<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mitchell Norcross on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mitchell Norcross on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mnorcros?source=rss-3d31a2a1c67c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 21:59:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mnorcros/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Internet as a Forum for Action]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mnorcros/the-internet-as-a-forum-for-action-9944856bbc05?source=rss-3d31a2a1c67c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9944856bbc05</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mitchell Norcross]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 23 Feb 2018 20:53:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-23T20:53:07.922Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>After years of viewing it as a source of poison, I got an IPhone my sophomore year of high school. I had social media for a few years leading up to this, but the accessibility of it was something I thought would only serve to make my life worse. I assumed this would have a net negative effect on me and my peers, and I am not sure I have ever been more right about something. For the better part of my life, I have seen the internet as the ultimate source of information within the world. The ultimate and all-encompassing forum through which individuals share ideas and display their identity as an actor within society to one another. Of course, it is a place to buy and sell things, and assumes many other forms of utility, so I will limit this to the sphere of individuals interacting with one another (social media). The purpose of this, it always seemed, was to bring people closer together, while also allowing each other to share ourselves truthfully. After all, you are generally leaving something on the internet in perpetuity because you believe it to be representative of something within yourself. This comes with the underlying assumption that it is something which you want people to view as inherent to you. There are many platitudes to this, many variations it comes in, with varying degrees of importance to the representation of one’s character. Some people may only be willing to share small parts of themselves, while others might feel the desire to post the entirety of their day online. This all seems to be a positive, but there is a lurking issue which has corrupted the utility of these platforms so deeply, that I fear the world would’ve been better off had they never existed.</p><p>The issue begins with people creating a strange duality between their personal identity within the real world, versus the one created online. I noticed this at a young age when people would act extremely confident and boisterous online, then become extremely anxious and silent in person. Similar to when you text somebody too much without actually speaking to them in person, and then you find every real interaction to be inconsistent and awkward. Only the difference is the parameterizing of the notable difference from an interaction with one person, to interactions with most people. On this small scale, it is obvious that some fundamentally imperative aspect of human interaction is missing when the interaction occurs through a screen. Yet you still find people are more comfortable sharing their deepest most serious opinions in the endless expanse of the internet, than they are in a personal, real conversation. It is really backwards, it’s like if people walked around wearing labels that said they ascribed to a multitude of beliefs, but when asked about it they pretended it had very little to do with what their identity as a social actor is. It’s almost as if the import of those character traits which they are loud and proud about online is limited to that sphere alone. Of course there are disassociated people both in the platform of real life and that of social media. But this duality holds for a large sect of people, and it is one which seems to be irreconcilable in many cases with how they carry themselves in actual conversation and interaction. The issue of having an online identity is obvious and linked to one crucial aspect of what I would call internet argumentation. This is the idea of an escape.</p><p>In a conversation between two people in which there is a challenge of something stated and thus an ensuing disagreement or argument, both seek the comfort and security of correctness. Obviously, nobody likes to be wrong, it’s the worst feeling in the world. In the real world, when two people engage in disagreement they can at least gauge the importance of it to one another through obvious social indications. Were all human beings, I do not need to explain this. The argument is had, generally between two people, and hopefully a conclusion is reached and you agree, or agree to disagree. There is a civil aspect to this, one which comes because there is not an obvious escape from the discomfort of dealing with an opposing viewpoint. The internet, by contrast, is the coward’s platform; this is not to say all who use it are afraid of working out issues, but rather it offers an easy escape to hiding from working out issues. This escape is the ready availability of a ceaseless horde of like-minded individuals who think the exact same way as you, and give you the comfort of not having to reach a conclusion in a discussion. Imagine now you’re having that argument in the real world with a million people on either side, one group cheering your opinion and the other cheering your adversaries uniformly. It doesn’t at face value seem to be something which would alter the substance of the debate, but it certainly does. Presidential debates would be a good example of this in the real world, whoever can reaffirm their sides opinions without saying something abjectly foolish, while also receiving the most cheers, generally wins. Though no valuable conclusion can even be abstracted from a transcript of the discussion which has just occurred. This is not to say the internet is a bad format to enact meaningful social change through discussion, but rather that it is not being used correctly. Simply because the temptation to escape back into the group which identifies most with you is overpowering, even with some outliers who fend off the temptation.</p><p>Thus we have the encouragement of the ever-growing and always useless group identity, as Nietzsche once said, “In individuals, insanity is rare; but in groups, parties, nations, and epochs, it is the rule.” To witness the uselessness and dangers of this you need look no further than what has occurred with political discourse on the internet. I do not need to share my political opinions because it is self-evident on both sides how absolutely useless this mutual grouping of one another has become. You will almost never hear a conservative say “wow that NowThis video about Australian gun laws sure changed the way I view the issue” or a liberal say “wow that Ben Shapiro video sure opened my eyes about abortion.” This holds true for people who are already in the business of formulating a stance from the prerogative of one who identifies with a certain stratum of political orientation. The sub-stratum for both is obviously the same, ideologically a set of principals which one identifies with, which can be consistently applied situationally and contemporaneously in such a way that a side is always picked. A perfect example of the immutability of this stance is in the rationale for sharing loaded opinions (loaded in the sense that a side in a controversial issue is picked). I might share a video online, and say it’s to “persuade you” but deep down we all know we share controversial things because we really see them as coherent and merited manifestations or representations of our feelings on the issue. The intent to “persuade” is a façade which coats the actual motivation, which is to re-affirm something you already believe in totality.</p><p>Furthermore, the source of the information you are sharing has no altruistic desire to make the world a better place. Look no further than the exact polar opposites of Fox News and CNN. They are two political news entities in direct competition with one another, who want nothing more than to garner profit and expand the amount of people sharing their message. The effectiveness of this is partial proof of the motivations. This is tugging at the heart strings of those who need something for this inconsistent identity to attach itself to. Victims might be propped up by these information outlets “they’re on our side, see how right we are!” suddenly this internet crusader from within feels that same outrage. A line in the sand is drawn, the enemy is clearly those who disagree, and they disagree for the reasons this outlet has taught. But how is this done? By tapping into that internet personality so many people have created for themselves, one which has a yearning to find others to identify with.</p><p>This follows the same pathology of a parasite searching for a host, of course if no host was around it would wither away and die, but the internet is a platform full of willing hosts. People whose behavior online directly shows that they would like nothing more than to feel like they are in a perpetual state of righteousness. The identity clings to the larger entity which voices the arguments coherently and an idolatress worship for it is born in the process. Yet you need look no further than at the conflicting narratives every competing source of information shares to realize there is a clear problem. Seriously, go find two information sources which are in direct competition, find an issue they are covering, then spend a couple hours doing independent research which pulls from objective primary sources. Like the actual written language inside of a bill rather than someone’s two-minute sound bite. A problem which is perpetuated by people who are willingly taken advantage of for the betterment of a cause they could not defend beyond the two-minute talking point they’ve been fed. Again you’ll feel the soft foundations of what the internet has taught you to believe weaken as you realize this is a systematic cycle of reaffirming what you already believe to be true.</p><p>This is a self-fulfilling prophecy predicated on positive feedback loops where you share it, the people you agree with praise you, and the people who disagree with you generally ignore it or comment only to be excoriated publicly. Either way, you feel pretty good at the end of it all! Which further intensifies ones fetishizing over their own predispositions which are constitutive of this online identity. Furthermore, both sides succeed only in further alienation from one another. This is not unique to the internet, as I am sure someone skeptical of my observation would point out. But no example could be provided which could comparably explain the amplification of these differences between people so rapidly. The polarization of politics within the United States is an easy example. But the issue of it is one which I believe reaches deeply into the core of people’s valuation of themselves as actors of change on the internet. Look at the animus religious and non-religious people share for one another on the internet, then watch them converse civilly in person. There is a direct causal link between doing something on the internet and wanting people to see something about you as you do it. I do not believe that every statement made is ill-advised, with the intent of corroding the fabrics of human interaction. I do however believe this problem comes from the earlier stated duality which is made exponentially worse by the easy escapes offered by the internet. With the acknowledgment of the dualities existence between how people act online, and how they act in real life, comes the consequences of this. The most significant one being the narrowing of possibility to enact change through discourse on the internet. or rather, the internet being a bad forum for action.</p><p>The endless interactions and discussion people will take part in as well as the numerous things a person will change throughout their lives is merely them acting in a world which is a forum for action. That is a thing with which we act upon to initiate change that we hope to be meaningful. The perception of the internet as something as real as real life is extremely problematic. Its superficial, all of it means nothing, there are people who literally lose sleep over how many people like their Instagram post. The most effective, but difficult thing to do would be for everyone to quit using it, but in the words of Thomas Aquinas, “not everything that is difficult is more meritorious.” I see this is something almost completely impossible. So what would the easiest solution be? What would the most meritorious solution be? Surely it couldn’t be to completely rewire ourselves as individuals either, this is another herculean task which would prove futile. It seems obvious that what must be done is to take a step back from the apparatus of social media which is strangling individuality in the good name of a purposeless form of tribalism. To begin viewing the internet as a place to conduct yourself as you would in the real world, not something separate, and especially not something to dictate the way you orient yourself in the real world. That is to say, do not engage in a fight which you would have no business engaging in had the opportunity arisen outside the four corners of a computer screen. Ignorance is not bliss, nor is comfort predicated on agreement with others about who you disagree with. You should ask yourself if you’re the person with convictions so strong you’d express inherent disdain and hatred for another person over a video shared on the internet. Or someone who is closer to the reasonable person you present in the real world where interaction has a legitimate chance to occur.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9944856bbc05" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>