<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 08:05:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Nearer to Nature”: Being-in-the-World Oriented toward the <Hors Texte>]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/nearer-to-nature-being-in-the-world-oriented-toward-the-hors-texte-dd2fa2ada808?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd2fa2ada808</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Oct 2026 07:26:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-13T07:26:40.841Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>— The Dialectic of Desire and the Ethics of the Real</strong></p><p>The phrase “nearer to Nature” appears in a letter Freud wrote in 1934 in response to Albert Einstein, an outspoken opponent of war.</p><p>The correspondence constituted a historically situated intellectual exchange on the problem of war between two Jewish intellectuals who represented the leading currents of Western thought in their time.</p><p>Freud’s contribution was accordingly entitled “Why War?”</p><p>Einstein argued that war was an enemy of humanity that could not be justified under any circumstances.</p><p>Freud, however, adopted a somewhat different position. Human beings, he maintained, possess an instinctual dimension of aggression; when that dimension is challenged, mere endurance or passive restraint may not be the most appropriate response. On the contrary, confronting aggression through resistance and combat may, in certain circumstances, constitute an act that is “nearer to Nature.”</p><p>This position extends the logic implicit in Hobbes’s famous proposition, Homo homini lupus — “Man is a wolf to man.”</p><p>At this point, one is reminded of an episode associated with Namhansanseong during the Manchu invasion of Joseon in 1636, known in Korean history as the Second Manchu Invasion.</p><p>In the confrontation between Choe Myeong-gil, who advocated a conciliatory policy toward the Qing, and Kim Sang-heon, who insisted on resistance, the former’s position ultimately prevailed. The outcome was the national humiliation subsequently remembered as the Humiliation at Samjeondo.</p><p>In the depths of winter, amid the bitter northerly winds, King Injo, sovereign father of the Joseon people, prostrated himself on the frozen ground at Samjeondo before Hong Taiji, the Qing emperor, who looked down upon him from his elevated position of power. There, Injo performed the ritual of samgwe-gu-godu-rye (三跪九叩頭禮), the ceremony of three kneelings and nine prostrations.</p><p>The ritual required the king to kneel three times and, on each occasion, strike his forehead against the ground three times. Three multiplied by three yielded nine. Injo thus struck his head against the earth nine times, enacting a thoroughgoing self-annihilation before the victorious sovereign.</p><p>What, one might ask, must the hearts of ordinary Joseon subjects have felt as they witnessed this spectacle?</p><p>They came to regard him as a sogun (小君), a petty or diminished sovereign, effectively stripping him of the stature befitting a daewang (大王), a great king.</p><p>Thereafter, Joseon increasingly became a polity incapable of waging war, while its people, unable to endure the humiliation at Samjeondo, were reduced to a condition resembling a form of collective neurosis. One need only recall the vacillating indecision and enfeebled resolve exhibited by Gojong, the last monarch of the Joseon dynasty.</p><p>It is precisely this predicament that Freud is concerned with in “Why War?”</p><p>When the moment calls for combat, to fight may be the course of action “more consonant with Nature”; it may also be a means of rescuing the human psyche from the trap of neurosis.</p><p>The history of warfare throughout human civilization bears witness to this proposition.</p><p>Among the oldest human remains ever discovered is the mummified body(Ötzi) found high in the snow-covered Alps, its skull depressed by a blow from an enemy’s arrow or stone.</p><p>Moreover, the principle of lex talionis — “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth” — enshrined in the <em>Code of Hammurabi</em> and in the <em>Pentateuch</em>, texts originating in the second millennium BCE and the first millennium BCE, respectively, adheres rigorously to the logic of aggression and counteraggression that underlies the dynamics of warfare.</p><p>In contemporary popular song lyrics, one encounters the Korean word eung-eori (응어리), denoting a deeply lodged emotional knot, a grievance, or a psychic burden that remains unresolved.</p><p>A victim of school bullying, for instance, appeals for someone to help release the eung-eori lodged within their heart.</p><p>This distinctly Korean word, eung-eori, names with remarkable precision the trace of a trauma arising from the frustration or distortion of the aggressive drive, whether through commission or omission: the objet petit <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>The eung-eori accumulated in layers, one might imagine, within King Injo himself, as he endured — or perhaps failed to endure — the humiliation of Samjeondo.</p><p><strong>Psychoanalysis, SInthome, and the Deconstruction of Binary System</strong></p><p>Psychoanalytic treatment is nothing other than the work of undoing this eung-eori — the deeply entrenched psychic knot.</p><p>Within the virtual reality enacted by the transference and countertransference that unfold through the analyst–analysand dyad, the task is to reread trauma (<em>ɑ</em>) through the “reconstruction of the past in the present.”</p><p>It entails re-presenting and re-enacting the crossing of the Berezina River, as depicted in Honoré de Balzac’s novella <em>Adieu</em>.</p><p>Through this process, a retrospective sentence of the form &lt;should have + past participle&gt; is brought to completion, and the game of Fort/Da — that “great cultural achievement” — can unfold.</p><p>The latter is particularly significant. Through a Copernican reversal whereby “What happened to me” becomes “What I made happen to me,” the therapeutic undertaking reaches its culmination, realizing that great cultural achievement.</p><p>This is the process through which the subject, rendered incomplete and subjected to suffering by the rupture of the Borromean knot, attains a fuller form of subjectivation: the formation of a “fourth existential knot.”</p><p>Lacan gave the title <em>Le Sinthome</em> to his Seminar XXIII to designate precisely this problematic.</p><p>James Joyce, who suffered from the failure of the paternal metaphor, was, through his singular mode of writing (écriture), elevated to the status of the sinthome — as though undergoing a form of canonization, or even sanctification.</p><p>According to Ferdinand de Saussure, the founding figure of structural linguistics, “In language, there are only differences.”</p><p>Roman Jakobson, who subsequently developed structuralist thought, elaborated the concept of difference within a binary system.</p><p>Jacques Derrida, a leading figure of poststructuralism, discerned how difference becomes transformed into discrimination when the concepts of value and desire are introduced into this binary system.</p><p>This is the intellectual context in which the term logocentrism emerged, evoking the biblical declaration, “In the beginning was the Word” (Logos).</p><p>Derrida’s philosophical project is known as deconstruction, and one of its principal targets is the dismantling of binary oppositions.</p><p>Ideology, understood as a collective system of human thought, represents an extreme manifestation of binary oppositions into which the concept of value has been introduced, as exemplified by the vehement antagonism between Communism and anti-Communism.</p><p>The “ideological trap” is nowhere more starkly illustrated than by antisemitism and the specter of the Holocaust that it engendered.</p><p>What deconstructive strategy, then, might be brought to bear against this historical and intellectual manifestation of evil?</p><p>Jacques Lacan, another major figure of poststructuralist thought whose theoretical stature may be set alongside Derrida’s, inherited and further developed Freudian psychoanalysis by introducing the problem of language into its conceptual framework, thereby inaugurating a structuralist psychoanalysis.</p><p>At the heart of this project lie the dialectic of desire and the ethics of the Real.</p><p>In his formula of metaphor, Lacan incorporated Freud’s theory of the Oedipus complex to formulate what has come to be known as the “paternal metaphor” (<em>Écrits</em>, 200):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*sYkdOnQNBnawdfk9_UsE_Q.gif" /></figure><p>This is a structuralist reformulation of the rite of passage through the Oedipus complex, the decisive juncture in psychosexual development.</p><p>The &lt;Name-of-the-Father/No!&gt; emerges prominently in the foreground, while, in the presence of the big Other, the signifier &lt;Phallus&gt;, as the vehicle of signification, sinks its roots deep into the ground.</p><p><strong>The Paternal No, the Dialectic Desire, and the Ethics of the Real</strong></p><p>This is the myth of the birth of the whole (All) subject.</p><p>In the case of the incomplete (Not-All) subject, something has gone awry in one or another of the three elements described above.</p><p>The crux of the problem lies in the &lt;paternal No!&gt;.</p><p>It is the voice of the dialectical antithesis.</p><p>Through the intervention of this paternal &lt;No!&gt;, which negates the order of the dialectical thesis, the signifier &lt;Phallus&gt; — the signifier of signification, civilization, and socialization — is inscribed and registered in the mind of the child in its state of nature.</p><p>This constitutes a positive sign that a natural being has entered the symbolic order, governed by language and law.</p><p>To enter the symbolic order is to enter the system of binary oppositions discussed above, and hence to become subject to the influence of &lt;Logocentrism&gt;.</p><p>This is why calls to abolish Seoul National University emerge alongside embittered comic laments about “a rotten world in which only those who come first can prosper.”</p><p>Under such circumstances, to proclaim egalitarianism is little more than an exercise in futility.</p><p>The &lt;Parable of the Talents&gt;, recounted in the Synoptic Gospels, may well have been intended to convey this notion of “equality within inequality.”</p><p>Although the servants receive different amounts — one, five, or ten talents, respectively — those who double what they have been given receive the same commendation: “Well done, good and faithful servant; you have been faithful over a little, and I will set you over much. Enter into the joy of your master.” By contrast, the servant who buries his single talent and returns it unchanged merely because he has received less is met with an accusatory rebuke: “You wicked and lazy servant …”</p><p>Whether this parabolic logic, so frequently invoked in theories of justice, can exert any real force within an ideological system characterized by a “tilted playing field” — a system beset by ideological bias and tormented by binary oppositions and logocentrism — remains an open question. After all, ideology represents the apotheosis of binarism.</p><p>One proposition, however, can be stated with confidence: although this parabolic logic may fail to hold within the symbolic order, which surges with the dialectics of desire, it may well hold within the ethics of the Real.</p><p>This is why one encounters the claim that, even where horizontal justice is absent, vertical justice nonetheless prevails.</p><p>How, then, are desire and drive defined in Lacanian discourse? Their names are similar, and their forms may appear alike, yet they belong to two fundamentally distinct orders, which they respectively represent: the Symbolic and the Real.</p><p>The path of desire, guided by the Lacanian dictum that “man’s desire is the desire of the Other,” enacts the binary logic — or logocentrism — immanent in the symbolic order. It stands in sharp contrast to the axis of drive, along which the drive circles around the objet petit a, thereby generating jouissance.</p><p>Yet the ground of both desire and drive is “real” in character. In this respect, it bears a resemblance to Kant’s Ding an sich, or “thing-in-itself.”</p><p>It is a primordial image untouched by the operations of language and symbolization.</p><p>If the Real is the register in which this primordiality remains preserved in its entirety, then the Symbolic is the register in which it undergoes a “dialectical” transformation, and in which desire surges and fluctuates.</p><p>Desire, therefore, exhibits a variable and unpredictable movement, capable of veering in unforeseen directions, whereas the trajectory of drive is markedly more “headlong.”</p><p>In other words, the binary opposition between nature and civilization broadly corresponds to the opposition between the Real and the Symbolic, and between drive and desire.</p><p>The central signifier governing the Garden of Eden was the &lt;Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil&gt;, whose fruit embodied good and evil within a single object.</p><p>In the language of alchemy, this is the coincidentia oppositorum — the “coincidence of opposites.”</p><p><strong>From Desire to Drive: Antogone and the Ethics of the Real</strong></p><p>When humanity’s ancestors ate the forbidden fruit, their eyes were opened, and they attempted to depart from Eden. This act may be understood as an expression of the human “will to civilization.” In its aftermath, the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil became subsumed within the binary logic of binarism, or logocentrism, in which good and evil came to exist as separate and mutually opposed categories.</p><p>To proclaim the slogan “From Desire to Drive,” therefore, is to reverse the human will to civilization and to embark upon a process of decivilization — that is, a return to the state of Nature. Is this not a kind of procession toward gwichon, the “return to Heaven” envisioned by the Korean poet Cheon Sang-byeong?</p><p>“Act in accordance with the desire within you” and “Do not give up on your desire”: these are formulations of what Lacan, in Seminar VII, calls the “ethics of the Real.”</p><p>Following the logic outlined above, however, has desire not already entailed the “sacrifice” (céder) of a portion of drive? If so, should not the foregoing injunctions have referred to drive rather than desire? It was Slavoj Žižek who raised precisely this question (<em>Looking Awry</em>, p. 172).</p><p>I shall let the foregoing explanation — that desire and drive alike have das Ding, the Thing-in-itself, at their underlying ground — serve as my response to this question.</p><p>A paradigmatic instance of putting into practice the categorical imperative of “From Desire to Drive” — in other words, of moving from the dialectics of desire to the ethics of the Real — is found in the case of <em>Antigone</em>.</p><p>Defying a decree issued by Creon, the supreme political authority of her time — “The body of one who has betrayed the state shall not be buried” — Antigone inters the corpse of her brother, Polynices.</p><p>Her transgression of this taboo ultimately leads to her being buried alive.</p><p>As she walks toward the tomb in which she is to be entombed, she sings a mournful song, a cry of anguish. It is in response to this lament that Lacan declares: “The aesthetics of the Sublime shines forth in all its splendor.”</p><p>Antigone follows the command of an inner god, a God within that speaks from the depths of her innermost convictions, and assumes full responsibility for her own act.</p><p>Does she not thereby approach the threshold of what Heidegger calls Eigentlichkeit — authenticity, or ownmostness?</p><p>Antigone was putting into practice Lacan’s &lt;Ethics of the Real&gt;: “Do not give up on your drive” and “Act in accordance with the categorical imperative within you.”</p><p>There is a Korean expression, “a storm in a teacup.”</p><p>It seems to carry a connotation similar to that of the Korean saying, “However high the mountain may rise, it remains a mountain beneath the heavens.” The implication appears to be that, however violent a storm may become, it will ultimately amount to little more than a minor disturbance confined to a teacup.</p><p>The phrase “appears to be,” however, harbors an unspoken reservation: perhaps things are not quite as they seem. It is precisely this reservation that I wish to explore here.</p><p>In my view, the teacup belongs to the domain of a certain boundary or frame: the &lt;World&gt; in Heidegger’s notion of being-in-the-world, or the &lt;Text&gt; in the expression &lt;Hors Texte&gt;.</p><p>An event that takes place within the boundaries sustained by the world and the text — what else could it be but an event belonging to the realm of desire?</p><p>Desire is an event that occurs within the symbolic order, that is, within the boundaries established by language and law.</p><p>A Jewish joke, adapted into Korean, might run as follows:</p><p>“Yesterday, you told me, ‘I’m going to Seoul.’ So I assumed you were going to Busan and prepared accordingly. But you actually went to Seoul! &lt;Therefore&gt;, you deceived me!”</p><p>The world of desire, saturated with binary thinking, is unpredictable and liable to veer in any direction. This is the dialectics of desire.</p><p>By contrast, the path of drive (Trieb/pulsion/drive), which boasts the headlong force of a wild boar, is quite literally headlong.</p><p>It acts first, before stopping to weigh the alternatives.</p><p><strong>From the Dialectics of Desire to the Ethics of the Real</strong></p><p>If Hamlet embodies the contemplative mode of thought characteristic of the path of desire, then Don Quixote represents the action-oriented mode of drive and impulse.</p><p>If we interpret the metaphor of “a storm in a teacup” in terms of human desire, it would mean that one should pursue the fulfillment of one’s desires within the framework of law and order.</p><p>This is because the human psyche is governed not only by the ego (Ich/Ego/moi) but also by the superego (Über-Ich/Superego).</p><p>To arrive at a compromise formation (Kompromissbildung) at approximately this level is what constitutes the dialectics of desire.</p><p>Let me reiterate, however, that the “ethics of the Real” articulated by Lacan in Seminar VII transcends this very boundary: “Act in accordance with the desire or drive within you!” It represents a higher-order mode of human desire’s fulfillment, one that goes beyond the dialectics of desire.</p><p>This is the path chosen by Antigone.</p><p>Returning to the metaphor of the teacup, the task is to shift the emphasis onto the “storm” itself. Lacan makes it clear that the next task facing analysands who have completed the “traversal of fantasy” is to “live the drive” (vivre la pulsion).</p><p>The expression “From desire to jouissance,” which emerges at the conclusion of analysis, likewise points toward the ethics of the Real: an ethics of living the drive.</p><p>To adapt Freud’s formulation in “Why War?”, this is an act that brings us “nearer to Nature.”</p><p>In the clinical setting, discussions of desire and drive — in other words, of the “storm in a teacup” — are abundant.</p><p>Professor Bruce Fink, for instance, speaks of an appropriate harmony between desire and drive. He also employs the metaphor of the former issuing the latter a “temporary permit.”</p><p>What remains clear, however, is that human existence encompasses both the dimension of desire and the dimension of drive, and that human beings are, fundamentally, beings-in-the-world.</p><p>Everyone acts through their own decisions and bears unlimited responsibility for those actions. The moment at which the subject assumes responsibility for their desire is the moment of the termination of analysis.</p><p>The final word that remains after Derrida’s <em>The Gift of Death</em> is “responsibility.”</p><p>And it is this responsibility that functions as the fourth existential knot, firmly securing the theoretical thread of the Sinthome.</p><p>This is another expression of the Fort/Da mechanism.</p><p>Beings-in-the-world situated between the dialectics of desire and the ethics of the Real look beyond the boundaries of the text, weighing which course of action might bring them “nearer to Nature.”</p><p>According to Hegel, history is the self-realization of Absolute Spirit (<em>ɑ</em>).</p><p>Its Christian counterpart is the event of the Incarnation, in which God (<em>ɑ</em>) assumes human flesh and is born into the world.</p><p>This, precisely, is the path of the Sinthome as Lacan conceives it (<em>ɑ</em>).</p><p>What, then, is the Buddhist truth-value (<em>ɑ</em>) of samsara — the ceaseless cycle of rebirth through which beings pass between karma, the deeds they perform, and karmic retribution, the consequences those deeds entail?</p><p>Come to think of it, today marks the 2,570th year of the Buddhist era and the Buddha’s birthday. Perhaps it is time to visit Seongjeonam, the sanctuary at Pagyesa Temple where Seongcheol Seonsa is said to have devoted himself to Zen meditation for ten years without venturing beyond the temple’s entrance.</p><p>Der bestirnte Himmel über mir und das moralische Gesetz in mir.</p><p>―Immanuel Kant</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd2fa2ada808" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hors Texte: S(Ø)―$◇ɑ―s(O)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/hors-texte-s-%C3%B8-%C9%91-s-o-3ef1e856e5eb?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ef1e856e5eb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Sep 2026 03:26:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-29T03:26:49.957Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Il n’y a pas de hors-texte.”</p><p>There is no outside-of-the-text.</p><p>This famous dictum of Derrida, a key phrase in deconstruction, resonates with Heidegger’s ontology of Being-in-the-World (In-der-Welt-Sein).</p><p>Were one a being outside the world, one might imagine oneself free from the laws and orders that govern it. Yet precisely because one is a being-in-the-world, freedom can be articulated only within the bounds of that Law.</p><p>In Lévi-Strauss’s structural anthropology, kinship relations and the incest taboo, for instance, function as indispensable norms and laws imposed upon beings-in-the-world.</p><p>For Derrida, all human meaning is constituted within the text. This is precisely why textuality comes to the fore under the categorical imperative: “Let the world become text!”</p><p>There is no hors — no “outside” — from which the text itself might be regulated, legislated, or mastered.</p><p>But what of Lacan?</p><p>Lacan and Derrida, two contemporaneous figures whose thought helped make poststructuralism possible, display a striking homology in that they even share the same first name, Jacques. Yet this homology does not ultimately culminate in a convergence of their thought.</p><p>The decisive divergence emerges in their respective theories of the text.</p><p>For Lacan, it is not the case that nothing exists outside the text.</p><p>Consider, for example, Lacan’s critique of Descartes’ <em>Cogito ergo sum</em>. Lacan turns the Cartesian proposition awry, declaring: “I am not where I think, and I think where I am not.”</p><p>What, then, is the being that exists outside the text for Lacan? — It is the subject of jouissance.</p><p>To articulate this point, let us recall the final passage of the abridged version of É:</p><p>“Castration means that jouissance must be refused, so that it can be reached on the inverted ladder of the Law of desire.” (<em>É</em>, 324)</p><p>In Lacanian discourse, castration — or, more precisely, symbolic castration — constitutes a decisive event that opens the path toward subjectivation, signification, and civilization.</p><p>It is the signifier that unlocks the door to the “paternal metaphor.”</p><p>Through the operation of this signifier, the passage from jouissance to désir becomes possible.</p><p>The world of the “Law of desire” designates the symbolic order, and to inhabit this order is to live out the logic of textuality as a being-in-the-world.</p><p>Through symbolic castration, the subject moves from jouissance to desire and thereby enters the text from its “outside.”</p><p>Within the world of desire, the subject becomes thoroughly governed by the logic of the text. Yet it is only through reading against the grain — that is, through a deconstructive mode of reading — that one can catch a glimpse of the world of jouissance situated beyond the text, in the hors.</p><p>We have thus arrived at an important binary opposition: the subject of the signifier and the subject of jouissance. The former is the subject within the text; the latter, the subject outside the text.</p><p>If Lacan’s notoriously complex four-stage graph of desire is simplified, it may be represented as follows: &lt;See the diagram in Lecture 143.&gt;</p><p>The process of subjectivation is depicted as traversing the vectors of the signifier and jouissance.</p><p>In the cross-shaped figure (+) that I have devised, this configuration bears a striking resemblance to the dialectical schema of deconstruction staged by the opposition between the conscious and the unconscious (I), and between the dimension of being and the dimension of meaning (―).</p><p>T<strong>he Subject of Jouissance and the Lack in the Other</strong></p><p>To understand this more clearly, we turn to the more transparent and fully elaborated Graph IV of Desire (Lecture 141).</p><p>There we can see that the configuration S(Ø)―$◇ɑ―s(O) is positioned along its left-hand line.</p><p>The formula $◇ɑ designates fantasy — that is, the relation that the divided subject establishes with object ɑ.</p><p>Moving upward and to the left from this configuration, we encounter S(Ø); moving downward and to the right, by contrast, we encounter s(O).</p><p>The significance of this movement corresponds to the binary opposition between fantasy and the Traversal of Fantasy.</p><p>To spell this out: when fantasy, as the relation between the divided subject and object ɑ, casts its shadow over the subject, the Other appears as a substantial, fully constituted big Other (the Other). When, by contrast, the traversal of fantasy is accomplished, the Other is revealed as the “empty” Other of lack (Ø), its body traversed by a bar.</p><p>S(Ø) thus signifies “the signifier of the lack in the Other.”</p><p>If s(O) is the object toward which the subject of the signifier is oriented, then S(Ø) is the point toward which the subject of jouissance is directed.</p><p>Translated into Derrida’s vocabulary, Lacan’s schema could be reformulated as the distinction between the subject within the text and the subject of the Hors Texte, the subject outside the text.</p><p>From this point onward, our attention will be concentrated on the subject of jouissance situated outside the text.</p><p>What now requires elucidation is the signifier of the lack in the Other, S(Ø), which has emerged so prominently in the diagram above.</p><p>According to Lacan’s psychic topology, the drive (pulsion) circles around object ɑ, and jouissance is generated as an effect of this circuit.</p><p>In other words, jouissance is an a posteriori Real, the Real that emerges after symbolization, and hence a mode of existence belonging to the hors-texte.</p><p>This Real jouissance — the remainder of the process of symbolization, the rem(a)inder — might be understood as something akin to “nature within civilization.” Could it be compared to the oases scattered here and there across the desert of civilization?</p><p>As Freud’s monumental <em>Civilization and Its Discontents</em> suggests, the substance of “the discontent” is precisely what belongs to the domain of jouissance.</p><p>Within Lacanian discourse, the distinction between phallic jouissance and Other jouissance is of crucial importance.</p><p>The former is not particularly difficult to understand as an extension of what Freud calls Eros, or the sexual drive. The latter, however — the concept of jouissance associated with the big Other (O) — is considerably more elusive.</p><p>A case in which this concept is presented in visual form can be found in Lacan’s formulas of sexuation (see Lecture 122).</p><p>With regard to the problem of psychosexual difference, &lt;Man&gt; is represented as $ → ɑ, whereas &lt;Woman&gt; is represented as Woman → Φ/S(Ø).</p><p>Here, “Man” designates the subject of &lt;All&gt;, the subject who has succeeded in securing a “quilting point” (point de capiton) within the process of signification and subjectivation. His pursuit of jouissance terminates in his relation to object ɑ — that is, in &lt;Phallic jouissance&gt;.</p><p>Does this mean that, having resolved the problem of the big Other (O) through the paternal metaphor, there is no longer any need for &lt;Other jouissance&gt;?</p><p>By contrast, the incomplete subject of &lt;Not-All&gt;, represented by (∀xΦx) — a subject that has not entered the symbolic order in its totality — pursues a mode of jouissance that unfolds as a &lt;both-and&gt; narrative, simultaneously grasping Φ and S(Ø).</p><p>From this perspective, as feminists have pointed out, the designation &lt;Woman&gt; would seem inadequate.</p><p>What is crucial, however, is that the jouissance enjoyed by this &lt;Not-All&gt; subject, who has (partially) failed to secure a quilting point within the process of signification, traverses both sides of the divide between Phallic Jouissance and Other Jouissance.</p><p>To borrow Nathaniel Hawthorne’s expression, might this be a “fortunate fall”?</p><p><strong>The Not-All Subject and the Repetition of Difference</strong></p><p>Let us look more closely into the heart of the matter.</p><p>It is only natural that women, like men, experience a flow of sexual energy toward the opposite sex.</p><p>The problem, however, is that unlike men, women are additionally endowed with another form of jouissance beyond this.</p><p>This is precisely where much of the discourse on jouissance comes to a halt.</p><p>With the support of my mentor, Professor Fink (Fink 2004, 164–65), I would like to confront this problem directly.</p><p>To begin with, if we were to gather together the various dimensions of the arduous pilgrimage undertaken by the Not-All, and express them in a single term, we might call it the realization of perfectionism.</p><p>The subject of the &lt;Not-All&gt; aims at the state of &lt;All&gt;.</p><p>Like K, the protagonist of Kafka’s <em>Das Schloss </em>(<em>The Castle</em>), who persistently seeks entry into the Castle despite his repeated frustrations, or like Sisyphus, who continues to push the stone uphill even though he knows that it will inevitably roll back down, the &lt;Not-All&gt; subject’s challenge to incompleteness through the pursuit of completeness has no end.</p><p>Here Freud’s notions of repetition and compulsion come into play. The technical term “repetition compulsion” (Wiederholungszwang) seems particularly apt for conveying this condition.</p><p>Yet the repetition at stake here is not a repetition of identity. Its Sinthome-like dimension lies precisely in the fact that it is a &lt;repetition with a difference&gt; — a repetition that produces a certain “difference.”</p><p>It is, in this sense, a powerful set of “vital signs.”</p><p>In Heidegger’s terms, such a pilgrimage may be understood as the path by which beings constituted through Schuldigsein, or indebtedness/guilt, attempt to settle their debt; in Christian terms, it is the path of redemption, the remission of sin; in Buddhist terms, it is the path toward the settlement of karma (業).</p><p>Why, then, should such a path not be arduous and painful?</p><p>Patience is bitter, but its fruit is sweet.</p><p>And is not the enjoyment of that sweetness of the fruit precisely what we might call &lt;O-jouissance&gt;?</p><p>The Greek etymon of trauma originally referred to an external wound, an injury inflicted from without.</p><p>Freud added the prefix “psychic,” thereby transforming the notion into psychic trauma — a wound of the mind.</p><p>The wound borne by the Not-All subject manifests, in Freudian terms, as what I shall call a psycho-signature (心紋) and a neuro-signature (身紋).</p><p>Lacan approaches the former through his theory of the Sinthome, and the latter through what he calls Topology.</p><p>The argument is that when, in the process of signification — for example, through the paternal metaphor — the subject sustains a decisive trauma that exceeds its capacity to bear, a “pore” is opened or a “breach” is produced within the subject. This breach subsequently manifests itself either as a psychic 心紋, or as a somatic 身紋.</p><p>Psychoanalytic treatment is nothing other than the process of filling this opening and suturing the breach.</p><p>Ask a well-analyzed analysand about the experience, and one may hear that both processes are taking place simultaneously, on both psychic and somatic levels.</p><p>It is an experience in which an “ingrown knot” within the mind begins to loosen and the “collapsed inner edifice” is restored.</p><p>This amounts to turning one’s gaze away from the subject of the signifier and toward the subject of jouissance.</p><p>And it proceeds in the direction of completing the sentence:</p><p>&lt;I should have + past participle&gt;: “I should have done …!”</p><p><strong>From the Subject of the Signifier to the Subject of Jouissance</strong></p><p>According to Professor Cannon’s &lt;fight/flight&gt; mechanism, when confronted with the binary crossroads of either standing one’s ground and fighting the advancing enemy or fleeing from it, the subject ought to have made a decisive, apophantic decision and acted upon it. The pathology arose precisely because, like Hamlet, the subject remained indecisive, suspended in an ambiguous state of hesitation: it should have acted, but did not.</p><p>Within the analytic space of transitional re-presentation, this problem is worked through in the tense relationship between the Analyst and the Analysand.</p><p>This is why the space of analysis may be called a “potential space.”</p><p>Analysis is nothing other than the work of returning the past to the past, of restoring the past to its status as Past as it is.</p><p>In M. Proust’s journey in search of À la recherche du temps perdu (In Search of Lost Time), there is the phenomenon of involuntary memory.</p><p>There, the protagonist Marcel’s pleasurable memory of the madeleine occupies a central place. Yet many patients suffering from trauma find themselves besieged on all sides by “bad” memories.</p><p>This is because the paternal metaphor has operated at the level of &lt;commission/omission&gt;.</p><p>Through the analytic act of the “present reconstruction of the past,” the debt of the indebted being is repaid and the past is restored to the past; in this way, the illness is healed.</p><p>More precisely, this process takes place through a reorientation from the subject of the signifier toward the subject of jouissance in its mode of Ex-sistence (脫存).</p><p>Here we encounter once again the contrast between the theories of the subject proposed by Descartes and Lacan.</p><p>The proposition “I think, therefore I am” (Cogito ergo sum) means, quite precisely, that the subject who thinks and the subject as Being coincide.</p><p>This is precisely where the Cartesian subject of the Cogito is situated.</p><p>In order to critique this Cartesian theory of the subject, Lacan, on p. 211 of <em>FFCP</em>, draws a diagram in which the dimensions of Being and Meaning are linked exclusively.</p><p>Here, the term “exclusive” means that the two dimensions do not overlap.</p><p>In the region of their overlap, Lacan inscribes “non-meaning”; elsewhere, he places object ɑ.</p><p>It is the mark of the &lt;remainder/rem(a)inder&gt;, the post-Symbolic Real.</p><p>In other words, Lacan’s diagram erases, from within the Cartesian framework of thought, the ontological status of the Cogito as a being that “exists while thinking”:</p><p>“I am not where I think, and I think where I am not.”</p><p>Through this move, Lacan not only rigorously distinguishes the subject of the signifier from the subject of jouissance; he also turns the direction of analysis from the former toward the latter.</p><p>He thus reverses the direction established by symbolic castration in the final paragraph of É — the direction articulated as “from jouissance to desire!” — and opens wide a deconstructive path running in the opposite direction:</p><p>“From desire and the subject of the signifier to the subject of jouissance!”</p><p>It is a return from the Symbolic Order to the Real, a change of trajectory from Desire to Drive, and a path that puts into practice Rousseau’s injunction to “return to nature.”</p><p>It is also the dialectical maxim attributed to Master Seongcheol:</p><p>“A mountain is a mountain; a mountain is not a mountain; and again, a mountain is a mountain.”</p><p><strong>Phallic Jouissance and Other Jouissance</strong></p><p>We are now in a position to examine the differential distinction between Phallic jouissance and Other jouissance.</p><p>Lacan once compared &lt;phallic jouissance&gt; to the bar separating S/s.</p><p>Following the logic of the primacy of the Signifier over the Signified, the bar between S and s is constituted in such a way that only the Signifier rises to the foreground, while the signified continually slips beneath it.</p><p>The insufficiency and uncertainty of phallic jouissance are analogous to this condition. I have attached to it the term “fallible” — that which can fail. By contrast, Lacan posits la jouissance de l’Autre, Other jouissance, as a form of jouissance that claims to be “infallible” — incapable of failure.</p><p>This is a jouissance of an almost religious order: “the God face of the Other” (165).</p><p>Among Freud’s four major analytic case studies, the Schreber case addresses precisely this problem.</p><p>One day, a highly educated and accomplished sitting judge of his time is suddenly overwhelmed by an intense fantasy: although himself a man, he is to be transformed into a woman, enter into a sexual relationship with the omnipotent God — the absolute I AM — and, as its consequence, give birth to the Messiah who will redeem the world.</p><p>It is the apotheosis of Epiphany, reaching the mythic dimension of the Hieros Gamos, the sacred marriage.</p><p>There is an analogy here with the sacramental ritual of Holy Communion, in which wine is drunk and bread is eaten in remembrance of the blood shed and the flesh torn from Christ upon the Cross.</p><p>Both are intimately bound up with death.</p><p>If Phallic jouissance operates on the level of the life drive (Lebenstrieb, Eros), then Other jouissance belongs to the domain of the death drive (Todestrieb, Thanatos).</p><p>We should recall that toward the end of <em>Beyond the Pleasure Principle</em>, Freud attempted to establish an equation among the Pleasure Principle (PP), the Nirvana Principle, and the Death Drive.</p><p>Other jouissance is thus a kind of Nirvana-with-remainder (有餘涅槃) experienced by beings who, while still alive, experience death — those who are “being-toward-death” (Vorlaufen).</p><p>Ecstasy in suffering, the experience of life within death: this is the very essence of jouissance. Other jouissance pushes this experience all the way into the religious dimension, into the domain of God.</p><p>Its reward is the acclamation:</p><p>&lt;Infallible! Mission Completed!&gt;</p><p>As its signifier, S(Ø), suggests, Other jouissance also presupposes the death of the Other (O).</p><p>The many Lacanian declarations concerning the death of the Other — “There is no Other,” “There is no Other of the Other,” and so forth — point toward precisely this condition.</p><p>Yet how does this differ from the absolute sovereign who appeared to Moses at Mount Horeb/Mount Sinai in the form of the &lt;I AM WHO I AM&gt;, the supreme Being of the Theophany?</p><p>The answer is:</p><p>Yes/No! NC/ND.</p><p>For the incomplete subjects who live in the condition of &lt;Not-All&gt; as a consequence of the failure of the paternal metaphor, the Other emerges as an object to be overcome.</p><p>They have been reduced to a state of “incompleteness” precisely because of its &lt;commission/omission&gt;.</p><p>The principle governing vengeance against transgressors is the law of Lex Talionis: “eye for eye, tooth for tooth.”</p><p>It is striking — and, from another perspective, entirely unsurprising — that such a Law should be explicitly inscribed both in the ancient <em>Code of Hammurabi</em> and in the <em>Pentateuch</em>.</p><p>For according to the ethics of analysis, returning precisely what one has received, in precisely the same form, is arguably the most effective means of treating trauma.</p><p>The problem, however, is retaliation and the reaction it provokes.</p><p>The way to circumvent this problem is to discover the secret of &lt;punishment with impunity&gt;: to punish without being punished.</p><p>The mock-analytic crossing of the Berezina River, enacted through analytic re-presentation/re-enactment — the present reconstruction of the past — is precisely such an operation.</p><p>It is an act of “punishing without being punished”: the liquidation of the debts of the past — its sins, karma, and debts (罪・業・빚).</p><p>The case in which the command of the goddess of vengeance, Nemesis, is followed without such a safety mechanism is the tragic failure of the revenge narrative of Kim Bu-nam, who famously cried out, “I killed not a human being, but a beast.”</p><p><strong>S(Ø), the Death of the Other, and Other Jouissance</strong></p><p>S(Ø) is the subjective jouissance brought about by the death of the Other.</p><p>It is the jouissance — the 快/悅 of pleasure and delight — that arises from completing the sentence:</p><p>&lt;I should have + past participle&gt;.</p><p>The big Other approaches the subject in an oxymoronic manner.</p><p>If the Other approaches the subject as a debt that must be settled, it can be dealt with through the Lex Talionis of “with impunity.” If, however, it approaches in the face of God (YHWH), in the form of the declaration, “I can do all things through Him who gives me strength,” then the subject may sublimate the encounter through a theory of Inherence, analogous to the biblical metaphor of the vine and its branches.</p><p>In most cases, the former involves the little other (o), while the latter concerns the big Other (O).</p><p>In either case, the subject encounters a logic of liberation, owing to the sacred/sexual (&lt;性/聖&gt;) function of jouissance that exists — or does not exist — in the Hors Texte, in the domain of Ex-sistence (脫存).</p><p>It is an exquisite symphony woven between the subject of the signifier and the subject of jouissance.</p><p>This is the world delineated by Vital Signs, and it is the path of the Sinthome.</p><p>Perhaps this was precisely the path of “poetic resolution” (詩的 해결) that the late Professor Park I-moon pursued throughout his life.</p><p>At the end of that path, there will stand a signpost bearing the inscription &lt;SK&gt;.</p><p>It will be a monument to resurrection: the “agape” wound, gaping open, is sutured, while the loosened knot is reborn as a point de capiton, a point at which meaning is once again fixed.</p><p><strong>To sum up: S(Ø)―$◇ɑ―s(O).</strong></p><p>The problem is object ɑ.</p><p>And the problem is the fantasy, the relation that the subject establishes with it.</p><p>In the schema above, taken from the Graph of Desire, when fantasy casts its shadow, the Other appears as a substantial, fully constituted Other (O). When that fantasy is lifted through the Traversal of Fantasy, the Other is revealed instead as the empty Ø.</p><p>The former — grounded in ɑ — represents Phallic jouissance, whereas the latter — defined by the absence of ɑ — represents Other jouissance.</p><p>Here lies the division between &lt;Father/God-Father&gt; and the distinction between the sexual and the sacred (&lt;性/聖&gt;).</p><p>As Lacan’s formulas of sexuation indicate, the &lt;Not-All&gt; subject has access to both forms of jouissance — Φ and S(Ø). The former turns out to be the mode of jouissance in which ɑ is present, whereas the latter is the mode in which ɑ is absent.</p><p>If the former manifests the life drive (Lebenstrieb, Eros), the latter bears the trace of the death drive (Todestrieb, Thanatos).</p><p>This resonates with Freud’s attempt in <em>Beyond the Pleasure Principle</em> to conceptualize an equivalence among the Pleasure Principle, the Nirvana Principle, and the Todestrieb.</p><p>Since S(Ø) — Other jouissance — has been described as “the God face of the Other,” the worldly product &lt;objet petit ɑ&gt;, within this religious ecstasy (悅樂) and ritual of Nirvana (涅槃), is treated, much like Lacan’s Cogito, as an absence “in between” Being and Meaning.</p><p>It is the encounter with the terrifying and awe-inspiring God — I-AM-WHO-I-AM — who appeared to Moses within the burning bush of Mount Horeb.</p><p>Such, indeed, is &lt;la jouissance de l’Autre&gt;.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ef1e856e5eb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fort/Da: Symptom―＄◇ɑ―Sinthome]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/fort-da-symptom-%C9%91-sinthome-8ab898a05638?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ab898a05638</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Sep 2026 01:24:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-06T01:24:01.259Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Let us begin with Heidegger’s notion of “being-in-the-world” (In-der-Welt-Sein). The crucial point lies in the preposition “in.”</p><p>For there is a fundamental conceptual difference between saying that human existence is an entity situated “outside” the world and saying that it is constituted as being-in-the-world.</p><p>If Heidegger’s formulation is interpreted from a structuralist perspective, it could be reformulated as follows: the human being is an entity situated within structure.</p><p>But what, precisely, is the “structure” of which the structuralists speak? It is as though, in the biblical declaration “In the beginning was the Word (Logos),” the term structure were substituted for Word.</p><p>The human being enters into structure at the very moment of birth. This means that one is inserted into the encompassing frameworks of the family, society, the nation, and the world.</p><p>It is only within such structures that the human being can secure the conditions of his or her humanity.</p><p>Yet at a more substantive level, to say that the human being is situated within structure means that the subject moves from the register of being into the register of meaning. Implicit in this transition is the presupposition of an Other (O) who stands over against the subject (S).</p><p>In the language of post-structuralism, this means entering the Symbolic order. Only the subject who has entered the Symbolic order fully — all — a subject of Bejahung, can be regarded as a healthy subject.</p><p>The incomplete subject, the not-all, who has failed to enter fully into the process of signification, remains a neurotic subject who has passed only partially through the point de capiton, the quilting point at which meaning is anchored. It is precisely this subject who becomes the object of psychoanalysis.</p><p>Structurally speaking, then, what does it mean to enter the linguistic Symbolic order?</p><p>The structuralist linguist Ferdinand de Saussure famously declared that “in language there are only differences,” and the subsequent work of Roman Jakobson connected this notion of difference to the logic of the binary system.</p><p>This, in effect, is the path of language and symbolization — and, by extension, the path of civilization itself.</p><p>The logic is analogous to that of the myth of the Fall from Eden. In the primordial unity of the coincidentia oppositorum, &lt;good + evil&gt; constitutes an undifferentiated whole; but once the divine command — Taboo! — is transgressed, this unity is split and differentiated into the binary opposition of good and evil.</p><p>From this perspective, signification, verbalization, symbolization, and civilization are merely different formulations of the same fundamental problematic.</p><p>Real₁ — Symbolic — Real₂ (ɑ) (Fink 1995, 27)</p><p>The above schema suggests that when the baptism of the Symbolic is imposed upon an originary Real, R₁ — a notion that remains strongly hypothetical in character — the result is the emergence of R₂. This R₂ is precisely objet petit ɑ: the remainder left over by symbolization, the residual element that may be rendered as the “memory” or “rem(a)inder” of the Real. This objet petit <em>ɑ</em> constitutes one of the pivotal concepts in Lacanian theory.</p><p>Philosophically, this crucial concept has been articulated in such formulations as the “non-thought ground of thought” or Aristotle’s “unmoved mover.” It is this enigmatic remainder that, in forming the identity-theme of a concrete individual, exerts a decisive influence upon that individual’s destiny.</p><p>The situation is analogous to Edgar Allan Poe’s “purloined letter”: the destiny of the person who possesses the letter follows the trajectory prescribed by the signifier itself.</p><p>Among the numerous algorithms — or mathemes — of Lacanian discourse, ＄◇ɑ is unquestionably one of the most fundamental. It designates the relation that the barred or divided subject ($) establishes with objet petit ɑ, and it is another name for fantasy.</p><p>But what is fantasy?</p><p>What else could it be but the semiotic manifestation of the unconscious (Ucs.)?</p><p>When Hegel declared that history is the self-realization of Absolute Spirit, Lacan might be said to have answered in kind: the history of an individual is the self-realization of objet petit ɑ.</p><p>Both propositions ultimately amount to interpretive glosses upon the same fundamental algorithm: ＄◇<em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>The semiotic manifestations of the unconscious take various forms of conscious expression, including dreams, symptoms, slips of the tongue, and other formations of the unconscious.</p><p>From this perspective, a symptom such as the compulsive running of the Rat Man can be understood as a self-expression of ＄◇<em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>The divided subject expresses his relation to objet petit <em>ɑ</em>, the object that constitutes the theme of his identity, through the “bungled action” of compulsive running.</p><p>In Poe’s “The Purloined Letter,” the second person to acquire the letter was Dupin. The letter had been conspicuously displayed on a shelf in the Minister’s drawing room — indeed, this ostentatious display was itself an elaborate strategy of concealment. Taking advantage of a momentary lapse in surveillance, Dupin replaced the original with a counterfeit and then “stole” the genuine letter. The Minister was, quite literally, robbed in broad daylight.</p><p>This is the manner in which objet petit <em>ɑ</em> moves unconsciously: it is the trajectory followed by the signifier.</p><p>An analyst with the perceptive acuity of the detective Dupin — Freud, and later Lacan — could hardly fail to trace the path of that unconscious signifier.</p><p>Through analytic interrogation, it was established that the analysand R harbored a murderous, erotically charged desire toward his English cousin, Richard, and that Richard’s childhood nickname was “Dick,” which in German was associated with the meaning “fat.” On this basis, the interpretive frame &lt;Killing Richard → Killing Fat&gt; was constructed. R’s “compulsive running,” therefore, was nothing other than the expression of an obsessive murderous desire.</p><p>This was Freud’s interpretation of R’s symptom: the interpretation of its “semiotic self-expression of the unconscious.”</p><p>It is the gift bestowed by “reading against the grain,” the paradigmatic form of unconscious reading.</p><p>What, then, occurred within R’s psychic economy when he received this gift? An apophantic event, a decisive disclosure that struck the Real, must have taken place, and the shock of that encounter effected the cure.</p><p>This is the therapeutic efficacy of the language of the oracle.</p><p>To follow the path of fantasy as the semiotic self-expression of the unconscious is thus to understand that $ encounters ɑ, and that the subject’s assumption of this encounter, as a matter of subjective appropriation, leads toward the cure of the symptom.</p><p>It is a movement from symptom to Sinthome.</p><p>Whereas the former is structured according to ＄◇ɑ — that is, according to the structure of fantasy — the latter accomplishes the feat of incorporating ɑ into the barred subject $, thereby embodying it. This is the achievement of the “Traversal of Fantasy.”</p><p>It is the completion of the Fort/Da game, that “great cultural achievement.”</p><p>Freud interpreted the game played by the young Ernst as a “great cultural achievement” because it transformed “what happened to me” into “what I made happen to me.”</p><p>Here we encounter the subject’s active and practical intervention in the movement from fantasy to the Traversal of Fantasy.</p><p>It is the realization of responsibility: the subject’s assumption of a position of agency with respect to objet petit <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>From this point onward flows the current of the Sinthome.</p><p>The Sinthome is, in a certain sense, a form of sublimation.</p><p>The fundamental mechanism of sublimation consists in redirecting the flow of a powerful drive (Trieb) by changing its aim and object, while without diminishing its intensity.</p><p>Leonardo da Vinci’s maternal passion, for example, may be understood as having been “sublimated” into artistic creation.</p><p>The path of sublimation is thus the enactment of an aesthetics of the Sublime, whereby an ordinary object is elevated — or, paradoxically, brought down — to the “dignity of the Thing.”</p><p>This is the path of the Sinthome that Lacan came to emphasize in his later work.</p><p>It is another formulation of the Traversal of Fantasy, as well as an application of the logic of Nachträglichkeit, or deferred action/après-coup, to the symptom.</p><p>In Seminar XXIII, Lacan developed his theory of the Sinthome (Le Sinthome).</p><p>His exemplary case was James Joyce, the writer associated with the “stream of consciousness.” According to Lacan, Joyce had been reduced to a Not-All subject as a consequence of the failure of the paternal metaphor. Yet through his singular mode of writing — his distinctive écriture as a creative writer — Joyce succeeded in restoring the damaged Borromean knot.</p><p>Let us take this opportunity to reconsider the Paternal Metaphor once again.</p><p>Is it not the first initiation and rite of passage through which human existence, as being-in-the-world, enters into the framework of the structure of which structuralism speaks?</p><p>The Paternal Metaphor (métaphore paternelle) is Lacan’s application of Freud’s theory of the Oedipus Complex to the Lacanian formula of metaphor (É, 200).</p><p>Structurally, the Desire of the Mother is replaced by the Name-of-the-Father / No! of the Father, thereby producing the signifier of the Phallus as signification.</p><p>Among these elements, the intermediate stage of &lt;nom/non du père&gt; is decisive.</p><p>It occupies the middle position corresponding to the dialectical antithesis in Hegelian dialectics — a crucial moment upon which the successful completion of the dialectical movement depends.</p><p>The father’s Name/No!, who, from the child’s perspective, assumes the sovereign authority of the absolute “I AM WHO I AM” revealed in the theophany on Mount Sinai, possesses the power to determine the child’s destiny.</p><p>Depending on whether the child fully accepts his injunction — “Stay away from Mom, or else …” — through Bejahung (All), accepts it only partially through Verleugnung (Not-All), or forecloses it through Verwerfung (None), the child’s particular psychopathological structure is determined.</p><p>In the case of James Joyce, Lacan’s diagnosis of a “failure of the Paternal Metaphor” would seem to place him within the second or third category above — that is, within the broad spectrum of neurosis/psychosis.</p><p>But what, then, was the “poetic technique” (ars poetica) by which Joyce was able to ride over, transcend, or otherwise negotiate this psychopathological trauma through his singular mode of writing?</p><p>An answer to this question can be developed through the argument of Freud’s early psychoanalytic essay “Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming” (1908).</p><p>The question Freud poses in this essay is essentially this: Are creative writers merely engaged in “day-dreaming”?</p><p>Having published the epoch-making and enduringly influential <em>The Interpretation of Dreams</em>, Freud had come to view human psychic activity through the underlying structural paradigm of the dream.</p><p>Put simply, writers are individuals who each suffer from their own particular form of psychopathology, and through their artistic production they conceal, or cover over, that pathology in much the same way that one dreams.</p><p>This is why the metaphor of the daydream, as in <em>A Midsummer Night’s Dream</em>, becomes so pertinent.</p><p>Freud thus understood the writer’s imagination as part of a symptomatic fantasy (＄◇ɑ).</p><p>Lacan, by contrast, in Seminar XXIII: <em>Le Sinthome</em>, interpreted James Joyce’s writing not as a symptom but as a Sinthome — indeed, as paradigmatic of the Traversal of Fantasy.</p><p>The former represents a pathologizing trajectory; the latter, a de-pathologizing path toward cure.</p><p>This does not mean, however, that there is an unbridgeable gulf between these two masters of psychoanalysis concerning the relation between literature and psychoanalysis.</p><p>In his subsequent writings, Freud repeatedly elaborated the path of artistic sublimation, and in this respect his position is not altogether remote from Lacan’s theory of the Sinthome.</p><p>If one accepts the categorical imperative of sublimation — to preserve the intensity of the primordial desire while altering its object and aim — would this not elevate the Not-All subject toward a condition of All, thereby allowing it to assume the status of an existential fourth knot, the Sinthome, through which the ruptured Borromean knot can be restored?</p><p>From this perspective, Freud’s essay on day-dreaming and Lacan’s seminar on the Sinthome were, in effect, saying almost the same thing, though in somewhat different vocabularies.</p><p>Both focused their attention on the diagram ＄◇<em>ɑ</em> and concentrated upon objet petit ɑ; yet Freud’s emphasis fell upon fantasy/dream, whereas Lacan’s fell upon the Traversal of Fantasy/interpretation of dreams.</p><p>There is, nevertheless, a significant difference between the two insofar as fantasy is grounded in Eros/Lebenstrieb, whereas the Traversal of Fantasy is grounded in Thanatos/Todestrieb.</p><p>If the former corresponds to “dreaming,” the latter corresponds to “the interpretation of dreams.”</p><p>Given that the formation of the dream — an “<em>ɑ</em>-way of dreaming” — constitutes a process of the semiotic manifestation of the unconscious, the interpretation of dreams, through the strategy of “reading against the grain,” reverses and deconstructs this process in order to reveal the primordial “dream-thought” (Traumgedanke) underlying it — that is, objet <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>It is the process by which the unconscious is brought into consciousness.</p><p>More precisely, it constitutes the crosswise dialectic of fantasy and its Traversal.</p><p>To elevate the fantasy that articulates the relation between the subject and <em>ɑ</em> — ＄◇<em>ɑ</em> — and to dwell upon, reflect upon, and work through its meaning: this is the Sinthome.</p><p>And this, according to Lacan, is precisely what James Joyce accomplished through his narrative writing.</p><p>More concretely, how can such a thing actually take place?</p><p>Through the logic of Nachträglichkeit — the retrospective reconstruction of the past in the present.</p><p>This is Lacan’s discourse of the Analyst.</p><p>The fundamental proposition of this discourse is that the analyst must assume the position of objet petit ɑ for the analysand.</p><p>But how?</p><p>Through Transference, the supreme language of the analytic encounter.</p><p>The patient unconsciously projects his or her Trauma onto the analyst.</p><p>More precisely, what takes place is the present re-presentation — or re-enactment — of the past. It is the logic of the Sinthome activated retroactively.</p><p>Through narrative écriture, the logic of the Sinthome operates by producing a grammatical structure of the form “I should have + past participle.”</p><p>The Trauma suffered by the writer — the failure of the Paternal Metaphor — is inscribed in retrospective expressions of regret such as: “At that time, in that place, I should have …” or “I should not have …”</p><p>The subject works and reworks the question of what to do with the objet petit <em>ɑ</em> that rises into the field of fantasy, turning the matter over and over in the mind and devising, in his or her own way, a possible solution.</p><p>This is, precisely, the practice of the Traversal of Fantasy.</p><p>It is an attempt to discover a way of settling the debt implied in what Heidegger calls Schuldigsein, the condition of being indebted or guilty.</p><p>Religious vocabularies such as the remission of sins or the expiation of karma presumably emerge from the same problematic.</p><p>Closely related to this is the concept of revenge.</p><p>The Lex Talionis — “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth” — found both in the Code of Hammurabi and in the Pentateuch, may likewise be understood in relation to the settlement of a debt, guilt, or karma incurred in the past.</p><p>The path of the Sinthome is to complete the sentence “I should have + past participle” in such a way that one punishes without being punished — a kind of “punishment with impunity.”</p><p>The effect of the Sinthome is a movement toward re-ordering: blocked passages are opened, what has been bent is straightened, and disorder is reorganized into order.</p><p>The hyperbolic relation between inside and outside enacted by the Möbius strip, and the topological imagination it makes possible, constitutes the metaphysical Sinthome’s geometric or material expression.</p><p>Earlier, we identified the Paternal Metaphor as both a problem of structure — the structure into which the human subject, as being-in-the-world, is necessarily inserted — and a problem of “forced choice.”</p><p>Because of the excesses and deficiencies — commission and omission — involved in this rite of passage, virtually every human subject is, in some sense, “executed” into the condition of the Not-All.</p><p>The Sisyphean labor of filling and repairing that missing portion, and of propelling the subject toward the condition of All, consists in completing the incomplete sentence. It is the path upon which perfectionism takes hold.</p><p>To the subjects of the Sinthome — like the Rat Man — who, knowing full well that the stone may roll back down the hill the moment they have pushed it to the summit, nevertheless rush headlong toward the “Mission Completed!” of All, we offer a single rose.</p><p>It is to discern the aesthetics of the Sublime in the face of Antigone, who defies the edict of Creon.</p><p>In this process of normalizing the abnormal, the “taxidermied genius” of Yi Sang comes into its own, while the “illness of knowledge,” or savant syndrome, associated with Woo Young-woo, the “extraordinary attorney,” manifests itself.</p><p>There is a theory that such “strange” genius may emerge when the emotional wounds received by the right hemisphere are rationally overcompensated for by the left hemisphere.</p><p>There is a longstanding European Catholic tradition, dating back to approximately the fifth and sixth centuries, in which the male sponsor of a person who has received the sacraments of Baptism and Confirmation is designated as a Godfather.</p><p>The concept bears a certain resemblance to the three films of <em>The Godfather</em> — Parts I, II, and III — though the two notions are, of course, conceptually quite distinct.</p><p>For subjects rendered Not-All by a failure of the Paternal Metaphor, the establishment of such a Godfather institution could, in principle, produce a substantial Sinthome effect.</p><p>For it would make possible an aesthetics of the Sublime in which the record of failure with the first father could be offset — or rewritten — through a “successful” relation with a second father, the Godfather.</p><p>Consider, for example, Pip, the protagonist of Charles Dickens’s <em>Great Expectations</em>. Pip is an orphan abandoned to the margins of the world, possessing no living memory of either parent.</p><p>According to Jung’s theory of archetypes, the parental imago assumes an archetypal character.</p><p>In the novel, Pip’s paternal imago is projected onto the terrifying escaped convict Magwitch, while his maternal imago is projected onto Miss Havisham, the mysterious mistress of Satis House.</p><p>These two mythic figures, both larger than life, provide the orphaned Pip with precisely the conditions and psychic environment necessary for the projection of his archetypal paternal and maternal imagos.</p><p>The narrative trajectory of the novel can therefore be said to enact, in Paul Frantz’s formulation, the grammar of “Projection and Re-Collection” — the projection of an imago followed by the withdrawal, or recollection, of that projection.</p><p>In other words, Great Expectations possesses a narrative plot structured so that Magwitch and Havisham come to function, respectively, as Pip’s Godfather and Godmother.</p><p>That plot is the path of the Sinthome.</p><p>And Pip’s redemption lies precisely along that path.</p><p>This universal human effort to elevate the record of a failed Paternal Metaphor, belatedly and retrospectively, into a field of success is also manifested in religiosity.</p><p>YHWH, the God who manifested Himself in the burning bush on Mount Horeb, and the absolute “I AM” who bestowed the Ten Commandments upon Moses on Mount Sinai, have been inscribed in the collective memory of humanity as the paradigmatic figures of authority.</p><p>Through a properly constituted relation with this Godfather of Godfathers, one attempts to erase, or rewrite, the record of the missed encounter with the “little” father — the failed encounter with the Paternal Metaphor itself.</p><p>It conforms to Freud’s definition of the dream as “compensatory wish-fulfillment.”</p><p>Dreams come true!</p><p>The record of the dream brought into realization is the Sinthome.</p><p>For this reason, whenever we speak of Lacan’s theory of the Sinthome, we should read it alongside Freud’s “Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming” (1908).</p><p>April is the month in which Easter and my birthday coincide.</p><p>We are now living in the age of AI.</p><p>＄◇<em>ɑ</em>: the relation that the divided subject establishes with objet petit ɑ.</p><p>SIR: when symbolic castration is imposed upon the Imaginary, the Real emerges.</p><p>Fort–Da: the dialectic of fantasy and de-fantasy, of entering into and moving beyond fantasy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ab898a05638" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[History and Fiction, Nachträglichkeit/Sinthome]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/history-and-fiction-nachtr%C3%A4glichkeit-sinthome-4538ca9555a0?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4538ca9555a0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 Aug 2026 12:33:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-22T12:36:46.389Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Finishing the Overdue Homework</strong></p><p>Aristotle’s distinction between history and literature — fiction — as set forth in his <em>Poetics</em>, is precise.</p><p>Whereas history is a record of “what was,” literature is a record of “what might be.” Hence, Aristotle’s claim that the latter is “more philosophical” than the former.</p><p>Here, to say that something is “more philosophical” would seem to mean that it is closer to truth proper — Eigentlichkeit, or authenticity. But why should this be so?</p><p>What, then, is the <em>ars poetica</em>, the “poetic technique,” of which Freud speaks in his 1908 essay, “Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming”?</p><p>It is the completion of the sentence “&lt;should have + past participle&gt;” — that is, the production, by creative writers, of a record of “what should have been,” or, more precisely, of what might have happened but did not.</p><p>Through writing about past events marked by regret and retrospective reflection — events condensed in expressions such as “I should have …!” — the writer is performing a kind of exorcistic ritual.</p><p>It is an act of settling the debt of the “guilty being” (Suldigsein) in Heidegger’s sense.</p><p>And this task requires the deployment of the apparatus of literary fiction.</p><p>Park Wan-suh, the author of “Who Ate Up All the Shinga?,” once remarked that, when she was asked to write an autobiographical piece, she struggled with the task; but once she overlaid the autobiographical material with a layer of fiction, the writing became considerably easier.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Because the former was a record of history, whereas the latter was a fictional mode of writing in the form of “&lt;should have + past participle&gt;.”</p><p>In other words, autobiographical writing and fictional writing differ fundamentally in that the former constitutes a historical record of “what happened to me,” whereas the latter constitutes a subjective record of “what I made happen to me.”</p><p>This is, precisely, the prototype of the Fort/Da game that Freud presents in <em>Beyond the Pleasure Principle</em>.</p><p>Freud famously elevated the dialectical play of “gone” (Fort) and “there/back” (Da) — the game through which the one-and-a-half-year-old Ernst overcame the traumatic situation of his mother’s absence by transforming it into a game of disappearance and return — into a “great cultural achievement.”</p><p>Here, one seems to encounter the paradigmatic form of the <em>Poetics</em> according to which fictional writing is “more philosophical” than autobiographical writing, just as literature is “more philosophical” than history.</p><p>This is precisely what Jacques Lacan identifies in James Joyce’s écriture in <em>Seminar XXIII, Le Sinthome</em>.</p><p>For the incomplete subject of the Not-All, who has failed to acquire a point of capiton because of the failure of the paternal metaphor, what remains to be done is to retrace the record of that failure and, here and now, undertake a fictional mode of writing in the form of “&lt;I should have + past participle&gt;.”</p><p>It is to enact, in a subjectively self-determined manner, the present representation/re-presentation of the past — much as the subject of the Fort/Da game actively stages and restages the experience of absence and return.</p><p>According to Hegel, history is the self-realization of Absolute Spirit.</p><p>Lacan’s Absolute Spirit is the <em>objet petit ɑ</em>.</p><p>Hence, psychoanalytic history is the self-realization of object <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>And this is the path of the Sinthome, the path that Lacan emphasized with such insistence in the final years of his teaching.</p><p>James Joyce, having assumed the fate of the Borromean knot collapsing under the failure of the paternal metaphor, was able, through his singular écriture — his writing as a “flow of the unconscious” — to construct a fourth existential knot in the form of the Sinthome.</p><p>Yet we need not derive our examples only from those who have achieved such “success.”</p><p>Even in some obscure country villager who washes his hands compulsively, as though it were an everyday routine, we may catch a glimpse of such a “stream” of the mind.</p><p>Through this ritualized act, he is performing a kind of salpuri — an exorcistic working-through of some “unfortunate” event that occurred at a certain point in the past, particularly around the time of his initiation into adulthood.</p><p>Consider, for example, a retrospective narrative of regret such as:</p><p>“I should have killed that bastard!”</p><p>By washing his hands repeatedly until they are impeccably clean, he is deploying a defense mechanism against an intru<em>th</em>ive force — a strategy designed to annihilate the invading power in one fell swoop.</p><p>It is the equivalent of intercepting an enemy missile attack with unfailing precision.</p><p>The reason I have written &lt;th&gt; rather than &lt;s&gt; in the word intru<em>th</em>ive above is to signify that, precisely at that point, the “Truth” of Eigentlichkeit has emerged.</p><p>Truth heals the illness.</p><p>Hence, in an important sense, even this country villager’s compulsive hand-washing constitutes a practice of Sinthome theory.</p><p>Enjoy your Sinthome!</p><p>The unconscious is often expressed through negative particles such as English “but” or French “pas.”</p><p>In the former case, what corresponds to “I cannot but …” serves to constrain and qualify the meaning of what precedes it.</p><p>Consider the meaning-restricting function of but in the line from the theme song of “The Godfather,” “No one hears us <em>but</em> the sky,” or in the popular-song refrain, “Nobody, nobody but you.”</p><p>If what precedes <em>but</em> is regarded as the conscious expression of the surface structure, what follows <em>but</em> may be taken as an indication of the unconscious meaning belonging to the deep structure.</p><p>Contents repressed from the conscious system — the repressed — constitute the unconscious, and the return of the repressed into consciousness requires a process of transformation analogous to dream-work, precisely in order to pass through the intervening line of censorship.</p><p>This process manifests itself throughout the various forms of semiotic representation of the ucs. — in dreaming, symptom formation, and related formations of the unconscious.</p><p>Accordingly, in analytic listening aimed at bringing the material of the unconscious to light, particular attention should be paid to semantically restrictive expressions such as English <em>but</em> and French <em>pas</em>.</p><p>The Sinthome is accompanied by compulsivity and repetition.</p><p>Is this perhaps the enactment of Freud’s theory of repetition compulsion (Wiederholungszwang)?</p><p>The Rat Man’s compulsive running is exemplary in this regard.</p><p>Why, under the blazing August sun of midsummer, did this young man have to run, and run, and run?</p><p>When Freud asked him, the answer came back: “To lose weight.”</p><p>This was his “conscious” answer.</p><p>The “unconscious” answer that Freud painstakingly traced and brought to light was, as I have argued elsewhere, &lt;Killing Richard&gt;.</p><p>The Rat Man, who harbored a profound grievance against Richard, was inwardly possessed by the murderous wish to kill him. Yet to act upon this wish as an expression of the pleasure principle would violate the reality principle. Thus, in a proverbial substitution of the chicken for the pheasant, he enacted a metaphorical substitution: rather than killing a man, he would “kill” fat.</p><p>Here a highly elaborate metaphorical mechanism is at work.</p><p>Richard’s childhood nickname in English is Dick, while dick in German (dick) signifies “fat” or “obese.” Hence:</p><p>&lt;Killing Richard&gt; → &lt;Killing Dick&gt; → &lt;Killing fat&gt;</p><p>In this chain of signification, the wish to kill Richard is displaced onto the wish to eliminate fat — thus transforming the murderous impulse into the ostensibly innocuous act of losing weight.</p><p>The Rat Man’s compulsive running can therefore be read as the bodily enactment of this metaphorical substitution: the killing of Richard becomes the killing of fat.</p><p>This is also living evidence that the unconscious is structured like a language.</p><p>What deserves particular attention here is the question of textuality.</p><p>Following Derrida’s injunction to “read the world as a text,” what happens if we read the Rat Man’s compulsive running as a text?</p><p>What emerges is the insight of the disjunction between surface and deep structures, between construction and deconstruction — in other words, the insight of deconstruction itself.</p><p>And this discovery becomes possible through the act of reading against the grain of the text.</p><p>What is disclosed in that process is the very existence of the unconscious as a rem(a)inder — that which remains over, or remains behind, as a reminder of signification.</p><p>In the Rat Man’s case, if compulsive running constitutes the surface structure of the text, then the unconscious deep structure disclosed through the deconstructive strategy of reading against the grain is “Killing Richard.”</p><p>Thus, the conscious and the unconscious face in opposite directions, like the two faces of <em>Janus</em>.</p><p>The archaeological exploration of the unconscious must therefore proceed through the <em>Nekyia</em> of <em>Odyssey</em> XI — the night journey beneath the sea.</p><p>Hegel’s injunction of “tarrying with the negative,” as well as Keats’s notion of “negative capability,” can likewise be heard as formulations emphasizing the necessity of exploring the unconscious through a willingness to read against the grain of the text.</p><p>The path toward discovering the textual unconscious begins by attending to the text’s lacunary phenomena.</p><p>If, as Lacan suggests, the text is a field constituted by “lies,” then those lies that contradict the order of consciousness are precisely what constitute the unconscious.</p><p>Whenever something that ought to be there is missing; whenever something that could just as well have been omitted nevertheless appears; whenever what ought to be emphasized and what ought not to be emphasized fall out of sync and begin, as it were, to “convulse” — such phenomena constitute the logical gaps of the text.</p><p>They function as a “tell-tale heart,” betraying the secret presence of the unconscious within the textual surface.</p><p>A more concrete way of discovering the unconscious of a text is to attend to the two axes of language identified by structuralist linguistics: the axes of metaphor and metonymy.</p><p>When we say that a dream is constituted through figurative language, the relevant English term is “trope.” The word itself carries the sense of turning or turning aside — of saying something by way of a turn.</p><p>More precisely, metaphor is a phenomenon of substitution, in which B takes the place of A; metonymy, by contrast, is a phenomenon of contiguity, in which B comes to stand alongside A.</p><p>Consider Freud’s “specimen dream,” Irma’s Injection.</p><p>Here we encounter the powerful metaphor of the “dirty syringe.”</p><p>It emerges from a linguistic slip — a slip of the tongue, or a piece of bungled speech — arising from the rivalry between Freud, Irma’s physician, and his colleague Otto, each competing for the status of the more competent doctor in relation to the attractive female patient, Irma — the widow.</p><p>When Freud sees the whitish patches on Irma’s throat and reproaches her for not having followed his prescription, he introduces the possibility that the injection may have been administered by his rival, Otto, and invokes the image of a “dirty syringe.”</p><p>In the midst of this scene, the word “trimethylamine,” a sexually charged chemical term, comes dramatically into close-up.</p><p>The syringe is a quintessential phallic symbol.</p><p>Its symbolic function corresponds precisely to that of the pipe in Magritte’s famous painting, accompanied by the declaration:</p><p>“This is not a pipe!”</p><p>The syringe is a paradigmatic metaphor that substitutes for the Phallus:</p><p>“This” takes the place of “that.”</p><p>In this structure, “that” is the tenor of the metaphor, while “this” is its vehicle. The tenor of the deep structure is transported by the vehicle of the surface structure, thereby becoming indirectly manifest.</p><p>This is precisely the structure of metaphor formulated by I. A. Richards, the intellectual forefather of what would later become known as New Criticism.</p><p>Through a mode of reading that might be called “symbolic reading,” or “reading against the grain of the text,” we decipher the deep structure lying beneath the conscious surface structure — the unconscious meaning inscribed there.</p><p>The interpretation of dreams (Traumdeutung), as a “semiotic manifestation of the ucs,” should likewise be treated as part of what Paul Ricoeur famously called a “hermeneutics of suspicion.”</p><p>Another important fact disclosed through Freud’s canonical dreams is that part and whole stand in an organic relation to one another.</p><p>In the dream, the seemingly minor signifier &lt;dirty syringe&gt; governs the title and, indeed, the semantic economy of the dream as a whole: &lt;Irma’s Injection&gt;.</p><p>Is this perhaps an instance of the relation between microcosm and macrocosm — or, to anticipate a distinction developed later, between the iron bell and the Golden Bell?</p><p>What, then, of metonymy, in which A and B are connected through contiguity?</p><p>Let us recall Freud’s second dream, the dream concerning &lt;The Botanical Monograph&gt;.</p><p>The most vivid image or symbol in this dream is a flower, a wildflower carefully collected and delicately pressed between the pages of a book.</p><p>Since B is figured in contiguity with A, we can recognize this associative operation as an expression of metonymic imagination.</p><p>The difficulty lies in the divergent interpretations to which this figurative language has given rise.</p><p>Freud himself, the author of the dream, refrains from offering any straightforward commentary on it. Erich Fromm, famous for <em>Escape from Freedom</em>, however, interpreted the image as an expression of resistance to Freud’s alleged intellectualism — a tendency to cover over affect with intellect. His reading presumably arose from the phrase “dried specimen of the plant” appearing in the book.</p><p>Whether or not this interpretation is correct, the contiguity of &lt;the flower in the book&gt; allows us to discern a distinctly metonymic mode of thought.</p><p>I would read this dream instead as “the self-collection of desire.”</p><p>Freud had burst upon the academic world like a comet under the sign of sex. Not only was he himself possessed of formidable sexual vitality; around the time of this dream, he had also brought into the world his monumental <em>Interpretation of</em> <em>Dreams</em>, an immortal work grounded in sexuality.</p><p>Unregulated sexuality is a pie in the sky. As the saying goes, a storm in a teacup: only sexuality contained within the teacup can acquire the force of a storm.</p><p>Only within the confines of the symbolic order can the storm of the Real/Id rage.</p><p>This is the path of desire (désir) articulated by the Lacanian proposition that “man’s desire is the desire of the Other.”</p><p>Only the language of flowers, carefully collected and orderly pressed within the intellectual text of &lt;The Botanical Monograph&gt;, can become the language of desire/drive in which one might “vivre la pulsion.”</p><p>At this point, we need to clarify the differential features of the terms desire and drive.</p><p>Although the two words are similar both in appearance and, in certain contexts, in sound, they must be rigorously distinguished. Both derive their primordial energy from “the It” (das Es, the Id); yet desire belongs to the Symbolic, whereas drive belongs to the Real.</p><p>This distinction also explains why Žižek engages in a polemical dispute over Lacan’s injunction “do not give up on your desire” in <em>Looking Awry</em> (p. 172): the issue turns on whether the object of giving up (céder) is desire or drive.</p><p>On Žižek’s own logic, it should have been not the giving up of desire but the giving up of the drive.</p><p>For desire, as a concept, already presupposes a certain renunciation of the drive.</p><p>If we formulate this in terms of the structure of fantasy, $ ◇ a belongs to the structure of the drive, whereas “traversing the fantasy,” through which a is incorporated into $, belongs to the structure of desire.</p><p>Accordingly, the nocturnal narrative presented in Freud’s dream of &lt;The Botanical Monograph&gt;, and the narrative truth disclosed through it, might more precisely be called not “the self-collection of desire” but “the self-collection of the drive.”</p><p>If we were to turn Erich Fromm’s negative assessment into a positive formulation, we might say that the wildflower specimen carefully collected and pressed between the pages of the book constitutes a “great cultural achievement” — a Fort/Da game in which the dreamer’s formidable sexual potential is contained, gathered, and embraced by the extraordinary intellect that produced <em>The Interpretation of Dreams</em>.</p><p>Thus, whether the figurative turn (trope) at work is metaphorical or metonymic, the existence of B is constituted by taking A as its host.</p><p>In other words, the language of the unconscious is formed by taking the language of consciousness as its host.</p><p>Even in the banal metaphor “I’m getting excited” (​저, 흥분돼요), the conscious linguistic element &lt;데&gt; contains, or is infiltrated by, the unconscious textual element &lt;돼&gt;.</p><p>The analytic injunction that a patient’s words should never be accepted “at face value” may itself derive from precisely this kind of disjunction, or misalignment, between A and B.</p><p>The same structure reveals itself without mediation in the unfolding of &lt;narrative and desire&gt;, or what might be called &lt;narrative desire&gt;.</p><p>Narrative necessarily entails a structure of conflict.</p><p>Indeed, the first lesson of narratology is that there can be no narrative from which the structure of 葛藤 — the entanglement of the kudzu and wisteria vines, the very etymological image of conflict — has been fundamentally excluded.</p><p>This is analogous to the fact that there is no human life entirely devoid of conflict.</p><p>Accordingly, a piece of storytelling such as “A certain person was born with a silver spoon in his mouth, ate well, lived well, and died peacefully” does not qualify as narrativity in the full sense.</p><p>This is one of the fundamental principles of narrative: without conflict, there is no narrative.</p><p>In Greek drama, particularly in tragedies such as those of Sophocles, it is precisely this kind of conflict that sets the dramatic reversal — the peripeteia — in motion.</p><p>Consider, for example, the opening of the dream concerning <em>The Botanical Monograph</em>. It begins:</p><p>“I had written a monograph on a certain plant. The book lay before me, and I was at the moment turning over a folded colored plate.”</p><p>Like the opening and initial development of an ordinary narrative, the dream begins with the seemingly innocuous statement: “I had written a monograph on a certain plant, and the book lay before me as I casually turned its pages.”</p><p>Then, at the next stage, the dramatic reversal occurs.</p><p>A “dried specimen” of the plant is discovered between the pages of the book, and its identity, its historical provenance, and the subtle ripples it sends through the dreamer’s psychic life — its mysterious shock — gradually come to determine the meaning of the dream.</p><p>It is precisely at this moment that the unconscious dimension of the dreamer, with a creaking sound, so to speak, begins to open a door that had remained shut. This is the momentum of the peripeteia.</p><p>The same is true of narrative in general. The difference is simply that, in narrative, the representation of the &lt;peripeteia&gt; is made more explicit and dramatically foregrounded.</p><p>Take <em>Moby-Dick</em>, the great American epic and a modern representation of the &lt;American Nekyia&gt;. The “land-part” of the narrator Ishmael’s life and the “sea-part,” filled with Captain Ahab’s suffocating drama of pursuit of the White Whale, form a precise binary paradigm of Cs./Ucs. — the conscious and the unconscious — thereby reenacting the myth of the “night journey beneath the sea.”</p><p>It is a modern re-presentation of <em>Odyssey</em>, Book XI, the &lt;Nekyia&gt;.</p><p>That the meaning of narrative emerges through such dramatic reversal, through the dialectical order of the negative, is true not only of dreams and narrative in general but of fictional works as a whole.</p><p>For the disclosure of Being takes place over the abyss of Nothingness (das Nichts).</p><p>Psychoanalysis may therefore be described as a Sisyphean labor of relentless suffering: the attempt to discover the primordiality (Eigentlichkeit) of the unconscious, the nucleus of Being, and thereby to arrive at its authenticity.</p><p>For those who set out in search of the legendary Golden Bell, the circular structure standing starkly upon the mountain was not merely a building.</p><p>It was the metaphoric/metonymic substitution and displacement of the humble iron bell hanging inconspicuously inside it.</p><p>I am referring to the classic film <em>The Long Ships</em>.</p><p>After enduring every imaginable hardship to find the treasure, the expedition members are bitterly disappointed when they discover that the object they have found is nothing more than an insignificant iron bell. But the captain refuses to give up. He orders them to search the entire building from top to bottom.</p><p>The result is a revelation: the circular building itself is the Golden Bell.</p><p>The iron bell inside was merely a signifier, no more than the little finger pointing toward the moon.</p><p>Here we encounter the asymmetrical structure of microcosm and macrocosm.</p><p>What they have seen is the substance of Heideggerian &lt;Eigentlichkeit/Authenticity&gt; — the reality of “the things hoped for” (Hebrews 11:1).</p><p>This is the &lt;a-way of the Sinthome&gt;: the path of the Sinthome that follows the identity-bearing subject a, the path of identifying <em>objet petit</em> <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>Joyce’s écriture, and Marcel Proust’s “involuntary memory” salvaged from <em>In Search of Lost Time</em>, are both instances of this same movement.</p><p>In the concrete setting of analysis, the way of the Sinthome opens only after Lacan’s L-schema has been twisted once again and reconstructed in a modified form.</p><p>The axis of the Imaginary (e–o) must first be replaced by the axis of the Symbolic (S–O), and then once again transformed into the axis of the Real (Id–a). Only then does the path of the Sinthome become accessible (Fink 2001, 212).</p><p>Magritte paints a picture of a pipe and then declares, with uncompromising force:</p><p>“This is not a Pipe!”</p><p>Is this an attempt to metaphorize the Real concealed within the Symbolic?</p><p>Or is it a statement of the truth of Nature concealed within civilization?</p><p>The dialectic of desire and jouissance that Lacan articulates on the final page of <em>É</em> (p. 324), in its very last line, is almost moving in its intensity:</p><p>“Castration means that jouissance must be refused, so that it can be reached on the inverted ladder of the Law of desire.”</p><p>If the decisive turning point in human life — the transition from Nature to civilization — is symbolic castration, then its psychoanalytic implication is a kind of derailing, a deviation from Real jouissance toward Symbolic desire.</p><p>Accordingly, re-entry into Nature from within civilization — the return journey after completing our brief “picnic” on the planet Earth, the “return to Heaven” (​귀천) of the Korean poet Cheon Sang-byeong — would constitute a journey from desire back to jouissance, that is, a movement of de-castration (De-Castration).</p><p>Here we encounter a point of convergence with the Deconstruction of Jacques Derrida, Lacan’s contemporary and one of the central figures of poststructuralism.</p><p>When asked what the subject is to do after completing the traversal of fantasy, Lacan gives a succinct answer:</p><p>“vivre la pulsion.”</p><p>It is a categorical imperative: live the drive, the drive situated on the axis of the Real.</p><p>From the original Mountain, one passes through the dialectical negation of “the mountain is not the mountain” — the moment of symbolic castration — and then returns once more to:</p><p>“The mountain is the mountain.”</p><p>Is this resurrection after death?</p><p>Come to think of it, next Sunday is Easter.</p><p>Perhaps, on that day, we should listen once again for the voice of God that awakened the spirit of the young Samuel:</p><p>“Samuel! Samuel!” (1 Samuel 3:10)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4538ca9555a0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Le Sinthome: Nekyia of the Sacred Stone Spring]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/le-sinthome-nekyia-of-the-sacred-stone-spring-af5c72992845?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/af5c72992845</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Aug 2026 08:56:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-14T08:56:35.010Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Joseph Campbell’s concept of the Monomyth follows a cyclical structure of departure–initiation–return. John Milton’s myth of Paradise likewise forms another triadic configuration: Paradise–Paradise Lost–Paradise Regained. I take these three stages to constitute decisive moments that determine the destiny of human existence, and shall therefore examine each of them in turn.</p><p>The first is the myth of birth.</p><p>The myth of the emergence of humankind, beginning with the legend of the Garden of Eden, originates in the oxymoronic enigma of the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil (seon-akgwa, 善惡果). “Good” and “evil” appear to coexist, oxymoronically, within a single fruit. The human drive toward civilization ultimately begins with the attempt to break open the contradiction embedded in this oxymoron.</p><p>By eating the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, situated at the very center of the Garden of Eden, in defiance of God’s command, Adam and Eve “derailed” from nature into civilization — to borrow Žižek’s suggestive formulation. As an effect of this derailment, their “eyes were opened,” and they became conscious of their nakedness and experienced shame. They consequently fashioned garments out of fig leaves and embarked upon the path of civilization beyond Eden — the path toward which Milton’s <em>Paradise Lost</em> had already prophetically pointed.</p><p>Let us leave aside, for the moment, the subsequent history of this process of civilization and turn instead to another mythic narrative of human genesis in which the logic of <em>Coincidentia Oppositorum</em>, the unity of opposites, comes into operation.</p><p>I have in mind Plato’s discussion of androgyny in the <em>Symposium</em>.</p><p>The argument concerning androgyny — andro (male) + gyn (female) — as delivered by the brilliant interlocutor Aristophanes in that philosophical symposium is considerably more elaborate and more radical than the paradox of the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil. Beginning with the question of Eros, Aristophanes’ account proposes that human beings were originally constituted as androgynous beings, possessing two faces and four arms and four legs. In this primordial condition, they possessed such extraordinary strength and power that they could rival the gods themselves.</p><p>For this transgression, the Greek sin of hubris, Zeus split these beings cleanly in two. What remained was a half-human creature, with a single face and only two arms and two legs. Thereafter, the agonizing struggle of each half-human being to move toward the whole, toward totality, came to be named love, or Eros.</p><p>Human subjectivity, born of the alienation and separation produced in the process by which the One becomes Two, can do nothing but internalize within itself a fundamental lack (manque). Lacan’s account in <em>The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis (FFCP)</em> begins precisely here: “Two lacks overlap” (p. 204).</p><p>One of these two lacks — the primordial one — derives from the very dismemberment of the primordial androgynous being described above. The other arises in the process of signification; I shall defer discussion of this second lack until later.</p><p>What must be emphasized here is that the myth of the birth of the human subject originates, at its very source, in the logic of <em>coniunctio</em>, or <em>coincidentia oppositorum</em> — the union of opposites, the principle according to which the apparently antithetical poles constitute a primordial unity. In the Buddhist formulation of the <em>Heart Sutra</em>, this is expressed as “Form is not different from emptiness; emptiness is not different from form” (色不異空 空不異色). It is the realization articulated in the formula “Form is emptiness” (色是空).</p><p>But what destiny awaited the human being once these two terms, originally constituting a monistic unity, were sundered and alienated from one another into the two poles of a dualistic opposition?</p><p>The diagram Lacan presents on page 211 of <em>The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis (FFCP)</em> illustrates precisely this point.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/230/1*nhbfikZjOUoBByskj1bz9Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>In Žižek’s formulation, human existence is “condemned” to derail from the dimension of being into the dimension of meaning. This is because such derailment constitutes the very path of human civilization, signification, and symbolization.</p><p>Those who reject civilization and yearn to return to nature, however, inevitably carry on their bodies the tattoos of civilization, already stamped upon them in abundance. The road out of Eden, the <em>Exodus</em> from androgyny, is therefore an unavoidable expression of the human drive toward civilization.</p><p>How, then, is this problem of signification to be read from the perspective of structuralism?</p><p>Structure precedes essence.</p><p>Human existence acquires the conditions of its very being only after it has been inserted into a structural framework. The moment a young living being opens its eyes to the world, it is bound within the structure called the family; thereafter, it is destined to live as a member of ever larger structures — society, the nation, and ultimately the world. What else could Heidegger’s concept of In-der-Welt-Sein, or Being-in-the-World, signify?</p><p>Consider, for example, the Family Romance that unfolds among members of a family. Structurally embedded within this familial configuration is the categorical imperative of the Incest Taboo. It is only within the confines of such a structure that the human subject can breathe and sustain its existence.</p><p>As the structuralist anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss demonstrated, the law of the Incest Taboo is rigorously observed not merely in the civilized nations of Europe but also in the remotest regions of Africa and the tropical rainforests of South America. Wherever human beings live, this prohibition operates as a fundamental principle of social organization.</p><p>Let us now consider the most elementary Oedipal triadic structure: Father–Mother–Child.</p><p>The paternal metaphor, obtained by transposing Freud’s Oedipus Complex into Lacan’s metaphorical formula, constitutes the very core of a structural theory of the subject (<em>FFCP</em>, 200). After the process of metaphorization involving S₁/S₂, what remains in the right-hand term of the equation is Nom/Non du Père (Name/No of the Father), represented by O/Phallus.</p><p>The message conveyed by this algorithm is that, in the early stages of childhood, the “Name-of-the-Father” and the paternal “No!” are indispensable to the formation of subjectivity, and that this function is represented by the Phallus as signifier. It is a paradigmatic instance of the phallus as signification.</p><p>A subject who fails to receive the phallic signifier in an adequate manner is, in this sense, “condemned” to live as an incomplete subject of the Not-All.</p><p>All psychoanalytic endeavors might therefore be understood as attempts, through the Sinthome, to elevate this condition of Not-All toward a state of All. I shall elaborate on this point later through the framework of narrative theory.</p><p>What deserves particular attention here is the linguistic dimension of structuralism.</p><p>Ferdinand de Saussure, the founding figure of structural linguistics, famously asserted that “in language, there are only differences.” One might imagine this as referring to the curious world in which adding a single stroke to the Korean character 님 transforms it into 남.</p><p>Following Saussure, another structuralist, Roman Jakobson, connected the concept of difference to the logic of binary opposition, as manifested at the level of the phoneme.</p><p>Once the order of language is understood as the symbolic order, and once the concept of value is introduced into this binary structure, the system may readily degenerate into a consciousness of discrimination. A world may thereby be produced in which what Derrida calls logocentrism comes to reign supreme.</p><p>The poisonous mushroom of civilization reaches its most virulent expression in ideologies such as the caustic dictum of a Korean comedian — “What a filthy world, where only those who come first get to live well!” — or in anti-Semitism.</p><p>Consider, for instance, the ideological confrontation between communism and anti-communism. The tragic story of a Korean elementary-school child in Gangwon Province who, confronted by the guns and bayonets of communist guerrillas invading from the North, cried out, “I hate communists!”, before being brutally killed, vividly illustrates the fatal consequences of the ideological division between North and South Korea. It was a tragedy produced by the extreme consequences of a binary structure of language and symbolism.</p><p>Within such a structure, there is little room for the concepts of equality and justice. What proliferates instead are the bitter imperatives of Homo homini lupus — “man is a wolf to man” — along with the logic of wǎxīn chángdǎn (臥薪嘗膽), enduring suffering while awaiting revenge, and Lex Talionis, the law of retaliation: an eye for an eye.</p><p>Small wonder, then, that John Rawls, the author of <em>A Theory of Justice</em>, introduced his celebrated notion of the “veil of ignorance.” His proposal is, in effect, to cover over and suspend our awareness of difference, so that we may deliberate as though we could not see it.</p><p>And yet, while we cover over difference in this manner, the corpse lying inside the “whitewashed tomb” continues to function as an “A Tell-Tale Heart,” insistently exposing the good and evil concealed within us. What, then, is the **Eigentlichkeit — Authenticity — **of this affair?</p><p>The deconstruction of Jacques Derrida, one of the seminal figures of post-structuralism, seeks precisely to dismantle the logocentrism governed by binarism. By tracing the etymology of the Greek term <em>pharmakon</em> and thereby deconstructing the binary opposition between poison and remedy, Derrida offers a deconstructive account of Socrates’ problematic relation between death and life. This is one of the signal achievements of deconstruction.</p><p>In the same vein, how might we deconstruct the ideological opposition between communism and anti-communism so that peace might finally become possible on the Korean Peninsula?</p><p>The methodology of deconstruction directs our attention to textuality: that is, it adopts a strategy of “reading against the grain.”</p><p>Post-structuralism may thus be understood as a movement that seeks to step outside the rigid framework of structure — a movement of de-structuring, of moving beyond structure.</p><p>Seen in this light, one comes to recognize that Derrida’s strategy is remarkably close to Lacan’s own mode of reading, and that these two post-structuralist thinkers, who even happen to share the same first name — Jacques — were, in significant respects, engaged in virtually the same intellectual operation.</p><p>For Lacan, the text is a field saturated with lies. In order to strip away those lies and bring into view the inner truth, or Authenticity, the strategy of reading against the grain becomes indispensable.</p><p>Did Lacan not, in a deliberately “awry” formulation, parody Descartes’ <em>cogito ergo sum </em>by declaring, in effect:</p><p>“I am not where I think, and I think where I am not.”</p><p>The point is to foreground the unconsciousness of the unconscious — the Unbewusstheit of das Unbewusste — and to insist upon the radical disjunction between consciousness, thought, and being.</p><p>In this respect, I wrote the following in my recently published English-language book, <em>Lacan and Derrida</em> (2026):</p><p>“Lacan and Derrida perform the same gesture on different stages: reading against the grain in order to displace logocentrism and expose what insists beyond meaning.”</p><p>Through the strategy of reading against the grain, Derrida and Lacan, in their respective projects of deconstructing logocentrism and exposing the unconscious dimension that resists and exceeds meaning, were, in a fundamental sense, performing the same operation. Both were attempting to disclose what remains repressed, displaced, or irreducible within the ostensibly coherent order of meaning.</p><p>This line of inquiry also encompasses the famous declaration in the opening of the Gospel according to John:</p><p>“In the beginning was the Word.”</p><p>One must not overlook the fact that the English “Word” is a translation of the Greek Logos. The entire problematic of Logos, language, meaning, and the constitution of the subject is already condensed within that single biblical sentence.</p><p>This deconstructive imagination manifests itself not only in the philosophical discourse of our century but also in the concrete setting of the analytic encounter. Lacan’s Discourse of the Analyst may be diagrammed as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/154/1*3Uye_4eXZ-CFNJJ99nkLQA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The position occupied by object petit a is the position of the analyst. The structure of fantasy — $◇<em>ɑ</em> — is produced by the analysand, the divided subject $, within a relationship of transference and projection with the analyst.</p><p>Psychoanalytic treatment consists precisely in “traversing the fantasy”: that is, in incorporating <em>ɑ</em> into $ within this structure.</p><p>The task of analysis is to incorporate objet petit a — the remainder/rem(<em>ɑ</em>)inder of the process of subjectivation and the cause of desire — into the divided subject $, thereby raising the subject from the condition of Not-All toward the dimension of All. This is the path of analytic treatment.</p><p>As the result or effect of the Discourse of the Analyst, the master signifier, S₁, emerges in the lower-right position of the discourse. This signifier indicates that the incomplete subject $, through the analytic process, has been elevated — aufgehoben — from the condition of Not-All to that of All.</p><p>This, in turn, converges with the path toward the recovery of subjectivity dramatized in Freud’s Fort/Da game: the passage from “what happened to me” to “what I made happen to me.” The subject thereby succeeds in securing a <em>point de </em>capiton, a point of symbolic quilting at which meaning can be temporarily anchored.</p><p>More concretely, this transformation takes place through the logic of Nachträglichkeit, or afterwardness: the retroactive temporality through which the past is reconstituted in the present.</p><p>A traumatic situation that once happened to me passively in the past is now, here and now, actively represented and re-presented — indeed, reenacted — by the subject. The analysand is, in a precise sense, playing an analytic Fort/Da game:</p><p>“The Fort-Da game marks a passage from what happened to me — the symptom — to what I made happen to me: the sinthome. This logic operates equally within Eros and Thanatos, each constituting a <em>caput mortuum</em> of the Oedipal omission and commission.” — <em>Lacan and Derrida</em></p><p>Illness is “what happened to me,” whereas cure is “what I made happen to me.”</p><p>This formulation conveys with particular force the decisive importance of the subjective position from which trauma is apprehended. Psychoanalysis is not simply an attempt to recover what happened in the past; it is an effort to transform the subject’s relation to what happened — to convert a history suffered passively into a history that can be actively assumed, symbolized, and re-authored by the subject.</p><p>Our present discourse of narrative analysis has, by this point, arrived at the theory of the sinthome.</p><p>Ever since Lacan introduced the title <em>Le Sinthome</em> in Seminar XXIII, this signifier has occupied a crucial position within psychoanalytic discourse. The figure who emerged in this seminar as the theoretical guinea pig — the experimental subject of Lacan’s inquiry — was James Joyce.</p><p>Joyce, a writer who had failed to pass through the paternal metaphor, the gateway into the Symbolic Order, is said to have transformed this failure into what Hawthorne calls a “Fortunate Fall” through the sinthome of his écriture, thereby writing the “paradox of failure” into existence.</p><p>Here, the word “failure” is deliberately polysemous.</p><p>In Freud’s Fort/Da game, the object that Ernst repeatedly throws away (fort) and draws back to himself (da) is itself a spool — a failure in the literal sense of a spool of thread, while in Joyce’s case the term refers, of course, to the “failure” of the paternal metaphor.</p><p>In both instances, however, the paradox of failure proves to be therapeutic and life-giving.</p><p>How could such a thing possibly occur?</p><p>First of all, we need to recall that Joyce’s sinthome as écriture bears a striking resemblance to Freud’s account of the daydreaming of creative writers.</p><p>In his 1908 essay of the same title, Freud identified the fundamental driving force of creative activity with dreaming or fantasy ($ ◇ a). Having published his monumental <em>The Interpretation of Dreams</em> only a few years earlier, in 1900, Freud naturally regarded the creative activity of writers and artists as fundamentally continuous with the mechanisms of dreaming.</p><p>For Freud, a dream was “a disguised wish-fulfillment of the repressed unconscious” (<em>SE</em> 4:160).</p><p>If we add Jung’s concept of compensation to this formulation, we arrive at one of the most representative psychoanalytic definitions of the dream: the compensatory fulfillment of a wish originating in the repressed unconscious.</p><p>As may be inferred from Lacan’s earlier formulation concerning the “two lacks,” the lack-of-being (manque-à-être) generated through the processes of bodily separation (neuro-signature) and psychic signification (psycho-signature) necessarily moves toward a state of plenitude. The compensatory function of dreaming performs precisely this work.</p><p>The phenomenon of epiphany, understood as the psychic manifestation of the unconscious within the field of consciousness, can be explained according to the same logic. The epiphanies experienced by Stephen Dedalus — as he encounters the image of the girl by the water or watches birds soaring through the sky beyond the library — are exemplary instances of precisely such a phenomenon.</p><p>Running through all these phenomena is a fundamental conceptual framework: the making-conscious of the unconscious and the self-realization of object petit <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>It is the movement by which I come to occupy the place where It was:</p><p>Wo Es war, soll Ich werden.</p><p>But why? And how?</p><p>To answer these questions, we must turn to what Aristotle calls ars poetica, the art or craft of poetry, in his <em>Poetics</em>.</p><p>There Aristotle distinguishes between history and literature — fiction. History records “what was,” whereas literature records “what might be,” and it is precisely for this reason, he argues, that literature is more philosophical than history.</p><p>The record of “what might be” opens onto the world of fiction.</p><p>But what is fiction?</p><p>It is, of course, something made up — a constructed narrative. Yet it is not an invention that is simply groundless. It is a construction made upon a ground, an imaginative fabrication that takes something as its foundation.</p><p>In terms of the theory of mimesis, or imitation, that was influential in Aristotle’s time, this foundational dimension is what may be called its “mimetic quality.”</p><p>Literary fiction, therefore, is not an aesthetics of arbitrary fabrication without foundation. Rather, the aesthetics of invention operative in literary fiction is an aesthetics of the bottom, or ground — an aesthetics that preserves and activates its underlying mimetic quality.</p><p>In psychoanalysis, the metaphor of this bottom/ground finds its objective correlative, to borrow T. S. Eliot’s term, in the unconscious (das Unbewusste).</p><p>The unconscious, in this sense, is not merely what lies beneath consciousness as a hidden depth. It is the ground from which the subject’s dreams, fantasies, symptoms, and creative acts emerge, the concealed matrix upon which the apparent fabrications of psychic and literary life are constructed.</p><p>For those of us who have followed the argument this far, a new interpretation of **James Joyce’s writing — the Sinthome — **now becomes possible.</p><p>It is certainly true that Joyce was not simply writing history in the sense of recording “what was.” Yet even this statement may contain only half the truth. For Joyce was writing not the history of consciousness, but the history of the unconscious.</p><p>Joyce’s technique of writing is commonly described as “stream of consciousness.” Yet for this formulation to be fully true, we would have to prefix the word consciousness with “un-”. His writing is, as the final episode of <em>Ulysses</em>, “Penelope,” makes unmistakably clear, nothing less than a “stream of pre-/unconsciousness” itself.</p><p>The verbal puns, grammatical violations, and syntactic deviations that reach their apotheosis in <em>Finnegans Wake</em> give the impression that Joyce’s writing freely deploys the language of unconscious metaphor — the Freudian mechanisms of metaphor/condensation and metonymy/displacement — in all their tropological distortions.</p><p>In a word, his writing is not so much “writing” as “being written.”</p><p>But what is being written?</p><p>It is the history of desire that is being written. Beneath the text lies object petit a, the cause of desire, and it is this rem(<em>ɑ</em>)inder that writes the history of desire.</p><p>It is the Sisyphus-like expression of perfectionism: the incomplete subject of Not-All, produced by the failure of the paternal metaphor, relentlessly striving toward the summit of All.</p><p>This process is accomplished through a mode of writing structured by the retrospective past perfect, the grammatical form of “should have + past participle.”</p><p>Traumatized human existence, as Schuldig-Sein, or Being-guilty/Being-indebted, continually undertakes a kind of vindicating writing, seeking to have its debt redeemed. The debtor-being writes and writes in order to reclaim, here and now, the debt accumulated in the past through the belated temporality of “I should have…” and “I should not have…”</p><p>This can be compared precisely to the “compulsive running” of the Rat Man.</p><p>Run, and run again, until the enemy is finally subjected to the Lex Talionis, the law of retaliation: “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth.”</p><p>This is yet another face of the Sinthome revealed through the practice of “reading against the grain.”</p><p>And when the protagonist of this relentless pursuit finally reaches the summit toward which he has been striving and cries out, “Mission accomplished!”, he is astonished to discover that, in the collective memory of humankind, he has been transformed into a saintly sage, the object of canonization.</p><p>Deferred justice has finally been realized.</p><p>Is this not, perhaps, what lies behind the “taxidermied” genius of Yi Sang, or the “disease of knowledge” of the savant syndrome embodied by the extraordinary lawyer Woo Young-woo?</p><p>It is the paradox of failure and the metaphysics of difference.</p><p>Within the <em>Nekyia</em> of the Sacred Stone Spring, the river of Le Sinthome continues to flow.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=af5c72992845" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nachträglichkeit: Temporality, the Sinthome, and the Self-Realization of Objet Petit ɑ]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/nachtr%C3%A4glichkeit-temporality-the-sinthome-and-the-self-realization-of-objet-petit-%C9%91-85e5dd412c57?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85e5dd412c57</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Aug 2026 01:42:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-08T01:42:41.349Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Even Achilles — the unparalleled hero of the Trojan War — was not without his vulnerability. His singular weakness was, of course, his Achilles’ heel.</p><p>How much more, then, is this true of ordinary human beings?</p><p>Human existence is constitutively that of a not-all subject (pas-tout): an intrinsically incomplete subject whose very incompleteness condemns it to what Alfred Adler termed the inferiority complex and to what Martin Heidegger described as Schuldigsein, the condition of being guilty, being indebted, or being in debt.</p><p>Accordingly, throughout today’s global landscape, countless attempts are underway to settle this existential debt — to locate one’s own “Achilles’ heel.” In a profound sense, these endeavors reenact the event of the Akedah on Mount Moriah as narrated in <em>Genesis</em>: a symbolic repetition in which the subject confronts the site of its constitutive lack.</p><p>How is such a confrontation possible?</p><p>It is accomplished through the mobilization of the symbolic emissary residing within us — the unconscious (das Unbewusste), Poe’s <em>The Tell-Tale Heart</em> serving as an apt literary analogue for its uncanny insistence.</p><p>Freud famously described dreams as the royal road to the unconscious. Dreams constitute the semiotic manifestation of the unconscious (Ucs.), and dream interpretation — performed through a reading against the grain of the dream-text — is ultimately nothing other than a search for one’s own Achilles’ heel, namely objet petit a (ɑ), the elusive cause of desire.</p><p>Freud defines the dream as the compensatory wish-fulfillment of the repressed (<em>Standard Edition</em>, Vol. 4, p. 160). Here, “the repressed” may already be understood as converging with what Lacan later theorizes as objet petit a, the object-cause of desire.</p><p>This logic corresponds precisely to the trajectory of fantasy ($◇ɑ). Since the traversal of fantasy (la traversée du fantasme) entails the subject’s symbolic integration — or, more accurately, its subjective assumption — of objet petit a, this process may be regarded as structurally analogous to the compensatory fulfillment achieved through dream interpretation. In both cases, what had functioned as the enigmatic cause of desire is no longer encountered as an external remainder but is reinscribed within the economy of subjectivity itself.</p><p>Any inquiry into the raison d’être of psychoanalysis inevitably returns to its master signifier: the unconscious. It is both the alpha and the omega of psychoanalytic thought.</p><p>The task of analysis is therefore to appropriate its significance through the strategy of reading against the grain. Mere intellectual comprehension is insufficient. This is precisely why Bruce Fink entitled one of his most important works <em>Against Understanding</em>: psychoanalysis aims not at cognitive mastery but at a subjective transformation that exceeds understanding.</p><p>Yet how does one gain access to what has thus far been designated as the cause of the dream — whether conceived as the repressed or as objet petit a?</p><p>The answer lies in the logic of Nachträglichkeit — deferred action, or afterwardness.</p><p>Discovered by Freud and subsequently rearticulated with renewed theoretical force by Lacan, this specifically psychoanalytic conception of temporality constitutes one of the foundational principles governing the analytic process as a whole.</p><p>As Honoré de Balzac’s <em>Adieu</em> vividly illustrates, psychoanalytic treatment proceeds through what may be called the present reconstruction of the past. Just as the traumatic crossing of the Berezina River is reenacted within the novel, analytic work likewise reconstructs traumatic experience in the present rather than merely recollecting it as a completed historical event.</p><p>The essential question, therefore, is not simply what happened in the past, but how the past comes to operate retroactively (nachträglich) within the present. Psychoanalytic temporality is constituted by this reciprocal determination: the present confers meaning upon the past even as the past incessantly restructures the present. Only through this dialectic of retroactive signification can the subject encounter the unconscious truth that has always already determined its desire.</p><p>The case of the Wolf Man provides perhaps the paradigmatic illustration of this logic. According to Freud’s reconstruction, this tragic patient witnessed the primal scene at approximately eighteen months of age: the direct observation of his parents engaged in sexual intercourse. This early encounter subsequently found expression, at the age of four, in the celebrated Wolf Dream.</p><p>The wolves standing rigidly upright, exposing their pale bodies, were in effect a symbolic replication of what the “wolf-man” had witnessed upon awakening one summer day: his parents engaged in coitus a tergo. The dream thus constitutes the symbolic return of a mnemonic trace from the past, a set of vital signs through which the unconscious inscribes itself in the present.</p><p>Freud — and Lacan after him — radicalizes this logic of Nachträglichkeit, a move that converges strikingly with Derrida’s deconstructive treatment of causality. Did the event at eighteen months produce the dream at four years of age? Or, conversely, does the dream retrospectively constitute the earlier event as traumatic? The truth of the primal scene emerges precisely within this deconstructive undecidability, where cause and effect no longer occupy fixed chronological positions but mutually produce one another through retroactive signification.</p><p>Such is the operative logic of deferred action (Nachträglichkeit).</p><p>The treatment of analytic trauma therefore begins with careful attention to the grammatical structure of “should have + past participle.” This therapeutic orientation is grounded in Lacan’s proposition that “the unconscious is structured like a language.” Expressions such as “I should have…” or “If only I had…” are not merely linguistic formulations of regret; they are symptomatic articulations through which the unconscious returns in language.</p><p>They give voice to retrospective reflections upon events that befell the subject — or actions committed by the subject — which continue to exert an unconscious efficacy.</p><p>An event from childhood becomes traumatic — leaving what may be called a Psycho-Signature upon the psyche or a Neuro-Signature upon the body — because it overwhelms the subject through an excess of Oedipal commission or omission. Trauma occurs when an experience exceeds the subject’s symbolic capacity for assimilation, leaving an inscription that cannot yet be metabolized.</p><p>Freud’s celebrated Fort/Da game may be understood in precisely these terms. For the young Ernst, Fort (“What happened to me”) signifies the experience of loss, absence, or psychic injury, whereas Da (“What I made happen”) signifies the subject’s symbolic appropriation — and thereby the beginning of healing. The gaze of the Other (O) is transformed into the agency of the subject (S). What had initially been endured passively is reconstructed through symbolic action.</p><p>A patient suffering from obsessive-compulsive neurosis, tormented by fantasies of being surrounded, invaded, or psychically penetrated, attempts to eradicate the threatening external force through compulsive handwashing and relentless cleanliness. Such behavior exemplifies the operation of a defence mechanism, but it is equally the subject’s enactment of the Fort/Da game: a symbolic effort to convert passive exposure into active mastery.</p><p>Through this process, the discourse of retrospective regret — “I should have…” — is gradually transformed into a discourse of subjective agency oriented toward the present. What had appeared as irreversible loss becomes susceptible to symbolic reconfiguration.</p><p>This movement anticipates what Lacan, in his final teaching, conceptualizes as le sinthome. Introduced as the organizing signifier of Seminar XXIII (1975–1976), Le Sinthome nevertheless remains profoundly continuous with Freud’s 1908 essay “Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming.”</p><p>Lacan argues that James Joyce, condemned, as it were, to a psychotic mode of existence owing to the failure of the paternal metaphor, nevertheless succeeded in escaping that labyrinth through the singularity of his écriture. Writing became Joyce’s sinthome: the unique mode by which he sustained his psychic consistency where the paternal function had failed.</p><p>The path taken by Joyce — his own <em>ɑ</em>-way, to borrow a Lacanian pun — is precisely the path of the sinthome. It is nothing other than the movement of sublimation, whereby “an ordinary object is elevated to the dignity of the Thing.” Writing ceases to be mere artistic production; it becomes the singular mode through which desire is knotted together and psychic existence rendered livable.</p><p>This is precisely the path traversed by the creative writers discussed in Freud’s Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming: the path of daydreaming itself.</p><p>If dreams are defined as compensatory wish-fulfillments, then daydreams equally instantiate this logic. They too operate as forms of sublimation and, in Lacan’s later vocabulary, as modalities of the sinthome. Both dreams and artistic creation transform what cannot be directly symbolized into forms capable of sustaining subjective existence.</p><p>Joyce’s celebrated technique of the stream of consciousness, therefore, is more accurately understood as a stream of the unconscious. One need only recall Molly Bloom’s concluding monologue in <em>Ulysses</em>. There, consciousness and the unconscious become virtually indistinguishable, dissolving into the uninterrupted flow of desire itself. Without any stable boundary separating the two, the reader is drawn into the dream-like economy of compensatory wish-fulfillment, where dream and daydream converge as different modalities of the unconscious’s ceaseless labor of desire.</p><p>The ars poetica articulated by Freud in his early essay “Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming” already anticipates what Lacan would later conceptualize as the path of the sinthome. Freud’s reflections on artistic creation are, in retrospect, nothing less than a theory of the sinthomatic mode of existence.</p><p>It is along this path that the “taxidermied genius” of the Korean modernist poet Yi Sang may be understood, as well as the extraordinary cognitive singularity dramatized through the savant protagonist of Extraordinary Attorney Woo. In both instances, creative singularity functions not merely as exceptional talent but as a sinthomatic solution — a unique mode of psychic stabilization.</p><p>The point of departure for this path, the Aristotelian “unmoved mover,” is none other than objet petit a. Dreams, accordingly, may be conceived as an <em>ɑ</em>-way of dreaming, while the sinthome is an <em>ɑ</em>-Sinthome — the self-actualization of objet petit a itself. The Lacanian pun is instructive: the object-cause of desire (a) simultaneously designates both the origin and the trajectory of subjective becoming.</p><p>Consequently, objet petit a and the sinthome are inseparable concepts. The latter is nothing other than the process through which the former realizes itself within the symbolic life of the subject. What Lacan calls the sinthome is the singular mode whereby desire acquires existential consistency.</p><p>The structure of the human psyche may therefore be represented topologically as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/115/1*RijakwysaHDWjY0XAHL-NA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Within this schema, the vertical axis corresponds to the topographical model proposed by Freud — and, by analogy, Chomsky’s distinction between surface and deep structures. Here, the governing mechanism is the dialectic of repression and the return of the repressed, a process perpetually driven by the compulsion to repeat (Wiederholungszwang).</p><p>The horizontal axis, by contrast, reflects Lacan’s distinction — schematically presented in <em>The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis</em> — between the dimension of being and that of meaning. Subjectivity emerges through the tension between ontological existence and symbolic signification.</p><p>Yet more fundamental than either axis is the position occupying their intersection: objet petit a.</p><p>This pivotal Lacanian concept, the kernel of being, is the remainder (rem(a)inder) generated through the subject’s movement from the dimension of being into the symbolic order of meaning — that is, through the processes of civilization, symbolization, and signification. It constitutes what may be called the unthought ground of thought, the irreducible residue that resists incorporation into the symbolic while simultaneously making symbolic thought possible.</p><p>As the generative matrix of an individual’s identity theme, this kernel silently governs every act of thinking (Denken) and every form of action (Aktion). It functions as the Aristotelian unmoved mover at the heart of subjectivity, directing desire without itself ever becoming fully representable.</p><p>As Lacan repeatedly insists, the entirety of human existence proceeds along the pathways of the Signifier (Signifiant). Desire is never immediate; it is mediated, displaced, and organized through the differential movement of signification.</p><p>Accordingly, every discussion of the sinthome ultimately converges upon the practical field in which objet petit a is enacted.</p><p>At this point I am reminded of the title of a lecture I delivered many years ago (2010): “Law and Desire: Horizons of Lacanian Discourse.” The title raises an essential question: How are law and desire mutually constituted?</p><p>Law exists only within the symbolic order — that is, within the order of language.</p><p>As the subject traverses the movement from the ontological register of being toward the symbolic register of meaning, the problematic of law and desire necessarily arises. Put succinctly, law performs the symbolic organization of desire. It regulates desire, establishes its coordinates, and renders it socially intelligible.</p><p>The paradigmatic instance of this process is Lacan’s account of the paternal metaphor. Through the operation of the Nom/Non du Père — the homophonic conjunction of the Name-of-the-Father and the father’s “No!” — desire is subjected to symbolic prohibition. The paternal injunction institutes the order succinctly captured by the formula: “No Mom, No Sis.”</p><p>The child thereby comes to recognize that neither the mother nor the sister can remain legitimate objects of desire. This marks nothing less than a Copernican revolution in the economy of desire: desire is displaced from the immediacy of familial attachment and redirected toward the symbolic field of exogamous relations.</p><p>For the young girl, the corresponding paternal prohibition assumes the complementary form: “No Dad, No Bro!” Here too, the paternal metaphor reorganizes the libidinal economy by instituting the incest prohibition as the founding law of symbolic subjectivity.</p><p>For both boys and girls passing through the Oedipal phase, the successful installation of the paternal metaphor signals the subject’s successful negotiation of the Family Romance and the incest taboo. It marks the moment at which desire is no longer governed by immediate biological attachment but is symbolically ordered through the Law, thereby making entry into culture — and into language itself — possible.</p><p>According to the structural anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss, no human society has ever existed — whether in the most remote regions of Africa, the tropical rainforest, or the most technologically advanced nations of Western Europe — that does not observe some form of the incest taboo. Its particular formulations may vary across cultures, but its structural function remains universal.</p><p>To become civilized is, fundamentally, to enter the domain of Law and the Symbolic. Such entry necessarily entails that desire be subjected to symbolic regulation. Indeed, one might even say that desire is executed — sacrificed to the order of culture — in order that social existence may become possible.</p><p>What remains after this symbolic operation, the caput mortuum of the structuration of desire, is objet petit a.</p><p>From this perspective, James Joyce, whose passage through the paternal metaphor Lacan famously regarded as structurally deficient, nevertheless attained both literary immortality and enduring cultural recognition through the singularity of his writing. Joyce succeeded precisely because he elevated the unconscious Real of objet petit a to the level of the sinthome, thereby transforming the Not-All produced by the failure of the paternal metaphor into a mode of existential consistency approaching the status of an All.</p><p>The significance of this operation cannot be overstated, for the sinthome functions as the fourth existential knot capable of reconstituting the disintegrating Borromean Knot. It provides the supplementary bond that secures the otherwise unstable articulation of the Real, the Symbolic, and the Imaginary.</p><p>One may find a literary analogue in the Korean novelist Choi In-ho’s final novel, <em>The City of Familiar Strangers</em>, where K1 and K2 ultimately merge into a restored and integral K, enacting a narrative of redemptive rebirth through the reunification of a fractured self.</p><p>Joyce accomplished something remarkably similar. By living according to the stream of the unconscious indicated by objet petit a, rather than merely reproducing the stream of consciousness, he transformed what happened to him into what he made happen. Trauma ceased to function as passive destiny and became the material of cultural creation.</p><p>This is, in effect, Joyce’s own version of the Fort/Da game.</p><p>The symbolic operation performed by the paternal metaphor is therefore decisive for the constitution of subjectivity. It establishes what Lacan calls the point de capiton — translated into English as the anchoring point or quilting point — the privileged signifier that momentarily arrests the endless slippage of signification and secures meaning.</p><p>This quilting point is simultaneously the gift of death, in Derrida’s sense, bestowed through the paternal metaphor — the Name/No of the Father — and the enduring lesson of the Akedah on Mount Moriah. Subjectivity is constituted only through a sacrifice that symbolically interrupts immediate desire.</p><p>The grammatical structure discussed earlier — “should have + past participle” — records precisely those moments at which this process of subjective signification has failed. Expressions such as “I should have…” or “If only I had…” are not merely linguistic expressions of regret; they testify to an unsuccessful symbolic inscription, to the failure of the subject to secure an anchoring point within the symbolic order.</p><p>For this reason, the establishment of such an anchoring point must occur in a decisive, transformative manner — what might be called an apophatic event.</p><p>A Zen Buddhist anecdote offers an illuminating parallel. In the celebrated story of Xiangyan Zhixian (香嚴智閑), enlightenment occurred at the instant when a fragment of roof tile accidentally struck a bamboo stalk. The sound itself — not conceptual reasoning — precipitated a sudden awakening. Truth emerged through an event rather than through discursive cognition.</p><p>The acquisition of a quilting point may likewise be compared to vaulting over a gymnastics horse. Before the leap, hesitation dominates: one fears failure, embarrassment, even bodily injury. Yet once the vault has been successfully completed, an irreversible transformation occurs. A qualitative difference has been introduced into the psychic economy, comparable to the biblical faith capable of “moving mountains.” Once the symbolic passage has been accomplished, the subject is no longer the same.</p><p>Failure to achieve such a passage, by contrast, leaves the subject engulfed in a pervasive sense of defeat and insufficiency, perpetually haunted by the grammar of “should have…”</p><p>Even after adulthood, the logic of Nachträglichkeit continues to operate. The subject becomes ensnared within the vicious circle of the repetition compulsion (Wiederholungszwang), repeatedly reenacting earlier failures in an unconscious effort to reverse their meaning retrospectively.</p><p>The compulsion is therefore not driven by a desire to repeat but by the impossibility of not repeating. The subject is compelled to reenact precisely because the original symbolic inscription remains incomplete.</p><p>Freud’s celebrated case of the Rat Man (R.) provides a particularly revealing example.</p><p>Despite the oppressive heat of August, R. insisted upon running obsessively every day. When Freud asked him why he subjected himself to such relentless exercise, R. replied that he simply wished to lose weight.</p><p>Freud, however, approached this explanation through the hermeneutic strategy of reading against the grain. What emerged through free association was an astonishing chain of unconscious signification.</p><p>R.’s principal romantic rival was named Richard, whose familiar nickname was Dick. In German, however, the signifier dick simultaneously denotes “fat,” “thick,” or “corpulent.” The unconscious therefore condensed the rival and obesity into a single signifying chain.</p><p>Consequently, the fantasy of killing Richard underwent a series of metonymic displacements:</p><p>Killing Richard → Killing Dick → Killing Fat → Compulsive Running</p><p>The obsessive act of running was thus never simply a matter of physical fitness. It constituted the symbolic enactment of an unconscious wish, translated through the differential play of signifiers. The symptom, as Lacan insists, follows not the logic of empirical causality but the itinerary of the Signifier itself. It is in this signifying chain — rather than in conscious intention — that the truth of desire becomes legible.</p><p>This episode above all demonstrates the extent to which the surface structure may be overturned by the deep structure, revealing the degree to which conscious organization can at any moment be disrupted by the revolt of the unconscious.</p><p>And it is precisely this unconscious dimension that Freud identifies as the core of our being (Kern unseres Wesens):</p><p>“Wo Es war, soll Ich werden.”</p><p>Where It was, there I shall become.</p><p>The analytic path consists in entering the very place where the It (das Es/Id) had previously occupied its position.</p><p>The Id, in this sense, corresponds to what Heidegger calls authenticity (Eigentlichkeit) — a state of genuine being that constitutes the unconscious ontological core of existence. The disclosure of Being takes place upon the abyss of Nothingness (das Nichts). Existence does not emerge from a stable foundation but from an encounter with the void that lies beneath all symbolic constructions.</p><p>Under the scorching August sun, as R. ran compulsively again and again, the thought of “Killing Richard” must have remained entirely hidden from his conscious awareness. Yet only through the Sisyphean labor of bringing this unconscious content into consciousness can a fundamental reconfiguration of the neuropsychic structure occur.</p><p>This is the miraculous transformation by which the failure of the paternal metaphor is elevated into its success.</p><p>The strategy of surmounting that Joyce pursued through writing — his “great cultural achievement” — was ultimately the restoration of the Name/No of the Father. Through his unique act of literary creation, Joyce reconstructed the symbolic function that had failed to stabilize him.</p><p>The result was the formation of the fourth sinthomatic knot, which securely bound together the unstable Borromean Knot. The Imaginary, the Symbolic, and the Real were thereby recollected around the central void and cause of desire: objet petit a (ɑ).</p><p>This is the moment of Epiphany.</p><p>The intermittent emergence of the unconscious into consciousness — the sudden flashes in which hidden truth reveals itself — is what Yi Sang metaphorically described as his “taxidermied genius.” The peculiar genius of numerous artists, writers, and inventors who have left luminous traces in history was purchased at an extraordinary existential cost. Their exceptional creativity was, in Derrida’s terminology, a gift of death.</p><p>Let us now explain this situation through the previously mentioned cross-shaped diagram.</p><p>First, the horizontal axis S–O represents the logic of transition from the dimension of being to the dimension of meaning. For the natural subject S to be reborn as the barred subject $ — the subject divided by the incision of language and signification — it must necessarily encounter the big Other (O), the symbolic guarantor and legislator of language.</p><p>This is the determinism of the subject by the Other: S is constituted through O.</p><p>The consequence of this determination appears in the structure: $ ◇ ɑ, namely, the structure of fantasy.</p><p>At this moment, the Other itself undergoes division: O is separated into Ø and ɑ, and it is ɑ that establishes a relation with the subject. The lost remainder of the Other becomes the object-cause around which the subject’s desire is organized.</p><p>The next stage is the Traversal of Fantasy (la traversée du fantasme) — the final stage of subjectivation in which ɑ becomes incorporated into $, allowing the subject to assume the very cause of its own desire.</p><p>The ultimate achievement of this process is the preservation of the Other as Ø: the recognition of the Other’s fundamental incompleteness.</p><p>This is the origin of the proposition that the flower of the subject blooms upon the death of the Other.</p><p>The reason Hamlet remained suspended in his endless meditation upon “To be or not to be,” continually postponing his act of revenge, was that he remained trapped within the hour of the Other. He had failed to complete the transition from O to Ø — from the imagined fullness of the Other to the recognition of its constitutive lack.</p><p>Only at the conclusion of the drama does Hamlet finally resolve this transition. By confronting the incompleteness of the Other and accomplishing the revenge that had been deferred throughout the entire play, Hamlet emerges at last as the authentic Prince of Denmark — not merely as the son of a murdered king, but as a subject who has assumed his own position within history.</p><p>His delayed action was therefore not simply hesitation or weakness. It was the prolonged drama of a subject attempting to separate himself from the desire of the Other and to achieve symbolic autonomy. The final act represents the successful completion of this passage: the birth of a subject who no longer exists under the command of the Other’s desire.</p><p>The next crucial dimension is the relationship between surface and depth, the vertical structure of above and below.</p><p>Fundamentally, this structure is sustained by the mechanism of repression and the return of the repressed. The binary configurations of consciousness and the unconscious, as well as the present and the past, follow this same paradigm.</p><p>Indeed, the latter — the question of temporality — constitutes almost the entire problematic of psychoanalytic discourse.</p><p>As Heidegger makes explicit in <em>Sein und Zeit</em> (Being and Time), human existence can never step outside the horizon of temporality. The human being is not merely an entity that exists within time; rather, existence itself is constituted through temporal unfolding.</p><p>The central theme of this essay — the logic of Nachträglichkeit (deferred action, afterwardness) — therefore belongs fundamentally to the category of temporality.</p><p>Even when psychoanalytic practice is defined as the present reconstruction/re-presentation of the past, the Heideggerian question of Being and Time inevitably reemerges. The analytic encounter is never a simple retrieval of what once happened; it is a temporal event in which the past is retroactively constituted within the present.</p><p>The obsessive running of the Rat Man, as well as the primal-scene fantasy of the Wolf Man, both reveal this essential dimension of temporality: the problem of the present re-presentation of the past.</p><p>Representation presupposes re-presentation.</p><p>To represent is always already to present again — to stage anew within the present what had remained unresolved in the past.</p><p>The temporality of Being and the logic of Nachträglichkeit are directly applicable to Lacan’s late theory of Le Sinthome.</p><p>Joyce’s act of writing (écriture) was nothing other than the attempt to restore, from the standpoint of the present, the paternal metaphor that had failed him in the past. Through writing, he reconstructed the symbolic structure that had previously collapsed.</p><p>To repair the ruined castle, to tighten the loosened knot, and ultimately to accomplish the Borromean Knot — this was the “great cultural achievement” that James Joyce achieved through his writing.</p><p>The act of transforming “what happened to me” in the past into “what I made happen to me” in the here and now is precisely the logic of the Fort/Da game.</p><p>Within Ernst’s “great cultural act” of reconstructing the past from the standpoint of the present subject, one encounters what Lacan calls the “dignity of the Thing.” The subject no longer remains a passive victim of what occurred; instead, the subject assumes authorship of its own history.</p><p>Expressed differently, this is an escape from the prison of the past.</p><p>The indispensable Ariadne’s Thread required for escaping the prison of Theseus was, for Joyce, his writing; for Vincent van Gogh, The Starry Night; for Edvard Munch, The Scream; and for Ludwig van Beethoven, the Fifth Symphony, Fate.</p><p>These works enacted a symbolic form of Lex Talionis — the law of retaliation — not as blind revenge, but as “punishment with impunity”: the transformation of suffering into creation, and injury into a sinthomatic form of cultural production.</p><p>They practiced a mode of deferred justice under the name of the sinthome: the present reconstruction of the past.</p><p>This movement represents the Zeno’s paradox through which the Not-All approaches the All — an asymptotic movement toward completion that can never fully arrive yet endlessly generates new forms of meaning.</p><p>It is the gift of death bestowed upon the past.</p><p>Just as the flower of the subject blooms upon the death of the Other, so too, after the declaration of the death of the past, there emerges an aesthetics of the Sublime, in which an ordinary object is elevated to the dignity of the Thing.</p><p>In the diagram presented earlier, objet petit a (ɑ) occupied the point of intersection between the vertical and horizontal axes — the point where the dimensions of depth and surface, being and meaning, converge.</p><p>Indeed, history itself is the process of the self-realization of ɑ.</p><p>History is the self-realization of objet petit ɑ.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85e5dd412c57" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[$◇ɑ: Objet petit a and Le Sinthome]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/%C9%91-objet-petit-a-and-le-sinthome-0b39dd052d75?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0b39dd052d75</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 08:11:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-24T08:11:04.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>$◇ɑ: Objet petit a and Le Sinthome</strong></p><p>What follows is an analytic discourse delivered by an elderly analyst assuming the guise of Zarathustra:</p><p>“The path of analytic treatment consists in seizing, with one’s own hands, that nameless X which crawls upward from below toward the throat, gripping it by the neck, and violently casting it onto the ground.”</p><p>The “something” (It, das Es) is the unconscious objet petit a; Sinthome, in turn, designates the analytic and therapeutic intervention performed upon it. Although strikingly terse and seemingly abrasive, this brief statement encapsulates the very essence of psychoanalysis.</p><p>First, it presupposes the topographical model of the psyche, whereby psychic life is divided into an “upper” and a “lower” domain, thereby revealing the structuralist binarism between surface structure and deep structure. Within this framework emerge the central psychoanalytic categories of consciousness (Cs.) and the unconscious (Ucs.), while the analytic act itself is foregrounded through Freud’s canonical formulation: “making the unconscious conscious.”</p><p>Objet petit a and Le Sinthome are the key signifiers that unlock the hidden portal of Lacanian discourse. Objet petit a is the a posteriori Real, the rem(a)inder left behind by symbolic castration — a mnemonic residue generated through the subject’s entrance into the Symbolic Order. It corresponds closely to what Norman N. Holland designates as the identity theme.</p><p>More precisely, it may be understood as the primordial neuropsychological image that fundamentally characterizes an individual’s mode of being. Holland’s celebrated study, Five Readers Reading, offers an exemplary illustration. The five readers each believed themselves to be approaching the assigned literary texts objectively. Yet Holland’s experiment demonstrated precisely the opposite: every reading proved to be profoundly subjective, organized by the reader’s own unconscious psychic structure.</p><p>This subjective organization constitutes the reader’s identity theme, leading reader-response criticism to its well-known proposition that literary interpretation is fundamentally the reconstruction — or indeed the recreation — of the text through the reader’s identity theme.</p><p>Occupying the very center of this identity theme is objet petit a. It functions as the compass directing the trajectory of the human subject and as an Ariadne’s thread guiding one’s existential journey. When this function operates negatively, psychoanalysis designates it a symptom; when it functions affirmatively, it is called Sinthome.</p><p>Freud’s celebrated Fort/Da game vividly exemplifies this distinction. The Fort movement — “What happened to me” — may appropriately be characterized as symptom, whereas the Da movement — “What I made happen to myself” — constitutes Sinthome. It was precisely through this latter act that Ernst earned Freud’s famous praise, who described the game as a “great cultural achievement.”</p><p>Who, in negotiating the identity theme that structures subjectivity, would not desire such recognition? Yet such an achievement is by no means universally attainable. It remains unavailable to those incomplete subjects whom Lacan designates as Not-All (pas-tout).</p><p>Their predicament stems from their failure to pass successfully through what Freud termed the Oedipus complex and what Lacan reformulated as the paternal metaphor (Nom-du-Père). As victims of symbolic commission and omission within this rite of passage, they remain incapable of fully entering the Symbolic Order. Consequently, they bear the logical inscription of ∀xΦx, while confronting an ordeal analogous to the endless labor of Sisyphus.</p><p>Sisyphus never ceases rolling the stone uphill despite knowing that it will inevitably fall back. His perseverance recalls Zeno’s paradox, wherein the runner continues the race despite recognizing that the pursuer can never overtake the one ahead. The significance of both metaphors, however, lies elsewhere: each repetition introduces a difference into the existing order.</p><p>It is precisely this difference that produces the therapeutic effect whereby the Not-All subject is dialectically elevated (Aufhebung) toward the universality of the All. Such efficacy is as decisive as transforming a malignant tumor into a benign one. It constitutes an apophantic event — a genuinely “great cultural achievement.”</p><p>This is precisely what is meant by the Copernican revolution from Symptom to Sinthome.</p><p>Lacan himself, in Seminar XXIII, famously diagnosed James Joyce by identifying the failure of the paternal metaphor. Such failure ordinarily culminates in psychopathology. Yet Joyce overcame this structural deficiency through his singular practice of écriture, thereby accomplishing a “great cultural achievement” that permanently transformed the history of modern literature.</p><p>Why? How?</p><p>To borrow Heidegger’s terminology, it is because Schuldigsein — Being-guilty or Being-in-debt — ultimately succeeds in discharging its debt. That debt is none other than the debt incurred through Oedipal commission and omission.</p><p>The mode of thinking adopted retrospectively (nachträglich) by a being-in-debt typically assumes the grammatical form of “should have + past participle.” It is the language of regret: “I should have…,” “If only I had…” Such utterances testify that an event occurring at some point in the past opened the gateway to trauma through either excess or deficiency. In this sense, objet petit a has undergone a negative incarnation within psychic life.</p><p>Consider, for example, an analysand designated as K, who repeatedly dreams that graduation is impossible because certain required documents have not been submitted. Clearly, some symbolic debt remains unsettled. The compulsive recurrence of this dream is nothing other than the subject’s own inner demand that the debt finally be discharged.</p><p>Analytic treatment consists precisely in listening to this inner voice. It involves deciphering the semiotic re-presentation of objet petit a through the reconstruction of the past within the present. This process is comparable to the decipherment of the epiphanies found throughout James Joyce’s writings.</p><p>Such is the path of Sinthome.</p><p>It is the event that emerges as the incomplete Not-All subject strives toward the impossible perfection of the All.</p><p>Charles Strickland, the protagonist of The Moon and Sixpence, produces on the primitive island of Tahiti a magnificent polychromatic masterpiece for the indigenous woman Ata. That painting is itself an embodiment of objet petit a and simultaneously the realization of Sinthome.</p><p>These two concepts belonging to the order of the Real are therefore inseparably intertwined.</p><p>From the perspective of dream theory, objet petit a corresponds to the dream-thought (Traumgedanke) lying at the deepest level of psychic structure. As the unconscious cause of dreaming, it repeatedly attempts to emerge into the surface structure through the mechanism of the semiotic manifestation of the unconscious, striving to evade the surveillance of the psychic censor.</p><p>To pass through this censorship, it mobilizes the rhetorical operations of metaphor and metonymy — or, in Freud’s terminology, condensation (Verdichtung) and displacement (Verschiebung). Freud designates this entire process of linguistic transformation as dream-work (Traumarbeit), maintaining that the same mechanism governs every conscious manifestation of the unconscious.</p><p><strong>Repression, the Return of the Repressed, and the ɑ–Sinthome Trajectory</strong></p><p>Let us now approach this problematic through the foundational psychoanalytic dialectic of repression (Verdrängung) and the return of the repressed (Wiederkehr des Verdrängten).</p><p>Whatever falls outside the field of vision of the conscious Ego inevitably becomes the object of repression. Such exclusion is not accidental but constitutes a necessary condition for psychic survival.</p><p>To borrow a spatial metaphor, psychic contents repressed from the upper to the lower region immediately constitute the unconscious (Ucs.). This is precisely why the Freudian formula,</p><p>the repressed = the unconscious (Ucs.)</p><p>may legitimately be established.</p><p>To this equation must be added objet petit a, giving rise to what may be called an “ɑ-way of dreaming.” Consequently, the dream mechanism outlined above is nothing other than the semiotic self-realization of objet petit a. The repressed gives birth to objet petit a, while the return of the repressed opens the path of the Sinthome.</p><p>Expressed in Heideggerian terms, analytic treatment consists in identifying the debt (Schuld). To identify one’s debt is simultaneously to disclose the identity of objet petit a. The analytic task is therefore another name for revealing the identity of a itself.</p><p>This formulation converges with Lacan’s celebrated proposition that “the unconscious is structured like a language.” Dream interpretation, accordingly, elevates the preceding signifying process of dream production to the level of the signified. It asks not merely how dreams are constructed but what they signify.</p><p>It is within this hermeneutic movement that the trajectory of ɑ–Sinthome unfolds.</p><p>If objet petit a, the cause of desire, functions as the causal principle governing this process of the Real, Sinthome appears as its consequential effect.</p><p>James Joyce offers the exemplary illustration. If the failure of the paternal metaphor became inscribed as objet petit a — that is, as a Psycho-Signature (心紋) — its external enactment assumed the form of écriture. Through writing, Joyce reconstructed the very psychic configuration that had produced his symptom. His writing reconfigured subjectivity itself.</p><p>The outcome was the emergence of a fourth existential knot, whose function was to restore the integrity of the disintegrating Borromean Knot. Thus, the tragic writer who might otherwise have succumbed to psychosis because of the failure of the paternal metaphor paradoxically achieved a form of canonization within humanity’s collective memory through the practice of the Sinthome.</p><p>Is it not one of history’s profound ironies that contemporary incomplete subjects continue to reenact the Akedah on Mount Moriah narrated in Genesis?</p><p>At this point, the notion of repetition deserves particular attention.</p><p>Freud’s concept of repetition compulsion (Wiederholungszwang) underlies the entire trajectory of the ɑ–Sinthome.</p><p>Modern psychiatric nosology includes the diagnostic category of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). Whereas obsession primarily manifests itself as a psycho-signature, and compulsion more typically as a neuro-signature, OCD is, from the psychoanalytic perspective, the characteristic clinical manifestation of obsessional neurosis. Its compulsive quality arises independently of conscious intention precisely because objet petit a continues to operate unconsciously at its deepest level.</p><p>Lacan explains that the drive (Trieb) perpetually circulates around objet petit a, generating jouissance as the effect of this endless orbital movement. At the very center of the Real stands objet petit a.</p><p>Consider, for instance, the ritual of compulsive hand-washing.</p><p>Within the binary relation of subject and Other, once the subject experiences exposure to the intrusive force of the Other, anxiety inevitably emerges, giving rise to a defensive posture. What is at stake here is the fantasy of boundary transgression.</p><p>Lacan schematizes fantasy as $ ◇ a, the structural relation between the divided subject ($) and objet petit a. Accordingly, the fundamental mechanism of subjectivation — the traversal of fantasy (traversée du fantasme) — consists in incorporating objet petit a into the divided subject, thereby transforming it into an internal structural moment of subjectivity.</p><p>The psycho-psychological mechanism underlying compulsive hand-washing may therefore be understood as an attempt to eradicate intrusive forces that seek to penetrate from outside. The deliberately coined term “intruthive” — substituting th for the conventional s — underscores that what invades the subject is not merely an external contaminant but a traumatic truth.</p><p>Individuals suffering from obsessional neurosis remain exceptionally sensitive to forces that move from exteriority toward interiority, perpetually caught within the binary logic of fight or flight, or attack and counterattack. Compulsive washing thus functions as the defensive strategy devised by the God within — an unconscious defense mechanism designed to repel the threatening intrusion of the Other.</p><p>In psychoanalytic terms, therefore, compulsive hand-washing is not simply a maladaptive behavioral symptom. Rather, it is a Sinthomatic practice: a singular mode through which the subject attempts to stabilize the relation between the divided self and objet petit a, thereby warding off the anxiety produced by the intrusive presence of the Other. In this sense, the ritual is less a pathological excess than an existential strategy for preserving psychic consistency in the face of an unstable symbolic order.</p><p><strong>From Fantasy to the Sinthome: Traversing Fantasy and the Ontology of the Not-All Subject</strong></p><p>Let us proceed one step further by considering the Rat Man (R) and his episode of compulsive running.</p><p>As I have argued elsewhere (for example, in Eros and Death), Freud’s celebrated case exemplifies, above all, the structure of fantasy and the traversal of fantasy. Within R’s fantasy, structured as $ ◇ a, the objet petit a is represented by the unconscious desire to kill Richard. Yet the direct enactment of this desire would violate the reality principle. Consequently, R displaced the object and aim of his aggression, substituting “killing fat” for “killing Richard.” This displacement assumed the form of compulsive running.</p><p>Through this overvalued (überwertig) act — which, in Lacanian terms, constitutes a Sinthome — R achieved symbolically what reality prohibited. He avenged himself upon his rival Richard while simultaneously relieving his own psychic suffering.</p><p>The situation recalls Hamlet, who remains suspended within the hour of the Other until the appointed moment arrives, at which point he finally accomplishes the act of revenge and thereby recovers both his princely dignity and his subjectivity.</p><p>The path of the Sinthome, insofar as it manifests itself as a form of traversing fantasy, is therefore the movement from Denken (thought) to Aktion (act). Yet this transition is by no means consciously orchestrated; it is fundamentally and irreducibly unconscious.</p><p>Joyce, whose failure of the paternal metaphor has become paradigmatic in Lacanian theory, likewise walked this solitary path through the practice of écriture. His writing itself became the fourth knot, the Sinthomatic itinerary through which psychic consistency was restored.</p><p>That pilgrimage extends symbolically from the Akedah on Mount Moriah to Derrida’s The Gift of Death. Such überwertig acts are constitutive of the Sinthome.</p><p>Through them, the incomplete Not-All subject undergoes the experience of subjectivation, being sublimated toward the universality of the All. This is the trajectory whereby an ordinary object is elevated to the dignity of the Thing, thereby exemplifying the psychoanalytic mechanism of sublimation.</p><p>Such, in its entirety, is the therapeutic variation orchestrated by the dialectic of ɑ–Sinthome.</p><p>At this juncture, however, an ontological question concerning the Not-All subject inevitably arises.</p><p>What, precisely, does it mean to fail the Oedipus complex or the paternal metaphor?</p><p>In Lacanian terminology, it signifies the failure to establish the point de capiton, the quilting point that arrests the otherwise endless slippage of signification.</p><p>Just as an anchor stabilizes a vessel upon turbulent waters, or a button secures the folds of a garment, so too does the Phallus as signifier of signification arrest the perpetual sliding of meaning and stabilize the Symbolic Order.</p><p>The Not-All subject therefore designates one whose entrance into signification, symbolization, and socialization remains incomplete. Such a subject is structurally unfinished, perpetually leaving something to be desired.</p><p>Whereas the All subject enjoys a stable and continuous bond between Subject (S) and Other (O), the relation between the Not-All subject and the Other resembles a broken or dotted line whose instability continually threatens psychic equilibrium.</p><p>Metaphors such as a chasm, crack, or pore opening between S and O aptly characterize this latter condition. Freud himself described it figuratively as a breach in the protective shield.</p><p>Because the boundary separating subject and Other is unusually thin, the Not-All subject becomes extraordinarily sensitive to the reactions of others.</p><p>As Robert Frost famously suggested, the question is always whether one should build walls or dismantle them. Once the branches of one’s fruit tree extend beyond the garden wall and bear fruit in the neighbor’s yard, the inevitable question arises: To whom does the fruit belong?</p><p>The integrity of the barrier separating Subject and Other ultimately depends upon what Lacan calls the death of the Other.</p><p>If the Other (O) is analytically decomposed into a and Ø, objet petit a becomes integrated into the divided subject, thereby constituting the fantasy structure $ ◇ a, whereas the remainder appears as the barred Other (Ø), signifying the death of the big Other.</p><p>It is upon the death of the Other that the flower of subjectivity blossoms.</p><p>For the incomplete Not-All subject, an incessant force continually strives to elevate incompleteness toward the universality of the All. It is here that Yi Sang’s notion of “taxidermied genius” finds its proper locus.</p><p>As Freud argued in Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming (1908), not only James Joyce but countless modern writers and artists repeatedly engage in a Fort–Da game in order to fill the lacunae constitutive of their subjectivity under the name of ɑ–Sinthome.</p><p>This constitutes the archetypal form of what Freud calls ars poetica.</p><p>The psychoanalytic mechanism of sublimation consists precisely in resolving the lacunary phenomenon of subjectivity through the mediation of ɑ–Sinthome.</p><p>Freud expressed this principle with remarkable clarity: the first condition of sublimation is to alter the object and the aim of desire while preserving the intensity of the drive.</p><p>The Rat Man illustrates this principle perfectly. Through compulsive running he transformed “killing Richard” into “killing fat,” thereby redirecting both the object and aim of his aggression without diminishing its intensity. Indeed, he ran, as the expression goes, as though his life depended upon it.</p><p>This is the indirect realization of desire — the royal road of sublimation.</p><p>Because such a process exceeds the level of mere symptom, incorporating instead the possibilities of psychic adaptation, symbolic stabilization, and existential recovery, Lacan designated it Le Sinthome.</p><p>Not only James Joyce but also Vincent van Gogh, Paul Gauguin, Ludwig van Beethoven, Charles Strickland, and numerous other artists may be understood as having survived precisely through the sublimatory Aufhebung accomplished by the Sinthome. Yi Sang’s notion of “taxidermied genius” may likewise be regarded as one of its most compelling manifestations.</p><p>In conclusion, Lacan’s two cardinal concepts — objet petit a and Le Sinthome — may be understood through two mutually constitutive dialectics: fantasy and the traversal of fantasy, and repression and the return of the repressed. Their relation is one of reciprocal implication rather than simple succession.</p><p>Ultimately, this dialectic opens onto the textual theories of postmodernism and poststructuralism, where the very question of textuality comes to the fore. It is within this textual logic that the dialectic of desire and the ethics of the Real unfold.</p><p>Significantly, Meursault, the protagonist of The Stranger — whose original working title was Indifference — does not begin to open himself to the possibility of benign indifference until the novel’s closing pages. That final transformation exemplifies, perhaps more eloquently than any theoretical formulation, the passage from symptom to Sinthome, from passive existence to an affirmative reconciliation with the Real itself.</p><p>요약본</p><p>The ɑ–Sinthome Trajectory: From Repression to Subjective Sublimation</p><p>The dialectic of repression and the return of the repressed provides the fundamental framework through which the Lacanian relation between objet petit a and Le Sinthome may be understood. Whatever falls outside the field of the conscious Ego becomes repressed and subsequently constitutes the unconscious. To this Freudian formulation — the repressed = the unconscious — Lacan adds objet petit a, the residual cause of desire that continually seeks symbolic realization. Dreams exemplify this process: the mechanisms of dream-work are nothing other than the semiotic self-manifestation of objet petit a. Accordingly, psychoanalytic interpretation aims not merely at decoding dream symbols but at identifying the unconscious debt embedded within them, thereby revealing the identity of a itself.</p><p>This process resonates with Heidegger’s notion of Schuldigsein (Being-in-debt) and Lacan’s proposition that the unconscious is structured like a language. If objet petit a functions as the cause of desire, Le Sinthome appears as its existential and symbolic resolution. James Joyce exemplifies this movement. The failure of the paternal metaphor became inscribed as his objet petit a, yet through the practice of écriture he transformed this structural deficiency into a fourth Borromean knot, reconstructing his psychic consistency and converting a potential psychosis into an enduring literary achievement. His writing thus illustrates how symptom can be transfigured into Sinthome.</p><p>Freud’s Rat Man provides a parallel illustration. His unconscious fantasy of killing Richard could not be enacted because of the reality principle; instead, the aggressive drive was displaced into compulsive running — symbolically “killing fat.” This überwertig act exemplifies Lacanian Sinthome, demonstrating how the object and aim of desire may be transformed while preserving the drive’s intensity. Such displacement constitutes the psychoanalytic mechanism of sublimation, whereby destructive impulses are redirected into culturally productive forms.</p><p>The same logic underlies obsessive-compulsive phenomena. Compulsive rituals, such as repetitive hand-washing, are not arbitrary pathological behaviors but unconscious defensive strategies organized around objet petit a. Within Lacan’s formula of fantasy ($ ◇ a), the divided subject confronts the intrusive presence of the Other. The traversal of fantasy consists in integrating objet petit a into the subject rather than remaining passively determined by it. In this sense, compulsive symptoms may become Sinthomatic practices that stabilize psychic existence.</p><p>This dynamic ultimately raises the ontological question of the Not-All subject. Failure of the Oedipus complex or the paternal metaphor signifies the inability to establish the point de capiton, the quilting point that arrests the endless slippage of signification. Consequently, the Not-All subject inhabits an incomplete symbolic order, leaving a constitutive lack at the center of subjectivity. The fantasy structure $ ◇ a emerges precisely within this gap, while the symbolic “death of the Other” enables the subject to establish an autonomous relation to desire.</p><p>Freud’s theory of sublimation provides the decisive conclusion: the object and aim of desire may be transformed without diminishing the intensity of the drive. Joyce, Van Gogh, Gauguin, Beethoven, Strickland, and many other artists exemplify this principle by converting psychic deficiency into creative productivity. Their works are not merely symptoms but Sinthomes — singular formations through which subjective fragmentation is reorganized into symbolic creation.</p><p>Ultimately, objet petit a and Le Sinthome are best understood through two mutually constitutive dialectics: fantasy and the traversal of fantasy, and repression and the return of the repressed. This theoretical configuration extends beyond psychoanalysis into the domains of poststructuralism and postmodern textuality, where meaning is continuously reconstructed through the interplay of desire, signification, and the ethics of the Real. In this sense, the ɑ–Sinthome trajectory describes not only a clinical process but also the fundamental logic through which subjects transform psychic lack into symbolic existence.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0b39dd052d75" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fort-Da: Surmounting the Akedah of ɑ-Sinthome]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/fort-da-surmounting-the-akedah-of-%C9%91-sinthome-4e2d6050b943?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4e2d6050b943</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 07:55:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-24T07:55:59.533Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The so-called Fort/Da game described in Freud’s <em>Beyond the Pleasure Principle</em> (1920) refers to a child’s play in which young Ernst repeatedly throws away and retrieves a spool tied with a string, a ritual devised to soothe himself in the absence of his mother.</p><p>When Freud famously characterized this play as “a great cultural achievement,” cultural theorists were inevitably prompted to ask what, precisely, is at stake in such a game.</p><p>In brief, the Fort/Da dramatizes a shift from “what happened to me” to “what I made happen to me.”</p><p>The event of the mother’s departure can be inscribed, from the child’s standpoint, as a major trauma — this inscription constitutes a symptom. Yet when the same event is articulated as something the subject actively brings about, one can already discern the contours of what Lacan would later conceptualize as the sinthome.</p><p>Through the Fort/Da game, young Ernst momentarily suspends the boredom and pain induced by maternal absence and attains a fleeting state of composure. If this is not a “great cultural achievement,” what could be?</p><p>But can one really believe that such a Fort/Da logic is re-enacted (re-presented) within the representational economy of the drives themselves — Eros and Thanatos?</p><p>Drives (Triebe) are given a priori, according to Freud. His dualistic theory of drives distinguishes between the life drive (Lebenstrieb) and the death drive (Todestrieb). In psychoanalytic discourse, the former has been predominantly associated with sexuality, the latter with aggression.</p><p>The decisive event — or structure — in which these two drives are simultaneously put into play is none other than Freud’s Oedipus complex, or, in Lacanian terms, the paternal metaphor.</p><p>Consider, for example, the young girl who implores her father, “Give me your big Phallus!” (Nasio), or the young boy who is met with the paternal injunction, “Stay away from Mom, or else…!” (Fink). In accordance with the dialectics of observation and participation, commission and omission, excess and lack, the child’s destiny is sealed. What operates here is precisely the logic of the Fort/Da game.</p><p>At the crossroads of whether one passively suffers (fort) the command of the Nom/Non-du-Père — the absolute injunction of YHWH revealed to Moses on Mount Sinai — or actively (da) assumes it “subjectively,” the fate of the subject is decided.</p><p>Strictly speaking, in this Oedipal commission/omission, sexuality and aggression emerge with equal force.</p><p>This rite of passage through the paternal metaphor constitutes the very path of signification, symbolization, and language that Lacan so emphatically underscores. Designated in French as the point de capiton and translated into English as the anchoring point or quilting point, it evokes the anchor that stabilizes a ship on turbulent waters or the button that arrests the drift of fabric.</p><p>What this metaphor ultimately designates is the decisive signifier of completed subjectivity — the All. Lacan’s semiotic formula ⟨∀xΦx⟩ proclaims that all signifiers are inscribed within the symbolic order. Conversely, the negation of this formula designates the Not-All, the figure of an incomplete subject.</p><p>For the fully symbolized subject who has successfully traversed the passage from the dimension of being to that of meaning, a capacity for discernment emerges — Render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s, and unto God what is God’s. A stable distance is established between subject and Other, between subject and object. Like a deeply rooted tree unmoved by the wind, such a subject remains relatively impervious to external perturbations; even a neighbor’s sudden prosperity need not provoke visceral envy.</p><p>By contrast, for the Not-All subject who has partially failed to enter the symbolic order — excluding the radical case of foreclosure (Verwerfung) — the wall separating self and Other is thin and porous. As in adjoining rooms divided by a fragile partition, the voices of others incessantly intrude. In extreme cases, this vulnerability culminates in persecutory delusions, the belief that external forces are infiltrating the self.</p><p>The Chinese idiom si mian chu ge (besieged by songs on all sides) or the medieval Western figure of the Panopticon may be read as transhistorical metaphors for intrusive external forces. Even Robert Frost, often hailed as America’s national poet, once posed the question: If the fruit of my apple tree ripens in my neighbor’s yard, to whom does it belong? — a fantasy of boundary transgression.</p><p>The compulsive hand-washing of the obsessive subject likewise functions as a counter-attack or defensive maneuver against an invasive outside. All these phenomena arise from a perforation or gaping fissure between subject and Other. Freud described this condition as a “breach in the protective shield.”</p><p>Interpreted through the logic of Fort/Da, such phenomena are the outcome of “what happened to me” in the process of subjectivation, and they circulate under the name of symptom.</p><p>When, however, this is transformed into “what I made happen to me,” we arrive at the theory of the sinthome that Lacan emphasized in his later work.</p><p>One might analogize this distinction to that between malignant and benign tumors. The theory of the sinthome articulated in Seminar XXIII: <em>Le Sinthome</em> outlines the path by which the Not-All subject lives — and must live — toward the recovery of subjectivity oriented to the All.</p><p>R₁ ― Symbolic ― R₂(<em>ɑ</em>)</p><p>This path entails subjectively inhabiting the <em>objet petit ɑ</em> as a Real a posteriori — a Real that emerges only after symbolization. Lacan argues in this seminar that James Joyce, having failed the paternal metaphor, sublimated his symptom into a sinthome through his singular mode of écriture. The stream of (un)consciousness embodied in Molly Bloom’s soliloquy in <em>Ulysses</em> exemplifies this transformation: an elevation of the ordinary object to the dignity of the Thing, a sinthomatic sublimation, an ɑ-way of Denken and Aktion.</p><p>Freud had already anticipated this logic in his early essay “Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming.” What, then, is the secret ars poetica by which psychologically troubled Not-All writers transmute their day-dreams into literary works, gain social recognition, and are ultimately canonized as All subjects?</p><p>It is to this very question that Lacan responds with a single word: sinthome.</p><p>At the dawn of <em>Genesis</em>, on Mount Moriah, the Jewish patriarch Abraham raises a knife to the throat of his only son Isaac — the Akedah. In a strikingly homologous gesture, artists and writers across the globe today lift the knife of the sinthome toward the throats of their most cherished “hot potatoes,” their <em>objet petit</em> <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>When Van Gogh painted <em>The Starry Night</em>, when Munch rendered <em>The Scream</em>, and when Beethoven composed the <em>Fate Symphony</em>, each, bearing an afflicted body and a tormented psyche, was traversing an ɑ-way of Akedah, crossing the deathly Mount Moriah.</p><p>Life arising from within death (死中生) — this is the path of the sinthome.</p><p>Let us now pursue this question more deeply through an internal narrative, in explicitly psychoanalytic terms. The most suitable guinea pig for this discussion is none other than the god of clay-court tennis: Rafael Nadal.</p><p>As is well known, Nadal enters the tennis court under a strict regime of taboos. Upon stepping onto the court, one specific foot must necessarily cross first, and at that moment neither foot may touch the court line. This declaration of taboo reaches its apogee in his service ritual.</p><p>Even in this breathless instant, when the gaze of thousands converges upon him, Nadal’s service motion unfolds with mechanical precision: holding the racket in his left hand — he is a southpaw — he touches his nose once with his right hand, lowers it to tug at his shorts, raises it again to touch his face, assumes the service stance, and finally unleashes a powerful serve. At times, this intricate and enigmatic ritual is repeated.</p><p>Under the scorching sun and the incandescent gaze of spectators, this service ceremony proceeds without the slightest deviation. One might dismiss it as a trivial habit or personal quirk, yet its psychoanalytic implications are immense. It exemplifies nothing less than an <em>ɑ</em>-way of the sinthome.</p><p>As the poet Jeong Han-mo writes:</p><p>“Within an orderly movement,</p><p>as silently as a day sinks</p><p>inside a single stone,</p><p>something lawful comes into being.”</p><p>Nadal is compelled to perform these ritualized acts. It is a form of forced choice. And a forced choice is no choice at all; it is the entry into necessity. This necessity is precisely what, in psychoanalysis, manifests as obsession or compulsion.</p><p>On the red clay of Roland Garros — heated by the sun and electrified by the roar of the crowd — the epochal clay-court deity Nadal performs his singular service ritual compulsively. Compulsion, after all, does not signify doing what one wants, but being driven into a situation in which one cannot not do it.</p><p>What, then, is the force that drives him so relentlessly?</p><p>As Lacan diagnosed James Joyce, so too might Nadal’s compulsion be understood as the <em>caput mortuum</em>, the residual remainder, of an Oedipal commission/omission resulting from a failure of the paternal metaphor. For these rites of passage are narrow bridges that no one can avoid, and their outcomes are inscribed unmistakably on the report card of All versus Not-All.</p><p>Though the concrete details remain inaccessible, it appears that Nadal — unlike Joyce, yet no less decisively — (partially) failed to pass through the gate of the nom/non du père, and thus received the grade of Not-All. Subjects marked by this non-totality are nonetheless destined — indeed, doomed — to orient themselves toward the All. Here emerges the phenomenon of perfectionism.</p><p>In striving for the perfect serve, the unerring power shot, Nadal is incessantly attempting to elevate the Not-All into the state of the All. This contemporary Akedah is incisively addressed by Derrida in <em>The Gift of Death</em>:</p><p>“I offer a gift of death, I betray; I do not need to raise my knife over my son on Mount Moriah for that. Day and night, at every instant, on all the Mount Moriahs of this world, I am doing that, raising my knife over what I love and must love, over those to whom I owe absolute fidelity, incommensurably.” (p. 68)</p><p>The Akedah, then, did not occur only once on Mount Moriah in the biblical age; its symbolic model is endlessly reenacted across the contemporary world. What is at stake is not actual death, but symbolic death.</p><p>It is worth recalling that for Freud and Lacan alike, the core of signification lay in symbolic castration. As Magritte famously inscribed beneath his painting: “This is not a pipe.”</p><p>Failure to die symbolically in a thoroughgoing manner — to linger ambiguously between life and death — results in the verdict of Not-All. The Sisyphean effort to elevate this partial negation into the dimension of the All is precisely what gives rise to compulsion.</p><p>Even if this effort, like Zeno’s paradox, endlessly defers its ultimate realization, it nonetheless achieves a fundamental game-changing transformation — from the malignant to the benign, to borrow the language of tumor theory. Lacan names this transformation the formation of a knot.</p><p>For the Not-All subject produced by the failure of the paternal metaphor, the Borromean knot — binding the Imaginary, the Symbolic, and the Real into a single regulatory system, a privilege of the All subject — fails to form. Yet those former incomplete subjects who have pursued Le Sinthome along the path of <em>objet petit</em> <em>ɑ</em> — and who are now canonized as All — are granted a fourth, existential knot.</p><p>Paradoxically, it is this fourth knot that retroactively guarantees the very possibility of the original Borromean knot. The newly ascended All subject, having already traversed the terrain of Not-All, possesses intimate knowledge of both worlds and is thus capable of enacting a psychic and existential will to synthesis.</p><p>It is precisely at this juncture that the birth of the legendary Wise Old Man or the Nietzschean Übermensch may be anticipated. Are not countless artists, athletes, philosophers, and inventors enshrined in history indebted to what Yi Sang called “taxidermied genius,” or to the peculiar “strangeness” dramatized in <em>Extraordinary Attorney Woo</em>?</p><p>This genius, this strangeness, emerges at the threshold of the <em>ɑ</em>-sinthome, where the Not-All subject returns to the state of the All. It marks the inception of what Hawthorne famously called “ Fortunate Fall.”</p><p>Mea culpa!</p><p>Strike your chest and cry out.</p><p>At this juncture, it is impossible not to speak of what unfolds within the analytic setting itself.</p><p>What, after all, is psycho-analysis?</p><p>As Freud famously defined it, psychoanalysis is the labor of rendering the unconscious conscious. Lacan radicalized this insight by insisting that the unconscious is structured like a language. It follows that the aim of analysis can only be a process of verbalization, symbolization, and signification.</p><p>Through the transferential and countertransferential alliance between analyst and analysand, memories from the developmental years — most crucially from the Oedipal period — are reactivated, allowing for what may be called a present reconstruction of the past. This reconstruction is then subjected to a strategy of reading against the grain, through which its unconscious meanings are deciphered.</p><p>A recent paper sent to me for review by a Lacanian society, bearing the title “Sexual Acting-Out,” provides a compelling point of entry into this discussion. In the analytic space, where transference and countertransference are intricately entangled, sexual and aggressive acting-out can, as dramatized in the film <em>Final Analysis</em>, precipitate serious ethical and clinical impasses.</p><p>The Ariadne’s thread that enables escape from this Thesean labyrinth is once again Lacan’s dictum: the unconscious is structured like a language. One must choose the path not of acting-out but of speaking-out: ça parle! — it speaks.</p><p>What takes place in analysis is nothing other than what Anna O. famously called the talking cure. As Bruce Fink puts it:</p><p>“By getting an analysand to dream, day-dream, and talk, however incoherently, about a traumatic ‘event,’ we make him or her connect it up with words, bring it into relation with ever more signifiers.” (Fink 1995, p. 26)</p><p>The following clinical vignette illustrates how deeply the linguistic approach of analysis can become embodied in the analysand’s dream language. The dream presents itself as a sequence of numbers: 2, 20, √2…</p><p>This female analysand, strikingly attuned to numerical symbolism in her dreams, repeatedly encounters the number 2. When asked for associations, she offers the chain 2 → “two” → 0/1. The initial Arabic numeral 2 gradually transforms, along the groove of association, into pictographic figures: a hole (0) and a stake (1).</p><p>For this woman, who has lived for many years under the burden of the primal scene and the incest taboo, sexuality constitutes an unavoidable Sphinxian riddle. The dream language through which this riddle speaks — the semiotic manifestation of the unconscious — takes the form of numerical symbolism. What the aforementioned paper terms sexual acting-out is here deciphered not at the level of behavior, but at the level of language.</p><p>Sexuality, after all, is structured around the question of sexual difference. When this question resists resolution, the analysand mobilizes yet another numerical figure: √2. This irrational number, whose decimal expansion (1.414213…) continues indefinitely without revealing a foundational ground, forms a structure of mise en abyme, an abyss without bottom.</p><p>Here, once again, the thesis holds with precision: the unconscious is structured like a language. Let us not forget that such dreaming and dream interpretation constitute an integral part of the process of signification — the point de capiton — described earlier. It is a procession in search of the raw gem, the pursuit of Eigentlichkeit, of authenticity.</p><p>Let us now reconnect this problem to Lacan’s discourse on the sinthome. As is well known, in the final years of his teaching (1975–76), Lacan entitled Seminar XXIII: <em>Le Sinthome</em>. To substantiate his argument, he summoned the figure of James Joyce, the writer of stream of consciousness.</p><p>Lacan asks: how was it possible that Joyce — despite having been effectively “sentenced” to a life marked by psychopathology due to a failure of the paternal metaphor and the consequent verdict of Not-All — nonetheless succeeded, through his écriture, in elevating ordinary objects to the dignity of the Thing and in leaving an indelible mark on modern intellectual history?</p><p>Let us approach this question through the oxymoron of an unconscious stream of consciousness.</p><p>First, the unconscious is structured like a language.</p><p>Second, dreams are semiotic manifestations of the unconscious.</p><p>Third, writing as stream-of-(un)consciousness is bound to these two in a relation of mutual constraint.</p><p>Through reading against the grain, dream interpretation is extended beyond the talking cure into what may be called a writing cure. This, in essence, is the philosophy of the sinthome. More concretely, it is the path of an <em>ɑ</em>-way of writing.</p><p>The <em>objet petit</em> <em>ɑ</em> — the a posteriori Real that constitutes the kernel of subjective identity — attempts its own epiphany through writing. The scene in <em>A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man</em>, in which Stephen Dedalus gazes at the girl wading in the water or beholds birds soaring into the open sky outside the library, experiences an epiphany, and renounces the priesthood in favor of the life of an artist, is inseparable from writing as sinthome.</p><p>Here, the <em>objet ɑ</em> follows its own path through writing. The result is a passage from the talking cure to the writing cure. The formation of a fourth, existential knot bears witness to this transformation.</p><p>History, in the final analysis, is the self-realization of <em>ɑ</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4e2d6050b943" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ideology (ɑ): Armageddon — The War of the Gods in an Apocalyptic Age]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/ideology-%C9%91-armageddon-the-war-of-the-gods-in-an-apocalyptic-age-575684311670?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/575684311670</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Jan 2026 12:14:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-17T12:14:22.038Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Ideology (ɑ): Armageddon — The War of the Gods in an Apocalyptic Age</strong></h3><p>In the beginning was the Word. (John 1:1)</p><p>Here, the “Word” refers to the Greek Logos.</p><p>Etymologically, Logos functions as a paradigmatic signifier representing what Western civilization has long regarded as the “Good”: reason, conscience, logic, order, and rationality itself.</p><p>The phrase “In the beginning” designates the primordial time of creation as narrated in <em>Genesis</em>.</p><p>And what, precisely, transpired at that beginning?</p><p>There was the incident of the Fruit of the Knowledge of Good and Evil.</p><p>YHWH — the Absolute I AM, the supreme and sovereign Creator — issued a prohibition to His creatures, Adam and Eve, forbidding them to eat from the fruit of the tree standing at the center of the Garden of Eden. This interdiction constituted a linguistic taboo. Humanity’s ancestors, however, transgressed it.</p><p>As a consequence, “their eyes were opened”; they became conscious of their nakedness, experienced shame, and fashioned garments from fig leaves. At that moment, they boarded the irreversible train of civilization.</p><p>This marks the inception of humanity’s will toward civilization — the inaugural derailment from nature to culture.</p><p>The price of this paradise lost has been severe throughout human history. As Freud observed, humanity has been condemned to live with <em>Civilization and Its Discontents</em>; at its most extreme, this condition culminates in what T. S. Eliot famously called <em>The Waste Land</em>.</p><p>The shame and awakening experienced by humanity’s ancestors in the aftermath of the Fall — the aftereffects of consuming the forbidden fruit — precisely represent the ethical and epistemological foundations of the civilizational impulse. Crucially, this impulse is grounded in an orthodox binarism: the division between Good and Evil.</p><p>In the Edenic moment of origin, however, Good and Evil coexisted as One. As the alchemists would have it, this was a state of coincidentia oppositorum, the unity of opposites.</p><p>In the language of the Heart Sutra, it was the realm where form is emptiness, and emptiness is form.</p><p>With the advance of civilization, this unity fractured. The polarity of opposites became polarized; not only were form (rūpa) and emptiness (śūnyatā) separated, but the concept of value was superimposed upon them. Thus emerged the rigid binary according to which Good is valorized and Evil is condemned.</p><p>Difference was no longer merely difference. Once infused with value, difference mutated into discrimination.</p><p>Anti-Semitism under the Nazi regime stands as one of history’s most harrowing testimonies to how such discriminatory consciousness operates in profoundly anti-life ways.</p><p>Human history, therefore, may be read as following the Zen logic articulated by the Seon Master Seongcheol: beginning from “the mountain is the mountain” — a system of unified opposites — passing through the dialectical negation of “the mountain is not the mountain” (the path of civilization itself), and ultimately returning to “once again, the mountain is the mountain.”</p><p>I am unhappy not because I have less,</p><p>but because I believe that others have more.</p><p>To grasp the key to this paradox is to uncover a solution to the dilemma of civilization and anti-civilization.</p><p>The “other” invoked here corresponds, in contemporary philosophical terms, to the Other — or more emphatically, the big Other (l’Autre).</p><p>Le désir de l’homme, c’est le désir de l’Autre.</p><p>The desire of man is the desire of the Other.</p><p>For the post-structuralist psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan, the subject’s desire is inseparable from the desire of the Other; the two exist in a functional relation that cannot be disentangled. This constitutes a decisive, almost apophantic aphorism: nothing meaningful can be said about the human subject (S) without addressing the question of the Other (O).</p><p>Within the process of subjectivation, there is a decisive turning point: Freud’s Oedipus Complex, or in Lacanian terms, the paternal metaphor.</p><p>In both formulations, the subject’s destiny is determined through encounter, confrontation, and reconciliation with the Other.</p><p>It is for this reason that Nazios could describe Oedipus as “the most crucial concept in psychoanalysis,” and that Lacan would designate the paternal metaphor as a point de capiton, a quilting point that anchors meaning. Their formulations underscore the game-changing significance of this moment — and, by extension, the decisive importance of childhood discipline and pedagogy.</p><p>In Lacan’s reformulation of Freud’s Oedipus complex, the paternal metaphor operates such that the desire of the Mother is erased (castrated) by the Name/No of the Father (nom/non du père), resulting in the structural formation of O/Phallus (<em>Écrits</em>, p. 200).</p><p>This operation of signification — this quilting or knotting process — succeeds or fails depending on whether the signifier Phallus is successfully installed.</p><p>If successful, the subject is inscribed as All and signified as ∀xΦx.</p><p>If unsuccessful, the subject is designated as Not-All and inscribed as ∀xΦx, marking the structure of neurosis.</p><p>When entry into the symbolic order is foreclosed at its origin (Verwerfung), the subject receives the diagnosis of psychosis.</p><p>This tripartite classification inevitably evokes the epochal event on Mount Moriah in the Genesis narrative: the Akedah.</p><p>Abraham, the patriarch of the Jewish lineage, raises a knife to the throat of his only son, Isaac — holding fire in one hand and a blade in the other — prepared to sacrifice his child as a burnt offering to YHWH.</p><p>This shocking scene, which confronted Kierkegaard with fear and trembling, is described by Derrida in <em>The Gift of Death</em> (Donner la mort) as follows:</p><p>I offer a gift of death, I betray. I don’t need to raise my knife over my son on Mount Moriah for that. Day and night, at every instant, on all the Mount Moriahs of this world, I am doing that, raising my knife over what I love and must love, over those to whom I owe absolute fidelity, incommensurably. (p. 68)</p><p>Derrida’s deconstructive formulation here signifies, with remarkable precision, what Lacanian psychoanalysis designates as the paternal metaphor and its operative tenor: symbolic castration. One need not embark on a pilgrimage to Mount Moriah to witness a man raising a knife to the throat of what he loves most. Such scenes unfold incessantly across the globe today.</p><p>What is taking place?</p><p>It is symbolic castration enacted for the successful installation of the paternal metaphor.</p><p>The symbolic castration effected by the paternal metaphor — operating as the Name-of-the-Father or the paternal No! — must be executed with the same decisiveness and thoroughness exemplified by the lesson of Mount Moriah. Should this operation falter, the subject is reduced to an incomplete Not-All subject, one in which the wall separating subject and object remains perilously thin and porous. Such a subject is effectively “sentenced” to a pathological trajectory.</p><p>The concrete meaning of this claim becomes unmistakably palpable in the analytic treatment of hysterical or obsessional subjects, where the signified of this signifier emerges with experiential force.</p><p>Let us not forget that the paternal metaphor constitutes the decisive — and inaugural — point of the subject’s process of signification (point de capiton). The taboo articulated in the paternal injunction — “Stay away from Mom, or else …” — marks the child-subject’s very first step toward signification, symbolization, and civilization.</p><p>The primary importance of this rite of passage lies in the fact that it enables the subject’s entry into what Žižek calls the social-symbolic reality (SSR), a fundamentally binary system. To say that a human being becomes a subject (subjectification) is to say that one enters the world of language and symbols — a world governed relentlessly by the logic of binarism.</p><p>The founder of structural linguistics, Ferdinand de Saussure, stated unequivocally:</p><p>“There are only differences in language.”</p><p>Roman Jakobson extended this insight by grounding difference in phonemic opposition, thereby linking difference structurally to binarism. Once the concept of value is superimposed upon this binary system, an impregnable regime of Logocentrism comes into being.</p><p>This is the outcome of linguistic and symbolic subjectivation as revealed by structuralism and post-structuralism alike. Logocentrism, therefore, is the invisible hand that has governed civilization from its Genesis moment — “In the beginning was the Word” — to the contemporary social-symbolic reality.</p><p>The gravity of the problem lies in the fact that this binary logocentrism enters into collusion with ideology.</p><p>What, then, is ideology?</p><p>According to the incisive metaphor proposed by the neo-Marxist Louis Althusser, when an agent of authority hails a passerby — “Hey, you there!” — and the individual turns his head 180 degrees in response, that very moment marks the birth of an ideological subject. This is Althusser’s well-known theory of interpellation.</p><p>Within a social-symbolic reality governed by language and symbols, the human subject is thus condemned to live under the regime of ideological logocentrism.</p><p>Ideology, in Marxian terms, is false consciousness; in Lacanian terms, it is akin to a mirror image grounded in the structure of méconnaissance — misrecognition. Before this ideological mirror, there is little room for genuine questions of equality or justice. What remains are occasional, begrudging concessions: resentful cries such as “a filthy world where only the first place wins,” or the sporadic application of the principle of the least advantaged, as in designated parking spaces for the disabled or procedures such as blind testing.</p><p>Hegel’s master–slave dialectic may be read as a parody — or, more precisely, a demystification — of such ideological logocentrism. Although the master appears to dominate the slave after prevailing in the struggle for recognition, a reversal of equilibrium occurs: the master becomes dependent upon the slave’s labor and compliance. Power thus reveals itself as structurally unstable.</p><p>This dialectic is vividly dramatized in Kim Yu-jeong’s short story <em>Spring, Spring</em>. A young farmhand, formally registered as a servant in a wealthy household, refuses to work during the busiest agricultural season. When the master demands an explanation, the young man responds that he will not lift a finger unless promised marriage to the master’s young daughter, Bun. Exasperated, the master exclaims, “I don’t know anymore which of us is the master and which the servant!”</p><p>Here, the master becomes the slave and the slave the master. We encounter this dialectic repeatedly in modern society — in labor–capital conflicts, and in scenarios of radical social dislocation such as the Bolshevik Revolution.</p><p>The philosophical intervention that most radically dismantles the binary system of logocentrism is Derrida’s deconstruction. Its methodological core lies in the logic of supplementarity. Within an A/B relation, B appears initially to supplement A; yet, over time, it comes to replace it entirely.</p><p>A familiar historical analogy may clarify this logic. In the Joseon dynasty, a powerful aristocrat might keep his lawful wife (the jeong-sil) properly installed in the inner quarters, while maintaining a concubine (so-sil) in the outer room for minor pleasure. Gradually, however, his visits to the outer room increase, and the core of his being — his libidinal and existential investment — shifts toward the concubine. The lawful wife is reduced to an empty shell. The binary of lawful wife/concubine collapses; the master–slave dialectic has played itself out. What began as supplementation ends in substitution.</p><p>Derrida famously theorized this principle through the Greek term pharmakon — both poison and cure. The philosophical engine of deconstruction operates through différance and the logic of Nachträglichkeit (deferred action) at work within textuality itself.</p><p>A Lacanian deconstruction of logocentrism proceeds through a reorientation from the symbolic order toward the Real, from realism to Real-ism. According to the graph of desire, it is from “the Signifier” to “Jouissance”.</p><p>As Bruce Fink observes:</p><p>“Something anomalous always shows up in language, something unaccountable, unexplainable: an aporia. These aporias point to the presence within or influence on the symbolic of the real.” (Fink 1995, 30)</p><p>To pursue what remains undecipherable in language — its aporias — to dismantle from the ground up texts “filled with a lie,” and to reconstruct them otherwise: this is the task of Lacanian deconstruction. It demonstrates that the Real exists within the symbolic order and exerts an irreducible influence upon it.</p><p>The Real in question is not the primordial Real (R1), but the post-symbolic Real — R2, the a posteriori Real — within the configuration R1–Symbolic–R2. This Real crystallizes around what Lacan names objet petit a.</p><p>As the cause of desire and the remainder or mnemonic residue of being — the rem(a)inder — objet a forms the axial core of Lacanian discourse. To undertake an archaeological excavation and a conceptual adventure in pursuit of this elusive object a is the very heart of Lacanian deconstruction.</p><p>How, then, is this accomplished?</p><p>Through the work of rendering the unconscious conscious by means of an analytic reconstruction of the past in the present.</p><p>A paradigmatic example of such an endeavor is found in Balzac’s novella <em>Adieu</em>, whose analytic reconstruction of the crossing of the Berezina River exemplifies this process with remarkable clarity. At the very moment the word “Adieu!” is uttered, the psychotic Countess Stéphanie is miraculously restored to life — as if by magic. It is a triumph of the signifier.</p><p>Lacan’s late attempts at developing a topological imagination and his theory of the Sinthome do not differ substantially from this analytic aspiration. These two therapeutic trajectories correspond respectively to what Freud, in his <em>Project for a Scientific Psychology</em>, termed the neuro-signature and the psycho-signature.</p><p>When the subject undergoes the initiatory passage of signification — passing through Oedipus or the paternal metaphor — a process of Bahnung (path-breaking) is set in motion. This process manifests topologically within the nervous system and takes the form of the Sinthome within the psychic economy.</p><p>Such phenomena are empirically observable. An obsessional patient suffering from Cannon’s fight/flight mechanism reports somatic sensations such as a “tilted playing field” within the chest or a neurological experience in which inside and outside appear inverted. When one recalls that topos in topology signifies place — just as Freud’s own metapsychological “topographies” do — such complaints acquire compelling plausibility.</p><p>The paradigmatic figure of topology is the Möbius strip, characterized precisely by the interpenetration and reversibility of inside and outside. The same logic applies to the torus, the cross-cap, and the Klein bottle, all of which operate through topological configurations that destabilize conventional spatial distinctions. Even the lament of ordinary people — particularly mothers — who complain that a “lump of han (resentment)” moves restlessly within their chest, or that their inner state resembles the scattered debris left after an earthquake or volcanic eruption, may be understood through the lens of topological imagination.</p><p>The Sinthome corresponds to what may be called an orthodox psychogenic psycho-signature. Though it resembles the symptom, the sinthome carries an affirmative, life-conferring dimension absent from traditional symptomatology.</p><p>The sinthomatic mode of thought is characteristically retrospective, oriented toward the grammar of “should have + past participle.” It is crucial to recall that perfectionism itself functions as a fort/da game enacted nachträglich by the incomplete Not-All subject who failed to pass fully through the rite of the paternal metaphor.</p><p>The sinthome is the labor by which a traumatic event — once experienced as “something that happened to me” — is retroactively transformed into “something I made happen to myself.” This is the repayment of debt in Heidegger’s sense of Schuldig-Sein (being-guilty), the liquidation of karma in Buddhist terms, and the remission of original sin in Christian theology.</p><p>Like Hamlet, the Danish prince, who lingers in the hour of the Other while repeating “To be, or not to be,” or like a criminal compulsively revisiting the scene of his crime, the incomplete Not-All subject is never free from war with the past that conferred this very incompleteness. He races relentlessly toward perfection. Here Freud’s concept of repetition compulsion (Wiederholungszwang) comes fully into play.</p><p>In <em>Seminar</em> <em>XXIII</em>: <em>Le Sinthome</em> (1975–76), Lacan introduces his theory of James Joyce’s sinthome. Joyce, an incomplete subject who failed at the paternal metaphor, succeeded in transforming Not-All into All through writing (écriture) as sinthome — leaving an indelible mark on modern intellectual history.</p><p>A scene from Joyce’s early work <em>A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man </em>illustrates this well. Stephen Dedalus, Joyce’s alter ego, is struck in the face by a fellow student; his glasses fall to the ground. Without resistance, Stephen bends down and quietly replaces them — an act coded as insufficiently “manly.”</p><p>This scene stands in sharp contrast to a childhood incident recounted by Freud. Freud’s Jewish father, wearing a fur hat, is assaulted by thugs who knock it into the gutter and shout, “Hey, dirty Jew!” The young Freud, walking beside his father, is enraged. Yet the father silently retrieves the hat and continues on his way.</p><p>In this moment, Cannon’s fight/flight mechanism operates decisively. Freud chooses fight; his father, flight.</p><p>“I may be destroyed, but not defeated” — Santiago’s famous line from <em>The Old Man and the Sea</em> — is enacted by the young Freud.</p><p>In Chapter 15 (“Circe”) of <em>Ulysses</em>, an “unnatural” encounter takes place between Stephen Dedalus and Leopold Bloom in the nocturnal red-light district. Symbolically, their relation is that of father and son. If the paternal relation takes this form, it cannot possibly pass through the Oedipal rite of passage. The failure of the paternal metaphor is evident, for the dialectical negation — the paternal No! — is conspicuously absent.</p><p>Stephen renounces his priestly vocation upon witnessing moments of epiphany: a girl standing by the water with pale knees exposed, gazing toward the sea; birds bursting into flight as he exits the library. He chooses instead the path of the artist. This is the path of the sinthome as writing.</p><p>The path of epiphany is identical to the path of the sinthome. Both possess revolutionary power to transform the superficial crust of existence at its very surface. This is the force of deconstruction — the power to dislocate construction itself.</p><p>Consider the “unbelievable yet true” case of a university student, deemed “below average” by a single IQ point and afflicted by severe panic anxiety, who is cured after hearing the “silent voice” of a Wise Old Man appearing in a dream. This captures the core of epiphanic sinthome theory.</p><p>The God within — Das Unbewußte — activates its self-regulating system in order to impose order upon the disorder of consciousness. This is indelible knowledge, the self-realization of <em>objet petit</em> <em>ɑ</em>.</p><p>Ça parle!</p><p>It speaks.</p><p>After the deconstruction of binarism, what remains?</p><p>The recitation of the Heart Sutra:</p><p>Form is not other than emptiness;</p><p>emptiness is not other than form.</p><p>It is a return to the primordial age of coincidentia oppositorum, the unity of opposites in which Good and Evil once coexisted.</p><p>Yet the mountain to which we return is no longer the original mountain. This return is possible only after passing through the dialectical negation — “the mountain is not the mountain” — and thus constitutes a return to the point of origin transformed:</p><p>“It is a world in which object and consciousness, humanity and nature, subject and object, the in-itself and the for-itself, you and I, dissolve and merge beyond all opposition. This is precisely the poetic world. Through such experience, amid the tensions and conflicts of tragic life, one comes — if only momentarily — to the most fundamental sense of ‘repose’ (repos) and ‘happiness’ (bonheur), in Gaston Bachelard’s sense.”(Yi-moon Park, <em>Poetry and Science</em>, p. 84)</p><p>This poetic world is the mountain of Eden rediscovered after the deconstruction of ideological binarism.</p><p>In the beginning was the Word/Logos.</p><p>What emerges here is the semiotic representation of the unconscious.</p><p>Strickland, the alter ego of the painter Gauguin, abandons the comforts of modern civilization and embarks upon a counter-civilizational adventure of thought on the primitive island of Tahiti. Even as his body withers and approaches extinction, the flame of his creative drive — his pursuit of the masterpiece — burns ever more fiercely.</p><p>At last, the masterpiece is completed. It is later revealed to be a painted mural on the wall of his hut: a raw, primal explosion of yellow, red, and blue — pure chromatic intensity, sheer originary force. It is a work perfectly attuned to the spirit of Tahiti.</p><p>Strickland commands Ata — the Tahitian “mermaid,” his young indigenous wife and the embodiment of innocence — to burn it after seeing it: “Let it be for your eyes alone.” Ata obeys faithfully. Thus, the only person to behold the masterpiece is Ata herself. Yet its existential archetype has been inscribed into humanity’s memory as indelible knowledge through Somerset Maugham’s <em>The Moon and Sixpence</em>.</p><p>This is the stage of canonization.</p><p>To live at this level of canonization — to practice what Shoshana Felman calls the vital use of death — is to walk the path of the Sinthome. It is an affirmative response to the semiotic manifestation of the unconscious, an act of deciphering the Da Vinci Code transmitted from the unknown:</p><p>It speaks!</p><p>The privileged site where the semiotic manifestation of the unconscious unfolds is the stage of dreams. Dreams function as compensatory wish-fulfillment of the repressed (Freud, <em>SE</em> 4: 160). In a similar, though distinct sense, the sinthome — Sinthome (<em>ɑ</em>) — which harbors <em>objet petit</em> <em>ɑ</em> within itself, may be defined as compulsive wish-fulfillment.</p><p>This is because the sinthome belongs to the incomplete subject, the Not-All. In the pursuit of transforming incompleteness into completeness — what we call perfectionism — an irreducible compulsive force necessarily comes into play. It is the moment when 99 percent of effort is joined by the remaining 1 percent of inspiration. It is the instant in which the petrified genius of Yi Sang, or the uncanny brilliance of Extraordinary Attorney Woo, releases its full power.</p><p>From the margins of history, a single rose is offered to Emily.</p><p>A Rose for Emily!</p><p>After completing this essay, I went to bed — and there, I dreamed a strange dream. It was a dream of the war of the gods in an apocalyptic age, of Armageddon. Within that dream, an intellectual hero was being born.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=575684311670" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lacan and Derrida: Poetics of Post-Psychoanalysis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@parkchanbu/lacan-and-derrida-poetics-of-post-psychoanalysis-316bbd40c0a9?source=rss-fffa513493d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/316bbd40c0a9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Park Chan-Bu, Ph. D in Psychoanalysis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Jan 2026 07:25:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-09T07:25:25.127Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Primal Scene (Urszene)</p><p>The primordiality of this term, coined by Freud in the inaugural years of psychoanalysis, cannot be overstated.</p><p>The analytic discourse of a subject who has traversed the Oedipal threshold and encountered the primal scene retains precisely the kind of mythic originary force articulated in Yi Yuk-sa’s poem “The Wilderness”:</p><p>On a day beyond reckoning</p><p>when heaven first opened,</p><p>where could the crowing of a rooster have been heard?</p><p>Even when all mountain ranges</p><p>rushed headlong, longing for the sea,</p><p>this place alone could not yet be violated.</p><p>…And again, after ages beyond ages,</p><p>a superhuman riding a white horse will come,</p><p>and in this wilderness cry out at the top of his voice.</p><p>Psychoanalytic pathology is rooted in such originary scenes.</p><p>It is precisely because of this mythic dimension of primordiality that analytic treatment is so arduous and inevitably time-consuming.</p><p>At its foundation lies what Freud termed Trieb — a word variously translated as instinct, drive, or impulse.</p><p>Given that James Strachey, in editing and translating <em>The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud</em>, rendered Trieb as instinct, it seems both reasonable and theoretically consistent to translate the term accordingly.</p><p>Freud is, in principle, a dualist.</p><p>Having initially posited the opposition between sexual instincts and ego instincts, he later returned — most decisively in <em>Beyond the Pleasure Principle</em> (1920) — to another form of dualism that persisted until the end of his life, this time through the introduction of the death instinct (Todestrieb).</p><p>In brief, human beings are born a priori with instinctual dispositions toward sexuality and death — the latter subsequently identified with aggression.</p><p>Throughout development, it is through the differentiation, confrontation, and hybridization (Triebmischung) of these instincts that all forms of psychopathology emerge.</p><p>My book <em>Sex and Violence</em> (2025) addresses this problematic head-on.</p><p>In the course of development, encounters with the significant Other are decisive for the formation of subjectivity — most crucially during the Oedipal rite of passage in which the paternal metaphor comes into operation.</p><p>When this metaphor functions effectively, the subject acquires a point de capiton, a quilting point that anchors meaning, thereby receiving the judgment of the All — formally expressed as ∀xΦx.</p><p>However, when the anchoring of meaning partially fails due to excess (commission) or lack (omission), the subject is relegated to the position of the Not-All, that is, the neurotic subject.</p><p>If we momentarily bracket the state of none characteristic of foreclosure (Verwerfung), the true domain of psychoanalytic treatment lies precisely in this middle terrain.</p><p>This is why Freud could claim that “everyone is a neurotic subject.”</p><p>The neurotic subject is broadly divided into hysteria and obsession/compulsion.</p><p>As was the case with many of the patients Freud treated in the early years of psychoanalysis, hysterical patients are predominantly women.</p><p>Almost without exception, they suffer from the problem of Eros within the dualism of instincts.</p><p>By contrast, most obsessional subjects grapple with Thanatos, that is, with the problem of aggression.</p><p>While exceptions certainly exist, this broad typology remains useful as a working hypothesis.</p><p>In other words, the breeding ground of psychopathology is the Oedipus complex and the paternal metaphor.</p><p>Through this rite of passage — what Shoshana Felman calls the “life usage of death” — a process of Bahnung, the opening of pathways toward Eros within the symbolic order, is effected.</p><p>The symbolic order is the world of language as the big Other (O), and language itself is constituted by difference:</p><p>“There are only differences in language.” (Saussure)</p><p>Another structuralist, Roman Jakobson, linked this concept of difference to binarism, and once the notion of value is added, an impregnable hierarchical order emerges.</p><p>It is crucial to recall that this very binary system constituted the primary target of Derrida’s project of deconstruction.</p><p>“In the beginning was the Word.” (John 1:1)</p><p>In the original Greek, this Word is Logos.</p><p>The signifieds attached to this signifier include reason, conscience, logic, and order — all the “good things” that form the foundational pillars of Western civilization.</p><p>This, precisely, is what Derrida calls logocentrism.</p><p>To dismantle it is the central task of post-structuralist deconstruction.</p><p>The opening line of the Bible, therefore, may be read as naming the first stage of civilization undertaken after the loss of Paradise.</p><p>The Genesis myth — according to which human beings eat the forbidden fruit of good and evil prohibited by the Absolute I AM, have their eyes opened, feel shame at their nakedness, fashion garments from fig leaves, and then board the civilizational train departing from Eden — accurately represents humanity’s will toward civilization.</p><p>In the Garden of Eden, good and evil were bound together within a single fruit.</p><p>In the language of alchemy, this was a coincidentia oppositorum, a unity of opposites.</p><p>Under the pressure of humanity’s civilizing will, this unity was split into the binary structure of good versus evil, to which the concept of value was subsequently added, solidifying the doctrine that good is good and evil is bad.</p><p>This consolidation is precisely what we call logocentrism.</p><p>This, precisely, is what Freud meant by civilization and its discontents.</p><p>If this constitutes the roadmap for the genesis of psychoanalytic pathology, then its treatment can only proceed through the deconstruction of its construction — that is, through a deconstructive approach.</p><p>A paradigmatic example is the pharmakon in the account of Socrates’ death.</p><p>This word simultaneously signifies poison and remedy, and once its binary opposition is dismantled, one can adopt a value-neutral position toward Socrates’ death itself.</p><p>In the full sense of the term, the methodology of deconstruction consists in creatively undoing the binary systems that govern the symbolic order, through the logics of différance and Nachträglichkeit (deferred action) that characterize textuality.</p><p>It is within this oxymoron — “creative destruction” — that the vital force of deconstruction resides.</p><p>In the historical aftermath of dismantled binaries, what comes to prevail is the logic of the unity of opposites, as articulated in the Heart Sutra:</p><p>Form is not other than emptiness; emptiness is not other than form.</p><p>This marks a dialectical return to the epoch of the fruit of good-and-evil, when good and evil coexisted.</p><p>The Eden that follows the passage through a Dialectical No! will not be the original Eden.</p><p>Rather, it will be a space animated by the aesthetics of the Sublime, where an ordinary object is sublated (Aufhebung) into the dignity of the Thing.</p><p>The psychoanalytic process unfolds in an analogous manner.</p><p>Derrida, in simultaneously criticizing and defending his contemporary Lacan, famously designated his position as phallogocentrism — a critique that can be read both as a challenge to his intellectual rival and as an implicit homage to another heroic figure of post-structuralism whose thinking nonetheless ran parallel to his own.</p><p>Lacan’s paternal metaphor constitutes a rite of passage in which the desire of the Mother is operated upon by the nom/non du père, producing the subjectivizing and signifying outcome of O/Phallus.</p><p>One must attend carefully to the fact that the Phallus occupies the position of the master signifier in this outcome.</p><p>It is the Phallus as signification, as the point de capiton anchoring meaning.</p><p>When the phallic signifier fails to settle through the paternal metaphor, an incomplete Not-All subject comes into being — like a boat wavering on water, or a piece of fabric without a knot, lacking structural binding.</p><p>This marks the inception of trauma (ɑ), which manifests as a gaping wound (agapē) or as a breach in the protective shield.</p><p>Analytic treatment, therefore, is nothing other than the labor of suture — the work of sealing these wounds and breaches.</p><p>Through this process, a fourth knot is fashioned to restore the disintegrating Borromean knot: this is the theory of the sinthome, which Lacan elaborated with particular intensity in his later years.</p><p>Carrying the fantasy of penis envy, the young girl entering the Oedipal phase launches an urgent communicative appeal toward the father:</p><p>“Give me your big Phallus!”</p><p>(Nasio, Oedipus: <em>The Most Crucial Concept in Psychoanalysis</em>)</p><p>Should the father take this bait, the child’s process of signification and subject formation collapses entirely.</p><p>Only the stance of the ordinary — yet, in another sense, extraordinary — father, who at the wedding ceremony walks his daughter down the virgin road, places her hand into that of the waiting groom, then turns away and weeps, can properly guide her through the Oedipal threshold.</p><p>This, once again, is the aesthetics of the Sublime: the elevation of the ordinary object to the dignity of the Thing.</p><p>The hysterical subjects discussed earlier were unable to traverse this path.</p><p>D. H. Lawrence’s line in <em>The Rainbow</em> — “My father came too near to me” — and his recurrent formulation that one “opened one’s eyes to the world too early” are precise records of a Lawrencian failure of the paternal metaphor.</p><p>Lawrence’s early novel <em>Sons and Lovers</em>, with its telling formulation of being “a son and at the same time a lover,” presents what appears to be an Oedipal tilted playing field, structurally skewed from the outset.</p><p>Rendered in a Lacanian logic inflected by Derrida, this pathology emerges from the failure to deconstruct logocentrism, that is, phallogocentrism — in other words, from the inability to dismantle the binary system embedded within this post-structuralist concept.</p><p>This very pathology is powerfully inscribed in <em>The Vegetarian</em> by Nobel laureate Han Kang.</p><p>There, it is metaphorized through the violence of a father who forces sweet-and-sour pork down the throat of his ailing daughter.</p><p>Naturally, the daughter resists: “No… No!”</p><p>And in “Mongolian Mark,” the dramatic primordiality of the primal scene reaches its climax, laying bare the metamorphosed distortion of sexual fantasy in all its brutality.</p><p>This is precisely where No! — the language of taboo — must be enacted.</p><p>Balzac’s <em>Adieu</em></p><p>Within the analytic space that attempts a present reconstruction of the past, the transference-based re-presentation or reenactment between analyst and analysand is metaphorized in Balzac’s novel through the reconstruction of the crossing of the Berezina River.</p><p>Through this transferential reconstruction, the primordial voice — “Adieu!” — is resurrected, and the dying Countess Stéphanie miraculously returns to life.</p><p>Seek the Raw Stone</p><p>Heidegger’s term Eigentlichkeit, translated into English as authenticity, originally signifies the genuine article — the true as opposed to the counterfeit.</p><p>It names, quite literally, a raw stone.</p><p>To seek authenticity is to privilege the former term in the binary opposition of genuine/counterfeit, original/forgery.</p><p>The primordial truth-value uncovered through the archaeological excavation of the past’s present reconstruction is precisely this raw stone, and the labor of locating it constitutes the psychoanalytic process itself.</p><p>The presentified memory-fragment or remainder of the past — the object ɑ as rem(a)inder — and its symbolic manifestations in dreams and dream interpretation: these are the means through which psychoanalysis attempts to reveal the primordiality of the primal scene, the authenticity of the raw stone.</p><p>The death instinct and its aggressive drive follow this same path after Eros.</p><p>This path is characterized by what Cannon termed the fight/flight mechanism — the ambivalent affective economy of whether to fight or to flee.</p><p>As evidenced in cases such as ‘the Rat Man’ and ‘the Schreber case,’ this fight/flight mechanism likewise derives from the paternal metaphor, and its negative archetype can be traced back to the ancient retaliatory law of equivalence, the Lex Talionis.</p><p>The logic of the Lex Talionis — “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth” — as articulated in <em>the Code of Hammurabi</em> (20th–30th century B.C.) and <em>the Pentateuch</em>, may well be understood as one of the most effective mechanisms for suturing and sealing the psychic wounds produced by the manifestation of the aggressive instinct.</p><p>Nothing elevates inner pleasure — psychic jouissance — more powerfully than revenge.</p><p>The film <em>The Revenant</em> offers a compelling illustration of this dynamic.</p><p>What remains terrifying, however, is retaliation.</p><p>It is precisely for this reason that the institution of “punishment with impunity” emerged.</p><p>The revenge drama of Kim Bu-nam, who famously declared, “I killed not a human being, but a beast,” follows with striking fidelity the retaliatory logic of the Lex Talionis.</p><p>Sexually assaulted in childhood, Kim murders her now-elderly assailant thirty years later by mutilating and killing him with a knife.</p><p>Yet she does not receive the privilege of revenge without retaliation and is instead brought before the court of law.</p><p>Is there, then, no place for the Lex Talionis within the Real outside the analytic space?</p><p>Obsessive subjects, haunted by a siege-like fantasy and living within a prison of duty, relentlessly seek out this space, engaging in a Sisyphean labor.</p><p>Even if ultimate success is perpetually deferred — like Zeno’s paradox — the tortoise and the hare continue to run ceaselessly toward its approximation, or even beyond it.</p><p>One analysand, whom I shall call K, is a victim of the binary structure of the fight/flight (f/f) mechanism.</p><p>At the crossroads of whether to fight or flee, he chose the latter.</p><p>The consequences of opting for flight under the situational logic of a man-to-man confrontation were severe, marked by a profound sense of defeat and shame reminiscent of the Humiliation of Samjeondo.</p><p>Just as King Injo of Joseon was brought low after performing the degrading ritual of the three kneelings and nine prostrations before Hong Taiji of Qing, K — compelled to choose flight over fight — remains ensnared in the logic of Nachträglichkeit, the retrospective temporality of “should have + past participle.”</p><p>In order to escape intrusive thoughts that besiege him from all sides, he washes his hands compulsively.</p><p>This act constitutes a symbolic annihilation of the enemy, a belated execution — here and now — of what should have been done in the past.</p><p>The etymological play embedded in the English word in-tru(th)-sive suggests that truth emerges precisely at this site.</p><p>This is Heidegger’s Eigentlichkeit — authenticity — the very synonym of the genuine, the true article (正品, 眞品).</p><p>Such is the conscious/unconscious stream of the obsessive subject.</p><p>This, too, is what Lacan formulated in his later years as the theory of the sinthome.</p><p>The sinthome is a positive reconfiguration of the symptom.</p><p>When the subject fails to traverse the gate of the paternal metaphor properly and the three rings of the Borromean knot cease to function coherently, the sinthome operates as a fourth existential knot that holds the structure together.</p><p>It was in this sense that James Joyce’s écriture functioned as his sinthome.</p><p>Beyond Joyce, one might also locate the taxidermied genius of all artists — and even the phenomenon dramatized in <em>Extraordinary Attorney Woo</em> — within this same logic.</p><p>They are flowers of subjectivity blooming atop the grave of the big Other.</p><p>ɑ-way of the Unconscious: Sinthome</p><p>The sinthome follows the path of object ɑ, the cause of desire.</p><p>In this sense, it closely resembles the path of dreams, which constitute the semiotic manifestations of the unconscious.</p><p>Dreams are defined as “compensatory wish-fulfillments” (<em>SE</em> 4: 16): they attempt to compensate for the loss and lack experienced in the process of subject formation by opening pathways toward desire, hope, and wish.</p><p>Such unconscious processes, when they surface within the stream of consciousness, manifest themselves as repetitive, habitual, and ritualized acts.</p><p>The so-called eccentricities, perfectionism, or taxidermied genius of artists are by no means unrelated to this dynamic.</p><p>All of these phenomena mark the sinthomatic path through which the incomplete Not-All subject aspires toward the condition of the All.</p><p>From Lacan’s perspective, it was precisely the sinthome that allowed James Joyce, who failed to traverse the paternal metaphor successfully, to choose life over death through his singular mode of writing, thereby achieving posthumous canonization within the history of modern literature.</p><p>In the analytic setting, this process of sinthomatization is realized through psychodrama and re-presentation, the present reconstruction of the past — exemplified earlier through the metaphor of the crossing of the Berezina River.</p><p>Something anomalous always shows up in language, something unaccountable, unexplainable: an aporia. These aporias point to the presence within or influence on the symbolic of the real. (Fink 1995, 30)</p><p>This remark by Bruce Fink appears in his discussion of the Lacanian subject situated between language and jouissance.</p><p>Within language, phenomena emerge that resist understanding and explanation — aporias — which indicate the presence of the Real within the symbolic order, or the influence exerted by the Real upon it.</p><p>Fink refers to these aporetic phenomena as “kinks in the symbolic order.”</p><p>This formulation resonates deeply with Derrida’s deconstructive strategy of dismantling surface structures in order to expose deeper ones through the logic of supplementarity.</p><p>It also converges with Lacan’s Copernican turn from realism to Real-ism, from the primacy of representation to the primacy of the Real.</p><p>Derrida’s critique of logocentrism thus finds its structural counterpart in Lacan’s Other-centrism.</p><p>For Lacan, the process of subject formation begins with alienation — the subject’s inscription into the discourse of the big Other (O).</p><p>The completion of subjectivity, however, presupposes what Lacan calls the alienation of alienation, namely separation, a process of de-alienation through which the subject emerges as such.</p><p>Lacan’s concept of de-alienation, the movement by which the subject loosens itself from the dominion of the big Other (O), bears a striking resemblance to Derrida’s notion of deconstruction.</p><p>The cry that both articulate, in unison, may be rendered in a Clintonian joke:</p><p>“Stupid — it is the Real that counts!”</p><p>What is at stake here is a dialectical movement: from “the mountain is the mountain,” through the negation “the mountain is not the mountain,” and finally back to “the mountain is the mountain.”</p><p>Yet the mountain to which one returns is no longer the mountain with which one began.</p><p>Within the symbolic order governed by ideological binaries — by what might be called their forked flame — there is no space in which equality or justice can truly take root.</p><p>Only by dismantling this binary system and proclaiming the passage “from the symbolic to the Real” can human existence come to taste what Gaston Bachelard called repos (rest) and bonheur (happiness).</p><p>Jacques Lacan / Jacques Derrida</p><p>Differing by a single letter in their first names, these two post-structuralist thinkers nonetheless share a remarkable consonance.</p><p>At their fingertips, modern civilization itself is being threshed and reworked.</p><p>As many of Derrida’s writings on Freud suggest, psychoanalysis was already deconstructive in its mode of thought from the very beginning.</p><p>Both psychoanalysis and deconstruction have consistently relied upon literature as their indispensable companion in the elaboration of theory.</p><p>In this sense, literature may be said to function not only as the unconscious of psychoanalysis, but also as the différance of deconstruction.</p><p>The passage above is drawn from the epilogue to “Literature and Psychoanalysis,” the second essay in my earlier book, <em>Modern Psychoanalytic Criticism</em> (Minumsa, 1996).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=316bbd40c0a9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>