<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Moni Washington Padula on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Moni Washington Padula on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@moniwashingtonpadula?source=rss-79b0168a2a4d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 14:18:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@moniwashingtonpadula/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When The Chickens Come Home To Roost: A Cautionary Tale Of  How One PWI Must Learn To Practice…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@moniwashingtonpadula/when-the-chickens-come-home-to-roost-a-cautionary-tale-of-how-one-pwi-must-learn-to-practice-394bbe3aee8c?source=rss-79b0168a2a4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/394bbe3aee8c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pwi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-black-racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[systemic-racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bipoc]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moni Washington Padula]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Feb 2020 03:47:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-23T04:05:20.547Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>When The Chickens Come Home To Roost: A Cautionary Tale Of How One PWI Must Learn To Practice Restitution Along With Inclusivity</h3><p>On February 19, 2020, an interactive concert entitled “Spirituals: From Ship to Shore” performed on the campus of Western Michigan University received an unexpected review and criticism that quickly went viral after being posted to social media sources. A Black music student who was observing the performance, performed by WMU choral ensembles, faculty, and facilitated by guest resident Dr. John Wesley Wright (who is also Black), expressed their outrage and hurt over the way the event was held to encourage the participation of a predominantly White audience. Among the comments made by the guest resident were those that the student says made the musical genre seem accessible to anyone of any background, not inherently belonging to Black people, which invites problematic ideas that Black-American sacred music such as spirituals has little to no boundaries in approach or practice. Although others involved in the planning of the program expressed feeling that the program and the guest resident, who spent a few weeks preparing the student ensembles for the recital, were part of an effort to producing more inclusive content to respond to incidents of Black students giving witness to anti-Black racism, microagressions, and myriad forms of exclusion, the student’s reaction shows that the mark was missed, regardless of the intent.</p><p>In an interview with Dr. Wright and Dr. Ken Prewitt, a School of Music voice faculty member, WMUk discusses the upcoming program and reveals the objective goal of the program. Dr. Wright discusses how learning spirituals in church provided a foundation and affirmed that it was ok for him as a growing musician to be comfortable with who he was as a Black musician; that it was ok to “be who you are”, to sing theater music, an oratorio, work songs, and even ring shouts. I understood Dr. Wright’s perspective, that not hiding your cultural background and the music we learn is a part of being proud of our identities and true to them regardless of the academic education we receive throughout our life. Dr. Wright expressed that “through participation, (we) take a look at what came before, and how they (spirituals) come full circle”. He added, “There is no other right way to do that rather than to have everyone participate.”</p><p>In the student’s video (name withheld because of the noted online harassment and abuse they are receiving), there is a snippet of them looking off camera in disdain as the refrain of “Wade in De Water” is being sung, and then another snippet of White students and audience members moving in a circle with some clapping and drumming to mimic an African ring shout. Ring shouts were a cultural and spiritual practice preserved from African origins and eventually incorporated and evolved into Black Christian church practices. This preservation of a practice with African origins is something that survived slavery and was morphed into the Christianity that enslaved Africans adopted. I was personally shocked to see this as well, since African practices were largely forced to go underground and be disguised into Christian practices, and to see them resurrected in front of the White gaze with White participation felt displacing to me. Black people work to preserve the integrity of their cultural practices, which have been heavily stigmatized, mocked, ridiculed, and used for foundations of minstrelsy performances. To overlook how this intent to include non-Black people would make Black people feel was an oversight, since no one can predict how someone would react to heavily stigmatized practices being performed publicly by people outside of that culture. It would be unfair to judge any reaction perceived as negative to exposing those cultural practices in a participatory way to a predominantly white audience.</p><p>Why is this a problem? America’s history of mocking and undermining the intelligence of Black people has long been pervasive and malicious. In Dr. David Pilgrim’s book “Watermelons, Nooses, and Straight Razors”, the discussion of racism being presented inside of entertainment was historically seen through theatrical forms, like comedic skits, dancing, music, and variety acts. These were done in Blackface by white people, and later as a way to gain some notoriety in entertainment, by Black people as well. Contexts were set around Black people being ignorant, lazy, and dangerous. They could be set on plantations, and even have many stereotyped depictions of Black people that were offensive and mocking. Minstrelsy, as racist entertainment, shaped depictions of Black people in real life by how White people portrayed them on stage. The rest of the book is full of thorough examples and explanations of how antiBlack racism throughout American history has shaped how Black people are stereotypically viewed and believed to be in real life. This painful history with having our lives taken out of context and used as entertainment needs space and time to heal. With that understanding of how racism and white supremacy has pained Black people and how they are presented to the public, it could be understood that this student was likely feeling embarrassed, exposed, displaced, and pained to see something sacred, private (practiced within cultural contexts exclusively) and something that could be seen as “strange” or “heathen” to be depicted onstage in front of a White audience. An intimate experience, like reconnecting to pre-enslavement African practices such as the ring shout, can bring up pain that we strangely cannot mourn publicly, because White people are happy that they have access to learning about this practice and we are used to not wanting to offend White people who are trying to learn even while our emotional labor is unbearable.</p><p>Although this was an experience that was curated with and facilitated by a knowledgeable Black educator, not intended to disrespect or portray Black culture or music in an inaccurate light, I think the space this was portrayed in added to the inability of all Black students to see this program as the positive and restorative move towards better inclusivity that was desired by those curating the program. WMU’s School of Music has had a long and painful history of anti-Black racism and exclusionary practices towards BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and People of Color) for a long time. A collection of testimonials addressing only the past 15–20 years shows a lot of hurtful and harmful action and inaction taken to exclude specifically Black students from advancing through the music program at WMU and causing detrimental impacts to mental wellness and trust of the faculty through the practices of institutionalized racism, unchecked racial biases and prejudices, and isolation of Black students from supportive resources available from within the School of Music itself. Listed below are some of the ways Black students were harmed and negatively impacted at the School of Music from 2004-present: (some spoke with family who were also alumnus who shared similar experiences in past decades)</p><ol><li>Some Black students expressed feeling their mental health was impacted in a way that made it hard to endure their four-year program, and some mentioned dropping out or quitting. Some moved away and succeeded in other programs at other institutions.</li><li>Black students experienced microaggressions and slurs such as being told their voice or singing style was “sassy”, comments about hair texture, and someone reported being called outright a “nigger”</li><li>Black vocalists reported being asked to educate a room of White freshmen students on the insensitive and offensive antiBlack text of music chosen by the professor.</li><li>Black students were acknowledged for their ability to sing and act only after they were given stereotypical Black roles, such as in Porgy and Bess.</li><li>Black students were part of a joke that asked if the class had an issue with “the Negroes being cast in the Black opera” as leads.</li><li>Black students called out how the jazz department is predominantly white in student body and staff, and some noted how this led to their steering away from studying jazz for feeling like they did not belong (although jazz is a genre that is historically Black-American music).</li><li>Black vocal students were given statements that implied that their vocal folds and inability to produce resonance made them anatomically predisposed to study the genres of jazz and gospel more than classical music.</li><li>Black students were made to feel that they had to remove “Black sound” or dialect form their natural voices in order to sing their repertoire.</li><li>Black students noted they had no role models and representation in the school of music that took interest in their growth as a student and musician.</li><li>Black classical singers were discouraged from practicing other genres, specifically jazz, despite it being a widely practiced contemporary genre that influences current musical styles, creates job opportunities, and gives Black students even more creative opportunities to contribute to and carry on a genre pertinent to their cultural history.</li><li>Contributions of Black American musicians and composers were frequently overlooked or altogether excluded in music history classes</li><li>Black students reported feeling deterred and discouraged from pursuing the degrees they originally desired to pursue; one student pursued and obtained a doctorate in Speech Pathology to prevent further claims of Black voices not being fit for genres of singing.</li><li>Students, when they or their families complained, reported being blacklisted and punished by teachers, losing casting opportunities and told they would never be cast for major roles (in opera)</li><li>A Black student used public transportation to come to class, was late, and was turned away and denied the opportunity to take their exam</li><li>Black students were shamed publicly and given public reproaches for late appearances in class or studios without a regard as to why they were late or to check-in to see if they were doing okay (one student reported their parents were divorcing and that was a difficult time for them).</li><li>A Black student reported a professor that persistently touched their hair without consent</li><li>A Black student experienced a comment on a New Student Audition Day that they were a “pretty one”</li><li>A Black student commented that “it’s difficult to find out where you fit in that world.”</li><li>Black students were questioned by their professors about their ability to learn or improve certain parts (in vocal and instrumental departments) for a satisfactory performance. A student, without knowing why, was asked to practice more or be replaced by the staff accompanist although they didn’t receive clear reasons as to why their performance was already unsatisfactory as is. Another student with a major role was told their professor was concerned about their ability to fulfill the role.</li><li>Black students were given microagressive gifts of “grills” for contributing to the “diversity” of their predominantly white choral group.</li><li>A Black student commented “My experience (at WMU) crushed my confidence as a musician and led to years of depression and unnecessary suffering”.</li><li>A Black student acknowledged that it hurt to have the silence of their peers, seeing and hearing the oppression and bias they were facing but didn’t speak out.</li><li>A Black student reflected that their youth contributed to their inability to process what they were going through and limited their capacity to speak up for themselves when anti-Blackness at the School of Music posed a threat to their healthy identity as a Black person.</li></ol><p>Below are some quotes from a student who gave a recorded testimony of their experience, and how it made them feel about themselves and being Black in the School of Music:</p><blockquote>I studied vocal music because I loved singing choral music. At WMU, I dealt with insecurity and self-esteem, I felt that my voice wasn’t a good fit, or needed or appreciated…that the faculty didn’t know what to do with Black voices.</blockquote><p>The student also said:</p><blockquote>I dealt with insecurity and low self-esteem. I felt I had to bridge the gap between the cultures, and it was the constant defending of ones self, ones culture and upbringing, this is why so many People of Color do not attend Western for music, both because of intentional and unintentional ignorance.</blockquote><p>The student gave more insight as to why it was difficult as a Black student to study in the music department, citing that one cannot learn in a constant state of defense, and that the courses were full of people and taught by people who didn’t look like them. They also talked about how non-western music as a course felt inauthentic and lacked a connection to the cultures being spoken about.</p><p>In 2019, there was controversy over the long-time programming of a piece called “Country Dances” in the Gold Company and GCII repertoire. Although it was being referred to be educators as “American folk music”, this particular piece and the lyrics and antics was discussed by Black students as being an egregious oversight of how performing minstrel and vaudeville songs impact Black students and audience members, who were largely the racial targets of that musical form. Students voiced their concerns throughout the years, but the controversy was raised to a peak most recently. Since then, a panel of Black students was formed to be invited to voice their concerns to faculty, with appropriate mediation from the director of the Kalamazoo College Counseling Center. It is believed that because of that dialogue, that the concert mentioned at the beginning of this piece was an intentional effort on the journey to inclusivity for the WMU School of Music.</p><p>The testimonies collected held an overwhelming consensus that although no ill will or intent is held, it does not make things that are offensive to Black students any less offensive. This leads us back to our primary example heading this extensive essay. When addressing institutional racism and racial bias, particularly anti-Black bias (where negative stereotypes, ideas, and beliefs about Black people, bodies, and abilities are expressed either implicitly or explicitly), a PWI like Western Michigan University cannot afford the privilege of thinking that something that would otherwise be considered inclusive without <em>an ongoing habit over time</em> of working collectively with Black people (artists, musicians, composers, historians, community members) will resolve the pain and hurt caused to multiple Black people, and also other People of Color along the way.</p><p>Suggested action steps towards ongoing restitution could look as follows:</p><ol><li>Acknowledge the current state of safety and security BIPOC feel at the school of music. Holding a forum where students can safely express their feelings, not separated from their community and where those committed to restoration work (organizations such as the NAACP, ERACCE, SURJ) can come and support the rebuilding process would be crucial to what is now a public ink stain on the reputation of WMU’s School of Music.</li><li>Diversify representation. Immediately. Make BIPOC faculty positions accessible, and because of the widely expressed harm caused to Black students, make sure that Black faculty is on that list. One Black staff or faculty member cannot carry this load for all Black students. If you don’t have a position open, create one. Prioritize hiring marginalized folks for faculty, staff, and resident artists. Make jazz recognizable again.</li><li>Diversify the curriculum. Expand the curriculum so that students of color can see themselves represented in the curriculum, and work on representing more equitably artists, composers, and pieces that represent regions and people of color. Not deduced to one class that doesn’t include the instruction and perspective of BIPOC. If this is not an area currently with it’s own curricula, create it.</li><li>Provide access to mentorship within the School of Music so that BIPOC can have a physical space to have convos, provide feedback to the department, and relate to faculty and staff who can encourage them with challenges of trying to obtain a degree in a PWI. Consider the mental wellness of your students of color.</li></ol><p>In conclusion, this piece was written to validate the feelings of the student who posted the viral video of this event, and to provide more context as to why this student could have seen this event through that lens. Given the long history of Black students in facing challenges with anti-Black bias and microagressions, along with reported intentional barriers placed along their way to success by faculty, it is safe to say that this isn’t a new feeling but one that is publicly encompassing the feelings of many Black students and other Students of Color on the heels of the concert that tried to bring an education of Black-American sacred music to the stage. Less those who curated the event find themselves so discouraged and unsure of how to process this backlash, another Black student provided this quote regarding the event and their observations of how Black music is treated in the School of Music:</p><blockquote>My fear is that this conversation will lead to African-American music being erased from the repertoire completely. I’ve been in the choral program for the majority of my time here and I can count on one hand the amount of times we’ve successfully studied Black music…I feel the conversation shouldn’t be “why are they singing sacred spirituals”, but rather, “why is it that when they sing sacred spirituals, that the music does not get the proper attention and score study and composer study that the White music gets?”</blockquote><p>The student made another poignant revelation in the difference observed between the treatment of Black music and European music in the choral program:</p><blockquote>We never talked about the composers, or the lyrics, or why they were significant. But had it been some floral-sounding piece with a pretty poem, we’d take turns reading a stanza around the room, interpreting it as a class. We’d talk about what it means to each of us and how it applies to each of our lives so that we can connect to the piece.</blockquote><p>Regarding students who are not Black that do not prepare Black sacred music thoroughly, the student goes on to say that it is clear when the time was not taken to study the piece the same way as arias and art songs, and the performance can come off as being forced, like the student did not want to include spirituals in their repertoire.</p><blockquote>“Singing them like they didn’t care, that is what hurts.”</blockquote><p>Could the concert have been a way to try to mend and restore old hurts, and begin a new conversation about Black-American music within a positive context in the School of Music? Most assuredly. But are Black students, alumni, and community members ready to move along at the selected pace without the proper acknowledgment and trust that the School of Music has a willingness to actively restitute those wrongs? Is this public exposure a necessary step in re-thinking what restitution looks like?</p><p>Although many saw the positives in this bold move on the part of the School of Music and felt included, others are feeling that “It Ain’t Necessarily So.” I argue that this matters, and that this must be addressed and handled with transparency moving forward, including the voices of marginalized people in what would make them feel safer in the spaces they take up in their institutions.</p><p>For more information and education, here are a couple relevant links:</p><p>“How PWI’s in Indiana address retention and graduation rates of African-Americans”: <a href="http://scholars.indstate.edu/handle/10484/8060">http://scholars.indstate.edu/handle/10484/8060</a></p><p>“The Reason Why We Sing”: <a href="https://www.wmuk.org/post/lhi-live-monica-washington-padula-and-dr-romeo-phillips-black-american-sacred-music#stream/0">https://www.wmuk.org/post/lhi-live-monica-washington-padula-and-dr-romeo-phillips-black-american-sacred-music#stream/0</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=394bbe3aee8c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>