<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Nobels on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Nobels on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@peter_91957?source=rss-49425f40625------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 16:55:44 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@peter_91957/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DAOs #4 — Shared value(s)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-4-shared-value-s-81d90f5dfeb2?source=rss-49425f40625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81d90f5dfeb2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lisk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kalipo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Nobels]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 May 2022 10:08:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-08T17:47:24.200Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>DAOs #4 — Shared value(s)</p><p><strong>This Blog post</strong></p><p>This blog post is about value. Isn’t that what life is all about: creating and enjoying value? To be able to create and enjoy value or not able to create and enjoy value. When we perceive value, the strings of our heart are touched; it makes our heart sing.</p><p>What a DAO, in support of a community, can do for shared value(s) is the essence of this post.</p><p>This blog post is part of a series of posts, a blogchain. This series is about DAOs (Decentralized Autonomous Organizations) in general and Kalipo in particular. <a href="https://kalipo.io/">Kalipo</a> is a platform on which communities can establish their own tailormade DAO. DAOs are the next step in collaboration, governance and value distribution.</p><p>This post is probably too long according to the rules of readability. But why cutting value?</p><p><strong>Message</strong></p><ul><li>Successful communities are able to create value for their members.</li><li>Clear values where members are strongly aligned by, are a prerequisite for successful communities.</li><li>Each community should specify its own value set and install constructs to support those values.</li><li>Blockchain has unique features which DAOs can use to fulfill value needs and solve value problems.</li><li>Constructs that support the capturing, distribution and exchange of value should be put under the governance of members.</li></ul><p><strong>Intro into value</strong></p><p>W e can look at life and communities from several angles. From a power angle (see my previous post <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/dao-3-its-all-about-power-869ac4221960">DAOs #3</a>), a risk angle or a care angle (see post <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAOs #2a</a>) for example. But value(s) should be the central theme for communities. Because isn’t this what communities are about: how to create value, how to enjoy value and how to live by values?</p><p>Value is a wonderful concept. It’s like a cut diamond with many facets. ‘Value’ in the English language shows two facets of value with one and the same word: value as in ‘added value’ and value as in ‘the values we like to live by’ (or maybe more often ‘the value we like others to live by’).</p><p>When hearing the word ‘blockchain’ most people think of crypto’s. Digital pieces of value to invest in or to use as a currency. This blog will not only shine a light on these digital pieces of value but also on the values where communities live by and how DAOs can support both types of value.</p><p><strong>Communities as value communities and value creators</strong></p><p>The brackets in the title of this post ‘Shared value(s)’ are there for a reason: communities can be seen as a group of people who share the same values (shared values) <em>and</em> as a collaboration where created value is shared between the members (share value).</p><p><em>Value communities</em></p><p>A mission is a community’s uber value. A community exists to fulfill that mission. Each step toward that mission, means that more community value is created.</p><p>Kalipo’s vision/mission ​​as an example: <em>supporting caring communities on their path to a better world for all</em>. More care delivered, with more support from our side, resulting in more happy people means we’re on track towards our mission.</p><p>But what makes a community successful? Here the second meaning of value kicks in. Create <em>value</em> (the goal) through living by <em>shared values</em> (the rules to play by). Values are the glue that binds the members of a community. The EU started as an economical project. But it would never have survived on business transactions only. The shared values of its member states and citizens kept the EU alive. Shared values make members caring for each other, willing to pull each other through bad and good times. In his book “Greenpilled,” Kevin Owocki beautifully describes the positive fallout of strong value(s) on all parties: <em>“with values as roots, everything else is a byproduct. It creates solidarity within a community, customer loyalty, member engagement and partner trust”</em>.</p><p>The mission and the shared values not only bind people, they also attract new ones. From a community perspective, it should for longevity reasons be a ‘value community’ with an appeal to current and potential members. Most soccer clubs outlive their members. The mission and values, as a center of gravity, stay (FC Barcelona ‘Més que un club’ meaning ‘More than a club’).</p><p>And there’s more. Mission and values become a distinguishing feature. People tend to choose, when given the choice, for a community that best connects to their needs <em>and</em> values. Would you and your friends stay on Facebook when there was an alternative that offered the same features but other values? Values like 100% privacy preserving (no data selling to third parties) or data transportability (= being able to leave the platform while taking your data with you).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/884/1*1KYjyYUyxW9YLHEaDpoMwQ.png" /></figure><p><em>Communities as value creators</em></p><p>The Western world is mainly focused on enterprises (a specific type of community) as value creators for their shareholders. Other types of communities, through the lens of ‘value creator’, get less attention. The Western world also has a blind spot for other stakeholders than shareholders. But how about a sports club that creates value for its members, a government that creates value for its citizens and a union that creates value for workers? And an enterprise that offers other values to its employees than mere salary?</p><p>Examples of how communities create less obvious value for members: for one, by just being a place for social interaction where members experience a feeling of belonging. Secondly giving members, who sometimes are ‘just’ doing their job, a sense of purpose, of leading a meaningful life. And thirdly, by offering people the opportunities to grow as craftsmen and as humans. How much value is that?</p><p><strong>What values to live by?</strong></p><p>What is it that we value? What is it that is precious to us? What makes our hearts sing? The answer is, what a community defines it does! Although most values feel like they are universal, and perhaps a lot are, it’s the community that defines and rewards certain kinds of value(s).</p><p>This means that every community has its own value set, that it’s up to each community to choose its own values. This makes every community unique as a community. Two enterprises can offer the same service, their culture will differ.</p><p>Communities don’t always explicitly define their values. What’s being valued can be expressed by members through likes, payments, friendships (expressing: “I value you”) or by becoming a member.</p><p>There are several frameworks for characterizing the value set of a community. I like to mention the one that puts <em>goal ethics</em> on one end of the spectrum and the <em>ethics of beliefs</em> on the other one. Where <em>goal ethics</em> has the adagium ‘goals above all (by whatever means)’ and the <em>ethics of beliefs</em> propagates ‘values above all (always play by the rules)’. This framework can help a community to consider what rules (values) to implement and what value to create.</p><p><strong>What’s the problem with value?</strong></p><p>While value is a valuable concept, it’s also difficult to handle. For individuals and communities alike. Some issues with one or both types of value:</p><ul><li>A limited view</li><li>Difficult to specify</li><li>Neglect to cherish</li><li>Difficult to protect</li><li>Difficult to live by</li><li>Difficult to discuss</li><li>Difficult to align</li><li>Difficult to impose</li><li>Difficult to notice, proof and reward</li><li>Difficult to share fairly</li></ul><p><em>A limited view</em></p><p>Values — Every community has its limited vision on value. Each community prioritizes a set of values above others. The Western world is very much focused on economic growth, on ‘getting’ and on individual freedom. In a community with such values people often lack a sense of purpose and belonging which one can get through ‘giving’ and social connection.</p><p>You could also state that many people in the Western world are addicted to <em>junk values</em> (which is a valuation of certain values of course). <em>Junk values</em> are about appreciating things that deliver short term or superficial satisfaction. <em>Junk values</em> don’t really connect to our (deepest) needs. As an example: we crave ‘likes’ on our social media posts to boost our self-confidence. <a href="https://academic.oup.com/joc/article/71/1/56/6124731">Research</a> shows that this boost rarely happens nor lasts.</p><p>And because communities reward what they value, they create more of the same. Tilting themselves even more out of balance. Capitalist communities laud money making, often neglecting the costs of externalities like damage to the environment or others parties (sometime labeled as ‘dumb losers’). The damaged ones often boomerang back which becomes a threat to the community.</p><p>Other problems with a limited view is that a lot of needs are left unfulfilled and that it’s hard to steer the community in another more fulfilling, sustainable, and caring direction.</p><p><em>Difficult to specify</em></p><p>Values — Most people are good at spotting and commenting on what they don’t like. Read the social media. But how often do you read what people <em>do</em> like, what it <em>is</em> they long for?</p><p>Values are like the air we breathe: we need it but hardly know how to describe it. Trying to describe values is like asking a fish to describe water. Because it’s everywhere, we aren’t aware of it and don’t realize it’s there. What does the value ‘freedom’ look like? ‘My freedom above all’ or ‘care for each other so we can all live in freedom’? It’s often not clear what somebody means when he talks about freedom nor that there are several kinds of freedom.</p><p><em>Neglect to cherish</em></p><p>Values — We start appreciating things when there is a shortage. In times of abundance we consider some values like physical freedom and freedom of speech as natural. No need to cherish it. Ask Russians how they feel about Russia’s transition to dictatorship over the last 10 years and what that meant for their freedom. Neglected values are very difficult to reclaim.</p><p><em>Difficult to protect</em></p><p>Value — Value attracts villains. Some people try to steal someone else’s catch instead of learning how to fish themselves. And imagine how in our globally connected world a digital vault attracts crooks from all over the world. Who, with digital hammers and chisels, try to break up the vault to take the honey out of the pot.</p><p><em>Difficult to live by</em></p><p>Values — Try positioning yourself in the shoes of a Ukrainian looking into the barrel of a loaded Russian gun. What do you do: shoot first to survive or stick to your principle “Thou shall not kill’. This is an extreme example. But even non life threatening situations can seduce us to abandon our principles. Values often capitulate to needs as many populist politician know so well.</p><p><em>Difficult to discuss</em></p><p>Values — Ever discussed the differences between Christianity and Islam without loud voices or damage to the relation? Discussions about values often include a valuation of one another’s values. Felt by the other as if the valuator claims a moral superior stance. Superiorities are not good for healthy relationships.</p><p>Then there’s another pitfall: blaming the other that (s)he fails to live by his/her own values. It’s another way of saying: “you aren’t allowed to say anything about my values before you live as a shepherd in woolen clothes only eating home grown vegetables.” It’s seldom: “I appreciate how you give more than you take”. Being mild towards the other and oneself, keeping the human dimension in mind, isn’t easy. It’s easier to put a verdict on the other and to find excuses for one’s own behavior. Or better, to dismiss any accountability at all. Trump is a champion at this with many sheep as followers.</p><p>On top of that, It seems that one better gets away with being honest about selfish values, than about altruistic values. “You only donate money to create a better image of yourself!”. Have you ever heard it the other way around? “You only keep your money for yourself because you want to create a bad image!”</p><p><em>Difficult to align</em></p><p>Values — Aligning your personal values ain’t easy. Most people value ‘staying fit’. How to combine this with the value ‘enjoy eating’?</p><p>And is aligning values on a personal level difficult, it’s even more challenging between two or more people, as everybody who is married can tell. Different people, different values. At the same time: aligned values are necessary to collectively fulfill the mission of a community.</p><p><em>Difficult to impose</em></p><p>Values — I taught my children some skills and values. I hope that these values help them to apply their skills wisely. Now it’s out of my hands. I can’t impose values on them. I tried to be a living example whose behavior can be adopted. Who knows if this will happen… (or that it should happen at all).</p><p><em>Difficult to notice, proof and reward</em></p><p>Value — The groundsman of the soccer club, the mother who assists during lunchtime at a primary school or the volunteer firefighter, do their contributions get noticed?</p><p>And let’s say we want to reward the groundsman, the mother and firefighter for their achievements (and not only with a medal after 40 years of honorable service). How to describe their achievements and what is fair? The number of mowed soccer fields, the number of buttered sandwiches or the number of extinguished fires? And how do they prove their achievements? A picture of a mowed soccer field, a child eating a buttered sandwich or a burned-out building?</p><p>And once the achievements are described and the proofs are settled, the gaming of the reward system can begin. Why not set fire to a building, spread an extra sandwich or mow a soccer field twice?</p><p><em>Difficult to share value fairly</em></p><p>Value — Communities struggle to distribute created value fairly (if they even strive for it). Having the key of the treasury or holding power, it’s tempting to use it for your own benefit and for the people close to you: rewarding yourself and your favorites with a bigger share. Telling yourself you all deserve it. How come that people close to funds often have a higher salary?</p><p>And even systems that seem to be fair from a value distribution perspective, like Meritocracy (reward created value), often aren’t: not everybody has the opportunity to create value. Due to a lack of pre-requisites like a full stomach, a starting capital or relatives in powerful positions.</p><p>That are a lot of difficulties. This blog post won’t be the ultimate guide for how to tackle all these problems, might these be ‘tackle-able’ at all. But I will touch on some things DAOs <em>can</em> do. And defining the problem is a good starting point.</p><blockquote>“A mission and its values become a distinguishing feature for a DAO”</blockquote><p><strong>Kinds of added value</strong></p><p>Before I dive into DAOs and how those can support value and values, I first dive with you into communities as value creators and value receivers. ‘Who creates which value to who/what?’</p><p>In the context of a community, I distinguish four kinds of value creation. Delivered added value to:</p><ul><li>External customers</li><li>Fellow members</li><li>The community</li><li>The commons</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/756/1*dUGL5Zmn8UPRqkqTxNv5jw.png" /></figure><p><em>External customers</em></p><p>One or more community members can supply a product or a service to a customer outside of the community. This is how enterprises make money.</p><p><em>Fellow members</em></p><p>Members can also supply a service or product to fellow members a.k.a. internal customers. One member who pours drinks at the bar of a sports club for another member, a HR-manager keeping the files of an employee or a civil servant stamping a passport for an entering civilian (‘members’ of the same nation state).</p><p><em>The community</em></p><p>The community as a whole can be another receiver of value. An army provides protection services to a community called the nation state (sometimes misused as attacking services).</p><p><em>The commons</em></p><p>Then there are the shared facilities, also called commons. Commons are owned by no one and can be used by everyone (more about commons in an upcoming post). Think of roads in the case of a nation state or of a soccer field in the case of a sports club. The value that those commons can get is to realize them in the first place, keep them operational and give them updates.</p><p><em>Member as contributor</em></p><p>A member who delivers value to others, be it an external customer, a fellow member, the community or a common, can also be the receiver of value. This value can be received in several forms. As tokens or reputation points for example. The DAO called ‘<a href="https://fractally.com/">fractally</a>’ has merged tokens and reputation points into one : their token, named ‘Respect’ or ‘R’ for short, is merely based on both the objectively and subjectively determined value a member has added to its community.</p><p>You can read more about how DAOs contribute to these value receivers in the next paragraphs.</p><p><strong>Blockchain’s unique feature</strong></p><p>First a technical intermezzo. A necessary one and a marvelous one. It’s about blockchain’s unique feature. That a digital string, within the boundary of its technical realm, is unique and protected. Secure in the account of the holder. This might not sound special. But compare it to other digital technologies where you can endlessly copy every digital item such as a document, a health record or an e-mail. With copybility you can’t protect IP, will never be sure who is the initial author or if the content is tempered with. Unless there’s an organization or nation state which is in control and thus has all the power. E.g. Facebook, Russia or China.</p><p>But now the relation between digital strings and value creation. Well-known examples of unique and scarce digital strings are Bitcoins and NFTs (non-fungible tokens). Bitcoins are created through hard computation. Bitcoins are digital gold nuggets dug out of the digital earth. This hard work and their scarcity are the reasons for the value of Bitcoin. Not bad um, 40.000 dollars for a row of zeros and ones.</p><p>For NFTs counts that their ‘limited edition of one’ determines their preciousness: no Apes (Bored Ape Yacht Club = BAYC) or Kitties (CryptoKitties) are alike. And might digital Apes and Kitties sound not so special nor valuable to you, although one Ape has been sold for $3,408,000, NFTs that provenly/securely represent a fact or an entity in the physical world might better connect to your understanding. E.g. a birth certificate, a property deed, a bachelor degree or a driving license. Those are nice things to have in your digital wallet. Now you can prove anytime anywhere to everyone when you were born (eligible to buy drinks for example), that a house is yours, or that you master a particular skill like driving a car or doing surgery. All without a the need for a thrusted third party to back up your claim.</p><p>With blockchain you can capture value that was intangible in web2. Every proven deed or right can be rewarded with a unique digital string representing exactly that: a proof of a deed or a right. Now you can’t only build currency systems like bitcoins and collections like the BAYC, but you can also develop registers for certificates, reputation systems and reward systems.</p><p>Kevin Owocki in his recommendable book Greenpilled puts it this way: “with programmed money we can <em>program</em> our <em>values</em> into our <em>money</em>”. I like to make this wonderful phrase a bit more generic: “with <em>tokens</em> we can program our <em>value(s)</em> into our <em>systems</em>”.</p><p>Blockchain’s unique feature ‘securely capturing created value with software’ is its real game changer. Changing <em>all</em> the games we as humans play. Now we’re talking DAOs.</p><blockquote>“With tokens we can program our value(s) into our systems”</blockquote><p><strong>DAOs</strong></p><p>When a community designs a DAO it has, from a value perspective, to ask itself at least three questions:</p><ul><li>“Which value do we want to capture?”</li><li>“How to tackle the value related problems?”</li><li>“Which constructs to use?”</li></ul><p><em>Which value do we want to capture?</em></p><p>For a starter: all the community’s constructs which aim to capture, distribute and exchange value should be a derivative from the community’s mission. Its mission should be the north star for the community’s value system.</p><p>It’s up to the community to decide which member contributions, delivered by an individual or a group, are considered valuable and what to reward. As pointed out before, value can be delivered to external customers, fellow members, the community or the commons. A community can see certain achievements as valuable. But even ‘passive’ contributions can be considered valuable such as just being a member or putting skin in the game.</p><p>Some examples of choices a community can make.</p><p>Example 1 — Does a community see making money as a huge accomplishment and does it want to reward the biggest hoarders with extra governance rights? Or does a community value members who are actively engaged in governance, and does it reward them with reputation points? This example shows that communities can make a choice between an emphasis on more business-like activities (transactions) or more social-like activities (interactions).</p><p>Example 2 — Does a community prevail commitment above contributions without any accountability? To be more specific: does a community not mind that members do ‘community hopping’ or does it reward long lasting memberships considering it as a sign for commitment? Or does a community, yes or no, ask its members to put skin in the game by putting tokens in escrow?</p><p>Example 3 — What does a community consider a real contribution? Attendance (“participated in it”), or an achievement (“delivered it”), or impact (“reached an audience”)?</p><p>The choices a community makes, connects the two types of value to each other: the captured value reflects what a community values.</p><p><em>How to tackle the value related problems?</em></p><p>Once you, as a community, have decided what value you want to capture, you want to do it in a way that works, a way that prevents gaming or even fraud. Let’s go back to problems you might encounter when dealing with value and let’s explore what DAOs can do to counter those problems.</p><p>Problem — A limited view</p><p>A DAO forces you to implement constructs with which you want to capture, distribute and exchange value. These constructs are part of the DAO’s constitution. They thus become subjects of management by members. Members can make proposals (bills) to change these constructs. Bills which are accepted, by majority vote, become the community’s new reality. In this way a community’s value set is a living thing, becoming more adjusted to the needs of a community over time. Blind spots can be patched and unfairnesses pruned. This process should broaden the view of a community on its values.</p><p>Problem — Difficult to specify</p><p>A community <em>must </em>become specific, for at least about the constructs of the DAO that are automated, on which achievements and contributions it is going to reward. A community has to offer clarity to its members: “How can you, as a member or a team, earn or be rewarded?”. By participating in governance? By offering security to the network (like miners do)? By staying a member for a certain period of time? By putting an amount of tokens in deposit?</p><p>Problem — Neglect to cherish</p><p>DAOs have fast feedback loops through their public indicators. This counts for communities that are doing well and for communities that are doing bad alike. For one, the value of a community’s token is an indicator. The higher the value of its token, the higher the community is valued. Another indicator is the number of members, of any kind, and their retention period. How many developers are building software? What’s the number of users? How many are participating in votes or polls? What is the average membership period? So, neglected or well cherished, how values connect to the needs of members can’t be overlooked.</p><p>Problem — Difficult to protect</p><p>Fraud and fraud protection are an arms race. Thus it will always be a challenge to keep digital assets like tokens safe from being stolen. Given the current state of the technology, blockchain is considered safe for a while. No fraudulent adjustment is made to the Bitcoin chain yet for example. Well-known breaches and thefts have occurred on technical and human interfaces. To protect their digital assets DAOs are installing, on top of the blockchain infrastructure, all kinds of constructs that have their counterpart in the physical world. Constructs like black lists, curated registers, token slashing in case of bad behavior or online courts for dispute handling.</p><p>Problem — Difficult to live by</p><p>DAOs offer their members constructs that incentivize or punish them to make decisions with a, for the actor <em>and</em> community, favorable outcome. This makes living by your values probably not always easier. It surely nudges members to do ‘the right’ thing.</p><p>Problem — Difficult to discuss</p><p>DAOs don’t make discussions about values less difficult. Perhaps worse, they challenge members to speak out. DAOs promote dialogues. A first hand example: the pizza payment policy. In a DAO I participate in, we have a monthly meeting. Some members accept their attendance tentatively, others accept straight away. Then on the day of the meeting there are no-shows. So how many pizzas to order? We decided that no-shows have to pay anyway and that accepting tentatively means no pizza will be waiting for you. The discussion on this policy started when members mentioned that the date of the meeting was settled too late to be able to cancel their attendance or that the wrong communication channel was used to inform them. Such discussions reveal values. Discussion which might result in changing a policy. Or not. Such policies aren’t exclusive to DAOs. But with DAOs you have the possibility to automate them in a secure and trusted way. And the coded policy will execute unstoppable. Transparent policies in action, with the possibility to change them, surely trigger discussion.</p><p>Problem — Difficult to align</p><p>A DAO gives its community with a clear mission and clear values, a clear profile. This offers members, both incumbents and newcomers, the opportunity to either align with those values or leave the community. And members don’t have to completely align to each other’s value sets. As long as each member contributes to the community’s mission, everybody benefits.</p><p>Problem — Difficult to impose</p><p>Reward and punish mechanisms are the means by which DAOs impose values upon a community. Earning reputation points through casting a vote on a proposal and a token airdrop for account holders are different reward mechanisms. The first is more subtle than the latter. Communities also can choose, by implementing DAO-mechanisms, to take the stimulating route or the punishing road. Does a community use a curated white list or a blacklist? Does it pay tokens for participating or does it slash a member’s token deposit when he/she is a no-show?</p><p>Problem — Difficult to notice, proof and reward</p><p>Because all automated transactions in a DAO are transparent, those will not stay unnoticed (ever seen a bank that is transparent on all its value transfers?). The next part, a proof of added value, is a real challenge. Especially for things that happened in the real world. It’s up to a community to decide what set of proofs it considers trustworthy. Two examples of sets of proofs a community can adopt as trustworthy enough to give an automatic reward:</p><p>Example 1 — Subsidy on solar panels; an automatic pay out.</p><p>The set of proofs, decided upon by the community, can be: 1) a picture on a certain date of installed solar panels on a roof 2) a deed of ownership of the building 3) an paid invoice of a 4) certified installer.</p><p>Example 2 — Delivered health care; an automatic pay out</p><p>In this case the set of proofs can contain: 1) an App on a device of a healthcare professional which must be unlocked with biometrics (proof = it’s the professional who unlocks the device) 2) a digital handshake between two unlocked devices, one of the patient and one of the healthcare professional, before and after the meeting (proof = patient and professional actually met within a certain time slot) 3) time and GPS coordinates of place of each handshake (proof = meeting on a certain time and place) 4) a review of the patient of the provided care (proof = delivered service).</p><p>Problem — Difficult to share fairly</p><p>What constitutes a fair distribution of value is for the community to decide. It comes down to two questions: “what to share and how to spread it?”. Or should it start with the preceding questions “why share value?” and “why should this be a community decision?”. To start with the preceding ones. DAOs are the result of an up front design process where designers set the possibilities and constraints of what a DAO can or can’t do. And, once live, a DAO’s constitution is subject to member management. So the designers and members have to make choices. Therefore is value distribution a community decision. And even “each one for him/herself” can be a shared decision that says “If someone can lay his hands on something it belongs to him.” Some communities consider this fair. However, such a decision will inevitably lead to power concentration and often to the end of a DAO.</p><p>What’s happening in the US is an example of this: the right of the richest. As richman you are able to finance an army of lawyers, lawmakers and lawmen. Lawyers to keep you out of jail, lawmakers to set the rules you want to play by and lawmen who mold the rules in your favor. Oh, and you also need to buy communication channels or its anchors, telling how your wealth is benefiting ordinary people (probably put in other words). If money overpowers the checks and balances of the US law system, the US will become destructive to itself.</p><p>What to share?</p><p>An obvious thing to share for a DAO are the tokens it uses for value storage and value exchange. But there’s more to share than tokens. Rights and chances for example.</p><p>What to share — Value storage</p><p>Most DAOs have a token for value storage. These tokens might start as a share in the DAO and later become ‘liquid’ and turn into a means for payment. That makes them a nice thing to have and thus to distribute.</p><p>What to share — Rights</p><p>DAOs are more and more coming down to ‘the right to’ instead of owning. That means that rights are the stuff that should be shared fairly. One type of rights are access rights. The right to participate in transactions for example and thereby having the opportunity to earn value. DAOs as lands of great opportunities.</p><p>Another right is the ‘right to decide’. There’s value in having influence, to have the possibility to turn things your way. Might that be turning to a better fulfillment of your needs or coming closer to your vision.</p><p>An often applied right in blockchains is the ‘right to service’. Nodes that have staked a lot of tokens or have a high percentage of community support, can be rewarded with a high frequency right to validate transactions and forge blocks. Each forged block earns them an amount of tokens.</p><p>What to share — Chances</p><p>Reputation is not shareable in the sense that you can transfer it from one holder to another. Reputation is bound to a specific holder which can be a person or an entity. But the <em>chance</em> to build and to use a reputation, could be shared equally among community members. Getting a medal shouldn’t be an old boys network thing, where members nominate each other. Nor should your family name be a prerequisite for getting a job. A lot of people do like prestige and standing. Every community member should have an equal chance to achieve and use it.</p><blockquote>“But there’s more to share than tokens. Rights and chances for example.”</blockquote><p>How to spread value — Source</p><p>First of all, where does the value you want to share come from? Most likely from two sources: from the community’s treasury or from the protocol. The community’s treasury could have been filled through profits which are the surplus of generated revenues out of services for customers. Another source for the treasury is ‘tax’. A small fee of every transaction can be tapped as VAT (Value Added Tax). This tapped fee can flow to the community’s treasury.</p><p>The community’s protocol can also be a source of minting tokens or reputation points. When proofs and a public key are supplied, the protocol will automatically mint tokens or reputation points and transfer those to a certain wallet. If this then that.</p><p>The tokens within the treasury can also be automatically dispersed, through a certain coded scheme. Another option is by community decision.</p><p>How to spread value</p><p>DAOs can provide their members a range of constructs for value distribution. It’s up to the community which constructs it considers fair. Let’s explore some.</p><ol><li>Token holding based distribution</li></ol><p>This type of distribution is based on the amount of tokens a holder has. The more tokens you have the bigger the share you receive from the pie. Compare this to shareholders receiving an amount of dividend that reflects their number of shares.</p><p>2. Achievement based distribution</p><p>A community can register the achievements of its members. How many positive customer scores one received for example. Think of a review of an Uber driver or a Airbnb host. High reviews can result in the right to hold your Uber license or in Airbnb points which give discounts when you as a host decide to become a guest yourself. This is like sales people being rewarded with regard to their KPI scores (key performance indicators).</p><p>3. Reputation based distribution</p><p>A member’s reputation can be taken as a factor for the distribution of value. More <a href="https://www.kudos.com/"><em>kudos</em></a> mean more tokens from the ‘pot’ or more rights for a member.</p><p>4. Membership based distribution</p><p>Just being a member can also be the leading distribution criterion. Every member can be granted the same decision rights (one-man-one-vote) or the same amount of tokens. The latter is like a universal basic income (UBI) or free health care or free education for all.</p><p><em>Which constructs to use to capture, distribute or exchange value?</em></p><p>In the text above, I gave some examples of constructs DAOs can apply to capture, distribute or exchange value. Below are some closing notes about constructs.</p><p>Constructs — More than token engineering</p><p>Token engineering is the magic word for decentralized applications (Dapps). Token engineering is about designing and building the tokens a Dapp is going to use, how these tokens can be obtained and which functions each token is going to have. Capturing, distributing or exchanging value includes tokens but there’s more. A DAO is in its core a value system. Thus for all the constructs of a DAO the question should be asked and answered “how to incorporate value(s)?” Whether the construct is a decision making mechanism, a reputation system or a construct for dispute handling.</p><p>Constructs — Value is more than constructs</p><p>DAOs aim to automate their constructs to the max. At the same time there are limits to automation and there must be human involvement for the human touch. There are some touch points between the automated part and the human part of DAOs. Parts that can’t be 100% automated but that do reflect the community’s values and can steer human behavior. Examples are a community’s vision, its mission and its constitution.</p><p>The vision and mission are the boss of a DAO. These live on while members can come and go. These uber memes should be carved in ‘digital stone’ and should be the inspiring uber values of a community. Again Kalipo’s vision and mission as examples:</p><ul><li>Kalipo’s vision: <em>“Making earth a super place to live by supporting consciousness into collective caring action”</em></li><li>Kalipo’s mission: <em>Support communities in creating value in accordance with their own defined values”</em></li></ul><p>With our vision and mission we broadcast the values we cherish: take action, create a better place, collectiveness, taking care of, create value, define your own values. A vision and mission can inspire but can’t enforce like DAO constructs can.</p><p>What’s in or out of a DAO’s constitution is also a value choice. E.g. Does a DAO have a dispute handling construct and, if yes, what does it look like?</p><p>Constructs — Co-govern</p><p>Fix values are the beginning of the end of a DAO. The constructs of a DAO are never perfect, the outside world will change and so will the needs of the members. If a DAO’s constructs stay the same, connection to the outside world and its members will go astray. Therefore it’s important to put the constructs under member management to be able, at any moment, to set, imbed and adjust values by community decision.</p><p>Constructs — (New) ways to earn</p><p>Especially from a member perspective, DAOs can offer interesting new ways to earn value. Two examples.</p><p>Example 1 — Play to earn</p><p>Playing and working are getting blended. The term ‘serious gaming’ has been around for some time. New is the term ‘play to earn’. <a href="https://axieinfinity.com/">Axie Infinity</a> was one of the first games through which gamers could earn a living. “What’s, for a community, the value of playing?”, you might ask. In the case of Axie Infinity gamers can obtain digital assets like a digital character, a digital piece of land or digital potion to feed and breed. These digital assets are tradeable within Axie Infinity. Other players, circumventing the hard work of playing, can buy these assets thus reaching a higher level. Buyers pay with tokens. These tokens can be exchanged on secondary markets for euros for example. See here, the income for a player. Now he can buy bread or pay his rent.</p><p>Further fantasizing about the idea of play-to-earn, the value for the community created by playing can be almost anything. For example, every bug discovered in the DAO’s code is valuable. Why not turn this into a game? Every discovered bug can be rewarded with a token. Who wins the most tokens?</p><p>Example 2 — Learn to earn<br>Some communities crave for skilled members. Members with a needed skill set mean value for the community. <a href="https://academy.binance.com/en/learn-and-earn">Binance</a> for example rewards people who pass a crypto exam with tokens. Tokens that can be exchanged for fiat currency. Yet another earning model for members.</p><p>Constructs — New services</p><p>Along with new ways of earning, new services appear on DAOs.</p><p>Let me start with Blockchain infrastructure services because those are not always understood. What kind of services does a blockchain infrastructure offer to its community? And how are those different from what more classic IT-infrastructure services do? The services of both types of infrastructures process and store information. But blockchain does it without one party owning the system. The Blockchain infrastructure offers data processing and storage services that are secure, autonomous (if this then that), robust and transparent, all without a single organization controlling the system.</p><p>Now back to DAOs. DAOs support communities. So what can be services that communities, acting in a digital environment, are in need of? Some examples of what they might be longing for: on boarding, predictions, curation.</p><p>Example 1 — On boarding</p><p>Due to the current state of the technology, decentralized application (Dapps) have their usability issues such as long and unreadable private keys and wallets as entry points. Once the access barrier is overcome, most DApps are not much different from their cousin apps built with non-blockchain technology. But users might appreciate an introduction into the functionality of a DAO; an intro in how to make a proposal, how to vote, or how to comprehend the state of the treasury. How nice it would be if someone offered an onboarding service which helps passing the access hurdles and makes first-time users acquainted with DAO-functionality. Paying users will be the proof for the need for such a service.</p><p>Example 2 — Predictions</p><p>Accurate predictions of future events are valuable: “what is going to happen on the stock market?” or “what will the weather be next week?”. A prediction that comes true can earn you a lot of money or save you from rained-out holidays. Welcome to the prediction markets where users can bet on the probability that an event will occur (see <a href="https://augur.net/">Augur</a> for an example). These markets tap into the wisdom of the crowd. Research reveals that a lot of people betting on an upcoming event usually beat the prediction of an expert. Communities, each with its specific information needs, might profit from such a prediction service.</p><p>Example 3 — Curation</p><p>Registers which entries that are scored against certain criteria, are valuable. Take a registry of organizations or people in a particular industry. Organizations or people with a hallmark in such a register are more likely to receive orders than organizations or people without. And Wikipedia is trusted because the content of its pages is thoroughly checked and modified by the community. Curated high quality registers are valuable. This opens the door for people earning tokens with curation services.</p><p>Construct — Challenges</p><p>The above text might suggest that I‘m a techno optimist and/or naive in what digital constructs can do for capturing, distributing or exchanging value. I’m very aware of the limitations of technology and that we still have a lot to learn. So let me conclude with some challenges we face.</p><p>Each construct has its pros and cons. By specifying requirements first, each candidate construct can be scored against those criteria. Only then a well-reasoned choice can be made, knowing that the chosen construct probably won’t solve all issues.</p><p>Constructs are often a trade-off between function and elegance (meaning usability). Constructs that are complex can expect a low adoption from users, although they might cover the requirements regarding to functionality very well. But you can’t expect miracles from simple constructs like a reputation system that has only a five star rating possibility. But no reputation system might be worse. How do you book your vacation? After reading reviews perhaps?</p><p>Sooner or later a construct will be gamed. Users are going to manipulate a construct in their favor. Think of a reputation system where you can endorse somebody (and where an endorsement is profitable). People might ‘buy’ each other’s endorsements: “I think you’re a great person, how do you like me?”</p><p>The above challenges make even more clear why a community should place its constructs under the governance of its members. This makes adjustments to their needs, based on learning experiences, possible. DAOs should apply fast learning loops for the best fit to ever changing circumstances and to counter attack gaming.</p><p>Be specific on values, build them into constructs and share value fairly ain’t easy. It’s never going to be. Nor with DAOs. But DAOs do broaden the possibilities.</p><blockquote>“DAOs should apply fast learning loops for the best fit to ever changing circumstances and to counter attack gaming.”</blockquote><p><strong>Wrap up</strong></p><p>I started this blog by stating that successful communities are able to create real value for their members. I also addressed a second, conditional element of successful communities: having clear values by which members are strongly aligned. This blog continued with the statement that it’s up to each community to specify its own value set and to install constructs to support those values. Then I named some challenges that come with specifying and applying values.</p><p>In an intermezzo I first shared some thoughts about several kinds of added value. Followed by a highlight on how blockchain’s unique feature, guaranteeing that digital strings are unique, offers the necessary building block for capturing, distributing and exchanging value.</p><p>The last part was about DAOs and how their constructs can tackle the challenges we face when handling value.</p><p>Constructs don’t build communities. A sense of belonging, rooted in a shared value-driven vision and mission, does. But constructs that incorporate the capturing, distribution and exchange of value can be very supportive, although all have pros and cons and flaws. Those constructs should be put under the governance of members.</p><p>Starting this blog post, I didn’t know where it would end. Now it has come to an end I realize there’s an awful lot more to discover. Happy for that. This makes DAOs so exciting for me.</p><p><strong>Next blog</strong></p><p>The next blog post, #5, is called ‘The art of decision making’. This post is about decision making, about how voting is only a part of a decision making process, about several voting mechanisms and about which elements a voting mechanism can consist of. DAOs make decision making easier, richer and more effective. Exciting topic!</p><p><strong>Invite</strong></p><p>I hope for a lot of reactions on my blog posts. To share thoughts and to sharpen each other’s visions. And perhaps, DAO-like, to walk along together and to work together.</p><p>Let’s make this world a better place together. Let’s create as much prosperity and well being for as many people as possible. While keeping the environment sustainable at the same time. So see this blog series as an invite. Maybe one day you will be joining the community of DAOnauts.</p><p><strong>Before you go</strong></p><p>I n case you got value out of this read, I encourage you to <strong>click the</strong> 👏<strong>button</strong> and <strong>hold it down to 20–50 claps</strong> as this will help DAOs, Kalipo and me to get more exposure.</p><p><strong>Links</strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/dao-3-its-all-about-power-869ac4221960">DAOs #3 — It’s all about power</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-2b-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-5d0147b90585?source=your_stories_page----------------------------------------">DAOs #2b — A new game: for the community, by the community</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419?source=your_stories_page----------------------------------------">DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-1-communities-make-the-world-go-round-2fa98dbaaa05?source=your_stories_page----------------------------------------">DAOs #1 — Communities make the world go round</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-0-how-to-we-all-can-benefit-from-blockchain-a-blog-series-9d4d6bcd67f8?source=your_stories_page----------------------------------------">DAOs #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series</a></p><blockquote>Join Coinmonks<a href="https://t.me/coincodecap"> Telegram Channel</a> and<a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/coinmonks/videos"> Youtube Channel</a> learn about crypto trading and investing</blockquote><h3>Also, Read</h3><ul><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/ftx-futures-trading">How to trade Futures on FTX Exchange</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/okex-vs-binance"> OKEx vs Binance</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/okex-kucoin">OKEx vs KuCoin</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/celsius-alternatives"> Celsius Alternatives</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/buy-vechain"> How to Buy VeChain</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/profitfarmers-review">ProfitFarmers Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/cornix-trading-bot"> How to use Cornix Trading Bot</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/buy-bitcoin-anonymously">How to buy Bitcoin Anonymously</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/bitcoin-cash-wallets"> Bitcoin Cash Wallets</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/wazirx-nft-review">WazirX NFT Review</a> | <a href="https://coincodecap.com/bitsgap-vs-pionex">Bitsgap vs Pionex</a> | <a href="https://coincodecap.com/tangem-wallet-review">Tangem Review</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81d90f5dfeb2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-4-shared-value-s-81d90f5dfeb2">DAOs #4 — Shared value(s)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DAOs #3 — It’s all about power]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/dao-3-its-all-about-power-869ac4221960?source=rss-49425f40625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/869ac4221960</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lisk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kalipo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Nobels]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Mar 2022 15:55:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-26T08:46:35.736Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>DAOs #3 — It’s all about power</p><p><strong>This Blog</strong></p><p>This post goes to the heart of the distributed way of working and thinking. In this post I make the claim that the mechanisms that make blockchains robust and censorship resistant, can be applied to DAOs. I particularly zoom in on mechanisms for power distribution, balancing and coordination. With these mechanisms communities become more effective, fair and hufter proof.</p><p>This blog post is part of a series of posts, a blogchain. This series is about DAOs (Decentralized Autonomous Organizations) in general and Kalipo in particular. Kalipo is a platform on which communities can establish their own tailormade DAO. DAOs are the next step in collaboration, governance and value distribution.</p><p><strong>Message</strong></p><ul><li>Power concentration is not robust, not hufter proof</li><li>Well distributed, balanced and coordinated power make healthy communities.</li><li>DAOs, by making use of and inspired by blockchain, can be an ultimate ‘powertool’.</li></ul><p><strong>Intro</strong></p><p>I don’t want to waste your time. So, you can stop reading if you see one of the following solutions as a way to a better world: strongmen, a surveillance society, capitalism or total individual freedom. All examples of centralized and/or unbalanced power.</p><p><em>Why this post now?</em></p><p>I intended to write about power in relation to DAOs later on in this blog post series. Actual developments made me change my mind. The war in Ukraine is for me <em>the</em> example of how power concentration can lead to horrible things. One person who is literally calling the shots with devastating consequences for millions. Is this war proof that all kinds of power concentration will lead to bad outcomes? A single example is not evidence, but I still believe that power concentration is a slippery road to abuse and will inevitably cause harm.</p><p><em>What is it, this issue with power?</em></p><p>In a previous blog post, I stated ‘a single point of power is a single point of failure’. SPOP = SPOF. Power concentration is not robust, not antifragile. Power concentrations are also vulnerable for deliberate attacks. SPOP = SPOF = SPOA (single point of attack). It’s easier to kill an anteater than an ant population.</p><p>But we can’t leave power alone. Power is an essential tool for getting things done. But this tool has the habit of turning on the ones holding the tool. Without counter powers, the holder will be overpowered by power. Because power is tempting. It offers a shortcut to reach one’s goals. No need to convince others or build coalitions, no need to work hard, no need to take the feelings, interests and needs of others into account. Just grab a piece of land, a piece of the market or someone’s belongings. Survival of the strongest, all with the argument that you have to protect your own interests. Turning power from a tool into a weapon.</p><blockquote>“Is power a sword by which we always be cut?”</blockquote><p>There are many means of power: money, weapons, resources, knowledge, tools for production, a coalition of actors and control over the narrative. Especially the last one is very dangerous: abuse of power under cover of a false story that is believed by those colluding with the abuser or even by those harmed by the abuser. Some people are very skilled in selling lies. Getting power and personal benefits in return. Whistle blowers are outcasted as traitors or as too stupid to choose not to profit. The ‘clients’ of those ‘salesmen in lies’ are mostly unaware that they co-create a monster by their ignorance, indifference or by wanting to profit by this abuse of power themselves. This monster creates more liars because lies keep the monster satisfied and in check. The Republican’s Big Lie only will die when people stop feeding it.</p><p>But the monster, having first feeded on opponents, will at some moment start eating the ones who feed it. Humans are great at creating beasts that hurt them.</p><p>Power asks for courage. Not only for using the power only as a tool for the right cause, but also for not using it. For resisting the temptation to use it for shortcuts, for personal gains at the expense of others. That amount of courage is too big of a task for most of us. There are not so many Herculeses.</p><p>Not exerting power is equally dangerous too. Power will come to haunt you. Sheep attract wolves. Wolves don’t play by the rules of compassion but by the rules of power. Their end justifies all means and their end is to satisfy their selfish needs. Eating sheep is their daily business.</p><p>Is power a sword by which we always be cut?</p><p><em>Organizing power, a challenge</em></p><p>Power concentration isn’t only the result of indifference or of ‘giving power away’ (and hoping to free ride on the efforts of others). It also happens because power is difficult to organize. While organizing power, by combining small forces, is needed to protect personal interests and to achieve greater goals.</p><p>Individuals need collective action, because how can you as an individual stand up against stronger forces than yourself? How to dare to speak out loud when there’s a chance of imprisonment? Ask Russians or Chinese. They are, as far as speech is concerned, serfs who only say what their landlord allows them to say. But how could they achieve a greater goal like changing the current system or establishing another system? How can individuals stand up together against the existing powers that be?</p><p>Houston, we have a problem: we don’t want power concentration but we don’t have the proper tools to organize distributed power for a shared purpose either.</p><p>That was until 2009.</p><p><strong>Power</strong></p><p><em>Power on a technology level</em></p><p>A solution for how distributed power can be turned into collective action without a central commander, came from a surprising side: technology. More accurate, from blockchain.</p><p>Satoshi Nakamoto offered in 2009 an unhackable data processing solution based on distributed computers. He coined the name blockchain for this solution. Blockchain is also called the trust machine. One trust producing element of blockchain is that data is cryptographically secured in its ledger. But there’s another element as well: power distribution. No single computer, called a node, can maliciously change the code or the data on its own. But together the nodes will act as a single force, processing and storing data according to the rules of the game, the blockchain’s protocol. The protocol is the invisible coordinator of an ant heap. A wonderful implementation of how small units fulfill a common task.</p><p>In the first paragraph I named some means of power: money, weapons, resources, knowledge, tools for production, a coalition of actors and control over the narrative. Blockchains contain the IT equivalent of these means:</p><ul><li>Tokens (money)</li><li>Reward/punish systems (weapons)</li><li>Data (resources)</li><li>Nodes (tools for production)</li><li>Access to data (knowledge)</li><li>Timestamped secured data with a digital signature (control over the narrative).</li></ul><p>With blockchain these means won’t fall in the hands of one who can abuse it. How the different blockchains implement these means of power, is a check of how distributed and how effective they are. Some examples:</p><ul><li>Have the tokens been distributed over many token holders or does the purchasing power belong to a few?</li><li>Are there enough nodes with equal chances to be rewarded (in blockchain terms: “is there enough distributed hashing power”)?</li><li>How well is the data secured?</li><li>How open is the access to the data and to the use of the blockchain’s functionality?</li></ul><p>The magic of blockchains is not how distributed these are. The magic is how blockchains, by their protocols, achieve to coordinate and use their distributed elements for collective, predictable and secured action.</p><p>Can we install the mechanisms that make blockchains a coordination-miracle within DAOs?</p><p><em>Power in general</em></p><p>I will jump onto ‘how to distribute and coordinate power within DAOs’ later. First some thoughts about power distribution, power balance and power coordination in general.</p><p>If you have read my previous blog posts, you might have noticed that I like to take communities as the simplest ‘units of collaboration‘. Communities which can have labels like ‘team’, ‘neighborhood or ‘board of directors’. They are the collaboration legos for bigger organizational constellations like companies, branches or societies. Following this point of view, power should be soundly implemented on the level of communities and within every community. When you don’t bake power into the dough of a community, the pie will be eaten by a few. Leaving the crumbles to the rest.</p><p><em>Power balance</em></p><p>‘Baking power into communities’ is not just about distributing power, it’s also about balancing power. Communities, with all their means of power, should keep a homeostasis. Their swinging power pendulum should stay within limits, keeping the community in the zone of viability. Separated powers, like attracting and repelling magnets, take care of this dynamic equilibrium.</p><p>There are many ways to look at a community’s power balance. Through the lens of the trias politica for example or through the lens of ‘liberalism — socialism — democratism’. The classic economical lens of ‘capital — labor’ offers another view on power balance.</p><p>In this post I put on the glasses of ‘business — government — individuals’. Looking through each of the three facets of these glasses, different values for a community are shown:</p><ul><li>Business: creating value.</li><li>Government: protecting individuals, distributing value and keeping the community on track of its mission.</li><li>Individuals: individual contributions to value creation and profiting from created value.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/614/0*ZKRNzvtBa5vDBu1d" /></figure><p>Business, government and individuals are power structures on their own. A balance between these power structures contributes to healthy communities. An imbalance makes parties suffer. Too much power for the government turns communities into dictatorships. Too much power for individuals results in an anarchy. Too much power for business is the road to a monopoly. Nor dictatorships nor anarchies nor monopolies reflect a healthy community.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*aDKSLim6W2JA1_M9" /></figure><p>Balancing these power structures is not an easy task. As humans we know this by experience. We excel in ignoring tipping points, also named Schelling points. We like to let one power structure push a system over its edge. We orchestrate our own Phoenixes. We are better at making communities clash and collapse and at bloody revolutions, than at evolutions. Look what’s happening in Ukraine.</p><p>DAOs might offer a solution.</p><p><strong>DAOs and power</strong></p><p>The goal of DAOs is to reach a common mission, to generate as much added value for all with the least effort and resources and with as few bad externalities as possible. The DAO-way, from a power perspective, is to achieve that by power distribution, power balance and power coordination. With blockchains as a source of inspiration.</p><p><em>DAOs &amp; power distribution</em></p><p>Let’s zoom in on what means of power a DAO could and should distribute. Let’s take the list of the means of power from the first paragraph and look at some examples of how DAOs settle the distribution of means of power.</p><p><strong>Tokens as means of value transfer and value storage (money)</strong> — There is no unique way by which DAOs have implemented token distribution. And there’s surely no central entity distributing tokens. To start with: for DAOs built on a public blockchain, anyone has the possibility to buy or earn tokens. There’s no threshold. So token spreading happens through ‘appeal’ and making people invest and contribute. Then there are mechanisms, as part of the DAO’s protocol, like bonding curves. Bonding curves are automated mechanisms for minting, selling, bonding and buying back tokens. Bonding curves can be seen as automated market makers. Bonding curves distribute tokens like any other market through ‘demand and supply’.</p><p><strong>Reward/punish systems </strong>— Reward/punish systems are part of a DAO’s protocol. The protocol is under management of all DAO members. That makes these systems distributed by governance: members co-decide how their reward/punish system should operate. There’s no single rewarder or punisher making decisions based on its personal benchmark. No single ‘authority’ who declares by decree that someone can be <em>put in</em> prison for 15 years, for calling ‘a war a war’.</p><p><strong>Resources</strong> — The main resource for most DAOs is their data. Especially transaction data (DAOs don’t have extensive data of members and customers. They have just public key related data). Because all the DAO’s data is on the blockchain, its data is public and thus distributed by architecture.</p><p>And as far as other resources are concerned, they are under collective governance. Resources are shared facilities, commons. There’s no ownership. And without ownership there are no individuals with exclusive control over resources (although there’s still the possibility for individuals to privately own resources that aren’t under management of a DAO). DAO’s only have a need to distribute the access rights to these resources fairly among their members. That’s a governance challenge.</p><p><strong>Tools for production</strong> — The DAO’s production tool is foremost its distributed IT-infrastructure, based on blockchain. From a distributed point of view this is a tick in the box.</p><p><strong>Knowledge </strong>— All members have access to the same data. Data is free to flow, anyone can tap it. Data distribution will happen to the extent to which parties collect this data to build their information position. There’s no build-in information asymmetry.</p><p><strong>Control over the narrative</strong> — All members of a DAO can produce data by participating in transactions. This generated data will be time stamped and has the digital signature of the transaction parties on it. And once data is registered, no-one can change it afterwards. People can make up a lot of stories based on this data but can’t change the data itself. Nor can they dispute the moment that data was created, the transaction parties that were involved, by which smart contract the data was generated and what data was used as input. DAOs block individual control over the ‘data building blocks’ of narratives. A blockchain is also a fake news and censor <em>blocking</em> chain.</p><p>A final remark on power distribution. DAOs tend to decentralize more and more over time, often by a chosen strategy. This phenomenon is called progressive decentralization. The story then starts with a small team of experts establishing a DAO and having exclusive governance rights. As the story of the DAO unfolds and the number of members grows, power gets diluted by granting governance rights to newbies. In DAOs founders don’t exit by selling the lot to the highest bidder, hoping to cash big, but through an ‘exit to the community’ by handing out governance rights. A DAO is like a child fostered by a group of people. So it will not only survive but thrive on the world wide web.</p><blockquote>“The ways you can distribute, balance and organize power, is what made me fall in love with DAOs.”</blockquote><p><em>DAOs &amp; power balance</em></p><p>A power balance doesn’t come by every DAO out-of-the-box. DAO designers and engineers have to design and build power balance into the DAO. And users should consciously look and choose for rightly and tightly balanced DAOs. Below are some mechanisms that DAOs could implement.</p><p><strong>Self sovereign identities (SSI)</strong> — SSI, which means that individuals own and manage their own data, is an inseparable part of DAOs. Within DAOs each individual, also called a token holder, has an account which contains his/her tokens and transaction results. Through SSI DAOs restore the power balance in the triangle ‘business — government — individuals’ (see previous paragraph). In Web2 business and governments grabbed the power. In the western world business has seized power. More precisely BigTech. Even more precisely: the big five a.k.a. MAMAA (Meta, Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon). Do you have data in a cloud that doesn’t belong to one of these parties? In the eastern part of the world governments have taken over. In China, Russia or Turkey this blog post could put me in prison. DAOs are meant to empower you as an individual, not to tap and sell your data, violate your privacy or follow your digital where-abouts.</p><p><strong>Multi role</strong> — For me one of the most spectacular ways of power distribution within DAOs is that individuals play all three roles: the investor role, the decision maker role and the role of participant. Within DAOs business, government and individuals become ‘one’. It’s no more capital against labor or politics against constituents. A token holder has three souls in one body.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/466/0*lcmhZt3cH7UfB34f" /></figure><p>An example shines light on how these roles blend in DAOs.</p><p><em>I’m a member of the DAO Hub (see blog post ‘DAO #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series’). We, as members, decided to organize a DAO-event. And, which should not come as a surprise, to use a DAO as the organizational structure. We started the establishment of the DAO ‘DAO Hub club event’ with a seeding round. During this phase we all invested an amount of money, hoping to profit from future revenues coming from ticket sales. We gave ourselves a club token in return which represents a share in our DAO ‘DAO Hub club event’. This made us all investors (we’re busy getting other </em><strong><em>investors</em></strong><em> interested to throw some money at this event as well). Our club tokens, DHubs, have governance rights. We are now, as </em><strong><em>decision makers</em></strong><em>, in the middle to submit and vote on proposals for our event. One proposal is about the program and format of the event. Another proposal is about the height of the presenter’s fee. Because we’re all experts on DAOs, most of us will be speakers at the event ourselves. As speakers we play the third role, the role of </em><strong><em>participant</em></strong><em>. See how roles blend? Notice also how capital (investing) and labor (organizing and presenting) come together in one person.</em></p><p><strong>Freedom to choose </strong>— The possibility to enter or leave a DAO is another power balancing mechanism. It offers actors the possibility to change the balance of the scale of power. When actors are able to ‘vote with the feed’, they can empower a DAO with a membership and disempower them by quitting. DAOs should, through their architecture, make it as easy as possible to come and go. E.g by allowing individuals to keep their data when they leave. Data as a take away commodity. One step further is that a DAO connects to one’s personal data store. Even when this data store isn’t built by the DAO itself.</p><p>Actors only have a real freedom to leave if there are serious alternatives. Here shines a unique feature of DAOs: forking. Every group of actors, maybe unhappy with their current DAO, can make a copy of a DAO’s software and start one of their own! How many people would choose for the ‘Putin DAO’? How many people would like to fork the ‘Russian DAO’?</p><p><em>DAOs &amp; power coordination</em></p><p>Power balance and power coordination are entangled like particles under the law of quantum mechanics. After all, how do you weigh distributed powers when they are brought together? That being said: the prism of power coordination might reveal new insights.</p><p>What is coordination about? In short: decision making, resource allocation and (collective) action. With fast learning loops. In this blog I’ll focus on decision making</p><p>While DAOs could and should learn from blockchains, it’s good to know where they differ. One difference is that a blockchain’s consensus mechanism is not the same as group decision making. Although the nodes of a blockchain collectively seem to come to the decision whether a transaction is valid yes or no, it’s actually distributed verification. All nodes verify if transactions comply with preprogrammed rules. And while the rules of a decision making process are fixed within DAOs, the members are free to vote in favor or against a proposal, based on their own judgment. Actors aren’t preprogrammed (although some countries try to achieve this).</p><p>Now some DAO power coordination tricks.</p><p><strong>Digitization </strong>— DAOs excel in the coordination of power though digitization. Digitization offers members easy access (“vote from the couch”) and instant and trusted execution (ITTT = if this then that). DAOs remove friction in coordination to the max.</p><p><strong>Different issues, different decision making</strong> — Decision making is often seen as a trade off between speed and quality with always a bad outcome: honoring the need for speed could be the road to autocracy; choosing for quality through participatory inclusiveness can stalemate communities. But not all decisions have equal impact and not all decisions have to be rooted in a broad knowledge base. DAOs can give us right-sized democracy. A fast lane with enough quality when possible, a quality approach with enough speed when necessary. On Kalipo, our DAO-platform, the constitution of each DAO prescribes what kind of decision making will be used for what kind of issue. With each decision making process optimized for speed <em>and</em> quality.</p><p><strong>Tokens with governance rights</strong> — As shown in the DAO-event example, tokens can have governance rights. Which especially means: the right to vote. A vote is a coordination mechanism because it collects the consolidated will of the members. Remark: there’s a scala of vote procedures and mechanisms. A vote mechanism should, from a power balance point of view, organize the say of community members fairly. It should weigh votes and balance them against each other. And it should take the interests, reputation scores and number of shares of all parties into account. An acrobatic balancing act in fairness and decisiveness. More on the art of voting in next posts.</p><blockquote>“Can DAOs help us to fight off the Putins of our planet?”</blockquote><p><strong>Wrap up</strong></p><p>In this blog post I looked at DAOs through the lens of power. I started with the challenges that come with the use of power. Challenges were we can’t run away from. Then I shone a light on power in general, then on how power is implemented in blockchains and last on how power could be handled in DAOs. More accurately: how you could distribute, balance and organize power with DAOs, making them less prone to the abuse of power and more effective and fair at the same time.</p><p>The ways you can distribute, balance and organize power, is what made me fall in love with DAOs. How about you? Do they for you equal hype and false hope? Do you see DAOs just an avenue for more revenue for a few (investor DAOs)? Or did you get a taste for DAOs as the next step in collaboration, governance and value distribution. DAOs as an alternative for strongmen, a surveillance society, capitalism or total individual freedom? DAOs to help us to fight off the Putins of our planet?</p><p>Disclaimer: DAOs alone don’t do it. First and foremost, it is the members who determine the success. And, although guard railed by the DAO, each member has also the challenge of fighting off his or her internal Putin.</p><p><strong>Next blog post</strong></p><p>The next blog post, #4, is called ‘DAOs — Shared value(s)’. This post is about all kinds of views on value. E.g. DAOs as a community of values, earning by value creation and maintenance of values. Keep posted!</p><p><strong>Invite</strong></p><p>I hope for a lot of reactions on my blog posts. To share thoughts and to sharpen each other’s visions. And perhaps, DAO-like, to walk along together and to work together.</p><p>Let’s make this world a better place together. Let’s create as much prosperity and well being for as many people as possible. While keeping the environment sustainable at the same time. So see this blog series as an invite. Maybe one day you will be joining the community of DAOnauts.</p><p><strong>Before you go</strong></p><p>In case you got value out of this read, I encourage you to <strong>click the</strong> 👏<strong>button</strong> and <strong>hold it down to 20–50 claps</strong> as this will help me, DAOs and Kalipo to get more exposure.</p><p><strong>Links to previous and next posts</strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-2b-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-5d0147b90585">DAOs #2b — A new game: for the community, by the community</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-1-communities-make-the-world-go-round-2fa98dbaaa05">DAOs #1 — Communities make the world go round</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-0-how-to-we-all-can-benefit-from-blockchain-a-blog-series-9d4d6bcd67f8">DAOs #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series</a></p><blockquote>Join Coinmonks<a href="https://t.me/coincodecap"> Telegram Channel</a> and<a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/coinmonks/videos"> Youtube Channel</a> learn about crypto trading and investing</blockquote><h3>Also, Read</h3><ul><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/5-best-crypto-trading-bots-in-canada">Best Crypto Trading bots in Canada</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/kucoin-review"> KuCoin Review</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/huobi-crypto-trading-signals">Crypto Trading Signals for Huobi</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/hitbtc-review-c5143c5d53c2"> HitBTC Review</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/ftx-futures-trading">How to trade Futures on FTX Exchange</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/okex-vs-binance"> OKEx vs Binance</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/okex-kucoin">OKEx vs KuCoin</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/celsius-alternatives"> Celsius Alternatives</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/buy-vechain"> How to Buy VeChain</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/profitfarmers-review">ProfitFarmers Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/cornix-trading-bot"> How to use Cornix Trading Bot</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=869ac4221960" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/dao-3-its-all-about-power-869ac4221960">DAOs #3 — It’s all about power</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DAOs #2b — A new game: for the community, by the community]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-2b-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-5d0147b90585?source=rss-49425f40625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5d0147b90585</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kalipo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lisk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Nobels]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Mar 2022 18:40:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-26T08:50:18.510Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>DAOs #2b — A new game: for the community, by the community</p><p><strong>This Blog</strong></p><p>This blog post is the second and last of two about the theme ‘how communities can flourish by installing the do’s of effective self-management’. Practicing these do’s need the use of a DAO.</p><p>This blog post is part of a series of posts, a blogchain. This series is about DAOs (Decentralized Autonomous Organizations) in general and Kalipo in particular. Kalipo is a platform on which communities can establish their own tailormade DAO. DAOs are the next step in collaboration, governance and value distribution.</p><p><strong>Message</strong></p><ul><li>There’s a new game for better collaboration, governance and value distribution</li><li>This game has the following do’s: co-govern, aligned incentives, attention for transactions &amp; interactions, polycentrism, frictionlessness, trusted transparency, fast learning loops and new tools (technology and mechanisms).</li><li>With DAOs we finally have a tool to practice these do’s efficiently.</li><li>DAOs open the door to new mechanisms for effective self-management.</li></ul><p><strong>Intro</strong></p><p>The previous blog post, <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a>, was an introduction into a new way of working and into the do ‘co-govern’. In this post I discussed how DAOs can support co-governing and that DAOs take us from a ‘world of owning’ to a ‘world of governance rights’ where wealth is distributed to all token holders. I ended that post with a plea that co-governing should be about care-ism.</p><p><em>Flaws</em><br>In blog post <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a> I also listed a number of flaws in our current ways of collaboration and governance. Self management, in order to be effective, should tackle a least the following flaws:</p><ul><li>Offering not enough protection for a community (its mission, its protocol, its values, its resources and its members)</li><li>Don’ tackle free ridership (members benefitting without contributing)</li><li>Being unnecessarily slow</li><li>Minorities which have too much or too little influence</li><li>Decision making that is not based in facts and wisdom</li><li>Member apathy</li><li>Too costly</li><li>Leaving ‘the impacted’ out of the decision</li><li>Failing to deliver to all their stakeholders</li><li>Decisions that are made without ‘skin in the game’</li></ul><blockquote>“The greater the wisdom the harder the application, but DAOs can make it a lot easier”</blockquote><p><strong>Do’s</strong></p><p>In blog post DAOs #2a I introduced the do’s of effective self management:</p><ul><li>Co-govern</li><li>Aligned incentives</li><li>Attention for transaction (TX’s) &amp; interactions (IX’s)</li><li>Polycentrism</li><li>Frictionlessness</li><li>Trusted transparency</li><li>Fast learning loops</li><li>New tools: technology and mechanisms</li></ul><p>In this blogpost I will elaborate on the do’s of effective self management. The application of these do’s ain’t easy: the greater the wisdom the harder the application, but DAOs can make it a lot easier.</p><p><em>Do: co-govern</em></p><p>See blog post <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a>.</p><p><em>Do: aligned incentives</em></p><p>Taking care of yourself and your community won’t work as long as incentives aren’t aligned. Why contribute to the community while having to sell yourself short; while not taking care of yourself? This is what DAOs should strive for and can achieve: aligning the incentives of all stakeholders with the mission of their community. And, by doing so, serving the interests of all stakeholders. Aligning incentives means taking care of everybody and taking care of the community at the same time.</p><p>As an example: I participated in a proof of concept (PoC) of a DAO for defined housing. Part of this PoC was the possibility for civilians to earn reputation points. These points were a reward for a contribution to the community. Contributions like being a volunteer firefighter or distributing free meals to people in poverty. Holders could exchange these reputation points for measures that made their homes more eco-friendly. This would give them a lower rent because of a reduced energy consumption.</p><p>Where is the win (incentive) for the stakeholders?</p><ul><li>The community: a staffed fire fighter department</li><li>People in poverty: free food delivered</li><li>Volunteers: reduced rents</li><li>The government (owning the houses): lower costs because of less energy consumption.</li><li>The community’s mission: citizen participation</li></ul><p>Aligning incentives also bypasses stalled progress resulting from different views. You don’t have to agree with all your fellow community members as long as your activities strengthen the community as a whole.</p><p><em>Do: attention for transactions &amp; interactions</em></p><p>As a starter for this ‘do’ a clarification about what I mean with transactions and interactions.</p><p>Transactions (TXs) are value exchanges under some kind of agreement: one party provides a product or service and the other party pays for it. Interactions (IXs) are more about strengthening the social cohesion of a community. Although helping a neighbor also adds value to the community, it is more difficult to express this act of care in monetary terms (and perhaps we shouldn’t). IX’s aren’t subject to formal agreements. They are more about reputation, social accounts or informal reward systems.</p><p>TX’s are indispensable for a community to flourish. They add value to a community (care for the community) and reward the contractor (care for the individual). Purely TX-based communities have a darkside. They can turn into very harsh environments where the social fabric is destroyed; environments where members act only out of self interest, searching for profit in return for every contribution they make. Whether this contribution is real or not.</p><p>Communities also need IX’s to thrive. IX’s are the lubricant. They offer the physical and emotional help members need to carry on (care for others). They provide a feeling of good doing, purpose and a sense of belonging for the helpers (care for yourself). IX’s also fill the gaps TX’s leave aside (care for the community). But communities can’t survive on IX’s alone. Purely IX-based communities often have a lack of deeds. They fail to realize their mission and ‘to deliver’ to their members. You can’t eat friendliness.</p><p>DAOs are equipped to support both TX’s and IX’s. There are a lot of examples of DAOs which support TX’s. <a href="https://commonsstack.org/">Commons Stack</a> and <a href="https://sourcecred.io/">SourceCred </a>are examples of DAO’s that (also) support IX’s.</p><p>More about TX’s and IX’s in an upcoming post.</p><p><em>Do: frictionlessness</em></p><p>Communities should lower the threshold for access and participation as much as possible. Visualize a wheelchair friendly building. Every transaction should be easy to do and every proof easy to collect. Voting from the couch and verified sensors that register who you are (proof of identity) or where you are (proof of location).</p><p>Without this ‘easiness’, members won’t participate with the desired frequency and commitment. Members should act on a level on which you can call a community really self-managed, inclusive, democratic and effective at the same time.</p><p>Communities should keep the mental energy costs and the time burden for their members as low as possible while keeping up democratic values as high as possible.</p><p>DAOs, having the properties to be available anywhere and anytime, to execute autonomously as specified (if this then that), and to provide the needed trust offer this level of frictionlessness.</p><blockquote>“Establishing a DAO as were it a WhatsApp group”</blockquote><p><em>Do: polycentrism</em></p><p>Decisions should be made at the place and level of ‘the impacted’. After all, the ones impacted likely have knowledge of the problem at hand and have skin in the game. A good or bad decision, they will have to live with it. This is real empowerment. Self empowerment.</p><p>And it’s strange: most of us make decisions every day in our private circles of concern, in our micro communities. So we’re all experts by experience. At the same time: in our professional lives we often don’t participate in decision making. Kept out by the system, others or by our own indifference.</p><p>As a consequence of pushing decision making to the impacted, many (poly) places (centers) of decision making by different groups of decision makers will arise. We will see better decisions and more efficient decision making as a result. Decision making by autocrats and managers might seem better and faster. But because of poor judgment and a lack of buy-in by the stakeholders there is often only feigned progress.</p><p>In our current governance structures, like command &amp; control for example, we bring the problem to the top tier where decisions are made, to the people who consider themselves knowledgeable. In a polycentric environment there is the challenge to bring the knowledge to the problem owners. Problem owners don’t have to become experts themselves; experts can be temporarily involved. But turning problem owners into problem solvers, whether or not in a close collaboration with experts, has a lot of advantages: problem owners get more skilled, it makes them better clients and it helps to strengthen a community’s self management skills. And for the collaboration between problem owners and experts: it surely triggers the empathy of both parties and their commitment to find a satisfying solution.</p><p>Polycentrism should be very dynamic. After all, the circle of concern that arises around a problem, can differ all the time.</p><p>This is one of the things where DAOs are very good at: ad hoc and effective organizing of, and decision making by, stakeholders who don’t necessarily know and trust each other. Establishing a DAO as were it a WhatsApp group and start collaborating.</p><p>With the possibility to dynamically organize around a problem or a mission, we can better tackle local and global issues. We can install right-sized democracy. Involving those who are impacted and who have knowledge. And as an individual you can participate in decision making about a playground in your neighborhood or in decision making about green taxation of air traffic. You can act local <em>and</em> global. By doing so we become glocal.</p><p>There are several DAO-platforms which offer the possibility to organize polycentric decision making. <a href="https://daostack.io/">DAOstack</a> and <a href="https://kalipo.io/">Kalipo</a> for example. With Kalipo you can make a constellation of DAOs. Each DAO, or ‘auton’ in Kalipo terms, has a certain level of autonomy and thus decision making power. These constellations are polycentric.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/848/0*FnKHPxHnlpXIIZU4" /></figure><p><em>Do: trusted transparency</em></p><p>Transparency is a pillar of efficient self-managing communities because it offers trust and efficiency.</p><p>Trust doesn’t happen by merely offering transparency. The revealed information and software should be reliable. An information consumer must have the guarantee that the digested information represents reality; that it hasn’t been tampered with. Not at the moment of creation and not through adjustment afterwards. And the software should execute the will of the community. Auditable for everybody.</p><p>Transparency is efficient for simple reasons. It avoids the need to search for information in hidden places or for a cipier holding the keys of the information locker.</p><p>DAOs, being built with blockchain technology, are ideally suited to provide this trusted transparency. They can’t be tampered with and are censorship resistant.</p><p>This ‘do’ should come with a note: it’s up to a community to decide which information to share and which information to keep private. Keeping information private is totally fine. But privacy comes with a cost: less trust by those without access.</p><p><em>Do: fast learning loops</em></p><p>Fixed rules are the start of the end of a community. Communities should, through self management, adjust to changed internal needs and changed external circumstances. Communities should approach their ‘being’ as an experiment. Hypothesize, act, gather results, analyze, adjust. Communities as Deming circles. These adjustments can be operational or constitutional. In other words: apply the rules differently or apply different rules.</p><p>Overlooked by a lot of people: adaptability might be one of the best properties of DAOs. Their rules, coded in smart contracts, are fixed and autonomous in their execution but are flexible in their specification. The code can be changed by community decision at any time. This makes a DAO the ultimate ‘tool’ for agility. As soon as its code has been changed, as the result of a group decision, the software part of a DAO shall run as coded. No time consuming implementations and deployments needed.</p><p><em>Do: new tools (technology and mechanisms)</em></p><p>Why don’t we apply the do’s mentioned above any time, anywhere yet? This might be because not everybody is convinced that these do’s are the road to success. But there might be another reason as well: we don’t have the right tools. Luckily times have changed. With blockchain we can add desired properties to communication, collaboration and governance tools. These properties are trust, value storage and transfer, autonomy and transparency. With these properties we can give the do’s substance. For example:</p><ul><li>The property ‘trust’ adds substance to ‘Vote from the couch’ (co-govern).</li><li>The property ‘transfer and store of value’ makes it possible to reward tokens for contributions to the community (aligned incentives).</li><li>The properties ‘transparency’ and ‘autonomy’ provide the trust for the use of template contracts (attention for TX’s).</li><li>The property ‘transfer and store of value’ opens the door to reward desired and proven behavior (attention for IX’s).</li><li>The property ‘trust’ can make civilians participate in decision making on local issues (polycentrism)</li><li>The properties ‘trust’ and ‘autonomy’ can result in the firing of coordinators (frictionlessness)</li><li>The property ‘trust’ can lead to the decision to disclose, in real time, the bookkeeping of a municipality (trusted transparency).</li><li>The property ‘trust’ is a must have for a vote on a proposal to adjust the constitution of a startup (fast learning loops).</li></ul><p>What we should remember though, is that we should protocalize <em>and</em> humanize. In other words: not every construct should be 100% automated. Algorithms, or smart contracts in blockchain terminology, can’t judge every situation ‘humanly’. Delicate decisions should be done by humans.</p><p>But there’s more in these tools for communication, collaboration and governance. They open the door to new mechanisms. Imagine new elements for votes like reputation weighted voting, quadratic voting, liquid democracy or rage quitting. Or ‘trust producing mechanisms’ like token curated registers and blacklists. More about these elements and mechanisms in posts to come.</p><p>Another advantage of trusted digital tools is that we can bring those tools, and their mechanisms, to the problem. No need to visit the notary for an adjustment of the share ratio and no more need for the municipality to decide where to place a common dumpster for a neighborhood. Give the community members the tools to vote.</p><blockquote>“This time around we have a trusted decentralized infrastructure with the possibility to fight off attacks.”</blockquote><p><strong>Counter arguments</strong></p><p>I imagine that there are a lot of arguments proclaiming that self-managed communities, applying the do’s mentioned above, won’t work. After all, Web2.0 also started with the hope for a digital paradise. An environment with user-generated content, a participatory culture and with access to everybody and everything digital. What did we end with? To list some excesses: cyber attacks, fake news, an addictive attention economy, BigTech cashing big, and surveillance.</p><p>This time around we have a trusted decentralized infrastructure with the possibility to fight off attacks. Whether those attacks are on the software or on the ownership/governance (power grabs).</p><p>And users and communities have an additional option. They have the ability to choose for communication, collaboration and governance tools (DAOs) that are trusted, frictionless, cheaper, more fair and offer new possibilities. Let them decide.</p><p>I’m confident about a brighter future.</p><p><strong>Wrap up</strong></p><p>This blog post was about a new way of working: by the community for the community. We have to play this new game, to be able to reach ambitious goals. I consider this game a prerequisite for achieving a better world. I’ve never heard BigTech or an autocrat embracing all UN goals for example. And democracies, in their current existence, often fail to deliver on those goals.</p><p>In this blog post I didn’t always become specific in how the discussed do’s, whether or not through a DAO, solve the listed problems. In my next posts I shall dig deeper.</p><p><strong>Invite</strong></p><p>I hope for a lot of reactions on my blog posts. To share thoughts and to sharpen each other’s visions. And perhaps, DAO-like, to walk along together and to work together.</p><p>Let’s make this world a better place together. Let’s create as much prosperity and well being for as many people as possible. While keeping the environment sustainable at the same time. So see this blog series as an invite. Maybe one day you will be joining the community of DAOnauts.</p><p><strong>Next blog post</strong></p><p>The next blog post, is called ‘DAOs #3 — It’s all about power balance’. This post is about the importance of power balance and power distribution. This post goes to the heart of the distributed way of working and thinking. In this post I make the claim that the mechanisms that make blockchain robust and censorship resistant, can also be applied to DAOs. With these mechanisms communities become more hufter proof and more ‘caring’.</p><p><strong>Before you go</strong></p><p>In case you got value out of this read, I encourage you to <strong>click the</strong> 👏<strong>button</strong> and <strong>hold it down to 20–50 claps</strong> as this will help me, DAOs and Kalipo to get more exposure.</p><p><strong>Links to previous and next posts</strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-0-how-to-we-all-can-benefit-from-blockchain-a-blog-series-9d4d6bcd67f8">DAO #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-1-communities-make-the-world-go-round-2fa98dbaaa05">DAO #1 — An ecosystem of communities makes the world go round</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAO #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/p/869ac4221960">DAOs #3 — It’s all about power</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5d0147b90585" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-2b-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-5d0147b90585">DAOs #2b — A new game: for the community, by the community</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419?source=rss-49425f40625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f0de1757419</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kalipo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lisk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Nobels]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Mar 2022 13:00:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-26T08:48:59.319Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</p><p><strong>This Blog</strong></p><p>This blog post is the first of two about the theme ‘how communities can flourish by installing the do’s of effective self-management’. Practicing these do’s need the use of a DAO.</p><p>This blog post is part of a series of posts, a blogchain. This series is about DAOs (Decentralized Autonomous Organizations) in general and Kalipo in particular. Kalipo is a platform on which communities can establish their own tailormade DAO. DAOs are the next step in collaboration, governance and value distribution.</p><p><strong>Message</strong></p><ul><li>There’s a new game for better collaboration, governance and value distribution</li><li>This game has the following do’s: co-govern, aligned incentives, attention for transactions &amp; interactions, polycentrism, frictionlessness, trusted transparency, fast learning loops and new tools (technology and mechanisms).</li><li>With the distribution of power and wealth comes the distribution of accountability and risk.</li><li>We go from ‘a world of owning’ to ‘a world of governance rights’.</li><li>We need a new word for a system of self-governance, collaboration and contribution; for a system of sharing and caring: <strong>care-ism</strong></li></ul><p><strong>Good news</strong></p><p>In my last blog post ‘DAOs #1 — Communities makes the world go round’, I discussed how we as humans became successful through collaboration. That we have constructs which help us to steer collective action. For example constructs like shared values (social), ways of working (procedural &amp; organizational), rules for protection and punishment (legal), mechanisms for collecting goods or money to pay for shared facilities and distributing wealth (tax), means of value transfer (monetary) and means for access (technical/physical). And, by digitizing these constructs, we became even more successful. That was the good news.</p><p><strong>Bad news</strong></p><p>The bad news? In the same blog post I named a few downsides of our current ways of working. For one, power concentration. Power concentration is prone to abuse by those holding the power. It’s also not anti-fragile: a single point of power is a single point of failure.</p><p><em>Solutions leading to more problems</em></p><p>There’s more bad news. To enable collaboration we’ve established institutes for control and trust. This has resulted in the trust paradox: more institutes leading to less transparency, more opportunities for fraud, and more need for control. Who supervises the supervisor?</p><p><em>Fake solutions</em></p><p>Then there are fake solutions. These fake solutions have their background in the different stakeholder groups.</p><p>Government: autocratic leaders positioning themselves as can-do-it-alls. Although sometimes successful in the short run, they always end up ‘dictatorish’, putting the interest of themselves and their inner circle first.</p><p>Business / the market: Big Tech companies offering user friendly communication and collaboration software. While at the same time selling customer data, manipulating customers thoughts with algorithms and extracting value (take rate) to the max once customers are locked-in.</p><p>Individuals: people claiming that serving one’s self interest or full autonomy is the way to utopia for us all. The darkweb proves them wrong.</p><p><em>Poor solutions</em></p><p>Okay, not all coordination solutions are <em>that</em> bad or fake. But we’re still stuck with coordination systems like uncontrolled command &amp; control structures, harsh markets and ineffective democratism. To be more specific, systems:</p><ul><li>That don’t offer enough protection for a community (its mission, its protocol, its values, its resources and its members)</li><li>That don’t tackle free ridership (members benefitting without contributing)</li><li>That are unnecessarily slow</li><li>Where minorities have too much or too little influence</li><li>With decision making not based in facts, wisdom and reality</li><li>With member apathy</li><li>That are too costly</li><li>That leave ‘the impacted’ out of the decision</li><li>That fail to deliver to all their stakeholders</li><li>Where decisions are made without ‘skin in the game’</li></ul><p>In most cases the players are hardly to blame for these flaws. It should not be a personal blame game. Systems are eating their members. It’s the game that is to blame.</p><p><strong>New game</strong></p><p>Reading how poorly organized we often are and how badly parties behave, might be nice to read (“This yet again confirms my belief: the system is rotten and others are bad!”). But you probably didn’t come to this blog for a confirmation of who you consider the bad guys or to get angry and excited.</p><p>So, what’s the fix? What are the rules and the tools of this new game?</p><p>This new game has the following do’s for effective self-management:</p><ul><li>Co-govern</li><li>Aligned incentives</li><li>Attention for transaction (TX’s) &amp; interactions (IX’s)</li><li>Polycentrism</li><li>Frictionlessness</li><li>Trusted transparency</li><li>Fast learning loops</li><li>New tools: technology and mechanisms</li></ul><p>All these do’s should be treated actively. These are do’s to install, to foster and to maintain.</p><p>Disclaimer: this new game won’t solve all our collaboration problems with a wave of a baton. We need experiments and failures, improvements and more failures. It’s a ‘learning game’ as well.</p><p>Here’s the first do-item on the menu: ‘co-govern’ (the other do’s will be served in my upcoming blog post).</p><blockquote>“DAOs take us from a ‘world of owning’ to a ‘world of governance rights’. A world where wealth is distributed to all token holders.”</blockquote><p><em>Do: co-govern</em></p><p>Co-laboration improves when members co-own the solution and have the ability to co-govern. Let me give you an example stemming from the realm of platforms and the gig economy, from the world of digital marketplaces where talent and clients meet and agree on work.</p><p><em>Let’s imagine a talent-platform where clients pay workers in the currency of the platform (e.g. Kalipo tokens) and that these tokens have governance rights. And let’s take the perspective of the worker. So, when you as a worker earn platform-tokens, you have ownership of the platform and a stake in its success. After all, the more successful the platform is, the higher the value of your tokens. That gives you an incentive to save your tokens. Now you trust the platform not only with your livelihood, finding work, but also with your savings. You have skin in the game and interests to protect. You want to make sure that the platform survives and is successful.</em></p><p><em>You can, on the platform, protect your interests in two ways: participate in win-win collaborations with co-members (just by doing successful transactions) and participate in decision making (steering the platform towards a future which you consider best).</em></p><p>This example shows how co-laboration, co-owning and co-govern can interplay. This is the world of DAOs. DAOs are actually not even about co-owning but solely about co-governance. No single member owns a piece of the software code or a chair in an office building. Members only have tokens. DAOs take us from a ‘world of owning’ to a ‘world of governance rights’. A world where wealth is distributed to all token holders.</p><p>Not all is blue sky. Here is an alert: with the distribution of power and wealth comes the distribution of accountability and risk. You can’t have one without the other.</p><p><em>An example: a vote</em></p><p>A vote, as an example, gives us more insight in how the distribution of power holds hands with the distribution of accountability and risk. Let me elaborate on this example: because all members have the ‘power’ to vote, the outcome of a vote is everybody’s accountability. If the outcome of a vote is to transfer value from the community’s treasury to software developers to improve the protocol, then all are accountable and all are at risk of a poor or too expensive result.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UL6YKHs6PpmS2PZZnwRCwg.png" /></figure><p>But there’s more to co-govern than members having decision making power and benefitting from added value. There’s inclusiveness and community intelligence as well.</p><p>This system of co-governance is inclusive because everybody can participate in transactions and governance. Your account is your ticket to the platform and your public address is your face to the community. There’s no distinction in race, gender or nationality (if anyone can even find this out). And, when community building is done right, members will turn their ‘right to’ into deeds. Then we’re talking about real inclusiveness. Participatory inclusiveness.</p><p>And where is the community intelligence? The community can profit from the wisdom of its crowd in many ways. Through prediction markets, for example, where members vote on possible future events while simultaneously staking tokens on their prediction. If their prediction comes true, they earn more tokens. And when they are wrong? Well, then they lose their tokens.</p><p>Is this communism with a new face? Or is this fighting capitalism with capitalism? There are hidden assumptions and mental frames in these questions. That this is an either/or situation. That this new way of collaboration should fit to one of our current systems. But it’s a new paradigm, a new game. We can transcend the chisma between capitalism and communism; between socialism, democratism and liberalism.</p><p>For me this new paradigm is an inner ‘healing’ as well. My inner parts have to come together. My liberal part, that is fond of freedom, with my democratic part that believes in equal rights and legal protection. The part of me that is social and stands for ‘fraternité’ has also to blend in.</p><p>We need a new word. A word for a system of effective self-management. A word for a system of collaboration and contribution; for a system of sharing and caring. Therefore I would like to introduce to you the word ‘care-ism’. This word represents: care for / take care of …<br>… yourself<br>… your fellow members<br>… the commons of your community<br>… the mission of your community<br>… the environment</p><p>We have the free market paradigm that tells us: when I take care of myself, that’s good for the community as well. Care-ism adds: when I take care of the community, that’s good for me too. We should build a care-economy or, even better, a care-society. A society where you are rewarded for caring for / taking care of whatever the subject is.</p><blockquote>“Care-ism”</blockquote><p><strong>Wrap up</strong></p><p>This blog post was an introduction into a new way of working ‘by the community for the community’ and into the do ‘co-govern’. I discussed how DAOs can support co-governing and that DAOs take us from a ‘world of owning’ to a ‘world of governance rights’ where wealth is distributed to all token holders. I ended with a plea that co-governing should be about care-ism.</p><p><strong>Invite</strong></p><p>I hope for a lot of reactions on my blog posts. To share thoughts and to sharpen each other’s visions. And perhaps, DAO-like, to walk along together and to work together.</p><p>Let’s make this world a better place together. Let’s create as much prosperity and well being for as many people as possible. While keeping the environment sustainable at the same time. So see this blog series as an invite. Maybe one day you will be joining the community of DAOnauts.</p><p><strong>Next blog</strong></p><p>The next blog post has the same name as this one <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-2b-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-5d0147b90585">DAOs #2b — A new game: for the community by the community</a>. In this post I will share my insights on the other do’s of effective self-management:</p><ul><li>Aligned incentives</li><li>Attention for transaction (TX’s) &amp; interactions (IX’s)</li><li>Polycentrism</li><li>Frictionlessness</li><li>Trusted transparency</li><li>Fast learning loops</li><li>New tools: technology and mechanisms</li></ul><p><strong>Before you go</strong></p><p>In case you got value out of this read, I encourage you to <strong>click the</strong> 👏<strong>button</strong> and <strong>hold it down to 20–50 claps</strong> as this will help me, DAOs and Kalipo to get more exposure.</p><p><strong>Links to previous and next posts</strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-0-how-to-we-all-can-benefit-from-blockchain-a-blog-series-9d4d6bcd67f8">DAOs #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-1-communities-make-the-world-go-round-2fa98dbaaa05">DAOs #1 — An ecosystem of communities makes the world go round</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/daos-2b-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-5d0147b90585">DAOs #2b — A new game: for the community, by the community</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f0de1757419" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DAOs #1 — Communities make the world go round]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-1-communities-make-the-world-go-round-2fa98dbaaa05?source=rss-49425f40625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2fa98dbaaa05</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lisk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kalipo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Nobels]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Feb 2022 19:29:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-20T18:41:40.386Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>DAOs #1 – Communities make the world go round</p><p><strong>This Blog</strong></p><p>This blog is about communities and how DAOs relate to them.</p><p>This Blog is part of a series of blogs, a blogchain. This series is about DAOs (Decentralized Autonomous Organizations) in general and Kalipo in particular. Kalipo is a platform on which communities can establish their own tailormade DAO. DAOs are the next step in collaboration, governance and value distribution.</p><p><strong>Message</strong></p><ul><li>The human world is built out of communities</li><li>On a community level lays the key for improvements</li><li>DAOs are the breakthrough to make communities healthy, vibrant and fair</li></ul><p><strong>Communities</strong></p><p>We are successful as a species because we collaborate. One single person couldn’t kill a mammoth, build a cathedral, or put a rover on the moon. These collaborations happen in communities.</p><p>We live in families, have our professional environments, are members of clubs and are part of a neighborhood. These are all communities. Communities are our habitats and our day-to-day reality.</p><p>There are business-like communities, club-like communities and informal communities. Those communities have labels like club, enterprise, tribe, guild, start-up, organization, society, market place, team, group, etc.</p><p>Some communities are local. These communities are often grouped around a subject in which members have an interest. E.g. a neighborhood or a school. Other communities are regional, national or global. These communities tend to have been formed around shared values and around subjects in which members are commonly interested. E.g. a political party or Pokemon Go players. Some communities gather mainly physically. Others live only in the digital world.</p><p>So the word for the human world is community.</p><p><em>What makes a community a community</em></p><p>For this blog it’s useful to zoom in on what makes a community a community.</p><p>All communities share a set of attributes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/1*h3_S89sGfirXMlTw8D2ibQ.png" /></figure><p>To start with: a community is a group of actors. For example the followers of a religion or the employees of a company. Those actors share a mission (some communities call it a shared meme). They believe in the same God or in their company’s mission.</p><p>Furthermore: communities have a shared value set, often in a published format. A religion has its holy documents and a company has its policies.</p><p>Communities also have their boundaries. The boundaries set the scope of a community. What or who is in or out. You are a member of a church or you’re not. And you are on the pay-role of a company or you’re not.</p><p>Another attribute of communities are their shared resources. A faith community has its houses of worship and companies have their offices and treasuries.</p><p>A community is also defined by the actions of its members. Those actions can be individual or collective. You can pray alone or together. You can be part of a company’s project team or have a personal assignment.</p><p><em>Constructs: steering behavior</em></p><p>In this blog I shall dive into the questions ‘Why a DAO?’, ‘what is a DAO?’ and ‘how do DAOs relate to communities?’ But before I do, some thoughts about individual behavior and collective action.</p><p>Communities have a set of constructs to steer individual behavior and to coordinate collective action. Communities have social constructs. E.g. the ten commandments of Christians or the values of a company.</p><p>Another set of constructs are procedural or organizational. Examples are the catechism of Catholics and a company’s organizational charter.</p><p>Legal constructs form another group. Legal constructs are meant to protect and punish. ​​Excommunication is an example of punishment used in Christian communities. Works councils are an example of protecting the interests of employees within companies.</p><p>Tax constructs are yet another type. Taxes are paid by individuals to the overarching entity. A governance body decides how to spend these contributions. In a faith community, the highest in rank usually decides where to allocate collections to. The company’s profits can be seen as taxes, to be decided upon by shareholders.</p><p>Then there are the monetary constructs. These constructs for example declare what the valid means of payments are and if interest is applicable. In the catholic church you can pay for commited sins with prayers, and companies have loyalty points and equity programs.</p><p>Technical/physical constructs are also applicable: a bench for praying or a tourniquet to allow entrance to an office.</p><p><em>Digitization of communities</em></p><p>A trend, of which DAOs are an exponent, is that communities become more and more digitized.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/568/0*AO-ozAtZwehG5k6h" /></figure><p>This digitization applies to all the construct types.</p><p>Social constructs, like codes of conducts, are reflected in the number of likes somebody gets.</p><p>Online dispute handling services are an example of a digitized legal construct.</p><p>An example of the digitization of a monetary construct (for those of us old enough to remember): loyalty points used to be kind of vouchers attached to a product. Nowadays these points are on a plastic or even on a digital customer card.</p><p>All workflow software are digitized procedural/organizational constructs: who is responsible for which part of the process is all automated.</p><p>An office building that can only be accessed with a keycard, connected to a system which registers who’s in or out the building, is an example of a digitized physical/technical construct.</p><p>Because there are strong drivers for collecting payments, there are a lot of digitized variants of tax constructs. Direct debit is one of them.</p><blockquote>“How nice it would be to strip collaboration from unnecessary obstacles?”</blockquote><p><em>Collaboration is hard</em></p><p>So we have constructs to steer collective action. We even have the ability to digitize these constructs. But before we get to DAOs, and how these can further optimize collaboration, let’s look at some of the problems we face while collaborating.</p><p>Collaboration isn’t easy. Look at your own family affairs, friendships, and business relations (oké, not yours, but the affairs, friendships, relations of others).</p><p>Our current ways of collaboration have their flaws. Some flaws are the result of an inevitable concentration of power. We leave a lot of decision making to others. Because of a lack of ownership, because of a lack of easy to use inclusive governance tools or because of a lack of knowledge (due to highly specialized jobs). Concentration of power is vulnerable. Single points of power are single points of failure (SPOP = SPOF): what if a decision maker gets ill or misjudges a situation? Power concentration is also prone to abuse by those holding the power. I imagine that most of you have their own examples of abuse of power.</p><p>There are also flaws on an operational level. Flaws like free ridership (benefitting without contribution) and the tyranny of majority (the winners take it all).</p><p>So, what do we do? We create institutes for control (like a chamber of representatives or an audit committee). Or we establish trusted third parties and trust creating mechanisms like notaries and paper certificates. Or we install command structures or leave it to the market. Which leaves us with autocrats, one party states and individuals owning trillions, and trillions owning almost nothing.</p><p><em>An opportunity for improvement</em></p><p>But how nice it would be to have solutions for the flaws in our current systems? To strip collaboration from unnecessary, costly and counter-productive measures? To distribute power and value more evenly? To solve problems where the pain is felt?</p><p>I’m not a techno-optimist, believing that technology is the answer to every problem. But I do believe that DAOs are part of the solution. DAOs aren’t the magic wand. But they can do a lot of tricks. They might shrink some problems, seen from our current paradigms, almost inexplicably.</p><blockquote>“There’s no unique shared definition for a DAO. Not only because it’s hard to make definitions, but also because DAOs are difficult to grab.”</blockquote><p><em>What is a DAO</em></p><p>Now a bit of a spoiler: how DAOs can improve collaboration and governance isn’t the subject of this blog post but of upcoming posts. So, no clearance for now. But I make up for that by giving an introduction into DAOs.</p><p>There’s no unique shared definition for a DAO. Not only because it’s hard to make definitions, but also because DAOs are difficult to grab.</p><p>Can a DAO be seen as…<br>…an organization?<br>…a software protocol?<br>…a governance &amp; collaboration tool?<br>…a legal entity?<br>…an actor, acting on behalf of its members?<br>…a common or shared facility?<br>…a monetary system?<br>…a digital nation state?<br>…all of the above?</p><p>I don’t have the answer. And actually I don’t even care. I <em>do</em> care about what communities can achieve with DAOs.</p><p>An approach to get a better understanding of what a DAO is, from a communities point of view, is to look at DAOs through the lens of the attributes of a community.</p><p>Looking through this lens, it becomes clear what the features or properties are that DAOs <strong>don’t </strong>have.</p><p>DAOs often don’t have an office building. The members of a DAO often don’t know each other. DAOs don’t have a CEO or a management team ‘calling the shots’. DAOs don’t have terms &amp; conditions unilaterally written by the lawyers of a company owning a product or supplying a service. DAO’s don’t own resources. DAOs don’t have a mission just for the sake of it and DAOs don’t fall under one specific jurisdiction.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*79TYLWEce-de7HZ4" /></figure><p>So, what are DAOs?</p><p>DAOs, as their name suggests, are (partly) autonomous and (partly) decentralized.</p><p>For their autonomous part: DAOs, through their software, execute what is put in their code: ‘if this is the situation, I act like that’ (ITTT = if this then that). So, if a particular situation occurs, the protocol will autonomously and unstoppable execute the next steps.</p><p>DAOs shift coordinating tasks from managers to code and members. This is the decentralized part of DAOs. Members decide, also what to put into code. Where code is unable to execute, or seen by the members as unfit to decide, the decision making is up to the members again. So, not all actions have to be autonomous.</p><p>The term ‘decentralized’ also refers to the technology used: decentralized ledger technology, also known as blockchain. With blockchain, there is not one central server, but multiple nodes that take care of security and power distribution. Once recorded data (ledgers) and software cannot be changed unilaterally by any party.</p><p>A blockchain doesn’t run in the cloud (on the servers of one provider) but in the crowd. This makes blockchain applications very robust. Ever experienced that Bitcoin was out of service?</p><p>As is the case for ‘autonomous’ a DAO is often also partly decentralized. The level of decentralization depends on the number of (active) members, the number of nodes, how tokens are distributed and the diversity of stakeholders.</p><p>Let’s dig deeper into DAOs through examining how DAOs <em>do</em> relate to the features of communities.</p><p><em>Features/properties of DAOs</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jP4bYvNqtCbjimkd" /></figure><p>Instead of having an office building, DAOs live on the web. That’s the place where you can find the open source code and its users. Communities that are using DAOs, and/or calling themselves a DAO, are usually web native.</p><p>The members are the account holders. Every actor, a company, a human or a bot having an account and having access, can participate. Actors are often only known by their public key or avatar name.</p><p>DAOs are member managed and member owned. Members have governance rights by having an account and/or holding tokens. Roles are often defined by the type of contribution: core contributors, affiliate members or bounty hunters, investors. Actors often have several roles.</p><p>A part of the coordination and execution happens through the protocol. The rules of the game by which the DAO wants to play, are as much as possible written in code. This results in a lot of straight through processing: events triggering the protocol which executes with no possibility for human interference. DAOs strive for a (fat) automated censorship resistant protocol.</p><p>The terms &amp; conditions of a DAO are under management of the members. At Kalipo we call this constitution management. Members decide upon the rules of their game. They can decide to change the rules to adjust them to their changed needs or changed circumstances.</p><p>This leads to a shift from ownership to governance rights. The resources of the DAO belong to no one but everybody can co-decide. The resources of a DAO can’t be taken away by others, but the DAO by itself doesn’t own these resources either.</p><p>DAOs, being a worldwide web entity, don’t fall under one specific jurisdiction. While acknowledging that they are part over overarching structures, they see themselves, internally, also as a jurisdiction on their own.</p><p>And for DAOs apply: the mission is the boss. Their mission is their guiding star to which all activities should direct.</p><p><strong>Wrap up</strong></p><p>With this blog post I offered my thoughts and insights about the basics of DAOs and how they relate to communities.</p><p><strong>Invite</strong></p><p>I hope for a lot of reactions on my blog posts. To share thoughts and to sharpen each other’s visions. And perhaps, DAO-like, to walk along together and to work together.</p><p>Let’s make this world a better place together. Let’s create as much prosperity and well being for as many people as possible. While keeping the environment sustainable at the same time. So see this blog series as an invite. Maybe one day you will be joining the community of DAOnauts.</p><p><strong>Next blog</strong></p><p>The next blog post is called ‘DAOs #2 — A new game: for the community, by the community’. This post is about how member management works and how communities, by using DAO mechanisms, can become more effective in reaching their goals.</p><p><strong>Before you go</strong></p><p>In case you got value out of this read, I encourage you to <strong>click the</strong> 👏<strong>button</strong> and <strong>hold it down to 20–50 claps</strong> as this will help me, DAOs and Kalipo to get more exposure.</p><p><strong>Links to previous and next posts</strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-0-how-to-we-all-can-benefit-from-blockchain-a-blog-series-9d4d6bcd67f8">DAOs #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/2a-daos-a-new-game-for-the-community-by-the-community-7f0de1757419">DAOs #2a — A new game: for the community, by the community</a></p><blockquote><em>Join Coinmonks</em><a href="https://t.me/coincodecap"><em> Telegram Channel</em></a><em> and</em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/coinmonks/videos"><em> Youtube Channel</em></a><em> learn about crypto trading and investing</em></blockquote><h3>Also, Read</h3><ul><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/bookmap-review-2021-best-trading-software">Bookmap Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/crypto-exchange-usa"> 5 Best Crypto Exchanges in the USA</a></li><li>The Best Crypto<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/hardware-wallets-dfa1211730c6"> Hardware wallet</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/bitbns-review-38256a07e161"> Bitbns Review</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/crypto-exchange-in-singapore">10 Best Crypto Exchange in Singapore</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/buy-axs-token"> Buy AXS</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/red-dog-casino-review">Red Dog Casino Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/swyftx-review"> Swyftx Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/coingate-review"> CoinGate Review</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/best-crypto-to-invest-in-india-in-2021">Best Crypto to Invest in India</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/wazirx-p2p"> WazirX P2P</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/hi-dollar-review"> Hi Dollar Review</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/5-best-crypto-trading-bots-in-canada">Best Crypto Trading bots in Canada</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/kucoin-review"> KuCoin Review</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/huobi-crypto-trading-signals">Crypto Trading Signals for Huobi</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/hitbtc-review-c5143c5d53c2"> HitBTC Review</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/ftx-futures-trading">How to trade Futures on FTX Exchange</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/okex-vs-binance"> OKEx vs Binance</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/okex-kucoin">OKEx vs KuCoin</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/celsius-alternatives"> Celsius Alternatives</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/buy-vechain"> How to Buy VeChain</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/profitfarmers-review">ProfitFarmers Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/cornix-trading-bot"> How to use Cornix Trading Bot</a></li><li><a href="https://coincodecap.com/buy-bitcoin-anonymously">How to buy Bitcoin Anonymously</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/bitcoin-cash-wallets"> Bitcoin Cash Wallets</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2fa98dbaaa05" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-1-communities-make-the-world-go-round-2fa98dbaaa05">DAOs #1 — Communities make the world go round</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DAOs #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-0-how-to-we-all-can-benefit-from-blockchain-a-blog-series-9d4d6bcd67f8?source=rss-49425f40625------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d4d6bcd67f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lisk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kalipo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dao]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Nobels]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Feb 2022 10:29:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-02T15:12:54.943Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>DAOs #0 – How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series</strong></p><p><strong>This Blog</strong></p><p>This Blog is a prelude of a series of blog posts about DAOs (Decentralized Autonomous Organizations) in general and Kalipo in particular. DAOs are the next step in collaboration, governance and shared ownership. Kalipo is a platform on which communities can establish their own tailormade DAO.</p><p><strong>Message</strong></p><ul><li>We can live in a wonderful world</li><li>We can benefit from blockchain to realize that wonderful world</li><li>Let’s act instead of react, let’s gain instead of complain, let’s get our interests aligned right instead of fight/flight, let’s build instead of getting tilled.</li><li>How? For one thing, become a follower of this blog series</li></ul><p><strong>A personal journey</strong></p><p>After I graduated as a teacher in physical education in the mid 80’s, I switched profession. As somebody who is always triggered by analytical challenges and who is interested in innovations, I chose to become an IT developer. IT was a young, upcoming, and very promising discipline at that time (and still is!). After three years learning the IT basics at a bank/insurer, I became a consultant.</p><p>During my 27 years in consultancy I steadily climbed the stairs in my profession. Starting off as a developer, I had job titles like technical designer, functional designer, analyst and digital value chain expert.</p><p>The main driver behind these career steps was that I wanted to be at the root of solving problems. I wanted to be at the origin of designing impactful solutions. So I ended up as an expert in ecosystems (or markets or networks or societies or whatever you want to call it). That’s the level where, for me, everything came together.</p><p>All along, with a background in team sports, I also stayed focused on team play, collaboration and results (during my life I had also a lot of manager roles).</p><p>Then, some 6 years ago suffering from a life threatening infection, I found myself in a hospital bed. It was a crossroads moment in my life: keep doing consultancy assignments for a living or choose to have real impact. The outcome was unavoidable. My passion chose for me. I was going to have a career switch. I was going to combine my three passions: IT, ecosystems and collaboration. With success as one of the possible outcomes.</p><p>That was also the moment I decided to dive into blockchain technology. Not for the crypto’s but for the possibilities I saw in blockchain to improve collaboration within ecosystems. All for the benefit of healthier communities and their members.</p><blockquote><strong>“Systems that give more than they take. Systems that serve all their stakeholders.”</strong></blockquote><p><em>My personal frustrations</em></p><p>Another less lofty reason to choose the path of ‘blockchain for the good of communities’, is that I’m averse of power. I have a better sensor for the misuse of power than for power as an essential tool for getting things done.</p><p>My crossroads moment happened to be at the time of the rise of autocratism: all over the world self declared strong men gained power in democratic societies. I considered these societies as hufter proof. But then I saw these autocrats demolishing one democratic pillar after another. I wasn’t so sure anymore that democratism, that I saw as the only viable long term system, was to survive. These anti democratic developments touched me deeply. I felt them as real pain in my body.</p><p>I decided that I could better act than react; that it was more self-serving to get some positive things built than getting tilled; that I could better produce gains then complaints; that I could better contribute to solutions that get interests aligned right then to start a fight or take flight.</p><p><em>My personal beliefs</em></p><p>I knew what I didn’t want. No autocratism, what I see as a road to dictatorship. No surveillance society, what inevitably leads to totalitarianism. No wild capitalism, from which many in the Western world suffer today. No anarchies with ‘survival of the strongest’ as the only law.</p><p>There were a lot of no’s. But what <em>did</em> I want? High over I knew I wanted to contribute to systems that not only put customers first, but that keep communities healthy at the same time. Systems that are ‘hufterproof’. Systems that give more than they take. Systems that serve all their stakeholders. I don’t only believe in ‘systems that give and serve’ from an idealistic stance, but because it’s rational: I’m convinced that such systems will outpace other systems.</p><p>I was aware that such vague goals are not the stuff where solutions are made of. So, part of the endeavor that laid ahead of me, was to specify my beliefs and solutions more in depth.</p><blockquote>“I don’t only believe in ‘systems that give and serve’ from an idealistic stance, but because it’s rational: such systems will outpace other systems.”</blockquote><p><em>My encounter with blockchain</em></p><p>My first encounter with blockchain was in 2015. I read that blockchain was a multiparty game; that blockchain offered a trusted infrastructure to parties who don’t necessarily know and trust each other. That they offer one single source of truth. I subconsciously felt that this was a necessary property for the solutions I envisioned.</p><p>In early 2016 I decided to go all in on blockchain technology. And blockchain didn’t disappoint me. I found out that blockchain didn’t only offer trust, but could also store and transfer value. How useful these properties were, I started to value more and more during the following years.</p><p>In these following years I saw initiatives to apply blockchain technology blooming. E.g. systems that could track the provenance of clothing (from cotton to closet), tuna (from fishing areas to cans) and coffee (from plantations to stores). Or systems for digital health records used by all involved health care professionals.</p><p>Parallel more technical driven experiments started. Experiments within DeFi (Decentralized Finance) and with NFTs (Non Fungable Tokens). Experiments such as micropayments (DeFi) and cryptoKitties (NFT’s).</p><p>But my eyes fell on a certain application of blockchain: DAOs. DAO is an Acronym for Decentralized Autonomous Organizations. DAOs hold for communities the promise for self management, for shared ownership, for rewarding all kinds of added value, and for frictionless transactions. With DAOs I found my destination.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/560/0*bMHY2UbVCbGuAtrg" /></figure><p>More on DAOs in upcoming blog posts.</p><p><em>My endeavor so far</em></p><p>The first steps I took in the blockchain space were at the University of applied science in Utrecht. At this university I established a Blockchain lab for which I was accountable for 2,5 years. The main focus of this lab was developing proof of concepts and doing research. This time turned out to be very educational for me. I learned what was technically feasible and what was not.</p><p>During that same period I became a member of the Dutch Blockchain Coalition. Because blockchain was in its infancy everybody was learning. This pre competitive period made it a very vibrant, open and sharing group of people.</p><p>After quitting my job at my consultancy firm, I established, with three partners, Vitallity. Our company developed a platform on which health care parties could share information and could collaborate. It wasn’t a success. My most important lesson learned? Building coalitions on a decision making level is more challenging than technology.</p><p>My Vitallity experience confirmed my belief that vibrant communities need two intertwined building blocks: a trusted collaboration environment ánd decision tools. Collaboration and shared governance go hand in hand. In other words: communities need DAOs.</p><p>When I encountered the guys of Moosty, I found my partners to build a DAO platform. At the moment Kalipo is in the making. Kalipo shall run on top of Lisk (a blockchain-platform). Kalipo will be a platform on which communities can establish their own tailormade DAO.</p><p>In the summer of 2021, to gain knowledge about DAOs and to get experience with DAO’s, I established the DAO Hub. All members are experts in their own fields. Fields of expertise such as DAOs, legal, economics, value chains, token engineering, blockchain technology, governance, trust, and philosophy. We also participate in DAO experiments. All in the spirit of DAOs.</p><p><em>My next steps</em></p><p>Some people ask me if blockchain is dead. While the hype is over, nothing is less true. The use of Blockchain, being a back end technology, is not visible for end users. As an example of the pace of things happening: I can’t keep up with all DAO initiatives, a niche in the blockchain world…</p><p>I see a bright future ahead for DAOs. DAOs have an almost endless design space. I hope to stay on its path for a long time more.</p><p><strong>The blog post series</strong></p><p>This post is an introduction in a series of blog posts about DAOs. The posts will initially be about communities and DAOs in general. In these posts I shall share my vision. The follow up posts will be more about Kalipo’s research, considerations and the specific mechanisms that we will implement in Kalipo.</p><p><strong>Invite</strong></p><p>I hope for a lot of reactions on my blog posts. To share thoughts and to sharpen each other’s visions. And perhaps, DAO-like, to walk along together and to work together.</p><p>Let’s make this world a better place together. Let’s create as much prosperity and well being for as many people as possible. While keeping the environment sustainable at the same time. So see this blog series as an invite. Maybe one day you will be joining the community of DAOnauts.</p><p><strong>Next blog</strong></p><p>The next blog post is called ‘DAOs #1 — Communities make the world go round’. This post is about communities, why they are the key for improving our (personal) worlds and how DAOs relate to communities.</p><p><strong>Before you go</strong></p><p>In case you got value out of this read, I encourage you to <strong>click the</strong> 👏<strong>button</strong> and <strong>hold it down to 20–50 claps</strong> as this will help me, DAOs and Kalipo to get more exposure.</p><p><strong>Links</strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-1-communities-make-the-world-go-round-2fa98dbaaa05">DAOs #1 — Communities make the world go round</a></p><blockquote><em>Join Coinmonks</em><a href="https://t.me/coincodecap"><em> Telegram Channel</em></a><em> and</em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/coinmonks/videos"><em> Youtube Channel</em></a><em> learn about crypto trading and investing</em></blockquote><h3>Also, Read</h3><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/3commas-review-an-excellent-crypto-trading-bot-2020-1313a58bec92">3Commas Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/pionex-review-exchange-with-crypto-trading-bot"> Pionex Review</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/coinrule-review-2021-a-beginner-friendly-crypto-trading-bot-daf0504848ba"> Coinrule review</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/ledger-vs-ngrave-zero-7e40f0c1d694">Ledger vs Ngrave</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/ledger-nano-s-vs-x-battery-hardware-price-storage-59a6663fe3b0"> Ledger nano s vs x</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/binance-review-ee10d3bf3b6e"> Binance Review</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/bybit-exchange-review-dbd570019b71">Bybit Exchange Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/bityard-reivew"> Bityard Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/jet-bot-review"> Jet-Bot Review</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/3commas-vs-pionex-vs-cryptohopper-best-crypto-bot-6a98d2baa203">3Commas vs Cryptohopper</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/earn-crypto-interest-b10b810fdda3"> Earn crypto interest</a></li><li>The Best Bitcoin<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/hardware-wallets-dfa1211730c6"> Hardware wallet</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/bitbox02-review-your-swiss-bitcoin-hardware-wallet-c36c88fff29"> BitBox02 Review</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blockfi-vs-celsius-vs-hodlnaut-8a1cc8c26630">BlockFi vs Celsius</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/hodlnaut-review-best-way-to-hodl-is-to-earn-interest-on-your-bitcoin-6658a8c19edf"> Hodlnaut Review</a> |<a href="https://coincodecap.com/kucoin-review"> KuCoin Review</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/bitsgap-review-a-crypto-trading-bot-that-makes-easy-money-a5d88a336df2">Bitsgap review</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/quadency-review-a-crypto-trading-automation-platform-3068eaa374e1"> Quadency Review</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/bitbns-review-38256a07e161"> Bitbns Review</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/top-10-crypto-copy-trading-platforms-for-beginners-d0c37c7d698c">Crypto Copy Trading Platforms</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/coinmama-review-ace5641bde6e"> Coinmama Review</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/bitcoin-exchange-in-india-7f1fe79715c9">Crypto exchanges in India</a> |<a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/bitcoin-savings-account-e65b13f92451"> Bitcoin Savings Account</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d4d6bcd67f8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks/blog-0-how-to-we-all-can-benefit-from-blockchain-a-blog-series-9d4d6bcd67f8">DAOs #0 — How we all can benefit from blockchain — a blog series</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/coinmonks">Coinmonks</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>