<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Palash Krishna Mehrotra on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Palash Krishna Mehrotra on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 06:23:25 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Killing in the Family: An Indian Tradition]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/killing-in-the-family-an-indian-tradition-67b464825980?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/67b464825980</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Palash Krishna Mehrotra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Sep 2025 14:56:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-03T16:02:15.807Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*diJWE55RBzHAJXWt" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@fedotov_vs?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Vladimir Fedotov</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>Bhoomika, Rajani, Radhika, Nikki –all killed by their husbands or fathers, in the last two months. What’s gnawing away at the Indian male?</em></p><p><em>Cruelty and killing within the family, specifically the girl child or married woman, has taken many forms: foeticide, infanticide, sati or the practice of widow-burning</em><strong><em>, </em></strong><em>the mistreatment of widows, and killing for dowry.</em></p><p><em>Religion (and its corollary, custom) in India is a flimsy facade, at times quite literally so, riddled with bullet-holes of hypocrisy. Under its guise, much criminality takes place. Vijay Solanki had taken his family on a trip to the temple, before he allegedly threw his daughter into swirling waters. As </em>Outlook <em>reports, the three-storey house where Radhika Yadav lived was named ‘Bhagwana Villa’, “its facade decorated with tiles of Hindu deities.”</em></p><p><em>In the eyes of Hindutva, it’s only the Muslim male who is a ‘love jihad’ monster from whom Hindu women need to be protected. Fact is: the Hindu woman needs to be protected from Hindu men — their fathers and husbands.</em></p><p>September 2. 4.23 am. The Najafgarh police station receives a call that a woman has been murdered. The woman, Rajani, was a thirty-year-old with a passion for creating Instagram Reels. She had over 6000 followers. Her husband, Aman, an e-rickshaw driver, disapproved of it. The couple had several arguments over the issue. On that fateful night, Aman allegedly strangled Rajani to death.</p><p>***</p><p>21 August 2025. Sirsa village, NOIDA. On a normal monsoon Thursday, as the rain pours outside, a woman goes up in flames in a seemingly normal middle class home, as her six-year-old son watches.</p><p>The reason: a dowry demand of Rs 36 lakhs and a Scorpio. Also, a successful beauty parlour (on the third floor of the house) that Nikki wanted to reopen with her sister, and Vipin’s resentment at her making Instagram Reels. Vipin, incidentally, was unemployed. He wanted the wife’s family to shower him with cars and cash, but was dead against the idea of his wife going to work. In the same house.</p><p>28-year-old Nikki was set ablaze allegedly by her husband and in-laws. The mother-in-law handed a bottle of paint thinner to her loyal son, who did the honours: setting Nikki on fire.</p><p>Nikki’s husband, his father, brother and mother, have all been arrested. Before Vipin was taken into custody, he managed to put out a post on Instagram: “Why did you leave me? The world is calling me a killer, Nikki.” The post was accompanied by a video of him smiling with his wife and son in happier times. Vipin was shot in the leg during a police encounter while trying to escape custody. He said from the hospital bed: “I have no remorse. I haven’t killed her. She died on her own.”</p><p>It’s like the 1980s and 1990s are back, with an updated social media and phone camera twist. The pattern remains classical: dowry deaths usually take place at home and involve burning the victim. The family of the husband is a partner-in-crime.</p><p>***</p><p>10 July 2025. It’s a scene straight out of a nightmare, the kind from which one wakes up sweating buckets, the sheets soaked with perspiration. Perhaps, Radhika Yadav had these nightmares. She was the one living with her parents in Gurugram’s upscale Sector 57, and only she knew what kind of pressure, societal and parental, she was under. But, Radhika also had dreams she wanted to realise.</p><p>It was 10.30 in the morning, and Radhika was cooking breakfast in the kitchen. It was her mother’s birthday. The mother claims she wasn’t well and was lying down in her room. Her brother had gone to fetch milk.</p><p>In that window, her father, Deepak, a wealthy property dealer, crept up behind her and shot her point-blank, pumping four bullets into his 25-year-old daughter<strong>: “</strong>three in the back and one in the shoulder”, according to <em>The Hindu</em>. There were no exit wounds.</p><p>The father, in his statement to the police, said: “When I went to Wazirabad to fetch milk, people in the village taunted me for living off my daughter’s earnings. This upset me. They also pointed fingers at her character. I told my daughter to shut the academy for this reason, but she refused. I was constantly tense over this. I was very perturbed. Due to this tension, I shot my daughter from behind when she was cooking in the kitchen.”</p><p>Radhika was a state-level tennis player. She had leased a tennis court from an academy, where she would coach young players. According to reports, Yadav had competed in 10 ITF junior tournaments, and, after reaching adulthood, 30 international events.</p><p>***</p><p>On July 16, the <em>Times of India</em> reported on another case: “Upset about not having a male heir, a man from Kapadvanj allegedly threw his seven-year-old daughter into a canal in front of his wife.” Vijay Solanki had taken his wife, Anjana, and daughter, Bhoomika, on a motorcycle trip. “On the way back, near the Vaghavat bridge over the Narmada canal, he allegedly stopped the vehicle, took the child to the canal’s parapet and suddenly threw her into the water…Anjana’s complaint states that Vijay was unhappy about not having a son and often argued with her.” The report goes on to state that the couple had another daughter aged three who had not come on the trip. Solanki, like Deepak Yadav, has been arrested.</p><p>I mention the two incidents in one breath, not just because they involve fathers killing daughters, and not only because they took place so close to each other. I mention them to make the argument that, shocking as they are, they aren’t that shocking either. In India, killing in the family is part of a larger cruelty practiced within families. In a tradition-bound society like ours, killing in the family, like other traditions, goes back in time. It’s as shocking or ‘normal’ as a school shooting in America.</p><p>Different societies have different pathologies of crime. In America we have the lone gunman — a disgruntled former employee or student who returns to his former workplace/ school and shoots people dead. The serial killer acting on his own is another American manifestation of criminal pathology. Mental illness is a factor.</p><p>In India, school shootings are unheard of; we don’t produce serial killers on an assembly line. But violence within the family has multiple manifestations, often sanctioned by tradition. The mental illness is collective, not individual. One can call it the mental illness of community norms, from where springs the stifling conservatism of moral norms.</p><p>Cruelty and killing within the family, specifically the girl child or married woman, has taken many forms: foeticide, infanticide, sati or the practice of widow-burning<strong>, </strong>and killing for dowry, where mothers-in-law are often the prime instigators.</p><p>I was twelve in 1987 when Roop Kanwar was consigned to death by fire in Rajasthan, also the title of Mala Sen’s book on the subject. In that decade, dowry deaths were rampant too. The story of the killings within continues in 2025 with Radhika Yadav and Nikki Bhati.</p><p>Religion (and its corollary, custom) in India is a flimsy facade, at times quite literally so, riddled with bullet-holes of hypocrisy. Under its guise, much criminality takes place. Vijay Solanki had taken his family on a trip to the temple, before he allegedly threw his daughter into swirling waters. As <em>Outlook</em> reports, the three-storey house where Radhika Yadav lived was named ‘Bhagwana Villa’, “its facade decorated with tiles of Hindu deities.”</p><p>There is often a clash between private morality: the informal morality of the individual and his community, and the formal morality of the state. Deepak Yadav didn’t try to run away after murdering his daughter. In his head he did the right thing, in line with his private morality. At the same time, he didn’t resist arrest — the morality of the Indian state said he was a murder accused, and he accepted it.</p><p>The morality of the state in India has a long tradition — of clashing with tradition, from the British who banned female infanticide and the Devdasi system (where women were dedicated to temples and sometimes forced into sexual servitude), to Hindu reformers of the nineteenth century like Rammohan Roy, who campaigned against sati.</p><p>Independent India enacted its own laws like the Dowry Prohibition Act of 1961 and Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), which deals with cruelty against women by husbands or their relatives in connection with dowry demands. But, as Nikki’s case shows, private morality is a beast unto its own, which runs parallel to the legal system — the morality of the state.</p><p>***</p><p>In the eyes of Hindutva, it’s only the Muslim male who is a monster from whom Hindu women need to be protected. ‘Love jihad’ laws are enacted to discourage interfaith marriage; Aftab Amin Poonawalla chopping up Shraddha Walkar gave the Hindu Right enough ammo. The Uniform Civil Code enacted in Uttarakhand covertly targets interfaith live-in relationships. Fact is that the Hindu woman needs to be protected from Hindu men — their fathers and husbands. Poonwala’s was a one-off case, whereas honour killings, dowry deaths and infanticide are embedded in tradition, our private morality.</p><p>In another part of the world, Radhika would be a tennis coach and player, earning her own bread, living independently, making TikTok videos. In India one is forced to live (and die) in the guttural claustrophobia of a family living under one roof.</p><p>This holds true in the Nikki Bhati case as well. She and her sister ran beauty channels on Instagram and YouTube to promote a parlour they owned. The Instagram handle had 54,500 followers.</p><p>Nikki’s husband, Vipin, didn’t like the idea and the parlour was shut down. <em>Mint </em>quotes the station house officer of Kasna, Dharmendra Shukla, as saying: “Nikki told Vipin that she and her sister would reopen the parlour. When he refused, Nikki said that no one could stop them from reopening, which Bhati opposed. Vipin told her that in their family, posting reels on Instagram and running a parlour were not allowed. The issue turned ugly and he started assaulting her.”</p><p>Nikki’s father, Bhikhari Singh, told <em>PTI Video</em>: “Both brothers don’t work, they kept asking for money; sometimes they said, ‘Give us your Mercedes’, or asked for our Scorpio. I helped my daughter open her own beauty parlour as Vipin had no work. He then started stealing money from the parlour.”</p><p>***</p><p>This claustrophobia of social norms also explains what’s come to be called the Shillong honeymoon case. Sonam, who killed her husband with the help of her paramour and hired killers, used to tie rakhi on her lover. In the eyes of their families they were <em>muh boley </em>siblings. It’s so easy to game facades.</p><p>As <em>The Quint</em> wrote: “The question we must ask is: what kind of society produces a Sonam who sees no viable path to pursue her love, except through conspiracy, deceit and death? What kind of cultural fabric makes a woman so cornered that even the act of loving outside prescribed boundaries becomes life-threatening?”</p><p>Agree, but it begs the question: what fault was it of the newly-wed husband who’d gotten into an arranged marriage like millions of Indians. If Sonam had actually married her lover, she herself potentially could have been the victim of an honour killing. Better to eliminate the husband. As I said: killings in India take place within the family. Someone has to kill someone<em>.</em> It’s tradition. Sonam only reversed the direction.</p><p>(The writer is the author of <em>The Butterfly Generation: A Personal Journey into the Passions and Follies of India’s Technicolor Youth</em>, and the editor of <em>House Spirit: Drinking in India</em>)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=67b464825980" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Now Streaming ‘Amrikan Electionama’: How U.S. Elections Appear to an Indian From Afar]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/the-re-invention-of-kamala-harris-in-the-streaming-phenomenon-amrikan-electionama-how-u-s-6d6fffe9c60e?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d6fffe9c60e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ott]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[american-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kamala-harris]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Palash Krishna Mehrotra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Aug 2024 16:19:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-20T11:50:30.311Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*mX4_jKMPL5Zoalr0PEay-w.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>American elections, with their televised debates, relentless speech-making and lengthy campaigning are tailor-made for an international audience. It reminds one of a Netflix series with universal appeal. The storyline might have nothing to do with one’s immediate reality but is engrossing enough to hold our interest; the characters are foreign, yet relatable.</em></p><p>I find American elections hugely entertaining to watch. It’s like following an OTT series, with multiple seasons. Or like watching the football World Cup as a neutral. One might have favourites — this year I was supporting Spain in the Euros, but it’s not that I would have been emotionally distraught if England had brought the Cup home. I don’t carry the English fan’s burden of 1966, the last time their men’s team won an international tournament.</p><p>Besides, this time Indians are in a win-win situation. Both Usha Vance, wife of Republican VP nominee, JD Vance, and the Democratic presidential nominee, Kamala Harris, have a Chennai connection. For us, what matters eventually is that an Indian is in the picture.</p><p>Our elections, that’s a different matter. You are standing in your balcony and watching events unfold in your own street. The American elections take place seven seas away. If one reads Indian elections as essentially a battle between Congress leader, Rahul Gandhi, and PM Narendra Modi — the battle of the bachelors, the US elections, until Biden pulled out, was the battle of the grandpas.</p><p>An interesting point here about bachelors, marriage and children. Republicans, including Vance in 2021, have taken chauvinistic pot shots at Harris (“childless cat lady”) for not having children of her own. She’s a co-parent to her husband’s son and daughter from his former marriage, who fondly call her ‘Momala’.</p><p>It’s a scene straight out of the iconic show, ‘Modern Family’, a fiction series about contemporary marital arrangements and unorthodox couplings. Vance doesn’t get the ‘blended family’. According to him, if you don’t spit out babies yourself, you have no “direct stake” in the country’s future.</p><p>In India, it’s the opposite. Modi has made a virtue of being unmarried. He’s successfully projected himself as being singularly devoted to the cause of the nation, undistracted by familial concerns. Not having children in the Indian scenario adds to the integrity of the politician. Modi cannot be corrupt because he has no family which will benefit from his corruption. Nor can he be accused of being a dynast who wants to pass on power to his kin. The public perception is that of absolute ascetic purity and commitment.</p><p>* * *</p><p>Now, if one is an Indian political analyst with a pronounced leaning, one might tend towards certain linkages. A commentator who defends the Hindu Right BJP will likely lean towards Trump. A columnist with left-liberal Congress sympathies will lean towards the Democrats. Where I’m coming from is the space of a mere viewer, one among millions, who is hooked to the greatest show on earth, a show that transcends boundaries.</p><p>The American elections, with their televised debates, relentless speechmaking and lengthy campaigning are tailor-made for an international audience. It reminds me of a Netflix series with universal appeal. The storyline might have nothing to do with our immediate reality but is engrossing enough to hold our interest; the characters are foreign, yet highly relatable. It’s like Indians being hooked to Korean or Turkish dramas, or Russians and West Africans being captivated by Bollywood films.</p><p>I’ll return to the present season of ‘Amrikan Electionama’ in just a moment. Let me sneak in a word about seasons past, back when it used to beam on cable TV. Responding purely as a lay viewer, it’s totally normal to forget certain characters and episodes. In the age of entertainment overload and binge-watching, I can barely remember the titles of shows and films that I might have watched on OTT platforms just weeks ago. This rarely happens with books. Partly, this has to do with the pace of consumption. It’s possible to consume three films a day on various streaming platforms, but it’s not possible to read three books in one night.</p><p>So, for instance, while I remember Barak Obama rising like a messiah in the 2008 season of ‘Amrikan Electionama’, I cannot remember the one who he vanquished. Obama: what a scintillatingly charismatic and memorably-written character, that seemingly came out of nowhere. Kudos to the writers of that season.</p><p>And who was his rival in the 2012 season? My mind draws a blank. If you asked me to name the characters of ‘Yeh Jo Hai Zindagi’, a popular sitcom that aired on Doordarshan (state-owned TV) in the mid-1980s, I’d fail similarly (even though I religiously watched each episode). The only thing I remember is the line: ‘Thirty years ka experience’, mouthed by, I think, Satish Shah’s character. The only thing I remember about the George Bush Sr season of ‘American Electionama’ is the line: “Read my lips. No more taxes.” As for Obama’s rivals, I had to do an internet search. It was John McCain in 2008 and Mitt Romney in 2012.</p><p>The 2016 season of ‘Amrikan Electionama’ was fantastic. The protagonist was whimsical, impulsive, erratic, and lived in a nest of tweets, lies and fried chicken. Donald Trump, a rank political outsider then, but an established TRP magnet as a television personality, pushed up TV ratings in the US and around the world. Apparently, the platform that was broadcasting ‘Amrikan Electionama’ was going to take the show off air, until Trump arrived to save the day.</p><p>The season finale couldn’t have been better scripted, what with the riots/ insurrection-on-Capitol-Hill plot twist. It made for great repeat viewing. Even Mike Pence, a minor figure in the supporting cast, finally got his moment. Reportedly, the scriptwriters had planned to kill off his character in a medieval hanging-unto-death scene, but decided against it at the last minute.</p><p>* * *</p><p>The 2021 season was the dullest and had the lowest international ratings. The only excitement, or comic relief rather, was provided by Joe Biden’s German Shepherd, Commander, who bit two dozen Secret Service agents, before being removed from the White House. Biden’s character didn’t make for great TV, not until this year when he started calling Zelensky Putin and Harris Trump, or going on absent-minded walks in the middle of high-profile summit photo-ops in Italy.</p><p>The show was failing primarily because the makers were trying to change tack: turn what was originally planned as a long-running political drama into a sitcom. They can’t be faulted though; the sitcom spin had worked quite well during the Trump era.</p><p>But, as recent developments show, there is a reason why ‘Amrikan Electionama’ is the longest running political TV show globally. What a plot twist! Reportedly, the writing team originally planned on having Biden slip on a banana peel and retire him from the script with a fractured hip.</p><p>In a desperate move to boost ratings they’d already brought Trump’s character back, but what the show really needed was a shot of freshness and tang. Biden’s character was turned into a kind of selfless hero for the cause and retired from the story. The show’s makers ensured that the audience felt sufficient empathy for him without exactly rooting for him.</p><p>Trump’s re-induction into the story brought back the older demographic, except that roughly half of America’s voting population is made up of Millennials and Gen Z, also called Zoomers. The makers of ‘Amrikan Electionama’, in a creative masterstroke, fired the earlier writing team, and hired a new one.</p><p>To be fair to the earlier team, it was they who had thought of the Trump assassination twist. The revamped Writers’ Room (industry jargon for the writing staff which brainstorms every element of a television show) re- wrote Kamala Harris’ character in an inspired moment. Instead of introducing a brand new character, they brought back one who was barely visible in the previous season.</p><p>Kamala is now cast as someone who has a certain joy about her, exudes likeability and is cool in a way young folks can relate to, both in the way she carries herself as well, as the causes she backs: a woman’s right over her body, climate change and even, perhaps, a slightly different take on Israel/ Palestine than Biden’s.</p><p>In one episode, she’s shown walking out a record store with her haul: Charlie Mingus, Roy Ayers and Louis Armstrong. Then there’s marijuana. In an earlier season, Kamala was portrayed as aggressively prosecuting weed-related crimes when she was California’s attorney general. In the current season, she has thoroughly embraced legalisation and urged the repeal of federal pot prohibition.</p><p>And man, has it worked. The influential British-born Gen Z singer, Charli XCX, tweeted “kamala IS brat!”, a reference to her new album ‘brat’, which started the trend ‘brat summer’<strong>. </strong>That single tweet brought in hordes of younger new fans. According to Fox5: “The ‘brat summer’ movement pretty much rejects the norm and embraces the unapologetic. Think edgy, imperfect, and confident, as opposed to polished, poised, and politically correct.” This is the kind of thing that international viewers of ‘Amrikan Electionama’ find bewildering and addictive at the same time. By this logic, wasn’t Trump’s character ‘brat’ all along? So American all this.</p><p>Coconut memes and emojis are everywhere, a reference to Kamala’s anecdote about her mother, who was fond of underlining the importance of context by saying, “You didn’t just fall out of a coconut tree.” Stephen Colbert, host of ‘The Late Show’ declared Kamala to be a ‘meme candidate’. That’s a compliment.</p><p>The battle of the grandpas had been upended into and recast as a generational and gender one. The young and the old are both now watching the show. Kamala has also helped bring in previously unenthused female, Black and Latino viewers.</p><p>Meanwhile, the dialogue writers have not fiddled much with Trump’s character. His issues are the same: immigration and abortion. His slogan is the same: MAGA. His vocabulary has been retained, largely consisting of words like ‘beautiful’, ‘great’, ‘good’, ‘bad’, ‘evil’, ‘witch-hunt’ and ‘fake news’. He’s gone from mouthing ‘Crooked Hillary’ to ‘Lyin’ Kamala’. Not much of a change. Every show needs some continuity.</p><p>What tickles the international viewer are the inventive merchandising slogans on the t-shirts and caps of Trump fans. In an episode set in a rally in Wildwood, New Jersey, the slogans said it all: ‘Biden suc*s, Kamala Allows’, ‘F*** Joe and the Hoe’ and ‘Joe and the Hoe Gotta Go’. In the real world, none of this is asterisked. Again, for the international viewer, not used to such filthy verbiage in their own elections, the profanities lend an air of novelty, exotica, thrill and danger to the show.</p><p>* * *</p><p>As a foil to Trump and Vance, the show cleverly added Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz as Kamala’s running mate. He calls the Republican nominees “weird”; is a protector of trans rights and LBGTQ rights in general; has codified pro-abortion laws; listens to Bob Dylan, and avant garde 1990s bands like Husker Du; goes pheasant and turkey hunting, but is also a gun control advocate. To counter Trump’s MAGA merchandise, the Harris-Walz campaign has launched a union-made woodsman camouflage cap — called camo hats — with their logo emblazoned on it. It speaks both to the Gen Z-er, who wears it as a fashion trend, as well as an older cohort, for whom it’s an everyday utility item.</p><p>Walz’s character has been given a pleasant backstory: chill dude schoolteacher who taught Social Studies and Geography, and introduced his students to Monty Python films; as coach, he led his school football team to victory in the state championship; as Governor he named a stretch of highway after Prince — the legendary singer and musician from Minnesota — remarking: “I think we can lay to rest that this is the coolest bill signing we’ll ever do.” The only thing he shares in common with Vance is the love for Diet Mountain Dew, very much a Midwestern thing. No network wants to lose ratings in Middle America.</p><p>Where to watch: For those who are just joining in and want to know more about where to catch the latest season, Haystack News is a great aggregator app for international viewers. Just like in the IPL the viewer can choose which camera angle to watch the game, Haystack offers a bunch of channels in a single app. The viewer can get different political angles, liberal like ABC News and CBS, Right-leaning ones, like all the variants of Fox and Newsmax, as well as the self-styled centrist, NewsNation.</p><p>So happy viewing everyone! Remember, the season finale airs on November 5, 2024.</p><p>PS: At the beginning of this piece, I said I’d be writing as a neutral viewer. But then, most viewers watching a show have their favourites. The more I see of Kamala, the more I like her. She’s the one I’m rooting for.</p><p>(The writer is the author of <em>The Butterfly Generation: A Personal Journey into the Passions and Follies of India’s Technicolor Youth</em>, and the editor of <em>House Spirit: Drinking in India</em>)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d6fffe9c60e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Aaftab Amin Poonawala gave love a bad name and turned the clock back a hundred years]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/how-aaftab-amin-poonawala-gave-love-a-bad-name-and-turned-the-clock-back-a-hundred-yearsby-palash-2a9f3ef2e7f?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a9f3ef2e7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sex-crimes]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Palash Krishna Mehrotra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Dec 2022 07:39:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-19T07:42:03.651Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>How Aaftab Amin Poonawala gave love a bad name and turned the clock back a hundred years</strong></p><p><strong>by Palash Krishna Mehrotra</strong></p><p>Different societies have different and unique pathologies of crime. When one thinks of America, one thinks of the lone gunman in a supermarket, nightclub or school. Or one thinks of the serial killer, as American as Coca Cola and McDonalds. American serial killers become immortalised in cult comics and have fan clubs, as the recent Netflix series <em>Dahmer</em> — <em>Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story</em> shows us.</p><p>Both these types are not as popular in India. Perhaps it has to do with familial surveillance. India is not an atomised society — although it is gradually becoming so — like America. There is a lack of physical space where one can plan such killings. Suppose one buys an assault rifle and rounds of ammunition. Where will one store this in a joint family set-up? There is also something like ‘crime culture’: some crimes simply don’t catch a society’s fancy. The lone gunman is an all-American type, in a way he is not in India or the U.K. We have no lack of country pistols and unguarded schools but the desi criminal isn’t interested.</p><p>Our criminal tendencies manifest themselves in other ways. Do an internet search for ‘toddler rape’. This horrific news item appears with depressing, almost daily regularity, in the form of a small box in the newspaper. Occasionally, the box makes it to the front page of a regional edition; usually, it’s tucked away inside, a five-sentence report buried in a page of tender notices (pun unintended).</p><p>If one googles it, one gets a consecutive long-list: Ghaziabad, Jhansi, Indore, Thiruvananthapuram, Morang, Nirmal district of North Telangana, it goes on. In most of these cases, the toddler is also murdered.</p><p>Brutal as they are, none of these murders capture our fancy or lead to outrage. They are too remote from the news cycle of cities. What grabs our morbid attention is the urban middle-class murder: Arushi, Jessica Lal, Sheena Bora, Nirbhaya, the tandoor cook-up.</p><p>The Aaftab-Shraddha case belongs to the latter category. It’s about people-like-us doing it to people-like-us — Aaftab sported a fashionable mini-Amish beard; Shraddha had lip piercings; both were English-speaking. More than that, it’s a very American-style murder, a generational first. This is a generation that has had to grapple with a rapidly changing environment, whether it comes to money; lifestyles and taboos; television, media and the internet. It’s different from the old tussle between tradition and modernity, the subject of a million saggy academic seminars. Indian society is in deep irreversible churn, our youth are at the vanguard of it, and this murder comes out of that churn.</p><p>*</p><p>On December 9, Vikas Walkar, Shraddha Walkar’s father, delivered his first public comments on his daughter’s murder. Two comments stand out, both to do with a changing social fabric. First, Mr Walkar questioned the ‘freedom’ that kids get on turning 18: ‘There should be counselling and control over children who turn 18. My daughter told me while leaving home that she was an adult, that’s why I’m saying this.’ Second, he also demanded that action be taken against phone apps that are ‘creating trouble.’</p><p>Meanwhile, over in Kerala, the issue of freedom for young women is being debated differently. The girl students of Government Medical College, Kozhikode, have been fighting against restrictions that prevent them from moving out of the hostel after 9.30 p.m. The Kerala High Court has asked some pertinent questions of the authorities. Justice Devan Ramachandran observed, ‘In these modern times, any form of patriarchy, even in the guise of offering protection based on gender, cannot be accepted. Girls, as much as boys, are fully capable of taking care of themselves, and if not, it must be the endeavour of the state and the public authorities to make them so competent, rather than being locked in.” He went on to add, ‘Lock up the men. I am saying (this) because they create trouble. Put the curfew for men after 8:00 pm. Let ladies walk out.’</p><p>*</p><p>I quote the judge’s remarks alongside the father’s, only to illustrate how hard-fought these small freedoms are. In many ways, Aaftab has turned the clock back a hundred years. While he sits in jail reading Paul Theroux’s <em>Great Railway Bazaar</em> and pondering chess moves, he’s made it that much harder for this generation’s tortoise march to autonomy and the freedom to choose its own destiny. The clamour now is for ‘more control’. Oh, look what have you done, you fool! Like in the Bon Jovi song, you gave love a bad name. And a fillip to old prejudices, which have returned with a sly smirking ‘told you so’.</p><p>Like live-in relationships are intrinsically bad. Indian landlords are controlling enough as it is; this will only encourage them to not rent out flats to unmarried couples. This, at a time when live-in relationships were getting more acceptable in our big cities, with even the courts coming to the defence of couples in such arrangements.</p><p>Like dating apps are evil. In a society that loves to clamp down on pleasure, dating apps have liberated a generation from conservative mores and allowed them a semblance of choice. But at the moment, as Mr Walkar has demanded, there is pressure to clamp down. I know several marriages where the couple met on a dating app or on social media like the now-defunct Orkut or Facebook, and lived happily ever after.</p><p>If anything, what has happened should teach us to be smarter. We often mistake social media presence for real-life presence. When I do not update my social media feeds for a couple of weeks, I start getting messages from people asking, ‘Are you okay?’ Aaftab cleverly manipulated this expectation of friends and family, by taking over Shraddha’s Instagram account and continuing to post on it, months after she was dead. Banning dating sites is like banning arranged marriage because of dowry deaths.</p><p>Aaftab’s actions have reinforced the arranged marriage brigade, which for long has insisted that love marriages are for the morally bankrupt. This then spills over into the communal divide where men from one community are seen as inherently barbaric and bloodthirsty, by men from another community. It’s a blow to interfaith relationships.</p><p>Aaftab has also given the TV series <em>Dexter</em> a bad name. While it does feature a serial killer, <em>Dexter</em> is one of the tamest shows on offer. If one follows algorithm logic, those who like <em>Friends</em> are told they might also like <em>Dexter.</em></p><p>There have been reports that Aaftab confessed to smoking pot on the night of the murder. This adds to the cliché that cannabis is a drug that turns one into a psychopath. It should be pointed out that as more and more American states have decriminalized or legalised the use of the plant, no link has been reported between an increase in violent crime and the use of pot.</p><p>Aaftab’s deft use of knives in posthumous chopping has pushed a legit degree down the ladder. Some reports say he worked in the kitchen of a Mumbai five star, others say he had a degree in Hotel Management. Hotel management has always been step cousin to an MBA. Once, when I told a family friend that I was attending college at St Stephen’s, she said, ‘Good boys go to Stephen’s, bad boys do hotel management.’ There was time when those who wanted to do hotel management were told by their families, ‘Why do you want to become a waiter or a bawarchi?’ Now, they will say, ‘You want to become a murderer or what?!’</p><p>In this kerfuffle, caught between the devil and the deep sea, is the Indian woman, the one who suffers the most. On the one hand is the fear of an honour killing, or, at the very least, the fear of being cut off by one’s own family, leaving one with no safety net. On the other, lurks the danger of being trapped in an abusive relationship with a boyfriend with murderous tendencies.</p><p>Let’s not blame dating sites. Let’s not blame kitchen knives. Let’s not blame big refrigerators. Let’s not blame crime shows. Let’s not blame small forests that provide green cover to a polluted city. Let’s take a long hard look at ourselves who live in a society that leaves no space for love across community, caste and class lines. It’s an unforgiving society that doesn’t allow for mistakes.</p><p>The writer is the author of <em>The Butterfly Generation: A Personal Journey into the Passions &amp; Follies of India’s Technicolor Youth</em>, and the editor of the anthology, <em>House Spirit: Drinking in India</em>)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a9f3ef2e7f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When it comes to Kashmir, don’t fetishize national identity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/when-it-comes-to-kashmir-dont-fetishize-national-identity-dfa9bbb5e367?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dfa9bbb5e367</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Palash Krishna Mehrotra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Aug 2019 11:37:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-13T11:37:37.893Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SwDjOLbjkw2njpQo" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@williamisted?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">William Isted</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>By Palash Krishna Mehrotra</strong></p><p>The grinning applauding laddoo-eaters celebrating the ‘integration’ of Kashmir into the ‘mainland’ forget what Indians often forget: that, for at least three generations, we’ve taken peacetime for granted.</p><p>If you’ve never lived in a war zone — there are 600,000 troops on the ground at the moment -, if you’ve never been fired upon, if you’ve never been humiliated by an ‘occupying force’ and made to rub your nose on the ground, you have no right to celebrate someone else’s ‘liberation’ or, rather, the clamping of chains.</p><p>India might not be a rich country but in large swathes of it people have gone about their daily business like clockwork automatons for decades: job, marriage, kids, roof above one’s head. Peacetime offers the lucky millions a luxury not afforded to those in areas of conflict: the privilege of being bored, of being exhausted by the mundanities of everyday life.</p><p>Films will come to theatres, ATMs will dispense cash, (demonetisation was the closest experience of a war-like situation for most of us), chemists will be well-stocked, veggies and fruits will eternally make their way from farm to fork. The mundanities of a war zone are different, more like a pathological boredom. You want to get out and make your space in the world, do your thing. But you cannot. The moment you step out you will be in the crosshairs of a gun, blinded in the eyes, maimed, killed.</p><p>The BJP was supposed to be the harbinger of big bang economic reforms that would unleash ‘animal spirits’. Instead, it has unleashed the ‘plant spirit’: plant animosity, plant saffron, plant hate.</p><p>Modi nipped the suit-boot ki sarkar/ pro-big business jibe in the bud. If there is one Congress PM he secretly admires, it’s Indira Gandhi, the strongwoman. From her he took the ‘garibi hatao’ line and rebranded himself as a messiah of the poor.</p><p>Simultaneously, Project Bharat was put on the fast track; this is where the big bang reforms are taking place: the NRC in Assam, Yogi in U.P., fighter jets crossing over into Pakistani territory, annexing Kashmir.</p><p>The alarm bells ringing in the automobile industry have been put on snooze. Employment is an issue but it’s not as important as it’s made out to be. It doesn’t sway voters anymore. Amit Shah and Modi have the uncanny knack of the soothsayer. Nobody reads the public mood better than them — just look at the celebrations. Critics will argue that the two don’t read the mood as much as assemble and manufacture it from thin air.</p><p>Modi has elevated the discourse for the common man, the little Indian. He’s injected it with a moral impulse whose motherlode is nationalism. Nationalism is one of the oldest yarns in the book, but Modi spins it on a different charkha.</p><p>He uses it to persuade the little Indian to rise above the insolvables of their daily lives: price rise, jobs, rapes, leaking roofs, potholes, creaking buses, e-rickshaws, garbage, dengue. The pettifogging Indian is offered an opportunity to be part of a Grand Narrative. He is endowed with a transcendental moral purpose.</p><p>Why think of earthly lack when you can imagine India on the moon, India in a fighter jet, India expanding into the land of fair women, beautiful landscapes and cheap plots. Modi has a way with words, from crusader to avuncular. Modi, the storyteller, borrows the technique of magic realism from Latin American novelists and applies it to the terra firma of Indian politics.</p><p>Protests have already erupted in Kashmir; teargas and pellet guns are back in action. But, even if Kashmir explodes, or if there are retaliatory terrorist strikes in other parts of the country, Modi still wins at the ballot box. The Indian voter will see it as the Kashmiri’s fault; Modi (and India) did his best; a genuine offer was made. Like with demonetisation, it will be proof that his heart is in the right place, the intention’s genuine.</p><p>In many ways, there are no surprises here. The BJP-RSS idea of an Akhand Bharat has been in the public domain for the longest time. The BJP in its second term is only executing this idea, on the double, and to loud cheering. What we are witnessing are the ripples of a muscular fantasy.</p><p>The broad brushstrokes of history are not a pretty sight to behold. Overnight, equations change; status quos perish; there is bloodshed. With the passage of time equations are reset again. Mao, Stalin and Hitler all rose and fell. In our times we have seen militancy, followed by peace, in Northern Ireland, Sri Lanka and Punjab. It might not sound like much of an insight, but when the combined power of the state is brought to bear on you, there is little room for manoeuvre.</p><p>It’s ironic that Amit Shah, who calls Muslim immigrants ‘termites’, now hopes to solve the Kashmir problem with immigration from mainland India. It’s what China did in Tibet and Israel in the West Bank.</p><p>What will the Kashmiris do now? The Kashmiris are not a homogenous entity, far from it. The options are not limited at the conceptual level; in fact, there are options aplenty; they’ve always been there: become an independent Islamic jihadi state; merge with Pakistan; be an independent secular country; be a part of either Pakistan or India and yet retain a degree of autonomy; or it can descend into perpetual bloody chaos.</p><p>My point is this: whatever the motivations of Hindutva might be, this deed is now done. Insurgencies die a natural death only when the people get tired of it. The desire to be a part of the mainstream and reap its benefits, unremarkable as they might be, is a resilient undercurrent. The initial sense of anger will make way for a sense of resignation, which in turn might just translate into a sense of ‘getting on with it’. This is what the BJP is banking on. In the end, Indians too forgave the British, though only after gaining Independence, the crucial difference.</p><p>Life is short and most young people around the world want the same things: the freedom to make love and money, the freedom to practice one’s religion or not, and to reap the fruits of modernity: movies and streaming videos, mobile phones, coffee-shops, American street fashion, rap music, films, automobiles. The Instagramable life is now a universal ideal.</p><p>I once attended a talk and a reading given by the Tibetan poet and activist Tenzin Tsundue. He said that while he knows that a free Tibet is a country that will never concretise, it’s important to keep the idea alive. I’ll add to this: keep the idea alive but non-violently so.</p><p>Another way of looking at the Kashmir-India equation is to say: Look, you can forcefully marry two people but you cannot make them fall in love. They will co-exist but in a living hell. As bureaucrat turned politician Shah Faesal told <em>The</em> <em>Indian Express</em>: ‘A new wave of indignation has begun from August 5. It’s the extremist side that will get traction now. Kashmir might enter a new phase of conflict, which we have never imagined.’</p><p>Good things though can emerge from bad ideas. We shouldn’t rule out that possibility, fight the liberal tendency to sink into an apocalyptic despondency, to compose awful aphorisms in the Twittersphere.</p><p>The Kashmiris can treat this as an ‘opportunity’, forsake violence and grab it with both hands. Perhaps I’m being an optimist but history also has a way of disposing off old ideas and ringing in the new. Hindutva might be here today and gone in forty years. To keep one’s hopes alive, one has to think the long haul.</p><p>To willingly be a part of a larger cosmopolitan Indian identity is not a bad thing in itself; it might even have its temptations. In the long run, integration can work wonders, even as the Hindutva era gradually fades away. All ideologies lose their pull eventually. The lifecycle runs itself out. Even saints turn to dust.</p><p>A recent survey conducted by the Centre of English Identity and Politics at Winchester University found that only one in ten people in England now think that being white is important to being English. What we are seeing here is a form of post-racial identity. Similarly, one can imagine an India of the future where minorities want to be a part of a larger collective identity, an Indian identity, and their religious identities either map neatly onto this larger identity or are slowly erased — the latter is what the Hindu Right wants. The BJP fictionalises and fetishises Hindu hyper-identity.</p><p>As Tom Slater writes on <em>Spiked</em>: ‘I don’t think national identity is anything to demonise. It can in fact offer a more inclusive and expansive identity than the limited racial, gender and sexual identities pushed today by the identitarian left. National identity can provide a framework within which we can transcend our differences.</p><p>But while I don’t think we should demonise Englishness, I don’t think we should fetishise it either. We shouldn’t treat it as something fixed and definable, something that either needs to be rediscovered or built from the ground up. Society is more fluid and complex than that.’</p><p>(A shorter version of this column appeared on DailyO, 13–08–2019.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dfa9bbb5e367" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dubravka Ugresic: Literary Gangster]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/dubravka-ugresic-literary-gangster-3fafaf2fe235?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3fafaf2fe235</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dubravka-ugresic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[croatian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palash-mehrotra]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marquez]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Palash Krishna Mehrotra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Apr 2019 07:35:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T07:35:55.330Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/333/1*U72tg6-LUStiyJZNr2k2rA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Every reader has a go-to writer, an author she can read and re-read, till death does them apart. For me, that writer is Dubravka Ugresic. I go to sleep with her books and wake up with them. She occupies a large slice of my literary soul. Seems exaggerated? Read on.</p><p>Speaking at the New Yorker Festival in 2011, Jhumpa Lahiri described a writer’s writer as someone who writes every book like their first book: “Everybody writes their first book with a certain innocence, a purity of vision. A writer’s writer writes every book that way.” If that is the case, then Ugresic is the writer’s writer’s writer. John Ashbery once called Elizabeth Bishop that.</p><p>The purity of Ugresic’s X-ray vision cannot be doubted, though ‘innocence’ doesn’t quite apply to her. It’s more like what American writer Curtis White said about her work: the writing is shot through with ‘rare cunning’, underlying all of which is a genuinely ‘humbling and inspiring honesty.’ It exudes an ironic ferocity. Ugresic knows the score. No one can fool her. The opposite of innocence.</p><p>Ugresic, I imagine, would be horrified by the phrase, ‘A writer’s writer’s writer’. It scares the reader away. Ugresic is the kind of writer who wants to draw the reader close. When asked in an interview what impact she’d like to leave on a first-time reader of her work, she said: “Remembrance. I hope to be remembered by readers because I wrote something powerful but also pleasurable, and it connected with the reader.<br> <br> “In fact, this is the secret ambition of every writer. The writers I remember are my ‘family.’ They go where I go and are always with me. To be remembered, to be a part of a reader’s personal ‘spiritual’ baggage, to be part of her/his literary family — this is the biggest achievement of a writer.” (<em>World Literature Today</em>). It’s rare to find one’s heroes actually saying what one idealises them as saying. Ugresic is family.</p><p>Ugresic, now 70, is a cult hero, with a voluminous body of work to her name: over twenty titles in Croatian, which include novels, collections of essays and children’s books. Fifteen of these are available in English translation, including her latest essay collection, <em>American Fictionary</em>. Her books been translated into more than twenty languages.</p><p>In 2016, she was awarded the Neustadt prize for International Literature (dubbed the American Nobel), the first non-European woman writer to win it in the four decades of its existence. Previous winners include Paz, Marquez and Bishop. Ugresic was also a finalist for the Man Booker Prize in 2009.</p><p>In the aftermath of the 1991 war in Yugoslavia, Ugresic was a vocal critic of both Croatian and Serbian nationalism, was ostracized and attacked by nationalistic journalists, politicians and fellow-writers. She was forced to flee and settled in exile in Amsterdam.</p><p>The manner in which she was hounded reminds us of the India of today. “Some of my former contemporaries remain dedicated fascists, and others are just a little bit fascist as it suits them. It turns out that nationalism benefits some people very well, which I think is an insight into some of the political rhetoric we’re seeing on the rise again now.”</p><p>I was drawn to Ugresic first because of her scathing, biting essays, which are also hugely entertaining and funny. She uses a light hammer to nail and hang heavy pictures. She writes about exile but also about Americana. In <em>Karaoke Culture</em>, she takes in everything from fan fiction to You Tube stars, and how the Internet is changing our relationship with art.</p><p>In <em>Thank You For Not Reading</em> (brilliantly translated by Celia Hawkesworth, and doggedly kept in print by Dalkey Archive), she sends up modern day book-culture and the cogs that make it. Published in 2003, it bears the stamp of her elegant grumpiness and mischievous sagacity. The essays are generously prefaced with quotes from <em>Winnie the Pooh</em>; Ugresic calls Eeyore “the best-known grumbler in literary history.”</p><p>Ugresic draws an unlikely comparison between the art of Soviet social realism and the books spawned by the capitalist marketplace of today. “Contemporary market literature is realistic, optimistic, joyful, sexy, explicitly or implicitly didactic, and intended for the broad reading masses. As such, it ideologically remoulds and educates the working people in the spirit of personal victory, the victory of some good over evil. It is socialist realist.”</p><p>The fate of the author is doomed in both cultures: “Writers who were unable to the demands of the ideological market ended tragically: in camps. Nowadays, writers who cannot adapt to commercial demands end up in their own ghetto of anonymity and poverty.”</p><p>We live in a time when authors behave like MBAs and editors lack the aesthetic wherewithal and courage to make brave calls about quality literature: “The world of the literary market is ruled by the producers of books, but producing books does not quite mean producing literature.”</p><p>In a parodic essay called “Book Proposal” Ugresic jokes about authors who spend more time writing proposals than the book itself. She imagines sending an editor a proposal for <em>One Hundred Years of Solitude</em>. The editor responds: “Forget the contents! No one could possibly follow that story. But there’s no reason not to use that great title.’” She pretends to be Proust: “I took the trouble to write a book proposal for <em>Remembrance of Things</em> past. It was turned down. Boring, too long, change the title.”</p><p>Here’s Ugresic on trying to sell essays to a literary agent who advises: “Essays, you say? Why don’t you turn those essays into non-fiction narrative?”</p><p>In other essays, she sends up book fairs that have nothing to do with books and editors trying to look like writers by having their photographs taken against a background of bookshelves. These days, in jacket photographs, male writers themselves “increasingly display intelligently formed muscles”; “women writers submit to facelifts.”</p><p>The best strategy for young authors to get published, she says, is to become famous in some other capacity: footballer, actor, chef. In “Low Income Writer” she has a word of warning: “A writer who thinks about his literary environment, not just about the writing itself, had best keep quiet. Hold his tongue. Otherwise he cuts away the branch he is sitting on.”</p><p>A “real writer” is never “sure that he or she is a writer”, “so the publishing industry profits from the low self-confidence of its producers.” “A real writer feels guilty and thinks that what he’s doing is unimportant, or useless or privileged (although he’s not paid for it), while other serious people work. Such writers are always in awe of physicists, carpenters and surgeons, and can always be crushed with the greatest of ease, like a worm or a fly. As soon as he is appealed to in the name of humanism, a writer with low self-esteem immediately forgoes his fee.”</p><p>In “The Aura of Glamour” Ugresic wonders how in the contemporary media market, “literature too has acquired an aura of glamour. How has it come about that all sorts of people are now rushing into the places formerly reserved for outsiders, bookworms, romantics and losers?… What is so attractive about the literary profession today that it makes so many people mill around the marketplace awaiting their starry moment?</p><p>“Tubercular neurotics, humble bunglers, drunks, wastrels, bohemians, thin men and women in black wool sweaters leaning against a well-stocked home bookshelf, short-sighted smokers of pipes and cigars — they are all a thing of the distant past.”</p><p>She answers this question via Milan Kundera who wrote that one day, when everyone writes, nobody will listen. That day has arrived. In other words, sums up Ugresic: “Literacy can have an aura of glamour only where literacy does not exist.”</p><p>(The writer is the author of <em>Eunuch Park: Fifteen Stories of Love &amp; Destruction</em>, published by Penguin India. It was a finalist for the Hindu Prize for Fiction and the Shakti Bhatt First Book Prize. A different version of this piece was first published in Hindu Blink, April 19, 2019)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3fafaf2fe235" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DID WE ALWAYS HAVE IT IN US OR DID MODI MAKE US THIS WAY?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/did-we-always-have-it-in-us-or-did-modi-make-us-this-way-90ca8c8a3b7a?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/90ca8c8a3b7a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[palash-krishna]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[idea-of-india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[modi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-elections-2019]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hindutva-and-hinduism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Palash Krishna Mehrotra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Apr 2019 15:19:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-18T15:19:08.773Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Did we always have it in us or did Modi make us this way?</strong></h3><p>By <strong>Palash Krishna Mehrotra</strong></p><p>These elections, I voted for the first time. I voted because I’m a liberal and I believe that the ‘idea of India’ is under threat. I came across the phrase for the first time, almost two decades ago, when I read <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunil_Khilnani">Sunil Khilnani</a>’s terrific book of the same name.</p><p>Till five years ago, ‘liberal’ wasn’t a word one used consciously. In the last five years the word has been reinvented as a punching-bag category that bhakts could vilify.</p><p>Hindutva is an acquired oppositional identity; it’s oppositional because like any fundamentalist position, it is, in essence, an anti-position: anti-liberal, anti-Nehru, anti-Dalit and anti-Muslim. The only positives that can be added to this, the majoritarian religion (Hinduism) and nation (India), already exist.</p><p>Hindu India was always prejudiced; Hindutva Bharat simply tapped into and exploited these latent tendencies. This is my argument.</p><p>* * *</p><p>Do the people of India feel that the idea of India is under threat? Certainly not.</p><p>It’s the reason why when Mamata Banerjee comes to Delhi and screams: ‘Modi hatao, desh bachao’, the speech comes across as a non sequitur. When Arvind Kejriwal says: “This election is about making sure that Modi and Shah do not return to power, no matter what. It’s about saving India’, it fails to influence the voter.</p><p>The very idea of the Mahagathbandan, a united Opposition based on a positive premise –to save the idea of a plural secular democratic India — comes across as a negative one to the average voter, who asks: “But why do you want to remove Modi?” In the perception battle, Modi is not power hungry, the Opposition is.</p><p>India, both in class and caste, is a deeply divided country; it was always so. The middle-class savarna voter is inherently prejudiced. Dalits, Muslims and farmers’ issues never had any resonance with him.</p><p>We live in segregated cities. In North Indian small towns, Muslims live in Chowk and the Hindus in Civil Lines. We take this for granted.</p><p>In a Dehradun bar, a girl from Welham asks me a question. She has a Muslim boyfriend but they’re thinking of breaking up. It’s too complicated, for both of them. “Do you think my parents will have less of a problem if I marry a Christian?” she wonders aloud.</p><p>Way before the BJP became a force to reckon with, a Christian friend, while driving through crummy West U.P. small towns, made a throwaway remark about Muslims lacking a basic sense of hygiene.</p><p>A Hindu boy, getting a haircut and shave from a Muslim barber, asks him to not shave off the beard completely. The barber asks: ‘How much should I trim?’ The Hindu boy says: ‘As long as it’s not a mulla cut’. The barber is taken aback, then recovers and says gently: “Nowadays everyone keeps a beard. It’s the fashion.”</p><p>An engineer, also a guitarist, is full of bile against Dalits. Anti-Dalit sentiment has always existed in India society; it’s what the caste system is based on. It was exacerbated after the Mandal commission report. Indians still lower their voice when they say, referring to someone: “He’s an SC I’ve heard. That’s why he doesn’t write his surname.” Dalits themselves want to keep it quiet.</p><p>We are, to twist a Millennial phrase, old soul bigots.</p><p>* * *</p><p>I’ve been asking everyone I meet –none of them are raging bhakts — why they are voting for Modi. Modi’s fan base goes beyond pure bhakts. They like Modi, that’s for sure, but none of them feel that the idea of India is under threat. When I talk to them about the atrocities being committed — a Muslim man sitting in slush, being force to eat pork; Dalits being flogged; farmers’ woes not being addressed, their eyes glaze over.</p><p>This applies to the kirana store owner as much as it does to the girl in the short black dress studying to be a criminal lawyer. What’s happening to Dalits and Muslims leaves them cold. They’re just not interested. Hindus never ate beef and so Muslims being killed for transporting cattle is not an issue that affects them. Nor does: how did demonetisation affect the poor Muslim in U.P. and rob him of his livelihood? There’s zero empathy. Any empathy they have is reserved for something imaginary: the fictional genocide of Hindus, apparently ongoing in several countries around the world.</p><p>The more pressing concern is: What’s happening in the IPL match at one in the morning? Is CSK winning? Even in cricket, our other religion, we have poor taste.</p><p>Yogendra Yadav said in a television interview that the narrative against the BJP cannot be changed by a deracinated English-speaking elite but by a charismatic leader who speaks the people’s language.</p><p>I played Kanhaiya Kumar’s speech on You Tube to Nitesh, an umemployed Bihari youth, a former Uber Eats rider, now out of work. His best friend is an Ansari, a Muslim embroiderer, also out of work.</p><p>Nitesh and Ansari are Modi supporters. The fact of their unemployment does not rankle them. Nitesh hails from the same part of Bihar as Kanhaiya. Ansari is from Chhapra. I am a fan of Kanhaiya and I tried to make one out of Nitesh. I tried to change the narrative, in not just his language, but his dialect. He walked off after five minutes of watching Kanhaiya, calling him a ‘ch***ya’.</p><p>Nitesh is not on WhatApp, but he watches Hindi news channels 24/7. They are full of glowing admiration for Modi. So is Nitesh.</p><p>He was thrilled when Modi announced the six-thousand-a- year direct transfer scheme for farmers. He turned to Ansari and said: “Chalo yaar Ansari, let’s go back to the village and get registered as farmers. Arre kuch to ayega jeb main.”</p><p>* * *</p><p>The idea of a secular modern India was always a Kantian “ought” and it served us well. But “ought” does not imply “is” forever. The lack of empathy on the part of the non-tax paying Hindu majority for the minorities, tribal Christians and the downtrodden is entrenched. It has been so even before Modi and the BJP worked it to their advantage. The hardware, the phone, was already on the table, all the BJP had to do was change the SIM card.</p><p>Let us not blame only Modi and Shah. They did not invent this hatred. They activated it. To that extent they are responsible. The genie is out of the bag and will be difficult to bottle. Lip-service has its advantages in a democracy. And yet, lip-service doesn’t change the truth. Lip-service is also hypocrisy.</p><p>A majoritarian savarna Hindu population does not for a moment believe that the idea of India is under fire. On the contrary, they believe that the idea of India is on a roll.</p><p>It’s possible that the Congress will win or a coalition government will take centre-stage. But this is not because the people have voted to save the idea of India. It will be for local reasons, regional issues, immediate agrarian distress (the selling price of sugarcane), arithmetic.</p><p>The majoritarian Indian voter is a veteran of democracy. She knows how to extract benefits by changing governments regularly, how to scare and spur the government into some kind of action, especially when elections are round the corner. She uses that Damocles sword for personal gain. But she’s not doing it to save the idea of India.</p><p>Even the Congress is continuing the good work of the BJP in the states it has won, like Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh. ‘Cattle smugglers’ are being arrested, more money is being channelled into gaushalas, astrologers are being given jobs in government hospitals. This is the majoritarian agenda. This is what people want. Hindu majoritarianism is here to stay because it is who we are, no matter who runs the government.</p><p>We are not the Irish who’d moved on in a generation. Church attendance collapsed, gay marriage was legalised and a half-Indian gay man was appointed head of state. Patriotism and hyper-nationalism passed into the realm of the uncool, the tacky, something beloved of third-world teenagers and nutty Americans. The new generation in India does not leave anything behind. It carries the past with it.</p><p>Modi is a rabble-rouser in the classic mould. In a country fascinated by spiritual gurus, he’s taken on that role as well. His ‘discourses’ combine the religious with the political. But no matter how seductive his charisma might be, he couldn’t have pulled off what he has, if the bulk of Indians were not what they are: brutal, insensitive, prejudiced, instinctual, money-minded, religious, selfish, anti-intellectual. They used free data not to discover the world but the hatred within (and pornography).</p><p>The photoshopped anti-Nehru fakery on WhatsApp University couldn’t have been able to lay down roots unless the soil was already amenable. The BJP and the RSS only added some fertilizer.</p><p>In such conditions, misanthropy cannot be avoided. It’s hard to like one’s fellow citizens. By doing this, one plays into the Hindu Right’s polarising agenda. The BJP wins again. That is the depressing truth.</p><p>* * *</p><p>Meanwhile, it’s not unlikely that at least some in the minority community will start following the Hindu Pied Piper’s agenda. It’s a version of: if –you-can’t-beat-em-join em. It’s a little more complicated.</p><p>In his book <em>Keeping the Peace: Spatial Differences in Hindu Muslim Violence in Gujarat in 2002</em> (CUP), Raheel Dhattiwala hints at Muslims gradually accepting “the presence of a national identity overlapping a gradually subsiding religious identity.” He writes: “Respondents blamed members of their own religion — and indirectly, their own selves — for the new found ‘compromise’ in favour of the BJP.”</p><p>“A Muslim supporter of the BJP, Shaukat, believed that ‘Hindus hate us because we behave uncouthly and are illiterate’; another Muslim BJP supporter, Aijaz, similarly attributed anti-Muslim sentiment to ‘our own illiteracy and jahalat (darkness and ignorance)’.”</p><p>Another way of looking at this is: first comes the Stockholm syndrome, which causes hostages to develop a psychological alliance with their captors as a survival strategy during captivity. This then transitions to the Helsinki syndrome in which a person being held captive begins to identify with and grow sympathetic to his or her captor, simultaneously becoming unsympathetic towards the police or other authorities.</p><p>The majority is already with Modi. Once the Muslim and the Dalit quit eating beef and fall in love with him, the dream of the Hindu Rashtra will have been fully realised, albeit minus the tricolour fluttering in Lahore.</p><p>Perhaps this why Ansari, the embroiderer, went with Nitesh, the Uber Eats rider, to see the Ram Lila every night. Perhaps this is why they hate Kanhaiya. Perhaps this is why Ansari has erased his Muslim name and prefers it when people call him, simply, ‘Jharkandi’.</p><p>I dread the day I’ll spot him riding pillion on a kanwariya’s motorcycle. Only a lynching might spare him that fate.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=90ca8c8a3b7a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Did Modi make us this way or did we always have it in us?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@palashkrishnamehrotra/did-modi-make-us-this-way-or-did-we-always-have-it-in-us-ef8ad00562f0?source=rss-87e2781d8d4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef8ad00562f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[narendra-modi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palash]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-elections-2019]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hindutva-and-hinduism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Palash Krishna Mehrotra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Apr 2019 10:59:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-24T15:01:40.399Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wrL6C3PcfAPdsIwx" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@fancycrave?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Fancycrave</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>These elections, I voted for the first time. I voted because I’m a liberal and I believe that the ‘idea of India’ is under threat. I came across the phrase for the first time, almost two decades ago, when I read <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunil_Khilnani">Sunil Khilnani</a>’s terrific book of the same name.</p><p>Till five years ago, ‘liberal’ wasn’t a word one used consciously. In the last five years the word has been reinvented as a punching-bag category that bhakts could vilify.</p><p>Hindutva is an acquired oppositional identity; it’s oppositional because like any fundamentalist position, it is, in essence, an anti-position: anti-liberal, anti-Nehru, anti-Dalit and anti-Muslim. The only positives that can be added to this, the majoritarian religion (Hinduism) and nation (India), already exist.</p><p>Hindu India was always prejudiced; Hindutva Bharat simply tapped into and exploited these latent tendencies. This is my argument.</p><p>***</p><p>Do the people of India feel that the idea of India is under threat? Certainly not.</p><p>It’s the reason why when Mamata Banerjee comes to Delhi and screams: ‘Modi hatao, desh bachao’, the speech comes across as a non sequitur. When Arvind Kejriwal says: “This election is about making sure that Modi and Shah do not return to power, no matter what. It’s about saving India’, it fails to influence the voter.</p><p>The very idea of the Mahagathbandan, a united Opposition based on a positive premise –to save the idea of a plural secular democratic India — comes across as a negative one to the average voter, who asks: “But why do you want to remove Modi?” In the perception battle, Modi is not power hungry, the Opposition is.</p><p>India, both in class and caste, is a deeply divided country; it was always so. The middle-class savarna voter is inherently prejudiced. Dalits, Muslims and farmers’ issues never had any resonance with him.</p><p>We live in segregated cities. In North Indian small towns, Muslims live in Chowk and the Hindus in Civil Lines. We take this for granted.</p><p>In a Dehradun bar, a girl from Welham asks me a question. She has a Muslim boyfriend but they’re thinking of breaking up. It’s too complicated, for both of them. “Do you think my parents will have less of a problem if I marry a Christian?” she wonders aloud.</p><p>Way before the BJP became a force to reckon with, a Christian friend, while driving through crummy West U.P. small towns, made a throwaway remark about Muslims lacking a basic sense of hygiene.</p><p>A Hindu boy, getting a haircut and shave from a Muslim barber, asks him to not shave off the beard completely. The barber asks: ‘How much should I trim?’ The Hindu boy says: ‘As long as it’s not a mulla cut’. The barber is taken aback, then recovers and says gently: “Nowadays everyone keeps a beard. It’s the fashion.”</p><p>An engineer, also a guitarist, is full of bile against Dalits. Anti-Dalit sentiment has always existed in India society; it’s what the caste system is based on. It was exacerbated after the Mandal commission report. Indians still lower their voice when they say, referring to someone: “He’s an SC I’ve heard. That’s why he doesn’t write his surname.” Dalits themselves want to keep it quiet.</p><p>We are, to twist a Millennial phrase, old soul bigots.</p><p>***</p><p>I’ve been asking everyone I meet –none of them are raging bhakts — why they are voting for Modi. Modi’s fan base goes beyond pure bhakts. They like Modi, that’s for sure, but none of them feel that the idea of India is under threat. When I talk to them about the atrocities being committed — a Muslim man sitting in slush, being force to eat pork; Dalits being flogged; farmers’ woes not being addressed, their eyes glaze over.</p><p>This applies to the kirana store owner as much as it does to the girl in the short black dress studying to be a criminal lawyer. What’s happening to Dalits and Muslims leaves them cold. They’re just not interested. Hindus never ate beef and so Muslims being killed for transporting cattle is not an issue that affects them. Nor does: how did demonetisation affect the poor Muslim in U.P. and rob him of his livelihood? <strong>There’s zero empathy. Any empathy they have is reserved for something imaginary: the fictional genocide of Hindus, apparently ongoing in several countries around the world.</strong></p><p>The more pressing concern is: What’s happening in the IPL match at one in the morning? Is CSK winning? Even in cricket, our other religion, we have poor taste.</p><p>Yogendra Yadav said in a television interview that the narrative against the BJP cannot be changed by a deracinated English-speaking elite but by a charismatic leader who speaks the people’s language.</p><p>I played Kanhaiya Kumar’s speech on You Tube to Nitesh, an umemployed Bihari youth, a former Uber Eats rider, now out of work. His best friend is an Ansari, a Muslim embroiderer, also out of work.</p><p>Nitesh and Ansari are Modi supporters. The fact of their unemployment does not rankle them. Nitesh hails from the same part of Bihar as Kanhaiya. Ansari is from Chhapra. I am a fan of Kanhaiya and I tried to make one out of Nitesh. I tried to change the narrative, in not just his language, but his dialect. He walked off after five minutes of watching Kanhaiya, calling him a ‘ch***ya’.</p><p>Nitesh is not on WhatApp, but he watches Hindi news channels 24/7. They are full of glowing admiration for Modi. So is Nitesh.</p><p>He was thrilled when Modi announced the six-thousand-a- year direct transfer scheme for farmers. He turned to Ansari and said: “Chalo yaar Ansari, let’s go back to the village and get registered as farmers. Arre kuch to ayega jeb main.”</p><p>***</p><p>The idea of a secular modern India was always a Kantian “ought” and it served us well. But “ought” does not imply “is” forever. The lack of empathy on the part of the non-tax paying Hindu majority for the minorities, tribal Christians and the downtrodden is entrenched. It has been so even before Modi and the BJP worked it to their advantage. <strong>The hardware, the phone, was already on the table, all the BJP had to do was change the SIM card.</strong></p><p>Let us not blame only Modi and Shah. They did not invent this hatred. They activated it. To that extent they are responsible. The genie is out of the bag and will be difficult to bottle. Lip-service has its advantages in a democracy. And yet, lip-service doesn’t change the truth. Lip-service is also hypocrisy.</p><p><strong>A majoritarian savarna Hindu population does not for a moment believe that the idea of India is under fire. On the contrary, they believe that the idea of India is on a roll.</strong></p><p>It’s possible that the Congress will win or a coalition government will take centre stage. But this is not because the people have voted to save the idea of India. It will be for local reasons, regional issues, immediate agrarian distress (the selling price of sugarcane), arithmetic.</p><p>The majoritarian Indian voter is a veteran of democracy. She knows how to extract benefits by changing governments regularly, how to scare and spur the government into some kind of action, especially when elections are round the corner. She uses that Damocles sword for personal gain. But she’s not doing it to save the idea of India.</p><p>Even the Congress is continuing the good work of the BJP in the states it has won, like Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh. ‘Cattle smugglers’ are being arrested, more money is being channelled into gaushalas, astrologers are being given jobs in government hospitals. This is the majoritarian agenda. This is what people want. Hindu majoritarianism is here to stay because it is who we are, no matter who runs the government.</p><p>We are not the Irish who’d moved on in a generation. Church attendance collapsed, gay marriage was legalised and a half-Indian gay man was appointed head of state. Patriotism and hyper-nationalism passed into the realm of the uncool, the tacky, something beloved of third-world teenagers and nutty Americans. The new generation in India does not leave anything behind. It carries the past with it.</p><p><strong>Modi is a rabble-rouser in the classic mould. In a country fascinated by spiritual gurus, he’s taken on that role as well. His ‘discourses’ combine the religious with the political. But no matter how seductive his charisma might be, he couldn’t have pulled off what he has, if the bulk of Indians were not what they are: brutal, insensitive, prejudiced, instinctual, money-minded, religious, selfish, anti-intellectual. They used free data not to discover the world but the hatred within (and pornography).</strong></p><p><strong>The photoshopped anti-Nehru fakery on WhatsApp University couldn’t have been able to lay down roots unless the soil was already amenable. The BJP and the RSS only added some fertilizer.</strong></p><p>In such conditions, misanthropy cannot be avoided. It’s hard to like one’s fellow citizens. By doing this, one plays into the Hindu Right’s polarising agenda. The BJP wins again. That is the depressing truth.</p><p>***</p><p>Meanwhile, it’s not unlikely that at least some in the minority community will start following the Hindu Pied Piper’s agenda. It’s a version of: if –you-can’t-beat-em-join em. It’s a little more complicated.</p><p>In her book <em>Keeping the Peace: Spatial Differences in Hindu Muslim Violence in Gujarat in 2002</em> (CUP), Raheel Dhattiwala hints at Muslims gradually accepting “the presence of a national identity overlapping a gradually subsiding religious identity.” He writes: “Respondents blamed members of their own religion — and indirectly, their own selves — for the new found ‘compromise’ in favour of the BJP.</p><p>“A Muslim supporter of the BJP, Shaukat, believed that ‘Hindus hate us because we behave uncouthly and are illiterate’; another Muslim BJP supporter, Aijaz, similarly attributed anti-Muslim sentiment to ‘our own illiteracy and jahalat (darkness and ignorance)’.”</p><p>Another way of looking at this is: first comes the Stockholm syndrome, which causes hostages to develop a psychological alliance with their captors as a survival strategy during captivity. This then transitions to the Helsinki syndrome in which a person being held captive begins to identify with and grow sympathetic to his or her captor, simultaneously becoming unsympathetic towards the police or other authorities.</p><p>The majority is already with Modi. Once the Muslim and the Dalit quit eating beef and fall in love with him, the dream of the Hindu Rashtra will have been fully realised, albeit minus the tricolour fluttering in Lahore.</p><p><strong>Perhaps this is why Ansari, the embroiderer, went with Nitesh, the Uber Eats rider, to see the Ram Lila every night. Perhaps this is why they hate Kanhaiya. Perhaps this is why Ansari has erased his Muslim name and prefers it when people call him, simply, ‘Jharkandi’.</strong></p><p>I dread the day I’ll spot him riding pillion on a kanwariya’s motorcycle. Only a lynching might spare him that fate.</p><p>(The writer is the author of <em>The Butterfly Generation</em> and the editor of <em>House Spirit: Drinking in India.</em>)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef8ad00562f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>