<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Paul Fox on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Paul Fox on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ozpaulfox?source=rss-7c7c1ab74b5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 03:09:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ozpaulfox/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SEC Chair is right. We need a new class of regulated fundraising for crypto.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ozpaulfox/sec-chair-is-right-we-need-a-new-class-of-regulated-fundraising-for-crypto-b47e8fc2cad7?source=rss-7c7c1ab74b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b47e8fc2cad7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Fox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Mar 2019 02:52:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-15T03:23:14.703Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Nobel prize winner Elinor Ostrom points the way to using Consumer Tokens to manage the commons or public goods.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Y7RybpPgYc7wgtQ9jLvOdQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>US SEC Chair Jay Clayton <a href="https://coincenter.org/link/sec-chairman-clayton-just-confirmed-commission-staff-analysis-that-ethereum-and-cryptos-like-it-are-not-securities">recently reaffirmed</a> previous SEC analysis that decentralisation of a digital asset may change its nature so that it no longer represents an investment contract. We’d like to take that a step further.</p><p>My purpose is to call for a special class of corporation and associated regulated fundraising used to bootstrap the creation of a commons, public good or non-profit.</p><p>In these applications a network of users, providers and facilitators eventually decentralises and value accrues to participants rather than a central entity. At the same time, we must acknowledge that bootstrapping a network requires risk capital, risk labour and risk data. The early contributors are taking a risk of loss in expectation of a return, even if they are simply pre-purchasing a good. Therefore we need sufficient level of transparency and accountability from the beginning. In the longer-term, liquidity is essential to the effective operation of network incentives, while preventing illicit activity, so AML/KYC must be applied. At some point the network crosses a threshold away from private ownership and becomes community managed.</p><p>As the SEC has found, these applications are <em>hybrid</em> in nature and clearly differentiated from assumptions of private ownership underlying the regulation of financial products and securities.</p><p>While there has been an explosion in innovation, these applications are complex, immature and rapidly developing space. We do not have definitive answers as to how they might develop or be regulated. However, as described below, such applications may unleash considerable social and economic benefit and are therefore worthy of favourable legal and tax treatment.</p><p>This post is based on a submission I made to the <a href="https://treasury.gov.au/consultation/c2019-t353604/">Australian Treasury consultation</a> on initial coin offerings.</p><h3>Narrowing the Scope to Consumer Tokens</h3><p>To narrow the scope of discussion, I have adopted the <a href="https://www.gdf.io/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/0003_GDF_Taxonomy-for-Cryptographic-Assets_Web-151018.pdf">GDF Taxonomy for Cryptographic Assets</a> published by the Global Digital Finance project. The taxonomy is quite similar to that used by Switzerland, the Brooklyn Project and others. According to GDF, the three main categories are:</p><ul><li>Payment Tokens: “Tokens whose intrinsic features are designed to serve as a general purpose store of value, medium of exchange, and/or unit of account.” Often called cryptocurrencies.</li><li>Financial Asset Tokens: “Tokens whose intrinsic features are designed to serve as or represent financial assets such as financial instruments and securities.”. Often called Securities Token Offerings or STO.</li><li>Consumer Tokens: “Tokens that are inherently consumptive in nature, because their intrinsic features are designed to serve as, or provide access to, a particular set of goods, services or content.” These can be further subdivided into Ownership, Coupon Rights and Activity Rights (including a reward or license). Often called utility tokens.</li></ul><p>In this discussion I will not address Payment Tokens and Financial Asset Tokens. While these applications are worthy, we believe they are broadly supported by current regulation with some tweaks.</p><p>The following discussion will focus on a subset of Consumer Tokens which, when combined with well designed crypto-economic incentives, enable new decentralised organisational structures (e.g. a digital autonomous organisation or DAO) and new ways to manage the commons or public goods. As such, their applications and opportunities lie well outside what could be achieved with conventional for-profit financial products or securities.</p><p>A question for further research is whether an additional dimension to the taxonomy is required to support Consumer Tokens used to enable a commons, public good or non-profit. For example the degree of decentralisation, mode of governance or distribution of earned value could be important factors. Perhaps part of the definition could be based on an understanding of the “good” enabled by the token, regardless of the ability to privately own the token. That is, can the current form of the good be defined as non-rivalrous or non-excludable? To whom the benefits accrue in a steady state of the network? How do we know the network is decentralised rather than proprietary?</p><p>While this post supports the concept of consumer tokens or utility tokens, we recognise that many of the projects in the ICO boom of 2018 were of questionable economics and utility. In some cases, the proposed native token could have been replaced with a payment token (e.g. Bitcoin or Ethereum) or even with a conventional fiat currency, without any impact on the utility of the network. Moreover, many of the projects were not attempting to enable decentralised governance of a commons or public good. We also acknowledge there were many failures in transparency and investor protection driven by naivete, inexperience and opportunism, and in some cases outright fraud. This history serves to underline the need for appropriate regulation to create investment confidence and protect retail investors. Although arguably, many of the “investors” in the 2018 ICO boom were speculators rather than investors and showed scant regard for due diligence or risk management.</p><h3>Tragedy of the Commons</h3><p>The tragedy of the commons, public goods and natural monopolies are well known economic problems. The “Tragedy of the Commons” was coined by Garrett Hardin in 1968. He described how individuals, acting independently according to their self-interest, can accidentally destroy a shared resource. Together, economists, policy makers and engineers have designed tools to mitigate the costs. For example, land tenure (essentially privatisation) solved overgrazing of commons. Regulated returns were enforced for utilities with natural monopolies. Set-top boxes helped pay to launch TV satellites. Toll-gates enable road funding. Buying groups enable neighbourhood grocers to compete with retail giants. Typically the solution has been some combination of private ownership and central regulation.</p><p>However, despite centuries of such policy intervention, modern markets still demonstrate one or more of the “Big 4” market failures:</p><ol><li>Concentration of market power, i.e. an oligopoly of giant players or regulatory capture by natural monopolists.</li><li>Failure to provide public goods e.g. poor system reliability and resilience, congestion, or limited access for vulnerable communities.</li><li>Externalities from exploitation of commons, e.g. environmental (i.e. air, water, climate) or social, e.g. free riding by corporations and underpayment of software developers contributing to open source software projects.</li><li>Asymmetry of information, i.e. volume and price data, aggregation of consumer data.</li></ol><h3>Cryptographic Networks to the Rescue</h3><p>Clearly private ownership and central regulation have not always worked. But there are commons and public goods that have worked without either private ownership or central regulation. There is an open source peer to peer payments system that has been operating for 10 years with no central owner, no single point of failure, and no central regulator. The community using this system are inherently motivated to improve the usability, security, and reliability, and therefore grow the size of the community and value of network. That network is called “Bitcoin”.</p><p>Wild and futuristic? Perhaps not. Elinor Ostrom (1933–2012), winner of the 2009 Nobel Prize for Economics studied how communities managed common pool resources in Switzerland, Kenya, Guatemala, Nepal, Turkey and Los Angeles. Some of these systems dated back hundreds, if not thousands of years. She identified eight design principles:</p><ol><li>Define clear pool and group boundaries.</li><li>Match rules governing use of common goods to local needs.</li><li>Ensure those affected by rules can participate in modifying rules.</li><li>Devise community based monitoring system.</li><li>Use graduated sanctions for rule violators.</li><li>Provide accessible low-cost means for dispute resolution.</li><li>Make sure rule-making rights of community respected by authorities.</li><li>Build tiers of governance of commons from local to global level.</li></ol><p>At a national level these governance principles are analogous to Citizenship, Law, Democracy, Enforcement, Penal System, Courts, Sovereignty, and Federalism.</p><p>However, until recently, these principles for managing commons were not viable at scale, essentially limited to the size of a workable human community (e.g. Dunbar’s number), geography, or the speed of transactions within that community.</p><p>Enabled by blockchain, we’re now seeing experimentation all over the world and the promise of a revolution in human organisation potentially equal to that of the blossoming of the joint-stock company 500 years ago.</p><h3>Bootstrapping a New Model needs Risk Capital, Risk Labour and Risk Data</h3><p>Prototype organisations such as Bitcoin, Ethereum and other aspiring projects demonstrate that Ostrom’s principles can be applied at global scale between people that cannot know each other personally, thus creating a new tool for managing markets, public goods and the commons.</p><p>The challenge is how to bootstrap such a network? Creating a new network requires capital, labour and data. However there is a strong risk that the network will not reach scale, resulting in insufficient returns on those resources. In the case of a for-profit enterprise, angel investors or venture capitalists may provide risk capital in return for equity. However, a return to equity or debt may not be applicable to a decentralised commons, public good or non-profit enterprise.</p><p>Pre-selling a consumer token economically tied to the network is one way to raise capital for such a venture. The community of innovators have spent a lot of time trying to convince ourselves and others that such token sales are not a securities offering. Moreover, jurisdictions such as Malta, Switzerland and Wyoming have made made changes that recognise the special nature of Consumer Tokens.</p><p>However, we argue that criteria such as “not marketed as investments” embodied in these new laws does not recognise that some expectation of economic return on the part of buyers and contributors is required to bootstrap a risky network, even if the ultimate form of the network is a commons. There is a risk that such criteria will create continued uncertainty for honest projects. We cannot shy away from the reality that there are aspects which are securities-like, while we try to define this new decentralised model.</p><p>Clearly the early buyers are taking a risk, and they are also anticipating an economic return, either through access to the network or through appreciation of the token value. While the long-term objective is a decentralised non-profit with no private ownership, the initial sale of tokens does have risks similar to a securities offering.</p><p>Moreover, trading and some speculation would be essential to enable liquidity of tokens and the operation of incentives in a network. However, speculative trading of tokens (or of conventional equity shares) is generally very damaging to early stage projects that have yet to find product-market fit or established cash positive economics. Moreover, secondary markets without adequate regulation can create incentives for poor behaviour such as “pump and dump” or “deep discount and dump” schemes. We believe lock-ups for founding teams and early investors are good practice and promote long-term investing rather than speculation. That said, a degree of speculation is useful to create liquidity in any market.</p><p>There is a clear need to protect token buyers and ensure confidence through fair, efficient and transparent markets. Also clear is the hybrid nature of the tokens. The design of regulation is further complicated by uncertainty over when such a venture makes the <em>transition</em> from the initial securities-like state to a real commons.</p><p>William Hinman of the SEC has <a href="https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/speech-hinman-061418">spoken on some of these challenges</a> in the US context. The recent legislation in Wyoming also implies a recognition of the difference from a conventional securities offering.</p><h3>A Special Class of Corporation and Fundraising</h3><p>We argue that token sales focussed on creating a new commons or a managed public good should receive special consideration, and perhaps even separate categorisation, on the following basis:</p><ul><li>Potential for solutions for market failures and inefficiencies in many conventional markets dominated by private ownership or regulation.</li><li>Ability to fund commons, public goods and non-profits, which is clearly differentiated from assumptions of private ownership implied by financial products or securities.</li><li>Promotion of finance for public benefits, which already gets favourable treatment in many jurisdictions e.g. taxation of local government bonds.</li><li>Promotion of risk capital, innovation and technology ecosystem, especially in regions remote from tech centres like Silicon Valley, e.g. similar to the favourable tax treatment of early stage venture capital limited partnerships (ESVCLP) or treatment of mineral prospecting using NL structure.</li><li>Ability to enable long-tail capital formation for such projects from international token buyers, rather than being limited to a small local market.</li><li>The inherent transparency and traceability of blockchain technology can actually enable simplified and more effective regulation.</li></ul><p>How can we enable such projects while holding the proponents accountable for achieving the decentralised state? One concept could be the creation of a special form of corporation for such projects, distinct from a limited liability company, partnership or trust. Jurisdictions have previously used unique corporate forms to stimulate important industries, e.g. the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_liability">No Liability</a> company structure created by Australian states in the mid to late 19th century to foster the mining industry*. Such a corporation could be eligible for special legal or tax treatment but have restrictions on converting to a for-profit status. The corporation could potentially be time boxed or “self destructing” life may be a useful may to enforce intent from the beginning.</p><p>In return for such restrictions, and subject to adequate AML/KYC, lock-ups, transparency and continuous disclosure (perhaps similar to current regulation crowdfunding) the entity could have higher and more flexible fundraising caps (We believe regulation crowdfunding caps in most jurisdictions are too low to adequately fund a company taking technical risk).</p><p>The special corporate structure could also enable tax certainty, perhaps even concessional tax treatment in recognition of the societal benefits. Current tax treatment of token sales tends to skew the structuring and behaviour of the participants. Could the proceeds be treated as a donation, grant or loan with certain rights? Could any tax liability be deferred or perhaps even eliminated at the issuer and treated as a form of capital gain in the hands of the token holders (which would also capture profits by members of the founding team and partners). For token holders, could personal use of the tokens be treated as currency, trading as regular income, and bulk sales from the ICO as a capital gain?</p><p>Eligibility for special treatment would need to be tested or applied at the time of issue, at the time of “transition” to a decentralised non-privately owned status, and/or at the time of “exit” or sale by a buyer, be that before or after the point of “transition”. However, having a special form of corporation could simplify the assessment.</p><p>We have no illusions as to the challenges of defining the criteria, proving eligibility at issue, then dealing with changes in plan prior to exit (i.e. the inevitable pivot beloved by startups). However, we see evidence of market failures in the commons and public goods all around us. The tragedy of the commons has become the biggest existential risk to humanity in terms of climate, water and economic access. The benefits of enabling this innovation far outweigh the risks.</p><p>Note: Shout out to Brenda Saveluc for bringing the No Liability Company to my attention. Thanks to ADCA for pointing out that blockchain could actually be easier to regulate due to inherent transparency. Thanks also to Enosi and Sydney Blockchain Professionals communities for comments on original draft.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b47e8fc2cad7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[One Belt, One Road, One Blockchain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ozpaulfox/on-belt-one-road-one-blockchain-9e5dd36219c4?source=rss-7c7c1ab74b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e5dd36219c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[geopolitics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[one-belt-one-road]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Fox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Oct 2018 22:09:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-22T10:58:21.359Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>China is bringing blockchain to the mainstream via the developing world. The Chinese “tech-fins” are leveraging massive user bases into real world use cases. They are de-banking global supply chains, unlocking growth and may ultimately change the global order. Are we ready?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pFKkSBLzQEeTF5bjtRCz7Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Craig Dunn, Chair of TC 307 addresses Wanxiang 4th Global Blockchain Summit in Shanghai</figcaption></figure><p>In September 2018, a delegation of Australian businesses active in blockchain technology participated in the 2018 Australian Blockchain Mission to Shanghai jointly led by the Australian Trade and Investment Commission (Austrade) and the Australian Digital Commerce Association (ADCA).</p><p>In addition to joining over 2,000 attendees at the prestigious 4th Annual Wanxiang Global Blockchain Summit, participants had the opportunity to receive briefings from officials, leading corporations and local startups. See <a href="https://www.afr.com/technology/china-and-australia-deepen-blockchain-links-20180905-h14ycd">China and Australia deepen blockchain links</a> (AFR, 10 Sep 2018) for more background. We heard from industry leaders, such as Vitalik Buterin, Jae Kown, Jihan Wu and David Chaum. Speakers from Australia included Craig Dunn from Standards Australia (Chair of ISO Technical Committee 307 on blockchain standards) and Sophie Gilder from the Commonwealth Bank.</p><p>Last year (during the 2017 Austrade Mission) the Chinese government cracked down on illicit token sales and the same time this year tightened restrictions on trading. However, it would be a mistake to think China is missing the wave of blockchain innovation.</p><p>We argue that Chinese technology companies are actually leading the world in the development of blockchain and, due to the inherent advantages described below, will reshape the world economy.</p><p>This post will assume a working knowledge of blockchain technology and its applications. Briefly, blockchain technology uses a shared ledger where multiple distrustful parties can record transactions between them in a secure, verifiable and irreversible way. It enables digital value transfer by achieving consensus between parties, preventing copying or double spend, and preventing censorship of transactions. Blockchain enables new ways to create markets and organise human behaviour, including the removal or minimisation of central authorities, intermediaries and overhead functions. Blockchain may even “de-bank” global flows of capital, physical trade and payments because for many transactions “trusted intermediaries” are no longer required.</p><p>In Shanghai this year the overall mood of the blockchain community was very positive and many believed that the government will accomodate token sales once the appropriate regulatory model has been devised. The Chinese government has made the development of blockchain technology a priority, as described in <a href="https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2018/07/19/is-china-leading-the-blockchain-innovation-race/">Is China leading the blockchain innovation race</a> by the Brookings Institute. The official stance is “blockchain without the token”, although that is not for lack of understanding of the organisational and economic potential of tokens. For example, Lihui Li, former President of the state-owned Bank of China and now head of the Blockchain Research Working Group at China’s National Internet Finance Association (sponsored by the central People’s Bank of China) demonstrated a nuanced grasp of the fundamentals and implications of cryptoeconomics and public chains during his keynote at the Wanxiang Summit.</p><p>In the commercial world, well known blockchain players include Alibaba (including their Ant Financial spin-out of Alipay fame) Tencent (owner of WeBank and WeChat pay), search giant Baidu and ecommerce juggernaut JD.com. Less well known to western ears are Dianrong, Gingkoo, Le.com, Ping’An, Wanda, Wanxiang, and ZhongAn.</p><p>Many of these companies look like conglomerates, with interests including online lending, insurance, property, automotive parts, health even movies and sports teams. With underlying strengths in financial products, they may sometimes seem like Western “fin-techs” but unlike typical fin-techs, they have massive scale. Unlike western corporates they are technology native from the CEO down, span multiple industry verticals, and retain enviable agility in the marketplace. These companies are already “de-banking” their industries. We are going to refer to them as “tech-fins” in this article.</p><p>Chinese entrepreneurs are also well represented among serious blockchain startups, including Loopring, Matrix, Nebulas, NEO, Nervos and VeChain. However, in this post we will focus on the aforementioned Chinese “tech-fins”.</p><p>Using mobile devices and QR codes, the tech-fins have leap frogged conventional payments and banking systems. Ant Financial serves 870 million customers and has now joined the global top 10 financial services companies with a market cap of $150B. They have used agility and technology to deliver services across city and rural areas alike at unparalleled scale and low cost. PingAn has 1.7M employees serving 1 in 8 people in China. Having honed their capability in China, the tech-fins are now expanding into India, Thailand, Phillipines, Korea, Indonesia and Malaysia.</p><p>The Chinese government encourages this expansion through the Belt and Road Initiative, a development strategy focused on connectivity and cooperation between Eurasian countries along a land-based Silk Road Economic Belt (through Central Asia to Europe) and a Maritime Silk Road (though South East Asia, India, Africa, the Middle East to the Mediterranean). While the initial focus has been on infrastructure, there are also financial, cultural and research components.</p><p>At home, the tech-fins are investing billions (USD $1.5B in case of Ping’An) in the technological pillars of artificial intelligence, internet of things, data analytics, cloud computing and blockchain. Specifically in blockchain, the companies we met described multiple projects in cross border payments, health, charity, electronics manufacturing, automotive, agriculture and real estate. We heard how one CEO demanded that his executives personally nominate blockchain applications.</p><p>These are not mere proof of concepts or pilots. For example, 27,000 small business are connected to a lending blockchain, while 9.9 million transactions have been processed for 300 projects on a charity blockchain. Not only is the scale impressive, but the speed and decisiveness implied by such scale.</p><p>Mirroring Amazon and Google’s cloud services, Chinese tech-fins such as Ant Financial, Dianrong, HNA, Ping’An, Wanda, Wanxiang and WeBank are expanding beyond their core business and also offering blockchain as a service (BaaS). For example, Ping’An has <a href="http://fintechnews.hk/5926/blockchain/hong-kong-monetary-authority-unveils-blockchain-trade-finance-platform/">built a trade finance platform for the Hong Kong Monetary Authority</a> which will link 21 banks. While this appears to bring the tech-fins into direct competition with integrators like IBM, Microsoft, PwC, or Deloitte, their <a href="https://www.marketwatch.com/press-release/ping-an-unveils-ai-technology-at-international-maritime-silk-road-forum-2018-09-24">motivations</a> appear to be driven more by expanding their trade ecosystem along the Belt and Road than generating software or professional services revenues.</p><p>But are these just enterprise chains? Merely a cost-cutting effort by an existing oligopoly to mutualize processes and costs around the back office? We would argue that “blockchain without the coin” does not realise the true disruptive power of cryptoeconomics. However, it does not take much imagination to see the future. For example, DianRong and Foxconn have worked together to create the TAP (Trusted Account Payable). The TAP is generated by Foxconn and flows down through the supply chain. Small businesses in the supply chain can either hold, finance or pass the fractionalised TAP to the next level below in the chain. Small business are thus able to prove their AP and access finance based on Foxconn’s credit worthiness. It would be easy to imagine a digital asset like the TAP being freely traded and perhaps sold on secondary markets, with massive implications for financial services. Moreover, a set of smart contracts built on top of the TAPS could be used to create economic incentives for participants to improve network performance for the common good.</p><p>In summary, the Chinese tech-fins have real deployments in well defined use cases in multiple verticals across significant user bases. This provides a significant advantage because, assuming a solid use case, the quality of a software solution is a function of user centricity, number of users, and time spent iterating product with users. Moreover, the finding effective solutions to blockchain’s significant technical challenges requires time, engineering talent and (again) real life use cases. Intellectual property, not necessarily formally registered, will arise from amassed data and the rapid learning loops. The tech-fins are likely to be well ahead of many western startups scrabbling to build a user base and even corporate consortiums running pilots at a slower pace and smaller scale.</p><p>China has leapfrogged conventional payments and banking systems. They have moved from serving the “un-banked” of China to “de-banking” conventional industries and supply chains. These capabilities can be naturally extended to the developing economies traversed by the Belt and Road. By “giving away” infrastructural blockchain software and deploying TAP-like tokens the tech-fins may create a lock-in effect and displace traditional trade financiers. They may also displace traditional trade currencies like the US dollar.</p><p>So, while news analysis has focused on the combination of government soft power and traditional infrastructure finance along the Belt and Road, perhaps blockchain technology will play a powerful role, one which also reshapes the role of financial institutions and even trade currencies.</p><p>So what should Australian governments, policy makers and businesses do to adapt? Clearly our foreign policy and economic experts should consider the influence of blockchain on trade flows, and therefore the economic and geopolitical implications. Given Australia’s dependence on financial services and export trade, we should both (1) position Australia to take advantage of China’s blockchain enabled trade along the Belt and Road, and (2) encourage our financial services industry to adapt to disintermediation and “de-banking” caused by blockchain.</p><p>While adaptation is important, how can we join forces to create value? What does Australia bring to the relationship? While Australia has definite strengths in blockchain R&amp;D, standards, governance and entrepreneurship (including areas of interest to China such as supply chain and food safety), one particular strength could be Australia’s <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/how-australia-is-becoming-a-cryptocurrency-continent-markets-regulations-and-plans">thoughtful approach to treatment of digital assets</a>. China’s sheer size creates regulatory enforcement challenges, necessitating aggressive action such as the recent bans. Australia could provide a friendly regulatory environment, an outlet for Chinese IP and capital, in turn stimulating the development of Australian IP and capital. For example, Australia could enable the bootstrapping of token networks through simplified disclosure, a security safe harbour, and beneficial tax treatment of token sale proceeds.</p><p>However, there is only a narrow window where China’s regulatory focus on “blockchain without the token” creates such an opportunity. Now is a good time for Australia industry, government and regulators to capitalise on the foundation created over the past two years through the efforts of the ADCA, Austrade and Standards Australia. The blockchain has left the station on the Belt and Road, Australia need to jump on board before it clears the platform.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e5dd36219c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[4 rules for your career in the 21st Century]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ozpaulfox/4-rules-for-your-career-in-the-21st-century-b1f2852779ea?source=rss-7c7c1ab74b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1f2852779ea</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[commencement-speech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[commencement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[career-advice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[graduation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[engineering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Fox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Jun 2018 10:07:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-18T07:38:52.208Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Commencement speech for UNSW School of Engineering Graduation, 12 June 2018</h4><p>On 12 June 2018 the most recent class from the School of Engineering at the University of New South Wales graduated and began their careers. I was honoured to be invited by the Dean, Professor Mark Hoffman, to give the Occasional Address at the Graduation Ceremony, presided over by Professor Geoffrey Crisp, UNSW Pro-Vice Chancellor (Education).</p><p>I’ve never been so nervous about getting a speech right, since it is a big day for the graduates. As an engineer I wanted to strike the right balance between inspiration and practical advice. Luckily, I was able to find some useful examples on the web. Hopefully someone will find this post usefeul too. Here is a link to the video of the entire ceremony (my speech around 58:00) and a transcript below.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Flivestream.com%2Faccounts%2F11251721%2Fevents%2F8194250%2Fplayer%3Fhide_external_links%3Dtrue%26autoPlay%3Dfalse%26enableInfoAndActivity%3Dfalse&amp;src_secure=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Flivestream.com%2FGraduationUniversity%2F2pm12June2018&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fimg.new.livestream.com%2Fevents%2F00000000007d08ca%2Fb583c807-f79e-4127-b3ba-2b8e4ded11b2.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=livestream" width="640" height="360" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d8890962c85723c05ee92f39a1a81b03/href">https://medium.com/media/d8890962c85723c05ee92f39a1a81b03/href</a></iframe><p>Good afternoon. It’s a great day, isn’t it?</p><p>Thank you Professor Crisp and Professor Hoffman for inviting me today. I’m honoured to be here on a very special day for the graduates. Thanks to the Faculty and staff of the University. Thanks to the families and friends – you must be very relieved.</p><p>And finally thank you, the Graduates, for it is all about you today, and really I’m here to talk to you.</p><p>There is a script for these graduation speeches. I am traditionally required to tell you three things:</p><ul><li>Follow your dreams</li><li>Be true to yourself</li><li>Always keep learning</li></ul><p>There, I have done it. We can go and have a beer.</p><p>However, Tomorrow morning, graduates, once your head clears after all the champaagnes and beers, you will have only one thought in your head:</p><p>“I need to get a job.”</p><p>I don’t need to follow my dreams, I need to get a paying job.</p><p>I don’t need to be true to myself, I need to be true to the job advertisement</p><p>And as for “always be learning”, after all those exams and papers, that’s the last thing I want to do!</p><p>So let me give you some job hunting advice. Some job hunting advice from the future. Because I have been living in the future for the past two decades. There is a good chance your career will look more like my career than that of your parents.</p><p>The world is changing. Organisations of the future will be more decentralised and work will be more fluid. More about small teams coming together to atack particular problems and then disbanding to re-form around other needs. So you might have a career like mine, one that only makes sense if you play it backwards.</p><p>I believe this is generally a good thing because large companies and large organisations are struggling with the pace of change. We need more flexible adaptive structures and more flexible adaptive people.</p><p>Well educated people like you will thrive in this new environment, and I hope, look after those who will find it more difficult to adjust.</p><p>So how will I get a job tomorrow? Should I take the job with the biggest safest company? The most prestigious brand? Maybe a hot new start-up trying to change the world? Should I take the first job that comes along?</p><p>Let’s see if I can turn those three cliches into something actionable for you tomorrow.</p><h3>Always keep learning</h3><p>Job hunting rule #1 is “always keep learning”. That doesn’t mean go back for your masters degree.</p><p>Look at the job opportunity. Can you identify the people that are going to teach you? Your new boss or colleagues? Maybe its your customers. If you cannot see who you will be learning from, its not the job for you.</p><p>After my MBA I joined a strategy consulting firm. I made myself an apprentice to the guy I thought had the most experience and greatest integrity in the office. I stayed up drinking red wine with the grey hairs and listening to their stories. I learned a lot from those people that I have applied to this day.</p><p>Later when I was a VC there were only two of us, so I learned from my co-investors, my fellow board members and the entreprenuers themselves.</p><p>Next, surround yourself with the smartest people you can, preferably those doing the most impactful work.</p><p>In the dot.com era I persuaded my boss to send me to Silicon Valley, because thats where the most interesting things were happening. When I got there I was literally intimidated. I felt like I was the dumbest person in the room, surrounded by the rest and brightest from around the world (Something like being on this podium). But you know what? In that environment you lift your game, you learn fast and you learn to learn faster.</p><p>So that’s a great way to learn. I’ll talk about another way to learn, but I’ll connect that to “following your dreams” in a minute.</p><p>When you have stopped learning at your job then it is time for you to go.</p><h3>Be true to yourself</h3><p>Job hunting rule #2: be true to yourself. Your best self, not the self doubting self.</p><p>Find you niche, your personal super power. Will all have one. It may not be clear to you right now. Usually, you will be interested in the things you are good at, and good at the things you are interested in.</p><p>Often your clients, colleague, friends and family may know. Sometimes your failures and frustrations will give you hints. Thats certainly been the case for me.</p><p>Usually your intuition knows for sure. Does it feel right? Can you validate your intuition?</p><p>At this stage in your career, give it time. Your super powers will emerge. Those capes you wear will come into use, and your powers may change over time.</p><p>Don’t try to be the person you are not. Too often I’ve found myself aspiring to a title, like “Executive General Manager”, “CEO” or “Partner”. It has take me a long time to work it out. Do the stuff you are good at, rather than the stuff that sounds good. If the job entails more than 50% of things you consider drudgery, well then its not for you.</p><p>In the next section I’ll talk about the power of “yes” but in terms of being true, the power of “no” has been just as useful. I’ve said no to some fantastic jobs. Sometimes I have applied for them, then reconsidered later. It was not easy, but has got easier. They would have been wrong for me. I would have done a bad job and would have been perhaps richer but unhappier.</p><p>Each time, within a few months or a year, something far more exciting has come along, and the money looks after itself.</p><p>If I had taken the first job offered the I came back to Australia from Silicon Valley, I would not have had the impact or be doing the cool things I am doing now.</p><h3>Follow your dreams (reinvent them occasionally)</h3><p>Job hunting rule #3 is to “follow your dreams” – but in the 21st century you’ll need to keep reinventing your dreams.</p><p>So, onto the practicality of dreams.</p><p>Very few of us have a grand plan, and no plan survives first contact with the real world. Lets assume you don’t have a grand plan, or if you do, you don’t see how to get there.</p><p>Step 1 is find what interests you. Study it. Read everything you can. Devour every video. Go to every meetup. Find like minded people. Seek out the smartest minds.</p><p>Sounds like “always be learning”?</p><p>With knowledge and a sense of community comes passion. Soon you will start to see how you fit in (being true to yourself).</p><p>You will develop your expertise and your own brand about how you deliver that expertise.</p><p>In a sense, each time you do this, you will have re-invented yourself and reinvented your dreams.</p><p>I did this in electronics, clean energy, venture capital and now again in blockchain. Maybe I am an extreme case, but I am not special, in the early 2000s I literally saw thousands dot commers in Silicon Valley re-educate and reinvent themselves (and their dreams), though multiple economic and technology cycles.</p><p>When you learn, pursue your passions and build your brand around that, you dreams will actually come to you. They will come as opportunities.</p><p>However, as Thomas Edison said:</p><blockquote>“Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work.”</blockquote><p>You will see these opportunities. Perhaps a transfer overseas, a challenging new project, or the opportunity to join a small company with big ambition.</p><p>But like jumping into a swimming pool, you have to get out of your comfort zone to enjoy the benefits. You have to give up the certainty and security of your cozy cabana.</p><p>Jump in! Use the power of yes. Embrace the uncertainty. Don’t be afraid to fail. The 21st century is about failing often, failing fast, learning and moving on.</p><p>Put yourself in the way of opportunity, and use the power of “yes”.</p><h3>Pay it forward (and be kind)</h3><p>My final job hunting rule for the 21st century is “Pay it forward”.</p><p>Silicon Valley has a secret, its not THAT they network, it is HOW they network. The secret is called “paying it forward”.</p><p>It’s applied to business networking between friends and between strangers</p><p>Essentially, I’ll introduce you to a new contact or opportunity, with no expectation of a reciprocal action, just trusting that what goes around will come around.</p><p>Bring something to each networking encounter – something you’ve learned, an idea you want to test, something you are passionate about. Then they will remember who you are, and when that time comes, they will come back to you.</p><p>I’m not naturally outgoing. In some ways more comfortable standing here speaking to a crowd than one-on-one, but I’ve been disciplined about networking, bringing value to each exchange, and paying forward.</p><p>Through that I have developed a big network and a reputation in my chosen areas of learning. All of my work or successful ventures in the last 15 years have come from networking in a disciplined way.</p><p>So Graduates how to get a start on your network? Look around you. My first big career change and my move to Silicon Valley both came about through the recommendation of my university friends. Twice I my career I’ve helped other university friends make big career moves.</p><p>I like to add an additional to this rule, and that is simply “be kind”.</p><p>Take the time to treat people with courtesy, respect and empathy. Give of your time, no matter how inexperienced you are, it is valuable to someone. Sometimes its hard in an intense business environment, but it pays back to your career.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>In the future world of work will be more decentralised, the jobs more fluid, more varied, and I believe more satisfying.</p><p>You will need to take control of your career.</p><p>To take control you must position yourself, put yourself in the way of opportunity.</p><p>You can position yourself by following these rules:</p><ul><li>Always keep learning</li><li>Be true to yourself</li><li>Follow your dreams (reinvent them when needed).</li><li>Pay it forward (and be kind!).</li></ul><p>Hopefully these are now not just cliches, but things you could put into action tomorrow.</p><p>Tomorrow will be delivered by lots of people, engineers like you and me, working in teams, often in the background, each pushing forward in the area where we personally can make the most impact.</p><p>As engineers we will build stuff and fix stuff. We are everywhere. We’re the first to arrive, we are often the last to leave. We have a duty to lead in society.</p><p>In 30 years you will be able to look back and see all the things you have created.</p><p>You will have followed your dreams, because you put yourself in a position to let dreams find you, and you said yes when opportunity came.</p><p>As for your professors, university staff, friends and family, repay them . . . by paying it forward.</p><p>Thank you.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*BaBE431UECB-Te79Hjuy1A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: UNSW</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1f2852779ea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>