<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Omar Masry on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Omar Masry on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 19:36:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[California Senate Bill 649 | The Problem with Not-So-Small Small Cells]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/california-senate-bill-649-the-problem-with-not-so-small-small-cells-973e562f1409?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/973e562f1409</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zoning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 May 2017 19:20:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-20T19:29:49.575Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Imagine if a company you never heard of showed up one day and placed an antenna on a street light near your house or even right next to your window, with several bulky cabinets, lead acid batteries, noisy cooling fans, and untidy cabling.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L3lHUe0GpaIF4ijU2gE3Zg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A “Small Cell” with noisy cooling fans in Oakland, California. Under Senate Bill 649, this could be placed on the sidewalk right in front of your home, even if there are no wooden poles (holding up the antennas) in your neighborhood. The large cabinets include lead acid batteries for backup power, computer racks, electric meters and more.</figcaption></figure><p>If <a href="https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180SB649">Senate Bill 649</a> passes through the State Capitol, that may become a reality. The bill would eliminate many types common sense local review to protect neighborhood character when wireless carriers propose equipment and antennas along streets, sidewalks, or on poles near your house.</p><p>Wireless carriers argue that they need these measures to meet the growing consumer demand for data capacity, but these same consumers are also residents of communities who experience the negative externalities associated with haphazard and poorly-planned wireless deployments. Since residents are not able to directly negotiate with wireless carriers, they pay taxes and rely on localities to represent them, which isalso a manifestation of market demand where no other means exists to influence the architecture and design of their physical surroundings. This bill is simply not necessary to unleash “5G” connectivity because it is possible for wireless carriers to work constructively with California cities and counties to build “Small Cells” that are actually small, quiet, and respectful of their surroundings. In fact, cities up and down the State already allow for wireless carriers to install Small Cells on City-owned poles and utility poles that are small, quiet, and well-designed. Whether it’s cities like San Diego, Los Angeles, or even historic residential neighborhoods in San Francisco like Telegraph Hill.</p><p>Yet, the incoherent and inconsistent language of SB 649 would represent the folly of allowing Sacramento politicians to dictate what gets built in your neighborhood with extreme legal overreach on local review and burden taxpayers with costs of protracted court battles that are likely to follow. SB 649 removes nearly all common-sense input by neighbors and allows for designs that look like something put together using the parts bin at the back of a Radio Shack (bundles of wiring, large industrial type brackets, carrier logos, etc.).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*KK2AXH_iEVTqH9p5Rtxgnw.png" /><figcaption>In many cities, carriers have placed Small Cell antennas in hidden locations such as atop bus stops. WIth SB 649, carriers can simply put up exposed cabinets, antennas, and large mounting brackets, nearly anywhere with little in the way of respecting neighborhood design.</figcaption></figure><p>While this legislation is being carried by State Senator Ben Hueso of Imperial and (southeastern) San Diego Counties, the real sponsors are well-financed lobbyists. State Senator Mike McGuire (Santa Rosa), as a committee chair, has tried to make some positive changes, such as exempting historic districts from the bill, but the last-minute changes by lobbyists have made this bill confusing even to City Attorneys that focus just on telecommunications issues. The lobbyists also neglected to mention that under a separate Federal rule known as “6409” the carrier could come back the day after a smaller site is approved and add a 10-foot height extension or more antennas, each the size of parking meter, or more fridge-sized cabinets on the ground next to the pole (including backup diesel generators).</p><p>Even now, it is not clear if the bill would allow a carrier to replace a 25-foot tall steel street light pole with a 120-foot tall pole (as one carrier has been proposing) on a downtown sidewalk or next to a home. In some rural residential areas adding antennas or pole extensions above utility poles, as low as 55 feet may require blinking aircraft warning lights. Plus, with SB 649, instead of allowing cities to encourage competition by balancing how our streets are used by different types of utilities, the bill would allow a single wireless carrier to grab all the City-owned (read: local taxpayer-owned) poles at a given intersection, with bargain lease rates of $100 a year. Many cities currently use the annual $1,500 to $4,000 they charge per pole to pay for things like free public Wi-Fi, upgrades to safer and brighter LED street lighting, or other public benefits. SB 649 would gut those sources.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1008/1*FFkYMgkRtsAP9bCHRCGhBA.png" /></figure><p>You wouldn’t walk down the street with a boombox duct taped to a StarTac flip phone and microwave dish, just to get great connectivity and your music together. Instead, folks in California, like at Apple, merged technology and design to unleash connectivity and functionality in an attractive package. SB 649, with language folks cannot even understand, would handcuff cities and counties from proposing even minimal design improvements using off-the-shelf tools. Or preferably, installing new street light poles with Small Cells completely hidden inside. SB 649 doesn’t belong in a State that should be on the leading edge of design and connectivity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/472/1*xSJ_3Cg_8N1Dm0692oVchA.png" /><figcaption>What the wireless industry considers a Small Cell, in Oakland, California. Which would you rather have on your block? This design, or the one below, representing the importance of common sense design and noise review at the local level?</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*cbT8Bobm_NxIRYG33A5WGg.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Omar Masry, AICP, is a City Planner who lives in Oakland, and recently testified on behalf of the American Planning Association before the State Senate in opposition to SB 649.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Irena Stevens, MS, is PhD Candidate in a telecommunications program who writes about wireless engineering, economics, business strategy, and policy.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>These comments do not represent official positions of the organizations with which we are affiliated.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ng0MiZK-rtsmiMkWWIjBaA.png" /><figcaption>An actual well-designed Small Cell in San Francisco. The cabinets do not generate any noise and are partially hidden by the road signage. If SB 649 passes, carriers could put up designs much larger, uglier, and noisier with no limits on whether the cabinets would block the view from your bedroom window, or if sidewalk-mounted cabinets would be placed next to your driveway.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=973e562f1409" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SB 649 Challenges | Legislative Pitfalls]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/sb-649-challenges-legislative-pitfalls-a61a4427651a?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a61a4427651a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zoning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Apr 2017 17:22:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-20T19:16:46.580Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180SB649">Senate Bill 649</a> is a proposed law (<em>mostly written by AT&amp;T, Verizon and the lobbying group, CTIA</em>), to allow bulky and large cell sites nearly anywhere (<em>including with refrigerator-sized cabinets on streets and sidewalks in front of homes</em>), with no local common sense discretion on location (next to bedroom windows or on/near historic buildings), noise, lighting, design, or fiscal impacts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*esw6W7uF19defOfzmH4W8g.png" /><figcaption><em>The antennas on the actual pole are easy to miss, if you have these large AT&amp;T cabinets (computers, lead-acid batteries, meters) with noisy cooling fans, on the sidewalk directly in front of your home. State Senate Bill 649 (when paired with size change exceptions by a separate Federal rule know as “6409”) will allow this on any street or sidewalk in California. The graffiti rarely gets removed, and the carrier typically refuses to allow murals or artworks, claiming the cabinet will overheat (retired engineers for same carrier will tell you the opposite).</em></figcaption></figure><p>Please note that it IS possible to build robust and competitive broadband wireless that is respectful of communities. I know this because, in a<em> </em><strong><em>prior role</em></strong> I worked for multiple cities, with carriers, on hundreds of well designed wireless sites in multiple cities. It is not easy though. Getting to that point only happens when cities/counties aren’t hamstrung by State/Federal laws, and is able to work with carriers on behalf of residents and Main Streets, to push for better design and siting. SB 649 guts that ability, and is taxpayer giveaway to telcos.</p><h3><strong>Equipment Noise</strong></h3><p>Many, but not all, Small Cells feature large cabinets and noisy cooling fans to cool equipment (computers or lead-acid battery packs).</p><p>While many cities have cajoled wireless carriers to use more efficient systems that are much quieter (or turn off at night in quiet coastal residential neighborhoods). SB 649 would gut that ability.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/281/1*lrZXZCqEa8x973St9Vj9qw.png" /><figcaption>65 decibels of fan noise by your bedroom window?</figcaption></figure><p>SB 649 would appear to preclude sensible noise limits (or relocation to a pole across the street) for Small Cells, even if on an existing utility pole that may only be 5 feet from a bedroom window. <br> <br> Cities have seen many frustrating examples of carriers failing to resolve this issue.</p><p>In some neighborhoods, the utility poles run directly through adjoining backyards. So, imagine a contractor demanding a right to enter and put up cabinets with noisy cooling fans on the pole.</p><h3><strong>Size Limits in the bill are deceptive</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/589/1*yqx72o_twpPCSitLQNO2yw.png" /><figcaption><em>A Small Cell without screening or common sense design standards. <br> <br> Imagine one of these for each carrier in front of your home.</em></figcaption></figure><p>SB 649 does not take into consideration the large nature of changes allowed under a separate <strong>Federal</strong> rule known as 6409<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> that allows for major changes to cell sites as soon as they are built; especially for the type of sites that would be allowed with SB 649. This essentially makes the size limits in the bill meaningless.</p><p><strong>For Streets &amp; Sidewalks (the <em>Public Right-of-Way</em>): </strong>When a carrier utilizes (Federal) 6409 rules to modify an existing “unscreened” site (built per SB 649) on a light/utility pole (+ equipment on the ground), a carrier can immediately convert a site (<em>and, yes we have seen substantial size increases in California</em>) into a quasi-monopole (tall tower, with exposed antennas and large cabinets on the sidewalk), next to a house) without any local discretion.</p><p>You could end up with equipment blocking handicapped access on sidewalks (bill language is silent on these issues).</p><p>If your neighborhood has wooden poles running directly through your <strong>backyard</strong>, imagine if SB 649 is approved and a wireless contractor shows up to demand the right to enter your backyard and put up bulky &amp; noisy cabinets and antennas on the poles.</p><p><strong>For Private Property: </strong>Because the bill fails to mandate any reasonable attempts at stealthing (<em>e.g. hiding equipment behind fiberglass elements such as vent pipes, fake rooftop elevator penthouses</em>), as soon as a Small Cell is built under this law, the carrier can make substantial changes in height, bulk, and size of both equipment on the roof of a building. They could also replace noiseless equipment with noisy cooling fans.</p><p>There is no limit on the number of Small Cells allowed per property, so if each carrier puts up Small Cells, then uses 6409 (to add more antennas, generators, cabinets), you could end up with dozens of antennas on the sides of a building (or hanging in front of windows).</p><p>For example, three cabinets the size of small briefcases can be replaced with large cabinets the size of refrigerators. Or, add 10 feet in height to the pole. <br> <br> One antenna, the size of a wastebasket, could be replaced with multiple panel antennas (each the size of a parking meter) and unsightly tangles of wires and brackets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1016/1*rxNf_7vbp0OXC4gbZVoyoQ.png" /></figure><p>If the original design allowed an electrical meter box on the ground, then the carrier can come back (using Federal 6409) and add battery cabinets (the size of a fridge) or diesel generator<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> without regard for whether the location would be a danger to pedestrians or drivers backing out of driveways.</p><h3><strong>No State guidance for future road widening or removing wooden poles (“undergrounding”) that may be effectively blocked by recently installed Small Cells on wooden utility poles.</strong></h3><p><em>If a standard wooden light pole features overhead electrical wires and a Small Cell, would it block investments in placing electrical wires underground and new poles such as these?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/629/1*kcuisNlcoNC2EfLpRJ2VwQ.png" /><figcaption><em>If a standard wooden light pole features overhead electrical wires and a Small Cell, would it block investments in placing electrical wires underground and new poles such as these?</em></figcaption></figure><p>The bill is silent as to what happens if a Small Cell is located on wooden utility poles in the public right-of-way (along streets/sidewalks) and the City plans to widen the road, add/widen sidewalks or bicycle lanes, or remove wooden utility poles, then replace them with better designed decorative poles and and place overhead wires underground.</p><p>Would the bill require Cities to leave that infrastructure in place, blocking investments, or would the City have to subsidize the substantial costs of relocation? <br> <br> Would each relocation now require State involvement, if a single Small Cell is no longer considered a “municipal affair.”<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a></p><p>Would the City be prohibited from replacing standard light poles with decorative fixtures in a main street setting, if some of the standard light poles have wireless attachments?</p><p>Lastly, can a carrier place a ground-mounted cabinet in a location that would impair access for the disabled (as some carriers often propose in initial plan submittals) persons in wheelchairs?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FAN7vf1xgWR_YaPOnvJUVA.png" /><figcaption>It appears Mobilitie (building a network for Sprint), put up a tall microwave backhaul pole without any building permits from the local jurisdiction. Not only is this a highly intrusive model (imagine this in front of your home), but it’s placement in the (rent-free) public right of way (still in private land) so close to a roadway raises concerns. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQjl9tREUTE">Video link</a></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Bill fails to provide guidance for locations in or near historic districts and historic buildings, and may violate CEQA</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/601/1*xBhg0X5Qjw_WOU76rdHG4Q.png" /><figcaption><em>Would cities have to allow more antenna mounts like this on a historic building, instead of up on the roof hidden in a fake vent pipe?</em></figcaption></figure><p>By removing any screening requirements and failing to account for the somewhat large changes allowed by a Federal rule known as “6409” the bill does not address concerns over facilities that could impair a historic district or historic building, which may conflict with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). <br> This could include attaching antennas (<em>as some carriers have done</em>) to the decorative masonry of a historic building, or cable trays running down the primary face (façade) of a historic building in a manner that would impair the building.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/593/1*9PPybW6GHSox6zmMqY5YWw.png" /><figcaption><em>A true (well-designed) Small Cell design like this in a historic area is only possible because of realistic discretion by a community over its poles.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ng0MiZK-rtsmiMkWWIjBaA.png" /><figcaption><em>A true (well-designed) Small Cell design like this in a residential area is only possible because of realistic discretion by a community over its poles. In this case the City had the carrier come up with brackets to use existing signs on the pole to hide the two (2) equipment cabinets (Ericsson mRRUs) and specifically designed a slim antenna shroud. SB 649 would let carriers do whatever they want, which would generally be noisier, bulkier, and uglier.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/404/1*ikqQpFNZz8f4lusYZ-Oe3g.png" /><figcaption><em>Would the law preclude City/County from requiring better designs &amp; cable management (which is possible, if a community requires it)? For instance, in many cities, the cabling and arms have to be shrouded and painted to match the pole.</em></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Quality of Life Challenges in Mixed-Use Residential Buildings</strong></h3><p>Since many commercial zones (as referenced in the bill) contain residences (mixed-use), the bill appears silent with respect to what would seem like common sense areas city planners work to avoid. <br> <br> For instance, for rooftop mounted antennas, telling the carrier to move the 14-inch wide equipment cable tray or caged access ladders coming down the side of the building (connecting antennas to equipment rooms at ground level) so it is not running directly over the only apartment window of an elderly person (this has happened). <br> <br> Or, avoiding placement of antennas and equipment on a roof area where it would effectively remove a roof deck used by rent-controlled residents without other outdoor areas to enjoy.</p><p>Or, placing limits on equipment fan or backup generator (often tested once a week for 20 minutes) noise that may bother residents or an adjacent library or day care center.</p><p>Or, for building mounted antennas, requiring the carrier to place equipment and antennas in mostly hidden locations on the roof, instead of antennas mounted on the front of a building with bundles of wiring and exposed brackets.</p><p>Or, instances where the small business tenant on the ground floor is theatened with eviction if they do not give up part of their commercial space to make room for wireless equipment cabinets (sometimes the size of 2 office cubicles or a small shipping container). Yes, this has happened. City Planners would loose the opportunity to work with all parties to find better locations and avoid displacement.</p><p>Lastly, because the bill does not address “6409” (Federal rule on changes to expand existing sites) it would appear to allow a carrier to add a diesel generator without any discretion over placement next to, for example, a bedroom window on an adjacent building.</p><h3><strong>Kills Jobs &amp; Innovation</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/426/1*I6EzRypux8UYIa0RwNdCKQ.png" /><figcaption><em>An Ericsson integrated light pole with antennas &amp; equipment hidden inside. With SB 649, why would carriers invest in these slim and quiet pole systems when they can place bulky antennas and equipment on the sidewalk instead?</em></figcaption></figure><p>This bill would negate the investments made by many local and international manufacturers of integrated poles (with antennas and equipment tastefully hidden inside), since carriers would be able to put up large exposed equipment and antennas on any pole.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0YXOVSwM2tepZCi54MzAUw.png" /><figcaption><em>An inappropriately designed (Not so Small) Small Cell proposed on a nicely landscaped entry street in South Orange County (Lake Forest). <br> <br> Small Cells should not be so large that they seem like they are being placed nearly rent free in the public right-of-way, in order to avoid leasing space on a church, for example, to place a cell site (that can be hidden from view).</em></figcaption></figure><p><em>SB 649 would remove the ability to consider alternative designs (e.g. different locations, hiding equipment behind existing monument signage or landscaping, or underground watertight cabinets — yes, they do exist).</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jArMG0NaZCrFzHz9Xc1MiQ.png" /><figcaption>What was proposed by the carrier</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*svA7El8a5zCxrMPXo3Ngiw.png" /><figcaption>What was actually built. If you look closely you will see nylon straps holding the system together.</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Block/inhibit Smart City projects</strong></h3><p>This bill would appear to limit the ability of a City to use sensible pricing strategies to encourage multi-carrier systems (one pole and set of antennas carrying signals for multiple carriers) as is being fielded in New York City. <br> In many California downtowns, the limited number of poles may not be sufficient at a given intersection to meet the demands (and equipment bulk) of competing carriers, if one carrier demands multiple poles for use. <br> <br> This bill would appear to allow a single carrier to squat and hold multiple poles at an intersection (some carriers have actually tried this in some denser urban areas); thereby reducing competition.</p><p>The bill appears to offer no ability for a City to preclude/manage the use of a pole by a commercial carrier, in order to reserve space on the pole for City public Wi-Fi antennas or smart sensors (e.g. Internet of Things); such as sensors to help buses move through intersections faster.</p><p>By mandating revenues for City owned poles, this law may: <br> <br> a) inhibit more cities from acquiring light poles from the investor-owned utility (e.g. So Cal Edison), as Huntington Beach and Laguna Niguel have done. This has ultimately assisted with <em>well-designed </em>commercial broadband siting as well. <br> <br> b) result in a taxpayer subsidy to (well-financed) commercial wireless carriers because of the accelerated wear and tear on not only the pole, but also conduit and pull boxes (many get damaged during deployments by commercial carrier contractors) for power and fiber cables serving the poles. <br> <br> c) Deny funding for Smart City projects, such as those noted above, by limiting fair revenue models on behalf of taxpayers. Cities like New York and SF charge 3k to 4k per pole per year. Smaller cities charge about 1K-2k a year per pole. SB 649 would mandate rates of about $20 bucks a year, which won’t even cover the cost of increased wear and tear on City owned poles. In essence it is a massive subsidy by local taxpayers, and does not improve the type of broadband kids use to do their homework or adults use to apply for jobs online (in-building broadband).</p><p><a href="https://backchannel.com/handcuffing-cities-to-help-telecom-giants-7d13cbb600b7">Article Link: Handcuffing cities to help telecom giants</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5iQNZFH8Q8-dRq80MNCblQ.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Aircraft warning lights on poles in residential areas</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/1*Y6hDO1rsc5M4gpwzIVdCkQ.png" /><figcaption>Would a carrier be able to use SB 649 to replace a 30-foot tall standard light pole with a 120-foot pole? Would the pole also require blinking aircraft warning lights?</figcaption></figure><p>This law would appear to allow a carrier to propose replacing an existing 30-foot tall utility pole within one that is 120-foot tall.</p><p>Mobilitie (no relation to AT&amp;T Mobility) has frustrated many California Cities/Counties with “optional” 120 foot poles on sidewalks or road shoulders, sometimes next to homes or in downtowns. <br> <br> These 120 foot tall poles are being proposed in order to deviate (hence: “optional”) from normal broadband deployment for Small Cells that uses fiber backhaul [wires from the antennas on a pole running back to a data center], by instead using microwave dishes to piggyback signals from Small Cells on a shorter pole nearby, then up to the 120-foot tall pole “motherships,” and ultimately back to the data center.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/656/1*M2Qsc6gcMvjVyWZEEjEt0w.png" /><figcaption><em>Would a carrier be able to build 120-foot poles in front of your driveway by replacing a 30 foot standard light pole? Would this height and location require aircraft warning lights? A new entrant “Mobilitie” (no relation to AT&amp;T Mobility) has been proposing a very intrusive model of using these 120 foot tall “motherships” to connect far away data centers for a carrier (mostly Sprint) to small cells on shorter poles nearby. This is a far more intrusive model of “backhaul” than when other companies connect small cells on shorter light/utility poles back to data centers using fiber optic cables (fiber backhaul) with wires running from each small cell under City streets or along existing utility lines. Mobilitie has proposed dozens of these poles, in rent-free locations along City streets and sidewalks, including in residential areas throughout California. Imagine one of these placed without any notification in your front yard….</em></figcaption></figure><p>In many rural areas (especially near farms with periodic crop dusting), taller poles, as low as 60 feet may require blinking red aircraft warning. This could harm rural character where folks value the absence of such lighting.</p><p>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1UVtQZqpd8LLKAVVEqxr-g.png" /><figcaption>How Mobilitie’s CEO (the folks proposing 120 foot poles in front yards and on downtown sidewalks) apparently sees communities….</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Blinking Lights and Advertising Stickers</strong></h3><p>City staff must often remind carriers to cover flashing indicator lights that may only be a few feet from a bedroom window. <br> <br> This bill would appear to prohibit a City from adding conditions such as requiring decals and advertising logos to be removed, covering over unnecessary indicator lights, and painting equipment or cables to match the pole. <br> <br> Even with conditions, City Planners often see carriers fail to abide by such conditions and build anyways, then threaten litigation when cited.</p><h3><strong>Street Maintenance Challenges</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/656/1*u7kvO2fZLXLEtCsD-H94IQ.png" /><figcaption><em>It takes a lot of wires to go wireless. Including electric and fiber-optic cables. Would the bill force cities to accept interruption to City streets in such a manner? This has happened time and time again with wireless carriers in California, where streets and sidewalks are ripped up to run power or fiber cables to a nearby pole. Would SB 649 prohibit cities from stopping this sort of poor treatment of its streets and sidewalks?</em></figcaption></figure><p>It is not uncommon for a carrier to trench for fiber optic cable from a pole to a manhole in the middle of the street or a nearby sidewalk vault, and then replace decorative sidewalks or concrete with large and bumpy patches of asphalt (even when prior agreed upon conditions require like for like replacement). <br> <br> It is not clear if the bill would prohibit cities from requiring adequate restoration of the street or sidewalk. <br> <br> It is not clear if the bill would allow carriers to “top” trees which can destroy some species, in order to (haphazardly) make room for pole changes or new wires being run. This has been an issue in many cities with carriers being cited .</p><h3><strong>Pole Safety</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/667/1*6id882lb7UDK9C1gAuv_Rg.png" /></figure><p>The CPUC and investor owned utilities have expressed concerns with unsafe practices by wireless carriers. Large settlements were paid out after the 2007 Malibu fires which appear to have been caused by overloading poles with too much equipment. It is not uncommon to see wireless facilities that still violate basic safety standards (General Order 95 — CPUC). <br> <br> The CPUC has indicated a City/County with unique issues can have some limited review of pole safety. This bill would appear to preclude any such discussion, or even the ability to ask for the safety reports for a pole that may not be capable of handling the load (especially in high wind and/or unstable soil areas).</p><blockquote>How to find your State Assembly member or State Senator (and share your concerns): <a href="http://findyourrep.legislature.ca.gov/">http://findyourrep.legislature.ca.gov/</a></blockquote><h3><strong>The State can assist with broadband design by:</strong></h3><p>1. Tabling this legislation as the FCC undergoes its own rulemaking, and encouraging the use of either regional working groups, or re-review in one year.</p><p>This bill would essentially allow carriers to cancel leases for rooftop mounted antennas (such as hidden on the roof of a church), and put up new cell sites, that look like quasi-monopoles in front of homes, essentially rent-free.</p><p>This would represents a huge step backward in smarter wireless siting that uses a blended approach of rooftop sites (instead of the old ugly steel monopole towers we remember from the 90s) paired with Small Cells that are actually small and quiet to fill in gaps where needed.</p><p>2. Mandating that investor-owned utilities allow wireless smart metering. This would reduce the need to place a meter cabinet (with glass bubble) on narrow sidewalks and reduce challenges associated with design and Federal 6409 changes (see above).</p><p>3. Establishing a clearinghouse of best practices, model ordinances (e.g. those used in San Diego, Palos Verdes, or San Francisco for the public right-of-way), and leasing templates to assist smaller communities that may not have had contended with Small Cells, particularly in the public right-of-way. <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wireless">Examples of well-designed Small Cells</a>.</p><p>4.Encouraging State agencies and independent districts to more proactively work with neighboring cities and counties to host wireless infrastructure. Often, these locations are more appropriate siting areas. Though the level of engagement and receptivity by these State/independent agencies varies greatly.</p><p>After minute mark 18, a Vice Present at Verizon Wireless (speaking at a wireless industry conference) mocks residents for protesting cell sites. However, at one point he specifically mocks them for protesting sites not meeting a City’s aesthetic standards, even though he goes on to say the sites are completely shrouded. That statement was actually incorrect, since a number of the sites being protested at the time consisted of unscreened (i.e. NOT shrouded) antennas and large refrigerator-sized cabinets (with noisy cooling fans) on wooden utility poles located about 15 few feet from bedroom bay windows (for a photo, see images below)<br>Speech video:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FZ2CVy0unHvE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DZ2CVy0unHvE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FZ2CVy0unHvE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7911e5360472539f9c2c0ce773794382/href">https://medium.com/media/7911e5360472539f9c2c0ce773794382/href</a></iframe><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/804/1*jU8ML7Nn6szHymVRVs-yWQ.png" /><figcaption>A bulky and noisy (cooling fans) <em>Not so Small — </em>Small Cell (Crown Castle for Verizon Wireless) about 15 feet from a home</figcaption></figure><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Section 6409 of the Middle Class Tax Relief and Job Creation Act, as further clarified in a 2014 FCC Rule.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> More likely as AT&amp;T seeks to abandon copper telephone lines (a failed attempt by the legislature in 2016) in Northern California, and replace much of the system with <em>wireless local loop </em>(antenna on home talking to a tower nearby to substitute for landlines), which may necessitate backup diesel generators in case of power outages.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> The reference to “municipal affair” is inherently incorrect as it was originally meant to refer to how a City/County conducts its business, such as payroll or programming of events at the local park.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a61a4427651a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 4 | Design Tips for Small Cells Based on Pole or Location Type (draft)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-4-design-tips-for-small-cells-based-on-pole-or-location-type-draft-5f8814f8be6d?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5f8814f8be6d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Sep 2016 04:45:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-28T04:35:18.750Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>&gt;&gt; Link Back to Main Article: <a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/10-key-issues-for-california-cities-counties-on-the-challenges-of-small-cells-not-so-small-c9e966f257a#.r9c78zdm7">10 Key Issues for California Cities &amp; Counties on the Challenges of Small Cells &amp; “Not So Small Cells”</a></p><h3>DESIGN TIPS BY NEIGHBORHOOD TYPE</h3><p>Think in terms of three types of tests:</p><p>a) Is this a neighborhood where the wooden utility poles have already been undergrounded (electric/TV/phone wires placed under street)? If yes, then you have more control over your public right-of-way (<em>e.g. issues of design, equipment noise, large equipment boxes on the ground, avoiding installation of new wood poles in lieu of integrated steel designs)</em>.</p><p>b) If your City/County also happens to own the steel/concrete light poles, then that’s even better.</p><p>c) On the other hand, for areas with existing wooden utility poles, you face more of a challenge (unless your City also owns the wooden poles). While you can generally say no to brand new wood poles just for cell antennas, in more rural/exurban areas you may have to allow some new steel poles, for cell antennas, in more rural contexts. Also, given the challenges of “6409” (rules on changes to sites after they are built), you may want to really focus on avoiding having any unscreened equipment added on the ground/sidewalk; and try to keep the equipment either wholly on the pole (or spread out on a secondary pole), or undergrounded, or screened (hidden) if on the ground.</p><p>If you do allow equipment on the ground next to a pole that is not owned by the City/County, then make sure the plans clearly show the dimensions and location/footprint of the equipment area. This is important with respect to “6409” and future changes. Carriers sometimes fail to abide by the placement locations shown on plans.</p><h3>TIPS FOR CITIES THAT OWN SOME EXISTING POLES OR WILL HAVE THE NEW/EXISTING POLE TRANSFERRED TO CITY OWNERSHIP</h3><ol><li><strong>Disconnect Switch Boxes &amp; Pole Ownership</strong> If the light poles are owned by the local investor-owned (electric utility) consider having the carrier by the pole from them to transfer it to the City/County (<em>which reduces potential 6409 challenges since those rules would not apply</em>).<br>If that is not feasible, the utility may require a disconnect switch box on the pole or ground. Sometimes the power level (“effective radiated power”) from the antenna(s) is so low that the disconnect may not actually be needed. This may allow for a better design (and one less equipment box lower on the pole where it is susceptible to graffiti).</li><li>There’s a difference between a franchise and a master license agreement. Consider an MLA for sites on existing City owned poles (Example: <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wireless">Link on Page 5 of this document</a>).</li><li>In California you can’t charge for access to the right-of-way, so avoid referring to agreements as “franchises.” You can charge for attachments (antennas/equipment) to City-owned assets (poles, bus shelters, and conduit for fiber if you have it). Call it a master license agreement instead.</li><li>If attaching antennas to City owned poles or the carrier will provide the City with a pole, make sure to bring your Administrative/Risk Management group in to the conversation early. Iron out issues regarding insurance, bonding, and indemnification early on. Check examples from SFPUC/SFMTA , Laguna Niguel (OC), or NYC (DoITT).</li><li>Work with your field staff to articulate a policy on when a pole needs to be replaced. Also, some of the underground conduit (<em>where electric and fiber wires run from the backhaul route then into the sidewalk pull box and into the pole</em>), may be crushed. Consider spot checking sites with the carrier. Some bases may not have room to allow more fiber/power cables and may need to be replaced as well.</li><li>If you own the poles, make sure the antennas/equipment won’t physically conflict with other City installations like future Wi-Fi access points or OptiCom and other similar sensors to allow buses or ambulances to trigger traffic lights. Send a copy of the plans to various peer City agencies and ask specifically ask them to notify you if they have equipment on poles that may cause conflicts.</li><li>If you decide to request the carrier to provide strands of fiber for City use (e.g. City Wi-Fi); which wouldn’t apply for carriers like Mobilitie, using microwave backhaul (no fiber-optic cables running back to data center); make sure it actually goes somewhere. A carrier for example, agreed to provide fiber, but it turned out they weren’t going to run fiber along PG&amp;E owned conduit to somewhere that mattered (like a splice point down the street). They were just going to provide fiber from the pole to the pull box a few feet away. This isn’t of much use.</li><li>If the City owns the light poles, try to get the carrier’s electric power circuit tied into the same fuse serving the existing streetlight. That way, your maintenance crews can easily turn off power to the cell antennas (<em>read: no doubt of potential radio-frequency emissions exposure by your hard-working staff since they can control the circuit</em>) when they need to change the light bulb, and you can avoid the need for a disconnect switch box (used to shut down the power to the antennas) that just adds more clutter near the bottom of the pole.</li><li><strong>Traffic Signals.</strong> The folks who operate traffic signals may be very wary of placing antennas, cabling and equipment on traffic signals. While many of these concerns are warranted; often these poles are far better locations (e.g. wider separation between poles and residential windows). Consider whether replacement poles within separate conduit channels for traffic signals and Small Cells (i.e. avoiding crossed wires) may be viable.</li><li><strong>Electricity to Small Cells on City-owned Poles. </strong>Talk to your maintenance workers about potential antennas on City-owned light poles. I recommend setting up the wireless system so that it is on the same fuse as the streetlight. That way there is no uncontrolled radio-frequency (e.g. “radiation”) exposure for workers, since they can just turn off the cell antenna automatically when they need to turn off the streetlight, in order to swap light bulbs (for example).</li><li><strong>Varied Pole Ownership and Jurisdiction Issues. </strong>If needed, add maps to your website, noting areas that may require further review (<em>State or other agency jurisdiction, habitat/wetland clearance by State/Federal agencies, aircraft zones where potentially required aircraft lighting may be an issue, pending utility undergrounding district project areas, decorative lighting upgrade plan areas, and privately-owned streets).</em></li><li><strong>Ask for a mockup</strong>. Check on issues like antenna and equipment mounting brackets, cabling, decals, grounding rods, illumination, logos, stickers.</li><li>Mandate that the <strong>RF warning sticker</strong> only be placed up higher on the pole near the antenna and uses a sticker background color that is the same color as the pole. The sticker should also face out toward the street (not toward the residential window behind the pole).</li><li><strong>Shot Clocks do not apply to City owned properties or poles.</strong></li><li><strong>Steel/Concrete Poles and Grounding. </strong>Make sure grounding rods don’t break through the foundation of the pole. Carriers usually want their own grounding rod (especially Verizon Wireless, due to lower Ohm tolerances) instead of tying into the ground rod used for the existing pole.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eAbWvNRP2hohn-QZhuFukQ.png" /><figcaption>If the facility is proposed on an existing pole try to have the equipment (computers) placed behind existing guide/information signs already on the pole. In this example, one of the two computers (radio relay units) is behind the informational guide sign.</figcaption></figure><h3>TIPS FOR SMALL CELLS ON EXISTING STEEL OR CONCRETE POLES (WHETHER OWNED BY THE CITY OR UTILITY)</h3><p>If your City does NOT own the pole, try to hide/underground/abandon the disconnect switch box . If the antennas have a very low effective radiated power limit (e.g. under 150 watts), you may be able to work with the pole owner and/or electric utility to avoid the need for a disconnect switch at all.</p><p>For attachments of equipment to existing steel or concrete light poles, consider requiring the carrier to add a bracket to place any road signs on the pole (if present) in front of the equipment cabinets. See <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wireless">www.sf-planning.org/wireless</a> for an example.</p><p>For attachments to existing Davit poles (pole with a rounded arm — see image below) consider requiring that the pole be replaced IF an antenna is proposed above the pole (not needed if only mRRUs are being used with an internal antenna). Otherwise you will end up with something ugly like this (Mobilitie, for Sprint, in Los Angeles, courtesy J. Kramer):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*_kngZedJpk5Duxjm_kU2jw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mobilitie (likely for Sprint) installation on an Los Angeles DWP “Davit” (rounded arm) style light pole. This is a very poorly designed facility. given the exposed brackets/cabling and varying types of equipment (some of which should be under the sidewalk instead). The entire pole should have been replaced with a standard tapered light pole and the antenna radome mounted to top of the main vertical pole element.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cVCy54BFjeWNyVbdWhRYfw.png" /><figcaption>Breakdown (J. Kramer) of a Mobilitie installation on an LA DWP standard tapered (not a Davit) concrete light pole. This is a very poorly designed facility. given the exposed brackets/cabling and varying types of equipment (some of which should be under the sidewalk instead).</figcaption></figure><p>Avoid cabling running up the outside of the pole.</p><p>Many concrete poles lack space inside the pole for the power and fiber cables. In San Francisco, Verizon proposed replacing the concrete pole with one made by the same manufacturer the City uses. The key differences would be a slightly wider pole and the entry holes (for cables from the two computer boxes) would be alternated depending on which “side” of the pole features existing road signs. This allows, the road signs to be placed in front of one, or both road signs, if present.</p><h3>TIPS PRIMARILY FOCUSED ON ATTACHMENTS OF ANTENNAS &amp; EQUIPMENT ON/NEXT TO WOODEN UTILITY POLES</h3><p>In urban and suburban areas you can likely easily say no to brand new wooden poles for Small Cells. However, in rural areas, you may have to allow some new poles. That being said, you can still require steel poles, integrated designs, and push for appropriate heights and placement locations (e.g. away from significant vistas noted in your General Plan).</p><p><a href="http://208.121.200.84/ftp/files/currentplanning/wireless/wireless_Design_Preferences_for_Wireless_Facilities_August2015.pdf">Design brochure (I put together in a previous role), on design preferences for attachments (antennas/equipment) to existing wooden utility poles. The brochure assumes no equipment boxes are also on the sidewalk/ground.</a></p><p><strong>Antenna placement on Wooden Poles: </strong>Antennas are typically added to wood poles as either a pole-top (antenna on top of the pole) or a side-arm mount midway up the pole in the communications zone or “comm zone”. The communications zone is the area midway up the pole where you typically see wires used for telephone, cable TV, and fiber-optic.</p><p>Equipment supporting the antennas, such as the computers (rru’s), battery back up (optional), electric meters, and a disconnect switch can either be placed on the same pole, a nearby pole, on the ground, or underground.</p><p>If a pole top antenna mount is proposed in a scenic, residential, or historic area consider requiring the entire pole to be replaced. The reason why is because the wooden extension arm holding up the antenna (“bayonet”), a few feet above the pole, can’t be made the same size and color as the pole below, so it catches your attention. As does the silver mounting brackets, above and below the bayonet that cannot be painted.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/166/1*c3wEUnRzbc2gtXDyN2zqqA.png" /><figcaption>Do not accept an electric meter cabinet twice as wide as the pole. It’s uglier and more prone to graffiti. The computers are the two mRRU boxes above. They are as wide as the pole and have no ugly decals/fins (preferred). Other than the wide electric meter, the facility is fairly less-intrusive given the absence of noisy cooling fans, the use of equipment cabinets (computers) about the same width of the pole, and an antenna with skirt that appears fairly streamlined and hides the mounting bracket below the antenna. Photo Simulation by AdvanceSim for Extenet Systems.</figcaption></figure><p>If you can’t get wireless metering and a meter is proposed, try to get it on the pole. In addition, say no to meter cabinets twice the size of the pole. Carriers will repeatedly tell you they can’t use a slimmer cabinet. That is absolutely false. There is at least one model that PG&amp;E and SCE will allow.</p><p>A replacement pole can taper toward the antenna for a cleaner design. Neutral host carriers will protest that the City/County is only requiring this because of pole safety concerns that are preempted by the CPUC. Ignore it. Funny thing is at the appeal hearing (when a resident raises pole safety concerns) the same carrier will often brag they are improving safety by replacing the pole……</p><p><strong>Height. </strong>Say no to Small Cells that are too tall. Cite general plan designated significant vistas, if applicable. Consider a 45-foot height limit in single-family residential areas, and a 60-foot height limit in all others. Be aware though, that if you don’t own the pole the carrier can build the site while complying with the height limit and then likely use “6409” (there are some exceptions) to exceed the local height limit by another 10 feet (specific to public right-of-way sites). Some communities try to say the antenna can’t rise above the pole. While in rare instances the carrier can use a shorter pole with an antenna on top; this rule may result in carriers placing antennas on side-arm extensions midway up the pole; where it could impair view from bedroom windows, if homes are close to the street.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qPogD4ZxrOJOGQlJFB3SHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Avoid the use of side-arm mounts with an angled support beam and unscreened cables and combiners (small boxes on side-arm). See shrouded arm examples below. The conduit running up the side of the pole is flush to the pole (preferred) but is not painted to match the pole (disfavored).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/323/1*NalFn8zyXg3fEyrUCGyQGw.png" /><figcaption>On wooden utility poles antennas are either mounted on top of the pole (prior image); or a side-arm extension midway up the pole (in the communications zone or “comm zone” where telephone/cable/fiber cables are attached). The design in this image is far less intrusive than other installations with hanging panel antennas (and associated visible brackets and cables). The flanged nature of the arm hides smaller equipment boxes and provides a more seameless design. Credit: Advance Sim for Extenet Systems</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tkKzfBwj1YrBbwxNrDa9Gg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Noise. </strong>Come up with noise standards, especially as they relate to sensitive receptors (residences, child care, retirement homes). Indicate this in your ordinance. For instance, indicate facilities may generate no more than 45 decibels within three feet of any residential dwelling or City park boundary, and no more than 55 decibels within ten feet of any other. Crown Castle tends to use cabinets with loud cooling fans to house Commscope ION units. It tends to be a partially shrouded box (ION) in a larger box, that is boxier than needed. If the facility does not generate noise,then ask the carrier to note that on the cover sheet of the plans (for the benefit of neighbors).</p><p><strong>Historic Preservation.</strong> Make sure you check if sites are next to known or potential historic resources. The key metrics shouldn’t be that it is in a historic district or next to a historic building, but whether the facility would detract from primary facades (typically main faces of the building along major streets).</p><p><strong>Pending Neighborhood Undergrounding. </strong>Say no to new aerial wires if you have a pending undergrounding district. Add this as a condition of approval.</p><p><strong>Handicapped accessibility.</strong> Ensure a level four (4) wide path of travel (taking into account computers/meters attached to the pole near ground level) is always clearly shown on the plans when poles or equipment are added on narrow sidewalks.</p><p><strong>Tacky Stickers.</strong> For some reason, Small Cell carrier sub-contractors have this really bad habit of adding a bunch of extra unnecessary and tacky stickers on sites. They will add multiple RF warning stickers on the electric meter at the bottom of the pole even though it doesn’t generate any significant RF emissions. Then residents will call you because they saw all those stickers and assume it must have really high RF output because it has not just one, but three separate stickers (not true).</p><p>Tell the carrier to place the sticker up near the actual antennas. Insist on this repeatedly and have it added with clear and large notes on the plans and reflected on photo simulations. You do NOT need those RF warning stickers everywhere at the bottom of the pole. If you own the pole and it is a low power system (typically under 200 watts of effective radiated power) insist on having the background color of the sticker match the pole and be no larger than 4 inches by 6 inches. Also, for all poles, require the sticker to face out directly toward the street, instead of right at the 3rd floor window, on the other side of the pole a few feet away (if applicable).</p><p>Remind carriers they do not need to add a bunch of bright and large carrier identification stickers on the pole. If they want a separate “node” identification sticker they should place it on the underside of the meter or equipment cabinet (radio head computers). For ground-mounted equipment, require (and condition) that street address labels should face away from street (unless facing a residential window/door) and consist of white reflective letters, instead of black labels with yellow lettering, for example.<em>Simply put, if carriers want to be treated as “infrastructure” they need to get rid of the advertising, logos and decals</em>.</p><p><strong>No logos</strong> or brand names on pole, equipment, or lids for sidewalk vaults. No illumination. Make these conditions of approval and notes on the cover sheet and elevation sheet. Ericsson equipment has an indented impression logo. Have it filled in (or a blank sticker placed on top and then painted).<em>Ericsson, if you are reading this, please get rid of the logo or move it to the underside.</em></p><p><strong>Battery Cabinets.</strong> These are optional, though the carrier could make a sincere argument for them in more rural contexts where there are not as many existing large tower or rooftop (macro) nearby (with larger on-site battery systems and sometimes generators). These outdoor batteries tend to fail faster due to outdoor temperature fluctuations (when placed on poles). In dense urban areas try to push back, unless the batteries are undergrounded (see Oldcastle photo).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k3vMkUyxpzIxv7g-Z-Rh3A.png" /><figcaption>The (optional) battery backup cabinet and electric meter (left side of photo) are on a separate pole across the street from the DAS “XL” node (with antenna). <a href="http://www.tsipower.com/">TSi Power </a>makes a battery cabinet that is longer, but slimmer (about as wide as the pole — which is preferred) and less likely to impair views as compared to bulkier (about 3 times as wide a the pole) Alpha brand cabinets typically used by carriers. The antenna and cabinet on the pole in the rear are too bulky and is missing the promised cable cover below the antenna.</figcaption></figure><p>The (optional) battery backup cabinet and electric meter are on a separate pole across the street from the DAS “XL” node (with antenna). <a href="http://www.tsipower.com/">TSi Power </a>makes a battery cabinet that is longer, but slimmer (about as wide as the pole) and less likely to impair views as compared to bulkier (about 3 times as wide a the pole) Alpha cabinets typically used.</p><p>The (optional) battery backup cabinet and electric meter are on a separate pole across the street from the DAS “XL” node (with antenna). <a href="http://www.tsipower.com/">TSi Power </a>makes a battery cabinet that is longer, but slimmer (about as wide as the pole) and less likely to impair views as compared to bulkier (about 3 times as wide a the pole) Alpha cabinets typically used.</p><p>In other areas, consider requiring the use of a TSI Power (or equivalent) battery cabinet instead of a Alpha cabinet. Reason why? Because the TSI cabinet is narrower; about as wide as the pole and less likely to impair views. Have the carrier place the battery cabinet on a nearby pole (along with the electric meter if you can’t get wireless metering); though preferably on a pole not next to a bedroom window and already next to a mature tree.</p><p>There are some miniature fuel cells (for backup power) coming out, but they are bulky and may not be appropriate for pole-mounts on narrower residential streets.</p><p>Generators (preferably natural gas or fuel cell) at larger macro (e.g. rooftop) sites seem a better way to achieve resiliency. Check to see if your zoning code unduly restricts them; assuming the location is appropriate (<em>e.g. avoiding instances where the carrier submits an over the counter building permit to place a diesel generator next to the air conditioning intake for a health clinic, a few feet away on the next building</em>).</p><p><strong>GPS Antennas</strong>. Ask carriers to use radome transmit antennas that have the GPS antenna built-in to them. They are made by numerous manufacturers, including Alpha and Commscope. Sometimes carriers promise the GPS antenna will be on top of the antenna (separate design) and flush to the antenna but then the contractor needlessly places it on a stick rising a foot above the pole. Make them correct it.</p><p><strong>Pole Replacements.</strong> If your City/County has a municipal electric provider you may want to see consider working with them to replace the wood pole with a integrated steel version that still holds up electric wires. Thus far it does not appear PG&amp;E, SCE, SDG&amp;E are willing to allow such replacements.</p><p>Push to hide the<strong> GPS antenna</strong>. Many “transmit” antenna makers offer primary transmit antennas with the GPS built into the cap of the “transmit” antenna. If the carrier pushes back (they often do), call the antenna maker noted on the plans and ask. Carrier will yell that cities/counties can’t dictate the technology. Push back. Not all sites need a GPS antenna anyways.</p><p>Determine <strong>archeological</strong> areas of concern. For instance, are new soil disturbances of less than 10 feet exempt from further review. Note this on the application form and CEQA determination.</p><p>For attachment of equipment to existing/replacement wooden utility poles, require no more than a four (4) inch offset between the pole and the equipment and require conduit/cabling to be flush to the pole. Avoid wide gaps that make the site uglier than functionally needed. If the carrier claims that a wide gap is needed due to the location of existing climbing pegs (for example) and the rotation of equipment; then have them replace the entire pole so everything can be better aligned with a flush conduit design.</p><p>Also, if the equipment cabinets are not mounted directly onto the wood pole, make sure the mounting channel is not wider than the pole.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*Oa9K5m8BE44TD-GhPBppWA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Example Foxtrot: Poorly designed facility in Oregon/Washington. In California the cabling running up the side of the pole (between the computers and the antenna) does NOT need to be offset from the pole. Keep an eye out for this on Extenet Systems and Crown Castle submittals (I’m not sure who built this out-of-state node). The antenna size at the top is appropriate. The equipment seems “ok” in terms of cubic size but more cluttered than needed (should be about as wide as the pole). The paint looks good on all elements. Notice the lack of an electric meter bubble (good).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0WAEgCYoGaTpjqOO6E5C3A.jpeg" /><figcaption>More akin to a Monopole than a Small Cell. 1) A single radome antenna centered at the top of the pol should be used instead of multiple panel antennas on a stand-off arm; 2) the equipment cabinets midway up the pole are too bulky and project too far off the pole; 3) the equipment cabinets should be no further than 4 inches away from the wood pole); 4; the RF warning sticker and Crown Castle stickers should be on the underside of cabinets, with the RF sticker only near the antenna up higher on the pole; 5) It appears excess power/fiber cables were left in place</figcaption></figure><h3>Reviewing Applications</h3><ol><li>If the design is problematic and carrier reps with government relations titles don’t seem to get it; ask them to bring the engineers with them to the meetings.<br>Be prepared for the government/external relations (“EA”) person trying to go over your head to the City Managers office when they do not like the answer. Funny thing is the EA person often fails to provide the full story (or contextually accurate story) to the City Manager; and it becomes a lot of wasted chatter, all to end up at the same place a few weeks later.</li><li>Try to get in the habit of taking some notes on key points during meetings. Yes it’s annoying to type during a meeting, but it is a constant frustration to work with carrier reps, and then six months later have all new carrier reps come discuss the very same project, in order to cover the very same issues, since their was no handoff between the two groups when the name brand carrier got rid of the first consultant. This happens constantly.</li></ol><h3>Technical Terms:</h3><p>· <strong>DAS</strong> — Distributed Antenna Systems, also known as “oDAS” with the “o” standing for outdoors. I refer to small systems that are context appropriate as “oDAS R” and larger, typically non-appropriate systems as “oDAS XL”</p><p>· <strong>Disconnect Switch</strong>. A box akin to a circuit breaker to turn off power to the system. If the wireless facility can run off the same circuit as the street light, you may be able to avoid the need for this box (preferred). If the disconnect is needed consider: a) placing it in a watertight enclosure under the sidewalk</p><p><strong>GPS Antenna</strong>. An antenna (the size of a grapefruit) used for precise timing of cell sites. Not needed for all Small Cells, but check to see if proposed. Some companies like Commscope or Alpha Wireless make main transmit antennas with a built-in GPS antenna (better design).</p><p>· <strong>Radio Relay Unit (RRU) or Radio Relay Head (RRH). </strong>These are the computers that take fiber optic cables (or signal from the microwave backhaul unit) and send power and signal over coaxial cables to the transmitting antenna. Your cell phone talks to the transmit antenna. The signal goes into the radio head unit then goes back to the carrier’s data center a few miles away by either fiber-optic (glass cables that carry data much faster than copper) cables (underground or strung up on wood poles) or via microwave. The data center may either be the telephone company switch building in town, or a larger rooftop or tower site for the same carrier nearby. Also referred to as an mRRU by Ericsson (equipment maker).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5f8814f8be6d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[APart 2 | Example photos of the good, the bad and the downright ugly]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-2-example-photos-of-the-good-the-bad-and-the-downright-ugly-ea483f83fe7?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ea483f83fe7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cellular]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[5g-wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zoning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Sep 2016 23:08:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-27T05:51:18.841Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>&gt;&gt; Link Back to Main Article: <a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/10-key-issues-for-california-cities-counties-on-the-challenges-of-small-cells-not-so-small-c9e966f257a#.r9c78zdm7">10 Key Issues for California Cities &amp; Counties on the Challenges of Small Cells &amp; “Not So Small Cells”</a></p><p>This section shows a variety of Small Cells. There are 5 main categories of deployment:</p><ol><li>Attached to existing <strong>wooden</strong> light or utility poles (<a href="http://208.121.200.84/ftp/files/currentplanning/wireless/wireless_Design_Preferences_for_Wireless_Facilities_August2015.pdf">link to sample design preferences guide</a>).</li><li>Attached to existing steel/concrete poles and replacements of concrete poles.</li><li>Integrated poles with antennas and equipment mostly hidden inside the pole.</li><li>Attachments of antennas to a pole and some or all of the equipment on the ground or underground.</li><li>Attachments to, or inside of, bus shelters, kiosks, and billboards or underground (experimental).</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-H3zjtCcMc0RSO8OmzqIrw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Example Alpha: A poorly designed Sprint site, by Mobilitie (<em>also using business names such as Interstate Transport and Broadband, NC Relay Technology and Networking, and The ______STATE NAME HERE____Utility Pole Authority</em>) on an existing steel light pole in the City of Los Angeles. Though, to be fair it does not feature the large and noisy cabinets often seen with some Crown Castle deployments (for example) for other carriers. The RF warning sticker is too large and bright and should be placed closer to the UE relay unit and facing away from homes toward the street. The exposed cabling is unacceptable. The main transmit antenna at the very top of the pole should be shrouded, along with the stick holding it up, so it is a more graceful addition to the pole. The UE relay unit (round object near banner) should have the side fins shrouded (so it won’t overheat), and the AC distribution panel should be placed under the sidewalk in a vault (square box). Credit: celltowersites.com</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/643/1*akUpl-iudvrx1L49aiWXnA.png" /><figcaption>Examples of large and ugly “oDAS XL” nodes. The one on the left is by Crown Castle for Verizon Wireless. It may not even comply with State safety rules (GO 95); based on discussions with PG&amp;E. The hanging panel antennas should be replaced with a radome antenna (see examples further below). The photo on the right shows a poorly designed Charles cabinet that should not be placed on poles in nice areas or areas that aren’t nice. It features batteries and computers. The batteries should be moved to a separate pole in a slim cabinet about as wide as the pole (e.g. those made by TSI Power). The larger Ericsson RRUs (grey boxes) on the pole mounted back to back are “ok” but should be painted to match the pole. Ericsson folks should make a more plain solar shield. The extra boxes on the back of the pole should be rotated onto the same side of the pole (since the batteries will be moved to another pole nearby).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/822/1*jVzAc0DXwfKZ9bQU7DDraA.png" /><figcaption>T-Mobile Small Cell. Two computers with antennas built in (other sites use an external antenna instead). The signal is then transmitted by cables running through the pole and under City streets through Pacific Gas &amp; Electric owned conduit.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*anZrQ_Nfo2z-6PmviB-w7w.png" /><figcaption>Small Cell on a steel light pole. Author recommended the use of brackets to place both of the guide signs already on the pole in front of the two equipment enclosures (mRRUs which are basically computers)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rs2e8D6_7eqr61CFLwQAMw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Pole-Top Mounted Antenna and equipment (computers, electric meter and disconnect switch) mounted on an existing utility (PG&amp;E) owned wooden utility pole. The offset nature of the conduit pipe (on the right side of the pole) is disfavored and should be flush to the pole (actual installation was flush).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/323/1*NalFn8zyXg3fEyrUCGyQGw.png" /><figcaption>On wooden utility poles antennas are either mounted on top of the pole (prior image); or a side-arm extension midway up the pole (in the communications zone or “comm zone” where telephone/cable/fiber cables are attached). The design in this image is far less intrusive than other installations with hanging panel antennas (and associated visible brackets and cables). The flanged nature of the arm hides smaller equipment boxes and provides a more seameless design. Credit: Advance Sim for Extenet Systems</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tkKzfBwj1YrBbwxNrDa9Gg.png" /><figcaption>Breakdown of a Personal Wireless Services Facility (Small Cell) on an existing wooden utility pole (Northern California Joint Pole Association). This photo simulation features a disfavored electrical meter cabinet (bottom box) that is nearly twice as wide as the pole. Actual installs used a meter cabinet about as wide as the pole, though wireless metering (hockey puck sized antenna instead of an electric meter) is preferable.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dtHdpmQbKB_VMV4fmgVx5w.png" /><figcaption>Integrated Pole with Equipment and Antennas inside. The designs should likely be tweaked. For example, not using as skinny a cobra head light arm (left) that makes the width of the vertical pole more noticeable. The pole on the left appears out of scale with the building behind it; while the pole on the right (with some tweaks) appears more appropriate.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/478/1*JgXNLQKegzhuOiS7hz0acg.png" /><figcaption>Enersphere ePole with antenna on top and equipment at the base. The large box at the base does not appear viable in most areas, but may be workable in a rural context with a wide right-of-way; if the pole is near mature trees, setback sufficiently from the road edge, and painted to match. Also, in this image the pole appears to hold up electric distribution wires too. The local electric utility may not easily allow for this type of replacement pole, based on their standards book (that can take a long time and a lot of effort to update).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/658/1*g8AtDCii242sfZRPJD8zTQ.png" /><figcaption>A Phillips SmartPole with antennas inside the pole and equipment in the base. The design has its pros and cons. Especially given its width on narrow sidewalks (though their is an underground base option) and narrower streets. The GPS antenna at the top should be better integrated. Also, since this site replaced an existing light pole and has fiber running to it; some broadband advocates would tend to feel their should be a free public Wi-Fi system integrated as well….</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YgnX_jsHx_JE2gWjzDgj-Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Recently proposed Ercisson Zero Site Small Pole. This appears to be viable, though the Ericsson logo should be removed. In addition you would need to verify no additional equipment is required (electric meter, disconnect switch, GPS antenna)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*seSgUFghuPYox8Wgb3mBug.png" /><figcaption>Initial Crown Castle proposal with a poor panel antenna (3 of them actually) design on an existing utility pole. The revised design was much cleaner (see below).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/472/1*G0R0s-yNlkYHx8XHh2VDlA.png" /><figcaption>An AT&amp;T Mobility Small Cell on an existing utility pole in Oakland. Don’t let this happen to you.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/288/1*jywN8nDS1A2IdFOEmrqXfw.png" /><figcaption>Portland example. Don’t allow this! This is not a Small Cell. It’s a quasi-monopole.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*i-ia45Zp0G_MjobMwObt5Q.png" /><figcaption>Verizon proposal. The base of the antenna needs a shroud transition onto the existing pole. Cabling below mRRUs needs cleaner integration into the pole ( messy looking set of drip loops for 4 cables each). Emergency disconnect should be inside the same sidewalk location where you turn off power to the streetlight. Narrower flush mounting bracket should be used for the mRRUs. I have no idea what a SAR-O is (likely the required RF warning sticker)…</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/599/1*pLqMbXaPFshzsMk24b0oqA.png" /><figcaption>See caption above</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k16U1Zwu4iYrmuNOjc0HSw.png" /><figcaption>An unrealistic and inappropriate proposal for a Verizon “Small Cell” on a nicely landscaped street in South Orange County. This is more of a quasi-macro than a Small Cell. The RBS cabinets on the left are the computers. A set of cabinets this large likely allows the carrier to serve every frequency with one system. The battery cabinets are for backup power (not required). The next box is the electric meter pedestal (can be replaced with wireless smart meter) and the the cabinet on the right is likely where fiber and power are converted.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*2W_nXvD_1a_d6ZCCODp3DA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Antenna on top of pole. Equipment is likely on the ground or underground.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tA8jvRE79UMjj-AysYKziA.png" /><figcaption>This is a fairly tall integrated pole with the antenna up top and equipment in a customized enclosure near the banner midway up the pole. It can be customized to add a streetlight attachment arm as well. Credit: Enersphere.com</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yprOBMaY_0iBlbxcPHFaQQ.png" /><figcaption>A Swiss Wireless Carrier placing cell antennas under special manholes (photo at top right). Courtesy of AGL Magazine June 2016. I doubt this is very effective in terms of data range and I’m concerned it would need an RF warning sticker on the lid as well.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ea483f83fe7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 3 | Tips on Crafting Ordinances, Public Outreach, & Design]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-3-tips-on-crafting-ordinances-public-outreach-design-8c43a7db17db?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c43a7db17db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[5g-wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zoning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Sep 2016 21:14:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-09T19:49:40.154Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>&gt;&gt; Link Back to Main Article: <a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/10-key-issues-for-california-cities-counties-on-the-challenges-of-small-cells-not-so-small-c9e966f257a#.r9c78zdm7">10 Key Issues for California Cities &amp; Counties on the Challenges of Small Cells &amp; “Not So Small Cells”</a></p><blockquote><em>This page discusses two example City ordinances; Citywide Policy Issues to Consider; issues to consider as you write your ordinance (permitting rules), public notification/outreach recommendations, design recommendations based on pole type; and tips on lease agreements.</em></blockquote><h3>EXAMPLE ORDINANCES TO CONSIDER</h3><p><strong>Example Wireless Public Right-of-Way Ordinance #2 | Rancho Palos Verdes| Key Highlights</strong></p><ol><li>Exempts some facilities from public notification/hearings based on size and location. In other words, it encourages small sites, and on collector/arterial streets, instead of in front of homes on residential streets. <em>Please note that the City of RPV is an example of a City with predominantly single-family homes with few tall structures or dense neighborhoods. Many homes feature sweeping views of the Pacific Ocean.</em></li><li>Places a ten year time limit on permits.</li><li>Requires coverage maps, discussion of alternate sites up-front, and proof of a coverage/capacity gap.</li><li><a href="http://www.rpvca.gov/916/Cell-Sites">Link to Ordinance and Application Forms</a></li></ol><p><strong>Example Wireless Public Right-of-Way Ordinance #1 | San Francisco | 16 Key Highlights</strong></p><ol><li>Does not require an automatic public hearing.</li><li>Does not require Planning Commission review (right-of-way sites only).</li><li>Does require notification to property owners and residential tenants (not commercial tenants) within 150 feet, and neighborhood groups registered with the Planning Department.</li><li>Once notification is mailed and posted on the pole, folks have 20 days to protest the tentative approval. If no protest is filed, then the permit is issued by Public Works.</li><li>Permits are submitted through Public Works, but referred to: a) Parks Department (if near a City park/plaza); b) Public Health Department (review of the RF report and compliance with City’s noise limits for things like cooling fans, if present); c) and Planning Department (Design, Historic Preservation, Environmental Review under CEQA).</li><li>Carrier must plant (or pay in-lieu fee) a street tree for each wireless facility, if requested as a condition of approval by Planning (<em>this was T-Mobile’s suggestion circa 2007</em>).</li><li>Places a ten-year time limit on permits for wireless facilities.</li><li>Includes specific noise limits near residential buildings.</li><li>Does not require coverage maps or proof of a significant gap that the site is intended to fill (<em>however, this is required for certain large/macro rooftop sites in residential and mixed-use areas as part of the Conditional Use Permit</em>).</li><li>Does not require a Conditional Use Permit. Review is discretionary in that it is based on the specific design and whether it will “significantly detract” from the specific streetscape at a given location (context-based test taking into account street width, significant views in City General Plan, nature of historic structures nearby).</li><li>Does require historic preservation review, but does not automatically prohibit wireless facilities in/near historic buildings/districts. Context-based test.</li><li>Explicitly requires a separate permit for any surface-mounted facilities (equipment boxes on the sidewalk/dirt). This is highly discouraged, given the very narrow public rights-of-way (narrow sidewalks with few parkways or greenbelts to place boxes).</li><li>Creates a dual protest opportunity. Residents may request a free hearing before a hearing officer assigned by Public Works Director, if requested within 20 days of tentative approval. In addition, if a final permit is issued, residents have 15 days from issuance, to file an appeal (approximately $300 filing fee) before the Board of Appeals (public hearing).</li><li>Does not include conditions of approval that would automatically apply if a facility was approved before the City made a decision on the application; if the (State) Shot Clock passed without a decision. <em>Your ordinance probably should include automatic conditions of approval</em></li><li><a href="http://www.sfpublicworks.org/services/permits/wireless-service-facilities">Link to Implementation Order, Application Forms, and Ordinance (Article 25 of Public Works Code)</a>.</li><li><a href="https://sfgov.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=2504411&amp;GUID=107371FE-F217-4C4D-9BE5-8140452419E0&amp;Options=ID|Text|&amp;Search=extenet">Sample Master Lease Agreements (for attachments to City-owned steel/concrete light/transit poles).</a></li><li>FAQ sheets for residents(<a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wirelessforms">link</a>). One version focused on wooden utility poles. Second version focused on steel poles which are mostly City-owned.</li></ol><h3>CITYWIDE POLICY ISSUES TO CONSIDER:</h3><ol><li>Do you want to work with the electric utility to get wireless smart metering allowed (as PG&amp;E is beginning to allow); using a meter that is basically a hockey puck sized antenna. This results in a much better design by avoiding the use of a bulky box with a glass bubble on the sidewalk or pole (which attracts graffiti given the low mounting height)? See Example “Bravo” below.</li><li>Do you want the carrier and the utility to have the carrier buy specific steel/concrete poles from the electric utility (if they own those poles) and then transfer the pole to the City, before Small Cells are added? This helps with ensuring the City has control over good design initially and in the future (see “6409” rules). Plus, it becomes easier to avoid adding a new electric meter and disconnect switch box, which can add more cluttered boxes to the pole or sidewalk.</li><li>Do you want to work with either the utility, or City agency that owns the poles to require that if the <strong>existing wooden utility pole</strong> only has street lighting (no other electric/cable tv/telco poles) on it now (no other wires); and a carrier proposes Small Cells; they have to replace the pole with a integrated or partially integrated (some boxes on the outside but cabling inside) steel pole? See Example Photo “Charlie” below. Thus far, it does not appear PG&amp;E is willing to allow such replacements if the pole has overhead power lines (instead of underground power lines serving the existing pole).</li><li>As you negotiate Master Lease Agreements, with carriers, for Small Cells on City-owned poles (if you own them or plan to acquire them), do you want to identify cost recovery arrangements (up front so you don’t have to go back to City Council for each issue) if the carrier proposes to add a Small Cell to <strong>concrete light poles</strong> that needs to be replaced (<em>some cities have complex rules on accepting assets from a private company that need to be worked out early</em>). Most existing concrete light poles have no entry holes for the cables from the radio head computer boxes (e.g. mRRUs) and the inside of the existing concrete poles is often too narrow for fiber and power cables to serve the Small Cell. So a replacement may be needed. See example photo “Bravo” below.</li><li><strong>Front Yard or Rear Yard Small Cells. </strong>If you have residential neighborhoods with wooden utility poles in alleys between nearly adjoining residential lots and concrete light poles along front yards; would you rather the carrier replace the concrete pole (for example) in the front yard (and add a Small Cell), or attach more exposed equipment and antennas to the wood pole in the alley? Talk to stakeholders.</li><li><strong>Bus Shelter Contracts</strong>. Ensure that as contracts are renewed, the bus shelter/billboard operators (e.g. JC Decaux, Clear Channel, TITAN) does not add language to renewal contracts to allow wireless facilities, without an opportunity for further review (design and revenue). On the other hand, provisions in contracts banning “all other uses” may be more limiting than needed. <em>Context: Clear Channel has an agreement with Vertical Bridge which is tied to Extenet Systems (a neutral host carrier that places antennas in the public right-of-way). It is possible they may choose to leverage that relationship to place antennas/equipment on bus shelters and billboards. However, the low height of these shelters limits the antennas reach (“propogation”) and may only be proposed in dense urban areas where other light poles are not available.</em></li><li>Consider reaching out to any <strong>regional agencies </strong>(e.g. light rail networks) that may own steel or concrete poles in your area. This may offer better placement closer to a lot of mobile device users (on the train, for example) and avoid placements on poles next to residences; or pressure by the carrier to add entirely new poles just for wireless.</li><li>Figure out if any existing contracts a City/County may have in place could complicate Small Cell siting on municipal poles/structures, and if those need to be highlighted early on for carriers and peer staff.</li><li>Do you want mailed/posted <strong>notification to neighbors</strong>, before a site is approved? If you do conduct notification consider including the photo simulations and plans, or a link to them online. I also recommend you create an FAQ sheet (<a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wirelessforms">two examples here</a>) on your website and include a link on the notification form or permit.</li><li><strong>Public Hearings</strong> | Do you want facilities in the public right-of-way to be reviewed administratively (Planning/Public Works Staff), or at a public hearing by the Planning Commission (i.e. Conditional Use Permits)? Also, do you want the initial concept design to be reviewed by Historic Preservation Commission (if applicable) or Design Review Boards. Consider asking for a blanket approval for a specific and appropriate design, if proposed en masse to avoid going back on multiple iterations.<br> — →Or do you only want to require public notification/hearings for certain sites such as only those on local two-lane residential streets (or within ~100 feet of a residential dwelling)? <br> — →Or do you want all sites to be reviewed, without a required public hearing/notice, by the Director of Public Works (<em>with, or without peer design/historic/noise/environmental review by Planning Department and Parks Department staff</em>)?</li><li>Are there right-of-way locations (poles or equipment on the ground) where special districts or unique properties (Air/Sea Port lands, tribal lands, regional transit agencies, and areas under Coastal Commission/Redevelopment Agency/National Park Service/Fish &amp; Game/Army Corps of Engineer purview) may have an interest?</li><li>Will<strong> civic design review board</strong> purview extend to wireless on exiting utility/light poles and new poles/structures.</li><li>Do you want to adapt your existing ordinance that currently covers wireless on private property, to also cover the public right-of-way as well? Or, would you prefer to adapt existing right-of-way specific wireless ordinances similar to those from other California cities/counties?</li><li>Do you want to take steps early on to avoid, to the extent feasible, carriers building a less-intrusive (“less ugly”) site and then coming back a year later and demanding the right (under a Federal rule known as “6409”) to make the site uglier, noisier, or bulkier? If a Small Cell is proposed on an existing investor-owned utility steel or concrete pole, do you want to require the pole to be transferred to City ownership? While this may be one more “challenge” (insurance/asset management) it can offer three big advantages. a) easier to fuse the system into existing circuit and avoid the need for ugly electric meters or disconnect boxes; b) retain more control over the initial design; and c) retain control over future changes so that a carrier can’t use “6409” to make the site 10 feet taller, put ugly panel antennas or large and noisy cabinets on the site later on.</li><li><strong>New Master Planned Communities and Small Cells.</strong> Consider requiring new subdivisions to include a wireless plan or narrative on where wireless facilities are contemplated (City of Irvine does something like this). Encourage developer to reach out to carriers in advance and build sites before residents move in. For example, can neighborhood entrance gateway structures have slightly taller columns that hide cell antennas inside? Can the developer work with integrated pole makers (e.g. STEALTH, Sabre Industries, Ericsson) to mostly hide antennas inside decorative street lights and new traffic signals?<br>If the developer sets up a new homeowner’s association or community management association, determine if the HOA or management association will have any discretion over fees, permitting, design.</li><li>Do you want wireless-ready street lighting and traffic signal poles as you upgrade existing streetscapes or develop new neighborhoods?</li><li><strong>New City Light Pole Catalog.</strong> When new neighborhoods are planned or major streetscapes are proposed, consider using light standards that can accommodate a radome style antenna (baseball bat size) above the pole. While many folks like the old-time style gas lamps, with bulbs at the top of the light standard; they are not dark-sky compliant (<a href="http://darksky.org/lighting/lighting-basics/">link</a>) and are not designed to easily accommodate cell antenna attachments. Though, there are companies like Sabre industries that make partially integrated models with a quasi-vintage design. <a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-2-example-photos-of-the-good-the-bad-and-the-downright-ugly-ea483f83fe7#.xc400tff7">See Section 2 for example photos</a>.</li><li>If you have <strong>banners </strong>on your poles, make sure to check your contracts with banner installers. You may have to tell them to obtain RF safety training and/or inform them of the need to call the carrier’s network operations center (“NOC”) in advance to request a shut down of the banner. Some antennas may have such a low effective radiated power that no power shutdown is required. Check with the RF engineer and carrier.</li><li>If your City/County has unique <strong>jurisdiction overlap</strong> areas (e.g. spheres of influence, specific plan areas subject to grandfathered rules) make absolutely sure you coordinate who has review authority over wireless in the right of way with the other jurisdiction. Avoid instances where the carrier takes advantage of confusion to build sites without permits. Consider asking the other jurisdiction to note review by your jurisdiction on the forms page of their respective Public Works or Planning websites.</li><li>Do you want to talk to Public Works Director about potentially allowing “<a href="http://www1.nyc.gov/site/doitt/business/microtrenching.page"><strong>micro trenching</strong></a>” (<em>various California cities, Chicago and NYC allow this</em>) to avoid large scale excavations for underground fiber-optic backhaul or bringing underground power to poles that do not have power running to them already (<em>e.g. some poles that hold up DC-powered wires only for buses and light rail</em>)?</li><li>Do you want permit fees to be based on time and materials; especially for large systems or those that require special environmental clearances. Bear in mind that two FCC Commissioners have noted very isolated examples of high permit fees as reason to propose capping rates (at rates considered absurdly low of under $50 for a permit, it appears) for permits by all cities/counties. It appears <a href="http://www.aglmediagroup.com/seeing-wireless-as-an-essential-service-could-speed-infrastructure-deployment/">Sprint/Mobilitie</a> is also noting isolated examples in order to push for rate (leasing and permit fee) limits. No specific proposals have been promulgated at the Federal level as of September 2016. However, wireless carriers have pushed unrealistically low permit fee caps at various Statehouses.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kTe7TbJxGPWo5vEO0Mv_bg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Example Bravo: This appears to be a wooden light pole owned by Pacific Gas and Electric in Point Arena / Mendocino, with no overhead electric lines. If a Small Cell is proposed on this pole, I strongly recommend requiring the pole to be replaced with a standard tapered steel light pole. Especially since the electric cables already come to the pole from underground. This can allow for a cleaner design (no outside cabling, no large brackets hanging off the wood pole). Please note that while there is cabling currently inside the wooden pole, it is highly unlikely there would be enough room for additional cabling (electric and fiber-optic) for a Small Cell. There are integrated poles that house the computers inside the pole, but be mindful that on some narrow sidewalks, the pole width may be out of place and may also block wheelchairs.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r7QjQsszfH7crRi4LZZ5Dg.png" /><figcaption>The pole in the background on the left lies between two residential backyards (no alley between). That would probably not be a good place to install a Small Cell; especially one with noisy cooling fans. Consider noting this in your ordinance. The decorative light on the far right can’t easily be adapted to hold Small Cell antennas; though there are some taller replacements that can mimic the design intent. If an antenna is added to the wood pole on the right there are two options. Placing the antenna above electrical lines requires 8 feet of vertical clearance. This may be too tall on a neighborhood basis. However, placing the antenna on a sidearm midway up the pole (in the communications or “comm” zone next to the lower set of telephone/fiber wires may be more visible from an immediate neighbor perspective. Given the lack of bedroom windows next to the pole a side-arm attachment may be better. Or better yet, replacing the concrete light pole with one with wireless antennas hidden inside.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fLPGhttebz21CQL6dMWfzQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5CWtIQ8KID6U3S8H8WlgCw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SKqT7YkwDotvynv47g3rvQ.png" /><figcaption>Example Charlie Preliminary Schematic for Wireless Smart Metering on a Small Cell on an existing steel light pole. The Smart Meter is an antenna instead of a metal box with a glass bubble style electric meter placed on the sidewalk or the pole. This allows for a much better and lighter design. Pacific Gas &amp; Electric has been moving in the direction of allowing this type of system instead of using older electric meters.</figcaption></figure><h3>ISSUES TO CONSIDER AS YOU WRITE YOUR ORDINANCE (actual permitting rules) AND APPLICATION FORMS</h3><ol><li><strong>Map out potential review bodies</strong>. Create a list of all the review bodies in your City/County (e.g. design review, historic preservation commission, neighborhood councils, overlap areas in County-run spheres of influence, California Coastal Commission, joint powers agencies, ports/airports, citizens advisory bodies, successors to redevelopment agencies, Native American Tribes, Department of Fish &amp; Game, U.S. Army Corp of Engineers) that may apply given the type of Small Cell (e.g. utility-owned wooden pole, City owned new/replacement/existing pole, bus shelter). Turn this into an appendix checklist on the application form.</li><li>Determine what <strong>exhibits</strong> you want for each application, such as: project plans, photo simulations, acknowledgment of the need for Section 106 tribal/historic preservation review, archeological/geological review for excavations of more than __ feet, historic preservation review, State/Federal environmental clearance (hint: wetlands), landscaping plans, local airport or FAA clearance (hint: aircraft lighting for sites near airports or poles over 50 feet near certain agricultural areas due to crop dusting), noise studies, radio-frequency (RF) emissions reports, engineer stamped surveys proving a site is in the public right-of-way, copy of the carriers certificate of public convenience and necessity from the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC); proof of permission from the pole-owner; copy of structural/pole-loading calculations provided to the pole owner.</li><li>Do you want <strong>public hearings</strong> for every new site or major modification? I do not recommend automatic public hearings, especially for well-designed Small Cells, that are truly small, and not located within 30 feet of a residential building wall (<em>in suburban/exurban communities encourage wireless facilities on arterial and collector streets, and discourage local streets</em>). Consider requiring public hearings for Small Cells that are a) either within 30 feet of specific types of properties (schools, playgrounds, residential dwellings not including sheds/barns/garages); b) feature new poles (not including replacements of existing poles with no more than a 10 foot height difference); or c) new ground-mounted equipment (other than an electric meter or disconnect switch).</li><li>If you require public hearings, consider removing additional requirements to announce hearings in the classifieds section of the <strong>newspaper</strong>, if applicable. This requirement doesn’t serve much of a public purpose and creates additional timing challenges when it comes to State/Federal Shot Clocks. If the goal is to ensure neighbors are notified, focus on notification that is understandable (e.g. including photo simulations in the packet, or a link to a website), broad-based (include relevant community groups) and accessible (foreign languages).</li><li>Do you want <strong>mailed notification</strong> to property owners only, or to also include neighborhood groups registered with the City and tenants? <em>I do not recommend you require notification of business/commercial tenants since it is more challenge to accurately find all commercial suites.</em> Also, do you want notification to be posted on the pole, with photo simulations? Do you want to exempt sites in commercial/downtown/industrial areas from public notification or public hearings, but still require staff design and historic preservation review?</li><li>Do you want <strong>notification mailings</strong> to be handled by the carrier or by City staff? If handled by the carrier, require that the envelopes include the phrase “notification of a nearby cell antenna proposal” (or similar) in English, Spanish, and Chinese in grey text on the front of the envelope (<em>so neighbors are less likely to throw it away assuming it is junk mail if the return address is a carrier’s office address</em>). Should the notification include a photo simulation (recommended)?</li><li><strong>Alternate Site Analysis</strong>: Do you want carriers to demonstrate efforts, as part of their submittal, to site on collector or arterial streets before proposing locations on local streets (and/or within X feet of a residential dwelling with habitable space; not including garages)? Or do you only want to require this effort for sites with larger equipment cabinets on the pole, or on the ground next to the pole?</li><li>Consider prohibiting Small Cells on existing wooden poles that run between directly adjoining <strong>residential backyards </strong>(these poles are typically treated as an easement, and not part of the public right of way if there is no intervening alley). Or, at a bare minimum require that they use passive cooling (no noise) and use cabinets no wider than 12 inches and no deeper than 10 inches. It may be harder to prohibit if there are poles in a vehicular alley between the homes. Bear in mind, the carrier may try to modify the site in the future and claim 6409 rights (if the pole is not owned by the City). However, if they are proposing to modify a site to add a large and noisy cabinet next to a residence, you can request a stay on the 60 day shot clock (act fast) and a waiver from the FCC. Talk to your City/County counsel early on if you see a potential problem. If you indicate a problem early on the carrier may back off and come back with something more reasonable (and wouldn’t be embarrassed to live near to).</li><li>Consider requiring review by your <strong>Parks Department</strong> if the site is adjacent to a City street or important plaza. However, do not just ban sites in front of parks though. For example, it may be better to put the small cell along the park edge that has a lot of dense brush and lacks a nearby park entrance or nice vista; instead of on a pole across the street, and in front of a bedroom window. <em>Context matters.</em></li><li>Prohibit <strong>new overhead wires</strong> in undergrounded areas.</li><li>Do you want to prohibit <strong>new wood poles for wireless</strong> (recommended), unless an appropriate replacement of a nearby wood utility pole? If so, do you want to note that new fully/partially integrated steel/concrete poles, that also provides street lighting in areas of currently deficient lighting is encouraged; if affirmed as appropriate by _______ (groups/department)?</li><li>Do you want to require a separate permit for removal, and for sites to be removed within 6 months or a year of being inactive/abandoned?</li><li>Do you want to indicate that a permit expires if the facility is not built in 18 months?</li><li>Create a separate permit type for Personal Wireless Services Facilities (addition/modification of antennas, equipment cabinets, poles/structures) specifically in the public right-of-way (as a different permit type than for wireless on private property). Otherwise, trying to track wireless facilities by looking up varying project descriptions under encroachment permits can become a headache. Consider creating a sub-category for modifications to existing Personal Wireless Services Facilities (addition of a 2nd carrier, additional ground-mounted equipment). Also put in place a ten year time limit tracker (from permit issuance).</li><li>If you track permits by street address, bear in mind that some poles near a street corner may have a nearest street address for the intersecting street instead. Consider creating a dummy address or adding a clear and consistent note (“on _______ street frontage”) on the plans, photo simulations, and permitting system. Train your front counter staff on this. Avoid instances where residents aren’t sure if two poles are proposed near the same intersection; or your field inspection staff assumes the pole was not yet built because they did not know to look around the corner.</li><li>Do you want to indicate a height limit for wireless facilities, especially for residential zones? Bear in mind, there are some tradeoffs with height limits. The carrier may seek more sites, or may move the antenna from a location at the top of the pole (“Pole-Top”) to a side-arm mount midway up the pole. This may not be an issue, unless you have buildings, especially residential windows only a few feet from the pole; where the side-arm design may impair views from adjacent residences. It’s a balancing act but consider your street context early on and discuss these preferences with carriers, or as a policy statement on your website. Bear in mind that if the City does not own the pole and the pole features unscreened antennas/equipment, the carrier can increase the pole height by 10 feet using the Federal rule referred to as “6409” after initial approval (even if the height limit increase violates City/County, or coastal commission imposed height limits).</li><li>Do you want to mandate that new poles may not be installed, if it is determined the pole would also require (blinking) <strong>aircraft lighting</strong> based on FAA/Airport Land Use Plan requirements?</li><li>Do you want a more narrow <strong>notification boundary</strong> (e.g. 150 feet) for <em>small</em> Small Cells, and a larger boundary (e.g. 300 feet) for facilities over 50 feet tall and/or with surface-mounted equipment (other than the meter/disconnect) on the ground/sidewalk.</li><li>Consider writing the ordinance to give the carrier an ability to challenge a denial by staff to a public hearing body (with or without neighborhood notification, depending on your City/County). Don’t require them to get neighbors signatures in order to qualify for an appeal (<em>that would be kind of funny to imagine though</em>).</li><li>Does your city have a “sudden death type rule: that says if your application is denied the applicant can’t come back to the hearing body with the same site for a year, for example? If so, determine if this rule also applies to wireless applications (and any related applications that may apply such as historic preservation commission or design review board) and make it clear in the ordinance.</li><li>Come up with a <strong>noise limit</strong>, or reference your existing noise ordinance (if sufficient). For example, facilities cannot generate more than 45 decibels at 3 feet from any residential (including retirement/convalescent homes) building wall; from any public library; and any child care or elementary school classroom or playground. Determine if you want a noise study for every site (not recommended), or just require noise studies for certain facilities (<em>e.g. those that do not indicate no noise generation on the cover sheet of plans, and are located within 15 feet of a residence, school, place of worship and playgrounds</em>). Indicate in your ordinance that the carrier has 10 business days to remedy any noise violations, from when notification is mailed, or must shut down the noise producing elements.</li><li><strong>Update your Utilities Condition Permit. </strong>Require those wireless carriers that add antennas/boxes to existing utility owned wooden poles, to affirm, in writing, every few years that they will remove their facility, at no cost to City/County, if the City/County actually begins under grounding overhead electrical and telephone poles/wires in a given neighborhood. If you don’t have any wooden poles, this doesn’t apply.</li><li>Determine if your application/ordinance should inform carriers that the Public Works Department will only accept a certain <strong>maximum number of applications per week,</strong> per carrier. <em>Word this carefully so the carrier doesn’t try to game the system by having multiple subcontractors submit permits in their name instead.</em></li><li><strong>Prohibit Tree Topping</strong>. Talk to your City’s Arborist about the potential for some carriers to top trees (harming them and making them ugly) when installing new poles or running aerial fiber cables along existing wooden poles (“backhaul”). If you decide to also require the carrier to provide a tree, work with them on managing the review process and neighborhood engagement. Avoid a situation where the wording of notification makes the neighbor think they can defeat the wireless facility permit by refusing to host a street tree in front of their home.</li><li>If you have <strong>freight rail lines</strong> in your community, determine if new wireless facilities on poles (especially those for commercial wireless) along those rail lines will require City/County review. It is likely some railroads will install new poles and antennas for positive train control soon (to stop runaway trains remotely using radio systems). Though this may end up being accomplished by satellite instead. <a href="https://www.fcc.gov/general/positive-train-control-ptc">FCC Link.</a></li><li><strong>Cable strand modems (CSMs)</strong>. Cable companies often install small Wi-Fi modems as antennas mounted on the black wires between wooden utility poles. They are typically low power antennas. <em>Some wireless carriers have inquired about using CSMs to serve “cellular” customers as well.</em> Many cities/counties do not require permits for attaching CSMs on wires between existing poles. Orange County requires a Conditional Use Permit if a new pole is installed to hold up the CSMs. Consider exempting these systems from review/permitting as long as they: a) do not generate noise b) do not require entirely new poles or additional equipment on the nearby pole (e.g. shutdown switches/battery backup/radio heads); c) do not feature indicator lights or other illumination; d) do not feature conspicuous logos/decals; and e) are not more than two cubic feet in size (for example).</li><li><strong>Surveys May Be Needed </strong>Remind the carrier to check on land use jurisdiction. It’s all too common for inexperienced carriers to turn in applications to the wrong agency (e.g. Port lands or other special districts). Some poles may look like they are in the right-of-way but actually be on land owned by the Parks agency or community college district.</li><li><strong>For Investor-Owned Utility Poles and Brand New Carrier-Installed Poles. </strong>Ensure the carrier provides their certificate of convenience and public necessity (that covers their subsidiaries as well, or equivalent proof) from the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC). You can waive this for attachments to City-owned poles. General Order 95 (GO 95) is the core reference to the CPUC-promulgated rules on attachments (including wireless antennas) to utility poles.<br>The GO 95 rules do not appear to apply to City owned light poles, as long as they do not feature telephone/electric distribution wires for other utility agencies. <em>I mention this because some carriers may assume those rules apply and create a more obtrusive design than needed.</em></li><li><strong>Trees. </strong>Consider requiring, in your ordinance, a free street tree to be provided by the carrier unless the facility is largely stealthed/screened or in an industrial area where trees may not be appropriate. Do not expect the carrier to maintain the tree. Getting them to build sites correctly is enough of a challenge.</li><li><strong>Window distance to facility metric</strong>. If you own the pole you should articulate a metric for when you will deny a site based on private view obstruction. For instance, only if three tests are met: the nearby window is for a residence (not office or hotel), the equipment and or antenna is somewhat bulky, and is less than nine (9) feet from the direct view of a residence. If you do not own the existing pole this is harder to contend with due to State law. So, focus on whether the overall design is contextually appropriate given the view from within the public right-of-way (standing on sidewalk). If you believe the carrier should look at a nearby pole (typically within 300 feet) then say so, within the first 30 days.</li><li><strong>Project Management for Assistant/Associate Planners/Public Works Engineers</strong>. Keep in mind the concept of critical path management. Ensure you highlight for the benefit of both the carrier and peer staff important issues that may cause delays if not fulfilled in a timely manner; even if the rest of the project is progressing. If facilities are proposed on City owned poles, make sure a mockup is requested, and the design includes conduit entry holes, and grounding rod locations. Ensure these issues are all approved by both administrative, and field engineering staff with the pole owning agency. Lastly, remind the carrier and pole owning agency of any pending streetscape improvement plans, that may affect existing poles. Simply put, make sure the folks who install and maintain the poles and those who work on new streetscape plans are all aware of the project. Have the carrier also affirm that no ground-mounted equipment or additional equipment (e.g. GPS antennas, overhead lines) is proposed but absent from plans and photo simulation.</li><li>Some older wireless ordinances tried to discourage single carrier monopoles (tall steel towers with antennas for only one wireless carrier) by requiring a <strong>separation distances </strong>of a 1,000 feet, for example, between other monopoles. If the City’s definition of a monopole also extends the public right-of-way, and even to fairly small Small Cells (especially if attached to existing poles), then this may push carriers to put the next Small Cell site closer to a residential area than needed (to maintain the buffer distance).</li><li>Do not “require” a <strong>pre-application meeting</strong>. Offer, and suggest them. Cities like San Marcos try to work out the design and application well in advance of an actual submittal. This approach appears to work well for them.<br><em>If you require a pre-application, then the carrier can argue that the Shot Clock starts running on that day and not the day they submit the application. 1 week before the meeting, strongly suggest that the carrier rep actually take the time to READ the application form and any suggested pages of the code/ordinance. Perhaps send them an example of a previously approved project packet. Ideally, they will come better prepared.</em></li><li><strong>Pole Safety</strong>. City can require the same structural calculations provided to the owner of the wooden poles (consistent with CPUC regs such as General Order 95); but can’t require anything more generally. The city/county can and should require structural calcs that take into account new mounting and conduit entry holes for poles it owns. If a pole top extension is proposed (though a pole replacement is preferred) you may want to check to see if the calcs determined the pole-overturning requirements show the current footing depth is sufficient.</li><li><strong>Shot Clocks. </strong>Verizon (and any network partner they use, like Crown Castle or Extenet Systems) may try to say that any wireless facility on an existing building or pole; even if it doesn’t have a wireless facility already; is subject to a 90 day collocation Shot Clock; instead of a 150 day clock. That’s wrong. Be clear on it in comment letters.<br>Shot Clocks do not apply to City owned properties or poles. <br>Keep a good written record. <br>Note if sudden changes are made or snuck in late in the process. Also, note, in writing the reasons for denials.<br>The Shot Clock can be paused, but only if you tell the carrier within the first 30 days of application submittal that it is <strong>incomplete</strong> and why. If the re-submittal is still incomplete, then you have 10 days to tell them, and indicate why and pause the clock once more.<br>The clock does NOT pause because the design is not code complying or appropriate (viable). The time it takes for the carrier to make changes counts AGAINST the City/County.<br>Create special color folders for wireless facility applications. Make sure your entire administrative staff knows submittals need to be routed immediately.</li><li>Be sure to come up with <strong>automatically applied conditions of approval</strong> that are specific to the public right-of-way; and place a ten-year time limit on permits. These conditions can focus on items listed further below (See: Sample Conditions of Approval for Auto Approvals).</li><li><strong>Project Plans Completeness: </strong>Consider requiring the following:</li></ol><ul><li>Nearest street address, based on an address a neighbor will actually recognize that matches the address on the photo simulations (yes, this often becomes an issue).</li><li>Name of Carrier and/or Network Being Served</li><li>Project Description that clearly indicates if a new pole is being added, a pole is being replaced, or if antennas/equipment are being attached to an existing pole.</li><li>The name of the pole-owning agency</li><li>A note indicate either “no noise generating equipment is proposed” or indicating the maximum decibel level at ground level.</li><li>An elevation sheet clearly showing any new excavations or a note indicating no new excavations.</li><li>An elevation sheet clearly showing any new surface mounted (boxes/electric meters/disconnect switches) within 100 feet of the pole, or a note indicating “no equipment is proposed on sidewalks/landscaping other than the pole.” <em>You will get a lot of calls from neighbors asking about this…</em></li><li>An elevation sheet that calls out the sizes of equipment, and top of the pole or antenna (whichever is taller).</li><li>For wood poles: elevation sheets that shows the offset between the pole and equipment (encourage flush attachment or no greater than 4 inch gaps). Also, elevation sheets that shows conduit/cables will be flush to the pole. See photo Example Foxtrot further below.</li><li>For concrete/steel poles: elevation sheets that show cabling will be located inside the pole and equipment will be flush to the pole.</li><li>Location of ALL node identification stickers and RF warning stickers. Require node ID (carrier name and phone number) stickers to be on the underside of equipment enclosures and RF sticker to be placed below antennas, and not near ground level on the pole.</li><li>Clear notes regarding the color that antennas, brackets, exposed cabling, electric meters, disconnect switches will be painted (e.g. Gray Matters or Sable by Sherwin-Williams — in a non-glossy matte finish). Please note that while painting antennas sky blue may seem like a good idea, it tends to look cheesy. Especially if there are exposed bundles of cables and brackets around the antenna.</li><li>Sheets which provided equipment specifications (equipment names, model numbers and size.</li><li><em>Staff note: always check to see the equipment specs match the elevation sheet. It often fails to match, and is a sign of poor quality submittals. Also see if the antenna descriptions match the antenna noted in the radio-frequency (RF) emissions report. They often do not. Make sure the RF report is stamped by an engineer licensed in the State. Yes, you have every right to ask for this. Neighbors will ask for it too.</em></li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*QU0X7mc9KPPkFZ1wRqMOIg.png" /><figcaption>Remember, Small Cells proposals may include inappropriately large/tall and unscreened ground-mounted equipment. It’s not just about the antennas….</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ahZpfInL1szOuG7p3WSOaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Citisite brand mockup integrated light pole with Nokia cell antennas/equipment near the top of the pole. Width of top element is 24 inches. Enclosure can be made opaque (instead of see-thru). In this example the light arms are shortened for the demonstration. Sometimes the very narrow nature of the arms can make the pole look larger than it is (you can request a wider arm).</figcaption></figure><h3>California Environmental Quality Act</h3><p><em>Archaeology for Pole Replacement, Aesthetics, Historic Preservation, Noise, Cumulative Effects</em></p><p>Think about context. If you have sensitive habitat such as wetlands within some public rights-of-way; then ask for environmental clearance for any new structures/trenching, up front, in those areas.</p><p>If you want noise studies (not all Small Cells have noise-generating cooling fans), then say so on the form; or perhaps only require them if the equipment can produce noise and is located within 50 feet of a sensitive receptor (home, child care center, hospice). If you are in a rural or agricultural area, or near an airport, be aware that some poles as short as 50 feet may need aircraft warning paint and lighting (<a href="http://wirelessestimator.com/articles/2016/new-faa-rules-will-require-some-50-to-200-foot-towers-to-be-marked/">link</a>).</p><p>If you think you may need it, ask for it up front; and preferably create metrics that focus certain items based on context. Look at examples in Calabasas, Ojai, San Diego, and <a href="http://www.sfpublicworks.org/services/permits/wireless-service-facilities">San Francisco</a>. Some applications are specific to wireless in the public right-of-way.</p><p>Map out how CEQA review will occur. If sites are on existing poles (or similar replacements) and no extensive trenching, aircraft warning lights, really tall poles, equipment areas on habitat/marshland; it may not be appropriate to require an Initial Study. Crown Castle will often try to tell you their work is exempted by the CPUC and you can’t require CEQA review. <em>You can review.</em></p><p>Discuss issues of aesthetics, archeology (if there is a ground disturbance such as a pole replacement), geology (special soils), historic preservation, illumination (aircraft or equipment indicator lights, if any) and noise (if any) in your exemption paperwork (if required). Reserve the right to reject sites further down the road if it seems the cumulative impact of multiple sites closely together on a specific streetscape segment (not a 360 or regional basis) would impair scenic vistas, for example.</p><p>Historic Preservation &amp; Individual Site Review. One metric to consider is not whether a site should be denied just because it is next to a historic building; but how it affects views of significant character-defining features of the building. For example a “not-too-ugly” wireless facility on an existing utility pole in front of a historic landmark, like a large old church, may be acceptable if the existing pole happens to be near a rear edge of the church where the facade is secondary (not the primary “face” the building presents to the community).</p><p>If possible place the CEQA determination online for residents to view. Attach sample plans and photo simulations. If no brand new pole locations are discussed (except replacements) then indicate that in the project description.</p><p>If you think you will need clearance from the Department of Fish &amp; Game or Army Corps of Engineers (habitat, wetlands/marshes) then ask for that up front on the application form, so it is a completeness item for the purpose of the shot clock challenge and solid review.</p><h3>PUBLIC NOTIFICATION/OUTREACH</h3><ol><li>You are going to get a LOT of calls to City/County staff. Even if public notification is not required. So, create clear information (FAQ) sheets to educate residents about what is proposed. Place a link to the online version that is prominently featured on issued permits, especially if the permits are attached to the pole or mailed to residents (if you require notification). See examples at <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wireless">www.sf-planning.org/wireless</a> (steel poles) and <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/woodenpoles">www.sf-planning.org/woodenpoles</a> (wood poles). Unfortunately, there are examples where the wireless carrier’s sub-contractor installs fiber optic cables at the pole a few months before the neutral host carrier submits an application to add cell antennas and equipment; and then the subcontractor tells a neighbor to buzz off when the neighbor asks why there is a large construction truck in front of their house, and what is being installed. This can results in justifiably upset calls to the council member or County supervisor, and staff taking a good deal of time to figure out what is being built. Some cities tell the carriers up front they may not install backhaul in advance of approvals.</li><li>Consider holding an information session for the City Council or various hearing bodies. Show the good, bad and ugly of designs. Invite carriers to present. Go into closed session, if needed, afterward, for your City Attorney to answer questions (or provide legal advice).</li><li>Require (in your ordinance) wireless carriers to arrange for free noise (cooling fans — if present) and radio-frequency (RF) emissions testing, for residents (within 150 or 300 feet), at no charge, in their homes. Provide any easy to find request phone number or e-mail address on the permit form itself.</li><li>Determine if you want to require public notification, or maybe only for sites along residential streets and historic districts. Or, only for sites with ground mounted equipment on local or collector streets. In other words, come up with a metric that makes sense (e.g. within 75 feet of a residential window, doorway, or usable balcony) for your neighborhoods. Consider creating tentative approvals and a 20-day hold during which protests/appeals to be filed. Decide if the initial protest/appeal hearing can be free (recommended), and be held by a Zoning Administrator or Public Works Director (either are recommended).</li><li>If public hearings are required and/or appeal hearings are required/afforded, tell the carrier not to bring an RF engineer who mumbles or has a thick accent that will make it hard for folks in the audience to understand. Also, some carriers will “hire” residents (often times folks who are, or appear to be, partially disabled) to say they need service at the hearings and the site should be approved. One could argue they should be registering as lobbyists, if required by City/County ordinance. Separately, Verizon will sometimes tout how they sent a message to subscribers nearby to see if they wanted better service. Though, it doesn’t seem they describe or send photos of the sites; especially “oDAS XL” (larger and uglier versions) ones as part of the survey…</li><li><strong>Foreign Languages. </strong>If you require public notification and you have a neighborhood with a high degree of folks for whom English is not their native language, consider requiring a portion of the notice to be printed in Chinese (simple) and Spanish. Since the term “Personal Wireless Services Facility” can confuse folks who may wonder if public Wi-Fi is being proposed; it may be advisable to indicate something like “small-scale cell antenna” in the translation.</li><li>Notify folks near both poles. If you do decide to require resident notification, ensure the notification boundary includes another pole if other equipment such as battery backup cabinets are placed on the second pole down the street. Consider having the carrier add a note to the cover sheet of the plans indicating no radio-frequency (RF) emissions or noise (if applicable) come from the secondary pole (if applicable).</li><li>In more suburban contexts consider waiving public notification or public hearings for well-designed sites on wider arterial (e.g. six-lane roads); but requiring notification for systems with larger footprints (e.g. any ground-mounted equipment unless undergrounded or stealthed inside the new light pole). In other words, incentivize placement away from locations a few feet from residences or scenic vistas, and toward more appropriate designs.</li><li>If you require a community meeting (earlier and different from an official public hearing), remind the carrier representative to make sure the location can easily be accessed by those with limited mobility (stairs/hills) and can be found on Google/Yahoo Maps and Mapquest, easily! Require a copy of the meeting notice, a copy of the sign-in sheet, the mailing list that was used, and a synopsis of what occurred.</li><li>Come up with a notification boundary that seems appropriate. For instance, 150 feet for Small Cells under 45 feet in height, and 500 feet for large or tall sites. Decide if you want to notify just property owners and residential tenants, and commercial tenants too. Remember, commercial tenant spaces are a lot harder to find/discern; so it is not generally recommended. Determines if notices need to go to individual units in dormitories or retirement homes that may not have public suite numbers available. Consider requiring the notice (and photo simulation) to be posted on each pole where equipment or antennas will be added. Include a link to an online FAQ sheet. Consider not requiring publication of hearings in newspapers too, as this can make scheduling of hearings more of a challenge given the Shot Clock issue.</li><li>If you have a Historic Preservation hearing body, consider notifying them of pending applications as part of a study session. Determine if this body needs to review facilities in the public right-of-way located in historic districts. Bear in mind that you may have a timing challenge (given AB 57) if the City/County does not own the poles and two or more public hearing bodies need to review. Some cities/counties allow for an administrative review track for historic preservation applications (if appropriately designed) that may be worth considering. Or alternatively, holding a joint review session (if the code allows for it).</li><li>If the system does not create any noise (lack of cooling fans for computers/batteries, aka, “passive cooling”) then ask the carrier to indicate that with a prominent note on the cover page of the project plans. It is a issue that your staff will get a lot of calls from residents on.</li><li>The<em> “Government/External Relations Representative Goes off the Reservation Syndrome.”</em> It is all too common for representatives of wireless carriers to put out inaccurate information at public meeting/hearing. See example below. Consider empowering your staff (or counsel, if present) to get up (if allowed by the forum) and provide a correction for the benefit of the public; if appropriate at the meeting/hearing. Otherwise it may frustrate elected/appointed officials and/or serve as fodder for continued appeals or lawsuits. Example X.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c43a7db17db" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[10 Key Issues for California Cities & Counties on the Challenges of Small Cells & “Not So Small…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/10-key-issues-for-california-cities-counties-on-the-challenges-of-small-cells-not-so-small-c9e966f257a?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c9e966f257a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[zoning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[5g]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Sep 2016 20:57:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-16T16:37:09.278Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>10 <strong>Key Issues for California Cities &amp; Counties on the Challenges of Small Cells &amp; “Not So Small Cells”</strong></h3><p>With only a few day left in the 2016 State legislative session, the wireless industry <a href="http://www.tellusventure.com/blog/bill-forcing-california-cities-to-lease-cell-sites-scrap-permits-magically-appears/">gutted and amended</a> a proposed California law (<a href="https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201520160AB2788">AB 2788</a>) on safe natural gas storage, into a law that would have allowed cell towers, rent-free, in front of your bedroom window or your driveway. Without any limits on height; limits on potentially large (coffin-sized) and noisy (cooling fans) cabinets for computer and batteries; or diesel generators on your sidewalk. The bill failed, thanks in large part to great work by the American Planning Association, The League of California Cities and the California State Association of Counties.</p><p>In the Spring of 2017, State Senator Ben Hueso (San Diego) introduced Senate Bill 649 (SB 649), which appears to allow wireless sites on private property and the public right of way (streets and sidewalks) with almost no discretion over issues like design, equipment noise, exhaust from backup diesel generators, aircraft lighting, or proximity of large cabinets to bedroom windows (when mounted on poles), or residential driveways, when mounted on the ground. The language appears to be written by AT&amp;T (Bill Devine), and Verizon (Reyes). <a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/sb-649-challenges-legislative-pitfalls-a61a4427651a">LINK TO ISSUES SPECIFIC TO SB 649</a><br> <br> <strong><em>Nonetheless, Small Cells…and “Not So Small Cells” are still headed your way (the public right-of-way). This is your crash course.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ECf5p5f9lRMGYyF08i1Cog.png" /><figcaption>Flyer depicting what AB 2788 would have allowed (without height limits), compared to a more realistic and pragmatic approach. The bill would have allowed brand new wood poles, just for cell antennas, and possibly accompanying diesel generators, on the ground (next to the pole) in front of your home.</figcaption></figure><ol><li><strong>Small Cells are definitely not all small.</strong> Some are:</li></ol><ul><li>Loud — <em>noisy cooling fans for computers (unless “passively cooled”).</em></li><li>Too tall — <em>up to 120 feet tall (see 3rd photo below).</em></li><li>Too large — Cabinets the size of <em>coffins or refrigerators, for computers and back-up batteries mounted on the sidewalk/lawn, or bulky cabinets mounted on the utility/light pole right in front of homes and bedroom windows</em>)<em>; and</em></li><li>Downright messy — <em>designs that sometimes look like they were put together at Radio Shack; if poorly designed (see photos below).</em></li><li>Dirty — <em>diesel generators for backup power.</em></li></ul><p>Small towns are not exempt from these challenges. Small Cells are likely headed your way (<em>especially if you have a downtown or highway that attracts tourists</em>). In fact, you may have accidentally already permitted them. See Item 2.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nAC3QCCDa_Zipvn6u6u5RA.jpeg" /><figcaption>New wood pole (holding up cell and microwave antennas) and equipment enclosures for a for a “Small Cell” (appears to be by “Mobilitie” for Sprint) in the public right of way (where all other electric/telephone/cable utilities are already undergrounded) in Woodbridge, Virginia. It appears this site (along with others in the County) was built without required permits.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>2. Small Cells Create New Challenges for Public Works. </strong>Instead of just placing large cell sites primarily on private property (<a href="http://celltowerphotos.com/thumbnails.php?album=3">towers in the middle of a ranch</a>) or <a href="http://sf-planning.org/sites/default/files/FileCenter/Documents/9393-WIRELESS%20PLANNING%20ADVISORY%20BULLETIN%203%20Best%20Practices%20for%20Micro%20WTS%20Facilities.pdf">hidden in fake vent pipes on rooftops of buildings</a>; wireless carriers are also pursuing sites in the “public right-of-way,” (PROW — streets &amp; sidewalks) which mostly means antennas and equipment on or next to either: existing wooden utility poles; City-owned light poles; or installing brand new poles just for wireless (generally disfavored).</p><p>While Small Cells offer less coverage/capacity (mobile data for hundreds of devices) than a large-scale rooftop cell site on private property; installing Small Cells in the PROW is often cheaper than leasing private property; provides a tool for carriers to provide mobile data faster/closer to customers in both dense urban areas and low-density residential neighborhoods; and is comparatively subject to less discretion by the City/County, due to State law governing the public right-of-way. However, a California State appeals court (<a href="http://www.fiercewireless.com/wireless/california-appeals-court-upholds-small-cells-ruling-against-t-mobile-crown-castle">T-Mobile/Extenet/Crown Castle versus CCSF</a>) recently re-affirmed ability of cities/counties to review (<em>with limited &amp; reasonable discretion</em>) wireless in the public right-of-way.</p><p>Since permitting for construction in the public right-of-way typically falls under permitting by a City/County Public Works Department (without automatic review by Planning Departments), ensure your Public Works staff keeps an eye out for encroachment permit requests that include antennas/dishes/modems or anything that does not sound like it belongs to an incumbent wireline (copper/fiber wires for landlines and cable companies) or electric provider. <br>Some companies use seemingly “confusing” business names like the “California Utility Pole Authority.” In one instance, an industry attorney told the audience of a 2013 wireless conference to tell Public Works staff members that they are installing telephone equipment; and to not reference terms such as: wireless, cellular, or antennas.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FlBW_vQRaclg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DlBW_vQRaclg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FlBW_vQRaclg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/bca094689fac52610172ec8741263494/href">https://medium.com/media/bca094689fac52610172ec8741263494/href</a></iframe><p>Small Cells will likely necessitate greater work across traditional boundaries between Planning Departments (<em>Design/Historic Preservation/Noise/Environmental Review</em>) and Public Works Departments (<em>encroachment permitting</em>). Along with potential involvement of electric utilities (<em>Power/Conduit/Fiber</em>) and pole-owning (Leases) agencies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*RsV3Uvzd-PosfScoLgFRqQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Do your current rules cover wireless in the public right-of-way? Or do they only cover wireless on private property (and City buildings/parks)?</figcaption></figure><p><strong>3. Your existing ordinances (rules) may not even cover Small Cells</strong></p><p>Determine if your existing wireless ordinance (<em>which typically only focused on cell antennas and towers on private property</em>) also covers wireless facilities in the public right-of-way.</p><p>Or, inquire if your City Attorney can make that determination that the existing ordinance already does.</p><p>This may be a challenge if a provision of your current Zoning Ordinance specifically says the Ordinance does not cover the right of way (for all development, not just wireless).</p><p>It may be best to adopt rules just for wireless in the public right-of-way, for now, and work on a cohesive ordinance that is up-to-date; and also covers private property when you have time.</p><ul><li>If an application is submitted for a facility that does not appear appropriate/complete/code-complying, then make absolutely sure to tell the carrier within 30 days, in writing (&amp; within 10 days of re-submittal). <em>Do not delay.</em></li><li>Your existing wireless ordinance may have been great; back in the 1990’s, but may actually be counterproductive now. See the last FAQ below for example reasons why.</li><li>You probably cannot “pause” an application that is new to your community, by just asking for a <strong>moratorium</strong>. Check with City/County counsel on the ramifications of AB 57, and the 2009/2014 FCC Broadband Orders. If possible, spend time adopting an urgency ordinance with actual standards, and not a moratorium.</li><li>Under a 2016 State law, <a href="https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201520160AB57">AB 57</a>, if a California City/County does not make a decision on a new wireless facility within either 90 days or 150 days (<a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-3-tips-on-crafting-ordinances-public-outreach-design-8c43a7db17db#.q8jkuwa19">Section 3</a>), then the site is <strong>automatically approved</strong>. Do not be in a position of having to explain a missed deadline and a new site being built, without review to your community.</li><li>Consider copying recent wireless ordinances, specific to the public right-of-way. Examples of recently updated ones include Rancho Palos Verdes, Ojai, Santa Barbara, San Francisco or San Diego. See <a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-3-tips-on-crafting-ordinances-public-outreach-design-8c43a7db17db#.q8jkuwa19">Section 3</a> for more.</li><li>Come up with clear application forms that are relevant. For example, figure out if you need: noise studies (<em>some sites have noisy cooling fans or generators</em>); habitat/wetlands clearance (if new poles/trenching) from State/Federal agencies; determinations of whether aircraft warning painting and lighting (this can apply to poles as short as 50 feet in some rural areas or near airports <a href="http://wirelessestimator.com/articles/2016/new-faa-rules-will-require-some-50-to-200-foot-towers-to-be-marked/">link</a>); consultation with local Native American tribes; proof of a coverage and/or capacity (mostly mobile data) gap.</li></ul><p>To be clear, wireless carriers CAN come up with well-designed and well-situated Small Cells, but it requires a concerted effort by the City/County to move in that direction.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*2W_nXvD_1a_d6ZCCODp3DA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Antenna on top of pole. Equipment is likely on the ground or underground. The box on the left looks more like an electrical transformer not tied to the Small Cell.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>4. Wireless Carriers may not build sites correctly, or with required permits. </strong>Make sure Planners or Public Works staff inspect sites. It is way too common for carriers to sneak in more equipment than allowed, install on the wrong pole, tear up concrete sidewalks and leave bumpy asphalt patches; or fail to live up to promises or conditions of approval (see FAQs below for examples of other “challenges”).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/710/0*qVI6Drr8V_vEflnO.jpg" /><figcaption>In Baltimore, Mobilitie (no relation to AT&amp;T Mobility) <strong><em>apparently</em></strong> installed a brand new pole on a new concrete base on the sidewalk (inset photo to right), without permits and was fined $5K.</figcaption></figure><p>Be clear that multiple violations will result in denial of all pending applications (or come up with specific fines), with no exceptions. Keep original photo simulation on hand, or better yet, require the photo sims to be copied onto the plan set, in legible format, so the contractors and City inspectors have no excuse for missing it. If the carrier builds a new site without any permits <strong><em>make them rip it out</em>.</strong> Do not let them legalize it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZTfPolDAixy3TsjDMUhO_g.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Why is this proposed 120-foot tall “Small Cell” so tall and so close to the residential driveways?</em></strong><em> It appears it is so that “Mobilitie”” (Sprint’s network partner — &amp; no relation to AT&amp;T Mobility) can save money by using microwave dishes to “talk” to the cell antennas on shorter poles nearby (see image further below). This means, unlike other wireless carriers, using microwave dishes instead of running fiber-optic cables for miles (below City streets or on existing wooden utility poles) for what is known as backhaul (backhaul = connecting your cell phone to the cell antennas and then ultimately back to the internet/switch center). Also, by placing the poles in the public right-of-way (road edges — some are proposed in front of homes along sidewalks/driveways), the deployment is generally rent-free (in California), instead of placement on private property, with leases running a few thousand a month on either existing multi-carrier (multiple antennas) steel towers, or building rooftops (hidden antennas) on private property. There is the significant concern that if a City allows this type of approach (towers, rent-free in the right-of-way), that the community could loose control of their public right of way. (e.g. more boxes to accidentally back into as you exit your home). Because these poles are not likely co-locatable; it means the other three major wireless carriers would need to install their own poles nearby, if they choose a similar path, in order to save money on fiber-optic backhaul. Plus, if this path was pursued by one wireless carrier, then one would wonder why other wireless carriers would think of continuing to paying a landlord (e.g. a church) to host multiple antennas on the same pole/rooftop, on private property, for multiple carriers (less-intrusive); when they can each put up their own poles, rent-free in the public right-of-way. Side note: in urban areas you may eventually see new microwave dishes (to backhaul data from new small cells nearby) show up on existing Sprint/Clearwire rooftop-mounted cell sites.</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>5. Carriers may propose brand new wood poles or really tall steel poles in the public right-of-way. </strong>If a carrier is proposing a whole new site/pole, then there is absolutely no reason you can’t require a cleaner design with antennas and equipment fully, or partially, hidden in a steel or composite pole (see photo examples further below); preferably within new street lighting over a dark alley or road curve.<strong> </strong>However if you do plan to say no to a certain design, you need to make your concerns known early on (within 30 days of first submittal and within 10 days of the re-submittal), and in writing! Tall (over 55 feet) poles in the PROW should generally be disfavored unless in a remote/rural location.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/322/1*zGS1FILkNzTJfXW2SAra3g.png" /><figcaption>New wood pole likely installed by Mobilitie, for Sprint, in Georgia. The boxes at the bottom appear to be computers and optional battery backup cabinets. It appears this site has more batteries than normal because the carrier could may not have been able to get electric power to the site. The round coffee can sized antenna on a side-arm above the battery cabinets appears to be a microwave relay so that the signal from your Sprint cell phone can connect to the antenna on top of the pole, and then the signal can travel through the microwave relay to microwave dishes on either a new 120-foot tall pole nearby, or an existing Sprint cell site on a rooftop within a few miles of the pole.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>6. Neighbors will be really upset. </strong>Neighbors will especially dislike ugly, noisy, and large systems on existing wooden utility poles (and boxes next to their driveway) that they already think give the neighborhood a 3rd world aesthetic, and should be removed (“undergrounding”).</p><p>They will also ask about the cumulative impact of multiple providers coming in nearyb once the first site is approved. They will want to know why carriers cannot install wireless facilities on roofs of office buildings or shopping centers instead. They may not understand the difference between a front yard they enjoy and what area of their yard constitutes the public right of way. This may lead to accusations that a carrier is trespassing on their property (<em>be prepared for phone calls to staff</em>).</p><p>Neighbors will typically be <strong>less</strong> upset if:</p><p>a) the systems are small and well-designed, and on a steel/concrete pole (<em>without the exposed brackets and cabling used on wood poles</em>); or inside an integrated pole (antennas/equipment hidden inside the pole);</p><p>b) it is clear on the permit form that the system does not create noticeable noise (if applicable) or light (indicator or aircraft warning);</p><p>c) it is clear there will not be any new above ground boxes taking over the sidewalk;</p><p>d) they are given a copy of the RF report, and it is clear that they can call a specific number for free RF testing in their own home;</p><p>e) they are told about the location of a mockup or example they can view;</p><p>f) they see that City/County staff explored better locations with the carrier early on; and</p><p>g) to put it candidly, they will be less upset if they sense that someone at the City/County actually gave a darn about what is being installed in their neighborhood and pushed for better placement and design.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/504/1*4ghJzIOG49Sa8_rK43PfUQ.png" /><figcaption>Bear in mind that the Federal rule (known as “6409”) on changes to existing cell sites (and the example change depicted above) does not apply if the City owns the actual pole. In California, most wooden poles are not owned by cities/counties; with the exception of some cities/counties with a municipal electric provider. Steel/concrete poles may be owned by either the City or the investor-owned electric utility (e.g. PG&amp;E, SCE, SDG&amp;E). The system on the left was built by NextG (Crown Castle) for Clearwire (Sprint). The system on the left was built by NextG (Crown Castle) for Verizon Wireless.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>7. The Federal rules (“6409”) on changes (modification) to Small Cells after they are built requires forethought for initially approval designs.</strong></p><p>For sites on poles not owned by the City/County, and also in the public right-of-way, a carrier can easily add 10 feet of height, six 6 foot horizontal arms, extra (bulky and noisy) equipment cabinets (on the pole) after the initial installation..</p><p>Simply put the carrier can take a well-designed site and make it look junky and noisy by using 6409.</p><p>For example,if equipment was also initially allowed on the ground, by the City/County, then more equipment (e.g. diesel generators for backup power, battery cabinets the size of coffins and computer cabinets) can also be added on the ground (hint: avoid any unscreened cabinets on the ground).</p><p>Keep in mind that factors like who owns the pole, and whether all the equipment is initially placed on the pole, or on the ground, or underground (instead of on top of the sidewalk) make a big difference years later.</p><p>It may not be appealing at first, but if the City, the carrier, and the electric utility work together to transfer the light pole (where Small Cells are proposed) from utility ownership to the City, then you can avoid a lot of future headaches (e.g. ugly/noisy equipment being added without much discretion due to “6409”), and get a better design. <a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-3-tips-on-crafting-ordinances-public-outreach-design-8c43a7db17db#.q8jkuwa19">See Part 3 for more information</a>.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FZ2CVy0unHvE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DZ2CVy0unHvE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FZ2CVy0unHvE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9c1c31027b56c5f3354c5e2d16ad4aa0/href">https://medium.com/media/9c1c31027b56c5f3354c5e2d16ad4aa0/href</a></iframe><p><strong>8. Wireless carriers may initially refuse to modify an unsuitable design, and have a tendency to provide inaccurate information. </strong>Cities and counties across California continue to see wireless carriers provide designs and photo simulations (<a href="https://nouglytowers.wordpress.com/">examples</a>) that feature inappropriately large antennas/equipment/enclosures and/or submittals that do not accurately show what is proposed. Be prepared to say no early on to bad designs.</p><p>In addition cities/counties continue to see an inconsistent ability to build or maintain sites correctly (e.g. adding equipment without review/permits).</p><p>Rancho Palos Verdes (near Long Beach) got so tired of what they felt were <a href="https://nouglytowers.wordpress.com/2016/07/15/crown-castle-catfishing/">inaccurate plans and photo simulations (example)</a>, by the neutral host carriers, that they now require a mockup to be built first, for the public to view.</p><p>In some instances neutral host carriers will tell City staff if they don’t approve quickly, they will just build sites on their own without permits.</p><p><strong>9. Carriers may proposed inappropriately large quasi-monopoles &amp; large equipment areas as “Small Cells.”</strong></p><p>It’s all about context. So, in a rural equestrian southwestern canyon context, perhaps it is best to leave only the antenna on the existing wooden utility pole and place all of the supporting equipment in fake wine/whiskey barrels (or behind some boulders) on the ground below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QU0X7mc9KPPkFZ1wRqMOIg.png" /><figcaption>The large cabinets on the ground were proposed on a nicely landscaped (undergrounded) main street in South Orange County. This is not an acceptable design. The antenna design is bit clunkier than needed (rounded radome with hidden GPS preferred).</figcaption></figure><p>In other contexts, such as a wider right-of-way in a suburban residential neighborhood; perhaps fake wood lattice fencing (<em>made of metal then textured and painted to match wood grain</em>) to screen equipment cabinets that are under 4 feet in height; along with berming of the soil, can do the trick.</p><p>Recently, Crown Castle and the City of Palo Alto explored using fake USPS mailboxes (the green relay ones not used by the public) to house the equipment and leave the antenna on the nearby pole, in downtown areas.</p><p>Generally, you have more ability to require undergrounding (below sidewalk placement) of large/bulky equipment (computers/batteries/meter/shutdown switch) if it is a nice streetscape without existing wooden utility poles. See example photo below. Carriers will fight you tooth and nail on placing equipment under sidewalks, but if it’s relatively large equipment and a nice and narrow undergrounded (no wood poles) street, without below-ground space conflicts, then you can probably prevail if you push hard and early (tell carrier within 30 days of submittal). <em>Oh, and you can’t place the antenna underground too. Just the equipment. The antenna needs to be above ground (</em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xqlAFHHyYME"><em>though there is an odd exception being trial’ed</em></a><em>) to work.</em></p><p>Carriers may also try to <a href="http://sumtercountyfl.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Item/8031?fileID=19264">claim</a> their monopoles are “not wireless facilities” and should be treated as utility structures (akin to poles for power lines). Reject this claim early, often, and in writing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wNq2qwB5kCcHmnxZKiooYA.png" /><figcaption>Example from Thousand Oaks (likely for Verizon Wireless). The antenna is on the basketball court light pole in the background. The bulk of the computers and batteries are underground. Carriers will say they will flood with water. That’s extremely rare. Plus, they make sump pumps anyways. Push for it…. Photo Credit: Oldcastle.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>10. Small Cells will require collaboration with Utility Providers and City/County/Transit Agencies. </strong>Try to work with your City Manager (or equivalent), pole owners, and the local electric utility, on steps (See Part 3) you can take to get a much better design; such as wireless metering (avoiding a graffiti-prone box with glass bubble meter on the sidewalk), forgoing disconnect switch boxes (line drops/fuses), and taking ownership of specific steel/concrete utility-owned light poles (<em>so that wireless carriers can’t use a Federal “6409” rule to make ugly/noisy equipment changes after the site is built</em>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*aATIAHI_2TyWNK3sHlqkqg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Small Cell Antenna in the box on top of the bus shelter (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VjQNB6RMv5E">JC Decaux Installation Video</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Also, consider working with the owners of bus shelters or regional transit agencies (e.g. poles that hold up overhead electric wires for light rail) to find more suitable locations and designs and avoid the push for brand new poles.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: These are my personal thoughts having worked as a City Planner in three California counties, and having conferred with many really bright Attorneys, City Planners and Public Works Engineers at plenty of other cities/counties. These perspectives are not representative of a specific City/County agency. I am not your City Attorney or County Counsel, so make sure to review applications, ordinances, and conditions with them.</em></p><h3>— — — — — — — — — NEXT STEPS — — — — — — — — —</h3><h4>Part 1 | Answers to Frequently Asked Questions by Elected Officials, Residents, and City Planners/Public Works (<em>see below</em>)</h4><h4><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-2-example-photos-of-the-good-the-bad-and-the-downright-ugly-ea483f83fe7#.8s3jlk5h8">Part 2 | Example photos of the good, the bad and the downright ugly </a>(draft)</h4><h4><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-3-tips-on-crafting-ordinances-public-outreach-design-8c43a7db17db#.q8jkuwa19">Part 3 | Tips on Crafting Ordinances, Public Outreach</a> (draft)</h4><h4><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-4-design-tips-for-small-cells-based-on-pole-or-location-type-draft-5f8814f8be6d#.uofz4889s"><strong>Part 4 | Design Tips Based on Pole or Location Type (draft)</strong></a></h4><h3>Answers to Some Frequently Asked Questions</h3><p><strong>Will wireless carriers abandon their efforts to build, or continue to operate existing larger (“macro”) antennas on either building rooftops, faux trees, or tall steel towers; and just put up Small Cells instead?</strong></p><p>No. Wireless carriers still need those for overall coverage (think mostly voice calls) since Small Cells have a limited range (due to lower mounting heights and lower power levels). <br>The industry trend is known as a “HetNet” (Heterogeneous Network); that uses Macro (large) sites (rooftops and big towers), outdoor Small Cells, and Indoor Small Cells all working together to provide not just voice coverage, but to also provide faster data speeds for things like mobile video.</p><p>However, there are always tradeoffs. Small Cell designs require more overall sites, but may be nearly rent-free (or a few hundred dollars a year depending on who owns the pole) if placed in the public right-of-way. Larger rooftop-mounted “Macro” sites, for example, can cover much wider areas, but site leases can range from $1,500 to $6,000 a MONTH, and approach $9,000+ in some prime urban/tourist-oriented areas.</p><p>Apart from leasing costs, in single-family neighborhoods, there may not be available locations (viable 3+ story apartment/office rooftops, church bell towers) for rooftop sites; which in turn drives interest by carriers to use Small Cells in the public right-of-way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T_C9kMc2OB4vWOZE3wp_Rw.jpeg" /><figcaption>This proposal by Mobilitie in Oregon appears to be intended to a) be nearly rent-free by virtue of placement on a sidewalk, in the public right-of-way, instead of on private property; b) designed to provide signal to other future Small Cells (likely for Sprint). For reasons noted earlier, this is a very problematic proposal.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WiFlAXovRWfxGOynO-Ro5Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>This photo simulation appears to show a proposed new wood pole and Small Cell, for Sprint, by Mobilitie in a residential neighborhood. The photo simulation seems inadequate in that it fails to clearly convey the cluttered nature of the actual design (given the installations seen in Los Angeles). A design like this seems like a poor choice and alternatives should be pursued such as attaching equipment to existing light poles or requiring a new steel streetlight pole on a nearby collector street (or blank corner) with more of the cabling inside the pole and a more streamlined design. It is also possible that photo simulations such as this neglect to include new overhead power lines running to the pole (unless it is clear that underground power cables will be brought to the pole).</figcaption></figure><p><strong>What are the types of challenges cities/counties face, when it comes to neutral host carriers (e.g. Crown Castle, Extenet Systems, Mobilitie and Zayo [new entrant])?</strong></p><p>Glad you asked. Here are some examples:</p><p>Carrier representative shops around photo simulations to City leadership (and/or municipal pole-owning agency) during initial leasing discussions (well in advance of permit submittals) that are misleading in that they do not show known required equipment (cabling, brackets, boxes on sidewalks, meters, RF stickers, GPS antennas) that may be needed/requested. You later realize that the actual intended design appears sloppy. <a href="https://nouglytowers.wordpress.com/">Example of residents calling out seemingly deceptive design submittals</a>.</p><p>Carrier never talks to the City and instead goes to the State (CPUC) for a CEQA Categorical Exemption (environmental review clearance). They then start installing new wood poles in known/potential Native American burial grounds next to residences, without any review. <em>Yes, this happened….</em></p><p>Carrier proposes large equipment boxes on the sidewalk in locations that would fail to meet basic wheelchair accessibility clearance rules.</p><p>Carrier submittals make little sense such as location maps with new poles proposed in the middle of ponds and on footbridges. <em>Yes…this happens.</em></p><p>Carrier makes the design of whatever modification staff requested look so bulky and ugly on the mockup, that they try to make it seem infeasible.</p><p>Carrier claims a strong desire to work with the community and constantly asks for meetings. Carrier then turns in plans and photo simulations noting the wrong pole locations, or unclear applications (<em>e.g. you can’t tell if a new pole is being added next to an existing pole, or if an existing pole is being used</em>). You will also encounter plans and photo simulations that do not match each other; and designs that are inappropriate (overly bulky boxes or antennas the size of trashcans on slim light poles).</p><p><em>FYI: Carriers will try to budge you in meetings to make decisions on the spot. Make sure you are comfortable making that decision then and there. If not, talk to your stakeholders first (counsel, pole owners, preservation/environmental, Planners or Public Works). Carrier reps may make veiled references at lawsuits by mentioning how their peers in “dark rooms” may have a problem with what the City/County is requesting. Remind them that the local utility may offer cost-saving LED light bulbs that may help brighten their rooms….</em></p><p>Carrier agrees to a design, and to conditions of approval requiring new City/County review if changes are sought after installation; but then makes changes to the site on their own accord, without review, or even claims oral permission (when none existed) to make unauthorized changes (e.g. adding larger antenna shrouds, fiber patch panel boxes, or disconnect switches).</p><p>Carrier agrees to conditions to turn off or hide indicator lights (<em>which detract from nighttime ambiance in residential enclaves</em>), add covers to hide bundles of cabling, and remove large stickers or decals; but then fails to do so.</p><p>Carrier constantly requests meetings or feedback on design but neglects to fully respond to issues raised previously. <em>Always keep a running check list so you do not forget an item. If you forget, the carrier rep may try to bully you later on claiming the City/County is the cause of delays.</em></p><p>Carrier claims it is too hard to satisfy both Planning, Public Works, and the pole-owning agency with their different requirements. Bear in mind, that is often without basis. Though, do make sure if some of poles hold up overhead electric lines (for light rail or buses) or have other special functions, that the pole owning agencies review the designs. Especially, the placement of entry holes for conduit to be placed inside the pole (have the carrier prepare structural calcs that take into account equipment and conduit entry points).</p><p>Carrier tells you they want to work with the community, but refuses to say which carrier they are putting up antennas for. This doesn’t tend to happen much in California and may make it harder for the carrier to sue (<em>since they may need to show a coverage/capacity gap for a given carrier’s network</em>). Make sure to remind the carrier it’s “not really working with the community” (a phrase they often use) if City/County staff has to spend hours on the phone with residents wanting to understand the reason for apparent secrecy or why the plans and photo simulations are not accurate (e.g. design, equipment sizes, or distance between dwelling). Ideally, the name of the actual wireless carrier being served should be easily shown on the front of the project plans or permit notification.</p><p>Carrier pushes really big and ugly boxes, but pretends they are small, and act really offended when you point out the obvious. They tend to say your ordinance is illegal a lot too or doesn’t comply with 6409 (<em>which doesn’t apply to new cell sites; just project sites with existing cell sites that were legally built</em>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wFqqAY1WHgn5iWD0MwtsSg.png" /><figcaption>It’s not uncommon for the carrier to ignore staff direction and submit sites to the wrong agency. Don’t let a design like this happen to you. Courtesy <a href="https://nouglytowers.wordpress.com/">https://nouglytowers.wordpress.com/</a></figcaption></figure><p>Carrier may have a middle management culture that says push back against whatever the City/County asks for; even if it is reasonable.</p><p>Carrier hires a local permit expediter that you are familiar with, but as soon as something goes wrong, they shift blame to him/her and you don’t see them again. Now you are forced to repeat guidance (hang onto notes/checklists) to new reps.</p><p>Carriers subcontractors are hit and miss, with some building sites correctly and others tearing up sidewalks or topping trees. If you approve large batches of permits all at once the carrier is more likely to rush and hire new sub contractors that are more likely to build sites poorly.</p><p>Carrier gets caught not building new sites on existing non-City owned poles correctly. They responded by hinting/threatening they could build the site to “look correct” (to get the permit final) and then come back and “6409” it, in order to make it look as ugly as they want with extra equipment boxes and visible cabling. <em>That is not allowed. A carrier can’t “6409” a site that was not built correctly (if you pay attention and call them on it).</em></p><p>All three neutral host carriers (I haven’t heard much about <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/gr4guhuzzcbpjf1/Zayo%20Small%20Cells.pdf?dl=0">Zayo; though their initial designs appear fairly cluttered/bulky</a>) have varying histories of adding sites without permits, building incorrectly, or sometimes just plain upsetting neighbors (e.g. topping beautiful trees to run fiber-optic cables to small cells, or telling neighbors to buzz off when they ask to view their permit).</p><p>Carrier reminded repeatedly to not put in place bumpy asphalt patches when breaking up a concrete sidewalk to add a small vault. Weeks later, elderly resident start calling City staff to indicate they tripped over bumpy asphalt.</p><p>Carrier claimed the need to increase the height of short wood light poles by 12 to 20 feet, based on GO 95 (State safety rules). In an area of the City known for beautiful and historic single-family homes with scenic views. Staff disputed this height justification. When carrier later pushed the issue within the context of Shot Clocks, staff denied about 14 sites. The next day, the carrier asked for a pause on denials and came back with a design without the height increase.</p><p>Carrier submits plans and RF safety report that has conflicting information, such as the distance between the pole and the nearest residential wall. This can result in an upset resident who feels the process is sloppy and false assurances are being made.</p><p>In Houston, a neutral host wireless carrier, apparently asked for a permit to install a new wooden pole to only hold up fiber-optic cables. They then came back and added cell antennas and equipment without telling the City (<em>in Texas, cities/counties can charge rent to carriers being in the right-of-way, even if the City/County does not own the pole</em>). In other cities, another neutral host carrier installed multiple new sites on sidewalks or in front of businesses, apparently without any permits.</p><p>Carrier and City discuss having carrier provide fiber-optic cable to City at poles where Small Cells are installed (for things like City public Wi-Fi), but it turns out the fiber-optic was never going to be installed back to any viable junction point and just go from the pole to the sidewalk box a few feet away. However, carrier still notes in forums that the City is being given fiber, when no such fiber is actually being provided (at all).</p><p>Carrier reminded by Planner that a certain type of review is required (e.g a specific historic preservation application) but they neglect to file in a timely manner. Months later, they contest the review not being applicable, by arguing the historic preservation commission review does not apply because the applicable historic districts only includes the buildings and not the public right-of-way (streets/sidewalks) inside the district (incorrect). <em>Remember to indicate review is required for these types of situations in your ordinance and application forms.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/483/1*Fu1l5PwdIMijADUFezE4xA.png" /><figcaption><em>What was actually approved</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*_A1a4JPLgW9pp7nnjvk1Vw.png" /><figcaption><em>What the neutral host carrier built (antennas &amp; equipment for two distinct wireless carriers), over time, without proper permits (Crown Castle for Verizon &amp; Sprint).</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Aren’t you being a bit “pointed” toward the wireless carriers?</strong></p><p>Nope. There are many smart and talented folks in the industry that follow through on picking less-intrusive locations/designs, and on building sites “right.”</p><p>There are also examples of designs/installations akin to something put together from the parts bin at the back of a Radio Shack (e.g.wild tangles of cabling). There are also some carrier reps that create frustrations for both staff and the community, by conveying incorrect information (<em>funny response by the City of Santa Clara: </em><a href="http://www.tinyurl.com/attsiliconvalley"><em>www.tinyurl.com/attsiliconvalley</em></a>) to residents and/or Federal/State government leaders (<a href="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/880/1*Ui9mVTgJIAVbK-MLeil8yA.png">example</a>), in order to try and gut local community review and common-sense siting/design. They make it harder for the more responsible actors who don’t cut corners.</p><p>Carriers will often note the need to work with communities, but absent from those discussions seems to be the need to work on neighborhood-appropriate siting by working with both the community and the actual antenna/equipment manufacturers on well-designed and quiet systems (which is achievable).</p><p><strong>I thought we were getting satellites and would not need towers and small cells.</strong> Not happening anytime soon. You can’t wait for <a href="https://www.solveforx.com/loon/">Google Loon Project Balloons</a> either.</p><p>Did you update your ordinance yet?</p><p><strong>Can we just ban Small Cells in our really beautiful residential zones or historic districts? </strong>Not easy to do in California (especially if you have existing wooden utility poles). For some background from a wireless industry lawyer perspective (not my perspective) read this article (<a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">link</a>).</p><p>There are two important State and Federal court cases that affirmed that a City/County can a) exercise <strong>some reasonable </strong>discretion over design/siting; b) can apply CEQA (environmental review); and b) can apply 10-year time limits to permits.</p><p>See the <a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">Palos Verdes case</a> that is referenced in the wireless industry perspective and, and <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/sh/atpenpk78ate738/AABkqbgoO4ca10z5c5xlOs-Ca?dl=0">T-Mobile/Crown Castle/Extenet Systems versus City and County of San Francisco</a> (legal docs).</p><p>In September 2016 a California (State) Appeals Court ruled in favor (<a href="http://www.fiercewireless.com/wireless/california-appeals-court-upholds-small-cells-ruling-against-t-mobile-crown-castle">article link</a>) of San Francisco (<em>and all California cities and counties</em>), and upheld the right for cities/counties to exercise reasonable discretion over design (“design” being inclusive of aesthetics, equipment noise, lighting [aircraft warning/indicator lights], specific placement, streetscape plans) of wireless in the public right-of-way.</p><p>The City and County of San Francisco and the League of California Cities (which filed a friend of the court brief) were NOT arguing for the ability to outright ban cell sites (Small Cells or oDAS) in the public right-of-way; but for the ability to have <em>reasonable discretion</em> over location and design (e.g. new excessively tall wood poles, large cabinets next to windows, noise limits, archeological review).</p><p><strong>Can our City/County charge rent or require a franchise?</strong></p><p>Yes and No.</p><p>You can charge rent for attaching antennas/equipment to Small Cells on City-owned poles or structures (e.g. bus shelters, kiosks, street furniture). If your lucky enough to have City-owned fiber (or own the conduit that the fiber is placed in) you should be able to charge rent for that too (e.g. Silicon Valley Power in Santa Clara).</p><p>In California, a City or County cannot charge rent or require a franchise for Small Cells in the public right-of-way (unless on City owned poles/structures); even if new equipment boxes are being proposed on the ground. This is due to State Law (California Public Utilities Code Section 7901). There may be some exceptions for Port lands and other unique districts.</p><p><em>If you work for a City/County outside of California then there are some important exceptions that may allow your City/County to require a franchise and/or charge rent. </em><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/part-3-tips-on-crafting-ordinances-public-outreach-design-8c43a7db17db#.q8jkuwa19"><em>See Part 3</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*Qyxsop8c8PuWP34_XVWCcQ.png" /><figcaption><a href="http://www.fiercewireless.com/wireless/fcc-must-walk-a-fine-line-convincing-municipalities-to-embrace-small-cells">Two FCC Commissioners have mentioned very isolated instances of cities charging what may be considered high fees as reason to propose either punishing cities or capping what rates they can charge for permits and for leases (if City owns the pole).</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/712/1*m4zYuTSLrzaX5JLeMswa3Q.png" /><figcaption><a href="http://www.fiercewireless.com/wireless/fcc-must-walk-a-fine-line-convincing-municipalities-to-embrace-small-cells">Article Link</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>But, hold on, what about franchising? We still use franchises for cable companies? <br></strong><a href="http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/General.aspx?id=2134">DIVCA</a> kinda killed it. It’s complicated. Ask your City Attorney/County Counsel. In California you cannot charge rent, just for a carrier “being in the public right of way.” You can charge rent for being on actual City property (e.g. parks) or on City-owned poles or buildings.</p><p><strong>The lawyer or carrier rep is threatening to sue if we deny the application, but we think we have realistic standards and the design is ugly. What do we do?</strong> <br>Talk your counsel. Also, consider writing up a denial letter that notes: a) your efforts to find a solution; b) the applicable community context (e.g. streetscape designations and vistas of significance noted in the City/County General Plan); and c) perhaps include as an attachment to the denial letter, a photo of a well-designed Small Cell built in another community that would be viable. <em>Take control of the narrative.</em></p><p><strong>What is the difference between AT&amp;T Mobility, T-Mobile, Sprint, Verizon Wireless; and these other companies like Crown Castle (they bought NextG/Newpath), Extenet Systems, and Mobilitie?</strong> <br>The last three are sometimes referred to as Neutral Host Carriers, that often put up Small Cells, and Not So Small Cells, on poles to serve the networks of the first four carriers (which are referred to as Tier 1 PCS carriers — PCS stands for Personal Communications Services).</p><p>A fiber-optic provider, Zayo, also appears interested in developing Small Cells to serve the 4 Tier 1 PCS Carriers. The initial designs (<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/gr4guhuzzcbpjf1/Zayo%20Small%20Cells.pdf?dl=0">images</a>) seem fairly poorly designed with exposed cabling, bulky cabinets that should be longer and narrower, and panel antennas instead of slim radomes.</p><p>Neutral Host Carriers like to tell City/County folks they are different (and somehow less subject to City regs, in so many words) than Tier 1 carriers, because they are “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competitive_local_exchange_carrier">CLEC</a>,” transport provider, carrier’s carrier, or flux capacitor interlocutor (just kidding). Or, they will say they are not a wireless carrier, “but just transporting signal.”</p><p>Mobilitie has been using various names like “the Utility Pole Authority” and “CA Transmission Network” or “Interstate Transport and Broadband” to make themselves sound like either a general electric utility or something other than wireless.</p><p><em>It’s all wireless in the “cell phone sense” for the immediate future…..</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8ypiCGTvdrvkCeRgMNdo4Q.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.cnet.com/news/at-t-plans-to-offer-super-fast-internet-using-power-lines/">AT&amp;T’s Project AirGig would attach antennas onto power lines to send data signals around the wires, instead of through them. From CNET.com</a>. In California the antennas/dishes would need to be at least 8 feet above electrical lines. Plus given the poor state of many Joint Poles, the poles would need to be replaced. This approach is considered “wireless fiber” (instead of new high speed fiber optic “wires” directly to the home/business. It has certain limits such as capacity and may not be subject to the same State rules on consumer rate protection or universal service (serving both rich and poor/rural neighborhoods) that apply to wireline systems. When you see round dishes think of it as more of a focused beam of information being sent to another dish somewhere else (usually to serve internet access directly to another site/customer), and NOT to send a signal out to hundreds of cell phones nearby.</figcaption></figure><p>There are other wireless providers coming on the scene like Google/Webpass/Artemis/<a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/s/601442/wireless-super-fast-internet-access-is-coming-to-your-home/">Starry</a> (that are mostly focused on antennas for in-building broadband to compete with the cable company).</p><p>There are also Internet Of Things (IOT) Providers (e.g.<a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/aarontilley/2015/10/27/samsung-backed-sigfox-has-built-a-wireless-network-for-the-internet-of-things-in-san-francisco-plans-coverage-of-10-us-cities-by-early-2016/#75a9989b6504"> Sigfox)</a> that seek low power networks (smaller systems) to serve devices, like sensors, instead of cell phones. Example of a separate trial long-range IOT network (<a href="https://hackernoon.com/loras-wireless-range-is-bananas-a-first-look-at-cellular-for-iot-in-san-francisco-d5298eec42f3#.w9ylh8sq1">link</a>).</p><p>Some aspects of what these “other” wireless providers are proposing may fall into this interesting regulatory challenge of proposing commercial neighborhood-serving small low-power antennas/dishes on residential buildings (<em>where most City ordinances disfavor or prohibit commercial neighborhood-serving wireless facilities</em>), but that are not quite <a href="https://www.fcc.gov/media/over-air-reception-devices-rule">OTARD-compliant</a> (which are typically <em>exempt from most local permitting, by the FCC, except based on historic preservation or safety issues</em>).</p><p>It should be noted that these systems are typically far less intrusive, in terms of power output, and antenna/equipment size; as compared to the systems used for Tier 1 PCS (the four main wireless carriers).</p><p><strong>It’s already hard enough trying to deal with the 150 day shot clock in terms of getting a comment letter out in about 20–30 days and then needing 20–30 days to notify neighbors and hold a public hearing. Now the carrier is trying to argue that putting antennas on an existing pole should be subject to a 90 day shot clock, as a collocation. What do we do?</strong></p><p>Talk to your counsel. Most City Attorneys disagree with this recent push by Verizon/Crown (thus far) which have recently tried to argue that if there is an existing building or utility pole (without existing antennas) that it counts as a collocation and is eligible for the 90 day shot clock. It appears they are cherry picking various FCC Orders, but ignoring a 2009 FCC Order on Shot Clocks that explicitly said the 90 day clock applies to more limited instances.</p><p>Nonetheless, if your City/County requires public hearings (with advanced mailed notification to property owners), you have a timing challenge. Especially if you require both a design review public hearing and a formal Planning Commission public hearing.</p><p>If the carrier submits a design that is both incomplete and poorly designed and then re-submits a complete application but with a poor design, you’ll need to tell the carrier, within 10 days, in writing that the design is not viable and you’ve scheduled a public hearing within 4 weeks to deny the application. The carrier can VOLUNTARILY offer to extend the shot clock, if they want to avoid a denial. You can’t demand that they do so.</p><p><strong>But my residents will get really upset about cell antennas in residential neighborhoods. Can we do anything? </strong>Well you could work to change CPUC Section 7901 (State Law) by educating State Assembly members and State Senators about how an outdated law on telegraph lines (<a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">background article</a>) is essentially being used by the wireless industry to <strong>sometimes try to </strong>force bulky noisy cabinets within a few feet of bedroom windows (<em>the two court rulings that sided with cities/counties focused on how the cell site would affect the view up and down the street segment and not necessarily the view from adjacent bedroom windows</em>).</p><p>In the meantime, work to articulate less-intrusive siting, design (so it doesn’t look like a cell tower to most folks) and placement standards (such as focusing on arterial and collector roads instead of poles right in front of a house). Empower your Planners and Public Works folks to demand better.</p><p>Encourage/require carriers to pursue arterial or collector road locations first instead of along two-lane residential streets. Look to your General Plan Circulation Element for metrics to consider using.</p><p>Work toward better design (aesthetics/noise/proximity to vistas and existing trees). Articulate a vision that shows you give a darn.</p><p>In the long term, if you really want to be bold, come up with a program to encourage residents to create an assessment district (yes, more property taxes), combined with a surcharge on electric bills (San Diego did this) and some general fund monies to underground utility poles; especially in neighborhoods with few rooftop-mounted cell sites nearby (most likely candidates for Small Cells other than downtowns). Then, you could have more discretion over the placement of better designed Small Cells on City owned steel light poles.</p><p><strong>I’m a Planner/Public Works Engineer. My City Attorney (or County Counsel) is awesome, but she/he said they are too busy to write an ordinance.</strong></p><p>Consider reviewing the ordinance and application forms noted on Section 3 and suggestion possible ways to adapt those ordinances to your City/County. Why reinvent, when you can adapt and evolve.</p><p><strong>I’m a State Assembly Member or State Senator. How do I encourage wireless deployment at the State level in a common-sense manner, but not suffer a backlash?</strong></p><p>If the legislature wishes to assist in this endeavor they should consider basic legislation to remove unnecessary impediments and reduce clutter on Small Cells, by mandating that investor-owned utilities allow smart wireless metering and hidden disconnect switches; thereby reducing clutter in the form of more boxes on sidewalks/poles. Simple measures like this can help cities and counties and wireless carriers find smarter solutions that balance beautiful neighborhoods and robust wireless coverage.</p><p>Furthermore, the legislature should work with the police &amp; fire first-responder community, and State agencies and independent districts (e.g. community colleges and water districts) to find smarter siting locations and designs for “police and fire 5G wireless” (FirstNet); so that we can avoid the recent LA-RICS debacle (tall steel towers next to fire stations in LA County).</p><p><strong>In my town the residential building lots/parcels run to the centerline of the street (not the back of the sidewalk or curb) with an easement for the public right-of-way. Can we say no to Small Cells on that basis?</strong>Probably not. Ask your counsel.</p><p><strong>In our town some of the residential neighborhoods feature wooden utility poles that are literally running through peoples backyards, without an alley separating their yard from the back yard of the home to the rear. Will wireless carriers try to enter peoples backyards to add Small Cells on these utility poles?</strong></p><p>It’s possible. I would recommend either banning Small Cells in those locations (in writing, in your ordinance, for everyone to see), or, at a minimum prohibit any Small Cells in those locations if they include noise-generating equipment (e.g. cooling fans for some types of computers known as radio heads).</p><p><strong>Why do we see such confusing or low-quality submittals/installations?</strong> <strong>Heck, my Planners work with non-profit groups that give us better quality submittals!</strong></p><p>Here’s the thing; there are often four layers of subcontractors between you and the actual brand name wireless carrier. These subs often get paid on pay points, like when they turn in an application; but not based on the quality of the application. So you often have to wade through poor quality submittals. If you keep seeing this (e.g. false RF reports, plans and photo simulations that are deceptive or inconsistent) do not be afraid to call them out on it and to tell the actual “brand name” wireless carrier representative.</p><p>When permits get approved in bulk the carriers race to hire contractors. It’s not uncommon to see 4 of 5 contractors do a great job and the 5th one tearing up sidewalks, putting in sloppy wiring designs, and failing to follow through on conditions of approval (e.g. proper painting of system to blend in with pole or backdrop). Spot check their work !</p><p>Oh, and remember the shot clock (time limit before auto approval) can be “paused” if the application is incomplete and you tell the carrier why it is incomplete in a timely manner (30 days for first submittal and 10 days for re-submittal). The shot clock cannot be paused because the submittal is complete but the design is not viable/appropriate/code-complying. See Section 3 for more information.</p><p><strong>If three of four wireless carriers in my area have good service and fast data, isn’t that enough to deny other carriers?</strong></p><p>Nope. Did you update your ordinance yet?</p><p><strong>Are these examples common throughout California or is this only stuff the author dealt with</strong>? <br>Yes, these issues occur in both rural counties and big cities.</p><p><strong>What is the difference between Small Cells and Distributed Antenna Systems?</strong></p><p>They are essentially the same with respect to the use of antennas, cabling, and equipment to provide wireless coverage. However, Small Cells are intended to function more as miniature versions of independent free-standing cell towers.</p><p>Outdoor Distributed Antenna Systems (also referred to as “DAS” or “oDAS”) are more common in California; and typically feature small antenna and cabinets mounted on multiple poles in a given neighborhood that all work together to provide coverage/capacity. I tend to refer to ugly/bulky systems as “oDAS XL.”</p><p><em>If you are an RF engineer or wireless carrier reading this, please bear in mind this is not meant to be a technical standards discussion…</em></p><p><strong>What are Indoor Small Cells?</strong> <br>Notice how the glass in those shiny new buildings seems to insulate better? That “low-e” glass also blocks outdoor cell site signals from reaching into the building. Carriers will add small antennas (indoor Small Cells, indoor Distributed Antenna Systems, or “iDAS”), akin to Wi-Fi antennas inside the building. Sometimes they will connect the system via fiber optic cables to their data center. Other times they will place a small donor antenna or microwave dish (<em>Verizon sometimes calls it a radio packet antenna for reasons I do not understand</em>) on the roof to “talk” to the nearest macro cell site. Usually these aren’t an issue as long as they comply with historic preservation rules on placement. Make sure the permit clearly notes this is for an indoor-serving on-site iDAS system only. Don’t give it collocation status unnecessarily.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*oQugW2Beu7y6dWvk.jpg" /><figcaption>Indoor Small Cell (akin to Wi-Fi antennas, but serving cell phones)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>This is giving me a headache.</strong> <br>True. Did you update your ordinance yet?</p><p><strong>Should I hold a study session for my Historic Preservation/Planning Commission, Design Review Board and City Counsel</strong>?</p><p>Yes, you should. Heck, invite the public and the wireless carriers to the initial session and then hold a closed-door session for your counsel to provide legal advice afterwards.</p><p><strong>What kind of rent should we charge for Small Cells on City owned poles?</strong></p><p>I’m not an appraiser. Find an expert.</p><p>My sincere “guesstimate” is to figure out the average yearly lease for a rooftop “macro” cell site in your area and divide it by 12 (<em>rough approximation of the number of Small Cells needed to provide similar coverage/capacity as a single “prime” rooftop macro site</em>). So in a dense urban area, $4K a year seems fair, assuming the systems are small and there is no additional equipment on the ground next to the pole (charge more for that).</p><p>I’m not a fan of just depending on the carrier to report gross revenues and provide a percentage. Especially if the company isn’t publicly traded and subject to outside audits.</p><p><strong>Will 4G/5G replace the cable company for broadband?</strong> <br>Sorta, but actually not really. A single fiber optic “strand” (cable) has enough capacity as the entire wireless spectrum. You can’t really serve a neighborhood with just “cellular” antennas to provide robust broadband, so that multiple folks can stream Netflix at high resolution in the house. Carriers are trying to get there, but there are limits, and the musing is that to do so would require thousands of antennas 150 feet from every residence. At that point, your not really saving money compared to running fiber to the home/business.</p><p><strong>Is the cable company trying to become a wireless carrier too?</strong></p><p>Sorta. It’s complicated.<a href="http://www.fiercewireless.com/wireless/charter-s-ceo-we-haven-t-activated-mvno-deal-verizon-yet"> Comcast and Charter (cable companies) are activating agreements with Verizon to use their network but under the cable companie’s name/brand (mobile virtual network operator, or “MVNO”)</a>. You will likely see more cable companies attaching cable strand Wi-Fi antennas/modems on above-ground wires between wooden utility poles. At one time, a proposed State law sought to exempt these antennas from any local review.</p><p>This would’t be a concern except the bill seemed poorly written in that it attempted to unfairly discriminate between Wi-Fi (using unlicensed spectrum) and Tier 1 PCS (cellular, using licensed spectrum). Plus more powerful systems may require boxes on the nearby pole (meters/disconnect/battery back up cabinets) and some have needless flashing lights.</p><p><strong>Why do wireless carriers keep talking about 911 access when we already have darn good call coverage?</strong></p><p>It’s part of their PR playbook. They’ll still bring it up even when there is a macro site and another small cell site within a few dozen yards of each other. Ignore it. Focus on crafting good policy.</p><p><strong>What is FirstNet and should I care?</strong></p><p>Good question. After 9/11 Congress mandated a first responder public safety network that was capable of advanced voice and data services. The standards sought to emulate those of 4G cellular networks. This creates a challenge of more antennas, closer to residential neighborhoods, instead of just using “whip” antennas on remote hilltop sites, for example. In LA County, the proposal to add tall steel monopoles at fire stations in residential neighborhoods met with substantial resistance. It remains to be seen if the State of California opts out and builds its own system or aligns with a Federal system.</p><p>If the Federal authority (part of NTIA under Department of Commerce) chooses to use a sort of virtual private network model running on the same towers as a carrier like AT&amp;T Mobility or Verizon; you may see increased pressure by the carrier, with the FirstNet contract, to build more sites or expand existing sites (more antennas or computer cabinets at an existing cell site).</p><p>Ideally, the State will work with State agencies (e.g. Caltrans) and independent districts (e.g. community college districts) to create more flexible siting for FirstNet systems so there is less pressure to put up new tall monopoles in residential or historic neighborhoods.</p><p><strong>Can we use the Small Cell installation to improve fire/police radio coverage?</strong></p><p>Maybe, but it’s complicated. Talk to your Police/Fire Departments and the regional authority (e.g. groups like <a href="http://www.la-rics.org/qa-for-la-rics/">LA RICS</a>) about what their needs are. In urban areas, the primary challenge nowadays tends to be indoor radio coverage (especially in parking structures) so outdoor Small Cells for Tier 1 PCS won’t help too much (fire and police radios use different signals). However, there may still be some opportunity to share fiber-optic backhaul, or put up signal boosters on the same pole as the Small Cell, for outdoor coverage.</p><p>Many police and fire agencies use their own radios (land-mobile radio or “LMR”) for voice communications, but they may also use laptops/tablets inside vehicles, with “cellular” modems running off the Tier 1 PCS networks. So Small Cells could assist with faster data speeds for those laptops, if the City is contracted with the same carrier. If not already in place, you may also want to discuss priority signal access for those modems, with the Tier 1 PCS carrier.</p><p><strong>While my City Council is interested in wireless antennas for cellular, but they are also asking about how a local business or non-profit cannot get in-building broadband for their high-tech manufacturing, or video conferencing for health seminars. Can our ordinance or City leasing help with this issue too?</strong></p><p>Possibly. While really high capacity/fast broadband generally means fiber-optic cable running into the building (and cellular systems cannot really provide the same capacity or reasonable costs); there is another tool to consider.</p><p>For example, a City/County could lease out existing rooftop or tower space, not just for cell antennas, but also for WISPs (Wireless Internet Service Providers) that use small microwave dishes (the size of pie tins) to “shoot” a very narrow and focused data feed from one location with strong internet connectivity to the roof of a business a few miles away that doesn’t have adequate broadband service from the telephone or cable provider. This isn’t a massive Citywide solution, but it can be a tool especially to retain a business (read: share this with your economic development folks) or assist non-profits and affordable housing sites when it comes to reliable and affordable broadband. Side note, from a Planning perspective, these dishes can often be set back further from the roof edge than cell antennas, so you typically don’t have the same aesthetic or historic preservation concerns.</p><p><a href="http://gigcommunities.net/cruzio-siklu-partner-to-bring-hybrid-wireless-gigabit-services-santa-cruz/">Example from Santa Cruz using fiber (wires) and microwave dishes (WISPs) to improve broadband competition, reliability, and affordability.</a></p><p>Tip: Ensure your City/County Real Estate Department adjusts the rates (typically lower) for WISPs instead of using the same rates for cellular. Especially since WISPs typically have very small footprints, compared to some cell sites with large roof footprints and equipment areas about the size of a shipping container.</p><p><strong>The wireless industry attorney showed up and scared my Counsel/Board/Commission, by saying our ordinance violates Federal or State law?</strong> <br>Their job is to advocate for their client. Come up with sensible rules that are fair and realistic. Provide comments on submittals that are clear and consistent within 30 days of submittal. You’ll be fine.</p><p>Carriers constantly say they will sue on things that seem pointless. Other times they will sue and get the approval judgement but never build the site. They just wanted to make a point to other municipalities. I’ve seen the lawyers “get ahead” of the carrier and threaten to sue, when the actual in-house carrier representative often wants to find a solution in the end. Sometimes the local carrier representative wants to work with you, but is being pushed by a higher up to push a bad design. Convey your intent clearly.</p><p>On the other hand, if the carrier’s attorney offers alternate code language during a code update; give it a sincere look. Ask around. Don’t dismiss it just because the carrier’s attorney bullied you in the past. As someone once mused, cities/counties do not pick their customers.</p><p><strong>We tell the carrier information they don’t seem to like, then they hire someone who shows up unexpectedly to discuss the same issue a few weeks later. Seems like a waste of staff time.</strong> <br>Yep. It happens. Take good notes and ask the new person to re-read any standards/prior correspondence before the meeting to discuss the same topic again.</p><p><strong>We are negotiating a lease to put Small Cells on City-owned poles. The carrier wants 15 year terms and volume discounts.</strong> <br>No to 15 year terms. Too long. Volume discounts (if at all) should be based on sites actually being built, not just turning in pole license applications for sites they don’t build, but get the discount for anyways.</p><p><strong>The carrier wants us to sign a non-disclosure agreement. <br></strong>Not recommended. Ask your counsel.</p><p><strong>But, they are claiming trade secrets! <br></strong>It’s cell antennas, not missile defense….</p><p><strong>The carrier wants time guarantees on permit approvals for City-owned poles? <br></strong>Have they given you an accurate mockup, a viable design, complete plans, and tested underground conduit for sufficient space for fiber/power? Yeah, I thought not. No…….</p><p><strong>We asked the carrier for a site map and they gave us locations that do not seem real, like in ponds or on footbridges.</strong> <br>Yep. Welcome to the suck (I was in the Army). Sorry, there I go again…</p><p><strong>My residents keep insisting there are more restrictive limits on this RF emissions “stuff” in Japan or Europe, is that true</strong>?</p><p>Not really…………</p><p>Public exposure standards in most European Union countries are similar to the U.S. for frequencies used by wireless carriers. Some European counties have few operators. Then again the U.S. had 7 primary operators until Sprint bought Clearwire and Nextel, and T-Mobile bought MetroPCS. Now most areas of California have 4 operators, not including WISPs and other “non-cellular” operators.</p><p>Many Small Cell sites put out actual operating RF levels that are lower than the predicted maximums, and often at about 1% of the limit for the public exposure limit (at nearby areas the public has access to) established by the FCC. Switzerland has more restrictive limits of about 1/100th (with some mitigating factors) of the FCC’s standards.</p><p>So often times the Small Cell site, in terms of typical operating condition, will tend to approach the more restrictive Swiss standards. Don’t believe me? No worries, I’m not an RF engineer anyways. The proof is in the RF testing. Request it. Don’t be shy.</p><p><strong>The resident is claiming the antenna that just got installed near their home is making them sick.</strong> <br>Check to see if the site has power. Sometimes it’s not even activated and there isn’t even power running to the antenna; and there is no glass bubble on the electric meter enclosure (still waiting for utility inspection). I’m serious. I know it sounds mean, but it happens.</p><p><strong>Can we make the carrier add shielding or low-e glass to a neighbors house, who is worried about RF emissions?</strong> <br>Nope. Can’t require it. I’ve never seen a carrier offer to do so.Though I have heard of carriers offering to install more sound-proof windows due to loud cooling fans. Or setting the fans so they turn off at night. <br>Tread lightly on requirements like this (new windows) unless vetted with counsel. <br>Be aware that it is not uncommon for the wireless carrier rep (even the ones that talk about their personal ties to the community) to promise something to the Planning Commission, then feign ignorance, or fail to follow through after approval.</p><p><strong>A resident asked if we can require wireless carriers to show “fall zones” (if the pole collapses) and ban Small Cells that have a fall zone that encompasses their home or an adjacent child care center (for example). Is that possible?</strong></p><p>Not likely. Ask your counsel. This paradigm would likely carry even less plausibility if the pole is owned by a investor-owned utility (or the SoCal or NorCal Joint Pole Associations), since the carrier could argue that pole safety (for those poles) is preempted by State (CPUC-administered) regulations. Yes, there are some rural counties that create setbacks based on fall zones, but that is generally tied to really tall (over 75 feet tall) steel lattice towers for macro systems (usually holding up dozens of antennas); and not for Small Cells.</p><p><strong>Can we ban Small Cells next to elementary schools or child care centers?</strong></p><p>Not if the basis is concerns over radio-frequency (RF) exposure, due to Federal law (1996 Telecommunications Act).</p><p><strong>The carrier rep said in areas with poor reception your phone puts out more radio-frequency (RF) energy. Is that right? <br></strong>Pretty much. Your phone battery drains faster as it puts out more energy to talk to the nearest cell site.</p><p><strong>The carrier rep said folks often get more RF exposure from the phone in their pocket or Wi-Fi router in their home than the cell site across the street. Is that correct? <br></strong>Mostly yes.</p><p><strong>A resident said Small Cells should be banned because it may hurt birds and wildlife. <br></strong>That isn’t a basis for denial that can likely stand up in court. Though, if required based on location, certain types of aircraft warning lights (white blinking instead of red steady burning) may lead to fewer bird collisions (<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/mar/24/airport-lights-birds-faa">link</a>).</p><p><strong>It seems the cooling fans get noisier over time or is it just me?</strong> <br>Yes, that can happen, especially in areas near the ocean where salt can settle on fan bearings and make them corrode. Carriers often don’t maintain the sites well. Better to push for systems with passive cooling, which means they have no noise generating cooling fans. This may require a large equipment cabinet. Require longer, but narrower cabinets for placements on poles.</p><p><strong>Can’t the wireless carriers all share the same system?</strong> <br>That was the promise made by carriers like NewPath and NextG (acquired by Crown Castle) years ago. It never really happened with a few exceptions such as stadiums and subway stations. <br>The challenge is this. You have four separate carriers (often apt to proclaim anti-trust concerns when it comes to working together) that want their own frequency-specific computers (more boxes) near the pole holding up the antenna. Each carrier has different challenges given the spectrum (some goes through buildings better, some delivers faster data) and network loads (T-Mobile and Sprint sites typically feature fewer antennas and equipment). In other words, they don’t all need antennas in the same place. New York City is exploring neutral-host poles given the demand.</p><p>Have you updated your ordinance yet?</p><p><strong>The carrier keeps saying they should be treated like a utility.</strong> <br>Funny. In the 90’s the carriers told Congress (circa the 1996 telecom act) they don’t want to be subject to those rules (e.g. universal build out so they don’t just cherry pick neighborhoods to serve, franchise fees, consumer protection rules, reliability standards).</p><p>Bear in mind that most cities just have one traffic signal operator or electric provider. There are multiple wireless carriers with individual infrastructure, and varying CHOICES in both where (private property versus right of way) and how (design) they deploy.</p><p><strong>If enough Small Cells get built, will this mean the large ugly steel towers/monopoles nearby will get torn down?</strong> <br>Not necessarily. Some of those sites carry other antennas for private networks or antennas for police and fire radios that serve wide (few miles) areas. They can’t easily be replaced with Small Cells. Though do make sure your wireless ordinances require abandoned towers to be removed within six months, and place a ten-year time limit on permits and Conditional Use Permits.</p><p><strong>A Planning Commissioner wants to know if we can require the carrier to comply with a lower RF limit?</strong> <br>Only if the site is on a building or pole the City owns (there was an interesting case involving the City of Carlsbad on this issue). Otherwise, you cannot dictate/request lower RF emissions levels. Bear in mind that for Small Cells, the antennas are typically directional, so the resident in an apartment near the pole and on the same level as the antenna is getting more RF exposure from their cell phone or Wi-Fi access point (if they have one) than from the Small Cell.</p><p><strong>The carrier reps seem to Planner Shop at the Planning Counter. Are they trying to slip something by me?</strong> <br>Probably. Create a checklist. Be consistent. If the plans do not make sense don’t approve it. Oh, and the carrier may offer to make handwritten corrections to plans. That’s great, but often those plans (the ones with the handrwritten notes) don’t get used for the job bid or ordering of equipment, and the site gets built wrong. Demand better.</p><p>Department Managers in Planning/Public Works — Empower your staff to provide early feedback to wireless carriers in advance of actual submittals. Carriers are more willing to make changes if you let them know of a significant concern before formal submittals (<em>and shot clock spreadsheets watched by wireless industry lawyers start moving</em>). Be clear, though that any surprises by the carrier may warrant further review.</p><p>Sample Disclaimer: <em>Thank you for providing an opportunity to comment. Below are code requirements/suggestions that appear to apply. Please note that further review may be required if any changes are made to the plans/exhibits, or based on any unique site-specific circumstances. No guarantee of approval, or an approval recommendation, is expressed by these comments.</em></p><p><strong>If we allow antennas on City light poles aren’t we going to basically create more interference for police and fire radios? <br></strong>Not necessarily. Carriers have generally been pretty good about resolving these issues. However, when carriers launch new services there have been instances where the cell sites caused interference (e.g. AT&amp;T 4G upgrades in Oakland a few years ago). Ask the carrier for the right network engineering contact and introduce them to your City/County radio shop. They may want to do benchmark testing to compare signal noise before and after Small Cells go up. Example: <em>The time a hair salon interfered with a cell site and really upset the FCC (</em><a href="http://www.fiercewireless.com/tech/story/atts-lte-network-impaired-salons-fluorescent-light/2013-10-30"><em>link</em></a><em>).</em></p><p>Right now it does not appear Small Cells are interfering with public Wi-Fi systems mounted on outdoor locations. However, there is a concern that a push by carriers and Qualcomm to use unlicensed frequency for cellular voice/data (referred to as LTE-U) may degrade Wi-Fi (which uses unlicensed frequency). As of September 2016, the interference testing protocols are still being hammered out between carriers/Qualcomm and a Wi-Fi alliance (includes cable companies and Google).</p><p><strong>How is Wi-Fi different from cellular antennas? <br></strong>It’s the same in the sense that it is radio-frequency energy coming out of a device. Wi-Fi typically uses very low power systems (e.g. router in your house) to send out a signal with a very limited range (often less than 150 feet). It can handle data speed and capacity really well, but because it uses “unlicensed” frequencies it can get bogged down by interference from other Wi-Fi antennas in the area. In dense areas, some wireless carriers like AT&amp;T Mobility will put up cell antenna on rooftops in a given neighborhood and then their wireline division (folks who lay fiber-optic cables for landlines) will come and add “Wi-Fi only” antennas at the same building or nearby buildings. This helps carriers to “offload” some traffic from existing cellular networks, which have some limits (factors like physics and licensed frequencies in a given neighborhood) when it comes to data capacity for a lot of mobile device users in a small area.</p><p><strong>I’m a City Planner, but not in California. What are some potential issues that may be relevant to my State?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/603/1*KhKmO2rWxlMi7jOX-g19Dw.png" /><figcaption>9th Circuit Federal Court Map</figcaption></figure><p>Check with your counsel but bear in mind:</p><ul><li>Your City/County/Parish may be able to charge the carrier for being in the public right-of-way, even if adding new ground-mounted boxes or poles that will not be owned by the municipality. The rates may vary based on whether the system is for a licensed carrier, or being built “on spec.”</li><li>The California State Appeals Court recently re-affirmed a previous <a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">FEDERAL 9th Circuit “en banc” decision</a> that said cities/counties should have reasonable discretion over wireless in the public right-of-way (Sprint versus Palos Verdes). The 9th circuit map is above. If you are not in the 9th circuit, this may be an untested area with no clear cut State laws or court decisions. This makes it even more important to articulate a clear vision of what is considered acceptable and non-acceptable in your community; to respond to carriers within 30 days of initial submittals (and 10 days of re-submittal) and to adopt a clear ordinance.</li><li>You may have varying degrees of success working with your electric utility to replace wooden light (only) poles with steel poles with cabling inside (cleaner design) and a more appropriate design. You may also have varying degrees of success with using Smart Wireless Metering and Fused Systems to avoid the need for ugly meter cabinets/disconnect switches on the pole or sidewalk.</li></ul><p><strong>Why did you say my existing ordinance may be out of date?</strong></p><p><em>Example One:</em> Your ordinance was written in the 1990’s with a goal of encouraging collocation on (fewer) tall steel monopoles (50 to 200 feet) with antennas/dishes for multiple carriers on the same pole. So the ordinance required a minimum separation between monopoles.</p><p>With Small Cells/oDAS; your ordinance may now have the unintended effect of treating these shorter poles (including smaller attachments to existing steel/wood poles) as monopoles, and pushing the carrier to seek a more intrusive location closer to residences or historic buildings, in order to maintain the separation distance from tall-large monopoles.</p><p><em>Example Two:</em> Your ordinance essentially prohibits new wireless facilities on buildings that are currently non-conforming (even if legally permitted). If it’s a general non-conformance due to building height, this may unintentionally push the carrier to avoid a taller office building (better location) and seek more sites in the public right-of-way instead; and/or rooftop-mounted sites on a shorter building where antennas are closer to upper story residences (i.e. potentially more RF exposure given the directional nature of panel antennas).</p><p><em>Example Three:</em> Your ordinance language creates a 1,00 foot separation boundary between wireless facilities and any residence. This may encourage carriers to choose a larger number of Small Cells (multiple poles in a given neighborhood) in the public right-of-way, instead of a mix of smaller rooftop-mounted sites in tandem with fewer Small Cells.</p><p>Example Four: Your ordinance/staff tends to inhibit/prohibit rooftop wireless facilities on historic buildings. Even for well-designed sites using screening (walls/vent pipes) to place hidden antennas in front of existing unscreened HVAC equipment (hiding ugly equipment). This may unintentionally encourage the carrier to pursue more Small Cells in the public right-of-way; and possibly closer to residential neighborhoods.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c9e966f257a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Brave New World for Cell Antennas in California]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/a-brave-new-world-for-cell-antennas-in-california-39d864a876d4?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/39d864a876d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[city-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[telecommunication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Jan 2016 17:49:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-20T01:02:40.071Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>by Robert “Tripp” May, and Omar Masry, AICP<br><em>(</em><a href="http://issuu.com/naphtaliknox/docs/northern_news_feb_2016"><em>published in the February 2016 newsletter for the Northern California chapter of the American Planning Association</em></a><em>). Tripp is an attorney and partner with Telecom Law Firm. Omar Masry, AICP, has served as a City Planner in Los Angeles, Orange and San Francisco counties. Both testified on AB 57 before the California State Senate. <br></em><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/10-key-issues-for-california-cities-counties-on-the-challenges-of-small-cells-not-so-small-c9e966f257a#.9i6wp86m1"><em> &gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;(Link to An Article Focused on Small Cells only)&lt;&lt;&lt;&lt;&lt;&lt;&lt;&lt;</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/395/1*Bmjon2kr9OntkaMJ93b-cQ.png" /><figcaption>Slideshare Presentation: <a href="http://www.slideshare.net/omarmasry/a-city-planners-perspective-on-wireless-facility-siting">http://www.slideshare.net/omarmasry/a-city-planners-perspective-on-wireless-facility-siting</a></figcaption></figure><p>Effective January 1, 2016, all wireless permit applications will be subject to an automatic approval rule under either California or federal law. In early 2015, the FCC promulgated a “deemed-granted” rule for applications for less-than-substantial requests for collocations or modifications to existing facilities pending for more than 60 days.</p><p>In late 2015, the California legislature adopted AB 57 (Quirk), a new state statute codified Government Code Section 65964.1 (see <a href="http://bit.ly/1RcnIpb),">http://bit.ly/1RcnIpb),</a> which deems approved all applications for new sites after 150 days and all collocations not covered under the FCC’s rules after 90 days. AB 57 turns the development process in California upside down to accelerate wireless infrastructure deployment. Whereas applicants must normally submit at least a complete permit application before it becomes entitled to an approval, AB 57 merely requires a submittal without an approval or denial within a specified period. Even the “deemed approval” provisions in the California Permit Streamlining Act required the applicant to complete CEQA review and observe due process, but now AB 57 grants wireless site projects a free pass irrespective of environmental or constitutional concerns.</p><p>The California legislature adopted this radical departure from orderly and deliberate deployment decisions about more-or-less permanent installations despite a consistent refusal from the FCC to grant the same extraordinary privileges to these applicants. Wireless lobbyists twice petitioned the FCC for deemed-granted permits for any wireless site application, and twice went home empty handed. In both instances, the FCC felt that too many complex and important issues are at stake to simply deem any permit granted. Nevertheless, AB 57 is the law in California. Local governments, their planners, public works engineers, officials, and elected representatives must learn to navigate the new law.</p><p>This article introduces planners to AB 57 and provides some real-world applications.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ui9mVTgJIAVbK-MLeil8yA.png" /><figcaption>During the hearings for AB 57, State legislators asked if there was a need for this bill. Verizon and Assembly member Bill Quirk noted Thousand Oaks as an example of a problematic City for wireless siting. This was the response from Thousand Oaks.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Which Shot Clock?</strong> At its core, AB 57 automatically deems approved any application for a new or substantially changed wireless site after the FCC’s “shot clock” expires. Those shot clock rules established “presumptively reasonable” times to process an application for a new site (150 days) or a collocation (90 days), after which an applicant could sue to force a decision. The distinction between a new site and collocation seems simple enough, but people often disagree over which clock applies. For example, most municipalities define a collocation to mean two wireless facilities on the same structure, but wireless industry lawyers sometimes claim that new wireless equipment added to any existing structure (whether the building or utility pole has wireless equipment or not) qualifies as a collocation subject to the 90-day clock. In contrast to both definitions, the FCC said in 2009 that a 90-day collocation means an application “does not involve a substantial increase in the size of a tower,” and a tower means a structure solely or primarily intended to support wireless antennas.</p><p>So what’s a collocation? For AB 57 purposes, the FCC’s 2009 rule applies. Unless a shorter shot clock applies (and yes, they exist), municipalities must process less-than-substantial increases in the size of a tower in 90 days or less. New sites, and substantial changes to existing sites, must be processed in 150 days or less.</p><p><strong>Exceptions to “pause” the Shot Clocks</strong>. There are two “pause” mechanisms that apply to these 90- and 150-day clocks. The first exception applies if a carrier submits an application and the local government provides a written letter indicating why the application is incomplete within 30 days. Then, the clock pauses until the carrier re-submits the application or provides the information requested. Once a project is re-submitted, the local government has 10 days to determine if the submitted materials are complete; otherwise the clock continues.</p><p>A second exception involves the wireless carrier and the city/county agreeing to a tolling agreement to extend the clock until a certain date, or a certain metric is met, or indefinitely. However, the carrier has to voluntarily agree in writing to such an extension.</p><p>Even when the application is “<strong>complete</strong>,” but the design is still <strong>not viable </strong>(e.g., minimally-intrusive and/or consistent with local development policies/guidelines/ordinances) or not legal (e.g., violates building codes, noise ordinances, CEQA, historic preservation regulations, has no legal access to the site), the time it takes to make further changes (e.g., revise the design, conduct outreach, perform environmental review and so on) to make the project “viable” (i.e., less-intrusive) counts against the city/county and the clock still runs. Given that 20 to 30 days of the clock will typically be used in reviewing the application when it is first submitted — and that in most cities/counties, it takes around 30–40 days to get a project and neighborhood notification mailed out in advance of the public hearing (assuming the hearing body doesn’t take time off in the summer) — the 90-day clock becomes an even greater challenge, especially if there are other recommendation hearing bodies such as Historic Preservation Commission or a public design review board.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/417/1*ATz8r7yXQsUKnUboPBuGpQ.png" /><figcaption>Even if a proposal is “complete” the design (especially if on a historic building) may not be viable</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*MzpjgHrmnrslDwYLCYuttA.png" /><figcaption>The second try wasn’t viable either</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*QEmAJ0YMbcK9G_gOdFXYnw.png" /><figcaption>A more viable revision. Notice the use of low profile screen boxes over the equipment (radio relay units) and lack of visible GPS antenna or caged access ladders. Photo simulation by <a href="http://www.photosim.com/">Previsualists</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZQ5Ey403kdufEqqg0i7vag.png" /><figcaption><strong>Why is this “Small Cell” so tall in front of a home?</strong> It appears it is so that “Mobilitie”” (Sprint’s network partner — no relation to AT&amp;T Mobility) can save money by using microwave dishes to “talk” to the cell antennas on shorter poles nearby (see image further below). This means using microwave dishes instead of running fiber-optic cables for miles (below City streets or on existing wooden utility poles) for what is known as backhaul (backhaul = connecting your cell phone to the cell antennas and then ultimately back to the internet/switch center). Also, by placing the poles in the public right-of-way, the deployment is generally rent-free (in California), instead of placement on private property with leases running a few thousand a month on either existing multi-carrier (multiple antennas) towers, or rooftops (hidden antennas) on private property. There is a concern that if a City allows this approach, then they loose control of their public right of way. Also, because these poles are not likely co-locatable; it means the other three major wireless carriers would need to install their own poles nearby. Plus, if this path was pursued, then one would wonder why other wireless carriers would think of paying a landlord to host multiple antennas on the same pole for multiple carriers (less-intrusive); when they can each put up their own poles rent-free in the public right-of-way. Side note: in urban areas you may see new microwave dishes (to backhaul data from new small cells nearby) show up on existing Sprint/Clearwire rooftop-mounted cell sites</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/710/1*DoK2KOrDGqPqgtMETClhlw.png" /><figcaption>In Baltimore, it appears Mobilitie installed a brand new pole on the sidewalk (inset photo to right on top of concrete base) without permits and was fined 5K.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>What happens after a Deemed Approval</strong>? Quite frankly, no one knows for sure. Neither the statute nor the legislative record gives any clues about the applicants’ or the municipalities’ respective rights and obligations. Does the applicant need a physical permit, or can it just go out and build the site? Although the statute permits localities to seek judicial review, that provision hardly authorizes construction without actual permits. Can the applicant build whatever it wants, or must it obey zone height restrictions and setbacks? What if the application involved a variance? Can municipalities attach conditions to permits issued after a deemed approval? What happens when the clock runs out during an appeal? Localities should think about these problems now rather than after they receive the first letter from an applicant declaring its application automatically approved.</p><p>Perhaps the best approach is to build safeguards into the review process that help prevent applications from falling through the cracks. Given that a deemed approval cannot occur unless the applicant has provided all the public notices required for the application, localities should consider requiring the applicant to send public notice that the shot clock is about to expire (and require a copy of the notice to be sent to the planner!).</p><p><strong>CEQA challenge</strong>. Unlike existing California “deemed approvals” in the Permit Streamlining Act, AB 57 provides no timing exceptions for complex environmental (CEQA) review. So, if a new hilltop tower (plus access roads and generators) would require an Environmental Impact Report (or similar) and complex studies (e.g., biological sampling for endangered species during the Spring, storm water review for new access roads, or geotechnical and archaeological review), what choice does the local government have?It may hope the wireless carrier will voluntarily request a tolling agreement (to extend the clock for a new facility). But failing that, the locality faces a conundrum: It will want to avoid automatic approvals for incompatible designs/locations, but it won’t be able to approve a project (or subsequent permits) if it hasn’t undertaken complete CEQA review.</p><p><strong>Due Process.</strong> AB 57 also deviates from the due process protections that appear in the Permit Streamlining Act. Whereas the PSA prohibits any deemed approval without a public hearing when one is required, AB 57 was worded to avoid as many public hearings as possible. Under the PSA, a permit cannot be deemed granted unless “the public notice required by law has occurred,” which the courts interpret to include a public hearing when a project would substantially impact neighboring property rights. AB 57, however, only requires the public notice specified for the application. So if your local code doesn’t require a public hearing, but the Constitution would, AB 57 apparently deems the permit approved whether neighbors receive their fundamental rights or not.</p><p>So how many wireless sites “substantially” impact property rights? That’s a good question, and like most good questions it doesn’t have a clear answer. However, it’s worth mention that the Ninth Circuit in American Tower Corp. v. City of San Diego recently found that the mere renewal of a large tower’s permit could substantially impact property rights — so it seems fair to say that an approval for a new tower might require a hearing in some circumstances.</p><p>Local jurisdictions should look very hard at their notice requirements. AB 57 seems to push localities toward more public hearings rather than more streamlined administrative processes. Wireless sites are already controversial in many cases. Can you imagine how the public might react if it found out that the jurisdiction could have required a hearing but didn’t?</p><p><strong>Conclusion.</strong> AB 57 presents significant new challenges for public officials and municipal staff members. Not only does it completely change the traditional development process, it also offers few if any clear rules to guide governments and applicants through the new paradigm. The regulatory void leaves ample room for gaming and bad behavior on both sides of the counter. It doesn’t have to be that way. Omar Masry has developed an excellent supplement to help guide planners through the wireless permit process: “Supplement: Tools for adapting to AB 57” is available at <a href="http://bit.ly/1Q9UEM3.">http://bit.ly/1Q9UEM3.</a> In addition, the authors encourage local officials and staff members to study AB 57, discuss it with the applicants, and develop thoughtful approaches to fill in its gaps and holes.</p><h3><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/10-key-issues-for-california-cities-counties-on-the-challenges-of-small-cells-not-so-small-c9e966f257a#.ozcx8p1b8">Other Article: 10 Key Issues for California Cities &amp; Counties on the Challenges of Small Cells &amp; “Not So Small Cells”</a></h3><p><em>*Key considerations for cell antennas and equipment mounted to light poles, utility poles and other structures in the public right-of-way (streets and sidewalks).</em></p><h3><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/6409-supplement-7d4176320061#.quh0v2n3v"><em>Separate link to areas of consideration for Federal “6409” rules governing potentially major changes to some </em>existing<em> wireless facilities</em></a></h3><h3>The Supplement: Tools for Adapting to AB 57 (New California Law on Cell Towers)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8tYitm5XM7A6I4OYojMPaQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Don’t Accept Incomplete Applications | </strong>Make it clear in application forms that applications will be considered “incomplete” (or decline to accept the application) if:</p><ul><li>Any existing on-site wireless facilities were not built, modified or maintained correctly (request current site photos and prior plans/permits in submittal forms).</li><li>There are current Municipal (Building, Fire) Code Violations at the Project Site.</li><li>Commonly expected submittal items are missing. Determine if based on local practice, whether specific exhibits (<em>geo-technical, </em><a href="http://ohp.parks.ca.gov/pages/1068/files/ic_roster.pdf"><em>archaeological surveys</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase_I_environmental_site_assessment"><em>Phase I reports</em></a><em>, and environmental evaluations</em>) should be required for freestanding facilities, or facilities with other major ground disturbances (<em>excavations, access roads, fuel tanks, new equipment/building pads</em>). Indicate these requirements up-front on the application forms.</li></ul><p>Require the wireless carrier to identify up-front on the application form whether they believe the site qualifies as a co-Location. This is important to ensure the local government is not “surprised” (<em>with a deemed granted letter at day 91, for example</em>) that the wireless carrier expected a 90-day clock, when it was originally assumed by staff that a 150-day clock would apply.<br> <br> If the existing facility was built without permits (if they were required); be clear, in the permit application form that such locations are not yet eligible for a co-location.</p><p>Decline to accept new facility applications that are substantially incomplete, and consider suggesting a pre-application instead (especially for new freestanding facilities).</p><p><em>See sample application checklist links in the Resources section further below.</em></p><p><strong>Work with Public Works | </strong>Determine if wireless facilities within the public right-of-way (e.g. antennas &amp; cabinets on utility/light poles) should (or should not) fall under the same process as wireless facilities on buildable lots. Some cities/counties place these rules within the public works code. Other cities/counties require Planning referral as part of an encroachment permit (with the ability to add conditions); while some cities/counties require a Conditional Use Permit for each location. <strong>If you don’t have a process in place; NOW is a good time to get one.</strong></p><blockquote>At a 2013 wireless industry conference, in Dublin, a lawyer who represents wireless carriers, advised carriers to tell city/county Public Works Departments they were installing telephone service, and avoid references to “wireless” or “cellular” in their applications.</blockquote><p><strong><em>One neutral host wireless carrier has been (recently) asking various California cities and counties about installing brand new wooden poles in the public right-of-way (even if right in front of a residence), just to hold up new wireless facilities. </em></strong><a href="http://www.rcrwireless.com/20160125/opinion/analyst-angle-sprints-network-plan-equals-suicide-2-tag9"><strong><em>They’ve indicated doing so will allow for faster and cheaper roll out of small cells.</em></strong></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K1Ccs1IRwfUstC2w4PL8fQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>New wood pole (holding up antennas) and equipment enclosures for a (appears to be by “Mobilitie” also doing business as Interstate Transport and Broadband or the Utility Pole Authority or CA Transmission Network or Telemobilitie or NC Relay Technology and Networking) wireless facility in the public right of way (where all other utilities are already undergrounded) in Woodbridge, Virginia. It appears this site (along with others in the County) was built without required permits.</figcaption></figure><p>While State law does grant fairly broad rights to wireless carriers (<em>who posses a Certificate of Public Convenience &amp; Necessity from the CPUC</em>) to enter the public right of way (<em>by granting them similar rights as “telephone corporations”</em>), cities/counties can still establish design criteria (<em>“time, place and manner”</em>) to ensure the wireless facility does not significantly (visually) incommode the public right-of-way; or generate bothersome noise (cooling fans). Cities/counties can also exercise CEQA (e.g. aesthetics, archaeology, historic preservation, and noise) review, beyond any potential CEQA review by the CPUC.</p><p>Avoid instances where Public Works issues an encroachment permit for a “fiber pole” only (without antennas shown on the plans) to an applicant claiming they are installing “plain old (wired) telephone service,” as occurred in Houston (and nearly occurred in one San Diego County town), where antennas and equipment were later added to the new fiber only pole without permits.</p><p>While the four national carriers can often install oDAS/Small Cells on poles in the public right-of-way by themselves, they often work with neutral host carriers such as Crown Castle (acquired NextG/Newpath), Extenet Systems, and Mobilitie. <em>Mobilitie also uses another DBA of “California Utility Pole Authority</em>”<em> (no relation to AT&amp;T Mobility or the </em><a href="http://www.scjpc.org/"><em>Southern California Joint Pole Committe</em></a><em>e and the </em><a href="http://www.ncjpa.org/about/"><em>Northern California Joint Pole Associations</em></a><em>)</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cdLeD_3j-YsgcqYUgPKmKg.png" /><figcaption>“DAS XL” (Crown for Verizon) with a noise generating (cooling fans) equipment cabinet (computers) and antenna on a PG&amp;E owned wooden light pole. The electric meter and battery backup cabinet are on a pole across the street.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k3vMkUyxpzIxv7g-Z-Rh3A.png" /><figcaption>The (optional) battery backup cabinet and electric meter are on a separate pole across the street from the DAS “XL” node (with antenna). <a href="http://www.tsipower.com/">TSi Power </a>makes a battery cabinet that is longer, but slimmer (about as wide as the pole) and less likely to impair views as compared to bulkier (about 3 times as wide a the pole) Alpha cabinets typically used.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>See also <em>“Areas of consideration for Public Right of Way Facilities (known as Small Cells, or oDAS)”</em></strong></p><p><strong>Early Warning on Other Items | </strong>Consider creating metrics when other studies, such as a noise study, photometric study (<em>new recreational field lighting w/antennas</em>) or structural analysis are required; and then requiring those studies/submittals up front, on the application checklist.</p><p><em>Example: Provide a noise study for all facilities that include any of the following: outdoor (diesel) generators in areas outside X (industrial zones); and any noise-generating equipment cabinets or condensers, that generate over 45 decibels from three feet away, and are also located within either 10 feet of a residential property line, or within 10 feet of the building face of a school, child care center or retirement home.</em></p><p><em>Example: Provide a (engineer wet-stamped) structural analysis for any new freestanding (screened or unscreened support structures over 15 feet tall) facility, and any facility on wood-framed buildings other than those buildings in X (commercial or industrial zones). Also affirm that there are no conflicting easements or other property restrictions (e.g. underground flood control culverts or pipelines).</em></p><p><strong>Track the Clock </strong>| If a resubmittal is provided by the wireless carrier and the application is complete but still not VIABLE, then consider scheduling a Planning Commission hearing (if required) and indicate the project will be recommended for denial by staff, at the hearing, if a viable (<em>and complete with respect to antennas, equipment, screening, support elements</em>) design is not provided by a specific date (e.g. 45 days before the 90 or 150 day clock, whichever applies).</p><p>Some cities (e.g. Rancho Palos Verdes) require the carrier to notify the City, in writing, of a pending shot clock expiration no later than twenty (20) days prior to the expiration. <em>It may be preferable to also indicate the notice should also not be sent more than forty (40) days before expiration as well.</em></p><p><strong>Community Meetings | </strong>While Planners always make a sincere effort to anticipate potential neighborhood land use concerns with nearly any type of land use development, they can’t predict every issue.</p><p>So, in order to avoid asking for last minute changes to remedy a sincere concern that arises a few days after the upcoming public hearing notice gets mailed out; consider requiring wireless carriers to hold their own community meeting, prior to either considering an application complete or allowing a carrier to submit a new facility (or co-location, depending on neighborhood) application.</p><p>Depending on the level of local challenges and land use patterns, such a requirement could be exempted for wireless facilities that are in wholly industrial/commercial areas; or for screened rooftop facilities, or for co-locations (at existing sites) that are fully screened (with equipment cabinets inside existing non-residential spaces) in certain land use areas.</p><p>If the city/county does decide to require a separate carrier-held community-meeting, make sure the outside of the envelope says something to the effect of “Wireless Facility Neighborhood Notification (or meeting)” in English and any predominant local languages (<em>grey text shouldn’t conflict with USPS mailing rules</em>). Also, require the carrier to send (via first class mail) the notice 10 days before the meeting; and to host the meeting within a certain radius of the site, on days other than Sundays, State holidays, and any relevant local holidays of importance (<em>e.g. lunar new year, or other holidays or teacher preparation days typically noted on calendars created by the local school district, for instance</em>).</p><p><strong>Encourage pre-applications | </strong>Especially for freestanding sites. For new freestanding sites (<em>e.g. new wood or steel poles in public right of way and new steel towers outside of the PROW</em>), be cognizant of issues such as: archaeology, native habitat, brownfields (<em>possible soil contamination or underground storage tanks</em>), easements (private or public agencies), noise (affecting residents or habitat), storm water rules, streambed adjacency (<em>Department of Fish &amp; Game and/or US Army Corps of Engineers may have some purview</em>) and whether the Federal Aviation Administration (see local airport land use plans) may require tower lighting (<em>tip: flashing white lights reduce bird deaths compared to steady red lighting</em>).</p><p>Ensure the project submittal shows the full scope of the facility such as new driveways and how power and communications cables will travel from the tower to any equipment area. Avoid above ground “ice bridges” (<em>which are basically steel cable trays elevated six or more feet above the ground</em>) that may be prominently visible from off-site.</p><p>During the pre-application meeting, ask the wireless carrier’s representative if they understand the application form. It’s not uncommon for carriers (especially for Small Cells/oDAS in the public right-of-way) to fill out the application incorrectly, including checking a YES and NO box next to each other at the same time.</p><p><strong>Establish an alternative site analysis preference | </strong>Consider requiring the carrier to submit documentation showing why a new facility is the least intrusive type of facility, in a given neighborhood. In rural (and some suburban) contexts this could include preferences for: screened rooftop facilities on shopping centers over X acres, any four-story or more commercial building rooftop mount (check on height limit rules for screening), <a href="http://www.cablinginstall.com/articles/2012/02/att-uses-magnets-to-secure-4g-infrastructure.html">magnetic mounts </a>(to hold up antennas) on existing (real) water tanks, freestanding structures integrated with an associated land use (e.g. new bell tower at an existing church), faux water tanks in an industrial area, office/retail center monument signs,<a href="http://www.cnet.com/news/disguised-cell-towers/"> faux trees in areas surrounded by existing mature trees</a> (with a “real” adjacent tree protection plan), and a “<a href="http://www.sanjoseca.gov/DocumentCenter/View/31751">wide slim line</a>” that basically resembles a 36-inch wide vertical rod.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/915/1*FAhl1YOMuiGaTplTc6Rdbg.png" /><figcaption><em>Left Photo: Example of a previously proposed 36-inch wide, 50-foot “tall wide slim line.” Right Photo: Previously installed (</em><a href="http://www.fresno.gov/planningdocs/June042014/A.pdf"><em>link</em></a><em>) 18-inch diameter slim line, in Fresno, and a prior (very bulky) modification proposal.</em></figcaption></figure><p>The older “slimmer” slim lines (typically 18-inch diameter) found in cities such as San Jose and Fresno, are generally considered too slim for wireless carriers, who try to either place radio relay units (RRU/RRH) near the antennas, add more/larger antennas, or run fairly thick bundles of cabling from ground-mounted RRUs to the antennas (leaving little, if any, space for a 2nd carrier’s antennas on the same pole).</p><p>While many community members may prefer zoning ordinances that prohibit all wireless facilities within or near residential zoning districts, this may, depending on a large number of factors, have the negative counter effect of encouraging wireless carriers to forgo rooftop-mounted sites (for example) that may be minimally intrusive (e.g. hidden in a church steeple) and instead seek a larger (overall number of sites) number of antennas and equipment on new or existing poles within the public right of way; and therefore right in front of homes (with equipment boxes potentially in front of windows). Or an even more challenging possibility of proposing antennas and equipment on wooden utility poles that run between adjoining backyards in some relatively older neighborhoods.</p><p>The ability to create large buffers (from residential areas) for wireless facilities is far more limited specific to public right-of-way locations (<em>compared to larger freestanding towers or rooftop-mounted sites on private property</em>), given State law.</p><p><strong>Accept No More Surprises | </strong>It’s all too common for project submittals, by wireless carriers to leave out significant required elements (<em>e.g. wide cable trays proposed running over a residential window, storefront level alterations for new generator plugs or electric meters on historic buildings, or large caged ladders on the edge of a historic residential building</em>) that are not included in the first submittal, or even the second submittal of plans and/or photo simulations. <br> <br> Or, for City staff to see RF safety reports that list the wrong number of existing antennas (for another carrier), or say there are no other carriers within 100 feet; when a cursory look on Google Earth or Google Search shows two other existing carriers on the same project site.<em> <br> <br></em><strong><em> </em>See list<em>, further below (</em></strong><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/Modules/ShowDocument.aspx?documentid=9392"><strong><em>or photos here</em></strong></a><strong><em>), of common items not accurately conveyed on plans and simulations for new rooftop-mounted sites and modifications.</em></strong></p><p>For rooftop-mounted facilities on buildings with residences below, require the carrier to affirm (based on consultation with the property owner) in writing that the antennas/equipment won’t displace (equipment areas range in size from 2 to 5 office cubicles) existing tenant spaces (e.g. roof decks). Consider requesting site photos as well. For mixed-use buildings ensure that equipment areas within buildings (ranging in size from the equivalent of 1 to 4 office cubicles) won’t displace a small business tenant (<em>even if on a month-to-month lease</em>).</p><p>Make it clear in the first screen check letter that any staff design direction or hearing body determination is based on a submittal that is complete; such as plans, photo simulations, and reports (e.g. RF and structural) that accurately depict all required facility elements.</p><p>Given that 20–30 days of the clock will be used up reviewing the application when it is first submitted; and in most cities/counties, it takes around 30–40 days to get a project and neighborhood notification mailed out in advance of the public hearing (assuming the hearing body doesn’t take time off in the summer); it may also be prudent to hold a date on the hearing calendar for the project and indicate to the carrier that if the project is not complete AND viable by a certain date (e.g. 10 days after the first re-submittal for collocations and 40 days after initial re-submittal for new facilities) staff may have to recommend disapproval at that hearing date.</p><p>Indicate that substantial revisions or additions after the first re-submittal may require either a denial if sufficient time is not provided to analyze those impacts; or may necessitate approval recommendations of the project without the last-minute changes (and a new application being necessary).</p><p>For projects with substantial completeness or viability challenges (especially for 90 day collocations), consider indicating within the first screen check letter that a public hearing is tentatively scheduled for a specific date (consider adding placeholders on the hearing calendar), and a disapproval recommendation is likely if items listed in the letter are not resolved <em>XX</em> days prior to the hearing date.</p><p>Encourage carriers to review applicable fire codes early on in the design process. A substantial number of revisions (e.g. antenna re-locations being requested by the carrier after Planning approval) occur due to project plans not in compliance, such as rules on smoke control, antennas near standpipes and emergency exits, cumulative levels of battery acids in a given room at co-location sites, and equipment (such as “RRUs”) impeding clearance within stairwells.</p><p><strong>Create Citywide Template Conditions of Approval | </strong>Consider creating conditions of approval that would automatically apply if a deemed granted action (automatic approvals) occurs. Conditions could address security, time limits (expiration), site maintenance, obtaining CEQA clearance, brush clearance for fire safety, fencing (e.g. rules on fence height/material and barb/razor wire usage), knox boxes (police/fire access during emergencies), landscaping, light glare/spill, aircraft lighting, noise limits, generator usage, and painting of exposed antenna/enclosure elements. <a href="http://www.cityofcalabasas.com/pdf/wireless/Wireless_Facility_Ordinance-w_CC_Changes052312.pdf">Example link</a>. Consider adopting an ordinance/conditions stating that entitlements will lapse/expire for wireless facilities that have been abandoned/inactive for more than six (6) months.</p><p><strong>Remedying Ongoing Code Violations | </strong>As many local governments face a challenge of wireless carriers improperly developing (<em>antennas/equipment in unapproved locations, missing screening, or using equipment not compliant with electrical codes</em>), maintaining or modifying (adding antennas/equipment without permits) wireless facilities; discuss with counsel if an appropriate remedy for repeated and unresolved violations is to decline intake of co-location applications at the same project site and/or new facility applications for the same carrier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/483/1*Fu1l5PwdIMijADUFezE4xA.png" /><figcaption><em>What was approved</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*_A1a4JPLgW9pp7nnjvk1Vw.png" /><figcaption><em>What the neutral host carrier built (antennas &amp; equipment for two distinct wireless carriers) over time without proper permits (Crown Castle for Verizon &amp; Sprint)</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Delegation for Denials| </strong>Evaluate whether current codes/charters allow for administrative denials of applications.</p><p>Allowing for administrative denials (for both conditionally and principally permitted locations) of co-Locations (90 day clock) may be especially useful for those applications normally requiring both a public hearing (including average 20 to 30 day noticing periods before the hearing); where sufficient time isn’t provided to also allow for scheduling of timely appeals. Ensure the denial is based on information in the written record.</p><p>Determine if staff denials of certain types of entitlements can be appealed, by the carrier, to a specific hearing body that is best suited to review such a project.</p><p>Determine if appeal requirements, such as requiring a percentage of neighbor’s signatures in support of an appeal by a wireless carrier (which would seem unlikely to obtain), need to be modified.</p><p><em>Many wireless carrier representatives may not be aware that in many cities/counties, if a project is actually denied at a public hearing, the carrier can’t come back for a public hearing, at the same project site, for time periods of six months, a year, or more. It may be prudent to discuss this issue with carrier representatives prior to public hearings.</em></p><p><strong>Sequencing for Multiple Review Bodies | </strong>Take a look at the order of hearings required for certain types of wireless facilities and whether changes should be made. For instance, determine if variances (<em>e.g. to place large equipment areas in a rear yard, or for height exceptions</em>) require a separate application that can be heard after the original Conditional Use Permit. If the agency requires some type of Coastal Act review prior to the entitlement, it may be better to reverse the review. AB 57 does not appear to apply to the Coastal Commission’s own review. Also determine if separate public design review hearing requirements (if applicable) should be waived for certain types of fully screened rooftop-mounted co-locations.</p><p><strong>Work with Building Department Staff | </strong>Many cities/counties face ongoing challenges of wireless carriers not developing/modifying sites correctly, per the approved plans and photo simulations, and conditions of approval. Therefore, if the City/County doesn’t currently require a Planner to visit the site before a building permit is completed (final inspection), then consider having the photo simulations (in a clear format) added to the plan set on a sheet preceding the site plan sheet. This makes it easy for both the contractor and building inspector to compare the facility to what was approved, while they are out in the field, since the case packet (and photo simulations) often doesn’t make it to the contractor. <br> <br>Also consider adding a stamp to building plan approvals (or permits by Public Works for public right of way permits) to require the contractor to send site photos to the case planner before calling for a final building (or public works) inspection. Ideally, the Building or Public Works inspector won’t sign off until they see the reply e-mail back from the case planner affirming the site appears correctly built.</p><p>Some cities/counties do not release electrical permits (to allow power to be turned on) for wireless facilities until it is determined the design is consistent with the approval. This is especially relevant for faux trees, given the challenge involved with inadequate construction (<em>exposed antennas/equipment, wrong installation locations, inconsistent foliage colors</em>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*x6eiIy7RqVkH0hDxI9JvOQ.png" /><figcaption>A sad excuse for a mono-palm in the San Fernando Valley. Well-designed tree examples have been created by firms such as <a href="http://utilitycamo.com/">Larsen Camo</a>,<a href="http://www.stealthconcealment.com/"> STEALTH</a>, <a href="http://www.steelheadmetals.com/custom-wireless.php">Steelhead</a>, and <a href="http://www.aglmediagroup.com/trees-branches-and-foliage/">Chameleon</a>.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hI7_KST1MSCbm0SHhZhlWA.jpeg" /><figcaption>What was approved (faux stairwell penthouse — with roof)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/441/1*80OxsmuKlXa_xQJ-pb6swA.png" /><figcaption>What was initially built (B&amp;V). Roof left off of faux stairwell penthouse and side walls too short to accommodate height of panel antennas. <em>Lesson Learned: Ensure the person creating the plan sheets depicting screening has also reviewed the photo simulations.</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Environmental Review Consultants | </strong>If a project involves complex CEQA review and the City/County doesn’t have staff in-house to adequately review reports (<em>e.g. archaeology, habitat surveys, storm water quality, geotechnical</em>) consider requiring the wireless carrier to have such studies commissioned before application submittal, and then using a separate consultant (from a list already created by the Department) to review the documentation.</p><p>Make sure the reviews take in the full project scope such as new access roads, excavation, trenching, lighting, and noise. Work through a checklist early on in the review in order to make sure items aren’t missed by staff or the carrier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/405/1*V8jIMtBXDnWbuROJDR2Qkw.png" /><figcaption>Remember that a rural freestanding wireless facility may also need a new access road along with fuel storage tanks, equipment shelters, grading and trenching</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Amend City leasing templates &amp; Work with nearby local districts (water, vector, flood control) and other government agencies | </strong>Determine if those agencies leases can be modified to expressly make<em> </em>property owner approval contingent upon specific “actual” approval (not a deemed granted automatic approval) by the local jurisdiction.</p><p>Consider reaching out to the local Caltrans District office to understand how referrals/reviews can/would occur for new wireless facilities along freeways, and if there are opportunities to require remediation of existing wireless facilities that are poorly designed as needed (or when leases are up for renewal). Cities/counties can request that new neighborhood serving wireless facilities on Caltrans right of-way be reviewed by the City (e.g. Planning Commission). This issue is particularly prescient as some State agencies sell off surplus land (that may have a tower on it) to private property owners.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/533/1*5Wr9y6H1IceDNM32JxRZSw.png" /><figcaption>Not quite a faux tree, and in need of major remediation….(and why sites on Caltrans PROW should go through City/County review)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Shot Clock Extensions that are workable | </strong>If a tolling agreement is requested (to extend the shot clock), consider amending it to include enough time for BOTH initial public hearings and a further extension for any timely appeals (if they are filed).</p><p>Also, consider advising local carrier representatives that they should try to be empowered (before the hearing) to sign a tolling agreement (they typically aren’t) at the public hearing, if the clock is running close and a hearing body isn’t supportive of the application and seeks a continuance to revise the design or resolve a siting challenge.</p><p>This may avoid instances where the Planner or City Attorney has to request that the hearing body (e.g. Planning Commission) decide on an approval/disapproval motion, because of the impending State’s Shot Clock issue; when the carrier’s representative isn’t empowered (at that moment) to request a tolling agreement, even if the carrier representative is “personally willing” to do so in order to resolve an unanticipated issue.</p><p><strong>Define Ridgelines and Vistas | </strong>Identifying significant ridgelines or vistas that define a community in public documents (<em>such as the General Plan, Wireless Guidelines, or Zoning Code</em>) can be especially useful in making findings regarding the approval/disapproval (or design recommendations) of wireless facilities. This is especially important for freestanding screened (faux water tank or windmill) or unscreened (monopoles) towers, and Small Cells (especially those proposed on brand new wooden poles), which are also known as Outdoor Distributed Antenna Systems, or the acronym “oDAS” (antennas and equipment cabinets on utility poles in the public right-of-way).</p><p><strong>Avoid moratoriums | </strong>The new State law may complicate efforts to impose a moratorium on certain types of facilities that represent a new siting type in a given community. Consider, for example, working early on to adopt rules for wireless facilities in the public right-of-way (<em>e.g. height and size limits, noise standards [cooling fans], screening of potential ground-mounted equipment, and neighborhood notification boundaries</em>) if they aren’t already in place.</p><p><strong>Coastal Commission Timing and Entitlement Processing | </strong>Determine the types of configurations (facility type, location, etc.) that require the issuance of a Coastal Development Permit. If the California Coastal Commission has not certified a Local Coastal Program for the agency, the Coastal Commission may retain approval authority over any required coastal permits. The Coastal Commission may also retain permanent coastal permit authority within certain areas of the jurisdiction. In order to comply with all FCC “shot clock” deadlines, Coastal Commission approval, when required, follow the local agency’s determination. AB 57 does not appear to apply to any reviews or entitlements processed by the Coastal Commission. If the agency requires Coastal Act consideration prior to review and/or approval of the requisite local entitlements (e.g. Conditional Use Permit or Administrative Use Permit), it may be beneficial to reverse the order of review or process all reviews concurrently.</p><p><strong>Noticing Materials up front | </strong>AB 57 refers to notification materials required for the application. This <strong>may</strong> complicate instances where additional types of notification materials are required as the project scope changes after the initial submittal. Keep an eye on whether this applies and notify the project sponsor early on.</p><p>In some cities and counties, disapproving a principally permitted application, requires a public hearing. Determine if notification materials (e.g. surrounding property owner labels) are required. The carrier may decline to provide such labels (since they weren’t required up front as part of the application) and you’ll have to decide whether to create them in-house, or to waive such a requirement. Or, to require adjacent owner labels for all sites up front (which may not be viable).</p><p><strong>Inform Commissioners and the Public | </strong>Determine if resolutions of approval (and public notices for the original hearing as well as appeal applications) should include an informational clause about State law potentially abridging timely appeal rights (e.g. up to City Council or Board of Supervisors) for wireless facilities.</p><p>If your City/County hasn’t yet seen installations of antennas &amp; equipment in the public right-of-way, consider holding an information session with your community leaders to discuss challenges/opportunities.</p><p><strong>Fast Track Appeals | </strong>Determine if it is possible to fast-track appeals, since the new State law provides no clear exception for due process. <em>Some folks have raised the concern that the law conflicts with the Permit Streamlining Act. That may have to be decided in the courts one day.</em></p><p><strong>Pre-approval of Screened Co-locations | </strong>If approving a co-locatable structure (e.g. a faux water tank), consider adding language to pre-approve a future carrier (via a building permit) if they meet certain metrics (<em>e.g. all transmitting antennas are stealthed, the GPS antenna and ancillary equipment [e.g. access ladders and generator plugs] is not visible from public right-of-way, equipment areas are both screened and adhere to a specific noise standard</em>).</p><p><strong>Coordinate intakes</strong> | Since a City/County has only 10 days from re-submittal (after the first incomplete letter) to indicate if an application is still incomplete (and pause the clock); consider requiring re-submittal appointments or ensuring administrative support staff (in Building/Planning/Public Works) immediately routes re-submittal materials to the assigned case planner (or public works reviewer).</p><p><strong>Fire Station Exemption</strong>| The law (automatic approval remedy) would not apply to applications for new facilities and collocations at fire stations. In most cities/counties, the antennas (e.g. thin “whip” antennas typically mounted on the roof) serving public safety (police/fire) purposes often do not require the same process (such as public hearings) as a commercial wireless facility (larger panel antennas and substantial equipment areas).</p><p>As the bill wound its way through the State Capitol, local governments raised concern with organizations representing firefighters that the changing language of the legislation was unclear if project review (planning, design, historic preservation and environmental), public hearings, and complex building and fire code (construction plan) review have to all occur within the 90/150 day clocks.</p><p>In fact, the first versions (shepherded by Verizon) of the (AB 57) legislation almost inadvertently got rid of the ability for a wireless carrier to even ask for an extension of the clock (tolling agreement); which would have been to the detriment of the wireless industry.</p><p>In response to initial opposition by firefighters, the bill’s sponsors inserted the additional language to gain their support. In reality, the bill language likely has no discernable effect since the city/county can still require more application review time anyways for a commercial wireless facility, in its capacity as the fire station’s property owner.</p><p>Lastly, it does not appear this bill would resolve some of the types of challenges that occurred with the new “FirstNet” (public safety network) rollout in Los Angeles County. Significant opposition came about (just prior to hearings for AB 57) from LA-area firefighters and neighbors to proposed FirstNet installations that involved approximately 70-foot tall freestanding steel monopoles, with panel antennas, at fire stations in areas such as residential neighborhoods.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*53kvjKvEMNedNsHDfrLQBw.png" /><figcaption>Monopole at a public safety facility in Los Angeles County. Panel antennas would serve police/fire systems and provide high speed data. This would compliment the existing “land mobile radio” (LMR) systems which involve primarily (fewer) hilltop mounted “whip” antennas used to provide basic voice services to handheld and vehicle radios. The author wonders if less intrusive means can be used such as single form antennas (multiple antennas in one enclosure the size of a school blackboard) mounted on the sides of bridges and flyovers.</figcaption></figure><h3>Additional Resources</h3><ul><li><a href="http://www.cityofcalabasas.com/wireless.html">City of Calabasas Wireless Facility Application Checklists</a></li><li><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wirelessforms">San Francisco Wireless Facility Application Checklists</a></li><li><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/index.aspx?page=1648">Best Practices for Rooftop-Mounted Micro Wireless Facilities (Bulletin #3)<br> <em>Many of the design/siting practices &amp; examples also apply to rooftop-mounted “Macro” (large) facilities.</em></a></li><li><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wirelessforms">Design Preferences for Wireless (oDAS/Small Cells) On Wooden Poles<br> </a><em>These preferences focus on narrower rights-of-way, where ground-mounted equipment cabinets (computers or batteries and electric meters are strongly disfavored, so all of the equipment remains on the pole.</em></li><li><a href="http://www.slideshare.net/omarmasry/slides-from-a-wireless-cellular-design-panel?related=1">Slide from a Design Discussion for Wireless Facilities</a> <br> <em>Presented at a Joint Venture Silicon Valley forum</em></li><li><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B7pIZT7oVSp7eHlvdTNTRHFRQkU/view">Presentation on the FCC Report and Order (6409) at the League of California Cities</a></li><li><a href="https://www.cacities.org/Resources-Documents/Member-Engagement/Professional-Departments/City-Attorneys/Library/2015/2015-Spring-Conference/5-2015-Spring-Harriet-Steiner-FCC-s-Wireless-Facil.aspx">League of California Cities article on Section 6409</a><em> (starting on Page 11).</em></li><li><a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">A wireless industry view on State rules for wireless in the public right-of-way.</a> <em>Includes an interesting “history lesson” on how old rules for telegraph lines affect wireless review now.</em></li><li><a href="http://rpv.granicus.com/MetaViewer.php?view_id=5&amp;clip_id=2458&amp;meta_id=22072">Recent City of Rancho Palos Verdes urgency ordinance for wireless facilities in the public right-of-way (oDAS/Small Cells)</a></li></ul><p><strong>MobileNow Act on the horizon | </strong>A wholly separate <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/n67ln4v09cwtl2d/Mobile%20Now.pdf?dl=0"><strong>draft</strong> (Federal) law</a> recently before some Congress members may prohibit cities/counties from: 1) placing time limits on approvals (<em>e.g. 10 year limits on Conditional Use Permits for wireless that many local governments have in place</em>); 2) limit local* discretion (e.g. noise limits) over (noisy diesel) generators, that are sometimes installed at wireless facilities; and 3) prohibit requiring proof that a new site is needed to meet a service/capacity gap, based on RF signal/noise studies (no more city/county requirements for coverage maps). These rules may further hinder community appropriate wireless siting. *It’s unclear what effect the law, if approved would have on generator permitting by many regional air quality districts in California.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/596/1*l-zWXGaam1aUsuomgauJFg.png" /><figcaption>Some of the concerns noted by the US Conference of Mayors (extract)</figcaption></figure><h3>Common items not consistently depicted on plans and photo simulations for new rooftop-mounted sites and modifications to existing sites</h3><p><strong>· Cable trays</strong> with exposed conduit at the ends (e.g. before it enters the building). Consider the use of faux hot water pipes instead. Ensure cable trays do not run over residential windows.</p><p>· <strong>Caged access ladders</strong> that are often left off the original plans and photo simulations. In a few instances (e.g. small residential-historic buildings) the carrier may need to use a man-lift (truck) instead to access the roof.</p><p>· <strong>Cross bracing</strong>. Ensure there are no horizontal bars between a group of freestanding antennas (or those in faux vent pipes). It is not uncommon for carriers to leave such bracing out of photo simulations and the initial set of project plans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*LBDDNb0Ks8xQGpYAZR0D-g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Disfavored cross bracing between freestanding antennas</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Doghouses</strong> not shown.</p><p>·<strong> Driveways</strong> (new) to access outdoor ground-mounted equipment areas at the back of the property.</p><p>· <strong>Generator Plugs / Cam Locks</strong> not shown on original submittals. Ensure their placement doesn’t detract from a potentially historic storefront. This is the receptacle (socket) that generators on trailers are plugged into, and used power the facility after a major power outage.</p><p>· <strong>GPS antenna</strong>s unnecessarily visible from street. In many instances they can be attached to a mid-roof cable tray (the property owner will not count it toward the carriers lease area). GPS antennas can be painted to match another color instead of bright white. Ensure plans show location and height. Some manufacturers (e.g.<a href="http://www.commscope.com/catalog/andrew/product_details.aspx?id=6590"> Commscope</a>) of primary transmitting antennas make versions with a GPS antenna integrated into the top of the antenna.</p><p><strong>· HVAC Units</strong> (condensers) that may cause a massing and/or noise concern if placed near a residential window.</p><p>·<strong> Noise. </strong>If a new equipment cabinet or backup generator is being installed, ensure the noise levels will be compatible. In some instances a cabinets that meets noise standards may cause concern if it’s placed in a narrow lightwell, and creates an echo effect.</p><p>· <strong>Radio-Frequency Barriers/Fences</strong> not adequately shown on the photo simulations, site plans or elevation sheets. Often a 2.5 foot tall barrier will suffice; instead of a 4-foot tall barrier (<em>especially since we don’t typically see snow drifts piling on most coastal California rooftops that would obscure view of the barrier</em>).</p><p>· <strong>Radio Relay Units (RRUs/RRHs)</strong> left off photo simulations, but shown on project plans in locations that are likely visible from nearby sidewalks. <em>RRUs are essentially computers the size of suitcases which filter/boost power/signal for faster data speeds. Wireless carriers prefer these to be as close to antennas as possible. A large facility may have 6 to 24 of them, per carrier. Often times photo simulations leave out the potential visibility of RRUs and the large bundles of cabling entering the RRU. Many RRUs feature visible manufacturer logos that should be relocated or covered with a screen plate.</em></p><p><strong>· Screening </strong>where the underside of the screen box is left exposed with visible dangling cables. Or faux vent pipes on roofs without parapets where the tripod and cabling may end up being visible, if a shroud is not used at the base. <em>Always check to make sure the screening wraps around the side sufficiently, so the equipment is not exposed to view as a pedestrian travels nearby.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/721/1*fB4JVz0hax747oHHBbmplQ.png" /><figcaption>Incomplete vent pipe on a building with no parapet. Additional cladding needed at base.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>· Screening</strong> with a “low-cost version” featuring visible protruding bolts and rivet points akin to an old warship. Plans should clearly indicate a smooth surface painted to match adjacent wall surfaces. For a color that should blend well with the sky (for rooftop elements) consider “Ponder” (non-glossy) by Sherwin-Williams, or equivalent.</p><p><strong>· Vent stacks and fuel lines for generators</strong> (if present)</p><p>· <strong>Work lights.</strong> These are small lights on rods rising a few feet above the primary equipment area. They are used by technicians to work on a facility at night. Sometimes plans and photo simulations do not account for the potential visibility of this item. Consider requiring the work light to be placed on a hinge so it can be swiveled up above the equipment area, but only when needed.</p><h3>Areas of consideration for Public Right of Way Facilities (known as Small Cells, or oDAS)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*ZIZIpMDrDzVJe8ywi31uJg.png" /><figcaption><em>Poorly designed facility in the public right-of-way along a coastal highway, with AT&amp;T Mobility panel antennas on a utility pole, along with a wide bundles of cabling below, and a ground mounted equipment area (partially screened except top of cabinet and GPS antenna) in a location next to a Federal land (open space), that also detracts from the scenic route.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Also, consider reaching out to the local electric provider to discuss whether wireless metering (no meter box with glass bubble — uses a small antenna to communicate with the SmartMeter network) or “line drops” (<em>flat rate charge for electricity, without a meter box, as is often used in SDG&amp;E service areas</em>) options are available to reduce the need for additional equipment on the pole, or on a separate freestanding meter pedestal in the public right-of-way.</p><p>Consider establishing noise (due to cooling fans), size, height and equipment area rules. In some places the street speed or number of lanes can be a useful metric for where larger oDAS systems (example below) are not allowed. In areas with a wider right-of-way (and no conflict with sidewalk widths for handicapped accessibility), moving all equipment (and meters) off the pole (except the antenna) may be less intrusive.</p><p>Even if a brand new pole (<em>twenty to forty foot average height, and located in the public right-of-way</em>) with wireless antennas and equipment boxes appears potentially palatable in a given area (e.g. rural road), there appears to be little reason the local government can’t require steel light poles instead of wooden poles (with cabling hidden inside and a decorative base to hide equipment); or visual mitigation for ground-mounted equipment cabinets such as underground enclosures, or faux decorative wood lattice screen covers (made of metal with texturing and painting to mimic wood) that are under four feet tall, and landscaping combined with modest berming of soil. Or, perhaps placing ground-mounted electronic equipment in fake vintage wood wine/whiskey barrels along mostly treeless rural canyon roads with equestrian trails.</p><p>In some cities each encroachment permit (to trench or build in the right of way) require City Council approval. Determine if approval authority should instead be delegated to the Public Works Director. This may be useful as there could be a timing challenge if appeals have to go to another hearing body first, then go to the next City Council meeting (if the appeal is denied).</p><p>Some cities include conditions within the utilities conditions permit (UCP) to require utilities (including wireless facilities on wooden utility poles) to be removed if the city begins undergrounding of wooden utility poles.</p><p>In some residential or historic areas, if a pole top antenna (instead of a side arm midway up the pole holding up the antenna) is proposed, it may be best to require the entire pole to be replaced, so that the pole can taper toward the top-mount antenna, instead of an unsightly (non-uniform profile and utility prohibitions on painting) bayonet arm (stick holding up an arm with a clamp attached to the top of the pole) rising 3 to 8 feet above the top of the pole to hold up the antenna.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/898/1*gr65Y3lO1Q-ucn05qL97xA.png" /><figcaption><em>Example of an intrusive Public Right-of-Way Wireless Facility featuring bulky unscreened cabinets within the Public Right-of-Way (on a nicely landscaped street in an undergrounded area). Credit: Public Document.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/449/1*RS6MBNOTXqHrz2jFMl96-w.png" /><figcaption><em>Example of a poorly designed oDAS (outdoor distributed antenna system) on a utility pole. Grey cabinets are the radio relay units (computers). Large box below features (optional) batteries (with noise generating cooling fans) for backup power. The electric meter is at the bottom of the pole, and multiple panel antennas are up top. Extra service loops of cabling were (for some unknown reason) left on pole.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Be skeptical of claims that the overall wooden pole height needs to be increased 13 to 20 feet taller than the existing wood pole in order to meet utility (vertical separation) rules, as they may not actually be true. Also:</p><ol><li>In some instances carriers have been willing to reduce the proposed pole height increase when they know the local government is inclined to deny the proposal (especially in single-family neighborhoods where a 50 foot tall pole would appear out of place).</li><li>At most an 8 foot extension may be needed above high voltage lines (bear in mind some wires are used for fiber-optic or copper wires for communications and do not require the same vertical separation).</li><li>In some instances the use of wireless metering (so that an extra meter box is not needed) and/or relocation of some equipment to a second pole may reduce the need for a pole height increase. In more limited instances, routing power or communication lines from a nearby pole on the same side of the street, first, before crossing the street may reduce the need for a pole height increase in order to accommodate required line separation and vehicle clearance heights as the wires cross a public street.</li><li>Moving a portion of the equipment (e.g. optional battery backup cabinet and shut down switch) to another pole may allow for height reductions.</li></ol><h4><a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">Article link providing a wireless industry point of view on wireless in the public right-of-way.</a></h4><p>· <strong>Antennas. </strong>Radome style antennas offer a more uniform profile than multiple panel antennas. Multiple short panel antennas are often made even more visible given the bulky mechanical tilt brackets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/175/1*tolRJrgzt_wumOsqquXxHw.png" /><figcaption>Older physical tilt bracket holding up the antenna that may not be needed with new antenna models.</figcaption></figure><p>However, many slightly longer (newer) panel antennas feature electronic tilt mechanisms built-in, which can allow for a panel antenna to be mounted in a manner that is more flush to the pole/bracket. Manufacturers also offer cable shrouds, which can make each panel antenna “look longer” but reduce visibility of multiple cables entering the bottom of the antenna.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/1*vPEcfOKpmkzNZrGw2cP3PQ.png" /><figcaption>Cable shroud below a panel antenna to hide cables (not shown)</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Battery Backup Cabinets.</strong> These are optional elements with lead acid or nickel cadmium batteries to run the facility in the event of power outages. Though with a more limited uptime compared to larger battery systems and generators used at “macro” rooftop or tower mounted sites. There are manufacturers, such as TSi Power, which offer battery cabinets that are about as wide as the pole, though longer, and are generally preferable to bulky enclosures about three times as wide as the pole that may be more noticeable as traveling down the street, and more likely to obstruct views from nearby residential windows.</p><p>· <strong>Bayonet/Pole Height Extensions.</strong> The use of a bayonet (4 x 4 post with metal clamps) to mount an antenna above the top of the pole can appear incongruous (change in profile, and prohibition of painting of the clamps and bayonet by utilities) with the pole. In more sensitive scenic, historic, or residential areas, it may be best to require the carrier to replace the entire pole so that the new pole tapers toward the antenna. Many initial photo simulations do not show the bayonet mounted correctly in terms of location (typically cannot be mounted in the center of the existing poletop), and lack of paint to match the existing pole or antenna.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/158/1*JJxEQoAeQUcZnB06cSRvQw.png" /><figcaption>Avoid the use of offset conduit elements that resemble a ladder (not needed)</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Cabling.</strong> Encourage the use of solid and narrow conduit pipes or flexible rubber elements running up the outside of wood poles to avoid the cluttered look of multiple power and communications cables. These elements can often be painted (to match the pole) and retain the paint color better than individual cables. Avoid instances where the carrier utilizes a ladder type system running up the pole with conduit offset a few inches from the wood pole. In some instances the photo simulations may not accurately depict this item. For steel poles ensure cabling will run inside the pole with clear notes indicating such on plan sets.</p><p>· <strong>Combiners/duplexers.</strong> These elements are often placed near the antenna and roughly the size of jewelry boxes. For side arm mounted antennas on wood poles, encourage the use of mounting arms with the combiners placed inside. Ensure these elements are shown (if needed) on plans and photo simulations, and ensure that they can be painted to match the pole (doing so will not void a warranty).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p5eBjBZQqAWZ4fauPsS6oA.png" /><figcaption>Side-arm mount for an antenna on a wooden utility pole. The arm has been designed so as to also “hide” the cabling and couplers inside the arm. Credit: Cable Engineering Services.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/420/1*5LdZUKohzwhc7SYLXkH3iw.png" /><figcaption>Credit: AdvanceSim</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Completeness.</strong> It is not uncommon for submittal to leave out known required elements (e.g. nearby freestanding electric meter pedestals, combiners, cabling). Request carrier to affirm in writing if the submittal is complete with respect to all elements needed to operate the facility (including those elements required by the utility and backhaul provider).</p><p>· <strong>Dual Poles.</strong> In locations where the carrier is proposing a substantial number of boxes on a single pole, and the public right-of-way is narrow (making ground mounted equipment problematic) consider requiring the carrier to place a portion of the equipment (e.g. battery backup, electric meter, shutdown switch) on a second nearby (existing) pole.</p><p>· <strong>Electricity.</strong> Encourage the use of wireless metering (<em>small grapefruit sized antenna that connects to existing “SmartMeter” networks</em>) or line drops (carrier pays an estimated flat billing rate for electricity) to avoid the need for new electric meter enclosures (whether on a separate freestanding pedestal or attached to the pole). If an electric meter enclosure is necessary, then require a slim meter enclosure that is about as wide as the pole (<em>instead of bulky meters nearly twice as wide of the pole, that often become graffiti targets).</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xWPoKL-QFKdC3tHIoH8k9g.png" /><figcaption>Credit AdvanceSim</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Excavation.</strong> Ensure the project scope (and environmental review) takes into account excavation that may be needed for new/replacement poles, equipment vaults, or backhaul (underground fiber-optic cables). <em>Avoid instances, as occurred in one town (where the town was not consulted on the project), where the carrier apparently excavated in areas with known Native American burial grounds.</em></p><p>· <strong>Fiber (PBX) Boxes</strong>. This is a box typically placed near the bottom of a wood pole and used to connect (backhul fiber) the wireless facility to the local “wireline” carrier. Ensure the box is shown, if needed, and ensure it is painted to match other adjacent equipment. Manufacturers of such boxes have not expressed a concern with painting such boxes.</p><p>· <strong>GPS Antenna</strong>. In some, but not all instances the carrier may need to add a GPS antenna. However, many plans and photo simulations often leave out this item. Some manufacturers (e.g.<a href="http://www.commscope.com/catalog/andrew/product_details.aspx?id=6590"> Commscope</a>) of primary transmitting antennas make versions with a GPS antenna integrated into the top of the main antenna. Evaluate opportunities to use the smallest GPS antenna available (e.g. versions the size of a shot cup instead of versions the size of large pear).</p><p>· <strong>Ground-Mounted Equipment.</strong> Ensure plans and photo simulations (not based on Google StreetView photos) accurately depict the height and massing of such elements. Have carrier affirm in writing that no other enclosures are required, including but not limited to electric meter pedestals. Determine if screening elements should be utilized such as an undergounded vault (with an above ground vent stack for ventilation and moisture pump out), soil berming, landscaping, or faux wood lattice screens (made of steel but painted and textured to mimic wood).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iiRftmYusASzLqZX1krqHw.png" /><figcaption>Antenna on pole, equipment in vaults below sidewalk, and vent stacks tucked into landscaping. Credit: celltowersites.com</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Grounding.</strong> For City-owned poles, ensure new ground rods won’t damage sidewalks or pole bases (underground).</p><p>· <strong>Guy Wires.</strong> Determine if new guy wires (used to anchor the pole to the ground) are needed and clearly shown in plans and photo simulations (they are often left out of initial submittals). Replacing the pole may negate the need for guy wires.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/476/1*9sHHfkbpu2qohWbo8KpVow.png" /><figcaption>Unnecessary flashing lights on enclosure midway up pole</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Lights.</strong> Add conditions of approval prohibiting flashing lights (visible from nearby residences or sidewalks) on equipment enclosures. Also, if side-arm mounted antennas are being added to existing wooden poles with streetlights, ensure the antenna placement won’t significantly impair street lighting. In some instances it may be best to have the carrier arrange for a longer light arm to be installed by the utility.</p><p>· <strong>Noise. </strong>Determine if equipment uses passive cooling (no noise) or requires cooling fans. If cooling fans are utilized have carrier provide the noise profile on the cover sheet of project plans. In quiet residential areas, carrier may need to either set fans to turn off at night, or turn off based on a thermostat. In other instances a slightly larger enclosure may allow for a larger fan that can turn slower and generate less noise.</p><p>· <strong>Overhead Wires. </strong>In undergrounded areas (no existing wood poles), ensure no new “aerial” or overhead lines (electricity or fiber-optic) are being utilized. It is not uncommon for the initial submittals to omit these items. Request carrier to affirm in writing.</p><p>· <strong>Paint. </strong>Have noted added to cover sheet, site plan and elevation sheets regarding painting of Antennas, Brackets, Cabling/Conduit, Electric Meters (except the glass bubble), Equipment Enclosures, and Fiber Termination Boxes. Non-glossy colors such as Sable (for brown poles) or Ponder (for washed out grey poles near ocean areas), by Sherwin-Williams, may be good choices.</p><p>· <strong>Pole offset. </strong>Ensure the offset of enclosures from the wood poles (gap between pole and boxes) is shown on the plan set. Avoid an offset greater than 4 inches (typical minimum allowed by wooden pole owners in California).</p><p>· <strong>Photo Simulations</strong>. Ensure photo simulations are not based on Google StreetView photos. Photo simulations should show all requirement elements of facility that may be visible (they often don’t) and provide a realistic depiction of cabling/conduit (they often don’t).</p><p>· <strong>Project Plans</strong>. Ensure the carrier uses a nearest building address that nearby neighbors will recognize (if public notification required). Consider requiring a site completion checklist and/or photo simulations to be added to the plans.</p><p>If plans and photo simulations are mailed to nearby residents, make sure the address listed by the carrier, is one that residents would recognize (it often isn’t). Consider indicating the noise profile on the cover sheet, such as “maximum of XX decibels from 6 feet away,” or “no noise generation (passive cooling).</p><p>Then again thanks to the FCC’s interpretation of “6409,” the day after carrier builds a small, and noiseless system on a non-city owned wouldn’t utility pole, they can demand the ability to replace the system with one featuring larger (refrigerator sized) cabinets with loud cooling fans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/325/1*mVbRC9pk3KUYjDGdo55Ohw.png" /><figcaption>Excessive stickers/decals not needed at this location. Three different RF warning stickers may cause a resident to think the facility has an unusually high RF emissions level.</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>RF Warning Stickers. </strong>Require plans and photo simulations to show location of RF warning stickers. Avoid placement of stickers near ground level on equipment enclosures where they appear cluttered and are not generally needed (sticker should be a few feet below antenna to inform utility personnel who may climb the pole).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eqdOG_9R_0ZQW6sLl_He8w.png" /><figcaption>Multiple repetitive stickers, tangled cabling and unpainted AT&amp;T fiber termination box (lime green element). Require carrier to place RF warning sticker only near the actual antenna further up the pole, and place a carrier ID sticker on the underside or back of the equipment, with a sticker background color which matches the equipment.</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Sidewalk vault lids. </strong>Condition approvals to ensure no logos or commercial names are added to new sidewalk vault lids (if needed). Descriptions such as wireless or telecom may be appropriate.</p><p>· <strong>Stickers and Decals. </strong>Condition approvals to require that all prominent logos and decals to be removed, painted over, or filled in (e.g. for indented Ericsson logos on mRRUs), if visible from surrounding sidewalks. Also require that carrier identification stickers be placed on the underside of enclosures, or if not possible, utilize a sticker background that is the same color as the painted enclosure surface) and no larger than 3 inches by 5 inches.</p><p>· <strong>Trees.</strong> Some local governments require the carrier to plant a street tree near the pole to reduce visibility of equipment on the pole.</p><p>Ensure that trenching (if needed) and overall facility construction does not damage existing trees (especially heritage trees), or that they are replaced at a 3:1 ratio. Additionally, one challenge often encountered by many local governments is when crews (in spite of rules already in place) running fiber-optic cables begin topping off nearby trees that harms them. It may be advisable to require crews obtaining street closure and/or encroachment permits to affirm in writing they are aware of such requirements, or notify City arborists of pending activity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*zZxZ6Lrj4D-ZeoxI0MJAKA.png" /><figcaption><a href="http://pvestates.granicus.com/MetaViewer.php?view_id=1&amp;event_id=36&amp;meta_id=19858">Proposed Crown Castle DAS node in the City of Palos Verdes Estates</a>. Replacement of existing stop sign.</figcaption></figure><p>See also: <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/ftp/files/currentplanning/wireless/wireless_Design_Preferences_for_Wireless_Facilities_August2015.pdf">Design preferences for oDAS on wooden utility poles</a></p><h4>Omar Masry, AICP, and Tripp May testified before the California State Assembly and State Senate on AB 57. The information contained herein does not reflect policy of any government agency.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9X0hgqfeMmt999XxmyPanw.png" /><figcaption>Proposed Extenet Systems (for Verizon Wireless) Small Cell (pole-top antenna and two computer boxes midway down pole) on a San Francisco light pole (Davit pole replaced with a standard steel tapered light pole) See also <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wireless">www.sf-planning.org/wireless</a></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=39d864a876d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Supplement: Tools for Adapting to AB 57 (New California Law on Cell Towers)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/supplement-tools-for-adapting-to-ab-57-5b53c78ac5bb?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b53c78ac5bb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[telecommunication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[landuse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Jan 2016 19:30:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-09T06:06:37.929Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="http://norcalapa.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Feb16.pdf">Link back to original AB 57 Article</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8tYitm5XM7A6I4OYojMPaQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*od5B82KqmHCo1moa31dgOg.png" /><figcaption>Remember that a rural freestanding wireless facility, like this (multi-carrier) one in New Mexico, may also need a new access road along with diesel generators, fuel storage tanks, equipment shelters, grading and trenching (celltowerphotos.com)</figcaption></figure><h3><a href="http://www.slideshare.net/omarmasry/a-city-planners-perspective-on-wireless-facility-siting"><strong>Slides from a February 2016 Seminar on Wireless Facility Siting</strong></a></h3><p><strong>Don’t Accept Incomplete Applications | </strong>Make it clear in application forms that applications will be considered “incomplete” (or decline to accept the application) if:</p><ul><li>Any existing on-site wireless facilities were not built, modified or maintained correctly (request current site photos and prior plans/permits in submittal forms).</li><li>There are current Municipal (Building, Fire) Code Violations at the Project Site.</li><li>Commonly expected submittal items are missing. Determine if based on local practice, whether specific exhibits (<em>geo-technical, </em><a href="http://ohp.parks.ca.gov/pages/1068/files/ic_roster.pdf"><em>archaeological surveys</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase_I_environmental_site_assessment"><em>Phase I reports</em></a><em>, and environmental evaluations</em>) should be required for freestanding facilities, or facilities with other major ground disturbances (<em>excavations, access roads, fuel tanks, new equipment/building pads</em>). Indicate these requirements up-front on the application forms.</li></ul><p>Require the wireless carrier to identify up-front on the application form whether they believe the site qualifies as a co-Location. This is important to ensure the local government is not “surprised” (<em>with a deemed granted letter at day 91, for example</em>) that the wireless carrier expected a 90-day clock, when it was originally assumed by staff that a 150-day clock would apply.<br> <br> If the existing facility was built without permits (if they were required); be clear, in the permit application form that such locations are not yet eligible for a co-location.</p><p>Decline to accept new facility applications that are substantially incomplete, and consider suggesting a pre-application instead (especially for new freestanding facilities).</p><p><em>See sample application checklist links in the Resources section further below.</em></p><p><strong>Work with Public Works | </strong>Determine if wireless facilities within the public right-of-way (e.g. antennas &amp; cabinets on utility/light poles) should (or should not) fall under the same process as wireless facilities on buildable lots. Some cities/counties place these rules within the public works code. Other cities/counties require Planning referral as part of an encroachment permit (with the ability to add conditions); while some cities/counties require a Conditional Use Permit for each location. <strong>If you don’t have a process in place; NOW is a good time to get one.</strong></p><blockquote>At a 2013 wireless industry conference, in Dublin, a lawyer who represents wireless carriers, advised carriers to tell city/county Public Works Departments they were installing telephone service, and avoid references to “wireless” or “cellular” in their applications.</blockquote><p><strong><em>One neutral host wireless carrier has been (recently) asking various California cities and counties about installing brand new wooden poles in the public right-of-way (even if right in front of a residence), just to hold up new wireless facilities. </em></strong><a href="http://www.rcrwireless.com/20160125/opinion/analyst-angle-sprints-network-plan-equals-suicide-2-tag9"><strong><em>They’ve indicated doing so will allow for faster and cheaper roll out of small cells.</em></strong></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K1Ccs1IRwfUstC2w4PL8fQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>New wood pole (holding up antennas) and equipment enclosures for a wireless facility (appears to be by “Mobilitie”) in the public right of way (where all other utilities are already undergrounded) in Woodbridge, Virginia</figcaption></figure><p>While State law does grant fairly broad rights to wireless carriers (<em>who posses a Certificate of Public Convenience &amp; Necessity from the CPUC</em>) to enter the public right of way (<em>by granting them similar rights as “telephone corporations”</em>), cities/counties can still establish design criteria (<em>“time, place and manner”</em>) to ensure the wireless facility does not significantly (visually) incommode the public right-of-way; or generate bothersome noise (cooling fans). Cities/counties can also exercise CEQA (e.g. aesthetics, archaeology, historic preservation, and noise) review, beyond any potential CEQA review by the CPUC.</p><p>Avoid instances where Public Works issues an encroachment permit for a “fiber pole” only (without antennas shown on the plans) to an applicant claiming they are installing “plain old (wired) telephone service,” as occurred in Houston (and nearly occurred in one San Diego County town), where antennas and equipment were later added to the new fiber only pole without permits. At a 2013 wireless industry conference, in Dublin, a lawyer who represents wireless carriers, advised carriers to tell city/county Public Works Departments they were installing telephone service, and avoid references to “wireless” or “cellular.”</p><p>While the four national carriers can often install oDAS/Small Cells on poles in the public right-of-way by themselves, they often work with neutral host carriers such as Crown Castle (acquired NextG/Newpath), Extenet Systems, and Mobilitie. <em>Mobilitie also uses another DBA of “California Utility Pole Authority</em>”<em> (no relation to AT&amp;T Mobility or the </em><a href="http://www.scjpc.org/"><em>Southern California Joint Pole Committe</em></a><em>e and the </em><a href="http://www.ncjpa.org/about/"><em>Northern California Joint Pole Associations</em></a><em>)</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cdLeD_3j-YsgcqYUgPKmKg.png" /><figcaption>“DAS XL” with a noise generating (cooling fans) equipment cabinet (computers) and antenna on a PG&amp;E owned wooden light pole</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k3vMkUyxpzIxv7g-Z-Rh3A.png" /><figcaption>The (optional) battery backup cabinet and electric meter are on a separate pole across the street from the DAS “XL” node (with antenna). <a href="http://www.tsipower.com/">TSi Power </a>makes a battery cabinet that is longer, but slimmer (about as wide as the pole) and less likely to impair views as compared to bulkier (about 3 times as wide a the pole) Alpha cabinets typically used.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>See also <em>“Areas of consideration for Public Right of Way Facilities (known as Small Cells, or oDAS)”</em></strong></p><p><strong>Early Warning on Other Items | </strong>Consider creating metrics when other studies, such as a noise study, photometric study (<em>new recreational field lighting w/antennas</em>) or structural analysis are required; and then requiring those studies/submittals up front, on the application checklist.</p><p><em>Example: Provide a noise study for all facilities that include any of the following: outdoor (diesel) generators in areas outside X (industrial zones); and any noise-generating equipment cabinets or condensers, that generate over 45 decibels from three feet away, and are also located within either 10 feet of a residential property line, or within 10 feet of the building face of a school, child care center or retirement home.</em></p><p><em>Example: Provide a (engineer wet-stamped) structural analysis for any new freestanding (screened or unscreened support structures over 15 feet tall) facility, and any facility on wood-framed buildings other than those buildings in X (commercial or industrial zones). Also affirm that there are no conflicting easements or other property restrictions (e.g. underground flood control culverts or pipelines).</em></p><p><strong>Track the Clock </strong>| If a resubmittal is provided by the wireless carrier and the application is complete but still not VIABLE, then consider scheduling a Planning Commission hearing (if required) and indicate the project will be recommended for denial by staff, at the hearing, if a viable (<em>and complete with respect to antennas, equipment, screening, support elements</em>) design is not provided by a specific date (e.g. 45 days before the 90 or 150 day clock, whichever applies).</p><p>Some cities (e.g. Rancho Palos Verdes) require the carrier to notify the City, in writing, of a pending shot clock expiration no later than twenty (20) days prior to the expiration. <em>It may be preferable to also indicate the notice should also not be sent more than forty (40) days before expiration as well.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/417/1*ATz8r7yXQsUKnUboPBuGpQ.png" /><figcaption>Even if a proposal is “complete” the design (especially if on a historic building) may not be viable</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*MzpjgHrmnrslDwYLCYuttA.png" /><figcaption>The second try wasn’t viable either</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*QEmAJ0YMbcK9G_gOdFXYnw.png" /><figcaption>A more viable revision. Notice the use of low profile screen boxes over the equipment (radio relay units) and lack of visible GPS antenna or caged access ladders. Photo simulation by <a href="http://www.photosim.com/">Previsualists</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Community Meetings | </strong>While Planners always make a sincere effort to anticipate potential neighborhood land use concerns with nearly any type of land use development, they can’t predict every issue.</p><p>So, in order to avoid asking for last minute changes to remedy a sincere concern that arises a few days after the upcoming public hearing notice gets mailed out; consider requiring wireless carriers to hold their own community meeting, prior to either considering an application complete or allowing a carrier to submit a new facility (or co-location, depending on neighborhood) application.</p><p>Depending on the level of local challenges and land use patterns, such a requirement could be exempted for wireless facilities that are in wholly industrial/commercial areas; or for screened rooftop facilities, or for co-locations (at existing sites) that are fully screened (with equipment cabinets inside existing non-residential spaces) in certain land use areas.</p><p>If the city/county does decide to require a separate carrier-held community-meeting, make sure the outside of the envelope says something to the effect of “Wireless Facility Neighborhood Notification (or meeting)” in English and any predominant local languages (<em>grey text shouldn’t conflict with USPS mailing rules</em>). Also, require the carrier to send (via first class mail) the notice 10 days before the meeting; and to host the meeting within a certain radius of the site, on days other than Sundays, State holidays, and any relevant local holidays of importance (<em>e.g. lunar new year, or other holidays or teacher preparation days typically noted on calendars created by the local school district, for instance</em>).</p><p><strong>Encourage pre-applications | </strong>Especially for freestanding sites. For new freestanding sites (<em>e.g. new wood or steel poles in public right of way and new steel towers outside of the PROW</em>), be cognizant of issues such as: archaeology, native habitat, brownfields (<em>possible soil contamination or underground storage tanks</em>), easements (private or public agencies), noise (affecting residents or habitat), storm water rules, streambed adjacency (<em>Department of Fish &amp; Game and/or US Army Corps of Engineers may have some purview</em>) and whether the Federal Aviation Administration (see local airport land use plans) may require tower lighting (<em>tip: flashing white lights reduce bird deaths compared to steady red lighting</em>).</p><p>Ensure the project submittal shows the full scope of the facility such as new driveways and how power and communications cables will travel from the tower to any equipment area. Avoid above ground “ice bridges” (<em>which are basically steel cable trays elevated six or more feet above the ground</em>) that may be prominently visible from off-site.</p><p>During the pre-application meeting, ask the wireless carrier’s representative if they understand the application form. It’s not uncommon for carriers (especially for Small Cells/oDAS in the public right-of-way) to fill out the application incorrectly, including checking a YES and NO box next to each other at the same time.</p><p><strong>Establish an alternative site analysis preference | </strong>Consider requiring the carrier to submit documentation showing why a new facility is the least intrusive type of facility, in a given neighborhood. In rural (and some suburban) contexts this could include preferences for: screened rooftop facilities on shopping centers over X acres, any four-story or more commercial building rooftop mount (check on height limit rules for screening), <a href="http://www.cablinginstall.com/articles/2012/02/att-uses-magnets-to-secure-4g-infrastructure.html">magnetic mounts </a>(to hold up antennas) on existing (real) water tanks, freestanding structures integrated with an associated land use (e.g. new bell tower at an existing church), faux water tanks in an industrial area, office/retail center monument signs,<a href="http://www.cnet.com/news/disguised-cell-towers/"> faux trees in areas surrounded by existing mature trees</a> (with a “real” adjacent tree protection plan), and a “<a href="http://www.sanjoseca.gov/DocumentCenter/View/31751">wide slim line</a>” that basically resembles a 36-inch wide vertical rod.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/915/1*FAhl1YOMuiGaTplTc6Rdbg.png" /><figcaption><em>Left Photo: Example of a previously proposed 36-inch wide, 50-foot “tall wide slim line.” Right Photo: Previously installed (</em><a href="http://www.fresno.gov/planningdocs/June042014/A.pdf"><em>link</em></a><em>) 18-inch diameter slim line, in Fresno, and a prior (very bulky) modification proposal.</em></figcaption></figure><p>The older “slimmer” slim lines (typically 18-inch diameter) found in cities such as San Jose and Fresno, are generally considered too slim for wireless carriers, who try to either place radio relay units (RRU/RRH) near the antennas, add more/larger antennas, or run fairly thick bundles of cabling from ground-mounted RRUs to the antennas (leaving little, if any, space for a 2nd carrier’s antennas on the same pole).</p><p>While many community members may prefer zoning ordinances that prohibit all wireless facilities within or near residential zoning districts, this may, depending on a large number of factors, have the negative counter effect of encouraging wireless carriers to forgo rooftop-mounted sites (for example) that may be minimally intrusive (e.g. hidden in a church steeple) and instead seek a larger (overall number of sites) number of antennas and equipment on new or existing poles within the public right of way; and therefore right in front of homes (with equipment boxes potentially in front of windows). Or an even more challenging possibility of proposing antennas and equipment on wooden utility poles that run between adjoining backyards in some relatively older neighborhoods.</p><p>The ability to create large buffers (from residential areas) for wireless facilities is far more limited specific to public right-of-way locations (<em>compared to larger freestanding towers or rooftop-mounted sites on private property</em>), given State law.</p><p><strong>Accept No More Surprises | </strong>It’s all too common for project submittals, by wireless carriers to leave out significant required elements (<em>e.g. wide cable trays proposed running over a residential window, storefront level alterations for new generator plugs or electric meters on historic buildings, or large caged ladders on the edge of a historic residential building</em>) that are not included in the first submittal, or even the second submittal of plans and/or photo simulations. <br> <br> Or, for City staff to see RF safety reports that list the wrong number of existing antennas (for another carrier), or say there are no other carriers within 100 feet; when a cursory look on Google Earth or Google Search shows two other existing carriers on the same project site.<em> <br> <br></em><strong><em> </em>See list<em>, further below (</em></strong><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/Modules/ShowDocument.aspx?documentid=9392"><strong><em>or photos here</em></strong></a><strong><em>), of common items not accurately conveyed on plans and simulations for new rooftop-mounted sites and modifications.</em></strong></p><p>For rooftop-mounted facilities on buildings with residences below, require the carrier to affirm (based on consultation with the property owner) in writing that the antennas/equipment won’t displace (equipment areas range in size from 2 to 5 office cubicles) existing tenant spaces (e.g. roof decks). Consider requesting site photos as well. For mixed-use buildings ensure that equipment areas within buildings (ranging in size from the equivalent of 1 to 4 office cubicles) won’t displace a small business tenant (<em>even if on a month-to-month lease</em>).</p><p>Make it clear in the first screen check letter that any staff design direction or hearing body determination is based on a submittal that is complete; such as plans, photo simulations, and reports (e.g. RF and structural) that accurately depict all required facility elements.</p><p>Given that 20–30 days of the clock will be used up reviewing the application when it is first submitted; and in most cities/counties, it takes around 30–40 days to get a project and neighborhood notification mailed out in advance of the public hearing (assuming the hearing body doesn’t take time off in the summer); it may also be prudent to hold a date on the hearing calendar for the project and indicate to the carrier that if the project is not complete AND viable by a certain date (e.g. 10 days after the first re-submittal for collocations and 40 days after initial re-submittal for new facilities) staff may have to recommend disapproval at that hearing date.</p><p>Indicate that substantial revisions or additions after the first re-submittal may require either a denial if sufficient time is not provided to analyze those impacts; or may necessitate approval recommendations of the project without the last-minute changes (and a new application being necessary).</p><p>For projects with substantial completeness or viability challenges (especially for 90 day collocations), consider indicating within the first screen check letter that a public hearing is tentatively scheduled for a specific date (consider adding placeholders on the hearing calendar), and a disapproval recommendation is likely if items listed in the letter are not resolved <em>XX</em> days prior to the hearing date.</p><p>Encourage carriers to review applicable fire codes early on in the design process. A substantial number of revisions (e.g. antenna re-locations being requested by the carrier after Planning approval) occur due to project plans not in compliance, such as rules on smoke control, antennas near standpipes and emergency exits, cumulative levels of battery acids in a given room at co-location sites, and equipment (such as “RRUs”) impeding clearance within stairwells.</p><p><strong>Create Citywide Template Conditions of Approval | </strong>Consider creating conditions of approval that would automatically apply if a deemed granted action (automatic approvals) occurs. Conditions could address security, time limits (expiration), site maintenance, obtaining CEQA clearance, brush clearance for fire safety, fencing (e.g. rules on fence height/material and barb/razor wire usage), knox boxes (police/fire access during emergencies), landscaping, light glare/spill, aircraft lighting, noise limits, generator usage, and painting of exposed antenna/enclosure elements. <a href="http://www.cityofcalabasas.com/pdf/wireless/Wireless_Facility_Ordinance-w_CC_Changes052312.pdf">Example link</a>. Consider adopting an ordinance/conditions stating that entitlements will lapse/expire for wireless facilities that have been abandoned/inactive for more than six (6) months.</p><h3><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/6409-supplement-7d4176320061#.quh0v2n3v"><em>Separate link to areas of consideration for Federal “6409” rules governing changes (new equipment or height increases) to existing wireless facilities</em></a><em>.</em></h3><p><strong>Remedying Ongoing Code Violations | </strong>As many local governments face a challenge of wireless carriers improperly developing (<em>antennas/equipment in unapproved locations, missing screening, or using equipment not compliant with electrical codes</em>), maintaining or modifying (adding antennas/equipment without permits) wireless facilities; discuss with counsel if an appropriate remedy for repeated and unresolved violations is to decline intake of co-location applications at the same project site and/or new facility applications for the same carrier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/483/1*Fu1l5PwdIMijADUFezE4xA.png" /><figcaption><em>What was approved</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*_A1a4JPLgW9pp7nnjvk1Vw.png" /><figcaption><em>What the neutral host carrier built (antennas &amp; equipment for two distinct wireless carriers) over time without proper permits</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Delegation for Denials| </strong>Evaluate whether current codes/charters allow for administrative denials of applications.</p><p>Allowing for administrative denials (for both conditionally and principally permitted locations) of co-Locations (90 day clock) may be especially useful for those applications normally requiring both a public hearing (including average 20 to 30 day noticing periods before the hearing); where sufficient time isn’t provided to also allow for scheduling of timely appeals. Ensure the denial is based on information in the written record.</p><p>Determine if staff denials of certain types of entitlements can be appealed, by the carrier, to a specific hearing body that is best suited to review such a project.</p><p>Determine if appeal requirements, such as requiring a percentage of neighbor’s signatures in support of an appeal by a wireless carrier (which would seem unlikely to obtain), need to be modified.</p><p><em>Many wireless carrier representatives may not be aware that in many cities/counties, if a project is actually denied at a public hearing, the carrier can’t come back for a public hearing, at the same project site, for time periods of six months, a year, or more. It may be prudent to discuss this issue with carrier representatives prior to public hearings.</em></p><p><strong>Sequencing for Multiple Review Bodies | </strong>Take a look at the order of hearings required for certain types of wireless facilities and whether changes should be made. For instance, determine if variances (<em>e.g. to place large equipment areas in a rear yard, or for height exceptions</em>) require a separate application that can be heard after the original Conditional Use Permit. If the agency requires some type of Coastal Act review prior to the entitlement, it may be better to reverse the review. AB 57 does not appear to apply to the Coastal Commission’s own review. Also determine if separate public design review hearing requirements (if applicable) should be waived for certain types of fully screened rooftop-mounted co-locations.</p><p><strong>Work with Building Department Staff | </strong>Many cities/counties face ongoing challenges of wireless carriers not developing/modifying sites correctly, per the approved plans and photo simulations, and conditions of approval. Therefore, if the City/County doesn’t currently require a Planner to visit the site before a building permit is completed (final inspection), then consider having the photo simulations (in a clear format) added to the plan set on a sheet preceding the site plan sheet. This makes it easy for both the contractor and building inspector to compare the facility to what was approved, while they are out in the field, since the case packet (and photo simulations) often doesn’t make it to the contractor. <br> <br>Also consider adding a stamp to building plan approvals (or permits by Public Works for public right of way permits) to require the contractor to send site photos to the case planner before calling for a final building (or public works) inspection. Ideally, the Building or Public Works inspector won’t sign off until they see the reply e-mail back from the case planner affirming the site appears correctly built.</p><p>Some cities/counties do not release electrical permits (to allow power to be turned on) for wireless facilities until it is determined the design is consistent with the approval. This is especially relevant for faux trees, given the challenge involved with inadequate construction (<em>exposed antennas/equipment, wrong installation locations, inconsistent foliage colors</em>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*x6eiIy7RqVkH0hDxI9JvOQ.png" /><figcaption>A sad excuse for a mono-palm in the San Fernando Valley. Well-designed tree examples have been created by firms such as <a href="http://utilitycamo.com/">Larsen Camo</a>,<a href="http://www.stealthconcealment.com/"> STEALTH</a>, <a href="http://www.steelheadmetals.com/custom-wireless.php">Steelhead</a>, and <a href="http://www.aglmediagroup.com/trees-branches-and-foliage/">Chameleon</a>.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hI7_KST1MSCbm0SHhZhlWA.jpeg" /><figcaption>What was approved (faux stairwell penthouse — with roof)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/441/1*80OxsmuKlXa_xQJ-pb6swA.png" /><figcaption>What was initially built (B&amp;V). Roof left off of faux stairwell penthouse and side walls too short to accommodate height of panel antennas. <em>Lesson Learned: Ensure the person creating the plan sheets depicting screening has also reviewed the photo simulations.</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Environmental Review Consultants | </strong>If a project involves complex CEQA review and the City/County doesn’t have staff in-house to adequately review reports (<em>e.g. archaeology, habitat surveys, storm water quality, geotechnical</em>) consider requiring the wireless carrier to have such studies commissioned before application submittal, and then using a separate consultant (from a list already created by the Department) to review the documentation.</p><p>Make sure the reviews take in the full project scope such as new access roads, excavation, trenching, lighting, and noise. Work through a checklist early on in the review in order to make sure items aren’t missed by staff or the carrier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*od5B82KqmHCo1moa31dgOg.png" /><figcaption>Remember that a rural freestanding wireless facility, like this one in New Mexico, may also need a new access road along with fuel storage tanks, equipment shelters, grading and trenching (celltowerphotos.com)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/405/1*V8jIMtBXDnWbuROJDR2Qkw.png" /><figcaption>Remember that a rural freestanding wireless facility may also need a new access road along with fuel storage tanks, equipment shelters, grading and trenching</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Amend City leasing templates &amp; Work with nearby local districts (water, vector, flood control) and other government agencies | </strong>Determine if those agencies leases can be modified to expressly make<em> </em>property owner approval contingent upon specific “actual” approval (not a deemed granted automatic approval) by the local jurisdiction.</p><p>Consider reaching out to the local Caltrans District office to understand how referrals/reviews can/would occur for new wireless facilities along freeways, and if there are opportunities to require remediation of existing wireless facilities that are poorly designed as needed (or when leases are up for renewal). Cities/counties can request that new neighborhood serving wireless facilities on Caltrans right of-way be reviewed by the City (e.g. Planning Commission). This issue is particularly prescient as some State agencies sell off surplus land (that may have a tower on it) to private property owners.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/533/1*5Wr9y6H1IceDNM32JxRZSw.png" /><figcaption>Not quite a faux tree, and in need of major remediation….</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Shot Clock Extensions that are workable | </strong>If a tolling agreement is requested (to extend the shot clock), consider amending it to include enough time for BOTH initial public hearings and a further extension for any timely appeals (if they are filed).</p><p>Also, consider advising local carrier representatives that they should try to be empowered (before the hearing) to sign a tolling agreement (they typically aren’t) at the public hearing, if the clock is running close and a hearing body isn’t supportive of the application and seeks a continuance to revise the design or resolve a siting challenge.</p><p>This may avoid instances where the Planner or City Attorney has to request that the hearing body (e.g. Planning Commission) decide on an approval/disapproval motion, because of the impending State’s Shot Clock issue; when the carrier’s representative isn’t empowered (at that moment) to request a tolling agreement, even if the carrier representative is “personally willing” to do so in order to resolve an unanticipated issue.</p><p><strong>Define Ridgelines and Vistas | </strong>Identifying significant ridgelines or vistas that define a community in public documents (<em>such as the General Plan, Wireless Guidelines, or Zoning Code</em>) can be especially useful in making findings regarding the approval/disapproval (or design recommendations) of wireless facilities. This is especially important for freestanding screened (faux water tank or windmill) or unscreened (monopoles) towers, and Small Cells (especially those proposed on brand new wooden poles), which are also known as Outdoor Distributed Antenna Systems, or the acronym “oDAS” (antennas and equipment cabinets on utility poles in the public right-of-way).</p><p><strong>Avoid moratoriums | </strong>The new State law may complicate efforts to impose a moratorium on certain types of facilities that represent a new siting type in a given community. Consider, for example, working early on to adopt rules for wireless facilities in the public right-of-way (<em>e.g. height and size limits, noise standards [cooling fans], screening of potential ground-mounted equipment, and neighborhood notification boundaries</em>) if they aren’t already in place.</p><p><strong>Coastal Commission Timing and Entitlement Processing | </strong>Determine the types of configurations (facility type, location, etc.) that require the issuance of a Coastal Development Permit. If the California Coastal Commission has not certified a Local Coastal Program for the agency, the Coastal Commission may retain approval authority over any required coastal permits. The Coastal Commission may also retain permanent coastal permit authority within certain areas of the jurisdiction. In order to comply with all FCC “shot clock” deadlines, Coastal Commission approval, when required, follow the local agency’s determination. AB 57 does not appear to apply to any reviews or entitlements processed by the Coastal Commission. If the agency requires Coastal Act consideration prior to review and/or approval of the requisite local entitlements (e.g. Conditional Use Permit or Administrative Use Permit), it may be beneficial to reverse the order of review or process all reviews concurrently.</p><p><strong>Noticing Materials up front | </strong>AB 57 refers to notification materials required for the application. This <strong>may</strong> complicate instances where additional types of notification materials are required as the project scope changes after the initial submittal. Keep an eye on whether this applies and notify the project sponsor early on.</p><p>In some cities and counties, disapproving a principally permitted application, requires a public hearing. Determine if notification materials (e.g. surrounding property owner labels) are required. The carrier may decline to provide such labels (since they weren’t required up front as part of the application) and you’ll have to decide whether to create them in-house, or to waive such a requirement. Or, to require adjacent owner labels for all sites up front (which may not be viable).</p><p><strong>Inform Commissioners and the Public | </strong>Determine if resolutions of approval (and public notices for the original hearing as well as appeal applications) should include an informational clause about State law potentially abridging timely appeal rights (e.g. up to City Council or Board of Supervisors) for wireless facilities.</p><p>If your City/County hasn’t yet seen installations of antennas &amp; equipment in the public right-of-way, consider holding an information session with your community leaders to discuss challenges/opportunities.</p><p><strong>Fast Track Appeals | </strong>Determine if it is possible to fast-track appeals, since the new State law provides no clear exception for due process. <em>Some folks have raised the concern that the law conflicts with the Permit Streamlining Act. That may have to be decided in the courts one day.</em></p><p><strong>Pre-approval of Screened Co-locations | </strong>If approving a co-locatable structure (e.g. a faux water tank), consider adding language to pre-approve a future carrier (via a building permit) if they meet certain metrics (<em>e.g. all transmitting antennas are stealthed, the GPS antenna and ancillary equipment [e.g. access ladders and generator plugs] is not visible from public right-of-way, equipment areas are both screened and adhere to a specific noise standard</em>).</p><p><strong>Coordinate intakes</strong> | Since a City/County has only 10 days from re-submittal (after the first incomplete letter) to indicate if an application is still incomplete (and pause the clock); consider requiring re-submittal appointments or ensuring administrative support staff (in Building/Planning/Public Works) immediately routes re-submittal materials to the assigned case planner (or public works reviewer).</p><p><strong>Fire Station Exemption</strong>| The law (automatic approval remedy) would not apply to applications for new facilities and collocations at fire stations. In most cities/counties, the antennas (e.g. thin “whip” antennas typically mounted on the roof) serving public safety (police/fire) purposes often do not require the same process (such as public hearings) as a commercial wireless facility (larger panel antennas and substantial equipment areas).</p><p>As the bill wound its way through the State Capitol, local governments raised concern with organizations representing firefighters that the changing language of the legislation was unclear if project review (planning, design, historic preservation and environmental), public hearings, and complex building and fire code (construction plan) review have to all occur within the 90/150 day clocks.</p><p>In fact, the first versions (shepherded by Verizon) of the (AB 57) legislation almost inadvertently got rid of the ability for a wireless carrier to even ask for an extension of the clock (tolling agreement); which would have been to the detriment of the wireless industry.</p><p>In response to initial opposition by firefighters, the bill’s sponsors inserted the additional language to gain their support. In reality, the bill language likely has no discernable effect since the city/county can still require more application review time anyways for a commercial wireless facility, in its capacity as the fire station’s property owner.</p><p>Lastly, it does not appear this bill would resolve some of the types of challenges that occurred with the new “FirstNet” (public safety network) rollout in Los Angeles County. Significant opposition came about (just prior to hearings for AB 57) from LA-area firefighters and neighbors to proposed FirstNet installations that involved approximately 70-foot tall freestanding steel monopoles, with panel antennas, at fire stations in areas such as residential neighborhoods.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*53kvjKvEMNedNsHDfrLQBw.png" /><figcaption>Monopole at a public safety facility in Los Angeles County. Panel antennas would serve police/fire systems and provide high speed data. This would compliment the existing “land mobile radio” (LMR) systems which involve primarily (fewer) hilltop mounted “whip” antennas used to provide basic voice services to handheld and vehicle radios. The author wonders if less intrusive means can be used such as single form antennas (multiple antennas in one enclosure the size of a school blackboard) mounted on the sides of bridges and flyovers.</figcaption></figure><h3>Additional Resources</h3><ul><li><a href="http://www.cityofcalabasas.com/wireless.html">City of Calabasas Wireless Facility Application Checklists</a></li><li><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wirelessforms">San Francisco Wireless Facility Application Checklists</a></li><li><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/index.aspx?page=1648">Best Practices for Rooftop-Mounted Micro Wireless Facilities (Bulletin #3)<br> <em>Many of the design/siting practices &amp; examples also apply to rooftop-mounted “Macro” (large) facilities.</em></a></li><li><a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/wirelessforms">Design Preferences for Wireless (oDAS/Small Cells) On Wooden Poles<br> </a><em>These preferences focus on narrower rights-of-way, where ground-mounted equipment cabinets (computers or batteries and electric meters) are strongly disfavored, so all of the equipment remains on the pole.</em></li><li><a href="http://www.slideshare.net/omarmasry/slides-from-a-wireless-cellular-design-panel?related=1">Slide from a Design Discussion for Wireless Facilities</a> <br> <em>Presented at a Joint Venture Silicon Valley forum</em></li><li><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B7pIZT7oVSp7eHlvdTNTRHFRQkU/view">Presentation on the FCC Report and Order (6409) at the League of California Cities</a></li><li><a href="https://www.cacities.org/Resources-Documents/Member-Engagement/Professional-Departments/City-Attorneys/Library/2015/2015-Spring-Conference/5-2015-Spring-Harriet-Steiner-FCC-s-Wireless-Facil.aspx">League of California Cities article on Section 6409</a><em> (starting on Page 11).</em></li><li><a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">A wireless industry view on State rules for wireless in the public right-of-way.</a> <em>Includes an interesting “history lesson” on how old rules for telegraph lines affect wireless review now.</em></li><li><a href="http://rpv.granicus.com/MetaViewer.php?view_id=5&amp;clip_id=2458&amp;meta_id=22072">Recent City of Rancho Palos Verdes urgency ordinance for wireless facilities in the public right-of-way (oDAS/Small Cells)</a></li></ul><p><strong>MobileNow Act on the horizon | </strong>A wholly separate <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/n67ln4v09cwtl2d/Mobile%20Now.pdf?dl=0"><strong>draft</strong> (Federal) law</a> recently before some Congress members may prohibit cities/counties from: 1) placing time limits on approvals (<em>e.g. 10 year limits on Conditional Use Permits for wireless that many local governments have in place</em>); 2) limit local* discretion (e.g. noise limits) over (noisy diesel) generators, that are sometimes installed at wireless facilities; and 3) prohibit requiring proof that a new site is needed to meet a service/capacity gap, based on RF signal/noise studies (no more city/county requirements for coverage maps). These rules may further hinder community appropriate wireless siting. *It’s unclear what effect the law, if approved would have on generator permitting by many regional air quality districts in California.</p><h3><strong>Common items not consistently depicted on plans and photo simulations for new rooftop-mounted sites and modifications to existing sites</strong></h3><p><strong>· Cable trays</strong> with exposed conduit at the ends (e.g. before it enters the building). Consider the use of faux hot water pipes instead. Ensure cable trays do not run over residential windows.</p><p>· <strong>Caged access ladders</strong> that are often left off the original plans and photo simulations. In a few instances (e.g. small residential-historic buildings) the carrier may need to use a man-lift (truck) instead to access the roof.</p><p>· <strong>Cross bracing</strong>. Ensure there are no horizontal bars between a group of freestanding antennas (or those in faux vent pipes). It is not uncommon for carriers to leave such bracing out of photo simulations and the initial set of project plans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*LBDDNb0Ks8xQGpYAZR0D-g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Disfavored cross bracing between freestanding antennas</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Doghouses</strong> not shown.</p><p>·<strong> Driveways</strong> (new) to access outdoor ground-mounted equipment areas at the back of the property.</p><p>· <strong>Generator Plugs / Cam Locks</strong> not shown on original submittals. Ensure their placement doesn’t detract from a potentially historic storefront. This is the receptacle (socket) that generators on trailers are plugged into, and used power the facility after a major power outage.</p><p>· <strong>GPS antenna</strong>s unnecessarily visible from street. In many instances they can be attached to a mid-roof cable tray (the property owner will not count it toward the carriers lease area). GPS antennas can be painted to match another color instead of bright white. Ensure plans show location and height. Some manufacturers (e.g.<a href="http://www.commscope.com/catalog/andrew/product_details.aspx?id=6590"> Commscope</a>) of primary transmitting antennas make versions with a GPS antenna integrated into the top of the antenna.</p><p><strong>· HVAC Units</strong> (condensers) that may cause a massing and/or noise concern if placed near a residential window.</p><p>·<strong> Noise. </strong>If a new equipment cabinet or backup generator is being installed, ensure the noise levels will be compatible. In some instances a cabinets that meets noise standards may cause concern if it’s placed in a narrow lightwell, and creates an echo effect.</p><p>· <strong>Radio-Frequency Barriers/Fences</strong> not adequately shown on the photo simulations, site plans or elevation sheets. Often a 2.5 foot tall barrier will suffice; instead of a 4-foot tall barrier (<em>especially since we don’t typically see snow drifts piling on most coastal California rooftops that would obscure view of the barrier</em>).</p><p>· <strong>Radio Relay Units (RRUs/RRHs)</strong> left off photo simulations, but shown on project plans in locations that are likely visible from nearby sidewalks. <em>RRUs are essentially computers the size of suitcases which filter/boost power/signal for faster data speeds. Wireless carriers prefer these to be as close to antennas as possible. A large facility may have 6 to 24 of them, per carrier. Often times photo simulations leave out the potential visibility of RRUs and the large bundles of cabling entering the RRU. Many RRUs feature visible manufacturer logos that should be relocated or covered with a screen plate.</em></p><p><strong>· Screening </strong>where the underside of the screen box is left exposed with visible dangling cables. Or faux vent pipes on roofs without parapets where the tripod and cabling may end up being visible, if a shroud is not used at the base. <em>Always check to make sure the screening wraps around the side sufficiently, so the equipment is not exposed to view as a pedestrian travels nearby.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/721/1*fB4JVz0hax747oHHBbmplQ.png" /><figcaption>Incomplete vent pipe on a building with no parapet. Additional cladding needed at base.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>· Screening</strong> with a “low-cost version” featuring visible protruding bolts and rivet points akin to an old warship. Plans should clearly indicate a smooth surface painted to match adjacent wall surfaces. For a color that should blend well with the sky (for rooftop elements) consider “Ponder” (non-glossy) by Sherwin-Williams, or equivalent.</p><p><strong>· Vent stacks and fuel lines for generators</strong> (if present)</p><p>· <strong>Work lights.</strong> These are small lights on rods rising a few feet above the primary equipment area. They are used by technicians to work on a facility at night. Sometimes plans and photo simulations do not account for the potential visibility of this item. Consider requiring the work light to be placed on a hinge so it can be swiveled up above the equipment area, but only when needed.</p><h3><strong>Areas of consideration for Public Right of Way Facilities (known as Small Cells, or oDAS)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*ZIZIpMDrDzVJe8ywi31uJg.png" /><figcaption><em>Poorly designed facility in the public right-of-way along a coastal highway, with AT&amp;T Mobility panel antennas on a utility pole, along with a wide bundles of cabling below, and a ground mounted equipment area (partially screened except top of cabinet and GPS antenna) in a location next to a Federal land (open space), that also detracts from the scenic route.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Also, consider reaching out to the local electric provider to discuss whether wireless metering (no meter box with glass bubble — uses a small antenna to communicate with the SmartMeter network) or “line drops” (<em>flat rate charge for electricity, without a meter box, as is often used in SDG&amp;E service areas</em>) options are available to reduce the need for additional equipment on the pole, or on a separate freestanding meter pedestal in the public right-of-way.</p><p>Consider establishing noise (due to cooling fans), size, height and equipment area rules. In some places the street speed or number of lanes can be a useful metric for where larger oDAS systems (example below) are not allowed. In areas with a wider right-of-way (and no conflict with sidewalk widths for handicapped accessibility), moving all equipment (and meters) off the pole (except the antenna) may be less intrusive.</p><p>Even if a brand new pole (<em>twenty to forty foot average height, and located in the public right-of-way</em>) with wireless antennas and equipment boxes appears potentially palatable in a given area (e.g. rural road), there appears to be little reason the local government can’t require steel light poles instead of wooden poles (with cabling hidden inside and a decorative base to hide equipment); or visual mitigation for ground-mounted equipment cabinets such as underground enclosures, or faux decorative wood lattice screen covers (made of metal with texturing and painting to mimic wood) that are under four feet tall, and landscaping combined with modest berming of soil. Or, perhaps placing ground-mounted electronic equipment in fake vintage wood wine/whiskey barrels along mostly treeless rural canyon roads with equestrian trails.</p><p>In some cities each encroachment permit (to trench or build in the right of way) require City Council approval. Determine if approval authority should instead be delegated to the Public Works Director. This may be useful as there could be a timing challenge if appeals have to go to another hearing body first, then go to the next City Council meeting (if the appeal is denied).</p><p>Some cities include conditions within the utilities conditions permit (UCP) to require utilities (including wireless facilities on wooden utility poles) to be removed if the city begins undergrounding of wooden utility poles.</p><p>In some residential or historic areas, if a pole top antenna (instead of a side arm midway up the pole holding up the antenna) is proposed, it may be best to require the entire pole to be replaced, so that the pole can taper toward the top-mount antenna, instead of an unsightly (non-uniform profile and utility prohibitions on painting) bayonet arm (stick holding up an arm with a clamp attached to the top of the pole) rising 3 to 8 feet above the top of the pole to hold up the antenna.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/898/1*gr65Y3lO1Q-ucn05qL97xA.png" /><figcaption><em>Example of an intrusive Public Right-of-Way Wireless Facility featuring bulky unscreened cabinets within the Public Right-of-Way (on a nicely landscaped street in an undergrounded area). Credit: Public Document.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/449/1*RS6MBNOTXqHrz2jFMl96-w.png" /><figcaption><em>Example of a poorly designed oDAS (outdoor distributed antenna system) on a utility pole. Grey cabinets are the radio relay units (computers). Large box below features (optional) batteries (with noise generating cooling fans) for backup power. The electric meter is at the bottom of the pole, and multiple panel antennas are up top. Extra service loops of cabling were (for some unknown reason) left on pole.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Be skeptical of claims that the overall wooden pole height needs to be increased 13 to 20 feet taller than the existing wood pole in order to meet utility (vertical separation) rules, as they may not actually be true. Also:</p><ol><li>In some instances carriers have been willing to reduce the proposed pole height increase when they know the local government is inclined to deny the proposal (especially in single-family neighborhoods where a 50 foot tall pole would appear out of place).</li><li>At most an 8 foot extension may be needed above high voltage lines (bear in mind some wires are used for fiber-optic or copper wires for communications and do not require the same vertical separation).</li><li>In some instances the use of wireless metering (so that an extra meter box is not needed) and/or relocation of some equipment to a second pole may reduce the need for a pole height increase. In more limited instances, routing power or communication lines from a nearby pole on the same side of the street, first, before crossing the street may reduce the need for a pole height increase in order to accommodate required line separation and vehicle clearance heights as the wires cross a public street.</li><li>Moving a portion of the equipment (e.g. optional battery backup cabinet and shut down switch) to another pole may allow for height reductions.</li></ol><h4><a href="http://calwa.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/WHOSE_STREETS_CALIFORNIA_PUBLIC_UTILITIES_CODE_SECTION_7901_IN_THE_WIRELESS_AGE.pdf">Article link providing a wireless industry point of view on wireless in the public right-of-way.</a></h4><p>· <strong>Antennas. </strong>Radome style antennas offer a more uniform profile than multiple panel antennas. Multiple short panel antennas are often made even more visible given the bulky mechanical tilt brackets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/175/1*tolRJrgzt_wumOsqquXxHw.png" /><figcaption>Older physical tilt bracket holding up the antenna that may not be needed with new antenna models.</figcaption></figure><p>However, many slightly longer (newer) panel antennas feature electronic tilt mechanisms built-in, which can allow for a panel antenna to be mounted in a manner that is more flush to the pole/bracket. Manufacturers also offer cable shrouds, which can make each panel antenna “look longer” but reduce visibility of multiple cables entering the bottom of the antenna.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/1*vPEcfOKpmkzNZrGw2cP3PQ.png" /><figcaption>Cable shroud below a panel antenna to hide cables (not shown)</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Battery Backup Cabinets.</strong> These are optional elements with lead acid or nickel cadmium batteries to run the facility in the event of power outages. Though with a more limited uptime compared to larger battery systems and generators used at “macro” rooftop or tower mounted sites. There are manufacturers, such as TSi Power, which offer battery cabinets that are about as wide as the pole, though longer, and are generally preferable to bulky enclosures about three times as wide as the pole that may be more noticeable as traveling down the street, and more likely to obstruct views from nearby residential windows.</p><p>· <strong>Bayonet/Pole Height Extensions.</strong> The use of a bayonet (4 x 4 post with metal clamps) to mount an antenna above the top of the pole can appear incongruous (change in profile, and prohibition of painting of the clamps and bayonet by utilities) with the pole. In more sensitive scenic, historic, or residential areas, it may be best to require the carrier to replace the entire pole so that the new pole tapers toward the antenna. Many initial photo simulations do not show the bayonet mounted correctly in terms of location (typically cannot be mounted in the center of the existing poletop), and lack of paint to match the existing pole or antenna.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/158/1*JJxEQoAeQUcZnB06cSRvQw.png" /><figcaption>Avoid the use of offset conduit elements that resemble a ladder (not needed)</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Cabling.</strong> Encourage the use of solid and narrow conduit pipes or flexible rubber elements running up the outside of wood poles to avoid the cluttered look of multiple power and communications cables. These elements can often be painted (to match the pole) and retain the paint color better than individual cables. Avoid instances where the carrier utilizes a ladder type system running up the pole with conduit offset a few inches from the wood pole. In some instances the photo simulations may not accurately depict this item. For steel poles ensure cabling will run inside the pole with clear notes indicating such on plan sets.</p><p>· <strong>Combiners/duplexers.</strong> These elements are often placed near the antenna and roughly the size of jewelry boxes. For side arm mounted antennas on wood poles, encourage the use of mounting arms with the combiners placed inside. Ensure these elements are shown (if needed) on plans and photo simulations, and ensure that they can be painted to match the pole (doing so will not void a warranty).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p5eBjBZQqAWZ4fauPsS6oA.png" /><figcaption>Side-arm mount for an antenna on a wooden utility pole. The arm has been designed so as to also “hide” the cabling and couplers inside the arm. Credit: Cable Engineering Services.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/420/1*5LdZUKohzwhc7SYLXkH3iw.png" /><figcaption>Credit: AdvanceSim</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Completeness.</strong> It is not uncommon for submittal to leave out known required elements (e.g. nearby freestanding electric meter pedestals, combiners, cabling). Request carrier to affirm in writing if the submittal is complete with respect to all elements needed to operate the facility (including those elements required by the utility and backhaul provider).</p><p>· <strong>Dual Poles.</strong> In locations where the carrier is proposing a substantial number of boxes on a single pole, and the public right-of-way is narrow (making ground mounted equipment problematic) consider requiring the carrier to place a portion of the equipment (e.g. battery backup, electric meter, shutdown switch) on a second nearby (existing) pole.</p><p>· <strong>Electricity.</strong> Encourage the use of wireless metering (<em>small grapefruit sized antenna that connects to existing “SmartMeter” networks</em>) or line drops (carrier pays an estimated flat billing rate for electricity) to avoid the need for new electric meter enclosures (whether on a separate freestanding pedestal or attached to the pole). If an electric meter enclosure is necessary, then require a slim meter enclosure that is about as wide as the pole (<em>instead of bulky meters nearly twice as wide of the pole, that often become graffiti targets).</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xWPoKL-QFKdC3tHIoH8k9g.png" /><figcaption>Credit AdvanceSim</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Excavation.</strong> Ensure the project scope (and environmental review) takes into account excavation that may be needed for new/replacement poles, equipment vaults, or backhaul (underground fiber-optic cables). <em>Avoid instances, as occurred in one town (where the town was not consulted on the project), where the carrier apparently excavated in areas with known Native American burial grounds.</em></p><p>· <strong>Fiber (PBX) Boxes</strong>. This is a box typically placed near the bottom of a wood pole and used to connect (backhul fiber) the wireless facility to the local “wireline” carrier. Ensure the box is shown, if needed, and ensure it is painted to match other adjacent equipment. Manufacturers of such boxes have not expressed a concern with painting such boxes.</p><p>· <strong>GPS Antenna</strong>. In some, but not all instances the carrier may need to add a GPS antenna. However, many plans and photo simulations often leave out this item. Some manufacturers (e.g.<a href="http://www.commscope.com/catalog/andrew/product_details.aspx?id=6590"> Commscope</a>) of primary transmitting antennas make versions with a GPS antenna integrated into the top of the main antenna. Evaluate opportunities to use the smallest GPS antenna available (e.g. versions the size of a shot cup instead of versions the size of large pear).</p><p>· <strong>Ground-Mounted Equipment.</strong> Ensure plans and photo simulations (not based on Google StreetView photos) accurately depict the height and massing of such elements. Have carrier affirm in writing that no other enclosures are required, including but not limited to electric meter pedestals. Determine if screening elements should be utilized such as an undergounded vault (with an above ground vent stack for ventilation and moisture pump out), soil berming, landscaping, or faux wood lattice screens (made of steel but painted and textured to mimic wood).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iiRftmYusASzLqZX1krqHw.png" /><figcaption>Antenna on pole, equipment in vaults below sidewalk, and vent stacks tucked into landscaping. Credit: celltowersites.com</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Grounding.</strong> For City-owned poles, ensure new ground rods won’t damage sidewalks or pole bases (underground).</p><p>· <strong>Guy Wires.</strong> Determine if new guy wires (used to anchor the pole to the ground) are needed and clearly shown in plans and photo simulations (they are often left out of initial submittals). Replacing the pole may negate the need for guy wires.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/476/1*9sHHfkbpu2qohWbo8KpVow.png" /><figcaption>Unnecessary flashing lights on enclosure midway up pole</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Lights.</strong> Add conditions of approval prohibiting flashing lights (visible from nearby residences or sidewalks) on equipment enclosures. Also, if side-arm mounted antennas are being added to existing wooden poles with streetlights, ensure the antenna placement won’t significantly impair street lighting. In some instances it may be best to have the carrier arrange for a longer light arm to be installed by the utility.</p><p>· <strong>Noise. </strong>Determine if equipment uses passive cooling (no noise) or requires cooling fans. If cooling fans are utilized have carrier provide the noise profile on the cover sheet of project plans. In quiet residential areas, carrier may need to either set fans to turn off at night, or turn off based on a thermostat. In other instances a slightly larger enclosure may allow for a larger fan that can turn slower and generate less noise.</p><p>· <strong>Overhead Wires. </strong>In undergrounded areas (no existing wood poles), ensure no new “aerial” or overhead lines (electricity or fiber-optic) are being utilized. It is not uncommon for the initial submittals to omit these items. Request carrier to affirm in writing.</p><p>· <strong>Paint. </strong>Have noted added to cover sheet, site plan and elevation sheets regarding painting of Antennas, Brackets, Cabling/Conduit, Electric Meters (except the glass bubble), Equipment Enclosures, and Fiber Termination Boxes. Non-glossy colors such as Sable (for brown poles) or Ponder (for washed out grey poles near ocean areas), by Sherwin-Williams, may be good choices.</p><p>· <strong>Pole offset. </strong>Ensure the offset of enclosures from the wood poles (gap between pole and boxes) is shown on the plan set. Avoid an offset greater than 4 inches (typical minimum allowed by wooden pole owners in California).</p><p>· <strong>Photo Simulations</strong>. Ensure photo simulations are not based on Google StreetView photos. Photo simulations should show all requirement elements of facility that may be visible (they often don’t) and provide a realistic depiction of cabling/conduit (they often don’t).</p><p>· <strong>Project Plans</strong>. Ensure the carrier uses a nearest building address that nearby neighbors will recognize (if public notification required). Consider requiring a site completion checklist and/or photo simulations to be added to the plans.</p><p>If plans and photo simulations are mailed to nearby residents, make sure the address listed by the carrier, is one that residents would recognize (it often isn’t). Consider indicating the noise profile on the cover sheet, such as “maximum of XX decibels from 6 feet away,” or “no noise generation (passive cooling).</p><p>Then again thanks to “6409,” the day after carrier builds a small, and noiseless system on a non-city owned wouldn’t utility pole, they can demand the ability to replace the system with one featuring larger (refrigerator sized) cabinets with loud cooling fans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/325/1*mVbRC9pk3KUYjDGdo55Ohw.png" /><figcaption>Excessive stickers/decals not needed at this location. Three different RF warning stickers may cause a resident to think the facility has an unusually high RF emissions level.</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>RF Warning Stickers. </strong>Require plans and photo simulations to show location of RF warning stickers. Avoid placement of stickers near ground level on equipment enclosures where they appear cluttered and are not generally needed (sticker should be a few feet below antenna to inform utility personnel who may climb the pole).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eqdOG_9R_0ZQW6sLl_He8w.png" /><figcaption>Multiple repetitive stickers, tangled cabling and unpainted AT&amp;T fiber termination box (lime green element). Require the carrier to place RF warning sticker only near the actual antenna further up the pole, and place a carrier ID sticker on the underside or back of the equipment, with a sticker background color which matches the equipment.</figcaption></figure><p>· <strong>Sidewalk vault lids. </strong>Condition approvals to ensure no logos or commercial names are added to new sidewalk vault lids (if needed). Descriptions such as wireless or telecom may be appropriate.</p><p>· <strong>Stickers and Decals. </strong>Condition approvals to require that all prominent logos and decals to be removed, painted over, or filled in (e.g. for indented Ericsson logos on mRRUs), if visible from surrounding sidewalks. Also require that carrier identification stickers be placed on the underside of enclosures, or if not possible, utilize a sticker background that is the same color as the painted enclosure surface) and no larger than 3 inches by 5 inches.</p><p>· <strong>Trees.</strong> Some local governments require the carrier to plant a street tree near the pole to reduce visibility of equipment on the pole.</p><p>Ensure that trenching (if needed) and overall facility construction does not damage existing trees (especially heritage trees), or that they are replaced at a 3:1 ratio. Additionally, one challenge often encountered by many local governments is when crews (in spite of rules already in place) running fiber-optic cables begin topping off nearby trees that harms them. It may be advisable to require crews obtaining street closure and/or encroachment permits to affirm in writing they are aware of such requirements, or notify City arborists of pending activity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*zZxZ6Lrj4D-ZeoxI0MJAKA.png" /><figcaption><a href="http://pvestates.granicus.com/MetaViewer.php?view_id=1&amp;event_id=36&amp;meta_id=19858">Proposed Crown Castle DAS node in the City of Palos Verdes Estates</a>. Replacement of existing stop sign.</figcaption></figure><p>See also: <a href="http://www.sf-planning.org/ftp/files/currentplanning/wireless/wireless_Design_Preferences_for_Wireless_Facilities_August2015.pdf">Design preferences for oDAS on wooden utility poles</a></p><h4><em>Omar Masry, AICP, testified before the California State Assembly and State Senate on AB 57. The information contained herein does not reflect policy of any government agency.</em></h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5b53c78ac5bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[6409 Supplement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@omarmasry/6409-supplement-7d4176320061?source=rss-b25d800408ee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d4176320061</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[telecommunication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wireless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[landuse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Omar Masry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Jan 2016 18:21:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-18T20:17:54.740Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A few important items on “6409” | Eligible Facilities Requests<br>- </strong><em>Federal Communications Commission Rules for Modifications</em><strong><em>*</em></strong><em> to Existing Wireless Facilities</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@omarmasry/supplement-tools-for-adapting-to-ab-57-5b53c78ac5bb#.rsb7xrq1s">Separate link to Tools for Adapting to AB 57</a> (New California law)</p><ul><li><strong>Can a waiver help? </strong>During oral arguments before the Court of Appeals, those representing the FCC were asked by the judges about the potentially significant size changes allowed by the FCC’s interpretation (2014 Report and Order) of Section 6049. The FCC took the position (both in oral argument and in its brief) that States and localities could seek a waiver: “The <em>Order</em> leaves States and localities free to request a waiver of the Section 6409(a) rules in appropriate circumstances under the Commission’s general waiver process, 47 C.F.R. § 1.925(b)(3)(i), (ii).” <br>When the Court asked about the 60 day shot clock continuing to run during this waiver process, the FCC responded that the locality could request a stay (presumably from a court). <br>It remains to be seen whether and under what circumstances the FCC would grant such waivers, since the FCC’s Report and Order indicated disputes should be resolved in courts of competent jurisdiction and, as explained by the FCC, the general waiver process is meant to address “outlier” cases. The Court, in footnote 8 of its Order, indicated that “the waiver procedure provides a forum for municipal complaints, even if the procedure is not formally part of the Order.” <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/qxrsd5cuzgwmzo5/FCC%20Brief.pdf?dl=0">Link to FCC Brief (see references to waivers).</a></li><li>A request to modify the site (e.g. new antennas/equipment) in a manner that defeats existing concealment (e.g. screening) elements (if present) would not quality for the 6409 process (and 60 day approval clock). <strong><em>Make sure the existing facility actually still features the screening that may have been required previously.</em></strong><em> </em>It is not rare to find that required screening was never actually installed during the initial build, or was somehow removed over time during un-permitted work at the site. <em><br> </em><br> The effect of this rule tends to now offer significant advantages to requiring substantial screening or concealment elements for new facilities. Without those elements, the FCC’s interpretations may mean that what gets approved for the initial site may not in any way resemble how the facility looks later on as substantial modifications to unscreened facilities are made over time based on 6409.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/884/1*_ZV0CnL0W5V98oMoDE4PEw.png" /><figcaption>This faux building contains existing SCREENED panel antennas (inside). Adding UNSCREENED panel antennas above the faux building would defeat existing screening and would therefore not be eligible for 6409.</figcaption></figure><ul><li>6409 doesn’t apply if the applicant’s (property owner) site features wireless facilities that were never built correctly (substantial conformance) or maintained properly by the project sponsor (wireless carriers). To qualify as an eligible facility covered by Section 6409, the facility (base station or wireless tower) must be “existing.” The FCC found that the term “existing” requires that “wireless towers or base stations have been reviewed and approved under the applicable local zoning or siting process or that the deployment of existing transmission equipment on the structure received another form of affirmative State or local regulatory approval (e.g., authorization from a State public utility commission).<br> Thus, if a tower or base station was constructed or deployed without proper review, was not required to undergo siting review, or does not support transmission equipment that received another form of affirmative State or local regulatory approval, the governing authority is not obligated to grant a collocation application under Section 6409(a).”</li><li>6409 would appear to allow a wireless carrier to increase certain facility heights beyond any local established <strong>height limits</strong>, as long as doing so didn’t defeat any existing concealment elements. Determine if height limit rules should be amended to allow for screening elements as an option (if not currently present and the carrier is willing to add some screening elements) that may temper the effect of such increases. <em>If a tower is near an airport, the height increase could trigger the requirement to add tower lighting. Additional cabinets to support new tower lighting may make the proposal ineligible for 6409.</em></li><li>6409 may not apply to certain facilities that may have been approved by right or <strong>without permits</strong>. So this may not apply to certain legacy facilities that pre-dated specific rules/review on wireless facilities. Review this issue closely with counsel.</li><li>Local government can still add certain conditions to projects; though not related to the height and equipment size changes allowed under 6409 (<em>unless existing concealment/screening elements would be defeated</em>). FCC also ruled that facility modification remains subject to “building codes and other non-discretionary structural and safety codes.” Specifically, local governments may require a request covered by Section 6409 “to comply with generally applicable building, structural, electrical, and safety codes or with other laws codifying objective standards reasonably related to health and safety.”</li></ul><h3>PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0Yt4DkFQEgQd7fTxUaKLCw.png" /><figcaption>Credit: <a href="https://www.cacities.org/Resources-Documents/Member-Engagement/Professional-Departments/City-Attorneys/Request-Amicus-Support/Recent-Filings/Briefs-(1)/Montgomery-County,-MD-v-U-S-and-F-C-C-_Amicus-Brie">League of California Cities Filing</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_1cLkkalsTukSiCtB2_GWw.png" /></figure><ul><li>For facilities in the <strong>public right-of-way</strong><em> (such as oDAS or Small Cell on brand new or existing wood or steel light/utility poles), </em>6409 would not apply if the scope involves new ground disturbances<em> (e.g. for ground mounted cabinets) </em>at sites that do not currently feature any ground-mounted cabinets. <br> <br> The request would not be covered by Section 6409 if it involves installation of any new equipment cabinets on the ground if there are no pre-existing ground cabinets associated with the structure, or else involves installation of ground cabinets that are more than 10% larger in height or overall volume than any other ground cabinets associated with the structure. <br> <br> In addition, a modification “substantially changes” the physical dimensions of a tower or base station, as measured from the dimensions of the tower or base station inclusive of any modifications approved prior to the passage of the Spectrum Act, if it entails “any excavation or deployment outside of the current site of the tower or base station.” <br> <br> The FCC defines “site” for towers outside of the public rights-of-way as “the current boundaries of the leased or owned property surrounding the tower and any access or utility easements currently related to the site.” For other towers (i.e. towers in the public ROW) and all base stations, the FCC further restricts the site to “that area in proximity to the structure and to other transmission equipment already deployed on the ground.” If there are currently cabinets make sure they were previously permitted.<br> <br> <em>In other words due to 6409, the most obvious limitations to significantly modifying a wireless facility on a wooden utility pole (for example) are primarily utility regulations (limits on equipment and antenna placement per a State rule known as General Order 95 or “GO 95”), and whether new ground mounted equipment is proposed if no cabinets are currently on the ground. <br> <br></em> So, for example, a “DAS R” facility (small and streamlined), on a pole not owned by a local government, could be modified after construction (using 6409) in a manner (<em>adding six foot horizontal extension arms, 10-foot vertical extension for new antennas, large noisy cabinets, and adding multiple antennas with wide cable runs dangling below</em>) that does not remotely resemble the original approval.</li></ul><h3>NEW SITES IN LIGHT OF 6409</h3><ul><li>If new projects are approved where antennas and equipment are not <strong>fully screened</strong> (e.g. with a screen wall or fake vent pipes) but have still been deliberately designed to minimize their appearance (<em>e.g. tops of antennas are even with the top of the penthouse wall surface and/or shrouds are placed below panel antennas to hide cable loops from view, along with slim mounting brackets for a more flush mount to the wall surface</em>); then make specific mention of those screening techniques (refer to them as “concealment elements”) in the motion of approval (<em>or notes associated with the building permit approval for principally permitted facilities</em>).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hT5Z-DI_H-BKyXDkWXtnaA.png" /><figcaption>Unscreened panel antennas and cable trays on an elevator penthouse.</figcaption></figure><ul><li>This is an important step in establishing a written record with respect to future modifications (e.g. significantly taller replacement antennas) that may seek to defeat existing concealment elements.</li></ul><blockquote><strong>However, it may be prudent to err on the side of caution and request screen walls or other screening elements more often.</strong></blockquote><h3><strong>HISTORIC PRESERVATION</strong></h3><ul><li>Section 106 (<strong>historic preservation</strong>) review still applies to certain types of building/location/districts (see the FCC’s 2014 Report and Order). If you agency receives a Section 106 letter, make sure to provide comment (if appropriate, based on concerns regarding historic/cultural resources), including suggesting mitigation measures (<em>e.g. relocation of antennas, cable trays or equipment, and use of screening</em>), and indicating that further review would be needed if plans and photo simulations weren’t provided up front.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/688/1*2YnX7uXBOcoBqP6tqxYapw.png" /><figcaption>Unscreened panel antennas mounted on the facade of a building considered a historic resource</figcaption></figure><ul><li>The FCC adopted several exclusions with regard to the Section 106 process for review of effects on historic properties, including: (1) for collocations on utility structures, including utility poles and electric transmission towers, that meet the following conditions: (a) The deployment does not exceed a specified size limitation, when measured together with any other wireless deployment on the same structure; (b) The deployment will involve no new ground disturbance; and (c) The deployment is not (i) inside the boundary of a historic district, or within 250 feet of the boundary of a historic district; (ii) located on a structure that is a designated National Historic Landmark or is listed in or eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places (National Register); or (iii) the subject of a pending complaint alleging adverse effect on historic properties. (2) for collocations on buildings and any other non-tower structures that meet the following conditions: (a) There is an existing antenna on the building or structure; (b) The new deployment meets certain requirements related to visibility and proximity to an existing antenna; (c) The new antenna will comply with all zoning conditions and historic preservation conditions on existing antennas that directly mitigate or prevent effects, such as camouflage or concealment requirements; (d) The deployment will involve no new ground disturbance; and (e) The deployment is not (i) inside the boundary of a historic district, or within 250 feet of the boundary of a historic district; (ii) located on a structure that is a designated National Historic Landmark or is listed in or eligible for listing in the National Register; or (iii) the subject of a pending complaint alleging adverse effect on historic properties.</li><li><a href="http://www.nlc.org/media-center/news-search/fcc-rules-of-wireless-facility-siting-order"><strong><em>See also National League of Cities breakdown of rules</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><em>Note that the following bullet point on the League website regarding State or local government does not appear to be relevant in California, for New and Collocation (if not eligible for 6409) Facility requests (due to AB 57): “Decline to adopt an additional remedy for State or local government failures to act within the presumptively reasonable time limits.”</em></li><li>November 2014 video presentation before the City of Calabasas on 6409:</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAel-bZAvu7M%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAel-bZAvu7M%26feature%3Dyoutu.be&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAel-bZAvu7M%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a520771537c294fd4316c63ab8dfea69/href">https://medium.com/media/a520771537c294fd4316c63ab8dfea69/href</a></iframe><ul><li><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B7pIZT7oVSp7eHlvdTNTRHFRQkU/view">Presentation on the FCC Report and Order (6409) at the League of California Cities</a></li><li><a href="https://www.cacities.org/Resources-Documents/Member-Engagement/Professional-Departments/City-Attorneys/Library/2015/2015-Spring-Conference/5-2015-Spring-Harriet-Steiner-FCC-s-Wireless-Facil.aspx">League of California Cities article on Section 6409</a><em> (starting on Page 11).</em></li></ul><p><strong><em>*</em></strong><em>Modifications typically involve 1) adding, relocating or swapping antennas (sometimes with newer antennas up to 8 feet tall) and microwave dishes; 2) Adding or replacing equipment cabinets, radio relay units, or diesel generators; and 3) increasing the overall tower height or width to support more equipment.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d4176320061" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>