<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Molly Shanahan, PhD. on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Molly Shanahan, PhD. on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@molshanahan?source=rss-a5324c6d7e69------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 01:25:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@molshanahan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Disguised as Sunlight 1.0: Philia, Firestorms, and the Self-Imposed Non-Disclosure Agreement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@molshanahan/disguised-as-sunlight-1-0-philia-firestorms-and-the-self-imposed-non-disclosure-agreement-f645d0f0a2ca?source=rss-a5324c6d7e69------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f645d0f0a2ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ptsd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-recovery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[silencing-victims]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Molly Shanahan, PhD.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jun 2026 20:21:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-05T13:32:20.161Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>All names but my own and Dan Brescoll’s have been changed. Titles, but not names, are used for Denison University officials. The term ‘Denison’ refers to the institution and, where context requires, to officials or bodies involved in my termination.* Quoted language reflects words I understand to be exact or substantially exact; italics are used for emphasis, internal language, recurring motifs, or terms I am holding at a slight distance. References to correspondence, documents, deposition testimony, and legal filings are based on records in my possession or on the public record.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O4YtSq2APjdOU-2jJ4jNzQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Zemmi on the desk under the back window of the red cottage on the hill. Photo by Molly Shanahan.</figcaption></figure><p>There is no way to tell this whole story all at once.</p><p>Sometimes I joke that my PhD, and the process of writing my dissertation, prepared me for the ordeal.</p><p>The story.</p><p>The events.</p><p>The saga that I’m writing about.</p><p>My dissertation process launched me into exploring <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhizome_(philosophy)">rhizomes</a> as a way to frame my work in dance. Paradoxically, because the rhizome’s calling card is complexity, that work clarified how complexity disrupts and re/forms, complicates, overwhelms, and orders phenomena, repeatedly, in a process that is both cyclical and defies being labeled as a cycle. A rhizome can’t be called repetition. Can’t, in fact, be <em>called</em> anything.</p><p>Except: rhizome.</p><p>As I consider this now, a rhizome might be a disco ball: the tiny mirrors, the turning mechanism, each facet of light, the surface the light bounces onto, the dust it lights along the way, the eyes that behold it, the consciousness that does and does not process it, the fascia that receives and sends sensation. All without hierarchy, beginning, or end.</p><p>This is one of the difficulties of a disco ball: each facet changes the light, and the light, elusive and changing, affects the whole picture. So does the gaze — mine, yours, Denison’s. Not every facet can be held in view.</p><p>There is no way to tell this whole story all at once.</p><p>My therapist said: “what if you wrote about it (the story, the saga, the ordeal, the events) <em>badly</em>? What if you gave yourself permission to experiment with putting it out there, and doing it badly.”</p><p>“That’s an interesting idea,” I said. “But I’m afraid of Denison.”</p><p><em>Your eustachian tubes are malfunctioning, </em>the nurse says.</p><p>That angry, taut knot of snot and tissue and inflammation at the intersection of my ears and my throat. A firestorm. A throat irritation so deep, so maddeningly intertwined with my ears and the inner reaches of my nose, I think I might lose my mind. Deep in my skull, a relentless gripping toward the back of my jaw, the spaces between my molars closing ranks like a trick dungeon wall closing in on a forsaken prisoner. These tubes clogged with toxic mucus, my throat on three-alarm fire, so deep inside my skull. The back of my tongue a flaccid rubber hose blasting kerosene onto the whole mess.</p><p><em>I want to poke out my ears with a shrimp fork,</em> I tell my sister, who in turn tells me to go to Urgent Care.</p><p>Here, I imagine myself like a comic figure, line drawn and printed on newsprint, a shrimp fork, or better yet a long metal kebab stick, enameled onion on the end, poking out of my head, yeah, out of both ears, as I lay back, head resting in my hands, elbows splayed. Finally getting some relief, sipping a cocktail from a coconut, flimsy paper and toothpick umbrella dangling off the edge. My legs outstretched on an aluminum lawn chair, the ’70s crosshatched lime green, blue, and orange “plaid” plastic woven bottom prickling the backs of my bare legs, crossed demurely at the ankle.</p><p><em>Self-lobotomized and happy</em>, that would be the cartoon’s caption.</p><p><em>Nothing to worry about,</em> the nurse says, recommending a better combination of over-the-counter allergy pills than the ones I was taking, along with resumed regular use of nasal spray.</p><p><em>Flush with salt water and a Neti pot twice a day, gargle with salt water before bed. Chew gum. Sleep propped up with an extra pillow.</em></p><p>The oceanic rumbling in my ears?</p><p><em>It will clear up on its own,</em> she says.</p><p><em>I’ve got it under control.</em> Repeat this statement, three times.</p><p>Allergy pills, generic Pepcid, salt water gargle, earplugs for the pool, alcohol drops afterward. Crush a dramamine in local honey and eat by the teaspoon at night. Put Flonase on the end of a Q-tip and gently treat the ears. (Those last two are from Instagram.)</p><p>Then the headaches start. First, just one morning after a bad dream. Then, the knot in my ear/nose/throat coms back. Worse than before.</p><p><em>My eustachian tubes are malfunctioning, </em>I say.</p><p>I affix peel-and-stick Salonpas muscle patches to each side of my throat. Order refills of black seed oil and oregano oil. Tilt my head and squeeze droplets of amber mullein into my ears, shivering like a cat shaking as they fall into my inner ear. Smear Vicks on my lips and the dried edges of my nose. Prop myself up more in bed. Order Fisherman’s Friend lozenges and sugar-free cinnamon gum in bulk.</p><p>The tightening in my jaw is now a near-constant gripping, as if to prove I can keep my mouth shut.</p><p><em>Relax your jaw,</em> I’d said a hundred thousand times to students, to myself, the ensemble. <em>Don’t add tension to what is already happening.</em> Here I am, now, with this tight-ass throat, no shrimp fork in sight, definitely adding to what is already happening.</p><p><em>It will clear up on its own.</em></p><p>I open my jaw repeatedly, the crispy remnants of water in my ears crinkling like tin foil.</p><p>&gt;&gt;&gt;Jump cut to me describing, almost apologetically, the hundreds of thousands of words I’ve already written. The voice memos, text messages to myself examining the what-ifs and maybe-this-is-what-happened. The constant drafting in my head and put to paper, journals, Post-it notes, backs of envelopes — at 10pm, 3am, first thing in the morning, 4pm. In the car. Walking in the bio reserve. Swimming at the YMCA. A brow continuously furrowed, working on this problem.</p><p><em>You’re so articulate, </em>some will say.</p><p><em>It’s my party trick, </em>I say.</p><p>But I don’t party anymore. Articulation is destroying me from the inside.</p><p><em>Speak.</em> Repeat this three times.</p><p><em>Take it easy, Mrs. McSteezy,</em> I say to myself, after waking from Zemmi’s distinctive meows. I stumble into the kitchen to fill the kettle with water to boil for coffee, my mind already racing ahead with words, words, words, instructions of things to do, things to notice, things that I promised myself I’d do “tomorrow” a hundred evenings ago, things I am not, things I could have been, things I might still be. I feel the speed of this freight train before its cargo of vocabulary-bombs lands. Some never land. But the freight train runs me over all the same.</p><p>Pajama’d, socks half pulled on, their ends flopping in front of me with each step, I sigh in defeat, scooping coffee. I’m unable to keep up with my thoughts. The day is lost. I haven’t even fed Zemmi.</p><p><em>Take it easy, Mrs. McSteezy.</em></p><p>I am Mrs. McSteezy. I am not happy about it, but I will settle for the day to be lost. It‘s been lost a thousand times before. I hope that this <em>McSteezy</em> mantra will keep the <em>other</em> words at bay.</p><p><em>Nobody likes you.</em></p><p><em>You’re a terrible person.</em></p><p><em>You’re a bad person.</em></p><p>And so many more.</p><p>Incantations of the worst kind. My companions these many years, these words of self-loathing.</p><p>A couple years into the saga, the ordeal, the events, the story, I take a big step forward:</p><p><em>Hey, you’re not so bad.</em></p><p><em>You’re not a bad person.</em></p><p><em>You haven’t harmed anyone. </em>Repeat this three times.</p><p>And another, even bigger step, surprised me recently:</p><p><em>You’re an okay person.</em></p><p>Ah, benign indifference.</p><p>And then, faintly, like a novice stand-up comic looking at himself in the dingy mirror before his first set, hands trembling, hoping the dozen or so audience members laugh:</p><p><em>You’re a good person.</em></p><p>I was terminated from Denison University at the end of December, 2022.</p><p>Sometimes, jokingly, I say that I worked hard to be fired, having rejected a few “offers” from Denison to say I “resigned.” I could “resign,” they said, rather than face the “fair” termination proceedings “as described in the faculty handbook,” which, I was told, “was written by faculty.” I am quoting Denison’s Provost, who repeatedly emphasized that faculty wrote the Faculty Handbook during my time at Denison. In 2024, she testified that the faculty-specific sections of the Faculty Handbook are typically generated through faculty proposals and approved by the faculty, but that the Provost’s office has an oversight role and consults with legal counsel and HR when putting policies into an employment handbook. I entered this process naive about the important distinction between a faculty handbook described to me as <em>written by faculty</em> and one that becomes institutional policy through administrative oversight and consultation with legal counsel and HR.</p><p>From the beginning, I refused to say I “resigned.” I wrote to the Provost, rejecting the offers: “In fairness to myself I cannot relinquish something I’ve worked so hard to achieve, based on the University’s misunderstanding of what’s transpired.” Good friends, the ones I trusted with my attempts at gallows humor as well as my anguish, would say, empathetically and sometimes hoping to share a laugh: “You paid dearly for this, Mol.” Or, “This is what you worked for, my friend.”</p><p>What happened in the weeks and months before my termination became official, and what followed in the four years since, marks the most continuously re-traumatizing, confusing, heart-shattering, identity crushing, cognitively debilitating, soul-and-body paining, and, I can only say now, enraging, period of my life.</p><p>It sounds dramatic, doesn’t it?</p><p>It was. Waves of “it” still hit me. Love for the institution — philia, my eyes tear up writing this — turns to disbelief, still.</p><p><em>I’ve got it under control,</em> I say.</p><p>I am irrevocably and forever changed, that’s for sure, sitting here gazing up at my <em>alma mater</em>. My <em>bounteous mother. </em>(That gets a laugh.)<em> </em>I am gazing up, literally, as I write this, from a small makeshift desk placed under a back window in a small red cottage built into the hillside leading up to campus. The trees at the top of the sloping grass-covered hill and tangled overgrowth outside this window, now filled out with June’s foliage, obscure my view, which is unimpeded from late November-March, of the top-floor windows and roof of Crawford Hall, the dorm I lived in as a freshman. Occasionally, a crumpled, faded Funyons bag blows down the hill and gets tangled in the shrubs outside the French doors of my bedroom, no doubt tossed down the hill by a student.</p><p>Denison (“Denison”) and I have different accounts of what happened. I later filed a federal lawsuit against the school. This writing, done once or a dozen times, well or poorly, is my account.</p><p>Through lawyers, my own words and theirs, I tried to reason with Denison’s account for a long time. I longed for a resolution that was mutual, compassionate, just, and grounded in the full picture. Oh, the elusive full picture. I agonized, trying to understand how Denison reached its narrative, and how the damaging statement it used to develop internal “termination charges” against me became part of that narrative.</p><p>I extended to Denison the benefit of the doubt at too many junctures. I presumed a kind of innate goodness. <em>Surely, this is a massive misunderstanding,</em> I thought. Yet from the very beginning, I also feared that Denison’s narrative had been developed immediately and strategically, as a way of gaining control by establishing a paper trail. The term paper trail makes me nauseous. My sister, betraying her own hope in the goodness of my bounteous mother and not believing that what was happening was, in fact, happening, said: “It’s like everyone went into a fugue state!”</p><p>I am coming out of that fugue state now.</p><p>When reason failed us, when explanation, context, documents, letters, statements of defense, and more words, words, words appeared only to supply Denison with more ammunition for its narrative against me, I tried to name the tactics and distortions I believed they were using, and still believe they used. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARVO">DARVO</a> was one of the first.</p><p>Some of this was conveyed in a state of terror only trauma survivors know.</p><p>It was exhausting. I am exhausted.</p><p>Now, joining me on my 1970s comic lawn chair, my outlined body lobotomized and bleeding from the ears, is anger. She arrives like a blue flame, purifying wounds, cauterizing flesh, eyeballs (!) sprouting up in place of scar tissue. With anger’s arrival, I am transformed into a chimeric monster with the gift of multiplying sight.</p><p><em>See.</em> Repeat this three times.</p><p>The caption for this cartoon?</p><p><em>Oh. My. God. How. Fucking. Dare. You.</em></p><p>My account of what happened was impacted first by never having the full picture, and by <em>facts I did not know and later came to learn, </em>including records and information that did not align with key aspects of what Lia, a former student, had told me about distressing circumstances she was facing involving the college’s Title IX and Campus Safety offices, local police, the county prosecutor, and, eventually, a victim advocate.</p><p>By distressing, I mean that Lia described these events as deeply distressing for her, and repeatedly said it was unfair that she was going through them alone. What she described was also deeply distressing for me to hear, think about, and try to make sense of, especially given my own history of surviving rape and stalking at Denison as a student in the late 1980s. Lia’s self-described vague style of communicating, and what she called her “need to be in control and manage all information myself,” often left me uncertain what she meant and imagining the possible scenarios that would cause her to say, repeatedly, that she was struggling. Those imagined scenarios morphed disturbingly with my own partially buried memories of being on campus as a student, some of them memories I had tried to outrun and had only just begun to talk about with a Somatic Experiencing therapist. Even speaking about those memories within the safe context of therapy—some fragmented, some quickly reforming and terrifying—brought me to tears. I did not want to be brought to this state in front of anyone else, especially in the professional context of what had been my dream job from the time I graduated from Denison in 1990.</p><p>The word <em>struggle </em>has been poisoned.</p><p>As her professor, my initial concern for Lia was nothing exceptional. What became exceptional was the level of distress and need she described, implied, or left me to infer, and the degree to which she eventually referred to me as the only adult she trusted. I cared about Lia as I cared about my students generally, and I truly appreciated what appeared to be her thorough commitment to dance. She was the only student in her year who enrolled as a dance major before starting at Denison, and she quickly became one of a handful of students, a number that grew in the following years, who adopted the department as a kind of home. She seemed enthusiastic and was often the first to volunteer for opportunities.</p><p>In general, I saw in Lia, and in a handful of other students, the kind of uniquely devoted aspiring dance artist and thinker I had encountered in every university position I had held. I saw aspects of myself in her, I suppose, too, remembering that I had been one of just two majors in my graduating class from Denison. This stirred pride and fond memories of what I understood as the outstanding mentorship I had received at Denison as a student, and of the small community of invested dancers I had belonged to there. I wanted to carry on what I viewed, and what Denison markets, as a tradition of strong mentoring.</p><p>When the story, the saga, the ordeal, the events began, Lia began saying, with increasing frequency, things like: “Denison doesn’t deserve you. You’re better off away from here.” Later, when it was clear that the small department was indeed growing, a goal of mine, she said she missed the days when it was just the very small group of new and committed students. Only much later did I begin to consider what those statements might have meant, or what needs, fears, loyalties, or motives may have been moving beneath them. At the time, once I understood Lia to be a survivor of some kind of harm, I treated much of what she told me through the moral framework I believed in: listen carefully without pressing for details, take harm seriously even without a complete understanding of what occurred, and do not make a vulnerable person prove pain before offering care, moral support, and encouragement to seek necessary resources.</p><p>In spite of doing well academically—she was punctual and almost never missed class, invested in assignments and co-curricular opportunities—and seeming to be well-liked socially and viewed as a leader by her peers, Lia repeatedly, almost daily, told me she was “struggling.” After a good class, as I bid the students farewell, she might pause at the door to the studio and say something like: “You know I’m really struggling, right?” “Don’t be fooled, today was a 1/10.”</p><p>Over time, the life circumstances Lia described became increasingly serious, confusing, and impossible to reconcile with anything I could have anticipated facing as a professor. Throughout, I repeatedly referred her to a counselor or member of the clergy, on or off campus, even in her home city. My worry for Lia, based on what she said and what she implied, what she told me directly and what she said she was intentionally <em>not</em> telling me — “there are things I’m not telling you “— grew over a period of years to become overwhelming, near-paralyzing fear for her physical and psychological safety.</p><p>Even before the email Dan Brescoll, my dear friend and dance company’s attorney, sent to Denison on my behalf, the email that started the saga, the ordeal, the story, the events, I had already reached out to Denison offices about Lia: the dean of students, twice; the VP of Student Life; the housing office. I think I copied the chief of staff on one outreach. In every response, they thanked me for supporting Lia, and then told me that “the student” needed to “step forward” and reach out for herself. In turn, Lia told me she did step forward, even sending me drafts of emails and screenshots of medical documentation she said she was providing to Denison, and, in some cases, describing meetings, many of which she said had gone very badly. From what she told me, and from what I could observe, there was no meaningful support reaching her.</p><p>I also met with production staff to check on safety concerns related to Lia’s involvement in performance activities and later, after Dan’s email and with Lia’s consent, to make arrangements for accommodating a health issue affecting her participation. They were as helpful as they could be within the limits of Lia needing, again, to be the one to step forward for support. Lia, meanwhile, frequently described contact with Denison offices as unsatisfactory at best, and contact with the Title IX office as worse. This was disheartening, since I had frequently referred her to that office in case she needed to explore supportive measures, which I understood, and still understand, to be one of Title IX’s central functions. Repeatedly, she said she “hated” the office. She said it had mishandled her outreach, insulted her, made her feel like she was to blame, and treated her concerns as “paranoid.” One afternoon, just before Dan wrote to Denison, she called me in a rage, saying she had just been threatened with potential misconduct charges from the Title IX office, which she connected to a criminal hearing she said was scheduled for later that week. Not long after, she said she began receiving repeated warnings from Denison about various undocumented misconduct charges the college was considering bringing against her.</p><p>At Lia’s request, and after she described fear about returning to her parents’ home, I drafted a letter to her mother, which I never sent due to FERPA concerns. I had not received guidance from Denison that helped me understand how to navigate a situation like this. I knew Denison had an anonymous “care report” function. But Lia was rarely absent, never failed to respond to an email, handed in assignments on time, and showed up for meetings and rehearsals. At the same time, in the years she was my student, Lia frequently cited privacy concerns and described situations in which she believed people, including Denison faculty and students, had violated her privacy. On one occasion, she angrily characterized a faculty member’s comment in class specifically as a FERPA violation, and said she reported it and had a follow-up meeting with the professor and an administrator.</p><p>A few weeks after drafting the letter to her mother, in a state of panic, I wrote to an extended family member Lia identified as someone she trusted, then withdrew the message after sending it through an app that allowed such retrievals. Continuously, I gently suggested, advised, requested, and finally urged her to seek support beyond the moral support I could provide, offering to accompany her to the counseling center if my presence would help her take that step. Anything, I thought, to convince her to accept support from someone other than me. Repeatedly, I reiterated that I could be her teacher and advisor, her mentor, but that I could not support her with the extensive hardships she described facing. I tried to be gentle but firm. Throughout, my fear for her safety and wellbeing merged with anxiety, and annoyance I was determined to never let show, each time she thanked me for being there, told me that I was the first adult she truly trusted, the only reason she felt safe on campus. It was too much. But I felt I had to assert this boundary with care, to not add to what I understood as Lia’s heavy set of life circumstances, or exacerbate what I viewed as, and what she described as, extreme vulnerability born of a lifetime of dire experiences, many at the hands of those she trusted.</p><p>My God, is she <em>Job</em>?! exclaimed Tim, a close colleague and fellow junior faculty member. For a week in late summer 2021 I called Tim almost daily, worried sick, going over my options, who I had already contacted, and what more I could do. He told me I was doing a good thing, being there for her, going to bat for her. When one of Lia’s hardships became housing, Tim suggested I offer her the option of staying in one of the guest rooms in the large farmhouse I rented at the time, a charming old house on the Bio Reserve and owned by Denison. The suggestion was not entirely out of context; just a year earlier, Denison had asked faculty to consider housing international students whose travel home had been interrupted by Covid-19.</p><p><em>“Absolutely not,”</em> I said. “I don’t think I could take that.”</p><p>My worry about Lia was taking a toll. So was what she conveyed as a lack of support from Denison, her parents, or anyone else, which seemed to explain, or at least contextualize, her stated aversion to getting outside help. It landed as if she were saying, “There are good reasons I don’t trust others,” which only heightened my concern and deepened my sense that I was powerless, and increasingly trapped in a position of responsibility I did not want, with authority and training I did not have. When I set firmer boundaries with Lia, her concerns could shift overnight into ordinary advisory concerns about dropping a major, taking the remote option at the time, transferring schools, requesting final-grade extensions in other classes, and other situations squarely within my duties as her advisor. I could not, in other words, simply step away or stop responding. But every interaction with Lia carried the possibility that she would drop another pointed hint that she was “struggling.”</p><p>And then even after Dan’s email to Denison on my behalf in early November 2021, when the saga, the story, the events, the ordeal began in earnest, I arranged for Lia to receive support from another faculty member while I was on leave. With Lia’s consent, I scheduled a meeting with Lia, one of her favorite professors in a different department, and me. I emailed both of them that I hoped to increase and widen Lia’s network of support on campus, especially while I was on pre-tenure leave. I entered the meeting hopeful, though I was surprised when the professor offered that Lia could come to her house to stay for the weekend if she ever needed a break from campus. Reminding me of Tim’s earlier suggestion, this seemed like a bad idea, even as a casual extension of faculty support. It was irrelevant, though. A couple of weeks later, Lia told me she could no longer trust that professor, who had, according to Lia, filed an online “care report,” which in turn triggered a dorm visit from Campus Safety and, according to Lia, left her shocked, fearful, and angry at what she considered a privacy violation.</p><p>I sought legal advice repeatedly about my options and responsibilities regarding Lia’s escalating hardships. A month after the meeting with the professor, after a frightening disclosure, Lia gave permission for a professional involved in her care to speak with me. I described Lia as an excellent student and someone whose wellbeing concerned me, and said that I encouraged her to seek professional care. She joked, affirming that she had heard what I had been saying for several months: “Yeah, she’s <em>always</em> telling me to see a therapist.”</p><p>I leaned on family and trusted friends, many of whom worried with me about Lia’s status, and then worried with me, and on their own behalf, about the increasing toll on me. The tragedy of it almost tipped into absurdity: for nearly the remainder of my employment at Denison, Lia continued to describe herself, over and over, as entirely without the support of family, Denison, or others, with new details continuing to emerge from each area of hardship she described, something I later told the executive committee of Denison’s Board of Trustees.</p><p>This detail requires more time, but some of the circumstances Lia stated outright, implied, or left me to infer through repeated vagueness overlapped eerily with my experience of rape and stalking as a student at Denison three decades prior. This overlap was traumatizing, confusing and existentially painful for me. It sparked deep grief that my generation had failed to address patterns of sexual violence we could, I thought, have helped to heal, or at least interrupt, to chart a better path for victims and survivors. I was shaken, and felt implicated, by the possibility that those patterns were now repeating across generations. Even though I knew it was irrational, I felt wracked with guilt that I had not done more to speak about what happened to me as a student, or about its impact on me as an adult. I consulted with a senior colleague and tenure mentor, who assured me this overlap would only make me a better mentor to Lia. That her trust in me was well placed, and that he was sorry I was going through this bizarre set of circumstances. He did not think I should tell the school or report anything to Title IX; Lia was already in contact with the office. I was afraid, I confided, of retaliation or other harm.</p><p>“Am I going to lose my job over this?” I asked, completely unaware of the prescience of the question.</p><p>“Over <em>what?</em>” he asked, incredulously.</p><p><em>The overlap. These circumstances.</em></p><p>“No,” he assured me. “<em>You</em> haven’t done anything wrong.”</p><p>Months later, when I told this same mentor about the saga, the ordeal, the story, the events as it was unfolding, I said that it was awful, yes, but I was still convinced it was a massive misunderstanding, so I was leaving his role in advising me out of it for now. After reassuring me that it would all work out, he leaned back in his office chair and propped his feet on his desk, adding: “Well, thanks for keeping me out of it. I’ve seen people just disappear from this place, never to be heard from again.”</p><p>There was another, more specific layer to my fear, one I have alluded to but am not yet ready to spell out completely: I learned while I was teaching as a visiting professor in 2017, before the tenure-track position, that the perpetrator of my rape and stalking had close family ties to Denison at the time. This is another facet of the disco ball. Another flash of the same story. The one I am trying to tell and afraid to tell and determined to tell.</p><p>All of this meant that the overlap between the challenges Lia was facing and my own history had become more than painful, worrying, or frustrating. My concern for Lia had dovetailed with, and exacerbated, concern for myself, all of which I tried to hide from Lia and others at Denison, students and faculty alike, and to mask in my outward demeanor in general. My anxieties about being secretly watched returned, along with disturbing memories and nightmares, a pronounced startle reflex in response to every sound at night, hyper-vigilance, and unease after dark. I wasn’t yet familiar with research into the impact of stalking, or with the ways it can leave victims with a lifelong sense of uncertainty; nor was I aware of how directly that research had been recognized in federal guidance and, as I later uncovered, in Denison’s own training materials for Title IX staff.</p><p>I was trying to understand my reporting obligations, while also feeling reassured by the involvement of the campus and law enforcement offices Lia described. But I did not want to speak of this overlap at all; it was that painful, and especially not with Denison officials. I was terrified that if I did report what I feared and suspected, I could cause harm I did not intend: damage to my credibility, my reputation, the reputations of others, and Lia’s sense of trust in me and in faculty more generally. Lia had repeatedly told me she was extremely careful about disclosing details that might trigger reporting obligations for me or others. She also expressed, again and again, her desire to decide what information she shared, what would be reported, and when. She had told me of her distrust of others, including the Title IX office and process. And I was afraid that reporting could place me in the path of retaliation or other harm from Denison, and, just as frightening, from people connected to the circumstances Lia had described, including the overlap she repeatedly implied between those circumstances and my own history.</p><p>For someone navigating PTSD, living and working in the place where the originating trauma occurred, and given that the perpetrator of my rape and stalking had connections to Denison at the time, all of this was like kerosene on an inferno. <em>What is bigger than an inferno? </em>I was about to find out.</p><p>While I was able to keep up a strong exterior, and was overjoyed by my students’ progress in classes and by the growing vibrancy of the dance department, privately I was falling apart in the weeks before Dan contacted Denison for me. I was busy, which was a blessing. But most of the time I was not in class, rehearsal, meeting with a student, or visiting a student rehearsal, I was crying, seeking help, or wringing my hands, literally and figuratively, pacing, trying to find a way forward.</p><p>While I had only been formally diagnosed with PTSD in February 2019, just two months before Denison offered me the tenure-track job I was in, I knew enough to know that these circumstances were worsening my post-traumatic stress response. I recognized it as increasingly debilitating and not sustainable. I consulted with my primary care physician, who encouraged me to propose accommodations, even partial accommodations, and with my trauma therapist, who supported my consideration of taking a full medical leave, which would have enabled distance from Denison and, crucially, from Lia.</p><p>I contacted Human Resources multiple times, seeking information.</p><p>Despite that possibility, I decided the positive momentum in the department was too important, and that remaining a stable presence for all of my students, including Lia, mattered more than simply pulling the plug on the semester. In hindsight: how wrong I was to put my teaching obligations above my health. I decided to tailor the request to Denison narrowly enough that I could fulfill my teaching and current departmental obligations, while letting the college know what was going on, trying to make clear that Lia needed more support than I could provide, while making clear that I was willing, even glad, to remain one source of stability and support for her.</p><p>“Teaching is going well,” I told my therapist. “And I love it and am good at it. I’m concerned about the impact on the students, including Lia, if I just disappear; on my colleagues in the department; and on the growth of the program.”</p><p>I consulted with Dan a couple of times. In spring 2019, before I took the tenure-track position, Dan advised me that I could accept the position and see how it went. He encouraged me, I thought wisely, to be honest with Denison about the challenges I was facing returning to the place where I had been raped and stalked. By the time I started at Denison, I had also begun acknowledging that I was a survivor of sexual violence as a college student. I did not lead with this detail, but I also did not hide it. It was an important part of my doctoral research and my creative scholarly research; after the #MeToo movement, living as a survivor had also become an aspect of my identity I was gradually owning. Being transparent with Denison mattered to me. It was in this context that Denison’s president wrote to me in 2018:</p><p>“I am sorry that you were victim and a survivor of sexual assault and violence at Denison. I appreciate and respect you willingness to talk openly about it. And I also appreciate your willingness and ability to be present for our students and to be a faculty member they can confide in and trust. Thank you. As you know, it matters a lot.”</p><p>At the time, I read this as sincere and affirming. The exchange from which this quote is taken was a big part of why I took the job. Looking back, it also marks a contradiction I am still trying to understand: the same institution whose president once thanked me for my openness and capacity to be present for students, to be someone <em>students could confide in and trust, </em>would later respond to the collision of trauma, disability, institutional responsibility, and questions of trust in ways that left me feeling punished for speaking at all. And that word: <em>confide</em> — from the 15th century, “to place trust in” — became central to a battle over meaning and to my advocacy against silencing.</p><p>Another truth it took me a long time to let in: my Denison education helped give me the tools, and perhaps even the obligation, to speak about what later happened there.</p><p>Remember: <em>Once or a dozen times. Well or poorly. I will tell this story.</em></p><p>Now, in fall 2021, I told Dan I was in hell. “I feel like I’m living inside a rape nightmare but there’s no waking,” I told him. “I know some of what I’m feeling is trauma. But I don’t know what the hell is going on here.”</p><p>I told him I was being swallowed up by memories of rape and stalking, and by panic about what I imagined Lia was going through. I did not know everything going on with her, but what she had shared about her interactions with the police, the county prosecutor, and the Title IX office terrified me and led me to imagine the worst. “Apparently there is a criminal hearing on Friday, my birthday, if you can believe it,” I explained.</p><p>We arrived at a plan. Dan would write to the school on my behalf.</p><p>He did.</p><p>Later, I wrote to my family: <em>Denison freaked.</em></p><p>That remains the most concise way I know to describe the sequence: I sought help from Denison, through counsel, and Denison responded almost immediately with something I could not have imagined.</p><p>Later, talking about the lawsuit with my dad, who is 96 years old, he would quote this back to me. “Yes,” he’d say. “Like you said, Denison freaked.”</p><p>Backing up a bit: less than 24 hours after Dan’s email to the then-Associate Vice President and Head of Human Resources, the ordeal, the story, the saga, the events officially began.</p><p>What I intended as a request for minor accommodations that would allow me to continue the bulk of my work through the five remaining weeks of the semester; a report of what I believed Denison already knew about what Lia was facing and the intersection with my own history; and what I thought would be the beginning of a conversation, or what the ADA refers to as an “interactive process,” appeared to be received as something else.</p><p>Then, less than 48 hours after Denison’s first response, Denison’s General Counsel emailed Dan a separation agreement and told him that I had until the next day to decide if this, the “resignation” outlined in the document, in the context of threatened termination proceedings, was a path I wanted to take.</p><p>This was only the beginning.</p><p>Denison did not provide the accommodations Dan requested on my behalf.</p><p>For the second time in a few years, I understood, in a new way, why PTSD can be recognized as a disability under the ADA. The first time was in 2019, when, as a visiting professor and faced with worsening PTSD, I pushed through: teaching a full load of courses, completing and defending my dissertation, graduating with my PhD from Temple University, producing and performing in a Molly Shanahan/Mad Shak performance in Chicago and at Denison, and accepting the job that moved me across the country to Ohio. I saw how PTSD can involve a terrifying disconnect: an inner state of fear masked by an external appearance of composure and the capacity for high-functioning. Yes, composure is generally a good thing. But the disconnect itself can be debilitating, the sense that you are radically different from how you appear, that no interaction is truly honest. It feels like screaming for help from behind placid eyes. This time, though, in fall 2021, I didn’t believe that pushing through was possible. The condition’s disabling aspects were glaring to me, even if not to others. Even if Denison did not see them, Dan had spelled them out as gracefully as possible in his email while trying to protect my privacy in the midst of my mounting vulnerability.</p><p>But Denison apparently did not view me as limited in any way that required accommodation, even as it would later portray me in terms entirely at odds with the work it continued to expect from me.</p><p>Unnerved by Denison’s first response, I wrote immediately to the two HR staff members who had been helping me with questions about a possible medical leave, trying to clear this whole mess up by providing documentation of PTSD. I was convinced that Dan’s letter had been misunderstood, that the misunderstanding could be corrected, and that the threatening tone of Denison’s first response, along with Dan’s subsequent conversation with the General Counsel, could somehow be explained.</p><p>“When I filled out employment paperwork, I believe I indicated PTSD as a condition/disability. Can you please confirm that this is correct? If not, I will either drop off or have my physician fax confirmation for your records.”</p><p>No one from Denison ever responded to this message.</p><p>So, I taught, attended meetings, interacted with colleagues as if nothing was wrong, and advised students for the rest of the semester. Even after setting a firm boundary, I continued fielding the continuously compounding circumstances Lia described, now related to school, coursework, an injury, family, and more, while managing what I can only describe as an extreme trauma response. When, on the same day Denison responded to Dan’s email, Lia asked if she could update me on the outcome of the criminal hearing she had told me had taken place on my birthday, I said no, not right now, but that I was glad it was over. She responded that it was not exactly over, and suggested there was more to the story than I yet understood.</p><p>To my knowledge, and based on deposition testimony taken three years later, none of Denison’s offices or officials reached out to check on her. Meanwhile, I was being forced to learn, in real time, what it meant to live behind the mask of composure that I had identified as part of my trauma response. At the department’s December dance concert, I welcomed faculty colleagues, students’ parents and extended family members, including Lia’s, who thanked me profusely for my support of their daughter. I had mentored all of the student pieces being presented, in addition to creating my own work and facilitating a guest artist’s work. In all, this amounted to nearly a hundred additional hours spent in mentorship, technical rehearsals, performance preparation, and production between Dan’s letter asking for help and the end of the semester. It was tragically bittersweet. I was overjoyed for the students, and the growth in our majors and minors had been momentous that semester. But even then, while still holding out hope, I suspected this would be my last dance concert at Denison, the place where I had learned to be a dancer and choreographer and had returned as a seasoned choreographer and teacher, hoping to spend the rest of my career.</p><p>Despite the unfolding circumstances, I ended up serving on a departmental search committee for a visiting professor, a responsibility Dan had explicitly asked that I be relieved from during the last five weeks of the semester. The next semester, while on pre-tenure leave and preparing to defend myself in Denison’s so-called “fair” termination process, I participated seriously and in good faith in the search process, with a pit in my stomach. I was, in the end, helping select the very person who would take over my position. As it turned out, she was also the person I had invited to teach my classes while I was on pre-tenure leave. The injustice of being required to help select my own replacement while in the midst of being fired from a job that had been my dream speaks for itself. Yet this is just one mirrored square on the disco ball of this story. This saga.</p><p>My heart is beating hard just telling you this. My jaw is clenched. My temples are throbbing. The muscles between my shoulder blades are like fused steel plates. I pause. Listen to the birds singing outside my open windows. A cool breeze ripples over my bare feet, Zemmi is asleep on the rug next to me. A car zips past on Pearl St. below, and then another heading in the opposite direction. I hear a neighbor’s voice in the distance. The thump of the manhole cover half a block away.</p><p><em>Take it easy, Mrs. McSteezy.</em></p><p>Under the terms of the separation agreement Denison’s General Counsel sent Dan, I would “agree” to resign my faculty position and, in what felt like a grotesque consolation prize, could tell people that I was “on leave” to signal continued affiliation with Denison. I would release all legal claims¹, affirm that signing the agreement was a “knowing and voluntary act” regardless of <em>any facts I might later come to learn</em>,² and agree to confidentiality about the agreement, its terms, and “any information relating to or concerning the confidential business, financial, or personal affairs of Denison or any of its students, identified or anonymized, or any of the other Released Parties,”³ which included just about anyone affiliated with Denison. The agreement’s confidentiality clause functioned, for all practical purposes, as a non-disclosure agreement, or NDA.</p><p>As bad as my PTSD had become in the weeks leading up to Dan’s email to Denison, it was now and would continue to be much, much worse. As I heal, and become a new person living with and adapting to the impacts of this trauma, I understand more clearly the ways that Denison’s response intensified the trauma I was already experiencing and gave it new force, new duration, and new shame. Denison’s response rendered my nascent recovery efforts exponentially harder, not only from the story, the saga, the ordeal, the events themselves, but from the original traumas, and from the three decades I had spent trying to outrun them.</p><p>If you understand sexual violence survivors’ trauma at all, or the culture surrounding survivors when and if they do ask for help, you have probably heard that many survivors describe what happens <em>after</em> they come forward as worse than the original assault. Indeed, I thought the rapes and stalking were the worst thing that could happen, and that carrying them, trying to outrun them for thirty years, and living with the ways those experiences mangled my understanding of my body, agency, and safety in public and private spaces formed the heaviest burden I carried. I thought it would be with me for the rest of my life. In winter 2019, with the perspective of time, new exposure to the traumas, and a diagnosis, I decided it was time to set the burden down: to name it, look at it, and be honest with myself about its impact. With all the developments in trauma research and healing, I started to believe I had a future to look forward to that was not held down by this history.</p><p>What I experienced next, however, made that burden seem, not insignificant, I can’t go that far, but utterly engulfed by a new, larger trauma and what felt like a cruel and inexplicable betrayal by my beloved alma mater. I was engulfed further still by incapacitating shame, self-blame, internalized self-hatred, and hypervigilance as I tried, over the next four-plus years, to restore some measure of faith in life, in human beings, and in the institutions that shape our lives. What happened after Dan’s email asking for help crowded those earlier memories out of my healing process for a time. After all, they were just beginning to breach the surface of safety after years of trauma’s occlusions and tricks. My therapist described our work as a kind of triage for what was happening in the present. For years. Four and counting.</p><p>Most nights I still have nightmares about Denison. The past and present blur. I’m back on campus but not allowed to be there. I’m teaching, but it’s a secret. It’s the last day of classes and I’m deciding whether or not to tell my students what’s going on. I act like I’m returning the next year, but I know that I’m lying to them. Graduation is approaching, but it’s not clear if it’s now or thirty years ago. Repeatedly, I don’t know if I’ll be allowed to graduate. I can watch, but there will be no diploma. I’m sneaking in to use my office, dust-covered, without electricity, and overgrown with plants. In each dream, Denison, once a second home, a place I once called on in my mind when I needed a reminder of safety in spite of what had occurred, is ghoulishly reimagined as a place of exile, haunting, and suspended belonging. In every dream, I want to tell someone what is happening, but I can’t quite bring myself to do it. I begin to open my mouth, and the dream ends. I stumble out of bed. <em>Take it easy, Mrs. McSteezy.</em></p><p>Shhh.</p><p><em>Don’t say anything or you’ll get in trouble.</em></p><p><em>Don’t say anything or it will get worse.</em></p><p>I did not sign that agreement with the NDA, or the version offered a few weeks after I rejected it, or the third, more restrictive agreement and NDA sent a year later. Still, the message got in. I feel like I’ve been walking around with a tacitly signed NDA, afraid of saying what happened, what I experienced, what I read, heard, saw, felt, learned months later, then months later still, a year later; what I found, requested, made sense of, still haven’t made sense of, may never make sense of.</p><p>Throughout, I felt like I was negotiating again with the man who raped and stalked me when we were students. I plead with him to stop, using every skill I have to end behavior I understand as wrong but, then, cannot yet speak of, while shame, not reason, directs the symphony of my young synapses. His sneering accusations against my character, my intentions, my very identity, whispered in my ear as he assaults me, parade as credible truth inside me. I hear them, and others like them: <em>You’re a terrible person. You’re a liar. I’m onto you.</em> I know that all of this, the words and the violations, is entirely wrong, yet asking for help seems the greater, more dangerous wrong. Some part of me still holds out hope, believes I can reason with him, appeal to his higher instincts and what I had once mistaken for his good intentions. <em>If I can only say the words perfectly, I might make him understand. I might set right what can never be made right.</em></p><p>And this, <em>this </em>is what it felt like communicating with Denison during the ordeal, the saga, the events, the story. And I remind myself, as a crystal prism dangling from my window, like a disco ball, sends shards of rainbow light across the floor: <em>done well or poorly, once or a hundred times, I will tell it.</em></p><p>What <em>is</em> worse than an inferno? A firestorm.</p><p>Molly Shanahan, PhD<br>Denison University Class of 1990</p><p>This is the first in a series of essays and related writing about the saga, the ordeal, the events, the story.</p><p>Notes:</p><p><em>*</em>These include Denison’s president, Title IX coordinator, provost, general counsel, six faculty members of the President’s Advisory Board, an outside attorney hired to oversee the termination proceedings and write the Advisory Board’s “recommendations,” and the then-executive committee of Denison’s Board of Trustees.</p><p>¹From the November 12, 2021 Separation Agreement: <em>Release in Full of All Claims. Shanahan, for herself and her heirs, administrators, executors, agents, and assigns, does hereby forever release and discharge Denison and its agents, servants, departments, members, trustees, officers, directors, employees, successors, predecessors, administrators, and assigns (hereinafter “the Released Parties”) from any and all charges, claims, demands, judgments, causes of action, damages, expenses, costs, and liabilities of any kind whatsoever. Shanahan expressly acknowledges that the claims released by this paragraph include all rights and claims relating to her employment with Denison, including without limitation any claims she may have under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, the Equal Pay Act, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, as amended by the Older Worker Benefit Protection Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, and any other federal, state, or local laws or regulations governing employment relationships. This Release specifically and without limitation includes a release of any claims for employment discrimination, wrongful discharge, breach of contract, and promissory estoppel, and extends to all claims of every nature and kind, whether known or unknown, suspected or unsuspected, presently existing or resulting from or attributable to any act or omission of Denison or the other Released Parties occurring prior to the execution of this Agreement. The Release contained herein does not apply to rights or claims first arising after the date of execution of this Agreement. Shanahan specifically agrees not to institute any civil action, request for arbitration, or any other proceeding raising any claim released in this Agreement.</em></p><p>²<em>Shanahan acknowledges and agrees that the release set forth herein is a general release. Shanahan, having been encouraged to and having had the opportunity to be advised by counsel, expressly waives all claims that exist as of this date, including without limitation any claims of which Shanahan does not now know or suspect to exist, whether through ignorance, oversight, error, negligence, or otherwise, and which, if known, might materially affect her decision to enter into this Agreement. Shanahan further agrees that she accepts the consideration provided to her under this Agreement as a complete compromise of all matters relating to her employment with Denison, which could involve disputed issues of law and fact, and Shanahan assumes the risk that the law and facts may be other than she believes. Shanahan further acknowledges and agrees that all the terms of this Agreement shall be in all respects effective and not subject to termination or rescission because the facts or law may prove different than she presently believes, and she provides this release voluntarily and with full knowledge and understanding of the terms hereof.</em></p><p>³<em>Confidentiality and Cooperation. The terms and conditions of this Agreement are and shall remain confidential. Except as specifically set forth below, Shanahan agrees not to, at any time, disclose the terms of this Agreement, in whole or in part, or any fact concerning the negotiation, execution, or implementation of this Agreement, including the existence and amount of the payments set forth in paragraph 2 hereof, to any individual or entity without the prior written consent of Denison; provided, however, that Shanahan may discuss the terms of this Agreement with: (a) her attorney, tax advisor, and immediate family, on condition that any such persons agree in advance to keep such terms confidential and not disclose them to others; and (b) any court of competent jurisdiction, the Internal Revenue Service, or other governmental agency, upon proper request by such court or agency compelling such disclosure. Shanahan further agrees not to reveal to any person, unless authorized by Denison in writing, any information relating to or concerning the confidential business, financial, or personal affairs of Denison or any of its students, identified or anonymized, or any of the other Released Parties. Shanahan expressly acknowledges that the provisions of this paragraph constitute material consideration for Denison’s obligations under this Agreement.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f645d0f0a2ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Love a Wolf: Rejection Tolerance]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@molshanahan/how-to-love-a-wolf-rejection-tolerance-e05aa738d3b9?source=rss-a5324c6d7e69------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e05aa738d3b9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Molly Shanahan, PhD.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Apr 2026 15:51:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-22T15:51:45.934Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>How to Love a Wolf: Rejection Tolerance</p><p>I’ve been thinking about rejection tolerance for the last several days, especially after getting this nice rejection letter from the Guggenheim Foundation. I felt good about my application this time, and my recommenders (a huge thank you to them); and when I saw those awarded a fellowship (well-deserved, congratulations) I felt for the first time like I belonged in the mix of those being considered, that it was possible that my application was competitive. I hope/d so. I resolved to try again.</p><p>For me, the biggest factor in staying in the dance field is rejection tolerance.</p><p>Once, in a break-out group at a conference of performing arts presenters, Peter Taub said, from his point of view, success for a performing artist meant that they could be in a cycle of feast or famine. Not continuous feast. Not continuous famine. But a cycle that would repeat. Then, I heard an artist coach talk about how successful artists get approximately one out of ten things they apply for. Grants, awards, performance opportunities, fellowships, etc. And that it was important not to compare those ten attempts: that if you got a $1000 grant during the same period you applied for and were rejected for a $10,000 opportunity, that you’d still count the $1000 as a success in the 1/10 ratio. I rarely share the rejections, but they are many in number. Sometimes they hurt and sometimes they don’t. I think this 1/10 math is pretty accurate.</p><p>This morning I remembered when I was quite young — nine, I think — and lots of the kids we knew in our neighborhood, including me and my sister, auditioned to be in The Sound of Music production at the Rosedale Park Community Center. Man, I wanted a part so badly. I knew every word to the songs and I knew I could do it. I thought I could be a star. My sister, a much better singer than me, was offered a part. So were a couple of the talented Heffernan kids, our good friends. I wasn’t. I could hear my mom on the phone, taking in the news, and, after hanging up (my sister was not home) conveying to me that they tried to find a part for me, but couldn’t. They said they hoped I’d be involved in the production in some other way.</p><p>I was undone. I wept in grief and the shame of rejection, the unfairness.</p><p>Later that evening, my mom said, “Molly, sometimes you’ve just got to be a trooper.”</p><p>A trooper!? I didn’t know what that was. Had they added a part to the show? She explained to me that a trooper was someone who worked, even in rejection. Someone who rolled up their sleeves and helped to get things done. Who got on with things.</p><p>How awful, I thought.</p><p>But I decided to try being a trooper anyway. So I helped out with snacks at a couple of rehearsals and a show, riding my bike to the Community Center to join the mom who was leading the snack effort. I followed her instructions, filling and putting out the juice cups and arranging the cookies on plates. When we were done, she thanked me and told me I did a good job and she’d be glad to have my help again. I rode back home, feeling a kind of dull satisfaction at having survived being a trooper, but not so sad, not so embarrassed.</p><p>I saw the show and thought, “That was ok.” I could sense my love of theater going dormant, the love replaced by what I still think of as a healthy suspicion. Ahh, coping.</p><p>Dance saved me, in many respects. But I very quickly found that my rejection tolerance came in handy in dance, too, as did my evolving understanding of what it means to be a trooper. I found eventually that I could handle one in ten. One acceptance for every ten tries, and every nine rejections.</p><p>When <a href="https://www.facebook.com/shanahandance?__cft__[0]=AZZDw_kZ6x5uWPm81024rLJ1TkkfBY6RHZXAA7hmOo9Ag2VqvVxeV3hmsPzy4xuziFm3FMsVqI7Njjz-cM4QTBmICx8BkoewZ_IuUQPgZCc8EeQvAGPuptdmqJex8S2eOAvZmRhMK8a9b89IR8njzU0okQLsT2IMHc0qBzC8hUtCSA&amp;__tn__=-]K-R">Molly Shanahan/Mad Shak</a> presented our first work, “Glass Slipper Totem,” at the original Links Hall in 1995, we received a scathing review in the Reader, written by Laura Molzahn. She wrote: “Who do they think they are?!” and proceeded to take down many (most?) aspects of the hour-long show. (Only now am I realizing that we probably forced her to sit for an hour in the blazing summer heat and air-condition-less Links, the El train roaring by, which I must admit would piss me off.)</p><p>I was so embarrassed. My first work in Chicago. Who *do* I think I am? The pit in my stomach was heavy. I saw an acquaintance in downtown Evanston a few weeks later. He called out, “Hey, I’m sorry I missed your show! How did it go?”</p><p>I replied, “Ohh, thanks, that’s ok. It was ok. We got a terrible review,” emphasizing the last point.</p><p>“I saw it!” he replied, smiling. “Wow, a full page and a huge picture! That’s amazing press.”</p><p>I hadn’t thought of it that way.</p><p>Six weeks later, I pulled out my copy of the Reader and read the review again. I thought, begrudgingly at first: “She has a point.” The words on the page still stung to read, but slowly replacing the sting was my dawning realization that this was a person who had no fucks to give about telling me what she really thought of my work. When else do we get this!? She wasn’t trying to be my friend, or simply “be nice.” This was a goldmine of perspective! I let it in, both Laura’s specific critiques, but also the realization that critique would be part of putting myself out there, whether or not it showed up in print. Since then, Laura’s written some wonderful things about my work, things that have made me say, “Yessss, we’re getting there,” and remember that first review, dare I say…fondly?</p><p>Am I suggesting that a critic knows the artist’s work better than the artist? Or that artists should mold their work to appeal to a critic. No. Of course not. I’m saying that critique is part of the rejection tolerance matrix that makes doing this work over decades both agonizing and possible. And for it to even be possible to make my work outside of the relative safety of an institutional/academic framework is close to a definition of success that I can live with.</p><p>This past December we premiered a work that felt vulnerable, scary, and risky. It involved glimpses of a personal story. Audiences, at least those that stayed for the post-show chat, seemed to really respond to it. I felt like a new artist all over again, though this time basking in relief and deep gratitude.</p><p>When the final, Sunday show ended, and we bid our patrons, family, and friends goodbye, I realized that I hadn’t thought to hire a load-out crew. In planning, I was focused on load-in, and offered two of the ensemble dancers the option to help with load-in a week before. It was a huge job. Never again, I said. But load out was going to be just as daunting, and I couldn’t leave our lighting designer to do it alone. I started pulling up gaff tape from the Marley flooring. My body hurt, but I knew I’d stay until the end. My sister, who’d come to see the show, joined right in, literally rolling up her sleeves. Our volunteer box office manager did the same. Eventually, all the dancers were hands-on. I said over and over again, “Guys, you can go, really; I know you didn’t sign up for this.” But everyone stayed, teaming up to do job after job: climbing ladders to rehang soft goods, stabilizing the ladders, taking down lights and disassembling them, loading lights and props into vehicles, rolling and storing the Marley floor, vacuuming the floors in the seating area, sweeping. As we neared the end, everyone still stayed, gradually transitioning to sitting in the house, waiting, their bags and coats ready to go, but not rushing the final stages.</p><p>The mood was light. Lightened by the need to work together, again, as we had in making and performing the piece. This time, in the tactile undoing of the container that held us. We were exhausted and giddy. Joking and laughing at everything. We walked out together, me carrying a disco ball and a bag of bowler hats. Everyone laden with their bags and foam rollers and flowers and water bottles, bidding each other goodnight and love and can’t wait for the next time.</p><p>Troopers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hg-tKqAQAE414Z2YcXdcjg.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e05aa738d3b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Breaking into Society: Timothée Chalamet, Opera, and the Politics of Cultural Reverence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@molshanahan/breaking-into-society-timoth%C3%A9e-chalamet-opera-and-the-politics-of-cultural-reverence-bc774d2d365f?source=rss-a5324c6d7e69------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bc774d2d365f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[e-jean-carroll]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[opera]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ballet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[timothée-chalamet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeffrey-epstein]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Molly Shanahan, PhD.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Mar 2026 17:54:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-11T00:03:05.545Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ohfpXhk_zvWJHDv5SNd2RQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Poster for <em>Breaking into Society</em> (1905), presented by Percy G. Williams and starring the Four Mortons. Cincinnati ; New York : U.S. Lithograph Co., c1905.</figcaption></figure><p>I wrote these many paragraphs about Timothee Chalamet, after reading (and agreeing with) <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/06/arts/dance/timothee-chalamet-ballet-opera.html">Gia Kourlas’ piece</a> in the Times. This issue admittedly struck a nerve with me, but not because I took offense at Chalamet’s comments.</p><p>Last night I started watching the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=424w9fJRgYk">full interview</a> between he and McConaughey. I’ll finish it today. Whether you like or dislike him, it’s clear in his words, embodiment, and continued honoring of the artists who have influenced him, that Chalamet is a deeply invested artist in a craft (acting) he understands as sometimes “foolish” but for the depth of personal investment, including in risking appearing foolish.</p><p>Over the weekend and yesterday I also listened <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-epstein-files-explained-everything-you-need-to/id1564530722?i=1000749023113">to the episodes on Epstein</a> on the podcast We Can Do Hard Things, recommended to me by a friend. I can’t recommend both episodes enough, especially if you weren’t following the Epstein horrors until recently. I have been, and I was still amazed at the level of collusion, actual conspiracy, cover-up, and depravity. I’ll put the link to the first episode in the comments.</p><p>Monday, March 9, 2026.</p><p><strong>Part I:</strong></p><p>The one-upmanship, snappy quips, memes, and “ooh burn” throw-downs say more about the moment we’re in than about the already absurd matter at hand.</p><p>But first: we have a man who has been found <a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/appeals-court-upholds-e-jean-carrolls-83-3-million-defamation-judgment-against-trump">civilly liable for sexual abuse and defamation</a> by a jury of his peers who holds the highest office in the country, and whose name appears repeatedly in Epstein-related records. It would be nice if the army of cultural defenders rushing to protect the sanctity of “centuries old institutions” were louder about that than they are about Chalamet.</p><p>Today someone sent me a meme mocking Chalamet for his comments while promoting a movie about ping pong. I think I was supposed to think, “Oh my god, what a burn!” as if the *subject* of a film (or an opera or a ballet) somehow determines the seriousness of the art or context surrounding it. But it just pissed me off more. Marty Supreme, as interpreted by Chalamet, appears to be a story about a flawed human being from humble origins who dreams of transcending his lot in life through fame and fortune in an unlikely arena. Hold onto that detail.</p><p>Opera and ballet have been around for hundreds of years, far longer than film, cinema, or “the movies.” They are also art forms that historically have been largely accessible to, and funded by, the ultra-wealthy. (Don’t come at me with “ballet as folk dance or as found ‘first’ in agrarian cultures.”)</p><p>The relationships between funders and those funded in these traditions have often carried incredibly fraught and deeply misogynistic dynamics, casting ballerinas as one step up from whores, women whose dancing was funded by men who expected sexual favors in return. In nineteenth-century Paris, wealthy male subscribers to the Paris Opéra were granted backstage access to the foyer de la danse. There, young dancers were expected to mingle with patrons, and intimate relationships and financial arrangements were hardly uncommon. Opera, for its part, emerged within aristocratic patronage systems in which courts and wealthy elites financed productions and careers. Singers, especially celebrated prima donnas, often navigated intense scrutiny, sexualized celebrity, and professional dependence on powerful patrons.</p><p>Opera and ballet may have grown more accessible in our lifetimes, but not by very much. Chalamet has said, on the Marty Supreme press tour, that he practically grew up backstage at New York City Ballet, where his grandmother, mother, and sister all performed or studied. That kind of proximity matters. It means growing up inside the rhythms, etiquette, and unspoken rules of an art world that still remains largely opaque to many people looking at it from the outside. It also means awareness of the patronage systems those forms require and of the fact that it is still primarily elites who keep them afloat.</p><p>Some people have responded by suggesting that his remarks were disrespectful to his mother, sister, or to the ballet world that helped shape his upbringing. I understand the instinct behind that reaction. But there is a lot about the “what would his mother say?” argument that rings false to me.</p><p>It is a form of sentimental gatekeeping. The conversation shifts away from structures and toward personal loyalty narratives, with people assuming, without a shred of proof about how Chalamet’s mother or sister actually feel about his comments, that failing to show family loyalty is a crime against decency. Instead of asking what Chalamet’s remarks might reveal about the economics or cultural positioning of opera and ballet, the focus becomes whether he has shown sufficient reverence toward the institutions, plural, that helped shape his life: ballet and his family.</p><p>That move replaces analysis with sentiment and elevates the family to a sacred seat of loyalty, even though appeals to family loyalty have historically been among the most reliable ways power protects itself from scrutiny. What might be a structural observation, or a declaration of choice-making, suddenly becomes a question of displays of gratitude. His mother and sister know him far better than the rest of us do and have presumably known for a long time his thoughts about his career, opera, ballet, and much more. I doubt they are offended or surprised. We don’t need to be offended on their behalf. The logic suggests that if an institution touched your life — family or ballet — you owe it perpetual public deference.</p><p>That expectation sidesteps harder questions about the systems surrounding opera and ballet: how they are funded, who gets access to them, and how cultural prestige circulates through them. Once the frame shifts to family loyalty or personal offense — the “for shame!” narrative — the institutional structure disappears from view. The conversation is no longer about patronage, cultural capital, or access. It becomes a moral drama about whether someone has shown proper respect.</p><p>That reflex reinforces existing power. It protects institutions from scrutiny while making the person who raised the structural question appear disrespectful, with disrespect treated as a cardinal sin. The moment someone says, in effect, you shouldn’t say that because you benefited from it, the conversation has already moved away from examining the system and toward policing tone. And that reflex is exactly the one I am trying to interrogate here.</p><p>It is still far cheaper to see a movie or pay for a streaming service than to buy a ticket to the ballet or opera. Even when ticket prices are reduced, subsidized, or discounted, cost is only one layer of access. There is also the question of cultural navigation, even if only of the lobby.</p><p>Walking into an opera house or a ballet theater often means stepping into a social environment whose codes are not immediately obvious. Dress codes, when one applauds, how intermissions function as social rituals, even how programs are read and discussed. For people who did not grow up around those spaces through family connections, school programs, or sustained arts exposure, those expectations can feel less like invitations and more like signals that the room belongs to someone else.</p><p>Sociologists have called this cultural capital. It is the invisible knowledge that allows certain people to move comfortably through particular institutions and excludes others. Marty Supreme would have been excluded. I would feel out of place, in spite of my own history. Opera houses and ballet theaters have long functioned as places where that capital circulates and is recognized. The art itself may be extraordinary and deeply meaningful, but the surrounding ecosystem, its price structures, architecture, history, and social codes, can wordlessly reinforce a sense that these worlds are designed for people who already know how to belong there.</p><p>Neither that reality nor Chalamet’s comments diminish the artistic value of opera or ballet. But the context of those forms does help explain why their audiences remain relatively narrow, still mostly elite, white, educated, and culturally literate. It also helps explain why artists working within those forms often find themselves doing the dual labor of making the work and advocating for its survival in, if not the mainstream, the vast world outside those institutions. It also explains why someone who grew up around those institutions and has dreams perhaps more akin to a Marty Supreme, might decide, quite consciously — and even conscientiously, recognizing the elite patronage structures that sustain those institutions — to pursue a field whose economic and cultural ecosystem functions differently.</p><p>Why conscientiously? Because, clumsy as his comment was, it hints at an awareness of the class dynamics embedded in those institutions. Chalamet did not grow up outside the elite arts ecosystem. He grew up inside it. His remark can be read less as ignorance than as a moment of recognition: that the patronage structures sustaining opera and ballet are not neutral and far from accessible to many, and that they sit uneasily beside the mythology of the outsider artist. In that sense, the comment aligns him, however imperfectly, with the “everyman” narrative embodied by Marty Supreme.</p><p>In other words, Chalamet’s comments about opera and ballet (and there have been others) may contain a latent critique of elite cultural patronage and a self-identification with the Marty Supreme “everyman” narrative. The tension, and the interesting part, is that he now inhabits elite culture by virtue of his success, both critically and as a celebrity, even as he remains drawn to the mythology of outsider ascent.</p><p>His relationship with Kylie Jenner complicates the picture in ways that actually reinforce this narrative. He is not dating into one of the old American cultural dynasties, a Guggenheim, a Mellon, a Rockefeller, or the kind of blue-blood family historically associated with underwriting elite arts institutions. He is dating the daughter of Kris Jenner, a formidable entrepreneur who has grown a modern media empire, and Caitlyn Jenner, once the Olympic gold medalist in the decathlon and famously featured on the Wheaties box.</p><p>Whatever one thinks of the Kardashian-Jenner universe (don’t come at me) it represents a very different mythology of success than the old patronage class that historically sustained opera houses and ballet companies. It is messy, sometimes trashy, grossly entrepreneurial, the definition of aggressively self-constructed, and deeply rooted in the contemporary machinery of celebrity culture.</p><p>Seen in that light, Chalamet’s public persona starts to make a certain kind of sense. He moves comfortably within elite cultural spaces, but the narrative that surrounds him, and that he seems drawn to, still leans toward the mythology of outsider ascent rather than the custodial stewardship of inherited cultural institutions.</p><p>Which brings me back to the context in which Chalamet has always referenced opera and ballet: not as a judgment of their intrinsic value, but as a matter of choice and dare I say discernment about how he intends to exercise his artistry and influence.</p><p>Which also brings me back to the online vitriol. Are all y’all suddenly the cultural elite now, defending your box at the Met? Your backstage pass to the ballet? When did everyone become a guardian of elite cultural institutions that most people have never set foot inside, let alone helped sustain?</p><p>I suspect opera and ballet will survive just fine with nearly three thousand billionaires in the world and a philanthropic system built precisely to convert wealth into cultural prestige. I also know there is a growing movement of experimental opera emerging, and I hope the funding structures that meet those artists operate under very different conditions than the inherently classist patronage origins of those four-hundred-year-old institutions so many people rushed online to defend.</p><p><strong>Part II:</strong></p><p>My subject position: I am a dance artist and organizational leader who lives with a disability; I use she/they pronouns. I have benefited from being educated in public schools and, later, private institutions through scholarships, fellowships, grants, and loans. I have also benefited from meaningful early access to the arts.</p><p>As a young child I received ballet tickets as Christmas gifts a few times. It was a big deal. I auditioned for and was accepted into the children’s chorus of La Bohème at the Michigan Opera Theatre, which included performances in Detroit and a small tour to Kalamazoo. From that experience I remember the brownies in the green room at the Music Hall, my mustard yellow velvet costume and hat, the other kids in the chorus, the song we sang, the raked stage, and our children’s chorus director, Tom Stallone of that Stallone family. During this period I also saw a few operas, Pagliacci, Il Trovatore, and La Traviata. I confess I have not seen a single opera since. I was eleven or twelve years-old.</p><p>That summer I played the witch-like Mrs. Grimshaw in a production of the well-known favorite, “The Wizard of Oz in the Wild Wild West,” at the community theatre in Rosedale Park in Detroit where my sister played Dorothy and other characters included Annie Oakley and Wild Bill Hickok. I wore a purple taffeta gown, and handled dry ice.</p><p>Those experiences were formative. They gave me early glimpses into artistic worlds that many people never encounter, and they shaped both my love for the arts, my dislike of auditions and tolerance for rejection, and my youthful awareness of how access to those worlds is structured.</p><p>In high school my aesthetics shifted. I was “crowned” Miss Michigan Pom Pon 1985 and choreographed the following year’s winning routine for my successor and dear friend to New Edition’s “Did Ya Git It Yet?”</p><p>I am also the great-granddaughter and great-grandniece of vaudeville performers known as “The Four Mortons,” whose Broadway act was called “Breaking into Society.” It was a comedic act that featured an Irish family fighting, singing songs, and dancing. They were considered heirs apparent to the popular troupe The Four Cohens, whose comedy routines were famous on the American stage in the early twentieth century.</p><p>At the height of vaudeville, and without taking inflation into account, my relatives earned more in a single week than I have ever earned in one. Their earnings did not, however, contribute to generational wealth.</p><p>Vaudeville, of course, was not an elite art world in the way opera and ballet historically have been. It was a chaotic, commercial ecosystem built on touring circuits, working-class audiences, immigrant humor, and the constant hustle of performers trying to move upward through increasingly prestigious venues. To “break into society” in that context was both literal and comedic. It meant aspiring to enter spaces that had historically excluded you, while also parodying the manners and codes of the people who already belonged there.</p><p>That history feels oddly relevant to the present moment. Opera houses and ballet theaters developed inside aristocratic and later philanthropic patronage systems. Vaudeville developed inside the marketplace. Both worlds produced extraordinary art. But they operated according to very different cultural and economic logics and both had deep problems relative to race and racism, ethnicity and discrimination, and misogyny.</p><p>Seen from that perspective, I’m thinking more about Chalamet’s comments about opera and ballet. And again, clumsy as they were, they may contain a faint echo of that American instinct to question elite cultural custodianship while still pursuing fame and brazenly endorsing one’s desire to make “a name for oneself.”</p><p>The irony, as I wrote above, is that Chalamet now occupies an elite cultural space himself as a film star. But the narrative he seems drawn to, and the one he is currently promoting through Marty Supreme, is still the mythology of the outsider who finds a path upward through talent, charisma, and sheer force of will.</p><p>In other words, a story about breaking into society.</p><p>Which is why the moral outrage directed at Chalamet feels so strangely misplaced and potentially dangerous given what is being revealed in the fight to expose the power intricacies surrounding and enabling Epstein. The real scandals of elite culture rarely involve a young actor making a clumsy comment about opera. They tend to involve power, money, access and, sometimes, like right now, collusion by elite networks including governments (the DOJ) to cover up criminal activity.</p><p>So, to repeat. We are living in a moment in which the president of the United States has been found civilly liable for sexual assault, and whose name appears over and over and over in the Epstein files, a criminal sex trafficking network that exposes (or should expose) how easily wealth, influence, and social prestige can function as shields for exploitation, at best, and (alleged) rape, murder, and child sex trafficking at worst.</p><p>Against that backdrop, people furiously defending the honor of opera, opera houses, ballet, and ballet companies from an awkward remark by a 30-year-old actor begins to look like a misallocation of moral energy. We are living through a moment that demands vigilance and clear-eyes in addressing how power moves and who is harmed; and about the ways elite power often hides in plain sight. It is also a reminder of how quickly the coarsening tone of our politics, grotesquely perfected by Trump, has seeped into everyday cultural discourse.</p><p>Opera and ballet will survive. They have survived empires, revolutions, world wars, and the arrival of film, television, and the internet. They will certainly survive Timothee Chalamet’s feelings about them.</p><p>The more interesting question is why so many people seem eager to defend institutions that have historically belonged to the powerful and elite, while directing their fiercest outrage at someone who put his finger on something real about the systems that sustain them.</p><p>— — —</p><p><strong>My original post: Sunday, March 8, 2026</strong></p><p>I’m going to get this out of my system.</p><p>I don’t care that Timothée Chalamet said what he said about opera and ballet. I do care about the sheer cruelty and apparent delight being taken in the attacks he’s getting, and only the latter make me worry about humanity.</p><p>The realities he ungracefully named have been drummed into live performing artists for decades, certainly the nearly four decades that I’ve been working in contemporary dance, FAR less funded or visible than *even* opera or ballet. Of course people care about those forms. And many people don’t. This is not news, and it’s not because of Timothée Chalamet. Surely no artist working in opera, ballet, or contemporary dance is unaware that some art forms are more valued in the mainstream than others.</p><p>The ruffled feathers prove his point: those *very valuable* and simultaneously *less valued* forms gain when a celebrity calls attention to them. Did ballet or opera need Timmy’s approval? Many companies sure are jumping on his comments to leverage a bit more visibility. And then there’s the outrage, which, again, proves his point: some art forms *absolutely* rely on the narrative that there is virtue in keeping them alive, uplifted, celebrated, sustained, etc. with contributions above and beyond paying to see a performance. What performing arts organization hasn’t produced a donation letter that includes a passage about how individual gifts “help to sustain this important work” or “play a significant role in keeping X vital to its community”? Mine sure have; and I believe in the message and continue to choose the path knowing the realities. You can bet with Chalamet’s upbringing, he saw quite a few of those letters at the breakfast table. So the sentiments in his statements that so many took offense to, about him not wanting to spend his career “saving” opera or ballet, didn’t simply appear out of nowhere in his consciousness in the moment of giving that interview. He’s echoing an existing narrative, and reflecting on it relative to his career choices and the economics of the performing arts. The precise language may shift, but this message of “need” tied to working in non-profit performing arts has been clear my entire career: “if you are a dancer, you have to also be a dance advocate because you can’t count on others valuing it the way you do.” He’s saying, “I want to do my work and if that work helps sustain something, I want it to be cinema.” I can’t think of a single dance artist who hasn’t expressed the desire to “just” do their work.</p><p>But I digress.</p><p>Everything is contextual. Chalamet came of age during a period that profoundly reshaped both the world and the U.S. arts economy. He was five years-old and living in New York when the Twin Towers were attacked. Twelve years-old during the 2008 financial crash, when arts funding collapsed and individual giving faltered dramatically, even as banks were bailed out. He was twenty years-old in 2016, entering adulthood during the first Trump presidency, when non-profit cultural institutions once again found themselves defending their legitimacy. And at twenty-three he watched Covid shut down theaters, dance companies, and opera houses around the world. Anyone paying attention during those years, especially when those years coincided with key human development processes, saw how precarious live arts ecosystems can be.</p><p>He’s a film actor and movie star who wants to be really, really famous and well-regarded for his acting. He has been consistent, and sometimes sloppy, about publicly exposing his dream and desire to work at the most visible AND critically-lauded level of his field. Many artists aren’t that transparent about their raw drive or desire. His field, at the level he aspires to and has in many ways reached, simply does not rely on the same funding realities or face the same economic precariousness as many live performing arts. Don’t shoot the messenger and stop pretending you didn’t know this already! He’s entitled to his desire and to that transparency. [An aside: People seem to demand “real” artists who tell the truth, yet those same people are frighteningly quick to excoriate artists for off-hand remarks that haven’t been fully vetted by a PR machine, the very mechanism that makes celebrities seem fake.]</p><p>It’s the harshness of much of the “backlash” that disturbs me: the unreflective, uncritical attacks on people who aren’t doing you any harm. That should sound familiar, it’s characteristic of the American political cesspool; and it’s behavior that has become a hallmark of one of the most base, ethics-free leaders and administrations our country has ever seen. The vitriol I’ve read about Chalamet makes me wince for its cruelty and disproportion.</p><p>I don’t share his desires, but I can see where they come from. I work in a niche field where visibility and economics function differently. That’s my choice, and navigating the financial realities that come with it, ie. writing grants, asking for contributions, sustaining a small organization, is part of that choice. It isn’t always comfortable, but it’s the ecosystem many of us operate in. And damn it all, I’d love for me and my work to be valued in ways that translated more abundantly into paid rent, food on the table, and less fear about the future! But none of that can be laid at Timothée Chalamet’s feet. How absurd.</p><p>Ironically, the outrage has probably done more to draw attention to opera and ballet than most of the people criticizing him. The comment was careless and off the cuff. That happens. He even immediately acknowledged it, which is more than can be said for the kind of hate I’m seeing online, a kind of sheer, wicked delight in trashing him. There are much, much more serious things happening in the world than a young actor saying something inelegant about the economics of art.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bc774d2d365f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>