<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Perspectives in C on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Perspectives in C on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@perspectivesinc?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 23:22:09 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@perspectivesinc/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AI is going to force America to evolve.]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/ai-is-going-to-force-america-to-evolve-19876229e0ec?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/19876229e0ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Sep 2025 03:42:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-20T03:42:13.070Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’ll be the end of the nation we know. The only question is what will replace it when the dust settles.</p><p>About 11,000 years ago, human beings invented “agriculture.” We all know that plants grow upon the earth and yield edible things for people to eat; agriculture is the business of doing this deliberately, of putting down seeds with the express intent of growing food, and thereby having control over the quantities and types of nutrition you receive. This was a major step forward for humanity, since prior to that they had to run around hoping to trip over plants, and if they failed to do so for too many days in a row, starvation set in and the humans died a lot. Of course, they still had to run around and trip over animals if they wanted protein, at least until about 1,000 years later when the first livestock were domesticated. People looking to make all of this agriculture stuff happen on a larger scale eventually settled between the Tigris and the Euphrates rivers, the so-called “Fertile Crescent,” and, 8,000 years ago, invented civilization as we know it today — the large-scale cooperation of humans in pursuit of farming.</p><p>But even with these new advances in techniques and cooperation, life was only so improved. With large quantities of human beings concentrated in a single location, mankind had to invent new technologies to help maintain social order and prevent individual whims from threatening collective safety. Laws, for instance, help do this; and while no one knows when marriage was invented, it would have started to be critical to survival about now. Even worse, farming isn’t a reliable science; you plant in the hopes of getting a lot of crops, but any number of natural mishaps or disasters could limit your output. Consequently, there sometimes wasn’t enough to go around. Mankind had stumbled on the concept of “scarcity” — “the basic fact of life that there exists only a finite amount of human and nonhuman resources which the best technical knowledge is capable of using to produce only limited maximum amounts of each economic good”,<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scarcity"> to quote Wikipedia</a>. And this was a big deal, because scarcity has defined the human existence.</p><p>What do we, as humans eight thousand years ago, do about the fact that there isn’t enough food? The obvious answer is to simply grow more… but, as mentioned, farming isn’t a reliable science. Weather, pestilence, acts of god, poor social standing with your community, pure bad luck, can all reduce the size of a crop. Human injury too: farming requires work, to both raise the crops during the growing season and harvest them when they’re grown, and if you lack sufficient hands, you lose some of the food to rot and age. Also, what if we’re out of room? — the Fertile Crescent is a specific, defined geographic area, meaning there are boundaries to the amount of arable land. We might have to move to a new place, where growing conditions aren’t as good — in addition to creating logistical issues where that food, grown far away from the population center, has to be transported <em>to</em> that population center, thereby exposing both it and its (current) owners to additional risks. No, we’re just going to have to do something drastic: We’re going to have to invent politics.</p><p>Now, before we continue, I should disclaim a couple of things. One: These are all broad oversimplifications. Please stick with me, because I have a point to make, but I know that there are details and nuances being glossed over. Second, let’s define politics briefly.<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics"> Wikipedia calls it</a> “the set of activities that are associated with making decisions in groups, or other forms of power relations among individuals, such as the distribution of resources or status.” This is a good definition, but I want to take it one step further: Politics is the set of activities that are associated with buying rights: you decide that certain people should get to have certain things, and you back up your decision by spending <em>actual effort</em>, or actual money, on those things. The American Declaration of Independence can parrot about things being “inalienable” all it wants, but the truth is that these things (“Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness”) are things the American government committed to guaranteeing to its citizens; if that government collapsed, so would American citizens’ “inalienable” access to these rights. At the end of the day, no human being has any rights; the point of politics, the point of a government, is to declare that a human being has rights, choose which rights those are going to be, and defend them. I am not saying this because I think the American system is bad, I am saying this because this is a fundamental premise of the point I’m trying to make: that the purpose of a government, the purpose of politics, is to assign rights to certain humans and then defend those rights. To take it a little further, the purpose of a government and politics is to decide which humans actually count as humans under the law — which ones are going to have all of their rights, at least the ones permitted by this particular government, defended.</p><p>And that’s where things get interesting, because: Which rights? And, for that matter, which humans? In my opinion, we can define any government, any political system, any economic system, by the rights it defends and the people it defends those rights for. We can define any government by who it thinks is fully human.</p><p>Back to Sumer, 8,000 years ago. We’re having a problem. The crops have come in and there isn’t going to be enough to feed everyone. We need to decide how to ration and apportion the food we have. Which means, at the end of the day, we need to decide which of our citizens, if any, have a right to life. If we can only feed / save some of them, which ones are they gonna be?</p><p>The most basic political system is the absolute despotism or dictatorship. Under this system, there is literally only one human: the despot or dictator. Everyone else is expendable. And, to (again) oversimplify broadly, we stuck with this system for a while. Sometimes the despot was called a king, sometimes they were called a pharaoh, whatever: but whatever the case, they were the only person whom everyone in the culture would try to save.</p><p>Within five thousand years, we had developed newer systems. Protecting your king is all well and good, but a king without subjects can’t accomplish much. But, again, scarcity: we can’t save everyone. So which subjects do we save, and how do we choose them?</p><p>Perhaps the simplest answer, after despotism, is feudalism, which is essentially a militocracy. What is a “knight,” at the end of the day?, if we take away the shining armor and the cool sword and the horse and the chivalry. At the end of the day, a knight is a professional soldier, someone whose full-time job is war. A knight is the lowest rank of nobility; a lord — a count, a duke, a baron, whatever — is just a promoted knight; a king is just a promoted lord. In a feudalism, the people we prioritize are our soldiers. (This is underlined in classic feudalism where a knight specifically needs a “fief,” a parcel of land, to be legitimate; the land comes with peasants, who till the soil and provide for the knight’s daily needs so that the knight can devote themselves exclusively to either fighting this war or training for the next one. These peasants were explicitly second-class citizens. One of Dave Barry’s books, satirizing history, had a diagram where the feudal hierarchy went from the king at the top all the way to knights at the bottom, followed by dirt, followed by peasants at the very bottom, which was both funny and 100% historically correct.) I’m not going to get into oligarchies, theocracies, caste systems, etc because I’m not as familiar with the logic behind them, but I can only assume the logic was similar: “We’re going to prioritize these people because they are who provide us labor we value.”</p><p>Besides, Feudalism actually had one feature that many of those other political systems lacked. It wasn’t just that it defined a larger number of people as first-class citizens. It also introduced the idea of “upward mobility.” If all we care about, in a feudalism, is military prowess, then, if we’re wise, we’ll open our system to the potential that mere peasants can provide that prowess. In a feudalism, the majority of knights were the offspring of other knights, because having the time to train with sword and shield and spear and horse requires large amounts of privilege… But some were peasants who were promoted in recognition of their valor. Feudalism was, in that sense, a <em>meritocracy</em>.</p><p>About 400 years ago, around the time of the Renaissance, non-soldiers started providing non-military value to their societies, and the political system shifted yet again. Here we saw the rise of both democracy and capitalism, which proposed the comparatively radical idea that anyone can contribute, and that non-military contributions are valuable. To quote Winston Churchill, “it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time”, and the same is true of capitalism. It’s a meritocracy writ large: In a democracy or capitalism, <em>anyone</em> can prove that they are a valuable member of the community. It’s not just that anyone can provide labor we value, it’s that we start valuing many different kinds of labor, not just professional soldiery.</p><p>Capitalism is still not perfect, of course. Throughout history, we have defined citizenship through that single axis, through the question of who provides valuable labor. Capitalism merely expands the definition of “valuable labor.” The single axis along which people are judged may be the broadest to date, but it still exists. We still live in a kyriarchy where people have to prove they deserve rights.</p><p>So why do I think it’s time to leave capitalism behind? Simple: it’s time to leave <em>scarcity</em> behind. I’ve <a href="https://medium.com/@perspectivesinc/the-only-presidential-candidate-that-can-defeat-donald-trump-is-a-pie-making-unicorn-b5ecfa83a4f5">written before</a> about how we have reached the technological point of no longer needing it. My essay does have some holes in it — it has no comprehension of the effects it will have on the environment, for instance — but the fact that we are approaching the possibility of a post-scarcity singularity <em>at all</em> is still worth discussing.</p><p>Plus, at the end of the day, while capitalism may be the worst form of economy excepting all the others, it is still a bad form of economy. It is still based on the idea that people do not deserve rights unless they prove otherwise. It is still based on the idea that only certain people qualify as human. It is still based on the idea that all people are <em>not</em> created equal.</p><p>And, lastly but not leastly, here’s the thing: to a very real extent, I no longer differentiate between political systems and economic systems, because both of them can and do provide the same thing: they determine who has rights. Yes, Americans <em>theoretically</em> are guaranteed LL&amp;PH, but as we all know, in practice this is gated behind employment. Yes, Americans <em>theoretically</em> are legally forbidden from doing certain things, but if something is punishable by fine, it is not <em>actually</em> illegal, it is merely illegal for people who aren’t rich. Yes, Americans <em>theoretically</em> are entitled to a jury of their peers, but if I am ever tried for a crime, the jury will not be my peers, because jurists are paid $15 dollars a day and I don’t have a single peer who can survive on that; I will be judged, instead, by people who are much, much richer than me, and there will be an inherent bias in whatever judgment they hand down. (Hopefully the crime I am being charged with is not somehow aligned against them.)</p><p>So, do we live in America, or do we live in a capitalism? Because we’re going to have to pick one.</p><p>And AI is going to force the issue.</p><p>The idea of “Artificial Intelligence” is all over science-fiction. Most of the time, storytellers jump past the idea of how the AIs were created and straight to the idea of what happens if they exist. We do not trust that artificial intelligences will have the same moral or ethical constraints on their behavior as humans do. (Let’s be honest, many humans don’t have moral or ethical constraints on their behavior as it is. What happens if you put such a mind in a resilient, tireless robot?) That’s why we have nightmares of AI being the death of the human species. And with companies going in hard on AI, it seems like we’re forging ahead into untrod territory.</p><p>Of course, that assumes that AI can do anything useful. To a very real extent, it can’t right now. Currently, generative models are big — the abbreviation in “ChatGPT” stands for “generative pre-trained transformer” — but these things have no reasoning ability of their own; they work is by regurgitating whatever is popular, uncritically and unironically. If someone started a Reddit post that said, “Let’s fool the AI learning models, everybody upvote if 1 + 1 = 3,” and enough people upvoted, ChatGPT would indeed start announcing that 1 plus 1 is 3. It is extremely limited, and its limits have already been found and defined.</p><p>Obviously, such limitations can be overcome. But what happens after they are? I, like many, was laid off in June ’22, at the beginning of the current recession; I ended up at the United States Post Office as a Rural Carrier Associate, where I spent most of my time driving that little mail truck towards and through the Santa Cruz Mountains, delivering to Saratoga and Los Gatos, CA. This seems like something you could invent an autonomouis mail truck to do: self-driving cars are certainly being developed; it seems pretty obvious that, if we can make robotic assembly arms, we can make some sort of robotic extender that comes out of the truck and physically plonks the mail into a mailbox; and the sorting of the mail? …Well, I mean, the DPS feed isn’t perfect. Each post office determines the routes it serves, creating comparatively contiguous strings of mailboxes to deliver to; that route then gets a “<a href="https://www.pinterest.com/pin/letter-carrier-case--94646029642584313/">case</a>” with a slot for every mailbox on its route, and every morning you have to fill that case — a business that perhaps inevitably became known as “casing” your mail.</p><ul><li>You get “delivery-point sorted” mail, which has already been organized, <strong><em>BY COMPUTER</em></strong>, into the order your case / route is. The DPS feed is only about 99.9% accurate; you still get mailpieces that aren’t for your route and need to be sent to the correct carrier. (Obviously, 999 accurate pieces out of 1000 is quite good, but when you’re delivering some 5,000 mailpieces a day, missorts are a very regular occurrence.) But you don’t have to case this, since it is (supposed to be) already organized for you, and some carriers just toss it into their truck and call it a day.</li><li>There might be Mass Marketing Mail — the formal USPS name for “spam” — that you have to deliver. Because it’s going to every single mailbox no matter what, you don’t have to case <em>this</em> either; just peel one off at every stop.</li><li>Finally, you’ll get some unsorted mail, not only assorted letters but periodicals, which <em>do</em> get Delivery-Point Sorted by the publisher but still come in newsstand-style bundles which you need to break open. “Okay, Mr. John Smith on 12345 Main St is getting this week’s issue of <em>People Magazine</em>. (RIP Matthew Perry.) So is Mrs. Maria Wang at, uhh, 34567 Main St, so I gotta skip several slots down to file this.” This is the only stuff you absolutely have to case.</li></ul><p>Still, computers are already helping us with this process, and there’s no reason — technological, physical or metaphysical — why they can’t take over it entirely.</p><p>The second step is when you “pull down” your mail. Again, the case is already in order, so all you have to do is preserve that order when you’re loading your truck. And finally, step three, you hit the street. When you arrive at your first delivery point, you should find that, if you cased and pulled down correctly, everything you need — unsorted, MMM, DPS, whether integrated together or in three separate streams — is just sitting next to your left hand, ready to deliver. This is the main reason I cased <em>everything</em>. Roll the the periodicals or MMM into taco shapes and put them in first, before casing anything else; put the DPS and other unsorted <em>into</em> the tacos; pull down the tacos in order. It’s not just that delivering a taco is easy, it’s that you have tactile information in your fingertips, from the feel of what you pick up, about whether you gathered the whole taco or not. The whole thing is a breeze, and you barely need to think about it.</p><p>Except for the packages.</p><p>The biggest problem I personally had, sitting in the driver’s seat of that <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grumman_LLV">Long-Life Vehicle</a>, dispensing mail tacos from a truck with no air conditioning, no dock for my phone or its GPS, and not even dashboard arrows for the turn signals, just LEDs, was the packages. You can’t case your packages, <em>and</em> there isn’t a coordinate system built into your pulled-down mail to remind you when you deliver a package. You could <em>make</em> one, but you’ve got like a <em>hundred</em> packages, and the delivery spots are going to change from day to day. The only way to make sure you deliver them all is to <em>remember your route</em>. All 500 mailboxes of it. I was taught several different methods for organizing packages, and was finally getting to the point of mastering one of them, when I moved on to another, less-fun but higher-paying, job. This kind of organization is exactly what computers are good for; and, as I understand it, the<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oshkosh_NGDV"> Next-Generation Delivery Vehicle</a> actually has a digital display that would help me keep track of where packages need to be delivered.</p><p>So building a truck that drives by computer is within our grasp; and sorting the mail by computer is already being done to a large extent. What about delivering it?</p><p>That’s where things break down. Because, sure, you can program a mail truck to drive up to a specific spot and put the mail in it… But can you program it to <em>find </em>that specific spot? Especially with every homeowner on the planet wanting to make a statement by giving their mailbox a unique design, size, placement? Can we find a mailbox that an automated truck would have trouble delivering to? Sure: <em>mine</em>. My mailbox, at my house, isn’t even on the streetside: it’s facing our driveway! <em>On the left side</em>, where the mailperson can’t reach it from their right-hand drive LLV and NGDV. The box is intended for delivery on foot. (To be sure, on-foot delivery is part of the difference between a City Carrier and a Rural Carrier, whose mailboxes are typically far apart. In six years of living in this house I have never <em>once</em> seen our carrier in their LLV.) I have barely gone out my front door and I’ve already ruined this idea of having a nation which can get its mail through an autonomous, self-driving truck: now it also needs an autonomous <em>robot</em> that can debark and walk up my driveway. Our budget just took a <em>massive</em> hit.</p><p>Now, to be sure, there’s a really simple solution to my problem: <em>move my mailbox</em>. And if a carrier came to me and asked me to do so, I would do it, and happily. But I know people, and I’m sure you, Dearest Gentle Reader, also know people, who would absolutely refuse. It would have to be a national mandate, and the law would be fought by <em>plenty</em> of NIMBYs. Yeah, AI is not only limited, it’s got people pushing back against it.</p><p>But it’s also got people pushing <em>for</em> it: the tech bros, the billionaires, the 1%, the ones sucking up to Trump. And none of that is a coincidence.</p><p>As mentioned, there are two things that determine whether a person has rights. One is the country’s political system; the other is its economy. At the moment, America’s politics and America’s economy are at odds; one is pushing the idea that <em>all</em> are created equal, whereas the other wants to claim that only some people, only the people who can provide valuable labor, should get rights. At the moment, the economy is winning. And AI is going to end the fight one way or another.</p><p>AI is not a problem; it’s a solution. It’s an answer to a question, and it’s been claimed to be the trillion-dollar answer. But what question is it answering? That question is, in short, <em>employment</em>. AI is the solution to the question of labor — of getting labor from human beings, and more importantly of <em>paying</em> those pesky human beings for that labor instead of keeping all the profits for oneself. AI solves the problem of capitalism needing labor. AI solves the problem of rich people needing to pay poor people.</p><p>And, as such, AI is the tool which oligarchs will use to turn capitalism — an economy where everyone can gain rights by selling their labor — into an old-style kyriarchy where <em>no one</em> can gain rights because the only thing they have to sell is their worthless labor. AI is the tool by which rich people plan to make the other 99% of the world into second-class citizens. AI is the tool by which rich people plan to murder America the Beautiful — all are created equal, LL&amp;PH, etc — and replace it with America the Dystopia, where 99.9% of the nation lives in squalor. AI is the tool by which oligarchs are trying to create the opening scene of <em>Terminator 2</em>, only with themselves on the side of the machines. And as such, the fact that they’re sitting at the table with Trump, who has also been very forward about his belief that only certain people deserve LL&amp;PH, is less a surprise and more an inevitability.</p><p>So now it’s time for us, as citizens of this declining democracy, to ask ourselves what we stand for. Do we stand for capitalism, and the idea that only some people deserve to live? Or do we stand for the idea that <em>everyone</em> does?</p><p>Because we can’t have both.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=19876229e0ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Quick Mathematical Debunking of the Idea that People Aren’t Choosing to Save Money]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/a-quick-mathematical-debunking-of-the-idea-that-people-arent-choosing-to-save-money-4a904a381f01?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a904a381f01</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[prosperity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Jul 2022 18:59:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-27T20:55:12.445Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is a popular talking point out in the world, and it won’t take me much effort at all to disprove it.</p><p>There is an unexamined belief amongst the older generation that poverty is self-imposed. Everyone, they believe, makes enough money to survive, and if those people are nonetheless having financial problems it’s because they <em>choose</em> to have financial problems. It’s just a matter of proper budgeting — as the McDonalds’ Corporation “proved” with their meme-worthy math.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/562/1*WWM69jC6lhJf--B138uGJw.png" /><figcaption>You know, this one.</figcaption></figure><p>Now, this budget was released in 2008. Money was a bit different then. So I think a better idea is to re-do this budget today.</p><h4>What’s our income?</h4><p>According to Zippia.com, <a href="https://www.zippia.com/advice/average-american-income/">the <strong>median</strong> U.S. household income was <strong>$61,937</strong></a><strong> a year </strong>in 2021. According to census.gov, <a href="https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2021/demo/p60-273.html">it was <strong>$67,521</strong> in 2020</a>. Since a household implies two incomes, let’s average the two together and call median income <strong>$32,364 per person per annum</strong>, about $16 an hour. That’s a darn sight better than the $24,720 (from two jobs!) McDonalds’ is ascribing to people. (And while you can argue that this is the first of me fudging numbers and lowering the accuracy of our thought experiment, it should be pointed out that I’m fudging the numbers <em>against my own argument</em>. Median household income is going <em>down</em>. For me to fudge it upwards results in an overly optimistic bias.)</p><h4>What’s our rent?</h4><p>According to a cnn.com report, itself quoting realtor.com, <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2022/05/19/homes/us-rents-april/index.html">median rent is <strong>$21,924 per year</strong> as of May 19, 2022</a>. I’m having trouble finding any data about rent by bedroom, so here is where the figure starts breaking down —and it won’t be the first time, obviously — but the whole point of this exercise is that we’re assuming the median, the person who makes more than 50% of Americans and less than the other 50%, the person in the exact middle, regardless of how factually likely this person is.</p><p>“C, these are median figures,” you might say, “and as you admit, you aren’t adjusting based on the reality of needs. A single person needs a one-bedroom apartment; does this figure of $21,924 serve to get them such a thing? Or are they paying for more?” The answer is, I might be <em>lowballing</em>: according to Redfin, <a href="https://www.redfin.com/news/redfin-rental-report-may-2022/">median rent breached $2,000 a month in May 2022</a>. Meanwhile, worldpopulationreview.com claims <a href="https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/average-rent-by-state">the average is $1,326 a month, or $15,912 a year</a>.</p><p>If we average those amounts, our hypothetical person is now paying <strong>$20,612 a year</strong>, and we’re going to use this as our figure. Which, I mean, we’re doing fine. After all, it’s only 64% of our pre-tax income.</p><h4>How much are we spending on food?</h4><p>This is one of the reasons the McDonalds’ budget was made fun of when it came out: the person who is living by it doesn’t eat. Since human beings, factually speaking, <em>do</em> eat, let’s factor this into our more accurate budget.</p><p>No one has done any studies on the median food budget in America. According to usda.gov, the average household spent about <a href="https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistics-charting-the-essentials/food-prices-and-spending/">$6,500 on food every year</a> (see the second-to-last chart) in 2020. While averages and medians are derived differently, the USDA chart shows food by quintiles (bottom 20%, next 20%, etc), so <strong>$6,500 will serve as a median</strong>.</p><h4>Information infrastructure (cable, internet, etc)?</h4><p>cnbc.com claim to be quoting a JD Power survey, but I can’t find the link to that. But supposedly, the average American <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/15/how-to-save-money-on-your-phone-bill.html">paid $1,528 a year for their cellphone plan</a> in 2020. This is where figures break down further, since averages and medians are derived differently — in a world where certain people at the top can pay a great deal, they can singlehandedly tilt the average upward. For instance, in America, the Social Security Administration has <a href="https://www.ssa.gov/oact/cola/central.html">determined</a> that while the median income in 2020 was $34,612, the average was $53,383. The median is only 65% of the average.</p><p>If we assume that the same ratio applies to mobile phone plans, that’s <strong>$993.49 a year</strong>.</p><p>If this seems like an astronomical amount of money, keep in mind that this bill, and this device, are standing in for a <em>huge</em> swath of other expenditures. We are pretending we live in the developing world: our cell phone is our <em>only</em> computer and serves all our entertainment and computing needs. We don’t own a TV, we don’t own a console, we don’t own a desktop computer or a laptop or even a tablet. (Let’s ballpark and assume that a person spends $100 a year on each of those things spread out over the duration of their use.) This does leave us in the frustrating place of having to update our resume on Google Drive using our phone keyboard, but hey, we’re being frugal. We don’t have cable (saved <a href="https://money.usnews.com/money/personal-finance/saving-and-budgeting/articles/how-much-is-cable-per-month">$304.80</a> there) or Netflix (<a href="https://help.netflix.com/en/node/24926">$119.88</a>) or Hulu (<a href="https://help.hulu.com/s/article/how-much-does-hulu-cost">$69.99</a>). We aren’t buying anything in the App Store. We <em>certainly</em> don’t have an internet plan for our apartment (<a href="https://www.allconnect.com/blog/cost-of-high-speed-internet">$350</a>). Everything we watch, play, read and write is on our cell phone, and doing this allowed us to cut out a <em>lot</em> of expenses.</p><h4>Gasoline?</h4><p>I mean, we’ve got a job, and presumably we have to go to it. Most of us will use a car; some jobs won’t hire us if we don’t have a car. So how much does it cost to fuel it up?</p><p>Per the Bureau of Labor and Statistics, <a href="https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cesan.nr0.htm">$1,568 in 2020</a>, when fuel prices (per eia.gov, the Energy Information Administration) averaged <a href="https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=pet&amp;s=emm_epm0_pte_nus_dpg&amp;f=a">$2.69 per gallon</a>. As of July 22 2022, the same administration claims the average price is <a href="https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/gasdiesel/">$4.77</a>. (This link is continually updated. Leave me a comment if I need to replace it some time in the future.) Today that’s <strong>$2,780.</strong></p><h4>So, where are we budget-wise?</h4><p>The answer is, we’re in a bad state.</p><ul><li>$32,364 in income a year minus…</li><li>$20,602 in rent…</li><li>$6,500 in food…</li><li>$2,780 in gasoline, and…</li><li>$993.49 for our cell phone budget, leaves us…</li></ul><p><strong>$1,488.51 left over.</strong></p><p>With which we need to buy a lot of things:</p><ul><li>What if our cell phone breaks? According to Android Authority, we’ll pay <a href="https://www.androidauthority.com/smartphone-price-1175943/">$705.85 on average</a> for a new one.</li><li>What if our car needs service? Per creditkarma.com, quoting (but not linking to) a AAA survey, we’re talking <a href="https://www.creditkarma.com/auto/i/what-it-costs-own-car">$1,186 per year</a>. Or we could just run the car until it dies and then buy something new — or, at least, new to us; we can’t afford the <a href="https://www.creditkarma.com/auto/i/what-is-average-car-payment">$7,728 in annual car payments for a new car, so we’ll do the $5,856/year for a used one</a>. It’s probably better to service the car.)</li><li>Insurance? Creditkarma claims, “The average car insurance premium in the U.S. was $1,062 annually, or $88.50 per month, in 2016.” The Kaiser Family Foundation claims that the average cost of health insurance is “<a href="https://www.kff.org/report-section/ehbs-2021-section-1-cost-of-health-insurance/">$7,739 per person.</a>” I’m not going through the bother of adjusting these for average vs median, because you can already see they’re going to have absurd impacts on what remains of our budget. Hopefully we’re not at one of those places that requires renter’s insurance (<a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/personal-finance/average-cost-renters-insurance">$174/yr</a>).</li><li>We aren’t buying any new clothes (<a href="https://www.creditdonkey.com/average-cost-clothing-per-month.html">$1,800 a year</a>). We aren’t buying any new furniture. We aren’t buying any new dishes or cookware. We haven’t spent a penny on Amazon. We don’t go to the movies. We don’t go out to eat. We don’t go on dates. We aren’t buying anyone birthday presents; heck, we aren’t <em>going</em> to birthday parties if they’re at restaurants, because we can’t afford the check. We <em>don’t turn on the lights in our apartment</em> because we need to reduce our electric bill lower than the average of <a href="https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=46276">$1,380/year</a>.</li><li>No pets. Can’t afford it: just feeding the thing could cost <a href="https://pets.costhelper.com/dog-food.html">$1,200 a year in kibble</a>.</li><li>We are <em>incredibly</em> lucky in that our parents paid for our college; we are not paying the <a href="https://thecollegeinvestor.com/33643/average-student-loan-monthly-payment/">$2,664 a year</a> in median student loans.</li><li>Our commute isn’t too terrible. Mine used to involve crossing a bridge every day. For two years I paid $7 in tolls a day: $1,750 a year.</li><li>Babies? At, according to <a href="https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2017/01/13/cost-raising-child">the USDA</a>, $12,980 a year? LOL.</li><li>And God forbid someone expect us to pay taxes.</li></ul><p>So, why aren’t people choosing to save money?</p><p><strong>BECAUSE THERE’S NONE TO SAVE</strong>. How am I supposed to put $2,000 into my 401K every year when I only have $1,500 to spare? <em>If</em> I have $1,500 to spare. If someone isn’t looking at the road for half a second and rear-ends my car, there goes everything.</p><p>This is the financial reality we live in now. It’s really that simple.</p><p>Or, let’s do it another way. Let’s assume we’re living this exact same frugal lifestyle — no cable, no television, just an apartment and two commutes and a kid. How much do we need?</p><ul><li>$20,602 in rent plus…</li><li>$6,500 in food plus…</li><li>$2,780 in gasoline <em>per person</em> — so, actually, $5,560 — plus…</li><li>$993.49 for our cell phone budget — per person, so actually $1,986.98 — plus…</li><li>Health insurance for your whole family, which in 2020 was <a href="https://www.ehealthinsurance.com/resources/individual-and-family/how-much-does-a-family-health-insurance-plan-cost">$13,824 per year</a>, plus…</li><li>$1,800 for clothing (which we might have been able to skip if we didn’t have a kid, but my youngest just turned 1, and we went through <em>three</em> sizes of clothes during that year) plus…</li><li>$12,980 for the cost of raising a child?</li></ul><p><strong>$63,252.49</strong>. After taxes. If we include taxes, we… God, I don’t know. I mean, that depends on where you live and what your state’s tax laws are. But let’s just ballpark it at $85,000 a year, between two incomes.</p><p>If you were living in an apartment with only second-hand furniture and kitchenware, no TV, no pets, no internet, and no lights, feeding your baby from a bottle by the meager glow of your phone’s flashlight, would you feel rich?</p><p>Because, to repeat: we’re calling median household income $64,728. Empirically, you’re in the top 50% of households in America. (I have no idea to find out the percentage more accurately, but I’m guessing you’re in more like the top <em>40%</em> of earnings.) <strong>Empirically, <em>you are rich</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>This is American prosperity today.</p><p>And that’s why some of us laugh when we’re told about it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a904a381f01" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lie of the Red Pill]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/the-lie-of-the-red-pill-20943c47e807?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/20943c47e807</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[the-matrix]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[misogyny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[red-pill]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Apr 2022 22:41:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-27T21:02:04.452Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>They’re actually blue all the way down.</p><p>You may see this term in online discourse these days: “red pill.” It’s from <em>The Matrix</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CAGfrltf5sCIHx7IA7MhaQ.png" /><figcaption>Warner Bros, 1999. Used without permission.</figcaption></figure><p>We all remember this shot, partially because it’s so iconic. (Fun fact: Laurence Fishburne’s glasses were covered with green screen, and the reflections added digitally.) It embodies the entire idea in one elegant image: Neo (the white guy in the reflection, played by Keanu Reeves) having to choose between a safe, pablum, brainwashed existence in one hand, and unsafe, uncertain awareness in the other. It’s not just an act of courage, it’s an act of <em>rebellion</em> — of throwing off the shackles imposed by society and seeing a hidden truth.</p><blockquote>You take the blue pill? The story ends; you wake up in your bed and believe whatever you want to believe. [But if] You take the <em>red</em> pill … you stay in Wonderland, and I show you how deep the rabbit hole goes.</blockquote><p>Neo, having been awakened to the nature of the oppressive system that imprisons him, then aids in fighting that oppressive system. It should be pointed out that he is awakened to that nature by a black man and a white woman, both of whom have prior experience with oppressive systems. There’s also some fun subtext concerning <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadnaming">deadnaming</a>: Neo chooses to think of himself as, well, Neo, but the oppressive system — personified most specifically in Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving) — insists on using his birth name, “Thomas Anderson,” as a way of denying him his right to self-determination. (Note that this was written <em>years </em>before Lana and Lilly Wachowski came out as trans women, though there’s evidence they were in the closet at the time: one of Neo’s shipmates, “Switch,” was originally intended to be a woman in the Matrix and a man in the real world.) And then there are two more movies, which weren’t as well received; and plus that fourth one got released during the pandemic. But I digress.</p><p>The reason I bring it up is because this striking visual image— specifically, taking the red pill and waking up to some greater truth about the world — has been co-opted by the “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manosphere">manosphere</a>,” the loose organization of misogynists on the internet: Men’s Rights Activists, incels, pickup artists, Men Going Their Own Way, and so on. While each group may have their own ideologies, they all share something in common: a belief that modern society is fundamentally misandrist. The person who has arrived at this belief is said to have “taken the red pill.”</p><p>In a way, it’s just posturing, a way to give legitimacy to their misogyny. “I wasn’t born a misogynist, I <em>became</em> a misogynist as part of my journey of self-growth. It’s proof that I’m a free-thinking rebel. The fact that I hate women should be treated as the crowning intellectual achievement of my life to date.” Which, I mean, good for you, I suppose.</p><p>It’s also 100% backwards.</p><p>The idea that society is misandrist — biased against men; “andros” is the Greek word for “man” just like the “gyne” from “misogyny” is the Greek word for “wife” — is something you could conceivably arrive at if you looked at the past century of social history and ignored about 10,000 years before it. Feminism has been working tirelessly, for millennia, to counter-balance patriarchy and its inherent bias against women, and has made tremendous strides in the last 100 years. Again, if you take only those 100 years <em>in a vacuum</em>, and see all those pro-female laws being passed, then it does absolutely look like society is biased towards women. Again, this only makes sense if you <em>only</em> take those 100 years of affirmative action out of context, and ignore the thousands of years of oppression that precede it. (How much oppression? Well, in Greek, “gyne” means “wife.” It <em>also, </em>as implied by the field of gynecology, means “uterus.” “I’m Roger Sterling. Have you met my new womb? Her name’s Jane.” <em>That</em> much oppression.)</p><p>Now. Let’s assume, at least for the moment, that these misogynists are right. Let’s assume that the past century of social progress has been unfair, that laws have gone past the point of “Let’s make women equal” and overshot into the area of “Let’s make women superior.” If you oppose this kind of thing, what does that make you?</p><p>It makes you the same kind of man who existed for thousands of years <em>prior</em> to this century. It makes you a misogynist. It makes you… <strong>absolutely nothing new</strong>.</p><p>And that’s why it’s interesting to me that these misogynists claim that their awakening to the “appropriateness” of misogyny describe themselves as “Taking the red pill.” It’s a masterful work of propaganda. Because, to re-iterate, these men have learned <em>nothing</em>. The whole point of patriarchy is — I’m going to oversimplify grossly, but only by leaving out a lot of detail — to encourage men to disrespect women. The whole point of patriarchy is to brainwash men into being misogynists. And that’s why it’s interesting to me that these people use the rhetoric of “awakening to a new reality” when describing how they have regressed themselves to an old one.</p><p>A person who “wakes up” and decides to become a misogynist <em>has done no waking up whatsoever</em>. In point of fact, he has merely succumbed to brainwashing; in point of fact, he has <em>accepted</em> his brainwashing and is now actively aiding in its application. He is <em>not</em> a free-thinker, he is <em>not</em> a rebel, he is <em>not</em> courageous: he is, in truth, the exact opposite. He is not just a slave but a <em>willing </em>slave, one who rejoices in his bondage. He has taken the shackles applied by society and <em>tightened them</em>.</p><p>He’s… well, he’s taken the blue pill. He just <em>thinks</em> its red because that makes him feel better about himself. He doesn’t want to be a garden-variety misogynist, he wants to be a <em>refined</em> misogynist (you know, <a href="https://twitter.com/EllenKushner/status/1119119928773099528">from that one region of France</a>), one who can feel good about being a bad person because he’s <em>justified.</em></p><p>Has anyone written this article before? I mean, this is such low-hanging fruit; it’s patently obvious, to anyone who has even the slightest knowledge of history. Someone must have written it already. But I’ve never seen it, and if it <em>hasn’t</em> been spelled out, then it needs to be:</p><p><strong><em>Claiming you’ve taken the red pill is proof you’ve done no such thing.</em></strong> The only person a “red pill” is fooling is themselves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=20943c47e807" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Harry Potter and the Unrealistic Expectations]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/harry-potter-and-the-unrealistic-expectations-6fda90a439f3?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6fda90a439f3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dating]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[failure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[domination]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Mar 2021 17:25:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-04T00:14:07.273Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Because for all his great work in the antifa space, he’s also doing his best to fan the flames of male entitlement.</p><p>One of the hardest things a man has to face, in the dating world, is rejection. It’s also one of the most common things. Dating is 99.8% rejection. I spent time on OKCupid, where sending out feelers was relatively easy, but at a rough estimate I emailed about <em>one thousand</em> women over the course of 10 years, of which about 200 women — one in five — replied to any extent whatsoever. (According to a now-deleted OKTrends blog post, that made me <em>twice</em> as charming as the average male suitor on the site.) I spent time on those messages: each one was hand-crafted, referring to specific things on the woman’s profile in an attempt to show that I was paying attention. There were no spelling errors; they used proper grammar and punctuation. I would spend up to half an hour on each e-mail and could confidently expect that 80% of that effort would simply go to waste, would disappear into an inbox and be disregarded. And, to repeat, I was <em>twice as effective</em> as the average suitor, who could expect that silence 10% more frequently.</p><p>It should also be pointed out that the numbers would continue to dwindle. How many women would progress to the point of actually going on a date with me? Since I used the site for a decade, it’s difficult for me to pin it down, but I’d guess at 50. How many of <em>them</em> would go on a second date? My guess would be 20. How many of them actually got to the point where they would agree to be my girlfriend? Two. (How many of them married me? Zero. I met Mara via a completely different app — after she saw me on OKC and pre-emptively downvoted me for reasons of her own.)</p><p>So when I say that dating is 99.8% rejection, I’m being quite literal. 1,000 attempts; two girlfriends. The vast majority of dating ends in failure.</p><p>And so it’s curious to me that modern society <em>does not even talk about rejection</em>.</p><p>If we want to talk about romance in mass media, what is the story? Obviously, there are a lot of different media to do it in: books, music, movies, theatre, television, even video games. There are a lot of different tones you can take, from the ecstatic optimism of (say) <em>Boy Meets World</em> to the fumbling embarrassment of Lena Dunham’s <em>Girls</em>, from the drama-filled chaos of <em>Grey’s Anatomy</em> to the pointed, almost snide deconstruction of <em>Romeo and Juliet</em>, from the typical happy endings (<em>Pride and Prejudice</em>, basically any Disney movie with a romance subplot) to the tragic denouements of <em>Titanic</em>, <em>Brokeback Mountain</em>, <em>Final Fantasy X</em>. You can do it a hundred different ways… but almost all of them (<em>Girls</em> is the exception) have one thing in common:</p><p>The characters who are going to end up together? They meet right at the beginning.</p><p>“<a href="https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FirstGirlWins">First Girl Wins</a>” is a very common trope in storytelling (so common, in fact, that I suggest you don’t click that link unless you have an entire afternoon to spare: it’s a long and engrossing document). It has fun metaphorical elements: she has a chance to “call dibs” on the male lead. It has important metatextual elements: it gives her relationship <em>with</em> the male lead the most room to grow and develop. And finally, if the love story is about how Alexis and Bryce fell in love, then obviously you start at the moment they met — the moment they began to fall in love. (The one exception, like <em>Girls</em>, is where the lead character doesn’t end up with <em>anyone</em> at the end of the story — which is considered a hideously brave and counter-cultural way to do things.)</p><p>But it also has one really simple, really worrisome flipside: it means that the protagonist never has to experience rejection.</p><p>Let’s take <em>Harry Potter</em> as an example. If you’ve been living under a rock, the titular character is a normal 11-year-old boy living with his aunt and uncle in Britain who discovers that he’s central to the IP’s mythology; there’s a Big Bad out there, an evil wizard named You-Know-Who — okay, he’s actually named Voldemort, but he’s so evil that people actually fear to speak his name — and Harry is going to be intimately involved in the fight against him. The books chronicle the next seven years, as he 1. learns he is, in fact, a wizard himself, 2. learns about magic at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, and 3. prepares to face down Voldemort. And, because he’s — despite everything — still a teenage boy, he spends some time on romance. Who does he end up with? His best friend’s little sister, Ginevra “Ginny” Weasley… the first wizarding girl his age who ever appears on page. It’s downplayed magnificently: on the day Harry meets Ginny, he’s old enough to go to Hogwarts but she won’t be until next year, so she’s written out after (in my Scholastic paperback copy) a mere five pages; and before the chapter is over, Hermione Granger sails in and makes herself at home in the narrative. The story doesn’t dwell on it, is my point. But Ginny Weasley <em>is</em> the First Girl, and the First Girl Wins.</p><p>Now, Harry and Ginny’s relationship isn’t precisely smooth sailing. First off, Harry is central to the IP’s mythology; I shan’t bother with many details, but, on October 31st, 1981, on the day he turned 15 months old, he deflected a bullet with his forehead — an act as miraculous amongst wizards as it would be for us “Muggles.” True, Harry’s forehead was magical… but the bullet was magical too: in fact, it was a spell called “the Killing Curse.” As its name might suggest, the purpose of this spell is to kill things. There is no counter-curse, there is no deflection, there is no extra life. If someone casts a Killing Curse at you, you have precisely two options: 1. dodge (a thing 15-month-olds typically do not excel at), or 2. die. Harry somehow found a third option; he is the only known survivor of the Killing Curse. Even better, that curse was cast by Voldemort, at that time an unstoppable juggernaut of carnage and terror… and after it bounced off Harry’s forehead, it went straight to <em>him</em>. Harry defeated the most evil wizard of all time. (I mean, not forever; since Harry has to face him again, it should be obvious that the deflected Killing Curse was sub-lethal as well. But it’s still much more than anyone was expecting of a 15-month-old forehead.)</p><p>And Ginny, who was 2 months old at the time, was raised on stories of this triumph, of the hero of the Wizarding World, of The Boy Who Lived. When she meets the real thing, she’s flabbergasted; Harry, despite having the emotional range of a teaspoon, can still tell she has a massive crush on him. (He never takes advantage of it.) It’s actually kind of a big deal when the fifth book rolls around and she’s gotten over him to the point where she can — for the first time in the series — speak more than one sentence to him per book. At that point she starts getting popular with the other boys at Hogwarts, and by the sixth book there’s been a reversal: now it’s <em>Harry</em> pining over her in awkward ambivalence, having no idea how to express his feelings. By the end of the book, they’ve officially gotten together, and they remain that way for the rest of the series — and, indeed, to this day, according to <em>Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.</em> (He’s now head of Wizarding Britain’s law-enforcement division; she’s a newspaper journalist covering the sports beat. They have three children, the oldest of whom graduated from Hogwarts in June of 2021.)</p><p>There’s also an interloper. For the first four books, Harry doesn’t return Ginny’s affections. (Why not? Because romance is rooted in personality, and Ginny’s too tongue-tied in his presence to <em>have</em> a personality. What would Harry be attracted <em>to</em>? The answer is, Nothing; and because Rowling is, <a href="https://www.glamour.com/story/a-complete-breakdown-of-the-jk-rowling-transgender-comments-controversy">despite her other faults</a>, a good writer, he therefore isn’t attracted.) Instead, his eye is caught by a girl a grade older than him, Cho Chang. As it happens, she’s seeing someone else… but she’s <em>very</em> kind about it. Harry is left disappointed, but not stung. Also, her boyfriend dies (long story — basically, the entire fourth book, as a matter of fact), and in the fifth they date a little bit. It doesn’t go well: she is, quite reasonably, not yet over her dead boyfriend, and Harry doesn’t have the faintest clue how to navigate her emotional distress, much less have some sort of romance <em>with</em> that emotional distress. By the time they meet again in the seventh book, Cho has gotten her issues sorted out, but Ginny has already staked her claim; and that’s how it ends.</p><p>So, to recap, Harry’s lifetime dating experience looks like this: He asks out a girl three times in his life, ever. The first time he’s given a polite No; the second time he’s given a Yes; the third time, he ends up marrying her. All three times he asks someone out, he gets a reaction. And all I’m saying is, his 0% failure rate looks <em>waaaay</em> different than the average guy’s experience of failing <em>90% of the time</em>. Not being given a polite No; not even being given an <em>impolite</em> No: being straight-up ignored.</p><p>And this wouldn’t be a problem if Harry’s 100% success rate was an exception to the rule. But it’s not: it’s the rule itself. With very few exceptions, <em>male characters do not get romantically rejected</em>. And if they do, it’s to generate drama and build tension. With very few exceptions, if a guy asks out a girl in a story, <em>he dates that girl</em>.</p><p>How many exceptions? Don’t know, but not many. I did a poll on Facebook. So far, we’ve only come up with <em>two</em> examples: Don Pedro asking out Beatrice in Shakespeare’s <em>Much Ado About Nothing</em>, and Kirk asking out Lorelai in <em>Gilmore Girls</em>. Is this every example ever committed to fiction? Obviously not. But the fact that we couldn’t think of any others — and, more importantly, generated a <em>bunch</em> of counter-examples in the process — is pretty damning.</p><p>How many counter-examples? Well, you have Tristan Dugray asking out Lorelai’s daughter Rory and being declined, but the two later kissing, which is my point: <em>he gets a shot</em>. Rory turns him down and then is told that she was <em>wrong to do so</em>. (Frankly, basically every relationship Rory has gets to come at it from that angle, except maybe Dean. For those keeping score, <em>Gilmore Girls</em> alone has already done three times as much to prove my theory as it has to disprove it.) The love triangle in <em>Twilight </em>works that way; the love triangle in <em>The Hunger Games</em> works this way. And then there are the counter-counter-examples that prove the rule. Here’s one: in the fifth book of <em>The Wheel of Time</em>, a bit character named Valan Luca is continually hitting on the prickly, aggressive Nynaeve. (The TV adaptation pronounces it “nine<em>-eve</em>.” Robert Jordan was a bit weird on his fictional names.) She has no trouble telling him off… and the audience has no trouble believing he’s going to <em>stay</em> told off, because the seeds of Nynaeve’s romance with Lan Mandragoran were planted before the first book ended. The First Boy Wins, and Luca isn’t the First Boy, and the reader <em>knows</em> it. Luca is a “Romantic False Lead” — which TVTropes used to call “The Paolo” after the <em>Friends</em> episode “The One With Mrs. Bing,” in which the eponymous Mrs. Bing — a romance novelist of some renown — compares (and hangs a lampshade on) the transitory nature of Ross’s competition:</p><blockquote>[Paolo]’s a secondary character. He’s just a, y’know, complication you eventually kill off.</blockquote><p>The implication is clear: Ross is not only the hero of his own story, he’s the hero of <em>everyone’s</em> story. And he <em>will</em> get the girl.</p><p>And that leads to an expectation amongst the young men who consume these media: “I, too, will date the girl. I may be rejected, but it’s only to generate drama and build tension. I, too, am the hero of everyone’s story. I, too, will have a 0% failure rate as opposed to a 99.8% failure rate.”</p><p>And <em>that’s</em> where we start seeing the problems.</p><p>Normally, this is where I would say, “Let’s talk about the Friend Zone,” but the thing is, I’ve already done that, and <a href="https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/the-friend-zone-explains-so-much-about-our-attitudes-towards-love-ba4ce9241834">written a whole article about it</a>. Much of that article fits in here. (Frankly, this article ought to invalidate that one. My intention is always to get to the root cause of a problem, and I believe the topic I’m discussing here is “lower” on the ladder of cause-and-effect than what I wrote about earlier.) Whatever the case, I’m going to grab the salient point to save everyone time:</p><blockquote>As far as Western dating culture is concerned, women aren’t allowed to turn men down. If a guy asks a girl out, then that girl <em>must</em> be attracted to him.</blockquote><p>And when you put that hand-in-hand with all the boys in fiction who don’t get turned down, who date <em>every</em> single woman they ever attempt to, you start having real issues.</p><p>Where, you might ask? Well, it turns we saw it happen not long before this article was published. Let’s just check out <em>Good Morning Britain</em> on 8 March 2021. The evening before, the American network CBS had aired a two-hour special: “CBS Presents Oprah with Meghan and Harry,” in which the television personality interviewed Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex, and his mixed-race American bride, the half-black Meghan Markle. Though they remained part of the British peerage, the two renounced their ties to the Royal Family in 2020 (an event immediately dubbed “Megxit”) on grounds of perceived racism against the Duchess. During the interview, Meghan spoke with some candidness on her feelings during her years within the Royal Family: she felt that she’d been tossed in the deep end without a life jacket, with her concerns largely ignored by her new in-laws, and admitted to entertaining thoughts of suicide.</p><p>The next morning, <em>Good Morning Britain</em> co-host Piers Morgan expressed disbelief in the entire thing: “I don’t believe a word she says. […] I wouldn’t believe her if she read me a weather report.” The day after, he walked back — or, at least, attempted to clarify — his comments: supposedly, his doubt centered around the alleged unwillingness of the Royal Family to address Markle’s concerns. But the damage had been done: His co-host Alex Bereford pointed out that he had been continually hostile towards the Duchess throughout most of his time on the programme… apparently stemming from an incident where she Markle turned him down for a date. “She’s entitled to cut you off if she wants to,” Bereford pointed out. “Has she said anything about you after she cut you off? I don’t think she has, but yet you continue to trash her.” Morgan’s response was to get so overwhelmed with anger that he <em>stood up and walked out of the live broadcast</em>… and, later that day, out of the programme entirely by tendering his resignation. (In total fairness, his condemnation of Markle set a new record as the most-complained-about moment in the history of British television.)</p><p>Let’s repeat: Piers Morgan, one of the (at the time) most respected media personalities in the world, was able to be goaded into <em>throwing away his career</em> by the simple mention of the fact that someone didn’t want to date him.</p><p>Or, as another analyst put it, “<a href="https://jessica.substack.com/p/hell-hath-no-fury-like-a-man-rejected">Hell Hath No Fury like a Man Rejected</a>.”</p><p>Now, I do have some small sympathy for Morgan in this situation. It’s not that he asked Ms. Markle out and she politely said no; it’s not that she <em>impolitely</em> said no; she <em>ignored him entirely</em>. To use the current parlance, she “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghosting_(behavior)">ghosted</a>” him: she simply ceased all contact with no explanation. This has become incredibly normal behavior in modern dating. It happened to me a number of times in my dating career, and it’s <em>incredibly</em> disrespectful: “I mean, yeah, sure, we went on a date, we had a fun time — it couldn’t have been <em>that</em> awful, because I didn’t run away screaming — but that doesn’t matter. Your effort and conduct and conversation have not even earned the common courtesy of a ‘No.’ You are, literally, beneath notice.” It’s more than just rejection: it’s dehumanization. And maybe this is a weird hill to die on, but I will die on it: dehumanizing people is bad.</p><p>So why is dehumanization not only an accepted but a <em>normal</em> part of dating?</p><p>Well, you could spill ink about the increasing disconnection of modern life: everyone on their phones all the time, everyone wired together but never touching. You could talk about “godless liberalism” encouraging the needs of the many over the needs of me. You could be an incel and go on about how women are fundamentally heartless: “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loyal_(Chris_Brown_song)">These hoes ain’t loyal</a>” and all that. And some of those things might even be true. But we also need to include our case in point:</p><p>Women ghost men because they know that men can’t handle rejection. They know that they will react — and, quite possibly, <em>overreact</em> — if they are forced to confront it. They know that, if she rejects him, he could get <em>so</em> angry that he’ll go on to pursue a vendetta against her, live on national television, for <em>years</em>. Rejecting a man means being on the receiving end of the Killing Curse of dating. The woman has precisely two options: 1. dodge — IE, ghost — or 2. die. And I don’t mean that figuratively, I mean that <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/26/opinion/when-misogynists-become-terrorists.html">men literally kill women who reject them</a>. With that in mind, ghosting suddenly seems a <em>lot</em> more reasonable.</p><p>And yes, there is a third option: the man himself could control his reactions and <em>not</em> get violent, just accept the rejection and move on. But the woman can’t control him, and can’t count on him being this civilized. She can’t even count on a <em>public figure, </em><strong><em>on live national television</em></strong>, to be this civilized. And if she can’t count on that, she can’t count on much at all.</p><p>We are raising generations of men who are not prepared for the realities of dating. We are raising generations of men who are not prepared to go out into the world and get rejected.</p><p>And that’s <em>directly</em> responsible for a lot of the problems we’re seeing in America these days. The entire concept of the Friend Zone: predicated on the idea that women are not allowed to reject men. The entire cult of incel: predicated on the idea that women are not allowed to reject men. The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pickup_artist">pickup artist</a> community is a bit better: it acknowledges that women <em>are</em> able to reject men, it simply attempts to circumvent it via subterfuge. (I mean, it’s a <em>bit</em> better.) And then of course there’s rape culture, which reinforces the idea that a woman is not allowed to reject a man by tacitly consenting if he refuses to accept that rejection.</p><p>And then we start contemplating the knock-on effects, the places where this refusal to accept rejection isn’t responsible but does nonetheless contribute. How about the alt-right, and their refusal to accept that the world has moved on? How about Trumpists and their sociopathic need to defeat others? — not just to be the winner, but to see others lose? How about Brexiteers and their similar need? — the need to defeat somebody, <em>anybody</em>, even themselves, because succeeding at beating yourself up is something that counts as winning, if you’re desperate. How about <a href="https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/the-wrong-answer-f86beb0ed1c4">murder culture</a>? — the belief that violence is an acceptable way to solve our problems? <em>All</em> of these things are influenced and reinforced by the fact that men are unable to accept defeat with grace.</p><p>Obviously, we all want to be winners. But we’ve taken that aspiration and turned it into an environment where people aren’t taught how to lose. We’ve refused to teach people how to lose despite the fact that the average human does <em>way</em> more losing than winning. And the result is violence, pain and death.</p><p>How do we change this?</p><p>Well, we could start by telling stories about people who don’t let defeat stop them. We could start by normalizing defeat. We could start by redefining “masculinity” to not be dependent on whether he wins or not. We could start by not lying to ourselves that life is going to be, or should be, easy.</p><p>But who wants to do <em>that</em> — not when we could read about an escapist character who is has everything: The Boy Who Lived, The Chosen One, a brilliant sports star and a success with girls.</p><p>If only we could all be like that…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6fda90a439f3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Two Things about Racism Most Americans Don’t Understand]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/the-two-things-about-racism-most-americans-dont-understand-f8e0e461385e?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8e0e461385e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prejudice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Oct 2020 18:01:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-30T18:01:33.875Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s only two — so far as I can tell from this particular vantage point in my life. But they explain everything.</p><h3>1. “Racism” is not identical to “prejudice.”</h3><p>I talked about this in another article already, but I’m just going to review it because it bears repeating: “Racism” is not identical to “prejudice.”</p><p>If you’re at a <a href="https://www.togos.com/">Togo’s Sandwiches</a> in California and you see a person of Chinese descent there and you give him a dirty look because of COVID-19, that’s prejudice. You don’t know anything about him; you haven’t heard him speak, you don’t know if he has an accent. You <em>certainly</em> don’t know if he’s been to China recently. (In point of fact, the last time he was there, it was 1997 and he hadn’t even started high school. Not that this example comes from real life or anything.) But you see his skin color and his eye shape and you <em>assume, </em>merely because of those features, that he must be the architect of all your pain. That’s prejudice.</p><p>That is <em>not</em> racism.</p><p>Racism is when you call the cops on him because you know they’ll shoot first and ask questions later. (Thankfully, we are now out of the realm of “real life example.”) Racism is when you exploit the fact that some forms of prejudice are <em>written into law</em>: the War on Drugs, stop-and-frisk, even the fact that schools draw their funds from the district’s income taxes — meaning that the poor are deprived of education, their best and most powerful weapon for escaping poverty.</p><p>Prejudice is a personal action. Racism is a legal structure. They are not identical.</p><p>This is why white people can’t complain about the system being racist. It isn’t: it’s not rigged <em>against</em> them. (Well, except for affirmative action. But when you consider how much the system is rigged against BIPOC, it seems only fair to rig it in favor of them at least once. The wise understand that Affirmative Action is a necessary evil; the ignorant claim it unnecessary.) Now, if you were a white person in China, where — I assume, if for no other reason than the fact that humans tend to be corrupt, and Chinese people are in fact human— there is institutionalized prejudice against <em>guilao</em>, you could most certainly be the victim of racism. But you can’t in America, because American laws do not, by and large, victimize white people.</p><p>Racism is not identical to prejudice.</p><h3>2. It is possible to be racist without being prejudiced.</h3><p>The truth is that America is coming along. Prejudice is becoming more and more unfavorable, and (Trump’s renaissance notwithstanding) more and more Americans are realizing that judging other people without having the whole story is bad. “I should not judge people by the color of their skin,” people are saying everywhere, and it’s definitely progress.</p><p>The problem is that a lot of people think that judging others by skin color is the only possible evil they can do, and it’s not.</p><p>How many times have you griped about how blacks tend to be less educated, more prone to trouble? These are, unfortunately, facts: crime rate, drug abuse, physical and emotional abuse, sexual abuse: all these things correlate with lower education, something which — as we’ve already covered — black people are disproportionately unable to access. But if you judge them for it, you’re being racist, because you’re ignoring how the system <em>forces</em> African-Americans into poverty. Acknowledging that the victims of a broken system are victims does not make you a bad person… but it doesn’t make you a good one either.</p><p>And then there’s the question of dismantling it. It’s, unquestionably, a huge task, daunting to contemplate, but it’s not your place to turn away. It’s something we need to do — and, more importantly, it’s something <em>we</em> need to do, to atone for the sins of our fathers, the ones who set up the broken system in the first place. (I mean, it’s not like <em>they’re</em> going to rise from the grave to do it.)</p><p>And yet we keep having people — of all races and colors — who don’t seem to want to do that. Because they <em>know</em> the broken system benefits them… and they don’t want to give up those benefits. They would never treat someone poorly because of the color of that person’s skin, but they’re okay if <em>someone else</em> treats them poorly.</p><p>Which is why I say it’s possible to be racist without being prejudiced. And why people have to <em>stop</em> being racist without being prejudiced.</p><p>It also explains some other things going around the interwebs these days.</p><ul><li>#ACAB: “All Cops Are Bastards.” On the surface, this seems, well, prejudicial; and, on the surface, it is. I may be going out on a limb somewhat when I say this, but I do believe it and I stand by this belief: <em>There are good apples in our law-enforcement agencies.</em> “Not all cops,” to co-opt the slogan. This being said, the distinction I made above — being racist without being prejudiced; refusing to engage in a corrupt power structure but also refusing to dismantle it — applies here too. If you are a cop and you see a fellow cop abuse their power, and <em>you don’t say anything</em>, are you guilty of a crime? Yes. Are you <em>as</em> guilty as that other cop? No, absolutely not; but you are still a non-zero quantity of guilty. You are still a non-zero quantity of bastard. All cops <em>must be</em> bastards because that’s the only way corruption could have penetrated America’s police departments as thoroughly as it has. Even if you aren’t prejudicial, even if you aren’t a bad cop, you are still a bastard. And that’s something every law-enforcement officer in the nation will have to face in the mirror some day.</li><li>#NotAllMen.<strong> </strong>Well… Similarly to the above: yes, all men. Unless you <em>are</em> speaking out about; unless you <em>are</em> fighting the systemic corruption introduced by rape culture. Some do. Not enough do. And until the work is done, I — as a man — will continue to say, with a mixture of both defiance and sadness, “Yes, All Men.”</li><li>And finally, a truly insidious thought: Are all Americans racist? Every single one of us? Regardless of their personal actions, regardless of their personal prejudices? You can guess what my answer is.</li></ul><p>Because that’s the thing. Edmund Burke didn’t say this — it’s a bastardized John Stuart Mill quote — but it’s still true: “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” And if you are a good person, doing neither good nor evil, doing nothing… then you aren’t helping. It’s why everyone is saying it’s not enough to be non-racist, you have to be <em>anti-</em>racist: because that’s when you stop doing nothing.</p><p>And besides, John Stuart Mill was wrong: a person who neither helps nor hinders <em>is not actually a good person</em>. Remember, the Good Samaritan didn’t just keep walking.</p><p>So, with all this in mind, what are you going to be? What choices do you plan to make? Because you can be the good person who does something… or the bad person who does nothing.</p><p>Only you can choose.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8e0e461385e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How a Meme Shed Light on One of America’s Biggest Problems]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/how-a-meme-shed-light-on-one-of-americas-biggest-problems-b7082155fedb?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7082155fedb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[traditional-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[violence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Oct 2020 17:55:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-04T19:50:13.478Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m sure we’ve all seen the <a href="https://youtu.be/SH329MmRikQ"><em>Daily Show</em> interview</a> where a man is asked his stance on abortion:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*E_RKSwfXB_qKVwm2-vK-ew.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image owned by The Daily Show, 11 October 2020. Used without permission.</figcaption></figure><p>And I’m here to tell you that this man is <em>not</em> a hypocrite in the slightest.</p><p>On the surface, my assertion seems impossible. If we care about protecting lives, why don’t we care about protecting lives from the coronavirus? And if we don’t care about protecting lives from the coronavirus, how can we claim that we care about protecting lives? On the surface, the two seem to contradict each other.</p><p>Here is where we drag in an old axiom from the field of psychology: “Correlation does not imply causation.” Sometimes this is quite obvious: if I step out my front door, and immediately get a text that my grandma has passed away, I don’t spend the rest of my life scared of going out the front door. The two events are correlated — they happened at the same time — but it is obvious that my front door did not instantaneously affect events in a state halfway across the country… And, furthermore, that my grandmother’s passing did not somehow psychically compel me to go on a walk.</p><p>The problem is when the events seem to be related. For instance, it is known that if you, as a child, had a night light in your room, you are more likely to need glasses in the future. So which causes which? It seems unlikely that night lights themselves could damage your eyes, since they are exposed to much higher amounts of light during the day; additionally, there are no physiological differences between daytime eyes and nighttime eyes which would cause the latter to be more vulnerable to smaller amounts of light. Is it possible that your adult glasses damaged your childhood eyes? Yes… In a world where time travel is possible. In <em>our</em> world, it is obvious that something that happens in 10 years has not had affected — okay, this is what TVTropes calls “Time Travel Tense Trouble.” But the point is, causality does not move backwards chronologically. (And while there are points to be made about the young children already having poor vision, it should be pointed out that this correlation affects children who, during their youth, had 20/20 vision.) One causation is physically impossible; the other causation is… physically impossible. How then could one cause another?</p><p>The answer is that they don’t. The answer is that A does not cause B and B does not cause A… And <em>C</em> causes both. The thing in common with both adulthood glasses and childhood night lights is your parents’ vision. <em>They</em> needed the night light, not you; and bad eyesight is known to be hereditary. Therefore, both the night light <em>and</em> your adult spectacles are different symptoms of a single underlying problem.</p><p>The lesson there is to understand that sometimes we have to think outside the box. Every problem can be solved if we understand what causes it… But “what causes it” is not necessarily obvious or even included in the presentation of the problem itself. In fact, it’s why I started writing. Modern politics spends too much time getting hung up on symptoms instead of identifying root diseases; I’m doing the best I can — with my, what, 40 hits a week — to correct that. But I digress.</p><p>Our maskless conservative presents a similar quandary. His two standpoints seem mutually contradictory if you look at the two of them in isolation. But when we bring in element C, it all makes sense.</p><p>Because element C is gender essentialism.</p><p>To oversimplify, America is a warrior culture. More accurately, America is a murder culture — the mutated descendent of a kyriarchy that enshrines violence. Murder culture is what you get when you move past the idea that violence is the <em>only</em> road to upward mobility, but do not move past the idea that violence is <em>a</em> road to upward mobility. In America, “just shoot the fucker” is not expected to be the only solution… but it is expected to be an <em>available</em> solution. And it is <em>never</em> considered to be an <em>inappropriate</em> solution.</p><p>(I mean, seriously: remember how surprised you were when people reminded you that police officers <em>aren’t actually supposed to kill criminals</em>. Which, again, underscores my point. “But if a peace officer kills a criminal, isn’t that a success of the system?” No, it’s a <em>failure</em> of the system. Especially when we know — from first-hand experience — that police officers are capable of talking down men wielding guns. At least, when they’re white.)</p><p>Now, in case you didn’t know what gender essentialism is, it’s the belief that the sexes each have intrinsic and immutable qualities — and not just the basic physiological ones of women being able to get pregnant and men being able to pee standing up. No, gender essentialism posits that there are intrinsic and immutable <em>personality traits</em> associated with each gender. When you put it this way, it’s pretty obvious where we’re going: men are from Mars, women are from Venus; men hunt and kill, women gather and nurture; so on and so forth.</p><p>Finally, we draw in one of the key elements of patriarchy. — well, “key elements” may be an overstatement, as in fact patriarchy consists of only two tenets. The first is that men are inherently better than women. The second is that gender essentialism is so true, that men and women are <em>so</em> opposite, that the essentials cannot mix. Those things which a woman are, men should not and cannot be. This is why conservatives oppose feminism: it encourages the mixing of oil and water.</p><p>And remember: women gather and nurture.</p><p>And then we get back to the idea that men and women are polar opposites, because that defines both of their roles. Women create life, right? Then, obviously, the role of a man — the role of a woman’s polar opposite — is, and must be, to end life.</p><p>In the context of this framework, our outspoken conservative no longer seems logically inconsistent. Instead, we see that he is positioning himself as a guardian of the old order — as, well, a conservative. Since a woman’s job is to have babies, it is his duty to make sure that women do that, by outlawing abortion. And since a man’s job is to kill, it’s his duty to remain ready to do so by any means necessary — including, if necessary, biological warfare. If you go by these traditional models, asking a man to <em>not</em> spread COVID is asking him to surrender his very identity <em>as</em> a man.</p><p>I said when I started out that this viewpoint is logically consistent. I stand by that statement. There is no logical conflict between the ideas that American men should be able to kill each other and that American women should not.</p><p>This does not mean, and should not be taken to mean, that I condone the idea that men and women must have polar and separate roles. I am not a gender essentialist, and anyone who is one, or ever has been one, has been ignoring fact the entire time. If you have met any number of real, actual people, you know that every man is not identical, that every woman is not identical, and that people like to do what they do. Some men are better parents than some women. Some women are better soldiers than some men. <em>This is how human beings have always been</em>, and trying to change it is a waste of time.</p><p>More importantly, this does not mean, and should not be taken to mean, that I <em>condone</em> the tenet of American men being allowed to kill each other. One of America’s biggest problems is its love affair with violence; one of its biggest problems is its insistence on, still, today, defining men by their capacity for violence. One of America’s biggest problems is its insistence that “just shoot the fucker” is and should be an appropriate solution.</p><p>It’s what we need to fix if we want to move forward.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7082155fedb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Quick Historic Debunking of the “Heritage, Not Hate” Defense]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/a-quick-historic-debunking-of-the-heritage-not-hate-defense-d753fec1d7ab?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d753fec1d7ab</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Oct 2020 16:36:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-27T21:04:44.066Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Because it’s about as specious as claiming that a crucifix doesn’t represent Christianity.</p><p>For those unaware: Once upon a time, a country called the “United States of America” was founded. This was in the 1700s, during a time when slavery was legal, and, like many other nations, America practiced slavery, importing and subduing large numbers of Africans.</p><p>The “Founding Fathers,” a group of philosopher-statesmen who put together the nation’s constitution, were aware that slavery constituted an ethical quandary. On the one hand, human rights violations are bad; but on the other, the profit margins made possible <em>by</em> said human rights violations were, well, very enticing. Various compromises were attempted, but in the end, the nation divided along this issue: people in the northern half of the country tended to fall on the “human rights” side, whereas people in the South, where slavery increased profit margins by the largest quantity, voted with their pocketbooks. It got to the point where the South <em>seceded from</em> (a fancy political word for “quit”) the union and started their own country, the “Confederate States of America.” The United States of America immediately declared that secession was illegal, and attempted to prove it via armies. This “American Civil War” lasted for four years and ended when the USA’s policy (IE armies) proved better. The CSA was dissolved and its states returned to the USA.</p><p>In the South, the four years of the Confederacy are still looked upon with some favor. The CSA had its own president, government, constitution, armies, uniforms, and — especially — its own flag, which some Southerners still fly today. Given that the CSA was known for its racism, one could be forgiven if one confused a modern Confederate-flag-waver for a racist. By and large, though, such flag-wavers disclaim any such taint. Their justification for doing so is that they are not (or rather no longer) rebels nor racists, but simply paying homage to the fight their ancestors gave and the deeds done therein. “Heritage, not hate.”</p><p>This justification might hold water if it were not an inherent contradiction.</p><p>On March 12, 1861, CSA Vice President Alexander H. Stephens gave the so-called “Cornerstone Speech” (<a href="https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/cornerstone-speech">link to full text</a>), in which he defined the Confederacy both in context to and in opposition to the United States. He drew attention to the parts of the Confederate constitution that had been copy-pasted directly from America’s:</p><blockquote>All the great principles of Magna Charta are retained in it. No citizen is deprived of life, liberty, or property, but by the judgment of his peers under the laws of the land. The great principle of religious liberty, which was the honor and pride of the old constitution, is still maintained and secured. All the essentials of the old constitution, which have endeared it to the hearts of the American people, have been preserved and perpetuated.</blockquote><p>He also drew attention to ways in which it had been altered:</p><blockquote>Another change in the constitution relates to the length of the tenure of the presidential office. In the new constitution it is six years instead of four, and the President rendered ineligible for a re-election. This is certainly a decidedly conservative change. It will remove from the incumbent all temptation to use his office or exert the powers confided to him for any objects of personal ambition.</blockquote><p>(There was no way to test this change empirically — the first and only President of the CSA never completed his term — but I don’t think it would have had the intended effect. If anything, such a president would display <em>more</em> corruption, because he had 1. less time to accomplish his goals, and 2. no election to lose if he screwed up. Regardless, I applaud the <em>intent</em> of the change. The idea of somehow enticing a president to act in good faith remains appealing, especially today.)</p><p>The most salient point, however, were the philosophical underpinnings of the changes, which Stephens made sure to highlight in full (emphasis mine):</p><blockquote>But not to be tedious in enumerating the numerous changes for the better, allow me to allude to one other though last, not least. … The prevailing ideas entertained by [Thomas Jefferson] and most of the leading statesmen at the time of the formation of the old constitution, were that the enslavement of the African was in violation of the laws of nature; that it was wrong in principle, socially, morally, and politically. … <strong>Those ideas, however, were fundamentally wrong</strong><em>.</em> They rested upon the assumption of the equality of races. This was an error. It was a sandy foundation, and the government built upon it fell when the “storm came and the wind blew.”</blockquote><blockquote>Our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite idea; its foundations are laid, its corner-stone rests, upon the great truth that <strong>the negro is not equal to the white man</strong>; that slavery subordination to the superior race is his natural and normal condition.</blockquote><p>You know, racism.</p><p>And I don’t mean “prejudice,” the act of a person judging or condemning another person by the color of their skin. I mean “racism,” a <em>codified</em> <em>system of laws</em> that condemns others by the color of their skin. Jim Crow laws, redlining, the war on drugs, the closing or removal of polling places, the recent evisceration of the United States Postal System, even the business of funding schools from income tax: <em>all</em> of these things, whether intentionally or not, penalize people for being Black. This is why it’s impossible for modern Black people to be racist against whites: there aren’t laws that do things like this to whites. (At least, not in America. If the two of you were in Africa, the black person probably <em>could</em> be racist against whites.) Can a Black person be <em>prejudiced?</em> Absolutely; and, unquestionably, some are. (No offense, Black readers.) But they cannot be <em>racist</em>. They cannot take advantage of pre-existing systems that stigmatize whites… because those systems <em>do not exist</em>.</p><p>So when anyone tries to claim that they fly their Confederate flag for reasons of “Heritage, not hate,” the only thing you need to do is remind them that their heritage <em>is</em> hate. <strong>The Confederacy was founded to be racist.</strong> Its sole purpose was to <em>dispute </em>the idea that “All men are created equal.” We know this because <em>the Confederates fucking said so.</em> And for our proud son of the Confederacy to deny this would be for him to deny his own heritage. Which is, to repeat, hate.</p><p>But, weirdly enough, you never hear CSA supporters admitting this. It’s almost like they’re just trying to use socially-acceptable symbols to advertise their prejudices. It’s almost like they’re, actually, just plain racist. And that could <em>never</em> be the case, right?</p><p>…Right?…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d753fec1d7ab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Fear of Not Being Able to Think About It]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/the-fear-of-not-being-able-to-think-about-it-28ebfa60fa4a?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28ebfa60fa4a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fear]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Aug 2020 16:51:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-02T16:56:38.274Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Washington <em>Post</em> laid it all out.</p><p>They <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/inspired-life/wp/2017/11/22/at-yale-we-conducted-an-experiment-to-turn-conservatives-into-liberals-the-results-say-a-lot-about-our-political-divisions/">published an analysis</a> done by psychologists on the differences between conservatives and liberals. The physiological analysis indicated that conservatives tend to have larger amygdalae, the structures in the brain responsible for fear; they also indicated that, when put in situations where they felt sure of their own physical safety, conservatives became less conservative. This article has been making the rounds of my social media feed, leading to no small amount of discussion (and, on my part, amusement, because I shared it when it was published, a year before it got popular, and most everyone ignored me).</p><p>Part of the discussion included the oversimplification spouted by the article, paraphrased here:</p><blockquote>“Wouldn’t everyone just be a conservative then? It’s not like liberals simply don’t feel fear.” And we determined that there was, indeed, more to it than that. The best explanation I heard involved the stimulus of an angry dog. “Is this a threat to me? Both liberals and conservatives are likely to answer yes: it’s growling, it’s posturing, its hackles are raised, it’s straining to reach me. It is probably a threat. And do you feel fear of it? Probably — I mean, at least if you have any common sense.</blockquote><blockquote>“But then we have a second question, the one that really draws the line: can I <em>defuse</em> this threat? If you say, ‘Yes, I can sit down with the dog and let him get to know me and see that I’m not a threat to him,’ you’re a liberal. If you say, ‘Nope, the dog’s nature is unknowable and immutable, and there is simply no way I could possibly reaching understanding with him,’ then you are a conservative.”</blockquote><p>So fear is described as the definition of the difference between a liberal and a conservative, but the whole discussion also skipped over an entire internal process which has already gone on. <em>Can I solve this problem?</em> If the answer is yes, there is no reason to be scared of it. But if the answer is no, then fear is an understandable response.</p><p>But here’s the thing: all of this is actually predicated not on the size of your amygdalae, but rather your facility with problem solving. It has to do with… I don’t even know if there’s a term for it. Let’s call it “intellectual confidence”, or maybe “confidence in your intelligence.” The question is not so much, Can I solve this problem, as it is, Can I solve problems?</p><p>And that’s where things start getting interesting.</p><p>Let me tell you a little bit about my mother.</p><p>My mother was born in Indonesia. She is a Chinese Catholic, and thus was a double minority in Muslim Indonesia — a triple minority, in fact, because, as has happened at other times and in other places in history, the foreign immigrant class in Indonesia were also the ones that had all the money. (And that’s before we address the minority of having no Y chromosome.) My mother described her childhood as physically comfortable, but she hasn’t spoken much about the prejudice she experienced, and I can only imagine it must have been pretty significant.</p><p>My mother and her five siblings (Baby Boomers, amiright) all emigrated to America, one by one, between about 1975 and 1985. She was the middle child of four sisters and two brothers, and joined her siblings in sending money back home. Her one remaining brother (the other actually passed away in an auto accident when she was a child) met a fellow Indonesian immigrant here in the States, wed, and had three children. The first child of that new generation, born in 1980, was a son, and my uncle invited over just about everyone he knew to come meet his bouncing baby boy, whom my mother was occasionally called upon to babysit. That’s what she was doing the day that my uncle invited home his coworker, a man with a very similar story to my mother: the middle child of four daughters and two sons (Baby Boomers, amiright), all of whom had emigrated to America between ’75 and ’85 and were now sending money home to their parents (in Hong Kong). This man was my father.</p><p>Dad once told me that he and Mom knew they had found their match within about 6 weeks of dating, but that they held off the wedding for 18 months solely to be polite. Whatever the case, I was born eight days before my cousin’s 3rd birthday — the same cousin over whose crib my parents first laid eyes on each other. (And who, apparently, had never heard the story before: when I told him about it, he immediately asked his dad whether it was true!)</p><p>Of course, to get married, you need jobs. Both my parents got their undergraduate degrees before emigrating, but my father continued his studies at Berkeley, earning a Master’s in civil engineering. My mother immediately went to work. Today we would call her a developer or a programmer, but at the time the job title was Software Engineer. She worked at a company called AMI on a parcel of land which later housed HP’s headquarters and today is the home of the Apple Spaceship; on that parcel of land, she was one of the very first human beings to use a newfangled computer interface device by Xerox that records two-dimensional hand movements, a peripheral they called a “mouse”. My mother may not have played a large role in the dawn of the Information Age, but she was there; she was part of the events that have shaped the world as we know it today. In between she was also the primary breadwinner for our family (while my father got situated at Arthur Anderson, where he failed to set a record for “fastest promotion to Partner” only because he left to pursue his dream of becoming an architect), and then became a full-time mother to myself and my sister once Dad’s paycheck stabilized. My mother has forgotten more about how computers work than I will ever know.</p><p>Which is why I’m always a bit concerned when she telephones me to ask why she can’t turn the volume up on her laptop.</p><p>“I don’t know what I’m doing!,” is always her explanation. To which I always protest, “I don’t know what I’m doing either!” Which is true. But she replies, “But you can figure it out,” which is also true. I’ve been working with Macs since I was 6 — my grade school was one of several across the country that received large infusions of hardware from Apple — and DOS not long after, plus the inevitable transition to Windows later. I own an Android phone, but I work at a company that makes smartphone games, and every such company starts with iOS (because that’s where the money is). I have plenty of experience with computers, across basically every operating system you could ask for; I’ve even, through MacBook terminal commands, started to learn some Linux! (I did a <em>git push</em> the other day and almost went mad with power.) Even when I don’t know what problem my mom is having, I feel confident in my ability to just go muck around in Settings and figure things out.</p><p>What goes unspoken in these conversations is that my mother, too, could go figure it out. She’s both intellectually and physically capable of clicking around in the Control Panel, of reading the buttons there, of using logic to determine which parts of it are relevant to her issues. She could figure it out. But she doesn’t <em>believe</em> she could figure it out. It’s the only difference… And it’s the only difference that matters.</p><p>My mother is not a conservative voter. But she is definitely conservative about technology.</p><p>Now, all of this is only so relevant to the current political situation. The Baby Boomers are on their way out, and their lack of ability to grapple with the problems of today will not limit the nation forever. But the thing is that there is another set of people who need to learn to grapple with problems, who need to learn the confidence to just stride into a situation and press buttons and flip switches until they figure out which one solves the problem they are trying to solve.</p><p>Who? Well, as you may recall, my mother is now a grandmother. My son is, or presumably will be, the middle child of <em>his</em> generation (I have five cousins, of which two have yet to breed), much like his grandparents were, much like I am. And what I learned, I must teach him.</p><p>I also want to take a moment to discuss psychology, because I spent a <em>ton</em> of money on that BS degree and I might as well get some use out of it.</p><p>I’m sure a lot of people have heard of the <a href="https://www.myersbriggs.org/">Myers-Briggs Temperament Indicator</a>. I personally prefer the <a href="https://www.enneagraminstitute.com/">Enneagram of Personality</a>, which is not any more scientific but in my opinion wiser. The point is that neither of them are based in any honest or genuine <em>research</em>; they’re both just hypotheses, as yet unproven. The only personality sorter that’s based in <em>research</em> is the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Five_personality_traits">Big Five</a>. I’m not going to bore anyone with the math, but the short of it is that researchers asked about a gazillion English speakers to fill out about a gazillion correlation surveys: “If a person is organized, would you say they are also punctual?” “If a person is organized, would you say they are also distracted?” “If a person is organized, would you say they are also chartreuse?” By combining the results of these surveys, the researchers found that most adjectives clustered together in five super-traits. These are the Big Five, and they describe an OCEAN of possibility, though you can use a different acronym if that doesn’t float your CANOE. The Big Five are:</p><ul><li><strong>Openness to Experience</strong>. Do you like novelty or are you a creature of habit?</li><li><strong>Conscientiousness.</strong> Are you aware of your obligations to others, and do you plan to do a good job of discharging them?</li><li><strong>Extraversion.</strong> Not just how much company do you like: what is your overall energy level? (The neurological underpinnings of extraversion lie in your brain’s optimum state of arousal. You remember how cars used to have that line on their speedometers that indicated their engines worked most efficiently at 55 MPH? Our brains have one too. The higher it is, the more extraverted you are.)</li><li><strong>Agreeableness.</strong> Do you tend to be kind and empathetic, or do you see life as a competition?</li><li><strong>Neuroticism.</strong> How prone are you to negative ideation? Are you self-conscious, shy and prone to bad moods? (Note that this has nothing to do with <em>positive</em> ideation. Someone who is low on neuroticism has nerves of steel, but optimism comes from Extraversion, and someone who is low on both is calm but stoic.)</li></ul><p>I bring this up because there are some problems with the Five Factor Model. The first was, hopefully, obvious to you from my description: It was constructed using English, and therefore its validity in other languages is questionable. It’s also missing a number of traits: religiosity, sex-positivity, manipulativeness, and more. (A competing proposal, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HEXACO_model_of_personality_structure">HEXACO</a>, adds “Honesty / Humility” to the above and replaces Openness with Emotionality.) The math itself has been disputed: the original analysis showed there were <em>twenty-something</em> factors before being refined further. And finally — and this is the part pertinent to our discussion — there’s a troubling correlation.</p><p>“Openness To Experience” correlates directly with not only “IQ,” the so-called general intelligence, but with liberalism.</p><p>Psychologists don’t like stereotyping people. We’re also trained to be suspicious of our own motives and biases. Some of us may <em>want</em> to get up on the rooftops and shout, “Research proves that <em>only</em> stupid people are conservative,” but the mere fact <em>of</em> wanting to do it is enough to make us question whether we misinterpreted the data. Besides, what scientific or theoretical framework could possibly explain this direct correlation? (Not <em>emotional</em> reasoning, but, y’know, <em>reason</em> reasoning.)</p><p>The answer is the thing we’re talking about. The answer is, “intellectual confidence.”</p><p>I don’t think conservatives are stupid. I think conservatives are <em>trained to believe</em> they’re stupid. I think conservatives are taught that they should not have faith in their own mental faculties: “Don’t think, kid, you aren’t equipped for it.” And what happens then? They perceive themselves as having low intelligence… <em>and they avoid situations they aren’t equipped for</em>. If you can’t think your way out of a paper bag, you steer clear of paper bags.</p><p>Now, this is <em>another</em> reason why we maybe shouldn’t go shouting “conservatives are dumb” from the rooftops. Openness To Experience <em>can be taught</em>. And, ideally, it <em>should</em> be taught, both in schools and in life. It isn’t being taught… because the modern Republican party has become the party of Power, Not People. They’re not the first; <em>every</em> aspiring dictatorship suppresses education so that nobody has the intellectual confidence to challenge them. Republicans may be that party <em>right now</em>, but that doesn’t mean they will be in three hundred years when the rot of corruption within the Democrats finally breaks free of containment. The side that doesn’t want its voters to think is the side that devalues education; their “political” alignment of liberalism vs. conservatism is an afterthought. (And, as we’ve already discussed, <a href="https://medium.com/@PerspectivesInC/socialism-can-devolve-into-fascism-so-can-everything-else-50851abe9431">neither liberalism nor conservatism has a unique link to fascism</a>.)</p><p>We started with conservatives. And there we must return, because the scope of this problem is much larger than just the next generation.</p><p>This lack of intellectual confidence: it’s becoming systemic. It happens to almost everyone today. It used to happen to me! When I was a teenager, I lacked critical thinking skills; I literally had to train myself to do it, mostly by spelling out my thought processes to those friends of mine who already possessed the faculty, and letting them correct me. I can’t recall any of my school teachers attempting to teach it to me (though I was an oblivious little idiot as a child, so it may simply have passed me by). And I know from Mara that increasing numbers of children are showing up unable to do it.</p><p>What is this systemic failure? Whence this surplus of individuals who not only believe that they do not know things, but that they <em>cannot</em> know things?</p><p>You can lay a lot of it at the feet of liberal policy: the insistence that each child be treated like a genius whether they are or not; the dumbing-down of educational standards to accommodate the lowest common denominator. You can lay a lot of it at the feet of conservative policy: the insistence, coming from religious influences, that there are many matters incomprehensible to the mere mind of man; the subtle emphasis on under-education because dumb people are easier to steal from. You can lay a lot of it at the feet of capitalist policy: the insistence that anything which cannot turn you a profit is worthless, and the resulting underfunding (not to mention monetization) of education. It’s a big melting pot, but it all results in one indigestible lump: most people don’t think learning is fun. They also don’t think school is fun, but I don’t care about that. I care about whether they think <em>learning</em> is fun.</p><p>How do you convince an entire population that learning is fun? Especially a population that is beginning to take refuge in their own ignorance, a population that treats their lack of intellectual confidence as a point of pride? To be frank, I don’t know. My wife, a trained educator, might have some ideas… but I asked her and she doesn’t either. This is a big problem, one larger than the two of us. But it needs to be solved, if the modern strain fascism is to be defused.</p><p>Now, to be clear: I don’t propose that all conservatism needs to be defeated. Conservatism, at least if practiced in the same manner, is based on a simple idea: “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” If you think that this philosophy is a bad one, you are an ignorant fool.</p><p>But “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” is not the rallying cry of the Trumpian conservative. On the contrary. Their philosophy is encapsulated in two different sentences. The first is the one revealed by the Washington <em>Post</em>: “We don’t know if we can live in a world that has changed, because doing so requires a level of thinking that we’ve been told, and we believe, we are incapable of achieving.” The other is the even more damning sentence: “The fix resulted in us losing part of the Zero Sum pie, so we want to re-break it. Progress represents an existential threat to us, and thus progress must be halted.”</p><p>This second sentence is so insidious that a lot of conservatives don’t know they think it — and even fewer are willing to <em>admit</em> they think it. So it’s hard to pin down exactly what drives it. Some of it can be attributed to simple selfishness. “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” is, after all, the mantra of the conservative… And the truth is that the system isn’t broke, <em>for certain people</em>. If those people don’t see any need to change it, that’s a reasonable (if horribly unsympathetic) conclusion to arrive at. But part of it is the other thing we’ve been talking about: the lack of intellectual confidence. “We don’t know how to live in a world without white / male / rich privilege: nobody’s ever taught us. But we also can’t <em>learn</em> to live in a world without privilege, because… nobody’s ever taught us.” And thus the lack of education foisted on our country by our fascist party is revealed to be one of the pillars that holds it up.</p><p>So how do we educate an entire generation of people to trust in their own brain cells? Not just white men, not just men, not just the rich — <em>everyone</em>. Because this shit is getting foisted on every single child in America’s education system, right now.</p><p>I wish I knew the answer. I’m not a teacher; I’m not trained in pedagogy. The best I can do for now is ask the question.</p><p>And I think it’s a question that needs to be asked.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28ebfa60fa4a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Virtues of Magic]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/on-the-virtues-of-magic-3cf0b73b62d2?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3cf0b73b62d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[magic-the-gathering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[raising-kids]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Aug 2020 16:55:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-27T21:43:13.258Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m going to need to build a bunch of <em>Magic</em> decks soon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/268/1*3WEdUzMu8rBSi06Hi6WM9w.jpeg" /><figcaption>copyright Wizards of the Coast, 1993-present</figcaption></figure><p>I don’t know if it’s a Millennials thing, or maybe just a product of being one of the first members of the Information Age, but as my generation gets older and starts having kids, we’re putting a lot of thought into the problems every parent faces. How am I going to raise my child? What do I want them to Value? How do I teach those values? And what parts of my own childhood do I want to pass on to my son or daughter? For some people, it’s a specific college or university; for some, it is adherence to a particular sports team. For many Millennials, it’s games.</p><p>And, speaking only for myself, games begin and end with <em>Magic: the Gathering</em>.</p><p>I first started playing <em>Magic</em> when I was 13, and I haven’t really stopped since. It’s an incredible framework upon which has been hung a variety of different and interesting experiences. At its core, <em>Magic</em> is about, well, magic: you take on the role of an immensely powerful wizard called a planeswalker, someone who can travel (“walk”) between universes (“planes”), using the pages of their spell book (AKA your deck) to vie against another wizard of equivalent power (your opponent). It’s a simple premise, but the execution makes it stand out.</p><p>First off, the cards themselves. There are two basic kinds of cards in <em>Magic</em>: Lands and Spells. Lands can be “tapped” to produce one “mana”, a form of magical energy, every turn. Spells consume mana to alter the current game state: summoning creatures to fight for you, creating artifacts and enchantments to strengthen your powers, weaving sorceries and instants to interfere with your opponent. Spells have increasing mana costs equivalent to their power. Here’s the rub: you can only play one new land a turn. This at a stroke slows down the game: whatever your most powerful spells are, they probably don’t cost only one mana, so you can’t play them until later.</p><p>Second off, the cards themselves. Land and spells in <em>Magic</em> come in five colors: White, Blue, Black, Red and Green. Each color stands for a philosophy, or perhaps an ideology, which determines what it is that color can and cannot do in terms of gameplay. Let’s take Blue as an example. Blue is all about intellect. Blue wants to create perfection by pursuit of knowledge. Blue cares about logic, reason, knowledge, research, facts, science, technology; it believes that Truth is the ultimate creator of prosperity. As such, Blue’s play style is very analytical. It has a lot of counterspells, which allow you to take a look at something your opponent is doing and then decide that, actually, you don’t want them to do it, so you’re going to stop them by playing a counterspell. Blue also lets you draw extra cards, since knowledge is power. On the other hand, Blue is very reactive; it can stop a problem as it happens, but not before. It has a lot of ways to stop itself from losing, but not as many ways to win. The tools it has for winning are very powerful, because Blue is the kind of color that wants to end wars with one well-placed punch, but they’re also very expensive in terms of mana costs. (They can also be very expensive monetarily, as Blue has historically been the most powerful color of the five.) If you want to play Blue, you have to play the long game, biding your time and waiting for your opponent to over-extend. Duncan Sabien already did a <a href="https://medium.com/s/story/the-mtg-color-wheel-c9700a7cf36d">brilliant article dissecting all five colors of <em>Magic</em></a> which you should read, but if you’re in a hurry, the other colors are, roughly: White wants to create peace through law &amp; order; Blue wants to create perfection through knowledge and progress; Black wants to achieve satisfaction through ruthlessness and power; Red wants to create freedom through action and emotion; and Green wants to achieve harmony via acceptance and interdependence. There are relations between colors that are complex and incredibly interesting; it’s not a surprise that Sabien’s article is about replacing the Myers-Briggs with <em>Magic</em>’s colors, which is probably nerdier than the MBTI but could scarcely be less scientific. And is definitely more fun, because <em>Magic</em> color theory is fascinating.</p><p>The reason this makes for good gameplay is simple: It means every deck has weaknesses. Every color has things it’s good at doing and things it’s bad at doing. Blue and White, for instance, share a common element of reactivity; if you have a threatening creature, Blue counters it reactively with counterspells, whereas White has all these spells which act like handcuffs — they shut your creature down, but can be removed again — or which deal with the creature permanently but only <em>after</em> it has thrown the first punch (White’s obsession with fairness outweighs its desire to not get punched), or which can be proactive but give the creature’s owner something of equivalent value (White and Blue also share a love of rules). Black and Red, on the other hand, don’t hesitate; Red has lots of <a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=438694">fireballs</a> and <a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=209">lightning bolts</a>, and Black has a spell that is straight-up called “<a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=414393">Murder</a>”. What did it do to you, Black? Nothing; it just happened to be in Black’s way. Now it’s not. (But Murder costs more mana than the lightning-bolt spell, so Black really has to commit.) And Green doesn’t go for proactively taking out creatures at all; instead, it just makes do with having <em>bigger</em> creatures, the biggest around, that yours can’t get through. Each color has completely different ways of solving their problems… and, even more than that, certain problems that it just flat-out <em>can’t solve</em>. If you’re playing that color, and your opponent presents you with that problem, you’re in trouble.</p><p>“Is it possible to play more than one color,” you might be asking, and the answer is, Yes. You can play as many colors as you want. Two-, three-, four- and even all-five-color decks have been created, and have gone on to win major tournaments. The problem <em>there</em> goes back to what I said earlier about mana. Lands in <em>Magic</em> produce <em>colored</em> mana: Plains for white, Islands for blue, Swamps for black, Mountains for red and Forests for green. If you’re playing a two-color deck — say, red-black — what’s the odds that your hand is filled with Black spells, which require black mana, but also Mountains, which only produce red mana? What’s the odds, in other words, that you draw a hand which is 100% completely unplayable? Well, the God of Random Numbers is, to put it bluntly, a vindictive asshole, so it’s higher than you think. The more colors a deck has, the higher the chance that math can screw you over.</p><p>Finally, the cards themselves. A standard <em>Magic</em> deck consists of 60 cards; 18 to 24 of them will be Lands, and the rest will be Spells. <em>You get to design this deck</em>. It’s not like chess, where you only get to choose whether you go first or not; in <em>Magic</em>, there are three more colors, <em>and</em> each color has a completely unique roster of troops. As of this writing, the game is 27 years old and has released over <em>twenty thousand</em> unique cards, not to mention thousands of cases where an old card (IE that good old Red lightning bolt) was <a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=191089">reprinted a second time</a>. (Or, in Lightning Bolt’s case, 19 times.) That’s a lot of options. So: how do you want <em>your</em> deck, yours personally, to win? Are you going to go “Aggro” and focus on introducing your creatures to the opponent’s face? Will you go “Control” and do the thing where you stop your opponent’s threats and delay until your own comes up? (Yes, Blue is the best at this, but every color can participate.) Or will you build a “Combo” deck that exploits unforeseen card interactions to create explosive, and hopefully overwhelming, amounts of resources? You have a chance to build a deck that is completely unprecedented, winning through means no one has every attempted before in the history of the game. You have the chance to put your mark on the multiverse. Or, at the very least, to do something that is uniquely you.</p><p>(Of course, you probably don’t have all 20,000 cards. You probably don’t even have 20,000 cards total; and some of the ones you do are probably duplicates of each other. You <em>certainly</em> may not have enough copies of this one card that, ooh, would be just <em>perfect</em> in the deck you’re trying to create right now. And there’s, on average, 800 new cards released per year. All of this just means one thing: you’ll want to <em>buy more cards</em>. Which <em>Magic</em>’s publisher, Hasbro subsidiary Wizards of the Coast, isn’t exactly complaining about.)</p><p>All of this combines with the previous point about the colors. You can design your deck to do one thing — to win in a particular fashion. But you can’t design a deck that does <em>everything</em>. Eventually you have to embrace the fact that your deck is going to be good at certain things and bad at others, and then work to sharpen its strengths, to make it even better at the one thing it’s meant to do.</p><p>These three elements — the mana system, the color wheel, and deck design — are what make <em>Magic</em>, in my opinion, the best game ever made. I mean, I’ve played hundreds of hours of <em>StarCraft</em>; my wife and I love us some <em>Splendor</em>; I’ve <a href="https://medium.com/@PerspectivesInC/mobas-and-the-psychology-of-success-bb044a0956ed">written an article</a> about <em>Heroes of the Storm</em>; my son’s first video game will be <em>Chrono Trigger;</em> and let’s not even talk about <em>Final Fantasy Tactics</em>. (To quote <a href="https://kotaku.com/why-everybody-loves-final-fantasy-tactics-5973196">a Kotaku article</a>: “Saying <em>Final Fantasy Tactics</em> is your favorite <em>Final Fantasy</em> game is like saying <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josiah_Bartlet">Jed Bartlet</a> is your favorite U.S. president. It is at once obviously correct, and obviously cheating.”) But the absolute best game in history? <em>Magic: the Gathering</em>. No contest.</p><p>And I want to make sure my son shares my love for it.</p><p>It’s not just pride or fandom, is the thing. I’m sure Mara and I will introduce Shiloh to many games over the course of his life (my wife hails from a clan that collects board games; if I need to prove the point: the two of us, her brother, and his girlfriend bought a mutual copy of <em>Gloomhaven</em>). But in my opinion, making sure he’s good at <em>Magic</em> will lay some critical foundations for his personality going forward.</p><ol><li>You learn problem-solving. In <em>Magic</em>, you have limited resources — the cards in your deck, and to a lesser extent the cards in your hand — with which to solve a problem (“Defeat my opponent, typically by reducing him from 20 life to 0”). If your deck is running smooth and unopposed, it should be able to do this well… but inevitably you’ll come up against a situation you never dreamed of. “He played <em>what</em> on my creature? And now this other thing happened… Ugh. How do I win <em>now</em>?” I dunno, buddy. How <em>do</em> you win now?</li><li>You learn good sportsmanship. I’ve designed a number of decks myself, some of which are not very good, some of which are very good, some of which are very silly, and one of which I don’t play anymore because it’s <em>too </em>good. (It uses some of those <a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Search/Default.aspx?action=advanced&amp;name=+[splicer]&amp;set=+[%22New%20Phyrexia%22]">Splicers from New Phyrexia</a> to get cheap artifact tokens on the board, followed by a <a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=194201">Shape Anew</a>, followed by exactly one copy of a <a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=48158">Darksteel Colossus</a>. Playing a Turn-11 card on Turn 4 is typically enough to cause a <a href="https://tappedout.net/mtg-questions/what-does-scoop-mean/">scoop</a>.) My stated goal in designing these decks is simple: <em>I want my opponent to have fun playing against it</em>. He — well, she; my most frequent opponent is Mara — may win, she may lose, but either way I want her to enjoy the game. That is, literally, secondary to winning as far as I’m concerned. (Which is <em>why</em> I describe that deck as being “too good.”) I think that this value — prioritizing fun over victory; the idea that losing isn’t the worst thing that can happen; the idea that there is, in fact, something more important than winning — needs to be a great deal more present in American society.</li><li>You learn to lose gracefully. I’ve mentioned the effects of the Random Number God on your opening hand: having too many spells, having not enough land. <em>This can happen no matter what deck you’re playing</em>. There are some ways around it: not just the <a href="https://mtg.gamepedia.com/Mulligan">mulligan rule</a>, but having specific cards that offset a lack of lands, from <a href="https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Once+Upon+a+Time">Once Upon A Time</a> to <a href="https://www.mtgstocks.com/lists/2">Fetch Lands</a> to the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Nine">Power Nine</a>. The problem with those specific cards is that they can be very, <em>very</em> hard on your wallet. They help you circumvent a weakness that’s built directly into the game: because your hand is random, it’s <em>always</em> possible that your deck simply won’t function the way it’s meant to. <em>Every deck is </em><strong><em>obliged</em></strong><em> to lose sometimes</em>, not because its opponent necessarily did anything right but because the deck was condemned, by luck, to do everything wrong. This sucks… and it’s an <em>incredibly</em> valuable lesson for anyone seeking to spend time in that arena called “real life.” (And, like real life, this issue can be defrayed by simply throwing money at it.)</li><li>You get good at doing a lot of math. Math is actually a fundamental skill of the game because it determines how creatures function in combat; and attacking (or defending) with creatures is typically the main way a deck reduces its opponent’s life total and/or maintains its own. The reason the math gets complicated is that, while creatures have starting stats in “Power” (how much damage it can do) and “Toughness” (how much damage it can take), these stats can become changed, both temporarily and permanently, by in-game abilities. An <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCzLf2MTt3c">incredibly funny show-match</a> between noted Internet personalities Sean “Day9” Plott and Jesse “OMFGcata” Cox shows this happening; Plott has a creature which starts the fight at 1/1 (basically the smallest that a creature can be), but by the end of it has <a href="https://youtu.be/TCzLf2MTt3c?t=16m26s">become a 5/3</a>. Learning to keep track of that many rapidly-changing variables is good mental exercise.</li><li>You learn to prioritize. Like I said, every deck is good at something specific and bad at something else. So when you’re tinkering with your deck, you’re asking yourself about priorities. “I have this one card — say, <a href="http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=45420">Naturalize</a> — that I need rarely, but when I need it it just wins me games straight out. The problem is that I need it so rarely. Most of the time it just takes up space in my hand. What can I replace it with?” This is really a second form of Point #1. “How many copies of it are <em>in</em> the deck?” The rules of the game state that unless the card is a basic land — one of those Plains, Islands, Swamps, etc I mentioned earlier — your deck can only contain four copies of it. “Do I need that many? If I removed two or even one, I could free up space for something else. Or, is there a version of the spell that is somehow beneficial even if I don’t need it? Say, <a href="http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=47219">it has Cycling,</a> which lets me pay 2 mana and discard it to draw another, presumably more useful, card. Or what if I just cut it out entirely and put in this other thing that doesn’t do what the original card does, but instead just helps the deck win. What if I double down on my strategy instead of building in safety valves?” There is no single right answer to this question — the correct answer depends on a lot of things, like, “Who am I playing against”; “How often do I need to solve that particular problem”; “How screwed <em>am</em> I, really, if I can’t solve it” — but learning to figure out the answer is an excellent way to build critical thinking skills.</li><li>You learn to prioritize. As mentioned previously, the game’s objective is to reduce your opponent’s life total from 20 to 0; as mentioned previously, the main way most decks accomplish this is by attacking with their creatures. Creatures attack <em>en masse</em>, but the defender gets to assign their own creatures as blockers on a case-by-case basis. Sometimes you will need to sacrifice a creature to do this — like if something with 4 Power is on its way, but your only creature would die if it blocked, but <em>you </em>would die if it didn’t block. At that point, it doesn’t matter what that creature is or how it’s meant to fit into your larger game plans, whether or not it’s meant to do something else than die in a fight; you let it die in the fight. But earlier in the game, when you still have all 20 Life? Do you <em>have</em> to throw away that creature that has other purposes in the context of your deck? <em>Should</em> you? What, genuinely, is the most important right now: your life total or your long-range plans for victory? Because you can’t have both. So choose one.</li><li>You meet a <em>lot</em> of people. <em>Magic</em> is a hobby that crosses all walks of life; I’ve played it against my wife, against strangers, against classmates, and once against the CEO of my company. (He kitbashed together an impressive Bestow creature that ran away with the game.) This puts you in social situations you might not have otherwise entered into… and that’s always good practice, even if it does mean you’re liable to have a few stumbles on the way.</li><li>You learn about your own strengths and weaknesses. Playing <em>Magic</em> will inevitably put you in situations that you weren’t prepared for, which is the first step to preparing for them next time. There’s also the fact that certain colors will inevitably appeal to you more than others do, because they’re consonant with how you want to live your life when you <em>aren’t</em> a planeswalker. Many of my decks revolve around gaining life and using that as an impediment to my opponent — not just because I’m staving off defeat via lifegain, but via cards that say things like, “<a href="https://scryfall.com/card/2xm/5/archangel-of-thune">When you gain life, you can make your creatures stronger</a>” or “<a href="https://scryfall.com/card/kld/192/aetherflux-reservoir">When you gain life, you can deal damage to your opponent</a>” (…or would, if these cards weren’t prohibitively expensive for someone whose eldest needs to be sent to college in 14 years). I like it when my victory is a byproduct of simply strengthening my own position. (Yes, Green <em>i</em>s<em> </em>my favorite color, why do you ask?)</li><li>It’s a vehicle for self-expression. My gift to Mara for our first wedding anniversary was a themed deck. Her maiden name (Barrett) means “bear,” and mine means the number 5, and she hyphenated, so I built a deck that revolves around <a href="http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=6613">five</a> <a href="http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=114905">different</a> <a href="http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=244727">kinds</a> <a href="http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=413733">of</a> <a href="http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=240088">bear</a>. It is, unfortunately, not very good — bears, by long tradition, cost two mana apiece, so on Turn 4 she has a maximum of 6, maybe 7 Power on the board, whereas that one “too-good” deck I mentioned has 11— but she really liked getting it, which is part of what matters. And the cool thing about <em>Magic</em> decks is that you can always tinker with them to make them better!</li><li>It’s relatively cheap. Even if we buy a box, 540 cards, once per set (which are released every 3 months), that works out to about $400 a year for a <em>lot</em> of useful tools that can be combined and recombined into new and interesting decks between the three of us. And in today’s economy, where cable companies are withering because their services are simply too expensive for most people, something which entertains all of us and doesn’t cost a lot of money could be a godsend.</li></ol><p>But most importantly, it’s something the three of us can do together. It’s a form of fun and entertainment we can all share. And I think that’s what matters most. After all, I can’t teach Shiloh anything if I don’t spend time with him.</p><p>Now to just wait the three or four years until he’s ready. I can’t wait to get started!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3cf0b73b62d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Mission Statement]]></title>
            <link>https://perspectivesinc.medium.com/a-mission-statement-4870fd2672bd?source=rss-755dc22d4ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4870fd2672bd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[progress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kyriarchy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Perspectives in C]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Apr 2020 17:29:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-20T01:19:36.687Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>You do not get to live in a world that satisfies your sense of ethics. You do, however, get to create one. And that’s what this blog has always been about.</p><p>A lot of people believe capitalism is a step forward. And they’re right. But it’s only a step forward.</p><p>Feminists have come up with a term: “Kyriarchy.” They invented it when they started talking about ‘patriarchal’ system that weren’t patriarchal, like the question of how popular girls oppress other girls. Calling this ‘patriarchy’ is… well, there’s certainly some of it in there; but it’s also not the best term, since — in general — when a girl decides to be mean to another girl, no Y chromosomes are directly involved. (I mean, one of the girls could have <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_androgen_insensitivity_syndrome">complete androgen insensitivity syndrome</a>.) “Patriarchy” is a power structure where men are in charge; feminists wanted a word that simply involved the power structure of dominance and control, regardless of the sex or gender of the person <em>doing</em> the controlling. Hence the term “kyriarchy”. If you’ve ever been to a Christian church or listened to any choir music (or remember that Mister Mister hit from the 80s), you’ve probably heard “Kyrie eleison.” It’s Greek. “Kyrie” means <em>lord</em> in this case, though figuratively it means God. And I think that’s a handy definition to keep in mind when contemplating the term <em>kyriarchy</em>.</p><p>In the past, we lived in highly delineated kyriarchies. In the days of absolute despotism, you had some sort of monarch — a king or an emperor or a pharaoh or whatever. This person could walk around confident that their life mattered: if something happened to them, someone would throw themselves in the way to save them if they could. Later we upgraded to feudalism, where landed gentry could assume their lives mattered: the king, the nobility, the knights, etc. One important key to feudalism was the concept of <em>upward mobility</em>: If you possessed certain skills which the feudal hierarchy valued (mainly, a facility with using pointy bits of metal to kill other people), you could get promoted to knighthood. It was still a kyriarchy, where only certain people were considered deserving of life, but it was more possible to become one of those people.</p><p>Capitalism was yet another step forward. Within capitalism, it’s the same concept: if you possess certain skills which the capitalist hierarchy values, you have access to upward mobility. In this case, the values are some combination of “hard work,” “creativity” and — let’s face it — “luck.” (I mean, tell me that Paris Hilton has any of the other two.) But prosperity was now in easier reach than ever before; in fact, basically an entire generation, the Baby Boomers, managed to achieve it. Now, obviously some people fell through the cracks; but by and large, upward mobility was accessible to everyone. Only certain people were considered deserving of life, but it was the easiest it’s ever been to qualify yourself as one of those people.</p><p>And with that in mind, people who are calling to tear down capitalism might seem… short-sighted.</p><p>Actually, I agree that they’re short-sighted. To mis-quote a famous soldier-statesman, “Capitalism is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried.” It is, in other words, the least-bad. It works — and works well — because it incentivizes self-interest. All human beings inherently want to, well, survive: they want to live long enough to mate and have children and die at old age. Capitalism works because it is built on a proven and empirical quality of human nature. And that’s not nothing.</p><p>Communism, on the other hand… Jeez, don’t get me started. Communism is built on fairy tales. The basic idea is, “Do what you can, take what you need” — everyone works, everyone puts the fruits of their labor into a central pot, everyone takes out of it what they need. This is a perfectly sensible system… but we’ve seen it fail over and over. Why? Because it’s based on the idea that humans are not lazy — that humans will work even when there’s no reason for them to do so. After all, Communism was obsessed with some silly crap about “the dignity of the common man” and such; cracking the whip would be antithetical to the kind of proletariat revolt they were trying to drive. People were allowed to work if they felt like it, and slack off if they felt like it. The Communists <em>hoped</em> humans would magically, radically change into industrious, driven workers, instead of remaining what they are — lazy, slovenly fucks that will not lift a <em>finger</em> if they can get away with it. So if you build an economy on a trait that doesn’t exist… Well, the economy itself stops existing soon after. Which is, weirdly enough, exactly what happened.</p><p>(Now, the counter-argument to this is the ‘commune’ — little clutches of people here and there who live under a Communist system. According to my argument, these communes do not and cannot exist; and yet, empirically, they do. How is this possible? Simple: Communism works <em>on a small scale</em>. If you’re in a small environment, one — to quote the old TV show — “where everybody knows your name,” then if you’re the person who slacks off, who takes out of the pot without putting everything in, then <em>everybody knows</em>. A small-scale commune can apply the age-old human governmental tactic of “shame” to its less-productive members, either cajoling them into pulling their own weight or — if worst comes to worst — simply exiling them entirely. Communism’s problems are problems of scale. Unfortunately, those problems are largely insurmountable.)</p><p>Capitalism is the least-bad system. That’s not nothing. But it’s also not nothing that it’s the least-bad — the best of a number of bad options. After all, capitalism — when you get down to it — is still a form of kyriarchy. “Only certain people, under capitalism, deserve life.” The criteria for becoming one of those people is the widest they’ve ever been, but the criteria <em>still exist</em>.</p><p>Which is why it surprises me that everyone’s answer seems to be, “Well, capitalism is broken, but the answer is to capitalism <em>harder</em>.” Because making something worse has such a <em>long</em> track record of making it better.</p><p>If you were to say, “Capitalism is the best we have,” you would not be wrong. But if you were to say, “Capitalism is bad,” you would <em>also</em> not be wrong. Because the ideal form of economy — the one to strive towards — is the one that <em>isn’t a kyriarchy</em>. The economy I want to see, as we move forward, is the one that doesn’t say that <em>only</em> certain people deserve life. The economy I want to see is the one that says — well, to co-opt that racist slogan — that All Lives Matter.</p><p>And until capitalism either says that or has given way to something that does, we haven’t finished our work.</p><p>Under the circumstances, I probably shouldn’t be surprised that my dad is such a cynic.</p><p>You have to keep in mind, my dad is arguably a poster child for the American Dream. He was born in Hong Kong, the fourth of six children, during the time when Hong Kong was an English colony. He emigrated to California and got a degree in Civil Engineering from UC Berkeley whilst simultaneously working a full-time job in a cannery and moonlighting as a construction worker. He got into the nuclear-reactor business, where he met his best friend, but later left for the comparatively sane world of accounting. Joining Arthur Anderson, he expanded their business to private accounting, and was on track to be named “youngest partner in the company” when he quit to follow his true love: architecture. Because of him and his design jobs, I’ve been inside Barry Bonds’ Los Altos Hills mansion, among other places. He did very well before his retirement, retained on the staff of a major construction company as their sole architect and helping to develop much of the Bay Area; the head of said company was also a partial owner of the Oakland A’s during the Moneyball years, and had the dubious honor of being portrayed by Bobby Kotick in the movie. My dad also helped bring his entire family over from Hong Kong, with his mother and father last; he built a house where they and two of his sisters lived, and helped a third sister demolish and remodel her home. He also built his own dream house in Cupertino, CA, and then a second one in Los Altos, which was done on a shoestring budget using connections from within the industry and today is estimated to be worth close to $5 million. (I do mean “estimated”, as the people who bought it from us still own it; there’s been no appraisal since then.) I don’t know if my dad is a millionaire — or, more accurately, I don’t know if he has a million in easily-accessible liquid funds accessible; the house where he and Mom live now is only 1.5 miles from the Apple Spaceship. In terms of the whole “pulling yourself up by your bootstraps” thing, you couldn’t ask for much more than my dad’s success story.</p><p>(He also met my mom. His best friend had just had his first child, a healthy baby boy, and my dad came to visit and pay his respects. His best friend’s younger sister, the fourth of six children, was helping to babysit, and she and my dad first met eyes over that crib. She is also an immigrant, a woman of Chinese descent who grew up in Indonesia, who got her degree there and came to America for more education. In Indonesia, they spoke Dutch and German in addition to Indonesian; my dad learned Cantonese. They flirted in English, the only language they both spoke. My dad says he knew my mom was the one after only six weeks of dating, but that they waited 18 months to marry to be polite. 14 months later, I happened. My mom’s family was a little more successful, monetarily speaking, so my dad didn’t have to build as many houses for them, but they’re all here now as well.)</p><p>Because my dad spent two decades as an architect, and more as a framer, he knows something about construction. And the part he hates most is the bureaucracy. From zoning boards to inspections, from fire codes to HVAC regulations, he knows the whole thing backwards and forwards. (He didn’t actually design Barry Bonds’ house; Bonds hired his own architect from Florida to do that. My dad was brought on <em>solely</em> for his expertise with navigating the local bureaucracy.) His time spent as a tax accountant certainly cannot have helped. He has basically no faith in government to function the way it was meant to; all he ever sees — and certainly, all he is ever exposed to — is time-wasting, red-tape and looking-out-for-number-one-ism. He retired from architecture not because he lost his passion for it, but because he was tired of his life resembling an endless visit to the DMV. Because, to him, that’s what government is: a waste of time and money.</p><p>And with this in mind, it’s probably not surprising that my dad is a conservative.</p><p>It all came to a head at dinner the other day. My dad, the certified tax expert, sat down with my sister (and her husband) and me (and my wife) to file our taxes. I’m not sure what my sister got, but Mara and I were in for a nasty surprise: between my new position, which I’ve been in for almost a year now, and my wife’s pay grade, we went up at least one tax bracket. Last year we owed quite a bit. This year it’s worse. Afterwards, we served dinner (my dad loves to cook), and my dad went in on his beliefs.</p><p>In short, he didn’t see good things for the country if Bernie Sanders were to be president. He claims that every Communist regime has eventually become a dictatorship. He dislikes the idea that billionaires like Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg are automatically evil. He is against big government, and against the idea that expanding the government can ever be a good idea. He also brought up the coming proposed repeal of California’s Proposition 13, which caps estate tax at 3.5% growth year over year. If it’s repealed, my dad and my sister and I (who all own property) could see our property taxes increase by <em>10,000%</em>. And that would be all well and good if we could <em>afford</em> it, but my sister and I cannot. (Part of the problem with the current meddling with taxes and all is that everyone is still using Baby-Boomer definitions of wealth. My wife and I, collectively, pull down a 6-figure income. The tax system treats us as if we’re in the upper class… even though, factually speaking, we’re not far above the poverty line.) In total fairness to my dad, someone within the government cooked up this scheme: “Everyone’s complaining that California is too expensive. Surely, the way to fix that is to make it <em>more</em> expensive!” I’m not sure what they’re smoking, but I’d really like some. But the point my dad made is well-founded: If this is how Government solves problems, then we’d be foolish to trust the Capitol Building any further than we can throw it.</p><p>(The idea that Communist regimes correlate 1-to-1 with dictatorships is something my sister challenged. It also does not follow that Sweden, Norway and Denmark are Communist hellscapes. A lot of people — my dad included — don’t seem to understand that there is a meeting-place <em>between</em> capitalism and communism. But that’s the first half of this essay.)</p><p>My dad’s argument boils down to a pretty simple statement: If we attempt to create a new government with the same old people in charge, we’re going to be stuck with the same old problems.</p><p>And my counter-argument is… nothing. I don’t have one. He’s 100% correct. If we attempt to create a new government with the same old people in charge, we’re going to be stuck with the same old problems.</p><p>“But then, C,” you might ask, “what the heck are you talking about on this blog? You’re <em>constantly</em> talking about creating some sort of new government! Now you’re saying that you were wrong? Why have we bothered reading anything you’ve ever written?”</p><p>Well, first off: wow, somebody reads anything I write? Cool! That’s awesome. But anyway. Second: you’re right, and you’re wrong. My mission here has always been about creating a new form of government… But <em>as a side-effect</em>. My <em>primary</em> mission, the goal I work towards — the reason I write everything I write here — is a different one.</p><p>“If we can’t create a new government with the same old people, then how do we create a new breed of people?”</p><p>That’s why almost everything I’ve ever written has been of an ethical bent. To me, everything about politics, about government, about business — everything worth discussing — comes down to one question: “How should we treat other people?” And it should be pointed out that a great deal of social-justice revolves solely around that very question. Black Lives Matter, Me Too, the separate-but-intertwined movements led by Ocasio-Cortez and Sanders… They are all concerned with questions of human rights and human dignity, and how those translate (or have failed to translate) into our modern policies. They are questioning the things we have been taught.</p><p>That’s where I think the future lies. Not in radical new forms of political science, but in the slow evolution of the human heart, the gradual understanding that we don’t need to worry about how we treat other people, because <em>there are</em> no other people — just us, ourselves, under marginally different circumstances.</p><p>Fundamentally, capitalism, like any kyriarchy, is broken. However, the parts of it that work also work better than anything else before it. It’s based on a truth and a lie — the survival instinct on one hand, the scarcity principle on the other. If we can ditch the lies and keep the truth, we’ll be better off.</p><p>And we’re part of the way there already. Again, my dad is absolutely right: If we attempt to create a new government with the same old people in charge, we’re going to be stuck with the same old problems. This is an accurate conclusion and one I would support him in. However, it does <em>not</em> follow that we must put the same old people in charge. It does not follow that we don’t already have, at least a little bit, a new breed of people. The way we train our children, the way they talk… My wife, a high school teacher, has a student who is openly transgender, and their colleagues by and large do not shun them. There is a growing understanding amongst Generation Z that diversity <em>is not</em> threatening, that uniqueness is acceptable, that pure normalness is not necessarily a good thing (if it even exists at all). I am, technically, a Millennial (though some demographists have identified a cusp microgeneration called the “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xennials">Xennials</a>” which describes me much more accurately) and even <em>we</em> didn’t have that sort of open-mindedness; I was one of the most bullied children in school until about 10th grade, and the only reason it stopped at that time was because the bullies finally grew a second brain cell and started growing up. And the thing is: I wasn’t trans. I wasn’t gay. I wasn’t outstanding in any way. What I <em>was</em> was shy and easily riled… And that all it took to make me start wondering whether my classmates deserved to be the victims of a Columbine re-enactment. When Mara describes this trans kid — who is not just trans but awkward about it — I am grateful that they (I don’t remember their preferred gender — and maybe oughtn’t share it in any case) are growing up today. If they had been in school with me, they would have killed themselves before high school. I say that not because I believe this trans kid is weak, but because that’s what bullying was like amongst my cohort. We had <em>no</em> tolerance for any sort of deviation. The open-mindedness my wife tells me about today is something I longed for but knew I would never experience. And it gladdens my heart to know that it has finally come to fruition today. Look how far we’ve come in such a short time!</p><p>(And also: thank the fucking <em>LORD</em> that Shiloh, who will be at <em>least</em> as weird as me, won’t have to put up with that fucking bullshit.)</p><p>I don’t think my dad is wrong to believe what he believes. But what needs to be pointed out is that politics are a product of their contexts. The Silent Generation protested de-segregation; today, interracial marriage is barely blinked at. Twenty years ago the country solidly opposed gay marriage; today it’s legal and barely blinked at. Marijuana is edging towards legality. Conservatives may call all of this “social breakdown,” but the rest of us call it “progress.” My dad is right in his opinions about his generation and the people it produced… but what he’s forgotten is that his generation is on its way out. “The Times, They Are A-Changing,” to quote the songwriter.</p><p>Now, this raises an important question: Is this amount of progress enough? Is this enough of a fundamental change that we can institute some newer, greater form of government?</p><p>Honestly, I don’t know. But honestly, I don’t care. If we, as a species, keep teaching ourselves more about ourselves — if we keep moving towards a society that doesn’t concern itself with how it treats the Other because it understands there is no Other — then newer, betterer forms of government will be <em>an inevitability</em>. I have no idea what they are or what they will be like, but that’s okay: it’s not my job to answer those questions. It is, however, my job to <em>ask</em> them, to pass to the next generation this sacred question: “Is this good enough?” We all know — my dad knows, I know, and I’m sure Shiloh will know as well once he figures out that “Agua” does not mean “Let me out of my high chair” — that the current system isn’t good enough. And when my dad says, “I don’t believe it can be fixed with the tools we have,” I trust him. He’s already spent his years in the trenches; he’s reporting first-hand based on experience I don’t have and never will. So if we can’t fix it with the tools we have, my job is to <em>create better tools</em>.</p><p>And that’s what this blog is about. It’s about asking the questions that, as far as I can tell, will lead us forward.</p><p>(And yes, I realize it’s a cop-out to disclaim that I can or will provide answers. But what else can I say? I am not exactly the world’s most brilliant political thinker. I know my limitations. This is one of them. I’m going to do what I can with what I have. I don’t claim it’s enough. But I <em>do</em> claim it can be useful.)</p><p>We don’t have a right to live in a world that satisfies us morally, but we <em>do</em> have the right to create one. And, insofar as I am capable of doing so, that’s what I’ll be trying to do. Merely asking the questions is, of course, not enough. But it’s a start. And, call me naive if you wish, but I believe that this journey does, in fact, have an ending.</p><p>Maybe I’ll even live to see it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4870fd2672bd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>