<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by phpdevster on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by phpdevster on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@phpdevster?source=rss-d7f7a0123354------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 08:14:37 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@phpdevster/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[7 Habits of Highly Effective Observers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phpdevster/7-habits-of-highly-effective-observers-dc47009f3367?source=rss-d7f7a0123354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dc47009f3367</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[astronomy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[observing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[telescope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[amateur-astronomy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[phpdevster]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 May 2020 04:59:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-26T11:55:52.815Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Different people enjoy astronomy in different ways. Some like going out and just looking up with the naked eye. Others take photographs. Still others love using equipment to push the limits of what they can see, or perhaps just enjoy casually browsing through star fields in their telescopes.</p><p>This list of good habits to get into is geared towards those amateur astronomers who are looking to push their observational skills, maximize their “productivity” at the eyepiece of a telescope, and get the most out of the equipment they own. If nothing else, these habits help you explore your curiosity about the night sky more effectively.</p><h3>1. Care For Your Equipment</h3><p>Amateur astronomy can be an expensive hobby. Between the telescope itself, and the eyepieces used with it, few of us can afford to be careless with our equipment and replace it at the drop of a hat.</p><p>Eyepiece that are left to roll around in a box may clang into each other, caps might come off, and lenses might get scratched. The risk goes up if you’re mixing things like filters, flashlights, and other miscellaneous bits of equipment into a bin. Put eyepieces and equipment in a foam case with a dedicated spot for each piece of equipment. A $60–100 pick ‘n pluck foam hard case may seem like it’s expensive, but if you have several eyepieces, it’s an investment that’s well worth it. I’ve had some eyepieces for well over 25 years that are in almost like-new condition because I’ve always kept them safe in a foam case, with caps on.</p><p>Telescopes need similar care. If you let significant dust accumulate on the optics, you will not get optimum performance out of the telescope until you clean it. But cleaning it introduces risk of damage, so the less you have to clean it, the better. The same is true of the finder scope and any red dot sight attached. Keep the telescope and finder scope(s) properly capped and covered. Store it in a dry location. Treat it like the relatively fragile, performance-sensitive piece of optical equipment that it is, and you will get better performance out of it when you use it.</p><p>You’ll also want to keep your eyepieces clean. Develop a habit of regularly inspecting them for optical fungus (which can grow as a result of humidity/moisture being trapped in the eyepiece case or behind the lens caps). Also, use a distilled water/alcohol solution and Q-tips to clean any grease/gunk that might be present on the lenses. The coatings on lenses are ultra-durable, and require aggressive chemical solvents to remove. Don’t be afraid to clean eyepieces regularly. It’s easy to keep their optics looking factory pristine, and this will guarantee your views of subtle planetary and lunar features are not obscured by eyelash grease or other debris.</p><h3>2. Prepare, Plan Ahead and Set Goals</h3><p>Have you ever had an observing session where you revisited a few of your old favorite objects and then said to yourself “Ok, now what?”, whereby you didn’t really know what to look at? This is remedied by starting with an observing plan. Spend some time building up a seasonal wish list of objects you want to see. Then put together a list of those targets that will be visible during an upcoming clear night. Write down their catalog designation, a brief description of what kind of object they are, and any other useful information that will help you know what to look for when trying to find an object you’ve never seen before (angular size, surface brightness, total magnitude etc…). Using a list to inform your observing sessions will help you discover more hidden gems in the night sky.</p><p>Preparing and planning ahead also means taking the time to ensure your equipment will be performing optimally. If you have a Newtonian reflector, do a collimation check at the start of every observing session. It takes a couple of minutes, and often requires only minor tweaks. For all scopes, make sure you’re letting them thermally acclimate. Take them outside just after sunset (or in a shaded place even if the sun hasn’t fully set yet), and let them start acclimating. Run any cooling fans if you have them. Do this ahead of time so that you can start observing as soon as it gets dark or the object you want to observe is visible, such as a planet or the Moon.</p><p>You can even set specific goals for an observing session to broaden your knowledge and observing skills. One such example might be learning how to evaluate the Pickering rating of atmospheric stability for the night, or learning how to star test your optics to check them for imperfections, or doing a critical comparison of eyepieces to see if there are any objective differences between them. You might even have a goal of performing various experiments, such as deliberately de-collimating your telescope to see how it affects the view.</p><p>There are many ways to make use of time under the stars, and setting goals or laying out a plan for an observing session can help you see more things, practice your observing skills, and gain new knowledge.</p><h3>3. Keep An Observing Log</h3><p>A fantastic way to build your observing skills is to record what you see. Better yet, sketch it if you can. This transforms your time at the eyepiece from a moment of “oh hey, I see that object”, to “Ok, what details within the object can I see?”.</p><p>It’s best to use more than one magnification. Sometimes higher magnification and a dimmer view will show more details. Other times the opposite is true. Sometimes an object shows different details at different magnifications. For instance, small bright planetary nebulae like the Blue Snowball Nebula can show a nice blue/green color at low magnifications and bright exit pupils, but then show structural detail at higher magnifications where color might not be visible due to the smaller exit pupil. There isn’t always one correct magnification to view an object. Recording what you see at different magnifications helps build observing skills and experience with what to expect from different combinations of equipment.</p><p>It’s also good to spend a lot of time at any given magnification. Don’t just put an eyepiece in and take a short glance. Really spend some time and let your eye adjust to the view through that particular eyepiece. Wait for moments of steady atmospheric seeing. Try different angles and distances of averted vision to see what details you can notice. Do you see some feature at a higher magnification that you didn’t notice at a lower magnification? Now that you know it’s there, try again at a lower magnification to see if you can see it.</p><p>It can also be very helpful (and interesting!) to do research after the fact and look for images or sketches of the object to see if they corroborate your observations. Then in subsequent observing sessions, try to look for features that you noticed in photos or sketches, but not during your initial observing session with an object.</p><h3>4. Deliberately Seek Out Challenging Objects</h3><p>If there’s one thing that’s true about astronomy, is that there is no shortage of objects that are at the verge of detect-ability in a given aperture telescope on a given night, from a given level of light pollution.</p><p>Whether it’s hunting down globular clusters in the Andromeda Galaxy, seeing M57’s central star, looking for M87’s jet, seeing small clusters and chains of galaxies, or even just looking for Pluto, there is plenty out there to test your skills and equipment. Don’t be afraid to look for things you might not be able to see, and don’t be afraid to keep trying. Different observing conditions may produce better results on different nights. Some nights are more transparent than others, some might have steadier atmospheric seeing.</p><p>Looking for challenging objects will not only force you to develop and fine tune your observing skills, it will also give you an interesting new dimension of observational astronomy to enjoy.</p><h3>5. Stay Organized</h3><p>For a long time, I was a scattered-brained observer. I would take an eyepiece out of the case, use it, and when I went to swap it out for a different focal length, I would lazily put the eyepiece back in the case without caps, and let it sit where ever there was space. After a while, all of my eyepieces were just sitting on top of the foam with caps strewn about. As a result, I ended up just losing caps, and in some cases, the eyepieces would roll out of the case and hit the ground (which goes back to the point about caring for equipment).</p><p>I forced myself to get into a simple habit: when I want to swap out an eyepiece for a different focal length, the eyepiece comes out of the focuser, the caps go back on, and it goes back into its spot in the case. Same is true of filters and other equipment.</p><p>Not only does this ensure the eyepieces remain protected while being used out in the field, it also makes it easier to pack up at the end of the night when you’re cold, tired, and don’t have as much motivation to pack up your equipment properly.</p><h3>6. Remove Barriers to Enjoyment</h3><p>Is dew a chronic problem that forces you to wrap up your observing sessions early? Look into getting a dew heater solution, and/or build an extended shroud / dew shield for your scope.</p><p>Do you wear glasses and hate holding them while looking through an eyepiece? Consider getting a long neck strap for your eye glasses (I say long because if it’s too short, your breath will fog your glasses as they hang from your neck).</p><p>Do you hate keeping one eye closed or using your hand to cover it to get maximum contrast when using the other eye? Consider getting an eye patch.</p><p>Do you have to make several trips to carry equipment out? Consider getting a larger bin and/or a cart to keep it all in one place to make bringing it out easier.</p><p>Does your back get sore after a while? Consider getting an observing chair.</p><p>These are just some basic examples, but different observers will face different annoyances, problems, and inconveniences that cause barriers to their enjoyment of the hobby. Try to actively address those problems as you become aware of them.</p><p>Sometimes those problems require throwing money at them, which may not always be financially feasible. In those cases, determine the priority and level of importance of the fix so you can budget and plan for it down the line. Others require making some simple changes or fixing something that might be broken. Do what you can to eliminate things that distract or otherwise impede you.</p><p>The worst case scenario is passing up a clear night because of an inconvenience with your equipment — whether it’s mobility, or the way it’s stored and needs to be set up. Any time you get the urge to avoid going out under the stars, take a moment to reflect on why, and if it’s because of something annoying or bothersome about getting set up, try to address the issue.</p><p>Sometimes the equipment itself is the problem. Not all telescopes and mounts are created equal in terms of their ease of transport, set up, and use. I found that after a while, I didn’t want to bother setting up my 8&quot; LX90 (even despite rare clear nights in my area), because it was a big procedure — take the scope off the tripod, carry the tripod out, level the tripod, put vibration dampeners under the tripod, go back inside to fetch the scope, carry it outside, re-attach the scope, run a 100 foot power cord out to the scope, attach the dew shield, plug in all the wires, go through the alignment procedure, and then break it all down again at the end of the night. I didn’t observe much because of this. Once I purchased a fully manual dobsonian that I could just roll out to my observing location fully assembled, I no longer felt like setting up to observe was such a chore, and I did it much more often. A 15 second vs 15 minute setup procedure made all the difference for me.</p><p>Don’t fall into the sunk cost fallacy. If you bought a telescope, and it’s not working for you, don’t force yourself to keep it if it means you are not deriving enjoyment from it for whatever reason!</p><h3>7. Socialize</h3><p>At the end of the day, the cosmos is too vast for any one person to discover it all, and the hobby too expensive for all but the wealthiest observers to try every piece of equipment first-hand.</p><p>Some of the best tips, tricks, targets, and general equipment advice will come from interacting with others. Whether you participate in an online astronomy community, or join a local astronomy club, having the experience of other observers to draw from can help tremendously.</p><p>Through others, you can discover new objects you’ve never even heard of, learn what equipment might work best for your needs (even try out equipment!), locate dark observing spots that can totally transform your experience of the night sky, get ideas for how to optimize your observing setup, and even get others to validate your observations (i.e. <em>“did I really see what I thought I saw? Was that possible in my equipment from my location?”</em>) or troubleshoot issues (e.g. <em>“why does Jupiter always look like a white featureless disk through my telescope?”</em>)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dc47009f3367" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The True Purpose of a Telescope]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phpdevster/the-true-purpose-of-a-telescope-cfa6e2cbdd7f?source=rss-d7f7a0123354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cfa6e2cbdd7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stargazing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[astronomy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[telescope]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[phpdevster]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Aug 2019 02:52:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-24T03:18:04.269Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="First quarter moon imaged using Meade 8&quot; LX90 and ZWI ASI224mc camera." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z1kcvwEL71wHRUU8hXJBMw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Craters on the moon courtesy of magnification. Image captured by author using a Meade 8&quot; LX90 and ZWO ASI224MC camera.</figcaption></figure><p>Around the web, and at various lectures or conferences, I’ve often seen people correcting a misunderstanding that the purpose of a telescope is to magnify things by stating that the true purpose of a telescope is to gather light. This is a popular, almost universally accepted understanding by the astronomy community.</p><p>Well, this article will make the case that the “misunderstanding” is in fact correct— that the true purpose of a telescope is to magnify things, and that the <strong><em>real</em></strong> myth is that the purpose of a telescope is to gather light. That is not to say that a telescope doesn’t collect more light than the human eye — it does — but that isn’t its true <em>purpose</em>, it’s simply a means to an end.</p><h3>1. Every thing in space is really tiny to us.</h3><p>We are accustomed to thinking of the universe and the things within it, as huge. And indeed, they are. The Milky Way is so large that human civilization as we know it didn’t exist at the time the light we now see from the core of our galaxy left for its journey to Earth. We were still nomads and hunter gatherers, just trying to eek by.</p><p>But in reality, just about everything in the night sky is <em>tiny</em> from our vantage point here on Earth. Hold a pencil at arm’s length. That’s how wide the Moon is. Hold your pinky at arm’s length. That’s how wide the Orion Nebula is. Hold a US nickle edge-on at arm’s length. That’s how wide the widest part of the Whirlpool Galaxy is. Hold a 0.7mm stick of mechanical pencil lead at arm’s length. That’s three times wider than the Ring Nebula. Pluck one of your hairs out of your head. Hold it arm’s length. That’s how wide Jupiter or the Eskimo Nebula are. Take a red blood cell, cut it in half. Cut it in half again. Hold it arm’s length. That’s the width of the space between the stars in φ Ursa Majoris.</p><p>It is literally easier to see detail in an <em>amoeba</em> than it is to see detail on Jupiter (no really — an average amoeba is 500 microns in size, while an average human hair is about 100 microns. If Jupiter is the same size as a human hair held at arm’s length, then an amoeba looks gargantuan in comparison…)</p><p>Objects in the universe are huge, but not as huge as they are far away. Their small size from our vantage point on Earth requires substantial magnification to see them in any appreciable detail.</p><h3>2. Telescopes actually make everything but stars dimmer, not brighter.</h3><p>Now you’re probably thinking I’ve lost it and I have no idea what I’m talking about. But it’s true. The average commercially obtainable telescope operating at normal magnifications (between 50x and up), presents the eye with a <em>dimmer</em> view than the naked eye would otherwise get.</p><p>How is this is possible?</p><p>As you increase magnification, the view gets dimmer. The brightness of the view is known as exit pupil. To calculate the exit pupil, simply divide the aperture in millimeters, by magnification:</p><blockquote>200mm / 60x magnification = 3.33mm exit pupil</blockquote><p>If you use a 20mm eyepiece in an 8&quot; F/6 telescope (such as a typical 8&quot; dobsonian), you are producing a magnification of 60x and an exit pupil of 3.33mm in diameter. You can think of magnification as a ratio between the entrance pupil (aka aperture) and exit pupil of the telescope. 60:1 means the effective aperture has been reduced by 60x (or light gathering power has been reduced by 3,600x).</p><p>A 3.33mm exit pupil is about half the width of a fully dilated human eye. In fact, it’s the same as if the human eye were constricted down to 3.33mm in diameter. If you looked at the night sky with pupils only 3.33mm wide, the night sky would look 1/4th as bright (half the diameter is 1/4th the area, so 1/4th the light).</p><p>How does this happen?</p><p>When an eyepiece magnifies the focal plane of the telescope, it effectively spreads the light out over the magnified area. 60x magnification means light is spread out over 3,600x the area. So even though the 8&quot; telescope collected about 850x more light than the human eye, that light was spread out over 3,600x the area when it was magnified 60 times, so it is approximately 1/4th as bright.</p><p>Even if magnification were set such the exit pupil matched the eye’s 7mm pupil, the view is still dimmer because all optics absorb and scatter light to some degree. A 7mm exit pupil in a telescope will never be as bright as a naked eye view of the sky with a 7mm dilated pupil.</p><h3>3. The human eye limits the light gathering power of a telescope anyway.</h3><p>Ok, so what if we use a really, really, really big telescope? Let’s increase the aperture by an order of magnitude, to 80&quot; (2032mm) and aim it at Messier 51 — the Whirlpool Galaxy. At 60x magnification, this would increase the exit pupil from 3.33mm to 33.3mm. At 33.3mm, the view should be almost 23x brighter than the naked eye. Surely that will really make M51 pop!</p><p>Well, no. That giant 33.3mm exit pupil cannot actually fit into a fully dilated pupil of about 7mm. Most of that light would be completely wasted. It would never hit the retina. So what this means that the net effective exit pupil would then be limited by the eye’s entrance pupil, which is 7mm.</p><p>This is a fundamental limitation, and there is no getting around it. A telescope can simply never present a view that is brighter than what the eye can see when fully dilated to 7mm.</p><h3>4. Aperture cannot change surface brightness.</h3><p>All extended / diffuse objects have a characteristic known as surface brightness — its total magnitude divided by its surface are. This is a feature of the object that cannot change. More aperture cannot selectively gather light from objects like M51, while ignoring light pollution. Thus contrast never changes.</p><p>This means faint objects stay faint (in fact, they get fainter if the exit pupil is smaller than your fully dilated pupil), they just get larger in size. Now, getting larger in size might very well be the thing that makes them visible, but increasing aperture cannot make them “stand out” more against light pollution (with one exception: star clusters, which are made of stars).</p><h3>5. Magnification is what matters.</h3><p>Ok, but what if, for the sake of argument, Messier 51 was as bright as the Moon. Surely it should be visible to the naked eye then? Indeed it would be. Messier 51 is about the the size of the seas on the Moon, and those are visible to the naked eye.</p><p>But the real question is, so what?</p><p>For starters, if it was so bright that it was already visible to the naked eye, then according to the logic that a telescope’s purpose is to collect more light than the human eye, you wouldn’t need it, since you can already see it with the naked eye. Secondly, you can easily see Jupiter with the naked eye. So why use a telescope if these objects are already naked-eye visible (hypothetically or otherwise)? Because they’re still small. We want to see them close up!</p><p>The thing that makes objects in the night sky not only visible, but <em>interesting</em>, is magnification. Magnification is what resolves stars in globular clusters, shows filaments and tendrils in small planetary nebulae, the Great Red Spot on Jupiter, the Cassini division in Saturn’s rings, and many other details.</p><p>Moreover, the eye’s ability to detect things boils down to contrast. The eye has to be able to see a difference between the background and the slightly brighter galaxy or nebula in order to identify the object. However, because our night vision is fairly low resolution, it means that the dimmer the object is, and the lower the contrast is between the object and light pollution, the bigger it has to be in order for the eye to detect it.</p><p>This is the real reason why Messier 51 is invisible to the naked eye — it’s simply too small for its brightness and contrast level. Magnifying it by 60x, even if the view is 1/4th as bright, is what makes it visible. The naked eye can tolerate dim views and low contrast as long as there is sufficient magnification!</p><h3>6. We need aperture to achieve magnification.</h3><p>Ok, but if all what I said was true, then why aren’t we all using little 2&quot; refractors? Why do big telescopes exist in the first place? Surely there’s a reason!</p><p>The reason was mentioned above: as you increase magnification, the view gets dimmer. If you go too high in magnification, the view dims so much that the object gets too dim for the eye see. To compensate for this, you need more aperture.</p><p>And therein lies the point of this article. What we really need is magnification, but in order to get it, we need more aperture. So light gathering power isn’t the <em>purpose </em>of a telescope, it’s merely a <em>function</em> of it — a means to an end.</p><p>A telescope is essentially an optical engine that converts light into magnification.</p><p><strong>A footnote about stars</strong></p><p>Everything I have talked about in this article applies to anything with a measurable surface area: galaxies, nebula, planets, the moon, sun, and light pollution. Stars, however, are different.</p><p>Telescopes do indeed make stars brighter proportional to the square of the aperture. An 8&quot; telescope makes all stars about 850x brighter than the naked eye. This is true regardless of magnification. Why? Because stars are too small for ordinary commercial telescopes to magnify. Their light always remains concentrated in the diffraction pattern produces by the telescope, so their light never spreads out with increased magnification.</p><p>However, in my humble opinion, individual stars are some of the least interesting things to look at with a telescope. Double stars are interesting, but it isn’t the telescope’s light gathering power that makes them interesting, it’s the magnification that does. After all, Alberio is visible to the naked eye, but it’s not resolvable as a double star without magnification.</p><p>Open clusters and globular clusters certainly get brighter and more interesting with increased aperture regardless of exit pupil, but again, they are are so small that it’s ultimately magnification that makes them grand.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cfa6e2cbdd7f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Help! I Can’t See Detail On The Planets!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phpdevster/help-i-cant-see-detail-on-the-planets-ac27ee82800?source=rss-d7f7a0123354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac27ee82800</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[astronomy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[phpdevster]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Sep 2018 06:39:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-12T06:11:47.750Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rXDuif0HtySQVr2MLd5PyA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Magnificent Saturn: Credits NASA, ESA and E. Karkoschka (University of Arizona) — </strong><a href="http://hubblesite.org/newscenter/archive/releases/2004/18/image/a/"><strong>http://hubblesite.org/newscenter/archive/releases/2004/18/image/a/</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>I often see pleas of help from new telescope owners who purchased a telescope to view features on the prominent planets that grace our evening skies, but are disappointed with the detail (or lack thereof) visible through the eyepiece.</p><p>The prospect of seeing Jupiter’s clouds, Saturn’s rings, and Mars’s polar ice caps is tantalizing, but these features often prove to be elusive. If you’ve just gotten a telescope and have struggled to see details on the other members of our solar family, read on for troubleshooting and steps you can take to optimize your chances.</p><h3>Managing Expectations</h3><p>The first order of business is to manage expectations. Even under ideal circumstances, a typical entry-level commercial telescope is not going to provide a large, detailed view of the planet. You may be expecting to peer through the eyepiece and see this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*oYxnS1TOC1HU3OgumxGRng.jpeg" /></figure><p>But in reality you will see something more like this under good conditions from a typical entry-level telescope:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*kX7a082oFy5fxjJeI0OfaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jupiter in a small, inexpensive scope (70–90mm) under good observing conditions using appropriate magnification. A more expensive scope in this aperture can show more details, but is ultimately limited by the smaller aperture.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Jupiter in a more moderate 5–8&quot; aperture telescope under good conditions." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*iOwldBdQGXaLNq_IhSI34g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jupiter in a more moderate 5–8&quot; aperture telescope under good conditions using appropriate magnification.</figcaption></figure><p>It should be noted that the surface features on all planets are often far more subtle than they appear to be in images. All image processing adds a certain degree of contrast and saturation, and the nature of viewing the images on a typical monitor in a bright room is quite different from how we perceive the light coming from the telescope when our eyes are dark adapted. Thus images of planets can be misleading representations of what you can expect to see through a telescope, and even the examples above are only approximations.</p><p>Moreover, the unfortunate reality is that there are often a number of factors working against the observer’s ability to see detail on the planets:</p><ol><li>Looking at a planet without a lot of detail on it, such as Venus</li><li>Using inappropriate magnification</li><li>Poor atmospheric seeing (bad turbulence)</li><li>Observing the planet when it’s low in the sky (too close to the horizon)</li><li>Poor collimation of the optics</li><li>Observing over heat sources like rooftops and air conditioning vents</li><li>Observing from indoors through a window</li><li>Not waiting for the telescope to acclimate to ambient air temperature</li><li>Poor optics</li><li>Inexperience</li></ol><p>The only thing that won’t degrade the view of the planets, is light pollution. Getting out in the dark countryside to observe planets isn’t necessary, since the major planets are bright enough to be seen even in broad daylight (if you know where to look!). Even the most light polluted cities are no match for the bright concentrated light of the major planets.</p><p>Let’s go through each of the above factors in more detail.</p><h3>Factor #1: Viewing the right planets</h3><p>Not every planet has detail to show. The only planets that have easily observable features or otherwise notable attributes are Jupiter, Saturn, and Mars.</p><p>However, Mars only gets close enough to Earth to see meaningful detail for a brief period once every couple of years, and even then, not all Mars oppositions are equal. Close oppositions like we just experienced happen once every 11–13 years or so. Further, Mars sometimes undergoes massive global dust storms which can completely obscure its surface features. One such dust storm occurred this opposition. Even under ideal circumstances, Mars’s features are subtle and require patience to see. Throw a global dust storm on top and Mars will just look like an orange ball.</p><p>Venus and Mercury will show you phases like our Moon does, but they will not show any features on their surfaces or clouds. Neptune and Uranus will show you their respective blue and green color as well as some moons, but will also not show any features in their clouds (even in large telescopes). They are also so far away they can be easily mistaken for stars, even in larger telescopes!</p><p>The most reliable planets for observing detail on are Jupiter and Saturn. Under good observing conditions, Jupiter’s cloud belts, the Great Red Spot, and shadows of its moons being cast onto its surface are visible, but the larger the telescope, the more detail you’ll be able to see. Jupiter’s four major moons are always easy to spot, even in binoculars. However the moons themselves will not show any detail. Only very large amateur telescopes under the steadiest of skies will show you very subtle albedo variation on Jupiter’s moons.</p><p>Like Jupiter’s moons, Saturn’s rings are at least detectable in just about any telescope at almost any magnification. Saturn’s cloud belts are also observable, but like Jupiter’s, they can be subtle and fairly low contrast. The Cassini Division in Saturn’s rings should also be visible, as well as Saturn’s shadow being cast onto its rings when Saturn is at quadrature. Saturn’s major moons are also visible, and become increasingly apparent as you go up in aperture.</p><h3>Factor #2: Magnification</h3><p>Typically the eyepieces included with telescopes (especially the smaller entry-level telescopes) are not appropriate focal lengths for planetary observation. It’s very likely you will have to buy one or more eyepieces to do planetary observation with your telescope.</p><p>As a reminder, this is about what you should expect from a smaller telescope using appropriate magnification:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*kX7a082oFy5fxjJeI0OfaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 1</strong>: Optimum magnification in a small telescope. The cloud bands are fairly well defined, but also not very high contrast either.</figcaption></figure><p>Here is what you might expect when trying to use too much magnification for the telescope or what the atmosphere will allow:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*SZz-N5om-AG0MXb1nPi2Bg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2: </strong>Using too much magnification for the telescope, the view becomes much dimmer, and the planet looks less distinct. Despite being larger in size, there isn’t any extra detail to be seen in the planet. If atmospheric distortion is present, it will also be more apparent.</figcaption></figure><p>Or this if using too little magnification:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*6mWfKG95hvYYIBItMwzJxg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3</strong>: Using too little magnification. The brighter view and lower magnification can make Jupiter just look like a bright white featureless disk to your dark adapted eyes.</figcaption></figure><p>Picking the right magnification is a balance between what the atmosphere will support, what the telescope will support, view brightness, and image scale. As you go up in magnification, the view gets dimmer. While the planet may still appear fairly bright despite getting dimmer, it will manifest as a loss in perceived contrast. Features become less distinct, and the planet just starts looking dull and muted. The larger your telescope, the more magnification you can use while preserving much-needed perceived contrast. However the bigger the scope and the more magnification you use, the more likely to bump into the magnification limit imposed by the atmosphere.</p><p>So what <em>is</em> the right magnification for planetary viewing of a given telescope size?</p><p>Setting aside the atmosphere for the moment, and to <em>really</em> over-simplify things, a good starting point is to pick a magnification between 25x and 35x per inch of aperture (or 1x and about 1.4x per mm of aperture).</p><p>For a 60mm scope (2.4&quot;), that means between 60x and 83x magnification.</p><p>For a 114mm scope (4.5&quot;), 114x — 160x would be good.</p><p>For a 203mm scope (8&quot;), 203x — 285x would be good.</p><p>For very small scopes (60–90mm), favor the upper end of the magnification range since the limit will typically be the scope, not the atmosphere. For small scopes and above (114mm+), favor whatever the atmosphere will allow. Often times this means going below the lower end of the magnification range.</p><p>To determine what eyepiece focal length you need, simply divide the telescope’s focal length in mm, by the magnification. For example if the 114mm telescope has a focal length of 910mm, then to achieve 160x you would need to use a 5.69mm eyepiece (910/160). Since no such eyepiece exists, just find the next closest focal length you can afford. In this case a 6mm would be fine, producing about 152x magnification.</p><p>How much magnification you can actually use will depend on the scope’s optical quality and the atmosphere, but those above rules of thumb will get you in the ballpark magnification range of planetary observation.</p><p>My personal opinion after many years of observing, is that about 120x magnification is the minimum for planetary observing. When all other conditions are optimal, you can readily see a wealth of detail on Jupiter at 120x. For this reason, telescopes smaller than 90mm in aperture will struggle to deliver good views of planets unless they are very high quality. If you are currently using anything less than 90mm in aperture, you may want to consider upgrading, but the more aperture you can upgrade to, the better. Aperture is king.</p><h3>Factor #3: Atmospheric turbulence</h3><p>The atmosphere is probably the biggest gatekeeper to planetary detail. It refracts, bends, and distorts light the same way water in a pool does, just to a lesser degree. Different parts of the world have different levels of atmospheric turbulence at different times of the year. Mountains, trees, lakes, oceans, latitude, and elevation above sea level can all influence how much atmospheric distortion you may encounter.</p><p>The level of turbulence is known as “seeing”, and it is often described by its Pickering number: <a href="http://www.damianpeach.com/pickering.htm">http://www.damianpeach.com/pickering.htm</a>. The higher the Pickering number, the more fine detail and steadier the view will be, and the more magnification you can use. While the Pickering scale isn’t a complete picture for how small the features you can see through a telescope will be, it’s a good enough approximation for the quality you might be able to expect.</p><p>Here is an example of Jupiter in very bad (Pickering 0) seeing:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FhSGGZMzOAU8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DhSGGZMzOAU8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FhSGGZMzOAU8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f75836b474aec60d192c1f9c3580f010/href">https://medium.com/media/f75836b474aec60d192c1f9c3580f010/href</a></iframe><p>Here is an example of Jupiter in excellent seeing (Pickering 8 or 9).</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FRavpiN0Axj4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DRavpiN0Axj4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FRavpiN0Axj4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/111631447f4bdccec9cd87ded65b217a/href">https://medium.com/media/111631447f4bdccec9cd87ded65b217a/href</a></iframe><p>Seeing conditions can change from second to second, minute to minute, or hour to hour. Some days, seasons, or even years may be significantly worse than others. Prolonged views of a planet will let you catch those fleeting moments when air stabilizes, and presents a clean, undistorted view of the planet.</p><p>In a very small telescope (60–90mm), you will likely run out of telescope capability before bumping into atmospheric limits (unless you have a very high quality small telescope). That is, as long as you stick to the 1x — 1.4x per mm of aperture rule of thumb, you will likely not have to worry about the atmosphere being the limiting factor. But scopes larger than that, regardless of their quality, can easily reach magnifications that might exceed what the atmosphere will allow, thus it becomes important to pick an appropriate magnification that matches the atmospheric limit.</p><p>There is no explicit cliff where the view goes from good to bad with too much magnification. It’s a slippery slope, and it’s all about your personal preference for the combination of steadiness, sharpness, brightness, and size. This is why it can be useful to have a zoom eyepiece, or a tight clustering of focal lengths around the average atmospheric limit for your observing location so that you can pick the right magnification for the seeing conditions.</p><p>From my experience, these are the approximate magnification limits for each Pickering level:</p><ul><li>Pickering 8–9: Whatever your scope will allow. Atmosphere is usually not the limit.</li><li>Pickering 7: about 500x</li><li>Pickering 6: about 350x</li><li>Pickering 5: about 180x</li><li>Pickering 4: about 120x</li><li>Pickering 3 and below: 90x or less</li></ul><p>Note that these magnifications are entirely arbitrary based on my personal preference for “crispness” of the view, as well as what eyepieces I have available to me. Those are the limits where the view stops looking crisp enough for my tastes. For you it may be different.</p><p>So what’s the takeaway here?</p><p>There’s nothing you can do about poor atmospheric seeing conditions other than wait for them to get better, or travel somewhere that they are better. The best you can do is pick an appropriate magnification that fits your personal criteria of crispness and size for the given night.</p><p>For a rough prediction of seeing quality, check out MeteoBlue and select your location: <a href="http://meteoblue.com/en/weather/forecast/seeing/">http://meteoblue.com/en/weather/forecast/seeing/</a></p><h3>Factor #4: Planetary altitude above the horizon</h3><p>This is somewhat related to Factor #3. The closer a planet is to the horizon, the more atmosphere you must look through to see it. If the atmosphere straight above you (90 degrees altitude) contains about 10 miles of turbulent atmosphere, then to look at an object just 25 degrees altitude above the horizon, you’re looking through approximately 24 miles of turbulent atmosphere. For objects just 10 degrees altitude above the horizon, you’re looking through almost 60 miles of turbulent atmosphere (and dust, and moisture, and ice crystals!)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GcleTgf8VKVSaW7CaGW2SA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 6:</strong> Light from objects lower on the horizon will pass through more atmosphere on the way to your telescope than objects straight above you. This means greater total distortion of light.</figcaption></figure><p>In addition to a thicker atmosphere, lower altitude also means atmospheric refraction can become an issue. Our atmosphere acts like a prism that splits white light into different wavelengths. The steeper the angle of light entering the atmosphere, the more pronounced these effects — known as atmospheric dispersion — become.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*L52Xj1Pc3_OkroKfeNEZzg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 7: </strong>The effects of atmospheric dispersion for objects at low altitude above the horizon. The atmosphere acts like a prism, refracting light at low angles of incidence, and breaking it up into its constituent colors.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*t1F24vmeyfDBwWMofr-Ypw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 8: </strong>Through the eyepiece, the effects of atmospheric dispersion can be quite pronounced. Blue and red fringes will flank either side of the planet, and the view will always look a bit blurry since not all wavelengths are coming to the same focal point.</figcaption></figure><p>How can this be avoided? Unfortunately, the major factor is a combination of your latitude, and where the major planets are in their orbits. Right now (as of summer 2018), the major planets are in the Summer zodiac constellations (Sagittarius, Scorpius, Ophiuchus). These constellations are low in the sky for those in higher northern latitudes (45 degrees or higher). Because the orbital periods of Jupiter and Saturn are very long, they will remain in these summer constellations for a few more years. When they eventually reach the Fall and Winter zodiac constellations, they will be high overhead. Those living closer to the equator will always get to enjoy planets that are relatively high above the horizon, regardless of where they are in their orbits.</p><p>To optimize the view, it’s best to wait until the planet crosses the meridian — the time of night when it will be highest in the sky. This changes day to day as the year progresses. I recommend <a href="https://www.timeanddate.com/astronomy/night/">Time and Date’s planetary rise, set, and meridian tools</a> for determining the meridian time and altitude for the different planets for your location.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*kDLcjhBiCFKBwOvSjiLvtQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 9: </strong>Waiting for a planet to reach the meridian for the night is the best way to minimize the effects of atmospheric dispersion and low altitude turbulence. Viewing a planet just after it rises is a recipe for poor viewing conditions and zero detail.</figcaption></figure><p>How close is too close to the horizon? There is no hard cutoff. Some nights will let you go down to 15 degrees, others won’t. You just have to go out and try it and see if the atmosphere is cooperating. If it’s <em>not</em>, however, then waiting for the planet to rise to its meridian height is the next best option. If that meridian height is still very low (below 15 degrees) due your latitude, then you may have to wait until the planets are in more favorable locations in their orbits.</p><h3>Factor #5: Poor collimation</h3><p>For refracting telescopes and Maksutov Cassegrains, collimation is rarely, if ever, an issue. For Schmidt Cassegrains, it’s sometimes an issue (though typically the long focal ratios of these scopes make small collimation errors less noticeable). But for Newtonian reflectors (especially ones with short focal ratios — F/6 and shorter), ensuring good collimation is an important piece to the planetary observation puzzle.</p><p>It’s easier for Newtonians to get out of collimation than other designs, and the shorter focal ratios typically found in Newtonians makes collimation errors more pronounced than in the more common longer focal ratio designs of refractors and Cassegrains.</p><p>If you are the owner of a Newtonian reflector, then be sure to familiarize yourself with how to accurately test and collimate its optics:</p><ul><li><a href="https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-resources/how-to-align-your-newtonian-reflector-telescope/">How to Align Your Newtonian Reflector Telescope | Sky &amp; Telescope</a></li><li><a href="https://garyseronik.com/a-beginners-guide-to-collimation/">A Beginner&#39;s Guide to Collimation - Gary Seronik</a></li><li><a href="http://www.astro-baby.com/astrobaby/help/collimation-guide-newtonian-reflector/">Astro Babys Guide to Collimation - Newtonian Telescope - Reflector</a></li></ul><p><a href="https://astro.catshill.com/collimation-guide/">https://astro.catshill.com/collimation-guide/</a></p><h3>Factor #6: Observing over heat sources</h3><p>Heat rising off of rooftops or from various vents can cause serious degradation to the view — as much or more as the atmosphere itself. Cities and asphalt shingles on roofs act as giant heat traps that absorb heat during the day, and release it at night. As the warm air rises off of these structures, it causes turbulence. It’s likely you’ve seen these effects in the form of mirages over hot asphalt, subtle shadows being created by heat rising from a radiator in the winter time as sunlight passes through the rising warm air, and distortions from a campfire.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJouXLJpaDjg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJouXLJpaDjg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJouXLJpaDjg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e1c1fe098a1688082ee86bc09614bb44/href">https://medium.com/media/e1c1fe098a1688082ee86bc09614bb44/href</a></iframe><p>Do what you can to get away from these heat sources. The higher the planet is above the heat source, the less pronounced the effects will be. Observing a planet over distant rooftops is not a problem. Observing a planet just a couple of degrees above a nearby rooftop or heat vent of some kind, <em>is</em> a problem.</p><h3>Factor #7: Observing from indoors through a window</h3><p>This feels like one of those things that should go without saying, but to get the clearest views of a planet, you cannot view it through a window. A window is not a piece of optical glass. It has substantial imperfections that will badly distort light passing through it. Most windows are multi-layered and are not coated with anti-reflection coatings, so you’re going to be seeing ghost images of the planet when looking through the glass. If the window has a screen, the fine mesh is going to add substantial diffraction effects that will greatly reduce contrast.</p><p>Even opening the window is not sufficient. Typically the indoor temperature is different from the outdoor temperature, meaning the heat escaping through the open window is mixing with the colder air outside, creating a thermal gradient and degrading the view in the same manner that was explained in Factor #6.</p><p>Further still, most radiant heating units are typically positioned under a window because that is where the greatest heat loss occurs in a room. This means during the winter time if you have a heating unit near the window, warm air is going to be rising and mixing with the colder air near the window, which will make thermal distortion that much worse.</p><p>Just don’t view planets from inside, through a window whether it’s open or closed. You will never see any meaningful details in them if you do. Go outside, and be sure to avoid looking at the planet when it’s just a few degrees above something that could potentially be a heat source.</p><h3>Factor #8: Thermal acclimation</h3><p>This is a major factor that is just as important as all of the others. When the surface of a telescope mirror, or the air inside the tube, has a substantially different temperature than the surrounding air, you get thermal distortions (the notion of thermal distortions is a widespread problem, if you haven’t noticed already).</p><p>Refractors typically don’t have a major issue with thermal distortions, but the thicker mirrors of reflectors and Cassegrains have high thermal mass, meaning they cool or warm slowly. The temperature differential between the mirror’s surface and ambient air creates a boundary layer on the surface of the mirror that absolutely clobbers light passing through it (which it has to do <em>twice: </em>once on the way in, and then again after being reflected off the surface).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*2imR2TEBL21SFsbhfQ87og.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 11</strong>: A special test setup that allows a camera to record the effects of the thermal boundary layer of a mirror that is warmer than the surrounding air.</figcaption></figure><p>But it isn’t just the boundary layer sitting on the surface of the mirror that’s a problem. Any thermal currents present in the tube can distort the light before it reaches the eyepiece.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FUbH4AS-0ViE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DUbH4AS-0ViE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FUbH4AS-0ViE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/92a603f374b7677f24f9277af4b9db7c/href">https://medium.com/media/92a603f374b7677f24f9277af4b9db7c/href</a></iframe><p>It’s worth visiting <a href="http://www.fpi-protostar.com/bgreer/sep2000st.htm">this page </a>for more videos and visualizations of the effect of the boundary layer and tube thermal currents.</p><p>So what can be done about this? The easiest thing to do is to bring your telescope outside a couple of hours before you plan to observe to let the scope acclimate to the ambient temperature. Once the temperature of the mirror gets within about 5 degrees Fahrenheit or 2 degrees Celsius of the ambient air temperature, it will perform well.</p><p>How long this takes depends on how big the temperature difference was from the start. Keeping the scope in a warm, heated house in the winter means it might take 3 or more hours to reach ambient if it’s particularly cold outside. Conversely, if it’s kept in an air-conditioned house, it might take an hour or two to warm up properly (but you might also exhibit fogging going from a cool to warm environment).</p><p>The best thing you can do to speed up the acclimation process of a Newtonian is to add a cooling fan to the back of the mirror to blow air against it. This will dramatically reduce the acclimation time of the mirror. Some telescopes come with cooling fans already installed, but you can make your own easily enough with just an 80mm PC cooling fan and some basic DIY skills:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FSsvMs4HGRnk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DSsvMs4HGRnk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FSsvMs4HGRnk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e691f3fe8e9623e8cb3e0368fce22f59/href">https://medium.com/media/e691f3fe8e9623e8cb3e0368fce22f59/href</a></iframe><p>If you’re curious about how long your telescope will take to acclimate with or without a fan, there is a <a href="http://www.cruxis.com/scope/mirrorcooling.htm">free program</a> you can use. You will need to know the thickness of your mirror and what type of glass it’s made of in order to accurately compute the time it takes to reach ambient.</p><h3>Factor #9: Poor optics</h3><p>Sadly, many entry-level commercial telescopes are either too small or too cheaply made to give you satisfying views of the planets. Telescopes with insufficient optical capability usually come in one of three flavors:</p><p><strong>#1: Too little aperture (typical 60mm refractors)</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/345/1*fLz5R_ZaJha2q_8YsG9rdQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 13</strong>: A classic entry-level telescope — the 60mm refractor with erecting image diagonal. In this price class, no single brand is better than another.</figcaption></figure><p>Going back to the magnification rule of thumb, the upper limit magnification for a telescope this size is about 84x. This is basically an insufficient magnification for viewing details on planets, and because of how cheaply made this class of telescope is, it won’t be a clean 84x either. It will likely contain a fair amount of chromatic aberration, and the erecting image diagonal it typically comes with (designed for terrestrial use), is of very poor quality and will further degrade the view before reaching the eyepiece.</p><p>The short story is that these small refractors are simply *not* designed for planetary viewing. You will see Jupiter’s moons, the shape of Saturn’s rings, and the phases of Venus, and that’s about it.</p><p>So what’s the solution? Avoid these “department store” quality refractors. The better quality refractors start at around 4&quot; (102mm) in aperture, but they are expensive compared to an equivalent Newtonian. Refractors, in general, are not cost-effective instruments.</p><p><strong>#2: Compact achromatic refractors</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P-ug1t81FjwprV_CqkboBg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 14</strong>: Notable offenders. These typical “travel” refactors all have short focal ratios, which means high levels of chromatic aberration when using magnifications needed to observe planets in detail.</figcaption></figure><p>As if their small aperture wasn’t enough of an issue, this class of telescope also has a short focal ratio. This means they refract light more aggressively than a refractor with a long focal ratio, and in doing so, they break it up into its constituent colors more severely. When light gets strongly refracted, not all wavelengths come to the same focal point. This is known as chromatic aberration, and all refractors (even camera lenses) suffer from it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*RzmUswq3HZ9veR2HdzvPIA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 15</strong>: The effects of chromatic aberration. The shorter the focal ratio, the more severe the effect is. The diagram on the left is a lens refracting light at a steep angle (e.g. short focal ratio). The left-most Jupiter image shows significant chromatic aberration and prismatic dispersion from interaction with a badly aligned prism diagonal. The right-most Jupiter image shows less severe aberration, but it still has an unnatural hue to it that reduces the already subtle contrast of its cloud belts. These are common problems in all but the most expensive refractors.</figcaption></figure><p>The only way for a refractor to have a short focal ratio and still produce a sharp, true color image, is if it uses more than two lens elements and expensive, extra low dispersion glass. These kinds of refractors are commonly referred to as “apochromatic” refractors, rather than just typical “achromatic” refractors. However, they are often 5–10x the cost of a normal achromatic refractor of the same size and focal ratio.</p><p>What’s the solution? <em>If </em>you do want to get a refractor, do not get a short travel refractor with a short focal ratio. Get a long refractor at least F/8 or longer, or be prepared to spend nearly $1,000 or more on a high quality small aperture apochromatic refractor.</p><p><strong>#3: Short Newtonian reflectors with spherical mirrors</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*amVscgHhBRGwRFr8VYqjZg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 16: </strong>Small reflecting telescopes with spherical primary mirrors. On the left is a Celestron PowerSeeker that uses a Bird-Jones configuration, and on the right is a very small, short focal ratio Newtonian reflector with a spherical mirror. Neither scope will give you satisfying views of the planets.</figcaption></figure><p>Newtonian reflectors gather light from a primary mirror at the back of the telescope. The shape of this mirror is supposed to be parabolic, but to save costs, sometimes it is made to be spherical. Spherical mirrors do not focus light properly, especially if they have short focal ratios. See this diagram for an illustration:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*WR3KMEu31z1oibPr-NZnIg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 17:</strong> How light comes to a focus in a spherical vs parabolic mirror. A spherical mirror does not bring all light to the same point of focus, but a parabolic mirror does. The shorter the focal ratio, the worse the problem gets for spherical mirrors. This lack of single focal point will dramatically limit the useful magnification of the telescope.</figcaption></figure><p>Making a spherical mirror is cheaper than making a parabolic mirror, which is why manufacturers will sometimes include spherical mirrors in their telescopes instead of parabolic mirrors.</p><p>Some designs attempt to correct for this problem with a special lens element in the bottom of the focuser tube. This is known as a Bird-Jones (or Jones-Bird) design. The Celestron PowerSeeker 127, Celestron Astromaster 114, and Celestron StarSense Explorer LT 127AZ utilize this design. The problem is that because of the lens element in the focuser tube, it becomes nearly impossible to precisely collimate a Bird-Jones scope (see Factor #5 above for why collimation is important). These kinds of scopes are also made to poor tolerances and the corrector lens often does a poor job of fixing the spherical aberration present in the mirror.</p><p>The solution? Avoid any Newtonian reflector that doesn’t have a parabolic primary mirror. Some Newtonians have spherical mirrors but long focal ratios (F/8 or longer). These are <em>passable</em>, but not great. It’s just best to avoid them entirely. Do some research to make sure the model you’re thinking about getting is a true Newtonian reflector with a parabolic primary mirror.</p><h3>Factor #10: Inexperience</h3><p>Astronomy has a weird quirk to it whereby you cannot take your vision for granted. You might think that by virtue of the fact that you’re (A) a human and (B) you have working vision, that you’re automatically an expert at seeing things.</p><p>The kinds of things we amateur astronomers like to observe are not things the human vision system naturally evolved to be good at perceiving. Just because we have the physiology necessary to see very faint light, or see very tiny features on a tiny planetary disk through an eyepiece, doesn’t mean we have the skill to <em>notice </em>those things easily.</p><p>This is where observer experience comes in — like any other skill, it’s something we must work at and develop. The subtle contrast of planetary features is something that takes the brain time to get used to. Our eyes are sending that information to the brain, but the brain may be dismissing it (subconsciously) as being unimportant. Over time, however, the brain will learn to care about the seemingly unimportant signals the eye is sending it.</p><p>You can practice your observing skills by taking the time describe what you see in as much detail as possible. Literally write down detailed notes or even talk to yourself while observing. Even better, try to sketch what you see. It forces you to really pay attention to small, subtle details.</p><h3>Summary</h3><p>While every factor is almost equally important, the truly most important factor in how much detail you can see (assuming you’re using optimum magnification), is your telescope.</p><p>If you already have a small 60–90mm telescope and it’s not a very high quality apochromatic refractor that cost you $1,000 or more, then my recommendation is to start saving up for a larger, better telescope. Aperture is king when it comes to planetary detail, and the more of it you can afford, the better. The absolute minimum aperture I recommend to begin observing meaningful detail on the planets is 114mm (4.5&quot;), but again, the higher the better.</p><p>The most affordable telescopes per inch of aperture are Dobsonians (Newtonian reflectors mounted on a Dobsonian base). A decent entry-level Dobsonian from 114mm to 150mm (4.5&quot; to 6&quot;) in aperture can be had for $200-$300 brand new. Some examples include the Orion FunScope 114, Meade LightBridge Mini 130, AWB OneSky, Heritage 130p, Orion XT4.5, Orion XT6, and SkyWatcher 6&quot; classic.</p><p>Of all those, my personal recommendation for the cheapest possible entry-level scope is a full size 6&quot; F/8 reflector like the Sky-Watcher 6&quot; Classic (also branded the Classic 150p), or Orion XT6, or Apertura DT6.</p><ol><li>6&quot; of aperture is still going to be a substantial increase in detail over a 5&quot; or 4.5&quot; scope.</li><li>The F/8 focal ratio means collimation will be more forgiving, it will have virtually no coma (an aberration of parabolic mirrors), and cheaper eyepieces will still perform well in it. The faster focal ratios of typical “table top” dobsonians are harder on cheaper eyepieces, requires more precise collimation, and the coma is strong enough that only the very center of the field of view is truly sharp.</li><li>Because it’s a “full size” dobsonian, it does not require a table to be placed on, meaning it will be more stable (though it’s still small, so a chair or stool to sit on is recommended).</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac27ee82800" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Telescope Aperture Affects Your View]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@phpdevster/how-telescope-aperture-affects-your-view-24507147d7fc?source=rss-d7f7a0123354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24507147d7fc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[astronomy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[telescope]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[phpdevster]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Apr 2018 03:11:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-24T12:32:31.280Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How Telescope Aperture Affects The View</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TXMRZJ5dG2hWwM3T8LQ5yQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>The Keck Telescopes on Mauna Kea inHawaii. Credits: Ethan Tweedie Photography/W. M. Keck Observatory</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p>A common question that new astronomers have about telescopes is how the aperture affects the view, particularly how much brighter it will make faint objects or how different apertures will perform in light pollution.</p><p>The typical answer is to describe how much more light gathering power one telescope has over another. For example, the mirror of an 8&quot; telescope has a surface area of approximately 50 square inches. A 12&quot; telescope has a surface area of approximately 113 square inches — 2.25x the surface area to collect photons with, meaning 2.25x the light gathering power. (More simply, you can just square the ratio of the apertures: <em>(12 / 8)² = 2.25)</em>. Sure sounds like a lot, right?</p><p>While the math is correct, the issue is that it’s not very useful information. What does 2.25x more light really mean? Will objects be 2.25x brighter? Will they be easier to see? It turns out, the answer to that is more complex than it seems.</p><h3>A Quick Summary</h3><p>Let’s start off with a quick summary of the effects, and then get into the explanations for them.</p><ol><li>The extra light gathering power of a telescope only directly affects the brightness of stars and star clusters. If a 12&quot; telescope collects 2.25x more light than an 8&quot; telescope, stars will be 2.25x brighter, or a little less than 1 magnitude brighter. This means globular clusters like M13 will appear significantly fuller and brighter.</li><li>For extended objects like nebulae and galaxies, the extra light gathering power does NOT make these objects brighter relative to the sky that surrounds them, thus they don’t have any better contrast. If an object like M1 (Crab Nebula) looks washed out in an 8&quot; telescope, it will be just as washed out in the 12&quot; telescope. The only difference is it will be 1.5x <em>larger </em>in the 12&quot; telescope at a given view brightness, and thus possibly look more detailed. Alternatively, the object will only be 2.25x brighter when viewed at the same magnification as the 8&quot; telescope, but the contrast won’t be improved. The whole view will be brighter — light pollution and all, but the object of interest itself won’t necessarily stand out more.</li></ol><p>Let’s look at why this is the case.</p><h3>A Crash Course in Telescope Optics</h3><p>Telescopes do two fundamental things: they collect more light than the human eye, and they magnify things. However, in the process of magnifying things, they naturally end up spreading out the light they collect over a larger virtual area, reducing the intensity (brightness) of that light, so the net gain in perceived brightness for many objects is zero <em>a</em>t <em>b</em>e<em>st</em>.</p><p>To better understand this concept, say you’re viewing a galaxy at 100x through an 8&quot; telescope. What happens if you increase magnification to 200x? You have the same amount of light to work with, but now it covers an area of your retina that is 4x larger. If you have X of something spread out out over Y area, and then take that same amount X, but spread it out over 4Y the area, it naturally means any given point must have 1/4th the concentration. Therefore the apparent brightness as perceived by any given photoreceptor in your eye, has to have dropped to 1/4th the intensity. <strong>Increasing magnification without increasing aperture, reduces apparent brightness.</strong></p><p>The exception to this is stars or other unresolved optical point sources. Unresolved point sources appear as diffraction patterns (called Airy patterns or Airy disks), and these diffraction patterns are so tiny that they remain concentrated on the retina for the practical range of magnifications you’ll typically use with a telescope. For all intents and purposes, their light does not dilute with magnification until the magnification becomes rather extreme.</p><p>Consider a 12&quot; telescope (304.8mm) vs a human eye dilated to 7mm<em>.</em> The telescope has a whopping 1,896x more light gathering power than the eye. <em>(304.8 / 7)² = 1,896</em>. However, for all that light to be utilized by the eye, it <em>must </em>fit within the ~7mm diameter of the eye’s pupil, else it is wasted. To do this, you need to use a minimum of 43.54x magnification, which just so happens to spread the light out over 1,896x the area <em>(43.54 / 1)² = 1,896 </em>(more on this later).</p><p>This means the view through the eyepiece is not actually 1,896 times brighter. Rather, it is the same brightness as what your unaided eye can gather, it is just 43.54x larger. In fact, because no optical system perfectly reflects or transmits light, the brightest possible view of extended objects through a telescope is actually a bit dimmer than the naked eye.</p><p>Again, it’s important to note that this effect only applies to what is known as <em>extended objects — </em>resolvable targets whose apparent size is readily magnified. This includes galaxies, nebulae, the Moon, planets, even sky glow.</p><h4>Exit Pupil Is The Limiting Factor</h4><p>Let’s look more closely at this relationship between magnification, and getting light to “fit” into a certain pupil size.</p><p>It turns out that when you magnify something using an optical system like a telescope, binoculars, or microscope, you produce a virtual aperture known as an exit pupil. The exit pupil behaves exactly like the iris in a camera lens, and the iris in our eye. The smaller it is, the less light it lets through. The larger it is, the more light it lets through. It’s ultimately the exit pupil (combination of aperture and magnification) which determines how bright the view is, NOT the telescope aperture alone.</p><p>One formula for determining the size of the exit pupil is as follows:</p><blockquote>Aperture (mm) / magnification = exit pupil (mm)</blockquote><p>If we plug in the values from before, we can see how they relate:</p><blockquote>304.8 mm / 43.54x = 7 mm exit pupil</blockquote><p>From the formula we can see that if we increase aperture, or decrease magnification, we can increase exit pupil size. Let’s try it:</p><blockquote>609.6 mm / 43.54x = 14 mm exit pupil</blockquote><p>In the above example, we doubled our aperture from 12&quot; to 24&quot; while keeping magnification the same, and thus doubled the size of our exit pupil. Unfortunately, 14mm is far larger than a human pupil, so while the telescope is technically producing a very bright view, your eye can’t make use of all of it. At this magnification, the view of light pollution, nebulae, galaxies, the moon, and even planets in the 24&quot; telescope is <em>identical</em> in brightness to the 12&quot; telescope. This is because the limiting pupil diameter is your own pupil, at 7mm. If your eyes’ pupils max out at a 7mm dilation, A 24&quot; telescope operating at a 14mm exit pupil is functionally the same as a 12&quot; telescope operating at a 7mm exit pupil.</p><p>This is a crucial point to understand — the useful pupil size range of our eyes (depending on our age) is from about 0.5mm to 7mm. Thus exit pupils must also fall within this range, regardless of the telescope size you’re using. While you can produce larger and smaller exit pupils in a given telescope with different eyepieces, it doesn’t matter, since our eye is the limiting factor.</p><p>When looked at this way, extra aperture of a telescope isn’t for increasing view brightness, it’s actually for increasing <em>magnification</em> at a given view brightness. Let’s compare an 8&quot; telescope, a 12&quot; telescope, and a 36&quot; telescope at the same exit pupil, but different magnifications.</p><blockquote>203.2 mm / 50.8x = 4 mm exit pupil</blockquote><blockquote>304.8 mm / 76.2x = 4 mm exit pupil</blockquote><blockquote>914.4 mm / 228.6x = 4 mm exit pupil</blockquote><p>The view brightness between all three telescopes is identical because they each have a 4mm exit pupil. The difference is that the 12&quot; telescope is producing 1.5x the magnification of the 8&quot;, and the 36&quot; telescope is producing 4.5x the magnification of the 8&quot;. What’s interesting is that a 12&quot; telescope is 1.5x the diameter of an 8&quot; telescope, and the 36&quot; is 4.5x the diameter of the 8&quot;. It’s not a coincidence that these aperture differences just so happen to be exactly the same as the magnification differences. Exit pupil, magnification, and aperture are all mathematically related.</p><p>Thus to best understand the difference between any two telescopes on any given diffuse object like a nebula or galaxy, you can think of a larger telescope as producing more magnification proportional to its aperture increase. A 10&quot; telescope is 1.67x larger than a 6&quot; telescope, and thus will produce a view 1.67x larger in size, at the same brightness level. A 100&quot; telescope is 10x larger than a 10&quot; telescope, and thus produces 10x the magnification at the same brightness level. Diffuse objects in that 100&quot; telescope aren’t any brighter or more contrasty than the 10&quot; telescope, they are simply larger. This increased size has important qualities which I will get into later.</p><h4>Brightness</h4><p>Let’s talk a little bit more about brightness and exit pupil.</p><p>Using the formula for exit pupil and magnification above, what if we kept the magnification constant between those telescopes to change the exit pupils?</p><blockquote>203.2 mm / 150x = ~1.35 mm exit pupil</blockquote><blockquote>304.8 mm / 150x = ~2 mm exit pupil</blockquote><blockquote>914.4 mm / 150x = ~6 mm exit pupil</blockquote><p>From those results, we can see that the 8&quot; telescope produces a somewhat dim 1.35mm exit pupil at 150x, while the 36&quot; telescope produces a really bright 6mm exit pupil at 150x. So does that brighter exit pupil mean faint diffuse objects will be easier to see? Not necessarily — it depends.</p><p>By increasing the view brightness with a larger exit pupil, we increased the brightness of both the light pollution, and the object, equally. This means the <em>contrast</em> of the object has not changed. However, the view is brighter, which means the eye-brain system has more signal to work with, and that extra signal may help it identify the faint diffuse object more easily.</p><p>There is also such a thing as too little exit pupil for a given object. Let’s use different apertures to illustrate this:</p><blockquote>60 mm / 150x = ~0.4 mm exit pupil</blockquote><blockquote>203.2 mm / 150x = ~1.35 mm exit pupil</blockquote><blockquote>914.4 mm / 150x = ~6 mm exit pupil</blockquote><p>From the above, we can see that dropping down to a 60mm aperture while maintaining 150x magnification gives us a super tiny 0.4mm exit pupil. Depending the size and contrast of the object, this may render the object invisible. Some objects like small, high-surface brightness planetary nebulae remain nicely visible at such small exit pupils. But low surface brightness / low contrast galaxies may become too dim or spread out for the eye to register them. Surface brightness is another concept I’ll go into more detail about in the next section.</p><p>In general though, the eye still works remarkably well on a wide variety of objects, even at small exit pupils. Larger exit pupils (brighter images), may help improve the signal to noise ratio of some objects and features, but it’s ultimately contrast that governs how well they stand out.</p><h4>Contrast</h4><p>Contrast — not brightness — is ultimately what makes us go “hmm, that looks faint and washed out” or “wow, that really stands out!”, and contrast is defined as the ratio of light from the object, to total amount of light being gathered by the telescope.</p><p>Remember, light pollution sits between us and the object we’re looking at, so any light we see is the combination of light pollution <strong><em>plus</em></strong> the object’s own light. This means that technically speaking, light pollution can never fully obscure an extended object. The place where the object is located will always be a tiny bit brighter than then surrounding light pollution.</p><p>However, the more light pollution there is, the lower the ratio of light coming from the object vs total light being gathered. Once this ratio gets too low, we can no longer perceive the object.</p><p>What’s important to note is that all extended objects have a measurement known as <em>surface brightness. </em>This is an inherent aspect of the object, and it cannot change with aperture. Even the brightness of the sky due to light pollution or moon light or day light has a surface brightness measurement.</p><p>The surface brightness is usually measured in <em>magnitudes per square arc second</em> (mpsas). The darkest skies on earth have a mpsas rating of about 22.0. A heavily light polluted area in the middle of a city might be as bright as 13.0 (in comparison, the surface brightness of the moon is around 4.0 mpsas, Jupiter is about 5.4 mpsas, and a clear blue daytime sky is about 3.0 mpsas).</p><p>A galaxy like Messier 51 has a mpsas rating of 21.7. This is almost as dim as the darkest skies on Earth, so how is it that we can still see it even from moderately light polluted skies? Again, it’s because the light is additive. It’s actually possible for an object to have a lower surface brightness than the light pollution in you area, and still be visible. Conventionally speaking, it can be about up to 5 magnitudes dimmer and still be detectable. So if you live in an area where light pollution clocks in at 18.0 mpsas, you can still see objects as dim as 23.0 mpsas (though this strongly depends on the nature of the object itself. Fuzzy objects like galaxies that tend to fade away and have no well defined edges are much harder to see when contrast is low, than well defined objects like many planetary nebulae). This is because there will still be a sufficient ratio of object light to total light — that is, there is still sufficient contrast.</p><p>Another important thing to understand is that a telescope cannot add contrast. It cannot selectively gather light from the object while ignoring light pollution. It gathers light from the object AND light pollution equally. This means that increasing aperture cannot increase contrast. However, if the object is a star, then increasing <em>magnification</em> can increase contrast. Magnification reduces exit pupil, which makes sky glow/light pollution dimmer. But because stars are point sources, and do not spread their light out with magnification, they stay the same brightness regardless of exit pupil.</p><h4>Magnification</h4><p>Earlier I had mentioned I would talk a little bit more about the effect that magnification has on dim objects. Magnification is the third concept to understanding the visibility of faint objects.</p><p>Here’s an experiment. If you live in an area where you are able to see Messier 51 through a telescope, try to see it with the naked eye. Chances are, you can’t.</p><p>But why not?</p><p>Is it too dim? From what we learned above, we know that if it’s bright and contrasty enough to be seen with a telescope, it must also be bright and contrasty enough to be seen with the naked eye.</p><p>Is it too small? Nope. It’s 7x11 arc minutes in size, making it about the size of some of the seas on the Moon. We can easily see those seas with the naked eye, so why not M51?</p><p>It turns out it’s a combination of both factors. The human eye can see detail as small as 1 arc minute, <em>if</em> the contrast is very high and it’s sufficiently bright. The dimmer it is, and the lower contrast it is, the larger it must be in order for our eyes to detect it. (<a href="http://www.bbastrodesigns.com/blackwel.html"><em>Here is some technical reading on this subject if you’re interested</em></a><em>. There is also </em><a href="http://www.bbastrodesigns.com/VisualDetectionCalculator.htm"><em>visual detection calculator</em></a><em> by Mel Bartels that might help interactively demonstrate the relationship between all of these concepts</em>).</p><p>In practice, what this means is that if an object is seemingly too faint to see, but you think it’s still within the threshold of detectability with your given light pollution levels, try throwing high magnification at it. Make it big enough to detect it.</p><p>This also applies for smaller details inside of already large objects. If you can fairly easily see M51, but can’t see detail in the spiral arms, just try more magnification. Even though you’re making it dimmer by making it larger, your eyes can still work fairly effectively even at small exit pupils. The benefits of magnification more quickly outweigh the detriments of a smaller exit pupil.</p><p>There’s a limit to this though, at some point it does become counter-productive to keep using higher magnification against the object, and this is where larger aperture starts to make a difference. Larger aperture affords higher magnification at reasonable exit pupils.</p><h4>Color</h4><p>There’s another misconception that more aperture is needed in order to see color in objects, but the reality is that our individual genetics are the limiting factor.</p><p>Eyes have two basic types of photoreceptors — rods, and cones. Rods are what our eyes use to see in low levels of light — known as scotopic vision. Rods do not detect color. Cones are active in moderate to bright levels of light — known as photopic vision. Cones <em>do </em>detect color.</p><p>There is also another state of vision, which is the transition from photopic to scotopic vision. This is known as mesopic vision, and is when both rods and cones are activated, such as during late twilight.</p><p>Thus in order to see color, the area of the retina illuminated by the object must enter at least mesopic vision, but ideally photopic vision. The threshold at which receptors in your eye move from scotopic (black and white) to mesopic or photopic (color) vision, depends on the individual. It should also be noted that being in scotopic vision doesn’t mean you can’t see in color at all. You can be fully dark adapted but still easily see the color of red giant stars, or even colors of things illuminated by your headlights when driving at night. Scotopic vision just means your cones recede and rods are more prominent, but light of sufficient intensity will still activate your cones and let you see color.</p><p>To give your eyes the best <em>chance</em> of seeing color, you need to maximize the intensity of light hitting your retina, which means flooding your eyes with as much light as possible. That usually means the larger the exit pupil, the better. Since we know that exit pupil is a function of both aperture and magnification (not just aperture) we can achieve large exit pupils in smaller telescopes, by using lower magnifications.</p><p>To achieve say, a 7mm exit pupil in a 6&quot; telescope, you’d want to use 21.77x:</p><blockquote>152.4 mm / 21.77x = 7mm mm exit pupil</blockquote><p>That will produce the brightest possible view in that telescope, giving cones the best chance of being activated in their recessed state. While 21.77x is not very high, and may not magnify a lot of smaller diffuse objects enough, it could be enough to show you color in larger objects like M42 (The Orion Nebula). As you go up in aperture, you will be able to add more magnification while maintaining that exit pupil, thus letting you potentially see color in broader range of object sizes.</p><p>However, light pollution is once again the real downer here. Any color you might be able to see will be quite subtle, and poor contrast as well as false color added by the light pollution will likely destroy any chance of seeing it. Getting out under really dark skies will give you the best chance of seeing color, <em>regardless</em> of your telescope’s aperture.</p><p>It should also be noted that there are plenty of bright planetary nebulae in the sky that show obvious bright blue and green color even in small apertures, and even at small exit pupils. Some examples are the Cat’s Eye Nebula (<em>NGC 6543) </em>and the Blue Snowball Nebula <em>(NGC 7662).</em></p><h4>Resolution</h4><p>I’ve spent an exhaustive amount of time covering the effects of aperture on DSOs like nebulae, galaxies, and star clusters, but what about other objects like the planets, the moon, and double stars?</p><p>This is arguably where a telescope’s aperture really struts its stuff.</p><p>Larger aperture increases the telescope’s resolving power, which is what allows you to see finer and finer details in planets, and the moon. It also lets you split double stars that are very close together.</p><p>Even when magnification isn’t being pushed too hard, a larger aperture will appear to show more detail than a smaller aperture, even at equal magnification. The difference in detail that can be seen on Jupiter between say, a 4.5&quot; telescope and an 8&quot; telescope is astonishing. In the 8&quot;, the Moon explodes with fine textures that otherwise look flat in the smaller instrument.</p><p>However, just as light pollution is the enemy of contrast, atmospheric turbulence (“seeing conditions”) is the enemy of resolution. A larger aperture, even with perfectly figured optics, won’t reveal its potential if you live under turbulent skies. In some ways, a larger aperture becomes detrimental when the seeing conditions are not steady.</p><p>The reason for this is because bad turbulence means you have to drop down to lower magnifications to maintain sharpness. This ends up increasing the exit pupil size. But our eyes don’t work very well when our pupils are wide open. We seem to have the best visual acuity at between 1.5mm and 3mm pupils (this varies from individual to individual). So if the exit pupil becomes larger than this, we are not seeing the object as clearly as possible.</p><p>As an anecdote, there are some nights where I am limited to about 100x when viewing Jupiter. 100x in my 12&quot; F/5 telescope means about a 3mm exit pupil. But 100x in my 8&quot; F/10 telescope means about a 2mm exit pupil. Despite the smaller aperture, I find the view of Jupiter to be cleaner in the smaller telescope. The reason is because my eye tends to focus light from a 2mm exit pupil better than a 3mm exit pupil. Jupiter is so bright at 3mm that some of the more subtle cloud textures get washed out, but are still visible in the 8&quot; at 2mm. The 100x magnification means I’m not really taking advantage of the higher resolving power of the larger aperture anyway.</p><p>If I’m looking at the Moon in poor seeing at 100x in both, then the exit pupil size becomes irrelevant because the Moon is so bright, my own pupil is constricted smaller than the exit pupils of either telescope. Meanwhile the low magnification and atmospheric turbulence is erasing the difference in resolving power between the two telescopes, so the view is basically the same in each despite a significant difference in aperture. It’s only on nights with exceptionally steady seeing that the advantages of the larger aperture really start to become apparent.</p><p>What this means is that while aperture is king when it comes to seeing fine details in the planets and the Moon, the atmosphere may be the limiting factor for you depending on where you live. If you’re considering a big telescope primarily to see as much detail as possible in the planets, you may want to start off with a smaller, cheaper telescope and evaluate the <a href="http://www.damianpeach.com/pickering.htm">Pickering seeing conditions</a> in your area for a few months to be sure your skies warrant a larger instrument.</p><h4><strong>Double Stars</strong></h4><p>Double star observing is greatly influenced by aperture since it depends on resolving power. The tighter the double stars are together, the more easily they are separated by larger apertures. However, sometimes more aperture isn’t always the answer. Larger aperture also increases star brightness, and due to various optical aberrations in most peoples’ eyes, that extra brightness can cause stars to look spikey and bloated unless you have very well corrected vision. The extra aperture also shrinks the Airy disk (the central diffraction peak of a star), which can, ironically, make the star appear less distinct to the eye. A smaller aperture producing larger Airy disks for stars, and also being slightly less affected by poor seeing, can actually produce a cleaner split of double stars that are within its resolving power.</p><p>For example, Epsilon Lyrae (the Double Double), is almost always easily split into four nice Airy disk diffraction patterns in my 90mm Maksutov Cassegrain. They are not too bright and don’t overwhelm my vision. Conversely, the look messy in my 12&quot; and 15&quot; scopes because they are so much brighter. While they are easy to split, the added brightness and messiness of the larger aperture requires more magnification to split them further apart, and atmospheric seeing conditions might not support such magnification, so they look blurry.</p><p>Double star splitting is very much a game of matching the aperture to the magnitude and angular separation of the stars. Different pairs of stars have different sweet spots for different instruments.</p><p>But it also depends on what your preference for the presentation is. Albireo in Cygnus looks glorious in big apertures — like two colored diamonds sparkling on a velvet background. In smaller apertures though, they look kind of bland by comparison. They are far enough apart that any aperture will resolve them, but the bigger the aperture, the more “jewel-like” they appear.</p><h4>Recap</h4><p>From the above, we have learned a few truths:</p><ol><li>There is a difference between point sources, and extended sources. Point sources get brighter with aperture, extended sources get brighter with exit pupil. This is because point sources do not spread their light out over a greater area when magnified, so their light never dilutes. Extended sources do. This dilution offsets the extra light gathering power of the larger aperture.</li><li>The exit pupil brightness limit is governed by our eyes. Depending on our age, it’s about 7mm. More aperture cannot change this fact. However bright an extended object is at a 7mm exit pupil, is the brightest it will ever be in a conventional eyepiece and telescope.</li><li>In reality, our unaided eye is the brightest view we can possibly get. Since telescope optics absorb some light, they will always be a bit dimmer than our unaided eye. What telescopes really provide, is magnification. And it’s this magnification — NOT the extra light gathering of the telescope — that allows us to see faint objects.</li><li>More aperture makes light pollution brighter in conjunction with extended objects. This means that contrast does not change with aperture. If an extended object looks very faint and washed out due to light pollution in a 6&quot;, it will look just as faint and washed out in a 60&quot;. The only cure for this is to drive to darker skies (or use a filter on objects that respond well to it — such as nebulae. Sadly, galaxies do not respond well to filters). However, the 60&quot; telescope would show an object 10x larger in size, which will still be very beneficial to seeing more detail in that object even though its contrast hasn’t changed.</li><li>You can make stars and star clusters brighter by using more aperture. You can increase the contrast of stars and star clusters by increasing magnification to drop the exit pupil (darkening the sky glow, while keeping the stars the same brightness)</li><li>While you cannot change the contrast of extend objects, you can somewhat offset the limitation of view brightness by magnifying them. More magnification means more details reach a size where our eyes can differentiate them. It’s not a magic bullet, but it does make a noticeable difference in how much detail you can see in otherwise “washed out” objects.</li><li>Larger apertures become extremely useful when teasing out fine detail on the Moon and planets, but this highly depends on how good the seeing conditions are. If they are poor, the extra aperture will be a waste (in some cases, possibly even a detriment, due to exceedingly large exit pupils at low magnification imposed by the atmosphere).</li><li>When it comes to double stars, bigger aperture isn’t always better. It very much depends on many factors, such as the brightness of the pair, what their angular separation is, how good your vision is, how steady the atmosphere is, and what your goal is (clean splits of Airy disks, or aesthetic presentation).</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24507147d7fc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>