<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Paul Klink on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Paul Klink on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@pbklink?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 16:50:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@pbklink/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[R&D vs Innovation — A productivity perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/r-d-vs-innovation-a-productivity-perspective-32599625bd63?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32599625bd63</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[subsidies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-and-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Sep 2026 17:24:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-30T17:24:25.531Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What is the difference between R&amp;D and innovation?</p><p>This is not an academic question. Both are vital¹ for the economies of advanced countries. However, the risks associated with R&amp;D and innovation are large and this deters companies from carrying out these activities. So governments subsidise² them — to the tune of billions of dollars.</p><p>In order for companies to access these subsidies, it can make a big difference whether they are undertaking R&amp;D or standalone innovation activities. This article explores the difference between R&amp;D and innovation and considers the different benefits they provide to an economy.</p><h3>Definitions</h3><p>Many articles and documents use the term <strong>R&amp;D</strong> loosely — treating it as interchangeable with <strong>innovation</strong> or <strong>RD&amp;I</strong>, or some combination of all three. This can be confusing and misleading so it is important to have a clear understanding of these terms.</p><h4><strong>R&amp;D (<em>Research and Development</em>)</strong></h4><p>From OECD’s Frascati Manual (2015)³ we get:</p><blockquote><strong>R&amp;D is the systematic, creative process of generating new knowledge.</strong> It encompasses activities — from basic and applied research through to experimental development — that are novel, uncertain in outcome, and aimed at increasing the stock of knowledge or devising new applications of existing knowledge. R&amp;D does not, of itself, produce a marketable product or service; its output is knowledge.</blockquote><p>The Australian Government take this one step further by stipulating that, in addition to R&amp;D requiring systematic processes, the processes also need to be based on <strong>Scientific Method</strong>. This limits its applicability and creates significant barriers for R&amp;D in fields such as software development, design, and social innovation, where hypothesis-driven experimentation is not standard practice.</p><h4><strong>Innovation</strong></h4><p>From OECD Oslo Manual (2018)⁴ we get:</p><blockquote><strong>Innovation is the process of translating knowledge — whether new or existing — into products or services that deliver value.</strong> An innovation is a new or significantly improved product or process that has been introduced to the market or brought into use. Innovation does not require the generation of new knowledge; it may draw entirely on existing knowledge, technologies, or methods to create something useful.</blockquote><p>That is, innovation is the process that creates or improves a sellable product or service.</p><h4>RD&amp;I (<em>Research, Development &amp; Innovation</em>)</h4><p>The term R&amp;D is often conflated/confused with RD&amp;I. RD&amp;I combines R&amp;D with innovation. From OECD Frascati/Oslo Manuals³⁴ , and RD&amp;I value chain literature⁵:</p><blockquote><strong>RD&amp;I is the integrated, end-to-end process that links the generation of new knowledge (R&amp;D) with its commercial or practical realisation (Innovation).</strong> It represents a value chain in which research produces new knowledge and technologies, development refines these into workable solutions, and innovation brings those solutions to market. RD&amp;I is therefore a subset of the broader innovation landscape — it is innovation that is specifically driven by prior R&amp;D activity.</blockquote><p>In the rest of this article the terms R&amp;D, innovation and RD&amp;I have the above meanings.</p><h3>Differences</h3><p>A wry, pithy observation of the difference is:</p><blockquote><em>R&amp;D is turning money into ideas, but innovation is turning ideas into money</em></blockquote><p>R&amp;D is an input into the innovation process whereas innovation generates the economically (or socially) valuable output. The intermediary between them is “knowledge and technology”. Diagrammatically this can be shown as:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/916/1*zOpwltbbsn7-6PNFThHZyw.png" /></figure><p>Accordingly:</p><ul><li>R&amp;D focuses on creating knowledge and technologies</li><li>Innovation focuses on using existing knowledge and technologies to create value through new or improved products and services.</li></ul><p><strong>RD&amp;I</strong> combines both these 2 processes. The critical distinction is that <strong>R&amp;D</strong> must be followed by <strong>innovation</strong> in order to generate economic value; however, <strong>innovation</strong> often does not need <strong>R&amp;D</strong>.</p><h3>RD&amp;I vs Non-R&amp;D innovation</h3><p>Ultimately, it is innovation that adds value to the economy. When governments consider innovation policy, the big question is not simply whether to support R&amp;D or innovation, it is the extent of support (subsidies) provided to different types of innovation. To that end, let us compare RD&amp;I and non-R&amp;D innovation across several dimensions:</p><ul><li><strong>Cost</strong><br>Non-R&amp;D innovation is inherently less expensive to carry out than RD&amp;I. Accordingly, these innovators face lower financing constraints and have more flexibility in undertaking innovation activities.<br>Government incentives may still be needed to encourage non-R&amp;D innovation, however, the <strong>amount</strong> should be less than incentives needed for RD&amp;I and can be spread across many more organisations.</li><li><strong>Price</strong><br>Non-R&amp;D innovation is very often process-based and used to drive down prices — the benefits flowing to consumers as lower prices. RD&amp;I however is more focused on new product categories and performance breakthroughs. When successful, the resulting products and services sell at a price premium until competition catches up⁶.</li><li><strong>Competition</strong><br>The incremental nature of non-R&amp;D innovation drives down pricing while mostly maintaining competitive markets (provided competitors also innovate). However, successful releases from RD&amp;I can destroy markets (creative destruction — the process by which innovations make existing products obsolete) and lead to monopolies until new entrants can break in.</li><li><strong>Local vs Global reach</strong><br>The lower costs and complexity of non-R&amp;D innovation allow more firms across wider areas to participate, distributing economic gains broadly across the economy. However, the spillover from RD&amp;I diminishes quickly and will be limited to university and research precincts, which tend to be geographically concentrated⁷.</li><li><strong>Research output channel</strong><br>RD&amp;I is a major output channel for research organisations (universities and research institutions) and highly valued by these organisations. As significant recipients of public research funding, these organisations tend to be well-represented in policy discussions, and may use this influence to shape government priorities away from non-R&amp;D innovation.</li><li><strong>Ecosystem</strong><br>Non-R&amp;D innovation builds broad entrepreneurial capacity whereas RD&amp;I builds deep and narrow expertise. The number of SMEs undertaking non-R&amp;D innovation is approximately three times the number of R&amp;D-active SMEs⁸. The greater participation rate of non-R&amp;D innovators develops a more diverse innovation and skills base.</li><li><strong>Commercialisation skills<br></strong>The shorter path to market and lower capital costs of non-R&amp;D innovation provide companies with greater opportunity to commercialise innovation. This is where innovation policy should focus to build general innovation commercialisation skills. However, RD&amp;I enables the development of specialised commercialisation skills relevant to complex and large-scale innovation.</li><li><strong>Productivity</strong><br>Non-R&amp;D innovation has a higher impact on productivity at an aggregate level, due to its volume, frequency and price competition. Essentially, it raises the floor of productivity. RD&amp;I has a higher impact per event (successful release) but low frequency. These events raise the ceiling of what is economically possible — but they are too infrequent to carry aggregate productivity growth on their own.</li></ul><h3>Why Productivity Favours Non-R&amp;D Innovation</h3><p>The productivity case for non-R&amp;D innovation rests on a well-established distinction: incremental vs radical innovation.</p><p>RD&amp;I produces paradigm shifts which can radically change a marketplace. They are rare and expensive — but when they land, they are newsworthy, carrying an air of prestige, controversy, and occasionally national pride, which inevitably draws them into the world of politics.</p><p>In contrast, non-R&amp;D innovation is the quiet background worker doing the hard aggregate lifting for productivity — with no fanfare. Its incremental and continuous improvements to process and design, reduce costs, increase quality, sharpen competition, and pass value to consumers through lower prices. The individual innovations themselves may be less ambitious than those resulting from R&amp;D, but due to their volume, they account for a substantial share of economy-wide productivity improvements⁸.</p><h3>Government Innovation Policy</h3><p>Governments subsidising innovation need to understand the difference between R&amp;D, innovation, and RD&amp;I — and to reflect that understanding in how they allocate support. With productivity growth weak in most advanced economies, the direct impact on living standards makes this a policy choice that matters.</p><p>Some governments limit their support to RD&amp;I — and narrow it further still by requiring the scientific method⁹. This concentrates subsidies on a small subset of innovation activity while leaving the larger, more accessible, and arguably more productive world of non-R&amp;D innovation without support. The evidence suggests the returns from this approach are not only limited, but diminishing.</p><ol><li><a href="https://scienceinsights.org/why-research-and-development-is-more-important-than-ever/">Why Research and Development Is More Important Than Ever</a> — Note, as with many articles it uses the term R&amp;D to cover both classic research driven R&amp;D and innovation.</li><li>In 2025/26, the Australian government <a href="https://pp.tax/services/rd-tax-incentive-advisory/statistics/#:~:text=Treasury&#39;s%202025%2D26%20Tax,Budget%20reforms%20exist.">spent</a> roughly $6.2 billion on subsidising R&amp;D activities within Australian companies.</li><li><a href="https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2015/10/frascati-manual-2015_g1g57dcb/9789264239012-en.pdf">OECD’s Frascati Manual (2015)</a></li><li><a href="https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2018/10/oslo-manual-2018_g1g9373b/9789264304604-en.pdf">Oslo manual 2018</a></li><li>The RD&amp;I value chain concept is formally recognised in the European Commission’s Framework for State Aid for Research and Development and Innovation (OJ C 414, 2022), which describes RD&amp;I as “a series of activities… upstream to a number of product markets” leading to new or improved products and services. The underlying value chain structure — from idea generation through development to commercialisation — is elaborated in Hansen &amp; Birkinshaw, “The Innovation Value Chain”, Harvard Business Review, 85(6), 2007.</li><li><a href="https://www.fraserinstitute.org/sites/default/files/benefits-of-incremental-innovation.pdf">The Benefits of Incremental Innovation</a></li><li><a href="https://www.brookings.edu/articles/localizing-the-economic-impact-of-research-and-development/#:~:text=This%20dispersion%20matters,within%2Dcity%20localization%20benefits.">Localizing the economic impact of research and development</a></li><li><a href="https://www.kfw.de/PDF/Download-Center/Konzernthemen/Research/PDF-Dokumente-Fokus-Volkswirtschaft/Fokus-englische-Dateien/Fokus-2022-EN/Focus-No.-394-July-2022-types-of-SMEs-innovation.pdf">Types of SMEs in the innovation system: activities, constraints and successes</a></li><li><a href="https://www.ato.gov.au/businesses-and-organisations/income-deductions-and-concessions/incentives-and-concessions/research-and-development-tax-incentive/eligibility-for-the-r-d-tax-incentive">Australian Tax Office: Eligibility for the R&amp;D tax incentive</a> — specifically the requirement that core R&amp;D activities follow “a systematic progression of work based on the principles of established science, proceeding from hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation.”</li></ol><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/r-and-d-vs-innovation-a-productivity-perspective/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32599625bd63" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[R&D Methodology: Spinning an overlay]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/r-d-methodology-spinning-an-overlay-9d541d0d570f?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d541d0d570f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-and-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[funding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ausindustryrdtaxincentive]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Jan 2026 19:40:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-18T06:32:10.730Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>My experience</h3><p>In August 2024, I wrote, “ <a href="https://medium.com/@pbklink/understanding-r-d-subsidies-a-software-perspective-4addf76769f6">Understanding R&amp;D Subsidies — A software perspective”</a>, after being advised that the methodology used in our <a href="https://incentives.business.gov.au/">RDTI</a> application was too software like. This previous article presented an methodology which tried to bridge software development and the scientific methodology required by RDTI applications. Essentially it is an overlay methodology — one which could be overlaid over software development methodology to make it look like a scientific-like process. My plan was to utilise this methodology in a separate software based RDTI application and write up my experience. And so I did. This article explores my experience in this endeavour.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/467/1*YHrjLSh6uV2soSKN9Q7QEg.png" /></figure><p>In summary, it was a terrible experience. I used it on a small R&amp;D project; very innovative — so it should have been easy to prepare an RDTI application for it. However, I found it excruciatingly hard. The problem was not the approach. The problem was with me.</p><p>I found it extremely hard to ‘spin’ the overlay. It felt too much like lying. I knew what I had to do, as I had observed R&amp;D consultants similarly creating overlays on previous RDTI submissions. Even then, I felt queasy about signing off on these submissions — despite the reassurances from the consultant that the application was legitimate. I should have realised back then, that these consultants not only have the high level technical/engineering skills to understand what we are building, they also have creative writing skills to map our development processes onto the scientific method. When it comes to writing, I have a very concrete style. Good for communicating actualities — not so good for spinning.</p><p>Upon realising this, it raised the question whether I should work on developing this skill. Obviously, I don’t have to as I can fall back to using consultants. However, it goes deeper than that.</p><p>As discussed in the previous article, the basic problem here is that scientific methodology is a lousy fit for software development — including novel software development. Software developers do not relate to it. They have spent years honing their skills around software development methodologies. They have become productive using these methodologies. They make sense to them. Using “scientific methodology” to develop software is far less productive. It is very waterfall-like and documentation heavy. Even worse it is bad for morale. Nobody likes having to do their job in an inefficient manner (the idiom “hands tied behind your back” seems both appropriate and inappropriate).</p><p>Yet to receive RDTI funding for a software project, <a href="https://business.gov.au/expertise-and-advice/ausindustry">AusIndustry</a> requires that scientific methodology be used. However, this does not seem to be a barrier for software companies claiming R&amp;D expenditure. In 2022/23, Atlassian, a large Australian software company, <a href="https://www.smartcompany.com.au/tax/research-and-development-tax-incentive-rdti-ato-report-2022/">claimed over $220 million</a>. I find it difficult to believe that Atlassian would use inefficient or unproductive software methodologies for their development processes. So I assume they have their own approach to mapping their methodology onto an overlay which meets AusIndustry requirements (I could be wrong about this¹). I suspect a similar situation for other Australian software companies making R&amp;D expenditure claims.</p><h3>Why allow overlays?</h3><p>So why does AusIndustry seemingly allow these companies to bypass the R&amp;D claim criteria by using overlay methodologies? I think the answer is that it is extremely hard to distinguish between software engineering and software R&amp;D. Some reasons for this are:</p><ul><li>The formulation of algorithms represents only a tiny fraction of software development costs and limiting subsidies to this would provide little to no incentive.</li><li>Productivity improvement (one of the ultimate outputs of R&amp;D) is not a useful criterion as most software (excluding games/entertainment) is developed to improve processes.</li><li>The use of engineering processes (for example working off specifications) is a possibility but that can easily be overcome by overlays and also leads to the perverse outcome of developments using poor engineering processes remain eligible.</li><li>In regards to being novel, because individual creativity is frequently an input into the development process, it is not that hard to find novel aspects in most development projects.</li></ul><p>So it looks like their answer to this predicament is to take an extreme position. Development has to use scientific method; must be novel (heavy emphasis on algorithms); and lower cost cannot be used as a basis of novelty (weird as this is a fundamental driver of productivity gains). I assume AusIndustry realise this is not a realistic position so they provide a lot of leniency in the enforcement of this criteria. This gives them the latitude to apply it to flagrantly non-compliant applications (via audits) but still allow applications that suitably ‘smell’ of R&amp;D to receive funding. The R&amp;D consultant firms which assist companies with R&amp;D applications, develop a feel of the extent of the leniency. To a large extent, they act as a regulatory intermediary that filters out applications which fall outside the bounds of the leniency.</p><p>While the above sounds convoluted, it seems to work. Software companies doing R&amp;D receive funding; R&amp;D consultants receive their commission; the research lobby (universities etc) are mollified as scientific method is specified and AusIndustry gets its BERD ( <a href="https://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_departments/Parliamentary_Library/Research/Research_Papers/2024-25/Australias_RandD_and_innovation_metrics__an_explainer">Business Expenditure on R&amp;D</a>). Everyone wins! Well — maybe not. The ultimate winner should be the tax payer. Let’s consider the following 3 downsides to the above process.</p><h3>Problems with overlays</h3><h3>1. Sub-par allocation of funding</h3><p>If software companies are receiving R&amp;D funding based on the overlays they develop, the more expansive the overlay, the greater the funding. The amount of funding received can become more dependent on the creativity of the application writer than the actual R&amp;D done. The more you spin, the more you receive. Ideally, a well spun overlay can cover most of the engineering as well as the R&amp;D. This obviously favours companies with many years of experience in submitting R&amp;D applications and have learnt to tune their overlays to take maximum advantage of the lenience in criteria.</p><p>The uncertainty of meeting the criteria also greatly increases the fear of audits. So companies with limited access to cash, avoid including R&amp;D funding in their business plans due to the chance of failing an audit and not being able to repay the subsidy. (An earlier company I worked in, made this decision after being audited.) The irony here is that the companies who can afford to fail an audit, so are not held back by this fear, are probably not the optimum targets for R&amp;D funding.</p><h3>2. Overstatement of BERD and reduced productivity growth</h3><p>The reason for subsidising R&amp;D is because of its value to the economy (generates creative destruction and drives productivity improvement) and to overcome businesses’ reluctance to carry out R&amp;D due to its high risk. Ideally the R&amp;D funding criteria should prevent funding low risk engineering activity which firms would have carried out without subsidy. As discussed above, this reduces the effectiveness of the subsidy.</p><p>In addition, this would lead to an overestimation of Australian BERD as (I assume), subsidised R&amp;D contribute to calculation of BERD. However this is now diluted with engineering that does not qualify as R&amp;D. While this may not be an issue for AusIndustry, whose remit is to maximise BERD, it probably does show up as reduced Australian productivity improvement.</p><h3>3. Reduces ability to retain R&amp;D talent in Australia</h3><p>While we may measure the output of R&amp;D in terms of intellectual property (eg. patents), I believe that the most important output is the improvement of R&amp;D skills within Australian people. This goes across the whole gamut of roles related to R&amp;D such as: researchers, developers, engineers, managers, entrepreneurs and investors. These are the people who not only make today’s R&amp;D, but will also make tomorrow’s R&amp;D — possibly supplanting their previous creations.</p><p>The value of these skills are very important to companies. While companies go to great lengths to protect their IP, if a competitor wants to develop similar IP, it is far easier for the competitor to induce <a href="https://medium.com/@mrsandelin/china-just-pulled-its-own-manhattan-project-and-no-one-saw-it-coming-90bda336fd15">key R&amp;D staff to work for them</a> with more attractive employment conditions. Companies who do not sufficiently look after their R&amp;D staff could find that their IP advantages simply walking out the door with resignations.</p><p>The same applies to countries. We subsidise R&amp;D to build up these skills in people — hoping that they will generate further R&amp;D in Australia. However, if after they build these skills, they are more attracted to other countries’ R&amp;D environments, then these skills are lost to Australia. A significant amount of the subsidies used to develop these skills have not been used to Australia’s benefit.</p><p>Obviously, there are many aspects to a decision as to whether an R&amp;D person would choose to work in Australia or overseas. Having faith in the government’s support of local R&amp;D would be a factor to many people. The problem with using overlay methodologies to gain funding is that there is a disconnect between the R&amp;D criteria and the the actual R&amp;D. The R&amp;D people have to live with this disconnect and maybe even sign off on it. It distances the funding from R&amp;D and makes it more an accounting/finance issue. In some ways government R&amp;D policy is seen to be divorced from reality. This may not be a big deal to many in the industry, however my experience with software developers is that many are quite principled and this does matter to them. Quite likely, these principles are also in researchers and other R&amp;D related roles.</p><h3>Use R&amp;D consultants</h3><p>Returning to the pragmatic, if you carry out software R&amp;D, funding is likely a struggle. Your competitors most likely have applied for RDTI funding and it makes business sense to also apply. Unless you are very experienced in this funding, my advice is to NOT do it yourself — ignore my previous article. The criteria is too opaque. Instead, use an R&amp;D consultant — they will have experience with the level of lenience allowed.</p><p>The consultant will step you through creating an overlay as part of your submission. It is a somewhat creative process that takes advantage of their experience of the lenience built into the RDTI criteria to maximise your funding. Just go with the flow. At some point you need to sign stating that the submission is accurate. If you have to, close your eyes or cross your fingers while signing. But what about getting audited? What about failing the audit and having to refund? That’s a risk you will have to live with. But then risk and R&amp;D go hand in hand, so hopefully you do not lose sleep over it.</p><h3>Policy Alternatives</h3><p>The above is both conjecture and based on my limited experience of submitting RDTI applications. So take it with a grain-of-salt. However, assuming that there are elements of truth to it, what are better policy alternatives? This will be explored in my next 2 articles.</p><p><strong>1.</strong> I have no knowledge of Atlassian internal processes and I am NOT, in any way, implying that they are doing anything wrong in relation to their R&amp;D expenditure claims.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/r-and-d-methodology-spinning-an-overlay/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d541d0d570f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[R&D Demand]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/r-d-demand-edb14fb01e5c?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/edb14fb01e5c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[behavioral-economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-and-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supply-and-demand]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Oct 2025 00:25:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-02T00:25:15.727Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The R&amp;D process is not very attractive¹ to businesses. It is high risk, has low productivity, and requires expensive talent. A few businesses manage to incorporate it into their business model. However most do not, and are happy to adopt the output of other organisations’ R&amp;D.</p><p>On the other hand, governments love the R&amp;D process. Estimates of private rate of returns to R&amp;D from numerous studies² cluster around 10% to 15% (but can be significantly higher). Studies have also estimated the social rate of returns from R&amp;D, from side-effects such as <a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/understanding-rd-subsidies/#ideas--spillover">spillover</a> and enhanced ability to adopt innovation. These estimates range up to 100%. Accordingly governments make great efforts to increase the levels of R&amp;D within their economy.</p><p>These government efforts include:</p><ul><li>Subsidising R&amp;D undertaken in businesses,</li><li>Prioritising research that feeds into R&amp;D and aligns with national focus areas,</li><li>Facilitating pathways for researchers and their organisations to develop and commercialise their research.,</li><li>Supporting development of eco systems which nurture entrepreneurs and startups,</li><li>Providing taxation and regulatory relief to assist companies raise funds and engaging skilled staff.</li></ul><p>In 2024/25, the Australian Government support for R&amp;D is forecast to be $14.4 billion which is 0.52% of GDP³.</p><h3>Innovation diffusion in purchasing processes</h3><p>If you consider the market for the outputs from the R&amp;D process (innovative products and services), it becomes apparent that this government support is targeting the supply side of the market. However a market cannot grow by increasing supply if there is no corresponding growth in demand. So to increase the amount of R&amp;D undertaken within a country, government support should proportionally also target the demand side of this market.</p><p>The demand for innovative products and services (what R&amp;D creates) differs from non-innovative products and services in that the demand also has to deal with adoption. This has been extensively studied under the field of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_innovations">innovation diffusion</a>. Briefly, there are risks and change associated with adopting (buying) innovation. Innovation diffusion divides people into categories based on the extent to which they are prepared to bear the risks and changes in order to get the benefits of the innovations.</p><p>The category most likely to bear the risks are called “Innovators”⁴. It is estimated that about 2.5% of the population are innovators. Innovators drive demand for brand new innovations. The second and third categories are “Early Adopters” (13.5%) and “Early Majority” (34%). People in these 2 categories drive scaling for innovations. They have an ability to evaluate and deal with risk associated with innovation and incorporate that into their careers.</p><p>Let me illustrate this with 2 experiences in my career. (R&amp;D purists may argue that these examples are not strictly R&amp;D, however they are high-tech and innovative — sufficiently so to illustrate the demand side of the market for innovation.)</p><h3>Adoption of an innovative alternative</h3><p>In the 1990’s I was a youngish project engineer working for a defence contractor building some ships for the navy. I was responsible for the delivery of the platform training facility and simulator. However this work had been subcontracted out to a multi-national defence firm (sub-contractor) — my job was to ensure that their deliveries met the navy’s requirements and successfully integrated with other part’s of the ship. It was a demanding task as this work was on the critical path and had to deal with delays in the ship’s design.</p><p>During the detail design phase of the simulator, the sub-contractor became aware of the need to simulate a sophisticated piece of electrical equipment on the ship. They advised that this was outside the scope of work they had contracted for and would require extra time and money to do this additional work. Naturally, at first we argued this was within the original scope but in the end, conceded that they had a valid point.</p><p>At that point, I assumed we would negotiate a variation to their contract which would require substantial payment, but more importantly, delay the delivery of the ship to the navy. However, the commercial manager I reported to, Kamal, had other ideas.</p><p>Kamal found a couple of electrical engineering lecturers at a university who also had a company which develops custom sophisticated electronic equipment. He asked myself and the engineering team to confirm that they had the ability to develop this simulation component, and then to negotiate an agreement with them to undertake this work. Kamal then authorised for us to proceed with this small firm to develop this critical piece of equipment required for the simulator.</p><p>In the end, they successfully, developed this simulation component to military standards, at a price far lower than the simulator sub-contractor would have charged and, most importantly, without an impact on the ship’s delivery schedule.</p><h3>Career risk</h3><p>Personally, I was very impressed with Kamal’s approach. My experience at my employer, is that they only deal with large, established firms. When confronted with this problem, Kamal, who had an electrical engineering background, identified the opportunity to resolve this by working with a small innovative company and he had the ability to balance the risk against the benefits. Not only that, once he decided that the benefits outweighed the risk, he persuaded senior management that this was the right course of action.</p><p>What impressed me most was how he managed the personal risk to his career. If the small, university-aligned company had failed to deliver, much of the responsibility would have rested with him, and the resulting fallout would likely have harmed his career. Instead of playing it safe, he incorporated managed risk into his career.</p><h3>Playing safe</h3><p>Let me now relate an experience where (it seems) an organisation decided to play it safe by only dealing with large established businesses and failed to meet their objectives.</p><p>My company, <a href="https://www.motifmarkets.com/">Motif Markets</a>, develops full stack trading platforms for security exchanges. It is a tough space for a small company as exchange operators like to deal with suppliers with large balance sheets (we mainly deal with startups).</p><p>A few years ago, a government organisation invited tier 1 exchanges to provide expressions of interest for the development of a carbon exchange. Tier 1 exchanges are typically integrators of expensive systems from different suppliers. It is unlikely that they could provide a solution that aligns with the revenue from a carbon exchange. However our product was an ideal solution — aligned with the requirements, in production use, and was largely off-the-shelf. So we conditionally partnered with a couple of tier 1 exchanges and submitted a response which we considered to have low technical risk and was very price competitive.</p><p>We knew it was a long shot and we were not particularly surprised when we were not short listed to tender.</p><p>Over the following 2 years it became apparent from the organisation’s website, that the tender was not proceeding well and it was then announced that the procurement process was closed without a successful tenderer. No progress has been announced since then.</p><h3>A rational decision</h3><p>I have no first hand knowledge as to why the tender process was not successful. It may have included reasons other than technical and price, however I believe that ignoring solutions from small innovative companies was a contributing factor.</p><p>While this lack of interest is frustrating for small innovative companies such as ours, it is important to realise that this is the result of a rational decision making process. Many organisations are risk averse. They attract and promote staff that who are in the “Late Majority” or “Laggard” categories of innovation adopters. Accordingly, they do not have skills to evaluate and manage innovation risk like Kamal. So the chance of an individual adopting the wrong innovation is high and such a decision would have a detrimental impact on their career. This avoidance of risk, protects the organisation in the short term from bad decisions, however in the long term, it limits the organisation’s operational growth and productivity.</p><p>It also reduces the demand for R&amp;D in our society.</p><h3>R&amp;D cannot defy supply and demand</h3><p>R&amp;D policy cannot ignore the basic economic law of supply and demand. If governments want to increase the level of R&amp;D in a their country, stimulating the supply side is insufficient. Sure it may increase the amount of R&amp;D in the short term but if companies cannot find buyers for the output of R&amp;D, then the increase will have low <a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/understanding-rd-subsidies/#additionality">additionality</a> and not be sustainable without the subsidies. Without corresponding demand, stimulating supply leads to overproduction, which never works in the long term.</p><p>The government could directly create some demand itself by funding organisations that purchase innovation, such as Defence or companies in favourite industries. They could also generate demand by assisting to companies to find overseas customers. However neither of these approaches are unlikely to scale commercialisation of R&amp;D in Australia. The best solution is to create independent local demand for the output from R&amp;D.</p><h3>How to increase local demand for R&amp;D?</h3><p>I believe the solution is to have Australian organisations become more adept at adopting innovation. They need more people with skills like Kamal’s:</p><ul><li>the ability to identify innovation adoption opportunities,</li><li>the ability to effectively evaluate the risks and benefits,</li><li>the ability to persuade the organisation to adopt innovation when the benefits outweigh the risks.</li></ul><p>So in effect, the solution requires changing: people’s behaviour, management approaches and organisational culture.</p><p>A challenging task! Something I will further explore in a subsequent article.</p><h3>Footnotes</h3><ol><li>In Australia only 2% of companies actively engage in the development of new and novel innovations: <a href="https://www.pc.gov.au/inquiries/completed/productivity/report/productivity-volume5-innovation-diffusion.pdf">Productivity Commission 2023, 5-year Productivity Inquiry: Innovation for the 98%</a></li><li><a href="https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn12.pdf">How important is business R&amp;D for economic growth and should the government subsidise it?</a></li><li><a href="https://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_departments/Parliamentary_Library/Research/Research_Papers/2024-25/RandD_and_innovation_in_Australia_2024_update">R&amp;D and innovation in Australia: 2024 update</a></li><li><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_innovations">Wikipedia: Diffusion of innovations</a></li></ol><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/r-and-d-demand/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=edb14fb01e5c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[R&D: Knowledge vs Profit]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/r-d-knowledge-vs-profit-1438db67bec9?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1438db67bec9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-and-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[commercialisation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policy-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 01:46:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-14T01:46:25.010Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The strategic examination of <a href="https://www.industry.gov.au/science-technology-and-innovation/strategic-examination-research-and-development">R&amp;D review</a> currently being undertaken by the Australian Government issued a <a href="https://consult.industry.gov.au/strategic-examination-rd-discussion-paper">discussion paper</a> to facilitate public input into the review. Surprisingly, the paper did not include a definition of R&amp;D. This made it <a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/rd-review-invention-is-out-of-scope/">difficult for me to provide feedback</a>, as it was unclear whether their definition was constrained to systematic research processes (as reflected in their current incentive programs), or included more incremental and iterative processes typically used by start-ups when <a href="https://medium.com/@pbklink/software-startup-r-d-process-17dfb8d4736a">developing innovative software</a>.</p><p>There are various definitions of R&amp;D available across the internet. Some link it to systematic processes for <a href="https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2015/10/frascati-manual-2015_g1g57dcb/9789264239012-en.pdf">discovering new knowledge</a> while others define it as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_and_development">first stage of creating new services and products</a>.</p><h3>Break down</h3><p>Another way of defining R&amp;D is by breaking it down into more basic constituent components:</p><ul><li>Basic Research</li><li>Applied Research</li><li>Innovation</li><li>Development</li><li>Commercialisation</li></ul><p>These components are shown in a the stacked chart below which shows their overlap on a spectrum that goes from knowledge (left) to profit (right).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/1*JNJp-FcBM3Mcyd7olfHcuA.png" /></figure><p>I wont go into defining these components as they are quite obvious and easily further investigated, however note the following:</p><ul><li>Both <em>basic</em> and <em>applied</em> research are based around systematic processes while <em>innovation</em> processes are more ad-hoc.</li><li>Nowadays, <em>innovation</em> is considered an important part of R&amp;D which is reflected in newer acronyms such as R&amp;D&amp;I (or RD&amp;I as the Australian review has <a href="https://consult.industry.gov.au/strategic-examination-rd-issues-papers">rebranded</a> itself).</li><li><em>Innovation</em> and <em>development</em> often run parallel with each other with <em>innovation</em> supplying new ideas into <em>development</em> in an iterative like fashion.</li><li><em>Commercialisation</em>! If you want R&amp;D to benefit the economy, then it is vitally important to consider the commercialisation aspects of R&amp;D.</li></ul><h3>Overlap</h3><p>The real value of this breakdown can be seen when considering the overlaps of the components. The chart below shows some key elements of these overlaps:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/840/1*zAhQWaQstE8zNp2QiQlq_A.png" /></figure><p>If we look at the <em>development</em> column, we see examples of the types of development projects associated with <em>basic research</em>, <em>applied research</em> and <em>innovation</em>. For research ( <em>basic</em> and <em>applied</em>) projects, development is far more specification driven with new knowledge up front, and process oriented. On the other hand, the iterative nature of innovation development means that new knowledge is gained in small amounts with each iteration. This necessarily requires more flexible processes.</p><p>The <em>commercialisation</em> column shows commercial related activities specific to R&amp;D and the approach to profits/costs. For commercialisation at the <em>applied research</em> level, managing costs is important however profit is not a driver. For commercialisation of <em>innovation</em>, profit is a driver. However, in all cases, minimising development (and production) costs is important.</p><h3>Analysis</h3><p>Obviously the above is a generalisation and there are other ways to slice and dice R&amp;D. However the beauty of looking at these overlaps, is that they clearly show how development of novel services and products in areas like software, fit into the R&amp;D pipeline.</p><p>Also by considering commercialisation in the R&amp;D pipeline, it suggests that the overlap of <em>innovation</em> and <em>commercialisation</em> is the sweet spot for policy focus if we want to improve Australia’s commercialisation of R&amp;D.</p><p>As Chris Berg and colleagues point out in their <a href="https://chrisberg.org/2025/04/submission-to-the-strategic-examination-of-rd-discussion-paper/">submission</a> to the Australian review, previous efforts to improve Australia’s R&amp;D commercialisation have achieved only limited success. I think this reflects an excessive focus on the “knowledge” end of the spectrum and insufficient attention to the “profit” end. The knowledge side is easier to reshape through policy: it is organised, procedural and benefits from concentrated advocacy. The profit side is far more complex — the boundaries between engineering and innovation are far more blurred, and regulatory change is politically difficult; our culture tends to deprioritise growth and progress when judging acceptable levels of change in safety and lifestyle insulation.</p><p>So it is understandable that reviews tend to focus on the easier <em>knowledge</em> side of the above <em>knowledge</em>/ <em>profit</em> spectrum. However it is then somewhat incongruous for the R&amp;D review to lament about Australia’s lack of commercialisation while limiting focus on this.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/r-and-d-knowledge-vs-profit/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1438db67bec9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[University Competition — Export skills or improving domestic skills]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/university-competition-export-skills-or-improving-domestic-skills-46a8b4a5fa0a?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46a8b4a5fa0a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[export]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teacher-training]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[competition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[skills-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Mar 2025 20:53:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-13T20:53:00.015Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>University Competition — Export skills or improving domestic skills</h3><p><em>Across August and September 2024, </em><a href="https://treasury.gov.au/"><em>The Australian Government Treasury</em></a><em> ran a </em><a href="https://consult.treasury.gov.au/c2024-557133"><em>consultation</em></a><em> to assist with </em><a href="https://treasury.gov.au/review/competition-review-2023/ncp"><em>revitalising National Competition Policy</em></a><em>. Members of the wider community were invited to make submissions pertaining to competition policy in Australia. This is the 1st of my two submissions.</em></p><p><em>This submission was not accepted by Treasury. It probably is a bit left field and proposes a disruption to a successful export industry. However I believe there are long term productivity disadvantages with the current competitive environment for education exports. I was hoping that a reasoned analysis supporting an alternative competitive environment would be of interest to Treasury.</em></p><h3>About Paul Klink (Author)</h3><p>I studied physics and maths at university and progressed into a career in software development. Across the last 27 years I have worked as CTO and then managing director of companies specialising in the development of brokerage and exchange trading platforms. Recently my interest has been drawn to ‘productivity’ and I developed the concept of a Productivity Exchange (<a href="https://prodxchg.com/">https://prodxchg.com</a>). My company, Xilytix (<a href="https://xilytix.com/">https://xilytix.com</a>), is creating the productivity technology needed by such an exchange.</p><p>To build up my knowledge of productivity (and improve my writing skills), I write articles in areas of productivity that interest me. The intersection of knowledge and productivity is one of those areas of interest. This submission combines this interest with competition policy.</p><h3>Competition between universities</h3><p>There is a perception¹ that Australian universities have a business model focused on exporting education. They use their research reputation and ranking to compete with other universities to attract overseas full fee paying students. It is a very successful business model for universities. For several universities, it brings in over 30% of their revenue; in Sydney University, it brings in 44% of its revenue (2022)². Income that universities can use to bolster their research and better compete in this market. Education is also is one of our top export industries. In 2022/23 it was the 4th largest export at $36.4 billion³.</p><p>However this industry exports skills. International students leave with skills supplied by Australian institutes. Skills that are highly valued in other countries. Skills that drive productivity. Considering that Australia (like many other countries) has a large problem with falling productivity⁴, this poses the following 2 questions:</p><ul><li>Is unrestrained competition which encourages the export of valuable skills beneficial to Australia?</li><li>Can competition policy be used to better focus university leadership on the improvement of skills within Australia?</li></ul><p>This submission explores some of the undesirable impacts of the competition environment in which Australian universities currently operate. It then presents a proposal for using a competitive market to incentivise the leadership of universities to improve domestic skill levels by improving teacher training.</p><h3>Foundational skills are key to productivity</h3><p>The skills of people in a country are the largest determinant of the long term growth of its economy⁵. Especially skills in mathematics and science. Skills could be considered as a countries most valuable resource. A perishable resource which constantly needs to be regenerated and improved. A resource that drives productivity.</p><p>While people can attain skills in many ways, the skills obtained during primary and secondary schooling education are foundational⁶. They lay the basis for the further skills needed to develop vocation and careers and participate in the workforce. So, the extent of foundational skills learnt during these schooling years, has a large impact on the level of skilling that an economy can achieve. Accordingly, they have a bit impact on productivity.</p><p>There are many factors which affect how well students in primary and secondary schools learn skills (student outcomes). However evidence from literature indicates the most influential factor is teaching efficacy (quality)⁷. Teaching efficacy can be separated into teacher attributes and teaching practice — both of which are developed as part of teacher training programs.</p><h3>Teacher training vs international students business</h3><p>In Australia, teacher training is carried out in Initial Teacher Education (ITE) courses run (mostly) by Australian Universities. From the Universities Australia report in 2022⁸ I estimate that ITE courses approximately contribute 5% to universities’ overall business⁹. The proportion of revenue from international students in Go8 universities range from 15% to 47%¹⁰ and in 2020, approximately 28% of students were international¹¹. From this, I estimate international students are approximately 30% of university business¹².</p><p>For universities, it makes a lot of sense to focus on a business model around exporting education and compete in this space. It is already a large part of their business, there is large demand with excellent growth potential, the margins are good¹³ and it is not dependent on government funding. The only significant constraint is Australian Government immigration policy.</p><p>The same does not apply to ITE courses. Competing in this space would provide universities with far lower growth potential¹⁴ compared with competing in the international space. ITE most likely provides a reliable revenue stream, the profits of which could be used to compete in the international space.</p><h3>Perverse Incentives</h3><p>The fact that universities compete in exporting skills rather than compete in developing local skill, can lead to some incentives that are detrimental to improving productivity in Australia.</p><ul><li><strong>Upper management not focused on growing productivity in Australia</strong><br>Competition is a powerful force to focus management on particular outcomes. Universities have strong and highly paid management teams. They also have access to some of the brightest minds in the country. Do we want these teams to be focused on exporting skills or improving domestic skills (and Australian productivity)?</li><li><strong>Standardised accreditation of ITE courses provide little incentive for continuous improvement</strong><br>Once an ITE course has been accredited¹⁵, universities can generate cash flow from it. There is little incentive to improve it unless the nationally agreed Standards and Procedures change. If these courses were subject to competition, then universities would have an incentive to develop improved teacher training techniques and update their courses.</li><li><strong>Are Universities sufficiently attempting to anticipate customer’s future demand?</strong><br>Education bodies which employ graduate teachers are also monitoring advances in pedagogy. Ideally employers’ expectations are incorporated in ITE courses as the pipeline covers several years. However it seems that employer input is limited¹⁶. Consider the recent Victorian Government announcement that government schools must employ the explicit teaching model when teaching reading¹⁷. This announcement generated considerable consternation amongst teachers. Yet, strong evidence supporting the benefits of a greater use of phonics had emerged in the previous decade¹⁸. Could this transition have been better facilitated if spearheaded by ITE courses rather than forced by government edict? Competition in the ITE space would encourage responsiveness to employers’ wants.</li><li><strong>Universities are rewarded for shortcomings in primary and secondary school teaching</strong><br>The government is funding universities to run ‘FEE-FREE Uni Ready’ courses for up to 30,000 students who wish to enter university but do not meet the usual academic entry standards¹⁹. However universities are key players in the supply chain that delivers students to universities. Providing universities with this extra business reduces their incentive to improve the supply chain.</li></ul><h3>Government revenue and policy</h3><p>The export revenue currently generated by university exports is likely to be highly valued by the Australian Government. Not only does it reduce Australia’s current account deficit, it also reduces the government funding required by universities. However sometimes it is in the interest of the Government to restrict or regulate certain economic activity — despite these activities generating substantial revenue for the state. For example:</p><ul><li><strong>Smoking</strong><br>By the late 1950s, significant evidence had amassed regarding the link between smoking and lung cancer²⁰. In 1964, the US Surgeon General issued a significant report describing the health hazard and concluded that remedial action was required. In the subsequent decades, some government action was taken, mainly in restricting advertisement. However actions to denormalise smoking only commenced in the 1990s. One of the reasons for this long delay, was the tobacco industry’s strategy of denying the harms of its products.<br>This example is not meant to imply any equivalence in regards to protecting business models. There is no evidence supporting the notion that engaging in competition to export skills is detrimental to a country’s productivity. However if such evidence should arise, I would hope that the Government responds more quickly than it did with smoking.</li><li><strong>Resource Reservation and Royalties Policy</strong><br>Gas is a resource that is currently critical to our domestic economy however it is also in high demand overseas. If our local supply cannot meet this overseas demand, the price of gas can rise to a level where it becomes unaffordable to domestic customers²¹. One way of addressing this is for governments to implement a policy where a portion of gas is reserved for the domestic market. Western Australia already has such a gas reservation policy²².<br>If we treat skills as a critical resource, we could potentially use reservation like policies to ensure that these are not exported at the expense of the Australian economy. We could even take this one step further and consider these as a public resource owned by all Australians and require royalties for their export.</li></ul><h3>Evaluating teacher training performance</h3><p>The above criticisms of the current university competition environment serve little purpose unless an alternative can be made to work. If not, we may as well accept the benefits of the export income and rely on other fixes to our productivity problems.</p><p>One alternative is for universities to compete based on the effectiveness of the teachers they train. Measuring teacher effectiveness is a difficult task. Various methodologies, using different data sources such as test scores, classroom observations, surveys have been developed — each with advantages and limitations. To get an accurate assessment requires using multiple methodologies²³. This would be a costly endeavor.</p><p>However we do not need to calculate the effectiveness of individual teachers. We are looking for an aggregate effectiveness for all teachers from each ITE provider which allows us to rank ITE providers. Is there a combination of methodologies which could provide this at an affordable cost?</p><p>One potential candidate is Value-added modelling (VAM). It uses complex algorithms to predict a student’s future test scores and then compares these against the actual scores. The difference is considered to be due to the teacher²⁴. While this methodology is not suitable for ‘high stake’ evaluations of teachers²⁵, with aggregation it may provide results sufficiently consistent to evaluate ITE courses.</p><p>Research would be needed to investigate whether teacher effectiveness evaluation methodologies could be used to measure performance of ITE courses. The application of machine learning/AI techniques may assist with this endeavor.</p><h3>A teacher training competitive market</h3><p>Assuming that that it is possible to score and rank ITE courses for the purpose of competition, how could those rankings be used to foster competition? It is unlikely that the reputational impact by itself would be sufficient to focus management’s mind on improving ITE courses. ITE is not a major part of the business and its growth prospect is small. Adjusting government funding per student in these courses would be counter productive as it impacts the quality of the courses. However the following financial adjustments may have a suitable impact:</p><ol><li><strong>Reducing (or rebating) HELP loans</strong><br>Students graduating from ITE courses would have their HELP loans reduced (or provided with a credit payment where reduction is not possible) depending on the ranking of the ITE course at the time a student graduates. The size of a potential reduction needs to be large enough to be a serious factor affecting in-coming students’ decision on which ITE course to take.</li><li><strong>Adjusting royalties for skills export</strong><br>If governments charged royalties for skills exported by universities, the ranking could be used to adjust a university’s cost of royalties. The higher the ranking, the lower the royalty cost. This would have the effect of rewarding universities for improving Australian productivity, with higher profits from their international business.</li></ol><h3>Recommendation</h3><p>Changing the competition environment in which universities operate would would have huge ramifications on our education system, research capabilities and even the wider economy. Before contemplating such a change, much discussion, consultation and research would be required to determine if this is feasible, and if so, what options and approaches could be used. It would also be necessary to weigh the potential long term productivity benefits against likely short term export losses.</p><p>Some initial research which investigates feasibility together with approaches and options would assist with such community and stakeholder engagement.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Recommendation 1</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Undertake research to investigate the feasibility of using a competition model based around performance of teacher training to better focus university management on improving Australian skills and productivity. Also investigate alternative competition models or options which could achieve this purpose. The outcome of the research should be used to stimulate and guide community discussion on the use of competition policy to encourage greater university management focus on improving skills and productivity within Australia.</em></blockquote><h3>Summary</h3><p>Skills are the largest driver of productivity in a country. Universities are a key part of Australia’s skills development infrastructure, with their ITE courses training teachers, who in turn, develop critical foundational skills in students. However it seems that universities operate in competitive environment which focuses university management on the export of skills — possibly at the expense of Australian productivity.</p><p>Competition policy could potentially be used to refocus university management on parts of their business which improve Australian productivity. Introducing competition to university ITE courses could possibly achieve this. Research into teacher effectiveness methodologies to enable this, and options for setting up such competition, would facilitate community discussions that can further explore this possibility.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/articles/university-competition-exporting-skills-or-improving-domestic-skills/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em>.</em></p><ol><li>Nico Louw: <a href="https://www.menziesrc.org/latest-reports-and-submissions/breaking-universities-addiction-to-international-students">MRC Report: Breaking Universities’ Addiction to International Students</a></li><li>ABC News: <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-05-16/group-of-8-universities-third-of-income-international-students/103846352">Group of Eight universities warn they are reliant on international student fees as government looks to cap enrolments</a></li><li>Australian Government Department of Education: <a href="https://www.education.gov.au/international-education-data-and-research/education-export-income-financial-year">Education export income — Financial Year</a></li><li>Australian Government Productivity Commission: <a href="https://www.pc.gov.au/ongoing/productivity-insights/bulletins/bulletin-2024/productivity-bulletin-2024.pdf">Annual productivity bulletin 2024</a> David Taylor: <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-09-09/productivity-key-to-increasing-wages/102831978">Australians are working as hard as ever, but output is going backwards. Who’s to blame?</a></li><li>Eric A. Hanushek, Ludger Woessmann, Ludwig Maximilian: <a href="https://hanushek.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/publications/Hanushek%2BWoessmann%202021%20OxfResEncEcoFin.pdf">Education and Economic Growth</a></li><li>Australian Government Department of Employment and Workplace Relations: <a href="https://www.dewr.gov.au/foundation-skills/resources/draft-national-foundation-skills-framework">Draft National Foundation Skills Framework 2022 to 2032</a></li><li>Deloitte Access Economics: <a href="https://www.education.gov.au/quality-schools-package/resources/school-quality-australia-exploring-drivers-student-outcomes-and-links-practice-and-schooling-quality">School quality in Australia: Exploring the drivers of student outcomes and the links to practice and school quality</a></li><li>UNIVERSITIES AUSTRALIA: <a href="https://universitiesaustralia.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/220207-HE-Facts-and-Figures-2022_2.0.pdf">2022 HIGHER EDUCATION FACTS AND FIGURES</a></li><li>Using the rounded numbers of total revenue, number enrolled in ITE courses, and total resourcing per student in education, we can estimate that ITE courses are approximately 5% of university business. We can also estimate based on student numbers (ignores research business) as being around 6%. Let’s assume 5%.</li><li>Maani Truu, Jake Evans: <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-08-27/australias-international-student-industry-in-charts/104244340">The true scale of Australia’s international student industry — in four charts</a></li><li>From above Universities Australia report</li><li>The simple average of the proportion of revenue from international students in Go8 universities range is approximately 30%.</li><li>Assumption based on reports that international students subsidise teaching of domestic students<br> Sydney Morning Herald: <a href="https://www.smh.com.au/national/international-student-numbers-not-easy-to-cut-without-dire-results-20240703-p5jqpd.html">International student numbers not easy to cut without dire results</a> (paywalled)</li><li>UNIVERSITIES AUSTRALIA: <a href="https://universitiesaustralia.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/220207-HE-Facts-and-Figures-2022_2.0.pdf">2022 HIGHER EDUCATION FACTS AND FIGURES</a> — Figure 51</li><li>aitsl: <a href="https://www.aitsl.edu.au/deliver-ite-programs/understand-ite-program-accreditation">Understand initial teacher education program accreditation</a></li><li>Glenn Fahey, Rob Joseph: <a href="https://www.cis.org.au/publication/starting-off-on-the-wrong-foot-how-to-improve-initial-teacher-education-in-australia/">Starting off on the wrong foot: How to improve Initial Teacher Education in Australia</a></li><li>Bridie Smith: <a href="https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/teachers-told-to-ignore-government-s-phonics-push-as-union-lashes-deputy-premier-20240614-p5jlvh.html">Teachers told to ignore Victoria’s phonics push as union lashes deputy premier</a> (paywalled)</li><li>Rachel M. Cohen: <a href="https://www.vox.com/23815311/science-of-reading-movement-literacy-learning-loss">The new “science of reading” movement, explained</a></li><li>Parliament of Australia: <a href="https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/bd/bd2425/25bd008">Universities Accord (Student Support and Other Measures) Bill 2024</a></li><li>National library of Medicine: <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK294310/">The Health Consequences of Smoking — 50 Years of Progress: A Report of the Surgeon General.</a></li><li>Australian Government, Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water: <a href="https://www.dcceew.gov.au/energy/markets/gas-markets">Gas Markets</a></li><li>Brett Cohen, Armin Fazely: <a href="https://www.claytonutz.com/insights/2024/may/domestic-gas-reservation-policies-are-they-a-good-thing-or-a-bad-thing">Domestic gas reservation policies — are they a good thing or a bad thing?</a></li><li>RAND: <a href="https://www.rand.org/education-and-labor/projects/measuring-teacher-effectiveness/faq.html">Measuring Teacher Effectiveness FAQ</a></li><li>Wikipedia: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_modeling">Value-added modeling</a></li><li>Hannah Putman: <a href="https://www.nctq.org/blog/Teaching-that-goes-beyond-the-test-How-to-measure-the-many-accomplishments-of-great-teachers">Teaching that goes beyond the test? How to measure the many accomplishments of great teachers</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46a8b4a5fa0a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Software startup R&D process]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/software-startup-r-d-process-17dfb8d4736a?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17dfb8d4736a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[subsidies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ausindustryrdtaxincentive]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-and-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Aug 2024 06:09:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-15T06:14:10.279Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Recently, I attended an excellent ‘Ask Me Anything’ event for founders looking for investment at <a href="https://www.stoneandchalk.com.au/">Stone &amp; Chalk</a> in Melbourne. The focus was on (pre) seed funding and the panellists were: <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/simonbeckett/">Simon Beckett</a>, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/thomaswsmalley/">Tom Smalley</a> and <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/andrewcicutto/">Andrew Cicutto</a>. Many thanks to <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/graham-mccorkill">Graham McCorkill</a> and <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/eike-zeller-1464b767">Eike Zeller</a> for running this event.</p><p>While <a href="https://xilytix.com/">Xilytix</a> is not looking for funding (yet), it is well worth attending these events to gain an understanding of what investors are looking for in startup companies. After all, they have experience and skill in identifying company attributes that are indicative of growth and success. One of the attributes they value is the ability to ‘move fast’. Set ambitious goals and reach them quickly. With that in mind, how should a software startup carry out R&amp;D?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hlDCNBSCm-Vq86643_lLzA.png" /><figcaption>R&amp;D process used within Xilytix</figcaption></figure><p>The above diagram overviews how we carry this out in Xilytix. There is no specification. Instead it is driven by ideas and vision that lead directly to design and code. (That is why it is R&amp;D.) The process is very incremental and iterative with frequent meetings to review ideas. Very agile! Our team members have the ability to quickly estimate whether we can implement ideas with our limited resources.</p><p><a href="https://www.industry.gov.au/science-technology-and-innovation/industry-innovation/ausindustry">AusIndustry</a> subsidises R&amp;D to assist Australia’s economy. However to be eligible, companies need use ‘scientific methodology’. This methodology is slower, less flexible (more waterfall-ish) and significantly more costly. In addition, the outcome has to be ’new knowledge’ — not creative destruction (eg productivity gains) which is what the economy really needs. ‘New Knowledge’ is great for universities and science based companies but not so useful for engineering/software based companies undertaking R&amp;D.</p><p>Software startups are an important part of driving productivity in our economy. Subsidies should be structured to encourage their use of R&amp;D with methodologies which are agile, low cost and make sense to the team. The article below explores this further:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@pbklink/understanding-r-d-subsidies-a-software-perspective-4addf76769f6">Understanding R&amp;D Subsidies — A software perspective</a></p><p>© Paul Klink 2024: <em>No AI Training<br>Without in any way limiting the copyright holder’s exclusive rights under copyright, any use of this publication to “train” generative artificial intelligence (AI) technologies to generate text is expressly prohibited. The author reserves all rights to license uses of this work for generative AI training and development of machine learning language models</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17dfb8d4736a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Understanding R&D Subsidies — A software perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/understanding-r-d-subsidies-a-software-perspective-4addf76769f6?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4addf76769f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[subsidies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-and-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scientific-method]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Aug 2024 23:00:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-15T06:12:58.518Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Understanding R&amp;D Subsidies — A software perspective</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S5XoodVDA-41YC3xgz9hJA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>R&amp;D tax relief</h3><p>Many countries in the world subsidise R&amp;D expenditure carried out in their local economy. A lot do this by providing tax incentives to firms undertaking research and development. The OECD estimates that the amount of tax relief provided to firms as a proportion of GDP increased approximately 3 fold from 2000 to 2020: from 0.04% to 0.12%.¹</p><p>Australia provides one of the most generous tax incentive schemes. For example, small companies can receive up to 43.5 per cent either as cash back, or a tax offset, on R&amp;D spending, depending on whether the company made a profit in the financial year.² Yet despite this, Australia’s R&amp;D expenditure as a proportion of GDP has approximately fallen from 2.25% to 1.68% across the period 2009 to 2022.³ In 2024, this proportion is approximately 1 percentage point lower than the OECD average.</p><h3>My experience with R&amp;D subsidy applications</h3><p>While there are many papers which discuss R&amp;D and associated subsidies at a macro level, this article provides a personal perspective of undertaking software R&amp;D and applying for the tax incentive. I have previously been involved with 2 applications and am currently commencing a third project for which I also intend to make an application. However, the previous applications were subpar. The first application was subject to an audit which initially determined that the application did not meet the guidelines. We argued that the project itself was eligible however the application was poorly framed. We were given the chance to resubmit a ‘reframed’ application which was eventually approved by <a href="https://www.industry.gov.au/science-technology-and-innovation/industry-innovation/ausindustry">AusIndustry</a> (who review it for technical eligibility) and <a href="https://www.ato.gov.au/">ATO</a> (who review it for financial eligibility). The second application has been reviewed as part of its registration and we have received feedback advising that our internal processes may not have sufficiently followed the specified “systematic progression of work” eligibility requirement. AusIndustry requires that core activities use the scientific method (hypothesis, experiment, observation, evaluation, conclusion) to create new knowledge. Our internal processes seemed to be too software like.</p><p>The first 2 applications were done in conjunction with R&amp;D consultants who reviewed our projects and prepared the submissions on our behalf. However, for the 3rd project I have decided to develop my own understanding of R&amp;D to better incorporate R&amp;D into our internal processes. So far I have found this both surprisingly difficult but also very enlightening. Merging the scientific method into our internal processes in a sensible fashion requires ‘out of the square’ thinking. However this leads to new insight as to how to approach innovation. Our firm, <a href="https://xilytix.com/">Xilytix</a>, a small software startup, is now 3 months into this project and, while I cannot talk about the project itself, I can share how we are addressing using the scientific method in our software project.</p><h3>Creative Destruction</h3><p>Firstly, let’s review why governments subsidise research and development.</p><p>While it is easy to find articles discussing R&amp;D and innovation, it is hard to find any discussing why these are actually good for the economy and why governments subsidise these. Many generalise about innovation improving productivity and providing an economic competitive advantage. A <a href="https://www.csiro.au/">CSIRO</a> <a href="https://www.csiro.au/en/work-with-us/services/consultancy-strategic-advice-services/CSIRO-futures/Innovation-Business-Growth/Quantifying-Australias-returns-to-innovation">report</a>⁴ in 2021 estimated that for each dollar a government invested in R&amp;D, the economy received a return of $3.50. That is a phenomenal 350% return. But what generates this return?</p><p>A deeper investigation suggests that this is due to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_destruction">creative destruction</a>⁵. This is an economic concept where new innovations replace older innovations. It is also referred to as Schumpeterian theory, named after the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Schumpeter">Austrian economist</a> who derived this theory in 1942 from the works of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Marx">Karl Marx</a>. While Marx’s writings around this, centred on the destruction of capital needed to sustain capitalism, nowadays it is considered as the vital energy which drives capitalism.</p><p>Simplistically, creative destruction is about firms developing new innovations that lead to better, cheaper and more desirable products and services. If other suppliers, or even industries, cannot match these innovations, they go out of business (hence destruction). If managed correctly, creative destruction drives growth in the economy and increases wealth in society. However in the process, it not only threatens firms, but also workers’ jobs, wages and skills.⁶ Maybe that is why the link between innovation and creative destruction is avoided as it highlights the disruptive nature of innovations — a topic which some people, especially politicians, would like to avoid.</p><h3>Ideas &amp; Spillover</h3><p>Innovation is very much associated with new ideas. In economics, the world is often divided into capital and labor. However in 1990, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Romer">Romer</a> divided it into ideas and objects (everything else).⁷ The key difference between these is that an object can only be used by only one person at a time, whereas an idea is nonrivalrous, meaning that at any one time, it can be used by an unlimited number of people.</p><p>The nonrivalrous nature of ideas means that other parties can benefit from the creation of a new idea. This is known as “spillover” (or more accurately, positive externality, however spillover sounds more intuitive). For example if you make a pizza (an object), you can eat it yourself and gain all the benefits of making it. However if you create the idea of a flat piece of dough with various toppings cooked in an oven, other people can use this idea and also benefit from it.</p><p>Spillover has both benefits and drawbacks in the economy. It is beneficial in that new innovative ideas that improve society can easily spread from the originator to other parties. The other parties do not even need to know how the idea was implemented — just that it is possible. This greatly reduces their risk in creating their own implementation of the idea and the economy benefits by having resultant productivity improvements becoming more accessible.</p><p>The down side is that not being able to keep all the benefits of a new idea can deter companies from generating innovations with them in the first place. Once other companies become aware of them, they can create their own implementation of the idea. Intellectual Property only protects implementations of ideas — not the ideas themselves. Patents may help but are difficult to obtain for software.⁸ So firms that innovate need to factor in the substantial risks of loss of benefits due to spillover.</p><p>The first R&amp;D Tax incentive project I was involved highlights aspects of spillover. It was for an API driven onboarding platform for an <a href="https://www.asx.com.au/">ASX</a> broker. This broker was targeting low cost broking with specialisation in technology services such as APIs for traders and advisers. We realised that the greatest cost to this business model was the onboarding of traders and investors (users). At that time, onboarding was an intensive manual process complicated by the interactive steps required for compliance and, that the nature of the financial information requested, was frequently not understood by users. We estimated that one person could onboard no more than 8 users per day. Our aim was to automate this with APIs so that one person can onboard at least 200 users per day.</p><p>This project was successfully implemented and, after running for a year, was onboarding thousands of users per day. Unfortunately our client decided to change direction to become a full service broker and switched to another supplier for onboarding services. We were not able to find another client for our TotalView system and had to shut it down. However by that time, we had demonstrated to the industry the feasibility and advantages of automating onboarding with the use of APIs.</p><p>The R&amp;D grant we received for this project somewhat compensated us for this spillover, and from AusIndustry’s point of view, the Australian economy also benefited as we introduced this productivity improvement into the industry.</p><p>Interestingly, at the time of this R&amp;D Tax Incentive application (2016), the AusIndustry website had numerous mentions of spillover and this was part of its guidelines to eligibility. In 2024, I have noticed that there is no longer any mention of spillover. This is probably a good idea as their focus is to encourage firms to perform more R&amp;D and spillover is actually a discouragement towards this end.</p><h3>Imperfect competition</h3><p>Competition within an industry has a large impact on the level of R&amp;D undertaken by firms. A graph showing the relationship between level of competition (x-axis) and R&amp;D undertaken by firms (y-axis) has an inverted “U” shape with most R&amp;D undertaken in the middle of the range of competition levels.⁶ Modelling has also shown that perfect competition leads to low levels of R&amp;D⁷, as the resultant low margins, provide firms with little scope to carry out R&amp;D. So imperfect competition is needed for high levels of R&amp;D.</p><p>Patents provide companies with relief from competition to encourage innovation. Likewise, R&amp;D subsidies allow firms to purse innovation which otherwise could not be funded due to lack of margin in competitive environments.</p><h3>Additionality</h3><p>The aim of R&amp;D subsidies is to increase firm’s R&amp;D activities and innovativeness. Typically their effectiveness is measured by comparing the extent of this increase against a baseline where no subsidy was provided. This measure is called additionality.</p><p>Additionality can be measured in different ways. Three common types of additionality are⁹:</p><ul><li>Input</li><li>Output</li><li>Behaviour</li></ul><p><strong>INPUT</strong> additionality is the most common and straightforward way of measuring additionality. It compares the amount firms invest in R&amp;D with and without a subsidy with the equation:</p><pre>Additionality =<br>  (Amount invested with subsidy - Amount invested without subsidy)<br>  /<br>  Cost of subsidy</pre><p>A subsidy is effective if the additionality is greater than 1. If it is less than 1, then the subsidy is considered to be “crowding out” private investment in R&amp;D as it is replacing R&amp;D investment a firm would have taken on without the subsidy.</p><p>The additionality of the current subsidy in Australia has been estimated to be 1.9.¹⁰ That is, for each one dollar a subsidy provides, a firm will invest $1.90.</p><p><strong>OUTPUT</strong> additionality compares the amount of innovation generated by firms with and without an R&amp;D subsidy. Studies normally use quantity of patents as a proxy for innovation when measuring output. However this is a coarse measurement as significant amounts of innovation don’t result in patents (especially in software) and it does not account for other innovation related benefits such as technology diffusion, knowledge exchange and spillover.</p><p><strong>BEHAVIOUR</strong> additionality focuses on a firm’s improvements to its R&amp;D skills and capabilities. R&amp;D is often not an innate skill in firms and individuals. It needs to be learnt, supported by infrastructure and, ideally, continuously improved. The improvements can be measured by changes in how firms manage R&amp;D: its confidence and faith in R&amp;D, the extent of knowledge acquisition and sharing, the level of integration of R&amp;D into internal processes and the level of R&amp;D skills in managers and staff.</p><p>Ideally, subsidies should place a heavy focus on behaviour additionality within firms with little previous experience in R&amp;D, as behaviour additionality is a precursor to input and output additionality. It is also critical to firms sustaining their investment in R&amp;D — a true success indicator of a subsidy program.</p><p>In my experience, the current Australian R&amp;D subsidy does not promote behaviour additionality and may, in some cases, work against it. This will be further explored in the rest of this article.</p><h3>Science based and engineering based firms</h3><p>How subsidies impact additionality in different types of firms is explored in a <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/14479338.2021.2015356">study</a>⁹ by Marianne Steinmo, Thomas Lauvås and Einar Rasmussen. This study categorised firms as either science or engineering based firms.</p><p>Science based firms focus on developing new technologies using scientific breakthroughs. They develop core knowledge in pursuit of breakthroughs, normally in close association with academic environments and often with multiple research partners. Their R&amp;D projects are of longer nature and innovation continues through to prototypes and and lead to several products after. Subsidies are often needed for firms to commence R&amp;D projects and they appear to increase knowledge development and innovation and enhance strategic use of R&amp;D. Biotechnology firms typically fall into this category.</p><p>Engineering based firms focus more on market opportunities and use R&amp;D to develop technology targeting these opportunities (application-specific technology). Their innovation is more incremental and used to improve technology and processes to solve particular problems — often related to cost reduction. As a consequence, their development of new knowledge is more focused on their existing domain. If they have research partners, they tend to continue using the one same partner. The study reports that firms would have undertaken R&amp;D activities even without subsidy but with less scope and at a slower pace. Subsidies also had the effect of providing a clearer R&amp;D focus with greater credibility, and also increasing collaboration within the firm.</p><p>For both science and engineering firms, subsidies generated behaviour additionality. These additionalities are more likely greater in small, young, and technologically specialised firms.</p><p>The software R&amp;D projects I have been involved in are far more aligned with the use of R&amp;D within engineering based firms however with some attributes of science base firms. Like engineering firms, they were targeted at market opportunities and innovation was used to lower process costs. For example, TotalView performed the same operations as were previously manually carried out but at a fraction of the cost. This innovation opened up new opportunities for our client to scale its business and the rest of the industry eventually followed (creative destruction).</p><p>New knowledge developed for TotalView was less tangible as it was based upon:</p><ul><li>A synthesis of existing knowledge which was novel within the domain context. For example, to allow clients to track the progress of onboarding, we developed a pipelined based API. This itself was not new knowledge however it was novel in the context of being applied to CHESS and banking in Australia.</li><li>Managing the complexity of developing and integrating the numerous elements needed for TotalView. Complexity is probably the greatest risk factor in any software innovation and higher levels of complexity require greater resourcing.</li></ul><p>Whether this knowledge is related to R&amp;D or the normal software development methodology is debatable. However what cannot disputed is that the overall product developed with all these items of knowledge is innovative. The idiom: “greater than the sum of its parts” seems to apply here.</p><p>TotalView has similarities with R&amp;D projects in science based companies in that we only really knew if it worked when the “prototype” (in our case, beta) was tested by the customer. The overall hypothesis covering the innovation behind this project could only be verified once the customer confirmed that it was good enough to replace their existing manual systems.</p><h3>Knowledge sourcing</h3><p>The acquisition of new knowledge is nearly always a prerequisite of innovation. A <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/2340944420933629">study</a>¹¹ by Afcha and Lucena shows that R&amp;D subsidies encourage knowledge sourcing, and this in turn, increases innovation.</p><p>In our current project, we have followed R&amp;D methodology more so than in the my previous 2 R&amp;D projects. As a consequence, I have found we have done a far greater amount of knowledge searching and learning. As a result, we have identified more innovations to incorporate into our product and our business plan has a stronger and clearer focus.</p><p>However so far we have only undertaken internal knowledge sourcing. External knowledge sourcing such as R&amp;D partnerships/alliances, technology in-licensing and R&amp;D outsourcing, provides greater opportunity for knowledge acquisition but requires more sophisticated R&amp;D skills. For example, knowledge networks¹², knowledge sharing¹³ and knowledge proximity¹⁴.</p><p>Knowledge sourcing differentiates R&amp;D from other many other types of development and engineering activities. R&amp;D subsidies encourage firms to build up their knowledge sourcing skills, and so provide significant behavioural additionality on top of the input additionality.</p><h3>Scientific Method</h3><p>In Australia, AusIndustry tackles input additionality by only subsidising activities which¹⁵:</p><ul><li>Generate new knowledge using the scientific method (hypothesis, experiment, observation, evaluation, conclusion). New knowledge is defined as knowledge that a competent individual cannot know in advance. (<em>Core activities</em>)</li><li>Directly support core activities. (<em>Supporting activities</em>)</li></ul><p>While this approach may work well for science based companies, it is difficult to follow in software (and probably engineering based) companies pursuing innovation. The reasons for this are:</p><ol><li>In science, a hypothesis shown to be false by experimentation generates new knowledge which is of value and assists with subsequent hypotheses. In software, information gained from a failed hypothesis is of far less value and is most likely discarded.</li><li>The fact that experiments fail is factored into funding of science based companies. Software companies are far less likely to have experiment failures factored into their funding.</li><li>Accordingly, a software company will create hypotheses that are far more likely to be proven correct. This leads to a conundrum where a hypothesis would lack <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability">falsifiability</a> — however falsifiability is one of the primary features of a hypothesis.</li><li>The scientific method is difficult to use when the need for new knowledge is not clearly known beforehand. Due to the complexity of software projects, unexpected new knowledge is often generated as part of the development process. For example, in the TotalView project we decided to use a database architecture with a high level of abstraction to provide flexibility. However this architecture caused significant scaling and maintenance problems which required large workarounds. Our architect was competent and very skilled so the knowledge gained from solving this problem certainly can be considered as new knowledge. While the knowledge itself is may not directly deliver creative destruction, it is a important part of developing the product that does.</li><li>The largest problem with specifying the scientific method is that it is difficult to map or merge with methodologies used for software development. This means it is not easily adopted and learnt by the team leading to very low behaviour additionality.</li></ol><p>However the reality is that AusIndustry needs clear guidelines for eligibility of activities and has chosen using the Scientific Method as the basis for eligibility. The rest of this articles explores how a R&amp;D software project can be structured to meet these eligibility requirements, however in a way that makes sense to the team and generates behavioural additionality.</p><h3>R&amp;D Plan</h3><p>Planning is the key to many things. I believe that creating a R&amp;D Plan will both lead to effective use of R&amp;D in a project, and also greatly assist in demonstrating the R&amp;D worthiness of a project in the event of a R&amp;D subsidy audit.</p><p>I gained experience in planning when I worked for a large defence contractor in their software standards compliance department. The department was responsible for ensuring that sub contractors followed defence standards (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DOD-STD-2167A">DOD-STD-2167A</a>) when developing software. Prior to this position, I had no experience in either defense or software compliance when they reviewed my resume for another job. However I was skilled in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCADA">SCADA</a> technology and grew up in a German community in Australia (don’t ask) which is what they were looking for. So I was offered this role.</p><p>My boss was an old hand at defence software development and trained me. However I felt uneasy when he described how he previously wrote software development plans for defence projects. He would shut himself in his office for several days and write the plan making sure that it met the requirements of the standard. After getting the required sign-offs, it was then ready for delivery to the client (Department of Defence).</p><p>This did not seem right to me. Surely the Department of Defence was not primarily paying for the document, but rather to ensure adequate planning was undertaken. This would require meetings and discussions within the team(s), getting input from other stakeholders and ensuring all members understand how the development would proceed. The document itself would be generated from the outcome of these activities.</p><p>As I got to know my boss better, I realised he understood all this but was quite practical about it. The company already had their internal development processes that could be relied on. The document was not needed internally. So his approach meant that they could get paid for this deliverable early and then continue with development according to their internal methods.</p><p>The reason for this reminiscence is that I believe AusIndustry encourages a similar behaviour to that of my boss. This is due to the difficulty in mapping their R&amp;D methodology onto internal software processes. Because of this mismatch, it is not integrated into a firms normal internal processes. Instead, a R&amp;D specialist (possibly a consultant) temporarily steps in to identify the R&amp;D performed and prepares the submission for a subsidy (similar to my boss creating a plan independently of the team). As a consequence, the R&amp;D skills largely remain with the specialist with little transferred to the firm and its staff. This lack of skill transfer stifles the growth of an R&amp;D understanding, ethos and possibly culture within the firm.</p><p>The solution to this is to create a R&amp;D plan internally. By involving staff, awareness of R&amp;D will grow and provide the skills to better generate innovation.</p><p>My view on what content should be included in the document is:</p><ul><li>A description of the overall product or service being developed.</li><li>A detailed description of the innovative elements of the overall product or service being developed. This should highlight the creative destruction aspects of these innovations and also identify potential spillovers.</li><li>An analysis of the types of knowledge that will be required for the project and how this will be sourced. Any use of external sourcing should be highlighted.</li><li>The use of training and learning to develop the skills needed to create the innovations</li><li>A list and description of the core and supporting activities.</li></ul><p>The plan should serve the dual purposes of steering the use of R&amp;D within the project and being able to demonstrate compliance with R&amp;D subsidy requirements. It may be beneficial to engage an R&amp;D consultant to assist with this planning as they can provide advice as to how R&amp;D is best integrated into internal processes while being compliant with subsidy requirements.</p><h3>Core and Supporting activities</h3><p>The hardest part of creating a R&amp;D plan for a software project is identifying R&amp;D core activities. Contextual new knowledge tends to be incremental in nature and gained by solving problems encountered during development and without the need for significant experimentation. For this reason and also since the need for this knowledge is not known beforehand, it is hard to consider it as core.</p><p>The following techniques can be used to address this and identify R&amp;D core activities:</p><ul><li>Review the design and architecture to identify subsystems whose behaviour could be considered as new knowledge within the context of the product domain and promote the development of that to a core activity. For example, TotalView’s use of a pipelined API to onboard users in Australia’s CHESS system and banks.</li><li>Carry out some research to find innovations which supplement the overall innovation of the product. Treat the development of these supplemental innovations as a core activity. Interestingly, when I used this technique in our current R&amp;D project at Xilytix, I found that these supplemental innovations significantly improved the overall product and its degree of innovation.</li></ul><p>Create hypotheses for the items of new knowledge and supplemental innovations around which these core activities are centred. The falsifiability of these hypotheses will probably be low however that is to be expected due to the engineering nature of this R&amp;D.</p><p>For each hypothesis, the corresponding experiment, observation, evaluation, conclusion can be mapped onto software test procedures and test results. Ensure these are formally carried out and well documented.</p><p>An innovation or new knowledge may require separate testing to cover different aspects. For example, testing a sub-system to confirm a technical outcome hypothesis, or testing user interaction with a prototype to confirm a usage hypothesis outcome. In this case, create separate core activities to cover each aspect; each with its own hypothesis and corresponding testing.</p><p>Once the core activities are defined, the next step is to identify all supporting activities associated with the core activities. This should include:</p><ul><li>R&amp;D planning</li><li>Research and knowledge sourcing activities</li><li>Training and learning activities for new skills directly needed to develop the software required to test the hypotheses.</li><li>Development of software required to test the hypotheses</li><li>Testing the hypotheses.</li></ul><p>The scope of the supporting activities will most likely far exceed the scope of the core activities. Their coverage of the project will depend on the number of core activities identified. Ideally, for a new product or service, the core and supporting activities will cover the development of a prototype, or beta version, that can be used to test the overall innovation identified in the R&amp;D plan.</p><h3>Record keeping</h3><p>AusIndustry expects firms to keep records which demonstrate the R&amp;D eligibility of core and supporting activities¹⁶. In addition to emails and design documentation, for our current R&amp;D at Xilytix, we are keeping the following R&amp;D specific records:</p><ol><li><strong>R&amp;D Plan</strong><br>To identify the new (in context) knowledge and innovations being sought and describe the structured approach to generating these.</li><li><strong>Test documentation for core activity hypotheses</strong><br>To demonstrate the systematic approach to confirming the hypotheses associated with core activities</li><li><strong>Internet browsing history</strong><br>To demonstrate internal research undertaken to find innovation and confirm that the sought new knowledge and innovations do not already exist elsewhere. Note that this information is conveniently stored in web browsers. It can be exported with tools such as <a href="https://www.nirsoft.net/utils/browsing_history_view.html">BrowsingHistoryView</a>. (Make sure it is not cleared before exporting.)</li><li><strong>External Knowledge Sourcing</strong><br>Records of communications and/or visits with external knowledge sources and all agreements relating to external knowledge sourcing.</li><li><strong>Timesheets and diary</strong><br>It is important for all staff to record time spent on core and supporting activities. In addition, it is also helpful for staff members to include notes describing the nature of work carried out in the time spent. It is highly desirable for these times to be recorded frequently — ideally daily — as AusIndustry expects contemporaneous records. There are many online timesheet applications which can be used for this task. However at Xilytix we ended up choosing <a href="https://www.jetbrains.com/youtrack/">YouTrack</a>. While this is primarily an issue tracking application, by treating issues as activities we found it an ideal solution for our time spent recording.</li></ol><h3>Summary</h3><p>In summary, my view on how to carry out R&amp;D within a software project which both, makes sense to the software team and, (hopefully) will also be acceptable for an R&amp;D subsidy in Australia is:</p><ol><li>Learn the fundamentals of R&amp;D.</li><li>Write a R&amp;D plan with the involvement of the development team which describes the overall innovation and knowledge sourcing and training needed as for the project.</li><li>Identify core activities by reviewing architecture and design for new (within context) knowledge and searching for supplemental innovations.</li><li>Create hypotheses for the core activities and map corresponding experiment, observation, evaluation, conclusion onto software test activities. Ensure these are well documented.</li><li>Ensure that the core and resultant supporting activities reasonably scope the project (through to prototype/beta).</li><li>Record knowledge sourcing activities. Using browser history is a convenient way of recording research carried out on the internet.</li><li>Use a timesheet application which allows all members to record time spent on individual core and supporting activities. Encourage members to update this frequently and include diary notes on what was done daily.</li></ol><p>The documentation from the above steps should contain most of the information needed to generate an R&amp;D Tax incentive application and hopefully be sufficient to justify the application if an audit arises. It may be helpful to get a R&amp;D consultant to assist with the above steps. To properly gain the benefits of R&amp;D, it is important that R&amp;D consultants only assist and not do it on your behalf.</p><p>Is the above approach “gaming the system”? I don’t think so. It may not exactly meet AusIndustry’s eligibility requirements but I believe it meets its purpose and intent. It is important to remember that the ultimate purpose of the subsidy is to encourage firms to generate creative destruction — not new knowledge. The aim of the subsidies is to assist firms with:</p><ul><li>developing R&amp;D skills such as knowledge sourcing which they can combine with their internal expertise, creativity and knowledge of markets to identify and create innovation that leads to creative destruction, (behaviour additionality)</li><li>funding to provide confidence to invest in and proceed with high risk innovation R&amp;D projects involving experimentation and complex development. (input additionality)</li></ul><p>The above is best achieved if R&amp;D can be integrated into a firm’s processes in a manner which makes sense to firm’s staff and project team members. Only then can a R&amp;D ethos and culture grow within a firm.</p><h3>Just a hypothesis</h3><p>If this article, was trying to sell you something, I’d finish off with Caveat Emptor. However I’m not! I am just looking for a R&amp;D framework that makes sense to me, feels right for Xilytix and hopefully will be accepted by AusIndustry and ATO as a way of undertaking R&amp;D as part of a Tax Incentive application.</p><p>Please note that, in respect to this framework, I have had no interaction with these government agencies and in no way should anyone infer that they in anyway approve of this approach. In some ways, this is a (possibly expensive) R&amp;D Tax Incentive experiment:</p><ul><li><strong>Hypothesis</strong>: AusIndustry and ATO will accept a R&amp;D Tax Incentive application for innovative software projects which undertake R&amp;D as described above.</li><li><strong>Experiment</strong>: Use the above R&amp;D framework for a software project and submit a R&amp;D Tax Incentive application which is based around this framework.</li><li><strong>Observation</strong>: See if the application is accepted or if we are audited!</li></ul><p>I will follow up with another article to report any observations. However any feedback — especially related to organising R&amp;D and/or how to best submit applications for R&amp;D subsidies — would be greatly appreciated.</p><p>See also:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@pbklink/software-startup-r-d-process-17dfb8d4736a">Software startup R&amp;D process</a></p><p>[1]: Accounting Times: <a href="https://www.accountingtimes.com.au/tax/australia-s-r-d-tax-incentives-among-worlds-most-generous-oecd">Australia’s R&amp;D tax incentives among world’s most generous: OECD</a></p><p>[2]: Rimon: <a href="https://www.rimon.com.au/blog/rd-tax-incentive-affect-on-company-franking-account-rimon-advisory">How RDTI Franking Debits Work</a></p><p>[3]: Group of Eight: <a href="https://go8.edu.au/go8-roadmap-to-lift-australias-rd-intensity-to-3-of-gdp">Go8 Roadmap to lift Australia’s R&amp;D intensity to 3% of GDP</a></p><p>[4]: CSIRO: <a href="https://www.csiro.au/en/work-with-us/services/consultancy-strategic-advice-services/CSIRO-futures/Innovation-Business-Growth/Quantifying-Australias-returns-to-innovation">Quantifying Australia’s returns to innovation</a></p><p>[5]: Wikipedia: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_destruction">Creative destruction</a></p><p>[6]: Akcigit and Van Reenen: <a href="https://www.production.hup.harvard.edu/file/feeds/PDF/9780674270367_sample.pdf">The Economics of Creative Destruction</a></p><p>[7]: Jones: <a href="https://web.stanford.edu/~chadj/RomerNobel.pdf">Paul Romer: Ideas, Nonrivalry, and Endogenous Growth</a></p><p>[8]: Hall, Mairesse and Mohnen: <a href="https://eml.berkeley.edu/~bhhall/papers/HallMairesseMohnen09_rndsurvey_HEI.pdf">Measuring the Returns to R&amp;D</a></p><p>[9]: Steinmo, Lauvås and Rasmussen: <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/14479338.2021.2015356">How R&amp;D subsidies alter firm activities and behaviour</a></p><p>[10]: Thomson and Skali: <a href="https://www.industry.gov.au/sites/default/files/May%202018/document/extra/research-and-development-tax-incentive-review-report-rate-of-additionality-swinburne.pdf">The Additionality of R&amp;D Tax Policy in Australia</a></p><p>[11]: Afcha and Lucena: <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/2340944420933629">The effectiveness of R&amp;D subsidies in fostering firm innovation: The role of knowledge-sourcing activities</a></p><p>[12]: Wang, Chen and Fang: <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2018.03.034">A critical view of knowledge networks and innovation performance: The mediation role of firms’ knowledge integration capability</a></p><p>[13]: Castaneda and Cuellar: <a href="https://doi.org/10.1002/kpm.1637">Knowledge sharing and innovation: A systematic review</a></p><p>[14]: Davids and Frenken: <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/00343404.2017.1287349">Proximity, knowledge base and the innovation process: towards an integrated framework</a></p><p>[15]: AusIndustry: <a href="https://business.gov.au/grants-and-programs/research-and-development-tax-incentive/assess-if-your-randd-activities-are-eligible">Assess if your R&amp;D activities are eligible for the R&amp;D Tax Incentive</a></p><p>[16]: AusIndustry: <a href="https://business.gov.au/grants-and-programs/research-and-development-tax-incentive/assess-if-your-randd-activities-are-eligible/#keeping-records-as-evidence">Keeping records as evidence of your R&amp;D activities</a></p><p>© Paul Klink 2024: <em>No AI Training<br>Without in any way limiting the copyright holder’s exclusive rights under copyright, any use of this publication to “train” generative artificial intelligence (AI) technologies to generate text is expressly prohibited. The author reserves all rights to license uses of this work for generative AI training and development of machine learning language models</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/post/understanding-rd-subsidies/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em> on August 4, 2024.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4addf76769f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cost disease or Risk vs Expectation]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/a-variation-of-cost-disease-da6a3c0f37ed?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da6a3c0f37ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[organisation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[employment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baumol]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Jun 2024 22:37:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-16T06:33:19.078Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the long run, a society’s prosperity is dependent on productivity growth. One of the conundrums societies face in respect to this is, that as economies become more advanced, they become dominated by industries with low productivity growth. This is best seen in the growth of service industries, which mostly have low productivity growth. The following chart¹ shows this domination by comparing US employment in service producing industries against employment in goods producing industries.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/497/0*zWd6ojuaJalLkkc3.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Baumol effect — or more colloquially, cost disease — is a theory that offers an explanation to this above phenomenon. Its main postulates are:</p><ol><li>As wages rise in high productivity industries they must also rise in low productivity industries in order for them to retain or attract workers.</li><li>Over time, society will continue to consume goods and services from both industries (low productivity growth and high productivity growth). Assuming the ratio of the consumption levels between these two industry groups remains about the same, then the proportion of people employed in low productivity industries must increase. This is because less workers are needed in industries with greater productivity to produce their goods and services.</li></ol><p>These two postulates go some way to explaining why low productivity industries tend to dominate advanced economies. However the extent to which it causes this phenomenon is subject to debate and studies.</p><p>My personal view is that this theory could be improved by taking the following into account:</p><ol><li>As the proportion of people employed in the industry with high productivity reduces, its ability to affect wages in less productive industries should decrease.</li><li>Productivity improvements are hard. They often involve adoption of new innovations which can have significant risk attached. Management will in most cases only take on these risks if substantial pressures are placed on the business. Competition or responding to changing market demand are examples of such pressures.</li><li>If competition is driving productivity improvement, we would expect that consumers would receive most of the benefits of productivity improvements — not workers.</li><li>It is far easier for goods producing businesses to transfer their operations (with associated employment) to other countries with lower costs.</li></ol><p>The real challenge for advanced economies is improving the rate of productivity increase in service industries. I believe that dominant factor causing this low productivity increase is:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Productivity improvement is hard — there are substantial risks associated with it.</em></strong></blockquote><p>When attempting to implement these improvements, management needs to balance the cost benefits of the improvements against:</p><ul><li>The disruption of changing existing working processes and the associated loss of output;</li><li>Dealing with people’s resistance to change;</li><li>Having to manage difficulties in changes to job roles — especially if this involves job losses;</li><li>The possibility of the implementation failure and the resultant consequences.</li></ul><p>While we would like to think that this balance will be struck in the interest of the organisation, it is quite likely that the self interest of individuals in upper management plays a large role in deciding on this balance. The ability to balance risks to favour career progression is an important skill needed to reach upper management. It potentially only takes one bad outcome from a risky decision to stall career development. So once in upper management (or CEO or member of the board), these individuals will likely view risky productivity related decisions through the prism of keeping their current role in the organisation (with its high income, power and prestige) and also further progression.</p><p>So if the organisation’s stake holders or the wider general community are not demanding productivity improvements within an organisation, then there is a large incentive for upper management to <strong>avoid</strong> tackling improvement.</p><p>In goods industries, manufacturing industries need to innovate and reduce costs to keep up with the competition. Therefore stake holders, such as share holders, expect management to improve productivity and factor in its risks when assessing management’s performance. This assessment refocuses management to balance the risks in improvement implementations against the risk of not doing them.</p><p>However in services industries there is less competition. It is harder for consumers to compare outputs and it tends to be harder to switch between suppliers. Therefore stake holders are more focused in avoiding disruption than in productivity improvements. This is especially prevalent in government organisations where political considerations need to be taken into account.</p><p>So how do we improve productivity in service industries?</p><p>Firstly we need to recognise that management’s behaviour in these industries is entirely rational. To paraphrase Adam Smith: “self-interest is the ‘invisible hand’ that guides the economy”. What is needed is to change either the expectations or the risk associated with implementing productivity changes.</p><p>I believe there is far greater scope in reducing the risks than increasing the expectations. Risks can be tackled with technology and organisational change. Expectations are more aligned with social change which is a far harder challenge.</p><p>So in summary, my variation of Cost Disease is:</p><ul><li>An industry’s adoption of productivity improvements will be determined by the following 2 factors:<br>1. The risks associated with implementing the improvements,<br>2. The expectations upon upper management in the industry’s organisations to improve productivity.</li><li>Upper management will strike a balance between these 2 factors that best lines up with their personal career objectives.</li><li>Productivity growth in an industry, will be driven by the extent that this balance leans towards the expectations factor.</li><li>Conversely, employment growth will be largest in industries where upper management decide that the career risks associated with productivity improvements outweigh the productivity expectations upon them.</li></ul><p>[1] <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=75494214">By BoH — data from Bureau of Labor Statistics, CC BY-SA 4.0</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/post/a-variation-of-cost-disease/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em> on June 12, 2024.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da6a3c0f37ed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Opposite of monopoly]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/opposite-of-monopoly-f3dd6fb10853?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3dd6fb10853</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[monopoly]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[words]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[english]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antonyms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 May 2024 22:44:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-08T22:44:07.065Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_K81BDFOgADmchd9JWSn7Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>What is the opposite (antonym) of the word “Monopoly”?</p><p>You are probably looking for a word that means <strong>competitive market</strong>. In fact, people have suggested that you actually use these 2 words as an antonym for monopoly¹. Clear and easily understood.</p><p>However if you really want a single word antonym, you could consider using <strong>Polypoly</strong> (or the alternative spelling <strong>Polyopoly</strong>). It means: “The presence of a large number of relatively small buyers and sellers, none of whom can influence the price of commodities”². This sounds like “competitive market” however this word is no longer in <a href="https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=monopoly%2Cpolypoly&amp;year_start=1900&amp;year_end=2000&amp;corpus=15&amp;smoothing=3&amp;share=">common usage</a>, so use with care.</p><p>If monopoly is where one <em>seller</em> dominates a market, what do you call a market dominated by one <em>buyer</em>? There is a word for that: <strong>Monopsony</strong>³. An example would be the Department of Defence for local suppliers. It is an opposite but maybe not an antonym. However it may be the opposite you are looking for.</p><ol><li><a href="https://ell.stackexchange.com/questions/8161/what-is-the-word-that-is-the-antonym-of-monopoly">StackExchange: What is the word that is the antonym of “monopoly”?</a></li><li><a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/polypoly">Wiktionary: polypoly</a></li><li><a href="https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/171868/what-is-the-opposite-of-a-monopoly">StackExchange: What is the opposite of a monopoly?</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3dd6fb10853" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introduction to innovation diffusion]]></title>
            <link>https://pbklink.medium.com/introduction-to-innovation-diffusion-2d2d372dedc6?source=rss-57700e003262------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d2d372dedc6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[research-productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diffusion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Paul Klink]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 May 2024 23:00:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-07T19:49:47.917Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ODEakm71ucTHRxsW8qBZOw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In Australia only 2%¹ of companies actively engage in the development of new and novel innovations. The other 98% are adopters of existing innovations. This adoption of innovation is called innovation diffusion. This diffusion can involve dated technology. Let me give you an example:</p><p>My wife runs her one person psychology practice. Like many others, over the years she has evolved her business scheduling, billing and admin so that it can all be run from her mobile. However she was using a generic accounting package. Her accounting consumed about 8 hours in a week.</p><p>Several years ago we investigated alternatives to accounting packages and found that online medical practice platforms were a good fit for her business. We chose one and scheduled a trial on her holidays. However it was a radical change in process and overwhelming at that time. 6 months later we again attempted the migration with success.</p><p>It did not take long for my wife to become proficient with the new package. She found that her weekly accounting time reduced to 2½ hours a week. Approximately a 12% increase in her productivity. Considering the average productivity increase in Australia was about 0.5%² in the last 5 years, my wife contributed more than her share in that year.</p><p>Research into innovation diffusion has been carried out since the late 19th century³, In 1962, Everett Rogers created a systematic theory covering innovation diffusion. (It is interesting seeing how our experience of adopting a new accounting system fits into this system and why we did not do it earlier.) There have been approximately 4000 articles published on this subject however critics complain that research in this field is stagnant. They complain that these later studies and articles explore variations in the theory but not in a cohesive way³.</p><p>I find this stagnation surprising as I assume there are greater opportunities for productivity improvements in an economy through innovation diffusion than with the development of new innovation. Will let you know if I find any study covering this in future posts.</p><p><a href="https://prodxchg.com/">https://prodxchg.com</a> — An exchange combining share registry and trading and innovation diffusion for MSMEs.</p><ol><li><a href="https://www.pc.gov.au/inquiries/completed/productivity/report/">https://www.pc.gov.au/inquiries/completed/productivity/report/</a></li><li><a href="https://www.pc.gov.au/ongoing/productivity-performance">https://www.pc.gov.au/ongoing/productivity-performance</a></li><li><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_innovations">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_innovations</a></li></ol><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://paul.klink.au/post/innovation-diffusion/"><em>https://paul.klink.au</em></a><em> on May 5, 2024.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d2d372dedc6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>