<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by comerade מ on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by comerade מ on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mxfeeling?source=rss-be868f2e1001------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 08:31:47 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mxfeeling/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[TIME & PLACE: THE NEED TO SEPARATE DE-ZIONIZING AND ORGANIZING FOR PALESTINIAN LIBERATION]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mxfeeling/time-place-the-need-to-separate-de-zionizing-and-organizing-for-palestinian-liberation-f3c5d6beada7?source=rss-be868f2e1001------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3c5d6beada7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine-conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestina]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[comerade מ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Nov 2023 15:04:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-10T20:06:50.987Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/649/1*jJcu6ggyxWZ9BEa7XS6lIA.jpeg" /><figcaption>ID: Person waving a large Palestinian flag against a cloudy sky. The sun lights the flag from behind and the person holding the flag is blacked out by the sunlight</figcaption></figure><p><strong>by comrade מ</strong></p><p><strong><em>[</em></strong><em>These are one person’s thoughts in one moment in time. As I’m editing, my thoughts are already changing. take this as an offering to start a conversation with]</em></p><p>Palestine will be free in this lifetime &amp; we all have a part to play in the struggle to get there. We need to be organizing for a liberated, decolonized &amp; autonomous Palestine from the river to the sea. We also need de-zionize Jewish communities: thoroughly uproot and destroy zionism individually, collectively, politically, institutionally, psychologically, spiritually. Even though de-zionizing Jewish communities could potentially represent enormous gains for Palestinian liberation, it is not the same as political organizing for Palestinian liberation: they call for very different approaches.</p><p>The work necessary to de-zionize requires grace and curiosity for the vile latent zionist beliefs and feelings we hold in order to truly break them down. But this approach, if given any air <em>within</em> movements for Palestine, can actively threaten our organizing for Palestinian freedom.</p><p>I believe:</p><p>a) Jewish communities must de-zionize if we are to survive as a people &amp; be in the struggles against oppression and domination both where we live and in our name.</p><p>b) the cause of Palestinian liberation is harmed when we messily merge this urgent decolonial struggle with our own intra-community project of de-zionization</p><p>c) when we organize self-consciously as Jews in Jewish-led groups for Palestine, as opposed to as Jewish members of larger anti-zionist liberation formations led by Palestinians, the tendencies 1) to include threatening de-zionizing approaches alongside political work and 2) to replicate zionist values (often Jewish supremacy) are high.</p><p>therefore: I propose we create Jewish groups whose purpose is to de-zionize our minds, hearts, and understanding of the Palestinian struggle AND, separately, throw our full weight behind movements led by Palestinians for the liberation of their land and people. I don’t condemn Jewish anti-zionist organizing as such, but in this historical moment where Jewish experience has been tied to zionism for so many…I am very worried at the tendency towards latent zionism within Jewish-led groups that primarily organize other Jews for Palestine.</p><p>In this zine I am mostly discussing groups that don’t truly consider Palestine liberation as their ultimate goal (like If Not Now and Jewish Voice for Peace, though the two differ from one another) because these groups may appear genuinely anti-zionist to someone new to pro-Palestinian organizing, and they are often viewed as existing in the same movement space as Palestinian liberation formations. Though my critiques focus on Jewish-led, majority Jewish groups, I believe they could extend to non-Jewish groups as well, and certainly to Jewish individuals within movements for a free Palestine.</p><p><strong>I: EXPLORING DE-ZIONIZING</strong></p><p>The process of de-zionizing will be emotionally and psychologically difficult, even for those of us who received relatively less zionist propaganda and with no personal connections to the zionist regime. It is imperative that we acknowledge, feel, and investigate these emotional reactions together, while remaining firm in our commitment to rid the world of zionism. <strong>We need to come undone to rebuild. </strong>Zionist propaganda rests on a suite of rotating, logically inconsistent excuses for its colonial violence against Palestinians. Broadly speaking, Americans receive a different propaganda package from settlers within occupied Palestine, just as Jews receive a different propaganda package from non Jews.</p><p>Part of the zionist propaganda package for Jews is to explicitly connect (often European) histories of violent antisemitism with support for the zionist entity. Frequently, when we learn of the Shoah, Jews are told we need the “Jewish state” to protect against genocidal antisemitism. Of course this “existential threat” argument is most often deployed by zionists against Palestinians and Palestinian resistance. It is also meant to set the zionist entity up as a permanent safe haven for Jews, because antisemitism will inevitably threaten communities of diaspora Jews again. Zionists believe antisemitism is like the weather and every few years we have a natural disaster. How has this understanding affected our ability to discern safety and risk, let alone do so when choosing action that does carry risks? How has this affected our deeper senses of safety and comfort?</p><p>This propaganda goes deeper than the head; it plays on our nervous systems and hearts too. It’ll be necessary to break down for all of us, even if you have long left zionism behind politically, and even if you’ve long left/been exiled from Jewish families and/or communities of origin, or never came up in one to begin with.</p><p>It will be necessary to confront these emotional and psychological reactions directly and collectively. These reactions may range from empathy-numbing grief to racist fear to an instinctive comfort in sticking with our own to valuing Jewish modes of thought and action above all else (Jewish supremacy). It will be impossible to de-zionize our community without feeling the emotional responses we seek to eradicate within ourselves and investigating collectively. We cannot build a robust Judaism, an anti zionist and anti fascist Judaism, on a foundation where any latent zionism still exists.</p><p><strong>II: KEEP ’EM SEPARATE</strong></p><p>What happens when this work is done within a political movement for Palestinian liberation?</p><p>This process of de-zionizing will bring to the fore ugly emotional and psychological attachments we Jews still hold — these ugly responses threaten Palestinian liberation if explored or given attention within groups working towards Palestinian freedom.</p><p>An illustration: Public-facing messaging may be polluted and watered down in an effort to address anticipated Jewish emotional responses to de-zionization. I rarely hear “from the river to the sea” chanted at actions led by Jewish groups unless begun spontaneously by someone in the crowd; I’m guessing that this is because of the zionist lie we are told that this chant means to murder all settlers/Jews, as opposed to a decolonial freedom cry passed thru generations. Many people present may <em>know</em> the truth of the chant, but still <em>feel</em> the zionist lie, and so leave this call for liberation unheard at their actions.</p><p><strong>THERE IS NO ROOM TO MINCE WORDS</strong>. When it comes to the Palestinian freedom struggle, every statement aids either the colonizer or the colonized. The necessary grace we may privately give emotional reactions to de-zionization must be kept separate lest they pollute or dilute our speech. <strong>Delaying a free Palestine is betraying a free Palestine.</strong></p><p>………………………</p><p><strong>An incomplete list of ways that de-zionizing approaches within formations for Palestinian freedom can threaten Palestinian freedom:</strong></p><p><strong>Groups (and individuals) may:</strong></p><p><strong>...maintain</strong> language that is both inaccurate &amp; harmful to the resistance in the effort to appeal to the maximum number of people; likewise, they may omit key Palestinian demands from their public demands. If Not Now, for example, purposefully refuses to define “occupation” in an effort to welcome so-called “liberal zionists” into the movement (who may consider only some of Palestine “occupied”). Obviously, Jews at all levels of brainwashed dedication to zionism will need to de-zionize; however, we can not call these Jews comrades in the movement for a free Palestine until they have fully abandoned zionism in their own words and actions. The illustration I gave above with “from the river to the sea” is a clear example of omitting Palestinian demands. Especially given how easily enemy institutions co-opt language, it is crucial to keep chanting the well-worn words of freedom spoken by Palestinians and uphold the Thawabit.</p><p>A related omission is the recent focus on a ceasefire (on the part of JVP &amp; others) with no mention of what is to come after this round of fire ceases. Another disgraceful approach I see is secularizing language in an effort to appeal to non-Muslim people (ex: referring to martyrs as “dead” or “murdered”). This is a way to separate Palestinian struggle from Palestinian life and spirituality and must be resisted at all costs. Lastly, we need to watch the language we use to describe colonial violence; using the word “terrorist,” even to refer to the violence of the zionist regime, is co-signing usage of this racist, colonial term more broadly. Inevitably, this will boomerang back on Palestinians and other comrades of the global south.</p><p><strong>…condemn </strong>Palestinians’ rightful resistance, in whole or by condemning H-mas, as a way to manage Jewish emotional responses to the hard truths of decolonization. Similarly, they may publicly grieve settler death — or even sympathize with settler fear — within a movement for a free Palestine. This is a clear example of the need to separate de-zionizing efforts (which may welcome these emotions while rejecting their conclusions) and organizing for a free Palestine. These public displays of grief/sympathy with settlers dangerously reaffirm that a) settlers are “civilians” in the sense that they don’t and have not participated in violence against indigenous Palestinians (untrue both because of the IOF draft and because of the nature of being a settler) and b) Jewish settler life is ultimately the most valuable life and worthy of grief within our political movements. To do this publicly turns precious attention away from Palestinians and instead underscores the oppressor’s victimhood, frailty, and need for protection and even solidarity.</p><p><strong>…fail</strong> to let go of language and symbols that connect them to settler culture. I’ve seen too many “Israeli Jew for Palestine” signs in the last month to not include this point. Obviously, claiming yourself as “Israeli” is counter to a free Palestine. Movements for Palestine should reserve the right to have no tolerance for descriptors like “Israeli” or magen/star of david* symbolism akin to the zionist flag. De-zionizing efforts should also reject these, but because they are premised on making sure these attachments are fully destroyed, we may give grace to ourselves as we let go of them together. Out of de-zionizing contexts, this grace effectively normalizes the zionist regime and settler culture.</p><p><strong>…have </strong>a<strong> </strong>warped view as to who our comrades are and who we should be trying to organize: Within If Not Now, I found that the focus on moving liberal zionists, imagined to be American white, wealthy, coastal Ashkenazi Millennials, was so strong as to constitute a fetish. Fear about alienating the fetishized faction was high; I remember being pulled over by one of the INN national team in 2018 and being given a very strong talking to for using the word “apartheid “ on a sign from an official INN action that read “Jews against: demolitions, occupation, apartheid.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/173/0*GDWeelW8JtZCokjy" /><figcaption>ID: white poster board sign with black writing “Jews against: demolitions, occupation, apartheid.” a person’s fingertips are gripping the top and bottom of the sign to hold it up</figcaption></figure><p>The reason was not that he personally disagreed that the zionist entity enacted apartheid, he insisted, or even that others within INN disagreed, but rather fear of alienating <em>people who might be interested in the movement</em>. The national team in particular frequently shared the belief that these people could be brought in with less “harsh” language and then moved leftward. (leftward to what? also undefined).</p><p>Another reflection: recently, I found myself handcuffed outside a pig precinct after a huge action organized by JVP. Dehydrated, anxious, angry &amp; grieving, I overheard a few groups of my supposed comrades joking and flirting with the pigs who had arrested us. I don’t doubt every one of them knew the NYPD trains with the IOF and had chanted it that night; I’m sure many would call themselves abolitionists. This, to me, is a reflection on who sees themselves as belonging within or drawn to JVP, even if these individuals were more like myself: showing up for the protest that night but not organizing with JVP in an ongoing sense. On the one hand, these people were willing to risk something &amp; did &amp; should have. On the other hand, are people who make nice with cops people who will — at this point in their lives/de-zionizing journeys— fight for a complete eradication of the zionist entity by whatever means the Palestinian people deem necessary?</p><p><strong>…Finally, groups and individuals may harbor Jewish supremacy, the beating heart of zionist ideology. I will address this directly below when i discuss Jewish-led, majority Jewish groups below.</strong></p><p>I encourage others with experience in these movements, however tangential, to reflect on other ways they replicate white supremacy, zionist Jewish supremacy, and settler colonialism &amp; ultimately betray the movement for a free Palestine in doing so.</p><p><strong>III: LATENT ZIONISM IN JEWISH-LED, MAJORITY JEWISH GROUPS FOR PALESTINE</strong></p><p>I have yet to engage with a self-consciously Jewish, Jewish-led, majority Jewish movement for Palestine that does not normalize the zionist entity and settler identity. While many individuals in these movements hold Palestinian decolonization, liberation, and sovereignty as genuine goals, these organizations themselves often fail to be full-throated in their support for a free, autonomous Palestine &amp; the right of Palestinians to resist their oppressors by any means necessary.</p><p>Let’s start with a basic question: why?</p><p>Why should Jews organize mostly with other Jews in Jewish-led groups for Palestinian liberation and self determination?</p><ul><li>it’s strategic. Between the fact that the zionist entity self describes as a Jewish state &amp; the frequent weaponized accusations of antisemitism hurled at those fighting for Palestine, it is strategic for Jewish people to publicly oppose zionism in our Jewishness. I don’t disagree! But i don’t see why this strategy means Jewish-led movements or Jewish groups with a broad focus on anti-zionism/“ending the occupation” instead of groups with a narrow focus on countering zionism within Jewish &amp; communities. Or, outside of Jewish-led groups, particular campaigns (like Jews organizing our own people to boycott ritual supplies made in occupied Palestine, or even JVP’s “return the birthright” campaign).</li><li>it’s our moral duty as Jews to take risks for Palestine &amp; speak out: not in our name! i also fully agree with this. But again, i don’t see why this has to result in Jewish-led groups primarily organizing other Jews as opposed to widespread Jewish participation in other movements for Palestinian liberation or more focused Jewish organizing.</li></ul><p><strong>The underlying issue with this type of formation is this: The perpetuation of the idea that Jewish people or even settlers in occupied Palestine have particular expertise or speak from an inherently more valuable moral position on the Palestinian struggle.</strong></p><p>This is rooted in Jewish supremacy, the vile, beating heart of zionism.</p><p>Let me be clear: we do not, because of our Jewishness, have unique insight into Palestinian history and struggle. Many of us do have experience that yields insight into the workings of zionism and the zionist entity; these experiences in the hands of a traitor to zionism can be incredibly powerful. But I can’t believe they are essential to Palestinian liberation because to do so would be to declare the necessity of the colonizer’s insight to the colonized’s fight for freedom. and I reject this. Likewise, I reject on its face the idea that anyone’s moral position is more valuable than another’s, with the obvious exception of those who have personal experience with the struggle at hand (and in this i include Palestinians all over the world along with those who face colonization and/or the effects of anti-Palestinian racism and oppression).</p><p><strong>Related-the chosen people</strong></p><p>I have yet to have a spiritual interpretation of “chosen people” than doesn’t turn my stomach, one that aligns with fundamental non hierarchy among people. But I digress…</p><p>One’s understanding of Jews as “the chosen people” could be religious or secular-justice (i define the secular-justice interpretation as the idea that Jews have a unique and unparalleled understanding of oppression and collective struggle because of our history). Either way, it ultimately harbors Jewish supremacy and must be resisted at all costs. Every people and every person brings something unique to the fight for liberation; we can celebrate what it is Jewish peoples bring alongside what everyone else does. But I believe when we organize as majority Jews in a Jewish-led movement these latently Jewish-supremacist tendencies are much more likely. We cannot work genuinely towards a free Palestine with Jewish supremacy and exceptionalism motivating our hearts and understandings of our place in the struggle.</p><p>Where does this leave an anti-zionist Jew looking to take action for Palestine’s liberation? First off, existing Jewish-led groups organizing for Palestine have been doing de-zionizing work already (teach-ins, communal ritual, reaching back into our history to recreate Judaism anew &amp; more). In fact, I think this work (often described as “moving” the Jewish community) has been more successful than these groups’ organizing for Palestine in many ways. They provide a starting point for de-zionizing our community. But the politics of these groups have been built on normalizing the zionist occupation of Palestine &amp; there is no building upon of this colonial foundation.**</p><p>So, I encourage Jews to ask ourselves: why do we need to organize only amongst ourselves in a struggle where we occupy the position of oppressor? What discomfort are we looking to avoid? Can we be content with our place as foot soldiers in a movement led by Palestinians, too many of whom have been scattered into diaspora by our communities’ vile, shameful, colonial violence?</p><p>Several years ago I listened to an imam who had spent time in interfaith justice movements being interviewed on a so-so podcast about spirituality. When asked what insight Islam had to offer the world he said: submission. submission not to oppressive conditions, not to another human, but to the higher purpose and to Allah. I think we Jews could take a page from this imam &amp; practice submission, some much-needed humility, to the higher purpose of Palestinian liberation. To upholding the thawabit. Then, once aligned with this purpose, our bodies submerged, swimming in the river of the Palestinian struggle, we can begin to deal with rescuing the spirit of Judaism and communal Jewishness from the black heart of zionism.</p><p>*I personally am in the process of letting the star of david go. It was the first symbol of Judaism, our people &amp; history I ever felt attached to, but I see no room for it spiritually in this moment. I question but don’t object to its private use, but am am firm in my belief that it has no public use for the foreseeable future.</p><p><em>[A brief background on the writer: I am a white Ashkenazi Jew with American citizenship whose family has been in the US for several generations. I’m a queer trans man (he/him) who is disabled and crazy. i grew up in a rich family in an East coast suburb &amp; have a college degree. I have been involved in struggles for Palestine on and off for about 6 years including: a nascent college Jewish group for those critical of zionism, If Not Now (in a local chapter that eventually split from INN national), Jewish Voice for Peace, and the Palestine Solidarity Committee at a local university I had no formal affiliation with as student or staff. ]</em></p><p>** I have recently heard of several smaller Jewish anti zionist formations that are principled in their stands for a liberated Palestine by any means necessary; my fingers are crossed but it remains to be seen if they can avoid weaving latent zionism into their organizing fabric.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3c5d6beada7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>