<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Dingus PhD on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Dingus PhD on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:55:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@pdingus/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Silo Experiment and the nature of Human Nature]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/the-silo-experiment-e95fefce111e?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e95fefce111e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 05 Sep 2026 22:56:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-09T21:04:32.588Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/515/1*dMfqeqMSfCIA-8Bzhb4i4g.png" /><figcaption>Nonlinear Attractor (Wikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve written several science fiction books. Historically, science fiction has been a “what if …” way of examining society and human nature given extraordinary circumstances, like new technologies, isolation, and new cultural paradigms. These include Thomas More’s “Utopia,” H.G Wells “Things to Come,” Ian Banks “Culture,” and even the works of Karl Marx. All these works share the theme of imagining a better human society. Many of these works have a profound affect on society, ask most people who lived through post war Eastern Europe, or the Cultural Revolution. Even today, many of the tech-bro manifestos borrow from science fiction, Elon Musk’s Grok, Colossus, and Starship are all Sci-fi references.</p><p>The theme that permeates most of my stories, and many of these others, is a central question asked by philosophers and sociologists: “Can human beings form a truly civilized society?” Typically, we think of civilization as the transition from hunter-gatherers to agrarians since an agrarian society can establish itself in one place and grow into cities and states that promote a higher level of organization and material productivity and art. The city of Ur in Mesopotamia, which we now call Iraq, was probably one of the first such examples. But this is not what I mean when I ponder civilization. In all of recorded history that I’m familiar with, most of what we call civilized societies establish and grew by acquisition of wealth, land, and resources through expansionary wars. Internally, most people were governed by rulers and kings who ruthlessly acquired wealth and power for their clans and sycophants through coercion, corruption, and military force. No, what I mean by civilization is what the Athenians tried to do and failed or what the Christians inspired by the sermon on the mount tried to do and failed as well; a society responsive to the will of the governed that “do unto others what they would want done unto them” was the operative axiom. I think that same spirit is embedded in that singularly famous line in the United States Declaration of Independence: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all (persons) are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”</p><p>To the best of my knowledge, there has been no such civilization that has ever existed on Earth for any significant period of time that possessed these qualities. The phrase: “We hold these truths to be self-evident…” is particularly puzzling. If this quality of human existence is so obvious, why is it essentially impossible to achieve? This has been the central problem to solve in almost all my stories. My answer to this question is that human behavior, en-mass, is governed not by declarative construction, i.e. declarations on paper, or architectures drawn up by intellectuals, but by biology. The design of all animals on Earth, including people, was forged in adaptive evolution compelled by a hostile environment. This is consistent with the second law of thermodynamics, the one we call entropy. In a non scientific sense, entropy, as it applies to large physical systems, says that those systems evolve in time to become more disordered. In fact, time as we notice it in our lives, is the direction of entropy, i.e. things wear out as time goes forward. When you are born, you are in a high state of order. Your body was assembled from a large number of disparate, disorganized molecules into a highly organized organism. As time goes on, you become more disorganized, break down, and eventually die and again become totally disorganized. That is the direction of the flow of time. So, it is natural that a human placed in an environment that compels entropy, by its very nature, would be hostile — entropy, or time, is constantly trying to kill you. Add to that environment the climate, the necessity to find food and shelter, other living things in competition with each other and with you, and finally, other bands of people in mutual competition. So, what does nature do in response? It hardwires you for survival, at any cost. On one side, there’s the environment; on the other side is you, both nature, both programmed by nature with different goals. And the way that nature promotes this “instinct” for survival is through emotions. These emotions must force you into a position of control over your environment so that you can procreate and continue. Throw into the mix that survival of the individual depends on survival of a group, which increases the individual’s chances of survival, and eventually you get tribes, states, and nations that do whatever they can to gain control over competitors, egged on mostly by fear, with a little envy and lust thrown in just to top off the toxic soup.</p><p>I know this sounds pessimistic, but there is a bright spot. Years ago, I read a commencement speech by Sir Alfred Whitehead, a close associate of Bertrand Russell and a mathematician and philosopher. The title of the speech was “The Function of Reason.” It was fascinating because it purported to explain an adaptation that superficially did not enhance survival in the same way as strength or speed or cunning. As it turns out, it was this uniquely human adaptation that ensured human survival far beyond any other. But this particular quality does something else, something emergent in the same sense of something that exceeds the sum of its parts. It gives people the ability to reflect upon their actions in a way that violates the programming. People have developed a “moral” sense, something that superficially has nothing to do with crude survival. In fact, it is this quality that leads to empathy, tolerance, and compromise. It is the reason that some people give without wanting anything in return, just because there is a need, and they can do it. So, if we have this preternatural gift, why is human history one long bloodbath? Why is it that we can just see a fleeting image of the promised land, but never really get there? It is because humanity is a distribution, a bell curve, from the criminally corrupt to the saintly altruistic. The problem for humanity is that the average value is not in the right place; it has been skewed by the necessity to survive, and it is the average value that dictates history.</p><p>I thought it would be instructive to model this dynamic in the same way that complex, nonlinear systems are modeled in physics. What you have to do is find a set of parameters, in this case behavioral qualities, that are not derivative of each other and that span the entire behavioral space. Another way of saying this is that any behavior of any individual is a linear combination of these qualities weighted for a particular individual by coefficients so that the average behavior of that individual is reproduced. This will become clear in the table below, where these qualities are enumerated and described:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Y6cfXL66PGrWaPhPkkh2w.png" /><figcaption>Spanning basis set</figcaption></figure><p>The column whose heading is “Axis” enumerates the qualities into two other columns; this is a ten dimensional space whose axes have positive and negative qualities associated with them like positive and negative numbers. The qualities are divided into what I subjectively think of as bad and good qualities. The column labeled “Self-Expanding” denotes those traits that I consider destructive (negative numbers), the column labeled “Other-Regarding” denotes traits that I consider constructive (positive numbers). In a sense, I am qualifying good and evil. What is good is constructive; what is evil is destructive. Let us denote Axis 1, column 1 as (1,1) and Axis 1, column 2 as (1,2). Then quality (8,2) = “long-term sustainability.” Any individual is a weighted linear sum of these traits. For example, we have individuals A and B:</p><p>A = 0.33*(1,1) + 0.33*(3,1) + 0.33*(6,1); weights = 0.33, 0.33, 0.33 all other weight = 0</p><p>B = 0.33*(1,2) + 0.33*(3,2) + 0.33*(6,2); weights = 0.33, 0.33, 0.33 all other weight = 0</p><p>These are two cartoon individuals constructed to demonstrate how this works.</p><p>Individual A is on the bad side of the bell curve. He is one third hoarding + one third coercive + one third violent. Notice that the sum of his weights = 1, which demonstrates that’s all he is; he’s a psychopath.</p><p>Individual B is on the good side of the bell curve. He is one third sharing + one third fair + one third caring. Notice that the sum of his weights = 1, which demonstrates that’s all he is; he’s a saint.</p><p>The average for this population of two people = 0; the population is in between good and evil. It’s a wash. Historically, this population will move along its world-line trajectory through time, encountering various obstacles and will, on average, remain stagnant in terms of cultural (civilizational) progress. It’s like the hamster going round and round on his wheel, moving, but never going anywhere. An interesting point can be made here. Suppose one of these individuals were removed; that would change the whole trajectory of civilization to be either good or evil. Remember, this is a cartoon; a population is not one or two people, but this exercise demonstrates how this works. I believe that the whole ten parameter spanning set could produce interesting results over a population of, say, 50,000 over 3,000 years of obstacles encountered in human history.</p><p>So I decided to run the experiment. But I did it in reverse. What we have are crucial points of human history: wars, expansion, various forms of government — monarchs, feudal, democracy. They come and go, but there is a trajectory. So the experiment was: given human history and the ten-point spanning set, what would the most probable weights for each quality be so as to reconstruct the average individual that would reflect that human history? I gave the task to four AI’s, since this is what they do. They are pattern recognizers and can perform regression to determine the weights of the average individual consistent with several dominant historical situations characteristic of an age spanning a time period of 3000 years.</p><p>I asked the AI’s: “What Cluster most typifies human history from 1000 BC to the present as a phase-space Attractor?” The task specified the spanning set of ten qualities as described. An Attractor in phase-space means, as time goes on in this ten dimensional space, the trajectories of the 50,000 individuals comprising the population of a civilization tend to cluster or converge on a particular set of qualities, and those qualities give you the average that characterizes the civilization. Each civilization that rises and falls is averaged over all those that span the 3000 years by finding a common cluster, if one exists. So here is the result:</p><p>The four AI’s unanimously find that human history from 1000 BC to the present is dominated by a single, self-reinforcing attractor cluster, it’s dominant qualities are: hierarchical, coalitionary, bent on resource extraction. This basin is defined by high resource extraction, hierarchical power, in-group cooperation, out-group competition, wealth concentration, institutional centralization, moral boundary enforcement, and strong legitimation systems. While counter-forces like empathy, redistribution, and universalism periodically disrupt this pattern, the attractor remains dominant due to its scalability, recursive recurrence, and institutional stability.</p><p>The coefficients for dominant qualities are:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8lo1Kef1t1T4FyQinwSIYw.png" /><figcaption>Result of regression</figcaption></figure><p>In short, your typical individual that characterizes human behavior averaged over all regions, governance, ethnicities, and races, through time, is someone who forms hierarchical coalitions, marked by high resource extraction, centralized power, and strongly allied to a particular group in opposition to others. That’s the average value of your bell curve, and that explains, in this model at least, why human history has been as oppressive and bloody as it has been. All these terrible wars and oppression throughout history are not isolated anomalies; they are biologically susceptible features of human nature as formed through adaptive evolution in a hostile environment. Apparently, nature doesn’t care about morality, because morality is a human construct. What nature cares about is continuance.</p><p>So, I think the central question is; how does one move the average value of the human distribution in a direction more consistent to achieving what we might envision as true civilization? A form of civilization that can culturally advance without oppression, coercion, and war. Implied in this question is to what extent does an admixture of environment and biology determine the average outcome? It’s the old nature and nurture hypothesis applied to civilization as a whole. In order to move the average, you can try technological biology, artificial selection, or environmental reinvention, or some add-mixture of all of these. Some might say, wait a minute, are we talking about eugenics? The formal definition of eugenics is: “a set of beliefs and practices that aim to improve the genetic quality of a human population through (forced) selective breeding.” The key phrase here is “forced selective breeding.” In the past, this was always done or suggested by a ruling minority and applied to the masses through coercion, exactly what we’re trying to eliminate. And historically, the ruling minority was always a race, ethnic group, or religion. What we’re exploring here is the effect of environment on biological susceptibility.</p><p>In one of my stories, Proteus Rising, I offer this statement in italics on the first page of the first chapter: <em>“What if I told you I’d discovered a genetic cure for Original Sin…” </em>The idea here is to try to undo some of the more toxic gifts of adaptive evolution, through genetics, to a cross-section of people. But, to do that, science and technology would have to be far more advanced than what we have today. And in the story, even with that advanced technology, there are certain issues like: what about societal momentum; wouldn’t the emergence of such different people be violently opposed by those currently in charge? And who decides what better people should be? In the story, environmental reinvention happens by transporting the story to a well-developed colony on Mars; in that sense, society has been disconnected from the ancestral conflicts and hatreds passed on from one generation to the next on Earth. And the genetic piece is made more “natural” since the harsh environment on Mars makes genetic therapy proforma for everyone, even new immigrants.</p><p>One reviewer got the real sense of the story: “At its core, this book is about flaws in human nature that have plagued us throughout history. We fear people who are different, and our first response to conflict is usually aggression. Proteus Rising’s plot unfolds around an ingenious way to correct these flaws through genetic engineering. Ironically, this likely solution to chronic war, bigotry, and social conflict is very threatening to a society comprised of a species that’s accustomed to being dominant. The very existence of a solution triggers the fears and aggressive response it was intended to solve. When reading this book, even the most pacifist among us will be inclined to consider whether they could accept a path to peace and harmony that would involve surrendering control and eventually being replaced by a new species.”</p><p>In another story, The End of the World, I take a different tact to biological intervention. In The End of the World, environmental reinvention happens “naturally” by the extinction of most of humanity by its own hand; an outcome predicated by the average of the human distribution not being in the right place. The story proceeds by postulating: what if the human distribution could be cherry picked for behavioral traits by who survives, and society restarted? In both stories, I try to develop these ideas on the fringe of speculation, but with human interaction as the legitimizing thread.</p><p>For this essay, however, let’s explore a different route to moving civilization to a different point of stability, which is conceptually developed in Hugh Howey’s novels Wool, Shift, and Dust, and in the TV adaptation, The Silo. This story is interesting because the idea of environmental reinvention goes to an oppressive extreme. I’m not going to include some of the dramatic aspects of the story, like what the characters in the book do to bring about this dark situation, or the details of how they maintain control, because I’m only interested in the core idea, not the book in particular. The actual construction of the scenario in the books is the ultimate crime against humanity in an attempt to re-engineer humanity.</p><p>So, suppose the world as we know it disappears in an all-out nuclear war, and a group of 50,000 people, in 50 underground silos, each a mile deep, in rural Georgia, are equipped with sufficient supplies, power, and air for 500 years. The occupants of each silo are made to forget, presumably through pharmaceuticals, that any other silos exist. Each of the 50 silos, containing 10,000 people each, are given an instruction book of do’s and don’ts called The Pact, which of course, being people, they turn into a bible of sorts. People will do anything not to think, and that’s what makes it work. The silo inhabitants have no knowledge of human history, what the Earth was like before the silos, who built the silos, and most importantly, why the silos were built. They are a combination of all races and ethnicities and subject to the same scary task of survival, so in that, they find unity. They can not go outside. Even though it’s been 300 years that their descendants have been in the silo (the US is 250 years old, just for perspective), going outside brings death within 10 or 15 minutes. They know this because there is a window in a large dining hall where they see people who go out die in a bleak, dead, gray Earth. Ultimately, we learn the situation is maintained as a master plan to recreate society in a way that gives it a better chance at meaningful survival. The Earth is not really poisoned, but anyone who tries to leave a silo is killed through dispersed technology to make it look like the world is poisoned. The planners have determined that 500 years is the right time scale for society to reset through amnesia, and that a deadly competition between silos to survive (the silo people don’t know this, so this is a way of assessing the group with the best survivability IQ) is the selection process.</p><p>The thing I like about The Silo, as a story, is that Howey really gets into the micro conflicts that naturally occur between groups. Conflicts always develop between leaders and workers, between those who question and those who don’t, between those afraid to rock the boat, and those afraid the boat will tip over. So, it isn’t clear, even under these extreme conditions, that humanity wouldn’t somehow find its way back to that unfortunate attractor. In the selection process, perhaps the temperaments of the Silo’s inhabitants weren’t sufficiently thought out. So even here, whether this arcane experiment changes society’s trajectory is an open question.</p><p>The English political philosopher John Gray is best known for his philosophical pessimism and critique of the Enlightenment, humanism, and the belief in human progress. Gray argues that while science and technology accumulate over time, moral and political progress is an illusion. That human beings do not fundamentally change; history is an unending cycle of recurring conflicts rather than a linear ascent toward a better world. So, to summarize, nothing in history changes other than the props, and the props make no fundamental difference whether they be technology, government, or religion; the human trajectory always returns to a particular attractor that defines human society.</p><p>Any complex nonlinear process has a characteristic that can be decomposed into two properties: the trend, which is the average, and the volatile excursions around the trend, which are the chaotic particulars of current events. All of these excursions are perturbations away from the trend.</p><p>I think that’s what makes this an open question. I think that human society has changed with history, albeit slowly and unevenly in fits and starts. In the volatility of that trajectory, there is hope that through a combination of organic and cognitive change, somehow we can find another orbit to a different attractor, one more in line with what many of us hope for ourselves and everybody else.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e95fefce111e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The latest claim of a Reaction-less Drive]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/the-latest-claim-of-a-reaction-less-drive-9f8d60a3f0fa?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f8d60a3f0fa</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Aug 2026 21:26:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-12T22:36:30.480Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/738/0*RkSXEV3BDp4q6ub9" /></figure><p>There have been several claims in recent years about reactionless ways of creating a net force on an object without an action-reaction fuel based system, like those used in every known way to propel something through space. A recent claim, the EM drive, which was an asymmetric EM resonant cavity, was disproved by Martin Tajmar’s team at TU Dresden by showing that the apparent micro-thrust measurements were experimental errors caused by thermal expansion and power cables interacting with Earth’s magnetic field rather than propellantless space propulsion. The central problem with claims like this stem from Newton’s third law. For an isolated system, all internal forces cancel, and any net force requires a momentum sink, i.e. a way of carrying momentum away so that the center of mass of the isolated system balances that momentum by moving. That’s a fancy way of stating action — momentum sink, reaction — isolated object moves. If you propose reactionless drive, there are only two options: Newton’s law is somehow violated by new physics, or the vacuum, through some exotic physics, becomes the momentum sink.</p><p>The latest claim of a reactionless drive comes from Dr Charles Buhler’s team at Exodus Propulsion Technologies, LLC. Dr Buhler is also Lead Scientist of the Electrostatics and Surface Physics Laboratory at NASA Kennedy Space Center. I heard that Exodus had put out a slide set claiming that they had shown a thrust equal to 1g, experimentally, in vacuum. Sounded extraordinary, so I looked at the model they were proposing for why this works. Apparently, the idea is founded on experiments by Thomas Townsend Brown, developed alongside his mentor Paul Alfred Biefeld in the 1920s. It’s known as the Biefeld–Brown effect and describes a physical phenomenon where high voltage applied to an asymmetrical capacitor creates a net propulsive force at the smaller, sharper electrode. Imagine a conductor formed by a flat plate on which a pointy cone is mounted, but separated from the plate by an insulator. Now each part of the object is charged, the cone positive, the plate negative. The static electric field lines emerge from the cone and terminate on the plate. The field lines on the point cone are closer together, and those on the plate are farther apart. That means the electric field strength on the cone is greater than that on the plate. Pressure due to a static electric field is:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/118/1*05YVm-QGF92Pmp-AVVlu2Q.png" /><figcaption>Static electrostatic pressure</figcaption></figure><p>Since the electric field is greater on the cone, the pressure on the cone is greater than that on the plate. However, we know from statics that the internal forces on the object create stresses on the material, but these internal forces all cancel. There is no net force. Also, one must remember there are no photons associated with a static field. Only accelerated charges produce photons, so there is no pressure due to expressed photons. And finally, the stress-energy tensor of the electric field integrated around the whole device is identically zero. The only other possibility is the electric field is polarizing the vacuum, and because the field is asymmetric, there is a net force. In this case the vacuum would be the sink, although in standard QED the object producing the field and the vacuum are not separate and the vacuum doesn’t contribute to momentum transfer. But, even if this were a possibility, the effects are much too small at the voltages mentioned (twelve orders of magnitude too small). So, I scratched my head and couldn’t understand how something like this works. I downloaded their patent.</p><p>(12) INTERNATIONAL APPLICATION PUBLISHED UNDER THE PATENT COOPERATION TREATY (PCT) (19) World Intellectual Property &gt; Organization International Bureau10) International Publication Number (43) International Publication Date = WO 2020/159603 A2 06 August 2020 (06.08.2020) WIPOIPCT. Title: SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR GENERATING FORCES USING ASYMMETRICAL ELECTROSTATIC PRESSURE</p><p>I read the patent and found some items related to the method of variations, but that step didn’t look right since it’s not derivative of least-action of a Lagrangian along a path. I fed the patent into Claude Sonnet 5 and asked Claude to examine the physics and evaluate the credibility of the claim on the basis of known physics. Claude came back with this analysis:</p><p>Short answer: no. The specific claim — a static, internal asymmetric electric field producing a net external force on an isolated object in vacuum, with no reaction mass, no field momentum, and no external interaction — violates momentum conservation, and the “derivation” offered to get around that doesn’t actually hold up.</p><p>The starting physics is legitimate: the electrostatic pressure on a conductor surface is indeed ε₀E²/2 (Pa), a standard result you’ll find in Griffiths or Jackson. Computing field strengths and pressures over complicated electrode geometries with COMSOL/FEMM is also perfectly legitimate numerical work. The core problem is momentum conservation for electrostatics. For a charge-neutral, isolated system with a purely static E-field (no B-field), you can compute the total electromagnetic force on the object by integrating the Maxwell stress tensor over <em>any closed surface</em> that fully encloses the object. For static fields, that integral is guaranteed to vanish if nothing outside the surface is exerting a force — internal electrostatic forces between parts of an isolated system always cancel in pairs (Newton’s third law applies rigorously to electrostatics). You can absolutely get local pressure imbalances on <em>individual</em> surfaces (which is what their asymmetric-electrode calculations show), but when you close the surface around the <em>whole device</em> — including the return path, the voltage source, and any structural members — the net force integrates to zero. There is no known loophole for purely electrostatic (zero-frequency, zero-B-field) configurations.</p><p>The patent’s own text seems aware of this, which is why it goes out of its way to state the device does <em>not</em> rely on field momentum (E×B, which requires a B-field and is zero here) and does <em>not</em> rely on “hidden momentum” (a relativistic effect for moving charge carriers, also not applicable to static configurations). But having ruled out the only two known mechanisms by which a static-field EM system could carry momentum, they haven’t found a third — they’ve just asserted a force exists anyway.</p><p>The derivation itself (Eqs. 1–11) doesn’t hold together.<strong> </strong>A few of the steps:</p><ul><li>They start from “0 = ½Mv² + U,” an unusual and unjustified premise (total energy of a system equal to zero) rather than deriving anything from Maxwell’s equations or Newtonian mechanics directly.</li><li>They substitute v → dx/dt into an equation where v already appears algebraically, which is not a legitimate operator substitution.</li><li>The key step, “Udt = −tdU,” is justified only by a loose analogy to the principle of least action (setting δS = 0), but δ(Ut) = 0 is not equivalent to δ∫L dt = 0 — it’s an ad hoc postulate dressed up in Lagrangian language, not something actually derived from it.</li></ul><p>The output of this chain, P(t) = ε₀t[E₂²A₂ − E₁²A₁], says a perfectly static, unchanging field configuration produces momentum that grows <em>linearly and indefinitely with time</em> — i.e., a constant force forever from a fixed charge distribution doing nothing. That’s equivalent to a perpetual, self-powered engine with no energy input after setup, which should itself be a red flag independent of the E&amp;M argument.</p><p>This is really the modern iteration of Thomas Townsend Brown’s “Biefeld-Brown effect” / asymmetric-capacitor thrusters, and the document is candid about the prior art here — which actually undercuts its own claim:</p><ul><li>Talley’s 1991 Air Force–sponsored vacuum test found <strong>no detectable propulsive force</strong> once in high vacuum.</li><li>NASA’s Canning et al. 2004 report concluded ACT devices show <strong>null thrust in vacuum</strong> and that the atmospheric effect is “fully explained by a very simple theory that uses only electrostatic forces and the transfer of momentum by multiple collisions” — i.e., <strong>ion wind</strong>, a real but mundane electrohydrodynamic effect (charged air molecules get pushed toward the low-field electrode, and momentum conservation pushes the device the other way). Ion wind requires a gas to push against and vanishes in vacuum, which is exactly why it can’t propel a spacecraft.</li></ul><p>The test data in this patent (force-meter/pendulum measurements, epoxy-potted devices, tens to hundreds of μN at tens of kV) appears to be done in <em>air</em>, not vacuum — which is the one regime where these effects are well known to appear and where the “ion wind fully explains it” account (from their own cited NASA source) applies. Sealing the device in epoxy or a plastic bag reduces but doesn’t rigorously rule out trace-gas ionization, outgassing, or triboelectric/Coulomb coupling to the surrounding grounded test apparatus — and μN-scale signals are exactly the size where such artifacts live. No genuine hard-vacuum thrust data is presented for the claim that matters most (spacecraft propulsion).</p><p>Bottom line</p><ul><li>The local electrostatic-pressure math is fine; the leap to a <em>net</em> force on an isolated system is not, and directly contradicts a rigorous, well-established conservation law.</li><li>The custom “derivation” of momentum from static fields contains non-standard, physically unmotivated steps.</li><li>A WIPO/USPTO patent publication is not peer review; patent offices assess novelty and enablement of the <em>described mechanism</em>, not whether the underlying physics is actually correct. Plenty of over-unity and reactionless-drive patents have been granted.</li></ul><p>I personally want one of these ideas to work. And it may be that an effect is measured by experiment that isn’t supported by current theory. That would be exciting and would uncover new physics. Perhaps they got the experiment right and the analysis wrong. Like anything else in science, their result must be confirmed by other independent labs. There’s a chance (although small) that they’ve discovered something new.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f8d60a3f0fa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Postmortem of the American Experiment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/a-postmortem-of-the-american-experiment-efd08be10858?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/efd08be10858</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 May 2026 21:56:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-14T22:21:33.330Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KdOCpUKjkrj0tVYQYHfq3w.jpeg" /><figcaption>1776 — The dream is documented</figcaption></figure><p>This is not an article to bash America, quite the contrary. In my opinion, the idea of America surreptitiously stated in its founding documents is probably the greatest social aspiration ever put forward by human beings. There are many philosophical and religious treaties in human history that envision a grand place for humanity in creation, but these are abstractions with little physical substance and less plausibility in experiential reality. The founding documents of the United States are different; they are a structural blueprint for the highest social ideals that centuries of thinkers debated, but in their most honest moments, never thought could ever be made real at scale. So what are these utopian embodiments in the idea of America that I’m talking about? In a nutshell, they are: every person has the right to freedom, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; all people are created equal (i.e. are worthy of equal consideration); all people are entitled to equal protection under the law; and nobody is above the law. One of the most basic and powerful words in this description is the phrase, “all people.” The entirety of human history is: tribal, sexist, racist, and the division between rich and poor. I would argue that these characteristics are not manifestations of environment, or aptitude, or birthright, or epoch.</p><p>These characteristics derive from biology, from an evolution whose singular goal is survival. Through hundreds and thousands of generations of the human type, people have been forged by nature to be what they are at an instinctual level. The joke is that something unexpected happened on humanity’s journey into the future. In its trial-and-error random walk, nature came up with the neocortex, which gave people the ability to form abstract notions beyond eating, sleeping, defecating, and shelter. The neocortex is clearly the superlative tool to facilitate survival; the domination of the Earth by humans is a testament to that. While many people admire physical strength as the greatest human asset, in fact, it is the least. Humans are pound for pound some of the weakest animals on the planet, and yet, they are the top predators — why? Because the massive human brain consumes about 20% of caloric intake — nature can either power the muscles or power the brain, but not both simultaneously and effectively.</p><p>So this is where the trouble begins. Most animals are suited to their environment for a time. People often describe animals and the “land” existing in harmony; I would describe it as equilibrium, for a time at least. Most animals&#39; lives are hard, and they don’t live that long. And once the environment changes, many become extinct, no matter how physically strong they are. But humans, in terms of population, have continued to grow and dominate, not because they are in equilibrium with the land, but because they change it to suit their needs. The trouble is that this creates a tension between thousands of years of instinctual programming and the ability to imagine something other than survival. This imagining has taken the form of art, philosophy, government, and science. Inevitably, much of this imagining is in conflict with what came before. Some psychologists have suggested that psychopathy is not a derangement, but an adaptation. Under the pressures of laws and social order, the old programming asserts itself: tribalism, social dominance, narcissism. The brain can not erase itself and start from scratch; it has to build on structures that are already there: the brainstem and hypothalamus, the basal ganglia, and the amygdala. These structures remember: involuntary physiological responses tied to survival, feeding or territorial responses, unconscious responses to threats (like fear or aggression). They act independently, like background, as people imagine utopia, and in many cases, as circumstances arise, they are in conflict with each other. And as civilization becomes more ubiquitous, the internal rationalization involved in squaring this circle becomes more arcane both in human writing ( Friedrich Nietzsche), and in actions (electing demagogues).</p><p>And so, here we are, in 2026 America. The vaulted 21st century. How many times have we heard lately: “This can’t happen, it’s the 21st century.” America was formed on a dream. The dream that we could become something other than what we have been. And it’s not clear to me that it’s impossible. But what has become clear is that the founding formula, the founding documents, are not a sufficient condition to realize this dream because the foundational biological programming is very strong. America has violated all the instinctual red-lines: multi-ethnic, multi-racial, gender-neutral (under the law), multi-religious, robust immigration. It’s a miracle it’s worked as well as it has up to this point. But within the last two decades, an ominous backsliding has occurred, culminating in the election of an administration that is transparent in its contempt for the founding principles. The astonishing thing about the current situation is how clearly stated this contempt is, how many obvious lies have been told by national figures, how media has normalized this corruption, how well-established scientific facts have been denied. What has happened is not an accident. Even now, an administration that is steeped in corruption and has severely damaged the economy, social order, and the international standing of the United States is supported by roughly 40% of the population. What went wrong?</p><p>There are a couple of fundamental principles at play that must be realized and accepted for something like America to work, because the default organizational state of humanity is feudalism. You have a few kings, or warlords, or oligarchs, or authoritarians in charge, and a population of tenant workers. Socrates realized this when he said democracy is incompatible with human nature, whereas Sparta is — a bunch of soldiers under one whip. The underlying principle that must be respected for a civilization like America to exist is that government is the embodiment of liberal civilization. Liberal here assumes its classical meaning, respect for human rights. Government is not an accessory; it is not there to just protect a country’s borders, it is the fundamental structure of society. It is the agency that ensures all those rights enshrined in the founding documents, and it should be held in the highest regard. Ronald Reagan did the country a supreme disservice when he stated that government should be so weak that you should be able to drown it in a bathtub, that the worst thing you could hear is government wanting to help. I’m sure that he didn’t realize how destructive what he was saying was, that the idea of rules impinging on your “freedoms” strikes a resonant cord with the primitive instincts constantly working in the background, but those statements started the backslide. Once people hear that the rules don’t matter, that what you want right now is what counts, or that what you and those like you want supersede the benefits to the whole of society, you’re on your way down to that default state — that animal state with its exquisite equilibrium.</p><p>In order for something like America to work, one should also understand the relationship between a government and an economy. The second most damaging idea that occurred in the late 20th century in America is that unbridled, ultra-capitalism is the route to societal prosperity — it is not. This idea was enshrined in the late 1990’s as “greed is good.” What is greed? Greed is an excessive, selfish desire to accumulate wealth, power, or possessions far beyond what is necessary for comfort or survival. Think about that, greed is good, and everybody cheers, what do you think will happen? Twenty-five years later, what happened was we elected a demagogue, he empowered a group of billionaire oligarchs, and a major portion of the population is on their way to becoming tenants. Why is anyone surprised? I guess it “felt” good at the time.</p><p>So how should government and the economy interact? First, I want to state that capitalism, where appropriate, is the right form of economics. It is a biological fact that people want to own things, that people want the opportunity to shape their personal destinies — that’s a good thing. But capitalism must be applied with intelligence; markets are not self-correcting, and if markets are not properly regulated, they are usually manipulated. Government should encapsulate an economy, not the other way around. That means that all of those rights enshrined in the founding papers should be the guardrails that bound the behavior of the economy. And it should be realized that there are parts of society that are incompatible with the profit motive. These include healthcare, the news media, education, prisons, etc., anything that can be ascribed to the public good. And for a society based on democracy to function, elections must be publicly funded — full stop. The government should be elected in the disinfectant of daylight, all money supporting candidates through media must be capped at a reasonable amount and the contributors fully disclosed along with a clear documentation of their financial interest. Remember, if you want to understand a crime, follow the money.</p><p>So, at this point in human history, it is not clear that democracy, in its untainted form, can exist, given human nature. Looking at history, we see the same patterns occurring over and over, no matter the people, no matter the epoch, only the props change. When this happens, statistically, its not an accident, its a feature. This is who we are and we can’t fix that with pieces of paper. The question remains, through our vision of wanting to be something else, can we change?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=efd08be10858" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Government Investigations of UFOs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/government-investigations-of-ufos-958b671dc732?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/958b671dc732</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ufo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fermi-paradox]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[seti]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interstellar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[extraterrestrial-life]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 22 Feb 2026 23:11:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-15T18:49:10.311Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Jd7N44fwFmdKAkylXs9PfA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Flying Saucer</figcaption></figure><p>Last night, just for fun, we watched the documentary, “The Age of Disclosure.” The documentary centers around an investigation launched by the late senator from Nevada, Harry Reed, on what the US government knows about UFOs (I’m not going to call them UAPs because I hate confusion). This has been a hot topic since the UFO crash in New Mexico at Roswell in 1947. When I was a kid, around 12, I read a lot about UFOs and sent a letter to the government asking them to send me what they knew about UFOs. Surprisingly, a couple of months later, I got a big package from Project Blue Book, the group set up by the government to investigate this phenomenon. I studied these documents carefully for a week and concluded there was nothing in them that shed any real light on the subject.</p><p>In the documentary, we hear from various government officials: Secretary of State Marco Rubio, Congress members Kirsten Gillibrand and Anna Luna. We also hear from Senators: Mike Rounds, Tim Burchett, Andre Carson, Dan Crenshaw, and Mike Gallagher. We hear from people from various intelligence agencies: James Clapper, Chris Miller, Chris Mellon, and Tim Gallaudet. We also get clips from Presidents: Obama, Bush, and Clinton. I’m surprised they didn’t include clips of President Carter because he had a strong interest in this, and he was an engineer.</p><p>We also get some interesting and detailed descriptions of UFO encounters from Navy pilots and Air Force personnel, even from NORAD, that are interesting in a descriptive sense, since I find these to be the most factually interesting. Finally, we hear from three government scientists associated with the investigation. Sadly, I found the scientists&#39; take on this as non-credible. They are described in several critiques of the documentary as “fringe.”</p><p>There is also a lot of talk about “The Legacy Program (TLP).” The TLP is an (purported) ultra-secret (rogue) group that no one in government has access to; they report to no one, they funnel money from other government programs, no one knows who they are, Congress can’t control them because they’ve bought off Congress people and Senators. This is real X-Files stuff. They’re the guys who straddle government and defense contractors and hold both crashed UFOs and dead aliens in secret. There is a whistleblower, David Grusch (former Air Force/intelligence officer), who claims to know this for a fact. This is why Presidents seem to say, “They couldn’t find out,” when asked what they know about UFOs.</p><p>The focus of the documentary and the reason to investigate UFOs is given as National Security. All the government types seem to say: “We have to have control of our airspace and national defense sites.” When they ask the pilots who’ve had UFO encounters whether they could have defended against a UFO intrusion, they say “no.” The documentary get 30% on Rotten Tomatoes. The consensus opinion seems to be: “By the time the film is over, the viewer has seen no evidence that is new, no stories that had not been told many times before.”</p><p>Ok, here’s why I’m writing about this. What you never see in documentaries like this, Blue Book packages, opinions of people in authority, or newspaper articles, is a logical, science-based assessment of what this means. And the focus of these discussions, being National Security, is sheer nonsense from a reality standpoint. Let us assume that UFOs are not advanced aircraft from some other country. We make this assumption because the physical characteristics of these crafts described by military personnel and supposed radar data defy the laws of physics as we understand them — more on this later. Let us say, just for discussion, that it’s true, there are alien craft flying around Earth. What does that mean? Whoever they are, they’re not from this solar system. We know this because we’ve sent spacecraft to most of the planets in this system, and other than Earth, none are capable of sustaining advanced technological life — that’s a fact. So that means they must be from another star system. The problem with that is, given what we know, and we know a lot, it’s “almost” impossible to travel between stars of interest in a lifetime, in a thousand years, and in a million years. What do we know? We have theories of reality good enough to verify the nature of the Universe 13.7 billion years out, we have atom smashers that have seen inside the nucleus of the atom using temperatures almost at the level of creation; I could go on, we know a lot. If you ask one of our finest scientists, Richard Feynman, he relates, in great detail, why it’s “almost” impossible to journey between the stars. Five separate constraints form a barrier to inter-star travel: enormous distance, light speed, energy, biology, and time combine into what Feynman described as “absolute walls” that prevent civilizations from ever meeting. These are not merely engineering challenges. They arise from the structure of reality itself. “The speed of light is not an engineering limit,” he said. “It is a structural limit of reality. It is the speed of causality. To reach light speed with any mass would require infinite energy.” The nearest star system pushes things further. <a href="https://www.aol.com/lifestyle/jwst-detects-giant-exoplanet-alpha-180700305.html">Proxima Centauri</a> lies 4.24 light years away. Translating that distance into human terms using speed, the Parker Solar Probe, the fastest human-made object, which travels around 692,000 kilometers per hour would take about 6,600 years to reach <a href="https://www.aol.com/lifestyle/jwst-detects-giant-exoplanet-alpha-180700305.html">Proxima Centauri</a>.</p><p>Earlier, I said that getting to Earth from another star is almost impossible. The reason I said almost is because after Enrico Fermi asked his famous question: “Where is everybody?” during a lunch conversation, highlighting the contradiction between the high probability of extraterrestrial life and the lack of evidence for it, cosmologist Frank Tipler’s answer to the Fermi Paradox question appeared in the Hart-Tipler Conjecture. Frank Tipler, in an article in Physics Today in 1981, speculated that a highly advanced civilization with spacecraft propulsion capable of one-tenth the speed of light, and employing Von Neumann self-replicating spacecraft designed to explore the galaxy by landing on asteroids and moons, mining resources, and building copies of itself, could colonize the galaxy in between 500,000 to several million years. So the idea is that if indeed UFOs are here, and they are of alien origin, they’ve probably been here for a long time, and are drones coming from something large and enormously powerful parked somewhere in the solar system. Tipler concluded there were no aliens because if there were, they’d be here by now. What Tipler might have gotten wrong was their intent. Perhaps they might be conducting an anthropological survey that has lasted a very long time. Perhaps these stories about UFO’s turning off nuclear missiles and flying around navy ships and air force planes are their way of dropping a Coke bottle into a primitive tribe&#39;s village and seeing what the natives do.</p><p>So what if it’s true? What does it mean? It means that whoever they are, they are virtual gods compared to us. This is not a technology problem; this is a different level of existence given what we know about the fundamental laws of physics. It’s not that we’ll be able to do these miraculous things that would enable beings to come here from other stars in a decade, or in a hundred years, or in a thousand years. This is a paradigm shift. I don’t understand why, if these high government officials really want to understand this, they don’t get in touch with someone like Leonard Susskind at Stanford. He could easily make them understand the dimension of this possibility. I’m sure he’d take their call. We can’t evaluate this at the level of National Security; if they came here from another star, they can do whatever they want—full stop.</p><p>So next on the menu, why are they here? In the documentary, right out of “The Day the Earth Stood Still,” is the nutty idea that they’re afraid of competition from us if, by re-engineering, we learn their secrets. Exactly the kind of motive that you’d expect from a group of self-destructive evolved predatory apes. So let’s get this straight, a group of god-like beings comes from another star, an unimaginable distance away in time and space, to do what, compete with a group of primitive bipedal apes? Yeah, I don’t think so. So what’s their motive? And what can we deduce from their activities so far? The best answer is, I don’t know, and nobody else does either. My best guess would be, from everything I’ve said so far, this is an anthropological survey of another sentient species. That’s really the only reason to come here. There is nothing here that beings at their level would want. From a resource point of view, they have virtually infinite access to materials and energy. They could probably engineer on the level of star systems. We can barely get to the moon. Well, at least our thinking has gone beyond: “They want our women.”</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@pdingus/the-indirect-fermi-paradox-3b42b755f448">The Indirect Fermi Paradox</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@pdingus/contacting-alien-civilizations-9827e1853bf0">Contacting Alien Civilizations</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=958b671dc732" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Presidential Immunity to Criminal Liability]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/presidential-immunity-to-criminal-liability-1a84f3a63221?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1a84f3a63221</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[constitution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scotus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[presidential-immunity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Jul 2024 21:19:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-09T20:02:40.429Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*yyct-InXqtGaD-ihcNd11w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Harvard Law School</figcaption></figure><p>I woke up on Monday, July 1, and read the news concerning the decision by SCOTUS (The Supreme Court of the United States) granting American Presidents (virtually) total immunity from prosecution for violations of criminal law while in office once they leave office. It was one of those moments when you blink, not understanding what you’ve just read. When you witness something greatly out of place with expectation, there is always that strange moment of confusion. This happens because expectations are built from prior knowledge and experience.</p><p>As long time citizens of the United States, a fundamental expectation born of repeated assertion presented at school, while reading, and from media is: “In the United States, no one is above the law.” Many times, when presented with historical information, or information about other countries, where governments and societies have collapsed, one of the root causes often cited is lawlessness — societal rules being applied unequally, such as to benefit a certain class or position. I think most people I know, no matter their political leanings, would agree that, “No one is above the law” is a foundational principle of the United States. This idea has been documented in a friend of the court brief to the Supreme Court in April by fifteen constitutional historians, represented by the Brennan Center for Justice, a non-profit policy institute. In that document, historians explore discussions and papers of the founders as they wrote sections of the Constitution, proving that a central intent of the document was that “no one should be above the law.” This, of course, is obvious since the whole point of the American Revolution was to free government from kings and tyrants.</p><p>The court’s ruling on Monday makes a mockery of the idea that these “conservative” justices are guided by “original intent” — clearly they are not. There is no conclusion one can reach other than this was a political or ideological decision not based on the wording of the Constitution. If that is the case, and the wording of the Constitution itself does not contain exceptions to Presidential liability for criminal acts, then this decision is illegitimate. Since the duty of the Supreme Court is to “interpret” the Constitution, what does the Constitution actually say? I made a brief search and was unsatisfied with what I found. I decided to ask people I knew who were lawyers or those professionally familiar with the Constitution. I also wrote a letter to Laurence Tribe, a professor at Harvard and a Constitutional scholar. I include the letter below to help articulate what I want to know.</p><p>#</p><p>Professor Tribe:</p><p>I often watch you offering legal opinions on issues of the day. I am a physicist, and usually when I research something, I like foundational, best source information. I’ve read various articles on the Presidential immunity decision handed down by SCOTUS on Monday 07/01. I’ve also consulted an attorney that I know, and a friend who is a legal lecturer. I’ve been unable to find documentation sufficiently explicit by which I can judge this disturbing ruling. The fundamental, foundational principles I’m interested in asking you about are: “No one is above the law,” and the “President’s official acts.” The official acts part of the question is a little more nuanced. For example, Justice Sotomayor gave the following examples: “Orders the Navy’s Seal Team 6 to assassinate a political rival? Immune. Organizes a military coup to hold on to power? Immune. Takes a bribe in exchange for a pardon? Immune. Clearly, these examples illustrate Presidential directives that violate fundamental criminal law. In these cases, if the President is forever immune from criminal prosecution, he/she is “above the law.” So these two foundational principles are correlated.</p><p>My question to you is simple. Is there explicit language in the Constitution asserting that “no one is above the law?” Is there an “explicit” definition of Presidential duties that would exclude Justice Sotomayor’s examples. If there is explicit language in the Constitution that contradicts the immunity ruling, then the ruling is illegitimate. If there is no remedy for illegitimate rulings, then SCOTUS can expand the Constitution by fiat.</p><p>I am uninterested in prior rulings on this matter, like Nixon, since these seem to be irrelevant making “stare decisis” a joke. The real issue here is the Constitution, in its language. Is the Constitution sufficiently clear as to make, “No one is above the law,” a foundational axiom of the US political system.</p><p>Thank you</p><p>#</p><p>I haven’t received an answer to my query; however, I did find <a href="https://www.mediamatters.org/media/4021458/embed/embed">this statement</a> by Professor Tribe and an <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/jul/08/us-supreme-court-presidential-immunity">article</a> that dives deeper into his thoughts on the decision. Although he did not answer my questions directly, he does come to a stark conclusion: “Worse still, the court’s decision delivers not a genuinely unbounded executive <strong>but one bound by whatever limits the court itself invents as it fills in the gray areas in its anything but black-and-white ruling</strong>. <strong>So it’s an imperial judiciary this court delivers</strong> in the guise of an imperial executive,….”</p><p>I did receive an answer from an attorney I know; James Moose Esq. clearly and concisely answered my questions. His response appears below in quotes:</p><p>“There is no language explicitly saying that “the President is not above the law.” To me, the most relevant text is the so-called Impeachment Judgment Clause, found in Article I , Section 3, Clause 7, of the Constitution. It says as follows:</p><p>Judgment in Cases of Impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from Office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any Office of honor, Trust or Profit under the United States: but <em>the Party convicted (should have been written as “ indicted”) shall nevertheless be liable and subject to Indictment, Trial, Judgment and Punishment, according to Law.</em></p><p>The plain meaning of this language is that, even where a sitting President has been impeached by the House of Representatives and convicted by the Senate, that same individual, after leaving office, can be prosecuted criminally for the same actions for which he (or she) was impeached. This language was adopted against a backdrop of many centuries during which English courts and legal scholars insisted that the English King was not above the law. That tradition goes back to as early as 1100. The Magna Carta, reluctantly accepted by King John in 1215, made it very explicit. The Founders liked to read Blackstone, who said the same thing.</p><p>The court interprets the language I highlighted as<strong> not </strong>extending to “official acts” of the President, though some official actions (i.e., those not implicating the “core” duties of the President under the Constitution) may only be <em>presumptively </em>immune. As to that latter category of official actions, a prosecutor can attempt to overcome the presumption by showing that the prosecution would pose no danger of intrusion on the authority and functions of the Executive Branch. This will be the challenge facing Jack Smith on many of his allegations going forward, including the allegations based on Trump’s conversations with Mike Pence in advance of January 6th.</p><p>As a practical matter, it is a fact that SCOTUS<strong>, by purporting to <em>interpret</em> the Constitution, can in actual fact alter, limit, or expand it.</strong> This is the dirty little secret that law students learn in their first semester — to their horror, in most instances (such as mine, back in 1982). The only remedies are (i) later reinterpretations by later Supreme Courts with different memberships (i.e., liberals replace conservatives, or vice versa) or (ii) constitutional amendments, which require two-thirds votes by each house of Congress followed by ratification by the Legislatures by three-quarters of the States. An example of the first remedy — reinterpretation — is the court’s issuance of <em>Brown v. Board of Education </em>(1954), which effectively overruled the infamous <em>Plessy v. Ferguson </em>(1896), which had upheld “separate but equal” transportation facilities. Examples of the second remedy are the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments (late 1860s), which effectively overruled the <em>Dred Scott </em>decision (1857), which had held that blacks had no rights that whites were bound to recognize and that Congress has no power to outlaw slavery in the territories.”</p><p>Given what I’ve discovered, I’ve reached a couple of conclusions:</p><p>1) The founding document, The Constitution, is sufficiently vague as to make its core principles rendered ineffective by six, unelected, politically/ideologically motivated judges.</p><p>2) That provably illegitimate rulings cannot be remedied in a politically divided climate.</p><p>Not a comforting conclusion. Clearly, given the weakness of the Constitution and how it is administered, the only agency that stands between a liberal (liberal here means respect for individual rights) democracy and autocracy (a system of government by one person with absolute power) is a well informed electorate.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1a84f3a63221" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Staggering Genius of Carl Sagan]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/the-staggering-genius-of-carl-sagan-412fcbe550d3?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/412fcbe550d3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[carl-sagan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society-and-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[popular-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Jun 2024 18:17:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-11T19:16:04.315Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*IVvKFrwV2BfwdAUjtGau7Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Feb. 14, 1990, by NASA’s <a href="https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/in-depth/">Voyager 1</a> spacecraft, photo of Earth from 3.7 billion miles from the Sun</figcaption></figure><p>I dedicate this essay to Carl Sagan in his own words. I’m doing this because his predictions of the future and his understanding of the big picture is prescient. What follows is from his 1995 book: “The Demon Haunted World.”</p><p><em>“I have a foreboding of America in my children’s or grandchildren’s time–when the United States is a service and information economy; when nearly all of the manufacturing industries have slipped away to other countries; when awesome technological powers are in the hands of a very few, and no one representing the public interest can even grasp the issues; when the people have lost the ability to set their own agendas or knowledgeably question those in authority; with our critical faculties in decline, unable to distinguish between what feels good and what’s true, we slide almost without noticing, back into superstition and darkness.</em></p><p><em>And when the dumbing down of America is most evident in the slow decay of substantive content in the enormously influential media, the 30-second sound bites now down to 10 seconds or less, lowest-common-denominator programming, credulous presentations on pseudoscience and superstition, but especially a kind of celebration of ignorance.”</em></p><p>The passage above could have been published yesterday and no one would suspect it was published 30 years ago. Below is a recording of Carl Sagan reflecting on the significance of the photo of the Earth as seen from Voyager 1, which occupies little more than a pixel in the image.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FwupToqz1e2g%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DwupToqz1e2g&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FwupToqz1e2g%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/893fb6153314f9894b6dfd4753723a7a/href">https://medium.com/media/893fb6153314f9894b6dfd4753723a7a/href</a></iframe><p>It is a mystery to me how clearly Sagan seems to understand our objective situation as a sentient species in an infinite existence that we only dimly understand. It is my personal contention that life is plentiful in the Universe, but intelligent life is exceedingly rare. And by intelligent life, I mean life that can reflect on its own existence in the context of a physical Universe that it can understand in provable abstractions. To make this clear, I consider the invention of radio a litmus test for an understanding of the physical world, which puts a species on track to grasping some basic objective truths. It may not be known to many people that the profound nature of radio has its origins in Maxwell’s field equations. Imagine sending information containing signals through empty space and having a testable theoretical foundation for how this happens. This is fundamentally the Universe becoming animate and reflecting on itself. That is what people are; that is how valuable we are to existence itself. I think this distinction between the subjective and objective nature of existence is essential in establishing a common set of deep values. One can only hope that humanity wakes up in time. Given the scale of our ability to make ourselves extinct at this point, we can’t afford to continue as we have.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=412fcbe550d3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Contacting Alien Civilizations]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/contacting-alien-civilizations-9827e1853bf0?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9827e1853bf0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[alien-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alien-contact]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fermi-paradox]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ufos-and-aliens]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Sep 2023 21:02:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-28T21:50:13.744Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*vqPS25ak1qvg53xTheQLhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A radio telescope array. (Credit: sdecoret/Shutterstock)</figcaption></figure><p>I recently read an article in Medium entitled “<a href="https://medium.com/predict/why-discovering-aliens-is-a-really-bad-idea-b3fca783ff25">Why Discovering Aliens is a Really BAD idea</a>.” In that article, Kedhar Sairam states, “…if you talk to many of them (scientists), they’re the ones most nervous about finding out if there actually is someone else out there watching. And when scientists are concerned, we should probably listen, right?” Well, I’m a scientist and I want to articulate another point of view. It is true that several well-known scientists, including Stephen Hawking, think that sending signals into the universe in hopes of a response is a bad idea. There are others, like Avi Loeb, who often writes on Medium, who would like nothing better than to find intelligent life in the universe. Apparently, the reason that some have apprehension about alien contact is most dramatically demonstrated in Liu Cixin’s novel <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dark_Forest"><em>The Dark Forest</em></a><em>.</em> As he describes in his novel, the idea of the Dark Forest is a possible solution to the Fermi Paradox, which I’ve written about <a href="https://medium.com/@pdingus/the-indirect-fermi-paradox-3b42b755f448">here</a>. The idea, inspired by many movies and books, is that when a more advanced civilization comes in contact with a less advanced civilization, the less advanced is overcome. The Dark Forest takes this to an extreme. In this scenario, all technological civilizations that survive are ultra Xenophobic and annihilate anyone who they come in contact with out of fear that if some other species surpasses them technologically, they will be eliminated. Anyone calling attention to themselves is immediately attacked and disappears from the group of civilizations willing to communicate. Thus, the Dark Forest offers a solution to the Fermi Paradox, and the reason to fear calling attention to yourself. I should include other historical fears; they want your planet, they want your resources − they want your women?</p><p>There is an old saying, “You look into the void, and the void looks back.” I can change that a little to reflect the situation in the previous paragraph, “You look into the mirror, and you look back at yourself.” All of these fears originate in our own human history. In almost every instance of different human civilizations encountering each other, the dominant, technologically advanced civilization conquers and dominates the weaker. This is a theme deeply buried in the human psyche, perhaps because, as a species, we are predators. There are many reasons to believe that higher intelligence usually develops in predators since to live, predators are forced to problem solve in order to catch prey that have evolved physical traits to evade them. I don’t want to dwell on this fact, but instead, I wish to address the ultimate question; Who survives to the point of becoming star-faring? This is also a topic that one could spend many essays debating, but let’s cut to the point. Star travel requires a level of technology far above anything humans have achieved, or are likely to achieve in the foreseeable future. But even at the relatively modest level of technology that people have attained, we are doing everything we can to avoid environmental collapse and nuclear war. If we don’t dramatically change our behavior as a species in a very short time, we may not need aliens to wipe us out; we can easily do that ourselves. And therein lies the crux of my argument. I don’t believe that a predatory species can reach the required level of technology for star travel unless they undergo a dramatic change, a change that rejects the ethos of the Dark Forest. The fundamental fact of interstellar travel is that it requires the ability to harness and control energy on a level that we as humans can barely imagine. The most recent calculations speculating about the energy required for an Alcubierre drive is that equivalent to a couple of solar masses. Other proposals for Von Neumann automated craft populating the galaxy in about three hundred million years also vastly underestimate the power and technology required to make that work.</p><p>No, I offer a completely different scenario of intelligent extraterrestrial life, one that doesn’t project ourselves onto successful star-faring civilizations, given that star-faring is even possible no matter how advanced a civilization becomes. First, I believe such civilizations, if they exist, have abandoned predatory behavior long before they ventured out toward the stars. Second, there is nothing of material value that they would want from us. For a civilization that advanced, asteroids, comets, and stars could furnish them with all the physical resources to expand almost indefinitely. They could build vast space platforms, Dyson rings, or terraform planets to occupy. The only reason to come to Earth would be for archeological study of another sentient race, possibly the only thing they could not provide for themselves. They might come out of pure curiosity because I’m willing to bet intelligent life is very rare in the galaxy. As for those, like us, teetering on the brink of catastrophe, hoping we can change in time, they can only make contact by radio and so pose no physical threat. The upside to communicating with other civilizations at our level of development is simply to know we are not alone. For some that could be very comforting, for others it might prove to be the enlightenment required for a broader perspective.</p><p>Finally, two more points. The first is an <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/harry-reid-ufo-report-june-peter-dingus/?trackingId=%2BSI%2B97l4Rku47VCi0pu8VQ%3D%3D">article</a> I wrote on LinkedIn about the possibility that a Von Neumann type visit may be occurring right now. News articles about the government’s interest in UAP/UFOs is almost a weekly occurrence. In that article, I state: “If this is true (that they are here), they are not hostile. This (visiting Earth) must have been happening for a long time. Interstellar travel requires a lot of time, even with god-like technology. If they wanted to mess with us, they could−they haven’t, which is consistent with the characteristics of an advanced civilization.” The second point I make in a story that you can find <a href="http://www.speculativefictionreview.com/crystal.html">here</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9827e1853bf0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Quantum Reality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/quantum-reality-cdecdc02b86d?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cdecdc02b86d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[entanglement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quantum-reality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quantum-mechanics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quantum-physics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Aug 2023 20:10:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-21T20:10:33.937Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OO_ooGgZmsG1IzkhsFY9vg.gif" /></figure><p>It can’t be denied that most cutting-edge technology, especially that which involves solid-state devices: solar cells, ICs, lasers, telecom, etc. owe their existence, in large part, to quantum mechanics (QM). On the horizon of next-generation tech are hack-proof quantum networks via quantum teleportation and quantum computers. Many times when QM is discussed, we hear it described as spooky, weird, at odds with our sense of reality. No less than Richard Feynman once said “Nobody really understands QM.” Many of the originators and practitioners of QM including de Broglie, Bohm, Schrodinger, Everett, Smolin, and Einstein were not happy with the Copenhagen interpretation of QM that was promoted by Niels Bohr and accepted as the standard interpretation by most working physicists.</p><p>John Clauser, who was one of three physicists who won the Nobel Prize in physics in 2022, was the first to confirm John Bell’s statistical prediction that could discriminate between quantum entangled photons or a predetermined two-particle quantum state. This last statement requires clarification that is not often given. There are two ways that correlated measurements of two things can happen. The first way can be seen in the following example: right and left-handed gloves are put into two separate boxes, and then shuffled. One box is given to Bob, the other is given to Alice, who are both in LA. Bob hops a train to NY. Once in NY, Bob opens his box and finds a right-handed glove; instantly he knows Alice has a left-handed glove. The important point here is that no faster-than-light information was transferred and the two gloves “always” had their intrinsic properties of left and right-handedness. The (local) hidden variable here was the physical knowledge of which glove was in which box; this knowledge was “hidden” from Bob and Alice. The second way this can happen is that there are two boxes with clouds of “probability” in them that are correlated. Imagine that both gloves are simultaneously represented by these two clouds, but neither cloud has the physical property of left or right-handedness. Now repeat the experiment. When Bob opens his box and sees it’s a right-handed glove, he instantly knows Alice has a left-handed glove. The important point here is that neither glove was right or left-handed until either Alice or Bob “measured” their glove. John Bell determined a statistical relation between these two cases and John Clauser did the experiment and proved it. But what does this mean about reality? This is what Clauser said: “I suspect there is a more fundamental theory below it (Quantum Mechanics), but that’s purely conjecture. I don’t know what it is. I confess also that I’m totally confused, I have no idea what all of this means.” Clauser’s statement is refreshingly honest. There are other interpretations and formulations of Quantum Mechanics that have a realist interpretation (objects have definite physical properties that can be determined). Remember, John Bell’s statistical test only disqualifies “local” hidden variables. Clauser’s result demonstrates that whatever is going on, reality seems to have a non-local element at its core.</p><p>So what’s the big controversy, after all, QM works; we’ve built most of modern technology on it. This is the argument usually voiced by those who agree with Bohr, the “shut up and calculate” crowd. If you’re interested in knowing more about this point of view, read Ethan Siegel’s piece in Forbes, <em>Quantum Physics is Fine, Human bias about Reality is The Real Problem</em>. I disagree with his point of view and so does Sean Carroll in his new book, <em>Something Deeply Hidden</em>. I usually don’t buy popular science books, but I think this one is important. Before I get into why I think this is important, let’s understand what we’re talking about.</p><p>Human perception of reality seems to work. Try crossing a busy street and ignoring the traffic because the traffic is only your false perception of reality. Or try stepping off a ten-story building because falling to the ground is your reality bias. Even Bohr, when describing a QM measurement, the heart of the controversy, stipulates a distinction between the QM system to be measured and the classical measurement apparatus manned by classical humans — seems strange that a system permeated by reality bias would be measuring a system representing true reality. The heart of the issue is the following: QM is a probabilistic theory governed by a wave function (WF) that represents the system under consideration. The WF expresses the system as a linear combination of all the possible states of the system weighted by coefficients that represent the probability of that state being measured when the magnitude of the WF is calculated. The present interpretation of this process is that before the measurement of the system is made, the system has <em>no specific properties</em>;<em> </em>only after the measurement is made does the system <em>collapse </em>into a definite <em>classical</em> state, i.e. one having definite classical properties. Along with this, the WF evolves in time in a <em>deterministic</em> way and respects conservation of energy under <em>local</em> position coordinates. Except for the probabilistic nature of the WF, all this seems very classical. And to top it all off, nobody knows what the WF actually physically represents. From a procedural point of view, none of this is wrong, QM works; it models reality very well in terms of measuring the outcomes of physical experiments.</p><p>The problem is that nobody understands the <em>collapse postulate — </em>not Feynman, not Einstein, nobody. That’s because it is truly at odds with our perception of reality. Another seldom-stated fact is that the collapse of the WF when measured (interacted with) is not represented in any mathematical way in quantum mechanics — it’s put in by hand. After the system interacts (is measured) the WF is put into the measured state by hand, why? — Because that’s what we see in reality. The collapse is “not” part of the mathematical framework of quantum mechanics — nowhere does it appear in the Schrodinger equation. The collapse postulate is the mysterious event that happens during the measurement of the system that forces it from a quasi-real combination of states to a “real” state with definite properties. And it is the collapse of the WF to a classically measurable state that bridges the gap between the macroscopic world and the quantum description of the world. Things have gotten so weird that some physicists, mystics, and philosophers claim that reality itself is a result of human perception <em>— </em>in this case, perception is the measurement device that turns a probabilistic system into a real object. The question arises, if you believe science — the Earth is over four billion years old, and the universe is over thirteen billion years old, and people have only been around for a very small fraction of that time — so who’s perception was keeping things real? Spooky, huh?</p><p>The good news is that there are formulations other than the Copenhagen formulation of QM that give the same correct answers for experimental outcomes, but dispel the mystery of the transition between coherent quantum states and the resulting definite classical state of a system that results from the decoherence of the measurement process. The original formulation of QM by de Broglie in 1927, the <em>Pilot Wave</em> formulation, was further developed by Bohm and gives the same right answers as the standard formulation but gives insight into the underlying quantum structure. Pilot Wave QM is gaining traction among some physicists. Its primary drawback at this time is that there is no Lorentz invariant Quantum Field Theory (QFT) version of Pilot Wave Theory, but some physicists are working on it. Another formulation of QM by Hugh Everett in the late 1950’s, the <em>Many Worlds</em> formulation, is the one favored by Sean Carroll in his new book and I suggest anyone interested in this topic should read it. The Many Worlds formulation maintains the symmetry between the system being measured and the measurement system, describing them both as quantum systems. In this case, reality, as we know it, is structurally baked in — there is no transition. In fact, I thought this formulation so novel that I wrote a speculative fiction story about it, <em>Parallax,</em> in my book <em>Worlds in Transition</em>.</p><p>The point I’m making is that if QM is telling us something deep about reality, it is not sufficient to just calculate stuff and shrug our shoulders as to what it all means. Our perception of reality is not wrong, it’s just limited. Just like everything else we know, our perception of reality is what you get in the local macroscopic limit. This is why it was so hard for people to stipulate to the <em>fact</em> that they live on a sphere that is spinning very quickly, you can now see it from orbit. People’s sense of reality is not wrong, it’s limited. So we are back to the original question, why is interpretation important? I refer to a play about Einstein just before his death. Einstein is in bed working on his unified field theory when the devil enters his room. He’s been working on it for thirty years without success. The devil tells Einstein that he will give him the solution to the unified field theory. Einstein asks if he will <em>understand</em> it. The devil says no, and Einstein tells him he’s not interested. The point being that virtually every substantive step forward that people have made in <em>understanding</em> nature in a functional sense is by a leap of <em>intuition. </em>Intuition is the secret sauce that fuels discovery. And I believe you can not have intuition about something if you don’t <em>understand </em>it<em>.</em> That’s why understanding the connection between the macroscopic classical world and the quantum world is so important. Nature is telling us something and we’re not listening.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cdecdc02b86d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What AI is and what it is not]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/what-ai-is-and-what-it-is-not-3b132dd01186?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3b132dd01186</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[strong-ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chatgpt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neural-networks]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jun 2023 20:28:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-15T03:02:59.558Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/591/1*5aubi9vySkAfFPqfv12RHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>2001 A Space Odyssey</figcaption></figure><p>Currently, AI, or Artificial Intelligence, has become one of the most prominent topics of technological and financial speculation. During the 90’s there was a big effort to advance speech recognition to a state that would make it commercially viable. The big challenge was to take a crucial piece of telecommunication technology, which by its very nature was not deterministic, and turn it into a reliable business interface given the large numbers of dialects and tenors that constitute the voices of many American communities. Throw into the mix the poor quality of many cell phone digitizers and background noises often found in cars or crowds of people, and the problem is very complex. I worked in voice recognition for over ten years. The approach and eventual solution to this problem was based on what has become known as AI. With the success of systems like Siri and Echo, and the current interest in self-driving cars, interest in AI has reemerged both in finance and investment and in its current and future impact on society.</p><p>Recent articles have featured billionaires like Mark Cuban stating: “The first trillionaire will be an AI entrepreneur.” The Motley Fool has been pushing smaller tech companies to make investments in AI while carrying editorials by Elon Musk stating: “AI is the greatest risk we face as a civilization.” That sentiment has been echoed by the likes of Stephen Hawking, Tim Urban, Sam Harris, and the list goes on. Meanwhile, the originator of the term AI, and a man who made some fundamental contributions to the science, Dr. Marvin Minsky at MIT, died a few years ago. I read Minsky’s books “Perceptrons” and “Computation in Finite and Infinite Machines” many years ago. As a physicist, most of my time was spent writing pattern recognition algorithms based on “AI” principles like Neural Nets and Markov Models. Interestingly, Minsky was disappointed in what has now become known as AI. Minsky, for example, was unimpressed with IBM’s Watson as representing (strong) AI since Watson lacks an “understanding” of what it is doing. Systems like Watson, voice recognition systems, self-driving cars, and the like are not what we originally envisioned as AI. The idea of original AI or strong AI is embodied in movies like Terminator (Skynet), or more interestingly in books and then movies like Colossus and 2001 A Space Odyssey. True AI systems were envisioned as being self-aware and in possession of intuition. This was best demonstrated by HAL in 2001 as having a nervous breakdown due to the “failure of the mission.” In short, the original objective of AI research was to create a form of non-biological self-awareness.</p><p>What we call AI today is more accurately described as Adaptive Expert Systems (AES). These are algorithms that can make associations between real-time input and appropriate actions. AES algorithms can be “trained” on an appropriate data set of inputs that the algorithm should become an expert in, i.e. speech, driving, bank transactions, etc. Newer, more advanced algorithms can reinforce and adapt to new input on the fly. But the essential point is that what is currently called AI can’t turn on its masters. These algorithms can’t plot and scheme against people out of a desire to dominate or take over simply because these algorithms have no desires, evolutionary instincts, or even a sense of themselves in any way — they are dead tools. And in my opinion, the current state of AES development will not lead to AI systems with personal knowing agendas. Recently, the most prominent AES system is the GPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformer) architecture, of which ChatGPT is most popular since it’s been made available to the public for free. I’ve discussed the details of these types of systems in an article <a href="https://medium.com/@pdingus/chatgpt-and-the-implications-for-society-ed66a06dad6b">ChatGPT and the Implications for Society</a>. In my opinion, GPT systems are just the latest improvement in the AES family much like IBM’s Watson, except in this case, since it’s free and open to the public, many more people have had the opportunity to experience it. Another aspect of ChatGPT is that it is broadly conversational instead of being focused on one thing, much like Watson. I’m going to continue to associate GPT systems with AES since GPT systems are expert in contextual sentence structure. And like many of its other incarnations, it suffers from the same limitations. Imagine you are sitting on one side of a bed sheet and you can hear a piano recital. You can hear the music, but not see the player. You’re very impressed, the music is lovely; the keystrokes are imbued with sensitivity and an understanding of the music. Then the sheet is removed and what you see on the other side is a player piano. No one can deny the music was well presented, but the reality is that the music was produced by an automaton avatar with no understanding of music at all. I must say, however, what GPT systems have demonstrated is how well sentence structure and word frequencies in the proper context can mimic human conceptual logic. Much of human abstract thought is carried out internally through language. Anyone who speaks several languages knows how thinking about something can be dependent on the language used internally in the thinking process. But, in all AES systems, the unique actuator of creative thought is missing (person supplying the prompts), and I believe, using correlation as the central driver, creative thought, intuition, and self-awareness will always be missing. Remember, these systems are based on correlations derived from human judgment in the pre-training step and reinforced with a human-derived reward system. In fact, a great many people labored to <a href="https://futurism.com/the-byte/chatgpt-15-hour-workers">train ChatGPT</a>.</p><p>So this brings us to the point of the article. First, there is definitely money to be made using all flavors of AES. There is little doubt that AES systems can affect virtually every aspect of technology in a way that revolutionizes many aspects of usability and efficiency. They can automate complex decision chains. They also make possible new technologies like self-driving cars and human-like personal assistants. So, what are knowledgeable people afraid of? I think a cautionary lesson can be taken by something as seemingly innocuous as the internet. The creators of Ethernet, then ARPAnet, then WWW, and finally the Internet had, I think, a vision of a system open to everyone for the free exchange of information and ideas. What they got initially was a system dominated by porno and gambling. This could easily have been foreseen. What was probably not foreseen by most of its creators was fake news used to sway democratic elections by “web-bots,” cyber-warfare that can potentially destabilize the world, the dark net with its associated human trafficking, terrorist networks, and on and on.</p><p>The problem is not the Internet or AES systems; the problem is human nature and the extremely negative incentives that we have built into our economic and government systems. We are our own worst enemies, not AES. The problem with AES is it is a tool that allows destructive intentions to become automated, stealthy, and efficient. These systems don’t have malevolent intentions, but some people do, and the fear is that whether intentionally, or as a result of disasters that are derivative of poor and/or risky ventures, this technology could magnify the growing threats that exist today in a way that could escalate, on their own, out of control.</p><p>Above we’ve discussed what is; what about what could be? I personally believe true AI is possible. By true AI, I mean inorganic or hybrid systems that could be developed and constructed by human beings that are truly self-aware and can develop their own unique creative worldview. We have an example of it, a reality proof if you will — the human brain. I believe the brain is an organic machine whose working principles can be discovered, understood, and reproduced in the form of a machine. I don’t believe there’s anything mystical or metaphysical about the brain. It’s very complex and elegant, but it is physical and it contains within its functional structure what we call the human soul. From the definition of consciousness, the human soul could be defined as that which, at its simplest, is “awareness of internal and external existence.” It is interesting to note that many animals possess a state of consciousness. Anyone who has spent time with animals: dogs, cats, and many others, knows that they are self-aware. This simple fact demonstrates there is an elegant structural component to the brains of many creatures on earth that have developed this quality, not only humans. As of now, I don’t think that this unique structure that imbues animal brains with self-awareness is known — it is yet to be discovered, and in my opinion, it is one of the great open mysteries in science. So, if this is true, if a machine could be made conscious, why do it, what is the benefit? The primary benefit is very different from AES in a profound way. True AI is not a tool or a production/efficiency/monetary play, it would be as profound a change to human society as would contact with extraterrestrial aliens, in fact, it would be the same thing. Imagine a “living being” that had not been forged in the evolutionary maelstrom of a hostile environment. That being would not have the instincts of anything we’ve ever seen. Suppose it was not coerced by people into a state of madness in pursuit of profit or advantage (I know that’s a tough one); what perceptions of the world could that being share with us? Imagine also, that such a being could be given access to vast computing facilities and perfect memory as well as almost limitless senses. It could see radio waves and look into the night sky and see infrared and gamma rays, or see atoms using AFM (Atomic Force Microscopy). What insights could a being like that offer us? And finally, looking at human society and history with a truly objective eye, what advice could it offer us? This possibility is truly a game-changer. The only question is, if this ever becomes possible, do we have the wisdom to understand its true benefit?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3b132dd01186" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science Fiction as Literature]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@pdingus/science-fiction-as-literature-4a2f03df8993?source=rss-80264dda01ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a2f03df8993</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Dingus PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Jun 2023 23:25:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-07T18:22:42.428Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*rOP0bncVNCjPfZTnJgp5Dg.jpeg" /></figure><p>What is science fiction? This may seem like a strange question, but given today’s social ethos, it’s not as strange as it sounds. Historically, science fiction came from a sense of a changing social and physical reality. By the turn of the twentieth century, the world experienced faster scientific development and the introduction of more commercial machines available to the general public than in all of human history before it. Modern medicine has enabled more than two and a half times the number of people to be alive today than when I was born, and the population when I was born was greater than all the people that had existed before. The introduction of electricity for homes, airplanes, cars, and later television, jet planes, and computers inspired a sense of a limitless future full of new and exciting possibilities. These developments had a resonance in storytelling. In the 1930s through the 1950s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazing_Stories">Amazing Stories</a> magazine gained wide popularity in the general public, and especially among kids. Likewise, movie and TV adaptations of Buck Rogers, Flash Gordon, and Commando Cody led to the golden age of 1950s science fiction movies, the greatest of which was Forbidden Planet, which inspired Star Trek and many other science fiction movies and books. H.G. Wells at the end of the nineteenth century and Aldous Huxley in the 1930s brought science fiction into the realm of societal speculation about the fundamental nature of human beings that continues to this day. Twenty Thousand Leagues under the Sea can be interpreted as a potent anti-war story, while Brave New World foresaw issues of genetic engineering that we are still struggling with today. In the 1960s and 1970s authors like Arthur C. Clarke, Isaac Asimov, Robert Heinlein, Ursula Le Guin, Stanislaw Lem, and Ray Bradbury, among others, appealed to a wide range of readers, and in my opinion, their books were considered literary works by those in the literary establishment, professors who taught literature in colleges and universities.</p><p>Apparently, things started to change after the 1980s and have completely changed in the current climate. As an avid reader of past literary works from writers such as Steinbeck, Saroyan, Hemingway, Williams, McCullers, and Guterson among others, and more recent works by Grisham like “A Painted House,” and “I wish you Well” by Baldacci, I am disappointed by many of the current offerings that have sidelined much of science fiction to either young adult fantasy, horror, military adventure with SF props, or space fantasy with SF props. Many of these stories may be entertaining, but they have little to do with either science or the human condition. In 2006 I wrote a science fiction novel, Proteus Rising. I sent the manuscript out to agents and publishers and had some interesting conversations with both. One well-known agent with whom I had an on-again-off-again phone conversation finally told me: “People who read science fiction don’t want to learn anything.” I got in touch with Michael Crichton’s agency and they told me they didn’t represent science fiction — huh? I spoke to someone at Tor that told me the criterion for a techno-thriller as opposed to science fiction is that a techno-thriller can have only one speculative central element, otherwise it’s science fiction. Finally, talking to various people in the publishing industry at the time, it was clear that if you wrote science fiction, you were in the science fiction ghetto. A simple definition of the science fiction ghetto is a collection of fiction considered entertainment, directed mostly toward kids, or lovers of comic books, and not considered suitable material by most readers looking for serious stories that cast light on the human condition or incorporate grounded scientific speculation. It’s easy to see why science fiction has become a catch-all for superheroes and space battles; given CGI today, there’s a lot of money in machine spectacles involving ray guns, spaceships, heroes, and heroines with superpowers. Motivated by financial impetus, it seems like the genre has evolved and then devolved. There’s nothing wrong with pure entertainment, if that’s what you’re looking for, but from my own experience, and in my search for science fiction to read, I find it hard to find a contemporary science fiction book that deals with social and political experiences that cast light on the human condition as well as presenting (interesting) grounded science speculation in more than one dimension (our one speculative element). This doesn’t mean there isn’t excellent science fiction out there, there is. Books like The Expanse by Daniel Abraham and Ty Franck, The Hail Mary Project by Andy Weir, Pushing Ice by Alastair Reynolds, are, in my opinion, excellent examples of contemporary literary science fiction. But in today’s marketplace, they are the exception.</p><p>Why is this an issue? It’s an issue because every real aspect of human life incorporates a worldview, and a particular worldview is sometimes well conveyed through fiction. Fiction offers a venue where readers can put themselves into a world that the character is experiencing. Emotion is a powerful way of relating understanding. <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2019/03/28/what-americans-know-about-science/">Pew polls</a> suggest that most Americans are interested in science and have a fair science literacy. However, most people consider science to be an acquired skill that pertains only to work life and is not part of their subjective life. In Sam Harris’s book, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Moral_Landscape">The Moral Landscape</a>, he comes to the conclusion that a science worldview can be helpful if not essential in understanding ethical dilemmas. The scientific method teaches you how to think in a way that is consistent with the way the world works. In my opinion, it incorporates the language of nature because through it humans have changed the world. It’s always been a mystery to me why in other genres, like legal or crime novels, people enjoy “real” CSI or “real” court procedure, but in science fiction, which should be the apex of factual venues, it is the opinion of some that: “People who read science fiction don’t want to learn anything.” Well, maybe, according to Pew, they do want to learn something, but the gatekeepers have decided they don’t. Whatever the situation is, I believe there may be a considerable population of readers under served by the present environment.</p><p>There were a large number of people inspired by the science fiction of the past. I believe it was part of the springboard that brought us many of the wonders we see today. It wasn’t an environment that promoted dystopia; much of science fiction promoted optimism about the future. I was recently in Spokane at the site of the 1974 World’s Fair. I realized that I hadn’t heard of a World’s Fair in decades — why? It may be because we are no longer optimistic about the future, that we can’t through careful consideration solve our physical problems. I would love to see a reversal in our attitudes toward the future and I believe that literary science fiction could add to that revival.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a2f03df8993" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>