<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by christopher netherland burger on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by christopher netherland burger on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nether_burg?source=rss-103a37b47bb9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 23:53:28 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nether_burg/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mining for History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nether_burg/mining-for-history-ba8afc916de1?source=rss-103a37b47bb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ba8afc916de1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[christopher netherland burger]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jan 2024 15:35:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-29T15:35:56.819Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Modern human societies have created a communication paradox. While capitalism has generated incredible communication infrastructure, it has simultaneously created monetization mechanisms for these powerful new tools that are affecting communication in an profound way.</p><p>Information must pass through a sprawling censorship apparatus created by media companies; both constricting access to raw data, as well as siphoning data into ideological frameworks. Once the information has been processed by the media, it then passes through output devices and social applications that exert yet another curatorial influence on the information.</p><p><strong><em>It has become impossible for any individual to access raw data concerning global events and confirm the authenticity of the information they receive.</em></strong></p><p>Though disinformation and misinformation are powered by a host of new technologies, largely hinging on the colossal network effects of social media platforms, the manipulation of information is hardly a new phenomenon. The bending of information to achieve social, political, and financial gain is a practice as old as human communities themselves. In fact, almost every culture on Earth has their own variation of the following African proverb.</p><p><strong><em>Tales of the hunt are told by the hunter.</em></strong></p><p>For every kingdom, there is some instance of memorialization inflating the ruler’s prowess in battle. The Poem of Pentaur, embellishing the Battle of Kadesh to depict Pharaoh Ramses II as a great warrior, is an early example of such propaganda. Various columns, arches, and sword wielding males on horseback litter city centers, conveying the ever present terms of a bargain struck between the state and its citizens; indentured labor in exchange for security.</p><p>With hundreds of libraries having been destroyed in war and conquest, the process of editing history is now as firmly rooted in human culture as history itself. Undermining every event that happens, is some other event that shakes the very historical substrate onto which each event is recorded. No manuscript without its retrieval from ashes, no land deed without its period of restitution, no map without its borders redrawn by war; all of history is subject to an unavoidable undercurrent of amendment.</p><h3>Enter Bitcoin</h3><p>Now, we have an immutable ledger of record, the security and validity of which is maintained by a community of peer users. Since 2009, the Bitcoin network has maintained a perfect record of all transactions that have taken place between its users, and no individual, corporation, kingdom, or country has been able to exert any censorship on either its operation or its ledger.</p><p>As monumental an innovation as this unbreakable record of history is, the scope of the truths it can store has been limited to simple transactions denominated in Bitcoins (“BTC”); the native currency of the blockchain. The protocol can only determine mathematically if the number of Bitcoins in pending transactions is correct relative to those stored in the wallets of its users. As the Bitcoin blockchain records all transactions and coins issued, the ledger disallows anyone from sending Bitcoins they don’t have.</p><p>Though this consensus mechanism counts digital tokens perfectly, it can do little to verify the validity of richer data; like pictures. However, in early 2023, the Ordinals protocol, a meta protocol built on Bitcoin, enabled the inclusion of media files into the Bitcoin ledger. Bitcoin was transformed from an abacus to a library.</p><p>Though the capacity to store images on Bitcoin has been achieved, their intrinsic validity, quality, integrity, or truth has fallen woefully short of the perfect record of financial transactions the ledger has heretofore harbored. Anyone can include any media file they want, with certain constraints on data type and size; as long as they have enough BTC to pay for their share of the block space required to store the file. There is nothing stopping anyone from enshrining content that is objectively false on the chain.</p><p>With this perfect freedom of speech, Bitcoin’s ledger of truth could easily be coerced to enshrine a completely fabricated rewriting of history purchased by the highest bidder. Herein lies the fundamental question.</p><p><strong><em>How can Bitcoin fulfill the promise of maintaining a ledger of objective truth, if it has no way to differentiate fact from fiction in data rich files?</em></strong></p><p>In truth, there is no way for Bitcoin, which employs a very simple scripting language that cannot even begin to execute tasks as complicated as image recognition, to accomplish this. However, Bitcoin can serve as the ledger of record for media that has been subjected to rigorous authentication, while the validation infrastructure can employ adjacent technology stacks; like Layer 2s and AI. But can these technologies be coordinated to transform Bitcoin into the first immutable canon of irrefutable human history?</p><p>In order to disintermediate data origination from media censorship and distribution, test content for authenticity, validate testing through peer-to-peer (“P2P”)consensus, and canonize authentic files, the following elements must be working in concert.</p><ol><li>Foster an open network for P2P data sharing and storage, such that the network cannot be coerced, censored, or commandeered.</li><li>Create a decentralized protocol which incentivizes the authentication of digital media.</li><li>Develop a consensus mechanism allowing P2P agreement that media files have been authenticated.</li><li>Inscribe authenticated information on an immutable and transparent public ledger.</li></ol><h3>Open Network</h3><p>There must be an open network that can create a safe and secure receivership of media files that lies beyond the orbit of human influence, coercion, and fallibility. This disqualifies centralized methods of data storage like cloud based social media platforms.</p><p>There are many options for decentralized (“deCent”) digital file storage including Filecoin, Sia, Storj, and Arweave, and it is likely that healthy competition between these and other similar protocols will help yield a more secure, cost effective, and scalable solution.</p><p>The next element in the stack is a simple file launching app that allows for media files to be freely uploaded; especially in states of emergency. Though there are plenty of encrypted messaging apps like Signal, WhatsApp, and Telegram, the capacity to receive live streaming directly into secure storage is vital. A simple app that allows for automatic upload of files or live streaming to a default destination, including any of the aforementioned deCent file storage protocols, that any user can specify ahead of time, would allow for frictionless upload and storage in times of duress.</p><h3>Authentication</h3><p>There is an entire battalion of digital tools that have emerged to protect intellectual property. In fact, the compound annual growth rate of digital authentication tools is &gt; 15%; one of the fastest growing sectors in the digital economy.</p><p>Though these authentication and forensics tools are upending traditional commerce, like artistic provenance, identity verification, biometrics, and cryptography, they have not been deployed across news media to catalyze a movement towards greater journalistic integrity; evidenced in the tsunamic proliferation of disinformation throughout the modern world.</p><p>Enter AI.</p><p>In the interest of sharing an example that, unfortunately, has become nearly globally known, imagine a person on the West Bank bears witness to some atrocity. This person has no agency to submit a digital account of the events, even with media evidence, and have any assurance that the journalistic media outlets will not subvert, Photoshop, and bend the witness’s account of the events to forward the positions of the stakeholders of the media company.</p><p>However, AI will soon (if not already) have the capability to assemble a group of pictures from disparate sources, and place them in chronological order. Shadows, reflections, sun bursts on the lens, etc. allow AI engines to discern the angle of the sun, helping to establish an objective timestamp of each media file. Background noises, especially those loud enough to be captured across multiple devices, can aid bots in time stamping files as well.</p><p>Further, humans can recognize traffic lights and bicycles in “noisy” CAPTCHA images, because we have an extensive reference library of images in our working memory that helps us make key visual differentiations. AI has been capable of facial recognition for years, and it will be simple work to train machines to recognize shared features in disparate images; including geographical features, buildings, vehicles, artillery, and uniforms, helping AI image recognition protocols authenticate both place and time.</p><p>A legion of open source AI bots can sift through catacombs of uploaded media, and undertake the work of authenticating files; queueing them for validation and inscription.</p><h3>Consensus</h3><p>A single engine, even one of incredible sophistication, can’t be trusted to undertake a task of such scale and import. Authentication can never be truly achieved without consensus from a meritocratic decentralized network. Just as the Bitcoin protocol validates each transaction before it can be included in a new block, digital media forensics must come to consensus regarding the validity of the timeline before files can be canonized.</p><p>AI engines can be deployed into the file sharing network to compete for a correct timeline of unadulterated data; effectively mining the products of human media capture to establish a historical timeline. Validation of authenticity can be incentivized with a portion of the value garnered from the consumer network; history mining.</p><p>Once a media file has been authenticated, then the validation apparatus must agree to include the file for canonization. The mechanics of this consensus could take many forms. This is very much like proposing a transaction to be included in a block on a public blockchain, so consensus must be reached between nodes that the authenticating agent is working in concert with the protocol and not defecting to include illegitimate historical media information in the canonical timeline.</p><h3>Canonization</h3><p>The Ordinals meta protocol has expanded the storage capacity of the Bitcoin ledger to include images and other media files. This expansion solves the problem that an open P2P network of disintermediated data sharing would face in securing the validated historical timeline into an immutable ledger.</p><p>Once validating nodes have reached consensus that authentication is valid, then a representation of the file can be added to the canonical timeline with a Bitcoin inscription. Large media files can be stored in their entirety in deCent storage, and an abstracted representation of the file could be stored more economically on Bitcoin.</p><p>This canonization, though incredibly important, is not without significant limitations. Since the canon and its inclusions must all be digital (with this proposed version anyway), there is no way to canonize events that occurred prior to what will be the first ledger entry at inception. This will effectively create a separate epoch of history; one analog and subjective and one digital and objective.</p><p>The digital limitation will also serve to further alienate analog societies from the global internet audience, as violence perpetrated against these peoples will lie outside of the sphere of communication and mechanics of this protocol.</p><h3>Cost</h3><p>The transfer and storage of files, authentication, consensus, and inscription will invariably come at a significant cost; especially as malicious actors flood the authentication pipeline with obfuscating information. For users to be enabled to share their content freely, as well as for the end product to be unadulterated, it is essential that these costs be underwritten by a network of consumers.</p><p>Subscriptions can fund the compensation of network participants. With the quality of global information plummeting as rapidly as the volume if information increases, billions of high earners demand source data of world events; data that has been rendered unattainable with current corporatized media infrastructure. A nominal subscription fee will fund the network and its capacity to receive and store files; at no cost to the people uploading. It’s likely that the network would run at a cash surplus sufficient to incentivize the capture and sharing of data that is burdened with higher risk.</p><p>Five billion internet users paying a modest $1/month would seem like a healthy start to any new venture.</p><p>We are living in the midst of the greatest information sharing epoch in the history of human civilization, and yet our ability to agree on the actual events that have taken place has never been more critically compromised. Can we coordinate our vast technological assets, and the inherent decentralization in media capture afforded by the ubiquity of mobile smart devices, to commandeer the authorship of our history?</p><p>The events that happen are not fungible; not subjective. And it’s time to graduate from the outmoded, self-sabotaging social consensus that loosely galvanizes history into the subject of endless argument and violence. Unlike in generations past, we now have an almost limitless battalion of digital tools. All we have to do is coordinate them correctly.</p><p>The sacred plume that pens our actions onto the ephemeral pages of history remains, as always, in the hands of the powerful, and, with a newly minted arsenal of social media platforms, society is being algorithmically fragmented into tribes programmed to fight against each other; instead of uniting against a media industrial complex that feeds us a version of history that facilitates the consolidation of power.</p><p>If our mobile devices are the new pens that write our history, then the Bitcoin ledger is the parchment on which this new history can be inscribed; extricating the human timeline from the powerful, and placing it in the hands of the human community. A history mining protocol coordinating smart phones, deCent data storage networks, AI data authentication bots, and a secure ledger of record could create an infallible and immutable consensus and inscription mechanism for events that is heretofore unprecedented.</p><p>All we have to do is build it!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ba8afc916de1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bitcoin — A New Commonwealth]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nether_burg/bitcoin-a-new-commonwealth-253b667fade6?source=rss-103a37b47bb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/253b667fade6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[neurology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin-mining]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[christopher netherland burger]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Dec 2023 13:18:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-22T13:18:16.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Bitcoin — A New Commonwealth</h3><p>In every cradle of human civilization, a process of desertification is well underway. Desertification is a type of land degradation in which biological productivity is lost and fertile areas become barren, due to the human practice of tillage and overgrazing livestock. These practices denudes the land, and the loss of plant matter causes carbon sequestered in the soil to be lost; reducing its water and nutrient holding capacity.</p><p>The reason for this lies at the very heart of mammalian neurology, behavior, and social organization. It is called the “Tragedy of the Commons.” This phenomenon describes the inherent difficulty that a group of individuals experience in sharing a common resource; where individual users, acting independently according to their own self-interest, behave contrary to the common good of all users by depleting a shared resource through their collective action.</p><p>Using a pasture as a prolific example of a shared resource, while each herdsman is motivated by their own self interest, the lasting viability of the pasture is dependent on maintaining healthy grazing practices; that is, not overgrazing the pasture. The tragedy is that, even when consensus is reached between the herdsmen regarding grazing rights, each individual herdsman must choose between upholding the agreement, that is, grazing only their own allotment, or defecting; grazing more than their share at the expense of the pasture and other grazers.</p><p>Over the course of millennia, thousands of iterations of governance and management schemes, one indisputable truth has emerged.</p><p><strong><em>Given the choice between serving the long-term sustainability of the common resource or serving their own self interests, humans will serve their own self-interests.</em></strong></p><p>Why is this the case? Why does humankind chart a course to ruin? The answer may be provided in part by the brain.</p><p>The human brain is the most complex structure in the known universe. Containing tens of billions of neurons, each neuron connects to thousands of other neurons to form a neural network of staggering complexity. This vast interconnected web of thoughts, feelings, memories, dreams, and imagination is a cradle of higher order meta cognition we call consciousness.</p><p>The mammalian brain in particular possesses a unique quality called neuroplasticity. Neuroplasticity is the ability of the brain to change and adapt in response to experience, learning, or injury. It refers to the physiological changes in the brain that occur as a result of our interactions with our environment, encompassing both the creation of new neural connections and the alteration of existing ones. This plasticity allows the brain to reorganize itself by forming new neural pathways to adapt to new situations, learn new information, and recover from brain injuries. Animals that successfully compete for resources are more likely to remember successful strategies and apply them in the future, a process effectuated by beneficial reorganization of the brain’s neural networks.</p><p>Another factor that can cause this type of neural reorganization is substance abuse. The brain is equipped with a kind of Pavolvian reward system that provides dopamine for “good” decisions; stimulating feelings of joy and happiness. This feature has adapted over the course of hundreds of millions of years, and has allowed mammals the cognitive ability to form complex social structures that have significantly aided survival; undoubtedly a factor contributing to mammals occupying the upper trophic echelon of nearly every living ecosystem on Earth.</p><p>Addiction occurs when the brain creates a positive feedback loop to a behavior that, rather than aiding in survival, does quite the opposite. The brain’s reward circuitry becomes increasingly sensitive to cues related to the addictive substance or behavior. This heightened sensitivity can trigger cravings and compulsive behavior. The Prefrontal Cortex (“PFC”), which would typically regulate and moderate responses to such cues, is less effective. As a result, the immediate desire for the addictive substance or behavior can override rational thought and consideration of long-term consequences provided by the PFC.</p><p>In short, the brain’s neural pathways are reorganized to reduce connections to the PFC, which serves to evaluate the repercussions of the choice at hand. The reason addicted people make horrible self-harming decisions is because their decision making apparatus has circumvented the part of the brain that evaluates the outcomes of their decisions.</p><p>So, what does The Tragedy of the Commons have to do with addiction?</p><p>Addiction clearly demonstrates that neural pathways in the human brain can readily be reorganized to seek pleasure at the expense of one’s own health, safety, and livelihood. From the standpoint of collective neurology, this is exactly what happens when a community is driven to ruin a shared resource in the pursuit of individual gain.</p><p>What is the analog for drugs in the pasture analogy? If certain substances and behaviors can supplant other learnings and create their own neural feedback loop, what is the crutch that allows pastures and other resources to be degraded?</p><p>A grazer’s share of pasture has nothing to do with their individual ability or ambition, rather it has only to do with the physical and biological limits of what the pasture will bear; what it will yield and how much impaction and tillage it can endure. If a grazer wants to increase their share, they will defect from the agreement with their cooperators. Though this is disastrous for the long-term yield potential of the pasture, as other members will likely do the same, it affords the defector greater income in the short-term. This encodes a new positive feedback loop into their decision making apparatus. This loop activates the and Nucleus Accumbens to create reward seeking behavior fueled by dopamine produced by the Ventral Tegmental Area of the brain; bypassing the PFC that would serve to better evaluate the long-term consequences of the decisions.</p><p>Not only does the defector’s victory over the community of cooperators feel good, but it allows them greater upward mobility to solve the problem of declining yields. With increased income, they can better afford to migrate their family and herd to fresh pastures. Herein lies the great risk of false positive feedback. It compels defectors to colonize new frontiers with a false sense of success. They have achieved greater profit than their peers, and they liken this achievement to being tantamount to success; when it is quite the opposite. (It is worth noting that the only reason someone can profit in the depletion of a resource means that the natural capital intrinsic to that resource is either discounted or not priced in at all to the net profits of the depleter.)</p><p>Until just a century ago, humans could always migrate to a less populous frontier to increase their access to needed resources. This has afforded a long lasting opportunity to ignore the problems that existing governance has created with critical resource mismanagement. One could always just move to fresh pastures.</p><p>Humanity’s lack of constraints has, up to this point, afforded us the luxury of simply abandoning areas where we have exhausted resources, and allowed us to migrate to new frontiers where fresh resource reserves have perpetually awaited us.</p><p>Unfortunately, this is no longer the case. With 8B people on Earth, resource pools depleted by mismanagement, stakeholders emboldened with a false sense of success, and no more new frontiers, the Tragedy of the Commons is now a burning existential threat to the current iteration of late global capitalist society.</p><p><strong><em>Humans are playing a non-zero sum game, on a zero-sum planet.</em></strong></p><p>So, how can we build a system in which individual participants help to uphold the sustainability and resilience of a common resource by acting in their own self-interests?</p><p><strong><em>Bitcoin is just such a system.</em></strong></p><p>The Bitcoin protocol is made up of a decentralized network of participants who contribute resources to validate transactions and maintain the security of the network. The primary mechanism that Bitcoin uses to achieve this is called “Proof of Work” (PoW). Here is how the Bitcoin protocol leverages the biological predisposition of humans to serve their own self-interest to secure the network.</p><p>Proof of Work is a consensus algorithm that requires participants, known as miners, to solve a complex mathematical puzzle, called a hash algorithm, in order to add new blocks to the blockchain. These puzzles are computationally intensive and require significant computational capability and energy to solve.</p><p>Miners compete against each other to solve the PoW puzzle. The first miner to solve the puzzle gets the right to add a new block of transactions to the blockchain. As a reward for their investment of resources, the miners are awarded the block reward, a certain amount of newly minted bitcoins, and transaction fees from the transactions included in the block.</p><p>Miners are incentivized to participate in the network because they can earn valuable rewards in the form of newly minted Bitcoins (BTC) and transaction fees. This financial incentive aligns their self-interest with the goals of the network, which include maintaining network security and transactional validity.</p><p>In addition to mining, the framers of Bitcoin foresaw the need to cap the supply of tokens; thereby eliminating inflation. They understood that constantly seeking new frontiers to fund progress was a trap that led to habitually poor resource management. They capped the supply of “money”, thus ensuring that resource considerations remained endogenic; rather than exogenic. To this day, such decisions are voted on through Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (“BIPs”).</p><p>The Bitcoin protocol makes use of humanity’s biological predilection for valuing individual self-interest over that of shared resources, specifically the potential for financial gain through mining rewards, to secure the network. This economic incentive drives participants to contribute their resources, making it extremely costly and impractical for malicious actors to attack the network. This combination of financial incentive, resource expenditure, and computational difficulty helps maintain the integrity and security of the Bitcoin blockchain.</p><p>The framers of the Bitcoin protocol understood that constantly seeking new frontiers to sustain communities was a trap that led to habitually poor resource management, therefore Bitcoin was designed to be more lucrative for individuals to use their work to preserve the shared resource, rather than to exploit it. The mining model aligns the brain’s neurological reward system with the financial reward system of the protocol, and this alignment creates a resonance between the security needs of the protocol and the financial needs of the participants.</p><p><strong><em>Bitcoin has created a novel syncopation of computational and neurological feedback systems.</em></strong></p><p>The challenge for humanity is to apply this harmonious incentivization model more universally to the panoply of shared resources on which our culture depends; resources like oceans, rain forests, ozone, rivers, wetlands, farmlands, fossil fuel reserves, etc. We can no longer employ failed governance models, and then arm centralized authorities to enforce them. It simply doesn’t work.</p><p>After thousands of years of mismanagement and an epidemic compulsion to migrate to new frontiers, human beings have entered into a perpetual cycle of formation and overconsolidation of governing bodies that invariably culminates in violent conflict.</p><p>Now, we finally have an alternative model of governance that employs the very deficiency that has plagued humanity for millennia. Bitcoin does more than transform electricity into data. Bitcoin transforms human self-interest into network security.</p><p><strong>End</strong></p><p><em>I would like to extend warmest thanks to Elinor Ostrom, author of the Tragedy of the Commons, for her magnificent work on the subject that inspired this essay. I draw from her work in this essay with deep humility and gratitude, and offer every credit to her.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=253b667fade6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Protein Problem]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nether_burg/the-protein-problem-7b1971be27c0?source=rss-103a37b47bb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b1971be27c0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[christopher netherland burger]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Mar 2023 20:16:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-26T13:04:40.951Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SL9ZdcV7mpuvvaOy52L5fw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I grew up in what used to be the rural South of the US; now the suburban South. In the Spring, I would help my mother plant tomatoes; after the danger of last frost had passed. I’d dig a hole, and she would put a small tablespoon of fertilizer in each hole. Seeing the tiny pebbles of granular fertilizer, i asked her what the stuff was, and she furnished some cryptic Southern euphemism like “TLC” or “good stuff.” She would instruct me to incorporate the fertilizer, and I would work it in by breaking apart the cool, friable soil with my fingers. We would then place a small seedling in each hole; burying the stem all the way up to the first true leaves.</p><p>One day, my mother came home and made an exciting announcement. She said, “Look, we finally have organic produce at our grocery store!” Beaming with pride, she held up a shiny, green Granny Smith apple. In response to this, I did what everybody does the first time they hear about organic food. I said, “So what? It doesn’t look any different than the apples you usually buy. What makes it organic?</p><p>Her response was horrifying. “Well, organic means that the food was grown without being treated with herbicides, pesticides, fungicides, antibiotics, hormones, and inorganic fertilizers.” To which I replied, “So that’s what you’ve been feeding us?!”</p><p>I promptly developed a fascination with agriculture, and all the different methodologies and cultivation practices related to the panoply of crops that make up the human diet. The next Spring, I asked my mother if the fertilizer we used in the garden was organic. To my dismay, she said that it wasn’t. I asked if we could fertilize the garden organically, and she capitulated; albeit, somewhat begrudgingly. I would soon understand the reason for her hesitation.</p><p>So, we set about soliciting a nearby cattle farmer for a bit of rotted manure. My mother instructed me to load the back of our pickup with shovel-full after shover-full of the black crumbly material, and when we returned home to apply it to the garden, I was shocked at just how much manure each plant required as an equivalent measure of fertility; compared with the granular synthetic fertilizer we had used before. I kept asking “Is this enough?” and with each shovel-full my mother would respond, “Keep going…”</p><p>The monumental conversion factor of organic manure to inorganic fertilizer was unsettling to me. It didn’t compute. Why should the nutrients in one form of fertilizer be locked in a package with orders of magnitude less mass than another? It felt like choosing between two multi-vitamins, where one was the size of a normal pill, and the other was the size of cinder block. It didn’t make sense, so I set out to figure out why.</p><p>In order to understand the vast disparity of nitrogen concentrations between the two fertilizers, I began researching the various ways organic matter is synthesized. The vast majority of trees, grasses, even seaweed are simply recipes of carbon that have been synthesized into organic forms of structural living tissues through the process of photosynthesis. Most are polysaccharides like the cellulose in wood and grass, however a relatively minuscule amount of living tissues are proteins; a type of organic molecule containing nitrogen that mammals need to ingest frequently in order to survive. These tend to be more concentrated in the seeds of plants, especially legumes (beans), as well as animal tissues.</p><p>The granular fertilizer my mother used was accordingly branded “Miracle-Gro” (see label below). A cursory investigation of the label revealed nitrogen as the most abundant ingredient, and I read on to see what the source of it was. It turns out that the material supplying the element nitrogen to the concoction is a chemical called Urea.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*osch472jHe5jMowvKBWhDg.png" /></figure><h3>The Haber-Bosch Process</h3><p>Urea is produced on an industrial scale from ammonium through the Haber-Bosch Process. Natural gas, a fossil fuel, is the principal source of energy that powers the process.</p><p>The process directly synthesizes ammonia (NH₃) from nitrogen (N₂) and hydrogen (H₂) gases. Natural gas is primarily used as a source of hydrogen and as a fuel for the process. Urea is then synthesized in a separate process from ammonia and carbon dioxide (CO₂). Ammonia produced in the Haber-Bosch process is the precursor for the near totality of inorganic fertilizers used in conventional agriculture, and the vast majority of croplands are cultivated conventionally using these inputs.</p><p>The miraculous feature of this process is that it enables nitrogen to be packaged without the bulky carbonaceous components associated with the heavy fiber load of plant tissues; abundantly present in organic sources of carbon like cover crops and herbivorous manures. This is why a few spoon-fulls of Mother’s granular fertilizer was so much less cumbersome than the comparatively monumental equivalent of rotted manure. Nitrogen that is organically bonded with carbon is loaded down with a lot of extra mass; compared to the nitrogen being delivered through urea.</p><h3>The Protein Element</h3><p>What is so special about nitrogen? It turns out a lot. Every single amino acid contains nitrogen, and amino acids are the building blocks of proteins. Put another way, every living tissue and metabolic pathway in your body is made of and dependent on proteins.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S0kuNXcJS538esz4gkD_UA.png" /></figure><p>How essential are proteins? Because living cells require nitrogen to synthesize proteins, and nearly all biological function requires proteins, nitrogen is absolutely vital. How vital? Humans can live for approximately 70 days without consuming proteins. You can be vegan, vegetarian, Paleo, Whole 30, anything you want; as long as you have protein, or you die. It’s that simple.</p><p>So, humans need protein to survive. Humanity is getting sufficient protein from agriculture, but farms are obtaining nitrogen for protein production from super highly concentrated inorganic fertilizer derived from mining via the Haber-Bosch process.</p><p>This begs an obvious question. What happens when it runs out?</p><p>Before we tackle that problem, let’s look at how we got here.</p><h3>Third Agricultural Revolution</h3><p>Our civilization is currently in the Third Agricultural Revolution. The first was the Neolithic Revolution over 10k years ago, in which wild plants were domesticated and permanent agrarian settlements were built.</p><p>The second was the British Agricultural Revolution, which began in the 17th century, and it was marked by the employment of crop rotations, exclusive land ownership rights, and heightened labor coordination.</p><p>The current epoch has been dubbed The Green Revolution, which began a century ago, and is principally characterized by the global scale distribution of fertilizers derived from geologic rather than organic means; that is, the use of inorganic fertilizers.</p><p>So, what’s the difference between organic and inorganic fertilizers? This is where Mother’s Miracle-Gro comes back into the picture.</p><p>For millennia, farmers have relied on legumes to deposit atmospheric nitrogen in the soil, and this has been accomplished by planting one cover crop for each cash crop harvested; replacing the nutrients from the harvest of a cash crop by committing a cover crop full of nutrients to the soil; feeding the soil dwelling microorganisms and loading the soil strata with surplus nutrients. Nodules on the roots of legumes fix atmospheric nitrogen in the soil; making it available to plants. However, legumes require an entire growing season to fix enough nitrogen in the soil to grow a cash crop with adequate fertility the following growing season.</p><p>In stark contrast to the relatively slow way that legumes fertilize soil, the abundance of nutrients supplied by inorganic fertilizers in which the cumbersome carbon has been removed, has allowed modern agriculture to produce crops every season. Conventional 3-crop rotations, including maize, wheat, and soybeans, are now accomplished in 2 years, whereas it takes organic production 5 years to produce the same yield; one growing season for each cash crop, and one for each cover crop to replace the nutrients that were harvested for consumption (plus winter dormancy).</p><p>As the Haber-Bosch process has made nitrogen readily available without the temporal limitations required for legumes and animals to organically restore nutrients over the course of a growing season, the Green Revolution increased yields in the developed world by 900%<strong> </strong>in less than a century<strong> </strong>(see chart below).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hDHUwDF3mwlS8UQ8XzU_RA.png" /></figure><p>The catch is that, because of the tremendous increase in crop yields that inorganic fertilizers have enabled, the scale of industrial agriculture has not increased proportionally with population growth (see chart below). In half a century, the number of acres in cultivation per capita has been reduced by &gt;50%.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*EujbYcHeQluuSZV_xcqDTA.png" /></figure><p>Therefore, if average crop yields remained at pre-industrial levels, the crop harvested in the year 2000 would have required nearly four times more land than is currently in cultivation; an area encompassing nearly half of all ice-free continents. This is compared to &lt;15% of the total land area being cultivated at present.</p><h3>Malthusian Trap</h3><p>Thomas Robert Malthus described in his 1798 book, <em>An Essay on the Principle of Population</em>, that population growth is exponential, whereas increases in food supplies are linear. A culture’s ability to invest in new agricultural resources and cultivate more land cannot mathematically keep up with increases in population.</p><p>So, populations ebb and flow. The Lotka-Volterra equations demonstrate that predator and prey populations are beholden to each other. The more the prey population is consumed by the predator population, the less available that food supply will be to the predators; thus, in turn, decreasing the predator population. This is also true for humans and the resources we need to survive, like proteins.</p><p>So, how has humanity maintained sufficient caloric supplies during the greatest population increase in the history of civilization? Simple: we broke the speed limit; or the nitrogen limit more precisely.</p><p>Rather than scaling organic agricultural assets with population growth, we have transitioned to an inorganic means of fertility to make up for the incredible increase in caloric demand.</p><p>The problem is that inorganic fertilizers bypass the natural limitations of nutrient transfer that are intrinsic to healthy ecosystems. The ecosystem doesn’t have to “make” the fertilizer through the breakdown of organic matter. It just, quite literally, falls from the sky. Our technological capacity to bypass this biological limitation has allowed us to increase yield without scaling cropland area. However, with over 5 billion people dependent on inorganic fertilizers produced using fossil fuels, we no longer have the capacity to transition from inorganic back to organic cultivation. The enormous loss of yield would create a famine of global proportion.</p><h3>The Future</h3><p>The human population of Earth has increased by nearly 500% in a century (see chart below), and this historically unprecedented increase coincides precisely with the widespread application of inorganic fertilizers; consistent with the Third Agricultural Revolution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Kf66L0rZjXnysNRCDLYkWA.png" /></figure><p>Humanity has nourished a civilization of 8 billion people with a food supply that is fatally dependent on non-renewable resources. It took the Earth 300 million years to fossilize the remnants of living tissues into the fuels that are burned to organize atmospheric nitrogen into the soluble fertilizers that power our food supply, and humanity has consumed an enormous portion of this supply in the span of a single century.</p><p>The entire food system is beholden to humanity’s collective ability to cooperate rationally to uphold a finite fossil fuel supply chain that has been strained for decades by global conflict.</p><p>Green ammonia, which is synthesized through the process of electrolysis rather than through the burning of natural gas, presents an approach requiring little to no fossil fuels. Though the prospect of creating green ammonia using nuclear power contemplates a near limitless supply of urea, it does not take into account the vast increases in arable cropland needed to deploy this fertilizer to maintain sufficient yield to sustain a growing population. We simply don’t have the area to meaningfully increase crop production.</p><p>More importantly, the second order effects of scaling up agriculture are vastly more challenging. We don’t know what happens when the spectrum of species is narrowed through the conversion of healthy biodiverse ecosystems to cash crop monocultures. The Industrial Revolution has already heralded the greatest loss of biodiversity since the extinction of the dinosaurs, and further disruption of ecosystems through conventional agriculture would exacerbate the current mass extinction.</p><p>If human beings intend to be viable tenants of Earth in a post-inorganic world, we are going to have to wean our culture off of inorganic fertilizers and transition to serving biologically functional roles in diverse, healthy ecosystems. A simple step in the right direction is to introduce yourself to a local cattle farmer, and see if they need rid of some rotted manure this season.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b1971be27c0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The ₿irth of Community Commerce]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nether_burg/the-irth-of-community-commerce-132f8f861f3c?source=rss-103a37b47bb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/132f8f861f3c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ecommerce]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[christopher netherland burger]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Aug 2022 18:40:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-23T18:40:25.797Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/1*mHQwqRvAhf3D_uCAqy9Isg.jpeg" /><figcaption>“United we stand, divided we fall” by Jerry Okolo</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Data unions disrupt the corporate intermediation of web2 commerce.</strong></p><p>Distributed computing networks, supported by growing numbers of community supporters, have established a resilient shared ledger system on which money, payments, ownership, as well as social and political layers can be built. However, due to factors such as technical understanding, computer literacy, financial risk, lack of regulation, evolving consensus architecture, and murky mining incentives, the latency of cultural and financial adoption of blockchain technology is proving significant.</p><p>Even so, crypto users are ready to deploy digital assets across the wider breadth of their personal and financial lives; expenses like rent and utilities, food, entertainment, as well as agreements like deeds, contracts, and licenses. Where are the solutions? How is web3 going to deliver on the promises of establishing a user-owned internet, if the only thing you can buy with digital tokens is…more tokens?</p><p>Though the solutions will come gradually through a new wave of community-focused web3 companies building their data systems on blockchains, the IRL goods and services you receive in this new commercial paradigm will be ordered, fulfilled, financed, and paid for through the coordination of decentralized organizations called <strong>data unions</strong>.</p><p>Through community consensus and validation, blockchain has enabled a great migration of data from centralized to decentralized data custodianship. Now that data is being liberated from corporate ownership, new layers are being constructed that allow the collective aggregation and monetization of this data to be possible. However, rather than this data processing being executed by a third party, like a corporation or government, a data union allows sovereign ownership, custody, deployment, and monetization of personal data.</p><p>This communal data aggregation is the next valent level of collective bargaining, and it will herald a unionization of consumers and workers that will streamline supply chains and fundamentally change the architecture of global commerce.</p><p><strong>What is a data union?</strong></p><p>A data union is a decentralized group of users that are aligned along a commonality of data that is anchored in a blockchain. The union provides its users an access mechanism, a digital token that allows them to both opt into the digital organization, as well as for their data to be indexed and searched; so that its value can be fully realized by its owners/creators. Data unions are essentially a group of digital wallets working together to aggregate demand for goods and services; precisely as third party wholesalers and mega-retailers do today.</p><p>With the technological innovation of the digital wallet, users are now able to share their data on a peer-to-peer basis; rather than through a centralized intermediary. Data unions are simply the digital platform that allows individual users to aggregate their data into a collective, so that it can be effectively monetized.</p><p><strong>Big Data</strong></p><p>To understand how a data union works, we need to first understand the current data system.</p><p>The near entirety of the data storage and analytics market is owned by 5 companies: Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple, and Facebook (“Meta”); collectively the “Big 5”. They achieved incredible market dominance by scaling to meet the unprecedented demands created by the mass internet adoption of the dot-com bubble. However, the process that web2 companies must engage in to collect, process, and monetize data is not simple or cheap.</p><p>The data must first be collected. This involves compelling users to agree to the terms and conditions of a user agreement. You know the one. It’s the lengthy legal contract we sign to buy a new phone or create an account on Gmail. We need the device and the service to compete and belong, so we all opt in.</p><p>The user data is then processed. This next series of steps is a bit more challenging for the data companies. Raw data is not salable. It must be scrubbed and structured to create a monetizable product. It must be de-identified, transformed, aggregated, and normalized. This is a resource intensive exercise that consumes 2% of all global energy production.</p><p>Once all these processing steps have been executed, then data can be mined to create a monetizable product. This involves more computational processing including association, classification, clustering, and a host of algorithmic, AI, and predictive analytical processes. It’s an enormously complex industry that supports hundreds of billions of dollars of commerce.</p><p>Data is organized into patterns that can inform retailers and manufacturers about consumer demand. It is this process that allows for those uncanny ads that pop up on your web browser that know exactly what you want.</p><p>The most important aspect of the data industry is user volume; network effect. You must have enough network effect to compel users to give their data away; just to access the benefits of the community. Facebook’s social graph and Google’s search engine are powerful tools that create user popularity that is absolutely essential to convincing users to give away their data.</p><p>Web2 works great. Google finds everything, Meta connects everybody, Apple and Microsoft provide the hardware and apps, we share content on Insta and Youtube, and Amazon gets us the stuff we need. So, what’s the problem?</p><p><strong>The Problem</strong></p><p>The problem is that over-consolidation of big data has led to a total corporate ownership of the internet. The specific problems are described below.</p><p><strong>Data Breaches</strong> Last year, data breaches cost the global economy &gt;$1.5 T. See chart below. It doesn’t matter how thick the vault is, because thieves with the correct tooling will continue to penetrate it. This is proven. Centralized data is inherently insecure, and the costs incurred by the consumers and businesses that use cloud storage will continue to pay dearly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wTadxA9bkEejk6TAsLqG5w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Cost of Cybercrime, Accenture Research (2019)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Revenue Distribution </strong>Big Data does not share ad revenues with content creators in a fair and equitable manner. The revenue obtained from the sale of our data last year was $215B, and 97.5% of content creators on YouTube don’t make enough from their split of ad revenue to reach the poverty line. See chart below. Since these web2 mega-platforms are the only mediums through which creators can currently engage with their fans, the owners of the platforms have no incentive to share revenues. They know that the creators cannot rebuild the network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QB4_bhQI6Q9tFPqzCUlKRw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Creator Earnings: Benchmark Report, Influencer Marketing Hub (2022)</figcaption></figure><p>As blockchain enables self custody of user data, and data unions empower collective data aggregation and deployment, these revenues will shift to the users and creators that generate the content, platform network traffic, product demand, and ad revenue.</p><p><strong>Data Inaccuracy</strong> Poor data is a tremendous issue facing businesses along the downstream data supply chain. Bad information, duplicate data, underreporting, and over-reporting all plague data mining. With global digital ad spend ballooning to &gt;$500B last year, coupled with a conversion rate of 3.3%, this inaccuracy comes at a high cost to both businesses and consumers. See chart below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JeW8Zi1iX9W3Wg3HBfus1g.jpeg" /><figcaption>E-commerce conversion rates benchmarks, Smart Insights (2022)</figcaption></figure><p>Data unions will allow the internet to transcend the Spam Era. With cryptographic tokens and digital wallets enabling disintermediated peer-to-peer data sharing, the era of junk mail, spam calls, and unsolicited offerings can finally be swept into the dustbin of commercial history. Data unions will enable consumers and brands to engage directly; eliminating costly speculation and inventory hangup from supply chains.</p><p><strong>Energy</strong> Digital ad spending is projected to grow at a CAGR of ~19% in the next 8 years. See chart below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h4v2LKmKk9DrEvj6vKoGYQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Market Analysis Report, Grand View Research (2022)</figcaption></figure><p>However, energy consumption of data centers is projected to increase 15x in the next 7 years at a CAGR of &gt;27%; eclipsing the growth rate of digital ad revenues. See chart below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jgrz0kWDPLPqhjdmG4DtCA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Andrae, A. &amp; Edler, T. <em>Challenges</em> (2015)</figcaption></figure><p>Why the deviation in growth? Why would the growth of revenues not track with that of the variable unit costs associated with producing the revenue? Why are the returns diminishing?</p><p>The answer is that human civilization is producing data at a rate far greater than it can be processed into marketable trends and patterns. Because the rate of data generation is growing faster than the computing resources needed to process the data, there is more processing power, thus electricity, needed to transform the data into intelligible data sets that render it into a salable good.</p><p>As watches, cars, television, phones, homes, and so many other things in our lives produces signals that end up being stored in data centers, the data analytics work and power needed to divine patterns from this increasing amount of digital noise is on a steep incline.</p><p><strong>Cambridge Analytica </strong>Perhaps the greatest weakness of centralized data is its corruptibility. Though the caustic bile spewed by the far right has been metastasizing for some time, it was formally shepherded into the digital age by the Facebook–Cambridge Analytica data scandal of the previous decade.</p><p>Because the data was not in the custody of its creators, it was able to be harvested without consent, and used in a divisive global misinformation campaign that has now engulfed the entirety of the developed world in extremist vitriol.</p><p><strong>A Great Transition</strong></p><p>Though web traffic on Big Data platforms has never been greater, data mining is becoming more and more difficult. More computing, more energy, greater inaccuracy, and greater corruptibility are plaguing commerce on the largest web2 platforms; all with a growing obligation to share a greater portion of revenues with content creators as well as provide better data security for users.</p><p>Data unions fix both problems by allowing end users to aggregate demand information themselves. Simply by opting-in, users can passively share their data; populating the data necessary for the manufacturers to grant the same volume discounts extended to any other bulk buyer.</p><p>With blockchain, your private key renders your data completely sovereign, that is, you are not beholden to any third party or corporation to access your information. By working together, users can now aggregate their data into accurate and immutable collective bargaining networks that couple directly with manufacturers and service providers.</p><p>As millions of people in the developed world are advocating for governments, the ultimate centralized third party intermediary, to both demonopolize big data as well as redistribute profits from the behemoth corporations, community supported blockchains are organically effectuating both outcomes.</p><p>Data is a multi-trillion dollar business. In the span of a few decades, information has become the foundational layer for the near totality of human commerce. Though we are all contributing to it, this information layer remains in the federated control of a few.</p><p>The access to audience that these leviathanic platforms promise has been leveraged for complete ownership and control of everyone’s data. With the help of the collective bargaining power enabled by data unions, users now have an actionable acquisition strategy for the trillions of dollars of commerce they direct through the internet.</p><p>Big Data has been leasing the global data asset class free of charge for decades. Blockchain anchored data unions are the technology needed for internet users to claim sovereign ownership of their data and realize its full revenue generating potential. All you have to do is download a wallet.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=132f8f861f3c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>