500d47c8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[board]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules-of-order]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Apr 2026 18:49:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-17T15:26:36.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*V80wCbF7EAWuXiRJph7p1w.gif" /><figcaption>Not following ‘proper’ procedures? Oooooh, scary!</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve written previously (most recently <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/parliamentarians-must-become-enemies-of-nonsense">last month</a>, but also <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/how-the-chair-can-speed-up-a-meeting">here</a>, <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/handling-friendly-amendments">here</a>, <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/yes-rules-are-important-%E2%80%93-but-so-is-good-judgement">here</a> and <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/zombie-procedures-they-just-refuse-to-die">here</a>) to encourage the use of unanimous or general consent to approve routine or noncontroversial business without a vote and even, where appropriate, without moving a motion.</p><p>Some readers have asked for more detail on how this actually works (and specifically, what the chair should say); whether the actions are ‘as official’ as formally moving a motion and taking a vote; how to record such decisions in the minutes; and how to deal with pushback from members who express concerns about bypassing ‘proper procedure’.</p><p>I know it can be disconcerting for some members to attend what they regard as a formal decision-making meeting, only to witness decisions being made informally, with the chair taking procedural shortcuts. This can be a challenge to everything we’ve been taught, i.e., when a group makes a decision, there must be a motion that is moved, seconded, stated by the chair, discussed, and voted on; skipping these steps is viewed as procedurally sloppy, undemocratic, even autocratic!</p><p>So let’s start with what <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em> has to say on the matter (in 4:58):</p><blockquote>‘<em>In cases where there seems to be no opposition in routine business or on questions of little importance, time can often be saved by the procedure of unanimous consent … [This method] can be used either to adopt a motion without the steps of stating the question and putting the motion to a formal vote, or it can be used to take action without even the formality of a motion’.</em></blockquote><p>Procedural shortcuts, in other words, are quite legitimate when making routine decisions or on questions that are noncontroversial and unlikely to generate divisive or contentious debate.</p><p><strong>How Unanimous Consent Is Used</strong></p><p>As to how it actually works and what the chair should say, <em>Robert</em> states (in 4:59) that the chair must first ‘<strong>obtain </strong>unanimous consent’, which he or she does by stating one of the following phrases:</p><p>· ‘If there is no objection …’ [<em>and then stating the action to be taken</em>]; or</p><p>· ‘Without objection . . .’ [<em>stating the action to be taken</em>]; or</p><p>· ‘Is there any objection to . . .’ [<em>taking the following action?</em>].</p><p>My personal preference is the third option. Asking ‘Is there any objection’ is more explicit and makes it clear to members that they need to respond if they have an objection.</p><p>After making one of these statements, the chair ‘<strong>then pauses</strong>, and if no member calls out “I object” [or “objection”], the chair announces that “Since there is no objection . . .”, [completing the sentence by stating the action decided upon]’(see 4:59, emphasis added).</p><p>Three important points to stress:</p><p>1. The chair needs to pause long enough to provide a reasonable amount of time for a member to object. Less time is required in a small board or committee where everyone is present in person than in a larger meeting or a hybrid/virtual event, where it may take longer for members to unmute themselves or otherwise get the chair’s attention. (It isn’t necessary to be recognized by the chair in order to object, but you need to make your objection known, usually by calling it out, although possibly by also standing or raising your hand.)</p><p>2. Even after the chair announces that there has been no objection, <em>Robert</em> states (also in 4:59) that ‘if an objection is made with <strong>reasonable promptness</strong>’, the chair must then disregard his or her announcement and ‘proceed to state the question in the usual manner’ (i.e., subject to discussion and vote).</p><p>3. If there is no objection from the members, the chair still needs to state clearly what action will be taken, so all members understand exactly what has been decided and the secretary knows what decision to record in the minutes.</p><p>Let’s take as an example the following scenario for processing the adoption of a meeting agenda.</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘The first item of business is the approval of the agenda. Are there any amendments to the agenda?’ [<em>Pause</em>] ‘Hearing none, is there any objection to adopting the agenda as circulated?’ [<em>Pause</em>] ‘There being no objection, I declare the agenda adopted as circulated.’</p><p>The chair thus avoids having to call for someone to move a motion to approve the agenda (‘Is there a motion to approve the agenda?’), which someone else would have to second (‘Is there a seconder?’). The chair then would call for discussion of the motion (‘Is there any discussion?’ or ‘Are you ready for the question?’); there would be no discussion. The chair would then restate the motion (‘The motion is to approve the agenda as circulated’ and call for the vote: ‘All those in favour? All those opposed? The motion is carried.’) This is called, quite appropriately, going through the motions, but to what end? It is simply following form for form’s sake.</p><p>An even leaner variation might look like this:</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘The first item of business is the approval of the agenda. Is there any objection to adopting the agenda as circulated?’ [<em>Pause</em>] ‘There being no objection, I declare the agenda adopted as circulated.’</p><p>In both options, the chair asks if there is any objection to approving the agenda; in the first, there is a call for amendments to the agenda and then a call for any objections to approval. In the second option, the chair eliminates the call for amendments, only asking for objections to approving the agenda as circulated, on the assumption that if someone <strong>does</strong> have a proposed change to the agenda, he or she would object to approval, and then suggest the change. After pausing and hearing no objection, the chair concludes, in both cases, by stating clearly what action will be taken, namely, that the agenda is adopted as circulated.</p><p>What happens if there is an objection? It might look like this:</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘The first item of business is the approval of the agenda. Is there any objection to adopting the agenda as circulated?’ [<em>Pause</em>]</p><p><strong>Member A:</strong> ‘I have an amendment’ (<em>or:</em> ‘Objection; I have an amendment’).</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘Please state your amendment.’</p><p><strong>Member A:</strong> ‘I have an update on the planning underway for the annual lecture series. Can this be added as the first item under New Business?’</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘If there is no objection, we will add ‘Update on Annual Lecture Series’ as the first item under New Business.’ [<em>Pause</em>] ‘Are there any other amendments to the agenda? Without objection, the agenda is approved as amended.’</p><p>Let’s say, however, that another member has a second amendment, but someone objects.</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘If there is no objection, we will add ‘Update on Annual Lecture Series’ as the first item under New Business.’ [<em>Pause</em>] ‘Are there any other amendments to the agenda?’</p><p><strong>Member B:</strong> ‘Yes, I have one. Can we re-arrange the agenda so we consider the Education Committee report before the Finance Committee report?’</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘The proposal is to move the Education Committee report up on the agenda to immediately before the Finance Committee report. Is there any objection?’ [<em>Pause</em>]</p><p><strong>Treasurer:</strong> ‘Yes, I object.’</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘There is not unanimous consent. The motion, therefore, moved by Member B, is to amend the agenda by moving the Education Committee report to immediately before the Finance Committee report. Is there a second?’ [<em>Member C signals yes.</em>] ‘The Chair recognizes Member B to speak to the amendment.’</p><p>Notice a couple of things here:</p><p>1. The Treasurer, in objecting and thereby denying unanimous consent, is not required (and should not be permitted by the chair) to provide at that point a reason for the objection. It is not necessary to explain why you are objecting.</p><p>2. As soon as there is an objection, the chair treats the proposal made by Member B as a motion (to amend the agenda), asks for a seconder, and recognizes the mover, Member B, to speak first. What was initially an informal proposal has now become a formal amendment and is processed in the ‘normal’ way, subject to discussion and vote. The Treasurer will have an opportunity during the discussion to explain why the sequence in committee reports should remain unchanged, and ultimately the members will decide by vote.</p><p>Even if an objection is made to changing the agenda, and it has to be settled by a vote on a particular amendment, the chair can still try to use unanimous consent to approve the agenda after the amendment has been dealt with. Eagle-eyed readers may recall from my previous blog on <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/preparing-approving-and-amending-an-agenda">approving agendas</a> that a change in the order of business, such as changing the sequence of committee reports, requires a two-thirds vote (for regular meetings occurring on at least a quarterly basis). In such a case, the amendment to the agenda would only require a majority vote, although the vote on approving the amended agenda (incorporating the change, if the amendment is approved) would need two-thirds. As <em>Robert </em>states, however, even actions requiring a two-thirds vote ‘can, in principle, also be taken by unanimous consent’ (4:63). If a matter has been approved by unanimous consent it has, of course, exceeded the threshold of two thirds.</p><p>What if a motion is formally moved and seconded, but the chair senses that there is likely no opposition to it? Let’s revisit the first scenario.</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘The first item of business is the approval of the agenda.’ [<em>Member A immediately raises hand</em>] ‘The Chair recognizes Member A.’</p><p><strong>Member A:</strong> ‘I move that the agenda be approved as circulated.’</p><p><strong>Member B:</strong> [<em>Calls out</em>] ‘Second.’</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that the agenda be approved as circulated. Is there any objection?’ [<em>Pause</em>] ‘There being no objection, I declare the agenda approved as circulated.’</p><p>Even though a motion to approve the agenda has been moved and seconded, the chair can still seek unanimous consent for approval, bypassing the need for a discussion and vote. (And a reminder that the member seconding a motion does not need to seek recognition from the chair, but can simply call it out.)</p><p>Finally, what if there is no motion on the floor, but it is clear that the members want to make a decision? A recent example from my own experience is a good illustration of how a chair can assume a motion and obtain consent. At this meeting (an AGM), the board announced that it had signed a Memorandum of Agreement with another association that would enable members of both organizations to share certain benefits. The members at the AGM were quite pleased with this news, and a few members indicated that they would like to endorse the board’s decision, even though it was clearly within the board’s authority to sign the agreement (a point that one member noted). Without missing a beat, the chair asked ‘Would members like to endorse the board’s decision?’ A number of heads nodded assent. Without waiting for a mover, the chair took the following action.</p><p><strong>Chair:</strong> ‘The motion is that the AGM endorse the board’s signing of the Memorandum of Agreement with [<em>name of the association</em>]. Is there any objection?’ [<em>Pause</em>] ‘The motion is adopted.’</p><p>The chair could also have invited someone to move a motion, but in this case it wasn’t difficult to see that there was broad support for a motion of endorsement, even from those who had jurisdictional concerns. The chair’s action also had the virtue of focussing any further debate, should there be any, on a specific proposal, avoiding what was in danger of becoming a rambling discussion in the absence of a motion on the floor. If any members wanted to discuss the motion, they could have objected to unanimous consent, in which case the chair would have invited discussion and then held a vote.</p><p>And no, the chair did not violate her duty of neutrality in assuming the motion. She was fulfilling her responsibility ‘to expedite business in every way compatible with the rights of members’ (47:7[7]).</p><p><strong>Rationale for Unanimous Consent</strong></p><p>One of the arguments often made against using unanimous consent in this way is that it violates democratic norms and potentially stifles discussion. In permitting this procedure, however, <em>Robert </em>notes that it ‘is in accord with the principle that rules are designed for the protection of the minority and generally need not be strictly enforced <strong>when there is no minority to protect</strong>’ (4:58; emphasis added). In other words, if there is no objection to taking a certain action, it means that members are <em>content </em>to do so; they consent to do so, which means that, in this particular instance, they have voluntarily agreed not to exercise their rights (to move motions, speak and vote). It is not a case of infringement but, rather, restraint; the members have freely chosen not to object.</p><p>Another argument is that the term ‘unanimous consent’ is misleading, inasmuch as it is not the same as a unanimous vote in which everyone explicitly votes to support (or oppose) a motion. <em>Robert </em>agrees: ‘ “Unanimous consent” does not necessarily imply that every member present is in favor of the proposed action . . .’ (4:60). It means that they acquiesce to the proposal — for any number of possible reasons, ranging from opposing the matter but feeling there is no point in discussing or voting on it, to not having a strong view one way or the other, to actually agreeing with the proposal. ‘General consent’ is sometimes preferred as a more accurate description of what members are doing when they decline to object.</p><p><strong>Is Unanimous Consent as Official as Voting?</strong></p><p>As the <em>AIP Standard Code of Parliamentary Procedure</em> notes, unanimous or general consent ‘is a valid method to adopt the motion’. The chair still needs to describe accurately what action is to be taken (just as he or she would in stating and re-stating a motion), so everyone can make an informed decision on whether or not to object. Voting for a motion, of course, is by definition ‘more <strong>formal</strong>’, but that doesn’t in and of itself make it ‘more <strong>official</strong>’. There is nothing second-class, in other words, about adopting a motion or approving an action by unanimous consent (without objection) compared to a motion adopted following debate and vote. There may be good reasons to prefer one method over the other (and obviously motions on which there are differences of opinion do require discussion and a vote), but there is absolutely no difference in the authority or validity of the decision between the two methods.</p><p><strong>How Is Unanimous Consent Recorded in the Minutes?</strong></p><p>The specific format of minutes does vary from one organization to another, but the basic principle should always be to record what was <strong>decided</strong>, not what was <strong>discussed</strong>. In the case of the first scenario discussed earlier (adoption of the agenda), the minutes might simply record:</p><p>‘The agenda was adopted as circulated, without objection.’</p><p>If there was an amendment:</p><p>‘The agenda, amended to include an update on the annual lecture series under New Business, was adopted without objection.’</p><p>In the case of a motion that was moved and seconded but adopted by unanimous consent:</p><p>‘It was moved, seconded and adopted without objection that …..’</p><p>If the chair assumes a motion, such as in the final scenario above:</p><p>‘The President reported that the Board of Directors had recently negotiated and signed a Memorandum of Agreement with [<em>name of other association</em>], enabling members of both organizations to share certain benefits. During discussion of the President’s Report, the following motion was proposed and adopted without objection: “That the AGM endorse the board’s signing of the Memorandum of Agreement with [<em>name of the association</em>].” ’</p><p>If the chair has obtained unanimous consent without seeking a mover or a vote, the secretary needs to find appropriate language to record the decision.</p><p><strong>How to Handle Pushback</strong></p><p>As I indicated earlier, some members have difficulty accepting procedural shortcuts such as the chair assuming motions and using unanimous consent to make decisions. Citing <em>Robert</em> can sometimes resolve concerns, but it may take time for members to become accustomed to change if a chair suddenly introduces new procedures. The chair can respond to questions from members (who might raise a parliamentary inquiry as to why a mover or a vote isn’t required), but if someone continually objects to unanimous consent simply because they insist on following ‘formal’ procedure, the chair may have to rely on others to try to persuade recalcitrant members that it is both appropriate and sensible to make decisions quickly when no one objects.</p><p>Ultimately, we have to choose our procedural battles, and this might not be a hill to die on. Periodically holding training workshops on parliamentary procedure, however, is always a good idea as a way to ensure that members have up to date knowledge. In fact, next to recommending the use of unanimous consent, organizing parliamentary training for members is my next favourite recommendation!</p><p><em>Michael Mouritsen is a Registered Parliamentarian based in Ontario, Canada. More resources can be found at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><strong><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></strong></a><em>. Your feedback, including pushback, is always welcome!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=70ec500d47c8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Parliamentarians Must Become ‘Enemies of Nonsense’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/parliamentarians-must-become-enemies-of-nonsense-a19ed7a258c4?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a19ed7a258c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Mar 2026 00:38:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-08T18:09:25.936Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CCp8Du_ffUDrNS5MmlWRJw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Eric Arthur Blair, better known as George Orwell, described The Observer, where he wrote a column, as ‘the enemy of nonsense’.</figcaption></figure><p><em>This article was first published in the Winter 2026 edition of the </em>National Parliamentarian<em>, the quarterly publication of the National Association of Parliamentarians. It has been edited to broaden the target readership (originally professional parliamentarians) to include those who support, provide procedural advice to, and chair decision-making bodies.</em></p><p>Almost eighteen months ago, the <em>New York Times</em> published an article by one of its national correspondents, Alan Blinder, entitled “Professors Are Uniquely Powerful. That May Be Changing”. The subject of the article was the long-standing right of faculty members to participate in university decision-making, and how their co-management role has been challenged by both university presidents and state politicians, particularly as universities respond to international events and campus protests.</p><p>You might wonder what this has to do with parliamentary procedure, but what caught my attention was a single sentence, buried deep in the November 2nd, 2024 article: “Critics of shared governance systems — often filled with senates, councils, committees, subcommittees and task forces grappling with motions, resolutions, reports <strong>and the finer points of <em>Robert’s Rules of Order</em></strong> — have complained that, well intentioned as they may be, they can be too plodding in a sped-up world.”</p><p>This, of course, is not the first time <em>Robert’s Rules of Order</em> has been attacked in the media, although it seems to be more frequent in social media than in mainstream publications like the <em>New York Times</em>. Regardless of the platform, it’s frustrating and annoying to see rules of order misrepresented in such a casual, dismissive way.</p><p>So, I have a question, particularly for professional parliamentarians, but more generally for anyone involved in supporting, advising, or chairing decision-making meetings: Why does <em>Robert</em> have such a negative reputation in the popular imagination? How has a manual designed to promote efficiency in meetings become synonymous with cumbersome, convoluted, and pedantic decision-making?</p><p>Is it the book itself? Despite many useful revisions over the years, <em>Robert’s Rules</em> does still retain archaic terminology, and its sheer size can intimidate the casual user. Nevertheless, I think the main reason why <em>Robert</em> is viewed so unfavourably has more to do with the personal experiences that many people have when they participate in meetings.</p><p>Most of the meeting-going public do not understand <em>Robert’s Rules</em> (the basics, let alone “the finer points”), but they do understand when a meeting is derailed because of procedural wrangling. People often blame “the rules” in such cases, even if the real problem may be poor presiding, or members who abuse the rules, or self-appointed procedural police insisting on rigid compliance with the rules for the sake of form.</p><p>If most of one’s experience is with meetings dominated by process rather than substance, it’s understandable that a journalist could use <em>Robert’s Rules of Order</em> as a punchline in a national news article, knowing that his readers would likely smirk in recognition.</p><p>So, what’s to be done about it? As parliamentarians and professional advisors, we can start by changing our own attitudes and behaviour in our various roles as presiding officers, consultants, trainers, clerks, and secretaries (and even as just plain members when participating in other organizations), thereby influencing how the rules are perceived by those we advise and train, and in the meetings we chair or attend.</p><p>As parliamentarians or procedural advisors, our instinctive response to most procedural problems is to cite a rule, but we know that there is more to <em>Robert’s Rules</em> than just rules; there is also important advice on how we should <strong>apply</strong> the rules — advice that is often overlooked when we talk about managing meetings.</p><p>Here are a few examples, under two categories: advice to presiding officers and advice to members generally. All citations are from <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em> (<em>RONR</em>) (12th ed.), unless indicated otherwise, and any emphasis in the text has been added by this author.</p><p><strong>Advice to Presiding Officers</strong></p><p><em>RONR</em> states (in 47:6) that the presiding officer “should be chosen principally for the ability to preside. This person should be well versed in parliamentary law and should be thoroughly familiar with the bylaws and other rules of the organization . . . . [<strong>but]</strong> at the same time, any presiding officer will do well to bear in mind that<strong> no rules can take the place of tact and common sense on the part of the chairman</strong>.”</p><p><em>Robert</em> goes on to say that the chair of a meeting “should never be technical or more strict than is necessary for the good of the meeting. <strong>Good judgment is essential</strong> [and]. . .<strong>strict enforcement of the rules, instead of assisting . . . [might just] greatly hinder business</strong>” (47:19).</p><p>This is clear, unambiguous and emphatic advice for the chair of a meeting: knowing the rules is important, but no rules can replace tact and common sense; good judgment is essential; mindless enforcement of the rules could greatly hinder business.</p><p>A specific example of exercising good judgment, of course, is the use where appropriate of unanimous consent to adopt a motion without a vote or “to take action without even the formality of a motion”, based on “the principle that rules are designed for the protection of the minority and generally <strong>need not be strictly enforced when there is no minority to protect</strong>” (4:58).</p><p>When there is no minority to protect — when no one’s rights are being violated — the rules can be relaxed, and the meeting can proceed with less formality.</p><p><strong>Advice to Members Generally</strong></p><p>In the section at the very beginning of <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em> entitled “Principles Underlying Parliamentary Law”, the manual states that “ . . . there is an underlying assumption of a right that exists <strong>even though it may not always be prudent or helpful for it to be exercised.</strong> Each individual or subgroup has the right to make the maximum effort to have his, her, or its position declared the will of the assembly <strong>to the extent that can be tolerated in the interests of the entire body” </strong>(<em>RONR</em>, p. xlix).</p><p>In other words, members have both rights and obligations, and one of those obligations is to at least consider, either individually or as a group, whether or not to pursue a particular course of action, even if they are entitled to do so, particularly if pursuing that action might not be in the best interests of the organization or body as a whole.</p><p>More specifically, the manual is clear (in 23:4) that “[i]n ordinary meetings, it is <strong>undesirable</strong> to raise points of order on minor irregularities of a purely technical character, if it is clear that no one’s rights are being infringed upon and no real harm is being done to the proper transaction of business”.</p><p>Henry Robert reinforced this notion in his 1923 supplementary text, <em>Parliamentary Law</em>, when he wrote that “Parliamentary law should be the servant, not the master, of the assembly. <strong>The assembly meets to transact business, not to have members exploit their knowledge of parliamentary law.</strong> A business meeting is not a class in [procedure] . . . It is a <strong>nuisance</strong> to have the time of the assembly wasted by a member’s raising points of order on technical points when no harm is done by the irregularity” (<em>Parliamentary Law</em>, p. 151).</p><p>Again, a very clear and strong message: focusing on technicalities is undesirable, a nuisance, and a waste of time!</p><p><strong>Declaring War on Nonsense</strong></p><p>I know that most parliamentarians (and many of my readers!) will be familiar with the examples cited above. And yet, I cannot count the number of times I have seen those claiming to be experts in parliamentary procedure insist on strict enforcement of all the rules all the time, ignoring the parliamentary situation or the context of the meeting; essentially, in my view, refusing to exercise good judgment. Some meetings, of course, <strong>do</strong> require strict formality, such as conventions or meetings with a contentious agenda, but <em>Robert</em>’s advice on tact, common sense and good judgment are relevant for any meeting.</p><p>I suggest that, as parliamentarians and procedural experts, we need to look within ourselves and consider whether, in insisting on a rigid compliance with the rules in every instance, many of us have been complicit in reinforcing the widespread view among the public that rules of order are an obstacle, rather than an aid, to efficient decision-making.</p><p>We need to reframe rules of order (both in our own minds and in how we talk about them) so that they are understood to be based on, and need to be applied with, <strong>common sense</strong>. As Henry Robert originally argued, good judgement is more important than a strict application of the rules.</p><p>George Orwell, author of <em>1984</em> and <em>Animal Farm</em>, used to write for the British Sunday newspaper, <em>The Observer</em>, a publication that he described as “the enemy of nonsense”. This seems like a useful mission statement that parliamentarians (and, frankly, anyone involved in running meetings) should adopt; we need to see ourselves as ‘enemies of nonsense’ at meetings: not just watching for violations of the rules, <strong>but for violations of common sense</strong>.</p><p>It takes a long time for public attitudes to change, but they won’t change if we don’t take the first steps. Let’s start now by declaring a war on nonsense! Who’s with me?</p><p>To the barricades!</p><p><strong>Further Reading:</strong></p><p><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/how-the-chair-can-speed-up-a-meeting">‘How the Chair Can “Speed Up” a Meeting</a>’, March 13, 2025.</p><p><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/zombie-procedures-they-just-refuse-to-die">‘Zombie Procedures: They Just Refuse to Die</a>’, January 8, 2024.</p><p><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/yes-rules-are-important-%E2%80%93-but-so-is-good-judgement">‘Yes, Rules Are Important, But So Is Good Judgement</a>’, December 19, 2021.</p><p><em>Michael Mouritsen is a Registered Parliamentarian based in Ontario. He works with clients across Canada and the United States and publishes a blog on parliamentary procedure at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><strong><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></strong></a><em>. Feedback (including pushback) is always welcome!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a19ed7a258c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[So, What’s With The Gavel?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/so-whats-with-the-gavel-7f743f051004?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f743f051004</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Feb 2026 19:10:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-04T20:19:39.729Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_YL_4xTVwe-qaKHTiqGJlA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The gavel at rest, where it should stay most of the time.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Updated March 4, 2026.</strong></p><p>I referred last month to the concept of <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/when-reaching-the-end-doesnt-quite-mean-its-over">‘gavelling through’</a>, a practice in which the chair of a meeting rushes to put a motion to a vote without permitting full debate, either by moving so fast that members don’t have time to seek the floor, or just by refusing to recognize members who indicate they wish to speak. The practice of gavelling through (also known as railroading) obviously exists, but according to <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em> (43:7), ‘there is no such thing’ permitted under ‘legitimate parliamentary procedure’; the presiding officer does not have the unilateral authority to end debate and force a vote, whether or not he or she bangs a gavel while trying to do so.</p><p>So, what’s with the gavel? Does the chair of a meeting need one? Is there a proper way to use it, and what does it mean when you hear a gavel being used?</p><p>Let’s return to <em>Robert’s Rules of Order</em>, in which use of the gavel is described in just five other situations:</p><p>1. <strong>For a</strong> <strong>Recess.</strong> After a motion to take a recess is adopted (the example used is a fifteen-minute break), the chair announces ‘The ayes have it and the meeting stands recessed . . . for fifteen minutes [rapping once with the gavel, <strong>if desired</strong>]’. See 20:9 (emphasis added). In other words, use of a gavel is optional, but if used to signal a recess, it should only be rapped once.</p><p>2. <strong>For</strong> <strong>Adjournment.</strong> Similarly, after the chair declares that the meeting is adjourned, ‘the adjournment may be signaled by a single rap of the gavel, <strong>if desired</strong>’ (21:20). Again, a single rap, but optional.</p><p>3. <strong>As a Symbol.</strong> In the chapter on organizing a convention, the manual notes in 59:55(12) that ‘if there is to be a formal installation of officers [following an election], this ceremony is often made a part of a closing banquet meeting, at which any presentations of <strong>gavels</strong>, pins, awards or the like are also made’. This, of course, is not a rule, but it does describe what happens in many organizations: the gavel, as a symbol of the chair’s authority and office, may be formally transferred from the custody of the former president or chair to his or her successor; it makes a good photo op to mark the transition. A gavel can also be given as a gift to a retiring chair as a mark of appreciation for having served in that capacity (and often bears a suitable inscription).</p><p>4. <strong>For Minor Breaches of Order</strong>. In 61:10, <em>Robert</em> states that ‘if a member commits only a slight breach of order — such as addressing another member instead of the chair in debate, or . . . failing to confine his remarks to the merits of the pending question — <strong>the chair simply raps lightly</strong>, points out the fault, and advises the member to avoid it.’ In this instance, the action of rapping does seem mandatory rather than optional, and is not explicitly limited to a single rap, although use of the word ‘lightly’ suggests that it be done only once. (Note also, however, that there is no actual reference to ‘gavel’ as the instrument with which to rap; perhaps a chair could use his or her knuckles?) It seems to make more sense in such a situation (a minor breach) for the chair to simply interrupt the speaker by saying ‘Excuse me’ and then pointing out the breach.</p><p>5. <strong>When Not to Use It.</strong> Aside from the prohibition against ‘gavelling through’ mentioned earlier, <em>Robert</em> offers this warning to chairs when dealing with a case of disorder at a meeting: ‘Under no circumstances should the chair attempt to drown out a disorderly member — either by his own voice <strong>or the gavel</strong> . . .’ (61:9). In other words, the gavel is <strong>not</strong> to be used as a way of getting attention or preserving order by banging it loudly and repeatedly.</p><p>So, there is no requirement that a chair have a gavel, but it is seen as a symbol of the office or position, and it should always be used with restraint: a single rap to announce a recess or adjournment, although I have also seen it used (quite appropriately) to signal the call to order at the beginning of the meeting, which is the only recommended use of the gavel in the <em>AIP Standard Code of Parliamentary Procedure</em>. (Fun fact: Using the gavel to both open and close a meeting gives rise to the phrase ‘gavel to gavel’ to describe media coverage of a meeting or hearing from start to finish.)</p><p>Why, then, do some presiding officers insist on banging the gavel loudly and frequently during meetings, particularly as a way to get members’ attention? There are a few possible explanations.</p><p>In courtroom dramas on film and television, we often see judges wield their gavels like a weapon, denying motions, overruling objections from lawyers, and calling for order in the court. News coverage of American politics often shows the Speaker of the House of Representatives banging the gavel to punctuate the conclusion of votes, and both congressional chambers, as well as their committees, permit the use of the gavel to maintain order in the event of disruptive behaviour, which of course makes for good television. (Fun fact #2: While the Speaker of the House uses a large wooden gavel, the presiding officer in the Senate uses a small <a href="https://www.senate.gov/art-artifacts/decorative-art/other/71_00001_000.htm">hour-glass shaped marble gavel</a>, based on an original made of ivory that was broken by Richard Nixon when he was presiding as Vice-President.)</p><p>Despite its very limited role as described in <em>Robert’s Rules of Order</em>, the gavel has become an ubiquitous symbol in the world of parliamentary procedure. It appears on the personal websites of many professional parliamentarians, and it is a central part of the logo of the American Institute of Parliamentarians. It adorns the covers of numerous parliamentary books, including the <em>Complete Idiot’s Guide to Robert’s Rules of Order;</em> <em>Robert’s Rules for Dummies</em>; the 2012 edition of the <em>AIP Standard Code of Parliamentary Procedure</em>; <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Fast Track</em>; and <em>Notes and Comments on Robert’s Rules</em>.</p><p>Even <em>The ABC of Chairmanship</em>, which is the leading parliamentary manual in the United Kingdom, features an image of two criss-crossed gavels on its cover, while the 1965 edition of <em>Bourinot’s Rules of Order</em>, originally based on procedures followed by the Canadian House of Commons, displays a single upright gavel.</p><p>These last two examples are interesting, inasmuch as a gavel is not used by the Speaker in either the UK or the Canadian parliaments, nor is it used by judges in British or Canadian courts. (Fun fact #3: There is an outlier among Canada’s Westminster-style legislatures; the Speaker of <a href="https://www.assembly.pe.ca/symbols-of-the-legislative-assembly">Prince Edward Island’s Legislative Assembly</a> does appear to have access to a gavel.)</p><p>There is another possible, and understandable, reason why some presiding officers might be motivated to engage in a Robust Round of Rapping (TM Reg’d). At the conclusion of a vote or a series of votes following a lengthy, contentious and amendment-filled debate, banging the gavel a couple of times is a signal to all members that it’s time for everyone to exhale, relax and collectively celebrate the success of having made a group decision. (It can also be an effective way for a chair to deal with the personal stress of presiding; pounding the gavel is more neutral, not to mention safer, than pounding members.)</p><p>In any event, for organizations that have adopted <em>Robert’s Rules of Order</em> as their parliamentary authority, the bottom line is clear: Unless your own rules say otherwise, the chair of a meeting should use the gavel sparingly, if at all. And if you don’t have a gavel, there is no need to rush out to buy one!</p><p><em>The author is a Registered Parliamentarian based in Kincardine and Toronto, Ontario. More resources can be found at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><strong><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></strong></a><em>. Comments, questions and suggestions for future posts are always welcome!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f743f051004" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Can Approve the Minutes?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/who-can-approve-the-minutes-811abd27eb39?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/811abd27eb39</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[corporate-governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Jan 2026 21:46:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-03T23:23:58.530Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1017/1*wPUid5v41dEV9Xea5Isc_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Any member can discuss and participate in the approval process of the minutes even if they weren’t at the meeting.</figcaption></figure><p>When a board or other body is reviewing the minutes of the previous meeting, the chair will sometimes say that only members who were present at the last meeting are entitled to correct or vote on the minutes. Is this true?</p><p><em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised (RONR) </em>says <strong>no</strong> — see 41:11: ‘… a member’s absence from the meeting … does not prevent the member from participating in [the minutes’] correction or approval’. Why? Because the minutes of a meeting don’t belong just to the members who were present. Minutes are official records of the organization, and all members have an interest in ensuring their accuracy, whether they attended the particular meeting or not.</p><p>Besides, where do you draw the line? Members who may have missed some or all of any debate are still entitled to vote on all motions arising from that debate, even if they were postponed from a previous meeting.</p><p>One alternative procedural manual used by some Canadian organizations (<em>Wainberg’s Society Meetings</em>) does insist that ‘only persons who were present at the [previous] meeting may properly move, second, or vote’ on a motion to adopt the minutes, but if you have adopted <em>Robert’s Rules</em> as your parliamentary authority, you shouldn’t be voting on the minutes at all — see <em>RONR</em> 41:11. The chair should ask for corrections; if any, they should be accepted by unanimous consent (with each correction voted on only if disputed); and the chair then declares the minutes adopted, either as circulated or as corrected (whatever the case may be).</p><p>Some organizations wisely place minutes on a <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/using-a-consent-agenda-for-efficient-and-effective-meetings?blogcategory=Meetings">consent agenda</a>, which should minimize unnecessary procedural wrangling and save time. For more information on what should and shouldn’t be in minutes, and how to handle them, check out <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/a-few-moments-on-minutes?blogcategory=Minutes">this earlier blog post</a>.</p><p><em>Michael Mouritsen, a Registered Parliamentarian based in Toronto and Kincardine, Ontario, works with clients across Canada and the United States. More resources can be found at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><strong><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></strong></a><em>, where you can leave questions and comments.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=811abd27eb39" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Special vs Regular Meetings: What’s the Difference?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/special-vs-regular-meetings-whats-the-difference-c4d7c5f59eb6?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c4d7c5f59eb6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-of-directors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[corporate-governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Jan 2026 21:13:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-26T15:21:51.688Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*0NZnK2lgO8oT7tk8zZyGBQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dana Carvey as the Church Lady on Saturday Night Live</figcaption></figure><p>Someone wrote recently: ‘I tried to amend the agenda of a special meeting to add a new item of business and it was ruled out of order. Why?’ Today’s episode of Myths and Misunderstandings in #ParliamentaryProcedure has the answer! Let’s look at <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em>, 12th edition (9:13–9:16).</p><p>Many organizations have a scheduled time and date for ‘regular’ meetings (e.g., the first Tuesday of each month or once every quarter), and the bylaws should specify the order of business at those meetings (both the items to be considered, e.g., the minutes, reports of officers, reports of committees, etc., and their sequence). ‘Special’ meetings are held at a different time to consider one or more items of business specified in the call or notice of the meeting.</p><p>Special meetings are typically convened to deal with urgent business arising between regular meetings or to devote an entire meeting to one or a few specific items, free of the constraints of the regular meeting agenda.</p><p>Robert says ’The only business that can be transacted at a special meeting is that . . . specified in the call of the meeting’ (9:15). This rule protects against an unrepresentative majority hijacking the agenda of a poorly-attended special meeting to make decisions on business for which members received no notice. The call of the special meeting must specify the purpose of the meeting and the subjects to be considered, but not necessarily specific motions (although it is always a good practice to pre-circulate as much information as possible, including the text of motions to be considered, if they are known).</p><p>It is not in order, therefore, to amend the agenda of a special meeting to add a new subject not specified in the call of the meeting, although motions *related* to the subject(s) of the meeting, including amendments, can always be considered.</p><p>Authorization to hold special meetings should be codified in the bylaws, indicating who can propose and call a special meeting, and the number of days’ notice required. If a special meeting (inadvertently or deliberately) makes decisions on subjects not specified in the call, that action is not valid unless ratified at a regular meeting or at a special meeting called for that purpose.</p><p><em>Michael Mouritsen, a Registered Parliamenarian based in Toronto and Kincardine, Ontario, works with clients across Canada and the United States. More resources can be found at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><strong><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></strong></a><em>, where you can also leave comments and questions.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c4d7c5f59eb6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Reaching the End Doesn’t Quite Mean It’s Over]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/when-reaching-the-end-doesnt-quite-mean-it-s-over-a8c58d6438d6?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8c58d6438d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[board-of-directors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Jan 2026 23:19:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-20T15:17:08.189Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*1raF0W-h_ivEtJPOJdROfw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Photo of Roy Orbison in 1965 by Jack de Nijs.</em></figcaption></figure><p>An organization with which I had some involvement a number of years ago had a president who prided himself on conducting efficient meetings. To establish his authority, he spoke very loudly, made frequent use of a gavel, and used exaggerated body language and facial expressions to indicate impatience when members were still discussing a matter that he felt had been given sufficient time. He would often pound his gavel and announce ‘OK, we’ve had a good discussion; let’s vote’, and proceed to call the vote. He essentially ruled unchallenged through intimidation.</p><p>The meeting agendas for this body often had timed items (special orders), meaning that at a certain hour, the agenda item that was created as a special order was entitled to interrupt the pending business. Whenever that happened, the president would immediately bang his gavel (usually interrupting someone who was speaking) and announce that the meeting was now considering the next agenda item, thereby leaving the previous item without taking a vote.</p><p>Similarly, when the meeting reached the scheduled time for adjournment (a particular hour approved when the agenda was adopted), the president would interrupt whoever was speaking, immediately announce adjournment, and leave the chair. As far as he was concerned, the meeting was over — and finished on time!</p><p>Was this an appropriate way to conduct meetings? No, but for different reasons in each of the three examples cited.</p><p>First, <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em> states clearly in 43:7 that ‘there is no such thing’ as ‘gavelling through‘ an agenda. As I have written <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/how-the-chair-can-speed-up-a-meeting">previously</a>, it is quite appropriate for the chair of a meeting to exercise ‘soft power’ to nudge members along, by asking if they are ready for the question, or by noting that debate has become repetitive, or by pointing out the time. However, the chair has no unilateral authority to end debate and force a vote. Even if a chair conducts a vote and announces the result, ‘the vote must be disregarded’ if it is found that members were still seeking recognition to speak, and in such a case, debate must resume.</p><p>The chair may think it’s the end of debate, but it’s not over until the <strong>members</strong> decide. And banging a gavel, besides being annoying, is procedurally meaningless.</p><p>Second, as I noted in <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/preparing-approving-and-amending-an-agenda">last month’s blog post</a>, when an agenda item is interrupted by a special order at the assigned hour, the chair is obliged to announce that fact, <strong>but</strong> before moving immediately to take up the special order, the chair ‘puts to a vote any pending questions without allowing further debate’ — see 41:65. In other words, any motions on the floor at the time the special order arrives must be voted on, essentially as if a motion to close debate and vote immediately has just been adopted.</p><p>There are also other actions that can be taken before consideration of the pending item is actually over:</p><p>· <strong>After</strong> the chair announces that the time to take up the special order has arrived, but <strong>before</strong> stating the pending questions to be voted on, members are entitled to move to lay the pending question on the table, postpone it, or refer it to a committee. If any of these motions are moved, the chair must put them, and any amendments, to a vote without debate.</p><p>· It is also in order to move to extend the time to consider the pending question; such a motion is also undebatable, but requires a two-thirds vote for adoption since it is amending an approved agenda.</p><p>Any of these motions can also be adopted with unanimous consent, of course, if the chair asks if there is any objection to approving the motion and no one objects.</p><p>Third, when the time for a scheduled adjournment arrives, there are a number of parliamentary steps that are in order before the chair can declare the meeting adjourned:</p><p>· <em>Robert</em> suggests (in 41:66) that, if the motion to close debate and vote immediately (aka ‘Previous Question’) has already been adopted by the time of adjournment, ‘there usually will be no objection to the chair’s putting [the affected motions] to a vote’ before declaring adjournment. This means that it probably makes sense to conclude the voting, but that the rules do not require it. If there is an objection to finishing the vote in such a case, the chair should immediately assume a motion to do so by asking ‘Those in favour of concluding the vote on the pending motion(s)?’ and ‘Those opposed?’. The motion is undebatable and requires a 2/3 vote, since it is technically extending the meeting, even if only slightly.</p><p>· If the motion to close debate and vote immediately has <strong>not</strong> been moved and the scheduled time of adjournment arrives, even if that time was created as a special order, the pending motions are not entitled to be voted on; they are eligible to be taken up as Unfinished Business at the next meeting, provided the next meeting is held within the next three months. If, however, it seems as if discussion on the pending motions was almost over, and/or if the next scheduled meeting will not be held within the next quarter, the chair should ask if there is any objection to voting on the motion or motions before adjourning. If there is an objection, but the chair senses that there is broad support for conducting the vote, my advice in such a case is that the chair should assume a motion to do so, as in the previous bullet point; it is undebatable and requires a 2/3 vote.</p><p>· After the chair announces that the meeting has reached the scheduled time of adjournment, but before he or she declares the meeting adjourned, any member can seek recognition (but it must be done <strong>promptly</strong>) to move to reschedule the adjournment time or to extend the time to consider the pending question for a specified period (41:67). These motions are undebatable and require a 2/3 vote (although the chair could also try to handle them by unanimous consent).</p><p>There are a number of other actions that are in order if a motion to adjourn has been moved, and these are also in order when a scheduled adjournment time has been reached — see 21:10:</p><p>o The chair or any other member can inform members of business requiring attention before adjournment (perhaps prompting a motion to extend the meeting time);</p><p>o The chair or any other member can make important announcements for information (such as a reminder of an upcoming election or announcing a change in the location of the next meeting);</p><p>o A motion to <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/to-reconsider-a-motion">reconsider</a> a previous vote can be made (although it cannot be taken up until a later meeting);</p><p>o Any member can give notice of motion to be made at the next meeting, if such a motion requires previous notice;</p><p>o Any member can move to set a time for an adjourned meeting.</p><p>Finally, if all business on the agenda has been concluded, the chair should note that fact, but should always ask ‘Is there any other business?’, allowing sufficient time (a brief pause) for members to seek recognition for one of the allowable actions discussed above. There is always a risk, of course, that members will see this as an opportunity to discuss a matter that should properly have been raised elsewhere on the agenda, so the chair needs to be firm to ensure that the meeting doesn’t descend into a free-for-all at the very end.</p><p>One of the actions that is <strong>not</strong> required if a meeting has either concluded its business or reached the scheduled time of adjournment is a motion to adjourn. If no one is seeking recognition to speak, the chair should simply declare the meeting adjourned, with no need for a motion or a vote. <em>Robert</em> says that ‘members should not leave their seats until this declaration has been made’ (21:12), which is the signal that the meeting is (really) over.</p><p>What to do if confronted by a chair who is gavelling through an agenda and not following proper procedure? Don’t be afraid to raise a <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/tuesday-teachable-tweets-%E2%80%93-episode-1-points-of-order?blogcategory=Presiding">point of order</a> and, if necessary, to move an appeal. Members shouldn’t tolerate poor presiding.</p><p>If you are a chair who, like the former president described earlier, values efficiency, you need to balance the efficiency of a meeting with its <strong>effectiveness</strong>, which my colleague Jim Lochrie defines in his great book <em>Meeting Procedures</em>, as a meeting’s ‘ability to reach useful and well thought out decisions’, with the chair responsible for ensuring the opportunity for ‘meaningful debate’ — debate that may require more time, more speakers, and more ideas to enhance its effectiveness. Conducting a meeting is not a race.</p><p>Roy Orbison was certain that it was the end in his classic 1964 song ‘It’s Over’. When it comes to meetings, however, it’s not always over when you think it is.</p><p><em>The author is a Registered Parliamentarian based in Toronto and Kincardine, Ontario. He works with clients across Canada and the United States. More resources can be found at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></a><em>. Comments and questions are welcome!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8c58d6438d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Resolved: That We Use ‘Whereas’ Sparingly]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/resolved-that-we-use-whereas-sparingly-b7402848b320?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7402848b320</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-of-directors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Nov 2025 18:53:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-17T17:31:53.573Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/310/1*srZ3K1S81Mbj5csf73z2Ww.jpeg" /><figcaption>Don’t wear out your Town Crier by including too many ‘Whereas’ statements in your resolutions.</figcaption></figure><p>Clients occasionally ask me about resolutions — for example: what’s the difference between a resolution and a motion; do resolutions need a preamble; how many ‘whereas’ statements should be in the preamble (is there a maximum or minimum number); how many ‘resolved’ clauses can be in a resolution, etc. Readers of this blog may have similar questions.</p><p>So, let’s start with some definitions. First, what is a <strong>motion</strong>? A motion is a formal proposal by a member that the body (whether it’s a committee, board, council, AGM or convention) should take some sort of action; it is the standard way in which business is proposed and processed at a meeting.</p><p>There are, of course, different kinds of motions. A <strong>main motion</strong> introduces a subject to a meeting for a decision. It is the most commonly used motion, and is the basic device by which a substantive matter is presented to a meeting for possible action — see <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em> (<em>RONR</em>), 12th edition, 10:3. (Technically, <em>Robert</em> distinguishes between <strong>original</strong> main motions and <strong>incidental</strong> main motions; for the purposes of this blog post, a main motion is equivalent to an original main motion.)</p><p>What, then, is a <strong>resolution</strong>? My colleague Jim Lochrie likes to refer to a resolution as a main motion ‘with bells and whistles’. A member may propose a main motion in the form of a resolution ‘either because of its importance or because of its length or complexity’ (<em>RONR</em>, 10:13). In other words, a resolution is a main motion, but with two key features: (a) it must always be submitted in writing (either pre-circulated before the meeting, if required, or submitted at the meeting), and (b) it adheres to a particular format, with one or more clauses each beginning with the word ‘Resolved’ followed by ‘That’. A main motion that is not a resolution, on the other hand, simply begins with ‘That’ and it may be in writing, but even if not called a resolution, any main motion that is long or complicated, <strong>should</strong> be in writing (and the chair can insist that it be so).</p><p>A third feature that is common to most resolutions is that they are often accompanied by a preamble consisting of one or more ‘Whereas’ statements that usually include background information or reasons for the motion’s adoption. Do resolutions need a preamble? No. <em>Robert</em> emphasizes that ‘neither rule nor custom requires a resolution to have a preamble, and one should not be used merely for the sake of form’ (10:16). The reality, however, is that the opportunity to use a preamble is precisely why a resolution is such a popular option, and why it is sometimes abused.</p><p>A preamble enables the mover and supporters of a resolution to signal, in advance, the rationale for the proposal. Before the meeting — before it is moved and before the debate even begins — the major arguments in favour of the motion can be provided to members in the absence of any opposing comments. Sometimes, this can be taken to extremes; I have seen resolutions with preambles consisting of ten, twenty and in one case, over forty whereas statements — a nasty form of procedural torture! (The potential downside of including whereas statements, even short ones, is that members can reach a decision to vote against the resolution before it even hits the floor.)</p><p>Without suggesting a specific limit,<em> Robert</em> suggests that the preamble should be a ‘<strong>brief</strong> statement of background’ and ‘should be limited to cases where it provides little-known information without which the point or the merits of a resolution are likely to be poorly understood’ (10:16); ‘a preamble generally should contain no more clauses than are <strong>strictly necessary</strong>’ (10:18) — emphasis added.</p><p>There is also no specified limit on the number of resolving clauses, although as with any motion containing several parts, ‘the parts can be separated to be considered and voted on as if they were distinct questions’ (<em>RONR</em> 27:1). If the resolving clauses relate to a single subject, and members want to discuss and vote on one or more of them separately, the motion for Division of the Question can be moved and adopted by majority vote (non-debatable). If, on the other hand, the resolving clauses relate to completely different subjects (more like an omnibus resolution), a single member can demand that they be separately discussed and voted on (27:10).</p><p>Debate and amendment should occur first on the resolving clauses and then on the preamble, if necessary.</p><p>What to do if members go crazy with whereas statements? The <em>AIP Standard Code of Parliamentary Procedure</em> notes that ‘the statements contained in the whereas clauses sometimes are the cause of disagreement. Members frequently desire to debate and amend these prefacing statements, often to the neglect of the substantive resolved clauses . . .’ (<em>AIPSC</em>, 2nd ed., 12.12). The <em>Code</em> offers two useful suggestions:</p><p>· If the preamble contains statements that would be out of order in debate, the chair must rule the entire resolution out of order, accepting its resubmission only if the offending language is removed (12.11).</p><p>· The preamble ‘should be factual as much as possible rather than expressing opinion’ (12.13).</p><p>And of course it is always within the authority of an organization to limit the size of preambles, or simply ban them, by adopting restrictions in their bylaws or in a special rule of order.</p><p>Are the whereas statements included in the minutes of the meeting? The short answer is yes, and that could be another reason why members prepare lengthy preambles with multiple whereas statements. The resolution may end up being defeated, but the motion and its rationale still appear in the official record of the meeting — even if the practice is not to include in the minutes a summary of what was said in debate. If an organization is plagued by frequent use of lengthy and/or inflammatory preambles, the members can <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/a-few-moments-on-minutes">adopt a special rule of order</a> specifying that preambles are not to be included in the minutes; public bodies such as municipal councils or school boards could accomplish the same objective by amending their procedural bylaws.</p><p>It is also worth noting that, just because a motion is submitted in the form of a resolution, it doesn’t necessarily trigger the need to be reviewed by a resolutions committee, whether one exists or not. For conventions and AGMs, it may be the case that all motions are submitted through a resolutions committee, but this requirement stems from the terms of reference or scope of the committee, not whether a motion is in the format of a resolution.</p><p>Resolutions are particularly useful if an organization is intending to publish or otherwise make public a decision. Two examples come to mind:</p><p>· <strong>If the organization wishes to express an institutional opinion or take a ‘political’ position on a particular issue. </strong>A union might, for example, adopt a resolution opposing government budget cuts, with the whereas statements outlining the arguments against the cuts.</p><p>· <strong>If someone is being honoured with a ‘courtesy resolution’. </strong>A courtesy resolution is often adopted to recognize someone’s achievements or to mark a retirement, with the preamble outlining the achievements or career highlights of the individual, and the resolution offering congratulations. (In such cases, the resolution and preamble are often printed and presented to the individual who is being honoured.)</p><p><strong>The key message:</strong> If you are drafting a resolution, don’t abuse your fellow members by inflicting multiple whereas clauses on them. Resolved: When it comes to the preamble, less is more!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7402848b320" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Secretary Does Not Own the Minutes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/the-secretary-does-not-own-the-minutes-0f9c9ef16bef?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0f9c9ef16bef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meeting-minutes]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 18 Oct 2025 21:22:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-19T16:36:00.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/327/1*h8WWE-DVkGiPqhI0w2--pw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A secretary, poised to correct the minutes? Agnolo Bronzino, ‘Young Man with a Quill and Paper’, 1527.</figcaption></figure><p>Although the secretary of a board or committee is responsible for preparing the draft minutes of a meeting, it is the members of the body who decide whether any corrections are required. I have written <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/a-few-moments-on-minutes">previously</a> about the proper process for approving the minutes, and won’t go into the details here, although to summarize: the chair should ask if there are corrections, handle any by unanimous consent, and then declare the minutes approved, without the need for a motion or a vote (see <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em>, 12th edition, 41:10).</p><p>For the purposes of this post, I am interested in discussing the secretary’s <strong>reaction</strong> to having the minutes corrected. Unfortunately, it’s not always a pretty sight, by which I mean that some secretaries do not react well when ‘their’ minutes are being changed. Some get quite defensive, take it personally, consider it an attack on their competence, and become argumentative or resentful. I am not suggesting that most secretaries are like this, but I have seen enough such reactions that I think it warrants a closer look.</p><p>Such behaviour is more likely in voluntary organizations, where the secretary is elected or cajoled into taking the position, and where it may be seen as a thankless job. I have witnessed several situations where a secretary became annoyed with suggested changes to the minutes. In one extreme case, someone who had held the position of secretary unchallenged for years abruptly resigned from the organization after the minutes were corrected (quite appropriately) in two consecutive meetings. This individual compared it to a vote of non-confidence, and nothing could persuade him that it was not personal.</p><p>I confess that, in the early stages of my career as a corporate secretary, I took occasional umbrage when someone raised questions about the minutes I had drafted, but I quickly learned two important lessons: first, that the corrections were never personally directed at me, and second, that in almost every case, the corrections were valid and resulted in more accurate minutes. Sometimes, a proposed correction might be based on a misunderstanding, and it would then be withdrawn when the situation was clarified by other members, but the key point was that the minutes did not belong to me; as the official record of a meeting, the minutes belong to the members.</p><p>The minutes circulated with the agenda are considered (and should always be labelled) ‘draft’ for a reason. They are not yet final until the members have an opportunity to review and correct them, after which they are then considered approved.</p><p>It is not just the secretary, of course, who can become possessive about his or her portfolio. In another organization in which I participated, it was the treasurer who couldn’t stand questions or comments about ‘her’ budget, again seeing them as efforts to undermine her authority.</p><p>My advice? As a secretary (or treasurer or committee chair), try not to take proposed changes to the minutes (or the budget or a committee report) personally. You’ve done your best, prepared a document that you believe is complete and accurate, and now you have submitted your draft for the consideration of your fellow members. You are human, meaning that it is always possible you have missed something or made an error. If you disagree with a proposed change, obviously you should speak up, but if a majority of members accept the change, <strong>you</strong> need to accept it and move on.</p><p>I know this is easy to say and often hard to do, but it’s always important to try to keep things in perspective and take the long view. Think about why you joined the organization originally, the good work that the organization does, and the contribution you make (and will continue to make) to that work. If you did miss something in recording the minutes, tell yourself you will do better next time.</p><p>A few other suggestions to deal with this problem if it occurs:</p><p><strong>·</strong> If you are a member reviewing the minutes, don’t nitpick, but if you spot a legitimate omission or error, try to draw it to the attention of the secretary before the meeting, if that’s possible. That would enable the secretary, if he or she agrees with the correction, to suggest the change when the draft is up for approval.</p><p><strong>·</strong> One of the principal reasons why there are often debates over the minutes is the tendency to include what was discussed at a meeting rather than just what was decided. <em>Robert</em> states that the minutes ‘should contain mainly a record of what was <strong>done</strong> at the meeting, not what was <strong>said</strong> by the members’ (48:2). The practices of organizations will, of course, vary, but expecting the secretary to summarize in the minutes the various points made by speakers when debating a motion just creates opportunities for members to argue that their points weren’t included, or weren’t emphasized as much as other perspectives, or weren’t recorded accurately. For more on what should, and should not, be included in the minutes, see <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/a-few-moments-on-minutes?blogcategory=Minutes">my earlier blog post</a>.</p><p><strong>·</strong> Many organizations establish a minutes approval committee to review and approve the minutes, particularly if the body itself does not meet again within three months of the last meeting (48:12). This could be the board or executive in the case of an annual convention, or it could be a special committee appointed just for the purpose of reviewing the minutes. Such a review should be welcomed by the secretary as a quality control measure to ensure that a few additional members are able to weigh in on the accuracy of the record shortly after the meeting, while memories are still fresh.</p><p><strong>·</strong> Even if there isn’t a formal minutes approval committee in your organization, it’s a good practice for the secretary to proactively send a first draft to the president (or perhaps the entire executive) for feedback before a second draft is finalized for circulation to the membership.</p><p><strong>·</strong> Some organizations routinely include the minutes on a <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/using-a-consent-agenda-for-efficient-and-effective-meetings">consent agenda</a>, which means they are approved in a block vote without debate (usually by unanimous consent), unless a member specifically asks for the item to be moved to the regular agenda. If the minutes are limited to recording decisions, it is usually unnecessary for anyone to offer a correction; essentially, the default is that the minutes are approved unless someone objects.</p><p>The bottom line: if members have the right to approve the minutes, they also have the right to propose corrections. The secretary needs to accept it.</p><p><em>Michael Mouritsen, a Registered Parliamentarian, is based in Toronto and Kincardine, Ontario, and works with clients across Canada and the United States. For more information, including his blog, please visit </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0f9c9ef16bef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Challenging a Vote? Be Quick About It!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/challenging-a-vote-be-quick-about-it-ede40fe08f80?source=rss-c60ffe76706------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ede40fe08f80</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-of-directors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roberts-rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliamentary-procedure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Mouritsen | RP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Sep 2025 20:44:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-01T20:44:56.964Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/143/1*qEGv52wPQGEIKedIiApJYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Make sure to be timely if you want to challenge the accuracy of a vote, or you might feel like one of Salvador Dali’s clocks. Detail from Dali’s 1931 painting ‘The Persistence of Memory’.</figcaption></figure><p>This post was prompted, in part, by a personal experience at a convention for which I was serving as parliamentarian (sitting beside the presiding officer and providing procedural advice during the meeting). There was a close show of hands vote on a contentious motion, and the chair announced that she was unsure of the result. She asked for the vote to be retaken by a rising vote.</p><p>Those in favour of the motion were asked to stand and sit down (without being counted), and then those opposed were asked to stand and sit down. Although the vote was still close, it was now much clearer (from the chair’s vantage point on a raised podium at the front of the hall) that the motion had been defeated, and the chair announced the result accordingly.</p><p>At that point, the meeting was almost at the scheduled lunch break and, rather than immediately move to the next agenda item, the chair asked if there was any objection to breaking a few minutes early; there was none, so the chair declared that we were recessed for lunch.</p><p>Shortly after the recess was announced, and as members were leaving the hall, a member rushed to the podium to express concern over the closeness of the previous vote. The chair pointed out that it was clear to her, based on the rising vote, that the motion had been defeated, and noted that no one had objected when she announced the result. The member said, ‘Well, <strong>I </strong>object!’. I explained to the member that it was now too late, but she was still upset and quickly walked away.</p><p>So let’s look at how to verify the results of a vote if you think the chair gets it wrong. The one important thing to keep in mind is that, similar to <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/tuesday-teachable-tweets-%E2%80%93-episode-1-points-of-order">raising a point of order</a> or <a href="https://medium.com/@mmouritsen/dont-like-the-chair-s-ruling-raise-concerns-at-meeting-not-in-text-message-9710d0e6ac43">moving to appeal a chair’s ruling</a>, <strong>timeliness</strong> is essential. You need to raise your concern immediately after the chair announces the result.</p><p>In the case of the upset member who wanted to challenge the result of the close vote at the convention, here is what <strong>might</strong> have happened instead.</p><p>After the chair had announced the result based on conducting a rising vote, the member could have immediately moved to retake the vote under another method. <em>Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised</em>,12th edition (abbreviated as <em>RONR</em>), notes that ‘In practice, the method of taking a vote usually can be agreed upon informally’ (30:4), so without requiring a seconder or a vote, the chair likely would have simply asked for a <strong>counted</strong> rising vote, in which those in favour stand again, but this time are counted, and then those opposed stand again and are counted.</p><p>The counting can be done by staff or designated members, called tellers, but the most transparent method of counting is when the members do it themselves, also known as a ‘serpentine vote’: first those in favour of the motion stand, and then those opposed, in each case with members counting off by rows and sitting down one at a time after counting off (see <em>RONR</em> 45:15).</p><p>If the chair is still in doubt after conducting either a show of hands or a rising vote, the chair under his or her own authority can <strong>require</strong> a counted vote, but if the chair doesn’t order a counted vote, it can be moved by any member. In such a case, unless the chair suggests proceeding informally, the motion for a counted vote needs a second, is undebatable, and is adopted by a majority — determined by voice, show of hands or a rising vote; the motion for a counted vote itself is never taken by a counted vote!</p><p>The result of a counted vote, in my experience, is always accepted as definitive.</p><p>If the chair in this case had <strong>not</strong> asked for a rising vote, but had simply announced the vote based on a show of hands, a single member could have demanded a rising (uncounted) vote. This is known as calling for a ‘Division of the Assembly’, and can also be demanded after a voice vote (where those in favour say ‘aye’ and those opposed say ‘no’) — see <em>RONR</em> 29:1.</p><p>It is also worth noting that, in verifying a vote, ‘a vote is never retaken by the same form of voting’ (45:14); it has to be a different method.</p><p>The call to verify a vote should be based on a sincere belief that the announced result is not accurate, typically because it appears too close to call. It is possible, of course, for a member to try to abuse this option, in order to waste time or otherwise disrupt a meeting. <em>Robert</em> states, in 29:7, that ‘when it is clear that there has been a full vote and there can be no reasonable doubt as to which side is in the majority, a call for a Division is dilatory, and the chair should not allow the individual member’s right of demanding a Division to be abused to the annoyance of the assembly’.</p><p>What about other methods of voting? I have previously written about the following related topics:</p><p>1. You might want to vote on a motion using a <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/secret-ballots---not-just-for-elections">secret ballot</a> in order to protect the confidentiality of members’ votes.</p><p>2. The complete opposite of a secret ballot is a <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/demanding-that-your-vote-appear-in-the-minutes">roll-call</a> vote, in which members are individually polled, with the minutes showing how each member voted.</p><p>3. You might have voted one way, but now want to <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/can-you-change-your-vote-in-a-meeting">change your vote</a> when the vote is retaken.</p><p>(Whether or not the vote was close, if you notice an irregularity with the voting procedure, such as someone voting who wasn’t eligible to vote or someone whose vote was counted twice, you would immediately raise a <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/tuesday-teachable-tweets-%E2%80%93-episode-1-points-of-order">point of order</a>, rather than moving to retake the vote by a different method. And on a somewhat related note, although not in connection with verifying a vote, if you feel a decision was taken too quickly or with insufficient information, you might be eligible to move to <a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/blog/f/to-reconsider-a-motion">reconsider</a> the vote, a procedure that has its own unique timelines and other characteristics.)</p><p>The key point to remember if you want to propose retaking a vote by a different method is that the action ‘must be taken <strong>immediately</strong> after the chair’s announcement, before any debate or business has intervened’ (<em>RONR</em> 45:9, emphasis added). It is too late to raise a challenge to the vote if the meeting has already moved on and started to discuss the next item of business.</p><p>To sum up:</p><p>· For most votes on most motions, most organizations typically start with a show of hands vote, and if that needs to be verified, they take a rising vote. If that needs to be verified, they then take a counted rising vote.</p><p>· On the demand of a single member, a rising vote <strong>must</strong> be held (known as a Division of the Assembly). The call for a Division does not require a second and it does not, itself, require a vote.</p><p>· A single member cannot require a counted vote, but may propose it by moving a motion (needs a seconder, undebatable), which is adopted by a majority. If such a motion is made, however, the chair will often informally simply ask for the counted vote (rather than having members vote to do so), in order to ensure that members have confidence in the result of the vote.</p><p>· One of the important responsibilities of the chair is to verify the accuracy of votes, so if the chair doubts a vote, he or she must require a rising vote or a counted vote (and on his or her own authority can move directly to a counted vote from a show of hands vote), without waiting for a member to raise it in either case.</p><p>· If, as a member, you have concerns about a vote, you need to speak up <strong>immediately</strong>. If you delay, you may miss the opportunity to retake the vote to confirm its accuracy.</p><p><em>Michael Mouritsen, a Registered Parliamentarian, is based in Kincardine and Toronto, Ontario, and works with clients across Canada and the United States. More resources can be found at </em><a href="https://michaelmouritsen.ca/"><em>MichaelMouritsen.ca</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ede40fe08f80" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>