<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Paul Vittles on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Paul Vittles on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@paulvittles?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 01:21:40 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@paulvittles/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Suicide and Suicide Prevention — the Numbers, the Human Tragedy Behind the Numbers, and Staying…]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/suicide-and-suicide-prevention-the-numbers-the-human-tragedy-behind-the-numbers-and-staying-e7a030956cf3?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e7a030956cf3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-prevention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[training]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jan 2025 06:33:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-17T15:34:17.253Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Suicide and Suicide Prevention — the Numbers, the Human Tragedy Behind the Numbers, and Staying Hopeful.</h3><h4>Latest results from the MEL Research Tracking Survey, in the context of trying to maintain hope in the face of rising suicide rates.</h4><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>For the past decade in the UK, suicide prevention advocates &amp; campaigners like myself have been highlighting the fact we’ve had “<em>more than 6,000 preventable deaths by suicide each year, and the numbers aren’t going down</em>”.</p><p>Sadly, it’s getting worse — the numbers are going up.</p><p>After sharp increases in suicides 2022–2023 in Scotland (4%), England &amp; Wales (7.6%) and Northern Ireland (8%), the number of suicide deaths in the UK in 2023 actually exceeded 7,000, and suicide rates were back to the levels being recorded in the 1990s.</p><p>Here’s the picture for England &amp; Wales:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mIt2dxs_2qcMHxDo7BIraQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Since the long-term downward trend in the suicide numbers halted in 2007, we’ve had more than 100,000 preventable suicide deaths in the UK, representing a human catastrophe, especially as there are 135 people directly touched by each suicide death (Cerel et al, SBUK) so that’s more than 13.5 million people affected from those 100,000+ deaths.</p><p>And in analysis carried out by the London School of Economics (LSE) for Samaritans, published in 2024, preventable suicide deaths cost the economy £10 billion each year, so the total cost of preventable suicide deaths since the downward trend halted in 2007 is now £170 billion.</p><p>No-one can claim ‘we can’t afford to invest in suicide prevention’ with such an obvious financial case and potential return on investment.</p><p>And most of us not in positions of power &amp; influence, especially those of us whose lives have been directly affected by suicide loss and/or suicide crisis, would probably conclude ‘we can’t afford not to’!</p><p>In 2023, more than 6,000 suicides were registered just in England &amp; Wales, with a suicide rate (per 100,000 population) that’s the highest since 1999.</p><p>It makes it hard to be hopeful sometimes but hope is exactly what we need, and what people who are struggling need, and what suicide prevention advocates &amp; campaigners need to keep going.</p><p>I’ve worked in suicide prevention since 2013 (my personal lived experience of suicide goes back 40 years — losing 15 blokes in our community in Teesside in the early 1980s who had no prior history of mental ill-health but who lost their jobs, with no prospect of finding another job close to their family and support network, and who lost hope).</p><p>It’s hard when you put your heart and soul into trying to get the suicide numbers down and can see the numbers aren’t coming down…and, worse, see the trend line going up.</p><p>It’s why I’ve worked collaboratively with many partners during that time to try and find breakthroughs, and will continue to do so — wherever there appears to be some common ground on mission, vision, ambition, values, and approach, along with joint understanding of and commitment to transformational change.</p><p>It’s why we organised the JoinTheDotsTour from the Humber to the Mersey, 11–23 June 2024, with 19 major events across 15 towns &amp; cities in 2 weeks, and 40 public education talks…</p><p><a href="https://nspa.org.uk/news/insights-and-learnings-from-the-zero-suicide-society-humber-to-mersey-tour/">Learnings from the Zero Suicide Society Humber-to-Mersey Tour</a></p><p>…with a follow-up mini-Tour of the North West (Blackpool, Warrington, Wigan, Bury) around World Suicide Prevention Day in September.</p><p>It’s why I’m now now working on several transformation projects with some established partners and several new partners.</p><p>It’s why I established the for-purpose business, Towards Zero Suicide CIC, to be 100% dedicated to creating and sustaining a Zero Suicide Society — “<em>a society that is willing and able to do all it can to prevent all preventable suicides</em>” — and to getting the (UK) suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero suicide.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AqfjKU72q3-fSpRrxepjHQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Towards Zero Suicide banners that have been travelling around the country supporting educational talks &amp; workshops and transformational change initiatives — with the Zero Suicide Society model &amp; framework on the left and key messages for education, advocacy &amp; campaigning on the right.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The MEL Research Tracking Survey</strong></p><p>In 2022, whilst I was working with The Jordan Legacy (as a mentor, coach, consultant, facilitator &amp; collaborative partner) on ways to make a difference, I liaised with national research agency MEL Research, and formed a new collaborative partnership to set up a new national tracking survey among a representative sample of the UK population to plug key data gaps and gather metrics on suicide and suicide prevention as well as mental health.</p><p>Governments often carry out major national surveys on these issues every 7 years through surveys like the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey (APMS), and that says a lot about the government’s commitment, or rather the lack of it, on suicide prevention.</p><p>MEL Research was as enthusiastic as it was professional in stepping in to plug the key data gaps, and I worked with them — as a Research Fellow as well as a suicide prevention ‘subject expert’ — including designing the questions and analytical framework, and producing summary reports.</p><p>We set up what is now the MEL Research Tracking Survey to be a twice-a-year survey (Spring and Autumn) among a representative sample of 1,500 adults across the UK.</p><p>MEL Research manages the survey fieldwork and analysis, produces an executive report with summary charts and slides, and provides the data to myself, from which I write reports like this one.</p><p>And MEL Research has also ‘democratised the data’ by making it available via a public portal.</p><p>MEL Research should be applauded for doing this, especially for doing it pro bono.</p><p>The latest wave of the Tracking Survey took place 23 Oct to 7 Nov 2024 among a representative sample of 1,707 UK adults (aged 16+).</p><p>So, let’s look at what the data from this enormously important tracking survey is telling us.</p><p><strong>SURVEY RESULTS SUMMARY</strong></p><p>[Note: if quoting the survey results, please give the source as the MEL Research Tracking Survey]</p><p><strong>Thoughts of Suicide, Suicide Plans &amp; Suicide Attempts</strong></p><p>In the most recent wave of the tracking survey, 2 in 5 UK adults say they’ve had thoughts about taking their own life at some point, with around half of these saying they’ve ‘seriously considered’ suicide.</p><p>1 in 9 say they’ve progressed to making a plan to end their life.</p><p>1 in 16 say they’ve made a suicide attempt.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vCakwE17hEm4ITRSnwaXHQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,700 UK adults aged 16+ in Spring 2024 and Autumn 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>These figures have been highly consistent over the 6 waves of the tracking survey, including the proportion saying they’ve made a suicide attempt being 6% in each of the three most recent independent sample surveys:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OjFbK_zi_WgINmSzjNt1RQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500+ UK adults aged 16+ in each wave of the tracking survey)</figcaption></figure><p>The tracking survey enables us to identify which particular sub-groups of the population are more likely to be reporting that they’re having thoughts of suicide.</p><p>One ‘group’ that stands out are unemployed people — 1 in 3 (35%) say they’ve seriously considered ending their life, almost twice the norm for the population as a whole.</p><p>Another ‘group’ is people who identify as neurodivergent.</p><p>2 in 5 (42%) say they’ve ‘seriously considered’ suicide; 1 in 4 (25%) say they’ve progressed to making a plan to end their life; and 1 in 7 (14%) say they’ve made a suicide attempt — so more than twice as likely as the population as a whole to make a suicide plan or suicide attempt.</p><p>Btw, I’ve put ‘group’ in inverted commas here because researchers and statisticians tend to refer to ‘groups’ within population data — and National Strategies often refer to ‘priority groups’ — but, of course, these are not neat, homogenous groups.</p><p>Indeed, people who are neurodivergent are, by definition, diverse, and people who are unemployed are disempowered and often ignored due to the fact they’re not an organised group but a collection of individuals facing their own independent struggles, often alone, which amplifies their suicide risk.</p><p>We need national and local strategies, action plans, and tailored support for all those people who are struggling — or as we say in the Zero Suicide Society model: ‘everyone must be a priority for someone’!</p><p><strong>Mental Health</strong></p><p>As we’d expect, people with poor mental health are significantly more likely to consider suicide and progress to a suicide plan or suicide attempt although, perhaps more surprisingly, the number of people reporting that their mental health is poor has been relatively low in recent surveys — 13% in the most recent wave in Autumn 2024:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ab2JScIq24ZEE_caM8xijg.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500+ UK adults aged 16+ in each wave of the tracking survey)</figcaption></figure><p>Importantly, however, the number of UK adults saying they’ve “<em>experienced mental health issues needing treatment or support</em>” in the past 12 months has remained at around 1 in 6 (16% in Autumn 2024).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lUKpCHHWXqT9OaAvkwXbgQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500+ UK adults aged 16+ in each wave of the tracking survey)</figcaption></figure><p>Twice as likely as the population as a whole to say they’ve experienced mental health issues that needed treatment or support in the past 12 months are disabled people, people with poor physical health, and those serving in the armed forces (32% in each case, compared with the 16% ‘norm’).</p><p>Again, all of these ‘groups’ and all of the individuals within these ‘groups’ who are struggling need suitable support in an integrated, co-operative collaborative approach not a competitive ‘priority group’ based system.</p><p>In addition to those personally experiencing mental health issues, many more know someone experiencing mental health issues that needed treatment or support:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ttiC178gh9fcoJwN9usc_w.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,700 UK adults aged 16+ surveyed in Autumn 2024)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Exposure to Suicide</strong></p><p>As well as having around 2 in 3 of the population exposed to mental health struggles (their own or others), around 2 in 3 have had exposure to suicide, including 28% of UK adults who’ve known someone who’s died by suicide and 1 in 8 (12%) who’ve lost a close friend or family member to suicide:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*em18fVcw68sp0_uT4rRsLw.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,700 UK adults aged 16+ surveyed in Autumn 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>These numbers have been very consistent over the last 4 waves of the tracking survey:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J8oYj-WM16aufU3rbguBhw.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500+ UK adults aged 16+ in each wave of the tracking survey)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Information, Education &amp; Learning</strong></p><p>The most prevalent source is websites such as Mind or Samaritans (33% say they’ve learned about mental health and/or suicide this way) but also significant are listening to and learning from lived experience, and training.</p><p>1 in 7 say they’ve “<em>learned from listening to someone who has had suicidal thoughts or experienced a suicide crisis</em>” (14%) and 1 in 8 say they’ve “<em>learned from listening to someone who has lost someone to suicide</em>” (12%).</p><p>In each case, the numbers could be a lot higher of course.</p><p>1 in 6 say they’ve “<em>attended a training course on mental health, such as Mental Health First Aid</em>” (16%) and 1 in 12 say they’ve “<em>attended a training course in suicide awareness or prevention, such as ASIST or Suicide First Aid</em>” (8%).</p><p>Again, in each case, the numbers could be a lot higher.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FXxvqx696J8gLTXnWAvTDQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,700+ UK adults aged 16+ in the Spring 2024 and Autumn 2024 waves of the survey)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Talking about Suicide, Spotting the Signs, and Signposting</strong></p><p>More than half the population (55%) are not confident about “<em>how to best ask someone if they are having suicidal thoughts</em>” and large numbers lack confidence in “<em>how to best continue the conversation if someone says they are thinking about suicide</em>” (47% not confident), “<em>how to spot the signs that someone is at risk of suicide</em>” (43%), and “<em>where to go to get training in suicide awareness and prevention</em>” (49%).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O6Z8yiMPuB03bTK0G2P89Q.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,700 UK adults aged 16+ surveyed in Autumn 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>Confidence levels are also low for “<em>where to direct someone for support if they are at risk of suicide</em>” (42% not confident), “<em>where to get information about suicide and suicide prevention</em>” (35%), “<em>how to spot the signs that someone might be struggling with their mental health</em>” (40%), and “<em>where you could get support if you were struggling with your own mental health</em>” (33%).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-TVZ0CVo1IcxGeJjYyUjSQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,700 UK adults aged 16+ surveyed in Autumn 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>The chart below has trend lines for the % confident in starting or continuing conversations about suicide, and how to ‘spot the signs’ along with the % saying they’ve attended training.</p><p>For having mental health training, there’s been a significant increase over the life of the tracking survey, from 10% in Autumn 2022 to 16% in Autumn 2024, although it’s still only 1 in 6 of the population.</p><p>For having suicide prevention training, there hasn’t been a significant increase and it remains very low at just 1 in 12 of the population.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*N6CnLL639ls78nJiZQdCjQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500+ UK adults aged 16+ in each wave of the tracking survey)</figcaption></figure><p>This is both a huge problem and a huge opportunity, as training is a obvious route to helping facilitate life-saving conversations.</p><p>The chart below shows very clearly what impact attending training has on confidence in starting and continuing conversations about suicide, spotting signs, and knowing where to direct people to for support:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nz_FVaKbJDFZFuijMP8VQw.png" /><figcaption>Source: Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,700 UK adults aged 16+ surveyed in Autumn 2024)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles FMRS is a Research Fellow, consultant, coach &amp; counsellor, Founder of Towards Zero Suicide CIC, and Chief Facilitator of the Zero Suicide Society JoinTheDots Transformation Programme.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul has personal lived experience of suicide loss and suicide crisis.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul was also Tour Director for the pioneering Zero Suicide Society Humber-to-Mersey JoinTheDotsTour, 11–23 June 2024, which comprised 19 major events across 15 towns &amp; cities in that 2-week period, and more than 40 public education talks.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The Tour included a ground-breaking Launch Conference at The Baths Hall in Scunthorpe, with a never-seen-before breadth of coverage of the many causes of and contributory factors for suicide, and 2 in 3 of the speakers &amp; panellists being people with lived experience of suicide.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*bfzyc9w5zE46j-o490CvtQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e7a030956cf3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Gaining an Understanding of Loss (& Grief & Trauma & Traumatic Loss)]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/gaining-an-understanding-of-loss-grief-trauma-traumatic-loss-31c037b792f4?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31c037b792f4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grief]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Dec 2024 08:36:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-08T08:36:07.527Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>This is a piece I’ve been writing over several months and I’m publishing it on Sunday 8 December at the end of National Grief Awareness Week 2024, after a series of LinkedIn posts covering different perspectives on loss &amp; grief.</h4><p>When I do my talks &amp; workshops on “<strong><em>Gaining An Understanding of Loss</em></strong>”, I emphasise two key points in particular:</p><p>1) there are many different types of loss experience.</p><p>Most people’s education and understanding tends to be very narrow and limited to their own personal experience.</p><p>2) every loss &amp; grief experience is very personal — in fact, unique.</p><p>You can help and support, empathise and sympathise, research and try to understand…but you can never have someone else’s experience.</p><p>Depending on how long I have for my talk or workshop — from a 30 minute conference keynote to a full-day workshop — I summarise what I’ve learned from my professional work as a researcher, consultant, coach &amp; counsellor (with an Advanced Study Major in Loss &amp; Grief as part of my Counselling Diploma), and from my own personal (multiple) experiences of loss, grief, trauma, and traumatic loss.</p><p>The feedback suggests that many people get a lot out of these talks &amp; workshops, and different people get different things out of them.</p><p>Again, it’s personal!</p><p>I also cover the relationship between loss &amp; trauma and suicide risk.</p><p>Sadly, anyone who experiences any form of loss or trauma is more likely to have thoughts of ending their life.</p><p>It’s especially common for those losing loved ones — no matter how they’ve died — to have thoughts of ‘wanting to be with them’.</p><p>For some people, this passes quickly; for some it’s a lingering thought; for some it’s a regular recurring thought for the rest of their lives; and for some it can lead to a plan to end their life, even following through on their plan and taking steps to end their life.</p><p>Anyone who experiences any form of traumatic loss is at a heightened risk of making a suicide plan and following through on that plan.</p><p>And ‘traumatic loss’ can take many forms, eg suicide, murder, losing a child in a preventable accident, losing a baby, an ‘unexplained death’, losing a lifelong partner to a ‘sudden natural death’ or losing a loved one to a long slow decline in their physical or mental health.</p><p>Again, it’s a personal experience and every experience is unique.</p><p>And every painful loss is exactly that — a painful loss for those affected.</p><p>It’s important that we show universal kindness and compassion for those who are grieving, and not diminish anyone else’s loss &amp; grief experience.</p><p><strong>Healthy Peer Support and Unhealthy Comparative Loss</strong></p><p>As I discovered when I started training and practising as a counsellor, there’s a tendency for people who experience ‘traumatic loss’ to think or believe that their loss experience is worse than other people’s loss.</p><p>Like most cases of comparison in our lives, this is usually — ultimately — not a healthy thought, for either those having such thoughts or for the many people hearing or seeing such thoughts expressed.</p><p>As my friend Chukes Maxwell says “<em>there’s no hierarchy in suffering</em>”.</p><p>As I heard Amelia Wrighton put it when she spoke at the ‘Let’s Talk About Suicide Lancashire’ Conference on 2 October 2024 in Blackpool, this is not “<em>The Grief Olympics</em>”!</p><p>And as many others express it, especially when they’ve reflected on their own loss &amp; grief journey including what helps others and what harms others, “<em>Bereavement is not a competition</em>”.</p><p>But everyone has to work through their own personal unique loss &amp; grief journey, work through their own personal unique experience of trauma, or work through their own personal unique experience of traumatic loss, with appropriate support along the way — if they are open to seeking such support…and not everyone is of course.</p><p>Also, what’s ‘appropriate’ differs from person to person, and it changes over time as their needs, circumstances and preferences change.</p><p>This can mean going through a phase where ‘comparison’ appears to be helping; thinking or believing that ‘your loss’ or your ‘form of loss’ is worse than other people’s loss or form of loss; gravitating to other people who’ve had the most similar types of loss experience as yourself rather than different loss experiences, including specific peer support services, networks or communities that appear to understand what you’re going through, and sometimes including people who reinforce your belief that you’re experiencing ‘the worst type of loss’.</p><p>It can also be the reverse experience, ie meeting people who’ve had traumatic loss experiences that you think are much worse than yours.</p><p>This is still a ‘comparative’ and even ‘competitive’ mindset which is often unhealthy, and can be a barrier to moving forward with your ‘grief process’ and moving forward with your life.</p><p>It’s highly complex, it’s highly sensitive, it’s highly personal.</p><p>Kindness and compassion also comes in many forms, including the ability to respect everyone’s unique personal experience of loss without feeling the need to compare experiences or create hierarchies of loss or ‘bereavement competitions’.</p><p>You might even feel that you have ‘objective’ data or evidence to ‘prove’ that you’ve experienced ‘the worst kind of loss’ — I’ll address this issue later — but there’s only ever one ‘worst type of loss’…and that’s the loss that you’ve experienced, or the loss you’re experiencing right now!</p><p><strong>It’s Personal As Well As Professional For Me Too!</strong></p><p>In my talks &amp; workshops on “<strong><em>Gaining an Understanding of Loss</em></strong>”, I open up about my own personal experiences of loss &amp; grief, including traumatic loss, and this helps others to open up.</p><p>My first ever memory of loss was my Granddad dying when I was very young.</p><p>I wept buckets without understanding why, and I was left on my own in the bedroom, and it was never talked about again.</p><p>I didn’t go to his funeral and never got the chance to grieve, so all that was stored up for later, as was the case with so many people of my generation.</p><p>More deaths followed, including my first experience of suicide loss in 1980, and losing 15 blokes to suicide in our community in Teesside — none of them with any prior history of mental ill-health, all victims of an ideological government policy which systemically de-hoped communities.</p><p>No-one talked about suicide, as those were the times, we just talked about what ‘Thatcher’ had done to our communities.</p><p>When Margaret Thatcher died in 2013, old industrial communities like ours in Teesside turned out in their 1000s…to be able to turn their back on her coffin!</p><p>This was part of the grieving process, and ‘closure’ for some, just as many of us bonded in our angry grief by listening to Elvis Costello’s Tramp The Dirt Down.</p><p>Even in 2013, there was little conversation about suicide.</p><p>I’d just started working in suicide prevention, after experiencing my own suicide crisis, in a series of events triggered by the death of my Dad in 2010, which hit me much harder than I expected.</p><p>I’d set up a new business in Australia in January 2010, after getting dual citizenship in 2009, and already made two trips to the UK, including in April when my wife and I took Mam and Dad on a reflective tour of some significant places from our history, which was a big high.</p><p>A big low followed in July when Dad was diagnosed with cancer, and the rapid decline in his health was traumatic, partly as I was living 12,000 miles away and my parents didn’t do online communications so it was ‘phone calls and desperately trying to arrange my next trip over whilst struggling to keep my new business going.</p><p>I finally flew over in October, my Dad had wasted away with the cancer which was hugely shocking when I first walked in the house.</p><p>We had a birthday party for him which was a huge high, followed by the huge lows of saying my final goodbye, knowing I’d never see my Dad again, and then getting the confirmation he’d died 4 days later.</p><p>I didn’t use the term ‘trauma’ then but, on reflection, I now know how hugely traumatic that experience was for me, and my mum, and my sisters, and how it impacted on the wider family, and how it impacted on me, including spiralling into severe depression and then, due to a range of other factors, including my business struggling, a suicide crisis.</p><p>Having now had multiple trauma and loss experiences, and having now trained and practiced professionally as a counsellor specialising in Loss &amp; Grief, I can more easily recognise the signs and impacts — in clients, colleagues, peers, friends, family members and all those I come into contact with.</p><p>I’ve had many personal and professional conversations where trauma and loss experiences have surfaced which had previously been deeply buried in the sub-conscious, not acknowledged at the time or since for what they were, and the impacts not recognised, including the compounded effects and how the grieving process can open up and connect these multiple loss &amp; grief experiences.</p><p>I now do my talks and extended workshop sessions on “<strong><em>Gaining An Understanding of Loss</em></strong>” and, each time, I always get feedback from audiences and workshop participants that:</p><p>1) they weren’t aware of the many different types of loss experience we have which we don’t acknowledge and grieve for;</p><p>2) this realisation has helped them put their own life and work struggles into perspective.</p><p>And, as mentioned in the opening summary above, I cover the complex and sensitive topic of ‘comparative bereavement’.</p><p><strong>The Worst Kind of Loss?</strong></p><p>When I trained, qualified, and first practiced as a Loss &amp; Grief Counsellor, one of the hardest things for me was the constant stream of people telling me about their traumatic loss experiences, and saying:</p><p>“<em>My loss is the worst kind of loss</em>”.</p><p>I heard about so many awful tragic loss experiences, including suicide, murder, rape-murder, murder-suicide, loss of an only child in a car accident, cot death, miscarriage, ‘losing someone twice’, totally unexplained deaths of people appearing to be in peak health &amp; fitness, group death pacts…</p><p>…and it was very common to be told “<em>mine is the worst kind of loss</em>”.</p><p>In my broader counselling training, and my broader mental health training, I’d been taught about the damage comparing ourselves and our life &amp; work experiences with others can do, and to help those struggling to focus on their own situation not compare themselves with others.</p><p>But it was new to me to see and hear so many people experiencing loss &amp; grief to be comparing themselves with others and, at worst, treating bereavement as a competition.</p><p>In my work, it was — and still very much is — important to highlight peer group and peer community support options for people experiencing loss &amp; grief, as many people benefit tremendously from being connected to other people who’ve had similar experiences to them and, therefore. ‘understand what I’ve been through’.</p><p>But there are also dangers from ‘getting stuck in a bubble’, losing rather than gaining perspective, and not being able to move forward as a result.</p><p>There are also dangers in the ‘Toxic Positivity’ and ‘Toxic Cheerleading’ that characterise some unregulated or poorly facilitated peer groups or peer communities, or just informal conversations between bereaved people.</p><p>Just trying to give people streams of unconditional positivity, confirming every belief system and narrative they absorb in their grief, and unconditionally praising everything they say or do is not really kind, it’s usually not helpful in the long-term, and it can be harmful.</p><p>Many of the people constantly giving these positive affirmations are doing it more for their own comfort, or because they felt it comforted them in their initial grief, but it can be counter-productive even for themselves.</p><p>Sometimes, these risk factors combine — ‘stuck in the bubble’, ‘Toxic Positivity’, ‘Toxic Cheerleading’ and ‘Ours is the Worst Type of Loss &amp; Grief’ — and it can be a very unhealthy mix for those who’ve got their wagons round in a circle, as well as potentially harming other people who feel their own loss &amp; grief experience is being diminished.</p><p>Where harm is being caused to others by those who are grieving, it’s almost always sub-conscious of course.</p><p>People get so wrapped up in their own grief, it can be hard to see someone else’s grief unless they’ve had — or think they’ve had — a similar type of loss &amp; grief experience.</p><p><strong>Valuable Peer Support or Stuck in a Bubble?</strong></p><p>Someone who’s lost a loved one to suicide after years of depression often feels they can empathise with someone else who’s lost a loved one to suicide after years of depression, but they might struggle to empathise with someone who’s lost a loved one in a terrorist attack or a murder of any kind or even another type of suicide death.</p><p>The bereavement landscape can be prone to silos and ghettoisation, cliques and cults.</p><p>It’s common — and, indeed, many would say ‘normal’ — for people who’ve experienced traumatic loss to want to cluster with people who they think have had a similar loss experience rather than people they think have had a different loss experience.</p><p>Bereavement support groups often go very narrow in their membership.</p><p>People often think that ‘mainstream’ bereavement and counselling services won’t understand their loss experience so they gravitate to more specialist support or they set up their own bereavement support services.</p><p>Such services can be very helpful in the short-to-medium-term in supporting people through the early phases of their grief.</p><p>People often feel safer in such an environment; they feel they can ‘just be’ without having to say much; and, when they do want to start ‘opening up’ about their loss experience, they feel they’re in a safe, supportive space to do so.</p><p>It’s understandable and, initially, it’s often very helpful.</p><p>It can be problematic in the long-term though, from both an individual perspective and a ‘system perspective’.</p><p>Individuals can find it harder to ‘move forward’ with their lives, especially if they become too dependent on narrow peer support groups or communities, particularly if these groups or communities are characterised by Toxic Positivity or Toxic Cheerleading.</p><p>In all other walks of life &amp; work, a key success factor in personal development and growth is being exposed to diversity in all its forms, including diversity of experience.</p><p>Recovery and then ‘moving forward’ after loss &amp; grief experiences are no different.</p><p>And from a ‘system perspective’, people often say that the ‘mainstream’ bereavement services and ‘non-specialist counselling’ services don’t understand their particular loss &amp; grief experience so there’s a need for specialist services or a need to set up new support services.</p><p>Up to a point, this creates healthy choice.</p><p>After this point, there can be unhealthy fragmentation and lack of viability.</p><p>And if we never educate the ‘mainstream’, we’re not tackling a key underlying problem.</p><p>Plus, of course, such arguments can be frustrating and distressing for counsellors who feel they can support anyone through any form of loss or grief experience; and with their exposure to multiple forms of loss &amp; grief experience being one of the benefits they provide!</p><p><strong>The Suicide Loss Bubble</strong></p><p>As I have personal lived experience of suicide loss and suicide crises, and I work professionally in suicide prevention, including suicide bereavement support — which is another form of suicide prevention —I want to highlight the problem of ‘the suicide loss bubble’ (other bubbles are available!).</p><p>Many people who’ve been bereaved by suicide regularly post and talk about those who’ve been bereaved by suicide being at greater risk of suicide themselves, without acknowledging that any group of people experiencing any form of traumatic loss have a heightened risk of suicide.</p><p>It’s part of the problem of ‘comparative bereavement’, of wanting to believe that their form of loss experience is worse than other people’s loss &amp; grief experiences, leading to this phenomenon of ‘bereavement as a competition’ or ‘The Grief Olympics’.</p><p>It’s a problem compounded by isolated peer support communities with Toxic Positivity and Toxic Cheerleading</p><p>And, as happens with people who have a personal belief they find comforting or which they feel helps them to advocate or campaign around their belief system, they go looking for some ‘evidence’ to support their belief system…and, of course, they find some!</p><p>In the case of people bereaved by suicide who believe their loss experience is ‘the worst form of loss’, they usually gravitate to the news headlines that say people bereaved by suicide are ‘two-thirds more likely to die by suicide’ or ‘65% more likely to die by suicide’ or ‘63% more likely to die by suicide’ — there are these three variations in the news headlines.</p><p>People who grab on to ‘evidence’ that appears to support their belief system rarely read beyond the headlines and the news reports, they rarely study the detail behind it, usually not even referencing the source material, and they rarely go out to search for other ‘evidence’ that might give a contrary perspective or even a complementary perspective.</p><p>The motivation (conscious or sub-conscious) is to support an existing belief, so one piece of evidence that appears to support their belief is enough, and they stop looking.</p><p>This two-thirds higher/65% higher/63% higher example for heightened risk for those bereaved by suicide is usually taken from the media coverage of a study by Alexandra Pitman, David Osborn, Khadija Rantell &amp; Michael King.</p><p>And I say ‘the media coverage of a study…’ because I know, in many cases, the figure has been taken from a media report or even just the headline and, when questioned, people almost always say they haven’t read the actual study in detail.</p><p>Indeed, most people never read the studies themselves, just the media reports.</p><p><strong>Let’s Look More Closely at the Research…and the Research Process</strong></p><p>Here’s the link to the paper itself in BMJ Open:</p><p><a href="https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/6/1/e009948">Bereavement by suicide as a risk factor for suicide attempt: a cross-sectional national UK-wide study of 3432 young bereaved adults</a></p><p>This study did indeed find an increased risk of a ‘suicide attempt’ among those bereaved by suicide, and people bereaved by suicide to have a significantly higher suicide risk than people losing someone to a ‘natural death’.</p><p>But, and there are a few buts:</p><p>1) the study was published in 2016, based on data collected in 2010, so the dataset the conclusions are drawn from is not only pre-Covid (which changed a lot of trends &amp; patterns), it was 14 years ago;</p><p>2) the data is from a survey among staff &amp; students at UK universities aged 18–40 who’d lost a friend or relative after the age of 10 (614 by suicide, 712 by ‘sudden unnatural causes’, 2106 by ‘sudden natural causes’);</p><p>3) there was evidence of a higher risk of suicide among those experiencing bereavement via any form of sudden ‘unnatural’ loss (eg fatal road traffic accident or murder) compared with those experiencing bereavement via sudden ‘natural’ loss (eg a heart attack or stroke);</p><p>4) there was a high degree of overlap of experience, ie multiple loss experiences, and therefore co-correlations, with 43% of those experiencing bereavement by suicide also having experienced a sudden ‘natural’ death and 22% having experienced another form of sudden ‘unnatural’ death.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/966/1*C2vQGCVXWU2HXRtp2dyuRg.png" /></figure><p>Once again, it’s important to state that this study did find evidence of an increased risk of suicide (attempt) among those bereaved by suicide but there was also a heightened risk of suicide among those bereaved by other forms of sudden unnatural death, and the study had a number of limitations, eg due to the sample being aged 18–40 and being staff &amp; students at universities, and the data set being collected 14 years ago.</p><p>If this study was repeated today, and with a broader sample going beyond university staff &amp; students, and including people aged over 40 as well, it may reach the same conclusions, but it may not!</p><p>As is common in many, if not most, academic research reports…’more research is needed’ — or, perhaps, different research is needed?!</p><p>Certainly, more up-to-date research is needed, among a more robust &amp; representative sample, and with more opportunity to test the extent to which different forms of traumatic loss result in a heightened suicide risk.</p><p>As a counsellor, I had many clients who’d experienced bereavement via road traffic accidents, cot death, etc who were having thoughts of suicide.</p><p>It was complex though and depended on many factors, such as degree of guilt, eg from not ensuring the seatbelt was on, or driving too fast, or not checking in on the baby often enough.</p><p>Surveys are often not sensitive to all these factors and they try to establish correlations between some variables included in the survey but don’t include other factors that could be at least as significant if not more so — at worst, even omitting factors that could be the main explanatory variable!</p><p>Academic researchers make a huge issue of the rigour and quality of their processes, including publishing in peer-reviewed journals, but this is a process of review by people who live in ‘their bubble’; and they talk less about the systemic biases in which topics tend to get researched and which topics rarely if ever get researched and therefore included in these research papers in peer-reviewed journals.</p><p>As a Trustee with Age UK York, and a member of the national Age UK Influencing Committee, and a person in my 60s who’s concerned about older people, and a person who has a passion for social justice…I’ve studied the issues facing older people, and their experiences.</p><p>Older people are a group often subject to systemic bias and discrimination.</p><p>Men aged 80+ often have one of the highest suicide rates of all and yet rarely feature in research and rarely if ever feature in national suicide prevention strategies &amp; plans.</p><p>It’s all part of society’s and government’s systemic bias &amp; discrimination against older people, which we also witnessed during the Covid outbreak, with evidence from the Covid Inquiry suggesting that policy was being formulated on the basis that older people, especially those in care homes, were ‘expendable’!</p><p>When we do take the time to study older people, and older men in particular, we find that the high suicide rates for men aged 80+ are often due to losing a lifelong partner or becoming housebound after an active outdoor life.</p><p>Losing a partner they’ve been married to for 40, 50 or 60 years can be devastating, and they often ‘just want to be with them’.</p><p>So, they can be bereaved by ‘natural’ causes but still have a heightened suicide risk.</p><p>Also, as I’ve found in my own research and my own experience working with older people, they can be traumatised by other factors, especially a partner having dementia.</p><p>What might officially be classified as a ‘natural’ death can feel very unnatural to the person losing their loved one — with the trauma of ‘losing them twice’.</p><p>As often is the case, it’s more complex and complicated than we first thought.</p><p>And if the survey sample was 18+ rather than 18–40, covering the whole population not just university staff &amp; students, it may be that a different picture would emerge.</p><p>Those aged over 40 are considerably more likely to experience ‘natural’ deaths, including ‘natural’ deaths that are highly traumatic, such as losing a lifelong partner, and to have a heightened suicide risk after a ‘natural’ death.</p><p>And this problem of ‘systemic data &amp; evidence bias &amp; discrimination’ can be further compounded by the tendency to respond to a challenge to ‘the evidence base’ by trying to get more ‘evidence’ to prove what has now become the ‘accepted wisdom’ rather than truly filling complete data gaps which address the underlying bias &amp; discrimination!</p><p><strong>Who’s Studying ‘Lonely Loss Syndrome’ and Its Impact?</strong></p><p>While I’m on my soap box on this, it should be pointed out that we still have very little research into the trauma impacts of ‘COVID deaths’ and the ‘Lonely Loss Syndrome’ created by the pandemic, which may well have contributed to the recent rise in the suicide numbers, and yet a narrative has been created and fuelled by people, including the lead adviser to government on suicide prevention (and note that he speculates on this, whilst criticising others for speculating without hard data!) that the recent rise in suicide rates is probably due (largely) to economic factors, with no mention of trauma factors like ‘Lonely Loss Syndrome’.</p><p>Also we shouldn’t be falling into the trap of just focusing on statistical correlations within population sub-groups when our goal is to get the suicide numbers down among all sub-groups of the population and when we have plenty of ‘cases’ of people with loss &amp; grief experiences with a heightened suicide risk, with lessons we can learn to help prevent preventable suicide deaths in the future.</p><p><strong>Is This Helping Us Create and Sustain a ‘Zero Suicide Society’?</strong></p><p>For those of us who want to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero suicide, including down for men and women, down for people of all ages, down for students and non-students, etc…and down for those bereaved by any means…and down for those experiencing any form of trauma…</p><p>…the best way to think about all of this is to conclude that any form of loss or trauma, and notably any form of ‘traumatic loss’, can lead to a heightened risk of a suicide attempt, and so we should get wrap-around support for anyone in this situation.</p><p>It’s why the Zero Suicide Society framework includes trauma &amp; loss support, as a key ‘piece of the puzzle’ for getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero…</p><p>…including supporting all forms of loss not just suicide bereavement, and supporting all trauma experiences, not giving any type of traumatic loss a higher or lower value than any other; not creating a hierarchy; and not prioritising with a competitive mindset:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HpiVRGc1VAAs8SsWwKgNRw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Final Thoughts</strong></p><p>Based on my many years of working in suicide prevention, and my research, and my studies and practice as a counsellor, and my own personal experiences of loss…</p><p>…I’ve come to one inescapable conclusion, which is…</p><p>…the ‘worst kind of loss’ is the loss that you’re experiencing!</p><p>Loss and grief is a unique personal experience, so the kind and compassionate response is to respect each person’s loss and give everyone support and care relevant to their personal needs.</p><p>Whilst you might feel that your own loss, or your ‘type’ of loss, is so much worse than someone else’s, saying that out loud can be hurtful to others, even harmful if it can lead to a heightened risk of depression and thoughts of suicide.</p><p>You might want to say it out loud in a ‘peer group’ or one-to-one conversation where you think it helps those in that peer group or the person in that one-to-one conversation, but saying it outside these specific environments carries risks, even dangers.</p><p>Hopefully, in time, with the right support, everyone can move forward in their loss &amp; grief experience to a point where they appreciate the need to extend their compassion to people ‘not like themselves’ as well as people who are ‘like themselves’.</p><p>This usually requires therapy or highly enlightened peer support groups or transitioning from, say, ‘suicide bereavement groups’ to broader ‘bereavement groups’ to broader social groups where they can both support others experiencing loss, grief or trauma and be supported in their own loss &amp; grief journey.</p><p>A pertinent example might be having ‘Bereavement Quilts’ not just ‘Suicide Bereavement Quilts’ which bring together diverse communities and challenge stigma by doing so, ie a square remembering someone lost to suicide sitting alongside a square remembering people lost to cancer, dementia, heart attack, MND, murder, traffic accident.</p><p>Sadly, some people do get ‘stuck’ and find it very hard to move forward, even impossible to not think that their loss experience is ‘the worst kind of loss’ 10, 20, 30 or more years after their bereavement.</p><p>We need to keep trying to find new and different supplies of kindness and compassion, including helping people ‘get outside the bubble’; helping people develop empathy for others even when they initially think (consciously or sub-consciously) that person has had a ‘less traumatic’ loss &amp; grief experience; and helping everyone move forward appropriately and effectively in their lives, work/career, and relationships, including self-care, self-compassion, and self-forgiveness without selfish self-centredness or self-pity.</p><p>It’s hard folks, it’s very, very hard.</p><p>Please be kind…to everyone experiencing any form of loss or grief!</p><p>Please show universal kindness and compassion — don’t make it selective or hierarchical.</p><p>Please recognise that kindness comes in different forms, including trying to change some of our unhelpful narratives and belief systems; and calling out anything that’s potentially harmful, and avoiding harmful phenomena like Toxic Positivity or Toxic Cheerleading!</p><p>I wish you all well with your current and future grief challenges and, especially, in becoming conscious of all the loss, grief &amp; trauma experiences you’ve had in your life that you’re not yet conscious of, and then joining those dots!</p><p>And I look forward to continuing to learn from those who attend my talks and workshops, as well as passing on what I’ve learned.</p><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles FMRS FAMI FRSA is a Research Fellow, consultant, coach, and counsellor — with an Advanced Study Major in Loss &amp; Grief within his Counselling Diploma.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul has had many loss &amp; grief experiences, including traumatic loss.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>He has personal experience of suicide bereavement and suicide crisis.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul is Chief Facilitator for the Zero Suicide Society JoinTheDots Transformation Programme, and Founder of Towards Zero Suicide CIC.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>He was Tour Director for the pioneering #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour, 11–23 June 2024 which comprised 19 major events across 15 towns &amp; cities in 2 weeks, and which had 40 public education talks on suicide &amp; #SuicidePrevention, including how those experiencing loss &amp; trauma have a heightened risk of suicide.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*bfzyc9w5zE46j-o490CvtQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31c037b792f4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We’ve had a change of Government, but any change on suicide prevention or commitment to suicide…]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/weve-had-a-change-of-government-but-any-change-on-suicide-prevention-or-commitment-to-suicide-18ea8dd63dfd?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18ea8dd63dfd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-prevention]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Nov 2024 09:43:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-18T08:56:31.304Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>We’ve had a change of Government, but any change on suicide prevention or commitment to suicide reduction?</h3><h4>The period of Conservative Government, 2010–2024, was the worst for suicide prevention since records began in terms of rising suicide numbers; and the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England 2023–2028 lacked ambition, vision, funding, commitment, positive dynamics for change, and hope.</h4><h4>With Labour’s landslide win, we might have expected change but will we get it from this new Government, ie our new political leaders, and can we get it from a ‘governance establishment’ which, it could be argued, is at least as responsible for the low ambition and systemic failure over the past 14 years as the elected politicians.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7BURpk0f-i6bL7SLGmyl5A.png" /><figcaption>A case study illustrating efforts to get the suicide numbers down, and the barriers faced by those trying to get the suicide numbers down, including specific proposals the previous Government rejected/ignored, which the new Government could adopt if it was committed to suicide reduction.</figcaption></figure><p>There are many different angles I could take on this question, but I’ve covered many already in my detailed critique of the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England 2023–2028, and I want to focus on one specific lens through which we can view change — both the lack of positive change in the suicide numbers during the past 14 years, and the potential for us to considerably reduce the suicide numbers over the next 14 years.</p><p>Let’s try to be hopeful.</p><p>After all, I am “<strong><em>in the hope business</em></strong>”!</p><p><strong>A petition for change</strong></p><p>The lens through which I’m going to view the transformational change challenge of suicide reduction in England (and the wider UK, although Northern Ireland, Scotland, and Wales now have their own suicide prevention strategies &amp; plans, so I’ll stick to England), is the petition to parliament that I drafted, published &amp; promoted last year with Steve Phillip of The Jordan Legacy, which got to the 10,000 signatures threshold requiring a written response from government/Government, and which was arrogantly dismissed by those with theoretical ‘responsibility’ for creating hope through action and bringing the suicide numbers down!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nsJCAC03AULsiOOEk-ylzg.png" /><figcaption>This is the summary of the petition to parliament for a Suicide Prevention Act, and package of proposals for suicide reduction, that I put together with Steve Phillip of The Jordan Legacy, published in July 2023, open until 19 January 2024, which had a disturbingly inadequate and incomplete response from DHSC on 24 January 2024</figcaption></figure><p>The package of proposals put forward emerged from action research among ‘experts by profession and qualifications’ and ‘experts by lived or living experiences of suicide’ summarising the key practical actions needed to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend #TowardsZeroSuicide.</p><p>Some of these measures would cost little to implement, and the whole package would ‘pay for itself’ many times over, so anyone truly committed to Suicide Prevention and Suicide Reduction would surely leap at the chance to support and implement these proposals?</p><p><strong>Who wants change?</strong></p><p>A few big questions need to be asked and, ideally, answered.</p><p><em>Who were these arrogant, out-of-touch people, who rejected these compassionate, constructive proposals so dismissively?</em></p><p><em>To what extent was it our elected politicians?</em></p><p><em>To what extent was it our civil servants?</em></p><p><em>To what extent was it advisers to government?</em></p><p><em>Or was it a combination of all three?</em></p><p>To what extent was it ‘the system’ to blame rather than any particular individuals, although isn’t any ‘system’ created and sustained by people, so we shouldn’t hide behind ‘the system’ being in the dock?</p><p>And another key question now is:</p><p><em>What or who would stop these positive proposals being implemented now?</em></p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/paulvittles_suicideprevention-labour-budget-activity-7257647534590889984-iLWN?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop">Paul Vittles on LinkedIn: #suicideprevention #labour #budget #zerosuicidesociety #livedexperience... | 12 comments</a></p><p>Let’s test to see if there’s a new Government “<em>willing and able to do all it can to prevent all preventable suicides</em>” — our definition of a Zero Suicide Society which underpinned the action research project, the wider engagement with the Suicide Prevention &amp; Suicide Reduction communities, and the resulting Zero Suicide Society (JoinTheDots) Transformation Programme.</p><p>Let’s test if the civil servants supporting Government; advisers to Government (with a large G from the world of Politics with a large P); advisers to government (with a small g and a small p); and the ‘Suicide Prevention Establishment’ are now willing and able to implement these life-saving and cost-saving measures, without the barrier of the Conservatives, or flush out if they’re not pushing forward these proposals; perhaps even preventing change?!</p><p>For those who supported the woefully low ambition National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028 — who didn’t publicly lambast it as myself and others did — who said they wanted higher ambition but thought ‘it’s the best Strategy we’re going to get from this Government’, now is the time to speak publicly and loudly about the need to raise our aspirations on getting the suicide numbers down.</p><p>In response to a recent question in the new parliament about action, following yet another preventable suicide death, the Labour Minister taking the question referred the MP to “<em>the government’s National Suicide Prevention Strategy</em>”, thereby adopting “<em>the government’s</em>” Strategy and distancing himself from the responsibility to do better than the previous Government; so accepting low ambition, inaction, and the absence of funding to take impactful action…and all of this supposedly trying to comfort the family of another young person lost too soon!</p><p>Whenever I ask those in positions of power and influence, those who shape these national strategies and plans, if they believe that ‘most suicides are preventable’, they invariably say yes, so that means — let’s do the maths! — we should, collectively, be aiming for a 50% reduction at least, as part of getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>You agree?!</p><p>If not, why not?</p><p><strong>Which ‘business’ are you in — Suicide Prevention or Suicide Reduction (or neither)?</strong></p><p>Please note that, in this piece, I’m using the two terms ‘Suicide Prevention’ and ‘Suicide Reduction’ quite deliberately, as some people and organisations have a primary focus on Suicide Prevention (or, in some cases, the primary focus might be on, for example, Suicide Bereavement support — valuable work! — which includes suicide prevention via supporting those impacted by a suicide loss) and some, like myself and Towards Zero Suicide CIC, have a primary focus on Suicide Reduction.</p><p><strong>Suicide Prevention</strong> covers all efforts to prevent suicides at a micro or macro level which could potentially reduce the overall suicide numbers or at least stop them from rising or stop them rising further or faster.</p><p><strong>Suicide Reduction</strong> covers all co-ordinated efforts via visions, strategies, plans, policy proposals &amp; policy change, advocacy, campaigning, collaborative movements for reduction, breakthrough thinking, transformational change programmes, facilitating systems change, etc to get the overall suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>Suicide Prevention activity can take place without Suicide Reduction. Suicide Reduction necessarily includes Suicide Prevention.</p><p>Btw many people are not engaged in either Prevention or Reduction, so we need to try and get more people and organisations engaged and involved!</p><p>Some people and organisations will (consciously or subconsciously) tolerate 6,000+ suicide deaths each year in the UK, by looking at the graph and saying (or at least thinking) things like “<em>it could be worse</em>” or “<em>we’re probably doing the best we can</em>” or “<em>it’s out of our control</em>” or, when presented with a woefully low ambition National Suicide Prevention Strategy, “<em>it’s probably the best we could get and I think we should support it, not criticise it</em>” — and, crucially, you don’t hear them regularly saying things like “<em>these suicide numbers are totally unacceptable in a so-called civilised society</em>”!</p><p>Some people and organisations are actively not tolerating those 6,000+ preventable deaths by suicide each year.</p><p>They look at the graph and say — and they believe this deeply and passionately — we <strong>must</strong> get the suicide numbers down and, crucially, we <strong>can</strong> get the suicide numbers down, towards zero.</p><p>These people and organisations are not just ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’, they’re ‘in the Suicide Reduction business’!</p><p><strong>Background and context for the petition proposals to get the (UK) suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero?</strong></p><p>I want to first sum up where these petition proposals came from.</p><p>Myself and Steve Phillip carried out action research and analysis, and co-authored the report ‘<strong><em>Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society</em></strong>’, which several Suicide Prevention Leads called “<em>ground-breaking”</em>, publishing the 1st edition on 11 July 2023, followed by an intensive and extensive period of public engagement to get further input and more practical suggestions for getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>We then published the 2nd Edition on 29 September 2023, along with other documents effectively putting forward an alternative National Strategy, and I started rolling out the Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme, now being driven through Towards Zero Suicide CIC which is 100% dedicated to delivering this (JoinTheDots) Transformation Programme, and getting the UK suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-edition-2-of-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - Edition 2 Of The Report | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>After the 1st edition of ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ was published, there were meetings, presentations, workshops, and two open-invitation webinars to fully explain the action research process and analysis; the resulting Zero Suicide Society vision, model, framework, Transformation Programme; and the petition proposals:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4UxlbliuacI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4UxlbliuacI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4UxlbliuacI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e691d1e7fe4f147c9b90043eccf55ce3/href">https://medium.com/media/e691d1e7fe4f147c9b90043eccf55ce3/href</a></iframe><p>In the original report, fine-tuned later, we set out all of the practical actions for getting the suicide numbers down that we can take ourselves, eg ‘take the training, have a conversation’, which I’ve subsequently fleshed out in this report published after the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour in June 2024…</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/take-the-training-have-a-conversation-about-suicide-c5e2b977963b">Take the Training, Have a Conversation…about Suicide!</a></p><p>…practical actions that communities can take, schools, hospitals, workplaces, sectors, professions, etc, and the practical actions we need from government/Government/parliament, especially where there’s a need for changes in the law or regulation or governance systems or parliamentary process or major policy shifts.</p><p>These practical actions needed from govt/Govt/parliament were then synthesised — there were more than 20 measures initially, reduced down to 12, to fit into the word limit in the Parliamentary Petitions Committee process — and packaged up under the banner of a ‘Suicide Prevention Act’ to have consolidated change, and relevant enabling legislation where necessary, and to make a clear statement that these measures were aimed at Suicide Prevention.</p><p>In fact the package of measures within the petition proposals were aimed at Suicide Reduction but this term is not used among the public at large, and not used enough within the field — maybe we can start using it more?!</p><p>As I explained at the webinar on 15 August 2023, the process of publishing the petition proposals highlighted that the civil servant administering the petitions process had a very low level of knowledge about suicide, suicide prevention, current legislation &amp; regulation impacting on suicide &amp; suicide prevention, and — most disturbingly perhaps — what we mean by ‘Lived Experience of Suicide’.</p><p>The petition proposal which referred to the foundation stone of the Zero Suicide Society (Building Blocks) model, Lived Experience Involvement with continuous listening to and learning from diverse lived experiences, was actually removed from our initial draft, and — as far as we could tell —this was because the civil servant we were liaising with simply didn’t understand what this was, never mind understanding how vitally important it is for Suicide Prevention and Suicide Reduction.</p><p>Our (otherwise polite and friendly) civil servant (just going about their job, which no doubt spans across many different subjects so we wouldn’t expect them to have an in-depth knowledge of suicide, suicide prevention, or related legislation and regulation necessarily, although we might expect them to check a few facts!) also responded by questioning why we wanted to change the Health and Safety at Work legislation as they thought “<em>it already covers suicide</em>”!</p><p>It doesn’t, the Act specifically excludes suicide!</p><h3>Paul Vittles on X (formerly Twitter): &quot;If there was a suicide in your workplace or you lost a colleague to suicide after they&#39;d been struggling at work, you&#39;d expect it to be investigated right? Learn lessons? Prevent future deaths?Current #HealthAndSafety laws stop this even being reported!https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m pic.twitter.com/OTIGTfbNZK / X&quot;</h3><p>If there was a suicide in your workplace or you lost a colleague to suicide after they&#39;d been struggling at work, you&#39;d expect it to be investigated right? Learn lessons? Prevent future deaths?Current #HealthAndSafety laws stop this even being reported!https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m pic.twitter.com/OTIGTfbNZK</p><p>They also changed the title of our petition from what we’d submitted — “<strong><em>Introduce a Suicide Prevention Act to seek to minimise suicides</em></strong>” — to “<strong><em>Introduce a Suicide Prevention Act to seek to reduce suicides</em></strong>”, so we had to emphasise one of our most crucial points about high ambition not low ambition and wanting to ‘minimise’ the number of suicides not just ‘reduce’ the number!</p><p>Here’s a recording from the section of our webinar on 15 August 2023 where I explain about these changes, the exchanges with our allocated civil servant, and the implications.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBZF5ImKBeN4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href">https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href</a></iframe><p>Let me make it clear, there’s no suggestion of malevolence or malicious intent here, but it emphasises that a combination of ignorance (not knowing), lack of competence (not checking), and institutionalised low ambition can hold us back in Suicide Prevention and Suicide Reduction.</p><p><strong>The petition process progresses and the National Strategy appears</strong></p><p>Another story was emerging as our petition was being promoted and the signatures were coming in.</p><p>When our petition was launched on 20 July 2023, we were still waiting for a new National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, which should have been in place from September 2022, 10 years after the first published National Strategy for England, with two 5-year plans having emerged during that time, including the most recent plan which had the low aspiration target of reducing the number of suicides by 10% within 5 years (btw — the numbers didn’t come down by 10%, they actually went up!), but still no sign of the new National Strategy at that point, so we couldn’t account for it or comment on it in our report.</p><p>This overdue new or updated National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, for 2023–2028, finally emerged, to great fanfare from the Minister, Maria Caulfield, on 11 September 2023, the day after World Suicide Prevention Day.</p><p>Many people working in the fields of Suicide Prevention and Suicide Reduction, especially those with lived experience of suicide, immediately pointed out the low ambition, the absence of a reduction target, and the absence of any new funding — in fact, with projections of reduced resources, as funding for existing programmes ceased — so little chance of getting the suicide numbers coming down.</p><p>In the Strategy document, there was a vague aspiration to reduce the numbers…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y0o-CrMfE62cwHJGLW156w.png" /></figure><p>…but with no specific numbers or clear route to achieving any reduction, with a scattergun of potential actions listed in a document that otherwise reeked of systemic low ambition from a Government that was likely to be out of office within the next 5 years or, to use the inexact language contained within the National Strategy, within “<em>half this time or sooner</em>”!</p><p>Steve Phillip &amp; I met with DHSC to express our dissatisfaction with the new National Strategy for England, and we published a response to the Strategy from The Jordan Legacy with our criticism of its low ambition but also with recommendations for practical actions that would constitute high ambition, taking measures mentioned in the Strategy and raising the bar for these specific measures, so we were effectively putting forward an alternative, more positive, more hopeful, more ambitious National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/the-jordan-legacys-response-to-the-governments-national-suicide-prevention-strategy-2023-2028/">The Jordan Legacy&#39;s Response To The Government&#39;s National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2023-2028 | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>Combined with our report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’, and our petition package of proposals, this higher ambition, practical alternative gave a lot more hope to those working in Suicide Reduction, we had widespread support for our proposals, and the numbers of signatures on our petition were gradually building towards the first key threshold of 10,000 which requires the govt/Govt to provide a formal, written response.</p><p>So there was superb support, especially from people in our network with lived experience of suicide, but there was some resistance from within the fields of Suicide Prevention and Suicide Reduction, mainly from the bigger national charities, with a few smaller charities also resistant or disengaged, and from some of those who were directly involved in shaping the National Strategy for England who, as we might expect, were defensive in the face of criticism of ‘their Strategy’ and ‘their low ambition’ baked into the new National Strategy.</p><p>Some told us “<em>it was the best Strategy we could get in the circumstances</em>” which is not much of a defence, especially when low ambition costs lives.</p><p>It’s certainly a huge risk to publicly back such a low aspiration Strategy, and be seen to be ‘conspiring with low ambition’.</p><p>As I remarked at the time, “<em>if you get into bed with low ambition, you tend to get infected with low ambition</em>”!</p><p>At an NSPA webinar dedicated to this topic, one supporter of the Strategy and a highly vocal supporter of the National Strategy Advisory Group repeated a line which has been used several times publicly by lead adviser Professor Appleby “<em>in the circumstances, we’re very lucky to even have a Strategy</em>”, which also smacks of institutionalised low ambition.</p><p>The most horrific response we received to our challenges around the flatlining of the suicide numbers over the previous 15 years was “<em>at least the numbers aren’t going up</em>”!</p><p>We also heard members of the National Suicide Prevention Advisory Group, trying to defend what to most people working in Suicide Reduction looks like failing national strategies and plans, “<em>without the National Strategy, the numbers could be higher</em>”.</p><p>Aside from this being speculative, it also misses the key point that the numbers should be on a long-term downward trend, towards zero, so even a flat line is a dreadful result.</p><p>Then, when we got the 2022–2023 ONS statistics for England, the numbers had actually gone up, by 6% (followed by confirmation of a 7.6% rise for England &amp; Wales), so no-one could again use that awful line “<em>at least they’re not going up</em>”!</p><p>In my conversations with Suicide Prevention Leads around-the-country, and the many people with lived experience in our network, I was urged to write a more detailed critique of the underlying, systemic, institutionalised failures in the current National Strategy for England and the process that keeps creating low ambition strategies &amp; plans, and to apply my ‘dynamics of change’ analysis to the barriers and potential for positive change and higher impact, so I published this 36,000-word critique and analysis of how we can break down the barriers to change and get the numbers down:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/are-we-in-the-suicide-prevention-business-or-is-it-suicide-maintenance-40a4e4129496">Are we ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’ or is it Suicide Maintenance?</a></p><p><strong>Nice to get support, sad to have opposition or ‘non-support’</strong></p><p>Our experience with promoting the petition proposals and trying to ‘get signatures’ was an education in itself.</p><p>On the positive side of the equation, we had lots of people giving us tips for how to boost the number of petition signatures including from those who’d achieved large numbers of signatures on their petitions such as the 3 Dads Walking and the #ForThe100 campaign.</p><p>We had lots of people &amp; organisations supporting us publicly with great enthusiasm.</p><p>We had pro bono support from Rashpal Singh Sagoo and his business BOXmedia producing superb promotional videos.</p><h3>Paul Vittles on X (formerly Twitter): &quot;2 quick actions, just 2-3 mins of your time, could help save 1000s of lives.1) Please sign this @jordanlegacyUK petition for the measures we need to reduce the UK suicide numbers, towards zero:https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m2) Repost &amp; urge others to sign it.#SuicidePrevention pic.twitter.com/ygBlv6Qv6o / X&quot;</h3><p>2 quick actions, just 2-3 mins of your time, could help save 1000s of lives.1) Please sign this @jordanlegacyUK petition for the measures we need to reduce the UK suicide numbers, towards zero:https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m2) Repost &amp; urge others to sign it.#SuicidePrevention pic.twitter.com/ygBlv6Qv6o</p><p>And we had many of our collaborative partners sending us videos they’d made themselves, inc Bob &amp; Maggie Abrahart, Charlie Hart, Ellie Hatto, Jeremy O’Dwyer, Richard McCann, Sam Southern, and Jayne Walsham.</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/paulvittles_nhs-suicideawareness-suicideprevention-activity-7133371463058763776-dsaj?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop">Why you should join Sam Southern&amp;#39;s petition for suicide prevention | Paul Vittles posted on the topic | LinkedIn</a></p><p>On the negative side of the equation, we had charities &amp; CICs working in Suicide Prevention who didn’t support our petition for a range of revealing and, in some respects, disturbing reasons.</p><p>All good insight though!</p><p>Some of them said they needed more detail on our proposals before they could support our petition, eg before supporting the proposal for suicide prevention education in schools, wanting to know exactly what would be covered, how it would be covered, and who would cover it.</p><p>This particular policy proposal was, of course, building on the petition the 3 Dads Walking had already initiated and taken all the way to parliament.</p><p>At the point where our proposal was launched, there still appeared to be no movement from the Department for Education, so we included it among the 12 specific asks in our petition to help keep the pressure on for a reform that virtually everyone we’d interviewed had said was a ‘no brainer’ for getting the suicide numbers down.</p><p>It’s actually quite common, when petitions are put up, for people and organisations to argue for more details on ‘the what, how and who’ even though there’s a compelling ‘why’ and the overwhelming majority in favour.</p><p>This can be in good faith, due to genuine strong concerns about potential adverse impacts.</p><p>And it can be a ‘campaign tactic’ from opponents because it’s easy to try and block what is intended as a positive change that most people and organisations support by demanding further detail that cannot actually be provided at this stage where the debate is still focused on the principle, and the detail takes time to work through with all the stakeholders.</p><p>We highlighted at the time that supporting our petition would enable a process where there would be much discussion, deliberation and debate on ‘the what, how and who’ before any detailed policy went forward, and there would be research, engagement and consultation with parents, pupils, teachers, school staff &amp; other stakeholders before anything was finalised…</p><p>…and we urged people to sign our petition to try and help kick start this process.</p><p>But some still chose not to, even though they claimed to want to help reduce the numbers of suicides, and the overwhelming majority of suicide prevention advocates had said this change would help reduce the numbers.</p><p>In the time that has elapsed since our petition, there has been some movement at DfE, although not as far or as fast as we would like, and we’ve heard from more experts about ‘the what, how and who’ of this particular policy proposal, including the really valuable Churchill Fellowship report from Nina Smith which includes detail on the successful implementation of suicide prevention education in schools in other countries, like Australia and the US.</p><p>But, at the time of our petition, we did face some opposition from some people and organisations we thought would be supportive, and that was challenging.</p><p>More recent calls for ‘collaboration’ and ‘bringing everyone together’ to facilitate the changes needed to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend #TowardsZeroSuicide has to of course take into account the fact that not all those people and organisations you think are ‘with you’ will in fact be active collaborative partners when it really matters.</p><p>Some will openly not support you and publicly give their reasons why, which at least ticks the transparency and accountability boxes even if unhelpful and frustrating; some will privately tell you why they’re not supporting your petition, which at least shows some level of courtesy and respect; some will just not reply to your messages and say nothing; and, probably worst of all, some will say they’re going to support you but won’t!</p><p>One prominent charity told us they would support our petition, that their Board of Trustees had agreed in principle to support our petition, that they would put something in their next newsletter urging support for our petition…but then didn’t follow through on their promises and they became conspicuous for their lack of support for our petition.</p><p>I have no explanation for this because this charity couldn’t explain its inaction, despite claiming to share the vision of a Zero Suicide Society and to want the practical actions that would get the suicide numbers down, towards zero; and claiming to want to work ‘collaboratively’ and even berating other people for not being ‘collaborative’!</p><p>It’s a strange world sometimes!</p><p><strong>The bigger charities often have their own agenda or a different focus</strong></p><p>As is often the case for advocacy and campaigns ‘from the ground up’, most of the big national charities didn’t support our petition, despite some of them being more than happy to take part in the action research project that identified and synthesised the practical actions needed to get the suicide numbers down, ie participated in the research and engagement exercise which shaped the petition proposals.</p><p>We knew they wouldn’t necessarily support all 12 of the policy proposals contained within the petition package, but we did think they might support the package in principle perhaps with some qualifications or conditions, but none of them supported our petition.</p><p>To be fair, Samaritans did have a conversation about it with us, and explained that they didn’t want to support a proposal for a Suicide Prevention Act because they weren’t sure if legislation was ‘the way to go’, they weren’t sure if legislation was actually necessary for the changes we were asking for in our petition package, and they’d been ‘burned’ by their experience with the Online Safety Bill which had taken up so much time and effort over a period of years, demonstrating how hard it is to effect change this way.</p><p>This gave us the opportunity to explain that several of the petition proposals didn’t need new legislation or changes to existing legislation but some did, and the petition was also a tactical tool to try and get MPs thinking about all the measures that can get the numbers of suicides down — and this was a constructive conversation which highlighted all the possible routes to desired changes.</p><p>In contrast, PAPYRUS didn’t want to engage with our petition at all and told us they had a blanket policy of not supporting petitions — other than those initiated by themselves or PAPYRUS ambassadors like the 3 Dads Walking — because “<em>we get lots of requests to support petitions and campaigns and we have to say no to them all</em>”.</p><p>Having a blanket policy like this of course means no scope for collaboration around shared goals, and no scope to be discerning and support those petitions that have particular worth…and it effectively creates an additional barrier to suicide prevention.</p><p>We did try to argue a case for PAPYRUS supporting this particular petition, including highlighting the fact that the PAPYRUS CEO was interviewed as part of the action research project which generated the co-created proposals contained within the petition and he seemed to be in favour (although he may not have supported each of the 12 specific measures).</p><p>We also highlighted the fact that we had been very active in helping promote the 3 Dads Walking petition for suicide prevention education in schools, and had interviewed the 3 Dads Walking as part of the action research project, and thought that PAPYRUS supporting this petition, which included a further call for suicide prevention education in schools, might help ‘keep the pressure on the Department for Education’…</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/paulvittles_schools-education-suicideprevention-activity-7133002305305473024-qTvk?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop">The Jordan Legacy CIC on suicide education in schools | Paul Vittles posted on the topic | LinkedIn</a></p><p>…but PAPYRUS thought being seen to support our petition could “<em>water down</em>” the 3 Dads Walking campaign.</p><p>So we had to agree to disagree on this!</p><p>I would certainly urge all charities, CICs, advocates &amp; campaigners in the fields of Suicide Prevention and Suicide Reduction to not have a blanket policy of not supporting the petitions or campaigns of others trying to get the suicide numbers down, and to seek ways to collaborate around our common goals.</p><p>Otherwise, it’s making it so much harder to effect change in getting the suicide numbers down, and it’s disheartening for the smaller charities and CICs when the bigger national charities like PAPYRUS have a blanket non-collaboration policy.</p><p>But, thankfully, we had lots of support from individuals and from many small, local, grassroots charities, CICs, and community organisations, and we managed to reach the 10,000 signatures needed to require a formal written response to our petition proposals.</p><p><strong>The sad story of the DHSC VCSE Suicide Prevention Grant Fund</strong></p><p>Just before summarising that response, the political backdrop here was a Government falling apart after 14 years in office, with consistently poor poll ratings for both the party and the PM; the Government regularly being described in focus groups as out-of-touch and arrogant; and it being almost certain there would be a change of party ‘in power’, so the Conservatives had no drive in terms of taking forward any policies or measures that it didn’t think would be immediate vote winners.</p><p>And suicide prevention has never been seen as a vote winner, by any party.</p><p>One way in which the Government and its Ministers had demonstrated they were out-of-touch and making poor decisions was the DHSC VCSE Suicide Prevention Grant Fund.</p><p>[DHSC is Department of Health &amp; Social Care]</p><p>[VCSE = Voluntary, Community and Social Enterprise organisations]</p><p>When the belated National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028, was finally released on 11 September 2023, the Mental Health Minister, Maria Caulfield, had announced this Grant Fund with great fanfare as an example of new funding for suicide prevention.</p><p>This was disingenuous for 4 reasons.</p><p>1) it was the only piece of ‘new funding’ as part of the new Strategy.</p><p>2) it had already been announced so it was the political game of having more than one ‘announcement’ for the same pot of money.</p><p>3) buried deeper in the Strategy was the bad news that some of the existing funding streams were running down and would not be renewed so, by the end of 2028, it was projected that significantly fewer resources would be devoted to suicide prevention.</p><p>4) the total amount allocated to the Grant Fund was a one-off pot of just £10 million when preventable suicide deaths were known to cost the country £10 billion per year</p><p>And along with a National Suicide Prevention Strategy that was effectively a big competition with winners (a small number of ‘priority groups’) and losers (a large number of groups and issues not given ‘priority’ status), the Government was creating yet another competition, in the form of the Grant Fund, which would potentially have a very small number of winners and a very large number of losers.</p><p>And this is what happened, with DHSC announcing there would be just 70 organisations receiving funding and 1700 organisations receiving no funding, so only 5% successful in this competition and 95% unsuccessful.</p><p>To make things worse, 25% of the total funding was allocated to just 4 charities, which was an extraordinary decision.</p><p>When the Fund was first announced, the Minister said that it was for “<em>small, local, grassroots organisations</em>” so it was an opportunity to give out small grants to hundreds of VCSEs which met these criteria, organisations for which even just £1,000 could be a a significant injection of cash.</p><p>And, btw, it had been announced that the Fund was to cover operational costs for existing services not capital costs for new investment, which in itself is unusual for a grant fund, but this provided an opportunity to assist hundreds of small, local VCSEs with their cashflow.</p><p>But by allocating 25% of the total Fund to just 4 charities, with these 4 charities each getting more than £500,000, it scuppered any possibility of a large number of small, local, grassroots organisations benefiting.</p><p>And who were these “<em>small, local, grassroots organisations</em>” getting huge grants?</p><p>Well two of them were PAPYRUS and Samaritans, neither of which would be generally regarded as “<em>small, local, grassroots organisations</em>”!</p><p>I was very critical of this decision at the time and publicly criticised the Government/DHSC for its poor decisions, organisations like PAPYRUS and Samaritans for taking the (lion’s share of the) money from the Fund, and all those responsible for being part of this fiasco as I saw it.</p><p>My arguments were robust and founded on sound ethical and moral principles, having had many experiences of helping to create grant funds, sitting on boards awarding funds, and evaluating grant funds:</p><p>&gt; no person or organisation involved in the creation or management of any Grant Fund should be eligible to receive money from the Fund</p><p>&gt; if the Fund is intended to be for “<em>small, local, grassroots organisations</em>”, then only ‘small, local, grassroots organisations’ should be eligible to apply and receive funds.</p><p>On this basis, I argued that organisations like PAPYRUS and Samaritans should not have even been able to apply for money from this Fund and certainly should not have been awarded funding.</p><p>The amount they received just made it look even worse but the underlying principles should have ruled them out anyway.</p><p>And then we had the Minister, Maria Caulfield, attending the NSPA (National Suicide Prevention Alliance) Conference on 31 January at The Oval with what I called her ‘David Brent moment’:</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/paulvittles_probably-how-not-to-break-the-good-news-after-activity-7167054911988293632-HFd7?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop">Paul Vittles on LinkedIn: Probably how not to break the good news after bad news | 33 comments</a></p><p>She breezily announced to the room “<em>I’m delighted to confirm that NSPA has been successful in its application to the DHSC VCSE Grant Fund</em>” (NSPA had been awarded £150,000, in addition to its ‘parent organisation’ Samaritans being given £530,000).</p><p>This was a room filled with people and organisations that had been unsuccessful in their applications, with around 95% of the applicants in the room having been unsuccessful, and yet the Minister — completely misjudging this moment — seemed to think there would be huge applause for her announcement!</p><p><strong>The #ZeroSuicideSociety Transformation Programme &amp; #JoinTheDotsTour</strong></p><p>For the record, I wrote a submission on behalf of The Jordan Legacy to roll out the Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme, designed to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, but this was one of the 1,700 applications that received no funding at all.</p><p>I ended up rolling out the Programme, including organising the #ZeroSuicide Society #JoinTheDotsTour from the Humber to the Mersey in June 2024 with no grant funding from DHSC or any other source, once again emphasising how hard it is for small, local, grassroots organisations working in collaborative partnership to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero suicide.</p><p>For those not already aware, we had a ground-breaking Launch Conference at the Baths Hall which was largely independently-funded but with very generous support from North Lincolnshire Council Public Health:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F48blmJWg1aE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D48blmJWg1aE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F48blmJWg1aE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b0df403747611590821ebc904c3dc093/href">https://medium.com/media/b0df403747611590821ebc904c3dc093/href</a></iframe><p>And we had a totally independently-funded, pioneering Tour across the M62 Corridor, and grand finale in Liverpool, with free venues supplied by several of our collaborative partners:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FFbYqHYclcnA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DFbYqHYclcnA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FFbYqHYclcnA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href">https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href</a></iframe><p>This piece on the National Suicide Prevention Alliance (NSPA) website summarises the whole Tour, with lessons learned and tips for anyone thinking of planning and organising anything similar in their area:</p><p><a href="https://nspa.org.uk/news/insights-and-learnings-from-the-zero-suicide-society-humber-to-mersey-tour/?cn-reloaded=1">https://nspa.org.uk/news/insights-and-learnings-from-the-zero-suicide-society-humber-to-mersey-tour/</a></p><p><strong>We’re quick to blame the politicians but is this fair criticism?</strong></p><p>Finally, before focusing in detail on those petition proposals, I want to highlight the fact that this ‘political backdrop’ is not just Political with a large P because it wasn’t just the Government with a large G that created the woefully low ambition National Suicide Prevention Strategy.</p><p>It wasn’t just the Government that created and administered the shambolic DHSC VCSE Grant Fund, it was government with a small g; civil servants at DHSC; advisers to (large G) Government; advisers to (small g) government; the National Suicide Prevention Advisory Group; and some of those organisations which ended up benefiting from the Fund.</p><p>When I raise these types of concerns, I know it can upset people who believe, in good faith, they are not doing anything ‘wrong’ and are simply trying to help — and, indeed, some contacted me to tell me “<em>all we’re trying to do is prevent suicides and save lives</em>” — but we’re all trying to do that, all the ‘small, local, grassroots organisations’ are trying to do that, along with all the individual advocates and campaigners, but not all have the same level of power &amp; influence, or access to decision makers, or access to funding, despite all believing we have the passionate desire and practical ability to prevent suicides and save lives.</p><p>These small, local, grassroots organisations, and these individual advocates and campaigners, are often working in collaborative partnership because they believe it’s the way to have most impact, and because they know they have very limited power and influence on their own…but they regularly come up against barriers to collaboration and collective impact.</p><p><strong>The ‘response’ to the petition from DHSC</strong></p><p>Given that we had not only submitted proposed actions to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, but criticised the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England for being woeful in its low ambition — and I’d gone further in my critique in saying it was also “<em>shameful in its spin; potentially harmful in places; and, at worst, the suicide prevention strategy that prevents us from preventing suicides</em>” — and given that we’d put forward more ambitious proposals for a considerably better National Strategy, it was immediately disappointing and frustrating to see this as the first line of the DHSC’s response:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q5QGYxWY7D7CfIssKJF9XA.png" /></figure><p>In subsequent interactions with DHSC, they continued to refer us to the National Strategy — just as Ministers in the previous Government did and the new Government has done — completely ignoring our criticism of, and proposed alternative to, the woefully low ambition National Strategy.</p><p>Large chunks of the DHSC response to our petition proposals were simply copied and pasted from the National Strategy, emphasising how little thought and effort had gone into the response, and how disrespectful it was.</p><p>It would be hard to blame the politicians for this lack of commitment to suicide prevention because it probably never got as far as being seen by a politician; probably not even a senior civil servant, just low level administrative processing.</p><p>The 2nd paragraph (below) is more of the same, patronising us by telling us what we already knew, ie that there was a new National Strategy for England; failing to acknowledge our criticisms of, and alternatives to, this woefully low ambition National Strategy; and with the additional, poorly punctuated, line at the end of this 2nd paragraph saying “<em>It is our view, that many of the actions suggested within this petition, will be delivered through the Strategy</em>”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5fQ3kQWx9H_mXm2iI3R9lw.png" /></figure><p>We had already highlighted how, in our view, many of these actions would NOT be delivered through the National Strategy, and how we didn’t believe it was truly a cross-government strategy.</p><p>Indeed, one of the petition proposals was for a National Suicide Prevention Office to help make sure it was truly a whole-of-government approach, not coming through the Health Department with largely a health lens.</p><p>The 3rd paragraph (below) states that “<em>The Strategy set an ambition to reduce suicides within five years</em>” but we’d already criticised it for being both vague and low ambition with no specific reduction target!</p><p>It says “<em>The strategy is informed by data, evidence, and engagement with stakeholders, including people with lived experience…</em>” but my critique had already highlighted the problems with ‘The Data &amp; Evidence Bias Trap’ which bakes systemic bias and discrimination in to the National Strategy — ie where quantitative data on higher-than-average risk exists, ‘priority group’ status is assigned whilst other groups are de-prioritised and penalised for not having the right type of data or evidence — and it had highlighted how thin the engagement among people with lived experience of suicide had been:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9u3Vt_dRV7mi54aYRvQdwA.png" /></figure><p>The text above also repeats a common claim from DHSC and the National Suicide Prevention Strategy Advisory Group that the National Strategy had been informed by public engagement via “<em>the mental health call for evidence</em>” in 2022. I’d also highlighted the flaws here in my published critique.</p><p>When DHSC put out a call for evidence in 2022, it was around the ‘Ten Year Mental Health Plan’ and it asked for input into the Mental Health Plan, it was not a public engagement or consultation or call for evidence specific to suicide prevention or specifically to shape the Suicide Prevention Strategy.</p><p>And this is an important distinction, as well as being in stark contrast to Scotland where there was a specific two-part process to develop the National Suicide Prevention Strategy.</p><p>In Scotland, as well as having a joint national government and local government approach, via the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (COSLA), there was an initial open engagement exercise with a call for evidence and proposals, and then the draft Suicide Prevention Strategy was put out for detailed public consultation.</p><p>In England, there was no public engagement at all specific to the National Suicide Prevention Strategy, and the draft National Strategy was not put out for public consultation.</p><p>Within the call for evidence around the 10-Year Mental Health Plan, there was a structure based around half a dozen questions, none of which referred to suicide or suicide prevention, and only one of which — around crisis intervention — could readily be related to suicide prevention.</p><p>Obviously, in the absence of an engagement process specifically for the National Suicide Prevention Strategy, people and organisations used the Mental Health Plan to try and put across their experiences and views around suicide prevention; and the National Suicide Prevention Strategy Advisory Group tried to shoe-horn a consultation around suicide prevention into this mental health consultation process.</p><p>Sadly, ironically, among the key points we’d been making for the past 12 months were that ‘suicide is not just a mental health issue’ and it’s problematic when suicide prevention is subsumed within mental health — and we were arguing that DHSC should not be in charge of developing and agreeing the National Suicide Prevention Strategy because of the health bias — and here was DHSC saying that suicide prevention had been covered within the Mental Health Plan process!</p><p>To make matters worse, the Government then announced that it was not going ahead with the 10-Year Mental Health Plan and, instead, was going to merge it into a Major Conditions Strategy that would include conditions like Cancer and Dementia, further watering down its commitment to mental health and doubly watering down any remaining semblance of commitment to suicide prevention.</p><p>The 4th paragraph in ‘the government’s response’, which turned out to be a DHSC response, all makes sense and is obviously designed to be reassuring but it also comes across as dismissive and arrogant because it also ignores the points we made about the flaws in the National Strategy and the National Strategy process and our specific proposal in the petition for a National Suicide Prevention Office for a genuine whole-of-government approach, not the limited and systemically biased approach that results from having ‘the Health Department’ responsible for the National Suicide Prevention Strategy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HCae0PYE4BfRuxm3UqhW7Q.png" /></figure><p>Next the DHSC response says:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KyJE6hVhWrwMx1aK2lHaBA.png" /></figure><p>DHSC may well, in good faith, believe that the actions identified in the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028, “<em>go some way to deliver what this petition seeks to bring forward</em>” but, even then, it’s acknowledging that some only go “<em>some way</em>” and we’d already highlighted the shortfalls and how much further the measures identified in the Strategy need to go:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/the-jordan-legacys-response-to-the-governments-national-suicide-prevention-strategy-2023-2028/">The Jordan Legacy&#39;s Response To The Government&#39;s National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2023-2028 | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>And, as I’ll highlight below, some of the petition proposals are not covered at all by the National Suicide Prevention Strategy, and some of them are not even given the courtesy of a specific response from DHSC which I think is totally unacceptable, making a mockery of this democratic process encouraging people to put forward petitions, get 10,000+ signatures, and have a requirement for a formal written response from ‘the government’.</p><p>So let’s look at the items DHSC does choose to comment on, along with its comments, before highlighting the petition proposals DHSC chose to completely ignore.</p><p>First, there’s a response to the proposal, reiterating the call from the 3 Dads Walking, for suicide prevention education in schools.</p><p>At the time of this response from DHSC, we’d had the 3 Dads Walking petition with 170,000 signatures, and almost universal support for this proposal from those working in suicide prevention, and many MPs had given it their backing in the Westminster Hall Debate that was prompted by the 3 Dads Walking petition; and many ‘experts’ had supported it.</p><p>We should have been well past the ‘whether to’ stage and moving forward with ‘the what, how and who’ but the Department for Education was still stuck in the ‘whether to’ stage.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*teNwHBKlKFOV-yXbunxZUA.png" /></figure><p>Since this response to our petition, there has been some revised guidance for RHSE published which goes part-way to what the advocates, campaigners and experts have been asking for.</p><p>We’ve also now got the report from Nina Smith’s Churchill Fellowship on this very subject, which highlights what is in place in other countries where they are several years down-the-track in having suicide prevention education, and other relevant support, in schools.</p><p>I know DfE has expressed interest in seeing this latest research but with a form of words that sounded typically conservative and defensive, certainly not positive about the opportunity to save lives. That’s obviously their default setting. But hopefully Nina’s report will enlighten and reassure, and help move this forward.</p><p>It’s already had a huge impact with Edge Hill University committing to building suicide prevention education in schools into its teacher training courses, and rolling it out to schools:</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/nina-jo-smith_yesterdays-mental-health-suicide-prevention-activity-7262792242552098816-qAv7?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop">Nina Jo Smith on LinkedIn: Yesterday&amp;#39;s &amp;#39;Mental Health &amp;amp; Suicide Prevention in Education&amp;#39; event at...</a></p><p>Heartwarming!</p><p>Next, DHSC responds to our call for Suicide Prevention Impact Assessments by saying there are plans to launch “<em>a mental health impact assessment tool</em>” as a guidance tool for policymakers.</p><p>This is a fail on several counts.</p><p>We’d actually had a meeting with DHSC 4 months previously where I’d emphasised that what we were proposing was a specific Suicide Prevention Impact Assessment, not a broad ‘mental health impact assessment’.</p><p>I’d also emphasised that it’s much harder to implement a broad tool around mental health than to implement a process focused specifically on suicide risk or benefit so better to start with suicide prevention first.</p><p>And, of course, there is the usual problem of a ‘mental health tool’ treating suicide prevention as ‘a mental health issue’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MgyvrP4jfCv7M3gV5KE_ew.png" /></figure><p>The proposal in the petition was for a Suicide Prevention Impact Assessment before the introduction of any new laws, new policy proposals, and before finalising the recommendations of any major policy review or Inquiry, so not just for ‘policy making’.</p><p>And to be a statutory requirement, not just a guidance tool for policymakers.</p><p>Now it’s possible a defensive DHSC might argue that this level of detail wasn’t apparent from the petition itself, and that would be true, but we had briefed DHSC previously on this detail, we had sent them copies of our response to the National Strategy with our wider proposals, we had sent them links to recordings of webinars where we discussed the proposals in more detail, we had sent them video summaries…</p><h3>Paul Vittles on X (formerly Twitter): &quot;Many of those interviewed in the @jordanlegacyUK action research said we can get the UK suicide numbers down by 50%+ in 5-10 yrs with just a few key measures from government &amp; parliament.Your key action? Help getting signatures on our petition👇https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m pic.twitter.com/5MNs17NR4j / X&quot;</h3><p>Many of those interviewed in the @jordanlegacyUK action research said we can get the UK suicide numbers down by 50%+ in 5-10 yrs with just a few key measures from government &amp; parliament.Your key action? Help getting signatures on our petition👇https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m pic.twitter.com/5MNs17NR4j</p><p>…and they could have asked!</p><p>But that’s a fundamental flaw in the petition process perhaps, that the ‘formal, written response from government’ can be made with no discussion and no attempt to understand the actual proposals they are dismissing!</p><p>This next paragraph (below) reads like a typical piece of government waffle and it’s not clear exactly which of our petition proposals it’s responding to.</p><p>It would have been helpful to have had headings covering each of our proposals.</p><p>I think it’s probably meant to be a response to our proposal for “<em>Establish dedicated crisis support and community support hubs</em>” but our proposal was focused much more on community-based solutions not services within the NHS or ‘health-based places of safety’ although we certainly need all NHS services to be ‘places of safety’ and capable of appropriate and effective triage for anyone experiencing crisis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gT4z1IYnYJHJlxGbCY7ohQ.png" /></figure><p>I’ve since learned about funding from NHS England for 6 pilot projects across the country that will effectively be 24/7 ‘Mental Health Hubs’, and this does sound interesting but, once again, the emphasis is on mental health not suicide prevention specifically, and it looks like these hubs could be in NHS premises rather than in independent community venues, which would be disappointing.</p><p>Next, we have another section of the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England (below) which has been pasted into the DHSC response to the petition without it being clear which particular proposal it’s meant to be responding to:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A5Rd4ArDrC6GBe2HNdjE3g.png" /></figure><p>As it happens, this has subsequently arisen in conversations and exchanges because the National Suicide Prevention Strategy included…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bqiepeIoXy9Pv9_fPlzKSw.png" /></figure><p>…but it hasn’t fulfilled this commitment.</p><p>It’s been a source of particular consternation and frustration for the Construction sector, where many people and organisations are desperate to reduce the suicide rates, because there have been no figures for the sector published by ONS since 2021 — when there were 507 suicides among Construction workers in England &amp; Wales, almost 10% of all suicides in England &amp; Wales.</p><p>This has fuelled (unhealthy) speculation that there’s been a considerable rise in the suicide rate among Construction workers in the past 2 years with the government frightened to publish the figures in the absence of any plan to tackle this problem.</p><p>And there’s one other problem with this text of course…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A5Rd4ArDrC6GBe2HNdjE3g.png" /></figure><p>…which is, as highlighted in my critique of the National Strategy for England, it potentially falls into ‘The Priority Trap’ of trying to prioritise which sectors to focus suicide prevention on rather than trying to reduce the number of suicides in each and every sector by working collaboratively with each and every sector, not turning suicide prevention into a competition!</p><p>Next (below), we have these comments…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Bf3wDHuLur5UQ5VvBTHKTA.png" /></figure><p>…which I think is a response to these particular petition proposals (although, again, it’s not clear because there are no headings and no synchronised order to the DHSC’s responses):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*iXh3It-sDTTc08r37XflbA.png" /></figure><p>The text on the nRTSSS system and data-sharing is fine as far as it goes, but the DHSC response misses the point again because the petition proposal was for statutory local suicide prevention partnerships which would have the necessary authority and funding to be able to effectively and sustainably gather, study, and analyse all the relevant data; plug gaps in the data; work in collaborative partnership with all other relevant local and national bodies; implement a system of Continuous Systemic Action Learning; take appropriate and effective action to reduce suicides in their area; and have continuous review and evaluation of impact.</p><p>This is not what we have.</p><p>Some local partnerships have been able to continue without national funding but many have fallen away as funding has ceased.</p><p>And, as data sets grow, there’s a tendency to start giving greater priority to analysis from national nRTSSS data when, in fact, the greatest value is in local data, local analysis, local collaboration, and local action; which is why we were advocating for well-funded, statutory local partnerships.</p><p>In response to the very specific proposal in the petition…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zns8H4PBNlG7Njz-iq4Oiw.png" /></figure><p>…DHSC’s response was:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JPmpwiDCUij57VtcPf4I2A.png" /></figure><p>At least it accepts that the National Suicide Prevention Strategy doesn’t cover amending the Building Regulations.</p><p>But, once again, it’s a disappointing and frustrating low ambition brush-off.</p><p>The petition was deliberately being very specific with a high ambition proposal designed to have high impact in reducing the suicide numbers.</p><p>We know there are other initiatives being planned or implemented around the country to try and better design the built environment or public spaces to try and reduce the numbers of suicides, but we were suggesting that we raise the bar and go for a whole systems change solution.</p><p>The Building Regulations have had past reviews which have taken into account the physical safety considerations of how to try and prevent accidents and accidental deaths, but not from the perspective of how to try and prevent and minimise suicide deaths and people intentionally trying to harm themselves.</p><p>This point seems to have been lost on DHSC, or deliberately ignored.</p><p>In response to the petition proposal…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/912/1*2YFMJKIM1HhZ9pDFqyo4Dw.png" /></figure><p>…DHSC responded:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dGHgrV7YzelrsRMAJnEe8g.png" /></figure><p>This is another case of not taking any time to understand the actual proposal being put forward here, and it’s indicative of a wider problem within the field of suicide prevention.</p><p>Because anyone experiencing any form of loss or trauma experience is at a heightened risk of suicide, with anyone experiencing any form of traumatic loss being at a considerably higher suicide risk, this proposal was for anyone experiencing any form of loss or trauma to have access to relevant counselling to help them through their loss or trauma experience and thereby reduce their suicide risk.</p><p>The DHSC in its response, as so many people and organisations do, has immediately narrowed the scope down to only those facing bereavement by suicide.</p><p>This is an important sub-group, and we welcome efforts to support those who’ve experienced suicide bereavement, but to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, we must support everyone who experiences any form of loss or trauma — and any form of traumatic loss — who we know can then have a potentially heightened risk of suicide.</p><p>Disturbingly and disrespectfully, there were some of the specific petition proposals that DHSC did not comment on at all in its response.</p><p>One was predictable because we were advocating for a whole-of-government approach via the establishment of a National Suicide Prevention Office (NSPO) which of course would be seen as a threat to DHSC or would be considered by DHSC as not needed…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/804/1*bgbDO7OGX1mZfgEFQw6S9w.png" /></figure><p>…but evidence around the world suggests that you don’t get a genuine whole-of-government response when the National Suicide Prevention Strategy is managed out of ‘the Health Department’; the health bias tends to be locked in.</p><p>This proposal wasn’t commented on at all either:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oZeIKzcpleG-vXUd41Vk5Q.png" /></figure><p>Was it lack of understanding or lack of commitment, or both?</p><p>This proposal was for all government departments, all statutory organisations, all regulated industries, sectors &amp; professions, and ideally all significant sized workplaces to have co-created Suicide Prevention Plans or Zero Suicide Plans, the implementation of Zero Suicide/Zero Suicide Society frameworks, and mandatory suicide prevention training.</p><p>This had been fleshed out in several presentations, webinars, video explainers, and correspondence which had all been forwarded to DHSC (because the word limit constraints of the petitions process can’t do it justice)…</p><p>…but I suspect no-one at DHSC had taken notice because they weren’t interested and/or the person or people who, probably very quickly, wrote the response to the petition (which came out surprisingly quickly!) just tried to brush it off asap and get it off their task list for the week!</p><p>And another important and complex proposal…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VivFSclcEUyxJk3xws3pbA.png" /></figure><p>…did not even get the courtesy of a response.</p><p>Two more specific proposals didn’t get a response, as far as we were concerned.</p><p>For one of these…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TlsIRqsJI_n9gA4tAWbf_A.png" /></figure><p>…DHSC might have thought it had responded because it made some comments about lived experience input…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yjQyoo4gPihkaIsSlg3kgg.png" /></figure><p>…but we’d already emphasised that the level of lived experience input into the Strategy was poor and inadequate in our view, and that the bar needed to be raised much higher for future Lived Experience Involvement.</p><p>Revealingly, when we first submitted the petition, the civil servant we were dealing with had taken out the specific proposal for ‘lived experience input’ and it appeared they didn’t really understand what this was, which I mentioned in the video explainer for the petition proposals:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBZF5ImKBeN4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href">https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href</a></iframe><p>We explained that it was crucial, the foundation stone for the Zero Suicide Society approach, and we were talking about a diverse mix of people with lived experience of suicide being involved in the development of the co-created Suicide Prevention Plans and Zero Suicide Strategies we’d proposed.</p><p>The other omission is also revealing.</p><p>We wanted proposals for reducing suicides among workers and we specifically wanted the RIDDOR requirements to be changed:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YCId04DXZuF6lHFMTibmTQ.png" /></figure><p>The civil servant we were dealing with said they thought suicide was covered by existing legislation so we had to explain that the reporting requirements explicitly excluded investigating suspected suicides, which was precisely why we were asking for this change.</p><p>Here’s a post I did about this on LinkedIn:</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/paulvittles_workplace-healthandsafety-suicideprevention-activity-7129707955112812544-APfZ?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop">Paul Vittles on LinkedIn: #workplace #healthandsafety #suicideprevention | 16 comments</a></p><p>And here on Twitter:</p><h3>Paul Vittles on X (formerly Twitter): &quot;If there was a suicide in your workplace or you lost a colleague to suicide after they&#39;d been struggling at work, you&#39;d expect it to be investigated right? Learn lessons? Prevent future deaths?Current #HealthAndSafety laws stop this even being reported!https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m pic.twitter.com/OTIGTfbNZK / X&quot;</h3><p>If there was a suicide in your workplace or you lost a colleague to suicide after they&#39;d been struggling at work, you&#39;d expect it to be investigated right? Learn lessons? Prevent future deaths?Current #HealthAndSafety laws stop this even being reported!https://t.co/PoPp9K6I9m pic.twitter.com/OTIGTfbNZK</p><p>And, after all that, DHSC did not even bother to respond to this specific proposal!</p><p>Which is another reason why we were advocating for a National Suicide Prevention Office not managing the National Suicide Prevention Strategy out of the Health Department where they often don’t understand these issues or don’t have the appetite for driving such changes, or both.</p><p><strong>You cannot be serious DHSC!</strong></p><p>And then, last not least, we have the ultimate piss-take from DHSC.</p><p>After making a submission to the DHSC VCSE Suicide Prevention Grant Fund for funding to support the roll out of the #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Transformation Programme, with a much more ambitious suicide prevention strategy than the National Strategy for England, and after publicly exposing the sham of the the Fund, with only 5% of applicants getting any funding, and 25% of the total funds going to just 4 charities, including 2 big national charities that, as I’ve explained, I didn’t think were eligible for this money, and shouldn’t have even applied for it, DHSC included this as the sign-off for its response to our petition!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DDhlFbYNadLlzSiMbjBgug.png" /></figure><p><strong>But we press on!</strong></p><p>With the petition proposals having been rudely ignored; govt/Govt having demonstrated their lack of commitment to suicide prevention; no serious consideration having been given to more ambitious proposals to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero; no funding being made available to support an alternative high ambition strategy; and many people &amp; organisations in what is increasingly, disturbingly, called “<em>the suicide prevention sector</em>” — or I’ve even heard “<em>our industry</em>”! — appearing to support the woefully low ambition National Strategy and make comments like “<em>the National Strategy is what it is, we just need to support it now</em>” and “<em>our job is to implement the National Strategy</em>”…</p><p>…I had to just press on with rolling out the #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Transformation Programme without any public funding or grants or government backing.</p><p>And that’s what I did, with some initial support from The Jordan Legacy, then setting up a new, dedicated, for-purpose business Towards Zero Suicide CIC, rolling out the Programme via the Humber-to-Mersey JoinTheDotsTour…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FFbYqHYclcnA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DFbYqHYclcnA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FFbYqHYclcnA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href">https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href</a></iframe><p>…and then embedding the Programme with our initial collaborative partners, with a view to then gradually and organically expanding the Programme.</p><p>The Tour made its way across the M62 Corridor, arriving in Liverpool, as planned, to dovetail with the 5th Global Zero Suicide Summit — strictly speaking, the International Zero Suicide in Healthcare Summit — which I attended on 24/25 June:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FtyaY1MbGgXY%3Fstart%3D3%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D3&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DtyaY1MbGgXY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FtyaY1MbGgXY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a60c86d5e9ce40b98afed1506ed53151/href">https://medium.com/media/a60c86d5e9ce40b98afed1506ed53151/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Follow-up and follow-through — the hard yards of suicide reduction</strong></p><p>Learning from previous Tours and major campaigns and awareness-raising initiatives, where I’d heard lots of complaints about the organisers “<em>completely disappearing at the end of the Tour</em>”, probably exhausted, as it’s tough to organise these types of major events and initiatives, I allocated the whole of July to follow-ups and follow-throughs, as we’d connected with more than 3,000 people from 550 organisations, and developed or deepened relationships in the 15 towns &amp; cities the Tour had visited.</p><p><strong>The General Election — did it make any difference?!</strong></p><p>And on 4 July, of course, it was the General Election with the expected win for the Labour Party, and a much bigger win than many had expected, including the polls, so we had a new Labour Government.</p><p>The outgoing Conservative Government had been ‘in power’ for 14 years, from 2010 to 2024, with its first National Suicide Prevention Strategy published in 2012, and the Mental Health Minister, Maria Caulfield, had told the nation on BBC Breakfast, and elsewhere, that there had been “<em>considerable progress since 2012</em>”, which was repeating the first line in the Executive Summary of the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England that so many people and organisations had signed up to:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D3H4OIW2bcGhk6e2RxatXA.png" /></figure><p>We now know that the Conservative Hall of Shame — led by Cameron, May, Johnson, Truss, and Sunak — had presided over the highest increase in the suicide numbers of any Government since records began.</p><p>It had been extremely hard to justify a claim of ‘considerable progress since 2012’ when this claim was initially made in September 2023.</p><p>It’s impossible to defend now we have the latest data for 2023.</p><p>So having waved goodbye to the worst Government in history for suicide prevention, we all thought the new Government must be better right?</p><p>But, so far, so little.</p><p>Nothing in the action plans for the first 100 days; nothing in the King’s Speech; nothing in their first Budget; no new funding; no new ideas; no interest in the more ambitious strategies we put forward; no dedicated Minister for Suicide Prevention (not even a Mental Health Minister); and appearing to embrace the previous Government’s woefully low ambition National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028, without raising the bar.</p><p><strong>Whole system change needed, not just another bunch of politicians!</strong></p><p>But, as the analysis above shows, especially the appalling response from DHSC which probably had no involvement from the politicians, and the way so many people &amp; organisations working in suicide prevention have seemingly happily got into bed with low ambition and are not actively agitating for a much more ambitious Suicide Prevention Strategy — just asking for more money, which is part of the answer but only part — we can’t just blame the Labour Party for the inertia since July, just as we probably shouldn’t just blame the Conservative Party for the lack of ambition in the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028.</p><p>One of the most depressing things I saw after the General Election was this post on LinkedIn by the CEO of one of the UK’s biggest suicide prevention charities, PAPYRUS:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gczY-7EBSd7JqibHjhir5Q.png" /></figure><p>Now, first let me say that I spend a fair amount of time promoting the services that PAPYRUS provides, and did so during the #JoinTheDotsTour Launch Conference and throughout the Tour; I have worked happily with many PAPYRUS staff; I’ve supported the PAPYRUS ambassadors, 3 Dads Walking, from the very beginning of their walks; I walked with the 3 Dads Walking for a day in April this year, and I invited Mike Palmer to be on our stage at our Launch Conference for our panel on suicide prevention education in schools — I try to do all I can to be collaborative, and I will continue to promote PAPYRUS and HOPELINE.</p><p>But I couldn’t let these comments on LinkedIn from the PAPYRUS CEO go because it just sounded defeatist and lacking in ambition to say “<em>I have no particular ‘ask’ of the new Government other than that it see suicide as a preventable death</em>”.</p><p>I thought “<em>surely PAPYRUS should be well prepared and have very specific ‘asks’ from the Government?</em>’’ and I was also frustrated by the comments from the PAPYRUS CEO (and others on his thread) being negative about ‘Zero Suicide’ and, by association, being negative about the Zero Suicide Society Programme, which is clearly designed to break through the inertia and get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero suicide.</p><p>So I replied…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5juDMhuTPRauiWPL56gZWA.png" /></figure><p>…which led to some rather nasty personal abuse in other reply comments but more understanding from others after I’d had the chance to explain the serious points I was making, and explain more about the Zero Suicide and Zero Suicide Society philosophies, visions &amp; frameworks.</p><p>The lasting impact was thinking ‘myself and all my collaborative partners, of which 80% are people with lived experience of suicide, are trying to make change happen from the ground-up and, occasionally, from the top down, eg via the petition proposals, and we’ve invested huge effort in collating all the practical actions we can take ourselves and all the actions we need others to take, including Govt/govt/parliament, and published all of this, and toured the country with it with enthusiastic support from hundreds of local charities and CICs (and wonderful practical support in each location from Samaritans incidentally), and tried unsuccessfully to get funding from DHSC (whilst others have got £500K+), and tried to get our alternative, high ambition suicide prevention strategies, plans and ‘specific asks’ in front of the new Labour Government…</p><p>…and here’s one of the most powerful and influential people in ‘the suicide prevention sector’, heading up one of the biggest national charities, and he doesn’t have any particular ‘ask’ of the new Government and no expectations of the new Government <em>“other than that it see suicide as a preventable death</em>”.</p><p>I find that very sad and quite depressing!</p><p><strong>Final Reflections</strong></p><p>Once again, at least it makes it clear that those of us who are out there trying to make a difference from the ground-up; who are ambitious; who want to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero; and who believe we can get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero suicide…</p><p>…probably aren’t going to get much support, if any, from the top down, whether that be the Government, government, DHSC, or the big national charities like PAPYRUS — although thank you once again Samaritans for all your practical support for our Summer Tour.</p><p>I believe that we can and we should continue to support the services that the big charities like PAPYRUS provide to support children and young people, but we know we can’t rely on them to support our advocacy and campaigning efforts to get the suicide numbers down for people of all ages; the 6,000+ preventable suicide deaths we have each year in the UK.</p><p>We know that the big national charities like PAPYRUS (and probably Samaritans, and I was told Mind as well) are very unlikely to support our petitions and national campaigns, so where does that leave us?</p><p>I’m not actually sure.</p><p>I have some ideas, but I’m not sure at this stage about the best way forward, and I’m open to ideas.</p><p>Meanwhile, I’ll just continue to focus on the further roll out of the #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Transformation Programme, and all the national projects and transformational change initiatives I’m involved in, most of which don’t involve Government or government, though some necessarily must do at some point…</p><p>…and which generally don’t usually involve the bigger national charities, or those charities and CICs that are growing and becoming bigger and tending to become more distant as they grow.</p><p>I’m a grassroots, from-the-ground-up, advocate and campaigner at heart, but I know we need to find a way to get some big changes from the top down.</p><p>Hopefully, some of those reading this analysis of the petition proposals — which, remember, were co-created from a research and engagement project (including interviewing people from PAPYRUS and Samaritans, and the 3 Dads Walking, and people working in the NHS, and employers, and people with lived experience of suicide, etc) — and they will want to see some of these specific ‘asks’ advancing in the course of this parliament.</p><p>And the sooner the better, because every month we don’t have these measures, it’s another 500+ preventable suicide deaths in the UK.</p><p>The baton is sitting there ready to be picked up by anyone or any organisation or group or coalition wanting to advocate or campaign for these specific measures and practical actions that most of those we interviewed said would get the suicide numbers down, towards zero.</p><p>We may have a new Government, but nothing has changed in terms of these actions still being the actions that will get the suicide numbers down.</p><p>Are we perhaps pointing the finger too much at the politicians because to have a more ambitious suicide prevention strategy, and to raise the bar in terms of actions, urgent actions, we don’t just need the Government to change, we need the government to change; we need a change of attitudes and behaviour from the kinds of civil servants that wrote the appalling response to the petition proposals; and we need a step change from those directly responsible for the National Suicide Prevention Strategy because the current Strategy is simply not good enough.</p><p>As I said in my critique of the National Strategy, we probably also need some fresh people involved, including a new lead adviser to govt/Govt, given his unhelpful low ambition language in his Foreword to the National Strategy document.</p><p>Anyone who is willing and able to move any of the specific petition proposals forward is free to do so.</p><p>They are not my proposals, or Steve Phillip’s proposals. or Towards Zero Suicide CIC’s proposals or The Jordan Legacy’s proposals, or even the proposals of all those who took part in the action research and engagement project in 2023, they are just a list of proposals that most of those working in suicide prevention told us would get the suicide numbers down, and down considerably. They are a shared resource.</p><p>A key factor in successful collaboration and collective impact is not trying to ‘own’ ideas and get obsessive about your personal or organisational ‘brand’ but to share visions, strategies, plans, actions, petition proposals as truly collective entities…and welcome efforts to take these forward to achieve shared goals in line with shared values.</p><p>Also, although the petition proposals were aimed firmly at national Govt/govt/parliament, more could be done at a local level to take these petition proposals forward, perhaps even as a demonstration for national government of commitment and of ‘what works’.</p><p>For example, a local council or ICB or combined authority or elected mayor could adopt many of the petition proposals, eg Suicide Prevention Impact Assessments for all new policies, Zero Suicide Plans, mandatory training.</p><p>Please do not hesitate to contact me if you want to know more detail or if I can assist in any way.</p><p>I am always happy to help if it potentially can prevent or reduce suicides.</p><p>Finally, writing this piece, and the deep thinking which goes into writing a piece like this, to get the transformational change we need — the systems change, policy change, structural change, and cultural change that will get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero suicide, not just superficial ‘awareness-raising campaigns’— we need more people and organisations to not just be ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’ but to firmly, clearly, and passionately be ‘in the Suicide Reduction business’!</p><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles is Chief Facilitator for the ZeroSuicideSociety JoinTheDots Transformation Programme, and Founder of Towards Zero Suicide CIC, and he designed &amp; delivered the Humber-to-Mersey JoinTheDotsTour, comprising 19 major events in 15 towns &amp; cities in 2 weeks in June 2024.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul is a Research Fellow, consultant, coach, counsellor, and ‘transformational change expert’ who has worked in the field of transformational change via community engagement for 40 years and is now focused on the transformational change challenge of getting the (UK) suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero suicide, via systems change, policy change, structural change, and cultural change.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul works in collaborative partnership with many people and organisations who share the same goals, the same values, the belief that we must get the suicide numbers down, the belief that we can get the suicide numbers down, towards zero, a desire to be part of a Zero Suicide Society community that is #InThisTogether…</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>…and, as Paul says at business conferences as he tries to ‘get outside the suicide prevention bubble’ and draw more people into the transformational change challenge, when asked what business he is in, he says and he encourages everyone else in the room or at the venue to say…</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>…we’re in the hope business!</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*bfzyc9w5zE46j-o490CvtQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18ea8dd63dfd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Take the Training, Have a Conversation…about Suicide!]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/take-the-training-have-a-conversation-about-suicide-c5e2b977963b?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c5e2b977963b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wellness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Jul 2024 14:50:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-21T03:51:40.482Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Asimple message that could save hundreds of thousands of lives in the UK, and millions around the world.</em></strong></p><p>This piece draws from the Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey, which I designed &amp; developed as The Jordan Legacy’s collaborative partner); also from other research &amp; engagement I’ve undertaken since returning to the UK in August 2019; and from interactions on the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour, 11–23 June 2024.</p><p><strong>Suicide Prevention Training — the Problem, the Opportunity!</strong></p><p>Firstly, let me just give you some headline figures before a few sensitivity messages and then more detail behind the survey and more depth on the crucially important topic of training to facilitate an informed, competent, confident conversation about suicide &amp; suicide prevention.</p><p>This includes, in this particular write up, why people should ‘take the training, have a conversation’; why employers should make sure their managers &amp; employees ‘take the training, have a conversation’; and why funding should be made available to support ‘take the training, have a conversation’ — both the human/moral/ethical case and ‘the business case’.</p><p>The dark green line in the graph below shows there’s been a significant increase in the proportion of people having some form of mental health training, from 10% in Autumn 2022 to 14% in the two most recent surveys, although that’s still only 1 in 7 people in the UK.</p><p>The light green line shows there’s been no change in the proportion of UK adults (aged 16+) having some form of suicide prevention training.</p><p>It’s just 6% of the population who’ve had suicide prevention training.</p><p>Or, to put it another way, 94% haven’t!</p><p>This is literally life-saving training, which also has many other benefits through the transferable skills &amp; knowledge it imparts, and yet 94% of the population have not yet benefitted from it!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lf7HsU38dsu3Uchcb6EjNA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Those Who Need It Most Are Not ‘Taking The Training’!</strong></p><p>Shockingly, it’s not just the general public.</p><p>We often hear of staff who’ve worked in the NHS for many years not getting this training, like Sam Southern from Blackpool, who lost her husband Glen to suicide in June 2020, the day before Fathers’ Day, leaving Sam with 6 kids, the youngest aged 2 and 5, her life (and those kids’ lives) devastated by suicide.</p><p>Sam worked in the NHS for 17 years but never had any suicide prevention training so she didn’t know how to talk about suicide or how to ‘spot the signs’ and was totally shocked when she lost Glen to suicide — feeling totally helpless, then feeling guilty for not having sought training or education to be able to prevent a potentially preventable death by suicide.</p><p>Sadly, and many might say tragically, we regularly hear about GPs who’ve had no formal training in suicide prevention, because there’s no legal or regulatory requirement for them to have such training.</p><p>They do have to have annual training in other disciplines, like CPR (Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation), where they have to take the training and demonstrate they’ve taken the training, with annual audits.</p><p>But, revealingly, many GPs say the last time they had to use their CPR training to resuscitate someone was 10 or 15 years ago, whilst they have people in their medical centres having thoughts of suicide every week.</p><p>So they have annual training and annual audits for a skill they might use once every 10 years, but often nothing for a skill they might need every week, ie having a conversation with someone experiencing thoughts about ending their life.</p><p><strong>You &amp; Your Organisation or Community Need to ‘Take the Training’!</strong></p><p>Now, at this point, you might be thinking ‘ah, so GPs and NHS staff need training in suicide prevention, but not me and not my organisation’?</p><p>Wrong thinking I’m afraid.</p><p>Anyone can be affected by suicide, and everyone can help prevent suicides.</p><p>And just one suicide — a single preventable suicide death — can have a devastating impact on your workplace, workforce, community, school, college, university, social club, sports team, family, friendship circle.</p><p>There’s a known ripple effect.</p><p>Two studies — one in the US by Julie Cerel, one in the UK by Suicide Bereavement UK — both found that for every death by suicide, an average of 135 people are directly adversely impacted by that single death.</p><p>And that’s before we start talking about the impact of a suicide attempt, with estimates of at least 20 suicide attempts for each suicide death; with many people personally experiencing a suicide attempt; or needing to support people through suicide attempts; or witnessing a suicide attempt; inc learning that those who make a suicide attempt have a high likelihood of making another attempt; learning that those bereaved by suicide have a higher likelihood of taking their own lives because of the inconsolable grief combined with guilt &amp; shame, and other adverse impacts due to stigma.</p><p><strong>The Human &amp; Economic Cost…and Our Opportunity!</strong></p><p>So there’s a massive impact on a human emotional &amp; psychological level.</p><p>It also impacts on business performance &amp; productivity.</p><p>‘The business case’ for investing in suicide prevention training is very strong.</p><p>Someone impacted by suicide loss, or knowing someone experiencing a suicide crisis, or someone experiencing a suicide crisis themselves, or someone having thoughts about ending their lives, or someone witnessing a suicide or suicide attempt…is not a fully engaged, productive, high-performing worker.</p><p>It’s part of the calculation taken into account by top economists like David McDaid from the London School of Economics (LSE) in his report for the Samaritans, published in March 2024, The Economic Cost of Suicide, which calculated that preventable suicide deaths cost the UK economy almost £10 billion per annum (yes, that’s £10 BILLION PER YEAR — worth bearing in mind when the Government says it can’t fund suicide prevention!), and each individual suicide death costs, on average, £1.46 million:</p><iframe src="https://drive.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=https%3A//media.samaritans.org/documents/The_economic_cost_of_suicide_in_the_UK_-_web.pdf&amp;embedded=true" width="600" height="780" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7ab662629dfed93877e449072cd29d22/href">https://medium.com/media/7ab662629dfed93877e449072cd29d22/href</a></iframe><p>We also have robust research now from sources like Deloitte, across many studies, across many countries, showing that poor mental health costs UK employers £51 billion a year (yes, that’s £51 BILLION PER YEAR!)…</p><p>…and, in addition to the poor mental health of employees themselves, most are caring for children, older people or people with disabilities, and an increasing number of people with mental health issues needing support or treatment, with unacceptably long waiting lists for NHS Mental Health Services (did you know that people who tell their GP they’re having thoughts of ending their lives are frequently put on a waiting list for assessment or treatment, for 3–6 months?!)…</p><p>…and 46% of working parents are concerned about their children’s mental health (did you know that, in 2023, the waiting list for children referred to NHS Mental Health Services clicked over 1 million?!)…</p><p><a href="https://www.deloitte.com/uk/en/about/press-room/poor-mental-health-costs-uk-employers-51-billion-a-year-for-employees.html">Poor mental health costs UK employers £51 billion a year for employees</a></p><p>However, here’s another crucially important finding from this impressive body of work, and it’s a positive number this time.</p><p>Deloitte’s latest calculations from evaluating a range of mental health at work initiatives is that the average return on investment in support of mental health at work is £4.70 for every £1 invested.</p><p><strong>Creating &amp; Sustaining a Mentally Healthy, Psychologically Safe Workplace Saves Lives; Helps You Be an Employer of Choice; Optimises Performance &amp; Productivity; and Helps You Achieve Sustainable Success</strong></p><p>Studies now show that around half of employees have left a workplace because of a poor mental health environment, and employees seeking work are increasingly looking for a positive, supportive, mentally healthy, psychologically safe workplace where they can survive and thrive.</p><p>There’s often talk about being “<em>an Employer of Choice</em>” and competing in a tough market to “<em>recruit and retain talent</em>” but if you don’t create and sustain the right environment to make employees and potential employees feel it’s a safe, supportive space they’ll leave, or they’ll stay and not be productive, not perform, they’ll add to absenteeism levels or — often harder to spot this one and certainly harder to monitor &amp;measure — to presenteeism levels.</p><p>And these ‘cases’ will often end in messy disputes, appeals, tribunals, compensation claims, pain &amp; suffering in court or out-of-court settlements, which no-one really wants; which costs employers financially; which costs employees &amp; managers in terms of their health; and which creates suicide risk for all caught up in the mess.</p><p>Also, in a ground-breaking study I carried out in Australia in 2014, taking Nobel Prize winning Econometrics and applying it to the Employer of Choice concept to measure sub-conscious drivers of choices — by flashing randomised job offers or workplace scenarios in front of employees on the screen and asking them to just click ‘Yes or No’, with the computer analysis calculating what was driving their choices without them even realising it — a mentally healthy, psychologically safe workplace environment where it’s possible to talk about topics like mental health &amp; suicide is second only to pay in driving employees’ workplace choices:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*loSi4iLFmP4DG4Iw9EJ_zw.png" /><figcaption>Employer of Choice ‘choice modelling’ study carried out by Paul Vittles in Australia in 2014, when he was Director with Instinct and Reason, for the Mentally Healthy Workplace Alliance and the Heads Up initiative established by BeyondBlue</figcaption></figure><p>Note that in the screenshot slide above, it refers to an ROI of $2.30 per $1 invested in mental health, which was a pioneering study in Australia in 2014 (just 10 years ago — this is all still new!) by PriceWaterhouseCoopers.</p><p>As previously highlighted, this work has since been developed around the world by Deloitte, including in the UK; it’s much more sophisticated now; and the latest estimate of ROI is £4.70 for every £1 invested.</p><p>Another Australian reference I can point you to, which I originally designed in 2014 and carried out the first published survey in 2015, although it’s been significantly developed and enhanced by many very smart people since, is the SuperFriend ‘Indicators of a Thriving Workplace Survey’, now in its 9th year with an expanded sample size of 10,000 to enable analysis by sector or industry:</p><p><a href="https://www.superfriend.com.au/research/workplace-mental-health-statistics">Latest Workplace Mental Health Statistics - ITW 2023 | Superfriend</a></p><p>For those not aware, SuperFriend is an excellent not-for-profit mental health &amp; suicide prevention foundation set up in Australia in 2007 by the insurance &amp; superannuation sector due to enlightened self-interest, as they were finding that half, or even more than half, of workplace claims were mental health related, not physical health, injury or disability, with emerging data — 17 years ago! — of the economic cost of suicide as well as the human cost.</p><p><strong>The Human Devastation &amp; Business Disruption of a Suicide Death</strong></p><p>The macro numbers can seem distant from your own situation but one of the saddest aspects of suicide specifically is that I have these two experiences, alongside each other, at least once a month:</p><ol><li>I speak with employers and managers to try to get them on board with suicide prevention initiatives to avoid experiencing the devastation that just one suicide can cause, but they resist; they find it too hard to talk about it; they fear talking about suicide; they don’t think they’re going to be affected; they don’t think suicide prevention is a priority for their workplace; and they say they don’t have the resources, not even the money to fund some basic training.</li><li>I get a call from a chairman, CEO, senior leader or business owner to say “<em>we’ve just had a suicide death, everyone is devastated, we don’t know what to do, can you help us?</em>”</li></ol><p>This is why we call what we do suicide PREVENTION, trying to avoid Scenario 2 by challenging the institutionalised inertia of Scenario 1.</p><p>I also once worked with an electricity distribution business that had a suspected suicide (was it an accident, was it a suicide, will we ever know?!) and ‘live wire work’ was completely suspended for 3 months, costing the company millions &amp; millions of dollars.</p><p>Now most businesses won’t have this specific human &amp; financial cost outlined above but you might have your equivalent, depending on who you lose to suicide, how you lose them, where, when &amp; why.</p><p>Those bereaved by suicide, including your colleagues (or clients or key customers or business partners) will agonise for years about the ‘why’ question, and ‘was there anything else we could have done?’, often concluding that there was, resulting in a huge burden of guilt.</p><p>Losing a colleague to suicide, like losing a family member or friend, can mean not wanting to go to a certain location any more, or not travel by a certain means of transport, or not want to work on the ‘anniversary’ of their death. It can disrupt lives and businesses for many, many years.</p><p>And those witnessing a suicide (or suicide attempt) are deeply affected, not only wrestling with the ‘why?’ question but also with the ‘who?’ question as they didn’t know the person or their loved ones or their colleagues or the other people who also had this most distressing witness experience.</p><p>====<strong>A SHORT INTERMISSION WITH SOME IMPORTANT MESSAGES</strong>====</p><p>If you quote any of the results from this survey/this report, please give your source as the ‘Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey’, and please link to this published summary to ensure accuracy, to avoid misrepresentation of the data, and to spread the word about the need for us all to ‘take the training, have a conversation’.</p><p>Please also note the following.</p><p>Given the subject matter, all those taking part in the survey are directed to appropriate sources of support.</p><p>If you or anyone you know needs support, there are many options (and it’s important to know there are many options!), including via the Resources page on The Jordan Legacy website…</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/help-resources/">Help &amp; Resources | Suicide Prevention | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>…and this excellent set of resources from Grassroots Suicide Prevention:</p><p><a href="https://prevent-suicide.org.uk/asknowsavelives/">Ask now, save lives - Grassroots Suicide Prevention</a></p><p>Please also check out local sources &amp; services in your area, including your local Suicide Prevention Lead (if you have one), your local Public Health team, and by putting your postcode into the Hub of Hope:</p><p><a href="https://hubofhope.co.uk/">Hub of Hope - Mental Health Support Network provided by Chasing the Stigma</a></p><p>Of course, this write-up is going to be covering the subject of suicide (along with the positive and hopeful subject of suicide prevention!) so if you find this triggering or distressing in any way, please seek support (using the help &amp; resources outlined above or other familiar sources).</p><p>Please be reassured by the number of amazing people working to prevent suicides and reduce the number of suicides, like those we had on our stage and in our audience at the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour Launch Conference at The Baths Hall on Wed 12 June…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F48blmJWg1aE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D48blmJWg1aE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F48blmJWg1aE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b0df403747611590821ebc904c3dc093/href">https://medium.com/media/b0df403747611590821ebc904c3dc093/href</a></iframe><p>…and all those we interacted with throughout the Tour across the M62 Corridor:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FFbYqHYclcnA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DFbYqHYclcnA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FFbYqHYclcnA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href">https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href</a></iframe><p>=======END OF INTERMISSION WITH IMPORTANT MESSAGES=======</p><p><strong>Gaining Competence &amp; Confidence through Suicide Prevention Training: High &amp; Immediate Impact</strong></p><p>Now, here’s some really important messages about suicide prevention training that should be of interest to everyone because anyone can be affected by suicide and everyone can help prevent suicide.</p><p>I highlighted earlier that only 6% of the UK population have ever had any suicide prevention training, so that means 94% haven’t had any.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fVuP2BZb51uq7x8ogxPykA.png" /><figcaption>Based on the Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Survey (a nationally representative sample of 1,900 UK adults aged 16+ surveyed in Spring 2024), only 6% have had any suicide prevention training and 58% say they haven’t got any information, training or support from any of these sources, although 1 in 6 say “Learned from listening to someone who has had suicidal thoughts or experienced a suicidal crisis”.</figcaption></figure><p>This is a major problem.</p><p>But it’s also an incredible opportunity.</p><p>Imagine how many lives we could save if we could get the number having life-saving suicide prevention training to 10%, 25%, 50%, 75%?</p><p>Imagine how many of the 6,000+ preventable suicide deaths in the UK every year — more than 100,000 preventable suicide deaths since the suicide rate was halted in its long-term downward trend in 2007 — we could avert if we all had some basic suicide prevention training?</p><p>Imagine how many of the 200 school-age children we lose to suicide each year in the UK could still be alive if we all — including all parents, all teachers &amp; all schools’ staff — had some basic suicide prevention training?</p><p>Imagine how many of the 100 university &amp; higher education students we lose to suicide each year could still be alive if we all — including all lecturers &amp; teaching staff, all university administrators, all parents and all other students — had some basic training in suicide prevention, including being aware of how almost all suicide deaths in universities are preventable?</p><p>Imagine what could be different if we all took some time out to ‘take the training, have a conversation’ — changing the current situation where suicide is the biggest killer of women aged under 35 and the biggest killer of men aged under 50, with the majority of those ending their lives each year being in employment, often working in offices, shops, factories, building sites (10% of all suicides are Construction workers!) and spending more time at work than at home in many cases?</p><p>Some people, who are not currently knowledgeable about suicide &amp; suicide prevention, might be thinking “<em>it’s too hard…I haven’t got time…we haven’t got the resources…we don’t have a training budget…</em>”.</p><p>Well, here’s a challenging thought.</p><p>If you click on this QR code, it takes you to an online training course on the Zero Suicide Alliance (ZSA) website on how to have a conversation about suicide —ie ‘take the training, have a conversation’! — and it’s just 20 mins and it’s free:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GGSvXoIhRoWBaKyMePykmg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Here I am ready to go on-the-road with the #ZeroSuicideSociety (model &amp; framework left) #JoinTheDotsTour from the Humber to the Mersey, 11–23 June, and the Key Messages (right) including ‘Take the training, have a conversation’ with the QR Code that takes people through to the Zero Suicide Alliance’s free online courses.</figcaption></figure><p>“<em>Only 20 minutes — is that enough?</em>” I hear you say, and maybe “<em>is this serious training?</em>”.</p><p>Yes, it’s serious training, it’s very serious training.</p><p>It’s evidence-based; it’s informed by people with lived experience of suicide (eg people bereaved by suicide or who’ve lived through a suicide attempt); it’s NHS-endorsed; it’s been taken 2.7 million times (good, but not good enough!); and it covers the basics you need to have a conversation about suicide and potentially save lives.</p><p>And it’s online, it takes just 20 mins, and it’s free — why isn’t everyone taking this training?!</p><p>It also covers transferable life skills that can help you in all aspects of life, work, career &amp; relationships, eg spotting signs, asking direct questions, listening, having difficult conversations, signposting to help available.</p><p>Is it enough?</p><p>No, it’s probably not enough, but it’s a start.</p><p>And the 20-mins Zero Suicide Alliance course is called ‘Gateway’ training.</p><p>It’s designed to be a starter, to quickly learn the basics, and then you can go on (some people within each workplace, sports club, community, school, etc at least) to undertake more intensive, longer-form training in accredited courses like ASIST and Suicide First Aid (and the suicide prevention components within the Mental Health First Aid programme).</p><p>If, like 94% of the population, you haven’t had any suicide prevention training, our Survey suggests that you’re likely to be feeling you don’t have the skills or the confidence to ‘have a conversation’ about suicide or to talk suicide prevention.</p><p>Indeed, just being told to ‘have a conversation’ or just ‘talk about suicide’ is scary, even traumatising, so please ‘take the training’ THEN ‘have a conversation’.</p><p>More than half the adult population are not confident about “<em>How to best ask someone if they are having suicidal thoughts</em>” (57%) or “<em>How best to continue the conversation if someone says they are thinking about suicide</em>” (51%) — two core topics covered in all the training courses, along with “<em>How to spot the signs that someone is at risk of suicide</em>” (55% not confident):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lNbe62aexmc0bnmRoIdtew.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>In addition, more than 2 in 5 (44%) are not confident about “<em>How to spot the signs that someone might be struggling with their mental health</em>”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-LBQqFbtIBlsCJbDuR9zwg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>If, however, you’re among the 6% of the population who’ve had some suicide prevention training, the confidence levels are radically different.</p><p>Listening to ‘lived experience voices’ certainly helps, as does having broader mental health training with a suicide prevention component, eg Mental Health First Aid (MHFA) but the biggest impact is from specific suicide prevention training.</p><p>Compared with more than half the population not confident about starting or continuing a conversation about suicide, it’s only around a quarter for those who’ve had suicide prevention training — a huge impact.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*avTfL-MEK5tP5c8Jo8b5qQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>The impact of the suicide prevention training is also in confidence levels for “<em>How to spot the signs that someone might be at risk of suicide</em>” — 55% of the whole population not confident, but just 21% of those who’ve taken had suicide prevention training — and “<em>Where to direct someone for support if they are at risk of suicide</em>” — 44% of the population not confident, but only 13% of those who’ve had suicide prevention training being ‘not confident’.</p><p>And this is probably all you need to know to have confidence that investing in suicide prevention training has a positive impact, often a considerable positive impact, and an immediate impact.</p><p>I’ve also facilitated peer support groups for those who’ve ‘taken the training’ and they often give examples of how they’ve put the training into practice, how they’re more confident generally, and — in particular — how they’re now confident (or at least less uncomfortable) asking the key direct questions “<em>Have you had thoughts about ending your own life?</em>” and “<em>Have you made a plan to end your life?</em>”.</p><p>The evidence is clear that asking these very direct questions doesn’t harm (you can’t make someone suicidal by asking the question), it just helps (people who are suicidal are often relieved that someone has at last asked these questions); and these questions must be asked in order to save lives, prevent suicides, and reduce the suicide numbers.</p><p>I highlighted these points — including covering ‘facts &amp; myths’ — in the write-up from the first wave of the Survey in 2022, which was a written piece accompanied by an online presentation and a panel discussion event, involving two highly experienced training providers, who also both have lived experience of self-harm &amp; suicide:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/lets-talk-about-suicide-35e4706f6bf7">Let’s Talk about Suicide</a></p><p><strong>This is Simple &amp; Straightforward: Let’s Not Make It Complicated!</strong></p><p>As a Research Fellow, and prominent suicide prevention consultant, coach &amp; counsellor, I often get asked about academic research studies which people claim, for example, “<em>show that MHFA doesn’t have any measurable positive impact, which is concerning</em>”.</p><p>And I also hear the usual calls for “<em>more research</em>” and “<em>more sophisticated research</em>” including “<em>the gold standard in research — randomised control trials</em>”.</p><p>I understand the needs of some people, including the academic research community and some corporate leaders, to feel as if the research has been more intensive and/or more extensive but this can become a barrier to getting the basic training ‘out there’ which then provides more scope for more and better ‘real world impact’ studies, rather than technically more sophisticated research which can be divorced from the real world.</p><p>When I take a closer look at the academic and applied research that has been done to date, there are 3 key issues I’d highlight.</p><p>Firstly, some of these studies have been carried out by people who’ve been openly critical of training programmes like MHFA because they see a lot of aggressive promotion of these courses, a corporatisation and almost commodification, with mass ‘box ticking’ to be able to say “<em>all our staff have had training</em>”. So, there might be a bias there and/or a reflection of the reality that there’s a lot of ‘box ticking’ in the ‘mental health market’.</p><p>Secondly, most of these studies have tended to focus on broader mental health &amp; wellbeing training or programmes, not specifically suicide prevention training; and the open criticism of these broader programmes, especially MHFA, is not so apparent for specific suicide prevention training like ASIST or SFA.</p><p>Thirdly, based on the published literature and my own research &amp; evaluation over the past 10 years, in Australia &amp; the UK, one research finding that leaps out — wherever the right questions are asked — is that management &amp; leadership commitment is absolutely crucial.</p><p>With ‘commitment from the top’ and managers at the top 2 or 3 levels committed to creating and sustaining a mentally healthy, psychologically safe workplace, and minimising suicides (ideally, aiming for zero), there tends to be a flow-on effect which means any training programmes invested in appear to be having a measurable positive impact, including actions taken after the training, and post-training support for those trained…and, for the especially committed, those training the trainers!</p><p>Conversely, where management &amp; leadership commitment is lacking, training courses appear less likely to have a measurable positive impact, if any.</p><p>It’s not rocket science!</p><p>With strong commitment from managers &amp; leaders &amp; business owners, any training course appears to be helping, certainly not harming, and to be a sound investment, including being part of a wider business strategy to have sustainable business success through putting ‘wellness’ at the core of the business and the business plan.</p><p>And without that commitment from the top, it‘s inevitably ‘box-ticking and arse-covering’!</p><p>So, if you have commitment to making a positive difference, you almost certainly will make a positive difference, whichever specific training courses or programmes you choose off-the-shelf or with suitable tailoring, working in collaborative partnership with providers who are prepared to be more flexible and meet your specific needs, understand your specific context/sector/industry/profession/market/customers/clients/staff.</p><p>Generally, suitable tailoring to your needs, and client/participant engagement around the course content, method of delivery, case studies used, degree of interaction, etc will pay dividends.</p><p>The more it’s ‘off-the-shelf’, the lower the impact will be.</p><p>Again, this is not rocket science, is it?!</p><p><strong>Suicide Prevention Training — Market Dynamics &amp; Your Options</strong></p><p>One of the great strengths of the ‘market for suicide prevention training’ is that there are many excellent providers around, all keen to provide basic awareness training and deeper education programmes.</p><p>There’s the Zero Suicide Alliance (ZSA) online courses I mentioned above — and which I promoted across the M62 Corridor in our recent Humber-to-Mersey #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDotsTour, including its ‘Gateway’ training — online, just 20 mins, free!</p><p>I promoted this — why wouldn’t you?! — across our Tour, and I continue to do so at every opportunity, for no reason other than I can’t think of a better way to have an immediate positive impact on people &amp; organisations…and still can’t think of a good reason not to!</p><p>The photos below illustrate this ‘education &amp; training on-the-road’ approach although please get in touch with your local training providers for training — I’m just a catalyst and a joiner of dots!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uhYPapCi2FZXD5IT78f5Jg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me on stage at the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour Launch Conference, 12 June, at a packed Baths Hall in Scunthorpe — in this area, please contact Farzana Khanum at North Lincs Council.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wWj9b-lpZqvEBP5xOIedxQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The astonishing Athletic Minds Foundation Wellness Centre in Sowerby Bridge, West Yorkshire (they also have Wellness Centres in Manchester &amp; Stockport). Jo Peel (right) can help direct you to relevant training &amp; support.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Rt6NDGrJtPjohoQcS0o7gw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rochdale &amp; Middleton covered by the Mind Wellbeing Centres and these beautiful people who can help you get the training &amp; support you need. Btw, I’m holding a ‘Hope Bag’ they made for me!</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YGq8PeG8nt8H7RhGWqPCJw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A bit of a stimulus from me in Bury, with local trainer (and much more!) Rebecca Jackson on the left from The Big Fandango, ably &amp; enthusiastically supported by Jim McGlynn from Bury Council</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HecaaTNQwVI4NsfqM_2D3Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>A big turnout in Wigan, Grand Arcade, Rebuild with Hope, organised by the superb local service EPiC HOPE CIC who can help people &amp; organisations in Wigan get the training &amp; support they need.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XiDzDrj56TXFFvQwXipbrA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me enjoying a fantastic evening at the extraordinary Sean’s Place in Bootle, Liverpool, with my banners at the side, just behind the amazing Debbie Rogers who can sort out all your suicide prevention training needs in Merseyside. Btw, on the way there, I had a distressed taxi driver so I signposted him to relevant support.</figcaption></figure><p>I also want to take this opportunity to not only highlight that all these areas, certainly all those our #JoinTheDotsTour visited, have excellent local suicide prevention training providers, but to say loud-and-clear:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Please Pay These Wonderful People!</em></strong></blockquote><p>Many of them run high quality suicide prevention services on a shoestring, with no regular income stream, and little or no government funding.</p><p>They usually charge very little, certainly no more than needed to cover their running costs; they save the NHS a fortune by keeping people out of expensive in-patient units; and, even where their training courses and other services are free-at-the-point-of-delivery, this is not a reason to abuse their goodwill or exploit their generosity but an opportunity to make a donation to help other people benefit from their much-needed community and business support.</p><p>And, more than incidentally, most of these local services have been set up, and are being run by, people with lived experience of suicide — bereaved by suicide or ‘been there themselves’ in experiencing a suicide crisis — so it’s crystal clear why they’re doing what they’re doing, and it isn’t to make money or profit from anyone’s pain &amp; suffering, it’s to help avoid other people having to endure the pain &amp; suffering they’ve experienced.</p><p>There are a number of different training providers accredited to globally-recognised programmes like ASIST from LivingWorks, and Suicide Prevention First Aid; and several national ‘charity brands’ provide training.</p><p>And there are usually lots of options in your area, with the added benefit of valuable local knowledge, eg local support services available, peer support, safe, supportive spaces where people can go, etc.</p><p>The main downside of ‘the mental health &amp; suicide prevention training market’ is that the various providers can be very competitive at times in a field that requires collaboration, co-operation, and great sensitivity; and they can get a bit proprietorial, with an ‘our training is best’ mindset.</p><p>Of course, with 94% of the population not having had any suicide prevention training whatsoever, the focus for providers should be on collaboratively ‘baking a bigger pie’ not competing for slices of a small pie; and there should be ‘plenty of business to go round’!</p><p>There really should be no place for competition in any aspect of suicide prevention.</p><p>I often go further and say that, in the suicide prevention field:</p><p>“<strong><em>Competition Kills People. Collaboration Saves Lives</em></strong>”!</p><p><strong>Please Check Out ‘Specialists’ Who Are Usually Good Generalists Too!</strong></p><p>Some people will seek out training via trusted ‘brands’ like Samaritans and Mind, which is understandable, and often a very good source of training or appropriate support.</p><p>As I’ve said previously, there are benefits from developing collaborative partnerships with local training providers who know your area and your issues, and have a lower cost base.</p><p>Bear in mind though that the global training programmes are often delivered by accredited local trainers, so there are benefits here too.</p><p>Don’t be afraid to shop around, then perhaps stick with what ‘works’ for you, then shop around again if it stops ‘working’ for you.</p><p>And always recommend those who wow you — they deserve it!</p><p>Then there are some specialists, eg in certain sectors, industries or professions — and there might be benefits in working with such specialists and/or going through your trade bodies, industry associations or professional societies, although there are drawbacks too, eg insularity.</p><p>If you operate in a rural area, you may want to approach a person or organisation who understands the specific issues faced by rural communities or working in a rural area, eg Melanie Costas of Rural Mental Health Matters:</p><p><a href="https://www.ruralmentalhealthmatters.co.uk/">Welcome to Rural Mental Health Matters (RMHM)</a></p><p>And there are a growing number of specialist training courses and programmes, eg for issues around autistic people and interacting with autistic people (latest estimates are that more than 10% of all those who end their life in the UK are autistic people)…</p><p><a href="https://www.zerosuicidealliance.com/autism-suicide-training">https://www.zerosuicidealliance.com/autism-suicide-training</a></p><p>…domestic abuse &amp; domestic violence (ground-breaking research in Kent &amp; Medway could trace at least 1 in 3 suicides in their area to DA/DV), military veterans &amp; first responders, eg check out Save a Warrior…</p><p><a href="https://www.saveawarrioruk.org/">Save A Warrior UK CIC | &quot;We Came Back For You.&quot;</a></p><p>…veterinary sector/profession, check out VetLife…</p><p><a href="https://www.vetlife.org.uk/">https://www.vetlife.org.uk/</a></p><p>…people who are neurodiverse, eg check out Ausome Charlie Hart:</p><p><a href="https://ausomecharlie.co.uk/">Home</a></p><p>And a big shout out to our main Tour Partner on the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour, 11–23 June, the Rugby League Cares Foundation.</p><p>Rugby League Cares doesn’t run specific suicide prevention courses or programmes (yet!) but covers suicide briefly in some of its excellent mental wellbeing &amp; mental fitness programmes:</p><p><a href="https://www.rugbyleaguecares.org/community/">Community - Rugby League Cares</a></p><p>When our Tour got to Warrington on 20 June, Rugby League Cares had worked in collaborative partnership with the excellent Warrington Wolves Community Foundation to run two of their superb programmes — <strong><em>Offload</em></strong> in the morning for a large group of professionals in the mental health &amp; wellbeing field, and <strong><em>Ahead of the Game</em></strong> for a smaller group of parents who also coach kids’ sports teams.</p><p>These two programmes can be delivered to anyone, but focusing on these two groups worked well.</p><p>And the whole concept works especially well taking place at the Stadium…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Sd-9vIYpUGkM6MFxiJ8yzA.jpeg" /><figcaption>An iconic sports stadium always good for attracting in members of the local community.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bHJua6DABejtYih4d01cYw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The facilities are very good too, plus plenty of space for my well-travelled banners.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g89bRfM3peadqhGLwD1Ahw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Again, good facilities, with screens in the Mike Gregory Suite upstairs, and in the changing rooms downstairs.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Dh6C6ibK3nCCxUNI9OQYag.jpeg" /><figcaption>I trained as an executive coach in 1997, and I’ve studied, qualified &amp; practiced in goal psychology, change dynamics, teamwork, resilience, mindfulness, conflict resolution, coping with loss, etc. I can tell you that “Woody” (Paul Wood) was not ‘just’ a Warrington Wolves Legend but a model facilitator as well.</figcaption></figure><p>…and it’s a particularly good bonding &amp; learning environment here:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h9d6C-lmUd0tKxsG_z5XWA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The scene of many a pre-match or half-time team talk. Now perfect for a mental fitness session.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CG5v0BgB5n6mP31Lppz7pw.jpeg" /><figcaption>There’s something quite special about being in this environment, and taking part in a levelling, bonding, sharing, group session where people are opening up about their experiences. Note the field position names above each booth. I had to move as I couldn’t be seen under a sign saying ‘Right Wing’!</figcaption></figure><p>…and a shout out for the excellent trainer Ellie MacDonald who was with us on our #JoinTheDotsTour for our ‘Hope Gathering in Hope Street’ after setting up her new business #HelloHope:</p><p><a href="https://hellohope.uk/">HelloHope Mental Health and Suicide Prevention Training.</a></p><p>…and, finally, my good friend and, more importantly for potential customers, highly-rated trainer Seamus Corry:</p><p><a href="https://seamuscorry.co.uk/">Home - Seamus Corry</a></p><p>I’d better stop there; I could go on…and on…and on!</p><p><strong>A Proposed BSI/ISO Standard for Suicide Prevention, inc Training</strong></p><p>It’s also vital to understand that all the basic training courses and all the deeper learning programmes all have the same basic core material around, for example, listening with respect, listening without judgement, asking direct questions, spotting signs, signposting, etc.</p><p>And this may all soon be consolidated into a defined Standard as the British Standards Institute has just approved a proposal for a Standard for Suicide Prevention, including Training/Learning &amp; Development, which could become a global ISO Standard.</p><p>This has been created as an idea and initiative by global standards guru Marcus Long after Marcus lost his 21-year old son Adam to suicide.</p><p>After 3 years of intense grief, Marcus re-emerged with the ideas, energy &amp; commitment to facilitate a suitable Standard for Suicide Prevention, with BSI’s help, that could apply to all organisations as a framework for suicide prevention policies, measures, processes &amp; practices with continuous, systemic action learning &amp; improvement, and designed-in assurances for ‘making excellence in suicide prevention a habit’.</p><p>Here’s Marcus at the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour Launch Conference, at The Baths Hall in Scunthorpe, Wed 12 June, after breaking the very well-received news that the BSI Board had approved this initiative:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iE7FuDl0SxqBre2LLbHoNw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Marcus makes the announcement from the stage. The audience warmly applauds and cheers!</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Other Survey Results, Access to the Data &amp; Acknowledgements</strong></p><p>This particular report has focused on the education &amp; training perspective and relevant questions/data from the Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey).</p><p>Below, I’ll summarise some of the other key results from the latest wave of the Survey, Spring 2024, and key data for patterns &amp; trends.</p><p>Each wave, Spring and Autumn, I’ll write a summary report with commentary, in addition to the slide deck.</p><p>All of the slides, and access to all of the data, is available via the portal that MEL Research has set up to ‘democratise the data’ (I love that!):</p><p><a href="https://melresearch.co.uk/suicide-suicidal-thoughts-tracking-research-statistics/">https://melresearch.co.uk/suicide-suicidal-thoughts-tracking-research-statistics/</a></p><p>And here’s the direct link to the PowerPoint Summary Report from the latest wave of the Survey, Spring 2024:</p><p><a href="https://melresearch.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/TJL-TZS-Research-With-A-Purpose-Omnibus-Analysis-Spring-2024_Final.pdf">https://melresearch.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/TJL-TZS-Research-With-A-Purpose-Omnibus-Analysis-Spring-2024_Final.pdf</a></p><p>Please note that I set up this Survey in partnership with MEL Research when working in collaborative partnership with The Jordan Legacy, hence why it was initially branded as The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey.</p><p>I designed the questions, and oversaw the design, analysis &amp; reporting of the survey.</p><p>MEL Research carries out the Survey, as part of its ‘Research with a Purpose’ Omnibus, which facilitates survey research around a number of important issues — vital research, without which we’d have gaps and shortfalls in the data necessary to tackle social, economic, health &amp; environmental issues.</p><p>MEL Research produces tabular analysis and a data summary slide deck/PowerPoint-based Report for each wave, and is also going to be undertaking further data analysis as the aggregated sample over several waves of the survey where the same questions have been asked (in the same order), has built up, enabling that robust analysis.</p><p>Most importantly, MEL Research does all of this vital research, analysis, reporting &amp; dissemination pro bono — at no charge to Towards Zero Suicide CIC, previously at no charge to The Jordan Legacy, and at no charge to anyone wanting access to the prepared data &amp; reports (obviously, they would have to charge for any bespoke analysis or changes to the core specification).</p><p>And MEL Research ‘owns’ the data at the end-of-the-day but has been as generous as it can possibly be in working in collaborative partnership with myself, The Jordan Legacy, and now Towards Zero Suicide CIC, in sharing this vital data, and in making it as widely available as possible.</p><p>So, a big cheer and round of applause for MEL Research!</p><p><strong>Summary of Other Survey Results + Some Key Notes</strong></p><p>You can access all of the survey results via the links provided in the previous section above, but just a couple of notes here from me.</p><p><strong>Mental Health Tracking Questions</strong></p><p>When I designed these questions, I studied many other published surveys and got feedback from data users.</p><p>Two key problems were: firstly, ambiguity in the question wording for other surveys and therefore the interpretation of the data; and, secondly, the use of technical or medical language.</p><p>So, for example, questions on other surveys asked about ‘mental health disorders’ (hmmm) or ‘mental disorders’ (yuk!) or had multiple questions trying to assess diagnosable mental illnesses.</p><p>We didn’t have the space to do this anyway, with a very limited number of questions but we also felt we could be much clearer and simpler, and ‘plain talking’, with just one or two key questions.</p><p>So, our question asks people if they’ve had “<em>mental health issues that needed treatment or support</em>” and we have a timeframe question as well so we can measure how many have had such an experience in the past 12 months:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KjRkXPPyhkzNGzoDHHuOJg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>When we ask for a self-rating on the extent to which their current state of mental health is good or poor, the proportion answering ‘fairly poor or very poor’ has fallen significantly from more than 1 in 5 in our first 3 waves from Spring 2022 to Spring 2023, to around 1 in 6.</p><p>However, for the more behavioural measure of ‘experienced mental health issues in the past 12 months requiring support or treatment’, the figures have been more consistent.</p><p>This Tracking Survey can monitor trends over time, and be sensitive to important changes, but we also need to be able to stand back from the detail and see that between 1 in 5 and 1 in 7 have reported experiencing such mental health issues in the previous 12 months and that, in the most recent survey, it’s at 15% which is very similar to the 16% saying their mental health is poor right now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3uaCVOhcfSDxZMTdkvm5fA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>A consistent survey finding is that people who identify as disabled, and those who rate their physical health as poor, are significantly more likely to rate their mental health as poor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P5pyJm43Whlcz_7o88mstg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>We know from other surveys &amp; data sources that disabled people and those with long-term physical health problems, including those in chronic pain, have higher rates of suicidal thoughts, suicide plans, suicide attempts, and death by suicide. This is reflected in our Zero Suicide Society model &amp; framework, which includes a dedicated piece, top-right:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HpiVRGc1VAAs8SsWwKgNRw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Suicide &amp; Suicide Prevention Tracking Questions</strong></p><p>The questions specifically about suicide are really important of course.</p><p>In any walk of life, business, government policy, etc, if we want to tackle a problem, we need high quality, robust, up-to-date data on ‘key metrics’.</p><p>Not having this previously for suicide &amp; suicide prevention was a barrier; potentially a key barrier to getting the suicide numbers coming down.</p><p>Some charities, government departments, academics, clinicians, politicians &amp; media commentators regularly quote out-of-date data, or the data is not clear.</p><p>Our 3 key goals here are to have accurate data, clear data, and up-to-date data on the key measures.</p><p>We often hear it quoted that ‘1 in 5 have had suicidal thoughts’ or sometimes ‘1 in 5 will have suicidal thoughts in their lifetime’.</p><p>In this Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey (formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey), we can see that it’s actually 2 in 5 who’ve “<em>ever had thoughts about taking your own life</em>” with 1 in 5 saying they’ve “<em>seriously considered</em>” suicide:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k-mWyi6crTqfJBPX5e3y9A.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>6% of those in our latest survey say they’ve made a suicide attempt. Some might think people ‘won’t be honest’ in answering such a question, and there may well be some under-reporting of these numbers, but these are people answering online surveys without being identified, and with suitable reassurances, and empirical research suggests a high degree of ‘honesty’ in answering clear and direct questions like this.</p><p>Adding together the % making suicide attempts and the % making plans to end their lives, we have around 1 in 10 of the population in these highest ‘at risk’ or ‘in danger’ categories — note that the biggest single ‘risk group’ for suicide is those who’ve lived through a suicide attempt; they’re likely to attempt again without proper support and treatment.</p><p>The chart below shows the distribution of responses on the timeline question, ie when they last had thoughts of suicide.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5ZYFueSvOsqYGlNMxqRxLw.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>The proportion of the population as a whole having had thoughts about ending their life in the past month has been around 6–9% in our surveys.</p><p>Even at its lowest point of 6%, that’s around 1 in 16.</p><p>At 9%, that’s around 1 in 11 people.</p><p><strong>The Need to Regularly Check In With Those Around You</strong></p><p>Here’s a sobering thought.</p><p>If you’re at work or at play in a room or office or factory or bar or theatre, with family or friends or work colleagues or a community organisation…and you scan the environment around you…1 in 16 of those people — rising potentially as high as 1 in 11 — have probably had thoughts about ending their life in the past month.</p><p>And that’s why we all need to ‘take the training, have a conversation’.</p><p>Take the training to help you ‘spot the signs’.</p><p>Take the training to help you ‘ask the question’.</p><p>Take the training to help you signpost to appropriate help.</p><p>Take the training, have a conversation, save lives!</p><p>As the trend line chart below shows, the numbers of people seriously considering suicide, making plans to end their life, and making suicide attempts are not going down.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WNbiXgXR81w2qY3n0_RNyw.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>Every suicide loss is devastating and affects many people, for many years, forever in most cases. And it affects organisations and relationships.</p><p>Also exposure to suicide is not rare — 7 in 10 people are exposed to suicide, it’s just that 7 in 10 people don’t openly talk about it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IBUZSXR163oN5zHKaGuHOA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>And, again, these numbers are not coming down.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Dt7HIQPE0OtNdy6-ygGvLQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>And let’s finish with the chart we started with.</p><p>Over the past 3 waves of the Tracking Survey, from Spring 2023 to the most recent wave, Spring 2024, there’s been no change in the % of the population as a whole confident in talking about suicide or spotting signs of suicide, in all cases it being well below half of the population saying they’re confident in talking about suicide or spotting the signs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lf7HsU38dsu3Uchcb6EjNA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Towards Zero Suicide/MEL Research Tracking Survey, formerly The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+, 1,900 sample in Spring 2024)</figcaption></figure><p>And, in this same time period, there’s been no change in the proportion having had some form of suicide prevention training.</p><p>A maximum of 6% have put into practice ‘take the training, have a conversation’.</p><p>We know that if we get that line at the bottom on an upward trend, we’ll get the number of people (competent and) confident in talking about suicide (and suicide prevention) and spotting the signs, and we know that will help get the numbers of suicides on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>So let’s all work together to get that training line going up and the number of suicides going down.</p><p>As it says on the wall in Sean’s Place in Bootle, we’re “In This Together”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wvk-sRHtHuJViHHzawPcJw.jpeg" /><figcaption>On my pre-Tour planning visit to Liverpool, I went to Sean’s Place and was blown away by what Debbie has done here. There was a men’s mental health session being run by the Liverpool FC Community Foundation, and I got to meet Mark Henderson (right) and former Liverpool goalkeeper Chris Kirkland (the tall one!).</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Note on the Sample Structure</strong></p><p>The Spring 2024 &amp; Autumn 2024 waves have had the sample boosted, from the usual 1,500 to 1,900, in order to have higher numbers in Yorkshire &amp; Humber and North West (minimum 200 in each) for more reliable statistical analysis in those two Regions.</p><p>This has been done because the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour travelled through these two Regions, 11–23 June 2024, and we wanted to study any significant differences in the results in these two English regions compared with the rest of the country, and to study any significant changes in the results in these two Regions between Spring 2024 and Autumn 2024, which could be as a result of Tour activity &amp; profile.</p><p><strong>Finishing with a Message of Hope</strong></p><p>When studying these survey results; seeing the suicide numbers not coming down; seeing the numbers of people considering suicide, making plans &amp; making attempts not coming down; seeing the number taking suicide prevention training at just 6% and not increasing; it’s understandable that we might feel disheartened or pessimistic, perhaps even low on hope and bordering on despair at times.</p><p>However, hope resides in the opportunity we have here as well as the problem we have. Hope resides in the potential to save lives through practical action, actions we can all take, including people and whole organisations (schools, hospitals, workplaces, communities, families, etc) all ‘taking the training, having a conversation’.</p><p>Let’s do it, and imagine what we can achieve if we can get more than half the population to ‘take the training, have a conversation’!</p><p>Yours, with hope — I’m in the hope business! — Paul.</p><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles is a Research Fellow (FMRS), transformational change consultant &amp; coach, and loss, grief &amp; trauma counsellor, who specialises in mental health and, particularly, suicide prevention.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul has lived with mental illness for 20 years, he has lived experience of suicide (from multiple perspectives), and he’s worked professionally in suicide prevention since 2013.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>After co-authoring the ground-breaking report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ with Steve Phillip of The Jordan Legacy, published in 2023 (1st Edition July, 2nd Edition Sept), Paul has been Chief Facilitator for the #ZeroSuicideSociety Transformation Programme.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>In April 2024, Paul founded Towards Zero Suicide CIC dedicated to rolling out the Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme; and Paul also designed, planned &amp; facilitated the Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour, 11–23 June.</em></strong></p><p>Contact:</p><p><strong>Paul Vittles on LinkedIn</strong> (the only Paul Vittles on LinkedIn!)</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/paulvittles/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/paulvittles/</a></p><p><strong>Towards Zero Suicide CIC LinkedIn Page</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/towards-zero-suicide-cic/">https://www.linkedin.com/company/towards-zero-suicide-cic/</a></p><p><strong>X (formerly Twitter)</strong></p><p>@ PaulVittles</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*bfzyc9w5zE46j-o490CvtQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c5e2b977963b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[3 Things that Kill People — Ignorance, Low Ambition & Political Spin!]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/3-things-that-kill-people-ignorance-low-ambition-political-spin-b2b8dac6a0a9?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b2b8dac6a0a9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-prevention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accountability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Jul 2024 10:44:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-03T10:44:45.575Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>3 Things that Kill People — Ignorance, Low Ambition &amp; Political Spin!</h3><h4><strong>Let’s call it out, challenge it, and help not harm.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uhYPapCi2FZXD5IT78f5Jg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Some people run away from the fact that suicide is a political issue. It shouldn’t be a divisive party political football but suicide is political. People living in poverty are far more likely to die by suicide. Poverty is political; therefore suicide is political. Also systemic injustice &amp; institutionalised cruelty are political issues (above — the #ZeroSuicideSociety Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour Launch Conference, Baths Hall, Scunthorpe, 12 June)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>UK General Election, Thursday 4 July 2024.</strong></p><p>The polls are suggesting a big win for Labour and a new shade of Government, although some things don’t change even when there’s a different political party in charge, so we won’t build up our hopes too much; certainly not our expectations.</p><p>There are no signs in the Labour Party Manifesto, or from the private conversations I’ve had with Labour MPs, that we’ll have a new Government that understands the nature or scale of ‘the suicide problem’ or will show any great commitment to tackling this problem, despite 6,000+ preventable suicide deaths every year in the UK.</p><p>But the previous Government’s record on suicide prevention was so bad, it surely can’t be worse?!</p><p>Two things are guaranteed:</p><p>1) we’ll get through yet another General Election Campaign with suicide &amp; suicide prevention not featuring at any stage.</p><p>2) there’ll be lots &amp; lots of spin — heightened during the General Election Campaign and continuing as the new Government forms and begins operating.</p><p><strong>Suicide &amp; Suicide Prevention During Elections — Visible or Invisible?</strong></p><p>On this first issue, ie the low or non-existent profile of suicide &amp; suicide prevention during election campaigns, many people working in suicide prevention tell me it’s a good thing because we don’t want suicide or suicide prevention to be a “<em>party political bunfight</em>”.</p><p>I agree we need to avoid suicide and suicide prevention being a party political football to be disrespectfully &amp; insensitively kicked around in the heat of an election campaign — and we should aim for cross-party or all-party approaches to reducing the suicide numbers — but it concerns me that not having the subject discussed at all can be considered a desirable situation!</p><p>Let’s find a way to have suicide &amp; suicide prevention being a high profile topic during election campaigns without the party political mud-slinging.</p><p>I have an idea on how to achieve this. Watch this space!</p><p><strong>Spin Is All Around Us!</strong></p><p>On the second issue of spin, we all need to be on our guard at all times, and do everything we can to counter the spin we get — not just from the politicians or candidates but from their advisers; civil servants; those ‘captured’ by the National Suicide Prevention Strategy process; and well-meaning ‘suicide prevention campaigners’ who (consciously or sub-consciously) frequently use fact-free campaign lines that can cause harm.</p><p><strong>The Woeful, Shameful, Potentially Harmful National Strategy for England</strong></p><p>The biggest Spinfest was in 2023 when the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028, was published (a year late) on 11 September (the day after World Suicide Prevention Day); and the Minister, Maria Caulfield MP, did the media rounds, including the BBC Breakfast red sofa, and told the nation we’d made “<em>considerable progress since 2012</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sASN3gZKTNxB7l8gAPe29g.png" /><figcaption>Minister Maria Caulfield MP, defending the indefensible on BBC Breakfast, 11 Sept 2023</figcaption></figure><p>Many people will have watched the Minister spinning like a top and dismissed it as Politics with a large P, with the actual published National Suicide Prevention Strategy being a much more measured, highly professional document, especially given the number of well-known people from the suicide prevention field involved in drafting and agreeing such an important document.</p><p>But, alas, when I read the document, not only was it full of spin, especially the Foreword by the Government’s Lead Adviser (politics with a small p!), there was this first line of the Executive Summary, in black and white:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RIzLhz71T2pL9QMVVgsZIg.png" /></figure><p>Really? Seriously?</p><p>How did this make the final edit?</p><p>Of course, it raises the questions:</p><p>&gt; “<em>what do you mean by ‘progress’?</em>”; and</p><p>&gt; “<em>how do you define ‘considerable’?</em>”.</p><p>I’ve asked some of those responsible for putting together the document, and they tend to do two things:</p><p>a) they refer to specific plans, activities, services, initiatives, research, developments, etc since 2012 which they think — in good faith — constitute ‘progress’ but without reference to the suicide numbers, which they think are largely outside their control and have been affected by economic factors, the pandemic, etc so even more out of their control than before…and yet they still conclude there’s been “<em>considerable progress since 2012</em>”!</p><p>b) they quote the one statistic in the entire Strategy document that is put forward as evidence of ‘considerable progress’, ie “<em>a 35% fall in suicides in mental health inpatient settings in England between 2010 and 2020</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Jt6BszNVC6BtfiMUH14v0Q.png" /></figure><p>In my highly detailed, published, critique of this woeful, shameful, and potentially harmful National Strategy for England, 2023–2028…</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/are-we-in-the-suicide-prevention-business-or-is-it-suicide-maintenance-40a4e4129496">Are we ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’ or is it Suicide Maintenance?</a></p><p>…I highlight two facts — lots more facts actually in my 36,000-word deconstruction &amp; demolition of the National Suicide Prevention Strategy — but two especially relevant here.</p><p>One is that inpatient suicide rates fell from 2010 to 2016 and have flatlined since, so that 35% fall, 2010–2020, was front-ended and there’s been no ‘progress’ since 2016!</p><p>The other is that a considerable fall in the numbers of inpatient suicides between 2010 and 2016 is unlikely to be due to the publication of a new National Suicide Prevention Strategy in 2012!</p><p>New strategies take time to be communicated, adopted, understood, implemented, reviewed for effectiveness, re-cast, etc.</p><p><strong>Let’s Talk Numbers of Deaths by Suicide Without Fear or Favour!</strong></p><p>Now, of course, the elephant in the room here — or the grizzly bear locked in the cupboard might be a better analogy — is the suicide numbers.</p><p>It seems that those trying to defend their Strategy, or defend their past record, or find some way to spin systemic policy failure as “<em>considerable progress</em>”, don’t like to bring the actual suicide numbers into this conversation or into the definition of ‘success’ or ‘progress’.</p><p>And I understand this, on a human level.</p><p>From my own personal &amp; professional experience over the past 11 years, as someone who has struggled with severe depression, I know it’s dispiriting to work so hard to try and reduce the suicide numbers and then not see the numbers go down — and they haven’t been on a downward trend since 2007.</p><p>It can make people despair and lose hope, which we don’t want.</p><p>It can make people defensive or look to invent rationalisations.</p><p>It’s perfectly natural.</p><p>But the facts are clear.</p><p><strong>We Need High Ambition. Low Ambition Kills People!</strong></p><p>The numbers haven’t been going down.</p><p>And they should be going down — considerably!</p><p>If we lower our ambition, we’ve given up.</p><p>Low ambition kills people.</p><p>We must aim high.</p><p>We must say that 1000s of preventable deaths by suicide each year is totally unacceptable in a (so-called) civilised society.</p><p>Not maintaining that high ambition is ‘giving up’.</p><p>Having low ambition National Strategies is giving up.</p><p>Not even putting a target in a National Strategy is giving up.</p><p>Not challenging spin — whether large P or small p — is giving up.</p><p>Not talking about it at all during a General Election campaign is giving up.</p><p><strong>Political Spin Kills People!</strong></p><p>One of the lowest points of 2023 for me was when talking with someone who was directly involved in putting the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England together.</p><p>I emphasised the flat-line graph we’d had for 15 years and got the response “<em>at least the numbers aren’t going up</em>”!!!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CPYiRphCm25pP82RDF2n3A.png" /><figcaption>The graph that didn’t appear in the National Strategy or the Minister’s media briefings</figcaption></figure><p>When we should be seeing the suicide numbers on a long-term downward trend, towards zero — as I believe and I’ve set up Towards Zero Suicide CIC to be 100% dedicated to this transformational change challenge — and the numbers are flatlining for 15 years, that’s an unequivocally bad result!</p><p>To wrap ourselves in an emotional &amp; psychological comfort blanket with “<em>at least the numbers aren’t going up</em>” is, once again, understandable on a human level, but it’s the polar opposite of how we should be thinking if we want to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend (towards zero).</p><p>And then what happened next?</p><p>Yes, that’s right, the numbers went up!</p><p>In England, for 2022–23, by 6% (5% for men, 8% for women).</p><p>So that line ‘at least they’re not going up’ can now be banished completely.</p><p><strong>Without the Denial &amp; Delusion &amp; Spin…How Bad Is It?</strong></p><p>Here’s some sobering figures, which don’t seem to get mentioned.</p><p>I haven’t heard them mentioned during the General Election Campaign.</p><p>And I haven’t seen, heard or read these numbers from within what I often refer to as ‘The Suicide Prevention Establishment’.</p><p>According to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), the number of registered suicide deaths in England in 2012 was 4,507.</p><p>For 2023, ONS has reported the number as 5,579 suicide deaths for England.</p><p><strong><em>That’s a 24% increase in deaths by suicide in England, 2012 to 2023.</em></strong></p><p>Do you think that’s ‘considerable progress’?</p><p>Is it a record you’d be proud of if you were in Government, or advising the Government?</p><p>Is it a record you’d want to defend?</p><p><strong>Finally, a Question for ONS</strong></p><p>Now we must always take care with statistics of course, and some of that increase is due to the 2018–19 change to the ‘burden of proof’ for Inquests, from ‘Beyond Reasonable Doubt’ to ‘Balance of Probabilities’, but only an out-and-proud political spinner would claim that all or even most of that 24% increase is due to the change in the way the numbers are measured.</p><p>Maybe those smart people at ONS can tell us precisely how much of the increase is due to the method change?</p><p>And then we can hold the spinners to account!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/970/1*6aueX_HmSzeRcHs-MTGQMw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles is a Research Fellow (FMRS), transformational change consultant &amp; coach, and loss, grief &amp; trauma counsellor, who specialises in mental health and, particularly, suicide prevention.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul has lived with mental illness for 20 years, he has lived experience of suicide (from multiple perspectives), and he’s worked professionally in suicide prevention since 2013.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>After co-authoring the ground-breaking report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ with Steve Phillip of The Jordan Legacy, published in 2023 (1st Edition July, 2nd Edition Sept), Paul has been Chief Facilitator for the #ZeroSuicideSociety Transformation Programme.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>In April 2024, Paul founded Towards Zero Suicide CIC dedicated to rolling out the Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme; and Paul designed, planned &amp; facilitated the Humber-to-Mersey #JoinTheDotsTour, 11–23 June.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>In past roles, Paul has worked for two of the top polling firms in the world — MORI in the UK and AC Nielsen in Australia — so he knows a thing or two about polls, elections, statistics, spin, politics &amp; other dark arts!</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*bfzyc9w5zE46j-o490CvtQ.png" /><figcaption>Towards Zero Suicide CIC is a spin-free zone! Our Core Values include Transparency &amp; Accountability.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b2b8dac6a0a9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[So What Is It You Actually Do?]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/so-what-is-it-you-actually-do-32bbd4d27c9d?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32bbd4d27c9d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-prevention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[impact]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 11 Feb 2024 19:06:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-19T06:39:24.095Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If I say I ‘work in suicide prevention’, this is usually the next question.</p><p>I also often deliberately intrigue people, and provoke a different type &amp; tone of conversation, when asked at business conferences ‘what business are you in?’, by saying “<em>I’m in the hope business</em>” but this too is usually soon followed by “<em>So what is it you actually do?</em>”.</p><p>Over the past three-and-a-half years, I’ve worked in collaborative partnership with Steve Phillip &amp; The Jordan Legacy — providing services and support as a ‘suicide prevention expert consultant’, mentor, coach, counsellor, facilitator.</p><p>Steve often says “<em>The Jordan Legacy wouldn’t be what it is today without Paul Vittles</em>” which is nice to hear.</p><p>We’ve certainly done some great work together and achieved a lot.</p><p>When we meet people who are new to suicide prevention and our <strong><em>Zero Suicide Society</em></strong> conversation, we explain that The Jordan Legacy was set up by Steve after losing his son Jordan to suicide, and that the core purpose of our collaborative partnership is to take and facilitate practical actions to get the suicide numbers in the UK on a downward trend, towards zero…</p><p>…and then they say “<em>what is it you actually do?</em>”!</p><p>So, we thought it might be helpful to illustrate what it is we actually do by listing ‘a month in the life’ of our work.</p><p>We’ve taken the month of January 2024.</p><p>January is usually a relatively quiet month, but not this January.</p><p>We were flat out for much of 2023:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tCxiaOQ2p1GVwHxlcF9H4A.png" /><figcaption>July-Dec 2023 a peak period of activity, output &amp; achievement for myself, Steve Phillip &amp; The Jordan Legacy and, now in 2024, this has been followed by our busiest ever January.</figcaption></figure><p>~ carrying out our action research project January-June 2023;</p><p>~ publishing the 1st Edition of our report <strong><em>Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society</em></strong> on 11 July and getting masses of feedback &amp; further suggestions;</p><p>~ publishing the 2nd Edition of this pioneering report on 29 September:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-edition-2-of-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - Edition 2 Of The Report | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>~ publishing The Jordan Legacy’s response to the National Suicide Prevention Strategy (NSPS) for England (2023–2028):</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/the-jordan-legacys-response-to-the-governments-national-suicide-prevention-strategy-2023-2028/">The Jordan Legacy&#39;s Response To The Government&#39;s National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2023-2028 | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>~ in addition, I published a much more detailed critique of the Government’s National Strategy in a deliberately provocatively titled piece “<strong><em>Are we ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’ or is it Suicide Maintenance?</em></strong>”:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/are-we-in-the-suicide-prevention-business-or-is-it-suicide-maintenance-40a4e4129496">Are we ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’ or is it Suicide Maintenance?</a></p><p>~ launching and promoting our petition for a ‘Suicide Prevention Act’ package of measures to help get the suicide numbers down, towards zero;</p><p>~ working through our typically busiest months of September (which includes World Suicide Prevention Day) and October (which includes World Mental Health Day) with lots of talks, workshops, posts, articles, advocacy meetings, campaigns, events, conferences, etc;</p><p>~ and our fortnightly Jordan’s Space radio shows:</p><p>~ through to the unique Hope for Life Conference in December.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YubUEuehC2FBo4h2BFqcww.jpeg" /><figcaption>Paul and Steve at The Jordan Legacy’s 2023 Hope for Life Conference at Pavillions of Harrogate</figcaption></figure><p>Through that period of peak activity July-December 2023, we prepared-the-ground for a strong start to 2024, with my primary focus being rolling out the <strong><em>Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme</em></strong>, which contributed to the record high level of activity and achievement in January.</p><p>So, what did we then actually do in January 2024?</p><p><strong>1 Jan: The One Million Steps Challenge</strong></p><p>The first day of 2024 was the launch day for the second One Million Steps Challenge for our supporters to raise awareness re suicide/suicide prevention whilst benefiting their own mental &amp; physical wellbeing and raising funds for The Jordan Legacy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UhbHFWLi2y01X4AKroQlDA.png" /></figure><p>The first Challenge from 1 June 2023 had 40 people taking part and raised more than £11,000. This second wave has 70 participating. Fingers crossed!</p><p><strong>1–5 Jan: The 12 Asks of Christmas Campaign</strong></p><p>I collaborated with the #ForThe100 campaign (set up to reduce student suicides in higher education) to raise awareness around suicide &amp; suicide prevention, and prompt action, including signing The Jordan Legacy’s petition to parliament for the measures needed to help us get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*m9PkXHFC9Tx8jbZam6eAZg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>2 Jan: Petition Clicks Over 10,000 Signatures</strong></p><p>Our petition to parliament clicked over the 10,000 signatures needed to require a formal response from the Government in writing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LbLvuDJyAZDTH9eURlv-9g.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>4 Jan: Jordan’s Space</strong></p><p>For the first week of the new year, we had a repeat broadcast for one of The Jordan Legacy’s fortnightly radio shows, Jordan’s Space — the only fortnightly radio show in the world dedicated to suicide prevention.</p><p>This was a repeat broadcast to enable the team to have a break and re-charge over the holiday period.</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-space/">Jordan&#39;s Space | In The Media | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p><strong>6 Jan: Steve on the Beeb!</strong></p><p>Steve Phillip, Founder of The Jordan Legacy, was interviewed for what became a superb piece of suicide prevention education on prime time BBC1, with ‘Jordan’s Story’ featured on BBC Look North:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplayer.vimeo.com%2Fvideo%2F900415454%3Fh%3Db5006a67db%26app_id%3D122963&amp;dntp=1&amp;display_name=Vimeo&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fvimeo.com%2F900415454%2Fb5006a67db&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.vimeocdn.com%2Fvideo%2F1778664759-d210b3ac174b8ddcdf6381d0a176d4798ae64e3f9d73833abcb54203990c0f65-d_1280&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=vimeo" width="1920" height="1080" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0942d7d8b91777f6d00b5d80d79c3f06/href">https://medium.com/media/0942d7d8b91777f6d00b5d80d79c3f06/href</a></iframe><p><strong>8 Jan: Meetings re the Global Zero Suicide in Healthcare Summit and the #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Tour</strong></p><p>As <strong><em>Chief Facilitator, Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme</em></strong>, I met with and exchanged correspondence with the hosts and organisers of the 5th Global Zero Suicide in Healthcare Summit to discuss the Summit, brief on our Summer Tour, and discuss collaboration.</p><p>Our Tour, 12–23 June, is timed to dovetail with the Global Zero Suicide Summit on 24/25 June, with our Tour ending in Liverpool.</p><p><strong>9 Jan: Meeting with Darren Barden re iTalk</strong></p><p>I met with Darren Barden, who we had as our guest on Jordan’s Space in December…</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-space/show-31-from-a-frenzied-attack-to-the-launch-of-the-italk-app-an-interview-with-darren-barden1/">Show 31 - From A Frenzied Attack To The Launch Of The ITalk App - An Interview With Darren Barden1 | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>…to discuss a collaborative partnership around the potentially ground-breaking iTalk mental health &amp; suicide prevention app.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BlIMyUYwu1JVz4_jqxc1kg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>9 Jan: Meeting with Dorset Mind re Rural Mental Health &amp; Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>I met with the CEO of Dorset Mind to explore ways of working together, including a possible event in Dorset, and various ways of educating and advocating around the ‘neglected’ issues of rural mental health and suicide prevention in rural areas.</p><p><a href="https://dorsetmind.uk/who-we-are/our-team/">https://dorsetmind.uk/who-we-are/our-team/</a></p><p><strong>9 Jan: Release of ‘This is The North’ Podcast on “<em>Suicide — a means of death not a cause of death</em>”</strong></p><p>Recorded in October 2023, but just released on 9 January 2024, this is an excellent podcast —with myself and Evelina Dzimanaviciute having the opportunity to talk about suicide &amp; suicide prevention at the systems change level as well as at the individual &amp; community human level.</p><p>The quality of the questions and content in this podcast is all the more remarkable given that the host, Citizens’ Advice Gateshead CEO Alison Dunn, witnessed a (public) suicide the day before the recording.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fembed%2Fepisode%2F2rtecRiS23JtW2aNnN7D0p%3Futm_source%3Doembed&amp;display_name=Spotify&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fepisode%2F2rtecRiS23JtW2aNnN7D0p&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.scdn.co%2Fimage%2Fab67656300005f1f059a2523ad1a466b5dc266d0&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=spotify" width="456" height="152" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a356218dafac48ea0429ebef080cad2e/href">https://medium.com/media/a356218dafac48ea0429ebef080cad2e/href</a></iframe><p><strong>12 Jan: Launch of the Not #JustAnotherNumber Fundraising Campaign</strong></p><p>Spearheaded by Steve Phillip, The Jordan Legacy launched this national campaign to specifically highlight that each suicide statistic is not ‘just another number’ but a real person, bereaved by real people left behind.</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/just-another-number/">Please Support Our #JustAnotherNumber Campaign | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p><strong>15 Jan: Brew Monday</strong></p><p>The commercial scam of ‘Blue Monday’ — with an evidence-free claim there’s a trough in people’s mental health at this time of year — has been challenged by a Samaritans-led campaign called #BrewMonday.</p><p>The Jordan Legacy collaborated with Samaritans, Andy’s Man Club, Govia Thameslink Rail, Stevenage Football Club, and the British Transport Police, with Steve spending Monday 15 January talking to commuters on a train from Peterborough to St Pancras about suicide prevention and handing out our 1-page guide on how to support people struggling with their mental health or feeling suicidal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QS6NKjNpvZMiuTb1LZ8F-w.jpeg" /></figure><p>I also showed my support for this excellent (counter)initiative at York Railway Station.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/667/1*0BsxtFJnR4tZ4m_WLqdeUw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Paul with Samaritans at York Station (top left); Steve with Samaritans et al at Peterborough Station (bottom left), before boarding the Brew Train to London; Steve (right) outside Norwich City FC (see below)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>16 Jan: Meeting with Norwich City FC</strong></p><p>Steve met with Norwich City FC to discuss a collaborative partnership with The Jordan Legacy, following their request for support in helping develop their mental health &amp; wellbeing strategy.</p><p>This meeting was prompted by the Canaries’ incredible suicide prevention video which has had 60 million views around-the-world.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FtX8TgVR33KM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DtX8TgVR33KM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FtX8TgVR33KM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/955e436963a32c80809ed03e8c8f0b9b/href">https://medium.com/media/955e436963a32c80809ed03e8c8f0b9b/href</a></iframe><p><strong>16 Jan: ICG Webinar “<em>Transformational Change Dynamics and The ‘S’ Word</em>”</strong></p><p>A key component of our <strong><em>Zero Suicide Society Strategy</em></strong> — to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero — is to try and draw in people &amp; organisations with transferable skills, experience, talents &amp; energy who have not previously engaged with ‘the transformational change challenge of suicide prevention’.</p><p>I ran this webinar through The ICG, a UK-centred global network of independent researchers and ‘insights professionals’.</p><p><a href="https://theicg.co.uk/recording-transformational-change-dynamics-and-the-s-word/">RECORDING: Transformational Change Dynamics - and The &#39;S&#39; Word! - The ICG</a></p><p><strong>17 Jan: Meeting with South Yorkshire ICB Suicide Prevention Partnership</strong></p><p>When our report <strong><em>Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society</em></strong> was published in 2023 (1st Edition on 11 July, engagement &amp; feedback, then 2nd Edition on 29 September)…</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-edition-2-of-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - Edition 2 Of The Report | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>…there was a lot of interest from local area Suicide Prevention Leads, some of whom called our report “<em>ground-breaking</em>”.</p><p>We sent our report out to all of the ‘ICB Partnerships’, and several Suicide Prevention Leads asked us to meet with them and/or deliver a presentation at their Suicide Prevention Partnership/Network gatherings.</p><p>On 17 Jan, I attended the South Yorkshire ICB Suicide Prevention Partnership meeting to brief on the <strong><em>Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme</em></strong>, and our #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Tour scheduled for June 2024.</p><p><strong>18 Jan: New Edition of Jordan’s Space</strong></p><p>This our 32nd radio show recording — all Jordan’s Space shows are on the website, forming a fantastic ‘resources library’ — this time interviewing Mark Simmonds, author of ‘Breakdown and Repair’ who, among other things, introduced us to the concept of “<em>a good breakdown</em>”!:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-space/show-32-break-down-and-repair-an-interview-with-mark-simmonds1/">Show 32 - Break Down And Repair - An Interview With Mark Simmonds1 | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p><strong>19 Jan: Meeting with Melanie Costas re Rural Mental Health &amp; Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>To discuss a possible collaborative partnership, The Jordan Legacy speaking at their events, and vice versa (including Melanie being involved in our Scunthorpe Conference on 12 June), I met with Melanie Costas who runs a charity called Rural Mental Health Matters, the leading charity working in the field of rural mental health and suicide prevention:</p><p><a href="https://www.ruralmentalhealthmatters.co.uk/">Welcome to Rural Mental Health Matters (RMHM)</a></p><p><strong>24 Jan: Recording of New Jordan’s Space Interview with Dr Sandy Onie</strong></p><p>For the 33rd radio show, Steve, Danielle &amp; myself interviewed Dr Sandersan (Sandy) Onie, a global leader in the field of suicide prevention, who achieved the remarkable feat in 2023 of getting suicide prevention enshrined in the laws of Indonesia, after facilitating the largest ever gathering of religious leaders:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-space/">Jordan&#39;s Space | In The Media | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Also, I’ve been liaising with Lifeline International about the global campaign to decriminalise suicide — attempting suicide is still a criminal offence in 25 countries, with the law unclear in a further 27 countries — around what support we can give from the UK (after all, we Brits exported these laws to many countries which didn’t previously have them!).</p><p><a href="https://lifeline-international.com/">LifeLine International | Suicide Prevention and Crisis Support</a></p><p><strong>25 Jan: Meeting with MEL Research</strong></p><p>I met with MEL Research to discuss our collaborative partnership.</p><p>MEL carries out a survey for us — pro bono! — with key mental health and suicide/suicide prevention questions asked, twice each year (Spring &amp; Autumn) to a nationally representative sample of 1500 UK residents aged 16+.</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-how-far-we-have-to-go-cb1b8564adc0">Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society — how far we have to go</a></p><p>In this particular meeting, I discussed another potential project focused on the relationship between suicide and socio-economic disadvantage.</p><p><strong>26/27 Jan: Bereaved Dads Gathering</strong></p><p>Steve spent a weekend with four other fathers bereaved by suicide. This group included the father of schoolgirl Molly Russell who has featured prominently in the national media in recent years and whose case of viewing harmful content online helped to bring about the Online Safety Act, coming into law in October 2023.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5ESSkGv87NZjFdiMEpJcAw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dads bereaved by suicide including — far left — Ian Russell MBE (father of Molly, online safety campaigner, recipient of The Jordan Legacy Creating Impact Award 2023 at The Jordan Legacy’s 2023 Hope for Life Conference) and — 2nd from right — Doug Cave (father of Stephanie, co-founder of The LEARN Network, who was interviewed for The Jordan Legacy’s action research project)</figcaption></figure><p>This meeting was to explore how the group could collaborate and join forces to help with public education and advocacy and, most importantly, prevent more suicides in the UK.</p><p><strong>27/28 Jan: Global Community Engagement Day</strong></p><p>Another excellent opportunity to draw in talented people who’ve not previously been actively involved in suicide prevention.</p><p>This time, community engagement practitioners around the world, with a diverse audience watching a panel discussion, including myself as a panellist:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FEmh2yszfVV0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DEmh2yszfVV0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FEmh2yszfVV0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/98358da15f3fa1b5a6b6eefe2d371da0/href">https://medium.com/media/98358da15f3fa1b5a6b6eefe2d371da0/href</a></iframe><p>I also wrote and published a ‘memoir-with-life-lessons’ especially for the 7th Global Community Engagement Day, which additionally celebrates my 40 years working in community engagement:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/40-years-of-community-engagement-7-global-community-engagement-days-8dbddeca79bc">40 Yrs of Community Engagement; 7 Global Community Engagement Days</a></p><p>Becky Hirst has also invited me to do a follow-up podcast on the topic of ‘Mental Health &amp; Disconnection’ in community engagement, which will be recorded on 29 February.</p><p><strong>29 Jan: Public Launch of the #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Tour</strong></p><p>After months of planning, and with the details starting to be firmed up, it was time to go public on our Tour scheduled for 12–23 June this year, including ‘the big start’ via our Launch Conference on 12 June and ‘the big finish’ in Merseyside 23 June, timed to dovetail with the 5th International ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ Summit taking place in the UK for the first time, in Liverpool, 24–25 June:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/time-for-a-breakthrough-in-suicide-prevention-our-zero-suicide-society-transformation-programme/">Our Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme Is Rolling Out | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Postscript</p><p>Since publishing this piece, the Tour has happened and was a huge success, including the ground-breaking Launch Conference, captured here by film-maker Garry Lynch of Bear Media…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F48blmJWg1aE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D48blmJWg1aE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F48blmJWg1aE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b0df403747611590821ebc904c3dc093/href">https://medium.com/media/b0df403747611590821ebc904c3dc093/href</a></iframe><p>…and Garry also made a short film with highlights of the Tour and the grand finale in Liverpool — the iconic ‘Hope Gathering in Hope Street’:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FFbYqHYclcnA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DFbYqHYclcnA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FFbYqHYclcnA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href">https://medium.com/media/7b3e9664421c451c487f0d383556f6ca/href</a></iframe><p><strong>30 Jan: R;pple Education Webinar</strong></p><p>Steve was one of four ‘expert panellists’ who were invited to discuss the topic of suicide prevention in education; specifically in UK universities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*T9qJdxe1_vilx7_iOOW7qA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>31 Jan: NSPA Conference at The Oval in London</strong></p><p>I attended the National Suicide Prevention Alliance (NSPA) Conference in London, with more than 300 attending, and speakers including the Mental Health Minister &amp; the Government’s Lead Adviser on Suicide Prevention; and also many of our collaborative partners.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pH31MX3zbK9idHUgRdNnng.jpeg" /></figure><p>Among other questions &amp; comments from-the-floor and in some of the breakout sessions, I publicly challenged the Government’s Suicide Prevention Adviser when some of his narrative commentary didn’t seem to be supported by the data on his slides!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lFS3WV-pQtui5ESNQRr2IA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Those who know me well know how passionate I am not only for suicide prevention but about transparency, accountability, accuracy, and having an evidence-based narrative that highlights the full scale of ‘the suicide problem’ and clearly sets out the way forward, so we need to be prepared to publicly challenge if necessary.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VX3jS2C-9mEFFxeFlOjkbw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Most people attending (not all!) seemed to appreciate the challenge!</p><p>I was also able to meet with several of our collaborative partners to advance our Tour Programme, and also promote the Tour from the floor, microphone-in-hand.</p><p>A remarkable month eh?</p><p>And the activity levels will remain high for the rest of the year.</p><p>Thank you for reading</p><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32bbd4d27c9d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[40 Yrs of Community Engagement; 7 Global Community Engagement Days]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/40-years-of-community-engagement-7-global-community-engagement-days-8dbddeca79bc?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8dbddeca79bc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-engagement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jan 2024 21:30:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-11T16:46:41.322Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*NF45E9W0iPNt2jcCjUobMA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A truly iconic panel for our discussion on Community Engagement Day 2024!</figcaption></figure><p>In 2017, whilst I was still living &amp; working in Australia (based in Sydney, working across Australia, and also involved in global mental health &amp; suicide prevention initiatives), I was contacted by two highly talented &amp; respected community engagement professionals, Andrew Coulson &amp; Becky Hirst, two of the nicest people on the planet, who told me they were launching “<strong><em>Global Community Engagement Day</em></strong>” on 28 January 2018.</p><p>I asked them about their ‘why’, ‘what’ &amp; ‘how’ for starting &amp; instituting this international day of celebration &amp; connection for the global ‘community engagement community’, listened to their replies, and said “<em>Count me in</em>”!</p><p>I asked them about the ‘when’, ie why they chose 28 January, especially as it was so close to Australia Day (26 January).</p><p>They said 28 January was chosen because it was the birthday of one of the great pioneers of community engagement, Dr Wendy Sarkissian.</p><p>Wendy is respected across the globe for her leadership and her innovative &amp; high quality practice in community engagement, and being a supportive mentor for many in the field, including Andrew &amp; Becky.</p><p>I said “<em>fair enough — 28 Jan it is!</em>”.</p><p><strong>#BeLikePaul?!</strong></p><p>I think it’s also fair to say that I threw myself in to the inaugural Global Community Engagement Day on 28 January 2018, both in terms of promoting it in advance and participating on the Day, with the kind of Obsessive Compulsive enthusiasm that those who know me well have got used to over-the-years, but which can be a bit overwhelming for those who are new to my particular brand of passionate immersion!</p><p>Andrew &amp; Becky were kind, generous, unconditionally supportive, and also hilarious in posting on social media #BeLikePaul!</p><p>Personally, as someone living with mental illness for more than 20 years, who’s experienced several episodes of severe depression-with-anxiety, I wouldn’t recommend being like me in some respects!</p><p>But, I knew what Andrew &amp; Becky meant in terms of enthusiastically embracing this new international day of celebration, showcasing, sharing, connecting, and facilitating engagement for those who are involved, or want to be involved, in our beloved ‘profession’ or ‘networked community’ of community engagement.</p><p>So I took the compliment, and I look back at that first Global Community Engagement Day with great fondness.</p><p>I basically went out into my own local geographic community where I lived in Pyrmont, then extending across City of Sydney, finding clusters of natural communities, chatting, taking photos, posting on social media, and also connecting with communities of interest online — in Australia, in my native UK (I’m a dual British-Australian citizen), and across the globe.</p><p>I also posted this piece about Global Community Engagement Day including a bit of analysis about different types of communities…</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/the-ultimate-power-of-people-communities-commengageday-b98d8c15f87f">The ultimate power of people &amp; communities (#CommEngageDay)</a></p><p>I kept going across several time zones for much of what’s effectively 48 hours for a ‘Global Day’.</p><p><strong>Positive mental &amp; physical health, including sleep, beautiful sleep</strong></p><p>Please note that I did sleep, and please do make sure you sleep.</p><p>Sleep is so important for our physical &amp; mental health. Sleep regulates our body and rejuvenates our mind.</p><p>Whatever we want to be, do, or aim for in life &amp; work, getting enough high quality sleep is crucial.</p><p>One of the main warning signs for those struggling with their mental health, is they’re not sleeping well and, whilst they might not want to open up about their struggles, they’ll usually tell you they’re not sleeping well or answer a question about how they’re sleeping right now, if you just ask.</p><p>I slipped into ‘health tips’ mode there for good reasons. It’s so important for us all — self-care and supporting those around us.</p><p>But also, <strong>Mental Health</strong> is the core theme for Global Community Engagement Day 2024, as you can see in this wonderful global panel discussion we had this year with Andrew Coulson doing a great job of holding together the energy sources that are Becky Hirst, Emma Broomfield, Dr Wendy Sarkission, and myself:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FEmh2yszfVV0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DEmh2yszfVV0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FEmh2yszfVV0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/98358da15f3fa1b5a6b6eefe2d371da0/href">https://medium.com/media/98358da15f3fa1b5a6b6eefe2d371da0/href</a></iframe><p>Also mental health — and suicide prevention — is now my main focus in life &amp; work, so I’m even more enthusiastic and even more supportive of Global Community Engagement Day this particular year.</p><p>We know that some of those in our local, national &amp; global communities will, at some point in their life &amp; work, feel ‘Disconnected’ and possibly isolated, lonely, pessimistic, questioning their worth…at worst, when people experience ‘dark thoughts’ (I work with people who’ve experienced suicidal crisis), trapped without feeling they have options, and hopeless.</p><p>Through our mutually supportive networks and through initiatives like Global Community Engagement Day, we have the opportunity to shift people, groups, organisations &amp; communities from Disconnected to Connected; from isolated &amp; lonely to feeling part of a supportive group or community; from pessimistic to optimistic; from questioning our contribution to recognising our contribution and celebrating how we make a difference in our valuable work; from lacking options to having positive choices; and from lacking hope to being full of hope for the future.</p><p>As a child, I was told “<em>where there’s life, there’s hope</em>”. Sadly, that turned out not to be true. I’ve worked with 1000s of people who’ve lost their hope, and I’ve had periods where I’ve lost mine. It’s hard to be hopeful when the world is so shit at times and our societies &amp; democracies seem so broken.</p><p>But I’ve turned my own life around, and — as a consultant, coach, counsellor, and mental health &amp; suicide prevention facilitator — I’ve helped many other people turn their lives around.</p><p>And I’ve turned that aphorism around to “<em>where there’s hope, there’s life</em>”!</p><p>These days, when I attend business events and people ask that inevitable opening question “<em>what business are you in?</em>”, I say “<em>the hope business</em>”.</p><p>They usually reply “<em>sorry, did you say the HOPE business?</em>”, enabling me to continue the intrigue with “<em>that’s right, I’m in the business of hope</em>”.</p><p>It leads to some wonderful conversations!</p><p><strong>Reflecting on 40 years of ‘making a difference’ &amp; having fun!</strong></p><p>I’d like to celebrate Global Community Engagement Day 2024, and celebrate Wendy’s birthday, and celebrate my 40 years working in this glorious field, by reflecting back on my career highlights, including the work I’ve done around mental health &amp; suicide prevention.</p><p>There’ve been lowlights too, and I’m always more than happy to share these as well where it can help others, and to be open in response to questions you might ask around topics such as mental health, mental illness, suicide &amp; suicide prevention, or even just projects that ‘went wrong’, or ‘didn’t go to plan’, and what we learned from these ‘bumps in the road’ — sometimes deep craters in the road!</p><p>But I want to focus here on the positive — on positive achievements; great case studies of ‘making a difference’ &amp; ‘making change happen’; flagship projects; memorable assignments; breakthroughs in approach &amp; outcomes; examples of overcoming challenges and moving forward on complex &amp; sensitive matters; getting stuff done despite mental health struggles or physical health challenges along-the-way; and having fun, enjoying what we do, how we do it, and who we do it with.</p><p>When I list my work in the fields of research, community engagement, deliberative &amp; participative democracy, coaching &amp; counselling, transformational change, optimal mental health &amp; suicide prevention, I know from the feedback I get that it inspires &amp; energises most people but it can overwhelm some, so I’m sensitive to that.</p><p>It’s easy to say ‘don’t be overwhelmed’ but that doesn’t necessarily help anyone who’s feeling overwhelmed. It reminds me of the saying “<em>No-one in the history of staying calm has ever stayed calm by being told to stay calm</em>”!</p><p>So if you’re feeling overwhelmed while going through the content below, just take a break, and read it in bite-sized chunks, or feel free to not continue reading.</p><p>Treat it as a menu to dip in &amp; out of, or look for another meal!</p><p>It’s good for your mental health to say ‘this is not helping and may be harming’, and to just stop doing whatever it is that’s not helping.</p><p>If you do find my list inspiring &amp; energising, please do three things.</p><p>1) please carry on reading, and engaging with the content.</p><p>2) please tell me, because I’m as insecure &amp; fragile as the next person — I grew up in a household where love was expressed only in a practical way like ‘food on the table’ and it was ‘an emotion-free zone’ — and I really like receiving nurturing feedback!</p><p>3) please keep a diary or journal of all your life &amp; career highlights, key projects, breakthroughs, favourite assignments, projects you most enjoyed, times you had fun. It rarely harms and it usually helps…a lot!</p><p>Btw, Becky is a step ahead of us because she’s published her wonderful book:</p><p><a href="https://www.beckyhirstconsulting.com.au/author">For the Love of Community Engagement - Becky Hirst Consulting</a></p><p>Btw, Becky’s book has a Foreword by Wendy Sarkissian, and Wendy has a new book out so check that out:</p><p><a href="https://creeksongbook.com/">https://creeksongbook.com/</a></p><p>OK, here goes!</p><p><strong>Postscript</strong></p><p>Since publishing this ‘memoir-with-lessons-for-life-and-career’ and being a panel member for the discussion around ‘Disconnection &amp; Mental Health’ on Global Community Engagement Day 28 Jan 2024, I’ve recorded this podcast with Becky Hirst on 29 February 2024 as part of her wonderful podcast series ‘For the Love of Community Engagement’ (Series 4, Ep 4):</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fembed%2Fepisode%2F1vC2p0qD0kac1Rb6jvz50e%3Futm_source%3Doembed&amp;display_name=Spotify&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fepisode%2F1vC2p0qD0kac1Rb6jvz50e&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.scdn.co%2Fimage%2Fab67656300005f1f4894b13a351552aedd973e9e&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=spotify" width="456" height="152" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/070a3ef3971e8e248285a0983bd0543b/href">https://medium.com/media/070a3ef3971e8e248285a0983bd0543b/href</a></iframe><p><strong>The Early Years — 1980s &amp; 1990s in the UK</strong></p><p>My participatory research &amp; community engagement career began in 1984, working in some broken communities in Bristol, then joining social research &amp; opinion polling firm MORI (later Ipsos-MORI, then just Ipsos).</p><p>Here, I was involved in some of the UK’s first ever residents’ surveys for local councils, research among MPs &amp; peers, and hundreds of diverse social research projects (when people asked me what my job was, I’d say “<em>professional nosey parker</em>”!); before becoming more of a specialist in urban regeneration assignments, customer-centric &amp; citizen-centric public service initiatives, and evidence-based, experience-informed public policy.</p><p>I continued with my citizen-and-customer-focused research &amp; development and moved into what many people today would call ‘community engagement’ even though that term was rarely used in January 1989 when I took up a new role at City of York Council.</p><p>At my interview for the role, I was given 2 hours to write a paper on ‘how to make the Council customer-focused’. I quickly pointed out that customer-focused services had to sit within a citizen-focused authority in terms of policy &amp; planning, and with excellent employee engagement internally.</p><p>I was offered the job (exciting!).</p><p>I moved from — from London to York (a huge change in work &amp; life).</p><p>I started in my new role (slightly anxious but still mainly excited).</p><p>My new ‘boss’ handed me the paper I’d written as part of the selection process, saying “<em>can you implement this?</em>”.</p><p>I said “<em>yes</em>”, and did just that, for the next two-and-a-bit years.</p><p>I had two roles, one specifically a transformational change role in Housing, where there were some urgent issues needing to be addressed, then broadening out across all Council activities &amp; services, making me effectively the first ever ‘Research &amp; Engagement Manager’ at City of York Council — and one of the first people in such a role anywhere in the world.</p><p>I pioneered new approaches to, and applications of, participatory research, community engagement, and deliberative &amp; participative democracy.</p><p>Here’s the story of ‘The York Revolution, 1989–1991’ which not only changed York irreversibly in some respects, including permanent physical changes, like the road that runs in front of York Minster (formerly a main thoroughfare having more than 100,000 vehicles a day passing through, now a peaceful pedestrian precinct), but it influenced the way local democracy works across the UK and around the world:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/the-york-revolution-1989-1991-and-beyond-96f0085c9d93">The York Revolution 1989–1991 (and beyond!):</a></p><p>I then built my own business in this field which grew to 50 people and carried out many groundbreaking assignments, including my most famous project — leading the community engagement exercise to decide what to do with the site of 25 Cromwell Street in (Becky Hirst’s home city of) Gloucester.</p><p>25 Cromwell Street was the home of the serial killers Fred &amp; Rosemary West, the so-called ‘House of Horrors’.</p><p>My role was to plan the entire engagement programme, meet with all of the victims’ families to establish what they wanted — which options should be ruled in or ruled out, and other issues they wanted us to take into account — and then work with the local community and the other key stakeholders to try and get the best possible outcome in the circumstances.</p><p>I’ve written this up as a detailed case study here:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/25-cromwell-street-gloucester-my-most-famous-engagement-empowerment-project-and-why-i-ve-e49dbad6f9a5">25 Cromwell Street, Gloucester: my most famous ‘engagement &amp; empowerment’ project…and why I’ve…</a></p><p>In the course of facilitating this particular engagement exercise, we all had many life-changing experiences.</p><p>There were four for me.</p><p>1) a heightened consciousness about loss, grief, trauma &amp; mental health. I learned a lot then, which I still reflect on today, and which still shapes my ‘practice’ today.</p><p>The loss experiences of those families was almost unimaginable, and yet our job, to some extent, is to try and imagine it, in order to build rapport, show empathy, try to understand, shape our recommendations.</p><p>But it made me more comfortable with the thought that, in some of our projects, there are things we will never be able to understand or fully imagine, and we don’t need to, and we shouldn’t try to.</p><p>We cannot have someone else’s experience, we can only listen to their experience and take that into account in our work, and try our best to support those we work with.</p><p>And everyone has a unique experience, including every experience of loss, grief, trauma &amp; mental health challenges being unique and personal.</p><p>We mustn’t deny that person their personal experience by pretending, or deluding ourselves, that we will ever fully understand what they’ve been through or what they’re going through right now.</p><p>When I later trained and qualified as a counsellor — and practiced person-centred counselling — I thought back to this project regularly.</p><p>One aspect I often think about is that because we thought this project would be especially sensitive and difficult, we decided to have regular check-ins with the team, to make sure they were ok.</p><p>These check-ins were good, but often nothing to do with the project or subject matter. Staff often raised other issues going on in their lives and work that were causing them stress, not this project!</p><p>2) I learned how to listen!</p><p>That might sound like a strange thing to hear from someone professionally trained as a researcher and highly experienced in community engagement, but I really did learn how to listen here, especially when meeting with the victims’ families.</p><p>I realised how we often go into our projects ‘armed’ with tools, techniques, frameworks, models, lots of questions, forms to fill in, analytical frameworks to fit into, program logic charts, etc…and we’re usually under time pressure to deliver so we cram in lots of interviews, group discussions, meetings, workshops, etc. We effectively create lots of barriers to listening!</p><p>When I met with the victims’ families, I put away all of my tools, techniques, frameworks, charts…and I listened, I just listened, and I listened for many hours, and I went back in some cases and listened again.</p><p>This deep listening process influenced my decision in 2010 to launch a campaign called ‘Listen Hear: the Global Campaign for Effective Listening’ which won the 2011 TEDxSydney award for “<em>the best idea worth spreading</em>”:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/just-listen-please-just-listen-ae5c373c9dc5">Just listen — please, just listen!</a></p><p>3) I learned about the importance of saying ‘sorry’. At this point in my life, I was the kind of person who would apologise if I felt I’d ‘done something wrong’ but could be quite stubborn and ‘all IQ not EQ’ in holding out and not apologising if I was adamant I’d ‘done nothing wrong’.</p><p>But I met lots of people through this project who were regularly using the word ‘sorry’ in all sorts of different contexts, eg ‘sorry for your loss’, ‘sorry to hear about that’, ‘sorry to hear you had to experience that’, and generally being quick to apologise to help maintain positive relationships, regardless of any objective sense of ‘right or wrong’, and to be sincere in issuing an unconditional apology whenever they felt they might have caused hurt.</p><p>It fundamentally changed the way I approach communications and relationships, and I’ve since witnessed the enormous power of the apology, including to those who have suffered injustice, such as the Stolen Generations, those who suffered institutional abuse as children ‘in care’, and those who’ve been wrongly accused or convicted of a crime.</p><p>There are many more such apologies we need of course, including the thousands of subpostmasters in the UK who’ve had their lives destroyed by the way The Post Office handled the Horizon Scandal.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-68067244">Post Office scandal: Former postmaster&#39;s joy after conviction quashed</a></p><p>I also started running mutual understanding workshops where I asked people at the beginning about their own personal approach to apologising and they went into groups based on this approach to try to explain to other groups when, why &amp; how they apologised or didn’t apologise, doing several rounds with people moving between groups until all of the participants felt they’d learned about other approaches, or at least recognised there were other approaches that resulted in different outcomes.</p><p>4) within this work, emerging through and beyond the 25 Cromwell Street assignment, I learned about the crucial importance of forgiveness.</p><p>I met Marian Partington, whose sister Lucy was one of the Wests’ victims, who told me how she’d gone through the pain of having Lucy missing for all those years not knowing what had happened to her, then the pain of knowing what had happened to her.</p><p>Marian then told me about how she’d woken up every morning hating the Wests, and wanting them dead, and then hating herself for wanting them dead, wondering if she was as bad as them for wanting to kill someone.</p><p>And she told me how she’d only been able to move on with her life when she finally took the huge step of forgiving the Wests, and forgiving herself for her own thoughts up to that point.</p><p><a href="https://www.theforgivenessproject.com/stories-library/marian-partington/">Marian Partington - The Forgiveness Project</a></p><p>I subsequently heard similar stories, like from Jo Berry who lost her father in the IRA Brighton Bombing.</p><p>Jo couldn’t understand, on a human level, how anyone would want to kill the father she loved so dearly.</p><p>It took a long time to come to terms with what she was feeling and the thoughts she was having about how to bring this situation to any kind of ‘resolution’ but Jo found a path by meeting with one of the IRA bombers who killed her father, Patrick Magee, and trying to understand the situation he was in rather that think in terms of what evil one human being had brought to another human being; and trying to practice forgiveness.</p><p>Jo now works with Pat Magee and they travel all around the world running peace &amp; reconciliation workshops, helping others to practice forgiveness, through the organisation Jo established, Building Bridges for Peace.</p><p><a href="https://buildingbridgesforpeace.org/about-building-bridges-for-peace/jo-berry-founder/">Building Bridges for Peace</a></p><p>Both Marian and Jo were/are active with The Forgiveness Project, which was set up by Marina Cantacuzino</p><p><a href="https://www.theforgivenessproject.com/">The Forgiveness Project</a></p><p>I got actively involved at one point, and attended some workshops on forgiveness &amp; self-forgiveness, which are still useful for me today, especially working with people experiencing mental health struggles or suicidal crisis and those bereaved by suicide who live with guilt, shame, regrets, pain, suffering, ‘what if’ questions, unresolved ‘why’ questions.</p><p>I often introduce them to this definition of (self) forgiveness:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*nTjh0507RbKiT-TGcdQYlQ.png" /></figure><p>Also, as a result of the deep introspection I was having around projects like this, plus taking on growing responsibilities with my business, plus joining the Academy for Chief Executives to get the kind of support I needed to help me in my role(s), plus getting my first ever executive coach, I decided to train as an executive coach, which was absolutely fascinating.</p><p>I started coaching other CEOs, business owners &amp; senior leadership teams.</p><p>I built rapport with my clients, created a relationship of trust, and they would open up to me about all sorts of topics — their business growth plans, team development issues, personal career aspirations, client relationships.</p><p>And, because of the trust in our relationship, they’d often open up about their mental health struggles.</p><p>At this point, I wasn’t a trained, qualified counsellor like I am now, so I would help in trying to get them the support they needed.</p><p>At this point in my life and career, I was a highly successful CEO of a highly successful, award-winning business, a nationally-recognised ‘transformational change expert’, a highly sought after executive coach, and in-demand public speaker…</p><p>…but I then experienced burnout in 2003–4 and — after a month off work travelling around South Africa didn’t really help (nice holiday but burnout isn’t ‘cured’ by a holiday!) — I took the rather radical step of moving to Australia, where I lived &amp; worked from February 2005 to August 2019.</p><p><strong>My Australian Adventure!</strong></p><p>My time in Australia was a rollercoaster ride.</p><p>Some big highs and amazing projects, including working with 15–16 year old kids in Indigenous communities in the Outback who’d never ever seen the sea, and being paid by Tourism Queensland to visit the Whitsunday Islands to carry out research (well someone has to do it!).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_JKWkcgsJAhtfCDJXwWpAQ.png" /></figure><p>And some big lows, including a breakdown after my dad died (in the UK) in October 2010.</p><p>This was after I’d got dual Australian-British citizenship and was able to leave the corporate world and set up my own business in January 2010.</p><p>My dad’s death hit me much harder than I expected, and other factors conspired to send me into a severe depression and life-threatening crisis.</p><p>I came through it and back onto the rollercoaster ride, and started specialising in (workplace) mental health and suicide prevention, working with the Mentally Healthy Workplace Alliance and clients like Beyond Blue and SuperFriend (a not-for-profit foundation dedicated to mental health &amp; suicide prevention, funded by the superannuation &amp; insurance sector).</p><p>This included (via a literature review, survey research, and two stakeholder workshops in Melbourne &amp; Sydney) mapping out what a ‘mentally healthy workplace’ looks like; and designing and establishing the ‘Indicators of a Thriving Workplace’ Survey, now in its 9th year.</p><p>It’s been enhanced by great teams of researchers and the SuperFriend team(s), with the sample size boosted, now at 10,000 per year to be able to analyse the results by sector.</p><p><a href="https://www.superfriend.com.au/research/itw-0">Indicators of a Thriving Workplace - SuperFriend</a></p><p>In 2013, for the 60th anniversary of the Samaritans in the UK and the 50th anniversary of Lifeline in Australia, I facilitated workshops &amp; forums, including a global forum on ‘breakthrough ideas for suicide prevention’ which generated ’10 Big Ideas’ to get the suicide numbers down.</p><p>I worked with clients like Suicide Prevention Australia, carrying out research &amp; engagement with various groups including researchers and community engagement professionals, people with lived experience of mental illness &amp; suicide, policymakers, academics, charities, service providers, and funders.</p><p>I facilitated the process that led to the establishment of the National Suicide Prevention Research Fund (with an initial $12 million seed funding from the Department of Health) and the creation of the very first National Suicide Prevention Strategy for Australia.</p><p>The article below summarises some of this work, and there was a session I ran at the Australian Market &amp; Social Research Society Conference (AMSRS — now The Research Society) in Melbourne in 2014, which included research studying the mental health of researchers and those working in community engagement:</p><p><a href="https://www.greenbook.org/insights/brand-strategy/research-should-make-a-difference">Research Should Make a Difference</a></p><p>It also mentions innovative research projects we carried out at that time, including for the Mentally Healthy Workplace Alliance.</p><p>One survey was the first to generate results such as 45% of employees in Australia saying they’d left a job (or left a workplace, or left a manager!) because of “<em>a mentally unhealthy</em>” or psychologically unsafe workplace.</p><p>Another sophisticated piece of research — the Employer of Choice study — identified the sub-conscious drivers of choices in employment decisions.</p><p>This study showed that a mentally healthy environment and factors (potentially) affecting mental health were second only to pay in driving job choices.</p><p>I presented this research at the 2014 National Suicide Prevention Conference in Perth. Many of those in the audience questioned the research findings, saying they’d never heard this before, and it seemed high. I explained that previous studies had not included these mental health factors, and also this was a new methodology.</p><p>Rather than asking people for conscious drivers of choices, eg ‘which of these are most important?’, we used a discrete choice modelling approach where all the factors were randomised and the different random combinations came up on the screen so those taking part in the research just had to say ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to different scenarios or job offers, and we could then analyse which factors were actually driving their choices.</p><p>Conference delegates also made comments like “<em>no-one has ever asked me at a job interview about mental health</em>”. I was able to explain that they don’t due to the stigma, but they do scan the organisation, and ask questions like “<em>what’s the culture like here?</em>” and about ‘management &amp; leadership styles’, much of which is checking ‘will I be safe here?’.</p><p>At this Conference in Perth, I also attended a ‘Healing Ceremony’ for people with lived experience of suicide, which was an incredible and unforgettable experience.</p><p>Below is a slide deck from a presentation I delivered to the Insight Innovation Exchange (IIeX) Asia Pacific Conference in Sydney in 2014.</p><p>It includes slides showing the ideas that emerged from global forums on breakthrough ideas for suicide prevention; the approach we took when facilitating workshops to develop national suicide prevention strategies &amp; plans; the Employer of Choice research; details of workshops on ‘Being Prepared to be Helped’; and transformation through technology:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.slideshare.net%2Fslideshow%2Fembed_code%2Fkey%2FlODFwEdLtnjV08&amp;display_name=SlideShare&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.slideshare.net%2FPaulVittlesFMRSFRSAG%2Fiiex-asia-pacific-2014-paul-vittles&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fcdn.slidesharecdn.com%2Fss_thumbnails%2Fcd568d17-4b90-4791-9503-f7dd2b2b946c-161218011836-thumbnail-4.jpg%3Fcb%3D1482024249&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=slideshare" width="600" height="500" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/466ce104a1a535e493543681941612a5/href">https://medium.com/media/466ce104a1a535e493543681941612a5/href</a></iframe><p>The ‘transformation through technology’ initiatives included improving search technology for those searching for harmful material or for information about suicide that could be harmful, including testing some of the early virtual assistants; ‘Tracking for Life’ apps for people known to be at suicide risk to help support them; and ‘Digital Life Saving’ to help identify people not known individually but potentially at risk or in danger.</p><p>2014 was a huge year in many ways. It included me getting through to the final of the TEDxSydney ‘Fast Ideas’ competition for “<em>the best idea worth spreading</em>”, becoming the first person to reach the final twice!</p><p>This time, I had 30 seconds to speak from the stage to a packed Sydney Opera House about the concept of ‘Digital Life Saving’.</p><p>I’ve done hundreds and hundreds of talks &amp; presentations over the years, but I’ve never rehearsed more than for this 30 seconds, to make the most of it, and have the biggest impact possible:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FtMVMpeKD1zs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DtMVMpeKD1zs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FtMVMpeKD1zs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/8ceae5264db5ffd0bc1accef42875e36/href">https://medium.com/media/8ceae5264db5ffd0bc1accef42875e36/href</a></iframe><p>This article for the ESOMAR Foundation “<em>Research &amp; Engagement ‘Making a Difference’ and Saving Lives</em>” from 2018 also summarises a lot of this work around mental health &amp; suicide prevention.</p><p><a href="https://esomarfoundation.org/saving-lives-the-ultimate-example-of-research-engagement-having-impact/">Saving Lives: the ultimate example of research &amp; engagement having impact - Esomar Foundation</a></p><p>By this point, I was becoming regarded as ‘an expert’ in suicide prevention which is always dangerous because it’s important to stay grounded and humble, to recognise what you don’t know, and to keep learning.</p><p>But I was clearly confident enough in my thinking at this point about what would get the suicide numbers down, that I made this submission to the Productivity Commission Inquiry on mental health &amp; suicide prevention in May 2019.</p><iframe src="https://drive.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=https%3A//www.pc.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/240762/sub262-mental-health.pdf&amp;embedded=true" width="600" height="780" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d1ae811f12f895f76c58058a1e5b5417/href">https://medium.com/media/d1ae811f12f895f76c58058a1e5b5417/href</a></iframe><p>I’d begun working with the global ‘Zero Suicide’ community or — as some called themselves — the ‘zero suicide community’ or the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ movement, which began in Detroit when the Henry Ford Health System made the bold step of aiming for ‘perfect healthcare’ and ‘zero suicides’ and managed to reduce the number of suicides by 75% in four years.</p><p>I ran a global engagement project on these ‘zero suicide’ initiatives around the world to learn about what was being done to get the numbers down, and transferable lessons.</p><p><strong>Return to the UK, August 2019</strong></p><p>It was getting progressively harder to be in Australia with family in the UK.</p><p>When my wife &amp; I moved to Australia in 2005, we didn’t have any grandchildren but we now have 5 granddaughters!</p><p>I also had more mental health challenges and personal crises, and was also diagnosed with ‘compassion fatigue’ which a clinical psychologist has since told me doesn’t exist — a story for another day!</p><p>On return to the UK, I reflected on my research, community engagement, consultancy, and coaching career, and life, and wrote this piece (which at the time I thought was my magnum opus — it might have been superseded by two major publications in 2023, detailed later):</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/citizen-community-empowerment-deliberative-participative-democracy-the-human-right-to-be-8a4999eb2ce7">Citizen &amp; community empowerment, deliberative &amp; participative democracy — the human right to be…</a></p><p>As we settled back into the UK and implemented our own mental health life plans, including being mortgage-free (huge for my mental health, and for many others) and renovating a house to our specific requirements…</p><p>…I picked up my transformational change coaching &amp; consultancy work, my training workshops, and lectures to business schools, with much interest in my ‘3 Key Dynamics of Change’ model which I’ve used for 35 years, to facilitate many huge and lasting changes in the UK &amp; Australia.</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/making-change-happen-with-less-stress-3edc6ed3572">Making change happen — with less stress</a></p><p>I worked freelance in the UK which was hard initially then, ironically, business boomed after the first COVID19 Lockdown, with several clients wanting me to help them with ‘survive &amp; thrive’ strategies — or just survive! — and being contracted to work with the Zero Suicide Alliance (please check it out — and take — their ‘Gateway’ course in suicide prevention, it’s 20 minutes online, and free, and can help you save lives):</p><p><a href="https://www.zerosuicidealliance.com/">Zero Suicide Alliance</a></p><p>I also facilitated wellbeing workshops for several clients, including the OneTeamGov network for people working in government in all its forms.</p><p>I suggested running an event for OneTeamGov on suicide prevention for World Suicide Prevention Day 10 September 2020 and was told it might not attract interest — “<em>it could be niche</em>” someone said.</p><p>I curated 15 speakers, 11 of them with lived experience, we put up the invite…and 933 people registered for it!</p><p>So not ‘niche’ then!!!</p><p>I put together this help &amp; resources pack for those attending the event, and anyone else interested. Some of these sites or sources may be out-of-date but this should still be a good place to look for where you might get support (in the UK and around the world):</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/oneteamgov/oneteamgov-event-otgsp-on-world-suicide-prevention-day-wspd2020-resources-pack-5ca5d9f3ed30">OneTeamGov event (#OTGSP) on World Suicide Prevention Day (#WSPD2020) — Resources Pack</a></p><p>Coinciding with the OneTeaGov event, I wrote up the key results and lessons learned from my research and engagement with the global ‘zero suicide community’:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/suicide-is-a-practical-act-suicide-prevention-means-practical-actions-do-you-want-to-help-save-91f221e7620d">Suicide is a practical act, suicide prevention means practical actions — do you want to help save…</a></p><p>I introduced the OneTeamGov event:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FCEVFWMtauLU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DCEVFWMtauLU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FCEVFWMtauLU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6cd6d6883fb738906fce45e4b97aba07/href">https://medium.com/media/6cd6d6883fb738906fce45e4b97aba07/href</a></iframe><p><strong>My Journey with The Jordan Legacy Begins (2020)</strong></p><p>One of the speakers I booked for the OneTeamGov event on World Suicide Prevention Day 2020 was Steve Phillip, who I’d met and bonded with over the past 3 months.</p><p>Steve spoke about losing his son Jordan to suicide in December 2019:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAIDoWrqCb6I%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAIDoWrqCb6I&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAIDoWrqCb6I%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/2d3e9c50eb88fe225e29cce2305ed99b/href">https://medium.com/media/2d3e9c50eb88fe225e29cce2305ed99b/href</a></iframe><p>Steve founded The Jordan Legacy to be dedicated to practical actions to prevent suicides, later refining this mission — in line with our transformational change philosophies &amp; frameworks — to getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>The Jordan Legacy website also summarises ‘Jordan’s Story’ which of course is also ‘Steve’s Story’ and it’s Steve’s ‘why’ — why he does what he does and continues to do what he does now:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-story/">Jordan&#39;s Story | About Us | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>I now work with Steve, and I’m Chief Facilitator of the <strong><em>Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme</em></strong> to create a ‘Zero Suicide Society’ which is a society “<em>that is willing and able to do all it can to prevent all preventable suicides</em>” and get the suicide numbers on a long-term downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>We run talks, webinars, workshops, panel discussion events — with all the recordings from all our events being on our website for viewing:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/speaking-and-events/">Speaking And Events | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Our Talks &amp; Presentations, including Steve’s “<em>How to Cope with The ‘S’ Word</em>” and my“<em>Gaining an Understanding of Loss</em>” are listed here:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/book-us-to-speak/">Book Us | Event Speaking | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>We run conferences, like the Hope for Life Conference, which was designed to bring together people with lived experience of suicide to hear hopeful stories, stories of ‘tragedy to triumph’, ‘life after loss’, and hope after trauma &amp; grief’.</p><p>It was also designed to be around the anniversary of Steve &amp; his family losing Jordan (in December 2019) so it would provide future positive memories to look back on, at a time of year that has such sad memories.</p><p>Here’s a short highlights video of the first Hope for Life Conference:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FsfL8-_f39IE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DsfL8-_f39IE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FsfL8-_f39IE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/124f5ffb6a45031d5965c1052a41f558/href">https://medium.com/media/124f5ffb6a45031d5965c1052a41f558/href</a></iframe><p>We carry out research &amp; engagement, and get involved in campaigning &amp; advocacy (using our research and engagement, including plugging gaps in key national data sets).</p><p>We thank MEL Research for carrying out this twice-yearly survey among a representative sample of 1500 UK residents aged 16+, and doing this for us pro bono:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-how-far-we-have-to-go-cb1b8564adc0">Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society — how far we have to go</a></p><p>We curate resources to help support people and organisations:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/help-resources/">Help &amp; Resources | Suicide Prevention | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>We collaborate with people &amp; organisations developing new approaches and new technology, like the R;pple intervention tool (our partner Alice Hendy just got an MBE for her services to online safety):</p><p><a href="https://www.ripplesuicideprevention.com/">Home - R;pple</a></p><p>We have the world’s only fortnightly radio show dedicated to suicide prevention and listening to diverse lived experience voices. The recordings of all shows are on our website, forming an incredible resources library:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-space/">Jordan&#39;s Space | In The Media | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Steve &amp; I were co-creators &amp; co-founders of the Baton of Hope — along with Mike McCarthy (who lost his son Ross to suicide in February 2021) and Ian McClure (who lives with mental illness).</p><p>In June/July 2023, the Baton of Hope toured 12 cities in the UK and was the biggest ever gathering of people with lived experience of suicide — more than 1000 Baton Bearers.</p><p>Here’s a short video highlights reel from the (Greater) Manchester leg:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FMCHDsbPf8Co%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DMCHDsbPf8Co&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FMCHDsbPf8Co%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f69fe0cd5e105808ec9525e44016cccb/href">https://medium.com/media/f69fe0cd5e105808ec9525e44016cccb/href</a></iframe><p>And here’s a stunning film from an extraordinary day towards the very end of the Baton of Hope’s Tour in Brighton (&amp; Hove):</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FmV6h7XxYFQc%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DmV6h7XxYFQc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FmV6h7XxYFQc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f4a6ce8628533336b2a70986e125814a/href">https://medium.com/media/f4a6ce8628533336b2a70986e125814a/href</a></iframe><p>In January to June 2023, Steve &amp; I dedicated ourselves to an action research &amp; engagement project to listen to all those in our network, plus key stakeholders nationally, focused simply on “<em>which practical actions will get the suicide numbers down?</em>”.</p><p>We published our first edition report on 11 July (which would have been Jordan’s 38th Birthday) and asked for feedback and further suggestions, which came in waves.</p><p>Here’s a webinar briefing on the action research project and our Report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ (Aug 2023):</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4UxlbliuacI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4UxlbliuacI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4UxlbliuacI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e691d1e7fe4f147c9b90043eccf55ce3/href">https://medium.com/media/e691d1e7fe4f147c9b90043eccf55ce3/href</a></iframe><p>We published the second edition of ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ in September in what has been called by several Suicide Prevention Leads “<em>a groundbreaking report</em>”:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-edition-2-of-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - Edition 2 Of The Report | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>We distributed this report far and wide, and continue into 2024 delivering talks, presentations &amp; workshops to take people through its contents.</p><p>We also published a formal response to the Government’s new National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028, which we criticised for being woeful in its low ambition:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/the-jordan-legacys-response-to-the-governments-national-suicide-prevention-strategy-2023-2028/">The Jordan Legacy&#39;s Response To The Government&#39;s National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2023-2028 | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>I privately described the Government’s National Strategy as woeful in its low ambition, shameful in its language and spinning of the suicide statistics and claims of ‘progress’ since 2012 (the suicide numbers have actually flat-lined since 2012 so no progress!), and potentially harmful — at worst “<em>a suicide prevention strategy that prevents us preventing suicides</em>”!</p><p>Several Suicide Prevention Leads asked me if I could write a paper with more detail on this.</p><p>I carried out a comprehensive content analysis and a ‘change dynamics’ assessment, and published this damning critique of not only the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England but the national strategy process used in many other countries too, including Australia &amp; Canada, entitled — deliberately provocatively — “<em>Are we ‘in the Suicide Prevention business or is it Suicide Maintenance?</em>”:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/are-we-in-the-suicide-prevention-business-or-is-it-suicide-maintenance-40a4e4129496">Are we ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’ or is it Suicide Maintenance?</a></p><p>The Jordan Legacy also launched a petition to parliament for the measures we need government &amp; parliament to take to help us get the suicide numbers down, towards zero, and we got the 10,000 signatures needed to require the Government to formally respond in writing to our proposals.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBZF5ImKBeN4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href">https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Ending 2023 with Momentum, then Moving in to 2024 and Beyond</strong></p><p>The day of finishing writing up this summary of my 40 years in community engagement, we actually got the formal written response from the Government to our petition proposals, and it was embarrassingly poor, which is actually quite useful!</p><p>It would have been better if it was a positive, constructive response, but the second best outcome from an advocacy &amp; campaigning perspective was an appallingly poor response that everyone could see was dreadful!</p><p>Here it is:</p><p><a href="https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/640961?reveal_response=yes">Petition: Introduce a Suicide Prevention Act to seek to minimise suicides</a></p><p>We’ve already sent out a newsletter and posted on LinkedIn to expose just how poor this response is, including ignoring our previous response to the Government’s National Suicide Prevention Strategy in September 2023, which I’ve provided the links to previously above.</p><p>In November 2023, I spoke at the launch of a potential groundbreaking mental health &amp; suicide prevention app called iTalk, and we had the key person driving this ‘tech for good’ innovation, Darren Barden, as a guest on our radio show.</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-space/show-31-from-a-frenzied-attack-to-the-launch-of-the-italk-app-an-interview-with-darren-barden1/">Show 31 - From A Frenzied Attack To The Launch Of The ITalk App - An Interview With Darren Barden1 | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Darren told us how he’d had two near-death experiences.</p><p>The first was when, in a terrible case of mistaken identity, he was beaten to a pulp and stabbed 47 times by two masked men turning up at his door armed with multiple knives. Thankfully &amp; incredibly, Darren survived this.</p><p>The second was 13 years later when Darren experienced PTSD, severe depression, and a suicidal crisis.</p><p>In the course of ‘telling his story’, Darren provides perspective when he says if he had to go through one of those two experiences again, he’d choose the beating &amp; stabbings every time!</p><p>Darren has also written a book about his ‘story’:</p><p><a href="https://www.darrenbarden.com/product-page/let-s-skip-to-the-good-bits">Let&#39;s Skip To The Good Bits | darrenbarden</a></p><p>Darren works with the Construction sector.</p><p>In the UK, almost 10% of all suicides are among people working in Construction.</p><p>Add in those, like Darren, working with the Construction sector, and it’s around 1 in 7 of all suicides.</p><p>People in the Construction sector are 3–4 times more likely to die by suicide than those working in other sectors.</p><p>People working in the Construction sector are 10 times more likely to die by suicide than by physical accidents at work.</p><p>Yes, these are shocking statistics, and they’re challenging startistics</p><p>And they are similar in other countries too.</p><p>Darren wanted to do something about this.</p><p>He thought an app would work well for Construction workers.</p><p>He teamed up with a tech genius called Phil Thorne</p><p>iTalk was born.</p><p>This is Darren &amp; Phil at the launch:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k2Q177qiV4OakDNt8ZzjVA.png" /></figure><p>and a banner display for iTalk:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EcGkDRKqJyXiC9s35-s-gA.png" /></figure><p>I’ve worked in the fields of suicide prevention, tech for good &amp; digital life saving for more than 10 years now, and this is the best prospect I’ve seen for reducing the numbers of suicide via integrated digital-human systems.</p><p>I’ve facilitated dozens of research &amp; engagement projects and been involved in several R&amp;D initiatives where I’ve put forward ideas only to have them knocked back or put in the ‘too hard’ basket.</p><p>It can be a very frustrating field, including governments not being prepared to invest or take any risks whatsoever, even where lives can be saved; and academics having dinosaur perspectives or getting bogged down in ethics debates &amp; processes, even where new approaches can almost certainly save lives.</p><p>With Darren &amp; Phil, it was like an oasis in the desert.</p><p>They listened to the ideas that had emerged from my previous projects over the past 10 years and simply said ‘let’s do it’!</p><p>And iTalk is being funded without any government grants or public money, it will be entirely private funding, with initial development coming from within the Construction sector.</p><p>So, Steve &amp; I will be working with Darren and the iTalk team in 2024.</p><p>The iTalk app will also incorporate the Speak Up app functionality which is designed both for simple product &amp; service improvement and ideas for improving your environment or workplace, and also the world’s most secure whistleblower identity protection system.</p><p>And that speaks to another topic close to my heart, as I know many people whose mental health — and lives — have been destroyed after they were outed as ‘whistleblowers’ (or ‘ethical champions’ I’d prefer to call them):</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/whistleblowers-are-our-most-valuable-resource-are-we-creating-a-safe-environment-for-them-8fb8c8a8e98f">Whistleblowers are our most valuable resource — are we creating a safe environment for them?</a></p><p>We finished 2023 with the Hope for Life Conference in December, which was another huge success.</p><p>One of our speakers was one of the world’s top speakers, Richard McCann.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L_HTVqL4VX8WY6MwtFntTQ.png" /><figcaption>Richard McCann speaking at the 2023 Hope for Life Conference in Harrogate, 1 December</figcaption></figure><p>Richard is famous for his motivational speaking engagements, events, workshops &amp; human development programmes:</p><p><a href="https://richardmccann.co.uk/">Richard McCann - Home of The iCan Academy</a></p><p>Tragically, Richard is also famous because his mum, Wilma McCann, was the first victim of the serial killer, Peter Sutcliffe (at Richard’s request, please don’t use the moniker that was given to Sutcliffe, and that created such fear, just call him Peter Sutcliffe, a flawed human being, and try to focus on his victims not the man who brutally murdered them).</p><p>And, further tragedy, Richard lost his sister Sonia to suicide. So he lost his mum to homicide and his sister to suicide, two women he adored.</p><p>One of the main terrestrial TV channels, ITV, recently had a 7-part dramatisation of the story of those women, The Long Shadow, seen through the eyes of those women &amp; their families — including the ‘system fail’ (from the police to the media) that let them all down.</p><p>Richard was played in the early episodes by a child actor, and appeared as himself as the credits rolled at the end, as a feel good finish to show how he’s done so well out of the most awful, traumatic life.</p><p>Richard gave himself to us for our 2023 Hope for Life Conference, including showing us something he’d never shown anyone before — a video of him and his sister Sonia.</p><p>Although they had a suicide pact, and Richard came through three suicide attempts, so the whole experience is tough for Richard, he wanted to share the good times with Sonia…with us. We felt honoured &amp; humbled.</p><p>And Richard told one of his own stories of transformation — “<em>getting his mum back</em>”.</p><p>Of course, his mum died many years ago, in 1975, but Richard said he’d been haunted by the awful black &amp; white photo the media &amp; police have used ever since, with his mum looking so sad, and so lifeless, and so not like the mum he knew.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7xcmIV5vRXTaq8SamxKyjA.png" /></figure><p>But thanks to Howard Rushfirth, of Rushfirth Creative in Leeds, his mum was somehow ‘brought to life’ in colour, and with a few other creative adjustments, Howard was able to give Richard a picture of his mum as he remembers her, so he feels like he’s got his mum back.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mZ36Ge6-3d6wmwLRvv42Rw.png" /></figure><p>and he’s very happy about it, and he was interviewed on the BBC with the Beeb agreeing to use this photo from now on, and to not use the ugly, offending moniker of his mum’s killer.</p><p>This is me speaking at the 2023 Hope for Life Conference, with my talk “<strong><em>Gaining an Understanding of Loss</em></strong>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9UFgnuSvd6fykZHnoYX9WQ.png" /><figcaption>Myself speaking at the 2023 Hope for Life Conference in Harrogate, 1 December</figcaption></figure><p>This talk covers all the different types of loss experiences, as they are many and diverse, and it always challenges people’s thinking.</p><p>I had 6 people coming up to me, or contacting me afterwards, saying my talk had ‘changed their life’.</p><p>Of course, I can’t claim the credit for this. I just helped them hear a message that resonated, in a place they felt safe &amp; secure enough to open up, and where I felt safe &amp; secure enough to open up. And I did open up!</p><p>You’ll notice in the photo ‘the empty chair’. This represents all those who couldn’t be with us at the Conference, including all those we’ve lost.</p><p>For the first time ever in public, I spoke about losing my dad.</p><p>Below is Ian Russell, now Ian Russell MBE. Ian got an MBE in the New Year’s Honours, as did Alice Hendy who also spoke at our 2023 Hope for Life Conference; in both cases, for services to online safety.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*INmVXAFuKx3LnbqR8TQQHg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Ian has campaigned relentlessly, with calm, quiet efficiency and effectiveness for the past 5 years to get the Online Safety Bill on the statute book, after his awful experience of losing his daughter Molly to suicide at just 14 years of age.</p><p>Molly’s Inquest has become a landmark case because the coroner ruled that the social media firms contributed to Molly’s death and, for the first time ever, a Meta executive appeared in-person at the Inquest.</p><p>Jurisdictions around the world trying to challenge the unethical might of the global social media firms are referencing Molly’s case.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-67556756">Molly Russell: Tech firms still failing after teenager&#39;s death, says father</a></p><p>At our Hope for Life Conference, we gave our 2023 ‘Creating Impact’ Award to Ian Russell and the charity he established, the Molly Rose Foundation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*do3ZAkbEUV2RPejR3YDxQQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>We also gave our 2023 ‘Spirit of Collaboration’ Award collectively to all of the Baton of Hope local organisers across all 12 cities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/726/1*eiY66pCA0pmrLwBKk09msg.png" /><figcaption>The Jordan Legacy’s 2023 ‘Spirit of Collaboration’ Award presented at the 2023 Hope for Life Conference to Jayne Walsham on behalf of all the Baton of Hope local organisers</figcaption></figure><p>And here’s me &amp; Steve enjoying the whole experience:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LrV_O3AIuwGbuMIh6YBJ2Q.png" /></figure><p>We started 2024 with another breakthrough — suicide, suicide bereavement &amp; suicide prevention being the lead story on prime time BBC1 News as Steve &amp; The Jordan Legacy were featured in this wonderful piece of public education around talking about suicide:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplayer.vimeo.com%2Fvideo%2F900415454%3Fh%3Db5006a67db%26app_id%3D122963&amp;dntp=1&amp;display_name=Vimeo&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fvimeo.com%2F900415454%2Fb5006a67db&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.vimeocdn.com%2Fvideo%2F1778664759-d210b3ac174b8ddcdf6381d0a176d4798ae64e3f9d73833abcb54203990c0f65-d_1280&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=vimeo" width="1920" height="1080" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0942d7d8b91777f6d00b5d80d79c3f06/href">https://medium.com/media/0942d7d8b91777f6d00b5d80d79c3f06/href</a></iframe><p>And our work continues every day, including Steve joining many other charities and suicide prevention campaigners on trains &amp; stations on Monday 15 January (dubbed ‘Blue Monday’, which is a myth created by companies trying to sell holiday packages, and now positively turned into ‘Brew Monday’) handing out free drinks, and leaflets about suicide prevention.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/667/1*0BsxtFJnR4tZ4m_WLqdeUw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Steve &amp; Paul joining in the campaign to banish the scam of ‘Blue Monday’ and replace it with ‘Brew Monday’ and then Steve outside Norwich City FC</figcaption></figure><p>Why are we forming a collaborative partnership with Championship football club, Norwich City FC.</p><p>This is why — one of the greatest pieces of suicide prevention educational content ever made and broadcast.</p><p>Across all platforms worldwide, it’s been seen by 60 million people.</p><p>It works in every country, regardless of culture or language.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FtX8TgVR33KM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DtX8TgVR33KM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FtX8TgVR33KM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/955e436963a32c80809ed03e8c8f0b9b/href">https://medium.com/media/955e436963a32c80809ed03e8c8f0b9b/href</a></iframe><p>I started 2024 with the release of probably the best podcast I’ve ever been involved in.</p><p>I did my bit (well, have a listen and judge for yourselves). I had the wonderful Evelina Dzimanaviciute, from Elite Mind, alongside me:</p><p><a href="https://elitemind.co.uk/">Home - EliteMind</a></p><p>And we had our excellent host, Alison Dunn, asking great questions.</p><p>All-in-all, it was a recipe for a truly excellent podcast.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fembed%2Fepisode%2F2rtecRiS23JtW2aNnN7D0p%3Futm_source%3Doembed&amp;display_name=Spotify&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fepisode%2F2rtecRiS23JtW2aNnN7D0p&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.scdn.co%2Fimage%2Fab67656300005f1f059a2523ad1a466b5dc266d0&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=spotify" width="456" height="152" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a356218dafac48ea0429ebef080cad2e/href">https://medium.com/media/a356218dafac48ea0429ebef080cad2e/href</a></iframe><p>But something else made it uniquely special.</p><p>The day before we recorded the podcast, Alison — previously with no lived experience of suicide — experienced a very public suicide on her way to work, and her life has changed forever as a result.</p><p>I checked in with Alison to see how she was. I asked her if she wanted to go ahead with the recording. She was absolutely resolute. She said “<em>yes, I want to go ahead with our podcast on suicide &amp; suicide prevention— more than ever</em>”.</p><p>In the circumstances, Alison did a remarkably professional job.</p><p>Just before Global Community Engagement Day, I delivered a presentation at a webinar for a global network of independent research &amp; insight professionals — some of whom specialise in community engagement or social research, some of whom specialise in commercial insights or market research — with some of my transformational change community attending and some of my global mental health &amp; suicide prevention peers there.</p><p>This global network is called The ICG. The presentation was entitled ‘<em>Transformational Change Dynamics — and The ‘S’ Word</em>”.</p><p>Here’s the link to the webinar, along with links to all the references and source material (I was being a good researcher!):</p><p><a href="https://theicg.co.uk/recording-transformational-change-dynamics-and-the-s-word/">https://theicg.co.uk/recording-transformational-change-dynamics-and-the-s-word/</a></p><p>Our ‘Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme’ is being rolled out this year, including our #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Tour 12–23 June which will begin with a huge Launch Conference in Scunthorpe on 12 June and will travel from the Humber to the Mersey connecting up people &amp; organisations currently working in suicide prevention, pulling in and educating others, and ‘joining the dots’ in terms of the different ‘pieces of the puzzle’ in our Zero Suicide Society model being connected together.</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/time-for-a-breakthrough-in-suicide-prevention-our-zero-suicide-society-transformation-programme/">Our Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme Is Rolling Out | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Postscript: Bookings site open for tickets for the Launch Conference:</p><p><a href="https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/the-jordan-legacy-zerosuicidesociety-jointhedots-tour-launch-conference-tickets-830356597937">The Jordan Legacy - ZeroSuicideSociety -JoinTheDots Tour Launch Conference</a></p><p>On the Tour, there will be ‘serious’ talks, campaigns, advocacy &amp; media, eg around our audit of mental health support, psychological safety &amp; suicide prevention for students in all the universities &amp; higher education institutions we pass along our route (we have collaborative partners who’ve lost sons &amp; daughters to suicide whilst studying at university, they launched a petition that got 128,000 signatures, and they’ve currently got their case for a statutory duty of care in the High Court).</p><p>But there will also be fun, lots of bonding, lots of connecting &amp; engaging, lots of self-care, lots of mutual support, and displays of ‘self-care leadership’, not flogging ourselves or burning out or breaking down in doing all of this. We will give a very high priority to our mental health, including ‘down time’, quiet reflection time, and ‘peace walks’.</p><p>When we get to Liverpool on 21 June, we’ll work with our collaborative partners in staging a ‘Merseyside Festival’ 21–23 June (there’ll be arts, music, sport, etc) to finish our #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Tour, and that will dovetail nicely into the 5th International Zero Suicide Summit, which is being held in the UK for the first time, in Liverpool.</p><p>Then we’ll have a rest!</p><p>If you find all of that breathtaking and hard to believe…we have to keep pinching ourselves as well!</p><p>It’s exhilarating stuff.</p><p>Btw, I had another episode of depression in late 2022/early 2023 and struggled some days with writing anything or believing anything I was doing was any good or believing I would ever make a difference ever again…</p><p>…but I coped — learning from past experience (and without medication this time, which I came off in 2019 after 7 years) — recovered in June/July 2023, partly because of the work we were doing and the phenomenal positive response we got to our report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’, and I’ve been on full throttle ever since, with my management of my mental health &amp; physical health making sure I don’t do too much too quickly.</p><p>It’s a challenge but finding ‘the sweet spot’ around clear meaning &amp; purpose is one of life’s greatest joys.</p><p>Wishing you all good health, happiness, a hopeful future, and plenty of time in your own sweet spot!</p><p>I’m going to leave you with two things.</p><p>Firstly, one of the greatest songs ever written ‘The Greatest Love of All’.</p><p>Take your pick (btw, positive mental health = feeling you have choices!)</p><p>You can have the George Benson original:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBw26pG7u5ak%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBw26pG7u5ak&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBw26pG7u5ak%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/81554ff9bcc8956c5aec6e728f8140b9/href">https://medium.com/media/81554ff9bcc8956c5aec6e728f8140b9/href</a></iframe><p>Or you can have the Whitney Houston version:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIYzlVDlE72w%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIYzlVDlE72w&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIYzlVDlE72w%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a142ac48c9cf2a791fd46129f2c956fd/href">https://medium.com/media/a142ac48c9cf2a791fd46129f2c956fd/href</a></iframe><p>It’s a song that includes the iconic line “<em>I believe that children are our future</em>”. Indeed, they are.</p><p>So, just one more thing to say — Go Florence!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tR2bFLFUNjeuQfL32EDxVw.png" /><figcaption>What will the future be like for “Florence, Age 7”? How can we make it a better future for Florence?</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles FMRS FAMI FRSA is a Research Fellow, community engagement facilitator, transformational change agent, coach, counsellor, and lived experience advocate for mental health &amp; suicide prevention.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul main focus now is in his role as Chief Facilitator, Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme, which he runs through The Jordan Legacy, highlighting that ‘suicide prevention is one of the great transformational change challenges of our time’; demonstrating the practical actions that will get the suicide numbers down, towards zero; and rolling out this Transformation Programme, including through the #ZeroSuicideSociety #JoinTheDots Tour in June 2024.</em></strong></p><p>You can financially support the work of The Jordan Legacy CIC via its website, or through a donation to support the Zero Suicide Society action research &amp; community engagement via this JustGiving page:</p><p><a href="https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/suicide-prevention-research-project?utm_term=8PNAG4gEx">Help raise £10000 to allow us to develop an important proactive suicide prevention action-research project to help us move towards a Zero Suicide Society.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8dbddeca79bc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are we ‘in the Suicide Prevention business’ or is it Suicide Maintenance?]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/are-we-in-the-suicide-prevention-business-or-is-it-suicide-maintenance-40a4e4129496?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40a4e4129496</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[change-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-prevention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transformation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Dec 2023 05:28:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-14T18:19:14.931Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A provocative title of course, partly to grab attention, but partly to make an extremely serious point. If we’re ‘in the suicide prevention business’, we should surely be doing all we can to get the numbers of suicides on a downward trend, towards zero? And if we’re not doing that, we’re effectively ‘in the suicide maintenance business’ aren’t we?!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CPYiRphCm25pP82RDF2n3A.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Government’s Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028</strong></p><p>I started writing this article-which-has-turned-into-a-30,000-word-dissertation almost three months ago after the publication of the Government’s new 2023–2028 National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England (NSPS), which was released on Monday 11 September 2023, the day after World Suicide Prevention Day.</p><p>I thought I’d write a thorough review of the new National Strategy, although I then questioned whether it was worth the investment of my precious time because the 2023–2028 Strategy publication is a thin offering that doesn’t need much in-depth analysis to see through its low ambition and low likelihood of impact on the suicide numbers.</p><p>But then my deep-rooted principles spoke to me and I thought “<em>it’s crucially important to have proper scrutiny and accountability</em>”; and I decided to write a very detailed critique of the Government’s dreadful ‘Strategy’ for anyone who shares my concerns — also maybe as a wake up call for those sleepwalking through this tragedy-on-a-tragedy — and to explain why these national strategies and plans (in the UK and in other countries) always fall so woefully short of where we need to be on suicide prevention.</p><p>It also provided another opportunity for me to talk some more about key change dynamics, and tackling suicide prevention as one of the great transformational change challenges of our time…right up there with tackling climate change, because there’s so much we can do to stop preventable suicide deaths as well as to prevent extinction of our planet.</p><p>After 12 months’ delay in us getting the new National Strategy, including several of the regular meetings Steve Phillip and I have with DHSC, with us asking “<em>any news on the new National Strategy?</em>” only to be told “<em>no, nothing to report…no scheduled publication date</em>” and, in the absence of any open engagement or public consultation around the 2023–2028 NSPS, I thought a thorough analysis might be appreciated by some of those I work with. Indeed, a couple of Suicide Prevention Leads encouraged me to write it.</p><p>Please note this piece I’m writing here now — a critique from the personal and professional perspective of someone who thinks this National Strategy goes beyond the usual woeful low ambition by being shameful in some of its phrasing and framing and, in parts, potentially harmful — is in addition to the formal published response to the NSPS from The Jordan Legacy, which was published on Thursday 21 September 2023, after our meetings with some of the ‘key stakeholders’, including DHSC and some of those directly involved in pulling the new National Strategy together.</p><p>For the record, direct input from Steve and I into this National Strategy was limited to just a single opportunity via one online forum on ‘Targets and Measurement’ and, remarkably, the Government then chose to not even set a target for reduction of suicides —which many in our network (of people with lived experience) believe is ‘giving up’ on suicide prevention!</p><p>And, indeed, we’ve heard people in positions of power and influence actually saying “<em>maybe we do need to think about shifting our focus from preventing suicides — accepting this 6000+ pa number — to helping people impacted by suicide</em>”.</p><p>This is dangerous, defeatist thinking!</p><p>One of the best ways, if not the best way, to help people impacted by suicide is to get the suicide numbers down, towards zero, so these people can live with greater hope that 6,000+ suicides per year is not inevitable, not regarded as acceptable, indeed never ever regarded as acceptable!</p><p>Many of those impacted by suicide, like Steve and myself, make it a life mission to do what we can to minimise the number of suicides so, in this context, ‘focusing on helping people impacted by suicide’ actually means making every effort possible to prevent all preventable suicides, including preventing people bereaved by suicide from taking their own lives.</p><p>The formal response from The Jordan Legacy was written after very careful consideration of what we thought was a fair and reasonable perspective, with fair and reasonable criticism of this long-awaited-then-extremely-disappointing offering.</p><p>You can read The Jordan Legacy’s published response to the NSPS here:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/the-jordan-legacys-response-to-the-governments-national-suicide-prevention-strategy-2023-2028/">The Jordan Legacy&#39;s Response To The Government&#39;s National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2023-2028 | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>In my own more detailed review below of the new National Suicide Prevention Strategy, I’ll go into more depth on some complex issues and nuanced points…and not hold back…so strap yourself in!</p><p>First, a quick summary, and a warning.</p><p><strong>The 2023–2028 National Strategy Lacks Ambition, Targets, Money &amp; Hope!</strong></p><p>The Government’s new National Suicide Prevention Strategy is yet another low ambition offering which may in fact have set the bar at an even lower level than the previous Strategy, although it’s difficult to tell because of the Government’s decision to not even include a reduction target this time.</p><p>In the previous National Strategy and related plans, the Government set what most people, certainly most people with lived experience of suicide, regarded as a low ambition target of ‘10% reduction in 5 years’.</p><p>One of the main reasons why ‘10% reduction in 5 years’ is generally regarded as a low ambition target is that all the evidence we have, and all the advice we get from ‘experts’ like President of the International Association for Suicide Prevention (IASP), Professor Rory O’Connor from the University of Glasgow, is that “<em>most suicides are preventable</em>”.</p><p>Indeed Rory often says “<em>all suicides are preventable right up until the last moment</em>” although some think that’s a contentious statement, but all agree that “<em>most suicides are preventable</em>”.</p><p>So, everyone reasonably concludes, we should be trying to prevent most suicides, which translates into a target of, say, 50% reduction right?</p><p>For those not aware, this institutionalised low ambition has actually become known as a ‘syndrome’ among the global ‘Zero Suicide community’. It’s known as “<em>The ‘10% reduction in 5 years’ problem</em>”.</p><p>This was after the World Health Organisation (WHO) in its first global report on suicide prevention in 2014 (yes, that’s right, only in 2014 did we get a WHO report!) urged every country to set a target of ‘a minimum of 10% reduction in 5 years’ — note a MINIMUM of 10% reduction in 5 years — and only two countries in the world chose to aim higher than the recommended minimum target. Almost every country opted to ‘go low’ at precisely 10% reduction in 5 years, including England.</p><p>So, the previous NSPS for England ‘went low’ and adopted the target of ‘10% reduction in 5 years’ in a ‘forward plan’ within the NSPS that was supposed to deliver this reduction by 2020. [Spoiler alert: it didn’t!]</p><p>This is a key date, especially given Minister Maria Caulfield’s appearance on BBC Breakfast when the new NSPS was launched and she talked about ‘progress being halted by the pandemic’ because the inconvenient truth is the plan was to reduce the numbers of suicides by 10% by 2020, so we should have seen progress before the pandemic even emerged.</p><p>Let’s just look at that chart carefully, and study the actual numbers:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CPYiRphCm25pP82RDF2n3A.png" /></figure><p>Yes, that’s right, the suicide rate went UP— and don’t be fooled by anyone telling you that we need to take into account that the burden of proof for Inquests changed from ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ to ‘balance of probabilities’ because that was only approved by the High Court in 2019.</p><p>So, the Government’s previous NSPS set the low ambition target of ‘10% reduction in 5 years’ and then failed to meet even such a low bar target.</p><p>And this new NSPS? Well, that’s a bit of a story, and not one with a happy ending because of the latest Strategy not having a target at all.</p><p>At the online forum that Steve Phillip and I were invited to, hosted by the National Suicide Prevention Alliance (NSPA) — the only formal invite we had to input into this NSPS remember, despite our extensive and intensive knowledge of what works in reducing the suicide numbers and having access to hundreds of people with lived experience of suicide in our network— we were asked to focus on the topic of “<em>targets and measurement</em>”.</p><p>There were some people putting forward a case for lower targets to “<em>be realistic</em>”, ie “<em>if we can’t achieve a 10% reduction, why set a target higher than that?</em>” — which is the ‘institutionalised low ambition’ syndrome in play again of course — and then some urging higher targets to “<em>demonstrate ambition</em>”.</p><p>Some of us from the ‘Zero Suicide Society community’ put forward a case for higher ambition targets like falls of 20%, 25%, 50% or more, to have the kind of ‘stretch targets’ that can drive the reductions in suicides we need.</p><p>And, fair to say, there were the usual arguments against. Some based on the ‘realism’ card again; and some based on misunderstandings about ‘Zero Suicide’ — which is a philosophy and framework for driving numbers down ‘towards zero’ with all the necessary cultural and structural change that requires, it’s not just a bald numerical target.</p><p>Some did argue a case for not having a target at all, which is an argument that Steve and I also heard in our action research interviews, but this argument rests on still having clear targets for all the component parts of strategies and plans, just not an overall target. High aspiration, stretching targets and accountability still have to be baked in somewhere or the National Strategy is just a piece of paper (or, these days, an online scroll).</p><p>Many of those in our action research project, especially those with lived experience of suicide, told us “<em>not setting an overall target for reduction in the suicide numbers would be like ‘giving up’ really</em>”; and we made that point in the NSPA forum — our sole opportunity for NSPS input remember.</p><p>NSPA helpfully published a summary of the discussions that took place at that forum, and passed it on to the National Suicide Prevention Advisory Group advising the Government on its new National Strategy.</p><p>And so, we now have the Government’s new National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England — which had plenty of time to consider all of these issues — and what did they decide?</p><p>They decided to have no target at all for the overall reduction in suicide numbers — that very action (or inaction!) that our lived experience community said would be “l<em>ike giving up</em>”!</p><p>The NSPS states its “<em>overall ambitions</em>” (can we really call them ‘ambitions’?) and limits its commitment to:</p><blockquote>“reduce the suicide rate over the next 5 years — with initial reductions observed within half this time or sooner”</blockquote><p>Not inspiring is it?! It reads like someone who’s had a terrible day at the races who’s in the bookies with their last £10 desperately trying to think of an each-way bet that’ll at least give them one win before they go home!</p><p>And, of course, money is a big part of this.</p><p>The Government’s new National Suicide Prevention Strategy has no new money in it and, with existing programmes scheduled to run out in 2024 and 2025, the NSPS is projected to have fewer resources in Years 3–5.</p><p>So, in summary, the NSPS lacks ambition, it lacks a target — making the next level of targets sitting underneath that even more crucial for action, progress &amp; accountability — it lacks the necessary resources to have impact and, for many people (with lived experience), it looks like ‘giving up’.</p><p>In that sense, the National Strategy lacks hope, and all of us involved in suicide prevention know how crucial it is to maintain hope.</p><p>With a bit of a scattergun, braindumping approach in the way the document has been written, another analogy that keeps coming into my mind is that the 2023–2028 National Suicide Prevention Strategy (is it really a strategy?) is a bit like someone with no money, and probably little hope of having the money they need, publishing their shopping list!</p><p>The NSPS does have some good measures in it, and you’ll see in The Jordan Legacy’s fair and balanced review that we’ve highlighted the good (in most cases ‘good, but could do better, and go further and faster’) as well as the bad and the ugly! — but overall…well let’s just say reading the content now it’s published would have been a massive disappointment if our expectations weren’t so low to begin with.</p><p>These low expectations are based on previous low ambition National Strategies and the reasonable assumption we’ll get more of the same, along with the 12 months’ delay in publication; the lack of public engagement or consultation; the very limited involvement of people with lived experience; poor communication around the NSPS; the fact that, very unprofessionally and disrespectfully, most ‘announcements’ about what was going to be in the NSPS were in the form of posts on ‘X/Twitter’ from the lead government adviser, Professor Sir Louis Appleby; compounded by the political spin that accompanied the launch, overstating progress since 2012 and understating the problem we’re trying to solve here so, potentially, creating further barriers to progress in reducing the number of suicides.</p><p>Remember you can read the formal published response to the new NSPS from The Jordan Legacy — a joint statement from myself and Steve Phillip — on The Jordan Legacy website here:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/the-jordan-legacys-response-to-the-governments-national-suicide-prevention-strategy-2023-2028/">The Jordan Legacy&#39;s Response To The Government&#39;s National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2023-2028 | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>What follows here is my personal review, reflections &amp; recommendations.</p><p><strong>And Here’s That Warning!</strong></p><p>I mentioned earlier there’d be a summary and also a warning. So, after the summary above, here’s the warning below.</p><p>At the events I’ve attended since the publication of the new SP Strategy, and in my many day-to-day conversations and exchanges via online business &amp; social media, from LinkedIn to Facebook, I’ve had many people say “I<em>sn’t it great the new National Strategy has been released (often followed by ‘at last’)</em>”.</p><p>I say to them “<em>Have you read it?</em>” and the answer almost always comes back “<em>Er, no…well…er, no, not yet…er, not all of it…er not in depth</em>”.</p><p>I also saw a post just after it was published saying “<em>I’ll be taking a look at this over the next few days but there is hope</em>” to which I replied “<em>I’ll also be reading it, and analysing it, very thoroughly over the next few days…then I’ll let you know if there’s hope</em>”.</p><p>We mustn’t make assumptions or let the political spin pass us by without proper scrutiny, transparency and accountability.</p><p>Our democracy depends on it and, in this case with it being the National SUICIDE PREVENTION Strategy, many human lives depend on it.</p><p>Please, please, please read the NSPS or, at the very least, scan the Strategy document and read The Jordan Legacy’s published response.</p><p>And I hope you’ll also read my critique below and the first 5 pages of the published National Suicide Prevention Strategy: including the Foreword from Minister Maria Caulfield MP; the Foreword from long-standing lead adviser to government on all matters suicide prevention, Professor Sir Louis Appleby (btw, in our action research project, some people referred to the National Suicide Prevention Strategy as “<em>Professor Appleby’s Strategy</em>” or just “<em>Appleby’s Strategy</em>” emphasising the degree of influence that a lead adviser can have!); and also please read the (3-page) Executive Summary.</p><p>There’s enough content in those first 5 pages to demonstrate the lack of ambition, the lack of commitment to getting the numbers of suicides on a downward trend, towards zero; and to highlight that, despite some positive measures, aligned to what people with lived experience, ie people who are ‘experts in their own experience’, and other ‘experts’ told us in our action research, some of the NSPS content can only be described as woeful… in places, shameful…and, in a couple of instances, potentially harmful.</p><p>And one further concern; a major concern.</p><p>Since the NSPS for England 2023–2028 was published, I’ve seen several posts on LinkedIn, and comments on social media, and even a couple of speeches from local Suicide Prevention Leads and leaders of prominent national charities saying “<em>we need to look at how we can implement the Government’s National Strategy</em>”.</p><p>No we don’t! It’s not our job to implement the Government’s Strategy — on suicide prevention or anything else for that matter!</p><p>It’s our role to find ways of getting the suicide numbers on a long-term downward trend, towards zero. Governments can help us achieve this goal or frustrate us in achieving this goal. In recent history, it’s been the latter.</p><p>It’s the role of local Suicide Prevention Leads to reduce suicides in their area. If drawing from the National Strategy or working with the Government — as genuine collaborative partners with shared goals — helps to get the numbers down, then that’s what we’ll do, that’s what we should do. If not, we won’t; we shouldn’t; we should challenge appropriately.</p><p>If, like me and many others, you think the Government’s Suicide Prevention Strategy is woefully low on ambition, why would you want to help them implement their low ambition strategy?</p><p>Work with them to get them to aspire higher for sure, but not conspire in low ambition. As I’ve found myself saying a lot in these past few weeks “<em>If you get into bed with low ambition, you tend to get infected with low ambition</em>”!</p><p><strong>The Suicide Numbers are Unacceptably High and Needlessly High!</strong></p><p>In my suicide prevention work, and in analysing a document like the new NSPS, I wear various professional hats, including Research Fellow analysing the data and dynamics; experienced public policy analyst; change coach and consultant with 40 years’ experience working on systems change and transformational change programmes; and counsellor working in mental health &amp; suicide prevention at one-to-one and small group level.</p><p>I also have my own lived experience, my own exposure to suicide, including losing many people to suicide — the first as long ago as 1980, the most recent being losing a family member in August 2020 — and I have my own tortured experience of debilitating depression with anxiety and many ‘complications’, which constantly reminds me that suicide is “<em>not just a mental health issue</em>”, a point that’s crucial to understand and act upon if we’re to get the suicide numbers moving downwards, towards zero.</p><p>I ‘think about’ and ‘feel about’ all of the above whenever I look at this chart below which is the chart MPs go to, or should go to if they haven’t seen it, in the House of Commons Library report on suicide rates.</p><p>It’s also the chart that Ministers and their advisers often ‘spin’ as showing a healthy picture of significant reduction in the suicide rate since 1981, without making it clear that reduction was in the period 1981 to 2007, with no reduction since 2007:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CPYiRphCm25pP82RDF2n3A.png" /></figure><p>Also, in the debate around The LEARN Network’s petition for a statutory duty of care for students in higher education, one MP described the recent suicide figures as “<em>mercifully low</em>”!</p><p>For anyone who’s lost a loved one to suicide or who’s almost lost their own life and managed to survive a suicide attempt, and for all of those like myself, Steve Phillip and The Jordan Legacy advocating and campaigning for a ‘Zero Suicide Society’, these suicide numbers are not “<em>mercifully low</em>”, they’re unacceptably high!</p><p>And they’re needlessly high because all the evidence tells us that most suicides are preventable. We need ‘the will’. We have ‘the way’.</p><p>IASP President, Professor Rory O’Connor, told us “<em>we know what works in preventing suicides, we’re just not good in putting this knowledge into practice</em>”.</p><p>People with lived experience know ‘what works’ or what will work.</p><p><strong>The Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme</strong></p><p>This is why we must listen to and learn from diverse lived experience voices — and go ‘wide and deep’ in our listening.</p><p>And it’s why the <strong>Zero Suicide Society Transformation Model</strong> is built on a foundation stone of listening to and learning from people with lived experience, as well as involving all the other key stakeholders who are part of the solution, because we know that ‘Involvement = Commitment’:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/1*WKjEdMDyyEB0v3RdHvtuZA.png" /><figcaption>The ‘Zero Suicide Society’ transformation model &amp; framework illustrating the ‘Building Blocks’ required for ‘moving towards zero’ and the ‘Jigsaw Picture Puzzle’ of suicide prevention (with ‘the missing piece’ a symbol of its complexity and the multiple factors involved which we continue to learn about and never have all the answers to— hence why we need continuous listening and learning, collaboration, and humility)</figcaption></figure><p>If you want to know more about the Zero Suicide Society Vision and Transformation Models, Frameworks and Programmes, including the Building Blocks/Jigsaw Picture Puzzle model illustrated above, you can read our (2nd Edition) Report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ via this link:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-edition-2-of-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - Edition 2 Of The Report | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p><strong>Suicide Prevention as a Transformational Change Challenge</strong></p><p>The report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’, which I co-authored with Steve Phillip, also highlights <strong>The 3 Key Dynamics of Change</strong> model that I’ve used in my transformational change consulting and coaching work for more than 30 years, and which I focus on in my lectures at business schools, and which I’ve applied to both our Zero Suicide Society model and the Government’s National Strategy for England 2023–2028. It’s quite a contrast!</p><p>There’s an explainer piece on this transformational change model here:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/making-change-happen-with-less-stress-3edc6ed3572">Making change happen — with less stress</a></p><p>Essentially, suicide prevention is a transformational change challenge. Indeed, one of the great transformational change challenges of our time.</p><p>That makes it a rather scary prospect for many — and some have clearly ‘given up’ or ‘buried their heads in the sand’ — but others, especially those who work in transformational change being exposed to ‘the suicide problem’ for the first time, see it as a positive challenge we need to rise to, and an opportunity to show what we can do, especially without the polarising politics of other great challenges of our time like climate action.</p><p>In our action research and analysis, we applied <strong>The 3 Key Dynamics of Change</strong> model to our inputs and outputs and it passed the tests, always with room for improvement of course.</p><p>To effect transformational change, we need a powerful <strong>Push</strong> effect moving us away from our active dissatisfaction with the current state.</p><p>The report, and everything we do as part of the Zero Suicide Society Programme every day, makes it clear we’re deeply dissatisfied with the status quo with 6000+ preventable deaths by suicide in the UK, and 5,000+ preventable suicide deaths in England, each year for the past 15 years, with no reduction in those numbers over that long period.</p><p>It’s a problem that’s clearly not improving and without the capacity to improve when, for example, the number of children on NHS Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services’ waiting lists exceeded 1 million in January 2023 for the first time, and where adults having thoughts of suicide are being put on a 6 months’ waiting list for NHS Mental Health Services!</p><p>Push? We desperately need urgent <strong>Push</strong>, urgent action!</p><p>To effect transformational change, we also need a powerful <strong>Pull</strong> effect, motivating us to move towards a compelling future vision that’s achievable and therefore inspiring, energising, and a source of hope.</p><p>The Zero Suicide Society vision — a highly practical vision and a realistically achievable future desired state, not a utopian dream — provides this necessary Pull effect.</p><p>And, last but not least, transformational change needs a powerful<strong> Engagement and Involvement</strong> effect. Those who need to be part of the change must be involved in that change — Involvement = Commitment!</p><p>Those who have ‘the answers’ must be engaged and involved. In the case of suicide prevention, we know that people with lived experience of suicide have ‘the answers’ and we must learn from them, as well as listening to anyone widely regarded as an ‘expert’ in the field — avoiding self-appointed ‘experts’! — and anyone who potentially has solutions, including evidence-based ideas or ideas that may need us to search for new evidence.</p><p>We constantly strive to have wide and deep engagement and involvement.</p><p>We do pretty well — certainly for a tiny VCSE organisation which relies purely on donations for its income — but with the perspective and humility to accept that we’re not doing enough and we can do much more.</p><p>We’re about to launch a new project which will create ‘a deliberative and participative democracy map for the suicide prevention landscape’ which will show what more needs to be done on ‘lived experience involvement and engagement’ and how we can do it.</p><p>We plan to make this a collaborative exercise, partly because ‘technically’ this makes sense, and partly because it will be important symbolically — a wide and deep engagement about wide and deep engagement!</p><p><strong>The NSPS 2023–2028 is not a Transformational Change Strategy!</strong></p><p>We applied these same three tests to the Government’s new National Strategy for England — NSPS 2023–2028 — and on <strong>Push</strong>, <strong>Pull</strong>, <strong>Involve</strong>, the report card is ‘<strong>Fail</strong>, <strong>Fail</strong>, <strong>Inadequate</strong>’.</p><p>To be fair, no-one gets above ‘Inadequate’ for involving and engaging stakeholders, including specifically involving and engaging people with lived or living experiences of suicide, as we all have so far to go here.</p><p>All able to comment felt that lived experience involvement in developing the new NSPS was much improved on previous National Strategies — although several people recounted how the process for developing the Government’s first National Strategy in 2012 involved three people with lived experience so not hard to top that! — but it’s crucial for our change dynamics to accept that what we’ve all done to date is still Inadequate.</p><p>It’s definitely a big <strong>Fail on Pull</strong> as there’s no compelling vision mapped out in the NSPS 2023–2028, no real vision at all in fact, and many people have commented on this to us, often praising our report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ for providing that vision as a much-needed source of hope and inspiration, as well as providing a practical road map.</p><p>And it’s a huge <strong>Fail on Push</strong>, because NSPS 2023–2028 and the subsequent communications around it, including the launch on 11 September, has appeared to play down the problem and talk up any evidence of progress in what is, at best, misunderstanding the crucial role dissatisfaction with the status quo plays in change dynamics and, at worst, the kind of political spin that causes so much unnecessary pain in our society and our democracy, which needs to be fed by honesty, transparency and accountability but is so often given the very opposite meal.</p><p><strong>Communications for Change or for Inertia?</strong></p><p>In our report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ Second Edition, published on 28 September, two weeks after the Government released its new National Strategy, we highlighted the incongruence between what Mental Health Minister Maria Caulfield MP was saying and the actual evidence:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3wgk0oj5nhO79gM9UfYdHg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CPYiRphCm25pP82RDF2n3A.png" /></figure><p>As part of the Minister’s media rounds on publication of the NSPS for 2023–2028, when asked by the BBC’s Jon Kay why it’s taken so long since 2012 to publish this new Strategy, with many lives being lost in this time, the Minister replied:</p><p>“<em>Well, it’s really important to note the progress that’s been made during that time. We saw a 20% reduction in the number of suicides compared to, say, two decades ago…so it’s just before the pandemic that progress began to plateau so we haven’t seen a huge increase in the numbers but we haven’t seen a reduction either</em>”.</p><p>Now we can be generous and say the Minister just got a bit flustered in the studio and a bit confused with the data, but let’s pick this statement apart.</p><p>Jon Kay was asking why there’s been no progress, in reducing suicide rates, since 2012, as he was aware of the ‘flat line’ since 2012.</p><p>The Minister did not acknowledge the lack of progress in terms of no reduction in the overall number of suicides since 2012 and, in direct contradiction, tried to imply there’d been progress.</p><p>She had two goes at it, in fact.</p><p>The first was implying there’d been a 20% reduction in suicides in the period since 2012 compared with the previous two decades. Not true of course, as the chart shows very clearly. The reduction came long before 2012, long before the first published NSPS was introduced in 2012.</p><p>The second go was implying progress between 2012 and 2019/20 with that progress ‘being halted by the pandemic’. Again, the chart shows this is not an evidence-based claim.</p><p>Was this mischievous political spin or simply a confused response under pressure? I’ll leave you to decide!</p><p>At the very end of her response, the Minister finally acknowledges there’s been no reduction in the numbers but her implication in her response as a whole is that there’d been a reduction 2012–2019/20 — which there wasn’t — and then no reduction since the pandemic reached our shores.</p><p>And to complete her confusion or obfuscation — again, you choose! — the Minister threw in “<em>we haven’t seen a huge increase in the numbers</em>” which also gives people the impression that everything might be rosy in the garden, and an attempt to reassure with there being no ‘huge increase’.</p><p>It’s often said that ‘the first step to solving a problem is accepting there’s a problem to be solved’. In all our communications at The Jordan Legacy, we consciously and very deliberately refer to “<em>the unacceptably high level of suicide deaths</em>” because 6000+ deaths each year in the UK, or 5000+ each year in England, is an unacceptably high number of suicide deaths.</p><p>We refer to “<em>the needlessly high level of suicide deaths</em>” because most suicides are preventable, and we know there are so many practical actions we can take to get the numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>And we constantly highlight the ‘flat line’ in the graph, ie the fact that the suicide numbers in UK/England &amp; Wales/England have not fallen for the past 15 years. We’ll have to start saying 16 years now we have 2022 data!</p><p>Regularly and highly visibly showing this graph highlighting the ‘flat line’ is the simplest way of highlighting the problem we’re trying to solve; it spurs on those who are already trying to get the line on a downward trend — although it can be dispiriting to see ‘no change’ year after year — and, importantly, it activates others who previously haven’t been involved in suicide prevention and not been aware there’s a problem to solve.</p><p>To get the change we need, we must frequently and prominently communicate that the suicide numbers are unacceptably high, needlessly high, and not coming down, with no reduction for these past 15 years. As described earlier, this is our important <strong>Push</strong> change dynamic.</p><p>What we often get though, very sadly and dangerously — at worst, putting lives at risk or in danger — is academics &amp; other data commentators saying the current suicide numbers are “<em>relatively low</em>”, which is factually correct when comparing current suicide rates to, say, the 1980s, but extremely unhelpful and even damaging from a change dynamics perspective…</p><p>..and in that one case already highlighted earlier, by an MP standing up in parliament and describing the suicide numbers as “<em>mercifully low</em>”!</p><p>For the record, the MP in question was Paul Blomfield (Sheffield Central), and he made some good points, eg about the education system taking the strain due to NHS Mental Health Services being unable to cope, and he made some compassionate and supportive comments, including most importantly in my view “<em>even one suicide is one too many</em>” and — quoting Ged Flynn from PAPYRUS — “<em>suicide is very much a preventable death</em>” but, in opposing a statutory duty of care for universities, he also ‘framed the problem’ by saying the overall suicide numbers are “<em>mercifully low</em>” and “<em>much lower among students…than among the population as a whole</em>”…</p><p><a href="https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2023-06-05/debates/9BA59E93-4342-4AD6-BA94-379DCA6A24E0/HigherEducationStudentsStatutoryDutyOfCare">https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2023–06–05/debates/9BA59E93–4342–4AD6-BA94–379DCA6A24E0/HigherEducationStudentsStatutoryDutyOfCare</a></p><p>…which, sadly, cancels out his positive comments and are part of what is a common (conscious or sub-conscious) narrative, among MPs and other people in positions of power and influence, that suicide rates are low and therefore not a big problem to be solved nor an issue to be prioritised.</p><p>As people who care about human life, as people who care passionately about reducing the numbers of suicides, as people who know there are practical actions we can take to get those suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, as people who believe that with the right ‘will’ and the right ‘way’ we’re capable of halving the numbers of suicides within the next 5–10 years, and as people with lived or living experiences of suicide, including losing loved ones to suicide…we should never, ever describe the current suicide numbers as “<em>mercifully low</em>” or “<em>reassuringly low</em>” as I’ve heard another MP say!</p><p><strong>NSPS 2023–2028: a Change &amp; Action Dynamics Analysis Critique</strong></p><p><strong><em>(inc Forewords that are not taking us Forward!)</em></strong></p><p>In the context of my own personal goal, my own primary goal for the remainder of my life and career, being to reduce the numbers of suicides in the UK and get them on a downward trend, towards zero, I’ll now provide a very detailed critique of the Government’s new National Suicide Prevention Strategy to illustrate the lack of help and the potential harm within this document.</p><p>It’s crucial that we challenge it, question it, pick it apart…and devise our own local and targeted strategies and action plans that we think will significantly reduce the numbers of suicides — the micro ‘Zero Suicide Plans’ that will add up to a ‘macro zero’ — and draw from the NSPS 2023–2028 as just one source (not the source) for our strategies and plans.</p><p>Apart from anything else, let’s have some self-respect, and empower ourselves to act as we believe we should act to get the change we want to bring about, not kowtow to the Government, especially one that appears to have no commitment to suicide prevention or which has run out of ideas for how to bring the numbers down, or both.</p><p>Where the Government’s strategies and plans are aligned with ours, helpful and not harmful, of course we’ll fully collaborate.</p><p>Even then, we need to make sure it’s true collaboration not a top-down, hierarchical misuse or abuse of power, status or influence. We must be partners, and all consider ourselves to be partners, tackling a complex, multi-faceted problem that the evidence clearly shows no-one person or organisation, not the Government nor its advisers, have ‘the solution’ to. Fundamentally, we need respect and we need humility.</p><p><strong>A Word from the Minister</strong></p><p>In the opening passage from NSPS 2023–2028 (see screenshot below ) it’s good that the Minister — our latest Minister through the revolving door of the mental health and suicide prevention portfolios! — acknowledges the devastating impact every suicide has.</p><p>This is not only the appropriate human response, and response we should expect from the Minister, it’s an essential component part of our <strong>Push</strong> change dynamic to get the numbers down.</p><p>The Minister then says she is/her Govt is “<em>committed to reducing the number of lives lost to suicide</em>” which I’d like to think is the case but the rest of the document, and her media interviews, cast doubt on this commitment.</p><p>Having no target at all for suicide reduction does look like ‘giving up’ on any aspirations to significantly reduce the suicide numbers, and not committing any new resources doesn’t breed confidence.</p><p>I’m discounting the £10 million DHSC VCSE Suicide Prevention Grant Fund, highlighted so prominently at the beginning of the NSPS document and featuring so strongly in the Minister’s public responses when asked about funding behind the National Strategy, because £10 million is a drop in the ocean when we’re talking about the funding needed to ‘tackle the mental health crisis’ and get the suicide numbers on a downward trend ‘to their lowest level ever’ as many have urged, including Samaritans.</p><p>Hopefully, that VCSE SP Fund will not only provide some useful prop-up funding for VCSEs doing really valuable work — the Fund will be covering operational costs for many existing activities with some development of existing and new activities — but it will also fund innovation, and new ideas, that can potentially be transformative.</p><p><em>[Postscript: I put in a submission on behalf of The Jordan Legacy for funds to demonstrate implementation of the Zero Suicide Society Transformation Model &amp; Programme, along with a crucial ‘Join the Dots’ initiative linking together otherwise disconnected parts of the system, and a scoping study to develop a prototype support centre transferable across the country; with all parts being transformational change proposals, not trying to prop up the status quo or stick a finger in the dyke! But we got a ‘no’ from DHSC].</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lKBGiCIV28YebA3bS1_b5g.png" /></figure><p>The most worrying aspect of the Minister’s words — both above in the NSPS document and also in her media interviews — is the emphasis she places on ‘progress’ since 2012.</p><p>Now where there really is progress, it’s crucially important to highlight it and to suitably ‘celebrate’ it, although ‘celebrating’ progress in suicide prevention is a very difficult thing to do because even if we’d halved the numbers of suicides and felt like we should be having a party to mark this great achievement that would still mean thousands of people losing their lives each year and individuals out there in pain at losing their loved ones who wouldn’t be impressed by an overt celebration of fewer deaths while we still have so many preventable tragedies.</p><p>But, privately, in the right kinds of environments, using the most appropriate and sensitive language, it’s important for our change dynamics to recognise progress where it truly is progress as this spurs us on to go further, and perhaps faster.</p><p>For example, the NSPS 2023–2028 refers to a fall in the number of in-patient suicides by 35% between 2010–2020 so this is definitely worthy of recognition, although tempered with two qualifications.</p><p>Firstly, a 35% reduction is still not enough of course and we should have high aspirations for reducing the number of suicides for those ‘within the system’, ie where we know who these people are, in contrast to those in the community who ‘suddenly’ end their lives ‘without warning’; we know they’re at risk or in danger; we know what support they need; and we have the potential to provide the treatment, care and support they need, including on discharge — and continually trying to improve community-based services that reduce the numbers needing to enter ‘the mental health system’ — to keep more of these people ‘alive and well’.</p><p>Secondly, note the timeline for this reduction, 2010–2020, and the timeline for the Government’s first, publicly announced, NSPS from 2012. Any new strategy takes some time to have an effect, so the Strategy introduced in 2012 would have started having some impacts from 2013–2014 and, where actions involved systems changes, perhaps from 2015–2017. We must take care not to attribute too much of a reduction in in-patient suicide numbers 2010–2020 to a new Strategy announced in September 2012!</p><p>The Minister in her foreword saying “<em>In developing this strategy, we have set out how we can build on the progress made over the past 11 years…</em>” is not unsurprising positioning for a politician who’s a member of the party that’s formed Government for the past 11 years but it becomes a problem in terms of change dynamics when the (political) narrative is centred around ‘progress’ and the suicide numbers are not going down.</p><p>Let’s just look at that ‘flat line chart’ one more time, and reflect:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L7-kpOw9qJwrqKclYT_3aQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s not ‘progress since 2012’ is it?!</p><p><strong>A Word from The Government’s Lead Adviser</strong></p><p>Following the Minister’s opening comments in NSPS 2023–2028, we have the Foreword from the lead adviser to the Government on suicide prevention, Professor Sir Louis Appleby. Prof Appleby has been the lead adviser on suicide prevention for many years, including for previous national strategies and plans.</p><p>As far as most people are concerned, the first National Strategy was that released in 2012 because that was the first published document that was generally known to be “<em>the National Suicide Prevention Strategy</em>” — and, in her media rounds on 11 September, the Minister referred to the 2012 document as “<em>the first National Strategy</em>”…</p><p>…although Professor Appleby says in his Foreword “<em>We have had a suicide prevention strategy in England for 21 years</em>”, ie going back to 2002, so we might want to take this into account in our analysis or just focus on the period since 2012 when the whole process has had some semblance of transparency and public accountability..</p><p>…although the lack of transparency and accountability around the National Strategy is a common criticism, including most public communication around the National Strategy being in the form of Prof Appleby’s Tweets.</p><p>Professor Appleby’s opening paragraph (see screenshot below) displays humanity and is a good summary of the situation we face. Individuals experiencing loss and pain ask what they could have done when there is often nothing (more) they could have done but there’s a lot more ‘the system’ could do to prevent future losses, future pain, future suffering.</p><p>His second paragraph is rather disturbing though, from a change dynamics perspective as well as from the human perspective of someone whose life has been touched by suicide on multiple occasions.</p><p>As just noted, he says “<em>We have had a suicide prevention strategy in England for 21 years</em>” and then continues “<em>During that time, national suicide rates have been the lowest on record, the average rate around 20% lower than in the previous 2 decades</em>”.</p><p>This is dangerously close territory to the MP who described current suicide rates as “<em>mercifully low</em>”!</p><p>For our <strong>Push</strong> dynamic, we need to emphasise that the current level of suicides, and the level they’ve been at for the past 11 years, and most of the past 21 years, is ‘unacceptably and needlessly high’. Without that clear expression of dissatisfaction with the status quo, we risk fuelling the inertia dynamic that is saying ‘no problem to be solved’ and holding back progress.</p><p>As soon as we start framing the numbers as ‘relatively low historically’ or ‘the lowest on record’, even if this is factually correct, we’re weakening our <strong>Push</strong> dynamic and encouraging others to think there’s not a problem to be solved here, including those MPs who might be tempted to use damaging lines like ‘reassuringly low’ or ‘mercifully low’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QkBB-D8yxgCGEDCOhysAfg.png" /></figure><p>Given that it doesn’t help us in achieving our goal of reducing the numbers of suicides and could actually hinder us, some would argue that this point about suicide rates being “<em>the lowest on record</em>” for the past 21 years should not appear in this Strategy document at all, certainly not so prominently in the Foreword by the Government’s lead adviser.</p><p>As with all so-called ‘evidence-based statements’, we also need to take care with our use and interpretation. The implication here — and in Professor Appleby’s public posts on this particular point — appears to be that having National Suicide Prevention Strategies has helped to keep suicide rates low.</p><p>This is a contestable claim and, again, it raises questions from a change dynamics perspective. It’s also at the heart of the low aspirations baked in to the latest NSPS for 2023–2028.</p><p>If we’re approaching this ‘problem’ — and talking up the fact it is a problem, not playing it down as the numbers being ‘relatively low’ or there being ‘huge progress since 2012’ — as needing to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend (some of us would add ‘towards zero’ but most would certainly agree the aspiration is a ‘downward trend’), then our ambition should be clearly stated as this, and our language should be geared to not just clarifying this but helping us achieve our goal and not hinder us.</p><p>The ‘fact’ that, for the past 21 years, “<em>national suicide rates have been the lowest on record, the average rate around 20% lower than in the previous 2 decades</em>” is not relevant and not a helpful ‘fact’ to highlight when trying to get the suicide rates on a long-term downward trend (towards zero).</p><p>Let’s look at that chart again:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CPYiRphCm25pP82RDF2n3A.png" /></figure><p>The chart shows suicide rates on a downward trend from 1981 until 2007 and then what we often refer to as the ‘flat line’ since then.</p><p>Although we use the term ‘flat line’, suicide rates have actually gone up, even allowing for the burden of proof at Inquests being changed (from ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ to ‘balance of probabilities’) since 2019.</p><p>We tend to use the term ‘flat line’ because our aspiration is to get the suicide numbers on a long-term downward trend, towards zero, and what we’re doing when interpreting this key graph is saying ‘the downward trend from 1981 to 2007 should have continued but it’s basically flat-lined since’.</p><p>If we try to argue that suicide rates have gone up since 2007, the argument gets technical and nuanced and it changes the focus from trying to get the numbers down to arguing about the data, which benefits no-one except the ‘data nerds’ who love arguing about data!</p><p>If we frame it as ‘no reduction for the past 15 years’, that’s both factually correct and helpful as a change dynamic.</p><p>The phrase ‘flat-lined’ is a shorthand we may or may not wish to use, but the data clearly shows ‘no reduction for the past 15 years’ so that’s where our focus should be, along with getting that trend line going down.</p><p>According to the Minister, the first National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England was introduced (at least published) in 2012. The data tells us there’s been no reduction in suicide rates since then, with a case for arguing that rates have gone up since 2012. This is why the Minister’s emphasis on ‘progress since 2012’ is so problematic.</p><p>According to Professor Appleby, “<em>we have had a suicide prevention strategy in England for 21 years</em>”, ie since 2002. The data tells us that in that period there was a continuation of the historic fall in suicide rates 2002–7, and then a rise 2007–2013, and then it’s basically remained flat since 2013.</p><p>Based on this evidence, it’s clear the introduction of National Strategies — whether from 2002 or 2012 — has NOT led to a reduction in suicide rates.</p><p>And the main argument for investing in National Strategies — in England and in other countries that have introduced National Strategies, including Australia where I was more directly involved — is to get the suicide numbers on a long-term downward trend (towards zero).</p><p>In this sense, let’s not be afraid to say it, the National Strategies for England have failed in this fundamental aim.</p><p>Let’s now return to the contestable claim that having these National Strategies have been a success because they’ve ‘stopped the numbers rising further’ or as Professor Appleby puts it in his Foreword “<em>We have faced overwhelming threats to our mental health: a global recession that put suicide rates up and a pandemic that — against most expectations — did not</em>”.</p><p>As I say, this is a ‘contestable claim’ so we’re not going to get a consensus view but we do need to ask ourselves which narrative we’re buying into.</p><p>In the period 1981–2007, when suicide rates were on the kind of downward trend we want to see revived right now, there were two deep recessions in England, two very different types of recession including the early 1980s where there were massive job losses in the old industrial parts of the country and suicides increased in these areas, as I personally experienced, and then the early 1990s where the job losses were much more spread across the country and across demographic and socio-economic groups including significant increases in ‘white collar’ unemployment, again placing upward pressure on suicide rates.</p><p>And yet, despite these two deep, biting recessions, the overall suicide rates in England were coming down, for a whole host of reasons. It’s rather disingenuous, therefore, to argue that National Strategies since 2002 or 2012 have been unable to keep suicide rates on a downward trend because of the recession caused by the global financial crisis in 2008–2009.</p><p>Of course, the global COVID pandemic was an exceptional event, but this hit us with real impact when we had the first Lockdown from March 2020. Much evidence, which Professor Appleby himself has highlighted, has shown that this period with these Lockdowns did not lead to an increase in suicide rates, although there may still be some delayed impacts to come, eg businesses that depleted all reserves during that period that have survived until now but may not make it through the next 5 years.</p><p>Suicide rates were not going down 2012 to March 2020 so we can’t blame the pandemic for our failure to reduce suicide rates during this period.</p><p>Another disturbing comment from the Minister when launching the new NSPS 2023–2028 on BBC Breakfast was about ‘making progress until the pandemic’. Let me just remind you of her exact words.</p><p>Asked by the BBC’s Jon Kay why it’s taken so long since 2012 to publish this new Strategy, the Minister replied “<em>Well, it’s really important to note the progress that’s been made during that time. We saw a 20% reduction in the number of suicides compared to, say, two decades ago…so it’s just before the pandemic that progress began to plateau so we haven’t seen a huge increase in the numbers but we haven’t seen a reduction either</em>”.</p><p>As I’ve already highlighted, the Minister’s statement implies a 20% reduction in suicides between 2012 and 2019/20 compared with ‘two decades ago’, which wasn’t the case; and that this progress was ‘only halted by the pandemic’ — not true because there was no reduction in this period, the (20%) reduction came prior to 2012.</p><p>So, we’ve got the Minister suggesting we’ve reduced the suicide numbers since 2012, which we haven’t, implying a 20% reduction which is clearly not the case, and Prof Appleby suggesting the numbers of suicides could have been even higher in the period since 2012 due to the upward pressures of recession, despite the fact we had deep recessions in the early 1980s and again in the early 1990s when suicide numbers were on a downward trend.</p><p>And, again trying to be generous, maybe the Minister got a bit confused with Prof Appleby’s text in this Foreword when he says, of the period 2002 to the present, “<em>during that time, national suicide rates have been the lowest on record, the average rate around 20% lower than in the previous 2 decades</em>”?</p><p>As the chart shows, the suicide rates may have been, on average, 20% lower 2002–2021 compared with the 2 decades prior to that but this is not due to the existence of National Strategies because the bulk of that 20% fall was pre-2002 and all of it was pre-2012.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2ywpLH3hFeEmds8wFi2-ow.png" /></figure><p>In his Foreword, Professor Appleby then says “<em>This is progress but not enough</em>” and, thankfully, goes on to give us a bit of a <strong>Push</strong> dynamic with “<em>There are still over 5,000 deaths by suicide in England each year</em>” and “<em>Suicide and self-harm have increased in young people</em>”.</p><p>But, again, whether there’s actually been ‘progress’ is a moot point.</p><p>With no reduction in the overall numbers of suicides, many of us would argue there’s not been progress, so it’s not a case of ‘not enough progress’, it’s a case of ‘no progress’.</p><p>And Professor Appleby also adds the line “<em>The national suicide rate has not fallen since 2018</em>”. That is definitely true but it’s also true that the national suicide rate hasn’t been on a downward trend since 2007.</p><p>Now you can say ‘it went up a bit, then down a bit, then up a bit so, technically speaking, it did go down a bit before going up again after 2017 so again, technically speaking, ‘it hasn’t gone down since 2018&#39;.</p><p>But for those of us wanting to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, and embrace that <strong>Push</strong> change dynamic, we would look at that data and say “<em>the suicide rate hasn’t gone down for the past 15 years</em>” or “<em>the suicide numbers have remained at an unacceptably high level of 5,000+ preventable deaths for each of the past 15 years</em>”.</p><p>Both of these forms of words and numbers would not only be evidence-based, factually correct statements, but also emphasise the problem we’re trying to solve here, the priority and urgency of the problem we’re trying to solve here, and the desperate need to do something to prevent us losing another 5,000 people next year and the year after that and the year after that and the year after that…</p><p>Just saying “<em>the national suicide rate hasn’t fallen since 2018</em>” is another example, consciously or subconsciously, of downplaying the problem here. For the vast majority of people who don’t know the details of the data, nor these nuances of interpretation, ‘no reduction since 2018’ sounds so much more palatable than ‘no reduction for the past 15 years’. It encourages disengagement. It encourages inaction. The very opposite of what we need!</p><p>To be fair, ‘no reduction since 2018’ is still informing readers of the document that there’s been no ‘success’ for 5 years, so that has some benefit, but ‘no reduction for 15 years’ emphasises the scale of the problem much much better.</p><p>Some might argue ‘no reduction for 15 years’ might encourage people to think there’s no scope for further reduction but that’s part of the change challenge — emphasising the ambition, the vision, what practical steps we can take, giving confidence that we can get the numbers on a long-term trend down, towards zero. Sadly, NSPS 2023–2028 fails to do this.</p><p>Professor Appleby has a feared reputation, especially among campaigners trying to make their case using data, for being a stickler for accuracy in data, interpretation of data, and presentation of data, so I’m sure he wouldn’t want anyone to misinterpret statements like “<em>During 20yrs of current strategy, suicide rates have been lower than at any previous time</em>”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hDtbTWAOWjJ8TgpVmnuI-Q.png" /></figure><p>As I replied at the time:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PehB3nA9O34VF9opUHXfwQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>NSPS ‘Why We Need a New Suicide Prevention Strategy’</strong></p><p><strong><em>(inc why we need honesty, transparency, accountability, and ambition!)</em></strong></p><p>Well that was a lot of time spent on the two Forewords, but they’re important. It’s the Minister with portfolio responsibility for suicide prevention and the Government’s lead adviser on suicide prevention for the period covered by these National Strategies framing the latest Strategy for the consumption of readers — many of whom will just read the two Forewords and the Executive Summary — and also framing the public conversation around the NSPS 2023–2028, so worth that investment of time.</p><p>The next section of the NSPS document — screenshot below — covers why we need a new national suicide prevention strategy.</p><p>Once again, it begins with the ‘considerable progress since 2012’ narrative. This of course is not progress in reducing the suicide numbers. It’s ‘progress’ in terms of ‘implementing priorities’. And, as we’ve been highlighting for some time, the focus on priorities — ‘The Priority Trap’ — is itself problematic, itself a barrier to reducing the suicide numbers. So ‘progress’ in ‘implementing priorities’ is not really progress at all!</p><p>And “<em>Local authorities, NHS organisations, and suicide prevention organisations have aligned their suicide prevention activities with the national strategy</em>” is not necessarily progress either, as there are two traps here — ‘The Priority Trap’, ie having winners and losers in a zero sum game where the overall suicide numbers don’t go down, and ‘The Top Down Trap’ where numbers don’t fall because local plans are driven by priorities in national plans rather than being shaped around local priorities.</p><p>The NHS is probably an exception because of its inherent top-down structure and culture and ‘sameness’ at its core, ie trying to provide the same nature and standard of care everywhere in the country.</p><p>It’s possible, and often desirable, to drive change from the top in the NHS — as long as local innovation is also encouraged as this can drive changes that can then be shared across the system, not just be ‘thought of at the top’.</p><p>The 35% fall in suicides among those in NHS Mental Health in-patient settings between 2010 and 2020, some of which may have been fostered by the National Strategy launched in 2012, is the kind of scale of reduction we should be expecting in other parts of our broader ‘suicide prevention system’ and should therefore be expecting in overall suicide numbers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8PxDs3fnH3QlBmBB9zwa-A.png" /></figure><p>We then have “<em>Within the last 10 years, we observed one of the lowest ever rates of registered suicides</em>”. That’s true. And it cannot be emphasised enough that it’s a case of ‘observing’ this phenomenon. It doesn’t mean that having a (published) National Suicide Prevention Strategy since 2012 has driven this, as the ‘relatively low’ flat line has been observed since 2007.</p><p>Next it says “<em>But we cannot ignore the fact that there is much more we can do</em>”.</p><p>We absolutely cannot ignore that fact, and must not ignore it. And it’s not just a case of ‘doing more’, we need to ‘do different’ as well because what we’ve been doing since 2012, indeed since 2007, hasn’t been ‘working’ in terms of getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend.</p><p>The next sentence is very disturbing, and another massive fail when assessed against our <strong>Push</strong> change dynamic. It says “<em>In 2018, there was an increase in the suicide rate following several years of steady decline</em>”.</p><p>Referring to our chart again shows that the suicide rate did indeed go up in 2018 but not after ‘several years of steady decline’. And the overall picture is of ‘no reduction since 2007…after 25 years of steady decline’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CPYiRphCm25pP82RDF2n3A.png" /></figure><p>The final sentence in that opening section, after the Forewords, states “<em>And while, overall, the current suicide rate is not significantly higher than in 2012, the rate is not falling. We must do all we can to prevent more suicides, save many more lives, and ultimately reduce suicide rates</em>”.</p><p>This wording gives us a little more hope, as it emphasises that there is more we can do to reduce the number of suicides, including saying “<em>we must do all we can</em>” so there’s a bit of heart in there too.</p><p>But it’s half-hearted. There’s an emphasis on ‘suicide rates not significantly higher than 2012’ rather than ‘no reduction since 2012’; ‘preventing more suicides’ not ‘preventing all preventable suicides’; and ‘reducing suicide rates’ rather than significantly or considerably reducing the numbers.</p><p>Imagine the difference in <strong>Push</strong> power if it read as follows: “<em>The overall suicide rate has not fallen at all since 2012. We must do all we can to prevent all preventable suicides, save thousands of lives, and get suicide rates on a downward trend (towards zero)</em>”. Much more motivating!</p><p><strong>NSPS Executive Summary — More Questions than Answers!</strong></p><p>Next it’s the Executive summary, leading once again with that ‘considerable progress since 2012’ narrative; also including the line “<em>We have seen one of the lowest ever suicide rates (in 2017)</em>”, despite the trend not being down, so a selective use of statistics; and repeating the half hearted “<em>However, while overall the current suicide rate is not significantly higher than in 2012, the rate is not falling. There is much more we must all do to save more lives</em>”.</p><p>There’s a strong flavour in the document, and in the media interviews, of an emphasis on ‘personal responsibility’, eg the ‘suicide is everyone’s business’ message going out at the same time as government is not stepping up — indeed, potentially allocating fewer resources to suicide prevention in this NSPS 2023–2028)— with the ‘we must all do’ narrative then appearing to be a case of smoke and mirrors!</p><p>Add to this a classic of modern day politics, ie the tendency to quote lots of big £ numbers and give a scattergun list of activities, in both the document and in the media interviews when responding to scrutiny questions, and it makes the heart sink further.</p><p>It’s great that “<em>All areas of the country now have local suicide prevention plans and suicide bereavement services</em>” but not good that many local plans lack ambition — lots suffer from the ‘10% reduction in 5 years’ syndrome — and they lack the resources to deliver even a 10% reduction in the numbers.</p><p>And note that, once again, the feature item in this Executive summary is the 35% reduction in in-patient suicides.</p><p>As already commented, it’s definitely progress between 2010 and 2020, with some of this progress possibly driven by the National Strategy introduced in 2012, and it’s the kind of scale of reduction we should be seeking across the entire ‘suicide prevention system’ not just ‘the NHS system’ where the main focus of suicide prevention plans and activities has been historically.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iZpjilOyWiDxT-WxwrpSmg.png" /></figure><p>In the final part of that first section of the Executive summary shown above, there’s reference to needing “<em>a national government effort</em>” as well as everyone else continuing to play their part.</p><p>Absolutely right, and the NSPS 2023–2028 suggests a weak effort from national government on this occasion.</p><p>It then goes on “<em>The aim of this cross-government strategy is to bring everybody together around common priorities and set out actions that can be taken to…reduce the suicide rate over the next 5 years — with initial reductions observed within half this time or sooner</em>”.</p><p>Firstly, is it really a ‘cross-government strategy’?</p><p>From what I’ve heard from those directly involved in putting this NSPS together, and from my own direct experience with several government departments, some are more committed than others, including some who display very little appetite for suicide prevention and tend to throw the ball back to DHSC rather than grabbing it and running with it.</p><p>And, as The Jordan Legacy has highlighted in its response to the NSPS 2023–2028, and in our report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’, and in our Suicide Prevention Act petition package for measures to minimise suicides, a true cross-government strategy needs to come out of a cross-government National Suicide Prevention Office (NSPO) — with teeth — not out of one government department, especially not DHSC, given the historic problem of suicide prevention being seen as ‘a (mental) health issue’.</p><p>And there’s The Priority Trap once again in that text “<em>to bring everybody together around common priorities</em>”. Far from helping us in getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend (towards zero), this could harm.</p><p>Yes, bring people together, link people together, join the dots, share experiences, share what works, innovate together, learn from differences in local circumstances, have better co-ordinated &amp; integrated approaches, find ways to work in collaborative partnership in a new form of system, which we’ve framed ‘Everyone is a priority for someone’…but not just coming together ‘around common priorities’. That could cause harm!</p><p>The Executive summary continues below with further featuring of the £10 million DHSC VCSE Suicide Prevention Grant Fund. Such funds are welcome, especially if they can be used for innovative ways of getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, and The Jordan Legacy put in a submission for this very purpose — to demonstrate our Zero Suicide Society Transformation approach — but DHSC said ‘no’!</p><p>Is this pot to fund innovation and breakthrough, or just more of the same?</p><p>It says here “<em>The Fund launched in August 2023 and will support non-profit organisations to meet the increased demand seen in recent years through a range of diverse and innovative activity that can prevent suicides, both at a national and community level</em>”.</p><p>So it does have the word ‘innovative’ in there. However, having read all of the detailed information as we completed the application, the emphasis is on funding operational activity (not capital investment) for existing services (not new services), so funding what is already being delivered.</p><p>There’s certainly opportunity to allocate resources to services, activities, projects or initiatives that are trying to innovate or ‘do something different’ to get the suicide numbers down and which can build the capacity of the system to be better at reducing the numbers, down towards zero.</p><p>But it looks like it might be primarily assisting with some prop-up funding for many existing services. And a one-off grant “<em>to meet the increased demand seen in recent years</em>” is problematic of course. Is it assuming that this ‘increased demand’ is a temporary blip and will fall away, so continuing funding will not be needed? That would be a dangerous assumption!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v1Ux13Xth-ltg3tTi6T0pg.png" /></figure><p>Also think carefully about that amount — £10 million.</p><p>In the bigger picture of suicide prevention — and the mental health crisis we’re facing — it’s a drop in the ocean.</p><p>The economic cost of each suicide death in England — taking into account police costs, coroners’ costs, bereavement counselling, the loss of an economically productive individual, the ongoing adverse impacts on those close to the person who’s died, etc — is estimated at £1.67 million.</p><p><a href="https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201617/cmselect/cmhealth/300/30005.htm">https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201617/cmselect/cmhealth/300/30005.htm</a></p><p>We should evaluate all these government announcements and programmes — and there are far more announcements than programmes! — against this economic cost as well as the clear human cost, including the fact that for every suicide death, an average of 135 people are adversely impacted, according to both Cerel’s research in the US and the Suicide Bereavement UK study (based on a sample of more than 7,000).</p><p>So that’s 5,000+ x 135 = 675,000+ people newly impacted each year, and compounded year-on-year.</p><p>The 5,275 suicide deaths registered in England in 2022 have caused immediate and enduring pain and suffering for 712,125 people, and cost the economy £8.8 billion — and, across the UK, it’s more than £10 billion.</p><p>So let’s keep £10 million for a Suicide Prevention Grant Fund in perspective! And also the £57 million being invested in the NHS Long Term Plan.</p><p>It’s good but it’s clearly not enough, and not enough in two ways. It’s not enough to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend (towards zero). And it’s not enough given the £8–10 billion cost pa from 5–6,000+ preventable deaths each year, which highlights there’s a strong ‘business case’ for much greater investment in suicide prevention.</p><p>Part of our <strong>Push</strong> change dynamic, part of our open expression of dissatisfaction with the status quo, must be highlighting this business case, this financial case, as well as the human and moral case, and saying this is simply not good enough…not accepting ‘we have limited resources’.</p><p><strong>NSPS Ambition and Vision — or Lack of Ambition and Lack of Vision!</strong></p><p>The next section of the document sets out the ‘ambitions’ and ‘vision’ for the NSPS 2023–2028— or does it?</p><p>Without a target for reducing the number of suicides in the next 5 years, and without signs of high ambition, and without the language of desperately wanting to get the suicide numbers down from the unacceptably high level they’ve been at for the past 15 years, it’s questionable if ‘ambition’ is the right word to use here. But let’s be literally accurate and say it sets out the low ambitions of the NSPS.</p><p>Does it set out a ‘vision’? Not in the sense of a clear picture of what our ‘finishing line’ looks like in 5 (or more) years’ time? Certainly not in terms of a compelling vision which can create the <strong>Pull</strong> change dynamic we need. It’s more a set of principles by which we could travel over the next 5 years.</p><p>And does this Strategy set out “<em>the steps we will collectively need to take to achieve them (ambitions and vision)?</em>” Not really, but maybe the more detailed action plans flowing from the Strategy will achieve that?</p><p>The principles set out (below) are largely ok. For example: suicide prevention does need to be a collective effort; and mental health should be as important as physical health; early intervention is vital; and “<em>nobody should be left out of suicide prevention efforts</em>”.</p><p>But the DNA of these National Strategies means they are fundamentally competitions for priorities with ‘winners and losers’ so many people do actually ‘lose out’!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*I51IPMGj2bNwFB8n3TrKpA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Lived Experience Involvement — and the Democracy of Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>The “<em>voices, perspectives and insights of people with personal experience</em>” (see below) should most definitely “<em>inform the planning, design and decisions at all levels of suicide prevention activity</em>”.</p><p>This is the foundation stone for The Jordan Legacy’s Zero Suicide Society Transformation Model, and it should be front and centre for any national strategies and plans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tWT5_9Z-XmkeWmnGoVKKDQ.png" /></figure><p>There’ve been improvements in this regard since 2012, although that’s not hard when there were just a handful of people with lived experience having input into that first published National Strategy in 2012 (some of those involved back then said “<em>there were basically 3 people with lived experience advising, and their testimony was very powerful, but it was just 3 people</em>”)…</p><p>…and the NSPS 2023–2028 definitely had more ‘Lived Experience Involvement’ than ever before…but still way below the wide and deep involvement we need.</p><p>We must guard against ‘satisficing’ or complacency. We mustn’t have low ambition in terms of Lived Experience Involvement, just as we mustn’t have low ambition in the Strategy as a whole.</p><p>Inevitably, some of ‘the privileged few’ who did have direct input into the NSPS 2023–2028 have praised the Strategy and praised the level of Lived Experience Involvement in its development, and praised the ‘ambitions’ for future Lived Experience Involvement.</p><p>This illustrates once again the crucial importance of wide and deep engagement to get the benefit of Involvement = Commitment, and why we must strive much harder and higher on Lived Experience Involvement.</p><p>We want many more people appropriately and effectively involved in shaping, and then implementing, strategies and plans, so more people feel involved, feel part of the process; so more people and organisations are committed to delivering on the aims, ambitions, goals and actions.</p><p>The very positive comments from some of those who were involved in the latest NSPS about the degree of Lived Experience Involvement suggest a degree of ‘capture’ as the privileged few involved this time have (subconsciously?) set low expectations and/or lowered their expectations.</p><p>As I highlighted earlier, Steve Phillip and I at The Jordan Legacy were formally invited to just a single online forum to have some input into the NSPS, on targets and measurement, and even on this one topic where we were asked for input, I’d say we weren’t really listened to. We were listened to by Jacqui Morrissey who hosted this NSPA forum but, ultimately, not listened to by the National SP Advisory Group, based on its decisions.</p><p>In our own networks — The Jordan Legacy’s networks, plus the personal networks of Steve and myself, and via those we closely collaborate with — we have around 600 people with lived or living experiences of suicide and, when we asked who’d been directly involved in shaping this new NSPS 2023–2028, there were 4. That’s 4 out of 600. That’s fewer than 1%!</p><p>Clearly, the NSPS process is still just scratching the surface on this key success factor for getting the suicide numbers down.</p><p>And let me make it crystal clear, I believe that we’re all just scratching the surface on Lived Experience Involvement.</p><p>I believe that myself and Steve and The Jordan Legacy are just scratching the surface because there are millions of people in our society with lived or living experiences of suicide, and thousands who are active in some way, so we must involve much wider and deeper than we are now.</p><p>We must avoid having the unhealthy situation where a small number of ‘lived experience voices’ — that includes us! — are being heard loudly and often whilst ‘the silent majority’ are not heard at all.</p><p>If we have a platform, we should try to use it to give others a platform.</p><p>If we are one of ‘the privileged few’ selected to have ‘a seat at the table’, we have a responsibility to find ways to involve others, not just bask in the glow of having a seat at the table or just focus on expressing our views.</p><p>We must avoid some ‘narratives’ being heard again and again, especially where these are neat ‘media friendly’ stories that fuel the soundbite culture and structure of our media, and yet other ‘stories’ not being told at all, especially where they are messy, multi-faceted, complicated, complex, including ‘mental health issues’ or suicide crises that had little or nothing to do with ‘mental health issues’ in many cases.</p><p>Just as in any other walk of life, we need to see this as a democracy and avoid any one person or small group of people having too much power and influence — whether that’s a small minority involved in an Advisory Group or a group or person directly advising government, or just being prominent in the media and on the speaking circuit.</p><p>It’s not healthy for the suicide prevention field to be such a hierarchy.</p><p>Quite rightly, people with lived or living experiences of suicide will be asked to ‘tell their story’ and they should grab every opportunity to do so, and do exactly that — tell ‘their’ story. Everyone has a unique ‘story’, and a unique ‘journey’, and no-one can have someone else’s experience.</p><p>We can only draw from our own experience, and we should be conscious of how our own experience shapes what we do and what we say, as well as — at a higher level of consciousness — what we’re not saying.</p><p>Of course, when we’re giving a talk or at a meeting with DHSC or sitting on an Advisory Group or appearing on the ‘red sofa’, we can talk about the ‘stories’ we’ve heard from others, we can summarise patterns and trends (as well as differences), we can draw from research and engagement exercises, we can share some collective experiences…but we’re still essentially talking from our own experience or, to put it another way, we are ‘experts in our own experience’.</p><p>In a democracy, we must always take care about representation, including self-representation, representing others, and being represented by others.</p><p>In what is often disturbingly called ‘the suicide prevention sector’ — becoming a distinct, organised ‘sector’ has some advantages but brings with it plenty of problems too!— we often hear claims of ‘representing others’ or ‘being a representative’ for others, with meetings often beginning “<em>I’m here representing…</em>” followed by a particular demographic group or socio-economic category or community of interest or geographical area.</p><p>On many occasions, this person has no democratic legitimacy at all, no right to speak on behalf of others. In reality, they’re speaking for themselves, and we should all be honest about this, starting with being honest with ourselves, as well as being entirely comfortable about this.</p><p>We need to provide more opportunities for more people with more diverse experiences to tell their ‘own story’, and shape suicide prevention strategies and plans, and delivery programmes, plus reviews and evaluation.</p><p>A few people will have the democratic legitimacy to speak on behalf of others, eg a democratically elected representative, or Chair/CEO of a member organisation with transparently accountable processes, or a universally recognised community leader with a track record of listening widely and deeply to their community members before speaking on their behalf, or a formal nominated proxy, eg a carer speaking on behalf of the person they care for.</p><p>But, talking of ‘care’, we must all take care on this point of ‘representation’, and spend more time giving a platform to others rather than using our platform and claiming to represent others.</p><p>It’s been very healthy to have recent meetings with the National Suicide Prevention Alliance (NSPA) and to both acknowledge that we need to go much wider and deeper than currently to have appropriate and effective Lived Experience Involvement. That even where we mark our report card as ‘good’ or ‘better than in the past’ or ‘better than for any previous National Strategy’, this has to be followed by “<em>but can and must do much better</em>”.</p><p>And, hopefully, those who’ve enthused about this new National Strategy’s ‘commitment to Lived Experience Involvement’ will be coming from the perspective that we need to raise the bar much higher, not have ‘more of the same’ or more low expectation satisficing because we’ve had a bit of involvement for a (still) privileged few and had our tummies tickled!</p><p>Because of my passion for and vast experience in ‘the democracy field’ over the past 40 years, I’ve offered to work with NSPA and others in producing a “<em>deliberative and participative democracy map for the suicide prevention landscape</em>” — which can also include ‘representation democracy’ and ‘direct democracy’ where relevant — and drafting a strategy for how we can widen and deepen Lived Experience Involvement with the highest of aspirations.</p><p>Now back to the detail of the National Strategy document…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tWT5_9Z-XmkeWmnGoVKKDQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Collaboration not Competition, Innovation not Inertia!</strong></p><p>The NSPS rightly highlights the importance of collaboration and there’s massive scope to improve collaboration as well as removing the barriers to collaboration and tackling destructive competition in the field of suicide prevention. Ironically, some organisations that regularly call for greater collaboration are very selective in who they collaborate with!</p><p>That final bullet point above also needs carefully unpicking.</p><p>Many might just read it and agree — yes, high quality evidence is important, as is being responsive to trends and emerging evidence, as is harnessing digital technology and data advancements for more effective, earlier interventions and better support.</p><p>But there are a few issues here.</p><p>Sometimes there’s too much focus on having lots of ‘evidence’, and new ideas are stifled.</p><p>To ‘do something different’ — and we must do some things different to get the trend line from a flat line to a down line! — we need to back new ideas, especially where people with lived experience are telling us what might help prevent suicides, and then start to build new evidence bases.</p><p>The traditional response from the academics and policymakers who’ve dominated suicide prevention strategy in the past has been to knock back any ideas that don’t yet have a ‘strong evidence base’ and to stifle new ideas by saying, often disingenuously, “<em>what are the ethics of doing this?</em>”.</p><p>Effective suicide prevention needs a culture that embraces new ideas; and, if the idea is one that sounds like it might save lives, we should all be asking “<em>what are the ethics of NOT doing this?</em>”.</p><p>Advances in ‘Tech for Good’ and ‘Digital Life Saving’ have suffered in particular, held back by traditionalists saying ‘where’s the evidence base?’ and ‘what are the ethics of doing this?’ and also by fuelling narratives like ‘technology isn’t the answer, people need human connection’, ‘people who are suffering don’t just want an app’ and ‘AI isn’t the answer to everything’!</p><p>These narratives are unhelpful, at times destructive, and they’re stopping us from saving lives.</p><p>These narratives are often fuelled by people who are not that familiar with the latest developments in ‘Digital Life Saving’, or digital communications technology generally, and who perhaps even feel threatened by it.</p><p>Those actually working in the ‘Tech for Good’ and ‘Digital Life Saving’ fields appreciate more than anyone that we need integrated digital-human solutions, eg with the technology identifying someone who needs human support — at crisis and/or early intervention stage — and directing those who need help to the sources, including human support, that they need.</p><p>Those developing ‘Tech for Good’ services around the known needs of people generally and particular sub-groups or segments of the in-need population know that ‘it isn’t just about an app’.</p><p>The background of these ‘app developers’ is increasingly in ‘user experience design’ and developing customer-focused services so when they apply their skills and experience, often driven by a personal suicide loss or personal mental health crisis, they’re totally focused on developing a very human, person-centred tool with digital-human integration and synergy, with the technology being very much a means to the ends, not an end in itself, although valuable human-centred technology developments which are groundbreaking technologically is clearly a motivator too.</p><p>When a leading adviser to government and ‘the suicide prevention sector’ recently ended his annual summing up with the line “<em>AI isn’t the answer to everything</em>”, I cringed because it’s such a silly thing to say as well as continuing to fuel these unhelpful, potentially harmful, narratives.</p><p>Of course ‘AI isn’t THE answer to everything’ just as ‘technology isn’t THE answer to everything’ but it is AN answer, it’s one of the tools we have in our suicide prevention toolkit, and we should be embracing this opportunity to develop new tools and new applications of established tools by utilising this new Tech for Good.</p><p>Once we engage with those working in Digital Life Saving &amp; Tech For Good, we find, for example, there’s a useful distinction between AI as Artificial Intelligence and AI as Augmented Intelligence, with many augmented intelligence data solutions being brilliant extensions of what the suicide prevention traditionalists do as well as completely new in some cases, eg studying patterns in financial data to identify people at risk of suicide, or in danger right now, so we can get them instant, targeted support.</p><p>In my meetings with the Digital Life Saving &amp; Tech For Good communities, I find a much more balanced perspective between tackling the (potential) harms of the online world and developing the (potential) helps of the online world.</p><p>And one of the ‘private sector’ developers we’re currently working with has developed systems to protect ‘whistleblowers’ — or ‘ethical champions’ as I prefer to call them. The ‘public sector’ often treats the ‘private sector’ with suspicion, in what is just prejudice or a sweeping generalisation, and sees itself as the guardian of ethics and protector against ‘online harm’. In this case, a ‘private sector’ solution is helping those experiencing harm in the private sector and those experiencing harm in the public sector!</p><p>Also, when the suicide prevention traditionalists talk about the online world, it’s usually heavily weighted to talking about ‘online harms’ and advocating for ‘more research into the impacts of online harms’ and ‘measures to tackle online harms’. In this negative culture, it can be hard to get the positive ‘help’ perspective on the agenda.</p><p>It reminds me of Martin Seligman, the author of the bestselling books Learned Optimism and Authentic Happiness, having his big light bulb moment when someone sitting next to him on a plane said “<em>so you’ve spent 30 years studying what makes people unhappy and depressed, do you ever study what makes people happy?”. </em>The Positive Psychology movement was born!</p><p><strong>Aims, Objectives, Goals…Action!</strong></p><p>The final part of the Introduction section of the National Strategy document concludes with ‘Aims’.</p><p>Once again, this includes the “<em>overall ambitions</em>” which don’t look at all ambitious, and with no quantifiable targets for reductions in suicides.</p><p>The National Strategy may feel positive and hopeful to the small number involved in drafting it, because they may have more faith in the people and institutions behind it but, for the rest of us, the whole document seems to require a ‘leap of faith’ — at a time when we have little faith in government.</p><p>And aims like “<em>continue to improve support for…</em>” are so non-specific and non-committal, they provide little or no insight or confidence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*seDYqlTnQuxKoy99gzYTzA.png" /></figure><p>The document also occasionally includes positively-worded text such as “<em>Suicides are not inevitable and collectively we should, and will, aim to prevent every suicide we can</em>” and “<em>…it is imperative that government departments and other organisations responsible for delivering suicide prevention activity are accountable for the delivery of these actions…</em>”…</p><p>…but the rest of the document doesn’t give any convincing indication that these are anything more than words in a PR-oriented document.</p><p>The “<em>summary of actions, setting out the basis for an implementation plan</em>” reads like a long wish list without the resources to deliver.</p><p>Also, the prevailing philosophy from all those involved is ‘limited resources, so must set priorities’ rather than ‘must do all we can to get these numbers down (towards zero)’.</p><p>The final paragraph above, and comments we’ve heard from people who are involved with the Advisory Group, is that ‘in many respects, the process is really just starting now, in getting into action plans and delivery plans’.</p><p>So there we were on 11 September 2023 thinking ‘we finally have a new National Strategy after a 12 months’ delay’ but we’re hearing at the end of November/beginning of December that “<em>we’re really just starting now</em>”!</p><p>Of course, some action plans are continuations of previous plans and don’t necessarily need major work or recasting but, as there’s been no reduction in suicide numbers for 15 years and we need to ‘do something different’, it sounds like there might still be a lot of preparation needed to even get to the new start line for the approach that will deliver reductions at scale.</p><p><strong>The Priority Trap plus Other Biases and Barriers to Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>As I comment from here, there’s a danger of people thinking ‘he’s just repeating himself now’ although, in my defence, the document does itself have some of the same points in ‘the main body’ and in the Executive summary and, in a few cases, in the Forewords too…</p><p>…and, just as the authors of the National Strategy probably felt these points needed repeating and emphasising, I feel that my criticism of some of these points also needs repeating and emphasising!</p><p>If you feel you’ve seen enough evidence of the National Strategy’s low ambition, unhelpful language and framing, and potential for harm as well as help, and all the flaws in the National Strategy process, you might want to skip to the final section, and my call-to-action at the end.</p><p>If you want to know more of the finer details and ‘hidden traps’ in the National Strategy/National Strategy process — potentially sub-conscious ‘hidden traps’ for even some of those involved in shaping it and drafting it! — please read on.</p><p>I’ve already highlighted ‘The Priority Trap’ with the entire National Strategy process being like a huge competition for priorities, with ‘winners and losers’, with privileged ‘winners’ and desperately sad that there are so many ‘losers’ when we’re talking about suicide prevention here, literally life or death decisions being made.</p><p>As we say in our Zero Suicide Society Transformation Model, and in The Jordan Legacy’s response to the NSPS for England, 2023–2028, we need a collaborative, co-ordinated approach to suicide prevention around the principle of ‘Everyone must be a priority for someone’.</p><p>Those of us committed to a truly compassionate as well as ambitious transformation programme to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, know that we simply cannot have ‘losers’.</p><p>The Government, and those conspiring with them, can choose to have ‘winners &amp; losers’ but that just emphasises that the Government is just one piece in the puzzle and its National Strategy is just one piece in the puzzle.</p><p>And this then emphasises why we must not simply roll over and say “<em>let’s just implement the National Strategy</em>” or “<em>let’s just align our priorities to the National Strategy’s priorities</em>”.</p><p>This would mean that as well as getting into bed with low ambition, failing your ‘local constituency’ and endorsing the approach of ‘pushing air around in the balloon while the overall numbers of suicides don’t come down’, you’d be conspiring in a process of systemic discrimination, which I’ll say more on below.</p><p>Many people will probably read the first paragraph in the section on ‘Priority areas for action’ (below) and think it sounds reasonable.</p><p>After all, setting priorities and determining actions based on ‘evidence’ and ‘data’ is what most people — in government and elsewhere — do as generally accepted good practice for generations, along with “<em>engagement with people with expertise</em>” in the subject and then, a more recent development in the field of suicide prevention, engaging with and involving “<em>people with personal experience</em>”, what we usually now refer to as ‘lived experience’ along with what are often referred to as ‘other key stakeholders’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-y_NdSf0hxuG73EUbiL66Q.png" /></figure><p>However, what this means in practice is that there are a series of systemic biases designed in, consciously or subconsciously.</p><p>First, there’s the bias towards whatever ‘evidence’ or ‘data’ exists, and a bias against any issue or group or potential solution where there’s currently little or no ‘data’ or ‘evidence’.</p><p>This happens frequently. Where there’s an established data set showing a high suicide rate among Group X, attention focuses on Group X. Where it’s suspected that Group Y has a high suicide rate, but there’s no hard data on this yet, attention continues to focus on Group X, not Group Y. As long as the data gap remains, the discrimination against Group Y continues.</p><p>Second, a view is taken, consciously or subconsciously, on what determines ‘expertise’ in suicide prevention, ie who is an ‘expert’ and what exactly we mean by an ‘expert’ in suicide prevention?</p><p>Historically, it’s tended to be a small group of academics, clinicians and policymakers who’ve largely come from within the health system. With many, if not most, of the academics also having a background largely in the health system, the systemic bias to health is well-embedded, including the ‘Department of Health’ overseeing suicide prevention strategy, despite us knowing suicide is not just a (mental) health issue.</p><p>The bias can be even worse where the academics, clinicians and policymakers involved not only share largely a health background, but more narrowly a mental health background and sometimes even more narrowly a professional psychiatric background.</p><p>And, traditionally, the academics involved in these national strategies and plans have a background in analysis of quantitative data. Their ‘expertise’ has been built up on years and years of analysing large data sets of historic suicide statistics and analysing large population sets to identify ‘patterns in the data’ and identify ‘risk groups’ and recommend policy solutions.</p><p>Of course, we have all sorts of other ‘experts’ in non-health fields, in other forms of data analysis, in predictive modelling, including the latest AI based models, in real-time response to real-time data, in qualitative research, in behavioural research, in transformational change, etc.</p><p>There are many other types of ’experts’ who could help us determine how we can get the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, drawing from their diverse disciplines, including getting the benefit of ‘fresh eyes’ on a problem that clearly needs different approaches because the approaches we’ve been taking for the past 15 years haven’t been getting the numbers of suicides down.</p><p>The third source of potential bias and discrimination, of course, is the selection of “<em>people with personal experience, researchers, and those involved in the planning and delivery of services</em>”, including who gets to be a member of the National Suicide Prevention Strategy Advisory Group (NSPSAG).</p><p>As I’ve said in my talks and webinars many times, the ‘system’ operating here is based on the fundamental principle of there being ‘a table’ and a select group of people ‘getting a seat at the table’ with a competition, overt and covert, to gain power by getting ‘a seat at the table’…</p><p>…but the table is never going to be big enough to have diverse perspectives; many of those at the table are ‘representing’ a particular viewpoint, constituency or issue so are effectively like a ‘lobby group’; there are many people and organisations without a ‘seat at the table’…</p><p>…and maybe the solution is not to have ‘a table’ to stop people trying to fight for one of the limited number of seats there?!</p><p>Through my analysis and commentary around the NSPS below, I’ll cover — with specific examples from the NSPS document— the many other systemic biases and discriminatory practices that have been designed-in to this process, whether deliberate or a case of unwitting design flaws or unintended consequences; and the many pitfalls in the NSPS process.</p><p>First, let’s study some content of significance in this section:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*I_T5AfFaGrZY1u7_3r-kEg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Wider Community Engagement and Public Consultation</strong></p><p>There’s a reference here to “<em>The responses to our engagement exercises, such as the mental health call for evidence, roundtable discussions, and many ongoing discussions with experts…</em>”.</p><p>There’s such a low degree of transparency and accountability in this process that the overwhelming majority of those who work in suicide prevention and/or have lived experience and take an interest, never mind the population as a whole, have no idea who these ‘experts’ are who’s shaping policy, apart from the very visible few like Professor Appleby, or who’s involved in these “<em>roundtable discussions</em>” or who sits on the Advisory Group — a question regularly asked in online forums and on social media but I’ve never seen it answered, and it should be published somewhere — or who’s been engaged by whom.</p><p>As I mentioned earlier, of around 600 people with lived experience of suicide in our networks, we found 4 who had been directly engaged in the National Strategy process; and the only invite Steve Phillip and I had to be directly involved was the one-off NSPA online forum on “<em>targets and measurement</em>” which was then largely ignored I’d say.</p><p>And then there’s the issue of public engagement or public consultation dedicated to suicide prevention. There was nothing at all in England, in stark contrast to the excellent model rolled out in Scotland.</p><p>Those responsible for the National Strategy for England have tried to defend their position by saying, and continuing to say, ‘but we had the Mental Health Plan consultation and we got lots of comments through it about suicide prevention’; and the National Strategy document refers to “<em>…our engagement exercises, such as the mental health call for evidence…</em>”.</p><p>This is probably the best example of the huge gap in thinking and expectations in what is good practice in public engagement around suicide prevention; around the adequacy of what was put in place in England; and around an appropriate culture &amp; structure for ‘engagement &amp; involvement’.</p><p>The public consultation on the 10-year Mental Health Plan was a public consultation by the ‘Health Department’ about mental health.</p><p>There was no dedicated, cross-departmental, public consultation focused on suicide prevention which, as we all know is not just a mental health issue — and such engagement should be co-ordinated by someone other than the ‘Health Department’ to avoid that systemic bias.</p><p>The public consultation around the Mental Health Plan was structured around 6 questions the public were asked to respond to. None of these 6 questions was explicitly about suicide or suicide prevention.</p><p>The final question was focused on crisis services and support, so implicitly suggested that we might be talking about suicide and suicide prevention, but still didn’t explicitly mention suicide or suicide prevention here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vHoxtNzky-uD2j8DghFqKg.png" /></figure><p>And nowhere else in the briefing around these 6 key questions, these 6 key chapters in the discussion document, was it explicitly asking for views on suicide prevention, just a passing reference to the Mental Health Plan consultation also being an opportunity to input into the Suicide Prevention Strategy with, at that time, no timetable set out for the new National Suicide Prevention Strategy and no indication of how views expressed might influence the Suicide Prevention Strategy.</p><p>Note how in the discussion paper briefing (above), it also indicates who DHSC were wanting to hear from. Once again, no explicit mention of suicide or suicide prevention.</p><p>It was like reading a corporate wellbeing strategy for a multinational corporation that dances around the subject of suicide with lots of references to wellbeing, mental health, mental health conditions…extending as far as referring to mental ill-health…but no explicit mention of suicide or suicide prevention, for fear of frightening the horses!</p><p>Not great leadership by example is it?!</p><p>Of course, many people used this only available opportunity to input their experiences and ideas around suicide prevention.</p><p>Those in the ‘inner circle’ like Professor Appleby, Tweeted that this was an opportunity to shape the new Suicide Prevention Strategy, but the fact that it wasn’t structured explicitly around suicide prevention — it wasn’t structured appropriately to get relevant, high quality input directly into a Suicide Prevention Strategy — meant it was not an effective engagement process, just a way of generating ad hoc comments. Useful comments in many cases but ad hoc and not a good practice engagement process.</p><p>In Scotland, there was a two-stage process with both stages dedicated to the Suicide Prevention Strategy specifically, which from the outset had been a collaborative initiative between the Scottish Government, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (COSLA), a multi-agency steering group, and a lived experience advisory group.</p><p>Stage One was a ‘blank sheet of paper’ exercise to hear evidence, experience, and ideas for what should be in the Suicide Prevention Strategy. Stage Two was a consultation around a draft Strategy which was published for comment. Nothing like this in England.</p><p>And then, in England, we had the announcement there would not now be a 10 Year Mental Health Plan but, instead, mental health was being merged into a broader Major Conditions Strategy, with the previous engagement responses for the Mental Health Plan ‘being taken into consideration in the shaping of the Major Conditions Strategy’ with a new “<em>call for evidence to inform the Major Conditions Strategy</em>” issued on 17 May 2023.</p><p>So expecting people who’d previously commented on the Mental Health Plan, thinking there was going to be a separate Mental Health Plan, to now comment on a new Major Conditions Strategy, and anyone wanting to focus specifically on suicide prevention effectively seeing their topic of focus being swamped by other huge issues like cancer and dementia.</p><p>And still nothing explicitly on suicide prevention at this stage, with nothing emerging until the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England was published on 11 September.</p><p>The document that was released on 11 September could easily have been published as a ‘draft Strategy’ inviting comments and suggestions. Then everyone would have had the opportunity to input, shape the National Strategy, and feel more a sense of ‘ownership’ of it perhaps.</p><p>I suspect that the Government — for which we might read DHSC and its Advisory Group — didn’t do this for the following reasons.</p><p>Firstly, it might not even have thought of it because it doesn’t have stakeholder engagement and lived experience involvement at its core. For some, this would be uppermost in their mind.</p><p>Secondly, it might have thought about it, and thought ‘we don’t have the resources to do this’ but that’s actually the Government saying ‘we’re not going to give suicide prevention a priority’ and allocating the necessary resources to do the right thing.</p><p>Thirdly, the ‘scarcity mindset’ of those involved in this National Strategy process, operating within a mental model that’s focused on setting priorities, is likely to have made them think ‘if we open this up to public consultation, we’ll get everyone arguing their case for being a priority and it’ll be a high profile bun fight’. Indeed, I’ve actually heard at least one civil servant say this out loud.</p><p>Let’s again deconstruct this language, this thinking, and let’s think of alternative perspectives and narratives.</p><p>What the public consultation process around a draft Strategy could have given us is greater transparency, more accountability, a more democratic process, a more inclusive process — with opportunities for the Government, DHSC, the Advisory Group, to hear more and more diverse perspectives, gather more evidence, hear the case for different approaches or a different focus, hear about ‘emerging evidence’, listen to new ideas, etc.</p><p>And, to repeat, in our Zero Suicide Society model, within the co-ordinated, collaborative ‘everyone must be a priority for someone’ approach, we’re not just seeking to allocate scarce resources to ‘priority groups’.</p><p>So, in our mental model, we’re entirely comfortable with an open public consultation around a draft National Suicide Prevention Strategy, inviting challenge. The only reason ‘the establishment’ isn’t comfortable with such an approach is because it’s boxed itself in with its own thinking.</p><p><strong>Priority Areas for Action — and the Dangers of the Prioritisation Model</strong></p><p>Now, back to the document, back to ‘their world’, and ‘priorities for action’.</p><p>It’s easy to read each of the 8 points below and agree and say these are all important and these might all get the suicide numbers down but there are many flaws that we should at least be conscious of; and it’s very hard to argue these are the most important 8 that we should give priority attention to and allocate ‘scarce resources to’.</p><p>Why these 8 and not another 8?</p><p>And note the ‘get out clause’ in inclusion of the word ‘include’.</p><p>This ‘priority’ list is not an inclusive list, which brings into question why call it a priority list? Of course, if they lengthened it to make it more inclusive, so it got to 15 points or 20 items or 25 actions…well it ceases to be a list of ‘priorities’ doesn’t it?</p><p>It’s more evidence of being stuck in the ‘priority mindset’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TaOefJIreUlj-pbv2yg7hg.png" /></figure><p>As this dissertation I’m writing is a critique of the National Strategy, let’s go through each of these with a ‘critical thinking’ head on.</p><p>Prioritising data and evidence can lead to reductions in the suicide numbers but it can also potentially lead to a bias against the kinds of new ideas that can provide breakthroughs in suicide prevention.</p><p>Focusing on ‘priority groups’ can mean neglecting other groups, effectively discriminating against other groups, possibly even harming other groups.</p><p>Just as we’ve identified harm in categorising patients in hospitals as ‘high risk’ and ‘low risk’ — with those categorised as ‘high risk’ getting the support they need and those categorised as ‘low risk’ then being more likely to end their lives because we’ve categorised them as ‘low risk’ !— having ‘high risk’ groups, and therefore ‘low risk’ groups, in a National Strategy is potentially harmful for those who are categorised as ‘low risk’.</p><p>“<em>Addressing common risk factors linked to suicide at a population level to provide early intervention and tailored support</em>” looks good on first reading but mainly because this is the accepted wisdom that has guided policy for 50 years. However, in terms of reducing suicide numbers, this approach stopped working 15 years ago — see our ‘flat line chart’. The world has moved on but policymakers haven’t moved on with it.</p><p>It’s the same mindset that applied to commercial marketing for 50 years and gave us the great TV advertising campaigns in the 1970s and 1980s. It’s the same mindset that was applied in many fields, from market research to epidemiology. But, in the digital age, commercial marketers don’t just look at the population level, identify groups or market segments, and then devise strategies and campaigns for these groups or segments, they target individuals who are more likely to buy the product or use the service.</p><p>In suicide prevention, we can identify a ‘population group’ or ‘target audience’ and devise strategies or group-based communications — and, in some cases, this might work, although it hasn’t ‘worked’ for 15 years in terms of bringing the national suicide numbers down — but, to save lives, to get the suicide numbers down, towards zero, we need to more effectively communicate with ‘individuals in danger’ not just ‘groups at risk’.</p><p>Of course, we can shape a broad policy response for a broad group, but it needs more targeting, including to the individual level.</p><p>We know that a very high ‘risk group’ is middle-aged men but people don’t end their life because they’re a middle-aged man. We know that middle-aged men are more likely to have certain ‘high risk experiences’ such as divorce or redundancy, so we can devise strategies and campaigns that focus on helping people who are experiencing divorce or redundancy, and we should have this kind of ‘behavioural’ or ‘experiential’ targeting, as the most effective commercial marketers do.</p><p>But then we still need to focus on the individual middle-aged man who’s experiencing divorce or redundancy right now. Our strategies and systems should be set up to make sure we’re communicating with this ‘active target group’ and the individuals within this group.</p><p>Our success in saving lives and getting the numbers of suicides down, towards zero, will be partly a result of our ability to have the right strategies, policies, plans and generic practices for all middle-aged men having these experiences — as well as any more upstream prevention that’s possible, eg avoiding destructive redundancies — but it will also very much depend on our ability to identify, communicate with, and support individuals in danger because they’re experiencing divorce or redundancy, or whatever the primary experience is, in ‘real time’.</p><p>“<em>Tailored support</em>” can be structured at a group level, but must be delivered at an individual level — something I learned from working in, for example, the funerals industry in Australia where you can have ‘preactive’ plans and packages for a range of types of funeral, ready to activate when there’s a death and ‘you get the call’, but then each funeral, within each ‘package’ must be completely tailored to the individual ‘customer’.</p><p>On the 4th point around online safety, I’d agree that ‘tech for bad’ and reducing online harm is something we need to tackle but we also need to invest much much more in the field of ‘Tech for Good’ and ‘Digital Life Saving’ to harness the latest technology in order to save lives.</p><p>The ‘suicide prevention sector’ is generally not good at embracing technological development, sometimes resistant to it, and with quite a few prominent Luddites who are quick to destroy even the possibility of technological enhancements with their (conscious or sub-conscious) unhelpful, even harmful, comments like “<em>technology isn’t the answer</em>” and “<em>people need human support not an app or machine learning</em>”.</p><p>I’m the first to agree that “<em>technology isn’t THE answer</em>” but it’s AN answer.</p><p>I also agree that ‘people need human support’. These apps and machine learning and augmented intelligence solutions to suicide prevention are often designed to more quickly and effectively identify people who are a suicide risk or in suicide danger, then get them the appropriate human support they need as quickly and effectively as possible.</p><p>It’s not a war between humans and machines. It’s not a war between public services &amp; charities focused on compassionate human support and private companies focused on their technical gizmos and making money.</p><p>These are destructive, prejudiced, outdated stereotypes. We need an outbreak of peace; and a spirit of collaboration among all those — and there are many — with a shared sense of mission around getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vW_od1cX5G9AInfbIgb53Q.png" /></figure><p>Yes, of course, we need to provide more and better crisis support, and we need to do much more to avoid people getting to crisis point.</p><p>Yes, of course, we need to reduce access to the means of suicide, and to reduce access to lethal means, and — again — be much better at upstream suicide prevention to minimise the number of people getting as far as a suicide attempt and therefore needing us to restrict access to means.</p><p>In our Zero Suicide Society model, restricting access to means is within a broader category of ‘Designing Out Suicide’ or ‘designing in suicide prevention’. There’s so much more we can do here, including a full scale review of planning guidelines and the Building Regulations from a ‘suicide safer’ perspective. Past reviews of the Building Regs have focused on ‘safety’ from the perspective of trying to prevent accidents. We should take another look from the perspective of trying to prevent deliberate self-harm.</p><p>“<em>Providing effective bereavement support to those affected by suicide</em>” is another ‘no brainer’. We know how traumatic it can be to lose someone to suicide and there should be ‘wrap around care and support’ for those affected. And we’re getting better with this, but with much more scope to improve.</p><p>We also need to think more about those experiencing bereavement in all its forms, including all forms of traumatic loss, because it’s not just bereavement by suicide that has adverse impacts which lead to a heightened risk of suicide, eg men aged 85+ losing their wife who they’ve been married to for 50+ years.</p><p>Whether their wife has died by suicide, from cancer, or a heart attack or stroke, these men are a high suicide risk and should have the full ‘wrap around care and support’ package.</p><p>And, finally from the list of 8 ‘Priority Areas for Action’ is “<em>Making suicide everybody’s business</em>”. Again, I totally agree that everyone can help in suicide prevention and we need more people providing help, although — as outlined earlier — we need to be careful to use the right, most inclusive language, ie avoid the preachy, finger-wagging ‘suicide is everyone’s responsibility’ and the more-likely-to-get-pushback ‘suicide is everybody’s business’ and use more engaging language like:</p><blockquote>anyone can be affected by suicide, everyone can help prevent suicides</blockquote><p>This next paragraph is another example of the ‘good but could be much better…and could go much further’ nature of this low ambition Strategy.</p><p>‘Encouraging everyone to review their plans and approaches’ is not a set of words to provide confidence that appropriate and effective action will be taken. Neither is ‘continuing to promote cross-sector working and joint action’. It would be easy for anyone in our target audience here to ignore.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*N1Ae_PwZxi2PJGNPQ03IaA.png" /></figure><p>And why should “<em>everyone — including employers, local government, NHS and VCSE organisations…ensure alignment with this new strategy</em>”?!</p><p>All employers, councils, NHS Trusts, VCSE organisations, etc who are committed to minimising the number of suicides among their employees or the people they care for or the area they cover should be looking at what they need to do in their workplace, area, hospital, etc to minimise the number of suicides and look at this National Strategy to see if it could help them to achieve their goals, or have no benefit, or even potentially harm their suicide prevention efforts, eg if their ‘priority groups’ are not listed as ‘priority groups’ in the National Strategy…</p><p>…and then decide whether to align with the National Strategy or ignore it or publicly speak out against it where it’s preventing suicide prevention, as I’m doing here of course.</p><p><strong>Improving Data &amp; Evidence — and the Data &amp; Evidence Bias</strong></p><p>Clearly having better data to guide suicide prevention strategies, plans and actions is an ongoing challenge and so ‘always a priority’ for improvement.</p><p>We do need to think more though about the biases and discrimination within the National Strategy process and ‘establishment suicide prevention activity’ due to the focus, at times obsessive focus, on ‘data and evidence’.</p><p>I’d say the most important sentence in this next section is the final sentence “<em>Future work must continue to address evidence gaps to inform more effective actions</em>” because the National Strategy is a bit like a patchwork quilt that’s full of holes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VxMLfIDU4vkBU-V7rRgNVA.png" /></figure><p>To reiterate two points highlighted previously…</p><p>Some ‘priority groups’ are well organised, or ‘the system’ is well-organised on their behalf, and we have access to high quality, insightful data, or are being presented with high quality, insightful data and evidence; and these groups are being given priority — for action, for further research, for inclusion in policy development, for funding, etc — effectively discriminating against other groups where we don’t (yet) have the data and evidence or where these groups are not (yet) organised enough, or not (yet) effective enough in lobbying, to be considered a ‘priority for action’.</p><p>There’s a bias against anything new, against new ideas for reducing suicide, against new groups coming forward, against new technological development…because being new, by definition, there often isn’t (yet) any ‘data or evidence’.</p><p>Sometimes there is, eg when it’s a new suggested approach based on existing data and evidence but, even then, ‘the new’ is looked upon sceptically, especially by those who’ve been involved in these National Strategy processes for many years, because they’re often ‘blind spots’.</p><p>Sometimes it really is completely new, different, innovative, even breakthrough thinking where there really is no data or evidence yet. The response — and I’ve experienced this personally many times — is usually to “<em>go away and gather the data and evidence to support it</em>”.</p><p>A more helpful response would be “<em>how can we help you gather the data and evidence</em>”! After all, every established, evidence-based, data-supported approach had to start somewhere as a new idea or hypothesis to test.</p><p>The ‘suicide prevention establishment’ — and I use the term ‘establishment’ deliberately because of its culture &amp; structure — is quick to knock back new ideas, especially where they involve technological change, or anything they don’t fully understand or don’t feel they can control, with lines like “<em>Ah, but is this evidence-based?</em>” and “<em>Ah, but what about the ethics of doing this?</em>”.</p><p>We need a complete change of mindset, where new ideas for suicide prevention are welcomed and embraced, especially where they come from people with lived or living experiences of suicide, ie from the ground-up — always the biggest threat to any establishment! — and where any new suggestions, in good faith, for preventing suicides and reducing the number of suicides is responded to with this line instead:</p><blockquote>this idea/suggested approach/new use of technology for suicide prevention could save many lives, so what are the ethics of NOT doing it; why would we not enthusiastically embrace this proposal and run with it?</blockquote><p>The next section — screenshot below — continues with the systemic bias and discrimination of the National Strategy process, with “<em>particular groups</em>” highlighted as being ‘priority groups’ for improving data and evidence.</p><p>They’re all important of course but for every group highlighted and prioritised, there are others not highlighted and not prioritised and therefore discriminated against.</p><p>Here’s just two examples of ‘groups’ of people with heightened suicide risk who rarely, if ever, feature in these national strategies and plans.</p><p>Firstly, older people, eg men aged 75+ who take their own lives for various reasons, including losing their lifelong partner and declining physical health. There are plenty of gaps in the data and evidence for this group, but they tend not to feature.</p><p>Secondly, people losing their jobs. At least men aged 75+ in theory have organisations like Age UK who could gather data and evidence and advocate on their behalf — although I haven’t seen much evidence of this — but not ‘people losing their jobs’.</p><p>There isn’t an organisation for people losing their jobs. There isn’t an organised lobby group to put their case to the powers-that-be or to the suicide prevention establishment.</p><p>They aren’t really ‘a group’ at all, just individuals dotted around the country, across all ages and socio-cultural groups, who happen to have two things in common: they’ve lost their job and they’re at heightened risk of suicide.</p><p>These people are overlooked and discriminated against in the National Strategy process, and within our political system more widely.</p><p>They sometimes feature in local suicide prevention strategies because some parts of the country have high unemployment rates and local analysis of suicides has shown unemployment to be a significant factor.</p><p>And this is why much suicide prevention activity must be ‘from the ground up’ — and why some local suicide prevention partnerships or local organisations might not want to ‘align’ too closely with a National Strategy that doesn’t reflect local issues and drivers, and may even not include a local ‘priority group’ at all.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3ZbLDBJlpWkcO2sQiBNsAQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Real Time Suspected Suicide Surveillance (RTSSS)</strong></p><p>Thankfully, we finally have Real Time Suspected Suicide Surveillance (RTSSS) and local partnerships coming together around this data and the actions that need to flow from a better understanding of what’s driving suicides and what can be done to reduce, to minimise, the numbers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kpCa4oUpm_B5UEulw8vNRQ.png" /></figure><p>Many of us have campaigned for this for 10 years or more, and it’s been sad to watch ‘the suicide prevention establishment’ resisting it until the arrival of COVID19 and, more particularly, the Lockdowns, caused a shift of thinking and practice that’s now made this a reality.</p><p>There are a few theories about why RTSSS was resisted for so long.</p><p>Some say ‘we needed to get it right, get the right systems in place, get the data right’, etc — which is a common problem in suicide prevention, as in other fields. At worst, it’s the search for near perfection before acting, rather than acting and seeing how it works, or piloting to test how it might work, including using dynamic formative evaluation designed to help make it work rather than passive, detached, summative evaluation designed to check whether it works. And did this process really need to take 10 years?!</p><p>There are those who say that some people or organisations within the suicide prevention establishment resisted RTSSS because it meant they would no longer have ‘control of the data’. I’ll let you reflect and decide on that one.</p><p>Meanwhile, I’m grateful we now have it, nationally and locally, and it’s potentially a breakthrough in suicide prevention, but please use it for ground-up analysis and tailored action in your area, don’t fall into the trap of continuing to be driven by what national data is telling us:</p><p><a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/near-to-real-time-suspected-suicide-surveillance-nrtsss-for-england/statistical-report-near-to-real-time-suspected-suicide-surveillance-nrtsss-for-england-for-the-15-months-to-august-2023">Statistical report: near to real-time suspected suicide surveillance (nRTSSS) for England for the 15 months to August 2023</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L_Vb7LiZRwZpKQqNCQw7Ig.png" /></figure><p>And let’s also avoid other traps that allow low ambition to breed. Having RTSSS data should empower us and energise us to aim higher, and get those suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>One danger from ‘establishment thinking’ is believing that our role is now to monitor this new real-time data to see where numbers might be rising and take remedial action to stop them rising and bring them back to our familiar flat line, rather than constantly aspiring to reducing the numbers, towards zero, and using the data to help us achieve that goal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Eo0Q5kQy8JYOOxUy7-jU7w.png" /></figure><p>What the national RTSSS data has given us is an extension of our flat line graph so we know that it’s no longer 15 years of no reduction in the annual suicide numbers, it’s 16 years of no reduction in the suicide numbers.</p><p>This is unacceptable, and we must all be dissatisfied with this status quo, certainly not ‘celebrating’ the numbers not being higher or getting excited at new data for its own sake.</p><p>All data and evidence is simply a means to an end — in this case, the end of getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero — not an end in itself although, as a Research Fellow, I know that researchers often see having high quality, insightful data as an end in itself, sometimes forgetting it’s actually just an input into a process, a means to our ends.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kiV3A6ncQT7vtSIdiLriwg.png" /></figure><p><strong>More Data &amp; Evidence Bias — and Selection Bias</strong></p><p>Obviously, a key role of Government is to conduct and commission necessary research to provide exploratory or explanatory data that enhances our ability to reduce the number of suicides, towards zero.</p><p>Again though, there’s a problem with the systemic biases and discrimination that takes place when certain groups are prioritised.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3ZbLDBJlpWkcO2sQiBNsAQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gSAs3dvOS03lD_hy_kcBCA.png" /></figure><p>We need to better understand incidences of suicide following a bereavement but this can be interpreted by those working in suicide prevention quite narrowly, usually studying where there is or might be heightened suicide risk among people bereaved by suicide, but not studying heightened risk among those bereaved by conditions or circumstances other than suicide, eg (older) people losing a lifelong partner to cancer or dementia.</p><p>Also, historically, the health bias in suicide prevention research has discriminated against research into socio-economic factors.</p><p>In the past few years, there’s been a bit more attention given to socio-economic factors, including broad relationships between the unemployment rate and the suicide rate in recessions or the relationship between suicide and poverty, but much of this research is simply number-crunching using existing datasets showing correlations, with perhaps some attempt to identify causation, but always highly qualified with caution.</p><p>What’s usually missing is the qualitative research and deep insights that shed light on these inter-relationships, the chain of causation, and what can be done to prevent suicides among those living in poverty, or those struggling to pay bills, or those who’ve just lost their job.</p><p>What’s also often missing is ceteris paribus research where we study a sample of people who’ve had a similar experience in apparently similar conditions but with a different outcome, eg a sample of people who’ve lost their jobs and been unemployed for 3–9 months where some have taken their own life and some haven’t, to understand what might have caused those who ended their lives to do so, and others not.</p><p>In very recent times, it’s “<em>the cost of living</em>” which has become the primary narrative and it’s an example of another systemic bias in the National Strategy process. It tends to pick up ‘topical issues’ at the point where a new National Strategy is being discussed and developed, like ‘the cost of living’ and ‘online sources of harmful drugs’ and pull them in to the published National Strategy; with other issues, which may or may not be just as important, not getting on to the agenda. This reflects the way that Government works generally of course, not just suicide prevention.</p><p>Another key bias of the National Strategy process is this concept of ‘having a seat at the table’ for ‘the privileged few’ who get to influence National Strategies and plans. In the past month, it was announced — once again through the only source we seem to have for information about the National Strategy, Professor Appleby’s X/Twitter account — that the charity Money &amp; Mental Health now has ‘a seat at the table’:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WWlkWTxfSIG1QqsjvQ179w.png" /></figure><p>These charities ‘getting a seat at the table’ are all fine charities and I want them all to be having input but, again, we must be conscious that, within the current system, these are 3 ‘winners’ and there are many more ‘losers’!</p><p>Btw, I’ve noticed at least a dozen posts and questions asked at relevant events asking “<em>who’s on the Advisory Group?</em>” (ie the National Suicide Prevention Strategy Advisory Group) and I’ve never seen the question answered. Is there a reason for this apparent lack of transparency and accountability? Is there a list published somewhere?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e726NE9vCVPhgKNreroGuQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Information and Accountability Deficit!</strong></p><p>There’s certainly a gaping hole in terms of accountability as no-one seems to have responsibility for communicating to the world outside the inner circle what the Advisory Group is discussing and recommending.</p><p>On the issue of ‘targets and measurement’ for example, NSPA published a summary of the online discussion that it facilitated on this particular topic but the Advisory Group didn’t publish a response or explain why, after receiving this input, it chose not to have a reduction target.</p><p>I’ve raised this with a couple of people who I know are members of the Advisory Group, and they don’t seem to think it’s an issue, so emphasising that they view the world through a different lens to the many people not members of the Advisory Group who, in contrast, think that an information flow with summaries of what’s being discussed and agreed by the National Suicide Prevention Strategy Advisory Group is a minimum expectation.</p><p>And saying, as they did, “<em>we don’t have resources for that</em>” is a weak response!</p><p><strong>Quantitative Analysis, Qualitative Insights, and Research-Backed Action!</strong></p><p>Back to the National Strategy document!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gSAs3dvOS03lD_hy_kcBCA.png" /></figure><p>It says Govt/DHSC/ONS “<em>will conduct or commission research or data linkage projects, including…trends in suicide rates in different occupational groups</em>”.</p><p>Now, I’d be the first to say that, to get the suicide numbers down, towards zero, we need to look at different occupational groups, and this is also part of our Zero Suicide Society model.</p><p>But one of the biggest frustrations with Government research is that it’s often number-crunching without actionable insights or highlighting specific actions that can be taken to reduce suicides or it’s monitoring of trends which clarifies what the problem is without necessarily providing solutions. At worst, ‘trend analysis’ simply tells us that there’s been a slight increase here and a slight decrease there whilst the overall numbers of suicides is the same…and we haven’t progressed at all.</p><p>Government should be working in collaborative partnership with different sectors and professions with the clear aim to reduce the numbers, including any further research needed. In many cases, no further research is needed, it’s action that’s needed, so ‘trend analysis’ can be naval gazing. In other cases, specific targeted action research would be useful.</p><p>The Construction sector is an obvious one to partner with, given that almost 10% of all suicides are people working in Construction, although I can’t see it explicitly referenced in NSPS 2023–2028. Add in those working with the Construction sector, it’s probably 1 in 7 suicides.</p><p>Now here’s another problem. I’ve attended meetings with some of the suicide prevention establishment in the past and when you say something like “<em>probably 1 in 7 suicides</em>”, their response is “<em>we’re not sure if that number is correct and we need to do more research to check if it is in fact 1 in 7</em>”.</p><p>An alternative response would be “<em>yes, it’s probably around 1 in 7, and we know for sure that 500 people working in Construction die by suicide each year, and we know that people working in Construction are 10 times more likely to die by suicide than by physical accidents at work; we don’t need any more data to tell us there’s a problem here; how can we get these numbers of suicide deaths down significantly, and on a downward trend (towards zero)</em>”.</p><p>Then we have “<em>suicide rates in veterans</em>”. This is another example of where it’s possible more or different research is needed, but we also have a lot of research, and a lot of knowledge from lived experience, pointing to actions we can take to reduce the number of suicides, so we often just need more action not more research.</p><p>The ‘scarcity mindset’ often causes further problems here, where people are, from the outset, looking for evidence of what to prioritise and how to prioritise, ie ways of limiting action, rather than being action-oriented.</p><p>And, last but not least, we have “<em>agricultural workers</em>”. Do we really need more (quantitative) research among this group? Why? To find out what? What actions can we take now to reduce suicides among agricultural workers that doesn’t need more data or more quantitative analysis?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0bvluRUNj6xB8VjVOc3k1w.png" /></figure><p><strong>Gaps in the Data and Data Quality</strong></p><p>In the penultimate paragraph, we’re informed that “<em>Government departments will consider insights from the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey</em>” (APMS). I understand this will be a new APMS, published in 2024, to provide up-to-date data and new insights.</p><p>That might be useful, especially if there’s wider engagement with key stakeholder groups, including people with lived experience, to make sure we’re asking the right questions to the right sample, although ‘the experts’ will probably want to keep these ‘technical matters’ to themselves.</p><p>It’s hard though when surveys like the APMS take place so infrequently, with the last one being in 2014, with some government departments, and charities like Mind on their website, still quoting some statistics from the 2007 APMS as if they’re the latest figures.</p><p>The world has completely changed since 2014, including being turned upside down by the COVID19 pandemic. It’s quite bizarre to still be developing plans, policies, campaigns, etc based on 2014 data.</p><p>No self-respecting commercial organisation would be basing decisions on data that’s almost 10 years out-of-date. HM Treasury wouldn’t be basing economic policy on data from 2014. Why should we be relying on data to underpin decisions on suicide prevention strategy from a 2014 survey?</p><p>Because of the lack of up-to-date data, The Jordan Legacy has been working in partnership with MEL Research to carry out a twice a year survey among a representative sample of 1500 UK adults to give us up-to-date data, and trends, on key figures around suicide and suicide prevention.</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-how-far-we-have-to-go-cb1b8564adc0">Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society — how far we have to go</a></p><p>But we shouldn’t have to do this. There shouldn’t be a gap to fill.</p><p>If the Government was truly committed to suicide prevention, it would make sure key data was collected annually — or, at the very least, every 2–3 years — and trends monitored.</p><p>Again, it’s good that we’ll have the new APMS data in 2024 but not good that a National Suicide Prevention Strategy has been developed in 2023 in the absence of this data.</p><p>While we’re on the subject of the APMS, I’d just like to highlight a pattern I’ve observed throughout my research career. These types of Government surveys are often highly sophisticated in their sample design and analysis to help provide high quality, reliable, representative data, but they often have poorly designed questions so undo the good work on sampling.</p><p>In my workshops, I often talk about the art and science of survey research. The sampling component is largely science with a bit of art. The question wording component is more of an art mixed with science.</p><p>As the screenshot from the APMS report below shows, the questions are rather strange and with potential biases.</p><p>“<em>Have you ever thought of taking your own life?</em>” would be a reasonable question on its own but what is probably a large ‘design committee’ has added “<em>even though you would not actually do it?</em>” which then just makes the question confusing.</p><p>After getting a ‘yes’ response to “<em>have you ever thought of taking your own life?</em>”, we can ask something like “<em>did you seriously want to end your life?</em>” or “<em>did you make a plan to end your life?</em>” or lots of other clearer questions that would give us a more accurate and less ambiguous set of answers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IUvx6JDuEnmUqoFEy-CDmA.png" /></figure><p>Similarly, it’s a perfectly good question to just ask “<em>Have you ever made an attempt to take your life?</em>” so why then add “<em>by taking an overdose of tablets or in some other way?</em>”?</p><p>I can imagine the ‘survey design committee’ arguing that this addition clarifies what’s meant by a suicide attempt and/or tries to get the widest possible definition, but is it really necessary and does it bias responses, eg those taking overdoses more likely to answer ‘yes’?</p><p>Surely just the first part of the question needed?!</p><p>I digress…</p><p><strong>Tailored &amp; Targeted Support — or Institutionalising Priority Group Bias</strong></p><p>Back to the National Strategy document again; back to ‘priority groups’; back to the problem of bias and discrimination due to the fundamental driver of the entire National Strategy being setting priorities.</p><p>As I’ve highlighted elsewhere, the systemic bias is deeply embedded in this whole process, eg where certain groups are selected for ‘priority status’ whilst other groups, like older people, are excluded completely, and then the Strategy demands that for the selected priority groups “<em>It is therefore crucial that organisations and individuals tailor and target resources and services to support these groups</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MTtqihvlMELGTbuReRIIbw.png" /></figure><p>In other words, it’s urging other people and organisations around the country to embed this constructed bias and discrimination, rather than focusing on the groups in their area or community of interest who they regard as needing particular attention…or simply treating every group at risk and every individual in danger as worthy of support.</p><p>While we’re on the subject of ‘The Priority Trap’, the inherent biases in the National Strategy process which can be counter-productive and potentially harmful, and the ‘top-down’ mentality that often drives these National Strategy processes, despite us now having some excellent local suicide prevention partnerships looking at ‘real time data’ in their areas and being able to react to local circumstances and be more effectively ‘preactive’, ie better prepared to react where being proactive is difficult…</p><p>…it’s worth just highlighting that the Government’s lead adviser on suicide prevention strategies, plans and policies, Professor Appleby, is very much from the ‘old school’ tradition of top-down, population data-driven, priority-setting, strategic planning.</p><p>In this presentation to the BMA, Prof Appleby tells the audience what he thinks the priorities should be, including priority groups to focus on, for the next 10 years; and he describes his thinking, his process, and his advice, which of course is the kind of advice he’s giving to government.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ASB6enUcAiH2n4PvBYfgKQ.png" /></figure><p>Just have a think about this.</p><p>In the fast-moving, ever-changing world we live and work in, with much uncertainty, and events like the COVID19 pandemic hitting us — only now in the Inquiry are we getting proper insights into the decisions taken, or not taken, and why — and technological transformations taking place whilst only just scratching the surface of AI, and with opportunities to build from the ground up with RTSSS-centred local partnerships and micro zero suicide plans…are we really in a position to say which groups should be a priority for the next 10 years?</p><p>And should we? How would this help? How might this harm?</p><p>Professor Appleby will often inform audiences in his presentations — and he delivers many presentations, including always being a keynote speaker, some would say the keynote speaker, at NSPA Conferences — that suicide is complex with many different causal and contributory factors, which is absolutely the case, but then he’ll also argue for focusing the National Strategy on a few ‘priority groups’ and a few ‘key drivers’.</p><p>The problem with these types of process is that as soon as you prioritise specific groups or particular actions or ‘key drivers’, you discriminate and introduce a bias that can harm as well as help.</p><p>In the National Strategy document, in addition to explicit prioritisation, there are several instances where it gives examples, or says ‘especially’ or ‘particularly’. On each of these occasions, a bias is created or reinforced.</p><p>It may be helpful, it may be harmful, helpful to some, harmful to others.</p><p>We need to be conscious that the bias is there and be sure we feel justified in creating or sustaining such a bias as well as thinking about alternative models with a co-ordinated approach where ‘everyone is a priority for someone’ and there’s a more flexible ground-up system.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ywx-m70rIQ-TRvWWUVc9Kw.png" /></figure><p>Of all Professor Appleby’s Tweets, this one is perhaps the most disturbing:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Okk6dNReTcAm7Pg8GklzQ.png" /></figure><p>Not only does the Government’s lead adviser on suicide prevention believe that we should set out priorities for the next 10 years, and build a National Suicide Prevention Strategy around ‘priority groups’, but he believes that the list of priority groups “<em>has to be short to be meaningful</em>”.</p><p>And this is at the very heart of the problem with this traditional mindset in government, in our institutions generally, and in the process used to devise our National Suicide Prevention Strategies…where you have a ‘scarcity mindset’ and believe that every process is about identifying priorities and allocating scarce resources.</p><p>You want to agree on as small a number of priorities as possible to have, and to demonstrate, impact, so you can continue to argue for further priority-setting, ie ‘we prioritised young people and we’ve reduced the suicide rate among young people’.</p><p>But not only does this process discriminate, it’s been proven over the past 15 years to not bring down the overall number of suicides— it just pushes the air around in the balloon — and, worse still, it doesn’t even have a good track record of reducing suicides in some of the ‘priority groups’, eg young people were given priority status in the previous National Strategy but rates have been rising among young people.</p><p>And, sadly, this can lead to a ‘doubling down’ effect where lack of progress encourages those caught in The Priority Trap to argue for a smaller number of priority groups to try and have more impact within these groups, ie fewer winners and more losers!</p><p>Here’s the list of ‘winners’ in the latest competition for priorities that we call the National Strategy process. As you look at the list, please study the ‘winners’ and also think about who the ‘losers’ are this time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XDCeGG7uenHXACAmcTSitg.png" /></figure><p>As I’ve highlighted a few times now, the list includes children &amp; young people and middle-aged men, but not older people or older men, despite men aged 75+ having a substantially higher suicide rate than men aged under 25. Again, I’m not advocating for any one group to be given a higher priority, just highlighting the bias, and advocating for a co-ordinated approach where ‘everyone is a priority for someone’.</p><p>It’s easy to make a case for each group to have some degree of focus, but also easy to argue a more inclusive case. For example, we know that many new mothers struggle but then so do new fathers. We know that there are people in contact with mental health services who need better support but also people not in contact with mental health services who are desperate to keep out of psychiatric services because of the harm they can cause, eg having a young anorexic girl placed in a general psychiatric ward.</p><p>It’s good to see more attention being given to autistic people, with emerging evidence that it could be 1 in 10 people taking their own lives, or more, who are autistic. But what about people with other neurodivergent conditions? Why specifically autistic people and not, say, people with ADHD? Again, to what extent does this narrow prioritisation help or harm?</p><p><strong>Not Trying to Cover Everything in the National Strategy from Here!</strong></p><p>Just a quick note here to say that, for the remainder of this critique of the National Strategy, I’m not going to try and comment on every part of it, just those parts I feel warrant comment, and content that illustrates the broad criticisms I’m making, eg around ‘The Priority Trap’; ‘The Top Down Trap’; the bias and discrimination embedded in the process, and what’s not included; the systemic low ambition; barriers to suicide prevention that are created or sustained by the National Strategy and its process; and the failure to have positive change dynamics built in to the National Strategy.</p><p>I don’t comment specifically on the sections in the National Strategy on people who’ve self-harmed; alcohol &amp; drugs misuse; people with chronic physical illness or physical health conditions; the broader issues around children &amp; young people, other than schools and higher education; crisis support; or the ‘responsible portrayal of suicide in the media’.</p><p>I’m not neglecting any of these issues or groups, or giving them lower priority in any way. They’re all important ‘pieces in the puzzle’, and they should all have a section in the National Strategy.</p><p>The main reason why I’m not commenting specifically on these issues/groups is that I largely agree with the content in the National Strategy document, and I welcome it.</p><p><strong>Risk/Causal/Contributory Factors</strong></p><p>Another key bias historically has been the health bias in the lens through which suicide &amp; suicide prevention are viewed and the structural approach to suicide prevention, which is seen as the responsibility of the Health Department, the NHS, and the health profession.</p><p>Anyone new to suicide prevention soon sees that suicide is not just a (mental) health issue and there are many causal and contributory factors.</p><p>It doesn’t take long for anyone with their eyes open, and their mind open, to see that factors like those listed below, and factors like poverty, are drivers of suicides.</p><p>Those steeped in the world of suicide prevention talk about ‘socio-economic risk factors’ or ‘socio-economic determinants’ of suicide.</p><p>Most citizens will recognise these factors — in plain language — as not having enough money to feed the kids or pay the bills and getting little or no support from government, being (made) homeless, being made redundant, feeling completely alone, etc.</p><p>It’s not rocket science, but it is science and it’s art too, as just a bit of creative compassion quickly identifies people who are struggling and the situations and environments in which they’re struggling.</p><p>The more we focus on ‘cure’ rather than on prevention, the more we focus on crisis and ‘crisis interventions’, the more we focus on downstream problems rather than on upstream solutions…the more we end up looking through that health lens again and not making much progress.</p><p>At the heart of solutions for getting the suicide numbers down from the unacceptably high level of 6,000+ preventable deaths every year in the UK, 5,000+ preventable deaths in England each year, down towards zero, are these underlying factors or determinants. They are central not tangential.</p><p>As the National Strategy document states “<em>Links have been evidenced between suicide and social determinants of health such as housing, poverty, employment and education</em>” but, again, please carefully study the language used here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gpSH3YICvaYtNsZRgpMyYA.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Health Bias, Socio-Economic Factors, and Suicide as a Political Issue</strong></p><p>Firstly, “<em>social determinants of health</em>”.</p><p>These are socio-economic and socio-political determinants of <strong>suicide</strong>. Calling them ‘determinants of health’ is part of the continuing health bias, like slipping suicide prevention as an incidental item into the consultation around the Mental Health Strategy rather than having a dedicated suicide prevention engagement process.</p><p>Secondly, people seem to run away from the reality that suicide is political. Not party political — we don’t want a destructive party political bunfight — but suicide is political, eg people living in poverty are more likely to die by suicide, and poverty is a political issue, so suicide is a political issue.</p><p>Thirdly, personal &amp; political beliefs have a massive bearing on suicide prevention strategies, plans, policies, practices…and communications around suicide prevention, including advocacy and campaigning.</p><p>Many people and organisations constantly focus on suicide as a personal responsibility, talking about people ‘needing to be more resilient’ or initiatives ‘to help build resilience’, and saying people should ‘reach out’</p><p>Other people and organisations (also) see suicide prevention as a collective responsibility and collective endeavour, with a significant role for government and our institutions, with a degree of individual resilience-building needing to be combined with fundamental improvements to the circumstances, conditions, and environment in which people live and work (or don’t work because they can’t get work) so individuals don’t have to keep summoning up huge reserves of personal resilience to just survive.</p><p>Constantly asking people to ‘reach out for support’ demonstrates a complete lack of understanding of what it’s like being in the depths of depression and suicidal despair. People don’t ‘reach out’ at this point. They can’t reach out at this point. That is the point! We must ‘reach in’ and get better at ‘reaching in’, not keep expecting these people to ‘reach out’!</p><p>Fourthly, think about this statement from the section of the National Strategy below: “<em>We encourage everybody working in suicide prevention to consider the wider determinants in their efforts to prevent suicides</em>”.</p><p>‘Consider’? They should be at the heart of suicide prevention strategies, plans, policies, and activities, not just be ‘considered’!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tiMhoPzgN7j999o_8gXJbQ.png" /></figure><p>And, of course, prioritising the ‘risk factors’ has many of the same flaws, pitfalls, risks and potential harms as having ‘priority groups’, including the problem of ‘data and evidence bias’ I highlighted previously.</p><p>The text below is more hopeful as it’s through collaboration and local plans that much of our success in reducing the number of suicides will come, although important that local suicide prevention plans are ambitious — Zero Suicide Plans! — and focus on local issues, local drivers, local data and evidence, local ideas and suggestions, and local priorities where they feel the need to focus…not just aligning to ‘national priorities’.</p><p>It’s absolutely crucial that local collaboration brings “<em>a wide range of partners together</em>”, and experience suggests that local partnerships tend to be much more inclusive than involvement at the national level.</p><p>It’s also absolutely crucial that local partnerships take into account “<em>wider determinants linked to suicide prevention, such as housing and financial difficulty</em>” and, again, the evidence shows that local partnerships are much better at doing this than at the national level.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JVloKeXbiY0O4XtwJzf1ew.png" /></figure><p>I’ve already commented on the DHSC VCSE Suicide Prevention Grant Fund, welcoming this opportunity — although putting this £10 million fund into perspective when preventable suicide deaths cost the UK economy more than £10 billion every year — and saying I’d like to see a focus on innovation and breakthrough ideas rather than just revenue funding existing services which, at worst, could just be propping up unsustainable services.</p><p>I also wanted to add here, or emphasise here once again, the inherent bias in this entire process, and the potentially harmful ‘winners and losers’ approach from the priority group-centred mentality.</p><p>The DHSC Grant Fund seeks applications from local VCSEs that focus on ‘the national priorities’. The OHID wants “<em>local plans in line with national priorities</em>”. The NHS Long Term Plan funding is designed to support “<em>specific groups</em>”. And so it goes on.</p><p>Local partnerships and local plans that are developed from the ground up based on local issues and then co-ordinated locally can generate a different picture to local plans feeling they have to align to national plans, national priorities, and especially, national funding.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QKsZgA09IaP6olj6QWDuww.png" /></figure><p><strong>Suicide Education in Schools for Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>Virtually everyone we speak with in our suicide prevention work, and virtually everyone we interviewed as part of our action research project in 2023, believes that suicide education in schools is a key piece in the puzzle, and many say “<em>it’s a no brainer</em>”.</p><p>The 3 Dads Walking petition to have suicide prevention as part of the schools curriculum got 170,000 signatures — one of the highest numbers of signatures for any petition to parliament — and, in the parliamentary debate it prompted on 17 March 2023, there was almost universal support for this proposal…until, that is, the DfE provided a cool response and said it would consider “<em>whether</em>” to take this proposal forward.</p><p>Many months later, when the National Suicide Prevention Strategy was finally published on 11 September, DfE is still saying “<em>whether</em>” in the Exec Summary and, below, “<em>reviewing RSHE guidance to consider the inclusion of suicide and self-harm prevention as an explicit part of the curriculum</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NZO15230eQA4msOd0A7YwQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s not very heartening or hopeful to still be talking ‘whether’ not how we implement this ‘no brainer’.</p><p>Young people, and often very young children, are already exposed to suicide &amp; self-harm. They’re already talking about suicide &amp; self-harm, and already engaging in self-harm behaviour, and 1 in 15 have made a suicide attempt by the age of 17, according to the UCL Millennium Cohort Study.</p><p>Not having suicide and self-harm as an explicit part of the curriculum would be irresponsible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RUzjLsXUeWPcbNAXGtKQgQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Suicide Prevention in Higher Education</strong></p><p>Another petition launched via The LEARN Network by parents who’ve lost their children after they went to university, arguing for a statutory duty of care, had widespread support, getting 128,000 signatures, but it had strong pushback from the higher education sector and lukewarm support or even opposition from some of the bigger suicide prevention charities — some of whom work closely with the universities and either genuinely didn’t believe that a statutory duty of care would help save lives or didn’t want to rock-the-boat in terms of their relationships with universities, or both.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-D6YlgzT9XoVNttQwlNSdQ.png" /></figure><p>This month (December 2023), Maggie &amp; Robert Abrahart will be in the High Court arguing their case for a statutory duty of care, as the University of Bristol appeals against the County Court decision that it effectively contributed to Natasha Abrahart’s suicide</p><p><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/education/2023/nov/20/high-court-to-consider-whether-universities-owe-students-legal-duty-of-care">High court to consider whether universities owe students legal duty of care</a></p><p>It’s possible that the courts will rule against a statutory duty of care, and it’s possible that other measures will be taken by universities to create a suicide-safer environment and get the numbers of suicides down, but it’s also clear that the group of people most knowledgeable on this topic, ie the bereaved parents — intelligent people, some of whom have worked in the higher education sector — believe that it’s only through a statutory duty of care that we’ll get change, and get change quickly. Any delay in making this change is putting more students at risk.</p><p>Those from within the higher education sector arguing against a statutory duty of care, and those from the ‘suicide prevention establishment’ arguing against having a statutory duty of care for universities, often include in their argument against this proposal — and the Government’s lead adviser on suicide prevention has made this same comment publicly on several occasions — that the suicide rate among students at UK universities is significantly lower than for the population as a whole. And it features again here in the National Strategy document:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RUzjLsXUeWPcbNAXGtKQgQ.png" /></figure><p>Whilst appearing to support action to prevent suicides among university students, it adds a preamble “<em>While ONS statistics suggest that higher education students in England have lower suicide rates…</em>”.</p><p>This is code for ‘so not a priority’. In the minds of those who think and operate around the need to limit actions to those that are ‘evidence-based priorities’, this is their staple diet and instinctive reaction whenever anyone suggests action to reduce the numbers of suicides among university students…to effectively say ‘it’s not really a problem to be solved’.</p><p>This is a very painful message for bereaved parents to hear, and bereaved siblings and others who’ve lost their family members or friends to suicide at university; and it’s needless pain and a needless comment; and it doesn’t help anyone apart from defensive higher education institutions that are not fully committed to preventing all preventable suicides.</p><p>If we approach this issue from a Zero Suicide Society perspective, ie trying to do all we can to prevent all preventable suicides and ‘move towards zero deaths’ in the higher education sector, then it doesn’t matter what the relative suicide rate is between university students and the general population (of people of a similar age). It’s irrelevant. It’s not helpful to even mention this. In fact it’s harmful to mention it. So why do it?!</p><p>We need mandatory Zero Suicide Plans for all higher education institutions so they all try to do all they can to prevent all preventable suicides. We need that level of ambition and commitment, and we need the National Suicide Prevention Strategy to include this level of ambition and commitment. We don’t need a National Strategy that sends a message to universities or anyone else that there’s not a problem to be solved here because suicide rates among university students are ‘relatively low’!</p><p><strong>Considering Problematic Biases due to The Priority Trap</strong></p><p>Let’s look at some of the other ‘priority groups’ in the context of “<em>yes, of course, there needs to be action to reduce the numbers of suicides among people in these groups but just focusing on a small number of ‘priority groups’ is not going to get the suicide numbers down towards zero, and may be harmful</em>”.</p><p>Firstly, middle-aged men.</p><p>Whenever I read text like this below re prioritising ‘middle-aged men’, my first three thoughts are:</p><ol><li>yes, we need to reduce the numbers of suicides among middle-aged men but people don’t die because they’re a middle-aged man, they die because of common experiences that middle-aged men are more likely to have and we must focus on these experiences with experiential and behavioural targeting;</li><li>we also need to reduce the numbers of suicides among younger men and older men, because we have suicides here too, and every life is equally important — despite some politicians and commentators clearly believing that older people were ‘expendable’ during the pandemic! — and so we also need specific plans for younger men and older men, ideally Zero Suicide Plans tailored to their needs and circumstances;</li><li>we also need to reduce the number of suicides among women — women of all ages — and, given that women are significantly more likely than men to attempt suicide, we must have ‘suicide attempt prevention’ strategies and plans for women of all ages as well as men.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z_gxAfuvTN2vEY7NbQsURQ.png" /></figure><p>Of course, the suicide prevention establishment doesn’t think like this — and doesn’t adopt a co-ordinated, collaborative approach where ‘everyone is a priority for someone’, as it believes ‘not everyone can be a priority’ in its winers and losers competition.</p><p>Two other thoughts I have when reflecting on the above text from the National Strategy, especially the line about middle-aged men having had the highest gender-age-specific suicide rate since 2010, ie for the entire period of the Government’s published National Strategies since 2012, which may sound like unfair criticisms, and I’m trying hard to avoid personal criticism of individuals who I’m sure will be acting in good faith:</p><p>1) if they’ve been a ‘priority group’ for attention since the very beginning, why have the numbers of suicides among middle-aged men not fallen?</p><p>2) from the content in the document, it still reads like they don’t understand the underlying issues and they don’t know what to do.</p><p>This is partly the health/health system bias causing this of course, because so many of the contributory factors and, especially, the underlying causes of suicide among middle-aged men are not health issues.</p><p>All the middle-aged men we lost in my own community in Teesside in the early 1980s — previously strong communities and big, strong men, systemically ‘de-hoped’ by the ideologically-based economic policies of the Government of the time — were not driven to suicide by ‘health issues’!</p><p>The paragraph below begins to get under-the-surface somewhat but it smacks of naivety and reflects what tends to happen in a system that is largely crisis-focused and health-focused.</p><p>It’s very common for ‘financial difficulty’ to be narrowly interpreted as ‘in debt’ and needing ‘debt counselling’ or ‘debt support’. Debt counselling is an important service, and there are some excellent debt counselling services available, and many people can be helped with “<em>debt support</em>”.</p><p>However, many of those in financial crisis are in a situation where they can’t meet their basic needs with the income they have and no amount of ‘better budgeting’ or ‘debt management’ can change this situation.</p><p>If we’re truly committed to doing all we can to prevent all preventable suicides, we’d be advocating for policies like a Universal Basic Income or Guaranteed Minimum Income, and appropriate reforms to the ‘benefits system’ (including not calling them ‘benefits’!) that will tackle the underlying problem rather than just trying to manage the symptoms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YFG72XKKZX8zCe95nbMDsQ.png" /></figure><p>As I’ve highlighted earlier, there are also fundamental problems with expecting people in distress and danger to “<em>disclose that they are experiencing thoughts of suicide or self-harm</em>”…to DWP!</p><p>The focus in this National Strategy on DWP being reactive not proactive is highly disturbing.</p><p>In the suicide prevention field, there’s often far too much emphasis on urging people to ‘reach out for help’ when we know that people who are in vulnerable situations, and certainly in suicidal crisis, don’t ‘reach out’ so need us to ‘reach in’.</p><p>So we need DWP and other public services to be proactive.</p><p>Of course, what we really need to ‘move towards zero suicides’ is a complete transformational shift in the entire culture and structure of institutions like DWP, away from a modus operandi of ‘give out as little money as possible, make it as hard as possible to get money, shame people for not having a job or independent financial means, and humiliate them on a regular basis to keep them from challenging the system’ — my characterisation for effect, but many people’s actual experience!</p><p>We should be shifting to a system where we do everything possible to support people in need; help them get (back) into suitable work as quickly as possible; listen carefully and empathically and with respect to people in need; proactively inform people about what support is available and help them to get it as painlessly as possible; help people to live independently with the highest possible quality of life, with opportunities to thrive beyond survive; do everything possible to ensure optimal (mental) health and prevent suicides because that’s the human thing to do and it saves the taxpayer lots of money in the long-run.</p><p>I read the study, referred to below, among middle-aged men — which was useful, and the specific actions outlined below will help — but two thoughts that kept going through my mind are, firstly, that this kind of research is so rare, despite middle-aged men having had a heightened suicide risk for decades and, secondly, the report highlighted the massive problem of stigma whilst fuelling a contrary message that ‘men are opening up’.</p><p>Many campaigners have used this report to ‘challenge the myth that men don’t talk and men don’t seek help’, arguing ‘this report shows that men are talking about their mental health and seeking support for their mental health’, and yet one of the key findings in the research was that men were opening up about their mental health issues and suicidal thinking after first making appointments to see their GP about a physical ailment. In other words, stigma and shame are still a huge problem, and the system discriminates against mental health issues.</p><p>I can draw from my own personal experience here in knowing that the entire system demands of people they diagnose themselves before even being considered for an appointment with a doctor and, even then, it’s often an initial telephone call or video call with a junior doctor — or “<em>trainee</em>” (self-described in my case) — and people are much more likely to get access to a GP (and I mean ‘a GP’ not ‘my GP’) by saying they have a tangible, specific, physical ailment rather than being honest about the emotional and psychological torture they’re currently wrestling with.</p><p>So we need fundamental ‘systems change’, we need transformational change, but we get a few transactional adjustments proposed alongside a misleading narrative about ‘men are getting better at seeking help and we should encourage more to seek help’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vumfj-dICy8EDTa71U0y3A.png" /></figure><p>Let’s unpack this: “<em>Each of these interaction points provides additional opportunity to prevent suicides and encourage middle-aged men at risk of suicide to seek the right support</em>”.</p><p>Yes, each interaction point is an opportunity, and not just for middle-aged men. We should be identifying and enhancing every opportunity to provide support, intervene early, prevent suicides, for men and women of all ages in all circumstances.</p><p>We should also be tackling those barriers to access at the point where people try to ‘reach out’ for support as well as developing more effective systems of us ‘reaching in’.</p><p>And we must continue to challenge the stigma and shame that prevents people from ‘seeking the right support’ as well as making sure the ‘right support’ is actually there.</p><p>Many people say they’re worried about urging their family, friends and colleagues to seek help because they’re not confident the help and support is actually there, or that they’ll get appropriate or effective support.</p><p>Support in ‘spotting the signs’ and pointing to guides and booklets and websites and online resources is fine as long as there’s actual support at the end of the search process.</p><p>Probably the most useful content in the National Strategy document, as it often is in any suicide prevention document, is lists like this of sources of information, services and initiatives to support people in need.</p><p>Publishing a national directory of services would have probably been more useful than the ‘strategy’ document we got!</p><p>Seriously though, we actually do have some great resources like, for example, the Hub of Hope (which is listed in the National Strategy document but could have been more prominent) where people can type in their postcode and find out what’s available in their area…</p><p><a href="https://hubofhope.co.uk/">Hub of Hope - Mental Health Support Network provided by Chasing the Stigma</a></p><p>…and we should be doing more to make sure more people are aware of these excellent resources, to support and build capacity to support.</p><p>Virtually every week, I have a conversation with someone about the Hub of Hope as a start point in their search, and they weren’t previously aware, and it’s a revelation to them. We must all raise the general level of awareness and knowledge, and it should be another component of suicide education and mental health education in schools.</p><p>Also provide the content in the most useful way, eg by group, by issue or challenge being faced, by sector people work in, not just lists.</p><p>And try to make the lists of resources as comprehensive as possible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fZ-eYir3APxOuOZ_yDrYVA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M-51BiQ3GzSQvQ5B_ZIS6Q.png" /></figure><p>A request I’ve had dozens of times in my mental health and suicide prevention research over the past 10 years is a system of referral and recommendation for all of the different sources and services available.</p><p>And another problem with top-down Government strategies that tend to mainly involve the bigger, more established charities, and a privileged few people with lived experience, they all run away from ideas like this, due to institutionalised conservatism, or put them in the ‘too hard basket’.</p><p>I’ve tried many times to work with government, at all levels, the NHS, other institutions and public services, and several charities…and none of them will touch the idea of a “<em>referral and recommendation system</em>” with a bargepole. They’re terrified of having any responsibility beyond ‘here’s a list’ — even then they’re terrified they’ve missed someone off the list! — and saying ‘this is good…we’d recommend this’.</p><p>Even when I’ve suggested a “<em>TripAdvisor style approach with user recommendations and referrals</em>”, the establishment looks the other way and goes back to its comfort zone, like identifying ‘priority groups’ or highlighting potential academic research projects or ONS analysis.</p><p>Interestingly, I mentioned the idea last month to the development team for the new iTalk mental health and suicide prevention app which has been designed initially for the Construction sector (where almost 10% of all suicides in England and Wales are to be found), and developed entirely with private funding from within the Construction sector, and they said immediately “<em>we’ll develop that and build it into the app</em>”!</p><p>This is the kind of ambition and practical innovation we need to be able to get the numbers of suicides on a downward trend, towards zero.</p><p>And watch this space for the roll out of the iTalk app:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vZNc4SqiKt3ll_hrz_mFMQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Suicide Prevention in the Criminal Justice System</strong></p><p>The content below is positive and hopeful, highlighting one area where there are lots of practical actions that can be taken to reduce suicides considerably — the justice system.</p><p>I recall one of my local suicide prevention partnerships having an overall target for reducing suicides as ‘10% in 5 years’ — the classic low ambition ‘10% reduction in 5 years’ problem manifesting itself once again — but having a reduction target for deaths in custody of 95%.</p><p>I asked them why their overall reduction target was so low but their target for reducing suicides in police custody was so high.</p><p>And the answer was very simple of course. They could think of the specific, practical actions they could take to reduce suicide deaths in custody, so aimed high. But they couldn’t think of practical actions to get the overall numbers down by more than 10% in 5 years, or they didn’t think they had the resources to get the overall suicide numbers down by more than 10%.</p><p>This is the psychology of suicide prevention which we need to understand and harness. Break it down into bite size chunks. Eat the elephant one bite at a time. Take each component part of the whole system and develop highly practical actions with those who would be responsible for taking those actions, in order to get the commitment that involvement brings.</p><p>It’s another reason why ‘The Priority Trap’ is so pernicious because the practical action plans are only encouraged and developed in a limited number of ‘priority areas’ for ‘priority groups’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e0tCbyZ8IwzRaWh3X93fJQ.png" /></figure><p>One significant concern I have with the above content is in relation to the line “<em>Action to prevent suicide and self-harm is needed across the criminal justice system</em>” — so far, so good — “<em>in police custody, in prison services for those on remand or serving a sentence, in probation, and for all those on release</em>”.</p><p>No mention at all of another huge source of distress and pain in the criminal justice system which is another driver of self-harm and suicide — its insensitive administrative incompetence!</p><p>I’ll highlight just two examples here.</p><p>Firstly, I have a family member who works in the courts trying to support witnesses as they give evidence. They of course provide emotional and psychological support independent of the case or circumstances, and don’t talk about the content of the court case to avoid any influence on the case.</p><p>What frequently happens is that it will be a really difficult case involving child sexual abuse or domestic violence, the trial has been delayed for months if not years, the witness finally gets a trial date, they make the physical arrangements for travel and accommodation, arrange time off work, and start preparing emotionally and psychologically…and then, a day or two before the due date, they’re told ‘the trial has been postponed’ and/or ‘it’s been moved to another court, in another jurisdiction’.</p><p>And the witness has to go through all this again, often twice or three times. There’s rarely an apology. There’s little or no support for these vulnerable people who’ve been further overloaded and distressed ‘by the system’.</p><p>Secondly, jurors, and I’ve experienced this personally.</p><p>Called for jury service as ‘ordinary, everyday citizens’, the jurors are thrust into some horrific cases, including child sexual abuse, domestic violence, exposure to harmful materials, and extreme cases like the Lucy Letby trial, listening to testimony week after week about the murder of babies.</p><p>In some jurisdictions, there’s some reasonable support for jurors as they prepare for and go through the trial, although not always, but there’s little or nothing after the trial.</p><p>Some of these experiences as a juror are life-changing and highly traumatising, and yet jurors are expected, at the end of the trial, to ‘go back to their normal lives’.</p><p>Their lives have just been changed forever. There’s no ‘normal’ any more. These people need access to counselling for the rest of their lives!</p><p>There should be mandatory access to counselling, as we’ve advocated for in our petition to parliament for a Suicide Prevention Act.</p><p><strong>Autistic People</strong></p><p>As with all of the ‘priority groups’ in this latest National Strategy, it’s great to see acknowledgement of the issues and potential steps that can be taken to reduce the number of suicides among autistic people, but the way the National Strategy process does this raises concerns.</p><p>Of course, there’s the problem of ‘The Priority Trap’, the biases, the ‘winners and losers’ approach that means autistic people are one of the ‘winners’ this time but there are many more non-prioritised groups who are ‘losers’ in the 2023 competition, including other neurodivergent groups. other than autistic people.</p><p>It’s interesting that this section begins with “<em>Evidence suggests autistic people, including autistic children and young people, may be at a higher risk of dying by suicide compared with those who are not autistic</em>”.</p><p>Note the cautious, non-committal language — “<em>may be at a higher risk</em>”.</p><p>At recent conferences I’ve attended, and in recent conversations with autistic people and advocates for autistic people, I’ve seen and heard suggestions that there’s a considerably higher suicide risk among autistic people and that at least 1 in 10 suicides could be autistic people.</p><p>Caution is understandable, not wanting to put out inaccurate data; and those involved in the National Strategy process tend to have a particular interest in data quality, with some harsh critics even going further, based on what they’ve observed, and saying ‘they’re more interested in data quality and accuracy than in actually reducing the number of suicides’!</p><p>But from a ‘dynamics of change’ perspective, until the scale of the problem is acknowledged, the <strong>Push</strong> factor for change, potential transformational change, is being constrained.</p><p>It’s also another example of data that’s been absent, ie there’s been a bias against autistic people in past National Strategies because the data and evidence wasn’t there, and wasn’t being collected, which then highlights the fact there are other biases still in place because of other gaps in the data and evidence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*44KoQ93wcWrKRHjch6SWfQ.png" /></figure><p>Also, many of the advocates I’ve spoken with have been very keen to emphasise the danger of just focusing on autistic people and ‘seeing autistic people as the problem’ and then trying to provide autistic people with support and not seeing ‘society as the problem’ in terms of stigma and stereotypical attitudes, lack of understanding, bullying, prejudice, etc.</p><p>There’s a tendency for National Strategy processes like this to focus, first, on the ‘health issues’ of autistic people then, second, on the education needs of autistic people, only then widening out into other issues that autistic people have and need support for, with ‘changing society’s awareness, knowledge, understanding, attitudes and behaviours’ coming a long way down the list, if it appears at all, even though this might be the solution to a lot of the issues autistic people and their families face.</p><p><strong>New Mothers. New Fathers?</strong></p><p>It’s good to see a spotlight on ‘new mothers’ in this new National Strategy but the obvious next question is ‘what about new fathers?’.</p><p>Again, what seems to be happening here is another case of the ‘data and evidence bias’. The available data, and emerging evidence, suggests a heightened suicide risk among ‘new mothers’ (and pregnant women), and so this becomes a ‘priority group’ in the National Strategy — another ‘winner’ in the competition — whilst other groups are competition ‘losers’, including groups like menopausal women, new fathers, and perhaps some more specific groups such as parents who’ve experienced a miscarriage?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aC-9m1tVi6Hg9McYj8JCeg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Financial Difficulty and Economic Adversity</strong></p><p>Having a focus on “<em>financial difficulty and economic adversity</em>” is another welcome development, and getting the excellent charity, Money &amp; Mental Health involved in the National Suicide Prevention Advisory Group is good:</p><p><a href="https://www.moneyandmentalhealth.org/">Money and Mental Health - a charity founded by Martin Lewis</a></p><p>But it’s disappointing it’s taken so long to have this focus. It seems to have taken a wider impact of the recent cost-of-living crisis on people who are working as well as those not working, to finally make this a ‘priority group’.</p><p>The National Strategy continues to give little confidence that the issues facing people losing their jobs are well understood with appropriate and effective support being forthcoming.</p><p>Experiences of losing a job — including unexpected and unwanted redundancy, unfair dismissal, an entire company unexpectedly going under — can be absolutely devastating.</p><p>And the lack of support and poor treatment for those losing their jobs, who also then can experience problems with housing, relationships, mobility, access to their children, deteriorating mental health…can be fatal.</p><p>It’s hard for people living in poverty, and people who experience long-term unemployment, although many of these people learn to cope and survive with levels of resilience most would find challenging to even imagine.</p><p>Often the highest suicide risk is among those who’ve never lived in poverty, never experienced unemployment before, never had to claim benefits, and certainly never had to rely on food banks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zZ146qhedmtuE0kRaymawA.png" /></figure><p>Many of those who lose their jobs go from a relatively good salary or wage to ‘the breadline’ and, if they don’t have access to significant levels of savings, they’re in deep trouble.</p><p>Many of those who lose their jobs these days also lose the access they had to relatively good workplace wellbeing programmes, EAP, counselling, and find themselves in a position with no access to any such support.</p><p>Many cope for 2–3 months, eg if there’s a redundancy payout or ‘outplacement package’ which includes continued access to workplace wellbeing support for up to 3 months on exiting a business, or there are some savings to draw from, but then the suicide risk grows in months 4–5 if they don’t get another job.</p><p>The ‘financial difficulty and economic adversity’ content in this latest National Strategy doesn’t appear to cover the kinds of issues that quickly emerge in any qualitative or ethnographic research. This may be due to the tendency to focus on quantitative analysis of available data sets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UdDrU0LZJwjTTIDWOjSdug.png" /></figure><p>One of the least reassuring aspects of the National Strategy is the section on what DWP will do for its part in trying to reduce the numbers of suicides.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aR2MK5OG2buITdz02LjB6g.png" /></figure><p>Just after I read this, I spoke at a suicide prevention conference where I parodied this proposal by saying “<em>because of course when someone has lost their job and had to experience the pain and humiliation of dealing with DWP services, and have to fight to get benefits and support they should be seamlessly entitled to, and are shamed and stigmatised and treated as non-humans, and they’re made to jump through demeaning hoops, and they find themselves on a decline into hopelessness and entrapment, and feel like it’s no longer worth living…the first thing they’re going to do is call the DWP helpline and say they’re having thoughts of suicide</em>”!</p><p>Yes, it is ridiculous isn’t it?! I’m afraid I tend to spiral into cynicism where DWP is concerned, even though I know some lovely individual human beings who work within their inhumane systems.</p><p>If DWP’s contribution to the National Strategy is largely waiting for people to call its helplines and disclose their suicidal thinking or planning, we’re not going to significantly reduce the estimated 500 suicides per year among unemployed (or underemployed) people.</p><p>Of course, I applaud efforts to have mandatory training for all front-line staff so they’re better able to spot signs and signpost. In terms of progress since the previous National Strategy, however, this does smack of ‘slightly more advanced lip service’.</p><p><strong>Gambling and Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>When I lived and worked in Australia, I did a lot of research into gambling and the devastation it causes, and I helped to devise services and support, and also devise campaigns to try and encourage people to seek support, including one campaign that had to be pulled because it was “<em>too successful</em>” in getting take up of counselling!</p><p>In the course of my research, I saw and heard some horrific ‘stories’ about the devastating impact of gambling and how the betting companies create and sustain addiction, so this is an especially sensitive subject for me.</p><p>Once again, I welcome the focus on gambling-related suicide in the latest National Suicide Prevention Strategy, and I applaud the brilliant work of charities like Gambling with Lives to get this issue on the national agenda.</p><p><a href="https://www.gamblingwithlives.org/">Gambling with Lives | Homepage</a></p><p>And, of course, I’m once again conscious of the ‘winners and losers’ model of the National Strategy process so as I see gambling-related suicides emerging as one of the ‘winners’ this time, largely due to the excellent advocacy of those who’ve been impacted, and I also think about the ‘losers’ in this national competition.</p><p>Once again, we read in this National Strategy document “<em>There is increasing evidence</em>…” around gambling-related suicide, despite the fact that the ‘evidence’ has been there for decades for anyone who wanted to look at it.</p><p>What they mean of course is their kind of evidence, ie some quantitative data brought to their attention showing a (potential) statistical correlation, possibly a causal relationship, between gambling addiction and suicides.</p><p>This is ‘evidence’ in the eyes of the suicide prevention establishment. Case studies of preventable suicides among people in the grip of gambling addiction back up the statistics, but are not sufficient to stimulate action.</p><p>Thankfully, this is starting to change but there’s still an emphasis on having ‘robust quantitative data’ and this is problematic when the absolute numbers might be ‘relatively small’ so not conducive to the number-crunching model, and where there’s not outrage at every single suicide death caused by betting companies feeding addiction, and when it needs an organised lobby group — a tiny ‘lobby group’ compared with the vast power and resources of the betting companies’ lobby — to get action.</p><p>It’s also disturbing that this opening sentence specifies “<em>younger people</em>”, ie “<em>increasing evidence of the relationship between harmful gambling and suicide in younger people</em>”. This problem is not just being experienced by younger people and it doesn’t take long to get out there and see that!</p><p>Hopefully, with advocates highlighting the issues around gambling-related suicides now having ‘a seat at the table’, these wider issues will be aired.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZerAU8Qlfp9c6EOZRy6ytw.png" /></figure><p>So, there are some signs and sources of hope, but such a long way to go when there’s such a power imbalance with the betting companies having so much power to do harm, and a weak response to calls for a total ban on betting companies’ advertising just like we have for smoking.</p><p>Also, once again, this is a highly political issue in many respects, eg the emphasis on ‘personal responsibility’ with the language being about ‘the problem gambler’ and getting ‘gambling addicts’ to ‘reach out’, and trying to help ‘people with a gambling problem’ and not focusing on the system and the betting companies that create and feed destructive addiction.</p><p><strong>Domestic Abuse and Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>Domestic abuse is another example of an issue we’ve known much about for many years with informal and anecdotal information, plus some small-scale qualitative research, showing a relationship between domestic abuse and suicide (risk) but it’s taken some more robust quantitative research and analysis to get this issue to the ‘top table’ and into the National Strategy.</p><p>Well done to Tim Woodhouse and the Kent &amp; Medway team who’ve brought forward the research and brought this issue to national attention.</p><p><a href="https://www.local.gov.uk/case-studies/kent-and-medway-highlighting-relationship-between-domestic-abuse-and-suicide">Kent and Medway: Highlighting the relationship between domestic abuse and suicide</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cZKkRO0VtQjbBJBKsG58cg.png" /></figure><p>It’s also another example of the dangers of ‘the Priority Trap’ and ‘The Top Down Trap’, ie ‘no (quant) data, no priority, no action’ and then the tendency to take an issue proven to be a particular driver of suicide or contributory factor in suicides in one area (Kent &amp; Medway in this case) and advocating for every area to prioritise this, via ‘aligning with National Strategy priorities’ even though domestic abuse or domestic violence may not be a key issue or risk factor in other areas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bfW-VEUFcEOQuk49RffjPA.png" /></figure><p>The fact that domestic abuse has now been given ‘priority status’ in the National Strategy means that it will now be given more prominence in more areas, and it will have more research and analysis around it, which will make it more likely to be a priority in more local suicide prevention strategies and plans…and so it goes on.</p><p>All good for tackling issues around domestic abuse, but not so good for all the other issues/groups not prioritised in the latest National Strategy.</p><p><strong>Limiting Access to (Lethal) Means of Suicide</strong></p><p>I recall a presentation by Professor Jane Pirkis of the University of Melbourne where she’d carried out a meta analysis of initiatives to reduce the numbers of suicides in various places around the world, and by far the most effective way of reducing the numbers of suicides was limiting access to the means of suicide, especially limiting access to lethal means.</p><p>It makes sense doesn’t it? Of course, we must have early intervention and upstream prevention to minimise the number of people even getting as far as making a suicide attempt but, sadly, people will get this far, and there’s much we can do to stop suicide plans and attempts becoming deaths.</p><p>So, it’s right that this appears in the National Strategy, although it could go much further.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ta3bM-WZ8qIKc1X0-Wauyg.png" /></figure><p>In the media rounds when the National Strategy was released on 11 September, the Minister made several references to “<em>emerging methods</em>” and more specifically “<em>places online where people can freely buy lethal drugs</em>”.</p><p>This development is extremely worrying, of course, although there was an element here of the Minister ‘playing to the gallery’ because this was a high profile news story at the time the National Strategy was published.</p><p>When this topic was discussed in various forums after the National Strategy was released, it was also another example of the ‘top down mentality’ when there were suggestions that the Department for Education could inform schools about ‘emerging methods’ of suicide or self-harm risk.</p><p>In reality, many schools will be aware of these emerging methods and harmful sites long before DfE does! But, yes, everyone should share relevant information and guidance.</p><p>And this is a DfE remember that is yet to agree that we need suicide education in schools as part of the curriculum!</p><p>Maybe they should be committing to the principle, and developing specific proposals for covering online access to medication in the content.</p><p>I can hear the panicked cries already of ‘we wouldn’t want to put the idea into kids’ heads’, which is partly code for ‘we don’t want to be held liable’ , and which is not an ‘evidence-based reaction’ as, firstly, kids already know about this stuff anyway — what they don’t have is the education around it — and, secondly, there’s lots of research evidence that tells us you don’t make a healthy person suicidal by talking about suicide, you just help people who are suicidal, and need help, to get help.</p><p>Of course there are risks with ‘prompting experimentation’ but that’s another good reason why this needs proactive education to prevent suicides rather than a reactive response after a suicide when it’s too late.</p><p>Another long-standing issue which is now, thankfully, getting more attention is “<em>frequently used locations</em>” — what the public at large and media still often refer to as “<em>suicide hotspots</em>” but that language is regarded as unhelpful, possibly harmful, so we usually refer to ‘frequently used locations’ or some call them ‘high risk locations’.</p><p>I’ve had a conversation recently with the CEO of a high profile bridge and we talked about how we know what measures are needed to significantly reduce the numbers of suicides and we know how much these measures would cost but no-one is prepared to invest the necessary resources even though we know there’d be a high financial return on that investment as well as the reduction in human pain and suffering.</p><p>Unfortunately, ‘the system’ works against such suicide prevention activity, including the National Strategy process which, in its current form, is not going to generate the millions of pounds needed to make these types of high risk locations ‘suicide safer’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lJeTYjwsV8UQu_UrEGpFMw.png" /></figure><p>This final paragraph above is another weak offering. “<em>We would encourage those with a role in the planning system to consider…</em>”?!</p><p>It doesn’t give us confidence, does it? Or much hope of action.</p><p>We should be demanding, and facilitating, a full-scale review of planning guidelines and the Building Regulations from a ‘suicide safer’ perspective!</p><p>And there’s also much scope for utilising ‘Tech for Good’ and ‘Digital Life Saving’ and ‘Tracking for Life’ technology to have better ‘digital-human systems’ working to prevent suicides in or near high risk locations.</p><p>Based on my own research and listening to people with lived experience of suicide, those reaching the point where they’re following through on their suicide plans have their smartphone with them and have it switched on. They often send a ‘final message’ or ‘do a final post’ on social media.</p><p>I’ve interviewed people who’ve lived through a suicide attempt — most of whom, by the way, don’t like the term ‘suicide survivor’, emphasising the importance of being sensitive to the language we use — and they’ve told me “<em>I decided to put a post on [social media platform(s) of choice] and said to myself ‘if I don’t get a reply to this message, I’m going through with it’…</em>”.</p><p>It was because of research like this that we developed the concept of ‘Digital Life Saving’ and why I took to the stage at TEDxSydney 2014 to urge everyone in the audience to develop initiatives to quickly identify people in danger from their publicly available social media posts to be able to instantly respond to them.</p><p>It’s sad there’s been so little progress in this field in the past 10 years. The main advances have been in improving search engines, improving advice via virtual assistants, and intercepts, including the fantastic browser-based intercept tool developed by Alice Hendy and her R;pple team:</p><p><a href="https://www.ripplesuicideprevention.com/">Home - R;pple</a></p><p>So much more could be done. And rather than have positive, enthusiastic, creative support for these types of initiatives through processes like the National Strategy, there seems to be resistance, or perhaps just lack of awareness and education around what’s possible?</p><p>I noticed this line in the National Strategy: “<em>The use of AI in predictive tools or in real-time conversations with individuals would not be appropriate</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uxPHUevbORQcKyUihfJujQ.png" /></figure><p>Why not? Why hold development back? Why slow the whole process of technological development and our capacity for suicide prevention to the pace that academics &amp; government policymakers work at? Why not engage in partnerships right now to develop capabilities and learn as we go?</p><p>As it happens, ‘the use of predictive tools in real-time conversations’ is happening anyway so a Canute-style response from the National Strategy is not helpful and smacks of arrogance as well as possibly ignorance.</p><p>‘Tracking for Life’ apps have enormous potential, eg in tracking people — with their advance, informed permission — who’ve been discharged from hospital to help ensure they get home safely, including pinging (nominated contacts or emergency services) if they go near ‘frequently used locations’.</p><p>I’ve had little or no joy from ‘the establishment’ with all these ideas for reducing the numbers of suicides via ‘Tech for Good’ solutions but, in contrast, a very positive response from the oft-demonised ‘private sector’!</p><p>The new, privately-funded iTalk app, initially designed for, and funded by, the Construction sector, will incorporate some of these ‘Tracking for Life’ and ‘Digital Life Saving’ concepts and turn them into practical functionality. The iTalk team has the will and the way!</p><p><strong>Bereavement Support for Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>This is another case of a positive development which needs to go further, deeper and wider; which needs to acknowledge inherent biases; and which illustrates the flaws in the National Strategy process as well as the benefits.</p><p>We’ve known for decades that loss and grief and trauma, and especially traumatic loss, has a massive adverse impact on people, which can increase their suicide risk. I personally experienced this after my dad died in 2010.</p><p>But formal, structured research around the impact of something like bereavement, especially quantitative research and analysis, is rare, so it’s struggled to get on the agenda for things like the National Strategy, because that’s the ‘system’ the National Strategy operates within…</p><p>…reacting to available data rather than being proactive; tending to react to quantitative data rather than qualitative insights; prompting, supporting and encouraging particular types of research into priority groups or priority actions or priority risk factors whilst discriminating against other groups/actions/factors; reacting to organised ‘lobby groups’, charities, advocates, campaigners putting forward a particular case, especially if they have ‘the right kind of data’, whilst neglecting other sources or factors causing or contributing to suicide.</p><p>Note that this section of the National Strategy begins with a very clear and specific statement “<em>Evidence suggests family, friends and acquaintances who are bereaved by suicide may have a risk of dying by suicide that is up to 3 times higher than the general population</em>”, with the usual get-out clause “<em>may</em>”.</p><p>Also note that no specific research sources are offered to support this statement. I’m not questioning the statement but it’s rather incongruous that those responsible for the National Strategy make such a fuss about having ‘data &amp; evidence’ before anything goes into the National Strategy as one of its priorities, and yet no research references for this statement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qC07WrcMW0VOXSNMHuA_bg.png" /></figure><p>I’ve looked into this subject via the referenced publications and websites that quote statistics like this, which also often include a statement about those bereaved by suicide being more likely to die by suicide than those bereaved by other means, so-called ‘natural causes’.</p><p>There seems to be one piece of research that has fuelled acres of coverage:</p><p><a href="https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/6/1/e009948">https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/6/1/e009948</a></p><p>It’s an interesting study, and it does indeed show that those in the sample were more likely to die by suicide if they’d been bereaved by suicide, and there’s no doubt that those who’ve lost someone to suicide should have ‘wrap around care &amp; support’ and that ongoing support and future (health) interventions should take into account the family history of suicide, just as (health) professionals would ask about family history of cancer or diabetes.</p><p>However, please note that this is just one survey, carried out in 2010, among students and staff at UK universities, aged 18–40.</p><p>As any professional researcher will attest, we should exercise caution because it’s only one study, more than 10 years old, pre-COVID19, among a very specific audience and what’s effectively ‘a convenience sample’ of students and staff — as many academic research studies are as it’s easier and cheaper to ‘keep it on campus’ — and among a specific age range.</p><p>This study could be replicated among the same audience in 2023 — now including those losing people to COVID19 — or among a different group of 18–40 year olds, or a sample of 18–80 year olds…and get a different result.</p><p>Again let me be clear, I’m not doubting that those bereaved by suicide are more likely to die by suicide themselves, and I want to see the fullest possible support for those bereaved by suicide.</p><p>But I’m highlighting bias/discrimination creeping in to these processes.</p><p>Some people and organisations advocating for being a priority in the National Strategy will be told they don’t have a strong case, not enough data or evidence, and they need to go away to gather more data and evidence.</p><p>Meanwhile, another case is being accepted on the strength of one or two research studies that are often quoted without highlighting their limitations, combined with having someone on the Advisory Group putting this particular case, often from ‘case studies’ rather than more robust quantitative data, in contradiction to practice for other groups or issues.</p><p>Most importantly, loss and grief is not a competition. We shouldn’t be setting out to argue that bereavement by suicide is a special case. It’s just become a special case because of ‘the bubble effect’.</p><p>Those working in suicide prevention, those bereaved by suicide, and those responsible for putting the National Suicide Prevention Strategy together consider themselves as working ‘in suicide prevention’ and their primary interest is suicide &amp; suicide prevention, not bereavement more widely or other specific forms of bereavement, eg by cancer, stroke, COVID19, etc.</p><p>When I did my counselling training and qualifications, and I did an Advanced Study Major in Loss &amp; Grief, and I carried out research into loss, grief, trauma, and traumatic loss, I found that people bereaved by any means were at a higher suicide risk, and the group with the highest suicide risk after bereavement was older men losing their lifelong partner where the risks were high regardless of how their wife had died.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qC07WrcMW0VOXSNMHuA_bg.png" /></figure><p>So when I read in the National Strategy “<em>there is widespread recognition that improving bereavement support is an important goal in its own right, and bereavement is a risk factor for suicide among family, friends and acquaintances</em>”, I think ‘yes, important to get that support around people bereaved by suicide…and important to get that support around all people who are bereaved’.</p><p>As Chukes Maxwell says “<em>there’s no hierarchy in suffering</em>”, and as I’ve found myself saying a lot recently “<em>bereavement is not a competition</em>”.</p><p>We mustn’t assume that a person might or might not be struggling after a bereavement, or might be struggling more or less than someone else, just as we mustn’t make assumptions about or discriminate against anyone in suicidal crisis, just try to have personalised safety plans for everyone.</p><p>We should be equally concerned about everyone at risk or in danger.</p><p>It’s part of the ‘at risk group’ mentality that makes people go looking first for a ‘group at risk’ then ‘individuals in danger’ within the group they’ve prioritised, which means two forms of bias or discrimination — first against other groups and everyone in those groups then, second, against everyone in their prioritised group they’ve created a hierarchy or risk profile for.</p><p>An alternative approach is to focus, first and foremost, on individuals in danger not groups at risk, and try to support everyone via a co-ordinated approach where ‘everyone is a priority for someone’, and not fall into ‘The Priority Trap’ and the other traps that come with beginning and ending your processes with “<em>there are limited resources…there’s only so much we can do…we have to set priorities and allocate scarce resources…not everyone can be a priority…</em>” which is effectively saying “<em>there have to be winners and losers</em>”.</p><p>It doesn’t have to be like this!</p><p><strong>Suicide Can Affect Anyone and Everyone Can Help Prevent Suicides</strong></p><p>I’ve commented on this earlier in this dissertation, so just a quick recap.</p><p>The key message to get across to everyone is a two part message. Firstly, “<em>suicide can affect anyone</em>”. Secondly “<em>everyone can help prevent suicides</em>”.</p><p>These two statements have been well researched and road-tested.</p><p>They get attention. They have impact, They’re inclusive, in terms of being embraced by almost everyone. And they don’t push people away.</p><p>So, we should be using such language in our advocacy, in our campaigns, in all our communications around suicide and suicide prevention, and in the National Suicide Prevention Strategy.</p><p>Another ‘no brainer’!</p><p>Too often though, we see language that isn’t so inclusive or ‘positive impact assured’, even though those using it are trying to achieve the same result.</p><p>Two key examples of this are “<em>suicide is everyone’s business</em>” and, especially, “<em>suicide is everyone’s responsibility</em>”.</p><p>Most people don’t think suicide is their business or their responsibility. When they hear these messages, they can be puzzled, offended, distressed, annoyed…especially being told it’s their responsibility which sounds very preachy and finger-wagging, so it has the opposite effect to that intended.</p><p>All of the measures set out below can be communicated to the public without us needing to explicitly use language like ‘everyone’s business’ or ‘everyone’s responsibility’.</p><p>No point pushing people away with such language, especially when we can pull them in to the conversation with the more inclusive and engaging “<em>Anyone can be affected by suicide, and everyone can help prevent suicides</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mKIq7vq2z0LEE4GSPNindg.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Role of Employers, Sectors, Professions, and Communities at Work</strong></p><p>In our report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’, we emphasise the role that ‘the workplace’ has in suicide prevention and this includes industries, sectors, and professions as well as individual employers and individual workplaces or — to reflect the flexible way people work these days plus changing thinking about the nature of workplaces — what we would call ‘communities at work’ because that’s what they should be ideally to help support each other, including when someone is struggling or in crisis, including when a whole team or business is struggling or in crisis.</p><p>In the National Suicide Prevention Strategy, the emphasis is on individual employers for whatever reason, with a note below “<em>ONS will publish analysis in 2023 to provide updated information about suicide rates across different occupations, which will inform further evidence-based action</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x0FP-MbTBB96gfBVl6bdEw.png" /></figure><p>This is consistent, of course, with the Government’s National Strategy process which is centred on quantitative data and evidence, analysis of patterns and trends, identifying ‘risk groups’, setting priorities, and focusing attention on the agreed ‘priority groups’ or ‘risk factors’…</p><p>…creating and sustaining that competition for priority status with winners and losers in the competition the Government’s National Strategy process has constructed.</p><p>Despite the fact we already know that almost 1 in 10 suicides are among people in the Construction sector, there’s no explicit mention of this in the National Suicide Prevention Strategy or any strategy or plan to work with the Construction sector to get these numbers down. Why is this?</p><p><strong>Call to Action?!</strong></p><p>Most of the people I’ve spoken with who work in suicide prevention and who’ve read the National Strategy document have said they’re not inspired by it, and it doesn’t come across as an engaging ‘call to action’. I’d agree.</p><p>So it was interesting to get to this section at the very end of the document using those very words.</p><p>For a call to action to be more than just words, to energise people and get them wanting to take action, it must engage their hearts and minds and inspire them with hope and with confidence, and with a belief that ‘this is going to make a difference’.</p><p>This National Strategy fails to do that, partly due to its very limited <strong>Engagement &amp; Involvement</strong> of key stakeholders, especially the wider community of people with lived or living experiences of suicide; partly due to the uninspiring content and language; partly due to the lack of a compelling vision so lack of the important <strong>Pull</strong> factor in <strong>The 3 Key Dynamics of Change</strong> model; and partly due to the lack of a <strong>Push</strong> factor…</p><p>…ie, the absence of a narrative which says, prominently and frequently, “<em>this level of (5-6,000+) deaths we’ve had in England/UK for the past 15 years is totally unacceptable, and largely preventable, so we’re going to aim to get these numbers on a long-term downward trend, towards zero</em>”.</p><p>In a so-called civilised society, we should expect nothing less.</p><p>In the Zero Suicide Society vision we’ve mapped out in our report ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’, we do expect nothing less, and we set out the practical actions that will get us there.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uafLw7oprd53YtP-oAz74g.png" /></figure><p>It’s also interesting to read this line at the end “<em>we have published a summary of actions alongside the strategy, setting out clearly where action will happen, by who and when</em>”.</p><p>Most of those I’ve sought feedback from so far don’t think this is clearly the case. Indeed, they say they’ve been told by DHSC and members of the National Suicide Prevention Strategy Advisory Group that “<em>developing action plans is actually the next phase</em>”.</p><p>Furthermore, I’ve personally been told by people directly involved in the National Strategy process that “<em>we’re working on action plans which will have targets</em>”. I look forward to seeing these and doing some maths!</p><p>Last but not least, when I read a document, I’m always conscious that it’s easy to comment on what’s there but it’s just as important to see what’s not there; and, throughout this critique, I’ve tried to highlight the gaps.</p><p>In this final Call to Action section, it refers to bringing together “<em>national and local government, the health service and the VCSE sectors</em>”.</p><p>What about ‘the private sector’? What about commercial sectors and organisations who are a big part of the problem and potentially a big part of the solution — from reducing suicides among their workforce to providing the technological innovation that could be a breakthrough in suicide prevention?</p><p>It’s often the case that ‘the private sector’ is excluded from processes like the National Strategy, eg due to the prejudice of ‘public good, private bad’, due to the ‘seats around the table with representatives’ mentality that then finds it hard to justify having just 1 or 2 ‘representatives’ from something as broad and diverse and little understood as ‘the private sector’, and/or due to the hierarchical culture that believes ‘we regulate the private sector, we’re not equal partners with them’.</p><p>But we are equal partners when it comes to suicide prevention. To get the numbers of suicides down, towards zero, we have to be all be equal partners in a truly collaborative partnership around our common goals.</p><p><strong>Mandatory Requirement: the Zero Suicide in Healthcare Framework</strong></p><p>When I was working in suicide prevention in Australia, in the period 2013–2019, I worked closely with Sue Murray who was the highly successful and popular CEO of Suicide Prevention Australia who then founded the Zero Suicide Institute of Australasia.</p><p>Sue &amp; I were worried about the lack of progress in getting the suicide numbers down, and decided to focus more on the growing ‘Zero Suicide’ movement around the world, with cases of considerable reductions in the numbers of suicides where the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ framework had been applied — 50%, 60%, 70%+ reductions.</p><p>I took a broader community perspective. Sue zeroed in (pun intended!) on the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ model, initially developed in the US, in Detroit, and developed it for Australia’s health system:</p><p><a href="https://lifeinmind.org.au/suicide-prevention/collaborations/zero-suicide-healthcare-framework">https://lifeinmind.org.au/suicide-prevention/collaborations/zero-suicide-healthcare-framework</a></p><p>When we ask people in our network, ie people who work in suicide prevention and people with lived experience who, like me and Steve Phillip, have made it their life mission to get the numbers of suicides on a downward trend towards zero, “<em>what will get those numbers down?</em>”…</p><p>…we regularly hear “<em>well, here’s another ‘no brainer’ — mandatory roll out of the proven evidence-based ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare Framework’ across the NHS and all healthcare organisations, so they can all individually work towards zero suicides in their Trust or healthcare organisation and we can collectively ‘move towards zero’ across the whole system and across the whole country</em>”.</p><p>Btw, I’m dedicating that previous ‘no brainer’ summary to Rob Shipley who is a tireless advocate for the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ framework and is currently implementing it in his Trust.</p><p>But I’ve scoured the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England, 2023–2028, I’ve read every word and re-read every word (I know, I’m a policy nerd, and among the 0.1% of the population who’ve read the document end-to-end!) and I can’t see anywhere “<em>Mandatory Implementation of the Zero Suicide in Healthcare Framework</em>”.</p><p>Why?</p><p>I’ve asked a few individuals privately and raised this question in some public forums. The responses I get tend to fall into two camps. One is people who don’t seem to actually know what the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ framework is, which is rather worrying if they’re responsible for developing the National Strategy. The other camp is those who clearly do know what the framework is but have chosen to reject it, which is odd.</p><p>In amongst the ignorance and prejudice, there are lots of ill-informed comments like “<em>we’re not going to get to zero suicides, there’ll always be suicides</em>”. In fact, the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ community of thinkers and practitioners make it clear that the Zero Suicide model &amp; framework is not just a numerical target and that it’s rare to be able to eliminate suicides in any sizeable system, but that it’s a philosophy and a framework for aiming high and getting the suicide numbers down as far as possible and keeping them down at the lowest possible level. Hence ‘a no brainer’!</p><p>Those who do know what the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ philosophy and framework are gave me some better informed responses — albeit tending to be out-of-date — including concern about whether the NHS is in a good enough place at the moment to absorb it, whether staff would embrace it given the pressures on them, and whether the necessary resources to start the process would be made available.</p><p>As a fully signed-up member of the ‘this is a no brainer’ club, I’d counter each of those objections, including the fact that it pays for itself, staff will embrace it with the right leadership, and it could well be exactly what the NHS needs right now because the ‘Zero Suicide in Healthcare’ model is not only a good practice approach for ‘continuous, systemic, action learning’ that can bring down the suicide numbers, it’s a transferable process with transferable benefits.</p><p><strong>Postscript: A Curious Message from the Government</strong></p><p>When the National Suicide Prevention Strategy for England for 2023–2028 was published on 11 September 2023, there was much disappointment in its apparent lack of ambition and some concern about the lack of a target for reducing the numbers of suicides. For some, it felt like ‘giving up’!</p><p>When the Minister, Maria Caulfield MP, did the media rounds on the day of release, she was trying to claim ambition where there was little or no evidence of ambition, as well as trying to claim considerable progress since 2012 when there was little evidence of progress, and no decline at all in the annual number of suicides over that period.</p><p>When questioned about the lack of a reduction target, she waffled and obfuscated and looked like a Minister not on top of her brief.</p><p>A very curious thing then happened on 27 September.</p><p>As someone who, in addition to launching our own petition, has signed previous petitions to parliament for measures to reduce suicides, I received this same email message twice from the Government, once because I’d signed the 3 Dads Walking petition for suicide education to be in the school curriculum, the one which got 170,000 signatures…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5W0SI9G6Crn21GJenEwLHQ.png" /></figure><p>…and one for The LEARN Network’s petition for a statutory duty of care for higher education students, which got 128,000 signatures.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l2Qg9FMZkBG081mW-Pqmiw.png" /></figure><p>Now, when I signed those petitions, I remember it said there’d be a formal written response to the petition proposals from the Government after 10,000 signatures, which I got, on both occasions, and I recall thinking how uninspiring those responses were.</p><p>I don’t recall signing up for communication from the Government about its National Suicide Prevention Strategy.</p><p>I can see how someone, in good faith, might think it relevant and might think we’d want to know that a new National Strategy had been published, despite the fact there were no further commitments in the document on either of these petition proposals.</p><p>It’s actually possible that the Government here is in breach of its GDPR duties because it does not have the explicit informed consent of those who, like me, signed these petitions and agreed only to receiving updates about these petitions and these petition proposals.</p><p>I then read the email message from the Government:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1viqQzxuUUlJ7cwbKwSloA.png" /></figure><p>I couldn’t believe my eyes when I got to the bit that says “<em>The strategy aims to half the number of suicides over the next five years</em>”.</p><p>After failing to commit to a reduction target when the NSPS 2023–2028 was first published on 11 September, and having tried to defend its decision to not have a reduction target in the Strategy, was the Government now saying it was aiming to reduce the suicide numbers by 50%?</p><p>It was unlikely they’d done a U-turn of course and, with no new money allocated to the new Strategy, unlikely that the Government would be able to achieve a 50% reduction in the suicide numbers.</p><p>So was this cock-up or conspiracy?</p><p>Was it an innocent ‘administrative error’ or a devious way of trying to send out what the Government thought would be a positive message about the Government’s new Suicide Prevention Strategy to the 200,000+ people who’d signed these petitions?</p><p>I suspected it probably was more likely to be cock-up than conspiracy but, as well as posting publicly about this…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*usNDyrJEvk_hJ0ClnTSweA.png" /></figure><p>…I sent a private message to 100 people (working in suicide prevention), including 4 people I knew were involved in the National Strategy process.</p><p>Interestingly, I had a response from one person saying “<em>Obviously cock up — the fact it says ‘half’ the number of suicides rather than ‘halve’ the number tells us it’s an administrative error</em>”, and yet 80% of the responses I received said “<em>conspiracy</em>”, which is probably a reflection of the lack of trust people have in this current Government.</p><p>I initially brushed it off as still probably an ‘administrative error’ but had lingering concerns about the fact that any message had been sent, the unauthorised nature of the message, and the potential harm from misinformation or spin.</p><p>Then, as I now finish off writing this piece more than 2 months after these email messages were sent, I’m thinking “<em>surely, if it was an administrative error and it got one of the most important pieces of content in the entire Strategy fundamentally wrong, there’d be an apology and a correction issued?</em>”.</p><p>But, of course, there’s been no apology, and no correction.</p><p>Sadly, incompetence, if that’s what it was, doesn’t breed confidence.</p><p>And, if was a deliberate political act, that’s giving us even less confidence that this Government is remotely interested in minimising suicides.</p><p>Time to round-up and round off…and do what we do at The Jordan Legacy and across our Zero Suicide Society community…finish on a note of hope!</p><p><strong>Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society — What We Must Do!</strong></p><p>In Jan 2023, The Jordan Legacy defined a ‘Zero Suicide Society’ as “<em>a society that is willing and able to do all it can to prevent all preventable suicides</em>”.</p><p>By having everyday conversations around this definition, as well as carrying out semi-structured action research around this definition, we’ve been able to flesh out in detail what a ‘Zero Suicide Society’ looks like and the practical actions that will get us there.</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-edition-2-of-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - Edition 2 Of The Report | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p>We’ve applied, indeed embraced, the <strong>3 Key Dynamics of Change</strong> with the huge <strong>Pull</strong> effect from our highly motivating vision, our ongoing efforts to <strong>Involve</strong> — along with accepting that we need to do way more here — and the big <strong>Push</strong> effect from continuously communicating about the unacceptably &amp; needlessly high numbers of suicides…and all the reasons why we need to have high ambition and not settle for low ambition as the latest NSPS has.</p><p>As a final thought to take away with us, perhaps we should add that in a Zero Suicide Society we would all be willing and able to do all we can to <strong>Involve</strong>, to <strong>Pull</strong>, and to <strong>Push</strong> towards zero.</p><p>As a ‘change coach’, I was taught that anything not taking us towards achieving our goal is potentially a barrier to us achieving our goal.</p><p>As highlighted in this critique, there’s much in this National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2023–2028 that is not taking us towards our goal of getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, and which is clearly creating barriers to us achieving that goal.</p><p>Several of those who were involved in the process of devising the NSPS (who some would describe as ‘the privileged few’) told me that the discussions were very calm, considered, respectful, polite…and those with lived or living experiences of suicide who were invited often had a reputation for being calm, considered, respectful, polite…and everyone worked together very harmoniously with a great sense of ‘team spirit’.</p><p>It all sounds really nice doesn’t it? And I always try my best to be a calm, considered, respectful, polite, harmonious team player wherever I think we’re a team where everyone is fully committed to a shared goal of getting the suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero, and demonstrating they have the capability to do so.</p><p>If, however, this approach isn’t getting the numbers of suicides down, towards zero, and appears to be leading to ‘satisficing’, devising and agreeing on low ambition strategies and plans, and public communications that play down the problem, overclaim on progress, use language that lessens the impact of our <strong>3 Key Dynamics of Change</strong>, and seems to be leading to the ‘capture’ syndrome where those with high ambition get into bed with those who have low ambition and get ‘infected with low ambition’, perhaps we need to be a little less calm, polite or ‘groupthink harmonious’?</p><p>Maybe we need to show more passion? Maybe get a bit more angry about the lack of ambition, lack of progress, and apparent attempts (unintended consequences of a cosy approach?) to talk up any evidence of progress whilst talking down the size and scale of the problem we’re trying to solve?</p><p>We should always remain respectful and considered, and not make it personal as everyone is trying to help in their own way — even if there are unintended barriers &amp; harms — but not be too passive, especially as there’s so much we can to get the suicide numbers down, towards zero.</p><p>My own approach in these situations is to say at the beginning of a meeting, workshop or forum “<em>I’ll be a calm, considered, respectful, polite contributor to the discussion…but if, at any point, I see low ambition, overclaiming on progress, misrepresentation of data to fulfil personal or organisational agendas, unhelpful hype, or political spin, or anything that is a systemic barrier to us getting the numbers of suicides on a downward trend, towards zero, you might find me getting angry</em>”!</p><p>The warning upfront helps people to see that your (controlled) anger is coming from a good place!</p><p>Finally, maybe to get the suicide numbers on that downward trend, towards zero, we need to take inspiration from Howard Beale (although the ironic twist here is that Beale was ultimately being controlled by the faceless power brokers in charge of the Network!), remind ourselves — as citizens, taxpayers, and human beings — that 5–6,000 preventable suicide deaths every year is totally unacceptable, and we should shout from the rooftops “<em>I’m as mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore</em>”?!</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FZwMVMbmQBug%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DZwMVMbmQBug&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FZwMVMbmQBug%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4409a4c92caad7c9d356d85447d66dba/href">https://medium.com/media/4409a4c92caad7c9d356d85447d66dba/href</a></iframe><p><em>[ps — I know some people don’t approve of the word ‘mad’ but, as someone living with mental illness, I’m owning it, and think it’s use in terms of being ‘mad’ at the lack of progress in getting the suicide numbers down is highly appropriate!]</em></p><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles is a researcher, consultant, coach and counsellor who now specialises in suicide prevention and mental health.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul has lived with mental illness for 20 years, he’s experienced suicide loss multiple times — the first as far back as 1980, the most recent August 2020 — and has worked professionally in suicide prevention for more than 10 years in Australia and the UK.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul’s work in the UK these days is primarily with The Jordan Legacy, where he’s ‘Chief Facilitator, Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme’.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Paul’s mission is to see the Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme implemented, to move towards a Zero Suicide Society, and to get the UK suicide numbers on a downward trend, towards zero.</em></strong></p><p>If you want to support the work The Jordan Legacy does, you can donate via the website or you can make a donation specifically to support The Jordan Legacy’s action research project via this Just Giving page:</p><p><a href="https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/suicide-prevention-research-project?utm_term=8PNAG4gEx">Help raise £10000 to allow us to develop an important proactive suicide prevention action-research project to help us move towards a Zero Suicide Society.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40a4e4129496" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society — how far we have to go]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-how-far-we-have-to-go-cb1b8564adc0?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb1b8564adc0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-prevention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-awareness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[training]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Sep 2023 08:12:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-29T14:31:22.753Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society — how far we have to go</h3><h4>This report includes some of the latest data from The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research ‘Omnibus’ Survey which questions a nationally representative sample of 1500 adults (aged 16+) in the UK and is generating key data for us on suicide, suicide prevention and mental health twice a year; along with the ‘Zero Suicide Society’ actions The Jordan Legacy has highlighted to get the UK suicide numbers on a downward trend ‘towards zero’.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9u59LtuldujJnNtCQGXLZA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research (nationally representative samples of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>If you quote any of the results from this survey/article-report, please give your source as The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey, and link to this published summary to ensure accuracy and to avoid misrepresentation.</p><p>Given the subject matter, all those taking part in the survey are directed to sources of support. If you or anyone you know needs support, there are many options (and it’s important to know there are many options!), including via the Resources page on The Jordan Legacy website:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/help-resources/">Help &amp; Resources | Suicide Prevention | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>And, of course, this write-up is going to be covering the subject of suicide (along with the positive and hopeful subject of suicide prevention!) so if you find this triggering or distressing in any way, please seek support.</p><p>This report also summarises the context in which this survey and The Jordan Legacy’s action research project are being undertaken, all to help us reduce the suicide numbers and move us towards a ‘Zero Suicide Society’.</p><p>Future reports will focus on the core survey results, along with ‘deep dives’ into particular topics or perspectives covered by the survey, eg the next report will be a more in-depth feature on education &amp; training sources and their impact.</p><p>But here, publishing around World Suicide Prevention Day 2023, I’ve included a link to the report from the first survey MEL Research carried out as part of its partnership with The Jordan Legacy in Spring 2022 and summarised the amazing strides Steve Phillip and I have taken since (in Spring 2022, Steve and I were having an unpaid sabbatical helping to develop the concept, vision &amp; strategy for the Baton of Hope, before switching our focus back to The Jordan Legacy’s important work in Autumn 2022, when the second wave of our national tracking survey took place).</p><p><strong>Let’s Talk about Suicide!</strong></p><p>The very first ‘baseline’ survey (which had some insightful questions about ‘facts &amp; myths’ and societal attitudes towards suicide, suicide prevention, and mental health — worth looking at) was carried out in Spring 2022, and was reported (here on Medium) as “<strong><em>Let’s Talk about Suicide</em></strong>”:</p><p><a href="https://paulvittles.medium.com/lets-talk-about-suicide-35e4706f6bf7">Let’s Talk about Suicide</a></p><p>That first survey was also presented (by myself) at an online event — also entitled “<strong><em>Let’s Talk about Suicide</em></strong>” — hosted and facilitated by The Jordan Legacy, including a post-presentation panel discussion with experienced training professionals, Steve Carr and Tara Powell.</p><p>You can access the recording via this link:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/previous-the-jordan-legacy-events-including-recordings/">Previous The Jordan Legacy Events Including Recordings | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p><strong>Much has Happened, Much is Happening!</strong></p><p>Since that first survey and first survey report, much has happened.</p><p>Not only have there been two further waves of The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey (in Autumn 2022 and Spring 2023 — results coming up later in this report) but The Jordan Legacy has been busy with its conferences, events &amp; workshops; facilitated peer support sessions for Mental Health First Aiders; its fortnightly radio show — Jordan’s Space — which provides a platform for diverse ‘lived experience voices’ (and a great educational resource for learning about diverse lived experiences)…</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/jordans-space/">Jordan&#39;s Space | In The Media | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>…plus our advocacy &amp; campaigning; and our action research project.</p><p><strong>The ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ Action Research Report</strong></p><p>Indeed, the first output from that action research project was a report, co-authored by myself and Steve Phillip, entitled “<strong><em>Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society</em></strong>”, which was published on 11 July 2023:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - The Report | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>The significance of that date is that it would have been Jordan’s 38th Birthday, had he not ended his own life in December 2019…and Jordan of course is the reason why The Jordan Legacy exists — to honour Jordan’s life; to try and stop other people having to endure the pain of loss to suicide experienced by those who loved Jordan; and to get the suicide numbers on a downward trend ‘towards zero’ as a key part of Jordan’s legacy.</p><p>The significance of that report is that it’s having a huge impact around the country with many of those reading the report regarding it as a breakthrough for suicide prevention in the UK, notably by mapping out a detailed practical vision of what a ‘Zero Suicide Society’ looks like — going way beyond the initial definition Steve and I set out in January 2023 as “<em>a society that is willing and able to do all it can to prevent all preventable suicides</em>” — and including the practical actions we can all take to make a difference; actions communities and workplaces can take; and actions we need government to take.</p><p>The Jordan Legacy has held webinars to go through the report content and the ‘Zero Suicide Society’ vision. Here’s a recording:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4UxlbliuacI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4UxlbliuacI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4UxlbliuacI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e691d1e7fe4f147c9b90043eccf55ce3/href">https://medium.com/media/e691d1e7fe4f147c9b90043eccf55ce3/href</a></iframe><p>Btw, we have taken on board the huge quantity and fabulous quality of feedback on that initial report, and a 2nd Edition was published on 28 September, including an Executive Summary that, among other things, has a detailed exposition and explanation of the ‘Zero Suicide Society’ transformation model &amp; framework:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/moving-towards-a-zero-suicide-society-edition-2-of-the-report/">Moving Towards A Zero Suicide Society - Edition 2 Of The Report | The Jordan Legacy CIC</a></p><p><strong>Our Petition for a Suicide Prevention Act</strong></p><p>Those actions identified in our action research project which we need government to take to be able to ‘move towards zero’, including the ‘systems change’ and transformational change required, have also been put into a package of proposals for a Suicide Prevention Act, and a petition launched (target: 100,000 signatures — the number needed for a Parliamentary evidence hearing and debate — by 19 January 2024).</p><p>You can sign the petition here…</p><p><a href="https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/640961">Petition: Introduce a Suicide Prevention Act to seek to minimise suicides</a></p><p>…and please promote this link wherever you can to maximise the number of signatures. Even if we reach the 100,000 target, it would give us more clout if we had well beyond that number.</p><p>If you feel you need a bit more information before signing the petition, have a read of this short note here:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/2838-2/">A Suicide Prevention Act - Please Sign This Petition | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>And there’s also a 10-min briefing on the petition proposals — and the fascinating story of the petition’s journey from our initial proposals to the final published content — here:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBZF5ImKBeN4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBZF5ImKBeN4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href">https://medium.com/media/f4ff198ec33f53b90291fca8fbaedf6b/href</a></iframe><p><strong>A Note on ‘Zero’, ‘Zero Suicide’, and ‘Zero Suicide Society’</strong></p><p>Please note that a ‘Zero Suicide Society’ does not mean a utopian world where there are never any deaths by suicide. We know that despite the best efforts of loved ones, clinicians, and many people providing many different types of support, we still lose some people to suicide.</p><p>There are many sensitivities to take into account and different perspectives out there on what these terms mean, and that’s why The Jordan Legacy put out a clear statement on this in January 2023, including defining a ‘Zero Suicide Society’ as “<em>a society that is willing and able to do all it can to prevent all preventable suicides</em>”:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/believing-in-change-collaborating-for-change/">Believing In Change, Collaborating For Change | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p><strong>Most Suicides Are Preventable, So Let’s Prevent Most Suicides!</strong></p><p>What the evidence tells us though is that most suicides are preventable, so our goal must surely be to prevent most suicides…and do all we can to reduce the number of preventable deaths to as close to zero as possible.</p><p>It’s not easy to achieve that though. Suicides are often complex and messy and usually multi-faceted with lots of different contributory factors — it often being difficult to single out any particular causal factor.</p><p>And, of course, when we talk about ‘getting the numbers down’, these ‘numbers’ are actually human beings who’ve experienced lives, illness, circumstances that have led to them leaving this world (and I deliberately say ‘leaving’ not ‘wanting to leave’ because many of these people wouldn’t have felt they had a choice)…and each individual ‘case’ is unique with their own mix of mess and pain and hopelessness and sense of entrapment.</p><p>We describe much of this complexity in our ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ report, and cover it in our webinars, including the issues around mental health or mental illness and all of the other factors — from socio-economic factors to chronic physical illness — as well as the complexity involved in ‘moving towards zero’ including having continuous, systemic action learning (CSAL), lived experience involvement every step of the way, and an integrated, co-ordinated approach where “<em>everyone is a priority for someone</em>”…</p><p>…not falling into ‘The Priority Trap’ which is often a feature of government, National Strategies and many suicide prevention initiatives where the focus on setting priorities and developing plans around priorities means it’s a competition — not the truly collaborative approach we need — and a competition which, by definition, has ‘winners and losers’ which we simply cannot have when we value all lives equally…and want to drive the suicide numbers down towards zero, from the totally unacceptable level of 6,000+ deaths by suicide each year in the UK where, sadly, it has been for the past 15 years.</p><p>In our ‘Moving Towards a Zero Suicide Society’ report (and in our webinars), we also discuss barriers to getting the numbers down, like ‘The Priority Trap’ highlighted above, and the psychology of change in a field like suicide prevention, including the fact there is little belief at national level that we can ‘move towards zero’ but at local level there is often total belief we can get those numbers down — so, hey, let’s get all those ‘micro zeros’ adding up to a ‘macro zero’!</p><p><strong>The Role of Data and Evidence in Helping and Not Harming</strong></p><p>Some of the barriers to getting the suicide numbers down are data-related — not having (up-to-date, accurate) key data; not having real-time data (though this is now changing due to the long overdue implementation of Real Time Suicide Surveillance Systems); priorities in national strategies being set based on limited data or ‘emerging evidence’ (eg from one local area not many, or via ‘effective single issue campaigns as data’); new ideas that are potential life-savers not being pursued due to ‘lack of evidence’; and a resistance from ‘the establishment’ to embrace new forms of data and evidence, including the potential for Augmented Intelligence Systems for detection and early intervention to save lives.</p><p><strong>The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey — Patterns &amp; Trends</strong></p><p>One of the main reasons why The Jordan Legacy partnered with MEL Research — apart from the fact that MEL Research has been incredibly supportive and generous in trying to help us in our mission to move towards a Zero Suicide Society! — …</p><p>…is that we could see gaps in the data: key figures we need but didn’t have; lack of up-to-date figures; government sources and some of the big charities regularly quoting figures in their public statements or on their websites from ‘official surveys’ carried out in 2014 or even 2007 when this is clearly way out-of-date (and it says a lot about the low priority given to suicide prevention when key measures are not continuously monitored); and a lack of basic ‘tracking’ of key measures.</p><p>So, The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey was established — among a nationally representative sample of UK adults (aged 18+ for the baseline survey in Spring 2022, and aged 16+ for the two subsequent waves in Autumn 2022 and Spring 2023).</p><p><strong>Core Tracking Questions Plus Opportunity to Add ‘Topical Issues’</strong></p><p>There are a set of core questions asked on each wave of the survey so we can monitor trends as well as patterns in the data (subject to that very minor adjustment from Wave 1 to Wave 2, going from 18+ to 16+).</p><p>Then there is the opportunity to ask some different questions on each wave of the survey.</p><p>In the Wave 1 ‘Baseline’ Survey (see link through to “<strong><em>Let’s Talk about Suicide</em></strong>” at the very top of this piece), there were some questions covering ‘facts and myths’, including checking what % of the population believe some basic facts and common myths to be true or false (or ‘don’t know’ or ‘prefer not to say’), along with some questions around key (societal) attitudes on suicide and suicide prevention.</p><p>In Wave 2 (Autumn 2022), these ‘facts &amp; myths’ questions and the attitudes to suicide/SP questions were replaced with a question about training received or information sources used and a question about confidence in talking about suicide — two questions we can cross-analyse of course to be able to see what effect education &amp; training has on confidence in talking about suicide.</p><p>These new questions were repeated in the Wave 3 Survey (Spring 2023) and we will continue to track these key measures.</p><p>It means we can study the relationship between training/information and confidence in having conversations around suicide — and, not surprisingly, those who complete training are far more likely to feel confident in both starting and continuing conversations about suicide.</p><p>And it means we can track this over time, in terms of the proportion of the population being trained, and the longer-term impact of this, as well as hopefully seeing significant growth in the proportion of the population feeling confident talking about suicide.</p><p>Whilst we’re on the subject of ‘training to be competent and confident in talking about suicide’, if you haven’t completed the Zero Suicide Alliance (ZSA) Gateway training, please, please, please do so NOW!</p><p>It’s evidence-based, it’s lived experience informed, it’s NHS-endorsed, it’s been completed 2.5 million times (but still nowhere near enough!), it’s online, it takes just 20 minutes, and it’s free!!!</p><p><a href="https://www.zerosuicidealliance.com/training">Free online training from Zero Suicide Alliance</a></p><p><strong>Incidence of Thoughts of Suicide, Plans, and Attempts</strong></p><p>If we as a country and as a society are serious about trying to reduce the numbers of suicide deaths, and suicide attempts (and to reduce the number of suicide deaths we must reduce the number of suicide attempts of course), then we must have regular monitoring of, and up-to-date data, on suicide deaths, plans and attempts.</p><p>Despite calls for many years for ‘Real Time Data’ on suspected suicides, it wasn’t until the COVID19 pandemic that we finally made serious progress on ‘Real Time Suicide Surveillance’ (RTSS) systems and reporting, with national and local teams and partnerships studying this data stream on suspected suicides (long before completed Inquests decide if it was a suicide ‘on the balance of probabilities’ — itself a lower ‘burden-of-proof’, moving away from ‘beyond reasonable doubt’, only introduced in 2018–19.</p><p>Prior to this, the data for suicide deaths tended to be reported or published at least 9 months out-of-date, eg ONS data for England &amp; Wales being published in September for the previous calendar year, eg published in September 2019 for deaths registered in 2018.</p><p>Meanwhile, it can be very hard if not impossible to get hold of data on suicide attempts.</p><p>There are some ‘pockets of excellence’ where particular hospitals or health trusts or local suicide prevention partnerships have gathered good data and set up good monitoring systems for suicide attempts, including coming through A&amp;E as a minimum and sometimes going much further.</p><p>But there are also many ‘black holes’ where data is poor, inadequate, very limited or missing altogether.</p><p>And even for an overall measure for the % of the population making a suicide attempt (or, at least, saying in a survey with suitably worded questions that they have made a suicide attempt), most of those working in the field tend to go back to the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey from 2014 to quote a number — 7% (for adults aged 16+ in England, n=7546) which is not only 9 years ago, but in a pre-COVID19 world in which much has changed.</p><p><strong>The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey</strong></p><p>So here’s a summary of some of the data this twice-yearly monitor is providing us.</p><p><strong><em>Current State of Mental Health and Mental Health Issues Experienced</em></strong></p><p>More than 1 in 5 adults say their mental health is poor “<em>at the moment</em>” (15% fairly poor, 7% very poor).</p><p>This is a similar level as for state of physical health.</p><p>The two are related in many cases. Also note that long-term physical health conditions or chronic illness often leads to poor or deteriorating mental health and a higher suicide risk; and generally poor physical health causes or contributes to poor mental health (and vice versa).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uR2z508b7G5ooNa_PTVT2A.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>In the latest survey for which data is available, Spring 2023, 1 in 5 said they had experienced “<em>mental health issues that needed treatment or support</em>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BvD1q-SrBNntylvac4BW0w.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Autumn 2022 and Spring 2023 (nationally representative samples of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+)</figcaption></figure><p>Note that, unlike some of the ‘official government surveys’ or surveys carried out by the health professions, we don’t use terms like ‘disorder’ or ‘psychiatric disorder’ which can, of course, record lower numbers of ‘people with mental illness’ (even then the numbers are worryingly high), instead we ask, in plain English, if they have had “<em>mental health issues that needed treatment or support</em>”.</p><p>Also note this doesn’t mean they got the treatment or support they needed, that’s another issue altogether!</p><p>We know that many don’t seek the support they need or cannot get access to the support they need.</p><p>In January 2023, the NHS reported that for the first time ever, the number of children on waiting lists for Child &amp; Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) had exceeded 1 million.</p><p>And, sadly, we also hear cases every week of people being referred to Adult Mental Health Services because they are having thoughts of suicide and they were put on a 6-month waiting list — yes, you may need to re-read that, a 6-month waiting list for someone thinking of ending their life!</p><p>With 3 ‘waves’ of our survey now completed, we can start to look at patterns and even possible trends, although we would be very cautious about ‘talking trends’ at this stage with just the 3 data points.</p><p>The pattern is certainly clear though:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QQsqNuJJrP66qRpqQzijoA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research (nationally representative samples of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Exposure to Mental Health Issues</em></strong></p><p>Almost 2 in 3 UK adults have known someone “<em>with mental health issues that needed treatment or support</em>”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*buuViJsI2N6Lw0UjbSAEhg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Incidence of Thoughts of Suicide, Plans, and Attempts</em></strong></p><p>All of the training courses that cover suicide prevention encourage us to ask direct questions to people because asking about suicide doesn’t ‘put the idea in the head’ of someone who isn’t suicidal and it creates an opportunity for the person who is suicidal to simply and briefly answer that direct question, and then get the support they need.</p><p>In our survey, we ask a similarly direct question “<em>Have you ever had thoughts about taking your own life?</em>”.</p><p>Based on the Spring 2023 Survey, 2 in 5 say they have. 1 in 5 say it’s something they have seriously considered. Around 1 in 8 say they have acted on these thoughts in terms of either making a plan (6%) or making a suicide attempt (7%).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3v9IGuS3avy8xAp54GuNSA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Autumn 2022 and Spring 2023 (nationally representative samples of 1,500 UK adults aged 16+)</figcaption></figure><p>When we share these results, we sometimes find people are shocked to hear that as many as 1 in 15 (7%) of those aged 16+ in the UK (say they) have made a suicide attempt but that is the same figure as recorded by the Adult Psychatric Morbidity Survey from 2014 which was quoted earlier — a survey with a random probability sample of 7500 and weighting designed to be fully representative of the population of England and which also includes an anonymised self-completion sample to check on any under-reporting (there is none!).</p><p>Although also note that the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey asks a different question, not one we would endorse it has to be said as it mentions a specific method (and a method used much more frequently by women, so a risk of bias in the results), “<em>Have you ever made an attempt to take your life, by taking an overdose of tablets or in any other way?</em>”</p><p>We also often find that, after the initial shock of processing the survey result that 1 in 15 adults in the UK (say they) have made a suicide attempt, people start trying to ‘play it down’ by rationalising like, for example, ‘ah, I see, so the question asks about ‘ever’ so that could be a suicide attempt at some point in their life over the course of a long life’ (not that that makes it any more palatable!).</p><p>But there are two problems with this ‘playing it down’ mindset. Firstly, the % saying they have ‘ever made’ a suicide attempt is much higher in younger people than in older people.</p><p>Secondly, the latest wave of the UCL Millennium Cohort Study found that 7% of 17-year olds (say they) have made a suicide attempt — yes, another one worth re-reading, 7% of 17-year olds trying to end their lives!</p><p>Again, with having 3 waves of our own survey, we can see the patterns in the data. The proportion seriously considering suicide has remained around 1 in 5. The % saying they’ve made a suicide attempt was 7% in both of the Spring Surveys, so consistency there too.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*un9wyveDNxC6mvqIRZBD3A.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research (nationally representative samples of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>For those who say they have ever had thoughts of suicide (the 2 in 5 of the population who have), we ask when was the last time they had such thoughts. Then by re-percentaging this on the total sample, we can see that 1 in 12 UK adults (say they) have had thoughts about taking their own life in the past month.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XTQ4FN_rmsvQLOrBvynFHg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Exposure to Suicide</em></strong></p><p>Among the UK population as a whole, 2 in 3 have been exposed to suicide in some way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XMFxz1ehzAK1E8i2TN2KPQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>We often say in our advocacy and campaigning ‘suicide can affect anyone’ and ‘everyone can help prevent suicides’.</p><p>We can also say that ‘2 in 3 people in the UK have had some exposure to suicide (eg losing someone to suicide, knowing someone who has died or made an attempt, witnessed a suicide, etc) — but the number of people who openly talk about suicide (and suicide prevention) is nowhere near 2 in 3.</p><p>The figures for exposure to suicide have been very consistent over the 3 waves of the survey so far.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K2aA6mo_1v6MZffA3gcG9g.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research (nationally representative samples of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Levels of Confidence in Talking about Mental Health and Suicide</em></strong></p><p>In the Survey, we asked about some key scenarios around information or support around mental health &amp; suicide prevention, and asked about the extent to which people would feel confident in each scenario — very confident or fairly confident (to add together for a total ‘confident’ measure), not really confident or not at all confident (to add together for a total ‘not confident’ measure) or ‘don’t know’ (which clearly is nearer to ‘not confident’ than ‘confident’).</p><p>There are just 3 scenarios where a majority of UK adults are confident — “<em>Where you could get support if you were struggling with your mental health</em>” (58% confident, though only 17% very confident and 31% not confident); “<em>Where to go to get information about suicide and suicide prevention</em>” (57% confident, though only 16% very confident and 33% not confident); and “<em>How to spot the signs that someone might be struggling with their mental health</em>” (54% confident, though only 11% very confident and 38% not confident).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1lC7iVJ4te_Qi-P7LjfZ3w.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>In the above chart, we also have “<em>Where to direct someone for support if they are at risk of suicide</em>”. For this, fewer than half are confident (47%) with almost as many (42%) not confident.</p><p>In the chart below, confidence levels are even lower.</p><p>For the absolutely crucial, potentially life-saving starter question (covered in all the suicide prevention training courses) “<em>How to best ask someone if they are having suicidal thoughts</em>”, only one in three (33%) are confident and more than half (54%) are not confident.</p><p>Interestingly, for “<em>How best to continue the conversation if someone is thinking about suicide</em>”, the gap narrows — 42% confident, 47% not confident.</p><p>So, it appears to be significantly harder to start the conversation than to continue the conversation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xTYy9uB_pv3IjxAk7vlgWg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>And that’s why it’s so important to get some basic training — to be able to start that conversation, and then continue.</p><p>Yet when asked about “<em>Where to go to get training in suicide awareness and prevention</em>”, only one in three (35%) say they are confident, with half (49%) saying they are not confident, and a further one in seven (14%) answering ‘don’t know’ which, in this context, is clearly not confident.</p><p>One other scenario was given to those taking part in the survey — “<em>How to spot the signs that someone is at risk</em>”.</p><p>This is something Steve Phillip and I at The Jordan Legacy are asked all the time — ‘what are the symptoms, what are the signs, how can you tell someone is struggling, how can you tell if someone might be thinking of ending their life?’.</p><p>This is one of the key topics we cover in our talks and workshops, including Steve’s very popular signature talk “<strong><em>The ‘S’ Word</em></strong>” and our highly acclaimed workshop “<strong><em>Having Difficult Conversations, including the ‘S’ Word</em></strong>”:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/book-us-to-speak/">Book Us | Event Speaking | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Well, when asked about “<em>How to spot the signs that someone is at risk of suicide</em>”, only two in five (42%) are confident, whilst half (51%) are not confident (and 9% answer ‘don’t know’).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xTYy9uB_pv3IjxAk7vlgWg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>Education and training is crucial for two reasons.</p><p>To learn how to better ‘spot those signs &amp; symptoms’.</p><p>But also, because it’s not always easy to ‘spot the signs’ and, sadly, with many suicide deaths, those bereaved (including close family, best friends, team members at work, and neighbours) say ‘there weren’t any signs, we didn&#39;t see it coming’, we need to ‘ask the question’…and, because it’s hard to ‘ask the question’, we need to ‘take the training’.</p><p><strong><em>Sources of Information, Education and Training</em></strong></p><p>When asked about which ways they have learned about mental health and suicide, the top answer by far is “<em>Read information on relevant websites such as Mind or Samaritans</em>” — more than 1 in 3 say they have done so (which, of course, means the majority haven’t, and 2 in 5 have not used any of these sources or resources).</p><p>Next (at 18%) is “<em>Learned from listening to someone who has had suicidal thoughts or experienced a suicidal crisis</em>”, and it’s interesting to know that almost 1 in 5 are learning from this type of lived experience, significantly more in fact than “<em>Learned from listening to someone who has lost someone to suicide</em>” (1 in 8, 13%).</p><p>Because more (prominent) public speakers &amp; campaigners tend to be people bereaved by suicide rather than people who have experienced a suicidal crisis, there can be a tendency to think this is a more common source of information and education but our data suggests otherwise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ItInwhCW3NZ6mT1HD0KBzg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2023 (nationally representative sample of 1,500 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>One in eight (12%) say they have “<em>Attended a training course on mental health, such as Mental Health First Aid</em>”, although only half this number (6%) say they have “<em>Attended a training course in suicide awareness, intervention or prevention, such as ASIST or Suicide First Aid</em>”.</p><p>When we combine those two categories, ie attended either a mental health course or a suicide awareness/intervention/prevention course, the total is one in seven (14%). A case of ‘good but could be much much higher’.</p><p><strong>Impact of Training</strong></p><p>You won’t be surprised to hear that those who have attended training are considerably more likely to be confident in having conversations about suicide.</p><p>This will be the main feature of my next article-report, going into more detail on those impact figures. So watch this space!</p><p><strong>Time for Action — Creating Hope Through Action</strong></p><p>Meanwhile, let me reiterate the practical actions you can take because it’s all about action at the end of the day — and, for the third year in a row, the theme of World Suicide Prevention Day is ‘Creating Hope Through Action’.</p><p>If you haven’t completed the Zero Suicide Alliance (ZSA) Gateway training, please, please, please do so NOW!</p><p>It’s evidence-based, it’s lived experience informed, it’s NHS-endorsed, it’s been completed 2.5 million times (but still nowhere near enough!), it’s online, it takes just 20 minutes, and it’s free!!!</p><p><a href="https://www.zerosuicidealliance.com/training">Free online training from Zero Suicide Alliance</a></p><p>And check out all of the other great courses out there, including all those actively supported by The Jordan Legacy such as Mental Health First Aid and Suicide First Aid (including those courses delivered through The Jordan Legacy’s partners Tara Powell and Steve Carr), and ASIST, and our collaborative partnership with 4MentalHealth:</p><p><a href="https://www.4mentalhealth.com/courses">Courses and Formats | 4 Mental Health</a></p><p>And the other key practical action you can take to help save lives, to help get the suicide numbers on a downward trend ‘towards zero’, is to sign &amp; share our petition to Parliament for a Suicide Prevention Act:</p><p><a href="https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/640961">Petition: Introduce a Suicide Prevention Act to seek to minimise suicides</a></p><p><strong>Hope for Life!</strong></p><p>And finally, have you got your tickets for ‘the event of the year’, the second Hope for Life Conference on 1 December in Harrogate?</p><p>The first Hope for Life Conference in December 2021 was an incredible event — so moving to have so many people with lived experience in the room, brilliant talks and performances (from music to immersive theatre), and it had a ripple effect impact that extended a long way in many directions…</p><p>…including sowing the seeds for the Baton of Hope in the closing conversation between myself, Steve Phillip &amp; Mike McCarthy (we initially agreed to have our first meeting to develop the concept in January 2022 but couldn’t wait so it was 16 December 2021)…</p><p>…and connecting us to so many people we now collaborate with regularly in working towards our shared vision of a ‘Zero Suicide Society’.</p><p>Here’s the video highlights from that first Hope for Life Conference:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FsfL8-_f39IE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DsfL8-_f39IE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FsfL8-_f39IE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/124f5ffb6a45031d5965c1052a41f558/href">https://medium.com/media/124f5ffb6a45031d5965c1052a41f558/href</a></iframe><p>And here’s the details of the forthcoming, second, Hope for Life Conference in case you want to book and experience this incredible event in-person, first hand:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/conference-2023/">Hope For Life UK Conference | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>I’ll be speaking at the Hope for Life Conference 2023 on “<strong><em>Gaining an Understanding of Loss</em></strong>”, including talking about my own experiences of loss; and the amazing insights I gained when doing my counselling training and further studies into the many different types of loss experiences; and how we need to better understand and support people’s loss (and trauma) experiences to be able to reduce the number of suicides down towards zero.</p><p>If you are going to be there in Harrogate on 1 December, I look forward to seeing you there.</p><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles is a researcher (FMRS), consultant, coach and counsellor who specialises in mental health and suicide prevention. Paul has lived with mental illness for 20 years, and worked professionally in suicide prevention for more than 10 years. Paul has recently taken on the role with The Jordan Legacy of Chief Facilitator, Zero Suicide Society Transformation Programme.</em></strong></p><p>If you want to support the work The Jordan Legacy does, you can donate via the website or you can make a donation specifically to support The Jordan Legacy’s action research project via this Just Giving page:</p><p><a href="https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/suicide-prevention-research-project?utm_term=8PNAG4gEx">Help raise £10000 to allow us to develop an important proactive suicide prevention action-research project to help us move towards a Zero Suicide Society.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb1b8564adc0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Let’s Talk about Suicide]]></title>
            <link>https://paulvittles.medium.com/lets-talk-about-suicide-35e4706f6bf7?source=rss-d1615fdad31d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/35e4706f6bf7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Vittles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Aug 2022 14:26:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-18T15:14:42.778Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Talking about suicide and suicide prevention is at the heart of preventing suicides, and yet so many people shy away from this (potentially life-saving) conversation. So let’s not shy away, let’s talk!</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/906/1*eTwiyEe8aoexOcmxaQf79w.png" /></figure><p>In the UK, more than 6,000 people die by suicide each year. Anyone who has even the most basic knowledge of suicide prevention will tell you that opening up the conversation is a key part of the solution to reducing these numbers.</p><p>This means appropriate one-to-one conversations with those who are at risk or in danger, and an open conversation in society at large about suicide and suicide prevention without stigma, with intent to prevent suicides (and move towards a ‘zero suicide society’), and around practical actions people can take to help save lives.</p><p>In suicide prevention, a valuable practical action is talking about suicide — learning how to have that conversation, and then having that conversation — so, in that sense, talk is action!</p><p>But many if not most people don’t feel confident or comfortable talking about suicide. How can we help encourage potentially life-saving conversations?</p><p><strong>The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022</strong></p><p>In the Spring of 2022, The Jordan Legacy CIC partnered with MEL Research to carry out a survey among a representative sample of 1531 UK adults (aged 18+) to make sure we had some up-to-date figures which could inform conversations around mental health, suicide and suicide prevention.</p><p>Many thanks to MEL Research for their generous support and professional service in partnering with The Jordan Legacy to make this survey happen.</p><p>Two notes before reporting on the survey results.</p><p>First, if you do quote any of the results from this survey, please give your source as The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022, and link to this published summary to ensure accuracy and avoid misrepresentation.</p><p>Secondly, given the subject matter, all those taking part in the survey were directed to sources of support. If you or anyone you know needs support, there are many options (and it’s important to know there are many options!), including via the Resources page on The Jordan Legacy website:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/help-resources/">Help &amp; Resources | Suicide Prevention | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p>Those involved in suicide prevention would argue that “<em>As a society, we should discuss suicide and suicide prevention much more openly</em>”. When we put this to the population as a whole, four in five agreed (79%, including 41% strongly agreeing and only 4% disagreeing). This endorses the decision to carry out this survey and talk openly about the results, which are highlighted below.</p><p><strong>How many people consider taking their own life?</strong></p><p>One of the problems with not having a society where there is open conversation about suicide is that its prevalence and impact can be underestimated.</p><p>As the chart below shows, two in five UK adults (42%) say they have at some point had thoughts about taking their own life; one in five (20%) have ‘seriously considered’ suicide (that’s the sum of the 7% + 5% + 8% in the right-hand column); one in eight (12%) have gone a stage further and planned how they would end their life; and one in fourteen (7%) say they have made a suicide attempt.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cXO7iGUhO0fkin2xL1AXeg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>As is usually the case in research on suicidal thoughts and behaviour, these figures are all higher in the youngest age group, 18–24.</p><p>Among the population as a whole, 9% say they have had thoughts about taking their own life in the past month, and 4% in the past week.</p><p><strong>How many people are exposed to suicide in some form?</strong></p><p>Because suicide is often not talked about openly, some people mistakenly assume that it only affects a small minority of the population. This is not true. The National Suicide Bereavement Survey has estimated that for every death by suicide there are around 135 people affected — family, friends, work colleagues, neighbours, those who were trying to support that person with clinical care, counselling, etc.</p><p>With more than 6,000 deaths by suicide in the UK each year, that means more than 800,000 people each year are affected by suicide each year, aggregating and compounding each and every year.</p><p>The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022 shows how this translates into the population-wide picture for the UK. Two in three UK adults (67%) have had some form of exposure to suicide:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*51DejeB2WaCWjEKApDNgjw.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>One in three (32%) say they have known someone who died by suicide. One in eight (12%) say they have lost a close friend or family member to suicide.</p><p>This is not ‘niche’! It’s just that the conversation about suicide is so limited.</p><p>We know that it can often be hard to talk about for those who have lost someone close to them, and it’s a different kind of hard for those with no past exposure to suicide joining this conversation.</p><p>Some people and groups are being brought into the conversation more, and getting more support. Some less so, including those who witness a suicide or suicide attempt who are often left alone to process what they’ve witnessed.</p><p><strong>How many people experience mental health issues?</strong></p><p>The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022 asked about mental health as well as suicide and suicide prevention. The two are closely related of course, as someone with untreated or unsupported mental health issues is at a higher risk of suicide and those having suicidal thoughts are experiencing a form of mental distress (although the suicidal crisis can be triggered by other factors, eg a financial crisis, loss of job, relationship breakdown).</p><p>Among the UK adult population as a whole, two in five (43%) say they have ever experienced “<em>mental health issues that needed treatment or support</em>”. One in six (17%) have experienced this in the past 12 months.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OI0GGk5yVb-16Mbn8DqrIA.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>One in five of those surveyed in Spring 2022 (21%) described their current state of mental health as fairly poor or very poor (the same proportion as described their physical health as poor — there is an overlap in these two groups, but they are not the same people).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Hoqfi5vqlbtdZs1YBLDndg.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>Among those aged 18–24, one in three (32%) said their mental health was poor. It was also especially high among those who identified themselves as having a disability (37%). This is consistent with other research which often shows especially high suicide risk and high suicide rates among people with disabilities or living with chronic physical pain.</p><p>Among all adults aged 18+, two in three (66%) have known someone with mental health issues that needed treatment or support — 35% knowing a close family member in this situation, 31% a friend, and 12% a work colleague.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y0WS4zSzf564dWfSm41kBQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>Again, this emphasises how widespread the experience is of being exposed to mental health issues and mental illness, as well as suicide. Most people’s lives are touched by these issues, but most people don’t talk openly about them, which perpetuates the problems, and continues the stigma, fear, etc.</p><p>The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022 also included some questions around knowledge the general population has around suicide and suicide prevention, and their attitudes on some key issues. These were designed to provide insights and data to help fuel the conversation around suicide and suicide prevention — in our networks, communities, workplaces, at public events, in our campaigning and advocacy, etc.</p><p><strong>Knowledge about suicide and suicide prevention (facts and myths)</strong></p><p>It is a fact that “<em>suicide is the biggest killer of UK adults aged under 35</em>”. Indeed, knowing this is one of the key drivers for many of those who are active in trying to reduce the numbers of deaths by suicide.</p><p>As the chart below shows, in The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022, a majority of the UK population (58%) said they thought this was true, but only one in six (16%) thought it was ‘definitely’ true, one in ten (10%) thought it was false, and three in ten (30%) answered ‘don’t know’. The two in five UK adults answering either ‘don’t know’ or ‘false’ illustrates the level of awareness-raising and education that is needed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eINt1P5laNBF-WWCfw5bHQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>National charities such as Papyrus, with its focus on children and young people, campaign and advocate around what are often regarded as startling statistics such as “<em>200 schoolchildren per year take their own lives</em>”. Half of those in our cross-sectional sample of UK adults (50%) think this is true but two in five (39%) answer ‘don’t know’.</p><p>Several studies have shown that, sadly, another fact is that “<em>those who lose a loved one to suicide become at greater risk of suicide themselves</em>”. The trauma of suicide loss and grief makes many people highly vulnerable. However, among the population as a whole, only two in five (39%) think this is true, only one in fourteen (7%) think it is ‘definitely’ true, one in three (34%) answer ‘don’t know’, and one in four (26%) think it is false.</p><p>Thankfully, the increased risk to those bereaved by suicide has been acknowledged much more in recent years, and there have been huge developments in support for those experiencing suicide loss (still with much more scope for improvement). But of course without greater awareness of this being an issue and without greater knowledge of how to provide support (ranging from clinical services to peer support groups to family and friends at least talking about it rather than shutting down), the risk remains high.</p><p>In this true/false survey format, we included a mix of key facts, common myths, and sweeping statements that mask much nuance and complexity. Given the proposition “<em>suicide occurs without warning</em>”, 43% think this is true, 36% think it is false, and 19% answer ‘don’t know’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eINt1P5laNBF-WWCfw5bHQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>It’s not surprising that many people think suicide occurs ‘without warning’ because they often hear about deaths by suicide where it appears to be a shock to even close friends or family members. And there are cases where there has been a very short time between an event triggering suicide (such as loss of a job, breakdown of a relationship, life-altering trauma) and someone taking their own life. There are also many cases where the person taking their own life has had no history of mental illness or mental health issues.</p><p>However, in many cases, there were ‘warnings’ or certainly noticeable signs or symptoms, clearly visible prior to a suicide attempt or with hindsight. And many cases where people taking their own lives had a (long) history of mental illness, where they had recently been having treatment, and — perhaps most tragically of all — where they had sought help but not been provided with the support they needed. So, in all these contexts, deaths by suicide were clearly not ‘without warning’.</p><p>Another proposition put to those taking part in the survey was “<em>suicide cannot be prevented</em>”. Two in three (67%) said this was false, including 44% answering ‘definitely’ false, although one in six (17%) thought it was true.</p><p>‘False’ is the ‘correct’ answer in the sense that most of those working in the field of suicide prevention would say that ‘most suicides are preventable’ and some would argue that almost all deaths by suicide are potentially preventable with the right prevention and intervention measures, including crisis interventions right up to the very moment a suicide attempt is made.</p><p>There is an important qualification though which is that not all suicides are preventable. Sometimes, despite the very best efforts to provide support to those in known danger — support from family and friends, support from clinicians, support from peer groups, charities, workplaces, etc — some people do take their own lives. This includes instances of mental illness and psychotic episodes where it has appeared impossible to prevent a death by suicide.</p><p>Anyone saying ‘all suicides are preventable’ can upset those who have done their utmost to support someone in danger or who has lost a loved one despite feeling they have done all they can. And public debates around ‘all suicides are preventable’ as an absolute tends to raise other issues such as an individual’s human rights, including the right to take their life if they choose.</p><p>But, as a general rule, it is healthy to open up and have the conversation and, it is healthy to think and act on the basis that most suicides are preventable (when developing suicide prevention strategies, plans, policies, campaigns, etc) and ‘suicides are never inevitable’ (when providing one-to-one or group support focused on individuals at risk or in danger).</p><p>In another question on the survey, more than two in three (70%) also rejected the proposition “<em>If someone has decided to kill themselves, there’s nothing we can do to stop them</em>”, although one in six (16%) agreed. Whether or not we should ‘stop them’ can be a highly complex ethical question. But the evidence suggests that, in most cases, we can do more to ‘stop them’ and help them through a temporary crisis and on to a future quality of life which means they don’t again see suicide as their ‘best’ option or ‘only’ option.</p><p>The chart below summarises the other survey responses on the true/false question format. In each case, these are generally regarded as ‘myths’, ie statements that are often made by those who are not well informed about the issues or evidence base. It makes them unhelpful comments and, in some cases, such statements can actually be harmful.</p><p>In The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022, we (thankfully) have a majority answering ‘false’ for each of these myths but we have between 13% to 30% answering ‘don’t know’ and 11% to 19% saying ‘true’, so this emphasises the need for more wider and deeper education to raise levels of awareness, knowledge, and understanding:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ruIrmEnAAGoXS7UZqYITDw.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>For those who are not well informed about each of these issues, here’s a summary of what the evidence base tells us.</p><p>Thinking about suicide is not ‘rare’. In this very same survey, we have found that two in five UK adults (42%) have had thoughts about taking their own life at some point, including one in eight (12%) who have got as far as planning how they would end their life. This is clearly not ‘rare’.</p><p>Many studies have included interviews with people who have been in suicidal distress or who have made suicide attempts and survived, to try and get a better insight into their lived experience and what can be done to help prevent suicides. A common theme from these studies is that ‘suicidal people don’t want to die, they just can no longer live with the pain they are living with’. Many of those who have survived suicide attempts report feelings of wanting to live moments after attempting to take their lives. Again, it’s important to emphasise that this is not all cases, and some who survive suicide attempts are distressed to find they did not die. But the sweeping statement “<em>suicidal people clearly want to die</em>” is not evidence-based and potentially harmful.</p><p>“<em>Only people who are mentally ill take their own lives</em>” is a particularly complex ‘myth’ to address. We can clearly state that it is factually incorrect in the sense that not all people who take their own lives have diagnosed or even diagnosable mental illnesses, and many suicides are triggered by a life crisis which did not appear to be a mental health crisis (eg a financial crisis). However, it clearly requires some form of ‘mental distress’ for someone to try to take their own life.</p><p>What is most important is recognising that each individual has their own set of circumstances that is causing them to consider suicide or try to take their own life, and to provide the tailored support each individual needs. If, with appropriate clinical input, they are openly acknowledging that they have a mental illness, that is part of facilitating the treatment and support they need. If they are seeing themselves as not being mentally ill but experiencing a crisis that is the result of other factors, it is likely they will be focused on addressing the underlying problems that have brought them to crisis (eg losing their home or job) than discussing whether they are ‘mentally ill’.</p><p>Again, it’s heartening to see in The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022 that so many people reject potentially harmful myths such as “<em>suicidal behaviour is motivated by attention-seeking</em>” — two in three (67%) say this is false, including almost half of the population (47%) saying ‘definitely false’ — but, sadly, one in seven (15%) think this is true.</p><p>First of all, there is a fundamental difference between a ‘cry for help’ and ‘attention-seeking’. The latter terminology is loaded with stigma, implying the primary motivation is just to attract attention rather than someone being in crisis and not knowing where to turn.</p><p>Secondly, suicidal behaviour is often the exact opposite of ‘attention seeking’. People suffer in silence, and take steps to conceal their distress from others.</p><p>If ever suicidal behaviour is visible, we should see it as a positive opportunity to help someone through their crisis, not criticise them for seeking attention! And because it’s often not obviously visible, we need to get better at spotting the more subtle signs and get better at asking questions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ruIrmEnAAGoXS7UZqYITDw.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>One of the most dangerous myths of all is “<em>asking people about suicide increases their risk of suicide</em>”. Thankfully, there have been many research studies carried out over the past 20 years that have concluded there is little or no risk from talking openly about suicide, and much benefit. Asking someone who is not suicidal if they are thinking of ending their lives does not make that person suicidal. Asking someone who is suicidal if they are thinking of ending their life can save their life.</p><p>As with all of these complex matters, we cannot say there is absolutely no risk from talking about suicide but we can pinpoint those circumstances where there may be a risk. In particular, it can be harmful for someone who is suicidal to be exposed to conversations about ways of ending their lives, so we shouldn’t talk about means of suicide with someone at risk, except where we are trying to support someone in immediate danger by talking through the plan they have made in order to keep them safe.</p><p>Also, talking about suicide in any context can be triggering for those with lived experience of suicide, so we need to be sensitive, give appropriate warnings, and provide appropriate support for those who might be adversely affected by being exposed to conversations about suicide.</p><p>However, these specific instances aside, what the evidence tells us is that opening up the conversation about suicide among the population as a whole (and in families, communities, groups, schools, workplaces, etc) has a huge benefit with a negligible risk (and a risk that can be managed); and asking direct questions about suicide to those we think might be concerned about is an opportunity to help them without harming them.</p><p>Another myth which is problematic is “<em>once someone becomes suicidal, they will always remain suicidal</em>”. In most cases, suicide attempts occur when someone is experiencing a crisis and set of circumstances that makes them feel their ‘best’ option or ‘only’ option is to take their own life. It is situation-specific and, if they get through this temporary crisis, they may go on to live a long life without ever again (seriously) contemplating suicide.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that we should not continue checking in with them. We should, because they may have suicidal thoughts in the future. And we know that those who have made a suicide attempt are at a particularly high risk of making a future suicide attempt if their mental health continues to be poor or the underlying issues that brought them to crisis are not addressed.</p><p>What it does mean is that we should not ‘give up on people’ or think that suicide is ‘inevitable’ in any individual case.</p><p><strong>Attitudes around Suicide and Suicide Prevention</strong></p><p>In The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022, we put a series of proposition statements to our representative sample of the UK population and asked them to what extent they agreed or disagreed. The results are shown in the charts below.</p><p>The vast majority agree that “<em>The Government should allocate more money to mental health services</em>” (80% agree, including 50% strongly agreeing) and “<em>The Government should allocate more money to suicide prevention</em>” (72% agree, including 38% strongly agreeing).</p><p>Four in five (81%) agree that “<em>We should aspire to a society where deaths by suicide are rare events</em>”. This means investing resources where it can help bring the suicide numbers down of course, along with more people, groups and organisations opening up the conversation and learning how to support.</p><p>The vast majority of UK adults also agree that “<em>Mental health and wellbeing should be taught in schools</em>” (83% agree, including 49% strongly agreeing) and that “<em>Suicide awareness and prevention should be taught in schools</em>” (74% agree). This is a topic discussed at one of The Jordan Legacy’s online events in 2022, with the recording available on the website.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hbOogCQ8isUW9A3esJOcNA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EfZSm1kruwiOhibRRS180Q.png" /><figcaption>Source: The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Spring 2022 (a nationally representative sample of 1,531 UK adults)</figcaption></figure><p>Given the proposition “<em>We can all do more to help prevent suicides</em>”, more than two in three agree (72%), including one in three (32%) strongly agreeing. Everyone ‘doing more’ is of course the way we can move towards a ‘zero suicide society’ or a ‘society where deaths by suicide are (very) rare events’. However, this does mean there are significant numbers disagreeing (9%) or answering ‘no opinion either way’ (19%) so part of the conversation we need to have is around how ‘we can all do more’, eg by taking basic training and learning how to spot signs or ask direct questions to those at risk or in danger.</p><p>In response to the statement “<em>I would know how to help someone who was struggling</em>”, fewer than half the population agree (43%). Around one in four (23%) answer ‘no opinion either way’ and around one in three (31%) disagree, ie admit they would not know how to help someone who is struggling. Given how many people are struggling — as evidenced by this survey — we need to raise our capacity to help.</p><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022 highlights that two in three UK adults are exposed to suicide in some way and to mental health issues, with one in six (17%) experiencing mental health issues needing treatment or support in the past 12 months and around one in ten (9%) having thoughts about ending their life within the past month.</p><p>The vast majority of the population want to see more support and more funding for support, they think we can all do more to help save lives (although most do not currently think they would know how to help someone who is struggling), they think we should aspire high in suicide prevention, and they think that, as a society, we should be discussing suicide and suicide prevention much more openly.</p><p><strong>So we end this piece as we began…Let’s Talk about Suicide!</strong></p><p>This piece is being published following an online event entitled “Let’s Talk About Suicide” hosted by The Jordan Legacy which included a presentation of The Jordan Legacy/MEL Research Survey Spring 2022 and facilitated discussion with Mental Health First Aid and Suicide First Aid trainers, Tara Powell and Steve Carr. A link to the recording of the event can be accessed here via YouTube:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FGWQ2aDtsCqw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DGWQ2aDtsCqw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FGWQ2aDtsCqw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ef2950f8e2360195680a35af445840ff/href">https://medium.com/media/ef2950f8e2360195680a35af445840ff/href</a></iframe><p>or via The Jordan Legacy website’s store of recordings from all events:</p><p><a href="https://thejordanlegacy.com/previous-the-jordan-legacy-events-including-recordings/">Previous The Jordan Legacy Events Including Recordings | The Jordan Legacy</a></p><p><strong><em>Paul Vittles is a researcher, consultant, coach and counsellor who specialises in mental health and suicide prevention. Paul works with Steve Phillip and The Jordan Legacy team to develop and implement strategies for transformational change in suicide prevention; to raise awareness and knowledge; to prompt actions (talking about suicide being a key action!); to highlight practical actions that we all can take; and to support people and organisations wanting to make a life-saving difference.</em></strong></p><p>If you want to support the work The Jordan Legacy does, you can donate via the website or via this Just Giving page:</p><p><a href="https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/jordan-legacy?utm_term=KExyywK82">Help raise £10000 to To help fund the work we do to prevent suicides by providing hope to those who are struggling with their mental health</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=35e4706f6bf7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>