<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Nicholas Watts on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Nicholas Watts on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nicholaswatts?source=rss-d2b79728b8c9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 17:13:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nicholaswatts/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The rule of law in Egypt]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/the-rule-of-law-in-egypt-967722c2575c?source=rss-d2b79728b8c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/967722c2575c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[egypt]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicholas Watts]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Dec 2016 09:42:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-02T20:51:11.187Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>Australian journalist Peter Greste was imprisoned in Egypt for supporting a terrorist organisation and producing “fake news”. His trial would have made Kafka blush.</em></h4><p>In 2012, the Egyptian people ousted their longtime ruler Hosni Mubarak, the most visibly successful moment of the Arab Spring movements that had spread across North Africa and the Middle East. A new leader was democratically elected, the head of the Freedom and Justice Party, Mohamed Morsi. His party was the political wing of the Muslim Brotherhood, an Islamist group with its ties all over the region.</p><p>Once elected, Morsi gave himself remarkable executive powers, claiming that without them, the new democratic government would be undone by treacherous judges who were still aligned with the deposed ruler Mubarak. Morsi proposed a new constitution, which would cement his broad powers, that he put to a referendum. The referendum passed with a voter turnout of around 35%, amid very loud claims of fraud from international observers. Huge protests against Morsi’s increasingly dictatorial leadership regressed into violence between pro– and anti–Morsi factions, providing a screen for a rogue group led by the chief of the army, General Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, to remove Morsi from power and suspend the constitution on July 3, 2013. They declared the Chief Justice of the Supreme Constitutional Court of Egypt, Adly Mansour, interim president, arrested Morsi and shut down four TV stations said to be supporting Morsi during the protests.</p><p>Morsi’s supporters and the Muslim Brotherhood continued their protests throughout June and July, demanding the leaders of the coup return power to the democratically elected leader. On August 14, the Egyptian government coordinated a raid with its security forces, targeting two sites in Cairo that were bases of the Muslim Brotherhood: a city square and a mosque. Ostensibly, they were dispersing protesters. This dispersal left almost 600 of them dead. The crackdown on Morsi’s affiliated Muslim Brotherhood had escalated. It was designated a terrorist group. By 2014, it’s reported that more than 16,000 of its members are imprisoned in Egypt.</p><p>One nation in the region broke away from its neighbours, most of whom had reacted positively to news of Morsi’s demise, in denouncing the coup: Qatar. It had fostered good relations with the Muslim Brotherhood and provided some of its leaders with protection after they were removed from power. The global news organisation Al Jazeera, based in Doha and funded by the Qatari state, became a new target for Egypt’s broad suppression of dissent.</p><p>Peter Greste, a journalist for Al Jazeera English, was sent from his base in Nairobi to Cairo to report on the situation in December, 2013. Three weeks in, he was arrested, together with an Egyptian-Canadian colleague Mohamed Fahmy and Egyptian Baher Mohamed, for reporting “false news” out of their hotel room. After a month in solitary connement, they were charged with: being members of a terrorist organisation, the Muslim Brotherhood; funding the Muslim Brotherhood; broadcasting false news; and not having the proper broadcast licences. Fahmy was accused of being the ringleader of a terrorist cell, bent on taking down the Egyptian government.</p><p>Born in Sydney, Greste has worked around the globe for BBC, Reuters and the CNN, before joining Al Jazeera n Africa in 2004. His life as a foreign correspondent is the stuff of Ben Affleck movies. He delivered satellite broadcasting gear from Uzbekistan to Kabul across rugged, snow-covered mountains on donkeys. Just before the election that would end apartheid in South Africa, Greste interviewed the isolated Zulu leader Mangosuthu Buthelezi, whose supporters had only days before strung up the dead bodies of election officials on the city’s lamp poles. His colleagues describe him as a man of great integrity, a true humanitarian whose exceptional work elevated the voices of war-torn and poverty-stricken communities around the world. His father Juris, a Latvian who migrated to Sydney and now lives in Queensland, wonders whether Peter’s will to become a premier foreign correspondent is in his blood:</p><blockquote>Latvians have been the driftwood of global political storms. My own ancestors in almost every generation have suffered. In my own time, World War II brought us here. Latvians, culturally, have always had to keep their antennae out beyond their borders.</blockquote><p>The allegations against Greste and his colleagues were bizarre. The three journalists each held commanding reputations of integrity and independence. They were said to be running a “media centre” in their hotel room, where they were producing fabricated news videos in cahoots with Muslim Brotherhood leaders. The Egyptian government made a statement, confirming the arrests of the three for committing acts “damaging to national security”. As Greste explained in letters to his family, the three did speak with members of the Muslim Brotherhood, an organisation he described as “the single largest and best organized social and political force in Egypt”. As a journalist, he asked, “how do you accurately and fairly report on Egypt’s ongoing political struggle without talking to everyone involved?”</p><p>It quickly emerged that Greste, Fahmy and Mohammed were the subjects of a proxy war between their Qatari news organisation Al Jazeera and the Egyptian government. When the Muslim Brotherhood was deposed by a military coup, many of its prominent members fled to Qatar. The Al Jazeera network’s coverage of the coup and its purges was predictably harsh and damning. The Egyptian government was quick to lump the two together in a transnational conspiracy bent on destabilising the new government. The three journalists in a Cairo hotel room presented an easy method to punish Al Jazeera, and by extension, the small but prosperous emirate of Qatar.</p><p>The three spent months languishing in a tiny jail cell together. In the lead up to their trial, their faces were all over Egyptian TV: their arrest had been videotaped and cut with the shadowy and sinister soundtrack to <em>Thor: The Dark World</em>, in a TV spot that took heavy cues from <em>America’s Worst Serial Killers</em>.</p><p>In Australia, there was a quiet optimism that the court would see the allegations as unfounded and set the three free. Hope was quickly dashed by the chief judge, who wore black sunnies throughout the entire indoor trial. The lead prosecutor, specially selected by the government, presented evidence to the court linking the Al Jazeera trio to 16 agents of the Muslim Brotherhood. This included hundreds of pages of secret lists of seized equipment said to be integral to their role as terrorists. This equipment designated as only fit for terrorist purposes featured a Mac and a number of USB thumb drives.</p><p>The prosecutor went on to show the court many hours of terrorist video footage seized by Egyptian police, framed as fabricated news stories the three had made to undermine the government. Much of the footage predated the trio’s time in Cairo. It had not even been produced by <em>Al Jazeera</em> but had come from the BBC, YouTube, CNN, and what could have been Shutterstock. Highlights from these hours of video included moving footage of horses galloping and the music video to Goyte’s 2012 hit song ‘Somebody That I Used to Know’. Before the trial had begun, the chief judge had demanded Greste pay $170,000 to view this same video footage to be presented in evidence.</p><p>The verdict was handed down. The court was unequivocal: these three had perverted journalism itself in a tryst with, you guessed it, “the devil”. They falsely depicted Egypt in a state of civil war. They colluded with the Muslim Brotherhood every step of the way. Greste and Fahmy were given a sentence of seven years each, Mohamed was given 10 years. Fahmy’s legal counsel, international human rights lawyer Amal Clooney, described the whole ordeal as a “show trial”:</p><blockquote>Not a single digital or hard copy piece of evidence showed the journalists were in any way linked to the Brotherhood. Not a shred of evidence showed that any of the journalists gave the Brotherhood money or other material support. There was not even an allegation by the prosecution that any particular video played by Al Jazeera had been doctored, let alone proof that it was so.</blockquote><p>There was no case to be made at all. Another of the prosecutors nonchalantly admitted as much during a break in questioning, telling Fahmy: “It’s just bad timing, this is all about Qatar and Al Jazeera, nothing to do with you.”</p><p>The presence of a courtroom and a judge had given the preposterous charade a passing legitimacy. We’re not a totalitarian regime, it said to the world, we have an independent judiciary and everything. Egypt’s ambassador to Australia, Hassan El-Laithy, empathised with Greste’s family but insisted that “this is the rule of law”. The rule of law in Egypt is hard to pin down: a trial in March, 2014 handed 528 supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood the death penalty in under 100 minutes. The same judge overturned 492 of the 528 death sentences a few days lat- er. When news broke that Greste, Fahmy and Mohamed were granted a retrial in early 2015, the reception in Australia was predictably muted and grave. A retrial could help get them out — or help them get killed.</p><p>Throughout the 400-odd days Greste spent in an Egyptian prison, his parents, Lois and Juris, together with his brothers Andrew and Michael, were his public face. Their graceful and articulate manner, on display through countless press conferences and interviews with journalists, lent the whole effort to retrieve Greste a firm and dutiful air. The situation was dire. He could have easily spent years in jail. Their composition contributed to a longstanding, deep concern for Greste and his colleagues’ welfare and future, and fostered true empathy for their family’s unique trauma.</p><p>“Without making any kind of deep confession, I lament the loss of my life,” Juris said to <em>The Australian</em>. “We’ve lost a year and so have the boys,” continued Lois. “So have their families. It’s not just Peter. It’s his brothers, Andrew and Mike, and their wives and their children. There’s a cloud over our head 100% of the time. And you can’t walk away from the cloud.”</p><p>Letters Greste sent his family while in jail were published in <em>The Guardian </em>and provide a chilling window into his mind. His attachment to the few books and pen and paper he has becomes profound: “I want to protect them almost as much as I want my freedom back.”</p><p>His growing cynicism is difficult to read. He describes his initial attempt to convince the government that he is being caught in a political dispute that has nothing to do with him personally, that this is all truly a mistake:</p><blockquote>I have sought, until now, to fight my imprisonment quietly from within, to make the authorities understand that this is all a terrible mistake, that I’ve been caught in the middle of a political struggle that is not my own… It is now clear that this is a dangerous decision. It validates an attack not just on me and my two colleagues but on freedom of speech across Egypt.</blockquote><p>A retrial for Greste, Fahmy and Mohamed was announced on January 1. One month later, news broke that Greste was being deported to Cyprus, where he would meet his brother and the two would return to Australia.</p><blockquote>“I can’t tell you how ecstatic I am to be here,” he said to a relieved and emotional family and press corps in Brisbane. “But of course this is all tempered… by a real worry for my colleagues Mohamed Fahmy and Baher Mohamed.”</blockquote><p>There was no immediate reason given as to why Greste was released. Egyptian law says that deported foreigners are to be imprisoned or retried in their home countries, but at no point did Australia commit to imprison Greste. A hint can be found in the thawing relations between Qatar and Egypt. Qatar recently expelled a number of the Muslim Brotherhood’s leaders. It also conceded and shut down a pro-Muslim Brotherhood affiliate TV channel of Al Jazeera’s, Egypt Direct, after it was banned by the Egyptian government a year ago. Changes in regional geopolitics, which factor in responses to the rise of isis and the touchy bastards running Iran, are also cited as a key shift in how Qatar is seen by its Gulf neighbours, helping both dampen and redirect previous acrimony.</p><p>Greste’s release also improved the international reputation of Egypt’s President Abdel Fatah al-Sisi, someone who coordinated a coup and followed it with waves of brutal political repression.</p><p>In one of his letters, Greste says, “journalists are never supposed to become the story… We are supposed to re- main in the background as witnesses to or agents for the news; never as its subject.” Against his will, his capture, his cruel treatment in prison, his farcical trial and inexplicable release have all become a commanding story. He is a special kind of foreign correspondent: one who is both the artefact and the storyteller, a remarkable event for us, but one that came at a great cost to him and his family.</p><p>From <em>Future Perfect</em> Issue 3.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=967722c2575c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/the-rule-of-law-in-egypt-967722c2575c">The rule of law in Egypt</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine">Future Perfect Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Seventy years after Auschwitz]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/seventy-years-after-auschwitz-7fd5fcc38e6d?source=rss-d2b79728b8c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7fd5fcc38e6d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicholas Watts]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Dec 2016 09:39:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-02T20:52:38.750Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oa7j_e6LK6tHlgFjsqbxWQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>When the great Jewish-Italian chemist and writer who survived Auschwitz, Primo Levi, wrote in his memoir <em>If This is a Man </em>that Germans “love order, systems, bureaucracy; even more, although rough and irascible blockheads, they cherish an infantile delight in glittering, many-coloured objects”, he wasn’t simply roasting his captors. Order, systems, bureaucracy, and many-coloured objects are foundational elements of modern civilisation. Without them we wouldn’t have the technology that has shrunk the world, neither would we have our cherished political and philosophical systems that underpin how we live and what it means to live. Throughout his time in Auschwitz, Levi lived to an absurd, hysterical degree of enforced order. He was one of very few who did not die by the same order.</p><p>We returned our gaze to Auschwitz in January of this year to mark 70 years since its liberation by Soviet troops in the dying days of World War II.</p><p>In 1945, many of the camps had been demolished or abandoned, the remaining prisoners were killed and buried in mass graves, or marched until they died. Levi was strangely lucky. He had fallen sick with scarlet fever and was placed in the infirmary, the Ka-Be, for 40 days of isolation. The guards had fled, his best friend Alberto had bid him farewell and joined the exodus. Without the hierarchy and order of the guards, their meticulous systems of labour and extermination, the camp became a hostile wasteland. Levi’s earlier remark, “Today, in our times, hell must be like this”, felt ill-fitting — this was a hell from which the devil himself had flown, leaving behind a handful of broken, diseased survivors.</p><p>The regulations under which Levi was once kept were themselves an object of play to the guards and wardens — the violence inflicted upon a prisoner who should accidentally leave his hat on when entering his sleeping hut was as brutal as it was assured. The point was not that hats were forbidden to be worn inside the sleeping huts (why on earth would hats be forbidden in the sleeping huts?), the point was the expression of power; a rigorously applied system of order and discipline institutes itself, and must be repeated.</p><p>The intricate set of rules and codes that Levi learns as a worker of Auschwitz give the camp its own language, provide a key to the order. It is in this small rebellion that Levi’s memoir comes alive: the series of different names that deviate from the official camp names for huts and divisions, the coded marketplace that launders stolen goods, the reconfiguration of ordinary day-to-day objects into sacred, life-giving vessels (a spoon in Auschwitz is infinitely precious).</p><p>When this same order, together with the furious bureaucracy and array of sophisticated systems, both real and discursive, turns away from the keeping of the workers and to the extermination of the rest, a great chasm emerges. No one returns from the dead. No one who went into the gas chambers can come out and reveal to us its language, the truth of its horror, the way its system was internalised and understood, because the system leaves no survivors. Death brings us to an experience that cannot be communicated, an experience that cannot even be experienced. An orderly death, the industrialised murder of the extermination camps, is both trauma and impasse.</p><p>The experience of Auschwitz was not traumatic in the same way we express, even fetishise, modern trauma. It wasn’t a violent incident which comes to dominate our consciousness in waves of anxiety, it was the vision of an extinction event. “One learns quickly enough,” Levi writes, “to wipe out the past and future when one is forced to.” For prisoners of the camps, like Levi, a self-inflicted erasure was a way of surviving. For those who went into the gas chambers, the erasure was more literal. For entire families, for whole geographical regions of Jews who were wiped out, this wasn’t the end of a culture, it was the effacement of culture, it was the unfathomable ambition to return Europe to a time before the Jews existed. On such a scale, the Holocaust is apocalyptic. To one man, confined to his hut, with his broken shoes and his tenacious will to just survive, it was inexpressible: “Our language lacks words to express this offence, the demolition of a man.”</p><p>The limit of expression, the silencing effect of trauma, is the defining characteristic of Holocaust literature.</p><p>In remembering the Holocaust, it is vital to be confronted with these limits. It is easy to ritualise the commemoration of this great tragedy along familiar lines, to either isolate it from history as a single event, a product of the world’s great dictator, or to consign it to history as an especially bad instance of the infinitely recurring event of genocide. These two films, the epic <em>Shoah</em>, and the irreverent <em>Night and Fog</em>, can disrupt these familiar categorisations and challenge us to consider what extremes order, systems, and bureaucracy are capable of.</p><h4>Night and Fog</h4><p>Alain Resnais, 1955</p><p>Alain Resnais, a true master of cinema who is often grouped with the French New Wave, is best known for his two black and white meditations on romance and memory: <em>Hiroshima mon amour </em>(1959), a romance set in post-war Japan, and <em>Last Year at Marienbad </em>(1961), a surreal, layered cycle of love and possibility. Before these two features, though, he made his debut with a short documentary about the Holocaust: <em>Night and Fog</em>.</p><p>In 1955, Resnais and his crew went into the Polish countryside and filmed scenes of the overgrown barbed wire and sleeping quarters of decaying concentration camps. This itself is a strange image: places like Auschwitz are either seen in archive footage as the site of ultimate horror, or in contemporary images as grey, sombre tourist attractions, rarely in this forgotten, half-buried state in muted shades of green, metres away from modern life. “Even a road where cars and peasants and couples pass,” <em>Night and Fog</em>’s narration opens, “even a resort village with a steeple and country fair can lead to a concentration camp.” He cut this picturesque footage together with archival material, some of it truly gruesome, into a very strange 32-minute documentary.</p><p>Where <em>Schindler’s List </em>is a vehicle for nine hours of sobbing and misery, <em>Night and Fog </em>is a sharp and brutal numbing. Its narration, written by Jean Cayrol, survivor of the Mauthausen-Gusen concentration camp, is classically French — impressionistic, deeply characterised, irreverent — and almost resembles a monologue. It is a film that, against what would be considered good taste, expresses the profound and suffocating gravity of life in the concentration camps through moments of levity — there are jokes about crappy Nazi architecture, and in listing the camps’ terrible facilities, it contrasts the long, putrid toilet blocks with an enormous stuffed bear belonging to the SS, which it dubs, “a zoo”. The film has a jaunty, brooding Alfred Hitchcock–style soundtrack.</p><p>François Truffaut considered N<em>ight and Fog t</em>he greatest film ever made. Before its release, key members of its crew were confident it was too graphic, still too politically raw for the French to see, and that it would never be allowed to be shown. Over time it became a landmark of both cinema and French culture.</p><p>In 1990, one of France’s oldest Jewish cemeteries was desecrated in Carpentras, a small Provençal town. Over 30 tombstones were smashed. The body of an elderly man, Felix Germon, was exhumed, having only been buried two weeks beforehand. Germon’s body was impaled on an umbrella and a Star of David was carved into his stomach. Three days later, the French public, disgusted by the attacks, marched in Paris in support of France’s Jews, the largest street demonstration since Paris’s student protests of 1968. N<em>ight and Fog w</em>as chosen to be shown on all three national TV stations simultaneously in response to the attack.</p><h4>Shoah</h4><p>Claude Lanzmann, 1985</p><p>To make a lm that not only tells the story of the Holocaust but embodies its great trauma is an impossible task. This reckoning with the impossible became the life’s work of Claude Lanzmann, a documentarian and French Jew, who interviewed survivors of the concentration camps, eyewitnesses and Nazi officers over the course of 10 years, to produce the nine-hour long <em>Shoah</em>. Lanzmann’s immense project is made to bear witness to the catastrophe — to be an archive of memories, a severe and tortured monument to humanity. It features no archival footage. We are guided around the ruins of concentration camps by returning survivors, visit Polish villages to interrogate those old enough to remember the trains full of starving Jews that rolled past their farms and houses. We visit the Jewish diaspora all over the globe, hearing their stories, slowly generating a comprehensive account of the Holocaust.</p><p>As a viewer it is a tremendously intimidating undertaking — some would say masochistic. A day of Holocaust stories is not everyone’s idea of good Sunday viewing. It’s not entertainment, it’s a challenge. As <em>Shoah </em>slowly unfolds, the question of responsibility creeps open, until by the end of its exhaustive, draining nine hours it is as though we have all become responsible. If not for the extermination itself, but the effective ways we have diminished its significance. It is a bulwark against erasure.</p><p><em>Shoah </em>rewires how you see forests. One survivor is brought back to the site of the concentration camp from which he escaped as a young boy. As the orders were given to kill everyone in the camp, he was shot together with his family, but the bullet missed the vital parts of his brain. He awoke under a pile of corpses and loose dirt, and dug himself out before crawling through the mud to a nearby house. He revisits the mass grave years later, travelling by boat along the tranquil creek, retelling the story of his survival. The guards would treat him well, take him on boat rides because he would sing for them. Lanzmann asks him to sing some of the songs he once sang for the guards. Against the soft lapping of the water, the twittering of the birds, the broad innocence of nature, his deep song conveys an inexplicable tragedy. A little later, this time along an overgrown road, two survivors of a different concentration camp stand amid a beautiful, vivid green forest of very tall trees. These trees, they point out, were planted by the Germans to cover the graves they had just filled with bodies. Even after hours of recollections of great trauma from different survivors, this concealment, this rape of nature, feels like the height of transgression. This wonderfully alive forest is a cemetery, these trees are unwitting tombstones.</p><p>There are many more tragic stories like this. Lanzmann’s impossible project wields extraordinary power. You will start <em>Shoah </em>confused at what you’ve signed yourself up for. And after it finishes it will never leave you.</p><p>From <em>Future Perfect</em> Issue 3.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7fd5fcc38e6d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/seventy-years-after-auschwitz-7fd5fcc38e6d">Seventy years after Auschwitz</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine">Future Perfect Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Murder in the skies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/murder-in-the-skies-4c25de71c5bc?source=rss-d2b79728b8c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c25de71c5bc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aviation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicholas Watts]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 May 2016 05:51:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-02T20:58:06.570Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>A deeply troubled German pilot intentionally downed his plane into the French Alps.</em></h4><p>Breaking news of a missing plane elicits a deplorable level of excitement in me. The circumstances around every crash are always slightly different, the pace at which details on the incident are released is fast enough to maintain a constant state of alarm, but slow enough to sustain weeks and months of coverage. The spectre of the terrorists is everywhere, even if they rarely show their faces.</p><p>On March 24, a 9am Germanwings (the low cost offshoot of German flag carrier Lufthansa) flight from Barcelona to Düsseldorf was reported missing over the French Alps. Real-time flight monitoring websites showed that Flight 9525 had descended in altitude rapidly, from 12 kilometres to 1,882 metres in ten minutes, after which radar contact was lost. This information was enough to know it had crashed. The region of the Alps it descended into, Prads-Haute-Bléone, rises to 2,961 metres. At 11am, French Prime Minister Manuel Valls confirmed the crash. By 4pm, photographs of wreckage strewn throughout a mountain ravine appeared online. Two days later, at a press conference in Marseilles, information from the flight’s black boxes was revealed.</p><p>Thirty minutes into the flight, once the plane reaches its peak cruising altitude, the pilot in command, Captain Patrick Sondenheimer, leaves the cockpit, (it is presumed to use the toilet) saying to his co-pilot Andreas Lubitz, “You have control”. Once the captain has left, Lubitz switches the emergency cockpit access system to locked. This system is operated with a keypad, and is set to lock the door on a fixed timer of between five and 20 minutes. Lubitz hits a button that configures the autopilot to adjust its cruising altitude from 12 kilometres to 30 metres — the lowest possible setting. Sondenheimer knocks on the cockpit door to no answer. He enters an emergency access code, but the emergency access system has been disabled. The captain can be heard loudly banging on the door, demanding via the plane’s intercom to be let into the cockpit. Lubitz remains silent. The captain takes to the door with an axe. Throughout this period, air traffic controllers in Marseille have tried to contact the plane 11 times. Proximity alarms begin ringing, drawing the attention of the plane’s passengers; they begin screaming. The plane hits the side of the mountain at just under 700 kilometres per hour, bounces once and disintegrates into a ravine, killing all 150 passengers and crew.</p><p>Who is this Andreas Lubitz?</p><p>Lubitz had grown up dreaming to be a pilot, not far from the city of Koblenz in western Germany. He first flew a light aircraft at 14 with his local aviation club. His former acquaintances and friends consistently described him as polite, “if reserved”. Before being accepted into training he worked for a year as a flight attendant. Once admitted, Lufthansa had twice refused to renew the medical certificate authorising him to fly while he was being treated for depression, during which he paused his training, citing his mental illness, which he did not hide from his friends. At the time of the crash, he was an ordinary 27-year-old pilot, who had passed all his physical and psychological checks, with 630 hours of flight time logged.</p><p>After the crash, investigators found crumpled notes from Lubitz’s doctor in his bin, all indicating he was unfit for work. German airlines have no authority to access medical records, and German sick notes do not provide any explanation for why they are given. Even before evidence became available that they were issued by mental health professionals, the key narrative of the crash became Lubitz’s history with depression.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*KuTRgSn97Sv2Wl_emSaGHQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The front pages of Britian’s tabloids from March 27 were widely denounced for stigmatising mental illness.</figcaption></figure><p>A large segment of the media, as well as mental health professionals themselves, condemned newspaper coverage that linked Lubitz’s depression with his criminal act — such sensational reporting only increases the stigmatism of those living with mental illness. The idea that those with depressive disorders be banned from piloting commercial planes was vociferously denounced. Why not ban males from flying, some said. They are statistically more likely to kill themselves than women. This concern for the marginalised voices of the mental ill is to be commended. It is also blind to the practices of airlines themselves, which will prevent a mentally ill pilot from flying. Lubitz himself had been refused a pilot’s licence in the US for this exact reason. Is this an objective or structural form of discrimination against those with mental illnesses? Or is it an effective form of risk minimisation?</p><p>Lubitz had the most powerful disincentive to report any of his mental health conditions: doing so would cost him his vocation. Shortly before his final flight, he had seen multiple doctors concerning an apparent loss in vision, which Lubitz thought would leave him completely blind. He would face a routine health check with the German aviation authority Luftfahrtbundesamt in June; fearing that his failing eyesight and depressive episodes may soon be revealed to his employer could have contributed to his decision to down the plane, according to German police. Investigators later reported that none of these doctors found any material damage to evidence a loss in eyesight. Some had referred Lubitz to psychiatrists.</p><p>Is there an implicit demand upon pilots that they be more surveilled, more scrutinised because they have the capacity to inflict catastrophic damage on large groups of people? If failing eyesight, a physical disability, disqualifies a pilot from flying, should a depressive episode do the same? Many airlines and aviation regulators think so.</p><p>Apportioning blame at the low cost airline market quickly succeeded talk of depressed pilots in the cockpit. The “budget” in a budget airline doesn’t stop with its refusal to offer free wine or access to Skynet. You’re also being flown by a budget pilot, who has received budget training.</p><p>The low number of flight training hours mandated by European airlines is concerning. According to pilot and writer Adam Shaw, the 1500 training hours demanded of US pilots in training are spent doing small jobs like crop dusting and writing engagement notices in the sky, often in “gritty, shitty, and temperamental” aeroplanes. Unless something goes very wrong, contemporary passenger planes are very easy to fly. Of equal importance, these 1500 hours also “expose [new pilots] to their peers, to repeated medical examinations”. In his characteristic wit, Shaw lambasts Europe’s lax aviation standards, a concession to budget airlines that put new pilots in commercial flights far too early:</p><p><em>These days, the 250-hour button-twiddling geeks can go from pounding the sidewalk to the right seat of a passenger jet in less than two years. That’s two medicals, and practically no peer review, no time for quirks, or worse, to become apparent.</em></p><p>In order for the Germanwings incident to be publicly digestible, there needs to be someone, or something, to blame. Shaw’s answer is simple: cast stones at “Joe-six-pack who wanted a $99 flight from New York to L.A, or Pierre Baguette who wanted a 65E Paris–Casablanca … and the cynical bean counters who make this possible.”</p><p>It seemed at first to be an exceptional incident: not the fault of any technology or policy, but of an inexplicable individual who consciously flew a plane into the side of a mountain. But this has happened before. In 1999, a regular EgyptAir flight from New York to Cairo crashed 100 kilometres off the coast of Massachusetts into the Atlantic Ocean. It came down in international waters, and according to civil aviation law, the investigation became the responsibility of the airline’s host nation. At the request of the Egyptian government, whose own aviation regulator was underfunded and inexperienced, the US’s highly regarded and autonomous National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) was tasked with investigating the incident. After recovering flight recording instruments from the ocean floor, a terrifying story emerged.</p><p>Shortly after takeoff, the flight’s co-pilot Gameel Al-Batouti had entered the cockpit to relieve the special takeoff co-pilot far sooner than is customary. He waited until the captain had left the cockpit to use the bathroom and then turned the autopilot systems off, took the controls himself and sent the plane into a sharp dive, dropping 4500 metres in just over 30 seconds. The captain raced back to the cockpit, screaming at his co-pilot, “what is happening?” while attempting to right the plane with his own set of controls. The co-pilot never responded to any of his captain’s questions or commands. Onboard voice recorders caught Al-Batouti quietly uttering the phrase “tawkalt ala Allah” 11 times as he dove into the sea. It can be translated into English as “I rely on God” or “I entrust myself unto God”, leading the NTSB to believe he knew his death was imminent. The last sounds of the recording came from the captain, who repeatedly implored Al-Batouti: “pull with me.”</p><p>The Egyptian government rejected the NTSB’s suggestion that the crash was the result of a “murder-suicide”. It decided to task its aviation regulator to perform its own investigation anyway, and ultimately concluded that a unique and unprecedented mechanical fault with the 767 was to blame. The Egyptian government and press could not even entertain the idea that Al-Batouti downed the plane himself. Some accused the US of shooting down the flight and of a vast conspiracy to cover it all up. Most took a suspiciously uniform line, that it couldn’t have been Al-Batouti’s fault, that it could be the fault of anything else but the co-pilot himself.</p><p>If the NTSB’s investigation reflects the truth — which it does — why would Al-Batouti fly a 767 filled with 217 passengers and crew into the Atlantic Ocean? An Egyptian whistleblower later told the NTSB that Al-Batouti had been demoted only hours before takeoff by an EgyptAir official who would later board the same flight. A series of sexual harassment allegations at a New York hotel often used by flight crew had come to light, and in response Al-Batouti had been told that this flight would be his last.</p><p>If taken together as deliberate acts, no one policy or regulation could have prevented both EgyptAir Flight 990 and Germanwings Flight 9525. Al-Batouti was not, as many pilots and commentators suggest of Lubitz, an inexperienced victim of budget airline cost-cutting. He had not locked his captain out of the cockpit like Lubitz had done. Al-Batouti did not have a reported history of mental illness. Both had been given bad, career-ending news in the days before their flights: Al-Batouti that he would be disciplined and no longer permitted to fly to America, Lubitz that his eyesight may have deteriorated.</p><p>The fevered demand that “something be done” in the wake of the Germanwings incident, for the ostensible purpose of preventing another tragedy just like it, is an understandable reflexive action for flyers around the globe. What this would actually be is not so clear. A new rule that says pilots must self-report imminent desires of murder-suicide? A sneakier way to test pilots for mental illnesses or depressive episodes without them realising they’re being tested? Since March this year, many airlines, including those based in Australia, have stated that two personnel will be present in the cockpit at all times from now on, a flight attendant must sit in if a pilot is to leave — something which may have prevented Lubitz from crashing into the French Alps, perhaps he could have been overpowered and forcibly removed from the cockpit. Al-Batouti wasn’t alone in the cockpit; in a panicked attempt to save the plane, his captain had no opportunity to wrest his controls away from him.</p><p>As German police investigated Lubitz — his girlfriend, his computer, his flight history — they found evidence that he had practiced switching the autopilot to descend to 30 metres on a previous Barcelona–Düsseldorf flight. Ominous, if at the time simply audacious, comments made to his girlfriend emerged: “One day I will do something that will change the whole system, and then all will know my name and remember it.” Troubled teens who go on to commit school massacres say stuff like this, but so does Elon Musk. His internet browser search history was littered with queries on suicide and the mechanics of cockpit doors. Upon release of the formal investigation into the crash of Germanwings Flight 9525 by France’s aviation regulator, its director said, “I can’t speculate on what was happening inside [Lubitz’s] head, all I can say is that he changed this button to the minimum setting of 100 feet [30 metres] and he did it several times”.</p><p>In retrospect, his will was clear. An impossible amount of surveillance would have been necessary to take all these disquieting indicators and arrange them into a plot to crash a plane.</p><p>When we talk about pilots as instrumental components of a plane, who undergo safety checks for their fitness and health, processes of licensing and certification that qualify them for different kinds of flying, it obfuscates the fact that they are still human beings, who are deeply inexplicable, erratic creatures. This is not to say standards should be ignored, that preventing plane crashes is a sorry date with the too-hard basket. It means understanding that no new safety measure, or even suite of measures, can ever completely account for human will. As long as we have humans flying planes, they will crash in confounding, tragic circumstances.</p><p>From <em>Future Perfect</em> Issue 3.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c25de71c5bc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/murder-in-the-skies-4c25de71c5bc">Murder in the skies</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine">Future Perfect Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the demand to be thankful]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicholaswatts/on-the-demand-to-be-thankful-31e351c3fbd6?source=rss-d2b79728b8c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31e351c3fbd6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eulogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thankfulness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicholas Watts]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Apr 2016 10:59:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-17T06:24:27.139Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6B3_vL3l8XEYoFt2AQ4FRQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>The speech I made to 350 people at my mum’s funeral on April 9, 2016</em></p><p>I want to thank everyone for being here at this thanksgiving service. I don’t really feel very thankful. I mean, I should. I had a wonderful mother. Twenty eight years with one as great as mum is something for which I should be very thankful. But still this feels wrong. Somehow unjust. I can think of so many people who I’d rather be dead, if we were playing a zero sum game and someone had to die. I’d pick myself before I’d pick my mother. I feel like mum has missed out on some of the canon of life. I just made that up. I guess it means some of the fundamental milestones that our culture celebrates. Some of which mum did get to experience. She just had her 30th wedding anniversary with dad. She got to see all of her children finish school. Actually with Allira she got to see one of her children put some effort in and finish school with distinction. But she didn’t get to have grandchildren. She didn’t get to retire and continue travelling the world. She didn’t get to grow old with dad. Two people who love one another growing old together. That is the stuff of Pixar movies. So I’m not thankful, I’m kind of angry. I feel like something grave has happened here. I’ve got up in front of the crowd at two other funerals, two of my grandparents, and even though our Opa Douwe, mum’s father, wasn’t especially old, he was still 20 years older than mum, and a celebration felt fitting. I don’t want to celebrate now, I want to cook up an alternate reality where this isn’t happening and retreat there for at least a week and a half. People say to me, Nick, death is natural. As if that is supposed to make this feel somehow less horrific. I have found myself crying a lot. I’m not used to crying. I’m someone who is, with great affection I hope, described as being dead on the inside. But I’ve been upended, my black heart has started beating again, and I’m not really happy about it. Even though I’m back to feeling regular human emotions, I don’t feel like a regular person. A few of us over the past few days have been struck when we look at the rest of society functioning as normal, as if no catastrophic event has just happened. We blow through each day as little balls of stress and bizarre numbness. It’s like there’s been a terrorist attack, but only we know about it. If mum were here listening to me describe her dying as a mini 9/11 I hope she would be pleased to know that the awfulness of losing her has not blunted my sense of humour.</p><p>So I’m talking about being thankful. Or rather being angry instead of being thankful. I don’t want to be here celebrating a life, I’d prefer to be at home with mum and dad and everyone else sitting around and doing nothing.</p><p>In order for me to be thankful I need to focus on the story of mum dying. She died with majesty. There are few people in real life or in books that died with such grace.</p><p>About three years ago mum and dad came up to Sydney for dinner. In retrospect it was a bit strange for them to come up at only a few hours notice, and we had dinner somewhere and then went to Cow and Moon gelato in enmore. This was before they won world’s best gelato and there weren’t crowds every night. Mum said at one point something like, hey there’s something I need to tell everyone (Jono and Dan weren’t here, it was just me, Lauren and Allira), I’ve got bowel cancer. There was a bit of silence, I was genuinely waiting for someone to laugh. We can have pretty sick senses of humour. Perhaps mum was indulging me with some of my own hideously offensive comedy. But it was real, she had bowel cancer and we had about a week of unknowing, where we didn’t know if it had spread anywhere or not. It could have been one small tumour that could be chopped out. It could have spread all over the place and mum had only six weeks to live. So mum’s cancer began in a state of great uncertainty. A happy future for our family was arrested. It was in this week that I had a strange realisation that almost all conversation is predicated on the future. In this moment of where we are unsure if mum had a future at all I found it tremendously difficult to talk to anyone about anything. Not because I was crippled by sadness but because conversations rely on future events, on future conversations, on a foundation that the present moment will keep going and not stop.</p><p>Anyway, her cancer at the time hadn’t spread much. She had an operation to remove it and temporarily help the body bypass the area of the tumour to let it heal. She had another operation about eight months later to reverse the bypass surgery. And we thought, and hoped, that that was it. We’d all been shocked into very regularly doing things together as a family.</p><p>But it came back. Without us knowing it spread to her liver and abdomen, there were spots on her lungs and her back. She started doing chemotherapy, but announced from the start that the aim of the chemotherapy was palliative and not curative, that it would relieve symptoms and give her more time but wouldn’t cure her. Hearing mum say the word palliative while standing in the kitchen stung. It was the very first time that I had to confront mum’s death, it was the beginning of my grieving, it had narrowed and fixed mum’s future. I became terribly afraid that mum would go mad. Some people are afraid of spiders, or the dark, others are afraid robbers will jump off the train and sneak into our house, Allira. I am afraid of madness. I knew mum, I knew she was a measured, reasonable and cool headed person, and I think that worsened my fear. If someone like mum breaks down in the face of death, surely I would too. But she didn’t. Even in her last week, she was anxious, she was scared, but she wasn’t crazy. She managed to come up with a way to look at dying that had a real effect on people. She said to us a few times that everyone will die, that death is natural, whether I die now or in 30 years doesn’t matter, I’m happy with my life. I think she didn’t quite realise that to us it matters very much whether she dies now or in 30 years, but to her, either one is still dying, no amount of extra years is going to help get around it. It’s going to happen to everyone. And this made sense when coming from Suzanne Watts. She’s someone who loved reading obituaries. The first TV show we watched together when I was a teenager was Six Feet Under. She was someone undeterred by death. Someone I suspect would groan a bit at our elaborate euphemisms that we deploy to try and soften speech about death. I haven’t passed away, I’m not lost, I can imagine her saying if she were here. I am dead.</p><p>If I stand here and continue to say that I am angry rather than being thankful, I can’t imagine mum would tell me off. But she’d quietly remind me, as she did many times, that she is thankful, that she felt she lived a good life. That, strangely enough, she loved her children and was proud of us. That, even if there were a handful of things about dad that drove her crazy, she was thankful for a husband that loved her so infinitely. She said about a week before she died, lying on her bed in a pretty bad state, her liver was failing and it made her extremely fatigued and very confused, to me while dad was nearby sorting through her medicine box, that I knew the facts. I love you and you love me, she said. She said that she’s ok to die, even if she’s a bit anxious about what it’ll exactly be like on the other side. She trusted God would take care of her. Steve mentioned to us earlier today that Jesus told his mates, “My father’s house has many rooms,” and mum had no doubt she had a reservation in one of these rooms. But what these rooms are, what new plane of existence she’s in now, and what this unknown place is like, is something that had her a bit nervous. When in hospital I caught her saying to one of her visitors, who was distraught and in tears, I heard her say to this person, in comfort and love, “I’ll be fine”. She said then and again in hospital and a few times in between, something I’ve rearranged to be her last words. “There are things I still want to say,” mum would say, “but I can’t put the words together.” Her mind was being poisoned by toxic chemicals that the liver ordinarily processes and removes, and she couldn’t think straight or have long conversations. “There are things I still want to say, but I can’t put the words together.” Her last words held in them all the possibility of her great life. What it was that she wanted to say will be in my imagination forever. But it would have been thankful. It would have been tender but not saccharine, brief and poignant, not the hyperbolic hysteria that seems to follow our conversations about her and death. Mum was a measured and intelligent person who knew how to express herself. Even in a weakened state she managed to open doors with only 15 words.</p><p>I have made these bookmarks. Please take one home. Mum loved to read books. She would read just about any book. I gave her one of my recent favourites, the first in a long series of autobiographical novels from the Norwegian writer Karl Ove Knausgaard, which she told me was probably the most boring book she’d ever read. In it Karl Ove deals with the death of his own father, who was quite abusive, and a hoarder. I think there are a good 40 pages where Karl Ove cleans his dad’s filthy house. It’s tremendous you should all read it. I am very lucky to have both a mother and a father that loved one another and loved their children. If I were to spend 40 pages telling the story of what happened after my mother died it would be a despondent road from rage to thankfulness. A story about a mother who became my friend, and about a son who tries really hard to make her happy. Some talk about the demand to make their parents happy as a great and unwelcome burden. But for me, at least for a number of years now, making my dying mum and now lost and grieving dad happy approaches the sublime.</p><p>Take this bookmark with you and use it when you’re reading. If I were to say that Suzanne Watts was still alive it would be in a different reality made of thoughts and memories, the same things used to make books and stories, and you can take Suzanne into her new home. A home not within a body but in some abstract way within all of us. When it was mum’s birthday last year I forced dad and Dan and Jono, Allira, Lauren, Oma Tineke and Michelle to write stories about mum and I made them into a book. I can tell you the story of making this book another time, but I haven’t said before in any of my retellings that it is the thing I am most proud of doing. Perhaps making this book and marrying my wife. It gave me a space to be uncharacteristically sentimental, and for someone as severe as me, that was a bit of a big deal. I’ll read out a little bit from <a href="https://medium.com/@nicholaswatts/something-i-wrote-to-my-mum-for-her-last-birthday-2de1653bbe2c#.xtp021pl5">the story I wrote for mum</a>, and then my speech will be over.</p><blockquote>You make up the margins around my life. In French literary theory that is a big deal. In almost everything I do, in the way I configure who I am, in the way I see memories of the past and go about daily life in the present, I try to be a better person, to know what it is to be a good person. The model of what this looks like most often is you. Someone who has shown me infinite hospitality and someone who is my dearest friend.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31e351c3fbd6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Something I wrote to my mum for her last birthday]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicholaswatts/something-i-wrote-to-my-mum-for-her-last-birthday-2de1653bbe2c?source=rss-d2b79728b8c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2de1653bbe2c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[obituary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mothers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eulogy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicholas Watts]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Apr 2016 04:49:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-06T04:49:22.467Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*elTx6oJUh_MwOoyqGbxnng.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>I forced my brothers, sister, dad, wife, my Oma Tineke and Aunty Michelle to write stories for mum that I turned into a book, which we then gave her for her birthday in October last year. This one’s mine, about a trip Mum and I went on to Europe in 2008 to go to her sister’s wedding on the southern coast of Spain. After visiting London on our own and travelling through Spain with our other relatives, the two of us stopped in Helsinki before arriving back in Australia.</em></p><p>We were in Helsinki for only two days. You had organised a hotel for us to stay in, and I remember the airport being tiny. I could make out the tall and thin trees in rows and clumps (which I now know are called copses) along the side of the road into the city. The ambient light was very low, even if the sky seemed bright when I looked straight at it. We were only a few days away from being home. I was anxious to see Lauren, I had missed her 21st birthday, and for some reason I was also anxious to see Winston, who I imagine was very young in 2008. At one point, in the car with Peter, Freke, Oma Tineke, you and me, I was sitting at the front. Uncle Peter was driving, and even though I remember seeing very little of the Spanish countryside, it was too bright (I spent a lot of time whining to you that I didn’t have any sunglasses, even though you had taken me to what were probably more than ten different sunglass shops — in each town we stopped in), I still liked spending time up there in front of the big windscreen with Uncle Peter. After a long silence, he leant over to me and in a secretive voice said, “look Nick, did you see that?” “No,” I would have replied, “see what?” “NWs, running over the road, they’re everywhere.” NWs, I thought? What is he talking about? I’m NW, Nick Watts (this was before I was Nicholas and Jono was Jon), and I’m not running anywhere, and there is only one of me. After at least ten seconds, which in this context was eternity, he said, “yes, they’re everywhere. NWs. Native Winstons.” At the time this was Uncle Peter’s great eccentricity. Each time I’ve thought about Native Winstons since I laugh. I see in it how much I would have been talking about Winston, talking about Lauren too, a pet and a girlfriend I cared deeply for. We were on an adventure, admittedly one with a bunch of old people, but at the time perhaps it would have been better that Dan were the older brother and I were the apprentice — a lesson in mindfulness might have been necessary.</p><p>In Helsinki we went from the airport to our hotel, you would have carried all my bags. I wanted to do some shopping, I think, or get something to eat (I was always hungry). I wouldn’t have let us go to Maccas. I waited with you outside our hotel while you tried to get us a taxi. We stood there for ages. You would see a taxi every few minutes and try to hail it. I stood, likely leant, becoming irritated. If I could see, I thought, I would be able to hail one of these taxis properly. This is my perpetual frustration — if only I could do the things I need other people to do for me then I could do them to my satisfaction. More time passed. You kept trying to get a taxi. It got cold. We were in Finland, where it gets cold. I can’t remember what I said to you, something in agitation and displeasure, and you turned around and started crying. “No cabs will stop for me,” you replied, not angry, which you should have been, but very, very tired. I remember you said cabs instead of taxis, which is what I had been saying, and shifted the anger onto myself for being such an idiot for insisting upon a term I thought was more proper than the term which everyone, at the time, actually used. I tried to mop up the damage I had done. I suggested we go inside and do some research about Helsinki on the internet, I think I said that I wasn’t so hungry anyway. Back in the hotel I read that no Helsinki cabs could be hailed, you had to book them. I had made you stand in the cold, giving you disapproving looks, for maybe an hour, while you were hard at work on a task that I had thought you were somehow failing.</p><p>Nietszche tells us not to look for the beginning of things. There is no beginning but multiple beginnings, and if you retrace a route back to its origin you will be driving through time in reverse — a fraught activity that has little to do with driving forwards, i.e., actually living. This moment on the curb outside a hotel in Helsinki is one of my beginnings. I think about it probably once a week, without meaning to. I’ll be sitting in an Uber trying to ignore the reprehensible fools on NOVA or in the broadcaster’s chair at FBi trying to ignore another one of them and it will pop into my head. We spent that night in a wonderful department store, you found us a chemist to see if Finland would sell me Nurofen Plus. I remember walking down the aisle of a Finnish supermarket thinking that this was the most foreign place I had ever been. Almost all the products on the shelves were from brands I had never heard of. We ate some burgers at a strange little fast food place. Attendants at shops all had little flag pins on their shirts and blouses to signify which languages they spoke, I could sometimes see them if I managed to get close enough without looking like a total nutcase.</p><p>After sleeping at our hotel we spent what is, as a memory, one of my favourite days of my whole life. We went to a market of handcrafted goods, I bought Lauren some earrings that I had thought after seeing them on display were made of silver and wood, they looked so beautiful, and I think I asked you for the 40 euros to buy them, which I felt like was an incredible amount of money. The woman who made them slipped the earrings into a bag and I gave them to Lauren when I got home. It wasn’t for years later, after my eyesight had improved a lot, that I realised they were completely silver. We had a peppery vegetable soup on the docks of a small harbour, outside a little tent that sold it. We walked to some shops in the city centre. We went to the airport and got on a plane to Tokyo.</p><p>It was just you and me walking around an faraway city together. After having started our trip as just the two of us in London and then Barcelona, I remember being excited to join up with the group of travellers in Madrid and journey to La Herradura in a car. You are relaxed and flexible, and a part of me likes structured activity. And then not long into the more regimented life of the grey nomad I realised that I much preferred travelling as just you and me. You were my friend. I didn’t have to explain myself and modulate my speech depending on who I was talking to. I remember thinking not long after we got home that travelling is about who is next to you, not where you are, and then realising how uncharacteristically sentimental that sounded, and trying to forget about it.</p><p>When, after a journey through southern Spain and a week-long wedding festival, we parted with Uncle Peter and Aunty Freke and Oma Tineke in the early hours of the morning in Malaga, and took an excruciatingly long flight in a tiny aeroplane to Helsinki, I had a second chance to hang out with you. And even though I am me, or was me in 2008, and made you cry when trying to hail a cab in a city that doesn’t permit hailing, we still spent the following day together as friends.</p><p>I find memory and remembering, in almost any context, destabilising and unknown. I have lost a lot of memories, from long periods of inactivity, when I have been especially sick, or when I first began to have trouble seeing. A lack of vision is an immediate impediment to functional living, but it also impairs your ability to make memories and hold on to them, I receive so much less information about the world and about people, it’s hard to go back and recreate scenes or events when I can’t see where I am or who I was with. Even though the time we went to Europe was my very first overseas trip, I struggle to remember so much of it. I could see so little back then. Everything was bright and harsh and chaotic.</p><p>But a lack of memory isn’t the real problem. I don’t know whether your memories of me align with my memories of you. I sometimes think before I come and visit when I’m in the passenger seat of the car trip to Bulli whether something I do will spark a memory in you of me that I have completely forgotten. And so many of your memories of me will be of stupid things I’ve said and done in the past, some of which I remember and regret, and many of which I am convinced I wouldn’t have even known were negative or hurtful at the time, and can’t remember them because they don’t stand out in difference. I haven’t ever mentioned to you that this day in Helsinki was so significant to me, I was afraid that it wasn’t to you, that you remember it differently, I was likely very annoying.</p><p>This is my third attempt at a piece of writing. The first was an long and winding story about prayer and mathematics that wasn’t at all good. The second was very conceptual. This one is unfortunately all about me. You have said before that you like your children, so I hope I can get away with it. As I went I must have thought, in an unconscious way, that writing about myself was writing about you. You make up the margins around my life. In French literary theory that is a big deal. In almost everything I do, in the way I configure who I am, in the way I see memories of the past and go about daily life in the present, I try to be a better person, to know what it is to be a good person. The model of what this looks like most often is you. Someone who has shown me infinite hospitality and someone who is my dearest friend.</p><p>I think, in walking around Helsinki, I felt at rest. At least, this is the memory I have built. It’s only very rarely after remembering the image of you crying on the side of the street at night that I go on to remember the day that followed it. You taught me something out there in the cold that I have made a part of myself. The patience and forgiveness and love you have shown me will live in me forever.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2de1653bbe2c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Somebody died trying to have a life like mine’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/somebody-died-trying-to-have-a-life-like-mine-26426e6f1b77?source=rss-d2b79728b8c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/26426e6f1b77</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[future-perfect]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alex-seton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[asylum-seekers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interview]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicholas Watts]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Apr 2015 09:01:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-03T01:45:57.630Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A conversation on the role of art in politics with visual artist Alex Seton</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fA9SBykZAHWgwHO5Pz1KKQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In May 2013, 28 life jackets washed up onto the shores of the Cocos Islands, a network of islands off Western Australia, southwest of Christmas Island, about half way between Sri Lanka and mainland Australia. One contained a small amount of Iranian currency.</p><p>This distressing image lingered in the mind of Sydney artist Alex Seton. When approached by the 2014 Adelaide Biennial to create a piece within its Dark Heart theme, he knew where to begin. “The event on the Cocos Islands provided a sort of aesthetic trigger,” he told me, “an idea through which to explore themes I was already thinking about.” He would recreate these life jackets in Australian marble — “part memorial, part personal meditation, part documentation of the state of affairs in Australia today”. The work, ‘Someone died trying to have a life like mine’ would expose “the dark heart of Australian society that will not offer asylum to those who seek it”.</p><p>Alex carries an urgent desire to point out what is missing in the national conversation around asylum seekers, something that has become disfigured as part of political games between the two bickering major parties. “The human stories are forgotten,” he says. Forgotten “in favour of a back and forth political blame game”. The idea that there are people as real as you and me who are dying at sea trying to get here is lost amid the “stop the boats” soundbites and conjured public hysteria over “queue jumpers” and “economic migrants”.</p><p>No one should accept the fatal consequences of our government’s cruel policies. The hope is that people “forget about the fear and hoopla of the party lines and the media” and confront the most immediate and significant underlying issue: the unconscionable loss of human lives.</p><p>The gravity of this artwork allays any sentimentalism, it instills the kind of immediate horror that a carefully manipulative political attack ad can only feebly grope towards. Alex sought to “bring the focus back to these people”, away from the inane rhetoric. The work demands that the audience imagine who might have filled the life jackets splayed out across the room, “each jacket is different in its details,” Alex emphasises. “Some are big, some small, some are tangled together and some prostrate and alone. Each has its own story, its own life.”</p><p>There is a careful mechanic at play — this artwork does not seek to participate in the worn and impotent conversation around methods of deterrence or the quantity of refugees Australia should accept, it forces you to recalibrate the entire foundation of this national problem and leaves you there. People are dying. At the heart of this entire circus is a tragedy no one ever wants to recognise and meditate over. The most basic of all rights, that to live, is being conveniently ignored. “No one should accept the death of innocent people at our hands,” Alex urges, “no matter what your thoughts on the present policies, the number of people that we should be accepting into Australia seeking asylum, or the method of processing them.”</p><p>This is a very specific and purposed artistic interaction with politics. “Rather than push any specific agenda and ‘pick a side’ of partisan politics, “ Alex tells me, “I’m trying to get people to pause and think about the real underlying issues that might be missing from the inflammatory rhetoric informing public opinion and debate.” ‘Someone died trying to have a life like mine’ doesn’t come with a four-point plan on what to do about the boats. It resists four-point plans and point-scoring in general. This antipathy towards the contemporary politics of asylum seekers is both understandable and necessary — we have had successive governments from both major parties contribute to the kind of event that leaves 28 life jackets washed ashore on the Cocos Islands. None of these governments displays a capacity for empathy or conscience.</p><p>There is a careful hope. This kind of installation art has the capacity to reframe our understanding of a previously muddy and tired problem, to dispel myths and draw attention to where it is needed. “It’s about grabbing someone’s attention,” Alex says. “That jolt that you experience when you’re looking at something that evokes emotion in you. In these moments people are open, they work to recompose their understanding of what’s in front of them.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=26426e6f1b77" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine/somebody-died-trying-to-have-a-life-like-mine-26426e6f1b77">‘Somebody died trying to have a life like mine’</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/future-perfect-magazine">Future Perfect Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>