<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Nikhil Biswas on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Nikhil Biswas on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nikhilbiswas?source=rss-4d972669e585------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 03:28:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nikhilbiswas/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where did Mahatma Gandhi fail?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nikhilbiswas/where-did-mahatma-gandhi-fail-5928da6b5cf?source=rss-4d972669e585------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5928da6b5cf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nikhil Biswas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Oct 2017 14:42:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-02T14:42:58.224Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>148 years ago today, our father of the nation was born. But, however this day known as Gandhi Jayanti is being considered as a holiday or an extension of a long weekend as the masses have made it look like. The root cause for this day to have lost national significance wouldn’t be the reasons of his failure which I am going to outline but it still it remains astonishing to why this day has such less national importance. However, that is not my concern here and the reasons which I am going to trace out has nothing to do with why this day being merely a national holiday and not festival. Let us now look at the dark side of Mahatma Gandhi to which our nationalist historians have always thrown a blanket on.</p><p>Firstly, the principles of truth and non violence advocated by him made him world famous. But, in reality the non violent greed got better off the nationalist feelings which he exhibited. There are many instances to prove where his non violent greed made him to sideline the other nationalist leaders from the main stream. One example was calling of the non-cooperation movement(1920) in response to the chauri chaura incident where he went against his fellow nationalist leaders and even threatened to withdraw himself from the freedom struggle if the movement got non violent. This act by him brought a massive set back for the large number of people who took part in the non cooperation movement in a belief that it would bring swaraj in a year. But, in reality the promise made by Gandhiji to the people was broken. Prominent freedom fighters like MA Jinnah and Bipin Chandra Pal left the congress after they were dissatisfied with the decision making of Gandhiji. Furthermore, the non-violent greed of Gandhiji prevented him from supporting the brave freedom fighter Bhagat Singh who had given his life for the country because he was violent in nature. No wonder why Subhas Chandra Bose disappeared from the national scene.</p><p>Secondly, his principle of non-violence was a failure in itself. The notion that Indian freedom struggle was non violent is a myth because the principles of non violence had gone for a six. There are official documents which record incidents of burning of police stations and attack on European officers during the quit India movement in the districts of UP where Thana Jalao Andolan gained momentum. Mahatma Gandhi did not have the guts to call off the quit India movement like he did for the non cooperation movement which reveals that it was his non violent greed that delayed our independence and when he himself realized that non violence was a massive failure, he had no option but to continue with the violent freedom struggle.</p><p>Thirdly, the Hindu- Muslim unity which he advocated turned out to be a failure when the country was partitioned. In practice, the Hindu- Muslim unity was promoting Muslim fundamentalism by giving it sanity and respectability. What he did in Kolkata in 1947 proves it, where he took a fast unto death to save the Muslims from being killed by the Hindus in the name of communal harmony but he did not do the same in Noakhali where Muslims had attacked Hindus and by the time he reached there, the damage was already done. He could not bring the Hindu women back to the fold of Hinduism who were forcefully converted to Islam. Irony is that this attitude of his caused his death, where in he was killed by a Hindu fascist named Nathuram Godse who was linked to RSS. There are stories from Delhi as told by Nathuram Gosde where Gandhiji had called back the Muslims who were set to leave for Pakistan and on their return to Delhi they reclaimed the houses and mosques which were inhabited by the Hindu and Sikh refugees from Pakistan. This one of the reasons why he is called as a disgrace to Hinduism.</p><p>Fourth, Mahatma Gandhi wanted to make Hindustani the national language of India because he believed that it was a language that united Hindus and Muslims and and the people of north and south. He did not realize that Dravidian south couldn’t simply accept an alien language as their own and moreover the script which he wanted for Hindustani was Persian to please the minority. He also wanted to abolish English which would prevent the masses from making use of the benefits which English language provided and it’s ironical that he himself drank the milk of an English cow and studied in London but was not willing have this language in his nation.</p><p>So , these were a few aspects where the father of our nation miserably failed and the nationalist historians have hid this side of history from the popular writings. It is important for us to know what had happened in the past , embrace the past but leave it in the past not that one arranges anti -Gandhi rallies to influence the masses against our father of the nation. Equally important is to increase the significance of those freedom fighters who were sidelined by Mahatma Gandhi.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5928da6b5cf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The True Nature of the 1857 Rebellion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nikhilbiswas/the-true-nature-of-the-1857-rebellion-9f9be0d1fd5c?source=rss-4d972669e585------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f9be0d1fd5c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nikhil Biswas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Jun 2017 13:58:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-07T13:58:02.487Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The revolt of 1857 has been described as a great watershed in Indian history. The movie ‘Mangal Pandey’ beautifully highlighted the events of the revolt and to a large extent convinced the viewers that it was the first war of independence. But, however, it is far from reality to what was portrayed in the movie and what exactly had happened.</p><p>The nature and character of the 1857 rebellion has been subjected to historical debate among both the colonial historians and nationalist historians. The historians who have interpreted the rebellion as a sepoy mutiny have outnumbered the historians who have called it as the first war of independence. There are historians from the imperialist school such as Eric Stokes, Thomas Metcalf and CA Bayely who have refused to accept the revolt as the first war of independence. There were Indian historians like RC Majumdar , SN Sen and SB Chaudhari who went along with the arguments put forward by the British historians and refused to accept the revolt as the first war of independence. It is surprising to see that the movie Mangal Pandey neglected the valid arguments put forward by the above historians and labelled the revolt of 1857 as the first war of Independence. It is important to remember there are numerous reasons to prove why the revolt of 1857 was not the first war of independence and reveal the true story. Let us have a look at them briefly.</p><p>Firstly, not always the common enemy was the British. The Zamindars and the Taluqdars who were in the forefront of the struggle often fought among themselves. There was no unity among them and also among the sepoys as mentioned by Eric Stokes. Secondly, the rebellion was only limited to a comparative narrow region of India which included few regions of Central and Northern India. South remained aloof although mutinies broke out at Vellore , but, however it did not have any proper connection with the revolt that was taking place in the northern part of the country. Sindh was quiet and North East was not even aware of what was happening . Rajputana , Punjab and Bengal were loyal to the British during the revolt. Although the rebellion began at Barracpore in Bengal with the execution of Mangal Pandey, the revolt quickly spread to the states of UP and MP but to a great extent nothing much had happened in Bengal. The movie Mangal Pandey reflected events at Baraccpore that centred around the sepoy Mangal Pandey but in reality these events actually took place in the then United Provinces. 80% of India was not involved in the rebellion and it would be wrong for us to call it as the first war of independence.</p><p>Thirdly, the Zamindars and the Taluqdars who were leading the revolt were uneducated and did not have any forward looking program to be implemented after the capture. Fourth, the racial discrimination in the army and the rumours of cartridges was one of the few causes which led to the rebellion ,but, however it was not the root cause. The reality is that to a great extent the rebellion was elitist in nature. Eric Stones also interpreted the revolt of 1857 as elitist in nature by arguing that in many places the rich peasants influenced the poor peasants to join the revolt for their own benefit. The British rule hindered the interests of the Zamindars and the rich peasants who wanted to overthrow the British by manipulating the sepoys and the peasantry. For the peasantry , it would have simply meant that mastery of the British replaced by the mastery of the Zamindars. The war of 1857 did not guarantee independence for them.</p><p>Fifth, we have heard of famous personalities like Nana Sahib and Bahadur Shah Zaffar who led the revolt. But, in reality the level of patriotism among them was zero. We get to know about this from the writings of R Mukherjee from his book AWADH IN REVOLT where he pointed out that Nana Sahib of Kanpur was threatened by the rebels with dire consequences and only then he assumed leadership. The same was with the case of Bahadur Shah Zaffar who was taken by surprise when approached by the rebels and only with great hesitation did he agree to be their leader. As kids we were taught about the bravery of Rani Laxmi Bai of Jhansi who fought against the British in the 1857 revolt but the reality doesn’t go hand in hand with what we have been taught. MN Roy has highlighted that it was the peasantry who were manipulated by the Zamindars, threatened Rani of Jhansi with death if she had refused to assist them in the rebellion. Such prominent personalities were forced to take part in the rebellion and labeling it as the first war of independence would be an act of insanity.</p><p>Sixth, the educated Indians from the British presidencies of Bombay, Madras and Bengal who drank the milk of an English cow chose to support the British during the revolt of 1857. They felt that the British government in India was destroying the feudal forces and bringing in a new era of progress. Their view was that the rebels stood for the old order along with superstitions. Our freedom fighters who gave us independence also drank the milk of an English cow. So, it is evident that English language and education was a major instrument which was used in the freedom struggle. The credit must go to the British, who gave us the language that actually unified the nation.</p><p>Lastly, there is another group of historians who believed that the revolt of 1857 was not the first war of independence rather it was a religious movement. There are contemporaries like Syed Ahmed Khan who believed that the allegation of the mutiny to be a Muslim conspiracy. British officials serving in the north western provinces were convinced that the revolt had an Islamic character and not Indian. It was felt that the old Muslim elite had conspired to arouse a political rebellion among the masses. They regarded the rebellion to be a handwork of the Muslims.</p><p>So, these were the numerous reasons which reveal the true nature of the 1857 rebellion. However, VD Savarkar was one of the few historians who drafted the revolt of 1857 directly into the historiography of Indian Nationalism. He considered it to be the first war of Independence against the British. There may be one reason to prove the rebellion as the national war of independence but at the same time there are 100 reasons which throw light on the true nature of the rebellion. Therefore, it can be rightfully said that nationalist elements as a whole went missing in the revolt of 1857.</p><p>I’d like to conclude by stating that for a revolt or a freedom struggle to qualify as a national movement, there are two main criteria — (i) It should have a wider nationalist base and (ii) the entire population should be a part of it. In this context, the American War of Independence was a myth because USA was comprised of White Americans, the slaves imported from Africa and the native Red Indians but ironically the American Revolution sidelined the Indians and Africans. Moreover, the freedom struggle only involved the thirteen American colonies on the Eastern coast while the Western coast and the central region remained aloof. Like the revolt of 1857 , the American Revolution was also not a true revolution.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f9be0d1fd5c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE OTHER SIDE OF BRITISH RAJ]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nikhilbiswas/the-other-side-of-british-raj-e7e218eb3c8e?source=rss-4d972669e585------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e7e218eb3c8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nikhil Biswas]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Jan 2017 20:43:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-02T20:43:23.812Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>THE OTHER SIDE OF BRITISH RAJ</p><p>When one speaks of the British Raj, the first thing that comes to our mind is the exploitative nature of the British rule. Over the years various books and movies in India have always portrayed the negative side of British rule but how often have we heard people talk about the benefits of the same.</p><p>As we take pride in the glorious past of our Hindu and Muslim emperors who ruled the subcontinent in the Ancient and Medieval periods respectively by overlooking their exploitative nature, isn’t it wrong for us to only look at the negative side of the British rule. Movies such as Mangal Pandey and Lagaan have always portrayed the ruthlessness of the British Raj in such a manner that it will make the viewers difficult to accept that the British have done any good to the people of the subcontinent . Let us look at the various aspects of the British Raj which benefited the people then and it continues to do so even now.</p><p>First and foremost is the widespread usage of English , it serves as the global Franca Lingua and almost every nation is learning it irrespective of the fact that the nation is a commonwealth or not. All thanks to the English Education Act 1835 which was implemented by the British to promote the use of English in the sub-continent which replaced the old and dead language-Persian, as the court language. TB Macaulay system fostered the widespread use of English language and when Indian National Congress was formed in 1885, its founding fathers were a product of the English education system and it was the Indian National congress that sowed the seeds of Indian Independence. English became the language of the native elites and it is important to remember that English first reached India in Asia and then spread to different parts of the the continent. After India received Independence from the British , the govt was not keen in continuing with English and wanted to make Hindi the sole official and national language of the nation. This was met by stiff resistance from the non-Hindi belt particularly from Tamil Nadu. The govt had no option but to make Hindi and English both as the official languages of India. The states belonging to the non-Hindi belt were given an option to choose one regional language as their official language and had to choose either between English or Hindi as their second language. Not surprisingly, majority of the non-Hindi states chose English as their second language over Hindi. Even today English serves as a Franca Lingua in the southern and the north eastern parts of our country. If we roam across India we will find sign boards only in one common language and that is English. I almost lived all my life in south and hardly encountered any sign boards in Hindi there. All hail English. If it wasn’t for the British we wouldn’t have had a common language accepted by all linguistic groups but some might argue by saying that if India was ruled by either the Portuguese or the Dutch their language would have served the same purpose that English did and continues to do. I have a simple answer to this , we know where Portuguese stands and where English stands, the advantages that India receives as an English speaking nation couldn’t have been the same if Portuguese was the language. Moreover , Indonesia received independence from the Dutch way back in 1949 but they did not continue with Dutch as their official language and same goes with Vietnam where French language ended with the French colonial rule. On the other hand , these nations have started the use of English in education and it has become a very popular language ever since the end of the cold war so it can rightfully be said that we are on a deliberate advantage because of the English colonial rule which helped us to recognize the importance of English way back in the nineteenth century.</p><p>Secondly, the popularity of cricket in India is a clear example of the colonial rule. Cricket came to India with the British and it soon became popular but it is important to remember that Cricket was not the only sport that was introduced by the British in India , there were other sports which were introduced by them such as Hockey , Football and Rugby. All these sports originated in England and these are very popular in the commonwealth nations . In the recently concluded Rio Olympics, The Great Britain finished second in the medal tally ahead of China however the British never laid down a strong sporting infrastructure for India but India was a strong hockey team prior to the independence and won gold medals at various Olympics but on the other hand the popularity of football and rugby remained very limited unlike in South Africa, a fellow British colony, where both these sports are extremely popular. In terms of progress in Sports , India lags behind its fellow commonwealth nations such as Australia, New Zealand and South Africa.</p><p>Thirdly, the railways was a relatively unknown phenomenon to the sub continent prior to the British rule. The British laid down the base for the development of a modern railway system that took place in India in the post Independence period. There were almost forty two rail systems in India at the time of Independence and today India has the fourth largest rail network in the world. Many scholars point out by arguing that laying of Indian railways as one of the prime examples of British colonial loot but it is important to note that even if Indians had the wealth, they couldn’t establish a sound railway system at that time because it required the use of modern technology which only came from the west. For instance, in Thailand the only Asian nation that was never under any foreign rule had to wait until 1890 for the operation of their first railway line and on the other hand in India took place way before in 1851. There is no denying the fact British built railways for their own benefit which was mainly used to transport goods from the countryside to the ports but how many of us knew that first railway line in India had run between Roorkee and Piran Kaliyar to solve irrigation problems and during the national movement, Gandhiji traveled across India in trains to mobilize support and widen the base of the freedom movement. Not only this, at the time of the partition of India, millions were uprooted from their homeland and were forced migrate to an alien land. The railways played a crucial role in transporting the refugees from India to Pakistan and vice versa. All these activities took place during the colonial rule which immensely benefited the natives and had nothing to do with the Englishmen.</p><p>Fourth, the age old Hindu practice of Sati which was an inhuman ritual where women were burnt alive along with their respective husbands when the latter passed away. The East Indian company abolished this brutal practice by passing the Bengal Sati Regulation Act in 1829 under the leadership of the then governor general-Lord William Bentick. This gave a ray of hope to the Hindu widows to survive in the society and many critics argue by saying that it was Raja Ram Mohan Roy who was responsible for banning Sati. However , Sati was a practice that was carried out across generations and such a practice couldn’t simply be abolished by a man who exercised very limited political authority. It required the efforts of a very strong and a centralized empire that people feared which only the British could do. Although Raja Ram Mohan Roy played a vital role but the main architect of the Sati Ban were the Britishers.</p><p>Apart from the Sati ban, the British took several measures to elevate the status of women in the patriarchal Indian society . British took firm measures on the aspect of child marriage which was prevalent in the sub-continent for generations. The first legislation was passed in 1860 under which the minimum age for consummation of marriage in the case of girls was raised to ten. It is important to remember that during the ancient and the medieval periods, the education system always sidelined women and access to education was only limited to the male members. But this came to an end with the establishment of British Raj , when they seriously took up the issue of women education and the Hunter commission of 1882 supported the right to education for women. The Calcutta , Bombay and Madras institutions did not permit the admission of girls till 1875.It was only after 1882 that girls were allowed to go for higher studies. Since then, there has been a continuous progress in the extend of education among females. So it can rightfully be said that prior to the British Raj , the status of women was in an unpromising state and with the coming of the British there was some substantial progress that was achieved in elimination of inequalities between men and women, in education, , social rights etc.</p><p>Fifth , the contribution of the British in the field of Indian archaeology has been over the mark. Most of us know about the Great Indus valley civilization that existed in the sub continent and all of us take pride in it but how many of us really know about it’s discovery. It was done by Alexander Cunnigham who is known as the father of Indian Archaeology and was also the first director general of ASI ( Archaeological Survey of India). In 1856 , Cunnigham along with colonial historians and British engineers excavated the sites of Harappa and Mohenjedaro. Since then excavations continued and it was in 1922 under the excavation campaign headed by Sir John Hubert Marshall that the world got introduced to this unique Indus valley civilization. If it wasn’t for the British , this great Indus valley civilization would have remained unknown. Apart from the Indus valley civilization ,the British made major contributions in the discovery of many historical monuments and also recognized their historical importance. The British govt passed various acts in the preservation of historical monuments such as the Bengal Regulation XIX Act of 1810, Madras Regulation VII act of 1817 and many more.</p><p>Sixth, this is one side of the contribution which only few have noticed or have written about. The British unknowingly made a major contribution in the spread of Hinduism to overseas territories. During the nineteenth century , the Caribbean and Mauritius were a part of the British empire. The British brought a large number workers from the sub-continent as indentured labourers to work in the plantations in these territories. Over time the immigration of Indian workers gradually increased and the majority of them were Hindus. Thanks to this policy of immigration of workers by the British , because of which Hinduism emerged as a major religion in these regions. Mauritius, a group of Islands, located in the African continent has a Hindu majority comprising over 50% of the population. In the Caribbean region , Guyana which is a country located in the South American continent has a Hindu population of 25% making it the second largest religion in that country. Similarly the Caribbean Islands of Trinidad and Tobago , located in the north American continent has a Hindu population of around 19%. If it wasn’t for the British then Hinduism as a major religion would have remained limited only to India and Nepal. Every Hindu in the world can be proud of this contribution by the British.</p><p>Hence, these were the few factors that throw light on the positive side of the British rule . Like every other emperor that ruled the sub-continent had a negative side so did the British. But it will be wrong for us to overlook their positive side and focus only on their negative side.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e7e218eb3c8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>