<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Nina Jankowicz on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Nina Jankowicz on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz?source=rss-bf2c01233014------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 04:58:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Quitting Facebook is easier in rich countries]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/quitting-facebook-is-easier-in-rich-countries-ec9de09de273?source=rss-bf2c01233014------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec9de09de273</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[facebook]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disinformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nina Jankowicz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Jun 2019 12:22:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-06T13:44:12.605Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This piece was originally published in the Brazilian newspaper </em>Folha de Sao Paulo’s Illustrisima<em> magazine. Read it in Portuguese </em><a href="https://www1.folha.uol.com.br/ilustrissima/2019/05/abandonar-o-facebook-e-mais-facil-para-paises-ricos.shtml"><em>here</em></a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8MHivjzTJzR0yviAi4uLPA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Voters in Ukraine — Facebook’s third-fastest growing market — attend a rally for Yuliya Tymoshenko prior to the first round of the country’s presidential election in March 2019.</em></p><p>KYIV, UKRAINE — Sometimes I feel like a professional Facebook critic. As a disinformation researcher, the past few years of missteps and scandals in the social media world have meant that my work has become synonymous with public condemnations of the company’s behavior. From the platform’s response to Russian election interference, to Cambridge Analytica, to Mark Zuckerberg’s confounding New Year’s Resolution to have controlled conversations about technology and society, I rarely have a good word to spare. I wish it were different; if I had more occasions to praise the platform, it would be an indication that the Internet is becoming more just and democratic.</p><p>Despite Facebook and other social media platforms’ public remonstrations that they are changing their behavior, we could not be farther from that online democratic utopia, and my criticism continues. I am often in good company, as social media users are becoming more aware of their rights and the platforms’ negligence for them. Lately, though, my public disapproval has been met with a unique chorus of pseudo-wise men, eager to inform me that yes, of course, Facebook is bad! But why didn’t I realize that sooner? The pseudo-wise man usually goes on to inform me that <em>he</em> had the foresight to delete Facebook years ago.</p><p>Bravo to the pseudo-wise men of the global west and north for their apparent foresight. What they don’t realize, however, is their very ability to delete their Facebook accounts and their audacity to brag about it is not only coming from a place of supposed intellectual superiority, but one of privilege. For millions of people outside of North America and Western Europe, Facebook, quite simply, <em>is</em> the Internet. Deleting it is tantamount to throwing your phone into the nearest body of water and retreating to the dark depths of the forest to begin your life as a hermit.</p><p>Most western social media users probably don’t realize the extent to which Facebook penetrates the fabric of daily life in other countries. I am writing from Kyiv, the capital of Ukraine, where my local cell phone plan includes free access to Facebook, Facebook Messenger, and Facebook subsidiaries WhatsApp and Instagram, among other social media and digital services. This is not simply a bonus to attract users to the mobile provider; it’s a necessity if telecom companies are to compete in the market at all. According to a <a href="https://plusone.com.ua/fb/">report by Ukrainian communications agency PlusOne</a>, Ukraine is one of the fastest-growing markets for the social media giant, behind only India and the Philippines. It boasts 13 million users, 8 million of whom access the platform exclusively through their mobile phones.</p><p>Without free access to the platform in their mobile contracts, telecom providers would be obsolete. But because that access is free, in comparison to using a native web browser to read the news or message with friends via SMS, Ukrainians turn to Facebook-owned apps for many of their online needs. Ukrainian Facebook users aren’t only sharing pictures of their cats, children, and vacations, either; in Ukraine, Facebook extends beyond the “social” aspect of social networking, and is an engine for politics, business, and other aspects of professional life.</p><p>Most of the interviews I scheduled during my time in Ukraine have been coordinated on Facebook Messenger. In several instances, I’ve sent an SMS to a colleague or interviewee only to receive a Facebook message in reply. It has increasingly become the all-in-one social network in Ukraine. Whereas Americans might use email for professional correspondence and LinkedIn to network professionally, Ukrainians use Facebook for these purposes as well, listing all of their professional credentials and affiliations in their profile, and adding those they have met at networking events, or those they hope to connect with in a professional capacity as Facebook “friends.”</p><p>Facebook has also become an increasingly critical tool for political discourse and mobilization. In the past, many Russian- and Ukrainian-speaking influencers used LiveJournal to blog about politics. But as Igor Rozkladai, a media expert and Ukrainian reform activist told me in an interview, he and many other Ukrainians moved their discussions to Facebook after LiveJournal was bought by a Russian company, migrated its servers to Russia, and began complying with the Russian government’s requests for data. Ukrainians have further relied on Facebook as an engine for political commentary since the 2013–2014 Euromaidan revolution and Russia’s illegal annexation of the Crimean peninsula. Activist Mustafa Nayyem posted a call to action on Facebook that called Ukrainians to the streets after then-President Yanukovych reneged on a promise to sign an Association Agreement with the European Union, beginning the Euromaidan protests. Moreover, Facebook’s role as the key forum to discuss politics has been hastened by the Ukrainian government’s ban of Russian social media platforms vKontakte and Odnoklassniki.</p><p>Ukraine will elect a new parliament this fall. Though the country is widely recognized as the laboratory for Russian disinformation, Ukrainians are not leaving social media, but flocking to it. The PlusOne study shows one million new Ukrainian users created a Facebook account in the last quarter of 2018 alone. Facebook is Ukraine’s window on politics, window on work, and window on the world. Deleting it is — both for the average Ukrainian and this analyst reporting from Ukraine — is not an option.</p><p>The situation in Ukraine is probably familiar to Brazilian readers, where telecom providers also offer free access to social networking platforms. My colleague Anna Prusa, a program associate at the Wilson Center’s Brazil Institute, tells me via email that like in Ukraine, “Facebook and WhatsApp are central to the way Brazilians engage with one another, from family group chats to professional communications.” As cell phone coverage has become more ubiquitous, more people are relying on Internet-based services for all of their communications; over <a href="https://www.valor.com.br/brasil/6033817/ibge-brasil-ganha-10-milhoes-de-internautas-em-apenas-um-ano">83 per cent of Brazilians</a> made a video or voice call using an Internet service last year.</p><p>But Brazilians’ dependence on Internet-based communications has consequences. Disinformation ran rampant during the 2018 presidential elections. Jair Balsonaro’s campaign, afforded little television time because of his party’s limited representation in parliament, “was almost entirely reliant on social media,” his preferred method of communicating with voters, the Wilson Center’s Prusa wrote. WhatsApp, Facebook’s encrypted messaging service, was particularly critical for Balsonaro: <em>Folha</em> reported that his campaign used to launch informational attacks against his leftist opponent Haddad.</p><p>As in Ukraine, a future without Facebook and its subsidiaries in Brazil is almost unthinkable, Prusa writes. “It is very hard to imagine that Brazilians could go without WhatsApp. It is the primary means of communication for many, and is used for both texting and phone calls, including by businesses.” She notes that even <a href="https://revistacrescer.globo.com/Criancas/Comportamento/noticia/2018/09/87-dos-medicos-brasileiros-usam-whatsapp-para-se-comunicar-com-pacientes.html">doctors</a> in Brazil use WhatsApp to communicate with their patients. Facebook and its children are everywhere; deleting them is not an option.</p><p>Dependence on Facebook is even more of a threat in countries less developed than Ukraine and Brazil. Its “Free Basics” program, which provides a curated, zero-data version of the Internet to users in developing markets, <a href="https://connectivity.fb.com/free-basics/">aims</a> to “help people discover the relevance and benefits of connectivity.” A <a href="https://advox.globalvoices.org/2017/07/27/can-facebook-connect-the-next-billion/">2017 report</a> by citizen media collective Global Voices shows, however, that the program is less altruistic than it appears on the surface. Far from purely seeking to inform and improve lives, the Free Basics program serves Facebook’s business model more than it does disconnected populations, the report’s six case studies concluded. Free Basics lacks basic language adaptability to serve multilingual countries such as Pakistan. It pushes corporate content originating in the West, most notably the Facebook app itself. And it collects every shred of data generated by the users of the Free Basics program.</p><p>Even outside of these problems, the Free Basics program means that in countries with low Internet connectivity, Facebook represents the Internet wholecloth to millions of people, and the company is swiftly moving to close the gap for it hasn’t yet reached. Maria Ressa, the founder of Rappler, a Philippines-based website that has been targeted by President Duterte for uncovering government-sponsored disinformation campaigns on Facebook, <a href="https://www.recode.net/2018/11/26/18111859/maria-ressa-rappler-facebook-mark-zuckerberg-philippines-kara-swisher-recode-decode-podcast">often tells</a> the story of a conversation in which she tried to explain the outsized impact of Facebook’s penetration of the Filipino media market to Mark Zuckerberg. Ninety-seven per cent of Filipinos are on Facebook, she told him. She invited him to travel to the Philippines so he might better understand the danger the platform posed. Far from addressing the problems she had identified, Zuckerberg asked instead: “What are the other 3 percent doing, Maria?”</p><p>Ukraine, Brazil, and the Philippines cannot quit Facebook. Neither can Burma, where Facebook played a part in the disinformation that hastened a genocide of Rohingya Muslims, or India, where WhatsApp disinformation is more rampant than in Brazil. Some of the world’s biggest democracies are dependent on Facebook for communication, regardless of the threat it poses their political systems or their information ecospheres. This is why, though I understand that deleting Facebook and its subsidiaries may seem like a noble personal sacrifice to the pseudo-wise men of the Internet, it is something I will likely never do. Instead, I hope to use my privileged position to make a positive change on the platform.</p><p>As an expert on social media and democracy, it is critical for me to maintain my accounts on Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp to understand on an intimate level the risks they pose, to empathize with those affected by the latest data breach, to understand how the platforms influence my own information consumption habits. Coupled with my research in countries like Ukraine, I can advocate for a more equitable, just, and democratic Facebook, and by extension, a more equitable, just, and democratic Internet.</p><p>Citizens in the global west and north must engage with Facebook’s problems, rather than simply deleting the platform. We are still Facebook’s primary advertising market, and thus, Facebook’s primary money maker. The United States is Facebook’s home. The consequences of the outrage of American citizens or regulation pursued by the US government will be felt not just within our borders, but around the world. We may not be able to single-handedly prevent telecom providers from furnishing free access to the social media company or stop bad actors from manipulating it, but by engaging with and understanding the risks Facebook poses on a personal level, we can use our position of privilege to make the service more democratic for all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec9de09de273" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social media self-regulation has failed. Here’s what Congress can do about it.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/social-media-self-regulation-has-failed-heres-what-congress-can-do-about-it-5b38b6bf9840?source=rss-bf2c01233014------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b38b6bf9840</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fake-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[congress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disinformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nina Jankowicz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Nov 2018 18:58:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-29T18:58:54.109Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Remarks delivered at </em><a href="https://www.csce.gov/international-impact/events/lies-bots-and-social-media"><em>US Helsinki Commission Briefing “Lies, Bots, and Social Media</em></a><em>,” November 29, 2018.</em></p><p>From calling the influence of malign foreign actors on our electoral discourse and processes a “<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/nov/10/facebook-fake-news-us-election-mark-zuckerberg-donald-trump">pretty crazy idea</a>,” to inviting regulation, however begrudgingly, the social media platforms have come a long way since 2016.</p><p><a href="https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/04/transparent-ads-and-pages/">Facebook</a>, <a href="https://business.twitter.com/en/help/ads-policies/restricted-content-policies/political-campaigning/US-political-content.html">Twitter</a> and <a href="https://transparencyreport.google.com/political-ads/overview">Google</a> have made political advertising more transparent, creating searchable databases of political ads and have tightened restrictions on who can purchase them. In order to reduce the amount of fake news being spread by ads, Facebook has <a href="https://www.facebook.com/help/1991443604424859">updated its policies</a> “to block ads from Pages that repeatedly share stories marked as false by third-party fact-checking organizations.” Twitter’s policies no longer allow the distribution of hacked materials.</p><p>Facebook has attempted to increase <a href="https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/04/transparent-ads-and-pages/">authenticity and transparency</a> around the governance of Pages, an influence vector Russia’s Internet Research Agency utilized in 2016. It claims that administrators of Pages with large audiences undergo extra verification to weed out fake accounts; Facebook has also made other adjustments to arm users with information about the pages they follow.</p><p>All of the platforms have made adjustments to their algorithms in order to attempt to combat the problem of disinformation. Facebook did this by <a href="https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/01/news-feed-fyi-bringing-people-closer-together/">focusing on content from “friends and family</a>.” Google’s “Project Owl” changed the search engine’s algorithm to <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/26/technology/google-search-bias-claims.html?_r=0">surface more “authoritative content</a>,” and Twitter has <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/twitter-chronological-timeline-will-save-us/">reverted its news feed </a>to a more chronological timeline with less algorithmic intervention. Facebook and Twitter have also invested more in content moderation to identify and remove content that violates the platforms’ policies, including those related to false information, fake accounts, and hate speech.</p><p><strong>This is not an exhaustive list of the changes platforms have made, but rather an overview of the more well-known and purportedly messianic features meant to deliver us from all manner of Internet evil.</strong></p><p><strong>They are not enough.</strong></p><p>Among the features I’ve just described, loopholes have been exploited, missteps unforeseen, and pernicious disinformation allowed to flourish to the point where there is no question that social media self-regulation has been a failure. Just a day before the midterm election, over 100 Facebook and Instagram accounts likely controlled by the IRA were still active; Facebook only removed them after a tip from the FBI. <strong>This is a more complicated problem than playing whack-a-troll to remove fake accounts and increasing transparency on political ad buys.</strong></p><p>These measures are, of course, important first steps towards ensuring authentic, healthy online discourse. But even a cursory look through the performance metrics of the ads released by the House Democrats reveals that plenty of the 2016 IRA disinformation performed very well organically. Because the IRA had over time built trust and community with their audience of sometimes hundreds of thousands on each Page, many people saw and engaged with that content without the purchase of a single ad.</p><p>Today, a lot of this type of content is spreading through Facebook groups, which the platform’s algorithm prefers based on the misguided understanding that they promote content between “friends and family” and which are not subject to the same level of content moderation.</p><p>Yes, groups are a means of connecting people, but they are also breeding grounds for disinformation due to their privacy settings. “Closed” and “secret” groups are not searchable or transparent and the content shared in them is only visible to members, so Facebook is less likely to moderate content within them. What’s more, the platform still <em>incentivizes </em>and <em>promotes</em> group activity.</p><p>Groups were a key vector in <a href="https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ninajankowicz/elizabeth-warren-senate-campaign-shiva-ayyadurai-facebook">my investigation for BuzzFeed News</a> into fake profiles supporting an Independent candidate for Senate in Massachusetts; a number of fake personae, controlled not by lines of code, but by a human and thus able to slip by some of Facebook’s detection tools for fake accounts, would astroturf groups with posts about their candidate, creating the guise of grassroots support for the campaign. Columbia University’s Jonathan Albright has also <a href="https://medium.com/s/the-micro-propaganda-machine/the-2018-facebook-midterms-part-ii-shadow-organization-c97de1c54c65">researched how groups support the spread of disinformation</a> on Facebook and has noted that banned pages and brands such as InfoWars often move their activity to closed groups after their public pages are banned.</p><p>Finally, the spotty and opaque enforcement of platforms’ terms of service, including with brands like InfoWars which have a record of spreading hate speech and disinformation, undermines the entire discussion of content moderation to begin with. Legitimate voices are being silenced for infractions such as repeated uses of profanity while groups with considerable public reach that are violating much more serious clauses of the platforms’ terms are allowed to continue their diatribes until public outcry becomes too great.</p><p>To that end, transparency around takedowns has been lamentable. While Twitter has released the entire archive of takedowns of state-backed content on its service, a truly laudable move, Facebook releases this content selectively, and Google rarely. This contributes to the opacity of the problem and both a Congressional and public lack of understanding of how best to solve it.</p><p><strong>However, there is an opportunity for Congress to join together in a bipartisan manner to address this issue.</strong> Here are a few areas where it might start:</p><p>To begin with, the <strong>Honest Ads Act should be passed before the 2020 election. </strong>There is no reason that online political advertising, which in 2018 saw <a href="https://www.tvtechnology.com/news/political-ad-spending-hits-historic-highs-in-2018-campaign">at least a 200% increase in spending</a> compared with the 2014 midterms, should be subject to different rules than television, radio, and print ads. The sooner these rules are harmonized across platforms (including smaller online advertisers) and integrated with existing FCC and FEC regulations, the safer and more equitable our electoral processes will be.</p><p>But as I noted earlier, regulating advertising only covers a fraction of the malicious information shared on social media. <strong>Congress should pressure platforms to increase transparency surrounding the administration of groups and pages.</strong></p><p>Further, <strong>Congress should explore the establishment of a specialized independent regulatory and oversight mechanism</strong> that could:</p><ul><li>Harmonize definitions of concepts such as hate speech, abuse, and disinformation across the Internet;</li><li>Define and require that platforms obtain informed and meaningful consent to their terms of service, serving as an awareness-building mechanism about data privacy issues and the limits of speech on the platforms;</li><li>Serve as a neutral appellate body for users who feel their content has been unjustly removed; and</li><li>Conduct public audits of algorithms, account takedowns, and data stewardship.</li></ul><p><strong>Congress must also consider the role of education</strong> — in particular, media and digital literacy, critical thinking skills, and civics — in protecting online discourse and empowering citizens. In short, Congress might consider earmarks or grants for educational initiatives in these areas — which I detailed in <a href="https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/06-12-18%20Jankowicz%20Testimony.pdf">my testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee in June 2018</a> — as well as the use of taxes or fines paid by social media companies to fund such initiatives or public awareness campaigns, <a href="https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmcumeds/363/36302.htm">as the U.K. is considering</a>. These are generational investments, and ones that Congress must begin now. No regulatory or oversight solution can be complete without an informed and discerning electorate.</p><p>Finally, it is important to note the critical awareness-building and oversight role that Congress can play without the passage of any new legislation. Pressure from investigative journalists and Congress is what has led the social media platforms to begin to reform. That should continue and be strengthened in the new Congress.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5b38b6bf9840" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How a Bot Brigade from Ontario Could Disrupt Online Discourse]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/how-a-bot-brigade-from-ontario-could-disrupt-online-discourse-863c09e4e0aa?source=rss-bf2c01233014------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/863c09e4e0aa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fake-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trolls]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bots]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[twitter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disinformation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nina Jankowicz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jan 2018 17:10:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-29T17:14:28.290Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Last week I <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/25/opinion/russian-trolls-fake-news.html">wrote an op-ed for <em>The New York Times</em></a><em> </em>on the responsibility of social media companies to stop the spread of homegrown disinformation instead of just playing Whack-a-Troll.</p><p>Like any glutton for punishment — I mean, writer!! — I searched Twitter to see who was sharing my piece and what they were saying. (Because of some misplaced belief that civil discourse in America might yet be saved, I try my best to engage with people who disagree with me.)</p><p>Among the tweets that decried my piece as a plea for full-blown censorship (it’s not), I discovered a network that apparently has a big stake in the fight against disinformation: hardwood floor and window specialists in Ontario, Canada.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/931/1*cisWP5XV2fruIR19tfKXow.png" /></figure><p>About 20 low-follower, low-following, rapidly tweeting accounts claiming to be windows, doors, and flooring specialists in Ontario were all tweeting about my article. All of them use <a href="https://twitter.com/search?f=tweets&amp;q=ift.tt%2F2GgioPv%20&amp;src=typd">the same “If This, Then That” link</a> to share my article. They all link to their own Wordpress shell site that has a teaser with a link to my article. And nearly all of them have YouTube channels listed as their websites. Some of them uploaded the same weird video of a “cheap tooth extraction without general anesthetic.” Okay then. (Only one of the bots claimed not to be interior design business in Ontario, focusing instead on orthodontics in Baton Rouge, LA. Perhaps that video has something to do with it?)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*dUIBUwkUvN2U46qU5RaNdQ.png" /></figure><p>After tweeting about my op-ed, the Ontario interior design bots went on to tweet about a Guatemalan businessman arrested in a tax scandal…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*4mv7A6FgyjwVF9T7-IjBOw.png" /></figure><p>…and continue to share the same links a few days later. They mostly share information from reputable news sources. None of the platforms to which these accounts link seem to be monetized, and they don’t share many commonalities in terms of accounts followed or followers, though all but one of the accounts were created between December 14, 2016, and January 30, 2017.</p><p>I share this case study not only because it is amusing that a small army of Ontario based interior decorating bots is seemingly interested in disinformation (oh, the irony!), or because <em>The New York Times</em> recently published an <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/01/27/technology/social-media-bots.html">excellent investigation into the bot economy</a>, but because there is an important implication for online discussion buried in this online micro-ecosystem: <strong>for a short period of time, a seemingly harmless group of accounts was able to clog up discourse on Twitter about my piece.</strong> The implications were few; after some scrolling and some chuckling, I moved onto engaging with the real users who were sharing my work.</p><p>But there are undoubtedly more bots where these came from, and they could be easily activated at any time to have a much larger impact on the global conversation. In addition to the false narratives with which we’re all familiar, we’ve seen bot networks <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbian_Chemicals_Plant_explosion_hoax">spread hoaxes about chemical plant disasters</a>. They can get accounts, stories, and hashtags trending with little support from actual humans. What good is free speech if we’re all just shouting into a void of fabricated content?</p><p>I’ll be reporting these accounts to Twitter, but I maintain that social networks need to be more proactive in stopping this content from being posted in the first place, or else removing it much more quickly.</p><p>On that note, <em>The National Review</em> published <a href="http://www.nationalreview.com/article/455825/russian-bots-twitter-scare-censoring-speech">an opinion piece by David Harsanyi</a> that was essentially the antithesis of mine. Rallying against a call from a few democratic Senators demanding that social media companies conduct research about Russian activity on their platforms in the wake of the #ReleasetheMemo controversy, Harsanyi claims he’d “rather we live with Russian troll bots feeding us nonsense than with authoritarian senators dictating how we consume news.” The problem with Harsanyi’s argument is that he ignores that networks are <em>already</em> “dictating how we consume news,” or, to use a popular euphemism, “curating content.” It is the very business model that made social networks profitable, and is unlikely to change any time soon, so we may as well demand they use it for good.</p><p><em>For more on bots and how to spot them, check out </em><a href="https://medium.com/dfrlab/botspot-twelve-ways-to-spot-a-bot-aedc7d9c110c"><em>DFRLab’s excellent guide</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=863c09e4e0aa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On order and freedom in modern Russia]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/on-order-and-freedom-in-modern-russia-34f3357a37cf?source=rss-bf2c01233014------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/34f3357a37cf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[navalny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[foreign-policy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nina Jankowicz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Jun 2017 18:24:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-14T08:00:55.214Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*CL3cOJepXqJLfE3NzTN7zw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo: Maxim Katz (<a href="https://twitter.com/max_katz/status/874239403341877248">https://twitter.com/max_katz/status/874239403341877248</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Mikhail Sergeevich taught Russian politics. He was in his thirties, about six feet tall and solid, with pale skin and sandy hair. He talked a mile a minute and had a habit of repeating the ends of his sentences. We were never sure if it was for emphasis or to aid our poor American understanding of his swallowed vowels. As foreigners fighting an uphill battle against the pitfalls of Russian language, we often left his class in a confused haze, gathered around the automated coffee machine that spat “espresso” into tiny plastic cups, and tried to make sense of whatever universal truth Mikhail Sergeevich had just unloaded on us.</p><p>“Today, your assignment is to choose one Russian you know well- and you must know them well, because this is a sensitive and personal question. Ask them whether they prefer order or freedom. Order or freedom. Order?” he said, “Or freedom?,” writing the requisite words on the chalkboard. “See you next week.”</p><p>I bent back the tiny winged handles of my coffee cup, which today held a “mocha” (watery espresso with a poof of powdered chocolate mixed in for good measure), and let the words roll over my tongue. <em>Por-YAD-ok.</em> Order. Its three crisp syllables were onomatopoeic, describing the neat St. Petersburg grid of boulevards and canals outside. It described the metro, with its trains arriving no more than two minutes apart and its own set of unspoken rules and regulations inside the train car, governing everything: how to offer seats to <em>babushki</em> and pregnant women, how to exit a crowded train. <em>Poryadok</em> permeated a lot Russian expressions, too. My host mother would tell me my room was <em>bezporyadochnaya</em>, or unorderly, when she wanted me to pick up in there. When “freshening up” in Russian, you “bring order to yourself.” It wasn’t an entirely new word.</p><p>But <em>Sva-BOHD-ah</em>. Freedom. We knew that one. We lived and breathed it. Back in Russian 201, during a unit on countries, “free” would be one of the token terms we could use to describe the United States. That and “big.”</p><p>But was Russia free? I wasn’t sure, and neither were my classmates. We stood in uncharacteristic silence, blowing on our tiny cups.</p><p>I waited almost until the last minute to talk to my host mother about our assignment. We were close, but I was nervous about a potentially contentious conversation. She was in her sixties and had lived most of her life in the Soviet Union. We usually talked about theater, music, and ballet; I had no idea what her political preferences were (though she did tell me that she thought Obama was handsome). The underscoring to all of our conversations at the kitchen table over tea was a murmuring radio with no off button. It was wired directly into the wall and emblazoned with a black and white silhouette of the Peter and Paul Fortress and the inscription “Leningrad.” Ostensibly, it had served as an emergency communication channel during the Soviet era, but then and now it was really a government mouthpiece, complete with Saturday morning kids’ programming for Russia’s tiniest upstanding citizens. It was a reminder that despite Petersburg’s shiny malls and ads plastered on every street corner, the Soviet Union still loomed large in everyday life.</p><p>I padded into the living room in my slippers and pajamas the night before my politics class. The state news was on in the background.</p><p>“Alyona? Can I ask you a question?”</p><p>“<em>Da, solnechnaya,</em>” she replied, calling me her sunshine.</p><p>“For politics class, I’m supposed to ask whether you prefer order or freedom… I mean, the way the country is run, and stuff like that…So which do you prefer?”</p><p>“Freedom, of course. Sit down,” she ordered. Alyona took my hand and described the hardships and fears she grew accustomed to growing up in the USSR. The stories I read about black cars coming in the night, disappearing neighbors and family members- they were actualized; Alyona had lived them. It was a long speech, not all of which I understood.</p><p>At some point, I realized that Alyona was using the present tense. “Journalists are being murdered. The government kills its own people for political gain. Grandmothers and grandfathers who saw this city through the blockade are suffering because the government refuses to provide for them.” Alyona paused and looked me straight in the eye. “Most Russians love Putin, but to me, he is worse than Stalin,” she said.</p><p>The next day at class, Mikhail Sergeevich was eager to hear about the findings of our “field research.”</p><p>“So which is it? Do Russians prefer order or freedom? Order or freedom?” I was the lone student whose interviewee chose freedom.</p><p>It’s a trend that continues today; in a <a href="http://wciom.ru/index.php?id=236&amp;uid=115815&amp;mc_cid=e6ca953871&amp;mc_eid=dded41b2f0">poll</a> conducted by the state-funded Russian Public Opinion Research Center (VTSiOM) last summer, 66 percent of those surveyed believe that Russia should be governed by a “firm hand” that can bring order to the country, while only 25 percent believe that political freedom and democracy are concepts that should be upheld under any circumstances. As relations between Russia and the United States continue to falter, stability, order, and the increase of Russia’s sovereignty seem to matter more to Russians than any seemingly Western-imposed notion of “freedom.”</p><p>— -</p><p>The first time I lived in Russia, when I was a student of Mikhail Sergeevich’s, it was great to be an American there. Russian-American relations were good, and Americans who spoke Russian decently were pretty rare, so Russians were usually happy to talk to me. The troubles Russia had at that time seemed mostly rooted in ethnic tensions; bombings by Chechens on the metro and the train, brawls between migrant workers from Central Asia and skinheads. I was worried I might get caught in the middle of the long-standing Russian-Polish discord that flared up in the wake of the crash of Polish President Lech Kaczynski’s plane on the way to a ceremony to honor the 20,000 Polish soldiers killed by the Soviets during World War II’s Katyn massacre. But even then, Russia handled itself with a surprising amount of dignity and grace. A few months later, when I traveled to Sochi, the future site of the Winter Olympics, amid early construction for the Games, the city was replete with billboards proclaiming, “Sochi 2014: Let’s go!” Russia was moving ahead.</p><p>Then, during my first semester of graduate school, Putin announced his intention to return to the presidency and protests broke out across the country. I compulsively refreshed Twitter and watched live streams of thousands on the streets, protesting the “Party of Crooks and Thieves.” Despite widespread accounts of voter fraud, Putin claimed victory, and I returned to Russia just after he returned to office.</p><p>The duality of the Russian population at that moment was palpable. Just six months after the largest protests in 20 years, I got acquainted with a more fearsome brand of Russian protester. On Russia’s Independence Day, I walked around the Summer Gardens with Petya, a Russian friend who studied Central Asian history. He joked that we had the day off from class so that we could celebrate “Independence (From What, We’re Not Sure) Day.” We rounded a corner near the Mars Field, a large, open space near one of the city’s many palaces, where tsarist-era armies used to conduct drills. Petya stopped in his tracks. There was a small protest going on. But not one that would inspire democratic visions of Russia’s future. About 200 skinheads were gathered with flags. “Russia for Russians,” their banners read. “Better to go the other way,” said Petya.</p><p>A few months later, I was chatting with a few young professors at my university who agreed to be interviewed for my thesis research and trying to get a feel for what EU expansion meant to average Russians. We sat around at an outdoor cafe with a few beers and I fired away. Yegor was a handsome, gregarious guy in his thirties. He taught Russian grammar to foreigners because he fiercely loved the Russian language. He told me he loved his country, too, but that country wasn’t Russia. It was the Soviet Union.</p><h3>“I’m upset, Nina,” he told me. “Every day I’m upset that the great country in which I was born no longer exists.”</h3><p>I scribbled down Yegor’s words with a bemused smile. Despite rising tensions in Russia that summer, Yegor’s desire to re-establish the Cold War order wasn’t one I encountered too often, and certainly wasn’t one I thought was dangerous. That day, basking in the rare sunlight on a St. Petersburg patio, beer in hand, Yegor was just a slightly eccentric friend.</p><p>— -</p><p>I came back to the US and started up my second year of grad school. USAID got unceremoniously kicked out of Russia. (“There go our jobs!” a classmate declared to the office when the news hit.) The Kremlin labelled a slew of democratically-minded organizations that had received western funds “foreign agents,” casting a Soviet-era spell over the entire civic and political organizing space. We were thrust back to the age of spycraft, complete with the late-night nabbing of a purported American CIA operative who was trolling around Moscow with cash and a bunch of bad wigs.</p><p>A small beacon of hope shone from Alexei Navalny, the popular blogger-turned politician who ran for Moscow mayor in 2013. He was allowed 27% of the vote. Though it wasn’t enough to force a runoff, it was enough to make some in Washington naively declare that “politics was back in Russia.”</p><p>While each of these developments sent shocks through the community of Russia experts the world over, none gained much traction in the general public. Even the Euromaidan protests in Ukraine were overshadowed by the glitz and glamor of the Winter Olympics in Sochi, which the press loved to hate. Anyone who could point to the vague location of Sochi on a map laughed along at the bizarre state of the Olympic city and many reporters’ first encounters with Russian culture. All the while, Putin quietly slipped his army into Ukraine.</p><p>Even then, the world did not react. It stayed relatively silent until a commercial airliner with 298 innocent people aboard was shot down in the conflict zone over a year later. Suddenly, Putin had the world’s attention, which even the Olympics could not fully deliver. Suddenly, the former Soviet Union was back on the front page. I thought of Yegor; he and many like him were probably pleased.</p><p>— -</p><p>While Putin’s global chess game has unfolded, I worked at a non-profit that delivered democratic assistance to activists across the post-Soviet region. I saw brave people damn the consequences of their beliefs and actions for the sake of advancing freedom and rule of law. They were raided. They lost elections. They were the subjects of defamation campaigns in print and on television. Their friends and leaders have been murdered on the street in the Kremlin’s shadow. Their lives aren’t orderly, and they see past the orderly facade that the Kremlin presents as fact.</p><p>But there are indications- which, of course, the Kremlin is doing its best to suppress- that order in Russia is crumbling.</p><p>In an attempt to further conceal the extent of Russia’s involvement in Ukraine after opposition activists released reports detailing those killed in action in the conflict, Putin ordered that deaths of military personnel during peacetime be classified as state secrets.</p><p>Prior to Putin’s order, after fierce fighting in Eastern Ukraine, I came across an obituary on Facebook. It read:</p><p><em>“St. Petersburg resident, member of the ‘Other Russia’ party, and volunteer fighter Yegor Vasylenko was killed in Debaltseve, Novorossiya. He was a professor of Russian language and literature for foreign students and leaves behind two daughters, Daria, 7, and Tatiana, 5.”</em></p><p>When Yegor chose (if it was indeed a choice) to fight in a foreign country, was he fighting for order? Or for freedom? Or was he, like Putin, merely concerned with bolstering Russia’s status as a great power, no matter how many lives got in the way?</p><p>— -</p><p>Today, five years to the day after I got my first taste of modern skinheads in St. Petersburg with Petya on “Russia Day,” I’m back to refreshing my Twitter feed and watching reports of protests all over Russia. It’s the third mass protest led by Navalny this year. Hundreds of people, including Navalny himself (and a giant inflatable duck, a symbol of the opposition movement), have already been detained since the protest started this afternoon. On the same field where I saw a few hundred people with nationalist banners, thousands have gathered today. Protesters are being beaten by riot police. Teenage girls are getting led away by cops. Universities and schools are threatening to expel detained students.</p><p>Putin and his team are working hard to impose order.</p><p>It’s times like these I think about the other interviewees from Mikhail Sergeevich’s class. I wonder if their opinions have shifted or just grown stronger, if their sons and husbands went off to Donbass to fight for a Russian order that no longer exists, or if their children are challenging the false dichotomy between order and freedom on the streets.</p><p>Maybe I’m out of touch, having not set foot on Russian soil in half a decade, but I still have hope that someday I will see Russia choose freedom.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=34f3357a37cf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[43 Fulbrighters to Trump: Don’t lift sanctions on Russia (русская версия)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/43-fulbrighters-to-trump-dont-lift-sanctions-on-russia-%D1%80%D1%83%D1%81%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F-%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%81%D0%B8%D1%8F-dea362ee8d53?source=rss-bf2c01233014------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dea362ee8d53</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[putin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ukraine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sanctions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fulbright]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nina Jankowicz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Jan 2017 10:34:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-29T10:34:56.383Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Это письмо было впервые опубликовано </em><a href="https://www.kyivpost.com/article/opinion/letters/fulbrighters-trump-dont-drop-sanctions-russia.html"><em>в газете </em>Kyiv Post</a>.<br><em>Ви також можете прочитати його </em><a href="https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/43-fulbrighters-to-trump-dont-lift-sanctions-on-russia-%D1%83%D0%BA%D1%80%D0%B0%D1%97%D0%BD%D1%81%D1%8C%D0%BA%D0%B0-%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%81%D1%96%D1%8F-ff86887a5730#.7px7ec6k2"><em>українською мовою</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Уважаемый Президент Трамп,</p><p>Мы, нижеподписавшиеся американские студенты, стипендиаты и выпускники Программы Фулбрайта, которые служили культурными послами в Украине, обращаемся к Вам с настоятельной просьбой не подписывать правительственное распоряжение, которое приведёт к отмене санкций против России за её агрессивные, внеправовые действия в этой стране.</p><p>Целью Программы Фулбрайта является содействие взаимопониманию между Соединенными Штатами и странами во всём мире. Мы прибыли в Украину в качестве преподавателей, исследователей и экспертов, но будем покидать её, получив столько же знаний, если не больше, чем мы отдали здесь.</p><p><strong>Санкции действенны</strong></p><p>Сдерживание российской агрессии в Украине с помощью финансовых санкций остановило Кремль от продвижения своих гибридных сил на востоке и дало России чёткий сигнал о том, что существуют последствия нарушения правил международного порядка. Мы пишем это письмо из Киева, столицы Украины, которому не пришлось слышать взрывы и выстрелы, ставшие привычными на востоке. Действительно, с момента Революции Достоинства три года назад, в то время, когда украинцы погибали в огненных уличных боях ради защиты будущего, в котором они могли бы быть свободны от коррумпированного правительства, действовавшего в интересах авторитарной России, город стал свидетелем роста предпринимательской деятельности и развития гражданского общества. Судя по сообщениям, которые мы получаем со всей страны, мы видим, что большая часть Украины является мирной и стабильной. Без санкций этому может прийти конец.</p><p><strong>Украина добилась прогресса</strong></p><p>Несмотря на войну, которая стоила драгоценных денежных ресурсов и более 10000 военных и гражданских жизней, Украине удалось стабилизировать свою экономику; Всемирный банк прогнозирует рост ВВП на 2% в следующем году. Благодаря в значительной степени поддержке и участию Соединенных Штатов и других западных союзников, она демонстрирует медленный, но устойчивый прогресс в борьбе с коррупцией. В некоторых частях страны правительство создало новую полицию, чтобы заменить структуру, которая регулярно вымогала взятки у беднейших граждан Украины. А осенью этого года было принято беспрецедентное законодательство, которое могло бы послужить образцом и для западных правительств, включая наше собственное, в соответствии с которым более 100000 высокопоставленных украинских государственных служащих, включая президента и премьер-министра, публично задекларировали свои доходы, совершив первый шаг среди многих других по искоренению коррупции в самом правительстве.</p><p><strong>Украинский народ обладает духовной силой</strong></p><p>Все наши студенты, коллеги и новые друзья — высокообразованные, мотивированные люди, которые разделяют ценности американского этоса: право на жизнь, на свободу и стремление к счастью. Многие из них посвятили себя служению обществу, потому что верят в будущее Украины. Они хотят быть частью реформ, которые приведут Украину к европейской интеграции и наладят стабильную и безопасную жизнь для их детей и внуков. Помимо того, что санкции — это карательная мера, они уместны, чтобы поддержать и эти общие идеалы, и развитие Украины по направлению к полностью свободному государству, где правит закон, а не коррумпированная, поддерживаемая Россией олигархия.</p><p>Многие из нас также работали и учились в России и питают глубокую любовь и уважение к этой стране, её народу и его культуре. Мы очень хотели бы видеть продуктивные отношения нашей страны с Москвой. Но это не должно быть сделано за счёт 10000 украинских граждан, отдавших свои жизни на войне, которую ведёт Россия; за счёт почти 2 миллионов жителей незаконно аннексированного Крымского полуострова, которые испытывают недостаток основных услуг и страдают от регулярных нарушений прав человека под властью Кремля; либо за счёт более 45 миллионов украинцев, которые сами вправе решать, к каким альянсам присоединяться.</p><p><strong>Отмена санкций против России не в интересах США</strong></p><p>Это даст сигнал России, что, за свой счёт, Соединенные Штаты готовы предоставить Москве место во главе дипломатического стола. Это будет работать явно против американских идеалов свободы, равенства и демократии, которые мы, фулбрайтовцы, приехали представлять и продвигать в Украине. Это те ценности, ради которых и американцы, и украинцы отдавали свои жизни и которые Кремль вопиюще не принимает во внимание.</p><p>Если сотрудничество с Россией должно быть достигнуто, мы взываем, чтобы это не происходило за счёт Украины. Санкции по отношению к России должны быть сохранены, пока она не удовлетворит условия Минского соглашения и не вернёт Крым Украине.</p><p>Nadina Anderson 2014–15 (Research)<br>John Biersack, 2011–12 (Research)<br>Charles Bonds (Research)<br>Irena Chalupa, 2015–16 (Scholar)<br>Dennis Chamberlin 2016–17 (Scholar)<br>Austin Charron, 2008–09 (Research)<br>Beth Ciaravolo, 2012–13 (English Teaching Assistant, ETA), 2016–17 (Research)<br>Benjamin Cohen, 2016–17 (Research)<br>Luke Drabyn, 2015–16 (Research)<br>Trevor Erlacher, 2014–15 (Research)<br>Tamara Fedoryshyn 2008–09 (Research)<br>Carolyn Forstein, 2011–12 (Research)<br>Anne Giocondini 2014–2015 (ETA)<br>Sarah ‘Daley’ Harris 2010–2011 (Research)<br>Kaley Hanenkrat 2011–12 (Research)<br>Christi Anne Hofland, 2008–09 (Research)<br>John Hofland 1995 (Scholar)<br>Nina Jankowicz, 2016–17 (Public Policy)<br>Christina Jarymowycz, 2015–16 (Research)<br>Lisle Jeremiah Kauffman 2011, 2014–2016 (Scholar)<br>Anna Khandros (ETA Tajikistan) 2014–15<br>Talia Lavin, 2012–13 (Fellow)<br>Sophie Lazar, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Grace Mahoney 2014–2015 (Research)<br>Jack Margolin, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Isabel Meigs, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Linda Norris, 2009–2010 (Scholar) and 2014 (Specialist)<br>Amelia Oliver 2015–16 (ETA)<br>Lara Palmquist 2015–2016 (ETA)<br>Abigail Poeske 2014–2015 (ETA)<br>Peter Rakowsky 2014–15 (Research)<br>Alexis Ramos, 2015–16 (Public Policy)<br>Cheryl Reed, 2016–17 (Scholar)<br>Zoe Ripecky 2015–16 (Research)<br>Megan Ritchey, 2010–11 (Research)<br>Jonathan Sanchez Leos, 2015–16 (Public Policy)<br>Julie Seidman 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Kathryn Stecyk 2010–2011 (Research)<br>Cynthia Sularz, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Tye Sundlee, 2008–2009 (Research)<br>Virlana Tkacz 2015–16 (Scholar)<br>Michele Vazquez 2015–2016 (Scholar)<br>Sofika Zielyk 2014–15 (Scholar)</p><p><em>Мнения, высказанные в этом письме, не отражают точку зрения Программы Фулбрайта или Государственного департамента США.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dea362ee8d53" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[43 Fulbrighters to Trump: Don’t lift sanctions on Russia (українська версія)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/43-fulbrighters-to-trump-dont-lift-sanctions-on-russia-%D1%83%D0%BA%D1%80%D0%B0%D1%97%D0%BD%D1%81%D1%8C%D0%BA%D0%B0-%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%81%D1%96%D1%8F-ff86887a5730?source=rss-bf2c01233014------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff86887a5730</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[putin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ukraine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sanctions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fulbright]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nina Jankowicz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Jan 2017 10:29:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-29T10:36:04.785Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Цей лист було спочатку опубліковано англійською мовою </em><a href="https://www.kyivpost.com/article/opinion/letters/fulbrighters-trump-dont-drop-sanctions-russia.html"><em>в газеті</em> Kyiv Post.</a> <br><em>Читать можете также </em><a href="https://medium.com/@nina.jankowicz/43-fulbrighters-to-trump-dont-lift-sanctions-on-russia-%D1%80%D1%83%D1%81%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F-%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%81%D0%B8%D1%8F-dea362ee8d53#.o0boalor9"><em>по-русски</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Шановний Президенте Трамп,</p><p>Ми, що нижче підписалися, американські студенти, стипендіати та випускники Програми Фулбрайта, які служили культурними послами в Україні, звертаємося до Вас з наполегливим проханням не підписувати урядове розпорядження, яке призведе до скасування санкцій проти Росії за її агресивні, позаправові дії в цій країні.</p><p>Метою Програми Фулбрайта є сприяння взаєморозумінню між Сполученими Штатами і країнами в усьому світі. Ми прибули в Україну в якості викладачів, дослідників і експертів, але будемо залишати її, отримавши стільки ж знань, якщо не більше, ніж ми віддали тут.</p><p><strong>Санкції є дієвими</strong></p><p>Стримування російської агресії в Україні за допомогою фінансових санкцій зупинило Кремль від просування своїх гібридних сил на сході і дало Росії чіткий сигнал про те, що існують наслідки порушення правил міжнародного порядку. Ми пишемо цього листа з Києва, столиці України, якому не довелося чути вибухи і постріли, які стали звичними на сході. Дійсно, з моменту Революції Гідності три роки тому, в той час, коли українці гинули у вогненних вуличних боях заради захисту майбутнього, в якому вони могли б бути вільні від корумпованого уряду, що діяв в інтересах авторитарної Росії, місто стало свідком зростання підприємницької діяльності та розвитку громадянського суспільства. Судячи з повідомлень, які ми отримуємо з усієї країни, ми бачимо, що велика частина України є мирною і стабільною. Без санкцій цьому може прийти кінець.</p><p><strong>Україна досягла прогресу</strong></p><p>Незважаючи на війну, яка коштувала дорогоцінних грошових ресурсів і більше 10000 військових і цивільних життів, Україні вдалося стабілізувати свою економіку; Всесвітній банк прогнозує зростання ВВП на 2% в наступному році. Завдяки значною мірою підтримці й участі Сполучених Штатів та інших західних союзників, вона демонструє повільний, але стійкий прогрес у боротьбі з корупцією. У деяких частинах країни уряд створив нову поліцію, щоб замінити структуру, яка регулярно вимагала хабарі в найбідніших громадян України.<strong> </strong>А восени цього року було прийнято безпрецедентне законодавство, яке могло б стати зразком і для західних урядів, включаючи наш власний, відповідно до якого більше 100000 високопоставлених українських державних службовців, разом із президентом і прем’єр-міністром, публічно задекларували свої доходи, зробивши перший крок серед багатьох інших з викорінення корупції в самому уряді.</p><p><strong>Український народ наділений духовною силою</strong></p><p>Усі наші студенти, колеги та нові друзі — високоосвічені, мотивовані люди, які поділяють цінності американського етосу: право на життя, на свободу і прагнення до щастя. Багато з них присвятили себе служінню суспільству, тому що вірять у майбутнє України. Вони хочуть бути частиною реформ, які приведуть Україну до європейської інтеграції та налагодять стабільне й безпечне життя для їхніх дітей і онуків. Крім того, що санкції — це каральний захід, вони доречні, щоб підтримати і ці спільні ідеали, і розвиток України в напрямку до повністю вільної держави, де править закон, а не корумпована, підтримувана Росією олігархія.</p><p>Багато з нас також працювали і навчалися в Росії і відчувають глибоку любов і повагу до цієї країни, її народу та його культури. Ми дуже хотіли б бачити продуктивні відносини нашої країни з Москвою. Але це не повинно бути зроблено за рахунок 10000 українських громадян, які віддали свої життя на війні, яку веде Росія; за рахунок майже 2 мільйонів жителів незаконно анексованого Кримського півострова, які відчувають нестачу основних послуг і страждають від регулярних порушень прав людини під владою Кремля; або за рахунок більше 45 мільйонів українців, які самі мають право вирішувати, до яких альянсів приєднуватися.</p><p><strong>Скасування санкцій проти Росії не в інтересах США</strong></p><p>Це дасть сигнал Росії, що, за свій рахунок, Сполучені Штати готові надати Москві місце на чолі дипломатичного столу. Це буде працювати вочевидь проти американських ідеалів свободи, рівності і демократії, які ми, фулбрайтівці, приїхали представляти і просувати в Україні. Це ті цінності, заради яких і американці, і українці віддавали свої життя і які Кремль кричуще не бере до уваги.</p><p>Якщо співпраця з Росією має бути досягнута, ми закликаємо, щоб це не відбувалося за рахунок України. Санкції стосовно Росії повинні бути збережені, поки вона не задовольнить умови Мінської угоди й не поверне Крим Україні.</p><p>Nadina Anderson 2014–15 (Research)<br>John Biersack, 2011–12 (Research)<br>Charles Bonds (Research)<br>Irena Chalupa, 2015–16 (Scholar)<br>Dennis Chamberlin 2016–17 (Scholar)<br>Austin Charron, 2008–09 (Research)<br>Beth Ciaravolo, 2012–13 (English Teaching Assistant, ETA), 2016–17 (Research)<br>Benjamin Cohen, 2016–17 (Research)<br>Luke Drabyn, 2015–16 (Research)<br>Trevor Erlacher, 2014–15 (Research)<br>Tamara Fedoryshyn 2008–09 (Research)<br>Carolyn Forstein, 2011–12 (Research)<br>Anne Giocondini 2014–2015 (ETA)<br>Sarah ‘Daley’ Harris 2010–2011 (Research)<br>Kaley Hanenkrat 2011–12 (Research)<br>Christi Anne Hofland, 2008–09 (Research)<br>John Hofland 1995 (Scholar)<br>Nina Jankowicz, 2016–17 (Public Policy)<br>Christina Jarymowycz, 2015–16 (Research)<br>Lisle Jeremiah Kauffman 2011, 2014–2016 (Scholar)<br>Anna Khandros (ETA Tajikistan) 2014–15<br>Talia Lavin, 2012–13 (Fellow)<br>Sophie Lazar, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Grace Mahoney 2014–2015 (Research)<br>Jack Margolin, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Isabel Meigs, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Linda Norris, 2009–2010 (Scholar) and 2014 (Specialist)<br>Amelia Oliver 2015–16 (ETA)<br>Lara Palmquist 2015–2016 (ETA)<br>Abigail Poeske 2014–2015 (ETA)<br>Peter Rakowsky 2014–15 (Research)<br>Alexis Ramos, 2015–16 (Public Policy)<br>Cheryl Reed, 2016–17 (Scholar)<br>Zoe Ripecky 2015–16 (Research)<br>Megan Ritchey, 2010–11 (Research)<br>Jonathan Sanchez Leos, 2015–16 (Public Policy)<br>Julie Seidman 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Kathryn Stecyk 2010–2011 (Research)<br>Cynthia Sularz, 2016–17 (ETA)<br>Tye Sundlee, 2008–2009 (Research)<br>Virlana Tkacz 2015–16 (Scholar)<br>Michele Vazquez 2015–2016 (Scholar)<br>Sofika Zielyk 2014–15 (Scholar)</p><p><em>Думки, висловлені в цьому листі, не відображають точку зору Програми Фулбрайта або Державного департаменту США.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff86887a5730" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>