<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Osaid ul Hasan Syed on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Osaid ul Hasan Syed on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 09:11:22 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Kashmir: Potential For An Anti-State Politics?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/kashmir-potential-for-an-anti-state-politics-139f068f71c9?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/139f068f71c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hindutva]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kashmir]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Aug 2026 08:01:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-14T08:01:02.728Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Since 2020, the Pakistani state has observed 5th August as Youm-e-Istehsal, or the ‘Day of Exploitation’. In 2019, on August 5th, the fascist Hindutva state of India, run by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, fulfilled a long-awaited dream for Hindutvavadis. The Indian state revoked the special autonomous status granted to Jammu and Kashmir under the Indian Constitution. It did this by revoking both Article 370 and Article 35A of the constitution. This meant that, instead of having control over their own region, the people of Jammu and Kashmir would be governed by the entire constitution rather than having special rights and privileges. These rights were granted due to the ongoing decades-old conflict over greater Kashmir involving both Pakistan and India, both of which have control over different regions of Kashmir. Since the revocation, the people of Indian-occupied Kashmir have faced continued repression at the hands of the Indian state. This repression has comprised both economic and militaristic forms, making Kashmir the most militarised zone in the world. Most recently, at the start of August this year, the Indian state arrested some 3000 youth in the region.</p><p>However, while Pakistan’s observation of Youm-e-Istehsal over the past six years has served as a moment of solidarity across borders, rightfully condemning the actions of an increasingly rogue Indian state, this year, Pakistan’s actions against its own Kashmiri population in ‘Azad’ Jammu and Kashmir (Azad means Free, the quotation marks indicate the recently shattered notion of freedom that Kashmiris in Pakistan and the broader Pakistani citizenry is waking up to) point to the hypocrisy of the Pakistani state as well as its own exploitative nature. Since June of this year, the Pakistani state forces have heavily repressed a grassroots people’s movement, called the Joint Action Awami Committee (JAAC). The movement was formed regarding grievances around flour and electricity prices, as well as the issue of electoral seats granted to refugees from Kashmir settled in mainland Pakistan, as a result of which they hold unnecessary decision-making power over the residents of Azad Jammu and Kashmir. State repression by Pakistan of protests held by the movement has led to multiple killings, injuries, and arrests. Due to the ongoing, more-than-a-month-long internet blackout, figures are hard to come by, with the number of deaths ranging from 30 to 90, and dozens arrested.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7MQBVqRi3a18otZRsf4oEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Thousands gathered at a demonstration in Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (GETTY IMAGES)</figcaption></figure><p>The brutal crackdown over the past six years by the Indian state and the recent repression by the Pakistani state in their respective territories represent a broader pattern of exploitation of the Kashmiri people that is decades-old. This system was, ultimately, created by and rooted in British imperialism. It was the British who when they finally decided to exit India, arbitrarily divided the region with unruly borders, leading to mass migration and millions of deaths in communal riots. One point of contention during this act of colonialism was the future of princely states under the British empire, one of which was Kashmir. These princely states were given the choice to either join India or Pakistan, or stay independent. In the case of Kashmir, this was a particularly difficult choice, as its population was majority Muslim, while its ruler was a Hindu monarch, Hari Singh. Hoping to stay independent, Singh delayed making a decision, prompting Pakistan to invade, leading to a full-blown war between India and Pakistan after Singh had agreed to accede to India.</p><p>Since then, Kashmir has seen multiple wars between the two countries, resulting in the region being split between the two warring nations. Thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, have died over the decades as a result. Both sides have continued to assert their sovereignty over the region while treating the indigenous Kashmiri people as sheep to be slaughtered. While the region has seen militant movements for liberation such as the Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front (JKLF), as well as the presence of communist parties (in India, since the Communist Party was banned in Pakistan), these have prioritised the nationalist, separatist struggle and have not succeeded. In fact, the JKLF also split when its Indian faction decided to transition to a peaceful movement, denouncing militancy. These failures have ultimately led to disillusionment and a sense of disunity amongst the Kashmiris, and have consolidated both states’ power and hold in their respective regions.</p><p>However, India’s 2019 revocation of Article 270, continued repression, and Pakistan’s crackdown on JAAC represent significant ruptures in the politics of the region. In Pakistan’s case, especially, the recent protests and subsequent state repression have profoundly dented Pakistan’s image as an upholder of Kashmir’s right to self-determination. Thus, both scenarios represent a rare opportunity to build solidarity within each nation and across borders. As landgrabbing continues in Indian-occupied Kashmir, and as JAAC continues to demand fair allocation of Kashmiri resources, we, as anarchists, recognise the inherent class struggle manifest in the politics of both regions, and hence, both lend our efforts toand urge the Kashmiri people to build solidarity and mutual aid structures towards the abolishment of class. True class solidarity can only be achieved by recognising the evil roles of both the British colonial history and the modern-day nation-states of Pakistan and India. It can only be built by recognising the legitimacy of the people’s movement and power. This is particularly applicable to Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir right now, given how JAAC has fought for fair prices. We, as anarchists, must always root our analysis in the material conditions facing the people. Finally, as anarchists, we must also always be cautious of statist counter-revolutionary forces that seek to appropriate genuine movements for their own agendas. On Pakistan’s side, we are already beginning to see this as Communist and socialist factions have suddenly started appearing on the ground in an attempt to appropriate genuine Kashmiri voices.</p><p>Any attempts at building solidarity and class unity are, of course, ultimately, a task to be taken up by Kashmiris themselves. We can only hope (while continuing to do propaganda)) that an anti-statist politics does start to emerge within the region. Surely, if it does, there will be plenty of examples to learn from and draw on, including the Rojava movement, not so far from South Asia itself.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=139f068f71c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[World-Systems Theory: A Self-Learning Series]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/world-systems-theory-a-self-learning-series-df94a2c10869?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df94a2c10869</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wallerstein]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-movements]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Feb 2026 15:09:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-26T15:09:05.508Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Part One: Why Am I Doing This? + Wallerstein’s Introduction and Response to Common Criticisms</strong></p><p>If you were to start looking to understand the world politically and socially, and to do that academically, you would likely be introduced to certain theories. Covering the breadth of the political spectrum from left to right, these would probably include communism, Marxism, socialism, liberalism, conservatism, and fascism, among others. If, however, you were a left-wing activist who did not want to do this academically but instead adopted the street approach of joining a political organisation, you would likely be introduced to theories of communism, socialism, and perhaps even anarchism. As you can see, only rarely, maybe even never, would you be introduced to world-systems theory or hear people talk about it.</p><p>I want to change that. Why? Well, personally, because I am a student of the theory. I utilised it for my master’s dissertation, in which I compared Spanish Civil War anarchists with contemporary movements of the Zapatistas and Rojava. And now, I am aiming to use it as the theoretical framework for my PhD research. While researching the theory for my dissertation, I was frustrated by the lack of material explicitly written for new students of the theory. Apart from the writings of Immanuel Wallerstein and his colleagues themselves (and yes, they do have beginner-friendly stuff), there are hardly any resources that explain what world-systems theory is and how it can be applied in the contemporary global context in laymen terms. No thousands (if not millions) of online articles, podcasts, and YouTube videos like you would get for Marxism/Communism/Socialism, for example. For a theory that claims to explain the world in totality (just like other theories on the left) and one with which perhaps the two most formidable experiments in people’s autonomy in contemporary times have engaged with (the Zapatistas and Rojava), this ignorance from the ‘other’ left (maybe we can switch to calling it ‘old’ later on) is shocking, if not deliberate.</p><p>Therefore, to start with, in this part one, I will first briefly introduce the theory itself and its use in contemporary times. Then, I will spend some time explaining the aforementioned ignorance, putting it into context by drawing on Wallerstein’s own responses to criticisms the theory has received from various sources, including proponents of other left-wing theories. Note that this will be a developing node in this series since Wallerstein continually points out the shortcomings of other theories throughout his body of work. Here we go, then.</p><p><strong>Introducing World-Systems Theory</strong></p><p>World-systems theory was put forward by Immanuel Wallerstein in the early 1970s. It takes a holistic approach to understanding political and socioeconomic phenomena in the modern world-system. Now, what is the world-system and what is modern about it? First, note the use of the article <em>‘the’</em> here, which implies that we live in a unique world-system. This also means that there can be other world-systems, i.e., the existence of <em>‘a’</em> world-system. Thus, a world-system is specifically a unit of analysis. And by <em>‘the’</em> modern world-system, Wallerstein means the current world-system we live in. To understand the emergence and the polycrisis of the world-system, there are three main turning points. According to Wallertein, these are:</p><p>1) The long 16th century during which the modern world-system first emerged as a capitalist world-economy.</p><p>2) The French Revolution of 1789 being a world/global event resulting in the dominance of central liberalism as the defining geoculture of the world-system.</p><p>3) The world revolution of 1968, which warned us of the coming of the terminal phase of the world-system in the following decades, and which eroded the centrist liberal geoculture.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*4-CVzZ4xapXXHPxXYjjdIg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Immanuel Wallerstein</figcaption></figure><p>Wallerstein argues that the social sciences have so far studied social phenomena in separate boxes with special names, such as politics, sociology, economics, and cultural studies. What this approach overlooks is that the separate boxes do not reflect reality and are instead imaginative constructs. In fact, these boxes are so entwined with each other that they flow into each other, affecting each other, and it is impossible to understand any social phenomena merely within the confines of a separate box. Wallerstein rejects this approach, and thus his theory has emerged from dissatisfaction with the dominant modes of historical research and social science theory. He frames this as a debate between the specific and the general; the specific is analysed using an idiographic approach (focusing on the unique, subjective experiences of an individual entity), while the general is analysed using a nomothetic approach (aiming to make general statements about social phenomena). Wallerstein not only rejects both approaches but also goes further to say that the unit of analysis for both has been the same, i.e., the state, which he also disagrees with. Hence, the unit of analysis is the/a world-system for Wallerstein.</p><p>Our social reality and the choices we are presented with are not determined by which state each of us is a citizen of, but instead, by the world-system. This world-system is comprised of many parts, including states and the interstate system between them, global and national firms, households (the family structure), social classes, etc, and it is the intermeshing of all of these that makes the world-system operate. Not only does this web make the world-system operate, but it also gives birth to the conflicts and contradictions inherent in the system. This system is a social creation, and world-systems theory is thus an attempt to explain its origins, lay out its mechanisms, and understand its multiple crises. World-systems theory, then, fundamentally challenges 200+ years of social science and is, in fact, a protest against the dominant structures of knowledge. Wallerstein encourages us to look at the world through a new lens and think about it in a different way. He sees it as a reflection of the inequalities that are so visibly present in our sociopolitical times. This delineation has necessarily led to critiques from the dominant mode(s) of social science research, which I will talk about in the next section.</p><p><strong>Critiques and Wallerstein’s Responses</strong></p><p>In the prologue to The Modern World System 1, Wallerstein engages with the critiques his work has received, almost four decades after the book was first published. He starts by explaining his chain of thought that led him to establish world-systems theory as a framework. He says that his argument was primarily with Weberian sociologists who insisted on the existence of certain values as a prerequisite to modernisation or development. Weberian sociologists then tended to examine each country’s values to see where it stood in the so-called ‘march of progress.’ Wallerstein challenged this narrative in three ways.</p><p>First, he criticised the use of each state or country as the unit of analysis, insisting instead on the larger category of the world-system. Second, he proposed that the values in question emerged after the period of modernisation and therefore could not be used as a factor in analysing why some countries progressed, and some did not. Instead, he argued that it was only possible to analyse this after placing the different countries in relation to one another. Finally, he rejected the Weberians’ modern-versus-traditional hierarchy and argued that both emerged together.</p><p>Wallerstein devotes little space to responding to the Weberians and quickly moves on to other critiques. He divides these into three firm categories: the major critiques, the minor critiques, and the revisionists. The major critiques reject world-systems analysis, instead arguing for the supremacy of some other analytical mode. Minor critiques accept world-systems analysis as a legitimate mode of analysis and instead point out faults in Wallerstein’s use of empirical data. The revisionists argue that there has always been just one ‘world system’ over the past 5,000 years. We will look at each critique category in detail now.</p><p><em>Major Critiques</em></p><p>The major critiques of world-systems analysis have come from four different schools of thought: orthodox Marxists, nomothetic economists, neo-Hintzians, and the ‘cultural’ camp. Let us look at each in order.</p><p>Orthodox Marxists responded to world-systems analysis by arguing that it ignored or sidelined certain fundamentals of Marxism. These fundamentals include the class struggle fundamentally being between the urban proletariat and the capitalist producers, the dominance of the economic sphere over the political and cultural spheres, the dominance of internal factors (within a country) over external factors, and modes of production defining levels of progress in the so-called march of history. Wallerstein argued back, responding that what he has attempted to do is develop an alternative view of capitalism, one in which <em>‘capitalism was the characteristic of a world-system, of the specific variety I called a ‘world-economy’’ </em>(Wallerstein, 2011, p. xx)<em>. </em>Thus, classes belong to the world-system, i.e., they are not national, and neither is the economy. States exist within this world-system. Orthodox Marxism has since waned, mainly due to the attacks it came under during the 1968 world revolution, which paid importance to issues of gender, race, and sexuality. It was also put under pressure by the counterrevolutionary forces of neoliberalism. Therefore, you would be hard-pressed to find many orthodox Marxists today.</p><p>The second school of thought, hostile to world-systems analysis, was that of the nomothetic economists. This hostility hardly took the form of detailed critiques, except to point out that world-systems theory did not explain why some countries had developed more than others. As explained before, the unit of analysis in the theory is not individual states or countries but a world-system. According to Wallerstein, the hostility from this camp stemmed from the fact that his theory effectively disproves David Ricardo’s ‘law of comparative advantage’, which is considered a fundamental law by economists. Obviously, economists did not like that.</p><p>The third school is that of the neo-Hintzians, following the work of Otto Hinze, a German political historian. They argued that world-systems theory collapsed the political and economic spheres into one and gave primacy to the economic sphere, i.e., that it is too ‘economistic’. It should be noted that neo-Hintzians give primacy to the political arena over economics. Wallerstein, obviously, refused to accept the primacy of either sphere, pushing instead for a holistic analysis in which economic and political institutional structures were simply one amongst others. He also pointed out that Otto Hinze himself admitted that <em>‘the affairs of the state and of capitalism are inextricably interrelated…’ </em>(Wallerstein, 2011, p. xxii).</p><p>The last major critique came from the cultural camp. Wallerstein points out two considerations regarding this. Firstly, he points out that the liberal discourse of modernity neatly categorised modern life into the spheres of the political, the economic, and the cultural, which was reflected in academia by the creation of separate disciplines for each: political science to study the state, economics to study the economy, and sociology for well, basically everything else. Therefore, if the nomothetic economists and orthodox Marxists urged the primacy of the economy, and the neo-Hintzians the primacy of the political, there was bound to be a critique from those who argued for the dominance of the cultural sphere. Secondly, the world revolution of 1968 produced fundamental critiques of Marxism, with extensive debate over the utility of master narratives as theoretical tools for explaining the world. The world-revolution also brought about critiques of Marxism from those who complained that it had sidelined the fundamentally important categories of gender, race, ethnicity, and sexualities to favour only the class struggle.</p><p>Now, world-systems theory presents a master narrative itself, albeit an alternative one. Therefore, naturally, Wallerstein was condemned for not joining the cultural camp of those who wanted to bring categories of gender etc. However, even though world-systems theory is a master narrative of its own, Wallerstein points out that the theory itself was born out of critiques of mainstream Marxism, the same critiques that those in the cultural camp were pointing out. Wallerstein points out that, in subsequent years, those concerned with the marginalised world ultimately began to find ways to incorporate world-systems theory into their own analyses.</p><p>According to Wallerstein, these major critiques from the four schools of thought have since moved to the background. World-systems theory has since been accepted as another paradigm for explaining the world as it is. Instead, he argues that the minor critiques demand more attention.</p><p><em>Minor Critiques</em></p><p>Three minor critiques have been noted. Remember that the minor critiques already presume the legitimacy of world-systems analysis. The three minor critiques each deal with a separate issue: the spatial boundaries of the world-system, its temporal boundaries, and the institutional variables operating within it.</p><p>The world-economy has boundaries, i.e., there are places inside it and places outside it. Within it, Wallerstein discusses core, peripheral, and semi-peripheral zones. But to define what is outside of the world-system, Wallerstein’s basic argument is to distinguish between trade in bulk goods versus trade in preciosities, with the latter associated with what is external to the world-economy and the former associated to unequal exchange, and therefore, part of the world-system. Based on this, Wallerstein argued that the Ottoman Empire, Russia, and India were not part of the modern world-system in the 16th century, but Poland and Hungary were. Critics later argued that the Ottoman Empire and Russia ought to be included within the boundaries of the modern world-system, and Wallerstein was receptive to this. Critics, however, also pointed out that the distinction between what qualifies as bulk trade and what qualifies as trade in preciosities is blurry. Although Wallerstein acknowledges this, he insists that his basic point is sound, i.e., the concept of zones outside the world-system in the 16th century is useful since it allows us to understand that the world-system did not start out as a global world-system but became that much later. Wallerstein encourages these debates from his critics.</p><p>Furthermore, he acknowledges that the temporal boundaries have been even more difficult to define, with critics pushing back the start of the modern world-system as far as the 13th century. Wallerstein responds by saying that this debate is essentially about the nature of feudalism in Europe. He points out that there is hardly any satisfactory explanation of European feudalism during the period of 1000–1500, with some critics seeing it as a protocapitalist phase in Europe, which then leads them to move back the date of the start of the modern world-system, while others tend to see it as the opposite of capitalism, and hence move forward the dates to the 1800s. In his work, Wallerstein distinguished between the first and second feudalisms of Europe, with the first belonging to medieval Europe and the second to the 16th century, which was, according to him, <em>‘an incorrect label for coerced cash-crop labor’</em> (Wallerstein, 2011, p. xxvi)<em>.</em> He viewed the feudal system of Europe as a fragmented world empire kept together by the institution of the Roman Church. He admits that there were forces within the institution which attempted to transform this medieval feudalism into a capitalist world-economy but ultimately failed. This is crucial to Wallerstein, as it shows that creating a capitalist world-economy is very difficult. Therefore, while Wallerstein was receptive to minor critiques regarding the spatial and temporal boundaries of the world-economy, he insisted on their essential correctness.</p><p>It is the institutional variables of the world-economy that Wallerstein acknowledges were insufficiently delineated in the first volume. He admits that he spent most of his energy laying out how what was happening in the economic arena was capitalist, to the detriment of other arenas, thus inviting critiques from those who insisted that the political, cultural, military, and environmental arenas could not be ignored. We have already discussed the first two. Replying to critics from the military arena, Wallerstein pointed out that he did talk about the role of military technology in bits and pieces but cautioned against giving too much agency to the arena since ‘war is a continuation of politics by other means.’ For critics from the environmental arena, Wallerstein points to the work of Jason Moore, expressing surprise, since Jason points out just how much focus Wallerstein actually gave to the environmental arena in his work. Finally, Wallerstein says that the best reply to the debate over institutional parameters is to point out that one cannot do everything at once, and he hopes readers of his work will see that he gave true primacy to keeping his analysis as holistic as possible.</p><p><em>The Revisionist Critique</em></p><p>The revisionist critique came from those who argued that China should be given much more importance in world-systems analysis. While some insisted that a Sinic world had existed since the 15th century, Andre Gunder Frank, an early adherent of world-systems analysis himself, took it one step further. He put forward the hypothesis that there has always been, and is, only one world system (notice the removal of the hyphen). This world system had existed for 5,000 years and could be analysed using the same analytical tools that world-systems theory had developed. He further argued that China has always been the central hub of this world system, noting that Europe’s rise was limited to the 19th and 20th centuries. He essentially accused Wallerstein and other world-systems theorists of being Eurocentric in their analyses.</p><p>Wallerstein argued back with three responses. First, he pointed out that Frank’s argument was truly circulationist, i.e., that he explained the 5,000-year-old world-system through trade flows alone (ancient trade links, for example), which is exactly how neoclassical economic models treat markets and exchange. Wallerstein, obviously, insisted on the world-system being characterised by a specific mode of production, hence why it is a capitalist world-economy. Secondly, Wallerstein argued that Frank’s own empirical data could disprove his analysis of relations between Western Europe and China. Finally, and most importantly, Frank’s mode of analysis actually completely excluded capitalism as a meaningful category for understanding the world and its history. Frank could not argue that capitalism dated back 5,000 years, and later himself admitted that capitalism ceases to be a meaningful concept.</p><p><strong>Conclusion and What’s Next</strong></p><p>In this first part of the series, I have briefly introduced world-systems theory and have attempted to do so as to explain it to any layman. I have also delineated the important critiques that world-systems analysis has faced over the years and shown how Wallerstein has responded to them. The critiques and Wallerstein’s responses shed some light on why world-systems theory has faced (and indeed, continues to face) ignorance from leftist circles. It is important to note, though, at the end of this first part, that Wallerstein insists that world-systems analysis should not be thought of as a new theory or a new paradigm but instead seen as a <em>‘call for a debate about the paradigm’ </em>(Wallerstein, 2011, p. xxx).<em> </em>In the next part, we will look more fully at the origins of world-systems analysis, going deeper into the contradictions and debates within and between the schools of thought that influenced Wallerstein in developing this mode of analysis.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Wallerstein, I. (2011). <em>The Modern World-System I: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Century.</em> University of California Press.</p><p><strong>Further Reading</strong></p><p>1. Imanuel Wallerstein, “The West, Capitalism, and the Modern World-System.”</p><p>2. Jason W. Moore, “The Modern World-System’ as Environmental History? Ecology and the Rise of Capitalism,” <em>Theory &amp; Society</em>, XXXII, 3, June 2003, 307–377.</p><p>3. Amiya Kumar Bagchi, <em>Perilous Passage: Mankind and the Global Ascendancy of Capital </em>(Lanham, Maryland: Rowman &amp; Littlefield, 2005)</p><p>4. Immanuel Wallerstein, “The Itinerary of World-System Analysis, or, How to Resist Becoming a Theory”, in J. Berger and M. Zelditch, Jr., eds., <em>New Directions in Contemporary Sociological Theory </em>(Lanham, Maryland: Rowman and Littlefield, 2002), 358–376.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df94a2c10869" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Empire of Light: Caste, Gender, and the Politics of Diwali]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/the-empire-of-light-caste-gender-and-the-politics-of-diwali-b71786641b25?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b71786641b25</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diwali]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hindutva]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Oct 2025 11:47:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-20T11:47:46.691Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As the Indian diaspora turns to celebrating Diwali across the UK — in the streets, in workplaces, in city halls — it is worth asking what histories and hierarchies are being illuminated, and which are being hidden.</p><p>Beneath the glow of diyas and the rhetoric of ‘light triumphing over darkness’ lies a mythology that has, for centuries, been used to naturalise caste hierarchies, justify patriarchal violence, and erase indigenous histories. Diwali is celebrated as the return of Rama to Ayodhya, the restoration of cosmic order after the defeat of Ravana. Yet that order was built on the subjugation of Dalits, Adivasis, and women; a divine morality that sanctified inequality as virtue.</p><p>From a Dalit, Adivasi, and feminist perspective, the Ramayana is not a tale of righteousness but of conquest. It is the story of a Kshatriya prince who negotiated power, killed a Shudra for transgressing Brahminical norms, humiliated and abandoned his wife in the name of purity, and murdered an indigenous king whose only crime was defying the Aryan order. To understand Diwali, then, is to confront the ideological machinery of Brahmanism itself: how conquest was rebranded as righteousness, how violence became light, and how that light continues to blind us to the social hierarchies it sustains. Diwali, in this reading, is not the festival of light. It is the ritual of Brahmanisation, transforming domination into divinity, and reproducing caste and gender power even in the multicultural landscapes of the diaspora.</p><p>The Ramayana’s moral world is not neutral; it is an architecture of caste. In the Uttarakāṇḍa, a later but deeply influential section of the epic, Rama kills Shambuka, a Shudra ascetic performing meditations <em>(see Valmiki Ramayana, Uttarakāṇḍa, Canto 73)</em>. His only crime was seeking spiritual elevation through penance, an act reserved for Brahmins under the logic of varna dharma. In slaying him, Rama ‘restores cosmic balance’. This is celebrated in countless retellings as the triumph of dharma. But what kind of dharma depends on killing a man of lower caste for meditating? B.R. Ambedkar, in Riddles in Hinduism, called this ‘the most cruel and shameful act recorded in Hindu scriptures’, a moment that exposes the theology of domination at the heart of Brahmanism <em>(Ambedkar, Riddles in Hinduism, Navayana, 2016)</em>. The divinity of Rama is constructed precisely through the policing of caste boundaries. Violence against the lower orders is framed not as sin, but as sacred duty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*UhnXkpSyNT9lOsZT48MMvg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rama kills Shambuka</figcaption></figure><p>Throughout the epic, Rama’s moral legitimacy is tied to his relationship with Brahmins: he honours them, gives them lavish gifts, and seeks their counsel at every step. His righteousness is, in effect, a contract with Brahmanical authority, a power legitimised through ritual hierarchy. As Periyar E.V. Ramasamy argued in Sachchi Ramayan, Rama’s virtue exists only in service of the Brahmins; he is the Kshatriya enforcer of a social order that places priestly purity above human dignity <em>(Periyar, The Ramayana: A True Reading, Periyar Self-Respect Propaganda Institution)</em>. Even his coronation in Ayodhya, the supposed culmination of Diwali’s celebration, is an act of caste continuity. Rama’s return restores not justice, but a Brahmanical order temporarily disrupted by exile. The lamps that are said to have lit Ayodhya in his honour thus illuminate not liberation, but submission: the joyous reaffirmation of hierarchy.</p><p>If the caste order in the Ramayana enforces hierarchy through ritual violence, its gender order sustains itself through the policing of purity. Sita, the epic’s moral centre, embodies this double bind: she is worshipped as the ideal woman precisely because she endures humiliation without rebellion. After being rescued from Ravana, Sita is forced by Rama to prove her chastity in an Agni Pariksha, a trial by fire. The symbolism is devastating: womanhood purified through suffering, loyalty measured by pain. When she survives the flames, it is not enough. Later, as rumours spread about her ‘purity’, Rama, now king, abandons her while she is pregnant, to preserve his reputation as a just ruler. This is not divine love; it is patriarchal sacrifice disguised as morality.</p><p>Feminist scholar Uma Chakravarti, in Gendering Caste, argues that Brahmanical patriarchy rests on controlling women’s sexuality to protect caste purity <em>(Chakravarti, Gendering Caste, SAGE Publications, 2002)</em>. Sita’s body becomes the terrain on which both patriarchal honour and caste discipline are inscribed. Her ordeal is not personal tragedy, it is political ritual. Later feminist reinterpretations, like Volga’s The Liberation of Sita, reimagine her not as victim but as rebel: a woman who walks away from the men and gods who define her worth. But mainstream Hindu culture still enshrines her humiliation as virtue, her silence as sanctity, her obedience as glory. In celebrating the return of Rama, Diwali also celebrates the silencing of Sita. The festival of light, in this sense, shines brightest on the erasure of women’s pain.</p><p>And just as the purity of women sustains Brahmanical patriarchy, the purity of caste sustains its empire. To the Brahmanical imagination, Ravana is the demon-king, the embodiment of arrogance, lust, and evil. But to many Dalit, Dravidian, and Adivasi communities, Ravana is not a monster at all. He is a scholar-king, an indigenous ruler, a defender of his people and their land. His so-called ‘defeat’ by Rama is not a triumph of virtue; it is a political conquest disguised as cosmic destiny. In the Tamil rationalist and Dravidian movements, thinkers like Periyar reframed the Ramayana as an Aryan invasion myth: Rama, the northern Aryan, invades and subdues the southern Dravidian realm of Lanka. ‘The story of Rama is the story of our enslavement’, Periyar wrote in Sachchi Ramayan, arguing that the text re-enacts the domination of the South by the North, of the dark-skinned native by the fair-skinned conqueror <em>(Periyar, The Ramayana: A True Reading, Periyar Self-Respect Propaganda Institution)</em>.</p><p>This reading aligns with Ambedkar’s broader critique in Riddles in Hinduism: that Hindu epics function as moral propaganda for Brahmanism, converting social violence into sacred order. The defeat of Ravana, like the killing of Shambuka, reaffirms the supremacy of caste and the piety of conquest <em>(Ambedkar, ‘Riddles in Hinduism’, Navayana, 2016)</em>. Among Adivasi retellings, Ravana often appears not as a villain but as a protector, a figure of resistance against encroaching powers who claimed divine right over the forest and its people. In some oral traditions, Lanka is remembered as a prosperous, egalitarian kingdom where no one went hungry. Ravana’s ‘sin’, then, was not immorality but defiance. Contemporary works like Anand Neelakantan’s Asura: Tale of the Vanquished re-narrate the epic from Ravana’s perspective, exposing how the language of divinity justifies domination <em>(Neelakantan, Asura: Tale of the Vanquished, Leadstart Publishing, 2012)</em>. These counter-narratives remind us that every empire needs its demons, and that Brahmanism’s moral order depends on making its victims monstrous.</p><p>When Diwali celebrates Rama’s victory over Ravana, it does more than re-enact a myth; it reaffirms a social geography of power. The lamps of Ayodhya do not only banish darkness, they mark the borders of civilisation and cast its others into shadow. Every empire guards its scriptures. The Ramayana, originally composed in Sanskrit, was never meant to be read by the majority of the population. Sanskrit itself was the sacred language of power, the language of priests, inaccessible to Shudras, Dalits, and Adivasis, whose tongues were deemed impure. The divine word was, from the beginning, a locked gate. This monopoly over language created a monopoly over truth. To know the text was to control morality; to quote the gods was to command obedience. Brahmanism did not merely rule through caste; it ruled through linguistic exclusion, sanctifying inequality by placing revelation beyond the reach of the oppressed.</p><p>When Tulsidas composed the Ramcharitmanas in Awadhi in the 16th century, it appeared as an act of accessibility, the Ramayana in the language of the people. But this was no revolution. As Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd argues in Why I Am Not a Hindu, vernacular Hinduism does not democratise Brahmanism; it domesticates the oppressed into its ideology <em>(Shepherd, Why I Am Not a Hindu, Samya, 1996)</em>. The Ramcharitmanas brought the story of Rama to every household, and with it, the logic of obedience, purity, and submission to caste order. The linguistic shift was a colonisation of imagination: those who were once excluded from the sacred now became its enforcers. They sang of their own subjugation in the language of devotion. For Dalits and Adivasis, the barrier of Sanskrit was not merely linguistic; it was existential. To be forbidden from sacred speech was to be denied humanity itself. The Brahmin’s control of the word mirrored his control of the world: a monopoly not just over gods, but over what could be thought, said, and remembered.</p><p>The story of Rama’s return to Ayodhya has never been merely religious. It has always been political. Its most violent reincarnation came in Ayodhya, 1992, when a mob of Hindutva activists demolished the Babri Masjid, claiming it stood on the birthplace of Rama <em>(‘Unforgivable’: The Hindu’s editorial on December 7, 1992 on Babri Masjid demolition, 2017)</em>. The myth of return — once framed as the triumph of dharma — was transformed into a modern crusade for Hindu supremacy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GUDLs-XgVN5zyOmYcEhPDQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Babri Masjid demolition</figcaption></figure><p>Yet even within Hindu circles, the origins of that ‘birthplace’ were an act of deceit. In 1949, a Hindu priest surreptitiously placed idols of Rama and Sita inside the Babri Masjid. Multiple eyewitness accounts say that the idols were placed by the priest, Abhiram Das <em>(Jha &amp; Jha, Ayodhya -The Dark Night’, 2024)</em>. Despite this, the site was declared ‘disputed’, and the seed of religious vengeance was planted. Subsequent archaeological surveys, including those by the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), were politically manipulated to justify demolition. Independent analyses, however, revealed evidence not of a Hindu temple but of an earlier Buddhist structure, a sign that Ayodhya, like India itself, has always been layered, plural, and contested <em>(Was there a temple under Babri Masjid? Reading the Archaeological ‘Evidence’, Economic and Political Weekly, 2010)</em>. When the Babri Masjid fell, it was not only the destruction of a building but the re-enactment of Rama’s conquest, a ritual of erasure repeated in the name of divine justice. The lamps of Diwali now glow on the ruins of that violence, their light refracted through the smoke of nationalism.</p><p>This fusion of myth and politics is not incidental; it is the very logic of Hindutva, which transforms myth into memory, and memory into weapon. Just as Brahmanism turned conquest into virtue, Hindutva turns nostalgia into vengeance. Rama’s Ayodhya has become India’s ideological capital, a nation-state built on the ashes of those it has declared impure. What began as Brahmanical mythology has now become cultural diplomacy, a seamless continuity between sacred hierarchy and soft power.</p><p>In the UK, Diwali has become a spectacle of inclusion — parades in Leicester, fireworks in Trafalgar Square, and festivals in corporate offices. It is hailed as a sign of multicultural harmony, of Britain embracing the colour and spirit of South Asia. But beneath the slogans of diversity lies a silence: caste. The same social hierarchies that the Ramayana sanctified live on in diaspora communities. Dalit and Adivasi Britons continue to face discrimination in housing, marriage, and employment, yet the UK has no anti-caste legislation. Years of activism by organisations like CasteWatchUK and Dalit Solidarity Network UK, have been blocked by lobbying from pro-Hindutva groups who insist caste ‘does not exist’. This denial is not ignorance; it is strategy. Caste is being repackaged as ‘culture’, and Diwali as its global brand. Through temples, festivals, and diaspora networks, Hindutva extends its reach, normalising Brahmanical identity under the rhetoric of heritage.</p><p>Political complicity amplifies the illusion. When Sadiq Khan, the Mayor of London, partners with the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), an organisation implicated in anti-Muslim pogroms in India, to host Diwali celebrations, it is presented as cultural diplomacy. But such gestures legitimise fascism as folklore <em>(Bal, UK Govt Inquiry Says VHP Planned to ‘Purge Muslims’ in the 2002 Riots, The Wire, 2023)</em>. They transform a supremacist project into a multicultural performance palatable to Western liberalism. In this alliance, Hindutva and white supremacy find common ground: both construct purity myths, both fear contamination, and both rely on selective amnesia. Diwali in the diaspora thus becomes not an immigrant celebration, but an ideological export, a soft power ritual that masks hierarchy as harmony. And in workplaces across Britain, as diyas are lit and sweets are shared, caste and gender vanish behind the language of ‘inclusion’. The festival that once mythologised conquest now replays it in miniature, not with armies, but with corporate banners and cultural grants.</p><p>The logic of Brahmanism, conquest moralised as enlightenment, did not end in the ancient world. It laid the groundwork for every empire that followed. Ashis Nandy, in The Intimate Enemy, writes that colonialism succeeded not merely through weapons, but through the colonisation of the imagination <em>(Nandy, The Intimate Enemy, Oxford University Press)</em>. The British claimed to ‘bring light to darkness’, just as the Aryans claimed to restore order over the demonic South. The same metaphor, light over darkness, purity over pollution, has justified domination from Ayodhya to Africa.</p><p>Gayatri Spivak’s warning that ‘the subaltern cannot speak’ echoes eerily in this context: Dalit, Adivasi, and women’s voices are not absent from Diwali. They are silenced by design. Their erasure is the condition of the festival’s harmony. Yet resistance persists. In art, literature, and film <em>(Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, Can the Subaltern Speak?, in Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture, edited by Cary Nelson and Lawrence Grossberg, Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1988)</em>. In G. Aravindan’s film, Kanchana Sita, the Ramayana is retold through Adivasi actors; Sita is not a submissive wife but Prakriti, Nature itself, violated by patriarchy and empire alike . In Volga’s The Liberation of Sita, Sita’s emancipation lies not in obedience but in sisterhood, as she unites with other women exiled or disowned by men. And in Anand Neelakantan’s Asura: Tale of the Vanquished, Ravana narrates his own story, turning the epic upside down, a literary insurrection against divinised hierarchy <em>(Neelakantan, Asura: Tale of the Vanquished, Leadstart Publishing, 2012)</em>.</p><p>These works do not seek to invert the Ramayana’s moral order; they seek to abolish the very categories of purity and pollution that sustain it. Their refusal is revolutionary, a cultural act of untouchability by choice. The political economist Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd offers a materialist extension of this critique. In Why I Am Not a Hindu, he argues that Hindu festivals, far from being communal celebrations, are ‘caste projects of consumption and purity’, rituals designed by the upper castes and performed by the labour of the lower. Diwali’s very structure: ritual cleaning, lighting, gifting, and firework consumption, replicates hierarchies of service, production, and display <em>(Shepherd, Why I Am Not a Hindu, Samya, 1996)</em>.</p><p>In that sense, Diwali is not merely mythic theatre but economic ritual: the Brahmanical elite’s annual renewal of power through the labour of those it excludes. Every flame burns on someone’s exhaustion. Every light casts someone else’s shadow. To read Diwali through caste, gender, and history is to see not the glow of devotion but the architecture of power. What is celebrated as the return of light is, for many, the persistence of a shadow that never lifts. The Ramayana’s moral universe sanctified the killing of Shudras, the humiliation of women, and the conquest of indigenous peoples. All in the name of restoring order. Diwali inherited that legacy, turning social domination into sacred rhythm. In the modern world, Hindutva repackages that rhythm as nationalism, while the diaspora exports it as culture. The empire of Brahmanism survives not by force, but by celebration.</p><p>Yet the cracks in that empire are widening. Dalit, Adivasi, feminist, and Muslim voices are reclaiming the right to remember differently to tell stories. Where Ravana is a scholar, where Sita walks away, where the divine is not pure but just. Their defiance exposes what Brahmanism fears most: not darkness, but memory. Perhaps the task before us is not to choose between light and darkness, but to end the empire of those who claim to own the light. Only then can we imagine a Diwali where illumination means equality, not hierarchy, and where every flame burns not to sanctify conquest, but to mourn it.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Ambedkar, B.R. <em>Riddles in Hinduism.</em> 2016. Navayana.</p><p>Bal, Hartosh Singh. <em>UK Govt Inquiry Says VHP Planned to ‘Purge Muslims’ in the 2002 Riots, Acted With Guj Govt’s Support</em>, <em>The Wire</em>, 24 Jan 2023.</p><p>Chakravarti, Uma. <em>Gendering Caste: Through a Feminist Lens.</em> 2003. Sage Publications.</p><p>Ilaiah Shepherd, Kancha. <em>Why I Am Not a Hindu.</em> 1996. Samya.</p><p>Jha, Krishna &amp; Dhirendra K. Jha. <em>Ayodhya — The Dark Night: The Secret History of Rama’s Appearance in Babri Masjid</em>. 2024. National Herald.</p><p>Nandy, Ashis. <em>The Intimate Enemy: Loss and Recovery of Self Under Colonialism.</em> 1983. Oxford University Press.</p><p>Neelakantan, Anand. <em>Asura: Tale of the Vanquished.</em> 2012. Leadstart Publishing.</p><p>Periyar, E.V. Ramasamy. <em>The Ramayana: A True Reading (Sachchi Ramayanam).</em> 2009. Periyar Self-Respect Propaganda Institution.</p><p>Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. <em>Can the Subaltern Speak?</em> 1988. University of Illinois Press.</p><p><em>‘Unforgivable’: The Hindu’s editorial on December 7, 1992 on Babri Masjid demolition</em>. 2017. The Hindu.</p><p>Valmiki. <em>The Ramayana of Valmiki: Uttarakāṇḍa.</em> 2016. Princeton University Press.</p><p><em>‘Was there a temple under Babri Masjid? Reading the Archaeological ‘Evidence’’</em>. 2010. Economic &amp; Political Weekly.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b71786641b25" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Illusion of Classlessness: Why Wages Don’t Define Class]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/the-illusion-of-classlessness-why-wages-dont-define-class-c7e59bba3bba?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c7e59bba3bba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[work]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 May 2025 17:04:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-29T17:22:48.566Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Illusion of Classlessness: Why Wages Don’t Define Class</p><p>In contemporary liberal discourse, class is often reduced to income brackets. The assumption is simple: if you don’t earn a six-figure salary or own property, you’re not part of the ruling class. This reductionist view flattens the structural complexities of capitalism and erases the material power that comes from one’s role in production. In Marxist terms, class isn’t about how much you earn, but about where you stand in relation to the means of production and the process of surplus value extraction.</p><p>Under capitalism, the working class—or proletariat—is defined not by income level but by the necessity to sell labor in exchange for wages. Workers do not own the tools, factories, or institutions that generate profit. Instead, they must sell their time and labor-power to survive. What they produce is always worth more than what they are paid; the difference is the surplus value that is appropriated by capitalists.</p><p>But capitalists rarely manage this extraction directly. That job falls to a mediating class: managers, supervisors, team leads, and administrators. These roles form what Marxist and critical theorists often refer to as the &quot;Professional-Managerial Class&quot; (PMC). Though they may themselves be waged workers, their structural function is to enforce capitalist discipline: monitoring performance, ensuring productivity, distributing tasks, and translating corporate goals downward. They are the face of capital to the worker.</p><p>This makes managers a contradictory class. They neither own capital nor labor under it in the same way frontline workers do. Their relationship to surplus value is not one of direct appropriation, but of facilitation. They are paid to extract labor efficiently from workers, and in doing so, they claim a cut of the value created.</p><p>Because of this, salary alone tells us little about someone’s class position. A manager earning a modest wage in an expensive city may feel economically insecure, but that doesn’t disqualify them from occupying a structurally privileged position in the workplace. Their economic anxiety may be real, but their job still involves overseeing, evaluating, and disciplining workers.</p><p>When managers complain about their own low wages or financial stress, they may conflate personal precarity with class oppression. But class is not just about hardship; it&#39;s about power. Who has authority over whom? Who can hire and fire? Who disciplines, and who is disciplined? These are the metrics of class in a Marxist framework.</p><p>This is why appeals to wage-based victimhood can be misleading. They obscure how power flows through institutions and into interpersonal dynamics. A manager might feel exploited by their own bosses—and they often are—but they still exert coercive power over those beneath them. Their participation in the reproduction of capitalist labor relations situates them on the side of capital.</p><p>Marxist class analysis refuses the seductive liberal narrative that everyone who isn&#39;t wealthy is equally oppressed. It insists on examining the entire circuit of capital: production, extraction, and reproduction. And in this circuit, middle managers are not neutral; they are instrumental.</p><p>To challenge capitalism effectively, we need to name this structure clearly. Not to demonize individuals, but to understand the mechanics of power. Solidarity can only emerge when we resist the temptation to see class as a personal identity or an income tier, and begin to see it as a set of structural relations. In the struggle against exploitation, clarity is a form of power.</p><p>Managers who seek solidarity with workers must recognize the contradiction of their position and commit to resisting the functions that capital assigns to them. Without that awareness, their politics risk collapsing into moral performance—a posture of empathy that does not disrupt the systems that grant them authority.</p><p>Understanding this is key to building a politics grounded in material reality, not individual sentiment. In the end, class is not a feeling—it is a relation. And that relation, under capitalism, is defined by exploitation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c7e59bba3bba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Uselessness of Non-Violence as a Method to Contest the Capitalist World-System]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/the-uselessness-of-non-violence-as-a-method-to-contest-the-capitalist-world-system-670451c0ff55?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/670451c0ff55</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gandhi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[violence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 May 2024 16:18:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-22T16:18:24.403Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In a recent update, I argued that non-violence as a strategy and method for protest utilised by an array of social movements, does not work out for the liberation of the masses. Here, I expand on five tenets of the uselessness of non-violence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CYNtgAyo9HagB-HkvfdgiQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>(they see me rolling….rolling into British, casteist, and communal propaganda)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Non-violence is ineffective</em></strong></p><p>Non-violent movements pose little real threat to the entrenched world-regime and its inherent power structures. Instead, it effectively allows the status quo to ignore or easily suppress the movement without major concessions. Regimes can and do respond with brutal crackdowns and state-sponsored violence against non-violent protestors, which allows them to nullify the moral/public relations impact of non-violence. Lastly, non-violence movements also lack effective bargaining power without the threat of violence to negotiate with.</p><p>The last point provides a useful adage in relation to the escalations the world has seen in relation to the US-Israel sponsored genocide of Palestinians. It is important to qualify that student encampments and direct actions against arms manufacturers are not non-violent. Students and workers, through their occupation and blockade strategies, threaten to disrupt the very economic and political structures of the world-system that are being so effectively used to conduct the Palestinian genocide, and which are employed by such institutions as universities. The state-sponsored violent reaction we see in response to these, therefore, itself generates a moral panic and public outcry, which then argues itself against statist repression (a good thing). It would do the movement for Palestine a world of good to realise this crucial difference between non-violent protests/movements in general and what the world is currently witnessing in response to the genocide of Palestinians.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*uQst96rN14Hf2jWGTY_Vmg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Student Encapment at Columbia University in Solidarity with Palestine</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Non-violence is patriarchal</em></strong></p><p>Non-violent protests and movements are often based upon values, among others, that are labelled ‘feminine’ under patriarchy. These include care, nurturing, and conflict avoidance, which lead to number of issues. It teaches women to accept violence and oppression passively, effectively reinforcing the traditional feminine ideal of submissiveness that is the core tenet of patriarchy. Placing an unfair burden on women to absorb violence and suffering, non-violent resistance allows oppressors and the patriarchal system to remain intact. Non-violent philosophy, thus, fails to adequately confront the systemic and structural violence that patriarchy perpetuates against women through socioeconomic exploitation, reproductive control, and sexual violence. Lastly, we have numerous examples from history where such movements have sought to marginalise women’s voices and perspectives, replicating patriarchal power dynamics within the movements themselves, i.e., the struggles of women have been appropriated by all kinds of resistance movements throughout history, whether nationalist, anti-capitalism, or anti-colonial. Women have effectively been told that their movement holds secondary importance compared to these other movements.</p><p><strong><em>Non-violence is racist</em></strong></p><p>Slavery, segregation, police brutality, amongst others, are violent forms of oppression. Contesting them through non-violence places an unfair burden on oppressed racial and minority groups to absorb violence while protecting oppressors. It preserves the power and privilege structures of the racist ruling class and has often been used as a compromise imposed on people of colour by white power structures to avoid more militant resistance. Such white power structures are visible within these non-violent movements themselves, reinforcing the narrative that white people know what is best for ‘less civilised’ people of colour. Thus, non-violent movements are rooted in privileged white experiences and perspectives that do not account for the realities of violent racism and have historically tended to marginalise voices advocating for confrontational tactics belonging to people of colour.</p><p><strong><em>Non-violence is statist</em></strong></p><p>Non-violent movements ensure that the state continues to hold a monopoly on the legitimate use of violence, allowing the state to maintain its violent apparatus unchallenged. Since, non-violent movements operate within the legal/judicial framework defined by the state, it allows the state to control and limit the boundaries of resistance. This serves to appease the state and prevents militant confrontation with the state’s authoritarianism. Instead of using more confrontational tactics like strikes and occupations, the non-violent doctrine reinforces the state’s purported legitimacy as the sole arbiter of the rules of the game for social movements.</p><p><strong><em>Non-violence is tactically and strategically inferior</em></strong></p><p>It limits the available tactics and options for a movement, putting movements at a strategic disadvantage against opponents who are more than willing to use violence. Thus, non-violent movements remain extremely vulnerable to violent repression by the state and its apparatus such as the police, military, and paramilitary groups. This strategic inferiority ensures that they have little to no bargaining power and leaves them vulnerable to be easily repressed or ignored by the state, since the state itself is defining the rules of the game, as explained above.</p><p>In conclusion, non-violence is a delusional method/strategy/tactic for fighting against oppression. It rests on the belief that oppressors and violent systems of power will voluntarily relinquish their power and privilege in the face of peaceful protest alone. It is based on the delusional assumption of a level playing field where reason, morality, and public opinion ultimately prevail, ignoring the realities of power politics. By denying the need for confrontational tactics and self-defence, it leaves the participants of these movements vulnerable to violent repression.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=670451c0ff55" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Anarchist Undercurrent in the Political Struggles of India]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/the-anarchist-undercurrent-in-the-political-struggles-of-india-2999f3a3b526?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2999f3a3b526</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gandhi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 May 2024 00:23:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-09T00:28:01.981Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Anarchism is a widely engaging political philosophy and penetrates many fields. As a political ideology, it rejects the notion of the state, arguing that as an entity, the state upholds structures that perpetuate oppression and violence. Crucially, anarchism separates itself from Marxism by rejecting historical materialism. Instead of history following a natural, pre-determined process that not only situates humankind’s current position but will eventually lead to a communist space, anarchism posits that the oppressive modes and forces of institutions are responsible for the current situation, and therefore, must be fought. One of the foremost strategies for fighting is to dismantle top-down hierarchies and create bottom-up ones that enable the transparent flow of information and favor consensus decision-making, leading to autonomy.</p><p>While anarchism has mostly gained popularity and followers in the West, it has not been completely invisible in the East. India has had its own history of anarchism that precedes its emergence and widespread popularity in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In this article, I move away from a Eurocentric lens and look at the development of anarchist thought in India.</p><p><strong>Religion, Ecology, and Anarchism</strong></p><p>The religions of Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, invoke the prehistoric state of nature where all living beings lived in harmony and their needs were satisfied by the land. Hindu cosmology, specifically, talks about the Satya Yuga, the first and the best of the four eras, where society was stateless, and governance was performed through the just principles of <em>dharma</em>. In the literary tradition of India (<em>sutras) </em>Chanakya wrote, “It is better not to have a king than have one who is wanting in discipline.” The Satya Yuga was a period when there were no castes, and Hinduism posits that with the coming of succeeding eras, corruption seeped in, subsequently degrading the status of humans.</p><p>All three religions have texts that could be interpreted as being akin to anarchist thought. In Hinduism, the Mahabharata contains a dialogue between Yudhishthira, the central figure of the epic and the emperor, and Bhishma, the supreme commander of the Kaurava forces, which can be seen as a critique of authoritarianism and support for non-statism. The dialogue is shown below.</p><p>“At first there was no sovereignty, no king, no chastisement, and no chastiser. All men used to protect one another righteously.” (Mahabharata, Book 12, Chapter 59)</p><p>Similarly, Buddhist texts include references to societies without rulers and violence. In the Sutta Nipata, for example, is the verse:</p><p>‘Let him not kill, nor cause to be killed any living being, nor let him approve of others killing, after having refrained from hurting all creatures, both those that are strong and those that tremble in the world.” (Sutta Nipata, Verse 393)</p><p>Lastly, in Jainism, there is the concept of <em>anekantavada </em>which highlights the importance of having multiple perspectives and opposing dogmatism. The concept can be seen as rejecting the rigidity of political ideologies in support for non-statism.</p><p>Swami Vivekananda, a prominent anarchist thinker, argued that the focus of the Bhagavad Gita on individualism can be seen as achieving liberty. He saw liberty as the first condition of growth and posited that individualism would lead to solidarity and social equality through self-actualization. In true ecological tones, Vivekananda’s goal was “freedom from the slavery of matter and thought, mastery of external and internal matter.” He saw the caste system as a form of oppression and called for the abolishment of the state in favor of a decentralized, self-governing society that prioritized individual freedoms above authority. He said,</p><p>“I do not believe in a God or religion which cannot wipe the widow’s tears or bring a piece of bread to the orphan’s mouth.”</p><p>Thus, Vivekananda not only emphasized the importance of individual responsibility and action for creating a just and equitable society but also criticized all forms of authority that did not prioritize the well-being of all individuals.</p><p>Going back three centuries from Swami Vivekananda to the 16th century, the poem <em>Begumpura </em>by Guru Ravidas paints a picture of a utopian city called Begumpura where people of all castes and religions lived harmoniously without the imposing jurisdictions of authority, taxes, and laws. The poem is quoted in full below.</p><p>“The regal realm with the sorrowless name:<br> they call it Begumpura, a place with no pain,<br> No taxes or cares, none owns property there,<br> no wrongdoing, worry, terror, or torture.<br> Oh, my brother, I’ve come to take it as my own,<br> my distant home where everything is right.<br> That imperial kingdom is rich and secure,<br> where none are third or second — all are one;<br> They do this or that, they walk where they wish,<br> they stroll through fabled palaces unchallenged.<br> Oh, says Ravidas, a tanner now set free,<br> those who walk beside me are my friends.”</p><p>Ravidas was a prominent member of the leather working community in the 16th century and was critical of the oppressive caste system in India. His poem has been interpreted as a vision for a decentralized, self-governing society. Baba Ramchandra, a social reformer and anarchist thinker in the 20th century, interpreted the utopia as based on mutual aid and voluntary cooperation. He argued using education, social reforms, and direct action to achieve such a society.</p><p>It is important to note that opposition to the state with respect to religions in India is non-statist and does not adhere to anti-statism. This is an important distinction that points to the salience of non-violent sociopolitical movements in India and is drawn from the concept of <em>ahimsa</em>, meaning non-violence. The concept is present in Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, and translates to attitudes toward animals and the environment, thus pointing to the ecological roots of anarchism in India. Buddhism also has the concept of ‘dependent origination, emphasizing the interconnectedness of all beings. It also teaches the values of non-attachment and renunciation of worldly desires, which can be interpreted as critiques of consumerism.</p><p>Before British colonialism, indigenous communities in India, such as the Adivasis, lived in harmony with nature and practiced sustainable forestry and agriculture. They practiced shifting cultivation to maintain soil fertility and prevent erosion, as well as community forestry. These communities felt a spiritual and cultural connection to the natural world, which relates to the theme of the interconnectedness of all beings, and points to the responsibility of humans to look after nature.</p><p>Hindu spiritualism, with an emphasis on nature, experienced a revival in the nineteenth century. One of the important figures was Sri Ramakrishna, a mystic who highlighted the importance of directly experiencing the divine. He emphasized the unity of all religions and the non-dualist relationship between the self and the universe, thus pointing to the importance of achieving spirituality by living in harmony with nature. Ramakrishna was also an influence on Swami Vivekananda, who argued for the relevance of Hindu spiritualism in tackling sociopolitical issues by advocating self-rule and independence from colonialism.</p><p>These ecological overtones were heavily present in the Chipko Movement in the 1970s. The movement was led by women in the Himalayan region of Uttarakhand against deforestation and commercial logging. It called for ecological democracy in the region and argued that local communities should have control and the power to make decisions regarding the use of natural resources. The Chipko Movement inspired subsequent environmental movements including the Narmada Bachao Andolan, that opposed the construction of large dams on the Narmada River.</p><p><strong>The Important Personalities</strong></p><p>Some important figures have been influential in shaping anarchist thought in India and have employed religious and ecological thoughts from the prevalent religions to inform their works. I have already discussed the work of Swami Vivekananda and will look at other important figures now.</p><p><strong>Sri Aurobindo</strong></p><p>Aurobindo was a disciple of Swami Vivekananda and was part of the Indian Independence Movement. He espoused non-violent direct action for countering British colonialism and sought to reconcile individualism with collectivism. Highlighting the importance of individual liberty in his book, <em>The Human Cycle</em>, he wrote:</p><p>“Thus, we should have a new typal order based upon purely economic capacity and function, <em>gunakarma</em>, and rapidly petrifying by the inhibition of individual liberty into a system of rationalistic conventions. And quite certainly this static order would at long last be broken by a new individualist age of revolt, led probably by the principles of an extreme philosophical Anarchism.”</p><p>He advocated for a nation-state of anarchy that could be achieved by building voluntary associations between free individuals and employing the principles of <em>swaraj</em> — self-rule for achieving liberation through a decentralized process. Aurobindo’s anarchism was deeply informed by spiritualism and in <em>The Ideal of Human Unity</em>, he wrote:</p><p>“But there is a higher, an intellectual anarchistic thought which in its aim and formula recovers and carries to its furthest logical conclusions a very real truth of nature and of the divine in man. In its revolt against the opposite exaggeration of the social principle, we find it declaring that all government of man by man by the power of compulsion is an evil, a violation, a suppression or deformation of a natural principle of good which would otherwise grow and prevail for the perfection of the human race.”</p><p><strong>Bhagat Singh</strong></p><p>Popularized by the biopic on him, <em>The Legend of Bhagat Singh (2002)</em>, Bhagat Singh was a Marxist-Anarchist who was extremely critical of British colonialism in the subcontinent. He was influenced by Western political thinkers, including Karl Marx, Mikhail Bakunin, Vladimir Lenin, and Leon Trotsky. He too emphasized the importance of individual liberty and voluntary associations, and was critical of the state for unjust oppression. He argued that anarchism was more effective for achieving social change. In an article for the Punjabi periodical Kirti, he committed to anarchism by writing:</p><p>“The ultimate goal of Anarchism is complete independence, according to which no one will be obsessed with God or religion, nor will anybody be crazy for money or other worldly desires. There will be no chains on the body or control by the state. This means that they want to eliminate: the Church, God and Religion; the state; private property.”</p><p>He was, however, not an advocate for non-violence and called for the arming of the general population of India as organized militias against British forces.</p><p><strong>Har Dayal</strong></p><p>Har Dayal was the founder of the Ghadar Party, which attempted to overthrow British rule in the subcontinent. To escape British surveillance on him, Har Dayal moved to the United States and continued his anarchist activities from there. He laid the foundations of the Bakunin Institute in California, which he described as a monastery for anarchism. He sought to reconcile Western political thought of social revolutions with the teachings of Buddhism and saw ancient Aryan culture as anarchistic in its values and works. He was also an advocate for direct action and being critical of the oppressive rule of the British, he declared:</p><p>“No Indian who really loves his country ought to compromise his principle and barter his rectitude for any favor whatever at the hands of alien oppressive rulers of India.”</p><p><strong>M.P.T Acharya</strong></p><p>Manikarnika P. Thakur, or M.P.T. Acharya was an Indian anarchist and feminist, who was critical of authoritative structures, the state, and oppressive hierarchies. He advocated the employment of non-violent tactics to counter social oppression and create a decentralized, self-governing social order based on cooperation and mutual aid. Thus, Acharya was critical of Western capitalist ideology. In one of his major works, <em>What is Anarchism</em>, he was critical of the state and saw it as espousing oppression on society, writing:</p><p>“Anarchy means non-rule, non-government, non-state. The Anarchists want non-rule, non-government, non-state. They want a non-governed, non-ruled, non-state society. Here, anarchism is the antithesis, the opposite of all other -isms. It negates fundamentally the necessity of all states, whatever their form. While in other -isms they try to find a synthesis between state and society, the anarchists believe, consider, and think that the state is the enemy of society, i.e., the state will suppress the society or the society will have to suppress the state. That means the two cannot co-exist.”</p><p>Acharya was also an advocate for the liberation of women from their oppression. He saw women’s oppression as inherently tied to the oppression of the poor and working class, and posited that anarchism is committed to the complete liberation of women from the evil of patriarchy. In one of his essays, <em>On Jealousy</em>, he was critical of patriarchal structures and wrote:</p><p>“Women had to be content with their fate. This system has prevailed so far, because the laws continue to guarantee the man the possession of his wife (of his love!), and to prevent the alienation and the transfer of his affections to someone else.”</p><p>Acharya highlighted the importance of Indian villages as forming communities to dismantle the oppressive structures of the state that could be built up to form a decentralized, self-governing society through utilizing mutual aid.</p><p><strong>Gandhi</strong></p><p>Gandhi epitomized non-violence through his <em>Satyagraha</em> movement of civil disobedience against the British. He was also an advocate of <em>Sarvodaya</em>, a Sanskrit term meaning ‘the welfare of all’. Gandhi was heavily influenced by the Russian anarchist and reformer Leo Tolstoy and saw violence as the root of all social problems, thus seeing the state as problematic due to its monopoly on violence.</p><p>Gandhi called for a bottom-up hierarchical approach to dissolving the state that would be based on communal relationships between Indian villages, regions, and then the national level in succession. George Woodcock, a political biographer, claimed that Gandhi self-identified as an anarchist. However, it is important to note that Gandhi collaborated with the Indian National Congress and saw the formation of the Indian state without British colonialism as a necessary step toward anarchy, which can be interpreted as an adherent to anarchist politics, since it does not favor parliamentarianism.</p><p><strong>Contemporary Anarchism in India</strong></p><p>While anarchism has not become a major political ideology in India, its elements can still be seen. There are small anarchist groups operating such as the Indian Anarchist Federation. There are also collectives disseminating political literature such as Radical Notes. Moreover, there are workers and trade unions, the most prominent of which is the Maruti Suzuki Workers’ Union in Gurgaon, whose struggles gained popular media attention in 2016 when it protested for better pay and workers’ rights, leading to multiple arrests.</p><p>More recently, the farmers’ protests in India as well as those against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and the National Register of Citizens (NRC) have had anarchist tones due to their anti-capitalist and anti-fascist stances. The CAA and NRC acts are discriminatory toward Muslims and other marginalized groups in India. The far-right, fascist ideology of Hindutva, calling for a pure Hindu nation, has emerged and anarchist thinkers and writers have heavily criticized it, including Maia Ramnath, historian, and author of the book <em>Decolonizing Anarchism</em>, who has said:</p><p>“The word Hindutva literally could be translated as Hindu-ness. But what is it? It’s a far-right religious ethno-nationalism based on the idea of Hindu supremacy. It’s a political ideology that defines Indian as synonymous with Hindu and treats Hinduism not as merely a religion, but as a form of racial or ethnic identity and furthermore, as a culture, which is very militaristic, patriarchal, purity-obsessed.”</p><p>Concerning marginalized groups in India, a salient issue that has been present since time immemorial is that of Dalits, who regularly face discrimination, violence, and social exclusion. The caste system may be legally abolished but continues to exist socially and culturally. During and after the Indian Independence Movement, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar was a prominent voice for the Dalits and led the movement for equality and justice. He criticized the hierarchical social structure of India as being the root cause of the oppression of Dalits, as well as the role of the state in maintaining and perpetuating the structure. In one of his speeches in 1943, he was critical of formal democracy in achieving an equitable society and said:</p><p>“A democratic form of government presupposes a democratic form of society. The formal framework of democracy is of no value and would indeed be a misfit if there was no social democracy.”</p><p>Dr. B.R. Ambedkar highlighted the importance of alternative forms of social organization based on mutual aid and direct action. He emphasized the need for social democracy and constitutional morality as well. Recently, the Dalits have been involved in struggles against the state and its oppressive politics. The Bhim Army, a Dalit rights organization, regularly organizes and protests caste-based discrimination and police brutality. Many Dalit farmers were affected by the farm acts of 2020 and participated in the farmers’ protests. The Dalits also showed solidarity with Muslims in protests against the CAA and NRC acts.</p><p>Thus, anarchism in India looks at these issues with an intersectional lens of struggles against caste, class, and religious oppression. The struggles of Dalits, farmers, and other marginalized groups are situated as struggles against capitalism and the state and argue for the people’s economic and political freedom. The Dalits have also forged a counterculture movement to raise their voices and discuss their struggles in resisting the dominant narratives. The Dalit Panthers drew inspiration from the Black Panthers in the United States, and still continually use music and street theater to fight against oppression. Other examples include the Dalit Women’s Self-Respect Movement, the Dalit Queer Project, and the Ambedkar Periyar Phule study circle. Festivals such as the Magnetic Fields Festival and the Ziro Festival function as alternate media outlets that provide a platform for such voices.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>While anarchism has not gained a following as a major political philosophy and ideology in India, its principles and the teachings of its early proponents can be seen as undercurrents in recent sociopolitical movements in the country. The saliency of the Dalit question has represented anarchism and has the potential to become a major outlet for espousing anarchist politics. Contemporary issues such as the farmers’ protests and the growing counterculture movement have firm ecological roots, while the non-violent characteristics of sociopolitical movements such as those against the CAA and NRC acts indicate the presence of the religious roots of anarchism in India.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2999f3a3b526" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Steven Pinker and Social Movements]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/steven-pinker-and-social-movements-4f8625aaa24a?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4f8625aaa24a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colonialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-movements]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolution]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 May 2024 15:16:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-06T15:31:48.606Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Note: The data in this article has been taken from Dylan Sullivan’s and Jason Hickel’s 2023 paper. See the reference below. This article should be read as a brief review of their work, which is a prominent piece of work and should be read by everyone.</em></p><p>What has Steven Pinker got to do with labour and other social movements? In his 2018 book, <em>Enlightenment Now,</em> Steven Pinker presents a graph (see below), showing declining levels of extreme poverty from 1820. He uses this graph to argue that capitalism has inevitably made the world better, pulling billions of people out of extreme poverty, which was, according to Pinker the natural condition of humanity before the advent of capitalism. Today, we debunk the f*ck out of Pinker.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/417/1*2sSTxbyI4_Y0Ft-n8ef72g.png" /><figcaption>Pinker is on a galactic ride propelled through the contents of his shitty work.</figcaption></figure><p>The graph itself is not Pinker’s creation but is borrowed from Martin Ravallion’s work (2016). And frankly, it runs into a few problems. The first thing to note is the irregularity of the data used to construct the graph: it relies on two different types of data. From 1981 to present, it uses household National Samples Surveys, which include both income and goods derived from social provisioning systems and subsistence work. However, prior to 1981, it uses GDP data in National Accounts Statistics. The problem with doing this? GDP data does not include income/earnings derived from subsistence activities such as foraging and subsistence farming, i.e., if this data was included, it is likely that poverty levels would not be as high as shown in Pinker’s graph prior to 1981.</p><p>It is well demonstrated that GDP per capita growth and household consumption changes do not move together. Think about it like this. If you lived in a small community and had access to a forest to use its resources, that would be included in subsistence activities. However, if a colonizer would come and appropriate the forest from your community, you would get to be employed by the colonizer to exploit the forest for its resources. These resources would now be used by your colonizer instead of serving the needs of your community. It would also show up in the GDP now, but yours and your community’s welfare has now declined due to the appropriation of the forest by the colonizer, i.e., production of resources from the forest becomes formalized. This would cause an upward bias in the GDP of whatever nation you live in, but you are left worst off than you started.</p><p>The second problem with the Pinker/Ravallion graph is its use of $1.90 PPP (purchasing power parity) as the poverty line. This value, as calculated by the World Bank, is based on prices from the whole economy. For example, while it includes prices for basic foodstuffs and clothing, it also includes prices for luxury cars and private jets, which do not matter for the purposes of assessing extreme poverty.</p><p>The third problem with the graph is its starting point of 1820. It assumes, incorrectly, that 1820 was the starting point of capitalism. It has thus been used to tell a convenient story about capitalism as saviour of humanity, pulling us out of destituteness. However, it has been well demonstrated that capitalism as a world-system has its roots in the late 15th and early 16th centuries. Thus, the graph disregards almost 300 years of relevant history, during which time, capitalism began manifesting as a world-system through systematic dispossession carried out by Western powers in the Global South.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/979/1*m-9Nn1zYOZIrELvpvHoLpQ.png" /><figcaption>Pinker’s incorrect graph</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/529/1*gR7fhmUwilmj77bel4DTaA.png" /><figcaption>The Haymarket Affair saw the bombing of a unionist meeting calling for an end to police brutality, followed by the unlawful trials of those falsely accused. Movements like these won freedoms for the working class all around the world.</figcaption></figure><p>Therefore, it is highly unlikely that 90% of humanity lived in extreme poverty prior to the rise of capitalism (1820, according to Pinker). Instead, recent research has shown that historically, throughout the world, even unskilled urban workers had wages high enough to support a family of four. This research clearly demonstrates extreme poverty as not a natural condition, but a function of processes of high social and economic distress, including wars, famines (often caused by colonizers), and dispossession. Secondly, more current research has demonstrated that the capitalist world-system is actually coincided in a deterioration of human welfare throughout the world. Even more surprisingly to Pinker, in regions where progress has actually occurred, it started much later than when Pinker’s graph suggests. What drove this progress? It is highly likely that this progress was driven by the rise of organized labour, anti-colonial, and other social movements, as these tended to organized labour to meet human needs and redistribute wealth.</p><p>Of prominent notice in this new emerging research that contradicts Pinker is Dylan Sullivan and Jason Hickel’s work (2023). They have performed an analysis of real wages, human height, and mortality from the long 16th century to present times in five major world regions: Europe, Latin America, Sub-Saharan Africa, South Asia, and China. Using these three indicators, they have demonstrated the impact of the rise of the capitalist world-system throughout the world.</p><p>As an adage, it is useful to briefly understand world-systems theory as outlined by Immanuel Wallerstein most seminally. In world-systems theory, capitalism is defined as a system whose only purpose is the continuous accumulation of capital, i.e., endless economic growth. Under this system, the core regions of the world hold a monopoly over high-profit yielding production processes, which allows them to exploit resources from the periphery regions of the world. The periphery regions are in turn subjected to produce low-profit yielding goods to be sold in highly competitive market. This capitalist world-system began in the long 16th century, with Northwest Europe being the core in relation to Eastern Europe and the Western Hemisphere as the peripheries. This system was expanded throughout the world in the 18th and 19th centuries by European powers as they went through pillaging, murdering, dispossessing, and forcibly integrating Africa, South Asia, and China into the new world-system.</p><p>Coming back to Dylan and Jason’s work, it is useful to look at their data from each of the five regions to see trends and explain why they occur.</p><p><strong><em>Europe</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/636/1*nQRQsQaHYAkMvTv78c5PoQ.png" /><figcaption>Daily income of an unskilled worker with a family of four working 250 days annually, where 1 = extreme poverty line</figcaption></figure><p>The data on real wages in Europe show that poverty was not a natural condition in Europe. Unskilled workers across Europe earned enough to support a family of four most of the past 600 years, with wages declining below the extreme poverty line in times of extreme social and economic distress only, such as epidemics and famines. The data also clearly shows that the rise of capitalism in Europe is actually associated with a decline in human welfare conditions. In the European periphery, wages fell dramatically, as its lands and resources were appropriated to serve in the new monopolized capitalistic world-system. Wages only began to rise in post-World War II times, an era associated with the rise of socialist parties and organized labour throughout Europe. In the European core, wage alleviation began earlier, in the 1880s, a full four centuries after the rise of capitalism, and again, in a time period heavily associated with the rise of labour and other social movements in the core. This progress should be checked though, since European countries have only been able to succumb to the demands of these social movements due to them having surplus extracted from their colonies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/637/1*hR65qWLzQU_ac39KsojrQA.png" /><figcaption>Daily income for an unskilled worker with a family of four, adjusted for 2011 PPP dollars</figcaption></figure><p>The trends in European height and mortality tell us the same story, with Europeans from the 19th century being considerably shorter than their 16th century counterparts. Height only began to recover in the 20th century, with progress attributed to the provisioning of sanitation systems and public healthcare access. It is important to remind yourself here that these provisions were secured with the demands of socialist and progressive movements throughout Europe. A good (but horrifying) measure of mortality rates in Europe is to look at the occurrence of famine. In the 1400s, Europe experienced only 13 years of famine. Under capitalism, the 17th century alone had 61 famines. The regular occurrences of famine did not improve until the 20th century, attributable again to the rise of democratic institutions, with data suggesting that famines rarely occur under democratic conditions.</p><p><strong><em>Latin America</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/648/1*sUU6z_2OfG_TmVw5rIQCHA.png" /><figcaption>Daily income of an unskilled worker with a family of four working 250 days annually, where 1 = extreme poverty line</figcaption></figure><p>An analysis of extreme poverty in Latin America cannot be complete without assessing the impact of the Spanish and Portuguese conquests. This conquest exterminated 90% of the Indigenous population, leading to the assimilation of Latin America into the capitalist world-system. However, looking at real wage data before the conquests reveals that workers made double the poverty line in the 18th century, with Argentinian workers enjoying levels up to 9 times more. Furthermore, Latin America’s assimilation into capitalism did not result in human welfare improvements. Once again, wages only improved from the 1940s with the growth of labour unions and leftist governments in power.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*7hGEja7NOciUfmpDxSOkaA.png" /><figcaption>Average male height in Latin America</figcaption></figure><p>These gains were, however, reversed with structural adjustment programs of the IMF and the World Bank imposed in the 1980s and 1990s. Looking at height and mortality data, we see the same trend, with decreasing heights associated with the onset of colonial conquests. Mortality rates returned to levels of 1850 in the 1940s with greater access to public healthcare, food, and education, which were won through the efforts of trade unions and sociopolitical activism. Therefore, social movements, not capitalism, brought progress to Latin America.</p><p><strong><em>Sub-Saharan Africa</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*QzT5EcTT9GoCQGlmyFAa_w.png" /><figcaption>Daily income of an unskilled worker with a family of four working 250 days annually, where 1 = extreme poverty line</figcaption></figure><p>Slavery and capitalism go hand in hand. One of the first regions to be incorporated into the capitalist world-system was Sub-Saharan Africa, with its people fulfilling a demand for cheap plantation labour through slavery in the 17th century. Other regions of Africa were assimilated into capitalism during the so-called ‘scramble of Africa’ in the 1880s. Real wage data from before this time from Ghana shows that wages were higher than the extreme poverty line, falling by 81% as it was acclimated into the new world-system. Generally, wages in Africa only revered from 1930s to 1950s, decades associated with the rise of African labour and anti-colonial movements. These gains were lost in the next decades due to constant interference by Western states, undermining independent African governments.</p><p>Height data shows a rapid decline in the 19th and early 20th centuries, with analysis showing that this was driven by European colonialism. Heights recovered to their 1860 levels in the 1950s, only to decline again with the advent of Western intervention and have not recovered significantly in many African countries. Mortality data too, shows a deterioration in population health during the colonial era. Progress only began in the 1940s, owing to the efforts of labour and other progressive movements to secure public healthcare provisions and access.</p><p><strong><em>South Asia</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/628/1*3n70yXChqjW4Vdk_wyLdFw.png" /><figcaption>Daily income of an unskilled worker with a family of four working 250 days annually, where 1 = extreme poverty line</figcaption></figure><p>The Indian subcontinent was incorporated into the capitalist world-system in 1757 when the East India Company (EIC) took control of Bengal. The EIC used economic measures such as high duties on Indian goods and low tariffs on British ones to create a surplus drain from India to Britain. Prior to the assimilation of the subcontinent, real wage was higher than the extreme poverty line. Recovery occurred after independence was gained in 1947 but fell again as the new regime failed in its perusal of contingent land reforms and public distribution systems. Height data indicates that the average height fell dramatically with the advent of colonization, especially as British regime led to several famines. Height has still not recovered to ancient Harappan civilization levels, except in Sri Lanka, a recovered associated with Sri Lanka’s public provisioning structures.</p><p>In fact, during the Mughal period in the 16th century, welfare standards in the subcontinent were similar to those of Western Europe. However, colonization resulted in a massive regression, with famines playing a major role, as they became more regular under British rule. About 50 million people lost their lives under British colonialism, which itself is a conservative estimate. India’s life expectancy only recovered to early modern England’s level after independence. However, these gains are mostly reflected in greater access to healthcare instead of provisioning of food.</p><p><strong><em>China</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/618/1*iHAx3pobvckchevGsZB3TA.png" /><figcaption>Daily income of an unskilled worker with a family of four working 250 days annually, where 1 = extreme poverty line</figcaption></figure><p>After India, it was China’s turn to become part of the capitalist world-system. Here, the British started by illegally trafficking opium grown in Indian fields to reverse the outflow of silver from Europe to China. Low tariffs on British goods and high duties on Chinese ones resulted in a drain of silver from China. The British even imposed a semi-slave trade in China, transferring Chinese labour to British plantations across the globe.</p><p>Before British colonization in China, labourers in China earned 50% more than the extreme poverty decline. However, wages plummeted with colonization and the resulting onset from the Opium War. Wages recovered in the aftermath of the Chinese communist revolution in 1949, continuing in an upward trend till 1990. This progress can be attributed to job and food security programs in Maoist China. After the 1990s, capitalist reforms were brought in and public provisioning structures were dismantled in China, leading to a collapse in wages.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*5G8OohJhgn37JHAQIl47Fw.png" /><figcaption>Average height of an adult male in China</figcaption></figure><p>Similarly, height also dropped following the Opium Wars, and an increase in mortality is visible following the incorporation of China in the world-system. Maoist China saw recoveries only for them to regress following Deng Xiaoping’s privatization of the health system and other capitalist reforms. Progress began again in 2004 as the state reintroduced these public provisioning measures again.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>This brief exercise into looking at data of three indicators across five regions of the world since the rise of capitalism has revealed that the dominant narrative of extreme poverty being a natural condition that can only be solved through capitalist measures is blatantly wrong. Data from all regions shows that real wages were higher than the extreme poverty line. Instead, extreme poverty is instead, often a result of processes of dislocation, carried out through colonial conquests, expropriation, war, and state repression. Capitalism has, in fact, resulted in declining levels of human stature and rising mortality in all of the regions discussed here.</p><p>Therefore, Pinker’s graph becomes more concerning, for it is a fabrication. It should be a sign of severe worry that despite instances of progress (albeit short-lived) from the middle of the 20th century, such levels of extreme poverty and dislocation are still prevalent under capitalism. Moreover, as we have seen, it is not capitalism, but labour, trade, anti-colonial, feminist, and democratic movements who have delivered tangible goals in the perusal of human welfare. Authors like Steven Pinker should take a closer look at the data they derive their ‘research’ from, since their narrative of capitalism as saviour of humanity is incorrect.</p><p>It has also become clear that human communities are inherently capable of taking care of themselves by producing enough to meet their own basic needs. Exceptions only arise with natural disasters and conditions where people are denied access to their land or when their labour is appropriated under less-than-ideal conditions. This is what capitalism is: a massacre of the freedom of people. It is an absolute undemocratic system where decisions are controlled through monopolistic structures to be imposed and implemented on the masses. Capitalism does not function to meet human needs but to accumulate profit through the expropriation of labour and sources, leading to destructions on massive scales. These conditions can only be eliminated through a recognition that any relevant gains in human welfare were only achieved through radical social movements, instead of capitalism as Pinker argues incorrectly. These movements argue for better production organized around human needs, access to public healthcare, distribution of wealth and resources, and public provisioning systems for basic needs such as food and housing.</p><p>References</p><p>Ravallion, M. (2016). <em>The Economics of Poverty: History, Measurement, and Policy.</em> Oxford University Press.</p><p>Sullivan, D., &amp; Hickel, J. (2023). Capitalism and Extreme Poverty: A Global Analysis of Real Wages, Human Height and Mortality Since the Long 16th Century. <em>World Development</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4f8625aaa24a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Essay on Oppressive Education]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@osaid.syed/an-essay-on-oppressive-education-6a615cc341b7?source=rss-8b5a7a96b8f4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6a615cc341b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics-and-protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolution]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Osaid ul Hasan Syed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Jan 2022 10:01:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-23T10:01:06.022Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have been giving private tuitions for the past four years while completing my undergraduate studies. Therefore, after graduation, I decided to become a teacher. Harboring a positive reputation, I got in touch with my old school from where I had completed my O-Level education. To judge my teaching capabilities, I was asked to give a demo, which I did, and was able to get the job as a physics teacher. To my surprise, I discovered that the school was not offering subjects such as philosophy and psychology to both O and A-Level students. Upon inquiring, the response by the principal was typical; not a lot of students (and by extension, their parents) want to be educated in these subjects because you cannot do much with such an education, and as such, there is also a shortage of teachers who excel in said subjects.</p><p>While this was worrying, I continued teaching physics, and yet, it soon dawned upon me that the problem with the whole educational system goes beyond the mere question of the ‘scope’ of a particular field or subject. I first noticed it in the way class periods, lunch, and off times were scheduled in rigid units of an hour, the starts of which were signaled using a large bell. Rather like the scheduling of shifts for laborers in a factory, the children are being conditioned to rigidify and excruciatingly sort their whole learning process. Pretty soon, I was asked to attend a meeting of the teaching staff where the topic of discussion was how best to penalize students who are seen to be violating some aspect of the school uniform (a missing tie, for example) and those who carry a mobile phone. There was a talk given by one of the old teachers on how to best control the ills of fashion in students. One suggestion that received wide approval was to cut off any fashionable hairdos.</p><p>Horrified by this, I presented arguments to the contrary, trying my best to explain that a uniform does not mean discipline, but rather a consistency in one’s morals and ethics does, but it fell on deaf ears. Instead, it was pointed out to me that it is necessary to control the students and establish an authoritative relationship with them. Being asked to be oppressive to students and their emerging identities, I quit. Upon much reflection and research, I was finally able to put into exact words my feelings and observations about the educational system.</p><p>George Ritzer (Ritzer, pp. 19–22) talks about the McDonaldization of society in his work, the analogy being that society has come to closely resemble the characteristics of a fast-food restaurant. This is indicative of the educational system too, where the goal has become to mechanize everything. In trying to create more efficient systems, assessments are now computerized, and there are multiple ways to grade a piece of work, each trying to objectify and measure. This breeds unnecessary competition. There is also a sense of predictability paramount in the way that everything falls under a carefully regimented routine. These three aspects, namely, efficiency, quantification, and predictability, are ultimately reductionist and give rise to the notion of control. The student is considered a product, rather than a human. This dehumanization is closely linked to that of the worker in the factory, who is mechanically reduced to performing one task, and the notion of his humanity is squashed. In the way that educators, whether knowingly or not, instill and use these principles, they have ceased to be educators, but have instead become bureaucrats. The whole approach of bureaucracy seeks to simplify and codify. David Graeber (Graeber, p. 16) talks about how government, corporate, and educational bureaucracies have fused, and in doing so, have created a system that objectifies with no regard for the subjective. Perhaps, therefore we see students rebelling in the only way they can: how they look, what they do on their phones, and how they speak. But this is merely a vain attempt, a useless fight between the simplification of bureaucracy and the subjectivism of postmodern culture.</p><p>A point of note stems from another personal experience. During the second semester of my undergraduate degree, a female friend expressed her anguish and frustration at not being able to do anything about a particularly sexist and harassing professor, apart from the bureaucratic procedure of a feedback form that ultimately does nothing and is a non-engaging process. There is something profound at play here. In trying to objectify such important issues, the subjective experience of the individual has taken a hit. Oppression has thus seeped through the very structures designed to fight it. The whole teacher-student dynamic exists in a dichotomy where both parties firmly stay at the poles of the relationship.</p><p>This has given rise to what Paulo Freire (Freire, p. 72) calls the banking concept of education, the analogy being that the teacher deposits, while the student receives. There is no input from the students. They are merely taught by teachers who are seen as beacons of all knowledge and are hence unable to be taught by the students at all. The teacher decides what is to be taught. Students are supposed to listen and be disciplined while the teacher talks and disciplines. This dichotomy has reduced students to mere objects. Ultimately, what has happened is the establishment of an oppressor-oppressed dynamic created by the extremely antidialogical action between the teachers and the students. The creative power of the students is thus killed.</p><p>Putting this into a broader context, we can see how oppressive education is a tool used extensively by the elite class to subjugate and dominate the masses. Man is to be managed. He must not think for himself and therefore, he must be dehumanized. Only when he is dehumanized can he, therefore, be dominated. The oppressor class utilizes a few tactics and methodologies to perpetuate this system of oppressive education, the foremost of which is conquest. The oppressor always seeks to conquer (Freire, pp. 138–141), and he does it by choosing to never engage in dialogical action. He must destroy the notion of the oppressed that they too are considerers of the world, that they exist to take part in the world and are not ahistorical as animals. A mythicization of the world thus follows. Leo Tolstoy in his book The Slavery of Times talks about the two major myths of human civilization. In the first, religion and the view of a God is utilized to explain why some men (slaves) are not equal to others (their masters). According to Tolstoy, once that failed with the slave class eventually realizing their domination and hence liberating themselves, a new explanation was needed and was provided hastily by the science/pseudoscience of economics and political economy. He criticizes the notion of using numbers and various ‘economic’ measures to not only justify a division of people into various classes but then use those measures to show and glorify the progress made (Tolstoy, pp. 17–18). Such measures include per capita income and gross domestic products (GDPs). While these are measures of modernization, they do not represent development. How can there be development when a majority is dehumanized and play no role in the active transformation of society in accordance with their own beings?</p><p>The oppressor class always fears the unification of the people since it poses a considerable threat to the domination established by them. Therefore, it must divide and rule (Freire, pp. 141–147). I have talked about this approach before in the essay, where the focus is to provide an extremely focalized view of the world. Issues are taken apart from their context and not seen in their totality. In my own country, this has been visible through the constant rife that exists between the Sunni and Shia religious communities (the two dominant Islamic sects). The tactic can also be seen in the so-called leadership training courses that have become so common, the very premise of which is troubling. In training and thereby promoting such leaders, the assumption is this: that it is a small portion that is to be promoted and which must carry the promotion of the whole. Again, we see that the whole referred to is not itself taken into consideration, leaving most of the people alienated. The oppressors continually manipulate the masses (Freire, pp. 147–152). Think about how separate the urban and rural populations have become from each other. The urban middle-class has come to naturally think of themselves as being more educated and more aware than the rural class, which thinks of itself as uneducated, never realizing it is the antidialogical action of the oppressive class which has perpetuated this myth into their conscious. Another manipulative tactic used is false generosity. Charity only exists in negation to poverty. The oppressor must be seen to be charitable if he is to be unjust. An unjust social order is thus supported by this false generosity of the oppressor. Perhaps a clearer way to see this is in the countless charitable foundations of the rich elite, who continue to exploit workers in their factories while they present themselves as human by appearing to be generous to the masses.</p><p>In the utilization of such tactics, the goal of the oppressor class is domination and through this domination comes cultural invasion (Freire, pp. 152–157). Cultural invasion is both a methodology and the result of domination. Through it, the oppressor class imposes its world view on the oppressed, disrespecting the various cultural contexts and in total disregard of the potential of the oppressed. It is thus a form of violence through which the invaded are molded into the shape of the invaders. To do this, the oppressors must know how those who are to be invaded perceive their reality. Therefore, they have come to utilize both the social and physical sciences as well as technology to improve their antidialogical action upon the oppressed. It is through this impression to understand that the oppressor may appear to be a friend and even generous. But it is ultimately an illusion. Through this invasion, the oppressed internalize and begin to perceive themselves as objectively inferior. The institutions and social structures of today have become agents of this invasion. From the household where paternal authority takes hold to the educational institutions where a teacher dominance takes hold, and from the countless bureaucratic procedures which fail to see things in both their focality and totality, to the myths of pseudoscience and consumerism representing a false view of humanization, oppressive action has corrupted the very minds of the people to even fear their own freedom and liberation.</p><p>In this essay, through my personal experiences and research, I have tried to present an overview of oppressive education and how it has come to shape our lives and to define our humanity in an ultimately dehumanizing way. The attentive reader will have noticed that the solution lies in the negation of the word ‘antidialogical’. It is through dialogical action that we must start the long process of liberation. Those aware of Paulo Freire’s work will be familiar with this. However, I do not mean to expand upon the theory and methodologies of dialogical action in this essay, for I believe it warrants a separate essay altogether. I hope that through my writing I have been successful in giving words to those like me who have long felt something to be terribly wrong with the world and the educational system in particular but have not found the descriptive language to express themselves.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. Ritzer, G. (1993). <em>The McDonaldization of Society.</em></p><p>2. Graeber, D. (2005). <em>The Utopia of Rules: On Technology, Stupididty, and the Secret Joys of Bureaucracy.</em></p><p>3. Freire, P. (1968). <em>Pedagogy of the Oppressed.</em></p><p>4. Tolstoy, L. (1900). <em>The Slavery of Our Times.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6a615cc341b7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>