<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Padmaja Goswami on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Padmaja Goswami on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@padmaja.goswami15?source=rss-642d35ed8a77------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 21:47:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@padmaja.goswami15/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Representative institutions are so often burdened with the imperatives of money, power, and…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@padmaja.goswami15/representative-institutions-are-so-often-burdened-with-the-imperatives-of-money-power-and-b1c2f96032f4?source=rss-642d35ed8a77------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1c2f96032f4</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Padmaja Goswami]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Jun 2019 14:35:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-15T14:35:42.854Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“<em>Representative institutions are so often burdened with the imperatives of money, power, and inertia that to call their decisions democratic and in the public interest is often something of a joke”</em> — Pratap Mehta</p><p>The Indian Parliament is ‘considered’ to be the Supreme legislative body of India. It undoubtedly represents the kind of democratic politics that a handful could have imagined when universal suffrage was brought in 1951.There has, however been in recent years quite some thinking and debate about the decline of the Parliament, devaluation of parliamentary authority, falling standards of debate, deterioration in the conduct and quality of Members, poor levels of participation and the like. Opportunity and corruption have become the watch words of Indian politics.</p><p><strong>Jessica Wallack</strong> in her paper <strong>“India’s Parliament as a Representative Institution”</strong> focuses on such limitations of the Parliament while comparing it with the rest of the world. To begin with, there has been an increasing concern about the ‘criminalization of Indian politics”. This includes not only charge sheeted criminals paving way into legislative assemblies, but also a noteworthy number of MPs who are subjected to criminal elements. Around 23.2% MPs elected in 2004 had criminal cases registered against them.<em> (Kapur and Mehta</em>, <em>2006, pp 24)</em>. Also, the conduct and behavior of some MPs inside the Parliament also causes distortions in legislative proceedings thereby decreasing public confidence.</p><p>Mehta argues that Parliament has become increasingly unprofessional, passing budgets with almost no scrutiny among other signs of decline. Nineteen bills along with a constitutional amendment were passed in one day during the 9th Lok Sabha (<em>Wallack, 2008, pp 94</em>). There is also little or no funding to support a research staff in the Indian parliament unlike the parliamentary committees of Western Europe who have numerous sources to generate the required information from or to prepare bills. Excessive government control on the placement of issues in the agenda is another factor contributing to the mass critique of representation of India’s parliament.</p><p>Moving on to the duration of parliamentary deliberations, there has been a decline by about a third in the number of its sittings since 1950. A study of the time spent on different businesses during the first to the twelfth Lok Sabh unveiled that the fifth Lok Sabha recorded an average of seven hours and 38 minutes per sitting, followed by the seventh Lok Sabha, devoting an average of seven hours and nine minutes per sitting. The average time taken by adjournments and adjournment motions is approximately 10 per cent of the proceedings of a characteristic parliamentary session. The cost incurred in such adjournments is extremely high.</p><p>Another limitation is the proceedings of the Parliament without a quoram as specified by Articles 100(3) and 100(4) of the Indian Constitution. It requires that atleast one-tenth of the total members be present during decisions and deliberations. However, this has hardly been followed. In 1982, 26 out of the total 543-member house were present for the approbation of the Finance Bill (<em>Kapur and Mehta</em>, <em>2006, pp 26).</em> The parliament is also stepping down of its responsibility of providing guidance to the bureaucracy thereby leaving quite a number of substantive decisions to be taken up by the unelected members of civil service. Stalling is preferred to resolve conflict in the Parliament over debates thereby leading to delayed policies and unaccountability. “The Eleventh Lok Sabha lost 5% of its time to disruption, the Twelfth 10% and the (current) Thirteenth 22.4%.” (<em>Wallack, 2008, pp 95)</em></p><p>Moving on to the redressal part, the quality of Members is the most important variable in the working of any Parliament. It is the most important duty of every Member irrespective of his party affiliations to project and maintain a good image of the Parliament by his demeanor both inside and outside the Houses of Parliament. Also, increasing allowance for a research staff should be granted rather than mounting up finances for individual MPs ‘miscellaneous’ purposes.</p><p>The Indian legislation has often been criticized for hasty drafting and for it being rushed through Parliament in an <em>ad hoc</em> and haphazard manner. There is a need for systematic programming of laws which may be proposed for enactment over a period of time. This can be done by streamlining the functions of the Parliamentary and Legal Affairs Committee of the Cabinet, by making greater use of the Law Commission etc. Considerably more time should be devoted over discussions and deliberations pertaining to law making, amendments and the like before finalizing<strong>/</strong>passing them.</p><p>Again, the NEP should lead to cutting back on Government involvement and drastic reduction in the State’s role in the national economy. This should again get reflected in the reduced role for Parliament and its Committees. Also their processes, control mechanisms, debating and decision making procedures would have to be revamped and made faster. Floor management techniques will have to be professionalized at the level of whips, parliamentary officials and the Presiding Officers.</p><p>According to me, the Indian Parliament should begin reasserting its position as that of the body that holds the executive accountable, and not be subservient to the wishes of the executive. Perhaps, the most important step that needs to be taken is to abolish the anti-defection law. Though the basic idea of the law was to diminish the instability of governments, it has become an instrument for party bosses to determine the way MPs vote on various issues thereby stemming dissent and debate on important issues of national interest. “Relaxing the anti-defection law would allow individual Members of Parliament to balance their constituents’ interests with the party platform.” <em>(Wallack, 2008, pp 108).</em></p><p>Adoption of a ‘few’ features of the Presidential system (as also pointed by Wallack) might too work out in favor of the Indian Parliament as in such a system the President being the supreme head can take decisions effectively without interference from the ministers. Such a system would help to revamp order to our politically troubled country, reduce the corruption of the political system and hasten the pace of development through swift decision making and implementation. It also provides stable governance in the country, unlike the changes of government through political realignments and mid-term elections.</p><p>Lately, the Parliament seems to be responsive to the imperative of regaining its’ lost grounds and glory by asserting autonomy from legal encroachments. For example, in 2006, both the houses expelled nearly a dozen members cutting across party lines who were caught by a TV channel in a sting operation, accepting bribe for raising questions on the parliament floor. For democracy and freedom to continue and if representative institutions are to be made invincible and if the new economic reforms and an all round effort at liberalization are to bear fruits, it is important to refurbish the Parliament and its Members in the affections of the people.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1c2f96032f4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Indian Parliament- a representative institution?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@padmaja.goswami15/the-indian-parliament-a-representative-institution-a9c5480db641?source=rss-642d35ed8a77------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a9c5480db641</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[institutional-commitment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-parliament]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jessica-wallack]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Padmaja Goswami]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Apr 2018 11:09:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-04T11:12:11.424Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“<em>Representative institutions are so often burdened with the imperatives of money, power, and inertia that to call their decisions democratic and in the public interest is often something of a joke”</em> — Pratap Mehta</p><p>The Indian Parliament is ‘considered’ to be the Supreme legislative body of India. It undoubtedly represents the kind of democratic politics that a handful could have imagined when universal suffrage was brought in 1951.There has, however been in recent years quite some thinking and debate about the decline of the Parliament, devaluation of parliamentary authority, falling standards of debate, deterioration in the conduct and quality of Members, poor levels of participation and the like. Opportunity and corruption have become the watch words of Indian politics.</p><p><strong>Jessica Wallack</strong> in her paper <strong>“India’s Parliament as a Representative Institution”</strong> focuses on such limitations of the Parliament while comparing it with the rest of the world. To begin with, there has been an increasing concern about the ‘criminalization of Indian politics”. This includes not only charge sheeted criminals paving way into legislative assemblies, but also a noteworthy number of MPs who are subjected to criminal elements. Around 23.2% MPs elected in 2004 had criminal cases registered against them.<em> (Kapur and Mehta</em>, <em>2006, pp 24)</em>. Also, the conduct and behavior of some MPs inside the Parliament also causes distortions in legislative proceedings thereby decreasing public confidence.</p><p>Mehta argues that Parliament has become increasingly unprofessional, passing budgets with almost no scrutiny among other signs of decline. Nineteen bills along with a constitutional amendment were passed in one day during the 9th Lok Sabha (<em>Wallack, 2008, pp 94</em>). There is also little or no funding to support a research staff in the Indian parliament unlike the parliamentary committees of Western Europe who have numerous sources to generate the required information from or to prepare bills. Excessive government control on the placement of issues in the agenda is another factor contributing to the mass critique of representation of India’s parliament.</p><p>Moving on to the duration of parliamentary deliberations, there has been a decline by about a third in the number of its sittings since 1950. A study of the time spent on different businesses during the first to the twelfth Lok Sabh unveiled that the fifth Lok Sabha recorded an average of seven hours and 38 minutes per sitting, followed by the seventh Lok Sabha, devoting an average of seven hours and nine minutes per sitting. The average time taken by adjournments and adjournment motions is approximately 10 per cent of the proceedings of a characteristic parliamentary session. The cost incurred in such adjournments is extremely high.</p><p>Another limitation is the proceedings of the Parliament without a quoram as specified by Articles 100(3) and 100(4) of the Indian Constitution. It requires that atleast one-tenth of the total members be present during decisions and deliberations. However, this has hardly been followed. In 1982, 26 out of the total 543-member house were present for the approbation of the Finance Bill (<em>Kapur and Mehta</em>, <em>2006, pp 26).</em> The parliament is also stepping down of its responsibility of providing guidance to the bureaucracy thereby leaving quite a number of substantive decisions to be taken up by the unelected members of civil service. Stalling is preferred to resolve conflict in the Parliament over debates thereby leading to delayed policies and unaccountability. “The Eleventh Lok Sabha lost 5% of its time to disruption, the Twelfth 10% and the (current) Thirteenth 22.4%.” (<em>Wallack, 2008, pp 95)</em></p><p>Moving on to the redressal part, the quality of Members is the most important variable in the working of any Parliament. It is the most important duty of every Member irrespective of his party affiliations to project and maintain a good image of the Parliament by his demeanor both inside and outside the Houses of Parliament. Also, increasing allowance for a research staff should be granted rather than mounting up finances for individual MPs ‘miscellaneous’ purposes.</p><p>The Indian legislation has often been criticized for hasty drafting and for it being rushed through Parliament in an <em>ad hoc</em> and haphazard manner. There is a need for systematic programming of laws which may be proposed for enactment over a period of time. This can be done by streamlining the functions of the Parliamentary and Legal Affairs Committee of the Cabinet, by making greater use of the Law Commission etc. Considerably more time should be devoted over discussions and deliberations pertaining to law making, amendments and the like before finalizing<strong>/</strong>passing them.</p><p>Again, the NEP should lead to cutting back on Government involvement and drastic reduction in the State’s role in the national economy. This should again get reflected in the reduced role for Parliament and its Committees. Also their processes, control mechanisms, debating and decision making procedures would have to be revamped and made faster. Floor management techniques will have to be professionalized at the level of whips, parliamentary officials and the Presiding Officers.</p><p>According to me, the Indian Parliament should begin reasserting its position as that of the body that holds the executive accountable, and not be subservient to the wishes of the executive. Perhaps, the most important step that needs to be taken is to abolish the anti-defection law. Though the basic idea of the law was to diminish the instability of governments, it has become an instrument for party bosses to determine the way MPs vote on various issues thereby stemming dissent and debate on important issues of national interest. “Relaxing the anti-defection law would allow individual Members of Parliament to balance their constituents’ interests with the party platform.” <em>(Wallack, 2008, pp 108).</em></p><p>Adoption of a ‘few’ features of the Presidential system (as also pointed by Jessica Wallack) might too work out in favor of the Indian Parliament as in such a system the President being the supreme head can take decisions effectively without interference from the ministers. Such a system would help to revamp order to our politically troubled country, reduce the corruption of the political system and hasten the pace of development through swift decision making and implementation. It also provides stable governance in the country, unlike the changes of government through political realignments and mid-term elections.</p><p>Lately, the Parliament seems to be responsive to the imperative of regaining its’ lost grounds and glory by asserting autonomy from legal encroachments. For example, in 2006, both the houses expelled nearly a dozen members cutting across party lines who were caught by a TV channel in a sting operation, accepting bribe for raising questions on the parliament floor. For democracy and freedom to continue and if representative institutions are to be made invincible and if the new economic reforms and an all round effort at liberalization are to bear fruits, it is important to refurbish the Parliament and its Members in the affections of the people.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a9c5480db641" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Revisiting Jeremy Waldron: The Partisan model or the Neutral model?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@padmaja.goswami15/revisiting-jeremy-waldron-the-partisan-model-or-the-neutral-model-e44ba556e145?source=rss-642d35ed8a77------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e44ba556e145</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-legal-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeremy-waldron]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal-system]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Padmaja Goswami]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jan 2018 06:19:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-18T06:19:47.118Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Revisiting Jeremy Waldron: The Partisan model or the Neutral model?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z0kRw4FnBqm-_yx2utFfCA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The law’s legitimate function is to delineate limits within which individuals can realize their autonomy without intruding others. The job of the lawyer is to advise a client faced with an intricate legal order about where the outer edge of this autonomy lies. Not to assist the client in realizing his autonomy upto the very edge allowed by the law would undoubtedly be to usurp the role not only of the judge and the jury but also of the legislature alongside. This would ultimately undermine the government’s legitimacy.<br>Jeremy Waldron, in his article ‘Law and Politics’, focuses on the two models of law, namely, the partisan model and the neutral model. The meat of this paper is based on how laws are formulated. The partisan model is an expression of the particular ideology and/ or policies of a political party in legislative terms. It furthermore states that law cannot be placed above politics. Parties compete for the Parliament’s control in order to reflect their own ideologies/ values to be reflected in the law. Here, the interest of the party enjoys an upper hand over the public’s interest. On the contrary, the neutral models places the law above politics and asserts that the law carries with it special ‘non-partisan’ responsibilities. The neutral model considers the law as a result of solemn, mutual deliberations rather than viewing it in terms of opposing political ideologies. The law is an over arching thing which demands to be followed and respected irrespective of whether it is Leftist or Rightist. The neutral model as is presented seems to be utopian in character while also being immensely compelling.<br>A striking statement by Waldron in regard to the partisan model goes as such, “to the extent that society makes a choice it does so crudely on the basis of which outlook commands the popular support, and it does that precisely in order to allow those who represent what is, for the time being, the most popular opinion to prevail in the determination of the laws of land.” <br>The neutral model as it focuses on the common law in particular would be devoid of ‘selfishly’ and politically articulated decisions. However on the contrary, a great deal has been written on the relationship between politics and law. Legislation is considered to be mostly political and is the result of a process or the creation of officials often intimately bound into party politics. Again, one of the exclusive powers of the state is legislation. As such, it is apparently both practical and inevitably political. Parallely, most of the understandings of the law and politics relationship have been overwhelmingly theoretical in nature. In this regards, public law is often seen as a part of the political order or as inexorably partisan. <br>However again, partisanship in India is limited to a party’s successful claim to power. The parties’ political principles in most cases in India are not very distinctly different (with handful exceptions) and so partisanship is not much about different ideologies as it is in the USA. For instance, the contrasting views on the foreign policy of the Republicans and the Democrats. Each party has had differing views in regards to foreign policy over the years depending on the circumstances. By and large, in times when military involvement might be essential, the Democrats favor more targeted strikes and a restricted use of manpower while on the other hand Republicans opt for a full military effort to displace regimes which are totalitarian in nature and detrimental to their own people and who are threatening others. Both parties in general agree that providing aid to other countries is an acceptable gesture, but oppose on the nature of that aid and the ones receiving it.<br>However again, to cite one of the few instances of the partisan model in India would be the Land Acquisition Amendment 2015. While the BJP successfully passed the Bill in the Lok Sabha with nine amendments, the Congress vehemently opposed it referring to these amendments as being unfavorable to the poor and the like.<br>Again, the recent beef ban incident of 2015. While the BJP has got the beef ban law enforceable now- the bill has been pending since around the year 1995- when the BJP was in power prior to the Congress. (This very fact echoes the partisan model’s view that the choice made is representative of what is the most popular opinion for the time being). As a reaction to this, the Republican Party of India declared a state wise protest against the government and posited that this passing of the Bill would be a threat to the livelihoods of thousands of people as it has been extended to include the ban of slaughtering bulls and bullocks as well.<br>Thus, as a subtle conclusion, it can be well argued that the Indian legal framework does not necessarily follow a strict partisan approach. However, partisanship throughout has been used as a mean to power by the varied political parties. But adhering to the same in a staunch manner has not been embedded in concrete empirical outcomes. To mention, the CPI (M) which ‘supposedly’ represents the labor and the working community interests, in 2011, took a stand contrary to its’ ideology wherein it resorted to violent means to counteract against the protestors, i.e., poor peasants and migrant workers who vehemently disapproved the land acquisition for the SEZs.<br>Finally, many studies have stated that the inefficiency of policies in developing countries like India is said to be a consequence of the logic of political choice and, further, that political institutions offer the inducement facing political officials.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e44ba556e145" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>