<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Pat Baumann on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Pat Baumann on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@patbaumann?source=rss-6daa5866dded------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:23:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@patbaumann/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social Ills and Basketball]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@patbaumann/social-ills-and-basketball-9727c4e7be03?source=rss-6daa5866dded------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9727c4e7be03</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nba]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basketball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teamwork]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Pat Baumann]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Apr 2018 13:23:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-26T13:23:34.695Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>— A Dime for Condoleeza [0] (see notes)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oxxHFOLNr8ZftHbtkMumVg.png" /><figcaption>(photo via Washington Times)</figcaption></figure><p>Basketball is a mess. It will always be a great game. It’s fun to play. It’s fun to watch. By many measures the NBA is stronger than ever. The league is flush with cash thanks to $24 billion from ESPN and TNT that started coming in 2016. Free agent signings set new records for player salaries every year. Top players are global icons, surpassing the popularity of Michael, Magic and Larry. And March is madder than ever. So what’s the problem?</p><p>Consider the purpose of sport. Health benefits for participants and entertainment for spectators. But there’s a third purpose, something more social, related to morality and ethics. Sports exemplify our highest values and shape our ideals. Sport teaches teamwork, discipline, commitment, sacrifice, confidence and more. Nothing is better at teaching these important life lessons. Especially to kids. Not school, not parents. In this, basketball is failing.</p><p><strong><em>Social Equivalents &amp; the State of Basketball</em></strong></p><ul><li><strong>Russian oligopoly </strong>— No parity, only two or three teams have any hope to win the NBA championship. Super teams are making the situation worse than ever.</li><li><strong>Using food stamps to buy lottery tickets</strong> — Tanking, teams that can’t win are losing on purpose. The league is full of drama and intrigue. But it’s mostly to see which team will win the lottery, not the championship. The bouncing balls even introduce an element of chance that is missing in a 7-game playoff series. [1]</li><li><strong>Tyranny</strong> — Coaches apparently no longer have final say which players are on the court. The commissioner has started weighing in, using threats and coercion, to keep stars on the court and in the starting line-up.</li><li><strong>Price fixing</strong> — The salary cap, max contracts and rookie contracts violate an individual’s right to negotiate a fair wage. All these rules affect players, mostly young black men, but not coaches and owners, mostly older white men. This violates free-market capitalism if it isn’t outright racist.</li><li><strong>Income inequality</strong> — The NBA’s wage gap can make Wall Street’s greediest CEO’s blush. The G-League gives players a max salary of $26,000. Given that players can make more money in Europe, China or Philippines, how can it attract and develop talent for the NBA? The short answer: It can’t. The G-League is a joke. But it doesn’t matter because it’s not a development league anyway. [2]</li><li><strong>Exploitation</strong> — The NCAA, the real development league, gives players zero financial compensation. Pro prospects might consider college basketball as an unpaid internship though it’s not a perfect analogy. Interns normally get in the way and don’t produce anything of value while athletes in Division I college basketball generate billions in revenue. Interns voluntarily forego a salary in exchange for valuable work experience that will benefit their career for decades. Young athletes, whose career is lucky to last 5 years, have no choice than let their earnings be usurped by a powerful government-sanctioned monopoly.</li><li><strong>Collusion</strong> — The NBA owners colluded against a vulnerable class of people. In 2005, as more and more young athletes were showing that the NCAA was a raw deal, the NBA barred elite prospects until a year after high school. The ‘one-and-done’ rule was implemented to protect big financial interests inside the NBA and NCAA. It was discriminatory. It also makes the NBA culpable for violations committed by the NCAA. [3]</li><li><strong>Corruption </strong>— The NCAA besmirched college basketball. It’s so bad the FBI diverts resources from stopping drug cartels and domestic terrorism. It’s a wonder they needed wiretaps, widespread corruption can be proven nearly a priori. [4]</li><li><strong>Censorship of free speech</strong> — Lastly, players and owners get fined for speaking. Mark Cuban was fined $600,000 for saying something the league didn’t want to hear. Magic Johnson, a former color commentator and certified basketball genius, is fined for tampering every time he opens his mouth. Does this make the world a better place?</li></ul><p>All of these issues have caught the league’s attention. And judging by the commissioner’s public comments, he’d like to fix them. But everyone is acting in their own self-interest according to the existing set of rules and rewards. Unless you expect people to voluntarily act against their best interest; memos, threats and complaints won’t affect any change. Fortunately, he’s in the best position to enact rules and policies that change the rules and rewards.</p><p>Adam Silver’s top priority should be to align the short and long-term interests of owners, players and fans. Following are ideas to do that.</p><h3><strong>1. The Two Quarter Restriction </strong>—</h3><p><em>Any individual player can play in no more than two regulation quarters. It could be first and second, first and third, second and fourth, etc. All players are eligible in overtime. [5]</em></p><p>This is a small rule change that’s easy to enforce, is not subjective and does not affect play on the court. Still it has far-reaching implications. Crucially, role players and reserves will get more minutes thereby taking pressure off the superstars and putting more responsibility on the rest of the team and coach. An increase in player’s median salary will accompany a modest decrease for superstars. In return, superstars will be more rested, healthier and less likely to sit out games for whatever reason. Coaches will face a bigger challenge managing lineups in-game. As a result, the best ones will deserve financial compensation or better job security.</p><p>Subtly, the game will be more team-oriented. Success of the team will be less dependent on a single player. Franchises will be unleashed from the career arc of a dominant superstar, less depleted when they retire or get injured, less devastated when they demand to be traded. Nineteen year old kids, no matter their potential, will have less impact on the game so there will be less incentive to tank. Instead of rebuilding, there will only be building. Teamwork will replace super teams, competitive balance will be restored. And ultimately, fans get a more strategic, exciting, entertaining game.</p><p><strong><em>Stay Healthy and on the Court</em></strong></p><p>The most direct and obvious consequence of the ‘Two Quarter Restriction’ is that certain players play less. As it happens, the players who get the most minutes and would be most affected tend to be the best players. In 2016–2017, LeBron James lead the league in minutes and was second, behind Dirk, among active players in career minutes. Check out this exchange about playing time in November:</p><blockquote><em>Draymond Green: “Man, he’s been playing a lot of 40-minute [nights] and it’s only Nov 12. He’s superhuman, but eventually his superhuman powers go away.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>LeBron James: “Draymond’s right…We want to get those minutes down for sure. But as of right now, we’ve had two point guards out and we’ve had some different lineup changes, so I’ve had to play more minutes than I would like, and more minutes than my teammates would like me to have.”</em></blockquote><p>Far from an endorsement to restrict minutes, he at least recognizes that too many minutes comes at a cost. Initially manifesting as player fatigue which leads to sloppy play and poor defense. Or, more tragically, injury. To the dismay of the league office, progressive coaches and teams have tried to manage fatigue by resting healthy players. Especially on back-to-backs.</p><p>Healthier players is good for everyone. Limiting players to two quarters reduces fatigue and injury which is a clear benefit to the player. Accumulating less wear on their bodies throughout the season even allows for longer careers or a better quality of life after leaving the league. Healthier players also benefit owners and fans who are invested either financially or psychologically.</p><p><strong><em>Inequality and an Antidote for Super teams</em></strong></p><p>There is vast income inequality amongst NBA players. It is becoming the norm for franchises to sign 2 or 3 players on max contracts then keep just enough cap space to fill out a roster with veteran minimum and rookie contracts. Franchises without players worth max money often give them max contracts anyway or keep the space to lure superstars in free agency. I’m not saying players shouldn’t get huge contracts and, as a principle, I’m not against income inequality. [6] In fact, I’d get rid of max contracts so superstars could get paid even more. Everyone should get paid what they’re worth. The problem is that superstars are worth too much.</p><p>Under the Two Quarter Restriction, well balanced teams would stand a good chance against a modern super team. First superstars will play less minutes. The corollary is that other players will play more thus becoming more important and more valuable. Next, a few teams rethink how they build their roster. They realize they can build a better team if they forego max players. Instead they invest in a deeper bench. By strengthening the weakest link, they are better overall. At the same time, compared to a team that relies on the raw talent of a couple superstars, they are also less vulnerable to injury. [7] Gradually the value for role players and reserves is bid up and the value for superstars declines. Eventually, the market resettles with superstars retaining the highest salaries. Perhaps 4–5x more than reserve players rather than 25–30x as is common today.</p><p><strong><em>Strategy and Making Coaches Think</em></strong></p><p>Compared to other team sports, like football, basketball is not a very strategic game. The most important decision coaches make in games is when to call time-out and which players are on the floor. Hint: Play the best players. Perhaps the General Manager has to make more strategic decisions in managing contracts and the salary cap just to build the roster. Hint: Sign the best players. More strategy would add a new layer to the sport, would engage fans and pundits, and give head coaches an opportunity to earn that million dollar check.</p><p>The Two Quarter Restriction, though a small rule change, forces the coaching staff to make several strategic decisions. Should I change my starting lineup to save my best players for the second half? Being a starter may be less prestigious if the alternative is to be a closer. Should I play my best players together or split them up? If I play them together in my first unit I can build up a lead, then the second unit just needs to lock down the defense and hold on for the win. Should I be reactive to the decisions of the opposing coach? If the other team is playing big, should I match them or go small to exploit their weakness? Should I be reactive to the conditions in the game? If my team has a commanding lead, I can save my stars either for the second half or give them more rest. Or should I be proactive?</p><p><strong><em>More Hustle, More excitement</em></strong></p><p>An exciting game of basketball is a special thing. It’s a pity it’s so rare. NBA games often start with a slow pace, sloppy play and poor defense. This can last for the first three quarters. Occasionally these games have an exciting 4th quarter and close finish. Other times the game gets decided early and the whole 4th quarter is garbage time.</p><p>With the Two Quarter Restriction, it is reasonable to expect a higher quality of play. Not only will players be more rested and healthy, they will be more focused. Some players, knowing they won’t be eligible in the 4th quarter, will try to make an impact whenever and however they can. That might mean playing defense in the 1st quarter or hustling in the 2nd quarter. Expect more effort overall especially in each <em>player’s</em> second quarter before hitting the shower. Giving full effort throughout the whole game even has a strategic benefit. Larger leads allow for more conservative strategies such as saving (i.e. resting) the best players. Whereas deficits must be countered with more aggressive strategies such as playing the best players earlier and longer.</p><p><strong><em>Teamwork or lack thereof</em></strong></p><p>Basketball is widely considered a team sport. If that’s true, then a sufficiently skilled and experienced team should beat a random group of all-stars. In other words, the <em>trust, discipline and coordination </em>that define teamwork can overcome a deficiency of talent. This plausibly explains why the US Men’s National team couldn’t win gold in ’02, ’04 and ’06 and why even many of their victories are closer than might be expected. The philosophy of professional basketball in the United States, which was transferred to the National team, is talent over teamwork. [8] Other countries with less raw talent can compensate with better teamwork.</p><p>So yes, basketball is a team sport. It’s just that teamwork is more optional than other team sports. If that’s too pejorative, it’s another way to say, “The team with the best players normally wins,” which is common sense. It’s most obvious when a single player dominates a game, whether he gets a hot hand, is more talented, or just bigger. This is true in the NBA, but is especially true in youth leagues when one player may be more physically mature. Ignoring teamwork for a moment, by default, the best team would be the team with the best players. The way to be the best team would be merely to get the best players, inevitably leading to a bidding war for the top talent and the creation of super teams. Sound familiar? Fortunately, super teams can be overcome with teamwork. Unfortunately, teamwork is hard to find in the NBA. [9]</p><p>Teamwork is not magic. But it needs <em>motivation towards a shared objective, leadership and time. </em>So are NBA players motivated? Generally players are motivated, although there is significant innate variability. It also varies over the course of a contract and a career, tending to increase towards the end of each. Do they at least have a shared objective, ostensibly to win? Unfortunately not. Players get distracted by their personal stats, free agency, endorsements or their new rap single. Of course it’s hard to blame players for not trying hard to win when some owners and GM’s are trying even harder to lose. What about time? Tellingly only 5 NBA coaches have been in their current job over 5 years. NBA coaches get little respect. They are fired quickly for losing and are even fired as a result of friction with players, euphemistically known as ‘losing the locker room’. [10] Star players at least have the job security not to get fired though they may be traded. Add this all up, the environment in the NBA doesn’t foster much teamwork.</p><p>The pinnacle of team basketball was in the NCAA before the one-and-done era. Players and coaches had motivation towards a shared objective. What about leadership and time? Top coaches had 3–4 years to mold players to fit their program. Players listened to the coach and if they didn’t they would ride the pine. They couldn’t go pro and even transferring was extremely difficult and costly. They definitely couldn’t get the coach fired, not even if they were physically abused, which was known to happen. If players weren’t satisfied, they didn’t have many options. As a result, teamwork in college basketball exhibited very high levels of <em>trust, discipline and coordination.</em> [11]</p><p>Basketball will be better for youth development and better for society if it is more team-oriented. Of course, the Two Quarter Restriction doesn’t automatically increase teamwork, but it does do two things. First, it becomes more difficult to win with just raw talent. Franchises can still try to build super teams but since each superstar is only eligible for two quarters, it requires more star power. The salary cap makes this less feasible. Second, the existence of the team beyond the individual is explicit. Whereas now, players have been known to resent the coach if they don’t start. Some players get upset when they feel they don’t get enough minutes. After all, playing time and shot attempts are limited. So if their teammates get more, they get less. Rivalry becomes animosity. To deal with it, coaches spend time managing egos at the cost of coaching basketball. The Two Quarter Restriction puts every player on the sideline for half the game. Then veterans have no reason not to observe rookies during the game and help them in practice. Is it crazy to expect a more cohesive locker room and even expect players to be better role models?</p><h3>2. <strong>Scoring by Quarters</strong> —</h3><p><em>Score tallied separately each quarter. The winner is decided not by which team has the most overall points, but by which team wins the most quarters. [12] If one team wins each of the first 3 quarters, the 4th quarter is superfluous and cancelled. Ties are resolved in overtime and, if necessary, sudden death (i.e. next bucket wins).</em></p><p><strong><em>Blowouts belong at Birthday parties</em></strong></p><p>Scoring by Quarters moderates blowouts in several ways. While blowouts may not be the biggest problem in the NBA, it is a real issue in youth leagues. Losing and failure can be great motivators to work hard and improve. However for kids, blowouts more often cause humiliation and quitting rather than internalization of valuable life lessons. A blowout can even make the better team perfunctory, arrogant or complacent and is no fun to watch. In short no one wins.</p><p>First, if a team wins the first three quarters, game over. There’s no opportunity to run up the score in the 4th quarter. One drawback, shortened games may upset fans. [13] On the other hand, under normal circumstances the 4th quarter would have been garbage time and many fans would file out early anyway. At least if the 4th quarter is cancelled it precludes the worst possibility of all, hearing the stadium roar as a team makes a huge comeback while being stuck outside the stadium unable to get back in. Shorter games may even appeal to the larger and growing, non-live, audience. I’m picturing the guy with the League Pass who watches 6–8 games per day. Or the other guy who only watches highlights on SportsCenter or YouTube. Or the other other guy who thinks basketball is too long and too boring. “There’s too many fouls and too many free throws!” Do you know these guys, too?</p><p>The second way is somewhat superficial. The number of points scored is obscured by the number of quarters won. For example, a girls’ high school game in Ohio from 2016, final score 108–1. Another girls’ high school game in California from 2015, final score 161–2. Instead the final score for both would be a more respectable 3–0.</p><p>Lastly, blowouts are moderated by the play of the game. If the game is clearly decided, the winning team often, though not always, refrains from running up a bigger lead. This primarily plays out in either of two ways. First, the coach may elect to play reserves. Depending on the size of the lead and the confidence of the coach, this normally happens in the fourth quarter. Second, the better team may run out the clock rather than try to score even if the other team has stopped defending. This usually happens only in the final minute. Basketball is a game of hot streaks and cold spells, so employing these tactics, both of which are considered marks of good sportsmanship, earlier in the game would be reckless. However, with Scoring by Quarter the moderating effects can take effect each quarter rather than only at the end of the game.</p><p>Stopping or reducing blow outs may be appropriate for high school and amateur leagues, but for professionals, there’s a credible argument that entertainment is more important than sportsmanship. Well, Scoring by Quarters is also much more entertaining.</p><p><strong><em>Entertainment = MoreCrunchtime^2</em></strong></p><p>Instead of boring games that start out slow with sloppy play only to get exciting in the 4th quarter’s crunch time, why not have crunch time every quarter? Finally the 1st, 2nd and 3rd quarter mean something. Everyone will be more focused from the opening tip and it will be more exciting for fans. [14]</p><p>To keep fans engaged in long games that feature lots of points, Scoring by Quarters is far superior. Perhaps this seems too alien or convoluted. After all, some tradition is worth preserving. And everything doesn’t need to be engineered for the shrinking attention span of today’s youth. Funny I never hear those issues raised about volleyball or tennis in which matches are decided by the best of 3 or 5 sets. Yet both are popular sports with a decidedly older and more conservative fanbase. Tennis even goes a step further. An average set has 60 points, so it’s divided into even shorter ‘games’. Imagine if the champion at Wimbledon was decided by who had the most points after 3 hours. I’m sleepy already.</p><p>What else is more entertaining? More overtime. And which is more likely to happen, the score is exactly tied at the end of the 4th quarter or the teams merely split the quarters? Overtime is then essentially a 5th quarter and it is logical to make the format the same as a regular quarter. [15] And what else? Ties at the end of a quarter’s regular time immediately trigger sudden death (i.e. next bucket wins). [16]</p><p>One last word about overtime and methods for resolving ties. The above method may not be best for every situation (i.e. NBA, NCAA, high school or youth, Regular games or playoffs). For example, the least competitive environment, regular games in a youth league may allow ties in both quarters and games. On the other hand, NBA playoffs can bar both. League administrators should consider the competitiveness as well as limitations on game duration. [17]</p><h3>3. <strong>Tiered Divisions with a Flat Draft</strong> —</h3><p><em>Three divisions based on win/loss record instead of 2 conferences based on geography. Final record determines promotion and relegation. Draft order descends by division and is random within division.</em></p><p>This change makes more compelling matches, while at the same time reduces tanking and improves player development. The first division has the ten best teams, second division has the 11–20th best teams and the third division has 21–30th best teams. Teams play a majority, but not all, of their games within their division against similar caliber teams. [18] The top 2 teams from the second and third division are promoted while the bottom 2 teams in the first and second division are relegated. [19] Draft picks are assigned randomly, one per team, with the first 10 picks assigned to the 3rd division, the second 10 picks to the 2nd division and the third 10 picks to the 1st division. [20] The end of season record has no effect on the draft order so there is no benefit to tank.</p><p>Tiered Divisions with a Flat Draft is a relatively large administrative change. Since upper and lower division teams have vastly different strength of schedule, end of season record is no longer a fair way to determine playoff seeding. [21] And divisions not based on geography may require traveling farther for matches. [22] These issues have simple and feasible solutions. Compared to the revenues involved in professional sports, any increased cost is negligible. And if it alleviates the problem of tanking and the lack of parity, it is a great bargain. A bigger hurdle may be convincing owners, especially those who anticipate landing in lower divisions and worry they will pay a steeper price. Or ensuring that a first division doesn’t sanctify super teams. These issues also have solutions but it is premature to go in detail now. [23]</p><p><strong><em>Compelling Matches</em></strong></p><p>One of the most common complaints from regular fans is that basketball is too boring. Seven foot monsters trying to stop fast breaks and alley-oops by the best athletes on the planet is not enough. “Games are too long and have too many fouls.” “The season is too long and most of the games are meaningless.” The lack of parity doesn’t help either. In each of the last several years, only 2–3 teams start the season with any real hope to win the championship. In 2018, it’s Warriors and Rockets. They’ll match up exactly 3 times during the regular season. Even those matches are not truly meaningful because teams are rarely at full strength and the main priority is getting into the playoffs. General basketball fans have little interest in the other 28 teams. The big storylines are which teams can do the best tank job, who will get MVP and which free agents will form the next super team. Non-basketball fans are unlikely to get drawn in. [24]</p><p>With new divisions, every regular season matchup between all 30 teams will be much more compelling. Divisions with Promotion and Relegation create real rewards for winning the division and punishment for losing. By design, the divisions will be competitive so winning or losing one additional game is likely to have implications. There will be fierce competition at the top of each division every year. Likewise, there will be fierce competition at the bottom of each division. Every internal division match will be meaningful. In short, it will never be safe to lose. Even external division matches will be interesting because they occur less frequently. Upper division teams will be challenged to sweep the lower divisions. Meanwhile, lower division teams can go for the upset. Or, when playing a team that previously induced their relegation, revenge.</p><p>Last but not least, promotion and relegation will have a strong motivational effect. Besides the intrinsic drama concerning which teams will move up and down, coaches and players will care more and try harder. The game will be that much more exciting.</p><p><strong><em>Distrust the Process</em></strong></p><p>Tanking is arguably the biggest problem in today’s NBA. The current draft format creates an incentive to lose and undermines the integrity of the sport. Changes to the lottery, taking effect in 2019, are in the pipe. It should help though the draft will continue to reward teams for losing.</p><p>This largely removes the incentive to lose. Since the draft is completely random within each division, there is no short term benefit. Tanking from an upper division lands teams in a lower division which increases the value of a draft pick in the future. However, the pick may not be significantly more valuable. For example, if a first division team considers tanking to get a higher draft pick, best case scenario is to get the #11 pick instead of #30 after waiting more than a year, though it might improve only from #21 to #20.</p><p>By directly punishing losers, relegation changes everything. Players, presumably, care about pride and prestige. Relegation will devastate both. Fans, presumably, want to see the best players play the best basketball and see the home team win. Relegation means fewer All-Stars coming to town and a longer, harder road to a championship. Owners, presumably, want to make money. Relegation means less gate revenue, less concessions and merchandise sales, less TV money [25] and a lower business valuation.</p><p>If the long term cost is worse than what is now only a short term cost, will anyone still trust the process? A first division team has only a 10% chance to tank, get a #1 pick, then return to the first division within 4 years. Getting consecutive #1 picks (like the 76ers in 2016–17, or Cavaliers in 2013–14) has odds of 1% and requires at least 5 years. Lower odds of a guaranteed top pick will be a deterrent to tanking, but so is the time and effort to get back to the first division. Rebuilds that take 4–5 years or more will be inherently unstable because rookie contracts eventually expire and free agents can get poached. [26] Bottom line: Luck in the draft will not turn poorly managed franchises into championship contenders. Instead it requires good coaching, focus on fundamentals, a culture of teamwork and a commitment to excellence. All things anathema to the tankers.</p><p><strong><em>Turn Back the Clock with Player Development</em></strong></p><p>Few of today’s rookies are prepared for the NBA. The draft has been getting younger for a long time. The ‘one-and-done’ rule implemented in 2005 had no affect on the trend. In 2017, 16 freshmen were drafted in the first round versus 5 juniors and seniors. In 1987, the first round of the draft had two juniors. The rest were all seniors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XNcdJm8TiWXQdxnQzIv3Vw.png" /></figure><p>It’s not obvious why this is happening. Are younger players getting better? High school and amateur leagues may be getting more competitive. Athletes may be training more. Has the game changed to give younger players a competitive advantage? Play has evolved towards more floor spacing, ball movement and a faster tempo. Meanwhile the physicality and hip checking of the 80’s and 90’s may have disadvantaged younger players. But this cannot fully explain the trend. The draft has been getting younger pushing down the average age in the league, but the top players are staying the same age.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hTw9bXQnBd47QkCn3hiGUQ.png" /></figure><p>Drafting and developing young players conflicts with assembling the best possible team. Young players coming into the league push out veterans who better deserve to be in the NBA. Frankly, it is impossible to accurately assess the potential of 19–20 year old kids. Bodies are growing and athleticism is changing. Not to mention social and psychological development or susceptibility to injury. Yet every team is investing millions of dollars in unproven youth, many of whom clearly will not contribute for years, if ever. Teams must have between 13–15 players on a roster. It may seem like a lot. The season is long, players get hurt. A healthy team needs 1–2 backups at each position.</p><p>While the league is drafting more and more young players, they are less and less willing to develop them. The NBA is not designed for player development. Partly because top draft picks demand huge salaries that cannot be supported by the G-League. But also because within 1–2 years the same players will be cut to make room for the next batch. Basketball is so dependent on superstars that teams are following a venture capitalist model for success. Even if 90% of the drafted players get cut in 1–2 years, the chance to get LeBron James or Kobe Bryant makes up for all the busts. The biggest losers are the veterans who get cut because franchises bet that a 6’10” teenager grows a few more inches or an athletic freak from the developing world develops passable footwork and a jump shot. Owners end up paying a premium for sub-par talent. For fans, the NBA is not the best possible group of players. If there are any winners, it must be the influx of young players who get a few million guaranteed before retiring in their early 20’s. On the other hand, if those same players earn a college degree, their lifetime earning potential may be somewhat less though they are less likely to be bankrupt at 30.</p><p>Relegation will make it more important to put together the best team possible. Teams will be less willing to cut proven veterans for immature rookies. Therefore, young players must do more, either more in school or in development leagues, to earn their place. And with 3 divisions, the best young players who do end up getting drafted will land in the third division. The competition will be slightly lower and there will be less pressure. Lower draft picks go to better teams in upper divisions but likely end up on G-League affiliates. For all rookies, it enables an easier transition to the professional ranks. Within a few years, rookies will develop and eventually find their way to the upper division either via trade, free agency or promotion.</p><p><strong><em>One Team’s Trash is Another Team’s Title</em></strong></p><p>A division title is a meaningless consolation prize. The championship is rightly the most important goal. However, beyond qualifying for the playoffs, fighting up in the standings for a better playoff seeding is a marginal and perishable benefit. Whereas sliding down has a longer-term benefit and is easier to boot. Any team that is good enough to win a division should have ambitions to win the championship. So division titles more likely represent dashed hopes. Franchises like the Lakers, Celtics and Spurs have more than 20 division titles. At best, a division banner makes a good decoration inside an arena. But the value is degraded that not even less successful franchises are proud of the achievement.</p><p>Promotion and relegation make division titles important and significant. Less successful franchises, like Memphis or Charlotte, can be proud of division titles which signify their qualification to upper divisions. For the most successful franchises, like the Lakers and Celtics, rather than rack up division title year after year, they can save space in the rafters for the championship banners they really want. And even when these teams win titles in the lower divisions, the banners tell an important part of history.</p><h3><strong><em>Notes:</em></strong></h3><p>[0] Haikus to inspire the NCAA’s Commission on College Basketball. Unfortunately their proposal doesn’t do enough.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KMpXBTcuPN319GSiDltweg.png" /></figure><p>[1] The NBA page on ESPN’s website literally has a category called “Tank Race”!</p><p>[2] Corporate sponsorship turns out to be an effective fix for egregious doublespeak. In this case, thank Gatorade. By the way, G-League salaries are more than last year in which players designated Tier C earned, believe it or not, a pitiful $13,000. That’s per season, not per game.</p><p>[3] Is it a coincidence that now, as international leagues are getting traction as viable alternatives to the NCAA, there is finally talk about reviewing the rule?</p><p>[4] A priori proof:</p><p>A. High level coaches and athletic directors are surely two of the most cutthroat and competitive demographics on the planet.</p><p>B. Top universities give them millions of dollars and a mandate to win. Or get fired.</p><p>C. The most reliable way to win is to recruit the most talented high schoolers, many of whom are poor.</p><p>D. Ipso facto, money gets dirty, cheating is normalized, integrity is penalized.</p><p>[5] Disclosure of the starting lineup can be done in various ways. For example, to increase home-court advantage, the visiting team could submit the starting lineup 30 minutes before tip-off. Alternatively, there may be no advance disclosure.</p><p>[6] There are socially acceptable justifications for a gap in wealth and income. Some people work harder or more hours. Some people have unique or special skills and knowledge. Some people are more willing to take risks. This is all considered fair. Luck, as long as it is non-discriminatory, is ok too. Income inequality is socially unacceptable to the extent it is unfair. For example, if people are rich due to rule-breaking or poor due to lack of opportunity. So the problem of income inequality is not a gap between what rich and poor <em>have</em>, but a gap between what people <em>have</em> and what they deserve.</p><p>[7] Staying healthy and avoiding injury is a critical and under-appreciated factor that determines success in the playoffs.</p><p>[8] Talent over teamwork is also the modus operandi for street ball. It is notable that this strategy requires very little coaching.</p><p>[9] Is it a coincidence that the only NBA team that consistently has a different philosophy, San Antonio Spurs, is well-known for using international players?</p><p>[10] Again, San Antonio is the outlier here. Gregg Popovich is in his 22nd season. Only 2 other coaches have finished more than 6 seasons on their current team. I’m tempted to make connections here between the tenure, salary and relative responsibilities for coaches in the NBA and NFL. It’s a fact that NFL coaches are paid more and enjoy longer tenure than in the NBA. Is that explained partly because football is more strategic and puts more leadership responsibility on the coach?</p><p>[11] I’m not defending coaches who abuse players. The best teamwork is founded on mutual respect. My point is that teamwork requires motivation towards a shared objective, leadership and time to build trust, discipline and coordination. Traditionally those conditions were more present in elite college programs than the NBA.</p><p>[12] Obviously this isn’t directly applicable for NCAA (or other leagues) that play 2 halves rather than 4 quarters. In those cases I advocate changing to quarters to get the benefits outlined in this article.</p><p>[13] An analog in boxing would be an early round KO. This doesn’t upset fans because, despite being short, it can still be exciting. While gambling contributes to the excitement, what would be the alternative? The superior fighter giving less than 100% just to make the fight longer. Who wants to see that? Back to basketball, maybe something akin to an undercard would be appropriate to fill out the evening. For example, a G-league game, dunk contest or more cheerleader action.</p><p>[14] Blow outs even get more exciting. Resetting the score at the beginning of each quarter reinvigorates what would otherwise be a rout in the 1st quarter.</p><p>[15] “Quarter” may no longer be the most appropriate term though I’ll continue to use it to minimize confusion and honor tradition.</p><p>[16] A tied score silences the buzzer. The clock stops yet the action and shot clock continue uninterrupted. The next point breaks the tie and concludes the quarter (or game). Alternatively, sudden death could require a 2-point or 3-point lead so games are not decided by one or two free throws. This shouldn’t be too crazy either since it’s also already a regular feature in volleyball and tennis.</p><p>[17] Another method allows ties in regular quarters but not in overtime. Or it may be suitable to skip overtime and enter sudden death at the end of the 4th quarter. This last method may be suitable for competitive games that face strict time limitations. Such as an AAU tournament that schedules multiple games on the same court.</p><p>[18] To be fair and ensure the right teams get promoted and relegated, game schedules must consider the division and have some symmetry. Below is one proposal that keeps the same number of games. For each team, the chart details the number of games against teams in each division. For example, a 1st division team has fifty-four 1st division matchups, twenty 2nd division matches and 8 games against 3rd division teams. That includes three home and three away against each of the nine 1st division rivals, a home and away against each 2nd division team. (Technically, this proposal has 2nd division teams play a plurality, not a majority, of their games within their division.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bJRHERmC2OLadJvTvKLWWw.png" /></figure><p>External division matches could potentially impact the standings more or less than internal division matches. For example, beating a 1st division team could be worth more than beating a 3rd division team. Though this is probably a needless complication.</p><p>[19] The number of teams selected for promotion and relegation, N, is a free variable. Ideally, N is tuned to the speed at which competitiveness of teams changes. In other words, promoted teams should actually be better than the relegated teams they replace. Otherwise, whether N is too high or too low, divisional tiers will not be properly stratified. As an initial condition, N=2 seems appropriate though it is subject to fine-tuning.</p><p>[20] In other words, each 3rd division team has one lottery ball with a 10% probability for pick 1–10. Each 2nd division team has one lottery ball for pick 11–20. Each 1st division team has one lottery ball for pick 21–30. It should be specified that the lottery transpires at the end of the season before promotion and relegation. The teams that won the 3rd division and are entering 2nd division get a top 10 pick (potentially #1). At the same time, the teams that fell out of the 2nd division will not get a top 10 pick until after playing the first season in the 3rd division. The design is to benefit the promoted team, encourage upward mobility and circulation between divisions. The alternative, a draft after promotion and relegation, is more likely to see some teams bounce back and forth and others become entrenched. Another consideration is about trading future draft picks. Generally there is a clear long-term sacrifice for short-term gain, or vice-versa. The league should be regulated such that short-term and long-term interests are aligned. If trading future draft picks negatively impacts competition, the practice should be barred.</p><p>[21] The easiest alternative that retains the current 4-round 16-team format would be to seed all upper division teams 1–10, then seed the top six 2nd division teams 11–16. However, since winning the upper division can’t result in promotion, a first round bye is a reasonable reward for finishing atop the upper division. Any byes automatically mean more rounds or less teams. In which case, the top 2 teams in the upper division get a first round bye and only the top 4 teams in the second division make the cut. More tinkering with the playoffs would probably preclude 7-game series, at least in the first round. Fans won’t miss the 1 seed vs. 8 seed series which is largely a waste of time. The qualifying players and coaches will appreciate the rest. Still the decisive factor may be whether owners value rest for their players over the lost revenue from an easy first round matchup.</p><p>[22] Short of reducing the number of games, the costs can be offset in other ways.</p><p>A. 2-game stands. Basically a rematch at the same venue either as a back-to-back or after a day’s rest.</p><p>B. An idea further out of the box is the round robin. Four teams go to a city for three consecutive double headers (i.e. each team plays one game Friday, Saturday, Sunday). It will be a novel experience for fans. If every city hosts, then no one loses a home game. At least from the perspective of fans and owners. Coaches and players would disagree. Local fans are most passionate about the local team, though it would also be novel to see a game that doesn’t feature the local team. Meanwhile, more fans of the away teams will travel in support if they can settle into a new city to see their team play 3 games instead of only 1. Alternatively, the round robin could be perfect for neutral venues. In recent years, the NBA has been aggressively trying to grow foreign markets. Regular season matches have been staged in Japan, Mexico City and London. Pre-season matches have been held all over. With skyrocketing demand in China, typically 2 teams play in Shanghai with a rematch in Beijing a few days later. With 4 teams on the road, they don’t even need to stay in the same city. Instead arrange round robins as mini tours hitting 3 or 6 cities in Asia (i.e. Tokyo, Seoul, Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Chengdu). Or Europe (i.e. London, Barcelona, Paris, Berlin, Rome, Belgrade). The demand is there.</p><p>C. Split each 10-team division in half roughly geographically (i.e. East, West). This recreates the current six 5-team divisions. There are potential benefits but this would compromise the effectiveness of the new divisions.</p><p>[23] Players’ loyalty is put to the test during free agency. A player will have more loyalty to a team that invested in his development. Especially if he contributed to their promotion. Of course, players will never have loyalty to poorly managed teams. Why should they? The best outcome is not that players always choose to re-sign with the incumbent but to sign with the franchise that is most competent. If bigger markets can attract the best coaches and best management, certain teams may still have an advantage (i.e. Lakers, Celtics, Rockets). But it is not inevitable (i.e. New York Knicks). Some other rule changes are possible to ensure the rules benefit well-managed teams. For example, contracts with team options effective on promotion.</p><p>[24] Does experimentation with the 2018 All Star format indicate the league’s awareness that it is less entertaining than it ought to be? Innovation is important and necessary. But basketball should be entertaining on its own merit. Novelty for novelty’s sake or reliance on gimmicks is not a good sign.</p><p>[25] Should upper division teams get higher proportion of TV money? Maybe. If a franchise consistently fields a superior team, why shouldn’t the franchise, owners and entire city benefit from a better stadium, better training facilities, even a higher salary cap? But maybe not. The purpose of multiple divisions is to punish tanking. Sanctioning differences in financial resources risks entrenching teams in a division. Some tweaking may be necessary to ensure fair and appropriate incentives all around.</p><p>[26] There are rules in place to prevent teams poaching free agents. Does anyone argue that the current rules are effective? While it may be undesirable for big market teams to easily poach the best players, it is equally undesirable for poorly managed teams to squander talent. Ideally, player movement is from poorly managed teams to well managed teams. Towards that end, a few things that should be considered. What if rookies can sign longer contracts with the team that drafted them? What if free agents can sign longer contracts with third division teams? What if players can only be traded to teams in the same division?</p><p>[27] Table only includes first round picks and excludes international players who did not play in NCAA.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9727c4e7be03" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>