<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jonathan Naymark on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jonathan Naymark on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@naymark?source=rss-3845f497f089------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:54:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@naymark/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Single Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@naymark/a-single-life-6c61140f8104?source=rss-3845f497f089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6c61140f8104</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Naymark]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Aug 2014 15:52:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-08-29T16:00:36.918Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By the time you reach your Jesus year (32) you will be able to classify your friends into 2 groups: those who like Taylor Swift and those who don’t. The in-betweens you can probably <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfWlot6h_JM">shake off</a>. Cheap jokes aside (and I’m tired yo), when you reach a certain age you will actually be able to group your friends into the <em>marrieds (</em>or those who may as well be married) and the <em>singles. </em>There are outliers (there are always fucking outliers thank you very much Malcolm Gladwell) but for the most part this bifurcated segmentation model (using business speak makes me feel better about my $100MBA) holds true for like 90% of your friends.</p><p>I was thinking about this segmentation model a couple of weeks ago as I attended Patti LuPone’s recent Broadway review with my friend and fellow <em>single</em>, JP. JP and I were seated at a four-person table with two other gay men who we quickly befriended. Why did we make friends? Because we were two gay men at a Broadway performance entitled: <a href="http://www.pattilupone.net/torch.html"><em>Lady with a Torch</em></a><em>. 54 </em>below is basically like a bathhouse for theatre geeks.</p><p>After the show, as our foursome trotted out to a nearby bar for drinks, I finally decided to ask if our new friends (Chad and Jesse) were romantic partners or not, a question that had been nagging me since Chad chastised Jesse for singing along during one of Patti’s songs. “We’re not sleeping together,” Chad told me, “We’re just gays of a certain age.”</p><p>I knew immediately what he meant; they were thirty or forty something gay men who were single, childless and whose only attachment in life was commitment a low carb diet and gym routine. At forty it was unbecoming to dance the night away at The Ritz with twenty-something twinks, but if not that, then what alternative?</p><p>Well in 2014, for the single person, there are thankfully a multitude of alternatives. The very modern single isn’t some sort of sad-suck Katherine Heigl character, spoon-feeding themselves chocolate ice cream, petting a mangy cat, in a frumpy housecoat, and waiting for James Marsden to come along and solve their 27 dresses dilemma.</p><p>There’s a resourcefulness combined with a pleasant contentedness amongst most single people I know. Perhaps this overly defensive bluster, “I don’t want to settle for just anyone” is simply code word for: “OMG I’m so fucking alone please see through my pathetic attempts at masking my feelings of loneliness and inferiority by setting me up with ANYONE.”</p><p>The truth, like the X Files, is probably somewhere in the middle; single people tend to have an accepting contentedness of their lot in life while if you caught them two margs deep after work on a Wednesday they’d probably admit they would be interested in meeting the right person, caveat, “should that person exist.” This is easier said than done.</p><p>As my new friend told me the other day at our office party, “I pay my own rent, I have a good job, I’m not just looking for someone to keep the bed warm.” And in an era where “I can’t get no satisfaction” is both a quaint relic of the 80’s and a time before dildos and on demand sex apps existed, if you’ve been single for the last four years its hard to understand why you would want to let someone tell you what type of throw pillow you could or should buy.</p><p>This is 2014 people – what happens in West Elm, stays in West Elm.</p><p>My mother often remarks, during our awkward conversations about my dating life, about how hard it is to meet people once you’re no longer in school.</p><p>“Is there anyone special in your life?” She asks with earnest.</p><p>“Nope.”</p><p>“Well… I don’t know where people meet people after college.”</p><p>My mother met my father on a beach when they were teenagers. Instead of Tinder, I suspect their romance was like an asexual (cause its my parents) version of Grease (oh wait, John Travolta is by his very nature asexual). And while my mother is empathetic in the nicest, most supportive way possible that a Jewish mother can be when discussing whether or not her son has met another boy, I tend to quibble with her thinking; it’s not hard to meet people, its hard to meet people to date.</p><p>I recently went on a couple of dates with who lives a couple of blocks away from me in Chelsea. I think I liked him because he was handsome, successful, kinda awkward and on the muscular side of the street. On our second date he admitted that his diet consisted entirely of organic food; and we’re not talking an “oh I go to Trader Joes every Sunday” type of diet. The only meal he had eaten outside of his home in the last two years was at a Four Seasons Restaurant where they served organic meat. At some point as we sat on a bench in Central Park talking about our families, I had an out of body experience and flash-forwarded to some point in our near future where I imagined a dramatic dénouement to our relationship, “SOMETIMES I JUST FUCKING WANT TO GO TO SHAKESHACK.”</p><p>I mean look… <a href="http://www.laineygossip.com/The-World-Needs-More-Gwyneth-Paltrow/26731">I love me some Gwyneth Paltrow, I’m just not sure I would want to live with and or marry some sort of Chelsea version of Goop or “Choop” if you will.</a></p><p>This is, to be totally honest, what concerns me about those of us who are late in life singles (although I do wonder if this concern is more acute in the gay male community where biological clocks are not ticking like Marisa Tomei’s in My Cousin Vinnie); as we grow older and become entrenched in our own single world do we become less open minded in our capacity to develop a meaningful relationship that exists beyond the binary of sex or friendship? Or put another way: are we too afraid or unwilling to accept our status quo (which has probably come to define us), and which we also view as a pretty decent one?</p><p>A couple of weeks ago, <a href="http://www.mycarlsbergyears.com/?p=2134">in Los Angeles for work</a>, I spent a day alone exploring the city. While I was at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA) I overheard a couple get into an epic argument over the duration of their cultural interlude. The dude was ready to cut and run (“Swirls, I get it”), while the girl had some unfinished business with Van Gogh. Me? I ducked out when I wanted to and spent the afternoon lying on the beach in Santa Monica and reading the Hunger Games.</p><p>Playing a game of would you rather… would I rather spend an afternoon, as I did last Saturday (actually to be honest it lasted 45 minutes), being interviewed by a single gay doctor about my past dating history, feelings on threesomes, open relationships and whether I was a gold star or platinum gay (this was a date, not a medical check up) or would I rather sit on my sofa (!) and finish the second half of <em>Mockingjay</em>? The answer is mockingjay and Team Gale.</p><p>Recently, after a couple of dates with a fellow whose intentions I couldn’t quite figure out, I called a friend to ask for her advice. “He’s just not that into you,” was her curt and obvious reply; but I wondered if the last 2000’s cop-out stopped being applicable to single people above 35? My gentleman caller was 39 and for all intensive purposes had been single most of his life – he may not have been into me (I am willing to admit that some people just aren’t that into all this – I mean I’ve been propositioning Aaron Schock for years and no dice) but I’m also pretty sure he may not have been that into anyone. As we discussed fall plans on our walk home from dinner I realized he was back and forth between Europe most weekends between Labor Day and Yanksgiving.</p><p>Did he like <strong>anyone </strong>enough to quell his ability and need to travel for work?</p><p>Truthfully his malaise sounded pretty common; if you’re contentedly single and you meet someone randomly off of a mobile app to date, do you really want to interrupt your entire life just so you can wind up six months later arguing about Van Gogh at LACMA, when instead you could be cruising out to Santa Monica at the speed of Singletown, population you?</p><p>I know the <em>marrieds </em>will comment about how amazing having a partner is and I don’t doubt it, but what I do know, is that for a single person who is used to be single (And ok with that) dating can feel like you’re forcing a square peg into a round hole (make an anal sex joke, I dare you).</p><p>This is not to say that single people are necessarily introverted – what I suspect that my mother has correctly identified is that as you age dating becomes an entirely different activity from making friends. Whereas I’m still making friends (I swear!) – dating how now become an active sport that requires multiple avenues, a/b testing of photos, and multiple account logins.</p><p>Friendships, no matter age, are created by natural progression built off of shared and common experiences. I have just started a relatively new job and I’ve been surprised that I’ve actually made some decent friends out of it. The reality is that no matter how old you are – at some point you will wind up drunk at an office party doing a tequila shot with your coworker and thinking to yourself, I fucking love this asshole.</p><p>Yet when it comes to actual assholes… the avenues aren’t as natural as they used to be.</p><p>At 30, or however old, the chances of you dating the person you drunkenly made out with at 80’s night at a bar is probably pretty low, instead you’re left with sitting across the table from someone you met via the internet in a forced social experience. If friendship is our natural state, dating is a social contract that says I like you enough to create shared experiences that may or may or invoke sticking my appendage into or more of your orifices. Truthfully, unless your biological is ticking, ticking, ticking, sometimes it doesn’t seem like there’s anything wrong living in a natural state of solitude…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6c61140f8104" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Money is Not the Message]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@naymark/the-money-is-not-the-message-a1f1ce69e0ef?source=rss-3845f497f089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1f1ce69e0ef</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Naymark]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Aug 2014 22:26:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-08-27T22:28:29.586Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-bU0rfSCq3f9hqdNg-5EDw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The day that Beyonce completes the Ice Bucket Challenge will be the day we have reached peak 2014 cultural zeitgeist. <a href="/service/mailto:https://www.youtube.com/watch%3Fv=gqcLcXPL3S0">Kinda like the episode of Seinfeld when Kramer finds himself a the corner of 1st and 1st</a>.</p><p>When it comes to the Ice Bucket Challenge, the viral video craze that has literally splooged all over your Facebook like a teenage boy fingering the underwear section of the Sears catalogue, the endless conversations on its merits has suddenly made every other person you know a veritable Nate Silver sprouting metrics of its overall success or failure. “Do you know ALS only impacts a small number of people” or the counter: “Over $40M has been raised,” “Do you know how much water is being wasted”. Heck even captain contrarian and Debbie downer of the Hipster Era, Vice Magazine, can’t figure out what <a href="http://www.vice.com/read/the-worst-part-of-the-ice-bucket-challenge-is-the-people-criticizing-it-822">side</a> of the Ice Bucket Challenge it should be <a href="http://www.vice.com/read/dumping-a-bucket-of-ice-on-your-head-does-not-make-you-a-philanthropist-813">on</a>.</p><p>Perhaps as Ronan Keating sang: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xrxrEEGVdM">you say it best when you say nothing at all</a>.</p><p>The debate will fade at some point, ALS will go back to being a fringe charity (and truly horrible disease) and eventually we can all stop thinking about cool new ways to make an ice bucket challenge video that will get featured on a Buzzfeed list (“Top Ten Shirtless Guys doing the Ice Bucket Challenge” or “Top 20 people who shouldn’t be doing the Ice Bucket Challenge but did it anyway”).</p><p>As with any mass cultural moment there is always some punditry associated with the rise of virality: why did we spend months watching Rebecca Black’s <em>Friday</em>? Why are we all growing moustaches in November? My take-away form the IBC, and not Irritable Bowel Condition, is the larger comment that any viral moment says about society. As philosopher of the moment Rocket Raccoon personified best in this summer’s blockbuster Guardians of the Galaxy the ice bucket challenge identifies the fact that we’re often solitary creatures.</p><p>Technology has done a weird thing to the concept of community – in many ways it has brought us closer together (we can Skype or WhatsApp friends who live millions of miles away from each other) yet in many ways it has also brought us further apart from our closest neighbors. Most simply the Internet has fragmented the experience through which we receive information and cultural touch points. The internet has created and aggrandized the singularity of the social experience creating individualized feeds and personalized self-select options. TV is the most obvious example; wherein Netflix has single handily destroyed the who shot JR water cooler moment and replaced it with binge watching or the standard, “Don’t tell me what happens in the first episode of Season 2, House of Cards – I haven’t finished Season 1.” The Internet has facilitated a choose your own adventure.</p><p>As a result of this disruption we are all, as Sarah Silverman aptly noted at the Emmy’s on Monday night (watched by too few people these days): just molecules hurtling through space.</p><p>As technology has fragmented the human experience and denuded ourselves from the concept of community the Ice Bucket Challenge is one of the tangible ways that pulls us back into a communal experience. It reminds us that we can be part of something, part of a greater collective and is in fact reinforced by its very viral nature. Not only are we waiting to be “tagged”, as if this is tacit approval and affirmation, but we can then tag others and perhaps more important show everyone that we are part of a group; on Wednesdays we wear pink and pour ice on our head.</p><p>What’s interesting is that this aggrandized need for community, tangentially a feeling of higher meaning, has manifested during times of crisis. The rise of fascist movements are perhaps the most widespread, extreme, recent and obvious example of humanities desire and need for community. I am not, for the record saying that the Ice Bucket Challenge is equivalent to fascism; however, I am arguing that in times of disruption we as humans tend to seek some sort of communal affirmation. The popularity of the Ice Bucket Challenge reminds humanity that in a world of digital anonymity we still need to feel a sense of belonging and community. The ice bucket isn’t so much a charitable endeavor as it is an expression of our need to reach out and touch someone. The irony in this particular case remains better left unsaid…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1f1ce69e0ef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The newspaper is dead, long live the news. ]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@naymark/the-newspaper-is-dead-long-live-the-news-4ef4a7568192?source=rss-3845f497f089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ef4a7568192</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Naymark]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Aug 2013 15:57:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-08-07T15:56:37.232Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/0*BhwLvtjBAryM9igh.jpeg" /></figure><p>There’s been so much bluster this past weekend over the news business that one may rightfully think that we’re back in the heady days of 2000 when the word convergence was being dropped like it was going out of style.</p><p>With the divestiture by the Washington Post Company of its namesake newspaper to<a href="http://gawker.com/uhhhhhh-jeff-bezos-is-buying-the-washington-post-1033049827"> Jeff Bezos for $250M</a> and the New York Times finally <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/04/business/media/new-york-times-company-sells-boston-globe.html?pagewanted=all">ridding </a>itself of cement shoe the Boston Globe (sold for $70M — although if you account for pension liabilities that the Times is still on the hook for, <a href="http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/08/03/pensions_included_boston_globe_sold_for_40_billion.html">the Times is actually out money on the deal</a>. This doesn’t even consider the fact the NY Times paid $1.1B for the Boston Globe’s holding company back in 1993… ) the newspaper business, an unglamorous industry at the best of times, suddenly became the talk of the financial sector. Add in the sale of Newsweek sold for an undisclosed sum to digital holding company IBT Media, and you have a trifecta of fairly significant transactions all of which continue to buttress the fact that for the news business the times they are continuing to change.</p><p>If the valuations for most of these companies seem rather paltry it’s because they are; as Justin Timberlake’s Sean Parker infamously noted: <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4e0n7vTLz1U">a million dollars isn’t cool anymore</a>. And in comparison to Facebook’s billion dollar acquisition of Instagram, the sale of the Washington (mother f’ing) Post seems rather quaint. I suspect that someone somewhere has marked the Post transaction as the nadir of our intellectual society, offended that the financial markets have valued an app that applies vintage filters to photos worth more than a 135 year-old news organization that once brought down an American President.</p><p>Can Words with Friends do that?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*Msnp1r0NVIZX8j59.jpeg" /></figure><p>But of course we’re living in a generation where print has little value when compared to clicks, uniques and likes.</p><p>If the death of print is a cliché that we have come to accept – the real carcass of the information age isn’t print – which is after all just the medium – but the message in and of itself.</p><p>I was having dinner with an intelligent, well read and very politically active friend a couple of weeks ago who embarrassingly told me that she had cancelled her Globe and Mail subscription.</p><p>“I was ashamed to tell you,” she admitted after a glass of wine. “I know you love the Newspaper.” In Canada, the Globe is the National Newspaper, our national paper of record.</p><p>My friend is right — I do love newspapers. In fact, I was the weird kid that had the Globe delivered to my residence room while completing my undergraduate degree at McGill. If you had asked me five years ago whether I would ever think about “cutting the cord” (or cancelling my physical newspaper subscription) I probably would have laughed in your face, clutched the front page of The Globe and Mail and emphatically declared: NEVER.</p><p>And yet – over the past year or so, every morning The Globe and Mail arrives at my door and sit, tied with its coloured elastic band, gathering dust. “We’ll catch up tomorrow,” I often hear myself saying as I rush out the door; this phrase, as most people know, is the famous last words of a disinterested lover.</p><p>And yet I refuse to cut the cord; it is seemingly too soon to end such a salient relationship — one that has actually informed my professional career. When I finished my MBA I started working at Torstar Digital, an operating unit of the Toronto Star – which remains Canada’s largest daily newspaper (by circulation). Torstar Digital is focused primarily on finding alternative revenue sources as traditional newspaper revenues declined. Although this is less eloquent than our corporate raison d’etre – I like to think that we exist “to save the paper”.</p><p>Which poses the seminal question: does the newspaper (either in print of digital form) need saving? Or to put it more clearly: do we really need newspapers?</p><p>My personal answer is a somewhat romantic yes.</p><p>I’ve always had a high-minded view of newspapers as an active player in fashioning a common civic identity. We jokingly call the Globe and Mail Canada’s paper of record (even if it officially bills itself as Canada’s National Newspaper), but, in Canada, a country with too few national icons, where else can we have a national dialogue about topics as varied as Justin Bieber, poutine or the privatization of health care?</p><p>While not Canada’s paper of record, my own corporate entity, The Toronto Star, has always seen itself as integral to telling Toronto’s story. To this day, the paper continues to publish according to the <a href="http://www.torstar.com/html/social-responsibility/Atkinson_Principles/index.cfm">Atkinson Principle</a>s, a set of six ideals outlined by publisher Joseph E. Atkinson, who helmed the Star from 1899 to 1953. The Atkinson Principles describe his beliefs of how a “progressive newspaper should contribute to the advancement of society through pursuit of social, economic and political reforms”.</p><p>The Atkinson ideology, while unique in their formality, are hardly unique in the defacto position that newspapers have often placed themselves in as civic flag bearers. It was Upton Sinclair’s reporting on health and poor sanitary conditions in Chicago’s meatpacking plants that would eventually lead to increased health and safety legislation in the United States (a general precursor to today’s United States Food and Drug Administration). And famously it was the Washington Post’s investigation into the Watergate affair that would lead to Nixon’s resignation.</p><p>Even Jeff Bezos, no fan of printed media, had this to say to Washington Post staff upon purchasing the paper:<a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/jeff-bezos-on-post-purchase/2013/08/05/e5b293de-fe0d-11e2-9711-3708310f6f4d_story.html"> “Journalism plays a critical role in a free society and The Washington Post—as the hometown paper of the capital city of the United States—is especially important</a>.”</p><p>While these may be high minded, there is something to be said of the fifth estate’s ability to help create and define a community’s civic identity. A strong, united and independent Canada is actually one of the aforementioned Atkinson principles. And I have always felt that passively or not, there is something somewhat unifying in a newspaper’s ability to fight for a unified vision of the geography it covers, be it progressive or conservative ethos.</p><p>And so while I would consider myself a big believer in our digital future (a futurist if you will), my one fear when I contemplate the digital disruption of “the newspaper” is what replaces old media may not have the same capacity to act as this unifying force that newspapers traditionally have been able to act as. After all – the conventional sense of “a nation” or “a community” has a totally different meaning in the digital world when compared to our analog one.</p><p>The most common fear of media disruption is that we will lose the ethical force of the fifth estate as investigative journalism gets replaced by click-bait, hurried blog posts and the like. This fear that “digital” will destroy “journalism” is misguided. If anything new media entities like Buzzfeed (yes! Buzzfeed) will start to move up the content value chain ;already Buzzfeed has started to publish “long reads” alongside its infamous Top 30 Signs You’re 30 lists. For example, a Buzzfeed reader can read an article on “<a href="http://www.buzzfeed.com/copyranter/16-homoerotic-photos-of-vladimir-putin">16 Most Homoerotic Pictures of Vladimir Putin</a>”, but it can also read a eloquent essay by Patrick Burke on the <a href="http://www.buzzfeed.com/patrickburke/dont-boycott-sochi">Sochi Olympics and anti-gay sentiment in Russia</a>. It wasn’t Sports Illustrated who broke the story of Manti Te’o fictionalized girlfriend , it was Gawker Media’s <a href="http://deadspin.com/manti-teos-dead-girlfriend-the-most-heartbreaking-an-5976517">Deadspin</a>.</p><p>Sports Illustrated may die, journalism will survive.</p><p>This fear associated with media disruption is therefore misguided even as it is not totally out of place. The new media reality recognizes that the way we receive news has fundamentally changed. The paper copy of a newspaper was forever static. 20 years ago a Canadian in Vancouver that subscribed to the Globe and Mail received 90% of the same content a sI did in Toronto. This commonality provided a unique lens through which a majority of Canadians saw their news. A1 was A1 from sea to shining sea. And while I may be waxing poetic, and will probably be accused of being a central Toronto snob, it isn’t just the Globe and Mail, as a published endeavor, which was used to tie disparate elements of our far-flung country together through its journalistic might. On a local level – the delivery of a physical newspaper to your door meant that you and neighbor received the exact same version of the Village Post. The news wasn’t divergent clicks; instead, the paper crafted a common language.</p><p>As we watch former media giants die at the knife of digital, what threatens to replace them– is the overwhelming personalization in how readers choose what news they will digest. If we have anything to be concerned about with the disruptive forces of innovation currently gnawing at the media industry — it is this personalization of media. Personalization in the digital sense is hardly new. We expect that our Facebook news feed to made up of news stories related to specific friends or identified likes, we are seemingly calmed when our Amazon home screen presents goods specific to ourpast purchases. Such personalization is almost needed from a commerce perspective – as a capitalistic society we’re all wired to walk into the same Gap across the United States but walk out having bought entirely different outfits.</p><p>But this transference of personalization to news — is a really big (and overwhelmingly disruptive) idea. Suddenly we’re not presented with one (or two or three) news lenses — instead we’re presented with infinite amounts of them.</p><p>The fear is that the high minded notion of newspapers as a stitch to our civic identity could be replaced by a pseudo tower of journalistic babel.</p><p>I had the chance once to talk privately with Conrad Black at an event a couple of weeks ago. My interest in the future of news was obviously piqued and so I asked Lord Black, a man who once personified the newspaper industry in North America, what he thought the “future of print” looked like.</p><p>His reply was that “In the future everyone would just assemble their own personal newspaper and then print it off at home.” On one hand it was cute that a former newspaper baron (and Lord) is still committed to the concept of physical newspapers, while on the other hand it was cloyingly out of touch.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VjPtM-MV2PSv8w5H.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yet Lord Black was right about one thing, every day with a hundred different clicking decisions, I am making my own digital newspaper. This newspaper will be infinitely different from yours. And as we all sit down to read our own personalized Town Crier’s and Chronicle Herald’s I do wonder if we will lose something altogether.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ef4a7568192" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Disrupt, You’re Designed To]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@naymark/disrupt-youre-designed-to-593f84bbd198?source=rss-3845f497f089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/593f84bbd198</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Naymark]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Jul 2013 00:49:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-07-03T13:27:08.028Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/0*fxNCZ3ObOxQwg5kz.png" /><figcaption>Credit: Fab.com</figcaption></figure><h4>Platform versus Product: the fundamental ecommerce business strategy</h4><p>Fab.com whose motto is: smile you’re designed to, is well on the way to becoming the most talked start-up of 2013.</p><p>No big surprise considering that Fab, which sells a curated stable of “well-designed” products, recently raised $150M at a $1 billion valuation.<a href="http://www.businessinsider.com/how-fabs-ceo-defends-its-decision-to-raise-100-200-million-more-than-any-other-e-commerce-startup-2013-6#ixzz2WgzoktVj"> If Fab raises an additional $100M, as it says it needs to, it will make it the largest funded ecommerce company, ever.</a></p><p><a href="http://pandodaily.com/2013/04/30/fabs-eyes-are-bigger-than-its-wallet-thats-nothing-100-million-cant-fix/">Not bad for a company that lost a reported $90M over the past year alone.</a></p><p>Party on Jason. Party on Brad.</p><p>While everything may not be entirely fabulous in the world of Fab, the company must be doing something right - in just over a year Fab has almost tripled its subscriber base from 5M to 14M; it now sells 1 product every 7 seconds.</p><p>But with conflicting reports of world domination vis-a-vis imminent collapse Fab is nothing if not contentious. General punditry is split: Fab is the next Groupon, the next Gilt, or as its founders Jason Goldberg and Bradford Shellhammer would like us to believe – the next Amazon – tapping into what Goldberg deems the burgeoning world of eEmotional Ecommerce?</p><p>To be totally honest - I sometimes would classify Fab as a digital regurgitation of infamous 1980’s retail dinosaur – Consumers Distributing. (For those who don’t remember, Consumers Distributing was that awful retail model that eschewed product display in favor of catalog,pencil and checkout counter).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/993/0*hF1173i_S2QHT9Pk.jpeg" /></figure><p>Conceived in 2009 as a social network for gay men, Fab quickly pivoted into a design focused ecommerce platform that deemed itself to be a “Global Leader, Synonymous with design”. In April Fab pivoted slightly, stating its very ambitious and very global goal: To become the world’s #1 design store.</p><p>Over the 24 or so months since its fundamental pivot, Fab has become as much of an industry darling, as an ecommerce industry bellwether.</p><p>The dirty little secret of ecommerce 2.0, (a noted distinction from the first round of ecommerce growth in the late nineties) is that ecommerce doesn’t really exist… at least in the way that we as pundits like to think that it does. This is not to say that I don’t believe in ecommerce or that ecommerce isn’t a big (and becoming bigger) business; rather, I would argue that ecommerce isn’t exactly what we think it is.</p><p>According to eMarketer ecommerce sales in the United States totaled $225.5B in 2012, accounting for about 6% of total retail sales. These figures exclude the largest category of online commerce - travel, which accounted for another $126B of sales.</p><p><a href="http://www.internetretailer.com/2013/05/24/big-and-getting-bigger">While ecommerce innovation gets its fair share of press, outside of Amazon.com, the top ten largest ecommerce retailers in the United States either sell computer equipment (Dell or Best Buy), are online incarnations of fairly old school American retailers (WalMart, Staples, Sears, Office Dept and Liberty Interactive [QVC]) or sell goods which are transacted almost entirely via the internet (Netflix, Apple [iTunes])</a>.</p><p>There’s a couple of key takeaways from this.</p><p>The first is that Amazon.com accounts for approximately 15% of total American ecommerce sales and together, the top ten ecommerce companies account for almost 50% of all ecommerce revenue in the United States.</p><p>Companies like etsy, Groupon, eBay and start-ups like Warby Parker and Bonobos are hailed as ecomm innovators, even if they are simply tiny specks on the ecommerce continuum. As Internet Retailer notes, two fastest growing ecommerce sites in the United States are actually those belonging to AnnInc (Ann Taylor) and Urban Outfitters.</p><p>Secondly, for all of the noise around disruptive online retail, as of yet – ecommerce is a difficult business. Beyond Amazon (and select old school retailers) the vast majority of products purchased online are digital products (books, music) or digital tickets which are then redeemed for physical goods and services.</p><p>Ecommerce is forever hampered by the fact that companies need produce and then deliver a product to the consumer; at least until 3D printing becomes readily available. As Jeff Bezos himself noted in 1999: “The physical world is the best medium ever invented and betting against it has always proved wrong, To bet that people won’t go into stores is to bet against human nature, which is always a bad bet.”</p><p>The logistical challenges of delivering a physical product to the consumer is why the only really successful ecommerce only entity (Amazon) is a platform that facilitates commerce for itself as well as for other companies.</p><p>The dirty little secret about “ecommerce ” is best articulated by Andy Dunn, who founded Bonobos in his recently published (and seminal piece) article: Ecommerce is a Bear.<a href="https://medium.com/what-i-learned-building/d233f02d52a5"> As Dunn notes: “[you’re] not building an e-commerce company, you’re building a brand that has e-commerce as its core distribution channel.”</a></p><p>This is not to say that Indochino, Frank and Oak, Everlane, Bonobos or Warby Parker won’t create significant long-term shareholder value or are bad ideas. Quite the opposite - I believe many may become top ten brands over the coming years. However, if they do so – it will be because, as Dunn notes, they are not ecommerce companies, rather they are building a physical product that happens to be distributed online. They may use digital in interesting or innovative ways, Frank and Oak’s subscription Hunt Club, Warby Parker’s disruptive pricing model, but are these the great ecommerce digital disruptive forces? Or are these innovative examples of decent customer service, disruptive pricing and innovative product offerings?</p><p>This is not to say there aren’t pureplay ecommerce companies. There are. The most successful of them are probably companies the general population hasn’t heard of. The real value creation, if I was a venture capitalist, that’s been unleashed in the e-commerce business is probably in the underlying products that are powering “e-commerce”.</p><p>You want to see some significant return on investment? Invest in Shopify. You want to make a risky bet on the future of the consumer? Invest in Birchbox.</p><p>In ecommerce is a bear Dunn argues that there are four primary strategies for ecommerce, including: Proprietary merchandise (Bonobos), prorprietary experience (ShoeDazzle), proprietary pricing (Gilt), proprietary selection (Nasty Gal).</p><p>To that I would contend that your choice as an ecommerce wannbe is actually more limited: are you selling a product? Or are you building a platform?</p><p>If you’re a business to consumer ecommerce player there are really only two strategies. You can either build an entirely new brand, as Dunn did with Bonobos, that has ecommerce as its primary distribution channel, or you can be a platform which facilitates the commercial activities of others. Data and analytics are great – but at some point, your physical product has to get to your end consumer (unless of course it can be downloaded). And unless you’re focusing on an awesome product, the consumer expects your product to be delivered tout suite. Shipping, logistics and fulfillment require massive scale and are incredibly costly to build out, which is why the platform model has created necessary scale.</p><p>Fulfillment of any sort requires a platform and in my mind there are probably 7 types of ecommerce platforms.</p><p>They are:</p><p>1) Local – website which provides a platform for local commerce; Groupon is the early adopter here, but I suspect we will see a secondary platform perhaps around loyalty.</p><p>2) Marketplace – those platforms which link buyers to sellers, i.e. Etsy, eBay, Amazon (marketplace).</p><p>3) Sampling – this is a nascent platform, however, 2012’s ecommerce trend du jour was companies which sent sample sizes of products in packaged boxes to consumers; as several ecommerce pundits have noted, including Jeff Bezos, ecommerce will always be limited by the need for consumers to buy a product and then consume it immediately. Sampling, to some degree, is a way for consumers to interact with products in a non immediate setting.</p><p>4) Discount – flash sale sites like Gilt and One Kings Lane are platforms for discount pricing models.</p><p>5) Services – with the huge amount of travel ecommerce, travel ecommerce platforms (from Expedia) to Priceline have become ecommerce leaders; however, the service based platform model is still in early days. There will presumably be a host of other service based platforms ranging from yoga to doctor appointments. As with other service based platforms logistics are nil because the service provider actually provides services on site.</p><p>6) Niche – successful examples of niche platforms that concentrate specifically on one category of goods – such as clothing, shoes, consumer packaged goods products, primarily in the apparel space such as Net a Porter; others, such as Zappos,</p><p>7) Mass – really, there is no other example here beyond Amazon, which has not only cornered the mass marketplace through its logistics capabilities and Prime account but by acquiring significant niche platform companies.</p><p>On top of these seven you also have a bevy of software platforms, which may or may not power a significant number of smaller ecommerce sites.</p><p>And while there are hypothetically a lot of room in each of these platforms to grow there are two important trends to point out:</p><p>1) Some of the most successful platforms (most of the service platforms, eBay, Etsy and even Groupon) don’t even touch the logistics side of the business. Fulfillment is not their problem. One could argue that most successful ecommerce platforms simply facilitate commerce without getting their hands dirty in the logistics of it all.</p><p>2) The entire concept of the niche platform may rapidly erode as Amazon consumes additional players, rendering any competing niche player unable to compete from a logistics standpoint.</p><p>Which is why Fab seems to have painted itself in a difficult corner. If they chose to become a platform - they’ll need to build out proper logistics capabilities (in ways that their ecommerce competitors like Groupon or Etsy don’t have to). If they build out logistics capabilities they’ll have to prove that unlike their platform counterparts they can compete even with a more expensive cost structure (shipping and logistics ) even if, at the end of the day Fab is simply reselling products designed and made by other companies. Presumably, a high cost structure and low margin business is something that Fab would want to avoid; in fact Goldberg has often lamented that Amazon’s gross margins are “in the low single digits”.</p><p>In Fab’s most recent state of the union address, Founder Jason Goldberg stated that by 2016 (the year Fab is purportedly going to become profitable) 30-40% of Fab’s sales will come from proprietary products which have significantly higher margins.</p><p>However, this makes Fab no longer a platform. It makes Fab a design focussed products company. The distinction is important. In this sense Fab is competing with Crate and Barrel and no longer competing with Amazon. It is, one would assume, a smarter, leaner and younger Ikea.</p><p>There is no problem with this vision; however, this no longer makes Fab an ecommerce platform. Presumably it is as a platform that Venture Capitalists have valued Fab as they have. <a href="http://betashop.com/post/53349076340/news-fab-closes-150m-in-initial-series-d-financing">To-date, as Goldberg has himself noted, there are only 4 ecommerce companies in the world that are valued at over $10 billion: Amazon, Alibaba, eBay, and Rakute</a>n.</p><p>All 4 are platforms.</p><p>At a $1B valuation Fab is going to have to sell a lot of its own products to see any significant ROI, which is why to all of those who have invested in Fab, I would say: Risk. You’re designed to.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=593f84bbd198" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>