<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Nik Proxima on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Nik Proxima on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nikproxima?source=rss-4033970f02ae------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:24:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nikproxima/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Reflection on Human Factors]]></title>
            <link>https://nikproxima.medium.com/a-reflection-on-human-factors-dde481f31b4e?source=rss-4033970f02ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dde481f31b4e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nik Proxima]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Jan 2025 01:08:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-31T05:54:40.111Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lMuZrUjwI23SnBoT.jpg" /><figcaption>Search and rescue efforts are seen around a wreckage site in the Potomac River from Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport on Jan. 30. (Mark Schiefelbein / Associated Press)</figcaption></figure><p>The modern landscape of technology, and the way humans interact with technology is complex. So often we take for granted how closely scrutinized the systems that govern our technological world are, the ways in which we can shape our landscape with technology. We, as a species, have gotten pretty good at this. Billions of devices, systems, relationships and more function every single day because they’re engineered to do so. Because we’ve put them through their paces, and ensured that at the end of the day — the product is designed to work. This is all well and good, but says nothing for one of the most complicated systems to ever walk the earth, humans. Humans are messy, complex machines that behave illogically, irrationally and outside of the value of norms we’ve come to expect, and we have barely begun to scratch the surface of how we operate.</p><p>As of the time of writing, it been 24 hours since a tragic mid-air collision shook the aviation industry to its core. American Eagle flight 5432 from Wichita, Kansas to Washington D.C and PAT25, a US Army Blackhawk on a training exercise collided roughly 400 feet over the icy Potomac river, claiming the lives of 64 onboard the CRJ-700 airliner and 3 aboard the helicopter. This crash ends a 16 year streak with no fatal crashes in the United States — an unprecedented milestone achieved through lessons learned in the industry. In the technology policy space, it is no secret that these lessons are learned through hardship, devastating and costly disasters do more to educate us more than systems testing ever could. From the tragic crashes of the de Havilland Comet, we learned about developing the very basis of the modern airliner. From Japan Airlines 123, we learned about the importance of maintenance and following procedures outlined by manufacturers. From the 737 MAX crashes of 2018–19, we learned about the importance of pilot training and how cutting corners leads to disaster. But what does the Potomac collision teach us? We are good at building these things, and nothing was technically wrong with either of the aircraft — as far as we know. How could this have happened? It may be time to look beyond the technical, and begin to integrate the complexities of human factors into our understanding of modern industrial accidents.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OiqojEljJ3l7AK8Q.jpg" /><figcaption>Boats search the Potomac River near Arlington, Va., on Wednesday night. (Julio Cortez / Associated Press)</figcaption></figure><p>Before we dive into the events of January 29, 2025, it is crucial to understand the current state of affairs. The aviation industry is at a critical point of stress. Airports are running into capacity issues, and airways are growing more and more congested. Runway incursions, which the FAA defines as an “occurrence at an aerodrome involving the incorrect presence of an aircraft, vehicle or person on the protected area of a surface designated for the landing and take off of aircraft,” are at an all time high — with several notable incidents <a href="https://youtu.be/mIiPt1YVkP8?si=0zhAas2fOOMuM7zW">nearly leading to significant loss of life</a>. Severe turbulence, the product of shifting climate patterns across the globe, has fundamentally reshaped how airlines operate, leading to fatalities in the air in the case of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singapore_Airlines_Flight_321">Singapore Airlines 321</a>. Manufacturers are struggling to keep up with demand, and face a torrent of issues from quality control, financial stability and more. Many of these issues are a product of human factors — insufficient staff, high stress environments with changing variables, and a disruption to norms that interrupts the “traditional” mechanisms of operation. The stage is set for disaster, and has been for some time. With all of these variables in motion, it has become a matter of when, rather than if.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*N3lNZgzBjpdbLhzx.jpg" /><figcaption>Boeing 737 MAX aircraft sit grounded at the company’s Renton facility following the type grounding in April, 2019.</figcaption></figure><p>The context of the U.S aviation industry is paramount in understanding the crash of AA5432. The last fatal crash of a commercial airliner in the United States, Colgan Air Flight 3407, took place on February 12, 2009 in Buffalo, NY. The technical rationale listed by the final NTSB report is that the Bombardier Q400 turboprop airliner entered an aerodynamic stall after encountering icing conditions, pitching up sharply and losing lift, before crashing into a house near the destination airport- Buffalo Niagara International Airport. The crew were relatively experienced, having well over 3,000 flight hours between them. Regardless, the accident claimed the lives of 49 onboard and 1 on the ground. But why had a perfectly functional airplane just fallen out of the sky after encountering weather they should have been familiar with? To answer that, the NTSB took a look at the conditions the pilots were in leading up to the accident. The report highlights the role fatigue and inexperience with procedure played, and underscores how degradation of performance and other human factors stressed the crew beyond recovery. It also highlighted a need for additional training and continued scrutiny on crew behavior, essential for managing a complex environment. The report does not place blame on Bombardier, the manufacturer of the aircraft itself, rather it closely scrutinized the systems that operated it on that fateful February day — a case study of a uniquely human disaster.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*aNZGWixSM9dgZ7Ae.jpg" /><figcaption>Flight paths of the helicopter and regional jet, with an approximate location of the collision.</figcaption></figure><p>This brings us to today, where the air traffic control audio and security camera footage of the Potomac collision is beginning to piece together a story of probable human error. Throughout the course of the accident sequence, the crew of Blackhawk PAT25 are instructed to fly under visual flight rules — something that is common for low level operations in D.C airspace. This is a challenging undertaking, and relies on acute attention being paid to all aspects of the system around the flight deck crew. The tower makes repeated checks to ensure that PAT25 and her crew are maintaining a visual awareness of their surroundings. On the flight deck of the regional jet, the controller instructs the crew to sidestep from Runway 1 to Runway 33, a tricky but not uncommon maneuver to help alleviate traffic in an already congested airport. It has been reported that aircraft lining up on Runway 33 are difficult to spot in low level flight, and the FAA has raised concerns about intersecting runways in an effort to reduce runway incursions. Throughout the night, pieces began to fall into place. It is not my place to speculate as to why the helicopter was where it was, or how it ended up crossing the flightpath of AA5432, but a likely scenario of confusion and disorientation ultimately led to the collision — resulting in the tragic loss of 67 lives.</p><p>The tragedy of this accident is not to be understated. For 16 years, the United States has faced a world where it has not had to contend with mass loss of life in the aviation sector. Regulations, policy and good practice has placed the U.S as a leader in modern aviation safety. How could it have all fallen apart so suddenly? This accident, and the circumstances around it, are puzzling, and present a unique set of variables to unpack. Starting with the technical, both aircraft were seemingly in good working order, and the crew of both seem to have been following instructions from the tower to the letter up until the collision. No mayday calls were made, and at no point did the tower express concern that the aircraft were too close. Everything was routine. What went wrong? Can we even begin to speculate? It is easy to point fingers and assign blame, yet another facet of human behavior when faced with extraordinary circumstances, but it is too early to know for sure.</p><p>During my initial unpacking of the accident, I began to consider what would be the most important data points that the recovery team would have to collect. To start to paint a picture of what truly occurred, I believe that the most crucial data lies within the cockpit voice recorders of both aircraft. While the flight data recorders will give us a picture of how each aircraft was handling, the cockpit voice recorders may paint a more telling picture of the attitude and behavior on the flight decks of both aircraft. Were the Blackhawk pilots distracted? Did the crew of AA5432 have time to react to their environment? All of this remains pure speculation until regulatory authorities can get their hands on the precious data contained within these hard drives, likely sitting at the bottom of the Potomac. This kind of data has proved vital in our understanding of past accidents, and presents us with an alarming statistic — as aviation has matured in its technological proficiency, human error now accounts for almost 80% of modern aviation accidents.</p><p>This trend is not unique to the aviation sector. We, as humans, are getting fairly proficient in producing complex systems. Several modern airliners have never seen a fatal accident, including the Airbus A340 and Boeing 787. We routinely send things to space, split the atom, and modify and splice the fundamental building blocks of life to further understand the universe and our origins. One thing we are not as proficient in is understanding our relationship with the things we create, a theme found across the broader sphere of technology. From the Titanic to Chernobyl, from biotechnology to the modern discussion surrounding A.I, we struggle to wrap our heads around all of the ways humans could potentially create a disruptive event of massive proportions. We struggle to understand the ways in which our own hand could shape the course of human history in totality. We behave illogically, we act in ways that our best models cannot possibly predict — which leads to a deep sense of uncertainty as technology continues to become a part of our lives. Now, I am not advocating for the abolition of technology in some sort of Butlerian Jihad scenario a-la Dune. However, I am calling for a greater scrutiny of the ways modern humans interface with modern technology, so that we may better understand future issues before they develop. What does this look like? That remains unclear, but there is a need for a greater emphasis on the squishy factors, the ways in which humans butt heads with the things they create.</p><p>Kai Erikson, most well known for his sociological examination of the Buffalo Creek Disaster in 1972, has long proposed a new field of analysis— the study of “na-tech” disasters — the confluence of humans and machines. In his book <em>“A New Species of Trouble”</em>, Erikson unpacks the ways in which humans respond to adverse conditions — from pollution to the existential dread of Chernobyl and Three Mile Island. He highlights the ways in which humans are still learning from their own mistakes, not in design but in the execution and relationships to — and hints at a future where such a thing becomes more common. As we navigate an ever more complex technological world, I am beginning to believe that Mr. Erikson is correct. Only days before, Boom Supersonic crossed the sound barrier for the first time, becoming the first civilian U.S aircraft to do so in anticipation of their future Overture airliner. What unique human-machine interactions could occur on such a cutting edge vehicle? How would that shape our future? The world is growing ever more complex in every sector, and we now find ourselves butting heads with technology in ways that highlight our own shortcomings, the ways in which the human element falls through the cracks. If we are to move forward as a technological society, then we must be prepared to closely scrutinize the human element of what we do and how it all goes wrong. The tragic collision of PAT25 and AA5432 is a testimony to the ever present complexity of systems, and the ways we are still understanding how humans fit into them.</p><p>So, where do we go from here? For now, things are returning to how they were. The airways in D.C are open again. Flights are landing and taking off from the same runway that flight AA5432 was just moments away from landing on. Recovery work on the wreckage is ongoing, a reminder of how fragile the human element in all of these complex systems are. Crucially, the hunt for that all important human factors data continues, a search that will shed new light on the ways in which our world is shaped by the dynamic and unpredictable behaviors that govern human beings. In many of same the ways in which Colgan Air 3407 was a watershed moment, AA5432’s crash will continue to inform our understanding of the human condition — and the ways in which our continued reliance on technology shapes our lives. Time can only tell.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dde481f31b4e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nuclear War Should Scare You]]></title>
            <link>https://nikproxima.medium.com/nuclear-war-should-scare-you-368132724bde?source=rss-4033970f02ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/368132724bde</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nik Proxima]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Mar 2024 23:16:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-01T05:11:13.053Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The following contains spoilers for Annie Jacobsen’s “Nuclear War: A Scenario.” Continue reading at your own will.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/831/1*QEEfgVtWygbr54LdC7So5w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Castle Bravo nuclear test, the largest test ever conducted by the United States. Taken March 1, 1954.</figcaption></figure><p>In Annie Jacobsen’s <em>Nuclear War: A Scenario</em>, the author lays out a compelling yet haunting vision of a world shattered at the end of March in the near future. It is an omniscient, prescient reminder of the world in which we live. It does not sugar coat it, nor does it try to hide the horror of a world so deeply disturbed by mankind’s greatest weapon. In pressing detail, Jacobsen explores the landscape of a conflict which reshapes every single aspect of human life, all happening so fast we can barely comprehend it. It so deeply gripped me, that I remained awake for hours on end, pondering every movement and sound in my home and wondering about the ways in which the world could end at any given moment, like a child waking from a nightmare. Yet, I did not feel this way prior to opening this book — I had considered myself fairly well versed in nuclear history, exploring the subject without fear or dread. However, confronted with this deeply upending reality I found myself asking why I had not been afraid. Why do we as Americans in 2024 do not fear the bomb in the same way as before — the way our parents and their parents did? That dear reader, is a question that could keep us pondering the policy and politics of power and control forever — but it is one I will explore in what little time I can secure from your day.</p><p>In Jacobsen’s book, the world comes to an end as we know it on March 30th on some unnamed year in the near future — with first a bang, then a whimper. World War III begins with the launch of a North Korean Hwasong-17 missile, a titanic, road launched ICBM designed to strike the United States at a moment’s notice — a Bolt out of the Blue attack. Interception attempt after interception attempt fails, highlighting the ways in which our systematic safeguards can fail us just as our politics do. Just when the world begins to brace, beyond the perception of the public — the Devil’s Scenario is enacted. A nuclear strike on the Diablo Canyon power plant from a North Korean submarine shatters the illusion of hope even further, spilling radioactive material across the West Coast in an unfortunate precursor of what is to come not in days or weeks, but in minutes. The world descends into chaos, with breakdowns in communication only exacerbating the conflict even further. The US launches a counterstrike, blindsiding Russia who are unaware of the true nature of the conflict. The Russians launch their own assault. Escalation continues. The last gasps of governments spell annihilation. The world is over before we can truly realize it. A mere 72 minutes from the first launch to the last breath of modern civilization is all it takes. The next World War will move quickly, and mercilessly.</p><p>Yet, we do not go about our days as those in the early Atomic Age did. We did not shelter in schools under desks, we do not know what to do in the event of nuclear fallout. We cannot remember what to do when faced with a growing fireball on the horizon. The term “Fallout” is more synonymous with a popular video game franchise than a substance which devours you from the inside out. Why? To this I point to the ways in which the American identity has changed since the end of the Cold War. Images of the Berlin Wall coming down, handshakes and signatures and a perceived warmth between former enemies have blinded us to the reality of a complex and growing geopolitical landscape in which it is no longer <em>just</em> superpowers that possess weapons of mass destruction. The field is far more diverse now. The American identity is a complex one, and one that cannot be entirely deconstructed in one person’s essay on the internet. But it is uniquely tuned to focus on one aspect of conflict at a time, in this case the perceived end of Nuclear Threat. During the Gulf War, it was oil and the power that came with it, the idea that a decisive strike could end the ways in which unstable governments loomed as ever present threats over the globe. During the War on Terror, again the idea of eliminating those who would do our nation harm remained front and center in the images we saw and how we as Americans perceived the conflict. But this has left us blind to the idea of the <em>implications</em> of conflict. We leave a conflict in the past, but the lasting impacts remain. The mycelial legacy of global disruption still remains. It is still within our capabilities, our playbooks, our global stage.</p><p>Such is the case with nuclear war, and the implications of a potential conflict are felt in every corner of the globe. As Jacobsen highlights in her book, the roots for global nuclear policy reach back to the labs at Los Alamos, as highlighted in the 2023 Christopher Nolan film <em>Oppenheimer</em>. The playbook has in many ways remained unchanged, as highlighted by Jacobsen’s exploration of nuclear war games throughout the years. It no longer lives in our minds as a new, Armageddon-bringing tool that threatens to disrupt our world; rather, a background thought, a blip on the horizon. We, as the average American, do not think about the 5,244 US warheads around the world. We do not think about the 5,580 Russian warheads stationed across the largest country on Earth and buried beneath the waves. We know, in some parts of our brain, that they are out there, all of the warheads sitting on planes, submarines and in silos, but we don’t think about them. Why is this so? Have we been so blinded by modern day that we have forgotten how far we’ve come? Moments like the Apollo-Soyuz test project, SALT-I and II, were highlighted as ways in which we could walk away from the threat of nuclear holocaust — and yet the collapse of treaties like Open Skies and New START barely resonate on the global news cycle. The systems that keep us from global war are cracking, and not many people seem to care. This speaks to the broader issue of global apathy, an attempt at understanding why we do not fear the bomb in a way that perhaps we should. The Information Age, a powerful and revolutionary era which presents immense human knowledge at our fingertips, provides us with all that we could ever ask for with a few simple keystrokes. But it also can consume us, dragging us down rabbit holes of our own focus, effectively putting the blinders on the rest of reality. The Information Age saturates us with stories, so many that seem so pressing that we cannot keep track of them all. Horrors beyond comprehension are relayed to our phones and computers from across the globe, and there is so little that we can do to filter it. A school shooting, a pandemic, a hate crime — all of these elements consume us and blind us. It can be inescapable.</p><p>Stories like Jacobsen’s, Dr. Jeffrey Lewis’ <em>2020 Commission Report on the North Korean Nuclear Attacks Against the United States</em><strong><em> </em></strong>and the recent opinion pieces in the New York Times on the world of brinkmanship should be a compelling reminder that this danger has not passed because the Cold War is over. In fact, quite the opposite — they are a wakeup call, a return to form in culture commentary that pervaded the darkest days of nuclear anxiety, a necessary reminder that <strong>this is now</strong>. The truth of the matter is, we do not fear the bomb because we do not see the bomb as relevant anymore. It is old hat, an old problem from an era gone by, when this is further from the truth. In the height of the Cold War, films like <em>Countdown to Looking Glass, Threads</em> and even Tom Clancy’s <em>Jack Ryan</em> reminded us then of the very real and present danger of full scale nuclear conflict, with stomach churning visuals designed to remind us of where we sat. We do not sit much farther from that point now — if anything, we sit with the clock closer to doomsday than ever before. The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists has placed the Doomsday Clock, used for 7 decades since the advent of nuclear weaponry, at 90 seconds to midnight — with the 0 hour representing nuclear armageddon. This is closer than at any point in history. Ever. In an age when the world viewed the Cold War as over, how can this be? How have we failed to notice the world moving in this direction? So often, the answer is swept under the rug and poorly understood, and fueled by the apathy found in the Information Age. We do not have the bandwidth to understand the ways in which the world is constantly shifting. There is a great perception that the Cold War was won, when in reality the power simply changed hands. There was no great stop to escalation and brinkmanship, it now exists in different forms, a constantly mutating organism within human culture. If we are to continue to function on planet Earth, we must confront this reality and have difficult conversations about the ways in which we govern ourselves and our actions.</p><p>Jacobsen highlights that deterrence works until it doesn’t, that systems work until they don’t. Our safeguards, designed to ensure something like the scenario highlighted in this book never happens, could all be for nought if we let it. Everything that is in place to protect us could break down in 72 minutes, until there is nothing left but basic human instinct. It is an alarming thought, but a relevant one. We live in a world that is governed by unstable forces; proxy wars, AI, climate change and more are threatening to reshape the landscape of our reality every day. At any moment, the very structure of our systems could change or fail — just as they do in Jacobsen’s text. It is why we must keep these ideas in our mind, not to scare us but to remind us that we can work for a better world, a world in which nuclear armageddon is treated as unacceptable. To do this, we must be bold — to tell the tough stories of “what ifs” and highlight the ways conflict has had a lasting legacy around the globe. We must pay close attention to the ways in which past actions remain ever present today, and to work for a future in which we consider our moves very carefully. This is, of course, a tall order. Dear reader, if you came to this essay expecting some sort of comfort or reassurance, you will sadly not find it here — I aim to highlight these elements of our world because they are so jarring. The world is a scary, unstable place, and we deserve a chance to talk about it — bluntly. Books like Jacobsen’s do just that, in ever present and gory details. In a constantly changing world, we must continue to highlight the various paths our species could take, the good, the bad and the monstrous.</p><p>There is no one solution to this problem — and certainly not one that I can provide for you here today. I am, after all, one person on the internet with a limited understanding of the complex systems at play. But I come to this space with a reminder that while we should be afraid, the first step to understanding our modern world is to examine it; to break down our complex network of human systems to the best of our ability in an attempt to understand how and why we are here. We must continue to produce books and other forms of media, literature informed by reality, that highlight the processes of what is happening now and what is to come. What <em>might</em> come. And, most importantly, we must not give in to apathy, and remain ever vigilant. We must pay attention to the world around us, and even though it is hard we must not look away from the reality of our ever changing landscape. The monsters of our day and age grow ever more powerful when they are left unchecked. It is crucial now more than ever to advocate for a better world through the exploration of <em>all</em> of our possible worlds. That is the power of informed literature, to alert us to the pressing dangers of reality. In 1962, Rachel Carson’s <em>Silent Spring</em> painted an eerie vision of the future in which birds no longer sang, and the natural world grew quieter as it withered away. Through this, she became instrumental in highlighting the shortcomings in environmental protections that plagued the United States, and helped to give rise to a climate movement that is still going strong today. Books like Jacobsen’s, Lewis’ and more explore these plausible realities and highlight the flaws in our systems, just as Carson did then.</p><p>So then, where does this leave us? The threat of nuclear war remains as present as ever, a reminder of our own mortality and the fragility of life on this planet. We exist in our dynamic, unstable world — a world governed by factors that threaten to make the loudest voices feel small. But the conversations that awaken us to our own shortcomings are starting again, and getting louder — a reminder that we can arrest the fall and potentially pull ourselves back from the brink of destruction should we be open to having these hard discussions. The fear that used to grip us does not have to control us, rather guide us towards a path in which we do not walk down that road filled with nuclear devastation. We fear the dark because of what could lie within it, and there is nothing darker than a world encased in nuclear winter.</p><p>Read this book. Confront the monster. Perhaps then we can work towards something better and brighter.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=368132724bde" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Go South — Space, Anxiety and Identity]]></title>
            <link>https://nikproxima.medium.com/to-go-south-space-anxiety-and-identity-235affe3541c?source=rss-4033970f02ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/235affe3541c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nik Proxima]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Dec 2023 12:32:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-10T16:04:34.027Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>To Go South — Space, Anxiety and Identity</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tshC-9jE6ZHJjaBf2ZgDKA.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you are like me, and you pay a lot of attention to space and the aviation industry, or you’ve been to Disney World recently, we can agree on one thing — Orlando International Airport is a labyrinthine hellscape to arrive in. The lines for the bathroom are always long, security is a nightmare, and trying to find your friends who have graciously arranged to pick you up is a borderline impossible task. However, there lies a sense of excitement and joy about the smell of the floor polish, the ride on the tram to the main terminal, and the first palm trees you see on the taxiway. It is a new place, a novel place that is so incredibly emblematic of the voyage ahead — an all too different reality. However frustrated I may be externally, however much I grumble and complain about the nature of my voyage, the cause of my delay, I am always grateful for this monument to patience. It is a gateway to a new place, an unfamiliar place away from my suburban Washington DC home — one where excitement sits lurking around every corner. Every time I travel there, I am reminded of the challenges ahead of me, and the obstacles I have overcome to get there — this strange transition period that I loathe outwardly coming to be something of a ritual, a place I pass through with grace and poise.</p><p>I voyage through here often as a reporter, dedicated to covering the insanely complex goings on of the space program. From commercial launches, to cargo resupply, to crews going to the International Space Station and beyond — the Space Coast of Florida has it all, and the party has only just begun. My list of events to cover next year is already long as 2024 shapes up to be a huge year in spaceflight, with the tenuous promise of humans returning to the moon in December on Artemis II. There was some degree of anxiety I experienced when I first stepped on the plane to go to the Space Coast — A wandering sense of dread that I was way out of my depth. This is normal for someone like me, I suppose — I often second guess myself and worry about things outside of my control. Being a naturally anxious person sometimes doesn’t mesh well with a profession spent covering razor thin margins and high risk environments. But that particular anxiety has started to pass, and in its place comes an enthusiasm for the industry that I don’t think will ever leave me — nor do I ever want it to.</p><p>My time spent covering such incredible events, whether it be rocket launches or conversations with the incredible people involved in the business, always manages to inspire me. The location, of course, is beyond compare. The iconic Vehicle Assembly Building, one of the largest buildings on Earth, looms over the press site — the NASA “meatball” insignia reminding you of the incredible history of this locale. Just 3 miles away sit Pads 39A and B, where the Apollo astronauts set off to the moon, and from where the Artemis astronauts will soon follow. For the launch of CRS-29 in early November, a cargo resupply mission to the International Space Station, my colleague D. Wise and I spent several hours conversing with researchers and mission leads on the various instruments heading to space that evening — an opportunity I wouldn’t pass up for the world. These men and women put their heart and soul into these payloads, and the excitement for them to fly is palpable. To hear their excitement, and then get to see the look on their faces when the mission leaves the ground is something I cannot ever forget. During this launch campaign, I spent a good deal of time with my colleague and friend Brandon Berkoff, a relative newcomer to our team. CRS-29, as it happened, was his first “on-site” launch — the first time he had ever seen the VAB up close. The moment that sticks with me, more than any of that incredibly beautiful launch, was watching the look on his face as the iconic countdown clock began to count up — signaling that the rocket we had been staring at and framing in our cameras for hours on end was well on its way. A picture perfect end to a picture perfect launch day.</p><p>It is not always a walk in the park, however. As powerful as these machines are, they are still privy to the things that govern us here on Earth. During my trip to Florida for the launch of Psyche, we sat dejected the night before launch as the mission team announced a 24 hour delay — something that threatened to spill into the following days. It was time I did not have, I had to return to Washington to be at an important function, and every hour was spent checking and rechecking the forecast. This mission itself was on a ticking timetable — the interplanetary window that the spacecraft had to meet in order to rendezvous with the asteroid of its namesake was running out, threatening the very survival of the already-late mission. Wednesday, October 11 turned into Thursday, and my Space Scout team and I sat inside as rain and wind slammed the space coast — powerless to change what the planet had in store. I remember a frank conversation with my team the night before we were next expecting a window — either we would go or we wouldn’t, and we would take whatever steps were needed from there. I fell asleep staring down the barrel of a 60% chance for flight, not great numbers by any means. However, in an act of kindness, the universe had decided we’d had enough suffering. The next morning, I woke up to what felt like the most incredible news of my entire life — my lead photographer, David Diebold, shouting across the house that our odds for flight had jumped to 85%. <em>My god</em>, I thought, desperately attempting to get my gear in order, <em>it’s go time</em>.</p><p>Our drive to the press site on the morning of Friday, October 13th was a pre-planned affair, cameras were loaded, placements were discussed, and the coordination of our on and off site team members was done in frantic phone calls and texts. I would find myself eventually apologizing to my colleagues for coming across as too formal and stuffy, something they all would laugh off later. Perhaps it was the Washingtonian in me. We arrived at the press site with several hours to spare, watching the clouds as they ebbed and flowed in the Florida skies. At 8am, the heat was already oppressive, and myself and my crew were running low on water quickly. My shirt clung to me as I sweat in the 85 degree heat, with temperatures continuing to rise. An hour out from launch, concerns over our cameras overheating as they baked in the sun would soon become our primary issue; I found myself pacing across the press site feeling helpless. Everyone else was focused; the roar of helicopters drowning out my anxieties. I wondered how anyone could focus in a place like this. But the count continued, we persevered, and milestone after milestone was passed. We were committed now, as the GO/NO GO poll was conducted, and the spacecraft switched to internal power. I remember myself shaking, just staring at this rocket out on the pad, knowing how close I had been to it just days prior. The minutes turned to seconds, and the seconds turned to 0. After days of delays, anxiety, and bad weather — the spacecraft lifted off, riding atop its Falcon Heavy launch vehicle towards an encounter with a strange metal world. I remember just watching it through the viewfinder of David’s camera as I hand tracked it, focused on the job at hand— and then remembering to view it with my own two eyes, a spectacle of such epic proportions. All of that fear, all of that dread had culminated in this incredible moment — a victorious climb to the stars.</p><p>It is very easy when things go well to forget how cruel the rest of the world can be, something that I see when I step away from this fantastical world of science and exploration. There is a deep set anxiety, one that lingers with me every time I make the trip to this strange and exciting place, one that isn’t so easily alleviated by reports of a healthy rocket, good orbital insertion or clear weather. Over the last several years, American politics has taken a divisive turn — with states enacting policies that aim to stamp out identities that don’t align with the values of those in government. It is, in many ways, an all out assault on human rights — a political machine designed to paint LGBTQ people as the enemy, as a target for violence and more. Florida is no exception to this, leading the charge with a slate of anti-LGBTQ bills that several states have imitated. Titusville and Port Canaveral, both of the major cities immediately surrounding the Space Coast, are deeply red — and are no stranger to this kind of discriminatory policy. It is enough to drive many away, and yet, I swallow this fear every time I step off the plane, or get out of my car. Because I am not doing this alone.</p><p>Rolling onto the press site, I have no fear. I do not feel shame for who I am, I do not dread the outcome of being myself in this environment. I am lucky enough to be surrounded in the press corps by those who I consider dear friends, and individuals who would stand by me no matter what. My team at Space Scout is composed of wonderful people from all walks of life, who have lived experiences so different from my own and have perspectives that I value in all settings. They are always there to alleviate fears and to explore new horizons together, making such incredible memories in the process. We are, in many senses, each other’s support network — a robust and reliable framework that keeps us safe and happy. And believe me, I know that not everyone has it this easy, that not everyone can escape these deep seated fears. I am immensely lucky that my team, and by extension the institutions that I work with, are dedicated to doing what they can to protect the rights of those who interface with them. It is a tremendous privilege to be around people who are so different from me, and have lived such incredibly unique lives. These differences make us unique, I think — we are a team comprised of dissimilar minds and stories, dedicated to covering these incredible feats of human achievement. It is for that reason I have never felt scared, whether it be in Florida or Utah or wherever this career may take me, because I have colleagues who I know would do everything they could to vouch for me. Even the people who aren’t on my team the people who work hand in hand with us I consider my dear friends — and I know they would do all they could for me.</p><p>It, in many ways, is the same effort which empowers my team and colleagues that drives space exploration. People from all walks of life coming together to overcome tremendous odds, work in hostile conditions, to accomplish a monumentally important task — document the world around us. We, as journalists, are responsible for telling the stories that need to be told and capturing the images that define us. It is in this same spirit that we as members of the press come together to support one another, to vouch for one another and act as members of a cohesive community. I have never felt ashamed of who I am when I am working, I have only felt the support and appreciation of everyone I have met. It is a strange field to be in, one that sees you pressed against a razors edge of science and innovation — yet still so uniquely human. It is that humanity that I seek in all of this, an element of humanity so committed to overcoming our differences, adversity and pushing us further — empowering us to be the best versions of ourselves that we can be. I am yet to watch the launch of a crew in person, but I know that I will be watching them with the same excitement, admiration and joy that I feel when I am with my team. The flame that resides within the hearts of astronauts, pushing them to accomplish such incredible things, is mirrored in the hearts of those who want to tell their stories — showcasing just how incredible humanity can be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=235affe3541c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Bennu and Back, a Personal Voyage]]></title>
            <link>https://nikproxima.medium.com/to-bennu-and-back-a-personal-voyage-d54ce8f7a02e?source=rss-4033970f02ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d54ce8f7a02e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nik Proxima]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Nov 2023 00:56:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-06T03:08:12.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/776/0*KCyHa7xeCf56Q0FG" /><figcaption>Principle Investigator Dante Lauretta exits the recovery helicopter, victorious. Credit: Matt Dahle, Space Scout</figcaption></figure><p>Today, in a rare moment of free time, I went and spent an hour in a museum. The Smithsonian’s Museum of Natural History has, for a long time, been a place where I’ve come to marvel at the wonders of our world — a place that shaped my long standing appreciation for science and technology. But today, I went to see a visitor from another world, a visitor who in many ways I had already met a few months prior — a piece of the asteroid Bennu, delivered to Earth by NASA’s OSIRIS-REx spacecraft.</p><p>I remember how cold it was that morning, deep in the salt flats of Utah, away from the lights and bustle of Salt Lake City. September in the desert is not always the kindest, it can be 80ºF or 30ºF all on the same day. It felt so alien, yet, somehow right for a pinpoint landing from deep space. My photographer Matt and I left the sprawling suburbs behind as we wove through the mountains and brine filled pools, singing along to music we had discovered a mutual interest in. The dark voids of landforms stood over us as we negotiated the twisting freeways, soon spitting us onto a two lane highway. We spent an hour and a half on our drive, checking and rechecking NASA’s Twitter for information about the mission until my cell service was reduced to one bar. There was a degree of confidence not found in rocket launches present that morning. We’d both covered launches in the past, and were acutely aware of the sensitivity of these great machines. Delays are the name of the game, but not today. This was happening, and we were powerless to stop it should anything go wrong.</p><p>The road we had taken through the inky expanse was narrow and dark, not a light to be seen. Only the ever dimming glow of the city we had left behind, and the ever brightening stars above us. We tried our best to pick out constellations and planets, craning our necks to see through the windshield. It was an alien world, and we were diving head first into it. There are no lights welcoming you to a military proving ground, only signs for you to stay away. Dugway is not exactly a friendly place, a complex and deeply secure military base lodged in the hostile flat expanse of the desert. Every element of our arrival was strange, the friendly welcome of NASA and University of Arizona officials contrasted strongly by the Army personnel. I can only imagine how strange it would have been for the staff of this isolated facility, watching a gaggle of press officials descending upon them.</p><p>As we filed in, through checkpoint after checkpoint, we found ourselves cemented in the thick of it. Officials from NASA, Dugway and UofA were eagerly counting off milestones. The spacecraft, having deposited its precious cargo, conducted its diversion maneuver as we sat on the dark and cold bus out the press site — truly alone. The spacecraft was off on the next part of its grand adventure, an exploration of the asteroid Apophis. But we were alone, just like those precious samples hanging over our heads. The press site was still dark when we arrived there, floodlights from the airfield bathing it in an eerie artificial glow as the sun threatened to creep over the distant mountains. Matt and I were quick to scour the place for a cup of coffee. The press tent was warm, warm enough to threaten to lull you to sleep — but there was too much excitement in the air. We were here, where we were meant to be, and those samples were coming. The flight line was adorned with helicopters, sleeping beasts equipped with cameras and other sensors to hunt for this precious treasure from deep space. We had a long wait before showtime.</p><p>I spent a good portion of this time speaking with Dr. Danny Glavin, from Goddard Space Flight Center in Maryland. Many of the questions he faced centered around the upcoming Mars Sample Return mission, a complex and expensive program proving to be a headache for many involved. He spoke to me with a genuine kindness and excitement for this mission, and missions to come. The desert’s silence was broken by the sound of rotor blades, as the four helicopters came to life, beginning their trek towards the staging area. This was a complex operation, practiced over the 7 years this spacecraft had been roaming the Solar System — becoming all too real this chilly September morning. It was getting closer now, closing seemingly impossible distances over our heads. I cannot describe the emotion I felt as the last helicopter left, threatening to topple us with the force of its rotor wash— somewhere between excitement and dread.</p><p>Somewhere up above us, two additional aircraft joined the hunt. A WB-57 and a modified Gulfstream business jet, each equipped with heat seeking and high resolution cameras, began orbiting the landing site in search of their prize. In the tent, we counted down the seconds until the start of entry interface, the moment in which the samples would make first contact with the atmosphere — watching the landing timer tick towards zero. In the skies of Utah, the SRC was suddenly met with the force of the atmosphere once more, something it last felt 7 years prior at liftoff. This is where I felt the extent of my helplessness, watching this tiny blip on the 57’s FLIR imager. In that moment, I felt truly united with everyone in the room — sitting in wait, and clinging to hope. The press site was dead silent, save for the commentary from the livestream being broadcast to the world a few hundred feet from us. I was busy tweeting, commenting everything that I heard and saw from the official Space Scout Twitter. I think I wanted to throw up the entire time, and could only barely bring myself to look. At 7:39 from landing, we heard it: “PARACHUTE DEPLOYMENT”. The press site felt energized, whoops and cheers, but there were milestones still to come, and the crash of the Genesis mission all those years ago still sat in our minds.</p><p>I don’t think the fear stopped until we touched down. The footage was too grainy for us to really make out what was happening against the desert, obscuring the SRC from view. Hearing “CONFIRMATION OF SRC TOUCHDOWN” was unlike anything I had ever felt. I had watched robots land on Mars, ships launch to the International Space Station, but this was here, returning to Earth. What a unique accomplishment that was, to not only make the trek across our Solar System, but to return to the place that created it. As the chute settled, and the teams were able to get closer, the noise returned. The press site was alive once more, people hugged and cried — all overjoyed with a sense of pride and achievement. Humans combined all their knowledge and brain power and talent and built this spacecraft, sent it to an asteroid a billion miles away, beat the odds, rethought our knowledge of the solar system, all before making the billion mile voyage back in order to get something that weighs less than a baseball into labs around the world. We were home.</p><p>It was, however, a strange homecoming. Coming home to a planet so different from how it was 7 years ago. So much had changed, as is the case in the information age. A globally connected world moves rapidly, and change is all around us — Nowhere was the notion of a pandemic, war, let alone the personal change in my life. Scientists describe samples like this as a time capsule of sorts, a look deep into our past to tell us what we’re truly made of, a unique and untouched look to how things once were. In 2016, when OSIRIS-REx lifted off, I was just starting college, a nervous wreck of an individual not quite ready for the real world. I was so unsure of what I wanted to do, I spent months agonizing about myself, my identity and the meaning of it all. But spaceflight distracted me, and ultimately motivated me towards my goal of telling stories and being a part of it. I watched this mission launch from my freshman dorm room, unable to fathom that 7 years later I would be at its landing, waiting with open arms for this precious piece of the universe to be returned. As the samples were flown back under the long line of the helicopters, a strange feeling started to creep over me. A great cosmic emptiness, a feeling that everything that I did was in vain, that despite my presence for this tremendous event, it was all for nought. This new fear, one of failure and regret, threatened to overpower me. I found myself far less social, drawing the curtain around myself — no longer as excited to be there. As we left the press site after a safe delivery, and said goodbye to all of our new friends, a strange feeling of emptiness settled over me.</p><p>My trip back to Washington was full of this line of thinking. I spent a good amount of time wondering about the scale of it all, feeling smaller than I ever had as I stared out the window of the ancient 757 that carried me home. The vast distances of the cosmic ocean, for the first time, threatened to overwhelm me and swallow me whole. Work quickly picked back up for me, and I made preparations to leave for the launch of NASA’s Psyche mission, a voyage to a metal world that alongside OSIRIS-REx, aimed to unlock the secrets of our solar system. But something still remained, this fear of the great unknown. Even as the spacecraft left the pad, I could not help but think back to the Utah desert, and the growing fear of the dark.</p><p>It was not until November 5 that I realized that this fear sitting in my gut was not some great eldritch horror. I was not afraid of the unknown, rather, I was afraid of my own change. This unusually warm November afternoon, I braved Red Line closures and crowds to catch a glimpse of the OSIRIS-REx sample, a measly fraction of what had been scooped up from this distant world. It was, in many ways, unremarkable. A grey rock sitting in a grey container in a glass case, flanked by models of the spacecraft and the Atlas rocket that launched it all those years ago. No longer was it separate from me, some unknowable cosmic entity, but a thing I could perceive. I did not stay long, taking only a few pictures before stepping out into the autumn breeze — but I found myself unable to go very far.</p><p>That fear, the one I had equated to the unknown for so long, was revealing its true form to me in that moment. It was a fear of change, a fear of the rapid progression of my life, a fear of growing old — where this cosmic morsel was already ancient. It had survived for hundreds of thousands of lifetimes, perhaps even longer than humans had been on this planet, and it had remained largely unchanged. It was so immune to change, until it was literally plucked from the heavens and brought back to Earth. And then I realized — the change that we enacted on this speck from space opens our world, changes our line of questioning, enables us to uncover more about our past. And that’s what change is like at the human level, too. Without this change, I would not be who I am today, a person shaped by experiences; triumph and defeat. I would not have the ability to question my world, and shape my inquiry as I have without change. For so long, I struggled to find a purpose — often curious as to why I was even here. Truth be told, I may never know the answer. But these great cosmic moments in life, be it a rocket launch, a sample return, or getting the chance to talk to the people who will be voyaging to the moon, remind me that change is part of it all. That’ll help me sleep at night, I think.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d54ce8f7a02e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Case for Robotic Assurance]]></title>
            <link>https://nikproxima.medium.com/a-case-for-robotic-assurance-112d27a46747?source=rss-4033970f02ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/112d27a46747</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[commercial-space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artemis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nasa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-exploration]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nik Proxima]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 May 2023 15:02:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-02T20:33:58.735Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Humankind’s Greatest Ally in Space Needs Confidence</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/985/0*G9HA2VoVdcC1YGez" /><figcaption>NASA’s LRO/LCROSS mission lifts off from Pad 41, bound for the moon and a multi year mission to help humankind better understand our celestial neighbor. (credit NASA).</figcaption></figure><p>As humankind prepares to go back to the Moon as part of the Artemis Program and beyond, there lies a player essential to all of this that I feel does not receive the recognition they deserve — the robots. For as long as space agencies have turned their eyes skyward in the hopes of uncovering truths about our universe, robotic explorers have been there — helping to guide us in our quest for discovery and understanding. Robots, in many ways, were braver than any of us — forging new paths into the unknown for human explorers to follow. Robotic explorers have laid out the groundwork, selected the targets, and pushed the limits of what we as humans can do. Now, in the dawn of the Artemis era, robotic missions play a crucial role once more. However, even with a good majority of the groundwork laid, and a lot of the hard parts out of the way, there exist potential flaws that threaten to derail the whole plan, and work that remains to be done which is essential to the mission statement of Artemis as a whole — sustainability and permanence. In this article, I will explore the history of robotic exploration in conjunction with human crews, and discuss the key issues facing combined human-robotic exploration going forward. In doing so, I hope to paint a picture that expands the viewfinder with which we think about human missions to space, to not just the bravery of the crew — but for the service of these plucky, sometimes unpredictable creations that seem to capture our hearts, showcasing just how important they really are.</p><p>As far back as the Apollo era, robotic explorers have acted as a light in the dark — pioneering adventurers whose mission was boldly go where no one had gone before. When it comes to Apollo, some of the precursor missions lay long forgotten, but to me, there are three that stand out: Ranger, Lunar Orbiter and Surveyor. Each of these missions tackled a new challenge, all of which would be required for landing crew on the moon. Ranger was up first, and arguably represented one of the greatest hurdles — <em>getting there.</em> Rocket reliability in this early age of space exploration was poor, so poor in fact that it took until Ranger 4 to hit the moon, and Ranger 7 to actually complete mission objectives. At one point, the program was called “shoot and hope”, something we’ll get back to later on in this article. Lunar Orbiter would come next, sending 5 missions to orbit the moon and help characterize the landing sites for the Apollo program around the equator. Surveyor, the last step in the Apollo era, would showcase that the lunar surface would be safe for the crew, performing soft touchdowns and characterization of the lunar environment. The crew of Apollo 12 would even visit the site of one of the Surveyors, making them one of the first crews to visit a deep space probe <em>after</em> it had launched.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HWC__CVmtswQ9e3s.jpg" /><figcaption>Pete Conrad poses with Surveyor 3 with the crew’s Lunar Module visible behind them. The crew landed just 600 feet from the spacecraft, and performed an inspection (Credit NASA).</figcaption></figure><p>In the years since, crewed lunar missions have ceased. But, the realm of exploration has maintained serious momentum in the robotic sphere. NASA and their partners have continued to lay the groundwork for eventual human missions to the Moon, Mars and beyond — while operating under tight constraints of budget and political will. Missions such as the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter, the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, twin Mars rovers Spirit and Opportunity, and more have continued to push the boundaries of what is possible, and prepare us for the next step. Curiosity and Perseverance, the two nuclear powered rovers on Mars that as of writing, remain operational, were designed with explicit human exploration goals in mind — look for sites of interest and help characterize the environment. LRO, in orbit of the moon since 2009, was born not out of a need for Artemis, but to a distant ancestor, the ill fated Constellation program. Slated to be a bold, American return to the moon, Constellation fell to the whims of budget cuts and program mismanagement, and the program was unceremoniously scrapped. LRO, having been in place imaging the moon, survived, and continued to perform studies of the lunar surface to this day, looking for ideal landing sites should a program gain the momentum to get there. There were other survivors of this drastic cut, which will soon play into our story. The Lockheed Martin Orion Multi Purpose Crew Vehicle, NASA’s deep space capsule, managed to survive as well, taking a new shape with its European Service Module built by Airbus. The Space Launch System, a rocket born of heritage components from the Space Shuttle, successfully completed its first flight as part of the Artemis I mission, and production is ramping up towards our return to the moon. These survivors have formed for themselves the backbone of an incredibly robust program, with bold ambitions for a brighter future. It is, to say the least, a very exciting time to watch spaceflight unfold.</p><p>Now, you may be asking yourself — In Artemis, where are the robots? And that answer is a bit complicated. A lot has changed since the age of Apollo, for a new player has entered the fold: commercial space. No longer is it just the work of governments to deliver vital resources to the lunar surface. And for many, this sends chills down our spines. In my previous article, <a href="https://lavieohana.medium.com/starship-ii-a-reprise-df3585d9e39d">and this really phenomenal article by my friend and colleague Lavie Ohana</a>, we discuss how commercial space partners are manufacturing a fleet of landers to enable human exploration of the moon. But in order to stay on the moon, and not just leave behind footprints like the Apollo program, we need a fleet of robotic missions in tandem. One of the key goals of Artemis is the establishment of a long term presence on the moon through the foundation of a Base Camp, and to demonstrate technologies required to eventually take us to Mars on each mission. This, in turn, requires technology to be in place well ahead of the crew’s arrival, in an approach that NASA and the Artemis partners are calling pre-staging. While some technology demos and components will be delivered by the crew, many of these payloads are to be delivered to the lunar surface by a new program, the Commercial Lunar Payload Service program, or CLPS (pronounced “clips”). To date, 8 landing missions have been contracted, with several landers being offered from a variety of size classes, with more on the way. Eventually, the lander fleet will consist of vehicles that can land a few hundred kilograms, to multi-ton behemoths which would preposition habitats or other vital human rated systems. CLPS aims to deliver in a variety of ways, by outsourcing the technology to commercial providers and ensuring that no one company has a monopoly. Peregrine Mission 1, also known as CLPS-1, is slated to fly on the first flight of United Launch Alliance’s Vulcan rocket sometime later this summer, officially kicking off the Commercial Lunar era.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/879/0*lP1gVnoorpISqpkG" /><figcaption>Astrobotic’s Peregrine lander in the clean room at their Pittsburgh Facility. (Credit Astrobotic)</figcaption></figure><p>Here’s where it gets tricky. CLPS, at its core, is not a program that ensures mission success. Mission management has repeatedly stressed that some vehicles “will not make it to the surface”, implying a willing acceptance of failure on the part of the program. Numbers thrown around have included a 30–50% success rate, something that an agency like NASA would deem unacceptable for an in-house mission. (Take this, however, with a grain of salt, this is from a verbal discussion and not a stated fact.) It’s worth noting too that the “40%-50% will make it” statement was not just talking about how the landers will perform when they’re up there, it’s that 50% of the contracts will result in missions that actually launch. One CLPS provider already folded, one might get bought, and one just crashed. This attitude carries even further, with high priority payloads being flown on the first flight of some landers, including the VIPER rover — a concept NASA has hoped to fly for nearly a decade. With VIPER, the agency hopes to characterize water ice deposits in the quest to utilize the moon’s resources, enabling astronauts to live off the land. Without it — they’re flying blind. There is some degree of higher checks provided to high priority science missions, but the attitude of the program as a whole threatens to derail the check-work done by the parent agency. CLPS has another unique vulnerability, the whims of the market. When the Japanese company iSpace lost their Hakuto-R mission to the lunar surface on April 25, 2023; their stock value fell by 50% — endangering the company’s financials. MASTEN Space Systems, one of the companies contracted by NASA in the initial CLPS bid, no longer exists — having filed for bankruptcy and been absorbed into Astrobotic. These issues are also compounded by the fact that NASA has expressed an interest in flying nuclear fission demonstration missions on later versions of some of these landers, which is a whole new ballgame for regulation. The OIG, the NASA Office of the Inspector General, has commented on the status of the program as a whole, stating: “<em>Although required by NASA policy, the first two awards under CLPS Task Order 2 have no safety and mission assurance plans. NASA has stated that the nature of the CLPS Task Order 2 is akin to a delivery by common carrier, similar to an express cargo service, and therefore does not require a PQASP or even a risk assessment.” </em>NASA’s CLPS program now looks to stand alongside Ranger in its fundamental mismanagement of Lunar exploration — a buckshot parallel that reeks of complacency, and further delays the transition from Flags and Footprints to Sustainable Presence<em>. </em>How did we get here?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3V6tb9WBvDZGByvO.jpg" /><figcaption>The Hakuto-R team watches as their lunar lander descends towards the surface, and its eventual demise. (Credit ispace)</figcaption></figure><p>To answer that question, we have to look back at the murky water that is the transition from government-only spaceflight to the government-commercial hybrid model we seem to exist in today. Companies such as SpaceX and Orbital Sciences(now Northrop Grumman) quickly impressed NASA leadership with their execution of the Commercial Resupply Program, a consistent stream of ships delivering payloads to the International Space Station, which lacked domestic cargo capabilities in the wake of Shuttle. This program was a resounding success, and ensured that the ISS remained a flagship laboratory for international science. In the reordering from Constellation, the CCDev/Commercial Crew program was spun up to ensure US crew access to space, eventually ending reliance on the Russian Soyuz. This program would be years behind schedule, SpaceX only flying their first crew in 2020, with Boeing having yet to fly a crewed test flight as of May 2023, coupled with numerous safety reviews that took place throughout the 13 year program. But, the mantra of “commercial = less work for us” stuck, and has placed NASA and their partner agencies in the hands of corporations that do not always align with the mission statement of the contractor agency. This leads us to the state we find ourselves in now, with the Human Landing System contract seemingly unsteady and un-worked on, Gateway Resupply (GLS) as a big unknown, and the CLPS program’s general attitude. There is a rather uncomfortable recent shift in the perspective of the agency, a willingness to turn a blind eye to difficulty, and ability to push the blame elsewhere when the management decisions from the top don’t pan out as expected.</p><p>To me, however, it goes beyond an agency culture that has shifted so fundamentally — it represents an overall air of cockiness that forgets that we as humans need help in doing these things. The Artemis Program, as a whole, is a good one — it enables our return to the moon in a way that allows us to ensure a sustained presence there. I find myself noticing that for an agency whose work is spent on managing robots to do such incredible things, they do not seem to consider the implications of utilizing robots alongside a human crew to perform truly groundbreaking science. They view these machines as expendable because they’re not the property of an agency, but a company acting as an extension of the self. And I don’t think this is a good way to go about this — this complacency only continues to bleed into other aspects of space agency culture, be it larger missions to destinations beyond the moon, or even human in loop programs. It is a slippery slope of behaviors that I feel needs to be arrested soon.</p><p>CLPS is a program that I feel could still be saved, and I, ever the optimist, retain some hope for a reality check. One unique aspect of CLPS is the ability to deliver payloads to a variety of destinations in space, something that could be leveraged in as a requirement before a landing site is ultimately selected on a later mission. These kinds of environments will absolutely put the systems through their paces, and enable the delivery of a variety of payloads into cislunar space — another requirement for Artemis operations. One immediate priority item could be the delivery of a replacement for our intrepid LRO, coming up on nearly 15 years in orbit of the moon. An early CLPS mission could use a modified lander bus to deliver a replacement, ensuring imaging and relay coverage for lunar explorers. On the subject of relays, I was overjoyed to see that Lunar Pathfinder, a European communications demonstration mission, will be utilizing a rideshare with a Firefly Aerospace CLPS lander, Blue Ghost— a capability that I personally would like to see greater utilization of. In terms of safety, I think a drastic rework of how NASA evaluates their lander entrants could be undertaken. In the aerospace industry, there is the AS9100 Audit System, a ranking structure which ensures that an organization meets the requirements to operate at a certain standard. A class standard could potentially inform agencies on company’s abilities to deliver cargo to different destinations, while enabling and fostering growth and experience gaining. Companies aiming to put payloads on the surface could potentially be subject to a ranking system based on performance of flights and internal safety review — much as launch providers for NASA missions are ranked today under the Launch Service Providers program.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mU_sfFlawLvoSSdu.jpg" /><figcaption>CLPS could enable hardware like rovers, science and even habitats to be in place at or around the lunar South Pole well before Artemis astronauts arrive. (Credit NASA)</figcaption></figure><p>I want to stress as well that I’d like to be proven wrong, that I’d like CLPS to succeed as a program that helps rather than hinders Artemis operations. It is how I feel about HLS, GLS and all of the other programs that have been tied into the return to the moon. In an ideal world, I am proven wrong, with CLPS succeeding as a program that advances international science and our return to the moon <em>to stay</em>. I was an early skeptic of Commercial Cargo, which has now had more than 40 flights, and I revel in the fact that I was wrong about the program as a whole. As I stated previously, the good folks on CLPS-1 are dotting their Is and crossing their Ts in preparation for the start of this new age — and I’ve had the fortune to interact with and get to know people across the industry who have worked on a wide range of aspects of this new and exciting program. CLPS, as it has positioned itself now, is as vital to the success of Artemis as the Rangers, Surveyors and Lunar Orbiters of the Apollo era were — and I think it is essential that we ensure mission success with everything we send to our nearest celestial neighbor. Entrusting these landers in their current management style with critical exploration payloads (VIPER, AIII surface science) seems, to put it gingerly, absurd. If we are to pursue these programs, and get humans and robots working together on the moon, the attitude with which we execute these missions must fundamentally change. The Jet Propulsion Laboratory was dragged through Congress in hearing after hearing after losing three Mars missions in the 90s, and I would hope to see a similar course of action if CLPS produces similar results. If (and hopefully this remains an <em>if</em>) there is failure, we had better be ready to hold parties accountable for failing to deliver, a trend in aerospace that seems to not be the standard course of action these days. I remain nervous about CLPS, but I hope to have those anxieties alleviated through successful landings and vast quantities of science. Godspeed you brave little explorers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=112d27a46747" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Moment’s Reflection on Starship]]></title>
            <link>https://nikproxima.medium.com/a-moments-reflection-on-starship-f91c51f3bf9?source=rss-4033970f02ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f91c51f3bf9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artemis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spacex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[starship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nik Proxima]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Apr 2023 20:17:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-22T20:16:07.059Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EeSNNEqdS_RpJgN7" /><figcaption>Starship IFT lifts off from Starbase Texas, Photo Credit SpaceX</figcaption></figure><p>To name your rocket “Starship” is a bold endeavor. The word starship itself is a loaded term, one that holds at its core the hopes for humanity, the ability to touch other worlds and explore the cosmos. The word starship, used in its most notable cultural setting, Star Trek, highlight a new age of sail — comfortable and expansive vessels on which humankind and their allies explore space together. The Space Exploration Technologies (SpaceX) Starship that lifted off from Boca Chica, Texas, was not that. Not yet at least. With a thundering roar that I can only imagine would have been even more devastating from the ground, and a column of flame and launch pad debris, the stainless steel rocket rose — with it the ambitions of the SpaceX team, fans, and agencies which have hedged their bets on the program to deliver payloads to orbit, and the most critical payload of them all — Humans to the Moon.</p><p>The moon. That’s what’s been looming over all of this — arguably one of the biggest gambles of the Starship program itself. Successful flights of every system are needed if they are to play into the Artemis program’s survival — a delicate balance of international and commercial cooperation that ebbs and flows with economic tides. Yesterday (April 20, 2023), despite SpaceX’s claims, was not a success. I find this milestone moving more disturbing than anything that could have happened during the launch, which ultimately ended in failure. During the Artemis I countdown, commentator Derroll Nail spoke with tense breaths, telling us about the mission at hand and how crucial it was to get it all right. He even spoke about how success was not guaranteed, but that they would do all they could to perform as flawless a flight as possible. During the Starship countdown, the comment “just clearing the pad is a win” was thrown around like nobody’s business. In that moment, I understood the differences in safety culture that governed these two agencies. And now, I begin to wonder, have they split too much to ensure mission closure? Are we even further from the moon than the day prior?</p><p>At this point, the only people who can tell us are the teams of engineers working on all sides of our human return to our nearest celestial neighbor. My colleague and dear friend Lavie Ohana put it so well when discussing the contrasts of these two programs: “If you had told anyone just two years ago that SLS (Space Launch System) would beat Starship, fly perfectly, and become the component of the Artemis program that contributed to delays the least, you’d have been laughed out of the room. And yet, here we are — of America’s two new and flown super-heavy launch vehicles, one has sent a deep-space crew-capable spacecraft to the Moon and back, while the other totaled its launchpad, struggled and failed the whole way up, and finally exploded not even a third of the way to space — never mind orbit — carrying nothing more than the hopes and dreams of the Artemis generation.” And that’s just it. What was seen as the tortoise has become the hare, and the hare has melted into something of a black sheep. It looks us in the face with more problems than solutions; and no clear path forward. Is the vehicle meant to be the be-all end-all of human spaceflight nothing more than a boondoggle? I think it is still to early to say.</p><p>So what can we gather from all this? Well. We have shown that the Raptors work. We have shown that there’s a decent chance it won’t detonate on the pad, if treated carefully. And, more importantly, that the system as a whole is getting started on a longer journey towards orbital flight. The pad is cooked, that’s for sure. There are scars across the delicate beach that was for the most part, untouched before the tower of fire yesterday. But is it right to call it a success? I am not so sure. Success means you met your mission goals, accomplished what you set out to do. Perhaps it is a success that they could press the button. I do hope, and I think I share this hope with many, that Starship does work. Being where we are is okay to some degree, we must learn how a system works in order to ensure that it works well. But it does threaten to derail the goal of the moon, kept away from us for so so long. After so long spent in LEO, vehicles of this caliber are revolutionary — ushering in an age of truly heavy lift vehicles for all of humankind to use so that we may explore together — the Star Trek future we all hope for. But we must get it right with these shaky first steps.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f91c51f3bf9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>