<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Condyles on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Peter Condyles on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@petercondyles?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 20:14:01 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@petercondyles/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Scotsman That (Really) Wanted to be King County Auditor]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/the-scotsman-that-really-wanted-to-be-king-county-auditor-93c45f09719a?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/93c45f09719a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Aug 2026 17:50:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-27T17:50:03.096Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Historians Note: I have always likened antique store shopping to going to a museum, only in this case you get to take the artifacts home with you. A few years ago, while at an antique store in the small hamlet of Conway, Washington I found something that sent me on a years long adventure. In a small, locked display case in the back of the store I discovered an undersized campaign pamphlet for a man that ran for County Auditor in 1912. Something about it seemed so mundane, but it intrigued me. Maybe it was the dapper man&#39;s photo, or the age of it along with the excellent condition. Whatever the case may be, I paid the $12 for the piece of paper and went home to figure out what significance my newfound artifact had.</em></p><p><em>After a few quick newspaper searches, I found that the subject of this pamphlet, Andrew J. Quigley was a Scottish Immigrant who had run for King County Auditor in 1912. The details of this race, and of Quigley’s involvement in Washington State politics fascinated me and made me want to dive deeper and deeper into this man’s life. I would pick up and put down this project over the period of four years, but the story of Andrew J. Quigley is too interesting not to tell. This story not only gives a glimpse into the political process of early Washington State but also serves as a case study for a political movement that swept the nation. This all came to be, because of one Scotsman that really wanted to be King County Auditor.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*WLL3tdQ0TvsrcaqlR3vzOg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The pamphlet found at an antique store in Conway Washington</figcaption></figure><p>What does a County Auditor do? Most people who are not creatures of politics might struggle to answer that question. Even today with information readily available, understanding the function of these seemingly bureaucratic positions is a tall order. That said, while not political in practice, positions like the County Auditor all too often get swept up in partisan politics further diluting what the function of the office actually is. As a consequence of this, elections for offices like these are not insulated from political trends that often start on the national scene. This was the case in the election for King County Auditor in 1912.</p><p>In February 1912, former President Theodore Roosevelt reentered presidential politics announcing he would seek a third term in office, after vacating the presidency four years earlier. Instead of running as a Republican as he had done throughout his career, he opted to run as a “Progressive” for a party that eventually became known as the Bull Moose Party. This announcement sent shockwaves through the Republican Party in all corners of the country. In Washington State, populist candidates had traditionally done very well. In fact, just twelve years earlier the state had elected Governor John Rankin Rodgers, who ran as a Populist. Because of this, the Republican Party in Washington split between those who supported Roosevelt and his progressive reforms, and those who supported the incumbent President William Howard Taft, and more traditional Republican values. The two factions would grow to hate each other, and this hate would spill out into every election on the ballot that year. From president all the way down to County Auditor, the schism in the Republican Party was on full display. Andrew J. Quigley, along with many other candidates, would get caught in that schism.</p><p>Andrew J. Quigley was born in Scotland in 1862. When he was just twenty-two, he immigrated to the United States and settled in Chicago. He went on to attend The Michigan State Normal School where he got his certification to be a teacher, and then eventually returned to Chicago to attend Northwestern University where he became a Certified Public Accountant. He would go into public service as a career, working for a number of cities in Illinois and Indiana to improve efficiencies, and balance their books. By all accounts, he was a smart man who had a mind for numbers and public accounting. It would be his wife, though, that helped take him to the next level politically.</p><p>On April 28, 1892, Andrew Quigley married Jessamine Greene in Chicago. Jessamine came from a very large and influential family, and had a keen sense for politics, and for publicity. She was a socialite in all respects, and this would push her new husband out of his comfort zone, but it would also prepare him to eventually run for office. The newlyweds would go on to make their home in Hammond, Indiana, just across the border from Illinois, and involve themselves with the city’s robust social scene. In reviewing the newspapers during the Quigleys’ time living in Hammond, Andrew is almost never mentioned, but Jessamine is mentioned almost weekly. From ladies&#39; groups at her house, to charity events, and gossip articles, Jessamine Quigley was at the center of the social scene in Hammond. For almost a decade Jessamine entertained the social class of Hammond, while her husband quietly continued his work with cities to improve their financial position. They had become somewhat of a power couple in their own right. This would all change in 1907, when to the dismay of the Hammond social class, the Quigleys announced they were moving west to Seattle. Jessamine’s sister Mayella Conway had been in Seattle for a number of years, and they decided to move and be closer to her. This did not stop Jessamine’s social rise, or her husband’s successful career.</p><h3>The Quigleys of Seattle</h3><p>Once in Seattle, Andrew and Jessamine wasted no time working toward their own personal and professional goals. Jessamine got involved with countless ladies&#39; clubs, and other civic organizations quickly rising to a place of prominence amongst Seattle society. This elevated social status, and deep civic connection would come in handy not only for Jessamine’s goals, but eventually for her husband’s political aspirations.</p><p>In Seattle, Andrew found work in the government efficiency and auditing sector utilizing his credentials as a certified public accountant and experience working for cities in the Midwest. He rose through the ranks of this industry very quickly, and within a short few years became the general manager of the Seattle Bureau of Public Efficiency. This organization acted as a watchdog group for government spending and waste and was routinely hired by cities and other government entities to perform audits and make recommendations on how to balance budgets and cut wasteful spending. One of the most high-profile clients came in late 1911 and early 1912, when the Seattle City Council considered hiring Andrew and the firm to perform an audit of the city’s books. The contract was initially $7,500 for six-months, but the council eventually negotiated the price down to $5,000. This would be over $150,000 in 2026.</p><p>While this contract was being considered by the city council, candidates had already begun to file for the 1912 Seattle municipal elections that were to take place that March. One office that was on the ballot was that of City Comptroller, who acts as the chief financial officer of the city, and in theory performs audits of all city departments. In January 1912, while in the middle of negotiating a contract with the city council, Quigley announced his intention to run for Seattle City Comptroller. This became a sticking point for the councilmembers considering the contract with Quigley, and the compromise ultimately became that if Quigley were awarded the contract he would drop out of the race for Comptroller. By the end of the month, the council had made the decision not to proceed with Quigley’s contract, allowing him to freely run for city Comptroller.</p><p>Quigley’s race for Seattle City Comptroller in early 1912 was his first attempt at running for office and as is the case with many first-time candidates he did not win. In fact, Quigley finished a close third in the primary election in February of that year. If he had just gotten about five hundred more votes he would have secured a spot in the March general election. The race was ultimately won by fellow CPA Harry Carroll. While he didn’t win this race, this brief campaign gave a glimpse into how Jessamine and her connections within the Seattle social networks would help her husband, as the Seattle Women’s Taxpayer’s League funded a series of advertisements for Quigley, and a “Women for Quigley” club was formed to support the campaign. This would prove to be somewhat of a “warm-up” for this network as they would again be utilized a few short months later when Quigley re-entered the political arena.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/1*3IiVR57ZM40egE8jQHYQAA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A pro-Quigley advertisement paid for by the Women’s Taxpayer’s League</figcaption></figure><h3>The Scot Standpat for Auditor</h3><p>While politically Andrew Quigley had not been successful, professionally his services were in high demand. The general consensus among professionals in Seattle and King County was that Quigley was good at what he did, and was a foremost expert on government efficiency, even if they didn’t want to vote for him. This led Quigley to the King County Auditor&#39;s Office, where in May 1912 he was offered a job as the Chief Deputy Auditor to incumbent County Auditor Otto Case. At nearly the same time, Case announced he would not seek re-election as Auditor in November of that year and instead would run for Governor as a member of the Bull Moose Party. In what could have been the worst-kept secret in 1912 King County politics, Case wanted to ensure the employees in his office would keep their jobs after he left office and brought on Quigley as his deputy to begin training him to run for the top spot later that year. Politically this was risky for Case, as the Republican Party had split earlier that year, and Case had sided with Theodore Roosevelt and the Progressive wing of the party and became a Bull Moose, while Quigley had sided with William Howard Taft and became what the Progressives would call a “Standpat”. The war between these two factions was about to be on full display as the elections of 1912 in Seattle and King County began to take shape.</p><p>Regardless of the political implications, Andrew Quigley announced his candidacy for the Republican nomination for King County Auditor in May of 1912. Initially, Case vowed to support Quigley publicly, but soon after his announcement, their plan was derailed by one of their colleagues, a young man named Claude Gage. Gage was the marriage certificate clerk within the Auditor’s office, and by all accounts had been a good employee for Auditor Case for a number of years. Politically, he was aligned with his boss, as a member of the new Bull Moose Party. Soon after Quigley’s announcement, Gage himself announced his candidacy for the Bull Moose Party nomination for King County Auditor. With two candidates from within the Auditor’s office, Case quickly called them into his office to discuss the situation. During that conversation Case committed to not support either man, instead letting the voters decide who was the best fit. Case also got both men to commit to not firing any of the Auditor’s office staff should they win the election. Both Quigley and Gage agreed to this, and the race to succeed their boss was on.</p><p>Even though less than a year before the election of 1912 the Standpats and the Bull Mooses had been members of the same party, they developed a deep loathing for each other as the November election came into sight. Newspapers that had once supported all Republican candidates now bitterly opposed their one-time allies, and the political party machines that had previously supported certain candidates now actively worked to defeat them. The target of a considerable amount of negative campaigning was Andrew Quigley himself. One of the main mouthpieces against Quigley was the newspaper <em>The Seattle Republican</em>, which as its name suggests was a reliably Republican newspaper that had turned to supporting Roosevelt and the Bull Moose Party. Upon Quigley’s announcement, <em>The Republican </em>stated that</p><p><em>“Andrew J. Quigley, who has recently acquired the office itch has announced his candidacy for County Auditor. Another political drubbing is in store for Mr. Quigley”</em></p><p>To make matters even worse, the Standpat Republicans also started to come after Quigley as the primary election neared going so far as to claim that Quigley was neither a Bull Moose nor a Standpat, but actually a Democrat. His main Republican primary opponent Elmer Conner took out a full-page ad in Seattle newspapers claiming as much with the large words “DO NOT VOTE FOR ANDREW QUIGLEY” prominently displayed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QbRniZt6W__W_OjUAiNKEw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Despite the accusation of being a secret Democrat, Quigley prevailed over Conner in the September primary election. As was the case nationally, the general election would include a Republican, a Democrat, a Progressive (Bull Moose), and a Socialist candidate for King County Auditor. National politics from Washington D.C. had trickled down to one of the most local and technical offices on the other side of the country.</p><h3>Behind Every Successful Man…</h3><p>Even with the support of the Republican voters in the primary, Quigley was still subject to attacks from within his own party. The most damaging would come in early October when Republican Party officials claimed that Andrew Quigley was not in fact a United States citizen. The allegation pushed by Republican Party Chairman Metcalf and his former opponent Elmer Conner was that in 1910 when Quigley first registered as a Republican in King County, he claimed he was naturalized in 1895 in Lake County, Indiana. However, when filing to run for office in 1912, Quigley stated that he was naturalized in 1904, nine years later than he first claimed. On October 5, 1912, Quigley was summoned before the executive board of the Republican Party and given until October 7 to produce proof that he was a naturalized citizen of the United States and eligible to run for office. In a statement to <em>The Seattle Post-Intelligencer</em>, Quigley stated that “the charge is a campaign canard.”</p><p>As was the case in most parts of Quigley’s life, it would be his wife Jessamine who would come to his rescue. On the morning of October 7, Jessamine Quigley, who had also been serving as his campaign manager, appeared at the offices of <em>The Seattle Post-Intelligencer</em> with the necessary documents to prove that her husband had become a naturalized citizen on October 16, 1896, in Lake County, Indiana. She also produced the following statement from her husband:</p><p><em>“When I registered in 1910, 1911, and 1912, the registration clerk stated that an approximate date would suffice, and I gave the following dates from memory: 1892, 1893, and 1894. By referring to my naturalization papers I now find that my declaration of intentions was made in the Superior Court of Cook County Illinois on April 6, 1891, four years after coming to the United States from Scotland, and that I was admitted to citizenship by the Superior Court of Lake County Indiana October 16, 1896.”</em></p><p>While this seemed to put the issue to bed, what was more remarkable about this whole episode turned out not to be the statement issued by the candidate himself, but by his wife. In addition to supplying <em>The Seattle PI</em> with her husband’s statement, Jessamine wrote one of her own. This statement seemed to have been received in such high regard that the paper chose to run it above the statement from the candidate. Jessamine Quigley’s statement read as follows:</p><p><em>“Has Mr. Quigley been naturalized? Oh yes, years ago, and the papers have been carefully preserved, and for the first time I have now shown them. Again, they will be tenderly folded and marked exhibit A and go back beside my marriage certificate and the birth certificates of our boys, and a few other foolish things women will keep.</em></p><p><em>My own citizenship goes back to 1620, when that famous little boat, Mayflower, left England and bore among its passengers the Whites, Howards, and Winslows, my ancestors. I have no doubt that Mr. Quigley’s ancestors saw them off and bade them godspeed. In the war of the revolution several of their descendents took and active part in the defense of the country. I am proud of the fact that I am a member of the Daughters of the Revolution, as well as state Secretary of the Mayflower Descendents of Washington.</em></p><p><em>While Mr. Quigley’s ancestors stayed longer in the mother country than mine did, I can see no difference in our loyalty to our country and its institutions. Together for twenty years, we have taken an interest, an active interest, in all lines of human advancement and were associated for years with some for the social workers of Chicago. When Mr. Quigley was asked by several civic organizations to run for the office of County Auditor because they believed he gave them efficient service, I gave my consent, realizing that our crying need today is honest, industrious, and capable men in public service.</em></p><p><em>Our public business can and will be done as efficiently and economically as private business when we select men trained in business principles, not mere political office holders. The time is past when a horse trader or hotel keeper can successfully run for positions requiring technical training.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*48E_SjmmsIz1XK7wu9rxNQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jessamine in the Society page of The Seattle Post-Intelligencer with her sons Kenneth and Allan.</figcaption></figure><p>Jessamine had emerged as one of the most effective forces behind her husband’s campaign. While he issued a statement solely focused on the facts of the issue at hand, his wife issued a statement that eloquently defended and advocated for her husband. The combination of the two statements seemed to put any doubt about Andrew’s citizenship to rest. This wouldn’t be where Jessamine’s campaign assistance ended.</p><p>As noted, Jessamine Quigley was a renowned member of Seattle society. There was hardly a social group, or ladies’ club in the city that she was not a part of or connected to in some way. As her husband’s campaign heated up, and the election got closer, she utilized these connections for political purposes. Throughout late summer and early fall, one would be hard pressed not to find a daily article in Seattle newspapers informing the readers of Andrew Quigley’s attendance at some social club or civic organization throughout the city. Groups that Jessamine arranged to host her husband included the Taxpayers League, the Nonpartisan Women’s League, Women’s Commercial Club, The Federated Improvement Club, Council of Women Voters, The West Hill Club, and The Northend Progressive Club. As was the case in Quigley’s race for Comptroller, some of these organizations, mostly the women’s organizations, would pay for advertisements for him in local newspapers.</p><p>At some of these meetings Andrew was joined by other prominent politicians of the day, including on some occasions Governor Marion Hay, who made stops in Seattle for his own re-election campaign, and to assist local Republicans. In one such appearance at the Leschi Heights Improvement Club there were three advertised speakers, Governor Hay, Andrew Quigley, and Jessamine Quigley. Based on her written defense of her husband to <em>The Seattle PI</em>, having her as a campaign surrogate was a wise choice on the part of the candidate. With the citizenship question behind him, things seemed to be going in Quigley’s favor, and as the election came into view, his campaign continued to be met with good news.</p><h3>The Fall and Rise of the Bull Moose</h3><p>Soon after the citizenship episode dissipated, local newspapers quickly found another political story to fill their pages. After months of campaigning and winning the primary election for the Bull Moose Party, Claude Gage, Quigley’s co-worker turned political opponent, made the announcement that he would drop out of the election and endorse Quigley. This announcement came October 5, just days before the cutoff to replace candidates on the ballot. The rumor spreading in the media was that this had been the plan all along and that Gage, Quigley, and Auditor Otto Case were all in on it to ensure Quigley won the election. None of the three men ever acknowledged that such a plan existed.</p><p>In his statement to the press, Gage called on the Bull Moose Party leaders to not replace his name on the ballot but instead throw their support behind Quigley who he believed was the most qualified candidate for the job. As an employee of the Auditor’s office, Gage had an intimate understanding of how the office functioned and what it would take to be its leader. His withdrawal highlighted the technical nature of the position and was an attempt to pull the Auditor’s race out of the hyper-partisan environment that had consumed it. In the aftermath of Gage’s withdrawal, it was reported that a number of women&#39;s clubs also flooded Bull Moose meetings to advocate for Quigley. Unsurprisingly, the Bull Moose Party, who was still in an all-out war with their Standpat opposition, did not take the advice of their former candidate and got to work to fill the spot on the ballot with only days to go.</p><p>The Bull Moose Party wasted no time replacing Gage on the ballot. Just two days later party leaders announced they had unanimously nominated Byron Phelps to be their nominee for County Auditor. Phelps was no stranger to King County politics; in addition to being a Civil War veteran, Phelps served as King County Treasurer from 1890 to 1894, and Mayor of Seattle from 1894 to 1896. Phelps told local papers that while he did not seek out the nomination for County Auditor, he would accept it. In fact, Phelps was on vacation out of the city when the nomination was made. Local progressive newspapers hailed this choice as a wise one and ran a number of puff pieces touting Phelps’ war record, and his record as an elected official in the 1890s.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/482/0*J0tv6NCzBKBQ0D2K.jpg" /><figcaption>Byron Phelps</figcaption></figure><p>With a little under a month until the election, Quigley, Phelps, and J.W. Valin, the Democratic candidate for Auditor, hit the campaign trail. With the citizenship question, and the Gage scandal behind them, the Auditor’s race calmed down significantly, and throughout the latter part of October the race took a clear backseat to other statewide and federal elections. Outside of paid advertisements and candidate rallies and events the closing of the race was devoid of the fireworks that had plagued it to this point. The race ended in an appropriate fashion for an elected position so mundane and bureaucratic in nature.</p><p>On November 5, 1912, King County voters went to the polls, and the results were mixed in contests between Standpat Republicans, and Bull Moose Progressives. Presidentially, Roosevelt won the County, but for Governor, Democrat Ernest Lister was able to win the county with only 37% due to the two Republican factions splitting the vote at about 26% each. Down the ballot however, Standpat Republicans did considerably well in the local races, with one glaring exception, the race for King County Auditor. Here, Progressive Byron Phelps narrowly edged out Andrew Quigley with the following vote count:</p><p>Phelps- 21,220</p><p>Quigley- 20,465</p><p>Valin- 12,713</p><p>Clise (Socialist)- 6,419</p><p>Byron Phelps had won the election, and reports began almost immediately that he intended to clean house in the Auditor’s office, and fire most of Otto Case’s staff. This was the exact situation that Case actively tried to prevent. While Case was licking his wounds politically from this, and his loss in the primary for Governor, Andrew Quigley was not going to accept the defeat. In fact, he intended to fight the results of the election he believed to be unfair, and he was ready to take the fight as far as he needed to.</p><h3>(Re)Start the Count</h3><p>Andrew Quigley did not believe that he lost the election for King County Auditor on November 5. In fact, he believed that there were problems with the way the ballots had been counted in the office where he was the deputy leader. The question in the wake of the election was if Quigley intended to contest the election in court. On November 18, nearly two weeks after election day, Quigley issued a thank you letter to the voters who placed their votes and confidence in him. In the letter he claimed that his loss had much to do with national trends stating that:</p><p><em>“The returns show that thousands of voters responded to the slogan of the party leaders to vote a ‘straight ticket’ and as Roosevelt had a lead of 11,300 over Taft, this was a serious handicap to anyone on the Republican ticket.</em></p><p><em>An analysis of the votes shows that I received 5,700 votes more than the head of the Republican ticket, while my opponent received 5,100 votes less than the head of the Progressive ticket. My opponent was only elected by a small majority.”</em></p><p>With the tone of this message, it seemed that Quigley was dropping his intention to contest the election. However, a week later on November 23, George Rummens, attorney for Quigley, filed papers with King County Superior Court requesting a recount in the Auditor’s race. The evidence that Quigley submitted in the filing was that many sources from polling places stated that those counting the votes had purposely counted votes meant for Quigley as Phelps, and that it was a coordinated effort from the Phelps campaign to steal the election. Quigley argued that the tally sheets were wrong, and the ballot boxes should be reopened and recounted. Washington State law at the time stated that recounts were only permitted in cases when substantial evidence was brought to warrant them. It was Quigley’s belief that this evidence was enough to trigger a recount.</p><p>On December 12 Quigley and Phelps appeared before King County Superior Court Judge Robert Albertson. After presenting their cases, Judge Albertson dismissed Quigley’s initial application for a recount in the election. In his decision Judge Albertson offered criticism of Quigley’s filing stating that:</p><p><em>“The Plaintiff ought not to charge malconduct of election officers unless prepared to produce evidence of it in the court. There are 391 election precincts in King County, and an election board in each precinct who are charged with malconduct. There ought to be in this case proof against some of them if the action is to be maintained. Even if one case of malconduct should be shown that would not be proof of others.</em></p><p><em>If the Plaintiff insists on opening the ballot boxes before proving malconduct, the court must dismiss these proceedings. I will not hear proof of the sufficiency of the protection of the ballot boxes after the election unless some proof of malconduct of election officers is produced.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z3CnLgv4crcTXHYx7xeM8Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>The reference to “protection of the ballot boxes” by Judge Albertson was in regard to the retained ballots that legally had to be guarded by Sheriff’s Deputies at the King County Courthouse. The law stated that multiple deputies must be on duty to guard the ballot boxes at the courthouse while the legal process surrounding a potential recount made its way through the courts. This was a pain point for lame duck Auditor Otto Case, who was extremely frustrated with his deputy for making the office spend about $20 (nearly $700 in 2026) a day in overtime for the officers to guard the boxes. The dismissal of the case meant that the officers could cease guarding the boxes, however, on December 23 the Washington State Supreme Court announced that it had taken up Andrew Quigley’s application for an extraordinary writ, meaning the guards would have to continue watching the ballot boxes.</p><p>Quigley’s application for an extraordinary writ was a way to skip the appeals process in the Superior Court and Appeals Court and go directly to the state Supreme Court and ask for a recount. The rationale for this was that Byron Phelps was set to be sworn in as Auditor on January 18, and Quigley claimed that the court needed to make a decision on whether a recount would be carried out before Phelps took over the office and presumably made that recount impossible. In the meantime, while the Supreme Court was deciding on Quigley’s application, the sheriff’s deputies guarding the ballot boxes decided to go on strike, requesting increased pay and heaters in the cold storage room of the County Courthouse. This strike did not last long as on January 5 the Supreme Court announced that it had denied Quigley’s writ, and the case would have to go through the normal process for appeals. With that, Auditor Case felt it appropriate to dismiss the sheriff’s deputies guarding the ballot boxes. While it seemed like the end for Quigley, the Supreme Court would be hearing from him again soon.</p><h3>Ambition and Heartbreak</h3><p>Andrew Quigley was not finished in his crusade to become King County Auditor, or his crusade to hold public office. He continued the appeals process to get a recount in the election for County Auditor, even as Byron Phelps took the helm of the Auditor’s office and replaced many of Otto Case’s employees with his own. On January 19, while still battling over his loss in the election a few months prior, Quigley announced that he would be a candidate for Seattle City Council in the March elections. This race would produce forty-four candidates that were all vying for three positions on the city council. In the February primary election, all the candidates would appear on the same ballot, and the top six would move on to the general election. In the March election all six candidates would again appear on the same ballot, and the top three would be elected.</p><p>Quigley’s campaign for Seattle City Council was run much like his campaign for City Comptroller, and County Auditor. He emphasized his experience helping cities to make efficiencies and save money, while auditing the books to find wasteful spending. Unfortunately for Quigley, his message did not resonate with voters, and he placed seventeenth in the field of forty-four. While Quigley was no doubt distraught over the lack of success in his political career, his old enemies at <em>The Seattle Republican</em> could hardly contain their excitement that their old foe had once again lost, remarking that “it looks as if the voters had tired of seeing him run for office.”</p><p>Even though he had just lost another election, Quigley was still determined to get his case back to the Supreme Court to order a recount in the 1912 Auditor’s election. In March of 1913 his appeal of Judge Albertson’s dismissal of the recount was formally rejected by the appeals court, which set him up to once again go before the Supreme Court. This case was different from the one he had earlier taken to the high court in that the question before the Justices was not about procedure as was the case in January, but about whether or not there should be a recount.</p><p>While preparing for this case, tragedy struck for Andrew Quigley when on April 14, 1913, Jessamine died of cancer, an illness she had been battling since the beginning of the year. In response to her death tributes poured into newspapers about her positive impact on local organizations and civic clubs. Publications across Seattle and The Pacific Northwest devoted considerable print space to her obituaries and to articles honoring her memory. Jessamine’s funeral was held on Thursday, April 17, at Seattle’s First Presbyterian Church where it was reported that her casket was completely covered in numerous floral arrangements, and that the Mayor of Seattle and other prominent members of the city attended to pay their respects. She was then cremated at Mount Pleasant Cemetery, where her ashes were interred. Andrew Quigley had lost his wife, mother to his two sons, and most valued political advisor. He would never run for public office again.</p><p>Even with this personal tragedy, Quigley continued with his appeal to the Supreme Court. On May 28, just over a month after Jessamine’s funeral, Quigley and his legal team argued their case in Olympia. It didn’t take long for the court to come back with a decision, denying Quigley’s request for a recount and upholding the original decision from Judge Albertson. The opinion written by Justice Overton Ellis stated in part:</p><p><em>In the case before us, the only evidence offered as to any irregularity was that the footings made by the election officers on the tally sheets were in many instances wrong; but it is admitted that these errors were all corrected by the canvassing board. They were mere mistakes in addition and did not materially change the result. This was no evidence of fraud or malconduct, nor even of mistake in the actual tally. The sheets themselves furnished the means of correction, and the correction of such errors is the very purpose of the canvass. The canvassing board has no other reason for existence.</em></p><p><em>The argument that a contestant, though strongly suspecting malconduct, would have no means of proving it outside of the ballots themselves does not impress us. Some evidence of the wholesale conspiracy charged could be produced. All of the 1,173 election officers would be competent witnesses to testify as to the manner of making the count. If there was any irregularity in their action such as would authorize a recount, their testimony would disclose it. Packard v. Craig, 114 Cal. 95, 45 Pac. 1033; Kindel v. Le Bert, supra.</em></p><p><em>In conclusion, we say that if the legislature had intended that the entire vote of any county, and for the same reason, of every county in the state, should be recounted upon mere demand (and that is what the appellant’s contention amounts to), it would have been easy to so state. If it was intended that the certificate of election based upon the official count by the election officers should have no force as against an unsupported charge of fraud or incompetence on their part, and that official action shall no longer possess even a prima facie presumption of rectitude, then the legislature should have so stated. If such is to be declared the public policy of this state, then the functions of election officials will become an idle form. Much time and expense would be saved by simply limiting their duties to a mere reception and sealing of the ballots and delivering them to the courts for counting in the first instance.</em></p><p><em>We find no abuse of discretion in the refusal of the trial court to recount the ballots, in the absence of any evidence of malconduct on the part of the election officials.</em></p><p>This decision, known today as Quigley v Phelps, established a precedent in Washington State law regarding election recounts, and is still cited by courts in Washington to this day. With this decision though, Andrew Quigley’s hopes of being King County Auditor was finished.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/208/0*5i4UD7AG23_0LhCx.jpg" /><figcaption>Justice Overton Ellis</figcaption></figure><h3>What Was Left Behind</h3><p>After losing his election for City Council in 1913, and his appeal of the Auditor’s election, Andrew Quigley retreated back into private life. In 1915 he moved back to Chicago and returned to working as a CPA and advisor for municipalities, conducting audits of their books as he had done before entering politics. In addition to this, he became a faculty member at the La Salle School of Accounting in Chicago, where he taught classes on public finance. Outside of his professional life, he remarried in 1918 to Mary Bernard of Ohio, and the two settled in Illinois. The remainder of Andrew Quigley’s life was quiet, and out of the spotlight. Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, public mentions of Andrew Quigley were almost exclusively regarding audit work he had done for various cities in the Midwest.</p><p>Andrew Quigley died on July 31, 1936, at age seventy-five. No obituaries were run in his memory, and the only available mention of his death was in the newspaper <em>Berwyn Life</em> that reported the City Council of Berwyn, Illinois was attempting to figure out how much of their audit Quigley had finished before his death. He was cremated, and his ashes were spread on the grounds of Graceland Cemetery in Chicago. His name was not memorialized anywhere on the cemetery grounds. Andrew Quigley would leave this life with only minor traces of his existence left behind.</p><p>Politically, 1912 was an unprecedented year for our nation. The split among the Republican Party with the reemergence of Theodore Roosevelt as a presidential candidate turned the entire political system on its head. This shift in politics and divide among the Republican Party trickled down to the most local offices and was the reality Andrew Quigley had to deal with running for a seemingly bureaucratic position. In all likelihood, Andrew Quigley was one of the most qualified candidates to be King County Auditor in 1912, and had the technical skills needed to be successful in that office. But as is the case today, the recipe to winning an election is a mixture of qualifications, and good political instincts. Quigley possessed the qualifications and with Jessamine by his side, enough political instincts to nearly overcome a disastrous partisan environment, but not quite enough to escape it. While President Taft trailed Roosevelt by 11,000 votes in King County, Quigley lost by less than 1,000. In the election of 1912 Andrew Quigley got caught in a brief but intense period of American political history that ultimately ushered in a new era of party politics.</p><p>In the aftermath of that election Quigley refused to accept the results and turned to the courts as a remedy. Regardless of its merits, his crusade helped produce a Washington State Supreme Court precedent on election law that continues to be cited more than a century later. While there are no physical markers memorializing Andrew or Jessamine Quigley in King County, Chicago, or Scotland, Andrew’s name nevertheless found a permanent place in Washington State political history. In the end, it was the election he lost that ensured he would not be forgotten.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=93c45f09719a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Logger That Saved a Forest: The Origins of Mother Nature’s Window]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/the-logger-that-saved-a-forest-the-origins-of-mother-natures-window-f96c07c7d455?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f96c07c7d455</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Jan 2026 23:53:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-10T21:18:28.799Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As a society, we celebrate change. From technological innovations to breakthroughs in science, we are always craving the next step toward modernity. Along with that, we also celebrate the change makers. Those innovators, scientists, and entrepreneurs that are always pushing the bounds of what is possible to create the impossible. But what about those that want to keep things the same? The people who want to preserve what is great about society and culture in this very moment, or what has been great about it in the past. Looking at what is celebrated and encouraged today, it seems that it is almost more difficult to try and conserve the wonders of today against the potential of new, better, wonders tomorrow. Now of course the world is not this black and white. One can celebrate and encourage innovation and change, while working to preserve what is worthy of preservation. But the latter task is inevitably going to be the more cumbersome one. One area where this tug-of-war between preservation and innovation has been ragging for centuries is that of land conservation.</p><p>One of the most celebrated conservationists in United States history was President Theodore Roosevelt. During his time in office President Roosevelt established the National Park Service, passed the 1906 Antiquities Act, and created five new national parks, and eighteen new national monuments. In addition to this, he was also an avid hunter, fisherman, and encouraged innovation while President. He was somebody that understood the power struggle between yesterday and tomorrow and governed as such. In fact, in a speech given in Osawatomie Kansas in 1910, Roosevelt stated:</p><p><em>“Conservation means development as much as it does protection. I recognize the right and duty of this generation to develop and use the natural resources of our land; but I do not recognize the right to waste them, or to rob, by wasteful use, the generations that come after us.”</em></p><p>In Western Washington, Roosevelt’s words still ring true. As one of the fastest growing regions in the United States, the pressures of development against conservation and vis-versa play out every day. The need for housing and economic development against natural resources and recreation. The tug-of-war continues over a century after Roosevelt started his crusade. One man who carried on that crusade in Marysville was Merton (Mert) Turk. A man with the spirit, and the contradictions of Roosevelt.</p><p>Turk, who spent his career as a logger, worked for many decades to preserve a portion of second growth forest in the middle of urban Marysville. This thirty-five-acre piece of land now known as Mother Nature’s Window is home to native plants, animals, and insects. More importantly though, it gives city residents an opportunity to experience unspoiled nature in the middle of their city. On more than one occasion Turk would go toe to toe with housing developers to save this land, and win. Thanks to Turk’s tireless efforts over many decades, the City of Marysville is on the verge of (re)opening Mother Nature’s Window as a city park in 2026. While the Mother Nature’s Window of today is thanks in large part to the efforts and determination of Mert Turk, four generations of Turks have lived on or around Mother Nature’s Window and have all played a part in its conservation. To appreciate just how much it took to preserve this land, it&#39;s important to understand just how much its gone through.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/779/1*MmSyY8pCJ3zydFIlpEfaGg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sign at Mother Nature’s Window</figcaption></figure><h3>BT (Before Turks)</h3><p>Mother Nature’s Window, and the land surrounding it was granted to John Brady by President Ulysses S. Grant on October 1st, 1875, to homestead. In one of Marysville history’s more ironic turns, Brady sold a large portion of his land to prominent logger Nicholas Healy sometime in the 1890’s. In fact, the word prominent might undersell just how influential Healy was to the logging industry in the Pacific Northwest at the turn of the century.</p><p>Born in 1852 on a farm in Ontario, Healy was the youngest of eight children. He left home at age sixteen and found himself employed in the logging industry in Michigan. Hearing lore of big timber in the Pacific Northwest, the young Healy made his way west in 1872, eventually settling in Olympia. Over the next two decades Healy would work in the logging industry at various mills and lumber yards throughout Washington and British Columbia. He gained a reputation as a hard worker, and a skilled logger. These skills led him to establish his own lumber company in 1895 with William Sisco, The Healy &amp; Sisco logging company. Healy &amp; Sisco operated along Ebey Slough and was a major employer in early Marysville. Two years later Healy and Sisco would join forces with C.H. Cobb, A.S. Kerry, and M.F. Backus to form the Port Susan Logging Company. This would go on to be one of the largest logging companies in the region. In addition to these business ventures, Healy was also the General Manager of the International Timber Company in British Columbia, and the General Manager of the Marysville-Arlington Railroad. Later in his life, he and C.H. Cobb would form the Cobb-Healy Investment Company based in Seattle. Throughout his career Healy lived in Marysville, becoming a key member of civic life in the infant city. His civic interests, and personal interests would collide in 1888 when he married Estella Comeford, the only daughter of Marysville’s founder James Comeford. Over the next decade they would have six children until Estella’s untimely death in 1898 at just 30 years old.</p><p>The piece of land that Healy purchased from Brady was much larger than the footprint of Mother Nature’s Window today. About triple the size in fact. The property ran from the eastern boundary of the park, west along present day 100th Street to 51st Avenue and then south to about where 93rd Place is today. Now there is no definitive written proof that Healy logged the property once he bought it. However, there is good circumstantial evidence to make this claim. The first, and most convincing being the age of the trees at Mother Nature’s Window today. Contrary to some claims, the trees at the park are not old growth, they are second growth. As the name implies, second growth trees are trees that were planted after the old growth trees were cut down. Studies done in the late 1990’s put the time of planting for these trees around the time Healy would have owned the property. Given his involvement in the logging industry, it would not be a surprise that he purchased the property to harvest the timber. Over the next two decades Healy would sell off pieces of this large property to different buyers, but he retained ownership of a large portion of it until his death in 1915.</p><h3>A Brief Detour Down the Comeford Road</h3><p>In addition to the natural and environmental history present at Mother Nature’s Window, there are claims of another piece of history present on the property, and that is Comeford Road. While there is much speculation about Comeford Road, there are some things that are known for sure.</p><p>There was absolutely a road that ran through the southeast corner of Mother Nature’s Window. It is present on the earliest maps of the area. In fact, this road is still visible from aerial images, and the trail system within the park follows this historic path. The road ran from the town of Marysville out to properties northeast of the city eventually connecting to another road near the present-day intersection of 67th Avenue and 132nd Street. The road was traveled by early pioneers that had homesteads away from Marysville to more easily travel back to town. It was also used by loggers to access timber in the interior of the county. Many have claimed, including Mert Turk himself, that this road was named Comeford Road, after the founder of Marysville James Comeford. There is no evidence based on mapping from that era to confirm or deny this claim. The argument is that the Comefords, who did in fact own land out in this area, built the road to get from their house in Marysville to their property outside town. Because of this the road was named after them. Whether or not the road had that name during this period of time or not, it definitely stuck with later residents and many still use the name to this day. Some have also suggested that Comeford Road was once a railroad. This claim also has no evidence to back it up and is actually quite unlikely given there were two railroad lines a few miles in either direction.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/577/1*s6_eeGPHmpAs8uY64wK2Sw.png" /><figcaption>Map of Healy’s property showing a road running through the southeast corner. Notice the property owned by T. Turk bordering Healy’s.</figcaption></figure><h3>AT (After Turks)</h3><p>The first member of the Turk family to move to this part of Marysville was Thomas Turk in 1904. He purchased a piece of property that bordered Healy’s property directly south of the present-day Mother Nature’s Window. This purchase would begin over one hundred years of continuous Turk family ownership in this part of the city. Over this period of time, four generations of Turks have owned property in this area. During some periods, up to five different members of the family have owned different properties on or around Mother Nature’s Window. In fact, Thomas Turks’ great grandson still owns property in this part of Marysville.</p><p>Thomas Henry Turk was born in 1852, the same year as Nicholas Healy. Also, like Healy, Turk was born in Ontario Canada and came to the United States in 1879. He settled in Minnesota and lived there for about two decades. It was here Turk met his wife Ernestine (Tena), a German Immigrant. They were married in Fergus Falls Minnesota on May 4, 1897. They would remain in Minnesota for some time, before making their journey west to Snohomish County in 1904. When they arrived, they already had five children (Tena had one from her first husband who died), and they would go on to have seven more, eleven children total. Only one of those eleven was a girl. With this many children all growing up in this part of Marysville it begins to make more sense how the family has remained in one place for so long. Four of the eleven children would stay and own pieces of land on or around Mother Nature’s window, William, Lewis, Roy, and Max (Thomas’s stepson). For the purposes of Mother Nature’s Window, William is the most crucial to the story, as he was Mert’s father.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/1*mw-b09Rd5Q4Equfs-uxWWQ.png" /><figcaption>William and Stella Turk in 1922 (right) and 1972 (left)</figcaption></figure><p>William Lewis Turk (not to be confused with his younger brother Lewis William Turk) was the oldest child of Thomas and Tena. Born in 1897 in Fergus Falls Minnesota, he was just seven years old when his family made the trek west to Snohomish County. He would go on to be the first of Thomas Turk’s children to purchase land near his father’s property, when he bought a small piece of land from Albert Grannell in 1927. This property is the southeast corner of 100th and 55th today and is still owned by the Turk family. Grannell had purchased the property over a decade prior from the Healy family after Nicholas passed away. William would go on to work in the logging industry from a young age, and work throughout the Pacific Northwest at various logging camps. When William and his wife Stella moved to their property in 1927, they brought with them their two children, one year old Marvin, and five-year-old Merton.</p><p>Merton Cecil Turk was born in 1922 in Everett. Once he moved to his family’s property north of Marysville in 1927, he never left. He grew up learning the logging industry from his father and took a particular interest in the natural environment around him. Once he was a logger in his own right, he and his father formed the Quil Ceda Logging Company together. This allowed Mert to purchase his own property in 1947 from the Hoekendorf family, just east of his father’s land, and north of his grandfather’s land. Most of the machinery associated with the Quil Ceda Logging Company would be located on Mert and William’s properties, and some can even still be seen there today. Over the course of his life Mert worked throughout the area, logging the forests of Snohomish County, and operating a mill back home. It was his connection to the land his family had been on for three generations though that would become his life’s work, something he described as his “greatest joy” and “deepest depression.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*51Y7gtF0OaoufxWJOYqsVg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mert Turk standing in Mother Nature’s Window</figcaption></figure><h3>Building A Window</h3><p>In the decades following his first land purchase, Mert would go on to purchase a number of properties bordering his land, eventually totaling fifteen acres. Most of these properties make up the Mother Nature’s Window one sees today. Initially Turk had planned to harvest the timber on these properties, but in 1963 he came up with a better idea. He was watching his own children enter adolescence and noticed that they didn’t have anywhere to go and safely be teenagers. An article published in 1986 described the impetus for the park from Mert’s perspective:</p><p><em>“(he) built the park…for his teenage son and his friends to have a place to go with their girlfriends where they could play music and drink beer…he had seen enough teenagers drink, drive, and die. He said he never provided alcohol but gave the teenagers a safe place to gather.”</em></p><p>And thus, Mother Nature’s Window was born. Over the next decade he would add a number of amenities to the park including a dance floor, bandstand, outhouses, food service area, running water, stump seating, a BBQ, around 100 kerosene lamps in the trees, picnic tables he made himself, and an 8-track player built into the stump of a tree. He also devised a pully system to lift speakers into the trees. Mert wanted to make everything out of recycled material and was against anything store bought being used in the park. As such, the dance floor was made from wood chips the city would donate after windstorms required them to grind up fallen trees. His grandson Jason Turk described the park amenities as “subtle nuance with flair.” Mert also cared about the wildlife that lived in the park, and built special birdhouses, and boxes for the flying squirrels. These became important pieces of the outdoor education that would take place on the property. At its height the park could fit 200 people, and he made sure it was wheelchair accessible.</p><p>To say that Mert Turk devoted his life to Mother Nature’s Window would be an understatement. Friends would recall that Mert spent majority of the day out working on and adding to the park, and his wife would often have to honk the car horn to get him in for dinner from out in the forest. In fact, at one point his wife Laura told <em>The Everett Herald</em> that he was “married to this place.” Mert didn’t need much sleep either, which led one of the original park volunteers Kim Veenhuizen to refer to him as the “energizer bunny.” But this devotion did not come without its sacrifices. He would tell a story about one winter when he didn’t have enough money to buy his son a new winter coat and had to make the choice between spending his time working on the park, or devoting more time to logging, which paid the bills. A stark contradiction. These experiences would only help to grow his devotion to the forest around him.</p><p>As time went on, and the park grew, Mert grew the mission of Mother Nature’s Window. Initially meant to give kids a safe place to gather, he branched out and started offering the land to organizations that wanted to have events, and girls and boys scout troops to come and learn about nature. Many of those who knew Mert were quick to share his love for children. He enjoyed showing his property to children and helping them learn about nature and the wildlife around them. As Mother Nature’s Window became an increasingly popular place for groups to have events, Mert decided to start charging to use the property. Instead of pocketing the money though, he donated it all to the Seattle Children’s Hospital. Along the same lines, he began offering the park to children with disabilities at no cost, so that they could come and experience nature in a way that was otherwise very difficult for them. Mert would share in an interview that he was a very sick child growing up, and there weren’t many treatments for the illnesses he had, so sick and disabled children had a very special place in his heart. The park was hitting its stride, but as the decades rolled on, Mert Turk would be tested, and he would have to fight for the park that he had so lovingly created.</p><h3>Saving A Window</h3><p>Mother Nature’s Window and the forested land around it totaled about forty-six acres. Mert owned fifteen of those acres, and the other thirty-one were owned by various individuals the largest being the Duffy family. In 1990 the Duffy’s decided to sell their property to Belmark Industries, a local housing developer that had built a number of homes in Marysville and surrounding communities. Belmark’s plan was to develop the site into thirty-five homes and leave a three-acre buffer around the park . This meant that Mother Nature’s Window would be boxed in by houses on two sides. This did not sit right with Mert, and he got to work doing all he could to stop the development. He talked to anyone that would listen about saving the land around his park. <em>The Marysville Globe</em>, <em>The Everett Herald</em>, The City of Marysville, Snohomish County, and the Marysville Community Action Network all participated in his media crusade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/963/1*DS7Jno3idG3wSm7aiv4Qhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Map showing the proposed Belmark development</figcaption></figure><p>The request from Mert, the neighborhood, and the community became a county park. Their idea was that the county should purchase the property that Belmark owned and combine it with Mert’s property to create a larger Mother Nature’s Window. Because of the city’s sewer moratorium that was in place in 1990, Mert and those seeking to stop the development had time to find a way to make their county park dream a reality. They approached Snohomish County about the idea, and they were receptive. The county acknowledged that there were not many parks in this part of the county at the time, and that the Belmark development would “have a marked effect upon the integrity of the Mother Nature’s Window forest habitat.” That year the county applied for a Conservation Futures Grant to purchase the land from Belmark. Unfortunately, that year the project was not selected for funding.</p><p>A year passed, and Mert continued to look for a solution to stop the development. In that time however, the sewer moratorium was lifted by the city, and Belmark was able to move forward with their plans. In the Summer of 1992 Belmark presented their plat to Snohomish County Hearing Examiner John Galt for approval. Mert and many others were still trying to find the money to purchase the property from Belmark, and they testified as such before the Hearing Examiner. In response to this testimony Examiner Galt explained that “it would be illegal to deprive the property owners of the right to develop their land because of something that might or might not happen” and that “the development had been delayed two years by a moratorium on sewer hookups in Marysville. Anyone interested in buying the property had plenty of time to negotiate.” With that, Examiner Galt approved the plat submitted by Belmark, allowing them to move forward with construction. In response to this <em>The Everett Herald</em> declared “A 45-acre park seems increasingly unlikely.” Mert Turk was not deterred.</p><p>Later that year in a last-ditch effort, Snohomish County once again applied for a Conservation Futures grant to purchase the Belmark property. This grant was for $500,000. It wouldn’t cover the entire purchase price, but it would get them close. The county agreed to put up the rest of the money if the grant was issued. The city joined as a “joint applicant” with the understanding that one day the land would probably be annexed into the city, and Marysville would take over ownership and control of the park. This process took a number of months, but a week before Christmas 1992, the county council awarded the $500,000 grant. In April of the following year the county officially purchased the property from Belmark for $580,000 and put plans in motion to establish Mother Nature’s Window as an offical park. For now, Mother Nature’s Window was saved, but the fight would continue.</p><p>Not even a decade after Mert’s first fight with development, he was faced with another threat. The land east of Mother Nature’s Window between the park and an existing neighborhood was comprised of three long narrow parcels of land. In early 1998, Progressive Holdings, a development company out of Canada purchased two of the three properties with the intention of building houses. With no sewer moratorium to stand in their way, Progressive Holdings moved quickly to get approvals to construct their project. They initially requested the Snohomish County Hearing Examiner grant them a rezone to a higher density zone, which would allow them to build more houses. In July of that year the Hearing Examiner approved the rezone application, which would allow forty-two homes to be built on the eight-acre property. This time was different though. Snohomish County had already spent money developing Mother Nature’s Window, and they were bought in from the beginning to save it once again. They made no secrets about their desire to purchase the property from Progressive Holdings after they applied for their permits. Upon the approval of their rezone a representative from Progressive Holdings bluntly told <em>The Everett Herald</em> “The county is going to make us an offer for the property. If it&#39;s reasonable we would have to accept it.” That is exactly what the county did.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Md1YTGWtS8bOm3rzdWHhOw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Map showing the proposed Progressive Holdings development</figcaption></figure><p>Later that year, Snohomish County once again applied for a Conservation Futures grant to purchase the land from Progressive Holdings. This time they were looking to stop this from happening again. The county submitted a grant for $2.4 million dollars of which:</p><ul><li>$1 million would go to buying the 8.2-acre Progressive Holdings Property</li><li>$510,000 would go to buying the 6.3-acre property west of the Progressive Holdings property owned by the Hoekendork family</li><li>$781,000 would purchase 10 acres from Mert Turk with that agreement that he and his wife could live on the property for the rest of their lives.</li></ul><p>This would put all the land surrounding Mother Nature’s Window under county ownership, allowing them to preserve the entire forest. In October of 1998, the county council unanimously awarded the full grant, the final step in creating the Mother Nature’s Window seen today. Once everything was offical, the county got to work planning a full-fledged county park. However, once the county took ownership and began this work, they experienced a number of roadblocks that stopped any park development.</p><h3>Rebuilding A Window</h3><p>Long before Snohomish County contemplated the of idea Mother Nature’s Window as a park, Mert had been dealing with vandals. On the more innocent side of things, local kids would occasionally spray graffiti on trees, break branches, and generally get under Mert’s skin. On the more malicious side, homeless people would set up camp within the forest and consume drugs. The remnants of which would be found by children and parents who were enjoying use of Mert’s park. As the years went on, the malicious vandalism because worse and worse, forcing the county to reassess the concept of the park. One of the early ideas was to convert Mother Nature’s Window into a dog park in hopes that would deter vandals, but that concept never quite caught on. By 2006, the neighborhood was fed up with the illegal activity taking place in the park and partnered with the Snohomish County Sheriff&#39;s Department to increase patrols, in hopes that crime would decline in the park, and the surrounding neighborhood. In one weekend during the summer of 2006, the county cleaned up hypodermic needles, a burn bin, an old couch, garbage, and a lot of graffiti from the park. Unfortunately, the crime problem within the park persisted even with the increased patrols, and presence of a neighborhood watch program. Patrolling within the dense forest was just too difficult, especially at night.</p><p>In 2009, as was the agreement from the start, the City of Marysville annexed and took ownership of Mother Nature’s Window and began the process of converting it into a city park. Due to crime, vandalism, and much needed upgrades, the city made the decision to fence off the property and close it completely to make the necessary improvements to ensure user safety. What was first thought to be a short-term closure to realize the county’s goal of creating a park would ballon into a decade-long ordeal. Due to the ongoing financial crisis from the Great Recession, the increased costs of improving the park, and debate among the community about what the park should look like, the city shelved the Mother Nature’s Window project and closed the property off indefinitely. Over the next decade the city would hold meetings to discuss the park, but any plans for the property remained just plans, with no money budgeted for improvements.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/594/1*Q7WmRSpJEAA8c3HM1EZ4xQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Advertisement for community meeting to discuss the park in July 2015.</figcaption></figure><p>Starting in 2021, a group of Marysville city employees took on Mother Nature’s Window as a leadership project. Their goal was to come up with a plan to reopen the park to the public. The team consisted of Alex Chamberlin (Marysville Municipal Court), Dave Hall (Parks Department), Jeff Laycock (Public Works Department), and Jeramie Roth (Parks Department). This group analyzed:</p><ul><li>The history of the property, and why the county was not able to establish a park.</li><li>The state of the property, along with the problems it was facing.</li><li>What improvements would need to be completed to restore public access.</li></ul><p>They also interviewed residents, police officers, and parks employees to get a better understanding of what various groups of people wanted to see out of a potential new park.</p><p>Ultimately the recommendation from the group was to break the park upgrades into two phases, the first of which would restore public access. The critical piece of this would be the funding, so city leaders got to work lobbying the state and federal governments for the money needed to carry out the project.</p><p>Finally, in 2024 under the leadership of Marysville Parks Director Tara Mizell, $1.47 million was secured for “Phase I” of improvements to Mother Nature’s Window that would allow it to be reopened to the public. This included $750,000 in money from The US Department of Housing and Urban Development, and $720,000 from the City of Marysville. These improvements include a paved parking lot, ADA accessibility, lighting in certain areas, enhanced trails, stormwater management systems, irrigation, landscaping, and education signage. The plan is to reopen the park to the public in 2026, and for Phase II to come in the near future. Nearly two decades after its initial closure, Mother Nature’s Window will once again be open to the public to learn about the environment around them, while not leaving the city. Unfortunately, Mert Turk did not live long enough to see the forest he saved reopened, as he died in January of 2013. His obituary read less than twenty words and didn’t mention anything about his work to preserve Mother Nature’s Window. Instead, the forest he saved stands as a testament to the life he lived. He didn’t need a long obituary; he had a park.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/469/1*6F8Wy0Mw7eeRyN0Bus-Xtw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Merton Turk’s Obituary</figcaption></figure><p>Merton Turk believed that his forest was worth preserving. He didn’t stop at just believing though, he acted and did everything in his power to make sure its preservation became a reality. It would have been much easier to let houses get built next door, and eventually even sell his own land and make a nice profit. But Mert picked a difficult route, one that cost him a lot, but in the end saved something irreplaceable for his community. It is quite confusing on the face of it that a man who built his career and made his living cutting down trees would save a forest. But after all that time spent in the forest, it makes sense that he would become attached to one. He understood forests and nature in a way only someone who spent their life there could. Much like President Theodore Roosevelt, Mert was full of contradictions when it came to land conservation, but also like President Roosevelt he used those contradictions to be successful. Roosevelt saved millions of acres of land, and Mert saved dozens of acres for the next generation of residents in the town his family has called home for over a century. While not similar in scale, these two can be remembered as similar in spirit and success. Roosevelt has his national parks as a testament to that success, and Mert has Mother Nature’s Window in Marysville Washington.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V-2KfFgAwxDAGwIREGwaNg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Groundbreaking of Mother Nature’s Window Phase I Spring 2025</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f96c07c7d455" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Year Washington Celebrated Franksgiving]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/the-year-washington-celebrated-franksgiving-cc4d3396b803?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc4d3396b803</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Nov 2025 02:32:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-27T05:57:00.190Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Thanksgiving is one of the few uniquely American holidays. There are many dates throughout American history that can be considered the “first” Thanksgiving. The oldest and most famous being the feast between Pilgrims and Indians at Plymouth in 1621. While there are historical accuracy issues that plague this American legend, its legacy continues to live on hundreds of years later. Alternatively, many link the first Thanksgiving to George Washington who first proclaimed a Thanksgiving celebration in 1789, though he never set a reoccurring date for the holiday. Finally, others refer to Abraham Lincoln as the father of Thanksgiving as it was Lincoln that gave Thanksgiving its offical November date in 1863, proclaiming the last Thursday in November be set aside to give thanks. Regardless of who is credited for the first Thanksgiving, and when, this holiday has become a significant date on the American calendar as one of the nation’s most treasured traditions. As such, any efforts to alter this tradition has been met with extreme resistance. This is exactly what happened to President Franklin Roosevelt in 1939, a situation that put partisan politics on full display.</p><h3>It&#39;s the Economy…</h3><p>In the presidential election of 1932, Democratic New York Governor Franklin Delano Roosevelt was swept in office. Roosevelt’s election as President was largely in response to the on-going depression that the nation had been in since 1929, and his promise of a “new deal” for the American people. Once in office, he quickly got to work making good on those promises starting new federal initiatives and assistance programs aimed at getting the United States economy moving again. While historians still debate whether or not these programs did anything to move the economic needle, the New Deal made Roosevelt wildly popular. In 1936 he was re-elected in a landslide winning 60% of the vote, and 46 of 48 states.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A4ci2ijSRzkbC6doMfM4Ug.jpeg" /><figcaption>President Franklin Roosevelt carving turkey on “Franksgiving”</figcaption></figure><p>By the Summer of 1939, Roosevelt was in the second half of his second term and still as popular as ever. However, the Great Depression was still as pressing of an issue as when he took office six years earlier. Looking ahead on the calendar, 1939 was one of the few years in which November had five Thursdays. While not enshrined in federal law, the country still followed the tradition that Lincoln set forth of having Thanksgiving on the last Thursday of November. This meant that Thanksgiving 1939 would fall on November 30th, the last day of the month. This date worried many in the retail business. It was not yet traditional at this point to do Christmas shopping before Thanksgiving, and having the holiday so late took away valuable Christmas shopping days. Business and retail leaders, including Frank Lazarus the head of the Federated Department Stores, began to lobby Roosevelt to move Thanksgiving up a week to November 23rd to give extra days for them to do business before Christmas. They argued that this would be a needed boost for businesses that were still feeling the effects of the Great Depression.</p><p>In July of 1939 at a press conference Roosevelt floated the idea of potentially moving Thanksgiving to help the retail sector by giving them more Christmas shopping days. It wouldn’t be until two months later, on Halloween in fact, that Roosevelt officially proclaimed that Thanksgiving 1939 would be on November 23rd instead of November 30th as was planned by all Americans. In his proclamation the president did not address the date change, opting instead to explain the necessity and importance of the nation pausing to give thanks. What Roosevelt saw as a small change based on his proclamation, set off a political firestorm. Many Republicans and anti-New Deal Democrats refused to celebrate the new day arguing that Roosevelt was going against tradition, and many state Governors issued proclamations negating Roosevelt’s, directing their citizens to celebrate Thanksgiving on November 30th. Atlantic City Mayor Charles White, a Republican, began to refer to the November 23rd date as “Franksgiving” as a way to mock the date change. In total, 22 states chose to celebrate the earlier date (referred to as Democrat Thanksgiving), and 23 states chose to celebrate the later date (referred to as Republican Thanksgiving). Three states, Colorado, Texas, and Mississippi opted to have two Thanksgivings in 1939. Washington State was one of the 22 states that chose to celebrate Franksgiving in 1939.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-Y_NLCMVbDILTKxGl0CtrQ.png" /><figcaption>A map of Democrat and Republican Thanksgiving in 1939 courtesy of MCI Maps.</figcaption></figure><h3>This Is What We Voted For</h3><p>Washington State was extremely pro-Roosevelt, and pro-New Deal. In the presidential election of 1936, Roosevelt had won 66% of the vote, and every county in the state. As of 2025 Roosevelt was the last presidential candidate to win every county. Regardless of this, there was still a great amount of push back in Washington State to the Thanksgiving date change. In the August 15th edition of the <em>Kitsap Sun</em>, a list of local objections to the date change was given, which included:</p><ol><li>It would make liars out of the 1939 calendars.</li><li>It would disrupt football schedules, which generally are arranged so that major games are played on the last Thursday of November.</li><li>It would disrupt the schedule of meat packers and turkey growers, but it probably wouldn’t greatly affect the supply of turkeys for the market.</li></ol><p>In addition to these logistical concerns, many also criticized the President on the basis that he was messing with the tradition started by Abraham Lincoln. In a scathing editorial by the <em>Bremerton Daily News Searchlight</em>, it is stated that “In changing it (Thanksgiving) the president is merely indulging his love of smashing traditions.” This was a sentiment that was shared by many, and over the course of a couple weeks in August, <em>The Columbian</em> published a number of stories criticizing the move. One of the most critical headlines read “Thumbs down: Vancouverites disapprove, Turkey Day OK as is.” The article would go on to list a number of quotes from local Vancouver residents, who overwhelmingly opposed the change mostly on the grounds of upsetting a tradition set by Lincoln. A couple did mention concerns about football schedules and the turkey industry. In an editorial a couple days later one Vancouver Republican, former Post Master Arthur Calder took the critisism a step further stating “Why don’t they abolish Thanksgiving all together? This nation hasn’t had a thing to be thankful for since the new dealers came into power.” Calder’s reaction shows the extent to which politics drove some of the resistance to the date change.</p><p>The criticism of the date change didn’t just come from the old or those that were politically opposed to President Roosevelt. A thirteen-year-old girl from Ruston, June Alego, wrote an essay in the <em>Tacoma News-Tribune</em> arguing that changing the date would not send the right message to children saying, “If you elders take away our regular date, you are taking away our ideals. You are supposed to be at least halfway responsible for the younger generation. You expect us to become the hope and pride of young America. Well, how can we if you take away our hopes and ideals?”</p><p>While there were many opposed to the change, there were many who either were in favor of the change or simply did not care. <em>The Seattle-Star</em> ran a survey of Seattle residents after the change was announced. In the list of reactions only a couple people voiced their objections to the change, the biggest of which was on the grounds that it would mess with the University of Washington vs. University of Oregon rivalry football game. May Copeland, a teacher in Seattle voiced her support for the change saying, “If businessmen think it will help them to have more time between Thanksgiving and Christmas it is alright with me. Businesses certainly need something to help. Otherwise, I believe we should celebrate the day as it was first started.” Throughout Washington, this sentiment was echoed by businessmen and shop owners who were happy to have the extra week in the Christmas shopping season. <em>The Spokane Chronicle</em> interviewed a number of business owners in Spokane, all of which were in favor of the change. D. Roy Johnson, owner of the Spokane J.C. Penney’s told the <em>Chronicle</em> that “Consumers never think of Christmas until Thanksgiving is out of the way because their minds are on different problems. With Thanksgiving earlier, it will spread out the big buying rush.” Fred Emery, owner of Emery’s Men’s Store gave a mixed reaction saying “If the extra week for Christmas shopping will improve business, I’m for the change. Overwise I would be opposed to upsetting tradition.” H.G. Ferris, President of the Spokane Chamber of Commerce voiced a dissenting view of the change saying “I hate to see a deep-rooted American tradition arbitrarily changed. I would vote against it.” Ferris would go on to organize a letter writing campaign to Governor Martin asking him to keep the original Thanksgiving date.</p><p>In Tacoma, like Spokane, the reaction from the business community was generally positive. The store owners throughout Tacoma appreciated the extra shopping days before the Christmas season. One industry though that was not pleased with the change in Tacoma was the F.B. Wines printing company that primarily printed calendars. Mr. Wines told the <em>Tacoma Times</em> that “It&#39;s too late to do anything about this year of course. The heck of it is, it’s too late to do anything about 1940 too. You see calendar men keep about a year ahead.”</p><p>While it was President Roosevelt who issued the proclamation to change the date on the calendar, setting the date for Thanksgiving is ultimately up the individual state governors. In Washington, Democratic Governor Clarence Martin skirted the issue for many weeks. When asked about the date change after Roosevelt’s summer press conference, Martin gave this response:</p><p><em>“Whenever I hear people quarrelling about what day Thanksgiving should fall on, I feel like telling them we should have Thanksgiving every day in the week. All we have to do is look at the situation in Europe and go back to work thankful we live in this country.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*65galgM2QA2P_ksO.jpg" /><figcaption>Washington State Governor Clarence Martin</figcaption></figure><p>Even though the governor attempted to avoid the topic, it was almost a forgone conclusion that he would side with the president. During a court proceeding in Spokane, City Prosecutor Arthur Hooper attempted to schedule a hearing on November 23rd. Spokane County Superior Court Judge Yuse objected, stating that they can’t have a hearing on Thanksgiving. Hooper quipped back that the President had changed the date, not the Governor, to which Judge Yuse responded that the governor probably would as “he&#39;s a democrat too.” This proved to be the case. On September 13th, Martin issued a proclamation setting the early Thanksgiving date for Washington. Interestingly enough, this was solely based on the summer press conference Roosevelt gave. Roosevelt didn’t issue his proclamation until October 31st, over a month after Martin himself changed the date in the state. Despite the objections, Franksgiving went on as planned in Washington. On November 23rd, most of the citizens of Washington, even those that grumbled about it, put aside their objections and celebrated Thanksgiving. In fact, some residents of Eastern Washington would celebrate two Thanksgivings, one on November 23rd in Washington, and a Republican Thanksgiving on November 30th with family in Idaho, where the Governor had not changed the date. To make matters even better, the popular University of Washington vs. University of Oregon football game was successfully rescheduled to November 23rd. What started as a hot political issue cooled off considerably as Thanksgiving got closer.</p><h3>Falling Back on Tradition</h3><p>The following year in 1940, President Roosevelt again tried to change the date of Thanksgiving, bumping it back further to the third Thursday. Once again, a number of states adopted this date change, and other did not. This pattern repeated itself again in 1941. Finally, congress decided to intervene, and in December of 1941 a law was passed setting Thanksgiving as the fourth Thursday of November. This was a compromise that seemed to satisfy everyone, and President Roosevelt signed it into law. Most states went on to adopt this as the standard date for Thanksgiving, however on years with five Thursdays in November, some states continued to hold out and celebrate Thanksgiving on November 30th. The last state to do this was Texas in 1956, nearly twenty years after the Franksgiving controversy began. Today, Thanksgiving, and most of American holidays, seem like unmovable dates that are not up for debate, but this is a rather new concept in the history of our nation. While Thanksgiving itself is a very old holiday, the fixed date in which we celebrate it is a newer invention.</p><p>The Franksgiving debacle illustrates just how strongly some Americans and Washingtonians hold on to certain traditions. It also underscores the how partisan politics can creep into all parts of society, including our holidays. Even as we attempt to navigate politically polarizing times, lets pause and give thanks that at least we don’t have a “Democrat” and “Republican” Thanksgiving anymore.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc4d3396b803" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Asbery Field: A Gift From Our Pioneers]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/asbery-field-a-gift-from-our-pioneers-480161116096?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/480161116096</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Jun 2025 22:04:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-15T16:15:48.499Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>All too often place names become background noise to the everyday hustle and bustle of a city. Names that at one time were established to honor a person or family who went above and beyond in service to their community, lose their meaning over time. There is an immense amount of comfort in these names, as they are familiar and remind people of home. What this comfort abandons is a curiosity to how that name came to be, or who the name is meant to honor. Having a place, whether that be a street, park, or building, named after a person, is an immense honor, and even today is only reserved for the best of humanity. Because of this, it is important that a community keep these stories alive and honor these people whose names have stood the test of time. It is important that we are curious.</p><p>Marysville has a number of names that should never be erased from public memory. Names such as Comeford, Jennings, and Ebey stand among us as giants, and their contributions to the modern-day city we enjoy today should always be celebrated. Another Marysville name that is rapidly fleeting from public memory is Asbery. The name given to the field adjacent to Totem Middle School stands today with no signage bearing the name, and no explanation about how the name came to be. Tens of thousands of Marysville students and community members have no doubt used the name, and played on the field, with little if any knowledge of how that field came to be. As is the case with these stories, the story of Asbery Field is a long and somewhat convoluted one. While the history of this unassuming playfield in the middle of downtown has taken many twists and turns, it started with one man, Isaac Asbery.</p><h3>The Three Families</h3><p>The story that has been passed down for generations in Marysville is that Isaac Asbery donated the land that is now Asbery Field to be used as a community park. His only request in return was that the field be given his family name. While this is true, there is much more to the story. The main detail that has gotten lost is that the property was originally split between three families. In addition to the Asberys, the Mott Family and the Henderson Family owned a piece of the future field. Also, the size of the field has increased considerably over the years, starting as a much smaller property when first established. The reason, and the process for each family donating or selling the property to the city to be used as a playground vary wildly and reveal some of the early controversies of the town that had to be decided by the Washington State Supreme Court, and the consequences of the Great Depression.</p><p>As Marysville grew into adolescence at the turn of the century, many property owners who had large pieces of land brought them into the city and subdivided them to build houses. This is why the downtown neighborhood of Marysville from First to Tenth is the uniform grid system we see today, and why many of the downtown lots are generally the same size. There were two property owners that did not follow this trend, Mary Guy and Otto Henderson. These two pioneers opted to keep their large parcels undivided and undeveloped. These two properties are what make up Asbery Field today. While probably annoying for city leaders early on, it is partly due to the stubbornness of these two people that land was available for Asbery Field to be established decades later.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/475/1*eCMH_aR2kWuxZRk5RUA4dg.png" /><figcaption>Map of two large properties owned by Mary Guy and Otto Henderson</figcaption></figure><p>While the Henderson family held on to their property, Mary Guy ended up splitting her property in two in 1922 and selling both pieces. The property to the north passed through a few owners before being sold to Isaac Asbery, and the property to the south was sold to Charles Robinson. One would cause a remarkable amount of controversy that spilled out of the Marysville city limits to Olympia, and the other the inspiration for the field we see today.</p><h3>The Namesake</h3><p>Born in 1852 in Indiana, Isaac Asbery was a decedent of pioneers from Kentucky. Learning farming at an early age, Asbery continued the family business in Indiana until his early 30’s, when the promise of a new life in the west brought him to Coos County Oregon. He worked a short stint in Oregon, and then came up to Washington, and in 1888 purchased twenty acres of land near Marysville from James Comeford. He immediately got to work logging and farming this property, making enough money to move south to California just a few years later. He would stay in California for a decade, returning to his farm near Marysville in 1898. An older man now, farming had become a difficult business on his body and soon after his return he sold the farm and purchased a home in Marysville. Here he started his next career, buying Edmund Smith’s hardware store with business partner Fred Smith. This became the Smith and Asbery Hardware Store, one of the most famous businesses to operate in early Marysville. Asbery was also involved in many civic groups, including the Marysville Free Masons Crystal Lodge, where he was one of two remaining charter members at the time of his death.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9fY7d4OkAXqWR3SMV4CNbA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Isaac Asbery</figcaption></figure><p>Isaac Asbery died on December 3rd, 1936, at the age of 84. Before his death he had made his wishes known that he wanted his property, which was adjacent to the Marysville School District property, to be donated to the city and used as a park that would be named after him. His widow Josephine, and son Sanford honored that wish, and offered the property to the city in March 1937. Leon Stock, who was the editor of <em>The Marysville Globe</em>, and founder of the Marysville Strawberry Festival proposed to the city council that the property be used as a playground for Marysville children. Stock’s reasoning was that the City Park (later named Comeford Park), and the playfield on the school district property were being used regularly and the town needed additional recreation space and possibly a community center. The council loved the idea and instructed City Attorney Phil Warnock to begin the process of acquiring the property and making plans for a new park.</p><p>By April, it became apparent that the city needed more space in addition to the Asbery property to make this park what Stock and the community envisioned. Luckily for the city, a neighboring property was exactly what they were looking for.</p><h3>May it Please the Court</h3><p>In 1922 Charles Robinson purchased the southern piece of the Mary Guy property with William Mott. Mott was the city Water Superintendent, and did not have the money to put up for the purchase. Instead, Robinson offered Mott a piece of the property if he did the work to clear the land and build a house. Mott agreed and got to work. As time went on however, Robinson’s health began to decline. Having never married, Robinson had no wife or children to take care of him in his old age, so he struck a deal with Mott and his wife Frances. This oral agreement was that if the Motts took care of Robinson until he passed away, he would leave them the entire property in his will. From all accounts, the Motts kept up their end of the deal until about two weeks before Robinson died in 1925. At that time, Robinson’s condition had gotten so bad that he went to live with Austin McDonald. It is unclear how Robinson and McDonald came to know each other, but McDonald could supply a greater amount of care that his advanced illness required.</p><p>Upon Robinson’s death, it was revealed that in his final two weeks he had changed his will and listed Austin McDonald as his sole heir. This meant that the Motts were entitled to nothing, and their agreement was voided without their knowledge. McDonald quickly got to work attempting to take ownership of the property and remove the Motts from their house. William and Frances Mott sued McDonald stating that they had held up their end of every agreement they had with Robinson, and they were entitled to the property. McDonald argued that their agreement was never put in writing, and oral agreements like this one were non-binding.</p><p>In April 1927, the case went before Snohomish County Superior Court Judge Ralph Bell. After hearing both sides, Judge Bell sided with the Motts, arguing that they had kept up their end of the agreement for over three years and were entitled to what they were promised. McDonald instantly appealed the decision to the Washington State Supreme Court, who heard the case in March of 1928. After spending a few days considering both sides, the court ruled in favor of the Mott family and upheld the decision by Judge Bell. In the majority opinion, Supreme Court Justice Mark Fullerton concluded the following:</p><p><em>“His (Judge Bell) memorandum opinion is brought up with the record, and in it he especially states that the evidence clearly establishes the subsequent oral agreement and clearly establishes that the respondents performed the agreement on their part. Our examination of the record convinces us that his conclusion is just.”</em></p><p>In addition to the property purchased from Mary Guy, the Motts daughter was awarded a house on the corner of State and Sixth that she argued was also promised to her. Unfortunately for the family though, this would be a short-lived victory as William Mott died suddenly in December of that year.</p><h3>Three Become One</h3><p>As the Great Depression swept across the United States, towns like Marysville were financially decimated in every corner of the nation. While overall Marysville fared better than most, there were still residents that got swept up in financial issues associated with the depression. Frances Mott was one of those residents.</p><p>Frances continued to live on the property awarded to her family by the Supreme Court, but as was the case when it was purchased, they could not afford the taxes or upkeep. Couple that with the financial downturn of the Great Depression and the situation got much worse. Frances fell extremely far behind on property tax payments, and foreclosure was all but guaranteed by 1937. At almost the same time, the Asbery family was in the process of donating their neighboring property to the city, and the city council was discussing how to turn the property into a park. It is unclear who made the first offer, Frances or the city, but the two parties eventually agreed that Frances would deed her property to the city. The only stipulation was that the city would pay the outstanding tax bill, $250. This was a win-win, as the property for a park would now double in size, and Frances would be debt free.</p><p>Just a week later, this same story would play out on the neighboring property. Otto Henderson, who had owned the property which encompasses the east side of Asbery Field today, died in 1931. He had owned the property for many decades, and in his will the property went to his wife, Matilda. Like Frances, Henderson’s widow struggled to pay the taxes on the property as the Great Depression took hold of the area and fell behind on her payments. Just like her neighbor, Matilda was also facing the foreclosure of her property around the time the city council began to discuss a new park on the Asbery property. In mid-April 1937 Matilda Henderson and the city came to an identical agreement as the one with Frances Mott. The city offered to pay off the taxes owed on the property, and Matilda would deed the property to the city. The only difference with this deal is that the city intended to use part of the property for the park, part to extend Quinn Ave north, and part to sell for housing. Matilda agreed to the deal, and the park doubled in size again.</p><p>The Asbery Field that came to be after these three properties became one is not the Asbery Field we know today. This property was much smaller, running from Fifth Street north to the alley between Sixth and Seventh Street, and from Alder Ave east to Quinn Ave. At this time, houses still occupied the northern parts of Fourth Street and the southern part of Seventh.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ym4YRn2AYrEaFojzleXC4g.png" /><figcaption>Aerial image of Asbery Field before development.</figcaption></figure><p>With the properties acquired, the city went to work improving the neighborhood for a future park. Part of the agreement to construct the field was the Fifth Street was be connected between Alder and Quinn and complete those two streets from Fourth to Seventh. The aerial above shows the completed street grid in this neighborhood in 1938. The major difference at this time is Fifth Street acting as the southern boundary to the park property. Additionally, the city began the process of subdividing the eastern part of the Henderson property along Quinn Ave to sell for housing. This work was all completed by the end of 1937, but any progress on a future park was put on hold as the city did not have the money to dedicate to such a large project. This is where the Great Depression comes back into play.</p><h3>The WPA giveth…</h3><p>When Franklin Roosevelt entered office in 1933, he quickly got to work on his “New Deal.” This set of policy initiatives was meant to help the United States get out of the Great Depression through various workers assistance programs. One of the more successful New Deal programs was the Workers Progress Administration, better known as the WPA. Established in 1935, the WPA employed hundreds of thousands of unemployed men and women to help rebuild the public infrastructure of the nation. This program’s mission was two-fold: employ those that were out of work due to the depression, and rebuild the nation’s parks, schools, roads, bridges, etc. Over the entire lifespan of the program 8.5 million people were employed by the WPA and it accounted for 6.7% of the United States GDP. The peak of the WPA was 1938, which conveniently was the same year the Marysville City Council began exploring just how to develop a park on the Asbery land.</p><p>The city council spent the end of 1937 and the beginning of 1938 debating how to proceed with development of what was being called Asbery Park. The city had expended considerable resources on recent updates to the water system, and little if any was left to invest in a new park. Likewise, the Marysville School District who stood to benefit from a park being installed next to their property had no resources to invest either. In February of 1938, A.J. Lindquist, who was chairing a committee of the Marysville Commercial Club tasked with assisting development of Asbery Park, suggested to city leaders that they submit the project to the WPA. The only stipulation was that the WPA would require a Superintendent be hired by the city to oversee the work, and the city would need to provide a truck. The estimate was that these two items would cost the city about $630. After discussing the matter, the council decided they could set aside only about $170. The community would need to step up and aid in funding the remainder if the project were to happen.</p><p>On March 3rd, 1938, <em>The Marysville Globe</em> made the announcement that it would be raising funds from residents to help close the funding gap. Over the next month, many Marysville residents gave what they could to help move the project along. Organizations in town also mobilized to help the effort. The Neighbors of Woodcraft club raised $5 among their membership, and the Marysville PTA raised $8.75 through a flower sale. Weekly articles ran in <em>The Globe</em> encouraging people to donate and listing publicly those that had. A bit of friendly peer pressure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Gjkz5w3Tu3G4T7A3VqKedQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Globe article showing the list of residents who had donated to the Asbery Park fund</figcaption></figure><p>Over the next six months, <em>The Globe</em> continued to raise money at their office for the Asbery Park project. The Marysville Commercial Club, and the city council worked during this time to draw up plans for the park, and what would be included in the initial phases of development. Controversial additions such as a baseball field and plumbed bathrooms were deferred, and clearing, grading, and planting grass rose to the top of the “to-do” list. During this time, the city also decided to pursue WPA assistance in repaving certain streets and alleys throughout town.</p><p>The final package that was submitted to the WPA in August of 1938 included eight miles of repaved streets, three miles of repaved alleys, and 5,895 square yards of new sidewalks, among other improvements. This submittal also included the beginning stages of developing Asbery Park. The total cost of the package was $54,224 ($1.2 million dollars today) with much of it being funded through local improvement districts (LIDs). This proposal to the WPA included much more than what was originally discussed earlier in the year, when Asbery Park was the only WPA project contemplated. Unfortunately, this large request proved to be a setback for the Asbery property. The WPA countered the city’s offer with a scaled back version of their proposal that did not include the Asbery Park improvements. The city agreed to this counterproposal, and it moved forward.</p><p>This was a major defeat for the Asbery project and left city leaders without a path forward. Without WPA involvement, city leaders did not see a way to develop the property at their own expense outside of the costs WPA had stipulated. For the first half of 1939 city leaders debated what to do next, and the decision was ultimately made that there wasn’t anything they could do. Thankfully, the interest from the community was still there to see something happen at Asbery Park. Because of this, the Marysville School District offered to purchase the property from the city and begin planning an athletic field to be associated with the school buildings that were right across the street. On August 31st, 1939, the city council officially sold the Asbery property to the school district for $1.</p><p>As soon as the school district took possession of the Asbery property, they got to work putting a plan together to develop it into an athletic field. One of the main problems was the row of houses that stood along Seventh Street that separated the property from the Lincoln School and Marysville High School. In total there were eight properties on this block. During the second half of 1940, and the first half of 1941, the Marysville school district was able to purchase all eight properties. While this may seem like a large feat for a short period of time, four of the properties were owned by one person, Florence Tirgstad, and one of them previously owned by the Holiness Church had been sold to the district in 1939. With these properties purchased, any athletic field built there would be easily accessible by the students at both schools. Once again, the Asbery field property had gotten even larger.</p><p>In January 1941, the Marysville School District submitted the Asbery athletic field development project to the WPA for their consideration. This was exactly what the city had done a couple years early with no success. In addition to this, the school district also submitted for construction of a new music room to be added onto to the high school. Within just weeks, the school district heard from Washington D.C. that both projects had been approved by the WPA, and construction would start the following month. The approved project consisted of grandstands, a baseball diamond, a track, and a seeded grass field. Additionally, the WPA would construct all necessary water and sewer lines to the field and do all necessary grading to prepare the site. With the music room addition, the total cost of the project was $48,829 of which the school district would pay $25,442.</p><p>This work was completed by the end of the year, and both new school district facilities were put into use. Despite initial denial from the WPA, it was that organization that was ultimately responsible for the Asbery athletic field project moving forward. Unfortunately, any additional plans for further development were immediately put on hold in December 1941 when the United States entered World War II.</p><h3>Let There Be Light</h3><p>For the next five years Asbery Field was not expanded or improved. Given that it had just been constructed, this probably wasn’t a big deal, and additional improvements were very low on the priority list for the school district. That said, there was still a desire among the community for upgrades to the field, and the school district had purchased the properties to the south of the field during its property shopping spree in 1940 and 1941. As it stood, the school district owned all the property between Fourth and Seventh running east and west and Alder and Quinn running north to south.</p><p>When the war ended in 1945, it took some time to return to normal. In Marysville, small signs that pre-war life had returned began to pop up in 1946. Most notable was the Strawberry Festival, which had been cancelled for the previous four years. It wouldn’t be until 1947 though, when the community found renewed interest in Asbery Field. This time it was the private sector that took the lead.</p><p>When Asbery Field was first contemplated by the city, the Marysville Commercial Club took a keen interest in the project. They went so far as to form a committee of members to work with the city. However, when the city sold the property to the school district, this effort on the part of the Commercial Club seemed to dissipate. In 1947, the Commercial Club once again took an interest in Asbery Field. At their January meeting, the club officially voted to take over sponsorship of lighting upgrades to the field. To this point Asbery Field had no lights. This was fine during baseball season, and during the school day, but the Marysville High School football games were now played at Asbery Field. During the fall and winter, it got dark before the games were usually over. This posed significant challenges to the team and the school district. Local business owners saw this firsthand and wanted to do something to help.</p><p>By March a committee had been formed to figure out how the Commercial Club could raise the necessary funds, chaired by Marysville School District Superintendent Chester Rhodes. The total price for the lighting would be $22,000. It was soon announced that together with the Lions Club, the Commercial Club would put on a new community event called the Tyee Festival with the express purpose of raising money for the lighting project. The Tyee festival was to take place August 8th and 9th, 1947 and include community activities, raffles, a dance, kiddie parade, rowboat race up Ebey Slough, carnival, and a pageant. All the activities, with the exception of the boat race, were to take place at Asbery Field. To differentiate themselves from the Strawberry Festival that was to take place two months earlier, the Tyee festival pageant would crown a King, while the Strawberry Festival crowned a Queen. The planning and advertising for the Tyee Festival was extensive and included radio and tv ads as far south as Seattle to lure people up to the sleepy town of Marysville. Residents of Marysville were expected to purchase a “Tyee badge” from local businesses for $1 to support the event. If a resident was caught without a badge Marysville police officers would write a ticket for $2 to incentivize purchases.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L5RiIseNNilKsm7Mb2it4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Advertisement for the Tyee Festival</figcaption></figure><p>By all accounts the Tyee Festival was a smashing success, and the Commercial Club was able to hit their fundraising goal through the various events and concession stands. They wasted no time in getting to work putting up the Asbery Field lights, and it was reported in the August 28th, 1947, edition of <em>The Marysville Globe </em>that work had already begun just two weeks after the event. Once work started, it went equally as fast, and by October the lights had been installed and were ready to be turned on. A dedication ceremony was held on Friday October 3rd before a scheduled football game between Marysville and Mount Vernon. Initially a long program had been planned with a flag ceremony, history of Asbery Field, and remarks by Mayor Ernest Washburn, School Board President John Moskeland, Commercial Club President Fred McCorkle, and School Superintendent Chester Rhodes. As is the case with Pacific Northwest Octobers, a rainstorm ended up forcing the program to be shortened substantially. Even so, over 1,000 people came out to participate in the historic occasion. <em>The Globe</em> reported that many walked home during halftime to get coats, ponchos, and blankets to watch the second half of the wet football game. In the end, the Tomahawks pulled off an upset victory over Mount Vernon 19–0. A fitting way to end the dedication ceremonies for the newly lit field. Thanks to the efforts of so many in the community, Asbery Field was now one of the most modern athletic fields in Snohomish County. This however didn’t stop the community from wanting the field to be even better.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IAIAaS7FRL5jNqh51FUu6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>A page from the Asbery Field dedication program</figcaption></figure><h3>If It Worked Once</h3><p>Over the next three months, the Marysville High School football team played their season under the new lights at Asbery Field. By all accounts the community was thrilled with the new addition, and the Commercial Club wanted to seize on that excitement. In February 1948, it was announced that the club was planning another Tyee Festival to be held August 6th and 7th to fund the construction of permanent grandstands at Asbery Field. To this point, temporary bleachers had been built for spectators and students to use. The new and improved grandstands would be covered, and able to seat 1500 people, and include ticket booths, concession stands, a press box, bathrooms, and locker rooms for players. The cost would be $5,000 which was considerably less than the lighting project had been the previous year. In addition to the Tyee Festival, the Commercial Club deployed students to walk door-to-door in Marysville to raise money for what was being called the “crowning feature” for Asbery Field.</p><p>As was the case the previous year, the Tyee Festival was extremely successful, and the money needed for the grandstand project was raised. This project was more complicated than the lighting project to design and construct. It was decided early on that the entire structure would be built by the high school shop class under the supervision of Earl Smith-Hughes. Four students in particular: Arnold Woge, Richard Haaland, Alvin Lyons, and Dean Crider took leadership positions in getting the project completed. In addition to this, local businessmen Ray Schneider and Virgil Fortune donated 4000 feet of lumber to be used for the construction. After months of planning, ground was eventually broken on the 50-yard line in November 1948 right in the middle of football season.</p><p>The construction moved along at a much slower pace than the previous Asbery Field project. To the frustration of the students involved, construction had to be halted for two months during the winter of 1949 due to snow and frozen ground. Because of this, it wouldn’t be until March that construction was restarted. Thankfully, the new addition was completed just in time for the 1949 football season. The new project was so successful, that the grandstands, and the students that built them, were given praise in the 1949 edition of the <em>Washington State Curriculum Journal</em>, a publication by the state department of education.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pfg-SLF9OwpaoXWtky1GPg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Asbery Field in 1954 before major development of the southern half of the property.</figcaption></figure><h3>What We See Today</h3><p>The Asbery Field one sees today is entirely different from the Asbery Field of 1950. It is the developments that took place in the late 1950’s and early 1960’s that helped to shape the field that modern Marysville knows and uses. One of the most obvious differences is the expansion south to Fourth Street.</p><p>During the school district property shopping spree in the early 1940’s most of the lots between Fourth and Fifth Streets and between Alder and Quinn were purchased by the school district (one final property on the corner of Fourth and Quinn wasn’t purchased until 1957). This included a number of houses as well. The plan was to ultimately demolish those houses and build a new high school on that land. As the district grew, and enrollment numbers went up after the end of World War II, it became clear to the school board that a new elementary school was needed more so than a new high school. Because of this, the district opted to purchase property on the corner of Tenth and Liberty to construct Liberty Elementary in 1950. Interestingly enough, for a brief period of time before Liberty was built, the school district used the houses it purchased on Fourth Street as classrooms for the kindergarten classes after they ran out of room in the existing elementary school.</p><p>With Liberty built, the appetite for a new high school was at an all-time low. The community viewed the existing facility as adequate, and didn’t see a need for the construction of another expensive school building. The question now became, what should be done with the land south of Asbery Field? After a few years of kicking around ideas, and preemptively demolishing the houses in 1954, it was decided to completely reimagine Asbery Field and expand it south to Fourth Street. But for a while progress seemed slow, painfully slow. Over the next number of years, the school board would have architects submit plans, and discuss the potential changes to the existing site, without deciding on much of anything. This would be the cycle from about 1957 to 1960, when architect Bob Bonjorni finally submitted something that caught the attention of the school board</p><p>This new plan included moving the baseball field to the new property south of the field from its current location in the northwest corner, moving the football field south, and installing a new track around the football field. Plans also included upgrades to the lighting system that was nearly ten years old. Unfortunately, this would cost a substantial amount of money, and the school district had made a number of other financial obligations. The chief among these being the recent consolidation with the neighboring Sunnyside School District. In early 1961 it was decided to let the voters have the final say on both these questions. The school board scheduled a special election in May of that year. The question to the voters would be whether or not they would fund a special levy of $108,000. Of this $72,000 would go to construct a new Sunnyside elementary, and $36,000 would go to the above-mentioned upgrades at Asbery Field. When all the votes had been counted, 83% of the voters voted in favor of the special levy. A high electoral watermark.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ls6XwaE6uaImZaTTkDvv0g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Installation of the new track with the grandstands in the background.</figcaption></figure><p>Once the election had been certified the district got to work turning those plans into a reality, this time under the direction of architect Galen Bentley. The big changes included the movement of the baseball field to the southern portion of the field not yet developed, and the addition of a new eight lane track. The football field would stay about where it was at, only moving six yards south, but now within the bounds the track. Something that had not originally been stipulated, but was included was the purchase of portable bleachers that could seat 500 people. They were to be installed next to the existing grandstands that had proved already too small. The thought was they could also be moved for other events when not in use at Asbery Field. Of all these upgrades the track would prove to be the costliest, accounting for about a third of the total project cost. As was the case with all the previous upgrades at Asbery Field, the school board made it a point to have all work completed by the start of football season. In this instance, the board got their wish and by the end of summer the work had been completed; Asbery Field had expanded again. The field that was initially only a block and a half, now spanned three blocks from Fourth Street all the way north to Seventh.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*awb42h523pNYhM9RLPK5Dw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Asbery Field after the 1961 improvements.</figcaption></figure><h3>Asbery Today</h3><p>There is one final piece of this story to get to where Asbery Field is today. A story that many Marysville oldtimers still recall today. On the afternoon of July 17th, 1975, the Marysville Fire Department received a call about a fire at the Asbery Field grandstands. By the time fire fighters arrived the grandstands were fully engulfed in flames, and the fire was spreading quickly. Embers from the fire had been picked up by the wind and ignited fires on the roofs of three neighboring houses. In addition to this, one of the light poles went up with the blaze, and a misplaced tarp by the fire department almost spread the flames to a parked fire truck. With a number of fires now started in multiple areas, the Marysville Fire Department received assistance from neighboring fire districts 1, 12, and 15. Neighbors in the area also came out to help spread hoses from the hydrants down the streets to fight the fires that had broken out on the homes.</p><p>After hours of fighting the fires, and the smoke had cleared, the grandstands had been completely destroyed along with one light pole, and portions of the track. After an investigation, it was discovered that the fire had been started by school kids playing with matches underneath the grandstands. The hot July weather combined with the dry wood of the grandstands made the perfect environment for the fire to spread quickly. The district opted to not to replace the grandstands after the fire, as all high school football games were now being played at Quil Ceda Stadium. The new stadium had been opened on the campus of Pilchuck High School (now Marysville-Pilchuck High School) four years earlier in September of 1971. With this fire, a chapter of Asbery Field’s history had come to a close, but a new one was opened. The Asbery Field that came to be after the 1975 fire is the Asbery Field that our community sees and uses today. With a few minor changes, Asbery Field has remained virtually the same over the last fifty years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PVW3LzHb9IL_ZeKxhoiuCw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Asbery grandstands fully engulfed in flames</figcaption></figure><p>Today, Asbery Field stands in downtown Marysville as a constant among a vast sea of changes. For over eighty years, this portion of the city has been reserved for its youth and for recreation. This is no small achievement given its location in the heart of a rapidly growing city. While the field no longer bears any physical commemoration of those that made it possible, it stands as a testament to those pioneers that had the foresight to set this land aside. Pioneers who understood that students, and a community, need an open space to play and recreate near their schools, and near their homes. Today tens of thousands of Marysville’s residents use Asbery Field for sports, community events, the Strawberry Festival, or just as a quiet place to walk. They may know the name Asbery but being curious about that name and remembering the significance of what he helped to create, and what so many helped to continue is what is truly most important.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=480161116096" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[1892: Washington’s First Vote]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/1892-washingtons-first-vote-aad6872b3b7c?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aad6872b3b7c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 31 Dec 2024 01:41:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-12T17:51:07.235Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Presidential elections in the United States act as benchmarks to the progression of public policy, history, and societal change. Many of these elections have ushered in sweeping changes that could be felt by every American. Others served as recommitments to the policies that were already in place, and as an endorsement of the party in power for another four years. Every one of the United States fifty-nine elections has been a unique story with its own set of determined players, pressing issues, and unprecedented challenges. Some of these elections have been the topic of wide-spread review and detailed study, while others are all too often glanced over by historians and the public. Unfortunately, the Presidential Election of 1892 falls into the latter category.</p><p>The twenty-seventh United States Presidential Election took place on Tuesday November 8th, 1892. On that day, former President Democrat Grover Cleveland defeated incumbent President Republican Benjamin Harrison to become the first president to be elected to two non-consecutive terms. While this alone should elevate the election of 1892 to an increased level of study, there were numerous other factors that made it truly unprecedented. Since the previous election in 1888, six new states were admitted to the union in the western half of the United States, Washington being one of them. This meant that the election of 1892 would see more new states at one time than any other election in U.S. history. Because of this, the election now had an addition forty-three electoral votes added to the count, once again the most ever added in a single election. In one of the newly admitted states, Wyoming, women were given the right to vote meaning that in 1892, for the first time in U.S. history, women would vote in a Presidential Election.</p><p>Finally, the candidates themselves served to make this campaign unique. This was only the fourth time in United States history that there was a rematch for President. In addition to this, Grover Cleveland was the first former President to successfully resecure his party’s nomination after losing the office, and at this point was the only person in history to secure his party’s nomination three times. The incumbent President Benjamin Harrison, who had defeated Cleveland in the 1888 contest, was the grandson of President William Henry Harrison. Throughout the campaign however, Harrison would be sidelined by his wife’s deuterating health, and eventual death two weeks before the election. Historian George Knoles, who authored the only scholarly analyses of this election would conclude that the election of 1892 was “a campaign of measures not men” referring to the high attention paid to the issues during the campaign, as opposed to candidate personalities as is commonplace today.</p><p>Both men were very well known among the voters, and their policy positions had been thoroughly established. However, as the campaign kicked off in early 1892, neither one had a clear path to their party’s nomination, and there were serious doubts if either actually wanted it.</p><h3>Parties of Discontent</h3><p>By the time the election of 1892 came into view, President Benjamin Harrison was tired. He entered office in 1889 with a Republican majority in the House and the Senate and was able to get key pieces of legislation passed such as the Sherman Silver Purchase Act, the Sherman Antitrust Act, and the McKinley Tarriff Act. The last of which would become a major theme in the upcoming campaign. In the midterm elections of 1890 however, the Republican Party was defeated across the board and reduced to the smallest minority in the history of the party. Personally, the President was also suffering, as the First Lady Caroline Harrison had been dealing with the effects of tuberculosis for over a year and was in failing health. Much of the president’s free time was spent tending to the needs of his wife, not organizing a re-election campaign.</p><p>Politically, Harrison had alienated a large portion of his party during his time in office. The President was no friend of the patronage system, and chose to instead make appointments based on merit, not politics. Party bosses benefited greatly from the patronage system, and without it their influence was greatly diminished. Couple this with Harrison’s aloof and cold personality that Senator Thomas Collier Platt described as “glacial as a Siberian stripped of his furs”, the Republican Party began looking for a new nominee.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*10GSDCRUwDzibLAl.jpg" /><figcaption>President Benjamin Harrison</figcaption></figure><p>While many names were floated as potential Republicans to replace Harrison, the one name that was consistently on the top of the list was Secretary of State James Blaine, who has been the party’s nominee in 1884 when Cleveland was elected to his first term. Blaine, who himself was in bad health, repeatedly declined calls to be a candidate for President again and did not actively seek the nomination. This didn’t stop members of the party from campaigning on his behalf and working to secure Blaine delegates to the Republican Convention that summer. By the Spring, Harrison had not yet begun to organize a campaign. When asked by supporters whether they could begin to secure delegates on behalf of the President, he told them he did not intend to seek the nomination and not to work on his behalf.</p><p>As the Republican Convention set for early June got closer, and the opposition to Harrison got louder, the President changed his mind and dug in his heels. On May 23rd, 1892, in a letter to a trusted political ally, Louis Michener, President Harrison aired his frustration and declared his commitment to seek the nomination after all. Michener later recalled that, “The attacks of the opposition led by Platt, Quay, and Clarkson (Republican party bosses) had become of such a character as to compel him to become a candidate in spite of his strong desire not to be.” Harrison was in the race, and his machine began its work putting together the last-minute campaign.</p><p>Grover Cleveland had settled comfortably back into private life in upstate New York after losing in 1888. Though his wife Francis had desires of returning to the White House from the moment the family left, its unknown if her husband shared the same sentiment. During the midterm elections of 1890, the former president remained quiet, and did not concern himself with politics. The results of that campaign seemed to be a turning point for the former President. With the electorate turning away from the Republicans, due to what Cleveland perceived as the unpopularity of their signature pieces of legislation, and giving Democrats huge majorities in 1890, the former president saw an opening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/787/0*ZZDQDo6seY1Q3GiO.jpg" /><figcaption>President Grover Cleveland</figcaption></figure><p>This did not take the form of an offical presidential campaign at first. Instead, Cleveland began to write letters commenting on current events, or legislation before congress, and then began speaking in public on topics of the same. After a series of speeches in early 1892 on hot button issues like tariff reform, and honest money, letters came in calling for Cleveland to declare his candidacy for President once again. The former President shrugged off most of these calls for him to run and made no offical declaration one way or the other. However, as was the case with Harrison, it would be the opposition that would ultimately force Cleveland’s hand.</p><p>While Cleveland remained bashful about his plans, his main opponent did not. New York Senator David B. Hill, who had served as Lieutenant Governor of New York while Cleveland was Governor, made his intentions crystal clear from the beginning. He was running for President. There was no love lost between the two New Yorkers. In the election of 1882, Hill had received eight thousand more votes for Lieutenant Governor than Cleveland who was running for Governor, though both won. In 1885 Cleveland resigned as Governor to become President, which allowed Hill to ascend the Governorship. In 1888, Hill successfully won re-election as Governor, while Cleveland lost his home state of New York in the Presidential contest, which cost him the election. Cleveland’s view was that Hill did not do enough for the Democratic ticket in that race, and instead only looked out for himself and his own ambition. During his time as Governor, Hill continually worked at building relationships with Democrat Party bosses and Tammany Hall, which was the most influential Democrat machine in New York in the late nineteenth century.</p><p>In the winter of 1892, with the machine of the New York Democratic Party behind him, Senator Hill began laying the groundwork to defeat Cleveland in his own state. At a meeting of the state party executive committee, it was decided to move up the state convention to vote for delegates to the national convention. Normally, the state conventions would take place in April or May, with a national convention in June or July. Instead, the New York Democrats scheduled their state convention for February 22nd. The thought was that since Cleveland had yet to organize a campaign, this would allow Hill to collect all of New York’s delegates, robbing Cleveland of support from his own home state at the national convention. The plan worked. At the snap-convention as it was called, Senator David Hill was awarded all seventy-two of New Yorks’s delegates.</p><p>This was the encouragement Cleveland needed. On March 9th, in a letter to his former Minister to Mexico, General Edward S. Bragg, Cleveland stated that he did not believe in a “self-seeking” campaign for the nomination, but if it was the will of the people for him to be nominated at the convention, he would accept. The letter was then published, and Cleveland’s third consecutive race to secure the Democratic nomination for president began.</p><p>Throughout the Spring, county and state conventions were held across the country. Here, local party members debated who had the best chances of winning in November, and whose views most aligned with their party. These conventions also elected state delegates to vote for nominees for President and Vice President at the national conventions in the Summer. In Washington State, this was the first time voters would get a chance to vote in the presidential election, and both political parties went to work organizing their respective conventions and working to ensure they won Washington’s first presidential contest.</p><h3>Republicans in Seattle</h3><p>The Republican Party was the first major political party to host a state convention in Washington during the 1892 contest. Held on April 14th and 15th at the Cordray Theater in Seattle, 213 delegates from around the state came together to pass a party platform and elect eight delegates to represent Washington at the national convention in Minneapolis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*6N6m0BNnZN0w06XT.jpg" /><figcaption>The Cordray Theatre on Third and Madison in Seattle</figcaption></figure><p>By all accounts, this convention was quiet, and harmonious. <em>The Fairhaven Herald</em> remarked that “Not a ripple of discontent or ill-feeling disrupted the peaceful serenity of the convention waters,” and for the most part this was true. The convention was opened by speeches from prominent state-wide Republicans, including popular Governor Elisha Ferry. Judge Scott, brother-in-law to President Harrison also made a stop at the convention to represent the President. One of the first items passed by the convention’s delegates was a resolution honoring President Harrison, and the work his administration had carried out, stating in part:</p><p><em>“Resolved that we heartily approve of the administration of President Harrison, as honest, capable, and courageous, and in all respects entitled to a continuance of the confidence of the American people.”</em></p><p>This would be where the niceties ended with respect to the incumbent President. Officially, the convention did not instruct its delegates to vote for a certain candidate in Minneapolis. However, when it came to the election of eight delegates, the overwhelming majority of them were supporters of Secretary Blaine. <em>The Spokane Chronicle</em> reported that “Delegates were not instructed, though Blaine was evidently the first choice, and his position left the party in doubt. Still the convention did not want to slight Harrison by formally acknowledging another leader.”</p><p>With the delegates elected, the body then voted on a platform that for the most part covered the issues of the day and didn’t stray from the national party line. Stances in favor of protective tariffs, free coinage of silver, and the construction of a Nicaraguan Canal easily passed through the body without much dissent. William Calkins of Tacoma, Chair of the convention gave an impassioned speech on the need for continued protective tariffs for the benefit of the new state, and the Pacific Northwest region. Like in the 1888 contest, protective tariffs would prove to be the central issue of the campaign, especially in Washington.</p><p>At the end of the second day in Seattle, with their work completed, the Republicans of Washington State went home. They stood ready to press on to elect whomever their party nominated, and to defeat their Democratic adversaries.</p><h3>Democrats in Vancouver</h3><p>A month later, on May 24th, the Democrats of Washington gathered for their convention in Vancouver. This gathering was much livelier than that of their Republican counterparts and put on full display the organization and energy behind both Cleveland and Hill.</p><p>When the 331 delegates arrived at the Columbia Hotel, it was apparent who the front runner of the proceedings would be. Along with a live marching band, twenty-seven photos of Grover Cleveland had been installed in the entry corridor with patriotic decorations to greet the guests. Upon the opening of the day, the former President was referred to by one speaker as “That man who sends messages to all the people that he may relieve their burdens.” This commentary was met with thunderous applause.</p><p>The Democrats also passed a declaration honoring Cleveland, stating that they:</p><p><em>“Point with pride to the administration of Grover Cleveland, as an exemplifying embodiment of those principles of practical government affairs”</em> and that they <em>“believe his (Cleveland) nomination to the presidency is favored by democratic masses throughout the land.”</em></p><p>Support for Cleveland would be one of the very few issues that the body took a formal position on. The Democrats opted to not pass a platform, which is highly unusual even to this day. While no reason was given for this decision, the Cleveland campaign had made its position on all the issues known, and a larger platform was planned to be passed at the national convention in Chicago. The party in this case seemed to defer to these other two forthcoming policy statements.</p><p>The Cleveland campaign continued to receive good news into the election of delegates, as the body elected eight Cleveland supporters to the national convention in Chicago. While officially sent as uninstructed, they were all known Cleveland men. However obvious it seemed that the convention supported the former President, the Hill supporters still believed they could carry Washington.</p><p>As soon as the convention adjourned at the end of the first day, Secretary of the Washington State Democratic Party, and loyal supporter of Senator Hill, George Hazzard rushed to the telegraph office to send a message to Hill. His message read in part:</p><p><em>“The Washington delegation chosen today to the Chicago convention is not instructed. The eight chosen men of sense who will not be carried away by the clamor of the delegates of Wisconsin, Michigan, Kansas, and other Republican states… Not one of our delegates will vote for Cleveland until his name is presented by the State of New York. These are the bottom facts, thank God.”</em></p><p>It is a mystery if Hazzard actually believed what he had written, or if he wanted to cushion any bad news to Senator Hill before more details of the convention came out. Whatever the case may be, Hazzard’s telegram was not well received by his fellow delegates, and some even attempted to call a special meeting to have him removed as Secretary. While he was able to avoid this, his reputation was tarnished. <em>The Spokane Daily Chronicle</em>, a Democrat newspaper referred to Hazzard as a “poor miserable creature” who had “dishonored the party.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/752/0*aGr69Aly0KLNkAEs" /><figcaption>George Hazzard. Courtesy of the Henry County Indiana Historical Society</figcaption></figure><p>Despite the best attempts from the Hill supporters, the Washington State Convention proved to be an uphill battle for them from the start. Cleveland had much more support from the delegates and party leaders. The former president would have eight solid votes from Washington in Chicago. The Democrat party in Washington, however, was left fractured after their convention, and the real work for them would be repairing it before the election in the Fall.</p><h3>The Others</h3><p>There were a number of third parties that nominated candidates for President in 1892, some of which received considerable support. The most successful was the People’s Party, a populist movement that ran opposed to the two major parties that they believed had abandon the American farmer.</p><p>The People’s Party had its roots in an organization known as the Farmers Alliance, which was formed in the 1880’s in response to increasingly hard conditions in southern and western agriculture communities. During this time, farming communities in these parts of the country had become wholly dependent on large industries, such as railroads, storage facilities, and processing plants to get their goods to market. As is the case with every industry, there was a desire to offer services and goods at a cheaper rate. This left these communities with less income, and less demand for their products. The organization that was behind the Farmers Alliance, which was officially nonpartisan, then turned into an offical political party as the election of 1892 neared, the People’s Party. This was seen as a way to give the message of the alliance a larger and more effective platform. They also sought to bring in other disadvantaged working-class people, not just farmers. Historian George Knoles said of this situation that “as has happened again and again in American history the depressed classes finally turned to politics as a means of expressing their discontent.”</p><p>There is no record of the People’s Party having a statewide convention in Washington. Despite this, counties in Eastern Washington had been very active in the Farmer’s Alliance since its founding, and a number of candidates running for state-wide office, and the state legislature opted to run under the People’s Party banner. While most would not win, they would end up winning several eastern counties and would foreshadow a sweeping Populist movement that would overtake Washington politics at the turn of the century.</p><p>Nationally, the People’s Party had their convention in Omaha at the beginning of July. Here they nominated Congressman James Weaver of Iowa as a candidate for President, and Virginia Attorney General James Field as a candidate for Vice President. In addition to this, the convention passed a platform that included what they called “demands.” These demands include:</p><ul><li>Free coinage of silver, and the issuance of currency only by the United States Federal Government.</li><li>Government ownership of railroad and telegraph companies.</li><li>Land should not be monopolized for speculative purposes, and any land that is owned by corporations in excess should be held for settlers only.</li><li>A graduated income tax.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*xZgj062w_Sx0GMCd.jpg" /><figcaption>Congressman James Weaver</figcaption></figure><p>The People’s Party candidates would go on to run a full campaign alongside the Democrats and Republicans. Many state parties would even go on to make deals with the People’s Party to take votes away from their adversaries, this would come to be known as fusion. This would lead to the People’s Party carrying a number of states in the general election.</p><p>In addition to the People’s Party, the Prohibition Party, and the Socialists Party also nominated candidates for President and Vice President in 1892. While they did marginally well in their home states, these other two parties had little impact on the race overall.</p><h3>Midwest Conventions</h3><p>In 1892, both the Republican and Democratic conventions were held in the Midwest. The Republican convention was notable, as it took place in Minneapolis Minnesota, and became the first convention held west of the Mississippi River. This singled the changing geography of politics in the U.S and also underscored the importance of the newly admitted states to the party’s strategy.</p><p>The Republicans were first to hold their national convention from June 7th-10th at the Industrial Exposition Building in Minneapolis Minnesota. When party loyalists gathered that week, many were still processing the shocking news that had come just days before that Secretary of State Blaine had resigned from President Harrison’s cabinet. Many saw this as perfect timing on his part to stand as a candidate against Harrison for the nomination. Blaine though argued against this, stating simply that he had completed the work he had set out to do, and was ready to retire. Historian George Knoles even argues that Blaine “did not realize what he had done” in resigning so close to the start of the convention. Nonetheless, those that were looking to replace Harrison on the top of the ticket continued to push for Blaine, and with his resignation, this became easier.</p><p>The issue for this wing of the party became having a willing opposition candidate. Secretary Blaine did not attend the convention, and repeatedly told anyone that would listen that he was not interested in being the nominee (again). This didn’t stop delegates and party leaders from campaigning for him and nominating him on the convention floor. Some, however, began to look for a new opposition candidate, someone who was popular and a contrast from the off-putting Harrison. This faction decided on Ohio Governor, and future President, William McKinley. McKinley had made a name for himself as a congressman, guiding a key piece of Republican legislation, the Tarriff Act of 1890 through final passage. This bill is better known as the McKinley Tarriff Act. Because of this, McKinley arrived at the convention with borderline celebrity status and was elected permanent chair of the convention. This meant he presided over the convention from start to finish. On paper this seemed like a great alternative to both Harrison, and Blaine, except for one problem: McKinley didn’t want the nomination either.</p><p>The Harrison machine showed up in force at the convention. While the President stayed in Washington D.C., his closest advisors descended upon Minneapolis to ensure their boss received the nomination. Upon learning of the opposition’s preference toward McKinley, the Harrison machine began campaigning to have McKinley elected as convention chair. While counterintuitive on its face, by forcing McKinley to preside over the convention at all times, it took away his ability to campaign for himself and begin to gather support. Regardless of if McKinley wanted the nomination, the Harrison team was not taking any chances.</p><p>Other names were floated including Speaker of the House Thomas Reed, and Robert Todd Lincoln, son of President Abraham Lincoln, but the opposition could not unite behind one candidate that could beat Harrison. On Friday June 10th, the convention began the first vote for the nomination. To the surprise of many, President Harrison received enough votes on the first ballot to secure the nomination. The totals were:</p><p>Harrison- 535</p><p>Blaine- 182</p><p>McKinley- 182</p><p>Reed- 4</p><p>Lincoln -1</p><p>In the end, the Harrison machine had been much more organized and effective than their opposition. The inability on their part to coalesce behind a willing candidate seemed to be the downfall of that wing of the party. The delegation from Washington State had split, with 6 votes going to Blaine, and 1 a piece to Harrison and McKinley. The convention then nominated U.S. Minister to France, Whitelaw Reid, for Vice President. With the ticket chosen, delegates went home to begin the campaign.</p><p>Two weeks later, Democrats gathered at the Wigwam Building in Chicago Illinois to select their nominee. Cleveland and his team arrived early and got to work wooing the delegates and attempting to minimize opposition. They made substantially good progress within a very short period of time. In the first days alone, the Cleveland machine was able to convince a number of “favorite son” candidates to withdraw and throw their support behind him. Because of this, a number of state delegations that had yet to commit to Cleveland before arriving in Chicago, began to gather around the former President.</p><p>Coupled with his struggle to get support outside his home state of New York, the writing was on the wall for Senator Hill. The “Hill Boom” as it was called, was collapsing. Even with swing states switching to Cleveland, and opposition candidates doing the same, Hill and the New York delegation continued their crusade against their fellow New Yorker. In a letter signed by seventy-one of the seventy-two New York delegates, they claimed that “Mr. Cleveland’s nomination would imperil the success of the party and would expose it to the losses of the electoral vote of the state.”</p><p>Tuesday June 21st proved to be a busy day for the Democratic delegates. Due to issues with the credentials committee, the session did not begin until 5:00pm. The body then took up the issue of a platform. This debate took most of the night, as delegates debated a number of pressing issues, including a free-trade, and an anti-tariff plank. By the time debate had ended, and the final vote was taken on the platform, it was already 2:00am. The next item on the agenda was to nominate candidates for President and Vice President. Knowing that this would be a fight, New York delegate Bourke Cockran made a motion to adjourn until 10:30am the next morning and vote on a nominee then. The body voted down this motion, and they proceeded on to the nominations.</p><p>Cockran then took the floor to oppose Grover Cleveland. In his speech he accused Cleveland of being a mugwump, a term for a faction of the Republican Party that was outspoken against political corruption in the late nineteenth century. This was a typical insult used between factions of the Democrat Party to paint another as too closely aligned to the Republican Party. Cockran went on to claim that as many as 25,000 Democrats in New York had pledged not to vote for Cleveland if he is the nominee, and that if he were to be nominated it would be detrimental to the success of the party in New York, and across the country. After his speech, two more motions were made to adjourn the convention until the following morning, and both failed. After a series of nominating speeches and debates, the convention moved on to the first round of voting. Just like at the Republican convention, Cleveland was able to secure the nomination on the first ballot with a landslide victory. The vote was:</p><p>Cleveland- 617</p><p>Hill- 114</p><p>Boies- 103</p><p>Gorman- 36</p><p>Stevenson- 16</p><p>Carlisle- 14</p><p>Morrison- 3</p><p>Campbell- 2</p><p>Pattison- 1</p><p>Russell- 1</p><p>Whitney- 1</p><p>The delegates then selected former Illinois Congressman Adlai Stevenson as their nominee for Vice President. The Washington delegation unanimously voted for Cleveland. The convention finally adjourned at 4:30am. Historian George Knoles paints an eloquent portrait of the aftermath:</p><p><em>“Out of the steaming Wigwam into the gray light of dawn, a weary mob poured into the streets and soon disappeared into hotels, eating houses, and barrooms. A man bitterly opposed by his own state organization; a candidate who had lost at the polls four year before, had been given the honor of being the first man in American history to be three times nominated by a great party for the presidency of the United States.”</em></p><p>The parties had their nominees, and platforms. It was now up to each of them to convince the nation why their candidate should be given a second term, including six new states that had never cast a ballot for President before.</p><h3>The Forgone Conclusion</h3><p>There was never any question as to how Washington State would vote in its first presidential election. From the start of the campaign, it was a forgone conclusion that Washington would award its four electoral votes to President Benjamin Harrison. Since its time as a territory, and in its short three years as a state it had been a Republican stronghold. Couple this with its low electoral vote count, it did not receive much attention nationally as each campaign formulated its victory strategy.</p><p>As the summer turned to fall, one of Washington’s Republican Senators, Watson Squire, returned from Washington D.C. to campaign for the Republican ticket. Upon his return he told the press that “the Republican ticket from top to bottom is perfectly safe.” Also arriving from the capital at this time to campaign for the Republicans was President Harrison’s Interior Secretary, John Willock Nobel. Once in Seattle, he told the <em>Seattle Post-Intelligencer</em> that there is “no reasons whatever to doubt that the Republicans will be successful in the present campaign.” Many newspapers in the state ran stories and editorials pointing to President Harrison’s dominance in Washington, and policy positions that he had taken that were in line with the interests of Washington voters. Among all this noise, there was one voice that had strong disagreement with these assessments of the situation, and that was Democratic Party loyalist, and former supporter of Senator Hill, George Hazzard. Under the headline “A False Profit” <em>The Oakdale Sun </em>reported “Hazzard predicts that Cleveland will carry Washington” followed by a reminder of his past political predictions that “this is the same man who knew Washington politics so well that he foretold the democratic party in it would support Hill for president.” The headline, along with the contents of the article point to how many in the new state felt about Hazzard’s political intuition.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/388/0*aTrw7gsaEGy924m1.jpg" /><figcaption>Senator Watson Squire, one of Washington’s first U.S. Senators</figcaption></figure><p>These predictions, outside of Hazzard’s, would prove correct. Benjamin Harrison went on to win 41.46% of the vote, to Cleveland’s 33.92%. People’s Party candidate James Weaver received 21.72%, a respectable showing for a third-party candidate. In addition to this, Harrison won twenty-nine of Washington’s thirty-four counties. As mentioned, the election of 1892 has received very little scholarly analysis, and the election in Washington State that year has received none. The answer that is usually given as to how Harrison won is that Washington was a Republican dominated state and voted as such. While correct, there is much more to the story. The real answer as to why Benjamin Harrison did so well in Washington’s first election involved many other political factors and also foreshadows a new era in Washington State politics that had yet to arrive. Outside of the analysis given by historians thus far, there are three other main reasons for Harrisons’ dominance in Washington in 1892. Tariffs, the Seattle Canal project, and political fusion (or lack thereof).</p><p>The number one issue of the 1892 presidential election across the nation was tariffs. For the past few cycles, Republicans had been arguing for higher protectionist tariffs, and Democrats had been arguing against them. Washington was no different from any other state in the nation in making this its top voting priority. Unlike other states though, Washington’s economy was based on the production of raw materials and was directly impacted by recently passed protectionist tariffs. Farmers and manufacturers across the state regarded Harrison’s signature piece of legislation, the McKinley Tariff Act, as essential to keeping their industry and the state’s economy booming. One crop that had become highly profitable in Washington was hops. The chief competitor to Washington in the industry was Canada. Because of Canada’s cheaper cost of labor, and continual surplus of raw goods, western markets would be flooded with cheap Canadian hay, barley, potatoes, eggs, and hops. The McKinley Tariff act imposed protectionist tariffs on all raw products coming into the U.S., raising import duties on hops from eight cents to fifteen cents a pound. Farmers, especially those in Washington, argued that those protectionist tariffs “rescued” American farmers from “invasion and capture by the Canadian farmer.” Many in Washington viewed tariffs as essential to creating a thriving economy in the new state. In October, just before the election the <em>Tacoma Tribune</em>, a Republican newspaper, reported on the successes of the McKinley Tariff Act in Washington, stating “When members of the other parties comprehend that protection means the development of Washington’s natural resources and consequently affects the pocketbooks of individuals, they are apt to think twice before voting for free trade.” In Washington, the Republicans had done a good job taking a national issue and making it hyperlocal. The other two issues that swung this election in Washington, did not require the same kind of effort, as they were already hyperlocal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*NXUSyvIQFH2tEi74" /><figcaption>1892 Washington State Presidential Election results. Courtesy of <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:PrusBis6187&amp;action=edit&amp;redlink=1">PrusBis6187</a></figcaption></figure><p>The election for Washington State Governor was running simultaneously in November of 1892. Incumbent Governor Elisha Ferry had won an election in 1889 upon the state being admitted but was not running for a second term. King County Sheriff John McGraw had won the Republican nomination, and Yakima County lawyer, Henry Snively had won the Democratic nomination. As was the case nationally, the People’s Party ran a full slate of candidates in Washington, and Whitman County farmer Cyrus Young won their nomination for Governor. The issue that dominated that race, which in turn impacted the Presidential election, was the proposed Seattle Canal. This project being studied by the Army Corp of Engineers would dig a canal from Puget Sound to Lake Washington. Proponents of the canal argued that this would help to increase commerce in the Puget Sound region and make it easier to get raw goods to market outside the Pacific Northwest. While this project eventually did come to fruition in 1934, and is now called the Lake Washington Ship Canal, it was highly controversial when first proposed in the early 1890’s.</p><p>Many outside King County saw the canal as a waste of money. Opponents, mostly in eastern Washington, argued that the cost of four million dollars (roughly thirty-five million dollars today) was only to the benefit of King County, and that the majority of the state would not profit from its construction. Overall, Republicans were in favor of the canal, and Democrats and Populists were opposed. However, support for the project was based on geography almost as much as politics. At the state Democratic Convention, party leaders told Democrats from King County who were in favor of the canal that “their interests were not the interests of Democrats in the state.” Meanwhile, the Republicans in Pierce County, who were opposed to the canal, took the extraordinary step of passing a resolution condemning their candidate for Governor for his support of the canal. The resolution stated,</p><p><em>Whereas The Pierce County Republican convention by resolution repudiated that portion of the Republican platform referring to the Lake Washington canal; and,</em></p><p><em>Whereas the present nominee for governor on the Republican ticket is the chief exponent and author of said objectionable clause; therefore be it</em></p><p><em>Resolved by the Pierce County executive committee that all speakers or advocates on behalf of the Republican County ticket be supplied with a copy of these resolutions and are hereby instructed not to assist in the election of said McGraw, but to use all honorable means for his defeat.</em></p><p>While John McGraw would go on to win the election, he did so without the help of Pierce County. He won the election nearly 37% of the vote, but in Pierce County he received only 16%, his worst preforming county by far. Snively would capture 32% of the vote statewide, and to the shock of many, Young would receive 26% of the vote, winning four counties and outperforming the national People’s Party candidate by nearly six points. The outcry against the Seattle Canal did not have the effect Democrats had hoped it would for the simple fact that, on top of its popularity, King County had the highest number of voters. Nearly one fifth of all votes cast in the election would come from King County, where Harrison and McGraw won in landslides. Another obvious contribution to the defeat of Cleveland and Snively in Washington was the high percentage of votes given to the People’s Party, particularly in the governor&#39;s race. This was due partly to a phenomenon that was common in the western states known as fusion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*d8tT5cIml4HipMec" /><figcaption>1892 Washington State Governor’s Election results. Courtesy of <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:PrusBis6187&amp;action=edit&amp;redlink=1">PrusBis6187</a></figcaption></figure><p>Democrats in the western part of the United States, especially in the newly admitted states, knew this region would be difficult for them. In 1888 none of the western states had voted for President Cleveland, and it didn’t seem likely that 1892 would be any different. This feeling of disenchantment with the west was only exacerbated by the emergence of the People’s Party, a populist political party born out of the Farmer’s Alliance, a very popular organization in western states. As the race began to take shape, some Democrats began to look to the People’s Party as a possible alternative to their unpopular party. The People’s Party took note of this, and over the course of the campaign the two parties in some states began to understand that they were stronger together. Democrats knew they couldn’t win many states in the west, but they could deny Harrison those electoral votes by supporting Weaver and the People’s Party. The People’s Party on the other hand knew that they couldn’t win on their own, but partnering with the Democrats would give them a least a fighting chance. This alliance became known as fusion.</p><p>Fusion between the Democrats (in some states Republicans) and Populists was attempted throughout the country, mostly on the part of the populists. Democrats in the eastern part of the country knew they could win on their own, and didn’t need support from the Populists. Western Democrats however couldn’t, so fusion tickets became much more popular in the west. In the eight western states, half had some sort of fusion ticket between the Democrats and Populists. In three of those four states, Grover Cleveland’s name did not even appear on the ballot. Weaver would end up winning three states in the west, two fusion ticket states, Idaho and Colorado, and one non-fusion ticket state, Nevada. He would also come in second in two states, Oregon and Wyoming, both of which had fusion tickets. Weaver placed third in Washington, California, and Montana, where no fusion tickets were accomplished.</p><p>Fusion never succeeded in Washington. Both the Democrats, and Populists remained highly skeptical of one another and encouraged their followers not to cross. Republicans were also skeptical of the Populists, and the Republican newspaper <em>The Seattle Post-Intelligencer</em> told its readers “The People’s Party is generally regarded as a sham originated solely for the purpose of defeating the Republican ticket.” Even with both parties suspicious of the People’s Party some Democrats broke off to support Weaver and Young. Most notable of the democratic defectors was Chester Warner of Whitman County, who was a former leader in the state Democratic Party and Democratic candidate for governor. Warner had also been a leader in the Farmer’s Alliance, which had an identical platform to the People’s Party. In fact, a large portion of the support for the People’s Party in Washington came from farmers on the eastern side of the state that had been involved in the Farmers Alliance. On the west side of the state, support for the People’s Party was concentrated north of Snohomish County. In Whatcom County, it was reported that there was “very little interest” in the “Seattle-Tacoma fight on the construction of the Lake Washington Canal.” Mixed with the agrarian economy of Whatcom County, the People’s Party began to take off there. <em>The Tacoma Ledger</em> reported that it was “almost impossible for either of the two old parties (Democrat and Republican) to hold a meeting outside the city limits of New Whatcom and Fairhaven.” Cyrus Young would go on to win Whatcom, Snohomish, and Kitsap Counties, along with Yakima County on the east side. Young also tied for first place in Island County. Young came in second place in ten counties. On the national front, Weaver did not win any counties in the presidential race, however he came in second place in six counties. While the numbers show that some Republicans voted Populist, the majority of voters that voted Populist were former Democrats. The appearance of the People’s Party ticket made it all but impossible for Cleveland to be successful in Washington.</p><p>The success of the People’s Party in Washington without an offical fusion ticket being in place would predict the next era of Washington State politics. While Cyrus Young did not become Governor, and James Weaver did not win Washington’s electoral votes, eight Populists were elected to the Washington State House of Representatives. Because of this, the legislature could not agree on a U.S. Senator, and the seat remained vacant for two years. This was only the beginning of Populism in Washington. Four years later Populist John Rankin Rodgers won the Governor&#39;s race in a landslide and captured majorities in both the House and Senate. Washington had ushered in an era of Populism, that was started in 1892.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*orjoqD37GeHDsXLB.png" /><figcaption>The 1892 Presidential Election electoral map.</figcaption></figure><h3>The Return</h3><p>In the end, much of what happened in Washington that year did not affect the race nationally. Grover Cleveland won the presidency in a landslide with 277 electoral votes, compared to Harrison’s 145, and Weaver’s 22. While Harrison and Weaver denied Cleveland any victories in the west outside California, the low number of electoral votes in those states could not match the east coast. Cleveland won the big prize of New York, with its 36 electoral votes, the most of any state, and more than all the western states combined. The victory overall had been vindication for Cleveland, but doing so with his home state that he had lost four years earlier made it even sweeter. Cleveland also swept every state in the south, leaving Harrison a handful of states in New England, the upper Midwest, and the rust belt. For Harrison however, this political loss would be nothing compared to what he was already feeling, as just two weeks before the election his wife died after a long battle with tuberculosis. Out of respect, much of the campaign on both sides was suspended during the final stretch. Given the results, this last two weeks wouldn’t have made a difference.</p><p>For one reason or another, not much is left in the American memory of the presidential election of 1892. Regardless of its historical implications, which include the first president to win a second nonconsecutive term, the addition of six new states, and the first time a woman anywhere could vote for the highest office, little has been studied or analyzed of the race. The one historian, George Knoles, who authored the only book on the subject concluded that “the chief contestants were comparatively well known to the populace and the main issues were clearly drawn, little need existed for the usual ballyhoo in campaigning.” There is merit to this argument. The nation had three consecutive races where the tariff was the main issue, and in all three the Democratic nominee had been the same, and in two of the three the Republican had been the same. On its face, the race was more of the same. But what went into it, and what came out of it was truly historic. While the election of 1892 did not have giant personalities, or life-altering issues at stake to create the “ballyhoo” we see today around presidential elections, it quietly created history and changed presidential politics.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aad6872b3b7c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Baptist Bell of Marysville]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/the-baptist-bell-of-marysville-f7e7b57e06c9?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7e7b57e06c9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Oct 2024 17:37:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-03T15:57:20.885Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is easier to spot changes in a community. Buildings that stood for decades, now replaced with towering modern structures. Forests and fields now large tracts of housing. Businesses that were once cornerstones of the community, now occupied by new and unfamiliar faces. These changes are sometimes uncomfortable, and scary. They bring with them an anxiety of losing a sense of place and home. What isn’t as easy, is recognizing and appreciating what has stayed the same. These things are usually smaller, and more mundane. Easier to miss in the frenzied movement of everyday life. These constants in a community live among us like a low rumble, always there, but often overlooked. In Marysville these relentless artifacts stand as a testament to a community that has changed, but in many ways has stayed the same. One of these, a bell, recently entered a new phase in its service to the town. With its newfound place in the community, its long, quiet, and storied history can now be fully appreciated.</p><h3>The Congregational Bell of Marysville</h3><p>The Baptist bell of Marysville has been in three different locations since it came to town 125 years ago. It initially was not even supposed to be a Baptist bell, in fact it came to town to be a Congregational bell.</p><p>On May 11th, 1894, twenty-nine congregants met in Marysville’s school building, and formed the Marysville Congregational Church. At first the congregation thrived. New members joined in mass, and within five years it was decided to build a church on the corner of State and 2nd. This new church would include a bell tower, which was standard for the time, and a bell was ordered from the C.S. Bell Works in Hillsboro Ohio.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tBo1CLExI4d0OStZ84-oXQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Marysville Congregational Church on the corner of State and 2nd</figcaption></figure><p>The C.S. Bell Works was one of the leading manufacturers of bells between its founding in 1858, to its eventual closure during the Covid Pandemic in 2020. Started by Charles Singleton Bell, the company initially made farm and kitchen appliances. Eventually in 1875, Bell got into the bell business offering fifteen different types in two categories, farm bells, and school/church bells. They would go on to grow this operation and become exclusively a bell manufacturer. Supplying over fifty different types of bells at various sizes and weights, for individuals and organizations across the United States. While they did business in many industries, it was the church bell business that made them famous. Around the time that the Marysville Congregational bell was ordered, the C.S. Bell Works was producing around 25,000 bells a year. The bell in Marysville, was a type 34 bell, with a weight of 765 pounds, and a cost of $90. A type 34 bell was fairly light compared to the largest bell offered by the C.S. Bell Works, a type 54 bell which weighed 3,150 pounds.</p><p>Delivered to the Marysville Congregational Church in 1899 its ringing could be heard throughout the small town from the minute it was hung. The bell would be a fixture in Marysville for over a century, but its stop at the corner of State and 2nd would be a short one.</p><h3>Just a Few Blocks North</h3><p>During the late 1890’s and early 1900’s, a number of churches sprang up in Marysville. The Catholics, Methodists, Lutherans, and Baptists all established churches in Marysville around the turn of the century. For a town with a population around 700, this was an exorbitant number of churches, and not all would have the ability to thrive. Unfortunately, it was the Congregational Church that was not to last in Marysville. In 1907 the congregation disbanded due to declining membership. The church building was sold to Lewis McCann, a member of the congregation, and owner of the store Crain and McCann on State and 3rd.</p><p>For a period of time community events took place in the old church building, including graduation ceremonies for the Marysville school. Eventually it became primarily a warehouse, presumably for the Crain and McCann Store, and in 1915 the building burned down. Thankfully, McCann had the foresight to remove the bell from the tower upon the closure of the church.</p><p>Around the time that the Congregationalists disbanded, a new church had just opened a few blocks north on the corner of State and 5th. This newly formed First Baptist Church had actually been started a number of years earlier in 1903 but chose to meet in the I.O.O.F hall, eventually building a church in 1904. In 1907, Lewis McCann now owner of the Congregational Church, removed the bell, and offered it to the Baptists who did not have a bell in the steeple of their new church. The Baptists enthusiastically accepted the offer, and church members Pat Powers, Bert Stewart, and Frank Plont, along with McCann, moved the bell three blocks north to its new home.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jgwTCUiT2m_QpgIi3JDwtg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Marysville First Baptist Church on the corner of State and 5th</figcaption></figure><h3>Just a Few Miles North</h3><p>For the next fifty years, the Baptist Bell of Marysville sat perched at State and 5th, overlooking Comeford Park, City Hall, the construction of the water tower in 1921, the first paving of State Ave, and countless Strawberry Festival parades. It rang to celebrate good times, and to commemorate the bad ones. It was a beloved piece of life for the Baptist Congregation, and wherever they went, their bell would go too.</p><p>As Marysville grew, the Baptist Congregation grew. By 1950, the population of Marysville was around 2,200 people, and the Baptist church at State and 5th was bursting at the seams with a membership around 250. Unlike their Methodist neighbors to the south, who opted to move and expand their existing church building, the Baptists began to look for land to build a completely new church. One that could serve their needs, and the community’s needs for decades to come. In 1957, church leaders presented five plans to the congregation for expansion:</p><ol><li>Tear down the existing church and rebuild on the current property.</li><li>Purchase property on the Arlington Marysville Highway (67th Ave).</li><li>Purchase property on the corner of Grove and Liberty (47th Ave).</li><li>Purchase the Haveland Property (?)</li><li>Purchase property on the corner of Highway 99 (State Ave) and Quil Ceda Lane (81st Place).</li></ol><p>The congregation voted for the 5th option and went ahead with the purchase of land on Highway 99 and Quil Ceda Lane, which at the time was a strawberry farm. This was a bold move, as the property was still miles outside the city limits, and away from the population center of Marysville. After the decision was made to purchase the property north, the congregation sold their property on State and 5th to the Carter Oil Company, who demolished the church and built a gas station.</p><p>In November 1957, a groundbreaking ceremony was held and church membership got to work on the construction of a Fellowship Hall. This building was ready the following year, and services began to be held in what was called the Addison Self Memorial Fellowship Hall in 1958. Addison Self was a former pastor for the congregation who died after having a heart attack while preaching. They named the first building on their new campus to honor him. The congregation would meet in this hall, while the larger sanctuary was constructed, a project that progressed much slower than the Fellowship Hall.</p><p>It wouldn’t be until Easter 1961 that the first services were held in the newly constructed sanctuary. The new building could fit 500 congregants and was a part of a church campus that also included the Fellowship Hall, and Sunday School classroom space. The offical dedication of the completed First Baptist Church took place on November 12th, 1961, nearly four years after the groundbreaking. The ceremony, conducted under the leadership of Pastor Edwin Swanson included a history of the church, and highlighted longtime church members Pat Powers, Bert Stewart, Gertrude Crain, and Sant Asbery, who gave the dedication prayer. One thing was missing from this dedication ceremony though, the bell.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a57TBtAa0-IvIgp-5ACk_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>The new Marysville First Baptist Church on the corner of Highway 99 and Quil Ceda Lane</figcaption></figure><h3>Where&#39;s the Bell?</h3><p>From 1957 to 1976 the bell did not ring. During this time there were plans to construct a bell tower at the new church, but after spending so much time and money on the other buildings, this project was shelved.</p><p>It would be nearly twenty years after being removed from the bell tower in the old First Baptist Church on State and 5th, that work would begin on a new bell tower. With a larger congregation, and a much larger budget, the First Baptist Church moved forward with the construction of a bell tower on the lawn in the center of the church campus.</p><p>On Easter morning, 1976, the new bell tower was officially dedicated. On hand to ring it for the first time was Pat Powers, now almost 100 years old. Powers had been on the crew that originally moved the bell from the Congregational Church to the Baptist Church in 1907. He would go on to have a long and distinguished career of public service in Marysville, serving as town Marshall, police judge, city councilmember, and Mayor. The timing of this would be impeccable, as just two months later on July 8th, 1976, Pat Powers died five days short of his 100th birthday.</p><p>With the help of Pat Powers, the Baptist bell of Marysville once again rang. Its new position allowed it to oversee the northward march of the town in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. For another forty years it would ring to help in happiness, and in sorrow, and be a source of continuity for a congregation that had grown and changed so much since its arrival.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*utYjXD6q2KF77-q0vcuGqQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Pat Powers ringing the Baptist bell of Marysville in the newly dedicated bell tower</figcaption></figure><h3>New Faces and Places</h3><p>While Marysville continued to grow into the 2010’s the Marysville First Baptist Church did not. With church attendance declining nationally, and a number of new Baptist churches throughout North Snohomish County, including two in Marysville, the congregation saw their membership steadily dwindle. In April of 2017 sixty years after they had broken ground on the new church on Highway 99, the First Baptist church was sold. This time, they did not take their bell with them, as many scattered to other Baptist Churches in the area. The church was purchased by Damascus Road Church, later named Mercy Fellowship, and for a brief time continued to use the bell and included it in the life of their church just as the Baptists had done for so long.</p><p>Unfortunately, maintenance projects that had been put off for far too long began to occupy the time and resources of this new congregation. One of those projects was the old bell tower. The tall and skinny tower had held up the 765-pound bell for over forty years, and it was starting to show its age. It became unsafe to have the decaying structure in the middle of the lawn where families gathered before and after church, and in 2021 the decision was made to remove the bell, and the bell tower.</p><p>That year, Mercy Fellowship reached out to the Marysville Historical Society to inquire if the organization wanted the bell. The society agreed to accept the donation of the bell and sent a team of members to retrieve it. Loading a bell that heavy into a trailer is no small task, but they were able to move the bell from the church to the museum. For the next three years it sat on the grounds of the museum disassembled, while the group took on other pressing projects and contemplated just what to do with the bell.</p><p>In the Summer of 2024, under the leadership of historical society members Tom King, and John &amp; Jodi Hiatt, the bell was officially installed on the museum grounds. An engine hoist was used to carefully move the bell into its new position outside the museum. It is quite fitting that the bell ended up at the museum, as a number of former First Baptist Church members are now a part of Berean Baptist Church, which meets at the museum on Sunday mornings. In one of life’s funny coincidences, the Sunday after the bell was placed, members of the Byers family visited Berean Baptist’s service at the museum while passing through Marysville from out of town. The Byers family was one of the historic Baptist families in Marysville, and they relished at the opportunity to once again ring the bell.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/796/0*wzYgFfIjAhYA3-TG" /><figcaption>Marysville Historical Society members with the newly placed bell</figcaption></figure><p>A bell is not the first thing that comes to mind when people think of important artifacts that help to define a place. A bell is small, and in many cases unseen. The preservation of the Baptist bell of Marysville might seem small and insignificant to many who see history being lost. But this bell, quietly perched in its tower has been a part of the Marysville community through some of its most historic milestones. This bell has made history, and it is history. While things continue to change, as they always will, its artifacts like this bell that hopefully will make people slow down and appreciate the sometimes-unrealized continuity of community and where we all fit into the place we call home. Even if you’re a bell.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zP-atcNRHhHcDLzpVmbzUw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Baptist bell of Marysville in its new home outside the Marysville Historical Society Museum</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7e7b57e06c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marysville’s Oldest Church Gets a Second (or Third) Chance at Life]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/marysvilles-oldest-church-gets-a-second-or-third-chance-at-life-b447a2bcd11e?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b447a2bcd11e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Oct 2023 04:14:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-15T18:43:30.227Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When a “for sale” sign went up in the Spring of 2023 at Marysville’s Evergreen Unitarian Fellowship, advocates for historic preservation in Marysville got nervous. The property on the corner of Fourth and Columbia is a prime piece of real estate in downtown Marysville, zoned such that a builder could construct a commercial or residential building, and turn a nice profit. This nervousness stemmed from the fact that this church is not only the oldest church in Marysville, but some argue the oldest building still standing in town. In short, the Evergreen Unitarian Fellowship building is one of the only links Marysville has left standing to its humble roots in the late nineteenth century. Its loss would not only destroy a piece of history, but it would also irrevocably sever a tie to a Marysville that is almost exclusively available in books and pictures.</p><p>Constructed as the Methodist-Episcopal Church, the building initially on the northwest corner of Third and State was dedicated in August 1891. This was just four months after Marysville was incorporated. At that time, Third and State was considered to be the far north reaches of Marysville and was somewhat far removed from the business and civic district that had formed on Front Street (now First Street) along the banks of Ebey Slough. The 6,000 square foot building Marysville residents see today on the corner of Fourth and Columbia is almost unrecognizable from the church that was constructed over 130 years ago. The building has grown with the community and changed to fit the needs of its parishioners over the last century, even moving a couple blocks in the 1940’s. Thankfully, the story of Marysville’s first church did not end with those for sale signs in 2023. This brief scare however reminds us that some things are not forever, and it&#39;s important that these historic buildings are appreciated, and that stories are told while we still have the chance. As a new church prepares to move to Fourth and Columbia, it&#39;s hard not to think about the Methodists that did the same thing, albeit a few blocks away, over a century ago.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2ln9aeay6-yMpiK7UEnqmg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Early Congregants gathered outside the Methodist Church</figcaption></figure><h3>The Methodists are Coming!</h3><p>The first services held in the Marysville area by the Methodist Church took place in 1887 in a small building east of town called the Stephen’s school house. The services were held sporadically by a Reverend based out of Snohomish and usually attended by three people who didn’t even live in Marysville proper. Mary Pease, one of the original members of the Methodist-Episcopal Church recalled that you could count the number of people who claimed to be Christian in Marysville at that time on one hand. It would take three years of diligent work by the church and parishioners for Marysville to have a Reverend assigned exclusively to the town, but in 1890 one was assigned to the unincorporated community. This man, Reverend John Flynn, organized the first religious classes in Marysville’s history at the schoolhouse on Beach and 4th, better known as the Lyceum. The church was still very small, and Pease recalls none of the members even lived west of State Street at the time.</p><p>Despite the small number of congregants, Reverend Flynn’s successor W.C. Hockett, immediately began drawing up plans to build a church when he arrived in the winter of 1891. The site selected was on the corner of State and Third, which was believed to be far enough away from the hustle and bustle of Front Street that church goers could enjoy quiet services in the far north part of town. Ironically enough, this would be the reason for the church’s eventual move after World War II. With an energetic group of members, and support from the state-wide conference of Methodists, the church went up rather quickly. By August of 1891, Marysville’s first church was complete and officially dedicated. A celebration was thrown to show off the new building to the town, and it was remarked that on that day “the whole town was a church”. Reverends and Methodists from all over the area descended on Marysville to help commemorate the event, and in the evening a dinner for the entire community was held under the trees behind the church. To the community, the new Methodist Church was a glorious success, and would be a fixture in Marysville for many years to come. While things looked good on the outside, internally the group was struggling to financially maintain the massive investment that they had just made.</p><h3>Good debt</h3><p>Initially Reverend Hockett had estimated that the church would cost around $1,000 to construct. The plan was that on the day of dedication, the church would collect donations and subscriptions to help pay off the remaining balance, leaving the church debt free on day one. Unfortunately, this was not the case, in fact it was very far from it. Because not enough was collected on that day, the church was left with a large debt burden, and with only thirteen members at the time, paying it off proved to be a daunting task. Even as the Methodists opened their building to many other denominations for worship, and Marysville’s high school for classes, the church was unable to even pay the interest on the debt that was adding up fast.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SZNTFtxGbpzvn3ClwaosKg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Work being completed on Marysville’s Methodist Church</figcaption></figure><p>While it was recalled that the church was thriving spiritually, it continued to struggle financially. So much so in fact, that the Conference of Methodists decided Marysville was not financially viable and that a dedicated Reverend would be removed. Marysville was then lumped in with Stanwood, and the Reverend there was to be responsible for conducting services in both towns. In the late 1890’s transportation between Stanwood and Marysville was unreliable at best, and one did not know day to day if the train would even come. This left the church without a Reverend on most Sundays, and eventually prayer meetings and Sunday school stopped all together. A Congregational Church was founded in Marysville at about this time, and many of the Methodist members began to attend their services that were being held at the Lyceum. While the Congregational Church filled the void for many in Marysville that desired spiritual nourishment, the fact remained that the Methodist Church still had an outstanding debt on their building, and they needed to figure out a way to pay it off.</p><p>By 1894 Stanwood had become too big to share its Reverend with Marysville, and the Methodist Conference opted to instead assign the Reverend at Arlington, George Frame, to Marysville as well. While it was recalled that Reverend Frame did very little to help pay off the Church’s debt, he was able to reinvigorate the Methodists in Marysville. Church attendance began to increase, and it felt as though the group was once again active. Because of this the Methodist conference decided to separate Arlington and Marysville and assign Marysville its own Reverend for the first time in nearly five years. That man was George Dimick, and he took the spiritual health that Frame had nourished and turned it into financial health as the church looked to usher in the twentieth century.</p><p>Pease described Dimick as “a good financer”, while taking good care to not disparage his competency in other realms of being a Reverend. His goal in Marysville from day one was to pay off the church’s debt and give the group financial freedom, and that is exactly what he did. Over the next three years Dimick worked diligently raising funds, cutting costs, and making sound financial decisions for the church. By 1901, a decade after its dedication, Reverend Dimick and the members of the Marysville Methodist Church held a mortgage burning and were officially debt free. Given the time it had taken to pay off, and the interest that had been accumulated over ten years, the total price for the church ballooned from its initial $1,000 to $3,000, which is a little over $100,000 today. Regardless of this, Reverend Dimick had accomplished his goal at an amazing pace, and the largest burden on the shoulders of the church had been lifted.</p><h3>More Debt</h3><p>With the debt gone, and a new century well underway, the Marysville Methodist Church set out to refocus its spiritual goals and tend to its community. Over the next few years, the church numbers grew, and the services offered followed suit, growing with the needs of the new congregants. By 1905 the Methodists boasted 110 members, which for a community of about 1,000 residents is a substantial number. It also must be remembered that the church started with about thirteen members just fourteen years earlier. Everything was looking up for the Methodists, so much so in fact that they decided to take a big leap of faith; put themselves in more debt.</p><p>In June of 1905, the <em>Marysville Glob</em>e reported that due to the substantial growth in Sunday School attendance, along with youth attendance, the church needed more space. The plan was to raise the entire building, and construct a basement underneath with classrooms for additional meetings. The project was estimated to cost around $1,000, the same amount that the church had originally cost in 1891. This time however, church leadership went about the project differently. In early June 1905, the church held a special offering to raise funds for the project to be completed that summer. That offering was able to bring in about $700, leaving a $300 debt for the church to pay off. This was much less than the debt the church held at the turn of the century and showed that the organization had grown immensely over the last decade. In addition to this, the Marysville School District contracted to purchase the fill that was excavated from under the church to fill a pond on district property.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VTmxb0-F2RzLrQp6Eq_doA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Methodist Church after the basement addition</figcaption></figure><p>With these funds collected, work commenced on lifting the church, and constructing the basement. Initially they had hoped to be finished by the end of summer, however the project took longer than anticipated, not being completed until the end of October. Once finished, the two new classrooms added nearly 2,000 square feet to the church, and the Junior League had the honor of being the first organization to utilize the space. In addition to being behind schedule, the project also came in over budget at $1,500. Given the much better financial state of the church, this amount did not seem to worry church leadership, and the debt that was created by the addition did not seem to create any issues for the church moving forward.</p><p>Unlike the construction of the church a decade earlier, this debt was managed and paid off within the set amount of time. This left the church with more space, and in good financial health, setting the Methodists up for decades of success in Marysville.</p><h3>A War and a Move</h3><p>For the next forty years the Marysville Methodist Church quietly tended to the needs of its community and its congregants. The building that had been constructed in 1891 and expanded in 1905 met the needs of the growing community exceedingly well, which allowed the church’s financial health to grow along with its spiritual health. It was this financial stewardship that allowed the Methodists to take on their biggest project yet, one that would change Marysville’s cityscape, and bring the Marysville community the church they know today.</p><p>As the twentieth century marched onward Marysville grew northward. Originally, the business and civic district was confined to Front Street, where access to Ebey Slough was quick and efficient for incoming goods and mail. However, as Marysville continued to grow, businesses and residents turned their sights north. By the 1920’s, a new business district had been formed along State Street from Front (now First) to Fourth, and businesses also began to take shape along Third Street. Additionally, in 1922 the city moved City Hall from its home on Front Street to the corner of Third and Delta, a block west of the Methodist Church. This move signified the view of city leaders that the hub of activity in Marysville was moving north. In 1891 the Methodists had intentionally built their church away from the hustle and bustle of life on Front Street, but now over fifty years later they found themselves right in the middle of a thriving downtown. Something they never wanted, and still didn’t. So, after the end of World War II, they took a cue from the city, and decided to move their church.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HCOUdNes_rttcK5SYCg2sw.png" /><figcaption>Looking north on State from Second. The Methodist Church is on the left.</figcaption></figure><p>In early 1946, the Methodist church purchased a property on the northeast corner of Fourth and Columbia known as the Terry property. The property had one small house on it that the Terry family lived in. It was also far enough off State Street that it was considered to be in a quiet residential neighborhood, much like what Third and State use to be when Marysville was incorporated. The intention of the Methodist Church was to demolish or relocate the Terry house, and then move their church building to the Terry property. The church also planned to eventually add “a large educational unit, as well as an auditorium.” While these plans would come to fruition over the better part of the next twenty years, the task currently at hand was how to move one of Marysville’s most iconic landmarks in a way that doesn’t damage the building, or the buildings it had to pass by.</p><p>By April of that year, the Methodists had already sold their property on Third and State to local businessman Cecil Crayton. Crayton’s plan was to construct a two-story office building with automobile showrooms on the ground floor and offices available for rent upstairs. All of this hinged on the church being properly removed from the site. Over the Spring and Summer months, church members and building movers from Seattle prepped the church for its move. The plan was to jack the building up off of the basement constructed in 1905, and then lower it to ground level as it had been when it was originally built. The unnecessary portions of the interior and exterior of the building that could be damaged would then be removed along with any furniture inside the building. Once stripped down to the bar bones, it would be moved to its new home three blocks east.</p><p>By Fall of that year, the Terry house had itself been relocated to Tenth and Alder, and the Methodist Church had been prepped for its move. On Wednesday, October 9th, the movers pivoted the church out from its home of 55 years onto Third Street, where a team of trucks carefully pulled it east. Along the way linemen from the power company removed powerlines, and quickly reattached them after the church had passed, making sure that the power outages caused by the move were minimal to the downtown business district. In addition to the movers, and the linemen, many curious residents gathered to watch as a building, many had known their entire lives, moved down Third Street. Taking it slow and steady, the move went off without a hitch. By that afternoon the Methodist Church had been delivered to its new home in one piece, ready to be reassembled.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xaJLSnXmp68sQRYY_LEUIA.png" /><figcaption>The Marysville Methodist Church moving down Third Street</figcaption></figure><p>Over the course of the next three months, parishioners met across the street at the Masonic Lodge, while work progressed on their newly moved church. A basement had been dug prior to the move, and work was coming along nicely to create additional classroom space downstairs, as had been the case when the building was on Third and State. Additionally, a personage was added to the front of the church as a living quarter for the Reverend and his family. With this addition, the building that Marysville residents would recognize today, began to take shape.</p><p>The work took place from October to late January of the following year. Finally, on January 26, 1947 the newly moved and remodeled Marysville Methodist Church was officially opened to the community. That Sunday the church was rededicated in front of a large crowd of church members, community members, and Methodist leaders. Former Reverends, and members were also invited to attend the ceremony, and many made the trip to Marysville to help the church celebrate. A dinner was served to the guests, along with live music, and a presentation on the history of the church was given. The Methodists had made their home on Fourth and Columbia, and even as they rededicated their building, plans for the future of the church were already being imagined.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4FQfHp4o3i5lgekUbKcvXA.png" /><figcaption>Marysville Methodist Church now on Fourth and Columbia with the addition of a living quarter.</figcaption></figure><h3>Going West</h3><p>During the 1950’s Marysville was no exception to the explosive growth in suburbs across the United States. After the end of the war, Marysville became a destination for families in western Washington, and the population grew steadily. This brought in many new families who were looking to get involved in religious life in their new town, and the Methodist church benefitted greatly from this. Now settled in a quieter part of town, and consistently growing, it didn’t take long for the Methodists to once again embark on more upgrades to their building.</p><p>In February 1954, the Methodist Church made their expansion announcement to the community in the <em>Marysville Globe. </em>The article reported that a unanimous vote of church leadership had been taken to expand the building by extending the sanctuary 24 feet west toward Columbia Ave. The purpose was to add more capacity to the main meeting area of the church. In addition to this, the church would be improving the current chancel, adding a new pulpit and lecture, adding more seating and installing new seating for the choir, and a new balcony. Plans also included the addition of screens to the sanctuary for use during services. Downstairs, the plans called for an enlarged basement with additional classrooms, and exterior improvements, mostly consisting of work on the steeple, and a new spire. Finally, a new layer of brick was planned for the outside of the building. The estimated cost for this work was reported to be just over $20,000 (about $230,000 today).</p><p>Just as had been the case with previous upgrades, the process moved quickly. By March of that year the Methodist Church reported that $13,000 had been raised toward the upgrades, and that the start of construction was imminent. Services were once again moved to the Masonic Lodge across the street, and in May construction on the expanded church had begun. From there the work moved without issue through the summer and into the fall, with a formal dedicated of the newly expanded portion of the church in November of that year. When all was said and done, the project left the church with much more space for its growing congregation and did not leave the church with any outstanding debt. The finished product is the modern church that many Marysville residents would recognize today, with a tall steeple, and iconic brick exterior.</p><p>The final upgrade to the church took place a few years later in 1961, when additional classroom space was added to the north side of the building. From then on, the building was as it stands today. The small church built in the quiet part of Marysville just after incorporation, was now a large landmark building in the middle of a growing suburb.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/791/1*yxxGKiTz_SS78XUrk6sjhQ.png" /><figcaption>The Marysville Methodist Church, expanded west with brick along the exterior.</figcaption></figure><h3>The More the Merrier</h3><p>With the 1961 addition of classroom space to the north, the Marysville Methodist Church has expanded as much as it physically could on Fourth and Columbia. With city streets on two sides, a home on the other, and a necessary parking lot to the north, there didn’t seem to be anywhere else for the building to grow. Initially, this was no problem, as the expansions in the 1950’s and 1960’s provided ample space for the church that served a booming community. The sanctuary proved to be large enough for Sunday services, and the classroom space served the congregation well. For the next thirty years, the building with all its expansions and upgrades was a suitable home for one of Marysville’s original churches. However, as the twenty first century came into view, and Marysville continued its march to the north and east, reality set in for the Church that now served about 300 members. They needed more space than their current location could provide.</p><p>After much consideration of what to do, and how to move forward the decision was reached in 1988 to build a new church in. This meant selling the church that had been the home of Marysville’s Methodists for nearly 100 years. With a decision made, the Methodists set out to accomplish two goals:</p><ol><li>Find a buyer for their current church.</li><li>Find a suitable place to build a new church.</li></ol><p>As luck would have it, a solution to the first goal seemed to find the Methodist Church quite quickly. At about this time, the Evergreen Unitarian Fellowship had outgrown its rented space in Everett and want to purchase a building somewhere in Snohomish County. Leadership from the two organizations were brought together, and the Unitarians agreed to purchase the Methodist church for $325,000 ($763,000 today). While this part came easy, it was the second goal that would prove to be difficult for the Methodists.</p><p>Finding property was not the issue. The Methodists decided on a five-acre spot on 64th Street right in the heart of recent residential development in eastern Marysville. With a buyer identified, and a property purchased, things seemed full steam ahead, however then the task of actually constructing the new church began, and obstacles began to appear left and right. The first being a sewer moratorium that the City of Marysville had recently put into place because of the boom in residential development. The next problem arose when it was discovered there may be wetlands on the property that was intended for the new church. Finally, the original plans that were drawn up did not take into account new earthquake standards that were now required. Because of all this, the plans for the new Methodist Church were put on hold while things could be sorted out. This did not change the fact however that the Unitarians had purchased the church and were chomping at the bit to move into their new home.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*36kIkAyhBSwNAG69.jpg" /><figcaption>The Evergreen Unitarian Fellowship</figcaption></figure><p>The two churches went back to the negotiating table in 1989 to come up with a temporary solution while the Methodists worked on getting their construction up and running. That solution ended up being the most obvious one, the two churches would just share the building. Starting on Easter Sunday 1990, the Marysville Methodist Church, and the Evergreen Unitarian Fellowship began sharing the building that was now owned by the latter. The Methodist Congregation moved one of their two Sunday services across the street to the Masonic Lodge once again, and the two split up classroom space throughout the week for small groups and classes. For the next year, the two occupied the same building, which created some uncomfortable times for both groups. It was especially difficult as the Unitarians began to remove Christian symbols from the building, and the Methodists continued to worship there. Annie Foerster, Reverend for the Unitarians described the situation like “selling your house and staying there and watching the new owners repaint the walls.” However awkward the situation was, in the end both the Methodists and the Unitarians had nothing but praise for each other&#39;s groups. Reveling in the fact that they found each other when they were both in need of a change, and that they made the most of an uncomfortable period of time. By Thanksgiving 1991 the Methodist Church on 64th was complete, and the Unitarians were the sole occupant of the church on Fourth and Columbia. After 100 years, the Methodist Church no longer belonged to the Methodists.</p><h3>The Methodists are Coming Back! (kind of)</h3><p>From the 1990’s through the turn of the century, the Unitarians became a fixture of downtown Marysville. The congregation was diligent in keeping the yard and flowerbeds clean, and for a period of time they installed a community garden in the parking lot of their church. Most Marysville residents who lived in the newly constructed housing developments east of downtown drove or walked by the church throughout their daily lives not knowing the storied history of the building, now painted its iconic green. The Evergreen Unitarian Fellowship flourished in Marysville, and they were an integral part of early twenty-first century Marysville, but as was the case with the Methodists who came before them, all good things must come to an end. This end though was sped up by global pressures beyond anyone’s control.</p><p>In March of 2020 the COVID-19 pandemic rocked the world and forced churches to stop in-person meetings for months, and in some cases years. As was the case for many, if not all churches, attendance numbers at the Unitarian Church never fully recovered from the pandemic. With numbers declining, and a new reliance on zoom services, the Evergreen Unitarian Fellowship made the decision to sell the church in 2023. While many in Marysville thought that this was the beginning of a horrible story that would end with the iconic church being torn down to make way for apartments or a strip mall, it ended up being the exact opposite. The sale of the old Methodist Church ended up being a new lease on life for the old and storied piece of Marysville history. In late Summer of that year, signs went up indicating that LifePoint Church out of Lake Stevens had purchased the property and intended to rehab it and plant a church at that location. This was especially fitting, as LifePoint Church initially started out as a Methodist Church. With that began the process of turning the facility back into a Christian church, work that is anticipated to be wrapped up by December of 2023. For the time being, the original Marysville Methodist Church is safe.</p><p>It is interesting that this church does not register to many in Marysville as a historic building. To most it is the green church behind Walgreens that they pass by on their way to work but have never really given a second thought about. This could be in part because of all the renovations that have taken place over the years that have stripped much of its original regalia. However just below this mid-century surface is a building that has watched Marysville for nearly its entire existence. A building that grew with the community and moved with the community. Stories of weddings, baptisms, and birthday parties in this church are a common occurrence when the building is brought up in conversation. As more and more of Marysville’s history goes by the wayside, it&#39;s important to embrace what we have left not because something being old inherently makes it special, but because most historic structures like this one are a part of the culture and fabric of a community. Yes, the Marysville Methodist Church is a vital connection to a past that we are rapidly losing, but it is also a part of the Marysville that so many know and love. That is why saving this church, and buildings like it is important to Marysville’s future, just as much as its past.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b447a2bcd11e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Spanish Flu: Marysville’s First Pandemic]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/spanish-flu-marysvilles-first-pandemic-7bdb732aabce?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7bdb732aabce</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Apr 2023 16:39:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-27T16:39:02.915Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On April 6th, 1917, at the request of President Woodrow Wilson, Congress formally declared war on Germany, and the United States entered the First World War. This global conflict that had ravaged Europe saw death and destruction the likes of which many nations had not seen in centuries. The mixture of nineteenth century warfare with modern day technology made the fighting that much more intense, and the consequences that much more deadly. By the time the United States made the decision to enter the war the allies were tired. They had been fighting a brutally stagnant war for the better part of three years and an end did not seem to be in sight. Starting in the summer of that year the U.S. sent over 10,000 troops a day into France to assist the allied nations, reenergizing them to fight on. However, as the war entered 1918 something far deadlier than trench warfare sprang up in Europe and the United States, something that did not care what nation they fought for and could not be seen. This was an illness, an illness that would outlive the war, and kill millions more people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/798/1*MMAHWQ2OYhoGg_bAt2BXGw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Looking east down Third Street from State Ave- 1919</figcaption></figure><p>Conservative estimates put the death toll of the Spanish Flu pandemic somewhere around 25 million, while some estimates go as high as 100 million. There are a couple reasons why this number is hard to pin down, the first and most obvious being that given the widespread nature of the pandemic a definitive number is hard to agree upon. Many non-industrialized nations did not keep records of deaths, and some died without knowing they had been infected with influenza. The other reason gets to the heart of why it&#39;s important to understand the context of World War I when studying the Spanish Flu. In June 1918 Congress passed the Sedition Acts, which barred Americans from using “disloyal, profane, scurrilous, or abusive language” that could hamper the war effort, or the selling of war bonds. This is how we get the term “Spanish Flu.” Most nations that were a part of the war had passed some variation of the Sedition Act, and for most journalists and newspaper editors, reporting on a pandemic that was infecting thousands of soldiers seemed to be a violation of these new laws. The only nation to not have this style of gag order was Spain, a country that remined neutral throughout World War I. Because Spain regularly reported the cases and deaths associated with the pandemic, this led many to believe the illness had come from Spain, giving it the name Spanish Flu. This fear on the part of newspapers of reporting on the pandemic trickled down from the largest media empires in New York and London, to small-town newspapers, and even <em>The Marysville Globe</em>.</p><h3>The Spread</h3><p>The first case of the Spanish Flu in the U.S. was recorded on March 4th, 1918, at an army base in Kansas, but the deadliest wave did not hit until the Fall of that year. As this wave of influenza entered Marysville in September 1918, one would hardly know it. <em>The Marysville Globe </em>continued its in-depth coverage of the war, and in each of the weekly editions encouraged citizens to purchase war bonds and continue doing their part for the war effort. At each of the weekly city council meetings in September, issues of bonding for street improvements on State and installing light posts on 7th and 8th Streets occupied the thoughts and actions of the city leaders. At the local schools, students were settling back into the classroom for the new year, and Marysville High School was anxiously awaiting its first football game against Monroe. In Marysville, life was proceeding as normal. October 1918 though proved to be the deadliest month entire pandemic, and the reality of the situation forced its way into the small town.</p><p>On October 9th, city health officer and former Mayor Dr. Clarence Munn ordered the cancellation of school, and all public meetings. Mayor Willliam Mansfield agreed and canceled the Columbus Day celebration and ordered the moving picture house to close as well. In addition to this, the Marysville City Council would not meet for an entire month while the city was under the quarantine order. The headline on the front of the Globe that week read “City Quarantined by Spanish Influenza” and went on to report that “while there were few cases here (Marysville), the fact that the disease has appeared is sufficient reason to take this action with the hope that there may be no serious outbreak.” The Superintendent of the Marysville School District Harley McMacken told <em>the Globe </em>that the school bell would ring at 5pm the day before students are to return to the classroom. It would be five weeks before that happened, and for McMacken it his return would be short lived, as he died of Spanish Flu in December of 1918.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*adMN8_6Nh9mfCkN04YU7kA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Clarence Munn</figcaption></figure><p>The next week, as the city was still under quarantine, <em>the Globe</em> resumed its reporting on the war, with six of nine front page stories being devoted to the topic. It wouldn’t be until page three that a reader could find any mention of the pandemic, and even then, it was a reprinted public service announcement from the U.S. Public Health Service. During this time very few obituaries were printed, and many did not list the cause of death. Given the lack of reporting on the pandemic, and its effects on the town, it is hard to know just how many were infected and how many died. It would be two weeks before <em>the Globe</em> again mentioned the pandemic, this time the reporting came in the form of a small article in the bottom corner of the front-page reminding readers that they must wear a mask when traveling to Seattle. The stories above that were given much more space included more calls to support the war effort, and information on the county elections that were to take place the next week.</p><h3>When a war ends, does a pandemic?</h3><p>On Tuesday November 12th, the day after the offical end of World War I, feeling the town had sufficiently weathered the storm of the pandemic, health officer Munn lifted the “flu ban.” Schools reopened the next day, city council resumed meeting, churches held services again, and the Marysville picture house reopened to a full crowd the next evening. That week <em>the Marysville Globe</em> ran two headlines with excitement, the war was over, which was referred to as “the greatest news in the history of the world”, and the city was reopened. The next week Marysville High School football games resumed, and the fair that was planned for September at the school took place. It was decided that week that the school year would not be extended as had been discussed, but students would have to make up a few extra vacation days throughout the year, including a shortened Christmas Break, and class on New Year&#39;s Day.</p><p>For the next few weeks, the town was quiet. Everyone went back to their normal lives, the kids were in school, traveling performers returned to Marysville, and on the outside, it seemed like the pandemic has spared the small town. This was not the case, and in mid-December <em>the Globe </em>admitted as much in another hidden article in the bottom corner of the front page with the headline “Much sickness in city- but many improving.” This little snippet from the December 13th edition gives a glimpse into exactly what had been going on for the last few months.</p><p><em>“The Globe has made no effort to record all the cases of influenza during the past few weeks, chiefly because we do not like to see too many “sick items” in the paper at the same time. However there is little else to record these days and this weeks paper contains more than usual of this class of news. We are satisfied that conditions are much the same in other localities, and it will be noticed that many of the sick are recovering so there is yet time for most of us to enjoy a merry Christmas which should be coming to us as a result of the ending of the great war.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/299/1*hxxptwXufOXDDhzxTXgWRQ.png" /><figcaption>An advertisement in the Marysville Globe, November 1918</figcaption></figure><p>As Christmas came and went, and Marysville rang in the New Year, the pandemic still gripped the town. Without news to report from the war, articles on influenza deaths began to increase. In fact, from December to February, nearly every week <em>the Globe</em> ran obituaries on the front page, something that was never done even before the pandemic. Nearly all of these listed the cause of death as influenza. This was a marked shift from just months early when obituaries were seldom published, and the cause of death was never listed. Whether this change had to do with a lack of content, or the fact that absent a war, the editor felt more freedom to openly discuss the public health crisis is open to speculation. However, it must be remembered that there was a period of time, at the height of the Spanish Flu pandemic in Marysville when death and illness were not being reported, and the shift to open reporting only came as the pandemic began to wane.</p><p>There is no way to know just how many people contracted and died from Spanish Flu in Marysville during this time. Given the global circumstances, what seems today like an emergency, took a backseat to a war that had consumed the world for the better part of a decade. Records were not accurately kept, and there was incentive for the press not to report on sickness and death. This is something that went from the largest and most widely read newspapers in the world, all the way down to the small <em>Marysville Globe</em>. As is the case with so many other events throughout history, Marysville did not escape the harsh realities of global events, but it weathered the storms of war and sickness, and came out the other end. The mixture of World War I, the Sedition Acts, and the Spanish Flu pandemic made for uniquely challenging circumstances. In hindsight the story of Marysville’s first pandemic can seem odd and almost counterintuitive, especially for those that lived through the COVID-19 pandemic. It is important though to contextualize history, and understand that no two events, however similar they may seem, are the same.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7bdb732aabce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Roaming Hall: A History of Marysville’s Seat of Government]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/the-roaming-hall-a-history-of-marysvilles-seat-of-government-2e70fc297cc4?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2e70fc297cc4</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Dec 2022 19:00:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-09T19:00:48.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For centuries communities throughout the world have constructed and occupied large halls to act as seats of local government, and for community meetings, celebrations, and other related business. The modern day “city hall” that is commonplace across the United States and takes similar form across the world can be traced back to Ancient Rome. During this time large halls known as Basilicas were occupied to carry out community meetings, facilitate trade, and to administer justice. This model of a community gathering place to conduct official business has stayed relatively the same to this day, of course incorporating many modern uses, but the premise has remained unchanged.</p><p>Marysville has had six city hall buildings in seven locations since its founding in 1891. While each additional seat of government has brought with it more space and increased services, it is interesting to consider that all six were and are in the “original” 1891 city limits of Marysville. Even as the city marched north to Smokey Point, and grew to nearly 75,000 residents, the housekeeping of a city is still carried out in relatively the same part of town. This speaks to a desire among leaders and residents to keep old downtown Marysville as the focal point of the community, and to continue reinvestment in the area. As city leaders prepare to open the newest city hall building at 501 Delta Ave, it&#39;s important to look back at how the community got to this point. While this grand opening is a time for celebration, it&#39;s interesting to note that the politics surrounding a city hall building in Marysville has not always been agreeable. In fact, from the beginning the question of even needing a physical seat of government was up in the air.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0hdDq8V6M-O0DQeedTYCGQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Calaboose First, Town Hall Second</h3><p>On March 20th, 1891, the city council of the newly incorporated town of Marysville convened for the first time. This inaugural meeting of town leaders lacked any of the fanfare and ceremony that modern observers of government would expect, and the notes from that meeting do not go on long enough to fill a single page. The pressing issue for that first meeting? Prostitution. In fact, the first ordinance that was drafted by the original five-member city council banned prostitution within the city limits and was adopted at that first meeting. Initially town leaders were blasé about where the council would meet, and where the seat of government would be, suggesting that meeting in the general store was perfectly acceptable. However, as the newly appointed town marshal got to work, it became clear that the city needed a building, if not to conduct business, to house the outlaws that were beginning to break the newly established laws.</p><p>On April 2nd, 1891, the council took the first step toward building Marysville’s first city hall. At this meeting a committee made up of Councilmembers Smith and Meyers was appointed to look into building a jail. Later that month the council gave approval for the committee to enter negotiations to acquire land to build the jail and town hall. The new committee with Councilmembers Smith and Plate set out to purchase a piece of property from Alexander Spithill, who was also a councilmember, on Sixth Street.</p><p><em>Historians Note: Councilmember Henry Plate played the biggest role in getting Marysville’s first city hall built. Unfortunately, of all Marysville’s founders, the least is known about him. In fact, we do not even have a photo of Plate. Through research done in 2020 however, </em><a href="https://petercondyles.medium.com/a-typo-that-led-to-the-rediscovery-of-a-marysville-pioneer-d11be7344d87"><em>new information was learned about his tragic death in 1900.</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KQ8P0Cq6VoDKFkyvcB_TlA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Henry Plate Signature</figcaption></figure><p>On May 2nd, 1891, a month after the committee was first charged with building a new town hall and jail, Smith and Plate reported to the council that “We your committee on Mr. Spithill’s property giving two lots on 6th Street for town building respectfully report that we have examined the same and, in our opinion, think it is too far from the business part of the town.” For the time being, the Spithill property was out. Exactly one week later though the committee came back with a new proposal: Lots 8 and 9 in Block 4 of the Myer’s addition. This would be the NE corner of Front and Delta, about where Big Lots is today. The council agreed with this proposal, and they instructed Henry Plate to act as a committee of one to handle the sale of the property. Plate began the process of purchasing the land, but on June 1st, nearly a month after city leaders agreed to purchase the property it was reported that the deal had fallen through stating “a difficulty with regard to getting a deed to same.” This put the council, and the leader of the charge, Henry Plate, back at square one. This would not last long.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/351/1*MqR2GSL_pYpyXGnIiQxuOA.png" /><figcaption>Marysville Sandborn Insurance Map- 1892</figcaption></figure><p>Four days later Henry Plate was back to report that the city was offered Lot 4 in Block 2 of the original town site for $300. This property is in the alley between Third and Fourth streets, approximately where the parking lot to Don’s Restaurant is today. The council passed a bond for the land within days, and Henry Plate was then appointed a committee of one to handle the construction. While there are no photos of Marysville’s first jail and town hall, Plate reported to the council that the building would be 16&#39; x 20&#39; and would be two stories tall. Given what is shown on the Sandborn Insurance Maps, this size appears to be what city leaders ended up building. Plate contracted with E.J. Anderson of Everett to construct the building, and after accounting for interior costs, the new jail and town hall totaled about $400. The building was opened later that year, with very little ballyhoo, and used primarily as a jail, and as a meeting place for the city council. In fact, the Sandborn maps label the building as “calaboose 1st, town hall 2nd” showing how city leaders prioritized its use early on. This building would not last long. Not even a decade later city leaders were desperate for more space, and a place for a new variety of city services. This time they would again look to E.J. Anderson, and for the only time in town history until 2022, they would look south, not north.</p><h3>A Proper Hall</h3><p>By the close of the century, it was clear Marysville needed a dedicated City Hall building. The seat of government was being operated out of the small two-story jail and it could not keep up with the growing town. In the time since incorporation Marysville had a growing police force, a much-needed fire department, and an increasing number of citizens visited city hall for treasury services. Not everyone agreed with this sentiment though. The first proposal for a new city hall came in late 1899 and was advocated for by councilmember Stohr. Stohr proposed the construction of a new building, and a bond for $500. During the January 13th, 1900, session of the Marysville City Council, Stohr had to leave the meeting early to attend to other business. In his absence the city council voted to call in the $500 bond and deplete the treasury making it impossible to move forward with the project. For at least a moment, the city hall question was shelved.</p><p>The question continued though, and throughout 1901, the council, which now included new members, weighed its options. By June the consensus was that a new building would need to be constructed, and the city purchased vacant land on the south side of Front Street between Beach and Cedar. Front Street was the hub of Marysville at the turn of the century, and a city hall situated on this bustling corridor would be convenient for residents and city leaders alike. On June 10th, 1901, just a little over a decade since the plans for the calaboose building were presented, the plans for a new city hall building were once again presented to the city council. The initial plans included space for the fire department, the city treasurer, the city clerk, council chambers, and even a library. That evening after little debate, the council adopted the proposed plans, and the next week approved $4,000 for the construction of a new city hall on Front Street. Additionally, the council appointed themselves as a building committee to oversee the project. Unlike a decade earlier when the building committee was made up of just Henry Plate, now the entire council would serve on the committee.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/888/1*FB6WGRJJsUsnz-eKOld_Eg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Once the decision to build the new hall had been made, the process unfolded quickly. By the end of June 1901 bids had been submitted to the city by local builders, and on July 1st the city council awarded the contract to E.J. Anderson of Everett, the same builder who had built the calaboose ten years earlier. The bid that was accepted came in much lower than what the city council had initially allotted for the project, only costing $2,574. The building was to be two stories and include a bell tower on top for the use of the fire department, which would be stationed in the bottom floor. Upstairs the library, Treasurer’s office, Clerk’s office and council chambers would all share a floor. The front of the new hall would have two large doors so that the fire equipment could be moved in and out when needed. The Police Department would then become the sole occupants of the calaboose. The new city hall would have everything necessary for a growing town.</p><p>The construction did not take long, and later that year the new city hall was opened, once again to little fanfare, and city services moved to the new site. For the next two decades the city hall building on Front Street would serve the city of Marysville well. But as time marched on and the city grew northward, Front Street became an inconvenient place for the seat of government. The building on the other hand was still at the height of its useful life. This proved to be a real predicament for the leaders of the growing city, and in the early 1920’s they settled on the most logical course of action. Just move it.</p><h3>We Don’t Need a New Building…</h3><p>The impetus to move city hall did not actually come from city leaders. In fact, the first calls to take on the project came from a group of concerned citizens. In March of 1922, a delegation from the Log Cabin Club (a group that later merged with the historical society in the 1990’s) led by Mabel Holmes attended a city council meeting and expressed their desire to work in cooperation with city leaders to move city hall to a more central location. As Marysville continued to grow north, a new business hub had been formed along State Ave and Third Street, making Front Street no longer the most convenient place for city services. The Log Cabin Club had hoped that in moving the building closer to where Marysville was developing, it would become a gathering place for residents. The group pledged to chip in money for the move, and the McMaster Shingle Mill, which was located directly south of the present city hall property, pledged $250 to the project in return for the vacant property. After much deliberation the city pledged $100 to the project, and in typical fashion, formed a committee made up of Councilmembers Smith and Argle to work with the Log Cabin Club to make the move happen.</p><p>The project to move city hall would undergo a series of stops and starts over the course of 1922. The committee initially came back with two plans: The first was to move city hall to the city park downtown (modern day Comeford Park), and the second was to purchase property from the Comeford family on the corner of Third and Delta. In April the council requested bids for both sites to compare prices. Later that month the city received only one bid from C.W. Thompson for $700 for either location. The cost caused much surprise among those involved who did not think it would be that expensive, and after sitting on the bid for a couple weeks the council unanimously rejected it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jlDLlZ51YGkM-zzvr9dOdg.jpeg" /><figcaption>City Hall at its original location on Front Street</figcaption></figure><p>The Log Cabin Club did not give up, and in June of that year the council allotted additional money to the project, and they readvertised for bids on both locations. The city once again only received one bid to do the work, this time from Homer J. Dennis a home mover in Everett who claimed that either site would only cost $600. City leaders were ecstatic, the price had come down even as they put more money to the project, and they approved the bid the same night. This jubilation was short lived. Exactly one-week later Dennis returned to the council explaining that the price had gone up, and that he now expected the city to pay for an additional contractor to build the new foundation. The news was not well received, and that evening the council voted unanimously to not move forward with the bid from Dennis. For the second time in two months, it looked like the project was dead. As spring of 1922 turned to the summer, and then the fall, the city hall project sat dormant on the ever-growing to-do list for the growing town. There was no mention of the project at the council meetings, or in the <em>Marysville Globe </em>for that entire period of time, and for many in town the project seemed to be defunct. That was until in late November, when a proposal come forward from an unlikely source.</p><p>One of the major projects that the city council had funded that year was paving the sidewalks along Third Street. On the evening of November 20th, 1922, Ellis Bancroft, the contractor doing the sidewalk paving came to the city council to report on the progress of his project. At this meeting Bancroft informed city leaders that he was aware of their predicament with the city hall move and had brought with him a bid to complete the project well under what had already been offered. The council, having already worked with Bancroft, was very interested in this offer, and reopened the bidding for the project so that he could submit his proposal. <em>The Globe</em> then ran a headline later that week saying, “SURE THING THIS TIME — REMOVAL OF TOWN HALL”. After languishing for nearly six months, it appeared that the move was back on. That is until it wasn’t. The next week in smaller and less bold lettering <em>The Globe</em> ran the headline “Another delay in moving town hall”. At the city council meeting that week the bid from Ellis Bancroft was opened to reveal his price the highest as one yet at $1,175. However even with this price, a minority of members expressed their interest in seeing the project completed and supported acceptance the higher bid. Unfortunately for Bancroft this was not the opinion of the majority, and his bid was rejected that evening. For the third time that year the project was dead.</p><p>Just when hopes for the move seemed dashed once again, <em>The Globe</em> printed a joyful headline the next week exclaiming “TOWN HALL REMOVAL IDEA NOT DEAD YET”. That week at the city council meeting it appeared to the council that the solution to their problem might have been under their noses all along. Marysville resident and local contractor S.B. Mapes, at the request of Mayor John Hilton, expressed his interest in putting forward a bid to move city hall to the corner of Third and Delta, and he guaranteed it would be affordable for the city. The council reopened the bidding, and the next week Mapes submitted a bid to move city hall for $835, higher than the initial bids, but much lower than the Bancroft bid. Not wanting to repeat any of the mistakes that had already been made with this project the council immediately accepted the bid and instructed Mapes to begin the move as soon as possible.</p><p>That winter proved to be wet and cold, weather that is not conducive for moving a building. For three months city hall sat waiting for a dry stretch of weather to make its big move. Finally, in the middle of March the opportunity presented itself. On March 12th, 1923, the building was prepped, the path cleared, and the move commenced. Being tugged by a team of horses, the building first moved NW across Front Street to Beach, and then east on Third. The plan was to wait until the 1:00pm freight train went through town before crossing the train tracks on Third and traveling one block to its new home on the corner of 3rd and Delta (present day Dairy Queen). This would give movers two and a half hours until the 3:30pm train was scheduled to come through. Unfortunately, the train was late that day, and did not come through Marysville until 2:00pm, giving the movers an hour and a half to move an entire building over an at grade crossing. As soon as the train passed, work was underway to cross the tracks. Things seemed to be going well at first, until the building was squarely in the middle of tracks and a steel cable snapped causing the ropes and coils to tighten so much that the building became unmovable. People came from all over town to help try and get the building over the tracks. Mapes’ crew, bystanders, T.F. Comeford, and even State Senator Mott all came to lend a hand to no avail. After a half hour city hall had not moved an inch from the middle of the tracks, and those watching were beginning to get nervous. That is when an unlikely hero arose from the crowd. F.J. Custer, a local painter, described by <em>The Globe</em> as having “never been accused of being a mechanic engineer scientific expert”, spoke up and suggested removing the entire core of the works in hopes of freeing the ropes and coils. Mapes argued that the plan wouldn’t work, but Custer and a couple of bystanders got to work, and within minutes the core pieces were out, and the ropes and coils were free. With the help of Custer, the building was able to cross the tracks to its new home with only minor damage to the plaster. When all was said and done the move had taken just under ninety minutes and came within minutes of missing the 3:30pm train. Mapes described the city hall as “a beast” that was much heavier than he anticipated. Regardless, the project that has been in the works for over a year had been successful, and for the time being Marysville was pleased with its new relocated seat of government.</p><h3>You Can’t Move a Building Twice</h3><p>Between 1901 when the city hall on Front Street was built, and the end of World War II the population of Marysville had more than doubled. What was once a fledgling fourth-class city with wooden sidewalks was now a respectable suburb with a teeming business corridor and a rapidly growing populace. Starting even before World War II city leaders expressed the inadequacy of the relocated city hall in meeting the needs of the growing town, but nothing concrete came of these concerns. When A.H. March was elected mayor in 1936, he pledged to build a new city hall. As is the case with many promises made on the campaign trail, this was much easier said than done. The issue for March became a lack of agreement among city leaders as to what should be done. Some believed that the old building had some usefulness left in it and argued it should be added on to. Others believed that the building was in terrible shape and should be demolished and a new city hall built. During his nearly two years in office March had brought forward multiple proposals, each one being struck down by the council. In 1937, near the end of his two-year term, Mayor March resigned and moved to Seattle, leaving senior city council member Arthur Brown in the Mayor’s seat. During his first couple years in office, he continued with little success to strike a deal to build a new city hall, but everything was put on hold as the world found itself in a global conflict for the second time that century. During World War II the old city hall became the meeting place for the Marysville Civil Defense group, and a spotter was assigned to the roof of the building to keep watch for enemy aircraft during the night. When the United States instituted a draft in 1940, all Marysville men eligible went to city hall to sign up. When the war ended though, the conversations regarding a new building began again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/897/0*VGoeCw7zVeAH5iTy.jpeg" /><figcaption>The old city hall on the corner of Third and Delta</figcaption></figure><p>For Mayor Brown though, the war seemed to be the major issue that occupied his time in office. While he helped Marysville weather the storm, he did not have the time or circumstances to get a new city hall built. He served two terms, and in 1944 chose not to seek re-election. Brown was succeeded by Ernest Washburn, a member of the city council, and someone who knew firsthand how badly a new city hall was needed. With the war over, and a new group of city leaders in place, Washburn went to work lobbying for the project ultimately deciding upgrades were far too costly, and a new building was the best course of action. During his first term he convinced the city council to begin putting away money to construct a new city hall on Delta Ave between Fifth and Sixth Streets in Comeford Park.</p><p>With some money saved, and it being abundantly clear the city needed a new building now more than ever, the council requested bids for a new city hall in the Fall of 1948. The desire of city leaders was to cap the project at $45,000, but as bids came back it became clear that may not be possible. Every bid that was received was well over budget, and the council unwilling to expand their budget reject every single bid. The created uproar in the town. Citizens along with the <em>Marysville Globe</em> editor Sim Wilson did not hide their feelings of frustration that the city council couldn’t seem to come to a decision on the project. This forced city leaders and architects back to the drawing board to see if a design could be put together with all the needed components while staying within the budget that the council had set for themselves. The mayor explained that “Ascending building costs have delayed construction of the city building which was expected would be erected soon after the close of the war. The much-needed building is nearer reality now than it has been.” This was hopeful news, and in Summer of 1949 city leaders once again requested bids for a new city hall.</p><p>On July 11th, 1949, the Marysville city council once again reviewed bids submitted to construct a new city hall in Comeford Park, and once again the bids were all well over the $45,000 cap the body had set for itself. The closest bid was $12,000 over budget and submitted by Eugene Solie of Everett. Understanding the predicament that the council found themselves in, Solie offered to alter his bid and “change the exterior appearance of the building to a less formal style” to make it more affordable. After spending a month reworking his proposal, and city leaders deliberating over the new design, it was approved on Friday August 12th with the full amount being $42,500. Considering the length of time at which the city had been waiting for a new hall, leaders did not want to waste any time, choosing to start construction the following Monday. With the modifications, the new city hall would include nearly all city services, the city jail in the south wing, the library in the north wing, and other city staff sandwiched in the middle. A second story penthouse would house the jail night guard, and a basement was included to serve as a fallout shelter. It was also agreed that for the time being the volunteer fire department would continue to operate out of the old city hall. That building was demolished in 1955.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1009/1*DDmx2_JvY4Fi4MhffbvMGQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A rendering of the proposed city hall in Comeford Park</figcaption></figure><p>From the beginning of the project, Mayor Washburn had set a goal of having the first city council meeting of the new decade in a new city hall. As Christmastime came to Marysville, and the 1940’s came to a close, this was seen as an ambitious goal. However, on January 10th, 1949, as the interior was still being completed around them, Mayor Washburn called to order the first council meeting of the 1950’s, he had achieved his goal. Over the course of January and February of that year, city departments moved from their old home a few blocks north to their new one. During this period there was also a frigid snowstorm that left the city covered in snow and ice during the move. While at first this might have seemed like a hinderance, it actually proved to be helpful. The City Treasurer was able to load the heavy safe on a sled and move in into the new office that way. On March 10th the city officially hosted an open house for residents to come tour their new city hall, and the <em>Marysville Globe</em>, which had been critical of the council during this process even published this gracious assessment of the new building:</p><p><em>“A pleasant walk through the city park from State Street, or a drive to the door of the building now attend the visit of these residents. Visitors to the city hall will find the building attractively decorated, with unusual color combinations to be found in each of the rooms.”</em></p><p>A detailed history of this building, later known as the Ken Baxter Center can be found <a href="https://petercondyles.medium.com/the-ken-baxter-center-a-home-for-civic-life-in-marysville-for-half-a-century-d81faa8414"><em>here</em></a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*js4lAV7uyx3NeLrWH8rhtA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Marysville City Hall 1950</figcaption></figure><h3>A New Building, and Another, and Another</h3><p>In the decades following the opening of the city hall building in Comeford Park, Marysville’s population exploded. Fueled by the rise in popularity of the suburbs, and by Marysville first ever annexations spurred by Mayor Gerald Dudley in 1952 Marysville welcomed thousands of new residents. All of which needed city services. Over a period of twenty-five years, the population of Marysville doubled, and those that worked and did business at city hall expressed the need for more space. Since the most used part of the building was the library, city leaders determined that Marysville needed a single building dedicated to that service. This new library was built at 4822 Grove Street and included a much larger collection of books, as well as a Log Cabin Club room. Upon the opening of the new library, the city council decided to move its official chambers to the Log Cabin Club room, and beginning in 1979, the council began to meet there regularly. Marysville was continuing its march northward.</p><p>In the ten years following the construction of the new library, Marysville’s population continued to explode. By the close of the 1980’s the population had more than doubled from when the new library was built and was now over ten thousand residents. The city hall building could not keep up. City leaders decided to do the same thing they had done ten years earlier, build a new building. This time the building was for the police department. With the police department moved out of city hall, city operations could expand to the south wing of the city hall building, and for the first time, city hall was solely occupied by city staff. With the opening of the new public safety building for the Police and Fire Departments on the corner of Grove and Alder in 1989, the city council decided to once again move its chambers into the newer facility, and for the next decade would meet there.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0UnRa_oxkqXAhsDlgh9MVw.jpeg" /><figcaption>City Hall at 4822 Grove Street</figcaption></figure><p>With the City Hall, the library, and the Police Department now all occupying separate buildings the thought was Marysville had plenty of room to grow. This would only last about another ten years. As the end of the century came into view the population of the once tiny town was still growing at a record pace, nearing twenty thousand residents. The library could not keep up, and neither could the city hall building that even with one tenant now, was out of room. The solution was once again, to build a new building. This time however it was for the library again. The city council voted to construct a new library further east on Grove (its present location), and city hall would temporarily move into the old library, while a new city hall was planned. This seemed to satisfy all city departments who were looking forward to moving somewhere with more space to serve the growing population. On July 19th, 1997, the city hall building that has been wished for by so many nearly fifty years earlier officially closed its doors. This time though city leaders believed their old home had potential, something that city leaders did not believe in 1950. Over the next few months, the city parks department remodeled the old city hall, and in August of 1998 reopened it as the Ken Baxter senior center, named for their colleague and longest serving city councilmember in Marysville history. This new arrangement though would be extremely temporary.</p><h3>One Stop Along the Road</h3><p>The City Hall on Grove Street would be the shortest occupant of Marysville’s seat of government. Only a few years into the twenty-first century city leaders were on the hunt for a larger building that could serve more city departments. In August 2002, a little over five years after City Hall moved from Comeford Park to Grove Street, the city announced it would purchase the Allstate Insurance building at 1049 State Ave for $2.1 Million. The plan was to move City Hall and the Municipal Court to the building which was more than double the size of the Grove Street building. City leaders at the time stressed that this new building wouldn’t be a “permanent house” for city hall and that it would be “one stop along the road to a city government campus.” The plan in fact was to only occupy the Allstate Insurance building for ten years, while planning for a civic campus where all city departments could occupy the same space for ease of services. Additionally, the sale of the Allstate building in ten years was supposed to go to the payment of the new campus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*a76egV-rkXaXZpDL.jpg" /><figcaption>City Hall at 1049 State Ave</figcaption></figure><p>Over the next year, the city worked on improving the interior of the Allstate building to serve as City Hall. One of the largest tasks was putting up walls in the upstairs portion of the building, which had been one large call center with no divided rooms. When all was finished, walls had been installed to create the City Council Chambers, Executive Department, and Finance Department. On June 6th, 2003, City Hall officially opened at 1049 State Ave, and on June 23rd the City Council held its first meeting at the new location. The next temporary city hall had been established, but over the next two decades, the plans that the city had put in place would be interrupted by many factors including the Great Recession of 2008.</p><h3>Back Home</h3><p>As the city was reaching the halfway point to the ten-year goal of selling City Hall at 1049 State Ave, plans began to take shape for the Civic Campus that had been dreamed about. With city services split between City Hall, a Municipal Court Building, a Public Safety Center, and a Community Development/Public Works Building, it was apparent that the situation was not a sustainable one. Citizens had to bounce between four buildings just for city services. The city looked at various options for services offered at one location, and different sites including one near the Ebey Slough waterfront park, and the other adjacent to Comeford Park where City Hall had once been for half a century. Plans were drawn up, but nothing final was ever decided on. Unfortunately, during this period of planning the nation was rocked by the Great Recession of 2008. Coupled with other factors, the civic campus idea was shelved and the ten-year mark at 1049 State Ave came and went.</p><p>In the mid-2010’s, as the city and the nation continued to recover from the lasting damage done by the Great Recession, talks of the civic campus began again. This time, city leaders were set on property adjacent to Comeford Park, between Delta Ave and the railroad tracks. One difference between this new plan and the plans that had been drawn up in the early 2000’s was that this new campus included space for a relocated police station. Originally the plan was to leave the police department at the public safety center on Grove Street, but more space was needed for the department to properly serve the growing city. In addition to a police station, the new proposal brought all city services into one building for the first time since the construction of the Comeford Park City Hall in 1950. With the new plan in place, the city put a 0.1% sales tax on the ballot to help fund the police department portion of the building, which would be the largest cost. Revenue from the sale of additional city property, and money in savings were proposed to fund the rest of the $68 million project.</p><p>On August 7th, 2018, 53.56% of Marysville voters approved the sales tax increase, and in effect approved the new civic campus project. From here final plans were agreed upon, and in October of the following year the bid for the new building was awarded to Lydig Construction of Bellevue. The community gathered on January 13th, 2020, for an offical groundbreaking along now leveled ground on Delta Ave. One piece of the project was the demolition of the Ken Baxter Center, which served as City Hall from 1950 to 1997. The demolition took place in May of 2021 and signaled the return of Marysville’s seat of government to the place where it stood for over half a century. The COVID-19 pandemic, and labor relations issues put the construction on pause multiple times, and led to delays in completion of the project, but in Fall of 2022 city leaders began the process of moving from their respective buildings to the Civic Campus. On November 7th of that year, the Marysville City Council met for the first time in the new building at 501 Delta Ave. The project that was supposed to take ten years had taken twenty-two, but the vision had finally been completed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QmnK6WwjJe7eBs5s" /><figcaption>The Marysville Civic Center</figcaption></figure><p>Over the span of one hundred and thirty years Marysville has had six city hall buildings. These buildings ranged from a small shack meant to house frontier outlaws, to a four-story tower that stretches three city blocks. These six buildings have served residents as the city went from a sleepy hamlet on Highway 99 to the second largest city in Snohomish County with a vibrant and growing economy. What is most remarkable however, is that the new Civic Campus opened in 2022 is less than a quarter mile from the location of Marysville’s first city hall built in 1891. Marysville has grown exponentially in size and population, but city leaders and residents alike still see the original part of town as the best suited place for the government business to take place. In that respect, the new civic campus that was a dream for so long pays tribute to those that led our city for decades before and will stand as a constant reminder of their efforts to make Marysville the dynamic community it is today.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2e70fc297cc4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Alexander Callahan: The “Demon” Sheriff of Whatcom County Part II]]></title>
            <link>https://petercondyles.medium.com/alexander-callahan-the-demon-sheriff-of-whatcom-county-part-ii-a11448508b2c?source=rss-47c2de19caff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a11448508b2c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Peter Condyles]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Nov 2022 23:47:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-21T23:47:38.433Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On New Year’s Day 1900, the world rang in a new century. Together civilization closed a chapter of human history marred with old world conflict, rampant bigotry, and intense industrialization and welcomed a new era that promised expanded commerce, social change, and exploration the likes of which many had never seen before. Much of this exploration that the twentieth century had to offer was in the western half of the United States. Decades before the turn of the century tens of thousands of pioneers packed up their lives and gambled on the idea of a better life in a wild land full of unknowns. For many, this gamble did not pay off, but as the world celebrated this calender change, one of these pioneers was busy plotting his move west. The gamble that Alexander Lewis Callahan took in the winter of 1900 moving from his quiet farm life in Nebraska to the fourth corner of the United States was one that would set him up for immense success and ensure that a fledgling community built into the untamed landscape of the Pacific Northwest would have a fierce and dedicated protector.</p><p>Arriving in Bellingham in February of 1900, Alexander Callahan entered the local carpentry business. Here he saw much success but opted to transfer to the law enforcement profession in 1905. He was quickly promoted to Captain, and on three separate occasions, served as Bellingham Police Chief. He then made another shift from municipal law enforcement to county law enforcement in 1916, becoming Deputy Whatcom County Sheriff. His career was briefly interrupted by the war that had broken out in Europe. Callahan volunteered to fight on the front lines at the age of forty-five, going on to see combat in France and leading an all-black engineering regiment in the First World War. After his service to his country was complete, he returned to Bellingham and picked up right where he left off. In 1920 he threw his hat in the ring running for Whatcom County Sheriff as a Republican. Callahan was so popular throughout the county at the time that the Democratic Party chose not to run a candidate for Sheriff that year, and publicly endorsed Callahan for the position. That November he prevailed with over sixty percent of the vote. In a period of twenty years, Callahan had gone from being a mid-western carpenter with little to no connections in a new and unfamiliar city, to a popular, dedicated, and beloved public servant. Now in public office Callahan had to live up to the support that he had been given. His tenure in office would be defined by not only dedicated service, but also immense tragedy, ugly scandals, and issues that seemed to remain prevalent as the passing of time marched forward.</p><h3>The first term: Prohibition and Tragedy</h3><p>The issue that would define Callahan’s eight years as Sheriff was prohibition. In the early 1920’s the Canadian border was not patrolled, and rum runners were pouring into the United States with illegal alcohol. It was up to local law enforcement to catch the criminals and enforce the federal mandates. Given the sheer volume of illegal alcohol entering Whatcom County, this proved to be nearly impossible. Upon taking office Callahan made many substantial changes to how the Sheriff’s office dealt with illegal alcohol seized near the border. Callahan believed the way the Sheriff’s office had been storing seized alcohol was asking for trouble. Rooms at the county courthouse were packed with confiscated bottles, and there was no real system in place to catalogue and eventually destroy the contraband. One of Callahan’s first moves was to retain the assistance of former Whatcom County Sheriff, and his old boss, Will Wallace. Callahan appointed Wallace as Special Deputy charged with getting the excess alcohol in the county’s possession in order for eventual destruction. The office was so far behind in processing, Callahan needed a full-time employee to take on this task.</p><p>The county did not have laws pertaining to what should be done with seized alcohol. The practice had been to store it at the courthouse to be used as evidence in criminal cases, but Callahan was not trusting enough to keep this practice in place. In February of 1921, he requested that a court order be issued allowing the Sheriff’s office to dispose of all seized alcohol once the case it was related to closed. Whatcom County Superior Court Judge Hardin agreed and signed the order allowing the Sheriff’s office in conjunction with the Clerk’s office to destroy the stored evidence. It was recalled in <em>The Bellingham Herald</em> that after this order was given, later that summer, Callahan was able to destroy $4,000 worth of alcohol in one day, equivalent to just over $66,000 today. While this took care of the alcohol already seized, the issue of the alcohol being illegally sold in Whatcom County only got worse.</p><p>Callahan increased patrols around areas where rumrunners were known to smuggle alcohol and made tracking local smugglers a priority for his deputies. In his first six months alone, the department arrested fifty suspected smugglers, a number that was unheard of under his predecessor. Additionally, Callahan had made such a ruckus to the federal government about the issue that in June of 1921 John Exnicios, a federal agent, was sent to Whatcom County for the sole purpose of aiding Callahan in tracking and arresting alcohol smugglers. Callahan became so proficient at arresting these criminals that the county jail was proving to be too small and underequipped to handle the volume. In July of that year Callahan went before the County Commission to request they purchase more blankets and bedding for the jail, as the facility only had bedding for thirty prisoners. Combined with the non-prohibition related offenders, Callahan was going above this number regularly. The County Commissioners did not take kindly to Callahan’s request, arguing that the federal government had given the county the impossible task of enforcing prohibition, and they should not have to foot the bill. The Commissioners instead expressed support for a law that would require smugglers carry blankets and pillows with them while partaking in their illegal activity in case they ended up incarcerated. In the end the body did not pass any such law or grant Callahan the extra blankets.</p><p>The business of bringing illegal alcohol across the border from British Columbia brought colorful characters into Whatcom County. One of those characters was Jack Kielt, who had regularly smuggled alcohol into the country near the Sumas border crossing. In the summer of 1921, sheriff’s deputies encountered Keilt near Columbia Valley and attempted to apprehend him. A fight ensued, and Kielt was able to disarm both officers and hold them at gun point. After a period of time Kielt let the officers go if they let him go in return, but issued this warning:</p><p><em>“If it was Sheriff Callahan, he would be dead right now. I am going to shoot him on sight. I have made up my mind to that and also that I am not going to jail again. Callahan has been making too much trouble for me and rather than go back to jail I will die.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/505/1*vDreoTKtn-HBB4qcR8Fk3Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>In typical form, Sheriff Callahan was not going to take this threat lying down. When he heard of the encounter he reportedly responded, “huh, I’ll go out and arrest him, and I’ll go alone.” With the exception of arresting Kielt, Callahan did just what he said. He got in a patrol car and headed for Columbia Valley by himself. This prompted much concern for his well-being around the county courthouse, and even led The Bellingham Herald to print an article under the heading “Where’s Callahan.” The Sheriff spent most of the day into the night searching for Kielt, and ransacking his cabin near Glacier to no avail. It was surmised that after his encountered with the deputies earlier that day, Kielt fled back across the border into Canada. Kielt was never heard from again.</p><p>The Sheriff’s Department would not be as fortunate in its next dust up with suspected rumrunners later that summer. In late July, while patrolling the border near Blaine, two sheriff’s deputies, James Chatfield and Holman Drain, the latter being one of the officers held at gunpoint by Kielt, encountered a suspicious man walking near a known smuggling trail. The deputies exited their patrol car and followed the men into the woods from a distance. Once in the woods Deputy Chatfield ordered the man to stop and fired two warning shots into the air. The man later identified as twenty-two-year-old Alfred “Red” Anderson did not realize the men were law enforcement officers and fired back shooting Chatfield in the lower abdomen. A gun battle ensued, with Chatfield emptying his revolver while on the ground, and Anderson eventually charging the officers. Once within close proximity Drain identified himself, and a horrified Anderson surrendered and aided Drain in carrying Chatfield back to the patrol car. It would later be discovered that Anderson was not smuggling alcohol but was camping with two friends in the area and thought the officers to be criminals themselves. The whole tragic incident had been a misunderstanding.</p><p>Coincidently Sheriff Callahan had also been in Blaine that day and met Chatfield, Drain, and Anderson at the doctor’s office after the incident. Callahan immediately sent Drain back to the scene to collect Anderson’s belongings and instructed him to arrest the other two campers Frank Tool and Elza Cowell. After Dr. Clinton McKinnis examined Chatfield and realized the extent of his injuries, he had an ambulance rush him to St. Joseph’s Hospital in Bellingham for surgery to remove the bullet and stop internal bleeding. At 8:12 on the evening of July 28, 1921, Sheriff&#39;s Deputy James Chatfield died after doctors were unable to stop the bleeding.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*wy9SzbTm9YR4PVk7OjlCew.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sheriff’s Deputy James Chatfield</figcaption></figure><p>The case and subsequent trial of Alfred Anderson dragged on for over a year and occupied a large portion of Callahan’s time remaining in his first term. To make this time all the more painful for Callahan, eleven days after Chatfield’s death, his nineteen-year-old daughter Mabel and her infant son died of an unknown illness. There is no record as to how these events impacted Callahan, but it is not a stretch to speculate that he was left broken after experiencing these losses so close together. On September 2, 1922, over a year after the incident, the case against Alfred Anderson ended in a mistrial when a juror and county probation officer were seen talking, breaking the judge’s order that jurors are not to speak to people other than the bailiff. The case was never retried, and Anderson moved to Grays Harbor County. This case ended just in time for Callahan to launch his next battle, re-election.</p><p>Alexander Callahan participated heavily in the trial of Alfred Anderson, testifying and attending throughout the duration. The trial took place in the fall of 1922, during his bid for re-election. If he had expected his opponents to give him a break during this period, he would have been wrong. The election of 1922 looked to be an even tougher battle for Callahan than his initial election two years earlier. This stemmed from no other issue than prohibition, and a situation that had unfolded near Lynden earlier that year.</p><p>In and around Lynden north to the Canadian border, clubs known as “beer resorts” began to illegally operate. These clubs were near the border, where alcohol could easily be brought to service customers coming from Bellingham and other parts of the county. The residents of Lynden and the surrounding area complained to Callahan about these establishments and wanted them shut down. In total, there were twenty-six beer resorts near Lynden, much more than Callahan and the Sheriff’s Department could handle. Callahan requested the assistance of Provincial Police in British Columbia, and the Lynden Town Marshall, J. Le Compte, to help raid and shut down the beer resorts. The Canadians provided invaluable support in the task, while the Lynden Marshall chose not to co-operate with the request. Even without Lynden, all twenty-six beer resorts were shut down and the proprietors arrested, but the whole situation left a bad taste in the mouths of Callahan and Lynden residents. Many accused Callahan of not tackling the beer resort issue right away, and in many cases implied that he was somehow turning a blind eye to rum running. Aided by the Lynden marshall, Callahan’s opponents ran with this.</p><p>The term for county-wide offices in Whatcom County when Callahan was first elected in 1920 was two-years, however between 1920 and 1922 these terms were extended to four years, meaning whoever won in 1922 would get a longer term in office. It was all but a sure thing that Callahan would run for re-election, but who his opponent would be, and from what party, was the real question. After much speculation, former Deputy Sheriff Chris Patterson entered the race as a Republican in July of 1922. As was the case in 1920, the Republican primary election would be the real test of Callahan’s popularity. Throughout the campaign Patterson made the beer resort debacle the number one issue and forced Callahan to repeatedly answer to the situation that had unfolded months prior. <em>The Lynden Tribune</em>, and Lynden Town Marshall J. Le Compte, aided Patterson by spreading negative information about Callahan and implying he was not enforcing prohibition as forcefully as he could. That September, the voters in the Republican primary once again affirmed their belief in Callahan, giving him 56% of the vote. While he won the county, he only received 12% of the vote in the City of Lynden, showing just how effective Le Compte had been in campaigning for Patterson. Another difference this time around was that Callahan now faced a Democrat opponent in the November election, and the beer resort issue was not finished.</p><p>James Laytham of Blaine was the Democrat nominee for Sheriff. Laytham had served in various law enforcement capacities at the state level, but never in Whatcom County. He ran on a platform of being the “dry” candidate both professionally and personally, a dig at Callahan. Callahan shot back, running a fierce campaign defending his record, and advertising support from the County Prosecutor, and various newspapers throughout the area. In the lead up to the November election Callahan even purchased a full-page ad in <em>The Bellingham Herald </em>to tell his side of the story. The voters once again made their confidence in Callahan known at the ballot box, giving the incumbent Sheriff 55% of the vote. His margins in Lynden improved a bit, receiving 22% of the vote, but was the only Republican that year to lose the city. Regardless, Callahan had been re-elected, and the voters of Whatcom County had once again reiterated their support for the man charged with protecting them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mBFIIxBg4ApY4-VnHULd0g.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The Second Term (Well, most of it, at least):</h3><p>As Prohibition became a settled reality, and organized crime surrounding it became more sophisticated, the City of Bellingham turned into a hub for criminal activity. With the city so close to a major port, new people were coming and going daily, many of whom did not arrive to contribute to the city’s betterment. Citizens took note of this and aired this displeasure to city and county officials. The Bellingham Police Department assured its residents that together with the Sheriff’s Office, the crime wave would be dealt with, remarking, “Liquor laws and traffic laws perhaps are the two items that will receive strict attention day and night.” This would be an excellent summary of Callahan’s second term in office and prove to be a roadmap for his policing.</p><p>The fight against rum running was only getting harder and more costly for the Sheriff’s office as Callahan was sworn into his second term. It now wasn’t just alcohol Callahan had to worry about either: on many occasions officers were discovering illegal drugs being smuggled into the United States from Canada. Callahan’s largest “dope” bust came in 1925, when Sheriff’s deputies seized $175,000 worth of illegal drugs entering the county, over $2.7 million dollars today. These crimes didn’t just include land, illegal substances were now coming into Whatcom County on ships. This crime on the high seas turned into a modern form of piracy, with rumrunners patrolling the waters of Washington and British Columbia armed and ready to seize the ship’s contents. The largest of these instances came in late summer 1924, when the cargo ship <em>Beryl G</em> destined for Victoria was discovered in a state of “confusion” by the Turn Point light housekeeper Chris Waters. The anchor had been dragging with the bodies Captain William Gillis, and his son William Jr. attached and floating in the water. Once aboard, it was discovered that the ship’s alcohol supply, along with all weapons had been raided by criminals looking for alcohol to smuggle into the U.S. From the start Callahan took an interest in this case, and together with B.C. Inspector Forbes Cruickshank, the perpetrators were arrested and convicted. <em>An excellent article on the Beryl G incident by historian Philip Jensen can be found </em><a href="https://www.canadashistory.ca/explore/politics-law/inspector-cruickshank-the-case-of-the-beryl-g"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*qBZZYZVwgdMqzmqj.jpg" /><figcaption>A painting of B.C. Inspector Forbes Cruickshank with the Beryl G in the background</figcaption></figure><p>Back on the mainland the smuggling and production of homemade alcohol was becoming a much more localized business. People in Bellingham and throughout Whatcom County were making their own alcohol, and distributing it to friends, neighbors, and even customers. The issue had gone from one of criminals coming across the border, to everyday citizens throughout the county. To the surprise of Sheriff Callahan, a great number of women were even getting into the alcohol business. So much so that, in his second term, deputies floated the idea of hiring a “jail matron” to watch after the female prisoners. Women weren’t the only problem at the jail, which was affectionately referred to as “Hotel Callahan.” The number of overall prisoners continued to increase as the department continued to arrest those breaking prohibition laws. The number of guests at Hotel Callahan had gotten so high in 1925 that the Sheriff was once again forced to request additional blankets and pillows from the County Commission, a request that had been denied during his first term.</p><p>With increased alcohol-related arrests, this meant an increased amount of seized product. Callahan, along with members of the County Clerk’s office, continued the practice of destroying the contraband after the cases had been settled, usually in batches about every six months. At one point during his second term, Callahan poured $8,700 worth of illegal alcohol down the drain of his office at the county courthouse, which is just shy of $150,000 today. Liquor was a problem for county leaders, and it seemed to be popping up around every issue. In 1923, not long after taking the oath for the second time, the County Commission was tasked with handling the Alki Bungalow Dance Hall near Ten Mile. The Alki, as it was referred to, was a rowdy club on the Guide-Meridian that had been a headache for neighbors. The Ten Mile Township Board of Supervisors ordered that the Alki close at midnight on Saturdays, an order that was not followed. In an effort to bring relief, they passed the issue on to the County Commission in November of that year. Here, Sheriff Callahan made his feelings clear, stating, “It costs the county about $20 more than the license brought into the County Treasurer to look after the place Saturday nights. Arrests are being made there for drunkenness nearly every Saturday night.” As was the case many times throughout his tenure in office, the County Commissioners did not agree with Callahan, and voted to allow the Alki to continue operation. Coincidently (or not) the Sheriff&#39;s office put an emphasis on dance halls throughout the county later that month, arresting seven individuals in one Saturday night. Callahan was going to get his way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v-pVyqJp3wUBTRao4T4vuQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Advertisement for the Alki Bungalow Dance Hall</figcaption></figure><p>Another item that had at one time been exclusive but was now becoming mainstream was automobiles. The number of cars on the road in Whatcom County had skyrocketed in the mid-1920’s, and as was the case for Callahan while a member of the Bellingham Police Department, the laws could not keep up. Now mix in the illegal alcohol that was readily available on the streets, and car crashes, thefts, and injuries were becoming all too common. This was an issue that aggravated Callahan, and combining his two biggest issues, alcohol and automobiles made his job that much harder. In March of 1923, with the complete support of Callahan, Whatcom County Superior Court Judge W.H. Heaton announced new consequences for drunk driving. These included ninety days in jail, and a $100 fine. When asked how he felt about the stricter law he stated, “This ought to help a lot.”</p><p>While this helped with drunk driving, Callahan still believed that more needed to be done to tighten up traffic laws, especially in the city of Bellingham. He was worried about cars parking and driving wherever they wanted, and many cars did not have proper lighting when driving at night. For Callahan, relief was not coming from the County Commission and Bellingham City Council, so he took matters into his own hands. In November of 1923, Callahan released a statement explaining that “war would be waged by his office against all violators of traffic laws.” From here Callahan issued new directives to his officers for patrolling cars in Whatcom County. The first instructed deputies to write a citation for any car that did not have the proper year stick on the windshield. During this time, similar to having year tabs on the license plate today, drivers were expected to display a sticker on their windshield with the year their car was registered for. Many people did not follow this instruction, and until this point there had been no real enforcement to ensure drivers were staying up to date. Additionally, in 1925, Callahan issued a directive for deputies to be rigorous in checking that drivers had up to date driver’s licenses. During this time, licenses had to be renewed yearly, and much like the windshield sticker, with no enforcement drivers did not always obey this law. When asked about it by <em>The Bellingham Herald,</em> Callahan curtly told them, “This don’t mean maybe.” Finally, Callahan received permission from the County Commission to purchase a motorcycle that year to help with traffic enforcement and patrol for speeders. Callahan’s disdain for automobiles seemed to not equate a disdain for motorcycles, which he was more than happy to employ in his department.</p><p>Throughout his time in office Callahan remained extremely involved in the community and displayed a good-natured sense of humor. One of the stories told early on in his second term came from the 1923 Lynden Fair when two alleged Gypsies were telling people their fortunes on the Fairgrounds without permission. Callahan responded to the call, and when they explained what they were doing he responded, “I’ll bet I can tell your fortunes”, going on to say, “you’re both going to jail.” Of all the fortunes told at the fair that day, Callahan’s might have been the only one that proved true. In addition to his good nature on the job, he was active in the community, serving multiple times as Grand Marshall of the Tulip Parade, and chairing the Veterans Parade that took place in November to commemorate the end of the First World War. Callahan was popular, there was no doubt about that. To this point in his career, he had been able to all but deflect any political scandals that came his way, and as his second term as Whatcom County Sheriff was nearing its end, he was beginning to look at higher office. It was at about this time that a scandal finally did stick to Callahan, and this time it involved more than one member of the Callahan family.</p><h3>Enter Walter</h3><p>Walter Thomas Callahan was Sheriff Callahan’s second child. Born in 1899 in Nebraska, Walter made the trek west with his family when he was still an infant. Walter served his country in World War One and was the reason his father also decided to enlist to fight in France. Once back in the U.S., Walter followed in his father’s footsteps, becoming a Whatcom County Sheriff’s Deputy, and later a Washington State Trooper. While extremely loyal to his father, Walter had an unpredictable side to him both personally and professionally. It was these wild tendencies that would not only have implications on his career, but also that of his father.</p><p>On December 15, 1925, the United States Department of Justice arrived at the Whatcom County Courthouse. The group of detectives were on a fact-finding mission to corroborate a tip they had received that rum runner Robert Farley, imprisoned in the Whatcom County jail on federal charges had been seen driving his car through Seattle with and without the county jailer. That jailer was none other than Walter Callahan, son of the sheriff. The accusation was that certain prisoners were getting special privileges, mainly being afford additional liberties that were not normal to prisoners. These included time outside of jail while under arrest and allowing prisoners to use their personal vehicles while in custody.</p><p>Walter of course had an answer to the whole situation, and in a sworn affidavit to a federal judge wove a tale that in all likelihood made his father cringe at every detail. On the morning of November 25, Walter was ending his shift at the jail for the night and planned on driving to Seattle for the day. Upon leaving the jail, Walter claims he was “accosted” by Farley, who desired to accompany him to Seattle to collect money he was owed. Farley intended to collect enough money to pay the $350 fine that had been leveled against him by the Whatcom County Superior Court. Sheriff Callahan was out of town at the time, and Walter decided that this request was not unreasonable so long as Farley was in his surveillance the entire time. While by today’s standards this seems absurd, it was common practice for sheriff’s deputies to transport prisoners to locations where they could collect money to pay their fines. This policy though stated that it must be within a “reasonable” distance. Upon leaving the jail, Farley suggested that they take his car, as it was closer and “more comfortable” to which Walter agreed. This was not common practice. En route to Seattle, Farley requested that they stop at his family’s home in Bothell to retrieve clothes and other personal items, another request that Walter granted. Once in Seattle, Farley was able to collect $300 from various people who were indebted to him, and Walter returned him to the jail that evening. When questioned about this trip, Sheriff Callahan explained that he had not known about his son’s trip to Seattle with Farley until December 15, when federal agents arrived at the courthouse to question him on the matter. This, however, was not the only instance that brought the Justice Department to Bellingham.</p><p>James Hird, the owner of a pool hall in Anacortes, signed a sworn affidavit that George Brown, another federal prisoner in Callahan’s custody, had been seen walking the streets of Anacortes while he should have been locked in jail in the neighboring county. After investigating the claims and interviewing members of the Sheriff’s office, the federal government charged Sheriff Callahan with contempt of commitments of federal prisoners sentenced to the county jail. In early January 1926, Alexander Callahan, the prisoners in question, and other witnesses were taken before a federal judge in Seattle. In the lead up to his day in court, Sheriff Callahan had signed an affidavit saying that George Brown had not been in Anacortes, and that he had never left the county jail as James Hird had argued. However, the day before Callahan took the stand, Brown admitted to Callahan that he had in fact escaped the jail during his duties in the jail kitchen, and that he had also lied in his affidavit. While on the stand the next day, Callahan admitted to this revaluation, but argued he had not been made aware of either instance until December 15, when the Department of Justice arrived in Bellingham, and moreover he had not known that Brown was lying until just the day before. The prosecution seized on this; Deputy U.S. Attorney Curtis Abrams stated that:</p><p><em>“He [Callahan] had probably trusted his deputies too far, and that is regrettable. It is apparent that his deputies abused their responsibility as jailers, and in this case the matter is one pertaining to carelessness in management of the county jail. That is also regrettable.”</em></p><p>Deputy U.S. Attorney C.T. McKinney took this a step further saying that:</p><p><em>“Knowledge of what is going on in his office is the Sheriff’s duty. It is his duty to know that when federal prisoners are put in his jail, they are put there to be punished, not to be sent to someone&#39;s summer home for a vacation.”</em></p><p>After only hearing the testimony of Sheriff Callahan, and the arguments from the Department of Justice, Federal Judge Jeremiah Neterer, who was coincidently the former Bellingham City Attorney, found Callahan guilty of contempt of commitments of federal prisoners sentenced to the county jail. This came with a $10 fine, and a pledge by Callahan to “shake-up” the department. Within a week it was announced that Walter had resigned his post as a Sheriff Deputy and accepted a position with the Ocean Falls B.C. Police Department. Whether this resignation came willingly or was requested by his father is a question lost to history. This arrangement did not last long, however, as later that winter Walter returned to western Washington, accepting a position with the State Patrol based out of Mount Vernon. While this whole fiasco, titled the “Callahan Affair” in the press, was a black eye on the Sheriff’s record of service, it would become clear in the following months that he intended to move forward with his political career as though nothing had happened. The question now became, did the voters still trust him?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4OpMAkPy4mfwWvHPq30QCw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sheriff Alexander Callahan 1925</figcaption></figure><h3>Commissioner Callahan?</h3><p>In an unexpected turn of events, that winter Sheriff Callahan announced he would not seek re-election for a third term in the November election. Whether or not this came as a surprise to the county is unknown, however within days seven candidates threw their name in the hat to succeed him. Then, in March, incumbent Whatcom County Commissioner James Miller announced he would also not run for re-election. With this announcement many names began to swirl around the county as to possible candidates for the open seat. When asked by <em>The Bellingham Herald</em> if he intended to run later that month, Callahan responded, “I might,” a very typical Callahan response. For months following Miller’s announcement, <em>The Herald</em> referred to Callahan as a “probable” candidate for Commissioner, and all but filed for the position for him.</p><p>He made the media, and the county, wait for months while other candidates began campaigning for Commissioner and for his current job. To some this shows a bit of political arrogance, to others it shows a level of comfort with the voters of Whatcom County. Whatever the case might have been for Callahan, he waited until July 1926 to formally announce his intention to run for the Republican nomination for Whatcom County Commissioner from District 1 in the September primary. The race to replace Miller now consisted of five Republicans and one Democrat. This would seem to be a hot race that would receive immense attention, and in most circumstances, it would be, however, that year the race to replace Callahan as Sheriff proved to be the exciting contest for voters to watch. This race included thirteen candidates, a large portion of whom had either worked for Callahan or had been involved in the Sheriff’s Department over the years. The press watched this race closely and reported on many of the developments throughout the summer and fall. This didn’t leave much time to report on the race for County Commissioner, and aside from the loyal support of veterans organizations, Callahan did very little campaigning. In fact, while cleaning out his office that summer, he found an old campaign card from his 1922 re-election campaign. As a joke he put the card up in the Sheriff’s Office garage, and a rumor began to spread that he had changed his mind and decided to run for re-election after all.</p><p>In September 1926, after enjoying nearly a decade of professional and political success, Alexander Callahan was defeated. In the Republican primary election for Whatcom County Commissioner, Callahan came in third place, receiving only 19% of the vote. County Engineer Fred McElmon won the Republican nomination with 40% and would go on to defeat former county Sheriff L.A. Thomas in the general election that November. It can be speculated what contributed to Callahan’s defeat, whether that be lack of campaigning, a scandal that had unfolded earlier that year, or another popular countywide official running on the same ticket. Whatever the case maybe, Callahan now saw the end of his public service career was in sight. Over the next few months Callahan continued working diligently as Sheriff, preparing a budget for the following year for a department that he would no longer lead. In honor of his service, the Bellingham Veterans club made him the marshall of the 1926 Armistice Day Parade. Near the end of 1926, it became clear that incoming Sheriff Thomas Fraser intended to “clean house” of some of Callahan’s deputies once he took office. On January 10, 1927, Alexander Callahan handed over the keys to his office, and Thomas Fraser was officially sworn in as Whatcom County Sheriff. With this, all but one sheriff’s deputy resigned their posts, opting to quit instead of staying to get fired by their new boss. The Callahan era had ended. The question on everyone’s mind now was whether that would last.</p><h3>A comeback and the irony of death</h3><p>After leaving office Callahan spent some time in Olympia working with the legislature on police issues, and for a brief period was considered a candidate for warden of the Walla Walla State Penitentiary. Back home in Bellingham he did side work as a contractor, harkening back to his early days when he built grand structures like the Fairhaven Carnegie Library. As the decade changed and time continued its march, reports of “Callahan” in local media referred more often than not about Walter, who was still with the State Patrol, as opposed to his father. Alexander Callahan now preferred quiet work with veterans&#39; organizations and remained active in other Bellingham civic clubs. It was politics, though, that was still in Callahan’s blood.</p><p>In summer 1934, eight years after winning his election, Sheriff Thomas Fraser announced he would not seek re-election. The open seat again fielded thirteen candidates, eight Democrats, and five Republicans. The first person to file was former sheriff Alexander Callahan. At age 64, Callahan was attempting to make a political comeback, and this time he was not taking anything for granted. Callahan spent a considerable amount of money campaigning that year and ran a series of advertisements detailing his law enforcement background and sharing his vision for the Sheriff’s Office. The voters however did not want to go backward, and in the Republican primary that year, Callahan received only 16% of the vote, coming in fourth in a field of five. His time in politics was over. He would never run for office again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*IJDA8XhnOvPeaI94hdcNeA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A 1934 advertisement for Callahan</figcaption></figure><p>The world did not hear from Alexander Callahan after this loss. He returned to a very private life and was mentioned very seldom in local press. He remained active in civic organizations, and even took up a job as a Special Deputy for the Alaska Department of Public Welfare. This period of private life would prove to be painfully short, as on Christmas Eve 1935, Alexander Callahan was struck and killed by a car on Dupont Street. He died the next morning, Christmas Day 1935. The untimely death had a stinging element of irony, as Callahan had devoted a large portion of his law enforcement career to the enforcement of automobiles within the City of Bellingham.</p><p>On December 27, 1935, on that hill at Bayview Cemetery overlooking the much smaller Douglas fir trees, Bellingham gathered to say goodbye to a friend. Over 200 attended the funeral, which spilled out from the Harlow-Hollingsworth house and onto the street. At the graveside service the Bellingham Police Department and Fire Department presented the colors, and the local American Legion Post gave Callahan full military honors. Former colleagues from the police department and Sheriff’s department were pallbearers, and law enforcement officers from around the state attended the service to pay their respects. It was reported that the casket was not even visible with the number of flowers that were stacked on top and around it. If Alexander Callahan or his family ever doubted the respect that the people of Whatcom County and the state had for him after his political losses, that was now dispelled. Politics can be blood sport, and throughout his life Alexander Callahan celebrated the victories and the defeats of that sport. But as the community gathered to say goodbye to the man whose sworn job it was to protect them for decades, it was not the political losses or the scandals that were top of mind for those in attendance, but the devoted service and dedication of a man whose life had been cut short.</p><h3>Back to the question</h3><p>Months of research, multiple trips to the archives, and two articles later, a new light (or at the very least <strong><em>a</em></strong><em> </em>light) has been shed on the life of Alexander Callahan. His story has been told, and an overgrown grave is now once again visible to the public. However, the question that kicked off this quest and opened this historian&#39;s eyes to the life of Alexander Callahan remains unanswered. In every document, news article, and book that mentions Callahan, there is never a reference to him as the “demon” Sheriff as the eBay photo did. There are not even clues as to how a nickname like this could have come to be. While this may seem like the search has turned up empty, that couldn’t be further from the truth. The life of a man who had been all but forgotten has now been told, and the public, and potentially descendants of Callahan&#39;s, can now maybe for the first time understand the contributions that this colorful and enigmatic man made to a part of our region at a time when criminals ran rampant, and policing was rugged and extremely dangerous. Sometimes in history we don&#39;t’ find the answers we are looking for. It’s aggravating, but it&#39;s one of the constants in an ever-changing field. That said, it&#39;s the questions that we ask that can lead us to unintended discoveries, and exploration we never expected. Asking questions doesn’t always lead us where we think we are going, but if we are open to seeing where they take us, the answers might lead us somewhere much greater.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a11448508b2c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>