<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Natalie Smolenski on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Natalie Smolenski on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nsmolenski?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 17:29:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nsmolenski/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[12 Healthy Habits for a Fulfilled Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nsmolenski/12-healthy-habits-for-a-fulfilled-life-ccac20fb82b7?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ccac20fb82b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wellness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[success]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Jun 2020 21:22:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-21T21:22:42.604Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Growing up is wonderful and exciting when it means becoming more fully who you are.</h4><p>There are plenty of advice books out there. Some of them rocket to the top of bestseller lists, while others remain obscure. Some of the advice they offer is truly helpful, while other advice is harmful or unhelpful at best. Most sources offer a mix of the two, and it can be difficult for people to separate the helpful from the harmful from the irrelevant.</p><p>When I was younger, I occasionally sought these resources out as I navigated my way through the world. Today, I’m a bit older — and after considerable trial and error, and real progress towards health and happiness, I thought it might be helpful for someone else if I summarized a list of general guiding themes that have taken me in the direction I want to go. These are things I have learned as I’ve been engaged in the deeply rewarding process of growing up — of becoming more peaceful, capable, and healthy as I strive towards my goals and aspirations. Ultimately, growing up has been a process of becoming who I am and more skillfully navigating the fields of human social life.</p><p>There are no specific prescriptions for how to live life, or how to grow up, as every person is different. Yet there are some — I believe — universals that reliably take people toward true fulfillment and self-realization over time. Below are a few of my thoughts.</p><ol><li><strong>Let go of judgments. </strong>We inherit our notions of “good” and “bad” from our surrounding culture and families of origin. These notions are meant as guideposts, directing us to want and like certain things while disliking and avoiding others. But the more you judge yourself, other people, and the world around you, the more you prevent yourself from encountering things as they are. Letting go of judgment doesn’t mean ceasing to be discerning; it’s actually the opposite. It’s preventing moral valuations (“good” and “bad”) from getting in the way of making the distinctions that actually matter. Sometimes, what you truly want might surprise you — it might be considered “bad” by others — and yet that may not be the right moral judgment to apply to that thing. Similarly, something that other people consider “good” may in fact be harmful or make you personally miserable. Try to let your experience be as unfiltered by your own biases and judgments as possible — that will free you to make decisions based more on ground truth than on cultural conditioning or the expectations of others. This will also have positive effects for the people around you: people are transformed into better, healthier versions of themselves by your love, acceptance, and — if the relationship is there — your discerning ability to compassionately speak truth into their lives, not by your judgment.</li><li><strong>Trust yourself. </strong>The world around you is filled with people who are more than happy to share their assessments of you — labels, whether you are “good” or “bad,” what you should think and do, how you should dress, what you should like or dislike, who you should be friends with or avoid, etc. Ultimately, you need to be able to trust your own assessment of these things. Sometimes we succumb to others’ judgments of us because we want to be socially accepted, or we care about a particular person and their point of view. But if someone is telling you something about yourself that isn’t true, or telling you to do something against your better judgment, trust yourself enough to stand up for yourself, say no, or simply walk away from the situation. Don’t wait for someone else to validate what you already know. Trust yourself.</li><li><strong>Privilege healthy social surroundings. </strong>We become what and who we are around. All of us have problems and struggles in our lives, and there is no doubt that social support and love are the most important ingredients for helping each other get through them. But there are people and communities — sometimes those we love very much — that are not privileging actually getting better or getting through their struggles. They may refuse to face the truth, refuse to do the work of change, or turn their struggles into harmful ways of interacting with you — lying, blaming, shaming, taking advantage, comparing, neglecting, excluding, petty point scoring, etc. The longer you marinate in these communities, the more like them you will become, even if you otherwise cultivate the healthiest personal habits. Removing ourselves from these communities can be difficult, but it is made much easier if former unhealthy relationships are replaced with healthier ones. Interacting with healthier people will not only make <em>you</em> healthier over time, but will give you firmer ground to stand on when you do need to interact with people who treat you poorly or who otherwise are leading lives of suffering and desperation that they don’t want to or know how to escape.</li><li><strong>Recognize trade-off decisions. </strong>We are limited beings with limited resources — time, attention, energy, money, etc. Anything we choose to do or become will foreclose other paths and opportunities. Sometimes people are terrified by this and choose to do nothing at all in the hopes that — magically — they won’t have to trade anything off. But of course this is a trade-off decision in itself. We cannot have, do, or be everything. And the more we choose to have, do, or be, the more we trade off the ability to go deeply into any of those things with our time, attention, money, or other resources. So choose wisely what you privilege and when.</li><li><strong>Make things right if you can, but don’t ruminate.</strong> At times we all fall short of the kind of behavior towards others that we know is acceptable. When you know or are made aware that you have harmed another person, do your best to make things right. What that means will differ from one situation to the next, so use your best judgment. The party you have hurt may or may not be receptive to your apology or attempt to repair things. Allow them to have whatever response they have without seeking to control it. And once you have done what you can to make amends, leave it alone. Don’t ruminate on your past actions, on the other party’s response to your apology, or on what could have been. Feelings of guilt are only useful as a prompt to do something to repair a situation. Once you have done what you can, let the guilt go. You don’t get any bonus points, or become a better person, by carrying it around.</li><li><strong>Recognize the limits of your control while taking responsibility for your power.</strong> You can’t force other people to change, and you can’t make the world the way you want it to be. However, you can work toward achieving your goals and making the world a better place by using the power you already do have responsibly and in line with your objectives. Often people get trapped in a cycle of ineffectiveness because they presume they have control they don’t have, while refusing to do the things that are actually within their power to achieve what they say they want. This is generally because it’s less exciting to consider the limited scope of our own influence, but it’s also scary to take responsibility for actions whose consequences we can’t fully anticipate. It is necessary, however, if we truly want to feel like we have agency in our own lives.</li><li><strong>Take care of your body. </strong>Physical health doesn’t come for free. It doesn’t require you to become a fitness guru or obsess over calories and nutrients, but it does require some discipline around diet and exercise. We live in a culture of excess where it’s easy to consume only food and drink with little nutritional value while living a sedentary lifestyle that precipitates disease. A little bit of discipline goes a long way toward longevity, health, and the ability to enjoy bodily pleasures when you do partake in them.</li><li><strong>Relativize authority. </strong>Humans everywhere use authority as a quick way of organizing knowledge (“what is true”) and making decisions (“what we should do”). Often, authority is useful because it allows groups of people to quickly coordinate action to solve a problem that can’t be solved by individuals alone. For example, a scientific authority may say that cleaning up a polluted river requires taking specific actions, and then a political authority may organize resources and deploy people to take those actions. But authority is also fallible and often misused. For example, a parent may believe they have the authority to tell their adult child what subjects to study, what job to have, who to associate with, or even whom to marry. This presumes that the parent knows what is best for the child and deprives the child of the autonomy necessary for an individuated life. Or a political authority may opine on questions of science about which they know very little. Often, we see people who have achieved great things in one area — say, running and selling a business — believe they have the authority to speak about someone else’s domain of expertise without understanding it. <br>Relativizing authority doesn’t mean getting in fights with authorities — that is usually ineffective in changing their views or behavior, and it will often bring terrible violence down upon us. Rather, relativizing authority means that we see it in its appropriate context. We acknowledge what this person or organization’s authority is based on and in what domain it applies, and we don’t extend it to other domains. We don’t lionize the authority and fully acknowledge its fallibility. Authorities that seem to be based in nothing — with no expertise and little to no value to society — can simply be done away with. Sometimes this happens through violence, but usually it happens simply by making those authorities obsolete — people stop caring about what they have to say and stop giving them resources (time, attention, money, position, power). Only through relativization can authority serve its most helpful function in society — beneficially organizing collective action — without falling into authoritarianism, or the overextended application of authority beyond its remit.</li><li><strong>Choose your battles well. </strong>Following on the above, there are countless potential battles we could fight in life. But we don’t have infinite energy, time, or resources. Every battle we fight will cost us emotionally, and potentially financially, socially, or professionally. Just like with other trade-off decisions, choose battles that will get you closer toward your goals. And when you do fight, fight to win. Many people fight mostly to prove something to themselves or others, which is just an ineffective way of expending energy. Or they fight blindly, without a strategy or tactics that will actually help them win. Fighting a battle is an expensive undertaking and should always be entered into consciously and with preparation.</li><li><strong>Know yourself. </strong>The age-old injunction of the Oracle of Delphi is as important today as ever. Self awareness has a lot in common with trusting yourself, but it also means having a sense for how you are motivated, how you typically behave, and <em>why</em> you are the way you are. Knowing yourself helps you better understand how you are different from others and the impact you have on people. It also protects your personality from people’s attempts to change you into a version of yourself that is simply more convenient or comfortable for them. It’s important to learn how to modulate yourself in a way that is appropriate to what you are trying to achieve in the social circumstances you are in; it’s also important to recognize where your behaviors may be harming others and need to change. But this must be done without compromising who you are. Cultivating self-knowledge is how all of these things can be achieved.</li><li><strong>Be yourself. </strong>Knowing yourself is important, but being yourself is even more so. It’s tempting to fall into the trap of unending self-analysis, cataloguing your problems or virtues, obsessing over your past, or going back and forth about what you “really” want and who you “really” are. Ultimately, having a tight narrative to describe yourself to yourself or to others is usually a way of concealing or omitting important things. Simply being yourself — without explanation or apology — is powerful. The world will form around you. And people will ultimately be more influenced by who you are than by anything you say, achieve, or claim to know.</li><li><strong>Character doesn’t come for free. </strong>I want to end on this note because one of the most common misconceptions I encounter in the self-help literature (and this includes much religious literature) is that morality is self-evident and people are either inclined to do “good” or “bad.” Sometimes writers urge you to change your inclinations by cultivating certain habits, but this often doesn’t go beyond a surface-level, behavior-based approach to character. But character is who you are when the social rewards and punishments are taken away: how would you be motivated to act if you thought no one would judge you, harm you, or reward you? That is shaped by how you see the world and the habits and patterns of behavior you have cultivated over a lifetime. Most of this cultivation happens unconsciously, but it can be consciously directed. When we see patterns and inclinations within ourselves that we want to change, we can do that through the work of cultivating character. This isn’t a project of forever “managing” our essential shortcomings — it’s a project of actively getting better over time. It is not only possible, but deeply rewarding. And it ensures that when we achieve the things we want in life, however we define success, that that success nurtures us and the people around us, rather than becoming the condition for a spiral into harmful behavior and unhappiness.</li></ol><p>This short list is not final but a work in progress — I continue to learn about life and about myself as I do the difficult but exciting work of growing up. But these principles can be applied by anyone in any stage of life to find greater fulfillment. Health and happiness are by-products of their application over time. They are evergreen.</p><p>Wishing you all peace, joy, and confidence as we navigate this shared world.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ccac20fb82b7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Never mistake a tool for the objective.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nsmolenski/never-mistake-a-tool-for-the-objective-221b2d110715?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/221b2d110715</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[obama]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Oct 2019 17:41:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-20T17:41:33.047Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What we can learn about hierarchy and disruption from the broken promises of the Obama administration.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GYbqxgtKCB_ij5CMoPa2Fw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The story of <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/140245/obamas-lost-army-inside-fall-grassroots-machine?fbclid=IwAR1WbnYNTN4lhHiWqEeWs8tUgAD113r4xb4p4txDecy6xeCdC_jQz5GgwiE">how the DNC killed the progressive grassroots energy behind Barack Obama’s 2008 campaign</a> by refusing to embrace a bottom-up theory of change — and Obama’s capitulation to them — is now fully available to historians. In 2007, Jon Schwartz devised “<a href="http://www.tinyrevolution.com/mt/archives/001705.html">The Iron Law of Institutions</a>” to describe this dynamic within the DNC: “the people who control institutions care first and foremost about their power within the institution rather than the power of the institution itself.” Jon stresses that this applies to most human institutions, not just the DNC. Institutions eventually take on a self-perpetuating logic that becomes oligarchic in its power structure.</p><p>The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_law_of_oligarchy">sociologist who intuited the above, Robert Michels</a>, eventually became a fascist, as he saw concentration of oligarchic power as an “iron law” that could not be changed — in keeping with the strongly deterministic bent of the social sciences in the early 20th century. We know, of course, that oligarchic institutions can be disrupted when the vectors of change are orthogonal: when they don’t ask permission of the institution (as Obama and his campaign leaders did of the DNC). Power hierarchies are always more fragile than they seem. The violence marshaled by institutions to defend themselves — from disinformation campaigns to legal challenges to outright physical suppression — is evidence of their fragility. This doesn’t mean they can’t do extraordinary damage. It just means they’re not invincible.</p><p>The 14th-century Moroccan sociologist Ibn Khaldun described the cycle of history as one of small marauding tribes with a “Bedouin ethos” based “group feeling” capturing corrupt, decadent empires who had succumbed to their seemingly self-evident hierarchies. We currently use this theory of change all the time in the tech sector — the story of the hungry, small, relatively egalitarian “startup” outcompeting the entrenched behemoth of a corporation is routinely trotted out to prove that meritocracy is alive and well. The reality is that any institution that becomes captured by the logic of its own hierarchy becomes vulnerable to this kind of challenge. We are seeing this play out today with governments, corporations, educational institutions, banks, media, and every other sector of society.</p><p>Remember: Hierarchy is just a tool. It allows human communities to get things done more quickly under circumstances where decisions need to be made and action coordinated relatively quickly. There is nothing self-evident about any hierarchy, anywhere, anytime. We can step in and out of hierarchies based on what we are solving for, and we can build systems that structurally preclude hierarchies from arising when that is necessary to preserve value over time (see <a href="https://www.facebook.com/hashtag/bitcoin?source=feed_text&amp;epa=HASHTAG">#bitcoin</a>).</p><p>Never mistake a tool for the objective.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=221b2d110715" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Does It Mean to “Own Your Data”?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nsmolenski/what-does-it-mean-to-own-your-data-514dfdd29208?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/514dfdd29208</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anthropology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Apr 2019 00:05:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-03T01:05:12.117Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A Structural Social Account of Human Ownership Allows Us to Move Beyond Terminological Battles</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zYZ3iNp-Lv6HgoDnjqLUog.jpeg" /></figure><p>Do you own your body?</p><p>I’d like to begin with this question because it prompts us to clarify what we mean when we talk about ownership of personal data. The question of whether or how we “own” our data has given rise to considerable controversy and debate as of late, but as is the case with many controversies, they arise in part because we haven’t really taken the time to define our terms.</p><p>What do we mean by “ownership,” and how does the adjective “digital” modify or nuance that meaning? In this brief piece I suggest a few ways we can begin thinking that question which point to the need for a structural social analysis — one that goes beyond the terms of a debate that have been primarily commercial, juridical, technical, and ethical. The reason a deeper structural analysis is necessary is because the fields above — commerce, law, technology, and ethics — derive their purchase largely from the particular local assumptions that frame the parameters of the problems and solutions they can possibly define and solve. This is why the social technologies of the past make little sense to us: whether it’s determining the number of cattle owed your tribesman for illegally breaking bread with his mother in law, or using a divining rod to cast for water currents to dig a well, these represent creative ways of meeting survival needs and resolving social tensions that no longer exist today as matters of everyday concern. Structurally, however, the problems of appropriate intimacy, restitution, and sustainability persist under different (also local) guises. So does the perennial problem of ownership and its derivative, property.</p><p>I started with the question, “Do you own your body?” in order to draw an analogy between something we generally consider an unproblematic “property” of self (but which sense of the word “property” do we mean here?) and the virtual sedimentation that accrues as an effect and index of that primary physical substrate. While much has been said about the need to bridge the physical/digital divide, the reality is that this divide itself is a cultural construct that presumes separation between body and mind, body and spirit, body and culture — a long inheritance in the Western philosophical tradition which has allowed for profound breakthroughs but which also has considerable limitations with which we are still wrangling. As we enter a century in which it is becoming possible to modify virtually any aspect of our self-presentation, and where the ongoing violence occurring in “virtual” lifeworlds is never neatly gated away from violence that impinges upon our bodies, we owe it to ourselves to think more deeply about the structures of ownership we can presuppose or interrogate going forward.</p><p><strong>The Body as a Condition of Legal Purchase</strong></p><p>Looking toward the future, it is highly likely that what we consider “physical bodies” — that is, the organic products of a gestational, developmental process rooted in millions of years of biological evolution — will not remain forever the sole condition of possibility for consciousness and subjectivity. In other words, as we move toward Artificial General Intelligence and its analogues and derivatives, we are creating a world in which consciousness will arise from many kinds of substrates and possess highly variegated characteristics as a result. For now, however, it is still our “body” with its “mind” (a product of the body-brain?) that is the vessel of our consciousness and agency in the world. Accordingly, you cannot “transfer” your subjectivity to a different substrate; nor can you sell your body in such a way that the buyer can make use of it without either also assuming the presence of your conscious self or destroying that self by killing you.</p><p>Yet this state of things is already being unsettled as the science of prosthetics advances. This includes neurobiological breakthroughs that facilitate the control of bodily movement at a distance. It is quite conceivable that at some point in the future, bodily control itself may be relinquished to pay for goods and services, with people agreeing to perform physical services or donate use of their physical agency as part of an exchange, in the same way that today they may give up their personal data at a point of sale. Similarly, nothing is to prevent governments from using “body overrides” as a new form of taxation, punishment, and social control. Corporate or state actors could influence behavior at scale by colluding to make certain movements more or less difficult. It is not a leap from these impingements upon the body to increasing encroachment upon the mind, with people literally allocating “mindshare” to companies and states in exchange for goods, services, and obligations.</p><p>For the time being, violations of “your” body — assault, battery, rape, harassment, murder — are, in principle, severely punished under virtually all legal regimes. (Of course, bodies are valued differently based on local hierarchies and so legal sanctions are weighted accordingly, but this is not yet a discussion of social hierarchy, so I will bracket this point for now.) In other words, in order to bring a legal claim against someone who has assaulted you, you must demonstrate that you are in fact in possession of a body and that that body was violated in some legally prohibited way.</p><p>This extends to “virtual” bodies as well: the legal fiction of incorporation has been used since the Middle Ages to confer social personhood, accountability, and restitution to human collectives that function together with common purpose. While today “corporate personhood” is much maligned in some activist circles as virtually synonymous with the preferential treatment of engines of revenue generation over actual human lives, doing away with the notion of corporate personhood would unravel a construct (for good or ill) that underpins virtually all contemporary human institutions.</p><p><strong>Virtual Bodies, Multiple Bodies</strong></p><p>So: a body, or <em>corpus</em> (physical and virtual), remains a necessary condition for most kinds of social personhood. Today, however, these bodies launch the products of their consciousness into new digital substrates which obfuscate the agent/body connection and allow for multiple agencies to manifest from the same organic body without having to invoke that body at all. Like the private key in a hierarchic-deterministic wallet, which generates new public keys to serve as identifiers for each new relationship, the organic body generates its digital avatars without needing to provide any reference to itself except in moments of high-stakes validation of claims. These virtual bodies may have very different identifiers and characteristics and never interact with one another.</p><p>Nevertheless, they still bear the brunt of social violence both <em>as</em> virtual selves and, more precariously, through their connection to their organic substrate body. Their violent public linkage to this organic body (for example, via doxxing, entrapment, network analysis, or other methods), with its everyday, “meatspace” identity and responsibilities, may result in catastrophic consequences for those who happen to be at odds with local social norms. Much like revealing one’s private key, revealing one’s physical body in digital space is an exercise in vulnerability — it holds out the possibility of someone else forcefully appropriating what is yours — i.e. of <em>theft </em>(and worse). This is why, <a href="https://oneworldidentity.com/podcast/an-owi-thanksgiving-with-dave-fields/">as identity investor Dave Fields has wryly remarked</a>, Bitcoin private keys are protected in pretty much exactly the same ways (underground armored vaults, human guards) as metallurgic stores of value like gold. The physical/digital divide is structurally pre-bridged.</p><p>So while it’s true (and at this point trivial) that on the internet, nobody knows you’re a dog, it’s also true that on the internet <em>you can be a dog </em>without either injunction or prohibition from an authority, and that is an amazing new condition of human possibility. Those who react to the growing importance of this liberative substrate with the instinct to inscribe onto it the logic of body-based (biometric) identifiers — where all agents can be immediately de-duped and made uniquely identifiable anywhere by those with the right informational privileges — are salting the earth of possibility the internet and its kin networks present. They are declaring that social and economic value emanates only from the top: from those actors privileged enough to maintain the virtual pseudonymity and anonymity that is structurally precluded for everyone else.</p><p>As a result, the “everyone else” may transact only on the terms of value created by this asymmetric surveillance relationship: exchanging bits of their (distended, virtual, embodied) selves for the necessities and pleasures of life. And as is always the case with social hierarchies, the privileged castes remove the most valuable objects, ends, and states of being from economic circulation as mere commodities and make them instead qualities of kind: just as Brahmins historically claimed the exclusive right/ability to read by virtue of karmic inheritance, and European nobility claimed that unique “qualities of blood” distinguished them from other classes regardless of their actual wealth, the new privileged classes will practice pseudonymity and anonymity on the basis of their unique relationship with the sources of capital generation and the sovereignty of the platform-state, which allegedly entitle them by definition to this informational seignorage.</p><p><strong>The Giving of Self</strong></p><p>But is this giving over of self-function, whether through data about the self or the body in which that self is “housed” (at least for the time being), really so new? Anthropologists have long recognized that ancient economies trafficked in various forms of self-giving as part of the regular ebb and flow of social relating. Marcel Mauss, in his treatise on gift economies, described “the gift” and its demand of reciprocity as a total social institution (that is, implicating entire collectives rather than discrete individuals) that eventually evolved into the modern institution of individual contract. Prior to contract, the gift represented a literal material/spiritual extension of the giver: both boon and debt note. Gifting defined relationships not only between human beings but between people and gods: the annual sacrificial calendar formed a “gifting circuit” that ensured the maintenance and growth of communal prosperity for both heaven and earth. Gift objects — jewelry, food, drink, land, crops, wives, slaves, cattle — were enduring, material reminders also of debt, of the provenance of value itself which was interpreted both as transcendental (from the gods) and as mundanely material (from my uncle in exchange for <em>x</em>).</p><p>There is no reason to believe the data economy will not also partake in this logic of debt and self-sacrifice. This is because the structures of human exchange have not changed much, despite an evolution of their forms. If you want something, something is required of you — always and without fail. Where it appears that nothing is required of you, you are contributing to wealth generation for the owners of the conditions that are generating value for you. The bill is either paid imperceptibly, or its payment is merely deferred.</p><p><strong>Inalienability</strong></p><p>The question now arises: in this fray of exchange, is there room for institutions characterized by <em>unconditionality</em>? For a giving or a taking that exists outside the logic of exchange? Anthropologists have argued that unconditional giving characterizes the most intimate and developmentally primal forms of human exchange, particularly in close kin relationships. A mother or father who keeps a running tab on everything they have spent on their children and then demands return payment would generally be considered monstrous. However, more diffuse logics of exchange enter even these close kin relationships: parental expectations that their children will care for them in old age, that their children will sacrifice their own desires and pursue goals or become people that the parents value, that their children will refuse or deny fundamental aspects of their personhood (interests, convictions, sexuality) as “payment” for parental services rendered — these are all just as commonplace as purported kin selflessness.</p><p>So, where even the “primary communism” of kinship cannot demarcate a pristine sphere of unconditionality, rights discourse enters history: whether through the concepts of human dignity, divine interdiction or mandate, or the sanctity of self/life/etc., human collectives have set boundaries beyond which commerce and even more fundamental logics of exchange are prohibited from going. Rights define the realm of sanctuary into which <em>even the debt collector may not enter</em>. The prohibition on slavery, for instance, makes it illegal to enslave people, even if they can’t pay their debts. This is very new: for most of human history, slavery (the forced labor of the body) was the collection of last resort. It was also an alternative to execution for criminals and prisoners of war (two categories that have often been conflated). Today, a growing number of human collectives simply posit that forced, unremunerated labor is always and everywhere unacceptable. That is because slavery violates something that must be unconditionally preserved for human individuals and societies to flourish: agency and dignity, qualities whose presence in human beings is increasingly seen as universal.</p><p>One of the concepts frequently invoked in rights discourse is <em>inalienability</em>: that there are certain properties (i.e. a house, a body, a quality, a right) which belong to a person essentially and <em>a priori</em>. Any attempt to alienate a person from this possession should be considered <em>prima facie</em> illegitimate and inadmissible within any legal framework. These inalienable possessions are not necessarily property in a commodity sense: that is, goods or services that can be bought and sold. Rather, they are elements critical to the flourishing of healthy human life and which comport to an individual’s “sphere of ownness” — of self-experience. These inalienable properties are generally identified intuitively and negatively: determined with reference to the adverse effects of commodifying and alienating them. These terrible adverse effects, primary among them unforced human suffering, become the impetus behind the positive project of rights demarcation — one that is never simply done and finished but continually evolving based on local needs.</p><p><strong>Inalienable Ownness</strong></p><p>The question is, can a framework of inalienability be applied to data? Is there, in fact, something in the category of personal data which should never, under any circumstances, be taken away? I argue that there is. In the same way that your body exists and “belongs” to you <em>a priori</em> — whether or not a state confers upon you an official identity; whether or not your parents name you; whether or not you “know” who you are — so your personal data is yours <em>a priori</em>, existing by virtue of your own existence as a human being. Accordingly, both your self-attestations as well as credentials conferred by others — identity documents, achievements, and credentials — should be considered <em>inalienable</em> and accessible by right. This fulfills several <a href="http://www.lifewithalacrity.com/2016/04/the-path-to-self-soverereign-identity.html">principles of self-sovereign identity as articulated by technologist Christopher Allen</a>: existence, control, access, portability.</p><p>You do not ask some authority for permission to take your body with you wherever you go, or to use it as you will. Likewise, your data is yours to take with you wherever you go, and to use how you choose.</p><blockquote>You do not ask some authority for permission to take your body with you wherever you go, or to use it as you will. Likewise, your data is yours to take with you wherever you go, and to use how you choose.</blockquote><p>Now, there are everywhere legally prohibited and socially sanctioned uses of both your body and your data — all human societies place normative constraints on behavior. I am not arguing here for the elimination of laws or norms. Rather, I am arguing for an <em>a priori ownness</em> (ownership, but not of a commodity) that makes the human body and its expressions a <em>possession</em> (though not necessarily “property”) of the individual they reference, and which may under no circumstances be alienated. Accordingly, they may be used by others with consent, but never taken away.</p><p>I propose that hostile acts such as revoking state-issued identity documents, refusing to issue or recognize legal identity documents, withholding academic records, or preventing people from accessing their own professional credentials without due process are violations of this human right to data ownership, in the same way imprisonment of a body without charge or selling someone into slavery are violations of human rights. For this reason also, my work has privileged the <em>unmediated</em> (that is, without vendor or issuer dependence) ownership of personal data. This end state is not something perfectly realized once and for all but an ideal pole toward which we are collectively striving. In a world where countless parties seek rent on every transaction you make and debt is still a principal way to be placed under surveillance and have your property alienated, individual self-sovereignty can only come from emancipatory architectures that provide for structural agency even in the face of the debt collector, the rent seeker, the employer, the family, and the state.</p><p>As Rousseau said in the eighteenth century, “Man is born free, but everywhere he is in chains.” Since that time, we have been sloughing off those chains one by one. It’s now time to liberate social personhood from dependency upon its mediators— to stop seeing it as as privilege, but as an inalienable right based on the <em>a priori</em> existence of persons.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=514dfdd29208" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[First Man]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nsmolenski/first-man-1004b04c177e?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1004b04c177e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[space-exploration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nasa]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Jan 2019 08:48:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-13T08:48:27.217Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5_X67glGBsR1p9kCz1fR0Q@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I just had the great privilege of seeing <a href="https://www.indiewire.com/2019/01/first-man-authentic-biopic-screenwriter-josh-singer-1202033682/">the movie First Man</a>. It is one of the most remarkable movies I’ve ever seen: a movie about failure and suffering. About the precarity and dismal odds of extraordinary ventures that are narrated as inevitable triumphs in retrospect. About the interdependence of multiple collectives and the singular individual in civilizational projects. Such projects are never the work of just one person; they require massive resourcing and distributed vision. Yet sometimes the success or failure of a massive venture can come down to just one person doing something at exactly the right time.</p><p>It is a movie about people choosing to do extremely difficult things together over long periods of time, and who they become, as individuals and together, in light of that. About a time before people spoke of their vulnerabilities the way they’re more accustomed to today, and the toll that took on them. About what they achieved nevertheless.</p><p>For these reasons, some American audiences didn’t like the film. Some stayed away from it altogether. They used words like “sad,” “cold,” and “unpatriotic.” Showing people in pain attempting to do world-historical things surrounded by social mistrust and lack of care is not the myth people are raised with and is a reality they generally don’t want to see. They want to believe the world is good and that there is always ultimately someone in power who will know, decide, and do what is right; that amazing outcomes are relatively straightforward or easy and once achieved, everyone lives happily ever after. Instead, the movie starkly juxtaposes the burden of care against a default backdrop of social indifference, and success as its own sea to navigate.</p><p>The movie also brilliantly captures the long bouts of silence that characterize mundane life, suffering, and space, without attempting to relieve people’s discomfort with silence. It shows failure in a novel way: Audiences generally love to see failure when it’s presented as a montage crescendoing to inevitable success, or as the “dark before dawn” narrative arc, but not as a recurring tragedy they must be present with, never knowing when or if it will end. They don’t want to be reminded of everything that is traded off and lost along the way. That everything came so close to being lost so many times. Of sacrifices that never returned reward for the people making them. Of deeply delayed gratification — sometimes delayed for generations. Audiences also love seeing heroic acts of generosity, but are often made uncomfortable by the deep generosity of the quiet selflessness over time that creates the experience of day-to-day normalcy for others. That makes the incredible appear normal and inevitable.</p><p>For all those of you who choose to do things not because they are easy, but because they are hard, this movie is a gift to you and a celebration of you, seen through the life of a man and many groups of people at various scales who did something utterly remarkable for the human species.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1004b04c177e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Incandescent Care]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nsmolenski/incandescent-care-4468ed9ec6d2?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4468ed9ec6d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[care]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Dec 2018 14:21:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-31T14:21:00.692Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The practice of self-suspension for the sake of something is a mechanism by which care moves us into the future.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FxkrDiaFWAoi5Ad5PwAhNQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/IAyLd1AYxdA?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Bradley Ziffer</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/incandescent?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>“I was really unhappy about how it went down for Tamils. And I had no help and nobody cared.” The rapper M.I.A. said this recently in an interview with Liz Goodman, a reporter for <em>Rolling Stone</em>. The piece, “<a href="https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/m-i-a-the-permanent-revolution-of-pops-most-fascinating-radical-248355/">The Permanent Revolution of Pop’s Most Fascinating Radical</a>,” meditates on the career trajectory of a woman who has been intimately connected to one of the world’s least-known revolutionary movements — the Tamil struggle for independence in Sri Lanka. While many anecdotes illustrate the dynamic struggles central to the formation of M.I.A. as a person, the simple phrase “I had no help and nobody cared” stood out to me for its stark nudity, like a leafless tree silhouetted against a winter sky.</p><p>We swim every day in a sea of words: spoken, written, read, listened to, sung, thought, screamed, whispered, repeated. And yet words that are true ring with a different timbre. It is as though a different place in the hollow bough-instrument has been struck. And what that leaves us with — us the hearers, that is — is an invitation to something that we may never at all have wished for. The sound of truth may be dissonant or harmonious; it may be complexly layered or bare in its simplicity. And yet there it is, perhaps simple, but not easy — hard.</p><p>Truth is hard not because it always engenders struggle, but because it is material, tangible. It is something to hold onto; it itself holds. Of course it may be simply ignored, forgotten, swept under various rugs, denied. The easy metaphysics of truth-triumphalism (“truth always wins in the end”) is very much a convenient falsehood, told when the invitation presented by truth is being refused. Those who benefit from the soft-focus arrangements enabled by truth-identical configurations of words, people, or ideas have every reason to indulge in this kind of inevitability narrative. If truth must necessarily win, then nothing is asked of me.</p><p>One of the difficulties truth presents is that the social conventions of meaning-making, which help us coast without too much cognitive load through the endless minutiae of life-making, suddenly seem to have abandoned us. The people we have leaned on to navigate the world, to whom we have perhaps even outsourced our navigational capacities, suddenly seem miles away. We encounter truth alone — floating on a sea with no one to come to our rescue. Not even those who may understand our experiences and inclinations under these circumstances, even those who have encountered the same truth, can help displace the weight of the invitation.</p><p>This predicament has been described with theological language; in some contexts as a “calling,” in others as a divine illness, and in many other ways. Yet its structure is familiar and profound. Something everyone thought they knew (or didn’t know, which is often the same thing) has suddenly appeared differently, manifesting in a manner that grammatically can be described as imperative. Truth inhabits a structure of demand.</p><p>Unskillful reactions to truth are legion. Alright, something has been encountered from which one cannot look away — an invitation has been felt in the body, rippled through crust to mantle to core. And now? Do I divorce my wife? Do I try to win back my child’s love? Do I blow the whistle? Do I say it out loud? Do I destroy something ugly — or something beautiful? Do I build something? What?</p><p>Posing the first question — the first honest question in response to the invitation — is the first manifestation of the quality that differentiates the transformative response to truth from its alternatives (denial, ignoring, forgetting, conveniently apotheosizing, etc.): care. Said another way, the one who asks, cares. Of course, the careful question is posed in good faith, not sophistry produced to smother what has just been encountered. And such smothering is both easy and likely. This is because the good-faith question is one to which there is no ready answer that plays to someone’s immediate advantage; it holds space for the unknown, for tension, for discomfort and pain.</p><p>The bad faith question, by contrast, believes it has already mastered the thing about which it pretends to ask. It is a tactical move on the existing game board, where the rules are (in the questioner’s mind) known to everyone and the objectives well-defined. The bad-faith question is a skewer; it is always there to kill something, and thereby fatten the position of the questioner. The bad-faith question plays excellently in the courtroom drama and all of its many analogues — theological sermon, morality play, political debate — all of these are really versions of the same thing.</p><p>The good-faith question, the question emerging from care, calls the terrain upon which the game is played into question. Not because the game is bad or wrong (it may or may not be, depending on how it’s evaluated), but because the encounter with truth has relativized it, hung it in a wider cosmos and thereby made it an object of inquiry. For this reason, the good-faith question is the beginning of method. It reproduces the structure of invitation which the encounter with truth introduced. Method could, indeed, be described as a good-faith response to the continual invitation to ask, to learn, to do, to be(come).</p><p>The doors of the good-faith question are open; the doors of the bad-faith question are closed in advance. The axis upon which this distinction turns is not sophistication or even skill but care. Care can be described as a moment of <em>self-suspension</em> <em>for the sake of</em> something; a bracketing of fears, desires, needs, and experiences in order to make room for something else, something new. This making-room is what holds the door open for the good-faith question and the life trajectory that begins with it and from it. Care lights the way, illuminating a navigable path in light of the event of truth that continues living and evolving with(in) the person who has recognized it.</p><p>Returning now to the truth statement with which I began: “I had no help and nobody cared.” The inclinations to dismiss, minimize, fix, or deny this statement I firmly push aside as knowing better responses emerging from bad faith. Instead, I see in this simple sentence something that any person on earth could potentially have uttered about a moment or ongoing predicament in their own lives: something they encountered alone, with no help, and without even the succor provided by the knowledge that someone else cared. It is these moments without help or care that describe trauma, and often enough the solitary journey in light of that trauma.</p><p>Yet the structure of care is such that it can be trained upon the self. Indeed, the illumination that care provides constitutes the first sign that hope is not lost; that a will exists for things to be better than they are, and to preclude future traumas. The self that becomes both the subject and object of care now has the ability to live a methodical life: to cultivate a set of inquiries, practices, and relationships that make the whole self the site of truth and responses to truths emerging from beyond that self.</p><p>We have inherited countless methods developed by other people in other times and places in response to their own encounters with truth — their traumas, their predicaments, their game boards. We are not obligated to carry them forward. Rather, we are invited to ask our own good-faith questions in light of what happened and what is happening with us. The methods that arise in response to our own incandescent care will not endure forever whole cloth, but those aspects of method that hold in a truthful sense — as handles that can be built upon reliably by many strangers over many years — will become the foundations of future ways of living and knowing that we cannot yet imagine.</p><p>The practice of self-suspension, of room-making, for the sake of something is therefore a mechanism by which care moves us into the future. As the year turns, we can turn to this as a source of comfort, and a guide.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4468ed9ec6d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Blockchains are Here to Stay]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/why-blockchains-are-here-to-stay-df1d290c336?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df1d290c336</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[credentials]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Oct 2018 14:30:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-31T15:01:35.107Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Blockchains can’t do everything, but they do two things really well: return ownership of personal data to individuals, and verify claims about identity.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hGT9VM5j_O9sij2rQ9nC4w.png" /></figure><p>As a company that sells software for issuing official records using a blockchain, Learning Machine sometimes encounters candid worries and concerns about the value and viability of blockchain technology. I wanted to take a moment to acknowledge some of those concerns and address them directly. If you have reservations about blockchain technology, hopefully by the end of this piece you will feel reassured and at least a little more open to the value blockchain technology can provide for your institution.</p><p>Now is a good time to write this piece, because over the past few weeks, <a href="https://twitter.com/Nouriel">Nouriel Roubini</a> has emerged as as a prominent public critic of blockchain technology. The other day the <a href="https://www.learningmachine.com/">Learning Machine</a> team got an email from someone asking us how much of Roubini’s recent article, “<a href="https://www.livemint.com/Opinion/FWk6Xchvj94uoFyELvkcXP/Opinion--Cryptocurrencies-and-the-big-blockchain-lie.html">Cryptocurrencies and the Big Blockchain Lie</a>,” they should be concerned about. Our response was perhaps not what some blockchain boosters would expect: we actually agree with quite a bit of what Roubini says. Nevertheless, we disagree with him on a few main points, which in our view undermine his conclusion that blockchain technology “has not even improved upon the standard electronic spreadsheet.”</p><p><strong>What Roubini Gets Right</strong></p><p>Let’s start with where we agree with Roubini’s analysis:</p><p>1. The vast majority of cryptocurrencies (tokens) will end up with a lower value than they started with, as virtually no one will use them.</p><p>2. Many of them were outright scams to make money in the short term.</p><p>3. There is a lot that blockchain technology cannot do by itself—for example, ending poverty, famine, or cancer.</p><p>4. Putting “the entirety of social and political life” on blockchains is a terrible idea.</p><p>5. Although blockchains themselves are highly secure, cryptocurrency exchanges (websites that allow people to trade tokens) have traditionally been highly insecure, with many notable hacks.</p><p>6. Some blockchains are more centralized than others. Ethereum, as Roubini points out, does have a “benevolent dictator” — Vitalik Buterin.</p><p>7. “Distributed Ledger Technology” — DLT — is in many ways an improved type of shared database because its governance and administration are centralized under the control of one or more institutions. For this reason, one could argue that it is not truly a “blockchain,” which has more decentralized governance.</p><p><strong>What Roubini Gets Wrong</strong></p><p>While much of what Roubini observes is true, his conclusions veer in the wrong direction. This is because:</p><ol><li><strong>He misunderstands how public blockchains work.</strong></li></ol><p>Roubini’s belief that public blockchains are insecure because they are public is a common (and understandable) misconception. He says, “there is no institution under the sun … that would put its balance sheet or register of transactions, trades, and interactions with clients and suppliers on public decentralized peer-to-peer permission-less ledgers.” This is trivially true. Pointing out use cases that make no sense does not argue against those that do, and for precisely the reasons Roubini lists, public blockchains simply are not used in the ways he suggests.</p><p>Public blockchains are called “public” because anyone can use them. Similarly, the internet is public because anyone can use it. In neither case would misguided uses of these public protocol stacks discredit the infrastructure itself.</p><p>When it comes to the question of data security, in many ways public blockchains are much <em>more</em> secure than the internet. This is because the data that needs to be verified is not recorded on the chain directly, but rather linked to the chain through various one-way methods. Some of those include hashing, pairwise decentralized identifiers (DIDs), and zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs). These technologies are all specifically designed to make off-chain data verifiable using public blockchains without putting the actual data on the chain. This means that data can also be “de-linked” when necessary. These methods make using public blockchains far more secure than a traditional database, because a public blockchain cannot be “hacked” to reveal sensitive information.</p><p><strong>2. Roubini doesn’t see the value of blockchains for verifying identity and returning ownership of data back to individuals.</strong></p><p>This is what Learning Machine uses blockchains for. There is a lot that blockchains can’t do, but there is also a lot they can — and the two main things blockchains are already being used for <em>today</em> are verifying official records (claims about identity) and returning ownership of data back to individuals. It’s quite simple: without blockchains, individuals will continue to be dependent on platforms owned by large software providers to access and use their data.</p><blockquote>It’s quite simple: without blockchains, individuals will continue to be dependent on platforms owned by large software providers to access and use their data.</blockquote><p>Data ownership is also one of the big advantages of using <em>public</em> blockchains specifically. If you’re using a private blockchain, the company or government running that chain still owns the network used to verify your data and prove your ownership. But if you’re using a blockchain that no one owns, you can take your data with you wherever and verify it wherever without worrying about losing access or the ability to verify.</p><p>You can read some <a href="https://www.learningmachine.com/customer-stories">real-world case studies of using the blockchain for data ownership and identity verification here</a>: they include institutions like MIT, Central New Mexico Community College, and countries like the Republic of Malta. The <a href="https://unblockedevents.com/2018/10/22/interview-with-eric-fish-fsmb/">Federation of State Medical Boards</a>, one of the most trusted institutions providing credentialing for medical professionals, is vocal about the potential blockchain technology has demonstrated for creating a more secure, independent credentialing ecosystem for everyone. Global adoption of blockchain for secure credentialing is gaining ground every month.</p><p><strong>3. Roubini says that because a Distributed Ledger is basically a shared database, it’s no better than a spreadsheet. That’s not true.</strong></p><p>Of course, as Roubini notes, not all blockchains are public. Private blockchains, or DLTs, that require permissions to use can also have value. These are like traditional databases in that they generally record much more data on-chain and have an access control system that authorizes interactions with the DLT. The more data you put on-chain, obviously the more you have to restrict who has permission to use that chain. This is why public blockchains record very minimal data, while private blockchains often record lots of data. Either may have value for different types of use cases, and each has its own security characteristics.</p><p>Distributed ledgers, even though they are permissioned and more centralized than public blockchains, can still do things spreadsheets can’t — for example, cut down the time it takes to <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/24/walmart-is-betting-on-the-blockchain-to-improve-food-safety/">verify the provenance of a mango or a diamond from 7 days to 2.2 seconds</a>. By creating a shared record of movements through a supply chain, DLT can also dramatically reduce the number of disputes and the amount of time and money companies spend arbitrating between different suppliers and shipment endpoints.</p><p>These efficiencies can both save lives and save suppliers significant money. This is why <a href="https://blogs.wsj.com/cio/2018/09/24/walmart-requires-lettuce-spinach-suppliers-to-join-blockchain/">Walmart is now mandating that its perishable food suppliers use the blockchain</a> to record the movement of each food SKU through the supply chain. That way, if, say, an <em>E. coli </em>outbreak occurs, it can be isolated to a specific batch of spinach rather than forcing the grocer to destroy all of its produce of the affected type. The issue can then be addressed much more directly with targeted process improvements up the supply chain.</p><p><strong>Blockchain for Identity Verification Is Inevitable</strong></p><p>I recently heard <a href="https://twitter.com/NSmolenski/status/1051247723310182401">Sandia Labs’ Nicholas Pattengale say that the impact of new technologies is overestimated in the short term, but underestimated in the long term</a>. Now that the blockchain hype cycle is dying down, a lot of the “overestimation” is dying down as well: people are realizing that blockchains are not a cure-all for every problem. But what is still <em>under</em>estimated is the impact blockchains will have for enabling individual ownership of data and verification of claims about identity. Over the next 5 years, most large institutions will quietly start using blockchains for identity verification.</p><p>It’s not a question of if; it’s a question of when.</p><p>How does Learning Machine approach using the blockchain for recipient identity verification? We do so by using the <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/top-10-reasons-to-use-blockcerts-ec7d29f2712c">Blockcerts</a> open standard, which we incubated with the MIT Media Lab. By using Blockcerts, you ensure that your institution implements blockchain for records verification in a manner that is <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/identity-and-digital-self-sovereignty-1f3faab7d9e3">self-sovereign</a> — empowering your organization and the citizens, employees, learners, and partners to whom you issue official records to own and verify their data for life. What that means is that even if Learning Machine, or any other software provider, used to issue Blockcerts goes away, you still own those certificates and can verify them using the open standard.</p><p>If you are an issuer of official records in any capacity, the blockchain stands to provide real value for your institution and your recipient stakeholders. Please <a href="https://www.learningmachine.com/contact">reach out to us</a>. We would love to continue the conversation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df1d290c336" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/why-blockchains-are-here-to-stay-df1d290c336">Why Blockchains are Here to Stay</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog">Learning Machine is now Hyland Credentials</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Innovating as a Customer]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/innovating-as-a-customer-f5d806ba5116?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f5d806ba5116</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Sep 2018 16:56:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-17T16:59:00.309Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The story of innovation usually focuses on companies building amazing new things. But rarely do we see the other side of the story: the customers who have the courage to make the future a reality. Without them, innovation simply wouldn’t happen.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*m4T6c2oI2MUWt8HMm35hfA.jpeg" /></figure><p>One thing I have learned in my work with customers all over the world: there are a lot of innovators out there. The vast majority of them don’t work in startups. Rather, they work in all kinds of organizations — schools, government ministries, multinational corporations, nonprofits. They have a secret, maybe something they’ve never said out loud:</p><p><em>They want to change the world.</em></p><p>Many of them have passion projects that aren’t directly connected to their everyday line of work, but make them better at what they do. Maybe they’ve started their own businesses on the side. Maybe they’ve contributed to open source projects. Maybe they’re artists. In short, there is something that motivates them to take courageous steps that few people ever see.</p><p>When you work for a technology company bringing fundamental change to an established way of doing things — like Learning Machine — these people find you. They don’t announce themselves. At first, they see real value and want to talk. Over time, it becomes clear that they are willing to do what is required to bring about the future. Some of them recognize opportunity and quickly seize it before the window closes. Others move slowly, methodically, creating the necessary conditions to introduce something new. Every organization — and person — is different. But what they all have in common is that they keep showing up, keep moving forward. They will not be deterred.</p><p>The word “<strong>customer</strong>” needs to be understood more broadly if it is to accurately describe who these people are. A customer isn’t just someone who pays money for a good or service.<strong> A customer is someone who puts their resources behind the world that is coming.</strong></p><p>People and organizations have a choice in how to spend their time, attention, and money. When they choose to place those valuable resources behind a transformative technology or a transformative team of partners, they are using the actual power they have to make the world better. There’s no magic to it, although it can often feel magical. The world simply changes because of the things we do, big and small. What we actually do is a choice we make about how to allocate the resources we have.</p><p>People often wonder how the world gets better. People often feel powerless to change things. Customers sometimes feel like if they’re not out building their own technology or company, they’re not really innovating. That could not be further from the truth. By contributing their vision, trust, and resources to new infrastructures and tools, they are using their real power to shape the direction in which the world moves.</p><p>That’s how you change the world. Together.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f5d806ba5116" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/innovating-as-a-customer-f5d806ba5116">Innovating as a Customer</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog">Learning Machine is now Hyland Credentials</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Top 10 Reasons to Use Blockcerts]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/top-10-reasons-to-use-blockcerts-ec7d29f2712c?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec7d29f2712c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain-technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 May 2018 12:01:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-19T13:33:39.128Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The open standard for issuing blockchain-based records is your easiest bet for creating records that remain verifiable for a lifetime.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*or_M-kju1TlooiJcEpuJKQ.png" /><figcaption>Verify any Blockcert instantly using the Universal Verifier at <a href="http://www.blockcerts.org/">Blockcerts.org</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>With more blockchain credentialing solutions popping up every week, it can be difficult to navigate the landscape of offerings. How do you decide which blockchain credentialing framework to use? One of Learning Machine’s previous posts <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/the-blockchain-in-education-5a322fe9fe86">discussed some of the options out there in more detail</a>, but in this post I want to keep it super simple: here are the top ten reasons to use the <a href="https://www.blockcerts.org/">Blockcerts</a> open standard for blockchain credentialing.</p><p>Notice I said top ten reasons to use “Blockcerts,” not top ten reasons to use “Learning Machine,” because while Learning Machine <a href="https://medium.com/mit-media-lab/blockcerts-an-open-infrastructure-for-academic-credentials-on-the-blockchain-899a6b880b2f">helped build Blockcerts with the MIT Media Lab</a>, we don’t own it. Blockcerts is published under an MIT Free and Open-Source Software (FOSS) License, meaning it’s free for anyone to use to build their own applications for issuing and verifying credentials. Learning Machine sells <a href="https://www.learningmachine.com/product/">software for <em>issuing</em> Blockcerts at scale</a> so institutions don’t have to build their own applications if they don’t want to. Learning Machine actually <em>wants</em> competitors out there also issuing Blockcerts: not only does this create a bigger, more competitive ecosystem for issuing institutions and their vendors, but above all, it helps recipients and relying parties who can use their Blockcerts in many different contexts instead of being marooned across varying proprietary platforms.</p><blockquote>Blockcerts helps recipients and relying parties who can use their digital records in many different contexts instead of being marooned across varying proprietary platforms.</blockquote><p>Unfortunately, some of the vendors out there who started out using the Blockcerts codebase ended up making their solutions proprietary in an attempt to create and maintain lock-in. This is against the spirit of the open standard. It would be like a vendor taking Open Badges, making changes to the code, and then selling a closed solution so you are dependent on their software to receive, view, and verify badges. This may be a way to make money, but it’s not a way to create a global, interoperable ecosystem for digital records. The people who suffer most from this practice are recipients, who are disappointed to find that their “digital credential” actually can’t be used very widely. And this gives digital credentials as a whole a bad rap.</p><p>So without further ado, here are the top 10 reasons to use Blockcerts:</p><ol><li><strong>Own Your Records.</strong><br>Blockcerts are co-owned by issuers and recipients, which means that issuers own and keep all the records they issue, even if they decide to switch vendors later on. It also means that recipients (students, alumni, workers, citizens) own and keep all the records they have received, even if if their government, company, or University switches to different records providers later. Recipients can still cryptographically prove that <em>they</em> are the individuals to whom certificates were issued. By contrast, most digital and blockchain credentials providers hold issuers’ and recipients’ keys for them, meaning they either can’t prove they are the rightful owners of their digital records, or they can’t take their documents with them if they choose to switch vendors later — or both. Not only does this make verification more difficult (how do you know whose digital credential you’re looking at?), but it defeats the purpose of using a blockchain. The promise of blockchain technology is that individuals should be able to <em>directly own</em> their digital assets without a middleman. That is <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/identity-and-digital-self-sovereignty-1f3faab7d9e3">what “digital self-sovereignty” means</a>.</li><li><strong>Vendor-Independent Verification.</strong><br>Verification of Blockcerts is vendor- and issuer-independent, meaning that if vendors are changed or issuers go out of business, Blockcerts remain verifiable. You can check out the Universal Verifier at <a href="https://www.blockcerts.org/">blockcerts.org</a> — it is a “Google for document verification” that will verify any Blockcert issued by any institution anywhere in the world, even if the original issuer or vendor used to issue the documents is no longer around. No need to download anything, buy tokens, or pay anyone. Verification is instant and free. This is important for documents that need to remain verifiable 10, 20, or 50 years from now. Try it out with some <a href="https://www.learningmachine.com/examples/">Example Blockcerts</a>!</li><li><strong>Issues to Multiple Blockchains.</strong><br>Blockcerts can issue to any blockchain (Bitcoin, Ethereum, Sovrin, Hyperledger, etc.). This means you can issue to multiple chains if you want to be extra secure, or just use the chain of your choice. No need to “pick a winner” blockchain today or get locked into a single company’s proprietary blockchain that might not be around in 5 or 10 years. Note: Many blockchain credentialing vendors don’t tell you <em>which</em> blockchain they actually anchor records to, because you’ve probably never heard of it! And those that do often want to lock you into using their proprietary blockchain, which generally has little adoption or chance for long-term survival. Remember, a blockchain is a network — how many “intranets” (closed networks so popular in the 90’s) are still around today? Answer: not many, because everyone just uses the public internet. When choosing blockchains, bet on large networks that have a proven track record for security and longevity. And hedge your bet by going with a solution that can issue to multiple chains.</li><li><strong>Portable.</strong><br>Blockcerts aren’t locked into any one identity platform. You can add them to any identity profile you choose — public profiles like Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, or an ePortfolio, or hold them privately and never associate them to a public profile. There is no need to create an account with Learning Machine or Blockcerts to receive Blockcerts — they’re sent peer-to-peer, directly from the issuing institution to the recipient. Recipients don’t need an account with Learning Machine to store, access, or share their records either. Issuers can store the Blockcerts they’ve issued in student profiles within their Student Information System, LMS, or CRM, or in whatever other database they choose. This means the <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/the-new-blockcerts-mobile-app-eea18053f526">free, open source Blockcerts Wallet</a> isn’t the only place recipients can store their Blockcerts. The Wallet allows recipients to prove ownership of their records by managing their keys, but it isn’t the only place you can keep a portfolio of your achievements!</li><li><strong>Private. </strong><br>Because Blockcerts are sent directly peer-to-peer, from issuer to recipient, only those two parties have copies of the records. And, if using a public blockchain like Bitcoin or Ethereum, no personally-identifiable information (PII) gets stored on the chain. Instead, what is stored is a “digital fingerprint” of the Blockcert: it can’t be used to reconstruct anything about the record, but the record references the hash for verification. If the issuer and recipient don’t want anyone to ever see the record, they can simply delete it. There is no way to recover the document from the blockchain. This makes <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/the-eu-general-data-protection-regulation-and-the-blockchain-1f1d20d24951">Blockcerts compliant with the GDPR, including the “right to be forgotten.”</a></li><li><strong>Interoperable.</strong><br>Blockcerts uses a standard data format (JSON-LD) which can be parsed by any system that can read structured data. This means it’s easy to automate verification and screening of Blockcerts without needing to buy special software. Some blockchain credentialing vendors have created proprietary file formats for their records that can only be decoded within their own ecosystem. Again, creating lock-in!</li><li><strong>Open Source, Open Security Review.</strong><br>Blockcerts is open source, meaning anyone can run a security audit of the code. What you see is what you get. With a “black box” solution, how do you know what is actually going on the blockchain and what is off-chain data? How do you know how verification actually works? How do you know where the security vulnerabilities are? Answer: you don’t.</li><li><strong>It’s Simple.</strong><br>This is perhaps the most important reason to use Blockcerts. So many blockchain solutions out there are based on a company’s ICO or proprietary blockchain, where you have to buy tokens, create accounts with identities tied to their blockchain, and everyone who issues, receives, or verifies the records has to become part of the network somehow. With Blockcerts, institutions can issue, recipients can receive, and relying parties can verify digital records without having to buy tokens, run a node, or become “members” of a network. You don’t even have to know what a blockchain is to use Blockcerts. It’s designed to be as open and easy as possible.</li><li><strong>It’s the Future.</strong><br>By 2020, most companies and governments will be using the blockchain in some way for verification of claims. The main question we have to answer now is, will organizations go with a solution that privileges ownership of data and vendor independence, or will they choose solutions that give ownership of their data over to yet another series of vendors? We are now at the exciting historical moment when we get to choose what our future will look like. Everyone who chooses an open standard makes the world better for everyone else. Blockcerts is a public good that creates a global ecosystem of truly interoperable, enduring digital records for all.</li><li><strong>Support a Women-Led Blockchain Company! </strong><br>OK, the tenth reason isn’t strictly a reason to use Blockcerts, but there’s a lot of discussion about the need for more inclusivity and diversity in tech and crypto. Learning Machine isn’t just talking the talk — we’re walking the walk. Our <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/kimdhamilton/">CTO is Kim Hamilton Duffy</a>, who is also Principal Architect of Blockcerts. She’s also Co-Chair of the <a href="https://www.w3.org/community/credentials/">Credentials Community Group at the W3C</a>, which is working on cutting edge, blockchain-based digital identity technologies like <a href="https://w3c-ccg.github.io/did-spec/">Decentralized Identifiers (DIDs)</a> and <a href="https://www.w3.org/2017/vc/WG/">Verifiable Claims (VCs)</a>. <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/nataliesmolenski/">I lead Business Development</a> and love translating Kim’s genius into concrete projects that make the world better. We’re a close, supportive, and talented women-led team. If you choose to license the Learning Machine Issuing System to issue your Blockcerts, you are contributing to the brain trust behind the open standard and supporting a future-focused company.</li></ol><blockquote>The upshot: Everyone who chooses an open standard makes the world better for everyone else. Blockcerts is a public good that creates a global ecosystem of truly interoperable, enduring digital records for all.</blockquote><p>So, if you want to try out the world’s simplest way to issue independently verifiable, recipient-owned, secure digital records, <a href="https://www.learningmachine.com/contact/">reach out to me</a> — I’m happy to show you what’s possible!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec7d29f2712c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/top-10-reasons-to-use-blockcerts-ec7d29f2712c">Top 10 Reasons to Use Blockcerts</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog">Learning Machine is now Hyland Credentials</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Net Neutrality as Generational Struggle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nsmolenski/net-neutrality-as-generational-struggle-c29756bb9644?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c29756bb9644</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[net-neutrality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[debt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[millennials]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Dec 2017 18:46:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-15T18:58:38.900Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VspbuwGHFvwTvf_quQ5f6A.jpeg" /><figcaption>The <a href="http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/fcc-evacuates-meeting-room-due-to-security-threat-just-before-net-neutrality-vote/article/2643513">FCC temporarily evacuates</a> the scene of the Net Neutrality vote in response to a security threat.</figcaption></figure><p>Yesterday the FCC voted 3–2 along party lines to <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/14/16776154/fcc-net-neutrality-vote-results-rules-repealed">repeal Net Neutrality rules</a>. The decision has prompted intense and varied commentary, but it has not frequently been framed in terms of a fundamental generational divide in the United States. This article places the world-historical importance of a freely accessible internet in the context of a debt economy in which younger generations must purchase access at the price of spiraling interest paid to older generations. In other words, the internet has functioned as an infrastructure of enfranchisement for generations who could not expect it through traditional channels. This enfranchisement occurs not simply in terms of cultural belonging or political activism, but in education (increasingly self-directed and lifelong) and entrepreneurship in a world where gatekeepers are keen to prevent the young from disrupting a manicured, hierarchical equilibrium. The internet has of course enfranchised not only younger generations, but many marginalized groups; however, this article focuses on a generational analysis because it points to a structural faultline in American society that goes frequently un- or misrecognized.</p><p>On November 24, <em>The</em> <em>Wall Street Journal </em>ran a front-page article entitled, “Rise and Fall of a Law School Empire.” It tells the story of an entrepreneur, Don Lively, who set out to give underserved minorities access to law school by opening a for-profit institution, Florida Coastal School of Law, that would accept candidates rejected elsewhere. Don, a white professor, hoped his school would help close the representation gap in the legal field. Initially, small class sizes and skilled teaching led to great results: in 2009, 83% of first time test-takers passed the bar, compared to a Florida state average of 80%.</p><p>Investors then got involved and attempted to scale the operation by opening up multiple branches in underserved cities under a network called InfiLaw. As the economy recovered, however, applications to law schools dried up. InfiLaw schools felt pressed to keep admissions (and revenue) up by continuing to lower admissions standards. To cover the costs of tuition and living expenses, many of their students relied on Grad Plus, a 2006 federal student loans program which allows students to borrow unlimited amounts of money for graduate school.</p><p>By 2016, fewer than one in five students at the Charlotte School of Law, a North Carolina branch of InfiLaw, were able to pass the bar exam and get a job that required a law degree. North Carolina revoked its license, and it shut down in August 2017. The majority of its students have left with a combination of no job and exorbitant student debt. Their debt has since been sold by the federal government to private collectors for pennies on the dollar.</p><p>The tale of InfiLaw resembles nothing so much as the sub-prime mortgage crisis. In an effort to extend home ownership to poor and middle class Americans (and make large profits from doing so), banks drastically lowered standards for taking out mortgages, leaving millions of people with homes they could not afford. When debts came due, these families lost their homes and found themselves under mountains of debt, much of which was paid by the taxpayer through bank bailouts and by bank shareholders through bank settlements.</p><p>Education in the US is an expense akin to buying a house — one which the vast majority of college-age Americans simply cannot afford without taking out the equivalent of “education mortgages.” However, unlike mortgage debt, education debt cannot be discharged through bankruptcy, thanks to a 2005 federal law designed to prevent students from gaming the federal student loan system. Unfortunately, what has happened instead is that schools — public and private, for-profit and nonprofit — have been gaming the federal loan system by raising tuition costs at a much faster rate, contributing to the vicious cycle of increasingly unaffordable education paid for by greater and greater individual debt.</p><p>The Millennial generation came of age at the nexus of these two debt crises: the mortgage crisis, which destroyed their employment prospects just as they were entering adulthood, and the education loan crisis, which has saddled them with more debt at an earlier age than any generation in American history. Many in the Baby Boomer generation — and the vast majority of the legislative, judicial, and executive branches of the US government are Baby Boomers — simply cannot understand this predicament. An especially illustrative comment came from Senator Orrin Hatch, who posted on Twitter on November 17:</p><h3>Orrin Hatch on Twitter</h3><p>I grew up in a shack with a Meadow Gold Dairy sign for a wall. I worked as a janitor to pay for law school. I believe in opportunity because I&#39;ve lived it. And that&#39;s what we&#39;re going to deliver with #TaxReform. https://t.co/D4VUj3lwls #utpol</p><blockquote>I grew up in a shack with a Meadow Gold Dairy sign for a wall. I worked as a janitor to pay for law school. I believe in opportunity because I’ve lived it. And that’s what we’re going to deliver with #TaxReform. #utpol</blockquote><p>Such a career trajectory is simply be impossible today. The average tuition for a public legal school in the US is $17,000 per year, which a janitor making the national average annual salary of $23,000 could never afford. The tax reform plan Senator Hatch is touting would give this janitor back about $200 annually (in the House plan) or about $350 annually (in the Senate plan) — hardly enough to enable her to attend law school. She is far more likely to take out a federal Grad Plus loan to attend a for-profit, private law school with a much higher tuition and an uncertain trajectory.</p><p>For Millennials, then, the back and forth of “pro-” and “anti-” government regulation debates that characterize American party politics are of little relevance. This is because both corporations and the state collude to extract the maximum amount of profit from them through debt interest. Rather than paying debt forward by building a social infrastructure of care to launch their children into the world, the Baby Boomer generation instead chose to structurally treat their children as a source of their own future profit. This is what Malcolm Harris has argued in his recent book, <em>Kids These Days: Human Capital and the Making of Millennials</em>. In short, he writes, “Millennials were the first generation raised explicitly as investments.” Investments for their parents — their perpetual creditors — not investments for themselves.</p><p>This generational debt peonage has, unsurprisingly, created a cycle of dependency upon parents, which those same Baby Boomers now see as a sign of inexorable moral decline in their own children. Most of this moral hysteria has been displaced, however, upon the most significant infrastructural innovation separating Boomers from younger generations: the Internet. While structural analysis of the material predicament of Millennials circulates mostly within that generation’s social circles, articles on the dangers of social media and smartphones are almost guaranteed to go viral across generations. Smart phones and social media have been repeatedly identified as the main culprits behind rates of anxiety, depression, and suicide among adolescents, which have been rising since the mid-2000’s.</p><p>Yet this blame game doesn’t present a nuanced enough account of the inexorable role the internet has played as a space for social identity formation, learning, free expression, and self-discovery for Millennials and younger generations. For every story about cyberbullying, there is another story, usually untold, about a kid from a small town who didn’t commit suicide because he found other kids like him online. Someone who discovered an educational or professional opportunity or help for a baffling medical condition who wouldn’t have otherwise. The internet has also fundamentally relativized local social norms in a way that is largely irreversible (barring a terrible black swan event). It is no longer possible to hide abuses of power in the village by making its worldview seem inevitable. Despite the destructive psychological impact of reputation gamification through social media, no evidence exists that it is any more vicious than the forms of reputation gamification that existed among previous generations. If anything, the Internet has been revealing those aspects of human society that have previously been much easier to hide — for good and for ill.</p><p>So pervasive is the influence of the internet for digital natives that free and unfettered access to it is increasingly presumed to simply be a human right. And this belief is shared not just by internet users from younger generations, but by their entrepreneurs and capitalists. The major internet-based businesses that have grown up since the 1990’s have largely been founded or led by Gen-Xers and Millennials; their success as businesses is inexorably tied to an open internet. “Net Neutrality” — equal access to all content on the internet — has emerged as a rallying cry for many in these groups.</p><p>Although Net Neutrality also refers to FCC rules promulgated under the Obama administration, which mandate that ISP’s provide equal access to the internet, the principle behind these rules is what appeals to Millennials. They support Net Neutrality not because they love government regulation, but because they correctly recognize that the business incentives of large Internet Service Providers — Comcast, AT&amp;T, Verizon, and Charter — correlate restricting access with profit. Not only that, but American ISP’s, mostly founded and run by Baby Boomers, are functional monopolies in particular geographical areas based on longstanding agreements they have with the state. There is little incentive for them to broaden access or improve their services. Younger generations not only expect the internet to be available to everyone, but fast and unencumbered. The business model of ISP’s militates against this outcome. This is why some tech companies have taken the goal of widening internet access into their own hands, most prominently Google through its Project Loon.</p><p>Of course, the big tech companies also turn access into profit; however, they do so on the back-end by allowing users to pay in data to generate a data-based profit ecosystem for industry and government, rather than on the front end by charging for it, as ISP’s do. The point here is not to valorize one business model over another, but to indicate that presuppositions about internet access are fundamentally different for younger generations. While Net Neutrality won’t directly address the structural predation practiced against younger generations by banks, governments, and educational institutions, it forms the conditions of possibility for a new kind of social fabric from which solutions might grow.</p><p>The self-assertion by the anti-competitive status quo through coordinated efforts by ISP’s and the FCC to do away with Net Neutrality rules signals nothing so much as older generations attempting to preserve their increasingly outdated business models. This generational struggle also recently came into relief on Cyber Monday, when America’s largest tech companies made an appeal to the FCC to preserve the Net Neutrality rules. But the Boomer-era ISP’s have their men in office now (yes, all three FCC Commissioners who voted to repeal Net Neutrality were men), who exercise power for their benefit. Obama’s appointee for FCC Commissioner, who became Trump’s appointee to FCC Chair, Ajit Pai, has had only one agenda: doing away with Net Neutrality. And he succeeded in orchestrating a repeal vote on December 14, 2017. Whether or not that decision will be implemented remains to be seen: <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/after-fcc-abandons-net-neutrality-states-take-up-the-fight/">over a dozen states’ Attorneys General immediately sued the FCC</a> to preserve the rules.</p><p>In short, Millennials — and younger generations — are being structurally preyed upon by both corporation and state, both still largely run by their parents’ generation. While the biggest companies of their generations also transform internet access into profit, at the very least they share the belief that access itself should not be gated. The internet has been a source of unparalleled empowerment for this generation, and this is in large part what makes it a target for those who don’t understand its value or see it primarily as a threat to their own incumbency. The unfortunate truth is that the centralized structure of the traditional web makes access restriction by powerful social actors possible — even likely to succeed. The <a href="https://www.accessnow.org/keepiton-shutdown-tracker/">Shutdown Tracker Optimization Project (STOP)</a>, which monitors restriction of internet access around the world, is recording rapidly-accelerating actions by states and corporations to prevent the free use of the web. For this reason, the main thrust of the next generation of internet innovation is occurring under the rubric of decentralization. Ultimately, preserving equal access to the internet is most likely if no central authority is empowered to make decisions about access in the first place. The FCC’s Net Neutrality vote is only another battle in this ongoing struggle.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c29756bb9644" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The EU General Data Protection Regulation and the Blockchain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/the-eu-general-data-protection-regulation-and-the-blockchain-1f1d20d24951?source=rss-e8367010507e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f1d20d24951</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[europe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gdpr]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalie Smolenski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Aug 2017 06:22:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-02T08:56:54.910Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yGuv6a3bglARfnIZd0htkw.png" /></figure><h4>A Declaration of the Rights of the Digital Subject</h4><p>The <a href="https://gdpr-info.eu/">European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)</a> is set to become active on May 25, 2018. It was created as a response to the rapidly-evolving challenges posed by the 21st-century information economy to the preservation of individual privacy and autonomy. These challenges have entered the popular lexicon under the terms “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism">surveillance capitalism</a>” and “<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Platform-Capitalism-Theory-Redux-Srnicek/dp/1509504869">platform capitalism</a>,” both of which describe an economy in which information — specifically, information about people, stewarded by centralized infrastructure providers — increasingly forms the raw material for profit.</p><p>It is not essentially a bad thing for corporations to make use of information about actors within their markets to better target their products and services. Particularly in an economy where personalization and niche industries proliferate in the absence of geographic colocation, the ability to reach the right audience and deepen customer relationships is crucial for the survival of many companies — not only large ones but especially small and medium-sized businesses. Danger arises, however, when individuals no longer have control over how their information is collected and used. Under those conditions, the good-faith matching of content to audience and knowing your customers becomes an intensifying regime of control and unending, predatory solicitation. The consumer becomes a <em>de facto</em> victim.</p><p>To remedy this, the EU has crafted the most robust and far-reaching privacy legislation the world has yet seen. Any company that does business in Europe will need to comply or face steep fines (up to 4% of global annual turnover). The GDPR mandates that the rights of the “data subject,” that is, the individual whose data it is, be protected. These rights include (in summary):</p><blockquote>Article 12: The right to have questions about use of personal data answered, and to seek redress if these questions are not answered in a clear, concise, timely manner.</blockquote><blockquote>Articles 13 &amp; 14: The right to know how personal data is being used at the time of collection, as well as the length of time for which it will be stored and contact information for the collecting party.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 15: The right to access the personal data that is being processed.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 16: The right to have incorrect personal data rectified.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 17: The right to have personal data erased when they are no longer necessary for the purposes for which they were collected and there is no legal ground for their maintenance.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 18: The right to restrict data processing where the data is inaccurate, its collection unlawful, or its processing no longer required.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 19: The data collecting party must inform all additional data processors with whom it shares personal data to cease processing data that has been rectified or erased.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 20: The right to receive their personal data in a structured, commonly-used, machine-readable format which they can freely share with other data processors.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 21: The right to object to personal data being used to profile or market to them.</blockquote><blockquote>Article 22: The right to not be subject to legal outcomes that rely solely on automated data processing.</blockquote><p>In addition to the explicit declaration of the rights of the data subject (data access, data portability, right to erasure, etc.), the GDPR also mandates that data controllers and processors abide by the principle of “<a href="https://gdpr-info.eu/art-25-gdpr/">data protection by design and default</a>.” This means architecting solutions with privacy as a foundational consideration rather than as an afterthought or add-on. It includes, wherever possible, employing techniques such as <em>pseudonymization</em> (decoupling data from individual identity) and <em>data minimization</em> (sharing only absolutely necessary data points) to protect privacy. Finally, by requiring that data controllers and processors use common technology standards, the GDPR aims to create an environment maximally friendly to individuals needing to transfer data between different vendors, governments, and institutions at their own discretion.</p><h4>The Blockchain: Data Protection by Design and Default</h4><p>All together, the GDPR could be considered a “Digital Declaration of Rights.” In listing the detailed requirements by which any institution or individual that processes personal data must abide, it places limits on the power of <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/identity-and-digital-self-sovereignty-1f3faab7d9e3">“digital states” — software platforms</a> — and those who make use of them. By doing so, it reflects a commitment to many of the <a href="http://www.lifewithalacrity.com/2016/04/the-path-to-self-soverereign-identity.html">principles of digital self-sovereignty</a> articulated by Christopher Allen in an influential 2016 essay. However, the GDPR also takes for granted centralized models of digital data storage and transmission that are now in the process of being replaced by newer ones based on distributed ledger technologies, most prominently blockchains. Blockchains get us closer than ever before to modes of digital identity in which the <em>user is the primary owner</em> of their data.</p><p>Centralized models of data storage rely on the implicit premise that custodians of information are trustworthy actors with a mandate to steward personal data. Blockchains, however, were designed in light of the frequent failure of even the best-intentioned centralized authorities to live up to their promise as stewards of the public trust. Accordingly, blockchains were built to function in a “trustless” environment — that is, one in which people can transact directly with one another without needing to trust any other actor in the ecosystem. This is why blockchains are not only decentralized but <em>distributed</em> — none of the nodes in the network running a blockchain protocol acts as an authority over others. A structure of incentives mediated by unidirectional cryptography ensures the integrity of a ledger of transactions that is shared by all the nodes, without relying on human beings to come to consensus. In short, math, executed and validated by a network of computers, functions as a substitute for middlemen.</p><p>Not only does the blockchain remove the need to trust a centralized authority in order to keep an accurate record of activity, but it makes surveillance of activity extremely difficult. There are many different types of blockchains out in the world today, but the Bitcoin blockchain, the world’s largest and most secure blockchain, was designed with pseudonymity and data minimization built in. All it records are the following pieces of data:</p><ul><li>The public key of the transaction sender</li><li>The public key of the transaction recipient</li><li>A cryptographic hash of the transaction content <br>(This could be anything: a land title, a birth certificate, an academic diploma, a copyright, an article of clothing, currency, a quantity of precious metal, etc.)</li><li>The date and time of the transaction</li></ul><p>This is “data protection by design and default.” It’s impossible to reconstruct the content of a transaction from the one-way cryptographic hash. And unless one of the parties to the transaction decides to link a public key to a known identity, there is no way to map transactions to individuals or organizations. What this means is that even though the Bitcoin blockchain is “public” — that is, anyone can see all the transactions on it — no personal information is made public. This is by design: it allows anyone to validate the integrity of the transaction ledger without violating the privacy of the parties transacting on it.</p><h4>Blockchain Applications: Centralization All Over Again?</h4><p>The Bitcoin blockchain was built with the intention that each individual transacting on it would own their own blockchain “address” — that is, their public and private keys. This makes individuals the true owners of their personal data, which they can transport and present for verification wherever they need to.</p><p>However, management of one’s own keys is far from an intuitive process. And the stakes are high: if a private key is lost or stolen, all of the data it owns is gone as well. For this reason, many applications that write transactions to the blockchain don’t give users their own keys. Rather, they <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/digital-identity-and-the-blockchain-10de0e7d7734">function as new centralized authorities</a>; they write transactions to the blockchain using their own keys. While appearing convenient for the user, this strategy has three broad implications:</p><ol><li><em>Uncertain identity: </em>Without proof of ownership, identity verification (i.e. making sure the person presenting a blockchain transaction is the one who really received it) continues to be insecure.</li><li><em>No longevity:</em> If these centralized blockchain applications go away, the individual has the same problem they would have had if a traditional centralized software platform (like Facebook or their University account) disappears: their data is gone.</li><li><em>Vendor/Issuer Dependence:</em> The recipient of blockchain transactions is in a new relationship of dependence: now with the application provider (usually a software vendor, but it could also be an issuing institution).</li></ol><p>In other words, many of the applications that use the blockchain are still functioning from the centralized authority model whose overreach the EU General Data Protection Regulation was designed to reign in. Some applications, however, hew very closely to the original promise of the blockchain for self-sovereign digital identity — a promise whose values are echoed in the GDPR legislation.</p><h4>Blockcerts: Beyond GDPR Compliance</h4><p>In order to achieve wide adoption as a consumer-facing technology, key management must be radically simplified and mediated through an intuitive user experience. The <a href="http://www.blockcerts.org/">Blockcerts</a> Wallet (<a href="https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/blockcerts-wallet/id1146921514?mt=8">iOS</a> and <a href="https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.learningmachine.android.app&amp;hl=en">Android</a>) is an example of an application that manages users’ public and private keys in a way that allows them to independently receive official records anchored to the blockchain. It doesn’t rely on centralization to achieve this: the app and the data it stores are not owned by any vendor or issuing institution, which means there is no centralized honeypot for attackers. It is also fully open source, so anyone can inspect the code and confirm that it meets the highest security standards, or build their own versions of the app.</p><p><a href="http://www.blockcerts.org/">Blockcerts</a> allows for issuing official records to the blockchain in a common, machine-readable format (JSON-LD). By using an open technology standard, Blockcerts also solves for maximum portability and interoperability of official records: recipients can take them anywhere in the world, and any organization can verify their authenticity and their ownership by the individual presenting them.</p><p>The issuing institution may choose to retain copies of issued certificate files in their own database, in which case they will need to protect them under the auspices of the GDPR, along with any other recipient data they choose to store. But Blockcerts recipients can rest assured that for the first time, they have vendor-independent, authentic digital documents which they own directly. And because they are written to a maximally-secure blockchain using an open standard, they have them for life and can verify them anywhere in the world.</p><p>The blockchain represents the opportunity to not only fulfill but go beyond the promise of the European General Data Protection Regulation. While not all applications that write transactions to the blockchain achieve this promise, some, like the <a href="http://www.blockcerts.org/">Blockcerts open standard</a>, do — and those will be at the forefront of digital privacy and self-sovereignty for years to come.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f1d20d24951" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog/the-eu-general-data-protection-regulation-and-the-blockchain-1f1d20d24951">The EU General Data Protection Regulation and the Blockchain</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/learning-machine-blog">Learning Machine is now Hyland Credentials</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>