<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by @mx_mokgoroane on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by @mx_mokgoroane on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 05:22:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dear Mamane,]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/dear-mamane-45ade08465be?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/45ade08465be</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[grief-and-loss]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jan 2024 07:45:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-29T07:45:16.196Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“<strong>I want to write about</strong></p><p><strong>women who pray for me</strong></p><p><strong>in a language so beautuful</strong></p><p><strong>english will bow. “– Ijeoma Umebinyuo</strong></p><p>I have read this particular poem and these lines so many times, but today they have appear to haunt me. Haunting is not always a bad thing. I think the words have been echoing in my spirit as a reminder that you are still praying for me. And now, you are praying in the heavenly language that you have always wanted to.</p><p>I remember our praying sessions at home, over the phone when I was in varsity and even in my absence. They kept me going. I remember the times that I would tell you that I could not study, we would pray. Your prayers were powerful. I still remember them. Sometimes I wished I pray more for you. For your healing and breakthrough.</p><p>I know how tough things got but you always showed up with a smile, always believing. I am taken back to the time when you could not attend my first graduation because of some family feud. Your absence was felt. And your absence will be felt this Friday, as I graduate from an American institution (UCLA).</p><p>Can you believe that? Nna, ngwana ko Kimberley, graduating mo America. I am sure you can because you were probably praying for this exact time to come. You believed in me so much. You believed in my potential and always wanted to set my anxieties at ease. You would confidently recite <strong><em>Phil 4:6 “Do not be anxious about anything, but in every situation, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, present your requests to God”.</em></strong></p><p>Time and time again, you would tell me about God and how God is able to do all things. I miss that. The certainty in your faith. I miss you praying for me, although I believe that you have not stopped.</p><p>I am sad this week, I was hoping that you would be here. Even if it is not in LA. I was hoping that you were still alive. I imagine that you would be ululating at the top of your lungs as I call you to tell you the news that I will be graduating and giving the commencement speech. I imagine the pride in your voice as you say: <strong><em>“these are the things that you are made of, Tlhogi</em></strong>”</p><p>I imagine the excitement as you go out to tell your colleagues and friends that “Tlhogi has made you proud again”. How I yearn for that! I yearn to hear your voice again. To hear your infectious laugh. To see your beautiful big brown eyes again. To glean from your knowledge. To hold onto the future prayers that you prayed for in the spirit.</p><p>I still look back and think that you and Bandusi really did something. You ignite so many fires in my weakened soul. You awakened so many died things in me. Thank you for calling me into existence. Thank you for always encouraging me to follow my dreams.</p><p>You always used to tell me about your dream of becoming a psychologist, an industrial one at that. And at some point, we were applying to have you admitted into the programme but it never came to fruition, for many reasons. I also vividly remember conversations about you wanting to live in Saudi Arabia or London. It was your dream to travel and live in another country for a little while. I know that LA is no Saudi or London, but I think you would love it here. I hope that you are looking down on me and you are smiling because it some ways coming to LA is a reclamation of all that was stolen from you.</p><p>Thank you for your life, Cocosi</p><p>It has allowed me to live out mine.</p><p>I miss you and love you forever.</p><p>Your beloved,</p><p>Tlhogi</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/375/1*3euBlpOOFQaij04ktdfeXw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=45ade08465be" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[BOOK REVIEW: AN ORDINARY WONDER BY BUKI PAPILLION]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/book-review-an-ordinary-wonder-by-buki-papillion-f0afd53c29f9?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0afd53c29f9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[african-literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intersex]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Aug 2021 11:19:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-08T11:21:31.855Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SFUWBLMfc89rw08Sot6qow.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><strong><em>“See, if you act like your uniqueness is a great thing and you couldn’t care less about their opinion, they eventually give up. And that feels so good that you do it again and again until you truly believe it.”</em></strong></blockquote><h3>There is nothing ordinary about this wonder.</h3><p>An Ordinary Wonder is a coming of age story about Oto — the main protagonist. Oto is a twin, who is born intersex and socialised as a boy and who experiences hardship in the family home because of her desire to live as a girl.</p><p>The book is filled with rich imagery, art, proverbs and folk tales. The writing is stunning, often lyrically.</p><p>There is so much violence in the book, which in a way is the reality of many queer, trans and intersex people in societies that do not believe that we deserve to exist.</p><p>I don’t know how many times I threw my book across the room because I could not handle the hardship.</p><p>But interwoven with the hardship is a tenderness between the siblings. Oto and Wura love each other, always managing to make their way back to each other. This loves allows both of them to live as their true selves.</p><p>Then there is the tenderness of friendship and love. Oto and Derin’s relationship is my favourite relationship in the book. Their love is innocent, pure and often times life-saving. It reminds us that the basis of any solid romantic relationship is friendship. That love can hold us together.</p><p>One character that stayed with me is the only teacher that protects Oto. He stayed with me because through Oto, he seeks to rectify what he couldn’t before. He shows up for Oto in ways he wished he could have showed up for his lover. He understands Oto because of his own positionality in relation to nationality and queerness.</p><p>The ending of the book was a happy one, which warmed my heart.</p><p>I recently finished <a href="https://www.netflix.com/gb/title/81210762"><em>Young Royals</em></a>, a new Netflix original series from Sweden, released on the streaming platform on July 1. The six-episode series is a coming-of-age story with a tenderly told love story at its center. The ending of the story left me heartbroken and deeply sad. The love story did not have a happy ending — the reality that many queer, trans and intersex people are constantly confronted with. That our lives do not deserve happier endings or even happy beginnings.</p><p>So, I appreciate an ending that makes room and space for us to have happy endings. It was beautiful. The reconciliation, the reuniting and the kiss at the airport allowed me to release a deep sigh of relief. Many queer, trans and intersex people live life holding their breaths and this book created for us a moment to finally release a lifetime of belief that we did not belong; this book finally said, you belong. The book gives a beautiful amatory moment at the end.</p><blockquote><strong>We — as queer, trans and intersex people — deserve happy endings. We deserve lush lives. We deserve love that desires and wants us daily. We deserve to be seen in our fullness as ourselves.</strong></blockquote><p>This book gave me all the emotions, from sadness and anger (I cried), to an overall feeling of happiness.</p><p>This book is heart-rending. It is a debut I would highly recommend. It will steal your heart.</p><p>This book unapologetically declares that our interior lives belong and matter.</p><p>You can watch The Cheeky Natives talking to Buki about the book</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7P78PRLoilw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7P78PRLoilw</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0afd53c29f9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pupillage in the time of Corona]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/pupillage-in-the-time-of-corona-290c3fedbe69?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/290c3fedbe69</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 31 Mar 2020 09:36:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-31T09:36:16.751Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*o4vqinZOu1jFNKsN87x6Lw.jpeg" /></figure><p>When this month began I had no idea that we would be under lockdown, with only the allowance to go get food and access health care. But here we are!</p><p>To be clear this is not a state of emergency, it is a state of national disaster under the Disaster Management Act, which means that our rights are limited. It is important to distinguish between the suspension of rights (state of emergency) and limitation (state of national disaster). Section 36 of the Constitution provides for the limitation of rights which authorises restrictions on fundamental rights under normal circumstances. In contrast, the suspension of rights, as provided for by section 37, is only operative for a temporary period in a crisis situation when the life of the nation is at risk and ordinary legal measures do not suffice. It may appear like we are in a state of emergency but we are not. The COVID-19 regulations limited our rights but do not as yet suspend them fully.</p><p>The month began off pretty well. I went to the Constitutional Court to hear argument in this matter of <em>Sylvia Bongi Mahlangu and Another v Minister of Labour and Others</em>. This was an application for confirmation of an order of the High Court, which declared section 1(xix)(v) of the Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act 130 of 1993 (COIDA) unconstitutional to the extent that it excludes domestic workers employed in private households from the definition of “employee”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XLs67fB5XQHYFcUrhkp0VA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I use the following summary, often verbatim, from the pre-hearing summary drafted by clerks at the Constitutional Court. I think it does a great job of crystalising the issues that came before the Court. So, thank you, law clerks.</p><p>The facts of the case are heart-breaking and make me wonder how many more people have been injured while at work and nothing was done about it.</p><p>On 31 March 2012, the deceased, the mother of the first applicant, was working outside in the back yard washing the windows, using a step ladder, outside a bedroom located next to the swimming pool when she slipped from the ladder and fell into the swimming pool, which was unfenced and uncovered at the time of the incident. It is alleged that the deceased was partially blind and could not swim resulting in her drowning. Her body was found floating in the swimming pool hours later by her employer who had been present in the home at the time of the incident, but asserts that he heard no sounds of a struggle.</p><p>The first applicant, the daughter and sole dependent of the deceased, approached the Department of Labour to enquire about getting compensation for her mother’s death, where she was informed that she could neither get any compensation nor could she get unemployment insurance benefits for her loss which was ordinarily covered by COIDA.</p><p>The first applicant along with the South African Domestic Service and Allied Workers Union (SADSAWU) (the applicants) brought an application in the High Court to have section 1(xix)(v) of COIDA declared unconstitutional to the extent that it excludes domestic workers employed in private households from the definition of “employee”.</p><p>The High Court declared the exclusion of domestic workers from COIDA unconstitutional and invalid and it ordered that section 1(xix)(v) be severed from COIDA. It postponed the issue of the retrospective effect of the order of constitutional invalidity for further submissions to be made. On 17 October 2019, it ordered that the declaration of invalidity apply retrospectively to provide relief to other domestic workers who were injured or died at work prior to the granting of the order.</p><p>In the Constitutional Court, the applicants submitted that the consequence of excluding domestic employees from the definition of “employee” is that domestic workers are denied the most basic entitlement to claim compensation under section 22(1) of COIDA. This exclusion does not pass constitutional muster as it violates the rights contained in section 9, 10 and 27 of the Constitution.</p><p>This case seems to be one of the first, where the respondents did not oppose the confirmation of unconstitutionality. In truth, it was an unopposed matter before the court. The respondents conceded that there is no rational basis upon which the legislature made the distinction between employees otherwise covered by the definition of “employee” in COIDA and domestic workers. Furthermore, they conceded that the exclusion of domestic workers limits their rights under sections 9, 10 and 27(1)© of the Constitution and given the absence of any justifiable purpose for the limitation which would satisfy the requirements of section 36 of the Constitution.</p><p>The respondents put up two justifications for the limitation of the retrospective effect of the declaration of invalidity. The respondents submitted that such an order will result in administrative burden since claims arising from old injuries or diseases and the retrospectivity will have financial implications on the viability of the fund (in particular the capacity and solvency of the fund) and the ability of the fund to meet future claims if old claims are to be met.</p><p>CGE was admitted as the first amicus curiae in this matter. CGE supports the confirmation of the order of constitutional invalidity. CGE contended that the exclusion of domestic workers from COIDA unjustifiably perpetuates the disadvantages suffered by this group of workers.</p><p>The Women’s Legal Centre Trust (WLC) was admitted as second amicus curiae in this matter. WLC submits that it is imperative for this Court to draw on the lived experiences of Black women and the manner in which the Constitution recognises their rights in sections 9, 10 and 27 of the Constitution and the discrimination that they face. WLC proposes an intersectional approach to this matter, which would require this Court to adopt a nuanced, purposive and socio-contextual approach in interpreting COIDA, when this Court makes its decision on the constitutionality of COIDA and any order it makes on the retrospectivity of the order. WLC submits that the respondents have not put sufficient reasons before this Court to limit the retrospective effect of the order of constitutional invalidity.</p><p>The Court had a few concerns. First, the respective nature of the order, the court asked a lot of questions about how retrospectivity would work and whether making an order to this effect would mean that there will be a floodgate of cases. Second, the Court kept pointing out that the High Court did not give judgment, Justice Jafta went as far as saying that this would appear that the Court is a court of the first instance, which is undesirable. Third, the Court asked the respondent when the Bill rectifying the mess would be passed and the answer from the respondents showed that it is still a long way to go. So, in truth, the Court must make a decision to come to the aid of these Black womxn. Fourthly, the Court wanted to know if the Commission had money for all the claims that could potentially be instituted. And the respondents said yes. I wonder if the respondents would change their answer in light of COVID-19. I need to actually look into this. I wonder if there are different pools of money for different types of compensation.</p><p>I am looking forward to the judgment. I think it will be an opportunity for the court to deal squarely with intersectionality. The submissions by WLC are helpful. And Justice Victor remained a champion for intersectionality. She said that the framework cuts across technicality, which I took to mean that we need to ensure that the Black womxn who are doing domestic work are not felt unprotected because of issues that can be remedied. I am also interested to see how the retrospectivity issue will be dealt with.</p><p>While leaving the court to return to chambers, I listened to the news on my drive back and heard that the High Court in Pretoria <a href="http://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAGPPHC/2020/9.pdf">delivered judgment</a> in the Public Protector case, I hope you still remember it from the first post. In essence, the President had taken the CR17 campaign report by the Public Protector on review. The Court handed down a strongly worded judgment. The Court said that the Public Protector in making some of her decisions made material errors of fact and law. The Court also said that she used the wrong legislation and lacked a basic understanding of the law. I will link you to an <a href="https://constitutionallyspeaking.co.za/why-busisiwe-mkhwebane-has-been-a-godsend-to-cyril-ramaphosa-and-the-cr17-campaign/">article by Professor De Vos</a>, who writes about the judgment and shares his thoughts. I was also on <a href="https://omny.fm/shows/powertalk-archive/unpacking-the-cr17-funding-campaign-report-by-the">Power FM talking about the judgment</a>. The interview was fine but I wish I set out clearly some of my points.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L2kX4jf0TUaoY5pX_lQQ4Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Later on in the month, I found myself at the regional court in Randburg listening to a criminal trial about the rape of a minor. The trial was in camera but as pupils, we were allowed to observe the proceedings. It was very interesting because the subject matter is close to my heart. Sitting in the courtroom for the two days made me realise that criminal law is not something that I want to find myself doing. I think I am too emotional and involved to be able to defend people, even my friends.</p><p>The following week a decision was made by the JSA to move all pupillage classes online. So, we still attend class but in the comfort of our homes. It has been a challenging time. We even had to do advocacy training online and will continue to do so. So this is pupillage in the time of Corona. Not spending quality time with your mentor, which is the whole idea of pupillage.</p><p>That said, my mentor has been very gracious to involve in the work that she has been doing. We have done so much regulatory work and I love it. My mentor thinks I am brilliant and I hope at some point this year that I, too, will start believing that</p><p>A lot of people says that this gives us time to study for the Bar exams, but I find that I am very anxious during this time. I hope that as time goes on I will be able to focus on this work and to do it.</p><p>This is random, but you know what I miss the most is affection, I wish I could still hug people. Physical touch is so important to me. So for the last few weeks, I have been missing that affection and grief have been a lot.</p><p>I hope that you all are keeping safe and sane during this lockdown.</p><p>Until we meet again,</p><h3><strong>STAY AT HOME.</strong></h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=290c3fedbe69" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[#LetlhogonoloTakesTheBar — Month 1]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/letlhogonolotakesthebar-month-1-d1e689a05191?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1e689a05191</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Mar 2020 05:22:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-08T05:22:59.703Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#LetlhogonoloTakesTheBar — Month 1</h3><blockquote><strong>‘Your new personality is tired’</strong> a friend proclaimed this to me over the phone during one of our catch up calls. She said it with such conviction that it stayed with me. And she’s right. I’m tired, all the time. Pupillage is a tiring training programme.</blockquote><p>It’s been a just over a month since I started pupillage and I thought like #LetlhogonoloTakesUCLALaw I should attempt to journal my sojourn.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/510/1*VfbA8HlJvwDFcUobfXhOtA.jpeg" /><figcaption>First day of Pupillage</figcaption></figure><h4>So the <strong>first question </strong>to answer is probably, why I want to be an advocate?</h4><p>I think the answer to this is simple. I want to make money. Haha! Jokes. I’ve always been an advocate in the social justice sense of the word, advocating for various causes and people, and I thought it would be great to become an advocate in the legal sense of the work. I enjoy litigation (the process of resolving disputes in a courtroom), I love the law and I think that my purpose may lie here. I hope that one day I will become an advocate that shapes law and hopefully a judge sometime in the future.</p><p>Do you watch The Good Wife? it&#39;s one of my favourite legal series. Do you have a favourite lawyer? Most people tend to do with Alicia, she is great, yes but she is not my favourite. My favourite lawyer is Elsabeth Tascioni. She is described as an astute, albeit scattered lawyer. She often makes observations at inappropriate times while still being able to stay on task to perform brilliant intellectual manoeuvres placing her in the frontline of the field. she reminds me of myself, the quirkiness. I want to remain who I am and be brilliant.</p><h4>The second question probably is how is pupillage?</h4><p>Short answer: Intense. Exhausting. Challenging. Great Learning.</p><p>The training programme is intense. We have classes Monday to Thursday and on some weeks, Monday to Saturday. The classes cover the work that we will be examined on. I think we will be examined on 5 subjects. It has been a long time since I’ve written exams, so I am nervous about these exams. what if I do not remember how to study and retain information?</p><p>We started classes the last week of January and classes happen from Monday to Thursday. Some weeks like this past week, it is Monday to Saturday. We are learning how to be advocates through understanding the ethics pertaining to our profession, knowing then rules applicable in motion proceedings (proceedings before the court by way of an affidavit), civil and criminal trials (action proceedings). Do you think it is called action proceedings because there is a lot of action in the courtroom? Anyway, action proceeding largely are cases where there will be witnesses, who give evidence in court.</p><p>We also have advocate training, which a process where you argue a case in front of a ‘judge’. it is a fun process but can be a very nail-biting process.</p><h4>The third question is how does it work?</h4><p>The programme is set up in a way that you have to be ‘supervised’ by a practising advocate, who is your mentor. My mentor is Advocate Reghana Tulk. She studied at Wits, then when to study in the US at Columbia University, came back to clerk at the Constitutional Court, worked and Bell Dewar and Bowmans before she joined the Bar. She is one of the most brilliant people I’ve met. She is also very kind. And has throughout this process she has been so gentle with me. And reassuring.</p><h4>Perhaps the last question is have you been to court?</h4><p>Yes I have.</p><figure><img alt="myself and other pupils taking the train to High Court in Pretoria" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SbYHtKTCfeE3ZKqQxH-M-w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Myself and other Pupils about to take the Gautrain to the High Court in Pretoria</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve managed to see some interesting cases. The first case was in the High Court in Pretoria. President Ramaphosa took a decision made by the Public Protector on review. The President was represented by Wim Trengove SC and Tembeka Ngcukaitobi. The public protector was represented by Muzi Sikhakhane SC and Adv Farzanah Karachi. There were other parties present. Follow the <a href="https://mg.co.za/article/2020-02-07-court-tests-protectors-powers/">link </a>to read more on the case.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3FCVMJod5ZPdjMvZ5u-NfA.jpeg" /><figcaption>My mentor arguing at the Labour Court</figcaption></figure><p>Then I attended an urgent application, where my mentor argued for the applicant. My mentor is short in stature (like me) but makes up for it with her knowledge of the law. She was so brilliant, even though she has a really tough time with the judge. We have attended a few other matters in the urgent court and I have seen her brilliance over and over again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gTZsfN8d12vFsOj6dFGLqA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mid-Feb, I went to the Supreme Court of Appeal. This was my first time at the Court. So you can imagine my excitement. The SCA has very different from other courts I’ve been to, the judges were very engaged in the matter and got straight to the point. The matter was about the Turquand rule. The rule allows people transacting with companies to assume that Internal Company Rules are complied with, even when they are not. It is a common law principle that has now been codified in the Companies Act.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DceU7Ud5ML4A8dIuw1PCbg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2uRfnp8biPH2BIR7WDNDBg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The next case I attended was at the Constitutional Court. The matter was about confirming an order of the high court, which held that a particular section of the Riotous Assembly Act was unconstitutional. It was a really interesting case. For me, an interesting question will be the remedy, I want to see how the court if it agrees with the High Court, will deal with the question of remedy. Read more about the case <a href="https://mg.co.za/article/2020-02-19-eff-tackles-apartheid-legislation/">here</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ydmlQgiXD-Ktg5RAP5OWJw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I now need to attend more to court, especially to observe trials both civil and criminal to see how witnesses are handled.</p><p>I will say this: I am happy. I am enjoying myself, albeit exhausted.</p><p>I need to send a special shoutout to all the people that support me, financially. Their generosity has kept me moving since the beginning of the year. The support has enabled me to turn my attention to the work and not worry about the finances. I am also so blessed to know that there are people out there who believe in my dreams and will support them. It is hard-warming. It reminds me of #LetlhogonoloTakesUCLALaw. If you would like to support, please follow <a href="https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfcUxgWru1unJwHFomOCMdrda2M23C6WcPTUWo0VOLE8Imj2A/viewform">this link</a>.</p><p>I will do my best to have monthly updates about my whereabout, for more frequent updates follow me on twitter.</p><p>Until next time,</p><p>Yours in law,</p><p>Letlhogonolo</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1e689a05191" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[COMMON PURPOSE:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/common-purpose-2c14aa116cd1?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2c14aa116cd1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[common-purpose]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[constitutional-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[south-africa]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Dec 2019 19:34:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-17T06:18:51.310Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A summary of the recent Constitutional Court judgment on whether common purpose applies in the context of rape</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/256/1*gzfQjgZQ7baicaw2jjqR9A@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Trigger warning: this case speaks about gang rape and Gender-Based Violence (GBV)</strong></p><blockquote>“He was taking my skinnes off. I started fighting, pleading, negotiating, trying to scare him but nothing worked. He got the kids to hold my arms down above my head, his legs keeping mine apart. I remember him saying he is about to show me that I am a girl, not the boy I think I am. ‘ek sal jou wys, ek sal jou wys’, he kept while thrusting into me repeatedly. I have never felt dick before and had never seen one that big either. I felt my pussy muscles fighting against him, my dry lips painful trying to guard the door…. When he was done he ordered everyone else to have a turn, all eight of them.” — Chwayita Ngamlana, If I Stay Right Here</blockquote><p><strong>INTRODUCTION</strong></p><p>On 11 December 2019, the Constitutional Court handed down a historic, monumental judgment that is a milestone for rape and Gender-Based Violence (GBV). The main question was whether common purpose applies to the common law definition of rape.</p><p><strong><em>What is the doctrine of common purpose you may ask?</em></strong></p><p>The best way for me to explain this is to refer to a scene in Sarafina. Sabela (played by Mbongeni Ngema) was an apartheid police officer, who was not trusted by the students in the community. The students came together and planned to kill him. Sabela’s house and car were burned and he was eventually necklaced. According to the doctrine of common purpose, those students would be guilty of murder on the basis of common purpose.</p><p>The doctrine of common purpose is where two or more persons agree to commit a crime by <em>prior agreement</em>, either expressed or implied or where there is no prior agreement by <em>actively associating</em> in the committing of the crime.</p><p>For the longest time, courts have given some conflicting decisions on the common purpose. In 2010, the High Court in Kimberley grappled with the application of common purpose in rape cases. The minority judgment held the definition for a perpetrator for robbery and rape is the same and thus the doctrine of common purpose should apply. In 2012, the Eastern Cape High Court held common purpose does not apply as instrumentality is necessary for rape. The common law definition of rape requires an unlawful insertion of the male genitalia into the female genitalia (this definition was used here because the crime was committed before the <a href="http://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZACC/2007/9.html">judgment </a>that found this definition to be unconstitutional and before the introduction of the<a href="https://www.saps.gov.za/resource_centre/acts/downloads/sexual_offences/sexual_offences_act32_2007_eng.pdf"> Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Act)</a>).</p><p>Instrumentality means the use of a person’s body. In the context of rape, if person A rapes a womxn while his friend person B assists person A in restraining the womxn and person B does not penetrate the womxn, person B will be an accomplice, as opposed to a co-perpetrator, to the rape. In 2018, the Johannesburg High Court grappled with whether the doctrine of common purpose applies to rape. The Court confirmed that the instrumentality applies in rape cases and found that rape is a crime that can only be committed by the instrumentality of a person’s own body. The appellate courts also dealt with this question but it appears that it was never fully resolved.</p><p>This case is one that finally resolves the issue for us. In short, the Constitutional Court unanimously held that common purpose applies to rape and it rejected the instrumentality argument.</p><p><strong>FACTS OF THE CASE</strong></p><p>The facts of this case began more than twenty years ago, one late night in September 1998. On that fateful night, a group of men went on a rampage in Umthambeka, a township east of Johannesburg. During this time, they forced their way into several homes located on nine separate plots and when they had gained entry, they ransacked, looted and stabbed one of the occupants in one of the houses. While committing these crimes, the group of men raped eight womxn, some of the men raped these womxn repeatedly. Amongst the victims was a 14-year-old and a visibly pregnant womxn. The victims knew their perpetrators. While the rapes were committed, some men stood outside to be on the look-out.</p><p>In the weeks that followed, these men were apprehended and charged. In August 1999, they appeared before the High Court. In the High Court, the main issue was whether these men could be found guilty of the common law crime of rape on the basis of the doctrine of common purpose.</p><p>In the High Court, Mr Tshabalala, Mr Ntuli and the other co-accused were found guilty of eight counts of rape, seven of which were imposed on the basis of the application of the doctrine of common purpose.</p><p>The applicants argued that the common law crime of rape is not an offence for which an individual can be convicted through the application of the doctrine of common purpose. This argument was rejected by the High Court. It held that the doctrine of common purpose applies.</p><p>The trial eventually came to an end and the applicants were convicted and sentenced to effective life sentences. They sought to appeal the decision, which was denied in 2000. Nine years later, Mr Tshabalala petitioned the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) for leave to appeal against his convictions and sentences and it said that Mr Ntuli did the same but no application was received. On 11 September 2009, Mr Tshabalala’s application for leave to appeal was again dismissed.</p><p>Separately, in 2012, Mr Phetoe, who was co-accused number seven, was granted leave to appeal his conviction and sentence to a Full Court of the High Court. The High Court effectively held that the state could not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that each member of the group raped the womxn and therefore the convictions based on the doctrine of common purpose was set aside. Importantly, it held “that the doctrine cannot be applied to crimes that can be committed only through the instrumentality of a person’s own body, or part thereof, and not through the instrumentality of another.” Consequently, the Court found that Mr Phetoe was an accomplice and not a co-accused and changed his conviction to one of being an accomplice and sentenced him to one term of life imprisonment.</p><p>Mr Phetoe still unsatisfied with decision approached the SCA. The SCA disagreed with the Full Court and held that “to convict the appellant on the basis of his mere presence is to subvert the principles of participation and liability as an accomplice in our criminal law”. The SCA reasoned further that there was no evidence to prove that Mr Phetoe was present at the scene of violence where the rapes, assaults, house-breakings and robberies were committed other than at one household and thus concluded that no common purpose with the other members of the group was established. Further, the SCA held that there was no prior agreement to commit the crimes. Consequently, it concluded that Mr Phetoe ought not to have been convicted of all other charges except where he was positively identified. As a result, it reversed the findings of the High Court on the application of the doctrine and of the Full Court on the finding that he was an accomplice. The SCA then set aside the convictions and sentences relating to all the convictions on common law rape.</p><p>It appears that Mr Tshabalala caught wind of this win and took his chances by applying to set aside his convictions and sentences to the Constitutional Court in December 2018. The Constitutional Court heard the matter on 22 August 2019.</p><p><strong>THE APPLICANTS’ ARGUMENT (Mr Tshabalala and Mr Ntuli)</strong></p><p>The applicants’ main argument was that the doctrine of common purpose does not apply to the common law crime of rape as the crime required the unlawful insertion of the male genitalia into the female genitalia. Therefore, it is impossible, according to the applicants for the doctrine to apply as the instrumentality applies. They also argued that the same benefits given to Mr Phetoe should be given to them.</p><p><strong>THE RESPONDENT’S ARGUMENT (The State)</strong></p><p>The respondent supported the findings of the High Court that there was a prior agreement and that common purpose must have been formed before the attacks commenced. Further, the respondent urged the Court to accept that there was a single group responsible for the attacks and they acted as a “cohesive whole because some of the men kept guard outside the households while some entered the households”. Moreover, they argued that applying the doctrine of common purpose in cases of rape is keeping with international standards.</p><p><strong>AMICI CURIAE (THE FRIENDS OF THE COURT)</strong></p><p>A friend of the Court is not a party to the proceeding but helps the Court through legal arguments related to the matter. The Commission for Gender Equality (the Commission) and the Centre for Applied Legal Studies (CALS) were admitted as friends of the Court.</p><p>The Commission made two primary submissions. First, the Commission submitted that our law already allows for the doctrine of common purpose to apply to common law rape and that the courts have previously failed to apply the doctrine. Second, the Commission submitted that the instrumentality approach is fundamentally flawed. They argued that the approach is both artificial and unprincipled. They argued that it is artificial in that there is no reason as to why the use of one’s body should be determinative in the case of rape but not in the case of assault or murder, where common purpose applies without any difficulty.</p><p>CALS’ main submission pertained to understanding the patriarchal roots of the common law concerning rape and sexual violence. This includes an understanding that the harm caused by rape is something greater than non-consensual penetration. Instead, they submitted that rape is the assertion of power and the exertion of this power is gendered as it is typically exerted by men at the expense of womxn. Further, they also requested the Court to develop the common law requirements of the doctrine of common purpose to include a positive duty on everyone to either report or prevent the commission of the crime of rape. Additionally, they had an interrelated request that the court develops the <em>active association </em>requirements of the doctrine of common purpose, so as to include the injunction that a person must “actively dissociate” themselves from the commission of the crime in order to escape liability. At the hearing, CALS conceded that this may be a step too far. Therefore the Court did not deal with these additional submissions.</p><p><strong>THE COURT’S DECISION</strong></p><p>The Constitutional Court delivered <a href="http://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZACC/2019/48.html#_ftn38">three judgments</a>. Below I summarise the salient points of each judgment. The main judgment was written by Mathopo AJ, the second judgment by Justice Khampepe and the last judgment by written by Victor AJ. These judgments are beautifully and powerfully written. I would encourage you to read the full decision.</p><blockquote>“Rape has survived as long as it has because it works to keep patriarchy intact. It communicates clearly who matters and who is disposable. Those who matter are not afraid of being raped because they have been taught safety. Rape is the communication of patriarchal power, reigning in, enforcing submission and punishing defiance. It is an extreme act of aggression and of power, always gendered and enacted against the feminine. The feminine may not always be embodied in a woman’s body; it may be enacted against a child of any gender, a man who is considered inappropriately masculine and any gender non-confirming people.” — Professor Pumla Dineo Gqola, Rape: A South African Nightmare.</blockquote><p>The main judgment in reaching its decision elaborated on the relationship between rape and power. The court held that “[t]o characterise [rape] simply as an act of a man inserting his genitalia into a female’s genital is unsustainable.” The Court highlighted that in cases of gang rape — as in this case — the presence of a group of men results in power and dominance being exerted. Moreover, the main judgment affirmed that rape is not purely a crime about sex, it also about the perpetuation of patriarchy and rape culture.</p><p>The main judgment concluded that agreeing with applicants that the doctrine of common purpose does not apply would do a grave injustice to direct and indirect victims of GBV. The inapplicability of the doctrine would — as the court concluded — give power to men or perpetrators who rape womxn with the knowledge that the doctrine does not apply.</p><p>In rejecting the argument about instrumentality in the context of rape, the main judgment held that “there is no reason why the use of one’s body should be determinative in the case of rape but not in the case of other crimes such as murder and assault”. Further, the main judgment held that instrumentality has no place in our society founded upon the Bill of Rights as it is obsolete and must be discarded as it&#39;s founded on patriarchal norms, which treated womxn as chattels. Additionally, the Court held that instrumentality ignores the fact that rape can be committed by more than one person.</p><p>In terms of the doctrine of common purpose, the main judgment held that its main purpose is “to overcome an otherwise unjust result which offends the legal convictions of the community, by removing the element of causation from criminal liability and replacing it, in appropriate circumstances, with imputing the deed (actus reus) which caused the death (or other crimes) to all the co-perpetrators.”</p><p>The main judgment found that the applicants knowingly participated in the activities of the group and fully associated themselves with the criminality. Therefore, there is no reason to treat the ones who penetrated differently to the ones who did not. The Court found that “the perpetrators were all complicit and acted in cahoots.”</p><p>The main judgment spoke about the role of courts in fighting against the scourge of GBV. The main judgment stated that the Constitutional Court and other courts, by extension, “would be failing in its duty if it does not send out a clear and unequivocal pronouncement that the South African Judiciary is committed to developing and implementing sound and robust legal principles that advance the fight against gender-based violence in order to safeguard the constitutional values of equality, human dignity and safety and security.”</p><p><strong>THE SECOND JUDGEMENT</strong></p><p>In Chapter 2 of <em>Rape: A South African Nightmare,</em> Professor Pumla Dineo Gqola asks the simple question, “What’s race got to do with rape?”. The simple answer is — everything. The chapter offers a historical perspective of understanding rape demonstrating how “the rape of Black women was central to slavery, colonialism and it is, as Sue Armstrong points out, a legacy of the past that stretched into the present, beyond the boundaries of apartheid. She ends the chapter by arguing that “Black women are the most likely to be raped because of these combined histories about who matters least…”.</p><p>Rape has everything to do with race and I am glad that Justice Khampepe in her judgment elevated this notion. She starts off her judgment with a quote from Alice Walker.</p><blockquote>“Who knows what the black woman thinks of rape? Who has asked her? Who cares?”</blockquote><p>In a footnote, possibly the best footnote in the judgment, she writes:</p><blockquote>“Rape is a scourge that affects women of all races, classes and sexual orientations, but we know that in South Africa rape has a pernicious effect on black women specifically. To erase the racial element in this epidemic is to erase the experiences of the women of that horrendous night. This “intersectional erasure” is a rhetorical gesture that not only negates the lived experience of women at these intersections of oppressed identities but also means that our response to the crisis will always be deficient and under-inclusive. Speaking of rape on these terms is not a preoccupation with personal identity but an analysis of the ways in which power impacts particular women. The quote’s simple purpose in opening this judgment is to centre the experiences of the women in this case and also the most marginalised in our society.”</blockquote><p>This acknowledgement by the second judgment is important because it recenters womxn who are pushed to the margins. It also makes a statement that the court is aware of the context we live in as well as the ways rape and GBV impact largely Black womxn of all classes, sexual orientations and gender identities. It enables us to put Black womxn at the front of the conversation of rape and GBV.</p><p>Professor Gqola in her introduction to Rape writes “How we speak about and respond to violence matters”. In her first chapter she asserts that “rape is not a moment but a language”, Justice Khampepe in her judgment demonstrates this aptly.</p><p>She starts off her judgment by stating that rape is often mischaracterised as being an act of sexual intercourse, absent of consent, committed by inhumane monsters. She states that this type of mischaracterisation of rape is dangerous, she writes:</p><blockquote>“[w]ords matter. Words give a construction of a certain viewpoint of the world, and this viewpoint tends to be gendered. Although rape is defined as an unlawful and intentional act of sexual penetration of one person by another, without consent, it must be buttressed that the victim does not experience rape as being sexual at all. The requirement of sexual penetration is a legal requirement which relates to the biological element of sexual intercourse. For many victims and survivors of rape, they ‘do not experience rape as a sexual encounter but as a frightening, life-threatening attack’ and ‘as a moment of immense powerlessness and degradation.’”</blockquote><p>She continues:</p><blockquote>“Rape, at its core, is an abuse of power expressed in a sexual way. It is characterised with power on one side and disempowerment and degradation on the other. Without more being said, we know which gender falls on which side.”</blockquote><p>She goes further to dispel the notion of “REAL MEN DO NOT RAPE”. She writes:</p><blockquote>“The notion that rape is committed by sexually deviant monsters with no self-control is misplaced. Law databases are replete with cases that contradict this notion. Often, those who rape are fathers, brothers, uncles, husbands, lovers, mentors, bosses and colleagues. We commune with them. We share stories and coffee with them. We jog with them. We work with them. They are ordinary people who lead normal lives.”</blockquote><p>She continues to say:</p><blockquote>“Terming rapists as monsters and degenerates tend to normalise the incidents of rape committed by men we know because they are not “monsters” — they are rational and well-respected men in the community. Yes, the abominable behaviour of these men is abhorrent and grotesque and the recognition that they are human does not seek to evoke sympathy — it serves to signify a switch from characterising rapists as out-of-control monsters, and centres the notion that rapists are humans who choose to abuse their power. The idea that rape is committed by monsters and animals may have adverse effects in that it may lead to the reinforcement of rape myths and stereotypes. For instance, labelling of this nature may lead to cognitive dissonance when the actual rapist does not match the description of rapists. It has been said that this cognitive dissonance leads to the problematic questions like “person X is a good man, what happened to cause him to rape?” These questions have the effect of then centring the actions of the victims and not those of the actual rapist. This in turn reinforces the prevalent rape culture in South Africa and safeguards the patriarchal norms which normalise incidents of rape.”</blockquote><p>She powerfully states that “you cannot tell that someone is a rapist by their mere physical appearance or their standing in the community or their relationship to you.” By determining what a rapist should look like “may obscure the wider targets of our response to the scourge by narrowing our focus onto abhorrent individuals as opposed to dismantling an abhorrent system.”</p><p>She continues to cite crime statistics for 2018 -2019 and says that these statistics “illustrates that rape is not rare, unusual and deviant. It is structural and systemic.” This acknowledgement by the Court is of paramount importance, it is indeed structural. The second judgment also recognised that rape not only affects the victim or survivor but also the people affected by the rape.</p><p>This means in order to reduce incidents of rape in South Africa, structures need to change. It means that we need to understand consent in the context of sexual interactions for example. Dr Tlaleng Mofokeng, in her book Dr T: A Guide to Sexual Health and Pleasure, states that “consent for sexual contact consists of more than a ‘yes’ or ‘no’.” She writes that it must involve the details of condom use, what kind of sexual positions will be involved, what body parts will be used. She writes “consent is mandatory, it is not sexy” and further on she writes “consent is compulsory and it always matters, regardless of the relationship status, irrespective of whether you’ve had sex with that person before and regardless of how adventurous you have been in the past.”</p><p>The second judgment powerfully reflects on structure changes within the criminal justice system. Justice Khampepe refers to Justice Sachs when he said</p><blockquote>“The ineffectiveness of the criminal justice system . . . sends an unmistakable message to the whole of society that the daily trauma of vast numbers of women counts for little.”</blockquote><p>This judgment, for me at least, seems to be the most important one. It speaks about the complicity of language, stereotypes and structural ineffectiveness contributing to rape culture. It is a clarion call for all parties to be involved in ending GBV. It requires, as stated by Justice Khampepe “the Executive, the Legislature and the Judiciary as well as our communities.” It reminds me of the historic judgment in <a href="http://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZACC/2018/16.html"><em>Levenstein and Others v Estate of the Late Sidney Lewis Frankel and Other</em></a><em>s, </em>where the Constitutional Court held that</p><blockquote>“The criminal justice system should play a role that supports the survivors of crimes involving sexual violence and create mechanisms that would encourage them to come forward more so in view of the fact that such crimes have become prevalent these days.”</blockquote><p><strong>THE THIRD JUDGMENT</strong></p><p>The third judgment was written by Victor AJ. She explains that she wrote the concurring judgment for two reasons. First, she wanted to engage insights from feminist legal theory that was raised in argument. Second, the use of international law in developing common purpose.</p><p>In relation to her first reasoning, she writes :</p><blockquote>“A historical overview of these legal barriers in our South African jurisprudence demonstrates a number of embedded patriarchal gender norms in the procedural rules of evidence in relation to rape. This Court has recognised this, for example in<em> Masiya</em>, where Nkabinde J referred to the statutory developments in the definition of the crime of rape in recent decades.”</blockquote><p>She cites examples of how patriarchal gender norms existed in the law. The examples include a rule that a husband could not rape his wife, which was thankfully abolished in 1993, the cry rule, which required a victim of rape to make a loud outcry after the rape. She speaks about the cautionary rule. This rule warned judicial officers that the evidence of certain witnesses, such as complainants in cases dealing with sexual assault/ crimes could not safely be relied upon without corroboration. As <a href="https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2018-10-10-patriarchal-procedure-the-hidden-problems-with-criminalising-the-identification-of-suspects-in-sexual-matters/">Jameeah Omar</a> explains “[t]he cautionary rule meant that aJameelah rape complainant’s testimony needed to be treated “with caution”. This was because we had adopted the <a href="https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=326260">English Law assumption that women</a> (who were the predominant victims of sexual offences) were prone to hysteria and malicious complaints.” This only was only critiqued by the SCA in 1998.</p><p>Another explanation that I can think of is the cross-examination of Cheryl Zondi, the first witness, at the rape trial of Timothy Omotoso. She was crossed examined by Peter Daubermann. Daubermann asked Zondi more than twice how many centimetres Omotoso had penetrated her after she specifically said he had only partially penetrated her vaginally. This type of question is contrary to the Criminal Procedure Act as well as constitutional rights.</p><p>Advocate Ngcukaitobi, in relation to this cross-examination, said cross-examination was an engine for truth verification and specifically said this about the cross-examination in the Omotoso trial:</p><blockquote>“It’s not an engine or an instrument of terror and an instrument of intimidation. It’s an instrument for verification of truth and that is where the line must be drawn, once it exceeds that function, then it becomes abusive and that is where I think in this case, counsel actually strayed. You can even look at some of the questions asked, it’s one thing to ask if there was penetration or not but it’s another thing to ask the degree of the penetration because penetration is penetration in the context of a rape case”</blockquote><p>Victor AJ relates these patriarchal norms to instrumentality and the doctrine of common purpose. She writes that the application of the doctrine of common purpose in the context of rape “may herald the end of sexism in rape trials.” Later on, in the judgment she recognises that there is “still a lot of work to be done”. Further, she writes that “[deconstruction of patriarchy should not only be a victim-centred societal project but it should also break down structures that enhance patriarchal practices that in turn give rise to gender-based violence”. She continues to say that in order to achieve this we must focus on “intersectionality”. She cites Crenshaw to argue that “the violence that many women experience is often shaped by other dimensions of their identities, such as race and class”.</p><p>My work is particularly focused on expanding our understanding of intersectionality. I would have loved to see the second and the third judgment engage more deeply with intersectionality. In particular, the role of geographical space when we think about GBV. Location plays an important role in how we can understand violence. Think about the experiences of Black lesbians in townships. Think of Noxolo Xakeka, Eudy Simelane, Noxolo Nogwaza and many others who will remain undocumented. The location they were in substantially influenced their experience of violence.</p><p>In terms of International Law, Victor AJ cited the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women and the Protocol to the African Charter on Human and People’s Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa to speak about the states obligation to enact laws to protect womxn. She highlighted that the introduction of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Act infused international law and that this Act eliminated the instrumentality in our law on rape.</p><p>This judgment coming out of the Highest Court in the land has changed the law on rape. It has stated that common purpose applies to rape cases, which means that people who have a prior agreement whether expressed or implicit will be held liable for rape. It also means that in the absence of prior agreement, where it can be proven that people actively associated themselves with the rape, they too will be guilty of rape. For me, this judgment will go a long way in fighting against rape culture and ensuring that people do not do things with impunity.</p><p>While I think this judgment is a step in the right direction, I think a lot still needs to be done in terms of ensuring that GBV is reported.</p><p>The Court is often the last stage in criminal matters. Reform needs to take place much earlier. We need to start thinking strategically about prevention, how can we ensure that heinous crimes like rape do not occur? It starts with dismantling patriarchal masculinity. We also need to start thinking about responses. We know that cisgender heterosexual womxn already have difficulties reporting GBV because of various structures, and it is even more so for queer and trans people, because of the heterosexism and queerphobia. How do we end this? We need better police officers, who will not ask people what they were wearing and other such intrusive questions. We need rape kits to be readily available and for health practitioners and medical staff to explain the process of the J88 and its importance. And for me, before anything, we need to BELIEVE rape victims.</p><blockquote>As Professor Pumla rightly asserts: “rape is not a moment it is a language.” I hope that this judgment will add to the vocabulary of rape language and that its words will be empowering. I hope that it communicates that we are coming for all the rapists and those who promote rape culture.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2c14aa116cd1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Stains of grief: another year without you.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/stains-of-grief-another-year-without-you-d512352b6c95?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d512352b6c95</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[grief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Oct 2019 05:42:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-03T07:11:09.196Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Stains of grief</p><blockquote>‘this grief —</blockquote><blockquote>this rugged thing —</blockquote><blockquote>it is ugly all over</blockquote><blockquote>and I got it all over everything’ — Ashlee Haze, this spot just won’t come out</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*1NsO43k6AHxY0AUgLGixhg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Tania, my mother and Sister Velda at my first graduation</figcaption></figure><p>Dear Mama,</p><p>I have not gone back to see you since we lowered your lifeless body into the dusty hole — your final resting place. In many ways, the trip back home to your graveside will be a confirmation that you are no longer here and I’m not sure if that is a reality I want to own. Yes, mama, I know. In reality I am fully aware that it has been two years since passed, but my body has not accepted that fate.</p><p>There is so much to tell you, so much to share, things to laugh about and things to celebrate. Your daughter will be finishing her first degree in two months. She was just in her second year when we lost you and now she will be in graduating. It is a bittersweet moment. We are happy that she is finishing despite all the hardships, but in the same breath, we are sad because you will not be here to see her walk on that stage and receive the fruits of your labour. That is what they are, our achievements. They are the consequence of your commitment to ensuring that we become people who have degrees even though you left school in standard 9 to take care of your family. You remain one of the most intelligent people I know. You were my Pan-Africanist library. A feminist. A linguist.</p><p>Our lives are a testimony of how you weaved magic from nothing, how you created beautiful lives with little or no help from the men who are said to have helped you create us. Your parenting molded us into who we are becoming. I know it was not easy to raise us, but I am grateful that you did it in the way that you did.</p><p>Graduation will always be weird for me. You were meant to here for my previous one, the one that would have taken you overseas for the first time but two months into that degree, we laid you to rest. My experience of LA is tainted by stains of grief. I felt your absence acutely then but more viscerally now that I am home and you aren’t.</p><p>I am raising your children without you and it is really the strangest thing to do. They both remind me of you, often when we spend time together I get to spend time with you. I appreciate that time but sometimes, I would rather have you instead. There is an absence I cannot fill.</p><p>Lately, I have been thinking a lot about you and my activism work. I wondered a lot about where this passion and fire to end injustice comes from and then one day when I was alone, mourning you, you whispered to me. It comes from you. I can see you a lot in the work that I do. It feels like I am invoking you. You fought injustice a lot, in your community especially. You were a lighthouse for a number of people in your community. You were determined to ensure that womxn in your community do not go unheard. It was magical to watch you operate and command respect from people. I wish that you fought for yourself more. I wish you showed up for yourself more.</p><p>Mama, I am glad that there are parts of you that remain throughout my life. I am happy that in some ways you are here. In <em>all about love</em>, a book that has helped me deal with your loss, bell hooks writes: “Love is the only force that allows us to hold one another close beyond the grave… Sometimes we invoke the dead by allowing wisdom they have shared to guide our present actions. Or we through reenacting one of their habits of being.” She continues to name this way of grieving as “a way to give homage to our dead, to hold them.”</p><p>I am grateful for her words, they have enabled me to see that I am holding you in my work.</p><p>Mama, I have been struggling with my grief. It has felt insurmountable and often enfeebling. It is a stain that does not seem to want to go away. Ashlee Haze opens her collection of poems with this poem. Her words resonate deeply with me. she writes:</p><blockquote>my father died</blockquote><blockquote>and every morning I wake up with grief outstretched</blockquote><blockquote>covering me like an extra blanket</blockquote><blockquote>grief dripping down the walls</blockquote><blockquote>grief rising from my clothes like cheap perfume</blockquote><blockquote>grief stuck under my shoes like stepped-in gum</blockquote><blockquote>grief in the crevices of my teeth</blockquote><blockquote>grief spilled on the rug I just bought</blockquote><blockquote>this grief —</blockquote><blockquote>this rugged thing —</blockquote><blockquote>it is ugly all over</blockquote><blockquote>and I got it all over everything</blockquote><p>I have been ashamed of grieving for so long. It is bell hooks through her writing who told me not to feel shame. In her book, she writes: “Love knows no shame. To be loving is to be open to grief, to be touched by sorrow even sorrow that is unending…. When we lose someone we love, we can grieve without shame.” I am learning this and it has liberated me.</p><p>I am sad that you are no longer here. I am sad that you will not be witness to so many milestones that each of us will achieve. That hurts me, Mama. I miss your smile. I miss your food. The way you cooked your streamed bread so that we could have it with that delicious chicken stew. I miss your crispy tasty fish with homemade chips. I miss your pap le mogodu that you would cut so finely because you knew I hated the texture of uncut mogodu. I especially miss your boisterous laugh, the one that came from the belly. I find myself even missing the not so nice times, those were hard but at least you were still here.</p><p>I hope that in years to come, I will write more letters to you, to share with you where your children are and how they are changing the world. To share with you even the little things like how books have shaped me and changed my life. I know how much you enjoyed reading. I know that this I share with you too. Mama, I run a literary podcast and it has given me the opportunity to connect with authors in ways I never imagined. Sitting here right now, writing to you made me think about how I should have told you about this and made you listen to it while you were this here. I regret not telling you.</p><p>I hope that in years to come I will write to you to honour your life by naming the legacies that you left behind.</p><p>I hope to always remember that “Love invites us to grieve for the dead as a ritual of mourning and as celebration”</p><p>I love you.</p><p>And I miss you, a little more each day.</p><p>Your son,</p><p>Tlhogi.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d512352b6c95" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Simon Nkoli Memorial Lecture 2018: Reading the Past into the Future]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/simon-nkoli-memorial-lecture-2018-reading-the-past-into-the-future-8b53fa646ea8?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b53fa646ea8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[simon-nkoli]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bev-ditsie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[constitutional-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Feb 2019 11:21:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-13T11:21:07.284Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HWMcPYf1PSQIhsQDOy5NAg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Good afternoon,</p><p>I want to take this opportunity to thank the Simon Nkoli Collective for granting me this amazing opportunity. It is not often when one gets to speak about things that are so close to one’s heart. For this reason, I feel this is a daunting task to undertake. I am going to speak on five things this afternoon. First, I will speak on humanising Simon Nkoli. Second, I will read the past into the future by historicising allyship. Third, I will speak on introduction of the equality clause in the constitution and some cases decided by the Constitutional Court on sexual orientation. Fourth, I will speak about intersectional failures in the law and LGBT histories. Lastly, I will spend some time dreaming about Black queer possibilities.</p><p><strong>1.</strong> <strong>Humanising Simon Nkoli</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.gala.co.za/resources/docs/Free_Downloads/Nkoli2.pdf">Simon Tseko Nkoli</a> was born in Soweto in 1957 and later moved to Sebokeng. While living in Sebokeng, he became involved in youth politics, becoming an active member of Congress of South African Students (COSAS) and the United Democratic Front in the fight against apartheid. A consequence of being involved in liberation politics was that Simon Nkoli found himself at the hands of the heinous apartheid criminal justice system. In 1984, at the age of 27, Simon, along with twenty-one other political leaders, was charged and tried for treason against the apartheid government. This speaks to the political nature of Simon’s life.</p><p>We also know that Simon was also political about his homosexuality. Simon was a member of the mostly white Gay Association of South Africa (GASA). Although he was openly gay at the time he was arrested, his fellow accused were not aware of his sexuality.</p><p>Simon’s imprisonment had a direct influence on South Africa’s white dominated gay rights movement. GASA claiming to be apolitical, refused to support Simon during his trial and imprisonment. Following his acquittal and release from prison in 1988, he felt that GASA as a mainly white gay organisation was not working towards the anti-apartheid struggle and had not done enough to protest his imprisonment. Consequently, in April of 1988, Simon founded the Gay and Lesbian Organisation of the Witswatersand, known as GLOW. GLOW was aimed to create an explicitly non-homophobic, non-racist and non-sexist space for gays and lesbians living in and around Johannesburg. GLOW had chapters across the city including in Hillbrow, KwaThema, Berea, Soweto and Yeoville. In 1990, GLOW organised the continent’s first Pride March with marchers chanting “We’re here, we’re queer, we’re everywhere” through the streets of Braamfontein.</p><p>The Pride march was historical. In Simon and I, a documentary directed by the muliti-talented, ever-gorgeous, queer hero and living ancestor, Bev Palesa Ditsie, she says “<em>[t]hat </em>Pride was one of the best days of my life.” Another member of GLOW, Phybia Dlamini in <em>Pride</em>, a book about Protest and Celebration, remarks:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“A Pride march in Africa! I can’t describe how affirming it is to be walking with all these people in one street and all of us singing with one voice. “Hi Hee, hi ho, homophobia has to go!” The experience is almost religious. I am meant to be one of the marshals, but once the adrenalin kicks in, I am pulled irresistibly to the front of the march.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Another marcher, Lee Randall recalls how a last-minute decision was made to prepare lots of brown paper bags with holes around the eyes so people could march anonymously if they wanted. She was afraid, as health worker, that she would encounter clients who would not see her again if they saw that she took part in the march. However, later in the march, she says she decided to pull off the brown paper she wore, and lots of other people did the same. She says there was a feeling of elation about the march.</p><p>At the meeting prior to the march, Simon gave a powerful speech, I would encourage each of us to go and listen to what he said. In his speech, he connected the struggle for gay rights and the anti-apartheid struggle, something we have come to understand as an intersectional struggle, connecting two oppressions happening simultaneously thus creating new forms of oppression. He said:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“This is what I say to my comrades in the struggle when they ask me why I waste time fighting for moffies. This is what I say to gay men and lesbians who ask me why I spend so much time struggling against apartheid when I should be fighting for gay rights. I am Black and I am gay. I cannot separate the two parts into secondary and primary struggles. In South Africa I am oppressed because I am black man and I am oppressed because I am gay. So, when I fight for my freedom I must fight against both oppressors. All those who believe in a democratic South Africa must fight against all oppression, all intolerance, all injustice. With this march gays and lesbians are entering the struggle for a democratic South Africa where everybody has equal rights and everyone is protected by law; black and white, men and women, gay and straight.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>In addition to organising the first Pride march, GLOW offered a range of resources as a community-based organisation aimed at increasing lesbian and gay visibility. It produced a monthly Glowletter featuring organizational updates, advertisements for pen pals, international gay rights news, book reviews, comics, and letters from GLOW members reacting to a range of topics. GLOW also had several working groups, including a media group, a lesbian forum, an education forum, and the AIDS working group led by Simon.</p><p>The impact of the work that Simon has done is enormous. He is rightly lauded for doing a lot for LBGT rights as well as the liberation of Black people. That said, in the litany of sources that celebrate Simon Nkoli and his legacy, I have failed to see Simon, the human. The politicising of Simon Nkoli has in some instances failed to humanise him. I want to spend some time humanising Simon Nkoli. Do you know what Simon’s favourite colour was? What type of music he listened to? Did he enjoy reading? What was his worries while he was standing trial?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e2jnEZDVI9BGX-6rJsnsBQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>You may be wondering, how I will go about humanising Simon. Simple. I am going to take you through some of the letters that Simon wrote to his lover, Roy Shepherd. <a href="https://www.gala.co.za/resources/docs/Letters_of_Simon_Nkoli.pdf">In these letters</a>, archived at GALA, we encounter the human Simon.</p><p>Simon loved and missed Roy dearly. In a letter dated 23 May 1985, Simon writes</p><blockquote><strong>“I remember the first time I met you at Gay Christian Community. When I moved in stay with you. It was so gentle. As sweet as summer shine, as warm as the dew of the rosy of yours. I remember those days I used to find myself in your arms. Those eyes who used to look at me. They only wanted to see me — only me. Roy I was yours.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>In another letter, he writes “Oh! Roy you’re a special gift from God…. I am so excited and wish to be with you.” In December 1985, Simon writes “I love you, and your letters keep me going. Every time I receive a letter from you I’ve got reason to live for you.”</blockquote><p>These letters give us insight into Simon and his fondness for Roy and how important Roy was in keeping him sane while he was in prison. In a way, Roy was Simon’s lifeline.</p><p>Simon was also saddened by the treatment of GASA. In a letter dated 23 May 1985, he writes “My dear me, you know I sometimes think what GASA saying about me. Do you think they are going to expel me from the association? And what about the Saturday Group doing? Probably died… In another letter, dated 5 December 1985, “My beloved Roy, GASA has done nothing for me since I was arrested… That has frustrated me a little and I know you are not going to be happy to hear such a story from me…” On 2 August 1986, Simon writes “what are the gay related matters Gasa wanted me to be arrested for? Sodomy? Loitering? Public indecency or what? I am absolutely mad to read about me being arrested on “irrelevant” issues to gay related matters”. In this letter, we can see how Simon speaks about the intersectional failures of GASA in placing gay rights above anti-apartheid work. In their minds, the two could not be linked and create an interlocking oppression in Simon’s life. He was seething that he writes in a letter dated 2 September “That’s why I become too scared when GASA started debating about me as if I used to live. I am still living… I am sorry to tell you that I have decided to resign from GASA as soon as I come out”. The lack of intersectional understanding of struggle lead to Simon started GLOW.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WvAoePOIB6pydAEXcFogww.jpeg" /></figure><p>Simon, like many of us, enjoyed reading. Simon requested, and read, several books by romance novelist Danielle Steel. South African and international supporters sent him other sorts of books as well, and he records in the letters having read The Trial by Franz Kafka, the Women’s Room by Marilyn French, The Persian Boy by Mary Renault, The Boys on the Rock By John Fox, Another Country by James Baldwin, amongst others. Simon dreamed of being a published writer himself. He writes <em>“the book where I will use your name will be entitled “Love Hangover” or “The Esctasy”… where Elvis (myself) had everything I wanted. A handsome boyfriend…rich and adored him</em>.”</p><p>Simon also relied on music to keep his spirits up. He listened to the radio and to cassettes that he had been sent. He requested, among others, music by Jennifer Rush, Peter Tosh, Grace Jones, and Gladys Knight and the Pips. He writes in one letter <strong>“<em>the music is the only thing that makes me feel happy during lonely times and it makes days to pass by as well”</em></strong></p><p>The letters are where I encounter Simon’s humanity. I often return to these letters to see Simon, to read his words and even for a moment to see Simon through his own eyes. These letters have given me a glimpse of the complexity of his life. They gave me an insight into his fears, his hopes, his dreams and his insecurities. Simon, for me, was more than the politics he held. Simon was a lover of books, music, board games, loved looking good, he was very precise about this dress sense. Simon was full spectrum person and sometimes when we politicise him, we forget this.</p><p><strong>2.</strong> <strong>Historicising Allyship</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*zxffMdSOUu9mfWRG.jpg" /></figure><p>There are many discussions on social media and in our circles about what allyship means and what it looks like. I thought it would be important in reading the past into the future, to spend some time historicising allyship. In the 1980s, an unassuming house in Kwa-Thema became a safe haven for the LBGT community. This house belonged to Thokozile Khumalo, affectionately known as <a href="http://www.historyworkshop.org.uk/radical-objects-mathokos-post-box-the-birth-of-the-black-lgbt-movement-in-south-africa/ma-thoko-house/">Mathoko</a>, who, for at least, a decade opened her home and her heart to countless young people. Mathoko was a heterosexual womxn. Vusi Norman Msiza, a gay man, writes:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“In Legodi street, lived the legendary MaThoko…who opened her house to gay and lesbian kids thrown out by their families. There were said to be 30 gay boys living under the roof at one point.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Mathoko’s house and her post box served as a key communication mode for the emerging LGBT movement. The house also become a gathering place to debate, strategise and party. It was a place of refuge. Mathoko’s house became the headquarters of the Kwa-Thema branch of GLOW. It was one of the most vibrant and active chapters. In an interview before he passed on, Simon recalls how MaThoko would provide emotional support for young LGBT people. He said “she did a lot of counselling for gay people. They would come with to her with problems — personal problems, organisational problems or whatever. She would also talk to other woman whose children were lesbian and gay… I think that is why KwaThema chapter was so strong.” In an earlier interview, Simon said: “KwaThema gays and lesbians have a place to go — MaThoko’s. It is her active role in the movement that earned MaThoko a second nickname: MaGLOW”.</p><p>MaThoko’s house was the primary point of contact for many young people coming to terms with their sexuality or gender identity. Her impact extended beyond the township’s borders: her post box allowed people from across South Africa and the world to connect with GLOW. Mathoko’s postbox helped LGBT people to connect at a time when homosexuality was illegal and highly stigmatised. This house and its postbox served as a beacon of hope for a group of people marginalised not just because of their sexuality, but also because of race, gender, gender identity, gender expression, disability and class. Her home was a place of business and organising but also of celebration and community, and it is remembered today as a place where the LGBT movement found its feet. MaThoko died in 1993, before South Africa before a constitutional democracy, but her memory and spirit lives on.</p><p>For me, this is the type of allyship I envisioned for LGBT people. It is so much more than retweets or “I stand with them”. I am not miminising the work that people do as on social media, but I think that allyship is more than a social media post. MaThoko, to my mind, epitomises allyship for LGBT people. MaThoko was more than just a place of refuge. She was, as Phumi Mtetwa puts it, “a counsellor, as support worker, an ally and, of course, a mother. She was a woman with a good heart.”</p><p>In Simon and I, Bev recalls that after the first Pride March, she was seen on tv and two days later while sitting in her room, she heard voices outside calling her name. She ran into the lounge and her granny opened the door and told her to hide. About twenty angry men were surrounding the house and demanded she go with them, so they could teach her a lesson. They wanted to rape her and possibly kill her. Gender Based Violence is a ubiquitous in this country but to be Black, womxn and queer in the township creates an intersectional struggle as you are constantly in danger. Bev always tell the story of how she feels safe in her community where she grew up: Soweto. She always tells me this story of how the cisgender heterosexual men in her community protect her. There was one incident where an angry mob of men came looking for Bev because they wanted to ‘uproot the homosexual spirit’ from the community. It was the unassuming cisgender heterosexual men who stood up and told the angry mob to leave Bev alone. They said: “she is one of us and you will not harm her”. This is also a manifestation of allyship. To take up the responsibility to protect LGBT people in your community and to ensure that they are safe because you are there.</p><p><strong>3.</strong> <strong>Equality clause</strong></p><blockquote>I would now like to move on to the more thematic considerations. In a June 1992 newsletter, Tanya, the secretary of GLOW at the time, wrote that GLOW needed to concentrate on pressing issues such as working towards a gay rights clause in the new South African constitution rather than “partying”. GLOW played an important role in the fight for the inclusion of a clause protecting South Africans from discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. Political lobbying towards inclusion of the clause began as early as 1990. Edwin Cameron, now a Justice of the Constitutional Court, at the first Pride meeting said:</blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>“This meeting and march today has a message — a message to all law makers and the constitution makers of South Africa. The message is that the criminal law is for criminals. Gays and Lesbians are not criminals. Being gay or lesbian is part of being human. To criminalise gays and lesbians is to criminalise a part of society.” ­</em></strong></blockquote><p>GLOW, under the umbrella organisation National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality, founded in 1993, prepared submission to the Constitutional Assembly in support of the equality clause. In 1996, South Africa adopted an equality clause which explicitly prohibits unfair discrimination on the sexual orientation among other things such as race and gender.</p><p>The first case in which the Constitutional Court had to engage the right to be free from discrimination based on sexual orientation related to the common law crime of sodomy, and other related legislative offences. The Court held in the first <em>National Coalition </em>case that:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“The concept ‘sexual orientation’ as used in section 9(3) of the 1996 Constitution must be given a generous interpretation of which it is linguistically and textually fully capable of bearing. It applies equally to the orientation of persons who are bi-sexual, or transsexual and it also applies to the orientation of persons who might on a single occasion only be erotically attracted to a member of their own sex.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>The Court held that the crime of sodomy was unfair discrimination as the impact it had on men was severe, as the purpose of the offence was to criminalise sex between consenting adults which causes no harm to others, and as it gravely affects the dignity of gay men.</p><p>Following from there, a whole host of cases extended the benefits accorded to married persons to people in homosexual relationships. In the second <em>National Coalition </em>case, the Court held that a provision of the Aliens Control Act which only extended an entitlement to residence permits to foreign “spouses” of South African citizens amounted to unfair discrimination, as it excluded foreign partners in same-sex life partnerships where the other partner was a South African citizen; that, despite the fact that by law the same-sex partners could not marry. The Court held that the provision “constitute[d] overlapping or intersecting discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation and marital status, both being specified in section 9(3).”</p><p>The Court pointed out that the message given out by the legislation was —</p><blockquote><strong><em>“that gays and lesbians lack the inherent humanity to have their families and family lives in such same-sex relationships respected or protected. It serves in addition to perpetuate and reinforce existing prejudices and stereotypes.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>The types of stereotypes being reinforced by the legislation were that homosexual relationships are merely sexual in nature with little of the ‘family oriented’ characteristics of marriage, such as love, affection and companionship, and that homosexual relationships are incapable of procreating. The Court pointed out that taken together this all has the effect of “constitut[ing] a crass, blunt, cruel and serious invasion of [the] dignity” of gay and lesbian people.</p><p>Following on from this case, the Constitutional Court: extended the benefits of joint adoption to same-sex couples; afforded to same-sex couples the entitlement to be registered as the parents of children born from artificial insemination; extended to same-sex life partners of homosexual Judges the benefits enjoyed by Judges’ spouses in terms of laws governing the remuneration of Judges.</p><p>Ultimately in <em>Fourie</em> the Constitutional Court declared the Marriage Act to be unconstitutional as it unfairly discriminated against homosexual people on the basis of their sexual orientation. The Court said:</p><blockquote>“The exclusion of same-sex couples from the benefits and responsibilities of marriage, accordingly, is not a small and tangential inconvenience resulting from a few surviving relics of societal prejudice destined to evaporate like the morning dew. It represents a harsh if oblique statement by the law that same-sex couples are outsiders, and that their need for affirmation and protection of their intimate relations as human beings is somehow less than that of heterosexual couples. It reinforces the wounding notion that they are to be treated as biological oddities, as failed or lapsed human beings who do not fit into normal society, and, as such, do not qualify for the full moral concern and respect that our Constitution seeks to secure for everyone. It signifies that their capacity for love, commitment and accepting responsibility is by definition less worthy of regard than that of heterosexual couples.”</blockquote><p>In no small measure, this decision was the culmination of the long line of Constitutional Court judgments that — over time — were chipping away at discrimination based on sexual orientation in the context of marriage and homosexual life partnerships.</p><p>The Court ordered Parliament to remedy the constitutional defect. Parliament enacted the Civil Union Act which provides for and regulates the conclusion of civil unions between heterosexual and homosexual couples.</p><p>The Civil Union Act was enacted more than a decade ago. It is a legislation that is said to be for queer people, but many writers have written about how it is not a true case of inequality. I want to highlight three things that are problematic with the Civil Union Act. First, homosexual couples can only solemnise their unions in terms of the Civil Union Act while heterosexual couples can formalise their unions either in terms of the Civil Union Act, the Marriage Act, or the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act. This, to my mind means, that the law does not recognise that Black queer people may want to get married in accordance to the customs and traditions. It creates the impress that the law supports the ubiqutious notion that homosexuality is unAfrican and a colonial import. This creates a “separate but equal” regime of marriage. Moreover, this regime is in direct conflict with the directives in the <em>Fourie </em>judgment — which specifically told Parliament not to create a separate regime, but we are here a decade later. Second, section 6 of the Civil Union Act infringes homosexual couples’ constitutional rights of dignity and equality. Section 6 provides that marriage officers can write to the Minister stating that they cannot marry homosexual people because of religion, conscience and belief. This section has made it harder for homosexual people to get married. A number of cases have been reported where Home Affairs officers have refused to marry people or told them that they only had certain dates for homosexual people to get married. This section is likely to be changed soon as COPE has initiated an amendment process. Third, the Civil Union Act does not allow minor homosexual children to get married in terms of the Civil Union Act, while heterosexual children can get married in terms of the Marriage Act.</p><p>More generally, while marriage equality is important, the reality of most Black queer people is not to get married. In contrast, as seen in the Fourie case, our white counterparts fought to access rights that are freely given to heterosexuals. Expanding marriage to include a narrow band of same-sex couples only strengthens the system of marginalisation and supports the idea that the state should pick which type of families to reward and recognise and which to punish and endanger.</p><p>A quick survey of all the cases dealing with sexual orientation reveal most of the parties are white queers, the question is where are the Black queers? The truth and the reality is: most Black queer are in the different locale dying. We remember all the Black queers who were killed both known and those who remain unknown.</p><p>We know the stories of Black queer people who have died because of their sexuality. Recently, a prosecutor argued that a Black lesbian womxn was not killed because she was lesbian, effectively citing other reasons. But the reality about most of the killing of our fellow queer family is that they were killed because of their sexuality. I want to live in a country where Black queer people are safe, where they have the right to be Black, African, queer. I want to live in a country that understand the heinous ways in which Black lesbian womxn have died and to do something about it. I want to live in a country where Black queer people can step into work in their fullness and not hide or diminish parts of themselves. I want to live in a country where Black trans people do not have to spend a lot of money and time to change their gender marker and names on their identity documents. I want to live in a country, where Black queer people have affirming health care. I want to live in a society, where we can be free to be who we are, not to get the crumbs from society’s table.</p><p><strong>4.</strong> <strong>Intersectional failures</strong></p><p>I also want to spend some time talking about the intersectional failures of the telling of LGBT histories. Simon’s role and story has been one that dominates the telling of South Africa’s LGBT history. I am not suggesting that his story and work are not remarkable, they are. However, his story is sometimes told at the expenses of others. If I asked you if there was a co-chair in the history of GLOW, would you be able to tell me? If I asked you about what happened on 13 September 1995, would you be able to tell me? I think a few people may know. The uncomfortable truth is that we have erased Black queer womxn in the telling of LGBT history in South Africa. Bev Ditsie and Phumi Mtetwa, too name only some, worked alongside Simon in pushing gay and lesbian issues to the forefront, yet we rarely talk about them. Some initial GLOW members even credit Bev with the idea of having the first Pride. Allow me to talk a little more about Bev as an illustration of the erasure. She has been reduced to a footnote in anything about Simon Nkoli. But Bev is not a footnote. Bev was a co-chair of GLOW. She was instrumental in lobbying for the equality clause by running workshops, writing articles and doing public appearance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7PQehOD99pJy0oa9s16jNg.jpeg" /></figure><p>On 13 September 1995, Bev was invited to the fourth UN conference on womxn held in Beijing. Her decision to go to the conference was not supported by some GLOW members, including Simon. Why is her attendance at the conference significant for LGBT rights? Let me read some parts her address and allow you to make up your own mind.</p><pre>“The Universal Declaration of Human Rights recognizes the “inherent dignity and . . . the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family,” and guarantees the protection of the fundamental rights and freedoms of all people “without distinction of any kind, such as race, color, sex, language . . . or other status” (art. 2).  Yet every day, in countries around the world, lesbians suffer violence, harassment and discrimination because of their sexual orientation.  Women who love women are fired from their jobs; forced into marriages; beaten and murdered in their homes and on the streets; and have their children taken away by hostile courts.  Some commit suicide due to the isolation and stigma that they experience within their families, religious institutions and their broader community.</pre><pre>If the World Conference on Women is to address the concerns of all women, it must similarly recognize that discrimination based on sexual orientation is a violation of basic human rights..</pre><pre>No woman can determine the direction of her own life without the ability to determine her sexuality.  Sexuality is an integral, deeply ingrained part of every human being&#39;s life and should not be subject to debate or coercion.  Anyone who is truly committed to women&#39;s human rights must recognize that every woman has the right to determine her sexuality free of discrimination and oppression.</pre><pre>I urge you to make this a conference for all women, regardless of their sexual orientation, and to recognize in the Platform for Action that lesbian rights are women&#39;s rights and that women&#39;s rights are universal, inalienable, and indivisible human rights.”</pre><p>This moment is historical, but few queer people know about the impact of Bev’s work for lesbian rights in South Africa. Bev was the first lesbian to address a UN Conference. A Black queer womxn from Soweto, surely this is the story that books should be filled with. Bev, I want to salute you and I want to let you know that I will celebrate you while you are still alive. I will ensure that books and documentaries are created about you, and all the Black womxn who worked with you because there is so much to learn about movement building and the intersectional failures we should avoid as we chart on with the queer revolution.</p><p><strong>5.</strong> <strong>Black Queer Possibilities</strong></p><p>One of my favourite writers is Audre Lorde and I feel it would be apt to quote her words at this moment. In her speech Learning from the 60s, she says:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“As Black people, if there is one thing we can learn from the 60s, it is how infinitely complex any move for liberation must be. For we must move against not only those forces which dehumanize us from the outside, but also against those oppressive values which we have been forced to take into ourselves. Through examining the combination of our triumphs and errors, we can examine the dangers of an incomplete vision. Not to condemn that vision but to alter it, construct templates for possible futures, and focus our rage for change upon our enemies rather than upon each other.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>If we are to imagine Black queer futures, we should not replicate the past. We should ponder on the insight offered by Audre Lorde. Black queer possibilities look likes defining things for ourselves, as Audre Lorde beautifully said “if I didn’t define myself for myself, I would be crunched into other people’s fantasies for me and eaten alive.” We should really ask ourselves: what does Black queer futures look like? And the answer to the question will be different for each person, because queer is not monolithic and that is its beauty. Black queer futures, for me, entails creating our own narratives. It is doing the work of intentional archiving our histories, our present, our joy (whatever they may look like). It means writing our — queer — selves into the global imagination. It is writing about how we have sex, the beauty, the glory and the not so nice. It means writing our stories — not to pathologies our pain or our suffering but to celebrate our lives. Because as Audre Lorde instructs “So it is better to speaking remembering that you were never met to survive.”</p><p>Black queer possibilities looks like including Black queer womxn and trans people and their writing as fundamental teachings in liberation movements and not as an add on. It means include their stories, analysis, praxis and wisdom as the starting point. Black queer possibilities mean allow each of us — as queer people — to tell our own stories, in our own languages and at our own pace.</p><p>In dreaming about Black queer possibilities, I want to leave you these words by Jose Munoz:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Queerness is not yet here. Queerness is an ideality. Put another way, we are not yet queer, but we can feel it as the warm illumination of a horizon imbued with potentiality. We have never been queer, yet queerness exists for us as an ideality that can be distilled from the past and used to imagine a future. The future is queerness’s domain.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Thank you.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b53fa646ea8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Grief]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/grief-5bb754b61548?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5bb754b61548</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[grief]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Dec 2018 13:48:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-10T13:50:47.385Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Grief corrodes my memories</p><p>Sitting like a lump in my throat</p><p>punching my lungs</p><p>taking my breath away</p><p>Grief is inconvenient</p><p>arriving at inopportune times</p><p>On the highway</p><p>In a meeting</p><p>On flights</p><p>At conferences</p><p>Sometimes arriving early in the morning and never leaving,</p><p>always present,</p><p>always pervasive</p><p>Grief is evasive</p><p>Always fragmenting my life</p><p>Into little pieces of sorrow</p><p>Into deathly spells</p><p>of wanting death to end all this hurt</p><p>of wanting death to neutralise all the pain</p><p>Grief arrives almost daily these days</p><p>to remind me</p><p>Of how much I’ve lost.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5bb754b61548" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Letter to my late aunt]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/letter-to-my-late-aunt-61cba653ffea?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/61cba653ffea</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grief-and-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[loss]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Dec 2018 07:32:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-10T07:32:48.905Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><strong>“For those who have never been consoled, remembering is an awful burden to bear” — Sisonke Msimang, Always Another Country</strong></blockquote><p>Dear Mamane,</p><p>It is on the evening of 10 December 2014 that you shook the foundations of my world. I vividly remember everything about this day. This week leading up this day and even the months leading up to this day. The week before you passed, you were rushed to the ICU like many times before. Only this time, you were no longer breathing on your own. I remember getting the call from my mother, telling me that things are not looking so great. I remember wailing to a friend on the phone about this news. The weekend before the fateful day, Tumelo (your son) phoned me to tell me that I need to come home, I have never experienced emotion from Tumelo but on this day, I could feel is heart. The urgency in his voice. He needed me at home. On the day, I went to work with my heart in my throat like I had done for months, because we were in and out of hospital. It was my then housemate’s birthday and we were due to celebrate with some cake. But that never happened. Instead, I received a phone call and the voice on the other line — your sister’s — uttered words that will stay with me forever, she said “Mamane has died”. In that moment, I wanted the world to stop orbiting just enough so that I can get my bearings, I was knocked off my feet and it was not a pretty sight. You had died. I actually think you died long before your physical body gave in. You die a while ago. I say this because, a month before you passed. I saw you and there was no sparkle in your eye. No life there. It was vacant.</p><p>Today is 4 years since you left us. In that mine, Refilwe (your daughter) has matriculated. Tumelo has gone back to school. I have completed another degree and lived abroad. Your sister died. She fell and died. We are all trying to piece together the remnants of you and her. We seem to be undone at the hemp.</p><p>I write to you because I miss you. I miss many things about you. Toni Morrison writes “Memory is the worst thing about healing”. She is right. I am constantly under the spell of memory in an effort to heal all the wounds inflicted by grief. I miss how we used to pray ad go to church, I do not that anymore. I pray, sometimes. I think I do it now because I still want to feel close to you. I miss the intimacy we shared while we read the Word and worshipped. I miss how you used to be certain that I was destined for greatness. Some days, I wish I could hear you say it one more time. I want to hear your voice because I think I may have forgot the melodies that settled my uneasiness. I miss the fashion shows that we had to undergo before you left the house because your image was very important to you. I miss untying your shoes after a hard day at work. I miss your stories your work places, you were always so animated about your days at what you called the madhouse. I miss you and our discussions about life and all things in between. I sit now wondering if my queerness would have gotten in the way of my relationship with me. I wonder if you would still love me the same if you knew then that I love differently but the same. I doubt things would have changed. I know that your love kept me alive. I still angry at everyone who did not make sure that you came to my first graduation. I owe that degree to you. I look fondly at my time in undergraduate and I am grateful that you were there.</p><p>I write to you to also tell you that December is here. Since your passing it has been the lonelinest time of me and I think for Refilwe as well. You loved this time of year. You would make us take out the Christmas tree and decorate it. You looked forward to spending time with family and to just be happy. I never took the time to ask you why you loved this time of year, but I wish I did. I wish I asked you so many questions. I took for granted that you would live passed 50 but you didn’t even make it to 45.</p><p>My heart is heavy and has been very for weeks now. The four months of every year are hard for me. Each year on 14 September, I remember how you phoned me to tell me that Mapu, your mother and my gran had died. On 1 October, we celebrate her birthday. On 3 October 2018, Bandusi (mama) fell and died. We celebrate her birthday on 25 November and then we mourn your demise on 10 December, I am succumbed by the weight of grief. Some days I start to cry and stop myself immediately because I am afraid there will come a day where I will never be able to stop lamenting all the loss in my life.</p><p>I also write to tell you that one of my friends reminds me of you in so many ways. Her name is Dr Tlaleng Mofokeng. Dr Tlaleng epitomises your spirit in so many ways. First, both you and her work(ed) in the medical profession. She’s a doctor and you were a nurse. She is passionate about human rights and womxn in the way that you were. She is one of most caring people I have encountered and like you, she does not do things for recognition. She is a public intellectual, a global trotter and she’s highly respected. It is not those things that make her incredible. It is the things that she does privately that make her so remarkable. She — like you — loves from deep within the crevices of her heart. She may seem aloof to many but to those close to her she is a treasure trove of all the love in the world. She is kind. She flew to celebrate my graduation with me. She brought me home after the celebration and she housed me when I was uncertain about how I was going to start living back in South Africa with all the grief. I think she feels me in her spirit, like you used to. She would call to check if I am eating because she knows on most days, memories of you, Bandusi and Mapu consume me and give me an inability to do anything. You would have really loved her. I think you are similar not only in spirit about also in how much you loved new clothes and looking good. She — like you — wants a different dress for each occasion. I have gone shopping with her and in those moments, I am grateful that I get to spend time with you.</p><p>I hope that you are resting. I know how much you wanted that. I hope that you are proud of the people we are becoming. We are realy trying our best with the little we have. I hope that this Christmas, you will restore the joy in our hearts and that you will mend our hearts even if it just for this season.</p><p>I love you, Cocosi</p><p>Your son,</p><p>Tlhogi</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=61cba653ffea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Happy Birthday, Mama.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mr_mokgoroane/happy-birthday-mama-b9ea8167fe22?source=rss-cfb847b05d3b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9ea8167fe22</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[birthday]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[@mx_mokgoroane]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Nov 2018 05:42:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-25T05:42:27.566Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/742/1*fL9d6BAeCIT5_9gBepkkiQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dear Mama,</p><p>It is the second birthday without you here. It hurts. I know that you loved celebrating birthdays for reasons unknown to me. I am sad that it is after your departure that I yearn to celebrate your birthday with you for all those unknown reasons. Some days I wonder if you were celebrating the fact that you were still alive in a world that sought to efface you; or whether you were truly grateful to be alive.</p><p>On this birthday, I am stuck in a memory. A beautiful memory. One that I wish I could return to, even if just for a moment. It is a sunny evening in the late 2000s. I think you and I were the only two people awake in the corrugated iron structure we called home. For a moment, we forgot about the crime infested township we called our neighbourhood. I was sitting down, watching you enjoy the music you were playing. You were so alive and elated when music played. In some ways, I envied how music could lift your mood. While watching you dance, Luther Vandross’ <em>Dance with my Father </em>starts playing. In that moment, you look at me, your eyes commanding and alive. You moved towards me and extended a dance, signaling me to the concrete floor you dubbed a dance floor. I stood up and accepted your hand and joined you on what we deemed a dance floor. You said words that will always stay with me. With your voice filled with loving command, you ebulliently said:</p><blockquote><strong>“Let us dance, so that one day when someone writes about dancing with their mothers, you’ve had the privilege”.</strong></blockquote><p>With you in my arms, we danced without a care in the world. Our heartbeats came one. We danced for all the times we couldn’t dance. We danced the absence of a father away. We danced to forget that poverty hung mighty on the walls. We sang and danced like our lives depended on it.</p><p>On your birthday, it is this moment that I wish to return to. A moment where you and I were dancing, and we were happy. A moment where our heartbeats pumped at the same tempo. A moment of maternal love, a tender-loving moment.</p><p>I am now sitting and trying to recall all the moments of tenderness and love. It seems that they were few and became fewer as I grew older. I think this moment I recall may be one of the very few moments where you and I held each other with tenderness. The other holdings I remember all included you consoling me about the passing of first your mother and then your sister. Those moments were filled with grief and a sense of loss for both of us.</p><p>I am trying to keep your memory alive, because I think that the best parts of me came from watching you live your life unapologetically. I want to do something on your birthday to celebrate your life. I will start by playing some of your favourite songs and perhaps then — even if for the moment you will be there too.</p><p>I love you, Mama</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/1*_z2n6ZgmzbiePdEuYFTVBA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Happy birthday.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9ea8167fe22" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>