<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Nara Petrovic on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Nara Petrovic on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@narapetrovic?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 08:31:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How far can you stretch a “guru”?]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/how-far-can-you-stretch-a-guru-efb564cfb844?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/efb564cfb844</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Apr 2022 22:24:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-27T22:24:32.405Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(Also posted at <a href="https://narapetrovic.com/">https://narapetrovic.com</a>.)</p><p>By a coincidence, I bumped into <a href="https://techhenzy.com/gurometer/"><strong>gurometer</strong></a> and <a href="https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/"><strong>Decoding the Gurus</strong></a> podcast. It’s a much-needed project given the amount of quasi-scientific and quasi-spiritual teaching in the world today. Matt and Chris dissect “gurus” with poignancy and sarcasm rooted in their Australian/Irish temperament. Thought-provoking (non-American!) analysis is refreshing!</p><p>I find the term “gurometer” reminiscent of documentaries like <a href="https://kumaremovie.com/">Kumare</a>, <a href="https://vimeo.com/174719640">Marjoe</a>, <a href="https://watchdocumentaries.com/religulous/">Religulous</a>, etc. Being a social commentator and writer I actively search for eloquence and outspokenness, especially in combination with a unique outlook on contentious issues. I have my own BS detector and I’ll certainly be augmenting it with some points from the gurometer. All in all, Matt and Chris offer insightful resources.</p><p>And I must add that the <strong>gurometer has much room for improvement!</strong> I delved deep into it and jotted down notes instantaneously (in a document <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vSwWstC886zWAwhW4Si0T6nJ5-sfDFK1MGa8z2ASL49JVVmXAjcPNZhWD8-5iDP3scm_wDrOcWQ_hli/pub">Nara’s Commentary on the Gurometer</a>). In this article, I refine my analysis after listening to a number of podcasts and interviews. I am making both public, inviting Matt and Chris to respond.</p><p>I do my best not just to point the finger at logical fallacies, red herrings, syllogisms, and loaded concepts but also to point out ways to fine-tune, calibrate, concretize, and operationalize the gurometer <strong>to serve a positive function.</strong> I think too much room is given to ranting about the so-called “gurus,” implying that (to quote Chris), “In most cases, <em>guru </em>is used as a term of disparagement.”</p><p>Making the gurometer methodical <em>and neutral </em>can turn it into a practical tool both for the naive followers of “gurus” <em>and </em>the “gurus” themselves. Outlining the bad should be followed up by defining a desired, ideal, or at least better alternative. Matt and Chris seem to (intentionally or not) defend a postmodern position (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postmodernism">postmodern</a> in the sense of “opposition to epistemic certainty and the stability of meaning.”)</p><p><strong>“Yes, but …” dynamic is strong in their analyses.</strong> They contend with the validity of some points that the “gurus’” raise but on the next step they will find something slightly flawed even in the points they contended with … and go on and on digging deeper for finer flaws. They state what needs correction but the alternative is not specified and made actionable.</p><p>Like in the <a href="https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episode/sam-harris">conversation with Sam Harris</a> (which most likely references this <a href="https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episode/special-episode-sam-harris-meditation-is-all-you-need">podcast about Sam</a>). Chris keeps insisting on Sam’s tribalism no matter how eloquently Sam explains his position and qualifies it, explaining why he doesn’t agree with being labeled as tribal. Chris sometimes smirks in the background and interrupts Sam with “no, no, no, no, no…” as if to imply: “You don’t get what I <em>actually </em>mean.” I find Sam’s defense excellent; he’s saying: “You may have a specific point, but all in all you keep failing to prove me wrong.”</p><p>Towards the end, Sam outwits Chris: “So, you’re telling me you and I are in the same tribe, yet we’re spending all this time disagreeing? This is what it feels like to be in a tribe: three hours of non-stop disagreement? Getting shit on endlessly on your podcasts and getting sniped at on Twitter?”</p><p>Sam obviously lost patience with the amount of intellectual contortionism involved in “proving” the (one-sidedly) predetermined “truth.” It’s like debating a flat-earther or a vegan: forget about them ever admitting that their central idea is wrong, you can only debate the details around it. Basically: <strong>I miss intellectual humility in asserting essential “truths.”</strong> Still, I must congratulate Matt and Chris on doing so well debating <em>Sam Harris,</em> who is a legendary debater with decades of experience.</p><p>“Gurus” may be guilty of fragmenting and contorting the image of reality and thus causing actual harm. Still, they will invariably appeal to a significant subsection of society by offering alternative narratives and challenging the dominant mainstream narrative — and they often do this knowingly. The mainstream needs this opposition to save it from going stale and stinky. Someone needs to probe into both old and new all-pervasive practices. Mainstream needs to keep up the stamina by fighting back and winning arguments by <em>proving to be right — authentically.</em> It shouldn’t abuse its privilege and the power of the majority; it needs to admit mistakes and apologize when it turns out it <em>was </em>wrong.</p><p>Donald Trump is interfering with the dominant narrative, and others are doing it too, in their own way, be it Robert Malone, David Icke, Eric Weinstein, John McWorther, Joe Rogan, etc. They do it in so many ways, some like a tank, some like a scalpel, some flashy, some dumbly. They often play out as rogue, or martyr archetypes, their massive personas standing above pale, non-controversial academics who purport everything with dry data. That’s why you hear more about Alex Joneses of this world, but almost nothing about meticulous analysts of their BS. In order to gain attention, I had to learn to be at least somewhat outspoken and theatrical, just like these people are. And as Matt and Chris are. That’s how we, the analysts, can have the attention of a wider audience, and that’s how <em>we risk becoming like the people we criticize.</em></p><p>Gurometer has the potential to measure the level of scam/quackery, but to do that fairly I suggest it needs <strong>a scale that extends to the positive side, too.</strong> I doubt it can achieve anything constructive unless smirky sarcasm gets sufficiently grounded in hardheaded realism, objectivity, and basic human courtesy. I find sarcasm a lot more powerful without smirking. Balancing manners in the critique can make all the difference. I find Chris’s smirking depreciative and offputting, as opposed to, for example, the lighthearted laughs by<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJ8fe3vtgfY"> Dr. Vinay Prasad and Dr. Zubin Damania</a>.</p><p>Please, note that mainstream is full of BS too. When I began analyzing mainstream from an extracultural perspective 20 years ago, I wasn’t sure where that would take me. I had an aversion to being an armchair philosopher and I took an extremely pragmatic approach to my analysis. There’s so much that our culture sweeps under the rug — looking at is painful. Our cultural conventions are a jumble of ancient traditions and many generations of quick fixes that fail to amend dumb and unquestioned collective manners. We tend to safeguard a substantial part of our everyday life from scrutiny and reformation.</p><p>The “gurus,” who <em>Decoding the Gurus</em> podcast probes into, usually did something significant, rebellious, daring. Somehow or other they brought value to many people’s lives, attracting attention and following. A balanced analysis would recognize and assess the positives of their contribution first and it would point the negative against the backdrop of the positive <em>and </em>against a calibrated scale. I’ll come back to the scale later.</p><p>I did a self-assessment with the gurometer. I found myself guilty of both attention-seeking and tribalism to quite a degree. I am guilty of so many other sins, such as writing and selling books, inventing neologisms, being a jack of all trades, etc. When I look around through the prism of the gurometer all of a sudden everyone is somehow or other a “guru,” lurking at me to hoodwink me! Including Matt and Chris. This is hardly an objective tool. It’s two armchair opinionators subjectively assessing other armchair opinionators, committing a lot of guruish BS themselves while exposing it. This cannot lead to much more than a cynical ping pong between the so-called “tribes” (whatever that is, anyway).</p><p>The “meter” needs to have a scale with clear qualifiers and definitions of states that are somehow discernable from other states. But I’m rushing ahead … my analysis of the gurometer must begin with the term <em>guru</em>.</p><p>Beware! The analysis is long …</p><h3>Guru in gurometer is deceiving</h3><p>The term “gurometer” first led me to expect Chris and Matt would scrutinize Rajneesh, Maheshvarananda, Aurobindo, Sai Baba, Sadhguru, Babaji, Dadaji, and similar <em>Indian</em> gurus. I searched for their coverage only to find mentions of a few of them in their coverages of <strong><em>secular </em>“gurus,”</strong> (I write “gurus” in quotation marks when I refer to Chris and Matt’s specific meaning, and without quotation marks when I refer to a broader, dictionary meaning).</p><p>They contend in the <a href="https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episode/eric-and-bret-weinstein-a-dark-horse-gallops-through-the-portal">very first episode</a> that the title of the podcast “Decoding the Gurus” might not be final. I found a pretty positive coverage of <a href="https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episode/anthony-demello">Anthony De Mello</a> (who I share the fancy of with Chris), but mostly, the center of the target evolves, loosely, from the IDW (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_dark_web">Intellectual Dark Web</a>) gang, around which other influential secular “gurus” are strung in concentric circles, some closer some further away from the center.</p><p>I listened to the explanation of why Matt and Chris find the term suitable but for me, it still seems like a bad choice. As someone who studied Sanskrit for a number of years, I have a bit of an allergic reaction when I see Sanskrit terms twisted. Chris and Matt use the term “guru” almost exclusively in a negative, diminutive, and even derogatory sense. Look at any <a href="https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/guru">dictionary</a> or <a href="https://www.encyclopedia.com/philosophy-and-religion/eastern-religions/hinduism/guru">encyclopedia</a> and you won’t find it described as a <strong><em>“disparaging term to describe secular gurus” </em></strong>(as Chris frames it <a href="https://www.iheart.com/podcast/263-the-strenuous-life-28782558/episode/334-ten-guru-warning-signs-84996918/">here</a>).</p><p>In Sanskrit (and Hindi and other languages on the Indian subcontinent), the term <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guru"><em>guru</em></a> conveys a sense of weight, importance, value, veneer, respect … It can be used to describe elders (such as parents), chiefs, and (spiritual) teachers. I put spiritual in parentheses because teachers were expected to embody high morals alongside the skill they taught, which could be pottery, archery, cooking, farming, rhetorics, philosophy, politics, arts, linguistics, etc. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drona">Dronacharya</a>, for example, was a famed teacher of military arts from Mahabharata. The term “acharya” in his name denotes that he taught by his example, not only by his words.</p><p>Gurus were highly respected because they kept and passed on knowledge that their society depended upon. They were not necessarily the best in a particular skill, but they were the best in teaching it. To be gurus they were expected to be detached from material goods and fame. For subsistence, they usually depended on alms. A “rich guru,” possessing a lot of stuff and living a posh lifestyle is a contradiction in itself.</p><p>Gurus’ reputation increased by winning debates against other experts in their field. In such debates, fake gurus would be exposed and their reputations damaged or lost. If they were thus knocked from a high moral position or fell down by being dishonest, disingenuous, etc. they were shunned and outcasted. All this, of course, depended on <strong>people’s ability to see through them.</strong></p><p>Gurometer focuses on flaws of character and behavior instead of focusing on the reader’s discernment (or at least including it). Giving people a list of negative personal characteristics can have adverse results. Teaching people the skills of seeing through all this would mean guiding them through the flaws in their inner processing of information, jumping to conclusions, looking at the world through colored glasses, etc. If you don’t deal with the colored glasses and just give them the list of the “gurus” flaws that might only add another color film to the glasses.</p><p>Regardless of the time when gurus were around: prior to modern science or recently, the moment of seeing through quackery is shocking for the follower. The most ardent follower will often deny the evidence that her or his guru is fake. There are ample examples of this phenomenon. As some in the Hare Krishna movement used to say: “Right or wrong, my guru is always right.”</p><p>Sadly, science hasn’t flooded the entire society with enlightenment and critical thinking. At least not deeply enough. Enlightenment remains relatively small pockets and is far from being homogenous. Folklore, superstition, popular culture, peer pressure, cultural and religious indoctrination, etc. condition people’s basic social instincts, desirable affiliations, information processing, logic, and reason … and make them vulnerable to quackery. The social media fragmentation only makes things worse.</p><p>Quackery happens everywhere and will continue to be a problem in many forms, including random people posing as trustworthy moral authorities, or “gurus” and some of them gaining large followings. I don’t know what’s worse: when fake “gurus” do it knowing they’re fake or when they’re actually convinced they are genuine gurus — in either case, followers worship them the same and even a sharp observer will have a hard time discerning fake from real.</p><p>During my studies in India, I was lucky to be exposed to (what I would consider) authentic gurus (who no one ever heard of in the West). One of them spoke seventeen languages and wrote poetry in nine. He was an epitome of modesty, light-heartedness, humor, and self-scrutiny. He never claimed access to specific knowledge. I imagine him scrutinizing the gurometer and laughing, noticing characteristics in himself and being entertained by it. (Especially the neologisms since in Sanskrit, it is very common to make up new terms and concepts.) He played along with what his society accepted from a guru, but without pomp.</p><p>I also met many murky gurus who’d score high on the gurometer. I dedicated my two travels to India some 20 years ago to assess the authenticity of the guru figures known in the West (Sai Baba, Osho, Brahma Kumaris, various Vaishnava ashrams). I went there with a list of questions (my version of a gurometer) and tested the gurus and their adjacents. On those trips, I realized many meanings of the saying: “The road to hell is paved with good intentions.” (Here, I’ll just keep it at that.)</p><p>I am aware that the perceived meaning of the term <em>guru</em> has degraded since the 1960s (some would say even since the 1920s) thanks to the influx of charismatic figures from India who presented themselves (or were interpreted by their followers) as gurus. Jiddu Krishnamurti famously <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Last-Guru-Significance-Krishnamurti-Modern-ebook/dp/B0096A6FE0">denounced the concept of a guru</a> already some 100 years ago (while, paradoxically, still being seen and followed as a guru). On the other hand, being a <em>business guru</em> meant something positive, describing a business expert with influence and integrity in their field. In any case, my point is that the appropriation of the term <em>guru</em> in the Western world had <em>both </em>positive and negative connotations. <strong><em>Guru is not a disparaging term.</em></strong></p><p>in the gurometer definition, I frowned at the lowest point that the meaning of “guru” has reached<strong>: “Someone who spouts pseudo-profound bullshit </strong>(with bullshit being speech that is persuasive without any regard for the truth).”</p><p>My reaction was: “Haven’t you heard the saying that when you point a finger at someone, three fingers point back at you?” In other words: with such a slandering definition of “guru,” do Chris and Matt believe that demanding, academic readers and listeners will take seriously their claims of their academic bona fides (which they put in opposition to those that they disparage as “gurus”)? How is that not spouting pseudo-profound bullshit?</p><p>I contend that many guruish figures from both East and West are indeed guilty of what is described in the above definition. I don’t think it justifies the contortion of the term <em>guru</em> even more towards meaning: “narcissistic, arrogant charlatans.” Should we bury the original meaning of “wise elders who deserve reverence for their knowledge, skill, and moral integrity,” and replace it with the disparaging one? As critical as I am of both religious and secular gurus (and “gurus”), I think such linguistic contortions are neither wise nor needed.</p><p>I know I might be treading on the edge of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etymological_fallacy">etymological fallacy</a> and I wish to stress that I’m by no means advocating for linguistic purism. Maybe Matt and Chris are right and the traditional meaning of the term “guru” is forever lost and irredeemable, at least in the West. Regardless of this, it would behoove academics to contextualize their subject matter very carefully and not assume that the audience shares the same (negative) interpretation of the <em>key term </em>that their entire project relies upon.</p><p>It would be fun to make an academometer and rigorously analyze Chris and Matt’s academic integrity. Would they agree with the term “academic” being used in an exclusively negative sense? Would they appreciate me describing them as dry, cynical armchair opinionators and podcasters, caught up in circular thinking, feeding on criticizing their subjects? It would be fun, but I wouldn’t do it. I don’t think this would offer a fair and accurate depiction. Real academics would shun me, rightfully so.</p><p>There is too much valuable knowledge and perspective in what Matt and Chris offer; slandering it would be unfair. Even this analysis of mine, because it is about correction, may misguide the reader into thinking that it’s all bad. It’s not! Go and listen to <em>Decoding the Gurus!</em> But know that it won’t really be about the gurus and it won’t be decoding either.</p><p>I am probably too late to suggest a correction of the name as the branded product has been around for a while and has caught quite some attention. “Charlatanometer,” “Quackmeter,” “Decoding the Quacks,” don’t sound so cool. Despite Matt and Chris stating that they think covering Deepak Chopra would be like shooting ducks in a barrel, I would say that would actually be a very good test of the metrics.</p><p><strong>It would be good to qualify the use of the term “guru” better to avoid coming across as those they criticize:</strong> as populist attention seekers, pretending their shallow criticism is rigorous scrutiny. “Gurometer” sounds exotic and fancy, which raises unease in the listener. I think that’s unnecessary. BTW, when I am invited to apply critical thinking I have a habit of applying it to those inviting me first, particularly when an academic background is quoted as proof of their credibility. Unless, of course, Chris and Matt disparage the term “academic” in the same way they do “guru.”</p><p>Although I am not Indian myself and I don’t see the false “appropriation” of the term “guru” as desecrating Indian culture, I appreciate the bright side of Indian culture and I hope my critique will land well. I’d gladly engage in a conversation with Matt and Chris to explore the dialectic of guruism in the East and the West and see where the meaning is actually going and what is a wise response to that.</p><h3>Is it “decoding” or “recoding” the gurus?</h3><p>Decoding is “converting (a coded message) into intelligible language.” If the decoder doesn’t consciously leave out judgments and interpretations, he has not decoded but instead <em>recoded:</em> replaced the original code with a new one.</p><p>I studied translation theory and worked as an interpreter for some years between a few different languages. The foundational rule was to translate the meaning of words and leave it up to the audience to make moral judgments and interpretations. In the case of an obvious lapsus, it was normal to correct the speaker, but in regards to moral and scientific “correctness,” I had to hold back my internal comments and simply translate the meaning of words. If I had a chance to talk to the speaker after the presentation, I would point out problems I noticed and invite correction (so she or he could avoid embarrassment in the future). I would do the same if I found their “code” hermetic and/or unintelligible.</p><p>The next level is to acknowledge that there is always a context in which a speaker or a writer nest the message. Anthony De Mello speaking to a hall full of Christians requires clear nesting of messages to “code” them appropriately and make them intelligible to the audience in question. Sam Harris talking about meditation to an audience interested in meditation is another example where following a “code” facilitates understanding. If Sam were standing in front of a Christian audience, I am sure he’d choose a somewhat different “code” to present the same ideas — depending on the receptiveness of the audience, of course. (I am not very enthusiastic about Sam-style meditation since he acquired a <em>new-agey</em> chest voice. I loved and still love when he speaks in his razor-sharp deep voice on divisive issues, especially religion — I love the later tone of his even when I disagree with him.)</p><p>I salute Matt and Chris for taking on Sam Harris, Bret and Eric Weinstein, James Lindsay, Joe Rogan, Robert Malone, etc. I am all in favor of putting these influential figures under a microscope. I salute the effort to wake those around these figures from passive consumption of their opinions and falling into any kind of echo chamber. I am in favor of “decoding” misleading and deceptive messages, but I lose trust in this work when I see <em>recoding.</em> When having fun turns to ridicule; when sarcasm is hitting below the belt. When academic and moral incentives get mixed up it’s highly unlikely that the picture presented is accurate and morally sound.</p><p>I heard once that a good writer reveals the truth about his characters while a bad writer reveals the truth about himself. The same could be said about a bad critic telling more about himself than about those he criticizes. Trying to expose someone’s (hidden) agenda sloppily, may cause the critic to expose his own agenda instead (like three fingers pointing back at you when you point a finger at someone). I see their “decoding” as repackaging a product from one box to another, not actually taking it out of the box and presenting it as it is.</p><p>Chris might remember De Mello’s words:</p><blockquote>When you say of someone, “He’s a communist,” understanding has stopped at that moment. You slapped a label on him. “She’s a capitalist.” Understanding has stopped at that moment. You slapped a label on her, and if the label carries undertones of approval or disapproval, so much the worse! How are you going to understand what you disapprove of, or what you approve of, for that matter? All of this sounds like a new world, doesn’t it? No judgment, no commentary, no attitude: one simply observes, one studies, one watches, without the desire to change what is. Because if you desire to change what is into what you think should be, you no longer understand. A dog trainer attempts to understand a dog so that he can train the dog to perform certain tricks. A scientist observes the behavior of ants with no further end in view than to study ants, to learn as much as possible about them. He has no other aim. He’s not attempting to train them or get anything out of them. He’s interested in ants, he wants to learn as much as possible about them. That’s his attitude. The day you attain a posture like that, you will experience a miracle. You will change — effortlessly, correctly. Change will happen, you will not have to bring it about. As the life of awareness settles on your darkness, whatever is evil will disappear. Whatever is good will be fostered. You will have to experience that for yourself.</blockquote><p>Yes, De Mello’s words are <em>New Agey,</em> spiritual, guruish, religious, sentimental, poetic … many labels could be used to describe them. But they do the job of telling us something about our colored eyeglasses. Throughout history, philosophers and poets alike relied on analogies and stories to bring attention to what’s most difficult to see: ourselves. We may look the other way and call this unscientific, but one fact remains: poetic analogies and stories will touch people’s hearts and change their perspectives. Dissecting them with scientific rigor will kill the beauty, especially if you push the analysis too far.</p><h3>Criticizing doers is very easy, creating viable alternatives is difficult</h3><p>In the last decade, I worked with teams from more than 100 countries doing nationwide cleanups. Going out there, getting our hands dirty picking trash. In my country, Slovenia, 14% of the population went out to pick trash on April 17, 2010. We collected 20,000 tons of trash on that day. There’s even a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHR7KF9-T1M&amp;t=8s">documentary</a> about it. For being at the core of this work I was praised — but also criticized.</p><p>I had a first-hand experience of how difficult is to manage massive projects: mistakes happen all the time when thousands of people are involved — and criticizing them is, oh, so easy.</p><p>There is no other choice but to ignore the insistent critics as the energy is needed elsewhere. When critics are also doers, not merely armchair opinionators, I strive to make alliances with them since their and my contrasting perspectives can be complementary. When they point at my shortcomings there is a lot of truth in their critique. They help me get better — I need their feedback to strive. But engaging with critics who bitterly yammer about this and that and keep looking for finer and finer flaws in my actions and words — that’s a waste of my time. Nowadays there are too many opinionators, posing as smartass “gurus” online and fighting for a piece of cake in this new attention economy. I think we need more people growing healthy food and, yes, picking up trash, and fewer people engaged in endless ping pong with trash being thrown between the so-called new “cultures.”</p><p>Every ambitious enterprise has flaws. It will be criticized. The recurring themes of the last decade are narcissistic hypersensitivity and infantile tantrums. They remind me of one of my favorite quotes by Duško Radović: “Let’s fight for dignity and a high level of our dissatisfaction. It is a shame what people can get dissatisfied with.”</p><p><strong>I am grateful to everyone who points out my flaws when I sense in their words that they genuinely wish me to make progress.</strong> If their words signal a negative bias (even by how they choose to label me), I doubt that engaging with them can have a positive outcome for either of us (or anyone else, for that matter).</p><p>My position is peculiar, as I am a doer but I am also a critic. I can be emphatic in both roles. Having been an object of harsh criticism changed my style of criticizing others. In my role as an essayist/journalist, I keep in mind how challenging it is to be a changemaker. <strong>If I choose to criticize,</strong> <strong>I make an effort to be gentle, firm, and constructive. </strong>I don’t attempt to <em>not</em> offend. Instead, I remind myself of a witty rule of thumb: “A gentleman is someone who never offends anyone unintentionally.” (Which needs to be taken with a grain of salt, of course.)</p><p>Influential people who gained a following add some kind of value to people’s lives. They can be absolutely crooked and still be idolized by many. That’s because something is inherently crooked in our mainstream culture, not because these people are such good swindlers. The Catholic church holds immense authority despite its deluge of atrocities. Similarly, “gurus” (spiritual and secular) will be widely followed no matter how much their nefarious deeds get “decoded.” Decoding should be a means to something more than that. You don’t measure things for no reason; you do it so they would fit better together.</p><p>I’d like to mention a relevant book, written by Slovenian author Vladimir Bartol. The title of the book is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alamut_(Bartol_novel)">Alamut</a>. It’s a literary, historical depiction of an Islamic sect from the 11th century and it raises a moral dilemma: since masses only change by manipulation isn’t a good leader justified to manipulate them because if he doesn’t, other (crooked) leaders will? The idea is that you cannot “decode” the society and thus guide it to a truthful state. The only option is swapping “codes” — <em>but </em>if you take responsibility for doing that you are also responsible for all the (bad!) consequences. The religious leader in the book justifies his actions with the slogan “nothing is true; everything is permitted.” (That’s one of the reasons why literary analysts tie the novel to postmodernism.)</p><h3>I love Anthony De Mello!</h3><p>I really enjoyed Chris and Matt’s podcast on <a href="https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episode/anthony-demello">Anthony De Mello</a>! De Mello was one of my deprogramming influences when I was leaving the Hare Krishna movement. I’ve listened to De Mello’s entire “Wake Up to Life” seminar many, many times — of which the book <a href="https://www.arvindguptatoys.com/arvindgupta/tonyawareness.pdf">Awareness</a> is almost a direct transcript.</p><p>Today I can see the naivety in De Mello’s teachings but I take that charitably. He has brought and will probably keep bringing value to more people’s lives than I ever will. Various “manipulations” De Mello relies upon are common in all religions, it’s what priests do every day in thousands of churches much more radically. To a mind constrained by a narrow religious bias, De Mello’s arguments can be liberating. De Mello synthesized eastern and western religious wisdom just like <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Watts">Alan Watts</a> did. De Mello had actually read Watt’s books and listened to his talks and thought highly of him.</p><p>De Mello uses the language of his audience: pious Christians. That has to be taken into account. I don’t know would he be able to use any other language, other code, but still, that was his domain, and relative to that background his teaching is full of innovation. I listen to De Mello as I read Krishnamurti or Kant or Marx or Varoufakis or Ian Rand — in the context of their time and social reality. I think context should always inform the boundary within which we understand, analyze and criticize such impactful individuals.</p><p>Acknowledging their subjectivity due to their context helps us be more objective. When a critic presents himself as coming from an objective, scientific point of view as opposed to a “guru” who holds a subjective, limited position — including De Mello — the critic is imposing a dubious hierarchy on the audience. Not everyone is able to see through it and only take the good.</p><p>My writing taught me that the best way to keep a moral high ground is by carefully including myself in the criticism. I respect people who can smile and admit: “I was wrong.” And then actually take steps to correct their mistakes. I learned that from De Mello. He quotes someone saying:</p><blockquote>“The three most difficult things for a human being are not physical feats or intellectual achievements. They are, first, returning love for hate; second, including the excluded; third, admitting that you are wrong.”</blockquote><p>I was surprised by how often I agreed with Chris (less so with Matt) in the critiques he had of De Mello. I know De Mello’s teachings intricately and I am used to both defending and criticizing him in conversations with my friends. So, were I ever to “decode” Chris and Matt, I’d base the friendly decoding on their podcast about De Mello. 😉</p><h3>Let’s not make science even more serious and hermetic than it already is</h3><p>I’m fed up with scientists (and “scientists”) pointing fingers at each other and not really listening (what to speak of understanding the complexity). Chris and Matt bring up the label of “anti-waxer,” for example, and it seems to be in the same category as “guru” — disparate by definition.</p><p>Only the most narrow-minded commentators of the pandemic hold a categoric position on the COVID vaccination: either unreservedly supporting it (for all ages at all times and with as many boosters as the pharmaceutic companies will come up with) or rejecting it (seeing it as very harmful, linking it to conspiracies, inflating side effects, etc.). The well-informed and thoughtful commentators are critical of carefully framed aspects of the measures taken at the time of the pandemic, public reactions to these measures and they ask a lot of questions. They are careful not to make any absolute statements. I agree that some go too far, aligning closely with cooky theories, but I wouldn’t brush everything they say off the table because some of it is weird or insufficiently substantiated. I’ve swallowed my pride enough in my life to hold absolute opinions about (almost) anything.</p><p>The same is true in the case of Social Justice. I have a grudge against but I can see it in a context. Last year I got burnt by putting my hand onto the hot plate of wokism. That’s actually how I discovered the whole Twitter/Youtube universe of left/right, heterodox/orthodox tensions (recently, that included the gurometer.) There was a Social Justice activist in our network and she started imposing some “truths” (essentially, that we have to decolonize the male racist white supremacist culture inherent in all western institutions). I reacted bluntly — only to be called out bluntly with all the typical labels that are evoked in such cases. I tried to fight back against this, but the core of the team didn’t agree with my assessment of the situation, so I made sure to state my position clearly, ask all the necessary questions, offer full collaboration in a fair process — and since it didn’t take place, I left. That’s how I discovered Bret Weinstein and Evergreen and the whole anti-woke universe.</p><p>I was astounded to see the extent of the cultural ping pong in cyberspace. I read books by Douglas Murray, Helen Pluckrose, Andrew Doyle, Peter Boghosian, Jonathan Heidt, and others to make sense of what’s going on. I also read the books and listened to talks of authors they criticize (including Ibram X Kendy, Robin DiAngelo …). Finally, Jonathan Heidt and Jonathan Rauch somehow calmed me down in my specific position at the margin of all this mess unfolding around me.</p><p>Finding my way through the new culture with tons of neologisms was tiring. The battle over what is true science seems bizarre. At the age of almost fifty, I find the current debates on science asinine. The inability to sit down and come to an agreement in civil discourse is ridiculous. It’s antiscientific indeed. But since I know that mainstream is inherently crooked, I expect that to be a norm rather than an exception.</p><p>I am at peace with the fact that the masses are never going to follow science uncompromisingly. In their everyday lives, they will choose superstition, folklore, tradition, and repetition. Science will be secondary for most; they will demand that the science fits within their biases, not vice versa. That’s why we have so few Dawkinses and Sagans and so many close-minded followers of authority figures.</p><p>Science will move on regardless of what you think and in two, or three centuries maybe Chris and Matt will be seen as the prophets of this age or maybe Deepak Chopra. Given how popular Jesus still is and how popular are Dennis Bray and Allen Bard, I think I would bet on Deepak.</p><p>I understand the argument that it can be deceiving when “gurus” comment on topics that are completely outside their expertise. They risk misguiding people with their incomplete knowledge <em>and</em> high moral authority. But it is just as dangerous to forbid any comments from non-experts on everyday issues. I don’t need to be a veterinarian to distinguish a male cat from a female cat, but I will hold back from commenting on genetic specifics that define a Siamese cat. I will look into contentious issues and sometimes comment on them — carefully and <em>focusing on the perspective,</em> helping others change their perspective too.</p><p>Gurometer is often more about the issue than about the perspective. Yes, Chris and Matt should point out when “gurus” make assertions that stem from incomplete knowledge — especially when they insist on these assertions even after they have been proven wrong. That’s a red flag for sure. But interpreting open questions and doubts as fixed positions and then criticizing them, I would consider that a fallacy.</p><h3>Let’s decode the loaded terms “guru,” “conspiracy theorist,” “anti-waxer,” etc.</h3><p>I think it is cheap and lazy to weaponize terms (even more than they already are) to dismiss dissenting voices. Among these voices, there are blatant conspiracy theorists, but there are also disagreeable voices of reason. Gurometer should help us draw the line between voices of reason and those of stubborn, irrational resistance.</p><p>Decoding various terms would mean presenting them in all their diverse aspects and showing how they are being abused. “Anti-waxer,” for example, has been thrown around so much that it doesn’t mean anything anymore. Everyone slightly disagreeable with the current dominant position can be labeled as such. This empowers cynical pro-waxers (anti-anti-waxers?) to wreak havoc.</p><p>BTW, the gurometer would have a greater impact if it decoded itself first.</p><p>Of all the current commentators (in English-speaking countries) that I know of, Jonathan Haidt strikes me as a scientist who doesn’t get swayed by the expressive, emotionally burdened terms, adopted by the current mainstream to smear dissenters, nor the similar term coming from the opposition.</p><h3>Calibrating the gurometer</h3><p>It would help if the gurometer explicitly specified a scale, at whichever <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Level_of_measurement">level of measurement</a> its authors choose. They mention a way to assign points at the end of their notes but they don’t explain how to actually do that. A user’s manual would be helpful.</p><p>Measuring “gurus” based on subjective criteria with a stretchable “measuring tape” is hardly a scientific process. To be scientific, it would need to be so designed to be a widely adoptable methodology whereby people can understand how to apply it accurately.</p><p>Calibrating the gurometer would mean defining empirically testable laws about each attribute and adding some kind of nominal and ordinal scale. I know there is no way to position the gurometer against something as material as length, weight, etc. but I can imagine a scale on which “gurus” score in various categories and can be compared. It can be a tool that everyone can use more or less reliably, not only Matt and Chris.</p><h3>I’m looking forward to Chris and Matt’s response!</h3><p>One of the main triggers for me to write this critique is when Matt and Chris criticized the “gurus” because they don’t engage with their critics. Since it took me a lot of time to write this, I hope I will hear back from them.</p><p>When I had this text already written, I looked around some more to see what other people had to say about <em>Decoding the Gurus</em> and I encountered David Fuller’s reflection: <a href="https://www.listennotes.com/podcasts/rebel-wisdom-rebel-wisdom-w_SZoTfUkyx/">Decoding the Gurus and the Necessity of Criticism</a>. I listened to David’s conversation with Chris too. I’m linking David’s text here because I think it complements my thinking and offers some additional resources and names. (I’d also like to thank David for engaging with Chris gentlemanly.)</p><p>To wrap up my analysis let me congratulate Matt and Chris for what they’ve accomplished thus far! It’s an important project that brings much-needed conversations to the public forum. If they are interested, I would be happy to offer additional feedback and suggestions to enhance the gurometer (or whatever better name might ensue).</p><p>Finally: I probably represent the 0.1% of the most demanding audience out here and I am aware that my critique may not be easy to swallow. I extend it together with my open hand hoping to build bridges.</p><p>Ultimately, I hope our shared wisdom will prevail.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=efb564cfb844" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strawberry Feast Forever]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/strawberry-feast-forever-44b2fe80434a?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/44b2fe80434a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mwc-space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wilderness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[home]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-and-death]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Aug 2021 06:14:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-26T06:14:41.904Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I don’t bother to properly peg down our tattered old tent. The Albanian Alps shelter us with virgin air and radiant moonlight while thick, intoxicating silence lulls us to sleep. The mosquito net on the tent’s door blurs the Milky Way into a soft pillow while the sweet smell of wild strawberries tickles my dreams.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*05vMQhIb9QHJP6WgX9cg2w.jpeg" /></figure><p>A blaring storm wakes me up at 2 AM, Milky Way spilling from the sky just a mile away!</p><p>“Quickly,” I shake her shoulder, “we need to move!”</p><p>By the time we roll our mats, sheets and sleeping bags, a raging wind hits the tent as a curtain of rain is approaching us dauntingly. I put stones into the corners of the tent and we rush to my 20-year old Citroën Xsara slamming the door behind us while giant drops bang against the roof. Zeus’s divine revelry splattering from his banquet table.</p><p>What a blessing to have a bendy body and soul! While in the car, we pack our stuff on the front seats all the way up to the roof, fold down the back seats and make as much space as we can in the extended trunk, all that time moving around each other like playful cats in a basket. Fifteen minutes later, we are back asleep. Lying down diagonally and tightly embraced, we can almost stretch our legs.</p><p>I don’t know how long the rain goes on. When I wake up with her warm back against my belly the sky is bright blue. The chilly morning air bites my nostrils, alerting me it is time to get up to feast on these mighty mountains with a strawberry field going on forever.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k9f-f2_x4Qc1OtZEtYLuDw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’m not tailored for a house. At 47, I remain a barefoot vagabond roaming the world in a loincloth, happiest when the membrane between me and the world can hold the weather out but not square me in. Grab me and carry me to another mountain, to a tattered tent or to the trunk of an old car, and I’ll care more for sweet strawberries, soft warmth against my belly and the roar of the Milky Way than I’d ever care for a mansion with a fabled chef, a cocktail bar, and a brand new Porsche.</p><p>Houses are not just walls and rooms, they’re rituals and patterns, they shape your behaviors and habits, they square you in. Houses are the forgetfulness of how to be read by spirits of nature. Instead, you’re put into brackets, a side note to be noticed by rare and overlooked by most. Only people can read you and even then merely those that belong to your school.</p><p>You’re meaningless without the context that’s wound around you like a cage around a fish at a fish farm, surrounded by the similarly bracketed destiny of a million other fishes. A fish-blind-for-the-sea analogy doesn’t describe the human condition adequately. It’s more accurate to say that the fish is blind for its cage in the sea.</p><p>Running barefoot down the lush grassland, sprinkled with ripe strawberries as far as the eye can see is my morning exercise of choice. Squatting and relishing the tiny berries for hours is my favorite breakfast. Here and now nothing can beat it. There’s also the cream of her giggles as we take a break, lie down and let the scattered clouds recalibrate our imagination.</p><p>Closing my eyes I merge with the mountain’s ancient soul, listen to the language of its spirits and learn what they think of the bracketed lives of my kin. Spirits talk in feelings and emotions. They admire our frivolousness and abhor our fear. They resent our boredom and how we squander the little time that we have. The mountain is always in fruitful movement.</p><p>A lot had changed in my life since my companion on every trip became the saying: “A wise man sees more from the bottom of a well than the stupid does from the top of a mountain.” Picture that: you’re deep down in a well and all you can see is a tiny patch of sky. If you have the eye of wisdom, you’ll make more of that tiny patch than most would make of a mountain view.</p><p>It’s the same with strawberries. Each one tastes the same, but each is different. And there are so many ways to eat strawberries! You can pop them in your mouth one by one in equal intervals and mind the subtle changes in taste. Or you can fill up your palm and stuff your mouth, chew slowly with your eyes closed, careful not to bite too hard and release the seeds’ bitterness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qR9ftQgTBJbc7OhlZu_-TQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>For her and me, a three-hour strawberry breakfast would be a shame to miss. Most people I know would lose interest in ten minutes, unable or unwilling to explore subtle tastes at the bottom of the well. They have their mountain tops, their views and I have to admit I am unable to relish the intricacies of those tastes as they do. They have been eating the same turkey dish on the same calendar date every single year of their life. At the dinner table, they discuss the nuances between the last year and the year before and how special it was in 2002 when the late aunt last cooked it. Such a dinner is best relished as a ritual over traditional dishes by family recipes, chosen drinks, decorations, and conversations.</p><p>I take my eyes off the countless strawberries and scan the peaks around me, triggered by a squeal. Eh, it’s just an eagle high up in the sky. Well, if there’s an eagle, there must be bears and wolves around here too. Not to mention ticks and mosquitoes. I’m not romanticizing the wilderness, I’m aware of perils hidden in the shadow of those trees resembling the pattern on a tiger’s back.</p><p>I admit my aversion to walls and rooms but still, my uncanny verdict is that humans need houses to live well and to be good custodians of the transition belt between culture and nature. That belt makes the Earth with humans richer than it would ever be without us. Each locality on Earth lends humans a blueprint of a home and of the transition around it if they only take time to connect with the spirits of the place.</p><p>People evolved like ants and bees, emulating their behaviors, making use of every available material to build better and sturdier homes. But even when they mastered the skill of building they reserved the majestic temples and palaces for gods, lords, and the dead, while homes for the commoners remained plain. Century after century the walls grew thicker, detaching us from the voices of those spirits out there (<em>and </em>of the ones inside.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b2ZmGPP6o_bk8jEM51oDwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I appreciate any house that grew out of its own environment and offers itself as a living tissue of that same environment to shelter its inhabitants and embellish its surroundings like an intricately decorated picture frame. I am distrustful of metropolises resembling cancerous growths across what used to be fields and forests, clear-cutting its way into endless grid patterns: the fish farm fences conspicuous only from an aeroplane. Urbanization reduces human beings to urbanites and intricate natural spatiality to plush urbanities that go on forever, as far as the eye can see, with ravaging wounds at their edges pretending to be frames.</p><p>Rigid culture can make people sit hungry at a divine banquet table because a dish of their unique demand hasn’t been served. They miss on Zeus’ divine revelry splattered from the sky only to refresh wild strawberries for a unique feast that can only be enjoyed a few days in a year. I almost consider it a sacred duty to step out the cage of my culture on a day like this and become at least a tinge of an animal, as much as I can muster without pretence: growl naked, stand high to sniff the air, attune my ears to the crackles of the woods.</p><p>I’m not saying culture is to be done away with. You can play along with whatever it demands when you’re in its realm. Today it’s barbecue, tomorrow it’s hot-pot, some other day it’s rice and curry, fish and chips, eggs and beans, pitta and hummus, pastasciutta, pumpernickel bread. Tomorrow it is plain mangoes, figs, grapes, oranges, blackberries, strawberries…</p><p>Her lips greet me softly. The kiss is the blend of culture and nature in its quintessential form. Our matching lipstick proves to be exactly that: lip-stick. Under the chilly top layer of her skin, I can hear her heartbeat and her warm belly full of fire.</p><p>From this mountain valley, those gridlocked fish farms and wounded frames seem too far away. Only red strawberry stains on my fingers remind me of my part in my species’ bloody sins. I wonder: What can I do about it now? Our sins are bigger than these mountains and I am just a tiny critter in their grace, for the good or for the bad.</p><p>I don’t ask the age-old question, how to move mountains. I wonder how to be moved by them. How to find my place in the middle, between the mountains and strawberries, with a home that suits me and a frame that heals<em> </em>both culture and nature, rather than wounding them. Can I do that whilst kissing her?</p><p>I whisper across those ridges to my friends on the other side: Your home is not just walls and rooms, it’s rituals and patterns. When you go outside, you carry your home with you as you choose how to move each thing or be moved by it. Nature is not yours for the taking, it&#39;s sacred. Most of all, you must know that when spirits of nature come to take you, that’s sacred too.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZHFgakYq553AdqRMKSvVYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s no secret that the rituals and patterns of the home I grew up in were shadowed by fear of death. That was not the invention of my parents, of course, they simply adopted the rituals and patterns from our vast fish cage. The fear has only gotten worse as we built increasingly smaller boxes in corners of the cage, intricately fractalizing it to allow privacy to all. In that “privacy” we could feel safe from each other, from bears and wolves, ticks and mosquitoes, and even from Sun and Moon chewing away that little time which we used to have.</p><p>“Tell me, what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life?” she whispers <a href="http://www.phys.unm.edu/~tw/fas/yits/archive/oliver_thesummerday.html">Mary Oliver’s</a> words in my ear. It’s a reminder that the greatest poets extend their spirits across culture and nature, broadening and embellishing the transition between them. They sculpt invisible guidelines on how to align with who we are. Death is just around the corner, just around the shade of that highest peak. A petty hurricane is enough to impress on us the rampancy of nature and how easily even the sturdiest homes turn into rumpled graves.</p><p>Homes of the living became grander than ever, some conglomerations of flats, shops and offices for millions, and others isolated mega-properties of the ultra-rich. While the cages of the rich paint on the landscape a deplorable patchwork of glitter with barbed wire strung around them, tiny cages of the poor are lumped in clusters of fifty shades of brown. The subtle spaces of transition between culture and nature are disappearing and with them the treasure that we humans have to gift to the Earth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IJiQC0Kp_PROTkCejIiNVA.jpeg" /></figure><p>We have squandered the treasure of squatting amid strawberries, forgetful of time, absorbed by our ancient instincts. To enjoy such space we would have to open our guts, but that takes time. It takes time to relax in our own storms and befriend the dirt under our bare feet, befriend the tiger’s breath on our neck.</p><p>To relish three hours of wild strawberry breakfast in a mountain valley I should be at peace with that breath on my neck. The paws of these mountains may reach out to eat me any time, a storm too mighty, a gourmet bear, a spirit mad with a vengeance. How do I know when to give it a fight, because it’s not my time, and when to give in, ripe and delicious?</p><p>I can only learn this here: from the eagle’s squeal, from the breeze echoing the storm, from the taste of that last strawberry I’m gently rolling in my mouth while folding the tent. We’re ready to head back to our homely fish cages. I tuck the berry under my tongue. I know it hasn’t ripened to be plucked to go, but I also know I can do it with this one. The rituals and patterns of these mountains are not to be flouted. After all, they feed me when I trust them, and I trust them even when they make me go hungry for a week. Up here hunger is food too.</p><p>Since I don’t need a house, I don’t need a coffin. I hope to return to those strawberries, to the Milky Way blended with the pounding rain, to merging with the eagle’s giggles and kisses as it gnaws on my open gut. I hope the eagle will take the seeds of those strawberries to another valley, to sprinkle the divine revelry across the mountains so they can keep reminding lost lovers to cherish their matching lip-stick. Kissing the strawberries for hours they will know the beauty of transitions between nature and culture, between life and death.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NrOhiyRaVGKjjfhCs52oTA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Driving past a monument next to the bumpy road to Shkodër, the aftertaste of those strawberries brings <a href="https://philipchircop.wordpress.com/2012/07/17/living-fully-in-the-moment/">Anthony de Mello’s story</a> to mind:</p><blockquote><em>One day, while walking through the wilderness, a man encountered a vicious tiger. He ran for his life, and the tiger gave chase.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The man came to the edge of a cliff, and the tiger was almost upon him. Having no choice, he held on to a vine with both hands and climbed down.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Halfway down the cliff, the man looked up and saw the tiger at the top, baring its fangs. He looked down and saw another tiger at the bottom, waiting for his arrival and roaring at him. He was caught between the two.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Two rats, one white and one black, showed up on the vine above him. As if he didn’t have enough to worry about, they started gnawing on the vine.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>He knew that as the rats kept gnawing, they would reach a point when the vine would no longer be able to support his weight. It would break and he would fall. He tried to shoo the rats away, but they kept coming back.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>At that moment, he noticed a strawberry growing on the face of the cliff, not far away from him. It looked plump and ripe. Holding onto the vine with one hand and reaching out with the other, he plucked it.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>With a tiger above, another below, and two rats continuing to gnaw on his vine, the man tasted the strawberry and found it absolutely delicious.</em></blockquote><p>I swallow that last strawberry for the last peek at freedom from the bottom of my well, and yes, it is delicious!</p><p><em>*Photos by Cynthia Tina and Nara Petrovic</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=44b2fe80434a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social charter for safe spaces]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/social-charter-for-safe-spaces-fab2c0d4b825?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fab2c0d4b825</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[safe-space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ideology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-charter]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 May 2021 15:25:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-07T12:43:43.097Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>There are many ways a sense of safety can be upset in any social setting. And there are also many possible reactions to that safety being upset.</em></p><p>Societies consisting of conflicting groups are highly “inflammable” and require stronger measures against transgressions (in places like Ireland, Balkans, Palestine, regions in India etc.). A small spark may ignite a massive fire. It goes without saying that such fires start around irrational, ideological and even dogmatic matters that people viscerally identify with.</p><p>Societies with fewer (overt!) tensions permit broader and freer expressions. There’s less chance that offence will be taken and that reactions to such “offence” will be fierce, even violent. <em>Covert </em>tensions, however, may come to the surface explosively in seemingly non-conflicting heterogeneous societies. We’ve seen that in ex-Yugoslavia — with the first religious war in history among atheists.</p><figure><img alt="Photo by &lt;a href=”https://unsplash.com/@ryoji__iwata?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText&quot;&gt;Ryoji Iwata&lt;/a&gt; on &lt;a href=”https://unsplash.com/s/photos/people?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText&quot;&gt;Unsplash&lt;/a&gt;" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/1*fT5PookeA3OvYthAOAuqgQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Homogenous vs. heterogeneous society</h3><p>In homogenous groups, everyone is immersed in common culture and certain normative behavior, guided by the same inner moral compass as everyone else. It’s tempting to go that way: let’s all become Mormons or Scientologists or Sufis or Evangelicals or Hare Krishnas or Democrats or … — being homogenous would level the ground and we wouldn’t need to struggle with a myriad of cross-cultural translations. (Everyone would, of course, be most comfortable with their own culture/ideology prevailing and uncomfortable adjusting to another culture/ideology.)</p><p>The history of civilisation is cultures and ideologies spreading dominance over each other in thousands of wars. Only recently have we learned to coexist in (a relatively) hetero-cultural reality without killing each other by millions over different beliefs, bodily characteristics, folklore, manners and habits.</p><p>The price of a diverse society is that everyone has to adapt to some shared neutrality (which, let’s admit, is never 100% neutral, but it’s the best we can do in any given era). No matter what culture and ideology you practice in your home and close social circles, there are secular rules of behaviour in common spaces. Therefore a high level of <em>freedom of ideological expression and pluralism is only possible in a secular state.</em> Secular society secures the neutral ground, the safe space for cross-cultural interactions that would otherwise be difficult or even impossible.</p><p>In shared spaces, it is necessary to follow neutral, non-instigating behaviour and messaging. No swastikas on shawls in Europe, for example. Let me add that in Europe, swastikas might be unacceptable but in India, they are a common symbol of good luck, visible on facades and on religious paraphernalia. It would be unenlightened to censor them in that cultural context predating nazism by a few millennia. On the other hand, if you drew a swastika in the Western countries to <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2016/10/28/499475248/diwali-dilemma-my-complicated-relationship-with-the-swastika">celebrate Diwali</a>, you shouldn’t be shocked if angry people knocked on your door.</p><p>Ah, how easy our lives would be in the simplicity of homogenous groups! People would keep themselves and others in place on their own. But would they really?</p><h3>Secularism secures space for ideological freedom</h3><p>As long as there is an enlightened, secular common space in society, there will be safe spaces for cross-cultural expression. Secular law depends on the separation of state and religion (or ideology) — the law is the guardian of just, safe space and people count on the law to hold transgressors accountable and to remove the most disruptive ones from the society.</p><p>When an ideology enters the state and the law, general social space becomes less safe for other ideologies to express — and paradoxically even for the dominant ideology itself! We can see this wherever a single ideology takes over: society becomes rigid, puristic and intolerant to the fringe inside its own ranks.</p><p>Ask a Muslim, adapted to living in the West, where she would prefer to see her daughter grow up, in Denmark or in Saudi Arabia (or the country of their ancestors). I don’t say <em>all </em>mothers would prefer Denmark but I wouldn’t be surprised if <em>most </em>would.</p><p>What’s true about the general society is also true about smaller groups and organisations. Secular (non-ideological) general culture is necessary to secure safe spaces for ideologies to coexist. Mature groups keep a large common space of neutrality where each individual can enter with their fuller self without feeling the need to self-censor her or his words, ideas, clothes, symbols … but it goes the other way around too: mature individuals respect the safe space and are conscious of how bringing in too much of their culture may make it smaller for others.</p><p>“What I stand for is not ideology, it’s science,” some people might say. To check if that’s true, ask them, under what conditions would they change what they stand for. If they wouldn’t change it under any conditions, it’s ideology. If they can think of conditions that would make them change their mind, then they’re standing on rational, scientific ground.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SwELYpMsjvFHbSL4R1-qDw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The own trap of secularism</h3><p>Secular openness to diversity allows for the spread of ideological radicalism inside that openness. A homogenous society gives less room to extrinsic ideologies, while a heterogeneous society is inherently open. Self-regulation by public opinion is not guaranteed when a powerful ideology comes up and starts spreading. Mature ideologies are patient and allow for decades, even centuries to spread, while young ideologies tend to proselytise more feverishly and forcefully.</p><p>The best mechanism for protecting heterogeneous societies from homogenisation is, still, self-regulation powered by cross-cultural enlightenment. To foster the coexistence of diverse ideologies we need a high level of cross-cultural literacy and tolerance. We need to scrutinise ideologies and detach them from cultural identities. Only in enlightened societies, can dogmatism diminish and <em>functional </em>diversity becomes possible.</p><p>The diversity of cultures enriches humanity, builds character and shouldn’t be done away with. In a pluralistic, metropolitan sphere, however, these cultures need to soften down on edges to be able to interact and create a safe space for all.</p><p>The mobility across subcultures is a sign of a truly pluralistic society. The ghettoization of subcultures, with low or no mobility, is a manifestation of false heterogeneity. Social pressure and cultural oppression keep diverse groups in their separate “fences” and discourage deep intercultural blending. High global cultural pluralization may enrich our civilisation or impoverish it.</p><p>The trap here is that in the name of diversity an open society may end up broken down, fragmented if people are not meeting across cultures sufficiently and if shared neutral spaces are not used.</p><h3>The danger of hypersensitivity</h3><p>Protecting the weak is a common instinct in humanity. Developed societies take good care of the disadvantaged and underprivileged. The quality of human culture literally depends on solidarity.</p><p>Ideologies can abuse such solidarity by inventing and inflating points of vulnerability and spreading their tenets to neutral spaces. Thus they make these spaces safer for the adherents of the ideology but less safe for others; safe space narrows down and becomes less inclusive.</p><p>Hypersensitivity plus hyper-reactivity make for a tremendous force. A pattern emerges: in the eyes of the ideologue even the smallest transgression justifies a fierce counterattack. They also insist on holding both the role of the “plaintiff” and that of the “judge” (they want to call out the wrongdoing and decide the punishment). The end <em>doesn’t </em>justify the means if you use bigotry to fight bigotry, intolerance to fight intolerance, hate speech to fight hate speech etc.</p><p>If neutral spaces become invaded by the rules of one ideology, especially if that becomes an official requirement or even a law, that’s the road to disaster. Organizations and governments should resist such infringements on liberal social agreements and protect secular, neutral spaces from ideological dominance.</p><p>Maybe we need to add a chapter on neutral, safe spaces to the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Social_Charter">European Social Charter</a>? The manner such spaces are used is an indicator of the heterogeneity of our society. If diverse people participated in cross-cultural exchange, that’s a good sign; if protests and boycotts occur at the suggestion of <em>broadening the freedom </em>of neutral spaces that’s a bad sign.</p><p>I think we need to insist that (sub)cultures respect the neutral, secular nature of shared spaces and participate in those spaces — knowing that these spaces can never be 100% neutral — they are and will always be tilted towards the prevailing cultural heritage and that’s inevitable. Presuming irreformable systemic viciousness in the dominant ideology and suggesting that the reform is only possible by replacing it with a new ideology, closes the doors for a conversation and will lead to a war of ideologies over neutral spaces. When one extreme conquers a fraction of the neutral space, the other extreme won’t stop until they do the same.</p><p>We should not tolerate ideologies violently imposing their norms on neutral spaces. If some people don’t want to collaborate in neutral spaces and if they choose to call such spaces systemically biased, they can do so, but that’s not a reason enough to expect that others will blindly consent to another, usually a much narrower version of “neutrality”, being enforced on everyone. We must challenge our own ideological shortsightedness and narrow-mindedness, we must challenge each other, we need more common ground, not less. That’s how human civilisation can keep collective madness and insanity from running amok.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fab2c0d4b825" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Three levels of knowledge for lasting prosperity]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/three-levels-of-knowledge-for-lasting-prosperity-38592a0e71d5?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38592a0e71d5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics-and-morals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[knowledge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-control]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innate-knowledge]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 Feb 2020 09:34:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-04T13:06:56.702Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Knowledge is the key reason why humans distanced themselves from nature and built an <em>artificial</em> society. Knowledge (or intelligence) is of three sorts:</p><p>1. innate knowledge,<br>2. technical knowledge,<br>3. moral knowledge.</p><p><strong>Innate knowledge</strong> originates from nature through the interweaving of diverse strands of life. Knowledge increments take place very slowly, coming from the genetic potential of past generations interacting with the environment. Innate knowledge is expressed instinctively and ensures the survival of species. Birds fly, fish swim, rabbits run — one life feeds on another. The swirling of living structures follows natural laws and weaves them into varied, constantly changing patterns.</p><p>If an animal is unable to enact its innate knowledge adequately, it won’t survive. A fish that doesn’t swim well will soon end up as food.</p><figure><img alt="Photo by R. Mac Wheeler on Unsplash" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EU1Ztv2TigYQAT29PeXOXg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@rmacwheeler?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">R. Mac Wheeler</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/dead-fish?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Humans have innate knowledge too. Such knowledge creates a strong foundation for all other knowledge. Innate knowledge is the <em>basis</em> of knowledge, but it is also whimsical, unpredictable, and impulsive if you don’t upgrade it with <em>technical </em>knowledge.</p><p><strong>Technical knowledge </strong>arises from the extra intelligence and the capacity for self-reflection that separates humans from other species. At first, the increase in technical knowledge has been slow — much faster than in the case of innate knowledge, but still slow. As small communities grew into civilizations, technical knowledge began to increase exponentially.</p><p>Without technical knowledge, there would be no ingenious musicians, painters, sculptors, mathematicians, craftsmen, cooks, etc. It enables them to assess and predict hundreds of details particular to their field of expertise and, most importantly, they’re <em>masters of consistent repetition</em>.</p><p>Innovating and repeating create an interplay. An invention’s greatest value is exhibited when it’s universal; when everyone can use it and reach a predictable result; when it can be repeated consistently. Technical knowledge is at the heart of all scientific progress, but on the other hand, it is cold, impersonal, mechanical, and heartless if it’s not accompanied by <em>moral </em>knowledge.</p><p><strong>Moral knowledge </strong>recognizes the relationship between people and their environment and <em>sets constraints </em>to innate and especially to technical knowledge, using qualifiers, such as good/bad, right/wrong, acceptable/unacceptable, allowed/prohibited, etc.</p><p>In every single society, setting constraints is partially rigid and partially flexible, thus determining the always-changing boundaries of the entire culture. As technical knowledge advances, new possibilities stretch the old constraints, often leading to cultural collisions, wars, and increased extraction from ecosystems.</p><p>Moral knowledge is not automatically good, it’s <em>always</em> relative. The way it sets constraints is limited by cultural biases. At one point, a society may justify genocide and even encourage it, but at another point, it may seek reconciliation at new boundaries between maturing cultures. The threat of global destruction is the ultimate moral motivator, especially the threat of <em>self-</em>destruction.</p><p>Between the extremes of self-destruction and self-preservation, you may notice moral knowledge at every step, for it sets constraints to various technological inventions. While in the past, moral knowledge defined the identity of various cultures uniquely, globalization has made it unavoidable to try to respond to moral questions universaly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*VGXBHnwcKQdBLxl2uv6Vrw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The interplay between technical and moral</h3><p>Moral knowledge keeps an eye on the harms that may come as side effects of new technical inventions and <em>tries to</em> set constraints on how we use them. I stressed <em>“tries to”</em> as it’s extremely hard to enforce limitations when a new promising technology emerges. Think about dynamite, DDT, asbestos, internal combustion engines, plastic bags, nuclear energy… Initially, it was hard to imagine how hazardous they will turn out to be.</p><p>All instructions for use (especially the warnings written in bold) fit in the category of moral knowledge. Other examples are the behavioral norms, laws, regulations, statutes, provisions, orders, standards, religious commandments.</p><p>As ancient systems of technology and morality keep fading away, many cultures are under immense pressure to give up their well-tested moral knowledge and replace it with some modern, global version of morality. The wise elders have good reasons to be suspicious of the ultra-rapid and uncontrolled technological development, but they don’t have the appropriate moral knowledge to constrain it.</p><p>Moral knowledge is clumsy and it reacts slowly. One part of it remains stuck in backward cultural traditions, while another is lured by the promise of technological advancement and prosperity. Go to Abu Dhabi, Bengaluru, Rome, Cairo, or Kyiv, and you’ll see both these forces in action in a very strange fusion of the old and the new. If you look carefully, you can see it everywhere.</p><p>Moral knowledge cannot keep pace with the whoosh of technological progress. It’s easy to take advantage of moral knowledge, as it depends on how it is interpreted. On the basis of one and the same religious morality, one person may kill, and the other save lives.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*f89vIe_ermLX7eMhpqVp6g.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Levels of a knife</h3><p>Let me illustrate all three forms of knowledge through the use of a knife.</p><p>At the level of innate knowledge, you use a knife pretty much as a claw, as an extension of your body. You’re not savvy at all, relying on the same “techniques” whether you dig a hole or stab an animal.</p><p>At the level of technical knowledge, you use the knife with skill. You may be a chef chopping an onion finely in five seconds, an artist carving a statue from wood, or a mercenary skillfully murdering a man. The skill doesn’t only change how you use the knife, you’ll change the knife itself to serve you better.</p><p>At the third level, the knife becomes a symbol. That symbol tells you to use any weapon within a specific framework. A knife emblem may remind members of an indigenous tribe to hunt only with cold weapons, thus constraining how many animals they can catch. In war, a symbol of a knife may mean that the aggressor must be stopped without mercy. In an extreme case, such a symbol can be used to incite ethnic cleansing. It can be a symbol of precision for a ham business because customers adore perfectly sliced ​​ham. Or it may serve as a reminder to descendants of war victims that violence leads to suffering and should, therefore, be avoided.</p><p>Moral knowledge determines in which directions you close or open the constraints of your behavior.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*yQRGenPBhF1TxhPwgGyF0w.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Harmonizing levels of knowledge</h3><p>In recent centuries, technical knowledge has exploded. The antiquated moral knowledge lags behind by centuries. The consequence is a wound in the environment, and the inadequacy of moral levers: laws, regulations, norms, etc. Just look at the impotence of climate negotiations.</p><p>Innate knowledge, when that’s the only knowledge you have, needs no constraints, because nature itself takes care of it. Technical knowledge, on the other hand, urgently needs to be constrained lest it becomes cancerous and self-destructive.</p><p>The larger the group of people involved in the chain of activities, the greater the cumulative impact of their knowledge. When a group of 70 or 7000 people gathers resources from nature — with very few tools and machines — it won’t do much harm. However, when 7 billion people unite, relying on millennia of their ancestors’ inventions, and when they start extracting raw materials with gargantuan machines, while their bosses are intoxicated with power, then the environment will end up under immense pressure.</p><p>Thus we come to the central idea of this article: <em>Technical knowledge needs adequate moral knowledge to constrain it.</em> It’s impossible to regulate modern technology with morality from two thousand years ago.</p><blockquote><em>The saddest aspect of life right now is that science gathers knowledge faster than society gathers wisdom.<br>- Isaac Asimov</em></blockquote><p>The dominance of technical knowledge is evident from the way it dominates school curricula, while moral and innate knowledge are marginalized as inferior or relative. The school system tries to keep up with new developments in the field of technical knowledge, but there’s no attention to innate knowledge, while moral knowledge is patched together from ancient ethics and laws without being in touch with real life and nature. It is important to note that good moral knowledge does not reject technical knowledge, it actually channels it to perform useful services and minimize collateral damage.</p><p>The solution is neither suppression of technical knowledge (a return to the primordial “paradise” when humans only had innate knowledge) nor extremely rigid morality (prohibiting technical knowledge with coercive structures). The solution is to get down to the heart of all three types of knowledge.</p><h3>What’s the benefit of knowledge?</h3><p>In the case of innate knowledge, it is essential to ask: <em>What is biologically right and natural for humans?</em> The innate knowledge contains the capacities of survival, procreation, self-affirmation, healing, and elementary satisfaction.</p><p>At the level of technical knowledge, the key question is: <em>What does an invention facilitate and how?</em></p><p>Throughout human history, an important function of technical knowledge was protection from the crude forces of nature, securing provisions, defeating foes, and conquering new territories. In it, we look for efficiency, we aim to make our lives easier, richer, healthier, to have fun, and expand our knowledge for its own sake.</p><p>Technical knowledge about things (managing “natural resources”), enhanced by technical knowledge about human groups (managing “human resources”) leads to some powerful individuals (chiefs, rulers, bosses) using people as chess pieces to fight against other powerful individuals’ chess pieces. Tribes grew into kingdoms, countries, and corporations.</p><p>The power, stemming from technical knowledge, became an end in itself, detached from any other purpose. It doesn’t make our lives easier nor is it fun.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WfGMYdalClU">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WfGMYdalClU</a></p><p>We should ask ourselves; to what extent does technical knowledge still increase efficiency? Does it really simplify and enrich our lives? Does it enable learning and deep satisfaction? Does it consider all people equally? Not only the end-user of a product, but also the miner in Africa, the factory worker in China, the Ukrainian technician on an ocean liner, the Turkish trucker who brings the product to the mall, and the local saleswoman sitting at the cash register, and listening all day to peep, peep, peep, peep…</p><p>True learning never loses touch with simplicity. Wise people see how much suffering comes from complicating life and they keep their lives as simple as possible. That’s the spiritual dimension of moral knowledge.</p><p>A key challenge for the whole of humanity today is bringing all three levels of knowledge in alignment. Technical knowledge has to join hands with innate and moral knowledge to facilitate humanity’s <em>sustainable and lasting</em> prosperity. All that moral knowledge has to do then is to apply the K.I.S.S. principle: “Keep it simple, stupid!”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38592a0e71d5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is the ideal of human existence?]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/what-is-the-ideal-of-human-existence-ababfe171e69?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ababfe171e69</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[simplicity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[good-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[joy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 Jan 2020 08:36:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-12T08:36:07.518Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The basis of a good life is the same for all of us on the planet. The six essentials are:</p><ul><li>clean air</li><li>pure water</li><li>healthful food</li><li>safe shelter</li><li>harmonious relationships</li><li>purposeful activity</li></ul><p>Improving these six will favorably affect any person’s life. Social progress at the expense of the essential elements is not only risky, but it’s also stupid. Quality at the elementary level is the basis of personal fulfillment, integrity, and satisfaction at all other levels, such as work, art, science, leisure, etc.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4dNFlP0ls5JUXWQewxqotg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Elizabeth Gottwald on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><h3>Why be poor, when you can <em>hope </em>to be rich?</h3><p>Frank Lloyd Wright said it so well: “Give me the luxuries of life and I will willingly do without the necessities.”</p><p>Give people a choice between a very simple life with the above six essentials guaranteed, and a mere prospect of a rich life without the above guarantee, and most will go for the later. But how many do actually achieve the luxuries? And does luxury equate happiness?</p><p>Millions of poor forsake a simple life and head for the promise in the city, ending up with a stressful minimum wage job renting a moldy flat close to a highway, or even worse, ending up homeless.</p><p>Democratic constitutions promise the citizens a safe and healthy living environment. So, in theory, your constitution guarantees you the six essentials of a good life. But does it really? How clean is the urban air? What’s the food like? And how affordable is decent housing?</p><p>Going to a large city is a gamble. Only a few become millionaires, often by putting themselves through immense physical, mental, and moral pains. They have to play dirty, maneuvering in gray waters of financial speculation, hoarding more than they’ve deserved.</p><p>The rest are forced to work hard. If they’re a little lucky with their initial standing (ethnicity, creed, family background, connections, wit, etc.), they’ll secure their place in the middle class. If not, they’ll work even harder for sheer survival. Those born in the city will inherit their family standings and they may move some steps up or down the social ladder, but extreme shifts remain rare.</p><p>There’s a lot of promise in the city, but once you buy the lottery ticket for this promise, you have to keep buying more tickets — whether you’re winning or losing. Once you get used to the inherent cost of participation in the system, you accept it as your only choice. There’s no way out.</p><h3>The power of context</h3><p>I’m drawing this picture to illustrate the power of social context as it limits your choices. The social context in our modern civilized lifestyle is an immense force. When trying to find solutions for global problems, we’re unable to think outside that box.</p><p>To understand why, let’s look at the last of the six essentials: <em>purposeful activity.</em></p><p>What’s your purpose in life? What are you living for? What excites you? What are your ideals, passions, and aspirations?</p><p>Please, give these questions some thought before you read on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*2SySnOChlbkHWFUKOLf3gA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I bet you haven’t thought of optimizing how you meet your basic needs. Or have you?</p><p>Have you considered your air, water, food, shelter, etc.? Or do you think they’re not in the domain of the life’s purpose? Maybe you even think there’s nothing you can do about them?</p><p>I bet you’re thinking about your purpose within your social framework. You can’t escape your context; even when you go to the remotest corner on Earth, the civilization is still with you, around you, and <em>in </em>you. Future generations will have to bear with an even more constraining context in the face of collapsing ecosystems and potentially social structures too.</p><p>But what do social constraints have to do with <em>your individual </em>purpose? Can’t you just choose to express it in whichever way you want?</p><h3>Externalized purpose</h3><p>Well, you can’t.</p><p>The pressure to fit inside the norms is horrendous. Your society doesn’t give you any other choice but to be part of purposes that are external to you and your natural environment. The society’s purpose is externalized and therefore your own too.</p><p>Today, the verb “to externalize” appears mostly in economy, meaning: “Fail or choose not to incorporate (costs) as part of a pricing structure, especially social and environmental costs resulting from a product’s manufacture and use. (quoted from Wikipedia)” Such is the norm in the economy and in that context, ethical businesses stand no chance.</p><p>In the same line of thought, to <em>externalize purpose </em>means to fail or choose not to align aims with essential needs at the cost of estrangement from one’s self, one’s community, and the natural environment.</p><p>The externalized purpose is the uniting feature of all major civilizations. You sacrifice your life in the pursuit of a “greater goal,” whatever that means in your cultural milieu. You can literally give your life in a war for your nation or in an evangelic mission to convert the faithless to your religion. Or you can give your life figuratively, by committing it to science, art, sport, health, career, or to simple acts of kindness. As long as you’re doing it within the civilization, the purpose of which is externalized, your own purpose will be externalized too.</p><p>The indigenous are not estranged from their tribe and their immediate natural environment. They don’t aspire for eternal bliss and they don’t fear eternal condemnation. Their deities are personifications of natural forces. After death, their bodies return to nature, and the living escort their spirit to an afterlife: reuniting with the ancestors, with the great spirit of nature, reincarnating, etc. The purpose of their present life is to nurture ties with the tribe and the environment, not to save themselves from the misery of this world and ascend to the blessed divine eternity.</p><p>I’m aware this is an oversimplification. I don’t idealize the life of the indigenous. It has its own agonies civilization found a solution for. My perspective is not “either, or”, but rather “hand in hand.”</p><p>By the way, to assess how estranged your culture is, look at what it does with the dead. Are bodies and souls forever removed from nature or do they go back to nature after death?</p><p>What is the dominant story about your fate after you die? Does the story of the afterlife affect your purpose in this life?</p><p>Now forgive me for my inability to resist the temptation to quote Anthony De Mello at this point. It’s one of my favorite passages and it’s so relevant here:</p><blockquote>“Many think the most important question in the world is: ‘Does God exist?’ Wrong!</blockquote><blockquote>“Many think it is: ‘Is there a life after death?’ Wrong!</blockquote><blockquote>“Nobody seems to be grappling with the problem of: Is there a life <em>before </em>death?</blockquote><blockquote>“Yet my experience is that it’s precisely the ones who don’t know what to do with this life who are all hot and bothered about what they are going to do with another life. One sign that you’re awakened is that you don’t give a damn about what’s going to happen in the next life. You’re not bothered about it; you don’t care. You are not interested, period.”</blockquote><p>And now back to the indigenous. For the most part, their purpose is internalized. After death, they release their bodies and souls back to nature. While they’re living, they move with the seasons, with the rhythms of nature. They take the most out of life’s essentials. It’s a very simple and very rich life.</p><p>Civilized people, on the other hand, live for something external from their selves and their environment. They’re estranged from their tribes and their natural environment. Their purpose is based on social constructs. They can choose to pursue happiness by aiming at riches, success, power, leisure, mastery in some skill, knowledge, charity, eternal afterlife … On the outside, their life seems very abundant, but on the inside, they often feel miserable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*djHAxeTUrMXeR3WJ42PXwg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@nic_bui?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Nicholas Bui</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/unhappy?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Living a good, simple life just for the sake of living, is not considered much of a purpose in Western culture. You could easily be accused of being an irresponsible freeloader!</p><p>You may say: “Ok, then let me out of the civilization! I don’t want to be seen as a parasite. All I want is a simple life in a cottage in the woods. I take full responsibility for my life and death.”</p><p>There’s no way you can do that!</p><p>There’s a tax for the land you occupy, the rain you harvest, the exchanges of goods with your neighbors. You’re not allowed to be just a human, without also being a legal entity with a birth certificate and tax number.</p><h3>The unstoppable momentum of externalization</h3><p>It’s impossible to stand in the way of civilization as gigantic as ours. Nobody can stop it.</p><p>The civilization tames and subdues nature to serve its pursuit of externalized goals. Nature has no value in and of itself. A human individual has no value in and of herself.</p><p><em>You have no value in and of yourself!</em></p><p>Oppression is institutionalized and the regulation of oppression too.</p><p>If you want to reason the giant out of his insane actions, you have to address him in his language. That language has no words for what he ought to hear. Even if there were, he doesn’t have the capacity to understand them. It’s like asking a member of a dogmatic cult to use common sense.</p><p>All civilizations were initiated by cults that externalized purpose. The 21st-century global civilization is the most dreadful phase of any cult so far. There’s nothing as estranging as the cult of consumerism.</p><p>Is there anything you can do?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YN50Vrndt-QdlstqyLIZUw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Jamie Street on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><h3>The ideal of human existence</h3><p>You can improve your life by making sure the essentials are never compromised. You can resist shiny toys and the quest for more. You can drop the unnecessary necessities and bring your attention to the internal purpose and align with nature. You can reclaim your soul from the fearmongering spiritual tyrants.</p><p>You can open yourself to the simple joy of living. You don’t need to do anything to be joyful. When joy is absent, that’s the sign of interference or obstacle. Tangible interferences in the form of the lack of water, food, health, touch, freedom, love, etc. cause distress and misery, but that’s relatively easy to solve.</p><p>Much worse are the imaginary lacks. If you’re accustomed to earning 10 million dollars a year, you’ll feel the lack when you earn “only” 1 million.</p><p>Take care of the essentials! Go on a walk, and joy should be there whether you’re rich or poor. To become richer you don’t need more stuff. Instead of wasting your energy on accumulating more, invest it in enhancing your capacity of enjoyment and lowering the threshold of satisfaction. When you do that even tiny experiences will be abundant.</p><p>Petty people highly condition their joy, so their “basic needs” include much more than they really need. The simplest way to enhance joy is to simplify the fulfillment of your needs. That should be the key function of science and technology, not all the complication that’s imposed on you.</p><p>Duško Radović put it so well: “You need little to have a life. To have a miserable life, you need a lot more.”</p><p>The ideal of human existence is actually so simple, it’s difficult to describe it in the language of the giant that I’m using here in this text because that’s the norm we all depend on. The key element is internalizing purpose and I can only hope you understand what I mean by this. If everyone did it, that would solve all the world’s problems.</p><p>We’d neutralize the illusion of consumerism without any fight. There’s no need to destroy and retaliate for the harm done thus far. There’s no need to reform and correct. We wouldn’t need to interfere with what’s going on out there. We’d be lying in the sun naked with a flower in our hair and humming our favorite melody. That’s it!</p><p>As it says it the Talmud: “Live well. It is the greatest revenge.”</p><p>—</p><p>This is my fourth article in the series. You can read each article individually, but to make the most out of it read them all from the beginning, starting from:<br> 1. <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/the-ultimate-test-of-your-spiritual-development-ca76b9905833">The Ultimate Test of Your Spiritual Development</a><br>2. <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/the-ultimate-test-of-your-awareness-72fb53605585">The Ultimate Test of Your Awareness</a><br>3. <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/why-is-self-change-is-so-hard-and-how-to-still-achieve-it-84550e06a753">Why self-change is so hard and how to still do it?</a><br>…</p><p>My next article will be about <em>three layers of knowledge:</em> innate, technical, and moral. Understanding their characteristics, you’ll be able to resist the externalization of your purpose, take control of self-change, self-reflection, and self-awareness, and move further towards transcending self-referentiality — relying on your ancient indigenous roots and the fine wisdom of your civilization.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ababfe171e69" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why is self-change is so hard and how to still achieve it?]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/why-is-self-change-is-so-hard-and-how-to-still-achieve-it-84550e06a753?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/84550e06a753</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transcendence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Dec 2019 21:47:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-29T21:47:43.428Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s no secret that sane society comes with a very high price. You have to let go of your sacred habits and norms, your rituals and repetitions, you have to admit that you don’t actually know. In most situations, you’re at least partially wrong. That’s extremely difficult to admit.</p><p>To quote Anthony de Mello: <em>“The three most difficult things for a human being are not physical feats or intellectual achievements. They are, first, returning love for hate; second, including the excluded; third, admitting that you are wrong.”</em></p><p>You have to allow foreign views to be true. Either that or you end up in an unambiguous worldview that never changes and causes great damage. That’s where we are as a society today.</p><p>Self-correction is a two-side road. It works inside out and outside in. The “traffic” sometimes alternates and sometimes takes place simultaneously. Therefore both of the following injunctions are true:</p><p><em>1. To improve yourself, improve something in your external world.<br>2. To improve the world, improve something inside yourself.</em></p><p>Sometimes, the best way to help yourself is to help others, while sometimes taking care of yourself is the best you can do for others. The authentic change affects both and that’s the only way it really works.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8ngZOraEfm2mVq-agE14HQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Self-correction doesn’t work in isolation</h3><p>A spiritual seeker went to a mountain to commit to self-realization. Ten years later, frustrated because he didn’t make it, he headed back but a bird attracted his attention. She kept flying hither and thither carrying water in her beak from a flooded area. The rain had flooded her nest and she wouldn’t stop carrying the water away drop by drop until saving the nest.</p><p>The seeker thought to himself: “Alas, I’m giving up too soon! I have to try harder!”</p><p>He meditated for another decade with no avail. He headed to the valley but, again, on the way he noticed a mouse trying to bite through a large rock. He paid attention to the little animal and realized that an avalanche had fallen on her den and she wouldn’t give up biting on the rock until reaching the den.</p><p>The seeker thought to himself: “Alas, I’m giving up too soon! I have to try harder!”</p><p>Ten years later, still unfulfilled, the seeker headed back and this time he found a dying dog on the path. The seeker opened his flask and poured water on the dog’s snout.</p><p>The dog transformed into a celestial being and said: “What you did just now is worth more than your 30 years of meditation.”</p><h3>Beyond the self and the world</h3><p>Self-seeker was self-preoccupied. He never thought of others. He could have helped the bird and the mouse. Why didn’t he?</p><p>The paradox of self-realization is that you come closest to it when you’re so immersed in others that you forget about yourself. But to be immersed in others genuinely, you have to be radically self-aware without being self-centered.</p><p>Awareness is like breath. That “breath” consists of extrovert intention, action, response, followed by introvert attention, assimilation, learning, thus informing the next breath, and the next… Extroverts spend more time in the first part of the breath than in the second, while for introverts it’s vice versa. Coherent self-change requires both, as well as coherent social change.</p><p>There’s too much specialization and exclusivism today. Dedicated spiritual practice and professional business or political engagement seem irreconcilable. Even if you are into both, you’re expected to keep them segregated. You can’t talk spiritually at a business meeting, and you can’t talk business at a spiritual retreat. It’s not only how you talk that matters, but how you dress, behave, and speak.</p><p>When you enter the realm of spiritual topics, you’re expected to be abstract, ethereal; when you enter the realm of material topics, you have to be concrete, measurable. Why can’t there be both in both realms? To make this possible we’d need to transcend self-referentiality (the concept explained in my <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/the-ultimate-test-of-your-spiritual-development-ca76b9905833">first article in this series</a>).</p><p>The story about soul-seeker draws an image of how an introvert finally “exhales,” releasing the tension. There’s certainly someone in your close circles that went through the opposite: after a long period of toiling and panting she stopped, inhaling slowly and with full attention for the first time in years, calming her breath and appreciating it. Her “breath” meaning her awareness.</p><p>With self-awareness, you access a broader picture of yourself and the world. You’re able to transcend your old images and form new ones. Your self-reflection becomes fresh, making your worldview adaptable <em>and </em>reliable. With that in place, self-correction becomes easy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*DwZe7zmOrJRc6jAENmuxdw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Joy or war?</h3><p>Self-correction should lead to more joy. When you lose track, suffering intensifies and you come back on track. In some cases, you have to change your track when it no longer serves you.</p><p>When you “exhale” you correct the world; when you “inhale” you correct yourself, changing self-awareness and self-reflection.</p><p>The internal change requires unlearning the introjected falsehoods. You have to admit that many of your (seemingly self-evident) convictions are false or at least flawed. You have to look yourself in the eye and face your addiction and dependency, your self-imprisonment, and accept it without self-condemnation. Then self-correction won’t come from violence but from benevolence.</p><p>There’s too much violent change in this world. So many people stand rooted in their own “truth” fighting against others, rooted in their opposite “truth”. Both such truths are flawed and relative but no side would ever admit that.</p><p>Usually, one side fights to consolidate the dominant status quo, while the other tries to undermine it and establish a new order which would, ideally, become a new status quo. You can see this in politics, economy, education, science… To establish a new truth it is often enough to rebut the old — you don’t need to prove you’re right, you only need to prove that your opponent is wrong. By the 21st century, that has become a dominant process of establishing a “truth.”</p><p>A great danger to the sanity of any society is when one “truth” eradicates all others and over a couple of generations becomes indisputable. Such a “truth” will prevail against others through general conviction. Changing the general conviction becomes practically impossible; attempting such a feat is risky! Rising above the face value of both “truths” to build agreement on a deeper level of basic principles, is extremely rare.</p><p>In the meantime, spiritualists are juggling with dozens of techniques of navel-gazing and constructing ever more abstract cosmologies and explanations of human purpose in this Universe. They build insanely complicated referential fields with unique imagery and jargon. Adherents of these referential fields consider their own field superior to others’. If they want to “coexist” they have to create bubbles, holding back from saying what they actually think about each other. The result is <em>violent non-communication.</em></p><p>Pressing the bubbles too closely together intensifies the tension and may trigger a war, where one side defeats the other and establishes domination. Wars are always fought between people caught up in self-referential illusions.</p><p>Were both sides capable of transcending their own referential fields, they could — together — form a new, unbiased referential field and be in agreement. That would be a win-win. Well, if both sides were open to this in the first place, there would be no tension, no war anyway.</p><p>Wars usually end in mediocre compromises. Initially, both sides stubbornly insist on their “truths” and remain impermeable to logic and common sense. When at some point a judge draws the line, then complaining and lamenting take ridiculous proportions.</p><p>What is a referential field, anyway? It’s an <em>agreement </em>of how we get along, how we communicate and negotiate, what we aspire for, how we steer our family, society, culture, etc., and where our (ethical) boundaries lie. We shouldn’t cement our referential fields! Every now and then, when our society runs amok, when the system turns sluggish, we should press the “reset” button and start anew.</p><p>We want more joy, don’t we? That’s the ultimate goal of self-correction: to eliminate suffering and pronounce joy. So, why don’t we use joy as our main measure of progress? Why is nurturing awareness so difficult?</p><h3>We’re all the same…</h3><p>The biggest obstacle to advancing awareness is that those who need it the most are convinced they don’t need it. Duško Radović wisely observed: <em>“When someone is stupid you can’t even prove that to him.”</em></p><p>A norm in our society is that you’re not supposed to probe into major referential fields, no matter how improbable their “truths” and how damaging their actions. Serious mental disorders are hidden under the guise of “freedom” of religious and political (or some other) expression.</p><p><em>That’s insane!</em></p><p>It’s very easy to show the level of insanity in our society. You don’t need to challenge whole referential fields — say, Christianity, neoliberalism, big bang theory, etc. It’s enough to take away a simple everyday ritual to unhinge the majority.</p><p>Let’s erase coffee! One day you wake up and there’s no coffee. Imagine the chaos!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gUJyoLFOdcOMucYNEQUk9Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>I chose coffee because our social ritual built around it is as irrational and redundant as any religious ritual. I’m not saying coffee can’t be good; I’m not saying religious ritual can’t be good. I’m saying neither of them is indispensable. Neither of them was around a while ago and many people can do without them just fine.</p><p>But hundreds of millions of people have introjected such rituals so deeply that losing them would hurt like losing a limb. Or more! For many people religious adherence is so intertwined with their sense of the self, with their culturally assumed identity, they literally can’t imagine changing it. What depends on it is not only survival and social inclusion, but the eternal afterlife! So losing a limb is a lesser concern than being disassociated from the one and only prescribed “truth.”</p><p>Think about it: if giving up coffee frightens you, what about giving up tenets of your sacred worldview? If you‘d rather fight for your coffee and your rituals than give them up, then please, admit in all honesty and modesty your ignorance. Admit you’re far, far from anything transcendent.</p><p>How can I say that? You can only express transcendence by practicing it. Locking yourself up in a fairy-tale about transcendence is dumb. If this statement upset you, it proves my point.</p><p>If you see the slightest sign that you might be locked up in a fairy-tale — even if that fairy-tale is considered infallible by a billion people — please allow that possibility. If you’re upset now, that’s a good sign there’s some falsehood in you.</p><p>When you see it, look for a pocket where correction is possible. Introduce change patiently. Broaden it on the two-way road: inside out and outside in. Talk to those around you and learn what’s realistic.</p><p>In a repressive society, you must be very careful! Make changes in the safety of your home and among trustworthy friends. Better safe than sorry! In the threatening world out there, play by the rules of the game and contribute to small changes only when opportunities open up.</p><p>In a liberal society, there’s repression too, but you can express freedom easier and stand for your rights. Social pressure still keeps the masses in line, but you have the option to step out of line. Liberal societies are usually very comfortable and there’s not much incentive for serious change. Don’t even try! You might cause a breakdown and lose the comforts you’re enjoying. (I’m being cynical, of course.)</p><p>By all means, do something! Change your life before addressing any issues in the world. And when your efforts bring about change in the world, don’t forget about your inner change. Please, never fall prey to the conviction that you’ve reached some ultimate state of perfection.</p><p>Don’t say: “I’ve already changed, I’m good. Now others should change to match my standards.” If you’re unable to <em>keep changing </em>yourself, you have no right to demand change from anyone else — especially not if “change” means expecting them to adopt your own referential field.</p><p><em>You may be the most objective environmental scientist with all the data on your side, but if you present your “truth” forcefully to convert climate change deniers to climate change believers, you’ve already lost your case. You should go beyond your self and the world to the level of principles, asking meta-questions and then looking for answers together with the opposition. Be the first to make that step.</em></p><h3>Stay true to your doubts</h3><p>Can you see how your self-conviction holds you back from self-correction? How self-delusion holds you back from self-reflection? How self-denial holds you back from self-awareness?</p><p>Even famous scientists have fallen in the trap of being over-confident.</p><p>Can you see how far we are from the vastness of change we’d have to undergo as a civilization to attain a truly joyful life? Both individually and collectively. Can we admit with humility there might be a better way? Can we talk about our reference fields openly and scrutinize them thoroughly? Can we accept that our constructed “truths” are not essential to our wellbeing and identity?</p><p>Let’s play a game of challenging each other’s blind rituals, religious and holy as well as blunt and mundane. Let’s challenge that cup of coffee twice a day. Let’s be gentle and understanding while we move on. If we’re aware enough, we’ll learn in the process that we’re all the same.</p><p>The foundations of a joyful life are the same for all of us on the planet. In the next article, I’ll ask the question: “What is the ideal of human existence?” Through the prism of that question, we’ll look at six pillars of organic living and the joy that comes as a natural consequence of it.</p><p>—</p><p>This is my third article in this series. You can read each article individually, but to take the most out of it read them all from the beginning, starting from:<br>1. <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/the-ultimate-test-of-your-spiritual-development-ca76b9905833">The Ultimate Test of Your Spiritual Development</a><br>2. <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/the-ultimate-test-of-your-awareness-72fb53605585">The Ultimate Test of Your Awareness</a><br>…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=84550e06a753" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Ultimate Test of Your Awareness]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/the-ultimate-test-of-your-awareness-72fb53605585?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/72fb53605585</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transcendence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-awareness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Dec 2019 12:44:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-26T12:44:16.033Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>To be aware is to perceive clearly and respond accurately, said Anthony De Mello. That’s also the prerequisite of love.</p><p>If you don’t even see the person in front of you, how can you say you love her? You’re in love with your false and prejudiced image of her. When you react harshly to her, something in you is foul, not in her. Your blurred perception leads to an inaccurate response.</p><p>You’re stuck, however, with unclarity and inaccuracy! You can never completely transcend it. You can’t be purely aware. Reactions and interpretations are preprogrammed and socialized into you. You can’t silence them and be clearly aware of an external object or event, of your internal state or, as in most cases, of a complex combination of both.</p><p>So what to do?</p><figure><img alt="Photo by Azamat Zhanisov on Unsplash" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GjKOJbh4WpEMHsv7ExnZiA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Stupid lemons!</h3><p>Imagine you pick a small pear from a bowl, bite into it without looking, and only then realize it was actually a lemon. Depending on your mental fervor, you’re likely to go through a chain reaction, involving (some or all of) the following:</p><p>You put on a grimace, give the lemon a piercing look, maybe even throw it to the ground.</p><p>“Yuck! Horrible! What in the world have I been thinking about!” you say out loud.</p><p>“Gosh, why am I so hard on myself?” you calm yourself down.</p><p>“It’s mom again! She’s put lemons on top of pears. Again!” you try to rationalize, identify the culprit.</p><p>You go on emotionally: “Ah, how I hate lemons! I don’t even want to eat a pear anymore!”</p><p>You stand up, go to the sink to wash out the lemon taste from your mouth. You take the lemons away and hide them, leaving only pears in the bowl — to teach mom a lesson.</p><p>Hours later when she comes home you observe her secretly while she’s walking around the kitchen table. She doesn’t seem to notice the lemons are missing. That upsets you! And when she picks a pear, bites into it and starts to chat with you about the day, you’re on the verge of exploding.</p><p>She surely knows, she’s irritating you on purpose!</p><p>Finally, you lash out, accusing her of spoiling your day with bloody lemons. She knew you hated them. Why does she <em>always </em>have to do this to you?</p><p>And on and on you go…</p><p>When you stop to take a breath, she tells you that aunt Lilly came on a visit last night and she brought some fruits. It was probably her that put the lemons on top of pears.</p><p>Her explanation makes you want to run to aunt Lilly right away and vent out your anger at her.</p><p>You may go as far as cursing God for creating lemons or to sinking in self-condmnation for being unable to break the spell of making mistakes again and again.</p><figure><img alt="Photo by Callum Shaw on Unsplash — slightly edited by Nara ;-)" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*km30Kz51yAm9h2yonfubgg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Be like a floodlight</h3><p>Are you aware of subtle and gross reactions to what you’ve just read? Can you at least see them in retrospect? Have you observed your internal agreements and disagreements, your feelings and your emotions? Has your mouth salivated when you imagined biting into a lemon? Have you noticed the word “condemnation” in the last paragraph misses an “e”? What’s your reaction to my mention of it?</p><p>I could continue endlessly with such questions, pointing out the impossibility of total awareness. My aim is not to denigrate your attempts to be more aware, nor to arouse frustration because the bar is (always) set too high. My intention is to invite you to relax within objective limitations and stretch the subjective ones gently, with love.</p><p>Forcing yourself to be present, eliminating distractions one by one is counterproductive and ultimately frustrating. Developing self-awareness is not so much about control, tension, and focus. It doesn’t require stopping the process of reaction, but rather encompassing it broadly and relaxing into it; widening the awareness instead of narrowing it.</p><p>Many spiritual teachers have said this: awareness is not a flashlight, it’s a floodlight.</p><p>The flashlight means focused attention. You end up being stuck with the lemon, while your body and mind frantically rush around without you noticing it.</p><p>The floodlight is an all-encompassing presence. You don’t obstruct the chain of reactions to what you perceived. You add awareness of your reaction to the awareness of the perception. And if there are further reactions and events, you keep adding them and removing yourself a step further each time. You can even register when you identified with perception and reaction and when you didn’t.</p><p>That’s the hardest part because <em>you’re programmed to identify</em>. Once your identifications are shaped, it’s extremely unpleasant to scrutinize them. Your instinct is to defend them, not to challenge them.</p><p>To become aware of your identifications, try alternating between defending and challenging them and observe what’s going on inside you. Break a holy habit once, stick to it more rigidly than ever the next time. Take another step back. When you notice being drawn to details and lost in reactions, observe yourself. And if you condemn yourself for being lost, observe that too. Notice the quality of your observing: is it soft and curious, or hard and judgmental? Observe that too.</p><p>There’s a limit to how many steps back you can make and how much you can encompass with your floodlight awareness, without creating a mental conundrum. Relax in your limits and be happy when you make progress. If trust and wonder come naturally to you, fear and prejudice won’t be in the way and you’ll be able to relax even in very stressful situations.</p><figure><img alt="Photo by Tim Marshall on Unsplash" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gIXlQOjOQKspm-Qdl5YyTw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Back to transcending self-referentiality</h3><p>In my <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/the-ultimate-test-of-your-spiritual-development-ca76b9905833">previous article</a>, I announced I’ll write about three key competencies of being spiritual. In my world, being spiritual means transcending self-referentiality. This article takes the explanation a step further. Chapters will be building on each other, so if you haven’t read the first, I’d encourage you to read it and continue with the next one.</p><p>Thus far I elaborated on the first competence: self-awareness. You can train it like a muscle to develop flexible broad floodlight qualities.</p><p>Self-awareness is an extraordinary human gift. It opens you to the curiosity which fosters all inquiry and thus all knowledge. The potential of self-awareness is so immense that society fears it. It would be easiest to completely relax into it; this would save us all the hard work currently invested in building and maintaining walls to keep us from being aware of the truth.</p><p>Allowing awareness, we’d have to face a terrible pain. A truth hurts since key concepts of personal identity are built on false premises and the longer it goes on the more difficult it is to break out of it. This is true in every single culture on the planet.</p><p>You can estimate the stage of development of self-awareness of an individual or a society by the kind of atmosphere around them: tense, stressful, nervous, or relaxed, light, humorous. Go to a spiritual event, a mass or ceremony and observe: are people pent-up or unbuttoned. Are behaviors rigidly measured and misdemeanor harshly judged and even punished?</p><p>Have you ever felt at ceremonies like a lemon among pears? Have others ever “bitten into you” and realized you’re not what you seemed to be and burst out against you? Have you bitten into lemons yourself? Have you been pent-up and bitter — even years later — disapproving of their mistakes unable to get over them?</p><p>You were (and still are) caught up in your own referential field. That’s unavoidable. Just don’t be proud of it and don’t block your own unfolding.</p><p>Self-awareness means seeing that you see, perceiving that you perceive, knowing that you know. And you don’t attach any value, any qualifier to it — neither good nor bad. On the height of self-awareness, you’re able, as an internal observer, to follow your own actions as if they are being performed by someone else.</p><h3>Self-reflection and self-correction</h3><p>Only with <strong>self-reflection </strong>(the second competency),<strong> </strong>values and qualifiers emerge. Here “<em>qualifiers”</em> are your means of evaluating what’s useful, good, right in a particular situation, and what’s harmful, bad, wrong. Like in the case of self-awareness, you may make many steps back by qualifying the qualifiers of qualifiers…</p><p>Let’s say a crowd reacts against a “misdemeanor” of an individual. They yell out negative qualifiers. You take a step back and see the injustice of it because people in the crowd don’t know the full story. You qualify the behavior as unfair. Then you look at your own judgment of them and notice you’re favoring the individual because of your own background. A lemon favoring another lemon amongst pears…</p><p>Your value system is based on socialization. In your childhood, your parents introduced you to some values as positive. Later in life, you may have recognized them as negative; and you’ve exposed many negative values as exaggerated. Such recognition is the driver of all personal and social change.</p><p>The process of being aware and self-reflecting is different in each individual. Each of you reads this text in your own way and interprets it uniquely. In each of you, the impetus for change awakens differently.</p><p>By the way: In large enough groups, the impetus to change is very diffused. It is no coincidence that, in such a diffused social field, the most organic social organization is exactly what we have today: representative democracy. This facilitates decision-making by reducing complexity to two poles and a few parties.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/797/1*Wqwf07A8atKhfv3QfaFO-g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Self-reflection allows you to see all this and be fine with it. The paradox of the pinnacle of self-reflection and all the decisions that go along with such self-reflection is a reconciliation with everything there is — both “good” and “bad”. You’re aware that no decision brings only good to everyone; every choice is can make someone inconvenienced.</p><p>“Mistakes” are portals of discovery. Closing yourself in cramps because you’re making mistakes will only lead to mental and even physical disease. Self-awareness lets you see this on diverse levels. Self-reflection lets you place qualifiers wisely relative to each person, each situation, and in many layers.</p><p>Such an attitude to the unfolding of fate, to the dance of coincidences and conscious decisions, enables healthy <strong>self-correction</strong> (the third competency). Such self-correction emerges from benevolence, not from indignation, fear, disgust, hatred. Ultimately, you are able to stand with courage and strength for the good, and allow the hurtful to fade away without violence.</p><p>The apparent contradiction of the pinnacle of self-correction is that you can be fully in two roles at once: in the role of a completely unaffected observer and in the role of a proactive agent of change.</p><p>(You can read more about self-correction in my next article.)</p><p>I’d like to wrap up the themes I’ve opened up thus far…</p><p>Spirituality is transcending self-referentiality. The three competencies for transcending self-referentiality are:</p><p>1. self-awareness<br>2. self-reflection<br>3. self-correction</p><p>These three competencies enable breadth and depth of presence — <em>clarity of perception and accuracy of response</em>. In practice, they are associated with: commitment without attachment, balance between reason and emotions, stable convictions and steadfast doubt.</p><p>Awareness is the light allowing you to perceive what’s happening — in you and around you. Then you reflect on what you’ve perceived, judge what seems positive and what doesn’t. Self-reflection is based on the value scales you adopt through socialization and as you scrutinize those, you qualify them. You can even qualify your manner of self-reflection etc.</p><p>As you embark on the path of self-change or self-correction, make sure you’re coming from love, not from resentment and hatred.</p><p>Those extraordinary people with broader self-awareness and deeper self-reflection end up changing their lives and teasing society to change too. The society pushes them off to the periphery: change is hard, especially a virtous change; we like it only in theory, not in practice. Only when we realize (self-awareness) how much hardship and suffering it saves us in the long run (self-reflection) are we ready to embrace it (self-correction).</p><p>People with such competences or at least openness to developing them can co-create foundations of a sane society.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=72fb53605585" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Ultimate Test of Your Spiritual Development]]></title>
            <link>https://narapetrovic.medium.com/the-ultimate-test-of-your-spiritual-development-ca76b9905833?source=rss-2e39ca457b0d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ca76b9905833</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-awareness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transcendence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nara Petrovic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Dec 2019 20:42:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-26T12:46:09.307Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>To be spiritual is to transcend.</p><p>“Transcend what?” I ask.</p><p>“Crude materialism. Isn’t that obvious?” I hear the answer.</p><p>No, it’s not obvious!</p><p>It’s highly suspicious, if not outright false.</p><p>When people present something as obvious, self-evident, undeniable, definite… I’ll definitely question it. Call it crude materialism, greed, sin, godlessness, attachment, illusion, arrogance, disobedience… none of these are <em>obvious </em>felonies to be transcended.</p><p>All such “obvious” truths need to be examined with utmost scrutiny! Particularly when such “truths” are prescribed, expected, enforced, especially in the ethereal domain of spirituality.</p><p>There’s hardly anything in the world as self-serving as spirituality. Charismatic speakers have often led their followers to literally moronic behaviors. Sometimes they convinced almost everyone.</p><p>Once everyone is doing something, it doesn’t seem moronic anymore. The behaviors closest to you are the most difficult to see and, yes, to transcend.</p><p>So, the test of genuine spirituality is: can you go beyond your most intimate field of reference?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*SCI8W4lXar9REPG3z_Kf-w.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Can you transcend your own self-referentiality?</h3><p>I guess you’ve never encountered this phrase — transcend self-referentiality — so please repeat it a few times (if you can even pronounce it) and then let me explain it as plainly as possible…</p><p>Christians hold the Bible as their cherished evidence and reference. Proof of a (religious) truth is simple: it says so in the Bible. The Bible is true because the Bible says so.</p><p>That’s a literal example of self-referentiality. A less literal example is when you hold something as true because your trusted source says so. The factfulness of that source is a fundamental social convention, deeply rooted in tradition.</p><p>Tradition defines cultural identity. Therefore tradition is bound to be irrational. Tribes have concocted their own symbols and manners to distinguish themselves from other tribes. Today, large ethnicities and nations base their identity on the same irrational concoctions.</p><p>At the core of cultural identity is usually a religion. Well, in the recent century, you have the liberty to choose nonadherence to religion, or a political ideology, or a thought system of logical axioms… and I bet you can think of some other possibilities.</p><p>Religion is diametrally opposed to spirituality; it is <em>cemented </em>in self-referentiality. Its definition of “transcendence” is unmistakable. The religious are more prone to exhibit relentless self-referentiality than the agnostics, but even the avowed skeptics may themselves end up in their self-constructed referential prisons.</p><p>All religions have worked out some form of absolute good and evil, virtue and sin. All other goods and evils are subjected to those proclaimed as absolute. Strip a religion to the bone and you’ll find that, for all practical purposes, it’s an ethical code. That code is made up of a number of ingredients: some ageless common sense, some ridiculous folklore, some control-mongering, some fear, some tact, some empty promises, and loads of repetition.</p><p>Yes, you can find fantastic wisdom in religion, but that doesn’t give any credit to the dumb, superstitious context around it.</p><p>And being non-religious doesn’t automatically absolve you of self-referentiality!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*BcPPw3aW_DPwWUDl0-hZoQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Take the ethics, the code of good and bad, and transpose it to your own life. What tensions do you notice? Which referential fields are clashing against each other? What do you consider holy and what do you abhor?</p><p>Your individual experience is invariably nested in the global tension between neoliberal capitalism (including consumerism) and the rising environmental movement. Currently, these two ideologies stand in opposition to each other, they’re caught in self-referentiality.</p><p>What’s good for capitalism is bad for ecology, and vice versa. Climate negotiations are bound to fail with both camps categorically insisting on their own referential fields and a priori dismissive of the other side.</p><h3>The best solution to this conundrum is spirituality</h3><p>But it has to be <em>spirituality </em>as I’ve defined it here: <em>transcending self-referentiality.</em></p><p>You can’t have a conversation in a vacuum, of course. You need a referential field to interact. When both opposing sides transcend their self-referentiality they may form a neutral referential field, free of biases and presumptions.</p><p>Then the capitalist can comprehend the ecologist’s “truth”, and the ecologist can understand the capitalist’s “truth”. Empathy serves as a super-conciliator.</p><p>Transcending self-referentiality is the precondition of every deep collaboration between different cultural backgrounds. It’s essential that both sides transcend it, and not that one side demands it from the other while not enacting it herself.</p><p>Evangelization is enforcement of a referential field. Yes, this does create the basis of social cohesion, but at a dire cost: institutionalized falsehood. The achieved uniformity can only be maintained with violence.</p><p>When a deeply spiritual message resounds in a religious society, it will be shunned or even declared a blasphemy. A wide agreement is a sign that the message doesn’t pierce through the institutionalized falsehoods. It’s tame and fearful.</p><p>Once you raise above your own self-referentiality sufficiently, you can see everything I elaborated on thus far. You can see your limitations along with the limitations of your society.</p><p>You know that grounding yourself firmly in your own “truth” doesn’t make much difference, It’s not really <em>your </em>truth. You’ve constructed this “truth” from stories and ideas and emotions and experiences you’ve picked from others throughout your life.</p><p>Maybe one day you reach a point where you define yourself, along with everything in your referential field, without any rigid “right and wrong.” Nothing shocks you. You see through everything because you’ve seen through yourself.</p><p>You see through the news on the TV. You’re immune to all the BS around you. You smile at atrocities and catastrophes. You laugh at inflated interpretation. And most of all: you laugh at yourself.</p><p>You notice your own idiocies and remain serene. Your self-change doesn’t happen as a fearful reaction, but instead as a patient and conscious act of love.</p><p>You don’t take yourself (too) seriously. You’ve transcended self-referentiality. Your identity is fluent, not cemented. You’re strong in your softness.</p><p>As such, you can interact with anyone and give them a fair deal regardless of what they appear to be on the outside: a president or a begar, a CEO or a teenager, a prostitute or a movie star.</p><p>You’ve transcended self-referentiality!</p><p>In my following article, I describe <a href="https://medium.com/@narapetrovic/the-ultimate-test-of-your-awareness-72fb53605585">three key competencies for transcending self-referentiality</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ca76b9905833" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>