<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Nicolas Kayser-Bril on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Nicolas Kayser-Bril on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:26:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The purpose-free organization]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/the-purpose-free-organization-c94b3203cdaf?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c94b3203cdaf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[organization-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bullshit-jobs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicolas Kayser-Bril]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Jan 2019 13:09:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-17T13:09:07.924Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*N-SeoGiLzOK8opEHqCRLJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>An organization’s main purpose is to give its members a certain social status. Whether employees do productive work or bullshit jobs makes no difference in the life of the organization. Other theories, which state that organizations exist to achieve a specific goal, fail to explain how so many of them can still smoothly obtain resources and pay salaries while being totally dysfunctional (the kind of organizations whose own employees tell you “I don’t understand how it can still run!”).</p><p>Based on this assumption (organizations exist to provide status), it becomes normal that an organization can function without a purpose, without any work being done. The more interesting question becomes: Under which circumstances can one do productive work? How can employees escape their bullshit job?</p><p>In 2006, I was a volunteer in an Israeli kibbutz in the Negev desert. The <em>kibbutzim</em> (plural of kibbutz) were collective farms created in the first half of the 20th century by socialist and communists emigrants to Palestine. On the kibbutz, all members were supposedly equal. But the families of the kibbutz’s founders were way more equal than the rest. They had the best houses, they didn’t have to participate in the daily chores and commuted by car to the big city nearby. Others, such as more recent, non-white emigrants, volunteers and <em>garin</em> soldiers (conscripts with no family in Israel), did most of the work. While the principles of kibbutz life were still respected (there was a common meal on Friday night, money was prohibited), few were stupid enough to believe that they were living the real thing.</p><p>A kibbutz member who had lived there long enough told me that things started to go downhill for kibbutzim in the 1970s, “when the swimming pools were built.” Swimming pools were much more than concrete basins painted blue and filled with water. They were the symbol of the victory over the desert, of the success of the irrigation plans that would provided Israel with food security. With the swimming pools, the kibbutzim’s mission was over.</p><p>The kibbutzim did not disappear with their mission. But from thriving communes where everyone was equal, they became purpose-less organizations, concerned only with maintaining the social status of their members, even if it meant reneging on their fundamental principles.</p><h3>Mission statements</h3><p>Kibbutzim lost their purpose in the 1970s because the goal they had set for themselves, to become prosperous communities in a secure Israel, had been met. They did not have an additional goal to keep the movement going, so they started unraveling.</p><p>The mission, or purpose, of an organization, is a tangible goal which members are asked to achieve. It can be fixed (e.g. “bring electricity to every house in the country” was the goal of national electric utilities in the second half of the 20th century) or continuous (e.g. “provide affordable energy in a sustainable way” could have been the goal of these utilities afterwards).</p><p>Having a clear mission is important, it keeps employees motivated. But it goes beyond mere motivation. Only with a goal that all members of an organization agree on can work be assessed: Anyone can see if a task contributes to the completion of the overarching mission.</p><p>To see the concept in action, look no further than a national army engaged in a war (provided the government issued clear war goals, e.g. “conquer a given territory”). There, any action or innovation that contributes to winning the war can be identified (e.g. because it kills more enemies or reduces losses) and rewarded. Trust emerges between colleagues because a joint endeavor can result in joint rewards.</p><p>If an organization has no mission, no work can be done to progress towards a common goal (there is no goal). Productive work on smaller projects (which might have been created with a goal in mind) within the organization can still be done but it will not be rewarded, as there is no way of telling a good project from a useless one.</p><h3>Management through fear</h3><p>In an organization that has a mission, hierarchy reflects past achievements or an ability to manage others efficiently towards the organization’s goal. Without a mission, hierarchy only reflects power relationships between individuals. Management is based on personal loyalty, not productive work. And because positive feedback is impossible (remember, there is no goal to positively assess someone’s actions), negative feedback is the only tool available to enforce hierarchy. Feedback can only be punitive and, as a result, fear of retaliation becomes the norm. Trust is impossible because an association between colleagues to do productive work will not be rewarded.</p><p>In an army at war, soldiers are usually promoted after a feat of heroism on the battlefield (hierarchy reflects past achievements). In an army engaged in wars that have no goals (e.g. the war on terror) or at peace, soldiers are promoted following personal allegiances rather than actual deeds. The existence or absence of a mission defines how an organization is managed.</p><p>Knowing whether or not an organization has a mission is surprisingly easy. If you doubt that it has one, it probably does not. If two people within the organization come up with vastly different answers, it probably does not. If it places faith in arbitrary numerical indicators to describe individual performance, it probably does not. If the official mission statement is bullshit (a mix of English and native words is a red flag), it definitely does not.</p><p>“Creating value for shareholders” is not a mission, it is simply the signal that the fruits of one’s work will be given to someone else. Franchised chains, where workers are explicitly excluded from the business’ core mission, which is managed by the brand-owning company, are salient examples of purpose-less organizations. “Making enough money to pay salaries” cannot be a mission for, as I wrote in the first line of this essay, it is the foundation of any organization.</p><h3>Losing it</h3><p>The loss of a mission can occur in two ways.</p><p>The mission can be accomplished. This was the case for the kibbutzim and for successful armies. It was the case for Facebook which, in the past few years, successfully linked together all computer-owning humans. Unsurprisingly, relationships between employees at Facebook are since based on fear and personal loyalty, as several journalistic investigations showed in the past few months.</p><p>The mission, though not accomplished, can also be altered to the point of irrelevance. A web start-up company that aimed at world dominance, reached profitability but failed to become market leader falls in this category (start-ups are never built to become mid-sized businesses). So, too, do many public services that have been transformed to mimic the private sector. Universities, for instance, were built to protect and research the truth and have been transformed into providers of human capital. The European Commission is another good example. Created to rule above the member states of the European Union, it has since the early 2010s become their secretariat, renouncing its original mission. Hospitals which went from curing patients to extracting money from customers, pharmaceutical companies which market addictive drugs instead of cures and appliance makers which design products to fail rapidly (built-in obsolescence) are all without missions.</p><p>Having a mission is not enough in itself. An army might have a clear war objective ; if it is being routed by enemy forces, any productive work done by soldiers or supporting staff will still lead to nothing. To exist, productive work requires growth.</p><h3>Growth</h3><p>If your organization does not grow, any reward to your colleagues mechanically means that you, or someone else, will get less. The impossibility of positive feedback that arises from the lack of a mission leads to fear. That any personal progress is made at the expense of others, leads, in turn, to generalized mistrust. Every member of the organization must be careful not to be overrun by an ambitious colleague.</p><p>Trust between members becomes impossible because A will always have a good reason to believe that any help given to B will never be paid back. Instead, B has an incentive to extract as much as possible from A, for there is no other way to progress within the organization. Duplicity and back-stabbing become everyday occurrences. Productive work is impossible because if B believes that A might be rewarded for a task well made, B will have a good reason to torpedo A’s work (otherwise, A risks being rewarded at the expense of B). A knows that and, as a results, refrains from doing productive work. When there is no growth, bullshit jobs become the norm.</p><p>Growth occurs in two ways. An organization might increase its power, by gaining command over more resources or by convincing others that its resources are more valuable. This is what most people think of as “growth”. It translates in more sales, by volume or by value, and in more assets.</p><p>Another path to growth opens when less humans are around to share a given capital. Destruction of life, provided that factories, fields and equipment remain intact, offers great perspectives to those who survive. Epidemics that kill randomly (so that people at all hierarchical levels disappear) or random purges have historically provided fantastic career opportunities to people who previously stood no chance because of their low social status.<a href="https://blog.nkb.fr/purpose-free-org/#foot_13">13</a></p><p>Growth is only important insofar as members of the organization can benefit from it. The bottom line of a company may increase ; if all the profits are directed to a third party (the state or shareholders), the organization behaves as if it were not growing at all. <em>Expectation of possible personal advancement</em> better describes it, but “growth” has the advantage of brevity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/910/1*qCUxP2OEbT-8dy4817nCpg.png" /></figure><p>From the two binary variables exposed above, organizations can be divided in four groups.</p><h3>No mission — No growth</h3><p>In the absence of growth, any work that is considered productive is a potential threat for all others. By engaging in productive work and being good at it, an employee further shows that she could apply her skills somewhere else and therefore, that she has less to lose from a challenge within the organization than someone mediocre. In a stagnating organization that has no mission, people engaging in productive work are never promoted and often fired.</p><p>Without a mission and without growth, relationships between colleagues are based on mistrust and hierarchical links are based on fear.</p><p>You can quickly assess the level of fear of your own organization with this simple test. If the resources your organization puts in preventing you from buying something (because several people need to approve your buying office supplies, say, or a train ticket) is more than double the price of the item you wanted to buy, fear overweights any sense of purpose.</p><p>Such organizations do not necessarily crumble. They still provide status to their members so that, even if fear becomes an everyday experience, even if work is constantly sabotaged, one is better in than out. For the overwhelming majority of people, doing a bullshit job is better than to be unemployed.</p><p>Unfortunately, this type of organization is the default and, except for periods of very high economic growth, the most common. It is the default because, as I show below, is the only stable one.</p><h3>No mission — Growth</h3><p>An organization can have no mission and still grow. This can happen because the economic environment is such that it “lifts all the boats”. Any organization that is so large that it suffers little from competition (that includes all public services and much of the corporate world) will benefit from a growing economy, even if it does not do anything productive.</p><p>In this context, the absence of a mission makes positive feedback impossible, so that productive work is not rewarded and fear still dominates. However, as long as the organization grows, productive work is not seen as a threat. Anyone who wishes to do something other than a bullshit job is free to do so.</p><p>This configuration lasts only as long as growth. Because productive work is not rewarded, the organization cannot grow by taking market share from its competitors — any growth must come from outside. As soon as growth stop, the organization reverses to the default state (no mission — no growth) and anyone engaging in productive work is either fired or leaves by themselves.</p><p>When employees are offered a bail-out to leave their company, a strong signal that the organization is shrinking, it is often the best among them who take it. They might have other professional plans, they are also the ones who know that they will not be able to perform a bullshit job if they stay.</p><h3>Mission — No growth</h3><p>An organization might have a clear mission but, like a retreating army, offer no opportunities to its members. In the words of Winston Churchill, they have “nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears and sweat”. This is probably the most unstable type of organization. Either members of the organization can regroup around the mission statement and turn the tide, starting growth anew, or they can give up on the organization’s mission and enter the stable state of “no mission — no growth”.</p><p>Turning the tide is only possible for organizations that acquire their resources themselves. If growth depends on a third party, as is the case for all public services, a return to growth is impossible.</p><p>You can witness the shift from growth to contraction in much of the public sector. In state-funded public education, for instance, teachers who care about their mission and try to innovate in the classroom are systematically punished, even when their work is appreciated by pupils and parents. In health care systems that are being shrunk (that means, in Europe at least, most of them), personnel who consider their occupation to be a bullshit job have a great advantage over those who care about patients, for they are not at risk of burning out.</p><p>Private sector firms also routinely renounce their mission when growth runs out. It is vastly more comfortable for decision-makers to abandon a mission rather than to jeopardize the value of the company’s shares at the stock exchange. The example of Facebook, mentioned above, is a case in point where a company remorselessly gives up on its mission in order to enjoy the benefits of the position it acquired. Google’s dropping its “don’t be evil” motto in October 2015 was also a sign of its renouncement to its original mission.</p><h3>Mission — Growth</h3><p>When an organization has a clear goal <em>and</em> provides new opportunities to all members through growth, productive work is sought and rewarded. Bullshit jobs do not exist because anyone not contributing to the organization’s goals risks being fired or, at least, not promoted. While some members might free-ride on the others’ work, trust between employees is the norm as everyone knows that better work will translate in better opportunities for all.</p><p>Most newly-created organizations enter this category, even if the growth is short-lived. In times of economic growth, any organization with a mission does, too. In times of stagnation, in which we find ourselves in since the late 2000s in Europe, such organizations are the exception.</p><h3>Extending the theory</h3><p>I started thinking about this theory to explain my own experiences working with or within some organizations. But its potential goes beyond my own work history. For instance, it explains why the same occupation (e.g. marketing director) can be a bullshit job in one organization and a fulfilling one in another.</p><p>If you extend the theory to society at large, assuming it can be considered one organization, it also explains why so many innovations happen in war time. It’s not that nationalism makes people smarter, or that the necessities of war force people to think in new ways. It’s simply that in war, there is a clear goal against which a job can be measured, which in turns allows for rewarding productive work. (And because many people die in war, there are plenty of career opportunities for who engages in productive work.)</p><p>The theory also fits nicely with the work of David Herlihy in <em>The Black Death and the Transformation of the West</em>, where he argues that the Age of Discovery, from the 15thto the 18thcentury, was made possible by the numerous plagues that hit Europe. Every forty years or so, a new plague killed one in ten, sometimes more, inhabitants, while leaving capital intact. These were as many opportunities for social promotion, which made productive work possible and led to the spread of the printing press, the compass and the caravel.</p><p>Finally, it explains why bullshit jobs rose as the economy stagnated (stagnated in the sense that income of all but the very richest stopped rising despite nominal GDP growth). Without growth, most organizations that had a mission had to jettison it to preserve their social standing, reverting to the first category of the typology above, “no mission — no growth”.</p><p>The rise of bullshit jobs has collateral effects. They require that employees accept the irrelevance of their work. They can do so in one of two ways, either by accepting a strong cognitive dissonance between their actions and their judgment, or by switching off critical thinking and accepting their bullshit job and their constant duplicity at work as a good thing.</p><p>Switching off critical thinking is obviously much easier, not to mention that cognitive dissonance might lead to psychological problems. The disappearance of critical thinking and the spread of dishonesty within organizations transforms the general population, making it easier for untruths to penetrate it and much harder for the truth to gain footing. Truth, which is the first tool needed to do productive work (assessing a task against a mission implies the existence of truth, which needed to make the judgment), is an obstacle to bullshit jobs. Because truth forces us to think critically, it can prevent loyalty (truth might contradict the person you should be loyal to), which is the cornerstone of management in organizations that have no mission.</p><p>It is no coincidence that science is seen positively only in times of high economic growth and considered a nuisance in times of stagnation.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://blog.nkb.fr/purpose-free-org/"><em>blog.nkb.fr</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c94b3203cdaf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Comment une industrie a raté le virage des données et du numérique]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/comment-une-industrie-a-rat%C3%A9-le-virage-des-donn%C3%A9es-et-du-num%C3%A9rique-c943cc3d8058?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c943cc3d8058</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[médias]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalisme]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accident-industriel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicolas Kayser-Bril]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Jan 2018 11:41:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-24T11:49:50.772Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Retrouvez </em><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/medias-numerique"><em>la version originale, qui contient les sources citées, sur nkb.fr.</em></a></p><p>Mai 1995 fut riche en évènements. Jacques Chirac a été élu président le 7 du mois, Mark Zuckerberg a fêté son 11e anniversaire le 14 et Libération a ouvert son site internet le 26. La plupart des grands noms de la presse quotidienne l’ont rejoint sur le web dans les mois qui suivirent, suivis quelques années plus tard par les radios et les télévisions.</p><p>1995, c’est trois ans avant la création de Google, six ans avant Wikipedia, dix ans avant YouTube et Facebook, sans parler d’Instagram ou de Snapchat. Vingt ans plus tard ces médias, arrivés si tôt en ligne, sont devenus les prestataires de ces géants du web, quand les milliardaires des nouvelles technologies ne les ont pas tout simplement racheté à la manière de Niel (Le Monde) ou Bezos (Washington Post).</p><p>Pourquoi, malgré ce départ sur les chapeaux de roues, les médias ont-ils glissés du haut en bas de l’échelle? Ont-ils commis des erreurs? Ou leur chute était-elle inexorable?</p><h3>Des métiers contradictoires</h3><p>Avant internet, les médias fournissaient des services variés: petites annonces (emploi, rencontres etc.), information locale et nationale, divertissement et publicité. Pour exister, chacun de ces services nécessitait un considérable investissement en capital, que ce soit pour acquérir une imprimerie ou bien un studio et une licence de radio ou de télévision. Logiquement, quasiment tous les acteurs du secteur ont adopté un modèle d’affaire où le média utilise au maximum son investissement pour fournir le plus de services possibles. C’est pourquoi les journaux offrent une flopée de sections et de cahiers, libre aux lecteurs·trices de faire le tri après achat.</p><p>Comme ce n’était pas rentable de publier un journal pour quelques centaines de lecteurs et qu’il était impossible de publier toutes les petites annonces sur un territoire trop étendu, ce modèle d’affaire avait une taille d’entreprise optimale. Cela aboutit à des fusions puis à des monopoles et à des excédents d’exploitation fantastiques. Pour Warren Buffet, un investisseur américain, “même avec un produit mauvais ou des dirigeants ineptes, aucun journal en situation de monopole dans sa ville ne pouvait éviter des profits débordants.”</p><p>Cette rente a duré jusqu’au milieu des années 2000. Avec internet, les petites annonces et les services associés se sont fait la belle. Craigslist, eBay ou Le Bon Coin sont mille fois plus efficaces qu’un journal pour revendre ses bibelots, tout comme Meetic ou Tinder le sont pour les rencontres. Puis vint la crise de 2008, qui a accéléré le passage des annonceurs en ligne. Or sur le web, le marché de la publicité est contrôlé par Google et Facebook, pas par les médias.</p><p>En une dizaine d’années, entre 2005 et 2015, quasiment tous les médias ont subit des crises d’identités, des restructurations, voire des faillites comme celle de la Comareg (ParuVendu) en 2011 ou celle de France-Soir en 2012. Ces crises multiples ne sont pas directement dues à l’attentisme des entreprises — elles avaient toutes, après tout, un site internet. Ces sites auraient pu être mieux fait mais le problème était plus profond.</p><p>La plupart des médias ont vu le web comme un espace où ils pouvaient calquer leur activité initiale. Ce fut fatal pour les journaux et les magazines qui virent dans les “pages” web une nouvelle version des “pages” en papier. Sans parler de la présentation du contenu, la numérisation a modifié l’essence même des métiers pratiqués par les médias.</p><p>Les petites annonces ne doivent plus être rassemblées au même endroit sous une même marque mais au contraire divisées en segments correspondants à une communauté d’acheteurs et de vendeurs. La prime est à la spécialisation, y compris pour les contenus qui accompagnent les annonces. Caradisiac par exemple liste 28 personnes dans sa rédaction — à peu près autant que chez Auto Plus.</p><p>Plus épineux est le lien entre information et publicité. Les annonceurs recherchent souvent les plus grandes audiences possibles. Or pour attirer de grandes audiences, rien ne vaut le spectaculaire, tant pis si l’information n’est pas vraie. Le glissement de l’information vers le divertissement a commencé en télévision avec l’arrivée du câble et du satellite dans les années 1980, quand les chaînes spécialisées ont commencé à empiéter sur le marché des chaînes généralistes.</p><p>Sur le web, le phénomène a pris de l’ampleur, entraînant toutes les rédactions dans une course effrénée aux pages vues. La confusion est telle qu’il n’est pas rare de trouver au pied d’un article dénonçant les “fake news” écrit par un journaliste des liens vers des articles bidons chez Outbrain ou Taboola, deux sociétés spécialisées dans la génération de pages vues et la vente de publicité.</p><h3>Les autruches, les cargo cultes et les autres</h3><p>Ensemble, les différents éléments constitutifs des médias n’avaient aucune chance de survivre sur le web. Pour autant, les groupes de presse auraient pu séparer leurs activités et adapter le modèle d’affaire de chacune d’entre elles. Certains l’ont fait, mais ils sont peu nombreux.</p><p>La plupart ont fait l’autruche. En cela, ils ont été aidés par leurs employés, à commencer par les journalistes qui ont fait de l’ignorance de l’économie de leurs entreprise un signe de fierté (ils appellent la séparation entre l’éditorial et le reste la “muraille de Chine”). Le premier cours que j’ai donné dans une école de journalisme en 2007 à Paris, dans une école se présentant comme la meilleure du lot, portait sur les modèles d’affaires de la presse en ligne. Au bout de deux heures, la moitié des étudiants avait quitté la salle. Non pas, comme c’était sans doute le cas, parce que mon cours était mauvais, mais parce qu’ils trouvaient intolérable qu’on puissent leur expliquer que le journalisme pouvait avoir un lien avec l’argent.</p><p>Dans ces conditions (qui ont un peu changé depuis mais pas trop), difficile de modifier quoi que ce soit en profondeur. Par ailleurs, en conservant à l’écart les équipes web, les médias ont créé un gouffre durable entre les journalistes papiers et ceux du web, moins bien payés, méprisés par leurs collègues et souvent hors des rédactions. Vu sous cet angle, le web était un repoussoir ; on comprend mieux pourquoi les rédactions ont freinés des quatre fers la transition numérique de leurs entreprises.</p><p>Plus grave que les autruches sont les entreprises qui traitent le web comme un cargo culte. Pendant la seconde guerre mondiale, l’armée américaine a installé des bases dans certaines îles du Pacifique et fourni les habitants en nourriture et autres objets. En 1945, ces bases ont été abandonnées mais les Mélanésiens s’étaient habitués à être nourris et habillés par l’armée US. Ils ont cherché à faire revenir ces livraisons en construisant des pistes d’atterrissage, des avions et des tours de contrôle en bambou — en vain. Cela nous semble évident que la piste d’atterrissage ne cause pas la livraison mais, vu de l’île, ce n’est pas une hypothèse absurde.</p><p>En voyant des sociétés créées par des ados ou des jeunes adultes brasser des milliards à partir de rien, de nombreux dirigeants ont réagit comme les Mélanésiens. Plutôt que de chercher la cause de ces succès, ils ont voulu imiter.</p><p>En juillet 2005, News Corp, alors l’un des plus gros conglomérats média du monde, achète MySpace, un réseau social, pour 580 millions de dollars. Six ans plus tard, le site est revendu pour un seizième de la somme. En Allemagne, le groupe Holtzbrinck a payé 85 millions d’euros en 2007 pour studiVZ, un réseau social aujourd’hui disparu. L’erreur de News Corp a été de traiter MySpace comme un journal disposant d’une audience captive. Le groupe de Murdoch a dégradé le site au maximum pour honorer un accord de publicité passé avec Google, poussant tous les utilisateurs dans les bras de Facebook. Quant à Holtzbrinck, ils n’ont pas compris que les effets de réseaux allaient favoriser Facebook sur le long terme.</p><p>Au delà des réseaux sociaux et de ces deux naufrages, les médias ont regardé chaque nouveauté comme un Graal qui allait leur permettre de remonter la pente. Faites une requête sur la phrase “va-t-il sauver la presse” dans votre moteur de recherche favori pour vous en convaincre. On trouve, pêle-mèle, “Le Kindle va-t-il sauver la presse” (2009), “L’iPad va-t-il sauver la presse” (2010), “Snapchat va-t-il sauver la presse” ou encore, en 2017, “Le Bitcoin va-t-il sauver la presse?” La liste est loin d’être exhaustive. Il y a eu la mode des blogs, celle de la personnalisation, celle des coupons, celle du big data, celle de la video, Instant Articles, les chatbots… La dernière tendance est au machine learning qui, on s’en doute, ne sauvera pas la presse.</p><p>Rien ne sauvera la presse puisque, comme je l’ai dit plus haut, le concept de “la presse” sur internet est non seulement obsolète, il est contradictoire. Cependant, alors que les conférences professionnelles débattaient des stratégies à adopter pour mener cette mission impossible, certains groupes comprirent ce qui était en train de se passer et ont prirent les devants.</p><p>Le groupe norvégien Schibsted, par exemple, a lancé son propre fournisseur d’accès à internet, Schibsted Nett, au début des années 1990, sur le modèle d’America On Line (AOL). En 1996, il l’a revendu à un concurrent pour se concentrer sur la fourniture de contenu, en créant un portail, avant d’investir dans des sites spécialisés dans les petites annonces. Dès l’arrivée du web en Scandinavie, Schibsted a compris que ce canal deviendrait incontournable et a tout mis en œuvre pour y conserver sa position de pilier de l’information et de la publicité. L’entreprise a investi considérablement et ne s’est pas laissée échauder par l’éclatement de la bulle du Nasdaq en 2001. Aujourd’hui, le groupe est leader des petites annonces dans 18 pays et s’est débarrassé de ses journaux partout sauf en Norvège et en Suède, où il continue à investir.</p><p>En Allemagne, le groupe Axel Springer, déjà numéro un des journaux dans les années 1990, a suivit le même parcours. Il est désormais organisé en trois pôles distincts: les petites annonces (LaCentrale en France, par exemple), le contenu payant (ses journaux sont tous passés au modèle payant sur abonnement) et la vente de publicité (auféminin en France). Parmi les groupes français, seul Le Figaro a réussi à retrouver sur le web un équilibre entre la production de contenu, la publicité et les petites annonces (Figaro Classifieds est leader des petites annonces en France).</p><p>Pas besoin d’être un mastodonte pour réussir sa transition numérique. En Suède, le journal de la ville de Skellefteå (35 000 habitants) s’est repensé en pilier de la communauté et organise désormais des évènements en plus de son activité purement média. Médiapart ou Valeurs Actuelles sont différents en tout, sauf dans leur modèle d’affaire: les deux montrent que l’on peut vendre du contenu et en dégager un bénéfice si l’acte d’abonnement devient un acte d’adhésion à une vision politique.</p><p>Le seul créneau sur lequel les médias n’ont pas investi sur le web est celui de l’information “pure”, celle qui, détachée de son contenant, sert de matière première aux analystes ou aux journalistes. Aucun média ne s’est transformé, passant d’un fournisseur d’articles à un fournisseur de données.<a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/medias-numerique#foot_20">20</a>Les spécialistes du secteur comme Thomson (aujourd’hui ThomsonReuters), The Economist Intelligence Unit ou Bloomberg existaient avant internet et n’ont pas été déstabilisé par les évolutions des deux dernières décennies. Il y avait pourtant des places à prendre, comme le montre l’histoire d’Opta Sports. Créé en 2001 (un an après que L’Équipe a ouvert son site web), Opta s’est donné pour mission de collecter toutes les données sur toutes les rencontres, dans tous les sports et en direct. Alors que L’Équipe possédait de vastes bases de données sur le même sujet, c’est Opta qui a raflé le marché. Si vous lisez des résultats sportifs dans un journal aujourd’hui, il y a de fortes chances qu’ils aient été vendu par Opta au journal que vous avez entre les mains (y compris si vous lisez L’Équipe).</p><h3>Une seule solution, la litigation</h3><p>La plupart des médias ne savent toujours pas s’ils sont là pour produire de l’information, vendre de la publicité à des annonceurs ou si leur mission se trouve ailleurs.</p><p>Ils se retrouvent pourtant tous sur une stratégie depuis une vingtaine d’années, celle des poursuites judiciaires contre les nouveaux entrants. Les premiers à en faire les frais furent les sociétés de l’audiovisuel public. En Allemagne, les médias privés annoncent depuis presque vingt ans que la présence de la télévision publique sur internet met leur existence en danger. Ce n’est évidemment pas vrai, puisque la mission d’information de la télévision publique n’a pas grand chose à voir avec les métiers d’Axel Springer. Mais ces procès permettent aux médias privés d’afficher leur pouvoir.</p><p>Les médias s’en prennent plus souvent à Google, accusé en général d’enfreindre les lois sur la propriété intellectuelle. Plusieurs éditeurs français ont lancé un procès en 2006 contre Google Books, en même temps que plusieurs titres de presse belges attaquaient Google News. Des médias allemands attaquent à leur tour en 2012.</p><p>L’histoire espagnole est la plus instructive. A la fin des années 2000, plusieurs éditeurs espagnols se liguent contre Google News. Une loi est votée, qui leur permet de réclamer à Google des royalties sur les liens affichés. Après un passage en justice, où Google perd, le moteur de recherche décide de supprimer Google News en Espagne. Cette fois-ci, les éditeurs dénoncent une grave menace pour la démocratie et demandent au gouvernement de faire revenir Google News! (Avertis de cette histoire, les médias allemands ont renoncé aux royalties que leur aurait permis d’obtenir la nouvelle loi sur le copyright votée en 2013.)</p><p>Google, suivi par Facebook, a réussi à monopoliser l’attention des Européens, que détenaient auparavant les médias, et, grâce aux données personnelles dont ils disposent, génèrent des milliards en revendant cette attention aux annonceurs. Pour ces GAFA, les médias sont des fournisseurs de contenus parmi une infinité d’autres. Ils sont aussi des empêcheurs de tourner en rond. Journalistes et patrons de presse ont l’oreille des politiques, via les jeux de pouvoir nationaux ou simplement parce qu’ils ont été à l’université ensemble.</p><p>Face à ce problème, Google (suivi encore une fois de Facebook) a vite trouvé la parade. Chacune des procédures judiciaires que j’ai évoqué s’est terminée par la création d’un fonds mis à disposition des médias. Google finance ainsi certains projets du Syndicat national de l’édition. Il a créé en France le “Fonds pour l’Innovation Numérique de la Presse”, suivi au niveau Européen de la “Digital News Initiative”. Dans ce jeu de dupes, Google se présente comme le partenaire des médias et met en scène une relation d’égal à égal alors qu’il ne s’agit que de les diviser (chaque média doit candidater individuellement pour obtenir un subside de Google) et d’acheter leur complaisance. Les GAFA organisent ou financent également les conférences professionelles des médias en Europe, comme le Global Editors Network Summit, le Newsgeist et le JournalismFest.</p><h3>La presse est sauvée!</h3><p>A l’exception de ceux qui ont suivi une véritable stratégie de long terme sur le web, les médias sont passé, en deux décennies, d’un rôle de monopoliste de l’attention et de la publicité à celui de fournisseurs de contenu vivants des largesses des GAFA.</p><p>La dégringolade des médias va sans doute s’arrêter là. Je ne pense pas que “la presse” va disparaître car internet a, lui aussi, beaucoup changé.</p><p>La mécanique des investisseurs web, qui financent à fonds perdu un champion jusqu’à ce qu’il soit en position de monopole et puisse augmenter ses marges, comme ils l’ont fait avec Google et Facebook (puis avec Uber, Delivery Hero etc.), a conduit au duopole actuel (Google/Facebook) sur le marché de l’attention et de la publicité. Alors qu’on pouvait, dans les années 2000, toucher une audience parce que son contenu était de meilleure qualité que celui des concurrents, on atteint aujourd’hui son audience en payant l’un des deux gardiens de l’attention. Impossible pour un nouvel entrant de se faire une place sans apport massif en capital. On est revenu à la situation qui prévalait avant internet.</p><p>De l’autre côté, la neutralité du net n’existe plus. Les fournisseurs d’accès peuvent choisir ce que leurs clients consomment, ne serait-ce que grâce à la vente liée et au <em>zero rating</em>. SFR a besoin de médias (Libération, L’Express etc.) pour son offre SFR Play, Orange a besoin de Deezer, dans lequel il a largement investi, pour ses forfaits mobiles et Comcast, le plus gros fournisseur d’accès américain, a acheté NBCUniversal et Dreamworks pour les mêmes raisons.</p><p>Et puis, les médias sont indispensables au système politique. Pas tant pour leur capacité à toucher une audience — Macron a quasiment autant de followers sur Facebook que Le Monde ou Le Figaro — mais dans leur rôle d’adversaire et de commentateur. Sans “les médias”, une bonne partie de la classe politique n’aurait plus de sujet sur lequel s’indigner et les autres n’auraient plus personne pour les écouter.</p><p>A quelques exceptions près (France-Soir), les grands noms de la presse continueront à exister. Libération a sans doute de meilleures chances de survie au sein de SFR que Buzzfeed, par exemple. Même si la start-up américaine a tout compris du web des années 2000 et 2010, le web des années 2020 appartient aux fournisseurs d’accès, pas aux innovateurs.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c943cc3d8058" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Magic Queendom of Europe]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/the-magic-queendom-of-europe-d8515bdbaaa2?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8515bdbaaa2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[political-satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dystopia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[utopia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[european-union]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[empowerment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicolas Kayser-Bril]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Oct 2017 08:46:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-10T08:46:28.822Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>I am sick of reading or watching dystopias.</em></p><p><em>Why do we keep producing blueprints for the idiots who are taking power? It helps them and we don’t need to be constantly reminded of what’s coming, it just increases our feeling of powerlessness.</em></p><p><em>We should provide alternatives instead. Here’s an attempt.</em></p><p><em>Many thanks to Johanna for her ideas and support.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TVz3NgaGms2QEF-s.png" /></figure><h3>Monday, 10 May 2027</h3><p>“Welcome to the Museum of Europe!” Smiling widely as a good guide should, I looked at the group of tourists that had gathered in the lobby. There were American pensioners in flip-flops and Chinese businesspeople in polished shoes — this group would be an interesting mix. “You’re here on the first floor of the Berlaymont building, which used to house the headquarters of the European Commission. Four years ago, when the European Union dissolved, it was decided that it would become a residency for artists, with the first two floors reserved for the Museum. I’ll take you through the history of our young state, which is also one of the oldest on Earth. Follow me!”</p><p>I was leading the group to the first room when I first noticed them. Two males that tried to mix with the elderly Americans but looked nothing like tourists. They were in their forties, wore old polo shirts in bright colors, sunglasses and analog reflex cameras. If anything, they looked like Vladimir Putin in the 1980’s when he was posing as a Russian tourist in East-Germany while working as an undercover KGB agent. Strange, I thought, but I didn’t give it much of a thought and went on with my visit.</p><p>‒ “In this room, we made a timeline of the creation of Europe. It seems very linear and logical when you look at the succession of events, from the end of World War 2 to the creation of the European Economic Community to the European Union to the Europe we know today, but let me assure you: it was anything but. Things could have turned out very differently.”</p><p>‒ “I remember well, said one Chinese woman in a sleek dark blue suit. I was working for Bank of China in Paris when the changes happened. It was quite a shock to everyone.”</p><p>‒ “Indeed, nobody saw it coming. In the Spring of 2022, just five years ago, in France, a new politician sprung out from nowhere…”</p><p>‒ “Marie-Rachida Cohen!” I heard several people whisper her name in the group.</p><p>‒ “Yes, Marie-Rachida Cohen, or Maraco as many people call her. It wasn’t a surprise to see a new face in French politics. Actually, since Macron, the previous French president, had come to power, French elections were more of a tombola than anything else. Due to the peculiarities of the French voting system, you just needed to be on the top of your wave on election day to be elected. President Cohen was elected with a comfortable 10-point margin against Le Pen and became the first French female president. That she was an Arabic-speaking Jew who converted to Catholicism was interesting to some, but at this point of the story, she did not arouse the kind of enthusiasm that would follow. The French had grown weary of hope, after they fell for Sarkozy in 2007, for Hollande in 2012 and for Macron in 2017, none of whom made any positive change to their lives. The majority of voters had been disappointed at least once and had no reason to believe that this time would be different.”</p><p>‒ “It was a bit more complicated than that, the Chinese woman interrupted. I’m an analyst, and I can tell you that our risk indicators were going through the roof in the months before the French election. With Merkel starting her fifth term in Germany in a coalition with the left-wingers of the far-right Alternative for Germany and Lithuania that had just triggered Article 50 to leave the European Union in order to join the Russia-dominated Eurasian Economic Union, we were expecting war to break out in Europe pretty quickly.”</p><p>The American side of the group nodded in agreement. Apparently, they were all former businesspeople or civil servants stationed in Europe doing a nostalgia tour. I wasn’t surprised that they did not speak. All the Americans I saw were afraid that they could be accused of antipatriotic sentiment when they returned to the United States, either because their devices recorded them speaking against their administration or because someone in the group reported them. The only two to stand out were the strange pair I first spotted, who simply stared at me ceaselessly. A bit disconcerting, but I had enough experience as a guide not to be distracted.</p><p>‒ “It’s true, I concurred. Uncertainty in the early 20’s was very high, but apathy was, too. Ever since the financial crisis of 2008, the population discarded authorities and institutions as useless at best and actively corrupt in general. What a surprise 2022 was.” I took my group further down the timeline, to the panel that listed the actions taken by president Cohen of France.</p><p>‒ “The population was expecting a mix of tax-cuts for the rich, token measures for the poor and more power for the coercive forces, as had happened in the past twenty years. Instead, president Cohen went on a rampage. She started by promising the introduction of universal basic income within a year. That got people interested. The next day, she legalized all psychoactive drugs. You could go to any pharmacy and ask for any drug with low addictive power, like cannabis, MDMA or cocaine, while more addictive ones could be delivered by medical doctors. She was smart. To prove that she was serious, she had had tons of cannabis secretly flown in from Colorado in the days before so that the pharmacies were fully stocked when the legalization happened. This profoundly shook the underworld. People in the banlieues cheered. Legalization meant that gangs would lose their income and their power of attraction. Most French people were happy to pay taxes before getting high, and people outside of France started paying attention. The legalization action was intended to destabilize the corrupt networks at the heart of the French state. At the time, mafia bosses were routinely ministers or high-ranking police officers. They suddenly had to rethink their entire business model. It’s no surprise that Italy was the loudest opponent of the legalization. The Calabrian mafia who owned the cocaine trade in Europe and most of the Italian government pushed the Italian army to stage an exercise along the French border, as a threat. Thousands of Italians took to the streets in support of the French president. That was the beginning of Maraco’s European plans. On that later.”</p><p>“After the Legalization Act, the pace of change increased. A few days later, she signed a law authorizing euthanasia. She had campaigned as a Catholic and the Church had supported her, so this move embarrassed bishops greatly. They got lost in internal disputes and in any case were too slow to react. With the Church neutralized, president Cohen canceled all public holidays except Easter and Christmas and replaced them with Yom Kippur, Eid al-Fitr, which are two important religious feasts for Jews and Muslims, and a series of secular holidays honoring historical figures, such as Marie Curie Day or Rosa Parks Day.”</p><p>“By then, just a few weeks in office, she had the country in a state of near chaos. The millions who had sheepishly accepted the outrage of the previous governments sensed that something was changing, and they were thrilled. But the millions of others, many of which Front National voters, who fed on hatred and distrust of politicians, felt that they had lost their momentum, too, and that they needed to act rapidly.”</p><p>“Upon taking office, president Cohen had secretly put an end to all French army deployments abroad. She waited until all units had arrived on French soil for her next move, in late August 2022. At that point, she made official that France was pulling out of all acts of aggression in Mali, Libya, Afghanistan, Somalia and more. These military occupations were at the core of the islamist propaganda, ending them boosted her popularity among Muslims even further. But there was more. In the same speech, she announced that the whole police force would be disbanded and that the army was taking over policing until the new police was in place. People were jubilant. Thousands of citizens sat in front of police stations across France to prevent laid-off policemen and women from accessing the weapons inside. Apart from a few incidents, the military peacefully disarmed police officers within a couple of days.”</p><p>“President Cohen had invited Georgian experts to reform the police force, because Georgia had also laid off and remade its entire police at once, back in 2003. But even as the new police was being set up, right-wing extremists — many of them former policemen — took action. One day, as president Cohen was giving a speech in front of the Chartres cathedral, three shooters emptied their pistols on her. They were immediately arrested by the crowd, but they aimed well. Maraco sustained nine gunshot wounds — but none of them serious. After a few hours at a nearby hospital, she came back on stage to finish her speech. Religious fanatics, not a few of them members of right-wing groups, saw it as a divine intervention. With that, everyone — her supporters and her foes — thought she was invincible. The movement for change continued apace.”</p><p>“Before the end of 2022, she had phased out private motor vehicles and made public transportation free of charge, she had increased inheritance taxes, started a massive reforestation plan and outlawed advertising (“a net social loss”, she said). Crucially, she ensured that the key statistic to drive public policy would not be the growth rate, but the CO2 concentration levels. When a decision was unpopular, she followed up with another one. When opposition started to build up against her euthanasia plans, for instance, she made the sharing of cultural contents, such as songs, films and books, free for everyone — this gave her a popularity boost. And when a piece of legislation did not go through the first time, she kept pushing it until her opponents became too tired to fight. She was restless.”</p><p>‒ “So much changes, so fast! It sounds like what Trump did at home, except in reverse.” That was an American man whispering in the ear of his wife. He immediately regretted his words when he saw the whole American group looking at him suspiciously.</p><p>‒ “Yes, it was fast. Though it was only the beginning. The big challenge was the introduction of universal basic income. By early 2023, the new police force was in place. The financial and fiscal police, which had hitherto been made of two dozen agents, grew thousandfold. They tracked billions’ worth in hidden assets and tax fraud. Before she asked prosecutors to get into action, she toughened the tax code a notch, making sure that rich tax-evaders understood what was coming to them. They could either bring back their assets and pay their taxes or go to jail. Having shored up public finances, she introduced restrictions on capital flows and started to pay a small amount to all French citizens every month, promising them that it would eventually be enough to cover all basic costs of life.”</p><p>‒ “Wait, how could she restrict capital flows under EU regulations? Wasn’t that one of the core tenets of the Union?” asked a Chinese man.</p><p>‒ “Yes it was, but the EU had shown repeatedly that it wasn’t going to enforce the Treaties. Ever since most member-states had stopped respecting the Schengen Treaty without the European Commission sending a single letter of complaints, no one took the EU seriously. Of course, the liberal wing of Merkel’s coalition was furious, but the CSU and AfD were cheering. All over Europe, popular opinion was so supportive of Maraco that no politician dared going head-on against her.”</p><p>“The rest, as you know, is history. Popular pressure in Germany was so great that Merkel started secret negotiations with Maraco which ended on May 9th, 2023, when France and Germany merged and became the Magic and Federal Queendom of Europe. Wallonia, Brussels and Luxembourg joined a day later. The European Commission immediately announced that it dissolved the European Union, in no small part because its high-ranking functionaries expected to be offered juicy positions in the Queendom. How wrong they were!”</p><p>‒ “Why did they call the new state ‘magic’?” asked the Chinese man.</p><p>‒ “When you remember how close we came to war in the early 2020’s, what happened is truly magical, don’t you think?” I answered.</p><h3>Tuesday, 11 May 2027</h3><p>“Here comes our little Lenin cheerleader!” said my Ph.D. supervisor when I entered the cafeteria of the social science department at the Free University of Brussels. “How was your day at the Museum of the Revolution?”</p><p>“Stop with the cynicism, I answered. You know full well that the Queen is nothing like your Lenin. She’s younger, brighter and she’s no dictator. More importantly, she has no Stalin behind her and no Trotsky to spill blood in her name. I mean, you saw what they did to our military, right?”</p><p>Upon creating the Magic Queendom of Europe, Maraco and Merkel decided on a new flag. The blue flag with yellow stars of the European Union was hated across the continent, so they chose an upside-down rainbow flag as the state symbol instead, on which they added six pink stars, one for each federal subject: France, Germany, Bavaria, Luxembourg, Wallonia and Brussels. The military of the Queendom had been fully reorganized, too. The trucks, tanks and uniforms abandoned their dull dark green colors for those of the rainbow, with huge pink stars painted on them. More significantly, the military doctrine was dramatically altered. Generals took a hint from their successful adversaries in Afghanistan, Syria and Libya. Expensive gear was phased out in favor of light vehicles, heavy bombs were decommissioned, training in propaganda and psychology were reinforced. The Italian campaign of 2024 showed the superiority of the new reginal army. The legalization of cocaine in Europe had caused such a turmoil in Rome (cocaine trade was about 5% of all Italian wealth and the main source of income for the political elite) that they decided to invade and force the Queendom to criminalize drugs again. Within hours of the first movement of troops at the Europe/Italy border near Ventimiglia, hundreds of European soldiers who spoke the local language infiltrated Italy. Unarmed and wearing civilian clothes, their goal was to convince members of the military and their families to stop fighting and to prevent local entrepreneurs from supplying the Italian army. Within days, millions were marching in Italian streets to demand the end of the war. Politicians and generals had no choice but to retreat meekly and order soldiers back to their barracks. A military victory without a gunshot fired — that, too, was new.</p><p>‒ “Granted, the campaign of Italy was less bloody than what the Red Army did in Poland in 1920, my supervisor said while staring in his empty coffee mug. And I have to admit that getting rid of the senseless paperwork and the stupid calls for proposals made quite a change. Having direct financing for researchers really transformed this place. But all revolutions end up in destruction, make no mistakes! History teaches us one thing: There is no such thing as peaceful changes.”</p><p>‒ “Yeah, yeah, I’ve heard your rant before. If the current revolution were as bad as the Communists’, you would already be in a reeducation camp. Believe me, the Museum of Europe is no Lenin Mausoleum, and I’m free to tell whatever stories I want to the visitors. Don’t you want to hear the progress I made on my Ph.D. instead of complaining?”</p><p>I took a seat in front of him, under the neon light of the cafeteria. That’s when I saw them again. The two guys from the day before who stared at me during the visit. They were now sitting at the other end of the room, about forty meters from us, dressed up as university staff from a cartoon movie, with burgundy pullovers and dark green corduroy pants, and the same sunglasses.</p><p>‒ “Do you know who they are?” I asked my supervisor, hinting at the weird couple.</p><p>‒ “Never saw them, he answered. Why, are you getting paranoid? You think that they are after you? You know, ever since the universal basic income was introduced, the university is full of all kind of people, and these two are far from the weirdest I saw this week. Turns out quite a lot of people are interested in what we do here, in the end. You should see the enrollment in my class, I’ve never had so many motivated students! But you wanted to tell me about your progress.”</p><p>I started to explain my work. “As you know, I’m working on the effects of universal basic income on the availability of certain products and services. The first part of my dissertation is as good as done. I could show that the inflationary fears most economists had were unfounded. With their basic needs covered by the universal income, most employees considered quitting their jobs. Employers, faced with a potential drain of their workforce, had to find a way to keep their staff working. They could not increase wages and pass on the extra costs to consumers by raising prices, because they knew that the central bank was working hard at keeping prices stable. After all, too much inflation would have rendered the basic income meaningless. Instead, employers had to slash their margins, automate as much as possible to compensate the sudden increase in the cost of human work and provide much better working conditions. I found many examples of companies that ended up being run by employees directly. Because the value of assets nosedived in 2024 after the introduction of the inheritance tax, the concept of ‘shareholder value’ disappeared almost overnight. Business owners did not care much about losing control, since the value of their investment had plummeted already. The employers who remained were the real entrepreneurs, those who were in for the fun of the ride, not for the money.”</p><p>‒ “This all sounds a lot like the collectivization of the means of production, my supervisor said. I’ve heard this story before, I know full well where it ends. The USSR of the early days had plenty of idealistic young cadres like you…”</p><p>‒ “You’re missing a key point, I interrupted. The USSR and all political systems since the American and French revolutions focused on increasing production, as if the pursuit of happiness was equivalent to GDP growth! The logic of the Queendom is different. Our whole economy is directed towards lowering CO2 concentration levels, not towards increasing production. If anything, that factories and companies produce less is a <em>good</em> thing. Where it gets interesting is in the second part of my thesis. Many factories closed down or reduced production levels in accordance with the wishes of employees. No one mourned the disappearance of marketing agencies or private guards companies, but some other activities vanished from the official economy and were taken off the market. Quite a few producers of honey, vegetables or fruits decided that it wasn’t worth selling to supermarkets and traded much of their produce to friends and acquaintances, in exchange for other things or services. In just a few years, we’ve moved from a market economy to an economy of favors. As the value of currency itself started to lose meaning, people went back to a culture of exchanging gifts.”</p><p>‒ “You mean we’re back to a barter economy? he asked. What a great progress your Queen gave us!”</p><p>‒ “It’s not barter, I answered. You can still use money if you so like. It’s just that, as money stopped being a means of distinction — everyone now has enough to live and few people have more than that — many interactions happen outside of the monetary system. Many people could technically sell their produce or services, but they don’t see the point. They’re much happier with the social interactions they get from the exchange of gifts. This brings us close to the economy of the USSR in the 1980’s, that’s right. And this could become a problem. If you are not linked to the right people, you lose access to certain goods. I’ll focus my research on who is being left out of this networked economy and how we can remedy to the problem.”</p><p>‒ “Back to the USSR!” My supervisor started to sing the Beatles’ tune. “Even you agree that Miss Lenin’s policies lead us to disaster.”</p><p>‒ “Three things, I snapped back. One: Disaster would have been to try nothing. Two: Of course, the enthusiasm of the first years will eventually wither. Do you think Theodor Herzl would have written his Zionist utopia if he’d known his imagined country would be run by thugs who support anti-Semites just seventy years after it came into being? And three: Be careful about the tone of your remarks. I sensed a hint of misogyny there.”</p><p>Ever since the Brussels police had been reformed on the French model, the gender equality force was strong. Reporting someone for a sexist remark was no empty threat. I left wondering if I shouldn’t find a new supervisor for my Ph.D.</p><h3>Wednesday, 12 May 2027</h3><p>I spent the whole time in the train looking through the window and watching the olive trees that covered the hills. There were some good things coming out of global warming — and olive oil from the Belgian Ardennes was one.</p><p>I was traveling to an old friend of mine from my high school days. She was one of those who suffered most from the political changes. She was born in a family of modest means, did brilliantly at school, especially at math, and went into high finance after an MA in statistics. Before 2023, she knew that the hedge fund she worked at wasn’t a charity organization, but she told us that her job was to best allocate financial resources so that the economy would be most efficient. She probably knew that this was bullshit, but she made a lot of money and couldn’t afford to quit. The hedge fund closed its Brussels office a few weeks after the city voted to join the Queendom. She was given the choice to be let go or move to Singapore. She decided to stay, but had no idea what to do next. The whole banking industry had vanished, almost overnight. Money was now a fairly boring vehicle of value, not an exciting means of getting rich quickly. In Brussels, the glass towers of the Northern Quarter business district were converted to urban farming to take advantage of the comprehensive air conditioning systems the banks had built for their offices. All that was left from the financial era was a profound disgust for expensive suits among the population.</p><p>The hardest thing for her was to admit that her previous professional life had been absurd and meaningless. She knew, deep down, that hedge fund managers were not creating any value for society, but she could not accept that the whole industry could disappear instantly and, that was most cruel to her, that everyone would rejoice.</p><p>She could have applied to a government job like most of the Brusselites. International people like them were in high demand now that the official language of the Queendom was European — a language just like English, except you can use any loan word you wanted without having to use italics. It was more or less the language everyone was already speaking in the Brussels bubble. The shift from banking to government was too much for her, so she decided to take on the opportunity the basic income provided her, moved to the countryside and became a sewist — a portmanteau word made of “sewing” and “artist”. She made clothes.</p><p>I was visiting her to support her in her new job (I had given her a shirt to repair a few weeks before) and because buying new clothes had become much more expensive. The brutal increase in tariffs decided by the Queen meant that it was impossible to buy cheap textiles from Ethiopia anymore. People were now learning to patch up worn shirts and pants instead of throwing them away, and quite a few became tailors, seamstresses and sewists. I didn’t have much money to pay her for her work, but she wasn’t interested in euros anyway. Instead, I brought her two paintings that the artists of the Berlaymont were busy producing.</p><p>From the train station, I rented a bike (with a cart for the paintings) and cycled the last ten kilometers under the heavy May heat. She lived in a large villa with a dozen former marketing managers, bankers and salespersons who explored communal life in the hills of Southern Wallonia. They were mostly working on digital projects. When advertising became illegal, almost all American online services pulled away or were blocked. As a result, an immense opportunity appeared for European techies, who had to replace all the American-built, advertising-supported businesses with subscription-based European alternatives. Not only did this provide an additional source of income for thousands across the country, it also ushered in a new era of innovation, which had been killed by the Californian monopolies a decade before.</p><p>I met my friend in the villa’s garden, a large, air-conditioned container where they did hydroponic farming. She was tending to the group’s green bean plants, which were already ripe for harvest. We had barely exchanged greetings that she brought me inside the house to show me an e-mail from the reginal Ministry for Citizen Power that she’d just received.</p><p>‒ “What on Earth does that mean? she asked. Do I have to go to Munich and work there? I don’t even speak German!”</p><p>I read the e-mail carefully. After the creation of the Queendom, the meaning of democracy changed a bit. In the 2010’s and early 2020’s, we’d seen that elections were not exactly a good way to ensure that capable people would hold power. All over what was now Europe, crooks kept being reelected, parliaments were jokes where industry lobbies ruled the day and the executive power could do as it pleased, unhindered by any parliamentary control.</p><p>‒ “You haven’t followed the news much in the past few years, have you?” I answered jokingly. “At the European level, the legislative body is now made of 700 randomly selected people, who each work four years. You’ve just been selected to be a Member of Parliament, congratulations!”</p><p>‒ “And I have to move to Munich?” She was visibly distraught.</p><p>‒ “No, it says here that your first session will be in Munich, for two weeks in October. Because there’s no fixed capital in the Queendom, Parliament moves from session to session. You’ll get to visit quite a few cities in four years, I really envy you! And no need to learn Bavarian, the Parliament only works in European.”</p><p>‒ “Is there a way I can say no? I mean, I haven’t followed current affairs at all since I moved here, there’s no way I can write law!”</p><p>‒ “Well, technically, you can apply for an exemption, but since you’re not sick and don’t have a close relative you need to take care of day and night, you probably won’t get any. But don’t worry, you’ll have an outgoing Member of Parliament come here in a few weeks to help you get up to speed on what you need to know. And each session only lasts a couple of weeks, you can work from here the rest of the time.”</p><p>‒ “That’s it then, I have to give up on my sewist career! I guess it’s payback time for me, I’ll have to bow to the wishes of the Queen like a good serf!”</p><p>I wasn’t sure if she was joking or not, so I remained serious. “If you dislike the Queendom that much, you can find allies in Parliament and push for a vote to bring back the Republic.”</p><p>‒ “Well, I’ll see how much sense this Queendom makes and then I’ll let you know if I decide to write a new constitution. But how do we know that the Members of Parliament are selected at random? I mean, couldn’t the Queen pick the people she wants, including a token opposition made of harmless fools like me?”</p><p>‒ “No chance of that. The Committee that selects the Members of Parliament is one of the most controlled institutions there is. The code of the software that makes the selection is open source and audited before each selection.”</p><p>‒ “Controlled by whom? By the Queen?”</p><p>‒ “No, controlled by randomly selected citizens. For every position in the reginal administration, you’ll find citizens who check their work, usually by going on location for a few days each month. If they find something fishy, they can report it to the reginal ombudsperson or directly to the reginal prosecutor’s office. That’s what democracy is all about: Holding powerful people to account. The whole voting thing was the way they went about it in the 18thand 19thcentury, when they thought human beings were rational creatures, but research in psychology in the 20thcentury showed that this assumption was totally wrong — hence the need the Queen had for a new kind of democracy.”</p><p>‒ “You mean there will be no elections at all in the future?”</p><p>‒ “Maybe at the state level. Brussels is changing its constitution to follow the reginal model, but Wallonia is keeping elections for local governments. At the European level, the Queen has already designated her successor, so there’s no risk of a crackpot like Trump or Le Pen taking power via an election. The guy’s Günther Öztürk, who currently serves as the head of the reginal army.”</p><p>‒ “And when he’s crowned, we’ll be living in a Kingdom, right? And we’ll switch all the ministries’ titles from <em>reginal</em> to <em>royal</em>?”</p><p>‒ “No way. The administration has already made clear that the Queendom will stay. After all, queens have ruled kingdoms for centuries, kings can probably run queendoms too.”</p><h3>Thursday, 13 May 2027</h3><p>I decided to spend the night at the villa after we received a warning on our devices that the cyclone “Milton” was coming our way (cyclones were now named after neoliberal economists). It took some time to board up the house, safely store the solar panels and activate the back-up batteries, but we were ready in time. The storm was only a category 2, with winds under 180 kilometers per hour. The noise of the wind against the doors and windows prevented us from sleeping, but not from sharing drinks in the living room.</p><p>Damage from Milton was minimal in the village, but a fallen tree had blocked the train tracks, so that I couldn’t make it to Brussels before the early evening. On the platform at Gare du Midi, the two guys I’d seen at the museum on Monday and at the university on Tuesday were there again, starring at me as I disembarked the train. I didn’t have the time to confront them now, but this stalking couldn’t go on anymore. If I ever saw them again, I’d bring them to the police and file a complaint for harassment.</p><p>I did not have the time to confront them because I had a date. We were to meet at the football stadium, where the Magic Queendom was playing against Flanders. I loved walking through the new Remembrance Park, which had just been opened around the Heysel Stadium. The park was dotted with little white stones, barely larger than pebbles — 10 million stones, one for each victim of Belgian rule in the Congo in the past century. When you walked there, you really felt that the political wind was blowing in a new direction.</p><p>My date and I were comfortably seated close to the pitch, getting ready to enjoy the game. The pair Kylian Mbappé-Leroy Sané gave the Queendom the best attack in the world, even though the Flemish defense would give us a hard time. Ever since FIFA had gone out of business, collapsing under the weight of its own corruption, the European football league was pitting national teams against each other. People loved it and the Queendom had won every championship since the beginning.</p><p>‒ “I have to confess something, my date told me. I know you went to great length to get us these tickets, but I’m not really comfortable with public displays of nationalism. You know, half of my family lives in Flanders and they resent us Brusselers for having joined the Queendom. Without Wallonia to blame, their national identity is in tatters and their politicians make it up by doubling down on nationalism.”</p><p>‒ “Hopefully a more courageous generation of politicians will rise up in Flanders, I said. The Netherlands can’t operate their levees by themselves anymore. If they don’t want to flood entirely, they’ll have to join soon. With the Netherlands in, there will be no choice left for Flanders. They’ll have to either join Europe or side with the United Kingdom. Once they’ll have joined, they’ll be free to fly their Flemish flags as high as they want.”</p><p>‒ “And why would that be a good thing?” my date asked.</p><p>‒ “The European identity is nothing like a national identity, I said. The government actively supports regionalisms, in part because the Queen is happy to uproot the political class that was entrenched at the national level, but mostly because the European identity is not bound to a territory. Being a citizen of the Queendom is an act of loyalty, not of belonging.”</p><p>‒ “Loyalty to whom? my date asked. To the Queen, as in feudal times?”</p><p>‒ “In a way, yes, I answered. But when you pledge allegiance to the Queen, you really declare your support for the constitution of the Queendom. Having these ideas and principles embodied in the person of the Queen is just more practical for our human brains. We’re just not good with abstract concepts.”</p><p>‒ “How’s this pledge of allegiance any different from what they do in the United States, or from the nationalism of any other country?” my date countered.</p><p>‒ “In other countries, nationalism was really a codeword for ethno-nationalism. In Europe, nationalists were the ones who hated people of color and foreigners, among other things. Those who pretended otherwise, who saw nationalism as a positive trait, simply had no credibility. The administration was fueled by racism from the bottom up. Now that the laws against racial hatred are being enforced seriously, racism is on the way down.”</p><p>‒ “Really? my date said. I think racism was more a result of individualism. By having individuals compete against each other, you needed to find a justification as to why some succeeded and some didn’t, because our brains refuse to process complex explanations or accept that chance plays a role. Racism was the justification: Brown people had to be at the bottom of society and those who weren’t had to be grateful for it. Individualism — not the guarantee of personal freedoms, but the action of thinking in terms of individuals — was the problem. To me, the most important step towards ending racism was the announcement by the government that organizations should stop thinking in terms of individuals and start thinking in teams that should be representative of the people they served. That’s why every police unit must be 10% Muslim, for instance. I remember the Queen saying that she didn’t care about having the most capable people in her government if this government could not understand how the country was doing. That was the beginning of the end for the supremacy of white males. This idea is the foundation of our stochocratic political system, where representatives are randomly selected.”</p><p>‒ “Interesting, I answered. To me, it seems like the end of racism had more to do with the introduction of the universal basic income. Without competition for jobs, most people stopped having a need to see the population in terms of ‘us’ and ‘people who want to take my job’. Security and a higher sense of self-worth made it unnecessary for most to have enemies within their societies. And because we have plenty of groups to feel different from, starting with the countries that refuse to go carbon-free, we remain cohesive, as a society, without the need for a racial ‘other’.”</p><p>‒ “You’re right, my date said. The government also has good political reasons to eradicate racism. There are so many people who want to build a new society with us, so many people fleeing war or misery… We need to integrate them as fast as possible. Making sure that everyone’s cool with all skin colors is necessary for the Queen’s policies. She could not pull out what she’s doing with a shrinking population of racists.”</p><p>‒ “And the integration of newcomers does a lot against racism, too, I added. I remember how it was before the Queendom: people were expected to integrate themselves, which obviously made no sense as everyone living here was, by the very fact of being here, part of society! Dropping the neoliberal dogma of individualism, the Queen made clear that integration was something only society, and not individuals, could perform. She immediately prohibited foreign financing of religious services, which made Roman Catholic and Muslim leaders equally angry. But they regained their smile when she announced a major drive to renovate churches and build new mosques, as well as the introduction of theology courses at university for all religions. She made clear that Islam was to be treated equally to Christianity and that the state was going to have a say in the way religion was organized. She basically extended the German model — with the introduction of Islam to the religious mix — to the rest of Europe.”</p><p>We were interrupted in our conversation by the national anthems. The loudspeakers first played <em>The Flemish Lion.</em> A few Flemish supporters sang along the military march, but even if they tried hard to show their national fervor, their efforts were more sad than proud. They knew what was coming. Since the creation of the Queendom, our anthem was Gloria Gaynor’s <em>I Will Survive</em>. When the disco song blasted in the stadium, thousands started dancing, waving rainbow flags and, singing but mostly shouting, telling each other that they used to cry but were now somebody new holding their heads up high.</p><p>I took my date’s hand. This was going to be a good game.</p><h3>Friday, 14 May 2027</h3><p>I came back from the night at my date’s in the early hours. I had just locked my bike when I saw, on the doorstep of my house, the two guys who had been following me for the whole week. They wore long trench coats and matching hats, and already had sunglasses on even though the sun was just rising. They were profusely sweating in the morning heat, which made them half-menacing and half-ridiculous.</p><p>‒ “Hello. I’m agent X and this is agent Y from the reginal service for Special Missions” said the shorter of the two. In the Queendom, Special Missions was as close as you could get to a secret service.</p><p>‒ “I would have expected secret agents to be a bit more… inconspicuous.” I snapped back.</p><p>‒ “We’re a new service, we’re still learning the tricks of the trade” said agent Y.</p><p>‒ “Maybe you should stop using comic books from the 20thcentury as learning material, that would help.” I answered. “What can I do for you?”</p><p>Both agents regained composure and explained why I was a person of interest for them. “You know that Europe alone cannot win the fight against carbon dioxide. The diplomatic corps is very active in convincing other countries that they need to act. But not everyone is playing along. For the few countries that still run refineries, oil drilling platforms, cement factories, coal-fueled power plants etc., we need to go beyond diplomacy. We send undercover operatives there to delay the entry in service of some factories or decrease the output of some others.”</p><p>‒ “Cut the bullshit, I said. You want me to do sabotage? Where? Why me?”</p><p>‒ “We prefer to talk about carbon dioxide management, but you get the idea. We recruit mostly singles who have had experience abroad and speak several languages, people like you, agent Y answered. Your task would be to reduce the production capacity of the Hot Lake tar sands in Alberta, Canada. We would provide you with a new identity for the duration of the mission, lots of money and a lifelong exemption from military duty.”</p><p>Tar sands production really was an abomination worth fighting against. On the other hand, it sounded dangerous and the perks were meager. For one thing, I loved military duty. Once a year, we had to report for two weeks of military training. It was, of course, a great opportunity to wear gorgeous rainbow uniforms, but it was also a way to meet people of all ages from all across the Queendom and from different social groups. The least fun part of it was the sub machine gun practice — the army still needed lethal force, after all — but the rest was more like a <em>MacGyver</em> camp than a remake of <em>Full Metal Jacket</em>. We learned to build houses in the forest, to operate secretly in a foreign crowd, to tail people in the street, to drive off-road, to hack into computer networks… I didn’t want to give up on that. Travel to Canada was the only attractive thing in the offer the agents were making me. Plane travel was a thing of the past now that kerosene was priced according to its real environmental cost, and intercontinental holidays had become all but unimaginable.</p><p>‒ “What’s the level of danger for such a mission?” I asked.</p><p>‒ “Not every mission is successful, but the country needs heroes to …”</p><p>‒ “Oh, please! I interrupted. Will you give me real numbers or shall I file a freedom of information request with your boss?”</p><p>After a short lull, his colleague answered matter-of-factly. “We have launched 15,000 individual missions since 2025. 6,000 are ongoing and 2,000 ended successfully. You do the math”.</p><p>Playing Russian roulette was slightly less dangerous than accepting. After all, blowing up a massive tar sands operation with my own two hands was not going to be a walk in the park. But staying in Brussels and watching the temperature rise year after year, looking by as the category 2 cyclones became category 3, 4 and 5 wasn’t an appealing alternative either.</p><p>“Let me think about it.” I finally said, and I went up to my apartment for a solid nap.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8515bdbaaa2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Il ne faut pas ‘libérer les données’. Il faut se libérer par les données.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/il-ne-faut-pas-lib%C3%A9rer-les-donn%C3%A9es-il-faut-se-lib%C3%A9rer-par-les-donn%C3%A9es-869eb8d0998d?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/869eb8d0998d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[open-data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture-numerique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalisme]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicolas Kayser-Bril]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Sep 2017 14:46:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-23T14:49:38.679Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*jdlXBylQbO0JO8c16yQekQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>J’ai écrit cet essai pour mon intervention au Datarama de Nantes, le 20 septembre 2017, sur le thème des données et de l’éthique. Il a été publié à l’origine à l’adresse </em><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/se-liberer-par-les-donnees"><em>blog.nkb.fr/se-liberer-par-les-donnees</em></a><em> où vous retrouverez les références et notes associées au texte.</em></p><p>“Libérer les données”, c’était le slogan des activistes de l’open data, les données ouvertes. Pour eux, l’administration devrait mettre à disposition ses données afin que l’on puisse les réutiliser. Mais réutiliser les statistiques de l’administration, c’est se plier à sa vision du monde. Pour pouvoir penser librement, il faut surtout créer ses propres données et mesurer le monde comme on le conçoit. Il faut se libérer par les données.</p><h3>Le carburant de la machine à gouverner</h3><p>La statistique veut être la science de l’état, la science de l’administration. Et comme “étatistique” ne sonnait pas bien, on a gardé le mot allemand, Staatistik, en le francisant un peu. Avec la statistique, le gouvernement imaginait créer une machine à gouverner. En connaissant précisément l’état du pays, il pourrait réagir en temps réel et corriger les déséquilibres afin de mener à bien une politique publique. Enfin… c’était la théorie.</p><p>C’était la théorie de Vauban, qui, quand il ne construisait pas ses jolies citadelles, imaginait des moyens de dénombrer la population de ce qui était encore le royaume de France. Ce n’est pas la moindre de ses réalisation que d’avoir quasiment inventé, dans son coin, le recensement moderne. Son obsession à Vauban, c’était la croissance de la population. Plus un roi a de sujets, plus il est puissant, répétait-il. C’est la raison pour laquelle, dans sa <em>Méthode Générale et Facile (sic) pour faire le Dénombrement des Peuples</em>, il divise la population en trois catégories: Adultes, enfants et puis les “à marier”. Il va de soit qu’il souhaitait que l’action publique se concentre à réduire cette catégorie en encourageant les mariages.</p><p>Vauban est mort en 1707 sans avoir pu faire le grand dénombrement dont il rêvait, et la France n’a pas été le premier pays recenser régulièrement ses sujets (ce fut la Suède, à partir de 1749). Sa méthode, elle, est restée. Mais les trois catégories ne suffisaient plus. On a d’abord ajouté une catégorie pour les vieux, afin de pouvoir compter les hommes en âge de combattre sur le territoire. Surtout, on a commencé à trier les hommes et les femmes par année de naissance, dans certaines villes dès la fin du 17e siècle. Pourquoi faire des statistiques aussi précises à une époque où les trois-quarts de la population n’ont pas à manger? Tout simplement car on vient d’inventer un instrument financier : la rente viagère. Pour ceux et celles qui ne connaissent pas le concept, une personne âgée peut échanger la propriété d’un bien, dont elle conserve l’usufruit, contre une rente qu’elle percevra tous les mois jusqu’à sa mort. Pour l’acheteur, il faut savoir combien de temps, en moyenne, le vendeur va vivre pour être certain de faire une bonne affaire. Là encore, les statistiques servent un intérêt bien précis, en l’occurrence celui des milieux financiers.</p><p>En plus de servir les intérêts de l’administration ou ceux de groupes d’intérêts, les statistiques peuvent avoir un troisième rôle, plus subtil, qui a longtemps échappé à ceux-là même qui conduisaient les recensements. C’est Foucault (le philosophe, pas l’autre idiot), qui théorise le mieux la notion de savoir-pouvoir. Le simple fait de produire un savoir sur une personne ou un groupe permet d’exercer son pouvoir sur eux, dans la mesure où l’on forge les manières possible de penser sur un sujet. Ce n’est pas un hasard si les meilleurs recensements que l’administration a effectués au 18e siècle sont ceux des colonies. Les catégories qu’elle a utilisée à l’époque, de Français, blancs, sauvages libres, esclaves etc. guident la réflexion sur les questions raciales depuis lors.</p><h3>Instruments de pouvoir</h3><p>Pourquoi raconter ces histoires de statistiques sous l’Ancien Régime? Parce que les problèmes posés à l’époque sont toujours d’actualité. On nous présente les statistiques comme une représentation fidèle de la réalité, on nous apprend à les considérer comme étant neutres, alors que ce sont des instruments de pouvoir d’une force inouïe.</p><p>Le produit intérieur brut, par exemple, avec lequel on calcule la croissance, reste l’objectif premier de toutes les politiques publiques depuis plusieurs décennies. Ce PIB a été créé pendant la seconde guerre mondiale aux États-Unis afin de pouvoir mesurer l’activité industrielle et planifier au mieux la production militaire. Cette mesure est-elle adaptée à une économie post-industrielle? Absolument pas. Les activités financières, par exemple, qui par définition ne produisent rien, sont intégrées au calcul du PIB, mais de nombreux économistes y étaient opposés. Nul doute que, si les banques et les assurances étaient exclues du calcul, certaines politiques publiques changeraient du tout au tout. Même chose pour les fonctionnaires. On calcule le PIB comme si leur valeur ajoutée était nulle (on ne compte pour le calcul que leurs salaires). Est-ce correct? Si on leur assignait une valeur ajoutée, une augmentation du nombre de fonctionnaires aurait des effets statistiques forts différents d’aujourd’hui.</p><p>Les problèmes que posent les statistiques de l’administration sont bien connus. Prenez les chiffres de la délinquance. On sait bien qu’ils ne reflètent que les ordres donnés par un préfet à ses policiers. Imagine-t-on une seconde qu’il n’y a eu en 2011 que <em>13</em> fraudes fiscales en Loire Atlantique, comme l’indiquent les chiffres de la police?</p><p>Même chose pour les chiffres du chômage. Ils servent deux objectifs: Savoir quel montant Pôle Emploi va devoir verser aux assurés tous les mois, et communiquer les progrès du gouvernement dans sa “lutte contre le chômage”. Vous connaissez tous des hommes ou des femmes sans emploi qui ne rentrent pas dans cette statistique parce qu’ils sont en catégorie D ou E, ou parce qu’ils ne sont pas inscrits à Pôle Emploi, ou parce qu’ils sont auto-entrepreneurs sans activité. Et vous connaissez tous des hommes ou des femmes qui sont partis en vacances alors qu’ils étaient officiellement à la recherche d’un emploi.</p><h3>Données toxiques</h3><p>Bien sûr, l’administration collecte des données pour pouvoir faire son travail, pas pour aider les chercheurs ou les journalistes. Si l’administration est honnête, on peut utiliser les statistiques qu’elle produit en restant attentifs aux biais éventuels qu’on y trouvera. Mais parfois, les données de l’administration ne sont pas seulement de mauvaise qualité, elles sont toxiques. En janvier 2016, par exemple, Europol, le centre de coordination des polices des états-membres de l’Union Européenne, a annoncé que 10.000 enfants réfugiés manquaient à l’appel et qu’ils étaient probablement entre les mains de trafiquants. On leur a demandé d’où venait ce chiffre, mais ils ont refusé de communiquer leur méthodologie. Ils ont refusé car cette statistique était fantaisiste, c’était une extrapolation à partir des données d’Italie, où les mineurs quittent effectivement les centres où ils sont enregistrés, le plus souvent pour rejoindre des membres de leur famille ailleurs en Europe. Le chiffre ne servait qu’un objectif: mettre Europol sur le devant de la scène à quelques jours de l’annonce de la création de leur “centre de lutte contre le trafic de migrants”.</p><p>Les forces de coercition du gouvernement sont de grands collecteurs de données. Et ils font des erreurs. Massives. En 2009, la CNIL a vérifié un fichier du ministère de l’intérieur. Elle a trouvé qu’une fiche sur trois était exacte. Il n’y a pas d’erreur dans la phrase précédente: la majeure partie de la base de données était erronée. Et on ne parle là que d’une des 70 bases de données que gère la police! Non seulement les statistiques produites par le ministère de l’intérieur à partir de ces fichiers sont complètement fantaisistes, mais des personnes innocentes se font interpeller et éventuellement condamner sur la base de ces données.</p><p>Dans ces conditions, à quoi sert de réclamer l’ouverture des données de l’administration? Plus on en utilisera, plus on se recroquevillera dans le moule des fonctionnaires parisiens qui décident quoi mesurer et comment mesurer. Évidemment, ce problème touche certains domaines plus que d’autres. L’historique des précipitations n’a pas la même sensibilité politique que le nombre de terroristes potentiels. Et pourtant. L’administration Trump montre qu’aucun domaine n’est épargné. En obligeant son ministère de l’environnement à ne plus utiliser le terme “changement climatique”, elle met en danger les données publiques sur le sujet. Ce n’est pas en vain que les scientifiques américains ont sauvegardé de tout ce qu’ils pouvaient avant l’entrée en fonction du président américain.</p><h3>Produire des statistiques</h3><p>Certains diront qu’il faut se libérer des données tout court et laisser filer notre imagination. Manque de bol, si l’on veut comprendre le monde, essayer de se rapprocher de la vérité, nous n’avons pas le choix. En tant qu’humains, nous sommes limités par nos sens et notre capacité d’analyse. La méthode scientifique est le meilleur moyen de produire de la vérité factuelle et pour l’utiliser, les données structurées sont indispensables.</p><p>Plutôt que de réutiliser les données de l’administration, il faut créer ses propres bases de données. C’est seulement en développant une statistique en dehors de l’état que l’on est capable de mesurer le monde — y compris l’action de l’état — en restant indépendant.</p><p>Combien de personnes ont-elles été tuées par la police? Ce nombre est-il en augmentation, en diminution? Ne cherchez pas la réponse dans les données publiques, le ministère de l’intérieur se moque bien de savoir qui la police tue (en revanche, vous trouverez des statistiques sur les policiers tués). Ce sont les journalistes de Streetpress qui ont collecté ces données et donnent la réponse: 47 personnes désarmées ont été tuées. Et comme des journalistes ont fait un travail similaire à l’étranger, on peut mettre ce chiffre dans son contexte. 47 tués en 10 ans, c’est moins qu’aux États-Unis, mais seulement deux fois moins (rapporté au nombre d’habitants) alors que la France est un territoire beaucoup moins violent.</p><p>Surtout, l’enquête de Streetpress a montré qu’aucun des policiers impliqués dans ces homicides n’a été condamné. Encore une statistique que le ministère de la justice se garde bien de collecter. En Allemagne, des journalistes de ZEIT Online ont créé leur base de données sur le traitement judiciaire des incendies criminels dans les centres d’hébergements de personnes fuyant la guerre. Ils ont montré que les policiers et les juges ne prenaient pas souvent la peine d’enquêter ou de juger ces affaires, comparé aux autres crimes du même type.</p><h3>Les données changent les perceptions</h3><p>En créant soi-même des statistiques, on change la manière dont un problème est perçu. En 2013, avec plusieurs journalistes européens, nous avons créé une base de données des personnes mortes en essayant de venir ou de rester en Europe, <em>The Migrants’ Files</em>. Jusqu’alors, quasiment personne ne comptait ces décès. Un personne de l’administration française nous a même dit que ce n’était pas son problème car “une fois mort, ce n’est plus un migrant”. En créant cette base de données et en la mettant à disposition dans un format facile à réutiliser, <em>The Migrants’ Files</em> a permis, à une échelle très modeste, d’influencer le regard des institutions sur le sujet. Lorsqu’un bateau faisait naufrage ou qu’un homme se faisait abattre par des gardes-frontières, c’était une anecdote. Avec des statistiques, ces morts peuvent être contextualisés. Ils ne sont plus des anecdotes, mais font partie d’un tout concret et mesurable. Et c’est parce qu’il est mesurable qu’il peut être l’objet d’une politique publique.</p><p>Dans tous les domaines, des choses importantes ne sont pas mesurées et, de ce fait, ignorées par le gouvernement. En commençant à les analyser avec des statistiques, on donne aux activistes des moyens d’agir et aux politiques des moyens de mesurer les résultats de leur action. D’autres époques mettaient l’accent sur le récit. Vous ne trouverez pas beaucoup de données chiffrées chez les <em>muckrakers</em>, les journalistes d’investigation américains du début du 20e siècle, ni chez Zola. Ni même chez Engels, dans sa <em>Situation de la classe ouvrière en Angleterre en 1844</em>. Aujourd’hui, le besoin de récit n’a pas disparu, mais il s’accompagne d’un besoin de données. Et les exemples abondent de projets où des rédactions ou des citoyens nourrissent le débat public avec des jeux de données nouveaux et crédibles, comme les observation des niveaux de radioactivité de <em>Safecast</em>, ou bien les statistiques sur les violences raciales en Inde collectées par le <em>Hindustan Times</em>, ou encore le <em>Indultometro</em>, un observatoire des pardons présidentiels en Espagne.</p><p>Réutiliser les données publiques, pourquoi pas. Mais l’éthique journalistique, celle qui affirme que les journalistes participent de l’équilibre des pouvoirs, impose de créer et d’entretenir soi-même des bases de données.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=869eb8d0998d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What could Google do? (If it cared about journalism)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/what-could-google-do-if-it-cared-about-journalism-fd65b6fd9822?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fd65b6fd9822</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-news-initiative]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[google]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalisme]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicolas Kayser-Bril]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Aug 2017 10:51:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-27T18:01:42.121Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>I wrote this post on June 4th, 2016. I did not publish it at the time, due to conflicting interests. Now that they are gone, the piece is yours to read, in its original version.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*r24PCf67qe53ckw8dBi7ZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In April 2015, Google said it wanted to be a “friend and a partner to the news industry” (1). On that occasion, Google created a money pot worth €150m for European publishers, the <em>Digital News Initiative</em> (DNI), to be spent over a few years (2). The amount represents about 30 hours’ worth of Google’s global revenues (3).</p><p>Google also organizes <em>Newsgeist</em>, a gathering of European media people it invites once a year (Google pays for the conference room and food, but not for hotel or transportation). I attended the first two editions and, before I start criticizing, I must admit that the people running Newsgeist are absolutely great — they managed to set up a networking event no publisher or association had ever done.</p><h3>GOOGLE CARES ABOUT CONTENT — NOT JOURNALISM</h3><p>During the first edition of Newsgeist, a Google representative told me that it was possible to make money with journalism: “just look at the Daily Mail”, she said. Of course, anyone who has read the Daily Mail understands that such content cannot be called journalism.(4) The Mail actively engages in spreading lies and hatred. Unlike most other tabloids around Europe, it does so purposefully (5).</p><p>The Mail is only one instance of a media company aggressively producing content with a total disregard for facts. Government-sponsored organizations such as Russia One, the Hungarian state media apparatus and others are happy to remix falsehoods sent their way by the administration and publish them as news (6).</p><p>The regular publication of lies by established media organizations allows for the emergence of several versions of the truth, to a point where different categories of the population hold world views that are so different that any debate is impossible. (7)</p><p>If the consequence of publishing falsehoods it so huge — the disintegration of society — surely an organization that pretends to be interested in journalism would have thought about it. It hardly has. The above-mentioned Google representative did not make the difference between content, which is what anyone can publish, and information, which is the result of a journalist’s quest for the truth.</p><p>Indeed, Google has absolutely no incentive to make a distinction between types of content based on their truthfulness. The company can sell advertisements next to facts or fiction indifferently.</p><p>Despite this lack of incentive, the company insists it cares about journalism. After all, the millions it poured in the DNI represent a substantial amount of money.</p><h3>WHAT GOOGLE IS DOING</h3><p>The DNI is surprising, because publishers and Google both compete for advertising revenues. When a competitor offers to be your friend, one should probably be weary.</p><p>Of its own admission, the DNI exists to fund innovative projects throughout Europe and sees itself as a reunion of publishers which, alongside with Google, can discuss and find solutions to the challenges they face. The DNI is not an investment fund. Its role is to give away money and, probably, disappear.</p><p>Some publishers actually did benefit from the help of the various Google funds and much prefer this to Google investing in their companies. Many others used the money to fund white elephants that have no hope of achieving profitability.</p><p>European venture capitalists are notoriously reluctant to fund anything other than commercial services online. It’s not a surprise if, over the past 30 years, Europe saw no equivalent of CNN, the Huffington Post, Buzzfeed or VICE News (8).</p><p>In Europe, most media investors follow the strategy elaborated by French telecoms oligarch Xavier Niel, which he summed up in the following sentence: “When a journalist bugs me, I invest in his fucking newspaper and then he leaves me alone”. (9)</p><p>There are investment funds specialized in media organizations, most notably the Media Development Investment Fund (MDIF). This fund is explicitly not interested in “content” or in “journalism” but in “the news, information and debate that people need to build free societies”. In other words, it thought hard about its role and the impact it wanted to have.</p><p>I doubt that MDIF would ever consider a Daily Mail clone as worthy of funding. MDIF has an incentive to see the funded projects prosper in the long run, because its goal is to make money from its investments. To give a sense of perspective, the DNI is spending in a few years more than MDIF has invested since its creation in 1996. (10)</p><p>Google does have investment funds, too. When Google became interested in transportation, it did not create a money pot to give some money to Uber, some money to Lyft and some money to the New-York Transportation Authority.</p><p>It did not ask them to develop innovative solutions. It did not ask them to solve the transportation issue together. It invested massively in one project and actively supports it (it bought a $258m stake in Uber and added an “Uber” feature in Google Maps. (11) One cannot but notice the different approach Google took to European journalism.</p><p>Of course, a cynic could see the DNI as a way to neutralize European publishers and prevent them from exercising power in the only area they are still superior to Google: Influence on policy makers. Distracted by what is, to them, a huge pool of money, publishers are less likely to lobby governments and ask them to get tougher on Google (regarding its tax-dodging, say, or its monopolistic position).</p><p>But certainly no one would think that way.</p><h3>WHAT GOOGLE COULD DO</h3><p>At its most obvious, Google could invest in journalistic operations, just like MDIF does. It could create an independent investment fund. Google could also do something else, potentially much more impactful, and fund actions of journalism directly. Not projects, not companies, just actual reporting. JournalismFund or JournalismGrants are two examples of successful grant-givers that finance reporting in Europe using funds from (mostly American) foundations.</p><p>By having an independent jury of respected journalists awarding reporting grants, Google would ensure that more journalism is produced which is up to the best standards of the profession. The pieces could be published in any European news organization, irrespective of its size.</p><p>Funding reporting is straightforward. But Google could improve it significantly by making sure that this journalism reaches its intended audience. By providing a budget for marketing (on AdWords, obviously), Google could help these pieces of journalism reach an audience that does not read traditional news outlets such as Le Monde, FAZ or Gazeta Wyborzca.</p><p>A piece on the MNB scandal, for instance (a friend of Hungarian strongman Viktor Orban embezzled about €1bn and gave it to friends) (12), could be proposed to an audience that rarely consumes anything other than official Hungarian TV. A story on how Russia funds the Front National could be served to people who are likely to be Front National voters. (13)Most publishers are not interested in reaching out new, often unprofitable audiences.</p><p>But this is what is needed to counter the trail of falsehoods that are propagated by the likes of the Daily Mail and Russia One. Only Google has the power to do this.</p><p>Google could also require that journalists who are awarded grants provide good analytics reports. It could require journalists in the program to run A/B tests on their stories. It could require them to improve a story until the proportion of readers who read it to the end reaches a certain level. In other words, it could help determine which stories work and which do not. It could really improve journalism.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/what-could-google-do-if-it-cared-about-journalism-fd65b6fd9822"><em>blog.nkb.fr</em></a><em> on August 24, 2017.</em></p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_1">1.</a> Read <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/https://www.journalism.co.uk/news/why-google-set-up-the-digital-news-initiative-in-europe/s2/a564944/">Why Google set up the Digital News Initiative in Europe</a></p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_2">2.</a> Full disclosure: We applied to the DNI and did not get funded. So this might just be a rancorous rant. [That was true in June 2016. We thereafter were awarded a 50,000€ grant for the <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://offshorejournalism.com">Offshore Journalism Toolkit</a> project.]</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_3">3.</a> Assuming $75 billion in revenues, which is about right when looking at their <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/https://secure.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/GOOG/financials">income statement</a>.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_4">4.</a> The following paragraph is a summary of my ‘Ignite talk’ at Newsgeist Bilbao. The person in question also mentioned the Telegraph as a successful example, just weeks after Peter Oborne quit in protest of the newspaper’s censorship of the ‘SwissLeaks’ stories.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_5">5.</a> This testimony from a former staffer of the Mail in New-York makes this point: <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://tktk.gawker.com/my-year-ripping-off-the-web-with-the-daily-mail-online-1689453286">My Year Ripping Off the Web With the Daily Mail Online</a>.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_6">6.</a> Anecdotes on Russian media repeating the Kremlin’s lies abund. Here’s one on Hungarian media, for a change: <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://budapestbeacon.com/politics/hungary-state-media-hits-new-low-with-report-on-refugee-cell-phone/28322">Hungary state media hits new low with report on refugee cell phone</a>.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_7">7.</a> This point is well made by Caitlin Dewey of the Washington Post: <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2015/12/18/what-was-fake-on-the-internet-this-week-why-this-is-the-final-column/">‘What Was Fake on the Internet This Week: Why This Is the Final Column</a>.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_8">8.</a> Euronews could stand the comparison, but it was funded with the public funds of European public service broadcasters, not private ones.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_9">9.</a> In <em>Un Si Petit Monde</em>. Read online <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://www.monde-diplomatique.fr/2011/06/RIMBERT/20696">Comment « Le Monde » fut vendu</a>.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_10">10.</a> Read <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://www.mdif.org/about-us/">on MDIF’s website</a>.</p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_11">11.</a> Read at TechCrunch <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://techcrunch.com/2013/08/22/google-ventures-puts-258m-into-uber-its-largest-deal-ever/">Google Ventures Puts $258M Into Uber, Its Largest Deal Ever</a></p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_12">12.</a> Read more at Bloomberg: <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-04/hungarian-bank-owner-denies-special-treatment-by-cousin-matolcsy">Hungarian Bank Owner Denies Special Treatment by Cousin Matolcsy</a></p><p><a href="http://blog.nkb.fr/what-could-google-do#note_13">13.</a> On the topic, read Luke Harding’s <a href="https://archive.is/20170816/http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/dec/08/russia-europe-right-putin-front-national-eu">We should beware Russia’s links with Europe’s right</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fd65b6fd9822" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A search-and-rescue network, for news articles]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/a-search-and-rescue-network-for-news-articles-80c0dfca741f?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80c0dfca741f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[archive]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[censorship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicolas Kayser-Bril]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 01 Jul 2017 16:50:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-03T07:29:57.419Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Imagine being a journalist researching the background of a newcomer on the political scene. Now, imagine not finding a single negative article about him as you Google his name. Sounds far-fetched? It’s actually a very real possibility and it’s happening — right now.</p><p>In the last six months, as part of the <a href="http://www.offshorejournalism.com/">Offshore Journalism Toolkit</a> project, we (Nicolas Kayser-Bril &amp; Mario Tedeschini-Lalli) researched how accurate, legally published content disappears from the archives of media outlets in Europe. Our preliminary report is out with some suggestions on what can be done (find it <a href="http://www.offshorejournalism.com/">here online</a> or <a href="http://bit.ly/offoshorejournalismreport">download the PDF directly</a>).</p><p>Journalism may disappear for many reasons: court injunctions, data protection orders and, increasingly, lawyers freely invoking the right to be forgotten on behalf of their client. Every day, publishers receive complaints from people who request that an article be deleted from their online archive.</p><p>Many requests are legitimate, such as someone who was suspected of wrongdoing, has been cleared and wants articles written about the case amended. Many other requests are not. Men and women who want their past deeds removed from news archives do not hesitate to pressure publishers into deleting articles. While some publishers consistently refuse to comply, others do not have the resources to do so and remove content, in some cases up to a dozen articles per month, even when the articles in question are clearly of public interest.</p><p>It is possible that the next generation of powerful people will have cleaned their names by the time they reach the public eye. Holding them to account for past deeds might become difficult, if not impossible for journalists and citizens alike.</p><p>To prevent such a dystopian future, our report discusses how different, more liberal jurisdictions could be leveraged to save journalism at risk. Since big companies go offshore to minimize their taxes, can’t we do the same to maximize freedom of speech? We propose to make the online archiving of journalistic content much more efficient. Several online archiving services exist, but none focuses on preserving news articles. As a result, they rarely store the most important articles of a news outlet.</p><p>Publishers could archive themselves the articles that are under threat of removal, but this would be time-consuming and open a legal risk (if a court requests the deletion of an article, a publisher could be held in contempt if a copy was made after the legal proceeding started).</p><p>This is why we propose to create a standard that will operate like a search-and-rescue mechanism for news. A meta element (a single line of HTML code) in the webpage of a news article will act as the distress signal. It will indicate whether or not it requires protection. Publishers will be free to change the indicator manually or automatically (e.g. all the articles tagged with names of politicians could be automatically flagged for protection). In the role of the rescue boats, crawlers will scan news websites and send the content to preserve to archiving services such as the Internet Archive.</p><p>Such a solution offers many advantages:</p><ul><li>Instead of preserving content in just one service, the crawlers could send them to multiple ones in different jurisdictions, such as archive.is (Iceland) or Arquivo.pt (Portugal).</li><li>The meta elements could indicate a date at which the piece of content should be released in the archive. That would enable articles to be made public several months after publication, or only in case of the original article being removed, ensuring that the archived copy does not compete for clicks with the actual article.</li><li>The crawlers could also extract audio and video content from a page (including YouTube videos) and preserve it accordingly. To this day, none of the preservation initiatives deal with video or multimedia content.</li></ul><p>We drafted <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NGHamIQULs_PGYdRO8xYlnOsnbJy3m3zykYfIK8gDg8/edit#">an early version of the specification of the meta element</a>. We are now looking for publishers and news organizations to test this concept with us.</p><p>Contact us at <a href="/service/mailto:contact@offshorejournalism.com">contact@offshorejournalism.com</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80c0dfca741f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How we created “The Good, The Bad and The Accountant”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nicolaskb/how-we-created-the-good-the-bad-and-the-accountant-bad855ae36b2?source=rss-2aaf04bf11e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bad855ae36b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-corruption]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[serious-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[corruption]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nicolas Kayser-Bril]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Mar 2017 13:20:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-03T14:34:33.422Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We released a “serious game” about corruption that’s been quite successful. Here’s why and how we did it. But first, if you haven’t yet, <a href="https://jplusplus.github.io/the-accountant/">play it here</a>:</p><p><a href="https://jplusplus.github.io/the-accountant/">The Good, The Bad and The Accountant</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ujv1J7AS16ccthRCA8_8og.png" /></figure><h3>Before the game</h3><p><a href="http://openbudgets.eu/">OpenBudgets.eu</a> is a project that wanted to use technology to fight corruption. The idea was, roughly speaking, to put all budget data from all municipalities of the European Union together and then apply some big data mumbo-jumbo to find patterns of wrongdoings. Our job in the project was to “empower stakeholders with new tools”, which, translated from EU-newspeak, really means teaching journalists how to use budget data to write good stories.</p><p>As is often the case with tech solutionism, reality didn’t really match with initial assumptions. First, municipalities in the EU are so different from one another that putting their budgets side-by-side is like putting a hamster next to a dolphin and wait for them to play together: it won’t work. Ever. More importantly, corruption isn’t visible in budget data. It happens via networks of cronies, in cartels, in bogus calls for tender or in fishy lease-back deals.</p><p>After we understood this, we switched focus to teaching how to spot patterns of corruption. We were afraid people would be bored to death if we just talked about accounting terminology and finicky legal considerations, so we made it kind of exciting. In the tutorials, you’re not an underpaid journalist working for hours to get a story that’ll potentially lend you in court for libel (which really is our target audience). Instead, you’re a young, ambitious civil servant who wants to get rich fast (the tagline is “Have a job in a public administration? Want to make some cash ?”) And so <a href="http://cookingbudgets.com/">CookingBudgets.com</a> was born. Each tutorial is written as if it were a recipe, split in very understandable steps.</p><p>The tutorials won us praise but not much traffic (VERY little traffic, actually). Which sucked, because we’d spent months reading about corruption, and we thought it was good that journalists know about it too. After all, it’s kind of important. If you don’t know how corruption actually works, how can you spot a good corruption story when you see one? We decided to build a game that would drive traffic to our tutorials.</p><h3>Building the game</h3><p>We decided on a question-based game because it’s the easiest way to interact with users. At first, we just had one character making decisions. It was boring.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xF4t0-sQoizJF94s9f9yDQ.png" /><figcaption>Early version of the game, without characters (or design!)</figcaption></figure><p>So we added other characters to build an actual storyline. We added a mayor to give orders, a lawyer to give advice and all the characters we needed to create situations of corruption (the contractor, the football club boss, the university director etc.) We just had one problem: users did not read anything in the “help” section. Actually, they didn’t even see there was a help section.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/909/1*PLBFg8WvK1kzxP_K41YoHA.png" /><figcaption>Do you see the helper text?</figcaption></figure><p>We created a last character in the game, who’s the user’s assistant. She tells the user to read the explanatory texts each time the user needs to make a decision and explains why a decision produces a given outcome. That’s where the beauty happens: Almost every user now reads the explanatory texts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/712/1*U0YxM9yBi6AHYJx5XuWMYw.png" /><figcaption>Lia Brune is the one doing the actual teaching</figcaption></figure><p>For illustrations, we used public domain pictures and <a href="http://prisma-online.ru/">Prisma</a> filters. The result was so beautiful people asked us for the name of the artist who did the paintings.</p><p>After a lot of testing with potential users, we released the game and are quite happy. We received widespread coverage in France<a href="http://www.telerama.fr/medias/jouez-a-un-serious-game-dont-vous-etes-le-heros-plus-ou-moins-crapuleux,154794.php">: Télérama</a>, <a href="http://www.liberation.fr/direct/element/_58845/">Libération</a>, <a href="http://www.numerama.com/politique/237024-le-bon-la-brute-et-le-comptable-saurez-vous-resister-a-la-la-corruption-en-politique.html">Numérama</a> talked about it (and not yet elsewhere! If you’re a journalist working outside of France, get in touch: hi@nkb.fr!). Users spend over 7 minutes playing, on average. More importantly, we’ve done a lot to teach how corruption works in Europe. I mean, had you <em>ever</em> heard of an emphyteutic lease before — and how you could use it for personal enrichment?</p><p>Final thing: If you want to embed, adapt or translated the game, feel free to do so. The code is so well-done that almost everything about the game holds in a Json file. That’s right, you can use it to build games on any other topic if you want to. It’s open-source and <a href="https://github.com/jplusplus/the-accountant#embed">waiting for you on Github</a> under an LGPL license.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bad855ae36b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>