<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by ::Nima:: on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by ::Nima:: on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@peoplewatcher?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 08:21:10 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@peoplewatcher/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Peoplewatcher: The Battering “Brand India” is Taking Right Now]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/peoplewatcher-the-battering-brand-india-is-taking-right-now-aed2712b6b7a?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aed2712b6b7a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-19-crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[branding]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 May 2021 05:04:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-26T05:04:20.624Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>2020 was a year of global solidarity thanks to Corona. We were bonded in isolation, pain and confusion.</p><p>2021 has been a story of recovery. That would be in most countries except India.</p><p>Within India, there are two major story arcs that color the imagination. One is of utter horror and disappointment in the government in general, Modi in particular, and the other is a series of rebuttals against anything that might dent the great leader’s righteous armor.</p><p>There are other stories of denial and idiocy that are quintessentially Indian like — <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/story/villagers-jump-river-up-barabanki-to-escape-covid-vaccination-1806217-2021-05-24?fbclid=IwAR2xW4M6r6JqX7bE2CybFjMfFnjlnZjDwLZXn9RgrIm5Bt3y1wHiNzaQ0lc"><em>Villagers jump into river in UP’s Barabanki to escape Covid vaccination</em></a><em> </em>but these are just sub-flavors of the dysfunctionality that is India’s current reality. Maskless covidiocy and crowding are the norm even now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3GJdEWlpyp3u9Lxx5B2AoA.jpeg" /><figcaption>While other countries seem to be moving forward, India is still deeply wedged in Covid’s stranglehold</figcaption></figure><p><strong>All the World’s a Stage and India is a Bottom Feeder</strong></p><blockquote>What we have seen and experienced and therefore believe, are our own stories to hold.</blockquote><p>Significant damage has been done to how the world now sees India and it’s hard to walk this back. While the US has demonstrated how radically a Covid-ravaged nation can be turned around in just 100 days by dedicated, competent leadership — India is unlikely to see a similar 180° flip in the short term.</p><p>Early 2020 saw horrific predictions of how bad Indian infection and death stats would be and there was public fear and government action then. But a series of unfortunate events, unforgivable decisions and utter lack of planning have made 2021 India the poster child of human-horror porn.</p><p><strong>The Indian Passport and persona didn’t travel well at any time in history.</strong></p><p>It ranks 85th on the passport index and there are a measly 58 countries you can enter without a visa. That’s less than a third of the countries on the planet. Most functional countries invariably look at Indians as an “immigration risk.”<em> People fleeing to be anything, anywhere out of their home. Not Syria or Rohingya-Myanmar bad maybe, but bad.</em></p><p>While the cliched associations about India used to be <em>snake charmers</em> and <em>fakirs</em>, we’d crawled our way up the perceptual ladder by also being known as customer service reps with questionable accents, diligent coders and the rare, raging success story of CEOs or actors of repute.</p><p>What April-May 2021 have successfully done is pull India <em>way down the social perception ladder</em> of how the world sees the nation — regardless of whose fault it is that bodies are rotting in the Ganga.</p><p><strong>Getting the Job Done vs. Impression Management</strong></p><p>Ideally, it’s critical to get the job done — but optics matter too. How India is perceived will affect <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/agriculture/indian-rice-exporters-in-a-fix-as-transport-costs-rise-demand-from-gulf-drops/articleshow/81330304.cms?from=mdr">exports</a> and earning sectors like tourism. The stock markets might be rallying for the rich but the masses are suffering. Lockdowns cause a stifled economy, loss of daily wages and being driven further into debt to barely survive for millions of Indians. Lifting lockdowns results in greater loss of life giving us few viable options other than to vaccinate 1.3 billion people. Twice.</p><p>Since we haven’t had bankable data on infections, deaths, tests or economic suffering of citizens, it’s unlikely we will ever have quantitative data on <em>perceptions of India among international audiences (2021.)</em> The social and economic impact of such perceptions will be significant and impact India for years before inching back to muted, conditional respect for select people and scenarios. Irreparable perceptual damage has been done in addition to the real carnage we’ve seen and experienced.</p><p><strong>What Cisco Teaches us About the Power of Perception</strong></p><p>Back in 2008 we studied why Enterprise customers <em>worshipped</em> Cisco. This isn’t a target that’s typically effusive about brands but they’d go into raptures about Cisco the way Apple loyalists gush about their treasures.</p><p>Cisco, in the Enterprise view, could do no wrong and it was in their minds what Dhoni as <em>Thalai</em> is to CSK fans. Even if there was a problem in a product or service provided by Cisco, they were more inclined to blame external factors or be incredibly forgiving of Cisco.</p><blockquote>What gives an entity that kind of power boils down to four factors —<strong> <em>Reliability, Innovation, Expertise and Customer Service. </em></strong>Not just “managing” but delivering on the four, which Cisco did. The converse of this theory is that when you don’t deliver on these four factors or are perceived poorly on these fronts, your whole image suffers and you’re seen as an object deserving of condescending sympathy, hate or ridicule.</blockquote><p>While New Zealand may be the sole country with Cisco-like sheen in the Covid context, India will stand out as a deeply shamed and scarred victim. (Many Indians don’t see this as so.) The idea here is to not disrespect the seriousness of Covid or the human tragedies associated with it by comparing it to a brand.</p><p>Countries do have a <strong>brand archetype and aura</strong> around them. There is a way in which they are perceived. A crisis of this magnitude or the presence of a leader like Trump alters our perceptions of a nation (negatively.)</p><h3><strong><em>1. Reliability</em></strong><em>: That you can be relied upon to do what you’re expected to do…</em></h3><p>The internationally broadcast images of mass cremations, bodies in the open, people gasping for oxygen will all be markers of a staggering lack of <strong>Reliability</strong> in the system and those in charge.</p><p>Despite government efforts to control the surge in the first wave through lockdown and relief efforts, any success then will be seen as a fluke now. What’s happening now will be seen as more in line with what’s expected for a country way too populated and far too poor for its own good with a corrupt, inept, self-serving power at the helm. Again, <strong>these are perceptions</strong> (how the world sees India) and regardless of what the truth might be about say — cigarettes, God or anything else, what matters is what people believe.</p><p>When the PM declared in Jan 2021 that “<a href="https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/pm-modi-address-davos-dialogue-at-world-economic-forum-101611835777705.html">India’s success will help the world</a>,” the idea was that our own had already taken care of and we were moving on with life. Helping others, even. That would have been fantastic and lent some credibility to the idea of <em>Atmanirbhar Bharat</em> or self-reliant India. That ship sailed into an ocean of statements that don’t age well.</p><p>When some people complained on social media about the lack of availability of oxygen and were subject to government harassment, the <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/news/story/no-action-against-anyone-who-seeks-covid-help-on-social-media-or-criticises-govt-supreme-court-tells-centre-1796637-2021-04-30">Supreme Court (SC) had to intervene</a> and explain to the government like a parent would to an errant child that punishing those in need wasn’t kosher.</p><p>Right now we also have the dubious distinction of festering an epidemic within a pandemic with <a href="https://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-black-fungus-vs-white-fungus-vs-yellow-fungus-which-is-more-dangerous-and-who-is-at-risk-2891829">multi-colored fungi</a> that have added to the lethality of Covid. That it’s triggered by a lack of hygiene and is spread primarily by tainted oxygen cylinders that what’s supposed to be life-saving is life-taking also add to the idea of a languishing brand.</p><p>If India were a Japanese car brand, it will absolutely not get respectable scores for Reliability or Self-reliance. For context, while rating a Toyota car, a 4 on 5 is a failure. Then again, they’re Japanese.</p><h3><strong>2. Innovation</strong>: The ability to think ahead, use technology to conquer the future…</h3><p><a href="https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india/india-made-vaccines-in-demand-92-countries-request-order-serum-institute-covishield-covaxin-latest-news-679537">In Jan 2021, 92 countries had approached India</a> to place vaccine orders. Just three months later, India needed help from the world.</p><p>As the “vaccine factory of the world” India was seen more as a drone factory rather than a pioneer in pharmaceutical prowess. Even before the destructive plunge-force of Apr-May 2021, there have always been doubts about technology, products or services (even people) exported from India. This despite the reality that export quality rules ensure that what’s shipped out is far better than what Indians in India consume. DQR (Durability, Quality, Reliability) which are considered basic attributes to do business, aren’t naturally associated with stuff that comes out of India.</p><p>The initial diplomacy of shipping vaccines through <a href="https://www.mea.gov.in/vaccine-supply.htm">Vaccine Maitri </a>while well-intended, now just looks like India didn’t have her act together. There was a sudden reneging on commitments while finding we were woefully short of vaccines, an embarrassing surge on our hands and no credible plan to get the 1.3 billion vaccinated.</p><p>Covishield/Astrazeneca which could have helped India’s “Innovation” creds has the dubious distinction of being associated with <em>“blood clots,” “countries that bought it opting not to use it,” and a “czar who escaped to England.”</em> Covaxin still does not have WHO clearance for travel. Both vaccines don’t have the faith inside or outside the nation that Pfizer, Moderna or J&amp;J have . There are however faithful Indian patriots who would prefer to remain unvaccinated than let foreign help aid them.</p><p>We also still have no quick plan of getting children vaccinated. It’s widely believed that when the third wave comes, it will come for kids. When kids aren’t vaccinated, they are likely to lose another year of school/college. A broad consensus was that this was a year lost where most kids learned nothing and parents just lost money. The poorest among them opted not to enroll them for online school because 20–40k during these times was simply not affordable. While the rest of the world is throwing off their masks and eating in restaurants, India will likely see a repeat of 2020 in social fear, debilitating uncertainty and economic chains.</p><h3><strong>3. Expert</strong>: To be a thought and action leader…</h3><p>The oxygen and vaccine saga take India down several notches on this front. The Farmer protests, <a href="https://washingtonmonthly.com/2021/05/22/in-indias-covid-crisis-echoes-of-a-colonial-past/#.YKmEJW9WIDE.twitter">Kumbh Mela</a> and election rallies during a pandemic do nothing to generate a sense of expertise or control. International coverage about Covid invariably veers off to these past stories to establish that the government was never interested in serving the people. That it pandered to political expediency over taking the tough calls to safeguard health. <a href="https://washingtonmonthly.com/2021/05/06/indias-long-struggle-to-breathe/">One such story</a> showed a parallel between India’s inability to improve air quality (which has also been successfully killing Indians prematurely) to the inept handling of the Covid crisis.</p><p>If all of these stories, the pictures of dead bodies and videos of gasping, wailing Indians didn’t do enough damage, there is also the delightful saga of <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/what-is-central-vista-project-that-supreme-court-has-halted-1747657-2020-12-08">Central Vista</a>. The project is controversial but the PM seems to have made an Unbreakable Vow to himself to see it through. That crores will be spent on a vanity project while the nation self-destructs is how it will be seen regardless of how disconnected any of it might be. Optics always matter. Way more so in politics. The archetype associated with a leader who doesn’t change course when his team is hurting and presses on with his own plans — is the dictator archetype.</p><p>IPL (Indian Premier League) is another significant body blow to India’s international image even if this is only known to cricketing nations. Had the country been able to pull it off, there may have been some credit for achieving safe passage even while the outsides were burning. While it would still have been seen as a thoughtless indulgence — it wouldn’t be incontrovertible evidence of systemic failure that it is now. Starting the IPL and possibly abandoning it midway is just another “<em>promise to give vaccine and take it back</em>” type reneging that establishes a lack of control and expertise.</p><p>Statements by <a href="https://www.livemint.com/news/india/covishield-vaccine-govt-is-buying-each-dose-for-rs-210-from-sii-11613177342407.html">various ministers in power </a>and more recently Baba Ramdev do nothing to disprove the idea that India is steeped in anti-science and cow-dung speckled superstition. Not precisely the definition or characterization of experts in the context of a health crisis.</p><p>While there may be a rare voice of gaunt, professorial reason in a Shailaja Teacher from Kerala, that’s not the broader Indian pitch. We don’t have a Dr.Fauci who spoke loud, consistent and clear — even while fighting the pall of Trumpian ineptitude.</p><p>There is an urgent, global call to prioritize medical science and lives over politics to deal with this multi-faceted, gnarly crisis and we don’t have a single trustworthy medical voice. Just a gazillion Whatsapp forwards of questionable intent and faux-science. That’s in addition to extreme politicization and petty bickering from most of our leaders. The citizens follow suit.</p><h3><strong>4. Customer Service</strong>: To be there when things go wrong and help resolve problems in a satisfactory manner…</h3><p>The premature declaration of victory and lack of preparation for a second surge experts said would come — make this seem like an avoidable tragedy to many inside the nation. For those abroad — the scary surge, the shallow graves in the Ganges, the Reuters and Getty images of mass cremation sites and stories of iron melting in crematoriums reinforce their worst fears about India as a festering sewer of disease, poverty and rape.</p><p>Indians in India and abroad are aware of the degree to which people had to fend for themselves. The Bangalore Apartments’ Federation (BAF) literally issued guidelines for apartments to set up their own Covid Care facilities. These are private entities. The idea was to not rely on the government or the system regardless of what happened.</p><p>Doctors and hospitals have long been telling relatives of patients to procure oxygen (BYOO), Remdesivir and other drugs. Whatsapp groups and social media enclaves of citizens in India and abroad have been mass coordinating efforts to get beds, ventilators, oxygen, concentrators and other essentials to people who need it. Often losing people in the process because ordinary citizens were NEVER engineered to be frontline medical experts who could save lives.</p><p>Indian doctors and hospitals have been recommending and peddling Plasma therapy and Remdesivir long after they were declared ineffective based on clinical trials. It’s only recently that ICMR removed these two from the treatment protocol (though belief in them is still strong among people.) Most of India has operated like latchkey kids without parental oversight, trying to figure how not to die and it’s unclear where the service aspect of the elected government truly is. The PM Cares Fund has a few 1000 whopping crores to its name and no transparency by design — which also doesn’t make for fantastic service or trust associations.</p><p>Vaccination, pegged as the one <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanjeevani_(plant)">Sanjeevani</a> to save the nation, seemed to start well before it crashed and burned. The Cowin platform was a demonstrable embarrassment that made rudimentary systems from the 90s look good. From doling it out free in the initial days to now pricing it at roughly Rs.1400 a jab (when internationally it’s largely free and the cost to government doesn’t exceed <a href="https://www.livemint.com/news/india/covishield-vaccine-govt-is-buying-each-dose-for-rs-210-from-sii-11613177342407.html">Rs.210</a>) is an act of price-gouging that’s similar to what ambulance drivers, oxygen cylinder traders and drug blackmarketeers have been doing. A government that had its customer service game in play would have ensured it never devolved to this degree of chaos, thievery and mortality.</p><p>Overreach and abuse by cops during a lockdown has been another pan-Indian story. It seems to span the spectrum from mild “<a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/videos/city/bengaluru/cops-beat-up-motorists-for-violating-covid-19-rules-in-bengaluru/videoshow/82515942.cms">beating of motorists</a>” to forcing a youth to <a href="https://bangaloremirror.indiatimes.com/bangalore/others/karnataka-sub-inspector-accused-of-forcing-dalit-youth-to-drink-urine-suspended/articleshow/82902006.cms#:~:text=The%20sub%2Dinspector%20at%20Gonibeedu,Police%20(IGP)%20on%20Sunday.">drink urine</a> to another being <a href="https://theprint.in/india/unnao-vegetable-seller-killed-by-cops-quit-school-to-help-family-now-they-want-rs-1-cr-relief/664355/">beaten to death</a>. There are rampant stories of delivery service men being harassed and their bikes being impounded. This despite delivery being classified as “essential services” which are exempt from the lockdown. This problem has existed since March 2020.</p><p>The granularity with which the international world will study and care about these aspects is negligible. That’s the thing with perceptions, they have near zero burden to be fair or based on factual research. They’re based on feelings and where most of the world will net out, won’t be in India’s favor. They won’t care what all happened and why. What they will largely see is a system that failed its people. And a people that are hard to reign in, in a crisis. That’s not untrue.</p><p><strong>Not surprising yes, but it’s cynical to have not hoped for better.</strong></p><p>When I planned to return to India after a decade plus stint in the US, a German colleague messaged me and said, <em>“Seriously? Back to that shit swamp?! You mean voluntarily?”</em></p><p>It wasn’t just rose-tinted, Swades glasses that made me return. I knew what I was trading off for what and I have no regrets. I even appreciated his German honesty. But right now, to watch other countries move forward while it’s clear that India going to be stuck in a 2020 Covid <a href="https://g.co/kgs/6CGzxY"><em>trishanku</em></a><em> </em>for the long haul, it does hurt. For many of us, we simply cannot get back to our lives for a while longer and even when we do, there’s no guarantee there won’t be another variant (that the authorities will tell you should absolutely NOT be called the Indian variant) that will find a new demographic to decimate.</p><p>The second surge may recede by end July according to math models — but without vaccinating most of the population, sending kids back to school, getting small businesses and services back on their feet — the country is going to drag its war-embittered body, in full public view, while other countries and economies seem to bounce back to business as usual. Like Israel and Palestine.</p><p><strong>We can argue about “what the truth is” — that matters little to how the world will perceive India</strong></p><p>None of what’s said above is a defense or attack of India’s leaders or systems. It’s unfair to compare some of the states to others and that’s not the intent. There is also a Centre-State tussle that contributed to the breakdown that killed <a href="https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/india/covid-19-second-wave-indias-death-toll-crosses-3-lakh-more-than-1-lakh-have-died-in-the-last-26-days-6929111.html">3 lakh Indians and counting</a>.</p><p>There are those who believe that Modi should never be voted into power and those who believe there is no option but him. The point here isn’t to establish which group has the answer. It’s likely they both don’t.</p><p>This is a qualitative audit of how Brand India has been critically wounded at a time when the establishment was promoting itself as an emerging, future-ready, self-reliant leader of the region.</p><p>All the aura around <strong><em>Digital India, Make in India and Atmanirbhar India</em></strong> were always suspect given the masses who remained untouched by any semblance of progress or dignity. But as we remain an outcast nation today facing travel bans and such — the reality is that we have become the benchmark for where not to be in a Covid or crisis context.</p><p>In addition to there being no “all hands on deck” Covid strategy that works for the country, the Centre is currently <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/features/story/will-india-ban-whatsapp-facebook-twitter-from-may-26-unlikely-but-it-is-complicated-1806863-2021-05-25">pressuring all major social media companies</a> to help them silence and stalk citizens, assuming they survive Covid.</p><p>Even with all that’s transpired in the past two months, with no concrete plan to deal with a potential third wave or the impossible task of vaccinating an ocean of misinformed people — some still hold out hope that the establishment (or God) will do right by the people.</p><p><em>“We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.” ~ Oscar Wilde</em></p><p><em>::Nima:: is the founder of Berylitics — a culture, consumer, brand insights boutique. She studies people, countries and brands and understands how perceptions work. She’s aware countries are not corporations. If you have a policy argument with what’s written above, you’re probably looking for Centre for Policy Research. She has been interviewing people across India and abroad about their Covid experiences since March 2020.</em></p><p>Have Questions?: <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/nima-srinivasan-9aa0159/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/nima-srinivasan-9aa0159/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aed2712b6b7a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Peoplewatcher: “IPL in the midst of a death wave?!”]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/peoplewatcher-ipl-in-the-midst-of-a-death-wave-c3d7d65ab9a2?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c3d7d65ab9a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ipl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2021]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Apr 2021 09:56:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-25T14:56:47.228Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>An emerging thought among some (<em>a microscopic sliver of uppercrust</em>) Indians is that it’s “inappropriate” to conduct the IPL right now.</p><p>More than one person I know, have actively chosen to stop watching it because it simply “feels morally wrong to engage in frivolity” while the nation suffers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*olafLx8ie5hM-LIu.jpg" /></figure><p>Here’s Adam Gilchrist asking this question — with some concern and not pre-judgment, open to the idea that there are two possibilities — inappropriate vs. important distraction:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/627/1*rz4yd5_lIf7fvmEdcTCOTg.png" /></figure><p>And US-residing Siddhartha Vaidyanathan who’s far more confident in his stance that this is completely tone-deaf and not okay:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/638/1*OEVBN79DgOSGffRkp3A8uQ.png" /></figure><h3><strong>“How can this be okay?”</strong></h3><p>A resounding number of Indians responded to Gilchrist saying it was <strong>an important distraction</strong>. Twitter may not always be a reliable index of where people are at, but in this case — it does align with what makes sense for India for a couple of reasons. This is a relevant question to people who follow the IPL because for those who don’t, it’s easier to not care or wish it away.</p><blockquote>Yes, the Covid numbers are bad, the stories are horrid and reality is worse. It’s not getting better any time soon.</blockquote><p><strong>FLASHBACK to March 2020 India</strong></p><p>During the first lockdown — as unprecedented as it was, there was large scale compliance. It’s common knowledge now that the poor in general and migrant laborers in particular struggled. It’s easy to say, “<strong>Stay at home</strong>” when one has a home that can fit and feed all its members, there’s less fear of being thrown out by a landlord and there is this assurance of a recurring, white-collar salary.</p><p><strong><em>This wasn’t the reality for much of mass India.</em></strong></p><p>A lot of the labor in India (not just below poverty line) is unorganized and if they can’t go out — they can’t eat, live or educate their kids. Their employers will invariably sideline them without a second thought because they’re squeezed as well. While government relief efforts did exist in sporadic magnanimity, much of this was hard to come by. There were also reports that it was handed to people based on political allegiance or caste and not pure human need.</p><p>For many (average) Indians, the economic consequences of what went down were unreasonably hard — even by punishing Harischandra-metrics of life being hard in India. A dent like this causes them to be sucked into an abyss that makes it hard to recover from and they drop a whole level. Lower middle class becomes lower class, that sort of thing, and it will take a whole generation for them to scramble back up even one rung on that treacherous economic ladder.</p><p>Across the board there are stories of how they have had to pawn what little jewelry they had so they could eat, borrow from more affluent relatives and <strong>not</strong> <strong>educate children for a year</strong>. This last factor for many is a massive sacrifice since most Indian parents tend to see their kids’ education as insurance for their own future. Not just a ticket to a better life for their kids.</p><p><strong>“Life More Important than Money”</strong></p><p>A comfortably middle-class shoe retailer in Luz, Chennai, spoke about how the lockdown meant the store was closed for weeks together. When a shop stocked with low-cost shoes from floor to ceiling doesn’t get aired, the glue used to hold the sole to the rest of the piece snaps out and it’s not easy to just re-glue and sell. The piece needs to be discarded. This results in a loss of lakhs to this one retailer — where no bank backs him and no partner will bail him out. He’s in the hole for that much even without having contracted the virus. When people don’t visit his store, he will likely not have enough to feed his family in the next quarter. <em>He needs life to move on.</em></p><p>Across the country, there are stories like these of people who really needed their life to get back on track so they could earn the little they earn on a daily or weekly basis. India isn’t engineered to be a Scandinavian nation or an isolated New Zealand fantasy planet where it can “shut the country down” and heal itself like white blood cells do with the body. Imposing lockdowns without a plan for ensuring people who are not techies can live, earn, eat and learn is a fool’s errand.</p><p>While the lockdown may have been imposed with good intent and the idea that economic gains were less important than life itself, that is undeniably easier to say if you already have economic gains in the first place. The government released the <a href="https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/economicsurvey/">Economic Survey for 2020–21</a> where it praises itself ad nauseum for the lockdown and lives saved (math model projected) which may well be true in some way, but it also neglects to mention the economic and therefore life cost to many Indians where a vast, whopping majority do not operate under first world conditions. It’s important to note that even in the US, they needed $1200 stimulus checks to keep the economy going and we have no institutional safety net whatsoever.</p><p>At the end of it (by June 2020), many average Indians lost faith in the government and decided that if they fall sick, that’s that but the lack of livelihood could not be tolerated. They had to move on — they had to live life, go to temples, see each other etc.</p><p>These people told stories of young drivers they knew who had died of stress and others of suicide, because of staggering financial debt with no hope ahead. None of this takes away from the tragedy and burden of frontline workers and doctors who fight an insurmountable battle against a disease that <strong>asks for social distancing from a people who are hugely social and averse to distancing.</strong></p><p>It’s tough.</p><p><strong>Covid-19 in 2021 is not Covid-19 in 2020</strong></p><ul><li><em>Then, people didn’t know what to expect, now they think they do. Whether they do or don’t, they are less afraid. Their guard IS down.</em></li><li><em>Then, there was a willingness to work together and suffer a little if it meant greater good. Now, that faith has eroded.</em></li><li><em>Then, they had some savings they could use to tide them over. Now, that luxury doesn’t exist. They need to earn to survive.</em></li><li><em>They need to move forward.</em></li></ul><p>The list goes on but less fear of the disease and more a crisis of survival has resulted in fewer people trusting authority, vaccines or the virulent ferocity of the virus.</p><p><strong>Yes, we’re screwed. What’s this got to do with IPL?</strong></p><p>Kumbh mela, political incompetence and right vs left bickering don’t flatten the curve. They don’t ensure beds in ICUs or a sufficient supply of oxygen. They don’t guarantee a decent burial. But it’s also what India has in fecund abundance.</p><p><strong>The People: </strong>Indians typically deal with the life-sucking pressures of everyday India and squalor with the belief that they have only God, family and themselves to lean on and the presumed dharmic truth that life (even if there’s death) must go on.</p><p><strong>One System among Many</strong>: The IPL ecosystem deals with the financial pressures of handling sponsors, players and massive extended support crews and teams in a narrow window when these players are available. Given by how it’s gone so far, it’s evident that their bio-bubbles, quarantines and systems are doing all they can to keep teams safe in hotels, on air and at the nets. Here too, there are economic pressures for life to go on.</p><p>IPL came back to India with the strictest of guarantees that safety would be ensured. The messaging about safety is constant — virtual guest boxes, #Unite2FightCorona, lack of spectators, pop ups and repeated urging from commentators to stay safe, stay home. It works like a first world metric of how systems could be.</p><p>In the run up to the event, the organizers did consider input from regular people. Evidently not people who see the IPL as a moral wrong but a large enough sample of people to “read the room.” The general consensus from a reliable sample of Indians was — yeah it sucks but this distraction is vital, it gives us something to look forward to and makes it easier to stay at home.</p><p>Another clear piece of feedback was to not overdo the “Go Corona Go” message. While NYT, BBC and WaPo may balk at the “utter breakdown of Indian health and social systems” — for most Indians in India, they get that it’s bad, that they must wear masks, sanitize, distance etc. They’ve heard it from Baritone Bachchan and they’ve heard it on their phones. They’ve seen sanitizer-standies in their apartments and in the stores. They’re the living embodiment of Covid fatigue. They don’t need more vacuous reminders to tune out.</p><p><strong>Getting People to Pay Attention Without Risk of Tuning Out</strong></p><p>This (well intentioned) ad below, is a sure shot way of ensuring people shut it out, don’t donate even if they can and move on — mostly because that’s what people do.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-Fc5bOZS4yU804Lh" /><figcaption>Will you watch an onslaught of such ads and donate or Skip Ads the second you can?</figcaption></figure><p>In India, the ability to shut out tragic pleas is even more well-honed in an environment that delivers a perpetual sensory overload of negative messages. It’s where anything good — festivals, faith, food, coming together is appreciated all the more. Even death has some aspect of all of those things. As does IPL. Cricket and films have always been a manifestation of that cohesive force of pan-Indian bonding and celebration. For most people in India, that still hasn’t changed.</p><p>The IPL production has responded with just that sort of calibration where even the number of people seen on the stands with mask hits the Goldilocks equilibrium of “just right” rather than go the Indian melodrama way of hit-over-the-head with overkill.</p><blockquote>To the average Indian, even the idea that IPL could be seen as morally wrong or something to be avoided would seem incredulous.</blockquote><blockquote>The average Indian doesn’t always do things to serve their own interest either.</blockquote><blockquote>But virtue signaling for optics makes little sense to a people who have the freedom to police the fashion, film, food and sexual choices of nearly everybody around them.</blockquote><p>The more pertinent question is, what is served by stopping IPL? Let’s assume that the rich sponsors are forced to swallow the cost and they suffer those consequences. A canceled IPL means that the entire ecosystem including ground staff and others who rely on this income won’t get any of it. N.Srinivasan, Ambani and SRK; Dhoni, Kohli and ABD will do fine. Many uncapped cricketers won’t. Hotels won’t. People won’t.</p><p>There is a tendency to think of the IPL as<em> “people earning crores, so screw them.”</em> Not everyone earns crores. Not the analysts who crunch those numbers and not the cleaning staff in the media companies who are now gainfully employed. For everyone responding to Gilchrist that they need that distraction, it ensures they literally stay at home, a basic Covid ask. Even for the most morally righteous opposer of IPL right now, the gains of Indians staying home should be a win?</p><p>Let’s say we suspend IPL, how does this make India’s Covid situation better? One could argue that that money and energy should be channeled to health and prevention. Which is similar to “instead of sending objects to the moon and Mars, feed the poor.” Money flows in not so mysterious ways and usually doesn’t where someone angsting on Twitter wants it to flow.</p><p>Obviously, the choice to not watch IPL can be a personal one but out of academic curiosity, what else can we do to make IPL our own personal, moral Lent. <em>Give up chocolate? Fine silks? Sex?</em></p><p>Not that I believe giving any of that will help the Covid situation in India — but making it the fall guy in a messed up situation doesn’t solve much either.</p><p>On the contrary, based on actual interviews with people, Emergency Response Team leads and IPL insiders (sure, vested interest), there’s more to be lost by not having IPL continue than to be gained by stopping it at the moment.</p><p>I detest the label “real India” while talking about those who are poor and suffering because it makes the assumption that not suffering is somehow not Indian — but a lot of English conversation by educated Indians does tend to be delinked from where non-white collar, majority India lives, breathes and dreams.</p><p>If you’re rich, one has the luxury of “reading the room” and worrying about optics. For most regular people, which is not just the poor but most of India — the desire to keep moving on is literally what keeps them alive.</p><p>Finally, to underscore that pure Indian fatalism — a quote from Best Exotic Marigold Hotel (attributed to John Lennon before that):</p><blockquote>Everything will be all right in the end and if it’s not all right, then it’s not yet the end.</blockquote><p>Which may sound flippant but is also a cultural reality of how many Indians think and behave. It’s also more on point than comparing the complex Indian cricketing ecosystem to <a href="https://www.hindustantimes.com/cricket/bhutans-cricketers-guardians-of-their-galaxy-101618920981899.html">Bhutan, where cricketers transform themselves to local Peace Corp type volunteers</a>. A country with 0.00056% of India’s population, a laughable fraction of its GDP and one that relies heavily on India for its economy and <a href="https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/bhutan-prime-minister-thanks-india-for-4-lakh-doses-of-covid-vaccine-2396539">vaccines</a> can’t fairly be compared to India and how it runs its business.</p><p>Should India aim to do better? Always.</p><p>It will also never be the niche, happy paradise that Bhutan is but we will get our jollies in other ways. Regardless of what any of us may think or want, it so happens that IPL is one of those happy pills.</p><p><em>::Nima:: is the founder of Berylitics and a culture, consumer, brand insights specialist. While she doesn’t save lives, she waded into the epicenters of Covid to bring some of these stories from the ground. She does love the IPL brand and would have just as objectively reported IPL hate if that was the writing on the wall.</em></p><p>Have Questions?: <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/nima-srinivasan-9aa0159/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/nima-srinivasan-9aa0159/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c3d7d65ab9a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Peoplewatcher: The Four Horsemen of the Indian Adpocalypse]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/peoplewatcher-the-four-horsemen-of-the-indian-adpocalypse-b8bf56bb8eb5?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8bf56bb8eb5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Apr 2021 07:17:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-21T17:59:13.991Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Peoplewatcher: Why are IPL ads as bad as they are?</h3><p><em>What are Indian ads supposed to do? Besides bring IPL into our homes so we watch this event-blitz for free? (IPL Edition)</em></p><h3><strong>The Four Horsemen of the Indian Adpocalypse</strong></h3><p>I’m an industry insider — advertising and research. I’ve worked in this space for 26 years, loved ads since TVs landed on Indian shores and I’m not sure anymore what Indian ads are expected to achieve.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/799/0*nlQqdL4kNRF85KXu" /></figure><blockquote>What brand books, ad schools and idealistic or iconic ad gurus will teach you is that it’s about building worlds, firing imagination, feeding dreams etc. It is all about the feels.</blockquote><p><strong>Reality Hits</strong></p><p>Consumers generally let ad pleas wash over them like ducks in Speedo suits. They literally don’t care about most things marketers and advertisers orgasm about.</p><p>So media folks will hunt them down while creative teams find ways to grab their attention (“eyeballs”). Perhaps in that order. The best ads are supposed to <em>cut through the clutter and make an impact.</em></p><p><em>Are the ads we are seeing today, especially now during IPL season, doing what they should </em><strong><em>for brands and consumers </em></strong><em>or is it largely just a repetitive, anodyne shouting match from people who have money to throw at the system?</em></p><p>When I speak to consumers for whom these ads are ostensibly made — they often can’t recall much of it. It’s super rare they can link ads correctly to the brand that paid whopping BHIM-loads of money for the ad.</p><p>Most people may not see a big difference between knowing “Vivo IPL” or “CEAT strategic timeout” or “Unacademy Cracking Six” VERSUS actually buying a Vivo phone, recommending CEAT tires or paying to have an Unacademy account.</p><blockquote>But for marketers and brand stewards, there is a burden to ensure that money spent for brand presence is followed up with people buying into the franchise. Even if the core goal is to “generate awareness at top-end of the funnel”— a massive spend without establishing why consumers should care — is morally questionable, self-indulgent extravagance.</blockquote><p>Spokespeople for brands will tell you, on record, how spending 145 crores-ish, over 3 years, to be an IPL partner is totally worth it.</p><blockquote>Gun to the head, truth serum to the vein, life on the line — we must ask the question, “Is it though?”</blockquote><h3><strong>So what’s an ad supposed to do?</strong></h3><p>Here’s the thing. <strong><em>No outsider can reliably tell you that.</em></strong> Sometimes, even marketers paying for it can’t tell you that.</p><p><em>Why spend lakhs and crores then?</em></p><p>For one, that’s what it costs to be out there and do business. If you’re not out there, no one will know you exist. If they don’t know you exist, people won’t buy you and soon you REALLY may not exist.</p><p>In India — in-your-face omnipresence, loud ads and 4–6 crore celebs (<em>who may never touch the brand they’re hawking)</em> are seen as markers of a legit business and brand. This ability to spend like a boss distinguishes monied brands from dubious, fly-by-night wannabes that flood the market. And so a lot of our ad and brand dysfunction becomes the norm.</p><h3><strong>What Ads have the Potential to do for their Brands</strong></h3><p>Here’s a 100% non-Indian ad.</p><p>Watch it. Trust me.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fm-WCrcyYLEk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dm-WCrcyYLEk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fm-WCrcyYLEk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e8ce1b591ccac57de8a7eb3b7c951dcb/href">https://medium.com/media/e8ce1b591ccac57de8a7eb3b7c951dcb/href</a></iframe><p><em>What does it make you </em><strong><em>feel</em></strong><em>?</em></p><p>While we can feel anything we want to — including complete disconnect, here’s what the ad will do for the people that it’s dog-whistling to (which is also the intent of the ad and brand):</p><p><strong>Consumer KEY</strong> (insight or truth, what opens that <em>magic door</em> to hearts and minds)</p><blockquote>The lockdown forces us all to feel stuck in our boring, chore-ridden, now stunted, home-imprisoned (American) lives. It seems to snuff out the will to live even more than before — but it doesn’t have to be that way. In our <strong>day dreams</strong> (the refuge of little kids in boring classes) — we can be better in so many ways. We can look, dress, sing, dance, twirl and flirt better. We can come alive! Not just us, even sexy actors are just like us and get upgraded in their daydreams. That light, affirming feeling of being in a better place even if reality sucks — that’s the dream.</blockquote><p><strong>Brand KEY </strong>(insight or truth, that ensures the consumer KEY fits ONLY this brand and not a competitor — most ads fail this part)</p><blockquote>It’s that alive, upgraded feeling you get to experience, when you partake of Stella Artois. Not any brand or any drink, just this one.</blockquote><p>That’s what the brand is selling here. That feeling of lightness, liberation, relief, joy. That promise to be and feel better. To dream. To be alive.</p><p>I am not a beer drinker but it makes me wonder for a second if I should try it — <em>it may perhaps not be as bitter and beer-y as other beers I’ve tried. This seems different. What would it hurt to try?</em></p><p><strong>The Indian Market is Different and yet the Same: Because all people Dream</strong></p><p>Indians too will tell you these stories if you ask them not just about things they consume but stories around how they feel. Indians more than most people, feel many feels.</p><blockquote>Why aren’t there more Indian TV/video ads that made us feel this way? These are our ads seeking our attention, faith and money. They should be singing to us.</blockquote><h3><strong>An Inside Look: Four Stakeholders of this Ecosystem</strong></h3><ol><li><strong>Product Manufacturers/Designers/Engineers: </strong>These are people who talk fluently in obfuscating specs. Most consumers will tune out product-centric specs. George Tannenbaum, ex-Ogilvy Copy Chief and lone Linkedin entertainer, writes beautifully about this <a href="https://adaged.blogspot.com/2021/04/translation-and-meaning.html">here</a>.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iZjC9KkbASTC4awCalw48w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Consumers who pay for the brand and product — aren’t typically as much a focus as they should be</figcaption></figure><p><strong>2. Marketers</strong>: They usually get that there is a <strong><em>manufacturer </em></strong>vs a <strong><em>consumer perspective.</em></strong> That they will need researchers and ad agencies to ensure the brand isn’t lost in translation. They fight a gazillion process fires which in India can involve anything from a trip to the police station to greasing bureaucratic palms to dealing with legal teams to the gnarly headache of logistics topped off with the overwhelming pressure of numbers, office politics and the Board. Given the load they carry, it stands to reason that the core language of consumer needs, pains and feels isn’t usually first nature to marketers. Being consummate experts in sales figures by zone, NPS scores by segments and having to “<em>achieve</em>” growth, expansion, acquisitions, lapsers and other MBA-y things doesn’t automatically make Consumer and Brand Keys accessible.</p><p><strong>3. Advertisers</strong>: The ad agency or similar partner will grab the baton and try to convert the specs of (1) product people and the business goals of (2) marketers by being the Pied Piper that makes the right music that consumers will respond to — <em>not to imply that consumers are lemmings or children of Hamlin</em>. The point is that the Magic is supposed to happen here. But it can’t happen without Consumer and Brand Keys and they rarely have the budget or expertise to access those.</p><p><strong>4. People</strong>: While the first 3 groups usually refer to people as consumers, the truth is <strong>people are not consumers — they choose to be</strong> <strong>when conditions are right.</strong> They have the choice to stop being consumers and will exercise that choice in most markets that aren’t North Korea or pre-lib India.</p><p>In a market like India, people may buy Lia agarbatti, Vimal Pan Masala, Tata Safari or Cadbury 5 Star simply because the brand had the money to throw at “the problem” and the buyer was in that space. Most Indian consumers will tell you that they really don’t care for any of those brands and for as less as Rs.5, they will switch to another brand because they really can’t tell much of a difference. It is also true that they can be made to care but these instances with mass brands are rare.</p><p><strong>True Lies</strong></p><blockquote>While there is a general consensus in India that movies, ads, marriages and politicians don’t have to be completely honest — the better movies, ads, marriages and politicians should hold themselves to a higher standard.</blockquote><p>Which begs the question: <em>Are you being honest about who you are and your attempt to understand what the consumer wants — or are you a smarmy snake-oil salesman?</em></p><p>Recently this <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtaLr_r8R2E">Bhima Jewellery ad</a> showed the journey of a transwoman and used the tagline — <em>Pure as Love. </em>This spontaneously got a lot of “<em>kudos</em>” and “<em>hails</em>” and “<em>stereotypes breaking</em>” praise from various <em>netizens, </em>with and without blue ticks.</p><blockquote>Here’s the thing though — when you pay <a href="https://www.timesnownews.com/sports/cricket/article/glenn-maxwell-says-he-was-not-surprised-by-his-rs-14-25-crore-price-tag-in-ipl-auction-explains-why/742286#:~:text=Maxwell%20RCB%3A%20Glenn%20Maxwell%20says,auction%2C%20explains%20why%20%7C%20Cricket%20News">14 crores for a Glenn Maxwell</a>, do you care that he delivers (scores, fields, helps team win — match after match all the way to the Cup) or do you care that he’s loved and “hailed&quot; by <em>Indian Twiteratti</em>? By Bollywood?</blockquote><p>Back to the Bhima ad, sure the journey shown is beautiful, the family acceptance etc is all nice. The more pertinent question that brand-insiders should be asking is — <strong><em>what does the ad honestly do for the brand?</em></strong></p><p>Is the brand truly as progressive as it claims to be? Talk to women who shop for gold and you’re not going to get the positive gushing that men like Devdutt Pattanaik on Twitter were doing. Yes, the ad is well shot, it’s sensitively executed and India can always use more progressive messaging that’s empathetic to marginalized groups.</p><p>Here’s a quote from a Tanishq and other brands gold shopper, “<em>Lovely to see a transgender story…this needs to be normalized…I saw a lot of Millenials sharing it on my timeline. I have </em><strong><em>accidentally</em></strong><em> been to a Bhima store once and interacted with their staff. They have nothing to do with the mindset they are projecting. I didn’t buy it for a second.”</em></p><p>This may be anecdotal and qualitative but it bears out decades-worth of research. When there is a mismatch between who the brand is and what they portray in the ad — less engaged consumers will miss the message, more engaged, evolved consumers will see the disconnect.</p><blockquote>Indian social media is full of exaggerated, poorly articulated reactions with no guarantee that ANY of them has the willingness to be a consumer and put their money where their ungrammatical tweet is. This should rarely, EVER be used as an index of what is right or wrong for the brand. An interesting barometer yes, but not a reliable diagnostic of brand/ad success or failure.</blockquote><p><strong>Get the attention of your Crush, not the entire Class</strong></p><p>A whopping majority of people (<strong>Universe</strong>) don’t know you exist. They may never care. Accurate unaided recall metrics from quant trackers will prove this. Even for legacy brands — the existence of sub-brands, rebrand efforts etc will ensure way more people don’t know a brand exists, than those who do. This also proves the 80/20 rule — most of your sales comes from the few.</p><blockquote>A note to brand-insiders: The reverse is also true. The more you know a brand, the larger the size of the blindspot about people whom you NEED in your fold but they don’t care about the brand. Which is why it’s important to have reliable eyes and ears on the ground.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*APnd-s1d0zaIVAtzIcxMOA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A skewed reality: Getting attention of a tiny group while shouting at the whole, blasted ocean.</figcaption></figure><p>Within this Universe is a small subset of people who know a brand exists (most people, even actual consumers, have a fuzzy recall of brand names and distinctions) and in this group you’ll have a bell curve of haters, lovers and meh-ers. The middle tends to be inert.</p><p><strong>The distraction: </strong>There’s a tiny group (red dot) there that amplifies reactions in social media and usually, these people cannot tell if an ad is good or bad even if it came with a video manual. <strong><em>They will tell you whether THEY liked it or not. And that metric is invariably useless. You don’t get to be an enduring, profitable brand on Likes. </em></strong>Alia Bhatt in a pink kurti is a Like magnet with the ability to deliver profitable hits but most brands don’t get that lucky. Social media saying an ad sucked or was offensive doesn’t mean anything unless people who buy into the brand franchise feel that way.</p><p>The only true metric for an ad should be if it did what it set out to do (generate awareness, change perceptions/behavior etc.) and didn’t SNAFU the situation (eg.<a href="https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/all-that-glitters-could-be-a-trojan-horse-tanishq-ad-decode-c30fcfa5bed2">Tanishq</a>).</p><h4>Reacting to social media Noise is a guaranteed way to miss the consumer Signal.</h4><p>Marketer focus really should be on the light colored circle or “low hanging fruit” — people who are willing to consider the brand, buy it, talk about it and bring lapsers into the franchise. Over time, bring new consumers in from the broader Universe.</p><p><strong>On CRED ads, where nearly every Indian has an opinion…</strong></p><p>This is why the CRED ad — <em>while it was entertaining, well shot, went viral, has the Wall and what not </em>— doesn’t do much for the brand beyond getting people to talk about Rahul Dravid, his brilliance and <em>Indranagar ka gunda.</em></p><p>It’s an executional (how it was relayed) win where credit should go to the filmmaker and Rahul Dravid. Both of whom got paid by the brand but owe it scant little. The brand is the bride who discovers at the altar that the groom ran away with the bridesmaid.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/946/1*gF-fbn8yo8X-LXoon_KSkw.png" /><figcaption>If your brand is associated more with celebs than anything about you — you are not building a brand or speaking to consumers about it.</figcaption></figure><p>CRED may not care that no one knows what the brand really does (check <a href="https://www.facebook.com/abijitgangulycomedy/posts/296402608520088">this sketch by comedian Abhijit Ganguly</a>) for as long as they have unicorn-sponsored yottabytes of cash to throw TRPs in our faces, but that’s not a luxury most brands have.</p><p>If the game is only about buzz and not about figuring what consumers want or how to get them to change beliefs and behaviors — <em>isn’t that like buying a 12 crore IPL player to warm the bench?</em></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6LCHLeDKV4"><strong>Thalavaipuram: The TN-based <em>Bangkok</em> of Nighties</strong></a></p><p>In sharp contrast, there’s this <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6LCHLeDKV4">video for Arthi Nighties t</a>hat’s completely devoid of sophistication, media monies, celeb strut or MBA cliches.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/947/1*0mQYAL3ZjaEKGeVeVlbJjg.png" /><figcaption>Image not video: Video link is above</figcaption></figure><p>What this amateur delight does is speak fluently, the language of the market, and directly to people (wholesalers and retailers) who buy, sell and wear nighties.</p><p>Sure, it doesn’t create a dream world and it reaches a small audience versus what IPL blasts can — but <strong><em>it speaks to its audience with an honest, aware sincerity and that’s a fantastic thing</em></strong>. It will blow that resonant dog whistle so they hear the right positive triggers and buy wholesale batches of nighties.</p><p>For those not Tamil aware — that’s the proprietor of Arthi nighties acknowledging that there is a lot of competition in <em>Thalavaipuram</em> but here’s what they can do for you:</p><p>Give you the right quality — <em>guaranteed by double-stitch, double overlock, reliable</em> (<em>standard-aana) </em>quality at astonishingly affordable prices (Rs.115–155) and they also enable small businesses and women-only entrepreneurs. The trump card she wields is the never-ending buffet of designs (necks, cuts, sizes, pockets, embroidery, <em>Titanic Model etc) </em>which may blind people with a more premium, sophisticated sartorial palate, but for the nighty buyer in that segment — this is like A to Zed of Amazon. No intended target watching this ad won’t get what Arthi is about and the vlog clearly hits every <em>attribute </em>that nighty retailers and wholesalers care about — there is a staggering power to that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/651/1*H7mRqquGVs0WYavxucfBEA.png" /><figcaption>What may seem like gauche, shot-gunned neon paint is really “<em>Titanic Model “— or Rose print to give what the nighty buying audience in that price segment will see as great variety, a brand and unique designs at an affordable price</em></figcaption></figure><p>Yes, a video that reached (at best) a few tens of thousands (views alone isn’t the right metric here because there will be group watching in this segment) — should not be compared to ads that cost crores to produce and air to millions.</p><p><strong>What is remarkable here</strong> is that the designer, marketer and advertiser are all the same person and she — and others like her — have the pulse and lingo of their people and therefore know their consumer. They get this because they listen. They are invariably the same segment of people as their consumers while marketers and advertisers tend to be more affluent than mass India (a different segment.)</p><h3><strong>The Three Stakeholders Talking At the Fourth (People)</strong></h3><p>I’m definitely not romanticizing small scale, lower-tier brands but want to establish that there is a challenge in understanding what consumers think and want. It’s hard to get them to care.</p><p>The farther away we are from them, the less likely we are to make ads or post Insta Stories that speak to them the way IPL speaks to the nation.</p><p>This gets even more complicated when selling brands at a premium because we pay extra for intangible factors that need to be conveyed by the brand world and ads.</p><p>Indie brands on Facebook and Insta (like <a href="https://www.facebook.com/itokri">itokri</a>, <a href="https://www.instagram.com/bhavyarameshjewelry/?hl=en">Bhavya Ramesh</a> Jewelry, <a href="https://www.facebook.com/fabriclore">Fabriclore </a>etc. have the advantage of smaller size, niche target, clarity around their brand story, the ability to be closer to their consumer and being the same segment.)</p><p>That’s where Consumer, Brand and Culture keys (insights) come into play for mass and premium brands. There is a need for brands to invest in finding those keys so ads aren’t just media-blasts and Twitter-bait. So brands aren’t generic defaults but strive to be something more — that justifies their premium.</p><p><strong>The IPL is Our Super Bowl</strong></p><p>In ceremony, viewership and boosted ad spends — the similarities are all there. The Super Bowl is also when the US ad industry showcases their best work that’s not just engineered for virality, but packs an enviable punch in terms of brand vitality.</p><p><em>Can we say the same of the IPL ads we are seeing now?</em></p><p><em>::Nima:: is the Founder of Berylitics and a consumer, brand and culture insights expert. It is undeniably self-serving to have written this Medium article. Which is also true of most social media expression. But this is also honest.</em></p><p><em>The reference to the Four Horsemen isn’t to establish anyone is evil as much as to say — these forces, together, have the power to herald the end of the ad world when it really shouldn’t be that way. Researchers are the Fifth Horseman but are often written out of the equation.</em></p><p>Have Questions: Message me at Linkedin: <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/nima-srinivasan-9aa0159/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/nima-srinivasan-9aa0159/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8bf56bb8eb5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Chakravyuh of The Great Indian Kitchen]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/the-chakravyuh-of-the-great-indian-kitchen-98293444772c?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/98293444772c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[insights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Apr 2021 19:53:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-13T16:49:13.187Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Peoplewatcher: The Chakravyuh of The Great Indian Kitchen</h3><p>In the book “Disappearing Daughters,” Gita Aravamudan tells the story of female feticide in India. She reveals that two factors “predicted” greater acceptance of daughters in an Indian home. Not education or money. It was W<em>orking mothers </em>or <em>Keralite homes</em>. None of this means that all working women or all Keralite homes are daughter-loving emancipated havens. The data just tags these two <em>fields</em> as predictors of more positive outcomes for female fetuses.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qgrVApp3wymYeUJw" /></figure><p>Being able to recognize these <strong><em>markers</em></strong> are how Buzzfeed quizzes work and you can see if you’re more of a Slytherin or less of a Phoebe. They’re not meant to be quant-perfect and replicable like pH or blood groups. They’re more intuitive. Which is precisely what makes it way more challenging to understand how <em>certain traits</em> in people influence <em>certain outcomes</em>.</p><p>Every Indian woman falls somewhere on the continuum of “<strong>traditional/conforming</strong>” to “<strong>modern/progressive</strong>.” A whopping majority of these women skew toward the traditional end of the spectrum.</p><p>In India, there is a tendency to believe “progressive” or “modern” means “<em>drinks, smokes, wears skimpy clothes and sleeps around</em>. <em>Likely works and does not cook.</em>” Many of these behaviors abound even among traditional/ conforming — even rural women. Like many beliefs about being Indian, it’s a fallacious default and is nowhere close to understanding ground realities.</p><blockquote>The true definition of being “progressive” in this context is that a woman is able to <strong><em>feel, think, move and do for herself</em></strong>, even (especially) when it doesn’t conform to what’s prescribed for “women of her station.”</blockquote><p>She feels a sense of freedom and isn’t shackled constantly by the fear of judgment by others. Which is why most of the women in Bombay Begums are NOT progressive while Sandya Giri from Pagglait is so, at least toward the end.</p><p>Back in 2012, when profiling working women for Van Heusen –we identified two strong factors that predicted how “<em>progressive</em>” a daughter would turn out.</p><p><strong>Her father and her husband</strong>. Like a lease transfer.</p><p>Regardless of how much talk there may be about culture being a matriarchal domain or the strong bond of Indian mothers and daughters, the mindset of the father dictates the choices and options a daughter will have. Her access to education, friends, love, marriage, career are all impacted by him. <em>When a father decides something for his daughter, there are few players who can override that call. When a mother decides something for her daughter, the father (often with a brother) can still throw a solid wrench in that capricious wheel of a daughter’s march forward. </em>Yes, there are exceptions to this rule. That still doesn’t negate the norm.</p><p>Thanks to Darwin, not one of us can choose who our fathers are. Many Indian women also don’t have the freedom to choose their husbands. What they can do however, is choose a husband that’s less likely to shackle their choices and freedom.</p><p>Most girls are raised to know at an early age that you don’t buy mottled tomatoes, overripe okra or moldy bread. The <em>markers </em>for a good husband are a lot fuzzier and more arbitrary. Which is probably why it’s easier to go “like my father” or “like current trending movie star.” Neither of which guarantee the outcome of “greater freedom and choices” if that’s what a woman wants. Most paths eventually are like <a href="http://mahabharata-research.com/military%20academy/the%20mysterious%20chakravyuha.html">Chakravyuhs</a> (<em>hopeless, no escape situation</em>) that lull the spirited warrior into a trap that will close in on them. For many (not all) women — marriages and the kitchen in a marital home are just that sort of Chakravyuh. That’s what Jeo Baby (director) learned from his many interviews with <em>real</em> women, trapped in <em>real</em> kitchens and undeniably <em>real</em> marriages.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*GP-EZvxXknd6tZTH" /></figure><p>What he lays out though is a list of markers that can tell women — <em>the husband you pick will impact what you wear, what you do, what you cannot do, your access and your sense of self. </em>It’s no dumbed down listicle. For women — it’s important to see this movie as more than just “the horror of patriarchy.” It is a complex feast to digest, share and be aware of how to stay away from Chakravyuh kitchens and marriages.</p><p><strong>Indentured Servitude: </strong><em>Everything and the Kitchen Sink</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AHofbI76kpikI8Mn.jpg" /></figure><p>In an interview, the director was asked about his portrayal of the kitchen as a jail and what he had to say to women who believe they love their role of homemaker, chef and nurturer. It’s clear in the response of the man that he’s no activist. He’s felt imprisoned in a kitchen at times and he heard this feeling from women who spoke to him. He goes on to say how it’s always girls who are told <em>how to dress, how long their clothes should be, that they should not shake their legs, that they can’t go out to play etc. </em>That chipping away at their sense of self, possibilities and freedom starts early in a girl’s life and gets worse after marriage. They’ve been groomed since fetus-hood to be chucked into the kitchen, the frying pan and the fire. And as long as that happens to be true — any of it, for any woman, he sees relevance in this story. There’s a reason women often say, “everything changes after marriage” and it’s usually devoid of positive spin. Young working girls, even today, say “I want to marry late, around 25–26 or so, I want to keep my freedom for as long as possible.” That’s an admission right there that their freedom is like a cellphone you handover before you check into prison.</p><p><strong>The kitchen is a prison. </strong>The movie mires you in continuous labor and pervasive squalor right from the start. You don’t just see it — you also feel and smell it. The slow, repetitive pace of every deliberate act of cutting, cooking and cleaning is absolutely sanitized of any beauty or romanticizing we’ve seen in Japanese cooking videos.</p><p>The snail’s pace isn’t just a geotag of being a Malayalam movie, it’s so you too can be trapped in that <strong><em>vortex of disgust</em></strong> with her and feel the noxious, decaying pool from the sink stain your hands. Which the wife carries to bed, like a Lady Macbeth stain.</p><p>If that’s the sort of Mobius strip hell kitchen that one is headed toward, there’s very little chance there are markers of hope. If the home has a disproportionate number of mess-makers to mess-cleaners, that’s obviously going to be a problem. But if the norm is to cater to men to the extent where they leave their chewed up remnants all over the kitchen table for the women to clean after them, it’s best to look at that potential marriage the same way one would at a mottled tomato. Would you really take it home?</p><p><strong>Sex is a duty.</strong> <strong>Like cooking. </strong>It’s on the cards when he wants it, catered to him, in the dark, sans-foreplay, predictably missionary and involves him painfully ploughing into what may as well be a blowup doll. <a href="https://happymag.tv/kazakhstani-bodybuilder-marries-his-sex-doll/">Except blowup dolls often get more emotional connect and humanizing from their owners</a>. The only time sex is not a duty, is when it’s weaponized to be punishment. Which in this case he withholds when she displeases him. In worse cases, it can be imposed as marital rape. The one instance where she makes a suggestion so it’s better for her — the shaming, punishment and withdrawal are swift. While this is a phenomenally reliable marker, premarital sex is the only way to check this box and not always a viable option.</p><p><strong>Anger is a normal human emotion. Not all anger is equal.</strong> Defensive or passive aggressive, recurring anger — especially in a husband-wife equation can tell us a lot about how far south a marriage will deteriorate over time. It’s worth rewatching the film just to watch his face change when she (taking care to smile and soften the blow) remarks that he seems to have “manners” when eating in a hotel. In the sense that he did not eat like a drunk, scavenging hyena — but she never uses those words. It’s still way too much of an assault on his ego and he weaponizes the word “manners” later in the game when he finds out she dared defy him and apply for a dance teacher’s job. Not a “real” job for a man but one that would take her away from the kitchen which is not okay, because it’s “auspicious to have a woman at home.” He asks her where her <em>manners</em> are considering she hasn’t behaved “appropriately” and made him lose face in front of his father — making him a husband who cannot control his wife.</p><p>Anger needs to be resolved and not be a recurring decimal. Signs of the latter — are a clear “run for the hills” marker.</p><p><strong>Women are replaceable. As laborers invariably are</strong>. Indian Men who travel abroad are expected to fend for themselves in the kitchen. The Indian system that aids keeping them out of kitchens doesn’t stretch far enough to protect them abroad. That’s until an H4 visa dependent wife is dispatched to foreign kitchens.</p><p>In India, there will always be a woman available to cater and pander to male needs and whims. A maid, an aunt, a second wife. The movie shows a revolving buffet of women who perform this service. The politically-floated idea of payment for a wife’s domestic labor is interesting — but the market rarely pays for labor that’s easily replaceable and not valued even as much as women value their maids. What women need to understand is that there will always be women available to serve their men and save the day. And the women who save the day, will take pride in the power of their momentary usefulness.</p><p><strong>How much of you are you anymore, woman?</strong> If you are denied what you want for yourself — a job outside the home, a calling beyond serving family, the freedom to meet your own friends, have your own time, pursue your passion (which in her case is dance), express yourself on social media —<em> how much of you remains? How much of you does the Chakravyuh consume?</em></p><p><strong>The Photo Montage on the Wall.</strong> You’ll know it when you see it. You can read what you want into why Salu Thomas (camera) dwells on it for a long Malayalam film moment. It seems to tell stories of “ghosts of the past” where so many women came and served so many men and there’s that stricken face of domestic misery that seems to mark photos of old times. The one clear exception is the husband’s sister –a color photo, more natural — where she seems to have “upgraded” to a home, kitchen and husband that “allow” her an entirely different set of rules. There is no visible Chakravyuh.</p><p><strong>The House Always Wins. <em>The System Always Status Quos.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/262/1*Ki_wpmcVafaBvx9TF-74hw.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Trap of Niceness:</strong> Most newly married women believe they’ll be the exception to make the complex mechanics of marriage work smoothly, beautifully — where so many of their ovarian compatriots failed. Check in with young women about to be married and they exude the optimism of giddy, prancing unicorns as they learn the ways of their new marital home and aim to “earn the approval” of their mothers-in-law.</p><p>At the start of the marriage ( first half hour of the movie) there is this treacly trap of niceness. No one is an aggressor and yet everything isn’t right. While all Indian women don’t react like they’re allergic to words like “<strong><em>allow</em></strong> you to work” or “wear that dress in Goa, not here” — it takes a lot of repeated micro and macro aggressions for women to finally realize that the marriage has been spiraling for a while . At which point it’s usually too late to do anything different — for most women.</p><p><strong>Glorious nostalgia. Hateful modernity.</strong> The fight against modernity (no time and labor saving appliances) and nostalgia for a glorious past is usually a male fantasy and a woman’s (or lower status human) burden. While there absolutely may be mothers-in-law insisting their DILs grind chutney and wash clothes old school — The Great Indian Kitchen lays out a broad norm where “father/husband” wants something and that’s delivered by women, with resentment but without resistance.</p><p>In countless (well thousands) of interviews I’ve done, women talk about how their husbands will only eat chapati if it’s freshly kneaded and made by their hands and not the cook. This will often have to be done late at night, after they’ve had a long day — rarely do these women suggest the man get over himself or make it to his own specification. That’s simply not the status quo.</p><p>Men don’t need to be infantilized and are capable of putting on their own footwear and brushing their own teeth (movie reference) — and if women feed this sort of behavior, all they need to know is that they still are replaceable and are reinforcing the status quo.</p><p><strong>The Male Guest Archetype</strong>: This character was a genius touch and one needs to be a newly married daughter-in-law entering Malayali terrain to know how completely identifiable the spot quiz on who random guests are and how they’re related is. While other cultures may expect you to skillfully light 6 wicks on an auspicious lamp or make <em>a specific </em>kitchen-poison of choice to prove your DIL creds, this genome mapping is a legit thing. This guest goes on to mock the tea she makes and gives grandiose instructions on how it should be made. Think of scenarios now where women guests tell rank stranger grooms how they should do their job. Unlikely to happen.</p><p>This man does offer to cook for the evening after barging in without announcement, but leaves in his wake a destroyed kitchen — one that the wife will have to clean up. His well honed callousness and cluelessness heighten to a crescendo at the point where when she says she needs to clean the kitchen, he mocks her with, <em>“What work is there in the kitchen, didn’t we (men) do all the work?”</em></p><p><strong>Menstruation, that Blood Bath. </strong>After the back-breaking, sense-numbing sequences of kitchen labor the wife endures — most people may begin to think, “Well those three days of rest make sense.” But over time, it becomes evident that what’s labeled as “rest” and justified as “purity” largely builds up to be an inconvenience, shaming and gradual dehumanization.</p><p>While it’s true that some women may not have a problem upholding these norms, it’s impossible to be honest and deny that this does harm way too many women. <a href="https://swachhindia.ndtv.com/23-million-women-drop-out-of-school-every-year-when-they-start-menstruating-in-india-17838/">That 23 million girls drop out of school every year because of this</a>. All to most of whom will be promptly married and likely Chakravyuhed.</p><p>The “modern” news reporter who reports on the SC judgment of the Sabarimala case deals with goons attacking her house, her sense of safety, her daughter’s sense of self and is labeled a “feminist bitch.” If you’re a woman, it’s far less important whether you see the SC judgment as acceptable or not, political or not, interfering or not. If there are women like the ones shown in this movie who suffer as a result of the dynamic, even if they choose to never set foot on the blessed Hill — <em>where do your loyalties lie?</em> <em>Which axe do you take into battle?</em></p><p>You may not need to battle at all — <em>so what happens if you or your daughter should ever need that kind of support in another context?</em></p><p>There are women who believe they’re doing fine and others need to pull their bootstraps and be strong — they are also women and that’s just that. Empathy is not an abundant resource. Though given the precision of Jeo Baby’s vision and heart in this project, it’s really important to accept that one doesn’t need women alone to tell honest stories of female pain, grief and lack of freedom. The more such stories are out there, the better.</p><p><strong>The Arc of Redemption</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/698/0*TsaHKTIXOulvhRIc.jpg" /></figure><p><strong>To read the movie as “man bad, woman victim” is an unfair oversimplification and an injustice to a carefully crafted piece of art.</strong> There’s an entrenched system and because of the way it’s easier to preserve the status quo, especially in a place like India — most women will veer into some version of this Chakravyuh.</p><p><strong>Some women do escape.</strong> The husband’s sister and the wife’s friend both have homes that have no “kitchen as prison” cues and seem to have husbands who don’t find it necessary to dictate their wives’ every move. If one can spend time picking the right kind of tomato and the perfect loaf of bread, a little serious thought to the kind of husband (and eventual kitchen) may well go a long way in helping young (and older) women avoid the crushing Chakravyuh.</p><p>The movie ends on an “upbeat” note with its final dance sequence and exhorts women to move beyond their grief and that they are “Slaves to no one.” But what’s also extremely clear from the ending is the clear emphasis that for husbands with <strong><em>kitchen Chakravyuhs</em></strong> at home, there isn’t much change. As a woman, you (may) have the choice to never enter it, or be a war-battered Arjun and find the way out.</p><p>Most Indian women though, tend to be some version of Abhimanyu and may course through valiantly, but will bear the brunt of a system that’s designed to flatten them. If that’s not your life story — you’ve defied serious odds. Buy a lottery ticket.</p><p><em>::Nima:: is a consumer insights specialist and has likely spoken to more women about their life experiences than Jeo Baby did. She has zero capability to have written and directed such a brilliant film and can only write a long-form review in appreciation for reflecting the core truth of so many untold stories. Some people have viewed this movie through the lens of politics or caste (which may explain why Amazon Prime refused to buy it earlier.) That doesn’t seem to have been the creator’s intent. It’s simply the story of many women.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=98293444772c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Subtle-Vibrant  Power of Enjoy Enjaami]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/the-subtle-vibrant-power-of-enjoy-enjaami-23b0c959426d?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/23b0c959426d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Mar 2021 14:43:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-13T16:50:06.897Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Peoplewatcher: The Subtle-Vibrant Power of Enjoy Enjaami</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jKMECWLPrqrwrDmX.jpg" /></figure><p>260 million views. That’s what Jerusalema had racked up by December 2020. It was a musical antidote to a pandemic year that saw people coming together and celebrating a time that didn’t warrant happiness. The musical vision of Master KG, the soul-stirring, resonant, genderless voice of Nomcebo Zikode, the Angolan dancers ‘Fenomenos do Semba’ performing a flawless version of “eating and dancing while living not fancy” told kids, clergymen and cops everywhere they could be part of something special. People didn’t need to understand the Zulu lyrics to celebrate it, hear it on a loop and vicariously watch others do a socially distanced, coordinated jig.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FeYq7WapuDLU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DeYq7WapuDLU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FeYq7WapuDLU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d0213968fbbae8c984c083bcc91d4e36/href">https://medium.com/media/d0213968fbbae8c984c083bcc91d4e36/href</a></iframe><p>At 52 million views and counting, in two weeks since its launch in early March 2021, <em>Enjoy Enjaami </em>is riding a similar wave. Going by feedback from a series of reaction videos, the general consensus is that “<em>there’s something powerful here</em>” but the Indian language (Tamil) is not Hindi (it definitely isn’t) and it’s not familiar. There’s a lot that’s working to make this the phenomenon it is and the team behind it spent 3 months working on it from concept to final product and there were 8–9 versions that Santhosh Narayanan (Producer) teased out, even testing how it sounded in a car versus on the radio, before eventually releasing the version we see.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/955/1*s-ORyB_8ZjLoX2ElraFDNg.png" /><figcaption>Amith Krishnan placed soil on vibrating speakers to get this shot.</figcaption></figure><p>Visually, what director Amith Krishnan brings to the table — with a power he seems to not know he wields, is a <a href="https://www.studiobinder.com/blog/wes-anderson-style/#:~:text=Wes%20Anderson&#39;s%20style%20can%20be,simultaneously%20idiosyncratic%20and%20relentlessly%20detailed.">Wes Anderson</a> styled world. It’s visually detailed, simple at the surface but way more complex and packs Easter eggs for the viewer to find and in that lies the joy of a video like this. He talks about how when he hears a song, he sees visuals and his brain assembles those visuals together and that’s what he’s tried to bring alive. When he first heard the <em>parai</em> (leather-skin drums) he saw in his head a shot of <em>mannu </em>or agricultural soil gently vibrating to that rhythm. The brown, earthy, honest rawness of what Arivu sculpted in his lyrics is captured on screen by Amith, Dhee and the rest of the team in each frame of this 5:05 masterpiece.</p><p><strong>The Punchy Combo</strong></p><p><em>Arivu</em> — pronounced Uh-reev-uh (where the second uh is short like a soft gasp when mildly surprised) and not Arr-ivoo, translates to <em>brain</em> or <em>sense</em> and that ability to intellectualize and state inclusive, aesthetized messages that reflect the stories (pain) of regular people is his brand.</p><p>His inspiration here is the need to appreciate his ancestors — specifically his grandmother Valliamma — and the various landless laborers who worked on the land, for the land — even when it wasn’t what they “owned” with a sense of respect and awe that he feels is necessary. It’s not just the cliched idea of loving the planet but his stories talk about a beautifully designed space that’s in harmony with itself and shouldn’t we all <strong><em>Enjoy</em></strong> that journey?</p><p>Rather than be critical of people abusing the planet he makes the commentary more palatable — in language, in style and visuals so it will be received by more people. That the soulfulness of <em>oppaari </em>or dirge, a folk form of music, which is designed to stir emotion will connect with people regardless of whether they follow the meaning or the writer’s intent.</p><p>Dhee channels a presence we’ve seen recently in Amanda Gorman. A sharp understanding of what she should wear, how she should look and what she should say (sing) which when expressed through that powerfully unique voice that emerges from that sculpted neck and high cheekbones makes for truly compelling viewing. The stark orange jumpsuit with Tamil <em>vadaseri </em>temple jewelry that stands out among the earthy brown background dancers wearing <em>mardani</em> (henna that’s not the more familiar <em>mehendi</em>) was her touch.</p><p><strong>What the Lyrics Really Mean</strong></p><p>The song starts by establishing an idyllic, rustic world where man and nature seem to get along and man doesn’t alter what happens to nature. Literal translations rarely work from non-Latin languages to English so what’s discussed here is more contextual intent than “Google translate” outputs which the video already does.</p><p><em>Cuckoo cuckoo… Thaatha thaatha kala vetti (Grandpa weeding the fields)<br>Cuckoo cuckoo…Pondhula yaaru meen koththi (who’s hiding in the tree-hole, the kingfisher)</em></p><p><em>Cuckoo cuckoo…Thanniyil odum thavalaikki (for the frog running in the water…)<br>Cuckoo cuckoo…Kambali poochi thangachi (…the caterpillar is its sister)</em></p><p>While Yuval Noah Harari may argue in Sapiens that man has always messed with the planet, in this nostalgic world — there is a a Disney-esque equilibrium, where animals are anthropomorphized and going about their business. The one symbol at the start, the parai drum stands for something that comes from cows that are worshipped by men, but when a man touches it — he becomes untouchable. But back to this perfect world where flora and fauna get to be all they can possibly be…articulated by the graceful, feminine, nature-Goddess-like form of Dhee…</p><p><em>Allimalar kodi angadhamae (the lily seems to mock me)<br>Ottara ottara sandhanamae (the sticky, fragrant sandal has a mind of its own)<br>Mullai malar kodi mutharamae (a jasmine necklace as valuable as pearls)<br>Engooru engooru kuthalamae (my city, my space Kutralam — a town)</em></p><p>This points to the transition where from it being about nature doing its thing, it now becomes about man’s ownership, assertion of cultural identity (<em>my town</em>.)</p><p>There’s an abrupt change in pace and tone and the Man becomes the narrator.</p><p><em>Surukku paiyamma Vethala mattaiyamma<br>Somandha kaiyamma Mathalam kottuyamma<br>Thaaiyamma thaaiyamma Enna panna maayamma</em></p><p>Here he establishes that it’s the story of Valliamma, his grandmother. He believes in the healing, resilient power of a matriarchal society and identifies with the struggle that women in particular would have had if they had had to leave their homelands, work the soil in tea plantations (Sri Lanka), lose their right to live there and find themselves homeless again and find ways to connect to the land, even if they don’t own it. In his view it’s amazing that they can find that peace and connection and wouldn’t it be nice if we all did? (He never outright says that we don’t, it’s more a question — something for us to introspect, if we do have the same sort of gratitude for the land we live on and what it gives us.)</p><p><em>Valliamma peraandi Sangadhiya koorendi<br>Kannaadiya kaanaamdi Indhaarraa peraandi</em></p><p>This is a conversational interlude between grandmother and grandson and a nod to what happens often in chaotic inter-generational homes. There’s stuff we can’t find (spectacles) and we’re often looking for stuff for each other. There’s a connection between us and our ancestors that is in play for everything from spectacles to soil.</p><p><em>Annakkili annakkili Adi aalamarakkela vannakkili<br>Nallapadi vaazhacholli Indha manna koduthaanae poorvakudi</em></p><p>Tamil celebrates word play, repetition, alliteration and rhyme (other languages/poetry might do it also, but Tamil writers see it as a demonstration of skill the way rap battles expect you to bring angry swag to the stage.) The celebration of flora (banyan tree) and fauna (colorful parrot) carries on but now with the explicit declaration that we were told by our ancestors who nurtured this soil, to live well. Where “living well” implies we appreciate all of this beauty and respect that soil — the earth we all go back to, inevitably. Without explicitly saying it — the point is to dial down the sense of ownership individuals feel over soil/land and get on board the “we are grateful, temporary caretakers” train. Arivu refers to the song itself as “song of the soil.” To appreciate it as an inheritance that was gifted to us that we must pass on as opposed to “using and throwing” it — but it never gets to that explicit preachy, screedy zone — which amps up its appeal.</p><p><em>Kammaankara kaaniyellaam Paadi thirinjaanae aadhikkudi<br>Naayi nari poonaikum thaan Indha erikkolam kooda sondhammadi</em></p><p>Our ancestors “sang and moved around these fertile lands” which refers to the need for harmony with the environment. The lines after that “dog, fox, cat also have a stake in this land, it’s theirs too” are a reminder that we do in fact live with them. We don’t qualify for special status higher up the hierarchy — not versus animals, not versus other humans.</p><p>Here’s where it veers into the chorus — “<em>Enjoy Enjaami…Vaango vaango onnaagi.</em>” In advertising one tries to stay away from negativity to get people to feel good, lower their guard and accept the message. A classic Arivu move is where instead of berating humans for being lousy planet tenants, the singers tell us to Enjoy this world, <em>come, come together as one</em>. Because honestly, why not?</p><p>Enjoy Enjaami is alliterative (a Tamil win) and “enjaami” expands to “yaen saami” which is used by grandparents to refer to their grandkids (you are my God) and also by laborers to refer to their landlords. When used with someone you love, it coopts the word and tries to knock off some of the feudal, negative load. Arivu also says that “enjaami” implies “en thaiyee” or “my mother” which feeds into notions of a maternal, birthing, sustaining earth but that reference is less common.</p><p><em>Ammayi ambaari Indha indha mummaari</em></p><p><em>Ammayi ambaari</em> translates to “ride on elephants” and the rhythm there(listen to it) feels like you are riding an elephant — it’s slow, it takes its time and rocks gently forward and backward. <em>Indha indha mummaari </em>is “here you go, here you go, shower in the rains.” For an agricultural nation, rains are a life-giving gift from above and again speaks to the need for living in harmony with nature and if you do, what you seek will shower upon you.</p><p>The next sequence again does the yin-yang shift where Dhee slow-paces her melodic reverie wondering <em>how the hen knows how to lay eggs, who did the makeup for the gorgeous peacock (national bird,) how does moss know to be green and how precisely did birds know how to line up twigs to make a nest…</em></p><p>Arivu lands firm right there with the story of the toiling, sweat-drenched farmer and markers of civilization that humans brought to riverbanks. This need to draw energy from the environment results in (some) humans being sucked dry. It’s at this point that he pivots to pure <em>oppaari </em>(dirge) style to establish how laboring farmers will rarely ever reap the benefits of anything they sow…</p><p><em>Naan anju maram valarthen (I grew trees)<br>Azhagana thottam vachen (I brought into being, a beautiful orchard)<br>Thottam sezhithaalum (even if that orchard flourishes…)<br>En thonda nanaiyalayae (my throat still remains parched)</em></p><p>Back to Dhee who now switches to third-person narrator — an emphasis that every aspect of space out there that we feel a need to own, in truth — belongs to all of us. Animals, plants, planet and us.</p><p><em>En kadalae Karaiyae Vanamae sanamae Nelamae kolamae Edamae thadamae… (MY sea, bank, forest, people, land, clan, space, footprint…)</em></p><p>Rather than see those markers and divisions…Enjoy Enjaami…</p><p><em>Paattan poottan kaatha boomi Aatam pottu kaattum saami<br>Raatinandha suthi vandha seva koovuchu Adhu pottu vacha echum thaanae<br>Kaada maarichu Namma naada maarichu Indha veeda maarichu</em></p><p>This bit talks about ancestors who protected the land and possibly a responsibility that’s incumbent upon us to follow through. If the rooster acknowledges its connection to the planet by crowing after each rotation and going the long mile to fertilize lands that grow into forests — <em>aren’t those forests the ones we claimed as country and as homes for ourselves?</em></p><p>The idea that we’re a planet-destroying marauding species isn’t really news. What Dhee and Arivu manage here is to keep hammering away at the idea that nature, the environment, living in harmony and equitably is awesome but never once making it feel like any of us is being accused. Just subtly nudging us to possibly do better. That’s again its inherent power.</p><p><strong>On Being Better</strong></p><p><em>Pandhalulla paavaaka Pandhalulla paavaaka<br>Vedhakallu vitturukku Adhu vedhakallu vitturukku<br>Appan aatha vittadhunga Appan aatha vittandhunga</em></p><p>Again in <em>oppaari </em>mode — he laments that a bitter gourd that leaves seeds for further growth, is also something that our ancestors left for us. This is an implied nod to nature (unlike humans) that often seems to know where to draw the line and even something unattractive at face value (bitter gourd) does its job.</p><p>Animals in the food chain seem to know to not decimate their food source. Where are we on this front? In traditional farming practice there would be some seed-bearing plants that were not harvested, usually placed near a deity, that would be revered as the infinite source of seed for the future. Decimating food sources is not the way. Here’s where we see actual villagers (presumably) from Arivu’s village and that again lends to the song an honest authenticity even if the production is dressed up to “international” standards. In quotes because the intent was never to seem overly finessed but only to aesthetize what might otherwise be too raw, too real, too banal and ergo — unpalatable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/899/1*1KTPeb9ubLu98MPmXWnytg.png" /><figcaption>The hand of nature, youth, us right now coming together with the ancestors that have tried to secure and protect the land, in the best way they know how. Dhee wears distinct nature motifs.</figcaption></figure><p>While Dhee on a throne with Arivu by her side still makes for a stunning visual, Amith Krishnan closes on an entirely different scene. One that he thought looked aesthetically good but apparently when it was shot, people on set told him that the visual of Valliamma at the center with older villagers in the background as prime focus and the younger Dhee and Arivu seeming to take over the baton, was more evocative. This makes for a more honest shout out to ancestors than making the singing stars the focus. The visuals and words had until now showcased earth, water, wind and sky. The closing shot brings fire into the background to include another nod to nature’s buffet of offerings.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/958/1*Fbzya3WGOAtPuHG7H49qag.png" /></figure><p>In its writing and conception, Arivu was clear that the song had to make people feel something. They should not have to understand the words to feel this connect to ancestors and the planet. The music and visuals are engineered to deliver on that premise. The translation of the lyrics provides some context as to what’s happening but even for a native speaker, the first run reads a little awkward because for many of us — these stories and feelings that are natural to who Arivu is and where he comes from, aren’t necessarily a dominant part of our modern ethos. Even for a career-hardened urban capitalist like me, his stories behind why he wrote what he did managed to make me care just a little bit more about my footprint on the planet. Looking at the reactions of people to this song and video, it would seem I’m not alone.</p><p><em>::Nima:: is a culture, brand and consumer insights specialist and happens to speak relatively fluent Tamil. Without which this would have been impossible to write.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=23b0c959426d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[BigBasket vs dailybasket: Who’s the real victim?]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/bigbasket-vs-dailybasket-whos-the-real-victim-433737cc67f4?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/433737cc67f4</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Mar 2021 10:54:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-13T16:50:48.523Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Peoplewatcher: BigBasket vs dailybasket: Who’s the real victim?</h3><p>The BigBasket vs. dailybasket fight has landed in court.</p><p>Out in the wild interwebs where anyone can weigh in — the defendant, dailybasket, has now positioned itself as a blameless david (lowercase) being crushed under the mega-Pascal pressure of BigBasket, a massive Goliath.</p><p>In a brilliant/petty, defensive move — and to gain public sympathy, dailybasket has a site called “<a href="https://bbisabully.com/">bbisabully</a>” that details how unfair this is because <em>evidently</em>, the two brands are vastly different. The logo, the apps, the interface — each of it laid out side by side for “impartial observers” (in quotes because people rarely are impartial, we all have our biases) to view how the two are apples and anacondas. The takeaway it pushes for is that <em>BigBasket is an overzealous bully and should stop picking on a tiny, diligent player operating in a micro-corner of the market</em>. Another defense that’s floating through the ether is that common words don’t really build a distinctive enough brand.</p><p><strong>What’s Packed in a Name</strong></p><p>It’s true that “big” and “basket” are common words — one an adjective and the other a common noun that are about as vague and generic as descriptions get. It doesn’t evoke the force that Amazon does or the conglomeratey-ness that Reliance bestows.</p><p>Why BigBasket even came to mean anything was because Hari Menon (founder) and his team have worked nearly a decade for it to go from being something few Indians wanted or trusted to something a sizable minority lean on. This didn’t happen easily or overnight and the slick, non-glitchy, user-friendly interface we see today evolved from the team (and other vendors) building the brand to be just that.</p><p>To be the sort of brand where consumers can liken it to “<em>my mother sending me something when I need it.”</em> — that power of associations doesn’t happen with ANY basket. Big or small.</p><p>It happens when you build a brand that means something. When the fight becomes about what lay commentators see in the logo or a noun like “basket,” what doesn’t get addressed is what the brand means to people and what the true loss is to a brand like BigBasket. I’m not fully sure even the courts get to this in a trademark infringement case because the logo and app alone don’t tell us much, not in this case at least.</p><p>While I cannot divine why the dailybasket team decided to go with the words “daily” and “basket,” I can explain what it looks like from a semiotic angle. That’s the science of figuring what images, symbols, colors (and definitely logos) mean in a given context. We may not all “see” multiple facets of a logo, but there is literally more dollars tied to logos than most people know. <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/panache/netizens-muninstall-snapdeal-app-instead-of-snapchat/articleshow/58210180.cms">Even in a country where (some) people intend to uninstall Snapchat but end up uninstalling Snapdeal.</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*rowNM-E70Z1-EUxvfgIUWQ.png" /><figcaption>Brands BigBasket has no major beef with: Why would that be?</figcaption></figure><p><strong>What can we tell about brands like Grofers, Amazon Fresh or Nature’s Basket?</strong></p><p>That they’re in a similar “online retail and groceries” category? What more can we <em>divine?</em></p><p>The choice of color (almost a Salamander orange, Pantone 179) in Grofers and a unique name tells us immediately that the brand simply wants to be different. It’s not <em>green-something</em> or <em>something-basket</em>.</p><p>Like its gorgeously distinctive Delhi-Gurugram core, it’s there to take a stand and make a point. It’s a portmanteaux (like <em>Brangelina</em> or <em>Virushka</em>) of <em>gopher</em> and <em>grocer</em>. There’s literally no way this can be confused with anything else in the market because they care about that identity and want to make something unique and establish a legacy. Not an ersatz copy and definitely don’t want to borrow from something that exists.</p><p>This is important with brand names.</p><p>India is a country where you can see obvious copies like “<em>Ray Bran</em>” sunglasses or “<em>Polon’s</em>” talcum powder (written typographically to look like Pond’s) because we have a massive illiterate (at least in terms of brand recognition) consumer base who won’t know better, a poor target audience who want aspirational benefits at a lower price and a weak, ineffectual and corrupt system that rarely does enough to protect brands, white-collar businesses or intellectual property. <em>We don’t often respect what makes brands distinctive, path-breaking or innovative so we tend not to get brands that are distinctive, path-breaking or innovative.</em></p><p>One doesn’t have to go into Tier 3 towns to see this in play. Even in major metros average consumers often assume a brand is “Kellogg’s” even when they’re holding a pack of “Saffola muesli” in their hands. The truth is that consumers really don’t pay that much attention to names and logos and operate under a cloudy web of assumptions and a whole lot of not caring. This is one of the reasons why even when our team does 80–100 interviews for a client we personally go into the home of each consumer and check what they’re saying about their clothes and packages. It’s not because I think they will lie. It’s because someone who sincerely believes they have Vero Moda, often owns something called <em>Vico Mode</em>. Now this consumer will likely never be able to afford Vero Moda — but she did pay money believing she was buying the brand. And the maker didn’t copy the cut and call it <em>Soundarya. </em>They borrowed from an existing brand that paid designers, advertisers, media, marketers and various others to build a world that would make the Vero Moda logo recognizable. It’s those plagiarizing waters that dailybasket seems to get its feet wet in. In the animal world when one animal feeds on the resources of the other, to the detriment of the host, it’s called parasitism.</p><p>Amazon chooses to use the generic adjective “<em>fresh</em>” but the green (cueing fresh) logo with the “a to z” infinity smile tells us beyond reasonable doubt that this is their promise and it’s backed by the reliable, delivery-genius power of Amazon. Also in India, if you want to go mass it’s important to not have complicated English words. Generic nouns and adjectives are a good thing — but they also can end up meaning a lot more when a brand burns through cash to hammer that in.</p><p>Nature’s Basket tells us about its parent (Godrej) but this is a slightly different game because the target is entirely different. This is a brand that stocks 150 gms of Arla Danish havarti cheese for Rs.520 (Indian cheeses are less than a fifth the price) and has the audacity to sell a handful of imported, Scandinavian vine-ripened tomatoes for about $20. Yes dollars. There really isn’t much “nature” to this as much as it is a “global, <em>frou-frou</em> market that’s severely overpriced for an experience that’s not significantly better than Foodworld.” Yet, those who can cough up $100–200 per shopping occasion will go there because there aren’t that many places you can get the exotic foods or imported brands they serve.</p><p>Most importantly from BigBasket’s perspective, there could be an overlap of premium Indian customers shopping at both Nature’s Basket and the BigBasket app, but this segment is simply not likely to confuse the two. Interviewing these customers, will yield stories (not just from marketers) where they tell you not just why Iceland frozen pizza available at Nature’s Basket isn’t worth it, but how Happy Chef pizza available exclusively on the app is a viable, local alternative and BigBasket’s house brand.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/354/1*G1A3H53AExKfPOmU6L6gtQ.png" /><figcaption>Parle’s Fab!0 vs Mondelez/Cadbury’s Oreo</figcaption></figure><p>That is a different audience from mass to mild premium customers who cannot be bothered about why Apple (of iPhone fame) had to trademark the “soft corner on a rectangle” or Coca Cola has famously protected the shape of its bottle. All of these seem super common and obvious and inevitably get mocked on Twitter — but it takes a lot of work, money, trials and losses to figure what works, what FEELS special, what builds a distinctive brand etc.</p><p>It’s not just small and obscure <em>Agrawale </em>brands that do an “Anu Malik” inspired copy of an established brand world and borrow from its glory, to make its life easier. Seen above is what Parle is currently playing. Here the brand name and logo are largely different, but even upper-end, English-first consumers could quickly grab Parle’s Fab!0 when they intended to select Oreo, because most people don’t overthink these purchases and are often hassled when at a store. That’s what some players bank on and then it becomes the business of serious brands and their team of lawyers to protect this world.</p><p>We may love to browse for clothes or electronics but few people derive great joy while shopping for groceries. It’s that “pain point” that BigBasket has worked tirelessly to eliminate for those who will pay into that world. That world was certainly not built in a day.</p><p>BigBasket is among the few businesses that grew under the rancid, destructive shade of Covid-19. A force that killed businesses, decimated services and hurt consumers across the globe. But a quick search will reveal that even as they grew 36% in FY20, their loss widened 6.7%. That’s a loss of 611 crores even when they’ve worked tirelessly through the pandemic while keeping many Indians safe and socially distanced, in their homes. They also face a constant existential threat from the likes of Amazon and Reliance and also the fickle, business-unfriendly country and price-conscious consumers who on any given day can choose to just order from the local grocer. (Which they should in a free market.)</p><p>Retail is a punishing business and inside stories from BigBasket will tell you of the blood, sweat, tears and hair lost in the process. The socialist markers in India’s DNA tends to have most citizens automatically believe <em>bad, rapacious rich versus poor, struggling masses </em>myths. The reality, as it often is, is way more complicated.</p><p>Is BigBasket a more powerful brand and is dailybasket operating in a city that’s outside BigBasket’s current operating turf — yes and yes.</p><p>But that doesn’t mean that they won’t benefit from the associations of what’s the most salient brand. Stuff that BigBasket built. Loyal, regular users will attribute any number of glowing associations to BigBasket and as the primary online player their halo will extend even in markets where they don’t operate. This is the norm in today’s more consumer-connected society where metros and Tier 2 towns “wait” for brands like Curefit or Urban Ladder or BigBasket to arrive on their shores. So the “not your turf” argument is a non-starter. In BigBasket’s words, “<em>they may be small but even they must play by the rules</em>.”</p><p>If dailybasket is allowed to operate with these borrowed/copied benefits, when BigBasket launches in Coimbatore, the latter will run into an established, local player that’s masquerading in BigBasket’s clothes and benefiting from the existing BigBasket world. Salient leaders invest to grow their categories.</p><p>Even assuming dailybasket has zero benefits, it’s BigBasket that takes on the body blow that comes from an upstart brand that tries to be “<em>somewhat it, but not quite</em>.” What you see below is literally “red, but not that red; green, but not that green; clip art plus swipe these two words.” Clip art images in the brand world are like a middle school project level of puerile art. It’s uncreative and unprofessional. Not much chance of mistaking one for the other if you’re paying close attention, but NO ONE who understands brands can honestly say the upstart doesn’t benefit from copying a model and borrowing from a world that’s worked. This is an approach that neither Grofers nor Amazon fresh used. This is an approach no self-respecting brand with an intent to build a a real brand and a legacy would use.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/799/1*DQdAnp8Xd0fbdt74hdGxvg.png" /><figcaption>While “big” and “basket” may not be inspiringly distinctive words, the two together have meaning. It’s hard to say that “daily” and “basket” aren’t derivatives or an easy copy of the leading, established brand with a sense of identity.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>You may have been BigBasket if you’re an older sibling</strong></p><p>If you have seen (or been) the older of a pair of siblings build something with significant love and have that swiped or destroyed by a younger sibling, only to have the parent intervene and coddle the younger sibling or be dismissive of the damage inflicted on the older (creator and owner) sibling — that’s the analogy in play here.</p><p>Consumers of mass India tend to side with bigger brands because they believe that one gets to be a leader only because it’s through the “<em>sheer dint of hard work</em>” that they achieved that sort of legacy and position. America, on the other hand, tends to hate on established brands and monopolies and loves challenger brands. English-speaking, westernized urbanites tend to toggle between these two worlds depending on context and it’s easy to think of dailybasket as a blameless challenger creating its own, independent footprint in a free market.</p><p>If that were true, it would be good to see an ounce of creativity and not the tell-tale signs of a shoddy, derivative copy job. Another Curefit or Swiggy— in terms of what these brands set out to create is a fantastic thing for consumers. Another Anu Malik “inspired by” A.R. Rahman, not so much.</p><p>More than that, to call a victim a bully is a special brand of injustice. Being smaller or younger doesn’t automatically make one more flawless or pure.</p><p><em>::Nima:: is the CEO and founder of Berylitics, a boutique consumer+brand+culture insights firm based in Bangalore. A partial client roster includes Reliance, Swiggy, Ajio Business, Asian Paints, Aditya Birla, Google (USA) and Siemens (Germany.) Before this, she was Sr. Vice President at Kantar Insights (WPP) Los Angeles. BigBasket is not a client. Any sympathy expressed here stems from a deep love of brands, originality and fair play.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=433737cc67f4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Parsing Art and People Like Us]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/parsing-art-and-people-like-us-b5069c2047b?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b5069c2047b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paava-kadhaigal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consumer-insights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Jan 2021 14:09:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-05T14:24:50.721Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Paava Kadhaigal Review</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kIsLFoIfkp-mfQGb.jpg" /></figure><p>Jaby Koay is a YouTuber who’s known for his reaction videos. For some reason, he reviews a giga-load of Indian content. In his <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wye9y1eHR8k">reaction video to the trailer of Paava Kadhaigal</a> (Stories of Sin, Netflix Anthology), it’s quickly clear that he’s able to grasp the core values and intent of the series to the same extent that he can pronounce the title of the movie. Which is not at all — and that is completely understandable.</p><p>He tries to compare lack of acceptance of inter-caste love to homosexuality and talks about how the latter is an “uphill battle” and “much harder than…” — there’s a pause after which he says, “than that.” He’s completely unable to articulate what “that” is.</p><p>The world of rural Tamil Nadu and its values are so incredibly far from his Los Angeles-Liberal domain, that it’s understandably hard for him to even begin to process a people whose language mainstreams the idea that honor is so important — that dying helps uphold it.</p><p>The idea of shame is routinely articulated as not just one word but a series of nouns that you are expected to possess —<em>vekkam, maanam, rOsam, soodu, soranai </em>and the nuanced semantic differences between each of those words matter less. What matters is the reality that there’s a lot that can impinge upon us and we must respond to that in line with prescribed codes because… <em>This is the Way.</em></p><p>It’s totally expected that Jaby Koay will not be able to process the Tamil underbelly of Paava Kadhaigal regardless of how culturally open he may be to “<em>weird, gut-wrenching Asian”</em> stories. He’s a rank outsider. But how many of us can process it given that these worlds are likely so far from our own?</p><p>Paava Kadhaigal doesn’t just mean “Sinful Tales” as it is marketed but also, “Stories of Victims” of which the system ensures there are many.</p><p>It’s that eye to detail and human stories that the four directors bring. <strong><em>Something one absolutely cannot do if you don’t know the people, their culture and things they will NOT tell you. </em></strong>These are things you need to observe, process and make accessible to others. Few people can do that better than directors, writers and cinematographers and we are lucky to have these four artists who took the trouble to do that with a cast that does justice to the core point which really isn’t about caste or honor killings — that’s on the surface. There are no spoilers here because you should watch it knowing that lead characters die. What these stories can do for you, if you will not resist it, is tell you a little more about what people truly are up against and how little it’s likely to change. What we see across the board is a trap — the prickly-golden chains of conditional and toxic familial love, the pressure of society to conform, the utter vilification of individuality and how the system ensures that anyone who deviates, will be eliminated so the status quo can be maintained.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/770/0*MUxcjvBLHVsbdXwe" /></figure><p>The series starts with the credits in the foreground of an <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IH7ow3-9ov8">animation that seems to say — <em>I love you, baby girl, you’re appreciated and protected</em></a><em>. </em>The girl seems to grow up, leave home, marry what seems to be a lower-caste man and has a baby. To read that as such is to look at a well-crafted tiramisu and label it bakery bread.</p><p>This is a primer to establish that as much as is invested in a child, a payoff is expected. Not in grades, not in urban notions of “<em>stay in school, don’t do drugs, find your passion”</em> — but you stay within the confines of what the big 4 tell you. That’s Parents, Family, Society and Religion. These are the codes shown in the song. This is why, for many parents, education is not seen as a liberator but an enabler of <em>bad behavior </em>and <em>deviation from these codes. </em>Especially for girls.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWSoYCetG6A&amp;t=10s">Tradition song</a> in<em> </em>Fiddler on the Roof, set in 1905, perhaps best describes how important it is to stay within the codes drawn by parents, family and religion and if you do that, everything will be good. What the animated intro also tells us is that in much of India — birth, menstruation, marriage, pregnancy are all <strong>never personal milestones</strong>, they’re all societal (of the many) celebrations loaded with sacred codes, rituals and expectations. This is important to process for anyone who lives in a nuclear family in a city where self-expression is not sufficient reason for snuffing life out of a person.</p><p>From thousands of interviews across the country, I know with a fair degree of authority that what is shown in these four films is a faithful representation of where much of the country is. The end credits in some of the stories seem to give the impression that they are real stories and “ripped from the headlines,” which would be because they do happen. For those born into most Indian families, deviating from the norm in terms of religious and gender identity is unthinkable. As is pursuing a passion or person to love (even if same caste.) Living in the 4–6 metros and occasionally traveling abroad often leads to a denial of this vast reality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/0*SUWgRkUvKuXBKI4f.jpg" /><figcaption>T</figcaption></figure><p>The trick to being able to process Paava Kadhaigal is to not do a Jaby Koay and assume things by superimposing our strong lenses but to hear out these four crews who know what they’re doing and the people they’re talking about in these stories.While each story is worth more than one watch to really pick up on all of the nuance — there’s a lot they do with sets, language and color.</p><p><strong><em>Oor Iravu (One Night): PREGNANCY</em></strong></p><p>The two different worlds of urban, more cosmopolitan Bangalore where life after an inter-caste marriage is possible versus Thindivanam, where it absolutely is not. It’s not just the decor, the clothes, the freedom, the possibilities that are limitless outside the rural parental cage if you’re young and ambitious, it’s also the language that’s entirely different. Vettrimaran brings to this an eye to detail that requires multiple watches but given how the story goes, it’s also not easy to keep rewatching. Even the cups convey cues of a progressive, hopeful future versus a regressive, cynical past.</p><p>That a father will kill his own daughter because she married a Dalit man is common Indian knowledge. That’s not what the story is trying to tell you. It tells you the story of a woman who knew enough to elope and not naively believe that her father will “forgive” her and accept her lover (which many Indian daughters do, often to end in Shakespearean tragedies.) But she loses that sense of mistrust once she’s pregnant and hormonal and that’s a fatal mistake more youngsters should learn to not make. It’s that mistrust of the father she loves that had kept her alive earlier.</p><p>While the average viewer may typically side with young lovers, the story keeps reinforcing the idea “<em>see what hell this child/sibling/relative put us through</em>.” That’s the thing with elopement in cases like these — if you’re young you can run away from it and hide in the city with some anonymity. Those who remain never can forget and they live the dishonor, burden and ignominy over and over and over again in ways urbanites can rarely understand. In the end, as the daughter dies she asks her father, “Let me die with dignity.” She cannot even say “die with dignity” in Tamil because that’s a construct that comes from the western and urban world.</p><p><strong><em>Vaanmagal (Daughter of the skies): MENSTRUATION &amp; RAPE</em></strong></p><p>Features Gautam Menon in so wooden and subtle an avatar that for the average Tamilian one could wonder why he’s not acting. Unlike the previous story this features a family that’s still traditional but has some progressive codes like the wife calling her husband by his first name, the husband and wife being intimate despite being undeniably middle-aged, daughters who will be educated and cherished, more affluence which doesn’t mean progressive but allows for more indulgence etc.</p><p>When the youngest daughter is raped is when it all comes unraveling and it’s an interesting ride to watch what transpires on screen versus what urban sensibilities tell us makes sense. If you’re thinking rape kit, possible need for abortion, counseling, police — all of these are nowhere in the schema of this world. And that’s broader Indian reality.</p><p>Simran, the mother, is truly made to work for her pay where she carries much of the story on her ability to emote. If you’re a mother, it’s extremely hard not to feel empathetic, visceral pain in every crevice of every nerve. There’s barely any dialogue but her face is an entire Plutchik’s wheel of emotions where you can see her go through denial, shock, agony, anger, disgust, fear, empathy/pain/sadness — over and over again, each time she looks at her raped daughter. That’s the binary there — she has one raped daughter and one unraped daughter. It’s an adjective that destroys her from within and the family all around.</p><p>In what seems to be an homage to an old Tamil movie, when a mother learns her daughter is raped, she first bathes her to wash off “his touch” but also all of the memories. So much for rape kit. This particular scene is beautifully executed where she does it once and runs through the emotions and later does it again and realizes the futility of attempting to “wash off” a daughter’s rape.</p><p>The story and its execution’s biggest success from a standpoint of what it tells broader India — “people not like us” — is that a raped daughter can move on and live well. By making it seem like the story ends in a predictably gory manner but allowing a “retake,” Gautam Menon tells many mothers and daughters what they need to hear. By allowing the mother to articulate her inner dialogue, he recalibrates the average mother’s values — the belief that women’s bodies (<em>breasts, face, words and between the legs</em>) are temples that hold honor and need to be protected. There’s less redemption for brothers who feel the need to protect their sisters’ honor but in terms of how the story ends, it’s a giant leap for mass Indian womankind.</p><p>The writing also does a nice job with turning “<em>my honor will board a ship and depart</em>” (common usage to talk about being socially embarrassed) to “<em>I’ll use this body and conquer Mars</em>.” It sounds sketchy and specious in English but it is well done and more importantly, it gives the language of overcoming trauma and relying on hope for people who need it most.</p><p><strong><em>Love Panna Uttranam (If you want to love, leave OR Leave them to Love): LOVE, MARRIAGE</em></strong></p><p>It’s hard not to see this one as a warning to those who want to escape the world that prevents them from loving and marrying those whom they want to be with — it has a delicious start with one of the prime honor-killing instigators almost <em>virtue signaling </em>to establish how killing young lovers and making sure they don’t get together, is what the market wants. That’s how order is maintained.</p><p>As the second story in the series what it also tries to establish on the heels of the first is that <strong>children are markers of honor</strong>. <strong><em>They are NOT little fledglings to be protected and nurtured to fly the nest</em></strong>. If they do anything to cross that pre-determined boundary, it’s better to destroy the marker. While it speaks matter-of-factly about lesbianism (in the world of Kalki Koechlin) it’s evident that that’s not okay either since the codes here are more grey than as with Dalit and other caste, especially dominant <em>aruvaal (machete)-wielding </em>castes. Considering gay marriage isn’t legal in the country, wherever the movie is at — even with the straight lover deaths involved — is still ahead of where the law is at.</p><p><strong><em>Thangam (Gold/Darling): GENDER IDENTITY, LOVE</em></strong></p><p>Kalidas Jayram is spectacular in this as a trans-woman and reminded me of a field recruiter I knew from TN who lived in a time where the idea of transitioning would never have been a possibility for him. Wiki interestingly refers to the character as “She” right off the bat, which is relatively new considering the trans struggle in India is not so much about preferred pronouns as it has been about living with dignity. It’s also a beautiful intersection of religion vs. gender vs. small town bigotry and a toss up where you’re not fully sure what specifically will result in a crude, barbaric death — which is guaranteed to come.</p><p><strong>Back to the Parsing…</strong></p><p>There are Easter eggs throughout and I’m not sure I picked up on all that we’re supposed to notice — but what they seem to tell us is that all of these social constructs are interconnected, entrenched, largely immutable and we have victims all around us.</p><p>In the third story, in a blink-and-miss-it sequence, the final outcome of the fourth story is the headline in a newspaper that’s hanging in a storefront. It shows the pictures of the father and daughter from the final and fourth story and declares how she was killed when she came for her baby shower. No published review I read referred to this, which indicates how many such instances could be missed.</p><p>The red that is highlighted in the initial animation — celebrates the color in Zhang Yimou style with its rich symbology for its spirituality and purity but also for the color of the rose (love), blood (menstruation, birth) and possible gore and death.</p><p><strong><em>“It is unwise to trivialize that which one simply does not understand.”</em></strong></p><p>That’s one of my favorite quotes by Spock (Star Trek Beyond) and also one of my favorite quotes ever. Paava Kadhaigal fairly represents a broader world of rural, regressive, traditional India (also mass urban India) and does it with a more nuanced accuracy if we’re talking about the Tamil context.</p><p>It’s possible to hate it, disagree with it, be repelled by it and annoyed — but the loss isn’t that of the makers here.</p><p>It’s completely understandable to not want to be part of any discussion that’s this steeped in regression. It’s also possible to reject it because these aren’t Dalit stories told by Dalits. But it is also art that deserves more than misrepresentation or outright rejection.</p><p>If you’re in the business of understanding people or art, it asks for a willingness to walk the walk in shoes that are not our own, in a world that’s way too close to us. For each young person living in these homes, clamped down by these values and norms — I sincerely hope it gives them some strength to begin to break free. And stay alive.</p><p><em>Nima Srinivasan is a brand, culture and consumer insights specialist who also watches movies. And Netflix.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b5069c2047b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Praising the Brave: Double Movie Review]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/on-praising-the-brave-double-movie-review-b1b38a0f4f50?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1b38a0f4f50</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[soorarai-pottru]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bränd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-trial-of-chicago]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2020 06:14:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-23T08:08:03.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What our Movies say about us</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/351/1*FiOLlArIMrpt5BHXoF23wA.png" /></figure><p>Soorarai Pottru (Praise the Brave) is one of the more recent Tamil movies by Sudha Kongara with Suriya playing the lead. It was released OTT on Amazon Prime and has largely received positive reviews. Most people praise the acting by Suriya and Aparna Balamurali, the upbeat energy the movie has and I guess at some level the relief that it isn’t outright terrible, which a lot of much hyped movies tend to be.</p><p>It’s presumably the story of Captain Gopinath’s struggle and vision to launch Air Deccan, the first low cost carrier in India, at a time when we hadn’t yet been mass liberated by Jio and we didn’t have the diehard optimism that Millenials, Insta and Tiktok brought to the mass Indian table.</p><p>This same weekend I also saw “The Trial of Chicago 7&quot; by Aaron Sorkin and a multi-star ensemble. That unpacks what happened after the riots in 1968 Chicago where anti-Vietnam war demonstrators clashed with the police. In typical Sorkinian fashion, it’s an homage to left liberal ideals of standing up to authority, especially conservative ruling authority. It’s a story of courage and principles, stories of the brave — so there exists some connection.</p><p>Any such comparison is going to be unfair and the idea is not to race the two movies but just highlight aspects of the core DNA of movies made for us and by us.</p><p><strong>(1) Our biopics can never be truthy, by design</strong></p><p>They start right off the bat by establishing that the Tamil movie (Soorarai Pottru) is a fantasy composite. That’s code for — <em>please don’t be offended because we can’t really step up and do a true biography</em>.</p><p>Check the image on the left that has Suriya levitating like Dr. Strange versus the poster on the right that’s Court and the people, painstakingly recreated from actual footage of what happened in the late 60s. That’s like a metaphor for what the two will be.</p><p>Serious bio pics, with complex storylines and multi-layered characters or process movies are unlikely to have an audience in this great nation so it stands to reason that we don’t get those. What we get are feel good, untruthy entertainers that don’t completely (hopefully) offend the masses but likely eviscerates the soul of anyone who wants to know what really happened.</p><p>The hero is a socialist-idealist battling a one-note caricature of a villain in Paresh Rawal to bring flying to the masses. Just as with Roja, everyone miraculously speaks Tamil wherever they are in the nation (helps that the President in 2006 also did) and this village bumpkin whose skills include ugly-dancing in front of corpses, he does complex VC math and finessed PowerPoint presentations to keep pushing his socialistic ideals through a resistant and bureaucratic India.</p><p>The credibility of all of that is not our problem because it never is.</p><p>If you wanted to know the true story of Capt. Gopinath you could read his book <em>Simply Fly: A Deccan Odyssey</em> but what purpose would that serve other than to wonder why the movie has little resemblance to what the man struggled with to birth this brand? Also how do we know how much of that is true, we just don’t.</p><p>Contrasting this with Chicago 7, not only does the movie literally match the people and their 1968 reality with Oscar-nominating accuracy, even the lines they say are culled from court transcripts. A simple reading of the wiki entry for Chicago Seven is this remarkable ride where you realize that you got a dose of real history and all the prompts you need to see why the fight against war, racism, authority — all of that is relevant to you regardless of where you come from, which era you read it in or what your identity is.</p><p>With Soorarai Pottru, you get fed a linear lesson on “the weak common man vs sociopathic capitalism with rich bad guys who don’t want anyone but the rich to fly.” India is a land that likes to hate upon the affluent even while craving nothing more than to gain the social respect and acceptance that comes from having the trappings of the rich.</p><p>Did Jet Airways (shown here as Jaz) truly try to sabotage every move made by a small player who was going after an untapped market, I do not know. It’s hard to know considering there is barely any truth to the story or recorded info on how it really went down.</p><p>One “iconic scene” is about how Suriya as Maaran (or a ghost of an idea of a hint of Capt. Gopinath) refuses to sell out to a self-indulgent, HughHeffneresque Mallya-inspired character. A scene that matters because after this confrontation, the hero’s loving wife hand-feeds him like one would a baby and tells him that she would have fed him poison only if he was a sellout. Because Tamil movies are where things escalating quickly was born.</p><p>In reality, Air Deccan was bought by Kingfisher after suffering losses that could not be controlled and the brand was reduced to Charter flights for the most part. It’s definitely not the common man who uses Charter flights. The truth is that brands need to keep rolling with the punches to survive and principles of the founders tend to evolve so they can stay afloat. But since there is no burden of truth, the movie can be a one-note, juvenile fantasy of common man good vs rich man evil in a world of complex grays.</p><p>Considering that the movie doesn’t even care to get the fashion of 2006 or a Tamil woman right, to expect that it would get the brand story of Air Deccan on point, is unfair. As someone who’s studied fashion for the good part of the last decade, I can confirm that the heroine’s blouses are closer to the India Circus upholstery palette than they are to anything the average middle class Tamil woman wears. Again, in contrast — there’s a scene in Mrs. America where the conservative women walk into the bathroom where “shameless libbers” are changing and down to the white, functional, utterly unsexy bras, the fashion codes for the time are right. But since we can settle for “feel good” or “how good hero heroine look” or “mass song” — there is no burden of accuracy in story telling or depiction.</p><p><strong>(2) Good art should change you, except when it doesn’t</strong></p><p>You watch the “Trial of Chicago 7” and you’re likely to come away — at the very least —with more information about a key event in history. Add to that you get some sense of the right vs. left tension, some sharp notes on racism and the Panthers, an understanding of how the left will always be fractured because of the values it embraces unlike a more homogenous and united right, how people with principle behave when under pressure and because it’s Sorkin, you also get a grammar lesson on personal pronouns and noun modifiers.</p><p>There is an iconic scene where Bobby Seale, the only black man held for a crime he did not commit, explains to Eddie Redmayne’s character how their white fight against authority is a rebellion against their “one father” telling them to “respect country, respect the flag, not be faggots” and he follows that with, “You can see how that is different from the view of a rope on a tree?” It’s a chilling scene that quickly establishes how even if they’re fighting the same beacon of white, rigid, conservative authority, their burdens are simply not the same. It’s the art of saying a lot without saying much. Where even as a brown person, the idea of privilege, race dynamics, allyship and all of that come coursing into a moment of empathy and learning. Contrast that with a scene in Soorarai Pottru where the hero realizes that a sparrow eats less and flies low because of its small frame and this analogy can be extended to low cost planes. But the unraveling of the scene and its sense of pregnant discovery makes it out like they just explained Ramanujam’s theorems to you. On average, Indian films consistently insult the intelligence of every viewer by over-explaining the obvious. It’s another cross we must bear.</p><p>I’d imagine “Praising the Brave” meant that one should feel inspired by the bravery, courage and vision of the protagonist and his team. It was harder to feel much of that knowing there was so much of a story that needed to be told that would never see the light of day, most likely because the story simply isn’t “mass” enough.</p><p>Creating a flight for people who believe they don’t deserve to fly because it’s ONLY for the rich in a country that struggled to provide access or connectivity should have made for an inspiring story. You learn no truth in the end about people, Indians or the brand. While that’s rarely ever been a test for what makes for a good or successful movie in India, it was hard not to feel that disappointment that our movie makers and story tellers rarely ever tell us why we should care or be better. A valuable lesson immortalized by Andrew Stanton of Pixar in this <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/andrew_stanton_the_clues_to_a_great_story?language=en">TED Talk</a>, and is possibly why a robot from Wall-E or a rodent from Ratatouille can often make some of us FEEL more than our own (emotion-on-sleeve-wearing) culture and that shouldn’t be okay, but that’s how it is.</p><p><strong>(3) Regression is our norm and we shall have it</strong></p><p>Soorarai Pottru is supposed to be a progressive story of a man who elevates the masses and marries a spunky woman with more identity and career goals than a lampshade. Without doubt it has those elements but the moment it comes to a point where his business and dreams seem to be crashing to the ground while her bakery is taking off, it doesn’t take too long before the benevolent-for-the-masses hero becomes a bitchy, petty, raging whiner who reveals his insecurity about being financially dependent on his wife (something she has no issue with as long as he pursues his dreams and was her T&amp;C while getting married.)</p><p>He slaps her right across the face in a post-Thappad world. I’m not sure if Capt. Gopinath did in fact slap his wife (who did actually a run a successful baking company) but even if they did, what value does it truly add other than reinforce for the masses that this is what “real men” do and how earning wives can create family tension? She of course welcomes him right back into her arms the moment he has sufficiently cooled down, because as is said in Tamil “it is the hand that beats that embraces.” While she doesn’t say that, it does perpetuate that norm in a culture that sees it as such already.</p><p>There are multiple moments in the movie when it was hard for me to calibrate if the amount of melodrama was overkill or “accurate for us as a people.” An argument between a father and son on pacifism versus protesting on railway tracks ends in “you don’t have to come to light my pyre” in under 30 seconds. It’s like “that escalated quickly” is the norm.</p><p>A son rushing home to meet his dying father is likely going to be traumatic but here it involves public wailing in an airport, heartless rich people not believing true story of lamenting man, kind and poor lorry people bringing the hero home to finally being ushered in by erstwhile-supportive mother who totally loses it in the context of death. It can be fairly assumed that the son who couldn’t make it feels bad enough but apparently it is important for the mother to slice into his soul with a serrated drama-dagger and keep going on about how his father had to be cremated by a stranger like an orphan (dial up drama by factor of 800 once in Tamil movie) and go at him until he falls to the ground and ugly-cries like a toddler. We are after all a country who vilified Nupur Talwar for “not crying like mother who had dead child so must have killed her own daughter” so it’s not surprising that so much melodrama has to be the norm, but it is also hard to swallow if you also watch movies by Pixar and The Trial of Chicago 7.</p><p><strong>In closing…</strong></p><p>Not to pan an entertainer, as many people said — this is immensely more watchable than the two terrible movies Suriya made before this. And this is often our standard. “Totally not as unwatchable as the movie before it.”</p><p>Suriya also looks astonishingly pristine and definitely not the middle-aged 45 that he is, nor does he look incongruous next to a young, uncharacteristically spunky and satiatingly dusky 25-year-old Aparna Balamurali. So there is that.</p><p>But the juxtaposition of The Trial of Chicago 7 (a must watch for everyone) versus Soorarai Pottru (a maybe watch if you’re under-Vindhyas India) is something that does mess with the head a bit.</p><p><em>Nima Srinivasan is a brand, consumer and culture deconstructor who also watches movies. Especially movies about brands, consumers and culture.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1b38a0f4f50" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[All that Glitters…could be a Trojan Horse (Tanishq ad decode)]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/all-that-glitters-could-be-a-trojan-horse-tanishq-ad-decode-c30fcfa5bed2?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c30fcfa5bed2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2020 10:42:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-20T16:16:04.104Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Peoplewatcher: All that Glitters…could be a Trojan Horse</h3><p><em>What’s really true about the Tanishq ad —</em><strong><em> hurtful &amp; offensive</em></strong><em> or </em><strong><em>sweet &amp; affirming</em></strong><em>? Are those really the questions we should ask to understand what’s going on here?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/0*8TTINL-At8yeFFGK.jpg" /></figure><p>In Zhang Yimou’s 2002 film, <em>Hero</em>, we see the story of an attempted assassination through multiple perspectives. The key assassin, the King who is the target, other assassins etc each take turns to tell the same story. What makes the movie distinct are the colors Yimou uses to differentiate each version — raw, angry, jealous <strong><em>red</em></strong> versus cool, calm, sacrificing <strong><em>blue</em></strong> and eventually ends with a neutral, sans-bias <strong>white</strong> that tells the viewer what really happened.</p><p>It’s a beautiful piece of art that tries to tell a complex story that could literally take on many colors.</p><p>Where we are at today with the Tanishq Hindu-Muslim ad debacle is something like that. There are multiple perspectives and any attempt to make “red” any other color fails to understand why it is red in the first place. When we attach labels like “misogynist” or “anti-national traitors” to those involved, it’s going to be near impossible to see the ad (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKZ98GCm_vs">here</a>) for what it is. That being said…</p><p><strong>The Detractors</strong>: <em>These are people who saw the ad as offensive, anti-Hindu, gratuitously woke, trying to appease Muslims while offending majority Hindus. There could be more but that’s the core essence.</em></p><p><strong>The Supporters</strong>: <em>These are people who saw the ad as sweet, cues an idyllic idea of diverse India, represents Hindu-Muslim unity which has always been a challenge and at a time when we should be past identity politics, feels super relevant now. At the very least, it’s not what the Detractors say it is and censoring/banning the ad is what is offensive.</em></p><p>The point here isn’t to deny what these two groups say but just accept that like Acids and Alkalis, they are different and exist.</p><p>With most art, especially polarizing art (and I refer to ads as art here) there will usually be two sides. If it’s going to touch political or trigger issues, so much more so, any attempt to get one side to see the point of view of the other is going to be utterly futile and about as useful as explaining science to a flat-Earther or silence to a honking goods train. It’s worth asking ourselves why we would do that.</p><p><strong>Why does an Ad even exist?</strong></p><p>Public <strong>arguments</strong> about ads tend to be about what we hate or love about them, presumed intent about the makers and while that could be important to those who feel those feels, that’s a pedestrian distraction. An ad usually exists because those in charge of the brand (owner, marketer, creator) need it to say something about the product/brand to a specific group of people so they believe or behave a certain way after watching the ad. Typically so potential consumers know the brand exists, believe certain adjectives about it, WANT to own it, say good things about it and keep coming back to it . Essentially, “Swipe right on us, left on all others.”</p><p>Ads rarely EVER exist to trigger a group of people or offend but that happens when a series of things go wrong in the back end. While it’s impossible for outsiders to know what precisely led to this ad being approved and aired, here’s what is in play to see the ad for what it is.</p><ol><li><strong>What’s the ad trying to do: </strong>Hard to say accurately without being privy to the brief and internal discussions but it is likely they wanted it to be salient (on people’s minds when Covid helpfully depressed gold sales,) establish the brand as inclusive (Ekatvam), progressive but not activist (ironic), associate it with milestone events - for everyone. While this may not exactly be how it’s articulated, it’s consistent with the Tanishq world. But that’s also largely generic. Only a few brands will go “<em>Nope. I’m not for everyone.</em>” Abercrombie &amp; Fitch and Victoria Secret have gone there and faced backlash for fat-shaming but on average most Indian brands want more buyers and don’t deeply care where they come from as long as they can pay into the franchise. All of that being said, it’s hard to say how much scripted, over-produced “soft, idyllic world” ads really help when the pulse of consumers rises when confronted with more real, honest, relatable stories and experiences. Even YouTube sketches by comics and Instagram Stories often lend way more credibility and brand value than big-budget ad productions (basis consumer feedback.)</li><li><strong>Who is it for? </strong>Nike believes <strong><em>“If you have a body, you’re an athlete.”</em></strong> And they see it as their mission to serve all athletes. The beauty of where they come from is that their goal is to cater to Greek-God styled sinewy perfection at the top end, but want to be sure it includes everyone who is inspired by that ideal. Tanishq serves a slightly upper-end gold consumer but not the true top-end. There is a premium and the stores project a certain kind of standoffish sophistication that makes it inaccessible to a lot of mass India that does buy gold. The truly top-end affluent buyer may consider it as one option but they have many others places to go and drop cash for metal. The truly progressive and avant-garde consider Tanishq too mainstream and are unlikely to go there. So the target, “Upper-end mass” of India is literally middle-class, with conservative values and money to spend. While many of them may not be the sort to pick up cudgels and set fire to stores, their values tend to be deeply conservative. “<em>Love marriage only people are doing these days.</em>” (Some sort of broader, macro acceptance.) “<em>Our children will marry of their choice.</em>” (Say the right things.) But slip into their WhatsApp convos or DMs and the core values will be more conservative and parochial. Not that that’s a bad thing — but it means that they’re likely to connect with the premise “<em>Hindu khatre mein hain.</em>” Contrary to popular belief (and what Detractors are saying now) — Indian brands don’t like to be controversial or take othering positions. “Take a stand” may work for Kaepernick (to some extent) and Nike, but here it’s easier to say something insipid and hope people remember the Amitabh/cricketer ad. Given that aspect, the ad doesn’t really gain a ton of mileage with people who would actually buy- and those who may not have processed the ad negatively will be influenced by the backlash conversations. <em>So what did it accomplish?</em></li><li><strong>Warning signs we miss</strong>: It doesn’t take a PhD in sociology and Indian Current Affairs to know that a Hindu wife and a Muslim husband should trigger the <em>Love-Jihad</em> association and yet Divya Dutta, narrator of the ad, is on record saying she <a href="https://www.thequint.com/entertainment/celebrities/divya-dutta-interview-tanishq-ad-voice-over-withdrawal">absolutely didn’t expect such a backlash</a>. Which is what happens when one stays in their own echo chamber. In reality, love-jihad is an issue that gets a lot of passionate traction on social media and the hives will be out on this. Women are considered property regardless of what unicorn-world of Gloria Steinem (or Raja Ram Mohan Roy) ideals we may want to subscribe to and for those who see “Love-Jihad” the immediate question will be “Why not Muslim bride and Hindu husband?!!!” The idea that it took a Muslim mother-in-law effort to understand what her Hindu daughter-in-law would want and recreate that is lost when a perceived double-standard is front and center. (People sometimes take offense when the word <em>perceived</em> is used and come back with “<em>it’s not perception, it’s reality.</em>” <strong><em>The truth is that pretty much everything people believe is perception — but it doesn’t make it less real for the person experiencing it.</em></strong> A marketer’s job is to be able to know both those sides and still navigate those waters like a crack, Olympic rowing team. It’s not wrong to show a <em>Love-Jihad</em> construct, but to what end? What is gained here? Literally nothing. From a story-telling perspective, the flipped case of an accepting Hindu-MIL serving Roohafza and mutton biryani to her uber-pregnant DIL is not really a baby shower. But none of that matters. If you’re in the business of telling stories through ads, it’s critical to be able to foresee this — it’s table stakes in the game of “<em>How will people react to X?</em>” It’s like knowing that if you give A positive blood to an O negative person, you will have a crisis (or worse) on your hands. It’s not like what happened with Covid where a lot of the brands and industries that suffered and shut down simply could not have foreseen a crisis of this magnitude.</li><li><strong>What is the fallout? </strong>It’s easy to assume that the fallout is that there are two warring sides, a lot of online nastiness, much handwringing about the state of the nation (from both sides) and a brand that’s fighting a soul-crushing fire — all of which is additional stress we don’t need in 2020. Those are a given.</li></ol><p>The key question if one cares about brands (and the people they cater to) is — <strong><em>what did the ad (or brand) achieve</em></strong>?</p><p>For the <strong>Supporters</strong> it’s no beacon of inspiration — at best it’s “sweet” and at worst it’s “saccharine.” But it’s no masterpiece that moves them to the core. What happened after the ad was pulled is worse.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/0*Htlj2BZ0KwX6rSE7" /></figure><p>For <strong>Detractors</strong> it is a war cry and will currently hold the lead position as evidence of <em>hateful propaganda against Hindus despite a Hindu Nationalist leader at the helm. </em>Many eager netizens from this army were digging further to prove how searches for “Muslim” yields 352 results on the Tanishq site while the same for Hindu yielded nothing. Anyone with even a minor understanding of online sales and search optimization can confirm that there is no communal angle to that and this is so because “Muslim” refers to a design ethos and style preferred by a group of consumers (who are also Muslim, most likely) and no one is likely to search for “Hindu” in this context unless you’re on a witch hunt to prove your persecution. The average shopping-with-money Hindu is more likely to search by regional preferences — Tamil, Punjabi, Bengali etc. And if someone is to take offense, the Keralites should ask Tanishq why they’re so woefully underserved. Part of the post-ad policing also involved hunting down a Brand Manager on LinkedIn with a Muslim name who most likely had no power. While there is no reported violence against him, it’s unlikely he and his family felt unattacked.</p><p>For the <strong>buyers</strong> there is no additional reason to specifically select Tanishq but enough reason to select others because just like a house with questionable history, buyers back away in the short term. <a href="https://retail.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/apparel-fashion/jewellery/indias-2020-gold-demand-may-hit-26-year-low-as-prices-rally-wgc/77256050#:~:text=%22Fast%20rising%20gold%20prices%20could,on%2Dyear%20to%20165.6%20tonnes.">If industry data is to be believed</a>, Covid affected sales negatively in the first half of the year and it’s unlikely there will be a magical recovery in the second half — which means the negative impact could fade over time but the industry itself is hurting. All of which to say, not a time when a premium brand can afford to lose buyers with intent.</p><p>For the <strong>brand</strong>, in terms of values that accrue to the brand — it will receive zero respect from Detractors despite them having acquiesced to their demands. It will be seen with the same contemptuous stare that a bully lashes onto his cowering target. It will receive no brownie points from Supporters who will see it as weak, self-serving and sans spunk because the brand failed to stand up for the progressive values it seemed to espouse for its own gain, but backed away from the moment the going got tough.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*-sbL2oVvAswVCLeqp2GJSQ.png" /></figure><p>And with social media fires and the majority taking offense, with the very real threat of stores being burned down, vandalized or employees attacked — the brand is in the unenviable position of just hoping someone else messes up quickly or triggers a vicious news cycle so they take the heat off from here.</p><p>Net net, the brand loses the most and if there’s someone who gains, it’s the Detractors because there is now evidence that this sort of sustained exothermic outburst works. It will not be seen as a victory where we can all now calm down and take it easy because that’s not how the majority reacts when they believe they have evidence of systemic persecution — specifically from the Indian ad industry. We’ve all now been recalibrated to be more persnickety and reactionary and all content creators will be more defensive. We all lose when that happens though it may not hurt as deeply as it does when your favorite IPL team loses a game.</p><p>Brands (and the people behind them) often make mistakes and are not expected to be infallible. How we react in the aftermath and what we choose to stand by or away from says a lot about who we are. <a href="https://medium.com/better-marketing/how-adidas-recovered-from-their-boston-marathon-marketing-blunder-2aaae987a7bc">When Adidas “inadvertently” sent out an email</a> telling customers they “survived” the Boston Marathon, in the aftermath of the bombing, they shut down the backlash by admitting they were clueless (<em>gave no thought</em>) and insensitive.</p><p>The art of apologizing today (especially for brands and celebs) is different from what it used to be because it’s not about saying sorry or being contrite or even “pulling the offending stimulus” but demonstrating one understands why something was an issue in the first place. Most of these arguments are typically two groups talking AT each other and knowing why the other took issue with what happened as with say Sunil Gavaskar and Anushka Sharma, but brands typically don’t have that luxury.</p><p>Regardless of the final stand they take, they need to know how different groups of people perceive them and which side they want to take. This is what Gillette did when faced with backlash from men (where they literally took on their own target — gutsy and/or self defeating) for their <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/gillette-we-believe-ad-men-backlash/#:~:text=On%20January%2013%2C%20Gillette%20released,much%20of%20this%20cultural%20moment.">2019 ad against toxic masculinity</a>. The outraged outburst that ensued pretty much proved Gillette’s point but that doesn’t help. Detractors in this case still make it a point to say that Gillette lost money (posted losses) and that demonstrates how wrong they were, but the real <a href="https://fortune.com/2019/01/23/gillette-ad/">math is more complex</a> if you have the intellectual bandwidth to parse that. Gillette took a progressive stand as P&amp;G tends to take with each of their brands (Ariel, Pantene, Always, Whisper.) In none of those however, do they “take down” a group to pull up another, marginalized group. Spokespeople for Gillette have since publicly stated that it was the right call for them and that’s where they want to be. Detractors may continue to hate the brand but it wins the respect of Supporters.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/526/0*mA5ndoT1Ya6WxMGv" /></figure><p>When a brand issues what’s called a “<strong><em>non-apology apology</em></strong>” — however sincere in intent — if it has generic, stock words that reflect no values they stand by, no indication of learning or change — but just a “<em>we wanted good, but you backed us into this, we are sad</em>” — it’s hard to win empathy, respect or hearts from either side of the aisle or the massive middle.</p><p>As Lin Manuel Miranda evocatively says as Hamilton, <em>“If you stand for nothing, Burr, what do you fall for?”</em></p><p>Definitely easy for most of us on the sidelines to comment on but this is a tough situation for a lot of people. It didn’t have to be — but it is. As it will be for the team working on Muttiah Muralitharan’s biopic 800 (where he’s being called a traitor along with the actor portraying him and some remarkable forces of intellect on Twitter wondering why a Tamil biopic of a foreigner is being made) or those taking issue with Gal Gadot (an Israeli Jew) playing Cleopatra (a Greek, Egyptian Queen.) This is the reality of the world today and with <em>cancel culture, </em>makers of content and builders of brands need to be clear how they’re going to play this game. Dipping one toe and backing off quickly makes most people wonder why one went into those piranha-infested waters in the first place.</p><p><em>Nima Srinivasan is a Cultural Insights and Research Specialist, is the founder of Berylitics — a research agency and figured how to write many, many words on Medium.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c30fcfa5bed2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Viral Impact (Episode 2)— Part 2 — Need States]]></title>
            <link>https://peoplewatcher.medium.com/viral-impact-episode-2-part-2-need-states-d63ac21e524d?source=rss-3e9d4e260989------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d63ac21e524d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[branding-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[::Nima::]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jun 2020 07:14:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-02T07:14:19.594Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Viral Impact (Episode 2)— Part 2 — Need States</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/923/1*RtiOcIn2HhBp7rjHFcMF-w.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Fallacy of “Creating” Needs</strong></p><p>In what may feel like a Peter Jackson hangover, Viral Impact is a Trilogy. <a href="https://medium.com/p/7bd2b5ac6b0b/edit">Episode2: The Existential Treadmill is covered in Part 1 </a>which defines what this is and why it matters. It gives context to what’s shaping where people are at today and how that would affect them as consumers.</p><p>Episode 2, Part 2 explores what Consumer (Human) Needs really are.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/592/1*Sngl2BHp4BzywtqZpRV5WQ.png" /><figcaption>Image: Berylitics</figcaption></figure><blockquote>Contrary to popular belief, <strong>marketers cannot create needs.</strong></blockquote><p>They can identify, activate and speak to them, hope people will respond — but of the various powers marketers arguably have, creating needs isn’t one. Marketers can create Needs no more than the government can create a Covid-free country by writing a PR piece that they did it.</p><p>One difference between good and not-so-good marketers is their <strong>ability to understand market (human) needs </strong>and then execute flawlessly what people see in market.</p><p>There is a tendency to think of Needs as <em>linear and progressive </em>(thanks, Maslow.) That there’s something basic and primal and once that’s achieved, we can progress to something more evolved — an elusive nirvana or self-actualization.</p><p>But a linear model does not account for a <em>self-actualized homeless person</em> or why we are more evolved in some aspects (taste in music) and maybe not need much at all in another area (food or fashion.) People also change with time, space and exposure and with that, their Needs change. Someone who never cared much about cars for the first 10 years of their driving life, may suddenly be exposed to a brand like Saturn or Prius or the VW Beetle that makes them care deeply about everything from cupholders to keyless entry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/623/1*pb_6Vjrz0O6RmXHUQWAFKg.png" /><figcaption>Image: Berylitics</figcaption></figure><p>Needs are not linear, constant or stepwise gradations. Human Needs are more like a <strong>galaxy</strong> — complex, multi-faceted and dynamic. Without understanding this aspect of people it’s near impossible to know them at all.</p><p><strong>The Galaxy Model of Human Needs</strong></p><p>Among other things, our NEEDS are <strong><em>defined by AND define our identity</em></strong>. There are forces that strengthen and reinforce who we are (Grounding) and those that grow us beyond our core (Expansive.) This is <strong><em>not</em></strong> about having a Fixed vs. Growth Mindset.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/568/1*i6ViHQMQT-1wHC6Fv872ig.png" /><figcaption>Berylitics: Galaxy Model of Needs</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Grounding Forces </em></strong><em>can make us feel like we have a sense of control but can also exert a great level of inertia and make us resist change. It protects the status quo.</em></p><p><strong><em>Expansive Forces </em></strong><em>can make us more spontaneous, self-caring but also unleash some level of risk-taking behavior. It’s about going out of our comfort zone and against the norm.</em></p><p>The interplay of these two forces create and resolve <strong><em>tensions</em></strong> that determine how we react to stimuli — people, pop culture, media, ads, stories etc. Neither on its own is good or bad — they just are.</p><p>Unlike the Boolean light vs. dark construct in <em>Batman vs. Joker</em> or <em>Ram vs. Ravana</em>, human reality is about grays and spectrums. Since <strong>balance</strong> is at the core of most constructs — each Expansive Force is balanced by a corresponding Grounding Force.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/642/1*9vDOTTlcIPBl6bwHSeeqIQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Berylitics</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/619/1*pJMZQw-xXkOeHT6V0UnHbA.png" /><figcaption>The Galaxy Needs Model: Berylitics</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/568/1*dovpmjcMghJ025LdzF0Ekg.png" /></figure><p>Most people tend to have stronger Grounding Forces in play than Expansive Forces. It’s not just an <em>Eastern group culture </em>vs. <em>Western individualistic culture </em>difference. Studies in the west on Need States also showed a similar skew. What seems evident now during the Covid crisis is that there is a definite pulling in toward what grounds, comforts and adds to a sense of control and the Expansive Forces recede even more. Which will again make more of us retreat to what feels safe, familiar and comforting. And the home will be a fertile space for that, <a href="https://medium.com/p/7bd2b5ac6b0b/edit">as discussed in Part 1</a>.</p><p>This observation refers to the Indian context and not the US where the <em>Need to Rebel </em>is tied to the act of refusing to wear masks, there are protests in public places and that rebellion is against science and liberals.</p><p><strong>In Search of Relevance</strong></p><p>For brands to have meaning, relevance is key. There are any number of profit-making brands that do nothing more than scratch a basic itch and that’s relevance too. There is likely no deep thought given to what Vimal Masala (Zubaan Kesari) or Pitambari powder should “mean” to people. It’s a habit, it’s available, serves a purpose, people will buy it and these brands could be impressively profitable.</p><p>But for brands that care about white-collar burden like <em>differentiation</em> and <em>cultural</em> <em>relevance </em>and want to go premium-not-mass, that’s a different game. These brands need to stay relevant with changing times, culture and competitive landscape. The way to do that, is to know what people Need, what gaps exist and what they can do better. For that, Need States are a great place to start.</p><p>Taking the <strong><em>Need for Change</em></strong> vs. <strong><em>Need for Control </em></strong>dynamic, we can plumb further to find where peoples’ values, beliefs and aspirations are at. Groups of people with common (sub)Needs form a <strong><em>segment</em></strong> — an archetype with more in common with each other than those not in the segment. This is why <em>Need for Status (Social Belonging) </em>through money markers will be high for the Badge Seeker segment but not for most others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/855/1*Jq3jkXApJcKp372BVvR3Vg.png" /></figure><p>The <strong>Need for Control</strong> really kicks in when there is a loss of it. More specifically in the Covid-19 context, things like a new <strong><em>Need for Normalcy</em></strong> — never articulated before, kicks into high gear. For a brand, now it becomes important to decode what normalcy means in the context of people’s lives and values and what relationship all of these have to the brand’s category. <em>What does normalcy mean if you are a restaurant vs. a food delivery partner vs. a cafe? How do we translate that into action? What concerns can we resolve? How do we ensure people care?</em></p><p>The <em>Need for Hygiene</em> has always existed especially when we’re talking about food. This may come as a surprise considering the default perception would be that India has none of it. But most people believe they have a finely honed sense of hygiene, especially in the context of their own home and food.</p><p>In Pre-Covid times things like warm, heated plates, hairnets and glasses delivered without finger smudges cued hygiene checks for people visiting restaurants. That alone won’t cut it anymore.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*uY6bLsary4qSPnPzpB5DWw.png" /><figcaption>Image: <a href="https://twitter.com/CentreStandView">@CentreStandView</a></figcaption></figure><p>A mass restaurant like Vidyarthi Bhavan may insert plus-shaped, plastic dividers to tell you they mean business. Fine dining restaurants may need to make structural changes and convert closed kitchens to open ones or use other methods (image from France below) to retain fine dining cues.</p><p>Contactless delivery, mandatory masks, social distancing will all be the norm — what else can a brand do to convey both Covid-relevant hygiene and a sense of normalcy?</p><p><a href="https://abc7ny.com/health/magnolia-bakery-installing-disease-destroying-uv-lights/6214093/?fbclid=IwAR0zFCa-d8IoBqaQ10mIx26pKjyes00IgTa5pTsmRJxs69HgNh4Q29Iu-pE">Magnolia Bakery in New York has installed a “corona virus killing UV light”</a> that allows shoppers to carry on, more or less, like they did before but feel the assuring presence of Covid-obliterating technology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/263/1*UQ4BcGJo2RoTLu0NkMct5Q.png" /></figure><p>Closer to home Swiggy now lets us know how the people in the kitchen near the food are doing. While the 97–98F by itself doesn’t scream “hygiene,” just like <a href="https://www.insider.com/van-halen-brown-m-ms-contract-2016-9">Van Halen’s M&amp;M rider</a> — it tells the user that the person or brand behind the scene sweats the details.</p><p>Swiggy constantly thinks about this from the perspective of what the consumer is looking for (Needs). People feel disinclined to eat out, are afraid to order in and miss eating out — what do they Need then — the assurance of safety is one. Not just using the “hot button words” but constantly developing a world view and language that means something, like the “VERY GOOD” and “Best Safety Standards” symbols (like the Green Dot vegetarian symbol) designed to generate a more credible sense of post-Covid food security.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/722/1*S9Nk9zV7jRYrYBRQPBLwsQ.png" /><figcaption>Swiggy: Going Beyond the Cliches of Just saying “Safe” and “No Contact”</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*7ymDxahGFM4nMf26Mkyj6g.png" /></figure><p>Identifying Needs and <strong>figuring how to deliver on them</strong> is always a challenge. Right now — with tiresome clichés about <em>unprecedented times and #InThisTogether </em>(including Nykaa peddling personal lubricant)<em>, </em>if we don’t want to repeat the tone-deaf Kent breadmaker debacle (<a href="https://medium.com/@nimavasan/sure-kent-messed-up-but-theres-more-1c1f1195c126">more on that here</a>), it’s critical to understand the Needs and Execution space.</p><p>More to come in next week’s Final installment on Viral Impact: Episode 3— how all of this is changing behaviors and what brands are doing about them.</p><p><em>Nima is a Consumer Insights &amp; Culture Specialist and the founder of Berylitics, a Boutique Insights Agency. Which is largely Linkedin speak for “she travels all over and speaks to people with no(ish) fear of the virus.” She can be reached at nima.srinivasan@berylitics.com</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/182/1*B2KfxpmcNSh4CMTqzVGh2w.png" /></figure><p>*Full Disclosure: Swiggy has been a client but Berylitics was not involved in the Covid-related efforts.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d63ac21e524d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>