<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mohammad on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mohammad on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mohammadmansur?source=rss-78fddfd4c7e4------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 04:51:11 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mohammadmansur/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Good judgement, bad judgement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mohammadmansur/good-judgement-bad-judgement-b30c4843606?source=rss-78fddfd4c7e4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b30c4843606</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pitching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judging]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mohammad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Jun 2017 18:01:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-12T18:05:35.507Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*d9h0lvOFqGCLZCStRvW41Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Any resemblance to actual persons living o dead is purely coincidental</figcaption></figure><p>I don’t care for much of the startup scene in Pakistan. That might seem like too sweeping a statement. On the contrary it’s about as qualified a statement that I could bring myself to put in writing, and that too because of a couple of very worthy programs that’ve cropped up recently.</p><p>The problems with our startup scene have been discussed at length on different forums. Those of us who’ve been part of the scene for more than a few months are well aware of the issues at hand, and the insightful ones are also cognizant of the reasons, so I won’t attempt a forensic analysis for fear of being repetitive. I would however, care to speak on a single, atomic aspect of our startup culture. It is by no means the biggest or the most urgent aspect, but it’s one that I’ve been annoyed enough by to actually make the effort to write about: bad judging at pitch competitions.</p><p><strong>What makes a good judge?</strong><br>A typical judges panel in Pakistan consists of a variety of characters. There are your experienced entrepreneurs, who’ve built and operated successful businesses (recently or not). There are your industry notables who hold executive positions in national or private organizations relevant to the startup scene (including individuals who may or may not have been, or ever aspired to be, startup founders). And then you have the rare breed who’ve been startup founders and transitioned into tentative angel investors. There are, of course, all shades of grey on either side of and in between these distinct categories, but let’s ignore that detail for the sake of brevity.</p><p>The type of experiences that the judge carries affects the way they look at the world, and how they end up judging a startup, a team or an idea. Timing matters (when did their entrepreneurial experience transpire), type of experience matters (startup vs. lifestyle business, product vs. services, tech-based vs. tech-enabled vs. non-tech) and personality matters (how full of themselves are they, can they see the future, can they ever be wrong, do they speak for the world).</p><p>You might assume that I’m arguing that a certain type of background is more suitable for functioning as a startup pitch judge, and you’ll be partially correct, but it’s also true that anecdotally, there are good and bad judges from all of these category of backgrounds. However, the law of averages is a thing, and on average those with prior startup experience tend to be better startup judges than those without. And those with investing experience tend to be the best startup judges. For the latter, the number of deals executed matter more than the number of pitches they get to hear on average, and that in turn matters more than just having money and calling themselves investors).</p><p>The difficulty here is that any pitch event organizer has finite options to choose from when it comes to inviting judges for their panel, and since all these types of people are successful and busy individuals and are generally doing this as a favor, the logistics of putting together a judging panel would be one of the tougher challenges any organizer has to face and they can’t be too picky. So the problem (and its solution) doesn’t lie in just picking the judges with the right background, because we simply wouldn’t have enough judges with that background to go around.</p><p><strong>A framework to judge judges</strong><br>So what’s the solution? It’s no different than what a startup has to do to improve their business. Build, measure, learn. In this case it would go more like choose, measure, learn. The operative action here is ‘measure’, and to measure you have to define metrics / criteria. Whereas a startup needs to use quantitative metrics because of their short iteration times (what’s the percentage change in conversions based on a button color / placement), startup events would have to rely on qualitative criteria (how did a judge perform, based on our criteria).</p><p>This is inherently subjective and not without its challenges, but it’s surely better than just cycling through the available pool of judges based on availability. And it matters. It matters because startup pitch competitions are invaluable for startups to receive validation and guidance. It matters because these events are important to pick more promising startups for promotion and exposure, and not least because it’s a privilege to have people offer themselves to you for judgement and if you’re doing a bad job you’re guilty of violating artcles 62 &amp; 63 of our constitution.</p><p>I’m proposing the following criteria for good startup pitch judging. These are subjective, based on my varied but finite experiences and surely open to judgement and improvement in themselves. But here they are, for whatever they’re worth:</p><p><strong>Dos:</strong><br><em>a. Judge what you’re asked to judge:</em><br>Depending on the event / nature of the event. The judge may be asked to evaluate a startup based on any of the following:<br>i. Pitch (clarity of thought, pitch design, completeness)<br>ii. Delivery (body language, tone, passion)<br>iii. Idea / business plan (value prop, market, viability, scalability, risks / showstoppers, competitiveness):<br>Probably the most important and most difficult aspect to judge well. I’ve seen startups win competitions without proposing a clear value proposition. I’ve seen startups win competitions with big question marks around scalability. Heck, I’ve seen ‘startups’ win competitions who’re not even a startup but a service shop working on a cool tech with no strategy or even plans to scale up by managing to wow the judges with a cool visual tech. When judges get this wrong you just wanna holler “you had one job!”.<br>iv. Execution (traction, team)<br>In many case, the judges are asked to judge based on some combination of the above. All these are fine and within the purview of the judges. Where many of the ‘bad’ judges mess up are when they venture into the forbidden territory, outlined below:</p><p><strong>Don’ts:</strong><br><em>a. Don’t judge the product</em><br>It may sound crazy, but it’s not. Understanding the product is necessary, but not because of the reasons you may have in mind. Understanding the product is only important to put the things you’re actually supposed to judge in perspective such as the business / execution plan, the market, competitiveness etc.</p><p>Andrea Barrica, Venture Partner at 500Startups once retorted to a group of us pitching to her with: <br>“Stop trying to sell me your product. I don’t wanna fall in love with your product, I’ll probably never buy or use your product. Sell me your business”.</p><p>Take a moment to think about it. You as a judge have never used the product, or may never want to. If you have, it was probably in some crappy beta stage otherwise the founder won’t be pitching to you.</p><p>More importantly, if you’re judging based on your experience with the product, you’re by definition not judging the pitch. If you don’t get this point, stop reading further and revisit this. Discuss this in comments. Don’t move on.</p><p>Even those instances where you think it’s important to judge the product, it’s probably something else about the startup you’re judging. If you think a smart sleep monitor won’t sell because it’s features are not compelling enough, you’re probably (rightly) judging its “competitiveness in the market” based on ‘currently planned’ features. If you’re judging it based on ‘currently built’ features, you’re wasting everyone’s time.</p><p><em>b. Don’t predict the future</em><br>Again, probably counter-intuitive. You may think you can identify the next big thing, you can’t. No one can. Mark Zuckerberg can’t. Marc Andreessen can’t. Mark Cuban can’t. The best anyone can do is pinpoint some aspect where the founders are screwing up to make a call with some degree of certainty that they’ll fail. If there isn’t a gaping hole in the execution plan or some smoking gun in the market dynamic sounding its demise, predicting a startup’s success or failure is little more deterministic than reading tea leaves.</p><p>Experienced investors understand this. That’s why they hedge their bets, that’s why they hunt in packs and never try to hog a deal. It’s also one of the reasons why they make excellent startup judges.</p><p><em>c. Don’t pretend to represent the world</em><br>It proceeds something like this:</p><p>“I don’t think this is a big enough problem”. “I don’t think people would want this”. “I never felt the need for this”. “I am in your target market and I’ll never use it”.</p><p>To start with, if you ever feel the urge to pass judgement about the need for a product based on a whim, get a job. You’re not fit to be an entrepreneur, or an investor or a judge. The only way to do this is with data, whether it’s market data or traction or even surveys (those who know me know how little stock I put in surveys, but it’s still data).</p><p>If you feel the urge to state your propensity to use a particular product / service or not, don’t. It doesn’t matter. You may well be 1 out of 10 million people who may or may not need / want the product / service. Forcing founders to convince you that you need a product or service is pointless.</p><p>Instead, try to understand why someone might need it, what would that someone be like, what would their life be like, how may the startup founder find similar someones, then proceed to project in your head how big a market that might represent, Would that be a growing or a shrinking market etc.</p><p>You’re not the market. Don’t pretend to be.</p><p><em>Philosophical rambling: </em><br>Appreciate the futility to judge the ‘need’ of something for anyone other than yourself. The separation of ‘needs’ and ‘wants’ is a bug in human language, and bucket-loads of people have inexplicable wants (such as wanting to make America great again, or to capture little pocket monsters while walking around the block in circles). Moreover, wants change over time. I never wanted an over-sized iPhone that couldn’t even make calls. Turns out I eventually bought one.</p><p>In short, this is the hall-mark of a ‘bad’ judge. Sadly, this is also the most common problem I’ve encountered in our pitch competitions.</p><p><em>d. Don’t judge founders based on preconceptions</em><br>Kind of self-explanatory. You may know the person pitching. You may like them, you may not. You may think they’re the worst entrepreneur and guaranteed to not achieve anything in life, or you may think they’re Steve Jobs reincarnate. In either case, remember that they’re not asking for your daughter’s hand in marriage. They’re pitching their startup to you. Listen to and judge the damn pitch!</p><p>Also there’s the minor detail of it being unfair and unethical. If you don’t get this, again, don’t read further. Or maybe do, you’ve already read 1350 words. Might as well finish it </p><p><em>Awesomeness:</em><br>In some rare cases, you come across judges who actually add value to startups during Q&amp;A and feedback. This happens only when:<br>a. The judge actually realizes that these events are not about the judges, but about the participants. <br>b. The judges hold themselves to the same exacting standards that they expect from entrepreneurs. Specifically, that it’s the easiest thing in the world to say “I don’t like this”, “this wouldn’t work” etc. but it adds no value, especially when it’s based on personal preferences. What’s more useful is basing their objections on market trends, empirical analogies or data.</p><p>However, awesomeness level 9000 is attained when the judges make the effort of understanding the startup enough to be able to recognize what the founder has missed and suggest reasonable improvements in story-telling, positioning, execution plan etc. Awesomeness deserves to be highlighted, and a few among the ones I’ve come across who’ve attained this level are <a href="https://medium.com/u/bbd168c39538">Yusuf Hussain</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/u/e4d37809da5e">Kalsoom Lakhani</a> and a few other. We need more judges like them.</p><p><strong>Conclusion (okay, I’m tired of writing now)</strong><br>I hope startup event organizers, entrepreneurs and, of course, past and future event judges start thinking along these lines and become part of this discussion, and hopefully use this as the basis of a framework to rate judges in future events. We need our judges to do a better job to make these events actually be useful. This may only be one of many things holding our ecosystem back, but it may also be one of the most easily solved. <br>Over to you guys. If you’ve had a similar experience when pitching, share it. If you think I’m full of it, let me have it (but know that I’m thick-skinned). Have you ever had to judge a startup pitch competition and guilty of the above mentioned sins… let’s hear your confessions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b30c4843606" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>