<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by mrbs on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by mrbs on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mrbs?source=rss-4a906801801b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 15:32:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mrbs/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unsolicited Incinerator Feedback]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mrbs/unsolicited-incinerator-feedback-cc2800d368a9?source=rss-4a906801801b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc2800d368a9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[mrbs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Feb 2022 19:05:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-21T04:27:57.748Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Obviously, the main purpose of <a href="https://incineratorpod.com/">The Incinerator</a> is to foster passionate discussion about movies. Even so, I think that works better if the underlying game mechanics force real choices.</p><p>Just as obviously, the secondary purpose of The Incinerator is Billy Ray to twist the screws on his guests, and that’s much more effective when the guests aren’t tempted to take their hands off the wheel because things are too random, and they don’t have enough autonomy to feel invested.</p><p>So here’s what I’m proposing to fix:</p><ul><li>There’s no reason not to just always choose the engineer’s picks, then your opponents picks, and then anything that was “in all good conscience” saved.</li><li>Additionally, there’s no reason to be precious about the order stuff gets burned, because it’s all the same result. Just save your top one or two and <em>c’est la vie</em> the rest.</li><li>The same movie can get discussed multiple times as it bounces around and gets resurrected by a land mine</li><li>There’s no “endgame”, whoever gets the last choice is very random and not the result of clever game play.</li><li>No payoff for unmasking the engineer</li></ul><p>Below is the <a href="https://letterboxd.com/mrbs/">mrbs</a> Incinerator proposal.</p><h3>The Set-up</h3><p>Player lists are created in the same way as they are currently. The engineer will also add 5 films to the list. Secretly, the engineer will have ranked their list 1–5, and assigned 5 landmines. Players know that 3 landmines are attached to the engineer’s picks, and a landmine is attached to a pick that was unique to each player. This makes it higher risk to eliminate an engineer pick, and adds a little risk to eliminating your opponent’s picks. It also lets the engineer’s personality shine through more by showing which film eliminations they want to punish.</p><h3>Landmines</h3><p>Landmines cannot undo anything that’s already happened, and cannot change the original list of 25. This means that people don’t end up talking about the same movie three times as it comes back and is re-incinerated later. The incineration being absolute and irreversible makes it more impactful.</p><p>Landmines can be things like:</p><ul><li><strong>One-for-one:</strong> Player that trips the mine needs to also incinerate one of their unique picks (a pick of theirs that wasn’t also chosen by their opponent)</li><li><strong>Everybody hurts:</strong> The opponent of the player that trips the mine needs to choose to incinerate one shared pick.</li><li><strong>Lose a turn:</strong> Player that trips the mine loses their next turn</li><li><strong>Heat surge:</strong> The opponent of the player that trips the mine’s next choice will be burned at the higher heat level (details below)</li><li><strong>Mercy:</strong> The opponent of the player that trips the mine can select one of the remaining films to save until the next heat level (details below)</li></ul><p>Landmines can also trigger rules like those you’d find in a drinking game. These are especially fun for the engineer to tie to a player’s choice, as it’s very likely they know who will trip that mine, and craft the punishment for them specifically. This is another good way for the engineer to get more of their personality into the match.</p><p>For example, the engineer could tie a landmine to one of Phil’s unique picks so that whoever triggers it (very likely Kenny) needs to say one good thing about “The Tomas Crown Affair” every round, or they skip their next turn. Anything like that is fair game for the engineer to torture players with, as long as it doesn’t un-incinerate anything or change the list of 25.</p><h3>Incinerator</h3><p>The Incinerator is magic, but it’s not unlimited magic. As it gets used over the course of an episode, the heat levels go down, reducing the impact of the incineration. This makes it so that the order that things get burned matters, and saving a film for the next tier accomplishes something instead of just slightly delaying the inevitable. The heat levels of the incinerator are:</p><ul><li><strong>Memory burning: </strong>The incinerator’s so hot, these films are burned out of everyone’s memory. The guests don’t even get to talk about these movies. You just announce the title (and year, if needed), and that’s all that can be said about the movie for the rest of the episode. Being burned early is ROUGH.</li><li><strong>Longevity burning:</strong> The incinerator can’t completely erase a film, but it can burn it back to its opening weekend. So these films wouldn’t have a chance to become cult classics, or to be re-appraised, or to be get word of mouth, or to be shared with anyone who wasn’t around for that first weekend.</li><li><strong>Future burning:</strong> The incinerator’s almost out of juice. It can’t burn through time anymore, but it can still eliminate all copies of a movie from right now. So you won’t be able to share it with future generations, or watch it again yourself.</li></ul><h3>In All Good Conscience…</h3><p>With the different heat levels, this mechanic now serves more of a purpose. But, it’s still too painless. Instead of just uttering a phrase and cashing in a marker that has no other use; a player can choose to volunteer one of their unique picks as tribute, and replace the film that’s going to be incinerated. They can do this as often as they have unique picks to sacrifice, but the same film can only be saved by the same player once. The saved film is safe until the next heat-level, or the standoff.</p><h3>Gameplay</h3><ul><li>25 Films left: [HEAT LEVEL: Memory Burning]</li><li>20 Films left: [HEAT LEVEL: Longevity Burning]</li><li>10 Films left: [HEAT LEVEL: Future Burning]</li><li>5 Films left: Any remaining mines are revealed and disarmed</li><li>3 Films left: The Standoff</li><li>1 Film left: [HEAT LEVEL: Projection bulb] The last movie is safe, and the incinerator projects it for all the audience to watch and comment on before the next episode. [<em>Edit: Maybe you actually clip the discussion of the saved movie from the episode, and put it at the top of the next episode, so people are encouraged to watch that film w/o spoilers, and then get to hear the discussion afterwards</em>]</li></ul><h3>Standoff</h3><p>So this is the most needlessly complex part. All that needs to be explained to players/audience is that once there are only 3 films remaining, you enter a standoff, and what happens there depends on whose picks are still on the list. Players will get to flex their gameplay muscles in setting up the standoff, and negotiating their way through the standoffs. It also makes unmasking the engineer a huge power play.</p><p><em>A= Film picked only by player A; B=Film picked only by player B; C=Film picked by both A and B; E=Film added by Engineer</em></p><p><strong>The Sweeps:</strong></p><ul><li><em>A-A-A </em>or <em>A-A-E</em> or <em>A-E-E </em>If only one player has any choices (shared or unique) remaining, they get to choose which films to incinerate, and which is saved.</li><li><em>E-E-E</em> If all 3 remaining films are the Engineers, they will be incinerated/saved in order of the ranked list the engineer selected. And the player should feel shame.</li><li><em>C-C-C</em> If all 3 of the remaining films were shared picks by both players, they get to discuss. Any films that they agree on incinerating is put to rest and memorialized. If there’s a deadlock, the remaining films move to the showdown.</li></ul><p><strong>The Splits:</strong></p><ul><li><em>A-B-C</em> If each player has one unique pick and one shared pick remaining, they get to discuss. If they can come to a consensus on which film to save, the other two are incinerated and memorialized. If not, both players have the option to force the issue and immediately incinerate the shared pick [C]. The remaining films move to the showdown.</li><li><em>A-B-E</em> or <em>C-E-E</em> or <em>C-C-E</em> If the engineer has picks remaining, and each player has the same number of picks as each other, then the players discuss. Any films that they agree on incinerating is put to rest and memorialized. If there’s a deadlock, the remaining films move to the showdown.</li></ul><p><strong>The Advantage:</strong></p><ul><li><em>A-A-B</em> If PlayerA has two unique choices left, and PlayerB has one, PlayerA gets first shot at unmasking the engineer. If successful, they get to choose the order of incineration/saving. If unsuccessful, PlayerB gets a shot to unmask the engineer. If successful, PlayerB can force PlayerA to incinerate one of the As. The remaining films move on to a showdown.</li><li><em>A-A-C </em>or <em>A-C-C </em>If PlayerA has at least one unique choices and the remaining choices are shared, PlayerA can choose to incinerate one (or both) of the As. If there are still 2+ films remaining, PlayerA can then unmask the engineer. If successful, they choose who gets first turn in alternating incineration of the remaining films. If unsuccessful, PlayerB has the same chance to unmask, with the same reward. If both are unsuccessful, the remaining films move on to a showdown.</li><li><em>A-C-E </em>PlayerA has one unique pick, one shared pick, and one engineer selection left. PlayerA has the option to eliminate both A and E, saving C. PlayerA then has the option to eliminate just E. PlayerA is then given the chance to unmask the engineer. If successful, they get to choose the order of incineration/saving. If unsuccessful, the remaining films move on to a showdown.</li></ul><h3>The Showdown</h3><p>Reaching this point means neither player was able to claim a clean victory. There are either two or three films remaining, of split origin. To resolve this, a player (whoever went second at the start of the game) gets to make one guess as to the identify of the engineer (this might be a second guess, depending on how the standoff went). If successful, they choose to act first or act second in feeding the incinerator one of the remaining films. If unsuccessful, the other player gets the same opportunity. If neither unmask the engineer, Billy Ray does so, and moves on to trivia. Whoever wins the trivia round gets to choose if they act first or second.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc2800d368a9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>