<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by ParisTech Review on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by ParisTech Review on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@paristechreview?source=rss-bfeecc5b3f18------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 00:29:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@paristechreview/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What to do with urban biomass? Energy, of course!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@paristechreview/what-to-do-with-urban-biomass-energy-of-course-c2035b0254d4?source=rss-bfeecc5b3f18------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c2035b0254d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[biogas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy-transition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biomass]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ParisTech Review]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Apr 2015 10:15:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-16T10:15:34.324Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>While the world suffers from energy shortages, there is still one resource that we are able to produce up to 1300 million tons a year on the global scale.</h4><p>While energy supply is becoming a major issue for global economy, new sources of energy are emerging or developing. The production of energy through waste recovery and recycling is part of this tendency. This process offers two benefits: it reduces our environmental footprint and increases the proportion of renewable energies in our energy mix. What techniques exactly are used, what is available potential, which fields are most innovative? An interview with Jean-François Nogrette, CEO of <a href="http://sarpi.pl/en/about-us-sarp-industries.php">SARP Industries</a> — a subsidiary company of Veolia specialized in special waste processing.</p><p>While the world suffers from energy shortages, there is still one resource that we are able to produce up to 1300 million tons a year on the global scale — in other terms, 1.2 kg per day and per city dweller. The production of this resource has doubled in ten years and should increase according to the same rates during the next decade.</p><p>This resource has nothing magical. It doesn’t come from a secret underground deposit, or from a mysterious micro-alga of a new kind. It comes directly from our garbage cans. The figures above are provided by a report published in 2013 by the World Bank, titled <em>What a Waste: A Global Review of Solid Waste Management</em>. This report only examines municipal waste.</p><p>The production of industrial and agricultural waste is much more difficult to assess, as there is no standardized data on the subject. A study published in 2009, titled <em>From Waste to Resource — An Abstract of World Waste Survey</em>, estimated that the global yearly production of industrial waste (leaving out the construction and mining sector) reached 1.7 to 2.1 billion tons. <a href="http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/waste/key_waste_streams/waste_excluding_major_mineral_wastes">According to Eurostat</a>, in the EU alone, the overall domestic, agricultural and industrial waste (leaving out the construction and mining sector) reaches approximately 900 million tons per year, in other terms, a yearly production of over 1800 kg per inhabitant.</p><p>What can we do with all this waste? The increasing importance of ecological issues has led to search for ways to reduce their production. But another method is to consider them as a valuable resource. Their transformation into energy responds to this challenge. What volumes are we talking about? What are the techniques that are used?</p><p>Energy can be produced by the recovery of waste. There are two main approaches that are adapted to domestic waste and industrial waste. The first is incineration and the second is anaerobic digestion.</p><p><strong>The future of incineration</strong> Used for decades, especially to fuel district heating plants, incineration doesn’t have a very good reputation. It does indeed eliminate a good part of waste and seems difficult to replace today: in OECD countries, 39% of domestic waste is processed this way (<a href="http://stats.oecd.org/BrandedView.aspx?oecd_bv_id=env-data-en&amp;doi=data-00601-en#">stats from 2011</a>) . But pollution is the main problem of this technique. In modern plants, the emission of dioxins and dust has been significantly reduced, but the remaining bottom ashes are still very toxic.</p><p>As reminded by Nogrette, “incinerators of domestic waste » produce a significant amount of energy”. To take the EU, this production covers 8% of the overall renewable energies, a proportion that can be compared to solar energy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/321/0*FHa1puG2i9IUMJmI.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Source European Union</em></figcaption></figure><p>The performances are still modest: to generate the same amount of energy as 1 ton of fuel oil, it is considered that you need 5 to 7 tons of waste. The modernization of the plants could still increase the output. Denmark is the European leader of power and heat production per inhabitant: the kingdom’s thirty plants consume 3.5 million tons of waste per year and cover 5% of the domestic demand of electricity and 20% of heat.</p><p>Africa is also beginning to produce electricity from household waste. In 2010, the first African production unit of electric power from domestic waste was launched in Ifrane, Marocco.</p><p><strong>Developing biogas</strong> As an alternative to incineration, anaerobic digestion is today a promising way to recover the biomass while mitigating the negative impacts on the environment, by letting nature do part of the work. Many countries have adopted this method that enables them to process a wide range of waste: wastewaters, sludge from wastewater treatment plants, household waste, animal manure, as well as the waste from the food industry…</p><p>Biogas (a mix of methane and CO2) is produced through fermentation, either by a “digestion” process in an appropriate facility, or else by burying waste in special landfills that produce gas during roughly 12 years. This solution was chosen in the UK.</p><p>Gas is generally used to produce electricity. It can also feed cogeneration units that produce both electricity and heat. This solution is widely used in Germany where farms have also anaerobic digestion facilities that produce organic manure for spreading. Part of the biogas (15% to 25%) is used to heat the “digesters” or to power the site.</p><p>Not all kinds of waste have the same energy value. In treatment plants, only highly energy matter is used to produce biogas: sugars, fats, and proteins. The productivity of methane can reach from 3 to 18 m3 per ton. For household waste, organic matter is more or less mixed with other kinds of waste and productivity can vary a lot, although it is generally much higher: between 50 to 90 m3 per ton.</p><p>Across all facilities, the production of biogas represents today about 6% of the primary production of renewable energy in Europe. A crucial lever for the development of this sector is the feed-in tariff (FIT) of the electricity produced from biogas. In the US, the price is set according to the energy policy. Germany, with its proactive policy, remains undoubtedly the European leader in this field, although FITs were significantly reduced in the recent years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/305/0*5JCWnjEv5SENdz33.jpg" /><figcaption><em>EU: the biggest biogas producers (in ktoe) Source: EurObservers</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Biofuels from recycling</strong> Recovery procedures aren’t the only way to transform waste into energy. Other activities are being developed around recycling. Unlike the recovery procedures mentioned above, they recover used material and process it so that it can be re-used.</p><p>Fuel can be produced by recycling specific kinds of waste oil. For instance: engine lubricants, residues recovered from hydrocarbon separators or from industrial vats. These contaminated petroleum products are re-distilled and can be used in industrial boilers. According to Jean-François Nogrette, “the challenge is that this recovery is very disseminated.” Obviously, this highly polluting waste is the main target of public authorities, which can finance their recovery or even make it compulsory. A French law from December 2006 imposes the implementation of hydrocarbon separators in service stations and in parking facilities that are exposed to significant amount of hydrocarbons. However, the overall volume of collected hydrocarbons will certainly not lead to the rise of a new sector: the aim is rather to mitigate pollution.</p><p>Agricultural waste provides another resource that is beginning to be re-used: bioethanol, produced from cellulose and lignin. Sometimes, vegetal waste, such as straw is even used. In 2009, Abengoa Bioenergy, a world producer of bioethanol, launched a production unit of lignocellulose-based bioethanol with a production capacity of 5 million liters, in Babilafuente, in Spain. The bioethanol sector has also been developed in some emergent countries (China, Brazil, South Africa) from manioc, sugar plants and cereals.</p><p>In the North, other more plentiful resources, easier to collect than oil, are being tapped. Since 2009, SARP Industries, in its Limay plant, produces 40 000 tons a year of biodiesel from fatty waste, mainly food oils. This feeds each year 300 trucks in B30, a fuel that contains 30% of biodiesel.</p><p>This is “second generation” biodiesel, as opposed to the first generation developed from oil plants (colza, soya, palm). The main benefit of the second generation is that is doesn’t use any cropland.</p><p>However, the produced volumes are very modest: used frying oil is certainly not an infinite resource! By contrast, the European leader of first generation biodiesel, Diester Industrie, has produced 2.1 million tons of biodiesel in 2011 in 13 European facilities, for an overall production capacity of 2 million tons, according to <a href="http://www.eurobserv-er.org/pdf/baro210.pdf">2012 data from the European observatory of biofuels</a>, EurObserv’ER.</p><p>To proper, the recycled fuel sector needs to rely on an effective collection system, that isn’t always easy to implement. “Some fatty waste recycled for non-energetic uses, such as recycled lubricating oil, are collected in Europe thanks to the virtuous systems that have been implemented for many years,” says Nogrette. “But for frying oil, it’s more difficult: restaurants aren’t necessarily very enthusiastic to keep used oil in cans where it could solidify, etc.”</p><p>The situation varies a lot from one country to another, even between neighbor countries. In France, despite the theoretic ban to reject used food oil through the public wastewater treatment network, or to through in landfills, the estimated collection rate is only 20%, whereas it reaches 50% in Belgium. The volume collected per year and per inhabitant is also an interesting fact that enables to get a clearer picture of the disparities: 600 grams in France versus 2300 grams in Belgium.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/326/0*hl2srGENNDMPVEjU.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Recovery of used food oils (grams/year/inhabitant)</em></figcaption></figure><p>“The production of second generation biodiesel from waste is minute compared with conventional petroleum diesel, and things will stay as they are,” according to Nogrette. “For instance, at this day, the French law provides an incorporation rate of 7% of biofuel in service stations. In the specific case of diesel, second generation biodiesel is only a 0,35% share of these 7%.”</p><p>The benefit of biodiesel produced with used oils is elsewhere. First of all, there is a dual impact on the environment: the recovery of polluting waste on one hand and the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions thanks to the replacement of traditional diesel, on the other hand. This double benefit has an economic value and can serve as a basis for business models.</p><p><strong>The economics of waste </strong>In Europe, the guidelines implemented by the European Commission promote the use of biofuel produced from waste and residues. These count as double in the 20% of renewable energies in public transports by 2020. More generally, in developed countries, compulsory regulations encourage increasingly recycling and the treatment of the most polluting waste. Treatment has a cost that can be charged to the waste producers. The sector will then combine service (waste treatment) and production that separately will not be beneficial but will integrate in a more complex value chain. Today, waste treatment specialists are learning today to work on both sides of the fence, by producing energy or raw materials without abandoning their original treatment activities.</p><p>Within the new models that are being implemented, the production of fuel or energy plays sometimes a complementary role. For wastewater treatment, for instance, the recovery of biogas aims simply at achieving energy self-sufficiency of treatment plants, by feeding electric turbines with the produced gas. Today, the Braunschweig and Budapest plants cover almost all of their needs by methanizing their sludge with co-products, such as expired goods from supermarkets. Methane can also be used locally in gas networks or as fuel, but these are limited uses.</p><p>Jean-François Nogrette highlights a key issue for the development of the recycling sector: trust. “Historically, recycled products are seen as second category products: recycled paper was bought to help make the world a little greener, knowing that recycled paper is clearly less attractive… For fuel, or engine oil, this becomes a real issue because consumers don’t want a lower quality product for this kind of use.”</p><p>To mitigate this image problem, Veolia has set up a partnership with Total for its recycling plant of engine lubricant oil, Osilub, that has recently opened in Normandy: recycled products are sold under a brand, Total, that is acknowledged by the consumers as a producer of “mainstream” products. “From a technical point of view, we have to offer the same quality as if the product were, so to speak, new,” adds Nogrette.</p><p>Apart from the trust of consumers, the growth of these activities relies on political commitment and regulation. Proactive public policies can help structure this sector and make it grow. It is already the case in Europe where, apart from quotas and objectives established by environmental policies, member states assign lower taxes for recycled fuel than for conventional petroleum products.</p><p>However, this political support also produces some negative effects. “As happened for other products, speculation on raw material, specifically waste, is beginning to appear,” according to Jean-François Nogrette. “Today, many American frying oils are exported to Germany, because of the tax benefits…” This is certainly a paradox for a sector that claims to be virtuous in terms of environmental impact… As noted by Jean-François Nogrette, “there’s an economy of waste, with everything the word “economy” involves.”</p><p>For investors, this is a sector with a huge potential because, as explained by Jean-François Nogrette, “the waste industry is increasingly evolving towards a transformation industry. For example, ten years ago, product sales were 1% of the turnover of SARP Industries, the subsidiary of Veolia specialized in special waste. Today, this proportion has reached 25%. The company has now become a producer of raw materials.”</p><p>Companies of this sector show a growing tendency of moving from the sorting of waste to the regeneration of raw materials and are getting involved in new business models. As consequence of the transformation of the sector, the entire value chain is growing and some activities that didn’t even exist 15 years ago are booming today, offering new opportunities.</p><p>Research and development can play a crucial role to identify these opportunities and design solutions. In close collaboration with researchers, Veolia and its American competitors are working on the liquefaction of polymers to produce liquid fuel — a source of energy that can be stored, unlike electricity. Beyond waste, many other organic resources can be recycled. An evolution that will be most interesting to follow.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c2035b0254d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Which future for hydrogen and fuel cells?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@paristechreview/which-future-for-hydrogen-and-fuel-cells-29c35fe5695?source=rss-bfeecc5b3f18------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/29c35fe5695</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[energy-transition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fuel-cell]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hydrogen]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ParisTech Review]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 10 Apr 2015 14:36:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-10T14:38:15.075Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An interview with Hélène Pierre (GDF-SUEZ, treasurer of the French Association for Hydrogen and Fuel Cell)</h4><h3>There are as many challenges ahead if we want hydrogen to be a significant part of the future energy mix. Actions are under way. Let us discover them!</h3><p><strong>ParisTech Review —</strong><em> In today’s context of changing energy systems, the hydrogen and fuel cell industry is often cited. What exactly do these terms cover?</em></p><p><strong>Hélène Pierre</strong> — Hydrogen is an element that has been used for decades by industry. Producing hydrogen, for instance, is quite simple: you just need water and electricity. In electrolysis of water with an electric current, the hydrogen and the oxygen molecules are separated.</p><p>The <a href="http://www.hydrogenics.com/technology-resources/hydrogen-technology/fuel-cells">fuel cell technology</a> enables us to operate the recombination process. Its principle was discovered in the 19th Century, but recent improvements have made it more relevant to today’s challenges. A fuel cell is a device that converts the chemical potential energy (the energy stored in molecular bonds) of the hydrogen gas (H2) into electrical energy. The fuel? Hydrogen gas and oxygen gas (02). The products of the reaction in the cell are water, electricity, and heat. In other words, the hydrogen and fuel cell industry proposes a solution to the problem of transforming and storing excess production of electricity from intermittent renewable energy sources, such as solar panels or wind turbines. That is why hydrogen is raising a lot of interest in the ongoing debate on energy transition.</p><p>The advantages of this technology are numerous. First of all, we can transform the unused renewable energies into hydrogen and store it for later use. In other words, it is equivalent to storing electricity over long periods of time — electricity which would otherwise have been lost. Secondly, no need to transform the hydrogen into electricity: it can used as a fuel or a source of heating, alone or combined with other gases such, for example, as methane natural gas. Thirdly, hydrogen encourages a territorial approach to energy production With renewable energies production is increasingly decentralized. It is consequently important to use them on a territorial scale and reduce the distance between production and consumption sites.</p><p><em>Given that hydrogen has already been used in industry for a long time now, how do you explain the upsurge in its attractiveness?</em></p><p>Techniques to obtain hydrogen by electrolysis have existed for a long time, notably alkaline technologies. But these technologies have evolved quite considerably, as is the case for hydrogen production with the introduction on the markets of Proton Exchange Membrane electrolysis. Extensive research and development in this area have accelerated the technologies, contributing to a sizeable drop in equipment costs. The objective is to obtain highly flexible electrolysis units, capable of instantly valorizing excess production of renewable energies. For this purpose, it must be possible, on one hand, to simply start and stop the units and, on the other hand, to have perfectly efficient units when operated at either full or low loads. This flexibility factor is important for the renewable energy markets, inasmuch as it allows for storing the production which is not consumed and therefore effectively reduces losses. The progress observed in electrolytic technologies holds great promise for the future, given that they are becoming increasingly efficient, from both technical and economic points of view. This clearly explains the renewed attractiveness of the hydrogen and fuel cell sector!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/0*9544jxWxDnW_ioOu.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Fuel cell developed by CEA in 2006 for the automotive industry</em> (©P. Stroppa/CEA)</figcaption></figure><p><em>What are the principal uses for hydrogen?</em></p><p>Apart from storing electricity, hydrogen can be valorized when mixed with methane natural gas. We are partners in the demonstrator GRHYD Project at Dunkirk (northern France), the objective of which is to explore the possibility of injecting hydrogen into the domestic gas distribution networks. This project will provide a new valorization for electricity produced via renewable energy sources. The aim is to assess the technical, economic and environmental relevance of this process called power to gas.</p><p>There are two aspects to the GHRYD project. On one hand, we study the feasibility of injecting hydrogen into the gas networks, with varying proportions (with up to 20% H2) to supply a new neighborhood with 200 lodgings, without needing to change either collective or private equipment. The aim is to make use of the excess renewable production of electricity, notably generated by wind turbines, through storing the energy as hydrogen and injecting this gas into the gas network, as and when needed. In doing so, we shall be able to study how the gas mix behaves in the distribution network, feeding a gas burning heat generator, and assessing the impact of possible variations. The objective is to be able to inject hydrogen in varying percentages, as a function of its availability, so as not to be required to produce hydrogen just to feed the network. We are therefore seeking to develop a flexible system at an acceptable cost.</p><p>On the other hand, the GHYD Project will allow us to test a compound fuel, with natural gas for vehicles (NGV) plus a proportion of hydrogen, from 6% to 20% max. In the long term, some fifty buses will be operated with this mixed gas fuel in Dunkirk and its surroundings. We aim here to study the behavior of the vehicles while valorizing the renewable energy sources. The advantage here is that the hydrogen will contribute to “greening” the fuel consumed. And if the hydrogen is produced from already “green” energy sources, this adds a renewable fraction, inasmuch as it will decrease overall CO2 emissions. Moreover, adding hydrogen improves the mixed fuel efficiency — as was observed during a previous project in Dunkirk, 2004–2009. There is no need to modify the NGV engines. In other words, the solution proposed is attractive, not only from an ecological but also an economic point of view.</p><p><em>Are we to understand that it is possible to see vehicles running on either a methane gas-hydrogen mix or on pure hydrogen?</em></p><p>Indeed; many countries are now engaged in development along these lines. Fuel cells come in various power ratings, from small domestic appliances installed in homes to large industrial installations, ranging from 1 kW to 1 MW. They can easily be fitted in vehicles along with a compressed hydrogen tank. By transforming the hydrogen into electricity, the cell feeds the vehicle’s electric propulsion system. It is estimated that a fuel cell of this type would offer a range of between 300 to 500 km<em>, i.e.,</em> far more than with an all-electric (battery driven) vehicle. Moreover, no major modifications are needed for the electric motor proper. Also, we can note numerous ongoing R&amp;D studies into fuel cell technologies and onboard storage systems with a view to reducing the space taken up by the fuel cell in the limited volume of the vehicles, optimizing the attainable range and lowering the cost factors. The first fuel cell vehicles introduced to the market place have proved successful sales. Toyota, for example, have started mass-producing and selling its Mirai model.</p><p>So-called “stationary” fuel cells are being developed, designed for installation in private premises, supplying the homes with both heat and electricity in a technique called co-generation. Cells in this category can also be used to feed electric vehicles. In Japan, some 100,000 stationary fuel cell installations have been assembled and run directly in the natural gas network. This alone proves that the technology is developing well and can be installed rapidly.</p><p><em>Does this suggest that recharge and stationary fuel cells infrastructures need to be installed in service stations?</em></p><p>Again the answer is yes; today we stand at a special cross-roads in time. We shall need to build a charging infrastructure, with specific hydrogen service stations. A study carried out in Germany, in England and France has led to a roadmap of how the infrastructures would be deployed over the coming twenty years. In France, we have a consortium of actors working on this thematic (H2 Mobility France) who have taken the option to proceed by clusters. The policy would call for first installing local <em>ad hoc</em> service stations for captive hydrogen vehicle fleets (company-owned or by local authorities). This category of vehicle usually only travels for short distances and returns to the depot in the evening. It is therefore perfectly adapted to the infrastructure. The next steps would be to extend the network of stations, progressively covering the country completely.</p><p><em>You also mentioned co-generation…</em></p><p>Fuel cells supply electricity and heat with high efficiency levels, especially for the electricity. Stationary fuel cells — installed in residential areas and fed by natural gas from the existing gas distribution network — are already supplying households with heat and electric power. In urban areas, these natural gas (CH4) distribution networks (or with a CH4-H2 mix) will prove to be truly efficient energy supply tools. That is what the GHRYD Project is designed to demonstrate.</p><p><em>What are the challenges the industry must now face?</em></p><p>Regulatory aspects are essential, inasmuch as they serve to guarantee safe use of equipment, whatever the uses. For the time being, hydrogen is used almost exclusively by industrial sectors. Regulations were framed but were not adapted to fuel cells used to recharge a mobile phone or to run a vehicle. A general public use calls for adapted regulations both for stationary and mobile uses. However, the rules must be drafted in concertation with the actors in the field so as to assure a proper balance and not block development of the sector by excessive rigidity or complexity. That is why we are working, among others, with Ineris, the French National Competence Centre for Industrial Safety and Environmental Protection.</p><p>Another challenge is that related to costs, which today are far higher than those of existing systems. The objective assigned to the R&amp;D studies also consists of optimizing equipment efficiency and decreasing their operational costs, or to put it differently, obtaining a better price/performance ratio. Industrializing electrolysis unit, thereby producing large quantities of hydrogen, will lower equipment costs and the final cost will go down more and more rapidly. In the last resort, the cost of producing hydrogen relates to the cost of generating electricity. We can safely forecast that, in the long term, a massive production of renewable source electricity will lower costs considerably.</p><p>Societal acceptance by the public at large will be a real challenge! There are many preconceived ideas about the level of risk associated with hydrogen. Improving user perception of realities here will be a major aspect of a breakthrough of hydrogen in the markets.</p><p><em>As you see it, the hydrogen and fuel cell industry has moved out of basic research. Is that so?</em></p><p>Yes, indeed! We are no longer in basic ‘blue-skies’ research, even if the R&amp;D efforts continue and these are important. We observe the territorial deployment of the first commercial developments as, for example, in Japan, but also in some parts of Europe. Hydrogen is now mature in certain markets, while others are still effectively in their applied research phases and initial prototype set-ups. One highly advanced area of application can be seen at relay antennae for mobile telecom operator utilities. Some of these antennae are totally isolated. Now we are equipping them with back-up electric supplies that rely on fuel cell units, the latter now being cost effective compared with classic, liquid/gas fuelled electric generators. However, we still have to create a valid economic model, simply because the price for a fuel cell will never be as low as that for a gas burning unit! Studies still have to be carried out here to improve the competiveness of these fuel cell units. This will no doubt call for involvement and action by Government authorities in order to reach acceptable cost levels. The convergence between hydrogen and methane natural gas will help hydrogen to be affordable. Increased volumes of H2 gas produced and incentive territorial decisions to decentralize energy production will also enhance the prospects for the sector.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=29c35fe5695" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The ambiguities of energy transition]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@paristechreview/the-ambiguities-of-energy-transition-6207454c3e28?source=rss-bfeecc5b3f18------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6207454c3e28</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[renewable-energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oil]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ParisTech Review]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Apr 2015 11:28:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-09T11:28:31.102Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>An interview with Philippe Chalmin (Professor of Economic History, Paris-Dauphine University)</em></h4><h3>The energy transition has begun and will continue. But if we wish to draw up an overall picture, it is the ambiguities and uncertainties that prevail.</h3><p><strong>ParisTech Review </strong><em>— The question of energy transition has become an issue of great importance in politics, especially in Europe, to the point that it occasionally appears to have replaced economic policy. The theme is credited with a capacity to improve our daily lives, reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, guarantee our energy procurement independence, stimulate innovation, improve competitiveness, create jobs, and so on. Could all this be a myth?</em></p><p><strong>Philippe Chalmin </strong>— Everybody is pursuing the same objective: to see a future planet Earth with ten billion inhabitants who have abandoned fossil fuels and where environment and global warming problems have been resolved. The aim is to move on from the oil and coal era to a new age with new energies, hopefully renewable and non-polluting. To achieve this goal, the commanding watchword will be energy transition. But beyond appearances, what we have here is a highly ambiguous concept which is being implemented with four very distinct dimensions.</p><p>The first, well-defined, dimension, relates to the reduction of GHG emissions, notably that of CO2. This constitutes a legitimate challenge, based on the almost undisputed conclusions of the IPCC on global warming.</p><p>The second dimension is tied to the development of clean energy sources, those that will have least negative impact on the environment. This covers all forms of pollution, from fine particles released into the atmosphere to pollution of water tables and even integrates the preservation of biodiversity. This thrust may call into question certain renewable energies, for example hydroelectric power plants, given that installing a dam will destroy some biodiversity.</p><p>Third dimension relates to how we shall adapt to abandoning fossil fuels. Even if we were to increase the volumes of known reserves, there will probably be no more oil at the end of the 21st Century, likewise for gas and coal by the end of the 22nd Century. We should also appreciate freeing ourselves from a dependency on certain oil producing countries, those associated with geopolitical risk, as for example, certain States in the Middle East or in the ex-Soviet bloc.</p><p>Lastly there is an irrational, fear-driven, dimension, notably where nuclear energy is concerned.</p><p>Energy transition is a concept standing at the crossroads of culture, psychology, economics and history. Europe is one of the rare, large regions of the world where this energy transition has already begun. However, we should bear in mind that it only represents a small fraction of the world’s energy scene. Europe can serve as an example, but the real challenges lie in the emerging countries.</p><p><em>An efficient way to reduce the incoherencies in GHG reduction policies would be to adopt a price for CO2 such that the most cost-effective investments would be favoured. But the European experiment to set up a CO2 coupon market, known as the </em><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_Emission_Trading_Scheme"><em>European Union Emission Trading Scheme</em></a><em> (based on a price setting and exchange of CO2 emission quotas) suffered considerably under the global economic crisis. Other European experiences are closely watched. Germany for instance has begun a radical transition, backing out the nuclear option after the Fukushima catastrophe. How do you analyze these initiatives?</em></p><p>The German experience has turned out to be a failure, both in economic and environmental terms. If we consider the resulting energy mix, the results do not reflect the investments. A comparison with the French figures tells us a lot. The French nuclear power programme represents a total capacity of 63 gigawatts, installed over a 20 year period, between 1970 and 1990. Renewable energies in Germany represent 60 gigawatts over 20 years, since 1993. On paper, these figures are comparable; total costs are also close: 96 billion euros for France (but we can consider that France did not invest sufficiently towards the end of the period) and 120 billion euros for Germany. The major difference lies in production: in 2013, French nuclear facilities produced 410 terawatt-hours contributing some 75% total electricity generation in France, while German renewables, in the same year, produced 75 terawatt-hours and contributed 15% total German electricity production<em>, i.e.,</em> 3 to 4% of their national energy mix. Germany’s decision to opt out of nuclear power production is not very rational, and is better explained by the political context rather than by any economic reasoning or rationality.</p><p><em>So the intrepid German initiative could not serve a basis for development of a general model for energy transition?</em></p><p>Not at all. The German decision can be largely disputed inasmuch as Germany, in order to replace its nuclear capacity, had to increase its dependency on natural gas imported from Russia and also to re-open numerous mothballed coal and lignite power stations. More than one quarter of Germany’s power production comes from burning lignite (the most polluting form of coal) and the fraction is growing, rising from 23% in 2010 to 25.8% in 2013. If we refer to some modelling studies done by the University of Stuttgart, pollution due to coal burning power stations, mostly in Germany and Poland, causes the deaths of 5,000 persons each year in Poland, 3,000 in Germany and 1,000 in France. Today, given the upsurge of use of shale gas production in the USA — which has seriously lowered the market price of coal — the latter has now become the least expensive source of energy. The <em>Energiewende</em> [energy transition policy] in Germany has led to an increase of CO2 emissions, but also of sulphur and other fine mineral particles that result from coal burning.</p><p>Moreover, even if coal burning is not expensive, the electricity produced by renewables carries a cost and this is mainly borne by households. The price of electricity in Germany is the highest in Europe, excepting Denmark, Europe’s champion for CO2 emission levels and wind-farming electricity production. Germany no doubt was convinced that the energy transition would generate new industrial sectors, notably in solar power production, but it simply scuttled its competitive edge, even if the industrialists and notably the electro-intensive sectors are largely exempted from paying the reallocation costs (<em>Umlage)</em> associated with the <em>Energiewende</em> programme.</p><p>Lastly, in the framework of a partly integrated European electricity market, the increase in intermittent (<em>viz.,</em> renewable) energy in Germany has led to collateral damage for its neighbors. A date to be remembered is May 11, 2014. On that particular day, Germany attained 75% renewable power in its total electric production, even if this electricity was being exported at negative prices! The reason — and not many people are aware of this — is that with a priority, regulatory access to the grid for renewable power production, the other source operators are legally required to adjust their own production downwards, knowing that they cannot totally stop their generators: consequently, even if the machines are turning at minimum rate, they are willing to pay to inject electricity into the grid.</p><p>All told, the German experiment leads to question the relevance of political determination when it comes to deciding about energy transition. First of all, an isolated decision is not very meaningful and its scope is very limited: negative effects are numerous, including for the environment. This is all the more regretful that the first ingredients of a European energy policy exist already. Secondly, as for the factors that help shape a decision (<em>e.g.,</em> future, global prices for gas or coal, or managing grids with a high percentage of renewables, or long-range photovoltaic efficiency, <em>etc</em>.), we are playing the score by ear and it seems a risky affair to force any decisions whatsoever.</p><p><em>Nevertheless, the German experiment has enabled us to better measure the economic relevance of a large scale deployment of renewables. So, what conclusions can you draw here?</em></p><p>Today, only one renewable energy source, apart from classic hydro-electricity plant, is economically viable: inland wind-turbines. It is the only source with a ROI rate (return on investment, the number of energy units generated per unit invested) comparable with that found for hydro-electric plant or nuclear power stations (knowing moreover that kilowatt hours are not all equivalent, depending on whether they are guaranteed or not). Offshore wind turbines and solar energy installations are not reasonable choices, or let me reframe that: the latter is only conceivable in very sunny countries. The Germans are very paradoxical. Wind farms in Germany are mainly located in the Northern regions, but the inhabitants do not want to see any high voltage lines — especially in Bavaria — to transport the wind-generated power to the South where the major electricity consumers are located. This provides a sort of anti-model for countries like France or the United Kingdom which, with their nuclear power option, possess a decisive comparative edge.</p><p>In reverse — and this is true for the rest of Europe — we must put more efforts into reforming the transport mix, notably by way of taxes or via development of smart forms of transportation, both in the urban areas and in the rest of the country. Two reasons in favor of this: transportation generates huge amounts of CO2 and could emit far less; road haulage is almost exclusively dependent on petroleum products and, consequently, is very sensitive to variations in global prices. Those two objective points can justify making these efforts.</p><p>Electricity has a key role to play for both public transports and freight, as well as private cars tomorrow. In more general terms, the main axis of energy transition is to produce electricity. However, if we take the example of a country where nuclear power is well-controlled, such as France or the UK and China tomorrow, and given the present state of the art in electricity storage, the alternative for producing electricity is not a choice between nuclear and renewables (wind turbines or photovoltaic arrays) but between nuclear and a renewables/thermal electric production mix, in which the latter will increasingly be represented by burning coal. Before 2016, it is estimated that coal will become the most consumed energy in the world, as is already the case in China and in Germany.</p><p><em>The main energy challenges lie in the emerging countries. As you see it, have China and India reached the point where they can become involved in a transition process?</em></p><p>China pollutes a lot but its CO2 emissions per capita are considerably lower than the figures for Europe; economic development in China is currently at the same level as the Western world was towards the end of the 19th Century, with an industry-based economy (50% of the Chinese economy for 2014) and a model to catch up with the developed countries through using the main energy source available<em>,</em> coal. The Chinese do not possess oil fields of sufficient capacity; they could exploit shale hydrocarbons (gas, oil) but a national shortfall of water is a discouraging factor here. China has chosen this industry-based model leading to a pollution level in Beijing that recalls smog over London towards the end of the 19th Century, aggravated by use of gas lighting in the streets and for home heating. The atmosphere of the capital city is unbreathable. We should recall, before we accuse China and by way of drawing a comparison, the state of so-called “advanced” Western Europe before WW1, <em>e.g.,</em> France with its life expectancy at 50 years — which alone obviates any debate about retirement and paid holidays — a working week of 70 hours given that Sundays only became a public holiday in 1908, and lastly a <em>per capita</em> wealth production five times lower in real value as it is today.</p><p>Notwithstanding, comparison is not a proof. The case of China is unique in human history. Never before has an entire continent-country, with its 1.4 billion human beings, undertaken such an effort in terms of the economy: a growth rate close to 10% annually since Mao died in 1976. Yes, there has been a considerable environmental cost to this, but it has been deemed worthwhile. The Chinese themselves are aware of the damage caused, far more than India, now ranking as 4th country in the world for primary energy consumption. India’s development model, based on activities with a low labour input but with a high intellectual capital outlay, in areas such as computer sciences and software or biotechnologies, does not lead to sufficient job creations. Consequently, India is now building up a powerful industrial sector (iron and steel-making, automobile assembly), consuming a lot of energy. India imports 75% of the petroleum products needed and environmental protection and preservation are not yet national priorities.</p><p><em>We can hope that China and India will engage in an energy transition more rapidly than England did in the 19th Century …</em></p><p>In China, President Xi Jinping is insisting a lot on the environmental issues. His aides describe the chairmanship of Hu Jintao as a “lost decade,” inasmuch as the former leader had not taken the right decisions to fight pollution. The patent sign of this failure are the crowds in Beijing constantly checking the air pollution index on their smartphones. In Paris, we start to get seriously worried when the index reaches level 80; in Beijing, the level is more often at 250 and sometimes reaches 400, because of the steel-making foundries in nearby Hebei Province and numerous iron-ore mines. Beijing has closed numerous factories close to Tangshan, a city with 7 million inhabitants, but this is not enough. A lot more would be needed to stop the air pollution phenomenon.</p><p>The Chinese today are the world’s first renewable energy producers and they are progressing faster than we do in Europe. Having said that, if their growth rate remains vigorous, they will continue to increase their CO2 emissions faster than the environmental protection measures have a cancellation effect. The Chinese are also investing massively in nuclear power production. The chances are that the world’s first Evolutionary Power Reactor (EPR) in operation will be Chinese. But nuclear is a long term vision. In the meantime, the three major Chinese petroleum groups are developing fossil resources exploitation throughout the world, to attain a sort of energy autonomy. The Chinese authorities also place their faith in the advent of “clean coal,” a legacy for older German patents for liquefying coal, a process improved upon by South Africa.</p><p>Calling for an energy transition is all the more fashionable when oil is expensive. But the signals here are ambiguous. End 2014, the price of a barrel of oil dropped significantly, despite the numerous crises raging in the oil producing regions, which suggests that the offer is overabundant. Simultaneously, the newly explored reserves are often disappointing whereas, according to the <a href="http://www.iea.org/">International Energy Agency</a>, the demand for oil will rise from 87 to 101 million barrels/day up to 2035. Are we in a position to predict future oil barrel prices?</p><p>The price for Brent Oil went under 60 $US/bbl. in autumn 2014, a long way from the 147 $US high in 2008. But we should not forget that a barrel cost somewhere between 10 to 15$ at the beginning of the century. We are, in fact, still undergoing an oil crisis. The oil market is a paradox: it is a free market albeit rather well controlled by a Riyadh-Washington axis. On one hand, the considerable upsurge of shale oil extraction in the US has created a glut. The question, on the other hand, is whether OPEP will return to its role as a market stabilizer generally via modulations of the Saudi Arabia production.</p><p>In the long run, we have always been wrong with our estimates since we still do not know how to anticipate technological change, for example, oil extraction technologies. With today’s technologies, a large quantity of brute oil remains at the bottom of the oil fields through lack of means to empty them completely. But the necessary means will be developed sooner or later. It is already the case for coal: in 2014, using hydrocracking rupture technologies, we are now exploiting old slag heaps which were simply not exploitable a century ago.</p><p><em>We often hear that the shale oil explosion in the US has severed the dependency of America on Middle East crude oil and even damaged the geopolitical link. It can be seen that OPEP pricing strategy today consists of attempting to limit US shale oil production by attacking the profitability of the American producers. How do you analyze this?</em></p><p>The argument of a US-Saudi Arabia scission is based on an exact observation, but the conclusion drawn here is wrong. For its domestic consumption, the US — who has become a large-scale oil producer — is indubitably less dependent on Middle East (and particularly Saudi Arabian) oil. But OPEP, even to counterbalance the new American competition, has no interest to lower its selling price too far. The financial balance of the US shale oil producers also depends on the world price for a barrel, set by OPEP. So this link still exists.</p><p>The costs for exploration-production of oil in the US have dropped to 70 $US /bbl. OPEP would like to keep the price in the range 90–100 $US/bbl. This price satisfies the geopolitical objectives of two crucial countries. The US preserves the profitability of its domestic production but does not make any concessions to Russia, the new strategic competitor, who is hardly balancing its budget. Likewise, Saudi Arabia is preserving the balance of its national budget but is making no concession to Iran.</p><p>In general terms, it is considered that the Russian budget requires a price level at 95 $US/bbl. and that Saudi Arabia with its rapidly increasing population, prefers not to leave the bracket 90–98$US/bbl. Kuwait, with a far lower population, would be satisfied with a barrel at 45$US/bbl.</p><p><em>All things considered and, taking market practice and political uncertainty factors into account, can we nonetheless foresee what the global energy mix will look like in 2050?</em></p><p>We can work on various scenarios, as IEA does, but it does seem extremely difficult to progress along any precise avenue: between technological innovations, political arbitration in the major emerging countries (economic development versus preserving the environment, for example) and the high uncertainty that surrounds the evolution of oil and gas prices 25 to 50 years ahead — a set of factors which, moreover are inter-independent — we simply do not possess the means today to know what lies ahead.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6207454c3e28" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>