<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Neil Weintraut on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Neil Weintraut on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 14:14:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@nweintraut/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Next Fundable Milestone]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/the-next-fundable-milestone-77933ae6bc70?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/77933ae6bc70</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Jun 2023 23:45:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-11T16:23:21.222Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Startup Founders, CEOs, Board Members and Investors take note: given a big market, a good team, enabling innovations, and a beachhead - to raise each successive round of capital, focus operations to succeed in the market, and even just simply have a compelling “pitch” for raising venture capital; a startup needs to be run and presented in a very specific way. This way is the practice of <em>running a startup to the Next Fundable Milestone</em>.</p><p><strong>No Cash No Company</strong></p><p>Startups are growth businesses and business growth requires cash.</p><p>The significance of this for a startup is black-and-white. At each stage of a startup’s life, a startup that achieves “something” that attracts more cash lives to fight another day (or more specifically to do this same process again), whereas a startup that does not, ends. This “something” that attracts more funds, is the Next Fundable Milestone</p><p>No cash no company. The rest of this article shows that this existential fact is not only is running and presenting a startup to the Next Fundable Milestone essential to success, but it actually makes running it easier and better.</p><p><strong>Investors Need It</strong></p><p>Any investor that has invested in at least one startup has seen firsthand the stark reality of no cash no company — that stark reality being that with the capital that an investor puts into a startup, that startup either achieves a milestone that attracts more capital (in which case, their investment is either preserved or even increased in value), or their investment becomes worthless.</p><p>So at any stage in a startup’s life, in order to attract more cash necessary to keep a startup alive, a startup needs to show prospective investors two fundable milestones:</p><ol><li>The milestone that it <em>just achieved</em> with the previous capital that it had, and</li><li>The <em>next</em> milestone that it will achieve with the capital that it is raising now.</li></ol><p><strong>Easier and More Successful</strong></p><p>While running a startup to the Next Fundable Milestone appears to be yet another burden for a startup, it actually makes a startup easier to run, more successful and even realizes less dilution.</p><p>Running a startup to the Next Fundable Milestone focuses it — and in particular, focuses it on the very items leading to success not just with investors but in their marketplace.</p><p>Many startups, for example, just “do stuff”, figuring that merely doing whatever they think is good stuff, will be rewarded with more capital. Not only does this not result in more capital but the startup isn’t nailing what customers or partners want, leaving the startup to fall further and further behind while the market and startups that did run to the Next Fundable Milestone move ahead.</p><p>In contrast, running a business to the Next Fundable Milestone focuses a startup on Product Market Fit. Product Market Fit is the rarified set of product features, pricing, targeting, marketing, partnerships and other nuances that win customers. Being on a path of Product Market Fit to more and more customers is what investors need to see to invest in the latest round of a startup — and it is also exactly what a startup needs to succeed in its market.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ucXio9a61U3OcFMl" /></figure><p>But this is only the beginning of the wisdom and benefit of running a startup to the Next Fundable Milestone.</p><p>For one, running a startup to the Next Fundable Milestone does away with the myriad of other features, ideas and things that a startup would otherwise waste capital and time; decisions are made; and employees have clarity in what they should do.</p><p>Running a startup by and to the Next Fundable Milestone also makes its Board functional and useful. With the Next Fundable Milestone, Boards have the means to gauge progress, make well-founded decisions, and avoid distracting tangents, whereas without running to The Next Fundable Milestone, Boards listlessly drift into minutia and fail to act on a path that cumulatively builds success.</p><p><strong>Auto-Populated “Pitch”</strong></p><p>Given a big market, a good team, enabling innovation, and beachhead in order to invest in your startup, investors need to see that you are turning these things into a continuously fundable business. That is, fundable milestones — the milestone that the startup just achieved with the capital that it had; the next fundable milestone that it is set up to achieve with the capital that it is raising now, and the mindset to make it happen.</p><p>For startups that fail to run their business to the Next Fundable Milestone, they find themselves frustrated and bewildered as to why investors aren’t responding favorably to their otherwise appearing story.</p><p>In contrast, startups that run their business to the Next Fundable Milestone find that their “pitch” is automatically populated by what they just did and already plan to do in the future.</p><p>Furthermore, the more that you can show investors that your startup is being run to achieve Next Fundable Milestones, the more likely that investment will occur at a higher valuation.</p><p><strong>A Call to Action for Startup Board Members, Investors and CEOs</strong></p><p>For ten plus-year period ending by early 2022, startups and their Boards and Investors were taught that they could raise additional capital without practices fundamental to the success of a business.</p><p>Not only was this eschewing of fundamental business practices needlessly dooming many startups to failure, but, save for a rarefied few deep Artificial Intelligence startups today, the easy money that startups have learned to count on, is no longer there.</p><p>If the startup that you are involved with cannot either show in a single sparse slide or say in a single brief sentence, what fundable milestone your startup is being run to achieve with the capital and resources that it presently has, then your startup doesn’t have a Next Fundable Milestone, isn’t being run to achieve the Next Fundable Milestone, and all but certainly will be incapable of raising additional capital.</p><p>The loss of fundamental business practices inculcated into the culture of startups for the past decade still lingers, and so the task falls on Board members, investors and CEOs to (re)instil and then maintain the practice of running a startup to the Next Fundable Milestone.</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/nweintraut/"><em>J. Neil Weintraut</em></a><em> is a Venture Capitalist at </em><a href="https://www.motusventures.us/"><em>Motus Ventures</em></a><em>, a Venture Capital firm focused on deep technologies in autonomy, green energy, quantum computing and space. Motus’ investments include Argus Cybersecurity, Elroy Air, EVConnect, Ghost Robotics, Helm.ai, H2U Technologies, Infinitum Electric, Memryx, Metawave, OrbitFab, Qunnect, and Sonatus. Prior to Motus Ventures, Neil co-founded the Internet-focused Venture Capital Firm, Palo Alto Venture Partners, achieving numerous exits including AdForce, AvantGo, CareerBuilder, DemandForce, Vicinity and When.com, and served on the Board of numerous Venture Capital-backed startups. Neil was a Managing Director at Technology Investment Bank Hambrecht &amp; Quist where he was one of the first Wall Street Internet Research Analyst, taking public more than 15 Internet companies, and publishing research on more than 200 Technology companies. Neil has an MBA from The Wharton School of Business and a BSEE from Drexel University. Neil has been an invited presenter on Technology companies at Harvard Business School, Stanford University, UC Berkeley, and other major Universities. Neil has been on the Advisory Boards of the MIT / Stanford Venture Lab (VLAB), and OpNet, an economic development group helping underprivileged residents of San Francisco achieve economic independence through technology. Neil was also the advisor to the International Olympic Committee on the application of the Internet to the Olympic Games.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=77933ae6bc70" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[New Fiduciary Standards and Actions in the Wake of the SVB Failure]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/new-fiduciary-standards-and-actions-in-the-wake-of-the-svb-failure-da5d8a4887c?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da5d8a4887c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[banks]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 Mar 2023 10:04:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-13T19:19:01.347Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><strong>The Takeaway</strong>: As a matter of practical and fiduciary responsibility going forward, every startup should have: accounts with at least two banks; at least two months of payroll in each account; each account preemptively connected to each payment processor (such as payroll and credit cards). Moreover, most of a startup&#39;s funds should be further diversified across multiple money market funds at entities independent of banks.</blockquote><p>In less than 48 hours, the bedrock bank of Silicon Valley, SVB, failed.</p><p>This failure, both the fact that it occurred and how it occurred, either exposed or created new lessons, indeed, new fiduciary duties for executives and boards of technology companies and beyond.</p><p>To be clear, this matter is still unfolding, with more details leading up to it and consequences following from it, to be discovered. But one of the lessons — indeed possibly the most sobering lesson of all — is the utter necessity or burden for us to act immediately, and hence, this article is being published to promulgate what this author sees as being the most insights and actions for executives and boards, discovered as of the time of its publication.</p><p>Editorially, at this immediate point of publication, updates or additions to this article are likely as new information is gleaned. Indeed, the author encourages readers to provide further insights or learnings either by emailing the author directly (to neil@motusventures.com) or adding comments.</p><p>And of course, in view of our litigious country, it must also be recognized that this article is not legal advice and anyone should seek and use their own legal and other counsel on this matter.</p><p><strong>The Salient Fact</strong></p><p>The salient fact that has come from this essentially-overnight failure of a 40-year respected banking institution is how any bank is dependent — decisively dependent — on <em>sentiment</em>.</p><blockquote><em>In the opinion of The New York Times columninst Kevin Rose: “But what brought S.V.B. down wasn’t lending to risky start-ups, or gambling on sketchy crypto coins, or some other ill-considered tech scheme. It was an old-fashioned bank run, set off back in 2021 by a series of old-fashioned bad decisions.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>At most normal, midsize regional banks, what happened at S.V.B. probably wouldn’t have led to a panic. Banks sell assets all the time. They run into liquidity problems and raise short-term capital to solve them. Most of the time, customers never notice or care.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>But S.V.B.’s depositors are not normal customers… Slack channels and Twitter feeds lit up with dire warnings from venture capitalists and soon many people were panicking.”<br></em><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/11/technology/silicon-valley-bank-failure-lessons.html">The New York Times. Kevin Roose</a>. March 11, 2023.</blockquote><p>People can, and likely will, debate for years whether or not the failure of SVB was necessary. And therein lies the key wake-up call because there are two specific circumstances about this failure that lead to one particular enlightenment — namely, that we as executives and board members need to view, act and supervise the custodian of a company’s treasury in an entirely new and highly-resilient and high-risk-diversifying way. Sentiment is a capricious and potent behavior that we have all just been shown can happen to almost any Bank and when it happens, has immediate and extreme consequences.</p><p>In this saga, two circumstances either one of which was likely just the ups and downs of business, but together, unleashed a turn of sentiment that in turn, drove a forty-year institution into failure and did so in just hours.</p><p>Circumstance 1: Rapidly Rising Interest Rates. Banks of all shapes and sizes dutifully placed sizable portions of their deposits into the U.S. government debt and other low-risk securities.</p><p>Of particular note, is that what the banks did actually appears good — that is, the full value of customers’ deposits would be available at maturity. So normally, this behaviour is to be admired.</p><p>However, the past year, in particular, was not normal. Instead, after 14 boring years of stagnation, interest rates rapidly rose to rates not seen in almost two decades.</p><p>This rapid rise in interest rates gave these seemingly prudent bond holdings into paper losses. That is, paper loss in the sense the value of these bonds at maturity remained unchanged (and in particular covered the deposits behind them), even though the market value today was less than the maturity value.</p><p>As long as it was “business as usual” everything would work out. But especially in the case of Technology-industry-centered SVB, business this past year was not “usual”.</p><p>Circumstance 2: The Downturn in the Technology Industry.</p><p>Essentially coincident with the uptick in interest rates, the flush of cash flowing into new and existing startups markedly turned down and established technology companies throttled operations. In practical terms, SVB found itself without the sizable cash flow that it enjoyed from just the comings and goings of large amounts of capital. Even worse, startups were increasingly drawing more cash as new infusions of equity cash were either taking longer, smaller or not happening at all.</p><p>And the combination of a portfolio bond with a loss, if sold at market value, with the turn of its clients from depositing to withdrawing cash, was the perfect storm either for SVB to ultimately fail, or at least for people to fear that it would ultimately fail.</p><p>Indeed, on Thursday SVB was in the midst of a deal that would have infused it with $2 billion of cash to cover its cash needs through this predicament, but the run on the bank the same day because of this same predicament, reportedly debased this deal from going through, assuring the self-fulfilling outcome of failure.</p><p>In the aftermath of SVB’s failure:</p><ul><li>A company’s capital is being constrained to various degrees for some time, and worse, possibly lose some part of it outright (see: <a href="https://www.theinformation.com/articles/wall-street-firm-pounces-on-svb-implosion-with-offer-to-buy-deposit-claims?rc=vsll6i"><em>Wall Street Firsm Pounces on SVB Implosion With Offer to Buy Deposit Claims</em></a>. The Information. March 11, 2023, 12:19 pm PST). Right now, companies have no access to their capital at SVB. On Friday the FDIC took over SVB and created a new bank called DINB of Santa Clara. On Monday, companies are supposed to have access via the FDIC up to the limit of $250,000 of insured deposits. Anything beyond that is in some unfolding state of limbo. Hopefully, things will work out quickly, but again, this unimaginable act smacks us with protecting ourselves from such exposure in the future.</li></ul><blockquote><strong>Subsequent event: At 6:15 pm EDT Sunday, March 12, the US Treasury, Federal Reserve and FDIC </strong><a href="https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/monetary20230312b.htm"><strong>announced</strong></a><strong> a “resolution of Silicon Valley Bank, Santa Clara, California, in a manner that fully protects all depositors. Depositors will have access to all of their money starting Monday, March 13. No losses associated with the resolution of Silicon Valley Bank will be borne by the taxpayer.”</strong></blockquote><ul><li>In parallel, this failure also exposed the dependence and vulnerability of the interconnected operational payment mechanism that hitherto was in the backwater. For example, within hours, startup-oriented credit card services such as Brex were sending out emails to startups telling them to provide a new source of funds or risk having credit cards turned off… which in turn affects a startup’s operational online services such as AWS, Github and Slack. Etsy reportedly stopped paying providers due to its dependence on SVB for processing payments (see: <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/etsy-delays-payments-sellers-due-silicon-valley-bank-collapse-rcna74475">Etsy warns sellers of delay in processing payments due to Silicon Valley Bank collapse</a>. NBC News. March 11, 2023, 9:30 am PST, updated 2:30 pm PST).</li></ul><p><strong>Actions/Practices for Executives and Boards to Embrace Now</strong></p><p>With these and other lessons in mind, here is a rolling list of actions or practices for startup executives and boards to embrace going forward and even if SVB’s failure is resolved without loss to its customers.</p><ol><li>Have two or more banks and take specific actions with them.<br>The practical reality is that each bank account entails a significant amount of administrative burden and even confusion. This practical fact combined with all the protections and practices put in place since 1929 fostered a reasonable belief and standard that a relationship with a single bank was sufficient.<br> No more. In the face of SVB’s failure, this belief, standard and reliance on a single bank are not only questionable, but one could reasonably expect that legally it will be found to failure of a board and officer’s fiduciary duties to employees, creditors, the company and shareholders.<br> Moreover, there are specific actions to do with these banks. Notably: (i) have deposits covering two months of payroll in each bank, and (ii) have both banks connected with each payment provider such as Gusto and Ramp.<br> These two particular actions come from the lessons made explicit by the aftermath of SVB’s failure.<br> Especially in California, employees need to be paid. And they need to be paid on time. Failing to make payroll is a violation of wage and hour laws. But that is just the beginning. It starts with penalties but can lead to liabilities for individual officers, directors and any other decision-makers. Requiring employees to work when you know that you can’t make payroll exposes officers and directors even more. Indeed, even presently, companies may need to literally layoff employees while they sort through being able to pay them rather than keeping them employed knowing that you can’t pay them in accordance with employment laws. Citing the fact that the second-largest bank failure just occurred may cut you some slack, but now that exposure to a single bank failure likely no longer qualifies as a force majeure, we as officers or directors need to install practices and systems that transcend another SVB event.<br> Taking the above actions solves all of this. That is, having two banks, each with sufficient capital for two months of payroll, and preemptively connected to payroll and other payment processing services likely shows sufficient fiduciary duty and similarly, will all but certainly avoid the mad scramble, rushed board meetings, and other “Clean up on Aisle 5” going on throughout Silicon Valley across hundreds of startups literally as this article is being prepared.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*orG8WjmcKEyQEGe6" /></figure><p>There’s also another advantage of having two banks. Namely, as one of my startups enjoyed, it gave them the ability to immediately wire out funds from a failing bank to a healthy bank. This startup didn’t have two different banks in anticipation of such an event, but the fact that it both had two banks and both banks had wiring templates set up to immediately wire funds from one to the other, likely made it possible for this startup to now be in the relatively comfortable position to cover its payroll for two months while the mess with SVB gets sorted out.</p><p>Delta of Bond Value. There are many factors that affect the solvency of a bank, but the rapidly rising interest rates have made the difference between the market value and held-to-maturity value of a bank’s bond holdings. Notably, The Wall Street Journal specifically highlighted SVB’s loss or delta of -$15.9 in November (see:<a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/rising-interest-rates-hit-banks-bond-holdings-11668123473?mod=Searchresults_pos3&amp;page=1"> <em>Rising Interest Rates Hits Banks’ Bond Holdings</em></a>. The Wall Street Journal. November 11, 2022). The adverse impact of rising interest rates on Banks affects even the big ones — for example, the Journal article identified that Bank of America had the largest book loss (-$116 billion) of all of the Banks.</p><p>2. Third-Party Money Market Funds. One bright spot that is emerging from SVB’s failure is that the sizable amount of funds put into SVB’s Deposit Sweep Accounts is likely detached from SVB’s failure. These Sweep Accounts actually hold shares in money market accounts maintained by third parties — SVB is merely an agent. According to Cooley LLP, the underlying agreement of these accounts indicates that in the event of SVB’s failure, the FDIC should recognized the client’s ownership in the Money Market Fund instead of being a creditor to SVB.</p><p>If the FDIC agrees with Cooley’s read of the agreement, there will be some delay in distributing the cash back to customers as the Money Market Funds have a limited view into SVB’s actual customers, but the end result will be a return of capital.</p><p>But regardless of what happens in this particular matter, the lesson here is to include another dimension of diversification by deploying much of the cash that a startup raises across multiple money market funds. This might be done via a Bank as SVB did, but could be a third party.</p><p>Another reason to do this is that one of the interesting if not amusing questions that have been raised by numerous directors and executives since Friday, is “which bank?”. That is, in the face of SVB’s “unimaginable” failure, stated rhetorically shouldn’t one assume that this could happen to almost any other bank? To wit, the answer to this question is to diversify not only across banks but also across non-banks and different instruments as well.</p><p>Historically, diligent CFOs have dutifully worked to place a company’s funds in entities where they can maximize returns within prudent (i.e. low) risk predicated on a belief in the durability of banks; now funds must balance returns with a built-in resilience against banks not being durable.</p><p>3. Initial Thoughts on Banks. In exploring what bank set-up that combines the startup-smart banking provided by SVB with resilience, a barbell-like structure with one “big” bank and one quality “speciality” bank has come up often. Via email, I can provide contacts to people at some of these banks actively setting up accounts for startups.</p><p>Morgan Stanley, Goldman, JP Morgan, Bank of America, and Chase are examples of big banks. Morgan Stanley is probably the best “tech-smart” of the big banks, while Bank of America is notoriously dumbed-down.</p><p>In terms of quality speciality banks, two banks in Silicon Valley that have some catering to startups, but have always played second-fiddle to SVB are First Republic Bank and Bridge Bank. Because First Republic Bank is closest in customer profile to SVB, it has come under some questions as to its exposure (see: <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-11/first-republic-regional-peers-try-to-boost-confidence-after-svb?sref=l5cxkaYx">First Republic, Regional Peers Try to Boost Confidence After SVB</a>. Bloomberg. March 10, 2023, 5:40 pm PST). First Republic subsequently made arrangements through the Federal Reserve Bank and JPMorgan Chase &amp; Co arming it with: “unused liquidity to fund operations is now more than $70 billion” (see <a href="https://news.firstrepublic.com/news-releases/news-release-details/first-republic-bank-strengthens-and-diversifies-liquidity?mkt_tok=Mzc3LVJFUS05NTcAAAGKd1gN2bpw5kG0jVR7Zbt_JicCSYz2aE-fqvDadPAnvtw6dKOdAVqMkRiIyd7Eg3PPpPBf9_9H7yh7ccbyvvQRERInoiejCDj-iIDGDBWt6AI">First Republic Bank Strengthens and Diversifies Liquidity.</a> First Republic Bank. March 12, 2023, 5:29 pm PST).</p><p>Startups with relatively small amounts of capital (e.g. under $10 million) may also want to use CDARS (Certificate of Deposit Account Registry Service) which allows them to invest in Certificates of Deposits (CDs) held by many different FDIC insured banking institutions, thereby achieving full FDIC coverage.</p><p><strong>Closing Thoughts</strong></p><p>SVB’s failure is a call to action for all of us to help the Tech industry by marshalling and sharing our best ideas and innovations. In particular ideas and innovations that carry the industry through this unprecedented circumstance with minimal adverse impact on employees and companies, and ultimately put in place structures and practices instilling resiliency against the financial ground underneath us moving… much as previous earthquakes have made Silicon Valley that more resilient against earthquakes moving literally the ground underneath us.</p><p>Hopefully, this article will contribute to or spur us all toward making this happen.</p><p>Below is a rolling list of articles that may be of use to your company, its management team and its board as you navigate this extraordinary circumstance.</p><p><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/13miTc6j1_Jbc9bCcxeFVKYKwZhSCKfcD/view?usp=sharing"><em>Strategic Actions / Q1&#39;23 Mid-Quarter Update</em></a>. March 8, 2023. SVB.</p><p><a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-03-10/startup-bank-had-a-startup-bank-run?sref=l5cxkaYx">Startup Bank Had a Startup Bank Run. One problem for Silicon Valley Bank is that its customers had too much cash, and now they don’t</a>. Bloomberg Opinion by Matt Levine. March 10, 2023, 12:34 pm PST, updated March 11, 2023, at 12:21 pm PST.</p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uDmyE6CSOzT-KGiHhaurkTG0U9L2cxLhIFwTM8rf_cU/edit?usp=sharing"><em>A note from Ramp’s CEO regarding SVB. Ramp</em></a>. March 11, 2023, 6:25 pm PST.</p><p><a href="http://Circle’s USDC Stablecoin Breaks Peg With $3.3 Billion Stuck at Silicon Valley Bank"><em>Circle’s USDC Stablecoin Breaks Peg With $3.3 Billion Stuck at Silicon Valley Bank</em></a>. The Wall Street Journal March 11, 2023 7:21 pm ET.</p><p><a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/investors-startups-work-to-find-cash-lifelines-after-silicon-valley-bank-collapse-1b7c9ceb?mod=tech_lead_pos1"><em>Investors, Startups Work to Find Cash Lifelines After Silicon Valley Bank Collapse</em></a><em>.</em> The Wall Street Journal. March 11, 2023, 10:59 pm ET.</p><p><a href="https://www.cooley.com/news/insight/2023/2023-03-11-common-questions-regarding-access-to-funds-after-failure-of-an-fdic-insured-bank?utm_campaign=0311_23_SVB_alert_&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_source=pardot"><em>Common Questions Regarding Access to Funds After Failure of an FDIC-Insured Bank</em></a>. Cooley LLP. March 11, 2023.</p><p><a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/where-were-the-regulators-as-svb-crashed-35827e1a"><em>Where Were the Regulators as SVB Crashed?</em></a> The Wall Street Journal. March 11, 2023.</p><p><a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-12/mccarthy-says-he-s-hopeful-for-svb-announcement-by-us-on-sunday?sref=l5cxkaYx"><em>McCarthy Says He’s Hopeful for SVB Announcement by US on Sunday.</em></a> Bloomberg. March 12, 2023, 7:23 am PDT.</p><p><a href="https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/monetary20230312b.htm">Joint Statement by Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC</a>. March 12, 2023, 6:15 pm EDT.</p><p><em>J. Neil Weintraut is a partner are Motus Ventures. Neil can be contacted via </em><a href="/service/mailto:neil@motusventures.com"><em>neil@motusventures.com</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da5d8a4887c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Getting South Florida Tech To Hockey Stick]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/getting-south-florida-tech-to-hockey-stick-e52ceadcd85d?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e52ceadcd85d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[miami]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[florida]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 May 2022 02:46:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-06T02:46:16.806Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/888/0*BgyCWW8ltlUKPAw5" /></figure><p>“We want this to be a movement not a moment”.</p><p>This is the rallying cry of the Mayor of Miami and much of the burgeoning Technology industry in South Florida make. Made being aware that similarly burgeoning Technology industries in other cities, states and countries over the years, failed to hockey stick into an exponentially growing Technology economy.</p><p>While there’s a chance that this hockey stick might happen on its own, both by bringing a focus on it and identifying additional actions for making it happen, this article hopes to increase the odds and speed of the promising Tech Scene in South Florida “Hockey Sticking” into a new Tech Economy outside of Silicon Valley, New York City and Austin.</p><h4><strong>South Florida is In A Good Position</strong></h4><p>For almost as long as Silicon Valley has been a “thing”, country after country, state after state, and city after city, excitingly thought and hoped that some stirring of Technology industry activity going on in their area, would transform their given economy into a Tech one, with all its societal benefits.</p><p>Of course, save for New York City and Austin, Texas, their respective grand Technology breakouts never turn the corner.</p><p>However, a variety of circumstances and attributes unique to South Florida make it very possible for the economy in South Florida to get to that vaunted inflection point “hockey sticking” its Economy into a Tech one.</p><ul><li><strong>Freedom Culture</strong>. Although venture capital and other tangible facets associated with a Tech Economy, get most of the press, the “magic” fueling the self-reinforcing growth of the Tech industry is intangible culture. The culture necessary for proactive self-innovation driving Tech businesses is a rare special culture perhaps beyond words, but a culture of Freedom captures most of it. Numerous indications are that South Florida has this rarified culture.<br>South Florida’s culture is symbolized, and in part caused, by refugees from the socialist South American countries, driven to inject and defend freedom, respect for others, drive, and personal responsibility in their new and permanent home (i.e. Florida).<br>This type of driven, open-minded culture was the invisible hand that made Silicon Valley, Silicon Valley, and now Florida has that same culture (and has it exactly as Silicon Valley is losing it).<br>A now-famous Tweet of “How Can I Help?” from the Mayor of Miami (Francis Suarez) to a Tech Entrepreneur expressing interest in South Florida, embodies the can-do/will-do/open-minded culture pervading South Florida.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/958/0*_2r0epDbqIUPpnAn" /></figure><ul><li><strong>Community/Grass Roots Support</strong>. In what may prove to be a model for the rest of the nation, amongst other things, South Florida is pioneering the direct injection of Technology industry skills and awareness into minority groups, high schools, and community colleges. <br>Simply tech-i-fying the community is beneficial unto itself, but by creating a pool of (moderate but sufficiently) skilled labor that can do baseline work at say, $100,000 per year versus $150,000 for overkilled labor Florida is setting itself up to be attractive to companies across all industries, not just Tech Industry with its inherent need for bleeding-edge skills.<br>Meanwhile, the South Florida community has taken to spontaneously embrace technology itself. The recently held Miami NFT (non-fungible tokens) Week, was created and organized by a Black South Floridian record producer, Ted Lucas, who at once had no previous involvement with the Tech Industry yet saw the benefits that it could bring to the erstwhile less privileged communities of South Florida.</li><li><strong>Geography</strong>. Within the past five months, four German Technology companies and one Israeli Technology company announced establishing their U.S. operations in South Florida.<br>Geographically (as well as air travel infrastructure), South Florida is well suited for the U.S. operations of Technology Companies outside the United States, notably almost every country in Europe, Israel which is the most innovative tech center outside of Silicon Valley, and South America.<br>And then there is Space — as in Outspace Space. At exactly the time when the harvesting of Space is emerging as one of the largest and most dynamic industries of all time, Florida is one of the few places in the World with the geography and infrastructure for this industry.</li><li><strong>Crypto Industry Kernal.</strong> While still nascent, a number of venture-backed blockchain and crypto companies (notably in DeFi and NFTs) have moved or set-up their operations in South Florida, making South Florida as one of the go-to places considered by blockchain and crypto entrepreneurs.</li><li><strong>Circumstances</strong>. South Florida has had a scattering of Technology Industry companies, incubators, and even financiers going back a decade or even longer.<br>And then came the COVID pandemic in March 2020. <br>Tech and Financial companies and people living in repressive, crime-ridden, filthy, high-tax, closed, and miserable California and New York City suddenly became aware of the freedom-loving, no-tax, open and fun World of Florida. The rest one might say is history.<br>The combination of a Tech culture already on the move in South Florida, the migration of successful entrepreneurs and venture capitalists to South Florida, and the inspiring portrayal of South Florida as the “can-do” place in America by Miami’s Mayor, South Florida’s technology industry, expanded roughly two-fold in terms of startups, investments, incubators, over the past two years. In tandem, numerous colleges and universities in Florida markedly expanded their Technology programs.</li><li><strong>Miami Urban Scene</strong>. The Miami and greater South Florida area has franchises in all of the major professional sports plus Formula One Racing, one of the Biggest Art Shows in the nation, numerous music festivals, museums, galleries and is in the process of opening three cultural centers, and of course, well-performing grade schools. Meanwhile, Miami has a functionally zero homeless situation, low crime, clean streets, and a “Future positive” government. Many if not most of Silicon Valley isn’t aware of the robust urban scene that has congealed in South Florida predisposing them to San Francisco, but as the word gets out, more and more entrepreneurs will find Miami offering all the urban lifestyle they seek combined with not needing to submit to the mob-culture of the San Francisco Tech scene (for example, 98% of donations from Twitter employees were for Democrats, indicating that anyone who thought differently either doesn’t get hired, quits, or just submits to the San Francisco mob).</li><li>F<strong>ive-9s — The Advent of Next Generation Internet Industry</strong>. As identified in another article recently published by the same author of this one (see:<a href="https://medium.com/@nweintraut/five-9s-dbcbb290455f"> Five-9s And the Advent of the Next Generation Technology Industry</a>), much of the Silicon Valley Internet has naively rendered the use of their products unreliable, when the fundamental requirement of every customer is unqualified availability always and forever (a requirement embodied by the statistical term Five-9s). Silicon Valley Internet companies have proudly weaponized this essential truth against their own customers. This problem is not a technology issue (which is fixable) but an unfixable cultural issue. <br>To wit, enter the Freedom Culture of Florida. In short, customers will gravitate to a new generation of — dependable — Internet companies, and South Florida stands out as one of the few regions in the Country where the culture exists to provide this dependability.</li></ul><p>The Tech Industry in South Florida has become a vibrant, driven, and freedom-loving region conducive to success in the Technology industry, exactly at a time when a repressive culture and crime have pervaded the Bay Area of Silicon Valley; Customers can no longer rely on products and services from Silicon Valley; and entrepreneurs have become open-minded to, if not preferring, starting their companies in regions outside of Silicon Valley.</p><h3><strong>Getting South Florida To Hockey Stick</strong></h3><p>All of the above and more are very promising for South Florida. However, what makes the Tech industry, well, the Tech industry, is when it hits an inflection point where everything compounds on itself on a hockey-stick of sustained and phenomenal growth and expansion.</p><p>Here are some ideas both assuring that South Florida does indeed turn the corner on the Hockey-stick, as well as having this happen as soon as possible.</p><h4>Big and Scared.</h4><p>As a venture capitalist who has seen hundreds of startups outside of Silicon Valley, they all suffer from not thinking big-enough or scared-enough.</p><p>It’s not that entrepreneurs outside of Silicon Valley aren’t driven and sharp, but rather that they aren’t exposed to the sheer mass of continuous dealings and innovations that goes on in Silicon Valley. It ranges from not being aware of the nine startups going after the same market that typically occur in Silicon Valley for each one outside of Silicon Valley, to truly just off-the-cuff insights arising from the near-continuous chatter between entrepreneurs, engineers, lawyers, and venture capitalist everywhere and all the time.</p><p>This intensity of “stuff” happening in Silicon Valley drives focus, action, speed, and change unlike any other place in the World. Hence adages such as “Only the paranoid survive”, “Move fast and break things”, and “Pivoting” are distinctly Silicon Valley born.</p><p>The entrepreneur culture in South Florida is already well suited to creating a Tech Economy, but getting it to think bigger and scared-er than they already are, is likely necessary to turn the hockey-stick corner.</p><p>What this can mean in practice, for example, is that instead of an entrepreneur or startup taking comfort in knowing that the only or best company in South Florida, to engage prospective customers outside of Florida until that startup discovers the what else is actually going on in industry including the nine-other startups forming in Silicon Valley right now. Indeed, experience has shown that if there aren’t at least nine other entrants in a market then that market itself isn’t that appealing.</p><p>Similarly, a given startup or entrepreneur should have a “Big Hairy Goal”, but then triage and focus operations to get fast wins — really fast wins — as if the success of the business depends on it. To be clear, in the Tech Industry, it does.</p><p>Another nuanced difference in thinking is realizing to do (and only do) things that raise the next round of capital. Thus for example, at the same time a startup is pitching (i.e. telling) the business to investors, that startup should be listening to what or how investors react. This doesn’t mean that investors always know what’s right, but jealously and smartly reacting to the queues from investors often makes the difference between a year-long force-march trying to raise funds while the market runs away, and investors calling up the startup begging to put money in.</p><p>This leads to the next item…</p><h4>Have Silicon Valley Help South Florida.</h4><p>Entrepreneurs and startups in South Florida should use whatever networks they have to routinely spend a few days or even weeks in Silicon Valley and other relevant areas.</p><p>The idea is to both get the constant shock that there are things happening and happening fast outside the local bubbles we all live in and equally impactful, “semi-random” events such as bumping into a pivotal employee or customer or even just get heads-up on a new React npm module or Blockchain protocol overheard from the two engineers having lunch at the table next to yours. I used the term “semi-random” because in these fortuitous magical moments and insights are unpredictable yet inevitably happen as a result of startups just “getting out there”. “Create-your-own-luck” is a term I routinely advocate for startups.</p><p>Venture-backed South Florida startups should tap their Silicon investors to meet with some of their portfolio companies that both are outside of Florida and outside their particular industry. Cross-fertilization of ideas and technology is yet another of the magic propelling the Hockey Stick.</p><p>Finally, and again in a relentless drive for a startup to move faster, claim customers, or discover decisive innovations; gain quick access to talent that is currently anchored in Silicon Valley by offering the opportunity for those employees to work jointly in South Florida and wherever they are now.</p><p>I believe it likely that doing this will also turbocharge the migration of top talent to South Florida, by taking advantage of, and showcasing, South Florida’s many advantages over Silicon Valley including no taxes and a free and vibrant culture.</p><p>Notably, allowing key Silicon Valley talent the latitude to work in South Florida 27 weeks per year saves them $10,000 to $20,000 in taxes that they don’t pay the State of California, while still allowing them to maintain their ties in California, on a path to transitioning out entirely.</p><p>An employee might time his time in each region such that he or she is in California during the hot and humid May through September period in Florida.</p><h4>Satellite Graduate and Executive Education.</h4><p>Court MIT, Carnegie Mellon, The Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania and possibly other Tier 1 University Engineering and Business Programs to set up Satellite Branches in South Florida.</p><p>As recent as a year ago, South Florida didn’t have enough of a business case for Tier 1 Universities to set up operations in South Florida. But now South Florida does. Hence, in pursuit of getting and staying on the Hockey Stick, this is an important addition waiting to happen.</p><p>To be clear, South Florida’s educational institutions have markedly up their game in the past few years, expanding Technology and Business curriculums and entrepreneurial centers. But bringing in Tier-1 Graduate-level programs puts South Florida in the league of other technology centers and moreover injects the important outside awareness as discussed above.</p><h4>Large-Company Technology Branches.</h4><p>In the early days of the Internet a group in San Francisco, called OpNet, provided a bridge for impoverished communities into the business world by, training people in basic Web Development skills and coordinating with major companies to employ graduates of the program.</p><p>Now South Florida could at once boost its region&#39;s progress toward the Hockey Stick, while directly engaging and benefiting the existing community of South Florida with the emerging Tech economy by doing something similar and more.</p><p>South Florida is already halfway there. South Florida’s Miami Dade College is in the process of launching a free tech-focused high-school program that leads into an Associate’s Degree in Cloud Computing, programming, cybersecurity, and data analytics.</p><p>But what will be needed is the other half — namely demand for these new techies. In particular, companies in essentially every industry (i.e. outside of Tech) have needs these mid-level skills.</p><p>Companies in manufacturing, health care, retail, and essentially everything else that don’t need $200,000 per year engineers designing an autonomous vehicle, do instead need hundreds of thousands of people operating the information technology infrastructure of their business. Technology-savvy people are increasingly hard to come by, the prospect of not only a ready pool of technology-savvy people but at a cost meaningfully lower than major tech centers, would be particularly attractive to major companies.</p><p>Accordingly, A coordinated effort in South Florida could draw hundreds of companies to set up technology branches, and this in turn, at once, provide high-paying jobs for South Florida’s existing community and in the course of doing so introduces and grooms people that once had little chance into being tomorrow’s entrepreneurs.</p><p>And so goes the self-reinforcing inflection point onto the Hockey Stick.</p><p><em>J. Neil Weintraut is a Venture Capitalist at Motus Ventures, a Venture Capital firm focused on deep technologies in autonomy, green energy, robotics, quantum computing and space. Motus’ investments include Elroy Air, EVConnect, Ghost Robotics, H2U Technologies, Infinitum, Memryx, Metawave, and Quanergy. Prior to Motus Ventures, Neil co-founded Internet-focused Venture Capital Firm, Palo Alto Venture Partners, realizing exits such as AdForce, AvantGo, CareerBuilder, DemandForce, Vicinity and When.com. Neil was a Managing Director at Technology Investment Bank Hambrecht &amp; Quist where he was one of the first Wall Street Internet Research Analysts, taking public more than 15 Internet companies, and published research on more than 200 Technology companies. Neil has an MBA from The Wharton School of Business and a BSEE from Drexel University. Neil was the advisor to the International Olympic Committee on the application of the Internet to the Olympic Games.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e52ceadcd85d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Five-9s]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/five-9s-dbcbb290455f?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dbcbb290455f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[availability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[next-generation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[woke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Apr 2022 21:34:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-22T21:27:42.162Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><em>And the Advent of the Next Generation Internet Industry</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/434/0*9fbGL9ylyob9g1nH" /></figure><p>The last time that the incumbent technology industry made itself easy prey spawned a wholesale and disruptive revolution both overthrowing the incumbents and spawning the amazing and expansive Tech industry we all know and love today.</p><p>Now the incumbent Technology industry — or at least the incumbent trillion-dollar Internet industry portion of it — has made itself easy prey again. How so? In a word — Five-9s.</p><h3><strong>Five-9s</strong></h3><p>Five-9s is the bedrock of all technology products and services.</p><p>Five-9s is a statistical measure as well as an operational mindset. Namely, it is the technology and customer requirement that any technology product or service will be available essentially always and forever. A standard of availability that is so high that over a ten-year period, that technology product or service will be available <strong><em>always</em></strong> save for all of one hour.</p><p>This certain availability is important. Indeed, the need for certain availability is so pervasive that most of us can recall the one time some retail merchant’s Internet connection was down, and outages are so rare that they make national news (see: <em>Google Maps Down As Global Outage Hits Mapping Service</em>. The New York Post. March 18, 2022).</p><h3>How To Get Overthrown In the Tech Industry 101</h3><p>How to Get Overthrown in the Tech Industry is straightforward, namely, switching from providing a platform empowering customers to do as they please to controlling what customers can do.</p><p>Although the technology industry that you see today may seem to have existed essentially forever, that is actually not the case. In fact, today’s Tech industry is actually the amazing end result of the overthrow of the original Tech industry that had allowed itself to become easy prey.</p><p>The original Tech industry was the likes of IBM and Honeywell. At that time, the notion of startups displacing the likes of the dominant industry goliaths was laughable. However, as these goliaths grew, they (naively) took control over their customers. In industry parlance, they were pejoratively known as Closed Systems vendors. And therein lay the vulnerability.</p><p>Controlling what customers can do motivates customers to seek and find alternatives where they (i.e. the customers) are in control. To wit, the advent of Open Systems, in form of both technology and companies, blew away the “unassailable” incumbents. The Technology Industry that you know today is the Technology industry that offered and promised unqualified availability and control to customers.</p><h3><strong><em>Déjà vu</em> All Over Again</strong></h3><p>Now fast forward to today. Once again the incumbent Internet Industry has switched from providing a certain platform of absolute availability for customers to do as they please, to taking away availability at the vendor’s whim.</p><p>Indeed, whereas the Closed-Systems era vendors of the bygone era, asserted control over their customers by limiting customer choice to what would work with their particular platform, at least their platform was always available.</p><p>Today’s Industry has foolishly — and I believe fatally — weaponized the crown jewel of any technology product or service against their own customers. Namely, certain availability. Whereas all technology customers require Five-9s, the current generation of Internet companies is instead offering Five-0s (as in Five… zeros).</p><p>This bizarre and hostile behaviour is rampant in core portions of the Internet industry. Vendors such as Amazon Web Services, AirBnB, Apple, Facebook, GoDaddy, GoFundMe, Google, PayPal, Salesforce.com, Square, Stripe, Twitter, YouTube and others have weaponized availability against their customers and even developers (see: <a href="https://medium.com/@appsrentables1/google-cancels-our-google-play-publisher-account-and-ends-my-familys-source-of-income-97d4e85cd046"><em>Google cancels our Google Play publisher account and ends my family’s source of income</em></a>). Existing Internet companies have gone so far into dictating to customers what they can think and write, that Microsoft even recently and quietly changed the word suggestions that its software presents to customers to only those deemed appropriate by Microsoft’s woke culture. Once again customers weren’t and aren’t offered a choice; instead, the only option <em>available</em> to customers is what current generation Internet companies deem that customers can have.</p><p>From Platforms to Policy. All technology companies are in the business of providing some type of (technology)<strong><em> platform</em></strong> for customers to do as they please, yet the current generation of Internet companies have bizarrely switched into the business of providing (social) <strong><em>policies</em></strong> that customers are forced to submit. Hint: This is not a durable business model.</p><p>Even obscure vendors such as JW Player have just summarily cut-off customers and done so just because their political views were different — a capricious standard leaving any customer at any time to find themselves naked at the whim of some faceless person in the Human Resources Department at JW Player.</p><p>Which begs the question: If you were building and operating a business, would you choose and integrate JW Player’s video platform in your business’ website knowing that JW Player is a company that can and will de-platform you at their whim? The answer, of course, is no — no business can operate with such uncertainty. Instead, the business will naturally choose the vendor who simply promises certain (i.e. Five-9) availability.</p><p>And therein lies the next generation of companies and offerings in the Internet Industry.</p><h3><strong>Certain Availability: The Next Generation Internet Companies</strong></h3><p>Where Closed Systems necessitated an entirely new Industry era built from the ground up on Open Systems, the Uncertain-Availability of today’s Internet Industry necessitates an entirely new Internet Industry era built from the ground up on Certain-Availability.</p><p>In particular, providing Certain-Availability is predicated on a new generation of culture, technology, features, and location built from the ground up on Certain-Availability.</p><ol><li><strong>Culture</strong>. A given Certain-Availability company’s mission is to provide great technology and customer experience for any legal purpose (and of course, without fail). Frankly, its a culture of respect — respect for others saying and thinking whatever they believe. Employees that believe in this mission are recruited and maintained and those that don’t aren’t recruited or let go.<br>Just merely having a culture of providing great technology, will give new entrants an insurmountable advantage overthrowing the incumbents mired in cultures of forcing social/political agendas on others.</li><li><strong>Technology</strong>. Next-generation Certain-Availability technology is built from the ground up assuming and resilient to a hostile environment — in particular, a hostile technology environment. This entails for example (i) building technology this is expressly not based on Amazon Web Services or other Uncertain-Availability vendors and (ii) greedily exploiting numerous decentralized systems technology such as Web 3 blockchains, Kubernetes, PWAs, and Docker containers.</li><li><strong>Features</strong>. Features in both form and attitude that offer fine-grain and transparent ways of dealing with abuse or illegal use (designed to be conducive to Certain-Availability), in contrast to the coarse and opaque practices (eagerly abused to crush customers, not of their liking) of the current generation of Internet companies.</li><li><strong>Location</strong>. In part to facilitate the above, but also to take advantage of pro-business and pro-freedom government and cultural environments, many if not most of the next-generation Internet companies will locate in States such as Florida, Texas, Utah and even Wyoming, and only have auxiliary operations in Silicon Valley and other anti-business/anti-freedom location, for specialized technology needs. Indeed, there are already even next-generation Internet companies setting up data centers and other core operations in other countries such as Switzerland and the Grand Cayman Islands and proudly marketing this inherent protection against the woke mobs in the United States and Internet industry complicity with the Federal Government, as part of their product offering.</li></ol><p>Marketing of this next-generation value proposition has already begun. In the high-saturated market of (current-generation) Internet hosting services, a RightForge is rapidly growing by offering “the first global internet infrastructure company committed to American principles online”. Its marketing literature takes direct aim of the (Uncertain-Availability) current generation goliaths touting: “We provide hosting for those who believe in Freedom of Expression and need Big Tech Independence.” This is foretelling of what is to come.</p><h3>Everyone Is Better Offer</h3><p>As this next generation of Internet companies unfolds, it will increasingly pick up momentum as everyone — consumers, business users, Tech company employees, and Tech companies themselves — see that they are better off doing it.</p><p>Right now, everyone is miserable. Consumers are seeing their data being used against them and even manipulated into hateful ideas by companies such as Facebook, Google, and Twitter exploiting consumers to maximize revenue. Businesses can find their business suddenly impacted or destroyed, even for something that they can’t control such as the daughter of the CEO posting something on Twitter that isn’t compliant with the impulse judgement of some Technology company’s mob. Employees either have a negative attitude toward others to see and act as they do, or live intimidated by the intolerant culture forced on them by these negative employees. And finally, Tech companies find their businesses both restricted and impaired and increasingly stuck-in-the-middle in divisive battles between vocal political factions. Just miserable.</p><p>In contrast, next-generation Internet companies are happy. Everybody lives free.</p><h3>Likelihood of Legal and/or Regulatory Disruption</h3><p>The election of President Nixon decades ago, has been linked to AT&amp;T and your Electric Power Company cutting off conversations and the electrical power of customers that didn’t support President Nixon.</p><p>Actually, this <strong>didn’t</strong> happen.</p><p>No one knows whether or not employees at AT&amp;T and your Electric Power Company may have wanted Nixon elected President, but what we do know is that even if they did, they couldn’t do anything about it. AT&amp;T and your Electrical Power company couldn’t do anything about it because of a profound Legal Doctrine, namely “Essential Facility”.</p><p>In the words of the Justice Department: “<em>The essential facilities doctrine holds that dominant firms may incur antitrust liability if they do not provide access to their truly unique facilities on a non-discriminatory basis, even to their competitors, where sharing is feasible and the competitors cannot obtain or create the facility on their own</em>.”<a href="https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/atr/legacy/2014/05/30/219672_a.pdf"> Essential Facilities, Infrastructure and Open Access</a>. 2006 Brett Frischmann &amp; Spencer Waller.</p><p>This legal doctrine deals with the reality that once society becomes so dependent on a “facility” (i.e. trains, energy, communications) controlled by a few, those few cannot restrict its use of it. In fact, they not only cannot restrict the use, but they must affirmatively aid competitors using it.</p><p>Noting that the State of Florida has already started enacting State laws marching toward this legal doctrine of Essential Facility, and there is already legally-significant evidence of the competitive and consumer harm done by the present concentrated power of the Internet Industry I believe that it is only a matter of time before various flavours of the Essential Facilities Doctrines are imposed over the Internet Industry…at once boosting the fortunes of the next generation (pro-Freedom) Internet companies and hurting the current generation (anti-Freedom) Internet companies whose very business models and employees are addicted to this monopoly-like position.</p><p>For example, as an Essential Facility, Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube would have to affirmatively enable competitors to literally milk off their social networks, thereby and exactly to, prevent the abrupt destruction that Facebook, Twitter and YouTube presently inflict on anyone with different political beliefs.</p><p>Ditto for the AppStores used by billions of people, yet absolutely restricted in use to competitors and customers by a few (i.e. two!) companies — it’s only a matter of time until we see Apple and Google being forced to offer as much if not more access to third-party app stores. I pause to note two particularly salient facts about the current AppStore (and associated operating systems) matter, foretelling of its eventual breaking-up.</p><p>Fact one is that what Apple and Google are saying about their AppStores and Telephones is exactly what AT&amp;T said about its telephone service and telephones. Namely, that their control of it was necessary to maintain quality and security. This brings up fact two…..</p><p>Namely, upon AT&amp;T giving up control under the force of legal pressure, not only did the ominous claims of quality and security not materialize but an explosion of innovation occurred exposing just how much innovation and benefit were being stiffed and crushed by the concentration of control.</p><p>In short, every time you hear Apple and Google cite quality and service as the case for continuing their centralized control, it is actually some if not the best case of destroying their centralized control. Again, when this happens, the floodgates open for the awaiting next generation of Internet companies, and the incumbents including Apple and Google will find their business being bled away.</p><p>Meanwhile, there’s the infamous “Section 230” protection matter, which is now the most open secret of absurdity and abuse in the Internet industry. Section 230 is a legal protection afforded Internet companies at the formative stages of the Internet, protecting them from liability based on the fact that the Internet Companies weren’t editors of the content. Obviously, today’s Internet Companies <strong>are</strong> editors of the content, violating the intent, and more decisively, legal facts/conditions of Section 230.</p><h3><strong>The Revolution With Be Certain</strong></h3><p>The primordial goo of this next generation is already percolating. Numerous DeFi (distributed finance) companies have already been well-capitalized to offer businesses and consumers, essentially to prevent by culture and technology what for example, PayPal recently did to one of its customers (<a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-13/paypal-sued-for-freezing-customer-accounts-without-explanation"><em>See PayPal sued for Freezing Customer Accounts Without Explanation</em></a> by Bloomberg, January 13, 2022). A technology even for enabling decentralized social media companies has recently appeared. While likely just stepped in where the market will wind up, companies such as MeWe, Rumble, and Signal already offer ready — and Certain-Availability — alternatives to the notoriously <em>Uncertain-</em>Availability platforms Facebook, YouTube, and WhatsApp. Another company featuring Switzerland-based immunity from Wokeism from messaging and storage, Proton Mail, already has over 30 million users and more than 10,000 business customers.</p><p>As one who has been in the Tech industry long enough to see the wholesale emergence of the Open Systems Tech industry so pervasive that we take its fact for granted, and today’s Internet industry from a primordial goo of eclectic websites in 1993, I see the same stimulants and patterns of a new generation in our immediate future.</p><p>I cannot say with certainty that this next revolution will be televised, but what I can say about this next revolution is that its availability will be certain.</p><p><em>J. Neil Weintraut is a Venture Capitalist at Motus Ventures, a Venture Capital firm focused on deep technologies in autonomous, green energy, robotics, quantum computing and space. Motus’ investments include Elroy Air, EVConnect, Ghost Robotics, H2U Technologies, Infinitum, Memryx, Metawave, and Quanergy. Prior to Motus Ventures, Neil co-founded Internet-focused Venture Capital Firm, Palo Alto Venture Partners, realizing exits such as AdForce, AvantGo, CareerBuilder, DemandForce, Vicinity and When.com. Neil was a Managing Director at Technology Investment Bank Hambrecht &amp; Quist where he was one of the first Wall Street Internet Research Analysts, taking public more than 15 Internet companies, and publishing research on more than 200 Technology companies. Neil has an MBA from The Wharton School of Business and a BSEE from Drexel University. Neil was the advisor to the International Olympic Committee on the application of the Internet to the Olympic Games.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dbcbb290455f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Soccer Ball]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/the-soccer-ball-391a2fa8eff5?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/391a2fa8eff5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Oct 2021 02:47:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-20T01:32:36.200Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Soccer Ball</strong></p><p>“Click”.</p><p>It’s 2023 and Bethany just submitted her request for a soccer ball.</p><p>On the one hand, Bethany had reason to believe that she had a good case; but on the other hand, she knew of two facts that would be held against her.</p><p>Helping her case is that Bethany: had achieved nothing, was entirely dependent upon the government, detested America, and outed her friends, parents, and anyone as racist and homophobic for anything at any time. In short, Bethany’s mediocrity, submission and dependence was music to the U.S. Federal Regime.</p><p>Similarly, Bethany went to great lengths to highlight that she had sent her victim’s-apology letter to the criminal that car-jacked her parent’s car. The carjacker sent her Father into the hospital and stole all that was in the car, including her soccer ball. This last fact, Bethany cited to the U.S. Department of Allocation, as the basis for it to allow her funds from the Nationalized Bank to acquire a Regime-approved ball.</p><p>However, there were those problematic facts.</p><p>One of the two facts was that after her sister was raped by another student self-proclaming gender-fluidity as a ploy to enter girl’s bathrooms and rape girls, her Father sought answers from the School Board, whereupon U.S. Attorney General, Merritt Garland, branded him a Domestic Terrorist.</p><p>To her Father’s credit, he was now entirely dependent upon the U.S. Federal Regime — his job was taken away as a result of being branded a terrorist, and now his rent and indeed his entire life was now dependent on total submission to the Regime.</p><p>The other fact was that Google’s citizen-surveillance group caught her searching on the words, “George Washington”, and promptly reported her to the Federal Regime.</p><p>In her application, Bethany went to great lengths to convince the unaccountable bureaucrat that would be reviewing her request for a soccer ball, that she was actually typing in about the “George Floyd’’ mural in Afghanistan, but Google’s type-ahead plugged “George Washington” instead. Bethany then proceeded to profusely apologize for George Washington being the General leading the Continental Army’s victory over Britain and creating America, as well as being the first President and the person to show the world how to achieve a peaceful transfer of power.</p><p>Bethany longed for the time she once knew where her parents could decide how to spend money… the time before the “innocuous” IRS Surveillance Act of 2021.</p><p><strong>The IRS Surveillance Act of 2021</strong></p><p>In 2021, The U.S. Federal Regime announced that the IRS would track every bank account with more than $600 in it.</p><p>At the time, Jen Psaki and numerous other Regime operatives were dispatched with talking points “assuring” the masses that this IRS Surveillance was but an innocuous measure that would not be abused for mass surveillance, warrantless searching, and subjugation of the average American with the immense power of the IRS and unlimited funds to bash anyone into submission.</p><p>This concern proved naive.</p><p>Naive, not because it didn’t prove true, but because it was minor compared to the monsters that no one imagined that this IRS Surveillance Act opened.</p><p>Most notably, was equity.</p><p>That is, within months of having unrestrained access to every American’s bank accounts, the U.S. Federal Regime discovered that people with lots of money tend to buy nicer clothes, enjoy dinners at fancier restaurants and worst of all, provide their children with tutoring.</p><p>All of which flew in the U.S. Federal Regime’s doctrine of equity. Everyone must be equally miserable and unaccomplished, and it was the U.S. Federal Regime’s mission to make this happen.</p><p>And since the U.S. Federal Regime already had access to every American’s bank account; it simply extended that from surveillance to control of the funds in them.</p><p>As Jen Psaki proudly rationalized this expansion of power, that since half or more of America was already dependent upon the Government, the U.S. Federal Regime’s take-over of every American’s bank account was merely a recognition of massive societal dependency on the U.S. Federal Regime had already “achieved”.</p><p>Accordingly, in 2022, the Federal Regime took control of all banks and funds in America — deciding and allocating for every American the funds that the Regime deemed appropriately… and equitably. The economy was destroyed, but at least it was destroyed equitably.</p><p>However, upon taking control of all of the banks and funds in the Nation, the Regime found itself overwhelmed — overwhelmed by the millions or even billions of different items Americans wanted, multiplied by dozens of product permutations.</p><p>The sheer volume of allocations dwarfed the number of America-hating graduates that Harvard, Yale, and Georgetown University could produce in a year or even a century.</p><p>Accordingly, the U.S. Federal Regime, then Nationalized everything and anything that Americans could buy, enabling the all-knowing-but-uninformed Harvard, Yale and Georgetown University graduates to select and reduce the number and types of products that Americans could have.</p><p>The number of vendors offering Soccer balls, for example, was reduced from 2,523 to the one that provided the most Lear Jet trips for AOC to fly to conferences about Climate Change. Similarly, the infinite expanse of clothing was contained both to simplify the bureaucracies logistics but also to remove any sense of individuality, although the Regime resigned itself to having to allow more than 100 different types of shirts and pants, all in grey colors. Although exceptions would be allowed for yellow, white, and red on a case-by-case basis. And of course, the ruling class was free to wear whatever they wanted, most of which was provided to them free from members of the servant class seeking to influence some allocation decision made by the Federal Regime.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/510/1*ekHgEmGr_z2-DOF6ptnWlw.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is the country that Bethany now lives.</p><p>And when no one is there to see her eyes that might expose her inner thoughts; when her cellphone is turned off so that the U.S. Federal Regime can’t know her every move; and when she is far away from people that she doesn’t have to worry about sending a victim-apology letter to someone that shoots, rapes, or robs her; Bethany wonders what life was like when Americans respected each other, had freedom, and controlled government.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=391a2fa8eff5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Date versus Citizens]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/date-versus-citizens-1b714621ae30?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1b714621ae30</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[afghanistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democratic-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Aug 2021 18:58:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-03T19:22:25.525Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Date versus Citizens.</p><p>The difference of one simple word makes the irrefutable and absolute fact that the Biden Administration and the entire Democratic Party supporting it, are detached from America.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c3XXp8LZfHzH8nT5X571wQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pYP_-XFzYbm-MXVfb3jQDQ.png" /></figure><p>The self-inflicted blunders of the Biden/Democrat-Party pull out of Afghanistan (none of which has anything to do with “Trump”), such as arming the World’s center of terrorism with $83 billion of our own weapons to use against us and the rest of the World, has inflicted damage on America and done so at a scale and duration beyond anything in America’s history that will haunt and hurt our country for decades to come if not forever.</p><p>But the chaos of this incompetence has distracted from the real problem, and this problem is of epic, absolute, irrefutable significance.</p><p><em>The irrefutable, absolute, and epic problem is that the Democratic Party-controlled government of America does not serve America.</em></p><p>From its founding, the one absolute purpose of America’s government was to protect its citizens. Without fail, in all 245 years of its existence, the American government eagerly fulfilled its duty from sending U.S. Marines to Tripoli in 1802 and even against the most impossible of odds such as the doomed attempt to rescue American’s from Iran in 1980.</p><p>Yet, upon the Democratic Party taking control of the government of America on January 6, 2021, the American government ceased protecting its own citizens…. a fact made irrefutable by the Democratic Party-controlled government setting a deadline not on the protection of its citizens but on something else.</p><p>It doesn’t matter what the something else is — <em>the mere fact that the people and party controlling our government acted in any other role than as protecting its citizens, is all that is needed to know that this particular government does not serve our country.</em></p><p>To be clear, it either simply didn’t dawn on the Democratic Party created and controlled Executive Office, State Department, Department of Defense, and Intelligence Agencies that their very purpose was to protect the average American citizen, or worse, they did think about it and then decided to ignore it anyhow. American Citizens do not matter to the Democratic Party.</p><p>And actually, things are much worse than this.</p><p>The mere fact that protecting its own citizens was not initially the goal of the Democratic Party-controlled government is unto itself irrefutable proof of a government not serving its own citizens, …. but then, even after both being made aware of its duty, and provided multiple opportunities every day for more than a month to do so, the Democratic Party-controlled government still acted without regard its own citizens.</p><p>The failure of the Democratic Party-controlled government to serve its fundamental duty was so blatant that it propelled third parties to unilaterally step in.</p><p>On their own, an all-volunteer group of U.S. Special Operations veterans organized, operated, and rescued 500 people from Afghanistan while the Democratic Party-controlled government sat on their hands (see <a href="https://abcn.ws/3ym85mZ).">https://abcn.ws/3ym85mZ).</a></p><p>Similarly, even U.S. Marines and the Democratic Party’s News Media (e.g. The New York Times) have felt compelled to openly speak against this government (see: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/28/opinion/afghanistan-biden-evacuation.html).">https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/28/opinion/afghanistan-biden-evacuation.html).</a> And American citizens such as the former owner of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers have resorted to full-page advertisements expressing their disgust of the actions of this Democratic Party-controlled government (see: <a href="https://twitter.com/AmieWohrer/status/1431669804323139585?s=20)">https://twitter.com/AmieWohrer/status/1431669804323139585?s=20)</a></p><p>As a side-note, just imagine the profound practical significance for its own good, if Citizens (and SIVs) rather than a date, had been the goal of the Democratic Party-controlled government. Namely, the Taliban “government”, would see to it that every citizen and SIV would be out of Afghanistan in the proverbial New York Second. True to form, incompetence and dereliction of duty not only harm others but also harms the very people and their agenda committing the incompetence and dereliction.</p><p>To most American citizens and most of the World, it was hard to believe that this behavior was even possible, but statements by Democratic Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (see <a href="https://www.speaker.gov/newsroom/81421-1),">https://www.speaker.gov/newsroom/81421-1)</a> literally commending this behavior, as well as the absence of statements from Democratic party members who are highly vocal on every other matter, tells of a <strong>Democratic Party governing body that exists simply to hold power, rather than serve its citizens.</strong></p><p>Every day the media needs to fill its 24 hours of television or hundreds of pages of print media. Similarly, every day, Politicians need to fill time with talk. And half of the population of America needs to find comfort in being part of the death of 13 young U.S. Marines, Navy, and Army Troops including a soon-to-be Father and woman that just days before posted a picture of herself caring for an Afghan baby (If you can bear to listen to it, this audio captures a Mother’s grief resulting from the Democratic Party-controlled government’s actions. <a href="https://bit.ly/3gKpMqd).">https://bit.ly/3gKpMqd)</a>, let alone the abandoned American Citizens and Afghan SIVs that we are certain to learn of in the future. The volume of incompetence, tragedies, heroics, and aftermath, can and will media, books, and history for months if not centuries to come. And the Democratic Party will be amply capable of feeding talking points, diversions, and rationalizations to fit this time and space.</p><p>So whenever the distraction and fog of the politic-talk arisen, very simply ask the question: Why did the Democratic Party-controlled government? as to ask this question is to answer this question. Namely: his Democratic Party-controlled government does not exist to serve America or Americans.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1b714621ae30" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Sustainability Reinvention of the Movement Economy Has Just Begun]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/the-sustainability-reinvention-of-the-movement-economy-has-just-begun-566a15cd5383?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/566a15cd5383</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hydrogen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[green-energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Jul 2020 03:03:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-01T21:09:30.693Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The Sustainability Reinvention of the Movement Economy Has Begun</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JRKkVK9_9nzbPCej0NMM_w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://unsplash.com/@mischievous_penguins">https://unsplash.com/@mischievous_penguins</a></figcaption></figure><p>Much of the economic activity in our world moves atoms or electrons — this ranges from transporting across oceans the computer (e.g. atoms) that you are viewing this very moment to powering (e.g. electrons) the Internet server farm presenting this article. Other sectors include commercial trucking, air transportation, heavy industries, mining, agriculture, construction machinery, iron-ore reduction, energy-intensive industries, and on and on. In short, half or more of the world’s energy usage is for moving atoms and electrons — the Movement Economy.</p><h4>The Energy Density Gap</h4><p>Alas despite exponential advancements in renewable energy, the fundamental gap in energy density between fossil fuels and renewable energy storage (in the form of batteries), has held back the Movement Economy from being reinvented as an environmentally sustainable one. Hydrogen held out hope for filling this gap, but producing hydrogen was neither cheap nor clean, as 95% of hydrogen is produced by burning other fuels.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*44eiq0Ed79z_VvZ8" /><figcaption>The Economist. July 4, 2020</figcaption></figure><h4>This changed in 2019</h4><p>During 2019 Hydrogen became cheap and clean, and this, in turn, unleashes the entire stack of renewable energy technology for the wide-scale reinvention of the Movement Economy.</p><p>Hydrogen became cheap and clean — so-called Green Hydrogen — because the cost of renewable energy became cheaper than fossil fuel energy, and the supply of it expanded outpaced the ability to store it to the point where states such as California, enforces curtailments of its generation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jvuxbG8hDMELtPFK" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/716/0*Xz3woGW5S4OfEHZJ" /></figure><p>Sources:<a href="https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=43775"> Large battery systems are often paired with renewable energy power plants</a>. May 18, 2020, by the <em>U.S. Energy Information Administration</em>. <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1cpwkGQiHIW1zX8eVVljsNus4YPQnbrjj/view">Renewable Power Generation Costs in 2019</a> (page 13) dated 2020 by the <em>International Renewable Energy Agency</em>.</p><p>Below is a plot of the curtailments regularly going on in California — literally megawatt-hours of energy being tossed for want of long-term storage such as hydrogen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NccH5LZZ9zljRvJvJA8YsA.png" /><figcaption>ACT Webinar July 22, 2020</figcaption></figure><h4>Sustainability Impact</h4><p>The two charts below project the impact on the world’s sustainability of just the green hydrogen part of the renewable energy stack on the Movement Economy. Notably, the first chart predicts that green hydrogen’s potential impact on reducing the environmentally harmful effects of aviation is not just in the reduction of CO2 emissions, but also environmentally harmful contrails.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ohM9EGrIr49asS-1" /><figcaption>Hydrogen-powered aviation. McKinsey &amp; Co. May 2020.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*IeyZFOnEyKAEfDKT" /></figure><p>Moreover, the benefits to the world go beyond even sustainability. The decoupling of countries and economies from the few centralized sources of fossil fuels to locally generated and stored energy reduces global conflict. It also spells employment not just for millions of people, which is good unto itself, but these new jobs are inherently distributed around the world, taking a swing at income inequality as well as boosting economies.</p><h4>Business Drivers</h4><p>While governmental and societal pressures to change are good unto themselves, business drivers make things happen quickly, and already, business drivers are manifesting. Case in point is fork trucks — the machines that move stuff in the millions of warehouses and factories around the world. Companies are already replacing the (zero-emission) batteries in fork trucks with hydrogen fuel cells. Since both are zero-carbon, companies are doing this because hydrogen has business advantages. There’s actually a long list of advantages, but one that makes the point is there’s essentially negligible energy-replenishment time with hydrogen storage, and hence, in turn, the much more utilization of a given fork truck. In 2020, According to the CEO of Hydrogen technology company Plug Power, 30% of the food that goes on the table in the U.S. every day, has been touched by a hydrogen-powered fork truck.</p><h4>Already things are happening</h4><p>Major ocean carriers have recently announced plans to switch their terribly atmospherically dirty diesel freighters with hydrogen-powered ones. Similarly, where green energy (i.e. just using batteries) previously lacked the range for commercial trucking, companies such as Nikola have been launched in partnership with major companies to provide trucking using renewable energy and in particular, hydrogen; the first zero-energy beer shipment was completed this past November by Anheuser-Busch. Zero-emission beer delivery is in our future!</p><p>According to a study by Wood Mackenzie done earlier this year (i.e. the numbers have only increased since then), businesses have already committed to projects aggregating to a <strong>twelvefold</strong> increase in hydrogen generation capacity in just the next five years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*shf8xpWfz2GlWD3quXC7sQ.png" /></figure><p>Within the past few months, governments and companies have put real commitments behind reinventing the Movement Economy:</p><ul><li>In June, the California Air Resources Board adopted a first-in-the-world rule requiring truck manufacturers to transition from diesel trucks and vans to zero-emission vehicles beginning in 2024.</li><li>In June, Germany announced a National Hydrogen Strategy that sees reformulating entire value chains and international trade with Green Hydrogen. This strategy includes €7 billion to support German Hydrogen companies and €2 billion to support international partnerships and a 200-fold increase in Hydrogen Electrolyzer capacity by 2030.</li><li>In June, Europe’s largest utility, Enel announced it will be installing Green Hydrogen electrolyzers as part of its plans to become carbon-free by 2050.</li><li>In June, a joint venture of Engie, Michelin, Credit Agricole, and Banque de Territoires announced that it will finance, build and operate Zero Emission Valley (ZEV) including the deployment of 1,200 fuel-cell vehicles and 20 hydrogen stations by the end of 2023.</li><li>In the past three months, major companies around the globe announced that they are switching all future business developments to green-energy based ones.</li></ul><p>Similarly, capital is suddenly available to back hydrogen-based startups. Major companies have started acquiring or investing in hydrogen businesses, and the market value of eight publicly-traded hydrogen companies doubled in the first six months of 2020.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UDE1bJnWiFZZnk8b1vC86g.png" /><figcaption>Prepared by the Author</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Calling All Entrepreneurs</strong></h4><p>The transformation of the fossil fuel automobile industry into the electrical one that it is racing to become today was caused by an industry outsider with ideas outside comfortable norms, and who got a footing for his innovation in a market that was too small and different to be considered by the existing industry players. Moreover, Tesla didn’t just disrupt the industry with an innovative product, but effectively blew-up the very structure of the industry, changing the century-old dealer network with direct sales, and similarly obviating the entire practice and industry structure of tiered component suppliers, with a completely inhouse stack.</p><p>A similar opportunity exists for entrepreneurs in the Movement Economy and the thousands of industries in it.</p><p>For example, the reinvention of the aviation industry isn’t going to occur by the incumbent air transportation industry replacing its airplanes which will take decades even to get off the drawing board, but rather start with short-hop services using new VTOL (vertical landing and take-off) aircraft, and then expand from there…. much as Tesla got it footing in a niche market for high-end sports enthusiasts and then progressed to the general consumer market. To be clear, just this one different path implies opportunities for startups providing the actual air service, producing the VTOL aircraft, maintaining the hydrogen power supplies, and fuel cells specifically optimized for aviation needs.</p><p>Ditto for the power industry. Currently, the power industry including infrastructure, pricing, regulation, employment, and so-on, is set-up around a highly centralized generation, whereas renewable energy power is inherently better (i.e. more reliable, safer, and less expensive) with distributed or even localized generation. Once again, this poses opportunities for entrepreneurs unconstrained by industry norms to create a business with inherently superior product offerings, pricing models, and service operations.</p><p>The entire massive Movement Economy is at the forefront of orders-of-magnitude innovation and self-enforcing demand drivers, as for example, as with each new application or innovation in base technologies, the capital costs for a given output goes down, which in turn opens up more applications and fuels more innovation — likely for decades to come.</p><p>In short, the starting gun has just gone off for thousands of entrepreneurial opportunities, but in this case, one that actually saves our planet.</p><h4>Update</h4><p>After publishing this story….</p><ul><li>The EU <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-07-21/eu-approves-biggest-green-stimulus-in-history-with-572-billion-plan?sref=l5cxkaYx">Approved €500 billion</a> for climate-change programs.</li><li>The UK announced £350 million to address greenhouse gas emissions in Heavy Industry, Construction and Transport.</li><li>The largest renewable energy generator in the United States, NextEra Energy, announced that it plans to build<a href="https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/nextera-energy-to-build-its-first-green-hydrogen-plant-in-florida?utm_medium=email&amp;utm_source=Daily&amp;utm_campaign=GTMDaily"> its first green hydrogen plant</a>; committing $65 million to do so.</li><li>Power Innovations announced successfully <a href="https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/power/power-innovations-announces-new-record-in-use-of-hydrogen-fuel-cell-technology/77164432">powering a full Internet data center </a>with Hydrogen Fuel Cells.</li></ul><p><em>J. Neil Weintraut is a partner at </em><a href="https://www.pathway.vc/"><em>Motus Ventures</em></a><em>, a venture capital firm focused on reinventing the Movement Economy. Neil can be emailed via neil@motusventures.com</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=566a15cd5383" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Respond to the Media — Don’t]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/how-to-respond-to-the-media-dont-533146fb1ca3?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/533146fb1ca3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Mar 2020 07:19:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-04T20:55:56.509Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How to Respond to the Media — Don’t</h3><p>As highlighted during one of Jason Calacanis’ “<em>This Week in Startups</em>” podcast (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eel8ABjrYZQ&amp;t=888s">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eel8ABjrYZQ&amp;t=888s</a>), a recent dustup between some notable Silicon Valley figures and the media brought-up the question and wisdom of tech companies and people in the tech industry responding to inquiries from the media. (Addendum: See also the footnote at the end of this article).</p><p>This article provides both the answer to this question, as well as some insights dealing with the media, if you still choose to ignore this answer.</p><p>Based on my twenty-some years of experience and observations of dealing with the media, the short answer to this question is: don’t.</p><h3>The Storyline or Storyline-Agenda is Already In Place</h3><p>There are many reasons why it’s not wise to respond to the media, but the one that I believe provides the most motivation and understanding for not responding, is that the storyline or storyline-agenda has already been set.</p><p>This is especially important to understand when you believe that the media is doing a story that is negative or contrary to your interests; important to understand because you believe, or at least hope, that you can persuade the reporter to write otherwise.</p><p>You can’t.</p><p>In fact, not only has the storyline or storyline-target already been set but set by an editor or editorial agenda that you will never engage or change. The last time I’ve ever seen a storyline being changed was in 1997 in a Time Magazine article telling of their intent and efforts to publish an article with the storyline tying the mass suicide of the Heaven’s Gate to some demented consequence of the then-emerging Internet that was the popular theme of the press at that time, but couldn’t find content that actually supported this storyline.</p><h3>The Reporter Isn’t Calling You for the Reason that You Think They Are</h3><p>Most of us naturally think — and the reporter happily allows you to believe — that you are being called by the reporter to hear your side of the story. They’re not.</p><p>So why is the reporter even calling you? The answer to this question is not only is what few people are aware of until it is pointed out to them, but it is an ironic and harmful twist.</p><p>The media isn’t calling you to hear <em>your</em> side of the story but to validate <em>their</em> storyline.</p><p>The media needs to show readers that it heard from the other side of the storyline, and in doing so not only affords credibility to their story, but is assuring readers that their storyline holds even in the face of the other side of the story. Bottom line — you responding to the media validates for the reader, the very storyline that you seek to change!</p><p>Just including some quote, indeed any quote, from you in the article showing the readers that they talked with you is the win for the media. The actual content of the quote is secondary to the mere fact that the media and reporter can show that they actually did speak with you. For example, even an outright refutation of the storyline winds up being used to show that even inclusive of your refutation, the storyline still holds.</p><p>Sharing an incident that I experienced personally: During a time when the standard media storyline on Amazon was that its loss-ridden operations were destined to fail, I was a vocal advocate for the future of Amazon. After being interviewed by <em>The Wall Street Journal</em> for an hour, I was quoted in their article, but essentially nothing of the positive case for Amazon that I made was cited or even just recognized. The storyline of the article was decidedly negative, and I was but a citation lending to the credibility of their storyline.</p><h3>You Haven’t Just Been Misquoted or Taken out of Context</h3><p>A, if not the most, commonly cited issue people experience with the media is being misquoted or taken out of context.</p><p>Most likely, anyone who has experienced this <em>was</em> misquoted or taken out of context. However misquotes and being taken out of context are not just the isolated incident that one might readily believe, but rather is a manifestation of the systemic storyline problem detailed above.</p><p>The distinction is important because merely being misquoted suggests that the outcome could be different in the future, whereas realizing that the misquote is but a consequence of storyline tells of a systemic problem with the same outcome in the future.</p><h3>A Story doesn’t Necessarily Mean that there’s a Story</h3><p>One day I received a call from a popular San Francisco Chronicle reporter. The reporter called because he happened to see that the stock of a particular computer company was up a dollar that day; to which I explained to him that today was no different than any other day as a dollar change was well within its normal trading range. Despite that, the reporter pressed to talk more about this stock. We talked about it for perhaps a half-hour, drifting off into incidental minutia such as the fact that Fujitsu owned 49% of the company leading people for wonder if Fujitsu will ultimately acquire it for more than a decade, although there was no particular reason to believe that this was happening anytime in the foreseeable future.</p><p>The next day, and to my surprise the headline story in the Business section, was a sensational story about this company being acquired by Fujitsu citing the dollar change in this company’s stock price. Although I was quoted in the story, absent from it was all of the salient facts that I had discussed — facts any one of which obviated the entire story.</p><p>There are two insights for all of us to appreciate from this anecdote.</p><p>One of the two insights, is the media’s game of soft truths — enticing us to believe a story through facts that while true, is misleading or wildly triaged. Think of totaling your car but only telling your significant other that your car needed new windshield wipers.</p><p>In the case of the above incident, the soft truths were the fact that the stock price moved by one dollar and there was a belief that the company would be acquired; these two soft-truths made the story credible. But of course, the story was actually fallacious. Consequently, hundreds of people on Wall Street scramble to figure out what was going on, let alone the company having to field hundreds of phone calls — all for sake of a media story that wasn’t a story at all.</p><p>The other insight from this anecdote, is that the mere fact that there’s a story in the media doesn’t mean that there’s actually a story that is new or even exists in the real world.</p><p>In the case of the story (http://bit.ly/2Ib8q45)behind the dustup that opened this article, the storyline is: <strong>“No handshakes please: The tech industry is <em>terrified </em>of the coronavirus</strong>” and opens citing the actions of “prestigious venture capital firm”….. yet nowhere is the word “terrified” used in the actual article, and the “prestigious venture capital firm” is doing nothing more than is widely done and has been widely advocated on mass media.</p><p>That is, much as the media used a routine dollar-change in a stock price to trump-up an article about a (fallacious) acquisition, here the media used a “prestigious venture capital firm’s” now common practice of not shaking hands, to trump up a storyline having the tech industry <em>terrified</em> of the coronavirus.</p><p>Tellingly, this “prestigious venture capital firm” declined to respond to this media’s inquiries, which is exactly the advice of this article.</p><p>Indeed, when you think about it, you’ll probably agree that the venture capital firm talking to this reporter wouldn’t have changed either the sensational storyline or exploitation of their firm’s name. Indeed, all that would happen from this firm talking with the media would be to lend credibility to the sensationalized storyline.</p><p>Moreover, most of us don’t actually read the full article but rather just read the headline and skim the first paragraph — this then becomes what we believe to be true.</p><p>Anyone doing this with this coronavirus story would be left believing that the tech industry is terrified to the point where a prestigious venture capital firm has taken extraordinary action.</p><p>This is unfortunate.</p><p>Unfortunate, not just because this leaves most people with a false understanding, but because it shortchanges us from valuable information on this matter of global significance, as the actual content of the article beyond the sensational storyline is quite informative.</p><p>For the minority readers that actually read the rest of the article beyond the sensationalized storyline, they’ll learn: (i) that nobody is irrationally “terrified” but rather sensibly have a “growing sense of anxiety” — and hence, possibly worth emulating; (ii) that this anxiety and behavior is not unique to “prestigious venture capital firms” but rather broad-based; and (iii) important information about the facial masks, the viruses history, both the risks of actually getting the virus and the likely consequences if you do. That is, a hell of a lot of good information.</p><p>I can’t help believing that merely presenting a storyline of “The Tech Industry’s Growing Anxiety about the Coronavirus and What You Can Learn From It”, or even just: “What you should know about the Coronavirus”, would have genuinely served the greater good of society, rather than the sensationalized one that the media instinctively resorted.</p><p>In total, just because a reporter calling you is doing a (media) story, doesn’t mean that there’s a (real) story, and the only thing that you’ll “achieve” by responding to the reporter is to ironically and unwittingly provide “soft truths” to pump up a storyline or even enable a story that would have otherwise collapsed.</p><h3>Disproportionality</h3><p>In his podcast, Jason Calacanis advises technophiles “to never talk to journalists on the phone” and instead “always use email and let the journalist know you plan to publish your answers to your blog”. Jason advises doing this to afford some incentive and protection from being misquoted, but it actually touches on a problem with the media that is severe yet invisible. Namely, Disproportionality.</p><p>This problem takes many forms. The most intuitive one is where a reporter interviews numerous people but disproportionately cites the people and responses that support the storyline. In extreme cases, the media will run with a storyline even after the majority of the people that they interview contradict it. Obviously, since you don’t know what the media leaves out, this practice and its highly distorting consequences, is invisible to us.</p><p>Another form of disproportionality is simply what the media does and does not report, often with broad-based effects on popular beliefs.</p><p>Case in point is that the media only report on a tech company once it is successful, leading many tech employees falsing believing there’s an overnight success, and in turn, wondering why their startup isn’t doing the same.</p><p>In reality, save for an extraordinary few, the seemingly overnight successes that we read about, were actually the culmination of years of grueling work, multiple startup attempts, with things like preparing for bankruptcy another such stuff that doesn’t fit the popular media storyline of overnight successes.</p><p>Similar behavior and consequence can be seen from the media’s disproportionality between consumer versus business tech companies. Google “bill.com IPO” and you’ll get precious few search results. But if you do the same for “doordash ipo”, your computer will all but meltdown with the outpouring of media stories. Yet bill.com publicly filed and then went public on December 12th, whereas doordash hasn’t done either (it has only recently confidentially filed). Bill.com is enterprise automation whereas doordash is consumer services. In short, business-tech is half or more of the tech industry, but you wouldn’t know that from the disproportionality of the media’s reporting.</p><p>I’ve long fantasized about requiring the media to publicly disclose all of the interviews and information that they had in preparing the article as this single act, I believe, would materially and affirmatively change media. It appears unlikely that the media industry will be doing this anytime in the foreseeable future, so Jason’s idea of only responding to reporters in writing and then publishing your responses on the Internet is the most likely path toward addressing the media problem of disproportionality.</p><h3>Choose One</h3><p>The article repeatedly warns about the media having a storyline that you cannot change. It’s actually much worse. One likes to think that the media is calling you about a storyline formulated especially for you, but the odds are that you are just today’s flavor of a small set of common storylines time-proven to garner the grab readers and entail little effort.</p><p>In particular, the storyline that you are being asked to respond to, and most of what you read in the tech media is just a flavor one of the following.</p><ul><li>IPOs. The IPO window is closed. The IPO window is open. The IPO was priced too low. The IPO was priced too high.</li><li>VCs. Powerful VCs take advantage of vulnerable entrepreneurs.</li><li>Unicorns. Becoming a Unicorn. Falling from being a Unicorn.</li><li>Entrepreneurs and Executives. He/She is a celebrity. He/She is bad.</li><li>Gender/Sexual-Orientation/Ethnic angle.</li><li>Rumors, Speculation or anything else that is juicy; no facts or discretion needed.</li><li>“Everybody has been &lt;fill in the blank&gt;” (Hint: It turns out that “everyone” is but the bubble of people in the media itself, not the real world.)</li></ul><p>IPO storylines exemplify why and how the media uses these storylines again and again. For starters, there’s inherently a ready base of readers, namely, everyone involved one way or another with the IPO. It’s also easy; if a stock goes up after an IPO, then just plug in the details to the “IPO was priced too low storyline”; if it goes down plug in the same details to the “IPO was priced too high storyline”.</p><p>But there’s another reason that I used the IPO storyline as an example, as it provides a warning about the storyline that the press is calling you about. Namely, it’s mostly nonsense.</p><p>That is, for example, when the press deems an IPO a success or failure, the press hasn’t done some fundamental analysis or even thought about it in any meaningful way (i.e. the media isn’t even clear for whom their measuring success — a stock that goes up after an IPO theoretically was bad for the company and good for the investor). The storyline is just that — a template that is force-fill with whatever content the reporter can scrounge-up to put out a story. Indeed, there’s a good chance that if you ask a reporter to calculate the market cap of the company that they are deeming to be a good or bad IPO, that they can’t do it.</p><p>How can you run a storyline deeming the success or failure of an IPO when you haven’t analyzed the market cap, revenue growth, debt, new product releases and any number of factors affecting the market value of the business? The answer, of course, is that you can’t… but that doesn’t impair the media from deeming an IPO a success or failure keyed off of nothing more than the relative direction of the stock price for some trivial amount of time.</p><p>Moreover, the above also exposes how recklessly the media creates a “fact” that is bunk. That is, for any given IPO, the media can and does deem it whatever it wants — that is, if an IPO, say, stays at its list price, depending on the whim of the editor, that media can decide that it was a successful IPO that was perfectly priced, or a failure because the price didn’t pop.</p><p>And the spirit of the media disproportionality mechanism, the media just call around until it finds someone that will give a quote to support whatever arbitrary storyline it is using, and voila! there is a story and a “fact” out of nothing more than an editorial agenda.</p><h3>Use Your Time on Social Media and Blogs, not Mainstream Media</h3><p>In his podcast, Jason Calacanis makes another important point for technophiles — namely, use social media.</p><p>Prior to social media, we had no choice. That is, the mainstream media was the only game in town, so we either submitted to their interviews or had no shot at all of having our say. The emergence of social media shattered this choiceless predicament, but there’s a lingering belief that we still need the mainstream media. We don’t. And you will be more effective using the time you would have otherwise spent on responding to the media, on your own social media.</p><h3>Media is a Business and a Bias</h3><p>We view the media as a vehicle driven to inform us, when in fact reality requires it to be a business and a business heavily biased by the people that run it.</p><p>Understand this difference and you’ll understand how to read and interact with the media.</p><p>If a media company actually crafted and published what we say we want (i.e. balanced and unsensationalized information), we wouldn’t read it or at least fewer of us will read it. Preparing balanced stories takes more effort — indeed massively more effort — and stories that aren’t sensationalized get fewer readers, inherently paring media companies with this business model from the economic system in favor of media companies that subjugate balance and sensationalize. Similarly, the reality is that editors that offer content biased toward their target audience replace editors that don’t; again in Darwinian self-selection toward media that inherently operates to sensationalization and biased agenda.</p><p>The media serves an important role in our society and in particular, the tech industry, and most if not all of the people in media are good people.</p><p>But when they call you, they are doing so not as some neutral court seeking to advocate for you and come to a conclusion as the facts unfold, but rather as a business needing to maximize its views within the shortest time and easiest effort.</p><p>The recent dustup cited at the start of this article encapsulates this understanding — the media conflated good content into a sensational storyline that maximized page views… and a season industry player refused to be played by it.</p><ol><li>The first 21 minutes of a podcast featuring Austen Allredy of the Lambda School (<a href="http://bit.ly/2uXQMOq">http://bit.ly/2uXQMOq</a>) details the realities of the media and dealing with them as discussed in this article</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=533146fb1ca3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Real Cybersecurity Future]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/a-real-cybersecurity-future-5104b4f62606?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5104b4f62606</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cybersecurity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Jul 2018 04:58:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-16T04:33:33.468Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If I could get President Trump’s ear in advance of his meeting with Russian President Putin I would try to convince him to do two things associated with this meeting.</p><p>Namely, walk into the meeting and tell President Putin that he needs to join the United States in a bilateral treaty against cyber-abuse, and if he refuses, end the meeting and have our cyber-agencies bring-down Moscow’s phone system or some other non-harmful cyber-effect that conveys to President Putin that times — and the United States — has changed.</p><p><strong>Politics</strong></p><p>Politically this would be quite the win. It would put to end all of the criticism that President Trump needs to deal with Putin as the untrustworthy adversary that he actually is, while at the same time, earning the attention and possibly respect-of-our-strength that President Putin needs to get. Indeed, it would put us in a position of strength to deal with all of the other matters with Russia including those that didn’t get addressed, by walking out of the meeting.</p><p><strong>Real World Cyber is Not What our Politicians or Media Think</strong></p><p>Politicians, media and other people that are in a position of power, talk of getting Russia to stop their cyber-activity. “Stopping” is not only unrealistic, but it is harmful.</p><p>Cyber-activity is an ever-expanding thing; doable by anyone anywhere at any time at essentially no cost or barrier, and can only be defended via a never-ending cat-and-mouse game where hackers discovering never-before-imagined attack-vectors makes the good guys aware of the vulnerability that in turn, they close.</p><p>In practical terms, if Russia was to somehow magically “stop” tomorrow, China, North Korea, Iran and some snarky teenager located who-knows-where (including our own Country) will still be working away accumulating vulnerabilities in everything from our Energy-grid to Election-systems.</p><p>Politicians and the media talk of “stopping” meddling in our elections. This can’t be stopped — even lone individuals provoking controversy on social media or even paying for inflammatory advertisements in plain sight, can, and it is wise to believe are, meddling with us even just for sport. Similarly, where and how does one draw the line in a country of free speech. We can’t “stop” it but there’s a heck of a lot that we can do to expose the sources and diminish their effectiveness.</p><p>I could go on and on, but the point is that instead of thinking that there’s some political or even technical way to “stop” cyber-activity, our politics and policy needs to expect and count on it happening more than ever.</p><p>With that brief encapsulation of the right way to “get” cyber matters, here are three of the implications to draw from it.</p><p><strong>Politics / Policy</strong></p><p>The bilateral treaty identified at the outset puts in place the mechanism assuming and expecting that there will be cyber-activity. Instead of trying to “stop” cyber-activity, the treaty puts the onus on each nation to cooperate in the identification and prosecution of the cyber-actors, but if and when Russia fails to comply with this prosecution, the treaty gives us the justification to cyber-retaliate against Russia. It’s somewhat akin the nuclear weapon treaties wherein they did not even expect that nuclear weapons could be stopped, but rather establish a point/counter-point incentive for each side containing the harmful conflagration of it.</p><p><strong>We Have Met the Enemy and It is Us. Burn Me Once Shame on You; Burn Me Twice Shame on Me.</strong></p><p>When we suffer a cyber-penetration (from someone else), we did it to ourselves.</p><p>The Gestalt of this perspective is woefully deficient throughout our entire economy and culture.</p><p>For example, it’s telling that there aren’t high-securitized versions of Android and Apple smartphones (and furthermore that our politicians, field technicians, and anyone touching any system with sensitive controls and/or information just resort to using the Android and Apple smartphones that are publicly available). We could have “perfect” cyber-technology, but as long as our people with power over sensitive information and systems walk around with a smartphone that is an inviting target for a pimply teenager to penetrate just for kicks, we are handing the gun that will kill us to our murderer. Witness, for example, the extraordinary-unanticipated side-effect of mobile-phone physical-training apps actually providing the Taliban with precise and predictable information about when and where to attack our troops in Afghanistan. It’s also time for Apple and Google to develop and offer a cyber-hardened version of their smartphones — indeed, it’s presently a missed business opportunity for them.</p><p>Similarly, the infamous cyber-penetration of the DNC computers was through well-known dirt-simple human-factor ploys almost as old as the commercial Internet itself. What was lacking, wasn’t some science-fiction type of cybersecurity technology, but rather nothing more than the proper mindset about cyber-security. Odds are that the cyber-hackers were probably very disappointed that the DNC made it so easy for them.</p><p>Meanwhile, the fundamental design of most of the systems the control much of our economy and government is woefully predisposed to cyber-based harm. These systems use single-points of decision; once the perimeter of the system is penetrated they are wide-open to all manner of side-effects. These systems need to be fundamentally redesigned using consensus-based decision mechanisms akin to blockchain technology and other modern technologies. Until we take on these major and decisive changes, both we are vulnerable and we put ourselves in this vulnerable position.</p><p>It’s time to cast aside the sound-bite “solutions” and mindset of our politicians and media, adopt the realistic mindset that cyber-resilience and defense is our perpetual responsibility, and let real cyber-experts do their job…. including abiding by any and all cyber-hygiene.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5104b4f62606" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Needs to Learn from Edwin the Robot, Michael Crichton, and…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@nweintraut/what-the-autonomous-vehicle-industry-needs-to-learn-from-edwin-the-robot-michael-crichton-and-7d669a0360f2?source=rss-90a4a400c4cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d669a0360f2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-driving-cars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uber]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autonomous]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Weintraut]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 May 2018 22:53:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-11T19:27:08.515Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TkV7LvxzTcaYxO5TIpcoOw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>(source: </em><a href="http://ecomento.com/2014/02/19/zero-emissions-hands-swiss-inventors-rinspeed-reveal-autonomous-tesla-model-s-video/"><em>ecomento</em></a><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>What the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Needs to Learn from Edwin the Robot, Michael Crichton, and Old-line Aviation</strong></h3><blockquote>On March 19, 2018, an Uber autonomous test vehicle avoidably struck and killed a person — the first known pedestrian fatality involving an autonomous vehicle of any kind.</blockquote><p>The aftermath of this incident showed that Uber, and probably everyone that is a player in super-advanced futuristic autonomous vehicle industry, will be well served to learn from the past, namely, Edwin the Robot, Michael Crichton, and (Old-line) Aviation.</p><p>First a recap on some of the recently established salient facts about the Uber incident as published in the The New York Times:</p><ul><li>“<em>The vehicle’s computer system determined it needed to break to avoid a crash</em>”, but… the “<em>built-in emergency braking system had been disabled while in autonomous mode</em>” and the reason that it was disabled was “<em>to ensure a smoother ride</em>”.</li><li>The safety driver “<em>was seen on dashboard cameras looking down and away from the road before the crash</em>.” Also, “A <em>toxicology report for the victim came back positive for methamphetamine and marijuana</em> (although they did not say drugs played a factor in the crash).”</li></ul><p>(See: “Emergency Braking was Disabled When Self-Driving Uber Killed Woman, Report Says”. <em>The New York Times</em>, Daisuke Wakabayashi, May 24, 2018.)</p><p><strong>Lesson 1: What Edwin the Mobile Autonomous Robot Knew Three Decades Ago</strong></p><p>In 1984, a group of five engineering students at Drexel University, including myself, successfully designed and deployed what was one of the first mobile autonomous robots. Below is a picture of Edwin traveling the hallways of Drexel University. Edwin has its own processing unit, autonomous navigation software, wheel encoders, and a constantly rotating 360 degree ranging sensor tracking everything around Edwin, every one second — just as the most advanced autonomous vehicles have today. The technologies that made Edwin run, of course, were hilariously archaic compared to the even a sliver of sliver of that fatalistic Uber vehicle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/334/1*PVA3-9Nojv62OxTHWaNhlQ.png" /></figure><p>But thirty-years-archaic that it is, our humble Edwin had a — and indeed the — fundamental “technology” that was shamefully left-out of the Uber vehicle.</p><p>Namely, Edwin had one fundamental design objective — hit no one.</p><p>That’s it. While our group too was enticed about all of the challenges of using and devising the most advanced technologies to show world and perhaps impress our girlfriends, this unsexy “hit no one” mindset, prevailed over everything.</p><p>Because of this fundamental culture that we levied on our ourselves, it was literally impossible for Edwin to ever hit anyone (short of someone maliciously climbing through the ceiling and literally plunging from above and landing exactly inches in front of Edwin… yes, our culture of “hit no one”, was so omnipresent that we thought of that scenario too).</p><p>This fundamental design standard meant for example, that the software had two levels, a regular level and a super level. The super level had one single and simple purpose, and it unstoppably overrode everything else. That single purpose was to… hit no one. The technology at this super-level was intentionally pretty darn simple; if there was a risk — any risk — of hitting something, stop. Period. No second-guessing, just stop.</p><p>Indeed, this culture of “hit no one” is physically visible on Edwin, as there is one sensor that is permanently mounted pointing forward. Edwin had other sensors that could also could detect (and hence avoid) a possible collision, but our culture of “hit no one” naturally led us to install a sensor dedicated to this virtuous mission. Indeed, this sensor had direct command on the “super level” described above. If the sensor stopped working Edwin stopped. If the sensor was working but detected anything that was at risk of being hit, Edwin stopped. If the rotating sensor detected a risk of hit something, Edwin stopped. And if the computer system itself somehow failed, Edwin would again, stop. That is, “hit no one” wasn’t some feature, another line of code, or something that could even be selected… it was essentially Edwin “himself”.</p><p>This culture further pervaded everything else. As we encountered the inevitable annoyances of “false positives” — circumstances that caused Edwin to erroneously decide to stop, “hit no one” held firm. That is, Edwin would continue to only operate to the unconditional standard of “hit no one” including erroneous stoppings, and only if and when we figured-out a 0% risk solution to a given false positive, would this be added into Edwin’s code.</p><p>I mention this particular design mindset toward “false positives”, because the reports of the Uber’s reaction to actually reducing safety in response to “false positives” speaks to a culture and management antithetical to “hit no one”.</p><p><strong>Lesson 2: What Michael Crichton Knew Four Decades Ago</strong></p><p>Four decades ago (1969), author <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Crichton">Michael Crichton</a> published the first of a series of novels — <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Andromeda_Strain"><em>The Andromeda Strain</em></a> — showing how human-fallibility and dirt-simple technology is always out there waiting to compromise complex-technology. Most people probably know of his literary work in the form of the movie <em>Jurassic Park</em> — which also shows human-fallibility and dirt-simple technology trumping complex technology — but <em>The Andromeda Strain</em> is the one that established him as a best-selling author and it was made into a movie in 1971. I think anyone in the tech industry would find this movie insightful and interesting to watch.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/212/0*OHreub0BD0WEbb-9" /></figure><p>In <em>The Andromeda Strain</em>, there are two critical flaws that almost lead to a worldwide infection of a extraterrestrial microbe (that came to Earth through a satellite that had fallen back to Earth). The story centers around an underground research center of scientist trying to figure out a defense against this microbe, and the Office of the President as it wrestles with a request from these scientist to drop a nuclear bomb, as what appears to be the only way to destroy the microbe.</p><p>Through much of the movie, the scientist are frustrated not receiving communications back from Washington, DC, only to have the operators of the research center proudly show and assure them of the highly-advanced communications technology and high-trained communication officers, who dutifully checked and drilled all of their advanced technology. Finally, as the situation collapses, the senior scientist presses the advanced communications people to look beyond their advanced-technologies, only to find that a trivial piece of printer paper scrap had wedged between the clapper and bell that notified these highly-trained officers when communications were received (and since the bell was blocked by a piece of paper, no notifications occurred). That is, all this advanced technology had obscured its vulnerability to dirt-simple technology.</p><p>In parallel with this communication system issue, an advanced-technology testing system subjecting the microbe to a battery of test was to designed to flag any test cases where the microbe didn’t multiply, with a bright flashing light to the scientist reviewing the test cases. Here, Crichton’s human fallibility comes into play, as the scientist reviewing them has epilepsy and she blanks-out on the flashing red lights signalling these profound results.</p><p>Now let’s look at the lessons for autonomous vehicles.</p><p>First, the matter of losing sight of dirt-simple technologies for sake of complex technologies.</p><p>The technologies that these autonomous vehicles use is pretty darn amazing. These technologies can figure out, say a dog, from a bike, from a car, from an overpass, and on and on. Albeit just most of time.</p><p>Meanwhile, the vehicles that these hyper-advanced autonomy technologies are being deployed, have standard — and hence, relatively low-tech — collision avoidance systems built into them. This includes the vehicle that Uber was using, namely, a Volvo XC9 Sport Utility Vehicle. Yetfor sake of its advanced-technology, Uber turned this low-tech system off(!)</p><p>Uber acted much as Michael Crichton’s communications-systems operators did in <em>The Andromeda Strain</em> — forsaking low-technology for the primacy of advanced-technology.</p><p>Parenthetically, I note that Edwin the Robot built more than three decades ago, intentionally foresaked advanced technology for the most dirt-simple solution possible; to us, “hit no one” prevailed over all… including and perhaps especially, advanced-technology.</p><p>Then there’s Michael Crichton’s other theme of human fallibility. Uber had a car-load of technologies dealing with the fallibility of the humans <em>outside</em> of the car, but not the human <em>inside</em> the car… and that human is the <em>safety</em> mechanism, as well as the human that is involved with the car the longest (i.e. hours versus just seconds with the outside humans).</p><p>Based on the reports, there was little effort or systems to either make this safety driver provide unconditional safety, and/or account for the reality that humans are indeed fallible.</p><p>For example, a simple message appearing randomly on the instrument panel or windshield prompting the driver to respond, not only would uncover the (distracted) behavior of this driver behind the Uber accident, but it would deter safety drivers from doing this bad behavior to begin with. Indeed, some these messages can actually be to offer relief, free lunch or even a bonus to the driver, turning this mechanism into one that the driver positively looks forward to seeing.</p><p>Similarly, the same image-processing capabilities of these outward-looking cameras, could also be applied as inward-looking cameras detecting when a driver isn’t paying attention. The driver’s manager then reviews the driver’s performance flagged by these cameras, and either takes corrective action with the driver, or removes the driver.</p><p>Then there’s plain-old human factors practices. For example, swap out drivers every two hours or even sooner. Similarly, give drivers a voice — literally invite and have them comment on what they are observing about the car’s behavior and the travel.</p><p><strong>Lesson 3: (Old-Line) U.S. Commercial Aviation</strong></p><p>The risks of flying through the skies, makes any type of vehicle travel on the ground seem like a walk in the park. Yet amongst numerous other achievements of safety of U.S. Commercial Aviation (e.g. American, Delta, JetBlue, Southwest, and other major airlines) is that not a single fatality occurred for more than a decade until the recent fan-blade tragedy on a Southwest flight. To be clear, this safety record was achieved in the face of phenomenal assaults on safety, such as the emergency landing of an airplane on the Hudson River. Simply put, flying entails exceptionally higher risks than driving, yet you are safer on an U.S. Commercial Airline than in a car.</p><p>This phenomenal safety exists because nothing less than an all encompassing culture and myriad of designs and systems… for safety.</p><p>For example, a new pilot learns on day-one that essentially anything and everything that happens with a flight is his or her responsibility — that is, it’s a mindset of absolute focus and responsibility on the pilot for nothing short of a safe flight.</p><p>Airplanes are designed with redundant systems. Every salient piece of information about every flight is captured and protected in the“black boxes” that have become synonymous with airplanes (the color of these boxes is actually bright orange). Simple deviations of anything putting safety at risk, triggers reviews and possibly retraining of pilots, air traffic controllers, mechanics and ground crew. Airplane parts are precisely tracked and routinely sent to manufacturers for preemptive examination. Learning is constant and iterative. Articles about safety, or even reports from the NTSB, are routine features of even routine aviation magazines.</p><p>And many not-obvious and enlightened innovations all in pursuit of safety pervade the aviation industry.</p><p>For example, once authorities realized that: (i) much of the information furthering safety, naturally comes from the people actually doing the work — pilots, air traffic controllers, maintenance, cabin crew and the like, and (ii) both there was no effective system for capturing this information, and often the people with the information were reluctant to report it lest it be turned against them.</p><p>Seeing this, the FAA set-up a confidential reporting system independently operated by NASA, providing the means and immunity, for the front-line people to report safety matters for the benefit of aviation at large. This system alone — the<a href="https://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/index.html"> Aviation Safety Reporting System</a> (ASRS) — receives an average of 366 safety-related reports every working day.</p><p>U.S. Commercial Aviation wasn’t always like this. Prior to 1956, substantially all that is behind today’s phenomenal safety, didn’t exist.</p><p>Then, on June 30, 1956, this lack — and wishful-thinking — of safety all came to roost. Two U.S. commercial airliners crashed into each other at 21,000 feet, killing all 128 people aboard. It was this incident that triggered a fundamentally new and different mindset and standard for aviation safety, that is still unfolding some sixty years later.</p><p>Perhaps you can see why I brought up this history — it is my hope that the autonomous vehicle industry uses this Uber tragedy as its trigger to any entirely different phase of safety-first, and similarly spare itself from reinventing a 60-year-long learning cycle that the aviation industry has already gone through, by embracing the best safety practices of the aviation industry, for itself.</p><p>There’s actually a long list of things and principles that the autonomous vehicle industry can adopt from the aviation industry, but as an example of something that is non-existent but is a proven winner, would the creation and operation of a collective autonomous vehicle industry reporting system akin to the highly-successful ASRS. That is, a system that pools together the individual learnings of each vendor for the collective good autonomous vehicles at large.</p><p>Another counter-intuitive step that the industry can do is to start tracking and publishing data about accidents that were avoided — that is, incidents where the autonomous vehicle had to deviate do to dangerous actions by pedestrians, human-driven cars, and animals. Sharing this information too will help the collective industry and actually be good for future public relations.</p><p>A future of Autonomous Vehicles is amazing. And of course, the accident and fatality rate is all but certain to be vastly superior to human drivers by orders of magnitude. However, the industry will be much better off, if its design-standard is not based upon merely being superior to human drivers, but a vastly different mindset of zero incidents at all. We’re the tech industry so we can do it. It may take decades to ultimately get there, but we won’t get there unless the standard and drive of zero incidents is the at our core.</p><p>UPDATE: On December 10, 2018 <em>The Information</em> published an <a href="https://www.theinformation.com/articles/how-an-uber-whistleblower-tried-to-stop-self-driving-car-disaster">article</a> disclosing that five days before this incident, a manager in Uber’s autonomous vehicle unit sent an email to senior management warning of a defective safety culture at the company.</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/nweintraut/"><em>J. Neil Weintraut</em></a><em> is a Partner at </em><a href="http://www.motusventures.com/"><em>Motus Ventures</em></a><em>, a Venture Capital firm with numerous investments in companies developing autonomous vehicle technologies, including Quanergy, Metawave, Metamoto, CivilMaps, and Argus Cybersecurity.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d669a0360f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>