<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Dumbo Feather on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Dumbo Feather on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@n.j.scolaro?source=rss-b70d7e2e8266------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 23:20:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@n.j.scolaro/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reaping-and Sharing-the Benefits of 'Radical Reciprocity']]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/b-magazine/reaping-and-sharing-the-benefits-of-radical-reciprocity-4a55679a2a1e?source=rss-b70d7e2e8266------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a55679a2a1e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[agriculture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[b-corp]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dumbo Feather]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Aug 2018 20:08:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-08T20:41:03.172Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Reaping—and Sharing—the Benefits of ‘Radical Reciprocity’</h3><h4>How Living in a Gift Economy Affirms a Sense of Belonging</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5FBObjeM-t6kok0prSTPpg.jpeg" /><figcaption>(Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/qgHGDbbSNm8?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Elaine Casap</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/share?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><em>By Erin Axelrod</em></p><p>For the past 10 years, I have cultivated a community that supports my most essential human needs (food, shelter, education) with limited exchange of money. Sometimes called the barter and gift economy, sometimes called family, I call it “radical reciprocity.”</p><p>I came to this lifestyle not long after college, when I moved back to my hometown of Petaluma, California, to take up a residential farm internship. In exchange for agricultural training, I labored. The trade felt equitable and mutualistic, and I became hooked on bartering for the basics. I saw viscerally how, when practiced with care and consideration, non-monetary exchange could yield more than the sum of its parts.</p><p><em>Dumbo Feather is part of the community of Certified B Corporations. </em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/#btc"><em>Learn more about this growing movement</em></a><em> of people using business as a force for good, and sign up to receive the </em><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58#btc"><em>B the Change Weekly newsletter</em></a><em> for more stories like this one, delivered straight to your inbox once a week.</em></p><p>These days, I rarely go to the grocery store. Instead I meet my caloric needs in other ways, including work-trade at the place that I live — a grass-fed beef and land restoration operation. Here, I not only receive the gift of housing, but my housemate and I feed ourselves from the herd we manage on the land.</p><p>There is seaweed, too. I climb down steep cliffs at low tide, stepping out carefully into tidepools to pick nori, wakame, kombu (all regularly sold seaweeds) off the wave-crashed rocks, and then sun-dry it back at home to eat and share throughout the year. Seaweed is a gift brimming with essential nutrients long lost in many other foods due to years of extractive agricultural practices. We harvest it to promote regrowth and mindfully tiptoe through tidepools to avoid causing unnecessary harm.</p><blockquote>Harvesting in this way becomes a ceremony of checking in, tending and expressing gratitude.</blockquote><p>It’s the same ceremony I experience when seeking out wild mushrooms, bay nuts (a local substitute for coffee and chocolate), elderberries (syrup for health and immunity) and kaffir limes from a tree I helped plant 10 years ago.</p><p>Participating in harvest requires giving back; I regularly plant trees to build habitat and to harvest from in future years. Foraging for food provides boundless strategies for meeting our nutritional needs “for free,” but in a way that redefines our place as stewards of our home.</p><h3>Gift of Knowledge</h3><p>In 2013, I felt called to move from the nonprofit space where I had been working into business. Whereas the conventional pathway exalted higher degree education, every bone in my body felt a dissonance at pursuing an MBA. I wasn’t convinced that it would teach me what I was yearning to learn: radical new strategies to remake our world based on economic principles of abundance, reciprocity and enoughness.</p><p>Instead, I pursued a relationship with the co-founders of <a href="http://www.lifteconomy.com/about/">LIFT Economy</a>, impact consultants and entrepreneurs, who were willing to gift their knowledge of next economy business principles. I spent the first two years receiving exquisite training in an “apprenticeship” program that ultimately led to my becoming co-owner of the company.</p><p>They saw my lack of an MBA as an asset, because it meant that firstly, I was not in debt — and by extension of that I was in accord with values of thrift and economy that define our work — and secondly, I was not indoctrinated by the norms of current economics. What surprised me was the amount of trust that we experienced in those first years: trust I would ultimately give back to others.</p><p>Today, I am a partner/worker-owner at LIFT Economy with equal decision-making power in the company. My day-to-day work is dedicated to creating, modeling and sharing a locally self-reliant economy that works for the benefit of all life. We counsel local businesses on ways to allocate funds to redistribute wealth, improve profitability and create ecological resilience.</p><p>I also offer these skills in exchange for the land bases that feed me. For example, a local farm, <a href="http://www.singingfrogsfarm.com/">Singing Frogs Farm</a>, trades my services for a membership in its no-till community supported agriculture farm just a few miles down the road. Each week, I pick up a box of herbs, veggies and staples from the land, and a newsletter that shares stories of farming that week, with endearing photos of heart-shaped carrots. In exchange, I help the farm deepen its expression of values and grow its impact. To be above-board we need to disclose the services we receive on our tax returns, but we save the dollars we would have spent to pay for these services outright.</p><p>I am also inspired by other people’s stories of leaning into the gift economy. A friend traded his labor to learn to build an Aleutian kayak. And Arrow, the business manager of <a href="https://www.nativestarquilts.com/about/">Owinza</a>, a worker-owned quilting cooperative in South Dakota, describes how her father built dozens of houses in compensation for a home of his own, all materials included. Each instance of trade is one less dollar circulating and one more heart engulfed in treasuring handcrafted skills and critical knowledge for survival.</p><h3>Need for Belonging</h3><p>Of course, bartering doesn’t come easy to a lot of people. The fear lies in the negotiation, which requires being honest about personal needs. But the rewards for this act of courage are greater: deep connection, exponential growth in our level of care for one another and an increased ability to withstand and respond to crisis.</p><p>Researchers are learning that our fundamental human need for belonging actually gives us an evolutionary edge, keeping us in communities working toward shared aims. It is a freedom to walk in the world knowing that you will be cared for, no matter how big or small your bank account. I encourage you to pursue this freedom. Barter, trade and gift have offered a daily opportunity to affirm my sense of belonging, whereas cash and credit have felt divisive and isolating by comparison.</p><p>I am a living commitment to regenerating California soils, water and community. I arrived at this purpose statement during coaching sessions with a mentor, and in exchange, I helped him with garden design and labor. Sometimes I struggle with whether that was enough of a payment. In some ways it’s much harder to barter than to simply write a check (which cleanly and neatly excuses me of further accountability).</p><p>The truth is, there will never be a way to pay him back, and tying myself in a state of eternal debt is actually a beautiful thing: It holds us accountable to one another as extended family and puts us in a state of perpetual service.</p><p>If everyone practiced these ways of transacting business, they might feel more indebted — not financially, but to each others’ humanity. How much more thoughtfulness, care and concern would we express to one another on a daily basis?</p><blockquote>It is fascinating how comfortable the West is with financial debt, and yet how starkly averse we are to accumulating this “emotional indebtedness.”</blockquote><p>What would our world look like if this were flipped? Imagine if people hesitated when they swiped their credit card but freely accumulated a “community balance,” a debt ledger reflecting items bought and sold on the basis of transacting kindness, trust and a commitment in return.</p><p>Yet, I do still earn money and engage in the financial realm. So the question is, what do I do with the money I earn now? Where can I invest financial wealth to accelerate the creation of a world that I know is possible, one in which needs are met for everyone (non-human species included), with equal abundance? How can we cultivate increased resilience from global markets and independence from our reliance on fossil fuel use?</p><p>Through my own investments I am learning strategies for answering these questions. My company has channeled more than $1 million to women and minority-owned businesses via the <a href="http://www.lifteconomy.com/forceforgood/">Force for Good Fund</a> launched in 2016.</p><p>I am learning the levers for using barter, gift and money to move us closer toward an abundance economy. I can only imagine what gifts radical reciprocity will bring to you, and to your neighbors too.</p><p><em>This article was featured in </em><a href="https://www.dumbofeather.com/product/issue-55/"><em>Issue 55 of Dumbo Feather — “Creating the next economy.”</em></a><em> B the Change gathers and shares the voices from within the movement of people using business as a force for good and the community of</em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/"><em> Certified B Corporations</em></a><em>. The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the nonprofit B Lab.</em></p><figure><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dLNTcwuxtfQeTB1-qIx3Ig.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a55679a2a1e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine/reaping-and-sharing-the-benefits-of-radical-reciprocity-4a55679a2a1e">Reaping-and Sharing-the Benefits of &#39;Radical Reciprocity&#39;</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine">B The Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Paul Hawken Is a Solutions Man]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/b-magazine/paul-hawken-is-a-solutions-man-e8065dc2a6c6?source=rss-b70d7e2e8266------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e8065dc2a6c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[earth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[changemaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change-adaptation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interview]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dumbo Feather]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Apr 2018 14:27:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-03T14:44:46.535Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The most comprehensive plan ever proposed to reverse global warming</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/476/1*OdlJX7tPN5kc00yvO63sHQ.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>“One problem with climate change is that there is no end to it in anybody’s sense of the future. The science is extraordinary but the way the science has been communicated has been inept because the emphasis has been on fear, dread and gloom. … The way climate change has been communicated is guaranteed to make most people feel like there’s not much they can do — that it’s too complicated.”</blockquote><p><em>Interview with Paul Hawken by Livia Albeck-Ripka, </em><a href="https://www.dumbofeather.com/conversations/paul-hawken-is-a-solutions-man/"><em>originally published by Dumbo Feather</em></a></p><p>On May 3, 2009, <a href="http://www.paulhawken.com/">Paul Hawken</a> stood before the graduating class of the University of Portland. He’d been asked to deliver a commencement address that was “direct, naked, taut, honest, passionate, lean, shivering, startling and graceful.” No pressure, he joked to his audience. Rousing the spirits of a few hundred young people embarking on a century of climate change, terrorism and extinction was, he knew, no small feat. “You are graduating to the most amazing and stupefying challenge ever bequested to any generation,” he told them.</p><p>When Paul was a young man, the world had other problems, many of which persist today: the war in Vietnam, civil rights abuses, racism. At just 18, he became Martin Luther King Jr.’s press coordinator, helping to organise the historic March on Montgomery. He photographed voter registration drives in Bogalusa, Louisiana and Florida. Later, in Mississippi, he captured images of the Ku Klux Klan — the group kidnapped Paul and held him prisoner.</p><p>At 20, Paul moved into business, opening one of America’s first natural food stores, Erewhon. With every step he’s taken since that time — whether as an author, entrepreneur or businessperson — protecting the environment has been his clear, committed path. He’s set up garden supply and solar energy companies. He’s taught organisations how to transition to renewable energy as head of the United States’ arm of The Natural Step. He’s consulted with businesses, governments and civic groups and written multiple books — one of which, Natural Capitalism, former President Bill Clinton described as among the five most important books in the world. His latest effort, <a href="http://www.drawdown.org/"><em>Drawdown</em></a>, is a handbook that, for the first time ever, lists and ranks the top 100 solutions to climate change.</p><p><a href="https://www.dumbofeather.com/"><em>Dumbo Feather</em></a><em> is part of the community of Certified B Corporations. </em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/#btc"><em>Learn more about this growing movement</em></a><em> of people using business as a force for good, and sign up to receive the </em><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58#btc"><em>B the Change Weekly newsletter</em></a><em> for more stories like this one, delivered straight to your inbox once a week.</em></p><p>Despite his accolades, Paul is softly spoken. He gives opinions tentatively and without bravado. Just a few days before we spoke, U.S. President Donald Trump had pulled out of the Paris climate accords. I don’t ask Paul whether this makes him feel pessimistic, because I know the answer. That day in Portland, he told the graduates, “When asked if I am pessimistic or optimistic about the future, my answer is always the same: ‘If you look at the science about what is happening on earth and aren’t pessimistic you don’t understand data. But if you meet the people who are working to restore this earth and the lives of the poor, and you aren’t optimistic, you haven’t got a pulse.’”</p><p><strong>LIVIA ALBECK-RIPKA: We are going through this moment of political upheaval — I was wondering, do you see any parallels between now and when you were young and involved in the Civil Rights Movement?</strong></p><p>PAUL HAWKEN: Not really. In some ways, the environment has always been about human rights. Addressing <a href="https://www.dumbofeather.com/categories/climate-change/">climate</a> is a human rights issue for sure. And the Civil Rights Movement was a human rights issue. So in that sense they overlap. But at that time, you had such violent responses to the assertion of voting and human rights in the South that it galvanised the whole country to support the Civil Rights Movement, pass the Voting Rights Act and more. Today, we have a divided country. That’s a big difference. You have the alt-right and the birth of proto-fascism in the United States, and its roots are understandable. But the rise of a militant and violent right is very different to the rise of a leader like Martin Luther King, who spoke to a cause which was unimpeachable in terms of its justice and fairness.</p><p><strong>So climate change and environmental issues seem to be a more difficult cause for people to get behind?</strong></p><p>One problem with climate change is that there is no end to it in anybody’s sense of the future. The science is extraordinary but the way the science has been communicated has been inept because the emphasis has been on fear, dread and gloom. And it’s been communicated in a type of lingo and jargon that is remote from almost everyone. Limits have been described in terms of “2° Celsius,” which just doesn’t mean anything. It’s an atmospheric measure and Americans particularly don’t understand it because they don’t use Centigrade. But putting that aside, it’s abstract, a concept, a number. The way climate change has been communicated is guaranteed to make most people feel like there’s not much they can do — that it’s too complicated.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*thuFRpTkQzpHheIQtFBlWg.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the Civil Rights Movement, when you saw people being set upon by German shepherds, fire hoses and truncheons because they wanted the constitutionally-guaranteed right to vote, it had a significant emotional impact: This was so wrong. Climate change doesn’t have that defining moment. The moral weight of it is mostly invisible; people can’t see it. I doubt that Syrian refugees understand that they are in the plight they’re in because of the failure of the wheat crop caused by the drought that lasted over four years. You step back and you look at the deracination of the agricultural community in Syria causing tens of thousands of unemployed impoverished young men to go to the city. That’s incendiary tinder for terrorism and demagoguery. Jobless, hungry youth looking for identity against a corrupt regime. But nobody can say absolutely that the Syrian refugee crisis was due to climate change.</p><p>You can only point out that what we’re seeing conforms exactly to what was foretold by science with respect to impacts. Those predictions include patterns of drought, torrential rainfall, heat waves, disruption, changing ocean currents and 500-year floods every 15 years. All that was predicted, but you can’t take any one of these events and say it is caused by global warming. All you can say is, “Global warming would cause these and this is the mechanism.” So you can’t relate weather directly to climate change, at least scientifically, on a case-by-case basis — which makes it very hard for the everyday person to relate to.</p><blockquote>On the other hand, the solutions to global warming have been remote, like solar farms and wind turbines. People don’t feel they have agency. The solutions to climate change have never been put forward in a graspable way so people could understand their role.</blockquote><p>Things like, “Eat smart, live closer to home, forgo fossil fuels, eat less meat” are what you will find if you Google the top solutions to climate change. These are proverbs, not solutions, and it doesn’t mean they’re not good things to do. Proverbs generally are. But they don’t give anybody a sense that their action is going to accumulate into a sufficient difference that will counter what is being predicted.</p><p><strong>So given this moral weight is, as you put it, often “invisible” — when did it become visible to you?</strong></p><p>I grew up outside and felt very safe there. I felt protected by nature. When I saw things like a new development, trees being cut down, a road scarring the landscape, the first RV camper in Yosemite, it was shocking. I would go, “Whoa, what’s that and why is it here?” I grew up with this sense of, “Don’t touch it, don’t do that.” A child can often see harm and damage where adults may see development or progress. An environmental way of seeing the world was imbued in me by my father’s friends. I grew up as a member of the Sierra Club and met David Brower when I was young. In my twenties I went into the natural food business which was all about the environment — the relationship between human beings and land practice and linking them together, the human health benefits of eating food grown in a healthy environment. My business made the connection between human and environmental health. That intention or purpose remains with me to this day. What’s interesting about <em>Drawdown</em> is that, with a couple of exceptions, all of the solutions regenerate human, ecological and economic wellbeing. They’re the same thing. Regenerating atmosphere is what happens when you regenerate a village, a fishery, a forest, a farm, a city, a transport system and the ocean. They’re all interconnected. We would want to do virtually every one of the solutions detailed in <em>Drawdown</em> even if there was no climate science, because they make things better on all levels.</p><p><strong>You do talk about climate change as an opportunity.</strong></p><p>Well, it’s a prepositional question. The despair and pessimism about climate change is a state of mind. And that state of mind comes from a preposition to: “Global warming is happening to us,” as if you’re the object, got the short end of the stick, are a victim. If you feel that way then you’re going to feel bad, you’re going to blame, be resentful, litigate, criticise — but is that where you want to live in your heart and mind? Is that helpful in the long term? The actual science created by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is an impeccable problem statement. And headlines and stories about climatic impacts validate the problem statement. Given that, the question is, “Okay, what do we do?” What we do at Project Drawdown is map, measure and model the 100 most substantive solutions to global warming, share what we discover, describe how these solutions are being done and measure how fast they are scaling.</p><p>The way I look at it, climate change is an offering, a gift, feedback from the atmosphere. All feedback is an instruction sheet on how an organism or system can change and transform.</p><p>That’s what climate change is offering us — a new story about how human beings should interact with each other in this heavenly home called Earth. Virtually everything we model in <em>Drawdown</em> (with two exceptions) makes this a better world on all levels — social, health, resources, economies, jobs. Consider this: we’re the only species on Earth that doesn’t have full employment. Yet there’s never been a time when there’s more work to be done, and not just work but good work, meaningful work, restorative work, regenerative work. Somehow we’ve gotten our shoelaces tied together such that we can’t imagine an economic system that offers full employment, that provides a sense of value, self-worth and dignity to every human being. Climate change offers us that possibility.</p><p><strong>But sometimes human beings don’t like negative feedback, do they?</strong></p><p>Well negative feedback isn’t necessarily negative. Negative feedback is information that modifies a harmful effect or activity from increasing. Positive feedback reinforces something that you may not want to enlarge. Positive feedback loops are already occurring due to climate impacts. Hotter, drier regimes increase forest fires and die-off, which releases more CO2 into the atmosphere, causing more heat, more fires. All systems require negative feedback in order to survive, live, grow and evolve. So negative feedback is what we want here. It is the guide to course correction.</p><p><strong>That’s easy for us to say in places where climate change is not yet wreaking havoc. But what about the human toll in places where climate change is already making life very difficult?</strong></p><p>The momentum of climate change is enormous and so too are the lag times. The atmosphere doesn’t care what we think or say. We know that climate disruption will increase in severity over the next 30 years. And even should we achieve drawdown, that point in time where greenhouse gases peak and decline on a year-to-year basis, it takes at least 20 years before cooling starts to happen. And at the outset it’s very slight. So humanity is in for the ride of our life, there’s no question about it. It is a perilous journey. So the question is, “Who do we want to be to each other and to ourselves on this journey? Because whoever I am to somebody else, I am to myself.”</p><p>And I’m writing a book called <em>Carbon</em>, I actually started it before <em>Drawdown</em>. <em>Carbon</em> is not about climate; it is a love story about life, about living systems. The first line of the book is, “Carbon is the element that hold hands and collaborates.” As an element, it’s gregarious. A shape shifter too — from diamonds to French fries to grasshoppers.</p><p><strong>It reminds me of Primo Levi’s “Carbon” chapter in The Periodic Table.</strong></p><p>Yes. When people finish the book, I hope they realise that in order for us to reverse climate change, we have to hold hands and collaborate! [<em>Laughs</em>]. We have to be like carbon. We have to be like life itself. What does life do? In the words of Janine Benyus, life creates the conditions conducive to life. Those are humanity’s marching orders. Our view of life has been a story of competition, dog eat dog (where did that phrase come from? Dogs do not eat dogs). What science knows now is that nature and living systems are pretty much one big co-op. What is actually happening is extraordinary symbiosis and support going on between organisms. Things which we thought were competitive have been revealed to be mutualistic. Science is revealing a kind of intelligence in life that we would do well to emulate.</p><p><strong>I’ve heard you make this distinction between dualism and non-dual mind before. I think every person has the capacity for both within them, just as systems do. Do you find yourself struggling with that?</strong></p><p>I’m dualistic every day. That’s the nature of the mind — to see itself as separate and distinct, and the rest of the world as other. The climate movement continues to speak of climate as if it’s other, something separate. It uses military words we apply to an enemy or foe: we’re fighting or combating climate change. I’m fascinated by that. Both linguistically — I’m an English major — and scientifically. The atmosphere is not the enemy. Our thinking is the problem. The atmosphere is just doing what atmospheres do. Saying you want to fight climate change is like saying you want to fight oceans, sunshine or the wind. That’s dualism on steroids. And that language isn’t helping us. It’s also incorrect, because you can’t fight change. Change happens every nanosecond in our universe, in nature and in our body. What we can do is work together to change our practices here on Earth. Carbon’s our ally, not the enemy.</p><p>You change your language, you change your mind. You change your mind, you change the world.</p><p><strong>In <em>Drawdown</em>, you describe how the build-up of greenhouse gases occurred in the “absence of human understanding” and that, therefore, to blame previous generations is wrong. Now we have the science, we have the facts, but we live in a world where people are still resistant. I think that’s the real “fight” we are in — one against the truth itself.</strong></p><p>You can’t fight truth, or untruth either. You embody truth. And for sure, in the age of the Internet, “A lie can go halfway across the world before truth can put its pants on.” That quote from Winston Churchill is based on a much older Arab proverb: “A good lie can walk from Baghdad to Constantinople while the truth is still looking for its sandals.” Either way, that’s the world we live in. It’s susceptible to enormous distortions; the United States is the most anti-science country in the world. If you poll the population as a whole, between 40 to 50 percent don’t believe in evolution. As an aside, we are not supposed to believe in science. Science is evidentiary. That being said, we are not going to make much headway telling other people they are wrong. It doesn’t work.</p><p><strong>Hopefully it should be a conversation rather than a kind of polemic</strong>.</p><p>Yeah, it should be. A true conversation is one where you want to truly understand what a person thinks and believes, and that means listening. It’s very instructive. You learn more by listening than when your mouth is open. I think the deepest human impulse is to want to understand and know. Most of the science communication around climate change is fear-based. Fear is great for soaking the news cycle with adrenalin, but it is a lousy way to create a movement to solve global warming. I think the climate movement has been its own enemy in using fear and righteousness as a means to motivate.</p><p><strong>When you say “the climate movement” — who is that?</strong></p><p>NGOs, activists, science writers. Ninety-nine percent of the communication has been about what’s going wrong and how fast it’s getting worse.</p><p>I do think that it’s an especially delicate balance in a world where the very act of putting truthful information out there has become radical. What should communicators do with information that is true, but might create fear? Should they not share it with the public?</p><p>Putting more science and facts into people’s heads isn’t going to change people. The theory is that if people knew more facts they would change. It is the opposite. More facts harden people’s positions. I was in Europe during the finals of Eurovision. There were more people in Spain who watched the finals of Eurovision, one of the worst singing contests in the world, than there are in the entire world climate movement. What does that tell us about how effectively we have communicated?</p><p><strong>Hey! [<em>laughs</em>] I love Eurovision. So do you see yourself as part of the climate movement?</strong></p><p>I see myself as a journalist, a researcher, a father, a husband, as somebody who’s always been curious. I’ve never been part of the climate movement as such. I’m a writer. I do what you do. I share stories.</p><p><strong>Are you an activist?</strong></p><p>If an activist means I want to sue Exxon, no I’m not an activist. Being a researcher and writer is a type of activism.</p><p>People need solutions. They don’t need data, they need narrative. We should be in the culture business, not in the science business, because we’re overwhelmed by the science. We’re scaring people shitless. It doesn’t give people a positive vision of the world. The only way we’re going to get out of this is to have a practical vision that we can all work towards.</p><p><strong>So in <em>Drawdown</em>, you lay out these solutions — in a very data-driven way, in fact.</strong></p><p>Right.</p><p><strong>So it’s interesting to hear you talk about narrative — which was so strong, by the way, in the commencement speech you gave in Portland in 2009. Maybe we need both? All of it? The data? The empathy? The narrative?</strong></p><p>Everything is needed. Although Drawdown is fact-based and laden, it is full of stories about real people in the world, like the man who stopped the desert, Yacouba Sawadogo in Burkina Faso. There’s Andrea Wulf on The Invention of Nature, the story of Alexander von Humboldt who first described climate change in 1831; stories about the first solar panel being installed in 1884 in New York City. If we didn’t have facts it wouldn’t be credible, however facts provide structure for narratives.</p><p><strong>When you were putting it all together, which narrative moved you most?</strong></p><p>They move me in different ways. The research we did on farmers moving to regenerative agriculture is good. These guys show you that addressing global warming is not a liberal agenda, it’s not a conservative agenda, it’s a human agenda.</p><p><strong>I read a piece today about the fact that the majority of American states investing in clean energy are Republican — just because it’s smart, economically. It makes sense.</strong></p><p>Yeah, absolutely. The book makes sense economically. Donald Trump is swimming upstream, Scott Pruitt’s mistaken too. But then what? What are you going to do? We need to focus on the solutions, and the red states in the middle of the country have the best wind regimes. That is where turbines are being made, sold and deployed.</p><p><strong>So what can individual people do?</strong></p><p>What people need is a menu; a sense of possibility. That’s what’s been lacking. The research we did has never been done. I get this question all the time — people raise their hand, “What should I do?” I think, I don’t even know this person. If I tell the person the answer to that question, they should run. I have no idea what you should do. Each individual is special, unique, has talent and ways of knowing the world and being in the world.</p><blockquote>What should you do? Depends what lights you up, what resonates. That’s what you should do. What should we do? Hold hands and collaborate; in other words, make a movement about solutions.</blockquote><p><strong>So what about you? What do you do?</strong></p><p>I do this interview [<em>laughs</em>]. I ride my bike but barely used it during the last few months due to the deadline on the book to be honest. My house has been solar clad for a long time. I have an old hybrid car, a gift. I am a vegetarian but eat pasture-raised eggs. I have an organic farm. I can go on but <em>Drawdown</em> is not about me. Every person has to figure what they’re going to do. What I do right now is try to change the conversation around climate change to solutions. I work with the Commonwealth of Nations, which is adopting <em>Drawdown</em> as a template for what may become the biggest climate initiative in the world.</p><p><strong>Tell me a bit more about your next project — <em>Carbon</em>.</strong></p><p><em>Carbon</em> coincided with <em>Drawdown</em> as an idea. The idea for both occurred at the same time. <em>Carbon</em> got sold before <em>Drawdown</em> however once it was sold my editor didn’t want to do <em>Drawdown</em> because climate and environmental books don’t sell. And that has been true. They thought the <em>Carbon</em> book would sell because it’s about nature. What turned them around about <em>Drawdown</em> was they talked to university faculty who said their students were longing for science-based books on solutions. So it was really the demand of younger people in educational institutions that caused Penguin to decide that it was the right book to do.</p><p>And as it turns out, it hit <em>The New York Times</em> bestseller list in its very first week. The <em>Carbon</em> book is very different. The cover looks like a blackboard and says, “A book about princes, frogs, fullerenes, fungus, fusion, biophony, beetles, voyages, stiction, fiction, drawdown, chirps, meshing, plasma, princesses, carbon seeds, highlines, sugars, anthromes, rewilding, resonance and earthlings” and, in parentheses, “and the future of civilisation” — with a smiley face. It’s actually a fantastic voyage. It is not a polemic.</p><p><strong>And you said it was a love story?</strong></p><p>Yeah, absolutely!</p><p><strong>Between… you and carbon?</strong></p><p>Not me and carbon per se. You can’t love a molecule. You love what happens when carbon molecules mix it up.</p><p>[<em>Laughs</em>].</p><p>It’s about the gregariousness of carbon as an element and all the things that are made of it; how life interacts. We’re carbon life forms. We know that but we forget that. I sometimes wonder about why pessimism has become so embedded in our culture. Why is that? Is that about identity?</p><p><strong>So you’ve been noticing this kind of embedded pessimism lately?</strong></p><p>I am seeing how attached people are to the pessimism and cynicism: “Game over, can’t be done.” It’s not that they are right or wrong so much as they’re so emotionally attached to the identity that cynicism gives them on this issue. I don’t see that in the Midwest. I don’t see it in the South. I see it here in the San Francisco Bay Area where, arguably, you’ve got great literacy.</p><p><strong>Do you hope that you will see changes in your lifetime? Do you believe that you will?</strong></p><p>I see change every day. I don’t have a threshold that defines change in a bigger way. I think we’re going to be shocked at how fast some of these solutions grow and displace fossil fuels. I think it’s going to cause economic dysfunction both on the positive and negative side. I think the rate of change is exponential right now with respect to many of the technologies. I think we’re going to surprise ourselves with how quickly we’re making this transition from non-renewable to renewable. The International Energy Agency has underestimated the growth of solar and wind every single year for 20 years. Nuclear energy and coal are no longer economic. When it comes to mobility, Apple, Tesla, GM, Ford, Daimler, Toyota, Google are all focussing on advanced vehicles. It’s going to be one of the biggest businesses in the world. They’re not fools. Tim Cook is not a fool. Lyft knows, Uber knows, they all know what’s coming. It’s kind of like the beginning of the PC revolution. So many companies vying to be the winner. Who is going to win the electric vehicles versus advanced vehicles race? No idea. Nobody thought IBM would lose. The electric grid companies are looking a bit worried because their business model may be gone in 10 years due to home energy storage combined with solar. Let’s say you live down the street from other people who are generating their energy. If they decide to link their systems together, swap each other’s energy as needed, the utility business is gone. That’s what’s coming.</p><p><em>B the Change gathers and shares the voices from within the movement of people using business as a force for good and the community of </em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/"><em>Certified B Corporations</em></a><em>. The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the nonprofit B Lab.</em></p><figure><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5dou-9mFqyTQVg9AbRsjqg.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e8065dc2a6c6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine/paul-hawken-is-a-solutions-man-e8065dc2a6c6">Paul Hawken Is a Solutions Man</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine">B The Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Look at Wholeheartedness with Brené Brown]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/b-magazine/a-look-at-wholeheartedness-with-bren%C3%A9-brown-c8d8f3fd8b63?source=rss-b70d7e2e8266------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c8d8f3fd8b63</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tedtalks]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[changemaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vulnerability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dumbo Feather]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Mar 2018 12:26:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-22T12:26:00.822Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Her Grounded Theory Reveals How Vulnerability Brings Us Closer</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uc4xrINN-19RH5AtnxH0cA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>By Berry Liberman</em></p><p>Brené Brown is everything you would expect her to be — warm, funny, gracious, articulate, and engaging. That’s partly why millions of people have watched her TED talk, <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/brene_brown_on_vulnerability">“The Power of Vulnerability,”</a> which was nominated by <a href="https://www.dumbofeather.com/">Dumbo Feather</a> readers as one of their standout favorites. A professor of sociology at Houston University, she studies human connection and all the nasty things that get in the way, like shame and fear.</p><p>In her talk, she candidly describes a day in 2006 when, while putting together years of collected data, an unexpected discovery caused her to have a breakdown, or “spiritual awakening,” as her therapist calls it. Brené had identified a unique group of people who “fully embraced vulnerability … (who) believed what made them vulnerable made them beautiful.” She named them the Wholehearted.</p><p>The scary part was that her life looked nothing like theirs. Like most of us, Brené avoided feeling vulnerable at all costs. But it was costing her too much. What had begun as a research project became a calling.</p><p><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/community/dumbo-feather"><em>Dumbo Feather</em></a><em> is part of the community of Certified B Corporations. </em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/#btc"><em>Learn more about this growing movement</em></a><em> of people using business as a force for good, and sign up to receive the </em><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58#btc"><em>B the Change Weekly newsletter</em></a><em> for more stories like this one, delivered straight to your inbox once a week.</em></p><p>Her honesty about her own story has seen millions of people connect with her and realize that we are not alone. Sitting in the uncomfortable space we all try to avoid, Brené asks the questions we run from: What makes us feel shame? What makes us afraid? Why do we never feel we are enough?</p><p>As it turns out, all of us have a heartbreaking story to tell, and all of us are capable of connection. It’s why we’re here.</p><p>On the day of our interview, a wild storm whipped through and the babysitter was 45 minutes late. As our (so carefully coordinated) interview time drew nearer, I was a dangerously disintegrating shame minefield. As a mother juggling work and family, I always walk a tenuous line between being on top of things and total chaos. There’s also this awful, sinking feeling that everyone is watching.</p><p>I had to answer this call to Brené, with my 20-month-old daughter, Willow, on my lap, waving and smiling sheepishly. I was sorry, but could I call back in 10 minutes? Brené laughed a big, hearty, Texan laugh and almost cheered. Phew. Fingers crossed the babysitter came in 10 minutes.</p><p><strong>BERRY LIBERMAN: I figured there was no better person to be imperfect with! (laughing)</strong></p><p>BRENÉ BROWN: Around motherhood issues especially … yeah, in fact I was like, Oh good, she’s gotta call me back! I’m frantically texting my daughter saying, ‘Back door open, take dog out, start homework immediately!’ We can do it all, we just can’t do it all at the same time</p><p><strong>Your TED Talk changed my life.</strong></p><p>Wow.</p><p><strong>It’s true. You do such meaningful work that traverses science and the unquantifiable realms of the heart and soul. How do you describe what you do exactly?</strong></p><p>Very specifically, I’m a Grounded Theory researcher. The idea behind Grounded Theory is that you don’t take existing theories and prove or disprove them, you develop new theories based on the lived experience of people. I focus on a question that I want the answer to, and I sit down across from people and conduct long interviews or in focus groups. I ask very open-ended questions and take anthropological field notes on the responses, and I then analyze that data and look for patterns and themes and categories — where I hear something over and over so much that it becomes a predictable pattern in people’s behavior.</p><p>So, for example, when I was looking at the question of men and women who feel a deep sense of love and belonging, what is it that they have in common? The primary thing that emerged from that question is that they believe they are <em>worthy</em> of love and belonging. And so then the question becomes, what does that look like? How can I get my hands and head around that? Do you just wake up one morning and say ‘I’m worthy’ and angels sing and it’s great?</p><p>No. They had behaviors and choices in common. They had ways of thinking about the world in common. They cultivate creativity in their lives and they work mindfully to let go of constantly comparing who they are and what they produce to other people. They absolutely honor things like play and rest. They stay very aware of the culture that tells us being exhausted is a status symbol and they work to overcome that.</p><p>Before I did this research, I had no idea what the values were that these people held or what their everyday choices and behaviors were that aligned with those values. … The thing about Grounded Theory is that there are no outliers. So if you didn’t fit the pattern that was emerging, I would have to change the theory that I’m developing to fit everything.</p><p>The goal for Grounded Theorists is to develop theories that explain basic social processes, and to name what we find in such a way that it is both compelling and feels like truth to the people reading it. So we often end up naming behaviors that we engage in that we’ve never even thought about or discussed.</p><p><strong>And you call it data with a soul.</strong></p><p>Basically, with the type of research I do, I’m a story-catcher. I listen to people’s stories and then subject those stories to a rigorous methodology of making sense of them. I want to come up with concepts and ideas that are broad enough to capture everyone’s experience but deep enough to be meaningful.</p><p>So when you ask people to talk about connection, they talk about disconnection, they talk about betrayal, they talk about being hurt. If you bring up the fear of disconnection, which is shame, and you say, “And here’s what gets in the way (of connection),” everyone goes, “Oh my God, you’re not supposed to know that.”</p><p>I was just so fascinated by this idea that the things that make us feel the most alone are really what connect us the most passionately, and that’s our fear of not being enough. After falling apart, and talking about that honestly and including storytelling and being more vulnerable in the way I present the information, I think that’s what shifted everything.</p><p><strong>What gives you the courage to say, OK, if I lean into the discomfort of these feelings and name them, then I can make more authentic choices and be more authentically myself?</strong></p><p>Sometimes I feel like a cheater when it comes to this. The truth is really, because of my work, I know everyone has a story that will break your heart. Everyone is completely feeling isolated and alone and ‘less-than,’ and those feelings are the one thing that we all share in common.</p><p>I know there’s no mansion that I could pull up in front of, no perfect group of Junior League moms or no group of successful CEOs that I could ever look at in the eye and believe that there’s no broken-heartedness there. I’ve been doing this work too long. I think courage is the ability to tell your story. I’ve heard so many stories in my life that I know I’m not alone. Everyone has a struggle.</p><p>It’s what I say about empathy in my shame work. If you have a petri dish and you have shame in there, this pervasive feeling of not being good enough and not being ‘whatever’ enough — thin enough, rich enough, popular enough, promoted enough, loved enough. It only needs three things to survive in this little Petri dish and actually to grow exponentially and creep into every corner and crevice of your life—and that is secrecy, silence and judgement.</p><p>If you have the same amount of shame in a Petri dish and you douse it with some empathy—you share your story with someone who can hear you and look back at you and say you’re not alone—shame dies. You’ve created a hostile environment for those gremlins who keep saying to you, ‘You’re not enough, you’re not enough, nothing you do is enough.’</p><blockquote>Courage is the ability to tell your story. I’ve heard so many stories in my life that I know I’m not alone. Everyone has a struggle.</blockquote><p>So I believe with my whole heart there are only two options: to let what scares us stay inside of us — and fester and grow and take over everything — or to share it. I think that we have to share our stories with people who’ve earned the right to hear them.</p><p>We hide our vulnerability because it’s quite a journey to find the ‘grown-ups’ who can hold the space and sit into the discomfort with you.</p><p>In my experience as a researcher, if you have one or two people in your life who you can really, honestly share with, you are <em>beyond</em> lucky. There are many people who die with their stories in them. And those stories become malignant and they metastasize and they eat us alive.</p><p><strong>You coined the phrase ‘Wholehearted.’ What does that mean?</strong></p><p>One of the things that’s very important in Grounded Theory is that when you identify a category that helps explain a basic social process, you name it with something that’s powerful, accurate and resonates deeply with people. Having spent six years studying shame, scarcity and fear, I wanted to turn that research upside down.</p><p>Going back into the data, there were clearly people who stand right next to us in this culture of scarcity, of ‘not good enough’, but they wake up in the morning and they say, ‘Phew, it’s scary out there, I’ve no idea what’s going on, I’m really imperfect, I’m feeling incredibly vulnerable, but I’m enough.’</p><p>I wanted to know what they had in common. I wanted to understand people who, despite shame and fear and scarcity, engaged with the world from a place of worthiness. So I thought about what that meant. I can’t call them ‘the people who engage with the world from a place of worthiness’ because that’s not very catchy! (laughs) You know, the funny thing was the first thing that actually came to mind was, these are <em>abundance</em> people. But the data didn’t bear that out.</p><p><strong>What do you mean?</strong></p><p>I always thought of the opposite of scarcity being abundance, but these are people who are as wary of abundance as they are of scarcity. These were folks who really believed in <em>enough</em>. I thought about that.</p><p>There are two axioms for grounded theory … ‘everything is data’ and ‘trust and emergence’. Trust if you’re doing your job and coding the data and listening to people that the theory will emerge from the data. You don’t have to make shit up. You don’t have to guess. It’ll emerge. Which I experienced as very true, because what emerged was not what I <em>wanted</em> to emerge.</p><p>When I started thinking about it, I just kept saying to myself, like poker, ‘Man, these people are all in.’ They’re just living and loving fully. Then I thought, there’s nothing half-hearted about these folks. They feel the dark emotions wholeheartedly, they feel joy wholeheartedly. So then I came up with Wholehearted.</p><p>The purpose of Grounded Theory is to identify basic social processes so that people understand more about what they do, and often what you end up doing is naming things that people are engaged in every day and then when you tell them about it they go, “Oh my God! Yeah! I just never thought about it as a concept or a word, but yeah, I do that!”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/682/1*GwiLw8pvCRu2MUnOX_5pbw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>There was a point in your research where you saw a pattern, you started to develop a conclusion or concept of Wholeheartedness, and then something happened to you.</strong></p><p>Oh yeah. It was the shit-list basically. I was coding data and I was looking at all these words and these phrases and these incidents that were re-emerging and re-emerging and re-emerging, and I started listing them on big poster-sized post-it notes all over my house. Authenticity. Creativity. Rest. Compassion. Boundaries. Worthiness. Joy.</p><p>Then I started making a separate list of words and ideas that clearly the men and women who we’re trying to learn more from, the Wholehearted, were mindfully trying to stay away from: Comparison. Perfection. Status. Exhaustion. Basically I just saw that whole list of, overly simplified, the ‘do nots’ just defining my life. That’s exactly what my life looked like.</p><p>I’m looking at this data saying, ‘Here are the guideposts, here are the properties of this category of worthiness,’ and I’m living contrary to them.</p><p>Had you asked me — before I started analyzing that data — what I thought the Wholehearted have in common, I would have honest-to-god told you, I think they’re very knowledgeable about shame. (laughs) Because that was me! Because I thought, <em>I frickin’ earned that!</em> The answer to Wholeheartedness should be a deep understanding of shame! Because I spent six years studying this shit that no one wants to talk about and that should be the prize, right? And it wasn’t. The prize was not that. I would rephrase that from a research perspective. They did have a healthy understanding of shame, but that was just a small part of it.</p><p>So as I started trying to understand the emotions, thoughts and behaviors behind worthiness, what I ran into were a lot of behaviors and thoughts that I didn’t have. … The two things that the Wholehearted have in common that are the most important to understand are worthiness and vulnerability. An expertise in shame does not make you a person who has a deep sense of worthiness.</p><p>Understanding vulnerability does not make you someone who can hold space for vulnerability. I became a researcher, really, specifically, to avoid vulnerability. So really for me my breakdown was about putting the data away. I trusted myself far more professionally than I did personally and I knew I trusted the data. Had these ideas emerged in therapy for me, I would have been like, <em>hell no</em>. But they emerged from data. For me that’s as real as it gets because I know the process, I know it.</p><p>I needed to figure out a way to experience and be OK with vulnerability and to cultivate worthiness in my life that did not hinge upon things like being a perfect mom, being a perfect professor, teaching evaluations, tenure, the size of my house, what car I drove, how my kids did. Clearly, what emerged was that worthiness has no prerequisites. Vulnerability is not something we can spend our lives outrunning and outsmarting, and I think I tried to do that.</p><p><strong>Was there a difference between men and women in your research?</strong></p><p>Around shame and worthiness? Yes and no. If shame washes over me, it’s gonna be the same as if it washes over a man. Shame is biology, shame is biography. We have a huge physiological response to it, and it triggers all the old messages.</p><p>What is very different is that the messages and expectations that trigger shame are organized by gender. … For women it’s be everything to everyone and happy while you’re doing it. For men what drives shame is do not be perceived as weak. I didn’t study men for the first four years that I did the work. It’s only been in the last five years that I have a full understanding of how shame works with men, and the next thing I’ll be doing will be bringing that to light. It was possibly the most heart-wrenching work I’ve ever done.</p><p>Show me a woman who can sit with a man in vulnerability, and I’ll show you someone who’s done her work. Show me a man who can sit with a woman in struggle and not try to fix it but just hear her and just hold space for it, and I’ll show you a guy who’s done his work.</p><p>That’s it. It’s how we’re programmed. I’m programmed to look for the knight in shining armor; he’s programmed to fix things. It’s a little bit in our DNA, but it’s really the culture. That’s why men are lonely and they die earlier and they die more violent deaths … it’s not good.</p><p>The consequences of shame are lethal. It robs us of who we are. People die in its wake. You take hopelessness and you compound it with shame and you’ve got violence. There’s nothing constructive about shame, and no one will talk about it. We hate it.</p><p><strong>Inside this journey of your research, collecting all this data and thousands of interviews, who was Brené at the start going into the research and then you talk about having a breakdown, a spiritual awakening, and then who emerged?</strong></p><p>(long silence) That’s a hard question.</p><p><strong>Would you like me to rephrase it?</strong></p><p>No. (silence) I think going into it, phew… Going into it I was absolutely just a head person. I thought I could think my way and analyze my way and study my way to a sense of worthiness, a sense of being enough, a sense of joy and love and belonging. I still have a profound respect for science and research, but there’s something … my call to do this work is different now.</p><p>There’s a deeply human spirit that is more important to understand than maybe anything else. We’re never going to have all the answers, but that just being in the question is what it’s really all about. I guess I started as someone looking for answers and ended as someone who has found joy living in the questions.</p><p><strong>You did all of this as a mother. How did you do that? How, as a mother, did you go from living with one paradigm to having a breakdown of that paradigm and finding a new one?</strong></p><p>You know, that day in November of 2006 when I was coding all that data, one of the things I was thinking about a lot was parenting. One of the things that emerged during that transformative four-day period was really about parenting. It’s probably what drove me to get help.</p><p>What emerged from the research—along with concepts like creativity, Wholeheartedness, authenticity, belonging and rest—was the idea that we can’t give our children what we don’t have. When I started seeing all these concepts emerge I’m like, where do these come from?</p><p>I honestly thought that I could give Ellen and Charlie what I didn’t have. I thought I could raise them with a sense of worthiness without having one. I thought I could raise them with shame resilience because I knew all about it, not that I really had a lot. I thought I could give them a joy and a love of being creative through really being creative.</p><p>What clearly emerged during that four-day period is that where we are on our own journey toward Wholeheartedness is a much more accurate predictor of how our children will do than what we know about parenting, and I think that was enough for me to say, ‘I’m not living like this any longer. Now that I know I’m heading the wrong way, I’m not gonna keep walking knowing that.’</p><p>It is not the job of parents to have children and then spend the rest of our lives after we have them setting them up for a happy life. The majority of important stuff that happens to us when we’re adults will happen to us after we’re parents — we will bury our parents, we will build our careers, we will struggle through marriages — all those things with kids in tow.</p><p>Once you have kids, it’s not time to set your life aside and figure out how to get them on the right track. It’s time to live your life in a way that we want our children to. So for me, ironically, I became more passionate about my work and less guilty about it. I want my children to do work they love and I want them to grow up seeing me doing work I love. I want them to, in some way, contribute to the big wholehearted journey that we’re making as a collective.</p><p>I don’t think Wholeheartedness is something we achieve. I think it’s something we spend our life walking toward. The metaphor of the North Star. You never get there, but you know if you’re walking in the right direction.</p><p><em>This article has been edited and condensed from a previous version published by </em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/community/dumbo-feather"><em>Dumbo Feather</em></a><em>. B the Change gathers and shares the voices from within the movement of people using business as a force for good and the community of</em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/"><em> Certified B Corporations</em></a><em>. The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the nonprofit B Lab.</em></p><figure><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dLNTcwuxtfQeTB1-qIx3Ig.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c8d8f3fd8b63" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine/a-look-at-wholeheartedness-with-bren%C3%A9-brown-c8d8f3fd8b63">A Look at Wholeheartedness with Brené Brown</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine">B The Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Krista Tippett Enriches the Debate]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/b-magazine/krista-tippett-enriches-the-debate-6328ed2f3679?source=rss-b70d7e2e8266------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6328ed2f3679</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conversations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dumbo Feather]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Mar 2018 20:45:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-19T16:12:07.552Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An Interview with the Creator and Host of On Being</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h59SZ3CqbCz1l2KTGDmgiA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Berry Liberman on Krista Tippett:</strong></p><p>There aren’t many people who will get me out of bed at five in the morning. Krista Tippett is most definitely one of them. She’s the creative force behind <a href="https://onbeing.org/">On Being</a>, a radio show and podcast that reaches 1.5 million listeners a month on topics ranging from religion and poetry to science and sound. Awarded the <a href="https://www.neh.gov/about/awards/national-humanities-medals">National Humanities Medal</a> from Barack Obama for “thoughtfully delving into the mysteries of human existence,” Krista has spent her life exploring the human condition in all its complexity — its darkness as well as its great potential.</p><p>Growing up in Oklahoma, the granddaughter of a Southern Baptist preacher, Krista felt the gap between what religion was teaching — a fearful lens of the world — and the everyday kindness and openness of her community. After graduating from Brown University she went to Bonn, West Germany in 1983 on a Fulbright Scholarship to study politics in Cold War Europe. This led to work as assistant to the US Ambassador to West Germany. Her time there, witnessing power up close, propelled Krista to pursue a Masters of Divinity from Yale, intensifying her sense that more meaningful dialogue could be had around the moral questions of our time.</p><p>Krista began to imagine radio conversations that spoke to this impulse — that wrestled and explored the inner workings of faith, science and ideas in a way that could enrich public life. On Being has become the connective tissue, a place to gather and learn about meaningful work and ideas being generated in the world. In my mind, this conversation with Krista has been happening through the podcasts for months now. She has become a familiar voice in my life, a daily ritual, a trusted companion on the quest for meaning and wisdom. I’m curious to know what she has gleaned from a life immersed in questions of the soul.</p><p>To my great delight I discover a voice of hope and reason, someone who sees “all this determined goodness, an abundance of good people and initiatives in the world” and understands that our mundane, messy, complicated lives are — when lived in the questions — an expression of what ultimately matters. Krista’s work illustrates that we can climb the highest mountains searching for answers, but the most muscular spiritual practice is one in which kindness, compassion and presence happen in the muck of the ordinary moment. Having spoken with some of the greatest spiritual leaders and thinkers of her time, Krista believes we are heading into an age of spiritual robustness, not bankruptcy.</p><p><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/community/dumbo-feather"><em>Dumbo Feather</em></a><em> is part of the community of Certified B Corporations. </em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/#btc"><em>Learn more about this growing movement</em></a><em> of people using business as a force for good, and sign up to receive the </em><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58#btc"><em>B the Change Weekly newsletter</em></a><em> for more stories like this one, delivered straight to your inbox once a week.</em></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>Berry Liberman:</strong> <strong>The first question I want to ask is the first question that you ask all of your guests: how would you describe the religious or spiritual background of your childhood?</strong></p><p><strong>Krista Tippett:</strong> Well, I had a Southern Baptist preacher grandfather who was the towering religious figure of my childhood. And church was not just a place you went. I mean, we actually went there a lot — three times a week. But it was a completely immersive religious culture. It was our friendship circle. It was the centre of culture in a small town in the Bible Belt. One thing I think a lot about as I get older is the gap between what I was being taught about religion, especially by my grandfather: it was a lot about rules. And it was mostly about what not to do.</p><p>It often had something to do with sex. It was always about the body. And it was about the body as dangerous. But the gap is that religion is pretty forbidding and fearful really — fearful of the world — and yet it’s also open and universal. My grandfather was the funniest person I knew. He had a huge heart. He was very passionate himself, which I think was why he was so attentive to how dangerous the body can be. So I internalised a lot of ideas about God and about the universe that were much more generous than the religion, than the explicit teachings. And as I’ve gotten older and worked in this field, that gap has been really defining for me. It sounds so obvious when I say it now! But maybe it’s kind of what I work through now in the work I do.</p><p><strong>You bring up something important there about belonging and religion. I was raised in an Orthodox Jewish tradition, although I personally don’t believe in God, but I deeply understand religion as community and belonging and, not necessarily tribalism, but story — which is a deep need for all human beings.</strong></p><p>You know, it’s always interesting to me when I talk to doctors who are learning to factor in people’s spiritual lives or religious identity into the care they provide and their prognosis. The way they define the effect of religion is about people having support networks. It’s about human connection and human support. I think that’s really stunning. Because that’s not necessarily what we think of when we think of religious institutions. But it is what matters to people and that’s what makes an imprint.</p><p><strong>It’s really important because religion has been so divisive and it has been so tribal and continues to be. And it’s so satisfying when you find your people. This is a huge question, but how do we open up the tribal lands and the tribal lines to belong to one another?</strong></p><p>Yeah. The word “belonging” has been so much on my mind lately. And it’s a word that gets at a lot of what we actually do need and what we long for. When we talk about the good that there is in a tribe, it’s that sense of belonging. And I honestly think that belonging is organic and that it’s real, it’s something we have to live into, but we actually create structures that work against it, which kind of make it invisible. It’s usually the violent and destructive manifestations of religion and religious identity that get all the attention. They get all the publicity. But the whole picture of religion in the world has a lot of beauty in it. It has a lot of music in it. It has a lot of art and it has a lot of quiet redemptive community. It’s not just throwing itself in front of microphones and cameras. So I’m really aware of that. But it’s also true that it is in our intimate human spaces — whether that’s a family or a church or a synagogue — that not only do we have our most intense belonging but it’s where our dark sides find expression too. Because religion touches such powerful places in us — when it is distorted, when it is mobilised in destructive ways, it is extremely powerful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/1*xRM7LpyF88Fkroxcz1XdvA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>I read that you’ve had psychotherapy?</strong></p><p>Yes, yeah. Uh huh.</p><p><strong>And I thought that was quite a sort of exquisite double-deep journey.</strong></p><p>[Laughs].</p><p><strong>The journey into therapy, which is the story of the self. And then the journey into all of this wisdom and richness of the ages. So tell me more about how your therapeutic journey has informed your exploration of the spiritual life?</strong></p><p>Well, I find that in ancient religious texts and any story or teaching that has survived millennia, that there’s some truth there. There’s something in there that human beings have recognised as true. I find there’s an exquisite psychological wisdom, a really sophisticated analysis of the human condition in our traditions, that we don’t often think of when we think of religion.</p><p>We think about teachings of God or something beyond us. But these are the places where we have really tried to grapple with the human condition in all its complexity — its darkness as well as its great potential.</p><p>I’ve written about reading the psalms when I was in the midst of my depression in my mid-thirties. And, you know, what’s so amazing about the psalms is that they really do give voice to the entire array of human emotion and potential — including murderous rage. It’s all there. And there’s a lot of raging against enemies which I never could really identify with. I mean, everything’s in there, from gratitude and joy and love to rage and misery and self-pity and a lot of talk of enemies. And then I started understanding that the ancient religious biblical scribes understood that those enemies can also be inside ourselves. And when I was in the midst of my depression that made a lot of sense to me.</p><p><strong>Right.</strong></p><p>Therapy absolutely saved my life for a couple of years. And I do think that one of the primary things I care about excavating from these traditions and these texts is a sophisticated analysis of who we are as human beings: the complexity of it, the richness of it, the paradox. And I actually think that all the lofty spiritual principles and aspirations require a certain amount of mental and emotional health. Right? I love this Buddhist language of having “mental hygiene.”</p><p><strong>Yes.</strong></p><p>And so I start to see that sophisticated understanding of the human condition not only in our traditions but also in something like therapy. Also in practices like yoga and meditation that work on all that is in our bodies and how our bodies and minds are connected. You know, it’s amazing that these ancient practices have carried that intelligence. And here we are, in the 21st century, able to see inside our brains and map that — that all of these practices are actually helping us provide something not necessarily lofty, but a basis for balance and health. I want us to be able to talk collectively about the spiritual evolution of our species. Like, where we’re going as a species. And these tools for mental hygiene, for spiritual grounding — however you want to use the word “spiritual” — provide a robust and reality-based understanding of the human condition. I think these are really the basic building blocks for progressing in a profound way.</p><p><strong>Everything you said is also my own hope and quest and work. And yet I have always felt excluded in so many ways from religion. How does the secular person searching for meaning stay open enough to listen to the richness of spiritual conversation?</strong></p><p>I think that’s getting so much easier all the time, right? I think we’re living in a remarkable time when spiritual identity, religious identity is no longer inherited like eye colour. And that’s been true for a long, long time in the history of our species. There’s all kinds of access to spiritual ideas, teachings, to spiritual technologies — which is how I think of meditation and yoga. And you can reach for that outside of any official identity. But interestingly as people go deeper on a spiritual path they often start reaching for a lot of the things that religion offers, including community. Right? And ritual. I think, and this gets back to the fact that we’re embodied and that means so much more than we’ve realised, ritual is something that we need and crave. And we actually create little rituals in our daily lives without calling it that.</p><p><strong>But there’s something really important about collective ritual and other religious traditions where you create containers for life passages. And grief.</strong></p><p>I also think what’s happening here is that this same energy is then rippling back and both challenging and questioning and revitalising the traditions. Because they do carry these rituals and this wisdom that is part of what we’re longing for.</p><p><strong>Do you belong to a community? Do you have a faith tradition that you adhere to or a spiritual practice?</strong></p><p>You know, right now I don’t. I don’t belong to a church. I do a lot of yoga. There’s a lot of bad yoga in the world just like there’s a lot of bad religion. But if you find a good yoga, it’s life-changing. I’m also very much an ideas person — I read, right? And what I read has changed over the course of time. There was a time when I read the <em>Book of Common Prayer</em> every night and found that incredibly meaningful, and I read a lot of amazing stuff for my work. A few years ago I interviewed <a href="http://onbeing.org/programs/karen-armstrong-freelance-monotheism/">Karen Armstrong</a>, a British writer who’s written a lot about religion in the 21st century. And she said she’s come to this conclusion that her work is her prayer. I don’t know if I would say it that way. But I do believe somehow that whatever spirituality and whatever religiosity is, these things emerge and deepen in the raw materials of our lives. And they are interwoven with what we do. It’s not a separate compartment. Which, as much as I said that my childhood religion was an immersive environment, when I left that environment, the whole institution stopped making sense. It was a separate world.</p><p><strong>For me, the word “spirituality” is entirely tangible and appealing. So the thought of spirituality not being a separate box is wonderful. Because it crept up on me, you know? The more I was doing my work with <em>Dumbo Feather</em>, which is similar to what you do…</strong></p><p>I learned. I knew about <em>Dumbo Feather</em> but I learned more and we’re such kindred projects.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/804/1*QJGZfS9z1PU3yxjFAA6w3A.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Yeah. I feel that. And it’s such a privilege. I realised that the more amazing people I interviewed, from Brené Brown to Parker Palmer, at some point the spiritual question arises. And I’ve also been in therapy for 11 years. And there’s only so far you can go before you suddenly hit this point and there’s something deeper, richer, bigger than you. This year has been very much about that for me. I went to Bhutan for 10 days. Left my family for the first time ever for that length of time. And I think I was viewing that spiritual question as a siloed thing. Parker Palmer in our last issue mentioned a Rilke quote: that we live into the answers. It seems to be similar to what you’re saying — that your life is the prayer. And that’s quite an exquisite thought.</strong></p><p>It is an exquisite thought! And it’s so different from the way these things have been taught to us. That it’s something you have to let settle in you and live, right? That you just decide: “Oh that’s right, my life is the prayer!” But even if it’s true we have to make it real. We have to make it three-dimensional. Because it’s still a whole new way of imagining ourselves. And imagining spirituality.</p><p><strong>What do you mean by that?</strong></p><p>I mean it is a radical thing, at least for me and the way I was raised, to insist that every moment, every encounter, that the most mundane, ordinary parts of our day are an expression of what ultimately matters. That sounds kind of lofty.</p><p>And so this task, this decision of saying, “Spirituality is in the elements of my everyday life, not in a corner somewhere, not in a separate experience” is big. John O’Donohue, the Irish poet — I wish you could have interviewed him, he died right after I interviewed him. He says: “Beauty is not all loveliness like” — in that wonderful Irish way — “Not all loveliness like.” Because when you talk about anything that’s deep and rich, even beauty, it has its messy places.</p><p><strong>It’s interesting because when I went to Bhutan I had a sort of angry reaction to — this is me revealing my shameful side — monasteries carved into the rock. I mean they were beautiful and it was an extraordinary human endeavour. But the mother in me — who’s in the muck and was far away from my children, missing them — didn’t want the monastery on the hill. I didn’t want the purified life. Couldn’t relate to it. Everything you’re saying is so much more human and relatable, it’s not transcendent.</strong></p><p>I love what you just said. And I think somehow the paradox is arriving at an understanding of transcendence that can only exist because it’s rooted in the muck. Right?</p><p><strong>Yeah.</strong></p><p>Which almost doesn’t make sense except we live it and it is real. I actually believe, I can’t really explain this, but I think somehow our capacity to really experience mystery and take it in is limited by how much we’re actually in our bodies. Like, how much we’re in the non-mysterious [laughs]. You know? The biological, the physical reality. And so one observation I have about my grandfather, who had a second-grade education and was fearful of a lot of things that he had every right to be fearful of: he grew up on the frontier. Not having sex until you were married actually made sense when childbirth was dangerous and sex led to pregnancy and pregnancy out of wedlock ruined lives. There was a lot of addiction in his family. There was no remedy for addiction. So a lot of these rules are about not drinking, not playing cards, not doing things that had addiction attached. And I understand that in the world in which he grew up, there were more perilous places from which people did not return. So that understanding and place of compassion has been a really important turning point for me. And I suspect, even like the Orthodox Judaism in which you grew up, there are rituals and a concern for purity, for example, that grew out of physical realities which no longer apply to the world we live in.</p><p><strong>Yeah, that’s really true.</strong></p><p>That there was actually an intelligence about the body behind what looked to us like really primitive practices. And now that intelligence doesn’t make sense but there was something honourable at its root. Yeah, I certainly think about that. What I also think about is how my grandfather was so fearful of physical reality — of the world. I think he actually had a great relationship with my grandmother. But they had a child who was stillborn. I mean, I think they were scared of all of this for good reason. And I almost feel like in putting up that firewall between oneself and one’s physical passions and the richness and ravages of the world, all he could hold onto in tradition were these rules that kept that at bay. And I think he was frightened of mystery. I don’t think he had been taught that he could love his questions as much as his answers, and that it was okay to have questions that just sat there and didn’t get answered. And I believe that limited his ability to experience mystery in the fullest sense.</p><p><strong>And it harks back to what you were saying about mental hygiene and having the ability to enter the darkness in ourselves, to enter relationships with our selves in a way that is not fearful and rageful.</strong></p><p>It’s a very strange thing about us as human beings. The classic historic question, the question of evil in the theodicy debate: “If there is a good God” — or the way I might say it now, “If there’s a loving intelligence, why is there so much suffering?” And that question to me remains sitting there. It doesn’t get answered. But on the other hand there’s something so strange and beautiful, kind of amazing about the fact that it is in that darkness that we grow. Now you have to be careful not to romanticise darkness and I think religion has sometimes romanticised suffering or dismissed it in some ways.</p><p><strong>Nominated it a noble place.</strong></p><p>Exactly. That’s not good. And everybody doesn’t survive, right? Everybody doesn’t survive depression or the multitudes of things we deal with. But the hardest things we deal with are also these incredible opportunities to move to a different place as a human being. And we encounter that again and again and again. And even when our children are little they have their small versions of this, right? You know that they have to fall down before they can walk. My kids are now 17 and 21. And the interesting thing, especially with my daughter, who’s 21 and has adult- sized problems [laughs], is that I can know her as well as I know anyone, know her struggle, but also know that what she’s grappling with is precisely how she’s going to become who she is! You talked to Brené Brown, right? That we actually learn courage and hope by walking through the things we didn’t know how we’d get through. It’s just so strange and mysterious that struggle has the bizarre aspect of holding gifts for us as well.</p><p>And somehow what we’re talking about is really the heart of spiritual life. Of course, it is about appreciating beauty and loving and being hospitable and learning to be generous. But it’s again and again about the things we walk through that scare us and form us and change us. And how we keep walking.</p><p><strong>I’m interested in the fact that you’re a mother who’s been compelled to ask the deepest questions. And you’ve had access to the great spiritual leaders and thinkers of our time. What lessons do you think your kids have learned from your enquiry, and how has it informed your parenting journey?</strong></p><p>I wish there were a really impressive answer to that [laughs]. I remember sitting with <a href="http://onbeing.org/programs/sylvia-boorstein-what-we-nurture/">Sylvia Boorstein</a>. Have you heard the interview I did with her?</p><p><strong>No.</strong></p><p>You should go listen to that one because it’s about parenting. We called it: “What we Nurture.” She’s one of the people who brought Buddhism to the West in the 1960s. And they were mostly Jewish — those American kids who went over and brought Buddhism to the West. So she’s a really renowned Buddhist teacher, but as she grew older she also really lived in her Jewish identity again. So she brings these things together in a beautiful way. Anyway, she said to me, and I know this is true — scientists will say this: our kids, they’re not necessarily listening to us, but they are watching us. They are picking up how we are and not what we say! Which is so alarming!</p><p><strong>That is so alarming! The pressure!</strong></p><p>[Laughs] my kids know what I do, of course. But being in radio is not like being in TV. It’s not like we walk down the street and people recognise me. But still they realise that I have a public persona and it’s been really important for them to have a distinction between that public persona and just me. So there’s a bit of a boundary there. I mean, I don’t impose what I learned at work today, but this is one of the most puzzling things about parenting: you never know really what you’re passing on. And I’ve actually worried that I haven’t overtly shared so many of the things that are coming at me. The other day my son, both my kids say they’re not religious, although their dad is an Episcopal priest. I mean he’s much more…</p><p><strong>Wow!</strong></p><p>Yeah! So there you go! It’s logical! But my son at breakfast the other morning suddenly read me this quote by the Dalai Lama. Someone had sent it to him on social media or something. And he just said: “How does this guy get so wise?” I said some things to him about why I thought the Dalai Lama was so wise. And then I was like: “You know I’ve interviewed the Dalai Lama?!” And when I interviewed the Dalai Lama he wasn’t that interested [laughs]. So I’m saying they have to discover these things for themselves anyway. There might be a zig-zaggy line between years ago when I interviewed the Dalai Lama and told him about this, and then it landed in his brain at 17 as something that he had discovered.</p><p>Earlier you were asking me about living a spiritual life through the raw materials of life. And one thing that I have really taken from my conversations, which is not as much spiritual as it is scientific, is this notion of neuroplasticity, this great discovery we’ve made in our lifetime.</p><p><strong>I met Norman Doidge this year. And that was incredible.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sPTdb2TshHbyOPpostvsWA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yeah! I mean, it’s a huge paradigm shift to know that we are physically, through our lives, changing — and that we can help shape that. The downside is, we have to work really hard to shape it. It’s not just the New Year’s resolution, it’s like: “Do you decide?” so that’s one thing that I’ve taken really seriously. I love the language of virtues. These ways of being in a world that hold some of the wisdom of our traditions and are kind of rituals at the same time. And it’s not just the big flashy ones like love and compassion. It’s hospitality and generosity and patience and kindness. Those are stepping stones to the big virtues. And at some point a few years ago I really took that in and, I mean, I had to fight really hard to create this project, and I did hit a point a few years ago where the person I was at work, at least some of the time, is not who I wanted to be. On the one hand I’m doing these beautiful spiritual interviews and then on the other hand there’s ambition, and I can be really impatient with people. I was in a bad organisational environment. And I understood that, but I also decided that I either had to be able to change — I either had to be able to be who I wanted to be at work — or I had to leave ’cause I couldn’t live with this disconnect. I also took it in in my private life. And there’s something magical about saying: “I am going to become a more patient person.” And not feeling like a patient person. I would not say it’s a word people use to describe me! But the whole idea here is that we can practice. Virtues are practices. Judaism actually does this better than Christianity in saying: “It’s not about what you believe, it’s about what you do.” And so it’s just saying: “I may not feel patient, I may not feel kind, but I am going to do kind and patient.” And even with my children, I have had this experience where you do become more patient. I know that the muscle memory strengthens. So that’s just really practical. Virtues are amazing tools for living.</p><p><strong>I’m wondering, having had all these incredible encounters that you’ve had and conversations that you’ve shared with the world — one point five million listeners a month I believe — do you have hope for humanity that we will act from our highest selves?</strong></p><p>Oh I do. I do. I also have faith that a lot of people are aspiring to their best selves already. But it’s like what we said at the beginning, that it’s the loud, stirring religious voices who get all the play. And loud, stirring cultural voices who get all the play. I’m privileged being at this media platform, and you are too, to have a view of the parallel universe. All the amazing energy and aspiration and good work. Which may be more real!</p><p>One thing that’s notable about generations coming up is that they’re very pragmatic. There’s an idealism, but it’s rooted and grounded and it’s not necessarily about saying, “We’re going to save the world!” It’s about looking at the world right in front of you and saying: “This is what I can do right here right now.”</p><p>I have to work hard to think of my project as being powerful because it’s something I grew and had to fight so long for. And it’s such an honour for me that you’re listening! I do take that in. Having a media project is a powerful thing. The last few years I’ve realised that. Because, you’re on a megaphone. And so I see all this quiet and determined goodness and a lot of searching for wisdom and practising wisdom, and then I ask: “What is it that I can do with this project I have?” That’s really where we are as an organisation — “How can we serve that?” The thing that concerns me is, I do feel like there’s an abundance of good people and initiatives and work and I long to see more connective tissue.</p><p><strong>You mentioned having a microphone and I have a quote here: “The best religious voices and lives are the last to throw themselves in front of a microphone. It’s a quiet story, it’s a story of everyday goodness.” It’s a question, I guess, around the word “humility.” It can be a challenge to lean in to the microphone and speak and be heard, because we need strong voices for peace and for the planet and for kindness and tenderness, and yet we need humility and gentleness and goodness. How do we reconcile that?</strong></p><p>So I had this cathartic moment in thinking about humility when my daughter was young. I was studying theology at the time and I was reading all these passages in the New Testament about humility and what a great thing it is and the humility of a child. And I never thought much of it. As a woman in particular, it’s like, Does humility get you anywhere? Talk about things that religion has exalted at the expense of human life. Humility is one of those. And then I realised…</p><p><strong>What do you mean by that?</strong></p><p>Well: “Women be humble,” which meant, “Make yourself invisible. Take anything that comes at you and take it gracefully.” That’s the association I have with that word and that I had with that word inside religion. And then I’m living with this child and the thing that Jesus is always talking about is the humility of a child, which also was never compelling to me at all…</p><p><strong>[Laughs].</strong></p><p>So then I was actually out walking with my daughter one day and I realised how a child walks through the world discovering everything for the first time and it’s all so amazing. And they have this approach of curiosity and a readiness to be surprised and a readiness to be amazed. I realised that’s another way to think about humility — not as debasing yourself but about walking through the world with curiosity, ready to be surprised. And ready to expect the best of and to see what is amazing about “the other.”</p><p>And so that is my definition of spiritual humility. It’s passionate, it’s big, it’s smart, it’s looking hard, it’s listening hard. Not everything and everyone is going to rise to that expectation. But you’re only likely to get more when you expect more. When you have created a space with your curiosity and your respect and your readiness to wonder that people can rise to that. So the word “humility” is problematic because it’s loaded with all these associations. But I do think it is one of these great, great virtues. If you just think of the opposite of that version of humility, it’s: we’re so guarded, we’re so defended, we’re so ready to be disappointed, we’re so cynical. And if you approach the world or another person in that mode, you’re going to get what you’re asking for. But for me humility asks for more and brings a readiness to take delight in the world and each other.</p><p><strong>That’s really beautiful. And one of the things that’s resonating for me is my slight horror at both deeply understanding what you’re talking about, my aspiration to it — that when you walk towards someone and your heart is open and curious and deeply empathic that that is what you’ll see and receive from them — but then my horror at how I trip every day. And there are small moments, shameful moments really, when I forget about kindness and I forget about empathy and compassion and I just get caught up in the smallness.</strong></p><p>And you’re at a really intense place in your life. You know, parenting is so interesting because it brings out the depths of love and empathy in us that we didn’t know were possible on the one hand, but it also is so all-encompassing that you hardly have the energy for the outside world, right? Or for other kinds of irritations or disappointments. So you should forgive yourself.</p><p><strong>You’re letting me off the hook! [Laughs] so, I’d love to know, has there been an interview that changed your life?</strong></p><p>I feel that I am a little bit changed by every conversation. I really can’t single one out. I do feel like my favourite interview is always the last one I did. I mean that’s a little glib ’cause clearly there are some that really stand out. But even the show we just did last weekend with this neuroscientist and epigeneticist: fascinating not only how we are changed by experiences and behaviours, but that this crosses generations. The good part of that is that this is knowledge which is a form of power and it’s telling a truth that is hard to see but does open the possibilities. And so that’s really formed me. And it’s often true that whatever we just did, it’s working on me from the inside. Sometimes people say, “The Dalai Lama or Desmond Tutu must have been a high point.” And you know, well, Desmond Tutu was pretty amazing, it was incredibly amazing. And the Dalai Lama is amazing in his way. But it’s just not true. I mean some people I’ve interviewed who are not famous and not really spiritual are completely spiritually illuminating.</p><p><strong>Like Gordon Hempton. That really stayed with me. Like they all do in different ways.</strong></p><p>Thank you.</p><p><strong>Thank you, Krista!</strong></p><p>Let me just say one last thing. You know, the story you told about Bhutan and the monasteries in the side of the mountain. I mean, this is how I feel in the 21st century. I feel like spiritual wisdom and spiritual technologies were historically consigned to experts, monks and nuns. Or rabbis. In all the traditions. I do think the amazing thing that’s happening now is that all of it is coming out for us to claim. And the potential power of that is just really remarkable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/223/1*X-IlNRktg6eA0WecR0azGA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This conversation featured in issue 45 of Dumbo Feather. Go to dumbofeather.com for more inspiring conversations and stories.</em></p><p>— — —</p><p><em>B the Change gathers and shares the voices from within the movement of people using business as a force for good and the community of </em><a href="http://www.bcorporation.net/"><em>Certified B Corporations</em></a><em>. The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the nonprofit B Lab.</em></p><figure><a href="http://go.pardot.com/l/39792/2017-08-30/7f5w58"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5dou-9mFqyTQVg9AbRsjqg.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6328ed2f3679" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine/krista-tippett-enriches-the-debate-6328ed2f3679">Krista Tippett Enriches the Debate</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/b-magazine">B The Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>