<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Phill Alexander on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Phill Alexander on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@phillalexander_6256?source=rss-71ba53928744------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 22:20:30 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@phillalexander_6256/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Toxicity in Gaming Spaces: On White Male Privilege in Games]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phillalexander_6256/toxicity-in-gaming-spaces-on-white-male-privilege-in-games-3837da3445?source=rss-71ba53928744------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3837da3445</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Phill Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Feb 2018 03:43:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-17T03:43:40.137Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Yesterday, I linked <a href="https://medium.com/@morganjaffit/the-cost-of-doing-business-c09cc5cc8728">this Medium post</a> to the Discord chat for the games program I work for. Jaffit’s post is smart, and it’s in places alarming. It’s something we need to think hard about. I thought a few students might comment. I woke up to 300+ notifications and over an hour of reading. It was an interesting discussion.</p><p>I teach game studies, writing for games, game design, streaming media, and related classes. I am the co-director of the Varsity Esports program at Miami. I say this only to establish the many fronts on which I interface with games: I am a gamer, a games professor, an Esports administrator, a content creator, an advocate, a developer of curriculum, a researcher, an advisor. I wear a number of hats: at work, at conventions, at conferences, in cyberspace. I have a connection to almost every aspect of games as an industry and an academic discipline.</p><p>My reaction to the Jaffit piece, and my reaction to Gamergate, and the discussion that I have with my Esports players when we talk about public behavior, are all strikingly similar: we have to <em>be</em> the change.</p><p>I want to take a brief detour here to talk about my history as a person outside of being a life-long game nerd and academic. I am Cherokee. My family, however, fled relocation and hid among Mexican immigrants in the small Indiana town that I’m from. We — which is to say I — pass for white. I went to an all-white high school in the suburbs. I grew up poor, but no one realized I wasn’t wealthy because I was in gifted and talented classes with the rich kids from my community. To this day if I don’t tell people, it is assumed I’m white. I even have people come to my speaking engagements and say “why are <em>you</em> talking about Indians, dude?” I’ve even had other academics yell repeatedly at me “you’re not Cherokee,” which is something I doubt happens to many other people.</p><p>My ancestors are treated like a museum exhibit by most, and in reality so many of us are gone that we live and exist within the margin of error. On the last US Census, which had a published margin of error of +/-3%, slightly less than 2% identified themselves as Native American or Indigenous. And I can’t trace myself back through any sort of documentation because my family <em>understood the game</em> that was fleeing relocation; you don’t leave a trail if someone is coming to get you. So in many ways, large portions of who I am have been erased, or at the very least are obscured from vision.</p><p>I point that out because the next thing I’m going to say requires that most of the people who will read this piece accept a gentle slap to the face. I’m about to make two declarations that might seem rash to some of you, but I ask only that you hear me out and read the rest of what I have to say after them.</p><ol><li>Heteronormative White America can never <em>actually</em> understand the experience of people who are not white, not male, and not straight.</li><li>It will make a white male uncomfortable to engage with issues related to discrimination and hate, but YOU NEED TO FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE.</li></ol><p>Now, then, let me explain myself. The first statement I made above isn’t at all a new idea. People have been saying this as long as people who weren’t from the dominant social group could write and share ideas. Being the dominant group —and in games, that means straight, white, and male — means that the reality is <em>crafted for you</em>. There’s no reason for you to be able to understand precisely why an Indian mascot does emotional and cultural damage to me. I wish I could just tear down Larry Bird or someone like that and illustrate to you how it feels to see my culture mocked. But it doesn’t work that way. Even if I could somehow find a parallel, you can <em>never</em> experience what people like me (and people who have it much worse, people who can’t pass, people who aren’t as safe as a 6&#39;2, 350 pound man) experience. It’s not real for you, because it doesn’t happen to white guys.</p><p>I’ll be fair. I can’t experience your white maleness either, even as someone who does pass and is confused for a white male. I live in the reality built for you, so I think I am relatively speaking closer to understanding you than you are to understanding my tribal background, but I can’t know whiteness the way that someone born white does. I am not claiming special status there. I don’t grasp the white man’s burdens.</p><p>Where the difference hits is that white people — in spite of the occasional claim of reverse discrimination — have it pretty good, culturally speaking. You won. If you were born into it, congratulations — you won the war without firing a shot.</p><p>But the world is changing. Slowly, but it’s changing. And that means that not everyone in positions of power is white and male. The world of games is changing more slowly, but it’s also growing exponentially. Women play. People of color play. LGBTQ people play. Not nearly enough people from those and other diverse groups work in games and make games, but the audience is changing.</p><p>When the whiteness rises up to try to silence, thrust out, or belittle anyone who isn’t a straight white guy, <em>we all lose</em>. Communities are made worse. Products lose purchases. Games become less fun.</p><p>I want to pause for a second to say something as clearly as I possibly can: I don’t think of the straight white guy who looks like Seth Green and makes indie games as the straw man for this argument. I know TONS of awesome straight white guys. Some of my very best friends are straight white guys, and I love and respect them. I am not proclaiming that being straight, white or male automatically makes anyone any certain way.</p><p>It’s a tiny percentage of people from that group who are toxic and entitled, and that combination is the inhibitor of sincere, valuable change. The people who threaten Zoe Quinn’s life, who flame a Blizzard employee because they got too many spray drops from their OW loot boxes, the people who say “retarded” or “gay” as an insult — while in the minority — do a massive amount of damage.</p><p>Now is the part where I get a little judgmental. Keep bearing with me, please.</p><p>What makes this worse is that all those good people I know who are white and male and straight… they’re often quiet when that tiny part of the white population is loud and hateful. Some of them aren’t. Some of them rise up. I love them the most. But many are silent, to keep from creating arguments.</p><p>And you can’t be. You just <em>can’t</em>. It makes you part of the problem.</p><p>I’ve heard numerous people say they don’t think one person can change how other gamers act. And no, one single person can’t fix all of it. But if you’re in a Twitch chat and one person says something horribly sexist, you can raise objection. And if you and the people who agree with you outnumber the loud person by the volume that you statistically should (say 99-to-1), you can harness your abilities to silence the person who would silence diversity. Tell him it’s unacceptable. Rally to the cause of others.</p><p>There’s an old proverb. It’s by a white dude. It’s about a nail. You can read the history of it here on <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_Want_of_a_Nail">Wikipedia</a>.</p><p>It goes:<br>For want of a nail the shoe was lost.<br> For want of a shoe the horse was lost.<br> For want of a horse the rider was lost.<br> For want of a rider the battle was lost.<br> For want of a battle the kingdom was lost.<br> And all for the want of a nail.</p><p>We have to be the nails. We don’t have any other option. Because if we keep being the community who says “oh, yeah, that’s awful. But <em>I </em>didn’t do it. I didn’t do <em>anything</em>,” we lose.</p><p>What I’m saying is that I live a life where I realize, quite often, that it’s my duty as a citizen of this world to make people uncomfortable. Once, a few years ago, I stopped at a rest area on a trip. I needed to get a drink of water and stretch my legs. By chance, I was at a historical marker for the Trail of Tears. The Trail of Tears, if you don’t know, is the path they led my ancestors — the ones who didn’t flee relocation — along, leaving their homeland in the Carolinas and eventually stopping in Oklahoma. It’s called the trail of tears because of all the crying and death.</p><p>A young white father — couldn’t be even as old as me, I don’t guess — was standing with his son. The kid might have been five-or-so. His father told him what a historical thing it was to be near the Trail of Tears, how it was a great moment for our country. I was in ear shot, and I did something I never do, trembling the entire time. I butted in. I told the man, as his son listened, that most of my ancestors died on that walk, as we were driven from our homes by people who we tried to help when they landed on our shores. “It should say trail of murder,” I ended. I didn’t say “and rape” because of the child, but I wanted to say “and rape.” There were a number of them.</p><p>That moment made ME uncomfortable. And I am certain it made him uncomfortable as well. I am certain that some people reading this will think it was uncalled for and unprofessional behavior on my part and cite it as a reason I don’t get invited to parties. And that’s fair. Part of me hates that I did it, or at least hates that I live in a world where I had to feel like doing it was a big deal. But my hope is that the son, having seen someone who was Cherokee and heard me talk a bit about my ancestors, will grow up not thinking that all the Cherokee took a happy walk with the white men to Oklahoma and then had a picnic.</p><p>We all have to do things like that. If you’re comfortable around hate and prejudice, <em>something is wrong with you </em>and you need help. If someone says “that’s retarded,” you need to point out the damage that word carries. If someone says they’re going to “rape” their video game opponent, you need to remind them what that word means, too. If you’re white, and you see another white guy say or do something racist, you need to check him.</p><p>It <em>will</em> make you uncomfortable.</p><p>And as you feel that discomfort, you will come as close as you ever can to understanding what it feels like to be the person taking the abuse.</p><p>And if enough of us are uncomfortable, things <em>will </em>change for the better.</p><p>That’s how we win. We don’t let it go. We can never, ever let it go.</p><p>If you let it go, you’re the enemy, and you’re functionally as bad as the person you’re letting get away with hate.</p><p>We can be comfortable, or we can be good people.</p><p>In the current moment, we can’t be both.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3837da3445" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Either we want change or we don’t: more on CCCC 2018 and the state of Missouri]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phillalexander_6256/either-we-want-change-or-we-dont-more-on-cccc-2018-and-the-state-of-missouri-9f7e6bd31a87?source=rss-71ba53928744------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f7e6bd31a87</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[kansas-city]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[st-louis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cccc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ncte]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Phill Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Aug 2017 23:08:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-15T23:46:21.827Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If you read <a href="https://medium.com/@phillalexander_6256/an-open-letter-to-the-cccc-executive-committee-re-cccc-2017-in-kansas-city-386c1fa6ce39">my previous post</a>, you know I’ve taken a fairly emphatic stance on the 2018 CCCC’s host city, Kansas City, and the problems that arise from hosting an academic conference and claiming to value doing social justice work. It’s counterintuitive to have the conference in a state where members of the academic community aren’t safe. It’s wrong.</p><p>I used the word hypocrite in my last post. In response to a friend who sent my letter on to the NCTE in reference to their other conference (which is also happening in Missouri, in St. Louis), the idea was introduced that it would be hypocritical to NOT have the conference, that it would be “running away.”</p><p>I want to explain why that’s wrong, because it’s time for us to stop playing games and be honest with each other. I have not called for people to flee Missouri in fear. All you have to do is read my words and you can see that. What I have called for is for us to not put money into an economy in a state that is unsafe for my colleagues, that is unsafe for me. I’m not scared of Kansas City. I’m not scared of Ferguson. I grew up in an all-white community, went to an all-white high school. I was shot at and beaten up. My car and locker and house were vandalized. I’m not scared.</p><p>I was more scared, up until just a while back, of the NCTE and CCCC. You see these institutions are quite talented with their rhetoric. And they’re trying to do the thing that Socrates told us, centuries ago, was the problem with rhetoric. They’re twisting their message.</p><p>The claim from the executive committee, <a href="http://www.ncte.org/cccc/conv/futureconventions/sitingprinciples">circa 2013</a>, was: <br><em>In principle, CCCC will work to change state or local policies in host convention cities that diverge from established CCCC positions or otherwise threaten the safety or well-being of our membership. We will do so by consulting closely with local groups who share our principles and arranging activities and opportunities for members to support those who are disadvantaged by offensive policies or otherwise to use their presence in the offending state as a vehicle for nonviolent protest. We will vigorously communicate the methods of support and/or protest to the media, convention and tourist bureaus, and local and state government officials, with the avowed purpose of provoking policy change or supporting current policies threatened by hostile change. In general, we will follow this strategy of engagement rather than abrogating or cancelling contracts for future conventions as a method of protesting existing or future legislation. (check link for citation)</em></p><p>This is where we all have to remember our rhetorical analysis training. What does that statement actually <em>say</em>? It starts with “in principle” which is a disclaimer, a hedge before the statement even begins. Then the solution offered is to work with local groups to try to arrange activities. Then to show “vigorous” verbal support. This is what we will do “instead of cancelling contracts.”</p><p>And sure, that’s a great idea if you’re going to a place where there’s something to protest. I can see that, though to be fair that’s not what happened in Houston when there was a major LGBT legal issue. The response to that was markedly “tepid” if I may choose a phrase to contrast to “vigorous.”</p><p>But what about when there’s NOT a way to specifically protest? What if the best method of protest is to not give money to the economy of the region? Money is what is valued in these situations in the first place, as the reason CCCC doesn’t want to cancel an event is loss of money. So CCCC understand the value of the money spent on the conference.</p><p>I’ve called for CCCC to cancel. I am sure, given how NCTE has reacted to the NCTE conference, my call for cancellation will be ignored, or worse, will be recast with this language of “we can’t run away,” which is an easy thing for a white person to say about a conference in Kansas City or St. Louis. The people who weren’t warned against going have nothing to fear, and they can pretend all they want that the presence of white academics in a city is a better protest than denying that city a huge weekend of business. It’s fiction; having the conference doesn’t bring about any sort of change, and the conference will not labor to bring about change because it really never has (members might, but CCCC isn’t going to stand up to the state of Missouri).</p><p>So I have a proposal to people who care, who want to see something done. Respond to this post with a vow to not attend NCTE or CCCC this year and instead to give the money you would spend on the conference to a charity. I can recommend a few. <a href="http://www.aateachingfellows.org/">AATF</a> seems appealing given current events. The <a href="https://www.uncf.org/">United Negro College Fund</a> is a great one. The <a href="http://www.naacp.org/">NAACP</a> is another. There’s a great charity called <a href="https://app.mobilecause.com/vf/SAMIFORSYRIA">Sami For Syria</a> that is providing medical care to refugees in Syria, and another called<a href="https://www.apopo.org/en/"> APOPO</a> that trains mine sniffing and tuberculosis rats. Locally, I often give to a battered women’s shelter called Genesis; if you have one of those locally, they can always use help. These are things that matter.</p><p>I am sorry to say this as an academic, because I do enjoy seeing my old friends, my current peers, the leaders of the field, etc. But attending CCCC is a sunken cost. The organization has become so large that it’s not concerned with doing what is right over what is financially expedient. We can share our ideas on the internet now; we can stream talks to each other. There is no need for us to spend hundreds on hotel rooms, hundreds on food, sometimes thousands on airfare. The era where we need to be in the same room for these sorts of things has ended.</p><p>And while it’s nice to see each other, if we gather and inflate the economy of a place where a number of us aren’t even safe, we’re doing bad work. That’s not — in principle — the right thing to do.</p><p>Join me in withdrawing from these conferences. We can find another way to talk about our ideas. But since we live in the era where money is the universal signifier for value, speak with your money.</p><p>If we do this together, maybe we can make a difference. Maybe we can “provoke change.” The old methods don’t work anymore. It’s time for us to start trying something new.</p><p>-Phill Alexander</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f7e6bd31a87" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An open letter to the CCCC Executive Committee, RE: CCCC 2018 in Kansas City]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phillalexander_6256/an-open-letter-to-the-cccc-executive-committee-re-cccc-2017-in-kansas-city-386c1fa6ce39?source=rss-71ba53928744------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/386c1fa6ce39</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Phill Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Aug 2017 18:10:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-13T18:26:24.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dear CCCC Executive Committee,</p><p>I write today to request that you strongly consider cancelling the 2018 event in Kansas City, Missouri. At the very least, you must move the event. If the venue of the event isn’t changed, I formally withdraw my proposal from consideration as I will not attend the event. I also will not renew my membership to your organization or spend money on anything NCTE or CCCC related, including cancelling my subscriptions to your print journals.</p><p>The reasoning behind my request should be clear from the <a href="https://www.naacp.org/latest/travel-advisory-state-missouri/">NAACP</a> statement on travel to Missouri, and though the advisory will have expired before the date of the conference, other events unfolding nationally indicate that we are at a moment where certain regions of this country are not safe for anyone who isn’t white. For example, take Saturday’s horrific attack in <a href="http://www.cnn.com/2017/08/12/us/charlottesville-car-crash-suspect-idd/index.html">Charlottesville, VA</a>, a tragedy perpetrated by a White Nationalist from the state where I teach, but an event that only happened because our country is currently undergoing a strange hate renaissance which certain regions of the country are offering safe haven. Missouri is not safe. Virginia is not safe.</p><p>More importantly than safety, however, as an organization NCTE needs to start putting its money where its rhetoric sits. The most recent claims were that it would cost too much to move the conference. CCCC is a gathering of writing studies scholars; one of the values we promote most frequently as a field is inclusion and tolerance. As an organization, you are claiming that the value of treating our peers as equals is too costly, that it is more important to throw a gala that pours massive amounts of our money into a state where things are so bad that people from outside have to be warned not to visit. This, frankly, is a lie. It might not be a willful lie. As an organization, you may believe that you cannot afford to move the conference. But this is a fiction you’ve created for yourselves.</p><p>What is the value of the organization’s <em>dignity</em>?</p><p>What is the value of the very <em>core</em> of what writing studies and communication hold as sacred?</p><p>What is the value of the health and safety (maybe even the <em>life</em>) of just one of the CCCC attendees, even if that person doesn’t happen to be white?</p><p>If what you meant to say is that you might have to break a few contracts, and you might lose a few deposits, and it might be hard, then yes, I absolutely believe that. I also, however, believe that for too long as a field of study the people who gather each year for CCCC have talked a very good game about diversity and inclusion and safety and social justice. I also, as someone who has pushed hard from within to make things better, have seen the vast majority of that field pick a place to stand and root their feet, and that place is far, far behind where any sort of line needs to be. To say you cannot suffer the cost of doing the right thing is <em>unacceptable</em>, particularly now in a world where education itself is under assault, where diverse people are threatened, where even the President of the United States wants to make this an issue where he sees an “ egregious display of hatred, bigotry and violence, on many sides.”</p><p>We currently live in a country where we have freedom and liberty. It’s a beautiful place. But we also live in a country where a 20-year-old hateful racist ran a car into a crowd and killed someone over a statue of a racist general from the losing side of a war, and our President thinks that the people getting hit by the car were just as wrong as a murderer wielding a massive motor vehicle. Things are far from right with the world.</p><p>If as an organization you choose to give money to the Missouri economy and to expect your members to come to an unsafe place so that they can take place in your event, you become a part of the problem, a part of the infrastructure that allows hatred to thrive. And in that moment, I sincerely believe that CCCC and NCTE become worthless to anyone who <em>actually cares</em> about what we do. I think the proper term for it is hypocritical. CCCC would become a hypocritical exercise.</p><p>I, personally, am tired of being in a field where everyone talks about bringing change but is too frightened of the consequences of actually <em>doing</em> things. The time for your “statements” and extensive “committee meetings” about things like this need to come to an abrupt end. You need to start doing what you claim you’ll do, or you need to be honest and admit that you’d like to talk about doing the right thing but will not do the hard work or take the risk of acting. It’s easy to say you want to do the right thing. It’s harder to put something at stake. But it’s also time to put something at stake.</p><p>I realize that scathing comments from me will not mean much. I’m a nobody to the machine that is the field of composition, communication, writing studies, etc. Even as a graduate student I felt out-of-place in the field, and I am currently working as an academic in a different-but-related discipline because English departments belittle video game scholars, aren’t interested in people who do critical race studies from a non-western point of view, and most of all don’t <em>appreciate</em> pre-tenure faculty who say the sorts of things I’m writing here. No one was going to bother to come to my presentation — if it was even accepted — because of my <em>name</em>. I don’t have that level of value to the field. They might have come because of my<em> topic</em>. And my topic of discussion was, basically, this. We need to try harder. We need to be better. We are not doing inclusion and respect for diversity correctly. And being nice about it, saying “hey, could you try harder, please, sir?” isn’t working. It’s time to start saying “you have to do better, or else.”</p><p>And I am as I say this, to the outside onlooker, one of the <em>lucky</em> ones. I don’t need to personally be afraid of going to Kansas City. If I put on a KC Chiefs hoodie, all irony aside for the Cherokee scholar, I could easily pass for a local. I grew up in Indiana. I watch sports. I’m working class. I teach video game design and writing. I scream “white” even though I’m far from it. I am not saying this out of fear for <em>myself</em>. If it weren’t for the soul crushing racism and quick-trigger police creating a maelstrom of hate, I could have a fun time in KC seeing old friends. I actually feel like writing this letter is more dangerous to me than walking the streets of Kansas City.</p><p>But I am the diversity you erase, the underrepresented member of a population that is in the census margin of error, the person you might not even realize is diverse. I’m not a special superstar, not a person you’ll invite for a keynote or put up posters to hype being present. I am just a person who works hard as a teacher, who trained hard in rhetoric and writing, who tries every single day to talk-the-talk and walk-the-walk.</p><p>I’m the sort of person who isn’t safe.</p><p>I’m the least of the people this conversation is about, and I am deeply concerned for my colleagues who, unlike me, can’t toss on a KC Chiefs hoodie and pass, because not that long ago an African-American in a hoodie did something I do all the time — walked to the gas station for a bottle of soda — and ended up dead. There are members of your organization, people in this field, who are always already marked and always already know they’re not the target audience. They know they’re on the margins. You can’t expect them to also accept that you want to meet in a place where people like them aren’t even safe to walk the streets.</p><p>So if I remove myself, you lose the <em>value</em> of a person like me. And one me leaving is not significant. Phill Alexander making an ultimatum to the executive committee of CCCC is a laugh, along the lines of a gnat threatening a lion. And if you know branding — which I also teach — the cynical among you will think this is a publicity stunt, as honestly what can I expect one angry letter to accomplish. I get that. But I also know that sparks start fires and snowballs grow as the slowly roll downhill.</p><p>There are so many others like me. Not exactly like me, but with aspects of my profile (non-white, pre-tenure, first generation student, working class poor, concerned with social issues but often feeling helpless). These are people who are early in their careers, who are afraid to speak up against CCCC because they need vita lines, they need to interview, they need the support of people who would be upset to see the boat tipped. They need to not be seen as insubordinate or as a “bad colleague” for criticizing the way things are.</p><p>More of your membership are people no one would come specifically to see than are your superstars that pack keynotes and wow audiences with featured panels. More of your members feel they have to be at your events than want to be at your events. And you’re perpetuating a machine that allows for — perhaps even encourages — fear with your current actions. You’re making it <em>worse</em>. You’ve put people in crisis by telling them that the conference they feel they <em>have</em> to be present for MUST happen in a place where they <em>will not be safe</em>, and you’ve told them that you think it would cost too much to actually give them peace of mind.</p><p>You need to do a better job.</p><p>I told the organization before the Houston meeting that I wouldn’t attend because I wouldn’t put my money in the hands of that community given how it was treating GLBT rights at the time, then I used network technology to support the people that I presented with. This could easily be done again, in fact CCCC could easily have an entirely online meeting this year — I’d gladly help organize that — and save people the travel budget. We could actually do something good with all the money, even after you pay whatever debts you’d incur for the cancelled KC meeting. Instead of scholars buying expensive meals in Kansas City and barely sleeping in overpriced rooms, we could do something that <em>mattered</em> with that cash.</p><p>I’ve also said I wouldn’t renew my NCTE dues. I get an email every week-or-so asking me to re-up. Imagine if you used that same infrastructure, those same emails, to offer support to issues that matter to your membership. What if you commented on the situation in Missouri, offered solutions for the KC meeting? I know you have to raise funds. I work for a program where we have to do that, too. I’m not foolishly saying money doesn’t matter at all. But you don’t have to be so blatant about how money drives your bottom line. You are, after all, part of a field of non-profits. And if you were trying to do something other than perpetuate the status quo, people like me would be pouring our money into your efforts. Right now I’d rather do what I did last year. I gave the money I would have given to CCCC to charity.</p><p>We are all trained in this field to look at the world with a critical eye and to understand how communication works. Right now, a critical eye can see that your organization isn’t taking a serious situation nearly as seriously as it needs to, and your communication is deeply lacking.</p><p>I know you don’t need to win <em>me</em> over. I’m not going to end this letter with some urge to prove the organization’s value to <em>me</em>. As I already said, I’m a nobody, just one of the people who comes to your meeting, one of the people who teaches classes full of students to be better people and better communicators. I’m not special.</p><p>But CCCC is only <em>special </em>because of a collection of people like me. And while my not attending, and my calling for you to cancel the event, is just one tiny voice, maybe someone else will see what I’ve said and join me. And if enough of the people who many don’t even see, the people who just show up and put in work, choose to skip the event, maybe you’ll see that a big academic conference without enough attendees is a bigger financial loss than the expense of moving the conference to a place where all those little people could feel safe and respected.</p><p>Because in the end, this is about money for you, isn’t it? That’s how it <em>looks</em>.</p><p>And for us, it’s about <em>life</em>. It’s about <em>respect</em>. It’s about being considered a part of what we do.</p><p>What we want is priceless.</p><p>And if you endanger and alienate us, your conference is worthless.</p><p>-Dr. Phill Alexander</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=386c1fa6ce39" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>