<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Dominic Chave-Cox on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Dominic Chave-Cox on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@musingsofdcc?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 01:18:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@musingsofdcc/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s our flag too — So why do we act like it isn’t?]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/its-our-flag-too-so-why-do-we-act-like-it-isn-t-eec1a7e73477?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eec1a7e73477</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[flags]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patriotism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[orwell]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nationalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Apr 2021 18:47:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-06T21:16:54.093Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>It’s our flag too — So why do we act like it isn’t?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2j4dSg7ctfhTlwBs.jpeg" /></figure><p>A flag is a curious object. It can arouse the strongest of emotions in people who are normally calm, stable and rational. One individual can be moved to immense pride, tears even, just as easily as another can be stirred into a frenzied anger, while yet another experiences acute shame or embarrassment.</p><p>Most (if not all) of those reactions have been on display recently as the government has stepped up its use of flags. It’s clear that one of the reasons for this is to cause a headache for the Labour leadership by first provoking and then highlighting the antipathy many activists on the left feel towards the use of flags (especially their own), in the full knowledge that recently acquired Tory “Red Wall” voters feel differently and will be further alienated from Labour as a result. Hence why the diktat has gone out to fly the oft-misnamed Union Flag from <em>all </em>government buildings, and why the latest BBC Breakfast row has been milked for all its worth.</p><p>But Labour politicians have also recently been making use of flags in their public Zoom appearances, prompted by the result of focus group research revealing that many of Labour’s ex-voters have come to see the party as unpatriotic. As someone who has in the past called for Labour to adopt a stronger, more clearly communicated patriotism, I should be delighted at these extremely visible signs of effort, but I have to confess there is something in me troubled by the display of all those flags. Call it my <em>Rochester and Strood</em> moment.</p><p>I first started thinking that the left needed to display and communicate patriotism better after the tumultuous events of 2016 (that’s Brexit and Trump, for any goldfish who’ve made it this far down the page). My chain of thought was influenced by articles such as <a href="https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk/2016/11/closing-liberal-mind">this one</a> by John Gray. I even specifically mentioned in an article I wrote that we needed to be less uncomfortable about flags. I suppose I just hadn’t expected anyone to take advice similar to mine quite so literally, to the point of adorning their office with flags or barely ever being seen in public without one conveniently to hand.</p><p>There is definitely a degree of overkill here, but inevitably voices have started popping up complaining about “performative nationalism”, “playing with fire” or just straightforward accusations that Labour is a nationalist party now, the real McCoy rather than a cheap knock-off. I don’t think these criticisms are fair, and not just because they emanate from the usual disingenuous suspects. On its own, in a darkened room with nobody to view it, a flag is simply an inanimate object. What many of these people (and perhaps my own subconscious too) are really afraid of are the ideas, values and attitudes which certain flags have come to symbolise.</p><p>When we see a Union Flag and particularly when we see a cross of St George, our heads are suddenly flooded with connotations. Some of us may see football hooligans, or bigoted xenophobes. We may think about some of the painfully awkward moments in our country’s past. We may think of Brexit. But what we are really doing when we have this reaction is surrendering what should be a symbol of unity to those who are comfortable with some or all of those things. They assume that they own the flag, and we confirm that they are right, and willingly give it up to them.</p><p>This is disastrous, because there is no good reason why national flags must be symbols only of right-wing values, or of an exceptionalist belief that our country is somehow uniquely great and its inhabitants the only people who matter. President Biden gave us an excellent demonstration of this in his inauguration speech. In front of a whole field of American flags, he spoke of unity, of what could bring all the citizens of his country together, not what divided them. At the same time, he also spoke of re-engaging with the rest of the world, in the understanding that America had duties to those outside its borders as well as within.</p><p>This is what George Orwell called “patriotism” in his 1945 essay <em>Notes on Nationalism</em>. He defined it as “devotion to a particular place and a particular way of life, which one believes to be the best in the world but has no wish to force upon other people.” Nationalism, by contrast, he defined as a catch-all term for what might better be termed “tribalism”, namely a concern to “secure more power and more prestige, <em>not </em>for [one]self but for the nation or other unit in which [one] has chosen to sink [their] own individuality”. Orwell admitted that these words can be defined in other ways, and if you quibble with him over their meaning then you are missing the force of his argument. Personally, I believe it is irrational to consider my place of birth or way of life superior to all others regardless of whether I wish to inflict it on anyone else. But it is the best place for me to live and the best way for me to go about my life there, because it gives me a comforting sense of familiarity, of home. It gives me a sense of belonging.</p><p>And that is the value of patriotism. It is in our very nature to identify with groups, seek out others who are like ourselves and crave belonging and a sense of community. Of course we all share a common humanity with people in other countries and on other continents. We share far more in common with them than what separates us, but ultimately the Earth is too disparate and its various settlements too remote from each other to fully provide that sense of community and belonging that we desire.</p><p>Charity does not end at home, nor should it, but as the saying goes, it does begin there. The United Kingdom is the place Labour are seeking to govern, and in order to win arguments for the kind of policies we believe are necessary here, it is in our interest to foster a sense of solidarity within the UK. If we understood properly what patriotism is (and is not) then this would come quite naturally to us. We already care about our fellow citizens. We already burn with righteous anger when we see some of them being treated by the government as if their lives don’t matter. We already worry about the traducing and underfunding of national institutions like the NHS, the BBC or the judicial system.</p><p>Communicating this requires us to emphasise the ties that bind us, to speak about the basic values of fairness, decency and generosity that the majority of Brits already share, to demonstrate pride in the best of our institutions as well as a determination to fix what is wrong with them. But we must also accept that the flag, the national anthem and (though republicans may especially struggle with this at the moment) even the hereditary monarch as head-of-state are accepted by most people in this country as basic symbols of our nation as a community-at-large. As a result, many people will feel pride and loyalty to such symbols and institutions even if they have their own personal quibbles with their imperfect history or meaning. They may well feel the same way about the armed forces. We don’t have to believe any of these things are above reproach or not in need of reform, but if we display a discomfort or squeamishness about them we send a message to voters that we are ashamed of what they take pride in, that we don’t even start from the same premises as them in our thinking, we don’t accept the most basic elements of what it means to belong to the nation-as-community that we all inhabit.</p><p>And then we don’t get to take credit for supporting some of the other institutions they take pride in, such as the NHS and the BBC. We don’t get a hearing to develop our arguments that the values and logic behind those institutions also demand government action to tackle poverty and homelessness, build a strong welfare state, end inequalities, fix the broken housing market and reform the relationship we have with businesses to protect our climate, environment, mental health and quality of life. We also don’t get a hearing to make the case that the same logic and values apply outside our borders, that the logic and the sentiment underpinning patriotism and internationalism are one and the same. They are both about solidarity, unity and common humanity. It is perfectly consistent with a sense of patriotism to be internationalist and outward-looking, funding international aid programs, promoting peace and reconciliation in conflict zones and seeking to co-operate with other nations on global problems like climate change and tax avoidance. But it is much harder for us to argue for solidarity with the poor, the sick and the defenceless around the globe if we haven’t first fostered that feeling of solidarity at home.</p><p>One of the main reasons Labour lost its “red wall” seats in the last general election was a perception among many working class voters in those areas that Labour had ceased to be a patriotic party that cared about the people who live in this country. That may have been a mostly erroneous and unfair portrayal even of Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour, orchestrated and amplified by hostile forces in parts of the media, but it was the perception, nevertheless. We have a choice. We can stick our fingers in our ears and by implication or otherwise call those lost voters nationalist or even racist, burning bridges forever. Or we can attempt to address the reasons why we were perceived in that way, both those that were valid and those that were not.</p><p>Next time you look at a flag, monitor your emotional response to it. If it generates in you pride, disgust, love, fear or any mixture of the above probe deeper and ask yourself what it is you’re really reacting to when you feel those emotions. It’s true that we shouldn’t need to ostentatiously display the flag of our nation as a kind of virtue-signal that we believe in solidarity with our fellow citizens, but through our rhetoric and our stated priorities over several decades we have allowed a perception to grow that this solidarity is not felt on the left. That is a damaging perception which undermines fundamental arguments key to winning support for left-wing policies. It simply must be addressed. Once we stop ceding the flag to those who practise intolerance and hatred and reclaim ownership of it, we put a stop to the abuse and misuse of the flag for nefarious ends and can finally reframe patriotism as an idea that truly belongs to the left, standing for solidarity, community and empathy, not for selfishness and jingoistic tribalism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eec1a7e73477" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections On My First Decade Of Atheism]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/reflections-on-my-first-decade-of-atheism-bf9a43be0b33?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bf9a43be0b33</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[church]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[atheism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Jan 2021 12:51:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-03T12:51:32.407Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*d4N95X4nnoS8_RgfluJNZA.png" /></figure><p>Last summer marked ten years since I lost my faith. It’s not a subject that I’ve ever written about before, but I’m a sucker for anniversaries. They’re important milestones that help us to measure the passage of time and think about the significance of ideas, people and events in our lives. And so, naturally, I’ve been thinking a lot about this particular anniversary during 2020, and wanted to get around to sharing some of those thoughts before we proceed too far into another year.</p><p><strong>***</strong></p><p>It was July 2010. I was a couple of months away from my twenty-first birthday. I had just finished my second year as an undergraduate at university, where I was on a combined degree course in Theology and Biblical Studies, and had returned home for the summer, suffering from a recent onset of depression and beginning to tell selected members of my friends and family that I was gay for the first time.</p><p>I’ve often wondered what role these last two facts played in my loss of faith. The truth is, probably some, but only as catalysts for the sequence of thoughts and ideas that were entering my head at the time. It is very hard, as a Christian, to come to the realisation that you are gay. Harder still when you are the son of a vicar. I’d like to think that I’m a naturally inquisitive and open-minded person but had I turned out straight instead I doubt somehow that I would have felt the need to question my beliefs quite as strongly as I did. For several years in my late teens this meant I developed an increasingly liberal and unorthodox interpretation of Christian doctrine and scripture, quite deliberately rejecting large parts of the Old Testament that I felt contradicted the values and teachings of the New Testament or which laid down rules which seemed to treat some people (especially gay people) unfairly.</p><p>But once I was studying the Bible in more depth, as an academic pursuit, and encountering for the first time contradictions within the New Testament and even between the different gospels themselves, this open, questioning mindset was leading me towards more fundamental doubts about my faith. I had developed a fairly strong empiricist, materialist (not to be confused with materialistic) worldview, and this didn’t sit easily with my belief that a supernatural deity existed which had created the universe and all of us, or that this deity had somehow conceived a son that was himself both human and deity and had come back to life after being crucified.</p><p>I don’t know why facts such as the likely dates and authors of the various gospel accounts (of which there is much scholarly debate) had such a big impact on me. Or the highlighting of disagreements those gospel authors had with each other about historical events and their sequential order. They probably just got me thinking a bit more about the events depicted in the gospels which I had always been encouraged to believe were of absolute centrality to the Christian faith. I began to ask myself on what basis I believed I <em>knew</em> that God existed, that Jesus of Nazareth was his son and, most crucially, that he had risen from the dead to forgive my sins. What I realised was that I had simply assumed these things to be true before. Why wouldn’t I have done? Almost everybody who had cared for me and been important in my life had told me they were true and I had no reason to believe such people would lie to me or make gross errors of judgement in forming their own beliefs. They all seemed reasonably intelligent.</p><p>But now, when I asked myself how I knew these things, my honest answer had to be that I couldn’t be sure, and from there it didn’t take long for the natural, rational position of an assumption of doubt to take hold. Since miraculous events like resurrections contradicted everything else I could more-or-less prove I knew about the world, then it didn’t make sense to believe in them without explicit evidence to affirm them that couldn’t be explained in any other way. I had no such evidence. Two thousand years had passed, rendering the existence of second-hand accounts of eyewitness sightings of the risen Lord impossible to verify.</p><p>Soon, I was reasoning the same way about the very existence of God or any kind of supernatural aspect to the cosmos whatsoever. Since that time, I have often described myself as “technically agnostic, but to all intents and purposes an atheist” but I have to credit Christopher Hitchens with changing my mind about this recently in an old debate I watched on YouTube. Atheism is simply the absence of a belief in theism. My inability to actively disprove the existence of God doesn’t make my lack of belief in his/her/its existence irrational. Theism is an unfalsifiable proposition similar to stating that pixies are dancing about the tree stumps in the woods. It’s not reasonable or necessary to be agnostic about the existence of pixies. Nor so with God.</p><p><strong>***</strong></p><p>I still remember the last Sunday service I attended. It was Sea Sunday at the local Anglican church where my dad presided, meaning the uniformed groups (Scouts, Brownies etc) were in attendance. I hated this. In my depressed state, the last thing I wanted was to have more people around me. For several months at university I had only been attending church some weeks, rather than every Sunday as had been my custom, and now I was back at home for the summer I had continued this habit. Some days I just couldn’t face getting up and going out, having to greet people I knew and field questions about how I was. Added to this were the new unpleasant feelings of doubt, confusion and alienation that I had started experiencing during church services, triggered by some words of the liturgy, lyrics in a hymn or worship song, or an idea in a sermon.</p><p>The first few Sundays after I stopped going were an almighty relief. I realised I had just been going through the motions, attending church because that was what I had always done. Now, I waited till the whole family had left to avoid the awkwardness of being asked if I was coming, then got up and had a long, relaxed breakfast with the house to myself. I don’t live with my parents any more but it’s hard to remember ever having had any other Sunday morning routine now.</p><p>Of course, after a few weeks my parents became worried. One Sunday, after returning from church, Dad popped his head around the lounge door and casually asked why I hadn’t been coming. I just told him, matter-of-factly. And that was that. It had all been very sudden in the end. Since that Sea Sunday in 2010, apart from the odd errand to carry some boxes for my parents or a quick look round a cathedral in some city I’m visiting, I’ve only set foot in consecrated buildings to attend weddings and funerals.</p><p>Losing your faith is a strange experience, all the more so if you were previously strongly committed in your belief and socially plugged-in to a network of people, events, buildings etc that revolved around a shared faith. In some ways it’s like grieving, except if you were to hang around churches and attempt to participate in services or fellowship and bible study groups it wouldn’t be cathartic. I experienced a horrible feeling of emptiness and lack of meaning in the last few services I attended. That was quite disturbing. It’s taken me some time to be able to appreciate religious music again. Now I can see the secular value in it, appreciate good tunes where they exist, even feel some sense of nostalgia for formative songs and hymns from my childhood. It’s never a good idea to think too closely about the lyrics though, or that sense of alienation and emptiness comes flooding back.</p><p>In that initial period after losing my faith I was quite hostile to anything to do with God or church. I resented that I’d been brought up as a Christian and lumbered with all this spiritual and ecclesiastic baggage. Now, I have a more nuanced view of my past. I don’t blame my parents for bringing me up as a Christian since I know they only wanted to do what they thought was best for me and teach me about the world as they sincerely believed it was. I still have many happy childhood memories that involve church, and I would have no desire to excise these from my personal history even if I could. They are part of who I am.</p><p>My Christian upbringing also gave me a strong sense of justice, and the importance of standing up for what is right. I don’t believe (as many theists claim) that we cannot talk about morality without the existence of God as the ultimate arbiter of good and evil. There is a long tradition of moral philosophers putting forward plenty of different appealing explanations for our intuitions about right and wrong and I won’t go into my preferred answer here, but I still have to acknowledge that it was my faith that gave me an intense interest in the subject of ethics. There was always a sense that doing the right thing really mattered. And that’s driven my politics as well.</p><p>***</p><p>As for my attitude toward faith in God today, if you presented me now with cast-iron evidence that God existed my very first question would be “but how do I know he/she/it is benevolent?” closely followed by “why do they deserve worship for creating me if they are omnipotent and can do so without any effort?” and “why must I ask them to intercede in the world to help the deserving if they are both benevolent and omniscient?” There are a great many questions like these, not all of which occurred to me at the time I lost my faith. I don’t believe there are satisfying answers to any of them.</p><p>And yet, we in the secular world should take great care when we pillory religions and seek to tear down their rituals and institutions. To take the example of Christianity, it has been baked into our culture here in the UK and in many other countries for at least a millennium. We have celebrated festivals, cooked dishes, built magnificent buildings and created gorgeous works of art and music, all inspired by faith. To throw away all of that heritage on the grounds that it was tainted by false belief would be an act of cultural vandalism. It is part of our history and our identity, just as much for the person who was never raised as a Christian and never taken to church as for me, the vicar’s son.</p><p>We have enjoyed Christmas and Easter, pancakes and patron saints. But beyond the cultural goods Christianity also provided us with social networks, community hubs, charitable works and a reminder of the need to be kind to one another. The decline of Christianity as a majority religion is relatively recent in countries like the UK and I sometimes worry that we haven’t worked out how to replace some of the social functions that church provided us with. Too many of us are not plugged into real-world social networks where we experience friendship and fellowship. We live atomised lives, without good role models or sources of support. We lack moral leadership and obvious places to gather as communities in fellowship.</p><p>Church cannot provide those things for atheists, however hard it might try, but there may be lessons for us to learn in studying how they were provided in the past, in other contexts. If the last year has taught us anything, it’s surely the value of community, both for the rewards that come from social interaction and the importance of caring about our neighbours and doing right by each other.</p><p>Much like western society as a whole, I haven’t been able to sustain my belief in messiahs, holy ghosts and almighty fathers, but there are many things we were encouraged to do in their name which I still hold dear, and hope we have not simply abandoned to collective amnesia.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bf9a43be0b33" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The new leader of the Labour Party is…]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/the-new-leader-of-the-labour-party-is-7cc3960c8a1c?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7cc3960c8a1c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[keir-starmer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Mar 2020 19:49:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-28T17:36:31.561Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HYxgB7goRVi_sc7Af0VGWw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Springtime for Socialism?</figcaption></figure><p>What makes a good leader? Many qualities come to mind. Courage, resilience and mental fortitude, intelligence, charisma and strong communication skills. Empathy, and the ability to listen. The capability to lead from the front but also build a strong team around you and inspire a wider movement to pull together and work collectively in pursuit of their aims. Central to all of this, particularly for any leader of a progressive political party, are values. If you have high ethical standards that you want to see reflected in society, you need to be led by someone who shares them, understands them, embodies them and communicates them effectively. Someone who can put those values into practice by both winning elections and then governing in a way that makes a tangible, positive difference to peoples’ lives.</p><p>The values that led me to choose the Labour Party as my home were the combined pursuit of liberty and equality. To build a happy and healthy world, people need not just to feel a sense of freedom in their lives, but to actually possess power and control over what happens to them. They need a real stake in the way their affairs are run, and to feel like a genuinely valued member of society. They also need this on an equal basis. We don’t need to deliver an exact equality of wealth or income, but we do need to build a society where everyone has the opportunity to flourish and has that sense of personal control and a stake in the community, country and world in which they live.</p><p>What is becoming increasingly clear is that this requires a sea-change in our politics equivalent to those enacted in 1945 or 1979. We would be wrong to simply recreate Britain as it existed in the 1970s, but many of the ills we face today were caused by a shift in the last four decades away from a mixed economy and the values of community and strength through solidarity with each other. You can see this in the increase in loneliness and mental illness, in the lack of resolve to adequately fund publicly provided health, education and broadcasting, or in the willingness to indulge those who give business a bad name by piling stress on their employees and polluting the planet.</p><p>Today, Labour needs a leader who is bold enough to seek to address all of this in a way which works for the 2020s. But to do this, they will need to be able to formulate an effective strategy to deal with the many obstacles strewn in the path of left-wing leaders in this country. They can’t be someone who provides free ammunition to parts of the media that have no interest in giving us a hearing. They also can’t be someone who lacks the powers of persuasion to change minds both of voters and those in the media, thinktanks etc who seek to influence them. For instance, Labour simply has to start dismantling head-on the argument that serious investment in our future is unaffordable or unnecessary. Far too many journalists and policy experts are currently in thrall to this idea.</p><p>What is less easy for the left to accept is the way identity is bound up with issues of power, freedom and personal control over our lives. When it comes to speaking up for the rights of women and minorities, the left is comfortable with this, but it has not realised that though many of its policies on equal rights are admirable, a relentless emphasis in its rhetoric on these historically disadvantaged groups can undermine a message of collective solidarity through appeals to the common good.</p><p>It also doesn’t help if we appear embarrassed of our national identity and its symbols and institutions, such as flags, anthems and monarchs. So we will also need to elect a leader who can reframe patriotism as an idea belonging better to the left than the right, through solidarity with others, a degree of collective identity that gives us that sense of belonging we all crave alongside our desire for individual freedom, and who can strongly stand up for the idea that even after Brexit solidarity and shared identity exists hand-in-hand with the logic of co-operation and respect for people wherever in the world they come from and wherever in the world they now live.</p><p>So, who is best equipped to deliver the marriage of principle, power, patriotism and pragmatism called for in our times? I’ve been heartened during this leadership campaign to see that most of the candidates were fighting on more-or-less the right turf, but the one I’ve been most impressed by is Lisa Nandy. Not only does she appear to have the courage, intelligence, empathy and charisma to be an effective leader, but she would also lead by example in demonstrating the fruits of co-operation and working together. She has delivered the most intelligent analysis of any of the candidates when it comes to understanding why voters have abandoned Labour and why many of them have backed leaving the EU or independence for Scotland. She gets that desire for personal control over our own lives, and how this relates to questions of identity.</p><p>I also think it is high time the Labour Party was led by a woman. Avoiding falling into the identity politics trap set by the right doesn’t mean we simply cease to care about the fact we are now the only party of note in the UK never to have been led by a woman. And on the evidence of her campaign, Nandy clearly isn’t going to fall into this trap anyway. My only remaining reservations about her are her comments and performance in a debate on Newsnight earlier in the campaign, and her admission in the Channel 4 debate that she is a republican.</p><p>On Newsnight, Nandy appeared to lapse into the kind of stale ambitionless rhetoric about economics and spending commitments that opened wide the door for Jeremy Corbyn to win the leadership in 2015. And yet her barbs about the folly of nationalisations and abolishing tuition fees were then followed by specific commitments to engage in both regardless. Nandy has been at her best when she reminds us there is no substitute for going into TV studios and winning arguments, so this performance left me confused and disappointed.</p><p>As for the Channel 4 debate, I felt it was a mistake for her to own up to wanting to abolish the monarchy. Yes, I realise she was merely asked a hypothetical question about a referendum she would never hold. I also realise honesty is at a premium right now when we badly need to restore trust in politics, but I have to think twice about electing a leader who would needlessly hand such tempting free ammunition to her opponents in the Conservative Party and parts of the media. We’ve had far too much of that in the last four-and-a-half years already. There can be no hostages to fortune this time. We simply must put our best foot forward.</p><p>Yet, in all other respects I’ve found her more inspiring and convincing than Keir Starmer’s blatantly obvious attempt to forge the path of least resistance towards the leadership. His skilful neutralising of outright Corbynism 2.0 is certainly a useful insurance policy in this leadership election, but I don’t want to pass up the opportunity to elect a winner and a potentially great Prime Minister, especially not when it could finally be a woman.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7cc3960c8a1c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Despair, then vote for the lesser evil]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/despair-then-vote-for-the-lesser-evil-472c4214efbe?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/472c4214efbe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[conservative-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberal-democrats]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[general-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brexit]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Dec 2019 12:33:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-08T12:33:55.788Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MITsC9qyrxk-Bpm_8cENog.jpeg" /></figure><p>“It’s better to light a candle than to curse the darkness.” So said Eleanor Roosevelt, former first lady of the United States. Living through two world wars and suffering the infidelity of her husband while trying to protect him from the ravages of his disability, she certainly had her fair share of darkness to contend with.</p><p>I wonder what she would make of this election campaign. The darkness is abundant, and I don’t just mean because the nights are drawing in and councils don’t have enough money to keep the streetlights on. Voters face a set of perverse choices. Do they opt for a Prime Minister who’s twice been sacked for lying, doesn’t know how many children he has and wants to do grievous bodily harm to the economy with a hard-boiled Brexit? Or would they prefer a PM who’s spent his career befriending terrorists, appearing on propaganda-spewing media outlets in authoritarian states and who can’t seem to get to grips with a racism scandal in his party?</p><p>Perhaps they’d like to take a punt on the outsider — who promises to ignore the majority verdict from a democratic vote without an equivalent mandate to replace it, and who has decided to outflank her opponents by ignoring all sensible advice on economic policy, instead pursuing a permanent budget surplus? Of course, if they do vote for a third party, all that will happen is its MPs will return to square one, choosing for themselves between the first two unpalatables in a hung parliament.</p><p>I’m sorry Eleanor, but the darkness has enveloped us all, and the only thing that’s been aflame during this campaign is a block of student flats in Bolton that somehow still had Grenfell-style cladding on it two and a half years after that particular disaster. If you’re looking for a vignette that sums up how stale and rotten the governing ideology in this country has become over the last forty years, you could do a lot worse. Any government so averse to interfering in the lives of wealthy private citizens that it won’t even act to prevent the risk of their tenants burning to death is not worthy of the name.</p><p>All of this suggests a desperate need for change, for hope, for that lit candle. And to anybody looking at it from the outside, the Labour Party contains a glut of personalities who believe in such a change and could positively articulate it but who do not share the yawning load of excess baggage dragged around by the member for Islington North wherever he goes. Maybe it’s just the cold and the damp, but I’ve been struggling to summon the enthusiasm to make any kind of case for Labour at all during this campaign. In every corner of the internet I find valid arguments being made against voting for my party, and reminders of unpleasant salient facts about the man I intend to make Prime Minister.</p><p>Nevertheless, vote for Labour I must. I know many would question the moral probity of that decision. Personally, when it comes to ethics, I’m a consequentialist. I don’t think in terms of arbitrary red lines or absolute rules, instead I ask myself what the consequences of different outcomes will be. And when I consider the parties’ positions on Brexit, climate change, the funding of public services, the treatment of the poor, the young, immigrants, the sick and the disabled I still judge the consequences of a Johnson-led Tory government to be far graver than those of a Corbyn-led Labour government. There is a strong case for voting tactically in this election, but as long as you view a Labour government as vastly preferable to a Tory one there is little reason to vote for the Lib Dems or other parties in most constituencies.</p><p>Of course, for many ex-Labour voters there is one unforgivable infraction that has caused them to reject this way of thinking and sunder all ties. I won’t insult your intelligence by ignoring it. Personally, I have found it difficult to judge from a distance the severity of the anti-semitism scandal, its scale and the culpability-level of senior party figures. Examples appended to the oft-cited IHRA definition of anti-semitism are frequently invoked without noting its instruction to carefully consider the context of statements that fit this template. It is an occupational hazard of policing anti-semitism that statements intended to criticise the policy of successive Israeli governments and the increasingly loose and vague definition of modern “zionism” tend to cloud that context in many of these cases. I don’t, for instance, interpret Jeremy Corbyn’s own comments and actions as anti-semitic, but there are more than enough clear-cut examples of ugly, racist abuse in the Labour Party to justify alarm.</p><p>These sorts of cases do seem to have led to suspensions and expulsions. Corbyn and other senior figures have denounced anti-semitism on numerous occasions, and Lord Falconer (not a Corbyn ally) was going to be appointed to some sort of watchdog role, though we haven’t heard anything more about that as far as I’m aware. Given that the EHRC won’t have reported on its probe into the party before 12th December, it’s difficult to know where that leaves us. Hysteria about the need for Jews to emigrate to avoid discrimination from a Labour government is preposterous, and those fuelling this panic are irresponsible, but I admit I honestly wouldn’t know how to persuade a Jewish voter on their doorstep that they could make a positive choice to back Labour at the moment. “Vote Labour, we’re probably not institutionally anti-semitic, just a bit crap at dealing with the many anti-semites in our ranks,” is hardly an election-winning slogan.</p><p>I am hawkishly watching how this scandal (among other issues) develops in the months and years ahead, and I can’t hand-on-heart say I am certain that evidence won’t emerge in the future that leads me to reappraise my decision about the consequences of a Corbyn-led government. But in a two-party electoral system, it is a huge step to give up on the major party your views are most closely aligned with unless you’re absolutely sure there is some disqualifying factor severe enough to have rendered them at least as bad as the other lot. We haven’t reached that point.</p><p>In the end, I dropped a few leaflets for my local Labour candidate during this campaign and I will definitely summon the energy to make it down to the polling station and cast my vote for Labour. But perhaps afterwards you will find me outside in the darkness, holding a vigil for decency, progressive values and respect for expertise. I might even light a few candles.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=472c4214efbe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[May’s Legacy and the Tory Identity Crisis]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/mays-legacy-and-the-tory-identity-crisis-b1fdd438012a?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1fdd438012a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theresa-may]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conservative-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Jul 2019 10:55:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-24T12:18:29.070Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RlMrTA7CxrTiE2cYvs8xyg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Three years ago, Theresa May stood in front of her new abode in SW1 and <a href="https://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2016/07/theresa-mays-first-speech-prime-minister/">reeled off a list of “burning injustices”</a> which she had identified in the country she was about to lead. Watching her speech at the time, two thoughts instantly popped into my head. The first was sheer surprise that she appeared to get what was wrong with the status quo in a way David Cameron never could have done. The second was “if she doesn’t live up to this speech, we’ll crucify her for it.” Metaphorically, of course.</p><p>Thirty-Six months later, and Brexit has inevitably diverted May’s time, energy and attention away from whatever plans she had to tackle these injustices, destroyed her premiership itself and permanently tarnished her record in government. For the last month or so we’ve witnessed one of the most futile examples of “legacy fishing” ever undertaken by an occupant of 10, Downing Street. The few minnows and tiddlers on the end of her rod will not satisfy the appetite of either journalists or historians. The May years will forever be remembered for her failure to get us out of the EU with a sensible, negotiated deal.</p><p>As such, we will never find out what she might have done to try and tackle those injustices she mentioned. I for one am sceptical that she planned anything truly comprehensive and transformational to solve the housing crisis, reduce in-work poverty or revolutionise our approach to mental health with a joined-up strategy across government. Even if May and her ministers had not had all their time drained into the swirling whirlpool that is Brexit, I suspect certain instincts that they all share as committed Conservatives would have hampered their efforts, and caused anything they did come up with to fall short of that soaring rhetoric delivered in 2016.</p><p>We’ve all followed the twists and turns of the still-unfolding Brexit drama since then, but this conflict between May’s rhetoric of a one nation conservatism that feels compassion for those who are struggling and a conservatism that robustly defends free market principles and small “value for money” government is the untold story of her premiership, and no less significant than Brexit for the future of our country and its oldest political party. The Tories under May have begun to suffer an identity crisis, and it can only get worse for her successor.</p><p>***</p><p>If the words “conference speech” and “Theresa May” are mentioned in the same sentence, the images and sounds conjured are almost certainly those of P45s, rasping sore throats and letter tiles refusing to spell out uninspiring slogans. But in terms of the actual content, May’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08JN73K1JDc">first conference speech</a> as leader in 2016 was far more interesting than her second. It was an extraordinarily brave and audacious speech in which she made a bid for what she saw as “the new centre ground.” This, she told her party, was all about standing up for ordinary, working-class people instead of a privileged few. It involved regaining faith in the good government can do, rejecting libertarian ideas and the cult of individualism in favour of a strong public service ethos. In places, it seemed as though May was telling her party that much of what it had stood for in the last forty years had been wrong, and had stored up problems for our economy and society which now had to be resolved. Thatcherism this was not.</p><p>The most telling phrase was a reference to Edmund Burke, long seen as the intellectual godfather of British Conservatism. May told her conference that from Burke onwards, Conservatives “have always understood that if you want to preserve something important, you need to be prepared to reform it.” Lord Salisbury, another Tory Prime Minister, had once put this more honestly when he called Conservatism “a fighting retreat.” From time to time, Tories must give up on some of their diseased and less sacred cows in order to preserve the rest of the herd. They must change things they may wish not to precisely in order to conserve what they hold most dear.</p><p>Every few decades, there tends to be a sea-change in our politics, where a broad consensus of views between major parties about the way our economy and society should be organised breaks down. There have been two of these sea-changes in the postwar period. The first, in 1945, reflected the desire of a war-weary public to see the completion of a fully-fledged welfare state that would take care of those unable to provide for themselves, and greater centrally planned government interventions in the market, to deliver among other things a strong manufacturing sector providing ample jobs. The Tories had to adjust to this new postwar consensus in opposition, because Churchill had been caught napping at the end of the war, failing to understand soon enough the extent of the change in the public’s mood, and just how differently things needed to be structured in order to satisfy it.</p><p>Three decades later, it was Labour’s turn to find themselves on the wrong end of a sea-change, as the public tired of the behaviour of trade unions that seemed to hold disproportionate influence.</p><p>Labour was uniquely positioned to sniff out the first sea-change and to feel comfortable delivering on it, the Tories were more naturally disposed to detect and deliver the second. But it didn’t necessarily have to be this way. If Churchill had paid greater attention to the mood music of the Beveridge report and listened to those in his party who had taken a moment to think ahead beyond the war, perhaps he might have had the opportunity to shape what was coming next. If Harold Wilson and Barbara Castle had succeeded in their “In place of strife” reforms to the trade unions, perhaps they might have managed to forestall Thatcherism and find their own solution to the problem of unproductive industry.</p><p>To her credit, Theresa May certainly hasn’t been complacent enough to fail to detect the cracks now showing in the Thatcherite consensus. She identified several of them in both of the speeches already mentioned. She probably hoped that the election of Jeremy Corbyn as her opponent and the class dynamics of the Brexit vote might help her to buck the historical trend and manage the pace of change in a controlled, orderly shift leftward on economic matters and rightward on issues like immigration. If this was her plan, it has laid in tatters ever since her disastrous election gambit in 2017.</p><p>But the strategy has also been stymied by those Tory instincts. Time after time announcements of new policies by the May government designed to tackle the burning injustices have looked like bland managerial tinkering. One of the main reasons for this is the Tories’ continued commitment to austerity. They now claim to be ending it, but any objective assessment of their macroeconomic policy reveals they are still wedded to the same illiterate nonsense about managing government debt like household debt that they began spouting under Cameron. As long as the Treasury is controlling the purse strings tightly, there isn’t enough money to fund genuinely transformational projects or even just reverse the impact of previous cuts. Quality public services cannot be provided on the cheap. If you want to spend less and tax less, you cannot expect to provide more. As public concern about the deficit ebbs away, the Tories will find themselves constantly outflanked by Labour on the question of public services until they are prepared to loosen the purse strings and overcome their aversion to tax.</p><p>Another instinct that stands in their way of claiming the “new centre ground” is their rigid belief in free markets. It’s easy to exaggerate the differences between right and left on the appropriate size of the state and the utility of markets. Few Tories genuinely qualify as the kind of minimal state libertarians May attacked in her 2016 conference speech, and even most Corbynites believe in the need for a good deal of private enterprise. However, we have reached a point where the balance seems clearly to be wrong. Large corporations have too much control over our lives — through nefarious forms of advertising on social media and exploitation of their workforces. Wages are too low, rents and house prices too high, hours at work for those who want them too few, the conditions when they get there not conducive to positive mental health. We also see the damage of Thatcherite policies in the rip-off prices for energy, water and train tickets. For politicians who profess a core belief in the providence of markets and how they are generally efficient when left alone, recognising all this is difficult enough, having the guts to tackle it almost impossible. Labour’s solutions to these problems may go too far, but if the public perceives the Tories to be all mouth and no trousers, they will take a punt on someone else sooner or later.</p><p>Now it is Boris Johnson’s turn to move into Number Ten and utter his first words as Prime Minister. The spectre of Brexit is likely to be looming large in both his mind and all of ours. This is quite appropriate since it already threatens to sink his premiership as it has done May’s. He too may depart so soon that we never find out how he intended to resolve his party’s identity crisis. But he might instead face an election in very short order, in which he will have to set out what the next phase of British Conservatism is going to look like. He hinted in his first brief comments as Tory leader that his party has generally been quite good at balancing the primal instincts of looking after Number One with the communal instincts of caring and providing for others. But it won’t get to set the parameters within which it balances these instincts itself unless it removes its blinkers and realises the scale of the changes necessary to build a fairer, more contented society. If the Conservative Party wants to live up to its name and preserve those things it holds dearest, it must not only deliver a sensible version of Brexit, but it must also remember Burke and embark on wider meaningful reforms. Its attitude and behaviour during the May years does not augur well for either project.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1fdd438012a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There Is Only One Solution To The Brexit Crisis — Compromise]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/there-is-only-one-solution-to-the-brexit-crisis-compromise-972d7c6ae9eb?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/972d7c6ae9eb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theresa-may]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brexit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conservative-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Mar 2019 21:38:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-03T12:15:07.559Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>There is Only One Solution To The Brexit Crisis — Compromise</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s1xfIM0hGnyjdEFh8CfmrA.png" /></figure><p>It may be hard to believe but against all logic we have found ourselves perched awkwardly on the precipice of a No Deal Brexit. Who knows how we got here. I certainly don’t.</p><p>I haven’t written anything specifically about Brexit since referendum day itself, and that’s largely because I’ve found it extremely difficult to keep up with all the twists and turns of the last three years. I’ve had to change my mind or simply suspend forming an opinion altogether about countless aspects of this torrid process since 2016. It’s not easy for a layperson to figure out exactly how different customs arrangements would affect our prosperity as a nation, or how it’s possible to end freedom of movement whilst keeping the Irish border open (this genuinely still puzzles me), or exactly which elements of our future relationship with the EU have to be decided in a withdrawal agreement, and which can be left for later in a political declaration.</p><p>There are also other factors which can be understood but which cause us to enter the realms of moral and philosophical complexity, in which a strong case is put by either side. Uncomfortable questions about the very meaning of democracy have been raised by the fact we held an advisory referendum that has understandably come to be seen as a solemn instruction from the public, and yet we still elect a parliament which must ultimately decide our fate, including whether or not there ought to be a second referendum of some kind. MPs are left trying to interpret an ambiguous “will of the people” at the same time as balancing the danger of mass disillusionment, possible riots etc against a likely increase in poverty and other unintended effects of change.</p><p>I have only managed to form tentative views on some of these subjects, but there are a few important points on which I am increasingly sure of my stance — issues which have become clearer and clearer as the danger of No Deal looms closer.</p><p>The evidence that leaving without a deal would be disastrous is unanswerable. Anybody who disputes this is deliberately ignoring a huge body of evidence from experts in various fields. To dismiss this all as “project fear” is utterly irresponsible. Those who do so have not really given up on expert opinion altogether. They haven’t stopped believing everything they read in their text books when they were at school, nor do they disbelieve every weather forecast or ignore every public health warning. What they have done is to decide that anybody who has built up a reputation of respect for themselves in some discipline or other by working hard and dedicating themselves to research over a long period can only be believed when they tell us things we want to be true. And that these same people can’t be believed when they tell us things which they themselves probably want to be true. Motives are everything. Bad faith rules. There is no such thing as objective, unbiased information. And George Osborne’s treasury forecasts prove this beyond doubt.</p><p>Except they don’t. Even the forecasts which have turned out to be false so far don’t establish this. If we were to pre-judge every piece of information we ever received in this way, we would never believe anything that didn’t fit our previous worldview. Imagine what this would have meant for various scientific discoveries over the last few centuries. Progress would have been impossible.</p><p>In parliament, the minority of MPs who don’t understand this are the most reckless group. Yet, extraordinarily, they are far from the only ones who appear willing to risk calamity by playing No Deal roulette.</p><p>Theresa May and her diminishing band of supporters (are there any?) have refused to budge on their red lines for a negotiated deal despite two heavy defeats. I realise May is in an unenviable position. She simply cannot deliver a Brexit that will please a majority in her party at the same time as pleasing a majority of the public and not lowering their living standards. She probably cannot soften her deal at all without subsequently splitting her party or being thrown out of office by it. But we are far beyond the point where partisan loyalties can be argued to serve the national interest. Of course May will believe, as a Conservative, that maintaining a strong, united Conservative party in government is squarely in the national interest, particularly at a time when the Labour opposition offers such a radical programme under an unorthodox leader. But, as a few of her own backbenchers appear to understand, it is possible to believe this and still see No Deal as a worse outcome than Labour dominance. Given No Deal would potentially damage the reputation of the Tories for decades to come anyway, she should now be prepared to do whatever it takes to avoid it. Her present calculations are short-termist and self-motivated.</p><p>The majority of MPs on the opposition benches have been almost as reckless. If they can find a way to deliver a softer deal with a long extension to Article 50 or a referendum on the Prime Minister’s deal then I am all for it. Any outcome which prevents either No Deal or the revocation of Article 50 without public consent is an acceptable compromise as far as I’m concerned. But most of these MPs show every sign of being prepared to let us crash out of the EU without a deal if they cannot get their preferred scenario. Their attempts to shift all of the blame for this onto the PM are unacceptable. A bad deal really is better than no deal, and they know this. If they spin the roulette wheel one time too many they may miss their final opportunity to quit their losses and accept the compromise of May’s deal. When we then end up with No Deal as a result, I will blame them almost as much as May and her party.</p><p>This refusal to compromise seems to be an endemic feature of our politics today. MPs and ordinary party members are more tribal in their thinking than ever used to be the case. So too are voters in fact. This may be a result of the worst elements of the press infecting other parts of the media with their methods and narratives. It may be partly down to echo chambers on social media. Whatever is causing it, it is toxic to civil debate. It hardens people against necessary compromises required to reach reasonable solutions to our problems, and that may ultimately prove to be a greater threat to democracy than anything else.</p><p>So, as the new deadline for No Deal approaches, I hope desperately that MPs on all sides will be prepared to give up on their preferred outcomes. Dying in a ditch will not serve the national interest at all. This may require Theresa May to sacrifice her own career or her party’s chances of remaining in office by applying for a longer extension to Article 50 and agreeing to soften her deal. It may require remain-minded Tory MPs to bring down their own government in a no confidence vote because she refuses to do this. Alternatively, it might require Labour MPs to vote for the Prime Minister’s deal if they run out of all other options to prevent No Deal, and it may also necessitate the Lib Dems and the SNP giving up on a referendum in order to join this sensible compromise.</p><p>That is the only thing I care about at this point. A sensible compromise. If there had been a march in support of this at the weekend, I might have been on it. Instead, we saw a million people demanding a referendum even if the numbers in parliament are not there for it and we crash out without a deal as a result. We saw several million signing a petition to cancel the vote of a majority of the public without any further say for that majority. And we saw a smaller, bedraggled bunch of Brexiteers down the pub in Beeston demanding that we ignore all expert opinion and gamble with the futures of the poorest in our society. They were all wrong. Our representatives in parliament need to find a sensible compromise, and we need to back them in whatever they decide as a result. Then we need to learn how to live with each other again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=972d7c6ae9eb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Farron, faith and “the gay sex thing”]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/farron-faith-and-the-gay-sex-thing-f45aa6e5d9f2?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f45aa6e5d9f2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gay-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberal-democrats]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tim-farron]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Jul 2017 18:59:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-17T19:05:13.213Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_1ou3mOHjWRlSbRF4EvPbw.png" /></figure><p>This coming Wednesday, nominations will close for the position of Liberal Democrat leader. Extraordinarily, it looks almost certain that despite a small increase in the number of Lib Dem MPs at the election, there will be only one candidate, and that candidate — Vince Cable — will be announced as the new elected leader, unopposed.</p><p>There are plenty of things to say about that and how it affects the future of the Liberal Democrats. There are also things I want to write at some point about Labour’s election result and all the ways it has (and hasn’t) changed the political landscape since the 8th June. But I thought now would be a good time to share some of my thoughts about <em>Farrongate</em> (if we can call it that) before it becomes old news completely. I’ve been meaning to write something about it ever since he resigned because not only was it a fascinating episode in the teledrama that was this year’s general election aftermath, but it could also have important long-term ramifications that may well return to the headlines another day concerning another party or leader.</p><p>Putting aside any general hostility towards the Lib Dems over the coalition (and I still harbour plenty of this), I found Tim Farron’s early interviews back in 2015 on the subject of gay sex troubling, and I had complained several times since then that his line on liberals being able to distinguish between their “private” moral views and their “public” political views seemed to me a cop-out. Yet, I confess that when I heard about his resignation last month, I was troubled by this also.</p><p>Of course, the main thing which had changed in between those two events was Farron’s belated decision to confirm on the record during the election campaign that he did not believe gay sex was a sin, and therefore did not think it morally wrong. When I heard that development during the campaign, my instinct was to give him the benefit of the doubt. Public debate is poisoned every time someone is accused of lying or hiding ulterior motives without there being any way of proving the accusations. We do not have mind probes, and I hope that neither the government, nor journalists, nor ordinary members of the public ever will have such sinister means of divining an individual’s inner thoughts. For me, if Farron said he did not believe gay sex was a sin, and if he was not on record ever contradicting this position, then it was his position and the matter ought to have been put to rest. In fact, I assumed it <em>would</em> be put to rest and wouldn’t become an issue on the doorsteps or a running sore with Farron’s internal opponents in his party.</p><p>The waters were already muddied somewhat by the fact that Farron seemed to be answering questions about abortion put to him later on in the campaign in exactly the same way that had got him into trouble over gay sex previously. To my knowledge, he never attempted to clear up his views on the morality of abortion in the manner he appeared to have done over gay sex.</p><p>But if that would have been a lingering issue with the continuing viability and desirability of a Farron leadership, then his resignation statement revealed far bigger issues that had been lurking beneath the surface by re-opening the question of his views on gay sex and establishing new ones about his honesty and integrity. That resignation statement was sufficiently vague as to leave anyone who heard it wondering if they had really discovered his true feelings about gay sex during the campaign after all. He chose not to repeat the “not a sin” line, which was odd, since even if he viewed the matter as being purely academic now in terms of his leadership and the party’s reputation, you would think that he would have wanted to leave no doubt about his position, to clear the matter up even if for nothing else but posterity’s sake and his own personal reputation and legacy as a party leader.</p><p>Even the resignation itself was confusing. I do not feel I am clear even now about the true reason for his decision to go. The stated reason was the difficulty in reconciling religious faith with the role of leading a progressive political party. But, if he truly believed gay sex was not a sin, and had stated this on the record, there seemed no obvious obstacle left that would prevent him from reconciling these obligations. Which means either that his statement was a coded message about his true feelings on abortion or it was an implicit admission that he had lied during the campaign about his views on gay sex. Perhaps it was both. Perhaps it was also an admission that he felt guilty about lying. Or perhaps he had simply come under overwhelming pressure from his own colleagues to step down without having actually done anything wrong at all. I don’t know to what extent stories about “the gay sex thing” coming up repeatedly on the doorsteps are true, and if they are, I have even less idea whether they caused extensive damage to the Lib Dems at the ballot box after Farron had publicly clarified his views.</p><p>Nevertheless, whatever the truth is, I am troubled by even the mere possibility that a leader of any mainstream party could have been forced out of their position without actually holding any controversial views whatsoever.</p><p>Others will have broader worries which I do not share. I believe it is perfectly reasonable for the public to have difficulty respecting a figure who holds views on matters to do with right and wrong that they would consider harsh and undesirable. How that figure has formed those views is not terribly relevant. If an atheist running for public office declared that it was morally wrong for two persons of the same sex to have intercourse with each other, or for a woman to have an abortion, but they did not think such things should be prohibited by law, then I would have just as much difficulty respecting them as I would any Christian holding these views.</p><p>To ask for special pleading on the grounds that your belief in a deity compels you to hold such views is to demand that circles should be square. Not only are there plenty of Christians, Jews and even Muslims who believe that gay sex, abortion, even in some cases promiscuity are morally permissible, but those who do not are reaching that conclusion on the basis of at least one (maybe several) flawed, irrational premises. I have sympathy for those who go down this road because I travelled it myself and understand how difficult it is to challenge deeply held theological beliefs about the world, but I do not believe that toleration of opposing views extends to some kind of duty to ignore them altogether, and be compelled to vote for an otherwise agreeable figure who holds them. If a candidate for public office considers major life choices I (or any other innocent party) might make to be morally objectionable, I will consider that a black mark against them inside the polling booth, and I make no apology for it. Even if their reasoning for holding that view is valid at every stage of their argument except one (belief in a specific deity), it is still flawed reasoning and they are responsible for it.</p><p>It might be appropriate at this point to introduce some caveats. I said that an individual holding the views mentioned above would be a black mark for me in the polling booth. But it would be only one factor influencing my vote, and in the case of Farrongate, diluted further by the fact that only voters in a remote part of Cumbria actually had the man himself on their ballot paper. On the 8th June, I actually gave serious consideration to voting for a Liberal Democrat candidate, and I don’t reckon that if Farron had clearly stated he believed both gay sex and abortion were sinful that this would have been sufficient to stop me. Other factors weighed more heavily in my decision to vote for Labour.</p><p>Quite evidently, it ought to be much more worrying if a politician advocated banning something in law on the basis of flawed moral reasoning, than if they merely found it personally distasteful. We should also see the mild tutting of a Christian who dislikes gay sex or abortion but does not wish to ban it in the full context of modern-day religious thought in Britain. There are a small but significant number of people in our country whose own views on morality extend to the idea that murdering their fellow citizens for ungodly acts is a just and righteous thing to do. Most members of all faiths in Britain would join liberal evangelical Christians in not even attaining membership of the same league of fundamentalist awful as this. Some actions cannot be tolerated in a liberal democracy. Most can. <em>Mere</em> <em>attitudes and beliefs </em>always can.</p><p>Even so, it is not true that a Christian publicly opposing gay sex or abortion has no impact on the lives of others. Every public figure who expresses such views, or even who chooses to leave ambiguity around their views, makes life that little bit harder for someone somewhere who is still in the closet, or who has come out without receiving support, or who is trying to have an abortion. This is especially true for other Christians struggling in these positions. The expression of a belief about right and wrong, or even the non-expression of the opposite belief is equivalent to an action. Words have consequences too.</p><p>If another Tim Farron should emerge at some point in the future, here is what I think should happen. If they are asked their views on such matters as gay sex and abortion (which it is quite fair for journalists to do), and they declare neither such thing to be sinful, then they should be left to get on with the job. There are many talented persons of faith in politics, and they have plenty to offer in a pluralistic society such as ours. The simple fact that a politician is a Christian, Muslim, Hindu or whatever is not a reason to snigger in the back row or consider them “a bit weird.” But if such a person is asked questions like these and declares that one of these things is sinful, then it will be up to all of us as voters to decide how heavily to weigh this inside our polling booths. It will be up to members of that figure’s party to decide how heavily it ought to weigh against them continuing in their position. And it will be entirely fair for journalists and satirists to make the public aware of that politician’s views, and offer their own opinions on it.</p><p>That is how we resolve these kinds of issues in a liberal democracy — with an open, honest debate, respect and toleration of differing opinions, but no obligation to discard our own opinions for the convenience of others, and the right to make up our own minds about who to vote for, and why.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f45aa6e5d9f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A last minute plea to the Corbynistas]]></title>
            <link>https://musingsofdcc.medium.com/a-last-minute-plea-to-the-corbynistas-83f3aaec9ed1?source=rss-1effbc494e50------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/83f3aaec9ed1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeremy-corbyn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[owen-smith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dominic Chave-Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Sep 2016 18:11:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-19T19:42:18.976Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/775/1*ZhGOY_Gp8OR9Ot0aWPA8uw.png" /><figcaption>This man is not the messiah</figcaption></figure><p>If you’re a supporter of Jeremy Corbyn, you’re probably sick of being told that you’re unintelligent, a bully, an unrealistic utopian, a militant entryist and a crackpot believer in wild conspiracy theories.</p><p>Now, don’t get me wrong — I believe there are plenty of Corbynistas who do fit some or even all of these descriptions, but I also don’t think it’s fair to tar all of you with the same brush. I’m a tolerant, generous sort of person, so I choose to believe that many of you are kind, decent, intelligent people who just want to be part of a movement that can make the world a better place, and stand up for what’s right. And there’s nothing wrong with that.</p><p>So, in that spirit, as someone who’s (to put it politely) resisted the charms of the bearded one up until now, I’ve been trying to put myself in your shoes and see the world as you do. Admittedly, this is only in the vague hope that I might be able to change your opinion about Corbyn, but if you’re reasonable and open-minded (as I believe many of you are), then you won’t mind spending a few minutes to read the rest of this blogpost.</p><p>What I’ve tried to do is summarise what I think are the key beliefs most of you have that are leading you to support Corbyn continuing as leader rather than Owen Smith or someone else in the future, and then explain why I think these beliefs aren’t the right ones. If you feel I’ve missed any out, or want to tell me why you still disagree afterwards, feel free to let me know with a tweet (@MusingsOfDCC). I’d only ask that you keep it civil, and read through the whole blogpost first.</p><p><strong>Austerity is bad for the economy and only Jeremy Corbyn will stand up against it</strong></p><p>Round about 2009, Gordon Brown and Alistair Darling decided that in response to the increase in the budget deficit caused by the financial crisis, there needed to be post-election spending cuts to reassure the markets and avoid losing heavily to the Tories. After 2010, Eds Miliband and Balls decided they would broadly stick to this strategy. Plenty of respected economists have criticised Labour’s policy during these years, and on the economics they’re probably right. On the politics, it may in hindsight have been better to take on David Cameron directly when he cynically pivoted from matching Labour’s spending plans to blaming them for a global economic crisis.</p><p>In any case, Owen Smith <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jul/17/smith-focus-labour-leadership-campaign-tackling-inequality">has accepted this</a>, and has plenty of ideas for what Labour should do instead in future. Meanwhile, the aforementioned anti-austerity economists have <a href="http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/economy/2016/01/opposing-austerity-not-enough-labour-s-leaders-need-lessons-economics-fast">this</a> and <a href="https://mainlymacro.blogspot.co.uk/2016/06/statement-from-members-of-labours.html">this</a> to say about the party’s current economic policy and leadership. If their expert opinion was worth listening to before, why is it not now?</p><p><strong>Corbyn’s opponents all support Trident, foreign wars, benefit cuts and NHS privatisation — all of which are unjust policies</strong></p><p>First of all, this isn’t true. Not everyone who has criticised Corbyn’s leadership supports all of these things. On the NHS specifically, I would be surprised if anybody in the Labour Party supports genuine privatisation (there is a <a href="https://fullfact.org/health/nhs-not-always-free-point-use/">vast amount</a> of <a href="http://www.sochealth.co.uk/national-health-service/a-concordat-with-the-private-and-voluntary-health-care-provider-sector/private-business-and-the-nhs/">hazy ground</a> between a fully public and fully private healthcare system — I know this doesn’t lend itself to easily casting moral judgement on people for their views, but hey, life is complicated). Owen Smith in particular has stated he <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJ4a96XWOT0">wants to reverse private sector involvement in the NHS</a> (watch from 8m50s), opposed UK military involvement in Syria on <a href="http://www.publicwhip.org.uk/division.php?date=2013-08-29&amp;number=70&amp;mpn=Owen_Smith&amp;mpc=Pontypridd&amp;house=commons">two</a> <a href="http://www.publicwhip.org.uk/division.php?date=2015-12-02&amp;number=139&amp;mpn=Owen_Smith&amp;mpc=Pontypridd&amp;house=commons">occasions</a> and now <a href="http://labourlist.org/2016/07/smith-my-regret-over-welfare-bill-vote/">regrets abstaining</a> on the welfare bill last year — an abstention which was solely driven by loyalty to Andy Burnham in his leadership bid.</p><p>Smith has also rightly said that military intervention cannot be ruled out in all circumstances (but <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqqzytMzOfY">even Jeremy Corbyn isn’t a pacifist</a>). Personally, although on balance I feel the Iraq War was a mistake, and that a full-blown involvement in Syria’s civil war would have been too messy as well, I do feel that the struggle against ISIS/Daesh has to involve some kind of military action. Theirs isn’t the sort of threat to global peace and security that can be dealt with entirely through diplomacy or appealing to “hearts and minds”. I also think Labour has to be smart about both rhetoric and policy when it comes to benefits, business, tax and so on — at the same time as trying to ensure fairness and compassion on these issues. But as far as I can tell, that puts me to the right of Owen Smith. Even if my views on these issues aren’t your cup of tea, I can’t see why Smith’s wouldn’t be.</p><p>The only major policy disagreement between Corbyn and Smith is over Trident renewal — something which will soon be irreversible for a long time anyway due to the recent Commons vote. Now, I know the idea of nuclear weapons is terrifying, and the thought of ever actually firing them seems horrific, but this is exactly why we call Trident a “deterrent”. Unscrupulous bullies like Vladimir Putin and Kim Jong-Un care about nothing but power. They would not graciously respond to us disarming by following suit. They would simply rejoice at one less link in NATO’s chain of defence. Until the leadership of authoritarian countries like theirs changes, we in the larger economies who can afford nuclear weapons have no option but to ensure two things cannot happen -</p><p>1) that the Putins and Kims cannot simply point their nukes at an enemy and blackmail them relentlessly; and</p><p>2) that they would never dare to strike, for fear of the consequences.</p><p>We will never need to use Trident precisely <em>because</em> we and our allies possess such terrifying weapons. And it wouldn’t be fair to expect NATO’s other major economies to shoulder the nuclear burden for us. Why should they pay for our security while we contribute nothing towards theirs?</p><p><strong>Labour can win a general election under Corbyn, and is so far performing quite well in polls and mid-terms</strong></p><p>Now, I realise that when we Corbyn-critics simply repeat ad nauseam that Corbyn makes Labour unelectable and that we’re heading for a landslide defeat at the next general election, we tend to say it as though it’s bloody obvious and all we need to do to convince you is just repeat it over and over again. Personally, I think the evidence is pretty clear that Corbyn would lead Labour to a landslide defeat, but I also respect your intelligence enough to actually lay out the reasons that I believe this.</p><p>Many of us felt instinctively that Corbyn would be an electoral liability (in a general election — internal party elections are not remotely comparable with nation-wide votes) from the moment he announced his leadership bid last summer. But there are various useful indicators which historically have been pretty good at giving us an idea of how a party will perform in a general election. Of course they’re not going to be able to predict an exact seat number, but if they all head massively up or down, that’s as close as you can get to knowing with certainty that you’re onto a winner (or a loser).</p><p>So, what have these indicators been saying since Corbyn was elected leader? Labour’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_next_United_Kingdom_general_election">polling average</a> has been behind the Conservatives throughout, when <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_2015_United_Kingdom_general_election">nearly</a> <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_2010_United_Kingdom_general_election">every</a> <a href="http://ukpollingreport.co.uk/voting-intention-1979-1983">opposition</a> tends to establish a lead in mid-term, even if it’s ultimately gone on to a defeat. In by-elections, the swing to Labour <a href="http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/elections/2016/01/how-jeremy-corbyns-labour-faring-elections-so-far">has been lower</a> than that achieved under Ed Miliband in the last parliament when it should really be getting up to 15 or 20% to indicate imminent victory. Then there’s the unavoidable fact that Corbyn has become the first leader of the opposition in anyone’s living memory to suffer a <a href="http://www.bbench.co.uk/single-post/2016/05/08/Elections-2016-All-the-key-results-and-analysis-in-one-place">net loss of council seats</a> at his first set of local elections. Add to that his <a href="http://www2.politicalbetting.com/index.php/archives/category/leader-approval-ratings/">dire leadership ratings</a> (which tend to suggest it’s him dragging the party’s ratings down rather than the other way round) and you have a set of terrible omens for Labour’s performance in a general election. Polls can be wrong, but if Labour was genuinely on course to win in 2020, they’d have to be so far out right now that some of the wild conspiracy theories about pollsters circulating the web would have to be true — and those are patently nonsense.</p><p><strong>The mainstream media is biased against left-wing ideas and individuals, particularly Jeremy Corbyn</strong></p><p>I will grant you, certain prominent sections of both print and broadcast media in the UK are hostile to anybody one iota to the left of Margaret Thatcher, and this would make the job of any Labour leader particularly tough. This also means that the more left-wing and socially liberal any such leader is, the more the press will go after them. But can anybody really pretend they didn’t know this when they voted for Corbyn? If you know large parts of the media are hostile to you, why on earth would you pick somebody as leader who’s going to give them free ammunition?</p><p>It’s also worth noting two other things about Corbyn and the media. Rather than just grinning and bearing the inevitable hostility they’ve displayed towards him, at times he’s appeared to actively demonstrate contempt towards them. Whatever he believes privately, that’s just downright irresponsible behaviour for a party leader to engage in — if you damage the party’s reputation with the messengers, you’ll damage the message too.</p><p>What’s more, I’m afraid the uncomfortable truth is that a lot of the questions asked and criticisms made about Corbyn in the media have been perfectly reasonable. If allegations are made about wrongdoing, or surprising connections of senior party figures with unsavoury characters, the media have a responsibility to investigate it and report it. Many of the issues around Corbyn’s leadership that they’ve fixated on are simply those issues that most voters would care about too.</p><p><strong>It’s not morally acceptable to seek to win an election and/or govern by violating core principles</strong></p><p>This has a lot to do with how you view ethics. For me, nothing is more important than the consequences of our actions. I support the Labour Party because I believe it’s the best vehicle for positively changing society and improving peoples’ lives. But apart from the occasional close parliamentary vote, that won’t happen when it’s in opposition. And, as I’ve laid out already, I don’t believe there’s any good reason to think Corbyn can deliver a Labour government. If you agree that consequences trump arbitrary red lines, then how can you tolerate perpetual Tory government? Even a Labour government that only differed in one or two policy areas to the Tories would surely be preferable. And as it happens, Owen Smith is probably <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jul/17/smith-focus-labou">far closer to Corbyn</a> on policy than he is to Theresa May. Or to Tony Blair for that matter.</p><p><strong><em>AND/OR</em></strong></p><p><strong>There is no alternative to Corbynism that would have better consequences than losing an election with Corbyn as leader anyway</strong></p><p>Maybe you accept that consequences trump red lines, but you either believe that a Smith-led Labour Party couldn’t win an election anyway, or would govern just as poorly as the Tories.</p><p>On the first of these, I’d argue that even if Labour didn’t win under Smith, it would still have so many more seats than it would under Corbyn that it might be 5 or even 10 years closer to winning an election than would otherwise be the case. It also looks distinctly like the party may be on the verge of splitting if Corbyn stays as leader, and who knows what a landslide defeat in a general election might lead to? A protracted time, energy and funding-sapping battle between two left-wing parties, plus UKIP and the Lib Dems doesn’t sound like a lot of fun. Unless you’re a Conservative.</p><p>On the second point, I’d simply refer you to the arguments I’ve already made about Owen Smith’s beliefs and <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jul/17/smith-focus-labou">policies</a>. Again, he would clearly not govern like Theresa May.</p><p><strong>So-called “moderate” Labour politicians like Ed Miliband and Owen Smith all hold similar, objectionable “Blairite” views</strong></p><p>“Blairite” is a term that originated to describe members of the Labour Party whose views closely aligned with Tony Blair. Surprisingly enough. Back then, it didn’t even include Gordon Brown (hence the term “Brownite”). Therefore, it’s simply either ignorant or deliberately disingenuous to apply this label to everybody who opposes Jeremy Corbyn. It’s not fair to them, and it’s not fair to genuine Blairites either. Frankly, it’s an attempt to distort the true picture of ideas on the left to make Corbynism seem more respectable and mainstream. If you disagree with Brownites, “soft left” types or those who can’t be easily categorised, fine. But you don’t have any right to deliberately misrepresent their views or call them names as a means to excuse yourself from having to bother debating them. Just as they shouldn’t call all of you “entryists” or “trots”. And if you genuinely believe that Smith sees eye-to-eye with Blair, then I would once again refer you to his <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jul/17/smith-focus-labou">policies</a> and his <a href="http://www.publicwhip.org.uk/mp.php?mpn=Owen_Smith&amp;mpc=Pontypridd&amp;house=commons">voting record</a>.</p><p><strong>Jeremy Corbyn is a principled, honourable man and a perfectly competent leader of the Labour Party</strong></p><p>It’s quite common to note that Corbyn is a fairly nice guy on the whole, whose heart is in the right place. I’d agree with this, and I think a lot of even his harshest critics would too. But it is possible to be a nice person and still make gross errors of judgement, or be a nice person but <a href="http://scopeni.nicva.org/article/corbyn-competence-and-the-future-of-labour">lacking in many of the skills you need</a> to do a tough job like leading a major political party. I’m afraid both of these things are true about Corbyn.</p><p>I understand that he belongs to a wing of the party that has been out in the cold for several decades, and couldn’t really have anticipated that he’d get a shot at the leadership one day (with all the scrutiny that brings with it). But, even for a lifelong backbencher, some of Corbyn’s choices have been naive at best, irresponsible at worst. I don’t believe every single one of the stories that have been spread about him, but it is not good judgement to fail to research controversial things people might have said before you share a platform with them. It’s even worse when you fail to denounce them afterwards. Then, there’s the continuing mystery of his <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/dec/11/stop-the-war-chief-corbyn-christmas-party-row-is-absurd">involvement</a> with the Stop the War Coalition — an organisation which has frequently had to retract offensive articles that provided apologism for ISIS/Daesh, Syria’s President Assad, and Russian military aggression in Ukraine.</p><p>There is also his conduct as leader. It may well be explicable as the behaviour of a normally polite and decent man put under enormous pressure, but the way he appears to have treated Thangam Debbonaire <a href="http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/staggers/2016/07/thangam-debbonaire-mp-why-i-have-no-confidence-jeremy-corbyn-s-leadership">in particular</a> — as well as other <a href="http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/staggers/2016/07/lilian-greenwood-mp-jeremy-corbyn-continually-undermined-me-job-i-loved">shadow ministers</a> — is extremely worrying. Even if there is no malice intended, there certainly does seem to be a large dose of disorganisation, and an inability to communicate effectively within a team. These are skills which are essential in a leader.</p><p>Finally, there seems to be a lack of strategic and tactical nous. You might find that somehow refreshing or endearing, but I don’t see how we can tolerate a leader who fails to even mention the resignation of a secretary of state over the government’s budget at PMQs. Ironically, Iain Duncan Smith’s exposure of the contradictions at the heart of David Cameron’s government probably did more damage to it than anything Jeremy Corbyn has ever said or done. It really comes to something when we’re relying on a man like IDS to provide opposition to a right-wing government. The episode was all the more frustrating for knowing the sheer scale of the opportunity a competent Labour leader would have been presented with during the Tories’ recent bout of in-fighting. Another leader might well have steered the party into an unassailable double-digit poll lead.</p><p><strong><em>***</em></strong></p><p>I think all of this really does provide more than enough argument that Labour can do a lot better than its current leader, and that Owen Smith is just one of several MPs that could achieve this, given the chance.</p><p>I realise that Corbyn is personally associated by many voters in this leadership election with the rejection of austerity and with a different, more compassionate set of policies for the country than we’ve witnessed of late. It’s understandable then that you might feel a strong emotional attachment to his leadership. But apart from the fact that his own words and actions sometimes undermine and contradict these values, we also have to face up to the fact that he will never be able to put them into practice by becoming Prime Minister.</p><p>If you dislike being tarred with accusations of forming a “personality cult” around Corbyn, then prove it. Prove that the values he’s put on the agenda are more important than the man himself — that they deserve to be put into action, via a credible strategy for securing a left-wing government.</p><p>And if you’re still not convinced, please at least ask yourself whether you’re challenging your assumptions strongly enough. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases">Cognitive biases</a> creep into our thinking all too easily. We all do it sometimes (including many of Corbyn’s critics), and the ways we now acquire information and interact with each other on <a href="http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk/2016/07/how-jeremy-corbyn-won-facebook">social media</a> are not helping. But there are a lot of people currently condemned to a long period of Tory rule who are relying on us not to slip into a self-indulgent comfort zone right now. If you still haven’t voted yet, please don’t let them down.</p><p>�</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=83f3aaec9ed1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>