<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ori Hoxha on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ori Hoxha on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 16:53:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@orihoxha/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Strong Lek Is Not Albania’s Real Story]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/the-strong-lek-is-not-albanias-real-story-33f26fbde7d6?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/33f26fbde7d6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Oct 2026 20:20:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-10T20:20:22.427Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What happens when a country gets very good at attracting foreign purchasing power before it gets equally good at creating domestic productivity?</h4><p>There is something strange about looking at Albania from the outside these days. The country looks richer. The roads are better. Tirana has changed almost beyond recognition. Hotels are multiplying. Restaurants are full. Construction cranes dominate the skyline. Foreign tourists arrive in numbers that would have been difficult to imagine fifteen years ago.</p><p>And then there is the lek. On October 1, 2026, €1 bought roughly <strong>92 lek</strong>. In 2020, the annual average was about <strong>124 lek</strong>. In other words, the lek has appreciated roughly <strong>26% against the euro</strong> in six years. For an Albanian earning in lek, this might feel like an extraordinary improvement in purchasing power.</p><p>This is all happening while Bank of Albania operates a flexible exchange-rate regime and states that exchange rates are freely determined in the market, while intervention can be used to avoid disruptions, adjust reserves and respond to macroeconomic conditions. And it has been intervening heavily… The Bank announced a 2026 foreign-exchange reserve accumulation program involving roughly <strong>€330–450 million</strong> of purchases, following substantial interventions in previous years.</p><p>The IMF has specifically argued that FX intervention can be useful in Albania because the foreign-exchange market is relatively shallow and large inflows can cause excessive appreciation. At the same time, it cautions against using intervention too aggressively or allowing it to replace the flexibility of the exchange rate. So, the Bank of Albania is not obviously the force creating the strong lek. In some respects, it is <strong>the institution trying to stop the appreciation from being even stronger.</strong></p><h4>Why is the currency experiencing such a growth momentum?</h4><p>The obvious answer is tourism; maybe some sustained remittances from the extensive emigration over decades. And ultimately, some limited amount of foreign investment. All of those are real. But that answer to me is still unsatisfactory, in particular towards connecting a strong lek to an objectively strong economy.</p><p>That is because tourism revenue, remittances, foreign direct investment, labor income earned abroad and even some forms of informal capital are fundamentally different things. Some represent Albanian production. Some are transfers. Some are financing. Some may be difficult to observe or measure. But they all bring foreign purchasing power into a relatively small domestic economy.</p><p>That is enough to strengthen a currency, but, what happens next? Does that purchasing power finance the development of a more productive Albania Or does it mostly make the existing Albania more expensive?</p><p><strong>I used to worry that Albania was heading toward a currency crisis back in 2023</strong> — in a macroeconomic analysis I worked on during my MIT years, we looked at Albania through the BB-NN framework and concluded that the country appeared to be simultaneously dealing with external imbalance, domestic overheating and social pressure. We were especially concerned about the current-account deficit, public debt, emigration, and the possibility that the country would eventually face a painful adjustment. The paper went as far as discussing the possibility of a currency crisis.</p><p>Some of that thinking was directionally useful; however, rather pessimistic in retrospect / in the short-term (there is always a timeframe when macroeconomic predictions become accurate!).</p><p>Albania did not collapse; public debt fell dramatically rather than exploding; foreign reserves increased; tourism surged; the current-account position improved. And instead of depreciating, the lek became dramatically stronger.</p><p>That is actually a useful lesson in macroeconomics -<strong> a country’s position is not its destiny. </strong>An economy that appears vulnerable can experience a sufficiently powerful external shock — or structural improvement — to move into an entirely different equilibrium.</p><p>The BB-NN framework I learned at MIT is useful precisely because it is not an equilibrium model in which the economy is assumed to be sitting neatly where it belongs. It asks where the economy actually is relative to external balance, internal balance, and social constraints. Competitiveness depends not only on the exchange rate and wages, but ultimately on productivity.</p><p>And that is where today’s Albanian puzzle becomes more interesting.</p><h3>Curve 1: Albania has become very good at earning foreign currency</h3><p>I am going to call the first phenomenon <strong>Curve 1, where we have foreign / external purchasing power coming into Albania, such as, t</strong>ourism, remittances, foreign direct investment, wages earned by Albanians working abroad, capital inflows, and potentially, in the least visible parts of the economy, cash and other informal flows.</p><p>In the first quarter of 2026 alone, Albania recorded approximately <strong>€1.0 billion of tourism-service exports</strong>, up nearly 15% from a year earlier. Remittances reached about <strong>€274 million</strong>, up 9.4%. Labor-income inflows increased more than 24%. FDI reached roughly <strong>€404 million</strong>, up 11.8%. Gross foreign-exchange reserves were around <strong>€7.4 billion</strong>.</p><p>The current account deficit in that quarter was only about <strong>3.5% of GDP</strong>, materially better than a year earlier. Moreover, s<strong>ervices, primary income and secondary income together financed roughly 83% of Albania’s goods-trade deficit. So, safe to say that </strong>Albania is still importing substantially more goods than it exports, but, it has become sufficiently good at earning foreign currency through services and income transfers that the gap is increasingly manageable.</p><p>This is not fake growth — a foreign visitor spending €1,000 in Albania is economically similar, in the balance-of-payments sense, to Albania selling €1,000 worth of something to a foreign buyer. From the perspective of the central bank, exports and capital inflows initially look remarkably similar because both leave domestic residents holding additional foreign currency. Under a flexible exchange rate, that excess foreign currency tends to produce appreciation; under a fixed or managed system, the same inflow can expand the monetary base unless sterilized.</p><p>So far, nothing controversial, but there is an important nuance hidden inside Curve 1: <strong>none of these euros entering Albania speak directly to Albanian productivity.</strong></p><p>Those flows all increase purchasing power inside Albania, but they have fundamentally different implications for the country’s future production capacity and sustained growth.</p><h3>Tourism is an export… of what kind?</h3><p>There is a temptation to dismiss tourism as somehow “less real” than manufacturing. However, modern economies export services all the time. The United States exports software, consulting, finance and education. Ireland exports intellectual property. Switzerland exports financial and professional services.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*33h0T6kbPgNccOqo0jv2ew.png" /><figcaption>Number of tourists visiting Albania from 2018 to 2026.</figcaption></figure><p>The question is <strong>how dependent a country should become on an export whose customer decides almost entirely outside the country whether to buy it.</strong></p><p>In 2024, roughly 11 million foreign citizens entered Albania, and approximately 95% of those arrivals were for personal reasons such as holidays or visiting relatives. The IMF estimates that euro-area economic shocks have measurable effects on Albanian tourism, FDI, and the lek. A contractionary shock to euro-area activity reduces arrivals from the region and is associated with weaker FDI and a weaker lek, although the measured effects are relatively short-lived and the estimates have important statistical limitations.</p><p>If a German family decides next summer to skip Albania because German households are worried about their jobs, Albania does not have much say in that decision. If a French family chooses Sardinia instead of Sarandë, Albania does not control that either.</p><p>Tourism demand is discretionary — it is sensitive to European incomes, geopolitical perceptions, airline capacity, weather, relative prices and simply fashion.</p><p>And there is another complication. The headline number — tourism revenue — is not necessarily the same thing as the amount of foreign purchasing power retained inside Albania.</p><p>A hotel may import food. An investor may repatriate profits. A foreign-owned business may use imported equipment. Construction may require imported materials. A tourist’s €1,000 of spending is therefore not equivalent to €1,000 of additional Albanian domestic value added.</p><p>The relevant question is not: <em>How many euros did tourists spend?</em></p><p>It is: <em>How much Albanian income, capital and productive capability did that spending create?</em></p><p>That distinction rarely makes the tourism headline.</p><h3>Remittances are just as complex in their impact to the Albanian economy</h3><p>Remittances are unquestionably valuable to Albanian households — they support consumption, housing, education and household resilience.</p><p>They have also become an increasingly important source of foreign currency. The Q1 2026 figure — €274 million — is roughly 4.3% of quarterly GDP. The introduction of SEPA appears to have contributed to stronger formal remittance flows by reducing transfer friction.</p><p>A euro earned by an Albanian engineer in Milan and sent to Tirana is income for an Albanian household. It is not, however, output produced in Albania. If foreign income raises household purchasing power, demand rises for housing, restaurants, construction, transportation and other domestic services. That increased demand, increases wages in those sectors and it can pull labor toward non-tradable sectors. It can increase land and housing prices. And it can make it harder for a domestic factory or exporter to compete for workers.</p><p>The international literature on remittances has documented versions of this mechanism: large external transfers can appreciate the real exchange rate and shift resources toward non-tradable activity, while simultaneously making recipient households materially better off. This is a genuine economic trade-off.</p><h3>The parallel economy is the uncomfortable variable</h3><p>Then there is the part of Albania that is hardest to measure. The World Bank estimates Albania’s informal economy at roughly <strong>29–33% of GDP</strong>, depending on methodology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/399/0*5oNtrbgdgahyKWXm" /><figcaption>Tirana’s changing landscape through a relentless construction / real estate boom.</figcaption></figure><p>The FATF’s assessment of Albania has explicitly highlighted the importance of formalizing the economy and reducing money-laundering risks associated with widespread cash use. Albania subsequently made enough progress in its AML/CFT framework to be removed from the FATF’s increased-monitoring list in 2023.</p><p>There are also documented cases involving suspicious foreign funds being invested in Albanian real estate. That does <strong>not</strong> prove that illicit money is responsible for the strong lek. It would be irresponsible to make that claim. It is equally irresponsible, however, to pretend that a large cash economy has no macroeconomic relevance.</p><p>The key issue is measurement. Imagine that €100 million enters Albania through tourism. Another €100 million arrives through remittances. Another €100 million arrives through FDI. And another €100 million enters the domestic economy through transactions that are only partially recorded — or whose source is not captured cleanly by conventional statistics.</p><p>From the perspective of the foreign-exchange market, all four flows can eventually create the same immediate action: <strong>someone wants to convert euros into lek. </strong>This is why I think the parallel economy matters less as a sensational explanation for the strong lek and more as a <strong>source of uncertainty around the equilibrium itself</strong>.</p><p>It becomes harder to know how much of the country’s purchasing power is permanent. It becomes harder to know how much is being converted into productive capital. And it becomes harder to know what happens when the flow reverses.</p><h3>Curve 2: the part we actually need</h3><p>If Curve 1 is foreign purchasing power arriving in Albania, <strong>Curve 2 is Albania becoming better at producing things that foreigners want to buy. </strong>These would consist of manufacturing, agricultural products with higher value added, engineering / professional services, software / technology, research output etc.</p><p>Going back to the BB-NN framework we can separate competitiveness into two related pieces: the cost of factors, particularly labor, and productivity. An appreciation of the currency or an increase in domestic wages makes the same worker more expensive in foreign-currency terms; productivity improvements, by contrast, can offset that deterioration in competitiveness.</p><p>The practical implication is almost painfully simple: <strong>If Albanian wages rise 10% and the lek appreciates 10%, but productivity does not improve, Albanian exporters are in trouble. </strong>The worker became considerably more expensive to a foreign customer. And that appears to be one of the tensions emerging today.</p><p>EBRD reports that Albania’s economy grew 3.8% in 2025 and 3.7% in Q1 2026, driven importantly by public administration, real estate, and construction. At the same time, industry and agriculture continued to contract, with the stronger lek, weak external demand, and rising wages weighing on competitiveness. FDI was increasing, but Q1 2026 inflows were concentrated heavily in <strong>real estate and financial intermediation</strong>.</p><p>If the country is getting richer because it produces more sophisticated things per worker, that is one story. If it is getting richer because more foreigners come to the beach, more buildings are constructed, and more foreign income is spent domestically, that is another. Both can increase GDP, but, they do not create the same future.</p><p>And just to be totally clear — there is nothing inherently wrong with Curve 1. A country should absolutely exploit its comparative advantages. Albania should welcome tourists. It should attract FDI. It should make it cheap and easy for the diaspora to send money.</p><p>The problem arises when <strong>Curve 1 becomes so successful that it discourages the development of Curve 2.</strong></p><p>Imagine what happens next.</p><p>Foreign tourists bring euros -&gt; The lek appreciates -&gt; Imports become cheaper -&gt; Restaurants, hotels and construction become more profitable -&gt; Land prices rise -&gt; Wages rise -&gt; Labor leaves manufacturing and agriculture -&gt; Imported machinery becomes relatively cheap while labor-intensive exports become relatively expensive -&gt; Capital flows toward sectors serving domestic demand or foreign visitors -&gt; More foreign income comes in -&gt; Domestic demand increases again.</p><p>And the loop reinforces itself… This is a version of what economists call the <strong>Dutch disease mechanism</strong>: an increase in foreign-currency inflows can cause real appreciation and pull labor and capital toward non-tradable sectors, potentially weakening other tradable industries. The literature is clear that this does not automatically reduce overall economic growth — but it can create long-term costs if learning, productivity, and export capabilities are lost.</p><blockquote>The most dangerous outcome therefore is that tourism-like sectors keep doing well enough that Albania never feels enough pressure to build the next engine.</blockquote><h3>Two neighboring countries that should make Albania pay attention are Romania and Croatia</h3><p>Between 2003 and 2008, Romania experienced exceptionally rapid growth. Real GDP grew around 6.5% annually on average, powered by large capital inflows, rapidly growing consumption and investment.</p><p>The currency appreciated sharply. Romania’s real effective exchange rate appreciated roughly 50% between mid-2004 and mid-2007. And by 2007 the current-account deficit had reached approximately 14% of GDP. Then the global financial crisis arrived and capital inflows dried up.</p><p>The Romanian leu depreciated more than 15% against the euro after October 2008, and the impact was magnified by the fact that more than half of private-sector credit was denominated in foreign currency. The learning here is that <strong>an inflow-funded boom becomes dangerous when domestic demand and balance sheets start assuming that the inflows are permanent.</strong></p><p>Albania today is in a much stronger external position than Romania was before 2008. Its current-account deficit is nowhere near 14% of GDP and its reserve position is considerably stronger. But the overall mechanism on how the situation can take a downturn spiral is worth remembering.</p><p>Croatia is perhaps even more relevant — just like Albania, it had tourism, strong links to Europe, and a high degree of euroization. It experienced rapid credit growth and substantial foreign financing. For years the exchange rate was relatively stable.</p><p>Yet the economy accumulated significant external vulnerabilities. Its current-account deficit reached roughly 9.2% of GDP in 2008, while capital and financial inflows were large enough to finance it. Foreign-currency borrowing was widespread. Then the financing environment changed. In 2009, Croatian GDP contracted 5.8% and unemployment rose sharply.</p><blockquote>Yet again we can see how tourim and its equivalent sectors <em>can be a genuine strength without being sufficient protection against an external-financing shock. </em>Meanwhile, currency stability can sometimes make leverage <em>feel</em> safer than it actually is.</blockquote><h3>There is a way to turn Curve 1 into Curve 2 through focused government intervention</h3><p>For instance, between 2013 and 2017, the Czech National Bank deliberately kept the Czech koruna from appreciating beyond a stated exchange-rate floor, accumulating a very large foreign-exchange position in the process. It eventually exited the policy once inflation and broader economic conditions made the extraordinary intervention unnecessary. Through this strategy the government and the central bank used favorable external conditions to foster a productive economy internally, which would sustain growth even if the external conditions change.</p><p>So, the goal for Albania should not be to suppress tourism, stop remittances, weaken the lek artificially or discourage foreign investment. However, today’s foreign purchasing power could be intentionally channeled toward building tomorrow’s domestic earning power.</p><p>Rapid credit growth, housing booms, and rising consumption are warning signs when they are not matched by productive investment. Albania should therefore think very carefully about where the incremental capital associated with the current boom is going, and how to influence it through the right economic subsidies.</p><p>A new road that reduces logistics costs for exporters can increase Curve 2 output. A functioning industrial park connected to cheap reliable electricity can increase Curve 2. A research center that helps Albanian companies develop exportable technology can increase Curve 2.</p><p>A speculative property development may not. That does not mean property development has no economic value. It means its opportunity cost matters.</p><h3>All roads take you to technology investments and a future based on the software industry that has no geographical sense</h3><p>I have written elsewhere about why I believe AI is changing the economics of acquiring technical capability. My experience building a coding-education business in Albania several years ago convinced me that the country already had substantial latent technical talent; what was missing was an efficient mechanism for converting that talent into internationally competitive output.</p><p>Software requires capital, but generally much less physical capital than manufacturing. A 24-year-old in Tirana can sell software to a company in London without ever putting a physical product on a ship. That matters enormously for a small country.</p><p>Albania’s ICT-service exports were already around <strong>$214 million in 2024</strong> and represented about 3% of total service exports. That is still tiny relative to tourism, but it demonstrates that a digital export industry already exists. The EBRD and Bank of Albania have also explicitly identified internationally tradable digital services — including IT, data analysis and related knowledge services — as potential areas for Albania to expand beyond traditional industrial exports. The question is how to scale it.</p><p>In a relatively small economy competing agaisnt the whole world, the scale will not happen organically. Even simulating the supply-side will not naturally create demand. In this situation the state is unusually important because it is one of the few entities large enough to generate meaningful early demand. This does <strong>not</strong> mean telling the government to pick winners or give contracts to politically connected companies.</p><p>Quite the opposite — the idea would be to create <strong>transparent, competitive demand for exportable products</strong>.</p><p>Imagine Albania said:</p><ul><li><em>We have a problem in healthcare administration.</em></li><li><em>We have a problem in municipal permitting.</em></li><li><em>We have a problem in agricultural logistics.</em></li><li><em>We have a problem in tax compliance.</em></li><li><em>We have a problem in energy forecasting.</em></li><li><em>We have a problem in tourism management.</em></li></ul><p>And instead of buying another customized consultancy report, government created competitive procurement programs around measurable outcomes.</p><p>Build it in Albania. Prove it in Albania. Own the intellectual property. Then sell it to Greece, Italy, Germany etc.</p><p>Suddenly the government is no longer simply subsidizing the supply of programmers. It is <strong>creating the first reference customer for an export industry.</strong></p><h3>The question I would ask in 2026 is: <strong><em>What are we doing with the purchasing power that the strong lek and the foreign-currency boom have handed us?</em></strong></h3><p>Because there are two possible stories.</p><p>In the first:</p><p><strong>Foreigners spend money in Albania → Albania gets richer → Albania invests → productivity rises → exports diversify → wages rise sustainably → the strong currency becomes a consequence of a stronger economy.</strong></p><p>That is the virtuous version.</p><p>In the second:</p><p><strong>Foreigners spend money in Albania → Albania gets richer → property and consumption rise → the currency appreciates → tradable sectors become less competitive → labor moves away from them → productivity lags → Albania becomes increasingly dependent on foreigners continuing to spend money.</strong></p><p>That is the trap.</p><p>Both stories can look almost identical for ten years. The difference only becomes obvious when the external environment changes. And by then, it is too late to start building the missing productive capacity.</p><p>A country does not become sustainably prosperous simply because foreigners are willing to spend more money there. <strong>The strong lek may therefore not be the problem Albania needs to solve. </strong>It may be the warning that Albania has reached the point where the easy part of the transition is over.</p><p>Now comes the harder part: <strong>turning foreign purchasing power into domestic productive power.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=33f26fbde7d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Fence: What Albania’s Flamingo Revolution Is Really About]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/the-fence-what-albanias-flamingo-revolution-is-really-about-b99a6355b5a2?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b99a6355b5a2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Aug 2026 00:31:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-17T00:31:57.210Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There is a fence on the Albanian coast that may ultimately matter more than the flamingos — <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/jared-kushners-albania-headache-flamingos-contested/id1469394914?i=1000782815254">learn about it here coved by the Wall Street Journal</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*mIGkJ0McOxQP4_Jd" /></figure><p>The flamingos are beautiful, vulnerable and politically powerful symbols. The proposed luxury developments around Zvërnec and Sazan raise legitimate environmental questions about protected landscapes, biodiversity and the kind of tourism Albania wants to build. Those concerns should not be minimized. However, they do not fully explain why a dispute over a resort has evolved into something much larger: <strong>a protest about corruption, political power, economic opportunity and, increasingly, the character of the Albanian state itself</strong>. By July, tens of thousands had joined demonstrations in Tirana, forming a movement that had expanded well beyond its original environmental cause into broader demands for constitutional reform, anti-corruption measures and political change.</p><p>To understand why, it helps to look first not at the flamingos, but at “the fence” itself.</p><p>On one side of that fence lies the Albania millions of citizens have experienced since the collapse of communism: disputed property titles, restitution claims, cadastral errors, court cases that last for years, buildings awaiting legalization, uncertain ownership and a bureaucracy that can be simultaneously slow, opaque, and absolute. Property rights remain sufficiently unresolved that the Council of Europe is still running a dedicated program in 2026 to address what it describes as continuing structural problems in Albania’s protection of property rights. Recent cases from the European Court of Human Rights are striking:</p><ul><li>In Ramaj v. Albania, the Court described a citizen left unable to register property despite a final domestic judgment, in part because of structural problems in the system;</li><li>In Zyberi v. Albania, decided in January 2026, the Court again confronted the collision between restitution rights, subsequent construction and contradictory state action.</li></ul><p>These are not obscure technical failures. They are part of the lived inheritance of Albania’s transition. For decades, families have been told that property is complicated — communism erased or displaced ownership; then, the transition created overlapping claims. Restitution takes time. Compensation takes time. Registration takes time. Courts take time. The state asks citizens to accept uncertainty as one of the unfortunate costs of history.</p><p>And then a major international investor appears, making the other side of the fence visible. Suddenly companies can be created, land can be assembled, plans can advance, officials can negotiate, and enormous amounts of capital can begin moving through the system. That contrast is the sociological core of the moment. The question is not necessarily whether one particular investor literally broke the law. Nor should suspicions surrounding land transactions be presented as established guilt while investigations remain ongoing. The more powerful question is what ordinary Albanians believe they have just seen: a state that is an obstacle course for some people and a concierge for others.</p><p>That is what the fence concrete and scary for everyone. A cadastral dispute is abstract. A strategic-investment law is abstract. A planning decision is abstract. A protected-area amendment is abstract. A fence is not. A fence says: there is a line; somebody has access to what lies beyond it, and you do not. For a society still carrying unresolved arguments about who owns the land beneath its feet, that is an extraordinarily potent image.</p><p><strong>A country can grow while people still feel locked out</strong></p><p>There is a temptation to describe this simply as a story about inequality. But the economic data suggest something more interesting. By the conventional measure of disposable-income inequality, Albania does not look like one of the most unequal societies on earth. INSTAT reported a Gini coefficient of about 29.8 for 2024. Yet the same living-conditions data portray considerable insecurity: roughly one in five Albanians was at risk of poverty, while a much larger share experienced material or social deprivation or fell within the broader category of risk of poverty or social exclusion.</p><p>The political grievance of this reality is defined by the inequality of opportunity rather than only inequality of income.</p><ul><li>Can I establish ownership of my family’s land?</li><li>Can I compete for a public contract?</li><li>Can I obtain a permit without knowing the right person?</li><li>Can I build a business without attaching myself to a political network?</li><li>Can my child get a good job based on competence rather than connections?</li><li>If I sue someone powerful, will the law work on the same timetable for me?</li><li>If I work hard and play by the rules, can I realistically build a comfortable life here?</li></ul><p>This is why property rights connect so naturally to corruption and social mobility. A clean property title is not merely a document. It is collateral. It is security. It is an asset that can be sold, inherited, borrowed against or invested. An unresolved property claim is wealth that cannot fully become wealth. And that may be one of Albania’s deeper inequalities: inequality of convertibility. Some people can convert access into permits, permits into valuable land, land into capital, and capital into influence. Others cannot convert a family property into a clear title. Others cannot convert an education into a professional future. Others cannot convert honest work into the standard of living they want.</p><p>So, they make a different conversion. They convert citizenship into mobility. They leave.</p><p><strong>Emigration as Albania’s most successful social mobility program</strong></p><p>Albanian emigration is usually treated as a demographic or economic issue. It is also a profound political fact. The latest national household migration research shows just how embedded migration has become in Albanian life. Around 37% of Albanian households have at least one member who either currently lives abroad or has returned from migration.</p><p>According to the INSTAT–World Bank migration survey, Albanian migrants earn, on average, about 2.5 times what they earned before leaving Albania, and nearly 2.5 times the wages of comparable people who remain. Economists can call that labor-market arbitrage, but, for the average Albanian that’s called Germany, Italy, Britain or America.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*P7Qwg3hguYjq-d8n.jpg" /><figcaption>Albania showed the highest annual expatriation rate of nationals to OECD countries in 2023 (22 per 1 000 inhabitants) — <a href="https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2025/11/international-migration-outlook-2025_355ae9fd/full-report/recent-developments-in-international-migration-movements-and-labour-market-inclusion-of-immigrants_203de29e.html">https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2025/11/international-migration-outlook-2025_355ae9fd/full-report/recent-developments-in-international-migration-movements-and-labour-market-inclusion-of-immigrants_203de29e.html</a></figcaption></figure><p>The late political economist Albert Hirschman famously described the choices available to dissatisfied members of an institution as exit, voice and loyalty. For 35 years, Albanians have made extraordinary use of exit. Leaving has improved millions of individual lives. The diaspora supports families, acquires skills, sends money home and connects Albania to the wider world. But politically, exit has a cost. The ambitious young engineer who leaves cannot challenge a patronage network at home. The doctor in Munich cannot reform an Albanian hospital. The entrepreneur in Milan is not creating a competing business institution in Tirana. The young professional in London may still care passionately about Albania, but she is no longer living every day inside the institutions she might otherwise have fought to improve.</p><p>In that sense, Albania has spent decades exporting dissatisfaction and importing enough income to make dissatisfaction survivable. The Flamingo movement becomes especially interesting if some of that exit is now turning back into voice.</p><p><strong>The comparison with George Floyd — and its warning</strong></p><p>This is where the comparison to the United States after the killing of George Floyd becomes useful — not because the underlying injustices are equivalent, but because the sociology of a catalytic event can be similar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WRGR5HZB_w_cBJw4.jpg" /></figure><p>George Floyd’s murder did not create America’s history of racial inequality or concern about policing. It concentrated it. A single event became morally legible enough to carry the weight of many accumulated grievances. Years of organizing, previous cases, statistics and arguments suddenly acquired a human image that millions of people could understand without reading a policy paper.</p><p>Social movements sometimes need such moments. Sociologists describe them in different ways: focusing events, moral shocks, threshold moments, legitimacy crises. People tolerate thousands of smaller frustrations partly because each can be explained individually. Your court case is delayed. My permit was rejected. His job went to somebody connected. Her property documents disappeared. Their child emigrated. Someone else paid a bribe. Then one event arrives that seems to organize all those stories into a single sentence.</p><p>For Albania, the sentence might be: “We have struggled with our own land and our own state for 35 years; when powerful international capital arrived, suddenly the system knew how to move.”</p><p>The legal facts will always be more complicated than the sentence. Political symbols usually are. But that is precisely why symbols work... we cannto expect everything, all at once, from such an inflection point though. And, the George Floyd protest experience captures this warning in the ultimate outcome of the reelection of Donald Trump.</p><p>The American protests of 2020 were not meaningless. They influenced public debate and produced significant legislation / policy / behavior changes. But they did not produce the total structural transformation many demonstrators imagined during that extraordinary summer. Political attention moved. Coalitions changed. Backlash emerged. Institutions absorbed some reforms and resisted others.</p><p>Public outrage proved intense, but, institutional memory proved longer. The lesson for Albania is uncomfortable: A society can win the moral argument and still lose the institutional one. A protest creates political energy. It does not automatically create new rules. And political energy has a short half-life.</p><p><strong>Changing the government is not the same as changing the system</strong></p><p>This becomes particularly important when the movement asks what victory means. Prime Minister Edi Rama’s resignation is a clear demand. So is political rotation more broadly. And alternation in power matters. Democracies are healthier when governing parties believe they can lose elections. Competition creates uncertainty for incumbents and reduces the temptation to treat public institutions as permanent extensions of one political organization.</p><p>Albania’s own electoral record shows why this question deserves attention. International observers described the May 2025 parliamentary election as competitive and professionally managed but concluded that contestants did not enjoy a level playing field. ODIHR cited misuse of public resources, pressure on public employees, intimidation and concerns around vote buying and ballot secrecy. Freedom House, meanwhile, rates Albania Partly Free, at 69 out of 100 in its 2026 assessment. It describes elections as competitive but political parties as highly polarized and strongly organized around leading personalities, while corruption and bribery remain major problems.</p><p>Rotation therefore has value. But rotation cannot be confused with transformation. Albania has changed governments before. If the same political operating system remains — personalized parties, patronage, opaque economic relationships, discretionary permits, vulnerable regulators, weak internal party democracy and unequal access to the state — then changing parties can simply change who gets to operate the machine.</p><p>That is why perhaps the most radical question the Flamingo movement can ask is not: Who should govern Albania? It is: How do we make it matter less who governs Albania?</p><p>A mature state should not require the right political relationship in order to obtain a predictable result. Election results should not threaten your property, your business, your career, or your access to justice. That is what institutional democracy ultimately means.</p><p><strong>What would winning actually look like</strong></p><p>A movement that insists on one maximal demand — the government resigns or nothing has changed — gives itself only two possible outcomes: total victory or apparent defeat. But, structural change rarely happens that way — it happens in layers, addressed over a period of time, with the trigger itself being the <strong>first</strong>.</p><p>The movement can demand full transparency around Zvërnec and Sazan: ownership histories, transactions, environmental reviews, planning decisions, beneficial ownership, government commitments, and the adjudication of disputed claims.</p><p>The <strong>second</strong> layer should get into the rules that made the trigger possible: Property registration and restitution workflows; strategic-investment procedures; protected-area legislation and public consultation; procurement and conflict-of-interest rules; transparency around companies receiving government privileges.</p><p>The <strong>third</strong> is political competition — ODIHR has already laid out reforms around misuse of state resources, election administration, and campaign integrity. Those do not require inventing an entirely new political theory for Albania; many of the necessary benchmarks already exist.</p><p>The <strong>fourth</strong> is independent enforcement of law and norms, where independent prosecutors are adequately funded and protected.</p><p>The <strong>fifth</strong> layer is economic citizenship — none of the constitutional architecture will ultimately feel legitimate if a 25-year-old Albanian continues to look at the wage data and conclude that the rational path to a middle-class life begins at the airport. The ultimate task is to build an Albania where staying no longer feels like an economic penalty.</p><p><strong>Protest needs leadership and funding to be successful while not being absorbed into a party</strong></p><p>A movement can organically begin leaderless, but it probably cannot negotiate leaderless. Leaderlessness is powerful during the birth of a protest, since it makes political capture harder. It allows people from different ideological traditions to participate; however, eventually somebody must sit across a table and verbalize clear demands to the powers that be.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qmi0yzpprj6m-89T" /></figure><p>Research on civil resistance repeatedly emphasizes that durable organization, strategic targeting, and relationships with institutions matter alongside crowd size. Highly decentralized movements can mobilize quickly but often struggle with the transition from mobilization to negotiation and institution-building.</p><p>That does not mean Albania needs another charismatic savior. It may need the exact opposite — a negotiating council could be plural rather than personal: lawyers, students, environmentalists, economists, property-rights advocates, local communities, entrepreneurs, members of the diaspora and civic organizations. Delegates can rotate. Votes can be public. Mandates can be published. Conflicts of interest can be disclosed. Experts can draft proposals that everybody can read. The movement can practice internally the political culture it wants Albania to develop nationally.</p><p>Most importantly, leadership makes partial victories possible. And partial victories are not necessarily betrayals. Suppose the government does not resign, but disputed construction is frozen. Suppose property records are published. Suppose protected-area legislation is rewritten. Suppose an independent land-title review mechanism is established. Suppose strategic-investment rules become substantially more transparent. Suppose several ODIHR election recommendations become law. Suppose independent prosecutors receive stronger institutional protections.</p><p>Has the revolution failed? Of course not! It has converted moral energy into institutional capital. The danger is confusing purity with effectiveness. A movement that can only accept everything may eventually receive nothing. A movement that knows where it wants Albania to be in ten years can recognize meaningful steps along the way without losing sight of the destination.</p><p><strong>Breaking the fence</strong></p><p>Perhaps that is where the fence metaphor ultimately leads. The real fence in Albania is not the one erected near Zvërnec. It is the accumulated barrier between citizens and the institutions that are supposed to belong to them. It is the fence between owning land and having the state reliably recognize that ownership. Between having talent and having opportunity. Between starting a company and gaining access to markets. Between voting and believing the competition is genuinely equal. Between working hard and believing your children can build a better life without leaving the country. And between an ordinary citizen asking something from the Albanian state and a powerful person asking the same thing.</p><p>The goal should be to dismantle that fence. That is also why the Flamingo Revolution’s ultimate success cannot be measured only by whether one resort is built, one law survives, or one prime minister leaves the office. The greatest democratic achievement would be to push for institutions strong enough that Albania’s future no longer depends so heavily on the virtue of whichever individual happens to hold power, and “weak” enough, to understand that when the people come to the negotiating table there is no ignoring it.</p><p>Five or ten years from now, success would look almost boring, and that’s how we would know the folks in the streets in 2026 were successful: A family resolves a property claim without political intervention; a young entrepreneur wins a public tender despite knowing no minister; a journalist discovers who ultimately owns a company receiving state privileges; a court rules against a powerful businessperson and the ruling is enforced; a public employee refuses a party request and keeps her job; a prosecutor investigates the government without asking whether the government will survive the investigation. And a 25-year-old graduating from university sees Germany, Italy, Britain or America as possibilities — but can also imagine a dignified, prosperous future in Albania.</p><p>There would still be rich people. Foreign investors would still come.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b99a6355b5a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Opportunity Hidden Behind the AI Panic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/the-opportunity-hidden-behind-the-ai-panic-903780fa6188?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/903780fa6188</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Jul 2026 03:59:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-05T03:59:22.770Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><em>We often ask whether AI will replace people. We spend far less time asking what AI might allow people to become.</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DcbLIMf9VHA_91cJEEGBSg.png" /><figcaption>ChatGPT was used to generate this image.</figcaption></figure><p>When <em>The 2028 Global Intelligence Crisis</em>, a speculative report by Citrini Research, began circulating earlier this year, it spread through financial markets with remarkable speed. Although explicitly framed as a scenario rather than a prediction, its vision of widespread white-collar displacement and economic contraction resonated deeply with investors already uneasy about the pace of artificial intelligence (AI) . Markets reacted sharply — technology stocks sold off; entire sectors associated with knowledge work came under pressure.</p><p>Whether the report ultimately proves prescient is almost beside the point. What fascinated me was how quickly the conversation converged around a single assumption: that AI’s primary economic consequence will be to eliminate human work. That assumption deserves to be challenged — not because technological disruption isn’t real, but because it overlooks a much more profound possibility. AI may fundamentally change not only how we work, but how and why we educate ourselves in the first place.</p><p>Several years ago, in a brief stint away from biotech, I focused on establishing coding bootcamps in Albania.</p><p>The motivation was simple. Too many talented young people believed that a traditional university degree was the only credible path toward meaningful employment. We wanted to demonstrate another possibility: that focused, practical technical education could equip someone with valuable skills in months rather than years.</p><p>Coding bootcamps had already proven this model across the United States and Europe. Our hope was to replicate that success by lowering barriers into the digital economy while creating opportunities for a generation of young professionals.</p><p>At the time, however, coding still required significant technical expertise. Learning software engineering remained a substantial undertaking; however, AI changes that equation entirely. For the first time, acquiring the practical skills necessary to contribute to software development, digital operations, automation, and product creation is becoming dramatically more accessible. AI does not eliminate the need for technical understanding, but it dramatically accelerates the journey from novice to productive contributor.</p><p>Ironically, this technological shift may also allow universities to rediscover the purpose they originally served.</p><p>Today we often treat higher education primarily as an investment, but, <strong>universities were never designed as employment factories</strong>.</p><p>Students choose majors based on projected salaries. Universities advertise graduate employment statistics. Employers increasingly use degrees as screening mechanisms. This feels so natural that we rarely question whether universities were always intended to function this way — historically, they were not.</p><p>The earliest European universities organized learning around four principal faculties: Arts, Theology, Law, and Medicine. Even the Faculty of Arts — the foundation upon which further study depended — focused on the liberal arts: grammar, rhetoric, logic, arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music. These subjects were not vocational training in the modern sense. They were disciplines intended to cultivate judgment, reasoning, intellectual curiosity, and an enduring capacity to learn.</p><p>Theology occupied the highest intellectual status, not because it maximized earning potential, but because universities viewed the pursuit of truth, ethics, and meaning as worthy ends in themselves. Even medicine and law were taught within broader philosophical traditions that emphasized reasoning as much as technical competence.</p><p>So, it is safe to conclude that education existed to shape minds. Employment often followed, but it was not the primary objective. That is until the <strong>Industrial Revolution fundamentally impacted that social contract</strong>.</p><p>Rapid industrialization demanded engineers, accountants, chemists, managers, and specialists capable of operating increasingly complex economies. Universities adapted accordingly. Professional schools expanded. Technical disciplines flourished. Degrees gradually became signals of employability as much as intellectual achievement.</p><p>This evolution was not misguided. Industrial economies required highly specialized human expertise, and universities responded to that need. <strong>Yet over time, in a subtle way, we began asking universities to fulfill two distinct responsibilities simultaneously: they were expected to cultivate thoughtful, intellectually curious citizens, while also serving as the primary pipeline into the labor market</strong>.</p><p>For generations, these goals remained largely compatible. Today, they increasingly compete. Students routinely feel pressured to abandon intellectual passions in favor of economically “safe” degrees. Society often evaluates academic disciplines almost exclusively through the lens of starting salaries and employment statistics. Curiosity has gradually become subordinate to career optimization.</p><h3>AI Gives Us the Opportunity to Separate These Goals Again</h3><p>AI may allow us to rethink this arrangement. For perhaps the first time since the Industrial Revolution, the acquisition of economically valuable skills no longer depends exclusively on lengthy formal education.</p><p>Modern AI systems dramatically reduce the barriers to building software, analyzing data, automating workflows, and creating digital products. Combined with focused technical education — whether through coding bootcamps, vocational programs, or self-directed learning — they allow motivated individuals to become productive far more quickly than previous generations could.</p><p>This creates an opportunity to separate two objectives that have long been intertwined. Universities can return to cultivating judgment, creativity, ethics, scientific inquiry, philosophy, and deep disciplinary understanding, while, complementarily, practical technical education can evolve continuously alongside rapidly changing technologies.</p><p>Perhaps the greatest consequence of this shift is not automation — it is entrepreneurship.</p><p>Historically, many transformative ideas never became companies (or maybe it took so long that the society incurred a significant opportunity cost in the process) because execution required enormous technical resources. A physician with an innovative healthcare concept needed engineers. A historian with a vision for educational technology needed software developers. Scientists, teachers, designers, and operators depended upon specialized technical teams to translate expertise into products.</p><p>AI dramatically lowers those barriers, by giving domain experts the tools to build, i.e. the physician prototypes software, the scientist develops laboratory automation, the educator creates personalized learning platforms, the manufacturing engineer designs digital operational systems.</p><p>Execution becomes more accessible. Domain expertise becomes more valuable. So, rather than concentrating innovation within large technology companies, AI has the potential to distribute innovation across society. That may prove to be its greatest economic contribution.</p><p>I see early evidence of this transformation every day in biotech manufacturing.</p><p>The bottleneck in advancing deep-tech manufacturing is typically related to drawing correlations and/or causations through complex multivariate analysis, recognizing subtle weak signals that might lead to deviations, and making high-quality decisions (which often remain, and will do so for a long time, monopolized by humans) under uncertainty and time pressure.</p><p>AI increasingly removes friction from routine operational work. Digital twins surface insights automatically. Predictive analytics identify potential issues before they negatively impact the system. Subject-matter experts spend less time interacting with software and more time understanding the manufacturing process itself.</p><p>The technology, rather than eleminating the need for human expertise, elevates it, i.e. engineers devote more time to improving processes, operators focus more on decision-making than documentation. Patients ultimately benefit from more reliable manufacturing systems and faster organizational learning.</p><p>The result is not fewer humans. It is humans contributing at a higher level — a perspective recently also also shared on X by Satya Nadella, Microsoft CEO.</p><p>Too much of today’s AI conversation focuses on which company will build the most capable model or dominate the next technology cycle. That is an important competitive question; however, it is probably not the most important societal question.</p><p>The real measure of AI’s success will be whether its capabilities become broadly distributed — enabling millions of individuals, researchers, educators, entrepreneurs, manufacturers, and creators to solve problems that previously required enormous organizations and highly specialized technical teams.</p><p>The future of AI and success in that particular vertical should not be measured by the concentration of intelligence. It should be measured by the democratization of capability.</p><p>The Citrini report that spurred by reflections here imagines a future defined primarily by displacement. I imagine one defined by liberation.</p><p><strong>A future in which universities once again become places where people pursue knowledge because it expands their understanding of the world rather than because it maximizes their future salary. A future in which practical technical skills become increasingly accessible through focused education and intelligent software. A future in which expertise — not coding syntax — is the scarce resource. A future in which entrepreneurship becomes available to scientists, artists, physicians, historians, operators, teachers, and anyone else with deep knowledge and meaningful ideas.</strong></p><p>AI will undoubtedly reshape the labor market. Every major technological revolution has.</p><p>But perhaps its most enduring legacy will not be replacing workers. Perhaps it will be giving us the freedom to rediscover why we learn in the first place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=903780fa6188" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Vulnerability… how come?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/vulnerability-how-come-7f118bd5e2d2?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f118bd5e2d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mba]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brené-brown]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vulnerability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uc-berkeley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit-sloan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Mar 2022 02:12:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-01T02:12:27.469Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As part of my MBA training at MIT Sloan, I am taking 15.336 ID LAB: INDIVIDUAL DEVELOPMENT AND INTERPERSONAL DYNAMICS — one of the most highly coveted classes right now. ID Lab aims to help us look introspectively and become more intentional with regard to how we show up and how we lead. Only five classes in though, I was surprised to find out that we would spend a whole lecture on <em>vulnerability</em>. Can vulnerability really be such an important ingredient of leadership and success? Isn’t vulnerability a bad thing for a leader? Or for anyone for that matter…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fembed.ted.com%2Ftalks%2Fbrene_brown_the_power_of_vulnerability&amp;display_name=TED&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ted.com%2Ftalks%2Fbrene_brown_the_power_of_vulnerability&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fpi.tedcdn.com%2Fr%2Ftalkstar-photos.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fuploads%2F9595cdc1-fd8e-4aa1-863a-2c6641ae3cbb%2FBreneBrown_2010X-embed.jpg%3Fh%3D316%26w%3D560&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=ted" width="560" height="316" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/df2e97679d55118ac0ccf802e5726b70/href">https://medium.com/media/df2e97679d55118ac0ccf802e5726b70/href</a></iframe><p>Over the years, studies have shown that vulnerability is indeed at the core of feeling share and fear; however, what has been surprising as of more recently, is that vulnerability is a necessary ingredient of joy too. It is only after we work through the potential for failure that we can give our best on what we have on hand. It is only when we take a step forward into the unknown, a step with no guarantees that we can tap into new outcomes and possibilities. Thus, we have to make ourselves vulnerable to discover what we don’t know for certain. If one shuts down vulnerability, one is doomed to walk down a very well-delineated road, robbing oneself of the potential for greatness, i.e. a great business outcome coming out of new, unchartered strategy; the best relationship arising from unlikely circumstances etc.</p><p>This particular lecture made me think back about my upbringing, as well as my academic and professional training. <em>If vulnerability is such a critical component of unleashing one’s potential, how come I have never heard about it in this context before?</em></p><p>I guess for a lot of people this is one of those things that you absorb by induction at home, while you see your parents, siblings or others be vulnerable. However, for people like myself, who grew up in a household where discussions around feelings and fears are taboo, vulnerability is groomed into an anti-value. Moreover, given my Albanian origin, I grew up in a community that lauds authoritarian leaders, rather than inclusive ones that say things as they are.</p><p>Thus, as I think back, given that I had no input on defining the values that my family and my country impart, I am particularly concerned about the fact that I never heard about the value of vulnerability even in college. Mind you, I went to UC Berkeley — a top 3 engineering school in the US. Berkeley is an institution that works us incredibly hard and that definitely aims to foster the next generation of technical and non-technical world leaders, as it has often done in the past 154 years. Somehow I missed the memo that one could be vulnerable and develop into a successful leader, colleague and partner. The take-home message for me had always been that when you struggle, you just grit your teeth and keep at it.</p><p>However, as I continue thinking about my time in the industry, I realize that I am not the only one that missed that vulnerability memo. Even though still in this case I have had the privilege to work in Fortune 500 companies; companies that ranked highly every year in terms of employee satisfaction and several other values. I can think of at least two of my managers that lacked any sense of vulnerability. And that’s where I get stuck again… I left those two jobs exactly because I could not build a proactive channel of communication with my very aloof managers. How come I never realized that it was exactly a hint of vulnerability that I was longing for? How come I never tried to nurture being vulnerable internally, having experienced first-hand the detrimental effects the lack of can have on others? I guess that’s why I decided to go to business school…</p><p><em>“We are much more accustomed to not asking for exactly what we need and then being resentful or disappointed that we didn’t get it.”</em><br>- Dare to Lead by Brené Brown</p><p>The gap between what we need privately and what we state publicly, can be a rather wide one. One that can most effectively be bridged by a hint of vulnerability. It is the latter that allows us to switch from a predicting and controlling mode of operation, trying to perfect everything, to one where we delegate and trust the others around us.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7_hKy_NCktM_-VXL.png" /></figure><p>Of course, such a transition requires courage and trust. And while courage can be obtained through the practice of being vulnerable, trust and vulnerability engage in more of chicken-and-egg problem. One can usually only be vulnerable with people whom he/she trusts. However, trust is only earned through paying attention, listening closely, and engaging in gestures of genuine care and connection. Thus, it is of utmost importance for each and everyone of us to take time and look introspectively in order to understand who we are willing to trust with our vulnerability and at what degree. It is critical for a successful leader, a loving partner, a caring friend, to communicate clearly where he/she is coming from, and open up a two-way, proactive, feedback channel.</p><p>Maybe one day, after enough of us realize the importance of vulnerability, either the hard way, — through a failed relationship because we were too busy keeping a straight face through struggles, or through a miserable job experience when working with a manager that displayed no emotions even when going through the highest highs or the lowest lows — or through venues like the ID lab, vulnerability will take the center stage it deserves. Given the multitude of opportunities that technology is offering to people of all ages around the world to join the workforce and get out of the classic education path that is socially rather well-behaved, I would say that every high-schooler should be taught early on about the importance of having the courage to show up even when you cannot control the outcome. These “vulnerable” folks will be the ones making a difference in the world through their leadership.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f118bd5e2d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ukraine under attack — where does the responsibility lie?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/ukraine-under-attack-where-does-the-responsibility-lie-b242178f0ab3?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b242178f0ab3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ukraine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Feb 2022 01:54:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-25T01:54:23.028Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Ukraine under attack — where does the responsibility lie?</h3><p>Today, on February 24th, 2022, I woke up at my studio in Boston, as early as usual, albeit the troubled sleep, and headed over to school. I was going to start my day, just like any given Thursday — sitting in my Corporate Finance class, participating in the discussion about the optimal capital structure of a business, without any consideration about where my head has been in the last few months, or even what is going on out there in the world right now.</p><p>Some 4,500 miles away, the last 12 hours had been some of the most terrifying in the lives of the people living there — at dawn, Russia launched a full-blown offensive against Ukraine. I do not think that anybody in Kyiv, unlike me and my peers here, is able to think about capital structure today… but, how can <em>we</em> pull it off and go about our day as per usual?!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/830/0*TB5rNS4Qf9gOTct1.jpg" /></figure><p>However far 4,500 miles might sound, in the world we live in, physical distance does not mean much. The pharma company across the street from my school in Cambridge, MA works daily with software engineering contractors based in Russia. One of the start-ups being incubated on campus just had their website built by a Ukrainian team of web developers. So, how can we be so myopic and not realize that a war in Ukraine is not any different from one on our backyard?</p><p>Given my inclination toward a strong government, I am always tempted to blame the US and the Western European countries for allowing this conflict to escalate. What is the point of having a mighty military power, if you are unable to deter conflict through it? And if you cannot deter it… do you really just stop and stare? <br>Nevertheless, I think that in the globalized economy we are all a part of, the blame falls beyond the governments of these countries.</p><p>In 2019, for the first time ever, the Business Roundtable came up with a commitment to shift away from Milton Friedman’s shareholder primacy mode of operation, to one that includes commitments to all stakeholders. These stakeholders consist of the shareholders of course, but also all of the customers, the suppliers, as well as the employees and their communities.</p><p>The 180 CEOs part of Business Roundtable did not make this course-correction simply because they want to give back to the ecosystem their companies are a part of. They realized how much more profitable their business can be if every stakeholder is operating at their optimum. That said, these CEOs still have a hard time to draw the line between what is right and what is easy. They do lip service to a new paradigm of doing business, while shamefully defaulting to the status quo.</p><p>Siemens, ArcelorMittal, Nestlè, Carlsberg, SAP are only a few of the multinationals that have significant operations in Ukraine. On the other hand, Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz, Shell, Exxon are present in large staff numbers in Russia. Apple has offices in both countries… The list of companies goes on. These companies combined have a net worth higher than the GDP of Russia and Ukraine combine. These companies have platforms that a lot of countries do not possess; their influence can be substantial. Yet, not a single one of them dares to take a stance toward the Russian invasion of Ukraine (or that of Crimea in 2014, or that of Ossetia in 2008…). Even though this is a move that might for a very long time disrupt the macro-economic landscape of the whole world.</p><p>It is saddening to see how much we rely on the agency of our private sector and still time and time again we see how the short-term incentives of the shareholders marginalize some of the most basic rights of the rest of the stakeholders. What is happening in Ukraine today, is a reminder for each and everyone of us, not only to keep our governments responsible, but to also be more conscious about who we work for / with and to keep them honest. Ultimately, it is all of us together that can make a difference in the world — not any single government official, not any single CEO.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b242178f0ab3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do what is fair, not simply what seems advantageous in the short-term!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/do-what-is-fair-not-simply-what-seems-advantageous-in-the-short-term-6d0dbcfddf5e?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d0dbcfddf5e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stakeholder-capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sloan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Oct 2020 14:44:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-21T14:44:31.525Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This essay is my personal reflection when asked about my individual leadership compass and my goals as a future leader. This was originally written during my first semester at MIT Sloan, for my 15.317 Leadership class. However, only a few days away from the general elections in the US, which this time around more than ever seem to ask for a very distinct choice between two very different types of leadership models and vision, I thought I would share my own, personal reflection on the responsibilities of a leader.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FkgKep5sr3AZXXMQ.jpg" /></figure><p>The word “lead” made its first appearance in 825 AD with a meaning defined as: “to cause to go along with oneself.” (OED Online, 1989) Several centuries later, I do not think that the definition of what a leader should be doing has changed much. In business terms, a leader is the person who can effectively align the constituents of an organization toward its overall mission. However, in my opinion, the drive toward the overarching goal of a company has to be much more of a cumulative sum of the individual intentions of its stakeholders, rather than a forced pull in that direction by leadership.</p><p>Here I will discuss the importance of understanding the input of all the stakeholders for a leader. After LGO I will be joining a work environment that has been operating under the shareholder primacy principle for decades. Thus, I want to bring forth statistical data that show why we are in need of a distinct course. I will discuss articles from Friedman, Stout, <em>et al</em>. to show that in the long-term, shareholder primacy can compromise human integrity. I base the latter concept on the tenet that “individual rights are absolute, but individual power is not,” and that frontiers should be drawn within which the rights of each person are inviolable. (Berlin, 1984) In a world that is effectively controlled by companies and private interests, it is the duty of the business leader to define these frontiers and operate within them with fairness.</p><p>Shareholder primacy legitimizes the opportunity for a company to marginalize the rights of its stakeholders other than its <em>de jure</em> owners; over the long run however, this leads to adverse business outcomes. Before trying to argue in favor of this thesis, I think it is important to understand why shareholder primacy has flourished. This philosophy was deemed unpopular in the early-20th Century; nevertheless, from the 1970s onwards it made a massive comeback. (Stout, 2012) What else happened in those years to make shareholders stop the common practice of reinvesting the earnings in increasing capabilities and enabling employees to work and live better? It was the latter practice that led to the post-World War II “sustained prosperity” in the first place. (Lazonick, 2014) So, why deviate from it? By 1970 the economies of countries debilitated by World War II were bouncing back. This pressure caused American business leaders to cut costs through a downsize-and-distribute scheme, such that they could allocate the same, and eventually even more profit to the shareholders, regardless of the reduced market share. Under the faulty assumption that business is a zero-sum game, these leaders embraced value extraction over value creation. Eventually they stepped over the needs of stakeholders such as their employees — real wages for hourly-paid workers in the US peaked in 1973 and have yet to reach that level today, at a time when until before the COVID-19 pandemic the stock market was indicating the most successful period in history for the economy. (Pew, 2018) How can one explain the fact that when productivity in the US grows by 74.4% from 1973 to 2013, hourly compensation grows by at most 9.2%, other than through an unfair tax on the splendid work done by the employees of these companies? (EPI, 2015)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*UWQFjIujR8wvePCA" /></figure><p>Moreover, from 1991 to 2003, the CEO-to-average employee compensation ratio has increased from 140 times to 500 times. This bias in compensation is one of the main drivers of wealth inequality, ranking the US as number one across the G7 countries. (Pew, 2020) Thus, I claim that shareholder primacy has contributed to employment instability, income inequality and ultimately a misalignment of the different stakeholders that define a business organization. The latter phenomenon which can easily be identified as a failure in leadership, is largely supported by the recent surge in union action across the US. (Kasturi, 2020)</p><p>Borrowing on Milton Friedman’s rhetoric, in my opinion, a leader who decides to disproportionately allocate resources toward making the shareholders richer today, rather than ensuring continuous investment into all of the stakeholders that produce these resources in the first place is engaging in “taxation without representation.” (Friedman, 1970) Needless to say, I exactly see this effective taxation opposite to how Friedman defines it, when he assumes that allocation of resources away from the shareholders is unfair. Thus, my long-term goal is to make a dent in how business is conducted, such that we can stop the ongoing alienation between different stakeholders. I deeply believe that if we are able to distribute the benefits of the abovementioned increase in productivity proportionately across all actors involved, we can shift from the unstable local optimum businesses are operating at, toward a globally optimal point. I want my legacy to be one of inclusivity, where we as business leaders, go out of our way to open a seat at the table for representatives of all of the interest groups that constitute the organizations we are part of. Only in that way we can make sure to align the company mission with that of all its constituents. Anything short of that can easily digress into a dynamic where what seems like a “miracle” to a set of stakeholders, can ignite the deepest hatred against the <em>status quo</em> from another group.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yrB84GoKPX8cha3g" /><figcaption>The “Miracle of Chile” eventually led to a stark wealth gap, leading to violent protests starting from the end of 2019, only to be put on hold because of the Covid-19 pandemic.</figcaption></figure><p>In this essay I have tried to identify what leadership means to me by exploring reasons why the type of leader I intend to be is not popular today, while also showing that there is room to move toward a more ethically sound position. However, I want to conclude by expressing my earnest goal to further my understanding of what different groups see as equitable. In LGO I intend to develop the necessary frameworks to be able to implement the vision and dream of the people I work with in the future into the company charter. As a leader, and as a person, I want to be seen as dependable and not reluctant to say “I am here” to the individual that needs my allyship. (Noddings, 2002)</p><p><strong><em>Bibliography</em></strong></p><p><em>Berlin, I. (1984). Two Concepts of Liberty. In M. Sandel, Liberalism and its critics (pp. 16–35). New York: New York Univeristy Press.</em></p><p><em>EPI. (2015, January 6). Wage Stagnation in Nine Charts. Retrieved June 2020, from Economic Policy Institute: https://www.epi.org/publication/charting-wage-stagnation/</em></p><p><em>Friedman, M. (1970, Septermber 13). The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits. The New York Times Magazine.</em></p><p><em>Kasturi, C. S. (2020, April 23). Butterfly Effect: Homeward Bound. Retrieved from OZY: https://www.ozy.com/around-the-world/butterfly-effect-homeward-bound/311197/</em></p><p><em>Lazonick, W. (2014, September). Profits without Prosperity. Harvard Business Review.</em></p><p><em>Noddings, N. (2002). Introduction: Starting at Home. In N. Noddings, Starting at Home: Caring and Social Policy (pp. 1–15). Berkeley: University of California Press.</em></p><p><em>OED Online. (1989). Retrieved June 2020, from Oxford University Press: www.oed.com</em></p><p><em>Pew. (2018, August 7). For most US workers real wages have barely budged for decades. Retrieved from Pew Research Center: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/</em></p><p><em>Pew. (2020, February 7). 6 Facts about Economic Inequality in the US. Retrieved June 2020, from Pew Research Center: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/02/07/6-facts-about-economic-inequality-in-the-u-s/</em></p><p><em>Stout, L. (2012). The Shareholder Value Myth. San Francisco: Berrett-koehler Publishers, Inc.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d0dbcfddf5e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who am I?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/who-am-i-5406356b8cfb?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5406356b8cfb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[engineer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accountability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 Jul 2020 10:16:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-20T07:59:47.339Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KOLzHdVt2W23361N.jpg" /></figure><p>I think this existential question is at the core of every decision we make, and determines how we project ourselves in all of the dynamics we encounter in life.</p><p>Hence, for me it has been important to look back at my journey and think about all of years I have spent / plan to spend training from a professional aspect. I am aware that who we are is not simply determined by what we are trained to do; our family, our communities etc. have a significant role too. However, when I considered the sheer number of years I have spent in school and then in the workplace putting in practice the ideas professed by our work domain, all of a sudden, it dawned on me that who I am today / who I want to to must be impacted significantly from my engineering and managerial training.</p><p>Thus, I want to very clearly state here the obligations I confer upon myself as an engineer and as a future manager:</p><h4>The Obligation of the Engineer</h4><p>I am an Engineer.<br>In my profession I take deep pride. To it I owe solemn obligations.</p><p>As an engineer, I, Ori Hoxha, pledge to practice Integrity and Fair Dealing, Tolerance, and Respect, and to uphold devotion to the standards and dignity of my profession, conscious always that my skill carries with it the obligation to serve humanity by making best use of the Earth’s precious wealth.</p><p>As an engineer, I shall participate in none by honest enterprises. When needed, my skill and knowledge shall be given without reservation for the public good.</p><p>In the performance of duty, and in fidelity to my profession, I shall give the utmost.</p><h4>The MBA Oath</h4><p>As a business leader I recognize my role in society.</p><p>My purpose is to lead people and manage resources to create value that no single individual can create alone.</p><p>My decisions affect the well-being of individuals inside and outside my enterprise, today and tomorrow. Therefore, I promise that:</p><ul><li>I will manage my enterprise with loyalty and care, and will not advance my personal interests at the expense of my enterprise or society.</li><li>I will understand and uphold, in letter and spirit, the laws and contracts governing my conduct and that of my enterprise.</li><li>I will refrain from corruption, unfair competition, or business practices harmful to society.</li><li>I will protect the human rights and dignity of all people affected by my enterprise, and I will oppose discrimination and exploitation.</li><li>I will protect the right of future generations to advance their standard of living and enjoy a healthy planet.</li><li>I will report the performance and risks of my enterprise accurately and honestly.</li><li>I will invest in developing myself and others, helping the management profession continue to advance and create sustainable and inclusive prosperity.</li></ul><p>In exercising my professional duties according to these principles, I recognize that my behavior must set an example of integrity, eliciting trust and esteem from those I serve. I will remain accountable to my peers and to society for my actions and for upholding these standards. This oath I make freely, and upon my honor.</p><p>One might argue that codes like the ones above are “merely motherhood and apple pie statements that carry no credible moral force to reliable shape behavior” as Dean Nohria and Prof. Khurana warned against in their “It’s Time to Make Management a True Profession” piece in 2008. However, as the political scientist Robert Axelrod points out, these meta-norms at the professional level are critical in guiding the behavior of individuals at the company/society level at large.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5406356b8cfb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Code for Albania — E Ardhmja Post-COVID19 kalon nga Teknologjia]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/code-for-albania-e-ardhmja-post-covid19-kalon-nga-teknologjia-3b22ff12ce6c?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3b22ff12ce6c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[code-for-albania]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[industrial-revolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alphaplan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[computer-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Apr 2020 16:40:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-21T16:40:45.188Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong><em>Code for Albania</em> — E Ardhmja Post-COVID19 kalon nga Teknologjia</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*BJbowVqrNTMNP5796oRaZA.png" /></figure><p>Prof. Simon Johnson, nga MIT, ish-Kryekonomist i FMN, identifikon 3 pika për të rihapur ekonominë në këtë situatë pandemie: 1) testim deri në 3% të popullsisë çdo ditë, 2) izolim të grupeve të rrezikuara, dhe 3) përmirësim i praktikave të përditshme të secilit prej nesh. Ndërkohë që dy pikat e para nuk lënë shume vend për ekuivokë, e treta duhet të na bëjë të vemë në lëvizje të gjithë kreativitetin tonë. Ajo na drejton jo vetëm që të përdorim maska e doreza në çdo kohë, por edhe të fillojmë të përshkallëzojmë në shoqërinë tonë aspekte pune e industri që e bëjnë jetën tonë më të sigurtë. Nje praktikë e tillë mbështetet fort në ekonominë dixhitale. Po të shikojmë përhapjen e virusit në ShBA sot, vëmë re se në <em>Silicon Valley</em> — vendi më pjellor teknologjik në botë — kurba e përhapjes së virusit jo vetëm është sheshuar, por spitalet e Kalifornisë tashmë po mbështesin edhe shtetet e tjera të ShBA me materiale të nevojshme për tu përballur me COVID-19. Ndonëse një marrdhënie shkak-efekt midis shtrirjes së ekonomisë dixhitale dhe tkurrjes së përhapjes së virusit është pothuajse e pamundur për tu ravijëzuar, korrelacioni mes kësaj të fundit dhe faktit që një individ në Silicon Valley mund të punojë pa asnjë mangësi në produktivitetin e tij nga shtëpia, ndërkohë që të gjithë shërbimet i gjenden po aty përmes një aplikacioni në telefon, na bën të mendojmë se diçka duhet të mësojmë nga ky realitet i cili përballet me pandeminë në një mënyrë kaq organike.</p><p>Të dhënat e Bankës Botërore tregojnë se ICT zë vetëm 0.1% të eksporteve të të mirave nga vendi ynë. Ndërkohë që mesatarja e vendeve të Ballkanik perëndimor dhe ajo e vendeve të BE, janë 1% dhe 5%, respektivisht. Këto shifra, së bashku me faktin që sot në botë ka rreth 2.4 million vende të lira pune në industri të lidhura ngushtë me teknologjinë, na tregojnë se tregu është më se i hapur për profesinistët shqiptarë. Gjithësesi, kompanitë e <em>outsourcing</em> në vend, të cilat kryejnë projekte ICT-je për kompani të huaja, ndonëse nuk e mohojnë kërkesën, identifikojnë një problem tjetër: në vendin tonë mungojnë njohuritë bazë dhe një numër i nevojshëm profesionistësh për t’ju përgjigjur kësaj kërkese.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LNUF6FtC-FwQMc0D" /></figure><p>Për të adresuar këtë nevojë esenciale të ekosistemit të teknologjisë në vend, një ndërhyrje në sistemin arsimor është një domosdoshmëri. Por ashtu siç dihet gjerësisht, reformat në arsim nuk janë të drejtpërdrejta e fillimisht është e nevojshme për të eksperimentuar në një mënyrë të decentralizuar. Pikërisht këtë po mundëson qendra <em>alphaPlan</em>, e themeluar nga rrjeti i diasporës shqiptare në Silicon Valley, përmes programit të saj të pare <em>Code for Albania</em>. Ky program jashtëshkollor për nxënësit e shkollave të mesme, i trajnon pjesëmarrësit në Shkenca Kompjuterike dhe Mentalitet Krijues, duke i vënë këta nxënës në kontakt të drejtpërdrejtë me instruktorë të përgatitur në Universitetin Stanford, universiteti numër një në botë për shkenca dixhitale dhe inovacion. Këta instruktorë vizitojnë Shqipërinë dhe angazhohen në rritjen e liderave të rinj të teknologjisë në vend përgjatë tre viteve për secilën klasë. Një kurrikulë e tillë, e shtrirë në kohë, i mundëson këta mentorë të mirëpërgatitur qe jo vetëm t’i japin të rinjve tanë aftësitë e nevojshme në programim, por gjithashtu edhe të ushqejnë tek ata një mentalitet rritjeje siç është përkufizuar nga Prof. Dweck, po nga Universiteti Stanford. Vetëm një mentalitet i tille, i cili fuqizon individin dhe e bën atë të ngrejë pyetje rreth mënyrës se si ai vetë mund të kontribuojë në përmirësimin e realitetit rreth tij, do te mundësojë shoqërinë tonë të bëhet pjesë e këtij adaptimi ekonomik.</p><p>Revolucioni i katërtë industrial po ndodh, dhe në qendër të tij është ekonomika dixhitale. Ne duhet të bëhemi pjesë e tij sepse ndryshe e dënojmë vendin tone me 100 vjet vetmi. E për këtë arsye në 10 vitet e ardhshme ne duhet të investojmë së bashku në përgatitjen e së paku 100,000 programuesve, të cilët do jetojnë, punojnë, edukojnë dhe investojnë këtu.</p><p>Sot duhet patjetër t’i bashkohemi këtij vizioni të përbashkët, duhet patjetër të investojmë te njeri-tjetri siç nuk e kemi bërë asnjëherë. Sepse shumëçka në ekonominë e revolucionit të katërt do varet nga fuqia jonë e zjarrit rreth sipërmarrjes në teknologji; diçka që nuk gjenerohet nga makineri, as nga toka, e as nga ndërtime, por nga persona të aftë në shkenca kompjuterike dhe mendim kritik.</p><p>Prandaj dhe për ne, nismëtarët e <em>alphaPlan,</em> përhapja e kodimit dhe inovacionit është një detyrë patriotike, siç ishte shkrimi dhe këndimi 100 vjet më pare. Prandaj dhe çdo ditë kërkojmë persona dhe organizata që t’i bashkohen vizionit tone — <em>Code for Albania</em> sot për të pasur 100,000 programues për Shqipërinë nesër. Së bashku do t’ja dalim!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3b22ff12ce6c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Një Shqipëri Globaliste Alternative]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/nj%C3%AB-shqip%C3%ABri-globaliste-alternative-dfdd73ff3d98?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dfdd73ff3d98</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[charter-cities]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[globalisation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[albania]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Mar 2020 14:06:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-23T14:06:03.467Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q-O5wJbGR6BgzZcWvJwJ9Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Sot, ne nje kohe kur i gjithe njerezimi po lufton me pandemine COVID-19, me shume se kurre kuptojme se si na duhet te bashkohemi me njeri-tjetrin, pertej kufijve, dhe te gjejme zgjidhje me te mira per problemet qe hasim te gjithe se bashku. Megjithese kjo pandemi e ben kete ide shume konkrete sot, probleme te tilla ne kemi hasur dhe hasim cdo dite; ngrohja globale, pergjigja ndaj kancerit etj. jane vetem disa shembuj qe na tregojne se ne si individe, apo qofte edhe shteti yne, cilido qofte ai, jemi shume te vegjel per tu perballur me keto probleme ne menyre te izoluar. Gjithesesi per nje vend qe te shtoje vlere ne nje realitet globalist, ai duhet qe ne nje menyre a nje tjeter te ofroje qendrueshmeri ekonomike e sociale, c’ka do ti jepte vlere punes dhe kapitalit te vendit. Ne cdo shtet, pasiguria ekonomike dhe mungesa e stabilitetit ligjor sjell renie te volumit te investimeve afatgjata apo atyre ne prodhimtari, cka jane jetike per te adresuar problemet e medha te njerezimit te permendura me lart.</p><p>Nje numer i madh ekonomistesh ne bote shikon hapesirat urbane si çelesi per zhvillimin e metejshem te ekonomise. Shume prej tyre mbeshtesin gjithashtu idene qe krijimi dhe menaxhimi ne menyre efikase i ketyre zonave urbane eshte ndoshta menyra e vetme se si vende qe nuk jane tashme akoma ne ballinen e zhvillimit ekonomik boteror, si Shqiperia, mund te arrijne atje. E ne fakt nuk duhet shume ekspertize per te arritur ne konkluzionin qe nje hapsire e dendur urbane, me diversitetin dhe ekspozimin e gjere qe ajo ofron per sa i perket kultures apo industrive te ndryshme, do te bente ata qe jetojne aty te mesojne si te adaptohen me shpejt me ndryshimin apo si te jene vete katalizatore te ndryshimit. Ky efekt pozitiv i te jetuarit ne hapesira urbane eshte ne fakt real jo vetem per qeniet njerezore; rrjedha e evolucionit e shume kafsheve ne bote po ndikohet thellesisht nga urbanizimi. Ne Sendai, Japoni, korbi ka mesuar si te perdore rrotat e makinave ne levizje per te hapur levozhgen e arres, duke ngrene arren pasi makina kalon mbi te. Ne ShBA nje tjeter familje shpendesh qe preferojne te jetojne prane urave te betonit ne autostrada, kane tashme nje shtrirje krahesh 2 milimetra me te shkurter se ne 1980-n; kjo sepse speciet me krahe me te gjate jane me te ngathet e rezultojne te paafte per te shamngur makinat qe kalojne me shpejtesi ne autostrade, duke mundesuar seleksionimin natyror te propagoje ekzistencen e homologeve te tyre te “shkathet.” Por nderkohe, a po marrim ne, njerezit, me te miren nga kjo mundesi zhvillimi nepermjet hapresirave urbane qe mund te aksesojme?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBGPGknpq3e0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBGPGknpq3e0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBGPGknpq3e0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/416d4ba5d752761cfe5b7eee47bff5e2/href">https://medium.com/media/416d4ba5d752761cfe5b7eee47bff5e2/href</a></iframe><p>Pike se pari, nga statistikat, duket se padiskutim, popullsia e botes po perqendrohet gjithmone e me shume ne qytete — 55% e popullsise se botes sot jeton ne zona urbane dhe pritet qe deri me 2050-n rreth 68% e popullsise se botes te kete levizur drejt qyteteve. Dhe ky eshte nje trend tashme i njohur edhe ne Shqiperi, ku pas renies se diktatures komuniste peshorja e perqendrimit te popullsise nderroji kah duke shenuar me 2016-n 53.4% ne favor te qytetit. Kjo zhvendosje nuk ka qene e rastesishme neper bote, por ka ardhur me krijimin e disa “super-zonave” qe sot terheqin perpara ekonomine boterore. Nje nga keto shembuj eshte Silicon Valley ne Kaliforni, e perkufizuar me zonat metropolitane te San Francisco, San Jose dhe Oakland se bashku.</p><p>Silicon Valley — nje zone qe mori kete emertim rreth viteve ’70 — shikon rritje te popullsise ne menyre te vazhdueshme qe prej 1800-tes. Ndonese me 1800-ten ishte uria per ar qe krijonte kete tendence drejt Kalifornise, sot rreth 34% e kapitalit te investuar ne ShBA vjen ne Silicon Valley. Duke pare kete progresion rritjeje te popullsise dhe njekohesisht edhe te urbanizimit ne kete zone, — 7 milion banore e 101 qytete ne nje rreze prej 1000 km2 — nuk eshte e veshtire te imagjinosh se si sot popullsia e Silicon Valley eshte nje nga me diverset ne te gjithe boten. Vetem 50% e popullesise eshte e bardhe, per te mos folur per diversitetin ideologjik i cili mund te jete vetem shume here me kompleks se sa ai etnik. Ky diversitet dhe kjo perzierje e kulturave dhe eksperiencave te ndryshme, shkakton shpeshhere qe norma te ndryshme qe ndalojne dike te ndermarre nje hap, apo mos te ngreje pikepyetje mbi menyra te caktuara perqasjeje ndaj problemeve, te anashkalohen dhe qe t’i besohet ne menyre radikale arsyes dhe argumentimit kritik. Besoj se kjo ka qene dhe eshte rrenja e inovacionit qe Silicon Valley ka ofruar per te gjithe boten, me kompani si HP, Apple, Google apo me start up-e me tregje te konsiderueshme tashme si Uber apo Square. Nje numer i madh organizatash ne bote po mundohen sot te riprodhojne nje ambjent te tille ne qytete apo shtete te tjera ne mbare boten.</p><p>Nje tjeter shembull per tu marre ne konsiderate eshte Hong Kong-u — nje rast shume ndryshe nga ai i Silicon Valley, po njekohesisht po aq me influence ne zhvillimin ekonomik te kontinentit Aziatik e ne ate menyre te te gjithe botes sot. Qe prej mesit te shekullit XX, Hong Kong-u u administrua nga Britania e Madhe per me shume se 150 vjet, periudhe gjate se ciles ritmi ekonomik i Hong Kong-ut ishte shume me i larte se sa i Kines vete. Gjate kesaj kohe ky territor qeverisej prej nje bashkesie rregullash e ligjesh shume te ndryshme nga ato te Republikes Popullore te Kines — rregulla pergjate linjave te ekonomise se tregut, te ngjashme me ato ne Britani. Ishin keto rregulla te mira qe bene qe shume prej banoreve te Kines te leviznin ne Hong Kong per te jetuar e per te punuar, per nje te ardhme me te mire per ta dhe familjen e tyre. Deng Xiaoping, lideri i Kines ne vitet 1980, e kuptoi potencialin e zonave urbane me nje bashkesi rregullash qe u jepnin nje mundesi te re zgjedhjeje banoreve te vendit, e ne te njejten kohe edhe kompanive te ndryshme per tu vendosur e per te operuar ne keto zona speciale. Duke u frymezuar nga rasti i Hong Kong-ut, ai vendosi te krijonte 4 prej ketyre zonave ne afersi te kolonise Britanike te asokohe — zona keto me rregulla te ndryshme nga pjesa tjeter e Kines, e me incentiva te forta per kompani te huaja per tu vendosur aty. Shume shpejt keto zona thellesisht urbane — ne kontrast me Kinen pergjithesisht rurale — terhoqen nje popullsi prej 20 milion banoresh. Shenzhen, “eksperimenti” me i suksesshem i Deng Xiaoping, sot eshte pergjegjes per prodhimin e iPhone-in nga i cili shume prej jush po e lexojne kete shkrim. Sot ka me shume se 15 zona te tilla speciale ne Kine.</p><p>Po zonat urbane ne Shqiperi si po ndikojne ne zhvillimin e vendit tone e te banoreve te tyre? Segmenti Tirane-Durres, me rreth 1 milion banore — nje e treta e popullsise se Shqiperise — padiskutim qe perkufizon nje zone urbane me shume potencial, me nje diversitet relativ te larte ku duhet te gelojne idete inovatore ne tregun e punes. Gjithesesi ne piken e fundit duket sikur hasim nje mosperputhje me pritshmerite; sipas nje raporti te 2019-s nga Ministria e Financave dhe Ekonomise, duket se ekonomia shqiptare akoma udhehiqet nga bizneset e ndertimit, ato minerare dhe ato te shitjeve me pakice, edhe sot, pothuajse 30 vjet pas levizjes drejt nje ekonomie tregu. Sic duket ne zonat urbane shqiptare akoma mungojne ato diskutimet ndjellese qe ekzistojne ne vende si Silicon Valley e cojne ne krijimin e bizneseve prodhuese, qofte te produkteve apo qofte edhe te sherbimeve; nderkohe, mungon gjithashtu edhe investimi i huaj qe beri vende si Hong Kong-u apo Shenzhen-i te tejkalonin cdo pritshmeri te ekonomise se shtetit tyre. C’ka eshte akoma me e veshtire per tu gelltitur eshte fakti se rreth 56% e shqiptarve kane deshire te imigrojne, kjo sipas nje raporti te Marsit 2018 nga UNDP. Pra, pak a shume, 1 ne cdo 2 shqiptare ne qofte se do kishte mundesi do largohej nga Shqiperia per tu bere pjese e nje hapsire urbane gjetku ku tregu i punes dhe rregullat e vendit jane te atilla qe e bejne ate vend me te deshirueshem se vendi yne. Largimi i kapitalit ne kete menyre nga vendi yne eshte nje tjeter tregues per mungesen e stabilitetit te nevojshem per ndjekjen e mundesive te reja ekonomike ketu. Me kete ritem shume shpejt zonat urbane ne Shqiperi do shkretohen e do te humbasin cdo te mire te mundshme qe vjen nga densiteti i larte i njerezve e ideve. Si mundemi ne atehere te riperterijme potencialin qe keto zona urbane prezantojne per vendin tone?</p><p>Nuk eshte e qarte se si dikush mund te riprodhje nje Silicon Valley 2.0; ketu behet fjale per nje sistem kompleks, rezultatet e te cilit nuk mund te ndiqen mbrapsh ne nje pikenisje te vetme. Por ka shume aspekte te jetes ne Silicon Valley nga te cilat mund te mesojme e permes te cilave mund te nxisim me shume mendim kritik ne vendin tone. Organizata si alphaPlan (www.codeforalbania.com) ne vend po punojne fort per te krijuar nje ure shkembimi njohurish me Silicon Valley e permes eksplorimit te njohurive ne shkenca kompjuterike ata po kerkojne te ngulisin mentalitetin e rritjes, i cili mund te thuhet se eshte ne thelb te iniciatives sipermarrese ne luginen e teknologjise, edhe ne vendin tone. Gjithesesi nuk me duket edhe aq e pamundur per te mundesuar ate qe ndodhi ne Hong Kong edhe ne vendin tone.</p><p>Shqiperia sot, e patjeter me se shumti zonat e saj me urbane, vuajne nga mungesa e ligjeve apo praktikave te mira. Shembujt me relevant te kesaj mungese jane rreth te drejtave te prones e te pamundesise per te perdorur ne menyre eficiente nje sistem kontraktual per shkak te ngerceve qe krijohen nga sistemi gjyqsor. Probleme te tilla, shume te rendesishme per cdo zhvillim ekonomik, sjellin renie te produktivitetit, si dhe te invesimeve, cka detyrimisht con ne zhvillim shume te ngadalte teknologjik. Jane pikerisht keto probleme qe Britania e Madhe adresoi ne Hong Kong, duke marr per baze thlebin e ekonomise se tregut qe solli suksesin e Revolucionit Industrial ne vitet 1800. Dhe c’ka perkufizon nje sistem ekonomik eshte pikerisht menyra se si institucionet e tij ligjore operojne. Nese biznesi eshte nen kontrollin e nje grupi te caktuar, atehere kemi te bejme me nje sistem merkantilist. Nese ai eshte nen kontrollin e shtetit, atehere kemi te bejme me kapitalizem shteteror, nje sistem kolektivist. Por nese cdo qytetar, pa dallim origjine, ngjyre, gjinie, apo pikepamje politike, mund te marre pjese ne te berit biznes, atehere ne kemi te bejme me nje ekonomi demoraktike, nje ekonomi tregu. Fuqia e ekonomise se tregut qendron ne perdorimin e inteligjences se cdo personi e te kapacitetit tij per pune, ne vend te kontributit te limituar te nje elite te caktuar. Cfare eshte e nevojshme per te arritur ne kete standard eshte tranzicioni nga nje sistem ku individet jane nen zgjedhen e qellimeve te shtetit, ne nje realitet ku shteti eshte ne sherbim te individeve dhe te komunitetit. E eshte pikerisht pergjate ketyre linjave qe ndoshta ne si shtet duhet te fillojme te mendojme jashte kornizave klasike te te berit politike e te mesojme nga raste si Hong Kong-u te cilat na tregojne se si nje pershkallezim tejet i thelle i nje partneriteti nder-shteteror mund te sjelle ate ndryshim qe ne persebrendshmi nuk po e arrijme dot ne 30 vite tranzicion.</p><p>Paul Romer, Profesor ne New York University, dhe fitues i cmimit Nobel ne Ekonomi ne 2018, konceptoi idene e “Charter Cities” ne 2009. Ideja e Charter Cities, apo Qyteteve me nje Statut te ri rregullash, bazohet mbi suksesin e Hong Kong-ut, ku kishim te bejme me nje zone te vecante, ndonse te kolonizuar, por qe sot mund te riprodhohet qellimisht pertej idese se kolonizimit, si nje bashkepunim midis nje shteti qe po kerkon zhvillim dhe nje fuqie ekonomike boterore qe di te krijoje zhvillim. Ideja e Prof. Romer, eshte pergjate linjave te krijimit te qyteteve te reja ne forme startup-i, pak a shume ashtu si dikush mund te krijoje nje biznes te ri. Nese ne ne Shqiperi kemi nevoje te ngulisim ekonomine e tregut ne vend duke i dhene jete ne kete menyre zonave tona urbane, a mund te mesojme nga nje eksperiment ne nje zone te re, qe mund ta zhvillojme se bashku me nje shtet qe ka ekseprience ne menaxhimin e menyrave te prodhimin? Nje zone e re, qe zhvillohet nga zero ne menyren e duhur, te jep mundesine te propozosh risi pa pasur nevoje te ndjekesh nje proces te gjate konsultimesh per shkak te impaktit qe ai propozim ka te njerezit qe prek — ne nje zone te re, ai ndryshim nuk prek askend pa deshiren e vete individit. Me nje Qytet Startup, themeluesit mund te propozojne dicka komplet te re dhe te lejojne njerezit te zgjedhin nese duan te jetojne nen kete statut te ri apo jo. Ata individe qe e pelqejne kete reforme mund te shperngulen ne kete qytet te ri, ndersa te tjeret mund te ndjekin jeten e tyre aktuale. Me ane te kesaj praktike pra, shteti mund te sjelli reforma pa dhune ideologjike.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*1C10NFF38e_rtK3vcvuHEg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Fillimisht nje Qytet Startup, duhet te jete i madh mjaftueshem per te dhene mundesine e eksperimentimit ne mase. Me pas, ai duhet te jete nje zone reformash dhe jo nje zone koloniale, si ne aspektin kombtar ashtu dhe ne ate te te berit biznes. Dhe kjo eshte edhe pika me delikate e kesaj ideje. Shteti i cili eshte mikpritesi i ketij Qyteti Startup, ka per detyre te pyesi veten per keto dy aspekte perpara se te institucionalizoje nje ide kaq radikale:</p><p>· A do ishte nje qytetari im i lumtur nese nje politike e caktuar e ketij qyteti te ri do te aplikohej pergjithmone?</p><p>· A do te ishte nje qytetari im i lutur nese nje politike e caktuar do te perhapej ne te gjithe vendin?</p><p>Nese pergjigjet e ketyre dy pyetjeve jane Po, — patjeter permes rezultateve konkrete te reformave — atehere ketu kemi te bejme me reforma te verteta, e jo ndere per disa grupe interesi apo trysnie.</p><p>Nje Qytet Startup nuk eshte aspak i thjeshte per tu ekzekutuar, ndonse Prof. Romer tashme konsulton disa shtete ne bote qe jane te interesuara ne venien ne realitet te idese se tij. Qeverisja e ketij lloj qyteti te ri kerkon dy shtete (apo me shume) proaktive qe jane te afta te kuptojne se cilat aspekte jane te nevojshme nga secili nga shtetet e perfshira per te krijuar nje hapesire produktive dhe eficiente per te gjitha palet, e per qytetaret e ketyre qyteteve ne rradhe te pare.</p><p>Nese leme ne nje ane kundershtimin romatik te kesaj ideje se ketu behet fjale thjesht per nje kolonizim modern, atehere kuptojme qe kjo ide nuk eshte asgje tjeter vecse nje menyre decentralizimi — nje hap kritik ne tranzicionin nga nje ekonomi pak a shume merkantiliste ne te cilen gjendemi sot, ne ate te tregut. Nje hap qe mund te sjelle per vendin tone jo vetem nje shperthim ekonomik ne versionin e Shenzenit, por edhe nje menyre per te testuar politika te reja qe mund te na ndihmojne ne si shtet ne teresi te ndreqim problemet institucionale qe kemi. Ne vitin 2007 shumica derrmuese e pasurise ne Shqiperi por edhe ne teresi ne Ballkanin jug-perndimor zoterohej nga 10% e popullsise; sot ajo vetem eshte perqendruar edhe me fort ne ate pak perqindje qe merr pjese ne rishperndarjen e nje pasurie te limituar tone si shtet, e cila nuk rritet por vetem rishperndahet politikisht. Ky lloj perqendrimi pasurie nuk lejon zhvillimin e stabilitetit afatgjate ne vend, sic ndoshta na tregon niveli i kriminalitetit dhe i emigracionit sot. Prandaj sot me shume se kurre eshte e rendesishme per shtetin tone te eksploroje menyra alternative te te berit politike e te te shmangurit te burokracive qe ndihmojne grupet e pakta qe mund te ushtrojne trysni mbi politikeberjen per interesat e tyre te ngushta. Vetem ne kete menyre ne do te mund te behemi pjese e nje realiteti global me te drejta te barabarta ku te mund te perfitojme nga mencuria dhe resurset boterore ekzistente. Nese do te kishim nje Qytet Startup sot qe do te frekuentohej nga kompani prodhuese nderkombtare, ndoshta do te kishim fatin qe brenda kufinjeve tone te kishim nje sasi shteruese maskash te nevojshme per tu mbrojtur nga koronavirusi i ri, dorezash, respiratoresh etj.</p><p>Nese ben cfare ke bere gjithnje, atehere mund te marresh vetem ate cfare ke marr edhe ne te kaluaren. Besoj se eshte koha qe te gjithe ne te fillojme te mendojme per nje Shqiperi te re, nje Shqiperi qe nuk ka frike ta sfidoje status quo-ne. Ashtu si edhe sfidat e medha te njerezimit te cilat zhvillimi ekonomik na mundeson te adresojme, edhe reformimi i nje sistemi ekonomik eshte nje sfide me vete. Sic ndodh rendom ne cdo sfide, shume prej ideve per ta zgjidhur ate apo edhe shume prej ketyre qyteteve eksperimentale vete, nese ata behen realitet, do te deshtojne, por nese nuk eksperimentojme, atehere ne kemi deshtuar pa marr pjese akoma ne kete sfide. E ky i fundit nuk eshte nje rezultat me te cilin mund te ndahemi ne paqe, sepse paraqet shume rrezik. Per ta vene ate ne perspektive, mjafton te mendojme edhe nje here per korbin ne Sendai, apo per shpendin kraheshkurter ne ShBA; seleksionimi natyror mund te jete shume i ashper ndaj nesh nese nuk arrijme ti pershtatemi kohes. Frike asapk, kujdes po!</p><p>Referenca</p><ol><li>Schiltuizen, M. <em>Darwin comes to town</em>. 2018. Quercus Publishing PLC.</li></ol><p>2. Gedeshi, I. dhe King, R. <em>Research Study into Brain Gain: Reversing Brain Drain with the Albanian Scientific Diaspora</em>. 2018. UNDP</p><p>3. De Soto, H. <em>The Other Path</em>, 1989. Basic Books</p><p>4. Pettifer, J. dhe Vickers, M. <em>The Albanian Question: Reshaping the Balkans</em>. 2007. I.B. Tauris &amp; Co Ltd.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dfdd73ff3d98" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Rrejta e Sigurisë” që na mungon]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@orihoxha/rrejta-e-siguris%C3%AB-q%C3%AB-na-mungon-4ef8559595c4?source=rss-29781169a680------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ef8559595c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-safety-net]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[albania]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dhjetoridyte]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tirana]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ori Hoxha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 16 Dec 2018 08:22:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-17T02:35:58.737Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“Rrjeta e Sigurisë” që na mungon</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iTUzifANHBvj87g0UK3_Nw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Imazhi kortezi e factmyth.com</figcaption></figure><p>“Vjen një moment që funksionimi i makinerisë bëhet kaq i neveritshëm — të sëmur zemrën — aq sa nuk mund të jesh më pjesë e saj. Nuk mund të jesh pjesë e saj as pasivisht. Dhe në atë moment të vjen të vendosësh trupin tënd nëpër ingranazhet dhe në rrotat, në levat, mbi të gjithë aparatin, dhe ta bësh atë të ndalojë. Dhe duhet t’i tregojmë personave që e drejtojnë atë, pronarëve të saj, që derisa të jemi të lirë, ajo makineri nuk do të funksionojë më.”</p><p>Kështu fliste Mario Savio, më 2 dhjetor 1964, në sheshin Sproul të Universitetit të Kalifornisë, Berkeley. Mario Savio, aktivist politik për gjatë gjithë jetës së tij, njihet si lideri i lëvizjes studentore të viteve 1960 në Berkeley, Kaliforni, Sh.B.A., e njohur si Lëvizja për Fjalën e Lirë (Free Speech Movement), një lëvizje kjo e lidhur ngushtë edhe me lëvizjen e drejtuar nga Marthin Luther King Jr. në po të njëjtën periudhë, Lëvizja për të Drejtat e Njeriut (Civil Rights Movement). Këto lëvizje, ashtu si shumë të tjera në botë në atë kohë, apo si disa protesta që shohim nëpër Tiranë këto ditë, kishin një parim në thelbin e tyre: dinjitetin njerëzor. Ndonëse Mario Savio e adresonte atë nga këndi i lirisë së të shprehurit mbi qëndrime politike, apo Pastori King nën këndin e barazisë racore, në të dy rastet luftohej për liri sociale. Luftohej për një shoqëri në të cilën liria e çdo individi është absolute, por ku pushteti i individit nuk është i tillë, dhe jo vetëm kaq, por një shoqëri me kufinj të përcaktuar qartë, brenda të cilëve, të drejtat e njeriut janë të pacënueshme.</p><p>Edhe pse në dukje, protestat e këtij dhejtori në Tiranë mund të duken me tematikë shumë të ndryshme nga ç’ka po ndodhte para 54 vjetësh në Sh.B.A., unë mendoj se thelbi i tyre nuk është shumë i ndryshëm. Këtu kam në mendje protestën mbi Teatrin Kombëtar, atë mbi prishjen e shtëpiave tek Astiri dhe së fundmi protestën e studentëve mbi tarifat e arsimit:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*al5wto1gf5cmXDJLanxO9A.jpeg" /></figure><p>(1) Unë nuk mendoj se protesta rreth Teatrit Kombëtar është thjeshtë një protestë kundër prishjes së teatrit ekzistues e ndërtimit të një teatri të ri në ndërtesën që do të ngrihet në atë truall. Besoj se shumica e aktorëve e përkrahin një projekt zhvillimor të tillë. Por mënyra se si ky projekt (nuk) ju parashtrua qytetarëve të Tiranës, e veçanërisht aktorëve vetë, të cilët e kanë jetën të lidhur shumë ngushtë me atë ndërtesë, ishte denigrues. Si mundet që një konstruksion aq madhor në mes të Tiranës të paraqitet si një fakt i kryer e të mos ketë një diskutim të hapur me ata qe janë <em>de facto</em> zotëruesit e asaj ndërtese, aktorët? Apo me ata njerëz që padyshim do preken në një mënyrë a një tjetër nga ky projekt, banorët e Tiranës? Jo vetem që këto konsultime nuk u ndërmorën kurrë, por edhe sot e kësaj dite, pas muajsh proteste para teatrit, akoma nuk ka një tryezë të përbashkët mes të gjithë grupeve të interesit për të qartësuar kërkesat dhe nevojat e gjithësecilit. Ky më duket mua një shembull librash i rastit kur maxhoranca në vend udhëheq me “dhunë,” duke injoruar kërkesat e një grupi interesi, sado i vogel të jetë ai, e duke shkelur në këtë mënyrë një nga parimet bazë të demokracisë.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/850/1*1IKG3igcx6Xf5jst3SV7uQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>(2) Rasti i projektit zhvillimor në unazën e madhe të Tiranës nuk është edhe aq i ndryshëm nga ai i Teatrit Kombëtar. Edhe banoret e zonës së Astirit, ashtu si aktorët e teatrit, papritur e gjeten veten pjesë të një marrëveshje shtetërore për përmirësimin e infrastrukturës dhe të urbanistikës së qytetit të Tiranës. Në parim as unë, e besoj se as banorët e asaj zone vete, nuk kanë ndonjë kundërshtim ndaj projektit në vetvete, ndoshta përveç ndonjë aspekti të mundshëm korruptiv, por ajo është puna e Prokurorisë për ta zgjidhur. Sidoqoftë, edhe në këtë rast disa të drejta themelore qytetare të këtyre banorëve u injoruan. A siguron një njoftim disa ditë apo dhe javë në avancë kohë të mjaftueshme për një familje që të zhvendoset nga aty ku ka ndërtuar realitetin e saj që prej ndoshta 20 vjetësh? Dhe kjo pyetje në fakt vlen vetëm për atë familje e cila do marrë një kompesim të arsyeshëm nga shteti. Dëgjoj që ka shumë raste nga ata që nuk do marrin asgjë, apo ndoshta do marrin qera për disa vite… Thuhet se kjo vlen për shtëpiat e palegalizuara. Por a janë vërtet pronarët e atyre shtëpiave të vetmit individë që duhet të mbartin forcën e ligjit mbi supet e tyre për këto ndërtime pa leje? Ku ishte forca e shtetit shqiptar për ta ndaluar një ndërtim të tillë pa leje mbi territorin e këtij shteti, që në nisjen e tij? Epo, në qoftë se shteti jonë nuk ishte i aftë për ta ndaluar një shkelje të tillë përpara se ajo të arrinte një dimension të tillë, atëherë duhet të bëhet tani i aftë për ta adresuar atë në një mënyrë që garanton integritetin e këtyre jetëve që u vendosën e lulëzuan në tokat e zonës së Astirit.</p><p>(3) Për të vijuar më tej me protestën studentore që prej disa ditësh ka sjell numra të mëdha pjesëmarrësish në Rrugën e Durrësit, pranë Ministrisë së Arsimit, Sportit dhe Rinisë. Kjo protestë, e cila akoma nuk po trajtohet me seriozitetin e duhur, për mendimin tim, nga qeveria shqiptare, prezanton në qendër të saj 4 pika (përditësim 15/12: 8 pika), të gjitha të lidhura ngushtë me koston e arsimimit në vendin tonë (përditësim 15/12: fokusi u zgjerua edhe rreth liberalizimit të vendim-marrjes në universitete). Por midis rreshtave të asaj kërkese me 4 pika, unë shoh një problematikë edhe më themelore në vendin tonë, atë të mirëqënies apo më saktë, të mungesës së saj. Unë personalisht nuk mendoj se pagesa e shkollimit në Shqipëri është shumë e lartë, por mendoj se kosto e jetesës është. Në një kohë kur të ardhurat nuk janë rritur ndjeshëm, kosto e jetesës në Tiranë rritet dita ditës. Duket sikur populli në tërësi përballet me një inflacion të shkaktuar nga një përqindje shumë e vogël e shoqërisë. E ndërkohe çfarë po bën shteti për të ndihmuar klasën e mesme? Sa vërtet progresive është taksa progresive? Si mund të fillojë një jetë të pavarur nga familja një i ri 18-vjeçar që nis studimet universitare? Nuk besoj se shumë 18-vjeçarë e çojnë nëpër mend në Shqipëri të jenë të pavarur nga familja e tyre, kur në shumë vende të tjera të Europës ajo indipendencë është e garantuar. Një varësi ekonomike kjo që mund të përshkallëzohet edhe jashtë familjes, e të çojë deri në kompromentimin e parimeve të këtyre të rinjve që nuk ishin duke kërkuar tjetër gjë veç një pavarësie e formimi intelektual.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/765/1*nr6K6L0ppU9w4m_Je3z_nw.jpeg" /></figure><p>E pra, janë këto linja arsyetimi që më bëjnë mua t’i lidh këto 3 protesta së bashku, e për më tepër edhe me ato të viteve ’60 në Sh.B.A. apo edhe me atë të dhjetorit 1990 në Shqipëri. Edhe pse në plan të parë këto protesta nuk mund të jenë më të ndryshme, brenda në bërthamën e tyre, unë dalloj një motiv të vetëm, atë të kërkesës për një rrjetë sigurie. Është kjo rrjetë e nevojshme sigurie që mund të garantojë gjithësecilin prej nesh me integritetin e dinjitetin që çdo qënie njerëzore meriton. Kjo rrjetë sigure që ka shumë ngjyra, që nga e drejta e fjalës, tek e drejta për arsimim të përballueshëm, tek e drejta për një sistem shëndetsor të denjë e deri te mundësia për një jete të denjë me një rrogë bazë, është një kusht paraprak për çdo aspekt zhvillimor tjetër në shoqëri. Nuk besoj se një punonjës do ta vlerësonte dot një zyrë të re në qoftë se nuk i dëgjohet fjala, siç po ndodh me rastin e Teatrit; nuk besoj se një tiranas do ta vlerësonte përmirësimin në infrastrukturen e qytetit kur bashkë me të rritet dhe numri i të pastrehëve, siç mund të ndodhë me projektin e unazës së madhe; dhe gjithëashtu nuk mendoj se një student mund ta vlerësoje edhe edukimin më ekzemplar kur ka barkun bosh. Prandaj uroj që këto protesta në mbarë Shqipërine këto ditë, të merren seriozisht nga qeveria e të shqyrtohet me të vërtetë thelbi i tyre. Sepse vetëm në atë mënyrë do të arrijmë në atë që Shqipëria e banorët e saj kanë kaq shumë nevoje, një shtet më social, me një rrjetë sigure, e ku mbi të mund të lulëzojë një sistem i vërtetë demokratik-kapitalist, për të gjithë e jo vetëm për disa.</p><p><em>Shkruar më 08/12/2018 — Dita e Rinisë.</em></p><p><em>Protesta studentore vazhdon tashmë deri më 15/12/2018 dhe lista e 8 kërkesave të studentëve akoma nuk është marr nën një shqyrtim serioz nga qeveria shqiptare.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ef8559595c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>