<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Phoebe on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Phoebe on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@phoebegmad?source=rss-cc59301616cb------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 18:20:22 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@phoebegmad/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Way of Putin’s Russia: Territorial Integrity or Conquest?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phoebegmad/the-way-of-putins-russia-territorial-integrity-or-conquest-dec394689099?source=rss-cc59301616cb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dec394689099</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[putin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ukraine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Phoebe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Sep 2022 05:30:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-22T03:03:27.173Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T8xywJHuEPBiXgcxUF1GBQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>‘Mr. President Vladimir Putin.’ Artwork by Daria Kolosova</strong> (Source: <a href="https://www.saatchiart.com/art/Painting-Mr-President-Vladimir-Putin/1488605/7394273/view">https://www.saatchiart.com/art/Painting-Mr-President-Vladimir-Putin/1488605/7394273/view</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Much of my geographical references are drawn from Tim Marshall’s </em><strong><em>Prisoners of Geography (2015).</em></strong></p><p><em>P. S. — I neither condone modern expansionism, nor do I subscribe to Marxist doctrines. (National sovereignty, self-determination, and developmental capitalism are to me, most preferable.)</em></p><p>In line with the cruder dictates of geopolitics, invasions occur almost inevitably as small powers find their national sovereignties stifled by larger ones. Hot wars naturally ensue, in which cities are ravaged, livelihoods are lost, and civilian lives are taken almost indiscriminately. Doubtless, to deem such casualties as mere ‘collateral damage’ is unsympathetic and likewise unmerited.</p><p>After all, international wars are but catalysts for more international wars. All the more in an interconnected world and the entangling alliances it breeds, of which tend to involve the rest of the world in the affairs of the few. As George Washington (in Allison 2015: 5) himself cautioned, such entanglements can escalate into a World War, if not stifle the global economy at the very least. Paired with the specter of nuclear power, the term ‘collateral damage’ becomes a mere understatement of the entailing catastrophes.</p><p>But for the time being, I suspend my emotional biases so that I can detail the Russia-Ukraine conflict from more <em>realpolitik</em> vantage points. After all, to acquire any informed understanding means being aware of the indifferent and amoral geopolitical struggles that influence national behavior.</p><h3>To Eat, or Be Eaten?</h3><blockquote>“The stronger a state is relative to its potential rivals, the less likely it is that any of those rivals will attack it and threaten its survival.”</blockquote><blockquote>— John Mearsheimer</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YZKoBEy_xgAfZnWg" /><figcaption>2/24/22 — President Vladimir Putin declares a military offensive in Donbas, Ukraine. (Source: The Telegraph)</figcaption></figure><p>Reminiscent of their 16th Century colonial approach, the Russian Federation employs an <strong>Attack-as-Defense Strategy. </strong>This signifies the formation of a territorial bulwark for blocking US-NATO expansion to Russia. By reclaiming post-Soviet territories through military incursions or by gaining control of their state resources, Russia can maximize its defense capacity versus expansionist threats.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*So8tvRi8JjAuNxjN" /><figcaption>A map of the<strong> Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR)</strong> including satellite states. A territorial colossus indeed. (Source: Google Image)</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>*Former USSR territories include:</strong> Ukraine (including the Crimean Peninsula), Belarus, Georgia, the Baltic States, Uzbekistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Turkmenistan, and Tajikistan.</blockquote><p>Should Russia succeed in reclaiming certain territories, then not only can it potentially restore its superpower status. If it aspired to, Russia may go so far as to challenge US-NATO influence in Eurasia, if not vie for regional leadership. The latter, however, remains a long-shot.</p><h3>Territorial Integrity</h3><p>Behind Russian attempts at territorial reclamation lies the notion of <strong>Territorial Integrity</strong>. Like all sovereign nations, Russia exercises its right to maintain and protect its territorial wholeness by any means necessary. <strong>After all, failure to uphold territorial integrity is tantamount to division and conquest by external powers.</strong></p><blockquote>territorial integrity / noun</blockquote><blockquote>1. the territorial ‘oneness’ or ‘wholeness’ of the State. As a norm of international law, it protects the territorial framework of the independent State and is an essential foundation of the sovereignty of States.</blockquote><blockquote>(Oxford Public International Law)</blockquote><p>Before invoking Moscow’s hypocrisy for annexing Crimea in 2014 and for invading Ukraine in 2022, first recall some relevant <strong>causal elements</strong> from the Soviet era.</p><blockquote>“To understand an object or action, political scientists have to interpret it in the wider discourse of which it is part.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Mark Bevir &amp; R.A.W. Rhodes</blockquote><p>Bent on dismantling global communism, the Western bloc actively supported separatist movements within Soviet jurisdictions. The Soviet Union was practically dismembered, and by 1991, had collapsed, as a result of the West strategically recognizing the independence of the breakaway republics as a wartime strategy. Stripped of its once magnificent territorial life force, Soviet Russia was eventually conquered and was since subjected to indirect US control. In fact, it was not until President Putin’s ascent that Russia regained its <em>de facto</em> sovereignty and its momentum as a key international player.</p><p>With the above scenario in mind, have a look at territorial integrity as described in <em>Article IV of the Helsinki Final Act of 1975</em> (via the <em>Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe</em> [CSCE])</p><blockquote>2. that nation-states should not attempt to promote secessionist movements or to promote border changes in other nation-states, nor impose a border change through the use of force . . .</blockquote><blockquote>(CSCE.gov)</blockquote><p>In conformity with this description, recognizing the independence of the breakaway Soviet republics was not particularly just. That being said, <strong>Russia’s recent expansionist postures are not actually aggressive, but defensive</strong> (to paraphrase Caitlin Johnstone.) Russia’s current posture also aligns with its right to self-preservation versus separatist and external threats alike. Impartially speaking, these principles also hold true for Ukraine, who likewise upholds territorial integrity versus Russia in the name of self-preservation.</p><blockquote><strong>*FOOTNOTE:</strong> The dismemberment strategy detailed above is currently being used by the West against Beijing. This is evidenced by the West’s open support for separatism in Hong Kong, Taiwan, Tibet, and Xinjiang. Like Moscow, Beijing has since adopted the attack-as-defense reclamation strategy under a similar pretext of territorial integrity.</blockquote><h3>The Problem with US-NATO</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/775/0*VMB6wq0WDiwr-0lc" /><figcaption>NATO’s sigil. (Source: nato.int)</figcaption></figure><p>In the words of the venerated international relations scholar, Kenneth Waltz (2000: 20):</p><blockquote>“The survival and expansion of NATO tell us much about American power and influence . . . The ability of the United States to extend the life of a moribund institution nicely illustrates how international institutions are created and maintained by stronger states to serve their perceived or misperceived interests.”</blockquote><p>Contrary to popular belief, the <em>North Atlantic Treaty Organization</em> (NATO) is not a benign democratic union whose loyalties are evenly dispersed among member states. Rather, NATO is an <strong>intergovernmental military alliance</strong> that functions as a US appendage for amplifying Washington’s policy interests abroad. <em>(Mind you, these foreign interests still include the subversion of all non-US allied regimes.)</em></p><p>As the foreign affairs specialist and bestselling author, Tim Marshall proclaimed,</p><blockquote>“The civilian head of NATO may well be Belgian one year, a Brit the next, but the military commander is always an American, and by far the greatest firepower within NATO is American. No matter what the treaty says, NATO’s Supreme Commander ultimately answers to Washington.”</blockquote><blockquote>(2015: 79–80)</blockquote><p>True enough, while NATO unambiguously condemns Russian invasions, it remains complicit in the event of US invasions.</p><h3>NATO Enlargement — What ‘unprovoked attack’?</h3><p>Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine is often misconstrued as an unprovoked attack. This is an inordinate display of both historical amnesia and of being a sucker for partisan media narratives. Understand that by 1999, NATO was already expanding eastward: integrating the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland — and eventually, post-Soviet territories (Marshall 2015: 14).</p><p>As NATO unceasingly moved east, it managed to contravene an alleged agreement with Russia promising non-NATO expansion to post-Soviet territories. Not to mention, NATO was also set on deploying ballistic missile defenses (Mearsheimer 2001: 12) <strong>right beside Russia. </strong><em>How is this not an act of provocation?</em></p><p>— Going back, below are photo comparisons of NATO’s enlargement as of 1991 during the late Soviet era, and as of 2022:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SOGVmDpybJPq8LO4" /><figcaption>NATO enlargement as of 1991.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1ZyAJrCVh3rkVq8k" /><figcaption>NATO enlargement as of 2022. (Source: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ug2468hDl6E)">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ug2468hDl6E)</a></figcaption></figure><p>Judging by the above images, Russia is just about cornered while NATO, by piecemeal, steadily expands to post-Soviet buffer states to which ballistic missiles can be deployed. (<strong>*Buffer states:</strong><em> The Baltic States, i.e., Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania; Belarus, and Ukraine.</em>)</p><h3>Putin’s Russia: A Prisoner of Geography</h3><blockquote>“So it is with all nations, big or small. The landscape imprisons their leaders, giving them fewer choices and less room to maneuver than you might think.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Tim Marshall, Prisoners of Geography</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TwwSTw3PXyuYAA_D" /><figcaption>President Putin. (Source: Atlantic Council)</figcaption></figure><p>First was the Crimean Peninsula then the Donbas region. Both Ukrainian territories were invaded by Russia under the pretext of <em>“protecting ethnic Russians from Nazis.”</em> As absurd as it sounds, Russia’s reason for war satirizes that of Washington (i.e.<em>, “protecting global citizens from evil dictators.”</em>)<em> </em>Nonetheless, Moscow’s actual policy rationale is far from ludicrous, and is actually quite grounded. Literally.</p><p>In <em>Prisoners of Geography</em> (2015), Tim Marshall underscores the most crucial geographic factor underpinning Russia’s need to invade. That is — <strong>to assume full control over the</strong> <strong>North European Plain</strong>, a vast flatland encompassing three key territories, namely; Ukraine, Poland and Moldova. Ukraine and Moldova are post-Soviet states, whereas Poland is a former USSR satellite.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*geSGZ49woz6f4cX5" /><figcaption>The North European Plain. (Source: <a href="https://www.earth.com/image/north-european-plain/">https://www.earth.com/image/north-european-plain/</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Dominating the North European Plain is so consequential to Russian security that a NATO membership of Ukraine or Moldova equates to war (Marshall 2015: 21).</p><p>Here’s why.</p><ul><li><strong>Ukraine is located at a strategic point of the North European Plain from which NATO can directly invade Russia</strong> (p. 1). To avert this monumental threat to Russian national security, Putin resorted to a military incursion to Ukraine. In effect, Ukraine, a buffer state ruled by US ally Zelensky, is momentarily blocked from joining NATO.</li><li>Situated at the narrow point of the North European Plain is Poland, a pseudo-buffer state that would markedly benefit Russia if Moscow decides to station its troops there. To paraphrase Marshall, <strong>Poland serves as a narrow corridor, whence the Russian military can block the entry of armies advancing to Moscow</strong> (p. 12). By the time an army approaches Moscow, its supply chains would have been exhausted. In fact, this factor twice accounted for Russia’s military victory over both Napoleonic and Hitlerian armies (p. 13).</li><li>Moldova is the third territory through which Moscow intends to control the North European Plain. However, <strong>a hostile military invasion of Moldova is unlikely as of yet.</strong> To dissuade Moldova from joining NATO, Moscow tugs at its volatile economic situation and its energy needs which Russia provides (pp. 31–32).</li></ul><p>Once again,<em> </em>attack as defense.</p><h3>Conclusion: Russia, China, New Empire?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*m5F_h9EsmhCMeRK5" /><figcaption>General Secretary Xi with President Putin. (Source: Reuters)</figcaption></figure><p>Many dramatically assume that the Russian Federation and the People’s Republic of China both seek expansion beyond their disputed territories. But upon closer inspection of postwar history, the assumption is historically untenable. As previously stated, it is territorial reclamation and self-defense — and not Empire-building — that motivate Sino-Russian postures in the international arena.</p><p>Then again, while both powers explicitly denounce US-style Empire-building, it is peak naïveté to believe that Russia and China will never resort to raw conquest in the future. After all, recent history attests to both Empire-building and US-style economic dependency as pivotal to hegemonic survival.</p><p>This is to say, <strong>dominant</strong> <strong>superpowers will take full advantage of their exalted position by “eating more” and getting as big as possible.</strong> This is to avoid getting eaten by foes attempting to knock them from the global pedestal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*4pFNDJwn5FWcyd4y" /><figcaption>Three revisionist nations; Russia, China and Iran, undermining America’s exalted position. Artwork by Ingram Pinn. (Source: ft.com)</figcaption></figure><p>Lest we forget, it is anarchy and her burdensome caprices that rule the international system and allow for conquest. So much that even “inviolable” constructs such as International Law do little to obviate hegemonic tendencies and defensive postures alike.</p><p>But such is only world politics in which nations are tasked to confront anarchy with the hand they were dealt. That is, in the name of national longevity and preservation — and for the highest civilizational order, whatever this might be.</p><h4>References:</h4><p>Allison, G. (2015, September 24). <em>The Thucydides trap: are the U.S. and China headed for war?</em> The Atlantic. <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/united-states-china-war-thucydides-trap/406756/">https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/united-states-china-war-thucydides-trap/406756/</a></p><p>Bevir, M., &amp; Rhodes, R. A. (2015, July). <em>Interpretive political science: mapping the field</em>. ResearchGate. <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283690005_Interpretive_political_science_Mapping_the_field">https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283690005_Interpretive_political_science_Mapping_the_field</a></p><p>Blay, S. K. (n.d.). <em>Territorial integrity and political independence</em>. Oxford Public International Law. <a href="https://opil.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/law-9780199231690-e1116#:~:text=Territorial%20integrity%20refers%20to%20the,of%20the%20sovereignty%20of%20States">https://opil.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/law-9780199231690-e1116#:~:text=Territorial%20 integrity%20reference%20to%20the,of%20the%20sovereignty%20of%20States</a></p><p>Marshall, T. (2015). <em>Prisoners of geography: ten maps that explain everything about the world. </em>Scribner.</p><p>Mearsheimer, J. J. (2001).<em> The tragedy of great power politics</em>. W. W. Norton &amp; Company, Inc., New York. <a href="https://www.pdfdrive.com/the-tragedy-of-great-power-politics-d156709729.html">https://www.pdfdrive.com/the-tragedy-of-great-power-politics-d156709729.html</a></p><p>Tiersky, A. (n.d.). <em>Territorial integrity</em>. CSCE. <a href="https://www.csce.gov/issue/territorial-integrity">https://www.csce.gov/issue/territorial-integrity</a></p><p>Waltz, K. N. (2000). <em>Structural realism after the cold war.</em> International Security, 25(1), 5–41. <a href="http://www.columbia.edu/itc/sipa/U6800/readings-sm/Waltz_Structural%20Realism.pdf">http://www.columbia.edu/itc/sipa/U6800/readings-sm/Waltz_Structural%20Realism.pdf</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dec394689099" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chasing the Übermensch in the Age of Ideology]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phoebegmad/chasing-the-%C3%BCbermensch-in-the-age-of-ideology-909968020c52?source=rss-cc59301616cb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/909968020c52</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[superman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ideology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ubermensch]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nietzsche]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Phoebe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Aug 2022 22:49:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-22T03:36:49.421Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9U7puDbpf-gT4Qcakck8Lg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>‘Übermensch’ (2020)</strong> by Jonathan German (<a href="https://www.artstation.com/artwork/GXxr4B">https://www.artstation.com/artwork/GXxr4B</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><em>This partially extensive essay is divided into two parts: </em><strong><em>The</em></strong><em> </em><strong><em>Profile of an Übermensch </em></strong><em>and</em><strong><em> Ideological Escapism.</em></strong></p><ul><li><strong><em>PART 1: </em></strong><em>The makings of the Übermensch are laid out along with Nietzschean perspectives on Christianity and Enlightenment Liberalism. I also dispel prevailing misconceptions surrounding Nietzsche’s Übermensch.</em></li><li><strong><em>PART 2:</em></strong><em> Ideological dogmatism is explored and later contrasted with the higher viewpoints of the Übermensch chaser. Throughout this section, I make guided assumptions based on my intuitive understanding of the Übermensch.</em></li></ul><p><em>(All movie stills, some of which I edited, were taken from </em><strong><em>Superman: Red Son (2020)</em></strong><em> by Sam Liu.)</em></p><h3>PART 1: The Profile of an Übermensch</h3><blockquote>“I teach you the Superman. Man is something that shall be overcome. What have you done to overcome him?”</blockquote><blockquote>— Friedrich Nietzsche</blockquote><p>In markedly liberal times, it’s not common to come across philosophy enthusiasts who hold a favorable view of Nietzschean philosophy. In fact, I have yet to encounter an establishment liberal who hasn’t already ascribed negative traits to the <strong>Übermensch</strong>: A type of Superior Man idealized by the great rogue philosopher, Friedrich Nietzsche in <em>Thus Spoke Zarathustra</em> (1883–85). Otherwise dubbed as the <em>Superman</em> or <em>Overman</em>, the Übermensch is often described as one who could “rise above conventional Christian morality to create and impose his own values.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0vJMIsSjRrcmc7tU" /></figure><h3>The Problem with Establishment Christianity</h3><p>In <em>The Anti-Christ</em> (1895), Nietzsche vehemently opposed Judeo-Christian morality for all the right, albeit counterintuitive reasons:</p><ul><li>It reduced Christ, an Übermensch-exemplar, into an establishment entity. To Nietzsche, this desacralized the anti-establishment values which Christ personified</li><li>It condemned <strong>human nature</strong>: that man is part-beast with amoral evolutionary propensities that are not for this reason, evil; and</li><li>It was born out of, as well as nurtured weaker human traits that inhibited man from self-overcoming (e.g., <em>servility, moral supremacy, dogmatism, unfounded guilt, groupthink, escapism, et al.</em>) A <em>slave morality</em>, in other words. Meanwhile, higher traits conducive to self-overcoming such as intense realism, mental autonomy, and the search for one’s truth, were greatly discouraged</li></ul><p>Needless to say, so long as these restrictive elements subsist, an Übermensch who can create and impose his higher values will inevitably be in demand. And the Übermensch is all about extricating humanity from self-limiting beliefs being instilled by institutional means. In surmounting self-limitation, humanity is expected to optimize under the Übermensch’s wing; and the succeeding generations, pick up from the solid foundations he laid.</p><h3>Establishment Liberalism &amp; the Last Man</h3><p>From darwinist vantage points, Nietzsche admonished against liberal idealism for promoting the use of man’s lower instincts and for calling their gratification ‘<em>progress’.</em></p><ul><li><strong>Lower Instincts </strong>— The impulse to indulge in <strong>cheap dopamine</strong> and its many enticing forms (e.g., <em>junk food, entertainment, video games, porn, incessant hookups, recreational drugs, </em>and<em> social media</em>); the inability to delay gratification; the constant need for stimulation; short-sighted planning; and the lack of command over human appetites</li><li><strong>‘Progress</strong>’ (in the standard of liberal idealists) — Modern ideas such as equality, scientific dogma, “woke” moralism, atomized individualism (the individual as divorced from the social fabric), crass materialism, — <em>and most of all…</em></li></ul><p><strong>The gradual elimination of natural stressors</strong>, without which man fails to evolve into something stronger. Instead, he gradually devolves into a physiologically weaker and domesticated species devoid of basic survival instincts. Nietzsche called him the <strong><em>Last Man</em></strong>, the ‘beginning of the end’ ([1908] 2018: 135); a comfortable consumer aided by technology and industry (Evola 1961: 140); and escapist who boasts of his comfort at the cost of deserving a lineage.</p><p>While liberalism provides us with limitless opportunities to enjoy the perks of human innovation, the perks we <strong>choose</strong> to enjoy are what ultimately determine our evolutionary direction.</p><p>But as Last Men inured to instant gratification, we tend to prefer cheap dopamine over the likes of <em>fitness</em>, <em>journaling</em>, and <em>meditation</em>. And we do so despite the remarkable, long-term benefits brought by the latter activities compared to the illusory gratification supplied by cheap dopamine. Ultimately, the difference between those who cultivate the virtues to become an Übermensch and those who personify Last Men is their <strong>impulse</strong> to detach from cheap fixes.</p><blockquote>“When a person can’t find a deep sense of meaning, they distract themselves with pleasure.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Viktor Frankl</blockquote><p>To cap off this socially relevant segment, I would like to raise a question:</p><p><strong><em>Do you pursue cheap dopamine at the cost of becoming stronger, or do you delay gratification to become the superior man liberalism tried (but failed) to produce?</em></strong></p><h3>The Übermensch &amp; the Herd</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Tta3DM-N-6zA7N9a" /></figure><p>While the Übermensch might come off as a hyper-individualist who floats above society and is divorced from the herd’s processes, this is not so. On the contrary, the Übermensch is an uprooted <em>extension</em> of the herd. He embraces the social fabric and the reality that like the herd, he too, remains a product of its unique native processes. And while the Übermensch remains unbounded by custom, he maintains a deep respect for it. Rather than defy existing customs, the Übermensch would instead think around them and preserve the customary appearance of things. He makes no attempt whatsoever at severing ties with his origins and his instinct for solidarity is in effect, largely potent.</p><p>As an uprooted member of the herd, the Übermensch is ordained by nature to ensure, as well as oversee the herd’s collective ascent. Bear in mind that this endeavor is not driven by the Übermensch’s altruism, but by the socially-oriented bent of his own self-interest.</p><p>Despite the characteristics laid out, the Übermensch should not be likened to the shepherd who looks after his flock. Rather, the Übermensch is better epitomized by the strongest ram of the flock who can <strong>empathize</strong> with its members, lock horns with challengers, and protect the flock from wolves.</p><h3>The Will to Power &amp; Transmutation</h3><p>The lower instincts previously described above were, to Nietzsche, detrimental to man’s higher instincts such as the <em>Will to Power </em>and its various modes of expression. To the great philosopher, it was the presence or absence of this Will to Power, or the need to impose our creative will on the rest, which determined our evolutionary trajectories. Humanity either becomes stronger or weaker, as a result of exercising this cardinal will.</p><p>The will to power conventionally predates other primal impulses (e.g.,<em> self-preservation, sex, the fear of death, envy, insecurity, resentment, et al.</em>), as these eventuate in physical reality in various ways. For instance, while some eminent figures employ charisma and rhetorical prowess to mobilize the collective, others opt for more coercive means for subordinating others to their will.</p><p>This leads one to ask:<strong> </strong>If we don’t suppress the <em>Will to Power</em>, then how can we temper the aggressive, <strong>antisocial</strong> elements it engenders?</p><blockquote>an·ti·so·cial / adj.</blockquote><blockquote>contrary to the laws and customs of society; devoid of or antagonistic to sociable instincts or practices.</blockquote><blockquote>(Oxford Languages)</blockquote><p>The answer is quite simple: by first acknowledging our less cultivated instincts and our natural aggression as <em>Homo sapiens</em>, we can choose to <strong>transmute</strong> our natural aggression into creative, purpose-driven endeavors. The expression of these are naturally <strong>prosocial</strong> as it seeks to realign humanity with more transcendent outcomes through one’s creative dexterity.</p><blockquote>pro·so·cial / adj.</blockquote><blockquote>relating to or denoting behavior which is positive, helpful, and intended to promote social acceptance and friendship.</blockquote><blockquote>(Oxford Languages)</blockquote><p>These characterize the life’s mission of the Übermensch chaser, and they can manifest in any given vocation. Once again, the answer to the <em>Will to Power </em>and<em> </em>natural aggression<em> </em>is transmutation<em> — </em>not suppression by ideological, nor institutional means.</p><p>Bear in mind that the while the Übermensch is inherently compassionate as well as empathic, he isn’t a jovial calf to prey on. On the contrary, the Übermensch will not hesitate to maul the unprincipled, nor reduce them to shrapnels.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1fsGX45i36kcYl1M" /></figure><h3>The Man of Resentment, or What the Übermensch Isn’t</h3><blockquote>“Resentment is all that is forbidden to the sick man — it is his worst evil: unfortunately it is also what he most desires.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Friedrich Nietzsche</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*InQ7S6fxvmHTfKRtNjdy_w.png" /></figure><p>Nietzsche is cited as one of the most <strong>misinterpreted</strong> philosophers for reasons worth enumerating. Due to his incessant tirades on conventional morality, rebellious and often marginalized readers took this as a green light to abandon moral restraint. This includes moral doctrines outside the scope of Judeo-Christian and liberal morality. Oftentimes, this was done on behalf of misdirected attempts at liberation and empowerment at the cost of the public welfare.</p><p>As a result of this dynamic, the Übermensch is often confused for the <strong>Man of Resentment </strong>(aka ‘men of <em>ressentiment’</em> in Nietzschean lingo.) Indeed, the Man of Resentment may well embody the Übermensch in terms of influential clout, vitality and missionary zeal. <em>(Take Adolf Hitler, for instance.)</em></p><p><strong>But unlike the Übermensch, the Man of Resentment fails to transmute and redirect his natural aggression toward noble endeavors.</strong> As a result, his social pursuits tend to be nihilistic and antisocial instead of purpose-driven and prosocial.</p><blockquote>res·sen·ti·ment / noun</blockquote><blockquote>An existential resentment of other people’s being, caused by an intense mix of envy and sense of humiliation and powerlessness . . .</blockquote><blockquote>(Mishra 2017: 14)</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HcPBkHNxmYje9Dwx5gkuNQ.png" /></figure><p>By unshackling impulses bent on material gain combined with feelings of inferiority and vengeful indignation, Men of Resentment eventually personify the <strong>Politics of Resentment.</strong></p><p>More than the need to promote <strong>peace</strong>, <strong>justice</strong>, and <strong>balance</strong>, Men of Resentment are driven by the need to stifle those at an advantage to them. Coupled with other psychic conflicts, they claim to despise the powerful — yet keep trying to associate with, mimic, and <em>be</em> the powerful.</p><p><em>A classic case of Darwinian mimicry.</em></p><p>If anything, empowering resentful types by giving them what they want is akin to giving gun rights to a proud and unbending lunatic. Alas, one doesn’t simply take away another’s<strong> Life Force</strong> — may it be love for humanity or resentment toward “the privileged other.”</p><blockquote>“I’m going to hate those who have found their treasure because I never found mine.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Santiago (Paulo Coelho), The Alchemist</blockquote><p>Men of Resentment tend to project onto society the insecurities triggered within them by whatever reminds them of their marginal state. As the Left-wing political theorist, Michael Walzer shrewdly expressed,</p><blockquote>“Marginal politics attracts marginal people who are ill at ease, resentful, graceless, unhappy, or frightened in the everyday world. . . . The movement liberates them, or leads them to think they are liberated, and so it becomes an arena within which their repressed discontents are acted out . . . often in naive and extravagant ways.”</blockquote><blockquote>([1971] 2019: 58)</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*sDG3mLv0h12XGwUb" /><figcaption>Things Men of Resentment say (1/2)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7O8r7_WgL59DAu-z" /><figcaption>Things Men of Resentment say (2/2)</figcaption></figure><p>Paired with ideological backing in the form of misconstrued Nietzschean principles, resentment politics easily gained traction wherever it sprouted. To no surprise, it just as easily wreaked havoc, too.</p><p>Throughout history, resentment politics has manifested through the following marginal politics:</p><ul><li><strong>Nazism</strong> (which falsely practiced social darwinism through racism); <strong>Marxism</strong> (which operated on entitlement and envy more than the need for equality); <strong>SJW Progressivism</strong> (which enabled gluttony, sexual profligacy, anti-white racism, and misandry instead of actual social justice); and <strong>Globalism </strong>(which espoused global conquest in the name of liberal thought, the very doctrine Nietzsche admonished against. While the <em>Will to Power</em> was used by US expansionists to justify foreign invasions, their core interest was in fact economic, and not ideological.)</li></ul><p>As World History illustrates, the compulsive need to entertain appetites similar to the ones above was what prompted the collapse of past civilizations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EnoaVknfkrXrkTCd" /></figure><p>Nietzsche ([1908] 2018: 63–64) ultimately had this to say about those who, like primitive men, let their feral instincts infect their higher faculties:</p><blockquote><em>“I do not even count these so-called first men among human beings — for me they are the waste product of mankind, fiends deformed by disease and instincts of revenge; they are all monsters, rotten to the core and sick beyond cure, avenging themselves on life… I choose to be their very opposite.”</em></blockquote><p>In contrast to such men, the Übermensch is far too superior to even bask in raw emotion and self-limiting impulses. Neither is he gaslighted by today’s fashionable ideologies bent on weaponizing these.</p><h3>PART 2: Ideological Escapism</h3><blockquote>“We run heedlessly into the abyss after putting something in front of us to stop us seeing it.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Blaise Pascal</blockquote><p>There is no more susceptible victim to the snares of ideology than modern man. Despite decades spent normalizing the freethinker, man remains clueless about decoding his nature and of knowing his place in the grand scheme. In effect, he is left equally clueless about how to fill the ensuing void inside of him.</p><ul><li>He finds no creative outlet through which his ideals could materialize</li><li>He perceives natural aggression as an “evil” that must be surmounted instead of a creative source to be transmuted. As such, his creative potential remains unrealized</li><li>Due to his inability to execute any mission as a result of his untapped creativity, his sense of purpose attenuates</li><li>Pangs of boredom and lethargy ensue and no amount of stimulation and cheap dopamine is able to alleviate the sensation</li></ul><p>To achieve a semblance of a life’s mission he believes would fill the gaping void inside him, he escapes to ideology.</p><p>It is such that his newfound sense of purpose fails to be a product of intensive reflection and self-cognizance. Instead, his “purpose” resembles a caricature of a life’s calling instilled in him by political lobbyists and tech advertisers.</p><blockquote>“The real purpose comes from within. It is an idea, a calling, a sense of mission that we feel personally and intimately connected to. False purposes come from external sources — belief systems that we swallow whole, conformity to what other people are doing.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Robert Greene</blockquote><h3>Behold, the Ideologue</h3><p>Whether a <em>Progressive Leftist</em> or <em>Modern</em> <em>Conservative</em>; <em>Authoritarian</em> or <em>Libertarian</em>; <em>Religious Fundamentalist</em> or <em>“freethinking” Scientific Dogmatist</em>, <strong>a person who builds his entire identity on ideology is an ideologue.</strong></p><p>With this dynamic, ideologues may have spent copious amounts of time and energy investing themselves in their ideological mission. Their pursuits are normally carried out by way of activism, rallying, social media influencing, and whatnot. Here, ideologues are driven by a faux purpose built on precarious foundations such as resentment, low self-esteem, or the need to feel socially valuable. This accounts for their defensive behavior, if not their impulse to take things personally when they feel that their beliefs are being challenged. <em>— No</em>, to the ideologue it is not merely his convictions that are under attack, but his assumed identity and reason for living.</p><p>The whole scenario is maladaptive: Rather than being a source of inner strength, the ideologue’s sense of purpose has become the source of his mental anguish and brittle character. Instead of using ideology to accomplish meaningful goals, he lets ideology use him.</p><p>Throughout recorded history, ideology has served as a blinder which kept us from confronting our own void. That is, in a sober way devoid of any coping mechanism that enshrines cowardice and escape. By acknowledging this, we are able to pause, reflect, <strong>courageously confront the void</strong>, and diagnose the root cause of our disgruntlement.</p><p>And under such favorable circumstances, a transformative sense of purpose might just reveal itself.</p><h3>Ideological Myopia</h3><p>These days, ideologues have had a knack for asserting their intellectual superiority in the following lines:</p><blockquote>“Our <strong><em>morally</em> <em>superior</em></strong> and <strong><em>modern</em></strong> ideas will eradicate the <strong><em>evils</em></strong> spawned by the <strong><em>outdated</em></strong> ideas of <strong><em>fanatics</em></strong>.”</blockquote><p><em>(Mind you, history has witnessed the recycling of this rabble many times over. And literally by every major political movement.)</em></p><p>Right off the bat, the ideologue’s perspective is already contaminated by both binary thinking and hypocrisy. Their inability to evaluate complex realities outside narrow ideological confines is just as discernible, too.</p><p>These perceptive deficiencies run counter to the higher perspectives of the Übermensch chaser: <strong>That fanaticism doesn’t discriminate between value systems and the socioeconomic status, educational attainment, and age of their adherents; </strong>and</p><p><strong>That reality and its multi-dimensions cannot be filtered through the one-sided lens of ideology. </strong>In fact, we can only know so much about the world and its absurdities for us to model any “universally-applicable” value system after it.</p><p><em>And that’s okay. </em>Instead of settling for a mere semblance of certainty which ideology provides, we can take a step back and just surrender to the mystery of life. After all, the road to fulfillment is through the unknown, the uncertain, and the uncomfortable. Truly, a proverbial road less traveled; but to the Übermensch chaser, it’s really the only road that exists.</p><h3>President for Sale</h3><p>Like Men of Resentment, ideologues perceive the world through trauma-colored glasses. Here, we speak of unresolved wounds that, with the right advertising and viral effects, could resurface, agitate, and eventuate as Resentment Politics. Oftentimes, skilled advertisers would deliberately invent wounds so as to elicit public hysteria right before selling the cure.</p><p>In terms of instigating electoral outcomes, advertisers naturally sell ideology in conjunction with political candidates vying for power. May they be raging demagogues, iron-fisted populists, or mollycoddled democrats, ideology can sell almost anybody to the public.</p><p>To the Übermensch chaser, however, all political ideologies are synonymous with propaganda. <strong>And in democracies, the value of ideological impact lies not in its ability to improve lives, but in its capacity to translate as majority votes.</strong></p><h3>Conclusion: Where Smoke &amp; Mirrors Lead Us</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uw52Srtxt05Y2ais" /></figure><p>In the higher perspective of the Übermensch chaser, ideology is socially valuable insofar as it enables social mobility, mass cooperation, and nothing more.<em> (Still, bear in mind that mass cooperation has hugely accounted for human survival over the past millennia. *See </em><strong><em>Sapiens (2011)</em></strong><em> by Yuval Harari.)</em></p><p>Indeed, the value of ideology is mainly hinged on its being a <strong>herding mechanism </strong>that hoodwinks people into collective action. And as we know, collective action demands cooperation between individuals with shared interests. This is despite the little value ideology adds to its adherents’ lives, let alone their mental health. From broader perspectives ideology has simplified the organization of millions into one tractable unit that can be mobilized productively, as well as destructively.</p><p>Whether the Übermensch chaser would throw support for ideology virtually depends on <em>where</em> ideology wants to take him. As such, ideologies clad in <em>Marxist</em>, <em>Liberal</em>, or <em>Conservative</em> garb hardly matter to the Übermensch chaser. To him, these sophisticated abstract concepts are but smoke and mirrors for concealing other undisclosed agendas. So much that ideological promises hardly eventuate without the involvement of other interests that may not always align with ideological values.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jGBzX5HAVDM8-YKL" /></figure><p>In light of the above,<em> </em>the Übermensch chaser may in fact use ideology, but <em>sparingly</em>. Just enough for him to accomplish his objective of realigning the herd with the highest evolutionary outcomes.</p><p>As threats of societal regression, disgruntlement and extinction linger, more creative Übermensch chasers would resort to more apolitical means for accomplishing their mission. After all, the herculean task of aligning humanity to the evolutionary continuum is not solely about acting on what works, but on what emotionally fulfills mankind.</p><p><em>(All movie stills featured above are credited to Warner Bros. Home Entertainment.)</em></p><h4>References:</h4><p>Nietzsche, F. (2018). <em>Ecce homo</em>. Arcturus Publishing.</p><p>Nietzsche, F. (1974). <em>Thus spoke Zarathustra</em>. Penguin UK.</p><p>Nietzsche, F. W. (1968). <em>Twilight of the idols: And, the Anti-Christ</em>. Penguin Classics.</p><p>Evola, J. (2018). <em>Ride the tiger: A survival manual for the aristocrats of the soul</em>. Simon &amp; Schuster.</p><p>Frankl, V. E. (1992). <em>Man’s search for meaning: An introduction to logotherapy</em>. Beacon Press (MA).</p><p>Greene, R. (2018). <em>The laws of human nature</em>. Penguin.</p><p>Mishra, P. (2017). <em>Age of anger: a history of the present</em>. Penguin Books.</p><p>Pascal, B., &amp; Ariew, R. (2005). <em>Pensées</em>. Hackett Publishing.</p><p>Walzer, M. (2019). <em>Political action: a practical guide to movement politics</em>. New York Review Books, New York.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=909968020c52" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Putin’s Rasputin: The Man Behind Russian Foreign Policy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phoebegmad/putins-rasputin-the-man-behind-russia-s-foreign-policy-51b25d38a1d?source=rss-cc59301616cb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/51b25d38a1d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[putin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[foreign-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alexander-dugin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regime-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Phoebe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Aug 2022 02:36:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-22T03:35:30.276Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NGzKeV1_68JJZokyrDdbNA.jpeg" /><figcaption>‘Alexander Dugin’ (2021) by Antonio Andreas Pires. (<a href="https://www.artstation.com/piresant">https://www.artstation.com/piresant</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>2022 Update:<em> </em></strong><em>While my appreciation for Alexander Dugin’s literary genius prevails, my views on some premises grounding his 4PT have shifted since I wrote this compulsory essay in 2020. Nonetheless, I continue to appreciate Dugin for his naked erudition as both a strategist and leading authority on foreign affairs.</em></p><p>Two years prior, I recall reading ​<em>Putin’s Master Plan </em>(2016) by Douglas Schoen &amp; Evan Smith. Flipping through the pages, I was impressed by president Putin’s strategic prowess and his calm, skillful mastery over the geopolitical chessboard and its invariably chaotic ways. <em>(For the time being, suspend all pop-culture notions of morality. Emphasis on pop-culture, as it doesn’t apply here.)</em></p><p>Even though the authors initially meant to malign the Russian president, I could not avoid contemplating on how the Kremlin managed to diagnose the vulnerabilities of Liberal Internationalism (then-overseen by the Obama administration); and then take advantage of these so as to destabilize its NATO<strong> </strong>arm. To cite conventional knowledge, the geopolitical expansion of <strong>NATO</strong>, a US-pioneered inter-governmental military alliance, is perceived as a principal threat to Russian territorial integrity or what was left of it after the USSR was dismembered; and its former territories, had their independence strategically recognized by the West. (Some such former USSR territories include: Ukraine, Belarus, Crimea, Moldova, the Baltic States, etcetera.)</p><h3>The Most Dangerous Philosopher in the World?</h3><p>None of Russia’s recent geopolitical maneuverings would have transpired if it weren’t for Putin’s foreign policy advisor,<strong> Alexander Dugin</strong><em> </em>(Александр Гельевич Дугин),<em> </em>aka “Putin’s Brain,” or “Putin’s Rasputin.” I liken him to Henry Kissinger in terms of his realist political philosophy, however Dugin has a slightly more ethnographic bent.</p><p>Google his name and you should see a <em>Wikipedia</em> preview which reads: ​<em>“Aleksandr Gelyevich Dugin is a Russian political analyst and strategist known for his fascist views” </em>(2020). Naturally, it was the Fascist-tag that stirred my curiosities: Dugin must really threaten Western interests so much that even the mainstream liberal web ditched its customary Far-Right-tagging and went straight for the Fascist-tag. Taking all things purveyed by partisan outlets with a grain of salt, I decided to engage in my own inquiry. That is, by directly immersing in Dugin’s literary works instead of relying on middlemen like journalists, opinion columnists, or anyone in need of a quick buck who insists on shaping your opinions for you.</p><p>Anyway, I browsed through Amazon looking for Dugin’s magnum opus, <em>The Fourth Political Theory</em> (2009) and literally ALL of his academic works were banned on the platform. Luckily, I was able to avail of a copy from <em>Free Speech Library</em>. Upon receipt, I could say that 4PT was easily a page turner, and not to mention, consistent with myriad academic claims I’ve encountered in my formal training. Most of all, Dugin’s so-called ‘fascist’ views were far from controversial and even struck me as generic, given that 4PT merely upheld orthodox International Relations (IR) principles. The only difference was that they were expressed in illiberal, anti-US foreign policy lingo.</p><h3>Some Clarity</h3><p>Once again on the groundless fascist-tagging of Dugin: throughout 4PT, Dugin vehemently denounced the 3 main political theories, namely; <strong>Communism</strong>, <strong>Liberalism</strong>, — and <strong>Fascism</strong>. And he did so repeatedly. In fact all three political theories he underscored as complete failures. Hence, the formulation of his titular Fourth Political Theory (4PT) premised on the values of “social justice, national sovereignty and traditional spirituality” (Dugin 2009: 197) divorced from Western-centric interests. Put another way, Dugin’s theory is bereft of the noxious, historically accurate elements he discerned in the three main theories. In his critique of liberalism, the dominating world ideology, Dugin writes:</p><blockquote>Liberalism is responsible for no fewer historic crimes than fascism (Auschwitz) and Communism (the GULag): it is responsible for . . . the aggression in Serbia, Iraq, and Afghanistan, for the devastation and economic exploitation of millions of people on the planet, and for the ignoble and cynical lies which whitewash this history (pp. 65–66).</blockquote><p>It is in such respects that Dugin’s animosity toward US foreign policy is far from unsubstantiated, nor borne out of just being “anti-liberal” for “evil, pro-authoritarian” reasons. After all, no serious academic truly grounds his convictions on simplistic dichotomies.</p><h3>World Order</h3><p>Dugin’s central thesis in the 4PT echoes IR scholar John Mearsheimer’s notion of <strong>Great Power Politics</strong>, a power dynamic positing that countries intend to maximize their power “<em>vis-a-vis</em> other states” (2001). This is normally carried out by way of conquest, or by a nation’s loud assertion of its influential clout. To both Mearsheimer and Dugin, this power dynamic ought to transpire on a <strong>regional basis</strong>, and not on a global one. But before we proceed, best be cognizant of the following:</p><ul><li><strong>Unipolar Hegemony</strong> — One global hegemon aspiring to, or already exercising global leadership (e.g., post-WW2 US [<strong>incumbent but unstable</strong>])</li><li><strong>Bipolar Hegemony </strong>— Two regional hegemons carving out nearby spheres of influence (e.g., China in the Eastern Hemisphere, and US in the Western Hemisphere [<strong>emergent</strong>])</li><li><strong>Multipolar Hegemony</strong> — Three or more regional hegemons carving out spheres of influence (e.g., US, India, China, Japan, Russia, etc. collectively assuming leadership over their adjacent nations [<strong>somewhat emergent, projected</strong>])</li></ul><p>First of all, Dugin’s thesis adheres to Mearsheimer’s, given that it recognizes the imminence of regional hegemony. Something both scholars deem to be much more stable than a unipolar, or global hegemony. Dugin’s 4PT essentially seeks out a multipolar world order with a solid cultural base to facilitate cooperation and harmony between culturally identical, yet disparate nations. But more on this cultural aspect later.</p><p>Throughout 4PT Dugin staunchly underscores the need to challenge US unipolar hegemony, something he would denounce as an unbalanced distribution of international power favoring US interests. Meanwhile, all other sovereign interests held by non-Americans are perceived by Washington as secondary, and are forcefully subordinated to Washington’s ‘supreme’ policy objectives.</p><p>Dugin describes the current world order in the following terms:</p><blockquote>. . . a unipolar world led by the open global hegemony of the USA. It is well-described in Fukuyama’s utopian work,<strong> The End of History and the Last Man</strong>. This world order ignored all other poles of power except the USA and its allies including Western Europe and Japan. It was conceived as a universalisation of free market economics, political democracy, and the ideology of human rights, all of which were assumed to be part of a global system that would be accepted by all countries in the world (p. 71).</blockquote><p>Dugin then reveals the formation of a World Government as the paramount foreign policy objective of Washington for the rest of the world. The very notion of a World Government — however fatuous it sounds, is a real IR concept perceived by aspiring hegemons as the most viable option to end all international wars. More than half a century later, the pursuit of realizing this worldwide program merely generated new reasons to wage war. True enough, independent nations are averse to being integrated on to a US empire after witnessing the fate of developing nations under Washington’s patronage. To invoke the old adage: <strong>All empires eventually fall</strong>, and no nation would want to be integrated on to a dwindling empire.</p><p>Dugin further describes Washington’s zealous pursuit of empire-building as,</p><blockquote>. . . a project of globalising the American model to global proportions. This is not simply colonisation or a new form of imperialism, this is a programme of the total implementation of the one and only ideological system, copied from American liberal ideology (p. 148).</blockquote><p>And rightly so.</p><p>Non-US groups who vigorously opposed this brand of democratic imperialism were either dubbed as “ultra-Nationalists” and subjected to demolition campaigns by liberal media; or were quashed by the US military under the pretext of humanitarianism.</p><p>Under the ideological front of globalizing democracy and human rights, Washington throughout recent history managed to monopolize foreign reserves and even the Governments of supposedly independent nations. This is thanks to democratic interventionism, a seemingly benign foreign policy weapon, whereby non-US allies, democratically elected or otherwise, are maligned as “nationalists” or “evil dictators.” These non-US allies are subsequently overthrown by Washington-backed revolutions and coups, and replaced by US-allied “pro-democracy” puppet regimes. These puppet regimes would, in turn, grant their US patrons unlimited access to indigenous reserves at the expense of their nation’s sovereignty. In effect, these US client states would degenerate into crime-ridden, failed, or semi-failed vassals like the Philippines, who maintain colonial institutions and whose elites defer to foreign interests.</p><p>On the American ruling elite’s foreign policy objective of globalizing liberal democracy, human rights, and free trade; it may appear noble in theory, yet has been disastrous in practice. So much that it begins to resemble Fascism and Communism in terms of body count desensitized as mere “collateral damage.”</p><p>As former US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger candidly expressed,</p><blockquote>The more sweeping the change, the more violence is needed to reconstruct authority, without which society will disintegrate. Reigns of Terror are not an accident; they are inherent in the scope of revolution (2014: 41).</blockquote><p>True enough, while a centralized authority is indeed vital for establishing order, this principle applies on national levels only. The Kissingerian rationale of instigating global violence to centralize US global authority and establish order merely catalyzed the most reprehensible crimes known to mankind.</p><p>Let’s not forget the Washington-sanctioned atrocities committed abroad such as the invasion of East Timor (1970s) by Indonesia’s Suharto regime of which resulted in the deaths of at least 102,800 Timorese (Grandin 2015: 116). And not to mention, Washington’s generous <em>illegal</em> bombings of Cambodia and Laos (1969–70), wherein “more bombs were dropped separately on Cambodia and Laos than combined on Japan and Germany during World War II” (Ibid, p. 69). These transpired alongside many other Washington-sanctioned savageries committed in US vassal states spanning the Middle East, Latin America, and Southeast Asia. And all in the name of “making the world safe for democracy.”</p><p>How ironic.</p><p><em>(</em><strong><em>*2022 UPDATE:</em></strong><em> More cases are recorded in-depth in the works of Pulitzer Prize finalist, Greg Grandin, among many others.</em><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><h3>Regime Change: A Utilitarian Endeavor?</h3><p>Many classical liberals from the Left &amp; Right tend to invoke the utility of violent regime change since it promises to advance greater goods of liberal democracy. In the process, liberal values like small governance and free trade were imposed to remedy Third World impoverishment. By now, this should have produced opulent democratic utopias all over the world. . . <em>Right?</em></p><ul><li>On the contrary, only disciplinarian regimes in East Asia who implemented “evil” protectionist-nationalist policies achieved industrial takeoff after WW2. Meanwhile, late ASEAN developers who replicated the US model failed to industrialize due to their burdensome reliance on foreign imports. In fact, it was not until after pursuing protectionist-nationalist policies themselves that Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand took off industrially. The Philippines, however, being the staunchest US ally in the region, deigned not follow in her neighbors’ footsteps. As a result, the Philippines has not industrialized and continues to be the Sick Man of Asia.</li><li>Let us also take the case of Libya (2011) and Ukraine (2014) after the successive Obama administrations staged pro-democracy regime changes against Muammar Gaddafi and Viktor Yanukovych. As expected, both “evil dictators” were customarily labeled as such as they refused to, or fell short in letting Washington pursue US interests in both nations: (1) In Ukraine, to bolster US-NATO power so as to contain Russia; and (2) in Libya, to protect the US dollar from Libyan market competition. To clarify, while Gaddafi was indeed a violent dictator, he was not overthrown for this reason alone. More realistically, Gaddafi was toppled for having encouraged Arab nations “to sell oil for Libya’s gold dinar instead of dollars” (Perkins 2016: 252). (Mind you, under free trade Libya is totally allowed, — even <em>encouraged</em> to compete with the US dollar.) As Washington overthrew both leaders, Ukraine turned into a failed state and ravaged country; whereas Libya ended up as both a failed state and terrorist bastion (Cohen 2018: 36–37) with lucrative slave markets. All these transpired under the new democratic regimes installed by Washington. — <em>But hey, at least they got rid of the evil dictators.</em></li></ul><p>Given the circumstances laid out above, did regime change really promote the greatest happiness for the greatest number? Or did it work more like an iatrogenic? (Iatrogenic: A cure that worsens the patient’s condition.)</p><p>Perhaps we could start learning from actual outcomes<strong> </strong>produced by regime change instead of invoking dubious utilitarian appeals that don’t even satisfy utilitarian ends.</p><h3>Liberal Absolutism vs. The Clash of Civilizations</h3><blockquote><em>“History is local. A shared sense of history is possible only on the basis of the domination of one society over another, and imposing its own history and, thus, its identity on the enslaved one.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>(Dugin 2009: 162)</em></blockquote><p>Once again, Dugin was only right to denounce unipolar hegemony as largely quixotic, given the profound degree of cultural homogeneity needed to sustain a worldwide value system. This is because US notions of cultural homogeneity are confined to the belief that liberalism is universal, hence compatible with all cultures. Conversely, much of the instability in the international arena have taken the form of the <em>Clash of Civilizations</em>, a hypothesis by Samuel Huntington suggesting that cultural and religious differences will catalyze international conflict in the 21st Century. Specifically, between Western missionary zeal in imposing its values abroad, and Eastern resistance to Westernization.</p><blockquote><em>“Liberalism (and, by the way, the US and the West) today does not offer itself up as an option among many to prefer; it calls this decision the only one possible.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>(Dugin 2009: 154)</em></blockquote><p>From Eastern resistance would eventually spring catastrophic reactions like Islamic extremism coupled with Russian and Chinese territorial integrity and defensive posturing.</p><p>Bear in mind that as Washington’s sought to universalize their liberal way of life, they also managed to omit one crucial aspect from their equation:</p><p><strong>Liberalism was borne out of specific social and historical dynamics unique to the West, and not elsewhere.</strong></p><p><strong>Thus, liberalism is to non-Westerners what a donor’s kidney is to a transplant recipient: rejected by default.</strong></p><p>Because a value system is imposed from the outside, it will likely interact differently with different groups of people; some of whom prefer to operate under their native systems. Islamic countries exemplify this since their theocratic natures are inconsistent with the structural demands of liberalism. While liberal values <strong>strictly</strong> enshrine the separation of the Mosque and state and freedom of religion, theocracies treat the Mosque and state as one entity. And when non-Westerners feel as though their native order is being eroded by external threats and in their <em>own</em> national territory… Well, defensive posturing in the name of survival is only a natural response. (I use the term <em>defensive</em> because the aggressor is already identified.)</p><h3>Moral Supremacy</h3><p>US unipolar hegemony involves not just the universalization of democracy and human rights, but also the dictation of moral standards. While all civilizations indeed share common denominators in their moral constructs, different civilizations still interpret and live out these shared values differently and in varying degrees.</p><p>That is, in ways understood only by individuals socialized under the same cultural web. As such, it would be ludicrous to claim that objective morality and how all civilizations <em>ought</em> to perceive it can be dictated from Western-centric vantage points. Equally bizarre is the belief that objective morality and its multi-dimensions must limit itself to the confines of liberal morality.</p><p>In light of things from a more elevated perspective, Dugin believes that humanity is inherently freer that what our fragile mental constructs make us believe.</p><p>In his sobering words,</p><blockquote><em>“However much liberalism today claims that there are no alternatives, there is always a choice in human history. While man exists, he is free to choose, both what everyone chooses, and what no one does.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>(Dugin 2009: 154)</em></blockquote><h3>The 4PT Solution</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*V3bYvU3pc65Cfjdg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The official sigil of Dugin’s <strong>Fourth Political Theory (4PT) </strong>(Artwork by Antonio Andreas Pires.)</figcaption></figure><p>Throughout the <em>Fourth Political Theory</em>, Dugin makes repeated calls for a shift in global norms. Instead of US unipolarity, Dugin espouses a multipolar order to balancing against excessive US power in the world stage and of evenly dispersing international clout to great powers like India and Russia. (Think the system of checks and balances but extrapolated on to global levels.) Only then can a true balance of power ensue between great powers.</p><p>Instead, Washington prefers to vilify great powers out of fear that US clout will dissipate in the Eastern hemisphere. A similar phenomenon can be discerned when Britain lost its hold over the Americas when the US, then a rising power, amassed enough military strength to challenge British supremacy and drive European influence out of the region. We can treat this as the reason behind US animosity toward the increasing military might of great powers like Russia and China. After all, these two powers have been challenging (though not necessarily driving away) US dominance in Eastern Eurasia and the Asia Pacific.</p><h3>Taming the Clash of Civilizations</h3><p>To mitigate the destructive elements of the <em>clash of civilizations</em>, Dugin’s model envisions a multipolar world order allocating international power to four cradles of civilization, namely; Russia, China, Iran, and India. In effect, US international clout is diluted, but not dissipated as international power is dispersed evenly among the five multipoles. The four great powers shall then act as key international stakeholders alongside US power. In the process, the five multipoles are able to extend their regional hegemony and cultural influence over their smaller, neighboring powers.</p><p>Bear in mind that one focal point of Dugin’s model is respect for national sovereignty, all the while censuring foreign intervention. In such respects, neither indirect control (aka neocolonialism), nor cultural influence can be imposed <em>forcefully</em> on smaller powers by any of the five regional hegemons.</p><p><strong><em>(*2022 UPDATE:</em></strong><em> Before Ukraine’s invasion is invoked, let me repeat this excerpt from Par. 2 implying that black &amp; white thinking has no place in any informed discourse:</em></p><p><em>“. . . the geopolitical expansion of </em><strong><em>NATO</em></strong><em>, a US-pioneered inter-governmental military alliance, is perceived as a principal threat to Russian territorial integrity or what was left of it after the USSR was dismembered, and its former territories, had their independence strategically recognized by the West. (Some such former USSR territories include: Ukraine, Lithuania, Belarus, Crimea, Moldova, etcetera.)” — </em>The exact same dismemberment strategy employed by Western nations as they plundered a peaceful, yet vulnerable China during the latter’s <em>Century of Humiliation</em> (1839–1949.)</p><p>In such cases, upholding territorial integrity is widely perceived as consistent with reclaiming one’s <strong>pre-colonial sovereignty</strong>. And like Russia, China has been persistent in reclaiming prior territories it believes were unjustly taken by Western expansionists not limited to the US. <em>You be the judge.</em><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><p><em>— Moving on</em>, tradition is repeatedly underscored throughout the 4PT not because it is romanticized by nationalists. Rather, diversity on global levels is believed to be a more sustainable alternative to liberal democratic uniformity.</p><p>As to why, Dugin believes that tradition reflects the unique historical dynamics which shape all civilizations. He also believes that tradition also provides the degree of homogeneity needed to bind and sustain millions. Not to mention, tradition, something inextricably tied to national identity, is something indigenous groups view intimately and consider indispensable to their sense of belongingness. By first upholding culture and tradition, nations are made aware of their distinction from other nations; hence are able to divorce their national interests from those of expansionist powers. In the case of smaller powers, they are able to discern whether they are being utilized as mere pawns by expansionists.</p><p>To further augment his 4PT model, Dugin cites geography as a grounding feature. Dugin’s thesis operates on geographical dictates stressing that nations in closer proximity with one another possess cultural similarities and interests. The inverse is true for nations that are farther apart. To cite John Mearsheimer once again,</p><blockquote>It is almost impossible for any state to achieve global hegemony, because it is too hard to project and sustain power around the globe and onto the territory of distant great powers (2004).</blockquote><p>As such, geographical dynamics cannot be omitted from any hegemonic blueprint.</p><p>Singapore’s founding PM Lee Kuan Yew also shared the geographical sentiment:</p><blockquote>I said that since different societies had developed separately for thousands of years in disparate ways, their ideals and norms were bound to be different. Therefore, it was not possible to insist that American or European standards of human rights of the late twentieth century be imposed universally (2000: 490).</blockquote><p>For instance, East Asians exhibit a communitarian bent as opposed to Westerners who subscribe to atomized individualism or the belief in the “sovereign self.” Meanwhile, Eastern communitarians measures the individual on the basis of his relations with the community. To Easterners, the “self” cannot be established irrespective of the “other” that produced him, shaped him, or with whom he must compare himself to even know his self. As such, the community is perceived by Easterners as the basic unit of society. It goes without saying that values geared toward the community are better-suited for Easterners than values like liberalism which is geared toward the individual.</p><p>Luckily for Dugin, his 4PT possesses the systemic versatility needed by the international system to endure. In contrast, Washington-style liberalism has ossified to the point of crumbling upon exposure to culture-induced shocks.</p><p>Taking the above into account, Dugin’s theory of a multipolar world composed of five regional powers — four of whom are cradles of civilization — no longer comes off as <em>“too idealistic,” </em>nor<em> “too theoretical.”</em> On the contrary, international trajectories illustrate how the spotlight is once again back on national actors and sovereignty, and not on international actors. This confirms that Dugin’s 4PT is becoming increasingly grounded on reality.</p><p>Suffice to say that the roles of state sovereignty and national actors reign supreme; and cultural variety, unable to be homogenized by liberalism. Policies which denied this reality only ever led to destabilization as attested to in our prior examples. Eminent IR figures like Robert Keohane and Joseph Nye, who famously remarked that international realism was obsolete thanks to liberalism, are downright refuted by these cruder realities. <em>(Then again, IR is not an exact science meaning that there can neither be absolutes, nor obsoletes.)</em></p><p>In International Relations, we can try to arrive at <strong>estimations</strong> of universally applicable international systems like the 4PT instead of making brazen claims to universality. We might also want to prioritize substance over form when thinking up global systems to be enshrined by the international community. By <strong>substance</strong>, I refer to;</p><ul><li>The capacity of a system to (1) recognize the pivotal impact of cultural forces when trying to achieve international outcomes; (2) to determine whether groups are intimate with their indigenous bases; and (3) to gauge the extent that groups depend on their indigenous bases to get by</li></ul><p><strong>It goes without saying that failure to take these into account is akin to pursuing policies without knowledge of the policy environment.</strong></p><p>Such principles are only among the fundamentals of systems thinking, without which policy solutions fail to take root among the receiving environments; or worse, end up being iatrogenics that exacerbate initial problems. Tragically, these vital elements have long been understated in the story of liberal globalization.</p><h4>References:</h4><p>Cohen, S. F. (2019). <em>War with Russia?: from Putin &amp; Ukraine to Trump and russiagate.</em> Hot Books, New York.</p><p>Dugin, A. (2012). <em>The fourth political theory</em>. Arktos.</p><p>Grandin, G. (2015). <em>Kissinger’s shadow: the long reach of America’s most controversial statesman. </em>Metropolitan Books, New York.</p><p>Kissinger, H. (2015). <em>World order</em>. Penguin Books.</p><p>Lee, K. Y. (2011). <em>From third world to first: Singapore and the Asian economic boom.</em> Harper Business.</p><p>Mearsheimer, J. (2004). <em>Why China’s rise will not be peaceful.</em></p><p>Mearsheimer, J. J. (2001).<em> The tragedy of great power politics</em>. W. W. Norton &amp; Company, Inc., New York.</p><p>Perkins, J. (2016). <em>The new confessions of an economic hit man.</em> Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc.</p><p>Schoen, D. E., &amp; Smith, E. R. (2016). <em>Putin’s master plan: To destroy Europe, divide NATO, and restore Russian power and global influence</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=51b25d38a1d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Solving the American Psycho Cliffhanger: A Geertzian Literary Perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phoebegmad/solving-the-american-psycho-cliffhanger-a-geertzian-literary-perspective-da3f11bd618e?source=rss-cc59301616cb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da3f11bd618e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[american-psycho]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clifford-geertz]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hedonism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bret-easton-ellis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Phoebe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Aug 2022 02:05:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-30T14:45:15.771Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fBAh71bPxDv_wqmLsNxyzQ.png" /><figcaption><em>A modified book cover of </em><strong><em>American Psycho (1991)</em></strong><em> by Bret Easton Ellis. (</em><a href="https://thechocolatesoflife.com/2015/06/10/american-psycho/"><em>https://thechocolatesoflife.com/2015/06/10/american-psycho/</em></a><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p><em>Below is my modest lay-attempt at solving the famous cliffhanger from American Psycho (1991) by Bret Easton Ellis. The same can apply to the 2000 film adaptation. Here, I apply Clifford Geertz’s </em><strong><em>Thick Description</em></strong><em> to reach my conclusion.</em></p><p><em>P. S. — For direct answers, skip to the last section. The prior sections are really just me substantiating my conclusion with what I found consistent with US history.</em></p><p>In 1991, Bret Easton Ellis garnered both acclaim and infamy after publishing his explicit magnum opus, <strong><em>American Psycho</em></strong>. The novel revolves around the everyday life of the affluent, yet psychopathic Wall Street yuppie, Patrick Bateman, who narrates his experiences throughout the novel.</p><p>American Psycho maintains its popularity thanks to the cult status it reached upon the release of its 2000 film adaptation starring Christian Bale. However, American Psycho’s cult following may also be attributed to its famous cliffhanger which left readers musing on whether an envious Bateman did in fact murder his more affluent colleague, Paul Owen. That is, along with other victims composed of escort girls and street bums.</p><blockquote><strong>*THE CLIFFHANGER:</strong> As the story went, Bateman violently murders Paul Owen along with two escort girls whose brutally dismembered cadavers were stored in the deceased Owen’s apartment. One morning, Bateman would be surprised to find Owen’s apartment cleaned out, newly renovated, scented a little too heavily with roses, — and for sale. The decomposing bodies of the escort girls were nowhere to be found, thus leaving no trace of the grotesque murders Bateman supposedly committed. Inside Owen’s apartment was instead the real estate agent, Mrs. Wolfe, whose suspicions were raised upon Bateman’s eerie visit.</blockquote><blockquote>The cliffhanger becomes more apparent when Bateman confesses to his lawyer, Harold Carnes, about murdering Paul Owen and the two escort girls. He also discloses his fragile mental state and his prior murders. Carnes ultimately laughs off the entirety of Bateman’s confessions, especially the one about murdering Owen. To Carnes, Owen’s murder was “simply not possible” because he [Carnes] was just having dinner with Owen in London recently. Given these scenarios, it is implied that Patrick Bateman neither murdered Paul Owen, nor the two escort girls, and that he merely imagined these.</blockquote><h3><em>The Invisible Antagonist</em></h3><p>Portrayed in American Psycho are highly affluent, self-obsessed, and nihilistic New York yuppies who act accordingly with the dictates of their profit-driven environment. Similar settings are discerned in Ellis’s other literary works such as <em>Less Than Zero</em> (1985) and <em>The Rules of Attraction</em> (1987) wherein financial decadence served as the invisible antagonist. This dark side of capitalism steers the events of all of Ellis’s novels as exemplified by his hollow, and often nihilistic characters.</p><p>The type of financial decadence seen in American Psycho became pronounced during the Cold War era just as the US aggressively globalized capitalism. At this point in time, it was in Washington’s core interest to contain the USSR and thwart communism. <strong>Set in 1980s Cold War America, the cultural tide of AP can be seen as a by-product of America’s free market campaign at home and abroad.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kvrVuwyQx_Egi6Zu" /><figcaption><em>US anti-Soviet propaganda. (</em><a href="https://www.history.com/topics/cold-war/red-scare"><em>https://www.history.com/topics/cold-war/red-scare</em></a><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p>By citing similar historical instances, I hope to provide a sound answer to the American Psycho cliffhanger.</p><h3><em>Thick Description in a Nutshell</em></h3><p>In solving the cliffhanger, an interpretivist approach is employed in the form of Clifford Geertz’s <strong>Symbolic Anthropology</strong>.</p><p>In Geertzian standards, cultures can be understood through the shared, as well as individual experiences of its cultural agents. Echoing Max Weber, Geertz writes; “man is an animal suspended in webs of significance he himself has spun” (1973: 311) and it is on this premise that man becomes both a cultural and moral agent.</p><p>Meanwhile,<strong> Thick Description</strong> is described as “intensive, small-scale, dense descriptions of social life from observation, through which broader cultural interpretations and generalizations can be made” (Oxford Reference). Through this method of inquiry, a general understanding of the symbolic meanings behind certain texts can be deciphered.</p><p>Best be reminded that producing thick descriptions ultimately depend on the intuitive and interpretive capacities of the inquirer. As such, all resulting descriptions cannot be divorced from my preconceived biases, nor my subjective understanding of American culture and history as an outsider.</p><h3><em>Birth of the Yuppie</em></h3><p>American Psycho was set in 1980s NYC during a period of robust economic growth experienced throughout the tenures of President Ronald Reagan (Anderson 1997). The events throughout this time period were markedly shaped by Reagan’s bold implementation of free market reforms famously dubbed <strong>Reaganomics</strong>.</p><p>While these reforms assisted in building US economic power versus communism, it also resulted in a compromise in the quality of life of average Americans. As the upper classes amassed tremendous wealth (Corbett et al. 2017), the lower classes were either kept in subsistence levels, or remained destitute.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*d_fQaB5S1TD_2RkB" /><figcaption><em>President Reagan teaches Reaganomics. (Credits: The Economic Historian)</em></figcaption></figure><p>The socioeconomic disparities between rich and poor were further magnified through the trickle-down logic behind Reaganomics as this meant larger tax cuts for US financial elites (Ibid, p. 920). This was premised on the libertarian belief that the wealth of those dominating the US economy would trickle down to the masses and stimulate the economy. But as reality illustrated, this was not so.</p><p>In 1984, Reaganomics would contingently spawn what was known as the <strong>Yuppie Culture </strong>wherein <strong>Yuppies</strong>, a pejorative label given “upwardly mobile,” “young urban professionals” prospered financially. Yuppies were marked by their indulgent lifestyles, obnoxious behavior, and their obsession with image, comfort, and socioeconomic status.</p><p>To maximize their financial capacity, yuppies often occupied economic hubs such as New York’s Financial District, home to Wall Street. According to Ferguson (2016) yuppies were a significant demographic for whom businessmen and politicians “transformed aspects of society” in ways that appealed to the yuppies’ expensive tastes. May these tastes be for luxury cars, properties, or even salad dressings which had to be imported for yuppies to even notice them.</p><p>This is to say that unimpressed yuppies = no US economic power for beating the USSR.</p><blockquote>“In essence what I’m saying is that society cannot afford to lose me. I’m an asset.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Tim Price, American Psycho yuppie</blockquote><p>In what was known as <strong>Gentrification</strong>, a process regarded by Smith (1986) as the “geographical correlate of the rise of the yuppie,” slum areas in 1980s New York were converted into market landscapes. Gentrification also transpired in hopes of expediting America’s economic ascent by promoting <strong>conspicuous consumption</strong> within the yuppie demographic.</p><blockquote><em>con·spic·u·ous con·sump·tion / noun</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>expenditure on or consumption of luxuries on a lavish scale in an attempt to enhance one’s prestige.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>(Oxford Languages)</em></blockquote><p>While the measure served as a good economic bulwark versus the USSR, gentrification panned out at the cost of displacing the urban poor who previously inhabited pre-gentrified areas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uTggW5EUb3X02ezZ" /><figcaption><em>An anti-gentrification placard carried by a protester. (Google Image)</em></figcaption></figure><h3><em>It’s the System, Stupid!</em></h3><p>On the importance of systems under which cultural agents operate: The social psychologist Phillip Zimbardo (2007) posits that the nature of an environment largely determines the moral behavior of its inhabitants. He also notes how mind-altering methods such as psychotropic drugs and brainwashing pale in comparison to the “systematic manipulation of the most mundane aspects of human nature” in confining settings (Ibid, p. 258).</p><p>Following Zimbardo’s controversial Stanford Prison Experiment, a participant observed how he and his fellow participants derived their “sense of identity and well-being from their immediate surroundings rather than from within themselves” (Ibid, p. 186). Drawing from these circumstances, thick descriptions can help identify some moral underpinnings that can shed light on the cliffhanger.</p><p>In regards to the novel’s setting, New York has been distinguished throughout US history as a major consumption landscape symbolic of financial extravagance and prosperity. In essence, New York is perceived as the ideal environment, whereby The American Dream is realized.</p><p>The financial symbolism of New York was such that as early as the 1920s, it already served as a major architectural recipient to the lavish Art Deco movement. Architectural designs include the Empire State and Chrysler Buildings which captured the lavish essence of the Art Deco movement. Inevitably, many Americans took the movement as one that reeked of opulent consumption and crass commercialism (NYPL 2009), among other negative connotations around material excess.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*dJxERCkcLOGWlaRk" /><figcaption><em>An example of Art Deco architecture in all its extravagance and grandeur. From </em><strong><em>The Great Gatsby (2013)</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p>Indeed, even in the 21st Century, New York continues to distinguish itself through its manifold financial symbols.</p><p>In light of the above, it follows that the novel’s events were set in New York, and not elsewhere. It also follows that Ellis’s yuppies worked only in Wall Street which [unsurprisingly] experienced an economic boom in the `80s.</p><p>With how American Psycho’s events unfolded and how they occurred at the height of Reaganomics, its setting is well-triangulated and consistent with US history.</p><h3><em>The Way of the Yuppie</em></h3><p>Being vain, conspicuous consumers obsessed with material comfort coupled with the absence of environmental stressors, Ellis’s yuppies embody Friedrich Nietzsche’s <strong>Last Man</strong>. Such men constitute members of “a comfortable consumer civilization of socialized human animals” aided by scientific and industrial forces (Evola 1961: 140).</p><p>In the case of American Psycho, the intrinsic value of the characters lied not in their character nor genetics, but in shallower social forces: Their income, the cost of their apartments, tanning salon memberships, the brands they sported, their sexual trysts, and their capacity to finance an expensive cocaine addiction. In fact, the novel’s yuppies would often get each others’ names wrong and could only ever recognize the other based on these socioeconomic indicators.</p><p>Bateman, who on many occasions, was confused with <em>“Hamilton”</em>, <em>“Halberstram”</em>, <em>“Baxter”</em>, <em>“Saul”</em>, <em>“Henderson”</em>, <em>“Davis”</em>, and so forth by his own colleagues is witnessed interjecting:</p><blockquote>“I mean, does anyone really <em>see</em> anyone? Does anyone really <em>see</em> anyone else? Did <em>you</em> ever <em>see</em> me? <em>See</em>? What does that mean? Ha! <em>See</em>? Ha! I just don’t get it. Ha!” (p. 229)</blockquote><p>In another one of his elitist internal monologues, Bateman narrates:</p><blockquote>“I take a deep breath and while I’m saying this my head starts nodding of its own accord and I keep swallowing, thinking <em>I have to see her shoes</em>, and so as inconspicuously as possible I try to peer over the counter to check out what kind of shoes she’s wearing, but maddeningly they’re only sneakers — <em>not</em> K-Swiss, <em>not</em> Trentorn, <em>not</em> Adidas, <em>not</em> Reebok, just cheap ones.” (p. 109)</blockquote><p>Ellis’s characters, being akin to Nietzsche’s Last Man, are secured individuals. They lead easy lives in safe and civilized urban-industrial settings, all the while exuding feigned satisfaction. This “artificial happiness”, as Evola (Ibid) put it, springs from vice as instilled by a market system that treats industrial forces like profit and consumerism as the highest point of civilization. Evola, however, assures that the “real human being” is left untouched, notwithstanding the influence of material forces over human affairs (Ibid, p. 139). He writes about modern man as “no more powerful or superior” than he ever was, except in material effects. And that despite this, man “remains as he was, with his passions, his instincts, and his inadequacies” (Ibid). Granted, no level of material advancement could truly eradicate our natural inclinations so long as we remain Homo sapiens governed by the laws of nature.</p><p>Motherhood before 30, naturally the best time to bear children without risking biological repercussions, is one such natural inclination among women stalled by their quest for individual financial freedom. <em>(And yes, financial freedom is an imperative safety net in this day and age.)</em> In one scene, Bethany, a yuppie woman and Bateman’s ex-girlfriend drunkenly tells him, <em>“… well, time is running out. That biological clock just won’t stop ticking.”</em> Meanwhile, Courtney, another yuppie woman with whom Bateman was having an affair, had likewise lamented about motherhood.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Aj57eYfpSfJRigj3" /><figcaption>Courtney, a dissatisfied and inebriated yuppie woman, randomly longs for motherhood inside a limousine.</figcaption></figure><p>In the novel, the neglect of transcendent human longings is felt through the corporate environment’s lack of concern over what wasn’t profitable.</p><p>Thus, for the sake of <em>“fitting in”</em> as he puts it, Bateman, who had more perceptive depth than his colleagues, suppressed his transcendent assets. He is also ridiculed for his political awareness and his ability to appreciate High Art as both were likely considered a waste of profitable time. (Mind you, appreciating High Art involves a high degree of philosophical aptitude.)</p><p>Bateman’s repressed state eventually culminates in a mental breakdown near the end of the novel where he commits a series of real or imagined public killings before initiating a car chase (in novel) and shootout with the NYPD whom he narrowly escapes.</p><p>Amid the outstanding economic milestones of postwar America, American Psycho’s materialist motifs illustrate the hollow core of the American Dream. The novel depicts this hollowness through its yuppies, of whom were Ivy League boys from affluent backgrounds. And like the yuppies of postwar America, they embodied no higher purpose than to flaunt their wealth, consume, gossip, and engage in petty status games.</p><p>On weekends, the yuppies customarily made reservations at luxurious restaurants such as Barcadia, and if lucky, — Dorsia. As implied in the novel, getting a reservation at Dorsia meant being on top of the socioeconomic ladder. In fact, it was partly for this reason (in film) that Bateman murdered Owen who easily got reservations at Dorsia, whereas Bateman was either laughed at by Dorsia’s maître d’ over the phone or hung up on before he could even inquire about advanced reservations.</p><p>In the novel, Bateman went so far as to mutilate and murder his ex-girlfriend, Bethany, with a nail gun before dismembering her. Bateman’s motives were predicated on the fact that Bethany was seeing — of all people— <em>the co-owner of Dorsia</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*--durQZZi3xmAanO" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*347LYbQlOOdhVCC-" /><figcaption>A furious Bateman references Dorsia while murdering Owen.</figcaption></figure><p>Identical symbols of socioeconomic prestige were characteristic of New York luxury hubs borne out of gentrification which, as previously noted, displaced the urban poor. It follows that Bateman and his fellow yuppie, Timothy Price, would pass by dozens of homeless individuals on their way to these gentrified hubs.</p><p>Speaking of the urban poor, they were objects of derision to the yuppies. For instance, David Van Patten is witnessed pulling a ‘tease-the-bum-with-a-dollar’ trick by pretending to hand over a crisp banknote to a street bum only to withdraw it just as the latter reached for it in gratitude. In another instance, Price is witnessed responding flippantly to another bum with: <em>“Do you take Am Ex?”</em> after the bum held out his empty styrofoam cup to Price. (Up until now, having a platinum American Express remains a widely recognized status symbol.)</p><blockquote><strong>Bateman </strong>[Inner monologue]: “On my way to the Chinese cleaners, I brush past a crying bum, an old man, forty or fifty, fat and grizzled, and just as I’m opening the door I notice, to top it off, that he’s also <em>blind</em> and I step on his foot, which is actually a stump, causing him to drop his cup, scattering change all over the sidewalk. Did I do this on purpose? What do you think? Or did I do this accidentally?” (pp. 78–79)</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RlbwYCENdJp-2Gkk" /><figcaption><em>The Yuppies of American Psycho. From Left: David Van Patten, Patrick Bateman, Timothy Bryce (aka ‘Timothy Price’ in the novel), and Craig McDermott. (Credits: Lionsgate)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Among the members of their clique, only Bateman and Price would experience any dissatisfaction with corporate reality and the illusory gratification it brought them. In the first half of the novel, Price even attempts to escape from the system by impulsively jumping off the nightclub’s railings and running away to <em>god-knows-where</em>:</p><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> “I’m leaving . . . I’m getting out.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “Leaving what?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> “<em>This</em> . . .”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “Where to?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> “I’m leaving . . . I . . . am . . . <em>leaving</em>!”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “Don’t tell me . . . Merchant banking?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> “<em>No</em>, Bateman. I’m serious, you dumb son-of-a-bitch. <em>Leaving</em>. Disappearing.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman</strong> [Inner monologue]: “I can hear Price shout, “Goodbye!” and then, the crowd finally paying attention, “Fuckheads!””</blockquote><blockquote>(Edited excerpt from pp. 58–60)</blockquote><p>Of course, Price returns at the end of the novel as though having accepted that there is no escape.</p><p>Though mostly obnoxious, Price was a politically concerned individual. This was showcased when he revealed his more human essence upon watching President Reagan’s Inaugural Address. As Reagan spoke, a stunned Price incredulously remarked:</p><blockquote>“How can he [Reagan] lie like that? How can he pull that <em>shit</em>? . . . I don’t believe it. He looks so . . . <em>normal</em>. He seems so . . . out of it. So . . . <em>un</em>dangerous. I just don’t get how someone, <em>anyone</em> can appear that way yet be involved in such total shit. . . . How can you be so fucking, I don’t know, <em>cool</em> about it?”</blockquote><blockquote>(Edited excerpt from pp. 381–382)</blockquote><p>Bateman responds apathetically to Price as the former preferred to talk about dinner reservations.</p><p>In spite of the deviant qualities ascribed to Bateman and Price, both men were still enmeshed by the exact culture that produced their underlying misery. But unlike Bateman, Price only appears to be distressed by, yet oblivious to the darker market forces underpinning his uneasiness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vQUcZIPiSyanIT-A" /><figcaption><em>Timothy Price watching President Reagan’s Inaugural Address in disbelief.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Meanwhile, Bateman’s self-awareness is evidenced by his open resentment toward the yuppie culture. But as a product of his times, Bateman, as though by instinct, maintained the yuppies’ <strong>corporate elitist ethics</strong> (Ferguson 2016).</p><p>These ethics emphasize the boundary between rich and poor and perceive the lower classes as degenerates who will defile and undermine the rich once they get too close. Granted, <strong>contact zones </strong>for promoting empathy and a true understanding of the plight of the poor scarcely existed in the elitist ethic.</p><p>In one scenario, Bateman callously tells a bum named Al, <em>“Why don’t you get a job? … Get a goddamn job, Al. You got a negative attitude. That’s what’s stopping you.”</em> This is right before killing Al and injuring his dog. In another scenario, an escort girl inadvertently brushes her arm against Bateman’s luxury watch. In response, Bateman tells her, <em>“Don’t touch the Rolex”</em> as though it would devalue upon being touched by a lower class woman. Whether Bateman was a true nonconformist in thought hardly mattered since his actions unambiguously conformed to yuppie norms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*c2BckWyU8rWWCD82" /><figcaption><em>Bateman unsympathetically confronts a bum named Al.</em></figcaption></figure><p>As previously mentioned, the novel’s yuppies recognized one another on the basis of the designer brands they flaunted, and little beyond this. There were two chief instances in which this occurred.</p><p>The first was when Paul Owen, Bateman’s more affluent colleague and main object of Bateman’s envy, would refer to him as <em>“Marcus.”</em> The mix-up came from the fact that Bateman and another colleague, Marcus Halberstram, both had a penchant for Valentino suits, had the same barber, and lived in the same residential tower.</p><p>Bateman never corrected Owen for the mix-up and it was partly through this dynamic that Bateman was never a prime suspect in Owen’s murder. After all, it was Halberstram’s name written on Owen’s planner instead of Bateman’s on the night of Owen’s murder. <strong><em>(Refer to the footnote for context.)</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_2mT5HYRvY9LAx2f" /><figcaption><em>Paul Owen or ‘Paul Allen’ mistakes Bateman for Halberstram.</em></figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>*FOOTNOTE:</strong> The real Marcus Halberstram was at a different event the night of Owen’s murder. As Detective Donald Kimball finds, Halberstram went to a separate event in the company of McDermott, Dibble, Newman, Butner — <strong>and Bateman</strong>. It is heavily implied that Halberstram mistook a different colleague for Patrick Bateman.</blockquote><p>In another instance, Bateman’s own lawyer, Harold Carnes, mistook him for <em>“Davis” </em>(and moments later, <em>“Donaldson”</em>), perhaps due to the lack of physical contact between both men. This was after Bateman confessed to Carnes about all the murders he committed. As established, Carnes took them for a “silly joke” provided that he [Carnes] “had dinner with Paul Owen twice in London.” — Thus, the cliffhanger. (Meanwhile, the other half of the cliffhanger involved the missing bodies of the two escort girls Bateman left in Owen’s apartment.)</p><p>Compared to his colleagues there was hardly an instance wherein Bateman got anyone’s name wrong, and right off the bat, this speaks volumes about his deviant nature. He also shows a profound liking to Whitney Houston (despite his racist and misogynistic bent); and is even skilled at deciphering obscure social implications behind song lyrics. In one scene (in film), Bateman shrewdly decodes the lyrics of the 1986 hit, Hip to Be Square, whereas others preferred to appreciate nothing more than its catchiness.</p><p>Unfortunately, Bateman was already too bent on fitting in even if it meant aggravating his deep-seated misery. It was such that Bateman already consigned himself to corporate reality’s erasure of who he was, — psychotic or otherwise.</p><p>In one of his internal monologues, Bateman laments:</p><blockquote><em>“I had all the characteristics of a human being — flesh, blood, skin, hair — but my depersonalization was so intense, had gone so deep, that the normal ability to feel compassion had been eradicated, the victim of a slow, purposeful erasure. I was simply imitating reality, a rough resemblance of a human being, with only a dim corner of my mind functioning.” (p. 271)</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_gf273xB2aVlqInL" /><figcaption><em>“I simply am not there.”</em></figcaption></figure><p>In another internal monologue, Bateman proclaims:</p><blockquote><em>“…there is an idea of a Patrick Bateman, some kind of abstraction, but there is no real me, only an entity, something illusory . . . you can shake my hand and feel flesh gripping yours and maybe you can even sense our lifestyles are probably comparable: I simply am not there. . . . Myself is fabricated . . . My personality is sketchy and unformed, my heartlessness goes deep and is persistent. My conscience, my pity, my hopes disappeared a long time ago (probably at Harvard) if they ever did exist.” (p. 362)</em></blockquote><p>Like his fellow yuppies, Bateman is reduced to embodying Nietzsche’s Last Man. He was no longer capable of basking in the sublime as a relief from corporate reality. And although he embodied redemptive qualities that set him apart from the rest, Bateman, by author’s design, was not meant to deviate further.</p><h3><em>Petty Envy, is all</em></h3><blockquote><em>“For not many men … can love a friend who fortune prospers without envying; and about the envious brain cold poison clings and doubles all the pain life brings him. His own woundings he must nurse, and feel another’s gladness like a curse.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>— Aeschylus (in Greene 2018)</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iaffT_Fzi5zAIgxP" /><figcaption><em>Mission accomplished. Owen is murdered.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Bateman’s motive for murdering Paul Owen was underpinned by Bateman’s envy toward Owen’s socioeconomic advantages:</p><ul><li>First, Owen handled the prestigious Fisher account which was known for being previously handled by a Rothschild (an eminent oligarchic clan in the US.) At a <em>U2</em> concert:</li></ul><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “Are you still handling the Fisher account?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Owen:</strong> “Yeah . . . Lucked out, huh, Marcus?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “You sure did . . . How did you get it?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Marcus:</strong> “Well, I had the Ransom account and things just fell into place . . . You know?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “Wow . . .”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Marcus:</strong> “Yeah” [Bateman’s narration: “. . . he shouts back, then turns around in his seat and shouts at two dumb-looking fat girls from New Jersey passing an oversize joint between them . . .”]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Marcus:</strong> “Will you please put your <em>skunk-weed</em> away — it <em>reeks</em>.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “I want it . . .” [Referring to the Fisher account]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Marcus:</strong> “You want <em>what</em>? . . . Marijuana?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “No. Nothing . . .” [Inner monologue: “I scream, my throat raw, and I slump back into my seat, stare emptily at the stage, biting my thumbnail, ruining yesterday’s manicure.”]</blockquote><blockquote>(Edited excerpt from pp. 141–142)</blockquote><ul><li>Second, Owen stayed at a more luxurious apartment in the affluent Upper East Side, whereas Bateman occupied a less luxurious, albeit still posh apartment in the Upper West Side. Before getting killed, one escort girl (in film) even remarked that Bateman’s “other apartment” [which was actually Owen’s] looked better than his real apartment. <em>Yikes</em>.</li></ul><p>While envy is a fundamental emotion, Bateman’s envy sprung from highly ludicrous matters. For instance, Bateman is witnessed experiencing bouts of anxiety, cold sweat (in film), and an envious outburst (in novel) upon realizing that his colleague, a certain Montgomery’s business card, looked far superior to his:</p><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> [Shows Price and Van Patten his business card] “New card. . . . What do you think?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> “Whoa . . . very nice. Take a look.” [Hands Bateman’s business card to Van Patten]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman: </strong>“Picked them up from the printer’s yesterday.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Van Patten:</strong> “Cool coloring.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “That’s bone . . . And the lettering is something called Silian Rail.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Van Patten:</strong> “It <em>is</em> very cool, Bateman . . . But that’s nothing . . . Look at this.” [Shows Bateman and Price his card]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> “That’s <em>really</em> nice.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Van Patten:</strong> “Eggshell with Romalian type . . . [turns to Bateman] . . . What do you think?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Batmen:</strong> “Nice . . .” [Inner monologue: “I’m looking at Van Patten’s card and then at mine and cannot believe Price actually likes Van Patten’s better.”]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> “But wait . . . You ain’t seen nothin’ yet . . . Mine.” [Dramatically presents his business card to his colleagues] “Raised letting, pale nimbus white.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Van Patten:</strong> “Holy shit . . . I’ve never seen . . .”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> “Nice, very nice . . .” [Inner monologue: “I have to admit.”] “But wait. Let’s see Montgomery’s.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Price:</strong> [Pulls out Montgomery’s card, indifferent]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> [Inner monologue: “I don’t see how he can ignore its subtle off-white coloring, its tasteful thickness. I am unexpectedly depressed that I started this.”]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>McDermott:</strong> “Pizza. Let’s order a pizza . . . Doesn’t anyone want to split a pizza? Red snapper? Mmmmm.” [Attempts to call the waiter’s attention] “. . . snapper pizza . . . red snapper pizza . . .”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman:</strong> [Inner monologue: “I’m still tranced out at Montgomery’s card — the classy coloring, the thickness, the lettering, the print — and I suddenly raise a fist as if to strike out at Craig [McDermott] and scream, my voice booming . . .”]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bateman: </strong>“No one wants the fucking red snapper pizza! A pizza should be <em>yeasty</em> and slightly <em>bready</em> and have a <em>cheesy crust</em>! The crusts here are too fucking thin because the shithead chef who cooks here overbakes everything!”</blockquote><blockquote>(Edited excerpt from pp. 42–45)</blockquote><p>Indeed, the politico-economic factors that created the yuppie accustomed its social actors to comfort so much that the <em>mildest</em> inconvenience was enough to elicit the most hyperbolic pangs of envy.</p><p>We can only expect more intensified responses from individuals like Bateman, who has loose screws. <em>(Then again, despite being insane, Bateman was ironically more in touch with humanity than his colleagues.)</em></p><p>In regards to this darker aspect of capitalism, it surely did wonders as the novel’s invisible antagonist. Not surprisingly, it also did wonders being Bateman’s protector, as well.</p><p>Here’s why.</p><h3>Conclusion: What Cliffhanger?</h3><p>What then counts as a plausible answer to the famous American Psycho cliffhanger provided the thick descriptions laid out above?</p><p>Based on the deciphered content, we can realistically conclude that the murders of Paul Owen and the two escort girls were not figments of Bateman’s imagination. After all, the novel’s characters frequently got each others’ names mixed up and there was no doubt that Bateman himself was saved by this dynamic. Harold Carnes’ claims about having had dinner with Paul Owen in London were likely unreliable as well. (Recall: Carnes even mistook Bateman, his own client, for <em>“Davis”</em> in a personal encounter.)</p><p>Moving on to the missing bodies of the two escort girls left in Owen’s apartment: <strong>The thick descriptions suggest that Mrs. Wolfe, the real estate agent, deliberately cleaned up the crime scene or was complicit at the very least.</strong></p><p>With darker market forces hounding New York, Mrs. Wolfe was set on taking the financial opportunity that came with Owen’s vacant apartment. After all, properties in the Upper East Side such as Owen’s are known to be the second most expensive in Manhattan (Glaeser et al. 2004). Without a doubt, homicide would have stigmatized these highly lucrative properties (Tomei 1992), resulting in a decline in their market value. Notifying the authorities about the crime scene would have also engendered a missed financial opportunity for Mrs. Wolfe.</p><p>Upon realizing that Bateman was not her <em>“eleven o’ clock” </em>appointment, Mrs. Wolfe suspiciously asked Bateman, who was holding a surgical mask, whether he saw her ad in the<em> Times</em>, to which Bateman responded affirmatively. Mrs. Wolfe then reveals that no such ad existed and tells Bateman not to make any trouble and not to come back. She also denies Paul Owen’s prior tenancy of the apartment. So as not to risk stigmatizing the property, Mrs. Wolfe is presumed to have let Bateman off the hook. Else, she would have also risked being criminally liable for being complicit in cleaning out a crime scene.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AinZXr7CfJuOi8pm" /><figcaption>Mrs. Wolfe sends Bateman out of Owen’s newly renovated apartment.</figcaption></figure><p>The moral bankruptcy of the novel’s characters is clarified through this passage by Philip Zimbardo: “The line between good and evil is permeable and almost anyone can be induced to cross it when pressured by situational forces” (2007). As established time and again, the situational forces in the novel were themselves products of America’s free market campaign against the USSR. As such, ramping up the US economy was among Washington’s chief policy objectives for quashing communism.</p><p>Drawing from the thick descriptions above, <strong>there was no cliffhanger</strong> <strong>to begin with, and that there was merely a semblance of one.</strong> Simply put, Patrick Bateman was spared because the wartime market setting of 1980s NYC could not enable less profit-driven outcomes. Lest we forget, had wartime economic demands toned down in the `80s, America’s war effort would have been compromised severely.</p><p>Granted, the idea of Bateman getting away with dozens of grisly murders was simply the lesser evil compared to global communism. At least in the eyes of Washington’s highest decision-makers, they were. <em>(And perhaps they really were.)</em></p><p>Although American Psycho was a cartoonish depiction of the actual Yuppie Culture, it still managed to embody real historical dynamics in ways that suited a cult masterpiece.</p><p><em>(All movie stills featured above are credited to Lionsgate.)</em></p><h4>References:</h4><p>Anderson M. (1997, October 1). <em>The ten causes of the Reagan boom: 1982–1997</em>. Hoover Institution. <a href="https://www.hoover.org/research/ten-causes-reagan-boom-1982-1997">https://www.hoover.org/research/ten-causes-reagan-boom-1982-1997</a></p><p>Corbett, P. S., Janssen, V., &amp; Lund, J. M. (2017). <em>U.S. history</em>. OpenStax.</p><p>Ellis, B. E. (1991). <em>American psycho</em>. Picador.</p><p>Evola, J. (2018). <em>Ride the tiger: A survival manual for the aristocrats of the soul</em>. Simon &amp; Schuster.</p><p>Ferguson, K. L. (2016). <em>Eighties people: New lives in the American imagination</em>. Springer.</p><p>Geertz C. (1973). Thick description: Toward an interpretive theory of culture. PhilPapers: Online Research in Philosophy. <a href="https://philpapers.org/archive/GEETTD.pdf">https://philpapers.org/archive/GEETTD.pdf</a></p><p>Glaeser, E. L., Gyourko, J., &amp; Saks, R. (2004). <em>Why is Manhattan so expensive? Regulation and the rise in house prices</em>. Scholars at Harvard. <a href="https://scholar.harvard.edu/glaeser/files/why_is_manhattan_so_expensive_regulation_and_the_rise_in_house_prices.pdf">https://scholar.harvard.edu/glaeser/files/why_is_manhattan_so_expensive_regulation_and_the_rise_in_house_prices.pdf</a></p><p>Greene, R. (2018). <em>The laws of human nature</em>. Viking Press, New York.</p><p>Smith, N. (1982). <em>Gentrification and uneven development</em>. Economic Geography, 58(2), 139–155. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/143793">https://doi.org/10.2307/143793</a></p><p>The New York Public Library. (2009). <em>Art Deco: A research guide</em>. <a href="https://www.nypl.org/node/171023">https://www.nypl.org/node/171023</a></p><p><em>Thick description</em>. (n.d.). Oxford Reference. <a href="https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803103924305">https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803103924305</a></p><p>Tomei, M. E. (1992). <em>Real Estate Bulletin</em>. North Carolina Real Estate Commission. <a href="https://www.ncrecbulletins.org/bulletins/Spring1992-Vol23-1.pdf">https://www.ncrecbulletins.org/bulletins/Spring1992-Vol23-1.pdf</a></p><p>Zimbardo, P. (2008). <em>The Lucifer effect: understanding how good people turn evil.</em> Random House Trade Paperbacks; Reprint edition.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da3f11bd618e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>