<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Naveen Mathew on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Naveen Mathew on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@naveenmathew0508?source=rss-e957104aba4f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 10:38:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@naveenmathew0508/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Music Tech and Production]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@naveenmathew0508/music-tech-and-production-a2a33a32145a?source=rss-e957104aba4f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a2a33a32145a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-production]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[online-music-streaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Naveen Mathew]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Aug 2020 11:22:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-15T00:05:12.511Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/594/1*B08avIuIzvCCy0WoRrd9lQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In Part 1 of “Is it getting harder to make good music?”, we restricted our discussion to primarily the aspect of composition. Here’s a link to that article in case you missed it :</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@naveenmathew0508/is-it-getting-harder-to-make-good-music-5a9e6ed5986d">Is it getting harder to make ‘good’ music?</a></p><p>Let’s abandon this thought momentarily, and try to approach the question in a more material sense.</p><p>What does someone need to make music? The obvious first thought that comes to mind is some sort of instrument. How have instruments changed over the years? What if we want to record our music to show someone else? Throw in maybe a mic into your setup as well. Is that all we really need? What really goes on behind the scenes, from start to finish, in recording and releasing a song to the public? How does the public consume the music that we make?</p><p>Let’s take a trip back in time!</p><h3>Tools for the job</h3><p>The 18th century was the advent of the classical era of western music, which really revolutionised how music was approached. By this point, there was a good amount of standardisation, with respect to how music was written and understood. Dozens of standard musical structures (e.g. symphonies, concertos) were now in the process of evolution. Educational institutions that imparted musical education were coming up, albeit in limited numbers.</p><p>Composition was fundamentally a pen — and — paper process (well, obviously), and was really dependent on the musical “<em>genius</em>” of the composer really. The only tools they had were their own instruments and references from older manuscripts (mind you which they had to possess physically).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bUQyILuKkB2joc1RINXcGg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A relatively cheerful painting of Bach :)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>An anecdote from Bach’s childhood days narrates him copying a stolen forbidden musical manuscript by moonlight over a period of six months, a really good indicator of how the process of composition was approached and it’s inherently physical nature.</blockquote><p>If the composer wanted to listen to what their music sounded like, they would likely have to make do with just trying to listen to it in their heads (unless they possibly had an orchestra in their backyards :P). The human mind was therefore the only means of “recording” a musical idea.</p><p>The first recording devices were invented around the start of the 20th century. Prior to this, all audio would have existed exclusively in live format (a really absurd idea to wrap your head around now). In fact, no modern composer/songwriter can understate the need to flesh out an idea as a demo recording, in fear of forgetting a day later. This allows you to capture additional details like dynamics or phrasing in the form of audio that your ears can perceive directly, as opposed to a bunch of musical notation that you would have hurriedly jotted down after an idea struck.<strong> </strong>The latter does have relevance to arrangement, which we’ll get into later.</p><p>Fast forward to the later half of the 20th century, and the music industry has been highly standardised in a lot of ways. The tool set available to a musician had been expanded significantly, both in terms of instrument choice and recording gear.</p><p>The access to analog mixers and tape decks allowed music to be recorded, spliced, combined, etc. and really changed how someone would look at the process of composition. You now had the capability to endlessly listen to a recording of your founding riff, to inspire further creative flow and arrangement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cPEQrGnlclO0mZvVZfh0hA.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>The Roland TR-808, one of the first analog drum machines (basically the “dwowww/bwoww” bass + kick drum sound), that became the cornerstone of hip-hop and electronic music, was released in the early 1980s, and was praised for it’s affordability and programmability.</blockquote><h3>Accessibility</h3><p>A key difference between music from the 18th century and now would be its accessibility and reach. Musicians then were required for only 2 fundamental reasons : entertainment for royalty and music for the Church. This allowed only individuals (predominantly men because of obvious societal restrictions) with a nearly virtuosic level of talent to succeed.</p><p>The only possible ways of gaining access to an instrument were if you were born into a musical household, had a role as an instrumentalist at a court or church, if you tried (and likely failed at :P) making one, or simply if you were a thief. Playing as a hobby was a concept of the privileged and the cultured. In fact Mozart himself died penniless, buried in an unmarked grave.</p><p>The industrial revolution and the subsequent 20th century drastically changed all that. The public was steadily gaining access to more music, with the advent of multiple distribution formats, be it the radio, age-old vinyls or the ubiquitous CD. People were inspired and driven by the music they heard, and this created a need in the market for music tech that anyone could afford. Instruments and recording hardware were being retailed much more, with factory processes competing against boutique instrument makers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zujbrJggCD19968EW5L2Kw.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>Kurt Cobain, a spearhead of the grunge movement, was known to often use cheapish guitars in their live acts, probably in an attempt to relate more to their audience (and well, just in case he felt like smashing stuff at the end of the show xD).</blockquote><p>For the aspiring artist still however, a lot of creative control remained with the record companies and studios.</p><p>The technology boom in the late 90s and 2000s brought a new player to the music business, aka software. Computers were slowly being integrated into the creative workflow, as applications that greatly simplified a lot of painstaking human tasks. The other great thing about software was that anyone on the internet could download and run it on their PCs, something that wasn’t imaginable a couple of centuries ago. The availability of software to record and produce your own music at home eliminated a lot of time wasted in the logistics associated with producing a record. So was going digital the right direction for music?</p><h3>Analog to Digital</h3><p>Before talking analog stuff, we have to remember that music is a very organic process at its roots. It’s the union of a gifted musician and the right instrument to produce art, however there aren’t really any rules on what constitutes a musician or an instrument either.</p><p>Once we figured out how to squeeze dozens of electrical circuits onto a tiny board, the possibilities became endless really. The piano, harpsichord and organ are now sometimes dwarfed by their common electric cousin, “<em>the keyboard/synthesizer</em>”. These circuits also made their way into guitars, allowing the natural string vibrations to be neatly amplified, to produce a whole new collection of never-before-imagined sounds and textures.</p><p>Technology that was being refined as part of World War II, made their way into studios as magnetic tapes that allowed multi-track recording. Compression, equalisation and other signal transformation techniques allowed you to clean up tracks, highlight or cut down desired frequencies and essentially end up with a pretty professional product. Huge boxes with a bunch of lights, switches, knobs and sliders who did god knows what in the eyes of an unsuspecting musician, were becoming more commonplace in the studio. We now had a hugely improved arsenal of gear to use, but there was still a certain amount of not-well-understood, complex “studio magic” involved.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VqoMFzXgaWwD46aaad7pOg.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>DJs in clubs started out with analog decks, working with just raw vinyls. Today, electronic music has migrated almost completely to the digital domain.</blockquote><p>The music industry then underwent the same change as most communication media went through, “<em>the digital revolution</em>”. Digital media offer countless advantages in terms of space, cost, re-usability and future proofness.</p><p>In fact, any studio setup nowadays involves a computer more often than not. Analog keyboards and synths are being replaced by even more capable and compact digital versions (however there is a renaissance of sorts with respect to analog instruments nowadays). Guitar amplifiers and effect pedals have inspired creation of software plugins and digital copies that compete closely with their hugely popular and worshipped physical counterparts.</p><p>You now have the option to emulate a real life instrument almost completely as software (crazy right?). You can also write out a part on a virtual instrument, add variations outside your current musical ability and draw inspiration to create more exciting music.</p><p>The arrangement process was also completely revolutionised, such that you can now arrange all your instrument parts on a computer screen with just a bunch of mouse clicks, mix and match to see how things change, experiment and receive instant playback of your new ideas. What all this means is that you could produce a release worthy song with just your laptop, software and the right knowledge on how to use both in conjunction. This also ties in with another hugely sought after role in the music world today, “the producer”.</p><h3>Production, Production, Production</h3><p>Software has always been our saviour when it comes to addressing our obsession with continuously producing more refined and marketable products. When we are involved in a process that requires a lot of experimentation, having some kind of organised workflow is the only thing keeps us from going insane. Here’s where our new all-star steps in — the producer.</p><p>When studio recording was still in its infancy, the producer (or now known as the audio engineer) was more concerned with the logistics and technical aspects of a record. Planning out the recording setup, walking through each step of the recording process (especially if it was a live “whole-band” recording) and performing final adjustments before the music was released, were their primary tasks. They weren’t expected to provide much creative input, or help artists in trying to achieve a desired aesthetic.</p><p>Hip-hop was a huge catalyst for the producer role as we know it today, distinguishing the lyrical creativity of the rapper from the beat which it was carried by. People began experimenting with beat sequencers, and tried to create beats that inspired or worked with the rapper’s intended message. Producers began carving out a niche for themselves in the underground scene, and became key players in the rap game.</p><p>Now that the producer has completely been separated from an audio engineer, we now have an additional creative voice to complement the artist. A producer might start with taking a rough idea from the artist and tinker with producing beats and samples that might work with that idea. Many even sit down with artists to bounce ideas on possible arrangements, maybe some lyrical inspiration or even wacky innovations that could make the track pop. Behind the scenes, they’re really the ones physically working on making a track, while the artist can focus on just the creative voice in their heads. In the context of a solo artist, the presence of the producer is sometimes really the difference between a bedroom demo and a billboard chart topper. This begs the question, has production overtaken raw musical genius? For lack of a better term, is there something like over — production?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*ZtWdyCCYuFo6QapuYo-Utw.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>Billie Eillish and Finneas, the Grammy-winning songwriter-producer duo, worked on most of their material at home and even recorded Billie’s debut album, “When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go?” in Finneas’ bedroom studio in California. The album featured many “everyday” samples that Finneas snuck in to make the tracks more real-sounding and homely.</blockquote><p>The name of the game is to strike a balance between a musical idea and the right level of production. If you don’t have enough production, you end up sounding amateurish. Too much production and you’ve diluted your original message or idea. It can be really tempting to add a crazy amount of effects and samples, only for all of it to sound like an unpleasant mush at the end.</p><p>Talking about samples, they’re a really neat way to add organic sounds that are contextually relevant, and offer a new creative opportunity. Nowadays, you could even sample the sound of a rock hitting the ground and turn it into an interesting snare sound if you liked. This amount of textural creativity is unprecedented, and calls for thoughtful restraint.</p><h3>Streaming platforms</h3><p>Music streaming services have been a game changer when it comes to the consumption of music. You now have access to the latest musical ventures of your favourite artists, can easily discover new artists that fit your taste and and even store music offline if required.</p><p>This is hugely powerful as an influence on your creative abilities, as you now have genre-fluid material to be inspired by. No longer do you have to physically own records, or even manually download tracks the old-fashioned way. As an artist, this gives you an endless amount of music to draw inspiration from, and that creates an interesting question. Do we have access to more music than we can chew? (Too many cooks spoil the broth maybe?)</p><p>This doesn’t concern the casual listener as much, but more so someone who’s early in their creative careers. Are they being bombarded with too much information to handle? This has a lot to do with the individual’s mental music capacity and an ability to clearly know what they want to create. Past artists had more limited access to music, and that would have highly influenced their taste (most likely restricting it to 1 or 2 genres), apart from the occasional outliers. This streamlines the creative thought process, and frees the mind of unnecessary clutter. With hundreds of genres at your fingertips now, it takes a strong will and gut to identify what works for you creatively.</p><p>The streaming biz has also worked wonders for independent artists who are trying to spread their reach. While not great in terms of monetary compensation (in fact even Spotify just pays<strong> </strong>about $0.006 to $0.0084 per stream to the holder of music rights), it gives them a chance to connect with more people and build a much wider fan base. Record companies are also notoriously known to limit how much an artist gets paid, and often demand to own rights to their material.</p><h3>Takeaways</h3><p>Tech has really changed how we look at music, from the way it’s made to how it’s consumed. The music making pipeline has definitely grown to accommodate more commercial success, but artists still have a chance to express themselves. Many have welcomed technological innovation, and some prefer to stay as organic as possible. At the end of the day, the difficulty in writing and releasing new music depends a whole lot on the individual’s environment and artistic inclinations. So to wrap up, catch you in Part 3, where we put together the final pieces of this musical puzzle!</p><p>Part 3 : The people behind the music, the storytelling aspect</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a2a33a32145a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is it getting harder to make ‘good’ music?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@naveenmathew0508/is-it-getting-harder-to-make-good-music-5a9e6ed5986d?source=rss-e957104aba4f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a9e6ed5986d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[composition]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Naveen Mathew]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Aug 2020 07:40:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-21T18:09:02.819Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My first attempt at writing something so please bear with me :) Inspired by a lot of Youtube binging and quarantine boredom :P More of a thought experiment than anything else really. Fashioned this as a 3-part series, so stay tuned for additions!</p><p>I’ve thought about this question multiple times, and more so in the recent past when (I think) I’ve matured the most as a musician. This question manifests in many different forms, in the most widely discussed fields, be it IT all the way to theoretical physics. What makes something ‘good’ in the first place? How much does our history and current environment affect our ability to produce a creative and novel product? Is there an upper bound to creativity? Will we run out of ‘good’ music to make? Let’s try and break it down to the basics!</p><h3>A melodic and harmonic analysis</h3><h4>The theory behind it</h4><p>I think for anyone who’s thought about this question before, this has to be one of the first logical ways to approach it.</p><p>Let’s consider the 12-tone/note scale, the most well known and classically accepted way of understanding and writing music. If we take for example a 10 note sequence, and apply some basic math, we end up with 12¹⁰ permutations (yes, the engineer in me had to use a quirky mathematical term). Now let’s eliminate all transposed versions, meaning we’re not counting pitch shifted duplicates of a melody. This leaves us with 12⁹ ~ 5 billion possibilities. Now we still haven’t introduced the idea of changing octaves, adding harmonies/chords or rejecting quantisation of pitch, which would just essentially give us endless freedom to compose.</p><p>For those of you who couldn’t follow the music math jargon (oh and math rock is apparently a genre now :P), what it all basically means is that theoretically there is no upper bound on the number of ways you can make a finite note sequence.</p><p>Now the catch is that just putting a bunch of notes together doesn’t make ‘music’ by itself. Most of those possibilities would just sound like nothing more than noise, which drastically reduces our options. (I’d really love to see an estimate on the number of possible ‘nice’ melodies within some realistic constraints!)</p><p>Modern music theory lays down some well established guidelines for how one can go about composing something. This is to say that music theorists (that’s a term now I guess) have documented a lot of music that is considered good, and derived patterns and collections of notes that sound ‘right’ together. This is our way of finding the reason behind why something sounds ‘good’. The most rudimentary form of this pattern extraction would be chords and scales, the foundation for all music as we know it today. The same rules apply to rhythm as well, with hundreds of well known patterns, like waltzes, shuffles or just the classic bread and butter 4/4.</p><p>The problem arises when we have this limited framework to play with. You can’t just recklessly throw around notes and call it music (well I guess you could sometimes :P). All the music we’ve loved listening to as we’ve grown up predominantly follows these same patterns, and so we’re naturally drawn to certain melodies, hooks, progressions, beats, riffs, or licks. This vast library of ‘good’ music and theory equips a composer with the tools required to write new music, but is this also their Achilles heel?</p><h4>Is our past starving our creativity?</h4><p>Whenever we hear some of the most popular tracks of our favourite artists, a question that often comes to mind is “<em>how the heck did they write that?</em>” The examples of genre-defining or iconic artists are numerous, all the way from the era of classical music, to the recent past, be it the Beatles, the Spice Girls, Led Zepp or<strong> </strong>Beyoncé.</p><p>Everyone wants to make the next one-hit-wonder that will go down as an all time classic. The question is how many such “potential” classics are left to be discovered, purely from a melodic standpoint? Is there actually an upper limit?</p><p>Another question that often plagues a composer is where to draw the line between drawing inspiration from and unknowingly plagiarising prior material. Even Chopin, a legendary Polish composer from the 1800&#39;s, was rumoured to hate one of his most celebrated works in piano today, his “Fantaisie Impromptu”, simply because he later believed it was a ripoff of the 3rd movement of Beethoven’s “Moonlight Sonata”.</p><p>This highlights the fear of being interpreted as unoriginal. Every artist gets caught up in writer’s block, when they’re unable to produce new material, whether it’s because of a lack of inspiration or general writing fatigue. Let’s say they did write something wildly new and exciting from a musical perspective. More often than not they’re put into these boxes of being the next “Daft Punk” or the all-new “Metallica”, or just a mashup of them all. For writers, I believe it’s getting increasingly hard to get recognised or make a dent in the scene, cause they’re unable to escape the shadows cast by their predecessors.</p><h4>Genre specificity</h4><p>Certain genres have some characteristics that make them highly ‘endless’ in nature. For example, jazz, a genre that thrives on soloing and playing in a nuanced setting. The solos contribute more to the ‘live’ and ‘human’ nature of the music, playing on the spot as the music guides you. They rely more on the way the music ‘feels’ rather than sticking strictly to a predetermined riff or progression. Genres like this inherently lend themselves to a more ‘live’ nature, and are extremely volatile and artist intrinsic. They also expand our options harmonically and rhythmically, when compared to other genres that are sometimes restricted. An important factor to consider when tackling the question of trying to retain novelty.</p><h4>Where’s the ceiling?</h4><p>Will we run out of music to write or genres to discover? Will there be a day when we just sit down and say “<em>yup, we’ve written all possible good music. Anything that somebody writes now is just a meaningless regurgitation of something older.</em>”? Can we just keep mixing and matching our past musical knowledge to create music endlessly? Where does it all stop making sense anymore? Relevant questions if we want to uphold the integrity of the music we make.</p><p>A related concept would be coherence of composition. To meld two genres together or possibly create a new one, a composer needs to spend a huge amount of time making sure that the ultimate product still sounds coherent while maintaining novelty. I firmly believe this is a really painstaking process now considering the endless amount of music and genres that are already out there, but there are still plenty of artists who challenge your ears every once in a while.</p><p>Who’s gonna come along and write the next “Comfortably Numb” or “Gravity”? (By no means am I trying to limit iconic songs to the genres I’ve mentioned, rather this is the limit of my musical vocabulary).</p><p>An interesting thought experiment that I find relevant would be the infinite monkey theorem. It states that a monkey hitting the keys on a typewriter at random for an infinite amount of time would surely type any given text. The analogue in music would be similar, except for how many meaningful pieces of music do we have to uncover? Could it be possible that as humans there is an upper bound to our musical creativity? Can machines forecast our future in music? (yes, we’re going sci-fi :P)</p><h4>Computers as fortune — tellers?</h4><p>The leaps in computer science and circuit technology are really showing, in a world that is becoming increasingly automated and data-driven. The amounts of compute power available at our fingertips is mind-boggling, and we can surely attempt to solve problems that we once thought were impossible.</p><p>A more recent innovation that’s been making the headlines is artificial intelligence, or known by it’s more mysterious acronym, AI. It refers to the ability of computers to be programmed to display intelligence and autonomy by learning from real world experience or data. The huge compute power that supports AI makes its learning very accurate yet sometimes highly unexplainable. It’s hard for even computer scientists to explain how AI produces the results it does, similar to a musical savant saying for example, ‘I could just hear the melody in my head’.</p><p>A relevant example would be a deep learning project I completed on Coursera, where a neural network was trained on a corpus of jazz solos, which could then be instructed to generate a new novel solo. The results were pretty primitive but still quite intriguing nonetheless. This got me thinking, let’s say we had an astonishingly powerful computer. Could we just train it on all the music known to humanity, or maybe a big enough subset, and then create a machine that continuously generates new music based on the data it was fed? Do machines have the capability to produce human-like music, and do we have the level of compute power required to achieve something like that? Can we just enlist a machine to create all the music we need for the next century, or all possible music maybe? (God forbid any crazy talented AI engineer musician from reading this blog and doing something like this xD).</p><p>I know this goes against the very ethos of making music, but it should really get us thinking about what music means to us. Is it just a bunch of numbers fashioned as sounds or is there something deeper?</p><p>An interesting asset of AI is it’s degree of arbitration or randomness, which could potentially mimic creativity in humans. Results can be varied by slightly altering the initial conditions and parameters of the machine learning process, possibly to imitate the natural variations and nuances of human-made music.</p><p>A more specialised application would be for example, train a machine on say 2 or 3 of your favourite artists, and what you end up with is essentially an AI composer, that generates music drawing inspiration from all your favourite music. Like I said before, if you look at music from a purely mathematical perspective, it’s just a collection of patterns, something computers can analyse much better and faster than humans can.</p><h4>Takeaways</h4><p>I may have been a little too bleak about our hopes for the future, but remember that this is just a discussion on compositional limitations, not music as a whole.</p><p>If you feel like the musical apocalypse is on its way (or already begun?), please let me know if you want to see Part 2, where things are looking much brighter!</p><p>Spoiler Alert : Part 2, Music Tech and Production</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a9e6ed5986d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>